Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet
chunk_id
stringlengths
22
24
cid
stringlengths
20
20
chunk_number
int32
0
195
nature
stringclasses
18 values
solution
stringclasses
67 values
title
stringlengths
4
256
number
stringlengths
4
47
decision_date
stringdate
1958-11-22 00:00:00
2025-07-18 00:00:00
text
stringlengths
8
1.5k
chunk_text
stringlengths
39
1.76k
embeddings_bge-m3
stringlengths
11.7k
13k
CONSTEXT000038657451_0
CONSTEXT000038657451
0
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL A ÉTÉ SAISI le 8 avril 2019 par la Cour de cassation (chambre criminelle, arrêt n° 841 du 2 avril 2019), dans les conditions prévues à l'article 61-1 de la Constitution, d'une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité. Cette question a été posée pour la société ENR Grenelle Habitat, M. Laurent A. et Mme Julie A. par Me Audrey Téani, avocate au barreau de Bordeaux. Elle a été enregistrée au secrétariat général du Conseil constitutionnel sous le n° 2019-790 QPC. Elle est relative à la conformité aux droits et libertés que la Constitution garantit des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation.
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL A ÉTÉ SAISI le 8 avril 2019 par la Cour de cassation (chambre criminelle, arrêt n° 841 du 2 avril 2019), dans les conditions prévues à l'article 61-1 de la Constitution, d'une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité. Cette question a été posée pour la société ENR Grenelle Habitat, M. Laurent A. et Mme Julie A. par Me Audrey Téani, avocate au barreau de Bordeaux. Elle a été enregistrée au secrétariat général du Conseil constitutionnel sous le n° 2019-790 QPC. Elle est relative à la conformité aux droits et libertés que la Constitution garantit des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation.
[-0.019948456,0.040272236,0.040459897,-0.02317624,-0.036237504,-0.07134904,0.009359635,-0.02617883,-0.035430558,0.02657292,0.003061234,-0.031283233,-0.064818405,-0.017771577,-0.039296392,-0.0140840225,0.043762747,0.00527799,0.006000488,-0.036594063,-0.032990955,-0.012357534,0.027117139,0.022050269,0.0056298557,0.041961193,-0.006783976,0.019723263,-0.01749947,-0.018278265,0.0020771823,-0.005564174,0.02096183,-0.019169658,-0.00773636,-0.045451704,0.004203626,-0.01920719,-0.051682077,0.028843628,0.0019645852,0.036237504,0.021825075,-0.09195431,0.06046465,-0.024865197,0.012995584,-0.004614136,-1.37722545e-05,0.015331974,-0.022069035,0.029763171,0.07063592,-0.051494416,-0.021787543,0.034754977,-0.0047056214,-0.02096183,-0.040872753,-0.029312784,-0.044213135,0.0018027268,-0.023251304,-0.03026986,0.00761438,-0.0030659258,0.042937033,-0.022275463,0.003994852,-0.04935507,0.0156134665,-0.008332186,0.008679361,0.013877595,-0.0779172,0.047515985,0.018006155,-0.032108944,0.0018777915,-0.02223793,0.018822486,0.009805332,-0.0068871905,-0.033572707,0.06913463,-0.029594276,-0.04492625,0.046765335,0.0149754165,-0.07634085,-0.03085161,-0.00014015996,-0.033891734,0.023757992,-0.028261876,-0.0068965736,-0.04826663,-0.0234202,0.027004542,0.05776232,-0.0044569694,0.0351866,0.058362838,-0.019132126,-0.0017945166,0.014618859,0.017827878,0.030007131,0.03588095,0.023757992,-0.014421814,0.0050058803,0.044025473,-0.027867787,0.0036781726,-5.0837305e-05,0.047553517,-0.020492675,-0.013445972,-0.014431197,-0.010631044,-0.024039485,0.07784214,-0.023082409,-0.041510805,0.014534411,0.0004465766,-0.0051372433,0.012385683,0.046915464,0.040722623,-0.023007344,-0.04481365,-0.012948669,-0.034210756,-0.022894748,0.011137731,0.027473697,-0.012413832,-0.041998725,0.044888716,0.043387424,-0.078817986,-0.031602256,0.011963444,-0.00819144,0.014140321,-0.013202012,-0.011165881,0.024152081,0.0019681037,0.01914151,0.050743766,-0.004644631,-0.032465503,-0.032990955,0.004750191,0.022669554,0.020004755,-0.01513493,-0.015059864,-0.0060990104,-0.029800704,-0.0028782638,0.023701694,-0.004271653,-0.0065212497,0.02612253,-0.033028487,-0.0021135418,0.06339218,-0.017508851,0.0068262,-0.032540567,-0.014262302,0.022350527,-0.001489566,0.023701694,-0.057799853,-0.0012397412,-0.035899714,0.046652738,-0.039746784,0.027623827,-0.030025898,-0.0149754165,-0.024020718,-0.0014203658,0.026685517,0.015388273,-0.007698828,-0.017255507,0.07574033,0.036462698,0.020886766,-0.03169609,-0.0024654078,-0.08639952,0.022294229,0.010340169,-0.043162227,0.018672355,-0.025859805,-0.027792722,-0.0675958,-0.033497643,-0.01729304,0.03695062,-0.009852248,-0.07078605,-0.047891308,0.02302611,0.0194793,-0.006605698,-0.015519636,0.027286034,-0.0028219651,-0.012845455,0.026047466,-0.01871927,0.00415671,0.01474084,-0.03813289,0.03272823,0.033441342,0.008702819,-0.035393026,0.04725326,0.0221441,0.02578474,0.011109582,0.040234704,0.06943489,-0.025859805,0.024471106,-0.004869825,0.008942088,0.05663635,0.014093406,-0.04571443,-0.048304163,-0.030663949,0.037569907,-0.02465877,-0.030307392,-0.01862544,-0.004780686,0.01880372,0.016551776,-0.015266293,-0.018118752,0.026216362,0.0046868552,0.03282206,-0.017180443,0.011522438,-0.046314947,-0.00044481727,0.024921495,-0.0051700845,0.02672305,0.01380253,0.06463075,0.007323504,-0.010236954,0.03484881,0.028299408,-0.050743766,0.025409415,-0.02190014,0.0047431537,0.03139583,0.0039362074,0.030570118,0.012526429,0.025109157,0.008435401,-0.016786354,0.032465503,0.010912538,-0.004182514,-0.058475435,-0.012348151,0.011513055,0.039408993,0.0045883325,-0.056073364,-0.032596864,0.0009834655,-0.07089865,0.026216362,-0.021337153,0.07108631,0.02293228,-0.019169658,-0.009889781,-0.02627266,-0.15418299,0.014797138,0.012132339,0.0032817367,-0.00018253048,0.008411943,0.00061928417,-0.051344287,-0.003302849,-0.0022918205,-0.015435188,-0.055773105,-0.057687256,0.006361737,-0.0123763,0.011316011,-0.0015247526,-0.00043953926,-0.0065306327,-0.016748821,-0.00955668,-0.007501783,0.018841252,-0.038545746,0.03237167,0.05689908,0.03167732,0.023345135,-0.0677084,-0.01680512,0.02017365,-0.015735447,-0.015547785,0.023251304,0.03558069,0.054834798,0.022331761,-0.019150892,0.04015964,-0.002297685,0.06718294,0.038733408,-0.017705897,0.025315585,0.031151868,-0.04237405,-0.018587908,-0.0047056214,0.0052920645,-0.0028688808,-0.0664323,0.026385257,-0.04841676,-0.021637414,-0.029631808,-0.009021844,0.02278215,-0.0017851335,-0.02809298,-0.006080244,0.0069763297,-0.055735573,-0.025127923,-0.006206916,-0.052470256,0.009871014,0.0037837324,0.012366917,0.032671932,-0.0065728566,0.00386818,-0.023382667,0.009078142,0.0001515956,-0.010321402,0.016101388,-0.02435851,0.033835433,-0.012395066,-0.103214025,-0.024377275,0.045151442,-0.01904768,0.03237167,-0.04192366,0.00952384,-0.015444571,0.026704283,0.027323566,0.19306652,0.057687256,0.066319704,0.042599242,0.004182514,-0.009293954,0.010499681,0.029387848,-0.0015751867,0.0019364358,-0.0021452096,-0.010996985,0.027717657,0.020924298,-0.029500445,0.008116376,0.038170423,-0.012348151,0.040910285,-0.03154596,0.00018912797,-0.029312784,0.020211183,0.0030424679,-0.03148966,-0.006694837,-0.009167282,-0.024733834,-0.049129877,-0.013821296,-0.016936483,0.00961767,0.072662674,-0.009195431,-0.025578313,-0.00828058,-0.023119941,-0.022219164,-0.012751624,0.09698365,0.017058464,-0.01734934,-0.032840826,-0.032127712,0.03498017,-0.008538615,0.0074877082,0.017809112,0.0039010209,0.019648196,-0.073600985,-0.013436589,-0.03910873,-0.022031503,-0.05674895,-0.012535812,-0.034867574,-0.012019742,0.00070901,0.029312784,0.06140296,-0.017217975,-0.0037954613,0.053746358,-0.032840826,0.03847068,0.02636649,-0.066995285,0.05123169,0.014703307,0.016495477,-9.771612e-05,-0.0057283784,0.037419774,0.039033666,0.0056580054,-0.046577673,0.015988791,-0.027361099,-0.000828058,-0.008712202,0.009692735,-0.036800493,-0.025484482,0.02111196,0.004902666,0.040384833,0.01665499,0.018578524,-0.011175264,0.005423428,-0.018653588,0.015688531,0.040534962,-0.05363376,-0.042937033,0.032146476,0.030344924,-0.039971977,0.012113573,0.030532585,-0.036631595,-0.01889755,-0.011391075,0.071536705,0.05186974,0.01765898,0.016167069,0.013539803,-0.0103964675,0.045264043,0.020924298,0.010931304,-0.032596864,-0.033159852,0.027661359,-0.034754977,0.007980321,0.042674307,-0.0070420112,0.01249828,0.06785853,-0.012244936,-0.017949857,-0.007787967,-0.02041761,0.03167732,-0.0066713793,-0.015791746,-0.016711289,0.001830876,-0.019423002,-0.009673969,0.019460535,0.012751624,-0.0012807922,0.038545746,-0.012000976,-0.045038845,0.0014156742,-0.01222617,-0.0014883932,0.017827878,-0.029763171,0.021412218,0.021731244,0.015425805,0.025991168,-0.054797266,0.010875005,0.018484693,0.023945654,0.027192203,-0.021918906,0.0031785227,-0.014994183,0.0325218,-0.0377388,0.018522225,-0.004747845,-0.013267694,0.03670666,-0.024771366,0.063016854,0.037288412,0.020586506,-0.034773745,-0.005662697,-0.00021566454,-0.014994183,0.030626416,0.00476192,-0.013173862,0.02878733,0.015153696,0.011878996,0.020680338,-0.01722736,0.0390712,-0.06200348,0.040084574,0.013905744,-0.017095996,-0.020492675,-0.029350316,0.000847997,0.015022332,-0.020999363,0.0679336,-0.029162653,-0.022069035,0.037363477,0.039296392,-0.00019807123,0.038733408,0.0006222164,-0.0071874494,0.06185335,-0.0010092689,-0.013661783,-0.03376037,-0.032746997,0.021581113,-0.038057826,0.0056392387,-0.012967435,0.00081574265,0.014909735,-0.039408993,0.053220905,0.01589496,0.02612253,-0.043875344,0.03676296,-0.027098373,0.024715068,-0.041323144,0.03188375,-0.009425317,-0.04395041,0.025653377,-0.0052639153,-0.0033450727,-0.07821746,-0.0016479057,-0.0069810213,-0.01577298,0.011869613,0.008838873,0.021787543,0.0015493833,-0.020886766,0.0109031545,0.019798327,0.006507175,-0.011437991,-0.0018848288,0.019854626,-0.015088013,-0.03743854,0.023776758,0.029181419,0.081745505,0.0073610367,-0.032878358,0.029068822,-0.014909735,0.022669554,0.035224132,0.06744567,-0.0101337405,0.025728442,0.01729304,-0.008533923,0.015397656,0.06305438,-0.023701694,-0.01613892,-0.027529996,-0.0045461087,0.01067796,0.0036265654,0.0054797265,0.01134416,0.0069669466,-0.033516407,0.013389674,-0.0455643,-0.024039485,-0.013689932,-0.00289703,-0.016101388,-0.0041332524,-0.041660935,-0.009927313,0.03695062,-0.045264043,0.028017916,-0.013370908,-0.013793147,0.07330073,-0.01756515,0.006446185,-0.044175602,-0.027135905,0.09022782,0.048867147,-0.031039272,-0.03154596,-0.004747845,-0.014140321,0.0019493375,-0.020023521,-0.008810724,-0.06305438,-0.03691309,-0.020136118,0.047478452,-0.015388273,-0.0060145627,-0.015735447,0.0559983,-0.02120579,-0.034417186,0.00722029,0.019854626,0.004637594,0.030870376,0.030213559,0.0035210056,0.011803932,-0.0913538,0.0033591473,-0.01225432,0.0338542,0.0067182947,-0.020042287,-0.016514244,-0.009795949,-0.028055448,-0.03148966,0.03409816,0.019742029,-0.0083509525,0.0045719123,0.04000951,-0.011222179,-0.066019446,0.01899138,-0.00870751,-0.065906845,0.013755615,-0.027192203,-0.038151655,-0.013905744,0.020436376,-0.04015964,-0.01537889,0.04331236,-0.029162653,-0.02514669,-0.019057062,0.08279642,-0.03227784,-0.02854337,0.043387424,0.015960641,-0.0038634886,-0.030814078,0.02578474,-0.03892107,-0.0054891095,-0.016392265,-0.055472847,0.020229949,0.030401222,-0.023307603,0.015923109,-0.021280855,0.018587908,-0.003363839,0.024020718,-0.00931272,0.027361099,0.033779137,0.04083522,-0.008308729,-0.0032934656,0.00052574644,-0.0039667026,0.013239545,-0.056373622,-0.011456757,-0.0010022316,-0.0039010209,0.008013162,-0.025465716,-0.031170635,0.009467541,-0.0077222856,0.014872203,-0.0016537702,-0.048341695,-0.026873179,0.058925826,0.01079994,0.02238806,0.0037368168,0.0074642505,-0.003164448,0.01340844,-0.03237167,-0.014008958,-0.035768352,-0.14224769,-0.0028501146,0.002451333,-0.024696302,-0.021036895,-0.0008790785,0.014600093,-0.018409628,-0.009073451,0.0041332524,-0.010931304,-0.045977157,0.010809323,-0.018334564,0.03985938,0.025202988,-0.012141722,0.012122956,0.010293253,0.052808046,0.01589496,0.027173437,-0.020192416,-0.0036781726,0.007698828,-0.0299696,0.006835583,-0.04702806,-0.058325306,-0.05566051,0.036650363,-0.024433574,-0.01844716,0.052808046,0.0009905028,0.015069247,0.021130726,-0.025428182,-0.030176027,-0.03858328,0.037232112,0.0064321104,-0.010377701,-0.0234202,0.018184435,0.014787755,-0.0017710588,-0.026516622,-0.011897762,-0.0014356133,-0.015416422,0.009232963,-0.022800917,0.035430558,0.031358298,-0.0073328875,-0.00925173,0.017152295,-0.05048104,0.036519,0.006516558,0.012592111,-0.009692735,-0.050593637,0.02809298,0.03700692,-0.020830467,0.0073188124,0.035205364,0.0071358425,-0.0076425294,-0.010818707,-0.014055873,-0.022538189,0.014299834,-0.026535388,0.020154884,-0.021956438,0.0175933,-0.04286197,-0.066995285,0.004665743,-0.038695876,0.00900777,0.057499595,-0.030870376,-8.1808845e-05,0.011569354,0.027811488,0.0057096123,-0.09728391,0.000403473,0.0015118509,0.08031928,0.0034905106,-0.02657292,-0.002451333,-0.01901953,-0.00955668,-0.055472847,-0.022294229,-0.03822672,0.021168258,0.003164448,-0.009176665,-0.00955668,0.013793147,0.003755583,-0.024527406,-0.009908547,-0.0058409753,0.008721585,-0.05536025,-0.006568165,-0.061478026,0.013905744,-0.033647772,0.012751624,-0.03209018,-0.010086825,0.022069035,0.009167282,-0.029763171,-0.03366654,-0.018850634,-0.04586456,0.060614783,0.011109582,0.061140236,-0.004522651,0.012113573,0.012882987,-0.00420128,-0.02627266,-0.0071874494,-0.022951046,-0.02888116,0.0152381435,0.012948669,-0.0234202,0.010358935,0.013155096,0.013267694,-0.0059676473,-0.045902092,0.018634822,0.016495477,-0.020286247,0.023664162,-0.062754124,0.01277039,-0.014618859,0.022219164,0.017039698,-0.014994183,-0.00010599963,0.003959665,0.0023926888,0.013915127,0.0679336,-0.0016596346,-0.01871927,-0.039146263,-0.015857428,0.01525691,0.044738587,0.0035233514,-0.016326582,-0.00031316074,0.0135773355,0.030044664,0.033178616,-0.025409415,0.02539065,-0.0002436672,0.016739437,0.012357534,0.0068590413,-0.025184222,-0.022763385,0.036181208,0.039896913,-0.039634187,-0.018794335,-0.0058175176,0.0221441,0.016598692,-0.012010359,-0.03158349,0.00057764666,-0.008139833,-0.004902666,0.017236741,0.013258311,0.027323566,0.031020505,0.0028383858,0.02460247,0.011259711,0.023833057,0.061665688,-0.040459897,-0.025634611,-0.02844954,-0.016345348,-0.004229429,0.023307603,0.0071076932,-0.0154914865,0.041285608,-0.035355493,0.025559546,0.032953423,0.029519212,0.012517046,-0.024715068,0.020398844,-0.027436165,0.071386576,-0.06924723,0.00085092924,0.030889142,-0.02096183,-0.02612253,0.00631013,0.005911349,-0.027436165,0.051644545,-0.0059254235,0.017424405,0.0052404576,-0.007168683,0.032409202,0.004996497,0.049092345,-0.04271184,-0.020398844,-0.011832081,0.009439392,0.007121768,-0.03877094,0.01653301,0.008233665,0.0058972742]
CONSTEXT000038657451_1
CONSTEXT000038657451
1
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
Au vu des textes suivants :- la Constitution ;- l'ordonnance n° 58-1067 du 7 novembre 1958 portant loi organique sur le Conseil constitutionnel ;- le code de la consommation ;- l'ordonnance n° 2016-301 du 14 mars 2016 relative à la partie législative du code de la consommation ;- le règlement du 4 février 2010 sur la procédure suivie devant le Conseil constitutionnel pour les questions prioritaires de constitutionnalité ;Au vu des pièces suivantes :- les observations présentées pour les requérants par Me Bertrand Perier, avocat au Conseil d'État et à la Cour de cassation, et Me Téani, enregistrées le 30 avril 2019 ;- les observations présentées par le Premier ministre, enregistrées le même jour ;- les secondes observations présentées pour les requérants par Mes Perier et Téani, enregistrées le 15 mai 2019 ; - les autres pièces produites et jointes au dossier ;Après avoir entendu Me Téani, pour les requérants, et M. Philippe Blanc, désigné par le Premier ministre, à l'audience publique du 4 juin 2019 ;Et après avoir entendu le rapporteur ; LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL S'EST FONDÉ SUR CE QUI SUIT :
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] Au vu des textes suivants :- la Constitution ;- l'ordonnance n° 58-1067 du 7 novembre 1958 portant loi organique sur le Conseil constitutionnel ;- le code de la consommation ;- l'ordonnance n° 2016-301 du 14 mars 2016 relative à la partie législative du code de la consommation ;- le règlement du 4 février 2010 sur la procédure suivie devant le Conseil constitutionnel pour les questions prioritaires de constitutionnalité ;Au vu des pièces suivantes :- les observations présentées pour les requérants par Me Bertrand Perier, avocat au Conseil d'État et à la Cour de cassation, et Me Téani, enregistrées le 30 avril 2019 ;- les observations présentées par le Premier ministre, enregistrées le même jour ;- les secondes observations présentées pour les requérants par Mes Perier et Téani, enregistrées le 15 mai 2019 ; - les autres pièces produites et jointes au dossier ;Après avoir entendu Me Téani, pour les requérants, et M. Philippe Blanc, désigné par le Premier ministre, à l'audience publique du 4 juin 2019 ;Et après avoir entendu le rapporteur ; LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL S'EST FONDÉ SUR CE QUI SUIT :
[-0.0015106623,0.0455958,0.029438786,-0.020905804,-0.028622588,-0.06381186,0.019662958,-0.0117792245,-0.03656197,0.020813053,-0.004043891,-0.025580393,-0.074422434,-0.016379613,-0.040476013,-0.012799472,0.039696913,0.019904107,0.004463584,-0.038843613,-0.013866095,-0.02259385,0.037749168,0.03285198,0.01638889,0.034706973,-0.00942338,0.013467271,-0.010360152,0.020163806,0.002708294,-0.016713513,0.03172043,-0.009673804,-0.003063062,-0.034929574,0.015377916,-0.019570207,-0.05034459,0.01854996,-0.003601011,0.01614774,0.0032439241,-0.083771616,0.061474565,-0.030978432,0.020145256,-0.017483337,-0.00022912098,0.02292775,-0.047302395,0.030440483,0.07141735,-0.047116898,-0.017316388,0.043629505,-0.015897315,-0.019217758,-0.07360624,-0.015786014,-0.019384708,0.019180657,-0.0033575427,0.017372036,0.015229517,-0.012168773,0.048266996,-0.02300195,0.014246369,-0.039548513,-0.002100783,-0.00574585,0.010592027,0.0027059754,-0.05787587,0.034373075,0.03140508,-0.017399862,0.03173898,-0.021851853,0.00091996207,0.02277935,0.006163224,-0.015433567,0.07160284,-0.018893134,-0.046894297,0.052681886,0.011769949,-0.07037855,-0.017613186,0.012957146,-0.010425077,0.017687386,-0.029679935,-0.00072692655,-0.046745896,-0.011408225,0.008992093,0.04945419,-0.0031395806,0.025988493,0.045484502,-0.03172043,0.0016393526,0.0019813676,0.014033045,0.018651985,0.026878892,0.030570334,-0.008078507,-0.0009101074,0.047079798,0.0026943816,0.0061585866,-0.00014173328,0.03741527,-0.016259039,1.2454197e-05,-0.008124882,-0.012697447,-0.014524618,0.08258442,-0.027862038,-0.039585613,0.025246495,0.021165503,0.0032369678,0.01128765,0.02767654,0.021202603,-0.013170471,-0.035448972,-0.0005492527,-0.031813182,-0.025654593,0.004572565,0.016221939,-0.002872925,-0.05913727,0.057727475,0.013393071,-0.06677985,-0.01592514,0.048526693,-0.0069655096,0.009840754,-0.018012011,-0.014237094,0.015711816,-0.009321354,0.028233038,0.05501918,0.0066594356,-0.014274194,-0.007220572,-0.0031534932,0.028158838,0.025673144,-0.0017610868,-0.042961705,0.0022201983,-0.010619852,0.009775829,0.03166478,-0.026674842,-0.0018202148,0.005546438,-0.048229896,-0.006789285,0.08043262,0.002409176,0.0038769415,-0.016917562,-0.01385682,0.019551657,0.0031882743,0.013281771,-0.056762874,0.008699931,-0.012335723,0.03711847,-0.032796327,0.012029649,-0.015220242,-0.008917893,-0.03277778,0.016249765,0.03620952,0.03606112,-0.008723118,-0.011936899,0.06303276,0.018605608,0.0032369678,-0.037359618,0.00914513,-0.070118845,0.00907093,0.0030305996,-0.016574388,0.0129849715,0.0054861503,-0.03136798,-0.07724203,-0.04014211,-0.04129221,0.004962114,0.0046560396,-0.050641388,-0.05101239,0.007308684,0.0006591032,-0.00469314,0.004846177,0.031423632,-0.011853424,-0.016861914,0.0458184,-0.048044395,-0.007099997,0.03609822,-0.042553607,0.023577,0.057616174,-0.02806609,0.005490788,0.04155191,0.029104887,-0.003610286,0.003218418,0.0135878455,0.052088287,-0.038880713,0.014227819,-0.0020462924,0.015470666,0.06663145,0.016787713,-0.041848708,-0.037285417,-0.039214615,0.022130102,-0.017956361,-0.034261774,-0.024337547,-0.021184053,0.012298623,0.019013708,0.009284255,-0.007753883,0.020089606,0.0053841257,0.029995285,-0.030644532,-0.002763944,-0.015804565,0.0026781503,0.034094825,-0.012855122,0.029958185,0.039474312,0.046115197,0.009172955,0.00018376054,0.0043661967,-0.005490788,-0.051383387,0.020163806,-0.020349305,0.0062652486,0.032128528,0.028251588,0.012743822,0.010925926,0.061845563,-0.0055325255,-0.025283594,0.033297177,-0.015841665,-0.003927954,-0.048712194,0.005829325,-0.00041563503,0.025339244,-0.013300321,-0.03758222,-0.042776205,-0.002689744,-0.042887505,0.03170188,-0.015377916,0.09735019,0.017288562,-0.03159058,-0.019514557,-0.0450393,-0.14565428,0.0022712105,-0.0065481355,-0.0023975822,-0.0005222973,0.008217632,0.0043035904,-0.043110106,-0.0014295062,-0.016796988,-0.032128528,-0.07060114,-0.025747344,-0.013031347,-0.011027951,-0.0009512651,0.002322223,0.009094117,-0.020998554,-0.016843364,-0.0065759607,-0.01143605,0.015507766,-0.032555178,0.025914293,0.033927877,0.028993586,0.019755706,-0.05932277,0.008087782,0.037044268,-0.021870403,-0.00681711,0.03209143,0.009353817,0.0459297,0.023725398,-0.014765767,0.017455513,-0.0060055493,0.08711061,0.03646922,-0.010221028,0.021109853,0.030477583,-0.03129378,-0.011074326,-0.010350877,-0.029067786,0.019180657,-0.07419984,-0.00055736833,-0.06629755,-0.0026317756,-0.042850405,-0.01803056,-0.0020022362,-0.011825599,-0.027565239,0.007573021,-0.0023199043,-0.063626364,-0.025561843,-0.018243885,-0.04017921,0.0023419324,0.021555053,0.008366032,0.023892347,-0.0007993873,0.024040747,-0.036895867,0.025821544,-0.009877853,0.0012347316,0.022130102,-0.030217884,0.0226866,0.0073504215,-0.09341759,-0.039919514,0.03632082,-0.020646105,0.026878892,-0.035430424,0.0089596305,-0.011751399,-0.001332119,0.02724989,0.21191473,0.04055021,0.04989939,0.05487078,-0.00556035,-0.024894046,-0.02292775,0.04010501,-0.0036195607,-0.00942338,0.006501761,-0.020367855,0.04192291,0.011204176,-0.012678897,0.012066749,0.026915992,-0.0026062692,0.056466077,-0.02669339,0.011927624,-0.0028195938,0.015312991,-0.017047413,-0.043035906,0.008143432,-0.0028080002,-0.04062441,-0.03572722,-0.0035569547,-0.020219456,0.017270012,0.064331256,-0.028103188,-0.008008945,-0.034762625,-0.021629253,-0.036895867,0.0058385995,0.084958814,0.009710903,-0.021944601,-0.03530057,-0.010638402,0.0444828,-0.006645523,0.016722789,0.0037239043,0.0013008158,0.030830033,-0.0464491,-0.019106459,-0.031386532,-0.042961705,-0.052125387,-0.024374647,-0.028900838,0.012493398,0.0023929446,0.042219706,0.07753883,-0.021165503,-0.021647803,0.0451877,-0.028548388,-0.0025761256,0.016101364,-0.058840472,0.060806766,0.010183928,0.023410048,-0.00054838316,-0.004809077,0.040364712,0.042887505,0.0006312783,-0.037674967,0.010814627,-0.051865686,0.007818808,-0.01128765,-0.010675502,-0.015201692,-0.032981828,0.021165503,-0.00039679522,0.035115074,0.014932717,0.012994247,-0.0024045384,-0.0010527102,-0.025858643,0.020571904,0.039103314,-0.047376595,-0.037879016,0.018095486,0.0050038514,-0.047116898,-0.0058988873,0.016620763,-0.0450393,-0.008505156,-0.010183928,0.06288436,0.05082689,0.008690656,0.012094573,-0.016639313,-0.016101364,0.056354776,0.028381437,-0.006436836,-0.017984185,-0.010007703,0.043963403,-0.03194303,0.013736245,0.033427026,0.0034247863,-0.008212995,0.06577816,-0.016008615,-0.0111207,-0.028325789,0.0005753386,0.014162894,-0.01812331,-0.024689997,-0.004382428,0.008059957,-0.002527432,-0.031238131,-0.013133371,0.03253663,-0.013022072,0.047265295,-0.016694963,-0.0054768757,0.008027495,-0.021276804,0.0036427483,0.008927168,-0.015229517,0.016221939,0.03277778,0.007670408,0.02266805,-0.037600767,-0.00013499444,0.038250018,0.02762089,0.039251715,-0.046041,0.014144344,-0.023781048,0.041811608,-0.032722127,0.0113711255,0.0030166872,-0.022018801,0.04017921,-0.03665472,0.024671447,0.03658052,0.012289348,-0.019347608,-0.0064646606,0.007253034,0.0034340613,0.008894705,-0.00027332205,-0.024133498,0.033315726,0.021888953,0.031256683,0.022482552,-0.039437212,0.05483368,-0.07219644,0.028585488,0.001295019,-0.008004308,-0.034688424,-0.019273408,0.009117305,-0.0050641387,-0.026285293,0.058098473,-0.031219581,-0.0121780485,0.05869207,0.045484502,-0.008848331,0.0460781,-0.0068310224,0.009896403,0.05401748,0.029735586,-0.020553354,-0.012855122,-0.016342513,0.021388102,-0.0041946094,0.0022062857,-0.008324294,-0.014515343,0.023818148,-0.038954914,0.03589417,0.040401813,0.043406904,-0.04125511,0.04058731,-0.006279161,0.024671447,-0.010610577,0.048489593,-0.008264007,-0.05019619,0.023428598,0.0024230885,-0.0025390256,-0.061548766,0.006237424,-0.006427561,0.015127492,0.0076472205,0.038250018,0.016806263,0.004192291,-0.0072669466,0.014422594,0.030292084,0.008672106,-0.00025172875,-0.01158445,0.025116645,-0.008273282,-0.0466346,-0.0027500314,0.037804816,0.07753883,0.00092459953,-0.029735586,0.025914293,-0.007545196,0.010963026,0.03222128,0.07679683,-0.008713843,0.020980004,0.030180784,-0.020275105,0.024819845,0.044186004,-0.0069237724,-0.01585094,-0.014580268,-0.010573477,0.01348582,-0.019087909,0.019885557,-0.0031766805,0.015461391,-0.044260204,0.008978181,-0.08392002,-0.025914293,-0.026173992,-0.0021796203,-0.016231215,0.004370834,-0.043481104,0.0010503915,0.020033956,-0.021963151,0.021851853,-0.023743948,-0.019904107,0.07746463,-0.009803654,0.023818148,-0.03554172,-0.04158901,0.06648305,0.052570585,-0.02715714,-0.034484375,0.0017912304,-0.011055776,0.02289065,-0.013420896,-0.004892552,-0.046745896,-0.053312585,-0.019644408,0.019662958,-0.020497706,0.0063672736,-0.013059171,0.05895177,-0.011148525,-0.0450764,0.008477331,0.022111552,-0.011102151,0.010796077,0.03172043,0.008931805,0.018355185,-0.07783563,0.0016150058,-0.02697164,0.029568635,0.016518738,-0.017010313,-0.024782745,-0.008792681,-0.034706973,-0.033686727,0.032592278,0.021276804,0.00678001,-0.037823368,0.0460781,-0.0011471991,-0.055946678,0.003951141,-0.013291046,-0.052793186,0.00046229977,-0.035115074,-0.024096398,-0.0023141075,0.011797775,-0.024096398,-0.0223156,0.034929574,-0.04155191,0.0019349926,-0.052273784,0.10031818,-0.03210998,-0.00010260446,0.009302804,0.0074570836,0.013207571,-0.018800383,0.007480271,-0.05910017,-0.010684777,-0.016694963,-0.048786394,0.021833302,0.026619192,-0.016973212,0.039029114,0.009414105,0.008829781,-0.009618154,0.01675989,-0.02769509,0.03737817,0.03183173,0.022074452,0.0031465369,-0.016991762,-0.00798112,-0.0020984642,0.009186868,-0.06826385,-0.0072298464,0.0050316765,-0.018605608,0.009645979,-0.04066151,-0.053794883,0.015841665,0.028103188,0.023539899,-0.0070397095,-0.03685877,-0.03769352,0.057579074,-0.010777527,0.03177608,0.0046653147,0.0048322645,0.0011576334,-0.001986005,-0.024727095,-0.03711847,-0.047265295,-0.1374181,0.008843693,-7.148256e-05,-0.020516256,-0.029976735,0.009186868,0.01784506,-0.026563542,-0.0035198547,0.0062559736,-0.016871188,-0.03995661,0.0023883074,-0.014979092,0.028103188,0.025060995,-0.025636043,-0.008259369,0.007480271,0.035003774,0.003009731,0.018114036,-0.009321354,-0.011241276,0.012678897,-0.03147928,-0.006960872,-0.025413444,-0.0460039,-0.043518204,0.034484375,-0.003781873,-0.01804911,0.07208514,0.0063672736,0.020145256,0.0226495,-0.039066214,0.010499277,-0.03758222,0.023335848,0.008208357,-0.017038139,-0.03789757,0.0123728225,0.011677199,0.015099667,-0.017566811,-0.029735586,0.002817275,0.0074663586,0.0031766805,-0.03607967,0.036895867,-0.008992093,-0.014737942,0.0015848621,0.025283594,-0.060695466,0.034113374,0.015071842,0.009497579,-0.010619852,-0.06763315,0.05858077,0.04003081,-0.036024023,-0.015656166,0.020813053,0.020423505,-0.012261523,-0.0097572785,-0.008032132,-0.030384833,0.0010092338,-0.010397253,0.03223983,-0.0017390586,0.020497706,-0.057319373,-0.06989624,0.0033459489,-0.039511412,0.015359366,0.0465975,-0.018577784,0.014144344,-0.0072947717,0.029438786,0.0050316765,-0.10655097,-0.008862243,-0.0025390256,0.08436521,0.0010643039,-0.0229092,0.0065388605,-0.01821606,-0.011927624,-0.0463749,-0.019032259,-0.047747597,0.02229705,-0.009803654,0.0025112007,0.011890524,0.0016463089,-0.00023854089,-0.016815538,-0.010109728,-0.011194901,0.034002077,-0.06266176,-0.016769163,-0.062402062,-0.0070907217,-0.034799725,-0.016648589,-0.051531788,0.00036375312,0.038435515,0.018151136,-0.03194303,-0.03652487,-0.016481638,-0.010740426,0.043481104,0.007308684,0.05498208,0.016592938,0.010758976,0.0051754387,-0.0002595545,-0.014923442,-0.004002154,-0.021684902,-0.039029114,0.022018801,0.0025946756,-0.024597246,0.0048415395,0.0017263056,0.009618154,-0.008848331,-0.031126833,0.006399736,0.013680595,-0.009803654,0.017622462,-0.061437465,0.00080692326,-0.022093002,0.025227945,0.007860545,-0.012447023,0.03127523,-0.0039117225,-0.004560971,0.015971515,0.08837201,0.0035824608,-0.021722002,-0.051531788,-0.024133498,0.015823115,0.061140668,-0.00029795873,-0.007995033,-0.006191049,-0.0037957854,0.014515343,0.0041899723,-0.028659686,0.043035906,-0.013318871,0.021202603,0.021981701,-0.0045215525,-0.03580142,-0.016194114,0.0229092,0.02708294,-0.01356002,-0.0111670755,0.030496133,0.07037855,0.017854337,0.008138794,-0.021703452,-0.018355185,-0.023818148,-0.019087909,0.030273534,0.016926838,0.018466484,0.051346287,0.020126706,0.046412,0.006228149,0.020980004,0.071194746,-0.031386532,-0.053869084,-0.05160599,-0.020738855,-0.011593725,0.018318085,-0.027991889,-0.012038924,0.01778941,-0.019514557,0.022464002,0.026915992,0.03645067,0.0061817737,-0.025227945,0.012298623,-0.025877193,0.055761177,-0.05483368,0.0065759607,0.048526693,-0.010295227,-0.02749104,-0.025617493,0.010916651,-0.024949696,0.047413696,-0.0067243604,0.019829907,-0.002717569,-0.0029332123,0.033538327,-0.0135878455,0.04084701,-0.047079798,-0.0226124,-0.021759102,-0.0032160992,0.017594637,-0.014088694,0.006664073,-0.02255675,-0.017984185]
