paper_id
uint32 0
3.7k
| title
stringlengths 14
154
| paper_url
stringlengths 42
42
| authors
listlengths 1
21
| type
stringclasses 3
values | abstract
stringlengths 413
2.52k
| keywords
stringlengths 4
397
| TL;DR
stringlengths 5
250
⌀ | submission_number
int64 2
14.3k
| arxiv_id
stringlengths 10
10
⌀ | embedding
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
300 |
Efficient Automated Circuit Discovery in Transformers using Contextual Decomposition
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=41HlN8XYM5
|
[
"Aliyah R. Hsu",
"Georgia Zhou",
"Yeshwanth Cherapanamjeri",
"Yaxuan Huang",
"Anobel Odisho",
"Peter R. Carroll",
"Bin Yu"
] |
Poster
|
Automated mechanistic interpretation research has attracted great interest due to its potential to scale explanations of neural network internals to large models. Existing automated circuit discovery work relies on activation patching or its approximations to identify subgraphs in models for specific tasks (circuits). They often suffer from slow runtime, approximation errors, and specific requirements of metrics, such as non-zero gradients.
In this work, we introduce contextual decomposition for transformers (CD-T) to build interpretable circuits in large language models. CD-T can produce circuits at any level of abstraction and is the first to efficiently produce circuits as fine-grained as attention heads at specific sequence positions.
CD-T is compatible to all transformer types, and requires no training or manually-crafted examples.
CD-T consists of a set of mathematical equations to isolate contribution of model features. Through recursively computing contribution of all nodes in a computational graph of a model using CD-T followed by pruning, we are able to reduce circuit discovery runtime from hours to seconds compared to state-of-the-art baselines.
On three standard circuit evaluation datasets (indirect object identification, greater-than comparisons, and docstring completion),
we demonstrate that CD-T outperforms ACDC and EAP by better recovering the manual circuits with an average of 97% ROC AUC under low runtimes.
In addition, we provide evidence that faithfulness of CD-T circuits is not due to random chance by showing our circuits are 80% more faithful than random circuits of up to 60% of the original model size.
Finally, we show CD-T circuits are able to perfectly replicate original models' behavior(faithfulness = 1) using fewer nodes than the baselines for all tasks.
Our results underscore the great promise of CD-T for efficient automated mechanistic interpretability, paving the way for new insights into the workings of large language models.
|
Automated Circuit Discovery, Explainable AI, Interpretation, Machine Learning, Language Models, Transformers
| null | 13,618 |
2407.00886
|
[
0.009057804942131042,
0.00984722189605236,
-0.033507972955703735,
0.05760820582509041,
0.022012906149029732,
0.02899785526096821,
0.010822652839124203,
0.008741025812923908,
-0.015456032007932663,
-0.006515687797218561,
0.010492755100131035,
0.0352475680410862,
-0.03862270712852478,
0.010613443329930305,
-0.03236085921525955,
0.04306716099381447,
0.027041524648666382,
-0.02366776578128338,
0.02855367586016655,
-0.003466772846877575,
0.040675800293684006,
-0.008753541857004166,
0.032382767647504807,
0.02854762226343155,
0.02485097385942936,
0.0066462792456150055,
0.021736634895205498,
-0.01966887339949608,
-0.027861962094902992,
0.010204111225903034,
0.04736975580453873,
0.005328090861439705,
0.03119664639234543,
-0.05215546116232872,
0.011542771011590958,
0.013614358380436897,
-0.026556815952062607,
-0.01511534582823515,
-0.028733614832162857,
0.015189556404948235,
-0.04399459436535835,
0.013997148722410202,
0.002023321809247136,
0.016268573701381683,
-0.05550307035446167,
0.028913874179124832,
-0.12225715070962906,
0.024436216801404953,
-0.017686564475297928,
-0.04213561490178108,
-0.09186919778585434,
0.03056725300848484,
-0.006579794455319643,
0.010223391465842724,
-0.0013030569534748793,
0.026941295713186264,
0.05287023261189461,
-0.061143942177295685,
0.017302997410297394,
-0.02613353542983532,
-0.025486081838607788,
0.03619803488254547,
-0.00005465047070174478,
0.035356856882572174,
0.011533408425748348,
-0.012198925949633121,
0.001086270553059876,
0.022160230204463005,
-0.0584709532558918,
-0.023028753697872162,
-0.015438621863722801,
0.007426947820931673,
-0.014769242145121098,
0.00969660747796297,
0.023859405890107155,
-0.027865540236234665,
-0.0009717394132167101,
-0.001968423370271921,
0.05379331484436989,
0.008424373343586922,
0.03651624172925949,
0.021700451150536537,
0.02023988403379917,
0.03689006716012955,
0.02751793898642063,
-0.0016000478062778711,
-0.05940565466880798,
-0.03810781240463257,
-0.051042694598436356,
0.016549963504076004,
-0.022682394832372665,
-0.036595527082681656,
-0.0011739792535081506,
0.035323090851306915,
0.031115319579839706,
0.0048140245489776134,
0.012744606472551823,
0.001471054507419467,
-0.014682120643556118,
0.008405270054936409,
0.019041333347558975,
-0.02111227810382843,
0.02715996280312538,
-0.02036254107952118,
-0.11794210970401764,
0.004021697677671909,
0.0034822095185518265,
-0.04231176897883415,
0.015755673870444298,
-0.00041500659426674247,
-0.0260637030005455,
-0.004462321754544973,
0.023488400503993034,
-0.005275925621390343,
-0.09707695245742798,
0.039685532450675964,
0.0079222172498703,
0.01703834719955921,
-0.00019843400514218956,
0.00047579279635101557,
0.06169024482369423,
0.04424930736422539,
0.016251226887106895,
0.08217692375183105,
-0.021476328372955322,
0.005570721346884966,
0.0003228742571081966,
0.033416785299777985,
0.0006995939766056836,
-0.044275958091020584,
0.010444971732795238,
0.015742607414722443,
0.02819513902068138,
-0.013710749335587025,
-0.0016047480748966336,
-0.03617704287171364,
0.01793396845459938,
0.005740626715123653,
0.06457087397575378,
-0.0021767537109553814,
0.007412932347506285,
-0.003121333196759224,
0.06696165353059769,
-0.05899214372038841,
0.057698968797922134,
-0.023700371384620667,
-0.07754135876893997,
0.0015944339102134109,
-0.012524283491075039,
0.007653823122382164,
0.02161969058215618,
0.0005545545136556029,
-0.0350416861474514,
-0.0914802998304367,
0.03677699342370033,
0.0724867507815361,
0.013893889263272285,
0.039206214249134064,
0.005597793962806463,
0.018648024648427963,
0.010659619234502316,
-0.03023964911699295,
-0.016219569370150566,
0.023130938410758972,
-0.027218332514166832,
-0.05763014778494835,
0.041481759399175644,
0.019834136590361595,
-0.05700599029660225,
-0.005191814620047808,
-0.03627895563840866,
-0.06060396507382393,
0.0611458420753479,
0.0010138381039723754,
-0.02889927104115486,
-0.01318351086229086,
0.041687075048685074,
-0.03613486886024475,
0.023186108097434044,
0.030642719939351082,
-0.08396532386541367,
0.01916540041565895,
-0.005385976750403643,
-0.020650867372751236,
0.039737313985824585,
-0.03171534463763237,
0.06473343819379807,
-0.034910138696432114,
-0.007674518972635269,
0.015961891040205956,
-0.08038497716188431,
-0.040438372641801834,
0.004567593801766634,
-0.00621039979159832,
0.06901311129331589,
0.01434799563139677,
-0.023784052580595016,
0.040824584662914276,
0.04813008010387421,
0.06125199794769287,
0.046628404408693314,
-0.02216537669301033,
0.057017501443624496,
-0.03047894313931465,
-0.038114648312330246,
-0.004575147293508053,
0.029609985649585724,
-0.02196589857339859,
-0.004074295982718468,
-0.016105003654956818,
-0.000789961195550859,
-0.02387889288365841,
0.033064208924770355,
-0.041608624160289764,
0.00655947532504797,
-0.016895979642868042,
-0.010742434300482273,
0.021740369498729706,
0.020876556634902954,
-0.062093522399663925,
0.027138708159327507,
0.033712632954120636,
-0.05053476244211197,
0.022306527942419052,
-0.03516164794564247,
0.11859958618879318,
0.06485151499509811,
-0.03053528442978859,
-0.02613627351820469,
0.0569152794778347,
0.007139527704566717,
0.005443461239337921,
-0.006728770211338997,
-0.059834469109773636,
0.0054639349691569805,
-0.018105927854776382,
-0.04234814643859863,
-0.0132119320333004,
0.03097682259976864,
-0.031526125967502594,
-0.005271099507808685,
0.06854800134897232,
-0.02748052030801773,
0.03142499178647995,
0.012724518775939941,
0.029857318848371506,
0.030821941792964935,
-0.020959194749593735,
-0.02776915207505226,
-0.002927512163296342,
-0.011312834918498993,
-0.011730757541954517,
0.004561855457723141,
-0.030094454064965248,
0.03842069208621979,
-0.044223230332136154,
-0.03418109565973282,
-0.01814846508204937,
0.06045011430978775,
0.058154698461294174,
0.008213086053729057,
0.023925958201289177,
0.0001596874208189547,
-0.058252982795238495,
-0.012498640455305576,
-0.11647999286651611,
-0.045484744012355804,
-0.01634100079536438,
0.026398586109280586,
-0.023011798039078712,
0.022048605605959892,
0.012007500045001507,
0.03412000089883804,
-0.03575949743390083,
-0.015381965786218643,
0.003436545841395855,
0.03172401338815689,
0.01901073381304741,
-0.007632399909198284,
-0.006699104327708483,
0.009063411504030228,
0.04160138964653015,
-0.02647818811237812,
-0.021838603541254997,
-0.03419319540262222,
-0.05695612356066704,
-0.021560661494731903,
-0.01483998168259859,
0.008712772279977798,
0.008929220959544182,
0.028172636404633522,
0.0028769478667527437,
-0.03785726800560951,
0.04371564835309982,
0.029639411717653275,
0.06200952082872391,
0.057751357555389404,
0.015443968586623669,
0.0011230726959183812,
0.00013576782657764852,
0.0011733752908185124,
0.023817293345928192,
-0.04478594660758972,
0.03331057354807854,
-0.004168355837464333,
0.00674481550231576,
0.02133309468626976,
-0.008727320469915867,
-0.25368180871009827,
-0.00966549851000309,
0.008180862292647362,
-0.02320292964577675,
0.029922693967819214,
-0.028719469904899597,
0.014829855412244797,
-0.000592702126596123,
-0.006271424237638712,
-0.013957238756120205,
-0.0018334080232307315,
0.03429974243044853,
0.0027745505794882774,
0.05461292341351509,
0.023395510390400887,
0.01431917306035757,
-0.018653035163879395,
-0.008779775351285934,
0.00713691208511591,
0.059434674680233,
0.008376100100576878,
-0.07412083446979523,
-0.02598503790795803,
0.04311973601579666,
-0.017530987039208412,
0.02066606469452381,
-0.09951851516962051,
-0.01797095127403736,
-0.02580323815345764,
-0.01410303357988596,
-0.031136687844991684,
-0.019227806478738785,
-0.006571584846824408,
0.03017093613743782,
0.01784476637840271,
0.027758486568927765,
0.050148289650678635,
0.022074557840824127,
0.006987699773162603,
0.010185732506215572,
0.01803494244813919,
-0.034684039652347565,
-0.013652157038450241,
0.0007897801115177572,
0.06395026296377182,
0.0026536346413195133,
-0.05289817601442337,
-0.014282211661338806,
-0.016555778682231903,
0.02927165850996971,
-0.01306891068816185,
-0.010600204579532146,
0.004415308125317097,
-0.002547565847635269,
0.02753201313316822,
-0.029127290472388268,
-0.013222400099039078,
0.012866245582699776,
-0.0232206080108881,
-0.006586355157196522,
-0.01713840290904045,
-0.03574153408408165,
-0.0041852425783872604,
-0.03157448023557663,
-0.028469962999224663,
-0.012719755060970783,
-0.07154455035924911,
-0.05723057687282562,
0.03567415103316307,
0.04313846305012703,
-0.036697112023830414,
0.038235705345869064,
-0.0173454899340868,
-0.0991450622677803,
0.012614402920007706,
0.011723128147423267,
-0.0007112368475645781,
-0.001707299961708486,
-0.0010464680381119251,
0.03914034366607666,
-0.05386357009410858,
-0.037653326988220215,
-0.021151069551706314,
0.010725174099206924,
0.026277126744389534,
-0.00580646563321352,
0.0003513254050631076,
-0.019744323566555977,
-0.008840473368763924,
0.00459847180172801,
0.03833473473787308,
0.0214045699685812,
0.033457282930612564,
-0.03866397589445114,
0.05180062726140022,
0.024960599839687347,
0.049535006284713745,
0.059872228652238846,
0.03696952760219574,
0.0015958776930347085,
0.01784045249223709,
-0.077192023396492,
-0.0016153062460944057,
-0.0120841758325696,
-0.05931989103555679,
0.0241619311273098,
-0.05757527053356171,
-0.06267177313566208,
0.03967205435037613,
0.01984943076968193,
-0.027684226632118225,
-0.0605800524353981,
0.003780543804168701,
-0.02479712665081024,
0.007828940637409687,
-0.009552810341119766,
0.0357222780585289,
0.019796278327703476,
0.04172298684716225,
-0.016058793291449547,
-0.002308098366484046,
0.04623880609869957,
-0.008315826766192913,
0.005049879662692547,
0.031876638531684875,
-0.023745901882648468,
0.001244337297976017,
0.023428739979863167,
0.008357063867151737,
0.01369116734713316,
0.04597405716776848,
0.03671397268772125,
-0.009947692975401878,
0.0393662191927433,
0.0292564257979393,
0.0008806338883005083,
-0.01764831691980362,
0.020228618755936623,
-0.002138052135705948,
0.00370447663590312,
0.011659574694931507,
-0.01691610738635063,
0.05306239053606987,
0.01117634866386652,
0.02426845394074917,
-0.0006363745778799057,
0.017093636095523834,
0.009720231406390667,
-0.01339647825807333,
-0.017165537923574448,
0.040743470191955566,
-0.04973650351166725,
-0.04307720810174942,
-0.032622333616018295,
0.02530011348426342,
-0.01786678656935692,
0.03963315859436989,
-0.014184650965034962,
0.0040502543561160564,
-0.06041484698653221,
0.04452965408563614,
-0.0026843922678381205,
0.022423798218369484,
-0.007043397985398769,
0.01929861307144165,
0.03345083072781563,
-0.02377939410507679,
0.0022802306339144707,
0.03184443712234497,
0.0362345352768898,
-0.0017023991094902158,
-0.003412684891372919,
-0.03709851950407028,
0.004961848258972168,
-0.017807524651288986,
0.026083724573254585,
0.0012211614521220326,
-0.016581891104578972,
-0.009585846215486526,
0.008481904864311218,
-0.0030009103938937187,
-0.042076319456100464,
0.025643736124038696,
0.02334177866578102,
0.08357454091310501,
0.005845495034009218,
0.007482149638235569,
0.006017496343702078,
-0.01877496764063835,
0.03197195753455162,
0.008456222712993622,
-0.002660319907590747,
-0.04562151059508324,
-0.047599684447050095,
-0.03975798189640045,
-0.03640260919928551,
0.02979656681418419,
0.030905835330486298,
-0.0017530409386381507,
-0.032548826187849045,
0.0038878940977156162,
-0.00799592025578022,
-0.023110711947083473,
-0.004379366058856249,
0.0399346686899662,
-0.07452452182769775,
0.017534172162413597,
0.04310327395796776,
-0.008636606857180595,
0.04073302447795868,
-0.0013647092273458838,
-0.01720082387328148,
-0.04086189717054367,
-0.022501101717352867,
-0.006087166722863913,
-0.006221436429768801,
0.0013128559803590178,
-0.01305230800062418,
0.0062807416543364525,
0.003398511791601777,
0.0029123101849108934,
0.01401789765805006,
0.000313238357193768,
-0.028950583189725876,
0.01746855117380619,
0.028274687007069588,
-0.01564321480691433,
0.0022226092405617237,
-0.023872461169958115,
-0.05813991278409958,
-0.021205930039286613,
-0.020818835124373436,
0.04655994102358818,
0.03820572420954704,
0.005644349381327629,
-0.035877034068107605,
-0.04306642338633537,
0.029872510582208633,
-0.009019212797284126,
-0.010114641860127449,
0.015698811039328575,
-0.00020044497796334326,
-0.04482314735651016,
0.035535018891096115,
0.016811178997159004,
0.032552920281887054,
0.05372422933578491,
-0.0025964246597141027,
0.01028153020888567,
0.02796308510005474,
0.047504790127277374,
0.044573087245225906,
-0.04701879248023033,
-0.015953952446579933,
0.07533317804336548,
-0.051928192377090454,
-0.034086667001247406,
-0.041451212018728256,
-0.051867756992578506,
-0.012303006835281849,
-0.03945262357592583,
0.03241723030805588,
0.007512986660003662,
0.02627149596810341,
0.015071537345647812,
0.02420254424214363,
-0.03510560095310211,
-0.01683783531188965,
0.03733813390135765,
-0.05107570067048073,
0.013608991168439388,
-0.06335771083831787,
0.013453283347189426,
0.08252330124378204,
-0.03736497834324837,
-0.009069515392184258,
0.002024139976128936,
-0.051315322518348694,
0.04541175439953804,
-0.022387802600860596,
-0.0527956560254097,
0.03424714878201485,
-0.00006420807039830834,
0.022001732140779495,
0.01433270238339901,
-0.037081316113471985,
-0.02817489393055439,
-0.03104119561612606,
-0.02604704350233078,
-0.003958858083933592,
-0.010104363784193993,
0.04712388664484024,
-0.008110548369586468,
-0.0088530657812953,
-0.018471751362085342,
0.042432282119989395,
0.02819376438856125,
0.06324504315853119,
0.03931806609034538,
0.014845778234302998,
-0.03522610664367676,
0.05042925104498863,
0.027529245242476463,
0.004388262517750263,
-0.025154106318950653,
0.030759194865822792,
-0.013601403683423996,
-0.03453785553574562,
0.04108649492263794,
-0.02993909828364849,
-0.034605905413627625,
-0.07197768986225128,
0.059107135981321335,
0.03153422102332115,
-0.04204750061035156,
-0.032923221588134766,
0.014571608044207096,
-0.09670287370681763,
-0.04597683623433113,
0.01988864317536354,
-0.014199448749423027,
-0.016403639689087868,
0.07840078324079514,
0.01682807132601738,
0.051196686923503876,
0.06990622729063034,
0.01923370361328125,
-0.03628818690776825,
0.008363441564142704,
0.08915645629167557,
0.08659475296735764,
0.033939771354198456,
0.0038443400990217924,
0.05477510392665863,
-0.008337982930243015,
-0.0429990291595459,
0.035285983234643936,
0.029235506430268288,
0.011333424597978592,
-0.03443362936377525,
0.02333400957286358,
0.0862627699971199,
0.0077797225676476955,
0.0915498286485672,
-0.05185706540942192,
0.005376074928790331,
0.05516656115651131,
-0.015346666797995567,
0.0000887650458025746,
0.0724562406539917,
0.022915644571185112,
-0.013300620950758457,
-0.016452539712190628,
-0.02509782463312149,
-0.0330938883125782,
-0.02019733190536499,
0.0014717165613546968,
0.051330965012311935,
-0.00808832235634327,
-0.0050670993514359,
-0.02348451502621174,
0.05700911954045296,
0.11234962195158005,
-0.028447454795241356,
-0.014566539786756039,
0.010677051730453968,
-0.002666034270077944,
0.003456112230196595,
0.03603782132267952,
-0.02966836281120777,
-0.017163610085844994,
-0.02577618509531021,
-0.06155243143439293,
0.009692544117569923,
0.025739546865224838,
0.007286769803613424,
0.008773626759648323,
-0.019643044099211693,
-0.0516531802713871,
0.005026077851653099,
0.04768408462405205,
-0.03513297811150551,
-0.055055372416973114,
-0.032040491700172424,
-0.04305143654346466,
-0.08101807534694672,
-0.051060475409030914,
0.01816403865814209,
-0.01894938200712204,
-0.032869063317775726,
-0.017143186181783676,
-0.010538185015320778,
0.018070530146360397,
0.004017923027276993,
-0.06247133016586304,
0.002849671058356762,
0.04108260199427605,
-0.018682722002267838,
-0.01605318859219551,
0.020672587677836418,
0.01296207308769226,
-0.009399663656949997,
-0.03375588357448578,
0.05766059830784798,
-0.009406806901097298,
0.0135696055367589,
0.0044218567200005054,
-0.01888350397348404,
-0.10273374617099762,
0.019549481570720673,
0.0008144741295836866,
-0.03156588599085808,
-0.10000511258840561,
0.03544023633003235,
-0.03591886907815933,
0.021331828087568283,
0.05907304957509041,
-0.02276734821498394,
0.023593759164214134,
-0.03206484019756317,
-0.0010478469775989652,
0.01548669021576643,
-0.003880151081830263,
0.04354460909962654,
-0.022126642987132072,
0.07288661599159241,
0.036290593445301056,
-0.02296512946486473,
-0.01857326179742813,
0.020988889038562775,
-0.017263127490878105,
0.01287795789539814,
-0.014185555279254913,
-0.03212698921561241,
-0.023102687671780586,
-0.10829053819179535,
-0.0370379276573658,
-0.01545308344066143,
-0.009536934085190296,
-0.04100174829363823,
0.009519091807305813,
-0.045100320130586624,
-0.028132250532507896,
-0.007517783436924219,
-0.017804952338337898,
0.004056318197399378,
-0.03161134570837021,
-0.04939521476626396,
-0.06451557576656342,
0.018649021163582802,
-0.05295681953430176,
0.04119586944580078,
-0.05085226148366928,
-0.023017916828393936,
-0.026245098561048508,
-0.0053397733718156815,
0.04654557257890701,
0.02349865436553955,
0.011448725126683712,
-0.02399129793047905
] |
301 |
How to Evaluate Reward Models for RLHF
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=cbttLtO94Q
|
[
"Evan Frick",
"Tianle Li",
"Connor Chen",
"Wei-Lin Chiang",
"Anastasios Nikolas Angelopoulos",
"Jiantao Jiao",
"Banghua Zhu",
"Joseph E. Gonzalez",
"Ion Stoica"
] |
Poster
|
We introduce a new benchmark for reward models that quantifies their ability to produce strong language models through RLHF (Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback).
The gold-standard approach is to run a full RLHF training pipeline and directly probe downstream LLM performance.
However, this process is prohibitively expensive.
To address this, we build a predictive model of downstream LLM performance by evaluating the reward model on proxy tasks.
These proxy tasks consist of a large-scale human preference and a verifiable correctness preference dataset, in which we measure 12 metrics across 12 domains.
To investigate which reward model metrics are most correlated to gold-standard RLHF outcomes, we launch an end-to-end RLHF experiment on a large-scale crowd-sourced human preference platform to view real reward model downstream performance as ground truth.
Ultimately, we compile our data and findings into Preference Proxy Evaluations (PPE), the first reward model benchmark explicitly linked to post-RLHF real-world human preference performance, which we opensource for public use and further development at https://github.com/lmarena/PPE.
|
RLHF, RL, Reward Model, LLM, Benchmark, Dataset, Evaluation
| null | 13,614 |
2410.14872
|
[
0.0007133029284887016,
0.0024910219945013523,
0.008961651474237442,
0.024766679853200912,
0.06183653697371483,
0.0015844135778024793,
0.013410583138465881,
0.018155813217163086,
-0.0317474901676178,
-0.006728544365614653,
-0.004586993250995874,
0.05350828543305397,
-0.05775140970945358,
-0.03209482505917549,
-0.0028444055933505297,
0.056096795946359634,
0.04006184637546539,
0.022226393222808838,
0.016110148280858994,
-0.0012449582573026419,
0.005223351065069437,
0.020312447100877762,
0.01827973686158657,
0.0043496424332261086,
0.0482025109231472,
0.03050815314054489,
0.03173529729247093,
0.009660571813583374,
-0.040408845990896225,
0.007350364699959755,
0.03739962726831436,
-0.04144982248544693,
0.035992078483104706,
0.0049772728234529495,
-0.0047335815615952015,
0.0033477761317044497,
-0.033125314861536026,
-0.007261305116117001,
0.023772332817316055,
-0.006161757279187441,
-0.030659817159175873,
0.01578768901526928,
-0.024133652448654175,
0.012098001316189766,
-0.04617217183113098,
0.02284410037100315,
-0.09296911954879761,
0.015032926574349403,
0.025114797055721283,
-0.01769223064184189,
-0.10159184038639069,
0.02587788924574852,
0.0014303374337032437,
-0.016628246754407883,
0.02596452087163925,
0.02576572820544243,
0.03482727333903313,
-0.07582934200763702,
0.00122000218834728,
-0.02214772254228592,
-0.014646956697106361,
0.02675321139395237,
0.029644722118973732,
0.020456470549106598,
-0.001502363826148212,
-0.021061360836029053,
0.01778455823659897,
0.025825949385762215,
-0.046147167682647705,
-0.009059281088411808,
-0.01565278321504593,
-0.00929525401443243,
-0.002744714030995965,
0.007755211088806391,
-0.015650859102606773,
-0.06945902109146118,
-0.007061885204166174,
0.06163580343127251,
0.03775513172149658,
-0.006719227880239487,
0.009390104562044144,
0.01308488380163908,
0.012430500239133835,
0.029789350926876068,
0.008073097094893456,
0.015158607624471188,
-0.000489781319629401,
-0.05167917162179947,
-0.06851997971534729,
0.04516943171620369,
-0.03294448181986809,
-0.027345675975084305,
0.013381808064877987,
0.01035480760037899,
0.04542184993624687,
0.0038163308054208755,
0.001722589018754661,
0.0696425586938858,
-0.029404129832983017,
0.0005856145289726555,
-0.03334147483110428,
-0.04638908430933952,
0.012460032477974892,
-0.013309274800121784,
-0.09106795489788055,
-0.018516849726438522,
0.01154390163719654,
-0.011126422323286533,
-0.01820707879960537,
-0.01063915342092514,
-0.026521267369389534,
-0.005643742624670267,
0.010684658773243427,
0.012708290480077267,
-0.0713597759604454,
0.04214182123541832,
-0.008498436771333218,
0.02908763848245144,
-0.02136962115764618,
0.018554963171482086,
0.032229773700237274,
0.02615860290825367,
-0.009604135528206825,
0.06539040058851242,
-0.0035246487241238356,
0.021972527727484703,
0.012727777473628521,
0.03397651016712189,
-0.0034100685734301805,
-0.0694182813167572,
0.03324879705905914,
0.05884866788983345,
-0.02747875265777111,
0.01147912535816431,
-0.01654897630214691,
-0.0004740595177281648,
0.020915472880005836,
-0.01948755607008934,
0.04930771887302399,
0.015156620182096958,
0.006078808568418026,
0.01455007866024971,
0.06380067765712738,
-0.045455995947122574,
0.0660734698176384,
0.009529761970043182,
-0.019572600722312927,
-0.027126844972372055,
-0.04004562646150589,
0.010331221856176853,
0.01925300620496273,
0.017439110204577446,
-0.012891403399407864,
-0.0381888747215271,
0.05250392481684685,
0.03748611360788345,
0.03398502245545387,
-0.033735956996679306,
-0.012381047941744328,
-0.007648942992091179,
-0.024899786338210106,
0.01689482107758522,
-0.02924162521958351,
-0.03268761187791824,
-0.011804912239313126,
-0.043680448085069656,
0.04315122961997986,
0.006526663899421692,
-0.02402772381901741,
0.0019835468847304583,
-0.04561539739370346,
-0.016839345917105675,
0.04555296152830124,
-0.00532139465212822,
-0.034589733928442,
-0.011989293619990349,
0.04917073994874954,
0.01983504928648472,
0.03416534140706062,
0.04403639957308769,
-0.07274792343378067,
0.05299793928861618,
0.00893243309110403,
-0.005011824890971184,
0.006589234806597233,
-0.04090040177106857,
0.10242685675621033,
-0.04388800635933876,
-0.0010746893240138888,
0.051415588706731796,
-0.09381149709224701,
-0.004067904315888882,
0.05458056554198265,
-0.010465940460562706,
0.06987903267145157,
-0.01496266108006239,
0.009027913212776184,
0.06291449815034866,
0.028574997559189796,
0.05896976590156555,
0.053435876965522766,
-0.018077028915286064,
0.024617258459329605,
-0.0386403352022171,
-0.023361794650554657,
-0.015719098970294,
0.04117142781615257,
-0.044861916452646255,
-0.04851197823882103,
0.008892117999494076,
-0.027798384428024292,
0.026667878031730652,
0.008940390311181545,
0.013702421449124813,
-0.00399240804836154,
-0.004401662386953831,
-0.011273836717009544,
0.027584955096244812,
0.011949467472732067,
-0.031723394989967346,
0.024904899299144745,
0.0049677141942083836,
0.01067808736115694,
-0.009825794957578182,
-0.06492555141448975,
0.08104792982339859,
0.06523680686950684,
-0.014222357422113419,
-0.024386059492826462,
0.055484842509031296,
0.009857707656919956,
0.017530309036374092,
0.03757699951529503,
-0.045295342803001404,
0.014645112678408623,
0.0009925573831424117,
-0.013630003668367863,
-0.012300209142267704,
0.050137557089328766,
-0.022297199815511703,
-0.010008972138166428,
0.05421645566821098,
-0.020963849499821663,
0.04218227043747902,
-0.01617187261581421,
0.015313009731471539,
-0.0007680514827370644,
0.015931453555822372,
-0.014896025881171227,
-0.02628702111542225,
-0.0654611736536026,
-0.00321841798722744,
0.008794940076768398,
-0.012902874499559402,
0.039261747151613235,
-0.0564875565469265,
-0.010500289499759674,
0.002044453052803874,
0.024127790704369545,
0.0516037754714489,
0.043820444494485855,
0.029505282640457153,
-0.057281117886304855,
-0.06490778177976608,
0.015352779068052769,
-0.10472648590803146,
-0.025299998000264168,
-0.03756069764494896,
0.006060196086764336,
0.04367367923259735,
0.008055227808654308,
-0.01811455376446247,
0.00650037731975317,
-0.035966090857982635,
-0.009430003352463245,
-0.001366039039567113,
0.03862585127353668,
-0.006067624781280756,
-0.054936327040195465,
-0.029030881822109222,
-0.024533448740839958,
0.05979648232460022,
-0.00026818428887054324,
-0.03720509260892868,
-0.017855530604720116,
-0.038578491657972336,
-0.0007425936637446284,
-0.022093594074249268,
0.00773549173027277,
-0.00421522231772542,
-0.03425392135977745,
0.020061690360307693,
-0.007766544818878174,
-0.0031771333888173103,
0.01272597722709179,
0.03822985291481018,
0.04607664421200752,
0.04422038793563843,
-0.006303709931671619,
0.037336867302656174,
-0.008291877806186676,
0.003658744040876627,
-0.0005657002911902964,
0.03554289788007736,
0.008817405439913273,
-0.018086913973093033,
0.027865754440426826,
0.02242915891110897,
-0.2823083698749542,
-0.04344955086708069,
0.00311673735268414,
-0.016897069290280342,
0.02038716711103916,
0.004636990372091532,
0.03209015354514122,
-0.019895510748028755,
-0.014590878039598465,
0.0023571611382067204,
0.03344417363405228,
0.03365645557641983,
0.013880888931453228,
0.05312164127826691,
0.055041540414094925,
0.0409897081553936,
0.0030993821565061808,
-0.025558557361364365,
-0.008283820003271103,
0.01895637810230255,
-0.03029000386595726,
-0.08058961480855942,
-0.028709692880511284,
0.029643910005688667,
-0.013392536900937557,
0.06304940581321716,
-0.07263268530368805,
0.0036195842549204826,
-0.03611977770924568,
-0.013955853879451752,
-0.003572809975594282,
-0.026965796947479248,
-0.04887942224740982,
0.028071021661162376,
0.02668105624616146,
-0.018971405923366547,
0.024025538936257362,
0.017424512654542923,
0.036544281989336014,
0.031399309635162354,
-0.0048992508091032505,
-0.01193202380090952,
-0.047062452882528305,
0.008436182513833046,
0.07237039506435394,
0.016364777460694313,
-0.061902426183223724,
-0.03532751277089119,
-0.018703686073422432,
0.030727270990610123,
-0.022827796638011932,
-0.03273220732808113,
-0.037293873727321625,
0.02112116850912571,
0.0070255594328045845,
-0.023158878087997437,
-0.03668450191617012,
-0.026648763567209244,
-0.008154316805303097,
0.007581544108688831,
-0.019973410293459892,
-0.026156090199947357,
-0.045555803924798965,
-0.014110800810158253,
-0.078916534781456,
-0.030325114727020264,
-0.02871626801788807,
-0.024375474080443382,
0.04073936119675636,
0.04316376522183418,
-0.023967331275343895,
-0.010245979763567448,
-0.010784637182950974,
-0.0938323587179184,
-0.01762859895825386,
-0.011692334897816181,
-0.0004831132246181369,
-0.005967792589217424,
-0.011535831727087498,
0.06143647059798241,
-0.02595912665128708,
-0.045759107917547226,
-0.007376621011644602,
-0.00646956218406558,
0.019649719819426537,
0.007436908781528473,
0.013633087277412415,
-0.019719351083040237,
-0.0070753456093370914,
-0.055171746760606766,
0.04126095399260521,
-0.009943371638655663,
-0.01686077006161213,
0.03650951385498047,
0.03871465474367142,
0.012774502858519554,
0.023479100316762924,
0.03405800461769104,
0.0062957629561424255,
0.034293584525585175,
0.023199493065476418,
-0.08378468453884125,
0.023105045780539513,
-0.04974442347884178,
-0.031082667410373688,
0.029493382200598717,
-0.06932000070810318,
-0.02074747532606125,
0.011954469606280327,
0.010300644673407078,
-0.01779029332101345,
0.0011901984689757228,
-0.0014344163937494159,
0.01791742816567421,
-0.031164882704615593,
-0.025134418159723282,
-0.006559798028320074,
0.031735315918922424,
0.03733700513839722,
0.01484284270554781,
-0.03961643576622009,
0.027551056817173958,
-0.02118055708706379,
-0.0010903853690251708,
-0.0165469441562891,
0.011915838345885277,
0.009838580153882504,
-0.015781592577695847,
0.027624933049082756,
-0.003403163980692625,
0.02989690564572811,
0.03863516077399254,
-0.011884046718478203,
0.035038866102695465,
0.035249218344688416,
0.005164119880646467,
-0.014209764078259468,
0.008535075932741165,
0.05804283171892166,
-0.03953250125050545,
0.01474781334400177,
-0.0009615489398129284,
0.06017810106277466,
0.06388723850250244,
0.03196590766310692,
-0.003094892483204603,
0.018035918474197388,
-0.02311110310256481,
-0.0095584187656641,
0.01573888026177883,
0.05005105584859848,
-0.062457915395498276,
-0.01503829937428236,
-0.05005842074751854,
0.02694728411734104,
-0.03766477480530739,
0.01534500252455473,
-0.0028151036240160465,
0.020192213356494904,
-0.0848517194390297,
0.047460608184337616,
0.013386514037847519,
-0.040121592581272125,
0.02675403095781803,
0.016865311190485954,
0.02610325627028942,
-0.03444566950201988,
0.020103292539715767,
0.014949742704629898,
0.005395527463406324,
0.017801973968744278,
-0.04729742929339409,
0.01879938505589962,
-0.024964045733213425,
-0.05461783707141876,
-0.016233859583735466,
0.04406105354428291,
-0.037987902760505676,
-0.03964405506849289,
0.04827815666794777,
-0.014665840193629265,
-0.028242601081728935,
0.010507452301681042,
-0.011549793183803558,
0.08079488575458527,
0.010142283514142036,
0.02890341728925705,
0.0019396520219743252,
-0.006105849053710699,
0.019384779036045074,
-0.026700163260102272,
0.034115053713321686,
-0.0070837331004440784,
-0.014831739477813244,
-0.048010796308517456,
-0.05793498083949089,
0.004334664437919855,
-0.002338284393772483,
0.026942618191242218,
-0.0004916106699965894,
-0.03478257358074188,
-0.004477487411350012,
-0.02798890694975853,
-0.024471668526530266,
0.026465142145752907,
-0.06677041947841644,
-0.005313531029969454,
0.05839252844452858,
0.007722925394773483,
0.03853296488523483,
-0.07104262709617615,
-0.06434787064790726,
-0.05848737433552742,
-0.0299485195428133,
-0.006152072921395302,
-0.029181716963648796,
-0.042437683790922165,
-0.04043557867407799,
-0.02679847739636898,
0.022670608013868332,
0.028716638684272766,
-0.03145716339349747,
-0.03232922777533531,
-0.0030819643288850784,
0.0029992221388965845,
0.0326685830950737,
-0.05202155560255051,
-0.06739834696054459,
0.01623963937163353,
-0.010067380033433437,
0.04323804751038551,
-0.043138183653354645,
0.05425461009144783,
0.039816953241825104,
-0.002619244856759906,
0.01996096782386303,
-0.0614316388964653,
0.06119196489453316,
-0.01784195564687252,
-0.021256381645798683,
0.015653440728783607,
0.014272166416049004,
-0.007671883329749107,
-0.026551494374871254,
-0.018886767327785492,
0.02588379941880703,
0.03056345507502556,
0.033036116510629654,
0.030528618022799492,
0.04138672351837158,
0.00944655854254961,
0.025756901130080223,
-0.021621935069561005,
0.005528279114514589,
0.0656362771987915,
0.002643529325723648,
-0.0015253606252372265,
-0.06000225991010666,
-0.03561607375741005,
0.0014773287111893296,
0.0017657451098784804,
0.020769137889146805,
-0.06419067829847336,
0.0343155674636364,
0.03497069701552391,
0.04659586399793625,
0.031297966837882996,
-0.04230364039540291,
0.03798159211874008,
-0.06101794168353081,
0.006659091915935278,
-0.04125121608376503,
-0.018661828711628914,
0.0631001740694046,
-0.03864290192723274,
0.0058662667870521545,
-0.003979932051151991,
-0.04658491164445877,
0.036906562745571136,
-0.021721849218010902,
-0.05976817011833191,
0.012005727738142014,
-0.018824394792318344,
-0.025651972740888596,
0.05732649192214012,
-0.04299415275454521,
-0.031180625781416893,
-0.03737286478281021,
-0.026588747277855873,
-0.00795550737529993,
0.004843709524720907,
0.03044024482369423,
-0.012930282391607761,
0.03148210421204567,
-0.010007417760789394,
0.021131694316864014,
0.018519986420869827,
0.05403677001595497,
-0.017203744500875473,
0.009129130281507969,
-0.0267316997051239,
0.060246292501688004,
0.028936004266142845,
0.0077676791697740555,
0.02126774564385414,
0.010979492217302322,
-0.003257779637351632,
-0.045120980590581894,
0.06039470061659813,
0.014900272712111473,
-0.014624998904764652,
-0.051693402230739594,
0.07250560820102692,
0.01744231954216957,
-0.0562797486782074,
-0.011509433388710022,
0.025313496589660645,
-0.0258591677993536,
-0.017786972224712372,
0.05139927938580513,
0.0004324850451666862,
-0.00636415695771575,
0.07990200072526932,
0.04787137731909752,
0.057191044092178345,
0.08880269527435303,
0.0018394461367279291,
-0.04460274428129196,
0.05262402072548866,
0.0798950269818306,
0.06021401658654213,
0.04974936693906784,
-0.011751137673854828,
0.06896716356277466,
-0.05062956362962723,
-0.053880415856838226,
-0.004761793650686741,
0.0376884751021862,
-0.034106072038412094,
-0.03326337784528732,
0.03775040805339813,
0.05291061848402023,
-0.021734710782766342,
0.03179537132382393,
-0.03273036330938339,
-0.002035816665738821,
0.04403703287243843,
-0.0017116437666118145,
0.01823902316391468,
0.035928912460803986,
0.02319924719631672,
0.013349329121410847,
-0.027627641335129738,
0.008617302402853966,
0.02262864075601101,
-0.001828964101150632,
0.014163960702717304,
0.017769934609532356,
-0.019977618008852005,
-0.010337786749005318,
0.009270237758755684,
0.03370627388358116,
0.10222147405147552,
-0.03094019740819931,
-0.0032196762040257454,
0.004121365025639534,
-0.01087771262973547,
0.020889053121209145,
0.013086950406432152,
0.01765289157629013,
-0.02537349797785282,
-0.005449165590107441,
-0.04989169165492058,
-0.011110348626971245,
0.0127399368211627,
-0.020659634843468666,
0.028299782425165176,
-0.050034910440444946,
0.01094396598637104,
0.030438650399446487,
0.010207509621977806,
-0.08060087263584137,
-0.030176401138305664,
-0.006236264016479254,
-0.07872959226369858,
-0.04281698539853096,
-0.07523009926080704,
0.004050813149660826,
0.008318084292113781,
-0.0626436322927475,
0.034073617309331894,
-0.009165029972791672,
-0.005746666807681322,
0.012021810747683048,
-0.07118939608335495,
-0.0023922340478748083,
0.030702384188771248,
-0.02914745733141899,
-0.009062240831553936,
0.039137665182352066,
0.025663718581199646,
-0.014082230627536774,
-0.017356468364596367,
0.01823369413614273,
0.016847500577569008,
0.021025851368904114,
-0.009167751297354698,
-0.03564805909991264,
-0.09425005316734314,
-0.013190392404794693,
0.031706370413303375,
0.0005360038485378027,
-0.07473155856132507,
0.027565177530050278,
-0.03888488560914993,
0.020849239081144333,
0.07930499315261841,
0.0410635843873024,
0.03040400892496109,
-0.038735438138246536,
-0.054567743092775345,
0.002875077771022916,
0.016044316813349724,
0.052217669785022736,
-0.022244593128561974,
0.07233060151338577,
0.02978121116757393,
-0.030203236266970634,
-0.07275047153234482,
0.028101511299610138,
0.001731983502395451,
-0.034828219562768936,
-0.02739974483847618,
-0.04256255552172661,
-0.01659517176449299,
-0.07472589612007141,
-0.011096036992967129,
0.029756076633930206,
-0.007185083813965321,
-0.02427724190056324,
-0.007495386525988579,
-0.026622289791703224,
-0.004040495492517948,
-0.005486747249960899,
-0.02168046124279499,
0.0015178481116890907,
-0.00464635482057929,
-0.02911776304244995,
-0.06318322569131851,
0.011586092412471771,
-0.024928519502282143,
-0.012155051343142986,
-0.014411059208214283,
-0.034500930458307266,
0.014665431343019009,
0.03615947440266609,
0.022398971021175385,
0.013910149224102497,
-0.002121425699442625,
-0.03391227871179581
] |
302 |
An Efficient Framework for Crediting Data Contributors of Diffusion Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=9EqQC2ct4H
|
[
"MingYu Lu",
"Chris Lin",
"Chanwoo Kim",
"Su-In Lee"
] |
Poster
|
As diffusion models are deployed in real-world settings and their performance driven by training data, appraising the contribution of data contributors is crucial to creating incentives for sharing quality data and to implementing policies for data compensation. Depending on the use case, model performance corresponds to various global properties of the distribution learned by a diffusion model (e.g., overall aesthetic quality). Hence, here we address the problem of attributing global properties of diffusion models to data contributors. The Shapley value provides a principled approach to valuation by uniquely satisfying game-theoretic axioms of fairness. However, estimating Shapley values for diffusion models is computationally impractical because it requires retraining and rerunning inference on many subsets of data contributors. We introduce a method to efficiently retrain and rerun inference for Shapley value estimation, by leveraging model pruning and fine-tuning. We evaluate the utility of our method with three use cases: (i) image quality for a DDPM trained on a CIFAR dataset, (ii) demographic diversity for an LDM trained on CelebA-HQ, and (iii) aesthetic quality for a Stable Diffusion model LoRA-finetuned on Post-Impressionist artworks. Our results empirically demonstrate that our framework can identify important data contributors across global properties, outperforming existing attribution methods for diffusion models.
|
data attribution, diffusion models, Shapley values
|
By model pruning and fine-tuning, we efficiently estimate Shapley values and attribute global properties of diffusion models to data contributors
| 13,612 |
2407.03153
|
[
-0.0002693835413083434,
-0.041459761559963226,
-0.0063656968995928764,
0.0615474097430706,
0.037315625697374344,
0.038085464388132095,
-0.0012822150019928813,
-0.00500020757317543,
-0.011885538697242737,
-0.06301088631153107,
-0.0027574943378567696,
-0.0035337810404598713,
-0.07143750786781311,
0.0014121923595666885,
-0.024267151951789856,
0.04059804603457451,
0.0287069883197546,
-0.016312602907419205,
-0.037669602781534195,
0.02813827060163021,
-0.021176328882575035,
-0.025895830243825912,
0.011701450683176517,
-0.004488461185246706,
-0.002433856250718236,
-0.019556723535060883,
0.04564158245921135,
-0.002599281957373023,
-0.023308390751481056,
0.015385160222649574,
0.03946418687701225,
0.01465396024286747,
0.010418490506708622,
-0.012402395717799664,
-0.01737663336098194,
-0.0058097755536437035,
-0.009568718262016773,
0.011210215277969837,
0.0077347527258098125,
0.011265719309449196,
-0.026732290163636208,
0.013640514574944973,
0.01778859831392765,
0.02119678631424904,
-0.03879283368587494,
-0.018246294930577278,
-0.10071361064910889,
0.04310787469148636,
0.0005846202839165926,
0.0013687292812392116,
-0.08181679993867874,
0.007399003487080336,
-0.0016557774506509304,
0.0056086014956235886,
-0.011567901819944382,
0.051007892936468124,
0.030211888253688812,
-0.077251136302948,
-0.014355465769767761,
-0.07007687538862228,
-0.026261983439326286,
0.019344249740242958,
0.028630344197154045,
-0.003801056882366538,
0.0024495951365679502,
-0.01737629435956478,
0.017870759591460228,
0.046206310391426086,
-0.04107183218002319,
-0.029710248112678528,
-0.02582511119544506,
-0.010780224576592445,
-0.017484618350863457,
-0.031556423753499985,
-0.018997378647327423,
-0.04559833183884621,
0.014984630048274994,
0.009818890132009983,
0.05380956828594208,
0.00024778328952379525,
0.0072879185900092125,
-0.00076491036452353,
0.004689924418926239,
0.034836310893297195,
0.018277298659086227,
0.00297535234130919,
-0.02392822690308094,
-0.03303711488842964,
-0.07705298811197281,
0.04103267565369606,
-0.03218209370970726,
-0.04014955088496208,
0.038970060646533966,
0.019739767536520958,
0.021141888573765755,
-0.0010596003849059343,
0.03737916797399521,
-0.0008469989988952875,
0.004016360267996788,
-0.027573086321353912,
-0.04153599962592125,
-0.032463230192661285,
-0.0027738490607589483,
0.016419434919953346,
-0.08929981291294098,
-0.028790917247533798,
-0.011385474354028702,
-0.030719542875885963,
-0.026663511991500854,
0.028945766389369965,
-0.013255094178020954,
-0.002980443648993969,
-0.03641971945762634,
-0.014020484872162342,
-0.06535512208938599,
0.02475811168551445,
0.009607935324311256,
0.014381103217601776,
-0.009520727209746838,
0.02805051952600479,
0.05965784937143326,
0.05622849985957146,
-0.00305946241132915,
0.05700581520795822,
-0.013416031375527382,
0.011468741111457348,
0.055293887853622437,
0.01961282081902027,
-0.05226464197039604,
-0.02295761927962303,
0.03246498107910156,
0.04005854204297066,
-0.02416977658867836,
-0.00534566817805171,
0.015805348753929138,
-0.06310690194368362,
0.005968346260488033,
0.009950608015060425,
0.050020694732666016,
-0.023783821612596512,
0.006405041553080082,
0.002998469630256295,
0.025644687935709953,
-0.011491840705275536,
0.06414209306240082,
-0.01790245622396469,
0.0061390334740281105,
-0.02381983771920204,
-0.021104151383042336,
0.0020426094997674227,
0.028031134977936745,
0.027887510135769844,
0.04634736478328705,
-0.05142628028988838,
0.015648115426301956,
0.03098008781671524,
0.026119830086827278,
0.008185338228940964,
0.005682391580194235,
0.007310353685170412,
0.02208627574145794,
-0.030798235908150673,
-0.011915391311049461,
-0.009799649938941002,
-0.005906959995627403,
-0.053602203726768494,
0.03330818563699722,
0.041114795953035355,
-0.0194467231631279,
-0.023961303755640984,
-0.039702579379081726,
0.005609394051134586,
0.05140695720911026,
-0.002149424282833934,
0.010933216661214828,
0.027542224153876305,
0.04686814919114113,
0.05788527801632881,
0.030429614707827568,
-0.0013835974968969822,
-0.08940736949443817,
-0.0006908067152835429,
0.015439558774232864,
-0.009875609539449215,
0.0001288786152144894,
-0.015078840777277946,
0.06748529523611069,
-0.015469304285943508,
0.009316669777035713,
0.026309873908758163,
-0.09428772330284119,
-0.0005616035195998847,
0.0373380109667778,
-0.006263588555157185,
0.04940536990761757,
0.016689982265233994,
-0.032611798495054245,
0.048405829817056656,
0.0449054092168808,
0.030005110427737236,
0.05857899785041809,
-0.015436332672834396,
0.030346814543008804,
-0.005100970156490803,
-0.03564427047967911,
-0.021858172491192818,
0.04986125975847244,
-0.038623686879873276,
-0.03673168644309044,
0.04818235710263252,
-0.03863786533474922,
-0.0076989163644611835,
0.021788422018289566,
0.013643773272633553,
-0.0020348273683339357,
-0.0001768346264725551,
-0.021150870248675346,
0.018827954307198524,
-0.014226589351892471,
-0.05459006503224373,
0.03443320840597153,
0.03352595493197441,
-0.049018967896699905,
-0.0007925165118649602,
-0.024903392419219017,
0.07875041663646698,
0.044692885130643845,
-0.018601078540086746,
0.021318290382623672,
0.038737520575523376,
0.008242514915764332,
0.017149057239294052,
0.03218730539083481,
-0.03381654992699623,
0.0498652309179306,
-0.014357208274304867,
0.005743371322751045,
-0.02497178688645363,
0.08776997774839401,
-0.04681217670440674,
0.007233503274619579,
0.05120271444320679,
-0.028438933193683624,
0.06884363293647766,
-0.00458369730040431,
0.023398559540510178,
0.0026796534657478333,
-0.0270854402333498,
-0.03715967386960983,
-0.02085971273481846,
-0.01493124384433031,
0.015924997627735138,
-0.014416464604437351,
-0.060116954147815704,
0.035909056663513184,
-0.04732044041156769,
0.023584075272083282,
-0.00205902848392725,
0.03990625962615013,
0.022275449708104134,
0.06249828636646271,
-0.0029591252095997334,
-0.052641354501247406,
-0.024534476920962334,
-0.004694583360105753,
-0.11065512150526047,
-0.04327107593417168,
-0.008808320388197899,
0.06371475756168365,
0.024557650089263916,
0.0821729376912117,
-0.02537289448082447,
-0.0021377343218773603,
-0.01885019615292549,
-0.029304523020982742,
0.008282310329377651,
0.00724458321928978,
-0.006574033759534359,
-0.05196268856525421,
-0.018711650744080544,
-0.01755264773964882,
0.0718834325671196,
-0.044723354279994965,
-0.02340507321059704,
-0.019171934574842453,
-0.019949505105614662,
-0.009675173088908195,
0.015440528281033039,
0.017422284930944443,
0.025910064578056335,
0.032553959637880325,
0.031725455075502396,
0.019988827407360077,
0.023532336577773094,
0.041958361864089966,
0.04979938268661499,
0.011452511884272099,
-0.01796167530119419,
-0.048110347241163254,
0.02988397143781185,
-0.028108030557632446,
-0.009074470028281212,
0.039488665759563446,
0.01977638341486454,
-0.017513608559966087,
0.0006240270449779928,
0.030725032091140747,
0.014144966378808022,
-0.2842649221420288,
-0.008522155694663525,
0.022376256063580513,
-0.0018151553813368082,
-0.0002654616255313158,
-0.0318269208073616,
0.05486057698726654,
-0.0012675932375714183,
-0.020955724641680717,
0.009557042270898819,
-0.005769480485469103,
0.028125062584877014,
-0.01619657874107361,
0.06953597068786621,
0.06441128998994827,
0.06423161923885345,
0.012652488425374031,
-0.018990421667695045,
-0.019217832013964653,
0.018967684358358383,
-0.04984492436051369,
-0.04694510996341705,
-0.03260060399770737,
0.024355659261345863,
-0.006631722208112478,
0.03236407786607742,
-0.058931950479745865,
-0.012405835092067719,
-0.045842960476875305,
0.0011984760640189052,
0.0018348386511206627,
-0.03524451330304146,
0.002499685622751713,
0.038593653589487076,
0.04291469603776932,
-0.03514781966805458,
0.024218639358878136,
0.026763174682855606,
-0.028347013518214226,
0.0017706798389554024,
0.023187745362520218,
0.007853448390960693,
-0.01642879843711853,
0.02007058635354042,
0.06584486365318298,
0.012724349275231361,
-0.044705215841531754,
-0.010987517423927784,
-0.02298424020409584,
0.03135128319263458,
-0.010924865491688251,
-0.0065153311006724834,
-0.042586710304021835,
0.01785007305443287,
-0.0486319400370121,
-0.015049810521304607,
-0.03751420974731445,
-0.030601756647229195,
-0.009599987417459488,
0.003763197921216488,
0.02452615275979042,
-0.053441621363162994,
0.003684771480038762,
-0.02183610014617443,
-0.03225354850292206,
-0.0424746610224247,
-0.09004558622837067,
-0.04320362210273743,
0.05051470920443535,
0.040315840393304825,
-0.010542146861553192,
0.0019314574310556054,
-0.004736362025141716,
-0.10806263983249664,
0.01961284689605236,
-0.003209953662008047,
0.017531486228108406,
0.01945422776043415,
-0.006523790769279003,
0.03914966434240341,
0.0032312513794749975,
-0.04376073554158211,
0.024741623550653458,
-0.02757895551621914,
-0.003333353204652667,
-0.01769155077636242,
0.024410611018538475,
-0.02914261445403099,
-0.024391312152147293,
-0.047831252217292786,
0.02647825889289379,
0.04357011243700981,
0.028692835941910744,
0.008669987320899963,
0.04233232140541077,
0.04691847413778305,
0.059043701738119125,
0.06436697393655777,
0.029970752075314522,
0.02785026654601097,
0.025786126032471657,
-0.08771774172782898,
-0.01818736456334591,
-0.07494400441646576,
-0.0362040139734745,
0.02194806933403015,
-0.05776922404766083,
-0.014124960638582706,
0.017114579677581787,
-0.025309186428785324,
0.004613709636032581,
0.0025177928619086742,
-0.026587558910250664,
-0.014713948592543602,
-0.0209707822650671,
-0.021722447127103806,
-0.008020737208425999,
0.036056745797395706,
0.022324254736304283,
0.007312908302992582,
0.0010850592516362667,
0.04082930088043213,
-0.027741150930523872,
0.027026761323213577,
-0.004877402447164059,
0.012114384211599827,
-0.0008354452438652515,
-0.010031076148152351,
-0.026718709617853165,
-0.024721067398786545,
0.02209777943789959,
0.030092379078269005,
-0.02408147044479847,
0.026094909757375717,
0.05300439894199371,
0.0006356845260597765,
-0.014230487868189812,
-0.020753461867570877,
0.024886080995202065,
-0.06290207803249359,
0.0349857360124588,
0.0038387486711144447,
0.02186788059771061,
0.02680468186736107,
0.05783284828066826,
-0.016583947464823723,
0.0025426247157156467,
0.01143472921103239,
-0.006661585997790098,
-0.02625889889895916,
0.014446370303630829,
-0.05390755832195282,
-0.008674654178321362,
-0.028038810938596725,
-0.01651379093527794,
-0.01887720450758934,
-0.008714591152966022,
-0.0642770379781723,
0.023897618055343628,
-0.0619928278028965,
0.051331777125597,
0.024679189547896385,
-0.03915201127529144,
-0.01467890851199627,
-0.005690803285688162,
0.05225060135126114,
-0.01518678106367588,
-0.030603278428316116,
-0.014638837426900864,
-0.005143208894878626,
0.028482802212238312,
-0.027654357254505157,
-0.010588668286800385,
-0.05314188823103905,
-0.02942795678973198,
0.006916377693414688,
-0.00697711668908596,
-0.006016696337610483,
-0.030263474211096764,
0.04975544661283493,
-0.03091045469045639,
-0.039325784891843796,
-0.0035801890771836042,
0.011232865042984486,
0.06533277034759521,
0.036871861666440964,
0.015164444223046303,
0.019191116094589233,
-0.03457730636000633,
0.04061517119407654,
-0.011266286484897137,
0.007879843935370445,
-0.023295143619179726,
-0.03807825222611427,
-0.030901040881872177,
-0.029259854927659035,
0.00036638625897467136,
0.023594388738274574,
-0.020860718563199043,
-0.013867112807929516,
-0.019955698400735855,
-0.011982311494648457,
-0.0405561700463295,
-0.0055824164301157,
0.01840464025735855,
-0.04975512623786926,
0.029591118916869164,
0.0445922389626503,
-0.044139958918094635,
0.039006538689136505,
-0.03245103359222412,
-0.048565953969955444,
-0.06336858868598938,
-0.01760939694941044,
0.025628719478845596,
-0.03953852877020836,
-0.016163483262062073,
-0.03855502977967262,
0.011965209618210793,
0.005553289316594601,
0.016522321850061417,
-0.028330393135547638,
-0.03573877364397049,
0.03708053380250931,
0.005248598288744688,
0.051366597414016724,
-0.03567587584257126,
-0.021619921550154686,
-0.051060184836387634,
-0.026680249720811844,
-0.005307297687977552,
-0.04465359076857567,
0.005370362661778927,
0.057150259613990784,
0.0023658231366425753,
0.009853798896074295,
-0.03462723270058632,
0.07058414816856384,
0.0034749917685985565,
-0.01585237868130207,
-0.024314530193805695,
0.013975624926388264,
-0.013874334283173084,
-0.010245620273053646,
0.03462259843945503,
0.011776349507272243,
-0.01860124059021473,
0.03051522560417652,
0.010110230185091496,
0.03366870805621147,
0.02199886180460453,
0.0132093895226717,
-0.04980946332216263,
0.03135693073272705,
0.0525064654648304,
-0.03272227197885513,
0.005782452877610922,
-0.06523866206407547,
-0.038445666432380676,
0.02855915017426014,
0.007096115965396166,
0.038570284843444824,
0.004978131968528032,
0.014914852567017078,
0.042723771184682846,
0.008079218678176403,
0.03221682459115982,
-0.003048770362511277,
0.02047594077885151,
-0.03311069309711456,
0.025914868339896202,
-0.04287028685212135,
-0.0031239993404597044,
0.05532262846827507,
-0.04163365438580513,
0.027033144608139992,
-0.001029657549224794,
-0.03192634880542755,
0.04803166538476944,
-0.061945993453264236,
-0.06672489643096924,
-0.00926803145557642,
-0.02510509081184864,
0.0015238083433359861,
0.03225024789571762,
-0.05568581447005272,
-0.010602783411741257,
-0.010903747752308846,
-0.03626858443021774,
0.0033306179102510214,
-0.015999561175704002,
0.02426406741142273,
0.00035879475763067603,
0.01217880379408598,
-0.026496633887290955,
0.021321475505828857,
0.01154980156570673,
0.04907411336898804,
0.0026023623067885637,
0.04213875159621239,
-0.01737331785261631,
0.04352894425392151,
0.043307721614837646,
0.0032174894586205482,
0.034374598413705826,
0.024067431688308716,
-0.005376813467592001,
-0.03799416124820709,
0.05952040106058121,
0.010376488789916039,
-0.020476723089814186,
-0.06976532936096191,
0.04053724557161331,
0.01930832490324974,
-0.0580720491707325,
-0.057682063430547714,
0.02823890745639801,
-0.02413342148065567,
0.030492840334773064,
0.007323873694986105,
0.015883781015872955,
0.020455779507756233,
0.06261830776929855,
0.01858513057231903,
0.08109809458255768,
0.053862761706113815,
0.013555203564465046,
0.00527338357642293,
0.021176598966121674,
0.0870007798075676,
0.08988647162914276,
0.07030383497476578,
-0.009145849384367466,
0.07407607138156891,
-0.003616997739300132,
-0.05840684100985527,
-0.014335330575704575,
0.023075148463249207,
-0.0175726730376482,
-0.03607318922877312,
-0.017669469118118286,
0.1085398942232132,
0.003626224584877491,
0.05841587483882904,
-0.053889200091362,
-0.027550509199500084,
0.011041482910513878,
-0.01662345603108406,
0.000992181827314198,
0.007113045081496239,
0.03748488053679466,
0.0028636327479034662,
-0.04915137588977814,
0.005878183990716934,
0.05269313231110573,
-0.0339166522026062,
-0.004036936908960342,
0.019659889861941338,
-0.006882592104375362,
0.012326732277870178,
0.027503592893481255,
0.037024613469839096,
0.08009151369333267,
-0.05555161088705063,
-0.046342652291059494,
-0.010922412388026714,
0.0038444544188678265,
0.010800594463944435,
0.05559738725423813,
0.033922214061021805,
0.0011373584857210517,
0.018978646025061607,
-0.026082094758749008,
0.02610333450138569,
0.04135643690824509,
0.019255761057138443,
0.013992993161082268,
-0.05517052114009857,
-0.00537146907299757,
0.04298383370041847,
-0.0000751270999899134,
-0.06678186357021332,
-0.04512348026037216,
0.00343637284822762,
-0.05710671842098236,
-0.07456392794847488,
-0.036601535975933075,
0.047582149505615234,
-0.003906837664544582,
-0.03900615870952606,
-0.014092453755438328,
-0.022917957976460457,
0.02530871331691742,
0.0624987967312336,
-0.07400533556938171,
-0.032666031271219254,
0.03909037262201309,
0.00004575083949021064,
-0.01356346346437931,
0.009685727767646313,
0.01457434892654419,
-0.03040149062871933,
-0.011619805358350277,
0.04749936982989311,
0.01987503096461296,
0.013876395300030708,
-0.010770396329462528,
-0.02469182386994362,
-0.092574343085289,
0.022190220654010773,
0.02804211899638176,
-0.057748548686504364,
-0.08530163764953613,
0.050082504749298096,
-0.0211750790476799,
0.02640848606824875,
0.06200050190091133,
0.06251674890518188,
0.012249245308339596,
-0.03490843251347542,
0.01223844476044178,
0.0037082305643707514,
0.012141924351453781,
0.0457538366317749,
-0.013307427987456322,
0.07525753229856491,
0.026346560567617416,
-0.050527140498161316,
-0.04583077132701874,
0.05914079770445824,
-0.011421404778957367,
0.007132763974368572,
-0.036440037190914154,
-0.027828531339764595,
-0.016524694859981537,
-0.08390826731920242,
-0.03312385082244873,
0.008699342608451843,
-0.014126425608992577,
-0.04719306156039238,
0.0032697829883545637,
0.010520454496145248,
0.0033928698394447565,
-0.028684459626674652,
-0.030793221667408943,
0.016169577836990356,
-0.024729197844862938,
-0.007508306298404932,
-0.059345927089452744,
0.02758246660232544,
-0.02654896304011345,
-0.013407758437097073,
-0.0196027010679245,
-0.05510876700282097,
-0.01233894657343626,
0.006680767983198166,
0.0347277969121933,
-0.007069885265082121,
0.016593895852565765,
-0.01013736892491579
] |
303 |
Decentralized Optimization with Coupled Constraints
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=AJM52ygi6Y
|
[
"Demyan Yarmoshik",
"Alexander Rogozin",
"Nikita Kiselev",
"Daniil Dorin",
"Alexander Gasnikov",
"Dmitry Kovalev"
] |
Poster
|
We consider the decentralized minimization of a separable objective $\sum_{i=1}^{n} f_i(x_i)$, where the variables are coupled through an affine constraint $\sum_{i=1}^n\left(\mathbf{A}_i x_i - b_i\right) = 0$.
We assume that the functions $f_i$, matrices $\mathbf{A}_i$, and vectors $b_i$ are stored locally by the nodes of a computational network, and that the functions $f_i$ are smooth and strongly convex.
This problem has significant applications in resource allocation and systems control and can also arise in distributed machine learning.
We propose lower complexity bounds for decentralized optimization problems with coupled constraints and a first-order algorithm achieving the lower bounds. To the best of our knowledge, our method is also the first linearly convergent first-order decentralized algorithm for problems with general affine coupled constraints.
|
decentralized optimization, convex optimization, affine constraints
|
Optimal algorithm and lower bound for smooth strongly convex setup
| 13,609 |
2407.02020
|
[
-0.048028916120529175,
0.011819600127637386,
0.013535847887396812,
0.01868104375898838,
0.02791496179997921,
0.040975745767354965,
0.01831994578242302,
-0.00734713627025485,
-0.011760452762246132,
-0.044191874563694,
-0.018800918012857437,
-0.0033217393793165684,
-0.06575878709554672,
-0.0036619724705815315,
-0.01781046763062477,
0.03611713647842407,
0.03300870209932327,
0.004846304189413786,
0.014445261098444462,
0.042582157999277115,
-0.03515702858567238,
0.00547768222168088,
0.010664460249245167,
0.04696850851178169,
0.02657553181052208,
0.02409893274307251,
0.02300151437520981,
0.025921158492565155,
-0.011504920199513435,
0.0028666506987065077,
0.020728081464767456,
-0.009568418376147747,
0.0273662731051445,
-0.0197345782071352,
0.008721425198018551,
0.03130115196108818,
0.002908037742599845,
0.011595403775572777,
0.011709163896739483,
0.023045260459184647,
-0.03363541141152382,
0.04756923019886017,
0.011606726795434952,
0.03326728940010071,
-0.058770570904016495,
0.04073157161474228,
-0.061468563973903656,
0.025989241898059845,
0.01406522374600172,
-0.04825539514422417,
-0.09006526321172714,
-0.010589937679469585,
0.029173851013183594,
-0.009597213938832283,
-0.014054153114557266,
0.024772748351097107,
0.020098265260457993,
-0.04572493955492973,
-0.01029910147190094,
-0.05354353412985802,
-0.038975007832050323,
0.033759478479623795,
0.013247827999293804,
-0.004535617772489786,
-0.022524971514940262,
-0.008066415786743164,
0.014398155733942986,
0.050482556223869324,
-0.038508858531713486,
0.0031151603907346725,
-0.03405937924981117,
-0.011615379713475704,
0.019158994778990746,
0.007503356318920851,
-0.007427333854138851,
-0.04829593002796173,
0.017790479585528374,
-0.009264958091080189,
0.041282594203948975,
0.02492307685315609,
-0.00996443722397089,
0.0379059799015522,
0.022669171914458275,
0.006431969814002514,
-0.003620241768658161,
-0.009718758054077625,
-0.049611013382673264,
-0.013543803244829178,
-0.09565424174070358,
0.06483320891857147,
-0.023521166294813156,
-0.03705231100320816,
-0.007386252749711275,
0.04599139466881752,
0.0211032647639513,
-0.031204871833324432,
0.031507037580013275,
0.038203202188014984,
0.06008348986506462,
0.014754412695765495,
-0.0019496162422001362,
-0.02007083036005497,
-0.00216951547190547,
-0.024974137544631958,
-0.08661895245313644,
-0.02126101776957512,
-0.0347161740064621,
-0.02455335110425949,
0.007037119474261999,
-0.0010698848636820912,
-0.029650148004293442,
0.03480257838964462,
0.007222812157124281,
-0.026367994025349617,
-0.08245714753866196,
0.07120222598314285,
-0.006977686192840338,
0.010015252977609634,
-0.0017668704967945814,
-0.005520287435501814,
0.061858754605054855,
0.04847661033272743,
-0.009608106687664986,
0.08327366411685944,
-0.0005947827594354749,
0.008492441847920418,
0.028358807787299156,
0.02891915664076805,
-0.055078499019145966,
-0.05478449910879135,
0.004578800871968269,
0.03677179664373398,
0.02632080763578415,
-0.03204171359539032,
-0.010193096473813057,
-0.04197070747613907,
-0.01824079267680645,
0.04968678206205368,
0.02089306339621544,
-0.003200652077794075,
-0.016570383682847023,
-0.0019051977433264256,
0.06101278215646744,
-0.010705067776143551,
0.04751100018620491,
-0.017148450016975403,
0.05553463101387024,
-0.04053792729973793,
-0.05922485142946243,
-0.008354373276233673,
-0.014176435768604279,
-0.010300865396857262,
-0.01428510993719101,
-0.06705760955810547,
0.01745307818055153,
0.03825075179338455,
0.044444385915994644,
0.0335380882024765,
-0.02757778950035572,
0.03271731734275818,
0.021383430808782578,
0.01102987676858902,
0.015385795384645462,
-0.00025174746406264603,
-0.008437162265181541,
-0.06249869987368584,
0.036730412393808365,
0.05098790302872658,
-0.0085720494389534,
0.0006651727017015219,
-0.022202588617801666,
-0.04326140135526657,
0.02831985056400299,
0.01975916139781475,
-0.0006220439681783319,
-0.003007651073858142,
0.0672902911901474,
0.011379634961485863,
0.03714734688401222,
0.032637421041727066,
-0.09036316722631454,
0.039995837956666946,
0.030378544703125954,
-0.016252290457487106,
-0.0018115428974851966,
-0.0025797816924750805,
0.08065422624349594,
-0.009063312783837318,
0.03435593098402023,
0.013349703513085842,
-0.04803392291069031,
-0.021629853174090385,
0.00873030535876751,
-0.03027160093188286,
0.03505810722708702,
0.006915705744177103,
-0.028781138360500336,
-0.005347325932234526,
-0.010626799426972866,
0.01834622398018837,
0.06346964836120605,
-0.03670371696352959,
0.03282544016838074,
0.013209541328251362,
-0.03350720554590225,
0.024114470928907394,
0.0350368358194828,
-0.04366280138492584,
-0.04303165525197983,
0.026517929509282112,
-0.02245990000665188,
0.0037374484818428755,
0.02110983245074749,
-0.009375101886689663,
0.03336550295352936,
-0.011906826868653297,
-0.014348265714943409,
0.027367442846298218,
0.05341683328151703,
-0.04847750812768936,
0.04580935463309288,
0.01769072562456131,
-0.03489670529961586,
0.07613983750343323,
-0.015271877869963646,
0.0674823671579361,
0.09603113681077957,
-0.020404715090990067,
0.0036789895966649055,
0.02621723897755146,
0.013105769641697407,
0.0062369974330067635,
0.003553439397364855,
-0.0033452389761805534,
0.014322305098176003,
0.035201579332351685,
-0.01625841297209263,
-0.03669049218297005,
0.0816178247332573,
-0.04211710765957832,
-0.019705073907971382,
0.06599142402410507,
-0.025753779336810112,
0.06445609033107758,
-0.01621808111667633,
0.0006463167374022305,
0.034615758806467056,
0.01654985547065735,
-0.004617656581103802,
0.0026349422987550497,
-0.029109735041856766,
-0.020458415150642395,
-0.01455563586205244,
0.0010603602277114987,
0.036339301615953445,
-0.06776384264230728,
0.04882068559527397,
-0.003132043406367302,
0.08038922399282455,
0.0439864881336689,
0.032345015555620193,
0.03307134285569191,
0.004315677564591169,
-0.05477359890937805,
-0.04233972728252411,
-0.1036137267947197,
-0.05864299088716507,
0.0335833765566349,
0.0565977543592453,
0.028977559879422188,
0.07737081497907639,
-0.03941933438181877,
0.03538601100444794,
-0.01583835668861866,
-0.022838065400719643,
0.002244063885882497,
0.012248401530086994,
-0.0020483590196818113,
-0.0366048663854599,
-0.019590014591813087,
0.028241897001862526,
0.06059417128562927,
0.0020962099079042673,
-0.012979192659258842,
-0.023583365604281425,
-0.05164547264575958,
0.042747434228658676,
-0.06851058453321457,
0.00005541564314626157,
0.0009128078236244619,
0.000995396520011127,
0.02083524316549301,
-0.037029117345809937,
0.027337361127138138,
0.019855733960866928,
0.048389188945293427,
0.04024713113903999,
0.01163097470998764,
0.014955497346818447,
-0.03085554577410221,
0.006020312663167715,
-0.012533416040241718,
-0.040976669639348984,
-0.002612689509987831,
-0.024318480864167213,
0.0031738511752337217,
0.018371302634477615,
0.0012238926719874144,
-0.28002652525901794,
-0.016734948381781578,
-0.01383005641400814,
0.00951799750328064,
0.03393041342496872,
-0.011900904588401318,
0.02313818782567978,
-0.04138743877410889,
-0.043965552002191544,
-0.006756748538464308,
0.010554821230471134,
0.016408929601311684,
0.022241832688450813,
0.083500437438488,
0.03206611052155495,
0.02108454331755638,
-0.029407653957605362,
-0.014974917285144329,
0.02839120849967003,
0.006943561136722565,
-0.028061633929610252,
-0.08531685173511505,
0.0004989492008462548,
-0.0021441143471747637,
0.013759614899754524,
0.011116634123027325,
-0.04971027374267578,
-0.005527463275939226,
-0.05327298864722252,
-0.014955845661461353,
-0.06372187286615372,
-0.017838848754763603,
-0.02258170209825039,
0.010357900522649288,
0.04339148849248886,
0.024397000670433044,
0.016109054908156395,
-0.005306204315274954,
0.012695122510194778,
0.004677315708249807,
-0.023375753313302994,
-0.005126056727021933,
-0.037538036704063416,
-0.02480512484908104,
0.03609706088900566,
0.04820875823497772,
0.0057488782331347466,
-0.03441314399242401,
-0.0232338048517704,
0.03599199280142784,
0.0199099350720644,
-0.052503012120723724,
-0.01750820316374302,
-0.017119726166129112,
0.01681162789463997,
-0.04432860016822815,
-0.00695140240713954,
-0.0479632131755352,
-0.009880323894321918,
0.04626162722706795,
-0.006207453086972237,
-0.06622389703989029,
-0.006676942575722933,
-0.046239130198955536,
0.010403472930192947,
-0.04218115285038948,
-0.0814950168132782,
-0.07000140100717545,
0.05005739629268646,
0.03397158905863762,
0.03880980983376503,
0.003828431712463498,
-0.04164520278573036,
-0.10207019746303558,
-0.013800505548715591,
-0.007845685817301273,
0.00814546924084425,
-0.008126110769808292,
0.007628269959241152,
0.049008142203092575,
-0.040796488523483276,
-0.04417344927787781,
0.008382965810596943,
0.03052297979593277,
0.014693666249513626,
-0.01590770296752453,
0.027081184089183807,
-0.023672914132475853,
-0.01719062775373459,
-0.034613266587257385,
0.019361183047294617,
-0.018742108717560768,
0.052937667816877365,
-0.020587820559740067,
0.07098529487848282,
0.01102257240563631,
0.017911510542035103,
0.015368149615824223,
0.03371052443981171,
-0.00460188090801239,
0.008622786961495876,
-0.08725868910551071,
-0.01419114414602518,
-0.015340179204940796,
-0.01865924894809723,
0.023610975593328476,
-0.06068924814462662,
-0.005649353377521038,
0.0469045452773571,
0.002597031882032752,
-0.003048376878723502,
-0.07120105624198914,
0.019165752455592155,
-0.052930377423763275,
-0.010936284437775612,
-0.03796651214361191,
-0.013671533204615116,
0.06214514374732971,
0.018823394551873207,
-0.001806505722925067,
-0.04422954097390175,
0.048368267714977264,
0.01827004738152027,
0.010198556818068027,
-0.0189354345202446,
0.026948435232043266,
0.002574673155322671,
-0.014676634222269058,
0.008329557254910469,
-0.03227914869785309,
0.03435574844479561,
0.03963746130466461,
0.03445833921432495,
0.0024399077519774437,
0.03462492674589157,
0.0006287941359914839,
-0.049286484718322754,
-0.036654770374298096,
0.05702589079737663,
0.0041836039163172245,
0.05406457930803299,
0.013985521160066128,
0.009164922870695591,
-0.011851858347654343,
0.0518585667014122,
0.031681306660175323,
0.005516097880899906,
0.009973767213523388,
-0.011136998422443867,
-0.018355010077357292,
-0.0006518522277474403,
-0.048576902598142624,
-0.0034292778000235558,
-0.004053964279592037,
0.027260836213827133,
-0.0008767307153902948,
0.04149028658866882,
-0.007578310091048479,
0.012838917784392834,
-0.06629666686058044,
0.015585778281092644,
-0.015232245437800884,
-0.025228897109627724,
-0.01671922765672207,
0.05737605690956116,
0.06773988902568817,
-0.023594778031110764,
-0.033402398228645325,
-0.025574877858161926,
-0.011983959004282951,
0.046048201620578766,
-0.007776714861392975,
-0.03989201784133911,
-0.006071328651160002,
-0.022643279284238815,
-0.02502705715596676,
0.022547168657183647,
-0.02638201415538788,
-0.031083563342690468,
0.0016815554117783904,
0.010006522759795189,
-0.0306069478392601,
-0.012106964364647865,
0.028850391507148743,
0.07515133172273636,
0.014726262539625168,
0.005822406150400639,
-0.023471521213650703,
-0.01980135776102543,
0.05491141974925995,
0.01601225510239601,
0.024964939802885056,
-0.0038507459685206413,
-0.02455192618072033,
0.004155749920755625,
-0.010463899001479149,
0.041343122720718384,
0.015703340992331505,
-0.0177912674844265,
0.005973218008875847,
-0.02355620078742504,
0.00576810585334897,
-0.030365094542503357,
0.03167758509516716,
0.01815851405262947,
-0.05809285491704941,
0.00579935684800148,
0.038703594356775284,
-0.009569886140525341,
0.01704530604183674,
-0.020783398300409317,
-0.0368000753223896,
-0.03714752942323685,
0.01655963808298111,
0.03139630705118179,
-0.014973945915699005,
-0.02954792231321335,
0.004196126479655504,
0.011083899065852165,
-0.013105451129376888,
-0.0056995791383087635,
-0.003821809310466051,
-0.0284041166305542,
-0.052700225263834,
-0.017511647194623947,
0.07059338688850403,
0.003903033444657922,
-0.01339001301676035,
-0.00323837180621922,
0.0013926386600360274,
0.039104435592889786,
-0.04444434866309166,
-0.024088570848107338,
0.04511134698987007,
0.00019837035506498069,
0.05287761986255646,
-0.028554968535900116,
0.010701353661715984,
-0.07636658847332001,
-0.03237682208418846,
-0.011105552315711975,
0.010448736138641834,
-0.028467407450079918,
-0.044245388358831406,
-0.02288200333714485,
0.0364280603826046,
0.015364199876785278,
-0.0017568544717505574,
-0.0067208316177129745,
0.0050279926508665085,
-0.0026561629492789507,
0.018642548471689224,
-0.060919132083654404,
-0.021444417536258698,
0.035600800067186356,
0.005010873079299927,
-0.04070533066987991,
-0.05151255056262016,
0.038217756897211075,
0.018876684829592705,
-0.08615531027317047,
0.03371495380997658,
-0.03073209896683693,
0.05426373705267906,
0.019650105386972427,
0.039251457899808884,
0.00457534147426486,
-0.008590931072831154,
0.02501467429101467,
-0.04236530512571335,
-0.03021327778697014,
-0.06553889811038971,
0.01699504815042019,
0.03025224059820175,
-0.020923344418406487,
0.05451904609799385,
0.031317099928855896,
-0.014219632372260094,
0.0020113415084779263,
-0.027138175442814827,
-0.052236735820770264,
0.018420597538352013,
-0.0489172488451004,
0.006662534084171057,
0.039062563329935074,
-0.07258766144514084,
-0.03586180880665779,
0.0030533429235219955,
-0.056924182921648026,
-0.026564689353108406,
0.0071953157894313335,
0.007484504021704197,
0.01828671433031559,
-0.003464958630502224,
-0.04106884077191353,
0.0028601984959095716,
0.04687589406967163,
0.03572077676653862,
0.014860730618238449,
0.006349185481667519,
-0.06113903224468231,
0.023168817162513733,
0.027517694979906082,
0.00937116052955389,
-0.014372770674526691,
0.06533707678318024,
-0.01527746208012104,
-0.03985338658094406,
0.05237993225455284,
-0.002427401952445507,
-0.02619771659374237,
-0.066630057990551,
0.0339069738984108,
0.012366795912384987,
-0.03952537849545479,
-0.018560167402029037,
0.020973432809114456,
-0.061908140778541565,
0.015431690961122513,
-0.0012794011272490025,
0.020028740167617798,
0.00006711985770380124,
0.06482037156820297,
-0.018074581399559975,
-0.010644219815731049,
0.07091417908668518,
0.020856838673353195,
-0.006353813223540783,
-0.008617346175014973,
0.08433443307876587,
0.06984768062829971,
0.031239842996001244,
-0.03338636830449104,
0.05683301016688347,
-0.053038690239191055,
-0.04357383772730827,
-0.005283624865114689,
0.004375299904495478,
-0.04109407588839531,
-0.004323442000895739,
-0.015009012073278427,
0.06888826936483383,
-0.005050035193562508,
0.07376605272293091,
-0.047276418656110764,
-0.00649994844570756,
0.03568542003631592,
-0.009246326051652431,
0.012039924040436745,
0.04010343924164772,
0.03187861293554306,
0.027126748114824295,
-0.012347716838121414,
-0.0023470292799174786,
-0.015793660655617714,
0.015639645978808403,
0.01544120255857706,
-0.018461259081959724,
-0.008604047819972038,
0.021652283146977425,
0.01573607325553894,
-0.015650350600481033,
0.05845822021365166,
-0.044888705015182495,
-0.05113117769360542,
-0.014068071730434895,
0.015203380957245827,
-0.03855755180120468,
0.03083241730928421,
0.028179548680782318,
-0.052293915301561356,
0.030873948708176613,
-0.023312991484999657,
0.04268394038081169,
0.01354636438190937,
0.029331667348742485,
0.010646839626133442,
-0.008259166032075882,
0.012338055297732353,
0.008921469561755657,
0.03690864145755768,
-0.04772124066948891,
-0.052345409989356995,
-0.04605249688029289,
-0.08124139904975891,
-0.01636645384132862,
-0.019039617851376534,
0.022296706214547157,
0.02152431383728981,
-0.037151236087083817,
-0.024391120299696922,
-0.018336696550250053,
0.01570424996316433,
0.010622442699968815,
-0.03976945951581001,
-0.004433704074472189,
0.022320153191685677,
0.01111410092562437,
0.0530182309448719,
0.017093796283006668,
0.04026251658797264,
-0.03629529848694801,
-0.002362872939556837,
0.014493151567876339,
0.02760513871908188,
0.021313847973942757,
0.001969211734831333,
-0.021695055067539215,
-0.05400291085243225,
-0.010582328774034977,
0.008273824118077755,
-0.06272336840629578,
-0.07699060440063477,
0.038483042269945145,
-0.009445463307201862,
0.010971274226903915,
0.06307052820920944,
-0.016580523923039436,
0.0009387361351400614,
-0.034496475011110306,
0.012143530882894993,
-0.009000390768051147,
-0.020567117258906364,
0.04719340428709984,
-0.02827942557632923,
0.04290982335805893,
0.03156028687953949,
-0.01535816304385662,
-0.0670115128159523,
0.07616365700960159,
-0.01603241264820099,
0.00598554965108633,
-0.045670077204704285,
-0.01047601643949747,
-0.014500509016215801,
-0.122530996799469,
-0.04115983843803406,
0.03196108713746071,
-0.02051602676510811,
-0.06479047238826752,
-0.008220944553613663,
0.023172028362751007,
-0.02735493890941143,
0.013249622657895088,
-0.02115047536790371,
-0.013953899033367634,
-0.042417172342538834,
-0.00395751278847456,
-0.06455366313457489,
0.02845015376806259,
0.001477608922868967,
-0.02361888624727726,
-0.042538367211818695,
-0.06287597864866257,
-0.015213465318083763,
0.019159559160470963,
0.03463050723075867,
0.035667408257722855,
0.03092554211616516,
0.03536170348525047
] |
304 |
You Only Prune Once: Designing Calibration-Free Model Compression With Policy Learning
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=5RZoYIT3u6
|
[
"Ayan Sengupta",
"Siddhant Chaudhary",
"Tanmoy Chakraborty"
] |
Poster
|
The ever-increasing size of large language models (LLMs) presents significant challenges for deployment due to their heavy computational and memory requirements. Current model pruning techniques attempt to alleviate these issues by relying heavily on external calibration datasets to determine which parameters to prune or compress, thus limiting their flexibility and scalability across different compression ratios. Moreover, these methods often cause severe performance degradation, particularly in downstream tasks, when subjected to higher compression rates. In this paper, we propose *PruneNet*, a novel model compression method that addresses these limitations by reformulating model pruning as a policy learning process. PruneNet decouples the pruning process from the model architecture, eliminating the need for calibration datasets. It learns a stochastic pruning policy to assess parameter importance solely based on intrinsic model properties while preserving the spectral structure to minimize information loss. PruneNet can compress the LLaMA-2-7B model in just 15 minutes, achieving over 80\% retention of its zero-shot performance with a 30\% compression ratio, outperforming existing methods that retain only 75\% performance. Furthermore, on complex multitask language understanding tasks, PruneNet demonstrates its robustness by preserving up to 80\% performance of the original model, proving itself a superior alternative to conventional structured compression techniques.
