paper_id
uint32
0
3.7k
title
stringlengths
14
154
paper_url
stringlengths
42
42
authors
listlengths
1
21
type
stringclasses
3 values
abstract
stringlengths
413
2.52k
keywords
stringlengths
4
397
TL;DR
stringlengths
5
250
submission_number
int64
2
14.3k
arxiv_id
stringlengths
10
10
embedding
listlengths
768
768
3,700
Both Ears Wide Open: Towards Language-Driven Spatial Audio Generation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=qPx3i9sMxv
[ "Peiwen Sun", "Sitong Cheng", "Xiangtai Li", "Zhen Ye", "Huadai Liu", "Honggang Zhang", "Wei Xue", "Yike Guo" ]
Spotlight
Recently, diffusion models have achieved great success in mono-channel audio generation. However, when it comes to stereo audio generation, the soundscapes often have a complex scene of multiple objects and directions. Controlling stereo audio with spatial contexts remains challenging due to high data costs and unstable generative models. To the best of our knowledge, this work represents the first attempt to address these issues. We first construct a large-scale, simulation-based, and GPT-assisted dataset, BEWO-1M, with abundant soundscapes and descriptions even including moving and multiple sources. Beyond text modality, we have also acquired a set of images and rationally paired stereo audios through retrieval to advance multimodal generation. Existing audio generation models tend to generate rather random and indistinct spatial audio. To provide accurate guidance for Latent Diffusion Models, we introduce the SpatialSonic model utilizing spatial-aware encoders and azimuth state matrices to reveal reasonable spatial guidance. By leveraging spatial guidance, our model not only achieves the objective of generating immersive and controllable spatial audio from text but also extends to other modalities as the pioneer attempt. Finally, under fair settings, we conduct subjective and objective evaluations on simulated and real-world data to compare our approach with prevailing methods. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, highlighting its capability to generate spatial audio that adheres to physical rules.
audio generation, multimodal learning, stereo audio
The multi-modal guided spatial audio generation dataset and method for immersive soundscapes
102
2410.10676
[ 0.008806755766272545, 0.015274105593562126, -0.005436927545815706, 0.029819291085004807, 0.040517501533031464, 0.027334505692124367, 0.033196981996297836, 0.00865834392607212, -0.0006070232484489679, -0.06541913747787476, -0.003570870729163289, 0.005422374699264765, -0.03688234090805054, 0.009557677432894707, -0.011263944208621979, 0.052674662321805954, 0.008085261099040508, -0.036282628774642944, 0.0037673909682780504, 0.04274542257189751, 0.021198324859142303, -0.018643422052264214, 0.019785208627581596, 0.036728303879499435, 0.0326419435441494, -0.0017294979188591242, 0.0020489534363150597, 0.01686575822532177, -0.04427069053053856, 0.013855433091521263, 0.029743511229753494, 0.007656761445105076, 0.006355669349431992, -0.04795679822564125, -0.005052654538303614, 0.04607817530632019, -0.042962294071912766, 0.004661800339818001, 0.002871130360290408, -0.008082998916506767, -0.049427617341279984, 0.004823370836675167, 0.01639571785926819, -0.003347448306158185, -0.05133426934480667, 0.011798686347901821, -0.10393856465816498, 0.043877944350242615, -0.007744526490569115, -0.024455342441797256, -0.09196082502603531, 0.0017944688443094492, -0.013690303079783916, 0.002533684018999338, -0.0020843425299972296, 0.017217984423041344, 0.0420365110039711, -0.04938998073339462, 0.005429001059383154, -0.05706268176436424, -0.027258044108748436, 0.004631306976079941, -0.011489879339933395, -0.013706855475902557, 0.01848340407013893, -0.022727586328983307, 0.0028393357060849667, 0.0366942435503006, -0.030076827853918076, -0.05178440734744072, -0.03680014982819557, 0.009272625669836998, 0.00923567172139883, -0.03022298775613308, -0.030805906280875206, -0.06171456724405289, 0.05445007607340813, 0.004769796039909124, 0.05231883004307747, 0.0029953690245747566, -0.00018522805476095527, -0.024503538385033607, 0.028015894815325737, 0.02672591060400009, -0.015927724540233612, -0.03373507410287857, -0.006350371055305004, 0.025100363418459892, -0.06294624507427216, 0.021211616694927216, -0.035825956612825394, -0.062249764800071716, 0.025282390415668488, 0.033078890293836594, 0.01454143226146698, 0.032495781779289246, 0.008723102509975433, 0.008488573133945465, 0.01473249215632677, 0.016466237604618073, -0.004696802701801062, -0.012008783407509327, 0.0003240536607336253, 0.02053900808095932, -0.08059919625520706, -0.031595222651958466, -0.023935044184327126, -0.020021647214889526, 0.03321303427219391, 0.011286808177828789, 0.011349255219101906, -0.04398117586970329, 0.03521203622221947, -0.015202510170638561, -0.04928591474890709, 0.024447370320558548, 0.025286545976996422, 0.03781452029943466, 0.044399820268154144, -0.00039208316593430936, 0.07116914540529251, 0.051496293395757675, -0.03279413655400276, 0.038669560104608536, -0.003978098277002573, -0.009688896127045155, 0.008133246563374996, 0.008264567703008652, -0.021722985431551933, -0.039057012647390366, 0.005458807572722435, 0.021666688844561577, 0.026693077757954597, -0.008819976821541786, 0.0240098237991333, -0.004144851118326187, 0.04473867639899254, 0.02648763917386532, 0.026909301057457924, -0.009320658631622791, 0.004422919824719429, 0.00736572127789259, 0.037717726081609726, -0.025090251117944717, 0.07788710296154022, 0.0036460375413298607, -0.03567693755030632, -0.011461460031569004, -0.05956298112869263, 0.0221627876162529, 0.006703043356537819, 0.01750793866813183, 0.020526986569166183, -0.06302345544099808, 0.01920333132147789, 0.04933255538344383, 0.03476361930370331, 0.021916551515460014, 0.019791465252637863, -0.009568569250404835, 0.03619421273469925, 0.013404465280473232, -0.02818908914923668, -0.016374455764889717, -0.0004944367683492601, -0.02060851827263832, 0.0026969625614583492, 0.04128067567944527, -0.0412822961807251, -0.032575082033872604, -0.043423835188150406, 0.005048149265348911, 0.0248277448117733, 0.00972420908510685, -0.03558966889977455, -0.030069435015320778, 0.03283560648560524, 0.0323682501912117, 0.016579940915107727, 0.042201682925224304, -0.07995287328958511, 0.007966241799294949, 0.002629244700074196, -0.01494173426181078, 0.05838441476225853, 0.0005501526175066829, 0.04841544106602669, -0.0053618298843503, 0.009943144395947456, 0.038013167679309845, -0.08695625513792038, -0.06013503298163414, 0.024705706164240837, 0.008411628194153309, 0.04912225157022476, -0.0020851311273872852, -0.02063341811299324, 0.019427338615059853, 0.06909578293561935, 0.025131583213806152, 0.04661400243639946, -0.007603383157402277, 0.050719693303108215, -0.014661341905593872, -0.03142193332314491, -0.046899255365133286, 0.03994973003864288, -0.06455470621585846, -0.025094036012887955, 0.009663546457886696, -0.007583641447126865, -0.029981452971696854, 0.025578195229172707, -0.0013707734178751707, 0.034923505038022995, 0.004586103837937117, 0.007188462186604738, 0.03458362817764282, -0.016160711646080017, -0.05205564200878143, 0.04780302941799164, 0.04147738590836525, -0.013678963296115398, 0.021328134462237358, -0.040149442851543427, 0.0904262587428093, 0.06600817292928696, -0.0344557985663414, -0.02212538942694664, 0.009650453925132751, -0.0025849533267319202, 0.008941007778048515, -0.008322871290147305, 0.000502633978612721, 0.012773951515555382, -0.010762043297290802, -0.001920146867632866, -0.0346156470477581, 0.03860655426979065, -0.04273023456335068, -0.039072535932064056, 0.05720490962266922, -0.03020230121910572, 0.05451487749814987, -0.016687598079442978, 0.013973201625049114, 0.06620248407125473, -0.01846727915108204, -0.006189083214849234, -0.030524320900440216, -0.0040253568440675735, 0.00222751684486866, 0.0187070332467556, 0.002994304057210684, 0.015175803564488888, -0.046647828072309494, 0.029559696093201637, -0.021327506750822067, 0.05485314503312111, 0.024620257318019867, 0.003701787209138274, 0.03589219972491264, 0.028600184246897697, -0.014140577986836433, -0.029133452102541924, -0.12536728382110596, -0.02453572116792202, 0.023581309244036674, 0.03939244523644447, 0.006463717203587294, 0.02582549676299095, 0.025476258248090744, 0.020171629264950752, -0.01843709871172905, -0.01613079011440277, 0.015258652158081532, 0.016927050426602364, -0.016200106590986252, -0.009651178494095802, -0.046514078974723816, 0.02442796342074871, 0.07302150875329971, -0.022797493264079094, -0.006029410753399134, -0.04719014838337898, -0.032795365899801254, -0.014594108797609806, -0.009702510200440884, -0.005637154448777437, 0.017947643995285034, -0.019859999418258667, 0.00012844782031606883, -0.00781640037894249, 0.03216247633099556, 0.04284040257334709, 0.04594695195555687, 0.012297851033508778, -0.024457518011331558, -0.05012734234333038, -0.013376404531300068, -0.02426769956946373, -0.00620243139564991, 0.01524422038346529, -0.0067567541263997555, -0.02729543298482895, -0.016285017132759094, 0.03136632964015007, -0.020945968106389046, -0.2626623213291168, -0.00703326566144824, 0.003907904494553804, -0.041523199528455734, 0.033232204616069794, -0.02202828973531723, 0.023019252344965935, -0.06775745004415512, -0.020779704675078392, 0.008508263155817986, -0.03401769697666168, 0.03794506564736366, -0.009919424541294575, 0.040281470865011215, 0.045925237238407135, 0.0023587041068822145, -0.04411763697862625, -0.03282015025615692, 0.019413987174630165, 0.006019971799105406, -0.02509002760052681, -0.04774253070354462, -0.003982629626989365, 0.005123916082084179, 0.0032867840491235256, 0.01412736251950264, -0.05524785444140434, 0.009994818828999996, -0.004315488040447235, -0.014430796727538109, 0.02700348012149334, -0.03884361311793327, -0.003090803511440754, 0.06235850229859352, 0.007863694801926613, 0.006014965940266848, 0.05632711201906204, 0.02605145238339901, 0.037651725113391876, -0.010217947885394096, 0.028290558606386185, 0.002410908229649067, 0.0020221618469804525, 0.01729777827858925, 0.052258141338825226, -0.020620975643396378, -0.025846188887953758, 0.0273224376142025, -0.023734990507364273, 0.057982612401247025, -0.0031741505954414606, -0.059696272015571594, -0.036318425089120865, -0.010132959112524986, -0.020738720893859863, -0.028806036338210106, 0.047765251249074936, -0.009227244183421135, 0.021193914115428925, 0.019913166761398315, 0.01952205039560795, -0.02606941945850849, -0.04918624460697174, -0.010962475091218948, 0.0473482720553875, -0.036210864782333374, -0.10284727811813354, -0.045397721230983734, 0.04013243317604065, 