CONSTEXT000038657451_2
CONSTEXT000038657451
2
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
1. La question prioritaire de constitutionnalité doit être considérée comme portant sur les dispositions applicables au litige à l'occasion duquel elle a été posée. Dès lors, le Conseil constitutionnel est saisi des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation dans leur rédaction issue de l'ordonnance du 14 mars 2016 mentionnée ci-dessus.2. L'article L. 132-2 du code de la consommation, dans cette rédaction, prévoit :« Les pratiques commerciales trompeuses mentionnées aux articles L. 121-2 à L. 121-4 sont punies d'un emprisonnement de deux ans et d'une amende de 300 000 euros.« Le montant de l'amende peut être porté, de manière proportionnée aux avantages tirés du délit, à 10 % du chiffre d'affaires moyen annuel, calculé sur les trois derniers chiffres d'affaires annuels connus à la date des faits, ou à 50 % des dépenses engagées pour la réalisation de la publicité ou de la pratique constituant ce délit ».3. L'article L. 522-1 du même code, dans la même rédaction, prévoit :« L'autorité administrative chargée de la concurrence et de la consommation est l'autorité compétente pour prononcer les amendes administratives sanctionnant les manquements aux dispositions mentionnées aux articles L. 511-5, L. 511-6 et L. 511-7 et l'inexécution des mesures d'injonction relatives à des manquements constatés avec les pouvoirs mentionnés aux mêmes articles ».4. Les requérants soutiennent que l'application combinée des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] 1. La question prioritaire de constitutionnalité doit être considérée comme portant sur les dispositions applicables au litige à l'occasion duquel elle a été posée. Dès lors, le Conseil constitutionnel est saisi des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation dans leur rédaction issue de l'ordonnance du 14 mars 2016 mentionnée ci-dessus.2. L'article L. 132-2 du code de la consommation, dans cette rédaction, prévoit :« Les pratiques commerciales trompeuses mentionnées aux articles L. 121-2 à L. 121-4 sont punies d'un emprisonnement de deux ans et d'une amende de 300 000 euros.« Le montant de l'amende peut être porté, de manière proportionnée aux avantages tirés du délit, à 10 % du chiffre d'affaires moyen annuel, calculé sur les trois derniers chiffres d'affaires annuels connus à la date des faits, ou à 50 % des dépenses engagées pour la réalisation de la publicité ou de la pratique constituant ce délit ».3. L'article L. 522-1 du même code, dans la même rédaction, prévoit :« L'autorité administrative chargée de la concurrence et de la consommation est l'autorité compétente pour prononcer les amendes administratives sanctionnant les manquements aux dispositions mentionnées aux articles L. 511-5, L. 511-6 et L. 511-7 et l'inexécution des mesures d'injonction relatives à des manquements constatés avec les pouvoirs mentionnés aux mêmes articles ».4. Les requérants soutiennent que l'application combinée des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation
[-0.037128136,0.035673592,0.038713213,0.0036013918,-0.026909038,-0.06258263,0.004519805,-0.009659655,-0.049603634,0.029426517,-0.03300693,-0.0018473158,-0.083766736,-0.0127925165,-0.05113277,-0.010051263,0.031813458,-0.005333323,0.00059906644,-0.021948677,-0.00404195,-0.009454527,0.018564068,-0.008032619,0.0038368225,0.06053135,-0.022620004,0.0030606003,-0.006475512,-0.0012948693,-0.012764544,-0.0047598975,0.035561703,-0.024540745,0.004661996,-0.014041931,-0.006526794,0.022135155,-0.050722513,0.014013959,0.006242412,0.015337965,0.016895073,-0.08145439,0.054116447,-0.017930036,-0.0060046506,-0.019282015,-0.016475493,0.018414883,-0.017939359,0.0065687518,0.066051155,-0.060419466,-0.0058181705,0.07809775,0.00091375114,-0.011319325,-0.05120736,-0.033025578,-0.0323356,-0.0148437945,-0.022340283,-0.014937034,0.0048624617,-0.0025268018,0.029445166,-0.02875519,-0.0015710925,-0.06150105,-0.010032615,0.0048111794,0.010256391,-0.009328653,-0.08145439,0.032018587,0.009902079,0.01737992,0.022843778,-0.03625168,0.01520743,-0.013109532,-0.021202756,0.015039599,0.056988236,0.003249411,-0.026909038,0.004261064,0.03153374,-0.095552266,-0.031850755,0.012111865,-0.02153842,0.02459669,-0.02551044,-0.011682961,-0.08018633,-0.00069813384,0.003419574,0.038825102,-0.02579016,0.017650316,0.053743485,-0.005641015,-0.0022039586,-0.00013680043,0.0031981291,0.041062858,0.0011969674,0.008433551,-0.018946351,-0.0050163073,0.024167785,-0.022358932,0.0029790152,0.0013449858,0.03041486,-0.005846143,0.007608377,-0.013892747,-0.012167809,0.0018904393,0.060121097,-0.034442823,-0.038675915,0.015906729,0.031664275,0.0090163,-0.0025780837,0.02931463,0.015216754,-0.008153831,-0.049044196,-0.018424207,-0.056652572,-0.020531429,0.027617663,-0.016503464,0.008717932,-0.06411176,0.036960304,0.039682906,-0.06821432,-0.027337942,0.052773792,0.028344935,-0.005076913,-0.028419526,-0.016335633,0.027654959,-0.02929598,0.0069603594,0.06414906,-0.009370611,-0.004496495,-0.033976626,0.01516081,0.016065238,0.02468993,-0.0039207386,-0.022489468,-0.008498819,-0.03494632,-0.0013706267,0.005337985,0.00859672,-0.009585063,0.02884843,-0.03718408,-0.0103962505,0.06496957,0.016428873,-0.004519805,-0.031645626,-0.023403218,0.01997199,0.01539391,0.025846105,-0.031682923,-0.0068997536,-0.009533782,0.028326286,-0.024428857,0.031925347,-0.003240087,0.0048577995,0.016466169,0.015076894,0.04826098,0.036456805,-0.009025624,-0.012111865,0.07205581,0.026125824,0.004552439,-0.04639618,0.0050163073,-0.05833089,0.031104835,0.0014883422,-0.019673621,0.0012307669,-0.016410224,-0.035822775,-0.055235326,-0.034554712,-0.060419466,0.023086203,0.0070862337,-0.078470714,-0.018946351,0.012111865,0.008750566,-0.0023123499,0.001702794,0.025752865,0.024335617,0.009104878,0.011198114,-0.04113745,-0.008447536,0.039869387,-0.03543117,0.035654943,0.04121204,-0.0030745862,-0.0069090775,0.016223745,0.035076857,-0.024932353,-0.009501147,0.037911348,0.061538342,-0.024951002,0.016913721,0.0015384586,-0.0046550026,0.066461414,0.0024848438,-0.02403725,-0.040354233,-0.07000453,0.016298337,-0.009240076,-0.024186434,-0.00037499928,-0.009421893,0.03930995,0.009188794,-0.021333292,-0.045650262,0.0046550026,-0.014358947,0.024149138,-0.016289013,-0.0025944007,-0.017491808,-0.0062144403,0.044605974,-0.01562701,0.010452194,0.022601355,0.050088484,0.004682975,-0.04419572,0.014265707,-0.015142162,-0.07328657,0.030545397,-0.011701609,-0.018349616,0.0116270175,0.025771512,0.02256406,0.0102657145,0.049006898,0.0016713254,-0.019300662,0.056055836,-0.013687619,0.028177103,-0.025622329,-0.00027520343,0.011636341,0.029240036,0.0180326,-0.07638214,-0.04844746,-0.00077797053,-0.072167695,0.03291369,-0.04934256,0.0933891,0.018163135,-0.043673575,-0.02929598,-0.031776164,-0.15045193,0.0014557082,-0.016801832,0.01104893,0.0027529085,0.029463813,0.011990653,-0.050424147,0.009184131,0.009389259,-0.00647085,-0.07735183,-0.019804157,-0.012997644,0.014405567,-0.0051048854,-0.0025780837,0.00875989,-0.011170141,-0.0060885665,-0.03751974,-0.034647953,-0.016913721,-0.03255938,-0.008979004,0.040764492,0.023906713,0.049230676,-0.032801803,-0.0013228413,0.012969672,0.011235409,-0.017389243,0.018004628,0.01539391,0.03919806,0.019282015,-0.026685264,0.030470803,0.007827491,0.0730255,0.07071315,-0.028158454,0.021594364,0.046843734,-0.045090824,-0.017874092,0.004102556,-0.013212096,-0.005337985,-0.059375178,0.012932376,-0.06877376,-0.003303024,-0.038526732,-0.013156152,0.020643316,0.023925362,-0.0333053,0.021985972,-0.011710933,-0.07537515,-0.013836803,-0.0048251655,-0.037090838,-0.019654974,0.017165469,0.016895073,0.006251736,0.0038578014,0.047030214,-0.030806467,-0.004529129,-0.018881083,0.0040139784,0.041808777,-0.0039673583,0.027487127,-0.021090869,-0.1220324,-0.024428857,0.040876377,-0.051804096,0.04262929,-0.023440514,0.008979004,0.0033053549,0.0096410075,0.027356591,0.22049375,0.013706268,0.07142177,0.04095097,-0.008456861,-0.0034545388,-0.035356574,0.018051248,0.0019766863,-0.0084521985,0.009911403,0.0062377504,0.028606005,0.010097883,-0.021836787,0.022694595,0.013193448,0.0052960273,0.056055836,-0.029333277,-0.020512782,-0.019860102,0.0027202745,0.0017354279,-0.030862411,-0.017874092,-0.0060652564,-0.043002248,-0.0072540655,0.0044522057,-0.018890407,-0.00038781977,0.070750445,-0.034797136,0.010163151,-0.016195772,-0.04050342,-0.015832137,0.011673638,0.06064324,0.015822813,-0.023552403,-0.013920719,-0.030079197,0.013678296,-0.016419549,0.026368247,0.0136130275,-0.011030282,0.020643316,-0.063626915,-0.012391585,-0.015226078,-0.01913283,-0.050908994,-0.0028974304,-0.02515613,0.011729581,-0.014992978,0.041622296,0.031384554,-0.02431697,0.007827491,0.027468478,-0.023048908,-0.012037273,-0.016065238,-0.029631644,0.030116493,0.012354288,-0.008703946,0.006433554,-0.003419574,0.030284325,0.05120736,-0.005641015,-0.033939328,-0.012018625,-0.05001389,-0.02062467,-0.010592055,0.002356639,-0.0091002155,-0.026181769,0.0072540655,0.012717924,0.012289021,0.028251695,0.008675974,0.000825756,-0.0111514935,-0.023067554,-0.005608381,0.066461414,-0.048820417,-0.028344935,0.02321674,0.0013752887,-0.047776133,-0.016177125,0.022974314,-0.044419494,0.00039044215,-0.003251742,0.06937049,0.042890362,0.017389243,0.0052540693,-0.023254035,-0.027916031,0.0070815715,0.032410193,-0.013724916,-0.041473113,-0.019300662,0.055235326,-0.04613511,0.021333292,0.04949175,0.0036596667,0.02772955,0.06996723,-0.0323356,-0.0068857674,-0.018396236,0.0014487152,0.01987875,0.023030259,-0.0023123499,-0.0013741233,-0.0072494033,-0.015272698,-0.018191107,0.022377579,0.023738882,0.008181803,0.054974254,-0.022881076,-0.016764536,0.01062935,-0.01607456,0.0038554706,-0.0037925334,0.0028275005,0.03226101,0.045351893,0.0031561712,0.056913644,-0.04550108,0.0365314,0.036494102,0.0171002,0.04826098,-0.040876377,-0.007972012,-0.04594863,0.02866195,-0.0049836733,0.029799476,0.008624692,0.004233092,0.020177117,-0.04937986,0.015561742,0.028065214,0.026107175,0.00936595,-0.004512812,-0.007193459,-0.0076689827,0.017398568,-0.0020198096,-0.0060512703,0.026181769,0.016904397,0.02394401,0.007897421,-0.009184131,0.017202765,-0.05721201,0.01987875,0.0061445106,-0.025640976,-0.020960333,-0.020661965,-0.001593237,-0.0029790152,-0.012512797,0.03815377,-0.036941655,-0.01006991,0.06761759,0.019300662,-0.011421889,0.015822813,0.00057138584,0.0034242359,0.046545364,0.043039545,-0.02459669,-0.014517454,-0.00033857743,0.020736557,0.0071048816,0.014051255,-0.019804157,0.0036713216,0.014312327,-0.024559394,0.023776177,0.0089277215,0.05620502,-0.039347243,0.0397575,-0.021333292,0.028326286,-0.025268016,0.04400924,0.0013135173,-0.03994398,0.0051048854,-0.008629354,-0.011300677,-0.054564,-0.020456837,-0.01511419,-0.021762196,0.03365961,0.004214444,0.021892732,0.009678303,-0.0122517245,0.04445679,0.03449877,-0.0061864685,-0.0059860023,0.0047878698,0.021240052,-0.013603703,-0.026088528,0.0010367113,0.013426548,0.08287164,0.015272698,-0.015748221,0.00029705654,-0.03457336,-0.0003379947,0.044233017,0.0905546,-0.025622329,0.018843787,0.027710903,0.0028578034,0.0025734217,0.025435848,-0.0029976633,0.0069184015,-0.022862427,0.011170141,0.020233061,-0.023888066,0.005118871,-0.017081553,0.009515134,-0.023608346,0.02810251,-0.056652572,-0.018974323,-0.04456868,0.0049929973,-0.015654981,0.0009533781,-0.05889033,0.03162698,-0.015487149,-0.040988266,0.014797174,0.02551044,-0.01700696,0.051841393,-0.030060548,0.026647968,-0.019766862,-0.030713229,0.07261524,0.049006898,-0.02662932,-0.04613511,-0.01516081,-0.01871325,0.007449869,-0.040801786,0.0028368244,-0.05437752,-0.024951002,-0.017389243,0.007673645,-0.028923022,0.0026340275,-0.00875989,0.03315611,-0.032316953,-0.025734216,-0.024988297,-0.006638682,-0.021668956,0.019953342,0.040615305,-0.002216779,0.008769214,-0.08473644,-0.0048018554,-0.009771543,0.023272682,0.004566425,-0.0058321566,-0.018349616,0.013389252,-0.02856871,-0.039347243,0.01737992,0.0182657,-0.0024055897,-0.024167785,0.060494058,-0.0051142094,-0.03727732,-0.00633099,-0.0038414844,-0.068288915,0.0071328534,-0.026853096,-0.018610686,0.001611885,0.022396227,-0.01067597,-0.0050116456,0.03632627,-0.038899694,0.013641,-0.044792455,0.08719797,-0.013510464,-0.0036596667,0.013249392,0.016885748,-0.009282034,-0.016988313,0.0009772709,-0.05463859,-0.008568748,-0.023794826,-0.07004182,0.026498783,0.008592058,-0.007706279,0.05631691,-0.012354288,0.004221437,-0.010191123,0.0011316994,-0.014396243,0.042107146,0.03199994,0.016783185,-0.009496485,-0.0314405,-0.011254057,-0.026741207,0.032783154,-0.0342004,-0.01525405,0.009263385,-0.0024988297,0.032018587,-0.027412536,-0.048671234,0.023421867,0.006265722,0.017156145,-0.032223713,-0.05064792,-0.032671265,0.029836772,0.0029160783,0.023179444,0.013827479,0.033323944,0.026871743,0.025286665,-0.016177125,-0.037668925,-0.018601364,-0.14202304,0.0006573414,0.0005850805,-0.018797167,-0.014797174,0.006699288,0.050536033,-0.048223685,-0.012960348,0.012475501,0.006382272,-0.026797151,0.015738897,-0.013631675,0.02931463,0.03604655,-0.010526787,-0.0062284265,0.009440541,0.015850786,0.014722583,0.037687574,0.0017039594,0.008731918,0.019095534,-0.008708608,-0.0010227254,-0.04419572,-0.036475454,-0.020885741,-0.009477837,-0.022452172,-0.006508146,0.035897367,0.002298364,0.026853096,0.024354266,-0.021426532,-0.02228434,-0.030358916,0.015104867,-0.0067925276,-0.039421834,-0.041062858,0.03697895,0.026797151,-0.010731914,-0.02922139,-0.0453146,-0.0071981214,-0.015888082,0.021090869,-0.07433086,0.012027949,0.008540777,0.019543085,-0.0058088466,0.035916016,-0.034536064,0.045053527,-0.012997644,0.008289028,-0.010694618,-0.009557092,0.05627961,0.036456805,-0.014461511,0.02560368,0.014974331,0.021668956,-0.0015862441,0.004477847,0.016811157,-0.05777145,0.0128577845,-0.005426563,0.0012610698,-0.0006987166,0.00642423,-0.053109456,-0.058927625,-0.003165495,-0.014853118,0.0030489452,0.052997567,-0.020568725,-0.0139580155,0.018097868,0.027897382,0.009184131,-0.09808839,-0.017491808,-0.007407911,0.069109425,0.007818167,-0.015571065,-0.010983662,0.0088624535,-0.0074871653,-0.052960273,0.005282041,-0.066051155,0.035804126,-0.0047226017,-0.004223768,0.037706222,-0.0014009298,-0.01053611,0.00077447406,0.0026573376,0.0060093123,0.0015897405,-0.030564044,-0.013808832,-0.043710873,0.011030282,-0.026424192,0.0087832,-0.0131748,-0.00051019713,0.03826566,0.0028368244,-0.022918371,-0.03345448,0.0006724929,0.0061305244,0.020923037,-0.017268032,0.08921195,0.010116531,0.031943996,0.010125855,-0.0070302896,-0.014312327,0.008144506,-0.018545419,-0.026927687,0.041174747,0.0009702779,-0.006060594,-0.01997199,0.017594371,0.017762203,-0.008424226,-0.0268158,0.020792501,0.014405567,-0.017864767,0.0342004,-0.037687574,-0.017958008,-0.023645643,0.028270341,0.0009504644,-0.009678303,0.021128165,-0.012606037,0.011319325,0.03845214,0.08854062,0.005393929,-0.0085174665,-0.028177103,-0.0151887825,0.012307669,0.04770154,-0.02431697,-0.0026480136,-0.0014976661,-0.026442839,0.017351948,0.017771527,-0.028829781,0.06027028,-0.035897367,0.011897413,0.008629354,-0.012233077,-0.044158425,-0.009128188,0.014461511,0.05851737,-0.010107207,-0.016354281,-4.03554e-05,0.06306748,-0.002223772,0.00320046,-0.017734231,-0.010144503,-0.03660599,-0.03716543,0.02357105,0.031198075,0.03550576,0.057025533,0.013892747,0.050685216,-0.0027016266,0.0061631585,0.082722455,-0.020382246,-0.044941638,-0.016689945,-0.030657284,-0.0046130447,0.035468463,-0.005202787,-0.020270357,0.025659624,-0.012680628,0.025286665,0.028904373,0.02726335,0.014918386,-0.0050256313,0.023626994,-0.0061724824,0.050685216,-0.056615274,0.013892747,0.044717863,-0.016102534,-0.036829766,-0.00029414278,-0.026405543,-0.016242392,0.062135078,0.0024615338,-0.002330998,0.014620018,-0.0129417,0.049603634,0.017818147,0.031794813,-0.048671234,-0.004293698,-0.003242418,-0.03078782,-0.0021620006,0.00852679,-0.0079347165,-0.024727225,-0.009958023]
CONSTEXT000038657451_3
CONSTEXT000038657451
3
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
à des manquements constatés avec les pouvoirs mentionnés aux mêmes articles ».4. Les requérants soutiennent que l'application combinée des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation méconnaîtrait les principes de nécessité et de proportionnalité des peines en permettant un cumul de sanctions administrative et pénale à raison des mêmes faits. En effet, selon eux, l'article L. 522-1 du code de la consommation permet à l'autorité administrative chargée de la concurrence et de la consommation de prononcer des amendes administratives pour sanctionner les pratiques commerciales trompeuses, qui sont, par ailleurs, réprimées pénalement par l'article L. 132-2 du même code.5. Il découle de l'article 8 de la Déclaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen de 1789 que le principe de nécessité des délits et des peines ne fait pas obstacle à ce que les mêmes faits commis par une même personne puissent faire l'objet de poursuites différentes aux fins de sanctions de nature différente en application de corps de règles distincts. Le contrôle de la conformité d'un cumul de poursuites à ce principe impose de déterminer les faits qui sont poursuivis et sanctionnés, les intérêts sociaux qui sont protégés par l'instauration des sanctions et la nature de ces dernières. Ainsi, pour que le Conseil constitutionnel puisse, dans le cadre d'une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité, contrôler la conformité à ce principe d'une disposition législative instituant une sanction ayant le
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] à des manquements constatés avec les pouvoirs mentionnés aux mêmes articles ».4. Les requérants soutiennent que l'application combinée des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation méconnaîtrait les principes de nécessité et de proportionnalité des peines en permettant un cumul de sanctions administrative et pénale à raison des mêmes faits. En effet, selon eux, l'article L. 522-1 du code de la consommation permet à l'autorité administrative chargée de la concurrence et de la consommation de prononcer des amendes administratives pour sanctionner les pratiques commerciales trompeuses, qui sont, par ailleurs, réprimées pénalement par l'article L. 132-2 du même code.5. Il découle de l'article 8 de la Déclaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen de 1789 que le principe de nécessité des délits et des peines ne fait pas obstacle à ce que les mêmes faits commis par une même personne puissent faire l'objet de poursuites différentes aux fins de sanctions de nature différente en application de corps de règles distincts. Le contrôle de la conformité d'un cumul de poursuites à ce principe impose de déterminer les faits qui sont poursuivis et sanctionnés, les intérêts sociaux qui sont protégés par l'instauration des sanctions et la nature de ces dernières. Ainsi, pour que le Conseil constitutionnel puisse, dans le cadre d'une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité, contrôler la conformité à ce principe d'une disposition législative instituant une sanction ayant le