|
Model Compression, Large Language Models, Structured Pruning
| null | 13,607 |
2501.15296
|
[
-0.03067953512072563,
-0.03638815879821777,
-0.021291891112923622,
0.038191184401512146,
0.03819870948791504,
0.05039104074239731,
0.006473855581134558,
-0.0071700396947562695,
-0.03163367509841919,
-0.02474472112953663,
-0.012515163980424404,
0.0244777649641037,
-0.05525383725762367,
-0.013943718746304512,
0.021227393299341202,
0.06660933792591095,
0.02824612706899643,
-0.005739505868405104,
0.01680814102292061,
0.031213702633976936,
0.019181745126843452,
-0.013735310174524784,
0.04708071053028107,
0.02703879401087761,
0.04069657623767853,
0.0061544859781861305,
0.03072189725935459,
0.01584119349718094,
-0.0378897450864315,
0.003063403768464923,
0.033703550696372986,
-0.004538602661341429,
0.012284385971724987,
-0.026980655267834663,
0.022968126460909843,
0.008340226486325264,
-0.057865310460329056,
0.03391733020544052,
-0.009426750242710114,
0.03056660108268261,
-0.02300320565700531,
0.018966589123010635,
-0.002400645986199379,
0.004221729002892971,
-0.043199051171541214,
0.002764233388006687,
-0.09210892021656036,
0.024516768753528595,
0.0053896307945251465,
-0.05216091126203537,
-0.12234342098236084,
0.04014319181442261,
-0.013663074001669884,
-0.020173434168100357,
-0.006429286673665047,
0.030371490865945816,
0.041180599480867386,
-0.11100023239850998,
-0.0030577119905501604,
-0.042484965175390244,
-0.04705318063497543,
-0.014884094707667828,
0.019082030281424522,
0.01940065063536167,
-0.010983076877892017,
-0.03366411477327347,
0.014921428635716438,
0.039598722010850906,
-0.09307834506034851,
-0.03924646973609924,
-0.011685243807733059,
0.024147002026438713,
0.005738844629377127,
0.02617940679192543,
0.02429208531975746,
-0.04025076702237129,
0.027331283316016197,
0.03479507192969322,
0.07409965246915817,
0.023853210732340813,
0.014521238394081593,
0.018656324595212936,
0.01981261372566223,
0.04551276937127113,
0.010188115760684013,
0.012626306153833866,
-0.05187496542930603,
-0.03754102811217308,
-0.09489552676677704,
0.006045976188033819,
-0.021145664155483246,
-0.056625764816999435,
0.029885396361351013,
0.01744776777923107,
-0.0005823998362757266,
0.01740136928856373,
0.011852020397782326,
0.030567076057195663,
0.019281666725873947,
0.011169405654072762,
-0.01027560792863369,
-0.03126907721161842,
0.04082196205854416,
0.02144676446914673,
-0.1269337236881256,
-0.02862660028040409,
-0.010246445424854755,
0.00518798129633069,
0.012037250213325024,
-0.006026582792401314,
-0.010246358811855316,
-0.030844271183013916,
0.017193568870425224,
-0.022113611921668053,
-0.09285128116607666,
0.025706946849822998,
-0.0035286250058561563,
-0.0047016507014632225,
0.004132332280278206,
0.008647413924336433,
0.0706457868218422,
0.0369788259267807,
0.022969072684645653,
0.07963990420103073,
-0.02715485356748104,
0.009133902378380299,
0.03516840562224388,
0.027141233906149864,
-0.008061288855969906,
-0.0618293434381485,
0.02421755902469158,
0.02902471087872982,
0.02705392800271511,
-0.012085743248462677,
-0.007310896646231413,
-0.011604659259319305,
0.009711074642837048,
0.02182270586490631,
0.032995402812957764,
-0.00494781881570816,
0.014419677667319775,
-0.002138726878911257,
0.04222138226032257,
-0.023093387484550476,
0.06105945631861687,
0.018232909962534904,
-0.035214826464653015,
-0.03025989606976509,
-0.040711499750614166,
-0.005584451369941235,
0.01749509759247303,
0.011898213997483253,
-0.021180501207709312,
-0.06757921725511551,
0.019494183361530304,
0.06537674367427826,
0.0033433057833462954,
0.007519139442592859,
-0.0006046310882084072,
0.026888234540820122,
0.01637815497815609,
-0.004745614714920521,
-0.06126698479056358,
0.033547695726156235,
-0.0063119931146502495,
-0.07407622039318085,
0.042756062000989914,
0.041198503226041794,
-0.024794692173600197,
-0.01624729111790657,
-0.05042438954114914,
-0.04912682995200157,
0.079288549721241,
-0.029606632888317108,
-0.024678179994225502,
0.01760399527847767,
0.057425279170274734,
-0.003748607123270631,
0.02419639192521572,
0.030683912336826324,
-0.08057224750518799,
0.024517808109521866,
0.023016780614852905,
-0.021804891526699066,
-0.010018476285040379,
-0.03733940050005913,
0.09932368993759155,
-0.03750625252723694,
0.015177884139120579,
0.011644894257187843,
-0.08099369704723358,
-0.01762409508228302,
0.01686365343630314,
0.009897230193018913,
0.06722334027290344,
0.0034743910655379295,
-0.005792541895061731,
0.03991048410534859,
0.011196993291378021,
0.04548202455043793,
0.047720059752464294,
-0.03321939706802368,
0.06136835739016533,
-0.019011301919817924,
-0.04273359104990959,
-0.007674873806536198,
-0.0071975188329815865,
-0.05872954800724983,
-0.03887925669550896,
0.007989427074790001,
-0.007245976477861404,
-0.010337951593101025,
0.02836131863296032,
0.0047071524895727634,
0.017704715952277184,
-0.018039625138044357,
-0.005209954455494881,
-0.010203557088971138,
0.03299097344279289,
-0.058744363486766815,
0.03789263218641281,
0.026042619720101357,
-0.03704582899808884,
0.0067456006072461605,
-0.02805968187749386,
0.06869953870773315,
0.06662286072969437,
0.001618187059648335,
-0.011685936711728573,
0.012204228900372982,
-0.002267334144562483,
-0.010038932785391808,
-0.0029677869752049446,
-0.03640087693929672,
0.0300340186804533,
-0.016731757670640945,
-0.003946544136852026,
-0.03637756407260895,
0.027639804407954216,
-0.031686585396528244,
-0.008603859692811966,
0.073940210044384,
-0.014066703617572784,
0.05364428460597992,
-0.0054714735597372055,
0.018077468499541283,
0.027993062511086464,
-0.014016527682542801,
-0.007172742392867804,
-0.021907253190875053,
-0.020205819979310036,
0.010996595956385136,
0.0018172819400206208,
-0.03731324151158333,
0.0038531720638275146,
-0.03876844793558121,
-0.03048504702746868,
-0.0005468418821692467,
0.07858883589506149,
0.05120047181844711,
0.012342722155153751,
-0.0014697887236252427,
-0.010046794079244137,
-0.029099928215146065,
-0.012994029559195042,
-0.10780750215053558,
-0.016384797170758247,
-0.03196988254785538,
0.051982466131448746,
0.0027120583690702915,
0.022749245166778564,
-0.010378566570580006,
0.028290286660194397,
-0.03297559171915054,
-0.006759558338671923,
0.020061489194631577,
0.018313441425561905,
0.02817322500050068,
-0.058081965893507004,
-0.01563246175646782,
0.0014857091009616852,
0.04192535579204559,
-0.015331779606640339,
-0.014342489652335644,
-0.03790482133626938,
-0.03598836064338684,
0.023984549567103386,
-0.03162007033824921,
-0.007697558030486107,
0.008184883743524551,
0.046762462705373764,
0.012335444800555706,
-0.025403108447790146,
0.007918687537312508,
0.04557505622506142,
0.07815378159284592,
0.05662107840180397,
0.024227624759078026,
0.007291718386113644,
0.018623296171426773,
-0.018020151183009148,
0.016755789518356323,
-0.027459686622023582,
0.026401368901133537,
-0.026354549452662468,
-0.014861074276268482,
0.024153074249625206,
-0.006177303846925497,
-0.27421507239341736,
0.009598363190889359,
0.02060515806078911,
-0.01477991696447134,
0.050781916826963425,
-0.004193040542304516,
0.05462862551212311,
-0.020392553880810738,
-0.024044159799814224,
0.008492211811244488,
0.021049976348876953,
0.02023724839091301,
0.026508361101150513,
0.053865354508161545,
0.05406319722533226,
0.05297346040606499,
-0.005378147587180138,
-0.022979596629738808,
0.017538253217935562,
0.045623455196619034,
0.004908370319753885,
-0.06836356222629547,
-0.005587687250226736,
0.045185722410678864,
0.002907615387812257,
0.04328989237546921,
-0.08667948096990585,
-0.005484502296894789,
-0.029428299516439438,
0.0007566490676254034,
-0.012413686141371727,
-0.018132386729121208,
-0.015250969678163528,
0.029827263206243515,
0.0071424450725317,
0.014304368756711483,
0.054208822548389435,
0.017831124365329742,
0.03807483986020088,
0.029901936650276184,
0.013710731640458107,
-0.020446639508008957,
-0.017543187364935875,
0.014371036551892757,
0.05740942806005478,
0.021123582497239113,
-0.0622844435274601,
-0.024224502965807915,
0.0004154240887146443,
0.030809132382273674,
0.0053162164986133575,
-0.03401274234056473,
0.0030471314676105976,
0.028228800743818283,
0.017889417707920074,
0.01440663356333971,
0.0022679101675748825,
-0.015782147645950317,
-0.01429955568164587,
0.0012873391387984157,
0.0004175752110313624,
-0.05218230560421944,
-0.016816098242998123,
-0.055172767490148544,
-0.009710375219583511,
-0.04426991939544678,
-0.05750050023198128,
-0.055745214223861694,
0.02278335578739643,
0.04339875280857086,
-0.02153373323380947,
0.007340714801102877,
-0.0028836585115641356,
-0.07774917781352997,
0.0128128407523036,
-0.006582675967365503,
-0.03609732910990715,
-0.019624849781394005,
-0.0005154205136932433,
0.06665500998497009,
-0.051114581525325775,
-0.05385937914252281,
0.0021322951652109623,
0.010664012283086777,
0.039198532700538635,
-0.0188828743994236,
0.03288194164633751,
-0.035852640867233276,
-0.015562174841761589,
-0.05268656462430954,
0.018723541870713234,
0.00977057870477438,
0.02560744620859623,
-0.008996354416012764,
0.038783252239227295,
0.02478818967938423,
0.028854530304670334,
0.05859234929084778,
0.028954578563570976,
0.007168910466134548,
0.007088571786880493,
-0.0740664005279541,
-0.027498098090291023,
-0.04277680814266205,
-0.02682153694331646,
0.03433389216661453,
-0.06077922135591507,
-0.03087080642580986,
0.04313384369015694,
0.010625536553561687,
-0.030984720215201378,
-0.028825264424085617,
0.02114732563495636,
-0.011487078852951527,
-0.03512834385037422,
-0.0019849592354148626,
0.00986512191593647,
0.016452942043542862,
0.02039201743900776,
-0.015736723318696022,
-0.02592606469988823,
0.03117220103740692,
-0.027513938024640083,
0.0007748869247734547,
-0.001355463988147676,
-0.020728006958961487,
0.017050644382834435,
-0.021724382415413857,
-0.027634678408503532,
-0.02135630138218403,
0.013246961869299412,
0.05209507793188095,
-0.005240960046648979,
0.0010691068600863218,
0.05871453881263733,
0.024877099320292473,
0.008942672051489353,
-0.010636426508426666,
0.03741804137825966,
0.013744709081947803,
0.002419424708932638,
0.0038079889491200447,
0.029978692531585693,
0.017902875319123268,
0.010680770501494408,
0.026990070939064026,
0.04179077595472336,
-0.009492781013250351,
0.010413476265966892,
0.002524404088035226,
0.03352545574307442,
-0.04460819810628891,
-0.004532177932560444,
-0.020466921851038933,
0.023666610941290855,
-0.007544920314103365,
0.033261846750974655,
-0.02513565868139267,
0.03133523464202881,
-0.06075263395905495,
0.04386701434850693,
0.019532879814505577,
-0.0583382323384285,
-0.0007754956604912877,
0.009674080647528172,
0.03446917235851288,
-0.009425126016139984,
-0.008589096367359161,
0.034296825528144836,
-0.003874508198350668,
0.006247965153306723,
-0.014946401119232178,
-0.02178952656686306,
-0.007438631262630224,
0.015283032320439816,
0.000335138727677986,
0.020765429362654686,
0.0054184067994356155,
-0.03913382068276405,
0.028111731633543968,
0.022957367822527885,
-0.01743818074464798,
-0.021321222186088562,
0.00205617374740541,
0.06320660561323166,
0.013085602782666683,
0.0028796594124287367,
0.03288613259792328,
-0.04916252940893173,
0.03146858885884285,
-0.007116008549928665,
0.014259684830904007,
-0.03093051351606846,
-0.04580991715192795,
-0.042041074484586716,
-0.028813624754548073,
0.010295521467924118,
0.016665533185005188,
-0.020522231236100197,
0.004408505279570818,
0.005823832470923662,
-0.0011254650307819247,
-0.044760990887880325,
-0.027902163565158844,
0.0032192966900765896,
-0.08232032507658005,
-0.010884852148592472,
0.04820699244737625,
-0.009452972561120987,
0.028364935889840126,
-0.028199853375554085,
-0.030609242618083954,
-0.05512440577149391,
-0.026954879984259605,
0.01863800175487995,
-0.03157424181699753,
-0.018081441521644592,
-0.0036212631966918707,
0.026434235274791718,
-0.01763775572180748,
-0.009439876303076744,
0.002433406887575984,
0.011159410700201988,
-0.024945393204689026,
0.012539682909846306,
0.06016362085938454,
-0.031121239066123962,
0.01976604387164116,
-0.01308608241379261,
-0.02401595562696457,
0.02320527657866478,
-0.06164412945508957,
0.02826678939163685,
0.06753750145435333,
-0.01153203472495079,
0.004129299893975258,
-0.06292886286973953,
0.05931796506047249,
-0.03862536698579788,
-0.008526182733476162,
0.0011752330465242267,
0.023506788536906242,
-0.05620991066098213,
0.0043000406585633755,
0.00215220358222723,
0.028097232803702354,
0.020503191277384758,
-0.003973578568547964,
0.010968825779855251,
0.004504302982240915,
0.025224147364497185,
0.035808950662612915,
-0.07403360307216644,
0.0001604437129572034,
0.06243671476840973,
-0.035908043384552,
-0.045473843812942505,
-0.06603679805994034,
-0.020638151094317436,
0.003293948946520686,
-0.033823031932115555,
0.026368169113993645,
-0.039364129304885864,
0.042610786855220795,
0.02580931782722473,
0.026024727150797844,
0.003040180541574955,
-0.028098296374082565,
0.014661900699138641,
-0.05167701840400696,
0.006079215090721846,
-0.05364333093166351,
-0.04207700863480568,
0.09223099052906036,
-0.03403962403535843,
0.0199761800467968,
0.006355654913932085,
-0.03962958976626396,
0.026476634666323662,
-0.015365354716777802,
-0.03726982697844505,
0.03105582855641842,
-0.0131189851090312,
0.011880774050951004,
0.04280329495668411,
-0.046538956463336945,
-0.03405432775616646,
0.001843594596721232,
-0.04608790948987007,
0.015992408618330956,
-0.002346446504816413,
0.053871314972639084,
-0.02992089092731476,
-0.008821340277791023,
-0.04967903345823288,
0.005898830946534872,
0.026172887533903122,
0.039794549345970154,
0.02709539607167244,
-0.0004243300063535571,
-0.03967832773923874,
0.05548185482621193,
0.017282266169786453,
0.02174185961484909,
-0.01270617451518774,
-0.002860826440155506,
-0.028193246573209763,
-0.062354713678359985,
0.058244045823812485,
0.006679195445030928,
-0.01284834649413824,
-0.04164985194802284,
0.0680304765701294,
0.03495919704437256,
-0.0563567578792572,
-0.01913483999669552,
0.03056858852505684,
-0.05782777816057205,
-0.006467325612902641,
-0.012055760249495506,
-0.0017715105786919594,
-0.012650636024773121,
0.08276916295289993,
0.022309787571430206,
0.04911217465996742,
0.0749155580997467,
-0.005409005098044872,
-0.027548713609576225,
-0.005275233183056116,
0.06877681612968445,
0.05136586353182793,
0.03906013444066048,
-0.010020173154771328,
0.055192966014146805,
-0.04022686928510666,
-0.034772541373968124,
0.06161414086818695,
0.02916855551302433,
-0.018842844292521477,
-0.06105587258934975,
0.032949626445770264,
0.07820603996515274,
-0.009948955848813057,
0.07358694821596146,
-0.02862580493092537,
0.0003154815931338817,
0.016824942082166672,
-0.01250618789345026,
-0.002867305651307106,
0.053339436650276184,
0.036714017391204834,
0.01798790507018566,
-0.021819768473505974,
-0.0313100628554821,
0.02616739831864834,
-0.022350773215293884,
0.008966309949755669,
-0.0008881091489456594,
-0.023002661764621735,
-0.02307671122252941,
-0.017116941511631012,
0.04121417924761772,
0.10316069424152374,
-0.036737047135829926,
-0.03427981585264206,
0.022804509848356247,
0.022491533309221268,
0.01912674866616726,
0.036233920603990555,
-0.008293068036437035,
-0.04678230732679367,
0.010471734218299389,
-0.03423807770013809,
-0.01618211716413498,
-0.0035443464294075966,
-0.017159223556518555,
-0.002340486506000161,
-0.010851051658391953,
-0.011966926045715809,
-0.011943304911255836,
0.020900767296552658,
-0.0761624425649643,
-0.05498223006725311,
-0.06262344121932983,
-0.053325872868299484,
-0.052314598113298416,
-0.06488584727048874,
0.011125239543616772,
0.0027395770885050297,
-0.017592525109648705,
-0.0011395104229450226,
-0.058042045682668686,
0.01069067046046257,
0.03888759762048721,
-0.07358996570110321,
-0.0018033041851595044,
0.025680141523480415,
-0.004985697101801634,
-0.018667273223400116,
0.037055328488349915,
0.049700479954481125,
-0.004999134689569473,
-0.018021415919065475,
0.01524612121284008,
0.03021107241511345,
0.028956539928913116,
0.002910532522946596,
-0.014958972111344337,
-0.08919185400009155,
0.01143533643335104,
0.022011077031493187,
-0.05339311435818672,
-0.07814030349254608,
0.029553186148405075,
-0.03135934844613075,
0.030820544809103012,
0.07114037126302719,
0.0006762947305105627,
0.032910048961639404,
-0.0440184660255909,
-0.012901688925921917,
0.018523061648011208,
-0.006196300033479929,
0.03422790765762329,
-0.008652152493596077,
0.057746898382902145,
0.057890668511390686,
-0.016884339973330498,
-0.041799262166023254,
0.01418756041675806,
-0.005066081415861845,
0.019824037328362465,
-0.015101409517228603,
-0.00908745639026165,
-0.027945946902036667,
-0.06877411156892776,
-0.018523480743169785,
0.04596324637532234,
0.0036091820802539587,
-0.03531474620103836,
-0.006999064236879349,
-0.029719460755586624,
-0.0005299803451634943,
-0.033011529594659805,
-0.021164488047361374,
-0.009664976969361305,
-0.03468194231390953,
-0.019718511030077934,
-0.07573089748620987,
0.033387091010808945,
-0.02988499589264393,
0.007760726381093264,
-0.029371172189712524,
-0.03500988706946373,
-0.0054582045413553715,
0.020742880180478096,
0.04215998575091362,
-0.001281295670196414,
-0.006152079440653324,
0.0008090237970463932
] |
305 |
FreDF: Learning to Forecast in the Frequency Domain
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=4A9IdSa1ul
|
[
"Hao Wang",
"Lichen Pan",
"Yuan Shen",
"Zhichao Chen",
"Degui Yang",
"Yifei Yang",
"Sen Zhang",
"Xinggao Liu",
"Haoxuan Li",
"Dacheng Tao"
] |
Poster
|
Time series modeling presents unique challenges due to autocorrelation in both historical data and future sequences. While current research predominantly addresses autocorrelation within historical data, the correlations among future labels are often overlooked. Specifically, modern forecasting models primarily adhere to the Direct Forecast (DF) paradigm, generating multi-step forecasts independently and disregarding label correlations over time. In this work, we demonstrate that the learning objective of DF is biased in the presence of label correlation. To address this issue, we propose the Frequency-enhanced Direct Forecast (FreDF), which mitigates label correlation by learning to forecast in the frequency domain, thereby reducing estimation bias. Our experiments show that FreDF significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods and is compatible with a variety of forecast models. Code is available at https://github.com/Master-PLC/FreDF.
|
Time series, Long-term Forecast
|
Learning to forecast in the frequency domain improves forecasting performance.
| 13,602 | null |
[
0.005575843621045351,
-0.04401431232690811,
0.019469423219561577,
0.038072578608989716,
0.030401771888136864,
0.006757799070328474,
0.013230307027697563,
0.022061245515942574,
-0.04241533949971199,
-0.03934113308787346,
0.006899032276123762,
0.02982308715581894,
-0.08924615383148193,
0.01955461874604225,
-0.0052484748885035515,
0.06123185157775879,
0.04816298559308052,
-0.0033281887881457806,
0.012578681111335754,
0.036881253123283386,
-0.01811649091541767,
-0.011605894193053246,
0.02570520155131817,
0.03601926565170288,
0.029020100831985474,
-0.005208231974393129,
0.023892030119895935,
-0.004876075312495232,
-0.0234929621219635,
0.0010887951357290149,
0.04614562913775444,
0.01115506887435913,
-0.01181051041930914,
-0.006521101109683514,
-0.005422255955636501,
0.0353906974196434,
-0.008699215948581696,
-0.009869706816971302,
-0.017752502113580704,
0.00755659956485033,
-0.04181964695453644,
-0.01653299853205681,
0.032751306891441345,
0.008383109234273434,
-0.07270736247301102,
0.03126300871372223,
-0.11415756493806839,
-0.008834341540932655,
0.01930808089673519,
-0.056595321744680405,
-0.10564638674259186,
0.034643303602933884,
0.038394492119550705,
-0.022401604801416397,
-0.015415635891258717,
0.05187809467315674,
0.018374057486653328,
-0.0799645334482193,
-0.035986874252557755,
-0.04082115367054939,
0.019190357998013496,
0.020716333761811256,
0.02076561562716961,
-0.013430982828140259,
0.007099737413227558,
-0.056459903717041016,
-0.022144146263599396,
0.04291253909468651,
-0.047141462564468384,
-0.022046847268939018,
-0.047237470746040344,
0.024745194241404533,
-0.024550987407565117,
0.00981161929666996,
-0.02759402245283127,
-0.051797255873680115,
0.016605911776423454,
0.012427168898284435,
0.09356053918600082,
-0.014226959086954594,
0.0035713620018213987,
0.01473292987793684,
0.08449317514896393,
0.01266319677233696,
0.015443377196788788,
0.009070145897567272,
-0.02414678782224655,
-0.036066774278879166,
-0.07634752988815308,
0.07501533627510071,
-0.0047588343732059,
-0.054796911776065826,
0.014609121717512608,
0.00994155090302229,
-0.019992874935269356,
0.016343506053090096,
0.043307095766067505,
-0.004594374913722277,
-0.011189357377588749,
0.04041833057999611,
-0.023094795644283295,
-0.02956761047244072,
0.023660849779844284,
0.028299739584326744,
-0.0773387923836708,
-0.04058738425374031,
-0.04354916512966156,
-0.027881724759936333,
-0.001066594384610653,
0.01759686879813671,
-0.03695060685276985,
0.009676950983703136,
0.06471122801303864,
-0.00021053338423371315,
-0.051159005612134933,
0.03272544965147972,
-0.01450875774025917,
0.006669941823929548,
0.002288945484906435,
-0.021861689165234566,
0.059051573276519775,
0.0319572389125824,
-0.03404270112514496,
0.039051081985235214,
-0.02913883700966835,
0.018191684037446976,
0.03512011468410492,
-0.001714722951874137,
-0.019627295434474945,
-0.030178505927324295,
-0.012028931640088558,
0.009892785921692848,
-0.01824217289686203,
-0.017159460112452507,
0.008566027507185936,
-0.0009951296960934997,
-0.03839448466897011,
-0.00789166335016489,
0.02854262664914131,
0.02653777040541172,
0.038024019449949265,
-0.012534979730844498,
0.026448380202054977,
-0.022631810978055,
0.04141171649098396,
0.009470985271036625,
-0.010323602706193924,
-0.036428745836019516,
-0.024776017293334007,
-0.0165953878313303,
0.013099598698318005,
-0.0005162356537766755,
-0.019872652366757393,
-0.051623888313770294,
0.02041497454047203,
0.058520421385765076,
0.023041347041726112,
0.000602428917773068,
0.026586921885609627,
-0.0033030749764293432,
-0.005187597591429949,
0.00569471251219511,
-0.032626450061798096,
0.015162738971412182,
-0.02078390121459961,
-0.056921929121017456,
0.09280361980199814,
0.022117191925644875,
-0.03657328337430954,
0.037788499146699905,
-0.026627831161022186,
-0.021817130967974663,
0.054486893117427826,
0.0058615244925022125,
0.04231114685535431,
0.011774774640798569,
0.04957694932818413,
-0.028522536158561707,
0.02236820012331009,
-0.005108695011585951,
-0.08889768272638321,
0.03088311478495598,
0.03890449181199074,
-0.020139653235673904,
0.020985538139939308,
-0.020497914403676987,
0.07168365269899368,
-0.023398730903863907,
0.041229672729969025,
0.018311629071831703,
-0.02433488704264164,
-0.022796183824539185,
0.010226214304566383,
-0.02395959571003914,
0.03497421741485596,
0.0007919209892861545,
-0.021513476967811584,
0.043856941163539886,
0.007270977832376957,
0.05034318566322327,
0.07216265797615051,
-0.009248745627701283,
0.021020127460360527,
-0.0017668353393673897,
-0.03993065655231476,
-0.0061727361753582954,
0.0266156867146492,
-0.04433073103427887,
-0.03685832768678665,
0.005740403197705746,
-0.017943598330020905,
-0.0013817286817356944,
0.03310506418347359,
-0.007774864323437214,
0.02435671165585518,
0.009723776951432228,
-0.020007381215691566,
0.04101415351033211,
-0.03561551123857498,
-0.03970761224627495,
0.007461380213499069,
0.025120778009295464,
-0.044759538024663925,
0.0331142395734787,
-0.022328699007630348,
0.09083102643489838,
0.08221851289272308,
-0.03760208934545517,
0.009503924287855625,
0.015341202728450298,
0.03169161453843117,
0.0035517378710210323,
0.025504564866423607,
-0.03547780215740204,
0.02009657584130764,
0.00967224221676588,
-0.014266262762248516,
-0.0294964537024498,
0.03386314958333969,
-0.023045340552926064,
0.02747308649122715,
0.0562756322324276,
-0.051148079335689545,
0.0680987611413002,
0.021342908963561058,
0.03432032838463783,
0.05420253053307533,
-0.018212871626019478,
-0.029879847541451454,
-0.0011170119978487492,
-0.019767453894019127,
0.013475688174366951,
-0.01361613254994154,
-0.02992655523121357,
-0.008154000155627728,
-0.06857766211032867,
-0.00973283126950264,
-0.005689871497452259,
0.06788244843482971,
0.06712344288825989,
0.031257208436727524,
-0.005167479161173105,
0.00030733642051927745,
-0.019902143627405167,
0.014283466152846813,
-0.1099667102098465,
-0.04228876531124115,
-0.0170165803283453,
0.051361918449401855,
0.03567739576101303,
0.012719233520328999,
-0.005538789089769125,
0.04220692813396454,
0.005584183149039745,
-0.02220521867275238,
0.014953200705349445,
0.06185990571975708,
-0.0028137234039604664,
-0.047330036759376526,
-0.02768612839281559,
0.0037640249356627464,
0.06321478635072708,
0.02008700929582119,
-0.0343962125480175,
-0.05066758021712303,
-0.04698615521192551,
-0.0013725380413234234,
-0.010343888774514198,
-0.01109337154775858,
0.0025191386230289936,
-0.0337032824754715,
0.02839336171746254,
-0.014939946122467518,
0.02918217144906521,
0.009425219148397446,
0.07384999841451645,
0.022346992045640945,
0.0010909693082794547,
-0.017977746203541756,
-0.008650735951960087,
-0.004297077190130949,
-0.002047183457762003,
0.024230265989899635,
-0.021549709141254425,
-0.0025364141911268234,
0.013160835951566696,
-0.0036354968324303627,
-0.018146485090255737,
-0.2750178575515747,
-0.010488570667803288,
0.03585022687911987,
-0.010493837296962738,
0.025062808766961098,
-0.006679700221866369,
0.05308755859732628,
-0.0013736605178564787,
-0.019228842109441757,
0.011037304066121578,
0.010039878077805042,
0.023218894377350807,
-0.011332597583532333,
0.06106869876384735,
0.01776745170354843,
0.008719499222934246,
0.014146066270768642,
-0.054367102682590485,
0.00879048090428114,
0.03211439400911331,
0.004960694815963507,
-0.05258866026997566,
-0.02940220944583416,
0.03351530432701111,
-0.02147802710533142,
0.033941540867090225,
-0.06850061565637589,
-0.018768806010484695,
-0.053299568593502045,
0.012855569832026958,
-0.011152601800858974,
-0.015712231397628784,
-0.0011152256047353148,
0.024841051548719406,
0.03132282942533493,
-0.012834573164582253,
0.02250613272190094,
0.05345703288912773,
0.018335264176130295,
0.01813548617064953,
-0.004797677509486675,
-0.009711135178804398,
-0.03171583637595177,
0.004752535838633776,
0.06514029949903488,
0.046131305396556854,
-0.014204951003193855,
-0.003066995879635215,
-0.028504472225904465,
0.03250410035252571,
-0.035705916583538055,
-0.008188484236598015,
-0.0031621011439710855,
-0.027751179412007332,
-0.014712771400809288,
-0.029628144577145576,
0.014974812045693398,
-0.007869057357311249,
0.0013303827727213502,
0.011441708542406559,
0.0007619039388373494,
-0.034918688237667084,
0.03007894940674305,
-0.050921373069286346,
-0.04291468858718872,
-0.03451878949999809,
-0.06282061338424683,
-0.040489014238119125,
0.07821443676948547,
0.03186970204114914,
-0.027335140854120255,
0.013569130562245846,
0.0078017390333116055,
-0.10642682015895844,
0.015309304930269718,
-0.002385646803304553,
0.017333190888166428,
0.00009022202721098438,
0.04046037048101425,
0.02686738409101963,
-0.01945461705327034,
-0.039581988006830215,
0.009424027986824512,
0.029097968712449074,
0.037740763276815414,
-0.0025936036836355925,
0.005823925137519836,
0.00924626924097538,
-0.03212396055459976,
-0.0483456589281559,
0.027781236916780472,
-0.04082530736923218,
0.05023200064897537,
0.024197768419981003,
0.042330097407102585,
0.04301341250538826,
-0.012737095355987549,
0.042870376259088516,
0.06173247843980789,
-0.020856618881225586,
0.010014496743679047,
-0.07326122373342514,
-0.021677955985069275,
-0.06600765883922577,
-0.012266899459064007,
-0.01343001239001751,
-0.04864486679434776,
-0.026196680963039398,
0.02455483190715313,
0.01886635832488537,
0.008030574768781662,
0.024171512573957443,
-0.00916237197816372,
-0.012752311304211617,
-0.033023543655872345,
-0.005063591990619898,
-0.01675797440111637,
-0.0031765876337885857,
0.01913355477154255,
0.006233858875930309,
-0.016631510108709335,
0.023431356996297836,
0.000055052831157809123,
-0.004733620677143335,
-0.030886657536029816,
-0.020703110843896866,
-0.02789372391998768,
-0.01952524669468403,
0.010115645825862885,
-0.012160035781562328,
0.015197096392512321,
0.032614484429359436,
0.01524649653583765,
0.044966816902160645,
0.062454335391521454,
-0.004304451402276754,
-0.01462378166615963,
-0.02343793213367462,
0.023567363619804382,
-0.031049693003296852,
0.007756222505122423,
0.0035783788189291954,
0.01824534498155117,
0.020462317392230034,
0.025175131857395172,
0.03169018402695656,
0.006331896409392357,
0.02996123395860195,
-0.0051498631946742535,
-0.03730378299951553,
0.03207498416304588,
0.007677955087274313,
-0.022331956773996353,
-0.048530351370573044,
-0.04886177182197571,
0.04470471292734146,
0.05393726006150246,
-0.0011883736588060856,
-0.023516783490777016,
-0.08311527967453003,
0.07500454783439636,
-0.012867948971688747,
0.002409345004707575,
-0.034921541810035706,
0.028683766722679138,
0.06086796894669533,
-0.04832925274968147,
0.01570475473999977,
0.06523679196834564,
0.01278485357761383,
-0.011615252122282982,
-0.01823095604777336,
-0.046381626278162,
-0.012371625751256943,
-0.021874211728572845,
-0.004477455746382475,
0.016469407826662064,
-0.05165872350335121,
-0.003012218279764056,
0.03260461986064911,
0.005895483773201704,
0.0042504314333200455,
-0.046790387481451035,
0.016460616141557693,
0.03739868104457855,
0.03186449781060219,
0.007638714741915464,
-0.026524970307946205,
-0.029077328741550446,
0.029613686725497246,
-0.007078591268509626,
0.0013861613115295768,
0.00843270868062973,
-0.03252987936139107,
-0.011574306525290012,
-0.04677847400307655,
0.02591111697256565,
0.05638742819428444,
-0.034223102033138275,
-0.004453436005860567,
-0.046801503747701645,
-0.003995305858552456,
-0.05229619890451431,
0.005061195697635412,
0.0069155446253716946,
-0.07887100428342819,
0.016951872035861015,
0.019456567242741585,
-0.018678389489650726,
-0.033761948347091675,
-0.052243538200855255,
-0.03191571310162544,
-0.08401812613010406,
-0.02495039626955986,
0.011957173235714436,
-0.003211077069863677,
-0.005081447772681713,
-0.010695896111428738,
0.025612199679017067,
0.004010570701211691,
0.024791240692138672,
-0.0049408660270273685,
-0.012462731450796127,
-0.012989248149096966,
0.042809657752513885,
0.040820974856615067,
-0.019992303103208542,
-0.01892990991473198,
0.010670183226466179,
-0.005685748998075724,
0.022466233000159264,
-0.05611487105488777,
0.03292926773428917,
0.05554415285587311,
-0.0028689466416835785,
0.014540424570441246,
-0.04227609559893608,
0.052800726145505905,
-0.022853126749396324,
-0.014538627117872238,
-0.0031564105302095413,
-0.0032243786845356226,
-0.011318603530526161,
-0.023438340052962303,
0.005356998182833195,
0.02371760457754135,
0.04375820234417915,
-0.009194308891892433,
0.0010381562169641256,
0.04566891863942146,
0.011650064028799534,
0.023588702082633972,
-0.05029597878456116,
0.005867644678801298,
0.03980492800474167,
-0.02192358486354351,
-0.051127154380083084,
-0.07728801667690277,
-0.005187411326915026,
0.0014180344296619296,
-0.0199314896017313,
0.02787264995276928,
-0.02888931892812252,
0.09107527136802673,
0.039333127439022064,
0.08121322840452194,
-0.00638785632327199,
-0.027952099218964577,
0.07392768561840057,
-0.018799863755702972,
-0.002136331982910633,
-0.052392296493053436,
0.015783118084073067,
0.06791182607412338,
0.029721742495894432,
0.035687580704689026,
-0.0063738226890563965,
-0.042590804398059845,
0.032596442848443985,
-0.017730461433529854,
-0.0610792301595211,
-0.008175906725227833,
-0.014632395468652248,
0.008815071545541286,
0.007801696192473173,
-0.034315839409828186,
-0.03454205021262169,
0.013476457446813583,
-0.040738046169281006,
-0.015029332600533962,
0.0183548666536808,
0.06026674062013626,
-0.018818190321326256,
-0.0072095668874681,
-0.027483388781547546,
0.006938052363693714,
0.01454378105700016,
0.058285199105739594,
-0.012445870786905289,
0.04580564796924591,
-0.03405647724866867,
0.09868592768907547,
0.03534192219376564,
-0.013379276730120182,
-0.016188381239771843,
-0.018129143863916397,
-0.02508634887635708,
-0.04482182860374451,
0.05492308735847473,
0.002245377516373992,
-0.037078455090522766,
-0.07471028715372086,
0.022687319666147232,
0.02404860407114029,
-0.0463591143488884,
0.0029139600228518248,
-0.018303385004401207,
-0.03010745719075203,
-0.011341171339154243,
0.043972983956336975,
-0.009259332902729511,
-0.05997009947896004,
0.04894620180130005,
0.024133605882525444,
0.026382172480225563,
0.06821727752685547,
0.01896081306040287,
0.024621520191431046,
0.018898116424679756,
0.033164266496896744,
0.05471120402216911,
0.06073298305273056,
-0.031651902943849564,
0.06729348748922348,
-0.02843352034687996,
-0.03372283652424812,
0.0006189406849443913,
0.01172985602170229,
-0.0177016481757164,
-0.0527278296649456,
0.028095705434679985,
0.07239791005849838,
0.050709664821624756,
0.06310670077800751,
-0.021422607824206352,
-0.0030681826174259186,
-0.002004431327804923,
0.011307029984891415,
0.03356373682618141,
0.0267164409160614,
-0.009604882448911667,
0.0031949833501130342,
-0.03652207553386688,
-0.056344591081142426,
0.0035378779284656048,
-0.007452021818608046,
0.043165095150470734,
0.009575268253684044,
0.012989752925932407,
-0.009407991543412209,
0.0027401403058320284,
0.05710851028561592,
0.07919048517942429,
-0.05464901775121689,
-0.03093659318983555,
-0.002895263722166419,
0.007116147316992283,
0.018582914024591446,
0.018755292519927025,
0.018884841352701187,
0.01681656762957573,
0.012604431249201298,
-0.03309132158756256,
-0.0008945667068473995,
0.020317191258072853,
0.00664528040215373,
0.0033497267868369818,
-0.04513444006443024,
-0.0386977344751358,
0.048619840294122696,
-0.012651273049414158,
-0.03527147322893143,
-0.049136340618133545,
-0.012609805911779404,
-0.05553516745567322,
-0.06777025759220123,
-0.05840569734573364,
0.02456415258347988,
-0.028065215796232224,
-0.021987903863191605,
-0.019511837512254715,
-0.023326091468334198,
0.0008292932761833072,
0.011979155242443085,
-0.06001410260796547,
-0.03492853045463562,
0.03462409973144531,
0.012269783765077591,
0.008632117882370949,
0.009058990515768528,
0.011931315064430237,
-0.030858296900987625,
-0.023295780643820763,
0.016235869377851486,
0.0008570682257413864,
0.039334364235401154,
0.03314988315105438,
-0.007263651583343744,
-0.07830385118722916,
0.025039974600076675,
0.01160686369985342,
-0.03754828870296478,
-0.07915421575307846,
0.05821797251701355,
-0.039259348064661026,
0.010144179686903954,
0.07358250766992569,
-0.0003575340087991208,
-0.0018608469981700182,
-0.06187565252184868,
-0.0017238063737750053,
0.005359698086977005,
0.015963401645421982,
0.04298170655965805,
-0.03571761026978493,
0.04728759825229645,
0.011712128296494484,
-0.005604707170277834,
-0.055458687245845795,
0.0033466091845184565,
-0.02083161100745201,
-0.050447627902030945,
-0.014490688219666481,
-0.0703955888748169,
-0.0390266478061676,
-0.08847758173942566,
-0.0041703167371451855,
-0.011803490109741688,
-0.03856651484966278,
-0.05099083483219147,
0.027747943997383118,
0.0032444335520267487,
0.008613470010459423,
-0.032578349113464355,
0.012999720871448517,
-0.030887680128216743,
-0.03084876574575901,
-0.0398050956428051,
-0.07373318821191788,
0.06444773077964783,
0.001361286616884172,
0.022830912843346596,
-0.03840382397174835,
-0.04842260107398033,
0.03459528088569641,
-0.027539914473891258,
0.0223076269030571,
0.03020479902625084,
0.009281096048653126,
-0.015413298271596432
] |
306 |
SageAttention: Accurate 8-Bit Attention for Plug-and-play Inference Acceleration
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=OL44KtasKc
|
[
"Jintao Zhang",
"Jia wei",
"Pengle Zhang",
"Jun Zhu",
"Jianfei Chen"
] |
Poster
|
The transformer architecture predominates across various models. As the heart of the transformer, attention has a computational complexity of $O(N^2)$, compared to $O(N)$ for linear transformations. When handling large sequence lengths, attention becomes the primary time-consuming component. Although quantization has proven to be an effective method for accelerating model inference, existing quantization methods primarily focus on optimizing the linear layer.
In response, we first analyze the feasibility of quantization in attention detailedly. Following that, we propose SageAttention, a highly efficient and accurate quantization method for attention. The OPS (operations per second) of our approach outperforms FlashAttention2 and xformers by about 2.1x and 2.7x, respectively. SageAttention also achieves superior accuracy performance over FlashAttention3. Comprehensive experiments confirm that our approach incurs almost no end-to-end metrics loss across diverse models—including those for large language processing, image generation, and video generation. The code is available at https://github.com/thu-ml/SageAttention.
|
Attention, Quantization, quantized attention, inference acceleration
|
We propose a quantization method for Attention that achieves speedups of 2.1x and 2.7x compared to FlashAttention2 and xformers, respectively, without lossing end-to-end metrics across various models.
| 13,596 | null |
[
0.017885206267237663,
-0.05598742514848709,
-0.007200523279607296,
0.037747807800769806,
0.0011850681621581316,
0.03685223311185837,
0.01911618746817112,
0.018206441774964333,
-0.03125575929880142,
-0.008627577684819698,
-0.03233426809310913,
0.01605207659304142,
-0.05620811507105827,
-0.008302940055727959,
-0.026449093595147133,
0.05705146864056587,
0.05103789642453194,
0.0005157481064088643,
0.03373001888394356,
0.011145183816552162,
0.009895304217934608,
-0.04214427247643471,
0.038293421268463135,
0.029803605750203133,
0.020437542349100113,
-0.01870792545378208,
0.005345633253455162,
-0.0023797741159796715,
-0.0353071354329586,
-0.015390422195196152,
0.016462361440062523,
-0.01995735429227352,
0.010028970427811146,
-0.02324940823018551,
0.0037178359925746918,
0.0024270215071737766,
-0.0579364188015461,
0.03168463334441185,
0.0361076295375824,
0.021468084305524826,
-0.04822441563010216,
-0.005987167824059725,
-0.010654017329216003,
-0.015704507008194923,
-0.06079007685184479,
-0.0016620535170659423,
-0.10046055167913437,
0.03282513469457626,
0.01099387463182211,
-0.01699645258486271,
-0.0856739804148674,
0.042485661804676056,
-0.010167442262172699,
0.014956814236938953,
0.00846948567777872,
0.02867683209478855,
0.04811137169599533,
-0.0885324478149414,
-0.014595967717468739,
-0.030153697356581688,
-0.008365592919290066,
0.005664006806910038,
0.02523491159081459,
-0.002598768100142479,
-0.01041088905185461,
0.002031346084550023,
-0.014345282688736916,
0.05603930726647377,
-0.052118707448244095,
-0.03111806884407997,
0.007430131547152996,
0.018223414197564125,
-0.014822663739323616,
0.006674240343272686,
-0.0024291148874908686,
-0.03481906279921532,
0.024923190474510193,
0.026199951767921448,
0.07494144886732101,
-0.005360787268728018,
0.007898110896348953,
0.03266160562634468,
0.010183933191001415,
0.055086515843868256,
0.017029931768774986,
0.0269303098320961,
0.006709722336381674,
-0.019342990592122078,
-0.10155895352363586,
0.03200863301753998,
-0.027771571651101112,
-0.06108731031417847,
0.015190831385552883,
0.0008201882592402399,
-0.013681312091648579,
0.036024052649736404,
0.03405445069074631,
0.0152097437530756,
0.017701957374811172,
-0.008337692357599735,
-0.002676898380741477,
-0.0019642245024442673,
0.03343487158417702,
-0.03597693145275116,
-0.10088364034891129,
-0.0034895683638751507,
0.01145560760051012,
-0.026000646874308586,
0.029603470116853714,
0.005273405462503433,
-0.009697181172668934,
-0.0076631102710962296,
0.007989606820046902,
-0.03302742540836334,
-0.08886327594518661,
0.006094399373978376,
-0.017230236902832985,
0.026540812104940414,
-0.04190394654870033,
0.03165454417467117,
0.05921298637986183,
0.04473685100674629,
0.006497844122350216,
0.06538986414670944,
0.00741307670250535,
0.019028622657060623,
0.011014898307621479,
0.020519208163022995,
0.006008228287100792,
-0.017262453213334084,
0.01467252615839243,
0.021383773535490036,
0.0021887223701924086,
0.02588401734828949,
0.003918101545423269,
-0.005073764361441135,
0.022489268332719803,
0.006719371769577265,
0.03605359420180321,
-0.04718969762325287,
0.01818513683974743,
-0.009040662087500095,
0.030685506761074066,
-0.026540379971265793,
0.06035132706165314,
-0.011898217722773552,
-0.028540775179862976,
-0.01881670579314232,
-0.03841244429349899,
0.018015850335359573,
-0.010002651251852512,
0.005942496471107006,
-0.0151832839474082,
-0.11676305532455444,
0.03730775788426399,
0.04811542481184006,
0.0003008508065249771,
0.03934985399246216,
0.009319246746599674,
0.012574899941682816,
-0.009297379292547703,
-0.028383972123265266,
-0.03035210818052292,
0.0036446473095566034,
-0.013868176378309727,
-0.05568626523017883,
0.033686280250549316,
-0.001336736255325377,
-0.037924278527498245,
-0.01849083974957466,
-0.035840779542922974,
-0.032822851091623306,
0.03744407370686531,
-0.0032928374130278826,
-0.03013424389064312,
0.020187264308333397,
0.057979680597782135,
0.01452102605253458,
0.026699192821979523,
0.062330856919288635,
-0.08236653357744217,
0.05252523720264435,
0.008515342138707638,
-0.03358585387468338,
0.018199186772108078,
-0.05403688922524452,
0.06804291903972626,
-0.013932992704212666,
-0.013170876540243626,
0.0007060443749651313,
-0.07453356683254242,
0.0017359224148094654,
-0.01805327646434307,
-0.006953544449061155,
0.06315562129020691,
-0.01513458602130413,
0.01463206484913826,
0.021497774869203568,
0.06440147757530212,
0.02982180379331112,
0.03489050641655922,
-0.025669746100902557,
0.054188378155231476,
-0.0023438804782927036,
-0.04835328832268715,
0.004465833306312561,
0.026549922302365303,
-0.040466926991939545,
-0.007455871440470219,
-0.010637865401804447,
-0.015549878589808941,
0.010180601850152016,
0.01220257394015789,
0.024572398513555527,
-0.031026048585772514,
0.01726660691201687,
-0.01028431486338377,
0.015805760398507118,
0.0275381188839674,
-0.06382539123296738,
0.00974961556494236,
0.04552660137414932,
-0.029659345746040344,
0.026517869904637337,
-0.03683485835790634,
0.10315907746553421,
0.04343319311738014,
-0.03671017289161682,
-0.018882842734456062,
0.019806332886219025,
0.0011264345375820994,
-0.022909458726644516,
-0.01383197121322155,
-0.057554036378860474,
0.021603316068649292,
-0.021868472918868065,
0.02014327049255371,
-0.025373246520757675,
0.06732121855020523,
-0.04143239185214043,
-0.0006201661308296025,
0.05487268418073654,
-0.019141171127557755,
0.03941086307168007,
0.01726922020316124,
0.04300472140312195,
0.03994666039943695,
-0.04339347407221794,
-0.009486737661063671,
-0.016381550580263138,
-0.03705352172255516,
0.006718087941408157,
0.0012810110347345471,
-0.028653718531131744,
0.004348834045231342,
-0.03499165549874306,
-0.024272745475172997,
0.00597834587097168,
0.06142798066139221,
0.054385729134082794,
0.020583976060152054,
0.001351945917122066,
0.009349020197987556,
0.0014624757459387183,
-0.009727773256599903,
-0.09503640234470367,
-0.031244998797774315,
-0.02093573473393917,
0.020857030525803566,
-0.014544256031513214,
0.04529882222414017,
0.022784067317843437,
0.03435694798827171,
-0.043404415249824524,
-0.011781839653849602,
0.003051970386877656,
0.046877529472112656,
0.017089389264583588,
0.0014041643589735031,
-0.01973695121705532,
-0.00228920578956604,
0.05290393903851509,
-0.005195525009185076,
-0.006789743434637785,
-0.006405068561434746,
-0.053965091705322266,
0.024133015424013138,
-0.0126279192045331,
0.0068387179635465145,
-0.0032215502578765154,
0.0426335446536541,
0.02386733517050743,
-0.022746704518795013,
0.031035805121064186,
0.043979257345199585,
0.05612396448850632,
0.07227808982133865,
-0.019101344048976898,
-0.030848955735564232,
0.01673164777457714,
-0.005505269393324852,
0.021973315626382828,
0.0009661741205491126,
0.0272084828466177,
-0.031739410012960434,
-0.013611676171422005,
0.025241782888770103,
-0.02839202806353569,
-0.26230475306510925,
-0.01165945827960968,
-0.030580559745430946,
-0.010103672742843628,
0.022007256746292114,
-0.04409217834472656,
0.02961953915655613,
-0.031662628054618835,
-0.030173752456903458,
0.037477899342775345,
0.012928502634167671,
0.00676762918010354,
0.015329718589782715,
0.026557840406894684,
0.04860551282763481,
0.028225906193256378,
0.007028848864138126,
0.0005573199596256018,
0.02446841076016426,
0.04694075509905815,
0.006356081459671259,
-0.08482737839221954,
-0.010016773827373981,
0.04404886066913605,
0.018519986420869827,
0.016035916283726692,
-0.0872100293636322,
-0.025812851265072823,
-0.021077558398246765,
-0.027068644762039185,
-0.008204164914786816,
-0.009175322949886322,
-0.0048269531689584255,
0.0635305717587471,
0.002741591539233923,
0.023069700226187706,
0.05989561602473259,
-0.0261747557669878,
0.02848590910434723,
-0.020503828302025795,
0.01776098646223545,
-0.028530480340123177,
-0.01640395075082779,
0.03337012976408005,
0.07890750467777252,
-0.015834148973226547,
-0.05314537510275841,
-0.018056092783808708,
-0.0006815700908191502,
0.03142505884170532,
-0.029107559472322464,
-0.028935318812727928,
-0.016964830458164215,
0.0031131927389651537,
-0.0037830332294106483,
-0.02039829082787037,
0.01534074917435646,
-0.012461086735129356,
-0.005349853076040745,
-0.004997957497835159,
0.00009941543248714879,
-0.03687115013599396,
-0.017861580476164818,
-0.01274125650525093,
-0.0051733870059251785,
-0.03672415763139725,
-0.034918081015348434,
-0.050763487815856934,
0.032437264919281006,
-0.0009193026344291866,
-0.020366620272397995,
0.023460986092686653,
-0.01483635138720274,
-0.09846038371324539,
-0.011492702178657055,
0.0017976858653128147,
-0.005490439012646675,
0.014413970522582531,
-0.024824317544698715,
0.05394330620765686,
-0.008255435153841972,
-0.087196946144104,
0.03126543387770653,
0.0051344409584999084,
0.015772180631756783,
-0.013387694954872131,
-0.0065729450434446335,
-0.05140126124024391,
0.007916518487036228,
-0.0272869523614645,
0.050478413701057434,
-0.028333565220236778,
0.022356951609253883,
-0.013800058513879776,
0.033126100897789,
0.038750164210796356,
0.03099450096487999,
0.06361355632543564,
0.01807636208832264,
0.010438406839966774,
0.03282393515110016,
-0.06785158812999725,
-0.0036740764044225216,
-0.048585329204797745,
-0.05086401477456093,
0.002751346444711089,
-0.020095041021704674,
-0.023295074701309204,
0.06914293020963669,
0.030651405453681946,
-0.04910954460501671,
-0.025669988244771957,
0.01077153068035841,
0.007962419651448727,
-0.023744525387883186,
-0.018517084419727325,
0.00037760287523269653,
0.013929462060332298,
0.019200846552848816,
-0.0395764485001564,
-0.014128657057881355,
0.00743587501347065,
-0.03981577605009079,
0.016671452671289444,
-0.021047042682766914,
-0.018061403185129166,
-0.0072834426537156105,
-0.015500885434448719,
-0.02081700786948204,
-0.004373704548925161,
0.04778415709733963,
0.059221960604190826,
-0.026000695303082466,
0.013834967277944088,
0.05746598169207573,
-0.0266029704362154,
0.014929522760212421,
0.004159738775342703,
0.04464716091752052,
0.0025641790125519037,
-0.00043057979200966656,
-0.028947731480002403,
0.01294630579650402,
0.04307958483695984,
0.011553766205906868,
0.003254236653447151,
0.009277349337935448,
0.008670402690768242,
-0.004613820929080248,
0.002875423990190029,
0.06774325668811798,
-0.052551768720149994,
-0.030172158032655716,
-0.006297027226537466,
-0.003472580574452877,
-0.013795449398458004,
0.003774716518819332,
-0.008600188419222832,
0.011975421570241451,
-0.04101001098752022,
0.030442411080002785,
0.03524870425462723,
0.0000761320989113301,
-0.003869097912684083,
0.04781581088900566,
0.020753132179379463,
0.0027467203326523304,
-0.026548394933342934,
0.007044269237667322,
0.03097718022763729,
-0.02686474286019802,
-0.01676006056368351,
-0.04812607541680336,
-0.016604337841272354,
0.012749907560646534,
0.014844964258372784,
0.007086973637342453,
-0.011363589204847813,
-0.01329950150102377,
0.052716877311468124,
0.0077183921821415424,
-0.028133492916822433,
0.01247692946344614,
0.007382451556622982,
0.08185610175132751,
0.01083240658044815,
-0.02540804073214531,
0.002126481616869569,
-0.039733219891786575,
0.034387096762657166,
0.011317717842757702,
-0.0009590756380930543,
-0.03251224011182785,
-0.02028702199459076,
-0.042871102690696716,
-0.04289514198899269,
0.014278695918619633,
0.00872790440917015,
-0.024528754875063896,
-0.012727380730211735,
-0.03925592452287674,
0.0267188660800457,
-0.02592390403151512,
0.0019769363570958376,
0.015412144362926483,
-0.07295025885105133,
-0.006075631361454725,
0.028426678851246834,
-0.022252827882766724,
0.025090547278523445,
-0.009304972365498543,
-0.014257128350436687,
-0.05218777060508728,
-0.0505276694893837,
-0.008190142922103405,
-0.018686778843402863,
0.019359270110726357,
-0.014543810859322548,
0.018317174166440964,
-0.040484484285116196,
0.024034136906266212,
-0.0006584309739992023,
0.0046959263272583485,
-0.023137176409363747,
0.029377933591604233,
0.027437396347522736,
-0.02571943961083889,
0.02560020610690117,
-0.014250543899834156,
-0.022189203649759293,
0.020390471443533897,
-0.05286112427711487,
0.02195042558014393,
0.056800052523612976,
-0.01370802242308855,
0.0030158869922161102,
-0.07564764469861984,
0.03575184941291809,
-0.005811829585582018,
-0.0012091310927644372,
0.022746702656149864,
0.0077740768902003765,
-0.051192618906497955,
0.05296486243605614,
-0.0027218465693295,
0.019379567354917526,
0.028164653107523918,
0.013814957812428474,
0.0052702464163303375,
0.037181563675403595,
0.002585645532235503,
0.01778964139521122,
-0.046694062650203705,
0.008799294009804726,
0.06827022135257721,
-0.07649745792150497,
-0.0006811912753619254,
-0.07368318736553192,
-0.04356970638036728,
0.008543455973267555,
-0.02817518822848797,
0.03807123005390167,
-0.043520595878362656,
0.06613652408123016,
0.02545633353292942,
0.022462908178567886,
0.00011158072447869927,
-0.032474033534526825,
0.04074835777282715,
-0.029779909178614616,
0.009439390152692795,
-0.055490825325250626,
-0.05746984854340553,
0.09109759330749512,
-0.018640385940670967,
-0.006065559107810259,
0.014028448611497879,
-0.07580403983592987,
0.0282302163541317,
-0.045567840337753296,
-0.04249131307005882,
0.023998675867915154,
-0.026691947132349014,
0.04688355326652527,
-0.017214935272932053,
-0.03977319225668907,
-0.007268781308084726,
-0.009342276491224766,
-0.02674747072160244,
0.005826675798743963,
-0.040576010942459106,
0.048133887350559235,
0.01768658310174942,
0.0014713790733367205,
-0.05356147885322571,
-0.009988898411393166,
0.03666457533836365,
0.054305095225572586,
0.03905221447348595,
0.004556240048259497,
0.007076071575284004,
0.07155661284923553,
0.04769330099225044,
0.008556422777473927,
0.011078464798629284,
0.01768428087234497,
-0.03439853712916374,
-0.057223621755838394,
0.04710639640688896,
-0.0361584909260273,
-0.013847379013895988,
-0.05608886480331421,
0.06326506286859512,
0.036900103092193604,
-0.05905850976705551,
-0.015225574374198914,
0.02558988332748413,
-0.03621191903948784,
-0.03308536112308502,
-0.030651232227683067,
0.002733204048126936,
-0.01873232237994671,
0.05934595316648483,
0.028591491281986237,
0.055033016949892044,
0.06903139501810074,
0.03196394070982933,
-0.006744010373950005,
-0.028571952134370804,
0.08922837674617767,
0.046233419328927994,
0.05885569751262665,
-0.01746539957821369,
0.04369653761386871,
-0.010347947478294373,
-0.04409497603774071,
0.05312125384807587,
0.021107135340571404,
-0.0083223357796669,
-0.045682162046432495,
0.007073026616126299,
0.0994732454419136,
0.03411727771162987,
0.06264906376600266,
-0.07829134911298752,
0.0008010243764147162,
0.05507010594010353,
0.008532281965017319,
0.0018022352596744895,
0.033620670437812805,
0.02315710484981537,
-0.024345839396119118,
-0.016790563240647316,
-0.03807993605732918,
-0.0011775807943195105,
-0.004973690491169691,
0.021388303488492966,
-0.010676478035748005,
-0.012899464927613735,
0.019970031455159187,
-0.025484105572104454,
0.024734312668442726,
0.09871815145015717,
-0.038276564329862595,
-0.023374106734991074,
0.006233311723917723,
0.006804910954087973,
0.02805214375257492,
0.056245964020490646,
-0.03233106806874275,
-0.006046533118933439,
-0.0036554450634866953,
-0.06916050612926483,
0.04759770631790161,
0.05411798506975174,
-0.01535461563616991,
0.018337903544306755,
-0.035249240696430206,
-0.05096717178821564,
0.005958173889666796,
0.0046929726377129555,
-0.03388328105211258,
-0.04418142884969711,
-0.0474967360496521,
-0.04461922496557236,
-0.02741970680654049,
-0.041327252984046936,
-0.014171265065670013,
-0.0014997287653386593,
-0.06942067295312881,
-0.058580152690410614,
-0.061667125672101974,
0.02388174645602703,
-0.002634634729474783,
-0.038207102566957474,
0.028414320200681686,
0.03122100420296192,
-0.019256820902228355,
-0.048949286341667175,
0.06390704214572906,
0.05417653173208237,
-0.0050815618596971035,
-0.002471966203302145,
0.021554797887802124,
0.049518145620822906,
-0.0024745541159063578,
0.027936790138483047,
-0.01599530689418316,
-0.10393425077199936,
0.003741212422028184,
0.04773508384823799,
-0.055780403316020966,
-0.07559394836425781,
0.013324597850441933,
-0.037134092301130295,
0.015740027651190758,
0.04955421760678291,
0.013362858444452286,
0.021917492151260376,
-0.041464898735284805,
-0.032895006239414215,
0.02263455092906952,
0.00253861746750772,
0.04332246258854866,
-0.019644347950816154,
0.09453022480010986,
0.04798246547579765,
-0.016692351549863815,
-0.008010255172848701,
0.03156154602766037,
-0.01970091462135315,
0.020663367584347725,
0.003359057940542698,
-0.04751390218734741,
-0.03370384871959686,
-0.10037606954574585,
-0.014339916408061981,
0.03263524919748306,
-0.012129428796470165,
-0.03037039190530777,
0.01324008870869875,
-0.02072015218436718,
-0.002991318004205823,
0.005759206134825945,
-0.02002403326332569,
-0.005783091764897108,
-0.027640245854854584,
-0.039610523730516434,
-0.059321194887161255,
0.014442465268075466,
-0.04911432042717934,
0.0010045664384961128,
-0.015477027744054794,
-0.04786676540970802,
0.023117955774068832,
0.006583601236343384,
0.05490073934197426,
0.02684478834271431,
0.0035307102371007204,
-0.0312359556555748
] |
307 |
Neural Multi-Objective Combinatorial Optimization via Graph-Image Multimodal Fusion
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=4sJ2FYE65U
|
[
"Jinbiao Chen",
"Jiahai Wang",
"Zhiguang Cao",
"Yaoxin Wu"
] |
Poster
|
Existing neural multi-objective combinatorial optimization (MOCO) methods still exhibit an optimality gap since they fail to fully exploit the intrinsic features of problem instances. A significant factor contributing to this shortfall is their reliance solely on graph-modal information. To overcome this, we propose a novel graph-image multimodal fusion (GIMF) framework that enhances neural MOCO methods by integrating graph and image information of the problem instances. Our GIMF framework comprises three key components: (1) a constructed coordinate image to better represent the spatial structure of the problem instance, (2) a problem-size adaptive resolution strategy during the image construction process to improve the cross-size generalization of the model, and (3) a multimodal fusion mechanism with modality-specific bottlenecks to efficiently couple graph and image information. We demonstrate the versatility of our GIMF by implementing it with two state-of-the-art neural MOCO backbones. Experimental results on classic MOCO problems show that our GIMF significantly outperforms state-of-the-art neural MOCO methods and exhibits superior generalization capability.
|
Neural Multi-Objective Combinatorial Optimization, Multimodal Fusion, Deep Reinforcement Learning
|
This paper proposes a graph-image multimodal fusion framework for neural multi-objective combinatorial optimization.
| 13,570 | null |
[
-0.019690409302711487,
-0.01745937205851078,
0.0047278692945837975,
0.060158684849739075,
0.02411690540611744,
0.0675344467163086,
0.001869094092398882,
0.02328753098845482,
-0.040619753301143646,
-0.05553841590881348,
0.0037389062345027924,
0.008771387860178947,
-0.07688891887664795,
-0.005907541140913963,
-0.008721436373889446,
0.04485885426402092,
0.023516060784459114,
0.012974336743354797,
0.007987617515027523,
0.01435806229710579,
-0.023569483309984207,
-0.03907139599323273,
0.017648663371801376,
0.011476842686533928,
0.026819642633199692,
-0.004767628852277994,
0.008582614362239838,
0.014148845337331295,
-0.012381895445287228,
-0.01984797604382038,
0.01831085979938507,
-0.005777361802756786,
0.03156431391835213,
-0.05552300438284874,
0.03677595779299736,
-0.011301824823021889,
-0.07455676794052124,
0.0021576620638370514,
0.028693897649645805,
0.015456820838153362,
-0.04605599120259285,
0.023661039769649506,
-0.005909925326704979,
-0.0011830542935058475,
-0.050120558589696884,
0.02913144789636135,
-0.0937611535191536,
0.029125245288014412,
0.008764885365962982,
-0.02789737656712532,
-0.07528923451900482,
0.030543213710188866,
0.00034326460445299745,
-0.005811708513647318,
-0.013246382586658001,
0.03871102258563042,
0.048879556357860565,
-0.035439588129520416,
-0.02656770683825016,
-0.05282609164714813,
-0.04857620596885681,
0.04795660451054573,
0.028659474104642868,
0.0010805370984598994,
-0.025245776399970055,
-0.011169694364070892,
-0.0142671475186944,
0.06474215537309647,
-0.026731688529253006,
-0.0020400879438966513,
-0.019211089238524437,
-0.015482776798307896,
0.05855510011315346,
0.029211292043328285,
-0.007289478555321693,
-0.040658775717020035,
0.01592188887298107,
-0.0076763080433011055,
0.022785164415836334,
-0.024609817191958427,
0.010634149424731731,
0.037075769156217575,
0.002590924734249711,
0.023226622492074966,
-0.003333387430757284,
0.01611379347741604,
-0.030169853940606117,
-0.03046574629843235,
-0.08783985674381256,
0.037302009761333466,
-0.027505196630954742,
-0.06525519490242004,
-0.007674384396523237,
0.042429134249687195,
0.019399987533688545,
0.007990173064172268,
0.02188221737742424,
-0.004268135875463486,
0.018570518121123314,
0.007042135577648878,
0.011682480573654175,
-0.007685639895498753,
0.011407086625695229,
-0.008164670318365097,
-0.1046622171998024,
-0.05573751777410507,
-0.013911079615354538,
-0.002283533802255988,
0.010044257156550884,
-0.02189776487648487,
-0.052206505089998245,
-0.016440827399492264,
0.014535999856889248,
-0.04687821865081787,
-0.07037895917892456,
0.02013522759079933,
-0.007374459411948919,
0.022574450820684433,
-0.018040958791971207,
0.01117248646914959,
0.05837376043200493,
0.048321329057216644,
-0.008591893129050732,
0.066911481320858,
0.014795975759625435,
-0.002345371525734663,
0.013045044615864754,
0.055710744112730026,
-0.04889872670173645,
-0.03936713561415672,
-0.01974223181605339,
0.025182895362377167,
-0.0157674141228199,
-0.04406088963150978,
0.02168586663901806,
-0.03910060599446297,
0.029948875308036804,
0.006315113976597786,
0.014304064214229584,
-0.023206893354654312,
-0.01777408830821514,
-0.037537556141614914,
0.05001465603709221,
-0.02686150185763836,
0.06699129194021225,
-0.027783464640378952,
-0.004190665669739246,
-0.02565797045826912,
-0.040044475346803665,
0.014362320303916931,
0.00031863010372035205,
-0.025523453950881958,
0.002663237042725086,
-0.04632186517119408,
0.023049334064126015,
0.10810460150241852,
0.030708562582731247,
0.03819546848535538,
0.025776434689760208,
0.011517590843141079,
0.012632854282855988,
-0.010500455275177956,
-0.016256282106041908,
0.015002844855189323,
-0.05536218732595444,
-0.04261127486824989,
0.022112848237156868,
0.04736551642417908,
-0.06921610236167908,
0.008467490784823895,
-0.038034018129110336,
-0.08217022567987442,
0.02749987319111824,
0.017412614077329636,
-0.030025018379092216,
-0.0012433115625753999,
0.08887192606925964,
0.004709247965365648,
0.039670951664447784,
0.015344815328717232,
-0.08206463605165482,
0.03510265424847603,
0.023343557491898537,
-0.0023295192513614893,
-0.004208682104945183,
-0.016116071492433548,
0.05688756704330444,
-0.025790240615606308,
0.003202776424586773,
0.0028371934313327074,
-0.06361827254295349,
-0.018314840272068977,
0.021406574174761772,
-0.033876050263643265,
0.07877758145332336,
0.03740476816892624,
-0.029950076714158058,
0.0017714279238134623,
0.02126185968518257,
0.03261168301105499,
0.06164926290512085,
-0.03156634047627449,
0.04707629233598709,
-0.011523102410137653,
-0.047174662351608276,
0.004567523021250963,
0.04462435469031334,
-0.05148341879248619,
-0.04097810387611389,
0.0012271093437448144,
-0.014191892929375172,
-0.011609276756644249,
-0.008606422692537308,
0.01789873093366623,
0.03979415073990822,
-0.0033444694709032774,
0.0027267213445156813,
0.008525661192834377,
-0.006207972299307585,
-0.04644739255309105,
0.02636583521962166,
0.02741640992462635,
-0.03673655539751053,
0.003108520992100239,
-0.020703481510281563,
0.08780322223901749,
0.050193168222904205,
-0.04690668359398842,
0.010874705389142036,
0.021318040788173676,
0.010802635923027992,
0.05245891213417053,
0.025138050317764282,
0.004638390149921179,
0.007606638595461845,
-0.03228959068655968,
0.013910914771258831,
0.006835107691586018,
0.04781246557831764,
-0.07164222002029419,
-0.03094312734901905,
0.04022807255387306,
-0.019112395122647285,
0.05653897672891617,
0.0030348135624080896,
0.00023827610129956156,
0.03308496251702309,
0.035750050097703934,
-0.0033054067753255367,
-0.014262712560594082,
-0.0028074777219444513,
0.021285858005285263,
-0.00916245486587286,
0.001333023188635707,
0.009776931256055832,
-0.06953287869691849,
0.021857213228940964,
-0.0393124595284462,
0.06310728192329407,
0.05739076808094978,
0.031428031623363495,
0.021453706547617912,
-0.005526459775865078,
-0.020432816818356514,
-0.0591474287211895,
-0.10947725921869278,
-0.04337894916534424,
-0.01256108470261097,
0.042438384145498276,
0.01987522281706333,
0.06117820739746094,
0.011243262328207493,
0.01947614550590515,
-0.013462907634675503,
-0.021758679300546646,
-0.000921963423024863,
0.028539638966321945,
0.026987694203853607,
-0.02675642818212509,
-0.02266998030245304,
0.008832225576043129,
0.07852069288492203,
-0.015170862898230553,
-0.008101384155452251,
-0.04481320455670357,
-0.027868332341313362,
-0.0030238365288823843,
-0.04331891983747482,
-0.009018021635711193,
0.013700009323656559,
0.038852863013744354,
0.03880636766552925,
-0.01589086465537548,
0.036822669208049774,
0.00826703105121851,
0.031515493988990784,
0.05579989403486252,
0.02083250693976879,
-0.013955541886389256,
0.03067822940647602,
0.0025585617404431105,
0.022536639124155045,
-0.003161924658343196,
-0.029212521389126778,
-0.015526184812188148,
0.005720536690205336,
0.01763789728283882,
0.017172321677207947,
-0.25922778248786926,
-0.0033864181023091078,
0.021921109408140182,
0.010189447551965714,
0.028043393045663834,
-0.03807708993554115,
0.005547376349568367,
-0.04272883012890816,
-0.017494313418865204,
-0.043122630566358566,
0.014985998161137104,
0.015443931333720684,
-0.0018358019879087806,
0.03943609073758125,
0.050256598740816116,
0.0341184176504612,
0.02701825089752674,
-0.022232698276638985,
0.025460168719291687,
0.02904953435063362,
-0.047422610223293304,
-0.08590151369571686,
-0.017312830314040184,
0.027603156864643097,
-0.009048212319612503,
0.03407946601510048,
-0.0948292538523674,
-0.026300454512238503,
-0.029553204774856567,
-0.016350921243429184,
-0.003830954898148775,
-0.016610389575362206,
-0.02341572754085064,
0.059142496436834335,
0.01724126562476158,
0.017284873872995377,
0.03233722224831581,
-0.06142077594995499,
0.015543351881206036,
0.009584391489624977,
0.021664228290319443,
0.014291360042989254,
-0.07034122198820114,
0.0026827198453247547,
0.06317249685525894,
0.00796424224972725,
-0.028618594631552696,
-0.01492885872721672,
-0.01401454210281372,
0.03394030034542084,
0.04088625684380531,
-0.0031284510623663664,
-0.0008961647399701178,
0.043733861297369,
0.006469682324677706,
-0.010990569368004799,
0.016926215961575508,
0.009820844978094101,
0.017002856358885765,
-0.016131781041622162,
-0.0031340911518782377,
-0.06108136475086212,
-0.01200078334659338,
-0.0013848412781953812,
-0.026005944237113,
-0.032970815896987915,
-0.06434138119220734,
-0.08585414290428162,
0.04210171848535538,
0.03478793054819107,
0.007869446650147438,
0.016848387196660042,
-0.00827701110392809,
-0.09211773425340652,
0.002666803076863289,
0.006235823035240173,
-0.008702633902430534,
0.0065132989548146725,
-0.03003855235874653,
0.0336771160364151,
-0.03984211012721062,
-0.0492316409945488,
0.03109068237245083,
0.025824274867773056,
0.01774129457771778,
-0.02459404245018959,
0.01920015923678875,
-0.028728071600198746,
-0.0065122791565954685,
-0.009980559349060059,
0.02938753552734852,
0.036594826728105545,
0.0674235075712204,
0.007042416371405125,
0.058673109859228134,
0.023693596944212914,
0.05888226628303528,
0.03976030647754669,
0.03565946966409683,
-0.007908573374152184,
0.018483620136976242,
-0.08121932297945023,
-0.03240406513214111,
-0.0006356341764330864,
-0.0624055415391922,
0.00018424526206217706,
-0.047976210713386536,
-0.03369941934943199,
0.05440303683280945,
0.025041067972779274,
-0.03432723134756088,
-0.043201763182878494,
0.03814053162932396,
-0.01759607158601284,
-0.024928446859121323,
-0.010743329301476479,
0.006937065627425909,
0.02952611818909645,
0.04139429330825806,
0.013493524864315987,
-0.013195186853408813,
0.04477847367525101,
-0.023329075425863266,
0.0012337445514276624,
-0.019159749150276184,
-0.0077183423563838005,
-0.030938997864723206,
-0.008167464286088943,
0.013687212951481342,
0.027449991554021835,
0.0334707573056221,
0.055500779300928116,
0.0029892537277191877,
0.028428947553038597,
0.03406868875026703,
-0.02908959612250328,
-0.024746712297201157,
-0.05404999479651451,
0.04962265491485596,
-0.026248710229992867,
0.04705455154180527,
0.0065216608345508575,
-0.012933957390487194,
0.005897838156670332,
0.01349721197038889,
0.014742123894393444,
0.00027492042863741517,
0.01770266331732273,
-0.025864990428090096,
0.009782426059246063,
-0.029240787029266357,
-0.0498633086681366,
-0.030674202367663383,
-0.03402627632021904,
0.023765025660395622,
0.013159277848899364,
0.0011968964245170355,
-0.045419931411743164,
0.041303906589746475,
-0.03235013410449028,
0.044213563203811646,
0.029877951368689537,
-0.013511376455426216,
-0.018330853432416916,
-0.016200492158532143,
0.05337747931480408,
0.010375520214438438,
-0.026204586029052734,
-0.01464170590043068,
0.003521963255479932,
0.022632203996181488,
-0.03253483027219772,
-0.032501038163900375,
-0.019284991547465324,
-0.017693182453513145,
-0.011118569411337376,
0.021399036049842834,
0.001032238476909697,
-0.024747997522354126,
0.05410042032599449,
-0.02509472891688347,
-0.05641476809978485,
0.022379955276846886,
-0.023250583559274673,
0.07761692255735397,
0.0044818660244345665,
-0.009979783557355404,
-0.018655965104699135,
-0.0053153326734900475,
0.056490253657102585,
0.02265818975865841,
0.028813133016228676,
-0.04154014587402344,
-0.03352286294102669,
-0.019928723573684692,
-0.021266592666506767,
-0.00998895987868309,
0.019161883741617203,
0.0019997244235128164,
-0.02535259909927845,
-0.0063957213424146175,
0.029844438657164574,
-0.042150307446718216,
-0.008867132477462292,
0.017282184213399887,
-0.07375351339578629,
0.0017215083353221416,
0.049238987267017365,
-0.009806505404412746,
0.021821357309818268,
-0.02843991480767727,
-0.035469766706228256,
-0.07138118892908096,
-0.010297628119587898,
0.01859789341688156,
0.0072490074671804905,
-0.018079107627272606,
-0.005093870218843222,
-0.007464466616511345,
-0.022806189954280853,
-0.023888973519206047,
-0.0029577005188912153,
-0.00864376500248909,
-0.05564141646027565,
0.00033768106368370354,
0.07289863377809525,
-0.026445403695106506,
-0.0030805717688053846,
-0.024834949523210526,
-0.010504859499633312,
0.029027242213487625,
-0.04282970726490021,
-0.0034318258985877037,
0.05514863133430481,
0.030246658250689507,
0.0266414787620306,
-0.06114418804645538,
0.03978747874498367,
-0.003291203174740076,
-0.015537166967988014,
0.026630520820617676,
0.008860884234309196,
-0.049759987741708755,
-0.013071245513856411,
0.001464163069613278,
0.03584470599889755,
0.015764713287353516,
0.021316666156053543,
0.0023239580914378166,
-0.0054211923852562904,
0.020597845315933228,
-0.011137368157505989,
-0.06117362901568413,
-0.010873043909668922,
0.08212915807962418,
-0.01976027339696884,
-0.01945243775844574,
-0.03723601996898651,
-0.022841360419988632,
-0.001327046426013112,
-0.05649900063872337,
0.05392386391758919,
-0.022160546854138374,
0.028116004541516304,
0.024099737405776978,
0.03694747015833855,
-0.005492034368216991,
-0.03608114272356033,
0.004371808376163244,
-0.053150299936532974,
0.048382990062236786,
-0.05769879370927811,
-0.018742188811302185,
0.04548176750540733,
-0.025116613134741783,
-0.0038990615867078304,
0.009820361621677876,
-0.018358485773205757,
0.03972405567765236,
-0.024714482948184013,
-0.04847944900393486,
0.014425746165215969,
-0.03669627755880356,
0.002733527449890971,
0.012187435291707516,
-0.02989434264600277,
-0.0012551294639706612,
-0.0040937806479632854,
-0.04757775366306305,
-0.006540166214108467,
0.0021724936086684465,
0.06856688112020493,
0.02464137226343155,
0.022787990048527718,
0.005686333402991295,
-0.005722776986658573,
0.04345611110329628,
0.07494036853313446,
0.028207669034600258,
0.023280896246433258,
-0.021467311307787895,
0.034784331917762756,
0.03444139286875725,
0.02233196422457695,
-0.017279883846640587,
0.031696218997240067,
-0.016021447256207466,
-0.034138694405555725,
0.03536417707800865,
-0.0012883574236184359,
-0.027787012979388237,
-0.06380435824394226,
0.0679325982928276,
0.009953318163752556,
-0.04792555049061775,
-0.03117908164858818,
0.04613999277353287,
-0.06894450634717941,
0.04029858857393265,
-0.009280066005885601,
-0.003459077561274171,
-0.0011130856582894921,
0.06665558367967606,
0.0033340922091156244,
0.019296802580356598,
0.08425844460725784,
0.011737699620425701,
-0.025774100795388222,
-0.008024780079722404,
0.062120355665683746,
0.039641790091991425,
0.05342363938689232,
-0.005028674378991127,
0.060014043003320694,
-0.02128487639129162,
-0.0350780114531517,
0.028757674619555473,
0.038761112838983536,
-0.05021188035607338,
-0.028795255348086357,
-0.03709361329674721,
0.09421154856681824,
-0.024815555661916733,
0.07630735635757446,
-0.022983266040682793,
-0.004073315300047398,
0.028095094487071037,
0.008148014545440674,
-0.033755235373973846,
0.030094610527157784,
0.022859999909996986,
0.03094780445098877,
-0.03393116220831871,
0.007628424558788538,
-0.008311321958899498,
-0.027577189728617668,
-0.002165180863812566,
0.031584881246089935,
-0.024020371958613396,
0.021929416805505753,
0.018021604046225548,
0.01743033342063427,
0.09885429590940475,
-0.06541071087121964,
-0.027098480612039566,
0.01186281070113182,
0.03097940981388092,
0.011008688248693943,
0.020430346950888634,
0.02056325413286686,
-0.021509835496544838,
0.017262998968362808,
-0.03523479402065277,
0.027800796553492546,
-0.003838899079710245,
0.03206568956375122,
0.0026283590123057365,
-0.030240889638662338,
-0.014514225535094738,
0.011727102100849152,
-0.0023595518432557583,
-0.007285681553184986,
-0.04499047249555588,
-0.024873191490769386,
-0.07636342942714691,
-0.057194530963897705,
-0.03878984972834587,
0.017866700887680054,
0.004305034410208464,
-0.0175139419734478,
0.01206367090344429,
0.010698939673602581,
0.013422655873000622,
0.033344339579343796,
-0.04648809880018234,
0.01970142498612404,
0.018713925033807755,
-0.006530425511300564,
0.009868399240076542,
0.009447870776057243,
0.03229890391230583,
-0.02446959726512432,
-0.010765423998236656,
0.05115937441587448,
0.036657799035310745,
-0.0036702724173665047,
0.006084172986447811,
-0.02091924473643303,
-0.10633405297994614,
-0.00624504080042243,
-0.013404907658696175,
-0.046000685542821884,
-0.08050335943698883,
0.004572050645947456,
0.01026066206395626,
0.022656425833702087,
0.08079664409160614,
-0.0018598005408421159,
0.008714977651834488,
-0.04491683840751648,
0.005919874180108309,
-0.023730386048555374,
-0.017606930807232857,
0.05579032748937607,
-0.046717386692762375,
0.03218790888786316,
0.029709920287132263,
-0.013432174921035767,
-0.006487118545919657,
0.03796086832880974,
-0.0026741495821624994,
0.026827214285731316,
-0.01293244119733572,
-0.036444928497076035,
-0.04350404441356659,
-0.13004012405872345,
-0.020949911326169968,
0.031517393887043,
-0.004834677558392286,
-0.037162892520427704,
-0.025278713554143906,
0.0028093147557228804,
-0.015267716720700264,
0.0029985266737639904,
-0.013317654840648174,
-0.017568442970514297,
-0.023939859122037888,
-0.02831919491291046,
-0.09609514474868774,
0.037892576307058334,
-0.010932819917798042,
0.030043648555874825,
-0.05113350227475166,
-0.05023719742894173,
-0.02177572064101696,
0.020455896854400635,
0.0316956490278244,
0.01609901152551174,
0.05401718616485596,
-0.0032992626074701548
] |
308 |
Have the VLMs Lost Confidence? A Study of Sycophancy in VLMs
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=E2PFv7ad3p
|
[
"Shuo Li",
"Tao Ji",
"Xiaoran Fan",
"Linsheng Lu",
"Leyi Yang",
"Yuming Yang",
"Zhiheng Xi",
"Rui Zheng",
"Yuran Wang",
"xh.zhao",
"Tao Gui",
"Qi Zhang",
"Xuanjing Huang"
] |
Poster
|
In the study of LLMs, sycophancy represents a prevalent hallucination that poses significant challenges to these models. Specifically, LLMs often fail to adhere to original correct responses, instead blindly agreeing with users' opinions, even when those opinions are incorrect or malicious. However, research on sycophancy in visual language models (VLMs) has been scarce. In this work, we extend the exploration of sycophancy from LLMs to VLMs, introducing the MM-SY benchmark to evaluate this phenomenon. We present evaluation results from multiple representative models, addressing the gap in sycophancy research for VLMs. To mitigate sycophancy, we propose a synthetic dataset for training and employ methods based on prompts, supervised fine-tuning, and DPO. Our experiments demonstrate that these methods effectively alleviate sycophancy in VLMs. Additionally, we probe VLMs to assess the semantic impact of sycophancy and analyze the attention distribution of visual tokens. Our findings indicate that the ability to prevent sycophancy is predominantly observed in higher layers of the model. The lack of attention to image knowledge in these higher layers may contribute to sycophancy, and enhancing image attention at high layers proves beneficial in mitigating this issue.