0.025752851739525795, 0.006894927471876144, -0.008585839532315731, -0.012795668095350266, -0.12875746190547943, 0.011723523959517479, 0.017234638333320618, -0.030377263203263283, -0.04487786069512367, -0.0004706860927399248, 0.06532052159309387, -0.053771279752254486, -0.014598245732486248, 0.020875101909041405, 0.04095573350787163, -0.031779829412698746, 0.016897590830922127, 0.01142934337258339, -0.018491216003894806, -0.0348740853369236, -0.029928555712103844, 0.03477093577384949, -0.029867971315979958, -0.008232383988797665, -0.018549486994743347, 0.04579279199242592, 0.025152256712317467, 0.00487326318398118, 0.03849423676729202, 0.06711909919977188, 0.0006557921878993511, 0.027411775663495064, -0.0899379774928093, -0.04146893694996834, -0.050418347120285034, 0.02548910118639469, -0.005138934124261141, -0.07884250581264496, -0.030659159645438194, 0.03296922147274017, -0.013418585993349552, -0.012334064580500126, 0.025320807471871376, 0.022617841139435768, -0.020942427217960358, 0.018394527956843376, -0.04330731928348541, -0.012384757399559021, 0.05244883522391319, 0.054019782692193985, -0.0174544770270586, 0.013772184029221535, 0.01761098951101303, -0.0323573537170887, 0.036191701889038086, -0.0002231542021036148, 0.042982980608940125, -0.027286088094115257, -0.028608746826648712, -0.05406658723950386, -0.03630387410521507, 0.021881019696593285, 0.008007417432963848, 0.01933148503303528, 0.01666400395333767, 0.05312200263142586, -0.024572109803557396, -0.012205400504171848, -0.020168926566839218, 0.02120107226073742, 0.006140607409179211, 0.02244722843170166, -0.03980199992656708, 0.038121335208415985, 0.023627186194062233, 0.01691270060837269, 0.02819407545030117, -0.01622689701616764, -0.005530259571969509, -0.011029554530978203, -0.06413744390010834, 0.04588963836431503, -0.042658109217882156, -0.03438586741685867, -0.035656318068504333, 0.012397988699376583, -0.02760201133787632, -0.00042626276263035834, -0.006785812322050333, 0.012337272055447102, -0.06824885308742523, 0.0669977217912674, 0.029843611642718315, -0.035027701407670975, 0.018327869474887848, 0.01666674017906189, 0.04546641930937767, -0.016277093440294266, 0.03427530452609062, -0.0018385445000603795, 0.0015193525468930602, 0.05542318895459175, -0.05236326530575752, -0.008573181927204132, -0.04251065105199814, -0.017889903858304024, 0.031849220395088196, 0.02572975866496563, -0.035297099500894547, -0.013335967436432838, 0.042428866028785706, 0.05827096849679947, -0.0074116503819823265, 0.013089156709611416, -0.010033616796135902, 0.06289097666740417, 0.0025162799283862114, -0.017602303996682167, -0.019939184188842773, -0.003574938513338566, 0.004863980691879988, -0.07056228071451187, 0.037633806467056274, -0.08299768716096878, -0.03734321519732475, -0.03227173909544945, -0.04083382710814476, 0.0022199349477887154, 0.01793617010116577, -0.08066464215517044, -0.020826274529099464, 0.02516121417284012, -0.010040813125669956, -0.00971011258661747, -0.040062885731458664, 0.04169236868619919, -0.06701068580150604, 0.025107398629188538, 0.03795725852251053, -0.08868936449289322, 0.017467467114329338, -0.03225405886769295, -0.025628065690398216, -0.05917394906282425, -0.015428709797561169, -0.012452020309865475, -0.02125738188624382, -0.027561673894524574, -0.026366787031292915, 0.007803182117640972, 0.0043403152376413345, 0.01900102011859417, 0.0044881487265229225, -0.028605593368411064, -0.008413393050432205, -0.01844763569533825, 0.0504385307431221, -0.07768953591585159, 0.0127534419298172, 0.017305469140410423, -0.041465725749731064, 0.017742063850164413, -0.03590197116136551, 0.021233081817626953, 0.06121240556240082, -0.0013522063381969929, -0.012100547552108765, -0.04547414556145668, 0.025223100557923317, 0.0044806660152971745, 0.03074699267745018, 0.03315870463848114, -0.004663805942982435, -0.04714168608188629, 0.03064921870827675, 0.0066750808618962765, 0.037224072962999344, -0.029023775830864906, 0.008689741604030132, -0.014750685542821884, 0.018350714817643166, 0.007007525768131018, 0.0031624699477106333, -0.06077214702963829, 0.006921819411218166, 0.04098605737090111, -0.04109184071421623, -0.0055786240845918655, -0.04211121425032616, -0.06834730505943298, 0.025721732527017593, -0.0121304327622056, 0.036211758852005005, -0.009546363726258278, 0.03748330473899841, 0.05504293367266655, -0.007443651091307402, 0.015986431390047073, -0.017329882830381393, 0.02891533449292183, -0.04083762690424919, 0.03409143164753914, -0.06330849975347519, 0.01312590204179287, 0.03713721036911011, 0.009632835164666176, -0.01097505260258913, -0.010394606739282608, -0.039825133979320526, 0.07105392217636108, -0.04385574534535408, -0.04065747931599617, 0.006948665250092745, -0.04046308994293213, -0.05138896033167839, 0.0008660212042741477, -0.0248117633163929, 0.010909025557339191, -0.027312858030200005, -0.018972380086779594, -0.0013508135452866554, 0.02985282428562641, 0.0256838146597147, 0.006714674644172192, 0.04687294736504555, -0.008411058224737644, 0.015185692347586155, 0.02710971236228943, 0.028288042172789574, -0.007291378919035196, 0.028676414862275124, -0.02085011452436447, 0.06390120089054108, 0.03727653995156288, 0.007310185115784407, 0.03188671916723251, -0.045696768909692764, 0.010711709968745708, -0.06973499059677124, 0.04236212000250816, 0.028920354321599007, 0.008142941631376743, -0.04168270528316498, 0.0643308013677597, 0.06162472069263458, -0.06063517555594444, 0.002337839687243104, 0.06302300840616226, -0.047524187713861465, 0.03398791328072548, -0.01938123069703579, -0.03185422345995903, -0.02067827247083187, 0.04589197784662247, 0.029878556728363037, 0.07398607581853867, 0.04607405886054039, 0.010065089911222458, -0.01433499250560999, 0.016106627881526947, 0.038909051567316055, 0.04533674940466881, 0.0510982871055603, 0.004463429097086191, 0.08399910479784012, -0.057548582553863525, -0.030982298776507378, 0.007539553567767143, 0.05303484946489334, -0.026843052357435226, -0.05017085000872612, -0.00873142946511507, 0.07915887981653214, -0.008192098699510098, 0.07399724423885345, -0.040775422006845474, -0.013402181677520275, 0.01250259205698967, 0.029803697019815445, -0.010051747784018517, 0.010826298967003822, 0.0712006464600563, 0.01625777967274189, -0.024954454973340034, -0.014508862979710102, 0.00047245141468010843, -0.03080775775015354, 0.03459733724594116, 0.024260511621832848, 0.004072429146617651, 0.03809873014688492, 0.00271015428006649, 0.04994459077715874, 0.08191642165184021, -0.0640743300318718, -0.018563944846391678, -0.0003408629272598773, 0.026571784168481827, -0.0210459902882576, 0.04299008101224899, 0.003934185951948166, -0.01165333203971386, 0.02338557131588459, -0.0568670853972435, -0.01354486308991909, 0.01124806609004736, 0.022435490041971207, -0.007951514795422554, -0.04578520730137825, 0.020423782989382744, 0.020260902121663094, 0.014382333494722843, -0.04832836985588074, -0.05846412852406502, -0.050158750265836716, -0.042585328221321106, -0.04182024300098419, -0.032854799181222916, 0.037791915237903595, -0.013303267769515514, -0.033327095210552216, 0.015635685995221138, -0.03673465549945831, 0.03327931836247444, 0.00841677188873291, -0.03984710946679115, -0.040718141943216324, 0.06342177838087082, 0.008469532243907452, -0.019963961094617844, 0.03450992330908775, 0.04426494613289833, 0.008030747063457966, -0.013256673701107502, 0.021155111491680145, 0.01037935633212328, 0.06030312553048134, -0.04506715387105942, -0.034174464643001556, -0.09003446251153946, 0.018729114904999733, 0.006148240994662046, 0.030387116596102715, -0.08756610751152039, 0.012883538380265236, 0.004274602979421616, 0.04447904974222183, 0.04036484658718109, 0.010802106000483036, 0.01589234732091427, -0.04251076281070709, 0.000997259747236967, 0.011655621230602264, -0.018743345513939857, 0.05502161756157875, -0.03115888126194477, 0.08012096583843231, 0.04622683301568031, -0.02781582809984684, -0.014646677300333977, 0.09540852159261703, -0.006434747949242592, 0.003032226348295808, -0.037427984178066254, -0.03470159322023392, -0.03745809197425842, -0.09108536690473557, -0.0371900238096714, 0.023524411022663116, -0.03921513259410858, -0.03401102125644684, 0.024443380534648895, -0.006687772460281849, -0.01034060213714838, -0.007863292470574379, -0.016483942046761513, -0.007318270392715931, -0.02359692193567753, -0.03281862288713455, -0.06722604483366013, -0.0015546039212495089, -0.025467846542596817, -0.023534027859568596, 0.024675218388438225, -0.018130267038941383, 0.0020713340491056442, 0.009048913605511189, 0.01611904427409172, 0.01864510588347912, 0.03685998171567917, -0.03221423923969269 ]
3,701
Moner: Motion Correction in Undersampled Radial MRI with Unsupervised Neural Representation
https://openreview.net/forum?id=OdnqG1fYpo
[ "Qing Wu", "Chenhe Du", "Xuanyu Tian", "Jingyi Yu", "Yuyao Zhang", "Hongjiang Wei" ]
Spotlight
Motion correction (MoCo) in radial MRI is a particularly challenging problem due to the unpredictability of subject movement. Current state-of-the-art (SOTA) MoCo algorithms often rely on extensive high-quality MR images to pre-train neural networks, which constrains the solution space and leads to outstanding image reconstruction results. However, the need for large-scale datasets significantly increases costs and limits model generalization. In this work, we propose Moner, an unsupervised MoCo method that jointly reconstructs artifact-free MR images and estimates accurate motion from undersampled, rigid motion-corrupted k-space data, without requiring any training data. Our core idea is to leverage the continuous prior of implicit neural representation (INR) to constrain this ill-posed inverse problem, facilitating optimal solutions. Specifically, we integrate a quasi-static motion model into the INR, granting its ability to correct subject's motion. To stabilize model optimization, we reformulate radial MRI reconstruction as a back-projection problem using the Fourier-slice theorem. Additionally, we propose a novel coarse-to-fine hash encoding strategy, significantly enhancing MoCo accuracy. Experiments on multiple MRI datasets show our Moner achieves performance comparable to SOTA MoCo techniques on in-domain data, while demonstrating significant improvements on out-of-domain data. The code is available at: https://github.com/iwuqing/Moner
MRI Reconstruction, Motion Correction, Neural Representation, NeRF, Unsupervised Learning
We propose Moner, an unsupervised method that can jointly recover high-quality MR images and estimates accurate motion from undersampled and rigid motion-corrupted radial MRI measurement data without the need for any extra data.