[-0.028174777,0.031240426,0.012654928,-0.022663908,-0.018302657,-0.05806486,-0.01249982,0.013713306,-0.054415274,0.0046554985,-0.04186071,-0.0065555624,-0.08605716,0.014370231,-0.061933417,-0.021295315,0.025656564,0.0056751007,-0.004139995,-0.032225814,-0.025109127,-0.0050957296,0.021039844,-0.0007116686,0.0055108694,0.056422547,-0.009452418,-0.0050957296,-0.022225957,0.009479791,0.004457053,0.015018032,0.031495895,-0.014050893,0.0052964566,-0.0139505295,-0.046933632,0.038430102,-0.026459472,-0.01249982,-0.015592841,0.019561762,0.006131299,-0.09729787,0.057480924,-0.018740606,0.008977973,-0.02412374,-0.013129373,0.0032390044,-0.040400878,0.022006983,0.0647071,-0.043685503,0.007983462,0.07715218,-0.010519922,0.021167578,-0.050583214,-0.029324396,-0.027317125,-0.018339152,-0.053393394,-0.02001796,0.0070117605,-0.010264451,0.012654928,-0.042079687,0.0003330244,-0.05576562,0.002193171,0.007084752,-0.00011433458,-0.009187824,-0.084743306,0.025857292,0.020857364,0.0020928076,0.01826616,-0.007969776,0.0024155674,0.015912179,-0.00546525,0.025182119,0.0463132,0.017499749,-0.04091182,-0.002181766,0.042700116,-0.050473727,-0.009265377,0.012609308,-0.011058235,0.020346422,-0.0028101786,0.018503383,-0.055035703,-0.005611233,0.016824575,0.043867983,0.0019445432,0.036021378,0.04317456,-0.03171487,-0.011523557,-0.032481283,0.0047125234,0.023266088,0.028339008,0.0061267368,-0.008813742,0.015209635,0.036660057,-0.01342134,-0.0071988013,-0.0045049535,0.050291248,-0.015401239,0.04999928,0.0048265727,-0.016058164,0.012043622,0.050364237,-0.046386193,-0.049597826,0.021988735,-0.007308289,0.013932281,-0.01905082,0.028412,0.021131083,0.002696129,-0.020875612,-0.029415635,-0.039926432,-0.011788151,0.023722285,-0.023375576,0.0051185396,-0.06762677,0.042554133,0.033174705,-0.035108984,-0.03215282,0.027609091,0.009461543,-0.00024976832,0.0010925938,-0.0071486197,0.004967994,0.002504526,0.008599329,0.06623992,0.010437806,0.031057946,-0.0051641595,-0.017280772,0.03346667,0.02246318,0.032134574,-0.0033576158,-0.013247984,0.009935988,0.031879105,3.6531466e-05,-0.022627411,0.002894575,0.016231518,-0.042736612,-0.004995366,0.05386784,0.0010173211,0.021824503,-0.02124057,-0.028083537,0.023996005,0.022590917,0.030401023,-0.034762274,-0.0022251047,-0.023466816,0.009274501,-0.018758854,0.0048493827,-0.009069213,-0.013667687,0.015018032,-0.020930355,0.040583357,0.061057515,-0.014881172,-0.020747876,0.081166714,0.040327888,-0.020401167,-0.06339325,-0.023010617,-0.044086955,0.012956018,-0.0043110694,0.011304582,0.008754436,0.01625889,-0.025474086,-0.06773625,-0.05551015,-0.08817391,0.020492407,0.009680518,-0.072042756,-0.0055245557,0.025547078,-0.013612943,0.024817161,-0.03576591,0.012563688,0.0086586345,0.024707673,-0.00042740031,-0.042882595,0.006263596,0.041641735,-0.03857609,0.040692843,0.03766369,-0.01503628,-0.0012123457,0.04222567,0.018302657,-0.03067474,-0.008987097,0.04510884,0.0681742,-0.033886373,0.006441513,-0.012919522,0.0022262454,0.051970053,0.007481644,-0.020747876,-0.023266088,-0.08664109,0.0541963,-0.013293604,-0.030054312,-0.025145624,-0.0023425757,0.0065783723,-0.001755221,-0.012472448,-0.03129517,0.009954236,-0.007066504,0.014306364,-0.019835481,0.010282699,0.0026094515,-0.010474302,0.0332112,-0.01171516,0.018275285,0.04186071,0.034853514,0.010182335,-0.02465293,-0.02352156,-0.0192333,-0.04842996,0.029233156,-0.026058018,-0.0057480927,0.010364815,0.0024155674,-0.00041342925,0.042079687,0.046021234,0.0034214836,-0.0067699756,0.06321077,-0.012353837,0.022207709,0.006464323,0.030401023,-0.002917385,0.015127519,0.0046486557,-0.032408293,-0.043503024,-0.012764415,-0.095327094,0.054962713,-0.033247698,0.08795494,0.019379282,-0.046130724,-0.0128009105,-0.02525511,-0.13269882,0.008818304,0.0065783723,0.010766269,0.0011490482,0.030017816,0.03609437,-0.04178772,0.010072848,-0.0062727197,-0.04492636,-0.0734296,-0.031112691,-0.018485134,0.04773654,-0.003521847,-0.007828355,-0.0030565253,-0.017171286,-0.0061267368,-0.04791902,-0.04186071,-0.013275356,-0.034397315,0.006254472,0.029324396,0.013923157,0.018621994,-0.04065635,-0.022937626,-0.008699692,0.019871976,-0.021222323,0.01123159,-8.019102e-05,0.030090807,0.03437907,-0.017052675,0.030747732,-0.017892078,0.070728905,0.07598431,-0.018339152,0.025218615,0.011268086,-0.021660272,-0.015173139,-0.018621994,-0.012198729,0.0040806895,-0.065692484,0.0018624276,-0.057736397,0.019835481,-0.03872207,-0.0073447847,0.007832916,0.007741677,-0.01826616,0.026094515,-0.024707673,-0.062407862,0.005647729,-0.024944896,-0.044269435,-0.030875469,0.04448841,0.03171487,0.025401095,-0.029525122,0.032463036,-0.01342134,-0.018777102,-0.0034625414,-0.026714943,0.04302858,0.015647585,0.033886373,-0.014114761,-0.09240743,-0.01985373,0.027937554,-0.026915671,0.0367148,-0.022061726,0.001671965,-0.0028033357,0.011158599,0.03923301,0.22758797,-0.010665905,0.02963461,0.0072991652,-0.018348277,-0.007326537,-0.004669185,0.0323353,-0.015437734,-0.011377573,0.014634826,-0.019653002,0.033083465,-0.00024606168,0.0036541445,0.00108404,-0.015264379,-0.021550784,0.06390419,-0.023284337,-0.014853801,-0.027955802,0.019014325,0.0032640954,-0.0013594695,-0.026441226,0.002728063,-0.06408667,0.0024589063,-0.01752712,-0.022864634,-0.0034556985,0.081166714,-0.0454738,0.0069889505,-0.024871904,-0.038138136,-0.021806255,0.021003347,0.043320544,0.02282814,-0.012700547,0.0051322253,-0.028375505,0.018850094,-0.020766124,0.009543658,0.032992225,0.00029652857,0.027517851,-0.022207709,-0.013539951,-0.042006694,-0.0051185396,-0.0428461,-0.003143203,-0.026185755,0.028448496,-0.0074770823,0.03748121,0.046386193,-0.025601821,0.017116541,0.05620357,-0.039561473,0.011341077,-0.02762734,-0.033685647,0.05525468,0.014379355,0.027700331,0.017682226,-0.009908617,0.039014038,0.046203714,0.013558199,-0.00034300372,-0.029050676,-0.047700044,-0.029525122,-0.027773323,-0.018621994,-0.013165869,-0.031149186,0.005770902,0.017335517,0.01870411,0.06696984,0.013795421,-0.0059853154,-0.023083609,-0.028375505,-0.0018270722,0.077809095,-0.018813597,-0.011797275,0.015738824,-0.016842823,-0.039926432,-0.023101857,0.013247984,-0.038247626,-0.0014746594,0.019634753,0.06696984,0.046714656,-0.02001796,0.008006272,-0.006893149,-0.014972412,0.01757274,0.035619926,0.01249982,-0.026167506,-0.014881172,0.045327816,-0.045510292,0.023448568,0.057991866,0.04529132,0.00022453486,0.065181546,-0.03226231,-0.021897495,-0.01976249,-0.026970414,-0.018868342,-0.008161379,-0.0183574,0.01766398,0.0021829065,0.0012157671,-0.013777174,0.012216978,0.0017951383,-0.0032184755,0.033594407,-0.02797405,-0.03339368,0.013494331,-0.016952312,0.046094228,-0.021350058,0.029050676,0.02218946,0.053028435,-0.010830136,0.040802334,-0.073539086,0.035437446,0.019999713,0.023193097,0.027025158,-0.034397315,-0.021988735,-0.06923258,0.012554564,-0.02063839,0.012408581,0.010684153,-0.016049039,0.023485063,-0.058794774,0.00878637,0.018904837,0.027061654,0.0067380415,0.0026824432,-0.004176491,-0.009443295,0.018284408,-0.028904693,-0.008275429,0.035546932,0.01817492,0.03733523,-0.01367681,-0.011587424,0.010410434,-0.06233487,0.017919451,-0.0030496824,-0.036240354,0.0134487115,-0.02324784,0.0030816162,0.00080062717,-0.029616361,0.052043047,-0.03653232,0.017746095,0.073904045,0.026860926,-0.0053420765,0.025638318,0.04861244,0.0038160947,0.02359455,0.059999138,-0.024160236,0.003567467,-0.04842996,0.007682371,-0.0021623776,0.022791643,-0.014561834,-0.029853584,0.032280557,-0.027171142,0.04091182,0.024360964,0.05850281,-0.040765837,0.022244206,0.0063593974,0.04186071,-0.014242495,0.030820724,0.012262598,-0.033941116,-0.0059761913,-0.024105493,0.011815524,-0.0236128,0.0026345423,0.012855655,0.006879463,0.01625889,-0.0037271362,-0.0017905764,0.010036352,-0.006012687,0.025145624,0.04003592,-0.006195166,0.009908617,0.005259961,0.015264379,-0.020601893,-0.03288274,0.009370303,-0.016952312,0.07470696,0.007892222,-0.008613015,-0.00747252,-0.012654928,-0.008029082,0.046714656,0.07229823,0.0034465746,0.017143914,0.03532796,-0.018393897,0.02771858,0.042955585,-0.02089386,0.02412374,-0.024817161,0.003939268,0.022882883,-0.021952238,0.020674884,-0.033795133,-0.022809891,-0.01665122,0.034306075,-0.032134574,-0.01171516,-0.052517492,0.007686933,-0.0131020015,0.0042814165,-0.05602109,0.032098077,0.002899137,-0.025127375,0.017536243,0.02465293,-0.01958001,0.04430593,-0.024725921,0.010857508,0.00539682,-0.02167852,0.063867696,0.056678016,-0.010109344,-0.043758493,-0.003918739,-0.0084350975,0.02456169,-0.03374039,-0.0013663125,-0.05295544,-0.021879246,-0.02218946,0.020492407,-0.032992225,-0.0044023087,0.0004208425,0.017417632,-0.019525267,-0.012508944,-0.030017816,0.006373083,-0.0101549635,0.025565326,0.062042903,0.023174848,0.010300946,-0.071458824,0.007093876,-0.020291679,0.015173139,0.0024155674,-0.005410506,-0.043904476,0.00440459,-0.04153225,-0.02806529,0.05313792,0.010182335,-0.004194739,-0.017490624,0.04799201,0.0031568888,-0.04116729,-0.008238932,0.008321048,-0.05832033,0.0077918586,-0.035656422,-0.009196948,0.0091787,-0.008517213,0.008891296,-0.032736756,0.066495396,-0.04572927,0.025401095,-0.045437302,0.099414624,-0.033703893,0.013457836,-0.010209707,0.016751584,-2.9670678e-05,-0.031149186,-0.021167578,-0.060108624,-0.031879105,-0.036952022,-0.05864879,0.026714943,0.008206999,0.025839044,0.024944896,0.029506875,0.010638533,-0.007312851,0.005634043,-0.031441152,0.036313348,0.021094587,0.019105565,0.0023973195,-0.034032356,-0.011687788,-0.017764343,0.03766369,-0.049232867,-0.009981608,-0.012956018,-0.010173211,0.020236935,-0.047262095,-0.0550722,-0.002317485,0.025455838,0.0066969837,-0.050583214,-0.04317456,-0.015802693,0.0014028082,0.017727846,0.020328175,0.044123452,0.0065418766,0.01932454,0.0017187253,-0.003544657,-0.048210986,-0.0030884591,-0.14043593,-0.0052964566,0.002211419,-0.006911397,-0.024689425,0.0057754642,0.029762344,-0.05025475,-0.03616736,-0.0003658136,0.016596476,-0.036587063,0.039488483,-0.015921304,0.024725921,0.028010545,-0.018740606,-0.011532681,0.025309855,0.005196093,0.011195094,0.02142305,-0.00025846457,0.0032207565,-0.015948676,-0.0070117605,-0.0166056,-0.03235355,-0.03156889,-0.00020799768,-0.0014929073,-0.0086267,-0.008631263,0.016623849,0.0077462387,0.018375648,0.029798841,-0.0073675946,0.0022581792,-0.026131012,0.002211419,-0.012262598,-0.014926792,-0.021933991,0.031057946,0.02631349,-0.0030816162,-0.018375648,-0.030182047,-0.025090879,-0.008056453,0.019069068,-0.062042903,0.017892078,0.0060719927,-0.012746166,-0.0011735689,0.052262023,-0.049415346,0.05919623,-0.018028937,0.023923013,-0.0012910399,-0.027061654,0.032827996,0.03364915,-0.04737158,0.02211647,0.021532537,0.018147549,-0.0066331164,-0.01639575,-0.0029698478,-0.036222108,-0.010483426,-0.0066969837,0.018868342,0.01914206,0.030984955,-0.053612366,-0.09342931,0.008813742,-0.0018031219,-0.044123452,0.071130365,-0.048977397,-0.012883026,-0.004835697,0.003138641,-0.015939552,-0.08021782,-0.019014325,-0.015191387,0.04145926,0.016049039,-0.008800056,-0.00929275,-0.008138569,-0.0016080973,-0.03784617,-0.01328448,-0.047517564,0.0498533,-0.006915959,-0.009123956,0.014835553,0.003546938,-0.0185855,-0.00578915,0.014981536,-0.007668685,0.017034426,-0.031422906,-0.00749533,-0.06189692,-3.107402e-06,-0.020747876,0.01939753,-0.040400878,0.041313276,0.040875323,0.0032755004,-0.0056751007,-0.021879246,0.0039027722,2.3487059e-05,0.028138282,0.0045505734,0.06408667,0.011030863,0.011258962,0.0071714297,-0.03315646,-0.014534462,-0.0028352693,-0.012518068,-0.045072343,0.036331594,0.016003419,-0.027025158,-0.0024429392,-0.005816522,0.023065362,-0.0019422622,-0.017162161,-0.011496185,0.014187752,0.024050748,0.006728918,-0.04835697,-0.0472256,-0.02562007,0.029944824,0.04434243,-0.004384061,-0.0036085248,-0.008138569,0.028028794,0.021806255,0.08357544,-0.005237151,-0.00094489974,-0.031021452,-0.021039844,-0.028795205,0.050145265,-0.018777102,-0.016140278,-0.013074629,-0.013494331,0.0117516555,0.029525122,-0.024871904,0.018977828,-0.019835481,-0.020437662,0.005615795,-0.012408581,-0.048904404,-0.03410535,0.0063867695,0.05664152,0.009092023,-0.012591059,0.0063183396,0.05926922,0.006222538,0.013567323,-0.009092023,-0.008179626,-0.046094228,-0.018056309,0.039087027,0.02638648,0.038685575,0.05386784,0.041824214,0.034397315,-0.002926509,-0.014707818,0.045583285,-0.025930284,-0.039123524,-0.0023300303,-0.03076598,0.0009471807,0.030273287,-0.02368579,-0.01289215,0.043867983,-0.029433884,0.023357328,0.021897495,0.031787865,0.013138497,-0.0007681231,0.029853584,-0.014689569,0.04116729,-0.035875395,0.007723429,0.03861258,-0.012116614,-0.028539736,-0.018028937,0.0011005772,-0.024853656,0.033685647,0.020766124,-0.0019331382,0.0062955297,0.0030496824,0.029214907,0.0014050893,0.01381367,-0.039853442,-0.018457763,0.02437921,-0.026952166,-0.009899492,0.029616361,-0.006058307,-0.014853801,-0.004858507]
CONSTEXT000038657451_4
CONSTEXT000038657451
4
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
le Conseil constitutionnel puisse, dans le cadre d'une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité, contrôler la conformité à ce principe d'une disposition législative instituant une sanction ayant le caractère de punition, il est nécessaire que le requérant désigne, au cours de la procédure, la disposition instituant l'autre sanction entraînant le cumul dénoncé.6. Or, les articles L. 121-2 à L. 121-4 du code de la consommation, qui figurent à la section 1 du chapitre Ier du titre II du livre Ier de ce code, définissent les pratiques commerciales trompeuses. L'article L. 132-2 du même code réprime pénalement ces pratiques.7. L'article L. 522-1 du code de la consommation se borne à donner compétence à l'autorité administrative chargée de la concurrence et de la consommation pour prononcer les amendes administratives sanctionnant les manquements aux dispositions mentionnées aux articles L. 511-5, L. 511-6 et L. 511-7 du même code. Il n'a ni pour objet ni pour effet d'instituer une sanction administrative. Le renvoi à l'article L. 511-5, lequel mentionne la section 1 du chapitre Ier du titre II du livre Ier du code de la consommation, n'a, en tout état de cause, pas davantage cet effet. 8. Dès lors, il ne saurait résulter des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation un cumul de poursuites. 9. Par suite, en l'absence de désignation par les requérants de l'autre disposition législative entraînant le cumul dénoncé, il n'y a pas lieu pour le Conseil constitutionnel
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] le Conseil constitutionnel puisse, dans le cadre d'une question prioritaire de constitutionnalité, contrôler la conformité à ce principe d'une disposition législative instituant une sanction ayant le caractère de punition, il est nécessaire que le requérant désigne, au cours de la procédure, la disposition instituant l'autre sanction entraînant le cumul dénoncé.6. Or, les articles L. 121-2 à L. 121-4 du code de la consommation, qui figurent à la section 1 du chapitre Ier du titre II du livre Ier de ce code, définissent les pratiques commerciales trompeuses. L'article L. 132-2 du même code réprime pénalement ces pratiques.7. L'article L. 522-1 du code de la consommation se borne à donner compétence à l'autorité administrative chargée de la concurrence et de la consommation pour prononcer les amendes administratives sanctionnant les manquements aux dispositions mentionnées aux articles L. 511-5, L. 511-6 et L. 511-7 du même code. Il n'a ni pour objet ni pour effet d'instituer une sanction administrative. Le renvoi à l'article L. 511-5, lequel mentionne la section 1 du chapitre Ier du titre II du livre Ier du code de la consommation, n'a, en tout état de cause, pas davantage cet effet. 8. Dès lors, il ne saurait résulter des articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation un cumul de poursuites. 9. Par suite, en l'absence de désignation par les requérants de l'autre disposition législative entraînant le cumul dénoncé, il n'y a pas lieu pour le Conseil constitutionnel
[-0.02846942,0.03616583,0.029746076,-0.011772589,-0.027904043,-0.07025254,0.0007568744,0.009392538,-0.05668351,0.031952865,-0.02881594,-0.009666107,-0.07805837,-0.00092272565,-0.053473633,-0.023180418,0.029600171,-0.0036498671,0.0047145067,-0.027119813,-0.022687994,-0.022086142,0.009857605,-0.0010737586,0.0006554259,0.040597647,-0.016833616,0.006392397,-0.0031255265,0.00796086,0.0023241972,-0.004906005,0.049753092,-0.013623739,0.015994672,-0.0154931275,-0.014991584,0.017444586,-0.019405166,0.013031006,-0.00247352,0.018985692,0.011380473,-0.09461842,0.044427615,-0.021338386,0.020098208,-0.0213931,0.004887767,0.01210999,-0.052014597,0.009014101,0.08221662,-0.05817902,-0.010103817,0.059090916,0.014745372,0.006871143,-0.048075203,-0.02166667,-0.020098208,-0.018730361,-0.015803173,-0.0028337196,0.006729799,-0.007295175,0.015319867,-0.03527217,0.009821129,-0.068246365,0.02387346,0.019660497,0.010933643,-0.010377387,-0.07010663,0.025751967,0.02325337,-0.0015205881,0.02582492,-0.02121072,0.0013165511,0.0032326744,-0.004942481,0.0017930171,0.048038725,0.0027288513,-0.027393382,-0.010678312,0.027101574,-0.061571278,-0.013815237,0.010632717,-0.0043269508,0.016833616,-0.026025536,-0.0007015907,-0.04340629,-0.019241024,-0.020499442,0.048658818,-0.010650955,0.037716053,0.053473633,-0.030712686,0.019642258,-0.011654042,0.023764033,0.009246634,0.024201743,0.0058680563,-0.0010663494,0.016742427,0.025879633,-0.0120643955,-0.0078103966,0.009748178,0.047017403,-0.012009681,0.017006876,0.0034515297,-0.019514592,-0.0042426,0.047528066,-0.0374972,-0.047601014,0.022615042,0.00857639,0.0148548,-0.021940239,0.035636928,0.014626825,0.013113077,-0.0427862,-0.006127947,-0.043734573,-0.012483868,0.021684907,-0.018547982,-0.007381805,-0.09476432,0.021429576,0.036494114,-0.053619534,-0.030037882,0.044427615,0.021174245,0.011307521,-0.011325759,-0.011015714,0.022122618,-0.013122195,0.026773293,0.05040966,0.0041582496,0.007814956,-0.0050336705,-0.0043018735,0.040086985,0.01936869,0.0027356907,0.0031323656,-0.0029317485,-0.029071271,0.03191639,0.016596522,-0.00786967,-0.014134401,0.011599328,-0.037278343,-0.0034948448,0.05701179,0.011161618,0.01918631,-0.006611252,-0.022651518,0.02378227,0.019313976,0.03702301,-0.042859152,0.006050436,-0.0069623324,0.02068182,-0.018785076,0.023180418,-0.022779183,0.007213104,-0.0014430768,-0.0004057941,0.043369815,0.054531433,-0.008170595,-0.021046579,0.07980921,0.0307674,0.00029893118,-0.038846806,0.011216331,-0.05854378,0.0014955108,0.0027539285,-0.0064334325,0.003909758,-0.0009734499,-0.034360275,-0.054567907,-0.039758705,-0.07262347,0.012848627,0.007381805,-0.08141415,-0.011243688,0.026116727,0.0006223696,0.00023039644,-0.00892747,0.013769642,-0.01645062,0.015930839,-0.0026672983,-0.04220259,-0.00884084,0.053801917,-0.030949779,0.037260104,0.04880472,-0.016386786,-0.0066249305,0.021520765,0.034287322,-0.000108715205,-0.0045663235,0.021137768,0.0427862,-0.022396186,0.0035746356,-0.010195007,0.0022432662,0.067334466,0.01687921,-0.045667794,-0.045996077,-0.0666779,0.055115048,-0.024292933,-0.034269083,-0.0049151243,-0.009315026,0.0075550657,-0.010578004,-0.031989343,-0.04738216,0.01882155,-0.0049835164,0.009647869,-0.012301489,0.008640223,-0.005138539,0.0065018246,0.030694447,-0.0022238884,0.016122336,0.052671164,0.03775253,0.00610059,-0.028834179,-0.011380473,-0.021520765,-0.059273295,0.016550928,-0.020736534,-0.014873038,0.013468716,0.030603258,0.006921297,0.013733166,0.05916387,0.0022307276,-0.007418281,0.081122346,-0.012529463,0.012274132,-0.02015292,0.020262348,0.0046278764,0.03569164,0.018584458,-0.06427049,-0.029344842,0.005498738,-0.07203985,0.053947818,-0.039758705,0.09790125,0.021922,-0.046470262,-0.004586841,-0.015137488,-0.13291809,0.007222223,-0.0017884577,-0.018028202,0.006319445,0.014435328,0.03510803,-0.026828006,-0.0007215384,0.009278551,-0.024548264,-0.07379069,-0.044245236,-0.021046579,0.038007863,-0.013751404,-0.017626965,-0.0016140575,0.0057267123,-0.0052616447,-0.03738777,-0.031788725,-0.044354662,-0.025405446,-0.0056081656,0.02431117,0.030493831,0.046360835,-0.045047704,0.016085861,0.022414425,0.011207213,-0.019970542,0.020754773,0.011024833,0.018228818,-0.0006827828,-0.044938277,0.042056683,-0.0064972653,0.08126825,0.069121785,-0.024511788,0.029891979,0.019441642,-0.04041527,0.0034104942,-0.014490041,0.0041696485,0.0036567063,-0.072732896,-0.0010070761,-0.042822678,0.005019992,-0.038919758,0.0012846347,0.03156987,-0.0026308224,-0.039320994,0.006241934,-0.03067621,-0.07265994,-0.01831089,-0.023526939,-0.046397313,-0.0065610977,0.030530307,0.02210438,0.014024974,0.0060777925,0.018338246,-0.0369683,-0.0023059591,-0.0151283685,-0.0043702656,0.013942903,-0.0012173823,0.05471381,-0.026499722,-0.10898991,0.0046369955,0.04136364,-0.043296862,0.04289563,-0.029326603,0.0017793387,-0.0048558507,0.015228678,0.025788443,0.20659935,0.034998603,0.05161336,-0.0007460456,-0.01893098,0.006127947,-0.010368267,0.0213931,-0.0029385877,-0.027119813,0.0042403205,-0.009821129,0.029071271,0.0033899767,-0.0030160989,0.016459739,0.0028838739,-0.007126474,0.056172848,-0.033813134,-0.012620652,-0.024876546,0.031059207,0.007089998,-0.026736816,-0.034998603,0.0091417665,-0.06430697,-0.0019377809,-0.0033512209,-0.016915686,0.025916109,0.09279463,-0.04774692,0.00645623,-0.03616583,-0.05340068,-0.011945849,0.0062829694,0.0633586,0.024949498,-0.021137768,0.0029955811,-0.014271186,0.038518522,-0.01645062,0.017554015,0.015484009,0.002881594,0.007947181,-0.031040968,-0.02077301,-0.018894503,-0.008781567,-0.06251965,-0.012474749,-0.025970822,0.014125282,-0.0021440976,0.037971385,0.04818463,-0.025916109,0.019222787,0.043150958,-0.022049665,-0.005019992,-0.014599469,-0.04887767,0.04668912,0.025934346,0.009793772,0.010231483,-0.01829265,0.04632436,0.0376431,-0.0073225317,-0.009328705,-0.034414988,-0.06361392,-0.025751967,-0.014809205,-0.008170595,-0.0061233873,-0.027393382,0.01397026,0.01291246,0.03146044,0.052452307,0.01476361,-0.009036898,-0.013103958,-0.019405166,0.006114268,0.079955116,-0.03913861,-0.020827724,0.014699778,-0.01007646,-0.04935186,-0.013897308,0.010149412,-0.06540124,0.0064288727,-0.009939676,0.0728788,0.034725033,0.020298824,0.013286337,-0.012930698,0.0013142714,0.0017041073,0.03775253,-0.017398993,-0.03253648,-0.009178242,0.037606627,-0.06536476,0.02175786,0.05661056,0.018611815,-0.004413581,0.08010102,-0.024274694,-0.0010133454,-0.019204548,0.0019833758,0.0005175015,0.023709318,-0.014371495,-0.0051795742,0.009574917,-0.0001768225,-0.019988779,0.034797985,0.0035883142,-0.0067161205,0.054349054,-0.0077237664,-0.02325337,0.009784653,-0.019879352,0.025751967,-0.0058908537,0.014444446,0.016477976,0.04526656,-0.020754773,0.050628513,-0.038044337,0.027265716,0.029819027,0.029873742,0.034506176,-0.036475874,-0.009333264,-0.06777217,0.016933925,-0.013587263,0.01370581,0.0027881246,-0.017006876,0.02183081,-0.05226993,-0.005412108,0.022760946,0.034560893,-0.00025262393,-0.0027630476,-0.0063012075,0.009711701,0.017736394,-0.014006736,-0.020007018,0.024548264,-0.002060887,0.041071836,0.017098065,-0.025350733,0.038518522,-0.07521325,0.024019362,0.008763329,-0.022031428,-0.005434905,-0.0069532134,0.0035153625,-0.0031232468,-0.01971521,0.055443328,-0.038190242,-0.015711984,0.07805837,0.028615324,-0.009438133,0.020627107,0.02952722,-0.0023412951,0.049461287,0.044792373,-0.036913585,-0.004146851,-0.04041527,-0.002712893,-0.0077420045,0.024785357,-0.0029135104,0.0012253614,0.028268803,-0.029928455,0.0323541,0.0025624302,0.061133567,-0.057267122,0.034013752,0.0019776763,0.03536336,-0.02775814,0.027976995,0.004887767,-0.05030023,0.005576249,-0.014034092,0.009246634,-0.031788725,0.004472854,0.00875421,-0.012930698,0.033886086,0.001987935,0.008238988,0.0087359715,-0.005699355,0.0364394,0.03685887,0.011772589,-0.0067024417,0.01935045,0.016477976,-0.018429436,-0.040780026,0.0071219145,0.01935045,0.073352985,-0.0060230787,-0.018365603,0.007919825,-0.038482048,0.0114351865,0.03924804,0.0834568,-0.013450479,-0.004554925,0.030712686,-0.009602274,0.009720821,0.031004494,-0.024602978,0.004746423,0.0048330533,-0.0009124668,0.031934626,-0.024347646,0.009438133,-0.009647869,0.00035820447,-0.01105219,0.025150115,-0.04993547,-0.023399273,-0.059966337,-0.0020016136,-0.008088525,0.00247352,-0.0583614,0.01989759,0.0011119442,-0.05686589,0.024475312,0.017900536,-0.022304997,0.07017958,-0.022487376,0.014599469,-0.022615042,-0.029545458,0.07557801,0.054349054,-0.017654324,-0.037789006,-0.011353116,-0.030986255,0.009976151,-0.02830528,-0.025314257,-0.04843996,-0.021557242,-0.029326603,0.023727557,-0.027612237,0.004181047,-0.009766416,0.018730361,-0.030420879,-0.029053034,-0.029399555,0.014800086,-0.003984989,0.016250001,0.05358306,0.020663584,0.012356202,-0.09593155,0.009866724,0.00048302035,0.013058363,0.010030866,-0.009702583,-0.025952585,-0.01193673,-0.028943606,-0.061936036,0.01786406,0.027648713,-0.009429013,-0.01989759,0.041874304,-0.018593578,-0.06251965,0.004942481,6.9888345e-05,-0.05059204,0.0031984781,-0.028578848,-0.013578144,-0.013003649,0.03467032,-0.014216472,-0.037716053,0.040159937,-0.005713034,0.02881594,-0.03616583,0.07754771,-0.023964649,0.012684485,0.010906287,0.01741723,0.008498879,-0.02237795,0.0029659446,-0.060367573,-0.011125142,-0.02387346,-0.05526095,0.018228818,0.013833475,0.017727274,0.045558367,0.002219329,0.014189115,-0.017225731,0.0077830395,-0.011827302,0.026390295,0.026718577,-0.013021887,0.0027539285,-0.024493549,-0.019824637,-0.019751687,0.027429858,-0.04800225,-0.005412108,-0.0006930416,-0.00049584394,0.013386646,-0.04471942,-0.049278907,-0.0014624546,0.0039735907,0.012447393,-0.042384967,-0.06536476,-0.033813134,0.026062012,-0.010331792,0.030840352,0.026499722,0.023764033,-0.004810256,0.006684204,-0.007947181,-0.02122896,-0.028414706,-0.13765995,0.005170455,-0.012720961,-0.0034241728,-0.02334456,0.015037179,0.018894503,-0.034123182,-0.01882155,0.0044865324,0.00073350704,-0.033120096,0.022742707,-0.026846243,0.03607464,0.029344842,-0.020882439,-0.009912319,0.018712124,0.02465769,0.013778762,0.036640014,-0.008708615,-0.01935045,0.0018887664,-0.026809767,-0.0069714515,-0.0337949,-0.03343014,-0.036293495,0.013596382,-0.029198937,-0.0039599123,0.030803876,0.016678594,0.030986255,0.025150115,-0.013578144,0.000742626,-0.04413581,0.01893098,-0.0097299395,-0.019241024,-0.03986813,0.02520483,0.012128228,0.0024712405,-0.025970822,-0.039466895,-0.005790545,-0.008945708,0.018949216,-0.061753657,0.00813868,-0.001954879,0.00707176,-0.009748178,0.04110831,-0.060951184,0.06748037,0.0018294931,0.014024974,-0.013806119,-0.02121072,0.043150958,0.025095401,-0.01989759,0.006041317,0.0078103966,0.0026217035,-0.01238356,-0.0104321,-0.008389452,-0.045339514,-0.01636855,-0.007240461,0.013742286,-0.0045024906,0.05015433,-0.045667794,-0.081122346,-0.015447533,-0.018247057,-0.00074376585,0.03483446,-0.05146746,0.0082891425,-0.002783565,0.010778621,-0.008466963,-0.08367565,-0.018666528,0.0077237664,0.057850737,0.008321059,-0.025934346,0.0033170248,-0.004413581,-0.01290334,-0.034779746,-0.004322391,-0.04880472,0.03826319,0.003738777,-0.009830249,0.01724397,0.014088807,0.008535354,0.004076179,0.012301489,-0.006036757,0.020262348,-0.03924804,-0.021794334,-0.054239627,-0.005197812,-0.02484007,0.0025601503,-0.032609433,-0.0075915414,0.047418635,0.003845925,-0.03782548,-0.0286518,-0.007769361,0.024183504,0.039977558,-0.00044141506,0.086301915,0.002058607,0.026572675,0.020809487,-0.03403199,-0.019824637,0.008425927,-0.012529463,-0.045303036,0.04234849,0.016505333,-0.0003810019,-0.005840699,-0.010249721,0.0124291545,-0.005986603,0.0028314397,-0.0009768695,0.0023458546,-0.0014305383,-0.0071766283,-0.047710445,-0.030949779,-0.008713175,0.032062292,0.030037882,-0.013988498,0.025423685,-0.015256034,0.004883208,0.016049385,0.069741875,0.012812151,0.016414143,-0.032171723,-0.019514592,-0.0038846806,0.05861673,-9.717401e-05,-0.004828494,-0.0031278061,-0.010951881,0.0153837,0.030730924,-0.019003931,0.046652645,-0.033667233,-0.007646255,0.0069076186,-0.014380613,-0.05365601,-0.0066887634,0.017736394,0.031971104,-0.017754631,-0.016943043,0.027958758,0.058033116,0.016669475,0.011590209,-0.025332496,-0.00777848,-0.030274976,-0.021976715,0.041035358,0.026116727,0.04544894,0.043296862,0.019952303,0.0625926,0.008321059,0.0023732116,0.065000005,-0.040196415,-0.055479806,-0.006310326,-0.028633561,-0.005225169,0.042384967,-0.012939816,0.0021383981,0.020481203,-0.027593998,0.018712124,0.015018941,0.033484854,0.010304434,-0.034889173,0.004315552,0.00583614,0.03775253,-0.023964649,0.028688274,0.05577161,-0.009032338,-0.046433788,-0.027046861,-0.004306433,-0.02527778,0.04439114,0.027101574,-0.010559766,0.0012253614,0.0043885037,0.034323797,-0.0027744463,0.033813134,-0.04409933,-0.02571549,-0.00069589127,-0.033630755,-0.011225451,0.01626824,-0.012593295,-0.008982184,-0.0040966966]
CONSTEXT000038657451_5
CONSTEXT000038657451
5
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
un cumul de poursuites. 9. Par suite, en l'absence de désignation par les requérants de l'autre disposition législative entraînant le cumul dénoncé, il n'y a pas lieu pour le Conseil constitutionnel de statuer sur la question prioritaire de constitutionnalité.
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] un cumul de poursuites. 9. Par suite, en l'absence de désignation par les requérants de l'autre disposition législative entraînant le cumul dénoncé, il n'y a pas lieu pour le Conseil constitutionnel de statuer sur la question prioritaire de constitutionnalité.