|
Multi-modal Model, Visual-Language Model, Sycophancy, Hallucination
|
Have the VLMs Lost Confidence? A Study of Sycophancy in VLMs
| 13,565 |
2410.11302
|
[
0.02974938228726387,
-0.008757412433624268,
0.028315244242548943,
0.04743126407265663,
0.021790554746985435,
-0.00204610638320446,
0.06189047917723656,
0.028265029191970825,
-0.04980263486504555,
-0.008929583244025707,
-0.042840901762247086,
0.026886260136961937,
-0.06926579773426056,
0.020884722471237183,
-0.011894443072378635,
0.05414814502000809,
0.047582995146512985,
0.021059861406683922,
0.001888944418169558,
0.037995465099811554,
0.004827012307941914,
-0.025794362649321556,
0.029154444113373756,
0.0009655469912104309,
0.018224015831947327,
-0.02424149587750435,
0.03670152649283409,
-0.005435227882117033,
-0.04469243809580803,
-0.006690171081572771,
0.03787292167544365,
-0.04419238492846489,
-0.00025739058037288487,
-0.011809227056801319,
0.024131406098604202,
0.02747792936861515,
-0.04088076576590538,
0.02136479690670967,
0.02772359549999237,
0.029562002047896385,
-0.04769406467676163,
0.005752745550125837,
-0.019229089841246605,
-0.0480843111872673,
-0.044041331857442856,
-0.02463548257946968,
-0.09138590097427368,
0.045304588973522186,
0.015454936772584915,
-0.03412289917469025,
-0.10555817931890488,
0.03798087686300278,
0.016543768346309662,
0.029646528884768486,
0.003394341329112649,
0.006838854402303696,
0.01330981682986021,
-0.10202129930257797,
-0.02035737782716751,
-0.051379647105932236,
-0.02304256334900856,
0.005472242832183838,
0.008179202675819397,
0.009411548264324665,
-0.001422204659320414,
-0.010658083483576775,
-0.016993697732686996,
0.03066829778254032,
-0.06171853840351105,
-0.027887560427188873,
0.00845278613269329,
-0.02549319714307785,
-0.009124215692281723,
-0.002099117264151573,
0.001767356414347887,
-0.04359012469649315,
0.03136966750025749,
0.013928321190178394,
0.0740853026509285,
-0.03236681595444679,
0.010496154427528381,
0.041492290794849396,
0.02632485330104828,
0.03880275785923004,
0.02381625771522522,
0.020049095153808594,
0.004165664315223694,
-0.036556221544742584,
-0.06521143019199371,
0.026186568662524223,
-0.012248127721250057,
-0.056380495429039,
0.019110990688204765,
0.028597353026270866,
0.015965234488248825,
0.019897980615496635,
0.04107631742954254,
0.002126729115843773,
-0.005844907369464636,
-0.0016242129495367408,
-0.011324177496135235,
-0.024324921891093254,
0.025025535374879837,
0.026668058708310127,
-0.08932444453239441,
-0.03225407004356384,
-0.021108796820044518,
-0.013093242421746254,
-0.01846889778971672,
0.009927983395755291,
-0.06801556050777435,
0.00802338495850563,
0.021938852965831757,
-0.0019988268613815308,
-0.07697884738445282,
0.011156701482832432,
0.007960393093526363,
0.028982210904359818,
-0.013188420794904232,
0.029093030840158463,
0.06351009011268616,
0.03177621588110924,
0.0055127511732280254,
0.07058830559253693,
-0.03350060060620308,
0.0320173017680645,
-0.01435739453881979,
0.03954511880874634,
-0.01815604604780674,
-0.007047007791697979,
0.025452332571148872,
0.037103649228811264,
-0.013506210409104824,
0.015500148758292198,
-0.016841191798448563,
-0.003108630422502756,
0.03415248915553093,
0.017093313857913017,
0.0409376323223114,
-0.017898917198181152,
-0.0092930244281888,
-0.008242171257734299,
0.03342888131737709,
-0.013937215320765972,
0.07085470110177994,
-0.029491068795323372,
-0.008861674927175045,
-0.008580682799220085,
-0.04811004176735878,
0.0003412823425605893,
0.03383547067642212,
-0.012420209124684334,
0.0130711505189538,
-0.07050696015357971,
0.034586101770401,
0.05573159456253052,
0.023709742352366447,
0.002799943322315812,
0.04325362667441368,
0.007117834873497486,
-0.012670793570578098,
0.018717164173722267,
-0.05123893916606903,
0.021044209599494934,
-0.01355406641960144,
-0.06140730530023575,
-0.0001055267930496484,
-0.006137057673186064,
-0.04584865644574165,
0.04632346332073212,
-0.05360085144639015,
-0.04031938686966896,
0.024043405428528786,
-0.007909970358014107,
-0.043039470911026,
0.0002959005651064217,
0.060826558619737625,
0.038131192326545715,
0.0240777600556612,
0.013301005586981773,
-0.06794004887342453,
0.01720537431538105,
-0.016786735504865646,
-0.032357119023799896,
0.014867052435874939,
-0.018017800524830818,
0.07714051008224487,
-0.03766719251871109,
-0.00666907848790288,
0.014991682022809982,
-0.06187525391578674,
0.018677104264497757,
0.002163425786420703,
0.0017377941403537989,
0.061129048466682434,
-0.003969774581491947,
-0.01264061126857996,
0.025594184175133705,
0.04251948371529579,
0.05084164813160896,
0.07238685339689255,
-0.013102484866976738,
0.035566747188568115,
0.00762838264927268,
-0.02882283180952072,
0.009501105174422264,
0.04726022481918335,
-0.03426765650510788,
-0.06533011794090271,
0.019738854840397835,
-0.02907920442521572,
-0.01993272267282009,
-0.006114485207945108,
0.0425228476524353,
0.0419340506196022,
-0.004997648298740387,
-0.019673023372888565,
-0.02517007663846016,
-0.0232030488550663,
-0.04332328960299492,
0.04388922452926636,
0.029430586844682693,
-0.010023221373558044,
-0.008839106187224388,
-0.04377099499106407,
0.07138796150684357,
0.06638384610414505,
-0.03887077048420906,
-0.023648714646697044,
0.013149832375347614,
0.01464099157601595,
0.01640559732913971,
0.017164001241326332,
-0.04336460679769516,
0.0022864555940032005,
-0.04229211062192917,
0.02635093405842781,
-0.036046575754880905,
0.07420651614665985,
-0.043133445084095,
-0.023377815261483192,
0.044374022632837296,
0.011534902267158031,
0.04562489315867424,
0.002352382754907012,
0.01624949835240841,
0.036988142877817154,
-0.010904472321271896,
-0.012889736331999302,
-0.0017798731569200754,
-0.019450629130005836,
0.015125609934329987,
-0.008576218970119953,
-0.03611133247613907,
0.03468795120716095,
-0.028243696317076683,
-0.019041581079363823,
-0.05288073047995567,
0.05368126183748245,
0.05623637139797211,
0.014451649971306324,
0.050513796508312225,
0.0009156059240922332,
-0.03524273633956909,
0.002657533623278141,
-0.07369139045476913,
-0.02388184703886509,
-0.03063918836414814,
0.03663773089647293,
0.01397612877190113,
0.03745809942483902,
-0.014539475552737713,
0.0031017882283777,
-0.03209973871707916,
0.015248111449182034,
0.023785149678587914,
0.021703168749809265,
-0.006930513307452202,
-0.01771261729300022,
-0.019024591892957687,
-0.019874325022101402,
0.052139539271593094,
0.0026880777440965176,
-0.0071390364319086075,
-0.04505043849349022,
-0.012452574446797371,
-0.010070540942251682,
-0.012703443877398968,
-0.002420034259557724,
-0.004031000193208456,
0.00995674729347229,
-0.0017514488426968455,
0.02153194509446621,
0.006610069889575243,
0.004532556980848312,
0.0571909137070179,
0.04108832776546478,
-0.025312473997473717,
-0.018985791131854057,
0.06938236206769943,
0.002237631706520915,
0.01683666743338108,
0.046583857387304306,
0.0033256527967751026,
-0.013850403018295765,
0.026690790429711342,
0.0046487366780638695,
-0.005888950079679489,
-0.28337642550468445,
-0.030252085998654366,
0.014038401655852795,
-0.036171384155750275,
0.026156773790717125,
-0.01568300649523735,
0.024524275213479996,
-0.03383193537592888,
-0.03292640298604965,
0.021902233362197876,
0.05182277783751488,
0.021885031834244728,
-0.0008958243415690958,
0.05686918646097183,
0.03699951246380806,
0.011183599941432476,
0.016484977677464485,
-0.04202626645565033,
0.010366974398493767,
0.04280081391334534,
-0.014416837133467197,
-0.05395292490720749,
-0.024452196434140205,
0.07213810086250305,
-0.001981250708922744,
0.0746314600110054,
-0.07238838821649551,
0.005473962984979153,
-0.01933215744793415,
0.0004989377339370549,
-0.0035875977482646704,
0.008275046944618225,
-0.02890808880329132,
0.05708962306380272,
-0.010732041671872139,
-0.00196544686332345,
0.031189125031232834,
-0.019407276064157486,
0.03354709595441818,
0.00794955063611269,
0.014537544921040535,
-0.03673582151532173,
-0.017445862293243408,
0.007719452027231455,
0.07160547375679016,
0.015614313073456287,
-0.082602359354496,
-0.0182998888194561,
-0.0247309822589159,
0.02552933059632778,
-0.049393393099308014,
-0.04807364195585251,
-0.018354497849941254,
0.040921781212091446,
-0.024202076718211174,
-0.014697724021971226,
0.00937015749514103,
-0.03140640631318092,
-0.013324035331606865,
-0.034882474690675735,
-0.005046018399298191,
-0.03539036214351654,
-0.01972883567214012,
-0.041818730533123016,
-0.019815636798739433,
-0.019826000556349754,
-0.0493999645113945,
-0.028211476281285286,
0.05231800675392151,
0.02832186035811901,
0.002594689140096307,
0.03676890209317207,
-0.04873588681221008,
-0.08988872915506363,
0.025534238666296005,
0.010473819449543953,
-0.006109941750764847,
-0.024445636197924614,
-0.018221404403448105,
0.01737144961953163,
-0.0044710831716656685,
-0.03645830601453781,
0.013132632710039616,
0.0032791541889309883,
0.027977224439382553,
-0.010286030359566212,
0.014936395920813084,
0.00431829784065485,
-0.027150487527251244,
-0.04609120637178421,
0.07783150672912598,
0.013303123414516449,
0.0064836530946195126,
0.0021773974876850843,
0.04712123051285744,
0.015148534439504147,
0.05860426649451256,
0.05156729742884636,
0.021755071356892586,
0.01692827045917511,
0.026498401537537575,
-0.08132568001747131,
-0.016358954831957817,
-0.015589897520840168,
-0.057966381311416626,
0.0148110780864954,
-0.05583413317799568,
-0.020639896392822266,
0.03693090379238129,
-0.004569001961499453,
-0.05334176495671272,
-0.02130827121436596,
0.020230822265148163,
0.04403538256883621,
-0.01597178354859352,
-0.01944378949701786,
0.013113301247358322,
0.028921129181981087,
0.015018335543572903,
-0.060751091688871384,
-0.01746360771358013,
0.025975599884986877,
-0.034523434937000275,
0.021824853494763374,
-0.011637141928076744,
0.007393715437501669,
-0.03301531821489334,
-0.01785934530198574,
-0.06328542530536652,
0.031000986695289612,
0.006844866089522839,
0.02814328670501709,
0.029766028746962547,
0.014946365728974342,
0.08015204221010208,
-0.018301691859960556,
0.0038693230599164963,
-0.016665911301970482,
0.03757207468152046,
-0.03261720389127731,
0.024882253259420395,
-0.015210134908556938,
0.023784684017300606,
0.06920241564512253,
0.022868555039167404,
-0.023259887471795082,
0.011599671095609665,
-0.02999095618724823,
-0.027096623554825783,
0.018301689997315407,
0.05301794409751892,
-0.048066042363643646,
-0.02266235463321209,
-0.010663315653800964,
0.005524707492440939,
0.005585983395576477,
0.0009675631881691515,
-0.015801703557372093,
0.0235910601913929,
-0.05192287638783455,
0.04478195309638977,
0.020424872636795044,
-0.01641940325498581,
0.010554595850408077,
0.0018872820073738694,
0.01402104552835226,
-0.00839521735906601,
0.005807971116155386,
0.03241806849837303,
0.018376067280769348,
0.0012969968374818563,
-0.033374957740306854,
-0.016303651034832,
-0.019486626610159874,
-0.020420687273144722,
0.01197268720716238,
-0.010013951919972897,
-0.040955062955617905,
-0.029278788715600967,
0.037542007863521576,
-0.0026129838079214096,
-0.01883615367114544,
0.0030204516369849443,
-0.0028886902146041393,
0.07505351305007935,
0.015321950428187847,
0.006955778691917658,
-0.02615378424525261,
-0.04855722934007645,
0.015684589743614197,
-0.008675462566316128,
0.01816871389746666,
-0.03155354782938957,
-0.015318847261369228,
-0.06966695934534073,
-0.057346686720848083,
-0.003123079426586628,
-0.007835726253688335,
-0.00538260955363512,
-0.029878919944167137,
0.009911804459989071,
0.027111541479825974,
-0.044797129929065704,
-0.028437508270144463,
0.034337133169174194,
-0.08331798762083054,
0.016264203935861588,
0.03298104554414749,
-0.037952642887830734,
-0.0044747912324965,
-0.0580340251326561,
-0.010194038040935993,
-0.06419774144887924,
-0.030616581439971924,
0.017751449719071388,
-0.028283314779400826,
-0.04018650949001312,
-0.03340598940849304,
0.006500192917883396,
0.009405317716300488,
0.009326289407908916,
-0.024436961859464645,
-0.022424032911658287,
0.0003811730130109936,
0.003976940177381039,
0.02836417965590954,
-0.013132394291460514,
-0.009766582399606705,
0.02453763224184513,
-0.027737729251384735,
0.026994002982974052,
-0.04909581318497658,
0.022232798859477043,
0.05521189421415329,
-0.025529127568006516,
-0.008606940507888794,
-0.05283212289214134,
0.026304449886083603,
0.01858355849981308,
-0.009750399738550186,
0.01441736426204443,
0.02978956699371338,
-0.03117993474006653,
-0.00028820353327319026,
0.014966914430260658,
0.042914312332868576,
0.02198375016450882,
-0.019482824951410294,
0.011705983430147171,
0.009487466886639595,
0.010271170176565647,
-0.007963070645928383,
-0.016313254833221436,
0.004361188039183617,
0.058671705424785614,
-0.02629830688238144,
-0.014364552684128284,
-0.06948795169591904,
-0.03970079496502876,
0.003077499568462372,
0.013561069034039974,
0.015202273614704609,
-0.043930914252996445,
0.04517487436532974,
0.017385749146342278,
0.052455492317676544,
0.02280629798769951,
-0.0045081512071192265,
0.034782834351062775,
-0.03802773728966713,
0.011973605491220951,
-0.062266990542411804,
-0.022492192685604095,
0.0508870892226696,
-0.007779513020068407,
0.010164658538997173,
-0.025188378989696503,
-0.06379399448633194,
0.04230104014277458,
-0.02470221370458603,
-0.032194316387176514,
-0.01523439772427082,
-0.051653601229190826,
-0.0033754378091543913,
0.03189801052212715,
-0.06788168102502823,
0.023724930360913277,
-0.02804427593946457,
-0.03857111930847168,
-0.012279028072953224,
-0.014918358065187931,
0.04409027099609375,
0.0007231751806102693,
0.025132130831480026,
-0.009564442560076714,
-0.004794858396053314,
0.0009578359895385802,
0.06396493315696716,
0.020576152950525284,
0.017369670793414116,
-0.009023258462548256,
0.08252070844173431,
0.07137604802846909,
0.00045688581303693354,
0.006282193120568991,
0.022752825170755386,
-0.030641762539744377,
-0.0573025681078434,
0.07208248227834702,
-0.0014239100273698568,
-0.010841337032616138,
-0.06103082746267319,
0.06443819403648376,
0.03492803871631622,
-0.05948757007718086,
-0.015495224855840206,
0.036800168454647064,
-0.029668699949979782,
-0.0028712672647088766,
-0.030990930274128914,
0.03795551881194115,
-0.014082000590860844,
0.05906789377331734,
0.02523561753332615,
0.05153117701411247,
0.06046091020107269,
0.017762988805770874,
-0.004639871418476105,
0.033846866339445114,
0.05582703649997711,
0.07358856499195099,
0.07912040501832962,
0.029169855639338493,
0.09207267314195633,
-0.0373123362660408,
-0.030308522284030914,
0.0051013207994401455,
0.033825717866420746,
-0.013333655893802643,
-0.042910970747470856,
0.01436873059719801,
0.0747091993689537,
0.02289636619389057,
0.0637364536523819,
-0.05872360244393349,
-0.01630254276096821,
0.04271939769387245,
0.010964925400912762,
-0.007602222729474306,
0.012377877719700336,
0.026376856490969658,
-0.000878243416082114,
-0.0027389689348638058,
-0.014332663267850876,
0.0052382005378603935,
-0.05265866592526436,
0.0056373649276793,
-0.034349068999290466,
-0.020263878628611565,
0.0037557207979261875,
-0.037854403257369995,
0.05636337399482727,
0.11592307686805725,
-0.014124511741101742,
-0.033658575266599655,
0.023563679307699203,
0.013060575351119041,
0.03650500252842903,
0.07157635688781738,
-0.018214916810393333,
-0.02151140384376049,
0.00554617727175355,
-0.059229642152786255,
0.021340830251574516,
0.022706596180796623,
0.005812059622257948,
0.03420756384730339,
-0.050605058670043945,
-0.04033033177256584,
0.023997625336050987,
0.02138599008321762,
-0.0355977937579155,
-0.04039663076400757,
-0.03283530846238136,
-0.044966597110033035,
-0.03131970390677452,
-0.04020622372627258,
0.022564858198165894,
0.005017510615289211,
-0.062199607491493225,
-0.007039983291178942,
0.00022889274987392128,
0.010776999406516552,
0.004754506517201662,
-0.045698635280132294,
0.007721615955233574,
0.02393162250518799,
-0.0027765461709350348,
-0.04780609533190727,
0.021696623414754868,
0.006313800811767578,
-0.031657591462135315,
-0.0006986947846598923,
0.024484390392899513,
0.004279097076505423,
0.021357616409659386,
0.0012974604032933712,
-0.019069362431764603,
-0.1354166567325592,
-0.005724000278860331,
-0.002985897706821561,
-0.023821469396352768,
-0.07286959886550903,
0.013406765647232533,
-0.004391350317746401,
0.023914314806461334,
0.06488221138715744,
0.02272324450314045,
0.03229553997516632,
-0.03386995941400528,
-0.00436749029904604,
-0.014749720692634583,
0.03147514536976814,
0.07526132464408875,
-0.012350560165941715,
0.06140803173184395,
0.015098435804247856,
0.0037076803855597973,
-0.04491769149899483,
-0.011655614711344242,
-0.010172047652304173,
-0.016779761761426926,
-0.010137212462723255,
-0.0269258301705122,
-0.03850487992167473,
-0.10955601185560226,
-0.014033842831850052,
0.03327441215515137,
-0.02149990014731884,
-0.017802907153964043,
-0.03562935069203377,
-0.04696948826313019,
-0.03245193883776665,
-0.0028596511110663414,
0.012166465632617474,
-0.023620229214429855,
-0.03212122619152069,
-0.022159496322274208,
-0.044611066579818726,
0.0054239919409155846,
0.010360263288021088,
0.007815120741724968,
-0.03963838145136833,
-0.05195054039359093,
-0.0010803552577272058,
0.033591821789741516,
0.041327331215143204,
-0.0035866033285856247,
0.05326668545603752,
-0.03141937777400017
] |
309 |
Generative Adapter: Contextualizing Language Models in Parameters with A Single Forward Pass
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=bc3sUsS6ck
|
[
"Tong Chen",
"Hao Fang",
"Patrick Xia",
"Xiaodong Liu",
"Benjamin Van Durme",
"Luke Zettlemoyer",
"Jianfeng Gao",
"Hao Cheng"
] |
Poster
|
Large language models (LLMs) acquire substantial knowledge during pretraining but often need adaptation to new contexts, tasks, or domains, typically achieved through fine-tuning or prompting. However, fine-tuning incurs significant training costs, while prompting increases inference overhead. Inspired by fast weight memory, we introduce GenerativeAdapter, an effective and efficient adaptation method that encode test-time context into language model parameters with a single forward pass.
GenerativeAdapter augments a frozen pretrained LM with a lightweight adapter generator, trained via self-supervised learning, to produce parameter-efficient adapters.
Notably, our generator is general-purpose, i.e., one generator can adapt the corresponding base model for all langauge processing scenarios.
We apply GenerativeAdapter to two pretrained LMs (Mistral-7B-Instruct and Llama2-7B-Chat) and evaluate the adapted models across knowledge acquisition from documents, learning from demonstrations, and personalization for users.
In StreamingQA, our approach is effective in injecting knowledge into the LM's parameters, achieving a 63.5\% improvement in F1 score over the model with supervised fine-tuning (from $19.5$ to $31.5$) for contexts as long as 32K tokens.
In the MetaICL in-context learning evaluation, our method achieves an average accuracy of $44.9$ across 26 tasks, outperforming the base model.
On MSC, our method proves to be highly competitive in memorizing user information from conversations with a 4x reduction in computation and memory costs compared to
prompting with full conversation history.
Overall, GenerativeAdapter provides a viable solution for adapting large LMs to evolving information and providing tailored user experience, while reducing training and inference costs relative to traditional fine-tuning and prompting techniques.
|
language model; efficient adaptation; fine-tuning; prompting
| null | 13,563 |
2411.05877
|
[
-0.014914107508957386,
-0.023805096745491028,
-0.009716834872961044,
0.038387101143598557,
0.025551535189151764,
0.028153173625469208,
0.01003991812467575,
0.016904044896364212,
-0.012844775803387165,
-0.015909763053059578,
-0.024041304364800453,
0.03970712795853615,
-0.05411331728100777,
0.017116429284214973,
-0.01431276649236679,
0.03882792592048645,
0.030453447252511978,
-0.02462247759103775,
0.02996436320245266,
0.01690804958343506,
0.004366831388324499,
-0.02027258276939392,
0.054304033517837524,
-0.003983152564615011,
0.023322446271777153,
0.031661029905080795,
0.012025558389723301,
0.006746449042111635,
-0.0422646664083004,
0.010011088103055954,
0.021699372678995132,
-0.001283326419070363,
0.009602615609765053,
-0.012925415299832821,
0.01680949702858925,
-0.05862995237112045,
-0.05573718994855881,
-0.008615761063992977,
0.017255542799830437,
0.02967796102166176,
-0.022458871826529503,
0.00617613410577178,
-0.01593518815934658,
0.026278482750058174,
-0.04609660804271698,
-0.0018852371722459793,
-0.10271767526865005,
0.02615392580628395,
-0.0065802703611552715,
-0.040718935430049896,
-0.12651826441287994,
0.04130503162741661,
-0.002425155835226178,
-0.0003775017976295203,
0.004594691097736359,
0.029730377718806267,
0.05599221587181091,
-0.1011592298746109,
0.018281249329447746,
-0.02800292707979679,
-0.04370672255754471,
0.023655109107494354,
0.023287713527679443,
0.02893943153321743,
-0.002956375014036894,
-0.033479951322078705,
-0.009780515916645527,
0.036987654864788055,
-0.05114663019776344,
-0.05151844769716263,
-0.04610395058989525,
0.011802843771874905,
-0.00031708943424746394,
0.019140666350722313,
0.017230411991477013,
-0.04231581836938858,
0.020299647003412247,
0.0547943040728569,
0.07429912686347961,
-0.0009778353851288557,
0.0012192991562187672,
-0.0032680598087608814,
0.04897577688097954,
0.03186715394258499,
0.014941493980586529,
0.004277650732547045,
-0.07729767262935638,
-0.015123841352760792,
-0.06846434623003006,
0.02312150038778782,
0.010266748256981373,
-0.055796168744564056,
0.009499052539467812,
0.02063111774623394,
0.015072116628289223,
0.0030288617126643658,
0.013785645365715027,
-0.01193472184240818,
-0.0026614952366799116,
-0.0014176353579387069,
-0.010516880080103874,
-0.03177768364548683,
0.039892226457595825,
-0.008203782141208649,
-0.10530044138431549,
-0.024669235572218895,
-0.048729248344898224,
-0.015600327402353287,
-0.003051756415516138,
0.004191483370959759,
-0.025988426059484482,
0.0017278935993090272,
0.026547659188508987,
-0.029396524652838707,
-0.07412975281476974,
0.02653328701853752,
0.021036362275481224,
0.03500901907682419,
-0.0036748521961271763,
0.01641944982111454,
0.05476713925600052,
0.042445022612810135,
0.009775007143616676,
0.06944004446268082,
-0.04231599345803261,
0.0356999970972538,
0.010120302438735962,
0.022725556045770645,
-0.03976479917764664,
-0.01652303896844387,
-0.00423395587131381,
0.015304476022720337,
0.0340583436191082,
0.03668764606118202,
-0.000003663348707050318,
0.0027042641304433346,
0.014537278562784195,
0.013057178817689419,
0.05866309627890587,
-0.001672728918492794,
-0.015927523374557495,
0.0031141696963459253,
0.04656924679875374,
-0.013070239685475826,
0.05509762465953827,
0.0033898837864398956,
-0.045121900737285614,
-0.015325496904551983,
-0.01451876387000084,
0.028139017522335052,
0.03263455256819725,
0.03366329148411751,
0.012823625467717648,
-0.05387217178940773,
-0.001031656051054597,
0.06857873499393463,
0.0002651918912306428,
0.0044702282175421715,
0.0136924022808671,
0.015562818385660648,
0.022962141782045364,
0.013937968760728836,
-0.04645369574427605,
0.011088068597018719,
-0.021496979519724846,
-0.05401212349534035,
0.0064916787669062614,
0.006546650547534227,
-0.03635287284851074,
-0.0029491058085113764,
-0.0348622165620327,
-0.05319453030824661,
0.05983464792370796,
-0.029687706381082535,
-0.021497255191206932,
0.004009854979813099,
0.044832415878772736,
-0.0020463946275413036,
0.04719037190079689,
0.0488446019589901,
-0.06888791173696518,
0.007685148622840643,
0.01577129028737545,
-0.0395752415060997,
0.03295425325632095,
-0.014040805399417877,
0.0804022029042244,
-0.00048249689280055463,
0.0017283590277656913,
0.011239164508879185,
-0.07088860869407654,
-0.0324053093791008,
-0.018047159537672997,
-0.004339322447776794,
0.058529630303382874,
0.0018770558526739478,
0.015358681790530682,
0.06768428534269333,
0.05724603682756424,
0.039631832391023636,
0.08143710345029831,
-0.01721271499991417,
0.02337097004055977,
-0.01180520560592413,
-0.04135598614811897,
-0.014899848960340023,
0.03966870158910751,
-0.04647843912243843,
-0.05510656535625458,
0.034397028386592865,
-0.021083781495690346,
0.022631412371993065,
0.03679952025413513,
-0.014255665242671967,
-0.005314527545124292,
0.02732546441257,
-0.03479369729757309,
0.00041989271994680166,
0.0025210303720086813,
-0.03682001680135727,
0.04286857694387436,
0.01211019791662693,
-0.026698889210820198,
-0.006432081572711468,
-0.04243503510951996,
0.10149826109409332,
0.047109514474868774,
-0.022021621465682983,
-0.023197650909423828,
0.005057539325207472,
0.013980495743453503,
0.007571888156235218,
-0.0006930171512067318,
-0.03129437938332558,
-0.0006323493435047567,
-0.02818283811211586,
-0.013243232853710651,
-0.022207632660865784,
0.032811012119054794,
-0.05198149383068085,
0.015906795859336853,
0.06812077015638351,
-0.04277247563004494,
0.053097520023584366,
0.03565580025315285,
0.017616642639040947,
0.04204436019062996,
-0.03212204948067665,
0.016281498596072197,
-0.0339718759059906,
0.008639569394290447,
-0.00230984203517437,
0.005794540513306856,
0.005910721607506275,
0.00025481090415269136,
-0.03988813981413841,
-0.04297086223959923,
-0.0398000106215477,
0.04873492568731308,
0.05604691058397293,
0.02296251803636551,
0.014273729175329208,
0.015171036124229431,
-0.04345162585377693,
0.004714523442089558,
-0.0997110977768898,
-0.014406050555408001,
-0.013106418773531914,
0.01560143381357193,
0.004649696871638298,
0.024371745064854622,
0.0271522868424654,
0.02296917699277401,
-0.031674087047576904,
-0.021443961188197136,
0.01233956404030323,
0.020317500457167625,
0.01450685877352953,
-0.042284004390239716,
-0.02467954158782959,
-0.010370319709181786,
0.029224993661046028,
-0.02729429118335247,
-0.05205303803086281,
-0.028155488893389702,
-0.05896584317088127,
-0.01889079064130783,
-0.04642009735107422,
0.014064371585845947,
0.020560476928949356,
0.026099184527993202,
0.0036736426409333944,
-0.02770562842488289,
-0.00408990029245615,
0.04603983834385872,
0.05169878527522087,
0.0533800832927227,
0.010978713631629944,
-0.04573354870080948,
0.018252205103635788,
-0.007796385325491428,
0.024499187245965004,
0.005445039831101894,
0.06132401525974274,
-0.029745446518063545,
-0.00740966247394681,
0.01523683499544859,
-0.0283553097397089,
-0.2658357322216034,
0.022330543026328087,
0.010754622519016266,
-0.00954171922057867,
0.04193500429391861,
-0.006517128087580204,
0.05510774627327919,
-0.04964940622448921,
-0.007795531768351793,
0.021012963727116585,
-0.0027798996306955814,
0.06201396510004997,
-0.016332106664776802,
0.03801427036523819,
0.04151499271392822,
0.029342809692025185,
-0.028464239090681076,
-0.02741389535367489,
0.01870713196694851,
0.040369194000959396,
0.026871459558606148,
-0.04789285734295845,
-0.015091539360582829,
0.07438395917415619,
0.001334233209490776,
0.025728821754455566,
-0.09848622977733612,
-0.005820777267217636,
-0.00798672903329134,
-0.0034579120110720396,
0.00748673640191555,
-0.02787027135491371,
0.004923864733427763,
0.019670069217681885,
-0.006674946751445532,
0.03640710562467575,
0.04753924533724785,
0.03272254019975662,
0.0475677065551281,
-0.010975568555295467,
0.008906411938369274,
-0.03334011137485504,
-0.0017046000575646758,
0.022060947492718697,
0.06396134942770004,
-0.002325126901268959,
-0.08232379704713821,
-0.025060297921299934,
0.0038640217389911413,
0.03889545798301697,
-0.020373478531837463,
-0.02008238062262535,
-0.008751981891691685,
0.02184983901679516,
0.00903416145592928,
-0.025576822459697723,
0.017536107450723648,
-0.023629017174243927,
-0.004294559359550476,
-0.006919800769537687,
0.0059699867852032185,
-0.03635820373892784,
-0.022120993584394455,
-0.031864918768405914,
-0.04008850082755089,
-0.03769169747829437,
-0.06305098533630371,
-0.045315053313970566,
0.03390485793352127,
0.05770977586507797,
-0.05157076567411423,
0.024261854588985443,
0.026522785425186157,
-0.08950413763523102,
0.005517634563148022,
-0.0006508941878564656,
-0.03144451975822449,
-0.0006941276369616389,
-0.03043575957417488,
0.036096200346946716,
-0.04461170732975006,
-0.03274531662464142,
-0.016973275691270828,
0.00977285671979189,
0.02003941312432289,
-0.03836388885974884,
0.007174166385084391,
-0.06439422070980072,
0.014784068800508976,
-0.02876579761505127,
0.048897866159677505,
-0.00017792407015804201,
0.02076547220349312,
0.03376191481947899,
0.043333958834409714,
0.025874212384223938,
0.04222928732633591,
0.07040903717279434,
0.052978191524744034,
-0.007193571887910366,
0.03664854168891907,
-0.08502815663814545,
-0.03594418987631798,
-0.031116735190153122,
-0.02688947319984436,
0.02595881186425686,
-0.05716417357325554,
-0.03278566151857376,
0.029277930036187172,
-0.022769281640648842,
-0.04679474979639053,
-0.03778235241770744,
-0.01560176070779562,
-0.009304381906986237,
-0.02867896854877472,
0.009702968411147594,
0.01584453135728836,
0.029775064438581467,
0.02875175140798092,
-0.034802984446287155,
-0.024461010470986366,
0.03577454015612602,
-0.032843537628650665,
0.0001401797926519066,
0.004141394980251789,
-0.04352842643857002,
-0.0023991847410798073,
-0.011147597804665565,
-0.024366412311792374,
-0.027920661494135857,
0.031213102862238884,
0.015621695667505264,
-0.007148013450205326,
0.005188298877328634,
0.044645726680755615,
-0.042323388159275055,
0.025944264605641365,
-0.0013886097585782409,
0.019221026450395584,
0.008333425037562847,
-0.014859383925795555,
-0.02415631152689457,
0.01844508945941925,
-0.0010736195836216211,
0.03448054939508438,
-0.009134449064731598,
0.026407212018966675,
0.02722993679344654,
0.008765676990151405,
0.023891102522611618,
0.07224799692630768,
-0.06706995517015457,
-0.02579396963119507,
-0.028237730264663696,
-0.002442464465275407,
0.0040602656081318855,
0.01624884270131588,
-0.026498258113861084,
0.025002378970384598,
-0.055602625012397766,
0.07461624592542648,
-0.021269110962748528,
-0.03417647257447243,
-0.004297405015677214,
0.025314688682556152,
0.006550785154104233,
-0.012986634857952595,
0.02716081775724888,
0.024484651163220406,
0.013397879898548126,
0.01894478127360344,
-0.024775223806500435,
-0.03714878112077713,
0.009816947393119335,
-0.008753359317779541,
0.013926609419286251,
0.008733493275940418,
0.000981275225058198,
-0.005854214541614056,
0.05263340845704079,
0.03085777908563614,
0.003211286850273609,
0.010574061423540115,
0.011356042698025703,
0.08562992513179779,
0.0076003968715667725,
-0.009567271918058395,
0.004915294703096151,
-0.04553254693746567,
-0.010800138115882874,
-0.018057210370898247,
0.0039645954966545105,
-0.01779356598854065,
-0.06489401310682297,
-0.028170501813292503,
-0.06194508075714111,
0.004239086527377367,
0.0037288996390998363,
-0.022216981276869774,
-0.013192050158977509,
-0.022616753354668617,
0.003223651321604848,
-0.0598064661026001,
-0.01903071627020836,
0.023523351177573204,
-0.07989602535963058,
-0.015865128487348557,
-0.006865459028631449,
-0.029343634843826294,
0.023643743246793747,
-0.006787692662328482,
-0.029810117557644844,
-0.03852500021457672,
-0.028762556612491608,
0.018418435007333755,
-0.03586290776729584,
-0.031608760356903076,
-0.0018420562846586108,
0.006087413057684898,
-0.02045760117471218,
0.010807614773511887,
-0.01245349645614624,
-0.002669216599315405,
-0.008740785531699657,
-0.025915345177054405,
0.03362991660833359,
-0.036624081432819366,
-0.012853805907070637,
-0.011055566370487213,
-0.0627995952963829,
0.01884647086262703,
-0.045092884451150894,
0.021012084558606148,
0.06557310372591019,
-0.011194066144526005,
-0.0029866350814700127,
-0.059819623827934265,
0.061995815485715866,
0.0334542952477932,
0.009150989353656769,
0.0160552728921175,
-0.03628556430339813,
-0.0458342507481575,
0.0128176873549819,
-0.000195389220607467,
0.04231696203351021,
-0.0030293946620076895,
0.019189879298210144,
0.0010810480453073978,
0.013028197921812534,
0.021573813632130623,
0.011125531047582626,
-0.04454527422785759,
-0.00033341048401780427,
0.07187803834676743,
-0.06448784470558167,
-0.05638725683093071,
-0.06645771861076355,
-0.03597050905227661,
0.020815517753362656,
0.00693916343152523,
0.03308931365609169,
-0.03858117759227753,
0.06165885180234909,
0.023026011884212494,
0.018452012911438942,
0.017436349764466286,
-0.018402280285954475,
0.02537151612341404,
-0.03648155555129051,
0.013845755718648434,
-0.06276129186153412,
-0.04362526163458824,
0.07875395566225052,
-0.02160293608903885,
-0.0296279639005661,
-0.017426081001758575,
-0.05453265458345413,
0.04601346701383591,
-0.012792333960533142,
-0.05195426195859909,
0.01433546282351017,
0.006866896990686655,
0.015185864642262459,
0.028830530121922493,
-0.019670529291033745,
0.012030979618430138,
-0.007439975626766682,
-0.03896555304527283,
-0.019107338041067123,
-0.016678063198924065,
0.07150261104106903,
-0.016563819721341133,
0.030784685164690018,
-0.03191795572638512,
0.028286859393119812,
0.0196338202804327,
0.06387116760015488,
0.03364215046167374,
0.035639841109514236,
-0.014294064603745937,
0.06929503381252289,
0.02912047505378723,
-0.012051006779074669,
0.028405634686350822,
-0.00415796460583806,
0.0006455875700339675,
-0.07431983202695847,
0.039510197937488556,
0.006041676737368107,
-0.04765006899833679,
-0.07115709036588669,
0.08347409963607788,
0.039731621742248535,
-0.04105543717741966,
-0.011349618434906006,
0.018133720383048058,
-0.028099678456783295,
-0.02605738490819931,
-0.02218022383749485,
-0.006542094051837921,
-0.005244608037173748,
0.06458195298910141,
0.011117411777377129,
0.054946962743997574,
0.06434177607297897,
0.015987996011972427,
-0.014292809180915356,
-0.01031742338091135,
0.06493977457284927,
0.058256566524505615,
0.048721592873334885,
-0.0006480675656348467,
0.06955978274345398,
-0.04038754105567932,
-0.03993771970272064,
0.014006237499415874,
0.03623553737998009,
-0.004712088033556938,
-0.03581709787249565,
0.02992638200521469,
0.09738557040691376,
0.006949921604245901,
0.06597428768873215,
-0.04383406043052673,
-0.017566777765750885,
0.04107414558529854,
0.0071059721522033215,
0.01187155395746231,
0.028887443244457245,
0.03233356028795242,
0.0004997042124159634,
-0.028862832114100456,
-0.030003787949681282,
0.006589315831661224,
-0.01834704913198948,
0.008288278244435787,
0.009337189607322216,
-0.005433549638837576,
0.02258669026196003,
-0.00676706014201045,
0.053621143102645874,
0.10180658102035522,
-0.04005621001124382,
-0.044405560940504074,
0.018126996234059334,
-0.012080904096364975,
-0.007126440294086933,
0.06680549681186676,
-0.02511449344456196,
-0.006529005244374275,
0.0024062925949692726,
-0.017885711044073105,
0.02096775732934475,
0.01473543606698513,
0.0008337969775311649,
0.020121309906244278,
-0.014077013358473778,
-0.0107381297275424,
-0.002711409470066428,
0.021521070972085,
-0.07990457117557526,
-0.061336636543273926,
-0.028852185234427452,
-0.0318981371819973,
-0.0548899881541729,
-0.040609486401081085,
0.024197591468691826,
0.0208195261657238,
-0.0327792651951313,
0.0006976952427066863,
-0.06189785525202751,
-0.00034333299845457077,
0.03211010619997978,
-0.06125548481941223,
0.009733937680721283,
0.034269437193870544,
-0.00389306852594018,
-0.016286997124552727,
0.035278648138046265,
0.005620559677481651,
-0.004312153905630112,
-0.007163462229073048,
0.04030861705541611,
0.03932768106460571,
0.02238232083618641,
-0.0112144211307168,
-0.019523972645401955,
-0.10047123581171036,
0.013607519678771496,
0.015860287472605705,
-0.039027098566293716,
-0.07799579948186874,
0.005798033904284239,
-0.016787933185696602,
0.06462746113538742,
0.05743908882141113,
0.038296911865472794,
0.011160997673869133,
-0.02607502043247223,
-0.000757077184971422,
0.011977528221905231,
0.021439559757709503,
0.041343461722135544,
-0.019593290984630585,
0.06539210677146912,
0.047650568187236786,
-0.013949285261332989,
-0.033117953687906265,
0.010778612457215786,
0.004560530185699463,
-0.000023855023755459115,
-0.008947310037910938,
-0.0343618243932724,
-0.014351612888276577,
-0.07453643530607224,
-0.013242527842521667,
0.03658411651849747,
-0.012544386088848114,
-0.0292921494692564,
-0.00518243620172143,
-0.014155784621834755,
-0.03854548931121826,
-0.0045876894146203995,
-0.018617982044816017,
-0.011354133486747742,
-0.020883042365312576,
-0.034523770213127136,
-0.051065873354673386,
0.026287607848644257,
-0.05618836358189583,
-0.0004971821326762438,
-0.030160171911120415,
-0.01822301559150219,
0.009427937678992748,
-0.029201464727520943,
0.054964322596788406,
0.005692191421985626,
0.015283197164535522,
-0.023575447499752045
] |
310 |
ICLR: In-Context Learning of Representations
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=pXlmOmlHJZ
|
[
"Core Francisco Park",
"Andrew Lee",
"Ekdeep Singh Lubana",
"Yongyi Yang",
"Maya Okawa",
"Kento Nishi",
"Martin Wattenberg",
"Hidenori Tanaka"
] |
Poster
|
Recent work demonstrates that structured patterns in pretraining data influence how representations of different concepts are organized in a large language model’s (LLM) internals, with such representations then driving downstream abilities. Given the open-ended nature of LLMs, e.g., their ability to in-context learn novel tasks, we ask whether models can flexibly alter their semantically grounded organization of concepts. Specifically, if we provide in-context exemplars wherein a concept plays a different role than what the pretraining data suggests, can models infer these novel semantics and reorganize representations in accordance with them? To answer this question, we define a toy “graph tracing” task wherein the nodes of the graph are referenced via concepts seen during training (e.g., apple, bird, etc.), and the connectivity of the graph is defined via some predefined structure (e.g., a square grid). Given exemplars that indicate traces of random walks on the graph, we analyze intermediate representations of the model and find that as the amount of context is scaled, there is a sudden re-organization of representations according to the graph’s structure. Further, we find that when reference concepts have correlations in their semantics (e.g., Monday, Tuesday, etc.), the context-specified graph structure is still present in the representations, but is unable to dominate the pretrained structure. To explain these results, we analogize our task to energy minimization for a predefined graph topology, which shows getting non-trivial performance on the task requires for the model to infer a connected component. Overall, our findings indicate context-size may be an underappreciated scaling axis that can flexibly re-organize model representations, unlocking novel capabilities.
|
In-Context Learning, Representational Geometry, World Models, Emergence, Percolation
|
Large language models develop emergent task specific representations given enough in-context exemplars.
| 13,560 |
2501.00070
|
[
-0.009203879162669182,
0.01021272037178278,
-0.021085431799292564,
0.032232705503702164,
0.0407530702650547,
-0.002728409133851528,
0.030175866559147835,
0.028314922004938126,
-0.03196505829691887,
-0.007839163765311241,
-0.03109721839427948,
0.001976547297090292,
-0.04395126551389694,
-0.007735287304967642,
-0.003813434625044465,
0.07343228161334991,
0.038967084139585495,
0.0017705068457871675,
0.016127951443195343,
0.010336055420339108,
-0.000607694499194622,
-0.01639540120959282,
0.008452430367469788,
0.0052955918945372105,
0.019632777199149132,
0.015602907165884972,
0.039810601621866226,
-0.001520292367786169,
-0.026872094720602036,
0.0110860550776124,
0.026223881170153618,
-0.019294722005724907,
0.030998993664979935,
-0.0306529700756073,
0.020416468381881714,
-0.0033430256880819798,
-0.05070165544748306,
-0.015192383900284767,
-0.010266578756272793,
-0.021453751251101494,
-0.06045994535088539,
0.02405576780438423,
0.0020340837072581053,
-0.01696629449725151,
-0.06714306771755219,
-0.009099232964217663,
-0.11897140741348267,
0.03694293648004532,
0.04896687716245651,
-0.029475875198841095,
-0.10772106051445007,
0.03026643767952919,
0.025726741179823875,
-0.014703849330544472,
-0.002799558686092496,
0.035376500338315964,
0.03727046027779579,
-0.07812250405550003,
0.0143585791811347,
-0.05228646472096443,
-0.038892801851034164,
0.022184349596500397,
0.0010244825389236212,
0.010873873718082905,
-0.01573275588452816,
-0.028995556756854057,
-0.013807912357151508,
0.03205497935414314,
-0.07080689817667007,
-0.03999657928943634,
-0.036484330892562866,
0.004508530721068382,
-0.03332104906439781,
0.04537653923034668,
0.002346478635445237,
-0.03844869136810303,
-0.0007058106712065637,
0.03291480615735054,
0.05302487313747406,
0.01328818965703249,
0.006264134310185909,
0.04840272292494774,
0.01295098289847374,
0.018110916018486023,
0.010610758326947689,
-0.015738384798169136,
-0.05474153533577919,
-0.06909476220607758,
-0.07025165110826492,
0.024617528542876244,
-0.032214656472206116,
-0.06272198259830475,
0.016889706254005432,
0.034695710986852646,
0.014763417653739452,
0.002849813550710678,
0.011696790345013142,
0.011208404786884785,
0.0027156714349985123,
0.00030488247284665704,
-0.013965504243969917,
-0.03620913624763489,
0.018738968297839165,
-0.006986605003476143,
-0.10786502808332443,
-0.022621693089604378,
-0.024708839133381844,
-0.01612880825996399,
0.00653726514428854,
-0.007929977960884571,
-0.06471828371286392,
-0.026275744661688805,
0.021228890866041183,
-0.019031334668397903,
-0.0629635602235794,
0.02413291111588478,
0.029016947373747826,
0.0464460514485836,
-0.009142721071839333,
0.020653968676924706,
0.02231464721262455,
0.03479815274477005,
0.022477775812149048,
0.06767640262842178,
-0.034532610327005386,
0.021987106651067734,
-0.019722312688827515,
0.022801006212830544,
-0.045901793986558914,
-0.05748738348484039,
0.01774759776890278,
0.05153655260801315,
0.008655551820993423,
-0.014803394675254822,
-0.014561415649950504,
-0.021462636068463326,
0.030924145132303238,
-0.007339582312852144,
0.028351593762636185,
0.024034865200519562,
0.020880544558167458,
-0.028182193636894226,
0.05042174458503723,
-0.018878573551774025,
0.07536480575799942,
-0.010637922212481499,
-0.049750614911317825,
-0.00531425466760993,
-0.022882239893078804,
-0.011616935022175312,
0.028801532462239265,
0.0049059768207371235,
0.014437318779528141,
-0.04941342771053314,
0.05330086126923561,
0.06774157285690308,
-0.0022663595154881477,
0.02828105166554451,
0.00678349519148469,
0.011773199774324894,
0.012845163233578205,
-0.014453820884227753,
-0.037119582295417786,
0.028125770390033722,
-0.010155663825571537,
-0.0702214166522026,
0.01418808288872242,
0.01123681478202343,
-0.04950925335288048,
-0.004353792872279882,
-0.01864209771156311,
-0.06729399412870407,
0.06262695789337158,
-0.03978344798088074,
-0.022626474499702454,
-0.02377924881875515,
0.0485859215259552,
-0.004871540702879429,
0.032027117908000946,
0.01190672256052494,
-0.07852914929389954,
0.016038626432418823,
-0.013733276166021824,
0.0026134327054023743,
0.009310363791882992,
-0.014260022900998592,
0.053550172597169876,
-0.019930636510252953,
-0.009028270840644836,
0.022725090384483337,
-0.0635809525847435,
0.004440488759428263,
0.023225272074341774,
-0.009860469028353691,
0.08967636525630951,
-0.021556610241532326,
-0.011695426888763905,
0.032783761620521545,
0.01983627863228321,
0.044109877198934555,
0.036079294979572296,
-0.029992107301950455,
0.029157042503356934,
-0.0016032792627811432,
-0.01304800994694233,
0.0042747617699205875,
0.028832636773586273,
-0.0635397806763649,
-0.04530499503016472,
0.014260594733059406,
0.0015354490606114268,
-0.004418313968926668,
0.03462269529700279,
-0.01304125227034092,
0.01340829860419035,
-0.0005075717926956713,
-0.014489015564322472,
0.01875610090792179,
0.018108708783984184,
-0.04531001299619675,
0.03762666881084442,
0.0024945177137851715,
-0.011451110243797302,
-0.015358900651335716,
-0.027886610478162766,
0.08146458864212036,
0.05758078023791313,
-0.02139783278107643,
-0.012313795275986195,
0.006195977795869112,
0.021750837564468384,
0.00540159922093153,
0.015806956216692924,
-0.042455337941646576,
0.01286837738007307,
-0.04200826212763786,
-0.01669410988688469,
-0.028379904106259346,
0.04771088808774948,
-0.03646785020828247,
-0.022592810913920403,
0.0811557024717331,
-0.03478151559829712,
0.046867311000823975,
-0.008282125927507877,
0.029909204691648483,
0.041230082511901855,
-0.019414115697145462,
-0.019608868286013603,
-0.010070333257317543,
-0.006112119182944298,
-0.00512000871822238,
-0.0300152488052845,
-0.02354726567864418,
0.0056246318854391575,
-0.03812902048230171,
-0.006481607910245657,
-0.01914973370730877,
0.07451635599136353,
0.05894993990659714,
0.03765484690666199,
0.03668181598186493,
-0.002579457126557827,
-0.013994994573295116,
0.000026848281777347438,
-0.08387582004070282,
-0.02331356145441532,
-0.03326421231031418,
0.05839639529585838,
0.0019227212760597467,
0.04443678632378578,
-0.012537619099020958,
0.029970666393637657,
-0.007518945261836052,
-0.018992358818650246,
-0.0058531248942017555,
0.015124897472560406,
0.002168194390833378,
-0.03012876585125923,
0.011817661114037037,
-0.026910729706287384,
0.022110573947429657,
0.015163218602538109,
-0.029025673866271973,
-0.019714735448360443,
-0.02570630982518196,
-0.009950214996933937,
-0.018768131732940674,
-0.012298451736569405,
-0.006488928571343422,
0.04155873507261276,
0.030882898718118668,
-0.008001157082617283,
0.008910112082958221,
0.04933873564004898,
0.07006049901247025,
0.06332772970199585,
-0.0063026160933077335,
-0.003263239050284028,
0.015917854383587837,
-0.03809410333633423,
0.039090562611818314,
0.013826907612383366,
0.030902650207281113,
0.0020191085059195757,
0.015173999592661858,
-0.0012325813295319676,
0.008898137137293816,
-0.25721246004104614,
-0.025988925248384476,
0.01440814696252346,
-0.03451230004429817,
0.02769326977431774,
-0.017201554030179977,
0.0467090979218483,
-0.025720223784446716,
-0.028534093871712685,
0.01574939303100109,
0.01613227091729641,
0.03286776691675186,
-0.0005920169060118496,
0.03927018865942955,
0.04609040170907974,
0.042070355266332626,
0.010213982313871384,
-0.021135078743100166,
-0.00927590299397707,
0.056605152785778046,
-0.006349007599055767,
-0.05345481261610985,
-0.05479377135634422,
0.0673104077577591,
-0.022151540964841843,
0.04195768013596535,
-0.10388606041669846,
0.02549750544130802,
-0.0402744822204113,
0.010632650926709175,
-0.029800472781062126,
-0.03679822012782097,
0.013827851042151451,
0.020564310252666473,
0.0016199663514271379,
0.004634255543351173,
0.06469541043043137,
0.02108028717339039,
0.021942317485809326,
-0.01708049699664116,
0.014341295696794987,
-0.027140207588672638,
-0.003587026847526431,
-0.0005231635877862573,
0.0682026818394661,
0.00009290866000810638,
-0.07801906019449234,
-0.04921530932188034,
-0.023675009608268738,
0.03236173465847969,
-0.019840754568576813,
-0.037137191742658615,
0.008811193518340588,
0.0030658424366265535,
0.02511576935648918,
-0.041726693511009216,
0.03426939249038696,
-0.02738005667924881,
-0.02388891950249672,
-0.03100721910595894,
0.018490664660930634,
-0.06251230090856552,
-0.014417743310332298,
-0.07408946007490158,
-0.008449398912489414,
-0.035848867148160934,
-0.06301134079694748,
-0.04992489144206047,
0.024950318038463593,
0.04429960995912552,
-0.021417129784822464,
0.03805634379386902,
-0.016006596386432648,
-0.08511331677436829,
0.002687308471649885,
-0.01690070703625679,
0.003423016518354416,
-0.029185928404331207,
0.023685840889811516,
0.028289955109357834,
-0.033378731459379196,
-0.021517403423786163,
-0.024986082687973976,
0.03035316988825798,
0.014321251772344112,
-0.0036607750225812197,
0.01909811794757843,
-0.034444987773895264,
-0.042231492698192596,
-0.030107365921139717,
0.018329737707972527,
0.03755839169025421,
0.014850794337689877,
0.028822368010878563,
0.0423450730741024,
0.03395131602883339,
0.03011169284582138,
0.04464094713330269,
0.06069542095065117,
-0.019272197037935257,
0.022133946418762207,
-0.09524174779653549,
-0.011449141427874565,
0.008238091133534908,
-0.05305447801947594,
0.04574684798717499,
-0.07493248581886292,
-0.03682955354452133,
0.03817245364189148,
-0.006414957344532013,
-0.03161062300205231,
-0.048396818339824677,
0.016259394586086273,
-0.013758332468569279,
-0.030555400997400284,
-0.02063974365592003,
0.014811175875365734,
0.028174910694360733,
0.009846575558185577,
-0.020377181470394135,
-0.04303475469350815,
0.046304475516080856,
-0.027604758739471436,
0.013473860919475555,
-0.007229664362967014,
-0.03152371942996979,
0.0062293121591210365,
-0.01875503920018673,
-0.039277683943510056,
0.0261848084628582,
0.029664484784007072,
0.032232895493507385,
0.009993116371333599,
0.018813427537679672,
0.06142953410744667,
-0.003394451690837741,
0.015613008290529251,
-0.006238250993192196,
0.04282904788851738,
-0.01925996132194996,
-0.012227131985127926,
0.022673845291137695,
0.04829235374927521,
0.021592948585748672,
0.038783688098192215,
0.011533591896295547,
-0.01222655363380909,
0.0014157197438180447,
-0.020381195470690727,
0.00699189119040966,
0.054037854075431824,
-0.03891923278570175,
-0.013217118568718433,
-0.012811941094696522,
0.012096365913748741,
-0.015267151407897472,
0.029011251404881477,
-0.027230091392993927,
0.01505697425454855,
-0.06049498915672302,
0.04702109843492508,
-0.0014313113642856479,
0.01967363804578781,
0.0031827527564018965,
0.005408260505646467,
0.03229731693863869,
-0.011225629597902298,
0.003466658992692828,
0.03507831320166588,
0.015938470140099525,
0.02337641827762127,
-0.004011789336800575,
-0.018870726227760315,
0.021384088322520256,
-0.04812195524573326,
0.01655697636306286,
-0.007323550526052713,
-0.0007212689379230142,
-0.009589724242687225,
0.039887685328722,
0.012110081501305103,
-0.04040856659412384,
-0.01731136254966259,
0.022975051775574684,
0.09437056630849838,
0.01696266233921051,
0.05124737694859505,
0.007815081626176834,
-0.03434506431221962,
0.023062976077198982,
0.011219033971428871,
0.00612837728112936,
-0.01426638662815094,
-0.0316222608089447,
-0.05049452185630798,
-0.018385453149676323,
0.022766543552279472,
0.00018820355762727559,
-0.025820037350058556,
-0.019477151334285736,
-0.021692868322134018,
0.008119489997625351,
-0.04605593904852867,
-0.0035066851414740086,
0.04592035338282585,
-0.06524933874607086,
-0.023563118651509285,
0.013639087788760662,
-0.01991836540400982,
0.0063464888371527195,
-0.05521892011165619,
-0.02575872838497162,
-0.0350099541246891,
-0.03548680245876312,
0.03095906600356102,
-0.021337144076824188,
-0.010615232400596142,
-0.043149832636117935,
-0.014879755675792694,
0.029146453365683556,
0.026779625564813614,
-0.00022662020637653768,
-0.00956768449395895,
-0.015032261610031128,
0.005574315320700407,
0.057205863296985626,
-0.017753997817635536,
0.0018556388095021248,
-0.0049432506784796715,
-0.05819537118077278,
0.018216338008642197,
-0.01957571506500244,
0.02831122651696205,
0.052785445004701614,
-0.027268679812550545,
-0.01672087050974369,
-0.029980214312672615,
0.06999684870243073,
0.04195311665534973,
0.008351429365575314,
0.02948150597512722,
-0.01434469036757946,
-0.03249368444085121,
0.005498021375387907,
0.017508693039417267,
0.0326557531952858,
0.026992525905370712,
-0.003977505024522543,
0.005913121160119772,
0.00853924360126257,
0.016128920018672943,
-0.012510545551776886,
-0.02236280031502247,
-0.025178806856274605,
0.07102488726377487,
-0.003914875444024801,
-0.05389378219842911,
-0.05106932669878006,
-0.036205045878887177,
0.0021696011535823345,
-0.008992229588329792,
0.011853146366775036,
-0.03412830829620361,
0.049491602927446365,
0.02933674119412899,
0.07363253831863403,
-0.0008776942268013954,
-0.01124098151922226,
0.031002871692180634,
-0.01228317990899086,
0.04374798387289047,
-0.053590331226587296,
-0.028963148593902588,
0.034150272607803345,
-0.026143444702029228,
-0.016201207414269447,
-0.030290387570858,
-0.013520332053303719,
0.050445497035980225,
-0.029321318492293358,
-0.07140515744686127,
0.019294213503599167,
-0.0013943708036094904,
0.01607092097401619,
0.04563846066594124,
-0.04380375146865845,
0.006673465017229319,
-0.044903628528118134,
-0.04782417416572571,
-0.035397935658693314,
-0.00693917740136385,
0.054853156208992004,
-0.03916890546679497,
0.022827308624982834,
0.017282117158174515,
0.042399197816848755,
0.011989676393568516,
0.08767647296190262,
0.04296738654375076,
0.049237996339797974,
-0.0335550531744957,
0.0569949634373188,
0.017292380332946777,
-0.015248574316501617,
-0.024095462635159492,
0.013500770553946495,
-0.005137702915817499,
-0.05170951783657074,
0.04535571485757828,
-0.00016712344950065017,
-0.004473371896892786,
-0.05085252225399017,
0.0889095589518547,
0.021383125334978104,
-0.03067002072930336,
-0.012577605433762074,
0.023708265274763107,
-0.07193222641944885,
0.012415321543812752,
0.02985699661076069,
0.012772773392498493,
-0.04476982355117798,
0.06589285284280777,
0.03965059667825699,
0.03513234108686447,
0.06972610205411911,
0.017691388726234436,
-0.023110315203666687,
0.008646063506603241,
0.07375168055295944,
0.07619711756706238,
0.05339350923895836,
0.02617563121020794,
0.07258140295743942,
-0.03863921016454697,
-0.03352559357881546,
0.007895221933722496,
-0.0060893031768500805,
0.007501303683966398,
-0.04468561336398125,
0.02060859650373459,
0.06661143153905869,
-0.003804197534918785,
0.06115239858627319,
-0.04757450893521309,
-0.014724989421665668,
0.06464269012212753,
-0.005156076978892088,
-0.004459844436496496,
0.03372945636510849,
0.04055487737059593,
0.0333639420568943,
-0.03377414867281914,
-0.021120674908161163,
-0.0023815662134438753,
-0.015528867952525616,
0.029712753370404243,
0.03534156084060669,
-0.008257519453763962,
-0.009044252336025238,
-0.026563633233308792,
0.0694110319018364,
0.1499321162700653,
-0.0289313904941082,
-0.02480776235461235,
-0.021136026829481125,
-0.008027704432606697,
0.030700847506523132,
0.03811982646584511,
-0.004784110933542252,
-0.037115179002285004,
-0.002885559108108282,
-0.05803766846656799,
-0.017631959170103073,
0.0032216012477874756,
-0.0049444236792624,
0.0005461880355142057,
-0.027657773345708847,
-0.03428247570991516,
0.008467627689242363,
0.01672866940498352,
-0.04259037598967552,
-0.06270487606525421,
-0.015552666038274765,
-0.020451100543141365,
-0.06810250878334045,
-0.033568672835826874,
0.05003634840250015,
-0.014877322129905224,
-0.018359718844294548,
-0.005563054233789444,
-0.02626604586839676,
0.016042660921812057,
-0.002864421810954809,
-0.06461537629365921,
0.008379565551877022,
0.011242431588470936,
0.012033825740218163,
0.003425970673561096,
0.02920532040297985,
-0.0004507172852754593,
-0.02287786453962326,
-0.01671791821718216,
0.040855519473552704,
0.012589427642524242,
0.030685963109135628,
-0.01702209934592247,
-0.015209861099720001,
-0.09933863580226898,
-0.0019809904042631388,
0.012272673659026623,
-0.05426279827952385,
-0.08122523128986359,
0.030450470745563507,
0.0026097192894667387,
0.04573947191238403,
0.05085103586316109,
0.0018274172907695174,
0.012115905992686749,
-0.010635160841047764,
0.0006016828119754791,
0.003506438573822379,
0.01982985995709896,
0.05734934285283089,
-0.03200143203139305,
0.08622664213180542,
0.05709752067923546,
-0.0013206759467720985,
-0.023102303966879845,
-0.03366617485880852,
0.022076338529586792,
-0.012891761027276516,
-0.029104169458150864,
-0.018615903332829475,
-0.011778834275901318,
-0.10562224686145782,
-0.01663495972752571,
0.009436517022550106,
0.015877865254878998,
-0.03901827335357666,
-0.01963627152144909,
-0.028976602479815483,
-0.05028242990374565,
-0.009561726823449135,
-0.011052552610635757,
0.019220327958464622,
-0.00668875640258193,
-0.04360876977443695,
-0.0531417615711689,
0.009703229181468487,
-0.026969831436872482,
-0.005054930225014687,
-0.05062808096408844,
-0.04001101478934288,
-0.00967560987919569,
-0.012785128317773342,
0.033238641917705536,
-0.007529933471232653,
0.04168388247489929,
-0.012726645916700363
] |
311 |
Ensembling Diffusion Models via Adaptive Feature Aggregation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=e32cI4r8Eo
|
[
"Cong Wang",
"Kuan Tian",
"Yonghang Guan",
"Fei Shen",
"Zhiwei Jiang",
"Qing Gu",
"Jun Zhang"
] |
Poster
|
The success of the text-guided diffusion model has inspired the development and release of numerous powerful diffusion models within the open-source community. These models are typically fine-tuned on various expert datasets, showcasing diverse denoising capabilities. Leveraging multiple high-quality models to produce stronger generation ability is valuable, but has not been extensively studied. Existing methods primarily adopt parameter merging strategies to produce a new static model. However, they overlook the fact that the divergent denoising capabilities of the models may dynamically change across different states, such as when experiencing different prompts, initial noises, denoising steps, and spatial locations. In this paper, we propose a novel ensembling method, Adaptive Feature Aggregation (AFA), which dynamically adjusts the contributions of multiple models at the feature level according to various states (i.e., prompts, initial noises, denoising steps, and spatial locations), thereby keeping the advantages of multiple diffusion models, while suppressing their disadvantages. Specifically, we design a lightweight Spatial-Aware Block-Wise (SABW) feature aggregator that adaptive aggregates the block-wise intermediate features from multiple U-Net denoisers into a unified one. The core idea lies in dynamically producing an individual attention map for each model's features by comprehensively considering various states. It is worth noting that only SABW is trainable with about 50 million parameters, while other models are frozen. Both the quantitative and qualitative experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
Image Generation, Diffusion Models, Model Ensembling
|
We propose Adaptive Feature Aggregation (AFA) to ensemble multiple diffusion models dynamically based on different states.
| 13,559 |
2405.17082
|
[
-0.0028666118159890175,
-0.03624468296766281,
0.012124773114919662,
0.017992554232478142,
0.030623747035861015,
0.048282381147146225,
0.04695826768875122,
-0.023908553645014763,
-0.021179111674427986,
-0.0654808059334755,
-0.016486000269651413,
-0.04396096244454384,
-0.05862996354699135,
-0.0012201734352856874,
0.01874653436243534,
0.0504176989197731,
0.04735615849494934,
-0.00484114047139883,
-0.0006999583565630019,
0.053455643355846405,
0.03262437507510185,
-0.01208074577152729,
0.03936620056629181,
0.000617275305557996,
0.022501276805996895,
-0.010516666807234287,
0.03429796174168587,
-0.021229123696684837,
-0.020353173837065697,
-0.01093667559325695,
0.03685219585895538,
0.0185390654951334,
0.020763779059052467,
-0.019643336534500122,
0.027979137375950813,
-0.012346399948000908,
-0.05855098366737366,
-0.011355639435350895,
0.024418745189905167,
0.02045937068760395,
-0.05402100458741188,
-0.0006849776837043464,
-0.005224817432463169,
0.009811151772737503,
-0.05568905174732208,
-0.015276605263352394,
-0.121303029358387,
0.033046040683984756,
0.0020072099287062883,
-0.04550942778587341,
-0.09906505048274994,
0.02233879268169403,
0.009985608048737049,
-0.00371969910338521,
-0.010520651936531067,
0.045743588358163834,
0.0512719601392746,
-0.07508241385221481,
0.01330315601080656,
-0.03924240916967392,
-0.0390380397439003,
0.03036772459745407,
-0.006362824700772762,
0.003707217052578926,
0.010698600672185421,
-0.012712709605693817,
-0.005777193699032068,
0.04199657961726189,
-0.03721959888935089,
-0.0494452603161335,
0.004973420407623053,
-0.0028540983330458403,
-0.009714122861623764,
0.0031496661249548197,
-0.007793199270963669,
-0.03197914734482765,
0.036981742829084396,
0.012938207015395164,
0.05125918984413147,
-0.035650819540023804,
0.026359442621469498,
0.004238499328494072,
-0.0008268344681710005,
0.0376802496612072,
0.038407664746046066,
-0.02743363566696644,
-0.03459072858095169,
-0.007987120188772678,
-0.0879398062825203,
0.03931774944067001,
-0.059731561690568924,
-0.06740249693393707,
0.019852569326758385,
0.03193892166018486,
0.031041322275996208,
-0.015016117133200169,
0.0073913224041461945,
0.0021266716066747904,
0.038388725370168686,
0.009638996794819832,
0.013298973441123962,
-0.025091467425227165,
-0.0013879539910703897,
0.02261527255177498,
-0.0829668715596199,
-0.022616811096668243,
-0.015548387542366982,
-0.003334247739985585,
-0.02170039527118206,
-0.005365884397178888,
-0.0029254117980599403,
0.00453134486451745,
-0.00032821818604134023,
-0.0042655738070607185,
-0.06578564643859863,
0.03197341784834862,
0.011594410054385662,
0.005527203902602196,
0.026361064985394478,
-0.013697353191673756,
0.07026156783103943,
0.055155444890260696,
-0.025802813470363617,
0.06668572127819061,
-0.01552833616733551,
0.002659520599991083,
-0.0017611122457310557,
0.017866717651486397,
-0.03959735482931137,
0.003441970329731703,
-0.008239825256168842,
0.026200026273727417,
0.0012020997237414122,
0.007010311353951693,
0.020061159506440163,
-0.03797575458884239,
0.015874790027737617,
0.02301848866045475,
0.05699256435036659,
-0.028353646397590637,
-0.004332942422479391,
0.01923791505396366,
0.028094986453652382,
-0.02747790515422821,
0.05064287781715393,
-0.002457311376929283,
-0.028724677860736847,
-0.034237105399370193,
-0.03722000867128372,
-0.02439626306295395,
0.020883629098534584,
-0.0026210120413452387,
0.034425877034664154,
-0.05328972265124321,
0.02211129106581211,
0.07533694058656693,
0.01738363690674305,
-0.009424205869436264,
0.024253401905298233,
-0.010578058660030365,
0.03303861245512962,
0.000623306434135884,
-0.024765202775597572,
-0.005091693717986345,
-0.017194602638483047,
-0.07100950181484222,
0.02194487676024437,
0.03794010356068611,
-0.030536772683262825,
-0.034804001450538635,
-0.03378906846046448,
-0.04500799998641014,
0.050694845616817474,
0.014988608658313751,
-0.012415053322911263,
-0.01653248257935047,
0.03201323375105858,
0.034065116196870804,
0.031280726194381714,
0.04062804952263832,
-0.08305177837610245,
0.014961346052587032,
0.010176336392760277,
0.012257697060704231,
0.01173660159111023,
-0.030791502445936203,
0.0956210345029831,
-0.02552896924316883,
0.004535318817943335,
0.022586969658732414,
-0.08012530207633972,
-0.033034548163414,
0.025567665696144104,
-0.010087206959724426,
0.04328863322734833,
0.022096790373325348,
-0.005184950772672892,
0.04523416608572006,
0.040704745799303055,
0.05430470407009125,
0.056472502648830414,
-0.03768781200051308,
0.04898945614695549,
-0.006773830857127905,
-0.020592758432030678,
-0.010006981901824474,
0.039465516805648804,
-0.029365452006459236,
-0.021168934181332588,
-0.008611937053501606,
-0.01009769830852747,
-0.016918610781431198,
0.012137976475059986,
0.014332861639559269,
0.029953977093100548,
0.01728866808116436,
0.016337323933839798,
0.008688881061971188,
0.0008013588958419859,
-0.040409624576568604,
-0.006667854730039835,
0.028254173696041107,
-0.04958254098892212,
0.036204542964696884,
-0.017316149547696114,
0.07564852386713028,
0.045858655124902725,
-0.03225132077932358,
-0.004252293612807989,
-0.003208960173651576,
0.004467122722417116,
0.009374546818435192,
0.014562167227268219,
-0.022536439821124077,
0.029468031600117683,
-0.020035818219184875,
0.027703410014510155,
-0.010013514198362827,
0.0434582345187664,
-0.04925107955932617,
0.006812465842813253,
0.06057517230510712,
-0.012523510493338108,
0.05224202200770378,
-0.0014647875213995576,
0.03685822710394859,
0.05383574217557907,
-0.005511218681931496,
-0.00311749754473567,
-0.001043044263496995,
0.017476482316851616,
0.0139162577688694,
0.014214778319001198,
-0.058016981929540634,
0.04039468988776207,
-0.04758678376674652,
0.0033417774830013514,
-0.021238626912236214,
0.09956172108650208,
0.02674971893429756,
0.009374991990625858,
0.0284116193652153,
-0.023193271830677986,
-0.02291116490960121,
-0.033561091870069504,
-0.121717169880867,
-0.018801970407366753,
-0.016193561255931854,
0.025290995836257935,
-0.008998832665383816,
0.039727479219436646,
0.00852495152503252,
-0.0011272643459960818,
-0.031076377257704735,
-0.000008329403499374166,
-0.02970256097614765,
0.0376017726957798,
0.007031700108200312,
-0.041574012488126755,
-0.021717479452490807,
0.007329586427658796,
0.07054701447486877,
0.029660319909453392,
-0.005101916845887899,
-0.03014468587934971,
-0.055010970681905746,
-0.005843800492584705,
0.00156432727817446,
-0.014014115557074547,
0.040663085877895355,
0.028358137235045433,
0.0292104110121727,
0.011533106677234173,
0.029478769749403,
0.018044324591755867,
0.06745345145463943,
-0.003295433707535267,
-0.026070982217788696,
-0.03630045801401138,
-0.008617881685495377,
0.0055573550052940845,
-0.0031854354310780764,
0.013537570834159851,
0.0067543648183345795,
0.0031372038647532463,
-0.003793448908254504,
0.010544045828282833,
-0.010289641097187996,
-0.26987385749816895,
0.025038225576281548,
0.05689869448542595,
-0.02495727501809597,
0.009505817666649818,
-0.016878696158528328,
0.04506276547908783,
-0.03873689845204353,
-0.024196669459342957,
0.014716733247041702,
-0.007622503209859133,
0.03319031000137329,
-0.0038074797485023737,
0.01962033100426197,
0.027603216469287872,
-0.008239704184234142,
-0.012236121110618114,
-0.03812017664313316,
0.018744997680187225,
0.0362129732966423,
-0.01684686727821827,
-0.0787745863199234,
0.002740405732765794,
0.04833894595503807,
-0.020003139972686768,
0.023679211735725403,
-0.06558731943368912,
0.014979285188019276,
-0.029101960361003876,
0.01734965853393078,
-0.011113297194242477,
-0.04312055930495262,
0.005702011752873659,
0.05746200308203697,
-0.0059889196418225765,
0.004520761780440807,
0.034021440893411636,
0.03492588549852371,
0.020360790193080902,
-0.002267194213345647,
0.04563194885849953,
-0.003474202938377857,
-0.014748764224350452,
-0.00434624869376421,
0.0520285964012146,
0.0022429798264056444,
-0.017252901569008827,
-0.011312845163047314,
-0.030357947573065758,
0.026618309319019318,
0.02191072702407837,
-0.022940365597605705,
-0.029464779421687126,
0.01024672482162714,
-0.02480217255651951,
-0.0326259508728981,
0.01355352345854044,
0.001983091002330184,
-0.002048210008069873,
0.034640632569789886,
-0.008933150209486485,
-0.06569849699735641,
-0.021770790219306946,
-0.05152767151594162,
0.0008506482699885964,
-0.03767320141196251,
-0.06943058222532272,
-0.056698620319366455,
0.04655630141496658,
0.04568476602435112,
-0.01302336622029543,
0.017923342064023018,
-0.00740960193797946,
-0.09834171086549759,
-0.0010007082019001245,
-0.0016448377864435315,
-0.008453087881207466,
-0.007683432660996914,
-0.027369294315576553,
0.0488433837890625,
-0.043487608432769775,
-0.0031914343126118183,
0.044339537620544434,
0.022451991215348244,
0.00024026203027460724,
-0.002082307357341051,
0.014705180190503597,
0.0023735465947538614,
-0.01621188595890999,
-0.025687461718916893,
0.03827010095119476,
0.03814741224050522,
0.03209322690963745,
-0.01808340474963188,
0.03182685002684593,
0.04601142555475235,
0.03436333313584328,
0.05393845587968826,
0.02834462560713291,
-0.016794640570878983,
0.057222880423069,
-0.07040443271398544,
-0.028652941808104515,
-0.04677959904074669,
-0.03797224536538124,
0.03972235694527626,
-0.07491615414619446,
-0.014329589903354645,
0.04027365520596504,
0.00598237756639719,
-0.0361485481262207,
-0.0224616676568985,
0.022998683154582977,
0.0011451167520135641,
-0.00794871523976326,
-0.02687361277639866,
-0.03839519992470741,
0.031598422676324844,
0.043321289122104645,
-0.015380140393972397,
-0.005985178519040346,
0.04738711938261986,
-0.030394697561860085,
-0.00518925441429019,
0.015830863267183304,
-0.017044590786099434,
-0.06133056432008743,
-0.012203237973153591,
-0.0024133173283189535,
-0.011323696933686733,
0.0588383786380291,
0.04919801652431488,
0.00973103754222393,
0.0207993071526289,
0.054090239107608795,
-0.02531268075108528,
-0.03853048384189606,
-0.012812242843210697,
0.043877966701984406,
-0.011065028607845306,
0.019310196861624718,
-0.026467347517609596,
0.02605612389743328,
0.02670603059232235,
0.02314397692680359,
0.006924035958945751,
0.0157181266695261,
0.026931140571832657,
0.004829470068216324,
-0.048191577196121216,
0.027247818186879158,
-0.060936518013477325,
-0.08444300293922424,
-0.012123056687414646,
-0.012628092430531979,
-0.032441459596157074,
0.005075281020253897,
-0.02933543175458908,
0.022212078794836998,
-0.08131226152181625,
0.04340139403939247,
0.03854990378022194,
-0.041330743581056595,
-0.004287888295948505,
0.012181883677840233,
0.030946118757128716,
-0.011664259247481823,
-0.015409941785037518,
0.012587425298988819,
0.0018494020914658904,
0.04447261989116669,
-0.031907327473163605,
-0.06162967532873154,
-0.0369606576859951,
0.009215543046593666,
0.024730222299695015,
0.007532787509262562,
-0.02571495808660984,
-0.030264485627412796,
0.05373283103108406,
0.0201790202409029,
-0.03062201291322708,
0.012956301681697369,
0.028283491730690002,
0.08307502418756485,
0.006032715085893869,
-0.002178611932322383,
-0.010276401415467262,
-0.03306537866592407,
0.043360788375139236,
-0.04930368810892105,
-0.004602251574397087,
-0.040874551981687546,
-0.04857045039534569,
-0.030130920931696892,
-0.0402996726334095,
-0.01923547498881817,
0.052965085953474045,
-0.0474771149456501,
-0.03144799917936325,
-0.007781993597745895,
0.01144817192107439,
-0.014138287864625454,
0.02364000305533409,
0.026138827204704285,
-0.07339226454496384,
0.03243829682469368,
0.028898457065224648,
-0.05688764154911041,
0.02346213534474373,
-0.02240990661084652,
-0.029178444296121597,
-0.06869513541460037,
-0.027878284454345703,
0.00440096203237772,
-0.030578384175896645,
-0.02254985086619854,
-0.05233882740139961,
0.020090479403734207,
-0.008570875972509384,
0.008235814049839973,
0.010408907197415829,
-0.002704314887523651,
-0.0034079409670084715,
-0.02003980055451393,
0.04691556468605995,
-0.025841770693659782,
0.011018977500498295,
-0.012438860721886158,
-0.016043638810515404,
0.008334134705364704,
-0.03647184744477272,
-0.011945437639951706,
0.05250275880098343,
-0.024337518960237503,
-0.02627496048808098,
-0.029414275661110878,
0.0029347925446927547,
0.0025738035328686237,
0.018415365368127823,
0.005656508728861809,
0.018875690177083015,
-0.053742680698633194,
0.0333719477057457,
0.006571226287633181,
0.06566417217254639,
-0.017869440838694572,
0.015611410140991211,
-0.0024776922073215246,
0.05399646237492561,
0.025917217135429382,
-0.021076343953609467,
-0.06408568471670151,
0.010206975974142551,
0.046991705894470215,
-0.052126672118902206,
-0.028855767101049423,
-0.08793371170759201,
-0.039503276348114014,
0.02838258072733879,
-0.012660245411098003,
0.026477929204702377,
0.0036984060425311327,
0.00564127741381526,
0.015009243972599506,
-0.017491957172751427,
-0.02374153397977352,
-0.004851820413023233,
0.017084674909710884,
-0.03657635301351547,
0.030308062210679054,
-0.05470484122633934,
-0.022445732727646828,
0.06035860627889633,
-0.05033665895462036,
0.0223906971514225,
0.0024891728535294533,
0.007487189024686813,
0.038442615419626236,
-0.03818276897072792,
-0.08301392197608948,
0.008184983395040035,
-0.026874246075749397,
0.004015539772808552,
0.017991933971643448,
-0.0262550450861454,
-0.019574303179979324,
-0.01687856763601303,
-0.05335516110062599,
0.005464037414640188,
0.010829508304595947,
0.03082161396741867,
-0.02646276354789734,
-0.005736481864005327,
-0.023341769352555275,
-0.010088711977005005,
0.011610174551606178,
0.05300615727901459,
-0.0012007404584437609,
0.0286442618817091,
-0.03926192596554756,
0.058286067098379135,
0.0383487306535244,
0.030914371833205223,
0.0032797798048704863,
0.0085224574431777,
0.016241827979683876,
-0.06323149055242538,
0.02335386909544468,
0.011524480767548084,
0.011352403089404106,
-0.07512465864419937,
0.07235103100538254,
0.04224151745438576,
-0.04963456466794014,
-0.03241806849837303,
0.025818195194005966,
-0.052257973700761795,
0.049825068563222885,
-0.01154632493853569,
-0.02079133316874504,
0.010744338855147362,
0.06902984529733658,
-0.0005305052036419511,
0.032502468675374985,
0.06017850711941719,
-0.0018994895508512855,
0.004890511278063059,
0.0149484071880579,
0.0595715306699276,
0.039950016885995865,
0.04263836145401001,
-0.023261183872818947,
0.06614678353071213,
-0.031720031052827835,
-0.06839285790920258,
0.04011401906609535,
0.015582661144435406,
-0.03380370885133743,
-0.08219768851995468,
0.02213805355131626,
0.09430569410324097,
0.007286555133759975,
0.05600728094577789,
-0.053998254239559174,
-0.012029334902763367,
0.030163001269102097,
0.0037132552824914455,
-0.016495291143655777,
-0.011334909126162529,
0.0456010177731514,
0.02770387753844261,
-0.057164136320352554,
0.009941422380506992,
0.0027729140128940344,
-0.011834242381155491,
0.007891022600233555,
0.025884920731186867,
0.018052944913506508,
0.04281628131866455,
0.03125762194395065,
0.051683101803064346,
0.08622699230909348,
-0.01835242286324501,
-0.04777602478861809,
-0.002678153570741415,
0.01293223537504673,
0.01404851209372282,
0.042020417749881744,
0.011796059086918831,
-0.006927118636667728,
0.0029582048300653696,
-0.02566571719944477,
0.017696205526590347,
0.03909134119749069,
0.021035145968198776,
0.007888443768024445,
-0.051263801753520966,
0.0013081860961392522,
-0.0003118458844255656,
0.02052903175354004,
-0.047950416803359985,
-0.06396796554327011,
-0.05425591394305229,
-0.06013744696974754,
-0.0576622448861599,
-0.0333147868514061,
0.024110322818160057,
0.015477959997951984,
-0.011547684669494629,
-0.02210565283894539,
-0.007473333273082972,
0.006140921730548143,
0.055537205189466476,
-0.07063616812229156,
-0.03009084425866604,
0.03363155201077461,
0.01858283393085003,
-0.02955218404531479,
0.0177293848246336,
0.01737203262746334,
-0.02856246940791607,
0.0005754267913289368,
0.07817202806472778,
0.03263571113348007,
0.036423198878765106,
-0.005018933210521936,
-0.0022860614117234945,
-0.07444287091493607,
0.025760188698768616,
0.026172056794166565,
-0.04233836382627487,
-0.0896308645606041,
0.06941930949687958,
-0.00576699199154973,
0.04746469110250473,
0.04369186609983444,
0.013559744693338871,
-0.010547159239649773,
-0.04174678027629852,
0.03319300338625908,
-0.02177049033343792,
0.021088987588882446,
0.022708579897880554,
-0.013868754729628563,
0.08173243701457977,
0.04336041584610939,
-0.016413258388638496,
-0.027928082272410393,
0.043576598167419434,
-0.019859561696648598,
0.007905849255621433,
-0.008247914724051952,
-0.03235863894224167,
-0.03565575182437897,
-0.10403581708669662,
-0.04334299638867378,
0.02826230600476265,
0.001627312507480383,
-0.023544183000922203,
0.00997148547321558,
-0.022107522934675217,
-0.012717720121145248,
-0.013085340149700642,
-0.008019541390240192,
-0.007987616583704948,
-0.030225763097405434,
0.006375796627253294,
-0.08467027544975281,
0.020443707704544067,
-0.03164440765976906,
-0.0027440544217824936,
-0.019192060455679893,
-0.027647579088807106,
-0.000049581438361201435,
0.005425145849585533,
0.023755518719553947,
0.020314594730734825,
0.017796073108911514,
-0.013277886435389519
] |
312 |
Solving New Tasks by Adapting Internet Video Knowledge
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=p01BR4njlY
|
[
"Calvin Luo",
"Zilai Zeng",
"Yilun Du",
"Chen Sun"
] |
Poster
|
Video generative models demonstrate great promise in robotics by serving as visual planners or as policy supervisors. When pretrained on internet-scale data, such video models intimately understand alignment with natural language, and can thus facilitate generalization to novel downstream behavior through text-conditioning. However, they may not be sensitive to the specificities of the particular environment the agent inhabits. On the other hand, training video models on in-domain examples of robotic behavior naturally encodes environment-specific intricacies, but the scale of available demonstrations may not be sufficient to support generalization to unseen tasks via natural language specification. In this work, we investigate different adaptation techniques that integrate in-domain information with large-scale pretrained video models, and explore the extent to which they enable novel text-conditioned generalization for robotic tasks, while also considering their independent data and resource considerations. We successfully demonstrate across robotic environments that adapting powerful video models with small scales of example data can successfully facilitate generalization to novel behaviors. In particular, we present a novel adaptation strategy, termed *Inverse Probabilistic Adaptation*, that not only consistently achieves strong generalization performance across robotic tasks and settings, but also exhibits robustness to the quality of adaptation data, successfully solving novel tasks even when only suboptimal in-domain demonstrations are available.
