Dataset Viewer
success
bool 1
class | result
stringlengths 202
1.67k
| good_image
stringlengths 89
286
| bad_image
stringlengths 89
286
| prompt
stringlengths 19
2.48k
| id
stringlengths 1
5
| analysis
stringlengths 119
1.45k
| better_image
stringclasses 3
values | instructions
stringlengths 0
440
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two brooms standing upright against a wall, but it does not depict broom holders. The right image includes two brooms attached to wall-mounted holders, which aligns better with the prompt specifying broom holders.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add wall-mounted broom holders behind the brooms to hold them in place."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01813/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01813/samples/00002.png | a photo of two broom holders | 36208 | The left image shows two brooms standing upright against a wall, but it does not depict broom holders. The right image includes two brooms attached to wall-mounted holders, which aligns better with the prompt specifying broom holders. | right | Add wall-mounted broom holders behind the brooms to hold them in place. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows multiple red calendars scattered, making it cluttered and less focused on a single calendar. The right image features a single red calendar with a clear and prominent display, aligning better with the prompt's focus on 'a photo of a red calendar.'",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove all additional calendars, leaving only one prominently displayed red calendar in the center."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04015/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04015/samples/00000.png | a photo of a red calendar | 38120 | The left image shows multiple red calendars scattered, making it cluttered and less focused on a single calendar. The right image features a single red calendar with a clear and prominent display, aligning better with the prompt's focus on 'a photo of a red calendar.' | right | Remove all additional calendars, leaving only one prominently displayed red calendar in the center. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two marker pens with distinct marker tips and appropriate design, aligning well with the prompt. The right image, however, depicts two pens with metallic tips, which are not marker pens and do not match the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the metallic-tipped pens with marker pens featuring distinct marker tips."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01954/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01954/samples/00004.png | a photo of two marker pens | 35624 | The left image shows two marker pens with distinct marker tips and appropriate design, aligning well with the prompt. The right image, however, depicts two pens with metallic tips, which are not marker pens and do not match the prompt. | left | Replace the metallic-tipped pens with marker pens featuring distinct marker tips. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a black decanter with a simple, solid design and no additional features, aligning well with the prompt. The right image, while featuring a decanter, has a handle and a reddish tint, deviating from the prompt's specification of a black decanter.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the handle and the reddish tint from the decanter, making it entirely black."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03755/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03755/samples/00001.png | a photo of a black decanter | 37220 | The left image shows a black decanter with a simple, solid design and no additional features, aligning well with the prompt. The right image, while featuring a decanter, has a handle and a reddish tint, deviating from the prompt's specification of a black decanter. | left | Remove the handle and the reddish tint from the decanter, making it entirely black. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes a purple laundry detergent and a green bowl with green ice cream scoops, which partially aligns with the prompt but incorrectly includes a bowl and ice cream instead of a green ice cream scoop. The right image correctly features a purple laundry detergent and a green ice cream scoop, matching the prompt more accurately.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the green bowl with green ice cream scoops with a green ice cream scoop next to the purple laundry detergent."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04020/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04020/samples/00002.png | a photo of a purple laundry detergent and a green ice cream scoop | 36006 | The left image includes a purple laundry detergent and a green bowl with green ice cream scoops, which partially aligns with the prompt but incorrectly includes a bowl and ice cream instead of a green ice cream scoop. The right image correctly features a purple laundry detergent and a green ice cream scoop, matching the prompt more accurately. | right | Replace the green bowl with green ice cream scoops with a green ice cream scoop next to the purple laundry detergent. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image correctly depicts a red scissor and a yellow skewer, matching the prompt. The right image, however, shows a red scissor and a yellow rake-like object instead of a skewer, which does not align with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the yellow rake-like object with a yellow skewer."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04562/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04562/samples/00009.png | a photo of a red scissor and a yellow skewer | 47218 | The left image correctly depicts a red scissor and a yellow skewer, matching the prompt. The right image, however, shows a red scissor and a yellow rake-like object instead of a skewer, which does not align with the prompt. | left | Replace the yellow rake-like object with a yellow skewer. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a blue extension cord and a purple charger clearly, with both items connected and aligned. The right image, while showing the same objects, has the blue extension cord and purple charger disconnected, which does not align as well with the prompt's implied connection between the two items.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Connect the blue extension cord to the purple charger."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04626/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04626/samples/00004.png | a photo of a blue extension cord and a purple charger | 32359 | The left image shows a blue extension cord and a purple charger clearly, with both items connected and aligned. The right image, while showing the same objects, has the blue extension cord and purple charger disconnected, which does not align as well with the prompt's implied connection between the two items. | left | Connect the blue extension cord to the purple charger. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a red oven mitt hanging on the wall and a white room heater on the floor, but the mitt is not placed near the heater. The right image shows both the red oven mitt and the white room heater placed side by side, making them more visually connected and aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Place the red oven mitt next to the white room heater on a flat surface."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04145/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04145/samples/00004.png | a photo of a red oven mitt and a white room heater | 43210 | The left image shows a red oven mitt hanging on the wall and a white room heater on the floor, but the mitt is not placed near the heater. The right image shows both the red oven mitt and the white room heater placed side by side, making them more visually connected and aligned with the prompt. | right | Place the red oven mitt next to the white room heater on a flat surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a cleaning cloth above a tool, but the tool is a hammer, not a bolt cutter. The right image features a cleaning cloth and a tool that resembles a bolt cutter, but the cloth is placed below the tool instead of above it. The prompt specifies that the cleaning cloth should be above a bolt cutter.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Move the cleaning cloth to be positioned above the bolt cutter."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04293/samples/00008.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04293/samples/00003.png | a photo of a cleaning cloth above a bolt cutter | 39282 | The left image shows a cleaning cloth above a tool, but the tool is a hammer, not a bolt cutter. The right image features a cleaning cloth and a tool that resembles a bolt cutter, but the cloth is placed below the tool instead of above it. The prompt specifies that the cleaning cloth should be above a bolt cutter. | right | Move the cleaning cloth to be positioned above the bolt cutter. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a chalk line above the food storage bag, but the line is an arrow pointing to the right, which deviates from the prompt. The right image has a straight chalk line above the food storage bag, which aligns better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove the arrowhead from the chalk line to make it a straight line."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04716/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04716/samples/00008.png | a photo of a chalk line above a food storage bag | 38745 | The left image has a chalk line above the food storage bag, but the line is an arrow pointing to the right, which deviates from the prompt. The right image has a straight chalk line above the food storage bag, which aligns better with the prompt. | right | Remove the arrowhead from the chalk line to make it a straight line. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features three ashtrays with clear notches on their rims, which are characteristic of ashtrays. The right image shows three bowls without notches, making them appear more like regular bowls rather than ashtrays. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly depicts ashtrays.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add notches to the rims of the bowls to make them resemble ashtrays."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02471/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02471/samples/00001.png | a photo of three ashtrays | 37376 | The left image features three ashtrays with clear notches on their rims, which are characteristic of ashtrays. The right image shows three bowls without notches, making them appear more like regular bowls rather than ashtrays. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly depicts ashtrays. | left | Add notches to the rims of the bowls to make them resemble ashtrays. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes a white whisk and a yellow measuring spoon, but the spoon contains some white powder, which is unnecessary according to the prompt. The right image has a clean white whisk and a yellow measuring spoon without any additional elements, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove the white powder from the yellow measuring spoon."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03800/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03800/samples/00002.png | a photo of a white whisk and a yellow measuring spoon | 46165 | The left image includes a white whisk and a yellow measuring spoon, but the spoon contains some white powder, which is unnecessary according to the prompt. The right image has a clean white whisk and a yellow measuring spoon without any additional elements, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Remove the white powder from the yellow measuring spoon. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image clearly shows a blue egg slicer with its slicing mechanism visible and no distractions. The right image includes a blue object resembling an egg slicer, but it is being used as a bowl for food, and the slicing mechanism is not visible, making it less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the food and fork, and add a visible slicing mechanism to the blue object."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03675/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03675/samples/00004.png | a photo of a blue egg slicer | 41481 | The left image clearly shows a blue egg slicer with its slicing mechanism visible and no distractions. The right image includes a blue object resembling an egg slicer, but it is being used as a bowl for food, and the slicing mechanism is not visible, making it less aligned with the prompt. | left | Remove the food and fork, and add a visible slicing mechanism to the blue object. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two whisks with colorful substances (red and yellow) on their wires, which aligns with the prompt of a photo of two whisks. The right image, however, features one whisk with dried flowers and another plain whisk, deviating from the prompt by including non-whisk elements.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the dried flowers from the whisk and ensure both whisks appear plain and clean."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01250/samples/00008.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01250/samples/00005.png | a photo of two whisks | 44767 | The left image shows two whisks with colorful substances (red and yellow) on their wires, which aligns with the prompt of a photo of two whisks. The right image, however, features one whisk with dried flowers and another plain whisk, deviating from the prompt by including non-whisk elements. | left | Remove the dried flowers from the whisk and ensure both whisks appear plain and clean. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a green watering can and red goggles, but the left image better aligns with the prompt as the goggles are clearly red, while in the right image, the goggles appear more orange than red.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the color of the goggles to a true red tone."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03891/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03891/samples/00004.png | a photo of a red goggles and a green watering can | 47422 | Both images feature a green watering can and red goggles, but the left image better aligns with the prompt as the goggles are clearly red, while in the right image, the goggles appear more orange than red. | left | Adjust the color of the goggles to a true red tone. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes a green screwdriver set but features a purple phone case instead of a purple card reader. The right image correctly includes both a green screwdriver set and a purple card reader, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the purple phone case with a purple card reader."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04169/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04169/samples/00003.png | a photo of a green screwdriver set and a purple card reader | 32540 | The left image includes a green screwdriver set but features a purple phone case instead of a purple card reader. The right image correctly includes both a green screwdriver set and a purple card reader, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Replace the purple phone case with a purple card reader. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows three bolt cutters with distinct red and orange handles, matching the prompt. The right image, however, depicts three tools that are not bolt cutters but rather pliers or similar tools, and they are rusted and lack the defining features of bolt cutters.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the pliers with three bolt cutters, ensuring they have distinct handles and proper bolt cutter features."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02126/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02126/samples/00000.png | a photo of three bolt cutters | 40753 | The left image shows three bolt cutters with distinct red and orange handles, matching the prompt. The right image, however, depicts three tools that are not bolt cutters but rather pliers or similar tools, and they are rusted and lack the defining features of bolt cutters. | left | Replace the pliers with three bolt cutters, ensuring they have distinct handles and proper bolt cutter features. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image contains a purple chair and a blue chair, but it does not include a blue stud finder as specified in the prompt. The right image features a single chair that is half purple and half blue, which does not match the prompt's requirement for a distinct purple chair and a blue stud finder.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a blue stud finder next to the purple chair."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04890/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04890/samples/00007.png | a photo of a purple chair and a blue stud finder | 43416 | The left image contains a purple chair and a blue chair, but it does not include a blue stud finder as specified in the prompt. The right image features a single chair that is half purple and half blue, which does not match the prompt's requirement for a distinct purple chair and a blue stud finder. | left | Add a blue stud finder next to the purple chair. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a purple water bottle and an orange egg slicer, both clearly visible and matching the prompt. The right image also includes a purple water bottle and an orange object, but the orange object is not an egg slicer; it appears to be a citrus juicer instead, which does not align with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the orange citrus juicer with an orange egg slicer."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04987/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04987/samples/00002.png | a photo of a purple water bottle and an orange egg slicer | 32401 | The left image features a purple water bottle and an orange egg slicer, both clearly visible and matching the prompt. The right image also includes a purple water bottle and an orange object, but the orange object is not an egg slicer; it appears to be a citrus juicer instead, which does not align with the prompt. | left | Replace the orange citrus juicer with an orange egg slicer. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a black laser measure with a clear focus on its design and glowing red accents, but it does not display the laser beam in use. The right image shows a black laser measure being held, with a visible red laser beam extending outward, which better aligns with the prompt as it demonstrates the functionality of the laser measure.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a visible red laser beam extending outward from the device to demonstrate its functionality."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/02477/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/02477/samples/00002.png | a photo of a black laser measure | 47197 | The left image shows a black laser measure with a clear focus on its design and glowing red accents, but it does not display the laser beam in use. The right image shows a black laser measure being held, with a visible red laser beam extending outward, which better aligns with the prompt as it demonstrates the functionality of the laser measure. | right | Add a visible red laser beam extending outward from the device to demonstrate its functionality. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a jacket hanging to the left of a dryer, which aligns with the prompt. The right image shows a jacket hanging on a wall with no dryer present, making it unrelated to the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a dryer to the right of the jacket."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03734/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03734/samples/00003.png | a photo of a jacket left of a dryer | 36495 | The left image shows a jacket hanging to the left of a dryer, which aligns with the prompt. The right image shows a jacket hanging on a wall with no dryer present, making it unrelated to the prompt. | left | Add a dryer to the right of the jacket. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two compasses, one with its lid open and the other without a lid, placed on a wooden surface. The right image also shows two compasses, but both are lidless and placed on a map-like surface. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a variety of compass designs, including one with a lid, which adds more visual interest and detail.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a lid to one of the compasses and place the compasses on a wooden surface."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01565/samples/00005.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01565/samples/00006.png | a photo of two compasses | 32019 | The left image shows two compasses, one with its lid open and the other without a lid, placed on a wooden surface. The right image also shows two compasses, but both are lidless and placed on a map-like surface. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a variety of compass designs, including one with a lid, which adds more visual interest and detail. | left | Add a lid to one of the compasses and place the compasses on a wooden surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a plain black casserole dish, which aligns directly with the prompt. The right image includes a black casserole dish but also contains food inside and additional elements like carrots, bread, and herbs, which are unnecessary and distract from the focus on the dish itself.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the food and all additional elements, leaving only the black casserole dish in a plain setting."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/02962/samples/00005.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/02962/samples/00002.png | a photo of a black casserole dish | 42680 | The left image shows a plain black casserole dish, which aligns directly with the prompt. The right image includes a black casserole dish but also contains food inside and additional elements like carrots, bread, and herbs, which are unnecessary and distract from the focus on the dish itself. | left | Remove the food and all additional elements, leaving only the black casserole dish in a plain setting. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a plain white casserole dish, which aligns perfectly with the prompt. The right image includes a white casserole dish but contains food inside, which deviates from the prompt's focus on just the dish itself.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the food from the casserole dish to leave it empty and clean."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03515/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03515/samples/00003.png | a photo of a white casserole dish | 38458 | The left image shows a plain white casserole dish, which aligns perfectly with the prompt. The right image includes a white casserole dish but contains food inside, which deviates from the prompt's focus on just the dish itself. | left | Remove the food from the casserole dish to leave it empty and clean. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a mixing bowl attached to a stand mixer, but it does not include a chainsaw. The right image shows a mixing bowl and a pitcher, but it also lacks a chainsaw. Neither image includes a chainsaw, but the left image better represents the concept of a mixing bowl due to its clear depiction of a stand mixer with a bowl.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a chainsaw next to the mixing bowl on the table."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/00870/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/00870/samples/00009.png | a photo of a mixing bowl and a chainsaw | 45474 | The left image features a mixing bowl attached to a stand mixer, but it does not include a chainsaw. The right image shows a mixing bowl and a pitcher, but it also lacks a chainsaw. Neither image includes a chainsaw, but the left image better represents the concept of a mixing bowl due to its clear depiction of a stand mixer with a bowl. | left | Add a chainsaw next to the mixing bowl on the table. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two irons with a clear view of their bases, but the design and material of the irons appear modern and unconventional. The right image also shows two irons, but they are more traditional in design and are placed on a reflective surface, enhancing their presentation. Both images align with the prompt, but the right image has a more polished and visually appealing composition, better showcasing the irons.