[-0.039338864,0.06292004,0.03985551,-0.018304013,-0.06856624,-0.043213706,-0.0019028238,-0.0033605022,-0.049302742,-0.004338438,-0.0018624609,-0.02090569,-0.0919629,-0.0039786315,-0.0624772,-0.009350361,0.04306609,0.004006309,-0.0141800735,-0.028895244,-0.024669822,0.0105543295,-0.0059921653,0.0048297127,-0.007459069,0.033895634,-0.022437176,0.029725568,-0.021938981,-0.004306148,-0.011818266,-0.008884457,0.0681603,0.0008729925,-0.04236493,-0.04029835,-0.0020319852,0.020979498,-0.018562334,0.03341589,-0.0033512763,0.037438348,-0.011190911,-0.07638973,0.045354094,-0.032493312,0.038748413,-0.011043297,0.002850776,0.010628136,-0.06539256,0.0106650395,0.055539392,-0.048933707,-0.008842941,0.022308014,-0.014023235,0.016643366,-0.018405495,-0.02771434,-0.0062689395,0.014189299,-0.014788977,-0.026681049,0.01180904,-0.0038148735,0.015536268,-0.020352142,0.015665429,-0.06494972,0.023359757,0.014964268,-0.0029637923,-0.021846723,-0.074544564,0.0312386,0.042438738,-0.029135115,0.024079371,-0.01749214,0.0061305524,0.0093642,0.013128331,0.011338524,0.03658957,-0.0058353264,-0.024688274,-0.0047974223,0.018654592,-0.02293537,0.00550781,0.014724396,-0.010148394,0.028267888,-0.014576783,0.003867922,-0.037973445,-0.00377797,-0.020739626,0.03361886,-0.019152787,0.03122015,0.039375767,-0.019706335,-0.003226728,-0.016385043,0.03260402,0.027123889,0.036036022,0.01317446,0.001984703,0.008160231,0.022898467,-0.007579005,-0.014438396,0.016781753,0.06524494,-0.009027458,0.021938981,-0.026275113,-0.0368848,-0.023267498,0.068455525,-0.025278727,-0.029208923,0.02474363,-0.034965828,-0.018091818,-0.027972663,0.039228152,0.00396018,0.0001822098,-0.02522337,-0.013091428,-0.013718783,-0.03996622,0.010139168,0.0010748071,-0.03871151,-0.05642507,0.014945816,0.018645367,-0.0204444,-0.026312018,0.0334897,0.03236415,0.012740847,0.020352142,-0.009401103,0.00091681513,-0.002382566,0.026182856,0.028083373,0.042770866,-0.0017990334,0.026625695,-0.022437176,0.029559502,0.010379039,0.028802987,-0.017695108,0.007888069,-0.029393438,0.009115103,-0.008234038,-0.021440787,-0.0013631138,0.0076804888,-0.05063126,0.0022937676,0.060004685,-0.008298618,0.03441228,-0.00069539563,-0.03319447,0.032917697,0.03849009,0.034356926,-0.03112789,0.00871378,-0.016375817,0.0061674556,-0.008160231,0.014226203,-0.012168846,0.017104656,-0.011135556,-0.012620911,0.037862733,0.046276674,0.018820656,-0.008049522,0.07089114,0.023562726,0.0028692277,-0.038896024,5.3588996e-05,-0.05007771,0.022880014,0.014041686,-0.026072146,0.0045160353,0.0018267109,-0.04443151,-0.05542868,-0.05144313,-0.058565456,-0.0027861954,-0.010600459,-0.09107722,-0.010203749,0.004862003,-0.019909304,0.014004783,-0.022400273,0.03055589,-0.015831495,0.022732401,0.016735625,-0.028433954,-0.018064141,0.03841628,-0.028433954,0.031496923,0.030906472,-0.022732401,-0.018636141,0.04760519,0.006947037,0.0210164,-0.019780142,0.007994167,0.053140678,-0.013229815,0.0117075555,-0.0066149076,-0.016338915,0.076463535,0.024503758,-0.04000312,-0.014539881,-0.015102655,0.03485512,-0.013266718,-0.032567117,-0.0135342665,-0.045575514,0.032567117,0.0005094378,-0.037419897,-0.03053744,0.01260246,-0.020924142,-0.010960265,-0.0027308404,-0.0047974223,-0.030186858,-0.012113492,0.02714234,-0.017732011,0.03507654,0.06753295,0.023802595,-0.00092777074,-0.011070975,-0.011218588,0.011993556,-0.034320023,0.02361808,-0.035279505,-0.0081925215,0.009239651,-0.0135896215,0.029725568,0.01692014,0.06649966,0.013663428,0.017584398,0.04133164,-0.008372425,0.014632138,-0.022787757,0.013755687,0.0048850677,0.05029913,0.0062228106,-0.033212926,-0.01692014,0.006061359,-0.047531385,0.07081734,0.0057384553,0.100672066,-0.00565081,-0.038121056,0.016754076,-0.023156788,-0.14229894,0.018460851,0.012279556,-0.0006596456,-0.0053878743,0.044136286,0.021403885,-0.030721955,0.017732011,0.013866396,-0.035980668,-0.08192521,-0.035703894,0.0032567119,-0.0012178072,0.013257492,-0.045760028,-0.02090569,0.004308454,-0.009945426,-0.029928535,-0.03747525,-0.08199902,-0.037309185,-0.009548716,0.015148784,0.023784144,0.030961826,-0.02511266,-0.011320072,-0.017722785,-0.01601601,-0.0012650895,0.032548666,0.012897686,0.03134931,0.0049311966,-0.016772527,0.019245045,0.020389045,0.0715554,0.11329298,0.013801815,0.011024846,0.014927365,-0.027566727,-0.007477521,0.0077404566,-0.01674485,0.008257102,-0.06402714,0.015213365,-0.035371765,0.005784584,-0.027880404,0.009119716,0.04686713,-0.02020453,-0.021219369,-0.03815796,-0.0067948108,-0.053066872,-0.02919047,-0.015397881,-0.05985707,-0.011569168,0.006098262,0.024854338,0.021366982,-0.012703944,0.00158338,-0.039560284,-0.009267328,0.023452016,-0.03963409,0.021791369,-0.003572696,0.040113833,-0.0017148479,-0.091372445,-0.008335521,0.03483667,-0.0021311627,0.021164013,-0.037788928,0.014908913,0.0043914868,-0.013423557,0.020167626,0.22570027,0.023156788,0.062956944,-0.009945426,-0.020149175,0.031423118,0.0017148479,0.03341589,0.027769696,-0.046534996,-0.010480523,-0.020997949,-0.0026109049,-0.0069193593,-0.0027931146,0.019392658,0.022510983,-0.023138337,0.044320803,-0.059561845,-0.003533486,-0.00953949,0.017003173,0.007717392,-0.01669872,-0.04361964,0.016163623,-0.06269862,0.026385823,-0.015314848,-0.011744459,0.014918138,0.087017864,-0.03269628,-0.0072468757,0.014087816,-0.019872399,-0.03214273,0.0064257784,0.06982095,0.018857561,-0.015702333,-0.033452794,-0.027289953,0.017196914,-0.016246656,-0.01680943,0.021791369,0.03841628,0.052771647,-0.021588402,-0.014097041,-0.015877623,-0.008123328,-0.062071268,-0.029485697,-0.03428312,0.0046867128,0.0031321633,0.034320023,0.0442839,-0.028249437,0.03337899,0.021533046,-0.03262247,-0.014170848,0.005959875,-0.04122093,0.072256565,0.014936591,0.0069516497,0.015702333,-0.023544272,0.018580787,0.0408888,-0.006734843,-0.011098652,0.0013631138,-0.0681603,-0.023673434,-0.029356536,-0.010766523,-0.0039117443,-0.033692665,0.004006309,0.0030006955,0.050741967,0.045354094,0.002224574,0.023654982,-0.03485512,-0.025942985,0.031183247,0.06483901,-0.041257832,-0.012427169,0.014964268,-0.014392267,-0.05243952,0.020352142,-0.0029868567,-0.04181138,-0.014290784,-0.011440007,0.06790198,0.021717563,0.0037848896,0.0035496312,0.0043476643,-0.001471517,0.007436005,0.025647758,0.004140083,-0.03804725,0.00860307,0.0071500046,-0.032659374,0.012454847,0.044763643,0.0033974054,-0.0051433905,0.03101718,-0.0556501,-0.018876012,-0.000867803,0.029208923,0.0066425847,0.0067163915,-0.0204444,0.007611295,0.040519767,0.00033241755,-0.06712701,0.0306666,-0.0011532266,-0.011320072,0.06269862,-0.014687493,-0.023710338,-0.005609294,-0.00817407,0.028969051,0.009613297,0.0046313577,0.045132674,0.037512153,-0.010415942,0.04040906,-0.024835886,0.017353753,0.0027654374,0.03841628,0.02463292,-3.2002037e-05,0.0069193593,-0.040113833,0.001857848,-0.014235429,-0.004529874,-0.006347359,-0.028802987,0.024393048,-0.033083763,-0.0015418639,-0.012648589,0.04860158,-0.017990334,0.018663818,-0.021606853,0.004963487,0.036368154,-0.01738143,-0.016062139,0.021053303,0.016449623,0.03476286,0.02180982,-0.00084358524,0.04066738,-0.043139897,0.023138337,0.0048435517,-0.025407888,-0.012122718,0.00032319175,0.0030375987,-0.013875622,-0.010434394,0.06232959,-0.022344917,-0.020942595,0.09100341,0.04158996,-0.01000078,0.047531385,0.028323244,0.004020148,0.037936542,0.016643366,-0.009797812,0.017372204,-0.07631592,-0.0069147465,-0.03190286,0.01965098,0.00485739,-0.0005910286,0.018986722,-0.02350737,0.015757687,-0.0024702114,0.040113833,-0.05838094,0.0066056815,0.031404667,0.04225422,-0.02590608,0.014936591,-0.0014230816,-0.05782739,0.03586996,-0.022437176,0.0033535827,-0.045243382,-0.0042530997,0.009161232,-0.0009675571,0.013608073,0.002657034,0.005060358,0.010139168,-0.022880014,0.057310745,0.05723694,-0.009239651,-0.0078050373,-0.014383041,0.0002581786,-0.010277555,-0.033655763,-0.008898296,0.007274553,0.059192814,0.02590608,-0.010821878,0.0002541423,-0.023821048,0.016864786,0.030002343,0.08620599,-0.0076620374,-0.015010397,0.01764898,-0.002391792,0.03646041,0.033102214,-0.0238395,-0.011873621,-9.838464e-05,-0.022344917,0.029799374,-0.01998311,0.0028945985,-0.041368544,-0.029541051,-0.039560284,0.013165235,-0.059598748,-0.022326466,-0.048527773,-0.011006394,-0.036349703,0.010462071,-0.05505965,0.0030745019,-0.0071961335,-0.06531875,0.011458459,0.024706725,0.011559943,0.03179215,-0.030961826,0.041368544,-0.017233817,-0.03361886,0.074433856,0.042401835,0.008736844,-0.03099873,0.00062101247,-0.03122015,0.012030459,-0.03179215,-0.03599912,-0.03926506,-0.009244264,-0.018276334,0.044579126,-0.031736795,0.0067948108,-0.012537879,0.020167626,-0.025149565,-0.015582398,-0.06491282,0.027751245,-0.004820487,0.016468076,0.04384106,-0.0064626816,0.01220575,-0.08598457,0.0135619445,-0.046719514,0.0044768252,0.021569949,0.023784144,-0.024153177,-0.017150786,-0.02066582,-0.067053206,0.049967,0.008810651,0.010923361,-0.011209362,0.05088958,-0.021274723,-0.073843405,0.009391877,-0.008441619,-0.057864293,-0.009640974,-0.0076020695,-0.014641364,0.010489749,-0.020721175,-0.029707115,-0.009521038,0.037438348,-0.019706335,0.030814214,-0.05845475,0.08096573,-0.032419506,0.006937811,0.004296922,0.0099361995,0.0053786486,-0.017685883,0.005314068,-0.016265107,-0.015573171,-0.031090988,-0.04487435,0.03487357,-0.024060918,0.028987503,0.025869178,0.026422726,0.032714732,-0.00976091,0.028802987,-0.013654202,0.037770476,0.0013977105,0.00604752,0.0072053596,-0.012833105,0.014373816,-0.033434343,0.034670603,-0.048896804,0.0023064532,0.01738143,0.02419008,0.024651371,-0.02760363,-0.038010348,-0.016818656,-0.016514204,0.012454847,-0.048453968,-0.03941267,-0.024024015,0.02793576,-0.0026731791,0.045021966,0.020776529,0.03826867,-0.016062139,-0.011938201,-0.023581177,-0.0012789282,0.0007155771,-0.13927287,0.014115493,-0.016145172,-0.014696719,-0.030020794,0.0037987283,9.773595e-05,-0.008916748,-0.029356536,0.010914136,0.054137066,-0.014936591,0.03144157,-0.026865566,-0.00018696685,0.040925704,-0.020758078,-0.007039295,0.026385823,0.0038148735,0.0032405667,0.02985473,-0.0153056225,-0.04609216,-0.007136166,0.0049819387,-0.02839705,-0.03579615,-0.03871151,-0.015287171,0.012058137,-0.026035242,-0.014973493,0.023249047,0.026607243,0.05461681,0.04520648,-0.03317602,0.0008989401,-0.031330857,0.0105543295,-0.004308454,-0.034578346,-0.032198086,0.016560333,0.0156193,0.025795372,-0.01918969,-0.07244108,0.0013907913,-0.0003269397,0.018147172,-0.039117444,-0.0028623084,0.016883237,-0.022972273,-0.01881143,0.002449453,-0.054985844,0.06288314,0.02725305,0.01573001,-0.034818217,-0.02782505,0.05542868,0.0306666,-0.0204444,-0.019466463,0.0085015865,0.02293537,-0.01952182,-0.026681049,-0.024024015,-0.015859172,0.006988553,-0.026533436,0.00097101677,0.0067671333,0.029153567,-0.039449573,-0.082958505,-0.024965048,-0.03122015,-0.01623743,0.063399784,-0.05723694,-0.0030652762,0.012187298,-0.021164013,-0.010748072,-0.08480367,-0.016357366,-0.015010397,0.04099951,0.014244654,0.00012454847,0.008035682,-0.024024015,-0.019171238,-0.038194865,-0.018654592,-0.019669432,0.057790488,-0.0069516497,-0.0026547275,-0.010886459,0.034227762,0.019890852,-0.0031114053,-0.015241042,-0.008930586,0.013912525,-0.008017231,0.006435004,-0.068307914,0.024282338,-0.0040801154,0.0058307135,-0.012168846,-0.016910914,0.022677047,-0.008344747,-0.023027629,-0.03804725,0.017372204,0.00037076234,0.018553108,-0.0034873572,0.07779205,-0.0005564318,0.018829884,0.022510983,-0.019577174,-0.019706335,-0.012058137,0.028563116,-0.032991506,0.03896983,0.015656203,-0.011006394,-0.012104265,-0.008810651,0.017575173,0.0039371154,-0.020038465,-0.025924534,0.00085742393,0.010545104,0.00097159337,-0.04339822,-0.024097823,-0.0019062834,0.04790042,0.060152296,-0.0069608754,0.0204444,-0.012251879,-0.023064531,0.0028738405,0.0408888,0.009128941,-0.022769306,-0.04712545,-0.033434343,-0.0238395,0.07712779,-0.009659425,-0.0051433905,-0.0054847454,-0.006933198,-0.0007374884,0.038674604,-0.01883911,0.031054085,0.0010390572,0.022584789,0.021311626,-0.023027629,-0.016421946,-0.017261496,0.01368188,0.030592794,0.00027129654,0.010231426,0.009327296,0.021496143,0.037419897,0.021588402,-0.032733183,0.0029914696,-0.051406227,-0.008842941,0.025869178,0.019724786,0.024485307,0.033784926,0.011098652,0.062071268,0.012722395,0.02633047,0.017510591,-0.013977106,-0.025795372,-0.011753685,-0.0037825832,-0.0019270416,0.019835496,-0.010766523,-0.0067163915,-0.008593844,-0.05472752,0.015979107,0.029079761,0.03896983,0.004043212,-0.054690614,0.028120276,-0.01169833,0.042955384,0.003990164,0.02941189,0.057273842,-0.009419555,-0.03623899,-0.021975884,0.01220575,-0.013847944,0.024559112,0.036718734,-0.005355584,-0.007020843,0.030980278,0.04063048,-0.008386264,0.02511266,-0.05664649,-0.03485512,0.014244654,-0.008699941,-0.031736795,-0.026164403,0.0032105828,0.0141523965,0.0084739085]
CONSTEXT000038657451_6
CONSTEXT000038657451
6
QPC
Non lieu à statuer
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation]
2019-790
2019-06-14
LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL DÉCIDE : Article 1er. - Il n'y a pas lieu, pour le Conseil constitutionnel, de statuer sur la question prioritaire de constitutionnalité portant sur les articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation. Article 2. - Cette décision sera publiée au Journal officiel de la République française et notifiée dans les conditions prévues à l'article 23-11 de l'ordonnance du 7 novembre 1958 susvisée. Jugé par le Conseil constitutionnel dans sa séance du 13 juin 2019, où siégeaient : M. Laurent FABIUS, Président, Mme Claire BAZY MALAURIE, M. Alain JUPPÉ, Mmes Dominique LOTTIN, Corinne LUQUIENS, Nicole MAESTRACCI, MM. Jacques MÉZARD, François PILLET et Michel PINAULT. Rendu public le 14 juin 2019.
Société ENR Grenelle Habitat et autres [Répression pénale des pratiques commerciales trompeuses et autorité compétente pour prononcer des amendes administratives en matière de consommation] LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL DÉCIDE : Article 1er. - Il n'y a pas lieu, pour le Conseil constitutionnel, de statuer sur la question prioritaire de constitutionnalité portant sur les articles L. 132-2 et L. 522-1 du code de la consommation. Article 2. - Cette décision sera publiée au Journal officiel de la République française et notifiée dans les conditions prévues à l'article 23-11 de l'ordonnance du 7 novembre 1958 susvisée. Jugé par le Conseil constitutionnel dans sa séance du 13 juin 2019, où siégeaient : M. Laurent FABIUS, Président, Mme Claire BAZY MALAURIE, M. Alain JUPPÉ, Mmes Dominique LOTTIN, Corinne LUQUIENS, Nicole MAESTRACCI, MM. Jacques MÉZARD, François PILLET et Michel PINAULT. Rendu public le 14 juin 2019.
[-0.008384607,0.04384374,0.043215815,-0.023861041,-0.043215815,-0.06142556,0.024692114,-0.0350713,-0.030454222,0.013694243,0.008813995,-0.030952867,-0.06364176,-0.01713858,-0.05108331,0.0017429456,0.041295115,0.019687206,0.0032804313,-0.04598606,-0.043326627,-0.013417218,0.00770128,0.042144656,0.008795527,0.045395076,-0.014146716,0.011699666,-0.008657015,-0.00048450424,-0.007835175,0.00024816775,0.023916446,-0.015808864,-0.019816482,-0.022642134,0.001998039,-0.016732277,-0.041812226,0.012927809,0.0058729188,0.02506148,0.004473945,-0.09034691,0.048017573,-0.025227694,0.0067732483,-0.013906628,0.020702962,0.017221687,-0.05998503,0.01838519,0.0694408,-0.06375256,-0.029364593,0.008929422,-0.0008524274,-0.01442374,-0.04273564,-0.02105386,-0.008010624,-0.0036636486,0.009935944,-0.008684717,0.022069616,-0.019447118,0.03296591,-0.026169578,0.0028487348,-0.051600423,0.008624695,-0.0007254578,0.0078074727,-0.012973979,-0.04554282,0.04480409,0.021903401,-0.04284645,0.013158662,-0.026668223,0.026169578,0.011117916,-0.0035643815,-0.04162754,0.076532625,-0.024969138,-0.034757335,0.028256495,0.034905083,-0.06537777,-0.030952867,0.011912052,-0.01682462,0.06552552,-0.04284645,0.002363942,-0.046170745,-0.011690432,0.0046586283,0.03538526,0.0026825203,0.04295726,0.03483121,-0.033372212,0.00992671,0.0305835,0.015457965,0.025227694,0.018597575,0.029032163,-0.022734474,0.017609522,0.051046375,-0.01279853,-0.015042429,0.009899007,0.025153821,-0.025874086,-0.0046078404,-0.026538944,-0.020869177,-0.02657588,0.07221104,-0.025338504,-0.021035392,0.0135187935,-0.016695341,-0.015855033,-0.0048571625,0.031008272,0.010997871,-0.006583948,-0.028182622,-0.0028487348,-0.01869915,-0.026095705,0.007382702,0.023510143,-0.037564516,-0.06689218,0.036918126,0.042661767,-0.087613605,-0.009432683,0.03896811,7.529799e-06,0.024692114,-0.0033704643,0.0011744683,0.009742027,-0.00992671,0.031174487,0.031174487,0.0017948877,-0.022789879,-0.022845285,-0.01931784,0.027868662,0.010462291,0.0022889148,-0.02354708,0.025079949,-0.047722083,-0.004792523,0.025837148,-0.008347671,0.0032688887,0.019243967,-0.040888812,-0.0028117984,0.053742748,-0.0016517583,0.0066716727,-0.012475335,-0.012964745,0.027240738,-0.02127548,0.028607393,-0.07512903,0.009201829,-0.014183653,0.04162754,-0.013629603,0.015984312,-0.031525385,0.0075766193,-0.034646526,-0.0078028557,0.039263602,0.03830325,-0.027610105,-0.008675483,0.04654011,0.031710066,0.0024424323,-0.032707356,0.005032611,-0.08362445,0.0041138134,0.0046216915,-0.043991484,0.024969138,-0.025320036,-0.027850192,-0.050492324,-0.04546895,-0.029974047,0.02602183,-0.020906113,-0.06375256,-0.035034362,0.0023027658,0.013980501,-0.0054296795,-0.02029666,0.044730216,-0.0077243657,-0.0094373,0.03246727,-0.031950153,0.022494387,0.038894236,-0.024433557,0.013648072,0.07191555,-0.026723627,-0.02504301,0.03514517,0.023584016,0.01226295,0.01106251,0.018357487,0.049495038,-0.021552503,0.03819244,-0.019484054,0.01041612,0.07121375,0.020148912,-0.04580138,-0.054185987,-0.02626192,0.025560124,-0.009192595,-0.020795302,-0.020924581,-0.04133205,0.011071744,0.002290069,-0.029106038,-0.010406885,0.023639422,0.010960935,0.026428133,-0.020887645,-0.0021238541,-0.044767153,-0.014682297,0.026206514,-0.023787167,0.031008272,0.042477086,0.04716803,0.010314545,-0.022623664,0.0037790753,0.030103326,-0.04554282,0.024211938,-0.017101644,-0.0004022626,0.03316906,-0.0020961517,0.00852312,0.0089848265,0.03689966,0.006159177,-0.0021757963,0.021977274,-0.003601318,-0.009492705,-0.050159898,0.0020430554,0.021718718,0.043659057,-0.008232243,-0.043769866,-0.04099962,0.00060829957,-0.012290652,0.028699735,-0.00095631153,0.09042078,0.005517404,-0.026649753,-0.01642755,-0.028551988,-0.1424275,0.01664917,-0.009326491,-0.036788847,-0.0008968667,0.014996258,-0.00042303946,-0.052560776,0.005332721,-0.026742095,-0.023159245,-0.058766123,-0.046798665,-5.1869945e-05,-0.010296076,-0.017757269,-0.012983213,-0.0059929625,0.015993545,-0.017988121,-0.0053696577,-0.023861041,-0.02430428,-0.04026089,0.014950087,0.038894236,0.031525385,0.032688886,-0.05023377,-0.00902638,0.023233118,-0.0054389136,-0.005849833,0.03025107,0.04554282,0.0505662,0.028995227,-0.011007105,0.012669252,0.0039014278,0.07379932,0.05533102,-0.02061062,0.017286327,0.02234664,-0.0445086,-0.0015628797,-0.024599772,-0.022697538,-0.016168995,-0.08022629,-0.0007808627,-0.050972503,-0.001980725,-0.024895266,0.0029064484,0.02744389,-0.010092924,-0.040741064,-0.024138065,0.0049264184,-0.055848133,-0.02485833,-0.0041115046,-0.045949124,0.013925096,-0.0008732042,-0.008158371,0.039559092,-0.00029924413,0.007198019,-0.032836635,0.0014197504,-0.0052265283,-0.042144656,0.013998969,-0.01796042,0.028736671,-0.00664397,-0.10046754,-0.010896295,0.0324488,-0.0071102944,0.041368987,-0.04144286,0.014996258,-0.0062238164,0.013989735,0.022217361,0.22516549,0.055922005,0.06404806,0.022106552,0.004012238,0.0051665064,-0.012715423,0.033353746,0.008107583,-0.014045141,-0.012142906,-0.028459646,0.017221687,0.015605711,-0.019576395,0.02179259,0.034701932,0.0076181726,0.050972503,-0.051932853,-0.0065977992,0.0017129346,0.029032163,-0.008781675,-0.047537398,-0.011080978,-0.012401462,-0.0339632,-0.04912567,-0.018865366,-0.0141744185,0.004769438,0.0683327,-0.020979986,-0.002277372,0.0222543,-0.014793106,-0.02766551,0.017803438,0.07889657,0.013380282,-0.011967457,0.0014070534,-0.016307507,0.034868147,-0.0042130803,-0.0032481118,0.0045824465,0.009769729,0.02712993,-0.041479796,-0.0073088286,-0.019077752,-0.028034875,-0.033870857,-0.028681267,-0.04458247,-0.017055472,-0.0071610822,0.027794788,0.06630119,-0.02029666,0.008744739,0.050492324,-0.03015873,-0.008943273,0.008596992,-0.061684113,0.04912567,0.0024493579,0.009160276,-0.00032665802,0.009769729,0.039780714,0.025966426,0.0051064845,-0.03374158,0.024599772,-0.056143627,-0.014359102,-0.008333819,0.006570097,-0.038487934,-0.024692114,0.011533452,-0.0072995946,0.06541471,0.029715491,0.008269181,-0.0080152415,-0.0029895557,-0.017978888,0.028902886,0.052154474,-0.05629137,-0.04436085,0.024488963,0.014793106,-0.041073494,0.0015894278,0.014026672,-0.036290206,-0.012927809,-0.03767533,0.07221104,0.0698471,0.024581304,0.014349868,-0.0052219112,-0.026520476,0.02419347,0.025079949,-0.0062884553,-0.032356456,0.0074750436,0.020518279,-0.036622636,0.013112491,0.03636408,-0.0028764373,0.0078028557,0.049605846,0.0035159022,-0.016953897,-0.020407468,0.017526414,0.0028487348,-1.8955254e-05,-0.037601452,-0.0019541767,0.026280388,-0.013675774,-0.06500841,0.018366722,0.018412894,-0.011007105,0.03970684,-0.011588857,-0.019484054,-0.0090587,0.008019858,0.0027079142,0.025670934,-0.029641617,0.03233799,0.029881706,0.008726271,0.018283615,-0.03102674,-0.00031165252,0.025209226,0.009935944,0.033261403,-0.0169816,0.017443307,-0.029586213,0.035440665,-0.024285812,0.014719233,-0.008403076,-0.01204133,0.031266827,-0.03351996,0.039448284,0.043991484,0.044951838,-0.0107670175,-0.010102158,-0.0076504922,0.010092924,0.027296145,0.004852545,-0.026188046,0.022845285,0.011985925,0.019391712,0.04351131,-0.03556994,0.045432013,-0.045321204,0.015162473,0.030288009,0.0016667639,-0.010896295,-0.032892037,-0.0009770883,0.02081377,-0.018357487,0.06534084,-0.023436269,-0.03350149,0.05932017,0.03038035,-0.004958738,0.04391761,0.014968555,0.0016390614,0.081777625,0.023196181,-0.029881706,-0.0046770964,-0.017258624,0.0056097456,-0.012927809,-0.008162987,0.0034835828,0.0014185961,0.012447633,-0.042994197,0.029900175,0.00558666,0.022180425,-0.040556382,0.027739383,-0.008019858,0.029697023,-0.041812226,0.039965395,0.0013447229,-0.030897463,0.03440644,-0.0027102227,-0.0062515186,-0.06371563,-0.00022883376,-3.097588e-06,-0.014442209,0.0017579511,0.011108681,0.022402044,0.004852545,-0.0051295697,0.033150595,0.025633996,0.0012743125,-0.00023936645,-0.014091311,0.024692114,-0.019059284,-0.056882355,0.0074104043,0.038414057,0.06692911,-0.0044762534,-0.038044695,0.009815901,-0.006699375,0.013860458,0.058913868,0.08820459,-0.030565033,0.017147815,0.025523188,-0.014516082,-0.0054250625,0.04956891,0.0040930365,-0.028404241,-0.0076089385,-0.022845285,0.03786001,-0.0023512451,0.010730081,-0.0083384365,-0.023343928,-0.03743524,0.016076652,-0.05751028,-0.014553019,-0.027868662,-0.00073873193,-0.014414506,0.00021440539,-0.048867114,-0.0037028936,0.020647557,-0.03882036,0.015374858,0.0051757405,-0.0064731385,0.085988395,-0.02430428,0.023122309,-0.03213484,-0.039743777,0.10837197,0.032947443,-0.019114688,-0.023436269,-0.0025947958,-0.03049116,-0.015171707,-0.03004792,-0.0022635208,-0.03612399,-0.022956094,-0.010453057,0.015799629,-0.016085887,0.000971317,-0.019613331,0.0464293,-0.020241255,-0.041036557,-0.00063484773,0.015661117,-0.0074842777,0.027074525,0.029900175,-0.017387902,0.003915279,-0.08554515,0.003979918,-0.027480828,0.025356973,0.016362911,-0.0068148016,-0.025947958,-0.016362911,-0.013832755,-0.06330933,0.007761302,-0.007378085,0.006403882,-0.03852487,0.03981765,-0.02127548,-0.07291284,0.022051148,-0.013878926,-0.06703992,-0.009917476,-0.01611359,-0.039522156,-0.0030357265,-0.004487796,-0.051378805,-0.0065100747,0.0328551,-0.013001681,0.009252617,-0.035514537,0.07435337,-0.03182088,-0.0019576396,0.050455388,0.028164154,-0.0021330884,-0.02940153,0.036216334,-0.051231056,-0.011468813,-0.021663314,-0.048867114,0.01996423,0.024359684,0.0021988817,0.02245745,-0.006459287,0.026723627,-0.0034604974,0.02387951,-0.013638838,0.036511824,0.020444406,0.017905014,-0.01219831,-0.008084497,-0.0019345542,0.007747451,-0.00060137396,-0.03701047,-0.016436785,-0.008186073,0.005632831,0.017230922,-0.02820109,-0.045505885,0.0010186421,0.0056743845,0.020241255,-0.011459579,-0.046355426,-0.04306807,0.050935566,-0.012456867,0.03981765,0.0049956744,0.047722083,-0.0062561356,0.018209742,-0.034055542,0.00014370643,-0.035865434,-0.13821673,0.010942467,-0.0049448865,-0.026040299,-0.030694311,0.005051079,0.010822423,-0.01649219,0.011071744,0.011792008,-0.007996772,-0.035034362,0.014469911,-0.0089063365,0.020001166,0.016723044,-0.0003136725,0.0020465183,0.0013377973,0.045432013,0.0035343706,0.027480828,-0.0048663965,-0.023528611,0.0117089,-0.030768184,-0.0181174,-0.03882036,-0.043991484,-0.048571624,0.043659057,0.011321067,-0.024544368,0.04373293,-0.008901719,0.04665092,0.033686176,-0.026520476,0.006385414,-0.030971335,0.029992515,-0.012650784,-0.012586145,-0.038746487,0.012955511,0.018283615,0.01633521,-0.024765987,-0.020259723,0.014119013,-0.013998969,0.0017660309,-0.024064193,0.024655178,-0.008878634,-0.008717037,-0.018708386,0.010434588,-0.056254435,0.030842056,0.03004792,0.016141292,-0.020869177,-0.05304095,0.012032096,0.0449149,-0.030823588,-0.008269181,0.009428066,0.024599772,-0.010997871,-0.0044762534,-0.033058252,-0.020961517,0.006907143,0.0045616697,0.00860161,-2.4456065e-05,0.026705159,-0.060797635,-0.068369634,-0.0004478562,-0.05935711,0.026206514,0.04358518,-0.009220297,0.013629603,-0.0018018133,0.03113755,0.0008910954,-0.098990075,0.006196114,-0.0059421747,0.083993815,0.017277092,-0.029364593,0.01475617,-0.032171775,-0.013509559,-0.041849162,-0.019151624,-0.02483986,0.03959603,0.007253424,0.010563866,-0.014728467,0.020204317,0.038340185,-0.0043562097,-0.012715423,-0.0030311095,0.023048436,-0.021238543,-0.0010988637,-0.061314747,0.013601901,-0.03416635,0.0119028175,-0.02788713,-0.011939755,0.014673063,0.007899814,-0.04240321,-0.037564516,-0.014663829,-0.030620437,0.03786001,0.010092924,0.052228346,-0.0154671995,0.014146716,0.032910507,0.019705674,-0.009649686,-0.0102776075,-0.021257011,-0.038450997,0.020148912,0.018745322,-0.017055472,-0.006957931,0.004021472,-0.008061412,-0.016095122,-0.023306992,-0.007627407,0.0010861667,-0.009340341,0.015411794,-0.03610552,0.0076551093,-0.012022862,0.025467783,0.0011888967,-0.016787682,0.017277092,-0.016261335,0.008638546,0.028921355,0.078453325,-0.0024378153,-0.009132573,-0.040741064,-0.025301568,0.0351267,0.04255096,-0.00093842036,-0.007959836,-0.012401462,0.015956609,0.027056055,0.032578077,-0.014137482,0.04162754,-0.017729566,0.03677038,0.026040299,-0.020038104,-0.035348322,-0.021737186,0.012179842,0.041147366,-0.039780714,-0.015799629,0.029106038,0.018579107,0.026612816,-0.006634736,-0.025523188,0.011810476,-0.026391197,-0.018505234,0.01854217,-0.0019645651,0.016861556,0.032042496,-0.002393953,0.055146337,0.009778963,0.044102296,0.08000466,-0.02626192,-0.052228346,-0.038155504,0.0024585922,-0.0049310355,0.027868662,-0.0006325392,-0.007147231,0.047278844,-0.057325594,0.022531323,0.024119597,0.03278123,0.0143221645,-0.05691929,0.02506148,0.000118312535,0.062533654,-0.023029966,0.011967457,0.04742659,0.01524558,-0.035237513,-0.01128413,0.006020665,-0.025116885,0.039115854,0.0033843156,0.030232603,0.011154852,0.003931439,0.046466235,-0.014636125,0.042661767,-0.030897463,-0.026206514,-0.017812673,-0.0018087389,-0.019668737,-0.014359102,0.03318753,0.0056143627,-0.010231437]
