janaab/supreme-court-speech · Datasets at Hugging Face

audio audioduration (s) 0.08 19.9	transcript stringlengths 1 414	duration float64 0.08 19.9
	yes my lords go back to the list of dates	2.36
	sibal would have ten matters	1.96
	whereas it goes into the question of establish and administer it ignores the purpose altogether	8.259938
	i mean it has no bearing on what your argument	3.44
	i will come back to the passage but it's part of the same judgment so i emphasize it	5.3
	five hundred and forty nine	2.7
	my lords actually again convoluted in its expression	3.88
	sharma whatever has been placed by you before us in compliance with the judgment we will direct that to be open right now	6.879938
	therefore there would be a dichotomy if your submission is correct	4.639938
	now since orissa is not going for the whole of the mineral value is saying that x not more than twenty percent of half of the mineral value	10.02
	see i three i	1.72
	it is not open for instance for the court to say that though this community is designated as a scheduled caste another community is part of the designated community	8.879938
	it could be just anything without meaning to be exhaustive about it	4.8
	i'll tell your lordship the problem in that in that area	2.92
	now second line of defence	2.18
	my lord we will argue the coelho point before a smaller bench once your lordship takes a view on thirty nine there's no problem with that	6.72
	i was on fourteenth	6.98
	the speaker's role in this regard is really administrative in nature the speaker cannot abuse his role to defeat the spirit and intent behind the provisions of the tenth schedule	10.1
	so mineral would have fallen there and states have been recovering under sales tax act and it's the sale price	9.379938
	as long as it remains an unstamped instrument it cannot be taken notice of for any purpose as contemplated in section thirty five of the stamp act	8.12
	i accordingly approach the dominions of india and pakistan and entered into a standstill agreement with my state	6.339938
	existence is by the court	2.04
	the arbitration must be fast tracked as much as possible	2.56
	the accession of j and k state was limited only to the areas of defence external affairs and communication	5.88
	justice untwalia in this judgment observed that we do not consider necessary to express any opinion with reference to article thirty one c read with clause b and c of article thirty nine of the constitution	11.88
	it is beda jangam	0.799938
	otherwise it would have been challenged as an executive act	3.04
	it couldn't have	1.86
	no no i'm not	1.16
	of spirits	0.88
	violation of the whip and giving up voluntarily giving up membership	4.839938
	for two reasons we hold that such bars of limitations are uncalled for impermissible	5.5
	so my submission is because of section five read with section eleven a the judicial intervention so it contemplates that the court notices there is a flaw there is a defect	12.099938
	the purpose was just the opposite	2.6
	you need not have a contract where both signed the bottom	2.799938
	there's no need to produce the original or certified copy	3.32
	similarly three hundred a is also not protected	2.72
	the abrogation of article three hundred and seventy was effected secretly unilaterally and coercively	6.08
	references	1.78
	now what is to be taken into account my lord	2.92
	in punjab we brought out an act in two thousand six where out of the posts which were reserved for the scheduled castes fifty percent of the posts were reserved for balmikis and mazhabis	15.139938
	states do not have any say in fixing royalty	2.6
	therefore a more special treatment among the special	3.46
	okay	1.04
	that is the constituent assembly of the j and k	3.32
	so we go to twenty three fifth of march nineteen forty eight	4.039938
	why would the constitution framers use this word 'deem'	4.58
	sibal we will have to have structured arguments	2.08
	in one case it goes to dmf other case to nmet	5.14
	now my lord	1.92
	the shiv sena legislative party in its meeting took note of shri eknath shinde and the rebel mla's and the fact that they had indulged in antiparty activities and were trying to destabilize the mva government	12.359938
	please come to para one hundred and three	2.5
	we say no it is all inclusive	2.04
	but one passage from puttaswamy	3.299938
	and you are not relying on that affidavit because in that sense	2.64
	having heard the council's at length we are of the opinion that the views expressed in sanjeev coke case requires reconsideration keeping in view the importance of the point and issue	9.16
	dwivedi begins with the timelines which have been indicated by the respondents are a little ambitious	8.2
	and i'm just trying to satisfy your lordship's conscience about the positive approach with which my lord we approach this problem	8.159938
	the first in 'eighty one and the second in twenty nineteen	4.32
	section three to five and sixteen	2.64
	five thousand bonds you have been able to collate	2.2
	your lordships will see it at a 'the words 'establish and administer' must be read conjunctively	7.4
	yes	0.4
	but what coelho did was to make a very clear statement on what is included in the basic structure as far as these three rights are concerned fourteen nineteen and twenty one	13.7
	dated twenty second	1.72
	double sixty of nineteen ninety eight	3.7
	my lord to begin with just to give a little summary of what are the issues and what is under challenge	7.039938
	i'll take my lords straight to page fifteen because the first part sets out the nature of the controversy how the reference was made	8.359938
	learned attorney will take about half an hour after your turn	3.4
	then please see b government of andhra pradesh	5.64
	lochner was declared not to be good law	6.399938
	something which is pending for fourteen years there's no timeline	2.8
	the power to impose rates is exclusively assigned to the state except in respect of the excluded entry	6.76
	this a well settled principle that law should not be unsettled merely on the ground that an alternative view appears to be more reasonable	8.02
	for a lawful consideration lawful object that takes us to section twenty three	6.34
	no no you please whatever it is	2.5
	an mla is constitutionally made part of that electoral college	6.039938
	in the process of separating ethyl alcohol from the fermented wash and in this process various components of the mixture are separated by virtue of their difference in boiling points	11.679938
	your lordships can hear them in chamber	2.68
	and the last one and the d point is that our constitution makers took the different provision of the constitution from the birth democracies according to indian perspective	12.319938
	sbi must disclose details of each electoral bond encashed by the political party which will include data of encashment and denomination of encashment of each bond	9.159938
	having given due consideration we are of the opinion that this interpretation of article thirty nine b requires to be reconsidered by a bench of nine learned judges	9.92
	now taking a cue from the example of bauxite have you not boxed in this tape so far as exercise of their power under fifty entry fifty list ii	12.599938
	'it is submitted that a ' your lordships have para one hundred and sixty five	4.52
	in nabam rebia you did it	1.64
	for the moment this distinction which i am pointing out has relevance to understanding the limit of limitation in entry fifty	13.22
	accordingly the five judges in i	1.88
	statute merely makes it inadmissible in evidence	2.52
	volume one	1.04
	judgment of the chief justice thakur	2.2
	it is contextualized in the first part as well as second part when they use that in respect of a vote and what is said and in respect of what is published	12.159938
	the chief minister will go	1.94
	page thirty nine	2.02
	but can somebody else say why are you giving it to him and not to others a person who is not eligible for it so this is just the slight thing	10.079938
	no that can't be	1.36
	now my lord the first submission i'm making is if your lordship sees section eleven six a of the act	10.58
	supreme court's order	1.4
	but at the same time on the reference to these very acts it is difficult to hold that they deal exclusively with beverages and are not applicable to certain articles which are strictly speaking not beverages	14.42
	yes mr	1.94
	and thereafter once the maharashtra rent act has come in then another five percent provisions are there	6