101
2409.16921
[ -0.04257665574550629, -0.0050169541500508785, 0.007050462998449802, 0.05039936676621437, 0.046955838799476624, 0.028040215373039246, 0.033105239272117615, 0.0047537763603031635, -0.04205385595560074, -0.04970049485564232, 0.023476392030715942, 0.0023253541439771652, -0.011918137781322002, -0.005241864360868931, 0.02122645266354084, 0.04554913192987442, 0.033899400383234024, -0.047308530658483505, 0.010855317115783691, 0.01660384051501751, -0.0038982199039310217, -0.0546584278345108, 0.029116535559296608, 0.002194114727899432, 0.011655541136860847, -0.016841946169734, -0.006904848851263523, 0.021863482892513275, -0.06450314819812775, -0.017221899703145027, 0.0033268302213400602, -0.006192069035023451, -0.008031637407839298, -0.028446603566408157, 0.03331410139799118, 0.018815070390701294, -0.031057070940732956, 0.0042541492730379105, -0.006287327501922846, -0.007922683842480183, -0.05591530352830887, 0.020065637305378914, -0.007902199402451515, 0.008830979466438293, -0.05465131998062134, 0.033094242215156555, -0.1067131981253624, 0.02330842986702919, 0.005537684075534344, -0.026674604043364525, -0.03627792373299599, 0.030323568731546402, 0.041460271924734116, -0.02142021432518959, -0.010534197092056274, 0.023813940584659576, 0.04505269601941109, -0.04233357310295105, -0.02738751843571663, -0.05659451335668564, 0.010564453899860382, 0.01196803618222475, 0.01553233340382576, -0.014238111674785614, 0.0025012693367898464, -0.013520387001335621, -0.00895838811993599, 0.04386311396956444, -0.015190056525170803, -0.017853155732154846, -0.009769589640200138, -0.030755743384361267, -0.002778439549729228, 0.018586136400699615, 0.020581282675266266, -0.06969080120325089, 0.005769255571067333, 0.02296038530766964, 0.040334731340408325, 0.006393855903297663, 0.0295540913939476, -0.008457686752080917, -0.008701138198375702, 0.0264991857111454, 0.02446664683520794, -0.013558846898376942, -0.04021008685231209, -0.033988695591688156, -0.06645186245441437, 0.04734506458044052, -0.026389097794890404, -0.03575515002012253, 0.018918463960289955, 0.013146384619176388, -0.007069760467857122, -0.0061358255334198475, 0.025781508535146713, 0.018767792731523514, 0.02164936438202858, -0.003790547838434577, -0.002706997562199831, -0.068364217877388, -0.0011439666850492358, 0.0033793810289353132, -0.06138862669467926, -0.023266419768333435, 0.002956463722512126, -0.032831937074661255, -0.03081994690001011, 0.018329394981265068, -0.07575748860836029, 0.015589886344969273, -0.005646235309541225, -0.027796156704425812, -0.09699883311986923, 0.02907056361436844, 0.014258770272135735, 0.0009077671566046774, -0.02041238360106945, -0.003666243515908718, 0.05544302240014076, 0.08176278322935104, -0.03334105759859085, 0.05672178789973259, -0.015821820124983788, 0.02157650887966156, 0.013896535150706768, 0.020872551947832108, -0.040486834943294525, -0.015587406232953072, 0.009554609656333923, 0.030066845938563347, 0.001779785961844027, -0.002822493901476264, 0.005734281148761511, -0.03769002854824066, 0.01020700205117464, -0.043964188545942307, 0.06003875657916069, -0.009131872095167637, 0.041613005101680756, -0.03372221812605858, 0.03325500339269638, -0.006788036320358515, 0.08830104768276215, -0.05723635479807854, 0.013842571526765823, -0.005207407288253307, -0.017907727509737015, 0.023854095488786697, -0.018523383885622025, 0.02330092340707779, 0.04929470643401146, -0.06505445390939713, 0.016010355204343796, 0.03165680170059204, -0.0073033603839576244, 0.030089668929576874, 0.0036927289329469204, -0.016717178747057915, 0.010029801167547703, -0.03761805221438408, -0.04498062655329704, -0.001059581758454442, -0.02668304555118084, -0.06348802894353867, 0.05896160006523132, 0.025825267657637596, -0.032631970942020416, -0.0135434465482831, -0.03737727552652359, -0.05092398822307587, 0.032421741634607315, -0.005785153713077307, -0.025113612413406372, 0.003234015079215169, 0.057629846036434174, 0.02168567292392254, 0.039432331919670105, 0.007016840856522322, -0.08563093841075897, 0.017277667298913002, 0.009656097739934921, -0.0018733566394075751, 0.007925177924335003, -0.01138769369572401, 0.09042104333639145, 0.0011463097762316465, 0.004269707016646862, 0.04315376654267311, -0.07734512537717819, -0.010903849266469479, 0.0392690971493721, -0.03180829435586929, 0.05060743913054466, 0.03379590064287186, -0.009123981930315495, 0.016834408044815063, 0.017704308032989502, 0.024771153926849365, 0.020303824916481972, -0.03160062059760094, 0.07131870090961456, -0.014591566286981106, -0.05759025737643242, -0.04678107425570488, 0.05273769050836563, -0.04580073431134224, 0.008157933130860329, 0.013328994624316692, -0.026585418730974197, 0.003856588853523135, -0.010785698890686035, -0.004109306260943413, 0.0004581743851304054, 0.0075280130840837955, 0.012362156063318253, 0.012915188446640968, -0.025449411943554878, -0.051023148000240326, 0.009710390120744705, -0.00272376392967999, -0.03484873101115227, 0.024993691593408585, -0.024309704080224037, 0.1268557757139206, 0.04249502718448639, -0.058978475630283356, -0.026854844763875008, 0.023401575163006783, 0.045516543090343475, -0.013660982251167297, 0.015711119398474693, -0.013030429370701313, -0.0032044637482613325, 0.026353320106863976, 0.007033466827124357, -0.025715036317706108, 0.03880947828292847, -0.038536082953214645, -0.03645935282111168, 0.06896694749593735, 0.004753076005727053, 0.028549030423164368, 0.023518985137343407, -0.012491852976381779, 0.028177235275506973, -0.030672689899802208, -0.03530168533325195, -0.01871540956199169, -0.004120055120438337, -0.00339612178504467, 0.0027759713120758533, -0.01441064104437828, 0.049407802522182465, -0.0710185244679451, 0.012981416657567024, -0.00914168544113636, 0.08725620806217194, 0.03853447362780571, 0.030971139669418335, 0.06764974445104599, 0.008351543918251991, -0.04982361942529678, -0.0606929175555706, -0.13240757584571838, -0.04053496941924095, -0.006725916173309088, 0.05462652072310448, -0.02028374932706356, 0.03142063692212105, -0.004956160672008991, -0.004563774447888136, -0.0034348159097135067, -0.021854177117347717, -0.018502838909626007, 0.004974996671080589, 0.027078058570623398, -0.012613538652658463, -0.004988751374185085, 0.025689268484711647, 0.06955614686012268, -0.00921853631734848, -0.0023797177709639072, -0.036341745406389236, 0.0063099912367761135, -0.012364249676465988, -0.007799141108989716, -0.002277098363265395, 0.02836768701672554, -0.024045592173933983, -0.0038639316335320473, -0.0179729163646698, 0.02400721050798893, 0.009583763778209686, 0.02367820031940937, 0.04300487041473389, -0.005940439645200968, -0.01670941710472107, 0.009064712561666965, -0.018427452072501183, 0.03967089205980301, 0.007402012590318918, -0.02012808993458748, -0.014582403004169464, -0.014875851571559906, 0.00536206504330039, -0.01440377626568079, -0.28731656074523926, 0.0009685894474387169, -0.014837906695902348, -0.0203610397875309, 0.04971690848469734, -0.004724367056041956, 0.013255038298666477, -0.02565666474401951, -0.013400129042565823, -0.015051010996103287, 0.026883870363235474, 0.0321115180850029, 0.013661494478583336, 0.044439349323511124, 0.06709011644124985, 0.0297754667699337, 0.021084919571876526, -0.002548924647271633, -0.026863526552915573, 0.020732197910547256, 0.004855291917920113, -0.06925787776708603, -0.007518516853451729, -0.004822457209229469, -0.02096816524863243, 0.06841984391212463, -0.08660117536783218, 0.02315291203558445, -0.049949292093515396, -0.028195876628160477, -0.014340794645249844, -0.011777672916650772, -0.016731437295675278, 0.0319061316549778, 0.0214836522936821, -0.00831692386418581, -0.0048072487115859985, -0.006207948550581932, 0.03272423520684242, -0.032318346202373505, -0.03574774041771889, -0.0242177564650774, -0.019437944516539574, 0.0030370706226676702, 0.07994366437196732, -0.024544989690184593, -0.04533829167485237, 0.019298985600471497, -0.021180447190999985, 0.02680272050201893, 0.00837783608585596, -0.041990477591753006, -0.02316279150545597, 0.001577013055793941, -0.02470267564058304, -0.05584065243601799, 0.005654876586049795, 0.04307645559310913, -0.011242632754147053, 0.02715058997273445, -0.00010188412852585316, -0.043544888496398926, -0.0270844679325819, -0.041050806641578674, -0.014556930400431156, -0.030013686046004295, -0.04916790872812271, -0.04541919380426407, 0.061833206564188004, 0.05506420135498047, -0.00021829575416631997, 0.04003610461950302, -0.04226039722561836, -0.0962614119052887, 0.008327528834342957, 0.021898547187447548, 0.017973408102989197, -0.03230356425046921, -0.03719617798924446, 0.046535417437553406, -0.016104284673929214, -0.0412619411945343, 0.03371347486972809, 0.02447410114109516, -0.02527725137770176, -0.011186376214027405, 0.007850910536944866, -0.05822381004691124, 0.008217332884669304, -0.028108935803174973, 0.05950912460684776, -0.009619956836104393, 0.05422239005565643, -0.013144266791641712, 0.03373868390917778, 0.05052556097507477, 0.028115540742874146, 0.00946288276463747, 0.0283732321113348, -0.009274586103856564, 0.011063809506595135, -0.07456992566585541, 0.02713785506784916, -0.0429583378136158, -0.027439402416348457, 0.010639824904501438, -0.010697412304580212, -0.005450800526887178, 0.0142039330676198, 0.007913971319794655, -0.00520732905715704, 0.006403926759958267, 0.0415196567773819, -0.02626761421561241, -0.009292803704738617, 0.0071407705545425415, -0.016463853418827057, 0.016670597717165947, 0.06287966668605804, 0.018050674349069595, -0.007687536533921957, 0.011034524999558926, -0.030444398522377014, 0.024543672800064087, 0.0008650723029859364, 0.015135833993554115, 0.022524751722812653, 0.04208885133266449, -0.01014330517500639, 0.013457839377224445, 0.06614565849304199, 0.059758350253105164, 0.021440798416733742, 0.052109286189079285, 0.04106937348842621, 0.005037510767579079, -0.01526800636202097, -0.002581921638920903, 0.045649249106645584, -0.025271479040384293, 0.05949106067419052, -0.026131154969334602, 0.04423948749899864, 0.041549570858478546, 0.013283506967127323, 0.04630124941468239, 0.0013126126723363996, 0.018933093175292015, -0.02188475988805294, 0.00993361696600914, 0.01747019588947296, -0.07036127895116806, -0.0521504171192646, -0.039059098809957504, 0.007334860973060131, -0.01704057678580284, 0.017409328371286392, -0.02952541597187519, 0.039552684873342514, -0.060849420726299286, 0.02518606372177601, 0.03025026060640812, -0.03280184417963028, -0.012077122926712036, -0.005155688617378473, 0.02411201409995556, 0.0004313055833335966, -0.020955843850970268, 0.015789801254868507, -0.014526167884469032, 0.0019288955954834819, -0.023728350177407265, -0.033335130661726, -0.04612446203827858, -0.017526937648653984, 0.011314921081066132, -0.020072996616363525, 0.015167067758738995, -0.002348037902265787, 0.03122144564986229, 0.0329803042113781, 0.016759784892201424, -0.01629825495183468, 0.003170525189489126, 0.07051167637109756, -0.01648416370153427, -0.0055079166777431965, -0.023029034957289696, 0.01758015900850296, 0.05610395595431328, 0.05533254146575928, 0.044925373047590256, -0.09054616093635559, 0.0023444844409823418, -0.00543711893260479, -0.050678133964538574, 0.011697947047650814, 0.03919307515025139, -0.024434374645352364, -0.009716960601508617, -0.00993089284747839, -0.0002822561946231872, -0.01507840771228075, 0.02559330128133297, 0.052857980132102966, -0.07681600749492645, -0.005051847547292709, 0.04023773968219757, -0.040439046919345856, 0.04243847727775574, -0.03730352967977524, -0.03801393881440163, -0.025236422196030617, -0.018022360280156136, -0.0020516456570476294, 0.0012859392445534468, -0.0129106929525733, -0.027490248903632164, -0.027547769248485565, -0.009149954654276371, 0.0008569495403207839, 0.002269226126372814, -0.019605519250035286, 0.0038189461920410395, 0.01708076149225235, 0.042089927941560745, -0.004589711781591177, -0.021736137568950653, -0.025543950498104095, -0.022982720285654068, 0.004897683393210173, -0.02543722279369831, 0.006860352586954832, 0.04420718550682068, -0.009026207961142063, 0.006102787796407938, -0.024420717731118202, 0.039959054440259933, -0.03896920755505562, -0.021753717213869095, 0.03649105876684189, 0.009400012902915478, -0.04983918368816376, 0.06687041372060776, -0.0003984696522820741, 0.02833975851535797, -0.017791779711842537, -0.013353189453482628, 0.02423057332634926, 0.04802250862121582, 0.04761800915002823, -0.0009832913056015968, -0.03216854855418205, -0.04235687851905823, 0.07059064507484436, -0.013443926349282265, -0.019507165998220444, -0.04780435562133789, -0.025129258632659912, 