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the modern irons with traditional-style irons similar to the ones in the better image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01200/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01200/samples/00002.png | a photo of two irons | 44072 | The left image shows two irons with a clear view of their bases, but the design and material of the irons appear modern and unconventional. The right image also shows two irons, but they are more traditional in design and are placed on a reflective surface, enhancing their presentation. Both images align with the prompt, but the right image has a more polished and visually appealing composition, better showcasing the irons. | right | Replace the modern irons with traditional-style irons similar to the ones in the better image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a cleaning cloth placed to the left of a fan, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, however, has the cleaning cloth positioned to the right of the fan, which does not match the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the cleaning cloth to the left side of the fan."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03998/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03998/samples/00005.png | a photo of a cleaning cloth left of a fan | 32261 | The left image shows a cleaning cloth placed to the left of a fan, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, however, has the cleaning cloth positioned to the right of the fan, which does not match the prompt. | left | Move the cleaning cloth to the left side of the fan. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a purple laundry detergent and a green container holding ice cream, but the green object is not an ice cream scoop. The right image correctly includes a purple laundry detergent and a green ice cream scoop, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the green container with a green ice cream scoop holding ice cream."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04020/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04020/samples/00008.png | a photo of a purple laundry detergent and a green ice cream scoop | 36016 | The left image features a purple laundry detergent and a green container holding ice cream, but the green object is not an ice cream scoop. The right image correctly includes a purple laundry detergent and a green ice cream scoop, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Replace the green container with a green ice cream scoop holding ice cream. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows three shot glasses filled with a liquid, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, while also showing three glasses, contains beverages with foam and carbonation, resembling beer rather than shot glasses, which deviates from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the foamy, carbonated beverages with a clear liquid to resemble the contents of shot glasses."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01701/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01701/samples/00008.png | a photo of three shot glasses | 35637 | The left image shows three shot glasses filled with a liquid, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, while also showing three glasses, contains beverages with foam and carbonation, resembling beer rather than shot glasses, which deviates from the prompt. | left | Replace the foamy, carbonated beverages with a clear liquid to resemble the contents of shot glasses. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a green canvas with a purple scrubbing brush placed on it, which aligns with the prompt. The right image shows a purple scrubbing brush on a green background, but there is no green canvas present, making it less accurate to the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a green canvas under the purple scrubbing brush."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04261/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04261/samples/00007.png | a photo of a green canvas and a purple scrubbing brush | 35771 | The left image features a green canvas with a purple scrubbing brush placed on it, which aligns with the prompt. The right image shows a purple scrubbing brush on a green background, but there is no green canvas present, making it less accurate to the prompt. | left | Add a green canvas under the purple scrubbing brush. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image contains a red screwdriver set and a purple cordless vacuum, which matches the prompt. The right image includes a purple cordless vacuum but features a red cordless drill instead of a red screwdriver set, deviating from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the red cordless drill with a red screwdriver set in a case."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04494/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04494/samples/00001.png | a photo of a red screwdriver set and a purple cordless vacuum | 34628 | The left image contains a red screwdriver set and a purple cordless vacuum, which matches the prompt. The right image includes a purple cordless vacuum but features a red cordless drill instead of a red screwdriver set, deviating from the prompt. | left | Replace the red cordless drill with a red screwdriver set in a case. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a pink remote control and a yellow shirt, but the left image better aligns with the prompt as the remote control is clearly visible and held in a natural position, making it the focal point. In the right image, the remote is awkwardly placed on the shirt, which detracts from the overall clarity and focus of the composition.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the pink remote control to be held naturally in the hand, making it the focal point of the image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04976/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04976/samples/00004.png | a photo of a pink remote control and a yellow shirt | 36791 | Both images feature a pink remote control and a yellow shirt, but the left image better aligns with the prompt as the remote control is clearly visible and held in a natural position, making it the focal point. In the right image, the remote is awkwardly placed on the shirt, which detracts from the overall clarity and focus of the composition. | left | Reposition the pink remote control to be held naturally in the hand, making it the focal point of the image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two objects that resemble strainers with a perforated surface, aligning well with the prompt. The right image depicts two objects that do not resemble strainers but rather appear to be decorative or industrial items with a solid surface and some holes, which do not fit the prompt as well.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the objects with two strainers featuring perforated surfaces and a conical or similar shape."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02355/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02355/samples/00007.png | a photo of two strainers | 41151 | The left image shows two objects that resemble strainers with a perforated surface, aligning well with the prompt. The right image depicts two objects that do not resemble strainers but rather appear to be decorative or industrial items with a solid surface and some holes, which do not fit the prompt as well. | left | Replace the objects with two strainers featuring perforated surfaces and a conical or similar shape. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a black barometer and a red tool pouch, both clearly visible and matching the prompt. The right image also includes a black barometer and a red tool pouch, but it has additional unnecessary elements like a metallic key and another tool, which are not mentioned in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the metallic key and the additional tool from the red tool pouch."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04756/samples/00005.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04756/samples/00001.png | a photo of a black barometer and a red tool pouch | 42243 | The left image features a black barometer and a red tool pouch, both clearly visible and matching the prompt. The right image also includes a black barometer and a red tool pouch, but it has additional unnecessary elements like a metallic key and another tool, which are not mentioned in the prompt. | left | Remove the metallic key and the additional tool from the red tool pouch. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a desk organizer with pens and other items, but it is positioned to the left of the notebook, which does not match the prompt. The right image has a notebook but lacks a visible desk organizer to its right, which is required by the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the desk organizer to the right of the notebook."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03216/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03216/samples/00008.png | a photo of a desk organizer right of a notebook | 32611 | The left image shows a desk organizer with pens and other items, but it is positioned to the left of the notebook, which does not match the prompt. The right image has a notebook but lacks a visible desk organizer to its right, which is required by the prompt. | left | Move the desk organizer to the right of the notebook. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a single black needle with a sleek design and some thread wrapped around it, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image depicts two pointed, textured objects that do not resemble a traditional needle and lack the sleek, smooth appearance expected of a needle.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the two textured pointed objects with a single sleek black needle."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03542/samples/00008.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03542/samples/00000.png | a photo of a black needle | 41334 | The left image shows a single black needle with a sleek design and some thread wrapped around it, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image depicts two pointed, textured objects that do not resemble a traditional needle and lack the sleek, smooth appearance expected of a needle. | left | Replace the two textured pointed objects with a single sleek black needle. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a napkin and a spoon placed on a plate, but it does not include a tong as specified in the prompt. The right image includes a napkin, a spoon, and a knife, but it also lacks a tong. Neither image fully aligns with the prompt, but the right image includes more utensils, making it slightly closer to the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the knife with a tong on the plate."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00247/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00247/samples/00007.png | a photo of a napkin and a tong | 34249 | The left image shows a napkin and a spoon placed on a plate, but it does not include a tong as specified in the prompt. The right image includes a napkin, a spoon, and a knife, but it also lacks a tong. Neither image fully aligns with the prompt, but the right image includes more utensils, making it slightly closer to the prompt. | right | Replace the knife with a tong on the plate. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a blue dryer and pink headphones placed side by side, clearly fulfilling the prompt. The right image has a blue dryer and pink headphones, but the headphones are wrapped around the dryer, which is less aligned with the prompt's description of the objects as separate entities.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Separate the headphones from the dryer and place them side by side on a flat surface."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04256/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04256/samples/00004.png | a photo of a blue dryer and a pink headphone | 46830 | The left image shows a blue dryer and pink headphones placed side by side, clearly fulfilling the prompt. The right image has a blue dryer and pink headphones, but the headphones are wrapped around the dryer, which is less aligned with the prompt's description of the objects as separate entities. | left | Separate the headphones from the dryer and place them side by side on a flat surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two barometers with clear and consistent designs, both placed on a wooden surface with a blurred background. The right image also shows two barometers, but one of them includes additional dials and markings, making it less consistent with the prompt of two simple barometers. Additionally, the background in the right image is a wooden surface, which is less visually distinct compared to the blurred background in the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Simplify the design of the barometer with additional dials and markings to match the simpler style of the other barometer."