|
Text-Conditioned Generalization, Video Diffusion, Adaptation, Planning, Policy Learning
|
We compare techniques for adapting large-scale video generative models to in-domain robotic data, and demonstrate that it facilitates text-conditioned generalization to novel tasks.
| 13,550 | null |
[
0.015132385306060314,
-0.010052877478301525,
-0.0008758225594647229,
0.05734148621559143,
0.05360656604170799,
0.010348053649067879,
0.023995546624064445,
0.009930606931447983,
-0.03238408640027046,
-0.018223507329821587,
-0.057640980929136276,
0.018290847539901733,
-0.08881237357854843,
-0.020612802356481552,
-0.03724023327231407,
0.053474463522434235,
0.015720577910542488,
0.004378657788038254,
0.004198147915303707,
0.00842825137078762,
-0.018834393471479416,
-0.033953823149204254,
0.049833714962005615,
0.008864750154316425,
0.035114407539367676,
0.0036592772230505943,
0.029688134789466858,
0.02539694309234619,
-0.02674647606909275,
-0.019999897107481956,
0.016713030636310577,
-0.04055149108171463,
0.01649947091937065,
-0.02893844060599804,
0.019544675946235657,
-0.018433650955557823,
-0.04469544067978859,
-0.020707787945866585,
0.006112891715019941,
0.015758855268359184,
-0.03289806470274925,
0.02874615788459778,
-0.04644642025232315,
-0.004947702866047621,
-0.03990912809967995,
0.016640804708003998,
-0.07212313264608383,
0.03545084595680237,
0.03345590457320213,
-0.019724169746041298,
-0.09425028413534164,
0.07128625363111496,
0.028497343882918358,
-0.023388979956507683,
-0.020208308473229408,
0.05571065470576286,
0.0800190344452858,
-0.08534559607505798,
0.007583429105579853,
-0.04096299037337303,
-0.033874187618494034,
0.04681861028075218,
0.015887059271335602,
0.026326633989810944,
-0.010692043229937553,
-0.009203118272125721,
0.01445144135504961,
0.05393829569220543,
-0.03599025309085846,
-0.020936809480190277,
-0.04640095308423042,
-0.02640649303793907,
0.021101798862218857,
0.02788369730114937,
0.012714632786810398,
-0.020565636456012726,
0.035463448613882065,
0.019831281155347824,
0.049420151859521866,
-0.029193567112088203,
0.020705167204141617,
0.03977333381772041,
0.033952102065086365,
0.034783054143190384,
0.034144774079322815,
0.035573553293943405,
-0.056186020374298096,
-0.035508446395397186,
-0.08524440973997116,
0.004549115430563688,
-0.03739098459482193,
-0.05154222249984741,
-0.019075952470302582,
0.047787927091121674,
0.025753159075975418,
-0.0032362311612814665,
0.011236227117478848,
-0.0008810243452899158,
0.00795922614634037,
-0.012621713802218437,
-0.036538854241371155,
0.0001556419301778078,
0.006266333628445864,
-0.014883344061672688,
-0.09361778944730759,
-0.027239982038736343,
0.00994596816599369,
-0.03145481273531914,
-0.025764038786292076,
0.006797557696700096,
-0.04047021269798279,
0.005562142468988895,
0.016224822029471397,
-0.035213958472013474,
-0.059321995824575424,
0.040428321808576584,
0.0004229152691550553,
0.04851644113659859,
-0.023342793807387352,
0.019752660766243935,
0.031243400648236275,
0.014540616422891617,
-0.03726094588637352,
0.07794800400733948,
-0.02734317258000374,
0.005064968951046467,
0.0063563017174601555,
0.018889952450990677,
-0.04521467909216881,
-0.02771935611963272,
0.029772868379950523,
0.016400214284658432,
-0.0038368315435945988,
0.027068765833973885,
-0.008642376400530338,
-0.01116347499191761,
0.018457917496562004,
-0.025301942601799965,
0.01625942625105381,
0.02290692739188671,
-0.018408114090561867,
-0.01465448085218668,
0.07538535445928574,
-0.021928947418928146,
0.09365347772836685,
-0.01628730818629265,
-0.005427751690149307,
-0.02598787099123001,
-0.036498699337244034,
-0.001263511017896235,
0.003027244471013546,
-0.01828073337674141,
0.017610928043723106,
-0.07228730618953705,
0.013976756483316422,
0.06224541738629341,
0.032560646533966064,
0.038850102573633194,
0.022110197693109512,
-0.018165117129683495,
-0.014072990976274014,
-0.011496199294924736,
-0.055148448795080185,
-0.010256491601467133,
-0.007246444933116436,
-0.07948462665081024,
0.015919920057058334,
0.02579612471163273,
-0.015469290316104889,
-0.004904998932033777,
-0.04440182074904442,
-0.022625058889389038,
0.03979698568582535,
-0.0052114808931946754,
-0.044329483062028885,
-0.004919285885989666,
0.029749300330877304,
-0.0016567728016525507,
0.03975937142968178,
0.007344591896981001,
-0.07418420910835266,
0.017065586522221565,
0.009885678999125957,
-0.019966721534729004,
0.011451558209955692,
-0.04910421371459961,
0.05606699734926224,
-0.04421506077051163,
-0.007820281200110912,
0.029041284695267677,
-0.05007336661219597,
-0.02228311263024807,
0.027915865182876587,
-0.0206817127764225,
0.058102529495954514,
0.0036653282586485147,
-0.017774099484086037,
0.04507363587617874,
0.03517545014619827,
0.05043424665927887,
0.027699926868081093,
-0.0443882942199707,
0.06498782336711884,
0.006734163500368595,
-0.007429712451994419,
-0.00012511028035078198,
0.03761228173971176,
-0.03865375742316246,
-0.02388817071914673,
0.009487136267125607,
0.014016914181411266,
0.018819138407707214,
0.015127467922866344,
0.013026316650211811,
0.003873895388096571,
0.03847291320562363,
-0.010706944391131401,
0.003234654199331999,
0.016688724979758263,
-0.03336470574140549,
0.020793847739696503,
0.01702648401260376,
-0.011756009422242641,
-0.011718579567968845,
-0.027040094137191772,
0.08036340773105621,
0.041829630732536316,
-0.038289230316877365,
-0.03399783372879028,
0.03459702804684639,
-0.011226783506572247,
0.025570744648575783,
0.00046507478691637516,
-0.0024652136489748955,
0.026998933404684067,
-0.008350526914000511,
0.02246314473450184,
-0.03002670779824257,
0.03142789378762245,
-0.057364825159311295,
-0.032786913216114044,
0.07446293532848358,
0.008927748538553715,
0.054532863199710846,
-0.006140642799437046,
0.02223404496908188,
0.0563652478158474,
-0.003841695375740528,
0.01488665770739317,
-0.017742054536938667,
-0.03803990036249161,
0.0007448826218023896,
0.016109593212604523,
0.008460957556962967,
0.001196225406602025,
-0.039689768105745316,
-0.0275384783744812,
-0.04863631725311279,
0.08881591260433197,
0.03940662741661072,
0.027043160051107407,
0.041403040289878845,
-0.000279386033071205,
-0.014699106104671955,
-0.024203520268201828,
-0.09200753271579742,
-0.0312940888106823,
-0.019017748534679413,
0.008080109022557735,
0.017552025616168976,
0.029736192896962166,
0.00735430745407939,
0.0461842305958271,
-0.019624166190624237,
-0.022954750806093216,
0.005159439984709024,
0.021674102172255516,
-0.009491370059549809,
-0.03600792959332466,
-0.014679498970508575,
0.009282545186579227,
0.049046557396650314,
-0.011455049738287926,
-0.014960283413529396,
-0.017917975783348083,
-0.052240580320358276,
-0.04654260352253914,
-0.05449056252837181,
-0.02176167257130146,
0.014507172629237175,
0.046259183436632156,
0.006558403838425875,
-0.01502166222780943,
0.012867921032011509,
0.015793098136782646,
0.06839166581630707,
0.0466696098446846,
-0.01844167709350586,
-0.001479521975852549,
0.025251226499676704,
-0.026744162663817406,
0.018259920179843903,
-0.002441649790853262,
0.030460014939308167,
-0.019177932292222977,
-0.0024958073627203703,
0.017138609662652016,
0.009156792424619198,
-0.2724243998527527,
-0.031784869730472565,
0.025925645604729652,
0.028019966557621956,
0.05656854063272476,
-0.02079080417752266,
0.0718228816986084,
-0.03688479959964752,
-0.03349394351243973,
0.027270173653960228,
0.019841806963086128,
0.03974926844239235,
0.01195479929447174,
0.06105339154601097,
0.032073527574539185,
0.0033462303690612316,
-0.0008570774225518107,
-0.00602763332426548,
-0.0015772865153849125,
0.022390592843294144,
-0.02857903763651848,
-0.06582517921924591,
-0.040219664573669434,
0.04629652202129364,
-0.006698885932564735,
0.037941720336675644,
-0.08224029093980789,
-0.011859253980219364,
-0.008823449723422527,
-0.0012397271348163486,
0.003871302120387554,
-0.011265999637544155,
-0.01436681766062975,
0.04942774027585983,
0.015537846833467484,
0.03649204969406128,
0.06556321680545807,
-0.02030249685049057,
0.0359405055642128,
0.03700367361307144,
0.01168314553797245,
-0.010756516829133034,
-0.05161929503083229,
0.030260814353823662,
0.06311318278312683,
0.010318498127162457,
-0.04896805062890053,
-0.03615868464112282,
-0.011147665791213512,
0.030689282342791557,
0.02237505465745926,
0.0020359281916171312,
0.013864059001207352,
0.03640255704522133,
0.03101550042629242,
-0.018375296145677567,
0.054850175976753235,
-0.031063174828886986,
0.011205115355551243,
-0.012873354367911816,
0.03345019370317459,
-0.04693790152668953,
-0.04379972070455551,
-0.053979985415935516,
0.015714377164840698,
-0.02703707292675972,
-0.04354296997189522,
-0.06539697200059891,
0.040543872863054276,
0.008431531488895416,
-0.03805805370211601,
0.021899795159697533,
-0.016693666577339172,
-0.10836063325405121,
0.02472027949988842,
0.0029339224565774202,
-0.022766148671507835,
-0.028465205803513527,
0.0012385343434289098,
0.0301936287432909,
-0.03264867141842842,
-0.052089810371398926,
-0.009843088686466217,
0.017849477007985115,
0.038889382034540176,
-0.023380422964692116,
0.02493448555469513,
-0.08993851393461227,
-0.014692392200231552,
-0.02873893268406391,
0.03599037975072861,
-0.015100196935236454,
0.026061691343784332,
0.002735714428126812,
0.0652378723025322,
0.04385295882821083,
0.031730979681015015,
0.07071659713983536,
0.03757669776678085,
-0.0068522244691848755,
0.0204396303743124,
-0.11000029742717743,
-0.015319013968110085,
-0.028720702975988388,
0.012595766223967075,
0.009066983126103878,
-0.05027913674712181,
0.021574199199676514,
0.03597859665751457,
-0.0029518944211304188,
-0.02458571083843708,
-0.027241690084338188,
0.0009765223367139697,
0.009211594238877296,
-0.03478803485631943,
0.009541296400129795,
0.007893227972090244,
0.0066217766143381596,
0.048808079212903976,
-0.0105819720774889,
-0.022771591320633888,
0.027693310752511024,
-0.011635002680122852,
0.027248455211520195,
-0.010818775743246078,
-0.044910501688718796,
0.015376806259155273,
-0.002798447385430336,
-0.0008364401292055845,
-0.018193427473306656,
0.061219472438097,
0.04032295569777489,
-0.012095654383301735,
0.01942691020667553,
0.05098525434732437,
-0.005888953804969788,
0.009156821295619011,
-0.0061386991292238235,
0.020697755739092827,
-0.04333069548010826,
-0.0137749332934618,
-0.003864441066980362,
0.005184992682188749,
-0.0033900996204465628,
0.024231484159827232,
0.009102482348680496,
0.05680154636502266,
0.02603239193558693,
-0.01131654717028141,
-0.0047440845519304276,
0.053313858807086945,
-0.05807795748114586,
-0.013710868544876575,
-0.022575801238417625,
0.02286810427904129,
-0.03441549092531204,
0.019853217527270317,
-0.037082064896821976,
0.03729000315070152,
-0.055970191955566406,
0.045916374772787094,
0.0036998738069087267,
-0.020208919420838356,
-0.012090913951396942,
0.042435422539711,
0.03454430401325226,
-0.020104892551898956,
-0.015465945936739445,
0.023862332105636597,
0.0062258439138531685,
0.01146109402179718,
-0.04187210649251938,
-0.05034128203988075,
-0.03952068090438843,
-0.02027050219476223,
-0.016774287447333336,
0.002881463151425123,
-0.017861736938357353,
-0.02452588826417923,
0.044299766421318054,
0.05906600132584572,
-0.016920479014515877,
0.016816090792417526,
-0.010496983304619789,
0.06340423971414566,
0.00813686940819025,
0.009578341618180275,
-0.004413035698235035,
-0.023104336112737656,
-0.0009359857649542391,
-0.008299409411847591,
0.0033784371335059404,
-0.01517502497881651,
-0.05033408850431442,
-0.034723736345767975,
-0.028744347393512726,
0.022131389006972313,
0.0015238095074892044,
-0.030734840780496597,
-0.010944423265755177,
-0.014576839283108711,
0.04121006280183792,
-0.03959169611334801,
0.006009283941239119,
0.0223586093634367,
-0.07955624163150787,
-0.002549184951931238,
0.045440204441547394,
0.011799066327512264,
0.013576647266745567,
-0.04673381522297859,
-0.029754705727100372,
-0.04899543896317482,
-0.04999556764960289,
0.00846807286143303,
-0.02920564077794552,
-0.024237172678112984,
-0.021175015717744827,
-0.009299143217504025,
-0.01377938874065876,
0.02372618019580841,
0.0002451871696393937,
-0.004508015234023333,
-0.01125601027160883,
-0.003610062412917614,
0.014745068736374378,
-0.02403259091079235,
-0.024284828454256058,
0.024411257356405258,
-0.05223725363612175,
0.017528275027871132,
-0.03544174134731293,
0.01569518633186817,
0.03920634090900421,
0.0013396829599514604,
-0.015314195305109024,
-0.04683520644903183,
0.05848199129104614,
0.014511367306113243,
-0.03614190220832825,
0.01841627061367035,
-0.003014011075720191,
-0.03532339632511139,
0.03040320612490177,
0.021842962130904198,
0.015744414180517197,
-0.0061944033950567245,
0.005636385641992092,
0.027827855199575424,
-0.006621086969971657,
0.04281791299581528,
-0.012742115184664726,
-0.024958599358797073,
0.0011657611466944218,
0.05092005804181099,
-0.04840467497706413,
-0.018108636140823364,
-0.07293134927749634,
-0.025193922221660614,
0.042561125010252,
-0.007757773157209158,
0.01873900182545185,
-0.0683351531624794,
0.018325386568903923,
0.006051163654774427,
0.04707498103380203,
0.005811145529150963,
-0.03009972907602787,
0.029956558719277382,
-0.06929483264684677,
0.005398206878453493,
-0.050694577395915985,
-0.03456395864486694,
0.04511052370071411,
-0.01218930259346962,
-0.01373489759862423,
0.01417749933898449,
-0.021115116775035858,
0.05519208312034607,
-0.0415431447327137,
-0.052408959716558456,
0.04269533231854439,
-0.039570730179548264,
-0.023296846076846123,
0.014680322259664536,
-0.04968016594648361,
-0.0009188842959702015,
-0.03152714669704437,
-0.059678997844457626,
0.007540982216596603,
-0.0025685331784188747,
0.06256535649299622,
0.00794672966003418,
-0.0007366530480794609,
-0.032488513737916946,
0.018270062282681465,
0.025581715628504753,
0.036101434379816055,
0.04230611026287079,
0.019275274127721786,
-0.021966127678751945,
0.07044477015733719,
0.022459734231233597,
0.013706858269870281,
0.0093395309522748,
0.007583937142044306,
-0.008552280254662037,
-0.05325435474514961,
0.056138716638088226,
-0.011588450521230698,
-0.038666851818561554,
-0.058236997574567795,
0.06068768724799156,
0.02504471316933632,
-0.05646738409996033,
-0.0019045951776206493,
0.03999438136816025,
-0.06563229113817215,
-0.017348838970065117,
0.004385870415717363,
0.005556460004299879,
-0.003696383675560355,
0.052975162863731384,
0.013959922827780247,
0.06745558977127075,
0.05335124582052231,
0.05928787961602211,
-0.0032358309254050255,
-0.008237861096858978,
0.05187400430440903,
0.060694996267557144,
0.05570344626903534,
-0.001218263292685151,
0.05883372202515602,
-0.03395051881670952,
-0.03046133555471897,
0.04537748917937279,
0.01812264695763588,
-0.0074048126116395,
-0.05339517071843147,
0.008269731886684895,
0.09340948611497879,
0.007259597070515156,
0.06285104155540466,
-0.03931467980146408,
-0.04976823180913925,
0.03476155921816826,
-0.007257768884301186,
-0.0030250102281570435,
0.024321841076016426,
0.0519830584526062,
0.009148012846708298,
-0.011691414751112461,
-0.0167876947671175,
-0.009475382044911385,
-0.051443345844745636,
0.0272445697337389,
-0.006175858899950981,
-0.013000693172216415,
0.01305390615016222,
-0.0011979338014498353,
0.017867855727672577,
0.11980976909399033,
-0.05323745682835579,
0.00006153160938993096,
0.016899405047297478,
0.008640703745186329,
-0.01889151707291603,
0.053224753588438034,
0.0011533071519806981,
0.0070803966373205185,
-0.01832941360771656,
-0.05489476025104523,
0.029265940189361572,
0.04995780438184738,
0.01450214721262455,
0.024621523916721344,
-0.04439481347799301,
-0.03894800320267677,
0.020817624405026436,
0.02584485523402691,
-0.01655486784875393,
-0.04648492857813835,
-0.040546964854002,
-0.050045620650053024,
-0.03495732694864273,
-0.027084123343229294,
0.05886638164520264,
-0.008559242822229862,
-0.052552103996276855,
-0.011802456341683865,
-0.035044074058532715,
0.018645018339157104,
0.036673326045274734,
-0.0696839988231659,
0.004621603526175022,
0.027396738529205322,
-0.00576786370947957,
-0.0011923125712201,
0.04262666404247284,
0.01886945590376854,
-0.0056765698827803135,
-0.00042032572673633695,
0.01659468561410904,
0.011462459340691566,
-0.005809375550597906,
-0.027047697454690933,
-0.01893778331577778,
-0.08550377190113068,
-0.000034214896004414186,
0.01960184797644615,
-0.041077110916376114,
-0.07602157443761826,
0.005337923299521208,
-0.02888048253953457,
0.045434340834617615,
0.07450665533542633,
0.011141838505864143,
0.013785050250589848,
-0.029829811304807663,
0.02015474997460842,
-0.006861081812530756,
0.004226085264235735,
0.05563339963555336,
-0.035253867506980896,
0.05595630779862404,
0.05436450242996216,
-0.020989349111914635,
-0.03324597701430321,
0.021875737234950066,
0.004423513077199459,
0.02712998166680336,
-0.01076898630708456,
-0.04721451550722122,
-0.010727290995419025,
-0.11421633511781693,
-0.03948089852929115,
0.052774783223867416,
0.003051825100556016,
-0.04163598641753197,
-0.022231286391615868,
-0.02630392462015152,
0.010944034904241562,
-0.01641446352005005,
-0.03691078722476959,
0.00341745070181787,
-0.03977241739630699,
-0.030664438381791115,
-0.03419367969036102,
0.0041941069066524506,
-0.04395168274641037,
-0.008716524578630924,
-0.03985462710261345,
-0.03308294340968132,
0.006881467532366514,
-0.03347495570778847,
0.019179781898856163,
-0.01429992076009512,
0.03473231568932533,
0.003260113764554262
] |
313 |
SoftMatcha: A Soft and Fast Pattern Matcher for Billion-Scale Corpus Searches
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Q6PAnqYVpo
|
[
"Hiroyuki Deguchi",
"Go Kamoda",
"Yusuke Matsushita",
"Chihiro Taguchi",
"Kohei Suenaga",
"Masaki Waga",
"Sho Yokoi"
] |
Poster
|
Researchers and practitioners in natural language processing and computational linguistics frequently observe and analyze the real language usage in large-scale corpora.
For that purpose, they often employ off-the-shelf pattern-matching tools, such as grep, and keyword-in-context concordancers, which is widely used in corpus linguistics for gathering examples.
Nonetheless, these existing techniques rely on surface-level string matching, and thus they suffer from the major limitation of not being able to handle orthographic variations and paraphrasing---notable and common phenomena in any natural language.
In addition, existing continuous approaches such as dense vector search tend to be overly coarse, often retrieving texts that are unrelated but share similar topics.
Given these challenges, we propose a novel algorithm that achieves soft (or semantic) yet efficient pattern matching by relaxing a surface-level matching with word embeddings.
Our algorithm is highly scalable with respect to the size of the corpus text utilizing inverted indexes.
We have prepared an efficient implementation, and we provide an accessible web tool.
Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed method
(i) can execute searches on billion-scale corpora in less than a second, which is comparable in speed to surface-level string matching and dense vector search;
(ii) can extract harmful instances that semantically match queries from a large set of English and Japanese Wikipedia articles;
and (iii) can be effectively applied to corpus-linguistic analyses of Latin, a language with highly diverse inflections.
|
natural language processing, full-text search, word embeddings, inverted index, pattern match
|
Achieving soft yet efficient full-text search, we introduce a novel method that extends inverted indexes with word embeddings to enable sub-second searches of billion-scale corpora without GPUs.
| 13,545 |
2503.03703
|
[
-0.0420491024851799,
-0.035176195204257965,
-0.012009119614958763,
0.01944560557603836,
0.02738337032496929,
0.04491397738456726,
0.016588173806667328,
0.05373501405119896,
-0.021942894905805588,
-0.01928088814020157,
-0.034521449357271194,
0.027036763727664948,
-0.0768933966755867,
-0.017359165474772453,
0.0006841857102699578,
0.052131909877061844,
0.014578585512936115,
-0.020673109218478203,
0.010719360783696175,
-0.022706499323248863,
-0.017654376104474068,
0.006328939460217953,
0.010124268010258675,
0.017276061698794365,
0.035234563052654266,
0.02381882071495056,
0.01199999451637268,
0.014500592835247517,
-0.050262369215488434,
0.024226609617471695,
0.04541769251227379,
0.017406880855560303,
-0.007890623062849045,
-0.017676131799817085,
-0.001201165490783751,
-0.01750670000910759,
-0.03442757949233055,
0.01107058022171259,
0.00725953932851553,
0.0033056451939046383,
-0.018299095332622528,
0.013391961343586445,
-0.03634544089436531,
0.014088800176978111,
-0.05066906660795212,
0.0005383803509175777,
-0.13806675374507904,
0.019586721435189247,
-0.026956265792250633,
-0.019306892529129982,
-0.11038573086261749,
0.025952033698558807,
-0.012654499150812626,
-0.006442048586905003,
-0.005865001585334539,
0.04988400638103485,
0.02019812911748886,
-0.09240106493234634,
0.011614203453063965,
-0.042136967182159424,
-0.03542988374829292,
0.012884539552032948,
0.018923727795481682,
0.010091947391629219,
0.005909744184464216,
-0.010393939912319183,
-0.03238030523061752,
0.03958351910114288,
-0.07439998537302017,
-0.05027589946985245,
0.0063076503574848175,
0.034554410725831985,
-0.00870758667588234,
0.021368617191910744,
0.012262105010449886,
-0.03660627081990242,
-0.014694198034703732,
0.039596714079380035,
0.069338358938694,
0.010548243299126625,
0.006335861049592495,
0.001764575019478798,
0.012947676703333855,
0.029956335201859474,
0.020695222541689873,
-0.0016217919765040278,
-0.04397016763687134,
-0.002518332563340664,
-0.07880190759897232,
0.028684847056865692,
0.021494369953870773,
-0.047301072627305984,
0.031205160543322563,
0.024056866765022278,
0.014272982254624367,
0.05506158620119095,
0.024621490389108658,
0.03246261551976204,
-0.01701771840453148,
0.01535238977521658,
-0.05775856226682663,
-0.033425502479076385,
0.04835350811481476,
0.033227745443582535,
-0.10458116233348846,
-0.03846807777881622,
-0.0190677922219038,
0.022604018449783325,
0.017460191622376442,
0.0037581108044832945,
0.00876937247812748,
-0.013692457228899002,
0.027745768427848816,
0.004406788852065802,
-0.06886695325374603,
0.02783319540321827,
0.01617009937763214,
0.03162806108593941,
0.00578281981870532,
0.021423349156975746,
0.043862782418727875,
0.02995963953435421,
0.027885524556040764,
0.05983347073197365,
-0.0027798458468168974,
0.020060155540704727,
0.015849540010094643,
0.029987355694174767,
-0.03059293143451214,
-0.03327872231602669,
-0.008491910062730312,
0.04715445637702942,
0.019973786547780037,
0.024213392287492752,
-0.00024736393243074417,
0.011259570717811584,
0.02397982031106949,
0.01460996363312006,
0.06933610886335373,
-0.004320039879530668,
-0.005826773587614298,
-0.03899165987968445,
0.024269426241517067,
-0.03799891471862793,
0.07193154096603394,
-0.014722730964422226,
-0.037516847252845764,
-0.047099415212869644,
-0.02856283076107502,
-0.01884569600224495,
0.009798732586205006,
-0.008001341484487057,
0.039454687386751175,
-0.0715685486793518,
0.0023833385203033686,
0.09329026192426682,
-0.0038258107379078865,
0.018787100911140442,
0.019972795620560646,
0.009670929051935673,
0.013498871587216854,
0.01888432167470455,
-0.09330443292856216,
-0.0008156457333825529,
-0.01985912211239338,
-0.05929822102189064,
0.016136178746819496,
0.03770371899008751,
-0.049807485193014145,
0.04828557372093201,
-0.024022996425628662,
-0.051375631242990494,
0.07104666531085968,
-0.031005432829260826,
-0.013286513276398182,
-0.02222232148051262,
0.04850437492132187,
0.03272263705730438,
0.04373253509402275,
0.023846212774515152,
-0.07110320031642914,
0.02210102416574955,
-0.009239464066922665,
0.0065865349024534225,
0.004936566110700369,
-0.020466379821300507,
0.08898703753948212,
-0.004562423098832369,
0.024349967017769814,
0.03548363968729973,
-0.07869289815425873,
-0.03319815173745155,
0.0009030167711898685,
0.0006597828469239175,
0.04796808585524559,
-0.007176706567406654,
-0.018168244510889053,
0.031477365642786026,
-0.00640326039865613,
0.05508274957537651,
0.03562215715646744,
-0.017224913462996483,
0.0476575642824173,
-0.0006771346088498831,
-0.037936072796583176,
-0.00722922058776021,
0.029326455667614937,
-0.03709357976913452,
-0.03767934441566467,
-0.009578402154147625,
-0.020024992525577545,
0.032740090042352676,
0.013191535137593746,
-0.013589601963758469,
0.006603396497666836,
0.010599513538181782,
0.014578444883227348,
0.01103548426181078,
0.02517605945467949,
-0.07316582649946213,
0.05835799500346184,
-0.001455190242268145,
-0.01152738556265831,
-0.009349933825433254,
-0.0491548590362072,
0.09432920068502426,
0.05794328823685646,
-0.027038946747779846,
-0.0005750380805693567,
0.014961441047489643,
-0.013530775904655457,
0.00008084075670922175,
0.033359844237565994,
-0.04379087686538696,
-0.02677125856280327,
-0.033569809049367905,
-0.0022675259970128536,
-0.04939436912536621,
0.06272812187671661,
-0.030390877276659012,
-0.013439247384667397,
0.058188751339912415,
-0.014404740184545517,
0.03898732736706734,
-0.0005234832060523331,
-0.0008035723003558815,
0.030400415882468224,
-0.03775706887245178,
-0.004185131285339594,
-0.010550936684012413,
-0.01835247315466404,
-0.0040134247392416,
-0.03371945396065712,
-0.037382740527391434,
0.022746438160538673,
-0.027432797476649284,
-0.03143350034952164,
-0.013658015988767147,
0.0737060010433197,
0.048883143812417984,
0.000426711980253458,
-0.003371806349605322,
0.0064453543163836,
-0.0271848663687706,
0.012255336157977581,
-0.0851219967007637,
-0.004388554487377405,
-0.007670602761209011,
0.019303912296891212,
-0.01211033295840025,
0.017767222598195076,
0.023101797327399254,
0.004989131353795528,
-0.018702035769820213,
0.01632850058376789,
-0.0068257092498242855,
0.04390141740441322,
-0.0028148526325821877,
-0.061112966388463974,
-0.03579401969909668,
-0.024047276005148888,
0.05941592901945114,
-0.025223562493920326,
-0.026595085859298706,
-0.032536379992961884,
-0.06919074803590775,
-0.02723200060427189,
-0.01980336755514145,
0.016583245247602463,
0.017893755808472633,
0.014425689354538918,
0.025999821722507477,
-0.04481419175863266,
0.0037313830107450485,
0.0384061299264431,
0.05090692266821861,
0.049488138407468796,
0.016520626842975616,
-0.03178606554865837,
0.023871006444096565,
-0.014331852085888386,
0.015893220901489258,
0.007616352755576372,
0.03580573573708534,
0.011680110357701778,
0.009477692656219006,
-0.0219657514244318,
0.008826467208564281,
-0.24533091485500336,
-0.012285077013075352,
-0.006108979694545269,
-0.004974285140633583,
0.04114999994635582,
0.0038636750541627407,
0.032948072999715805,
-0.01650809682905674,
-0.012221713550388813,
-0.02019314654171467,
0.0023988669272512197,
0.059506870806217194,
0.018827693536877632,
0.05999443680047989,
0.02501012571156025,
0.03605790436267853,
-0.0038728059735149145,
-0.034893400967121124,
0.008479094132781029,
0.0377332903444767,
0.012216390110552311,
-0.05676782876253128,
0.018321214243769646,
0.06609881669282913,
0.021904487162828445,
0.06775171309709549,
-0.08650549501180649,
-0.02985697239637375,
-0.019905265420675278,
-0.014996905811131,
0.007944137789309025,
-0.011743506416678429,
-0.0002720833581406623,
0.02569965086877346,
-0.014056788757443428,
0.014953810721635818,
0.063836969435215,
-0.0004219590628053993,
0.023824535310268402,
0.039646413177251816,
-0.000005992980277369497,
-0.019039401784539223,
-0.05348920077085495,
-0.026452286168932915,
0.06286638975143433,
-0.01002179179340601,
-0.060735948383808136,
-0.00842492375522852,
-0.0006691745365969837,
0.018955236300826073,
-0.014565601013600826,
-0.03571208938956261,
-0.02974744327366352,
0.012674462050199509,
0.020357610657811165,
-0.03491482511162758,
0.001158511615358293,
-0.015044261701405048,
-0.04003729298710823,
-0.02386518567800522,
0.0268067866563797,
-0.03492962568998337,
-0.019671831279993057,
-0.061377912759780884,
-0.018642200157046318,
-0.04106566682457924,
-0.0857200175523758,
-0.06193339452147484,
0.05227144807577133,
0.05008535087108612,
-0.015040643513202667,
0.04034597426652908,
0.0010415632277727127,
-0.0872875303030014,
-0.04575994983315468,
-0.01009372342377901,
-0.007968699559569359,
-0.03251880779862404,
0.019841350615024567,
0.019705088809132576,
-0.050811342895030975,
-0.03536853566765785,
-0.008977835066616535,
0.014345324598252773,
0.039800975471735,
-0.05698107182979584,
-0.0068318345583975315,
-0.03832077234983444,
-0.0029907068237662315,
-0.03415629640221596,
0.042359523475170135,
-0.022437024861574173,
-0.031646642833948135,
0.00831124559044838,
0.060034800320863724,
0.01680361106991768,
0.01934385672211647,
0.05088270828127861,
0.04080306366086006,
-0.0008168131462298334,
0.027877938002347946,
-0.09227826446294785,
-0.021650345996022224,
-0.04409502074122429,
-0.0055778250098228455,
0.007264898158609867,
-0.07232578843832016,
-0.035882461816072464,
0.03452571853995323,
-0.02462352253496647,
-0.01414421945810318,
-0.02676372416317463,
-0.0008093891083262861,
-0.049436431378126144,
-0.007283900398761034,
-0.029251933097839355,
0.02923470176756382,
0.01987393945455551,
0.009929727762937546,
-0.012435090728104115,
0.018909914419054985,
0.016416778787970543,
-0.008273862302303314,
-0.02282688021659851,
-0.008353926241397858,
-0.04364289715886116,
0.0007752319215796888,
-0.03323879465460777,
-0.025016266852617264,
0.007492226082831621,
0.02608112245798111,
0.033715181052684784,
-0.025309858843684196,
-0.007385682314634323,
0.052251603454351425,
-0.010117786936461926,
0.007889109663665295,
-0.0026323008351027966,
0.02134186215698719,
0.014371630735695362,
-0.000764186552260071,
-0.02039813995361328,
0.013361579738557339,
0.05721115693449974,
0.047112997621297836,
0.028895894065499306,
0.026340901851654053,
-0.011328088119626045,
0.011719683185219765,
0.042648617178201675,
0.008132345974445343,
-0.018720731139183044,
-0.0070815798826515675,
-0.012613519094884396,
0.015956027433276176,
-0.01343883853405714,
0.028070058673620224,
0.020725347101688385,
0.012380985543131828,
-0.07011467963457108,
0.04198210686445236,
-0.03587927296757698,
0.016123078763484955,
0.030903013423085213,
0.01894485577940941,
0.029221968725323677,
-0.02740861289203167,
0.04006737098097801,
0.020984208211302757,
0.016074802726507187,
0.0019866193179041147,
0.012669499032199383,
-0.023200493305921555,
0.0028953086584806442,
-0.03772231191396713,
0.0005128697375766933,
0.014984022825956345,
0.014249944128096104,
-0.027169538661837578,
0.05391561985015869,
-0.0014368528500199318,
-0.021837254986166954,
-0.012691202573478222,
0.021886611357331276,
0.07821021974086761,
0.008342064917087555,
0.015470381826162338,
-0.004008180927485228,
-0.0515735000371933,
0.028506264090538025,
-0.027414102107286453,
0.008067534305155277,
0.00045471786870621145,
-0.0360167920589447,
-0.04597100988030434,
-0.06479745358228683,
-0.015180110931396484,
0.009499268606305122,
-0.013375912792980671,
0.005701285321265459,
-0.013098673895001411,
0.007554655894637108,
-0.0471038855612278,
-0.028502585366368294,
-0.004125699400901794,
-0.0986151471734047,
0.003515321295708418,
-0.015263074077665806,
-0.0223799217492342,
0.029479993507266045,
0.0023866472765803337,
-0.04973912611603737,
-0.04207171872258186,
0.00612123915925622,
0.015140370465815067,
-0.007411923259496689,
-0.026778195053339005,
-0.031083794310688972,
0.03340419754385948,
-0.027670785784721375,
-0.014526777900755405,
0.008316663093864918,
-0.004197526257485151,
0.00004265895040589385,
0.03284907713532448,
0.04695148766040802,
-0.033580902963876724,
-0.03112812153995037,
-0.00486073549836874,
-0.012373813427984715,
0.055167123675346375,
-0.05563511699438095,
0.019679665565490723,
0.022487185895442963,
-0.007926379330456257,
0.017042728140950203,
-0.06193845346570015,
-0.02069258876144886,
0.03693966940045357,
0.013241486623883247,
0.019986582919955254,
-0.032407332211732864,
-0.005627427250146866,
0.02629753388464451,
-0.025994619354605675,
0.04099104553461075,
0.012628541328012943,
-0.01816919632256031,
-0.02191980555653572,
0.026163063943386078,
0.0179748497903347,
0.038300007581710815,
-0.05221594125032425,
-0.030022870749235153,
0.04379875585436821,
-0.021238140761852264,
-0.037574682384729385,
-0.06521563231945038,
-0.06185057386755943,
0.008602919988334179,
0.0031997663900256157,
0.037667449563741684,
-0.03467266261577606,
0.03760024160146713,
0.015478522516787052,
0.05510539188981056,
0.01129957940429449,
0.0007391315302811563,
0.034044526517391205,
-0.05721278488636017,
-0.03212658688426018,
-0.07295354455709457,
-0.034019164741039276,
0.07401556521654129,
-0.02933402732014656,
-0.002059898106381297,
-0.013404990546405315,
-0.023492418229579926,
0.009441506117582321,
0.013774506747722626,
-0.05418574437499046,
0.030785460025072098,
-0.014300298877060413,
0.010336660780012608,
0.016746152192354202,
-0.04167889803647995,
0.004040187690407038,
-0.0020899279043078423,
-0.021853305399417877,
-0.012587971054017544,
-0.015459825284779072,
0.08708511292934418,
-0.022482378408312798,
0.00997865665704012,
-0.04290681332349777,
-0.008933351375162601,
0.01383661013096571,
0.07234001904726028,
0.011269672773778439,
0.04216623678803444,
-0.04214373603463173,
0.058549217879772186,
0.052228521555662155,
-0.016855847090482712,
0.0024949428625404835,
-0.0025391546078026295,
-0.023280449211597443,
-0.04836629331111908,
0.05851941928267479,
-0.004470631945878267,
-0.005313777830451727,
-0.05876099318265915,
0.07137193530797958,
0.04803360998630524,
-0.03864665701985359,
-0.01800856925547123,
0.005024775862693787,
-0.03558183088898659,
0.02962944656610489,
-0.015508386306464672,
0.04039918631315231,
-0.0002221075410488993,
0.07713636010885239,
0.0482424758374691,
0.03961361572146416,
0.059501372277736664,
0.0012978800805285573,
0.013656060211360455,
0.026530425995588303,
0.07000177353620529,
0.07373446971178055,
0.039053499698638916,
-0.0030994703993201256,
0.05451232194900513,
-0.02042052522301674,
-0.06443949043750763,
0.052904706448316574,
0.022925646975636482,
-0.01170184276998043,
0.018623678013682365,
0.00603703036904335,
0.08450589329004288,
-0.013082744553685188,
0.0741390585899353,
-0.03346538543701172,
-0.028653007000684738,
0.001596648944541812,
-0.009269851259887218,
0.035457711666822433,
0.030475560575723648,
0.029827047139406204,
0.03879264369606972,
-0.03578823804855347,
-0.00481163477525115,
0.028886154294013977,
-0.03980317711830139,
-0.016571873798966408,
0.00537909334525466,
-0.02453218586742878,
0.01443946361541748,
-0.029412345960736275,
0.08151034265756607,
0.0899106115102768,
-0.007281319238245487,
0.005201105494052172,
0.017600851133465767,
0.01440618559718132,
0.035345397889614105,
0.06068633496761322,
0.007376638241112232,
0.005394259002059698,
0.000435799389379099,
-0.060388900339603424,
0.008237125352025032,
0.023452455177903175,
-0.017907943576574326,
0.03377451002597809,
-0.022239819169044495,
-0.045022595673799515,
0.014444999396800995,
0.003899248084053397,
-0.03400277718901634,
-0.0612921379506588,
-0.01710752211511135,
-0.021766889840364456,
-0.053266629576683044,
-0.036192636936903,
0.016704268753528595,
0.011605781503021717,
-0.03202719986438751,
-0.01959017477929592,
-0.04425428807735443,
0.009599875658750534,
0.027829036116600037,
-0.0859738141298294,
0.026857780292630196,
0.03368658944964409,
0.003759545274078846,
-0.01449585985392332,
0.03755518049001694,
0.017817821353673935,
-0.05426759272813797,
0.00006878750718897209,
0.02490350417792797,
0.005081127863377333,
0.032249122858047485,
0.02524331770837307,
-0.029771864414215088,
-0.09063085913658142,
0.003977410960942507,
0.0047768293879926205,
-0.014860553666949272,
-0.08682142198085785,
0.019221283495426178,
-0.038389962166547775,
0.026179002597928047,
0.047159429639577866,
0.026422996073961258,
0.02815660461783409,
0.00830495823174715,
-0.029963333159685135,
0.007443949580192566,
-0.0074510169215500355,
0.029316939413547516,
-0.016293885186314583,
0.047118768095970154,
0.041210614144802094,
0.02224264293909073,
-0.07162679731845856,
0.03248975798487663,
-0.02334062196314335,
0.0380905419588089,
-0.019720371812582016,
-0.045006461441516876,
-0.029445907101035118,
-0.09440992027521133,
-0.0563180111348629,
0.030107680708169937,
-0.0061456598341465,
-0.060244347900152206,
0.009141718968749046,
0.026968158781528473,
-0.011284749954938889,
0.006180683616548777,
0.01699085719883442,
-0.004057375248521566,
-0.02742505818605423,
-0.010564119555056095,
-0.06956934183835983,
-0.013863938860595226,
-0.007923087105154991,
0.02496277540922165,
0.013471992686390877,
-0.028967298567295074,
0.003911202773451805,
0.0010416005970910192,
0.027121122926473618,
-0.017141643911600113,
0.013501839712262154,
-0.014184843748807907
] |
314 |
Model merging with SVD to tie the Knots
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=67X93aZHII
|
[
"George Stoica",
"Pratik Ramesh",
"Boglarka Ecsedi",
"Leshem Choshen",
"Judy Hoffman"
] |
Poster
|
Recent model merging methods demonstrate that the parameters of fully-finetuned models specializing in distinct tasks can be combined into one model capable of solving all tasks without retraining. Yet, this success does not transfer well when merging LoRA finetuned models. We study this phenomenon and observe that the weights of LoRA finetuned models showcase a lower degree of alignment compared to their fully-finetuned counterparts. We hypothesize that improving this alignment is key to obtaining better LoRA model merges, and propose KnOTS to address this problem. KnOTS uses the SVD to jointly transform the weights of different LoRA models into an aligned space, where existing merging methods can be applied. In addition, we introduce a new benchmark that explicitly evaluates whether merged models are general models. Notably, KnOTS consistently improves LoRA merging by up to 4.3% across several vision and language benchmarks, including our new setting. We release our code at: https://github.com/gstoica27/KnOTS.
|
model merging; lora PEFT; computer vision;
|
We align LoRA PEFT models to improve the application of existing merging methods.
| 13,539 |
2410.19735
|
[
-0.013344043865799904,
-0.04266064241528511,
0.004019091837108135,
0.0481155589222908,
0.018528759479522705,
0.032432977110147476,
0.03228399157524109,
-0.008302319794893265,
-0.043194204568862915,
-0.05744529888033867,
-0.020265726372599602,
0.013892740942537785,
-0.08910492807626724,
-0.007260187063366175,
-0.009668279439210892,
0.06679245084524155,
0.03783583268523216,
0.023546665906906128,
0.015188628807663918,
0.02600475586950779,
-0.03216663748025894,
-0.015914201736450195,
-0.015900999307632446,
0.016749540343880653,
0.0001867685205070302,
-0.0033981252927333117,
0.023531533777713776,
0.01681218110024929,
-0.0552145317196846,
-0.005696234293282032,
0.050310809165239334,
-0.0037708571180701256,
0.015558836050331593,
-0.012101787142455578,
0.007715933956205845,
-0.03463123366236687,
-0.043588221073150635,
0.0077289072796702385,
0.009385972283780575,
0.0033712571021169424,
-0.03093959577381611,
0.035245176404714584,
-0.010905923321843147,
0.019846178591251373,
-0.014624743722379208,
-0.011046450585126877,
-0.10988130420446396,
0.0437520369887352,
0.04456833004951477,
-0.01906490884721279,
-0.10807282477617264,
0.004991136025637388,
-0.006411498412489891,
-0.0017911038594320416,
-0.008986399509012699,
0.0658845379948616,
0.013771427795290947,
-0.07817285507917404,
0.013524309732019901,
-0.049023695290088654,
-0.040951356291770935,
0.013315706513822079,
0.005335014779120684,
-0.00037566269747912884,
0.025668885558843613,
-0.010789786465466022,
0.006010888610035181,
0.050014592707157135,
-0.04169057309627533,
-0.025759346783161163,
0.00809311494231224,
-0.007526921108365059,
0.00466186972334981,
0.00968251097947359,
-0.0065690940245985985,
-0.04849850386381149,
-0.0021651897113770247,
0.03901190310716629,
0.08606643974781036,
-0.010622593574225903,
0.018351081758737564,
0.02520120143890381,
0.03265472501516342,
0.04432237893342972,
0.04079323634505272,
0.016373978927731514,
-0.04183134809136391,
-0.03617273271083832,
-0.054838985204696655,
0.032267630100250244,
-0.017871197313070297,
-0.06840581446886063,
0.011031323112547398,
0.041962631046772,
0.004571105819195509,
0.045460741966962814,
0.0196097269654274,
0.046568579971790314,
0.0153671158477664,
-0.0002106803876813501,
-0.02215830609202385,
-0.015210961923003197,
0.009142458438873291,
0.022695377469062805,
-0.07128651440143585,
-0.04522532969713211,
-0.011447413824498653,
-0.01659775711596012,
-0.008046796545386314,
0.004981065168976784,
-0.03789310157299042,
-0.021841250360012054,
-0.014844385907053947,
-0.010964537039399147,
-0.07546538859605789,
0.04717392846941948,
-0.000736055604647845,
0.02732871100306511,
-0.05772422254085541,
-0.01725408062338829,
0.035101886838674545,
0.05297417566180229,
-0.008136817254126072,
0.0693339854478836,
0.0033899543341249228,
0.037120092660188675,
-0.03206690400838852,
0.035872653126716614,
-0.07356175780296326,
-0.03308476507663727,
-0.0010495494352653623,
0.028627358376979828,
-0.030837304890155792,
-0.004418367985635996,
0.012625365518033504,
-0.04165922850370407,
-0.019977934658527374,
0.020801139995455742,
0.02095883898437023,
-0.01862492598593235,
-0.010215526446700096,
0.02405449189245701,
0.045842912048101425,
0.010490020737051964,
0.08227957040071487,
0.0073187462985515594,
-0.008396193385124207,
-0.018977481871843338,
-0.042125847190618515,
0.0010222687851637602,
0.012028881348669529,
0.0294460691511631,
-0.009002634324133396,
-0.0909743458032608,
0.041448500007390976,
0.10880900174379349,
0.010747539810836315,
0.02980821579694748,
0.020584452897310257,
-0.016883397474884987,
0.019055737182497978,
-0.01775568537414074,
-0.03502662852406502,
0.030230363830924034,
-0.02559816837310791,
-0.049460843205451965,
0.021520715206861496,
0.0123837199062109,
-0.004743914119899273,
0.02555951289832592,
-0.05669281259179115,
-0.03793919458985329,
0.05891402065753937,
-0.03587036579847336,
-0.018803155049681664,
0.00500980531796813,
0.08148375153541565,
0.01399370189756155,
0.012879307381808758,
0.03439439833164215,
-0.07962768524885178,
0.012687409296631813,
0.01614592783153057,
-0.037317611277103424,
0.002989432541653514,
-0.004633672069758177,
0.1248345598578453,
-0.03608052432537079,
-0.010978066362440586,
0.013359355740249157,
-0.08557509630918503,
-0.02038498781621456,
0.03338005766272545,
-0.014667648822069168,
0.045952025800943375,
0.014901944436132908,
-0.031114628538489342,
0.0628967359662056,
0.010740919038653374,
0.04378647357225418,
0.04366590827703476,
-0.027815673500299454,
0.04668084532022476,
0.011612129397690296,
-0.030435631051659584,
0.007872866466641426,
0.027574550360441208,
-0.02782399207353592,
-0.0319003202021122,
0.016470735892653465,
-0.00003769649629248306,
-0.03923426568508148,
0.018459118902683258,
-0.007818811573088169,
0.0188846904784441,
0.05240076035261154,
-0.0010889602126553655,
-0.019130149856209755,
0.0034814353566616774,
-0.03792079910635948,
0.0051711625419557095,
0.014904595911502838,
-0.037662480026483536,
-0.015326395630836487,
-0.024205738678574562,
0.06389528512954712,
0.0489150807261467,
-0.02082199975848198,
-0.027720952406525612,
0.019561272114515305,
-0.002623450243845582,
0.00803932175040245,
0.005036942660808563,
-0.0031777438707649708,
-0.003850111970677972,
-0.0454123355448246,
0.013746480457484722,
-0.0313606821000576,
0.04063024744391441,
-0.05418764427304268,
0.0007387019577436149,
0.046326491981744766,
-0.0024626420345157385,
0.061081692576408386,
0.03371943160891533,
-0.00774367107078433,
0.02617686241865158,
-0.033995430916547775,
0.004208269529044628,
0.007399861700832844,
-0.004268179181963205,
-0.01342848688364029,
-0.01437301654368639,
-0.03239774703979492,
0.0024890215136110783,
-0.05987607687711716,
-0.0051450347527861595,
-0.042943745851516724,
0.06199502944946289,
0.032779667526483536,
0.03278159722685814,
0.012651129625737667,
-0.004220031667500734,
-0.010152805596590042,
-0.014274843037128448,
-0.08314477652311325,
-0.03955389931797981,
-0.04115286096930504,
0.06196856126189232,
-0.002328072441741824,
0.033045511692762375,
0.04053760692477226,
0.0042250268161296844,
-0.05466833710670471,
0.003604589030146599,
0.015888269990682602,
0.045112572610378265,
0.008181430399417877,
-0.042062029242515564,
-0.037270013242959976,
-0.009023725055158138,
0.06787282973527908,
-0.016461782157421112,
-0.044689666479825974,
-0.046816129237413406,
-0.027844281867146492,
0.011251524090766907,
-0.041435834020376205,
0.009978415444493294,
0.003731315489858389,
0.0049402168951928616,
0.04227307066321373,
-0.03254740685224533,
0.005712137091904879,
0.013938946649432182,
0.05453991889953613,
0.040043387562036514,
0.005376010667532682,
-0.016063207760453224,
0.03411334380507469,
0.034320127218961716,
0.041275326162576675,
0.03412952646613121,
-0.004738072864711285,
-0.017627151682972908,
0.01124358270317316,
0.03386946767568588,
-0.026457875967025757,
-0.2782955467700958,
-0.036306705325841904,
-0.002292259596288204,
-0.04771265387535095,
0.020892979577183723,
-0.00903338473290205,
0.035067442804574966,
-0.0364195741713047,
-0.01623610593378544,
0.012135205790400505,
0.007662241347134113,
0.04623202979564667,
0.03211056441068649,
0.016849340870976448,
0.05222102254629135,
0.023184657096862793,
-0.015959449112415314,
-0.012874369509518147,
0.009806379675865173,
0.045251231640577316,
-0.040341753512620926,
-0.07347062230110168,
-0.025507768616080284,
0.04170599579811096,
-0.0332782156765461,
0.028422797098755836,
-0.08541452139616013,
-0.019012846052646637,
-0.04644938185811043,
-0.041928935796022415,
0.011485327035188675,
-0.0009596990421414375,
-0.01632075570523739,
0.04142977297306061,
-0.020102931186556816,
-0.025083715096116066,
0.03515472263097763,
-0.007805002387613058,
0.009763460606336594,
-0.013256624341011047,
-0.01770276203751564,
-0.005691664759069681,
-0.008249008096754551,
0.01457187533378601,
0.0834592804312706,
0.01059276144951582,
-0.026445213705301285,
-0.013535424135625362,
-0.03571145236492157,
0.04644622281193733,
-0.001720437197946012,
-0.0008634495316073298,
-0.009590019471943378,
-0.0028528948314487934,
-0.021319594234228134,
-0.011357802897691727,
0.011728656478226185,
-0.0030787489376962185,
-0.006560612935572863,
0.05297962948679924,
-0.022502444684505463,
-0.07972877472639084,
-0.025594312697649002,
-0.06722863763570786,
-0.03827131912112236,
-0.02297646924853325,
-0.06926976889371872,
-0.04656049981713295,
0.02318110689520836,
0.015704989433288574,
-0.029353952035307884,
0.07660123705863953,
-0.02201715297996998,
-0.08927823603153229,
-0.0008894777274690568,
-0.01916583627462387,
-0.0133172906935215,
-0.022731252014636993,
-0.004852957092225552,
0.038128968328237534,
-0.033179450780153275,
-0.08653312921524048,
0.04027894511818886,
0.01988796330988407,
-0.004167406354099512,
0.0010387833463028073,
-0.0014638258144259453,
-0.036705344915390015,
0.011769271455705166,
-0.039095621556043625,
0.05232492461800575,
0.016002008691430092,
0.0023998632095754147,
0.008696293458342552,
0.03462902456521988,
0.026148002594709396,
0.023869002237915993,
0.026203453540802002,
0.028745653107762337,
0.03942888230085373,
0.013257548213005066,
-0.08169934898614883,
0.004703590180724859,
-0.015267828479409218,
-0.031110618263483047,
0.022669535130262375,
-0.03370646387338638,
-0.03521522507071495,
0.06164475902915001,
-0.0022878600284457207,
-0.016057247295975685,
-0.029824508354067802,
0.007008499000221491,
-0.006581098306924105,
-0.013235114514827728,
-0.005372113548219204,
0.021609695628285408,
0.011850375682115555,
0.004476608708500862,
-0.018508465960621834,
-0.04106713458895683,
0.02316592074930668,
-0.01353755034506321,
0.00338050932623446,
-0.03224317729473114,
-0.005605127662420273,
-0.01794200949370861,
0.010189914144575596,
-0.03391912952065468,
0.04812771454453468,
0.01166639942675829,
0.055863287299871445,
-0.008886794559657574,
-0.020975736901164055,
0.0488734096288681,
0.02262543886899948,
-0.0028756477404385805,
0.01787930354475975,
0.050571128726005554,
-0.018554482609033585,
0.03364826366305351,
-0.01854318380355835,
-0.013434775173664093,
0.032449591904878616,
-0.002906563226133585,
0.01372389867901802,
0.021313706412911415,
-0.02359258383512497,
0.0036510294303297997,
0.023458052426576614,
-0.011260374449193478,
-0.04640470817685127,
-0.0390053428709507,
-0.045017585158348083,
0.022663775831460953,
-0.030926724895834923,
-0.015219812281429768,
-0.014761194586753845,
0.006416900549083948,
-0.04758106544613838,
0.02099674381315708,
0.03958988934755325,
-0.005837192293256521,
0.009560509584844112,
0.020006850361824036,
0.024993138387799263,
-0.029601499438285828,
-0.030981838703155518,
0.016402369365096092,
-0.004735828842967749,
0.015741756185889244,
-0.030031822621822357,
-0.02489341050386429,
-0.03486734628677368,
-0.014569398015737534,
0.04242532700300217,
0.019148889929056168,
0.014240053482353687,
-0.025483088567852974,
0.050142742693424225,
0.0148538863286376,
-0.0003524224739521742,
-0.009127487428486347,
-0.03208475932478905,
0.03083278425037861,
-0.006219490896910429,
-0.026198267936706543,
0.00864527840167284,
-0.02505098655819893,
0.04086752608418465,
0.020665643736720085,
0.03224378824234009,
-0.018557768315076828,
-0.002664459403604269,
-0.04007183015346527,
-0.06350705027580261,
0.005716135259717703,
0.020696138963103294,
-0.006391049828380346,
-0.011070062406361103,
-0.03718593716621399,
0.018407143652439117,
-0.032213374972343445,
-0.010052596218883991,
-0.0024639617186039686,
-0.09283426403999329,
0.005921702831983566,
0.031378623098134995,
-0.022241011261940002,
-0.0037290798500180244,
-0.016596345230937004,
-0.04855554550886154,
-0.064860500395298,
-0.020317891612648964,
0.035104312002658844,
-0.01715158112347126,
-0.0256594680249691,
-0.022160081192851067,
-0.019124379381537437,
-0.01743697188794613,
0.03559396415948868,
-0.0007731329533271492,
-0.028465908020734787,
0.009724930860102177,
0.00654463330283761,
0.041802357882261276,
-0.02853475511074066,
0.00568870035931468,
0.0016074078157544136,
-0.0366937629878521,
0.038231465965509415,
-0.06388045102357864,
0.03570953756570816,
0.05410099774599075,
-0.014954856596887112,
0.03723011910915375,
-0.09344275295734406,
0.018116354942321777,
0.018231375142931938,
-0.015454523265361786,
0.049698956310749054,
0.027693521231412888,
0.0017348030814900994,
0.023426905274391174,
-0.007683697156608105,
0.03590342402458191,
-0.015332627110183239,
0.0030599921010434628,
-0.017604626715183258,
0.02141116000711918,
0.0021919417195022106,
0.011859296821057796,
-0.008170736953616142,
-0.03196807578206062,
0.058617886155843735,
-0.021076271310448647,
-0.03577321395277977,
-0.07850905507802963,
-0.06283106654882431,
-0.01716633327305317,
-0.00703989015892148,
0.05147102102637291,
-0.0553283654153347,
0.05235232785344124,
0.02694411389529705,
0.05126023292541504,
0.011741215363144875,
-0.018820134922862053,
0.052597369998693466,
-0.0012664636597037315,
0.020486578345298767,
-0.03098895214498043,
-0.012004509568214417,
0.053177595138549805,
-0.026655320078134537,
0.02199237048625946,
0.010088608600199223,
-0.01978881098330021,
0.001735797501169145,
-0.0593290850520134,
-0.03768324851989746,
0.02788882702589035,
-0.02090385928750038,
0.009592072106897831,
0.009865865111351013,
-0.032681599259376526,
0.008992532268166542,
-0.02795412577688694,
-0.04558475688099861,
0.013154043816030025,
-0.020027415826916695,
0.058561746031045914,
-0.02179044485092163,
0.048299167305231094,
-0.019928675144910812,
0.009997054934501648,
0.0253777913749218,
0.07012668251991272,
0.05169949680566788,
0.023689929395914078,
-0.0009459019638597965,
0.07666581124067307,
0.014197690412402153,
-0.015057476237416267,
-0.022971032187342644,
0.02908686362206936,
0.007897526025772095,
-0.03847432881593704,
0.08619123697280884,
-0.0014639194123446941,
-0.03001408278942108,
-0.0208296962082386,
0.06645581871271133,
0.04607441648840904,
-0.0571369044482708,
0.0034145561512559652,
0.01361736562103033,
-0.05538743734359741,
0.024498676881194115,
-0.009588547050952911,
0.029002508148550987,
-0.006270694080740213,
0.05902940779924393,
0.021130802109837532,
0.027548443526029587,
0.03127846121788025,
-0.019163820892572403,
0.02158002369105816,
0.025171512737870216,
0.09035848826169968,
0.05774230882525444,
0.04690517857670784,
-0.0036844818387180567,
0.04984362795948982,
-0.010880829766392708,
-0.054722003638744354,
0.057067032903432846,
-0.0005004691192880273,
0.02693210542201996,
-0.04358223080635071,
0.017838140949606895,
0.049493566155433655,
0.01694696769118309,
0.055488910526037216,
-0.042772162705659866,
0.009270882233977318,
0.0012687628623098135,
-0.010879344306886196,
0.008457314223051071,
-0.004711118061095476,
0.032183583825826645,
0.0016958822961896658,
-0.02981192246079445,
-0.003909981343895197,
0.016459425911307335,
-0.005172525532543659,
0.025930313393473625,
0.017887447029352188,
-0.016052942723035812,
0.013926059007644653,
-0.024877134710550308,
0.04988429322838783,
0.09430322051048279,
-0.03062347322702408,
-0.0472768135368824,
-0.03609554469585419,
0.030785517767071724,
0.0328204445540905,
0.014602366834878922,
0.00648134108632803,
-0.03423041105270386,
0.028282131999731064,
-0.05390876531600952,
0.04954047501087189,
0.03859267011284828,
0.008864320814609528,
0.0028499977197498083,
-0.02242504060268402,
-0.012512203305959702,
-0.0012302492978051305,
0.007698433939367533,
-0.05035572499036789,
-0.013330068439245224,
-0.020273393020033836,
-0.08056338131427765,
-0.03559364750981331,
-0.022718703374266624,
0.0011589893838390708,
0.011929529719054699,
-0.023137280717492104,
-0.03267648443579674,
-0.05504308268427849,
0.028612319380044937,
0.06982918083667755,
-0.04166499897837639,
0.015574615448713303,
0.029342863708734512,
0.006143954116851091,
-0.03490852192044258,
0.06177743151783943,
0.043195754289627075,
0.0010666907764971256,
0.004276697989553213,
0.031959641724824905,
0.03547480329871178,
0.020831162109971046,
0.04022617265582085,
0.002019729698076844,
-0.09137959033250809,
0.017972687259316444,
0.01667800545692444,
-0.030347075313329697,
-0.07583195716142654,
0.0014516706578433514,
-0.00947977602481842,
0.011223365552723408,
0.051658082753419876,
-0.006328473333269358,
-0.010297431610524654,
-0.019814511761069298,
-0.02988964319229126,
0.0016637389780953526,
0.008991925977170467,
0.026518620550632477,
-0.021202566102147102,
0.06236625835299492,
0.03105464018881321,
0.009279847145080566,
-0.04132126644253731,
0.04387418180704117,
-0.009458869695663452,
0.03529161214828491,
-0.04135490953922272,
-0.04697727411985397,
-0.026725919917225838,
-0.0973065197467804,
-0.046741969883441925,
0.02843010425567627,
0.00402411725372076,
-0.06547024101018906,
-0.0008775028982199728,
-0.029597055166959763,
-0.05006418004631996,
0.003705618204548955,
0.0253724567592144,
0.0019132283050566912,
-0.05168161913752556,
-0.005504311062395573,
-0.07116497308015823,
0.0010076877661049366,
-0.013944584876298904,
0.0028849253430962563,
-0.0170244500041008,
-0.034021686762571335,
0.025983549654483795,
0.022646524012088776,
0.014986414462327957,
0.013774448074400425,
0.056631531566381454,
-0.007521171122789383
] |
315 |
PolyhedronNet: Representation Learning for Polyhedra with Surface-attributed Graph
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=BpyHIrpUOL
|
[
"Dazhou Yu",
"Genpei Zhang",
"Liang Zhao"
] |
Poster
|
Ubiquitous geometric objects can be precisely and efficiently represented as polyhedra. The transformation of a polyhedron into a vector, known as polyhedra representation learning, is crucial for manipulating these shapes with mathematical and statistical tools for tasks like classification, clustering, and generation. Recent years have witnessed significant strides in this domain, yet most efforts focus on the vertex sequence of a polyhedron, neglecting the complex surface modeling crucial in real-world polyhedral objects.
This study proposes \textbf{PolyhedronNet}, a general framework tailored for learning representations of 3D polyhedral objects. We propose the concept of the surface-attributed graph to seamlessly model the vertices, edges, faces, and their geometric interrelationships within a polyhedron.
To effectively learn the representation of the entire surface-attributed graph, we first propose to break it down into local rigid representations to effectively learn each local region's relative positions against the remaining regions without geometric information loss. Subsequently, we propose PolyhedronGNN to hierarchically aggregate the local rigid representation via intra-face and inter-face geometric message passing modules, to obtain a global representation that minimizes information loss while maintaining rotation and translation invariance.
Our experimental evaluations on four distinct datasets, encompassing both classification and retrieval tasks, substantiate PolyhedronNet's efficacy in capturing comprehensive and informative representations of 3D polyhedral objects.
|
polygon, polyhedron, polygonal representation, representation learning, graph neural networks
|
A framework for encoding polyhedral objects using surface-attributed graph
| 13,538 |
2502.01814
|
[
-0.001036422443576157,
0.010080395266413689,
-0.004064909648150206,
0.03717217966914177,
0.005838778335601091,
0.02084522508084774,
-0.014222047291696072,
0.005788679234683514,
-0.029818128794431686,
-0.06489654630422592,
-0.025463417172431946,
-0.021332578733563423,
-0.062153395265340805,
0.03495154529809952,
0.017231246456503868,
0.02433164045214653,
0.024385223165154457,
0.01304794754832983,
0.01549534872174263,
0.06730996817350388,
-0.00724090076982975,
-0.03485216945409775,
0.02682722546160221,
0.0044691432267427444,
0.027066221460700035,
-0.005722702480852604,
0.03920520842075348,
-0.011426652781665325,
-0.023266198113560677,
0.00684737553820014,
-0.018223151564598083,
-0.024694854393601418,
0.011882362887263298,
-0.06575018167495728,
0.021902907639741898,
-0.011555546894669533,
-0.04205332323908806,
0.007681022863835096,
-0.014025771990418434,
0.009562482126057148,
-0.0033316309563815594,
0.00814325362443924,
0.01231676060706377,
0.023556997999548912,
-0.02531520090997219,
0.02064327895641327,
-0.09601939469575882,
0.03857282176613808,
0.015745440497994423,
-0.03330178186297417,
-0.105767622590065,
0.033651720732450485,
0.013414387591183186,
0.0034766686148941517,
0.00463314913213253,
0.019906898960471153,
0.03486078605055809,
-0.05352795124053955,
-0.003029024228453636,
-0.060745999217033386,
-0.03667992725968361,
0.05161357298493385,
0.02004741132259369,
0.014515779912471771,
-0.008347664959728718,
0.009822011925280094,
0.014935891143977642,
0.03634529188275337,
-0.06127851828932762,
-0.0069854846224188805,
-0.0242120660841465,
-0.04796178638935089,
-0.00712162209674716,
0.01173934992402792,
0.01808255910873413,
-0.029335033148527145,
0.016337227076292038,
0.004569303244352341,
0.08579489588737488,
-0.024377955123782158,
0.006140842568129301,
0.06067328900098801,
-0.0032004332169890404,
0.03193693235516548,
-0.0038302878383547068,
0.00010462076170369983,
-0.06303621828556061,
-0.02918616496026516,
-0.06719975173473358,
0.031813476234674454,
-0.038065336644649506,
-0.026761043816804886,
0.017272263765335083,
0.023451730608940125,
0.0008364511304534972,
-0.01997470110654831,
0.02490277588367462,
0.039642106741666794,
0.047592468559741974,
-0.005044934339821339,
-0.019881026819348335,
-0.0824446752667427,
0.002058034297078848,
0.016726313158869743,
-0.08611711114645004,
-0.03570689260959625,
-0.028264882043004036,
-0.013160152360796928,
-0.0248152706772089,
-0.010601067915558815,
-0.042923565953969955,
-0.018299318850040436,
0.012400327250361443,
-0.03105843812227249,
-0.04882053658366203,
0.031743716448545456,
0.021006682887673378,
0.00709210429340601,
-0.032772570848464966,
0.022664280608296394,
0.017262224107980728,
0.031346388161182404,
0.010621123015880585,
0.0597759373486042,
-0.0058222743682563305,
0.0036217845045030117,
0.00622617918998003,
0.014145737513899803,
-0.04141180217266083,
-0.03945254907011986,
0.009422888979315758,
0.05843561887741089,
0.01022747065871954,
0.016501693055033684,
0.033345747739076614,
-0.06860534101724625,
0.0027685551904141903,
0.005228206980973482,
0.019061492756009102,
-0.01777670718729496,
0.002623323816806078,
-0.028500771149992943,
0.03862569481134415,
-0.01117151603102684,
0.07945007085800171,
-0.03808329999446869,
0.000006871126970509067,
0.0018091421807184815,
-0.039834149181842804,
0.004169314168393612,
0.03321612626314163,
-0.0145600326359272,
-0.012222647666931152,
-0.04212115332484245,
0.03233175352215767,
0.06383932381868362,
0.03650717809796333,
0.07813860476016998,
0.008801853284239769,
0.0028477252926677465,
0.015210731886327267,
0.004990919027477503,
-0.03166617080569267,
0.016069728881120682,
-0.011238669976592064,
-0.06142471358180046,
0.034403733909130096,
0.03567613288760185,
-0.018310295417904854,
-0.017226936295628548,
-0.02775527723133564,
-0.06485211104154587,
0.04377707466483116,
-0.01217574905604124,
-0.01575080305337906,
-0.03671678155660629,
0.07534665614366531,
-0.013800577260553837,
0.033885128796100616,
0.007347299251705408,
-0.08724402636289597,
0.005261935759335756,
0.013341384008526802,
-0.05838034301996231,
0.014729109592735767,
-0.024647509679198265,
0.08760959655046463,
-0.013091317377984524,
0.008332502096891403,
0.01778804510831833,
-0.05846699699759483,
-0.01325884647667408,
0.026211809366941452,
-0.02803053893148899,
0.05346112698316574,
0.040629416704177856,
-0.04369383677840233,
0.006486562546342611,
0.00005672941551893018,
0.0510498508810997,
0.018055401742458344,
-0.0008686048677191138,
0.04876206815242767,
-0.025425467640161514,
-0.036214105784893036,
-0.04165799170732498,
0.044981133192777634,
-0.03870515897870064,
-0.05663132667541504,
0.004333340097218752,
-0.0022518085315823555,
-0.026986099779605865,
-0.0025515544693917036,
-0.024932105094194412,
0.01653626188635826,
0.004723869264125824,
0.013046201318502426,
0.024949248880147934,
0.017296625301241875,
-0.06566173583269119,
0.007640060968697071,
0.02846592292189598,
-0.03022145666182041,
0.0018890228820964694,
-0.03010515496134758,
0.08521026372909546,
0.05306616052985191,
-0.05125382915139198,
-0.009562497027218342,
-0.0027840533293783665,
0.019230680540204048,
0.032980676740407944,
0.013009061105549335,
-0.040035780519247055,
0.014498425647616386,
-0.0202594306319952,
0.031065624207258224,
-0.0498017892241478,
0.04803043603897095,
-0.04166523367166519,
-0.030138641595840454,
0.0691794753074646,
-0.0019953916780650616,
0.018806446343660355,
0.033714067190885544,
0.03150808811187744,
0.07670153677463531,
-0.014832260087132454,
-0.002935547847300768,
-0.011225380934774876,
-0.016259778290987015,
0.001231853268109262,
-0.0036216662265360355,
-0.013953967951238155,
-0.023632608354091644,
-0.06188315898180008,
0.0068842447362840176,
-0.035972826182842255,
0.05795968696475029,
0.049835044890642166,
0.029990509152412415,
0.017053620889782906,
-0.027835436165332794,
-0.02058020420372486,
-0.06247471272945404,
-0.12117987871170044,
-0.032525546848773956,
-0.032893188297748566,
0.06251952052116394,
0.012548296712338924,
0.06096590310335159,
0.009461620822548866,
0.016461757943034172,
-0.022240348160266876,
-0.0028239507228136063,
0.011374120600521564,
0.008506380021572113,
-0.000717775197699666,
-0.06962825357913971,
-0.014123802073299885,
0.020121796056628227,
0.05775974318385124,
0.007620629854500294,
-0.024381710216403008,
-0.011762615293264389,
-0.053600963205099106,
0.010699275881052017,
-0.05535683408379555,
-0.017788033932447433,
0.000036968616768717766,
0.026305751875042915,
0.01167469285428524,
-0.0320315808057785,
0.0024902361910790205,
0.06285616755485535,
0.06733586639165878,
0.04534712806344032,
-0.04019804298877716,
-0.011686993762850761,
-0.019646214321255684,
-0.009619776159524918,
0.050846174359321594,
-0.009772284887731075,
-0.002249587792903185,
0.008779537864029408,
0.02338302880525589,
0.009953349828720093,
-0.019776981323957443,
-0.24360060691833496,
-0.04943989962339401,
0.011171398684382439,
0.0001244839804712683,
0.03702285885810852,
-0.0004046222602482885,
0.04091421142220497,
-0.01708751730620861,
-0.027247440069913864,
0.0006700585363432765,
0.030138062313199043,
0.01801379583775997,
0.0019430418033152819,
0.06348966807126999,
0.061726607382297516,
0.041056618094444275,
0.016400564461946487,
-0.02006484940648079,
-0.005539557430893183,
0.008665020577609539,
-0.03183509409427643,
-0.07621311396360397,
-0.051487356424331665,
0.0448448546230793,
-0.06828862428665161,
0.02285674773156643,
-0.06850048154592514,
-0.02922942489385605,
-0.04852840304374695,
-0.014545749872922897,
0.011739479377865791,
-0.011875167489051819,
-0.004814954474568367,
0.02556758001446724,
-0.011698267422616482,
-0.003003222169354558,
0.028053315356373787,
-0.0210739579051733,
0.03811635076999664,
0.02398361638188362,
-0.0017555149970576167,
-0.013868759386241436,
-0.023015039041638374,
0.04737955331802368,
0.10220760852098465,
-0.015491635538637638,
-0.06754525750875473,
-0.034217629581689835,
-0.03566614165902138,
0.020662784576416016,
0.01979519985616207,
-0.028224272653460503,
0.011861050501465797,
0.018052073195576668,
-0.008762122131884098,
-0.015579511411488056,
0.033686671406030655,
0.0028435741551220417,
-0.05713605880737305,
-0.003935370594263077,
-0.018007423728704453,
-0.03621822968125343,
-0.011574247851967812,
-0.028918547555804253,
-0.019929783418774605,
-0.043647680431604385,
-0.08551058173179626,
-0.0694517120718956,
-0.00042676058365032077,
0.06516796350479126,
-0.007014736998826265,
0.09315082430839539,
-0.03763483464717865,
-0.09297312796115875,
0.035871896892786026,
0.031756844371557236,
-0.005605073645710945,
-0.008764363825321198,
0.02247755043208599,
0.044663529843091965,
-0.022800324484705925,
-0.044592514634132385,
0.0055497800931334496,
0.012853714637458324,
0.007646890357136726,
0.01430016290396452,
0.030183782801032066,
-0.04231100156903267,
-0.011508150957524776,
-0.007199568208307028,
0.047800734639167786,
0.025277502834796906,
0.037716928869485855,
-0.006241882685571909,
0.016269851475954056,
0.04600491374731064,
0.03654850646853447,
0.029481468722224236,
0.06464388966560364,
0.00729665532708168,
0.006379233207553625,
-0.07163108885288239,
-0.019025186076760292,
0.00877254270017147,
-0.07484805583953857,
0.015636155381798744,
-0.04942677915096283,
-0.01715204492211342,
0.057644233107566833,
-0.0014711936237290502,
-0.044108133763074875,
-0.03570745512843132,
0.02345208451151848,
0.004322110675275326,
-0.0009488850482739508,
-0.011531000956892967,
0.019018782302737236,
0.016574801877141,
0.006251789629459381,
-0.02254941500723362,
-0.03065086342394352,
0.03329947218298912,
0.008059184066951275,
0.021187253296375275,
-0.02429916150867939,
-0.0321916900575161,
0.008833826519548893,
-0.016017677262425423,
-0.005355347879230976,
0.0145431412383914,
0.013933025300502777,
0.042667217552661896,
-0.005273241084069014,
0.03787657618522644,
0.06331725418567657,
0.04204647243022919,
-0.02060404233634472,
0.0008636739803478122,
0.056826796382665634,
-0.024859171360731125,
0.05199165269732475,
-0.0045181093737483025,
0.03412406146526337,
0.016418328508734703,
0.0446048378944397,
0.012749929912388325,
-0.008563952520489693,
0.01818053238093853,
-0.005288936663419008,
-0.0163858775049448,
0.02313927747309208,
-0.04178301617503166,
-0.0022704857401549816,
-0.03633524477481842,
0.004364104475826025,
0.00940723903477192,
0.034094102680683136,
0.0006575850420631468,
0.006227464880794287,
-0.0496436208486557,
0.060746438801288605,
0.03336199000477791,
-0.013355626724660397,
0.006867084186524153,
0.010213294066488743,
0.0528363399207592,
0.0016483532963320613,
-0.022144492715597153,
0.010795108042657375,
0.005944668781012297,
0.023976244032382965,
-0.019610708579421043,
-0.021004168316721916,
-0.023111600428819656,
-0.019494222477078438,
0.01847093738615513,
0.008157175965607166,
-0.013735365122556686,
-0.02364228293299675,
0.023216979578137398,
-0.016827313229441643,
-0.0394410602748394,
0.013751327060163021,
-0.016337186098098755,
0.04884776473045349,
0.023629194125533104,
-0.016148103401064873,
0.008829092606902122,
-0.04190000146627426,
0.03825293481349945,
0.022652944549918175,
0.013875391334295273,
-0.05567418783903122,
-0.018048424273729324,
-0.012316297739744186,
-0.03821940720081329,
0.014404408633708954,
-0.02120337449014187,
-0.0469936728477478,
-0.02746916003525257,
-0.030381327494978905,
0.031352460384368896,
-0.0634206011891365,
0.010088255628943443,
0.03968548774719238,
-0.059196535497903824,
0.015172959305346012,
0.04417867586016655,
0.0004039460909552872,
-0.006882255431264639,
-0.020909836515784264,
0.00833932776004076,
-0.04695015028119087,
-0.032212208956480026,
0.006924238055944443,
-0.006799948867410421,
0.007559856399893761,
-0.023986198008060455,
-0.02245466411113739,
-0.009591339156031609,
0.026450209319591522,
0.016457917168736458,
-0.021602191030979156,
-0.04441439360380173,
0.00927021075040102,
0.08529666066169739,
0.002447154140099883,
-0.006976344622671604,
-0.030564427375793457,
0.004238672088831663,
0.04394375905394554,
-0.011735295876860619,
-0.0007461480563506484,
0.04107404872775078,
-0.021429693326354027,
-0.009311194531619549,
-0.042106498032808304,
0.02248196117579937,
0.03724849596619606,
-0.022211240604519844,
0.02132602222263813,
-0.007601236924529076,
-0.039804473519325256,
0.03659336268901825,
0.021756963804364204,
0.01280670054256916,
0.04602038860321045,
0.013205424882471561,
0.019947171211242676,
0.02214019000530243,
0.01972011849284172,
-0.03185197338461876,
-0.027201279997825623,
-0.051856666803359985,
0.032970018684864044,
-0.02828904055058956,
-0.012053582817316055,
-0.03394873067736626,
-0.01753120869398117,
0.014531602151691914,
-0.0497392900288105,
0.03262769803404808,
-0.013231161050498486,
0.04325827211141586,
0.013202548027038574,
0.04055320844054222,
0.008192854933440685,
-0.026302892714738846,
0.03411461040377617,
-0.06114799529314041,
0.006668105721473694,
-0.021306078881025314,
-0.021770523861050606,
0.06106630340218544,
-0.02060258947312832,
-0.02289746142923832,
-0.01060567982494831,
-0.030261602252721786,
0.03496547415852547,
-0.035041745752096176,
-0.07288862019777298,
0.034579116851091385,
-0.010639555752277374,
-0.008621015585958958,
0.04833083599805832,
-0.01248219795525074,
-0.00927245244383812,
0.005137550178915262,
-0.029505234211683273,
-0.029623989015817642,
-0.017419777810573578,
0.017565567046403885,
-0.06499669700860977,
0.015923472121357918,
0.0036573554389178753,
0.025070374831557274,
0.04244261607527733,
0.07421562075614929,
0.036686308681964874,
0.03682866320014,
-0.0299492459744215,
0.06362948566675186,
0.02762351930141449,
-0.006807767786085606,
0.017436901107430458,
0.03232503682374954,
0.005387375596910715,
-0.03730771690607071,
0.016689900308847427,
0.016650689765810966,
-0.026690775528550148,
-0.061444614082574844,
0.05438249930739403,
0.011503305286169052,
-0.051912009716033936,
-0.008865834213793278,
0.03141006454825401,
-0.05736299231648445,
0.0060197594575583935,
-0.013283015228807926,
-0.016062606126070023,
-0.012298041954636574,
0.06376192718744278,
0.001588347484357655,
0.04477638378739357,
0.06300915032625198,
0.033045992255210876,
-0.031051190569996834,
-0.0475878044962883,
0.0830809697508812,
0.049132198095321655,
0.025148281827569008,
0.00023650546791031957,
0.07967011630535126,
-0.017142711207270622,
-0.04509079456329346,
0.01238401047885418,
0.00972012896090746,
0.009739122353494167,
-0.05433448776602745,
-0.013011270202696323,
0.07793381065130234,
-0.015909411013126373,
0.029119383543729782,
-0.04132634028792381,
-0.004149133805185556,
0.012601790018379688,
0.00659551378339529,
0.0013305535539984703,
0.048571400344371796,
0.06086435168981552,
0.03820669278502464,
-0.027285443618893623,
0.01814461685717106,
-0.019847718998789787,
-0.02535919100046158,
0.03733803331851959,
0.023146821185946465,
-0.023427249863743782,
0.04156137630343437,
-0.019458478316664696,
0.03484327346086502,
0.10051652044057846,
-0.013843041844666004,
-0.08777755498886108,
-0.007697338704019785,
0.004277527332305908,
0.010206199251115322,
0.03353889659047127,
0.008081337437033653,
-0.009420801885426044,
0.010826066136360168,
-0.06199042871594429,
0.05017109215259552,
0.016051216050982475,
-0.017644427716732025,
0.02006201632320881,
-0.015040220692753792,
-0.0441439226269722,
-0.010211598128080368,
0.01379892323166132,
-0.04195268452167511,
-0.0639679953455925,
-0.023289168253540993,
-0.03578915819525719,
-0.0472915843129158,
-0.02448136918246746,
0.03411327302455902,
0.019382605329155922,
-0.062045466154813766,
-0.031165484338998795,
0.0007517306366935372,
0.031535468995571136,
0.041307635605335236,
-0.06736806780099869,
0.00722385011613369,
0.053738269954919815,
0.04544356092810631,
0.008338362909853458,
0.05314772576093674,
0.03186265379190445,
-0.040686752647161484,
-0.0005878102383576334,
0.04140743240714073,
-0.005342344753444195,
0.01745813526213169,
0.0028951370622962713,
-0.016336239874362946,
-0.12284665554761887,
-0.018910810351371765,
0.016552750021219254,
-0.03659332916140556,
-0.07114846259355545,
0.01050515379756689,
-0.017942994832992554,
0.031584810465574265,
0.03786960616707802,
0.023655587807297707,
0.014045211486518383,
-0.04178083315491676,
0.028604764491319656,
-0.03036591410636902,
-0.00022587593412026763,
0.046916428953409195,
-0.01881013810634613,
0.047577615827322006,
0.054382503032684326,
-0.03848932310938835,
0.004379813559353352,
0.02426924556493759,
0.0038948256988078356,
0.010486388579010963,
-0.03959202021360397,
-0.06183325871825218,
-0.023400887846946716,
-0.10770926624536514,
-0.024622399359941483,
0.03731917589902878,
-0.0001997108047362417,
-0.029017966240644455,
-0.0031189839355647564,
-0.0124320974573493,
-0.02016007900238037,
0.003600003197789192,
-0.01815302111208439,
0.001994411228224635,
-0.028506549075245857,
-0.005056154448539019,
-0.054316069930791855,
0.03873519226908684,
-0.02395619824528694,
0.03070935234427452,
-0.03041096217930317,
-0.043378736823797226,
-0.013918736949563026,
-0.04495297372341156,
0.007712936028838158,
0.0011253979755565524,
0.051974087953567505,
0.0205046609044075
] |
316 |
SafeDiffuser: Safe Planning with Diffusion Probabilistic Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=ig2wk7kK9J
|
[
"Wei Xiao",
"Tsun-Hsuan Wang",
"Chuang Gan",
"Ramin Hasani",
"Mathias Lechner",
"Daniela Rus"
] |
Poster
|
Diffusion models have shown promise in data-driven planning. While these planners are commonly employed in applications where decisions are critical, they still lack established safety guarantees. In this paper, we address this limitation by introducing SafeDiffuser, a method to equip diffusion models with safety guarantees via control barrier functions. The key idea of our approach is to embed finite-time diffusion invariance, i.e., a form of specification consisting of safety constraints, into the denoising diffusion procedure. This way we enable data generation under safety constraints. We show that SafeDiffusers maintain the generative performance of diffusion models while also providing robustness in safe data generation. We evaluate our method on a series of tasks, including maze path generation, legged robot locomotion, and 3D space manipulation, and demonstrate the advantages of robustness over vanilla diffusion models.