0.017607033252716064, 0.0021732987370342016, 0.015489659272134304, -0.0083723533898592, 0.015147026628255844, 0.029621340334415436, 0.05376376211643219, -0.008068829774856567, -0.07070093601942062, 0.05824359878897667, -0.047348711639642715, 0.008538879454135895, -0.043592918664216995, 0.01633966527879238, 0.05295611172914505, -0.015174677595496178, 0.03773630037903786, 0.0008857977227307856, -0.022246286273002625, 0.017168790102005005, -0.03322507441043854, -0.04396957531571388, 0.010505988262593746, -0.010547788813710213, -0.023469824343919754, -0.01403979491442442, -0.03981706500053406, -0.012655951082706451, -0.008108089677989483, -0.042055897414684296, 0.002470102161169052, 0.0023490553721785545, 0.038366708904504776, -0.021601568907499313, 0.017497198656201363, -0.037430014461278915, 0.0267176553606987, 0.036441802978515625, 0.05834367498755455, -0.016545256599783897, 0.039904579520225525, -0.035397712141275406, 0.06468724459409714, 0.053895965218544006, -0.008863086812198162, 0.015620985999703407, 0.019326265901327133, 0.009049362502992153, -0.027547428384423256, 0.01811499148607254, -0.028098471462726593, -0.06377635896205902, -0.061329737305641174, 0.04851003363728523, 0.015224752016365528, -0.028128914535045624, -0.045660894364118576, 0.03193357214331627, 0.002973893191665411, -0.0017694499110803008, -0.009501015767455101, -0.007024822290986776, 0.027728069573640823, 0.04655607417225838, -0.021694762632250786, 0.03767473250627518, 0.07066626101732254, 0.010886697098612785, -0.022039979696273804, 0.012518191710114479, 0.08924277871847153, 0.06573367118835449, 0.015005798079073429, -0.020735258236527443, 0.09959781169891357, -0.039301879703998566, -0.03419801592826843, 0.03301239013671875, 0.015565469861030579, -0.020951641723513603, -0.008252480998635292, -0.022551188245415688, 0.10650802403688431, -0.01852916181087494, 0.03109869919717312, -0.048951808363199234, -0.026903802528977394, 0.05967786908149719, 0.018783891573548317, -0.009566349908709526, -0.0088172173127532, 0.05244491621851921, -0.02068413235247135, -0.026255205273628235, -0.01586255244910717, -0.03781043738126755, -0.007049739360809326, 0.018299173563718796, -0.011616846546530724, -0.020320042967796326, 0.025003604590892792, -0.05728776380419731, 0.0078008100390434265, 0.07972700148820877, -0.03686391934752464, -0.021686922758817673, -0.01869683526456356, 0.014921962283551693, -0.005343677941709757, 0.011269031092524529, 0.042704928666353226, -0.037896186113357544, 0.01921943575143814, -0.03352830186486244, 0.008927716873586178, 0.06013225391507149, -0.017479609698057175, -0.004226641729474068, -0.043260954320430756, -0.03592373803257942, 0.014473971910774708, -0.0024005661252886057, -0.022522468119859695, -0.03657662123441696, -0.0287675391882658, -0.05411379039287567, -0.04266603663563728, -0.016613490879535675, 0.043378133326768875, 0.005728601943701506, -0.03841643035411835, -0.004088761750608683, -0.020791204646229744, 0.03070186637341976, 0.03192571923136711, -0.06248469650745392, 0.001245540683157742, 0.044040463864803314, -0.04373692721128464, 0.002647504210472107, 0.049843981862068176, 0.025358645245432854, -0.010819969698786736, 0.006240556016564369, 0.06123069301247597, -0.01850935071706772, 0.014165366068482399, 0.012663142755627632, -0.03278174623847008, -0.09654770791530609, 0.005146641284227371, 0.041955672204494476, -0.014813225716352463, -0.09155461937189102, 0.020737413316965103, -0.017523568123579025, -0.006097877398133278, 0.05568806454539299, -0.027270039543509483, -0.0009549181559123099, -0.008223949931561947, -0.021371465176343918, -0.0009112354600802064, -0.00022694066865369678, 0.06287037581205368, -0.02861541509628296, 0.0784316137433052, 0.07111532986164093, -0.03052738681435585, 0.003963041119277477, 0.04221908375620842, -0.00920349732041359, -0.019304882735013962, -0.05286230519413948, -0.03360065817832947, -0.04372992366552353, -0.1095924898982048, -0.026061436161398888, 0.025180991739034653, -0.024680033326148987, -0.028544601052999496, -0.009273710660636425, 0.02963738515973091, 0.007660397328436375, -0.012963858433067799, 0.062244899570941925, 0.0023648308124393225, -0.0281531885266304, -0.0547553114593029, -0.0503823459148407, 0.003601056756451726, 0.0004085739201400429, 0.03183811902999878, -0.009987461380660534, -0.04927107319235802, 0.00481689115986228, -0.005709649063646793, 0.04810827597975731, 0.025675853714346886, 0.041855260729789734, -0.008006203919649124 ]
3,702
UniMatch: Universal Matching from Atom to Task for Few-Shot Drug Discovery
https://openreview.net/forum?id=v9EjwMM55Y
[ "Ruifeng Li", "Mingqian Li", "Wei Liu", "Yuhua Zhou", "Xiangxin Zhou", "Yuan Yao", "Qiang Zhang", "Hongyang Chen" ]
Spotlight
Drug discovery is crucial for identifying candidate drugs for various diseases. However, its low success rate often results in a scarcity of annotations, posing a few-shot learning problem. Existing methods primarily focus on single-scale features, overlooking the hierarchical molecular structures that determine different molecular properties. To address these issues, we introduce Universal Matching Networks (UniMatch), a dual matching framework that integrates explicit hierarchical molecular matching with implicit task-level matching via meta- learning, bridging multi-level molecular representations and task-level generalization. Specifically, our approach explicitly captures structural features across multiple levels—atoms, substructures, and molecules—via hierarchical pooling and matching, facilitating precise molecular representation and comparison. Additionally, we employ a meta-learning strategy for implicit task-level matching, allowing the model to capture shared patterns across tasks and quickly adapt to new ones. This unified matching framework ensures effective molecular alignment while leveraging shared meta-knowledge for fast adaptation. Our experimental results demonstrate that UniMatch outperforms state-of-the-art methods on the MoleculeNet and FS-Mol benchmarks, achieving improvements of 2.87% in AUROC and 6.52% in ∆AUPRC. UniMatch also shows excellent generalization ability on the Meta-MolNet benchmark.
Few-shot molecular representation learning, maching learning
We introduce HierMatch, which performs matching across multiple levels, from atoms to tasks, to enhance molecular property predic- tions in few-shot learning scenarios.
45
2502.12453
[ -0.0018100764136761427, -0.017122440040111542, -0.009517395868897438, 0.016110850498080254, 0.039458051323890686, -0.012298358604311943, 0.026981035247445107, 0.0033403157722204924, 0.01876337081193924, -0.0424664206802845, 0.00634417962282896, 0.022558070719242096, -0.09606510400772095, -0.01932465098798275, 0.043174732476472855, 0.0651046484708786, 0.043899793177843094, 0.026085898280143738, -0.0003779919061344117, -0.002983712824061513, -0.03346101939678192, 0.0010366524802520871, 0.014253220520913601, 0.017643820494413376, 0.025435760617256165, 0.01807446777820587, 0.007681814953684807, -0.02786398120224476, -0.039122357964515686, 0.017001023516058922, 0.04529273509979248, 0.017028579488396645, 0.0100429467856884, -0.061647363007068634, 0.04077057167887688, 0.0012267990969121456, -0.04780994728207588, 0.014377055689692497, 0.015552251599729061, -0.01629234105348587, -0.05042797699570656, 0.010069247335195541, -0.028020624071359634, 0.028954003006219864, -0.013816568069159985, 0.03813991695642471, -0.1073588877916336, 0.0411200188100338, 0.011625389568507671, -0.040337271988391876, -0.08294770866632462, 0.029223691672086716, 0.03296090289950371, -0.03357729688286781, -0.01273742038756609, 0.04419838637113571, 0.020141959190368652, -0.043462906032800674, -0.004087101202458143, -0.03686509653925896, -0.025846775621175766, 0.04369261488318443, 0.013271177187561989, 0.03249001502990723, 0.001055545057170093, -0.0231828261166811, 0.030338149517774582, 0.02544875256717205, -0.059948086738586426, -0.01690804958343506, -0.004150092601776123, -0.041451867669820786, -0.01430541928857565, 0.008180612698197365, 0.036992572247982025, -0.02729858085513115, 0.015254159457981586, -0.03617984056472778, 0.09245069324970245, 0.05056668072938919, 0.00421431427821517, 0.021653417497873306, 0.0157226100564003, 0.0416991226375103, -0.0059585850685834885, -0.013451280072331429, -0.07703468948602676, 0.01567770540714264, -0.10476040095090866, 0.050490692257881165, -0.02252030372619629, -0.046962808817625046, 0.0625169575214386, 0.01990063115954399, 0.031333453953266144, -0.02854699268937111, 0.019082138314843178, -0.009488383308053017, 0.0036386733409017324, 0.010453793220221996, -0.0206549521535635, -0.03699430823326111, 0.006665170658379793, -0.014426207169890404, -0.07221213728189468, 0.02572653815150261, -0.0312136672437191, -0.04682917147874832, -0.01167967077344656, -0.014007900841534138, -0.012611611746251583, 0.000705848156940192, 0.005267823580652475, 0.013406839221715927, -0.08984668552875519, 0.02636583149433136, 0.010499808937311172, 0.022017769515514374, -0.007938050664961338, -0.0030602416954934597, 0.03333648294210434, 0.07702428102493286, -0.008397756144404411, 0.07629495114088058, 0.008903078734874725, -0.004302028566598892, -0.003202790627256036, 0.00895522441715002, -0.0481497198343277, -0.01783215068280697, 0.0069054896011948586, 0.06972777098417282, -0.005747361574321985, 0.00814894400537014, 0.0039554801769554615, -0.008882823400199413, 0.01046724058687687, -0.0038735971320420504, 0.06746053695678711, -0.00931329932063818, 0.0069388351403176785, -0.0037992126308381557, 0.027602439746260643, -0.01301946397870779, 0.0663541853427887, -0.022558575496077538, -0.018167542293667793, -0.03257286176085472, -0.030701037496328354, 0.012987479567527771, 0.018248295411467552, 0.01853000558912754, -0.0009659308707341552, -0.028241408988833427, 0.0294768288731575, 0.09648103266954422, 0.004065330605953932, 0.015248795039951801, -0.012628238648176193, 0.010439903475344181, -0.004601482767611742, -0.03261914849281311, -0.029815761372447014, -0.014830186031758785, -0.012879556976258755, -0.039888277649879456, 0.0371127650141716, 0.0715864822268486, -0.03019551932811737, -0.009628010913729668, -0.03851627930998802, -0.08334056288003922, 0.06151296943426132, -0.014492413960397243, -0.006175985559821129, -0.018528589978814125, 0.03977657109498978, 0.007287629414349794, 0.018474483862519264, 0.02016443945467472, -0.07844055444002151, 0.03818952292203903, 0.0027885667514055967, -0.004095320124179125, -0.0015009946655482054, -0.0072872755117714405, 0.09494580328464508, 0.002053854987025261, -0.007530301343649626, 0.016872089356184006, -0.04831104725599289, -0.02589660882949829, 0.0416608564555645, -0.016930295154452324, 0.0682196095585823, -0.0003389777266420424, -0.02187889814376831, 0.04438140243291855, 0.008570369333028793, 0.025136547163128853, -0.008240562863647938, -0.0034975765738636255, 0.05176777020096779, -0.042839210480451584, -0.05324676260352135, -0.01279702689498663, 0.04774882644414902, -0.056956615298986435, -0.031545158475637436, 0.011658787727355957, 0.03431301936507225, 0.018183086067438126, 0.006542883813381195, -0.02410207875072956, 0.01402328722178936, 0.018674295395612717, 0.02253090962767601, 0.015182871371507645, -0.01570652797818184, -0.004821454640477896, 0.014721032232046127, 0.006611685734242201, -0.042499374598264694, 0.022562580183148384, -0.006315629929304123, 0.11489725112915039, 0.06995879858732224, -0.05567155405879021, -0.008970578201115131, 0.009624657221138477, 0.045370567589998245, -0.01339926291257143, 0.014057794585824013, -0.04572775959968567, -0.007397048640996218, -0.05295463651418686, 0.033580582588911057, -0.007052863482385874, 0.054282333701848984, -0.073530413210392, 0.008575612679123878, 0.06279639154672623, -0.01692640222609043, 0.032613605260849, 0.020100025460124016, -0.01218785997480154, 0.04159499332308769, -0.035461995750665665, -0.03300006315112114, -0.02397139184176922, -0.03604666143655777, -0.0029817181639373302, -0.01644088700413704, -0.00991495605558157, 0.026514781638979912, -0.079632468521595, -0.03265964984893799, -0.004231179598718882, 0.06543504446744919, 0.03919149935245514, -0.002765433629974723, 0.029551275074481964, 0.011934311129152775, -0.04259122163057327, -0.030079137533903122, -0.10090017318725586, -0.03758174553513527, -0.013024807907640934, 0.01765993796288967, 0.004905992653220892, 0.05112474411725998, 0.017795829102396965, -0.0059666987508535385, -0.03897516429424286, -0.019431091845035553, 0.011366921477019787, 0.0176987387239933, 0.011237381026148796, -0.06270412355661392, -0.014017977751791477, 