CONSTEXT000038657449_0
CONSTEXT000038657449
0
RIP
Conformité
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris
2019-1
2019-05-09
LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL A ÉTÉ SAISI, le 10 avril 2019, par le président de l'Assemblée nationale, sous le n° 2019-1 RIP, conformément au quatrième alinéa de l'article 11 et au premier alinéa de l'article 61 de la Constitution, de la proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l'exploitation des aérodromes de Paris. Au vu des textes suivants :- la Constitution, notamment ses articles 11 et 40 ;- l'ordonnance n° 58-1067 du 7 novembre 1958 portant loi organique sur le Conseil constitutionnel, notamment son article 45-2 ;- la loi organique n° 2013-1114 du 6 décembre 2013 portant application de l'article 11 de la Constitution, ensemble la décision du Conseil constitutionnel n° 2013-681 DC du 5 décembre 2013 ;Au vu des pièces suivantes :- les observations du Gouvernement, enregistrées les 23 avril 2019 ;- les observations de M. Sébastien Nadot, député, enregistrées le même jour ;- les observations en réponse de Mme Valérie Rabault et plusieurs autres députés, enregistrées le 29 avril 2019 ;- les observations en réponse de M. Gilles Carrez, député, enregistrées le même jour ; - les observations en réponse de M. Patrick Kanner, sénateur, enregistrées le même jour ;Et après avoir entendu le rapporteur ;LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL S'EST FONDÉ SUR CE QUI SUIT :
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL A ÉTÉ SAISI, le 10 avril 2019, par le président de l'Assemblée nationale, sous le n° 2019-1 RIP, conformément au quatrième alinéa de l'article 11 et au premier alinéa de l'article 61 de la Constitution, de la proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l'exploitation des aérodromes de Paris. Au vu des textes suivants :- la Constitution, notamment ses articles 11 et 40 ;- l'ordonnance n° 58-1067 du 7 novembre 1958 portant loi organique sur le Conseil constitutionnel, notamment son article 45-2 ;- la loi organique n° 2013-1114 du 6 décembre 2013 portant application de l'article 11 de la Constitution, ensemble la décision du Conseil constitutionnel n° 2013-681 DC du 5 décembre 2013 ;Au vu des pièces suivantes :- les observations du Gouvernement, enregistrées les 23 avril 2019 ;- les observations de M. Sébastien Nadot, député, enregistrées le même jour ;- les observations en réponse de Mme Valérie Rabault et plusieurs autres députés, enregistrées le 29 avril 2019 ;- les observations en réponse de M. Gilles Carrez, député, enregistrées le même jour ; - les observations en réponse de M. Patrick Kanner, sénateur, enregistrées le même jour ;Et après avoir entendu le rapporteur ;LE CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL S'EST FONDÉ SUR CE QUI SUIT :
[-0.009402347,0.008746584,-0.009928804,0.0067423508,-0.01822282,-0.023422742,0.05707908,-0.020227052,-0.00743044,0.044222433,-0.0100765815,-0.013992687,-0.004020011,-0.028576484,-0.016412545,0.012875119,0.05549047,0.025898015,0.0013207619,0.0036690396,-0.009503944,-0.027375791,-0.008123147,0.040269382,0.008224744,0.015091782,-0.037018277,0.02222205,-0.027043292,0.019580526,-0.03234481,-0.005841831,0.006871656,-0.07119183,-0.02096594,-0.035669807,-0.0033249948,-0.05767019,-0.042929377,0.023976907,0.00031027512,-0.008451029,-0.010261304,-0.05079853,0.050133534,-0.017797958,0.012450258,-0.009827207,-0.014620742,0.0434466,0.002096594,0.015636712,0.0155166425,-0.051389642,-0.010122762,0.024808157,-0.021039829,-0.02063344,-0.04370521,-0.0020573407,-0.008335577,-0.0006170867,-0.0047196457,-0.0424491,0.0034473732,0.018518375,0.06572407,-0.004548778,0.02491899,0.010039638,-0.016283238,0.038200498,-0.034561474,0.00743044,-0.06738656,0.00984568,-0.0061420044,-0.043151043,0.015932268,0.013318452,-0.00185761,-0.0018726187,0.017243793,-0.034210503,0.0026530689,0.037073694,0.008229363,0.05803963,0.02020858,-0.008460265,-0.03184606,0.006959399,-0.00093169126,-0.0036598034,-0.051759087,-0.014279006,-0.03890244,-0.0134847015,0.015756782,0.045072153,0.010963247,-0.00087512017,0.0048766593,-0.043668266,0.02163094,0.04680854,0.03282509,-0.03469078,0.00035501248,0.011960746,-0.028280929,0.031125646,0.036519527,0.016551085,-0.0054954775,-0.048138537,0.02188955,-0.015267268,-0.0125888,-0.021002885,0.00972561,0.017262265,0.05345853,0.010566095,-0.017650181,0.0073288428,0.015904559,0.04403771,-0.01696671,0.036076196,0.009370021,0.054677695,-0.02331191,0.03114412,0.021963438,0.0006292091,0.021649411,0.052350197,0.011046372,-0.06727573,0.04688243,-0.008363286,-0.083420426,-0.04008466,0.034395225,-0.04983798,0.046586875,0.0050983257,-0.046660762,0.016643446,0.017668653,0.029703287,0.051722143,-0.049431592,-0.041377716,-0.0062066573,-0.04041716,-0.007351933,0.015202615,0.0045326147,-0.046402153,0.05936963,-0.034210503,0.020005386,0.018370597,0.00138426,-0.0015274195,-0.0001267077,-0.020319413,0.016283238,0.03243717,-0.029149123,-0.016772753,-0.017991917,0.0046203574,0.017604,-0.011711371,0.010159707,-0.05556436,-0.037424665,0.0022420625,0.07318683,0.004394073,-0.012173176,-0.011064844,0.00113604,-0.006959399,0.011868385,0.00045170286,-0.0012122378,-0.016523378,-0.024124686,0.016098518,0.007416586,-0.005500096,-0.053310752,0.006802385,-0.06188185,-0.005440061,0.014971714,-0.019063303,0.024715796,0.037258416,0.017881084,-0.055121027,-0.021021357,-0.0066915522,0.0044148546,0.01654185,-0.022609966,-0.055010192,-0.022628438,0.011859149,0.02129844,0.0167081,0.04858187,0.0050013466,-0.030165093,0.06443101,0.0045580138,0.005269193,0.020910524,-0.02525149,0.009092937,-0.0004447758,0.0124225505,-0.029075233,-0.012136231,0.011147969,-0.015258032,-0.00955936,-0.0022813159,-0.014879352,-0.0034404462,0.09007042,-0.009910332,0.013096785,0.058704633,-0.014066576,-0.002752357,-0.070342116,-0.026452182,-0.0026438327,-0.03360092,0.004465653,-0.024475656,0.026322877,-0.0055878386,-0.02804079,0.000739465,0.04034327,0.011360399,-0.016902057,0.059480466,0.016809696,0.017761014,0.0034427552,0.013503173,0.0789871,-0.0056478735,0.011203386,0.00014424186,0.010990955,0.0141219925,0.013235327,-0.014205117,-0.017299209,-0.013558591,-0.0065160664,-0.009633249,-0.006479122,0.005407735,-0.00799846,-0.010990955,-0.001663652,0.01490706,0.005509332,-0.012450258,0.04185799,-0.03956744,-0.07215239,-0.035392724,0.0125888,-0.024955934,-0.0017744851,-0.013872618,-0.05212853,-0.019746775,-0.018241292,-0.057116024,-0.0014927841,-0.021778716,0.06624129,-0.0034912447,0.00028502019,-0.026563015,-0.017862612,-0.14334422,0.053606305,0.013567827,-0.025916489,0.012671925,0.017733306,0.016948238,-0.019580526,0.006599191,0.0044033094,-0.032954395,-0.064098515,-0.042966325,-0.0017363862,-0.0061604767,-0.0018933999,0.020430246,-0.006760823,0.011480468,-0.021316912,0.004098518,0.010289012,0.064135455,0.03343467,0.017363863,0.0060542617,0.030959398,0.019211082,-0.03402578,0.017816432,0.053754084,-0.015858378,-0.017373098,-0.029149123,0.070600726,0.004560323,0.05220242,0.0006015008,0.0042647677,0.011720607,0.07145045,0.019007888,-0.037276886,0.001332307,0.017539348,-0.06106907,-0.024013853,-0.038200498,-0.021741772,0.00842332,-0.040121604,-0.03166134,-0.006488358,-0.026747737,-0.024050796,0.0015424282,-0.04647604,0.000520685,-0.02432788,0.0148701165,-0.040269382,-0.061586294,-0.01978372,-0.034395225,-0.033157587,0.042818546,0.031199535,0.0013172983,0.038274385,-0.013401576,-0.005800269,0.0004955743,-0.0122008845,0.04603271,-0.045921873,-0.0033042138,-0.031809118,0.053938806,-0.019857608,-0.06491129,-0.019044831,-0.027800651,0.003625168,-0.0053523183,-0.039715216,-0.017751778,0.008760438,-0.031439673,0.02467885,0.22521299,0.027431209,0.012191648,0.023699826,0.034007307,-0.052054644,-0.0067515867,0.036279388,0.0148701165,-0.0051860684,-0.024771212,0.0068855104,0.023090241,-0.004788916,-0.0087927645,-0.0061650947,-0.012293245,-0.0067423508,0.03064537,-0.023182603,0.013567827,0.016652683,0.051574364,-0.02678468,-0.050133534,-0.030460648,-0.016274003,-0.009974984,-0.043224934,-0.0024198573,-0.02063344,0.005888012,0.033711754,-0.020614969,-0.0707485,-0.016144697,-0.0033457761,-0.011526649,-0.03184606,0.06069963,-0.0022108906,-0.024143158,-0.011369635,0.030885508,-0.0065391567,-0.0012641908,-0.019672887,-0.0075412733,-0.02188955,-0.0072272457,-0.04300327,0.008774292,-0.013752548,0.008686549,-0.0967943,0.022258993,-0.05312603,0.013327688,-0.0072226278,0.0052045407,0.05194381,0.0010546468,-0.038459107,0.05253492,0.00021228592,-0.019303443,0.053310752,-0.040786605,0.031698287,-0.0007117567,0.009688666,-0.028317872,0.04049105,0.03114412,0.009171444,-0.02619357,-0.032769673,0.11777871,0.0045464686,-0.012810467,0.017373098,-0.042818546,-0.016255531,-0.01313373,0.031236479,-0.0012757359,0.03469078,-0.0017029054,0.019081777,-0.0050937077,-0.0035720605,0.0144822,0.021095246,0.04647604,0.024346352,-0.012284009,-0.0032672693,0.05582297,-0.034321338,0.057411578,0.009097556,-0.011360399,-0.0058556856,-0.0255101,0.071117945,0.033028282,0.022960937,0.0062482194,-0.049801033,0.020079276,0.056266304,0.01523956,-0.008081585,-0.03611314,0.001961516,0.03378564,-0.02046719,0.041488547,0.0048397146,0.02567635,-0.055786025,0.07484933,0.030663842,0.026175098,-0.007416586,-0.0073011345,-0.015341157,0.010224359,0.0070286696,-0.011739079,-0.022536077,-0.005047527,-0.009734847,0.017908791,0.019081777,-0.0289644,0.06276851,0.023293437,-0.061512407,0.014731575,0.0036736575,-0.0051121796,0.020153163,-0.026138155,0.0078922445,0.03596536,-0.021169133,-0.016338656,-0.013290743,-0.023016354,0.038274385,-0.0054631513,0.003149509,-0.0431141,0.021520106,-0.059000187,-0.014463728,-0.052682698,0.013263036,-0.0091668265,-0.022923993,0.011942273,0.012431786,0.07115489,0.035891473,0.036999803,-0.032640368,0.017834904,0.009550124,-0.014796227,0.00012930535,-0.051500477,-0.012265537,0.047621317,0.032880504,0.023441214,0.03107023,-0.006197421,0.042929377,0.01945122,0.02366288,0.030275926,0.00018356743,-0.027560513,-0.03064537,-0.044407155,0.052497976,-0.033046756,0.029610926,-0.012976716,-0.001959207,0.05246103,0.033859532,-0.010362901,0.0320862,0.012062343,-0.0061281505,0.0103906095,0.014971714,-0.0019753703,-0.022443715,-0.012450258,0.0048350967,-0.040047716,-0.030867036,0.010233595,0.031550508,0.032123145,-0.010455262,0.004775062,0.005740234,0.048692703,0.0057910327,0.028336346,-0.02163094,-0.014879352,-0.01692053,0.029924953,0.025694821,-0.031236479,0.049283814,0.058482967,0.02685857,-0.08090821,0.028391762,0.025491627,-0.02222205,-0.0026576868,0.024050796,0.018416777,0.0051722145,-0.032898977,0.02340427,-0.027172597,0.0057633244,0.0062713097,0.0017525494,0.018970944,-0.017539348,-0.016634211,0.013660188,0.00830787,0.065059066,0.0028331727,-0.030756203,0.05297825,-0.026470654,0.0651699,0.02331191,0.010002693,-0.027080236,0.025805654,0.011295747,-0.019949969,-0.004645757,0.057263803,-0.019469693,-0.017899556,-0.025491627,-0.020651912,0.006095824,0.015470463,-0.0039438135,0.026913986,0.00076486426,-0.041119102,0.027689818,0.0053707906,-0.068421006,-0.011702135,-0.02853954,-0.011268038,-0.0441116,-0.0051167975,-0.048729647,0.07603155,-0.006871656,-0.025103712,-0.035928417,0.00984568,0.038532995,-0.0027038674,-0.013420049,-0.05386492,0.0066453717,0.03882855,0.02382913,-0.02534385,-0.027080236,-0.02063344,0.006954781,-0.044850487,-0.05371714,0.0026322876,-0.04603271,-0.028133152,-0.008986723,0.023090241,-0.01919261,0.010990955,-0.014629978,0.033951893,-0.030700786,-0.047141038,-0.0046041943,0.025214545,0.019562053,-0.042781603,0.006802385,0.007799884,0.023293437,-0.06856878,0.03712911,-0.026636904,0.0135955345,-0.005264575,0.024900516,-0.021021357,-0.03267731,-0.046254374,-0.007818356,0.0009720992,-0.010113526,-0.0023436595,-0.003161054,0.045367707,-0.05345853,0.00257918,-0.0015228015,-0.01317991,-0.04514604,0.00058880117,-0.044924375,-0.01486088,0.02358899,0.06081046,-0.04370521,-0.02903829,0.03107023,0.022240521,-0.012487203,-0.032880504,0.005541658,-0.04732576,-0.005878776,-0.0066915522,0.022295939,0.0027477387,-0.038163554,0.033028282,-0.04603271,-0.0092776595,-0.017825667,-0.060477965,-0.01204387,0.07669655,0.019358858,-0.0074904747,0.007134885,0.0051953048,-0.046512984,0.04396382,0.010704637,0.008691167,0.008931306,0.0031218007,0.0127458135,0.017243793,0.01642178,-0.039899938,-0.003918414,-0.013096785,0.03712911,-0.010575331,0.012930536,0.052424088,-0.008460265,-0.03282509,-0.012514912,-0.03166134,0.00018573213,-0.015165671,-0.015101018,0.0014650759,-0.011859149,-0.0114619965,-0.020485664,-0.022369826,0.008774292,-0.01064922,-0.09243486,-0.037941888,0.018352125,-0.037498552,-0.14652145,-0.027117182,-0.0026461417,-0.00707485,-0.05297825,0.024531074,-0.011711371,-0.010030401,0.035669807,-0.02079969,0.011268038,0.0046088123,0.0014131229,-0.014066576,-0.0017987299,0.034986336,0.017096015,0.031199535,0.038089663,0.052091587,-0.02011622,0.022462187,-0.0124225505,-0.000906292,0.014620742,-0.048027705,0.02198191,-0.025029823,-0.04758437,-0.019321915,0.07654877,0.010796998,-0.005740234,0.057116024,0.05179603,0.008603425,0.0053523183,-0.012598036,-0.008561862,-0.0020030786,-0.017373098,0.0052876654,-0.038717717,0.012939772,-0.026378293,-0.009577832,0.01810275,-0.01426977,-0.007822975,0.019876081,-0.0009663266,0.00031951122,-0.012718106,0.030072732,-0.009808735,0.0155166425,0.0018426013,0.0018287472,-0.059997685,0.032474115,-0.004659611,0.021113718,-0.032511063,-0.08519376,0.030626897,0.032898977,0.0046319026,0.027191069,0.033453144,-0.030220509,-0.031218007,-0.017059071,0.0016832787,0.0026969402,-0.00669617,0.008007696,0.04093438,-0.00082432164,-0.008931306,-0.017142195,-0.065280735,-0.026045794,-0.09406041,-0.021834133,0.007250336,-0.0028470268,-0.02331191,0.0018218202,0.041636325,0.0021450836,-0.07196767,-0.0039114873,0.0027246487,0.09649874,-0.007813738,-0.0077583212,-0.033157587,0.0070286696,0.034543004,-0.002387531,-0.018823165,-0.0011123724,0.009393111,0.015886087,0.009411583,0.012671925,-0.048434094,-0.030220509,0.008363286,-0.042375214,-0.033453144,0.015174908,0.0046065035,-0.024069268,-0.08083432,-0.006774677,-0.014094284,-0.016024629,-0.019174138,0.0015516643,-0.00513527,0.03360092,-0.0026161245,-0.021778716,-0.017881084,0.015008657,0.09406041,0.052054644,0.071598224,-0.014722339,0.020245524,0.045700207,-0.018712332,0.0065206843,-0.008113911,-0.015498171,-0.024937462,0.030996341,-0.0062713097,-0.042079657,-0.030682314,0.0008497209,0.016929766,-0.01005811,-0.02408774,0.02887204,-0.0056848177,0.026175098,0.044222433,-0.030442176,0.045072153,0.01128651,-0.026563015,0.03740619,-0.0073657874,0.07093322,-0.010732344,0.00094554544,-0.003925341,0.05179603,0.023053298,-0.036833555,-0.015775254,-0.045663264,0.039862994,0.0052738115,0.0068208575,-0.03040523,-0.0038583796,0.06121685,0.0421166,0.03064537,-0.020910524,-0.019562053,0.015174908,-0.0008162401,0.0019880699,0.006400615,0.010769289,-0.00515836,0.021593995,0.011535885,-0.013244563,-0.0059988447,0.009309986,0.03182759,0.016338656,-0.0035697515,-0.03417356,-0.02972176,0.006188185,0.009337694,0.016486432,0.0027061764,0.047141038,0.034487586,0.008040022,0.06513295,0.013789493,0.03437675,0.026489126,-0.011526649,-0.016412545,-0.010621511,-0.02096594,0.009947277,0.029001344,-0.0041516256,-0.016624974,0.02425399,0.024641907,0.007652106,-0.01557206,0.052645754,-0.039899938,-0.02248066,-0.004308639,0.022591494,-0.00013139792,-0.030017314,-0.031790644,0.008464883,-0.00077871844,-0.032178562,-0.013650951,0.021538578,-0.05153742,0.0090051945,-0.011203386,0.011212622,0.0034704634,-0.027154125,-0.052830476,0.024106214,0.036501054,-0.02903829,0.0055601303,-0.025233017,-0.0056848177,-0.03090398,-0.0055693663,-0.015895322,-0.0046965554,4.96801e-05]
CONSTEXT000038657449_1
CONSTEXT000038657449
1
RIP
Conformité
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris
2019-1
2019-05-09
1. La proposition de loi soumise à l'examen du Conseil constitutionnel a été déposée sur le bureau de l'Assemblée nationale, en application du troisième alinéa de l'article 11 de la Constitution.2. Aux termes des premier, troisième, quatrième et sixième alinéas de l'article 11 de la Constitution : « Le Président de la République, sur proposition du Gouvernement pendant la durée des sessions ou sur proposition conjointe des deux assemblées, publiées au Journal officiel, peut soumettre au référendum tout projet de loi portant sur l'organisation des pouvoirs publics, sur des réformes relatives à la politique économique, sociale ou environnementale de la nation et aux services publics qui y concourent, ou tendant à autoriser la ratification d'un traité qui, sans être contraire à la Constitution, aurait des incidences sur le fonctionnement des institutions. »« Un référendum portant sur un objet mentionné au premier alinéa peut être organisé à l'initiative d'un cinquième des membres du Parlement, soutenue par un dixième des électeurs inscrits sur les listes électorales. Cette initiative prend la forme d'une proposition de loi et ne peut avoir pour objet l'abrogation d'une disposition législative promulguée depuis moins d'un an ».« Les conditions de sa présentation et celles dans lesquelles le Conseil constitutionnel contrôle le respect des dispositions de l'alinéa précédent sont déterminées par une loi organique. »« Lorsque la proposition de loi n'est pas adoptée par le peuple
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris 1. La proposition de loi soumise à l'examen du Conseil constitutionnel a été déposée sur le bureau de l'Assemblée nationale, en application du troisième alinéa de l'article 11 de la Constitution.2. Aux termes des premier, troisième, quatrième et sixième alinéas de l'article 11 de la Constitution : « Le Président de la République, sur proposition du Gouvernement pendant la durée des sessions ou sur proposition conjointe des deux assemblées, publiées au Journal officiel, peut soumettre au référendum tout projet de loi portant sur l'organisation des pouvoirs publics, sur des réformes relatives à la politique économique, sociale ou environnementale de la nation et aux services publics qui y concourent, ou tendant à autoriser la ratification d'un traité qui, sans être contraire à la Constitution, aurait des incidences sur le fonctionnement des institutions. »« Un référendum portant sur un objet mentionné au premier alinéa peut être organisé à l'initiative d'un cinquième des membres du Parlement, soutenue par un dixième des électeurs inscrits sur les listes électorales. Cette initiative prend la forme d'une proposition de loi et ne peut avoir pour objet l'abrogation d'une disposition législative promulguée depuis moins d'un an ».« Les conditions de sa présentation et celles dans lesquelles le Conseil constitutionnel contrôle le respect des dispositions de l'alinéa précédent sont déterminées par une loi organique. »« Lorsque la proposition de loi n'est pas adoptée par le peuple
[-0.009995983,0.025342977,0.012625039,0.0073111886,0.00014196201,0.010191072,0.05469921,-0.014343679,-0.013832731,0.023113389,-0.013804861,0.014640957,-0.0040945443,-0.025584515,0.010804209,0.034893043,0.04035553,0.025993273,0.0021854602,0.015319123,-0.010302551,-0.035116002,-0.014566638,0.028780257,0.023707945,0.030805465,-0.0016164508,0.008207669,-0.023707945,0.003855328,-0.021571258,-0.0029890405,-0.0036137896,-0.05611128,-0.03676961,-0.012160541,-0.039166417,-0.032310437,-0.043291155,0.041396003,-0.023596466,0.0063171643,-0.0063032294,-0.05826655,0.04057849,-0.02298333,0.0059223413,-0.016824095,-0.013349654,0.019527469,-0.009800894,0.018375516,0.030972684,-0.04871648,-0.031028423,0.005945566,-0.008593202,-0.034595765,-0.07907603,0.016963443,-0.014854626,0.0069070756,-0.052283823,-0.06893141,-0.0016640618,0.0037670736,0.05135483,-0.024283921,0.009977403,-0.0021575904,0.004895802,0.050388675,-0.07405946,-0.0024409336,-0.0356734,-0.0053649447,-0.009773024,-0.0020623682,0.012940897,0.009856634,-0.01769735,-0.018301196,0.025175758,-0.001703544,-0.008486367,-0.0010097012,0.024692679,0.039166417,0.014334389,-0.001636192,-0.021961436,0.037178367,-0.013266045,-0.033703927,-0.023559306,-0.021905696,-0.03559908,-0.012764388,0.01583007,0.023131968,-0.029096115,-0.0105533805,0.009949533,-0.011166517,0.035896357,0.074208096,0.020419303,-0.022054335,0.009605805,-0.0029983304,-0.032719195,-0.0039459052,0.055256605,0.017483681,-0.02456262,-0.018041078,0.013907051,0.014111429,-0.039240737,0.0035975322,-0.017539421,-0.024339661,0.02647635,0.028371498,-0.030471027,0.0071764844,0.041247364,0.045000505,-0.024283921,0.017994627,0.012913027,0.057523355,-0.055182286,0.035580497,0.028222859,0.006372904,-0.008588556,0.043811392,0.0031307123,-0.064769514,0.026253391,-0.005676158,-0.09044693,-0.06369188,0.037958723,-0.076549165,0.08933213,-0.0060849153,-0.03730843,0.0069535254,0.039203577,0.060496137,0.066032946,-0.08212313,0.010200362,-0.009336397,-0.007822135,-0.012773678,0.029411973,0.027535403,-0.036230795,0.0706036,-0.06532691,0.019007232,0.032143217,0.025473036,-0.018793562,0.00016242891,-0.028798837,0.008560686,0.050537314,-0.018254746,-0.01061841,-0.01586723,-0.0280928,0.03140002,-0.025082858,0.024321081,-0.046078138,-0.004593879,0.005495004,0.042139202,-0.01227202,-0.00075422757,-0.038311742,0.045297783,-0.019508889,-0.003620757,0.03167872,0.02080948,-0.023094809,-0.021013862,0.011733203,0.046375416,-0.026773628,-0.070157684,-0.003616112,-0.043774232,-0.03528322,-0.00884403,-0.009392137,-0.0027939517,0.03712263,0.01749297,-0.035654817,-0.030210909,-0.01220699,0.00621962,-0.007441248,-0.041061565,-0.017307172,-0.027405344,0.014966105,0.009062343,-0.00051472115,0.040875766,-0.02298333,0.0213483,0.07294466,-0.027089486,-0.013637642,0.033592448,-0.007037135,0.016145928,0.010181782,-0.019694688,-0.007241514,-0.021608418,0.031920258,-0.012764388,-0.0053695897,-0.022165814,-0.0034860526,-0.014557348,0.06621874,-0.05592548,0.014613087,0.015477052,0.014111429,-0.0050165714,-0.030192329,0.0039041003,-0.009522196,-0.03379683,0.0049561867,-0.0073483484,-0.025603095,-0.0009504777,-0.046747014,-0.0065772827,0.019620368,0.03154866,-0.0024548685,0.0713468,0.018774983,0.012634329,0.020623682,-0.0070789396,0.06922869,-0.018719243,0.0088719,0.011761073,0.027386764,0.027721202,0.030563926,-0.026234811,-0.009447876,-0.027907,0.0034697952,-0.01227202,0.012922317,-0.002747502,0.013098826,-0.026011853,0.03307221,0.009680125,0.0027056972,-0.008323792,0.059269864,-0.02454404,-0.04715577,-0.014668827,0.029746411,-0.014984685,0.00700462,-0.041210204,-0.01928593,-0.010051723,-0.024302501,-0.03307221,-0.013024506,-0.04173044,0.07394798,-0.007854651,0.0019520501,-0.004287311,-0.01924877,-0.14930803,0.021738477,0.0005916535,-0.006535478,0.0064843833,0.019954806,-0.006698052,-0.0348373,0.014548058,0.039575174,0.0014225232,-0.0666275,-0.032514814,0.0001901536,-0.015337703,-0.013693382,0.0037554612,0.023243448,0.018942202,-0.025918953,-0.038348902,-0.026086172,0.063914835,0.01399995,-0.012550719,-0.013089536,-0.016675455,0.03008085,-0.0049654767,0.032217536,-0.0006160396,-0.007998644,0.005801572,-0.0026313777,0.07398514,-0.011761073,0.04875364,-0.016210958,0.0016152896,0.007538792,0.05425329,0.050165717,-0.004484722,-4.895367e-05,0.0027916292,-0.009995983,-0.025120018,-0.027591143,-0.041173045,0.008147283,-0.030173749,-0.04585518,-0.030415287,-0.005499649,-0.03173446,-0.017028473,0.007394798,0.0033467035,-0.0074923425,0.0031516147,-0.027721202,-0.05860099,-0.012847997,-0.067184895,-0.043179676,0.027702622,0.022444513,0.02086522,0.012847997,0.015031135,0.03000653,-0.039798133,-0.011296576,0.035078842,-0.032904994,-0.02277895,-0.032682035,0.027832681,-0.018226877,-0.07246159,0.024692679,0.00066945684,-0.017771669,0.016396757,-0.025212917,-0.022221554,0.009043763,0.0045358166,0.045297783,0.23693082,0.060421817,0.04763885,0.035004523,0.013089536,-0.04035553,0.0137769915,0.025584515,0.014436578,0.0048493524,0.0021239142,0.018700663,0.03136286,0.0010892464,-0.019824747,0.01577433,-0.02281611,0.012606459,0.054141812,-0.0011850488,-0.0063032294,0.0134518435,0.016712615,-0.011835393,-0.05120619,0.008351662,0.00804045,-0.022463093,-0.0074737626,0.013182435,-0.0068931407,-0.043216836,0.049311038,-0.0006021047,-0.04745305,-0.0064750933,0.0134518435,0.004928317,-0.04548358,0.03879482,0.013349654,-0.010274681,-0.01065557,0.00079545175,-0.013331074,-0.0048354175,-0.0017767024,0.0061685247,0.002919366,-0.0030378127,-0.030563926,-0.013284625,0.00533243,0.016944863,-0.074208096,0.00023079713,-0.048084766,0.013108116,-0.0111943865,0.0066330223,0.053844534,0.007831425,-0.03676961,0.032068897,0.032700613,-0.050500154,0.025733154,-0.036286533,0.040727127,0.016749775,0.018013207,-0.012996636,0.03541328,0.008151929,0.013897761,-0.04403435,-0.018096818,0.059344184,-0.01743723,-0.019564629,0.008175153,-0.027331024,-0.0026894398,-0.034001205,0.033592448,0.007376218,0.05094607,-0.0028729162,0.011556694,0.01070202,-0.025045699,-0.022091495,0.015179774,0.04236216,-0.0048586424,-0.020214925,0.016675455,0.018552024,-0.04254796,0.023930904,0.017845988,-0.013554033,0.03543186,0.0060709803,0.07253591,-0.005090891,0.037568547,-0.021552678,-0.028650198,0.024283921,0.01218841,0.01566285,-0.03522748,-0.009280657,0.042919558,0.046895653,-0.003859973,0.018877173,0.018979361,0.02127398,-0.035952095,0.04054133,0.046747014,0.016851963,-0.017130664,-0.004951542,-0.018932912,0.0067352117,0.024098122,0.009420007,0.022648891,0.0036532718,-0.03193884,0.028204279,0.011761073,-0.048196245,0.07082656,0.046263937,-0.046598375,0.010163202,-0.0044823997,0.025231497,-0.02996937,-0.047007132,0.021849956,0.046189617,-0.04046701,0.00042472477,-0.024079543,-0.013043086,0.013498293,-0.0021819763,-0.003344381,-0.02121824,0.016536105,-0.05261826,-0.023057649,-0.050202876,0.015235513,-0.03727127,-0.025491616,0.05629708,-0.008402757,0.05462489,0.0104419,0.04960832,-0.0208838,0.032198958,0.0046728435,-0.036360852,0.002533833,-0.05841519,-0.023484986,-0.0020159185,0.010107462,0.02441398,-0.017251432,0.01764161,0.016889123,0.0019253416,0.021682737,0.03849754,0.003774041,-0.026123332,-0.026847947,-0.032570556,0.0076827863,-0.026606409,0.016517526,-0.01606232,-0.021552678,0.06900573,0.034149844,-0.028390078,0.039352216,0.024674099,0.040838607,0.033165112,0.037568547,-0.00352089,-0.030322388,-0.038348902,0.004154929,-0.019601788,-0.022314453,0.01244853,0.0010636989,0.031028423,-0.013646932,-0.010906398,-0.012652908,0.057523355,-0.013823441,0.018533