yes my lords go back to the list of dates

2.36

sibal would have ten matters

1.96

whereas it goes into the question of establish and administer it ignores the purpose altogether

8.259938

i mean it has no bearing on what your argument

3.44

i will come back to the passage but it's part of the same judgment so i emphasize it

5.3

five hundred and forty nine

2.7

my lords actually again convoluted in its expression

3.88

sharma whatever has been placed by you before us in compliance with the judgment we will direct that to be open right now

6.879938

therefore there would be a dichotomy if your submission is correct

4.639938

now since orissa is not going for the whole of the mineral value is saying that x not more than twenty percent of half of the mineral value

10.02

see i three i

1.72

it is not open for instance for the court to say that though this community is designated as a scheduled caste another community is part of the designated community

8.879938

it could be just anything without meaning to be exhaustive about it

4.8

i'll tell your lordship the problem in that in that area

2.92

now second line of defence

2.18

my lord we will argue the coelho point before a smaller bench once your lordship takes a view on thirty nine there's no problem with that

6.72

i was on fourteenth

6.98

the speaker's role in this regard is really administrative in nature the speaker cannot abuse his role to defeat the spirit and intent behind the provisions of the tenth schedule

10.1

so mineral would have fallen there and states have been recovering under sales tax act and it's the sale price

9.379938

as long as it remains an unstamped instrument it cannot be taken notice of for any purpose as contemplated in section thirty five of the stamp act

8.12

i accordingly approach the dominions of india and pakistan and entered into a standstill agreement with my state

6.339938

existence is by the court

2.04

the arbitration must be fast tracked as much as possible

2.56

the accession of j and k state was limited only to the areas of defence external affairs and communication

5.88

justice untwalia in this judgment observed that we do not consider necessary to express any opinion with reference to article thirty one c read with clause b and c of article thirty nine of the constitution

11.88

it is beda jangam

0.799938

otherwise it would have been challenged as an executive act

3.04

it couldn't have

1.86

no no i'm not

1.16

of spirits

0.88

violation of the whip and giving up voluntarily giving up membership

4.839938

for two reasons we hold that such bars of limitations are uncalled for impermissible