0.027751624584197998, 0.04858388751745224, 0.010196303017437458, -0.036381274461746216, -0.04018457978963852, -0.05211552977561951, -0.043637122958898544, -0.03540857136249542, -0.0005379266222007573, -0.007089577149599791, 0.02720492333173752, 0.02446855790913105, -0.026111489161849022, -0.0025647201109677553, 0.029102256521582603, 0.018802063539624214, 0.034173622727394104, 0.03353413939476013, -0.01112484373152256, 0.009441571310162544, 0.027450939640402794, 0.010861323215067387, -0.03759351000189781, -0.006427919492125511, 0.02629898674786091, -0.006770003121346235, 0.006741274148225784, -0.011430696584284306, -0.25569775700569153, -0.022289225831627846, -0.0018469172064214945, 0.021089114248752594, 0.05580706149339676, -0.03747762367129326, 0.011108947917819023, -0.02947887033224106, -0.024899322539567947, -0.009601269848644733, 0.022865228354930878, 0.0632472038269043, -0.00046122181811369956, 0.03153113275766373, 0.05938639119267464, 0.03217006102204323, -0.007405110169202089, -0.015192295424640179, 0.03365651145577431, 0.024143036454916, -0.00031217356445267797, -0.057290367782115936, -0.009944825433194637, 0.047603461891412735, -0.01994829624891281, 0.025656409561634064, -0.06503575295209885, -0.047349702566862106, -0.0239639263600111, -0.03010726347565651, -0.03769117593765259, -0.030418774113059044, -0.006629743613302708, -0.007858417928218842, 0.03416186943650246, 0.0032041887752711773, 0.035640209913253784, -0.02871270850300789, -0.002555686281993985, 0.0016774206887930632, -0.018853679299354553, -0.008267346769571304, -0.042438287287950516, 0.019543791189789772, 0.06236032769083977, 0.025408925488591194, -0.014851775020360947, 0.003764009801670909, -0.013965056277811527, 0.01777031645178795, -0.011267479509115219, -0.027704160660505295, -0.038026951253414154, 0.008150364272296429, 0.021417617797851562, -0.050718117505311966, -0.0018400988774374127, 0.010768083855509758, -0.025335395708680153, 0.007855868898332119, -0.0001647152821533382, -0.042008206248283386, -0.016968613490462303, -0.014451025985181332, -0.02654413878917694, -0.03923753276467323, -0.050810910761356354, -0.07085637003183365, 0.038420941680669785, 0.044641390442848206, -0.0003545499639585614, 0.01283554919064045, -0.01051242370158434, -0.08308999240398407, 0.036624763160943985, -0.001729288138449192, -0.010138788260519505, -0.03215599060058594, -0.02039472386240959, 0.044498659670352936, -0.05043158307671547, -0.022076020017266273, -0.01612846553325653, 0.043185096234083176, 0.047720085829496384, -0.0519195981323719, 0.0011474152561277151, -0.023621786385774612, -0.025128472596406937, 0.0062710996717214584, 0.04275986924767494, -0.011477413587272167, 0.043154843151569366, -0.010355840437114239, 0.03513389825820923, 0.0002772691077552736, 0.01687026023864746, 0.030301572754979134, 0.022387633100152016, 0.03506786376237869, 0.04082703962922096, -0.055209945887327194, -0.022756427526474, -0.042502596974372864, -0.021820293739438057, 0.009440292604267597, -0.049741536378860474, -0.007797364145517349, 0.0772278681397438, 0.023762919008731842, -0.056141067296266556, -0.022254573181271553, 0.018397001549601555, -0.02329087071120739, -0.006511600222438574, -0.05253227427601814, 0.03315632417798042, 0.03256873041391373, 0.02769548073410988, -0.004495054949074984, -0.025253895670175552, 0.0640958845615387, 0.003779546357691288, 0.019693516194820404, -0.005935464985668659, -0.03507404774427414, -0.009758943691849709, -0.006576212123036385, 0.004792034160345793, 0.013120472431182861, 0.04225169122219086, 0.06791673600673676, -0.04857495054602623, -0.008357041515409946, 0.02178995870053768, -0.003093672450631857, -0.02619987726211548, -0.008801188319921494, 0.03167509660124779, -0.05276704579591751, 0.025502711534500122, -0.020969631150364876, -0.0032409473787993193, 0.011344422586262226, 0.060107436031103134, 0.017901791259646416, 0.04759034514427185, 0.04449557140469551, -0.013253641314804554, 0.03065970167517662, -0.017590325325727463, -0.01179453730583191, -0.019530685618519783, -0.017152873799204826, 0.02821096032857895, -0.009128390811383724, 0.010454080067574978, 0.0009510525851510465, 0.06576383113861084, -0.06935407221317291, 0.029658524319529533, -0.03675678372383118, 0.0008968047332018614, 0.003274623304605484, 0.0319911353290081, 0.049182772636413574, -0.010991200804710388, 0.014372851699590683, -0.008882035501301289, 0.017144497483968735, 0.023807089775800705, -0.02394036389887333, -0.025097288191318512, -0.021092625334858894, -0.047227803617715836, 0.036457158625125885, -0.013361030258238316, 0.007615850307047367, -0.052256111055612564, 0.04220490902662277, -0.0012573553249239922, -0.03366561233997345, -0.023244589567184448, -0.012764306738972664, 0.08820154517889023, -0.01925281621515751, -0.005150529555976391, -0.00537274032831192, -0.007872606627643108, 0.051015548408031464, 0.009773999452590942, 0.047174498438835144, -0.036867041140794754, -0.05359771475195885, -0.018967632204294205, -0.04860639572143555, -0.031192108988761902, 0.016766835004091263, -0.01607227511703968, 0.009083835408091545, -0.04488141089677811, 0.04995165020227432, -0.050616517663002014, -0.01737825758755207, 0.03705909475684166, -0.0912441834807396, 0.002760127652436495, 0.037416115403175354, 0.009936864487826824, 0.029793841764330864, -0.020503168925642967, -0.0255910474807024, -0.0355234295129776, 0.0098845474421978, 0.030841417610645294, 0.026454569771885872, 0.019178926944732666, -0.01462940126657486, -0.00034486103686504066, -0.0343291275203228, 0.03204161673784256, 0.010632422752678394, 0.002847949741408229, -0.02950366772711277, -0.00993648637086153, 0.02816774696111679, -0.0025570974685251713, -0.0030043162405490875, -0.007899302057921886, 0.008279427886009216, 0.03566693142056465, -0.04946143180131912, 0.023229539394378662, 0.027519280090928078, -0.003768069203943014, -0.01989954523742199, -0.03871861472725868, 0.021410373970866203, 0.01627971976995468, -0.0223892442882061, 0.00865117460489273, -0.028603900223970413, -0.043886326253414154, 0.0193435437977314, -0.01421433500945568, 0.018704812973737717, 0.017266899347305298, 0.003665823256596923, -0.01808551885187626, 0.029245397076010704, 0.01548899244517088, 0.004848306067287922, -0.024720897898077965, -0.009550665505230427, 0.034870583564043045, -0.020923631265759468, -0.0386321060359478, -0.04209784418344498, -0.04958343133330345, 0.022262681275606155, -0.006303939502686262, 0.0414123460650444, -0.06381497532129288, 0.04338441789150238, 0.01831270568072796, -0.004590492229908705, -0.0080761993303895, -0.07117917388677597, 0.04304281249642372, -0.06323292851448059, -0.006350474897772074, -0.06221163645386696, -0.029281124472618103, 0.07752919942140579, -0.025177203118801117, 0.02667335234582424, -0.0031916729640215635, -0.0359639972448349, 0.005492481868714094, -0.02935558743774891, -0.05956578254699707, 0.032109152525663376, 0.00496477959677577, 0.0470704585313797, 0.050830818712711334, -0.043449997901916504, -0.030133739113807678, -0.05621647462248802, -0.030909469351172447, -0.014726638793945312, 0.014710916206240654, 0.06073925644159317, -0.03280875086784363, -0.0013397253351286054, -0.02501637674868107, 0.056755974888801575, 0.02107381448149681, 0.0424540638923645, 0.00889511313289404, 0.0459681898355484, -0.014281696639955044, 0.07085773348808289, 0.05752473697066307, -0.002054215408861637, 0.011135023087263107, 0.016319235786795616, 0.011886767111718655, -0.02233014442026615, 0.03615895286202431, -0.01458792481571436, -0.02966400608420372, -0.0698542445898056, 0.0799727663397789, 0.011861150152981281, -0.07409389317035675, -0.030085017904639244, 0.030109547078609467, -0.03493138775229454, 0.023051846772432327, 0.008716434240341187, -0.005997197702527046, 0.0007621187251061201, 0.06044169142842293, 0.011280778795480728, 0.04790271446108818, 0.06402884423732758, 0.042668990790843964, -0.008338107727468014, -0.030779005959630013, 0.09416311979293823, 0.042072705924510956, 0.02583165094256401, -0.01148130837827921, 0.0647212490439415, -0.009549827314913273, -0.06266265362501144, 0.02459530159831047, 0.0036082728765904903, -0.01700698956847191, -0.03394535928964615, 0.03526534512639046, 0.05821280553936958, -0.021313168108463287, 0.052718378603458405, -0.013090310618281364, 0.0032428898848593235, 0.03853635862469673, -0.000884070701431483, 0.018493695184588432, 0.046352941542863846, 0.033952340483665466, 0.03857255354523659, -0.032136522233486176, -0.0019881671760231256, -0.02049858868122101, 0.012609791941940784, 0.02929244376718998, 0.007680399809032679, -0.03959697112441063, 0.04513584449887276, -0.030326824635267258, 0.015800854191184044, 0.07677823305130005, 0.001808944041840732, -0.008256020955741405, 0.01545299869030714, 0.03307819738984108, -0.009062769822776318, 0.034251634031534195, -0.012133731506764889, -0.0021393299102783203, 0.0002521434216760099, -0.043425217270851135, 0.015968959778547287, 0.019889459013938904, 0.00656139524653554, 0.02686561830341816, -0.042001690715551376, -0.018056640401482582, 0.009685694240033627, 0.01812043786048889, -0.021440371870994568, -0.059845976531505585, -0.016782129183411598, -0.01947392150759697, -0.037359148263931274, -0.06119328737258911, 0.0035072367172688246, -0.009055949747562408, -0.027406519278883934, 0.021409019827842712, -0.04031553491950035, 0.025226382538676262, 0.053180061280727386, -0.04432649537920952, -0.020255552604794502, 0.05977708473801613, 0.0027923625893890858, -0.016057094559073448, 0.037403080612421036, 0.02963368408381939, -0.02135663852095604, -0.03912867233157158, 0.06972557306289673, 0.001583909965120256, 0.03297917917370796, -0.04094161093235016, -0.008706469088792801, -0.10184766352176666, 0.03646615520119667, 0.018551303073763847, -0.03822808340191841, -0.09388444572687149, 0.0017284825444221497, -0.02729262225329876, 0.005636411253362894, 0.034818898886442184, 0.03308050334453583, 0.007344903890043497, -0.06011881306767464, 0.015421399846673012, 0.0168648399412632, -0.017652206122875214, 0.04278472810983658, -0.05158624425530434, 0.07013009488582611, 0.001384494360536337, -0.007959326729178429, -0.016223270446062088, -0.0014406751142814755, 0.042739421129226685, 0.01598333567380905, -0.02237342670559883, -0.03801228106021881, -0.05210874229669571, -0.10845278203487396, -0.04020310938358307, 0.03998163342475891, -0.016153652220964432, -0.05013815313577652, -0.00974983349442482, 0.038332175463438034, 0.001027871621772647, -0.0015696248738095164, -0.01549670472741127, -0.004451537970453501, -0.046245332807302475, -0.02825573831796646, -0.07677110284566879, -0.01840859092772007, -0.046296317130327225, 0.0006035190890543163, -0.02836034633219242, -0.009126794524490833, 0.029421595856547356, -0.029554026201367378, 0.029904430732131004, 0.0072956024669110775, 0.013870617374777794, 0.014545081183314323 ]
3,703
OASIS Uncovers: High-Quality T2I Models, Same Old Stereotypes
https://openreview.net/forum?id=L6IgkJvcgV
[ "Sepehr Dehdashtian", "Gautam Sreekumar", "Vishnu Boddeti" ]
Spotlight
Images generated by text-to-image (T2I) models often exhibit visual biases and stereotypes of concepts such as culture and profession. Existing quantitative measures of stereotypes are based on statistical parity that does not align with the sociological definition of stereotypes and, therefore, incorrectly categorizes biases as stereotypes. Instead of oversimplifying stereotypes as biases, we propose a quantitative measure of stereotypes that aligns with its sociological definition. We then propose OASIS to measure the stereotypes in a generated dataset and understand their origins within the T2I model. OASIS includes two scores to measure stereotypes from a generated image dataset: **(M1)** Stereotype Score to measure the distributional violation of stereotypical attributes, and **(M2)** WALS to measure spectral variance in the images along a stereotypical attribute. OASIS also includes two methods to understand the origins of stereotypes in T2I models: **(U1)** StOP to discover attributes that the T2I model internally associates with a given concept, and **(U2)** SPI to quantify the emergence of stereotypical attributes in the latent space of the T2I model during image generation. Despite the considerable progress in image fidelity, using OASIS, we conclude that newer T2I models such as FLUX.1 and SDv3 contain strong stereotypical predispositions about concepts and still generate images with widespread stereotypical attributes. Additionally, the quantity of stereotypes worsens for nationalities with lower Internet footprints.