|
Diffusion model, Safety guarantees, Planning and control
|
We propose a new method to ensure diffusion probabilistic models satisfy specifications by using a control theoretic method
| 13,531 |
2306.00148
|
[
-0.02108863927423954,
-0.01760890521109104,
-0.03876468911767006,
0.061692096292972565,
0.07624717056751251,
0.024194393306970596,
0.023069249466061592,
-0.04037608951330185,
-0.018089503049850464,
-0.07209896296262741,
-0.004095269832760096,
-0.03487665206193924,
-0.05296465381979942,
-0.003913062624633312,
-0.0009933564579114318,
0.06378095597028732,
0.010369081981480122,
-0.01576559990644455,
-0.009095659479498863,
0.018992451950907707,
-0.020198378711938858,
-0.02385796047747135,
0.01697237603366375,
0.014854195527732372,
0.021577300503849983,
0.013293788768351078,
0.024831732735037804,
-0.0006276940694078803,
-0.026471884921193123,
-0.013330990448594093,
0.03705146163702011,
-0.006393030751496553,
0.011010857298970222,
-0.031016111373901367,
0.007633234839886427,
0.009174566715955734,
-0.044520650058984756,
0.002987521467730403,
-0.020504221320152283,
-0.009986378252506256,
-0.03165629506111145,
0.04353553429245949,
-0.0228281170129776,
-0.011073113419115543,
-0.04266832768917084,
-0.010851390659809113,
-0.0647684782743454,
-0.0032569647300988436,
0.014242532663047314,
-0.047177400439977646,
-0.10035259276628494,
0.05153738707304001,
0.019353410229086876,
0.016838572919368744,
-0.012330352328717709,
0.011275765486061573,
0.067625492811203,
-0.08965915441513062,
0.0014086453011259437,
-0.0668041780591011,
-0.01676144078373909,
0.01695125177502632,
0.00040099769830703735,
-0.005043363198637962,
-0.01178947277367115,
-0.007884680293500423,
0.011744322255253792,
0.04593266174197197,
-0.0012798322131857276,
-0.021485991775989532,
-0.0373830646276474,
0.009636258706450462,
0.025053586810827255,
0.005751818884164095,
-0.0268139336258173,
-0.043001968413591385,
0.026780905202031136,
0.04255971312522888,
0.04487088322639465,
0.003433855716139078,
0.0390155203640461,
-0.0038482407107949257,
-0.01048815157264471,
0.04906351864337921,
0.03863372281193733,
-0.0016097556799650192,
-0.049355994910001755,
-0.004495035856962204,
-0.06215556338429451,
0.04294944927096367,
-0.03993283584713936,
-0.053507719188928604,
-0.0048018451780080795,
0.011465942487120628,
0.020461587235331535,
0.0130259795114398,
0.02729043923318386,
0.007480447646230459,
0.01667201891541481,
0.006397174205631018,
-0.03548305481672287,
-0.0186763983219862,
-0.02344248816370964,
-0.021124044433236122,
-0.09274465590715408,
-0.03668941929936409,
-0.04936160519719124,
0.00809005182236433,
0.026352519169449806,
0.00745529355481267,
-0.047120071947574615,
0.007491808384656906,
0.030423210933804512,
-0.03416138514876366,
-0.052653759717941284,
0.07187364995479584,
0.0280041191726923,
0.005771762225776911,
0.03290941193699837,
-0.0009750266908667982,
0.03390544280409813,
0.01491477619856596,
-0.022307632490992546,
0.0538424551486969,
-0.043329570442438126,
0.04262184724211693,
0.03476979583501816,
0.012793554924428463,
-0.008426733314990997,
-0.015034118667244911,
0.031063415110111237,
0.04332292452454567,
-0.012264234945178032,
-0.025052115321159363,
-0.009899307042360306,
-0.008026513271033764,
-0.009836696088314056,
0.06230371072888374,
-0.013247544877231121,
-0.023305170238018036,
0.009523734450340271,
-0.02069556713104248,
0.08082973957061768,
-0.03182370588183403,
0.05224430561065674,
-0.030745208263397217,
0.018170585855841637,
-0.017017826437950134,
-0.06148388609290123,
0.007451258599758148,
0.007127672899514437,
0.012969085946679115,
0.038693130016326904,
-0.06156150624155998,
-0.0016924506053328514,
0.03263523429632187,
0.03794403001666069,
-0.013124571181833744,
-0.01626945286989212,
-0.004828823730349541,
0.0013085249811410904,
-0.011241289786994457,
-0.02919129654765129,
-0.048340823501348495,
-0.0061808484606444836,
-0.04707902669906616,
0.027325326576828957,
0.02389276586472988,
-0.0011354915332049131,
-0.036948300898075104,
-0.019191302359104156,
-0.028916098177433014,
0.045258332043886185,
0.006559391506016254,
0.010597890242934227,
-0.010804110206663609,
0.04764310270547867,
-0.011527280323207378,
0.033154379576444626,
0.02213115617632866,
-0.07215394079685211,
0.004971805028617382,
0.00804765522480011,
0.026499632745981216,
0.022232886403799057,
-0.042060524225234985,
0.069240503013134,
-0.02810453064739704,
0.01192457228899002,
0.017680900171399117,
-0.06889194995164871,
-0.027639273554086685,
0.04009835422039032,
-0.02524692192673683,
0.037081316113471985,
0.008574272505939007,
-0.0075300149619579315,
-0.0021401536650955677,
0.021185629069805145,
0.09126249700784683,
0.05534854158759117,
-0.02275613695383072,
0.04892072081565857,
-0.00968956295400858,
-0.003793923882767558,
-0.003196320030838251,
0.04084070399403572,
-0.03737456724047661,
-0.028196578845381737,
0.01534206047654152,
-0.011563612148165703,
0.0012707358691841364,
0.02684376761317253,
-0.011536668986082077,
0.028398433700203896,
0.01615099050104618,
-0.00880589708685875,
0.015117472968995571,
0.022556807845830917,
-0.05919012054800987,
0.01404417585581541,
0.012438655830919743,
-0.03726915642619133,
0.0014382287627086043,
-0.01893206313252449,
0.0913432165980339,
0.0926889032125473,
-0.03498780354857445,
-0.024452462792396545,
0.010044834576547146,
-0.021880673244595528,
0.002546062460169196,
0.008637581951916218,
-0.010616498999297619,
0.04744848608970642,
-0.030519671738147736,
0.022891908884048462,
-0.01167296152561903,
0.055643703788518906,
-0.03774546459317207,
-0.002107073785737157,
0.06635759770870209,
-0.009614505805075169,
0.07480716705322266,
0.014603559859097004,
0.03820258378982544,
0.05683646723628044,
-0.010239895433187485,
-0.014946081675589085,
0.00004635998629964888,
-0.024149984121322632,
0.0046597630716860294,
0.0812770202755928,
-0.010549846105277538,
-0.013130910694599152,
-0.07038349658250809,
0.02425423264503479,
-0.0212696585804224,
0.07399725914001465,
0.06170959770679474,
0.0518537275493145,
0.012999068014323711,
-0.004681963007897139,
-0.006048207636922598,
-0.01756409741938114,
-0.11552849411964417,
-0.027500391006469727,
0.0018593325512483716,
0.027483170852065086,
0.065340057015419,
0.03497186303138733,
-0.032561589032411575,
0.04568206146359444,
-0.008213800378143787,
-0.018689539283514023,
0.005638744216412306,
0.011293052695691586,
0.03845997154712677,
-0.022445233538746834,
-0.00679585337638855,
0.030870860442519188,
0.08800490200519562,
-0.0023468132130801678,
-0.009704094380140305,
0.010066899470984936,
-0.01920601911842823,
0.03959484398365021,
-0.03016556240618229,
-0.027099769562482834,
0.04600030928850174,
0.013765867799520493,
-0.010417954064905643,
-0.019502010196447372,
0.028914742171764374,
0.029696999117732048,
0.05139850080013275,
0.008684535510838032,
-0.00014845962869003415,
-0.017504917457699776,
0.021760012954473495,
0.013921528123319149,
0.0007961362134665251,
0.0059228804893791676,
0.004191793501377106,
-0.006742286030203104,
-0.016745951026678085,
0.02107473462820053,
-0.010088220238685608,
-0.2592533230781555,
-0.0003942158364225179,
-0.0022562865633517504,
-0.02929597534239292,
0.008787109516561031,
0.05162147060036659,
0.056243646889925,
-0.007947228848934174,
-0.020425373688340187,
0.010452046990394592,
0.023225493729114532,
0.019425610080361366,
0.024374935775995255,
0.04665593057870865,
0.055926986038684845,
-0.0034293693024665117,
0.007384022697806358,
-0.03661957383155823,
-0.009199327789247036,
0.008713980205357075,
-0.03699884191155434,
-0.08093398064374924,
-0.038071464747190475,
0.00538997957482934,
-0.0004048207774758339,
0.02946499176323414,
-0.05795716866850853,
0.001492466893978417,
-0.04362703114748001,
0.01421415340155363,
0.0036263696383684874,
-0.028019504621624947,
-0.042640380561351776,
-0.016786493360996246,
0.011993678286671638,
0.01248252484947443,
-0.005534221418201923,
0.037511833012104034,
0.024832282215356827,
0.01003169920295477,
0.03744683787226677,
-0.007172482553869486,
-0.054513998329639435,
-0.007513980381190777,
0.045503728091716766,
0.0034535168670117855,
-0.03152919560670853,
0.02417454868555069,
0.01099114678800106,
0.01865288056433201,
0.0226264800876379,
-0.02269543893635273,
0.019294241443276405,
0.002482150448486209,
0.024947691708803177,
-0.016828782856464386,
0.005382942967116833,
-0.014763416722416878,
0.006842713337391615,
0.03967512398958206,
0.02153269574046135,
-0.039577435702085495,
-0.030374685302376747,
-0.028407923877239227,
-0.005871990695595741,
-0.02583855763077736,
-0.04004019498825073,
-0.05479001626372337,
0.0258786641061306,
-0.017357109114527702,
-0.025497572496533394,
-0.03142726421356201,
0.010293582454323769,
-0.11773992329835892,
0.0030731752049177885,
0.033319052308797836,
0.01033404003828764,
-0.06625214219093323,
0.029856840148568153,
0.023466965183615685,
-0.058780234307050705,
-0.02508826181292534,
-0.009797981940209866,
0.03590288758277893,
-0.0029227240011096,
-0.004401679616421461,
0.031032638624310493,
-0.050230737775564194,
-0.024025676771998405,
-0.05076416954398155,
0.04133957624435425,
0.007419886067509651,
0.03936634212732315,
-0.02149835415184498,
0.05178413540124893,
0.04105493798851967,
0.011213807389140129,
0.035666417330503464,
0.027949446812272072,
-0.01895507238805294,
0.023546256124973297,
-0.08826318383216858,
-0.01946386881172657,
-0.06572319567203522,
-0.004177701193839312,
0.030189460143446922,
-0.060146573930978775,
-0.020113172009587288,
0.03637784346938133,
0.006348750088363886,
-0.0003260876692365855,
-0.005110456608235836,
0.02074331045150757,
-0.016494806855916977,
-0.018478697165846825,
-0.031140349805355072,
-0.0008551046485081315,
0.04296434298157692,
0.027322974056005478,
0.000016234598660958,
-0.056979116052389145,
0.022136451676487923,
-0.047283221036195755,
0.040251657366752625,
-0.003993188962340355,
0.01103487703949213,
-0.002931277733296156,
-0.012248886749148369,
0.06180734932422638,
-0.006490572355687618,
0.022690044716000557,
0.08024140447378159,
0.0023794742301106453,
0.008994648233056068,
0.043632157146930695,
-0.03128676116466522,
-0.039321038872003555,
-0.0008895139908418059,
0.019207393750548363,
-0.022711144760251045,
-0.014749083667993546,
0.01622368022799492,
0.036118753254413605,
-0.000394960748963058,
0.03732606768608093,
0.017500676214694977,
0.025793544948101044,
0.009333599358797073,
0.03749433904886246,
-0.04352926090359688,
0.017038030549883842,
-0.05523817241191864,
0.01453970093280077,
-0.046566713601350784,
0.015489841811358929,
-0.05103384703397751,
0.023304065689444542,
-0.02631508558988571,
0.00608131755143404,
-0.056447770446538925,
0.0577649250626564,
0.024141639471054077,
-0.05003064498305321,
-0.009982381947338581,
0.00009753934864420444,
0.06764411181211472,
-0.054182250052690506,
-0.021423224359750748,
-0.02853487804532051,
-0.02493952587246895,
0.02235342562198639,
-0.05109810084104538,
-0.051642633974552155,
0.0025702842976897955,
-0.009440666995942593,
0.016210179775953293,
-0.020045382902026176,
-0.0326959565281868,
-0.05987505242228508,
0.02750791423022747,
-0.00004929639908368699,
0.005020931363105774,
-0.01725172810256481,
-0.006439780816435814,
0.059013206511735916,
-0.027067184448242188,
0.005676342640072107,
-0.01960991509258747,
-0.017748070880770683,
0.018097884953022003,
-0.02600516751408577,
0.023579170927405357,
-0.03693774715065956,
-0.024477887898683548,
-0.02280556596815586,
-0.046397410333156586,
0.014529827050864697,
0.016925005242228508,
-0.03588631749153137,
-0.0019635881762951612,
-0.018869450315833092,
-0.009745540097355843,
-0.0135433254763484,
0.025956885889172554,
0.012459861114621162,
-0.04638373479247093,
0.0017271310789510608,
0.05897698551416397,
0.02423371747136116,
0.029641663655638695,
-0.03644503653049469,
-0.005387850105762482,
-0.042020149528980255,
-0.036582864820957184,
-0.00527949258685112,
-0.016721908003091812,
-0.016604596748948097,
-0.031807150691747665,
-0.010537770576775074,
0.017562150955200195,
0.020433565601706505,
-0.014628395438194275,
-0.01653253100812435,
-0.004008783958852291,
-0.007444731425493956,
0.04339416325092316,
-0.05204423889517784,
-0.02130800113081932,
0.030163545161485672,
-0.02585817500948906,
-0.0009223207016475499,
-0.05997809022665024,
0.02420482598245144,
0.003704710630699992,
-0.008191465400159359,
0.015254060737788677,
-0.029179122298955917,
0.03580985218286514,
-0.03988892212510109,
-0.008056074380874634,
-0.005865865852683783,
0.020526347681879997,
-0.005152687896043062,
-0.02396375685930252,
0.018039850518107414,
0.04549238830804825,
-0.010608434677124023,
-0.02976677380502224,
0.02809750661253929,
0.026942113414406776,
-0.0004907032707706094,
-0.002539512002840638,
-0.060716550797224045,
0.0033931704238057137,
0.028157439082860947,
-0.0046486384235322475,
-0.04445589333772659,
-0.08771294355392456,
-0.013642747886478901,
0.013673697598278522,
-0.014010998420417309,
0.037117794156074524,
-0.029748035594820976,
0.004231447819620371,
0.012877685017883778,
0.03323538973927498,
0.01014536153525114,
-0.03145906701683998,
0.03255567327141762,
-0.09920480102300644,
0.028295697644352913,
-0.04665635526180267,
0.04809468984603882,
0.05933871120214462,
-0.06030893698334694,
0.001165300840511918,
0.026341985911130905,
-0.016391843557357788,
0.0256609208881855,
-0.05794733390212059,
-0.08142280578613281,
0.034669335931539536,
-0.023651961237192154,
-0.03126124292612076,
0.015094052068889141,
-0.03768680989742279,
-0.02259170450270176,
0.0038608007598668337,
-0.06662184000015259,
0.046275004744529724,
0.029391881078481674,
0.014594432897865772,
-0.037748705595731735,
0.024362435564398766,
-0.00987948663532734,
0.018164413049817085,
0.014726189896464348,
0.04382263496518135,
-0.0005812051822431386,
0.038896750658750534,
-0.034509070217609406,
0.0803665965795517,
0.050002314150333405,
0.030525073409080505,
0.022654514759778976,
0.028140757232904434,
0.03688300773501396,
-0.03876921907067299,
0.024792948737740517,
0.02475641667842865,
-0.0018159957835450768,
-0.076115682721138,
0.07393239438533783,
0.04638288915157318,
-0.07339557260274887,
-0.036657482385635376,
0.016550879925489426,
-0.06488753110170364,
0.02908407896757126,
0.004440098535269499,
0.019390171393752098,
0.029849784448742867,
0.05049457773566246,
-0.011563938111066818,
0.031099669635295868,
0.05419258400797844,
0.017832083627581596,
0.004349108785390854,
-0.021051594987511635,
0.06611443310976028,
0.05405886098742485,
0.0507977120578289,
-0.041553597897291183,
0.047797027975320816,
-0.045668505132198334,
-0.04398604482412338,
-0.006295009516179562,
0.005832123104482889,
-0.016940200701355934,
-0.050785332918167114,
0.028714584186673164,
0.06920736283063889,
-0.005018820054829121,
0.05931974947452545,
-0.03187302500009537,
-0.0005569551722146571,
0.030903436243534088,
0.02251448854804039,
0.0008470861939713359,
0.020098911598324776,
0.049102894961833954,
0.005645615980029106,
-0.00881224311888218,
-0.0013645021244883537,
-0.00038455650792457163,
-0.00602318998426199,
0.029597463086247444,
0.006346824113279581,
0.00427263556048274,
0.009080841206014156,
0.022043175995349884,
0.011321372352540493,
0.10676731914281845,
-0.054835788905620575,
-0.012561381794512272,
-0.024562735110521317,
-0.010318437591195107,
-0.00756031321361661,
0.02149653434753418,
0.057315777987241745,
0.0040907771326601505,
0.0134761156514287,
-0.05767166614532471,
0.0187541451305151,
0.018530694767832756,
-0.0024434456136077642,
0.04741230234503746,
-0.052694592624902725,
0.0038477107882499695,
0.03062751702964306,
-0.010587036609649658,
-0.021092817187309265,
-0.036505840718746185,
-0.01738344132900238,
-0.022557346150279045,
-0.08164046704769135,
-0.025350673124194145,
0.026568520814180374,
-0.005041620694100857,
-0.07032009959220886,
0.022077329456806183,
-0.02156900428235531,
0.0037578456103801727,
0.009482999332249165,
-0.04987329617142677,
-0.02424943447113037,
0.09066236019134521,
0.02911103330552578,
0.012678244151175022,
0.026303689926862717,
0.040340133011341095,
0.005537004675716162,
-0.029808811843395233,
-0.0006527952500618994,
0.0016614896012470126,
0.051581867039203644,
-0.01517095323652029,
-0.01393849030137062,
-0.06882403045892715,
-0.0009516721474938095,
0.050372835248708725,
-0.026165714487433434,
-0.09576225280761719,
0.04239000380039215,
-0.05479457229375839,
0.029322179034352303,
0.047479089349508286,
-0.008671433664858341,
0.0022434850689023733,
-0.029967712238430977,
0.0053328946232795715,
0.0005074508371762931,
-0.011196163482964039,
0.025822190567851067,
-0.06365565210580826,
0.06096601486206055,
0.05630031228065491,
-0.06067269295454025,
-0.031656473875045776,
0.06803810596466064,
-0.0003980867622885853,
-0.035900577902793884,
-0.0031516586896032095,
-0.032370954751968384,
-0.026951519772410393,
-0.11734306067228317,
-0.0001528989232610911,
0.01878511533141136,
0.007290021050721407,
-0.033386386930942535,
-0.0026337874587625265,
-0.0024703966919332743,
0.013888952322304249,
-0.02453102543950081,
-0.06300239264965057,
-0.027052070945501328,
-0.03157643973827362,
0.003938836976885796,
-0.05862785503268242,
0.0544431246817112,
-0.02045978605747223,
0.013885429129004478,
-0.024635497480630875,
-0.04565448686480522,
0.03424672782421112,
-0.012462636455893517,
0.014943002723157406,
-0.03019816242158413,
0.025388607755303383,
0.015748804435133934
] |
317 |
BrainACTIV: Identifying visuo-semantic properties driving cortical selectivity using diffusion-based image manipulation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=CGON8Btleu
|
[
"Diego Garcia Cerdas",
"Christina Sartzetaki",
"Magnus Petersen",
"Gemma Roig",
"Pascal Mettes",
"Iris Groen"
] |
Poster
|
The human brain efficiently represents visual inputs through specialized neural populations that selectively respond to specific categories. Advancements in generative modeling have enabled data-driven discovery of neural selectivity using brain-optimized image synthesis. However, current methods independently generate one sample at a time, without enforcing structural constraints on the generations; thus, these individual images have no explicit point of comparison, making it hard to discern which image features drive neural response selectivity. To address this issue, we introduce Brain Activation Control Through Image Variation (BrainACTIV), a method for manipulating a reference image to enhance or decrease activity in a target cortical region using pretrained diffusion models. Starting from a reference image allows for fine-grained and reliable offline identification of optimal visuo-semantic properties, as well as producing controlled stimuli for novel neuroimaging studies. We show that our manipulations effectively modulate predicted fMRI responses and agree with hypothesized preferred categories in established regions of interest, while remaining structurally close to the reference image. Moreover, we demonstrate how our method accentuates differences between brain regions that are selective to the same category, and how it could be used to explore neural representation of brain regions with unknown selectivities. Hence, BrainACTIV holds the potential to formulate robust hypotheses about brain representation and to facilitate the production of naturalistic stimuli for neuroscientific experiments.
|
brain, selectivity, visual cortex, fMRI, manipulation, variation, diffusion, neuroscience
|
BrainACTIV manipulates a reference image to drive or suppress activity in a target brain region using pretrained diffusion models, providing insights into neural selectivity for experimental purposes.
| 13,524 | null |
[
-0.0003054440312553197,
0.017871491611003876,
0.02220729924738407,
0.014757798984646797,
0.04032624885439873,
0.02567218244075775,
0.031235313042998314,
0.025942362844944,
-0.03908255323767662,
-0.05722629651427269,
-0.04141678288578987,
-0.0014144126325845718,
-0.04840314760804176,
0.0029421928338706493,
-0.011023181490600109,
0.04852573573589325,
0.03267183154821396,
0.0029383718501776457,
-0.011248302645981312,
0.016054341569542885,
0.0011347020044922829,
-0.021748965606093407,
0.03493691608309746,
0.030290955677628517,
0.04134334996342659,
-0.018575377762317657,
0.010715337470173836,
-0.028452662751078606,
0.011573608964681625,
-0.027647461742162704,
-0.004677366930991411,
0.010194115340709686,
-0.013532958924770355,
-0.011878041550517082,
0.01975352130830288,
0.00898002553731203,
-0.030388934537768364,
-0.004522665869444609,
-0.00955558754503727,
0.003283457364886999,
-0.06975537538528442,
0.008482933044433594,
-0.01635342463850975,
-0.017859291285276413,
-0.06920216232538223,
0.02598077431321144,
-0.099164679646492,
0.04758134484291077,
-0.00968685932457447,
0.003160323016345501,
-0.047851964831352234,
0.021618343889713287,
0.02708616852760315,
-0.014800859615206718,
0.0042146979831159115,
0.03477693721652031,
0.03348058462142944,
-0.025094926357269287,
-0.004345786292105913,
-0.0898771733045578,
-0.01070017833262682,
0.021518971771001816,
0.0180711317807436,
-0.0066521731205284595,
0.006899758242070675,
-0.017814235761761665,
0.01621503010392189,
0.04212122783064842,
-0.03047102503478527,
-0.028327584266662598,
-0.031197460368275642,
-0.02358345128595829,
-0.004321842920035124,
-0.024520238861441612,
-0.002692704787477851,
-0.060272179543972015,
0.0015717758797109127,
0.016768114641308784,
0.049485575407743454,
-0.011464428156614304,
0.030907616019248962,
0.05218082666397095,
-0.027920551598072052,
0.03779606521129608,
0.005328894127160311,
-0.009111673571169376,
-0.0038649155758321285,
-0.020302461460232735,
-0.04488418996334076,
0.023785417899489403,
-0.049805156886577606,
-0.01160577591508627,
0.02946438081562519,
0.033194173127412796,
0.03082945942878723,
0.003071831539273262,
0.036416664719581604,
-0.02330794930458069,
0.007066050078719854,
0.016201114282011986,
-0.00359313259832561,
-0.027028745040297508,
0.02031858265399933,
0.006757843773812056,
-0.08460007607936859,
-0.018572473898530006,
-0.012043910101056099,
-0.05687844380736351,
-0.020073581486940384,
0.022220786660909653,
-0.036109551787376404,
-0.016968267038464546,
0.018543099984526634,
-0.007413618266582489,
-0.0729021430015564,
0.03492939844727516,
0.015417658723890781,
0.028263594955205917,
0.000166766214533709,
0.019890522584319115,
0.050750549882650375,
0.05970603600144386,
-0.018741169944405556,
0.05303744599223137,
-0.00776831666007638,
-0.027600238099694252,
0.012574481777846813,
0.03526485338807106,
-0.010867990553379059,
-0.04364589601755142,
0.02305309846997261,
0.015961457043886185,
-0.019647231325507164,
-0.008381516672670841,
0.004445321392267942,
0.005662835203111172,
0.05767840892076492,
-0.012272330932319164,
0.009620975703001022,
0.009777641855180264,
0.002598112914711237,
-0.042441774159669876,
0.013917085714638233,
-0.04983348026871681,
0.09309449791908264,
-0.04776432737708092,
0.011107536032795906,
-0.0007186000002548099,
-0.04309048131108284,
-0.01777082122862339,
0.033480845391750336,
0.00804173108190298,
0.0466226264834404,
-0.04366164654493332,
0.026491042226552963,
0.08418408781290054,
0.03274121508002281,
0.033120136708021164,
-0.0004622240667231381,
-0.015847353264689445,
0.02727692201733589,
-0.02684895694255829,
0.00031810798100195825,
-0.013412900269031525,
-0.013852613978087902,
-0.031997039914131165,
0.013995969668030739,
0.038337718695402145,
-0.05831534042954445,
0.004668109584599733,
-0.04989549517631531,
-0.032986197620630264,
0.02817009575664997,
0.002717189257964492,
-0.0009917326970025897,
0.0297430120408535,
0.024366382509469986,
0.01474155206233263,
0.03432879596948624,
0.04099840298295021,
-0.09534618258476257,
0.028077127411961555,
-0.009112616069614887,
-0.011438458226621151,
0.02285057306289673,
-0.029183683916926384,
0.05211571976542473,
-0.01292630285024643,
-0.007066001649945974,
0.0277839545160532,
-0.040492817759513855,
-0.03443128988146782,
0.012675993144512177,
-0.009738351218402386,
0.0809551551938057,
0.030548201873898506,
-0.026902848854660988,
0.03220720216631889,
0.055974237620830536,
0.049331288784742355,
0.05159115046262741,
-0.058676403015851974,
0.031874533742666245,
-0.025957470759749413,
-0.009682593867182732,
-0.03579622507095337,
0.04880981519818306,
-0.026639191433787346,
-0.020126963034272194,
0.019886992871761322,
-0.011805815622210503,
0.0051460363902151585,
0.002601328305900097,
0.0194450244307518,
0.03997001424431801,
-0.013895481824874878,
-0.024455325677990913,
0.04942609742283821,
-0.01242635864764452,
-0.05178403854370117,
0.0060739703476428986,
0.02762848138809204,
-0.021129431203007698,
0.018436023965477943,
-0.025526845827698708,
0.12147913873195648,
0.053749460726976395,
-0.06273328512907028,
-0.003995480947196484,
0.026464294642210007,
-0.004567926749587059,
0.034269992262125015,
-0.0004597468359861523,
0.004097673576325178,
-0.002837472828105092,
-0.03631214052438736,
0.03117525391280651,
-0.009171840734779835,
0.07571353018283844,
-0.07115332037210464,
-0.03423742204904556,
0.04056105390191078,
-0.005650505889207125,
0.033699825406074524,
-0.015575453639030457,
0.03383840247988701,
0.04736913740634918,
0.01353070791810751,
-0.020066427066922188,
-0.01286371424794197,
-0.01771494187414646,
0.009937194176018238,
-0.021645549684762955,
-0.021553033962845802,
0.042474422603845596,
-0.048471275717020035,
-0.013484122231602669,
-0.029112040996551514,
0.08087087422609329,
0.03875632956624031,
0.005072591360658407,
0.04359493404626846,
-0.020331110805273056,
-0.023562204092741013,
-0.020352164283394814,
-0.11083950847387314,
-0.016506830230355263,
-0.006210692226886749,
0.03262467309832573,
-0.020545322448015213,
0.053991593420505524,
-0.01370409969240427,
-0.0015750626334920526,
-0.01581309735774994,
-0.03345896303653717,
0.02386879362165928,
0.0030132236424833536,
0.0006158386240713298,
-0.02310314029455185,
-0.029686547815799713,
0.022624900564551353,
0.07102121412754059,
0.030554475262761116,
0.018179811537265778,
-0.030216379091143608,
-0.06463627517223358,
-0.029433738440275192,
0.021852999925613403,
-0.02111053466796875,
-0.002368290675804019,
0.021430494263768196,
0.011904655024409294,
0.013053348287940025,
0.041688911616802216,
0.0018394659273326397,
0.07162677496671677,
0.04823180288076401,
-0.004736879840493202,
-0.029640065506100655,
0.021056318655610085,
0.021840717643499374,
0.03980802744626999,
0.0042242249473929405,
-0.01643286645412445,
0.004790950566530228,
0.017190415412187576,
0.015304695814847946,
0.00019220095418859273,
-0.26475095748901367,
-0.009638638235628605,
-0.00706477789208293,
-0.005946346092969179,
0.02699120342731476,
-0.0009607040556147695,
0.04226335138082504,
-0.04213351011276245,
-0.020924286916851997,
0.019967153668403625,
-0.0020909023005515337,
0.008241591043770313,
-0.012084780260920525,
0.08352850377559662,
0.03744709491729736,
0.02410811558365822,
0.022193115204572678,
-0.0354483500123024,
0.0025493602734059095,
0.027194906026124954,
-0.02408117800951004,
-0.03991108387708664,
-0.025655103847384453,
0.05899092182517052,
-0.013688663952052593,
0.054059676826000214,
-0.054040465503931046,
0.0027630364056676626,
-0.011133280582726002,
-0.010796411894261837,
-0.018787873908877373,
-0.045065250247716904,
0.014966555871069431,
0.05525955557823181,
0.047254424542188644,
0.0026088764425367117,
0.018384728580713272,
-0.026763223111629486,
0.007036441471427679,
0.0008080396219156682,
-0.00029648651252500713,
-0.0013739269925281405,
-0.015684155747294426,
0.00990051869302988,
0.05708594247698784,
-0.0051805078983306885,
-0.04463859647512436,
-0.02384185418486595,
0.013218240812420845,
0.021760156378149986,
-0.012021242640912533,
-0.03121277131140232,
-0.039958126842975616,
0.034212373197078705,
-0.024146728217601776,
-0.013637963682413101,
0.023000016808509827,
-0.00017376724281348288,
-0.015229166485369205,
-0.005458756349980831,
-0.016409389674663544,
-0.0363740399479866,
-0.020802410319447517,
-0.004790181294083595,
-0.005616429727524519,
-0.016929086297750473,
-0.07091217488050461,
-0.06783498823642731,
0.06876085698604584,
0.04007919132709503,
0.0056236060336232185,
0.008332675322890282,
-0.027819687500596046,
-0.1008569598197937,
0.028960300609469414,
0.021938156336545944,
-0.020832907408475876,
-0.027772972360253334,
-0.039100728929042816,
0.006139092147350311,
-0.0006554867140948772,
-0.025007331743836403,
-0.011909793131053448,
0.03502843156456947,
-0.003392267506569624,
0.0006313456688076258,
0.05860110744833946,
0.00007342993194470182,
-0.049356620758771896,
-0.016766905784606934,
0.04727230593562126,
0.0077224052511155605,
0.010300688445568085,
-0.035359691828489304,
0.02256334386765957,
0.03820664435625076,
0.05689796432852745,
0.07799167186021805,
0.04980045184493065,
-0.015768174082040787,
0.04891040176153183,
-0.08849349617958069,
-0.02728165313601494,
-0.03296079486608505,
-0.053169604390859604,
0.019783789291977882,
-0.06316791474819183,
-0.026397326961159706,
0.06123189628124237,
-0.021714603528380394,
-0.022212428972125053,
0.030505020171403885,
0.016182029619812965,
-0.014749649912118912,
0.02756098471581936,
-0.01591198891401291,
0.005722540896385908,
0.013514070771634579,
0.03899506479501724,
-0.02677748166024685,
0.005126480013132095,
0.026301221922039986,
-0.03408205136656761,
0.0060805631801486015,
0.007113083265721798,
-0.0008887742296792567,
-0.020280204713344574,
-0.01066739484667778,
-0.021307388320565224,
0.028644710779190063,
0.0819086804986,
0.01738470233976841,
0.0037989583797752857,
0.0302116759121418,
0.04744033142924309,
-0.012248285114765167,
-0.0006818993715569377,
0.00211387500166893,
0.013486538082361221,
-0.054491493850946426,
0.04033397510647774,
-0.02599533088505268,
0.021224355325102806,
0.027379849925637245,
0.007898026145994663,
-0.007838175632059574,
-0.016618486493825912,
0.008994617499411106,
-0.08099091053009033,
-0.002223247429355979,
0.038839537650346756,
-0.04190342500805855,
-0.07864943146705627,
0.004101709462702274,
-0.00017911221948452294,
-0.029198171570897102,
0.004886948503553867,
-0.03091273084282875,
0.06426943838596344,
-0.06659302115440369,
0.017202505841851234,
-0.00818101316690445,
-0.00816288497298956,
0.014111765660345554,
0.005857930518686771,
0.05460885539650917,
-0.028103971853852272,
-0.012914393097162247,
0.012242879718542099,
-0.0038769247476011515,
0.047911230474710464,
-0.007535865064710379,
-0.014194218441843987,
-0.03237282112240791,
-0.01963111199438572,
0.015681220218539238,
0.0020687284413725138,
-0.042431268841028214,
-0.028276996687054634,
0.061364058405160904,
0.016220062971115112,
-0.0337039977312088,
0.01828460767865181,
-0.012481670826673508,
0.07699868828058243,
0.0178418830037117,
0.009993953630328178,
-0.017350561916828156,
-0.029711902141571045,
0.018356990069150925,
-0.03273756057024002,
0.014334011822938919,
-0.05844436585903168,
-0.04467271268367767,
-0.03802424296736717,
-0.021857021376490593,
-0.028890460729599,
-0.0027872752398252487,
-0.019151361659169197,
-0.0431058406829834,
0.007048822473734617,
0.027205782011151314,
-0.013097243383526802,
-0.005619097501039505,
0.04452378675341606,
-0.06481941044330597,
0.001564927864819765,
0.04731231555342674,
-0.04769650101661682,
0.027254236862063408,
-0.0189870186150074,
-0.0010457781609147787,
-0.05056034028530121,
-0.025270909070968628,
0.007777141407132149,
0.0006621976499445736,
-0.021084338426589966,
-0.059563953429460526,
-0.02644958719611168,
0.014524243772029877,
-0.0025944651570171118,
0.012869300320744514,
-0.0211251862347126,
-0.03301622346043587,
0.008441507816314697,
0.015591166913509369,
-0.018409159034490585,
-0.04568536579608917,
0.035032499581575394,
-0.015235926024615765,
-0.0062754652462899685,
-0.030349459499120712,
-0.008625754155218601,
0.04992971941828728,
-0.007648743689060211,
-0.03302497789263725,
-0.024202663451433182,
0.028252989053726196,
0.028077244758605957,
0.0070920283906161785,
0.029202817007899284,
-0.005291437264531851,
-0.05490081012248993,
0.006332356948405504,
0.02258293144404888,
0.026600748300552368,
-0.011876474134624004,
0.022502059116959572,
0.027762357145547867,
0.018919702619314194,
0.014171862974762917,
-0.005542938597500324,
-0.016880545765161514,
0.013803189620375633,
0.054925817996263504,
-0.030981283634901047,
-0.00013858132297173142,
-0.07043207436800003,
-0.0414372980594635,
0.010272794403135777,
0.021892819553613663,
0.041507501155138016,
-0.013314148411154747,
0.04992559924721718,
0.01744254119694233,
-0.006948241498321295,
-0.022075338289141655,
-0.017269670963287354,
0.019281946122646332,
-0.055636126548051834,
0.0215789545327425,
-0.05193227529525757,
-0.026359526440501213,
0.05580971762537956,
-0.07102756202220917,
-0.015669068321585655,
0.015158532187342644,
-0.032674238085746765,
0.042629122734069824,
-0.04647292196750641,
-0.048618827015161514,
0.03642812371253967,
-0.0034097786992788315,
-0.03630711883306503,
0.004351355601102114,
-0.07622577995061874,
0.0250052809715271,
-0.03220169246196747,
-0.056479476392269135,
-0.029826607555150986,
0.020259883254766464,
0.047055866569280624,
-0.014323744922876358,
-0.006497607566416264,
-0.021488096565008163,
0.0495121069252491,
0.03308092802762985,
0.07136398553848267,
-0.023473506793379784,
0.005641918163746595,
-0.00898709800094366,
0.07234270870685577,
0.02161344699561596,
0.03902177885174751,
0.008859993889927864,
0.00880389753729105,
-0.005510776769369841,
-0.04003966599702835,
0.03576510399580002,
-0.01970658451318741,
0.007621379103511572,
-0.0935920774936676,
0.06893474608659744,
0.028794225305318832,
-0.032456036657094955,
-0.004686804488301277,
0.0642910972237587,
-0.01238852459937334,
0.013836486265063286,
0.004304070957005024,
-0.00009383988799527287,
0.02187160588800907,
0.05192652344703674,
0.007947319187223911,
0.03187761828303337,
0.0708869993686676,
0.01132202334702015,
-0.01722344011068344,
0.020519929006695747,
0.05820241943001747,
0.060289718210697174,
0.06662936508655548,
0.029486818239092827,
0.11380542814731598,
-0.008486973121762276,
-0.06170063093304634,
0.02420402131974697,
0.01784961111843586,
-0.018231594935059547,
-0.011589987203478813,
-0.010801389813423157,
0.09483784437179565,
-0.013050581328570843,
0.04540577530860901,
-0.04758520796895027,
-0.007490175310522318,
0.026609007269144058,
0.022791100665926933,
-0.02717944234609604,
-0.008241399191319942,
0.07473341375589371,
-0.02725433185696602,
-0.029464786872267723,
0.01569696143269539,
-0.0393604040145874,
-0.027295483276247978,
0.01995142176747322,
-0.0026250670198351145,
-0.04514606297016144,
0.022982412949204445,
-0.020591704174876213,
0.030421976000070572,
0.09350385516881943,
-0.0065549034625291824,
0.004299329128116369,
-0.0004286823095753789,
0.010361521504819393,
0.03980840742588043,
0.03418159857392311,
-0.011515766382217407,
0.029907483607530594,
-0.008087290450930595,
-0.0009223297238349915,
0.01943926326930523,
0.028276728466153145,
0.023040907457470894,
0.013646659441292286,
-0.06746015697717667,
-0.014858289621770382,
0.005433198530226946,
0.015027363784611225,
-0.055715035647153854,
-0.06449561566114426,
-0.021382607519626617,
-0.04393940791487694,
-0.060433510690927505,
-0.01261103805154562,
0.029299361631274223,
-0.03942282125353813,
-0.053734179586172104,
-0.018315738067030907,
0.009274962358176708,
0.0015208135591819882,
0.03161373361945152,
-0.0732896700501442,
-0.02087024785578251,
0.0406583771109581,
-0.01728685013949871,
-0.017139144241809845,
0.01446838304400444,
0.03846379742026329,
-0.03584859147667885,
-0.03391509875655174,
0.047660622745752335,
-0.023812972009181976,
0.017461922019720078,
-0.031108830124139786,
-0.013934087939560413,
-0.11057578027248383,
0.0001208024550578557,
0.0003995215811301023,
-0.03090372122824192,
-0.08711627870798111,
0.0077780126594007015,
-0.0062614609487354755,
0.02256479486823082,
0.07500077784061432,
-0.00766382273286581,
0.018147943541407585,
-0.04949796572327614,
-0.014443290419876575,
0.023592904210090637,
-0.00423114700242877,
0.08435411006212234,
-0.030329611152410507,
0.07731971889734268,
0.048875704407691956,
0.003764715977013111,
-0.04570630565285683,
0.0044604637660086155,
-0.022274591028690338,
0.0011637263232842088,
-0.023327361792325974,
-0.02790422923862934,
-0.02995537407696247,
-0.132057324051857,
-0.040728483349084854,
0.010123444721102715,
-0.011752642691135406,
-0.030554188415408134,
-0.013512077741324902,
-0.015008315443992615,
0.011471787467598915,
-0.025052810087800026,
0.00013598502846434712,
-0.031632695347070694,
-0.0017087224405258894,
-0.041030798107385635,
-0.040684282779693604,
-0.01845581829547882,
-0.01258910447359085,
0.005593675654381514,
-0.017794473096728325,
-0.05037938803434372,
-0.021985074505209923,
0.0175155159085989,
0.015432608313858509,
0.00844489224255085,
0.05411367118358612,
-0.025246694684028625
] |
318 |
Efficient Online Reinforcement Learning Fine-Tuning Need Not Retain Offline Data
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=HN0CYZbAPw
|
[
"Zhiyuan Zhou",
"Andy Peng",
"Qiyang Li",
"Sergey Levine",
"Aviral Kumar"
] |
Poster
|
The modern paradigm in machine learning involves pre-training on diverse data, followed by task-specific fine-tuning. In reinforcement learning (RL), this translates to learning via offline RL on a diverse historical dataset, followed by rapid online RL fine-tuning using interaction data. Most RL fine-tuning methods require continued training on offline data for stability and performance. However, this is undesirable because training on diverse offline data is slow and expensive for large datasets, and should, in principle, also limit the performance improvement possible because of constraints or pessimism on offline data. In this paper, we show that retaining offline data is unnecessary as long as we use a properly-designed online RL approach for fine-tuning offline RL initializations. To build this approach, we start by analyzing the role of retaining offline data in online fine-tuning. We find that continued training on offline data is mostly useful for preventing a sudden divergence in the value function at the onset of fine-tuning, caused by a distribution mismatch between the offline data and online rollouts. This divergence typically results in unlearning and forgetting the benefits of offline pre-training. Our approach, Warm-start RL (WSRL), mitigates the catastrophic forgetting of pre-trained initializations using a very simple idea. WSRL employs a warmup phase that seeds the online RL run with a very small number of rollouts from the pre-trained policy to do fast online RL. The data collected during warmup bridges the distribution mismatch, and helps ``recalibrate'' the offline Q-function to the online distribution, allowing us to completely discard offline data without destabilizing the online RL fine-tuning. We show that WSRL is able to fine-tune without retaining any offline data, and is able to learn faster and attains higher performance than existing algorithms irrespective of whether they do or do not retain offline data.
|
Reinforcement learning, fast fine-tuning
|
We find that previous RL fine-tuning methods fail because of Q-divergence when no offline data is kept, and propose a new method WSRL that can finetune more efficiently with no data retention.
| 13,523 |
2412.07762
|
[
-0.024263419210910797,
-0.03839772939682007,
0.008748238906264305,
0.04154275357723236,
0.06173616647720337,
-0.0005991528159938753,
0.009164759889245033,
-0.014920804649591446,
-0.028286660090088844,
-0.026627635583281517,
-0.043493177741765976,
0.035155393183231354,
-0.07611878961324692,
-0.028455160558223724,
0.00786335114389658,
0.0524187833070755,
0.04962641000747681,
-0.025982148945331573,
0.011300835758447647,
0.00853645708411932,
-0.01579083316028118,
0.019040364772081375,
0.023036936298012733,
0.031789571046829224,
0.0032259109430015087,
0.011090153828263283,
0.019578566774725914,
0.010561209172010422,
-0.0198646392673254,
-0.008842169307172298,
0.05317011848092079,
-0.02220829576253891,
0.0162992961704731,
0.007406563498079777,
0.01733516901731491,
0.0006964526255615056,
-0.017485490068793297,
0.006190492305904627,
-0.0016499285120517015,
0.01586795412003994,
-0.04457559064030647,
0.03681210055947304,
-0.0249059796333313,
0.005713948514312506,
-0.011840755119919777,
-0.0019391435198485851,
-0.06931863725185394,
0.029172033071517944,
0.02215924859046936,
-0.040304116904735565,
-0.10699333250522614,
0.050670068711042404,
0.022364316508173943,
-0.016513032838702202,
-0.021485304459929466,
0.036590881645679474,
0.020834604278206825,
-0.07503458857536316,
0.0010163052938878536,
-0.06693960726261139,
-0.022811084985733032,
0.026265185326337814,
0.007251520175486803,
0.027579274028539658,
-0.025042586028575897,
-0.0028275237418711185,
0.02892635203897953,
0.04323713481426239,
-0.01918964833021164,
0.004063525702804327,
-0.04607732966542244,
-0.025753630325198174,
-0.011855448596179485,
0.0030388261657208204,
-0.0022957941982895136,
-0.025958731770515442,
0.018578268587589264,
0.02830818109214306,
0.07018416374921799,
0.004951695445924997,
0.008202134631574154,
0.013268303126096725,
0.02026343159377575,
0.026117080822587013,
0.0053881253115832806,
-0.010902614332735538,
-0.03546904772520065,
-0.046911537647247314,
-0.10296139121055603,
0.0428292341530323,
-0.05164451152086258,
-0.03519386798143387,
0.028993962332606316,
0.03711140900850296,
-0.007583527825772762,
0.009843813255429268,
-0.005305960774421692,
0.031368836760520935,
0.01597723737359047,
-0.004545329604297876,
-0.0703933835029602,
-0.019412634894251823,
0.011505295522511005,
-0.0316653847694397,
-0.10159850865602493,
-0.001909575774334371,
-0.007085919845849276,
-0.011580482125282288,
-0.007682590279728174,
0.04586965590715408,
-0.04475397989153862,
0.003084325697273016,
0.014252439141273499,
-0.033829592168331146,
-0.10054094344377518,
0.017606433480978012,
0.017058948054909706,
0.06984787434339523,
-0.009838209487497807,
0.0075183589942753315,
0.03373407572507858,
0.03166540339589119,
-0.02473156899213791,
0.06894925981760025,
-0.0013175582280382514,
-0.002241401933133602,
0.029973525553941727,
0.029170162975788116,
-0.03397980332374573,
-0.0546351782977581,
0.0654187947511673,
0.03742413967847824,
-0.0038901260122656822,
0.001965712523087859,
-0.02933155931532383,
0.02312103658914566,
-0.01979605294764042,
0.005506450776010752,
0.05309315398335457,
0.024735622107982635,
-0.02660459093749523,
-0.022283943369984627,
0.06856384873390198,
-0.018493222072720528,
0.06731290370225906,
-0.00764219556003809,
-0.01904384233057499,
-0.04392099753022194,
-0.057236943393945694,
-0.010806952603161335,
0.032232899218797684,
-0.02751351147890091,
-0.019314073026180267,
-0.05806265398859978,
0.03855576738715172,
0.06067458540201187,
0.016728248447179794,
0.0277453251183033,
-0.00012988293019589037,
0.00916803628206253,
0.015939386561512947,
0.012081538327038288,
0.009493536315858364,
-0.015509973280131817,
0.01512106228619814,
-0.06584370881319046,
0.05852871760725975,
0.015695882961153984,
0.008073917590081692,
0.0011008377186954021,
-0.04397093877196312,
-0.0329972505569458,
0.04664988070726395,
-0.0007446447270922363,
-0.042476557195186615,
0.004833235405385494,
0.043971166014671326,
0.0027002920396625996,
0.028878068551421165,
0.005927599035203457,
-0.08825452625751495,
0.02231028862297535,
0.008264428935945034,
0.011340166442096233,
-0.0031339924316853285,
-0.03237159922719002,
0.08408964425325394,
-0.019445549696683884,
0.019884394481778145,
0.005158782936632633,
-0.06971489638090134,
-0.01267189159989357,
0.019351638853549957,
-0.03152880817651749,
0.07669059932231903,
-0.005947957746684551,
-0.027984682470560074,
0.05608845502138138,
0.021752843633294106,
0.04806454852223396,
0.029023678973317146,
-0.022374548017978668,
0.02031160704791546,
-0.04094123840332031,
-0.03872760757803917,
-0.003283274592831731,
0.05101095885038376,
-0.054352257400751114,
0.00008695307042216882,
-0.006445595528930426,
-0.04393476992845535,
0.0019546158146113157,
-0.022117145359516144,
-0.002777993679046631,
0.002842106856405735,
0.03869497776031494,
-0.0239478200674057,
0.004869320895522833,
0.01611126773059368,
-0.059859536588191986,
0.038125380873680115,
0.0178297720849514,
-0.03511328995227814,
0.005283474922180176,
-0.051417429000139236,
0.0929715558886528,
0.06542366743087769,
-0.03626369312405586,
-0.020075200125575066,
0.02667161263525486,
-0.009036790579557419,
0.01635264977812767,
0.004090834408998489,
-0.04097067192196846,
0.021090278401970863,
-0.0040281061083078384,
-0.012127482332289219,
-0.024144189432263374,
0.05618078261613846,
-0.030945217236876488,
-0.015201171860098839,
0.06944841891527176,
0.01568121835589409,
0.06109181419014931,
0.02152966894209385,
0.022181987762451172,
0.024591557681560516,
0.005232882685959339,
-0.006247848737984896,
-0.018229661509394646,
-0.042274702340364456,
-0.0027333488687872887,
0.017536381259560585,
-0.01735619083046913,
0.015166761353611946,
-0.057813096791505814,
-0.028301255777478218,
-0.01212930679321289,
0.06139679253101349,
0.039502400904893875,
0.011708436533808708,
0.04025842621922493,
0.005182933993637562,
-0.01728435605764389,
0.01470592524856329,
-0.1067725419998169,
-0.045189257711172104,
0.0009478421998210251,
0.0572366900742054,
0.0331922248005867,
0.02236309088766575,
-0.009840055368840694,
0.03294287994503975,
-0.009833946824073792,
-0.04622991010546684,
-0.0032123804558068514,
0.021951928734779358,
-0.009195219725370407,
-0.02975522167980671,
-0.020283576101064682,
0.03296099230647087,
0.08736713975667953,
0.00996401160955429,
-0.0289569403976202,
-0.025126425549387932,
-0.03799854591488838,
0.0010546856792643666,
-0.031554605811834335,
-0.022645017132163048,
0.03274476155638695,
0.008854958228766918,
0.020826557651162148,
-0.038100987672805786,
0.030298667028546333,
0.03925320878624916,
0.0817447379231453,
0.02302500046789646,
0.0347239188849926,
0.014323634095489979,
0.02053144760429859,
-0.016980402171611786,
-0.007208280730992556,
-0.015277662314474583,
0.020442405715584755,
0.0013892326969653368,
-0.007024896331131458,
-0.011445335112512112,
0.008696961216628551,
-0.25649723410606384,
-0.03352402523159981,
0.026213260367512703,
0.014786136336624622,
0.04523938149213791,
0.0015530926175415516,
0.04971469193696976,
-0.024285247549414635,
-0.03343132138252258,
0.015167350880801678,
0.04798112064599991,
0.046667542308568954,
0.007197828497737646,
0.06026465818285942,
0.03223850205540657,
0.04225071147084236,
0.019427547231316566,
-0.013652389869093895,
0.015549435280263424,
0.01886792480945587,
-0.014610886573791504,
-0.0934121236205101,
-0.021703915670514107,
0.03607245907187462,
0.012661220505833626,
0.07449452579021454,
-0.06343517452478409,
-0.010904759168624878,
-0.03631998226046562,
-0.029102873057127,
-0.017616618424654007,
-0.03980183228850365,
-0.015367578715085983,
0.04442457854747772,
0.0414254330098629,
-0.013579820282757282,
0.03774980828166008,
-0.0066053071059286594,
0.03468270227313042,
0.021140217781066895,
-0.019731657579541206,
-0.008439464494585991,
-0.0083420155569911,
0.04161325842142105,
0.057600393891334534,
0.06334743648767471,
-0.0655091181397438,
-0.014422272332012653,
-0.004661619663238525,
0.047203429043293,
0.00099125225096941,
-0.031900856643915176,
-0.01354842260479927,
0.015283492393791676,
0.005378136411309242,
-0.03405769169330597,
-0.02384999394416809,
-0.01062898337841034,
-0.0028590925503522158,
-0.0015545411733910441,
0.010519728995859623,
-0.04513489082455635,
-0.030950011685490608,
-0.0340803824365139,
-0.009424109943211079,
-0.05637842416763306,
-0.05723787099123001,
-0.030962178483605385,
0.033727552741765976,
0.07083334773778915,
-0.01127837784588337,
-0.01295466162264347,
-0.021016955375671387,
-0.10250049084424973,
0.025811946019530296,
0.008077050559222698,
-0.022299982607364655,
-0.019561396911740303,
0.037323594093322754,
0.0631660744547844,
-0.017894528806209564,
-0.0264712106436491,
-0.003699986496940255,
-0.008297992870211601,
0.024489086121320724,
-0.0038454621098935604,
0.05404156073927879,
-0.0355168953537941,
-0.015451240353286266,
-0.01833035983145237,
0.052330244332551956,
-0.002856045262888074,
0.027654262259602547,
-0.01900106482207775,
0.07079584896564484,
0.04336686059832573,
0.023800842463970184,
0.03557271137833595,
0.042339276522397995,
0.013934004120528698,
0.020765123888850212,
-0.0885118618607521,
0.0014015991473570466,
-0.057607416063547134,
-0.012246712110936642,
0.018474305048584938,
-0.0798424631357193,
-0.024141786620020866,
0.028934672474861145,
0.015417195856571198,
-0.004732686560600996,
-0.03745805472135544,
-0.02423393912613392,
-0.006019135005772114,
-0.004525316879153252,
-0.014544504694640636,
0.012667571194469929,
0.035977911204099655,
0.026595117524266243,
-0.03210226818919182,
-0.041943617165088654,
0.03550572693347931,
-0.013886647298932076,
0.0010514886816963553,
-0.010713492520153522,
-0.03615960851311684,
0.03645508363842964,
-0.017940714955329895,
0.0026695148553699255,
-0.010135119780898094,
0.026851609349250793,
0.03718632832169533,
-0.0009095979039557278,
0.032357409596443176,
0.055059563368558884,
-0.011418226175010204,
-0.032756026834249496,
0.005779966711997986,
0.04056448116898537,
-0.004997889045625925,
0.008985147811472416,
-0.0024693659506738186,
0.05339523404836655,
0.03790196776390076,
0.02487773820757866,
0.04212569072842598,
0.019236231222748756,
0.008619243279099464,
0.02631651796400547,
-0.019473431631922722,
0.03134169057011604,
-0.06866438686847687,
0.0034534973092377186,
-0.0446297861635685,
-0.0007396111614070833,
-0.023075314238667488,
0.031069599092006683,
-0.025401704013347626,
0.0010413010604679585,
-0.05796027556061745,
0.016407933086156845,
-0.02758181281387806,
-0.050889767706394196,
0.006745694205164909,
0.02563644014298916,
0.05653074383735657,
-0.008775884285569191,
-0.013379190117120743,
0.0035799986217170954,
0.005145213101059198,
0.0004513498570304364,
-0.01793966256082058,
-0.018492581322789192,
-0.03355247899889946,
-0.026090361177921295,
-0.03357679024338722,
0.007277072872966528,
-0.055340930819511414,
0.007978945039212704,
0.0038234898820519447,
0.003026452846825123,
-0.004315584432333708,
-0.028910649940371513,
0.004693147726356983,
0.07146847248077393,
-0.006886031478643417,
0.011049937456846237,
0.00414856243878603,
0.0013243677094578743,
0.015856681391596794,
-0.009849879890680313,
0.044892050325870514,
-0.017065739259123802,
-0.0327463299036026,
-0.011987999081611633,
-0.037378761917352676,
0.00921943224966526,
0.019542034715414047,
-0.028587767854332924,
0.019968032836914062,
-0.009632189758121967,
0.0024027845356613398,
-0.004982249345630407,
-0.011632412672042847,
0.025992413982748985,
-0.06447912752628326,
-0.016216453164815903,
0.032296277582645416,
-0.017900388687849045,
0.038312822580337524,
-0.07298646867275238,
-0.03634052351117134,
-0.021752649918198586,
-0.002924269763752818,
0.019241420552134514,
-0.02593042701482773,
-0.04148849844932556,
-0.0011725119547918439,
-0.014705846086144447,
-0.02344358153641224,
0.01809675246477127,
-0.00268534361384809,
-0.019454456865787506,
-0.012626325711607933,
-0.011241830885410309,
0.032311879098415375,
-0.018827006220817566,
-0.02678755484521389,
0.018442848697304726,
0.002259588800370693,
0.027018720284104347,
-0.04149400815367699,
0.00795288197696209,
0.03774157166481018,
-0.016214918345212936,
0.021582193672657013,
-0.06208290159702301,
0.07278423756361008,
0.002542086411267519,
-0.04076910763978958,
-0.02718300186097622,
0.002859806874766946,
-0.05133979395031929,
-0.004691892769187689,
-0.02906925603747368,
-0.004398843739181757,
-0.007065152283757925,
0.04555247724056244,
0.017961721867322922,
0.0027687714900821447,
0.0019511033315211535,
0.009842283092439175,
-0.020578093826770782,
-0.0011625094339251518,
0.04412514343857765,
-0.03786735236644745,
-0.018276726827025414,
-0.0703493282198906,
-0.030406290665268898,
0.04782582074403763,
-0.024394940584897995,
0.002735941903665662,
-0.057046324014663696,
0.012993855401873589,
0.01491115428507328,
0.03397328406572342,
0.03955911099910736,
-0.029089991003274918,
0.06756697595119476,
-0.06806058436632156,
0.03309178724884987,
-0.07243882119655609,
-0.013660924509167671,
0.06946359574794769,
-0.022805267944931984,
0.030199497938156128,
0.01801818422973156,
-0.026024922728538513,
0.03887346386909485,
-0.03553474694490433,
-0.09086751937866211,
0.026234472170472145,
-0.04363883659243584,
-0.04537564143538475,
0.046350959688425064,
-0.04774758964776993,
-0.03376893326640129,
-0.026267537847161293,
-0.038454245775938034,
0.009125500917434692,
-0.029521873220801353,
0.052195508033037186,
-0.03530701994895935,
-0.030528806149959564,
-0.03668488934636116,
0.024115730077028275,
0.005621755495667458,
0.01975218765437603,
0.011632244102656841,
0.032278724014759064,
-0.03455568850040436,
0.06053553894162178,
0.03212517499923706,
0.013253182172775269,
0.011572331190109253,
0.018741372972726822,
0.024071838706731796,
-0.012266892939805984,
0.047861021012067795,
-0.013901444151997566,
-0.004673775751143694,
-0.0456080362200737,
0.04230061545968056,
0.02500944398343563,
-0.06648426502943039,
0.0012409816263243556,
0.028198575600981712,
-0.03853020817041397,
-0.00376686779782176,
0.01575303263962269,
0.023359693586826324,
0.001684534945525229,
0.08091679960489273,
0.02058841846883297,
0.0381852425634861,
0.08462611585855484,
0.03820342198014259,
-0.007198682986199856,
-0.01083388552069664,
0.07532438635826111,
0.08615582436323166,
0.04822227731347084,
-0.025513796135783195,
0.05584532022476196,
-0.04245744273066521,
-0.05927613005042076,
0.03704160451889038,
-0.0011988556943833828,
-0.03182976320385933,
-0.03431209549307823,
0.019330095499753952,
0.047367386519908905,
-0.01659032143652439,
0.06242102012038231,
-0.05705363303422928,
-0.019361436367034912,
0.054859887808561325,
-0.00498751038685441,
-0.009268599562346935,
0.02757737971842289,
0.025969961658120155,
0.042224444448947906,
-0.014021271839737892,
-0.022236518561840057,
0.005072880070656538,
-0.016216346994042397,
0.01018567755818367,
-0.002046719193458557,
-0.04069044068455696,
-0.00283231632784009,
0.007670889608561993,
0.01891731098294258,
0.11569061130285263,
-0.05853820964694023,
-0.01146357785910368,
0.015499581582844257,
0.007049277424812317,
0.005170788150280714,
0.021359968930482864,
-0.010828412137925625,
-0.015916256234049797,
0.021606747061014175,
-0.022442100569605827,
0.019417880102992058,
0.026171380653977394,
-0.0018012769287452102,
0.01894601620733738,
-0.04985290765762329,
-0.0059172664768993855,
0.012414990924298763,
0.007489456795156002,
-0.03276439756155014,
-0.04118850827217102,
-0.02804320864379406,
-0.04594898223876953,
-0.049726035445928574,
-0.06050335243344307,
-0.003653113730251789,
-0.016762690618634224,
-0.03422630950808525,
0.0036653063725680113,
-0.029150433838367462,
0.0017602245789021254,
-0.01061414834111929,
-0.06982201337814331,
-0.0060697211883962154,
0.01820475235581398,
-0.023504432290792465,
0.04294483736157417,
0.0326167531311512,
0.028172755613923073,
-0.005296141374856234,
-0.023525098338723183,
0.03203167766332626,
-0.00206848606467247,
0.03600709140300751,
-0.00004724774771602824,
-0.011908839456737041,
-0.08701375126838684,
0.010007320903241634,
0.021031856536865234,
-0.02341081202030182,
-0.06920779496431351,
0.01158848311752081,
-0.024400005117058754,
0.010788093321025372,
0.06128736585378647,
-0.006348529364913702,
-0.0009506102069281042,
-0.029314318671822548,
-0.005513051990419626,
0.0023084855638444424,
0.0450756661593914,
0.04498232528567314,
-0.058616477996110916,
0.059288058429956436,
0.039221182465553284,
-0.022441020235419273,
-0.07090236991643906,
0.04096068814396858,
0.020400362089276314,
-0.032010700553655624,
-0.02182924933731556,
-0.04097611457109451,
-0.0035440041683614254,
-0.0972796231508255,
-0.027061400935053825,
0.048289742320775986,
0.013100270181894302,
-0.028418203815817833,
-0.019453376531600952,
-0.0032516622450202703,
-0.021135203540325165,
0.0025127113331109285,
-0.033926282078027725,
-0.002928361529484391,
-0.06837432831525803,
-0.01640000008046627,
-0.048873431980609894,
0.047866884618997574,
-0.03540372475981712,
0.0029089516028761864,
-0.026950446888804436,
-0.027796197682619095,
0.023271683603525162,
0.013241316191852093,
0.032074034214019775,
0.023547401651740074,
-0.004928667563945055,
-0.008719009347259998
] |
319 |
Making Text Embedders Few-Shot Learners
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=wfLuiDjQ0u
|
[
"Chaofan Li",
"Minghao Qin",
"Shitao Xiao",
"Jianlyu Chen",
"Kun Luo",
"Defu Lian",
"Yingxia Shao",
"Zheng Liu"
] |
Poster
|
Large language models (LLMs) with decoder-only architectures have demonstrated exceptional text-generation capabilities across a variety of tasks. Some researchers have also adapted these models for text representation tasks. However, in text representation tasks, these models often face performance degradation on unseen tasks. In-context learning (ICL), which leverages examples provided in the input context, enables LLMs to handle unseen tasks effectively. Inspired by this, we aim to fully utilize the inherent properties of LLMs to enhance text representation performance across different tasks through the ICL approach.
In this paper, we introduce a simple yet effective training strategy, which significantly improves text representation capabilities. Unlike previous models that prepend task instructions to the text, our method randomly samples a varying number of examples during training, endowing the embedding model with in-context learning abilities while maintaining its zero-shot capabilities. This approach does not require additional data construction or modifications to the model architecture. On the contrary, we find that some popular modifications to the model, such as bidirectional attention, can degrade performance, undermining the inherent characteristics of LLMs. We have publicly released our method at this \href{https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding}{repo}.
|
large language model, embedding model, in-context learning
| null | 13,517 |
2409.15700
|
[
-0.006511179264634848,
-0.006304183043539524,
-0.02696920745074749,
0.046350982040166855,
0.042687252163887024,
-0.0024553807452321053,
0.030084067955613136,
0.03590204566717148,
-0.02154303528368473,
0.021616816520690918,
-0.0382264144718647,
0.026668598875403404,
-0.05766956880688667,
-0.02358342707157135,
-0.009432823397219181,
0.06004258617758751,
0.02049155719578266,
-0.006056012120097876,
0.03188291937112808,
0.01253441907465458,
0.01106939185410738,
-0.004106713458895683,
0.036648236215114594,
0.008460020646452904,
0.032750535756349564,
0.02872628904879093,
0.025328904390335083,
-0.00928579457104206,
-0.046118829399347305,
0.009661504998803139,
0.02703399583697319,
-0.01514709647744894,
0.025570835918188095,
-0.031221747398376465,
0.017590094357728958,
-0.006813390180468559,
-0.05916966497898102,
0.014864769764244556,
0.023184185847640038,
-0.0051639205776154995,
-0.04941295459866524,
0.01834992878139019,
-0.0015119597082957625,
0.010380749590694904,
-0.04782823100686073,
0.009794034995138645,
-0.11260951310396194,
0.011250884272158146,
0.020421918481588364,
-0.045333582907915115,
-0.12169604748487473,
0.04812247306108475,
0.000518446322530508,
-0.005406539887189865,
0.022922566160559654,
0.03246361389756203,
0.05618970841169357,
-0.09142416715621948,
0.01733388565480709,
-0.02881733328104019,
-0.04499184712767601,
0.012436916120350361,
-0.0032953096088021994,
0.04187510162591934,
-0.0026795282028615475,
-0.038740966469049454,
-0.018010122701525688,
0.009123085997998714,
-0.07309531420469284,
-0.04396592825651169,
-0.028019392862915993,
0.025065481662750244,
-0.0323123037815094,
0.03295133262872696,
0.02007712982594967,
-0.05669240280985832,
0.013910269364714622,
0.048451825976371765,
0.07003004103899002,
0.02010524459183216,
0.007845908403396606,
0.013146549463272095,
0.03387445956468582,
0.02975989319384098,
0.005291332490742207,
0.0011822175001725554,
-0.03985094279050827,
-0.040393657982349396,
-0.05709207430481911,
0.01874656230211258,
-0.023565907031297684,
-0.062387581914663315,
0.020831367000937462,
0.030088577419519424,
0.043739452958106995,
0.02270647883415222,
0.012869063764810562,
0.04121033847332001,
-0.018331093713641167,
0.013779866509139538,
-0.032982442528009415,
-0.017657939344644547,
0.037278760224580765,
0.003039405681192875,
-0.12019472569227219,
-0.011778277345001698,
-0.014999505132436752,
-0.0017817955231294036,
0.007493957411497831,
-0.025644566863775253,
-0.027348877862095833,
-0.03347679600119591,
0.010140328668057919,
-0.010296091437339783,
-0.06244872882962227,
0.010950670577585697,
0.024751925840973854,
0.04908183217048645,
-0.021310212090611458,
0.010178890079259872,
0.030537722632288933,
0.06135142222046852,
0.034919317811727524,
0.061640139669179916,
-0.014636954292654991,
0.0173004399985075,
0.009601798839867115,
0.0052095032297074795,
-0.044673219323158264,
-0.032252512872219086,
0.004195047542452812,
0.04937192052602768,
-0.01984497159719467,
0.020618654787540436,
-0.006894007325172424,
-0.0005831474554724991,
0.010470587760210037,
0.005381853319704533,
0.04581820219755173,
-0.007446834351867437,
-0.0019080393249168992,
-0.02163790725171566,
0.055033303797245026,
-0.029386410489678383,
0.09331097453832626,
0.004644990433007479,
-0.04382888227701187,
-0.015609309077262878,
-0.02162761427462101,
-0.00802822969853878,
0.031651128083467484,
-0.03632602468132973,
0.003453426528722048,
-0.06156882643699646,
0.05794018507003784,
0.0723654255270958,
0.028612809255719185,
0.008802734315395355,
0.007498032413423061,
0.03187037631869316,
0.017244528979063034,
-0.005736103281378746,
-0.057637862861156464,
0.023652076721191406,
-0.010075071826577187,
-0.0837165117263794,
0.01675129495561123,
-0.00208836211822927,
-0.02332390658557415,
-0.014132543466985226,
-0.022153696045279503,
-0.0612090602517128,
0.05976934731006622,
-0.03465095907449722,
-0.011970873922109604,
-0.020106833428144455,
0.06746222823858261,
0.004981735721230507,
0.029545964673161507,
0.03284847363829613,
-0.07639776915311813,
0.05022846907377243,
0.018854038789868355,
-0.0008415250340476632,
0.00879640318453312,
-0.01582586206495762,
0.06910508871078491,
-0.01675347238779068,
-0.011090549640357494,
0.010019591078162193,
-0.08598833531141281,
-0.02508540451526642,
0.017427384853363037,
-0.006814547348767519,
0.06708779186010361,
-0.025475865229964256,
0.007884985767304897,
0.03659540042281151,
0.024055765941739082,
0.038292866200208664,
0.04424905776977539,
-0.012744421139359474,
0.036379843950271606,
-0.006490317638963461,
-0.02630864456295967,
0.0036957755219191313,
0.0168302059173584,
-0.0382540300488472,
-0.052268654108047485,
0.01284975465387106,
-0.0072405654937028885,
0.0010675076628103852,
0.034657642245292664,
-0.0029048779979348183,
-0.02650715410709381,
0.0025651368778198957,
-0.011429484002292156,
0.008061254397034645,
0.02761550433933735,
-0.05265907198190689,
0.04033779725432396,
0.005171714350581169,
-0.020329946652054787,
-0.0003456466947682202,
-0.03933468833565712,
0.10402149707078934,
0.0354628823697567,
-0.027747873216867447,
0.00036666193045675755,
-0.010779709555208683,
0.017618846148252487,
-0.02398296631872654,
0.00504786754027009,
-0.045525599271059036,
0.008332151919603348,
-0.013273770920932293,
-0.009984491392970085,
-0.035716839134693146,
0.04004722461104393,
-0.02612893655896187,
-0.018387259915471077,
0.09452138096094131,
-0.056799061596393585,
0.037691548466682434,
0.002027310896664858,
0.02355327643454075,
0.029314259067177773,
-0.017211565747857094,
-0.010844776406884193,
-0.03935188055038452,
0.001807155436836183,
-0.003907063044607639,
-0.024295354261994362,
-0.0252804234623909,
0.013351368717849255,
-0.02480716072022915,
-0.05336033180356026,
-0.009784705005586147,
0.06122176721692085,
0.03494412451982498,
-0.010476663708686829,
0.02520902454853058,
-0.0020669838413596153,
-0.02988540753722191,
0.01827661693096161,
-0.07286269217729568,
-0.015451591461896896,
-0.01663724146783352,
0.027289578691124916,
-0.011669306084513664,
0.03885931521654129,
0.009419552981853485,
0.009441346861422062,
-0.026784440502524376,
-0.012353884056210518,
0.0010556629858911037,
0.04440347105264664,
0.0070782797411084175,
-0.042472872883081436,
-0.023429419845342636,
-0.03462275490164757,
0.04218614101409912,
-0.013838629238307476,
-0.02595432847738266,
-0.02758610062301159,
-0.027806110680103302,
-0.021842993795871735,
-0.0542718730866909,
-0.02936777099967003,
0.02122756466269493,
0.032818753272295,
0.02419382892549038,
-0.016331695020198822,
0.00021664200176019222,
0.04344779625535011,
0.08124739676713943,
0.03736196458339691,
-0.008013037964701653,
-0.02628147415816784,
0.030722394585609436,
-0.028634347021579742,
0.009519072249531746,
0.017469115555286407,
0.03633982315659523,
-0.01696258783340454,
0.0023821794893592596,
0.017323866486549377,
-0.002377925906330347,
-0.2776671350002289,
-0.012151756323873997,
0.008151154033839703,
-0.03565989062190056,
0.03778119757771492,
-0.02779540605843067,
0.04257588088512421,
-0.02608724869787693,
-0.03288785740733147,
0.017875971272587776,
-0.002405297476798296,
0.05487076938152313,
-0.0045179277658462524,
0.0008755867020227015,
0.048476725816726685,
0.024191753938794136,
0.02540886402130127,
-0.02326003462076187,
-0.0027284722309559584,
0.04939171299338341,
0.006732662208378315,
-0.07360352575778961,
-0.02766554057598114,
0.05521636828780174,
-0.018357740715146065,
0.04422644153237343,
-0.09341789782047272,
0.002275619423016906,
-0.003643220756202936,
0.020002398639917374,
0.002647100482136011,
-0.03797287866473198,
-0.00006379107071552426,
0.010772068984806538,
-0.01422986201941967,
0.022496961057186127,
0.08427011966705322,
0.038014888763427734,
0.02190808765590191,
-0.0006544979405589402,
0.019711507484316826,
-0.022462135180830956,
-0.005519228056073189,
-0.027702847495675087,
0.07662416994571686,
-0.00695056701079011,
-0.07346989959478378,
-0.024900902062654495,
-0.01377180777490139,
0.03454785421490669,
-0.014565659686923027,
-0.0469515323638916,
-0.0019303588196635246,
0.030393654480576515,
0.028292037546634674,
-0.025006229057908058,
-0.0009049567161127925,
-0.02718111127614975,
-0.00618322566151619,
-0.026409229263663292,
-0.0023695204872637987,
-0.036870915442705154,
-0.05901721864938736,
-0.04348810389637947,
-0.00007539548823842779,
-0.029969463124871254,
-0.05812741816043854,
-0.059988800436258316,
0.0233222134411335,
0.055048804730176926,
-0.048517100512981415,
0.04483529552817345,
-0.009250018745660782,
-0.0810234397649765,
0.025658363476395607,
-0.013419314287602901,
0.001823471044190228,
-0.02456958219408989,
0.01837676391005516,
0.05279456079006195,
-0.056290462613105774,
-0.04932694882154465,
0.001058381050825119,
-0.004954429343342781,
0.0426710769534111,
-0.02790364809334278,
0.00821305438876152,
-0.03647204488515854,
-0.0038021255750209093,
-0.031797245144844055,
0.042919669300317764,
0.01212609838694334,
-0.007800173945724964,
0.05055855214595795,
0.037134673446416855,
0.019116882234811783,
0.028118707239627838,
0.05587207153439522,
0.04347514733672142,
0.02674296125769615,
0.011415176093578339,
-0.07238083332777023,
-0.02196275256574154,
-0.035994041711091995,
-0.029826994985342026,
0.047431621700525284,
-0.08581513166427612,
-0.0347941517829895,
0.03012959100306034,
-0.009442443028092384,
-0.036994945257902145,
-0.04968669265508652,
0.00389771512709558,
-0.00543265650048852,
-0.04487061873078346,
0.009830377995967865,
0.025097142904996872,
0.017927154898643494,
0.016917886212468147,
-0.03826246038079262,
-0.020235469564795494,
0.043611641973257065,
-0.0046604531817138195,
0.012203793041408062,
0.012273324653506279,
-0.022557485848665237,
0.011678599752485752,
-0.006735028233379126,
-0.007037841249257326,
-0.034212756901979446,
0.04245535284280777,
0.03040117770433426,
-0.0014468508306890726,
0.016424261033535004,
0.05303984880447388,
-0.026622874662280083,
0.025939512997865677,
-0.0015697969356551766,
0.026656582951545715,
-0.0035072723403573036,
-0.011382787488400936,
-0.008973303250968456,
0.027459001168608665,
0.035234421491622925,
0.03777647018432617,
0.004151395056396723,
-0.0013876190641894937,
0.03762451931834221,
-0.016430145129561424,
0.017346404492855072,
0.035745467990636826,
-0.04807429388165474,
-0.03273973986506462,
-0.005210691597312689,
0.020976832136511803,
-0.020542705431580544,
0.015422973781824112,
-0.0016597916837781668,
0.018212663009762764,
-0.06457667052745819,
0.04949593171477318,
0.0022150378208607435,
-0.01158098690211773,
0.02245309390127659,
0.01854068972170353,
0.030126478523015976,
-0.0016377036226913333,
0.017455561086535454,
0.056097276508808136,
0.011247973889112473,
0.021916478872299194,
-0.024612456560134888,
-0.04044162854552269,
0.0007462595240212977,
-0.03702333942055702,
0.017515745013952255,
-0.010732983238995075,
0.02969237044453621,
-0.024381032213568687,
0.026155883446335793,
0.02806626446545124,
-0.026726815849542618,
0.018313204869627953,
0.006430812645703554,
0.08844756335020065,
0.0030206134542822838,
0.03231967240571976,
0.00999602023512125,
-0.03575971722602844,
0.006380729377269745,
-0.016670191660523415,
0.01212537195533514,
0.004867919720709324,
-0.042491793632507324,
-0.043745007365942,
-0.040468305349349976,
0.006640113890171051,
0.01553342305123806,
0.003984441049396992,
-0.006462396588176489,
-0.03868772089481354,
0.00009066992060979828,
-0.06290896981954575,
-0.0045886714942753315,
0.01173481997102499,
-0.08505334705114365,
0.0035933314356952906,
-0.009823235683143139,
-0.014939526095986366,
0.012025927193462849,
-0.031741827726364136,
-0.03646840900182724,
-0.05207432433962822,
-0.017003944143652916,
0.02589109167456627,
-0.03487446904182434,
-0.017108064144849777,
-0.03408195823431015,
0.0015383540885522962,
-0.014353643171489239,
0.0023868184071034193,
-0.009535351768136024,
-0.016572173684835434,
-0.021616816520690918,
-0.005635019391775131,
0.06113330274820328,
-0.02546248957514763,
-0.02250717394053936,
-0.0021505358163267374,
-0.03424813225865364,
0.04168300703167915,
-0.03434689715504646,
0.0729418694972992,
0.06599253416061401,
-0.03820561245083809,
0.014790983870625496,
-0.0314507894217968,
0.033783938735723495,
0.01429399847984314,
-0.00293784704990685,
0.007847070693969727,
-0.014049472287297249,
-0.041353289037942886,
0.03265723958611488,
0.012714453041553497,
0.02609206736087799,
0.01261238381266594,
0.00889069028198719,
-0.025875570252537727,
0.03398839011788368,
0.030492903664708138,
0.027136962860822678,
-0.03543081134557724,
-0.01626497693359852,
0.06789906322956085,
-0.012340523302555084,
-0.04622599110007286,
-0.0532621368765831,
-0.03477653115987778,
0.027607470750808716,
0.011323334649205208,
0.03156888857483864,
-0.05277564376592636,
0.0655050203204155,
0.04055606946349144,
0.0337829627096653,
0.02093699388206005,
-0.03382726386189461,
0.04682859405875206,
-0.023231592029333115,
-0.015594356693327427,
-0.07577811926603317,
-0.03796539828181267,
0.05059574916958809,
-0.011818342842161655,
0.004827326629310846,
0.003661134047433734,
-0.031242122873663902,
0.036452047526836395,
-0.007309250999242067,
-0.06326070427894592,
0.00018232407455798239,
-0.0191558375954628,
0.023897966369986534,
0.032346393913030624,
-0.011263076215982437,
-0.010955561883747578,
-0.02476448379456997,
-0.04207497835159302,
-0.027850473299622536,
0.007991783320903778,
0.06274339556694031,
-0.04101292043924332,
0.006766174919903278,
-0.010400451719760895,
0.0034104418009519577,
0.011708029545843601,
0.04891738295555115,
0.04615486413240433,
0.0353507362306118,
-0.015167039819061756,
0.05874697118997574,
0.01048875693231821,
-0.015814146026968956,
0.004143775440752506,
-0.010197693482041359,
-0.038535114377737045,
-0.05741235241293907,
0.052257075905799866,
0.003277586540207267,
0.004583390429615974,
-0.04271060228347778,
0.06909666210412979,
0.042480792850255966,
-0.010318873450160027,
-0.04435786232352257,
0.026521747931838036,
-0.05176524072885513,
-0.0003768322931136936,
-0.0032703951001167297,
0.006078572943806648,
-0.029124537482857704,
0.0707189291715622,
0.03751661628484726,
0.011903028003871441,
0.06313680857419968,
0.002090710448101163,
-0.02542457915842533,
-0.016281357035040855,
0.03923999145627022,
0.053369950503110886,
0.060103897005319595,
0.020911427214741707,
0.05599345266819,
-0.04755612835288048,
-0.046989019960165024,
0.0092162461951375,
0.012862902134656906,
0.0004189613100606948,
-0.05388501659035683,
0.007825683802366257,
0.07114572077989578,
-0.00930467527359724,
0.05492968484759331,
-0.02353978157043457,
-0.009807992726564407,
0.03766750916838646,
0.009657119400799274,
-0.006393346469849348,
0.0625116154551506,
0.03347894176840782,
0.02642207406461239,
-0.050900209695100784,
-0.019317004829645157,
0.003412073478102684,
-0.03640471026301384,
0.028037402778863907,
0.033421486616134644,
0.006070730276405811,
-0.009388163685798645,
-0.025541212409734726,
0.07999897003173828,
0.1293194442987442,
-0.030616743490099907,
-0.039450664073228836,
0.008902352303266525,
0.01673661544919014,
0.03248625621199608,
0.05474453046917915,
-0.006509683560580015,
-0.04832310602068901,
-0.012100527994334698,
-0.038148149847984314,
-0.008814284577965736,
0.011020389385521412,
-0.012579105794429779,
0.015966031700372696,
-0.02191614732146263,
-0.03692285716533661,
-0.0063251289539039135,
0.02488004043698311,
-0.05710185691714287,
-0.04364907369017601,
-0.008736132644116879,
-0.0241592675447464,
-0.04767000675201416,
-0.05499168485403061,
0.040973011404275894,
0.019943177700042725,
-0.03314642235636711,
-0.017437029629945755,
-0.057854488492012024,
0.000024352644686587155,
0.008442981168627739,
-0.06031590700149536,
0.038924477994441986,
0.022696156054735184,
0.024090835824608803,
-0.030584469437599182,
0.041488513350486755,
0.0016388314543291926,
-0.012572894804179668,
-0.01886923424899578,
0.03105825185775757,
0.025328893214464188,
0.029554501175880432,
-0.011687412858009338,
-0.019651226699352264,
-0.09222664684057236,
-0.0025425644125789404,
0.030067529529333115,
-0.02751116454601288,
-0.07035543769598007,
0.011878026649355888,
-0.015489122830331326,
0.04708760604262352,
0.06302332133054733,
-0.010533961467444897,
0.027899324893951416,
-0.005547632928937674,
-0.0006385071319527924,
-0.010196651332080364,
0.03715746849775314,
0.053548093885183334,
-0.009015563875436783,
0.07284647971391678,
0.042316287755966187,
-0.012368766590952873,
-0.00628252699971199,
-0.025383073836565018,
0.018028495833277702,
-0.014268233440816402,
-0.02498536929488182,
-0.0017710794927552342,
-0.0347638875246048,
-0.08500737696886063,
-0.01897341199219227,
0.02022268809378147,
0.006098766811192036,
-0.029911145567893982,
-0.005242460872977972,
-0.023381590843200684,
-0.0563628226518631,
-0.009236144833266735,
-0.030055077746510506,
0.005242366809397936,
-0.003047363134101033,
-0.019199151545763016,
-0.0639985054731369,
0.012189477682113647,
-0.01565570943057537,
-0.04050823673605919,
-0.03312673047184944,
-0.03532177582383156,
0.014438406564295292,
0.005883203819394112,
0.04500642418861389,
-0.003239370184019208,
0.0025789286009967327,
-0.011399458162486553
] |
320 |
Diverse Preference Learning for Capabilities and Alignment
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=pOq9vDIYev
|
[
"Stewart Slocum",
"Asher Parker-Sartori",
"Dylan Hadfield-Menell"
] |
Poster
|
As LLMs increasingly impact society, their ability to represent diverse perspectives is critical. However, recent studies reveal that alignment algorithms such as RLHF and DPO significantly reduce the diversity of LLM outputs. Not only do aligned LLMs generate text with repetitive structure and word choice, they also approach problems in more uniform ways, and their responses reflect a narrower range of societal perspectives. We attribute this problem to the KL divergence regularizer employed in preference learning algorithms. This causes the model to overweight majority opinions and sacrifice diversity in exchange for optimal reward. To address this, we propose Soft Preference Learning, which decouples the entropy and cross-entropy terms in the KL penalty — allowing for fine-grained control over LLM generation diversity. From a capabilities perspective, LLMs trained using Soft Preference Learning attain higher accuracy on difficult repeated sampling tasks and produce outputs with greater semantic and lexical diversity. From an alignment perspective, they are capable of representing a wider range of societal viewpoints and display improved logit calibration. Notably, Soft Preference Learning resembles, but is a Pareto improvement over, standard temperature scaling.