444,0.010506931,-0.022035755,0.0043709204,0.02285327,0.02478558,-0.02983931,0.078258514,0.0350231,0.02092096,-0.05845235,0.017344331,0.050797433,-0.0039807423,0.012076931,0.037549965,-0.0015560662,-0.0030285227,-0.028966056,0.03543186,-0.015458472,-0.0011124712,0.023763685,0.04039269,0.0029890405,-0.014548058,-0.02487848,0.019546049,0.023856584,0.07472833,0.01939741,-0.0022841657,0.019137291,-0.009717285,0.0736507,0.04559506,0.011612434,-0.057114597,-0.034484286,-0.002968138,-0.022407353,0.015634982,0.04243648,-0.03875766,-0.007761751,-0.021552678,-0.02452546,0.013637642,-0.007915035,-0.02792558,-0.0041967337,-0.027665462,-0.06543839,0.043774232,-0.0071207443,-0.07610325,-0.04396003,-0.038014464,-0.027052326,-0.0048679323,-0.037772924,-0.05120619,0.01406498,0.011370895,-0.030229488,-0.04184192,-0.022481672,5.0949555e-05,-0.008449207,-0.018988652,-0.03552476,0.013925631,-0.00011118905,0.025974693,0.0029309783,-0.037698604,-0.017288592,0.051763587,-0.05417897,-0.048382044,-0.0100795925,-0.027423924,-0.03205032,-0.022611732,0.008198379,-0.014659537,0.023522146,-0.015727881,0.008537461,-0.009615095,-0.029616352,-0.026940847,0.004010935,0.002145978,-0.024116702,0.0031260673,0.020530783,0.026922267,-0.04243648,0.005838732,-0.005081601,-0.0045102695,0.015504922,-0.0006288133,-0.016629005,-0.020382144,-0.01406498,0.02491564,-0.015272673,0.018356936,-0.013386814,0.0024409336,0.04039269,-0.057857793,-0.057077438,-0.033889726,-0.01758587,-0.02482274,-0.02474842,-0.005973436,-0.0037415263,-0.022277294,0.03009943,-0.029374814,-0.03190168,0.029653512,0.010116752,0.015532792,-0.076623484,0.04957116,-0.026847947,0.0160809,-0.006516898,-0.0050397962,0.0140464,-0.025287237,0.024228182,-0.036360852,-0.006823466,0.017112082,-0.052060865,-0.0029751055,0.019787587,0.036416594,-0.011120067,0.012067641,-0.02084664,-0.025194338,0.023410667,0.059084065,-0.0022353935,-0.025231497,0.008727905,-0.0017070278,-0.03838606,0.014594507,-0.04927388,-0.0023538403,-0.019713268,0.019062972,0.025881793,-0.005109471,0.042139202,-0.030322388,-0.04444311,0.00882545,-0.0457437,-0.0008262247,-0.023131968,-0.021868536,-0.011212966,-0.032254696,0.0064611584,-0.014408709,0.00050659245,0.011584564,0.01943457,-0.082940646,0.010153912,0.01240208,-0.04024405,-0.15138897,-0.023633625,-0.009800894,0.018133977,-0.04422015,-0.008607136,-0.0013923309,-0.011166517,0.0015920647,-0.021571258,0.008347018,-0.004905092,0.029486293,-0.011965452,0.011445215,0.035747718,0.003639337,0.016721904,-0.0047936128,0.05265542,-0.041990563,0.028668778,0.027684042,-0.03136286,0.0051280507,-0.043811392,0.032904994,-0.010144622,-0.041470323,-0.022091495,0.03517174,-0.010265391,0.0009173823,0.057709154,0.029560613,0.016619716,0.010506931,0.0064147087,-0.01926735,-0.0027173096,-0.01943457,0.00619175,-0.04737873,-0.025287237,-0.027070906,0.008913704,-0.0021831377,-0.012699358,-0.012550719,0.025101438,0.025287237,0.013080246,-0.0013888471,0.05417897,-0.025101438,0.03838606,0.011073617,0.015105454,-0.06636738,0.051540628,-0.008895124,0.036082156,-0.009921663,-0.085764796,-0.00310981,0.032774933,0.021682737,0.04600382,0.032236118,-0.024655519,-0.01934167,-0.016991314,-0.034187004,-0.006828111,-0.008509591,0.026067592,-0.019508889,0.008370242,-0.025788894,0.0018684407,-0.028445818,-0.044740386,-0.039946772,0.011343026,0.033592448,-0.005281335,-0.0389063,0.036082156,-0.0095872255,-0.013804861,-0.052432463,-0.04407151,-0.009847344,0.09921664,-0.027907,0.0058805365,-0.011807523,0.014668827,0.034967363,0.0025942177,-0.026086172,-0.013674802,0.0018045723,0.0025686703,0.015096164,0.052469622,-0.03857186,-0.017957468,0.0245812,-0.004291956,-0.001221628,0.026736468,0.0012413692,-0.00063055515,-0.046152458,0.016647585,-0.0316973,0.008556041,0.0040736417,-0.011296576,-0.014111429,0.017084213,-0.014352969,-0.032719195,0.0043685976,0.025120018,0.07677212,0.01745581,0.082866326,-0.0141021395,0.0107113095,0.03545044,0.0013876859,0.0211625,-0.0040388047,-0.020010546,-0.019676108,0.043737072,-0.0070975195,-0.039538015,-0.057151757,-0.008974089,-0.0011269867,-0.014455158,-0.009327107,0.02812996,-0.009048409,0.021088181,0.024283921,-0.04280808,0.03658381,0.0015061327,-0.029151855,0.055256605,-0.017483681,0.071235314,-0.015124034,-0.005044441,-0.009800894,0.07208999,0.036286533,-0.027070906,-0.0018835368,-0.057449035,-0.023577886,0.046561215,0.025844634,-0.01926735,0.0015386475,0.012058351,0.026996586,0.01926735,-0.006558703,-0.044554587,0.018644923,-0.025565935,-0.0016919316,0.04414583,0.011435925,0.0014991652,0.013609773,0.040875766,0.004891157,-0.03543186,0.0559998,0.0529527,0.01762303,0.00050949556,-0.010153912,-0.04228784,0.01593226,0.0048168376,0.05284122,0.018886462,0.055739682,0.00800329,0.016183088,0.018459124,-0.03184594,0.045149144,0.02647635,0.009596515,-0.04169328,0.027869841,-0.046375416,-0.0071114544,0.016341018,-0.016944863,-0.04723009,0.017957468,-0.014185749,-0.028315758,-0.028594458,0.022035755,-0.009420007,-0.009930953,0.04024405,0.034261327,-0.011733203,-0.04243648,0.0315115,0.04396003,-0.023131968,0.017353622,-0.018161846,0.004001645,-0.046412576,0.014297229,-0.030675406,-0.0044731097,0.012123381,-0.04749021,-0.02285327,-0.0035301798,0.03860902,-0.03349955,0.009596515,-0.017483681,-0.021032441,-0.008240183,0.0024455786,-0.0116867535,0.023782264,-0.032589134]
CONSTEXT000038657449_2
CONSTEXT000038657449
2
RIP
Conformité
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris
2019-1
2019-05-09
le Conseil constitutionnel contrôle le respect des dispositions de l'alinéa précédent sont déterminées par une loi organique. »« Lorsque la proposition de loi n'est pas adoptée par le peuple français, aucune nouvelle proposition de référendum portant sur le même sujet ne peut être présentée avant l'expiration d'un délai de deux ans suivant la date du scrutin ». 3. Aux termes de l'article 45-2 de l'ordonnance du 7 novembre 1958 mentionnée ci-dessus : « Le Conseil constitutionnel vérifie, dans le délai d'un mois à compter de la transmission de la proposition de loi :« 1° Que la proposition de loi est présentée par au moins un cinquième des membres du Parlement, ce cinquième étant calculé sur le nombre des sièges effectivement pourvus à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine par le Conseil constitutionnel, arrondi au chiffre immédiatement supérieur en cas de fraction ;« 2° Que son objet respecte les conditions posées aux troisième et sixième alinéas de l'article 11 de la Constitution, les délais qui y sont mentionnés étant calculés à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine par le Conseil constitutionnel ;« 3° Et qu'aucune disposition de la proposition de loi n'est contraire à la Constitution ». 4. En premier lieu, la proposition de loi a été présentée par au moins un cinquième des membres du Parlement à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine du Conseil constitutionnel. 5. En deuxième lieu, elle a pour objet de prévoir que « l'aménagement, l'exploitation et le développement des
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris le Conseil constitutionnel contrôle le respect des dispositions de l'alinéa précédent sont déterminées par une loi organique. »« Lorsque la proposition de loi n'est pas adoptée par le peuple français, aucune nouvelle proposition de référendum portant sur le même sujet ne peut être présentée avant l'expiration d'un délai de deux ans suivant la date du scrutin ». 3. Aux termes de l'article 45-2 de l'ordonnance du 7 novembre 1958 mentionnée ci-dessus : « Le Conseil constitutionnel vérifie, dans le délai d'un mois à compter de la transmission de la proposition de loi :« 1° Que la proposition de loi est présentée par au moins un cinquième des membres du Parlement, ce cinquième étant calculé sur le nombre des sièges effectivement pourvus à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine par le Conseil constitutionnel, arrondi au chiffre immédiatement supérieur en cas de fraction ;« 2° Que son objet respecte les conditions posées aux troisième et sixième alinéas de l'article 11 de la Constitution, les délais qui y sont mentionnés étant calculés à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine par le Conseil constitutionnel ;« 3° Et qu'aucune disposition de la proposition de loi n'est contraire à la Constitution ». 4. En premier lieu, la proposition de loi a été présentée par au moins un cinquième des membres du Parlement à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine du Conseil constitutionnel. 5. En deuxième lieu, elle a pour objet de prévoir que « l'aménagement, l'exploitation et le développement des
[-0.009005483,0.012038083,0.0030510633,0.026088668,-0.0022756038,-0.01664468,0.06938515,-0.04157939,-0.024390042,0.052842014,-0.00027493032,0.0014112898,0.017097032,-0.021122035,-0.008225407,0.02337456,0.028341193,0.0028433509,0.008770076,0.020826621,-0.008096165,-0.034655645,-0.017567847,0.025793254,0.025830181,0.020808158,-0.021362059,0.023226853,-0.004211944,0.04970325,-0.015564577,-7.078807e-05,0.021546692,-0.06362459,-0.019275703,-0.007653045,-0.01931263,-0.046564486,-0.0358373,0.046712194,0.016672375,-0.018334074,-0.017244738,-0.035652667,0.059784222,-0.028175022,0.009619389,-0.025737865,-0.020328112,0.030298304,0.017410908,0.01034869,0.010025581,-0.06177826,-0.026457934,0.033160117,0.0060098097,-0.04959247,-0.037646703,0.008525437,0.0004434081,-0.0019236469,-0.021232815,-0.041320905,-0.012776615,-0.017180117,0.047783066,-0.024279263,0.021583619,-0.0024810082,0.020900475,0.034360234,-0.05487298,-0.015601503,-0.062036745,0.002384076,-0.0036326577,-0.016321572,0.018214062,0.03027984,-0.019608043,-0.03266161,0.023466876,-0.016340036,0.021029718,0.01592461,0.00589903,0.043721136,0.024870088,-0.010754882,-0.01686624,0.043499574,-0.0008983558,-0.010357921,-0.052952792,-0.022359077,-0.037923653,-0.013210503,0.030519864,0.017410908,-0.011668816,-0.010690261,0.011530342,-0.019109534,0.018897206,0.06395693,0.025571695,-0.017964808,0.004781999,-0.0009941342,-0.01791865,0.023245316,0.031683054,0.006083663,-0.013921341,-0.015112225,0.017650932,-0.0073160892,-0.032403123,-0.006351381,-0.011502647,-0.028802775,0.044570446,0.0023194542,-0.047118384,0.00051697285,0.035874225,0.056313116,-0.028765848,0.027861146,0.019127997,0.05838101,-0.043610357,0.008774691,0.010579481,0.01135494,0.010487164,0.072117716,-0.002972594,-0.0628122,0.05827023,-0.020992791,-0.08574364,-0.033141654,0.051734217,-0.025091648,0.06846198,-0.0150568355,-0.028156558,0.017567847,0.0305014,0.062849134,0.072265424,-0.07776749,-0.016930861,-0.0014378309,-0.03072296,-0.02610713,-0.0012208868,0.0133674415,-0.025793254,0.051734217,-0.05561151,0.03522801,0.030298304,0.009757863,-0.025516305,0.00762535,-0.035874225,-0.008714686,0.054356005,-0.046896826,-0.012398117,-0.02594096,-0.009093184,0.037277438,-0.026845664,0.019349556,-0.06916358,-0.02254371,0.020678915,0.04050852,0.001108376,-0.011068759,-0.034674108,0.017023178,-0.00584364,0.0009854796,0.012979712,0.008977788,-0.03655737,-0.010597944,0.009822485,0.039142232,-0.018657181,-0.055316098,0.007990001,-0.04191173,-0.0133674415,0.01881412,-0.014004426,-0.004385038,-0.0021532844,0.003355708,-0.030741423,-0.013847488,0.012545824,0.0028295033,0.009591693,-0.03611425,-0.008183866,-0.018961826,0.03522801,-0.00768074,0.004948169,0.03171998,-0.018075587,0.0058805663,0.050109442,-0.030538326,0.0020413506,0.0080176955,0.0014205215,0.0024117709,0.017097032,-0.019404946,-0.01836177,-0.013256662,0.012195021,-0.019848065,0.0014551402,-0.022783734,-0.01685701,0.022359077,0.06986519,-0.049444765,0.024260798,0.0474138,0.0075376495,-0.00951784,-0.06151977,-0.0022836816,0.0136351595,0.0014262913,0.025959425,-0.017937113,-0.021343594,-0.017346287,-0.0519927,-0.02754727,0.018795656,0.025664011,-0.018564865,0.0564239,0.0072883945,0.012942785,-0.011447256,-0.00665141,0.09475374,-0.014456778,0.004458891,0.016340036,0.016441584,0.019294167,0.031036837,-0.01297048,0.0022398313,-0.031313784,-0.0074545643,0.0031756905,0.01313665,-0.023411486,0.00019775944,-0.01747553,0.013062797,0.036483515,0.0031410719,-0.012656604,0.07533033,-0.027011832,-0.061815187,-0.022469858,0.02599635,-0.025867108,0.013727477,-0.042391777,-0.040102325,-0.009554767,-0.009314744,-0.0497771,-0.0026333306,-0.027934998,0.075441115,-0.0103763845,-0.01664468,-0.0133674415,0.004892779,-0.14401388,0.021528227,0.0028018083,-0.026697956,0.004454275,0.022155982,-0.001786326,-0.044607375,0.0014839892,0.04948169,-0.008945477,-0.071785375,-0.043831915,-0.01335821,-0.0049066264,-0.021583619,-0.010717955,-0.005192808,0.020125017,-0.018675646,-0.035154156,-0.034637183,0.03757285,0.012425813,-0.027307246,-0.0053174356,0.006272912,0.020235796,-0.04091471,0.026531788,0.016229255,0.012351959,0.0002082893,-0.03245851,0.06761267,-0.01903568,0.072043866,0.013699781,0.02226676,0.05236197,0.04959247,0.05114339,-0.034101747,0.0045512076,-0.010154825,-0.055426877,-0.023005294,0.001972113,-0.020937402,-0.012573519,-0.020937402,-0.02331917,-0.027842682,-0.012601214,-0.036206566,0.00082854135,-0.004022695,-0.008299261,-0.057310138,-0.0072006937,-0.030981446,-0.067723446,-0.016238488,-0.06458469,-0.028285801,0.045936733,0.0009491299,0.005114339,0.021509765,-0.004541976,0.01859256,-0.038034435,-0.005063565,0.035985004,-0.038329847,-0.012619677,-0.052915867,0.050737195,-0.0268272,-0.068203494,0.0055066845,-0.004634293,-0.0075238016,0.021122035,-0.028415045,-0.045604393,0.016146172,-0.012047314,0.0038496016,0.22909284,0.040434666,0.021214351,0.021989811,0.028341193,-0.016727766,0.014198291,0.049555544,0.009924033,-0.0013489762,-0.013478221,0.003030292,0.03506184,-0.021509765,-0.03880989,-0.005238966,-0.030759886,-0.0033072417,0.041542463,-0.009023947,-0.017438604,0.008931629,0.0268272,-0.0016824697,-0.06458469,-0.0150568355,-0.0066929525,-0.01664468,-0.019829603,0.008391578,-0.010302531,-0.00078526797,0.06665257,-0.022174444,-0.054577567,0.0036418894,-0.00053889805,0.009490145,-0.06499088,0.043499574,0.009730169,-0.0020701995,-0.034914132,-0.036982026,0.006836043,-0.01163189,5.012502e-05,-0.007297626,-0.008982404,-0.016570827,-0.027196467,0.010533323,0.005972883,0.011096453,-0.07270854,0.023023756,-0.04571517,0.017106263,-0.0257194,0.0059544197,0.04937091,0.010173288,-0.02304222,0.043425724,0.012351959,-0.035412643,0.046564486,-0.047783066,0.050109442,0.016127707,0.014844507,-0.023226853,0.024943942,0.01480758,0.005432831,-0.028802775,-0.0115765,0.057753257,-0.0034595642,-0.027639586,-0.0032749309,-0.026624104,-0.0013224351,-0.009868643,0.033990968,0.024297725,0.025350135,-0.003870373,0.010422543,-0.011447256,-0.04091471,0.00039003757,0.02732571,0.01570305,-0.013598233,-0.023429949,-0.0063236863,0.036668148,-0.0299475,0.04770921,0.013875183,-0.022894513,0.021675935,0.0012601214,0.061815187,0.008262334,0.04102549,0.0030949134,-0.041653242,0.042834897,0.01886951,0.013570538,-0.038994525,-0.00055534195,0.027842682,0.035523422,-0.013376674,0.0268272,0.013312052,0.024777772,-0.048226185,0.07148997,0.046859898,0.01007174,-0.01641389,0.0029402832,-0.037923653,0.007385327,0.020845085,-0.004241947,-0.0036926635,-0.013625928,-0.04246563,0.046306,0.016607754,-0.033326287,0.058750276,0.024851626,-0.045161273,-0.012176557,0.0047543044,0.007274547,-0.0065498617,-0.03266161,0.018380232,0.04981403,-0.019940382,-0.008290029,-0.034489475,-0.017097032,0.0034687957,-0.005271277,-0.0023586887,-0.036261953,0.022912977,-0.05003559,-0.004320416,-0.026125593,0.0039165313,-0.017272433,-0.037886728,0.041727096,-0.015075299,0.05882413,-0.0035588045,0.022026738,-0.023817679,0.037037414,-0.013053565,-0.0056036166,0.0046666036,-0.033824798,-0.008590058,0.013644392,0.018851047,0.026439471,-0.030649107,0.024722382,0.025793254,-0.009028562,0.010533323,0.044016548,-0.0034549483,-0.031923074,-0.02710415,-0.03733283,0.049444765,-0.030187523,0.04287182,-0.012545824,-0.01669084,0.061593626,0.020328112,-0.022469858,0.034600258,0.030759886,0.025460914,0.05609156,0.045235127,-0.004357343,-0.013764403,-0.021805178,-0.0069422075,-0.0299475,-0.031018373,0.036742,0.021417448,0.05099568,-0.020069625,0.016127707,-0.011871913,0.06702184,-0.024205409,0.016912399,-0.0029656703,-0.012628909,-0.006577557,0.016589291,0.026864126,-0.019109534,0.04124705,0.05550073,0.029264357,-0.062479865,0.018463317,0.051328022,-0.016072318,0.0074222535,0.009425524,-0.0018890281,0.001811713,-0.04530898,0.03293856,-0.016543131,0.0035911151,-0.011198002,0.024593139,0.022192907,-0.022229834,-0.052842014,0.037388217,0.060596608,0.059968855,-0.009804022,-0.0014262913,0.03266161,-0.022783734,0.06728033,0.04080393,0.024962405,-0.03696356,-0.0098409485,0.015896916,-0.0015889993,0.024316188,0.042834897,-0.034471013,-0.010514859,-0.020457355,-0.033363216,0.008446967,-0.009157806,-0.0058805663,0.0006744881,-0.02304222,-0.055869997,0.034378696,0.012942785,-0.066431016,-0.03022445,-0.033215508,-0.017881723,-0.023891533,-0.05686702,-0.044902787,0.012130399,-0.019626506,-0.032809313,-0.043536503,0.012287337,0.032643143,0.012942785,-0.0036003469,-0.0497771,0.011502647,0.020605061,0.008248487,-0.011991925,-0.028415045,-0.039437644,0.0066144834,-0.04674912,-0.06554478,0.0083823465,-0.042982604,-0.032883167,-0.03340014,-0.011207233,-0.016995484,0.025405524,-0.013201272,0.023171464,-0.017263202,-0.054836053,-0.002105972,0.0026171752,0.002972594,-0.015509186,-0.004539668,0.0054928367,0.008368499,-0.037665166,0.022377541,-0.0061436687,0.006166748,-0.00027824796,0.008511589,0.0058621033,-0.0077453614,-0.023134537,0.017927881,-0.006642178,-0.0031964618,-0.008257719,0.004135783,0.029855184,-0.06443698,-0.015989233,-0.014336766,-0.013921341,-0.020346576,-0.03760978,-0.0025548616,-0.011068759,-0.008636217,0.055389952,-0.040323883,-0.063329175,0.044127326,0.028802775,0.006305223,-0.066098675,0.061925966,-0.036631223,0.015915379,-0.002598712,0.0059082615,-0.00078526797,-0.0446443,0.027584195,-0.044902787,-0.0047543044,0.0115765,-0.05594385,0.0033741712,0.023909995,0.03456333,0.010930284,0.021842103,-0.008682375,-0.01480758,0.03829292,0.034674108,-0.018278684,0.00876546,-0.012471971,0.002760266,0.005308204,0.01914646,-0.04224407,0.009563998,-0.023836143,0.028673531,0.020826621,0.016893934,0.044053476,-0.027307246,-0.025313208,-0.029375138,-0.061408993,-0.018832583,-0.019884992,-0.023429949,-0.020291185,-0.025036259,-0.023411486,-0.010265605,-0.006868354,0.034378696,0.014567558,-0.068129644,0.023522265,0.0113734035,-0.03716666,-0.15346709,-0.022580637,-0.016663143,0.012010388,-0.04139476,-0.003030292,0.014392156,-0.010957979,0.019903457,-0.020845085,0.009637851,-0.019626506,0.0220452,-0.033529386,0.036317345,0.024999332,-0.0133305155,0.028138096,-0.0030787583,0.047783066,-0.02715954,0.04379499,-0.0034572561,-0.020882012,0.0065037035,-0.047893845,0.00018362346,-0.0314061,-0.026421007,-0.037240513,0.044053476,0.007708435,-0.020014236,0.042317923,0.040434666,0.043536503,0.010182519,0.015813831,-0.021786714,-0.010967211,0.0030626028,0.009319359,-0.036151174,-0.0044658147,-0.023356097,0.0028364272,0.0042373314,-0.007463796,-0.025442451,0.021712862,0.02955977,0.0020078858,-0.027491879,0.021952884,-0.010320994,0.04379499,0.033307824,0.020438893,-0.072597764,0.062479865,0.013450527,0.04047159,-0.020863548,-0.083232634,0.0033233971,0.031129153,0.006836043,0.031701516,0.024666991,-0.015343017,-0.032846242,0.008414657,-0.026679493,-0.016386194,-5.6724213e-05,0.010865662,0.0011441486,0.005183576,-0.012213484,-0.0020725073,-0.043167237,-0.0716746,-0.049260132,0.014133669,0.038108286,-0.025830181,-0.03712973,0.03796058,0.02053121,0.0044565834,-0.049001645,-0.015998464,0.004108088,0.09578769,-0.02398385,0.0028271955,-0.030039817,0.008446967,0.024519285,0.0029148962,-0.007888452,0.009702473,-0.0043250322,0.00812386,-0.008086933,0.03245851,-0.014484473,-0.002654102,0.007551497,-0.013201272,0.021952884,0.01964497,0.016155403,-0.01045947,-0.07197001,-0.014844507,-0.021602081,0.0015093762,-0.025073186,-0.03249544,0.00062832976,0.021011256,-0.020955864,-0.03624349,-0.020014236,0.017614005,0.075514965,0.020272722,0.082272545,-0.027898073,0.00057986355,0.039326865,-0.008663911,0.041283976,0.006189827,-0.020808158,-0.023946922,0.047339946,0.010976442,-0.029042797,-0.03378787,-0.016506206,-0.010357921,-0.00025473608,-0.007172999,0.019829603,0.014133669,0.022783734,0.025165502,-0.039769985,0.039179157,0.0005628427,-0.021583619,0.041431684,-0.021158962,0.064547755,0.013967499,-0.0026310226,0.018823352,0.05232504,0.046859898,-0.020438893,-0.0257194,-0.050294075,0.005945188,0.039880764,0.010699492,-0.017115494,0.030187523,0.013108956,0.022285223,0.03005828,-0.01547226,-0.00871007,0.0150568355,-0.014318302,0.005575922,0.028138096,0.0092455065,0.015730746,0.028507361,0.034360234,-0.03439716,-0.020346576,0.038736038,0.034046356,0.025368597,0.011198002,-0.03439716,-0.036058858,0.012416581,-0.0045442837,0.040360812,0.018149441,0.048853938,0.012379654,0.0037919038,0.03188615,0.001056448,0.05461449,0.04545669,0.0010045199,-0.021915957,0.038366772,-0.035264935,-0.015887685,0.026697956,-0.03149842,-0.028765848,0.01563843,-0.012278106,-0.0007229543,-0.03400943,0.027731903,-0.017567847,0.0043965774,0.022082128,0.03400943,-0.0108379675,-0.013699781,0.010320994,0.044385813,-0.0358373,0.009365518,-0.02415002,0.0009087414,-0.05298972,0.012287337,-0.03829292,0.019441873,-0.013607465,-0.051401876,-0.032310806,0.012481202,0.032144636,-0.025405524,0.0053220512,-0.042059436,0.011502647,-0.016773924,-0.0031664588,0.0033141654,0.031590737,-0.031184543]
CONSTEXT000038657449_3
CONSTEXT000038657449
3
RIP
Conformité
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris
2019-1
2019-05-09
membres du Parlement à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine du Conseil constitutionnel. 5. En deuxième lieu, elle a pour objet de prévoir que « l'aménagement, l'exploitation et le développement des aérodromes de Paris-Charles-de-Gaulle, Paris-Orly et de Paris-Le Bourget revêtent le caractère d'un service public national au sens du neuvième alinéa du préambule de la Constitution du 27 octobre 1946 ».6. Il en résulte que cette proposition de loi porte sur la politique économique de la nation et les services publics qui y concourent. Elle relève donc bien d'un des objets mentionnés au premier alinéa de l'article 11 de la Constitution. 7. Par ailleurs, à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine, elle n'avait pas pour objet l'abrogation d'une disposition législative promulguée depuis moins d'un an. Et aucune proposition de loi portant sur le même sujet n'avait été soumise au référendum depuis deux ans. 8. En dernier lieu, aux termes du neuvième alinéa du Préambule de 1946 : « Tout bien, toute entreprise, dont l'exploitation a ou acquiert les caractères d'un service public national ou d'un monopole de fait, doit devenir la propriété de la collectivité ». Si la nécessité de certains services publics nationaux découle de principes ou de règles de valeur constitutionnelle, la détermination des autres activités qui doivent être érigées en service public national est laissée à l'appréciation du législateur ou de l'autorité réglementaire selon les cas. 9. L'aménagement, l'exploitation
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris membres du Parlement à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine du Conseil constitutionnel. 5. En deuxième lieu, elle a pour objet de prévoir que « l'aménagement, l'exploitation et le développement des aérodromes de Paris-Charles-de-Gaulle, Paris-Orly et de Paris-Le Bourget revêtent le caractère d'un service public national au sens du neuvième alinéa du préambule de la Constitution du 27 octobre 1946 ».6. Il en résulte que cette proposition de loi porte sur la politique économique de la nation et les services publics qui y concourent. Elle relève donc bien d'un des objets mentionnés au premier alinéa de l'article 11 de la Constitution. 7. Par ailleurs, à la date d'enregistrement de la saisine, elle n'avait pas pour objet l'abrogation d'une disposition législative promulguée depuis moins d'un an. Et aucune proposition de loi portant sur le même sujet n'avait été soumise au référendum depuis deux ans. 8. En dernier lieu, aux termes du neuvième alinéa du Préambule de 1946 : « Tout bien, toute entreprise, dont l'exploitation a ou acquiert les caractères d'un service public national ou d'un monopole de fait, doit devenir la propriété de la collectivité ». Si la nécessité de certains services publics nationaux découle de principes ou de règles de valeur constitutionnelle, la détermination des autres activités qui doivent être érigées en service public national est laissée à l'appréciation du législateur ou de l'autorité réglementaire selon les cas. 9. L'aménagement, l'exploitation