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/01988/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/01988/samples/00008.png | a photo of two barometers | 37198 | The left image shows two barometers with clear and consistent designs, both placed on a wooden surface with a blurred background. The right image also shows two barometers, but one of them includes additional dials and markings, making it less consistent with the prompt of two simple barometers. Additionally, the background in the right image is a wooden surface, which is less visually distinct compared to the blurred background in the left image. | left | Simplify the design of the barometer with additional dials and markings to match the simpler style of the other barometer. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features three wine stoppers with distinct and varied designs, including a mouse-shaped stopper, which adds uniqueness and aligns well with the prompt. The right image also shows three wine stoppers, but they are uniform in design, lacking the variety and distinctiveness seen in the left image. The prompt does not specify uniformity, so the left image better matches the prompt's intent of showcasing three wine stoppers with individuality.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the design of the wine stoppers to make them distinct and varied in shape and style."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01290/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01290/samples/00005.png | a photo of three wine stoppers | 45506 | The left image features three wine stoppers with distinct and varied designs, including a mouse-shaped stopper, which adds uniqueness and aligns well with the prompt. The right image also shows three wine stoppers, but they are uniform in design, lacking the variety and distinctiveness seen in the left image. The prompt does not specify uniformity, so the left image better matches the prompt's intent of showcasing three wine stoppers with individuality. | left | Change the design of the wine stoppers to make them distinct and varied in shape and style. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two clay vases, which aligns with the prompt of 'a photo of two clays.' The right image depicts two clay figurines of children, which does not match the prompt as closely since it focuses on figurines rather than generic clay objects.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the clay figurines with two clay vases of different sizes."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02645/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02645/samples/00007.png | a photo of two clays | 40639 | The left image shows two clay vases, which aligns with the prompt of 'a photo of two clays.' The right image depicts two clay figurines of children, which does not match the prompt as closely since it focuses on figurines rather than generic clay objects. | left | Replace the clay figurines with two clay vases of different sizes. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a pizza cutter placed inside a container along with a bottle, which does not clearly depict the pizza cutter being to the left of a water bottle holder. The right image correctly shows a pizza cutter positioned to the left of a water bottle holder, aligning with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Reposition the pizza cutter to the left of the water bottle holder and remove the bottle from the container."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03278/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03278/samples/00005.png | a photo of a pizza cutter left of a water bottle holder | 34169 | The left image shows a pizza cutter placed inside a container along with a bottle, which does not clearly depict the pizza cutter being to the left of a water bottle holder. The right image correctly shows a pizza cutter positioned to the left of a water bottle holder, aligning with the prompt. | right | Reposition the pizza cutter to the left of the water bottle holder and remove the bottle from the container. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows four push pins with distinct, vibrant colors (red, yellow, blue, and red) arranged on a flat surface, closely matching the prompt. The right image also has four push pins, but the colors are less vibrant and include orange, red, blue, and green, which deviates from the prompt's implied standard colors. Additionally, the pins in the right image are standing upright, which is less typical for a 'photo of push pins' as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the colors of the push pins to red, yellow, blue, and red, and arrange them lying flat on a surface."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02142/samples/00008.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02142/samples/00003.png | a photo of four push pins | 37476 | The left image shows four push pins with distinct, vibrant colors (red, yellow, blue, and red) arranged on a flat surface, closely matching the prompt. The right image also has four push pins, but the colors are less vibrant and include orange, red, blue, and green, which deviates from the prompt's implied standard colors. Additionally, the pins in the right image are standing upright, which is less typical for a 'photo of push pins' as described in the prompt. | left | Change the colors of the push pins to red, yellow, blue, and red, and arrange them lying flat on a surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a fan but lacks a silicone mat, while the right image includes both a fan and a silicone mat, fulfilling the prompt more completely.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a silicone mat next to the fan on the wooden surface."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/01151/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/01151/samples/00002.png | a photo of a fan and a silicone mat | 39294 | The left image shows a fan but lacks a silicone mat, while the right image includes both a fan and a silicone mat, fulfilling the prompt more completely. | right | Add a silicone mat next to the fan on the wooden surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two green plastic compost bins with clear labels, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image depicts two wooden structures resembling small sheds, which do not resemble typical compost bins and deviate from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the wooden shed-like structures with green plastic compost bins similar to those in the other image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01465/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01465/samples/00003.png | a photo of two compost bins | 35316 | The left image shows two green plastic compost bins with clear labels, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image depicts two wooden structures resembling small sheds, which do not resemble typical compost bins and deviate from the prompt. | left | Replace the wooden shed-like structures with green plastic compost bins similar to those in the other image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a white alarm clock, but the left image has a brand name 'Berria' on the clock face, which is unnecessary for the prompt. The right image has a cleaner clock face without any brand name, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove the brand name 'Berria' from the clock face."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03104/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03104/samples/00001.png | a photo of a white alarm clock | 39076 | Both images depict a white alarm clock, but the left image has a brand name 'Berria' on the clock face, which is unnecessary for the prompt. The right image has a cleaner clock face without any brand name, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Remove the brand name 'Berria' from the clock face. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features red goggles with a realistic design and a green watering can, both matching the prompt. The goggles are placed on top of the watering can. The right image also has a green watering can, but the goggles are more stylized and less realistic, resembling toy goggles, which deviates from the prompt's description of 'red goggles.'",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the stylized red goggles with realistic red goggles similar to those in the other image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03891/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03891/samples/00004.png | a photo of a red goggles and a green watering can | 47418 | The left image features red goggles with a realistic design and a green watering can, both matching the prompt. The goggles are placed on top of the watering can. The right image also has a green watering can, but the goggles are more stylized and less realistic, resembling toy goggles, which deviates from the prompt's description of 'red goggles.' | left | Replace the stylized red goggles with realistic red goggles similar to those in the other image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a green canvas with a purple scrubbing brush that has a wooden handle, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image shows a purple scrubbing brush with a plastic handle on a green background, but there is no green canvas present, which is a key element of the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a green canvas as the background and replace the plastic handle of the scrubbing brush with a wooden handle."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04261/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04261/samples/00008.png | a photo of a green canvas and a purple scrubbing brush | 35772 | The left image features a green canvas with a purple scrubbing brush that has a wooden handle, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image shows a purple scrubbing brush with a plastic handle on a green background, but there is no green canvas present, which is a key element of the prompt. | left | Add a green canvas as the background and replace the plastic handle of the scrubbing brush with a wooden handle. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a pink rolling pin and a red marker pen, both matching the prompt. The right image also includes a pink rolling pin and a red marker pen, but the rolling pin has red handles, which deviates from the prompt's description of a pink rolling pin. Additionally, the marker pen in the right image has text and a cap, which is not specified in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the handles of the rolling pin to pink and remove the text and cap from the marker pen."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04530/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04530/samples/00000.png | a photo of a pink rolling pin and a red marker pen | 45451 | The left image features a pink rolling pin and a red marker pen, both matching the prompt. The right image also includes a pink rolling pin and a red marker pen, but the rolling pin has red handles, which deviates from the prompt's description of a pink rolling pin. Additionally, the marker pen in the right image has text and a cap, which is not specified in the prompt. | left | Change the handles of the rolling pin to pink and remove the text and cap from the marker pen. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a close-up of a white whiteboard eraser, which directly matches the prompt. The right image depicts a whiteboard with an eraser placed on its tray, which includes unnecessary context and does not focus solely on the eraser as specified in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Crop the image to focus solely on the whiteboard eraser, removing the whiteboard and its frame."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/02103/samples/00006.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/02103/samples/00007.png | a photo of a white whiteboard eraser | 47814 | The left image shows a close-up of a white whiteboard eraser, which directly matches the prompt. The right image depicts a whiteboard with an eraser placed on its tray, which includes unnecessary context and does not focus solely on the eraser as specified in the prompt. | left | Crop the image to focus solely on the whiteboard eraser, removing the whiteboard and its frame. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a step stool with a button placed on its top, which aligns with the prompt. The right image depicts a circular object resembling a stack of wooden discs, which does not resemble a step stool and lacks a button above it.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the circular object with a wooden step stool and place a button on top of it."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03708/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03708/samples/00000.png | a photo of a button above a step stool | 35096 | The left image shows a step stool with a button placed on its top, which aligns with the prompt. The right image depicts a circular object resembling a stack of wooden discs, which does not resemble a step stool and lacks a button above it. | left | Replace the circular object with a wooden step stool and place a button on top of it. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a yellow pot and a blue hairbrush, both matching the prompt. The right image also has a yellow pot, but the hairbrush is partially blue and has a wooden handle, which deviates from the prompt's specification of a fully blue hairbrush.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the wooden-handled hairbrush with a fully blue hairbrush."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04391/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04391/samples/00008.png | a photo of a yellow pot and a blue hairbrush | 32123 | The left image features a yellow pot and a blue hairbrush, both matching the prompt. The right image also has a yellow pot, but the hairbrush is partially blue and has a wooden handle, which deviates from the prompt's specification of a fully blue hairbrush. | left | Replace the wooden-handled hairbrush with a fully blue hairbrush. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two wallets, one black and one brown, with the brown wallet containing visible cards, which adds context and detail. The right image also shows two wallets, one black and one brown, but they are standing upright and lack the additional detail of visible cards. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it provides a more dynamic and detailed representation of the wallets.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add visible cards partially inserted into the brown wallet to enhance detail and context."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01096/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01096/samples/00003.png | a photo of two wallets | 43398 | The left image shows two wallets, one black and one brown, with the brown wallet containing visible cards, which adds context and detail. The right image also shows two wallets, one black and one brown, but they are standing upright and lack the additional detail of visible cards. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it provides a more dynamic and detailed representation of the wallets. | left | Add visible cards partially inserted into the brown wallet to enhance detail and context. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows white gloves under a ceiling light, which is not a black nightlight as specified in the prompt. The right image features white gloves and a wall-mounted light fixture that resembles a nightlight, but the fixture is not black as required by the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Change the color of the wall-mounted light fixture to black."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03855/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03855/samples/00004.png | a photo of a white gloves and a black nightlight | 44222 | The left image shows white gloves under a ceiling light, which is not a black nightlight as specified in the prompt. The right image features white gloves and a wall-mounted light fixture that resembles a nightlight, but the fixture is not black as required by the prompt. | right | Change the color of the wall-mounted light fixture to black. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a humanoid figure with a yellow monitor as a head and blue pants, which aligns with the prompt. The right image shows a yellow monitor stand with a blue cable attached, but it lacks the blue pants mentioned in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add blue pants to the base of the yellow monitor stand."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04543/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04543/samples/00003.png | a photo of a yellow monitor stand and a blue pant | 46694 | The left image features a humanoid figure with a yellow monitor as a head and blue pants, which aligns with the prompt. The right image shows a yellow monitor stand with a blue cable attached, but it lacks the blue pants mentioned in the prompt. | left | Add blue pants to the base of the yellow monitor stand. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows three storage boxes stacked on top of each other, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, while containing three storage boxes, does not have them stacked and instead displays them side by side, which deviates from the prompt's implied arrangement.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Stack the three storage boxes on top of each other."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02315/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02315/samples/00006.png | a photo of three storage boxs | 38092 | The left image shows three storage boxes stacked on top of each other, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, while containing three storage boxes, does not have them stacked and instead displays them side by side, which deviates from the prompt's implied arrangement. | left | Stack the three storage boxes on top of each other. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows four lunchboxes in different colors, but they are closed and do not display any contents. The right image also features four lunchboxes in different colors, but they are open and display food inside, which aligns better with the prompt of showcasing lunchboxes as they are typically used.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Open the lunchboxes and add food items inside them to showcase their functionality."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02301/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02301/samples/00006.png | a photo of four lunchboxs | 41658 | The left image shows four lunchboxes in different colors, but they are closed and do not display any contents. The right image also features four lunchboxes in different colors, but they are open and display food inside, which aligns better with the prompt of showcasing lunchboxes as they are typically used. | right | Open the lunchboxes and add food items inside them to showcase their functionality. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a glowing orange light with a decorative base, which resembles a lamp rather than a nightlight. The right image depicts a glowing orange light directly mounted on a wall socket, which is more characteristic of a nightlight. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly represents a nightlight.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove the decorative base and make the light appear mounted on a wall socket."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01901/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01901/samples/00005.png | a photo of an orange nightlight | 44688 | The left image shows a glowing orange light with a decorative base, which resembles a lamp rather than a nightlight. The right image depicts a glowing orange light directly mounted on a wall socket, which is more characteristic of a nightlight. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly represents a nightlight. | right | Remove the decorative base and make the light appear mounted on a wall socket. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows an easel with a blank canvas, but it is positioned left of the coffee machine, which does not match the prompt. The right image correctly places the easel to the right of the coffee machine and includes a detailed design on the canvas, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Move the easel to the right of the coffee machine."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03497/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03497/samples/00003.png | a photo of an easel right of a coffee machine | 47769 | The left image shows an easel with a blank canvas, but it is positioned left of the coffee machine, which does not match the prompt. The right image correctly places the easel to the right of the coffee machine and includes a detailed design on the canvas, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Move the easel to the right of the coffee machine. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a red calendar with a fully red background and red pages, aligning well with the prompt. The right image has a red calendar but includes a white section for the dates, which deviates from the prompt's emphasis on a red calendar.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the white section of the calendar to red to match the rest of the calendar's color."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04015/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04015/samples/00000.png | a photo of a red calendar | 38121 | The left image shows a red calendar with a fully red background and red pages, aligning well with the prompt. The right image has a red calendar but includes a white section for the dates, which deviates from the prompt's emphasis on a red calendar. | left | Change the white section of the calendar to red to match the rest of the calendar's color. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a realistic tent with a yellow fabric cover and a blue sticky tape dispenser, both clearly identifiable and distinct. The right image, while creative, uses a sticky tape dispenser as part of the tent structure, making it less clear and deviating from the prompt's requirement of a separate tent and sticky tape dispenser.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Separate the sticky tape dispenser from the tent structure and add a distinct, realistic tent next to it."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/00873/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/00873/samples/00001.png | a photo of a tent and a sticky tape dispenser | 40328 | The left image features a realistic tent with a yellow fabric cover and a blue sticky tape dispenser, both clearly identifiable and distinct. The right image, while creative, uses a sticky tape dispenser as part of the tent structure, making it less clear and deviating from the prompt's requirement of a separate tent and sticky tape dispenser. | left | Separate the sticky tape dispenser from the tent structure and add a distinct, realistic tent next to it. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a single needle above a stack of three towels, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image, however, shows two needles instead of one and only two towels, deviating from the prompt's specification of a single needle above a towel.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove one of the needles and add an additional towel to create a stack of three."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03376/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03376/samples/00004.png | a photo of a needle above a towel | 45926 | The left image features a single needle above a stack of three towels, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image, however, shows two needles instead of one and only two towels, deviating from the prompt's specification of a single needle above a towel. | left | Remove one of the needles and add an additional towel to create a stack of three. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a stack of brown dish towels with a smooth texture, matching the prompt. The right image depicts a single towel with a bright orange color and a textured surface, which does not align with the prompt for a brown dish towel.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the color of the towel to brown and remove the textured surface to make it smooth."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03775/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03775/samples/00002.png | a photo of a brown dish towel | 41579 | The left image shows a stack of brown dish towels with a smooth texture, matching the prompt. The right image depicts a single towel with a bright orange color and a textured surface, which does not align with the prompt for a brown dish towel. | left | Change the color of the towel to brown and remove the textured surface to make it smooth. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a metallic fan-like object on a textured surface, but it lacks a clear button. The right image features a fan with detailed designs and a button, both clearly visible and distinct, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a clear button next to the metallic fan-like object."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00326/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00326/samples/00001.png | a photo of a fan and a button | 34595 | The left image shows a metallic fan-like object on a textured surface, but it lacks a clear button. The right image features a fan with detailed designs and a button, both clearly visible and distinct, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Add a clear button next to the metallic fan-like object. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a yellow charger with a red thread-like element attached to one of its prongs, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image, while featuring a yellow charger and a red thread-like base, has an additional red suction cup and a more complex design that deviates from the simplicity of the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Simplify the design by removing the red suction cup and making the red thread-like element attach to the charger in a straightforward manner."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04822/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04822/samples/00009.png | a photo of a yellow charger and a red thread | 33867 | The left image shows a yellow charger with a red thread-like element attached to one of its prongs, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image, while featuring a yellow charger and a red thread-like base, has an additional red suction cup and a more complex design that deviates from the simplicity of the prompt. | left | Simplify the design by removing the red suction cup and making the red thread-like element attach to the charger in a straightforward manner. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a purple battery and a pink iron. However, in the left image, the iron is shown from the back, obscuring its functional details, while in the right image, the iron is displayed from the front, clearly showing its design and features. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it provides a clearer view of the pink iron.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Rotate the iron to display its front side with visible functional details."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04779/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04779/samples/00009.png | a photo of a purple battery and a pink iron | 32846 | Both images feature a purple battery and a pink iron. However, in the left image, the iron is shown from the back, obscuring its functional details, while in the right image, the iron is displayed from the front, clearly showing its design and features. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it provides a clearer view of the pink iron. | right | Rotate the iron to display its front side with visible functional details. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature an orange horse and a wine glass. However, the wine glass in both images is not brown as specified in the prompt. The left image has a more realistic background and lighting, while the right image has a wooden surface. Both images fail to meet the prompt's requirement for a brown wine glass, but the left image has a slightly better composition overall.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the color of the wine glass to brown."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval1/03704/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval1/03704/samples/00006.png | a photo of a brown wine glass and an orange horse | 47991 | Both images feature an orange horse and a wine glass. However, the wine glass in both images is not brown as specified in the prompt. The left image has a more realistic background and lighting, while the right image has a wooden surface. Both images fail to meet the prompt's requirement for a brown wine glass, but the left image has a slightly better composition overall. | left | Change the color of the wine glass to brown. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a single orange cleaning cloth clearly, which aligns with the prompt. The right image includes an orange cleaning cloth but also features an additional object, a spray bottle, which is unnecessary and deviates from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the spray bottle from the image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/02628/samples/00005.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/02628/samples/00009.png | a photo of an orange cleaning cloth | 47727 | The left image shows a single orange cleaning cloth clearly, which aligns with the prompt. The right image includes an orange cleaning cloth but also features an additional object, a spray bottle, which is unnecessary and deviates from the prompt. | left | Remove the spray bottle from the image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes both a screwdriver and a casserole dish, fulfilling the prompt. The right image only shows a casserole dish being handled with a serving utensil, but no screwdriver is present.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a screwdriver next to the casserole dish on the table."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/00047/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/00047/samples/00000.png | a photo of a screwdriver and a casserole dish | 41453 | The left image includes both a screwdriver and a casserole dish, fulfilling the prompt. The right image only shows a casserole dish being handled with a serving utensil, but no screwdriver is present. | left | Add a screwdriver next to the casserole dish on the table. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a whiteboard eraser but does not include a tong, which is a key element of the prompt. The right image includes a tong being held and used on a whiteboard but does not show a whiteboard eraser.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a whiteboard eraser next to the tong on the whiteboard surface."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00032/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00032/samples/00004.png | a photo of a whiteboard eraser and a tong | 35681 | The left image shows a whiteboard eraser but does not include a tong, which is a key element of the prompt. The right image includes a tong being held and used on a whiteboard but does not show a whiteboard eraser. | right | Add a whiteboard eraser next to the tong on the whiteboard surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a circular object resembling a decorative button but lacks a fan. The right image includes both a fan and a button, fulfilling the prompt more accurately.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a fan next to the circular object to match the prompt."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00326/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/00326/samples/00004.png | a photo of a fan and a button | 34584 | The left image shows a circular object resembling a decorative button but lacks a fan. The right image includes both a fan and a button, fulfilling the prompt more accurately. | right | Add a fan next to the circular object to match the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a whiteboard eraser but does not include a tong, which is required by the prompt. The right image shows a hand holding a tong-like object interacting with a small eraser, but the eraser is not clearly a whiteboard eraser, and the tong is not clearly visible as a standalone object.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Make the eraser in the image clearly resemble a whiteboard eraser and ensure the tong is fully visible and distinct from the hand."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/00232/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/00232/samples/00007.png | a photo of a whiteboard eraser and a tong | 37255 | The left image shows a whiteboard eraser but does not include a tong, which is required by the prompt. The right image shows a hand holding a tong-like object interacting with a small eraser, but the eraser is not clearly a whiteboard eraser, and the tong is not clearly visible as a standalone object. | right | Make the eraser in the image clearly resemble a whiteboard eraser and ensure the tong is fully visible and distinct from the hand. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a water bottle placed to the left of a microphone, but it is not a water bottle holder. The right image features a microphone with a built-in water bottle holder, but the holder is not positioned to the left of the microphone as specified in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the water bottle with a water bottle holder to the left of the microphone."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03184/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/03184/samples/00008.png | a photo of a water bottle holder left of a microphone | 42073 | The left image shows a water bottle placed to the left of a microphone, but it is not a water bottle holder. The right image features a microphone with a built-in water bottle holder, but the holder is not positioned to the left of the microphone as specified in the prompt. | left | Replace the water bottle with a water bottle holder to the left of the microphone. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a black electric blanket and a red matchbox with the lid open, revealing matches and a black fabric inside. The right image also shows a black electric blanket and a red matchbox, but the matchbox is open without a lid and contains only matches. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a more complete depiction of the matchbox with its lid and additional details.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a lid to the red matchbox and include a piece of black fabric inside it."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04607/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04607/samples/00009.png | a photo of a black electric blanket and a red matchbox | 33791 | The left image features a black electric blanket and a red matchbox with the lid open, revealing matches and a black fabric inside. The right image also shows a black electric blanket and a red matchbox, but the matchbox is open without a lid and contains only matches. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a more complete depiction of the matchbox with its lid and additional details. | left | Add a lid to the red matchbox and include a piece of black fabric inside it. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two buttons with a metallic, aged appearance, while the right image depicts two buttons with a polished, wooden and plastic-like texture. The prompt specifies 'a photo of two buttons,' and both images meet this requirement. However, the left image has a more realistic and detailed representation of buttons, including texture and lighting, which aligns better with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a metallic, aged texture to the buttons and adjust the lighting to create a more realistic appearance."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01421/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01421/samples/00008.png | a photo of two buttons | 43515 | The left image shows two buttons with a metallic, aged appearance, while the right image depicts two buttons with a polished, wooden and plastic-like texture. The prompt specifies 'a photo of two buttons,' and both images meet this requirement. However, the left image has a more realistic and detailed representation of buttons, including texture and lighting, which aligns better with the prompt. | left | Add a metallic, aged texture to the buttons and adjust the lighting to create a more realistic appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a close-up of a yellow flashlight mounted on a bike, with the flashlight clearly visible and glowing. The right image shows a bike with a yellow flashlight, but the flashlight is less prominent and partially obscured by its housing, making it less clear and less aligned with the prompt's focus on the flashlight.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the flashlight more prominent and clearly visible by reducing the housing around it and increasing its glow."