Stereotype Measurement, Responsible AI, Trustworthy AI, Interpretability, Generative AI, Text-to-Image Models, Multimodal Models
We propose a toolbox to quantify stereotypes in Text-to-Image models
17
2501.00962
[ 0.0012617958709597588, -0.02166053280234337, -0.0591469444334507, 0.03253406286239624, 0.010107713751494884, 0.023382114246487617, 0.046687960624694824, 0.012645212933421135, -0.006831571459770203, -0.013512772507965565, -0.05331652984023094, 0.010848836973309517, -0.07259798794984818, -0.012099333107471466, -0.010019727051258087, 0.05780496820807457, 0.025174938142299652, 0.0211873110383749, -0.010967295616865158, 0.0050709303468465805, -0.009415626525878906, -0.018878350034356117, 0.012894222512841225, 0.0024352087639272213, 0.03545724228024483, -0.015107715502381325, 0.07635415345430374, -0.020305320620536804, -0.02861100248992443, 0.01943264715373516, 0.03792259097099304, -0.002152156550437212, -0.018546242266893387, -0.010519501753151417, -0.003943001385778189, -0.0011454228078946471, -0.07048003375530243, 0.011247361078858376, 0.01996729150414467, 0.0013813916593790054, -0.010751080699265003, 0.01843309961259365, 0.01271501462906599, 0.002704342594370246, -0.0864906832575798, -0.023601632565259933, -0.12274200469255447, 0.028414249420166016, -0.003520319936797023, 0.015249643474817276, -0.09467054158449173, 0.035592902451753616, 0.0005810094298794866, 0.007262767758220434, 0.026934029534459114, 0.02492697723209858, 0.0076756710186600685, -0.09072422236204147, -0.0033128708600997925, -0.07183624804019928, 0.01866474375128746, 0.020264949649572372, 0.019873926416039467, -0.004252682439982891, 0.006176621653139591, -0.02482687309384346, -0.014672697521746159, 0.014668534509837627, -0.04948824644088745, -0.02593444101512432, 0.0006468956707976758, -0.00835314579308033, -0.017468135803937912, 0.005251383408904076, 0.001940826652571559, -0.04899945855140686, -0.003620510222390294, 0.02931116707623005, 0.05795235186815262, -0.032814037054777145, 0.007951801642775536, 0.03991859406232834, 0.02360856719315052, 0.05912792682647705, -0.0029156652744859457, -0.017845017835497856, 0.03365163505077362, -0.012046193704009056, -0.08025430887937546, 0.030112016946077347, -0.001996708568185568, -0.01815626583993435, 0.03603934869170189, 0.040338292717933655, 0.02462177723646164, 0.010572823695838451, 0.04510859027504921, -0.01849830150604248, 0.0005942301941104233, -0.014264220371842384, -0.0037813973613083363, 0.0032857288606464863, 0.01268894411623478, 0.016101334244012833, -0.09770216792821884, -0.01912415400147438, -0.01072667259722948, -0.020794672891497612, -0.017277127131819725, 0.017540330067276955, -0.004783648997545242, -0.0158540066331625, 0.004491468425840139, -0.002180241048336029, -0.05398492142558098, 0.028303006663918495, 0.014717773534357548, 0.0007062001968733966, 0.004872371442615986, 0.03683149814605713, 0.04602060467004776, 0.020359816029667854, -0.02572878636419773, 0.055405594408512115, -0.028767669573426247, 0.01332994643598795, 0.017031561583280563, -0.0009420886053703725, -0.008641902357339859, -0.005740148946642876, 0.013106582686305046, 0.007922755554318428, -0.021663416177034378, 0.010706582106649876, -0.014922735281288624, -0.019593050703406334, 0.052403148263692856, 0.01053592935204506, 0.06533060222864151, 0.00011474085476947948, 0.021026069298386574, -0.025400782003998756, 0.0071907793171703815, -0.0427434928715229, 0.08793677389621735, -0.0482918843626976, -0.00222721416503191, -0.02394690364599228, -0.0031097130849957466, -0.0008316284511238337, 0.010992885567247868, -0.030550016090273857, 0.006944642402231693, -0.05801596865057945, 0.030949613079428673, 0.06506598740816116, 0.026813212782144547, 0.03875408694148064, 0.015818921849131584, 0.0011938016396015882, 0.0035618781112134457, -0.0058766622096300125, -0.04080823436379433, 0.028127942234277725, 0.038051214069128036, -0.008731933310627937, 0.02447645179927349, 0.016521181911230087, -0.05091742053627968, 0.016068050637841225, -0.033528778702020645, -0.07441815733909607, 0.03404930606484413, 0.005194041877985001, -0.032922398298978806, 0.02398485131561756, 0.051159702241420746, 0.0449577197432518, 0.0004725045582745224, 0.03837728500366211, -0.08798682689666748, 0.033136095851659775, 0.025075405836105347, 0.006692942697554827, 0.040153868496418, -0.029336243867874146, 0.05046747252345085, -0.0420062355697155, -0.01936238445341587, 0.024212902411818504, -0.07160163670778275, -0.029601702466607094, 0.03493373841047287, 0.012416533194482327, 0.05929942429065704, -0.006485982798039913, -0.026989392936229706, 0.041362449526786804, 0.01746862195432186, 0.03733878955245018, 0.027746371924877167, -0.06012779101729393, 0.06060641631484032, 0.006154304835945368, -0.030981741845607758, -0.014426765032112598, 0.046859804540872574, -0.03265231102705002, -0.04362662881612778, -0.006399884354323149, -0.012750132940709591, 0.0005548589397221804, -0.02947814390063286, 0.036557599902153015, 0.007537460420280695, 0.03587610274553299, 0.023098375648260117, 0.009052501060068607, 0.0253900159150362, -0.06476658582687378, 0.043929681181907654, 0.003385578515008092, -0.009152625687420368, -0.05120003968477249, -0.029129501432180405, 0.08466976881027222, 0.07278317958116531, -0.03802555426955223, 0.03443688154220581, 0.02508438751101494, 0.012237418442964554, 0.01725699007511139, 0.028178006410598755, -0.025974493473768234, -0.0010068891569972038, -0.020532017573714256, 0.03385110944509506, -0.05441373586654663, 0.07659876346588135, -0.03738413751125336, -0.018097303807735443, 0.06739523261785507, -0.028337586671113968, 0.03957019001245499, -0.004512172192335129, 0.0012377649545669556, 0.04384634271264076, -0.004475489724427462, -0.018613392487168312, -0.031605880707502365, -0.010340671055018902, 0.01836705394089222, -0.017365528270602226, -0.042747437953948975, 0.03198283165693283, -0.05409897863864899, 0.02011558972299099, 0.009623723104596138, 0.05867304652929306, 0.036078136414289474, 0.004854402970522642, 0.0130582544952631, -0.014202802442014217, -0.007943210192024708, -0.004995845258235931, -0.08587471395730972, -0.03395639359951019, -0.019522983580827713, 0.02726593427360058, -0.04009246453642845, 0.062235601246356964, -0.01564665697515011, 0.00911945104598999, -0.024086521938443184, -0.007996495813131332, 0.017616000026464462, 0.0021544890478253365, -0.0019040096085518599, -0.016248103231191635, 0.015017280355095863, 0.004605964291840792, 0.06314975023269653, -0.00931279081851244, -0.003947475925087929, 0.0019818604923784733, -0.055823348462581635, -0.020543433725833893, -0.019602056592702866, -0.009721183218061924, -0.004714928101748228, 0.03647204861044884, 0.03885534033179283, 0.02726316638290882, -0.006754460744559765, 0.02804608643054962, 0.056735605001449585, 0.04507790505886078, 0.009270863607525826, -0.003368949983268976, 0.04596306011080742, -0.02658003754913807, 0.038067527115345, 0.014211778528988361, 0.013647578656673431, 0.05100322142243385, 0.017754001542925835, 0.014694279059767723, -0.015010466799139977, -0.27255988121032715, 0.003111885627731681, 0.0422908291220665, -0.02104349620640278, 0.021981364116072655, -0.07075177133083344, 0.04863385483622551, -0.02268964797258377, -0.026720192283391953, 0.030465878546237946, -0.0033179237507283688, 0.031162044033408165, -0.005569921340793371, 0.07339374721050262, 0.023519640788435936, 0.056257158517837524, 0.031846631318330765, -0.030899329110980034, -0.0015605774242430925, 0.061964768916368484, -0.05032183229923248, -0.05872376635670662, -0.041007041931152344, 0.043007854372262955, -0.008210845291614532, 0.061450544744729996, -0.043349217623472214, -0.009429844096302986, -0.021767769008874893, 0.0046247155405581, 0.017584998160600662, -0.028017425909638405, 0.012382346205413342, 0.05399050563573837, 0.02039748802781105, -0.02040458656847477, 0.030502023175358772, -0.001485586166381836, -0.020912373438477516, 0.024165047332644463, 0.014108117669820786, -0.0289249699562788, 0.015780925750732422, -0.0033945611212402582, 0.07027819007635117, 0.004090464673936367, -0.03824738413095474, -0.04805973544716835, 0.008430375717580318, 0.019142204895615578, -0.008420811966061592, -0.0014515998773276806, -0.03072558529675007, 0.01767456904053688, -0.026973523199558258, -0.01205732673406601, 0.010217462666332722, 0.01033124327659607, -0.03396529331803322, -0.03979320079088211, -0.009203732013702393, -0.019838377833366394, -0.016842234879732132, -0.012152808718383312, -0.030200978741049767, -0.04327176883816719, -0.11300304532051086, -0.06630390882492065, 0.0034131917636841536, 0.033302001655101776, -0.016764597967267036, 0.021416645497083664, -0.010396471247076988, -0.098467618227005, 0.019056525081396103, -0.00921802967786789, -0.016348475590348244, 0.0018485656473785639, 0.006503409240394831, 0.017001984640955925, -0.014071491546928883, -0.04125838354229927, 0.018390558660030365, -0.002433564281091094, -0.013593452982604504, -0.05236097797751427, 0.010609658434987068, -0.018293602392077446, -0.039291370660066605, -0.028309335932135582, 0.03299751877784729, 0.003190645482391119, 0.0032245672773569822, 0.007786648813635111, 0.037970706820487976, 0.04716884344816208, 0.015646591782569885, 0.05710822343826294, 0.040390510112047195, 0.007577680982649326, 0.0321657769382, -0.09220142662525177, -0.014039005152881145, -0.011594820767641068, -0.019650589674711227, 0.016149936243891716, -0.0377054288983345, -0.024994077160954475, 0.04155107960104942, -0.03439716994762421, -0.027877945452928543, -0.034042246639728546, -0.02156151458621025, -0.0035135443322360516, -0.013222442008554935, -0.023037290200591087, 0.02272907830774784, 0.009075596928596497, 0.04709349200129509, -0.003694807644933462, 0.011712942272424698, 0.036518391221761703, -0.02206450328230858, -0.0015097452560439706, -0.01271328516304493, -0.026308102533221245, -0.022003525868058205, -0.03192748501896858, -0.022746384143829346, -0.015806177631020546, 0.04556455835700035, 0.0043604811653494835, -0.014872190542519093, 0.03615212067961693, 0.06991369277238846, -0.019780758768320084, -0.0008371457806788385, -0.013373661786317825, 0.03316259756684303, -0.048459336161613464, 0.04057767242193222, -0.05783071741461754, 0.040975421667099, 0.028274163603782654, 0.0434349961578846, -0.007584193721413612, 0.004501333925873041, -0.015383288264274597, -0.0251985602080822, -0.0031445343047380447, 0.01982579007744789, -0.018084147945046425, -0.03340570256114006, -0.021381214261054993, -0.011390214785933495, 0.0008130582282319665, 0.007393470965325832, 0.023274768143892288, -0.005932628642767668, -0.07231289893388748, 0.057715676724910736, -0.009798699989914894, -0.019670827314257622, -0.01795785501599312, 0.02760852314531803, 0.046970535069704056, 0.03548332303762436, -0.005525002721697092, 0.02170800231397152, 0.029023993760347366, -0.005694224964827299, -0.005443857982754707, 0.01390891894698143, -0.020304452627897263, -0.04745142161846161, 0.02760019712150097, 0.01158271636813879, -0.03146829456090927, -0.046116285026073456, 0.05346231162548065, -0.016310159116983414, -0.0032874534372240305, 0.042352378368377686, 0.004190446808934212, 0.084914930164814, 0.04511111602187157, -0.005775122437626123, -0.0069253528490662575, -0.02404043823480606, 0.03947249427437782, -0.011150308884680271, 0.0021196601446717978, -0.04361344128847122, -0.04000025987625122, -0.06698566675186157, -0.046180713921785355, 0.0009642558288760483, 0.009673843160271645, -0.02233743481338024, -0.030557557940483093, -0.01653198152780533, -0.0050417641177773476, -0.011482213623821735, 0.001155758392997086, 0.011121852323412895, -0.09177268296480179, 0.018612677231431007, 0.016555074602365494, -0.0922258123755455, 0.01763109117746353, -0.01040420588105917, -0.0569610670208931, -0.06722362339496613, -0.04607429727911949, -0.008475431241095066, -0.04621253162622452, -0.0313902385532856, -0.05425975099205971, 0.007413916289806366, -0.02500070631504059, -0.016495727002620697, 0.005331577733159065, -0.01623762771487236, -0.003817418124526739, 0.020991720259189606, 0.03515880927443504, -0.02269001491367817, 0.009503467939794064, 