[-0.038369205,0.047223635,-0.02699294,0.026824817,-0.009550271,0.008504177,0.049876228,0.0020816787,0.0072012306,0.0077289473,0.003332087,-0.0020057904,0.0064166607,-0.04438424,-0.002449446,0.007546815,0.065306105,0.038201082,-0.010274129,0.023238212,0.009400829,-0.036034174,-0.02454583,0.023499737,0.0011640121,0.021332828,-0.03261569,0.017550081,-0.038966972,0.019502167,-0.024863394,0.010899917,-0.027478626,-0.039452657,-0.026283091,-0.002535842,-0.022789888,-0.03577265,-0.047410436,0.03741651,0.0054499586,-0.001705739,-0.019745009,-0.05577918,0.041694283,-0.03904169,1.8160326e-05,-0.014075558,-0.037696715,0.00953159,-0.02219212,0.027721468,-0.0015527946,-0.060897566,0.020174654,0.018306632,-0.00716387,-0.025984207,-0.05159481,0.0071218396,-0.0050903643,0.012207534,0.010918598,-0.043487586,-0.013001444,-0.0062905694,0.04498201,-0.03177508,0.018175868,0.015513935,-0.01976369,0.03424087,-0.05484517,0.019278003,-0.05944051,-0.012767941,-0.012571799,0.004137672,0.001347312,-0.0022194455,-0.0061598076,-0.00034266556,0.0444216,0.0013741648,0.004067621,0.037117627,0.011535046,0.053724356,0.008541537,-0.032335486,-0.036482498,0.014131598,0.010694435,-0.021220747,-0.040909715,-0.0032153355,-0.060710765,-0.0045416323,-0.006281229,0.019502167,-0.012039412,0.0159249,0.0047961506,-0.013842055,0.0378088,0.04819501,0.032260768,-0.02387334,0.020566938,-0.0027366546,-0.020903183,0.0124503765,0.028804922,0.04995095,-0.0121047925,-0.04203053,0.03338158,-0.025162278,-0.021911915,-0.03403539,-0.025517201,0.007546815,0.04061083,0.026675377,0.0035469097,0.017139116,0.013384389,0.038556006,-0.030897109,0.029496092,-0.027273145,0.029215887,-0.010162048,0.0040933066,-0.0017092415,0.0061084367,0.021108666,0.0444216,0.015317793,-0.05301451,0.046625867,-0.032055285,-0.05637695,-0.04599074,0.03990098,-0.025816085,0.06638955,0.013748653,-0.054210044,0.0014815761,0.023948062,0.029608173,0.07255404,-0.06355016,-0.0061644777,-0.016242465,-0.073338605,-0.010460932,0.0152617525,-0.0033227468,-0.059851475,0.061607417,-0.054135323,-0.0032947266,0.011338903,0.018147849,-0.011507025,-0.00237706,-0.04132068,0.031980563,0.03566057,-0.030728986,0.014393121,-0.007546815,0.0068976767,0.025872126,-0.010825196,0.012515757,-0.036127575,-0.028917003,-0.01574744,0.024508469,0.020324096,0.010376871,0.01194601,0.022098718,0.025517201,-0.0012363981,0.015317793,-0.0031429497,0.005963665,-0.022958009,-0.009148645,0.010657074,-0.037734076,-0.075057186,-0.00037885853,-0.015112311,0.0016777186,-0.011647127,-0.02540512,0.0056040706,0.027179742,0.0125250975,-0.058282334,-0.033811226,0.000522171,-0.004149347,-0.0073600127,-0.032223407,-0.035249606,-0.041731644,0.041582204,0.005636761,-0.0011424131,0.033736505,-0.0074300636,0.017288558,0.060225077,0.0033951327,0.014794746,-0.008228644,-0.011245502,0.026768778,-0.0039181793,-0.005463969,-0.0023210193,-0.018082468,0.00790641,-0.007621536,-0.009620321,0.014131598,0.006024376,0.010862557,0.06926631,-0.028001674,0.018923078,0.03551113,0.01667211,0.005253816,-0.03171904,-0.020099934,-0.020473538,0.0013636572,-0.008223973,-0.007369353,-0.0017804599,0.008415446,-0.030374063,0.0046467087,0.018745616,0.015224392,-0.00217975,0.044757843,0.02222948,0.01032083,0.016335865,0.0013181241,0.049539983,-0.022677805,0.0040863017,0.009321437,0.026694056,0.015018909,-0.006113107,-0.040274587,-0.024377707,-0.038089,-0.0007798998,0.04128332,-0.0189044,-0.0254238,0.0005309273,-0.0002904193,0.03560453,0.02934665,0.008116562,-0.010685095,0.049427904,-0.039153773,-0.058095533,-0.03168168,0.034521073,-0.040274587,0.017867645,-0.00054668874,-0.01674683,-0.023705218,-0.04427216,-0.062317267,-0.022042677,0.0133376885,0.06624012,-0.013020124,-0.005389248,-0.014551903,-0.011684488,-0.1519824,0.026712736,0.021015264,-0.035959452,0.007747628,0.04755988,0.013132205,-0.029851016,0.039415296,0.013543171,-0.021930596,-0.057385683,-0.05693736,-0.022659125,-0.020174654,-0.0018785312,-0.010208748,0.006187828,0.007995141,-0.019987851,-0.0040045753,-0.029963098,0.017587442,0.03952738,0.000112957045,-0.023238212,0.022976689,0.036351737,-0.0238173,0.02222948,0.044571042,0.020903183,0.0014056878,-0.0043921904,0.042628296,-0.03164432,0.059926197,-0.0072572716,0.006584783,0.017802265,0.043562308,0.06582915,-0.025349079,-0.012039412,-0.007462754,-0.06728621,-0.04774668,-0.018960439,-0.009797784,0.009101945,-0.051818974,-0.032951936,-0.022789888,-0.022715166,-0.03177508,-0.0014395457,-0.012123473,0.016139723,-0.010021946,-0.00081083894,-0.012160833,-0.060860205,-0.0014278705,-0.042366773,-0.030318022,0.034763917,0.010236769,-0.003654321,0.034857318,-0.013048144,-0.0041586873,-0.02310745,0.0020840138,0.066277474,-0.05790873,-0.010339511,-0.012581139,0.031158634,-0.031793762,-0.073450685,-0.0043221395,-0.01673749,0.010703775,0.0051884353,-0.040872354,-0.039415296,0.030579545,-0.023929382,0.03907905,0.2301405,0.037771437,0.048045564,0.01901648,0.025722684,-0.039452657,-0.023499737,0.027459946,0.014010176,-0.008859102,-0.0030635586,0.034315594,0.027254464,-0.012982763,-0.022005318,-0.022005318,-0.024190905,-0.008616258,0.033941988,0.0021715774,-0.008578898,0.023387656,0.07352541,-0.017540742,-0.013132205,-0.02856208,-0.024302986,-0.040087786,0.006654834,0.016999014,-0.034689195,-0.020006532,0.044795204,-0.01667211,-0.057385683,0.002449446,0.00084352936,0.006804276,-0.06284031,0.05144537,0.01108672,-0.0190912,-0.053425472,-0.018465413,-0.035305645,-0.002619903,-0.011422964,0.015495256,-0.016961653,0.007542145,-0.022491004,0.01032083,-0.006752905,0.004688739,-0.08802127,0.016896272,-0.053537555,0.0035258944,0.005006303,-0.005029653,0.059814114,-0.0051277247,-0.017587442,0.023368975,-0.019931812,-0.0301499,0.0381824,-0.052827705,0.050212473,-0.0061831577,0.02312613,-0.011329562,0.0569,0.031606957,0.014972209,-0.0127212405,-0.034446355,0.07741089,0.0025825426,-0.004688739,0.0084668165,-0.04991359,-0.0014792412,-0.029122487,0.015429875,0.00058200606,0.015495256,0.0032690412,0.030822389,0.0039041692,-0.0035142193,-0.01430906,0.0444216,0.049016938,0.021781154,-0.010647735,-0.006682854,0.03653854,-0.032410208,0.04203053,0.027833551,-0.009816464,-0.013701953,0.011507025,0.04292718,0.0065194024,0.03993834,0.006299909,-0.036164936,0.007691587,0.04539297,0.013589871,-0.016569369,-0.015541956,0.028842283,0.032204725,0.022659125,0.024433747,0.0056694513,-0.00553402,-0.03739783,0.062167823,0.033811226,0.0073600127,-0.0190445,-0.0049876226,-0.012618499,0.010442251,0.018829677,-0.00877971,0.003633306,-0.0131415455,-0.031532235,0.055480298,0.037640676,-0.045654494,0.048718054,0.028393958,-0.03412879,-0.0037640673,0.008784381,0.025517201,0.004041936,-0.0014500533,0.01665343,0.0756176,-0.024807353,-0.0053425473,-0.00396021,-0.0011038851,0.024228266,-0.0048101605,-0.0025498522,-0.03242889,0.019520845,-0.06250407,-0.015000229,-0.02940269,0.022958009,-0.011432304,-0.025816085,0.005053004,0.004027926,0.06825758,0.02142623,0.028281877,-0.024153544,0.03028066,-0.017241858,0.00057967106,0.021276789,-0.09691306,0.008023161,0.007822349,0.02213608,0.026563294,0.01428104,0.036295697,-0.0028977715,0.021669073,0.017755564,0.039228495,-0.005258486,-0.039303213,-0.041358043,-0.031606957,0.024153544,-0.022565724,0.019240642,-0.024433747,-0.0067248847,0.055330858,0.04034931,-0.011703167,0.035473768,0.017699523,0.009779103,0.0025218318,0.018876377,0.0026595986,-0.015485915,-0.036856104,0.0068603163,-0.029701574,-0.028020352,0.025778726,0.01737262,0.021575673,-0.016055662,0.00715453,0.005053004,0.06108437,-0.027852232,0.016970994,-0.018353332,-0.010292809,-0.007070469,0.02303273,0.02861812,-0.051408008,0.063662246,0.0462149,0.012917383,-0.078980036,0.0047354396,0.026469894,-0.0036916814,0.024938114,0.010339511,0.011310883,0.0003803179,-0.030747667,0.037248388,-0.030728986,0.0107971765,-0.0065474226,-0.004926912,0.015943581,0.0024027452,-0.039452657,0.02777751,0.021519631,0.0763648,0.03009386,-0.0041049817,0.03907905,-0.038406566,0.07199363,0.011264182,0.023387656,-0.041395403,0.0140288565,-0.0063699605,-0.008891792,0.00435483,0.077933945,-0.05297715,-0.022603085,-0.033101376,-0.02301405,0.0124130165,0.029851016,-0.022005318,0.010601033,0.01987577,-0.027273145,0.038331844,0.0006024376,-0.05775929,-0.0064820414,-0.029776296,-0.0206043,-0.012142153,-0.015159011,-0.022117399,0.029234568,-0.0012714235,-0.0476346,-0.007299302,0.013421749,0.016354546,0.0030285332,0.015775459,-0.05312659,-0.00014834733,0.015719417,0.016298505,0.012076772,-0.044720482,-0.02217344,0.02376126,-0.0140662175,-0.038369205,-0.0013776673,-0.0153364735,-0.018932419,-0.014729366,0.016261145,-0.022845928,0.0140288565,-0.02540512,0.0140288565,-0.01823191,-0.053574916,-0.012375656,0.0019976178,0.018465413,-0.05215522,-0.0058515836,0.021669073,0.043188706,-0.036800064,0.038201082,-0.04128332,-0.006169148,0.00787372,0.022117399,0.015289772,-0.004497267,-0.048531253,0.027646748,0.03338158,-0.018745616,0.012739921,-0.019520845,0.06381168,-0.074496776,0.0019263993,-9.909281e-05,-0.020099934,-0.055853903,-0.010339511,-0.029869696,-0.018241249,0.028954364,0.035212245,-0.034558434,-0.029981777,0.025872126,-0.00052508974,0.0071825506,-0.061420612,0.051295925,-0.030112538,0.0028090405,-0.063662246,0.012235554,0.006047726,-0.022733847,0.023611818,-0.048830137,-0.029944418,-0.008476157,-0.045803938,0.03093447,0.0040045753,0.02618969,-0.016961653,0.020174654,0.018437393,-0.043039262,0.042329412,-0.0014021852,-0.002143557,-0.0058562537,0.012123473,-0.005393918,-0.007388033,0.02213608,-0.036949504,0.008284684,-0.04147012,0.01732592,0.025554562,-0.00398823,0.04468312,-0.030504825,-0.011572406,-0.017335258,-0.054621007,-0.024284307,-0.02452715,0.004903562,0.018521454,-0.028412638,-0.0027226442,0.011647127,-0.009639001,0.020548258,0.014383782,-0.07696257,-0.025106236,0.017933026,-0.020081254,-0.14563112,-0.022061357,-0.0066361534,0.0024704612,-0.051183846,-0.006930367,0.020099934,-0.016121043,0.016961653,-0.02052958,0.042703018,0.015971601,0.039191134,-0.00010981935,-0.01908186,0.06657636,0.007551485,0.025050195,0.0039858953,0.008536868,-0.024452427,0.019632928,0.030112538,0.0026479233,0.022472324,-0.033325538,-0.0128333215,-0.013552511,-0.05148273,-0.0020198005,0.061345894,0.01428104,-0.02142623,0.02217344,0.045505054,0.025647962,0.016858913,0.0052164556,-0.039826263,0.005104374,-0.050548717,0.013281647,-0.0856302,-0.038089,-0.030112538,0.010460932,0.019165922,-0.013178906,-0.046326984,0.031270713,0.0147200255,-0.0075281346,-0.019296683,0.018147849,-0.023910701,0.03018726,0.036183614,0.0005113714,-0.072666116,0.053051867,-0.006907017,0.0108345365,-0.009382148,-0.06930368,0.03722971,0.019427445,-0.009470879,0.032895893,0.027217103,0.010731795,-0.016307846,-0.016924294,-0.012889363,0.003493204,0.011058699,0.026040249,0.03085975,0.014122258,-0.041694283,-0.0044949315,-0.03420351,-0.04034931,-0.057012077,-0.016784191,0.029178528,-0.032690413,-0.024695272,0.02699294,0.0038761487,-0.00393686,-0.07550551,-0.018558813,-0.013711292,0.10782232,-0.03347498,0.017764904,-0.050548717,0.006047726,0.0269369,-0.0035982803,-0.030131219,0.015401854,-0.0158315,0.0053238673,-0.024359027,0.047223635,-0.052865066,-0.035529807,0.028730202,-0.034465034,-0.027515987,0.010759816,0.011264182,-0.014047537,-0.072666116,0.0140288565,0.006752905,0.0068509765,-0.005239806,-0.01664409,-0.024863394,0.019100541,-0.032914575,-0.027422585,0.011198801,0.048718054,0.058394417,0.00714519,0.04677531,-0.014692005,0.03646382,0.039191134,-0.013645912,0.010460932,-0.033082698,-0.0023665524,-0.02463923,0.05062344,-0.02219212,-0.052752987,-0.031158634,0.015299113,4.0863015e-05,-0.0004229322,-0.01351515,0.010843877,-0.010143368,0.042441495,0.027459946,-0.029907057,0.028860964,-0.015504595,-0.002211273,0.07445942,8.090512e-06,0.045094088,-0.032895893,0.0004929831,0.0011838599,0.060710765,0.03199924,-0.041619565,-0.0175781,-0.06280295,-0.0068463064,0.023144811,0.004464576,-0.025554562,0.02052958,0.03754727,0.027646748,0.03403539,-0.022061357,-0.024807353,0.0127212405,-0.016233124,0.016924294,0.026507255,-0.002538177,-0.024377707,0.03388595,0.026339132,0.010759816,-0.0008505345,0.035081483,0.044571042,0.0074861045,0.0060664066,-0.01827861,-0.040947076,-0.015289772,0.00716387,0.022434963,-0.0027529998,0.06829494,0.008144583,0.012964083,0.043562308,0.014579924,0.05704944,0.050287195,0.019278003,-0.026750097,-0.007621536,-0.026656697,0.0136832725,-0.0094989,-0.049726788,-0.0701256,0.013403069,0.006729555,-0.0058515836,-0.011376264,0.060598683,-0.009807124,-0.016242465,-0.00632793,0.018175868,-0.0011447482,-0.02529304,-0.014626624,0.02146359,-0.04229205,-0.00035667574,-0.024359027,0.03425955,-0.012739921,0.010703775,-0.009139305,-0.0158315,0.01983841,-0.025461162,-0.056152787,0.020043893,0.0034254882,-0.040237226,0.008205294,0.0044879266,-0.009358798,-0.0022404608,0.0007133515,-0.003873814,0.01896978,-0.02529304]
CONSTEXT000038657449_4
CONSTEXT000038657449
4
RIP
Conformité
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris
2019-1
2019-05-09
des autres activités qui doivent être érigées en service public national est laissée à l'appréciation du législateur ou de l'autorité réglementaire selon les cas. 9. L'aménagement, l'exploitation et le développement des aérodromes de Paris-Charles-de-Gaulle, Paris-Orly et Paris-Le Bourget ne constituent pas un service public national dont la nécessité découlerait de principes ou de règles de valeur constitutionnelle. La proposition de loi, qui a pour objet d'ériger ces activités en service public national, ne comporte pas par elle-même d'erreur manifeste d'appréciation au regard du neuvième alinéa du Préambule de la Constitution de 1946.10. Il résulte de tout ce qui précède que la proposition de loi est conforme aux conditions fixées par l'article 11 de la Constitution et par l'article 45-2 de l'ordonnance du 7 novembre 1958 tels qu'ils sont rédigés.11. Dès lors, l'ouverture de la période de recueil des soutiens des électeurs à la proposition de loi doit intervenir dans le mois suivant la publication au Journal officiel de la République française de la présente décision. Le nombre de soutiens d'électeurs inscrits sur les listes électorales à recueillir est de 4 717 396.
Proposition de loi visant à affirmer le caractère de service public national de l’exploitation des aérodromes de Paris des autres activités qui doivent être érigées en service public national est laissée à l'appréciation du législateur ou de l'autorité réglementaire selon les cas. 9. L'aménagement, l'exploitation et le développement des aérodromes de Paris-Charles-de-Gaulle, Paris-Orly et Paris-Le Bourget ne constituent pas un service public national dont la nécessité découlerait de principes ou de règles de valeur constitutionnelle. La proposition de loi, qui a pour objet d'ériger ces activités en service public national, ne comporte pas par elle-même d'erreur manifeste d'appréciation au regard du neuvième alinéa du Préambule de la Constitution de 1946.10. Il résulte de tout ce qui précède que la proposition de loi est conforme aux conditions fixées par l'article 11 de la Constitution et par l'article 45-2 de l'ordonnance du 7 novembre 1958 tels qu'ils sont rédigés.11. Dès lors, l'ouverture de la période de recueil des soutiens des électeurs à la proposition de loi doit intervenir dans le mois suivant la publication au Journal officiel de la République française de la présente décision. Le nombre de soutiens d'électeurs inscrits sur les listes électorales à recueillir est de 4 717 396.
[-0.025197927,0.018955369,-0.018205881,0.024970235,-0.00041506373,-0.004601278,0.03709484,-0.04273022,-0.0034035225,0.008509993,0.0009024672,-0.007233968,0.023926646,-0.041288167,-0.026602028,0.030605614,0.03242715,0.021251263,0.0073999935,0.005436149,-0.013168193,0.0075802496,-0.022086134,0.032711767,0.014875884,0.012096143,-0.03599433,0.009800248,-0.021042546,0.017143318,-0.039732274,-0.0041933297,0.020473314,-0.05654354,-0.050395854,-0.00047198677,-0.037398428,-0.03517843,-0.040605094,0.021441007,0.014781012,-0.007200763,-0.018718189,-0.05445636,0.024287159,-0.03718971,-0.0047696754,-0.005929482,-0.012067682,-0.011792554,-0.0154546015,0.024287159,0.0035126251,-0.047473803,-0.023964595,0.024590747,-0.01579614,-0.0044494835,-0.0461456,0.017655626,-0.012617937,0.019695368,-0.018367164,-0.050016366,-0.018651778,0.0015096461,0.042882014,-0.012323835,0.0033062792,0.0076846085,-0.015075115,0.050623544,-0.046525087,0.037436377,-0.06902866,-0.008813582,0.020454342,0.017750498,0.0042549963,-0.023755876,-0.006512943,-0.026943566,0.024457928,0.0052179443,-0.004288201,0.06910455,0.02512203,0.021725621,-0.014961269,-0.008391403,-0.03726561,0.035406124,-0.0070679425,-0.010350504,-0.049143545,-0.0169346,-0.046487138,-0.004394932,-0.0025828823,0.01254204,0.018794086,0.013509732,-0.011583836,-0.010454862,0.018167933,0.039618425,0.03872663,-0.034153815,0.02787331,0.005839354,-0.044513807,0.0048574316,0.05563277,0.042160988,0.0048337136,-0.030757409,0.018167933,-0.0094349915,-0.05529123,-0.030226128,-0.016612036,0.007973967,0.05107893,0.028044078,0.0036264712,0.022237929,0.0027062155,0.03958048,-0.01813947,0.03722766,0.017352035,0.043640986,-0.0018606714,0.0028366642,0.005322303,0.021422032,0.030795358,0.039049197,0.029998435,-0.04990252,0.035804585,-0.019002805,-0.05802354,-0.04667688,0.031611253,-0.0095535815,0.07183686,0.015008705,-0.044855345,0.018737163,0.031535357,0.025330747,0.05578457,-0.06986353,-0.013993577,0.00979076,-0.05419072,-0.014705115,0.011991784,0.020473314,-0.045500472,0.0763907,-0.0678902,0.0028248052,0.018964855,0.02290203,0.001362595,0.015767679,-0.026791772,0.033622533,0.040453296,-0.044096373,0.026981514,0.007390506,-0.012826655,0.021877417,-0.0024085555,0.0060765333,-0.039770223,-0.022617416,0.00833448,0.04383073,0.034096893,-0.014657679,0.0093923,0.03481792,0.03396407,-0.01572973,0.02106152,0.004148266,-0.0009249992,-0.018281778,-0.0015997742,0.021554854,-0.020036906,-0.068041995,-0.0044376245,-0.02984664,-0.0075043524,-0.001854742,-0.007390506,-0.0047791624,0.005346021,0.028290745,-0.06546148,-0.0244769,0.010976657,-0.0009558325,-0.0013590372,-0.04698047,-0.02612767,-0.038309198,0.042882014,0.015207935,0.011251785,0.04242663,-0.009733838,-0.009335376,0.048536368,0.0013471784,-0.009064992,-0.0044589704,0.0055215335,0.0022271133,-0.017323574,-0.019277932,-0.008230121,0.0014550949,-0.0015950307,-0.029543051,-0.0115364,-0.01046435,-0.035463046,-0.005858328,0.07570763,-0.037872788,0.015615883,0.039884068,0.008263326,-0.023812799,-0.049636878,-0.02180152,-0.016887164,-0.008410377,0.0092073,-0.011574348,-0.0025046133,0.0027299335,-0.033186127,0.012485118,0.01737101,0.0082917875,-0.006807045,0.032313306,0.028973822,0.017010499,0.02237075,-0.0029718564,0.057947643,-0.029315358,0.018481009,-0.00601961,0.005402944,0.023034852,0.005312816,-0.053166106,-0.026336387,-0.04360304,-0.004017817,0.02062511,-0.0022413442,-0.03829022,-0.009828709,0.0096958885,0.020587161,0.022351775,-0.0051420466,-0.029372282,0.055898413,-0.049523033,-0.047625598,0.012826655,0.0382333,-0.026146643,-0.008405633,-0.01868024,-0.018974341,-0.018092036,-0.03553894,-0.06094559,-0.039125092,-0.008472044,0.077718906,-0.00247378,0.015881525,-0.016175628,-0.002654036,-0.16424191,0.01975229,0.025862029,-0.016185114,0.009193069,0.036905095,-0.014610244,-0.019733315,0.03303433,0.021118443,-0.0080973,-0.060983535,-0.04386868,-0.013433835,-0.037170738,-0.00086214667,-0.00028105744,0.011887426,0.03115587,-0.028499462,-0.026962541,-0.04064304,0.043754835,0.044362012,0.017266652,-0.019885112,0.028063051,0.03487484,-0.012722297,0.0149802435,0.005663841,0.02075793,0.007746275,-0.013291527,0.04360304,-0.028082026,0.058668666,-0.0038992274,0.006750122,0.030112281,0.0107679395,0.060490202,-0.0108153755,-0.012817169,-0.007907557,-0.059162,-0.039125092,-0.028025104,-0.0059816614,-0.019942034,-0.06231174,-0.049485084,-0.030093307,-0.006214097,-0.03829022,0.013889219,-0.061818406,0.00551679,-0.023167672,0.00066647376,-0.023224594,-0.08310762,-0.0034746765,-0.050661493,-0.025311772,0.012029733,0.021991262,0.008870505,0.03071946,0.009107685,0.011213836,0.0027323053,0.00583461,0.018509472,-0.024457928,-0.013130245,-0.021592801,0.035007663,-0.013196655,-0.08986249,-0.0082917875,-0.01284563,0.006218841,0.0052179443,-0.0360133,-0.046525087,0.023243569,-0.013500244,0.060224563,0.24196081,0.01800665,0.049447138,0.019543573,0.009520376,-0.026222542,-0.01831024,0.035368174,-0.007769993,-0.014866397,-0.018765625,0.030871255,0.016023831,-0.018670753,-0.033356894,0.0154071655,-0.041933298,-0.005355508,0.039125092,0.022010237,-0.01737101,0.027569719,0.034893814,0.00821589,-0.030434845,-0.056960974,-0.01760819,-0.042882014,-0.0013649667,-0.010416914,-0.024666645,-0.002025511,0.037512276,-0.02411639,-0.022560492,0.01039794,0.012096143,0.022807159,-0.05965533,0.04379278,0.039959963,-0.02049229,-0.03347074,-0.010853324,-0.018699214,-0.010758452,-0.0106730675,-0.020226648,-0.001910479,-0.0016448383,-0.020833828,0.015615883,-0.009989991,0.008443582,-0.0837907,0.015008705,-0.058744565,0.0011455759,-0.009989991,0.047397908,0.039276887,-0.002827177,-0.018158445,0.020833828,0.0023445173,-0.008941659,0.027171258,-0.06595481,0.048802007,0.018955369,-0.005782431,-0.011612297,0.06906661,0.03544407,-0.0061998665,-0.023812799,-0.052748673,0.086371206,-0.0048360857,0.0010222427,0.0033726892,-0.031819973,0.0016389089,0.007822173,0.0080071725,0.002656408,0.029220488,-0.02136511,0.041212272,-0.01314922,-0.01697255,0.010303068,0.037758943,0.027000489,0.024628697,0.0005959129,-0.0045064064,0.043223552,-0.026032798,0.02665895,0.027190233,0.021384085,0.0029267923,0.038935352,0.037720993,0.022845108,0.02089075,-0.020226648,-0.05016816,0.02254152,0.03766407,0.02626049,0.011081016,-0.0095535815,0.046259448,0.032142535,0.034533303,0.026564078,0.017997164,0.014951781,-0.037739966,0.02176357,0.049485084,0.0043901885,-0.0036074969,0.0003969788,-0.007907557,0.0026089721,0.030339973,-0.012096143,0.016991524,-0.011175888,-0.017333062,0.04929534,-0.0025378184,-0.025577413,0.075745575,0.016678447,-0.0338692,0.0006581725,0.018955369,0.020606136,0.036127146,-0.02219998,0.0012404476,0.060717896,-0.014752551,-0.013775373,-0.017503832,0.007385763,0.020112803,0.0030714716,0.0035173688,-0.028689206,0.0115364,-0.06466456,-0.037341505,-0.028841,0.03168715,-0.017295113,-0.026336387,0.029163564,-0.017057933,0.08105839,0.00030299652,0.026013823,-0.014059988,0.019277932,-0.017143318,-0.025672285,0.0066315327,-0.07122968,-0.0040557655,-0.00519897,0.017627165,0.019828187,-0.0053982004,0.009145633,0.006807045,0.022560492,0.0097433245,0.04462765,0.00054788415,-0.034685098,-0.019524598,-0.0031094204,0.019562546,-0.023888698,0.028651256,-0.028195873,-0.01197281,0.051192775,0.01958152,-0.013566655,0.022826133,0.027038438,0.022389725,0.0012345181,0.02106152,0.0095535815,-0.0309851,-0.040263556,-0.0020954788,-0.034533303,-0.03635484,0.0245528,-0.0007957365,0.020036906,-0.012485118,-0.00526538,0.012096143,0.04553842,-0.0020812482,0.033451766,0.03923894,-0.009216786,-0.01234281,0.010369478,-0.0019519854,-0.04273022,0.030833306,0.045348678,0.03954253,-0.0721025,-0.009629479,0.018737163,-0.015483064,0.027759463,0.0063706352,-0.0007981083,-0.0007465218,-0.05741636,0.041288167,-0.028537411,0.0039087147,-0.002677754,-0.022693314,0.02035947,-0.023850748,-0.050889187,-0.0033821766,0.00959153,0.06090764,-0.0052179443,-0.0023895812,0.030112281,-0.036070224,0.07278558,0.021384085,0.018281778,-0.045348678,-0.027512796,-0.013367424,-0.034134842,-0.0044708294,0.07923685,-0.09009018,-0.00016306076,-0.03176305,-0.015701268,0.011432041,0.025994848,-0.012997424,-0.00638961,0.014316142,-0.063222505,0.047170214,0.017551268,-0.059275847,-0.029068692,-0.047739446,-0.03350869,-0.022313826,-0.028195873,0.00034776411,0.018642291,0.0056164055,-0.045690216,-0.02722818,-0.0036620481,-9.9615296e-05,0.001362595,-0.008509993,-0.047397908,-0.0016163768,0.021004597,0.034950737,0.030396895,-0.009055505,-0.040225606,0.035823558,-0.018670753,-0.048612267,0.01898383,-0.004316663,-0.015615883,-0.03669638,-0.0033299972,-0.006569866,0.021706648,-0.020738956,0.023034852,-0.005554739,-0.035330225,-0.035102535,-0.005597431,0.0057397387,-0.04269227,0.010027939,0.036108173,0.02089075,-0.03400202,0.020036906,-0.02709536,-0.00030225536,0.0023753506,0.05047175,0.023490235,0.00047999158,-0.058706615,0.019031266,0.02927741,-0.022010237,0.008951146,-0.02106152,0.04580406,-0.06474046,0.022408698,-0.008068839,-0.021687673,-0.05885841,-0.023186646,-0.046259448,0.005483585,0.030491767,0.012048707,-0.03276869,-0.045766115,-0.005028201,0.03451433,0.045766115,-0.062843025,0.028575359,-0.036943045,0.0017195498,-0.050016366,-0.003856535,0.0020314406,-0.049485084,0.04064304,-0.03806253,-0.023414338,-0.017968703,-0.057492256,0.025767157,0.010018453,0.036203045,-0.0046463422,0.031383563,-0.0034770481,-0.037018944,0.018556906,-0.0008917941,0.010265119,-0.018775111,0.005929482,0.019410752,-0.002485639,0.038536888,-0.04348919,-0.00928794,-0.020112803,0.0150276795,0.043185603,0.0021144534,0.036373813,-0.006399097,0.0070252502,-0.009420761,-0.043147653,-0.033280995,-0.01254204,0.017152805,0.012304861,-0.030169204,-0.0057682,0.0057302513,-0.010824862,0.024268184,0.049674828,-0.094871715,-0.02612767,0.020966649,-0.021023571,-0.1504286,-0.02176357,-0.019562546,0.0014124026,-0.04212304,-0.017389985,0.027474849,-0.020682033,0.033053305,-0.013689988,0.03273074,0.023850748,0.019363316,0.0021464725,0.0042407657,0.04698047,0.016355883,0.002184421,0.00485506,0.041022528,-0.039276887,0.0031141639,0.007566019,-0.013832295,-0.008751916,-0.038650736,0.0018345817,-0.039618425,-0.050889187,-0.0021144534,0.04390663,0.013927167,-0.0009475312,0.040567145,0.033793304,0.014486911,0.026507156,0.016782805,-0.03430561,0.0040035862,-0.0367533,0.010170247,-0.056050207,0.00084791594,0.010540247,0.03643074,0.007362045,-0.021725621,-0.031364586,0.042160988,0.005744482,-0.015141525,-0.0187846,0.014799987,-0.017854856,0.03324305,0.0155020375,0.031933818,-0.050433803,0.057833795,-0.010929221,0.022807159,-0.017095882,-0.07255788,-0.00048829283,0.016507678,-0.010843837,0.017997164,0.028347667,0.0017895177,-0.023585107,-0.012693835,-0.012817169,0.018765625,0.011849477,0.0028698693,0.020112803,-0.0013993578,-0.018765625,-0.0048265983,-0.044020474,-0.03984612,-0.03923894,-0.03958048,0.010341017,-0.026886644,-0.036297917,0.043185603,-0.0054219184,0.020644084,-0.056088157,-0.03071946,-0.031098947,0.07381019,-0.022237929,0.0031212794,-0.03980817,-0.004703265,0.030358948,0.0008657044,-0.0461456,0.03923894,-0.03089023,0.014771526,-0.022162031,0.052407134,-0.057264566,-0.04064304,0.021725621,-0.035273302,0.010065889,0.009401787,0.035368174,-0.03565279,-0.05741636,-0.0029765998,0.013082809,0.002964741,-0.029182538,-0.017845368,-0.019211521,0.013168193,0.00776525,-0.02176357,0.0039917273,0.03470407,0.057150718,0.029163564,0.04580406,-0.025368696,0.018623317,0.044931244,-0.015767679,0.011830502,-0.021915365,0.013841783,-0.012485118,0.049219444,0.023850748,-0.052293286,-0.037246633,0.00039964708,-0.009999478,-0.0035956379,-0.01566332,0.03128869,-0.0076087113,0.045120984,0.027323052,-0.02390767,0.05024406,-0.00039193875,0.008396147,0.047170214,0.015558961,0.02971382,-0.008528966,-0.033110227,-0.0069303787,0.04181945,0.038347147,-0.045993805,-0.019847162,-0.058327127,0.01549255,0.033926126,0.02813895,-0.015568448,0.05016816,0.028385617,0.0154546015,0.048650213,-0.03166818,0.009064992,0.02569126,-0.029960487,0.008766146,0.017655626,0.0144205,-0.008989095,0.0149802435,0.04553842,0.033755355,-0.003341856,0.044589706,0.026032798,0.020226648,0.024723569,0.00086451846,-0.0054930723,0.0028508948,0.013727937,0.02106152,-0.01794024,0.079995826,0.04899175,0.0078031984,0.051762007,0.001407659,0.07145737,0.026108695,0.033110227,-0.020871777,0.0041150604,-0.027778437,-0.0031402537,-0.01234281,-0.027019463,-0.05969328,0.011488964,-0.0025354465,-0.002141729,-0.019211521,0.028480487,0.0037901248,-0.0014444218,0.030207153,0.019809213,-0.019562546,-0.031933818,-0.007836403,0.019258957,-0.022750236,0.0058678156,-0.026507156,0.013130245,-0.024609722,-0.0069635836,-0.03916304,-0.0026706387,-0.0024548054,-0.029922538,-0.03792971,0.027512796,-0.0022532032,-0.00928794,0.0075612753,-0.011213836,-0.01703896,-0.040491246,-0.008045121,-0.0043095476,0.009178838,-0.0025473055]
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