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03888/samples/00008.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03888/samples/00002.png | a photo of a yellow flashlight (bike) | 38494 | The left image shows a close-up of a yellow flashlight mounted on a bike, with the flashlight clearly visible and glowing. The right image shows a bike with a yellow flashlight, but the flashlight is less prominent and partially obscured by its housing, making it less clear and less aligned with the prompt's focus on the flashlight. | left | Make the flashlight more prominent and clearly visible by reducing the housing around it and increasing its glow. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two toolboxes stacked on top of each other, with a clear and clean presentation. The right image depicts two toolboxes, but they are open, revealing their interiors, and the setting is more rustic and less focused on the toolboxes themselves. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it emphasizes the toolboxes in a straightforward manner.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Close the toolboxes and stack them neatly on top of each other in a clean setting."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02633/samples/00008.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02633/samples/00000.png | a photo of two toolboxs | 37802 | The left image shows two toolboxes stacked on top of each other, with a clear and clean presentation. The right image depicts two toolboxes, but they are open, revealing their interiors, and the setting is more rustic and less focused on the toolboxes themselves. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it emphasizes the toolboxes in a straightforward manner. | left | Close the toolboxes and stack them neatly on top of each other in a clean setting. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features blue socks and pink varnish, aligning well with the prompt. The right image shows blue and pink socks but does not clearly display pink varnish, which is a key element of the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add pink varnish to the toenails of the feet wearing the socks."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04479/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04479/samples/00007.png | a photo of a pink varnish and a blue socks | 44490 | The left image features blue socks and pink varnish, aligning well with the prompt. The right image shows blue and pink socks but does not clearly display pink varnish, which is a key element of the prompt. | left | Add pink varnish to the toenails of the feet wearing the socks. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a yellow shovel and a red curtain, but the left image has a more realistic and proportional shovel design with a proper handle, while the right image has an elongated and less realistic shovel handle. The red curtain in both images is similar, but the left image better aligns with the prompt due to the more accurate depiction of the shovel.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the shovel handle to be shorter and more proportional, resembling a realistic design."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04600/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04600/samples/00003.png | a photo of a yellow shovel and a red curtain | 41973 | Both images feature a yellow shovel and a red curtain, but the left image has a more realistic and proportional shovel design with a proper handle, while the right image has an elongated and less realistic shovel handle. The red curtain in both images is similar, but the left image better aligns with the prompt due to the more accurate depiction of the shovel. | left | Adjust the shovel handle to be shorter and more proportional, resembling a realistic design. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features two carafes with distinct colors and a visually appealing setting, but the carafes are not uniform in design. The right image shows two carafes that are identical in shape and design, which better aligns with the prompt of 'a photo of two carafes' as it emphasizes the carafes themselves without distractions.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Make the two carafes identical in shape and design."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01354/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01354/samples/00007.png | a photo of two carafes | 35079 | The left image features two carafes with distinct colors and a visually appealing setting, but the carafes are not uniform in design. The right image shows two carafes that are identical in shape and design, which better aligns with the prompt of 'a photo of two carafes' as it emphasizes the carafes themselves without distractions. | right | Make the two carafes identical in shape and design. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows four humidifiers of varying designs and colors, all emitting visible steam, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image only displays three humidifiers clearly, with a fourth one partially visible and cut off, making it less aligned with the prompt of showing four humidifiers.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a fourth fully visible humidifier to the scene, ensuring it matches the style and placement of the existing humidifiers."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02663/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02663/samples/00009.png | a photo of four humidifiers | 37620 | The left image shows four humidifiers of varying designs and colors, all emitting visible steam, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image only displays three humidifiers clearly, with a fourth one partially visible and cut off, making it less aligned with the prompt of showing four humidifiers. | left | Add a fourth fully visible humidifier to the scene, ensuring it matches the style and placement of the existing humidifiers. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt as it shows four parchment papers with a more natural and realistic texture, including uneven, torn edges that are characteristic of parchment. The right image, while also showing four parchment papers, has smoother and less realistic edges, making it less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add more realistic, uneven, and torn edges to the parchment papers to enhance their authenticity."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02459/samples/00005.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02459/samples/00004.png | a photo of four parchment papers | 39883 | The left image better matches the prompt as it shows four parchment papers with a more natural and realistic texture, including uneven, torn edges that are characteristic of parchment. The right image, while also showing four parchment papers, has smoother and less realistic edges, making it less aligned with the prompt. | left | Add more realistic, uneven, and torn edges to the parchment papers to enhance their authenticity. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a green garden fork integrated with a spray nozzle and a yellow cleaning cloth, which aligns with the prompt's mention of a yellow carpet cleaner and a green garden fork. The right image only shows a green fork on a yellow background, missing the yellow carpet cleaner element entirely.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a yellow carpet cleaner next to the green garden fork."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04813/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04813/samples/00002.png | a photo of a yellow carpet cleaner and a green garden fork | 45856 | The left image features a green garden fork integrated with a spray nozzle and a yellow cleaning cloth, which aligns with the prompt's mention of a yellow carpet cleaner and a green garden fork. The right image only shows a green fork on a yellow background, missing the yellow carpet cleaner element entirely. | left | Add a yellow carpet cleaner next to the green garden fork. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows exactly three seedlings, which aligns with the prompt. The right image contains four seedlings, which does not match the specified number in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove one seedling to leave only three seedlings in the image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01210/samples/00002.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01210/samples/00007.png | a photo of three seedlingses | 46511 | The left image shows exactly three seedlings, which aligns with the prompt. The right image contains four seedlings, which does not match the specified number in the prompt. | left | Remove one seedling to leave only three seedlings in the image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a pink garden fork that matches the prompt, while the right image shows a metallic fork that is not pink and does not resemble a garden fork. The left image aligns better with the prompt as it accurately depicts a pink garden fork.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the metallic fork to a pink garden fork."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03414/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03414/samples/00002.png | a photo of a pink garden fork | 40238 | The left image features a pink garden fork that matches the prompt, while the right image shows a metallic fork that is not pink and does not resemble a garden fork. The left image aligns better with the prompt as it accurately depicts a pink garden fork. | left | Change the metallic fork to a pink garden fork. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a green bandage and a brown charger, but the left image has a more compact and neatly rolled bandage, while the right image has a taller and slightly unevenly rolled bandage. The left image also has a consistent green background that complements the objects, whereas the right image has a two-tone background that distracts from the focus on the objects.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the bandage more compact and neatly rolled, and change the background to a consistent green color."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04878/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04878/samples/00001.png | a photo of a green bandage and a brown charger | 45640 | Both images feature a green bandage and a brown charger, but the left image has a more compact and neatly rolled bandage, while the right image has a taller and slightly unevenly rolled bandage. The left image also has a consistent green background that complements the objects, whereas the right image has a two-tone background that distracts from the focus on the objects. | left | Make the bandage more compact and neatly rolled, and change the background to a consistent green color. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a paintbrush cleaner bottle with a paintbrush lying nearby, but there is no thermos present. The right image includes a thermos and a paintbrush, but the paintbrush cleaner is missing, and the paintbrush is placed in front of the thermos rather than to its left. Additionally, there is spilled paint in the right image, which is unnecessary for the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a thermos to the right of the paintbrush cleaner."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04504/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04504/samples/00009.png | a photo of a paintbrush cleaner left of a thermos | 39557 | The left image shows a paintbrush cleaner bottle with a paintbrush lying nearby, but there is no thermos present. The right image includes a thermos and a paintbrush, but the paintbrush cleaner is missing, and the paintbrush is placed in front of the thermos rather than to its left. Additionally, there is spilled paint in the right image, which is unnecessary for the prompt. | left | Add a thermos to the right of the paintbrush cleaner. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows four electric kettles, each distinct in design, color, and style, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image, however, features four identical electric kettles in a kitchen setting, which lacks the variety implied by the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the identical kettles with four distinct electric kettles of varying designs and colors."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/01979/samples/00001.