|
alignment, diversity, natural language processing, reinforcement learning
|
We identify a cause of diversity loss from RLHF/DPO and propose a simple solution.
| 13,501 | null |
[
0.003987891599535942,
-0.02289046347141266,
0.011367127299308777,
0.026179635897278786,
0.05009740963578224,
0.02320326305925846,
-0.0031103803776204586,
0.012476430274546146,
-0.025772668421268463,
-0.010922316461801529,
-0.025907695293426514,
0.037783700972795486,
-0.08565985411405563,
-0.005613952875137329,
0.001794164185412228,
0.055034343153238297,
0.012058485299348831,
0.026176709681749344,
-0.0023307777009904385,
0.014579016715288162,
0.022083451971411705,
-0.019415758550167084,
0.00465841218829155,
-0.007825549691915512,
0.05038486048579216,
0.0008250382961705327,
0.022217603400349617,
0.00469789607450366,
-0.006338281091302633,
-0.0023578964173793793,
0.031164798885583878,
-0.017923550680279732,
-0.0014392758021131158,
0.011849919334053993,
-0.00075138034299016,
-0.03232812136411667,
-0.061362240463495255,
-0.01562042161822319,
0.020730484277009964,
0.010316234081983566,
0.004325843416154385,
0.023729898035526276,
-0.001138930325396359,
0.007812635973095894,
-0.03631104901432991,
-0.00600533839315176,
-0.11499293148517609,
0.02010212652385235,
0.00276556215249002,
-0.03274545446038246,
-0.08453056216239929,
0.02097662352025509,
0.001418256782926619,
-0.01661745086312294,
0.0017248837975785136,
0.028874654322862625,
0.02694152668118477,
-0.06303563714027405,
-0.018498996272683144,
-0.029056956991553307,
-0.04781051725149155,
0.004650612361729145,
0.007737059146165848,
0.009285660460591316,
0.014833865687251091,
-0.022032661363482475,
-0.004266543313860893,
0.015836194157600403,
-0.042450543493032455,
-0.029981721192598343,
-0.040076352655887604,
-0.004339240025728941,
0.016114523634314537,
0.022172797471284866,
-0.009183913469314575,
-0.05787711963057518,
0.010820124298334122,
0.04412095621228218,
0.051490962505340576,
0.00036441278643906116,
-0.015348619781434536,
0.056955721229314804,
0.028226761147379875,
0.04332136735320091,
0.03177919611334801,
-0.002329393522813916,
-0.010102331638336182,
-0.008058855310082436,
-0.07678420841693878,
0.026321053504943848,
-0.019832322373986244,
-0.06349648535251617,
0.027052022516727448,
0.05268128961324692,
0.04269593954086304,
-0.008272121660411358,
0.03077000565826893,
0.035798560827970505,
-0.020264972001314163,
-0.006764096207916737,
-0.026301337406039238,
-0.016967827454209328,
0.030091017484664917,
-0.03367900103330612,
-0.11683794111013412,
-0.053283561021089554,
-0.025849243625998497,
0.012355056591331959,
-0.01546142902225256,
0.03317711874842644,
-0.05631067603826523,
-0.0173158161342144,
0.029095804318785667,
0.0028341328725218773,
-0.08115232735872269,
0.013437858782708645,
0.01739923097193241,
0.024492766708135605,
0.01204192079603672,
-0.004287112969905138,
0.034201253205537796,
0.016431646421551704,
-0.019100332632660866,
0.06712012737989426,
-0.015201006084680557,
0.0024197720922529697,
-0.008013860322535038,
0.04501056671142578,
-0.0400683619081974,
-0.031469400972127914,
0.020734896883368492,
0.03975185751914978,
-0.03610973060131073,
0.013064945116639137,
-0.02382412925362587,
0.012870131991803646,
0.03867035731673241,
0.015926990658044815,
0.061339691281318665,
-0.002331309486180544,
-0.01426259707659483,
-0.022662239149212837,
0.05211060494184494,
-0.012816847302019596,
0.05614759400486946,
-0.009056906215846539,
-0.005868840496987104,
-0.017594339326024055,
-0.060820914804935455,
-0.020554877817630768,
0.0018828550819307566,
-0.0022981169167906046,
0.017663948237895966,
-0.04884001612663269,
0.03045826219022274,
0.05081736296415329,
0.021871833130717278,
0.0020767715759575367,
0.01998196728527546,
0.018330596387386322,
-0.02506238967180252,
-0.0013792664976790547,
-0.04244639724493027,
-0.006309359334409237,
-0.0035076881758868694,
-0.06930436939001083,
0.0492631159722805,
0.012498128227889538,
-0.036939702928066254,
0.01736983098089695,
-0.03597625344991684,
-0.014188949950039387,
0.023355860263109207,
-0.015777919441461563,
-0.02888963744044304,
0.007878518663346767,
0.05722326785326004,
0.035189438611269,
0.05125022679567337,
0.03325905278325081,
-0.05879750847816467,
0.0025259319227188826,
-0.0005985951866023242,
-0.014010058715939522,
0.027225155383348465,
-0.00444603618234396,
0.07557523995637894,
-0.015440912917256355,
0.02330329827964306,
0.014612426981329918,
-0.07672492414712906,
0.003746029920876026,
0.0041123502887785435,
-0.016091996803879738,
0.08959557116031647,
-0.005750932730734348,
-0.007988388650119305,
0.050280675292015076,
0.00506551843136549,
0.07411589473485947,
0.048626143485307693,
-0.02850189059972763,
0.024432910606265068,
-0.010070462711155415,
-0.03956352174282074,
-0.010695572942495346,
0.04447207599878311,
-0.02337697148323059,
-0.024849841371178627,
0.015049466863274574,
-0.035357628017663956,
0.009577909484505653,
0.005567421205341816,
0.008025910705327988,
0.02423747070133686,
-0.009436327032744884,
-0.004480326548218727,
-0.023498743772506714,
0.007740695029497147,
-0.02622336335480213,
0.049560368061065674,
0.005458399653434753,
-0.012254097498953342,
0.0010336191626265645,
-0.028682973235845566,
0.07897008955478668,
0.05760844051837921,
-0.029366815462708473,
-0.007981091737747192,
0.041480887681245804,
0.009970714338123798,
0.010370781645178795,
0.041456062346696854,
-0.028102753683924675,
0.01681533269584179,
-0.02160303294658661,
-0.012249208986759186,
-0.04959957301616669,
0.06628191471099854,
-0.040318336337804794,
-0.027306005358695984,
0.0692567527294159,
-0.03640415519475937,
0.052610788494348526,
-0.02445383556187153,
0.03380603715777397,
0.01390595268458128,
0.021763356402516365,
-0.017966922372579575,
-0.028785178437829018,
-0.0417502336204052,
0.011912988498806953,
0.009596237912774086,
-0.015053865499794483,
0.015396969392895699,
-0.05135473981499672,
-0.024773364886641502,
-0.015282785519957542,
0.060180921107530594,
0.05279521271586418,
0.006107451859861612,
0.009061163291335106,
-0.0033696226309984922,
-0.016396526247262955,
0.021665995940566063,
-0.09331213682889938,
-0.0459161140024662,
-0.008117004297673702,
0.0013298197882249951,
0.012034458108246326,
0.041893139481544495,
-0.009089497849345207,
0.03531796112656593,
-0.026726694777607918,
-0.0008884292328730226,
0.016724176704883575,
0.03003809042274952,
-0.008596619591116905,
-0.01282603107392788,
-0.036044642329216,
0.00252866605296731,
0.051053982228040695,
-0.02506212890148163,
-0.051786284893751144,
-0.044784631580114365,
-0.03585673123598099,
0.00019545966642908752,
-0.03560981899499893,
-0.019412824884057045,
-0.0008956631063483655,
0.032784704118967056,
0.0017035205382853746,
0.014814574271440506,
0.003956140018999577,
0.03358318284153938,
0.05137864500284195,
0.0521957091987133,
0.025878671556711197,
-0.01240882370620966,
0.05283404886722565,
-0.016743097454309464,
0.011373646557331085,
0.02709815837442875,
0.023427210748195648,
0.022161738947033882,
-0.0008357066544704139,
0.021143345162272453,
-0.019275104627013206,
-0.2705354392528534,
-0.05164201185107231,
0.02901732549071312,
-0.003917766734957695,
0.029924461618065834,
-0.01654251664876938,
0.04850466549396515,
-0.042281657457351685,
-0.013779202476143837,
0.013982631266117096,
0.02332274615764618,
0.030615491792559624,
0.016009554266929626,
0.05323469638824463,
0.049803417176008224,
0.028122279793024063,
0.003375774482265115,
-0.011699949391186237,
0.022501148283481598,
0.03166266158223152,
-0.019659923389554024,
-0.08316221088171005,
-0.041381191462278366,
0.04180555418133736,
0.006926728878170252,
0.06130387261509895,
-0.04523896798491478,
0.00470746448263526,
-0.03777839243412018,
0.0039595658890903,
-0.026439858600497246,
-0.005734291858971119,
-0.016633737832307816,
0.03822598606348038,
0.011094892397522926,
0.012716574594378471,
0.06668239831924438,
-0.03652370721101761,
0.03037974052131176,
0.0576104111969471,
0.013741292990744114,
-0.030426181852817535,
-0.040100857615470886,
0.00941512268036604,
0.04867297038435936,
0.02147689089179039,
-0.07164571434259415,
-0.00005866506035090424,
-0.01262714248150587,
0.023867398500442505,
0.01866210252046585,
-0.03301801159977913,
-0.02120375819504261,
0.05475665256381035,
0.007383198477327824,
0.0022387795615941286,
0.015860917046666145,
-0.028117597103118896,
-0.012784257531166077,
-0.01846088096499443,
-0.0037660503294318914,
-0.07301948219537735,
-0.04143514484167099,
-0.010971151292324066,
-0.05046192929148674,
-0.03176257759332657,
-0.06346044689416885,
-0.059133417904376984,
0.029639914631843567,
0.02085958421230316,
-0.03962361440062523,
0.007909993641078472,
0.00371391698718071,
-0.08778541535139084,
0.017481835559010506,
-0.017847146838903427,
-0.012406166642904282,
-0.015834124758839607,
-0.00976518914103508,
0.02145405113697052,
-0.016238415613770485,
-0.024884484708309174,
0.017380237579345703,
0.007097157649695873,
0.01994745247066021,
-0.04372233897447586,
0.0046841963194310665,
-0.0034870184026658535,
-0.025860626250505447,
-0.04626492038369179,
0.025869768112897873,
-0.0028079324401915073,
-0.018701951950788498,
0.007268876302987337,
0.057439737021923065,
0.0008656106074340641,
0.006639751605689526,
0.05333826690912247,
0.028677988797426224,
0.0032559481915086508,
0.014980044215917587,
-0.08812304586172104,
-0.03043423965573311,
-0.03380798175930977,
-0.016589483246207237,
0.03235509246587753,
-0.051998071372509,
-0.03317318856716156,
0.04225476458668709,
-0.008510759100317955,
-0.010117488913238049,
-0.0167421605437994,
-0.0048531461507081985,
0.008151600137352943,
-0.02214077115058899,
-0.010914552956819534,
-0.016527298837900162,
0.043520644307136536,
0.030729759484529495,
-0.005309750325977802,
-0.013054308481514454,
0.02875344641506672,
-0.01971649006009102,
0.00021884254238102585,
-0.02609771117568016,
-0.0250552985817194,
-0.037575799971818924,
-0.035507626831531525,
-0.03702923655509949,
0.012041005305945873,
0.021527934819459915,
0.022434115409851074,
-0.0007461820496246219,
0.028954314067959785,
0.026684025302529335,
0.0071272277273237705,
0.01238354854285717,
-0.000384399521863088,
0.04112813249230385,
-0.03398994356393814,
0.007326710037887096,
-0.022384969517588615,
0.03406551107764244,
0.026313532143831253,
0.03150992840528488,
0.015088960528373718,
0.014727342873811722,
0.006068856921046972,
-0.016949260607361794,
0.03074788488447666,
0.013477104716002941,
-0.025867953896522522,
0.003735538339242339,
-0.015638811513781548,
0.022988369688391685,
-0.016152776777744293,
0.019248902797698975,
0.007966176606714725,
0.019200848415493965,
-0.06713855266571045,
0.03597910329699516,
0.024435289204120636,
-0.041231974959373474,
0.016724955290555954,
0.056607428938150406,
0.022149553522467613,
-0.03218403086066246,
0.012780802324414253,
0.021359935402870178,
0.026808103546500206,
0.04278937727212906,
-0.038509801030159,
-0.01607564277946949,
-0.0668928250670433,
-0.05286962166428566,
-0.04445585608482361,
0.031818829476833344,
-0.046028945595026016,
-0.05852627754211426,
0.06312250345945358,
-0.01328582875430584,
-0.05400344729423523,
0.013157900422811508,
-0.0052961502224206924,
0.0861336961388588,
0.003000853816047311,
-0.01749303750693798,
-0.017982391640543938,
-0.012081041932106018,
-0.0035937929060310125,
-0.011846202425658703,
0.027365999296307564,
-0.03420601412653923,
-0.04146592691540718,
-0.05618365481495857,
-0.04823625460267067,
-0.004288249183446169,
-0.022185789421200752,
-0.009238065220415592,
-0.027568573132157326,
-0.04768538847565651,
0.013578321784734726,
-0.04618436470627785,
-0.08097387850284576,
0.0370134562253952,
-0.08258236944675446,
0.008477668277919292,
-0.002836077706888318,
-0.024080945178866386,
0.015497363172471523,
-0.06570382416248322,
-0.08845232427120209,
-0.012019330635666847,
-0.013952045701444149,
0.016894562169909477,
-0.031960658729076385,
-0.025033973157405853,
-0.041203707456588745,
-0.013667921535670757,
0.005181057378649712,
0.026622837409377098,
-0.023515518754720688,
0.01544230431318283,
-0.007407328579574823,
-0.010686625726521015,
0.061480965465307236,
-0.05251539871096611,
0.012280186638236046,
0.02052256092429161,
0.017151882871985435,
0.031637273728847504,
-0.06506385654211044,
0.048338085412979126,
0.06353001296520233,
-0.016588808968663216,
0.06151745468378067,
-0.06287986040115356,
0.03151223063468933,
-0.006446899846196175,
-0.016745762899518013,
-0.0110857542604208,
-0.010909230448305607,
-0.02454078570008278,
-0.01026239711791277,
-0.0011104323202744126,
0.020811498165130615,
0.01350211538374424,
0.03636229410767555,
-0.038053009659051895,
0.012117914855480194,
-0.010235482826828957,
-0.0029023445677012205,
-0.028203992173075676,
0.01903689280152321,
0.0891130194067955,
0.007086681202054024,
-0.019499169662594795,
-0.06594734638929367,
-0.029094820842146873,
-0.015795212239027023,
-0.01793082244694233,
0.02549600973725319,
-0.03386961296200752,
0.04671711474657059,
0.027053972706198692,
0.048763394355773926,
0.004583839792758226,
-0.016471775248646736,
0.018561305478215218,
-0.06093504652380943,
0.005491478834301233,
-0.05119955167174339,
-0.005986711475998163,
0.05752232298254967,
-0.010403928346931934,
-0.00990315806120634,
-0.014103858731687069,
-0.05223321542143822,
0.07836191356182098,
-0.015481973066926003,
-0.050168849527835846,
-0.005688813515007496,
-0.04394148290157318,
0.00712951086461544,
0.09335768967866898,
-0.04034654423594475,
-0.024334149435162544,
-0.035419050604104996,
-0.03535597771406174,
-0.015318037010729313,
-0.0018230801215395331,
0.04069805517792702,
-0.017446428537368774,
0.01865234412252903,
-0.03673066198825836,
0.027498630806803703,
0.02233409509062767,
0.061990488320589066,
0.00880010798573494,
0.015281101688742638,
-0.02933906950056553,
0.07147124409675598,
0.0386364683508873,
0.012559125199913979,
0.011726931668817997,
0.014023379422724247,
0.011449727229773998,
-0.03794853389263153,
0.052231062203645706,
0.03342703729867935,
0.016272732987999916,
-0.04850463941693306,
0.05768900737166405,
0.04567389935255051,
-0.03759065642952919,
-0.020976854488253593,
0.025852128863334656,
-0.06675144284963608,
0.03558039292693138,
0.008485672064125538,
0.01874697022140026,
0.005904261488467455,
0.09210549294948578,
0.001034193322993815,
0.06071895360946655,
0.06957748532295227,
0.013805652037262917,
0.0002894712961278856,
0.06028347089886665,
0.07216167449951172,
0.050306323915719986,
0.07605157047510147,
-0.002689081709831953,
0.056444764137268066,
-0.020415814593434334,
-0.0698949471116066,
0.015631359070539474,
0.02433054707944393,
-0.01123885903507471,
-0.025126706808805466,
0.004146733321249485,
0.049779850989580154,
0.02703326754271984,
0.05355193465948105,
-0.02158033475279808,
-0.0057304976508021355,
0.035566192120313644,
0.0348818339407444,
0.024495180696249008,
0.028269104659557343,
-0.0006266998243518174,
0.0022448236122727394,
-0.030721811577677727,
0.011096145957708359,
0.02866367995738983,
-0.006440225522965193,
0.005934957880526781,
-0.016117002815008163,
-0.02154584415256977,
0.02631230279803276,
-0.008031504228711128,
0.08635067194700241,
0.1083044707775116,
-0.0912015363574028,
-0.043855972588062286,
-0.007607931271195412,
0.006886199116706848,
0.0004602358676493168,
0.020072091370821,
-0.0017331467242911458,
0.002173983957618475,
-0.029696937650442123,
-0.04953824728727341,
-0.005896841175854206,
0.05073206126689911,
0.03113577514886856,
0.032842669636011124,
-0.0351528562605381,
0.007310018874704838,
0.026080844923853874,
0.05221788212656975,
-0.07492510229349136,
-0.04281831532716751,
-0.026005446910858154,
-0.04205196350812912,
-0.0371970534324646,
-0.03694269806146622,
0.02084151841700077,
0.04549703374505043,
-0.031135089695453644,
0.008206803351640701,
-0.0402136892080307,
0.04399824142456055,
0.007045973092317581,
-0.07323800772428513,
0.02298944815993309,
0.006065486464649439,
0.009189060889184475,
-0.011070198379456997,
0.011101586744189262,
0.030096113681793213,
-0.012760202400386333,
-0.02221229299902916,
0.04361381009221077,
0.016847996041178703,
0.022391589358448982,
-0.02809612639248371,
-0.01425743568688631,
-0.08301372826099396,
-0.007486044894903898,
0.012158180586993694,
-0.029104404151439667,
-0.07865606248378754,
0.00970251765102148,
-0.023210108280181885,
0.020218458026647568,
0.08460193872451782,
0.041965365409851074,
-0.003989412449300289,
-0.025478892028331757,
-0.03204536437988281,
-0.024019747972488403,
0.009573383256793022,
0.054018404334783554,
-0.03479788079857826,
0.04203319922089577,
0.023938938975334167,
-0.025930656120181084,
-0.05616569519042969,
0.049708638340234756,
-0.0046372804790735245,
-0.017085179686546326,
-0.002908348571509123,
-0.03979182988405228,
-0.02732526883482933,
-0.07958237826824188,
-0.010155954398214817,
0.03681516274809837,
-0.03621703386306763,
-0.014148978516459465,
-0.005509419832378626,
0.012405292131006718,
-0.03293265774846077,
-0.012027105316519737,
-0.022679481655359268,
-0.03823743760585785,
-0.01625230349600315,
0.008524289354681969,
-0.07822459936141968,
0.026161037385463715,
-0.03176259249448776,
0.02028595469892025,
-0.010334696620702744,
-0.038256365805864334,
0.009706038981676102,
0.0021489704959094524,
0.025858763605356216,
0.01699296198785305,
0.006958334241062403,
-0.01480153203010559
] |
321 |
Efficient Reinforcement Learning with Large Language Model Priors
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=e2NRNQ0sZe
|
[
"Xue Yan",
"Yan Song",
"Xidong Feng",
"Mengyue Yang",
"Haifeng Zhang",
"Haitham Bou Ammar",
"Jun Wang"
] |
Poster
|
In sequential decision-making (SDM) tasks, methods like reinforcement learning (RL) and heuristic search have made notable advances in specific cases. However, they often require extensive exploration and face challenges in generalizing across diverse environments due to their limited grasp of the underlying decision dynamics. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) have recently emerged as powerful general-purpose tools, due to their capacity to maintain vast amounts of domain-specific knowledge. To harness this rich prior knowledge for efficiently solving complex SDM tasks, we propose treating LLMs as prior action distributions and integrating them into RL frameworks through Bayesian inference methods, making use of variational inference and direct posterior sampling. The proposed approaches facilitate the seamless incorporation of fixed LLM priors into both policy-based and value-based RL frameworks. Our experiments show that incorporating LLM-based action priors significantly reduces exploration and optimization complexity, substantially improving sample efficiency compared to traditional RL techniques, e.g., using LLM priors decreases the number of required samples by over 90\% in offline learning scenarios.
|
Reinforcement Learning; Probabilistic Inference; Language Prior;
|
To harness LLMs' rich prior knowledge for efficiently solving complex SDM tasks, we propose treating LLMs as prior action distributions and integrating them into RL frameworks through Bayesian inference methods.
| 13,493 |
2410.07927
|
[
-0.03282821923494339,
-0.00653099874034524,
-0.019890066236257553,
0.04054267704486847,
0.03360017016530037,
0.03711232542991638,
0.02145897038280964,
0.008909709751605988,
-0.026473011821508408,
-0.0198016669601202,
-0.02976343035697937,
0.04398507624864578,
-0.05333561450242996,
-0.007920459844172001,
0.020795542746782303,
0.04840496927499771,
0.019194642081856728,
-0.008263367228209972,
0.014985141344368458,
0.019732637330889702,
-0.008726436644792557,
0.022406646981835365,
0.047129735350608826,
0.013584085740149021,
0.05680195242166519,
0.009505747817456722,
0.04055483639240265,
0.021590014919638634,
-0.01867055334150791,
-0.026817668229341507,
0.0337006077170372,
-0.039631664752960205,
0.02340233325958252,
-0.014510486274957657,
-0.014380521140992641,
-0.00847709085792303,
-0.03260543569922447,
-0.014339174143970013,
-0.00878048688173294,
0.029400039464235306,
-0.04835111275315285,
0.02027828060090542,
-0.01881539449095726,
0.006418813951313496,
-0.03445424139499664,
0.0021551758982241154,
-0.0736476480960846,
0.03158979117870331,
0.035932671278715134,
-0.04486355558037758,
-0.09592326730489731,
0.024855926632881165,
-0.0011025725398212671,
-0.03389260545372963,
0.007463923655450344,
0.021873096004128456,
0.028245659545063972,
-0.11067099124193192,
-0.003906709142029285,
-0.04729343578219414,
-0.025398587808012962,
0.004490924067795277,
0.021243516355752945,
0.015572242438793182,
0.004312083125114441,
-0.0015025355387479067,
0.030258996412158012,
0.05755060538649559,
-0.043509528040885925,
-0.03348337486386299,
-0.0546061135828495,
0.0007613615016452968,
-0.0009967763908207417,
0.021895211189985275,
0.0013996693305671215,
-0.045273344963788986,
0.021812519058585167,
0.034447841346263885,
0.035651858896017075,
-0.008385996334254742,
-0.0005126232281327248,
0.034378163516521454,
0.011676066555082798,
0.022064000368118286,
0.012150192633271217,
0.024454306811094284,
-0.010188465006649494,
-0.044159844517707825,
-0.08183889091014862,
0.020218078047037125,
-0.010625331662595272,
-0.07427091896533966,
-0.008861846290528774,
0.047247834503650665,
-0.001376408152282238,
-0.0025552704464644194,
0.017191706225275993,
0.03356436267495155,
-0.007655719760805368,
-0.0038191629573702812,
-0.05457228794693947,
-0.03772128000855446,
0.03346865624189377,
-0.021190747618675232,
-0.12477990239858627,
-0.028842778876423836,
-0.0007936545298434794,
0.014330527745187283,
-0.012122110463678837,
0.029820319265127182,
-0.01919957995414734,
-0.008890911005437374,
-0.0035365766379982233,
-0.023752504959702492,
-0.06926201283931732,
0.03328355774283409,
0.013045625761151314,
0.03611740842461586,
0.010530799627304077,
-0.015152264386415482,
0.04090648889541626,
0.022100472822785378,
0.008081166073679924,
0.06936509907245636,
-0.01693877950310707,
-0.019004976376891136,
0.016764195635914803,
0.031032690778374672,
-0.02489921636879444,
-0.08045385777950287,
0.04871338978409767,
0.027099935337901115,
0.001598826376721263,
0.0009875046089291573,
-0.03214738517999649,
0.005161994602531195,
0.01818973943591118,
0.032549623399972916,
0.024765921756625175,
-0.0022874390706419945,
0.006467930041253567,
-0.013438900001347065,
0.08649910986423492,
-0.016978878527879715,
0.0694095715880394,
0.016649702563881874,
-0.028608271852135658,
-0.008064175955951214,
-0.07193782180547714,
0.005584276281297207,
0.01493753306567669,
-0.019210297614336014,
-0.0045109521597623825,
-0.03440858796238899,
0.04008901119232178,
0.056749310344457626,
0.012875442393124104,
-0.005356904119253159,
0.005652328487485647,
0.023488465696573257,
0.013407803140580654,
0.006802485324442387,
-0.03914840519428253,
-0.005893159657716751,
0.0071811368688941,
-0.09294973313808441,
0.042285919189453125,
0.010240747593343258,
-0.04201961308717728,
-0.020561013370752335,
-0.014384329319000244,
-0.02904151938855648,
0.0424373522400856,
-0.040064990520477295,
-0.021989881992340088,
-0.0040644071996212006,
0.06517470628023148,
-0.014611927792429924,
0.04102429375052452,
0.00503747072070837,
-0.06945303082466125,
0.012924355454742908,
0.020581558346748352,
0.001548884785734117,
0.02732565999031067,
-0.04224882274866104,
0.06933330744504929,
-0.03800434246659279,
0.0085358377546072,
0.018547680228948593,
-0.08033917099237442,
-0.003592492314055562,
0.03510162979364395,
0.013363717123866081,
0.06772126257419586,
0.004126757849007845,
-0.006301693618297577,
0.07072493433952332,
0.03120739385485649,
0.03874318674206734,
0.04574928805232048,
-0.019695986062288284,
0.02111741527915001,
-0.01633000746369362,
-0.016696570441126823,
-0.00625363877043128,
0.03753052279353142,
-0.046718355268239975,
-0.015624049119651318,
0.0281833428889513,
-0.01950894668698311,
0.016655443236231804,
0.017745433375239372,
0.004076014272868633,
0.03612733632326126,
-0.028386235237121582,
-0.009701238945126534,
0.000010292478691553697,
0.010193318128585815,
-0.05152697116136551,
0.03992752730846405,
0.015141264535486698,
-0.024634651839733124,
0.0033184033818542957,
-0.031709976494312286,
0.0762944221496582,
0.07245400547981262,
-0.015279334038496017,
-0.028630955144762993,
0.02208128571510315,
0.023386793211102486,
0.03817763552069664,
0.025474779307842255,
-0.02627083845436573,
0.05639118328690529,
-0.023256395012140274,
-0.00032772045233286917,
-0.021743904799222946,
0.027281425893306732,
-0.021598072722554207,
-0.01889822632074356,
0.07391420751810074,
-0.006637495942413807,
0.06588476896286011,
-0.013087655417621136,
0.021207191050052643,
0.03046494536101818,
0.01429087296128273,
-0.010038027539849281,
-0.03285713493824005,
-0.02620466984808445,
0.0007400524336844683,
0.03675425425171852,
-0.003459089668467641,
-0.006164048332720995,
-0.036277540028095245,
-0.006680249236524105,
-0.015292897820472717,
0.0654074102640152,
0.05013944208621979,
0.01064369734376669,
0.04774542525410652,
-0.00304235122166574,
-0.02797255478799343,
-0.0037280574906617403,
-0.10808011889457703,
-0.03011162392795086,
-0.024764375761151314,
0.003169821808114648,
0.0438687726855278,
0.00846478994935751,
-0.027614738792181015,
0.034793782979249954,
-0.03694500774145126,
-0.024824244901537895,
-0.006891860626637936,
0.02185288444161415,
0.0187759380787611,
-0.02409256249666214,
-0.014655153267085552,
0.015782132744789124,
0.04600241035223007,
-0.00040803285082802176,
-0.03530186787247658,
-0.025278324261307716,
-0.03465234115719795,
-0.006061396095901728,
-0.042182330042123795,
0.0019202566472813487,
0.036530252546072006,
0.03350471332669258,
-0.0022620565723627806,
-0.04164010286331177,
0.03537151589989662,
0.03994854539632797,
0.04886394366621971,
0.0547090545296669,
0.007058341987431049,
-0.01123354397714138,
0.026580458506941795,
-0.04671439900994301,
-0.005264691077172756,
-0.024057064205408096,
0.026482589542865753,
0.0036032088100910187,
-0.0122204115614295,
0.018255338072776794,
0.035064876079559326,
-0.25764647126197815,
-0.02703365497291088,
-0.002549055963754654,
-0.022199302911758423,
0.03216322138905525,
0.010254616849124432,
0.05595756694674492,
-0.0581340491771698,
-0.03340831771492958,
0.04664900526404381,
0.023215368390083313,
0.03959834203124046,
-0.00419844314455986,
0.05120532214641571,
0.06447824090719223,
0.06432037800550461,
-0.01350585650652647,
-0.006791307125240564,
0.015383620746433735,
0.022336401045322418,
-0.015555442310869694,
-0.06753848493099213,
-0.02347356081008911,
0.04500503093004227,
-0.002237413078546524,
0.08535952121019363,
-0.08236739784479141,
0.011615523137152195,
-0.02098221704363823,
0.012006553821265697,
-0.018250595778226852,
-0.032465506345033646,
-0.01135705504566431,
0.028867997229099274,
0.006765997502952814,
0.02544192411005497,
0.03129417076706886,
-0.0018636472523212433,
0.03605899587273598,
0.02888178825378418,
0.004642287269234657,
-0.010345702059566975,
-0.03387309983372688,
0.016259431838989258,
0.04818563908338547,
0.016029445454478264,
-0.050207216292619705,
-0.024647019803524017,
-0.007836734876036644,
0.03892296925187111,
0.008152949623763561,
-0.03301224857568741,
-0.00043077717418782413,
0.003149963216856122,
0.03789297491312027,
-0.01924991048872471,
0.01918363943696022,
-0.040955476462841034,
-0.0074350545182824135,
0.02384892664849758,
0.017746392637491226,
-0.06096787378191948,
-0.042032256722450256,
-0.03565941005945206,
-0.008527311496436596,
-0.03720149025321007,
-0.04564528539776802,
-0.05649910122156143,
0.03221752122044563,
0.047398485243320465,
-0.027816306799650192,
-0.00811649952083826,
-0.0049731372855603695,
-0.09117294102907181,
0.008432202972471714,
0.01101648434996605,
-0.025720221921801567,
-0.028909463435411453,
0.019393691793084145,
0.04322996735572815,
-0.050363246351480484,
-0.04705660417675972,
-0.025236841291189194,
0.004809698089957237,
0.02677334100008011,
-0.021626124158501625,
0.015326366759836674,
-0.04486848786473274,
-0.0281401127576828,
-0.04588087275624275,
0.01615838333964348,
0.017318110913038254,
0.018249578773975372,
0.017501994967460632,
0.07443789392709732,
0.020293517038226128,
0.002779677277430892,
0.041050978004932404,
0.02960951253771782,
-0.024385837838053703,
0.016158830374479294,
-0.08528043329715729,
-0.020376678556203842,
-0.051800187677145004,
-0.030376801267266273,
0.027511099353432655,
-0.07896043360233307,
-0.04170629754662514,
0.02148241549730301,
0.0031008427031338215,
-0.01437392644584179,
-0.009567968547344208,
0.016214080154895782,
0.017322039231657982,
-0.024810612201690674,
-0.018952710554003716,
-0.009469602257013321,
0.05940346047282219,
0.047823019325733185,
-0.016069095581769943,
-0.05346192792057991,
0.0367521308362484,
-0.051017556339502335,
0.00922445673495531,
0.017860565334558487,
-0.02591121941804886,
0.010139728896319866,
-0.0026458404026925564,
0.004598412662744522,
-0.002086990512907505,
0.03400931507349014,
0.019741542637348175,
0.014564153738319874,
0.012008005753159523,
0.04357541725039482,
-0.003599882125854492,
-0.006332142278552055,
-0.024899763986468315,
0.02177322655916214,
-0.018904365599155426,
-0.010478327982127666,
-0.031598206609487534,
0.03288103640079498,
0.021681278944015503,
0.009525241330265999,
0.0022007932420819998,
0.02418810874223709,
0.031131206080317497,
0.012866523116827011,
0.020583434030413628,
0.03187400475144386,
-0.06592153757810593,
0.008443674072623253,
-0.00012342042464297265,
0.04329284653067589,
-0.030614327639341354,
0.04012317210435867,
-0.05618080124258995,
0.041288670152425766,
-0.08633636683225632,
0.03616686537861824,
0.004335913807153702,
-0.027848349884152412,
0.011562732979655266,
0.04138931632041931,
0.04134170711040497,
-0.058133963495492935,
0.0016540077049285173,
0.02676284685730934,
0.025113018229603767,
0.017536809667944908,
-0.05540948733687401,
-0.022956877946853638,
-0.0027745848055928946,
-0.03178361430764198,
-0.006271196994930506,
0.008878962136805058,
-0.03330894559621811,
-0.03841562196612358,
0.03051762655377388,
0.03666432574391365,
-0.04961889609694481,
-0.01857265643775463,
0.0003017413255292922,
0.0802525132894516,
-0.010677732527256012,
0.02120078355073929,
0.021816130727529526,
-0.05127202719449997,
0.012166537344455719,
-0.006828357931226492,
0.025910761207342148,
-0.010035871528089046,
-0.04891139641404152,
-0.04065258055925369,
-0.04664916545152664,
0.0022801964078098536,
-0.004417411983013153,
0.005380555056035519,
0.00010275032400386408,
0.010303781367838383,
-0.03355802223086357,
-0.04094364121556282,
-0.02722199447453022,
0.017145682126283646,
-0.06468572467565536,
-0.009605957195162773,
0.04631917551159859,
-0.010247615166008472,
0.0318562313914299,
-0.06454148143529892,
-0.02303794026374817,
-0.03332814946770668,
-0.012813707813620567,
0.005427677184343338,
-0.012244532816112041,
-0.02384861744940281,
-0.010082578286528587,
-0.019670145586133003,
0.01690712384879589,
0.011584702879190445,
-0.019318990409374237,
0.0032740393653512,
-0.03369252383708954,
0.0008121424471028149,
0.055487010627985,
-0.06360310316085815,
-0.03440717235207558,
0.04012206569314003,
-0.03128628805279732,
0.031622182577848434,
-0.06591419130563736,
-0.0009220482315868139,
0.054636817425489426,
-0.01055432390421629,
0.03655502200126648,
-0.0436522476375103,
0.0655423104763031,
0.008701872080564499,
-0.026506932452321053,
0.018779130652546883,
0.018011653795838356,
-0.03409132361412048,
0.0008368428098037839,
-0.003705657785758376,
0.01655159704387188,
0.005919198971241713,
0.027315109968185425,
0.025882884860038757,
0.007332810200750828,
-0.004958375822752714,
0.0011006731074303389,
-0.04282710701227188,
0.018903793767094612,
0.058192744851112366,
-0.007460007909685373,
-0.04500051215291023,
-0.0587935708463192,
-0.04252597689628601,
0.014383872970938683,
-0.012492566369473934,
0.020818093791604042,
-0.06981084495782852,
0.02814122475683689,
0.011313091963529587,
0.0376637801527977,
0.02909134328365326,
-0.012215240858495235,
0.03039066307246685,
-0.04805487394332886,
0.007482255343347788,
-0.07068400084972382,
-0.017390092834830284,
0.05244559049606323,
-0.061538904905319214,
0.007765973452478647,
0.017524033784866333,
-0.03327135741710663,
0.03406699001789093,
-0.005334662739187479,
-0.05117076635360718,
0.0401892364025116,
-0.016121376305818558,
-0.03359615430235863,
0.07720351964235306,
-0.05198277533054352,
-0.027399325743317604,
-0.013986830599606037,
-0.030906962230801582,
0.004362468142062426,
0.011614402756094933,
0.04793363809585571,
-0.035733841359615326,
0.012318206951022148,
-0.04923038184642792,
0.013166481629014015,
0.004126451443880796,
0.04931074008345604,
0.02578759379684925,
0.02296283468604088,
-0.03766006603837013,
0.04162275046110153,
0.028958121314644814,
0.036784566938877106,
-0.010670646093785763,
0.0008830685401335359,
-0.023241037502884865,
-0.041874222457408905,
0.05140307918190956,
-0.00007054883462842554,
0.010588381439447403,
-0.039991382509469986,
0.07636258751153946,
0.03666261211037636,
-0.04175381362438202,
-0.0125692468136549,
0.015154032967984676,
-0.07779330760240555,
-0.010363207198679447,
0.0003272172762081027,
0.009217200800776482,
0.01700877957046032,
0.08123838901519775,
0.030138306319713593,
0.05921678617596626,
0.07565870136022568,
0.0032755539286881685,
-0.020170889794826508,
-0.00011298917524982244,
0.06642628461122513,
0.044080328196287155,
0.061100296676158905,
-0.013199280947446823,
0.0743740051984787,
-0.05745259299874306,
-0.037196867167949677,
0.04353398084640503,
0.008599241264164448,
-0.00637746462598443,
-0.05421208217740059,
0.018039075657725334,
0.054585229605436325,
-0.028598405420780182,
0.04252684488892555,
-0.043611351400613785,
-0.01658957451581955,
0.06289542466402054,
0.0012945558410137892,
-0.014241592027246952,
0.050945304334163666,
0.04756631329655647,
0.03142695501446724,
-0.02582288533449173,
-0.006358204409480095,
0.010459484532475471,
-0.023970285430550575,
-0.006224935874342918,
0.019682547077536583,
-0.028533462435007095,
-0.01620994508266449,
0.009619594551622868,
0.021554021164774895,
0.14166651666164398,
-0.02605605497956276,
-0.014334570616483688,
0.004687747918069363,
0.00045876018702983856,
0.01605495624244213,
0.05102207511663437,
0.0016070296987891197,
-0.02947140298783779,
0.014974965713918209,
-0.02729438804090023,
0.001887945574708283,
0.040913358330726624,
-0.020525939762592316,
0.014139940030872822,
-0.035061098635196686,
-0.02150416001677513,
-0.0014127218164503574,
0.022854162380099297,
-0.07818824052810669,
-0.05110326409339905,
-0.03144663944840431,
-0.053648099303245544,
-0.04711221531033516,
-0.05779850855469704,
0.03195216879248619,
0.011899596080183983,
-0.026135912165045738,
0.017153363674879074,
-0.021153215318918228,
0.015062372200191021,
-0.013663118705153465,
-0.049818623811006546,
0.01384645700454712,
0.03017176128923893,
-0.007914668880403042,
0.006582968402653933,
0.0356099009513855,
0.02798714116215706,
-0.015559719875454903,
-0.02741001732647419,
0.023683324456214905,
0.008044605143368244,
0.01891930028796196,
-0.04785526171326637,
0.006879356224089861,
-0.08002442866563797,
-0.0003638337948359549,
0.00915918406099081,
-0.030139008536934853,
-0.07272857427597046,
0.004676156211644411,
-0.03255882114171982,
0.03840739279985428,
0.0841178447008133,
0.030688468366861343,
0.049335088580846786,
-0.02552565187215805,
0.00631615100428462,
0.012936518527567387,
0.011715133674442768,
0.02280852198600769,
-0.04527393355965614,
0.036164358258247375,
0.0451020747423172,
-0.021399138495326042,
-0.06988587975502014,
0.02478845790028572,
0.01631668023765087,
-0.02221721224486828,
-0.016116192564368248,
-0.014525139704346657,
-0.01373298279941082,
-0.08937164396047592,
-0.024380052462220192,
0.01928083598613739,
0.002162607153877616,
-0.01654260791838169,
0.0022840627934783697,
-0.021331561729311943,
-0.019866354763507843,
0.0007131518214009702,
-0.03721630200743675,
-0.038463227450847626,
-0.02016121707856655,
-0.037678297609090805,
-0.05649426206946373,
0.03283483535051346,
-0.038073476403951645,
-0.009856341406702995,
-0.03533845767378807,
-0.0175928995013237,
-0.007476961240172386,
0.0201277956366539,
0.043018367141485214,
-0.018148820847272873,
0.00890024658292532,
-0.035187676548957825
] |
322 |
Geometry-Aware Approaches for Balancing Performance and Theoretical Guarantees in Linear Bandits
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Oeb0I3JcVc
|
[
"Yuwei Luo",
"Mohsen Bayati"
] |
Poster
|
This paper is motivated by recent research in the $d$-dimensional stochastic linear bandit literature, which has revealed an unsettling discrepancy: algorithms like Thompson sampling and Greedy demonstrate promising empirical performance, yet this contrasts with their pessimistic theoretical regret bounds. The challenge arises from the fact that while these algorithms may perform poorly in certain problem instances, they generally excel in typical instances. To address this, we propose a new data-driven technique that tracks the geometric properties of the uncertainty ellipsoid around the main problem parameter. This methodology enables us to formulate a data-driven frequentist regret bound, which incorporates the geometric information, for a broad class of base algorithms, including Greedy, OFUL, and Thompson sampling. This result allows us to identify and ``course-correct" problem instances in which the base algorithms perform poorly. The course-corrected algorithms achieve the minimax optimal regret of order $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}(d\sqrt{T})$ for a $T$-period decision-making scenario, effectively maintaining the desirable attributes of the base algorithms, including their empirical efficacy. We present simulation results to validate our findings using synthetic and real data.
|
Linear bandit, Thompson sampling, Greedy, Data-driven exploration
| null | 13,487 |
2306.14872
|
[
-0.01688281074166298,
-0.01066763699054718,
-0.003424615366384387,
0.036703865975141525,
0.023953095078468323,
0.04533112794160843,
0.03132976219058037,
0.008707931265234947,
-0.003518514335155487,
-0.0698888823390007,
-0.00993131659924984,
-0.023341571912169456,
-0.07088296115398407,
-0.02613084390759468,
-0.005843530874699354,
0.07067099958658218,
0.03451882302761078,
0.001163744949735701,
-0.005808715708553791,
0.026019545271992683,
0.0032336257863789797,
-0.00244937208481133,
0.03475794568657875,
0.0189606212079525,
0.05425005778670311,
0.012622461654245853,
0.039088740944862366,
0.024366850033402443,
0.001017912058159709,
0.0019647914450615644,
0.035361047834157944,
-0.005926633253693581,
0.0013798065483570099,
-0.0511891208589077,
0.017004933208227158,
0.039397478103637695,
-0.005501186940819025,
0.009984460659325123,
0.002769160084426403,
0.005131079349666834,
-0.056732177734375,
-0.0005698880995623767,
-0.03424674645066261,
0.03743106499314308,
-0.03534260764718056,
-0.002889536553993821,
-0.04636918008327484,
0.03464554250240326,
0.035572394728660583,
-0.04184598848223686,
-0.06417464464902878,
0.060975831001996994,
0.035540468990802765,
-0.0036197772715240717,
-0.03012322448194027,
0.037842486053705215,
0.07176880538463593,
-0.06881482899188995,
-0.001502879778854549,
-0.05567748844623566,
-0.04360686242580414,
0.029248375445604324,
0.010316389612853527,
0.022003840655088425,
-0.004539551679044962,
0.007571539841592312,
0.023725073784589767,
0.06470515578985214,
-0.020384518429636955,
-0.026631953194737434,
-0.04269300773739815,
-0.015560832805931568,
0.004462321288883686,
0.03706846013665199,
0.007077490910887718,
-0.05119362846016884,
-0.0009396180394105613,
0.04321715235710144,
0.019648585468530655,
0.02978375181555748,
0.012842481024563313,
-0.01211928017437458,
0.022420743480324745,
0.015305629931390285,
0.0025492054410278797,
-0.0003827363543678075,
-0.0336192287504673,
-0.050869446247816086,
-0.08437060564756393,
0.03566795587539673,
-0.05273117497563362,
-0.06410150229930878,
0.04582487419247627,
0.04695123806595802,
0.00014176609693095088,
-0.02832813560962677,
0.02619524486362934,
0.036917075514793396,
0.02899959124624729,
-0.04317833483219147,
-0.012775341048836708,
-0.04028880223631859,
0.013590393587946892,
0.002855369821190834,
-0.1076141744852066,
-0.02529333531856537,
-0.02066061459481716,
-0.011278881691396236,
-0.0149118946865201,
0.019014783203601837,
-0.05744653940200806,
-0.00798356905579567,
0.004420003388077021,
-0.030809946358203888,
-0.08776738494634628,
0.04430246353149414,
0.00395953981205821,
0.03516519069671631,
-0.0138247637078166,
-0.0163575429469347,
0.03890983387827873,
0.049614645540714264,
-0.015026314184069633,
0.07639455795288086,
0.0000629513815511018,
0.007701443508267403,
0.04121492803096771,
0.018477631732821465,
0.00017217203276231885,
-0.05922919884324074,
0.0372796356678009,
0.03893721476197243,
-0.014682901091873646,
-0.0035750872921198606,
-0.038997288793325424,
-0.005069083534181118,
-0.009527565911412239,
0.010480647906661034,
0.021321512758731842,
-0.010443702340126038,
-0.002764886012300849,
-0.01489646639674902,
0.05987992137670517,
0.008003434166312218,
0.06755977123975754,
-0.035111308097839355,
0.05261286348104477,
-0.03313922882080078,
-0.0687832459807396,
-0.030593737959861755,
0.0213636364787817,
-0.029015356674790382,
-0.00911179929971695,
-0.04818215221166611,
0.0038143841084092855,
0.023259330540895462,
-0.0024927963968366385,
0.051001351326704025,
-0.009398622438311577,
0.015686243772506714,
0.02948707714676857,
0.0069070858880877495,
-0.012125355191528797,
-0.007029421627521515,
-0.007385368924587965,
-0.07050159573554993,
0.0914222002029419,
0.05650453269481659,
-0.011605990119278431,
-0.006008938420563936,
-0.03582177683711052,
-0.022189822047948837,
0.04115232825279236,
-0.007992315106093884,
0.0018988382071256638,
0.006000845227390528,
0.044560015201568604,
0.009409675374627113,
0.03319168835878372,
0.015634268522262573,
-0.08607934415340424,
0.022519713267683983,
0.030874356627464294,
0.010198818519711494,
0.020517850294709206,
-0.020620493218302727,
0.07967336475849152,
-0.014164207503199577,
0.028037117794156075,
0.0111065823584795,
-0.0786929652094841,
-0.014529770240187645,
0.032710444182157516,
0.0018018262926489115,
0.08206615597009659,
-0.008056499995291233,
-0.013189805671572685,
0.01585010252892971,
0.00785495899617672,
0.01551624946296215,
0.03327051177620888,
-0.021162187680602074,
0.03771260008215904,
0.010846423916518688,
-0.046470873057842255,
-0.025340503081679344,
0.03196856379508972,
-0.05433022975921631,
-0.04071257263422012,
0.022214895114302635,
0.0080778943374753,
0.0008542674477212131,
-0.02287871763110161,
0.001075051142834127,
0.03693610802292824,
-0.012079601176083088,
0.019260499626398087,
-0.016530882567167282,
0.05136508867144585,
-0.04171380400657654,
0.02133527584373951,
0.0015362065751105547,
-0.03631513938307762,
0.005502703599631786,
0.005777745973318815,
0.09017134457826614,
0.0757928416132927,
-0.024283545091748238,
-0.021802304312586784,
-0.0007801033207215369,
0.009679329581558704,
0.010107344016432762,
-0.006182982586324215,
-0.02388106845319271,
0.012560627423226833,
0.011785768903791904,
-0.003780170576646924,
-0.045314300805330276,
0.08892745524644852,
-0.033507414162158966,
0.004337473772466183,
0.08008533716201782,
0.017022179439663887,
0.05728670954704285,
-0.014127102680504322,
-0.0045074778608977795,
0.018705595284700394,
0.04638899862766266,
-0.022840838879346848,
-0.03704534471035004,
-0.03219965845346451,
-0.007962534204125404,
0.029190082103013992,
-0.02393452636897564,
0.013872567564249039,
-0.05204538628458977,
0.008002689108252525,
-0.00840478204190731,
0.0963001549243927,
0.04611176624894142,
0.029507461935281754,
0.013938244432210922,
-0.0058482252061367035,
-0.03076222725212574,
-0.02513073943555355,
-0.10999699681997299,
-0.07030843943357468,
-0.0002467757149133831,
0.029501313343644142,
0.057269178330898285,
0.04206718131899834,
-0.01627509482204914,
0.048750005662441254,
-0.016181202605366707,
-0.042753614485263824,
0.012617918662726879,
0.04364569112658501,
0.017216797918081284,
-0.0472707524895668,
0.003149131080135703,
0.036602336913347244,
0.062413785606622696,
0.008662795647978783,
-0.015009842813014984,
-0.023498637601733208,
-0.017532063648104668,
0.004409742541611195,
-0.018493076786398888,
-0.0355515331029892,
0.00616184389218688,
-0.01667746715247631,
0.038207706063985825,
-0.049331821501255035,
0.004126505460590124,
0.04774582386016846,
0.050841085612773895,
0.015333966352045536,
-0.010818412527441978,
0.01473084557801485,
-0.015191594138741493,
0.0037698533851653337,
0.014560356736183167,
-0.019770711660385132,
-0.010335613042116165,
-0.022786078974604607,
-0.035744428634643555,
0.026142846792936325,
0.004429013002663851,
-0.2688654661178589,
-0.039268042892217636,
0.009031152352690697,
0.02159980498254299,
0.007904413156211376,
0.0006203585071489215,
0.04017513617873192,
-0.023401115089654922,
-0.058215461671352386,
0.024988817051053047,
0.0005730995326302946,
0.02622195892035961,
-0.0010955964680761099,
0.05624646320939064,
0.06615717709064484,
0.035079970955848694,
-0.020964056253433228,
-0.0012424656888470054,
-0.0025917456950992346,
0.020114662125706673,
-0.008829440921545029,
-0.07535848766565323,
-0.00309744686819613,
0.020705517381429672,
-0.022344626486301422,
0.0643085315823555,
-0.04556453600525856,
0.004344537854194641,
-0.03244015946984291,
-0.0031933304853737354,
-0.0004939477075822651,
-0.030346006155014038,
-0.018844299018383026,
0.023388173431158066,
0.0166389849036932,
-0.020856792107224464,
0.03231113776564598,
-0.03141666576266289,
0.005964193027466536,
0.015024041756987572,
-0.007152193691581488,
0.008893925696611404,
-0.038142066448926926,
0.015404594130814075,
0.057836759835481644,
0.010159025900065899,
-0.008509651757776737,
-0.008884015493094921,
-0.011956090107560158,
0.038471903651952744,
0.03413541987538338,
-0.022984882816672325,
-0.017803777009248734,
2.97498502277449e-7,
-0.0117102125659585,
-0.024983471259474754,
-0.007574544288218021,
-0.028501808643341064,
-0.03288661688566208,
0.04876340180635452,
0.029176611453294754,
-0.052211061120033264,
-0.02192801423370838,
-0.03441477566957474,
-0.007438850123435259,
-0.04851857200264931,
-0.060489218682050705,
-0.04919853061437607,
0.023752601817250252,
0.03578134998679161,
0.00820787064731121,
0.027038922533392906,
-0.024661406874656677,
-0.09456838667392731,
0.023585250601172447,
-0.012296578846871853,
0.0048029557801783085,
0.021172285079956055,
0.035727400332689285,
0.06382643431425095,
-0.05326370149850845,
-0.04496753588318825,
0.037843216210603714,
0.022018300369381905,
0.011528260074555874,
-0.017559342086315155,
0.00511225825175643,
-0.010979151353240013,
-0.0323001928627491,
-0.04226301982998848,
0.014158844016492367,
0.011840504594147205,
0.03522597998380661,
-0.0214067529886961,
0.054386258125305176,
0.049535270780324936,
0.0232417993247509,
-0.005026528611779213,
0.044066235423088074,
0.014157041907310486,
0.03672485798597336,
-0.08382540941238403,
0.007639230694621801,
-0.02954428270459175,
-0.040186766535043716,
0.01667952537536621,
-0.043432168662548065,
0.006668379995971918,
0.05511011928319931,
-0.03688352555036545,
-0.000730321102309972,
-0.011909187771379948,
0.0007333733956329525,
0.005204496439546347,
-0.008203582838177681,
-0.03895438089966774,
-0.000013979290997667704,
0.04439432919025421,
0.026451390236616135,
-0.012748993933200836,
-0.06298398226499557,
0.009439535439014435,
-0.02944296970963478,
-0.0032576199155300856,
-0.0148654505610466,
0.009721756912767887,
0.00842147134244442,
-0.012110400013625622,
-0.00989053025841713,
-0.009783350862562656,
0.03814298287034035,
0.06834273040294647,
0.002477302448824048,
0.002211479702964425,
0.04390774294734001,
0.012719365768134594,
-0.028138089925050735,
-0.008503980003297329,
0.0470254011452198,
-0.00313293794170022,
0.04190889000892639,
0.020043540745973587,
0.004237791523337364,
0.02300834283232689,
0.033227428793907166,
0.014937534928321838,
0.0047945501282811165,
-0.013910667039453983,
0.009572702459990978,
-0.00360218551941216,
-0.0019772741943597794,
-0.03391989693045616,
0.04281816631555557,
-0.0036361359525471926,
0.041803132742643356,
0.01076257973909378,
0.03682654723525047,
-0.00013434792344924062,
0.013469996862113476,
-0.08033373951911926,
0.04330451041460037,
-0.016304878517985344,
-0.04752982780337334,
-0.0007910511922091246,
0.009541486389935017,
0.07790110260248184,
-0.04973042011260986,
-0.015796473249793053,
0.025254618376493454,
0.011629790998995304,
0.026160771027207375,
-0.051555730402469635,
-0.021978074684739113,
-0.015657177194952965,
-0.03246704488992691,
-0.01117892749607563,
0.018918944522738457,
-0.036228593438863754,
-0.0648340955376625,
-0.012016323395073414,
-0.012191304005682468,
-0.022039268165826797,
-0.013249489478766918,
0.0021464191377162933,
0.06333956867456436,
-0.0032059508375823498,
-0.016385167837142944,
-0.027920588850975037,
-0.04760745167732239,
0.014273237437009811,
-0.002090400317683816,
0.012112084776163101,
-0.03834760934114456,
-0.033443666994571686,
-0.019214535132050514,
-0.028342781588435173,
-0.0028145667165517807,
-0.010142747312784195,
-0.0301519725471735,
-0.010829223319888115,
-0.0034235361963510513,
0.016077930107712746,
-0.018384486436843872,
-0.014765575528144836,
0.02429661899805069,
-0.060283634811639786,
0.03711017966270447,
0.040362417697906494,
-0.03183918818831444,
0.03541293367743492,
-0.08089172095060349,
-0.035340581089258194,
-0.0018934357212856412,
0.007923492230474949,
0.01868310756981373,
-0.018459822982549667,
-0.03121369145810604,
0.009852530434727669,
-0.01837613433599472,
-0.012246489524841309,
0.016012294217944145,
-0.033453647047281265,
-0.027672167867422104,
-0.01455715298652649,
-0.005103135481476784,
0.07360797375440598,
-0.02148321643471718,
-0.055843982845544815,
0.021582022309303284,
-0.005676569417119026,
0.015664109960198402,
-0.058171141892671585,
-0.01110560167580843,
0.03658006712794304,
-0.015845615416765213,
0.039552073925733566,
-0.060204148292541504,
0.03667987138032913,
-0.021127626299858093,
-0.017146339640021324,
-0.007307977415621281,
0.010080475360155106,
-0.03325137868523598,
-0.009686681441962719,
0.005497088190168142,
0.05432840436697006,
0.021936869248747826,
-0.0037276011426001787,
0.015350408852100372,
0.01064022071659565,
0.009525674395263195,
-0.012738155201077461,
-0.023666424676775932,
-0.0014674318954348564,
0.04877127707004547,
0.007367289625108242,
-0.005842697806656361,
-0.04435301944613457,
0.012163105420768261,
0.03524443134665489,
-0.03586428984999657,
0.015803135931491852,
-0.024254072457551956,
0.035114992409944534,
0.018091371282935143,
0.05529960244894028,
0.009074481204152107,
-0.021330462768673897,
0.01789177395403385,
-0.08510833233594894,
-0.012666149996221066,
-0.08198168128728867,
0.016944395378232002,
0.03537134826183319,
-0.017169920727610588,
0.03259086608886719,
0.04691562056541443,
-0.03303117677569389,
0.014285728335380554,
-0.05381616950035095,
-0.06851958483457565,
-0.014790104702115059,
-0.02421632409095764,
-0.01822841539978981,
0.06037791818380356,
-0.05354186147451401,
-0.0473610945045948,
0.00038364430656656623,
-0.03056895174086094,
0.0013175619533285499,
0.010368352755904198,
0.026972806081175804,
-0.023711316287517548,
0.0029065718408674,
-0.04788323864340782,
0.012439376674592495,
0.03716565668582916,
0.03674140200018883,
0.024301519617438316,
0.025404460728168488,
-0.050642311573028564,
0.04142167419195175,
0.04936375468969345,
0.024623427540063858,
0.030233440920710564,
0.013709913939237595,
0.010541430674493313,
-0.03201357647776604,
0.06503191590309143,
-0.0044102962128818035,
-0.02954334393143654,
-0.06178702786564827,
0.054260920733213425,
0.04642290621995926,
-0.07282321900129318,
-0.043906282633543015,
0.0169824305921793,
-0.052085328847169876,
0.019727760925889015,
-0.012501777149736881,
-0.01889055222272873,
0.031836748123168945,
0.07658343017101288,
0.016855694353580475,
0.03786260262131691,
0.036030638962984085,
0.006408190354704857,
-0.017368106171488762,
-0.00847040768712759,
0.09110127389431,
0.07411034405231476,
0.048894427716732025,
-0.019918497651815414,
0.06396374106407166,
-0.051254451274871826,
-0.03833577409386635,
0.009949288330972195,
-0.03514036908745766,
0.0010725728934630752,
-0.051824167370796204,
-0.012735187076032162,
0.013197392225265503,
0.02290216088294983,
0.06587617844343185,
-0.0613274946808815,
0.00995388813316822,
0.045859407633543015,
-0.015587466768920422,
0.0286546777933836,
0.034707944840192795,
0.029009761288762093,
0.020360849797725677,
-0.04019507020711899,
-0.03211485221982002,
-0.0003888340143021196,
0.010331815108656883,
0.02212320640683174,
0.014355415478348732,
-0.0362735278904438,
0.011923268437385559,
0.011460001580417156,
0.006799766328185797,
0.08554396033287048,
-0.05131310969591141,
-0.03493189066648483,
-0.0006556011503562331,
0.012026702985167503,
-0.02688133902847767,
0.07590027153491974,
0.04228708893060684,
-0.029608428478240967,
0.017399195581674576,
-0.056232865899801254,
0.0034406220074743032,
0.03849918767809868,
-0.0035776724107563496,
-0.0107945641502738,
-0.03633957728743553,
-0.0002133411035174504,
0.022308994084596634,
0.027040662243962288,
-0.04344726353883743,
-0.03832031041383743,
-0.021717781201004982,
-0.05205832049250603,
-0.06205521523952484,
-0.04899163916707039,
0.0009826351888477802,
-0.002954675117507577,
-0.05346366763114929,
0.008529437705874443,
-0.014332013204693794,
0.020684584975242615,
-0.02893143892288208,
-0.026559188961982727,
-0.029840992763638496,
0.03748004510998726,
0.04182235896587372,
0.031520094722509384,
0.02930804342031479,
0.024468066170811653,
-0.01210574060678482,
-0.04312829300761223,
0.020917760208249092,
0.021085457876324654,
0.04531564936041832,
-0.01818162389099598,
-0.018689880147576332,
-0.0893801599740982,
-0.01088590919971466,
0.048506781458854675,
-0.02219483070075512,
-0.06966471672058105,
0.001532306894659996,
-0.05337027087807655,
0.007105465047061443,
0.044255331158638,
-0.007979514077305794,
0.003894087625667453,
-0.04271535575389862,
-0.007697783410549164,
0.00895538367331028,
-0.013326236046850681,
0.016878794878721237,
-0.04035227373242378,
0.03227449208498001,
0.03568023443222046,
-0.049166250973939896,
-0.05608442798256874,
0.0737486481666565,
0.012240647338330746,
0.00746655510738492,
-0.02842702902853489,
-0.02365933358669281,
-0.039802804589271545,
-0.09229715913534164,
-0.009108931757509708,
0.042446769773960114,
0.0018458504928275943,
-0.016454005613923073,
0.010904274880886078,
0.029498010873794556,
-0.0142027223482728,
0.024848412722349167,
-0.010060838423669338,
0.019412169232964516,
-0.06161486729979515,
-0.013643953949213028,
-0.0697321891784668,
0.05741199105978012,
-0.04287431016564369,
0.008959457278251648,
-0.030575012788176537,
-0.029895734041929245,
-0.025657014921307564,
-0.01233706809580326,
-0.011203986592590809,
0.010154585354030132,
-0.007847307249903679,
0.005080192815512419
] |
323 |
Langevin Soft Actor-Critic: Efficient Exploration through Uncertainty-Driven Critic Learning
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=FvQsk3la17
|
[
"Haque Ishfaq",
"Guangyuan Wang",
"Sami Nur Islam",
"Doina Precup"
] |
Poster
|
Existing actor-critic algorithms, which are popular for continuous control reinforcement learning (RL) tasks, suffer from poor sample efficiency due to lack of principled exploration mechanism within them. Motivated by the success of Thompson sampling for efficient exploration in RL, we propose a novel model-free RL algorithm, \emph{Langevin Soft Actor Critic} (LSAC), which prioritizes enhancing critic learning through uncertainty estimation over policy optimization. LSAC employs three key innovations: approximate Thompson sampling through distributional Langevin Monte Carlo (LMC) based $Q$ updates, parallel tempering for exploring multiple modes of the posterior of the $Q$ function, and diffusion synthesized state-action samples regularized with $Q$ action gradients. Our extensive experiments demonstrate that LSAC outperforms or matches the performance of mainstream model-free RL algorithms for continuous control tasks.
Notably, LSAC marks the first successful application of an LMC based Thompson sampling in continuous control tasks with continuous action spaces.
|
Actor-Critic, Exploration, Reinforcement Learning, Thompson Sampling, Langevin Monte Carlo, Deep Reinforcement learning, Continuous Control
|
We propose a principled exploration approach for actor-critic algorithms through critic learning using approximate Thompson sampling
| 13,486 | null |
[
-0.006885150447487831,
-0.013265660032629967,
0.001259344513528049,
0.029593342915177345,
0.062366507947444916,
0.018276046961545944,
0.01967833936214447,
-0.015506822615861893,
-0.031711943447589874,
-0.035672202706336975,
0.016685141250491142,
0.033851392567157745,
-0.07285427302122116,
-0.013986730948090553,
0.021640844643115997,
0.06297163665294647,
0.022471588104963303,
0.002409197622910142,
0.003893957007676363,
0.021448999643325806,
-0.014230707660317421,
-0.005571635439991951,
0.04464792087674141,
0.017576484009623528,
0.02665378898382187,
0.00803191028535366,
0.025822538882493973,
0.03892320394515991,
-0.019079262390732765,
-0.006313110236078501,
0.021314265206456184,
-0.01988057792186737,
0.006157020106911659,
-0.024308739230036736,
-0.0046312808990478516,
0.00867066066712141,
-0.02117026224732399,
0.002734554698690772,
0.006388674024492502,
-0.002581313718110323,
-0.036946941167116165,
0.00558949401602149,
-0.017420949414372444,
-0.00023258395958691835,
-0.030420852825045586,
0.014940651133656502,
-0.0633753165602684,
0.019394975155591965,
0.028353767469525337,
-0.05445298179984093,
-0.09257986396551132,
0.032570790499448776,
0.04046931490302086,
-0.029374537989497185,
-0.002078851219266653,
0.025933263823390007,
0.053955331444740295,
-0.10737294703722,
-0.017681598663330078,
-0.08757397532463074,
-0.0203629732131958,
-0.0019351225346326828,
0.01708250306546688,
-0.0028225374408066273,
-0.0024368693120777607,
0.04188064858317375,
0.034623321145772934,
0.03852325305342674,
-0.022967396304011345,
-0.0024954453110694885,
-0.029651831835508347,
-0.012477300129830837,
0.01164029911160469,
0.011498916894197464,
-0.007310379296541214,
-0.03784516826272011,
0.01607700251042843,
0.041157741099596024,
0.06994398683309555,
0.010283209383487701,
0.017427785322070122,
0.013407191261649132,
0.0064666783437132835,
0.04249901697039604,
0.021064849570393562,
0.029434194788336754,
-0.011829986236989498,
-0.012008060701191425,
-0.07222730666399002,
0.033513277769088745,
-0.047902680933475494,
-0.0636526569724083,
0.01883087307214737,
0.03666200116276741,
0.03403884917497635,
-0.024814270436763763,
0.012230844236910343,
0.03849688544869423,
0.013564725406467915,
-0.009865015745162964,
-0.021201999858021736,
-0.01831897161900997,
0.007657374255359173,
-0.007150376681238413,
-0.09785812348127365,
-0.015891678631305695,
-0.018835481256246567,
0.0005955050000920892,
-0.03255007416009903,
0.044561564922332764,
-0.049813978374004364,
-0.01634196937084198,
0.0009038001880981028,
-0.04674737527966499,
-0.08927971869707108,
0.017585838213562965,
0.0024449301417917013,
0.01582089066505432,
0.029201025143265724,
0.012917234562337399,
0.044941920787096024,
0.05688297376036644,
0.018209846690297127,
0.05780606344342232,
-0.0023092341143637896,
0.02157597430050373,
0.021757883951067924,
0.028344497084617615,
0.013037621043622494,
-0.04199203848838806,
0.042716339230537415,
0.04801173508167267,
-0.02177114598453045,
0.0013664819998666644,
-0.02577594295144081,
0.0017271224642172456,
0.02659374289214611,
0.033786341547966,
-0.013878467492759228,
0.0008103682775981724,
0.011570333503186703,
-0.0366392619907856,
0.07871518284082413,
-0.017271945253014565,
0.062980517745018,
-0.01590672694146633,
0.014511209912598133,
-0.04450526833534241,
-0.07897397130727768,
-0.015346097759902477,
0.0027232361026108265,
-0.015824012458324432,
-0.01916477456688881,
-0.027186641469597816,
-0.0038123915437608957,
0.009995000436902046,
0.025173518806695938,
0.02258012630045414,
0.017145324498414993,
-0.0013833421980962157,
0.033572353422641754,
0.004943968262523413,
-0.023353729397058487,
-0.023696288466453552,
0.004681057296693325,
-0.10294365882873535,
0.0407741405069828,
0.03341120854020119,
-0.01083702128380537,
-0.01148052979260683,
-0.04231056571006775,
-0.030858945101499557,
0.026036012917757034,
0.00044273416278883815,
-0.012676404789090157,
0.027012759819626808,
0.045526325702667236,
-0.008625522255897522,
0.05157729238271713,
0.016919096931815147,
-0.07173453271389008,
0.023326897993683815,
0.0029793137218803167,
-0.02167317643761635,
0.01720225065946579,
-0.04263545945286751,
0.05658108741044998,
-0.014583680778741837,
0.033170104026794434,
0.01649581827223301,
-0.0617162324488163,
-0.0054902127012610435,
0.023029346019029617,
-0.0021334511693567038,
0.04801581799983978,
0.005780092440545559,
-0.018020881339907646,
0.025516284629702568,
0.028175877407193184,
0.04539968818426132,
0.03211256489157677,
-0.026497239246964455,
0.030228182673454285,
-0.012779035605490208,
-0.027181224897503853,
-0.015737373381853104,
0.03930901736021042,
-0.030288608744740486,
-0.017594514414668083,
0.014999426901340485,
-0.015642831102013588,
0.025380020961165428,
0.006930692121386528,
0.006869732402265072,
0.02407703548669815,
0.00038539807428605855,
0.0014359232736751437,
0.008988115936517715,
0.019543442875146866,
-0.035103216767311096,
0.014662607572972775,
0.005582683254033327,
-0.02811119146645069,
0.007149500772356987,
-0.021899046376347542,
0.08903264254331589,
0.07426601648330688,
-0.03101985715329647,
-0.030280623584985733,
0.015686921775341034,
-0.013417044654488564,
-0.0005447677103802562,
0.0048970854841172695,
-0.02852863445878029,
0.016450662165880203,
-0.011835074052214622,
0.03507426381111145,
-0.0592770017683506,
0.03687159717082977,
-0.03529536724090576,
0.005419348366558552,
0.08236348628997803,
-0.0040126522071659565,
0.06314753741025925,
-0.021834291517734528,
0.012380079366266727,
0.03590802475810051,
0.021703526377677917,
-0.028664199635386467,
-0.00044704420724883676,
-0.0425594188272953,
-0.0003635848988778889,
0.04472442716360092,
-0.012521009892225266,
-0.006347164046019316,
-0.0531066469848156,
-0.04629893600940704,
-0.006605394184589386,
0.07683193683624268,
0.06656578928232193,
0.021856093779206276,
0.027844272553920746,
-0.007006671279668808,
-0.008096624165773392,
-0.04731637239456177,
-0.10303930938243866,
-0.026582546532154083,
0.004392847418785095,
0.012513116002082825,
0.04180197790265083,
0.0045014736242592335,
-0.025956129655241966,
0.043250344693660736,
-0.0017063769046217203,
0.00020552569185383618,
0.024702390655875206,
0.012272941879928112,
0.05182093381881714,
-0.011939714662730694,
-0.018461482599377632,
0.008424917235970497,
0.0894084945321083,
0.012585300020873547,
-0.010184521786868572,
0.006326282862573862,
-0.05346190184354782,
-0.00789064634591341,
0.009357074275612831,
0.01311536692082882,
0.011065788567066193,
0.016655724495649338,
0.0030773512553423643,
-0.034203361719846725,
0.0161662045866251,
0.014510676264762878,
0.04782912880182266,
0.037901073694229126,
0.0272445697337389,
-0.01897498592734337,
-0.0020985316950827837,
-0.02114841341972351,
-0.005042990669608116,
-0.045217860490083694,
0.005966034717857838,
0.0065735261887311935,
-0.014161120168864727,
0.027503112331032753,
0.025263335555791855,
-0.25108516216278076,
-0.02514703758060932,
0.03557051345705986,
0.03679554536938667,
0.022611957043409348,
0.01918700523674488,
0.048298366367816925,
-0.05211181193590164,
-0.044745370745658875,
0.015924010425806046,
0.017032073810696602,
0.015293885953724384,
-0.0025488852988928556,
0.06629893183708191,
0.05911843478679657,
0.03345607966184616,
-0.007374155335128307,
-0.019228782504796982,
0.0025827488861978054,
-0.003814119379967451,
-0.010051554068922997,
-0.06819117814302444,
-0.004738873802125454,
0.009876667521893978,
0.0195167139172554,
0.05183187872171402,
-0.08657044917345047,
0.011838388629257679,
-0.02362564392387867,
0.0007735216640867293,
-0.07418953627347946,
0.0024752572644501925,
-0.051941465586423874,
0.00997958518564701,
0.030463749542832375,
0.026013681665062904,
0.04826141893863678,
-0.007109641097486019,
0.015410239808261395,
-0.002734326058998704,
0.0053170910105109215,
0.01982315629720688,
-0.07174652069807053,
0.0044969539158046246,
0.06398597359657288,
0.024735169485211372,
-0.03978116810321808,
-0.00521412817761302,
-0.007394781336188316,
0.03967168927192688,
0.01909606344997883,
-0.023539818823337555,
0.010204553604125977,
-0.004621998406946659,
0.02785332314670086,
0.003429681295529008,
-0.005767321214079857,
-0.024712195619940758,
-0.003609943203628063,
0.01425598468631506,
0.0017685177735984325,
-0.04837126284837723,
-0.01256284024566412,
-0.0157335065305233,
-0.0028560033533722162,
-0.04463914781808853,
-0.051214832812547684,
-0.061711929738521576,
0.04734396934509277,
0.02310929447412491,
0.0020731219556182623,
-0.03611065447330475,
-0.018634075298905373,
-0.10614585876464844,
0.025363588705658913,
-0.027172042056918144,
-0.001077532535418868,
-0.06280810385942459,
0.03359048068523407,
0.045644551515579224,
-0.03425315394997597,
-0.031897079199552536,
-0.007720180321484804,
0.023755203932523727,
0.030245013535022736,
-0.008339365012943745,
0.034574445337057114,
-0.04151046276092529,
-0.02181016467511654,
-0.053303591907024384,
0.018256867304444313,
0.017539050430059433,
0.02538875862956047,
-0.04311925917863846,
0.027631336823105812,
0.020371679216623306,
0.020289311185479164,
0.015384338796138763,
0.003128836629912257,
-0.0191057026386261,
0.022525591775774956,
-0.0919213593006134,
0.009366247802972794,
-0.05354851484298706,
-0.023415246978402138,
0.004829992074519396,
-0.06213333457708359,
-0.028989152982831,
0.03157368674874306,
0.02588999830186367,
-0.006784556433558464,
-0.03589683398604393,
0.025697816163301468,
0.004966786131262779,
-0.005811304319649935,
-0.013200357556343079,
-0.017755022272467613,
0.055247317999601364,
0.020444650202989578,
-0.003421675181016326,
-0.05514125898480415,
0.03816599398851395,
-0.05680430680513382,
0.01040250901132822,
-0.00858730636537075,
-0.02216148190200329,
0.03870384767651558,
-0.011684367433190346,
-0.016079943627119064,
-0.00218597031198442,
0.018234966322779655,
0.058663178235292435,
0.020916853100061417,
0.01512390561401844,
0.053456418216228485,
-0.0033805035054683685,
-0.031632617115974426,
-0.015673361718654633,
0.04234214499592781,
-0.010441447608172894,
-0.004242685157805681,
-0.008908660151064396,
0.027566686272621155,
0.0388554111123085,
0.03352619335055351,
0.02725703828036785,
0.03296492621302605,
0.027897268533706665,
0.03062104992568493,
0.023975582793354988,
0.05241422355175018,
-0.055375706404447556,
-0.02470291405916214,
-0.003454154124483466,
0.037310779094696045,
-0.010659676976501942,
0.02357073687016964,
-0.02415502816438675,
0.038266658782958984,
-0.05368340015411377,
0.023944048210978508,
0.013436228968203068,
-0.04064954072237015,
0.018744589760899544,
0.046265631914138794,
0.03735358640551567,
-0.0521523617208004,
0.0005641459138132632,
0.02176528237760067,
0.0023820605129003525,
0.002710937289521098,
-0.03876545652747154,
-0.025704490020871162,
-0.032047562301158905,
-0.016272036358714104,
-0.023192573338747025,
0.01908041350543499,
-0.08106821030378342,
-0.04129456356167793,
0.025313038378953934,
0.0037320218980312347,
-0.05367431044578552,
-0.026611538603901863,
-0.014603931456804276,
0.06334276497364044,
-0.02099969983100891,
-0.0101486686617136,
-0.014058089815080166,
-0.03921660780906677,
0.024739613756537437,
0.025732554495334625,
0.033965814858675,
-0.013124467805027962,
-0.04340866208076477,
-0.017134353518486023,
-0.03289157152175903,
0.011639256030321121,
0.017010729759931564,
-0.018324509263038635,
-0.0005017665680497885,
0.021086249500513077,
0.0019521433860063553,
-0.023509150370955467,
-0.0012488400097936392,
-0.005534451454877853,
-0.0504588782787323,
0.007226608693599701,
0.04531025514006615,
-0.00564564997330308,
0.06646689772605896,
-0.07942552119493484,
-0.04832608625292778,
-0.025548335164785385,
-0.014079022221267223,
0.00214008498005569,
-0.03386712446808815,
-0.023289944976568222,
-0.017739808186888695,
-0.003839540295302868,
0.019536249339580536,
0.0067120143212378025,
-0.02290501818060875,
0.002240388421341777,
-0.03890440985560417,
0.011006291024386883,
0.03698553517460823,
-0.055642206221818924,
-0.02509397640824318,
0.021744294092059135,
0.013569321483373642,
0.02632463164627552,
-0.03654368221759796,
0.009152808226644993,
0.029741914942860603,
-0.03850298374891281,
0.022748930379748344,
-0.07123103737831116,
0.054106760770082474,
-0.008018706925213337,
-0.04409037157893181,
-0.01798039674758911,
0.04377661272883415,
-0.061444833874702454,
-0.020868055522441864,
-0.028925318270921707,
0.017567096278071404,
0.03319330886006355,
0.016283491626381874,
0.021625110879540443,
0.0159896370023489,
0.026208927854895592,
0.020095327869057655,
-0.05507740378379822,
0.024933306500315666,
0.06110864877700806,
-0.011522295884788036,
-0.014798850752413273,
-0.054965440183877945,
-0.015497660264372826,
0.01988234370946884,
-0.042528629302978516,
0.010310277342796326,
-0.038408782333135605,
0.025664210319519043,
0.02216576598584652,
0.03414526209235191,
0.010129476897418499,
-0.03645436093211174,
0.005278380122035742,
-0.08771193027496338,
0.0031248400919139385,
-0.06802621483802795,
-0.016453320160508156,
0.06197301298379898,
-0.039438359439373016,
0.013626855798065662,
0.06187855452299118,
-0.048723313957452774,
0.055219635367393494,
-0.04221750795841217,
-0.06872772425413132,
0.03646745905280113,
-0.03351326659321785,
0.0035096921492367983,
0.02719326689839363,
-0.06688759475946426,
-0.05482690781354904,
-0.010876558721065521,
-0.055874500423669815,
0.01573578454554081,
0.006684566382318735,
0.03191978484392166,
-0.022105464711785316,
-0.005490196868777275,
-0.05466237664222717,
0.035179998725652695,
0.009590803645551205,
0.04222923889756203,
0.015383930876851082,
-0.0009018191485665739,
-0.07314487546682358,
0.06636461615562439,
0.04471981152892113,
0.035291437059640884,
0.007738234009593725,
-0.005693653132766485,
-0.022434603422880173,
-0.022829389199614525,
0.045992422848939896,
-0.02071535959839821,
-0.004512741230428219,
-0.06266054511070251,
0.0356951504945755,
0.037323612719774246,
-0.07191488891839981,
-0.02659839391708374,
0.023390332236886024,
-0.07077660411596298,
-0.01661486178636551,
0.008263872936367989,
0.020270688459277153,
0.030737198889255524,
0.0788666158914566,
0.028609970584511757,
0.05577346682548523,
0.05993901193141937,
0.021620476618409157,
0.01684069260954857,
0.005064237862825394,
0.06726039946079254,
0.07566320151090622,
0.038152895867824554,
-0.043561968952417374,
0.0643872618675232,
-0.05230794847011566,
-0.03009522333741188,
0.050601307302713394,
0.00022742472356185317,
-0.028379077091813087,
-0.06206446513533592,
0.02531074732542038,
0.05574958026409149,
-0.01038445346057415,
0.06106379255652428,
-0.051700569689273834,
-0.05859399959445,
0.05395996943116188,
-0.018377508968114853,
-0.009864442981779575,
0.02335488423705101,
0.020842483267188072,
0.01601848378777504,
-0.0029347941745072603,
-0.02926282025873661,
0.020714115351438522,
-0.008796235546469688,
0.01041380874812603,
-0.005289088934659958,
-0.02423390932381153,
-0.007753191515803337,
0.022828347980976105,
0.03549506515264511,
0.11263269186019897,
-0.05475222319364548,
0.00437112245708704,
0.02078082598745823,
0.0018130148528143764,
-0.0211747158318758,
0.05047833174467087,
0.03000100702047348,
0.0022452755365520716,
0.018277600407600403,
-0.04852597787976265,
0.013368215411901474,
0.04491366073489189,
0.0041189659386873245,
0.006578931584954262,
-0.025422073900699615,
-0.019317572936415672,
0.03286360576748848,
-0.0007725553005002439,
-0.03528837114572525,
-0.03341097757220268,
-0.033663857728242874,
-0.05111744627356529,
-0.05268797650933266,
-0.0746707171201706,
0.014340916648507118,
-0.003590654581785202,
-0.02739964984357357,
0.022755393758416176,
-0.04693380370736122,
0.03215789794921875,
-0.002143565099686384,
-0.03949218615889549,
-0.006906168535351753,
0.025462370365858078,
-0.00542784808203578,
0.008963542059063911,
0.014792720787227154,
0.039159297943115234,
0.021231042221188545,
-0.026287224143743515,
0.022933626547455788,
0.04087623208761215,
0.020779142156243324,
-0.0369887575507164,
-0.007944274693727493,
-0.09427476674318314,
-0.01569386012852192,
0.03885814920067787,
-0.015065908432006836,
-0.07374711334705353,
0.03414811193943024,
-0.07652002573013306,
0.02520713582634926,
0.06381712108850479,
0.002285013673827052,
0.02221229113638401,
-0.036675676703453064,
-0.034018561244010925,
0.01369214616715908,
0.019559327512979507,
0.033897221088409424,
-0.05029824748635292,
0.041528671979904175,
0.04373465105891228,
-0.042109210044145584,
-0.06363358348608017,
0.0476660430431366,
-0.003692941041663289,
-0.005637960508465767,
-0.0073858886025846004,
-0.01226423867046833,
-0.02869056537747383,
-0.11088375747203827,
-0.018171753734350204,
0.054272815585136414,
0.024032507091760635,
-0.03140958026051521,
0.027883917093276978,
-0.001893478911370039,
0.006525853183120489,
0.009423794224858284,
-0.011715946719050407,
-0.03304823860526085,
-0.04090293124318123,
-0.01431980635970831,
-0.059727743268013,
0.017509354278445244,
-0.029448000714182854,
-0.014440251514315605,
-0.014924122020602226,
-0.04821694269776344,
-0.006497523281723261,
0.00576674472540617,
0.0012412745272740722,
0.01734238490462303,
-0.004777018912136555,
-0.005538807716220617
] |
324 |
Searching for Optimal Solutions with LLMs via Bayesian Optimization
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=aVfDrl7xDV
|
[
"Dhruv Agarwal",
"Manoj Ghuhan Arivazhagan",
"Rajarshi Das",
"Sandesh Swamy",
"Sopan Khosla",
"Rashmi Gangadharaiah"
] |
Poster
|
Scaling test-time compute to search for optimal solutions is an important step towards building generally-capable language models that can reason. Recent work, however, shows that tasks of varying complexity require distinct search strategies to solve optimally, thus making it challenging to design a one-size-fits-all approach. Prior solutions either attempt to predict task difficulty to select the optimal search strategy, often infeasible in practice, or use a static, pre-defined strategy, e.g., repeated parallel sampling or greedy sequential search, which is sub-optimal. In this work, we argue for an alternative view using the probabilistic framework of Bayesian optimization (BO), where the search strategy is adapted dynamically based on the evolving uncertainty estimates of solutions as search progresses. To this end, we introduce Bayesian-OPRO (BOPRO)––a generalization of a recent method for in-context optimization, which iteratively samples from new proposal distributions by modifying the prompt to the LLM with a subset of its previous generations selected to explore or exploit different parts of the search space. We evaluate our method on word search, molecule optimization, and a joint hypothesis+program search task using a 1-D version of the challenging Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (1D-ARC). Our results show that BOPRO outperforms all baselines in word search (≥10 points) and molecule optimization (higher quality and 17% fewer invalid molecules), but trails a best-k prompting strategy in program search. Our analysis reveals that despite the ability to balance exploration and exploitation using BOPRO, failure is likely due to the inability of code representation models in distinguishing sequences with low edit-distances.
|
search, optimization, LLMs, test-time steering, bayesian optimization, reasoning
|
We present Bayesian-OPRO (BOPRO), a method for generating optimal solutions with LLMs via Bayesian optimization that explores and exploits the search space based on evolving uncertainty estimates of the solution space as search progresses.