🇫🇷 French Constitutional Council Decisions Dataset (Conseil constitutionnel)

This dataset is a processed and embedded version of all decisions issued by the Conseil constitutionnel (French Constitutional Council) since its creation in 1958. It includes full legal texts of decisions, covering constitutional case law, electoral disputes, and other related matters. The original data is downloaded from the dedicated DILA open data repository and is also published on data.gouv.fr.

The dataset provides semantic-ready, structured and chunked content of constitutional decisions suitable for semantic search, AI legal assistants, or RAG pipelines for example. Each chunk of text has been vectorized using the BAAI/bge-m3 embedding model.


🗂️ Dataset Contents

The dataset is provided in Parquet format and includes the following columns:

Column Name Type Description
chunk_id str Unique generated identifier for each text chunk.
cid str Unique identifier of the decision (e.g., CONSTEXT...).
chunk_number int Index of the chunk within the same decision.
nature str Nature of the decision (e.g., Non lieu à statuer, Conformité, etc.).
solution str Legal outcome or conclusion of the decision.
title str Title summarizing the subject matter of the decision.
number str Official number of the decision (e.g., 2019-790).
decision_date str Date of the decision (format: YYYY-MM-DD).
text str Raw full-text content of the chunk.
chunk_text str Formatted full chunk including title and text.
embeddings_bge-m3 str Embedding vector of chunk_text using BAAI/bge-m3, stored as JSON array string.

🛠️ Data Processing Methodology

📥 1. Field Extraction

The following fields were extracted and/or transformed from the original source:

  • Basic fields:

    • cid, title, nature, solution, number, and decision_date are extracted directly from the metadata of each decision record.
  • Generated fields:

    • chunk_id: a generated unique identifier combining the cid and chunk_number.
    • chunk_number: index of the chunk from the original decision.
  • Textual fields:

    • text: chunk of the main text content.
    • chunk_text: generated by concatenating title and text.

✂️ 2. Generation of chunk_text

The Langchain's RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter function was used to make these chunks, which correspond to the text value. The parameters used are :

  • chunk_size = 1500 (in order to maximize the compability of most LLMs context windows)
  • chunk_overlap = 200
  • length_function = len

The value of chunk_text includes the title and the textual content chunk text. This strategy is designed to improve document search.

🧠 3. Embeddings Generation

Each chunk_text was embedded using the BAAI/bge-m3 model. The resulting embedding is stored as a JSON stringified array of 1024 floating point numbers in the embeddings_bge-m3 column.

📌 Embedding Use Notice

⚠️ The embeddings_bge-m3 column is stored as a stringified list of floats (e.g., "[-0.03062629,-0.017049594,...]"). To use it as a vector, you need to parse it into a list of floats or NumPy array. For example, if you want to load the dataset into a dataframe :

import pandas as pd
import json

df = pd.read_parquet("constit-latest.parquet")
df["embeddings_bge-m3"] = df["embeddings_bge-m3"].apply(json.loads)

📚 Source & License

🔗 Source :

📄 Licence :

Open License (Etalab) — This dataset is publicly available and can be reused under the conditions of the Etalab open license.

Downloads last month
151

Collection including AgentPublic/constit