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/01979/samples/00007.png | a photo of four electric kettles | 40050 | The left image shows four electric kettles, each distinct in design, color, and style, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image, however, features four identical electric kettles in a kitchen setting, which lacks the variety implied by the prompt. | left | Replace the identical kettles with four distinct electric kettles of varying designs and colors. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a single yellow sticky note above a bottle resembling paint thinner, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image has multiple sticky notes in different colors and a can of paint thinner, deviating from the prompt's specification of a single sticky note above a paint thinner.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove all sticky notes except one yellow note and position it directly above the paint thinner can."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04841/samples/00005.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04841/samples/00009.png | a photo of a sticky notes above a paint thinner | 40860 | The left image shows a single yellow sticky note above a bottle resembling paint thinner, which aligns well with the prompt. The right image has multiple sticky notes in different colors and a can of paint thinner, deviating from the prompt's specification of a single sticky note above a paint thinner. | left | Remove all sticky notes except one yellow note and position it directly above the paint thinner can. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows an adjustable wrench positioned above a plastic container, aligning well with the prompt. The right image has the adjustable wrench resting inside the plastic container, which does not match the prompt's requirement of the wrench being above the container.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Position the adjustable wrench above the plastic container instead of inside it."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04810/samples/00004.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/04810/samples/00009.png | a photo of an adjustable wrench above a plastic container | 40263 | The left image shows an adjustable wrench positioned above a plastic container, aligning well with the prompt. The right image has the adjustable wrench resting inside the plastic container, which does not match the prompt's requirement of the wrench being above the container. | left | Position the adjustable wrench above the plastic container instead of inside it. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two identical webcams, which aligns well with the prompt of 'a photo of two webcams.' The right image, however, features two different webcams, which does not fully match the prompt's implication of similarity between the two webcams.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the mismatched webcam on the left side with a webcam identical to the one on the right side."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02705/samples/00000.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02705/samples/00005.png | a photo of two webcams | 40641 | The left image shows two identical webcams, which aligns well with the prompt of 'a photo of two webcams.' The right image, however, features two different webcams, which does not fully match the prompt's implication of similarity between the two webcams. | left | Replace the mismatched webcam on the left side with a webcam identical to the one on the right side. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a blue compass and an orange tureen, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, while including a blue compass, has an orange pumpkin instead of an orange tureen, which does not match the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the orange pumpkin with an orange tureen."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03815/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/03815/samples/00000.png | a photo of a blue compass and an orange tureen | 45493 | The left image features a blue compass and an orange tureen, which aligns with the prompt. The right image, while including a blue compass, has an orange pumpkin instead of an orange tureen, which does not match the prompt. | left | Replace the orange pumpkin with an orange tureen. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features three mops with distinct and vibrant colors (green, red, and white), which makes them visually distinct and aligns well with the prompt. The right image also has three mops, but their colors are more muted and similar (beige, off-white, and brown), making them less visually distinct and less aligned with the prompt's emphasis on three mops being clearly identifiable.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the colors of the mops to vibrant and distinct shades such as green, red, and white."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02083/samples/00009.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/02083/samples/00000.png | a photo of three mops | 41588 | The left image features three mops with distinct and vibrant colors (green, red, and white), which makes them visually distinct and aligns well with the prompt. The right image also has three mops, but their colors are more muted and similar (beige, off-white, and brown), making them less visually distinct and less aligned with the prompt's emphasis on three mops being clearly identifiable. | left | Change the colors of the mops to vibrant and distinct shades such as green, red, and white. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows four rolling pins that are uniform in size, shape, and material, aligning well with the prompt. The right image contains five rolling pins, one of which has a textured surface, deviating from the prompt's specification of four rolling pins and uniformity.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the fifth rolling pin and the textured rolling pin to leave four uniform rolling pins."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01201/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/01201/samples/00008.png | a photo of four rolling pins | 43370 | The left image shows four rolling pins that are uniform in size, shape, and material, aligning well with the prompt. The right image contains five rolling pins, one of which has a textured surface, deviating from the prompt's specification of four rolling pins and uniformity. | left | Remove the fifth rolling pin and the textured rolling pin to leave four uniform rolling pins. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a white colored pencil and a purple shovel clearly, with the shovel having a proper handle and blade. The right image has a white pencil and a purple shovel, but the shovel's handle is missing, making it incomplete and less accurate to the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a proper handle to the purple shovel to make it complete."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04029/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04029/samples/00009.png | a photo of a white colored pencil and a purple shovel | 44332 | The left image shows a white colored pencil and a purple shovel clearly, with the shovel having a proper handle and blade. The right image has a white pencil and a purple shovel, but the shovel's handle is missing, making it incomplete and less accurate to the prompt. | left | Add a proper handle to the purple shovel to make it complete. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a single brown compass on black fabric, aligning with the prompt. The right image includes two compasses, which deviates from the prompt's specification of a single brown compass and introduces unnecessary elements.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the additional compass to leave only one brown compass on the black fabric."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04561/samples/00003.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04561/samples/00004.png | a photo of a brown compass and a black fabric softener | 45833 | The left image features a single brown compass on black fabric, aligning with the prompt. The right image includes two compasses, which deviates from the prompt's specification of a single brown compass and introduces unnecessary elements. | left | Remove the additional compass to leave only one brown compass on the black fabric. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a close-up of an orange tool with a spring mechanism, but it does not clearly depict a bolt cutter. The right image, however, shows a part of an orange tool with a cutting blade, which is more indicative of a bolt cutter. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a key feature of a bolt cutter.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a cutting blade mechanism to the tool to make it resemble a bolt cutter."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03788/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval3/03788/samples/00001.png | a photo of an orange bolt cutter | 39000 | The left image shows a close-up of an orange tool with a spring mechanism, but it does not clearly depict a bolt cutter. The right image, however, shows a part of an orange tool with a cutting blade, which is more indicative of a bolt cutter. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a key feature of a bolt cutter. | right | Add a cutting blade mechanism to the tool to make it resemble a bolt cutter. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a yellow whisk and a white needle. The left image shows the objects upright with a dark background, while the right image displays them lying flat on a light background. The prompt does not specify orientation or background, so both are acceptable. However, the needle in the left image has a more realistic and detailed design, while the needle in the right image appears less precise.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the design of the needle to make it more detailed and realistic, similar to the one in the other image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04794/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval5/04794/samples/00005.png | a photo of a yellow whisk and a white needle | 45535 | Both images depict a yellow whisk and a white needle. The left image shows the objects upright with a dark background, while the right image displays them lying flat on a light background. The prompt does not specify orientation or background, so both are acceptable. However, the needle in the left image has a more realistic and detailed design, while the needle in the right image appears less precise. | left | Enhance the design of the needle to make it more detailed and realistic, similar to the one in the other image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows a single red sock and a blue screwdriver with a transparent handle, which matches the prompt. The right image has two red socks and a blue screwdriver with a solid handle, which deviates from the prompt by including an extra sock and altering the screwdriver's handle design.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove one red sock and change the screwdriver handle to a transparent blue design."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04708/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/04708/samples/00009.png | a photo of a red socks and a blue screwdriver | 35303 | The left image shows a single red sock and a blue screwdriver with a transparent handle, which matches the prompt. The right image has two red socks and a blue screwdriver with a solid handle, which deviates from the prompt by including an extra sock and altering the screwdriver's handle design. | left | Remove one red sock and change the screwdriver handle to a transparent blue design. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows two tweezers clearly, with distinct shapes and proper focus. The right image, however, includes three tweezers instead of two, which does not align with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the third tweezer from the image."
}
``` | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01481/samples/00007.png | /mnt/petrelfs/gaopeng/zl/data/reflection/geneval_samples/geneval4/01481/samples/00002.png | a photo of two tweezers | 34223 | The left image shows two tweezers clearly, with distinct shapes and proper focus. The right image, however, includes three tweezers instead of two, which does not align with the prompt. | left | Remove the third tweezer from the image. |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
No dataset card yet
- Downloads last month
- 25