| 13,475 | null |
[
-0.024495741352438927,
0.017761994153261185,
0.006341944448649883,
0.03896447271108627,
0.056881677359342575,
0.028343942016363144,
0.03342815861105919,
0.020020149648189545,
-0.013829133473336697,
-0.02064596861600876,
-0.00979510135948658,
0.035261619836091995,
-0.05890277028083801,
-0.012243042699992657,
0.012561557814478874,
0.06087610870599747,
0.01243302971124649,
0.013905387371778488,
0.03178517147898674,
-0.0037270067259669304,
0.014948719181120396,
0.0025512247812002897,
0.02598898485302925,
0.020301619544625282,
0.05131983384490013,
0.025784941390156746,
0.013206404633820057,
0.018452204763889313,
-0.028362128883600235,
-0.022784577682614326,
0.01860462874174118,
-0.016984129324555397,
0.02151680923998356,
-0.012584472075104713,
0.0009925778722390532,
0.015010328032076359,
-0.05309554189443588,
0.010979008860886097,
-0.007211967837065458,
0.023280322551727295,
-0.06713002175092697,
0.03738512471318245,
-0.01928500458598137,
0.02559772878885269,
-0.03922167420387268,
0.01841839589178562,
-0.09693349897861481,
0.030066054314374924,
0.01058889925479889,
-0.041057951748371124,
-0.10638236254453659,
0.040264252573251724,
0.01609465666115284,
-0.02909761853516102,
-0.016412707045674324,
0.03467694669961929,
0.05542463809251785,
-0.08662862330675125,
-0.0031501329503953457,
-0.04520797356963158,
-0.0490533821284771,
0.02323256805539131,
-0.006340432912111282,
0.02351534180343151,
0.0067626540549099445,
-0.02467714250087738,
0.009716356173157692,
0.04277482256293297,
-0.07569268345832825,
-0.019306901842355728,
-0.050406716763973236,
0.0006129172979854047,
-0.004217429086565971,
0.0012873031664639711,
0.0037744930014014244,
-0.020890483632683754,
0.003765352303162217,
0.03215697035193443,
0.0352693572640419,
0.024067120626568794,
-0.007876674644649029,
0.034688014537096024,
0.016236599534749985,
0.03223990648984909,
0.012497633695602417,
0.02517782524228096,
-0.04260699823498726,
-0.022695263847708702,
-0.08549582213163376,
0.036680158227682114,
0.035184334963560104,
-0.06868433952331543,
0.011111174710094929,
0.03449244797229767,
0.026377862319350243,
-0.0037588607519865036,
0.03377781808376312,
0.022808561101555824,
-0.02767675742506981,
0.0069474950432777405,
-0.033654388040304184,
-0.03610612079501152,
0.03595731407403946,
-0.005405903793871403,
-0.12436401098966599,
-0.00928185973316431,
-0.01872282475233078,
-0.004791733343154192,
-0.013719073496758938,
0.007153556682169437,
-0.015029949136078358,
0.0011906800791621208,
0.015672553330659866,
-0.0008342252112925053,
-0.07667241990566254,
0.026792196556925774,
0.00374598428606987,
0.04390504211187363,
0.0006780367693863809,
0.006620639003813267,
0.025105111300945282,
0.049259256571531296,
-0.0023481477983295918,
0.058496154844760895,
-0.0061202580109238625,
0.0026226623449474573,
0.023028593510389328,
0.028870901092886925,
-0.036971565335989,
-0.03950009122490883,
0.004240995738655329,
0.038999516516923904,
0.012400844134390354,
-0.011089896783232689,
-0.017451653257012367,
0.0041201235726475716,
0.004475916735827923,
0.030665062367916107,
0.03177831321954727,
-0.004964315798133612,
-0.01884479634463787,
-0.004541768692433834,
0.06749868392944336,
-0.008057231083512306,
0.0589594841003418,
-0.015723135322332382,
-0.012021311558783054,
-0.023715103045105934,
-0.03817667067050934,
0.000031239142117556185,
0.010129788890480995,
0.0041151028126478195,
0.000008665884706715588,
-0.06645149737596512,
0.021865027025341988,
0.07235133647918701,
0.02373824082314968,
0.0014165713218972087,
0.0024369140155613422,
-0.001753246528096497,
0.006293207406997681,
0.01103997603058815,
-0.06524738669395447,
0.02143530547618866,
-0.00412055803462863,
-0.05136757716536522,
0.034158043563365936,
0.05088163912296295,
-0.062091466039419174,
0.011042666621506214,
-0.03030262142419815,
-0.042504288256168365,
0.07722073793411255,
-0.03120875544846058,
-0.024739768356084824,
-0.017668332904577255,
0.07218515872955322,
-0.011902808211743832,
0.055271148681640625,
0.00844553392380476,
-0.07596316933631897,
0.005098923109471798,
0.011771529912948608,
0.008608109317719936,
0.0261888038367033,
-0.03274880722165108,
0.09730903059244156,
-0.013187099248170853,
0.01843692734837532,
0.020227741450071335,
-0.061951540410518646,
-0.022178323939442635,
0.03887581825256348,
-0.0018355114152655005,
0.07005826383829117,
-0.017599398270249367,
-0.011805965565145016,
0.054504990577697754,
0.019990453496575356,
0.04335840791463852,
0.04607030749320984,
0.009798950515687466,
0.042108409106731415,
-0.02365700714290142,
-0.04551567882299423,
-0.002908482449129224,
0.05910010635852814,
-0.0615779384970665,
-0.018582167103886604,
0.03773421421647072,
-0.016871187835931778,
0.01819121651351452,
-0.00141379632987082,
-0.00832962803542614,
0.03709099441766739,
-0.03907915949821472,
0.0015111815882846713,
-0.018724914640188217,
0.01755112037062645,
-0.04264667257666588,
0.01393305417150259,
0.008189824409782887,
-0.0007053181761875749,
-0.005419669207185507,
-0.01715504378080368,
0.08136329799890518,
0.06659341603517532,
-0.052229177206754684,
-0.028002904728055,
0.020702240988612175,
0.03748735040426254,
0.005134309642016888,
0.03275582939386368,
-0.02782842144370079,
0.0022796420380473137,
-0.03208707645535469,
-0.006837360095232725,
-0.029995523393154144,
0.04513564333319664,
-0.03104851208627224,
-0.027163518592715263,
0.04964231327176094,
-0.0267246775329113,
0.0597471259534359,
-0.024111071601510048,
0.0013472134014591575,
0.04497940465807915,
-0.004225199110805988,
-0.025243114680051804,
-0.021376125514507294,
-0.01921396702528,
0.003125515766441822,
-0.02686689980328083,
0.005422858987003565,
0.006148865446448326,
-0.0646248534321785,
-0.00741120520979166,
-0.013075613416731358,
0.06855971366167068,
0.06401531398296356,
-0.009762070141732693,
0.030033988878130913,
0.02747746743261814,
-0.03426518663764,
0.0008471761830151081,
-0.10869869589805603,
-0.021082157269120216,
-0.030208049342036247,
-0.0004762491153087467,
0.029350873082876205,
0.015924911946058273,
-0.001998588675633073,
0.030947182327508926,
-0.03889614716172218,
-0.0181750375777483,
-0.0037843212485313416,
0.022145317867398262,
-0.006842771545052528,
-0.029158147051930428,
-0.021678423509001732,
0.013132496736943722,
0.050533708184957504,
-0.037387747317552567,
-0.010388825088739395,
-0.04944148659706116,
-0.04895036295056343,
-0.025605544447898865,
-0.05913734808564186,
0.0018760612001642585,
0.039652179926633835,
0.0005587777704931796,
-0.0021423627622425556,
-0.034746505320072174,
0.028912793844938278,
0.051012441515922546,
0.009401666931807995,
0.06135181710124016,
0.017419962212443352,
-0.02817934937775135,
0.02709970809519291,
-0.008600099012255669,
0.010414094664156437,
-0.026871349662542343,
0.016849985346198082,
-0.007006615400314331,
0.003944890573620796,
0.011406134814023972,
0.009223772212862968,
-0.2505812346935272,
-0.018363822251558304,
-0.024964556097984314,
-0.03464214876294136,
0.028946615755558014,
-0.006836456712335348,
0.03155884891748428,
-0.04684792459011078,
-0.024313105270266533,
0.0017981305718421936,
-0.0002495031803846359,
0.04474128782749176,
0.005403082352131605,
0.06660312414169312,
0.058561742305755615,
0.03761221468448639,
-0.022229041904211044,
-0.015421122312545776,
0.0018226609099656343,
0.020352698862552643,
0.018403643742203712,
-0.05495598912239075,
-0.012558110058307648,
0.033230312168598175,
0.0055869449861347675,
0.06840947270393372,
-0.07348188757896423,
0.004036610946059227,
-0.028879284858703613,
0.0009918201249092817,
-0.04748942330479622,
-0.030778398737311363,
-0.021275272592902184,
0.02257753349840641,
0.014351367950439453,
0.01695931702852249,
0.043363168835639954,
-0.030697612091898918,
0.04138091951608658,
0.05542890727519989,
0.017373528331518173,
-0.023906689137220383,
-0.0547003298997879,
-0.019144702702760696,
0.047355666756629944,
0.008968431502580643,
-0.059227246791124344,
-0.004042023792862892,
-0.015107459388673306,
0.041171617805957794,
-0.015371039509773254,
-0.04373723268508911,
-0.021855542436242104,
0.009471471421420574,
0.04461183398962021,
-0.015919875353574753,
0.03826116397976875,
-0.048443589359521866,
-0.016195528209209442,
-0.011452148668467999,
-0.004157413728535175,
-0.02873380109667778,
-0.02917073294520378,
-0.03761718049645424,
-0.0195172019302845,
-0.03932090103626251,
-0.05482606589794159,
-0.0371098667383194,
0.040996525436639786,
0.0462157279253006,
-0.00623761210590601,
0.008583060465753078,
-0.01701904833316803,
-0.09153948724269867,
-0.012282680720090866,
0.026657791808247566,
-0.00883029866963625,
-0.0034529182594269514,
-0.012879760935902596,
0.024972308427095413,
-0.0574350506067276,
-0.03303807973861694,
-0.013803921639919281,
0.040044523775577545,
0.04383348673582077,
-0.055574897676706314,
-0.012584280222654343,
-0.01850203610956669,
-0.022672956809401512,
-0.03838155046105385,
0.023220647126436234,
0.008146483451128006,
0.021070662885904312,
0.0034889853559434414,
0.04810640588402748,
0.017527300864458084,
0.031231507658958435,
0.054006826132535934,
0.03765008598566055,
0.007690887898206711,
0.01576496660709381,
-0.05439594015479088,
-0.004589378368109465,
-0.017397882416844368,
-0.039341773837804794,
0.016311457380652428,
-0.07375336438417435,
-0.01910233125090599,
0.02324734628200531,
-0.0014373378362506628,
-0.0419432707130909,
-0.024900922551751137,
0.0054917242377996445,
-0.000657435564789921,
-0.017695432528853416,
-0.015649016946554184,
0.019856499508023262,
0.04614219069480896,
0.01800520345568657,
-0.009540972299873829,
-0.048520274460315704,
0.033615805208683014,
-0.022852817550301552,
-0.00996387004852295,
-0.00973082147538662,
-0.021282240748405457,
0.003969151061028242,
-0.017989620566368103,
-0.017524678260087967,
0.008952291682362556,
0.025636890903115273,
0.03805602714419365,
0.006709257140755653,
-0.00525135500356555,
0.0455007329583168,
-0.016152488067746162,
-0.013027680106461048,
-0.020778900012373924,
0.03920246660709381,
-0.021436087787151337,
0.0015103539917618036,
-0.016325097531080246,
0.05098894611001015,
0.024020865559577942,
0.036325853317976,
0.02895364537835121,
0.03209318965673447,
0.01950843073427677,
0.00972568616271019,
0.022151552140712738,
0.02836715616285801,
-0.047514282166957855,
0.0010657745879143476,
-0.02226182259619236,
0.04911740496754646,
-0.038905251771211624,
0.036666139960289,
-0.01752052642405033,
0.03710120916366577,
-0.06747737526893616,
0.03238840773701668,
-0.011325446888804436,
-0.00447981059551239,
0.018797919154167175,
0.022227277979254723,
0.05178672447800636,
-0.03616756573319435,
0.025128083303570747,
-0.004897209350019693,
0.01827014423906803,
0.0117061547935009,
-0.04795435443520546,
-0.04915674403309822,
0.004289809614419937,
-0.038538169115781784,
0.0011341468198224902,
0.021871721372008324,
-0.015803754329681396,
-0.05485925078392029,
0.041534390300512314,
0.007184156682342291,
-0.04512849450111389,
-0.01709686405956745,
0.007213256787508726,
0.09625613689422607,
-0.02010333351790905,
0.014954130165278912,
-0.007861869409680367,
-0.050574466586112976,
0.010363049805164337,
-0.008884970098733902,
0.00797454733401537,
-0.002592572709545493,
-0.036540716886520386,
-0.042234599590301514,
-0.05741693824529648,
0.033076681196689606,
0.017072046175599098,
-0.009071484208106995,
-0.009781665168702602,
-0.004703480284661055,
0.0018913050880655646,
-0.0533677339553833,
-0.029562178999185562,
0.04101132974028587,
-0.0780186578631401,
0.012092381715774536,
0.028990698978304863,
-0.015407189726829529,
0.0537818968296051,
-0.04156428948044777,
-0.03481055051088333,
-0.04566614329814911,
0.015851974487304688,
0.011882452294230461,
-0.022264201194047928,
-0.030520841479301453,
-0.0007503398810513318,
0.024141261354088783,
0.006800290197134018,
-0.002541656605899334,
-0.015008121728897095,
0.015965929254889488,
-0.030500521883368492,
0.01710628531873226,
0.06737709790468216,
-0.03557465597987175,
-0.025930674746632576,
0.021463792771100998,
-0.04549303650856018,
0.03595198318362236,
-0.07525911927223206,
0.009451602585613728,
0.054121315479278564,
0.0033494627568870783,
0.02089335024356842,
-0.03371329605579376,
0.03220898658037186,
0.0065955547615885735,
-0.003308474086225033,
0.021546054631471634,
-0.009943165816366673,
-0.019983958452939987,
0.0015083375619724393,
0.002921364502981305,
0.04658476263284683,
0.02586837112903595,
0.0024792314507067204,
-0.015450900420546532,
0.019733598455786705,
-0.01446074154227972,
0.021208683028817177,
-0.046306807547807693,
-0.018497416749596596,
0.06484079360961914,
0.02465025521814823,
-0.060231588780879974,
-0.06680639833211899,
-0.04692576080560684,
0.013156131841242313,
-0.015883339568972588,
0.023774800822138786,
-0.06478287279605865,
0.036406733095645905,
0.006308534182608128,
0.03193618729710579,
0.002287680981680751,
-0.029259221628308296,
0.050030164420604706,
-0.05195924639701843,
0.020397726446390152,
-0.05888941138982773,
-0.012815362773835659,
0.08077265322208405,
-0.03044435754418373,
0.015494079329073429,
-0.002596439328044653,
-0.027886664494872093,
0.047966085374355316,
-0.004055500030517578,
-0.04800812527537346,
0.03359149768948555,
-0.019211215898394585,
-0.009852014482021332,
0.07394666969776154,
-0.057280283421278,
-0.014909560792148113,
-0.015298305079340935,
-0.022587159648537636,
0.00048446684377267957,
0.016735240817070007,
0.06982257217168808,
-0.02584095671772957,
-0.0025563491508364677,
-0.03696959465742111,
0.003145470516756177,
0.021526891738176346,
0.05601657181978226,
0.007039709948003292,
0.02330571971833706,
-0.03642312064766884,
0.05116694048047066,
0.06710341572761536,
0.03665134310722351,
-0.010733122006058693,
0.008933772332966328,
-0.02880295366048813,
-0.046627819538116455,
0.045035652816295624,
-0.010308568365871906,
0.007392208091914654,
-0.0326843187212944,
0.0838969275355339,
0.03974448889493942,
-0.04905981570482254,
-0.02467234805226326,
0.023652272298932076,
-0.05571147799491882,
-0.0039558676071465015,
-0.009063269011676311,
0.015320105478167534,
-0.012049499899148941,
0.06666304171085358,
0.030715588480234146,
0.043859802186489105,
0.10206884890794754,
-0.004290033131837845,
-0.0124059421941638,
0.0052223061211407185,
0.06880450248718262,
0.069122813642025,
0.04267240688204765,
0.004471807274967432,
0.06340212374925613,
-0.06644400954246521,
-0.033254124224185944,
-0.005734266713261604,
-0.0031109480187296867,
-0.03756621479988098,
-0.023872390389442444,
0.039792750030756,
0.057029854506254196,
-0.022449959069490433,
0.06697505712509155,
-0.04097647964954376,
-0.028674742206931114,
0.05148760974407196,
0.017403295263648033,
0.0009343127603642642,
0.051271844655275345,
0.03488458693027496,
0.018982261419296265,
-0.02629585936665535,
-0.03464435413479805,
-0.006427695509046316,
-0.025226052850484848,
-0.016962537541985512,
0.012643523514270782,
-0.021373363211750984,
-0.019865134730935097,
-0.024380717426538467,
0.026522060856223106,
0.1292625367641449,
-0.016094157472252846,
-0.021097611635923386,
0.007286952342838049,
0.010122297331690788,
0.00014515817747451365,
0.053591538220644,
0.004888459108769894,
-0.00676516629755497,
-0.024225398898124695,
-0.035402197390794754,
0.005104530602693558,
0.018412094563245773,
-0.0006758869276382029,
0.01977626606822014,
-0.026122665032744408,
-0.01854228600859642,
0.002210990060120821,
0.02800227515399456,
-0.07230611890554428,
-0.0796576514840126,
-0.0364227220416069,
-0.039052318781614304,
-0.059944648295640945,
-0.04039543494582176,
0.02143036760389805,
-0.026423878967761993,
-0.030126996338367462,
0.028507454320788383,
-0.011467223055660725,
0.008952295407652855,
-0.003838576376438141,
-0.05661735683679581,
-0.005436661187559366,
0.056584544479846954,
0.006943558342754841,
-0.00009546272485749796,
0.03159048780798912,
0.019343795254826546,
-0.024942660704255104,
-0.005647380370646715,
0.042102403938770294,
-0.0007050679414533079,
0.01671604998409748,
-0.0063974629156291485,
0.010979261249303818,
-0.09497123211622238,
0.0033108917996287346,
0.006290401332080364,
-0.0029945422429591417,
-0.0791902244091034,
-0.0014410821022465825,
-0.015832018107175827,
0.05150468274950981,
0.07631094008684158,
0.01954548992216587,
0.04048188403248787,
-0.035873133689165115,
0.006435207556933165,
0.006302156485617161,
-0.0008233633707277477,
0.051901355385780334,
-0.032097019255161285,
0.03962622955441475,
0.019909029826521873,
-0.01618543453514576,
-0.0824277475476265,
0.006826926488429308,
0.007224339991807938,
-0.010349903255701065,
-0.007839465513825417,
-0.03907981142401695,
-0.026273809373378754,
-0.11131825298070908,
-0.03625917807221413,
0.020475011318922043,
-0.019931362941861153,
-0.0401485450565815,
0.02532811090350151,
0.016560746356844902,
-0.009934600442647934,
-0.0035037656780332327,
-0.029836636036634445,
-0.022247707471251488,
-0.01082787849009037,
-0.029308708384633064,
-0.047464385628700256,
0.007388197351247072,
-0.01560261845588684,
0.016268592327833176,
-0.06334783136844635,
-0.029212528839707375,
-0.014736290089786053,
0.011685212142765522,
0.038083598017692566,
0.012398350983858109,
0.0162154920399189,
-0.020069777965545654
] |
325 |
Context Steering: Controllable Personalization at Inference Time
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=xQCXInDq0m
|
[
"Jerry Zhi-Yang He",
"Sashrika Pandey",
"Mariah L Schrum",
"Anca Dragan"
] |
Poster
|
To deliver high-quality, personalized responses, large language models (LLMs) must effectively incorporate context — personal, demographic, and cultural information specific to an end-user. For example, asking the model to explain Newton's second law with the context "I am a toddler'' should produce a response different from when the context is "I am a physics professor''. However, leveraging the context in practice is a nuanced and challenging task, and is often dependent on the specific situation or user base. The model must strike a balance between providing specific, personalized responses and maintaining general applicability. Current solutions, such as prompt-engineering and fine-tuning, require collection of contextually appropriate responses as examples, making them time-consuming and less flexible to use across different contexts. In this work, we introduce Context Steering (CoS) —a simple, training-free decoding approach that amplifies the influence of the context in next token predictions. CoS computes contextual influence by comparing the output probabilities from two LLM forward passes: one that includes the context and one that does not. By linearly scaling the contextual influence, CoS allows practitioners to flexibly control the degree of personalization for different use cases. We show that CoS can be applied to autoregressive LLMs, and demonstrates strong performance in personalized recommendations. Additionally, we show that CoS can function as a Bayesian Generative model to infer and quantify correlations between open-ended texts, broadening its potential applications.
|
personalization, context, large language model, inference, controllable generation
|
We propose Context Steering (CoS), an inference-time technique that enables generating outputs more relevant to the user-provided contexts, leading to better personalization and various applications for large language models.
| 13,474 |
2405.01768
|
[
-0.00285269133746624,
-0.00473402114585042,
0.0051603433676064014,
0.010726505890488625,
0.043037883937358856,
0.022231338545680046,
0.008735306560993195,
0.0267690010368824,
0.0012033985694870353,
-0.00022711003839503974,
-0.03704468533396721,
0.032914597541093826,
-0.035590752959251404,
-0.02995985746383667,
-0.018181446939706802,
0.03138589859008789,
-0.0009124841308221221,
0.008481997065246105,
0.011058183386921883,
-0.009788094088435173,
0.00617755064740777,
-0.02436365745961666,
0.05158969759941101,
0.02111838571727276,
0.03016856499016285,
0.014599031768739223,
0.011548776179552078,
-0.008855803869664669,
-0.06078537181019783,
0.007516636047512293,
0.03413378819823265,
0.007629385218024254,
-0.00937917921692133,
-0.011670349165797234,
-0.011592966504395008,
-0.03452292084693909,
-0.009125499054789543,
0.013391733169555664,
0.001588151790201664,
0.03564853221178055,
-0.03636160492897034,
0.0011385182151570916,
-0.00018731472664512694,
0.009029319509863853,
-0.0524863563477993,
-0.005192745476961136,
-0.10420762002468109,
0.0414506271481514,
0.002690685447305441,
-0.05652910843491554,
-0.09664098173379898,
0.0433238260447979,
-0.0008022701367735863,
-0.030225807800889015,
0.022417712956666946,
0.03841429203748703,
0.08312010020017624,
-0.10152722895145416,
-0.01089162565767765,
-0.03920445591211319,
-0.054538119584321976,
0.055421117693185806,
0.015061615034937859,
0.023206161335110664,
-0.0005007305298931897,
-0.007317209150642157,
-0.04170645773410797,
0.032809067517519,
-0.052473604679107666,
-0.03129766136407852,
-0.046815939247608185,
0.011780180037021637,
0.0011263553751632571,
0.0033486976753920317,
-0.006681243889033794,
-0.026959968730807304,
0.02627652697265148,
0.04298684746026993,
0.04096698388457298,
-0.03327067941427231,
-0.009563599713146687,
-0.01521705836057663,
0.020415280014276505,
0.04010794684290886,
-0.0036244618240743876,
-0.011277043260633945,
-0.01067735068500042,
-0.027698999270796776,
-0.032178882509469986,
0.011843238025903702,
0.035080526024103165,
-0.07945553958415985,
0.01924809254705906,
0.029022667557001114,
0.025392092764377594,
-0.007820158265531063,
0.036939311772584915,
0.0016277477843686938,
-0.03943139687180519,
0.013432415202260017,
-0.025772836059331894,
-0.03357386961579323,
0.02583697810769081,
0.0014146636240184307,
-0.12533919513225555,
-0.018497800454497337,
-0.007216972764581442,
-0.010178781114518642,
0.002723249141126871,
0.004921464249491692,
-0.034511905163526535,
-0.0014687981456518173,
0.0326923169195652,
0.0012385585578158498,
-0.058365751057863235,
0.02430308796465397,
0.014724254608154297,
0.057744208723306656,
0.02579130232334137,
0.016969731077551842,
0.05598302558064461,
0.05676282197237015,
0.014741582795977592,
0.07439756393432617,
-0.02176881581544876,
0.007008279673755169,
0.0032314585987478495,
0.02667822688817978,
-0.017683735117316246,
-0.05316273868083954,
0.007287553045898676,
0.02234838902950287,
0.0032391278073191643,
0.004958149045705795,
-0.006303085945546627,
0.011132831685245037,
0.028924506157636642,
0.017406897619366646,
0.07594358921051025,
0.021831456571817398,
0.026387915015220642,
-0.01789892464876175,
0.06154966354370117,
-0.019794944673776627,
0.09822970628738403,
-0.032555848360061646,
-0.027595149353146553,
-0.010958166792988777,
-0.029714928939938545,
0.01055898331105709,
0.02951676771044731,
-0.021210012957453728,
0.00820164941251278,
-0.05540018156170845,
0.034355781972408295,
0.06617386639118195,
0.015370319597423077,
0.0225644763559103,
0.010003656148910522,
0.015176625922322273,
0.025379175320267677,
0.00048171603702940047,
-0.08197733759880066,
0.007947498932480812,
0.018716204911470413,
-0.05217505618929863,
0.009962430223822594,
0.022275477647781372,
-0.039649635553359985,
0.0015318368095904589,
-0.036874741315841675,
-0.038137879222631454,
0.04229303449392319,
-0.033226288855075836,
-0.022517969831824303,
0.0034062813501805067,
0.047224514186382294,
-0.00608441699296236,
0.05321783572435379,
0.04003416374325752,
-0.0765279233455658,
0.03326352685689926,
0.010774525813758373,
-0.020358514040708542,
0.055477455258369446,
0.023484675213694572,
0.04706193879246712,
0.007778330240398645,
-0.00857805460691452,
0.024618953466415405,
-0.06885349005460739,
-0.04237343743443489,
-0.011800135485827923,
0.010277501307427883,
0.05158562213182449,
-0.014008650556206703,
0.0005642870673909783,
0.09864261746406555,
0.04597930610179901,
0.030487900599837303,
0.04576120153069496,
-0.007785571273416281,
0.06397100538015366,
0.006746952887624502,
-0.02708807773888111,
-0.02821281924843788,
0.022100022062659264,
-0.030777473002672195,
-0.013050707057118416,
0.05001946538686752,
-0.04638604819774628,
0.021328730508685112,
0.030483728274703026,
-0.001284450525417924,
-0.026638444513082504,
0.004468024708330631,
-0.010995879769325256,
0.006487081293016672,
-0.019295407459139824,
-0.03401812165975571,
0.057088013738393784,
0.003937937319278717,
-0.005989304278045893,
0.008695029653608799,
-0.03305942937731743,
0.12422903627157211,
0.05667708441615105,
-0.022552961483597755,
-0.021802539005875587,
0.016416769474744797,
-0.009653189219534397,
0.006041646935045719,
0.0416858047246933,
-0.022906934842467308,
-0.006886258255690336,
0.001675132312811911,
-0.01688203029334545,
-0.03415948897600174,
0.03483475372195244,
-0.031410738825798035,
-0.0050529660657048225,
0.07516466081142426,
-0.04699280485510826,
0.07439780235290527,
-0.02963516302406788,
0.03354329988360405,
0.007990643382072449,
-0.011248110793530941,
-0.013164778240025043,
-0.005118455737829208,
0.008212270215153694,
-0.010756180621683598,
0.0028588410932570696,
-0.016700616106390953,
0.029979318380355835,
-0.018094366416335106,
-0.0053856647573411465,
-0.001174959004856646,
0.042276762425899506,
0.06276866793632507,
0.008514074608683586,
0.03452445939183235,
0.004231414757668972,
-0.030607163906097412,
0.015777194872498512,
-0.09940813481807709,
-0.014309776946902275,
-0.023316731676459312,
-0.03133345767855644,
0.001286887563765049,
0.014903075993061066,
-0.022279521450400352,
0.01803657039999962,
-0.03770340979099274,
0.013359995558857918,
0.015201936475932598,
0.024937167763710022,
-0.006166679318994284,
-0.020342115312814713,
-0.03340764716267586,
-0.02076142653822899,
0.0372166745364666,
-0.03494127094745636,
-0.023436956107616425,
-0.006747326347976923,
-0.05677233263850212,
-0.025569824501872063,
-0.028201838955283165,
-0.0002567428455222398,
0.03370724990963936,
0.024018142372369766,
-0.008464286103844643,
-0.018657945096492767,
0.020990753546357155,
0.04429760202765465,
0.06436724960803986,
0.04162024334073067,
0.01673843339085579,
-0.04944105073809624,
0.029367301613092422,
-0.015881899744272232,
0.013135222718119621,
0.02546771615743637,
0.03851785883307457,
0.0022578206844627857,
0.0027816130314022303,
0.009057757444679737,
-0.011507399380207062,
-0.26230815052986145,
-0.010566290467977524,
0.03494152054190636,
-0.019042452797293663,
0.039690013974905014,
-0.007813513278961182,
0.07394024729728699,
-0.03159523382782936,
-0.02255605161190033,
0.014458856545388699,
-0.0017687762156128883,
0.03344311565160751,
0.007490104995667934,
0.036224037408828735,
0.0343436673283577,
0.03379084914922714,
-0.015286952257156372,
-0.016661688685417175,
0.001968222903087735,
0.04356568679213524,
-0.0050220126286149025,
-0.06363050639629364,
-0.008672880940139294,
0.058058105409145355,
0.0011015404015779495,
0.0412684828042984,
-0.08783748000860214,
-0.007380715571343899,
-0.03431457281112671,
0.00191396230366081,
0.012921803630888462,
-0.0068300082348287106,
-0.001986138755455613,
0.023428501561284065,
0.003485560417175293,
0.00866033136844635,
0.06406231969594955,
0.017526686191558838,
0.027509741485118866,
-0.03072860836982727,
0.006717318203300238,
-0.027821842581033707,
-0.03802267462015152,
-0.013649813830852509,
0.07058241218328476,
-0.014953937381505966,
-0.05240301042795181,
-0.025389567017555237,
0.002903593238443136,
0.02852797694504261,
-0.022930623963475227,
-0.03857364505529404,
-0.027882929891347885,
0.014339638873934746,
0.028015265241265297,
-0.030047055333852768,
0.01844441331923008,
-0.006755031645298004,
-0.021151065826416016,
-0.018386999145150185,
0.030111119151115417,
-0.023406848311424255,
-0.003585599362850189,
-0.04940056428313255,
-0.012462982907891273,
-0.061608027666807175,
-0.10373660922050476,
-0.048345401883125305,
0.041588444262742996,
0.05087421461939812,
-0.02041766047477722,
0.01954609341919422,
0.007954013533890247,
-0.1083480715751648,
-0.00011641147284535691,
-0.02020958624780178,
0.0018231924623250961,
-0.025359977036714554,
0.009512095712125301,
0.027911655604839325,
-0.051237110048532486,
-0.034049298614263535,
-0.0073240976780653,
0.005229321774095297,
0.02881069853901863,
-0.04024123027920723,
0.003136144485324621,
-0.04619176313281059,
-0.025285009294748306,
-0.017669349908828735,
0.036504458636045456,
-0.006219638977199793,
-0.02900082617998123,
0.013542860746383667,
0.055329423397779465,
0.03809625282883644,
0.0262604970484972,
0.0727597326040268,
0.045850951224565506,
-0.018519630655646324,
0.015745297074317932,
-0.07854993641376495,
-0.012901515699923038,
-0.023875057697296143,
-0.015489092096686363,
0.0270147193223238,
-0.07487452030181885,
-0.044128693640232086,
0.014507682994008064,
-0.01379142701625824,
-0.027816860005259514,
-0.004540846683084965,
0.00346767483279109,
-0.019157618284225464,
-0.052310530096292496,
0.002046045148745179,
0.006001888774335384,
0.028864841908216476,
0.04280858486890793,
0.005395298358052969,
-0.02135617658495903,
0.04498164355754852,
-0.014742976054549217,
0.018606707453727722,
0.0024434002116322517,
-0.04218672588467598,
0.015963220968842506,
-0.016486816108226776,
0.007026389706879854,
-0.03245462849736214,
0.0061307670548558235,
0.009261822327971458,
-0.0022434762213379145,
0.006492832209914923,
0.041970692574977875,
-0.012381751090288162,
0.028380615636706352,
-0.021679308265447617,
0.007486456073820591,
-0.010085368528962135,
-0.027573054656386375,
-0.02745126374065876,
0.027496980503201485,
0.03940238803625107,
0.030992746353149414,
-0.00883334968239069,
0.002896275371313095,
0.026675088331103325,
-0.009822987951338291,
-0.0002804960240609944,
0.04494006186723709,
-0.018972720950841904,
-0.044600848108530045,
-0.019356464967131615,
0.023834064602851868,
-0.002782289870083332,
0.013015673495829105,
0.0004785573109984398,
0.007019601762294769,
-0.059623848646879196,
0.03875693306326866,
-0.02248469367623329,
-0.013980255462229252,
0.00867046695202589,
0.006359779741615057,
0.020662719383835793,
-0.054370563477277756,
0.024281853809952736,
0.014530563727021217,
0.011101488023996353,
0.022122150287032127,
-0.005051529034972191,
-0.0308426171541214,
-0.009382335469126701,
-0.043171580880880356,
0.009040001779794693,
0.0025725977029651403,
-0.03085632435977459,
-0.009052710607647896,
0.015543471090495586,
0.02255028486251831,
-0.01324998214840889,
0.012329877354204655,
-0.0013674104120582342,
0.08442839980125427,
0.025075320154428482,
0.013783557340502739,
0.01433719415217638,
-0.046231210231781006,
0.007621313910931349,
-0.02989122085273266,
0.009940700605511665,
-0.020843494683504105,
-0.05557434633374214,
-0.03510003909468651,
-0.03193354606628418,
0.01872451789677143,
0.000996944261714816,
-0.03799020126461983,
0.004496193490922451,
-0.02945025824010372,
0.02685922011733055,
-0.039137788116931915,
-0.028221942484378815,
0.03089781664311886,
-0.08310116082429886,
-0.003379456466063857,
-0.020825348794460297,
-0.02426833100616932,
0.04410934820771217,
-0.043768517673015594,
-0.047376543283462524,
-0.029883872717618942,
-0.039463385939598083,
0.007900061085820198,
-0.04503290355205536,
-0.03459637239575386,
-0.04419558122754097,
-0.009378548711538315,
-0.008503212593495846,
0.0036904949229210615,
-0.006187822204083204,
-0.004200126510113478,
-0.02710655704140663,
0.03141552954912186,
0.04330555722117424,
-0.06871038675308228,
-0.024629581719636917,
0.019233934581279755,
-0.03715597465634346,
0.027602670714259148,
-0.017053529620170593,
0.0262454766780138,
0.038124945014715195,
-0.025214122608304024,
-0.015613791532814503,
-0.05091208592057228,
0.04019423946738243,
0.015850165858864784,
-0.005395045969635248,
0.015576872043311596,
-0.04004119336605072,
-0.048874642699956894,
0.017639515921473503,
0.017889630049467087,
0.03435476869344711,
0.005284771788865328,
0.0419195219874382,
0.006318777333945036,
0.01095147617161274,
0.023080553859472275,
0.0015121165197342634,
-0.02668789215385914,
0.007640330120921135,
0.045156531035900116,
-0.019171541556715965,
-0.0397045835852623,
-0.06598936766386032,
-0.04255091771483421,
0.01738296076655388,
-0.005782217252999544,
0.027085235342383385,
-0.020852982997894287,
0.05616294592618942,
0.028243234381079674,
0.0175373163074255,
0.029168441891670227,
-0.0056546516716480255,
0.028369516134262085,
-0.0275237038731575,
0.0032953256741166115,
-0.08723184466362,
-0.006667399778962135,
0.055890411138534546,
-0.028077222406864166,
-0.005755546502768993,
0.018462641164660454,
-0.026266220957040787,
0.07399702072143555,
-0.013495438732206821,
-0.055979639291763306,
-0.0024727240670472383,
-0.015981372445821762,
0.001446869457140565,
0.026578662917017937,
-0.060991644859313965,
0.007163542788475752,
-0.010803600773215294,
-0.07001943141222,
-0.020059699192643166,
-0.0023444017861038446,
0.08469926565885544,
-0.02091897837817669,
0.0410003587603569,
-0.01762542687356472,
0.018916437402367592,
0.01224304735660553,
0.0677858516573906,
0.006780278868973255,
0.030610332265496254,
-0.019505277276039124,
0.03630548715591431,
0.016500208526849747,
0.030556896701455116,
-0.004756852053105831,
-0.0022176236379891634,
-0.015283078886568546,
-0.049401283264160156,
0.06310983747243881,
0.003390330821275711,
-0.03110112063586712,
-0.07969319820404053,
0.08338949084281921,
0.03849414736032486,
-0.050786085426807404,
-0.027096496894955635,
0.01934983767569065,
-0.04905589669942856,
-0.018376505002379417,
0.000014258841474656947,
0.00848422385752201,
-0.028056006878614426,
0.0744466707110405,
0.05454212427139282,
0.04304150864481926,
0.07870128750801086,
-0.007840445265173912,
-0.011246579699218273,
-0.005671316292136908,
0.052627161145210266,
0.05726468190550804,
0.09721007198095322,
0.02309623919427395,
0.0769084021449089,
-0.047684989869594574,
-0.04316100478172302,
0.01361407432705164,
0.04793943464756012,
-0.019588632509112358,
-0.03252647817134857,
0.010260828770697117,
0.07553552091121674,
0.005649584345519543,
0.06681112945079803,
-0.02930019050836563,
-0.02364988811314106,
0.03969140723347664,
0.02575075998902321,
0.004263680893927813,
0.03836826980113983,
0.027674363926053047,
0.02799306996166706,
-0.062092531472444534,
-0.03101266734302044,
-0.00375039572827518,
-0.0320478118956089,
0.00001588293343957048,
0.01874266006052494,
-0.02355377748608589,
-0.009068071842193604,
-0.009709159843623638,
0.04941176995635033,
0.11447206139564514,
-0.017213651910424232,
-0.03556777536869049,
0.04813618212938309,
0.005259269382804632,
0.012209891341626644,
0.0758085623383522,
-0.0026156289968639612,
-0.012295323424041271,
-0.00764986639842391,
-0.040369391441345215,
-0.018219422549009323,
0.016156857833266258,
-0.017764898017048836,
0.010724816471338272,
-0.008989096619188786,
-0.012347551062703133,
0.019014805555343628,
0.020689645782113075,
-0.06454622000455856,
-0.041793376207351685,
-0.030014706775546074,
-0.04929397255182266,
-0.040881406515836716,
-0.05811714380979538,
0.05029190331697464,
0.008738361299037933,
-0.0053662932477891445,
0.021040473133325577,
-0.05392002686858177,
0.013803827576339245,
-0.010890888050198555,
-0.05009794980287552,
0.026393022388219833,
0.02064991369843483,
-0.007358278147876263,
0.0007158666849136353,
0.016062505543231964,
0.007771977223455906,
-0.014691701158881187,
0.014379050582647324,
0.02827095054090023,
0.031092913821339607,
0.03302229940891266,
0.0026971844490617514,
-0.041272617876529694,
-0.09836394339799881,
-0.016052188351750374,
-0.005710037890821695,
-0.025968628004193306,
-0.0949813649058342,
0.021126631647348404,
-0.03175462782382965,
0.04549207538366318,
0.06821495294570923,
0.034952837973833084,
0.010519730858504772,
-0.012091990560293198,
0.0031862673349678516,
0.02617924101650715,
0.02759864553809166,
0.03268628194928169,
-0.017947139218449593,
0.0719221979379654,
0.042586181312799454,
-0.04768766462802887,
-0.024869225919246674,
0.013026049360632896,
-0.0042019677348434925,
-0.026097575202584267,
-0.01187959872186184,
0.00388818746432662,
-0.01528535969555378,
-0.08194466680288315,
-0.028478378430008888,
0.022093283012509346,
-0.011841973289847374,
-0.031674824655056,
-0.024153193458914757,
-0.03356468677520752,
-0.025968922302126884,
0.001397883053869009,
-0.0230866726487875,
0.02300947904586792,
-0.02770950086414814,
-0.006488559301942587,
-0.06274190545082092,
-0.015538384206593037,
-0.05353419855237007,
-0.013775533065199852,
-0.04251336678862572,
-0.023812999948859215,
-0.01308123767375946,
-0.02141084149479866,
0.03625917434692383,
-0.009344051592051983,
0.01378379762172699,
-0.010925867594778538
] |
326 |
Efficient Policy Evaluation with Safety Constraint for Reinforcement Learning
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Dem5LyVk8R
|
[
"Claire Chen",
"Shuze Liu",
"Shangtong Zhang"
] |
Poster
|
In reinforcement learning, classic on-policy evaluation methods often suffer from high variance and require massive online data to attain the desired accuracy. Previous studies attempt to reduce evaluation variance by searching for or designing proper behavior policies to collect data. However, these approaches ignore the safety of such behavior policies---the designed behavior policies have no safety guarantee and may lead to severe damage during online executions. In this paper, to address the challenge of reducing variance while ensuring safety simultaneously, we propose an optimal variance-minimizing behavior policy under safety constraints. Theoretically, while ensuring safety constraints, our evaluation method is unbiased and has lower variance than on-policy evaluation. Empirically, our method is the only existing method to achieve both substantial variance reduction and safety constraint satisfaction. Furthermore, we show our method is even superior to previous methods in both variance reduction and execution safety.
|
Reinforcement Learning
| null | 13,457 |
2410.05655
|
[
-0.029687892645597458,
0.005039277486503124,
-0.015893250703811646,
0.044687654823064804,
0.042248211801052094,
0.01777217909693718,
0.04102880507707596,
-0.0353170670568943,
-0.03349870815873146,
-0.03754251077771187,
-0.02446776255965233,
0.01905491016805172,
-0.07976994663476944,
-0.020005395635962486,
0.002483130432665348,
0.05628162994980812,
0.008085218258202076,
-0.015242042019963264,
0.011022980324923992,
-0.017249170690774918,
-0.015598038211464882,
0.005786442197859287,
0.05139784887433052,
0.02619044855237007,
0.06941567361354828,
0.03629586100578308,
0.03706121817231178,
0.026817744597792625,
-0.01770969294011593,
-0.010340956971049309,
0.045188210904598236,
0.016302580013871193,
-0.008150190114974976,
-0.0026900668162852526,
0.0028311258647590876,
0.0251558106392622,
-0.0041650100611150265,
0.005843997932970524,
-0.01317555271089077,
0.03360937908291817,
-0.04099521040916443,
-0.004530549515038729,
-0.035326868295669556,
-0.008565254509449005,
-0.03133222833275795,
-0.004834175109863281,
-0.03812478482723236,
0.015953581780195236,
0.01821906864643097,
-0.0560205914080143,
-0.09683696925640106,
0.06655187159776688,
0.006459681782871485,
-0.0004964248510077596,
-0.00663717370480299,
0.021377500146627426,
0.05187198147177696,
-0.09759131819009781,
0.002846539719030261,
-0.06309211254119873,
-0.021698646247386932,
0.03517132252454758,
0.03131646290421486,
0.020378706976771355,
-0.004436815623193979,
0.00830076728016138,
0.03506277874112129,
0.04698445647954941,
-0.020997170358896255,
-0.007716719061136246,
-0.06506635248661041,
0.004110423848032951,
0.007639961317181587,
0.01582779549062252,
-0.003363886382430792,
-0.052669573575258255,
0.014806973747909069,
0.029376309365034103,
0.05383208766579628,
0.009177351370453835,
0.027348583564162254,
0.007692217826843262,
0.001845911960117519,
0.025427820160984993,
0.040304914116859436,
0.013488859869539738,
-0.016887230798602104,
-0.02632729336619377,
-0.09155730903148651,
0.028639279305934906,
-0.025028113275766373,
-0.03896290808916092,
-0.033401064574718475,
0.049425218254327774,
-0.002152889734134078,
0.01283984538167715,
0.02099212259054184,
0.011735368520021439,
0.010705794207751751,
-0.01295530702918768,
-0.03155282139778137,
-0.008449092507362366,
-0.013283898122608662,
-0.002209978410974145,
-0.10877794027328491,
-0.025698348879814148,
-0.0033760606311261654,
-0.013541923835873604,
-0.013832696713507175,
0.022713657468557358,
-0.049568261951208115,
0.005683728959411383,
0.02473229356110096,
-0.008592937141656876,
-0.08960119634866714,
0.05592314898967743,
0.011396861635148525,
0.023995503783226013,
0.017955534160137177,
0.012589680962264538,
0.031108083203434944,
0.02296864427626133,
0.00022587948478758335,
0.06622049957513809,
-0.001421971246600151,
0.03279227390885353,
0.004641760606318712,
0.03603554889559746,
-0.007525925524532795,
-0.04382692277431488,
0.03926242142915726,
0.029846714809536934,
-0.013232007622718811,
-0.003667667740955949,
-0.050211552530527115,
0.0230279341340065,
0.024372722953557968,
0.030980447307229042,
0.007848547771573067,
-0.016458576545119286,
-0.015160291455686092,
-0.033537544310092926,
0.08148015290498734,
-0.019450493156909943,
0.0681157186627388,
0.0005730194970965385,
0.0027143280021846294,
-0.020569998770952225,
-0.05418427661061287,
-0.007290844339877367,
0.018602263182401657,
-0.014166424982249737,
0.002552423859015107,
-0.032850105315446854,
0.012637516483664513,
0.03105580061674118,
0.027070075273513794,
-0.00046973550342954695,
-0.0059992363676428795,
-0.021342037245631218,
0.004342216532677412,
0.00542802968993783,
-0.04183321073651314,
-0.0193550493568182,
-0.0025549072306603193,
-0.06935643404722214,
0.04149548336863518,
0.023116404190659523,
-0.027343736961483955,
-0.030845148488879204,
-0.02929224818944931,
-0.030696343630552292,
0.01272964384406805,
-0.002574280137196183,
0.011285672895610332,
0.025497786700725555,
0.058339279145002365,
-0.037829890847206116,
0.040645498782396317,
0.03497323766350746,
-0.08351457864046097,
0.01909421570599079,
0.0053025176748633385,
0.027315963059663773,
-0.003851640038192272,
-0.02320430427789688,
0.07955234497785568,
-0.050159502774477005,
0.004072871059179306,
0.0075108702294528484,
-0.08317133039236069,
-0.019639408215880394,
0.04631945118308067,
-0.004901024512946606,
0.04104912281036377,
-0.01079997606575489,
0.0007341334712691605,
0.041991256177425385,
-0.01682066172361374,
0.06920988857746124,
0.043250322341918945,
-0.003765788860619068,
0.05303603783249855,
-0.027343422174453735,
-0.03497213497757912,
-0.01333991065621376,
0.038818199187517166,
-0.026196857914328575,
-0.051018234342336655,
0.0014132733922451735,
-0.01209182944148779,
0.02779223397374153,
-0.028258375823497772,
0.003734546946361661,
0.02326514758169651,
-0.006911783944815397,
-0.03326763957738876,
0.004276479594409466,
0.040649183094501495,
-0.051185302436351776,
0.02948402613401413,
0.00817954633384943,
-0.013915883377194405,
0.0262849610298872,
-0.026007359847426414,
0.08508925139904022,
0.08102026581764221,
-0.036887526512145996,
0.005978862755000591,
0.010346143506467342,
-0.0022305671591311693,
-0.0052975076250731945,
0.006969829089939594,
-0.0009808618342503905,
0.02349448949098587,
0.024427887052297592,
-0.002552457619458437,
0.007941520772874355,
0.06078796088695526,
-0.04585327208042145,
0.0003050764789804816,
0.07104422897100449,
0.002289184369146824,
0.06965810805559158,
0.006917229853570461,
-0.012201781384646893,
0.07962483167648315,
0.020174900069832802,
-0.02061869204044342,
-0.017938854172825813,
-0.02537001669406891,
-0.008819867856800556,
0.05702868849039078,
-0.002599582076072693,
0.0014924946008250117,
-0.06598296761512756,
-0.0037025033961981535,
-0.030720483511686325,
0.06263317912817001,
0.06652148067951202,
-0.004536094143986702,
0.01607920415699482,
0.0037137893959879875,
-0.016657957807183266,
-0.001289400621317327,
-0.11734622716903687,
-0.06301944702863693,
0.008089716546237469,
-0.000986711005680263,
0.027616217732429504,
0.014910892583429813,
-0.03079511784017086,
0.0346100740134716,
-0.0063805654644966125,
-0.04860331118106842,
0.0033469435293227434,
0.022448629140853882,
0.031161397695541382,
-0.005434446502476931,
0.013347246684134007,
0.023821242153644562,
0.06831970810890198,
0.013355636969208717,
-0.010499127209186554,
0.012187330983579159,
-0.022384630516171455,
0.0048033143393695354,
-0.0551973432302475,
-0.010986500419676304,
0.006415325216948986,
0.012966752052307129,
-0.008360977284610271,
-0.053499117493629456,
0.008238672278821468,
0.01436576433479786,
0.02744843252003193,
0.02650863118469715,
0.034822966903448105,
0.02600061520934105,
0.018720125779509544,
0.008115846663713455,
-0.010003156960010529,
-0.011069444939494133,
0.010562760755419731,
0.004001397639513016,
-0.004199483897536993,
0.013114790432155132,
0.009031759575009346,
-0.26284006237983704,
-0.03747954219579697,
0.04859946668148041,
0.007518676109611988,
0.027078701183199883,
0.016362329944968224,
0.0718856006860733,
-0.02746032550930977,
-0.051710620522499084,
0.012555660679936409,
0.03914312273263931,
0.021528223529458046,
0.048612356185913086,
0.06578440219163895,
0.04331459850072861,
0.02348589152097702,
-0.00831341091543436,
-0.04110725596547127,
-0.0034947588574141264,
0.000768254220020026,
-0.008615571074187756,
-0.09455839544534683,
-0.04194258153438568,
0.004760469309985638,
0.012310061603784561,
0.035878028720617294,
-0.05455780029296875,
0.02294553816318512,
-0.04079017415642738,
-0.0019862332846969366,
-0.028887251392006874,
-0.016506871208548546,
-0.05427449196577072,
0.0012185232480987906,
0.03572079539299011,
0.035906095057725906,
0.03130766749382019,
-0.017188023775815964,
0.022330351173877716,
0.046677667647600174,
0.012525116093456745,
-0.03352009505033493,
-0.0360739566385746,
0.013726629316806793,
0.031495824456214905,
0.044018443673849106,
-0.03239811956882477,
-0.011828846298158169,
-0.011815172620117664,
0.021398454904556274,
0.021320881322026253,
-0.021393684670329094,
-0.010205788537859917,
0.009797448292374611,
0.009101533330976963,
-0.0023435531184077263,
-0.016385802999138832,
-0.01751421019434929,
-0.00004802377225132659,
0.01520390436053276,
-0.003978004213422537,
-0.05103135108947754,
-0.044957950711250305,
-0.02720518968999386,
0.019160043448209763,
-0.04113483428955078,
-0.0366499088704586,
-0.058650873601436615,
0.038267653435468674,
0.0350368469953537,
0.00024881865829229355,
-0.03617624565958977,
-0.01590149849653244,
-0.10118032246828079,
0.015735691413283348,
-0.01974557153880596,
-0.013581755571067333,
-0.030720744282007217,
0.027410438284277916,
0.03438365459442139,
-0.06294505298137665,
-0.04472057521343231,
0.008838493376970291,
0.02945103496313095,
0.014589508064091206,
-0.014270125888288021,
0.04038386791944504,
-0.031518369913101196,
-0.031206056475639343,
-0.0380021296441555,
0.01720692589879036,
0.024085693061351776,
0.02678912691771984,
-0.0267439316958189,
0.050187721848487854,
0.029992418363690376,
0.03404441103339195,
0.02575688250362873,
0.02347397431731224,
-0.014198430813848972,
0.010451700538396835,
-0.10923048853874207,
-0.0201133843511343,
-0.07892389595508575,
-0.03677972033619881,
0.04536658525466919,
-0.05210832506418228,
-0.020960357040166855,
0.05943834036588669,
0.0070327334105968475,
-0.007871127687394619,
-0.01843729056417942,
0.028888119384646416,
-0.019071165472269058,
0.01504438929259777,
-0.023026935756206512,
0.004604303278028965,
0.03966629132628441,
0.0356954000890255,
-0.01614733412861824,
-0.05159183219075203,
0.029542826116085052,
-0.01237441599369049,
0.004755685105919838,
-0.012618957087397575,
-0.008566712029278278,
0.03613380342721939,
-0.0015105330385267735,
0.0111546004191041,
-0.013906803913414478,
0.03625885024666786,
0.06476790457963943,
0.006590430159121752,
0.015702461823821068,
0.026412105187773705,
-0.018845155835151672,
-0.003535172203555703,
0.0010423018829897046,
0.027741745114326477,
-0.015615866519510746,
0.012798579409718513,
-0.009371967986226082,
0.0030009099282324314,
0.03373410552740097,
0.01753690093755722,
0.014512663707137108,
0.025077128782868385,
0.022634288296103477,
0.009003235958516598,
0.005611284635961056,
0.018726997077465057,
-0.08880625665187836,
-0.010633711703121662,
-0.02892937883734703,
0.01031607948243618,
-0.010706333443522453,
0.035580746829509735,
-0.03217524290084839,
0.023114971816539764,
-0.061951618641614914,
0.041163306683301926,
0.0031502784695476294,
-0.017339972779154778,
-0.017243245616555214,
0.007634744513779879,
0.06387635320425034,
-0.030940255150198936,
-0.033429376780986786,
-0.005129723343998194,
0.015989940613508224,
-0.003466526512056589,
-0.043007709085941315,
-0.03122691623866558,
-0.01357598602771759,
-0.018936090171337128,
-0.0047510541044175625,
0.0013363671023398638,
-0.0700833648443222,
-0.07388295978307724,
-0.01339499931782484,
0.0231751948595047,
-0.0032271898817270994,
0.005552227608859539,
-0.002075027674436569,
0.06266345828771591,
-0.02056051231920719,
0.01431884616613388,
-0.00058285694103688,
-0.009605336003005505,
0.024935303255915642,
0.01642042212188244,
0.002649943344295025,
-0.002048265654593706,
-0.04112078621983528,
-0.001592678832821548,
-0.010449407622218132,
0.0062788394279778,
-0.010212174616754055,
-0.014120187610387802,
-0.004711129702627659,
0.0027045763563364744,
-0.020220952108502388,
-0.007019891403615475,
0.006315330043435097,
-0.014776273630559444,
-0.049668505787849426,
-0.021009458228945732,
0.0674540176987648,
-0.00346807180903852,
0.04061981663107872,
-0.10276222974061966,
-0.05632203817367554,
-0.0410250686109066,
-0.00857942458242178,
0.011080201715230942,
-0.008291167207062244,
-0.04738158360123634,
-0.005912175867706537,
-0.036519359797239304,
0.0062714992091059685,
0.013267391361296177,
-0.017778009176254272,
-0.016724003478884697,
-0.030447741970419884,
-0.006625437177717686,
0.04437931999564171,
-0.01999659463763237,
-0.029269861057400703,
0.043458566069602966,
-0.02367936074733734,
0.010159211233258247,
-0.03301632031798363,
0.027904609218239784,
0.0206736009567976,
-0.02567385323345661,
0.015042276121675968,
-0.06057446822524071,
0.05887986719608307,
-0.03862676024436951,
-0.03986672684550285,
-0.05290043354034424,
0.01766517199575901,
-0.031892210245132446,
-0.0359441339969635,
-0.01655684970319271,
0.012798993848264217,
0.02092047967016697,
0.022213831543922424,
0.02830447256565094,
0.006926668342202902,
0.006191311404109001,
0.01604033075273037,
-0.030291108414530754,
0.015240740031003952,
0.0764666274189949,
0.00013237072562333196,
-0.01191303227096796,
-0.049655474722385406,
-0.008032122626900673,
0.03390926495194435,
-0.031158285215497017,
0.021717704832553864,
-0.03333168849349022,
-0.00031515193404629827,
-0.008045637048780918,
0.05052020773291588,
0.031167741864919662,
-0.0538395456969738,
0.026751253753900528,
-0.08993887901306152,
-0.0015453688101843,
-0.05406387522816658,
0.024748237803578377,
0.06738223880529404,
-0.05700569599866867,
-0.0030831738840788603,
0.025133199989795685,
-0.03253316134214401,
0.043213240802288055,
-0.017811810597777367,
-0.07373471558094025,
0.02011861838400364,
-0.049593549221754074,
-0.024489162489771843,
0.04944515600800514,
-0.03735030069947243,
-0.00864058081060648,
-0.009436306543648243,
-0.04360003396868706,
0.028957974165678024,
0.026601755991578102,
0.048121701925992966,
-0.017101876437664032,
-0.0020463354885578156,
-0.04320850223302841,
0.01000086311250925,
0.014918125234544277,
0.0328688845038414,
0.026822339743375778,
0.03951825574040413,
-0.05666894093155861,
0.05401116609573364,
0.051690492779016495,
0.0346730574965477,
0.007501306477934122,
0.01778966560959816,
0.010985319502651691,
-0.02285500057041645,
0.031010814011096954,
-0.004760586656630039,
-0.027754195034503937,
-0.06016499549150467,
0.05611677095293999,
0.021991107612848282,
-0.07266344130039215,
-0.013706723228096962,
0.012915109284222126,
-0.06266985833644867,
-0.024402379989624023,
0.0025384239852428436,
0.019172094762325287,
0.022283360362052917,
0.10295579582452774,
0.013880107551813126,
0.04057938605546951,
0.052540574222803116,
0.010861845687031746,
0.027048390358686447,
-0.01324903592467308,
0.07700640708208084,
0.044305864721536636,
0.04533807188272476,
0.008424494415521622,
0.06840447336435318,
-0.06687439233064651,
-0.04719138890504837,
0.029824867844581604,
0.0034731838386505842,
-0.04876251891255379,
-0.015694359317421913,
0.017977045848965645,
0.03918205946683884,
0.011183387599885464,
0.05762463063001633,
-0.0393705815076828,
-0.01194189116358757,
0.03826656565070152,
-0.01895895041525364,
0.008448001928627491,
0.04418070614337921,
0.02231731079518795,
0.01118514034897089,
-0.013034072704613209,
-0.03404897078871727,
0.001288600149564445,
-0.0014246730133891106,
0.018795734271407127,
-0.0030242842622101307,
-0.023440565913915634,
-0.008449180983006954,
0.03699430078268051,
0.012714366428554058,
0.10661861300468445,
-0.04836529865860939,
-0.01207196805626154,
0.01756434515118599,
0.015615525655448437,
0.0006431266665458679,
0.04218378663063049,
0.02394014596939087,
-0.0292514655739069,
0.020481819286942482,
-0.05265709012746811,
0.039299119263887405,
0.014827652834355831,
0.005967319011688232,
0.032416705042123795,
-0.032158996909856796,
0.0036375822965055704,
0.034429050981998444,
0.025757253170013428,
-0.02543462999165058,
-0.04015585780143738,
-0.04145359992980957,
-0.02087729424238205,
-0.04117918759584427,
-0.052916351705789566,
0.02172720432281494,
-0.021779125556349754,
-0.06079372018575668,
0.03002406843006611,
-0.005818067118525505,
0.02018004097044468,
0.00759567366912961,
-0.07084990292787552,
-0.02234608307480812,
0.06562234461307526,
-0.018431467935442924,
0.03885769844055176,
0.032187897711992264,
0.027184074744582176,
-0.005007111933082342,
-0.037313077598810196,
0.0032051883172243834,
0.04349571093916893,
0.026509162038564682,
-0.03116607666015625,
-0.010127797722816467,
-0.0809241533279419,
-0.006836735177785158,
0.02367774024605751,
-0.032110102474689484,
-0.06778031587600708,
0.031721457839012146,
-0.08049866557121277,
0.0009215721511282027,
0.08449754118919373,
-0.0011812986340373755,
-0.007863636128604412,
-0.037137217819690704,
0.007508731912821531,
-0.00010413069685455412,
0.016544852405786514,
0.03096403367817402,
-0.05456266552209854,
0.04120904579758644,
0.03412027657032013,
-0.04478316754102707,
-0.04601844772696495,
0.05909426137804985,
-0.0024492843076586723,
-0.037516165524721146,
-0.016240183264017105,
-0.0035396527964621782,
-0.0288922730833292,
-0.10198152810335159,
-0.015682702884078026,
0.0630355253815651,
0.026302114129066467,
-0.011029976420104504,
-0.01079631969332695,
0.009543748572468758,
-0.03535760939121246,
-0.0009568768437020481,
-0.043573442846536636,
-0.012375077232718468,
-0.019154617562890053,
-0.009218838065862656,
-0.05628509074449539,
0.0349130742251873,
-0.06276926398277283,
-0.007233389187604189,
-0.034840185195207596,
-0.03797230124473572,
0.0283306036144495,
-0.02749028243124485,
0.0198373980820179,
0.007922560907900333,
0.005855570547282696,
0.007018747739493847
] |
327 |
Agent S: An Open Agentic Framework that Uses Computers Like a Human
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=lIVRgt4nLv
|
[
"Saaket Agashe",
"Jiuzhou Han",
"Shuyu Gan",
"Jiachen Yang",
"Ang Li",
"Xin Eric Wang"
] |
Poster
|
We present Agent S, an open agentic framework that enables autonomous interaction with computers through Graphical User Interface (GUI), aimed at transforming human-computer interaction by automating complex, multi-step tasks. Agent S addresses three key challenges in automating computer tasks: acquiring domain-specific knowledge, planning over long task horizons, and handling dynamic, non-uniform interfaces. To this end, Agent S introduces experience-augmented hierarchical planning, which learns from external knowledge search and internal experience retrieval at multiple levels, facilitating efficient task planning and subtask execution.
In addition, it employs an Agent-Computer Interface (ACI) to better elicit the reasoning and control capabilities of GUI agents based on Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). Evaluation on the OSWorld benchmark shows that Agent S outperforms the baseline by 9.37\% on success rate (an 83.6\% relative improvement) and achieves a new state-of-the-art. Comprehensive analysis highlights the effectiveness of individual components and provides insights for future improvements. Furthermore, Agent S demonstrates broad generalizability to different operating systems on a newly-released WindowsAgentArena benchmark. Code available at https://github.com/simular-ai/Agent-S.
|
Large Vision and Language Model, Agents, Retrieval Augmented Generation, GUI, Large Language Models, Agent Computer Interface
| null | 13,452 |
2410.08164
|
[
-0.02308419533073902,
-0.021580282598733902,
0.007359188515692949,
0.01890714466571808,
0.05176587402820587,
0.012825156562030315,
0.027850905433297157,
0.019673071801662445,
-0.03456991910934448,
-0.057073719799518585,
-0.04272787272930145,
0.03755471110343933,
-0.07432594895362854,
-0.029043719172477722,
-0.0015876229153946042,
0.04932212084531784,
0.005385407246649265,
-0.021420365199446678,
-0.002207845449447632,
-0.02442019060254097,
-0.04277898743748665,
0.004653009120374918,
0.051042307168245316,
0.014075702987611294,
0.022011931985616684,
0.04504317790269852,
0.027659602463245392,
0.019076107069849968,
-0.01690729707479477,
-0.0009347720770165324,
0.032486170530319214,
-0.02992161735892296,
0.006018864922225475,
-0.056071460247039795,
-0.013128954917192459,
-0.01459245290607214,
-0.050319962203502655,
0.01108959224075079,
-0.04625765606760979,
-0.016459472477436066,
-0.03769605606794357,
0.0447976253926754,
-0.005373222287744284,
0.018748337402939796,
-0.01612047851085663,
0.01914696954190731,
-0.07812230288982391,
0.020008644089102745,
0.024763258174061775,
-0.014120274223387241,
-0.08558999747037888,
0.006117694079875946,
-0.017121993005275726,
-0.017166776582598686,
-0.003182004438713193,
0.03677262365818024,
0.05996603146195412,
-0.08870001882314682,
0.0023054578341543674,
-0.04258386790752411,
-0.022065656259655952,
0.010675098747015,
0.0303549375385046,
0.012737587094306946,
-0.01709517277777195,
-0.019527269527316093,
0.011385925114154816,
0.030118707567453384,
-0.03344699740409851,
0.004110364709049463,
-0.01861977018415928,
-0.009505443274974823,
-0.05450758710503578,
-0.022839436307549477,
0.021149689331650734,
-0.029189707711338997,
0.05698874592781067,
0.01646718569099903,
0.062173087149858475,
-0.019144508987665176,
0.007705328520387411,
0.06671490520238876,
-0.007296350318938494,
0.01330566592514515,
0.025071533396840096,
0.023952607065439224,
-0.006423023529350758,
-0.015612468123435974,
-0.06302844732999802,
0.03339430317282677,
0.012439457699656487,
-0.06516363471746445,
0.01498019602149725,
0.039006080478429794,
0.019456811249256134,
0.03745363652706146,
-0.0027210754342377186,
-0.0010131326271221042,
0.004336508922278881,
-0.003435788443312049,
-0.03311731666326523,
0.01080157421529293,
-0.004612710792571306,
-0.0008910982287488878,
-0.07929621636867523,
-0.008418585173785686,
-0.009221640415489674,
-0.008921060711145401,
-0.003649441059678793,
-0.005461135413497686,
-0.028476275503635406,
-0.013766573742032051,
0.039273880422115326,
-0.014922462403774261,
-0.06746344268321991,
0.05056477338075638,
0.006393041927367449,
0.049472976475954056,
0.018535180017352104,
0.049967486411333084,
0.05482364445924759,
0.06425376981496811,
-0.022645486518740654,
0.052937738597393036,
-0.004301466979086399,
0.0031904897186905146,
0.031112436205148697,
0.005311104469001293,
-0.012719337828457355,
-0.035537347197532654,
0.025134723633527756,
0.03025549277663231,
-0.0011175402905791998,
0.0033723798114806414,
-0.014242937788367271,
0.018872853368520737,
0.02926679328083992,
0.006471299100667238,
0.023372000083327293,
0.017981721088290215,
0.0009698038920760155,
-0.009717926383018494,
0.06997017562389374,
-0.007795544806867838,
0.07153601944446564,
-0.012348352000117302,
0.009133290499448776,
-0.004431768786162138,
-0.0537697933614254,
-0.00010544324322836474,
-0.0017208539647981524,
-0.03926899656653404,
0.016833629459142685,
-0.05125612020492554,
0.03503118455410004,
0.07446525990962982,
0.04080669954419136,
0.002796557266265154,
0.006185569334775209,
-0.0071617113426327705,
0.018611006438732147,
-0.007217355538159609,
-0.04442582651972771,
-0.017668548971414566,
-0.006539545487612486,
-0.030984114855527878,
-0.009687413461506367,
0.00855166558176279,
0.014054736122488976,
-0.01563137024641037,
-0.02581813372671604,
-0.042142972350120544,
0.028892485424876213,
-0.0426996648311615,
-0.00728389760479331,
-0.0006413433002308011,
0.06750783324241638,
-0.029145952314138412,
0.05215950682759285,
0.02334703505039215,
-0.07285010069608688,
0.012269112281501293,
-0.009007304906845093,
-0.00853216927498579,
-0.003053076099604368,
0.001266529317945242,
0.07208243012428284,
-0.016891125589609146,
-0.007519778795540333,
-0.0031362453009933233,
-0.08850140869617462,
-0.03612435236573219,
0.02302548475563526,
0.022278891876339912,
0.06125975027680397,
0.0026662780437618494,
-0.043996237218379974,
0.04643523320555687,
-0.0035235953982919455,
0.04078363627195358,
0.0447518453001976,
0.002439645351842046,
0.04824258014559746,
0.01468291599303484,
-0.010916177183389664,
-0.013281388208270073,
0.013449834659695625,
-0.04973125085234642,
-0.03377549350261688,
0.03569365292787552,
-0.009763008914887905,
0.018030725419521332,
0.05056272819638252,
-0.012170940637588501,
0.03731567785143852,
0.040100809186697006,
-0.007890862412750721,
-0.007773477118462324,
-0.00310671329498291,
-0.06337770074605942,
0.004032892640680075,
-0.0011812272714450955,
0.003328456310555339,
0.014496944844722748,
-0.023670630529522896,
0.07378558814525604,
0.06295719742774963,
-0.08170690387487411,
-0.01083158329129219,
-0.008843908086419106,
-0.04128650948405266,
-0.003312105080112815,
0.025976521894335747,
-0.03189031779766083,
0.009077129885554314,
-0.02470759116113186,
0.02275564707815647,
-0.010257494635879993,
0.012746725231409073,
-0.03969554975628853,
-0.02445797435939312,
0.046882934868335724,
-0.011400377377867699,
0.0798749327659607,
0.02782154083251953,
0.02983180433511734,
0.03169606998562813,
-0.008127558045089245,
0.015297233127057552,
-0.011462702415883541,
-0.004464419558644295,
0.00019775469263549894,
0.01664678566157818,
-0.04676945134997368,
-0.037557393312454224,
-0.054621148854494095,
0.029704684391617775,
-0.03846673667430878,
0.05393299087882042,
0.041379664093256,
0.0038601337000727654,
-0.008631152100861073,
-0.0005289580440148711,
0.016675328835844994,
0.009877132251858711,
-0.13051539659500122,
-0.03537915647029877,
-0.00460707675665617,
-0.017595753073692322,
0.04466767609119415,
0.004084850195795298,
-0.03829975426197052,
0.04228876158595085,
-0.027098560705780983,
-0.018715238198637962,
0.030477523803710938,
0.025065848603844643,
0.022591734305024147,
-0.004333878867328167,
-0.015644952654838562,
0.031230304390192032,
0.06326379626989365,
0.0017591454088687897,
-0.008749417029321194,
-0.011804488487541676,
-0.033286791294813156,
0.009747164323925972,
-0.07794492691755295,
-0.026394274085760117,
-0.018370984122157097,
0.019399182870984077,
0.009363584220409393,
-0.0208442285656929,
0.011198787949979305,
0.04059658944606781,
0.034501079469919205,
0.023799674585461617,
-0.01373346894979477,
-0.029588958248496056,
0.0025655461940914392,
-0.015735648572444916,
0.022422637790441513,
-0.03869543969631195,
0.03702409192919731,
0.01728142611682415,
-0.021904530003666878,
0.01691978983581066,
-0.003588646650314331,
-0.27403247356414795,
-0.047108717262744904,
0.03582732379436493,
-0.008249574340879917,
0.04733177274465561,
-0.00978816207498312,
0.09366223216056824,
-0.02299933135509491,
-0.02794947475194931,
-0.009571313858032227,
0.02155405655503273,
0.047163140028715134,
0.026400627568364143,
0.07309795916080475,
0.054036155343055725,
0.035031937062740326,
-0.025920651853084564,
-0.04107002913951874,
-0.0012715120101347566,
0.0043717906810343266,
-0.022278694435954094,
-0.05554044991731644,
-0.010823247022926807,
0.016492079943418503,
0.008222748525440693,
0.04883533716201782,
-0.09325239062309265,
-0.04348515346646309,
-0.0049168760888278484,
-0.016819104552268982,
0.00930927786976099,
-0.024096984416246414,
-0.04709004610776901,
0.013767226599156857,
0.019290592521429062,
-0.01688244752585888,
0.07147650420665741,
0.014144964516162872,
0.056376513093709946,
-0.0060656690038740635,
0.015231139026582241,
-0.004707013256847858,
-0.060398295521736145,
0.007863282226026058,
0.06151679903268814,
0.022499341517686844,
-0.06824243813753128,
-0.014059760607779026,
-0.00025142167578451335,
0.03654686361551285,
-0.02050109952688217,
-0.016174770891666412,
-0.025264335796236992,
-0.021755017340183258,
0.02278890274465084,
-0.03716755658388138,
0.009100855328142643,
0.0034220179077237844,
-0.01780744083225727,
-0.011619796976447105,
-0.019386673346161842,
-0.009980774484574795,
-0.032116565853357315,
-0.02806662581861019,
0.01892479881644249,
-0.033758822828531265,
-0.06200756877660751,
-0.0724419578909874,
0.03424655646085739,
0.015486913733184338,
-0.02004045434296131,
-0.011252076365053654,
-0.0009756750660017133,
-0.11039043217897415,
0.011493911035358906,
0.025007223710417747,
-0.036019764840602875,
-0.06152107194066048,
0.018840298056602478,
0.024520371109247208,
-0.04240578040480614,
-0.04025570675730705,
-0.01194013562053442,
-0.0031578615307807922,
0.031051741912961006,
-0.015247109346091747,
0.030999217182397842,
-0.04400772601366043,
-0.02587161399424076,
-0.02397887594997883,
0.05105043575167656,
-0.00020360585767775774,
-0.008605721406638622,
0.01879104971885681,
0.07894010096788406,
0.051716629415750504,
0.04418341815471649,
0.050603874027729034,
0.04029594361782074,
-0.00996575877070427,
0.06322982162237167,
-0.07866890728473663,
0.022293508052825928,
-0.01234728004783392,
-0.036979030817747116,
0.0237718615680933,
-0.04576639086008072,
-0.031681209802627563,
0.047156065702438354,
0.009763244539499283,
0.007970346137881279,
-0.04493655264377594,
-0.0012676110491156578,
-0.011051193810999393,
-0.0031921134795993567,
0.0026248455978929996,
0.0038482944946736097,
0.030345596373081207,
0.02538485638797283,
0.014911317266523838,
-0.024778056889772415,
0.006135986652225256,
-0.025212449952960014,
0.014257377944886684,
-0.01023479737341404,
-0.005241457838565111,
0.012773032300174236,
0.005916080437600613,
0.057096242904663086,
-0.019553741440176964,
0.007945005781948566,
0.024713972583413124,
-0.01733521930873394,
0.007458014879375696,
0.05786551162600517,
0.009470829740166664,
-0.029811877757310867,
-0.004218672402203083,
0.026035908609628677,
-0.01812151074409485,
-0.004384487401694059,
-0.009663360193371773,
0.03255651518702507,
0.00956706888973713,
-0.002780113834887743,
-0.00846510287374258,
0.041882965713739395,
0.005764925852417946,
0.03761336952447891,
0.0009122244082391262,
0.03210330381989479,
-0.025051025673747063,
0.005958384368568659,
-0.02205069363117218,
-0.01584724336862564,
-0.0792016088962555,
0.04017246142029762,
-0.04446094483137131,
0.01591271348297596,
-0.06370726972818375,
0.006409752182662487,
-0.051716625690460205,
-0.01774122565984726,
0.0005552550428546965,
0.0266029704362154,
0.05753230303525925,
-0.026238789781928062,
-0.006497716065496206,
-0.006139284931123257,
0.004715613089501858,
0.00029742263723164797,
0.0020060117822140455,
-0.029470637440681458,
-0.007864740677177906,
-0.031197883188724518,
0.003374141175299883,
0.01237910520285368,
-0.012360961176455021,
-0.036336369812488556,
0.02536945603787899,
-0.0008516590460203588,
-0.02520553208887577,
-0.02139873616397381,
-0.025299137458205223,
0.05361967533826828,
-0.012778992764651775,
0.03850632905960083,
0.014992328360676765,
-0.02771458402276039,
0.00034817022969946265,
0.006307697854936123,
0.021034447476267815,
-0.015788335353136063,
-0.02889840118587017,
-0.031162746250629425,
-0.04194090887904167,
0.03036188706755638,
-0.02897152118384838,
-0.02057947777211666,
0.021825850009918213,
0.023885676637291908,
0.0191099364310503,
-0.052296530455350876,
-0.030499473214149475,
0.01595243066549301,
-0.07720425724983215,
0.013666363433003426,
0.01144788321107626,
0.04636587202548981,
0.03315763548016548,
-0.06577154248952866,
0.0005686888471245766,
-0.04341486096382141,
-0.013581857085227966,
-0.01244704145938158,
-0.013682334683835506,
0.004937418270856142,
-0.05610426887869835,
-0.026713723316788673,
-0.020681502297520638,
-0.017059415578842163,
-0.0024353438057005405,
-0.029151083901524544,
-0.03763734549283981,
-0.018836315721273422,
0.026897689327597618,
-0.004891690332442522,
-0.03710835427045822,
0.017485881224274635,
-0.009871790185570717,
0.029361365363001823,
-0.026089983060956,
0.0024355596397072077,
0.007679425645619631,
0.005110417492687702,
-0.016660433262586594,
-0.026829617097973824,
0.0001471399882575497,
0.019129272550344467,
-0.04270303621888161,
-0.026935597881674767,
0.012199778109788895,
-0.017249956727027893,
-0.01243932731449604,
0.030051806941628456,
0.01561927143484354,
-0.0074941255152225494,
-0.025424662977457047,
-0.001775554963387549,
0.0333622545003891,
0.017693931236863136,
0.000439704570453614,
-0.036415185779333115,
0.00475314911454916,
0.04780406504869461,
-0.04575071111321449,
-0.037139780819416046,
-0.03923138603568077,
-0.045227352529764175,
-0.008584798313677311,
0.0013707922771573067,
0.03647862747311592,
-0.04437171295285225,
0.035313647240400314,
0.01153381634503603,
0.009228475391864777,
0.007973768748342991,
-0.031166935339570045,
0.0469692125916481,
-0.06531061232089996,
0.034550152719020844,
-0.07276786863803864,
0.004068803042173386,
0.07086958736181259,
-0.043301165103912354,
-0.049151625484228134,
0.03859874606132507,
-0.0166760366410017,
0.035233184695243835,
-0.007361269555985928,
-0.04016653820872307,
0.07720304280519485,
-0.020510006695985794,
0.003909123595803976,
0.020927010104060173,
-0.030738653615117073,
-0.019680822268128395,
-0.015607655979692936,
-0.04153403267264366,
0.02888452634215355,
0.005226765759289265,
0.07291275262832642,
-0.012809762731194496,
0.06176239624619484,
-0.053060051053762436,
-0.018648622557520866,
0.009724552743136883,
0.02987692505121231,
-0.01453868206590414,
0.06171102449297905,
-0.016112206503748894,
0.0609755776822567,
0.061635833233594894,
0.05550551414489746,
0.028214873746037483,
-0.012875865213572979,
-0.03241942450404167,
-0.041080038994550705,
0.03449913114309311,
0.00482881860807538,
-0.030992276966571808,
-0.07358521223068237,
0.0568498857319355,
0.008478030562400818,
-0.04403597488999367,
-0.0006887689232826233,
-0.005588402505964041,
-0.09464512020349503,
0.011333123780786991,
-0.005361274350434542,
0.006038733758032322,
0.018537651747465134,
0.04916336014866829,
0.004429899156093597,
0.06295844912528992,
0.08762217313051224,
0.036682628095149994,
0.009188482537865639,
-0.027727996930480003,
0.06406857073307037,
0.059821873903274536,
0.05273561552166939,
-0.012609418481588364,
0.08151710033416748,
-0.040342964231967926,
-0.034962624311447144,
0.029620854184031487,
0.03464046120643616,
-0.009647042490541935,
-0.022879602387547493,
0.015407636761665344,
0.058672793209552765,
0.0004570351738948375,
0.04884679988026619,
-0.06371817737817764,
-0.0346403494477272,
0.06840848922729492,
0.01795392669737339,
0.0005054210196249187,
0.011058878153562546,
0.06111547723412514,
0.05452229082584381,
-0.033793170005083084,
-0.010230930522084236,
0.007539370097219944,
-0.07914258539676666,
-0.005362036172300577,
0.004466402810066938,
-0.0050773597322404385,
0.036250218749046326,
-0.003155076876282692,
0.048895999789237976,
0.12029804289340973,
-0.0341053307056427,
0.006842799950391054,
0.002276269719004631,
0.001030771411024034,
0.0019138890784233809,
0.03217436000704765,
0.02058502286672592,
0.019303621724247932,
0.02076024003326893,
-0.04721276834607124,
0.03835368901491165,
0.05489987134933472,
0.0014462408144026995,
0.050539273768663406,
-0.020096778869628906,
-0.0418417751789093,
-0.016246581450104713,
-0.004098962061107159,
-0.05667010694742203,
-0.04479025676846504,
-0.021712303161621094,
-0.02368481643497944,
-0.017206190153956413,
-0.016147471964359283,
0.04692567139863968,
0.004070548340678215,
-0.053686220198869705,
-0.01362173818051815,
-0.01052124798297882,
0.014221416786313057,
-0.022501666098833084,
-0.046384915709495544,
0.025189435109496117,
0.018765779212117195,
0.023526562377810478,
0.012744702398777008,
0.0405966192483902,
0.04380209743976593,
-0.016873294487595558,
-0.01835419237613678,
-0.024019205942749977,
0.00374620477668941,
0.023068413138389587,
-0.003513325471431017,
-0.029389791190624237,
-0.08198505640029907,
-0.001727724215015769,
0.024301614612340927,
-0.018213964998722076,
-0.07806015759706497,
0.020232388749718666,
-0.044922444969415665,
0.06298689544200897,
0.06872348487377167,
0.03281787782907486,
0.039370346814394,
-0.00015887875633779913,
0.023741740733385086,
0.025786934420466423,
-0.00619790144264698,
0.04599693790078163,
-0.03886551409959793,
0.06965178996324539,
0.02528657391667366,
-0.030003530904650688,
-0.0444912314414978,
0.04808243736624718,
0.008846121840178967,
-0.026612257584929466,
0.019362689927220345,
-0.032378267496824265,
-0.008708596229553223,
-0.12292487919330597,
-0.013982064090669155,
0.022791685536503792,
0.025028323754668236,
-0.057929545640945435,
-0.0003813612856902182,
0.001909035723656416,
-0.013158191926777363,
0.0021610904950648546,
-0.05348770692944527,
0.006077948492020369,
-0.026354050263762474,
-0.04025300592184067,
-0.052071861922740936,
-0.008775620721280575,
-0.03418426960706711,
-0.006998396012932062,
-0.027458053082227707,
-0.02088218368589878,
-0.027375847101211548,
-0.0033647085074335337,
0.027408510446548462,
0.0056713842786848545,
0.019818713888525963,
-0.001771501381881535
] |
328 |
Semantic Loss Guided Data Efficient Supervised Fine Tuning for Safe Responses in LLMs
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=kO0DgO07hW
|
[
"Yuxiao Lu",
"Arunesh Sinha",
"Pradeep Varakantham"
] |
Poster
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) generating unsafe responses to toxic prompts is a significant issue in their applications. While various efforts aim to address this safety concern, previous approaches often demand substantial human data collection or rely on the less dependable option of using another LLM to generate corrective data. In this paper, we aim to take this problem and overcome limitations of requiring significant high-quality human data. Our method requires only a small set of unsafe responses to toxic prompts, easily obtained from the unsafe LLM itself. By employing a semantic cost combined with a negative Earth Mover Distance (EMD) loss, we guide the LLM away from generating unsafe responses. Additionally, we propose a novel lower bound for EMD loss, enabling more efficient optimization. Our results demonstrate superior performance and data efficiency compared to baselines, and we further examine the nuanced effects of over-alignment and potential degradation of language capabilities when using contrastive data.