5.5

so my submission is because of section five read with section eleven a the judicial intervention so it contemplates that the court notices there is a flaw there is a defect

12.099938

the purpose was just the opposite

2.6

you need not have a contract where both signed the bottom

2.799938

there's no need to produce the original or certified copy

3.32

similarly three hundred a is also not protected

2.72

the abrogation of article three hundred and seventy was effected secretly unilaterally and coercively

6.08

references

1.78

now what is to be taken into account my lord

2.92

in punjab we brought out an act in two thousand six where out of the posts which were reserved for the scheduled castes fifty percent of the posts were reserved for balmikis and mazhabis

15.139938

states do not have any say in fixing royalty

2.6

therefore a more special treatment among the special

3.46

okay

1.04

that is the constituent assembly of the j and k

3.32

so we go to twenty three fifth of march nineteen forty eight

4.039938

why would the constitution framers use this word 'deem'

4.58

sibal we will have to have structured arguments

2.08

in one case it goes to dmf other case to nmet

5.14

now my lord

1.92

the shiv sena legislative party in its meeting took note of shri eknath shinde and the rebel mla's and the fact that they had indulged in antiparty activities and were trying to destabilize the mva government

12.359938

please come to para one hundred and three

2.5

we say no it is all inclusive

2.04

but one passage from puttaswamy

3.299938

and you are not relying on that affidavit because in that sense

2.64

having heard the council's at length we are of the opinion that the views expressed in sanjeev coke case requires reconsideration keeping in view the importance of the point and issue

9.16

dwivedi begins with the timelines which have been indicated by the respondents are a little ambitious

8.2

and i'm just trying to satisfy your lordship's conscience about the positive approach with which my lord we approach this problem

8.159938

the first in 'eighty one and the second in twenty nineteen

4.32

section three to five and sixteen

2.64

five thousand bonds you have been able to collate

2.2

your lordships will see it at a 'the words 'establish and administer' must be read conjunctively

7.4

yes

0.4

but what coelho did was to make a very clear statement on what is included in the basic structure as far as these three rights are concerned fourteen nineteen and twenty one

13.7

dated twenty second

1.72

double sixty of nineteen ninety eight

3.7

my lord to begin with just to give a little summary of what are the issues and what is under challenge

7.039938

i'll take my lords straight to page fifteen because the first part sets out the nature of the controversy how the reference was made

8.359938

learned attorney will take about half an hour after your turn

3.4

then please see b government of andhra pradesh

5.64

lochner was declared not to be good law

6.399938

something which is pending for fourteen years there's no timeline

2.8

the power to impose rates is exclusively assigned to the state except in respect of the excluded entry

6.76

this a well settled principle that law should not be unsettled merely on the ground that an alternative view appears to be more reasonable

8.02

for a lawful consideration lawful object that takes us to section twenty three

6.34

no no you please whatever it is

2.5

an mla is constitutionally made part of that electoral college

6.039938

in the process of separating ethyl alcohol from the fermented wash and in this process various components of the mixture are separated by virtue of their difference in boiling points

11.679938

your lordships can hear them in chamber

2.68

and the last one and the d point is that our constitution makers took the different provision of the constitution from the birth democracies according to indian perspective

12.319938

sbi must disclose details of each electoral bond encashed by the political party which will include data of encashment and denomination of encashment of each bond

9.159938

having given due consideration we are of the opinion that this interpretation of article thirty nine b requires to be reconsidered by a bench of nine learned judges

9.92

now taking a cue from the example of bauxite have you not boxed in this tape so far as exercise of their power under fifty entry fifty list ii

12.599938

'it is submitted that a ' your lordships have para one hundred and sixty five

4.52

in nabam rebia you did it

1.64

for the moment this distinction which i am pointing out has relevance to understanding the limit of limitation in entry fifty

13.22

accordingly the five judges in i

1.88

statute merely makes it inadmissible in evidence

2.52

volume one

1.04

judgment of the chief justice thakur

2.2

it is contextualized in the first part as well as second part when they use that in respect of a vote and what is said and in respect of what is published

12.159938

the chief minister will go

1.94

page thirty nine

2.02

but can somebody else say why are you giving it to him and not to others a person who is not eligible for it so this is just the slight thing

10.079938

no that can't be

1.36

now my lord the first submission i'm making is if your lordship sees section eleven six a of the act

10.58

supreme court's order

1.4

but at the same time on the reference to these very acts it is difficult to hold that they deal exclusively with beverages and are not applicable to certain articles which are strictly speaking not beverages

14.42

yes mr

1.94

and thereafter once the maharashtra rent act has come in then another five percent provisions are there

6