0.004221894312649965, -0.03126858174800873, 0.01702224090695381, -0.03939485177397728, 0.01914086751639843, 0.061220940202474594, -0.03015431948006153, -0.02419494092464447, -0.024548670276999474, 0.010486483573913574, 0.036123406141996384, -0.005666382145136595, -0.0005003740079700947, -0.02525893785059452, -0.022237269207835197, 0.007026006933301687, 0.0389227457344532, 0.026749057695269585, 0.017630400136113167, 0.004627182614058256, -0.012250475585460663, 0.02847166359424591, 0.008107265457510948, -0.006951129995286465, -0.030470579862594604, 0.014953311532735825, 0.053362876176834106, -0.05516335740685463, -0.004930203780531883, -0.0714988112449646, -0.05668086186051369, 0.02928890846669674, 0.0031352536752820015, 0.026813335716724396, 0.0040649971924722195, 0.04802762717008591, 0.0009742567199282348, 0.03016459010541439, 0.028480203822255135, -0.0035582834389060736, 0.031377360224723816, -0.031242752447724342, 0.0016927493270486593, -0.06667996942996979, -0.030525485053658485, 0.038288239389657974, -0.04931255057454109, -0.036501288414001465, -0.009411805309355259, -0.035154685378074646, 0.048343583941459656, -0.014865060336887836, -0.0635400116443634, -0.00920903030782938, -0.027939731255173683, 0.02989039197564125, 0.0507318377494812, -0.04855773225426674, 0.03254806622862816, -0.03788180276751518, -0.043027203530073166, -0.01653585582971573, 0.011965797282755375, 0.05244016647338867, -0.0326550155878067, 0.0025051620323210955, -0.023605303838849068, 0.01829199120402336, 0.016867490485310555, 0.055663999170064926, -0.025340378284454346, 0.007175043225288391, -0.02212461829185486, 0.0779009684920311, 0.013619127683341503, -0.003880575066432357, 0.045239366590976715, 0.004452126566320658, -0.007441987749189138, -0.0578153133392334, 0.02589435689151287, 0.01336377952247858, 0.015314621850848198, -0.08241958171129227, 0.056975770741701126, 0.034390877932310104, -0.06401950120925903, -0.018729785457253456, 0.039333000779151917, -0.03627246990799904, 0.03421185538172722, -0.00561569957062602, 0.013183292001485825, 0.012012628838419914, 0.04966588690876961, -0.0028395354747772217, 0.07605405151844025, 0.08609981834888458, 0.0029164592269808054, 0.018551992252469063, -0.0006986644002608955, 0.0660417452454567, 0.06348636001348495, 0.04954749718308449, 0.017734209075570107, 0.07670002430677414, -0.010316908359527588, -0.07620008289813995, 0.02403874322772026, 0.049946486949920654, -0.005196147132664919, -0.019473491236567497, -0.015886152163147926, 0.08806173503398895, 0.017353752627968788, 0.06592598557472229, -0.044713132083415985, -0.020362919196486473, -0.006079265382140875, -0.0006737794610671699, -0.0076822200790047646, 0.011476904153823853, 0.045742567628622055, 0.018520332872867584, -0.05059558153152466, -0.016364330425858498, 0.01829923316836357, -0.03300999477505684, -0.008472026325762272, -0.019684137776494026, -0.019204474985599518, -0.007577936165034771, -0.043827567249536514, 0.04404451325535774, 0.10103612393140793, -0.02275945246219635, -0.013697262853384018, 0.0010393981356173754, 0.020986370742321014, 0.01274870429188013, 0.05887937545776367, -0.010613586753606796, -0.006995031144469976, -0.01732492260634899, -0.0466729998588562, 0.00857445877045393, 0.05212603509426117, -0.0068993838503956795, 0.010910253040492535, -0.04441705346107483, -0.02732190303504467, 0.012735355645418167, 0.021446939557790756, -0.06969920545816422, -0.04473983868956566, -0.012932486832141876, -0.012065252289175987, -0.04736405611038208, -0.009830886498093605, 0.02973663993179798, 0.004247955046594143, -0.061902984976768494, -0.021657541394233704, -0.004431956447660923, 0.03130855783820152, 0.014617596752941608, -0.07095110416412354, 0.01079818606376648, 0.03311287611722946, 0.006886190734803677, -0.007539300248026848, 0.012581384740769863, 0.03250417485833168, -0.030547868460416794, 0.0019863671623170376, 0.03857080638408661, 0.00028073496650904417, 0.038668740540742874, -0.006074537988752127, -0.03118470311164856, -0.09155838191509247, -0.02584720030426979, 0.046721480786800385, -0.04009084776043892, -0.07487452030181885, 0.045929230749607086, -0.0019017503364011645, 0.034284185618162155, 0.055409543216228485, 0.028060659766197205, 0.02201405167579651, -0.00955910887569189, 0.011201879009604454, -0.04615906998515129, 0.03071167878806591, 0.05289849638938904, -0.033266980201005936, 0.09381598234176636, 0.009186625480651855, -0.02973560243844986, -0.026971401646733284, 0.02599669061601162, -0.02679719589650631, 0.01721944287419319, -0.028081394731998444, 0.009742665104568005, -0.026829643175005913, -0.08695749938488007, -0.012777077034115791, 0.05618131533265114, -0.02460533007979393, -0.0077821421436965466, -0.006254403851926327, -0.02290240302681923, -0.01287566963583231, -0.014375066384673119, 0.002464496763423085, -0.012745038606226444, -0.02533079870045185, -0.022404653951525688, -0.0384213924407959, -0.014284866861999035, -0.02026716247200966, 0.01592118665575981, -0.033242691308259964, -0.05435856431722641, -0.004839702509343624, -0.03371733799576759, 0.04537321999669075, 0.00446221511811018, 0.05197757109999657, 0.0011599838035181165 ]
3,704
Instance-dependent Early Stopping
https://openreview.net/forum?id=P42DbV2nuV
[ "Suqin Yuan", "Runqi Lin", "Lei Feng", "Bo Han", "Tongliang Liu" ]
Spotlight
In machine learning practice, early stopping has been widely used to regularize models and can save computational costs by halting the training process when the model's performance on a validation set stops improving. However, conventional early stopping applies the same stopping criterion to all instances without considering their individual learning statuses, which leads to redundant computations on instances that are already well-learned. To further improve the efficiency, we propose an Instance-dependent Early Stopping (IES) method that adapts the early stopping mechanism from the entire training set to the instance level, based on the core principle that once the model has mastered an instance, the training on it should stop. IES considers an instance as mastered if the second-order differences of its loss value remain within a small range around zero. This offers a more consistent measure of an instance's learning status compared with directly using the loss value, and thus allows for a unified threshold to determine when an instance can be excluded from further backpropagation. We show that excluding mastered instances from backpropagation can increase the gradient norms, thereby accelerating the decrease of the training loss and speeding up the training process. Extensive experiments on benchmarks demonstrate that IES method can reduce backpropagation instances by 10%-50% while maintaining or even slightly improving the test accuracy and transfer learning performance of a model.
Early Stopping, Supervised Learning, Deep Learning, Efficiency, Sample Selection, Data Pruning
We propose an instance-dependent early stopping method that stops training at the instance level by determining whether the model has fully learned an instance. It reduces computational costs while maintaining or even improving model performance.
2
2502.07547
[ -0.037999168038368225, -0.008495135232806206, -0.007511965464800596, 0.01241594459861517, 0.04485277459025383, 0.026203496381640434, 0.018314218148589134, -0.0041054366156458855, -0.02969985455274582, -0.03020693175494671, -0.01762242428958416, 0.020553408190608025, -0.03693462908267975, -0.01756639964878559, 0.007467011455446482, 0.048744846135377884, 0.0579664371907711, -0.03265061229467392, 0.002828423399478197, 0.01249875221401453, -0.008631037548184395, -0.004235665313899517, 0.06682036817073822, 0.04371621087193489, 0.026381252333521843, -0.01801258698105812, 0.004338187165558338, -0.013008028268814087, -0.030756065621972084, 0.017127837985754013, 0.03524080663919449, -0.009717426262795925, 0.004879641812294722, -0.002392793772742152, 0.03569956496357918, 0.03813791275024414, 0.0020522465929389, -0.009648158214986324, -0.002876446582376957, 0.018299276009202003, -0.02637743577361107, 0.007629080675542355, -0.015120724216103554, 0.02269727736711502, -0.06300565600395203, 0.010632457211613655, -0.09799202531576157, 0.010205261409282684, 0.015278519131243229, -0.055607691407203674, -0.10309915244579315, 0.022653114050626755, 0.011275368742644787, -0.02525528147816658, -0.012549168430268764, 0.039121903479099274, 0.040483444929122925, -0.050214726477861404, 0.0026730054523795843, -0.040003616362810135, -0.03893880173563957, 0.010094593279063702, -0.004170541185885668, 0.039737261831760406, -0.002926369197666645, -0.01770845800638199, 0.04064272716641426, 0.04482366517186165, -0.05428869649767876, -0.032440442591905594, -0.04486750438809395, -0.030274884775280952, -0.007866308093070984, 0.028832459822297096, -0.010743927210569382, -0.009199319407343864, 0.018624376505613327, -0.01971486024558544, 0.05313405394554138, 0.000618483463767916, 0.016931550577282906, 0.02465258166193962, 0.01373855210840702, -0.0028410397935658693, 0.00498364120721817, -0.007903491146862507, -0.01483954582363367, -0.042332034558057785, -0.09317304939031601, 0.030841533094644547, -0.003496097633615136, -0.04016363248229027, 0.05019661784172058, 0.030534906312823296, 0.018550585955381393, -0.02412739209830761, 0.02898852340877056, 0.014772116206586361, 0.03221653401851654, -0.009940027259290218, -0.004096482414752245, -0.04711834341287613, 0.007939985953271389, 0.028394518420100212, -0.11060351878404617, -0.04256036505103111, -0.006490228697657585, -0.011788423173129559, -0.016589557752013206, -0.008311589248478413, -0.040221549570560455, 0.004777881782501936, 0.0016863072523847222, -0.033059775829315186, -0.10795699059963226, 0.01060129702091217, -0.02472175844013691, 0.02861693501472473, -0.01996012032032013, -0.01627447083592415, 0.028589528053998947, 0.04834187775850296, -0.008878345601260662, 0.07027336955070496, 0.007930838502943516, -0.003310093656182289, -0.005602998659014702, 0.05428581312298775, -0.00928767304867506, -0.025722000747919083, -0.014024952426552773, 0.03366370126605034, 0.03345603123307228, 0.023093078285455704, 0.006880460772663355, 0.015258789993822575, 0.011715132743120193, -0.008375709876418114, 0.07019191980361938, -0.006734034046530724, -0.006303461734205484, -0.021201476454734802, 0.04692130908370018, -0.03458636999130249, 0.0542704276740551, -0.03158324211835861, -0.023100316524505615, -0.010260367766022682, -0.018097102642059326, -0.02302863821387291, 0.01348939724266529, -0.0014880176167935133, -0.027170095592737198, -0.043248340487480164, 0.022089429199695587, 0.054286155849695206, 0.007583067286759615, 0.030085530132055283, -0.017174355685710907, 0.0016863422933965921, 0.03971150144934654, 0.022458527237176895, -0.012396450154483318, 0.009968425147235394, 0.00026341842021793127, -0.052206359803676605, 0.05555982515215874, 0.031113222241401672, -0.03988809883594513, 0.03729923442006111, -0.04110276326537132, -0.0358128622174263, 0.07151763141155243, -0.03141307085752487, -0.03204939886927605, -0.0025578585918992758, 0.06578516960144043, -0.006467535626143217, 0.030673207715153694, 0.02368171326816082, -0.09149017184972763, 0.03571688011288643, 0.02218870259821415, 0.0010131052695214748, -0.007351596374064684, -0.02262684516608715, 0.07159217447042465, -0.04510262981057167, 0.022006649523973465, 0.004566729534417391, -0.06903212517499924, -0.013969534076750278, 0.03802673518657684, -0.041688933968544006, 0.059566039592027664, 0.014421326108276844, -0.02511013112962246, 0.022019697353243828, 0.010664846748113632, 0.0710073933005333, 0.07091815024614334, -0.036359917372465134, 0.0490441732108593, -0.013898112811148167, -0.034411199390888214, 0.0015872038202360272, 0.042313139885663986, -0.06688767671585083, -0.04137743264436722, 0.030159685760736465, -0.034639280289411545, 0.008450604043900967, -0.01506941206753254, 0.03400470316410065, 0.015063043683767319, 0.03339396044611931, -0.003554282709956169, -0.004241632297635078, 0.014418283477425575, -0.07775397598743439, 0.042782507836818695, 0.008970544673502445, -0.0320771187543869, 0.005776587408035994, -0.0015168215613812208, 0.07459176331758499, 0.05036821961402893, -0.028673158958554268, -0.027288077399134636, -0.010302766226232052, 0.011529987677931786, 0.00901197548955679, 0.01978372037410736, -0.025639593601226807, 0.02856430597603321, -0.013132337480783463, -0.0037595124449580908, -0.011427655816078186, 0.08029210567474365, -0.03097420558333397, -0.00881543755531311, 0.060865797102451324, -0.004795313812792301, 0.05554189905524254, 0.02451869286596775, 0.02645130269229412, 0.05401209741830826, 0.009712694212794304, -0.017412325367331505, -0.02916022203862667, -0.035918086767196655, -0.010125993750989437, -0.011600053869187832, -0.032930344343185425, 0.0033895440865308046, -0.058810483664274216, -0.03464459255337715, -0.0022404410410672426, 0.047432731837034225, 0.03969854116439819, 0.006942715961486101, 0.027697842568159103, -0.015159588307142258, -0.017451252788305283, -0.001218048157170415, -0.12129098922014236, -0.03850049525499344, -0.01681593805551529, 0.06882882863283157, -0.021605128422379494, 0.02415027655661106, -0.025120088830590248, 0.04911292344331741, -0.02197403647005558, -0.03141744062304497, 0.032875511795282364, 0.02504577487707138, 0.007752342149615288, -0.059442728757858276, 0.005833431147038937, 0.027045950293540955, 0.05826272815465927, -0.004647401161491871, -0.024328526109457016, -0.020003218203783035, -0.05485710874199867, -0.03788064792752266, -0.0524294488132, -0.034614503383636475, 0.026349248364567757, 0.015594790689647198, -0.0020636876579374075, -0.03842567279934883, 0.026525959372520447, 0.03647398203611374, 0.08065769076347351, 0.026205092668533325, 0.040435221046209335, 0.0452997162938118, -0.011156321503221989, -0.0010081282816827297, 0.013681145384907722, -0.008068096823990345, -0.003477361984550953, 0.004036314785480499, 0.004646166227757931, 0.010675216093659401, 0.01658150926232338, -0.2620883882045746, -0.01611153967678547, 0.01956913061439991, 0.0235306229442358, 0.020655548200011253, -0.059114959090948105, 0.0658789575099945, 0.003034073393791914, -0.03979417309165001, 0.041424818336963654, -0.003340871771797538, 0.025348950177431107, 0.030755795538425446, 0.051659002900123596, 0.0291630607098341, 0.031021304428577423, 0.00484430743381381, -0.010349826887249947, 0.010333357378840446, 0.04218938201665878, -0.0030632938724011183, -0.07117389887571335, -0.002229607431218028, 0.027333777397871017, -0.011292021721601486, 0.05394059792160988, -0.0819815844297409, 0.0017647010972723365, -0.047350235283374786, -0.029261158779263496, 0.008539406582713127, -0.04603084549307823, -0.004766697064042091, 0.04434152692556381, 0.01587776467204094, -0.015517178922891617, 0.05055995658040047, 0.026146890595555305, 0.0264822319149971, 0.014957698062062263, 0.02804332785308361, -0.012658917345106602, 0.0025963291991502047, 0.03618766739964485, 0.05681953579187393, -0.0031296503730118275, -0.023534635081887245, -0.04156423732638359, -0.006780232768505812, 0.04010450839996338, -0.024076493456959724, -0.027633721008896828, -0.03272027522325516, 0.011939936317503452, 0.02500242553651333, -0.011595448479056358, -0.005222988314926624, -0.021812718361616135, 0.008740545250475407, 0.0076358444057404995, -0.019927620887756348, -0.05088723078370094, -0.02049991488456726, -0.03073567897081375, 0.019473474472761154, -0.038174793124198914, -0.07102429866790771, -0.05309973657131195, 0.03581031784415245, 0.04016512632369995, 0.014156105928122997, 0.012250659987330437, 0.010615922510623932, -0.10203681886196136, 0.033163975924253464, -0.017449280247092247, 0.013596233911812305, 0.040004290640354156, 0.017864154651761055, 0.08051253855228424, -0.027928786352276802, -0.025820665061473846, 0.003747716546058655, 0.01569371111690998, 0.01719578355550766, -0.02194562926888466, 0.02456256002187729, 0.01700349897146225, -0.008917717263102531, 0.005824422463774681, 0.04102485999464989, 0.04587884992361069, 0.0228461641818285, -0.03423723578453064, 0.06800324469804764, 0.08737197518348694, 0.02629701793193817, 0.07866664975881577, 0.058215368539094925, -0.044676464051008224, 0.01435053814202547, -0.08643688261508942, -0.0011917043011635542, -0.03490817919373512, -0.01429118774831295, -0.0026634514797478914, -0.03383219242095947, -0.017724936828017235, 0.052713096141815186, -0.014984219335019588, -0.009182828478515148, -0.049314357340335846, 0.003994831349700689, -0.031101636588573456, -0.03812035173177719, -0.009778669103980064, -0.02043817564845085, 0.012873955070972443, 0.04642849415540695, -0.023315735161304474, -0.02601868472993374, 0.019216759130358696, -0.020036494359374046, 0.0013398160226643085, 0.010585286654531956, -0.015881121158599854, 0.016946636140346527, 0.0038082613609731197, -0.03215838596224785, -0.041987448930740356, 0.048055268824100494, 0.060265932232141495, 0.0006798953399993479, 0.05728011578321457, 0.05951280891895294, 0.007259325589984655, -0.0002821325324475765, 0.005481185391545296, 0.03307955339550972, -0.00015419474220834672, 0.018271440640091896, 0.009129407815635204, 0.060946520417928696, 0.025826696306467056, 0.06929215043783188, 0.013272258453071117, -0.0026024244725704193, -0.012785643339157104, 0.006481367163360119, -0.00549719762057066, 0.03220975771546364, -0.05721491575241089, -0.03936216980218887, -0.021091453731060028, -0.014214973896741867, 0.009258377365767956, 0.03222125023603439, -0.02082226611673832, 0.0059693376533687115, -0.07552991807460785, 0.06298922747373581, 0.017531029880046844, -0.004619286395609379, -0.023697031661868095, 0.017764849588274956, 0.05161163583397865, 0.005274927709251642, -0.02139238268136978, 0.015278367325663567, -0.026451123878359795, 0.008737342432141304, -0.009883790276944637, -0.0324128121137619, -0.0038901471998542547, -0.005815884564071894, 0.029300982132554054, 0.0008870465098880231, -0.027851613238453865, -0.03227384760975838, 0.008306162431836128, -0.001893816632218659, -0.013618335127830505, -0.007314332760870457, -0.022470705211162567, 0.08803636580705643, -0.0023302396293729544, 0.018448757007718086, 0.010970710776746273, -0.020117992535233498, 0.020385051146149635, -0.02800138108432293, 0.006759413052350283, -0.004857068881392479, -0.023610977455973625, -0.006247761659324169, -0.04189238324761391, -0.013628361746668816, 0.018783720210194588, -0.02390165813267231, -0.004136976320296526, -0.015780312940478325, 0.009604050777852535, -0.015141939744353294, -0.021431326866149902, 0.029829084873199463, -0.08075010031461716, 0.012418525293469429, 0.030987227335572243, -0.014331614598631859, 0.031299762427806854, -0.028713751584291458, -0.03774965554475784, -0.05703834444284439, 0.012521686032414436, 0.028764119371771812, -0.03963799029588699, -0.008373434655368328, 0.0032664774917066097, 0.004978765733540058, -0.020998086780309677, 0.008100210689008236, -0.007617300376296043, -0.018510185182094574, -0.0076079946011304855, 0.001926421420648694, 0.07613691687583923, -0.040450941771268845, -0.021452175453305244, 0.0048150597140192986, -0.011638657189905643, -0.02037149667739868, -0.030241476371884346, -0.00723308976739645, 0.019917815923690796, -0.010788596235215664, -0.011725062504410744, -0.026003727689385414, 0.07019784301519394, -0.0019754446111619473, -0.038562312722206116, -0.025459999218583107, 0.018452364951372147, -0.02517658844590187, 0.007918080314993858, 0.00525264535099268, 0.021333051845431328, -0.004395495168864727, -0.0236434917896986, 0.0014770537381991744, 0.026791807264089584, 0.03506113588809967, 0.0013879608595743775, -0.043542683124542236, -0.015116051770746708, 0.05487312003970146, -0.058894313871860504, 0.019774090498685837, -0.0804477110505104, -0.012139000929892063, 0.07244720309972763, 0.002632635412737727, 0.017154471948742867, -0.016733229160308838, 0.01470942609012127, 0.037587739527225494, 0.06586340814828873, 0.012460630387067795, -0.04828077554702759, 0.031052403151988983, -0.06691925972700119, 0.02148553915321827, -0.07357646524906158, -0.039622046053409576, 0.05454164370894432, -0.06533333659172058, 0.01101719681173563, 0.011674596928060055, -0.016823921352624893, 0.009479641914367676, -0.01994321681559086, -0.0644078403711319, -0.010806797072291374, -0.032483793795108795, 0.0017627759370952845, 0.015771178528666496, -0.036510955542325974, -0.021974679082632065, -0.011992279440164566, -0.05383013188838959, 0.024021074175834656, -0.01147931907325983, 0.03998725861310959, -0.017577245831489563, -0.003418175969272852, -0.035423871129751205, -0.003814529161900282, 0.030186710879206657, 0.06490381062030792, 0.01007064525038004, 0.0002674954885151237, -0.039256852120161057, 0.06414738297462463, 0.031205033883452415, -0.00708700530230999, -0.02061605267226696, -0.001731196534819901, -0.00022226925648283213, -0.036667294800281525, 0.05422442406415939, -0.03558386489748955, -0.037435442209243774, -0.06576056033372879, 0.05143478885293007, 0.033859364688396454, -0.04235072061419487, -0.0446150004863739, -0.018305109813809395, -0.062173228710889816, -0.007044349797070026, -0.00839939247816801, -0.02590245008468628, 0.005029395222663879, 0.05275942385196686, -0.00045683697680942714, 0.03955649957060814, 0.0635175034403801, 0.03073272854089737, -0.010432055220007896, -0.017041366547346115, 0.07799173891544342, 0.07583239674568176, 0.017195232212543488, -0.008575866930186749, 0.0693197250366211, -0.026172347366809845, -0.05431797355413437, 0.032951872795820236, -0.03175080567598343, -0.017641426995396614, -0.03340960666537285, 0.029292795807123184, 0.07170265913009644, 0.0213670302182436, 0.06059127300977707, -0.07821127027273178, 0.007072844076901674, 0.05059092119336128, 0.010454301722347736, 0.0007037801551632583, 0.03169715031981468, 0.0380542166531086, 0.017128530889749527, -0.010701872408390045, -0.023913029581308365, 0.004288847558200359, -0.01347188651561737, 0.0056910705752670765, -0.01406988687813282, -0.00955990981310606, -0.007230901625007391, 0.028922326862812042, 0.04535244032740593, 0.10483376681804657, -0.03174516558647156, -0.020877623930573463, -0.002387388376519084, 0.024668902158737183, 0.006045360118150711, 0.04294569045305252, -0.007147025782614946, -0.004219864495098591, -0.004044745117425919, -0.03009985387325287, 0.03479147329926491, 0.013634921051561832, 0.0007140233065001667, -0.009081386029720306, -0.023066870868206024, -0.037941548973321915, 0.021141039207577705, 0.02748480997979641, -0.02220108173787594, -0.04461277276277542, -0.04331619292497635, -0.04918473958969116, -0.05076625570654869, -0.03774811327457428, 0.008000684902071953, 0.022086866199970245, 0.00011303296923870221, -0.005312186665832996, 0.0008628212381154299, 0.02157089114189148, 0.03363852947950363, -0.07903464138507843, -0.01400473527610302, 0.04842829704284668, -0.0058265929110348225, -0.01860806904733181, 0.03991148993372917, 0.018228890374302864, -0.023633526638150215, -0.025147484615445137, 0.024268340319395065, -0.012294004671275616, 0.03923816978931427, -0.02693185582756996, -0.0016248136525973678, -0.08780007064342499, 0.0057463813573122025, 0.015994645655155182, -0.03178490698337555, -0.07265498489141464, 0.062048740684986115, -0.038584403693675995, 0.012872652150690556, 0.049891147762537, -0.017806276679039, -0.026156600564718246, -0.023401105776429176, -0.030770476907491684, -0.0235334150493145, 0.004451481159776449, 0.060417089611291885, -0.003534499788656831, 0.05447762459516525, 0.03543565794825554, -0.017273355275392532, -0.003216362092643976, 0.04186142235994339, -0.03385830670595169, -0.01846352033317089, -0.04786539077758789, -0.0028993410523980856, -0.02188311703503132, -0.10984770953655243, -0.03348323330283165, 0.02552315592765808, 0.0022081825882196426, -0.04234788566827774, -0.0066222227178514, -0.007834707386791706, -0.008501803502440453, -0.02964097447693348, -0.013747822493314743, -0.0438317134976387, -0.047837380319833755, -0.0508730374276638, -0.05342748388648033, 0.0018242787336930633, -0.030202146619558334, -0.0011631831293925643, -0.02248714491724968, -0.014738180674612522, 0.007715668063610792, -0.024938657879829407, 0.04853379726409912, 0.017873644828796387, 0.0027786563150584698, -0.03765083849430084 ]