|
Large Language Model, Safe Large Language Model, Earth Mover Distance, Supervised Fine-tuning
| null | 13,451 |
2412.06843
|
[
-0.01609456166625023,
-0.01074122078716755,
0.0016298212576657534,
0.036587174981832504,
0.05692964792251587,
0.0162384994328022,
0.017897045239806175,
0.004138120450079441,
-0.021336006000638008,
-0.0015452876687049866,
-0.03460286185145378,
0.03743138164281845,
-0.06677138060331345,
-0.012932931073009968,
0.007018055766820908,
0.04813598096370697,
0.015956103801727295,
-0.0038399037439376116,
0.03705726936459541,
0.025760352611541748,
-0.00887982826679945,
-0.025575000792741776,
0.035081926733255386,
0.002566597191616893,
0.0585421584546566,
0.04808276146650314,
0.004536462016403675,
0.010467490181326866,
-0.041510820388793945,
0.007689313031733036,
0.042859144508838654,
0.001569868647493422,
0.007706712931394577,
-0.009130362421274185,
0.01320230308920145,
0.01292224321514368,
-0.06719500571489334,
0.003797840792685747,
-0.0017878977814689279,
0.02477763220667839,
-0.033352985978126526,
0.026394030079245567,
-0.021861637011170387,
0.009417385794222355,
-0.058615542948246,
0.0014832394663244486,
-0.09883297979831696,
-0.008929216302931309,
0.025295522063970566,
-0.07490769773721695,
-0.11062302440404892,
0.04566071555018425,
-0.009742606431245804,
-0.018475502729415894,
-0.00568237854167819,
0.007144625298678875,
0.06404800713062286,
-0.09707941859960556,
-0.010383340530097485,
-0.026172690093517303,
-0.05100325867533684,
0.01398493628948927,
-0.0007848339737392962,
-0.00871977861970663,
0.004128508735448122,
-0.006300071254372597,
-0.01579258218407631,
0.034338802099227905,
-0.059181325137615204,
-0.02137123979628086,
-0.009505542926490307,
0.016779251396656036,
-0.02877754531800747,
0.019411873072385788,
0.027746424078941345,
-0.06133066862821579,
-0.0009099144372157753,
0.0027667309623211622,
0.056276023387908936,
0.02600741572678089,
-0.021463483572006226,
0.02646614983677864,
0.03113194741308689,
0.02193509042263031,
0.021490374580025673,
0.014785770326852798,
-0.02155289240181446,
-0.021177485585212708,
-0.053464557975530624,
0.02050364390015602,
0.021470002830028534,
-0.029425475746393204,
0.008950352668762207,
0.01660388708114624,
0.010330227203667164,
0.026830313727259636,
0.012822108343243599,
0.015597675926983356,
-0.056695956736803055,
0.003722209483385086,
-0.03769535571336746,
-0.029913369566202164,
0.026992155238986015,
-0.009950158186256886,
-0.10782123357057571,
-0.015897128731012344,
-0.01845311000943184,
-0.017651602625846863,
0.0013180205132812262,
-0.025606174021959305,
-0.0402035117149353,
-0.017204588279128075,
0.0018666523974388838,
-0.016095057129859924,
-0.08161023259162903,
0.024508388713002205,
0.0379633828997612,
0.036528538912534714,
0.005449710879474878,
-0.0003046882920898497,
0.038645192980766296,
0.02233249880373478,
0.016212908551096916,
0.07804860919713974,
-0.052503444254398346,
0.016906019300222397,
-0.014971945434808731,
0.04883817210793495,
-0.024845575913786888,
-0.04270447790622711,
0.02067815698683262,
0.05008392035961151,
-0.003220213809981942,
-0.007202866952866316,
0.0021640534978359938,
0.03885927051305771,
0.016668815165758133,
0.010152569971978664,
0.05860701575875282,
0.00458587845787406,
0.010000853799283504,
-0.019781848415732384,
0.05297792702913284,
-0.028029168024659157,
0.09336704760789871,
-0.010185212828218937,
-0.0584830641746521,
0.0042551723308861256,
-0.05189592391252518,
0.016774794086813927,
0.011945393867790699,
0.004684025421738625,
-0.02210495062172413,
-0.060130562633275986,
0.021791469305753708,
0.08991456031799316,
0.007496860343962908,
-0.0051223402842879295,
-0.0005234106793068349,
0.007791837677359581,
-0.0005335915484465659,
-0.010739991441369057,
-0.0452708937227726,
0.006691876798868179,
-0.014767113141715527,
-0.06718116998672485,
-0.0003099855384789407,
-0.02391229383647442,
-0.03833644837141037,
0.01160277146846056,
-0.010313073173165321,
-0.010017809458076954,
0.04022768512368202,
-0.018754133954644203,
-0.01279138121753931,
-0.022739361971616745,
0.056083694100379944,
0.027058053761720657,
0.03382335230708122,
0.04077712073922157,
-0.07186855375766754,
0.02415567636489868,
0.020748300477862358,
0.01820659264922142,
0.03906736522912979,
-0.005944474600255489,
0.10518477857112885,
-0.04074077680706978,
0.02009354904294014,
0.01359554659575224,
-0.08349888771772385,
-0.02200804278254509,
0.026278236880898476,
-0.003505709581077099,
0.0533992238342762,
-0.027119172737002373,
-0.002134850015863776,
0.06329548358917236,
0.031105520203709602,
0.06627985835075378,
0.03152914717793465,
-0.017845362424850464,
0.019447747617959976,
-0.04610327258706093,
-0.00992745254188776,
-0.001583282952196896,
0.03982922434806824,
-0.02647240273654461,
-0.06126284971833229,
0.036891717463731766,
-0.030724849551916122,
-0.0036315061151981354,
0.03915741667151451,
-0.002485021250322461,
0.018626462668180466,
-0.018036704510450363,
-0.01610751822590828,
-0.006189869251102209,
0.00829861406236887,
-0.05418196693062782,
0.04885607212781906,
0.03035834990441799,
-0.011898702010512352,
0.003941209055483341,
-0.05421973392367363,
0.09966642409563065,
0.07668460160493851,
0.025430437177419662,
-0.009162196889519691,
0.013807883486151695,
0.021349508315324783,
-0.016724571585655212,
0.0066030919551849365,
-0.02232123166322708,
0.004721156787127256,
-0.011337301693856716,
-0.016092637553811073,
-0.04084942862391472,
0.07260484993457794,
-0.03597373515367508,
-0.015621433965861797,
0.059848859906196594,
-0.02294033020734787,
0.06322091817855835,
-0.00767773250117898,
0.02690943144261837,
0.055710870772600174,
-0.02869274839758873,
-0.02510417066514492,
-0.02509402483701706,
-0.017112813889980316,
0.006302145309746265,
0.010043247602880001,
0.0013998609501868486,
0.001752097625285387,
-0.05305340513586998,
-0.016799740493297577,
-0.0171598419547081,
0.0536450520157814,
0.05707684904336929,
0.00536775728687644,
0.04104425758123398,
0.009114083833992481,
-0.03967564180493355,
0.01896258071064949,
-0.08643361181020737,
-0.03236168622970581,
-0.0033161956816911697,
0.014624781906604767,
0.000365059677278623,
0.028605306521058083,
0.01183339487761259,
0.030326426029205322,
-0.0064861406572163105,
0.0023000098299235106,
0.008294232189655304,
0.05562250316143036,
-0.007565471809357405,
-0.05598552152514458,
0.011102898977696896,
0.005849881563335657,
0.04830059036612511,
-0.01713530533015728,
-0.01743718981742859,
-0.018096689134836197,
-0.035389356315135956,
0.0006142935599200428,
-0.04912961646914482,
-0.007015199866145849,
0.011182784102857113,
0.008061738684773445,
-0.03403962776064873,
-0.011226438917219639,
-0.003984122071415186,
0.031117575243115425,
0.027959706261754036,
0.03017025627195835,
0.022862248122692108,
0.016529731452465057,
0.05063638836145401,
-0.02598818764090538,
0.030635545030236244,
-0.00700197322294116,
0.011336646974086761,
-0.025551458820700645,
-0.015648193657398224,
0.0033856562804430723,
0.011081039905548096,
-0.26749297976493835,
-0.02973276749253273,
0.012083075940608978,
-0.016545318067073822,
0.028258202597498894,
0.00355926644988358,
0.04275239631533623,
-0.03167774900794029,
-0.013613725081086159,
0.0251876562833786,
0.02553449757397175,
0.03650406375527382,
0.049596164375543594,
0.040233273059129715,
0.07751930505037308,
0.04747358337044716,
0.0038366804365068674,
-0.05417269468307495,
-0.0008137217373587191,
0.02628394588828087,
0.003239190438762307,
-0.05232861265540123,
-0.05144285410642624,
0.06963758170604706,
-0.008573681116104126,
0.08585509657859802,
-0.05762839689850807,
0.001952553284354508,
-0.022037414833903313,
-0.031120019033551216,
0.008494340814650059,
-0.03167310729622841,
-0.02413921058177948,
0.007978157140314579,
0.006656297016888857,
0.008774489164352417,
0.009428117424249649,
0.01348201185464859,
0.040116164833307266,
0.010903360322117805,
-0.001702605397440493,
-0.05681817978620529,
-0.030431455001235008,
-0.01244741678237915,
0.044471610337495804,
-0.004536396823823452,
-0.06509184837341309,
0.006779055576771498,
0.01841462217271328,
0.038582805544137955,
0.008844083175063133,
-0.04308188334107399,
-0.005143745336681604,
0.030278554186224937,
0.030257921665906906,
-0.013675802387297153,
0.016686631366610527,
0.011592122726142406,
-0.024554328992962837,
-0.006516208406537771,
0.009815295226871967,
-0.05528484284877777,
-0.04148770123720169,
-0.046903274953365326,
-0.02380966581404209,
-0.02982068620622158,
-0.0544540211558342,
-0.04765554517507553,
0.040887653827667236,
0.026645073667168617,
-0.02414030022919178,
0.021773209795355797,
0.008983839303255081,
-0.09720182418823242,
0.009516021236777306,
0.01770000346004963,
-0.003256941679865122,
-0.021604707464575768,
0.01555972546339035,
0.0255899578332901,
-0.06544119864702225,
-0.044707007706165314,
0.013593005016446114,
0.019343556836247444,
0.008170802146196365,
-0.03502007946372032,
0.03163609653711319,
-0.040006328374147415,
-0.023710550740361214,
-0.03379378467798233,
0.025092914700508118,
0.005049244966357946,
-0.022345392033457756,
0.02100091427564621,
0.030704772099852562,
0.027920076623558998,
0.02067878097295761,
0.03370392695069313,
0.02325725182890892,
-0.02438007853925228,
0.005019155330955982,
-0.057505130767822266,
0.0011952329659834504,
-0.058483850210905075,
-0.012359172105789185,
0.04349817335605621,
-0.06732045859098434,
-0.03503536805510521,
0.03397008404135704,
-0.024571150541305542,
-0.0011783060617744923,
0.01197514683008194,
0.030055353417992592,
-0.008629300631582737,
-0.025455648079514503,
0.0008244771743193269,
0.015851158648729324,
0.024050623178482056,
0.037398360669612885,
-0.03991593047976494,
-0.007758324034512043,
0.028537586331367493,
-0.0047938586212694645,
0.034372031688690186,
-0.003201915882527828,
-0.03462853655219078,
0.042316462844610214,
-0.0046105957590043545,
-0.03545602038502693,
-0.009913760237395763,
0.025107866153120995,
0.051270753145217896,
0.011980278417468071,
0.03327808156609535,
0.0502019077539444,
-0.02451111190021038,
-0.012102082371711731,
0.017459942027926445,
0.04489678516983986,
-0.0016109081916511059,
-0.0010593890910968184,
-0.017791949212551117,
0.022147521376609802,
0.04708985239267349,
0.05027220770716667,
0.012489799410104752,
0.01689445786178112,
-0.02926849015057087,
0.02134714461863041,
0.005415965802967548,
0.0157706867903471,
-0.05415426567196846,
-0.008475895039737225,
-0.054717980325222015,
0.006113233044743538,
-0.004657429177314043,
0.038774196058511734,
-0.02284075878560543,
0.029382217675447464,
-0.05308574065566063,
0.040832988917827606,
0.008069219067692757,
-0.004009061027318239,
0.0115725789219141,
0.017674608156085014,
0.024509532377123833,
-0.022165494039654732,
-0.0164345595985651,
0.024637017399072647,
0.009760669432580471,
0.004903746303170919,
-0.03991793096065521,
-0.026017751544713974,
-0.004402180667966604,
-0.014287767931818962,
-0.010565406642854214,
-0.005268656648695469,
-0.04024025797843933,
-0.014024562202394009,
0.05568994954228401,
-0.01371089555323124,
-0.022778011858463287,
0.010163597762584686,
0.012034106068313122,
0.08236566185951233,
-0.008714554831385612,
0.029030531644821167,
-0.004580158274620771,
-0.017495794221758842,
-0.0048585268668830395,
-0.01571938395500183,
-0.00652901828289032,
-0.018786825239658356,
0.00030189278186298907,
-0.023870844393968582,
-0.06012479215860367,
0.025624241679906845,
-0.018801044672727585,
0.026751546189188957,
0.007618460804224014,
-0.005351571831852198,
-0.006070251576602459,
-0.029532786458730698,
-0.02742692641913891,
-0.01111298892647028,
-0.09096992760896683,
-0.01775379478931427,
0.031915389001369476,
-0.02472151443362236,
0.026622947305440903,
-0.03208909183740616,
-0.04292749613523483,
-0.04276570677757263,
-0.007410119287669659,
0.030694391578435898,
-0.03729375824332237,
-0.03888089582324028,
-0.020245982334017754,
0.0006694967160001397,
-0.028401941061019897,
0.0038879013154655695,
-0.02977929264307022,
-0.0020111326593905687,
0.0052132620476186275,
0.021139774471521378,
0.038407303392887115,
-0.03698170185089111,
-0.012950483709573746,
0.004813108593225479,
-0.027538862079381943,
0.0029133143834769726,
-0.04646584019064903,
0.054007742553949356,
0.044796302914619446,
-0.006369261536747217,
0.00749146519228816,
-0.026764698326587677,
0.05014343187212944,
0.024087879806756973,
-0.018590852618217468,
0.005887477658689022,
-0.010888239368796349,
-0.005744272377341986,
0.003327751997858286,
0.031229790300130844,
0.053051985800266266,
0.011643832549452782,
-0.018374580889940262,
-0.0182198453694582,
-0.004577317275106907,
0.012928207404911518,
0.03616177663207054,
-0.03486087545752525,
-0.012642741203308105,
0.06436581909656525,
-0.03794708102941513,
-0.03389851376414299,
-0.08058862388134003,
-0.04237101972103119,
0.0030010193586349487,
0.010317654348909855,
0.03907161206007004,
-0.027699174359440804,
0.062285974621772766,
0.011268207803368568,
0.07194571197032928,
-0.0014975699596107006,
-0.020180130377411842,
0.056060101836919785,
-0.03951055184006691,
-0.01747586764395237,
-0.05665483698248863,
0.00010443000064697117,
0.07022107392549515,
-0.06753388792276382,
-0.006836795713752508,
-0.040064625442028046,
-0.05652349069714546,
0.005060538649559021,
-0.002484142780303955,
-0.0661909431219101,
-0.0034211622551083565,
-0.01077769324183464,
-0.031661856919527054,
0.03633688762784004,
-0.03361322358250618,
0.0036332944873720407,
-0.003893436398357153,
-0.02864047698676586,
-0.012722275219857693,
-0.028522290289402008,
0.05257584527134895,
-0.05433613434433937,
0.022685891017317772,
-0.06396496295928955,
0.008158845826983452,
-0.0009254520409740508,
0.05742393806576729,
0.00753013975918293,
0.01832420378923416,
-0.022634202614426613,
0.05762829631567001,
0.021314362064003944,
-0.028683319687843323,
-0.011563172563910484,
0.0075221904553473,
-0.000046217341150622815,
-0.03757341951131821,
0.057417143136262894,
0.007678164169192314,
-0.016081348061561584,
-0.042632848024368286,
0.06181619316339493,
0.06606011837720871,
-0.040228042751550674,
-0.01521222572773695,
0.03226074203848839,
-0.035838451236486435,
0.012586631812155247,
-0.01056232862174511,
-0.010510248132050037,
-0.006790538784116507,
0.0925498977303505,
0.019719254225492477,
0.04393572732806206,
0.07835549861192703,
0.003229603637009859,
-0.011338933371007442,
0.025911495089530945,
0.07750231772661209,
0.072465680539608,
0.06924636662006378,
-0.0063254437409341335,
0.06627450883388519,
-0.052599892020225525,
-0.06254474818706512,
0.009937820956110954,
0.01207356434315443,
-0.021353840827941895,
-0.029986083507537842,
0.010463598184287548,
0.049960725009441376,
-0.0148348119109869,
0.06490088254213333,
-0.04413299635052681,
0.001563382102176547,
0.044777967035770416,
0.0018626218661665916,
0.014942336827516556,
0.030907398089766502,
0.019859159365296364,
-0.0016758532728999853,
-0.0006487705395556986,
-0.007664158474653959,
0.013521038927137852,
0.005082216579467058,
0.023234959691762924,
-0.006166808772832155,
-0.029882825911045074,
0.019258800894021988,
-0.028132040053606033,
0.045901622623205185,
0.1285284012556076,
-0.03845265135169029,
-0.04284404590725899,
-0.010890573263168335,
0.006950235925614834,
-0.021213531494140625,
0.04353060573339462,
0.005953571759164333,
-0.028941502794623375,
-0.010825060307979584,
-0.06236226484179497,
-0.01307706255465746,
0.012231052853167057,
-0.035578712821006775,
0.04608200863003731,
-0.04063688963651657,
-0.03214620053768158,
0.01739276386797428,
0.03341808542609215,
-0.026257028803229332,
-0.03927331045269966,
-0.06128319352865219,
-0.026945918798446655,
-0.06475868821144104,
-0.06103651598095894,
0.010742547921836376,
0.04006810486316681,
-0.0088974479585886,
0.040575891733169556,
-0.039065998047590256,
-0.007778232451528311,
0.006055791396647692,
-0.08251313120126724,
0.01579480990767479,
0.06486789882183075,
-0.007848302833735943,
-0.02856852486729622,
0.044879015535116196,
-0.0014376374892890453,
0.0034777463879436255,
-0.028149357065558434,
0.058930348604917526,
-0.009052691981196404,
0.0234793983399868,
0.0029541063122451305,
0.01061936840415001,
-0.09879527240991592,
-0.008719393983483315,
0.004462019074708223,
-0.010224543511867523,
-0.0845186784863472,
0.03745907545089722,
-0.018556734547019005,
0.04223286733031273,
0.04829685762524605,
0.0019760613795369864,
0.01652836613357067,
-0.013391155749559402,
-0.02368062175810337,
-0.015512299723923206,
0.028701530769467354,
0.029311789199709892,
-0.02505270577967167,
0.04552894085645676,
0.04273431748151779,
-0.03761272132396698,
-0.02572910487651825,
0.005698126740753651,
0.010503399185836315,
-0.025501959025859833,
-0.0391525998711586,
-0.043625399470329285,
-0.016228066757321358,
-0.08728061616420746,
-0.02425985038280487,
0.015234945341944695,
0.006587166339159012,
-0.03045523166656494,
0.002939204452559352,
0.0022014142014086246,
-0.05541481822729111,
0.012072645127773285,
-0.021335234865546227,
-0.03888317570090294,
-0.0430571585893631,
-0.03095841407775879,
-0.04696397855877876,
0.048882875591516495,
-0.014735289849340916,
-0.013212825171649456,
-0.022231578826904297,
-0.013486278243362904,
0.05077274888753891,
0.0023555837105959654,
0.05694800242781639,
-0.019942350685596466,
0.02808362990617752,
-0.014039547182619572
] |
329 |
Adversarial Generative Flow Network for Solving Vehicle Routing Problems
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=tBom4xOW1H
|
[
"Ni Zhang",
"Jingfeng Yang",
"Zhiguang Cao",
"Xu Chi"
] |
Poster
|
Recent research into solving vehicle routing problems (VRPs) has gained significant traction, particularly through the application of deep (reinforcement) learning for end-to-end solution construction. However, many current construction-based neural solvers predominantly utilize Transformer architectures, which can face scalability challenges and struggle to produce diverse solutions. To address these limitations, we introduce a novel framework beyond Transformer-based approaches, i.e., Adversarial Generative Flow Networks (AGFN). This framework integrates the generative flow network (GFlowNet)—a probabilistic model inherently adept at generating diverse solutions (routes)—with a complementary model for discriminating (or evaluating) the solutions. These models are trained alternately in an adversarial manner to improve the overall solution quality, followed by a proposed hybrid decoding method to construct the solution. We apply the AGFN framework to solve the capacitated vehicle routing problem (CVRP) and travelling salesman problem (TSP), and our experimental results demonstrate that AGFN surpasses the popular construction-based neural solvers, showcasing strong generalization capabilities on synthetic and real-world benchmark instances.
|
Generative Flow Network, Adversarial Training, Vehicle Routing Problem
| null | 13,449 |
2503.01931
|
[
0.022538188844919205,
-0.04675490781664848,
-0.008373924531042576,
0.06332429498434067,
0.027027273550629616,
0.056309714913368225,
0.018657781183719635,
0.024660257622599602,
-0.015090109780430794,
-0.05256194993853569,
-0.0008793656597845256,
-0.0352611280977726,
-0.08365833759307861,
0.035625290125608444,
-0.02251136489212513,
0.058766718953847885,
-0.007753828540444374,
-0.009774460457265377,
0.01901368238031864,
0.017083918675780296,
-0.003598235547542572,
-0.04367442801594734,
0.05752851068973541,
0.018481174483895302,
0.05626263469457626,
-0.013338263146579266,
0.00978357158601284,
0.020484745502471924,
-0.02342268079519272,
-0.024777164682745934,
0.031025299802422523,
-0.02633005566895008,
0.044080574065446854,
-0.020089976489543915,
-0.009677808731794357,
-0.04128292202949524,
-0.04240809381008148,
-0.056775715202093124,
-0.0006958537269383669,
-0.004952997900545597,
-0.03511180728673935,
0.005915337707847357,
-0.05913383513689041,
0.009115124121308327,
-0.020754747092723846,
0.04571346938610077,
-0.055265843868255615,
0.019049108028411865,
-0.003365226788446307,
-0.04038626700639725,
-0.08568687736988068,
0.03601831570267677,
0.0008088133181445301,
-0.005757278297096491,
0.008274850435554981,
0.009790265932679176,
0.046549271792173386,
-0.07111182808876038,
0.004452156834304333,
-0.07573763281106949,
-0.01561895664781332,
0.047577887773513794,
0.02418685331940651,
0.03443128243088722,
-0.0037504390347748995,
-0.01913742534816265,
-0.0017406472470611334,
0.06848397105932236,
-0.026603855192661285,
-0.02935933507978916,
-0.049305595457553864,
0.0073645468801259995,
0.03329470753669739,
0.0015607785899192095,
-0.037814170122146606,
-0.03279036656022072,
0.001546364277601242,
0.032148174941539764,
0.04946538433432579,
0.004402165301144123,
0.021701183170080185,
0.01739967055618763,
-0.009333726949989796,
0.042510248720645905,
0.0527578704059124,
0.04492422565817833,
-0.02135961689054966,
-0.010255817323923111,
-0.056783996522426605,
0.031507812440395355,
-0.024042604491114616,
-0.05101915821433067,
-0.049276191741228104,
0.034115973860025406,
0.03199445456266403,
-0.020506078377366066,
0.024036763235926628,
-0.0024877190589904785,
0.005973054561764002,
0.011155185289680958,
-0.011151718907058239,
-0.019078992307186127,
0.022821981459856033,
-0.021816741675138474,
-0.08532390743494034,
-0.029167043045163155,
-0.009177381172776222,
-0.022958116605877876,
0.0076895831152796745,
-0.021652409806847572,
-0.0358414426445961,
0.0020225520711392164,
-0.017159353941679,
-0.012983376160264015,
-0.049895577132701874,
0.04409865662455559,
-0.006383180618286133,
-0.0189216248691082,
-0.010815372690558434,
0.008877559565007687,
0.05735445395112038,
0.020740820094943047,
-0.025501543655991554,
0.06327004730701447,
-0.024497898295521736,
0.012550550512969494,
0.013267001137137413,
0.026440700516104698,
-0.025094173848628998,
-0.010604052804410458,
-0.02825368009507656,
0.03794084116816521,
-0.018294895067811012,
0.013748353347182274,
-0.010795490816235542,
-0.027152320370078087,
-0.008810625411570072,
0.026062844321131706,
0.04802614450454712,
-0.0317729152739048,
-0.0473838709294796,
-0.006524647586047649,
0.08240244537591934,
-0.04103749990463257,
0.09001634269952774,
-0.0073770880699157715,
0.018430421128869057,
-0.05778151750564575,
-0.04895683750510216,
0.005827305838465691,
-0.013473805040121078,
0.009212466888129711,
-0.008547483012080193,
-0.06624674052000046,
0.0018369018798694015,
0.07142726331949234,
0.019120560958981514,
0.03933515399694443,
-0.048970941454172134,
-0.025849848985671997,
0.007886780425906181,
0.014929032884538174,
-0.04400042071938515,
0.0066024307161569595,
-0.03726857900619507,
-0.03653687983751297,
0.03368864208459854,
0.04114965721964836,
-0.06674446165561676,
-0.022735992446541786,
-0.026326581835746765,
-0.05266673117876053,
0.040322013199329376,
-0.012552747502923012,
-0.011984598822891712,
-0.018285294994711876,
0.06999797374010086,
-0.02560586854815483,
0.04590907320380211,
0.018591048195958138,
-0.07216167449951172,
0.04741334542632103,
0.031055202707648277,
-0.004524893593043089,
0.0054784961976110935,
-0.03385545313358307,
0.04175107181072235,
0.005897732451558113,
0.0002278292377013713,
0.029754728078842163,
-0.05854567512869835,
-0.06271336227655411,
-0.011752113699913025,
-0.03129637986421585,
0.039475638419389725,
0.022448891773819923,
-0.03015848621726036,
0.0374213382601738,
0.0074170236475765705,
0.06982188671827316,
0.04495682194828987,
-0.01801157370209694,
0.029439782723784447,
-0.0589049831032753,
-0.05505738779902458,
0.032865025103092194,
0.06094250828027725,
-0.02433169260621071,
-0.04244896396994591,
0.05152032524347305,
-0.018983857706189156,
-0.01641533337533474,
0.004889111500233412,
-0.009900244884192944,
0.03874289244413376,
0.023720448836684227,
-0.01673910580575466,
0.012951274402439594,
0.05053984373807907,
-0.037035953253507614,
0.058149565011262894,
0.010956342332065105,
-0.026081480085849762,
0.010265232995152473,
-0.0711842030286789,
0.06920849531888962,
0.06816621124744415,
-0.03269806504249573,
-0.017547085881233215,
0.009817217476665974,
0.03417471796274185,
0.03912973403930664,
-0.005628057289868593,
-0.023812977597117424,
0.008840546943247318,
-0.028371451422572136,
0.007736044004559517,
-0.0005233079427853227,
0.037593740969896317,
-0.03344164043664932,
-0.02939426340162754,
0.05200233682990074,
-0.014008661732077599,
0.054854463785886765,
0.028783058747649193,
0.03479202836751938,
0.0249550212174654,
0.005665190517902374,
0.009963961318135262,
-0.025848593562841415,
-0.0320250503718853,
0.006976525764912367,
0.02376665361225605,
0.027742989361286163,
-0.03041342832148075,
-0.05627644434571266,
-0.024865612387657166,
-0.027785371989011765,
0.08841370046138763,
0.07296182215213776,
0.00545296398922801,
0.027308786287903786,
-0.00608109263703227,
0.0006312885088846087,
-0.035267360508441925,
-0.12531861662864685,
-0.028692029416561127,
-0.027914049103856087,
0.05800536274909973,
0.05105813220143318,
0.04852890968322754,
-0.004900223109871149,
0.024526450783014297,
-0.03638661280274391,
-0.013706090860068798,
0.020380094647407532,
0.008637728169560432,
0.03810705244541168,
-0.02474886178970337,
0.000059594523918349296,
0.00001774994052539114,
0.06265991181135178,
-0.018104802817106247,
-0.0013234562939032912,
-0.03148685395717621,
-0.04004441946744919,
0.015662241727113724,
-0.03312152996659279,
0.014936144463717937,
0.035309914499521255,
0.016124766319990158,
0.026580391451716423,
-0.04432304576039314,
0.008505888283252716,
0.05221659690141678,
0.04581686854362488,
0.03884470835328102,
-0.007040033116936684,
-0.014803501777350903,
0.021035045385360718,
-0.0003372129867784679,
0.01402859203517437,
-0.04794936254620552,
-0.0028772286605089903,
-0.026997921988368034,
-0.01017916202545166,
0.0037234334740787745,
-0.0023307043593376875,
-0.2557699978351593,
-0.025778762996196747,
0.004956085234880447,
0.002146494807675481,
0.01006926130503416,
-0.011078611947596073,
0.03820369392633438,
-0.026136131957173347,
-0.03494369611144066,
-0.013547579757869244,
0.007055787835270166,
0.012230549938976765,
0.004014359787106514,
0.04864572361111641,
0.02889145165681839,
0.015392684377729893,
0.011598327197134495,
-0.051445793360471725,
0.03252303600311279,
0.005420727655291557,
-0.03384702280163765,
-0.09324522316455841,
-0.0538698211312294,
0.015280934050679207,
-0.007190721109509468,
0.0371953547000885,
-0.07467447221279144,
-0.033338576555252075,
-0.009921211749315262,
0.008737356401979923,
-0.009490681812167168,
-0.00795748271048069,
-0.014074171893298626,
0.04839901998639107,
-0.014369159005582333,
-0.01565101370215416,
0.03399444371461868,
-0.01640941947698593,
0.050946298986673355,
-0.00820252113044262,
-0.003651545848697424,
-0.0032081727404147387,
-0.02703217975795269,
0.004174650181084871,
0.05986563488841057,
-0.008039738982915878,
-0.03657890111207962,
-0.003578010480850935,
-0.010864566080272198,
0.02543116919696331,
0.014830031432211399,
0.004985333885997534,
0.0050134845077991486,
0.0035239916760474443,
0.01579982414841652,
-0.018863514065742493,
0.028915701434016228,
-0.05825745314359665,
0.025050470605492592,
0.025448894128203392,
0.019508952274918556,
-0.033716149628162384,
-0.012685060501098633,
-0.03702164813876152,
-0.029770750552415848,
0.016655201092362404,
-0.033902041614055634,
-0.08271776139736176,
0.03215945512056351,
0.005824989173561335,
0.0044818539172410965,
0.037320904433727264,
-0.005293380469083786,
-0.09278536587953568,
0.0070250858552753925,
-0.0006165009690448642,
-0.018012480810284615,
0.013493992388248444,
0.020005259662866592,
-0.011484524235129356,
-0.018913935869932175,
-0.06687203794717789,
-0.016642211005091667,
0.00364454067312181,
0.004110138863325119,
-0.0006803066353313625,
0.04442610219120979,
-0.007461485452950001,
-0.05118719860911369,
-0.007996056228876114,
0.04899446293711662,
0.010871547274291515,
0.047968894243240356,
-0.02907365933060646,
0.08140931278467178,
0.037885963916778564,
0.023180002346634865,
0.043900199234485626,
0.04735403135418892,
0.000025543393348925747,
0.038725901395082474,
-0.0774582177400589,
-0.018678728491067886,
-0.031126273795962334,
-0.04027216508984566,
0.040739238262176514,
-0.012928578071296215,
0.0032086146529763937,
0.043216366320848465,
0.03504835069179535,
-0.006865516770631075,
-0.026321593672037125,
0.025126498192548752,
-0.003432922763749957,
-0.008155589923262596,
0.025580212473869324,
0.01734764128923416,
0.023070719093084335,
0.07121359556913376,
0.007461706642061472,
-0.02733522094786167,
0.05381206423044205,
-0.04500593617558479,
0.028188223019242287,
-0.012043074704706669,
0.005101623013615608,
-0.005198894068598747,
0.02129882387816906,
0.04169737920165062,
-0.00017378892516717315,
0.053630392998456955,
0.037364475429058075,
0.0011343199294060469,
-0.010822705924510956,
0.03997043892741203,
-0.012566902674734592,
-0.03373243659734726,
-0.01666967011988163,
0.046993568539619446,
-0.0043896702118217945,
0.013164591044187546,
-0.020460881292819977,
0.03489892557263374,
-0.03423084691166878,
0.0372074656188488,
0.026081308722496033,
0.0025602111127227545,
0.04378121718764305,
-0.0010122662642970681,
-0.014957450330257416,
0.028039008378982544,
-0.05040208250284195,
-0.0014295156579464674,
-0.029758810997009277,
0.03873312473297119,
-0.02510790340602398,
0.022674182429909706,
-0.02195585146546364,
-0.0024448528420180082,
-0.061017248779535294,
0.0843125432729721,
-0.00675276480615139,
-0.007527066394686699,
0.008100483566522598,
0.0028431902173906565,
0.056142110377550125,
0.027096793055534363,
-0.0244539063423872,
-0.030249567702412605,
0.02258884347975254,
0.0030369958840310574,
-0.017952371388673782,
-0.03952370211482048,
-0.005906876642256975,
-0.02560381032526493,
0.029740123078227043,
-0.004415386822074652,
-0.0252159982919693,
-0.024162689223885536,
0.028900284320116043,
-0.02238931879401207,
-0.005852190777659416,
0.021362531930208206,
-0.01614382676780224,
0.055872585624456406,
0.0257880762219429,
0.0045312996953725815,
-0.003417256288230419,
-0.003088036784902215,
0.0650596022605896,
-0.005733484867960215,
0.028359880670905113,
-0.015053583309054375,
-0.04246032238006592,
-0.02119688130915165,
-0.061981040984392166,
0.015330804511904716,
0.03020816296339035,
-0.026019178330898285,
-0.029184607788920403,
-0.007491053082048893,
-0.010105807334184647,
-0.026309426873922348,
-0.022285863757133484,
0.010392643511295319,
-0.07174172252416611,
0.015576976351439953,
0.02098555862903595,
0.04483722522854805,
0.037249255925416946,
-0.008588242344558239,
-0.021030502393841743,
-0.07271452993154526,
-0.007217868231236935,
-0.026844235137104988,
-0.00310898432508111,
-0.017099710181355476,
0.004922530148178339,
0.007217139005661011,
0.017912598326802254,
-0.010485497303307056,
-0.0154249407351017,
-0.02441868558526039,
-0.040340546518564224,
-0.02011844888329506,
0.07460051029920578,
-0.04373718053102493,
-0.04898086562752724,
-0.0033313909079879522,
0.0040856036357581615,
-0.003905537538230419,
-0.06800949573516846,
0.013104773126542568,
0.03518449887633324,
0.011738110333681107,
0.04974883422255516,
-0.03408787399530411,
0.0017211823724210262,
-0.004358074627816677,
-0.029345238581299782,
-0.002573951380327344,
-0.012214322574436665,
-0.02972140535712242,
0.004796427674591541,
0.020627273246645927,
0.007503848522901535,
-0.007083453703671694,
0.003789023030549288,
0.01097723376005888,
0.026502352207899094,
0.03248600661754608,
-0.014553558081388474,
-0.03495008498430252,
-0.005811556242406368,
0.05232282355427742,
-0.02999565191566944,
-0.028429273515939713,
-0.034061167389154434,
-0.018230775371193886,
0.018815943971276283,
-0.04150935634970665,
0.0018964388873428106,
-0.026926914229989052,
0.030653495341539383,
0.0316988006234169,
0.025234675034880638,
0.0007684743031859398,
-0.04794761538505554,
0.017265059053897858,
-0.05626668781042099,
0.02575051225721836,
-0.07441874593496323,
0.021403469145298004,
0.060269877314567566,
-0.002594208577647805,
-0.018910063430666924,
0.00275936140678823,
-0.03530724719166756,
0.039095524698495865,
-0.031790927052497864,
-0.07674536108970642,
0.0275346077978611,
-0.017831197008490562,
-0.0007079009083099663,
0.02622084505856037,
-0.03296186774969101,
0.0006650073337368667,
0.008975222706794739,
-0.052323829382658005,
0.004010520409792662,
0.024082044139504433,
0.04099838435649872,
-0.03819021210074425,
0.0004500952491071075,
-0.023494655266404152,
0.002730641048401594,
0.04000125080347061,
0.060581840574741364,
0.0035527674481272697,
0.03869674727320671,
-0.03433588519692421,
0.0593816339969635,
0.053177423775196075,
0.005141088739037514,
0.0012894223909825087,
0.03821393847465515,
0.0025418978184461594,
-0.06434180587530136,
0.05215669050812721,
0.023678921163082123,
-0.02008962258696556,
-0.08054841309785843,
0.06162530556321144,
0.002623338019475341,
-0.06356415152549744,
0.01114693470299244,
0.0198124460875988,
-0.08763248473405838,
0.00463336193934083,
0.01798311620950699,
0.029733510687947273,
0.022492675110697746,
0.04564867541193962,
-0.01907483860850334,
0.022006534039974213,
0.060582518577575684,
0.02698558010160923,
-0.01629701815545559,
0.006704845931380987,
0.04937291517853737,
0.03030502423644066,
0.02002178691327572,
-0.033196546137332916,
0.04621322825551033,
-0.009950580075383186,
-0.027044400572776794,
0.01979008875787258,
-0.006312960758805275,
-0.03769122064113617,
-0.032992321997880936,
0.00026113211060874164,
0.07694997638463974,
0.009419295936822891,
0.05953517556190491,
-0.04478103294968605,
0.020069565623998642,
0.04773453250527382,
0.01826493814587593,
-0.0197193194180727,
0.07249823957681656,
0.03698474168777466,
-0.0019318818813189864,
-0.014872422441840172,
-0.002369371708482504,
-0.042198438197374344,
0.01130768284201622,
-0.011974205262959003,
0.04292697086930275,
-0.02895837090909481,
0.009909328073263168,
0.0059992363676428795,
0.010582023300230503,
0.0922333151102066,
-0.06598208099603653,
-0.04806528985500336,
-0.03315964341163635,
0.03300464525818825,
-0.02188682369887829,
0.008454006165266037,
0.03145262598991394,
-0.05053448677062988,
-0.016872067004442215,
-0.040364526212215424,
0.0019246949814260006,
0.023498475551605225,
0.03628632798790932,
0.012287888675928116,
-0.01373274251818657,
-0.005716754589229822,
0.030302077531814575,
0.004110266920179129,
-0.01280203741043806,
-0.03550103306770325,
-0.03752521798014641,
-0.07162629067897797,
-0.0441800057888031,
-0.05431152135133743,
0.0035947891883552074,
-0.03418121114373207,
-0.048260707408189774,
-0.013830277137458324,
0.018094774335622787,
-0.0035335009451955557,
0.07953516393899918,
-0.0698876827955246,
-0.004229214508086443,
0.03762582689523697,
0.009318982250988483,
0.00027114342083223164,
0.00872355792671442,
0.03242436423897743,
-0.006544066593050957,
0.005232282914221287,
0.024643639102578163,
0.004612610675394535,
-0.0029807297978550196,
0.005088289268314838,
-0.002300584688782692,
-0.09253838658332825,
0.026844525709748268,
0.030291222035884857,
-0.05065473914146423,
-0.0950000137090683,
0.013568930327892303,
-0.030538499355316162,
0.029381413012742996,
0.08398918807506561,
0.020312955603003502,
0.006806283723562956,
-0.06808166950941086,
0.00914972834289074,
0.043408073484897614,
-0.03293279930949211,
0.05702131614089012,
-0.04487554356455803,
0.04589293152093887,
0.05831547826528549,
-0.019703028723597527,
-0.025099977850914,
0.04343678057193756,
0.017326682806015015,
0.002303633140400052,
-0.04232584312558174,
-0.03239631652832031,
-0.030083324760198593,
-0.0988616943359375,
-0.001226169872097671,
0.0005077547393739223,
-0.0002221725444542244,
-0.022099431604146957,
0.006930539384484291,
-0.029014665633440018,
0.018641194328665733,
-0.0024228242691606283,
-0.03276491537690163,
-0.01231051329523325,
-0.006137461867183447,
-0.022819768637418747,
-0.07997436821460724,
0.057137250900268555,
-0.005858803167939186,
0.014301192946732044,
0.0004011350101791322,
-0.05368700623512268,
0.014038734138011932,
-0.034180209040641785,
0.021625787019729614,
-0.02234886959195137,
0.028599094599485397,
-0.006657734978944063
] |
330 |
Tracking the Copyright of Large Vision-Language Models through Parameter Learning Adversarial Images
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=K7xpl3LZQp
|
[
"Yubo Wang",
"Jianting Tang",
"Chaohu Liu",
"Linli Xu"
] |
Poster
|
Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated remarkable image understanding and dialogue capabilities, allowing them to handle a variety of visual question answering tasks. However, their widespread availability raises concerns about unauthorized usage and copyright infringement, where users or individuals can develop their own LVLMs by fine-tuning published models. In this paper, we propose a novel method called Parameter Learning Attack (PLA) for tracking the copyright of LVLMs without modifying the original model. Specifically, we construct adversarial images through targeted attacks against the original model, enabling it to generate specific outputs. To ensure these attacks remain effective on potential fine-tuned models to trigger copyright tracking, we allow the original model to learn the trigger images by updating parameters in the opposite direction during the adversarial attack process. Notably, the proposed method can be applied after the release of the original model, thus not affecting the model’s performance and behavior. To simulate real-world applications, we fine-tune the original model using various strategies across diverse datasets, creating a range of models for copyright verification. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method can more effectively identify the original copyright of fine-tuned models compared to baseline methods. Therefore, this work provides a powerful tool for tracking copyrights and detecting unlicensed usage of LVLMs.
|
Copyright Tracking, Large Vision-Language Models, Adversarial Attacks, Fine-tuning
|
By allowing model parameter updates during adversarial attacks, the adversarial images can more effectively trigger fine-tuned models to output specific texts, thereby achieving the copyright tracking.
| 13,438 |
2502.16593
|
[
0.011184935458004475,
-0.006461398210376501,
0.0043407827615737915,
0.04127384349703789,
0.024005362764000893,
0.007092658430337906,
0.00788517203181982,
0.004066267050802708,
-0.030909007415175438,
-0.013606001622974873,
-0.04264445975422859,
0.005124371498823166,
-0.0624389722943306,
0.002382054226472974,
-0.00228469748981297,
0.05175573378801346,
0.018549315631389618,
0.0143483467400074,
0.026396101340651512,
0.020419539883732796,
-0.010725980624556541,
-0.018968380987644196,
0.030118484050035477,
-0.006189893465489149,
-0.005965101532638073,
-0.003778026206418872,
0.03611819073557854,
0.015019982121884823,
-0.04829806834459305,
0.021876033395528793,
0.04015038162469864,
-0.02224995754659176,
0.02569437213242054,
-0.016890810802578926,
0.035641200840473175,
0.004558362532407045,
-0.07787902653217316,
0.006992441602051258,
0.005998505745083094,
0.03635629266500473,
-0.020478811115026474,
0.03228263184428215,
-0.019012996926903725,
0.011321693658828735,
-0.0684831514954567,
0.008485212922096252,
-0.11829205602407455,
0.05058813840150833,
0.006516573950648308,
-0.021238436922430992,
-0.10634763538837433,
0.032675452530384064,
-0.04037833586335182,
0.0026394024025648832,
0.03830261528491974,
0.0342586450278759,
0.044678740203380585,
-0.08975342661142349,
-0.0020566515158861876,
-0.04401862621307373,
-0.015187500976026058,
-0.012139590457081795,
0.01864967681467533,
0.009737233631312847,
-0.006951690185815096,
-0.01791045255959034,
0.034291017800569534,
0.04205835610628128,
-0.05551401898264885,
-0.05682047829031944,
-0.0030481580179184675,
-0.004222196526825428,
-0.0209568552672863,
-0.03326869755983353,
-0.008817980997264385,
-0.04725964367389679,
-0.004340421874076128,
0.01819821074604988,
0.061159323900938034,
-0.014085792005062103,
0.013197164982557297,
0.03635748475790024,
0.0037762303836643696,
0.03195657953619957,
-0.008443528786301613,
0.013710683211684227,
-0.04762602597475052,
-0.018859917297959328,
-0.07022542506456375,
0.0037920752074569464,
-0.017088523134589195,
-0.042573850601911545,
0.018576232716441154,
0.030689869076013565,
0.010953649878501892,
0.006340872962027788,
-0.012410326860845089,
0.019058354198932648,
-0.018003586679697037,
0.02168959006667137,
-0.017542531713843346,
-0.029880465939641,
0.02454289235174656,
0.005851720925420523,
-0.10604076832532883,
-0.026700489223003387,
-0.018730076029896736,
0.0074857366271317005,
-0.011070596054196358,
-0.0026668733917176723,
-0.012759136967360973,
0.021602317690849304,
-0.003109038807451725,
-0.023788699880242348,
-0.06797843426465988,
0.02378305420279503,
0.007243981584906578,
0.004067608155310154,
-0.004767647944390774,
0.02167707309126854,
0.05683165416121483,
0.03754632547497749,
0.009328632615506649,
0.06609351933002472,
0.028595302253961563,
0.0014301800401881337,
0.016362475231289864,
0.03215765580534935,
-0.0525156706571579,
-0.04163084551692009,
0.010447117500007153,
0.02452820912003517,
0.017872128635644913,
0.015707191079854965,
0.02448936738073826,
0.0009439753484912217,
0.011812384240329266,
-0.0007202323758974671,
0.02657446078956127,
-0.03524301201105118,
0.02442663349211216,
-0.01992294192314148,
0.031134532764554024,
-0.032398901879787445,
0.07134786248207092,
0.010615706443786621,
-0.012544452212750912,
-0.038138654083013535,
-0.05198844149708748,
-0.017468905076384544,
0.014301198534667492,
0.006666778586804867,
0.016300594434142113,
-0.07327666133642197,
0.022928668186068535,
0.05573682859539986,
0.036021098494529724,
0.021165747195482254,
-0.006203027907758951,
-0.010432148352265358,
0.017289111390709877,
-0.019196225330233574,
-0.05006585642695427,
0.042218808084726334,
-0.006517231930047274,
-0.06365752965211868,
0.009050145745277405,
0.010186128318309784,
-0.018262062221765518,
-0.01441812515258789,
-0.057225894182920456,
-0.03577303886413574,
0.051552046090364456,
-0.003874418558552861,
-0.017120206728577614,
0.020066997036337852,
0.06805500388145447,
0.01940387859940529,
0.04920576140284538,
0.030557386577129364,
-0.08383719623088837,
0.04671954736113548,
0.017742520198225975,
0.012893704697489738,
-0.003497786819934845,
-0.03944654017686844,
0.08255201578140259,
-0.030773242935538292,
0.009425505995750427,
0.012106504291296005,
-0.06505569070577621,
-0.013886537402868271,
0.02154933288693428,
-0.019774334505200386,
0.05814367160201073,
0.02270195260643959,
0.016835015267133713,
0.030030084773898125,
0.044759951531887054,
0.06388435512781143,
0.02611800841987133,
-0.028159871697425842,
0.06662371754646301,
-0.027006007730960846,
-0.02841537818312645,
0.002262210240587592,
0.034344762563705444,
-0.0652971938252449,
-0.04036587476730347,
0.023532697930932045,
-0.03770720958709717,
0.01796209067106247,
0.01903238520026207,
0.014624091796576977,
0.00277852825820446,
-0.007470566313713789,
-0.03422439098358154,
0.01289287582039833,
0.02119581773877144,
-0.056718017905950546,
0.021904049441218376,
0.027096714824438095,
-0.017111886292696,
0.0268195029348135,
-0.03378111124038696,
0.10639916360378265,
0.03469542786478996,
-0.0032578501850366592,
0.01108858734369278,
0.005186173599213362,
0.005102470982819796,
0.005843915045261383,
0.0020403084345161915,
-0.03618216514587402,
0.017583809792995453,
-0.04154062643647194,
0.002899239072576165,
-0.02512282133102417,
0.07422774285078049,
-0.02731471322476864,
-0.005675996653735638,
0.052469465881586075,
0.0015543962363153696,
0.03992689400911331,
-0.031013311818242073,
0.027933405712246895,
0.03431004658341408,
0.009085499681532383,
0.005392809864133596,
-0.007515777833759785,
-0.01406936626881361,
0.009653128683567047,
-0.022600671276450157,
-0.027120495215058327,
-0.0009638964547775686,
-0.03798530623316765,
-0.025258325040340424,
-0.04869726672768593,
0.06788721680641174,
0.046342216432094574,
0.014220708049833775,
0.028657909482717514,
-0.011653056368231773,
-0.02370438538491726,
-0.029171587899327278,
-0.0792275071144104,
-0.0146904606372118,
-0.011028294451534748,
0.038726139813661575,
0.03323069214820862,
0.05730048567056656,
0.03888876736164093,
-0.001965561183169484,
-0.027201907709240913,
-0.015074344351887703,
0.05273362994194031,
0.028564801439642906,
0.02436204068362713,
-0.06856963783502579,
-0.01415433082729578,
-0.009185385890305042,
0.05549037456512451,
-0.0061712986789643764,
-0.03054950386285782,
-0.03612349182367325,
-0.0388796366751194,
-0.02130844257771969,
-0.037170395255088806,
-0.023982897400856018,
0.026042424142360687,
0.0022055860608816147,
0.02370845526456833,
-0.004316131584346294,
0.03354703262448311,
0.008364422246813774,
0.06756841391324997,
0.02329385280609131,
-0.014277791604399681,
-0.018721377477049828,
0.030914828181266785,
-0.020954784005880356,
0.010153505951166153,
0.01809556595981121,
0.003439061576500535,
-0.018996763974428177,
-0.006486379075795412,
-0.0008857225184328854,
-0.01654808409512043,
-0.28028610348701477,
0.0035813595168292522,
0.0019967772532254457,
0.013795828446745872,
0.024589890614151955,
-0.011301711201667786,
0.03852112963795662,
-0.06187992915511131,
-0.028433063998818398,
0.02095554955303669,
0.05437949299812317,
0.01552952267229557,
-0.00422493414953351,
0.054571039974689484,
0.04282868653535843,
0.04416125640273094,
-0.017601991072297096,
-0.029260072857141495,
0.024831663817167282,
0.028437500819563866,
-0.018340036273002625,
-0.0607709176838398,
-0.016356153413653374,
0.052718713879585266,
-0.007177055347710848,
0.05162636190652847,
-0.08252887427806854,
-0.033191174268722534,
-0.008158178068697453,
-0.021343188360333443,
-0.015581048093736172,
-0.02627681940793991,
-0.036327507346868515,
0.019474361091852188,
-0.0006468217470683157,
-0.008664370514452457,
0.045496273785829544,
-0.01921287178993225,
0.019913092255592346,
0.0020967929158359766,
0.028083311393857002,
0.003410416655242443,
-0.0018432018114253879,
0.022550996392965317,
0.07475832104682922,
-0.0043760305270552635,
-0.04680905491113663,
-0.0317610464990139,
-0.013933522626757622,
0.03695955500006676,
0.018118565902113914,
-0.031845469027757645,
-0.014298231340944767,
0.03198686242103577,
-0.028305064886808395,
-0.018107950687408447,
0.021080343052744865,
-0.029466798529028893,
0.0016647732118144631,
0.02522400952875614,
0.008945372886955738,
-0.03643093258142471,
-0.024234022945165634,
-0.01997319422662258,
0.0025647974107414484,
-0.01526633184403181,
-0.016927197575569153,
-0.08985674381256104,
0.04104968160390854,
0.04819372668862343,
-0.012138464488089085,
0.003576503600925207,
-0.016800999641418457,
-0.09873274713754654,
0.011287174187600613,
-0.01208442822098732,
-0.006685141008347273,
-0.016744539141654968,
0.005936700385063887,
0.03882915526628494,
-0.014018218964338303,
-0.03869181126356125,
0.016477208584547043,
0.011855794116854668,
0.007485740818083286,
-0.052383359521627426,
0.03887740150094032,
-0.024905258789658546,
0.011063591577112675,
-0.058515530079603195,
0.057393912225961685,
0.010207903571426868,
0.013448614627122879,
0.014884472824633121,
0.02500825934112072,
0.002430875087156892,
0.06614335626363754,
0.03792012110352516,
0.03467179834842682,
0.026980239897966385,
0.019058793783187866,
-0.08355418592691422,
-0.010155277326703072,
-0.05754560977220535,
-0.039684444665908813,
0.037354420870542526,
-0.06194772571325302,
-0.02321707084774971,
0.028438033536076546,
-0.037544332444667816,
-0.043270062655210495,
-0.031353823840618134,
0.018971668556332588,
0.0006434821989387274,
-0.028864268213510513,
-0.02046760730445385,
0.017126891762018204,
0.018399011343717575,
0.029975956305861473,
-0.06844061613082886,
-0.04850343242287636,
0.05204607918858528,
-0.05212424695491791,
0.008181143552064896,
-0.006365571171045303,
-0.011667764745652676,
-0.004887736868113279,
-0.012244242243468761,
-0.031252071261405945,
0.0013318335404619575,
0.022469086572527885,
0.03370308876037598,
0.005747408140450716,
0.023701943457126617,
0.05845027044415474,
0.01274383906275034,
0.000008909323696570937,
-0.02270841784775257,
0.021825920790433884,
-0.017497679218649864,
0.022564172744750977,
0.008510674349963665,
0.06021930277347565,
0.04229310154914856,
0.01854940503835678,
-0.02209903858602047,
0.05422310531139374,
0.0016562880482524633,
0.023932086303830147,
0.011436833068728447,
0.058969076722860336,
-0.05657382681965828,
-0.0084297526627779,
-0.02923714742064476,
0.036936864256858826,
-0.009133083745837212,
0.01833806373178959,
-0.01592232845723629,
0.008463144302368164,
-0.0464605949819088,
0.07507792860269547,
0.025611605495214462,
-0.025444399565458298,
0.01863524504005909,
0.02395399659872055,
0.030466504395008087,
-0.0039958348497748375,
-0.004347784910351038,
0.01768490858376026,
-0.0010365124326199293,
-0.013838251121342182,
-0.019493790343403816,
-0.016777213662862778,
-0.01258853729814291,
-0.0048126461915671825,
-0.007795785553753376,
0.008133020251989365,
0.00191483274102211,
-0.03499184548854828,
0.027591487392783165,
0.008741844445466995,
-0.017993230372667313,
0.016641197726130486,
0.0057930713519454,
0.07955440878868103,
-0.009385774843394756,
-0.007788723800331354,
-0.02863530069589615,
-0.05537835881114006,
0.058694884181022644,
-0.02817307785153389,
0.03261137753725052,
-0.041603934019804,
-0.0228673554956913,
-0.031164094805717468,
-0.05097111314535141,
-0.009688419289886951,
0.012309188023209572,
0.028240319341421127,
-0.028739476576447487,
0.0006663606618531048,
0.030243495479226112,
-0.04400429129600525,
-0.007524596527218819,
-0.003956559579819441,
-0.07043273001909256,
0.007332286797463894,
0.04468479007482529,
-0.035882167518138885,
0.04423302039504051,
-0.04168613627552986,
-0.023397212848067284,
-0.0391804538667202,
-0.04172815755009651,
0.01283041201531887,
-0.018537506461143494,
-0.031462084501981735,
-0.013464324176311493,
0.008840733207762241,
-0.006191694177687168,
0.02982161194086075,
-0.008737725205719471,
0.009736758656799793,
0.0004906610702164471,
-0.003058010945096612,
0.03936319053173065,
-0.04100530967116356,
0.02290804497897625,
0.015732405707240105,
-0.02252962440252304,
0.027148941531777382,
-0.05464620143175125,
0.010698172263801098,
0.04919072985649109,
-0.044282615184783936,
0.0024157813750207424,
-0.05612827092409134,
0.03629552572965622,
-0.018232038244605064,
-0.014518152922391891,
0.0227523073554039,
0.022342391312122345,
-0.02481355518102646,
0.008964505046606064,
0.01796405017375946,
0.06101537495851517,
0.001487269066274166,
0.017007380723953247,
0.006108954083174467,
0.0012065806658938527,
0.00733151426538825,
0.02599736489355564,
-0.06023167073726654,
-0.0251231137663126,
0.049496494233608246,
-0.04392791911959648,
0.015726128593087196,
-0.06974111497402191,
-0.05328891798853874,
0.013006549328565598,
-0.017734099179506302,
0.02577294409275055,
-0.024361200630664825,
0.00886357482522726,
0.021561408415436745,
0.029276935383677483,
-0.0025476275477558374,
0.0015464718453586102,
0.013167406432330608,
-0.03926830366253853,
0.0026445493567734957,
-0.06852893531322479,
0.018447188660502434,
0.0588032603263855,
-0.012373551726341248,
0.010315927676856518,
-0.037785641849040985,
-0.044282615184783936,
0.032812267541885376,
-0.02772272564470768,
-0.059318650513887405,
-0.0038102595135569572,
-0.024667497724294662,
-0.02926037274301052,
0.017667638137936592,
-0.04255742207169533,
0.025891385972499847,
0.005149750504642725,
-0.03245680406689644,
-0.0186244398355484,
-0.02478102035820484,
0.05123442783951759,
-0.010185116901993752,
0.008904390968382359,
-0.023951536044478416,
0.008885235525667667,
0.02436770685017109,
0.03936539217829704,
0.013144654221832752,
0.027182159945368767,
-0.0033659080509096384,
0.04688544571399689,
0.014777882024645805,
-0.007316451985388994,
0.03128552809357643,
0.01936105079948902,
-0.05868202820420265,
-0.06699248403310776,
0.06259433180093765,
0.004981634672731161,
-0.04869293048977852,
-0.05301131308078766,
0.06973987072706223,
0.031701575964689255,
-0.0218589399009943,
-0.023786421865224838,
0.057012658566236496,
-0.04849681630730629,
0.0013421536423265934,
-0.014131083153188229,
-0.005641433876007795,
-0.0015576091827824712,
0.06989389657974243,
0.011325114406645298,
0.058410562574863434,
0.04244479164481163,
0.013829055242240429,
-0.014596271328628063,
-0.002094046212732792,
0.06403584778308868,
0.06229326128959656,
0.056355126202106476,
-0.02272738516330719,
0.06122225895524025,
-0.033323533833026886,
-0.048132628202438354,
0.02704363316297531,
0.01049108523875475,
-0.012719757854938507,
-0.042590152472257614,
0.012577938847243786,
0.09256846457719803,
-0.014772291295230389,
0.04455594718456268,
-0.044026464223861694,
-0.0073900967836380005,
0.03521044924855232,
0.002527689328417182,
-0.016580285504460335,
0.018461799249053,
0.025436915457248688,
-0.008142423816025257,
-0.025861648842692375,
-0.024202201515436172,
0.020112326368689537,
-0.026619866490364075,
0.023651987314224243,
0.015324845910072327,
-0.034070611000061035,
-0.000715263478923589,
-0.013893735595047474,
0.04310031607747078,
0.11814384907484055,
-0.05055675655603409,
-0.06328431516885757,
0.027048833668231964,
0.02490268275141716,
0.04605324938893318,
0.05003946274518967,
-0.00798146054148674,
-0.0025205009151250124,
0.018409907817840576,
-0.04170435667037964,
0.026270970702171326,
0.020229725167155266,
-0.03755408897995949,
0.03825679048895836,
-0.029795872047543526,
-0.03957217559218407,
0.021797263994812965,
0.01743994653224945,
-0.025203527882695198,
-0.038233134895563126,
-0.04163862392306328,
-0.07745208591222763,
-0.043075621128082275,
-0.05135677009820938,
0.010122506879270077,
0.03623000159859657,
-0.05710725113749504,
-0.02882755734026432,
-0.02934453636407852,
0.024971455335617065,
0.06925708055496216,
-0.07686278969049454,
0.028104716911911964,
0.01379275694489479,
0.029998471960425377,
-0.009376403875648975,
0.04273555055260658,
0.017529206350445747,
-0.03394824638962746,
-0.027280587702989578,
0.04480870068073273,
0.02090742625296116,
0.00564097985625267,
-0.03276382386684418,
-0.007008243352174759,
-0.11410779505968094,
0.0009659333736635745,
0.01715114898979664,
-0.052372951060533524,
-0.08007597178220749,
0.042107775807380676,
-0.018463170155882835,
0.053514424711465836,
0.08473807573318481,
0.002113513881340623,
0.020331792533397675,
-0.02739475481212139,
-0.02553613670170307,
0.00553547590970993,
-0.016669675707817078,
0.060617610812187195,
-0.003710506483912468,
0.07599565386772156,
0.04071452468633652,
-0.016297385096549988,
-0.033952947705984116,
-0.009077233262360096,
-0.020725445821881294,
0.020316364243626595,
-0.030789343640208244,
-0.005704594776034355,
-0.018869251012802124,
-0.09146936982870102,
0.005872785113751888,
0.04694994166493416,
-0.016018858179450035,
-0.03696264699101448,
-0.011705571785569191,
-0.001736339763738215,
-0.008043474517762661,
-0.03733757138252258,
-0.0015525667695328593,
-0.0346914678812027,
-0.005714878905564547,
0.00054333166917786,
-0.0620492585003376,
0.03074638545513153,
-0.019008910283446312,
0.01795494556427002,
-0.0022694668732583523,
-0.05889161303639412,
-0.036154232919216156,
0.029522797092795372,
0.047616347670555115,
0.0076280925422906876,
0.006340949330478907,
-0.02067551016807556
] |
331 |
Self-Supervised Diffusion MRI Denoising via Iterative and Stable Refinement
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=wxPnuFp8fZ
|
[
"Chenxu Wu",
"Qingpeng Kong",
"Zihang Jiang",
"S Kevin Zhou"
] |
Poster
|
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), including diffusion MRI (dMRI), serves as a ``microscope'' for anatomical structures and routinely mitigates the influence of low signal-to-noise ratio scans by compromising temporal or spatial resolution. However, these compromises fail to meet clinical demands for both efficiency and precision. Consequently, denoising is a vital preprocessing step, particularly for dMRI, where clean data is unavailable. In this paper, we introduce Di-Fusion, a fully self-supervised denoising method that leverages the latter diffusion steps and an adaptive sampling process. Unlike previous approaches, our single-stage framework achieves efficient and stable training without extra noise model training and offers adaptive and controllable results in the sampling process. Our thorough experiments on real and simulated data demonstrate that Di-Fusion achieves state-of-the-art performance in microstructure modeling, tractography tracking, and other downstream tasks. Code is available at https://github.com/FouierL/Di-Fusion.
|
Diffusion based models, Self-supervised MRI denoising
| null | 13,426 |
2501.13514
|
[
-0.03973810747265816,
-0.011157714761793613,
-0.006429525092244148,
0.04214344546198845,
0.055511850863695145,
0.03702589496970177,
0.05320541188120842,
-0.025179017335176468,
-0.022077633067965508,
-0.08935166150331497,
0.04549478739500046,
-0.016731424257159233,
-0.025485169142484665,
0.029456578195095062,
0.02728058397769928,
0.05967235937714577,
0.07450449466705322,
-0.05728710815310478,
-0.021123569458723068,
0.03758871927857399,
-0.023470072075724602,
-0.04137628152966499,
0.016910970211029053,
0.0451035350561142,
0.004140837583690882,
-0.009883376769721508,
0.020497741177678108,
0.007982386276125908,
-0.022974591702222824,
-0.00919374730437994,
0.035202834755182266,
0.0035044436808675528,
0.006708028260618448,
-0.012629047967493534,
0.032641734927892685,
0.023854974657297134,
-0.02076018787920475,
-0.020384427160024643,
-0.003981991671025753,
-0.010992343537509441,
-0.08478183299303055,
0.010132476687431335,
-0.014783136546611786,
0.024601437151432037,
-0.06842625141143799,
-0.011082036420702934,
-0.10612809658050537,
0.00813258532434702,
-0.006820378825068474,
-0.008896091021597385,
-0.07357693463563919,
-0.00905329454690218,
0.03157183527946472,
-0.0010654455982148647,
-0.045817781239748,
0.033754777163267136,
0.03255413472652435,
-0.0767238438129425,
-0.015135947614908218,
-0.05525868758559227,
-0.0036476377863436937,
0.00868605263531208,
-0.017607025802135468,
-0.015834981575608253,
-0.0037061888724565506,
-0.07037750631570816,
-0.0032814396545290947,
0.060027413070201874,
-0.016206840053200722,
-0.023032961413264275,
-0.026002012193202972,
0.013349993154406548,
-0.005542883183807135,
0.002121873199939728,
0.01938573084771633,
-0.05424879118800163,
0.004081622697412968,
0.007318142801523209,
0.06575775891542435,
0.0028841719031333923,
0.04250187426805496,
0.005015317350625992,
-0.008546791039407253,
0.02795197255909443,
-0.006561279296875,
-0.02322908118367195,
-0.011679220013320446,
-0.02431233413517475,
-0.0668662041425705,
0.03191624581813812,
-0.049135319888591766,
-0.03668058291077614,
0.03501296043395996,
0.008569059893488884,
0.057167988270521164,
-0.02308840863406658,
0.03437801077961922,
-0.003496288787573576,
0.017430081963539124,
0.0033095641992986202,
-0.008770542219281197,
-0.029127387329936028,
0.009021811187267303,
0.040113430470228195,
-0.06448191404342651,
-0.010870148427784443,
-0.02521120384335518,
-0.010320491157472134,
-0.03069128841161728,
0.009007473476231098,
-0.015250150114297867,
-0.010155631229281425,
-0.015121100470423698,
-0.014240853488445282,
-0.1055026724934578,
0.03437360003590584,
0.029880164191126823,
0.01945565454661846,
0.0047433204017579556,
-0.017651602625846863,
0.05013265833258629,
0.07108128815889359,
0.0048192404210567474,
0.05323205143213272,
-0.029066838324069977,
-0.01272618118673563,
0.03729698061943054,
0.031590335071086884,
-0.04403077811002731,
-0.019336463883519173,
-0.004930732771754265,
0.03422718122601509,
-0.01663052663207054,
-0.009901691228151321,
0.002655684482306242,
-0.014813384972512722,
0.014580193907022476,
0.018966807052493095,
0.037702400237321854,
-0.021018333733081818,
0.005880195181816816,
-0.03706039860844612,
0.009589176625013351,
-0.028739718720316887,
0.04879985377192497,
-0.060066454112529755,
0.013759580440819263,
0.009899504482746124,
-0.043499283492565155,
-0.004993707872927189,
0.0032664139289408922,
0.020123658701777458,
0.058260321617126465,
-0.05133996531367302,
-0.0029238173738121986,
0.04227030277252197,
-0.009020011872053146,
0.009138844907283783,
-0.0050602867268025875,
-0.015956664457917213,
0.020939160138368607,
-0.024349583312869072,
-0.009083624929189682,
-0.0021641734056174755,
-0.03185965120792389,
-0.043227143585681915,
0.047118719667196274,
0.0009578403551131487,
-0.028827190399169922,
-0.018734263256192207,
0.0010315211256965995,
-0.038444843143224716,
0.023721445351839066,
0.01405955571681261,
0.012564966455101967,
0.0038478004280477762,
0.007941997610032558,
0.007011432200670242,
0.04273972287774086,
0.04368055239319801,
-0.09034674614667892,
0.0020498030353337526,
0.010238109156489372,
0.0018645349191501737,
0.00962094496935606,
-0.017586739733815193,
0.09209910035133362,
-0.019793901592493057,
-0.008992220275104046,
0.0387599840760231,
-0.05925990268588066,
-0.007504600565880537,
0.06579484045505524,
-0.03078456036746502,
0.07529596239328384,
0.057751502841711044,
-0.009611512534320354,
0.02834842912852764,
0.02875472791492939,
0.02238967828452587,
0.04918741062283516,
-0.05376899614930153,
0.044487401843070984,
0.0004222769639454782,
-0.03751486912369728,
-0.022046750411391258,
0.04996943473815918,
-0.04381132125854492,
-0.0006196716567501426,
-0.008515269495546818,
-0.02968519553542137,
-0.03527208790183067,
-0.011028769426047802,
0.011451308615505695,
0.030168283730745316,
0.00803384929895401,
-0.008107531815767288,
0.016685711219906807,
-0.00444921525195241,
-0.03832126781344414,
0.026588808745145798,
0.01200708094984293,
-0.03176131099462509,
0.03474007546901703,
-0.015156177803874016,
0.1318863034248352,
0.0686684101819992,
-0.048803381621837616,
-0.007641470525413752,
0.014000347815454006,
-0.035494185984134674,
-0.0031170675065368414,
0.030774567276239395,
-0.017952000722289085,
0.0043857889249920845,
0.011888411827385426,
0.018697429448366165,
-0.01644212193787098,
0.06653763353824615,
-0.06133207306265831,
-0.0177875068038702,
0.05869048833847046,
0.0009820322738960385,
0.05533518269658089,
0.019773442298173904,
0.00910246092826128,
0.04568402096629143,
0.01194347906857729,
-0.04502088576555252,
-0.015906518325209618,
0.015659205615520477,
0.01639312319457531,
-0.026126891374588013,
-0.03755232319235802,
0.03497662767767906,
-0.08599620312452316,
0.0032348984386771917,
0.007277854718267918,
0.07618026435375214,
0.03949553146958351,
0.0006667127599939704,
0.01815229281783104,
-0.0012416240060701966,
-0.036956142634153366,
-0.020341262221336365,
-0.0942332074046135,
-0.00394982798025012,
0.027270374819636345,
0.059049416333436966,
-0.04654444009065628,
0.017526522278785706,
-0.010230706073343754,
-0.007495060097426176,
0.013706994242966175,
-0.024350542575120926,
0.024163322523236275,
0.00012979314487893134,
0.01789993792772293,
-0.04065466672182083,
-0.021399542689323425,
0.028060397133231163,
0.06542830914258957,
0.019413916394114494,
0.0019655933137983084,
-0.06306298822164536,
-0.06197934225201607,
-0.01581314578652382,
0.005385724827647209,
-0.035281527787446976,
-0.00909818522632122,
0.016390543431043625,
0.01140510756522417,
-0.010347733274102211,
0.02919432520866394,
0.007301521021872759,
0.03155883029103279,
0.030221981927752495,
0.011476556770503521,
-0.004781274124979973,
-0.013250223360955715,
-0.012358768843114376,
0.005652278661727905,
0.011459478177130222,
0.022420799359679222,
-0.019553499296307564,
-0.010313696227967739,
0.03464536741375923,
-0.020943092182278633,
-0.2589380741119385,
0.019645843654870987,
0.024294497445225716,
-0.024406123906373978,
0.04733562842011452,
-0.002843383699655533,
0.025578605011105537,
-0.026873422786593437,
-0.02204071916639805,
0.026536419987678528,
-0.003362811403349042,
0.048334717750549316,
0.01959877274930477,
0.048278070986270905,
0.05696052312850952,
0.01019491907209158,
0.007802881766110659,
-0.024696653708815575,
0.025512393563985825,
0.03362307697534561,
0.005914467852562666,
-0.04144154116511345,
-0.014506233856081963,
0.016259485855698586,
-0.012368761003017426,
0.03790135681629181,
-0.05640389025211334,
0.03986614570021629,
-0.03875824436545372,
-0.00599475484341383,
-0.03464578464627266,
-0.025633668527007103,
-0.01741255819797516,
0.022496478632092476,
-0.006507046986371279,
0.005895664915442467,
0.009640528820455074,
0.03981136158108711,
0.008263910189270973,
-0.01058527547866106,
0.018382271751761436,
0.001693114172667265,
0.0018885659519582987,
-0.02811194211244583,
0.05537491664290428,
0.010774277150630951,
-0.04203413054347038,
-0.006534893997013569,
0.010215812362730503,
0.03011004813015461,
0.007483683526515961,
-0.01574944145977497,
-0.021440260112285614,
0.003564628539606929,
-0.030808227136731148,
-0.037995852530002594,
-0.007152286823838949,
0.04577576369047165,
-0.023408519104123116,
0.0447758324444294,
-0.01817227341234684,
-0.04353689029812813,
-0.047375962138175964,
-0.03889046609401703,
0.0027862212155014277,
-0.024465225636959076,
-0.0697992593050003,
-0.04042686149477959,
0.07116328179836273,
0.040499262511730194,
-0.00829850509762764,
-0.0056341360323131084,
-0.0379088930785656,
-0.09824299812316895,
0.03148818388581276,
-0.007643299642950296,
0.002625714521855116,
-0.031186401844024658,
-0.03564399853348732,
0.04489561915397644,
-0.0445387102663517,
-0.04442114010453224,
0.0436556413769722,
0.007190680131316185,
-0.019800206646323204,
-0.003677866654470563,
0.010966581292450428,
-0.03532904013991356,
-0.02625947631895542,
-0.05654565989971161,
0.04059676080942154,
0.012979801744222641,
0.03261367976665497,
-0.018039966002106667,
0.02786869928240776,
0.06353436410427094,
0.03894403576850891,
0.04703235626220703,
0.03582870960235596,
-0.03725823760032654,
0.07941509783267975,
-0.05808602273464203,
-0.009398049674928188,
-0.04957118630409241,
-0.020454810932278633,
0.020960580557584763,
-0.0545903779566288,
-0.029378529638051987,
0.045703496783971786,
0.0088949641212821,
-0.018254879862070084,
0.035555996000766754,
0.02750508114695549,
-0.007468077354133129,
0.009278489276766777,
-0.04681381955742836,
-0.010350176133215427,
0.03751728683710098,
0.023265291005373,
-0.04616518318653107,
-0.014961635693907738,
-0.0019411678658798337,
-0.033684298396110535,
0.011521504260599613,
0.024995723739266396,
0.051284559071063995,
0.0024579644668847322,
0.002619155216962099,
0.03094162419438362,
0.018350208178162575,
0.06565994024276733,
0.050193533301353455,
0.03265189751982689,
0.07001832127571106,
0.05561071261763573,
0.008956425823271275,
-0.019382985308766365,
0.011126593686640263,
0.017658274620771408,
-0.004124729428440332,
0.04997541755437851,
-0.019904056563973427,
0.06687743961811066,
0.008960975334048271,
0.03422917053103447,
0.030297070741653442,
-0.025989970192313194,
0.004079572390764952,
-0.026077833026647568,
-0.055124033242464066,
0.036630284041166306,
-0.0544448047876358,
-0.0773615688085556,
-0.026301417499780655,
0.004072380717843771,
-0.006257844157516956,
0.032779205590486526,
-0.029453016817569733,
0.026864469051361084,
-0.0765342265367508,
-0.003953033126890659,
0.031215189024806023,
-0.03754989802837372,
-0.01692405343055725,
0.010400591418147087,
0.06085683032870293,
-0.011996298097074032,
-0.02597278170287609,
0.03507461026310921,
-0.030725179240107536,
0.027508089318871498,
-0.02274845354259014,
-0.035192884504795074,
-0.04204580560326576,
0.004892728291451931,
0.016672326251864433,
0.00629480741918087,
-0.003954083658754826,
-0.02858559787273407,
0.05647033825516701,
0.03126431629061699,
-0.02826193906366825,
-0.022553319111466408,
0.0029538124799728394,
0.06682122498750687,
0.0035570727195590734,
0.018264709040522575,
-0.035011954605579376,
-0.02545763924717903,
0.05476737394928932,
-0.01436360739171505,
-0.005049163941293955,
-0.08174159377813339,
0.0018401455599814653,
-0.016418782994151115,
-0.03773634135723114,
0.00016066768148448318,
0.05593476817011833,
-0.025173665955662727,
-0.012047048658132553,
-0.008003604598343372,
0.0078046442940831184,
-0.001229400746524334,
0.019081557169556618,
0.0407928004860878,
-0.07374202460050583,
-0.0233223307877779,
0.006144306622445583,
-0.025479981675744057,
0.05434979125857353,
-0.03532010689377785,
-0.0329228937625885,
-0.04334251582622528,
-0.013677234761416912,
0.009231293573975563,
-0.01045183464884758,
-0.02375744841992855,
-0.04855654761195183,
0.010805862955749035,
0.011106877587735653,
-0.0016041328199207783,
0.02693181112408638,
-0.019291212782263756,
0.0070473323576152325,
-0.011897517368197441,
0.011450633406639099,
-0.04242177680134773,
-0.022201839834451675,
0.005996586289256811,
-0.04012218490242958,
-0.010910030454397202,
-0.02210349403321743,
-0.03393234685063362,
0.03173251077532768,
-0.014772573485970497,
-0.005812522955238819,
-0.029816247522830963,
0.040282752364873886,
-0.020265599712729454,
-0.007565066684037447,
0.014245358295738697,
-0.0020499159581959248,
-0.05546501278877258,
0.04008639603853226,
0.002603629371151328,
0.07327748835086823,
-0.027417855337262154,
0.0038929092697799206,
0.010102883912622929,
0.058624930679798126,
0.014326347038149834,
0.027126897126436234,
-0.06444606930017471,
-0.012703772634267807,
0.0741778165102005,
-0.015005567111074924,
-0.014436119236052036,
-0.1023368164896965,
-0.03298857435584068,
-0.001610897365026176,
-0.01792040653526783,
0.041242681443691254,
0.010272592306137085,
0.020229019224643707,
0.012240398675203323,
0.0038534312043339014,
-0.04267839342355728,
-0.03217453509569168,
0.034025344997644424,
-0.05057966336607933,
-0.019267743453383446,
-0.04274250194430351,
-0.006441888399422169,
0.05113613232970238,
-0.05473022162914276,
0.04946507140994072,
0.010987114161252975,
0.02878764644265175,
0.01887315884232521,
-0.01886189728975296,
-0.054937172681093216,
-0.007235878147184849,
0.004726247396320105,
-0.02629600279033184,
-0.00994302798062563,
-0.03248288109898567,
-0.0027984785847365856,
0.00047081083175726235,
-0.04384265094995499,
-0.0030003839638084173,
0.017294226214289665,
-0.007899329997599125,
0.0018798999954015017,
-0.023646458983421326,
-0.017471222206950188,
-0.0005276140291243792,
-0.001459315768443048,
0.08090833574533463,
-0.007684680633246899,
0.008426829241216183,
-0.04312342777848244,
0.07010313123464584,
0.02790328860282898,
0.028803173452615738,
0.03392497077584267,
0.01595638506114483,
0.025354117155075073,
-0.02509896270930767,
0.023807382211089134,
-0.020307864993810654,
0.004722177051007748,
-0.06524109840393066,
0.04474496468901634,
0.06849601119756699,
-0.05697176232933998,
-0.04589275270700455,
0.03329605236649513,
-0.01841074600815773,
0.013118269853293896,
0.01211179606616497,
-0.0012141054030507803,
0.021869778633117676,
0.06461046636104584,
-0.002897523110732436,
-0.01157341431826353,
0.02318681590259075,
-0.013342292048037052,
-0.0010542760137468576,
0.011638554744422436,
0.0995878204703331,
0.06767579168081284,
-0.008944851346313953,
-0.017109133303165436,
0.09439525753259659,
-0.0007683846051804721,
-0.06064711883664131,
0.03458156809210777,
0.025057675316929817,
-0.007379335816949606,
-0.050230320543050766,
0.016726352274417877,
0.08522256463766098,
-0.015835445374250412,
0.06500943005084991,
-0.0452059842646122,
-0.023748595267534256,
0.04321769252419472,
0.015499347820878029,
0.01700921356678009,
-0.04574429616332054,
0.03182346001267433,
-0.0005636313580907881,
0.0015042093582451344,
0.01575586386024952,
-0.021838294342160225,
-0.020553404465317726,
0.025680365040898323,
-0.003108740085735917,
-0.023760676383972168,
0.031523238867521286,
0.02350502274930477,
0.026795590296387672,
0.0745471939444542,
-0.02027071826159954,
-0.011545454151928425,
-0.030523672699928284,
0.008624217472970486,
0.019121013581752777,
0.0015122086042538285,
0.02263803593814373,
-0.03569930046796799,
0.025961581617593765,
-0.036071449518203735,
0.00295527302660048,
0.02741413563489914,
-0.03614623472094536,
0.01436111144721508,
-0.0351829007267952,
-0.006084774620831013,
0.02224445901811123,
-0.007394746877253056,
-0.055692631751298904,
-0.04847630858421326,
-0.052542440593242645,
-0.022322988137602806,
-0.0433039627969265,
-0.023886360228061676,
0.025429939851164818,
0.015713367611169815,
-0.02870091423392296,
0.013392528519034386,
-0.037501003593206406,
-0.023079240694642067,
0.01623818464577198,
-0.05780685320496559,
-0.061232779175043106,
0.04954366758465767,
-0.04211948812007904,
0.00396385882049799,
0.0322004035115242,
0.022393669933080673,
-0.012685666792094707,
-0.008492188528180122,
0.06396911293268204,
-0.022998036816716194,
0.05701969936490059,
-0.018581068143248558,
0.021498965099453926,
-0.08661095052957535,
-0.004363916348665953,
0.042209479957818985,
-0.02843150682747364,
-0.08880278468132019,
0.05742475017905235,
-0.015987109392881393,
0.002191065112128854,
0.02344338782131672,
-0.0005807869601994753,
-0.004943431355059147,
-0.014111231081187725,
-0.02892444096505642,
-0.005318699404597282,
0.003905183169990778,
0.06785223633050919,
-0.0067634591832757,
0.08801113069057465,
0.06859906017780304,
-0.00032503079273737967,
-0.031428396701812744,
0.015831358730793,
-0.03773505985736847,
-0.013095579110085964,
-0.03565554320812225,
-0.004462074488401413,
-0.034980062395334244,
-0.09474435448646545,
-0.027117060497403145,
-0.00841876957565546,
-0.019100192934274673,
-0.0030727041885256767,
-0.007375513203442097,
-0.000808226817753166,
-0.0015699906507506967,
-0.04218009486794472,
0.006014757789671421,
-0.010231166146695614,
-0.017670992761850357,
-0.04568701237440109,
-0.06098703294992447,
-0.0014067215379327536,
0.023045936599373817,
0.043728768825531006,
0.018650665879249573,
-0.023188989609479904,
0.016270069405436516,
0.015691738575696945,
0.010139953345060349,
0.01562394667416811,
0.01768888719379902,
0.0018127580406144261
] |
332 |
LongMamba: Enhancing Mamba's Long-Context Capabilities via Training-Free Receptive Field Enlargement
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=fMbLszVO1H
|
[
"Zhifan Ye",
"Kejing Xia",
"Yonggan Fu",
"Xin Dong",
"Jihoon Hong",
"Xiangchi Yuan",
"Shizhe Diao",
"Jan Kautz",
"Pavlo Molchanov",
"Yingyan Celine Lin"
] |
Poster
|
State space models (SSMs) have emerged as an efficient alternative to Transformer models for language modeling, offering linear computational complexity and constant memory usage as context length increases. However, despite their efficiency in handling long contexts, recent studies have shown that SSMs, such as Mamba models, generally underperform compared to Transformers in long-context understanding tasks. To address this significant shortfall and achieve both efficient and accurate long-context understanding, we propose LongMamba, a training-free technique that significantly enhances the long-context capabilities of Mamba models. LongMamba builds on our discovery that the hidden channels in Mamba can be categorized into local and global channels based on their receptive field lengths, with global channels primarily responsible for long-context capability. These global channels can become the key bottleneck as the input context lengthens. Specifically, when input lengths largely exceed the training sequence length, global channels exhibit limitations in adaptively extend their receptive fields, leading to Mamba’s poor long-context performance. The key idea of LongMamba is to mitigate the hidden state memory decay in these global channels by preventing the accumulation of unimportant tokens in their memory. This is achieved by first identifying critical tokens in the global channels and then applying token filtering to accumulate only those critical tokens. Through extensive benchmarking across synthetic and real-world long-context scenarios, LongMamba sets a new standard for Mamba’s long-context performance, significantly extending its operational range without requiring additional training. Our code is available at https://github.com/GATECH-EIC/LongMamba.
|
Large Language Models, State Space Models, Long Context Understanding
| null | 13,423 | null |
[
-0.027158353477716446,
-0.03347493335604668,
-0.03860808536410332,
0.012235010042786598,
0.037877969443798065,
0.03897000476717949,
0.025380078703165054,
0.007913395762443542,
-0.03800816833972931,
-0.02549051120877266,
-0.02583281323313713,
0.022514918819069862,
-0.07326861470937729,
-0.007143550552427769,
0.0039543756283819675,
0.05780275538563728,
0.05099228397011757,
-0.020690402016043663,
0.026765944436192513,
0.025157935917377472,
0.005229025147855282,
0.011198070831596851,
0.05403628572821617,
0.03353668376803398,
0.014170595444738865,
0.024790186434984207,
0.023524312302470207,
-0.010587950237095356,
-0.035938575863838196,
-0.018754279240965843,
0.02892906591296196,
-0.019767338410019875,
0.006785239093005657,
0.008189933374524117,
0.02276872843503952,
-0.015809355303645134,
-0.047320812940597534,
0.019636061042547226,
0.01985284872353077,
0.0001438419712940231,
-0.049952149391174316,
0.00627910066395998,
0.0024021717254072428,
-0.0013771702069789171,
-0.04409843683242798,
0.015508297830820084,
-0.10386502742767334,
0.040154073387384415,
-0.0074187652207911015,
-0.05672350898385048,
-0.11029034107923508,
0.04040097817778587,
0.011638607829809189,
-0.0029922479297965765,
0.02470904216170311,
0.02509447932243347,
0.029298048466444016,
-0.08392837643623352,
0.014512266963720322,
-0.04324118047952652,
-0.03497784584760666,
-0.009075906127691269,
0.015811147168278694,
0.01779191754758358,
-0.013119815848767757,
-0.0007698836852796376,
0.004445706494152546,
0.03819402679800987,
-0.04513987526297569,
-0.02350340411067009,
-0.007973870262503624,
-0.003406379371881485,
-0.03470062091946602,
0.020132405683398247,
0.0037048724479973316,
-0.056403208523988724,
0.011508493684232235,
0.023440800607204437,
0.07791198045015335,
-0.019664786756038666,
-0.0028661831747740507,
-0.0063735307194292545,
0.023713700473308563,
0.04791802167892456,
0.0007097929483279586,
0.012426893226802349,
-0.01834224723279476,
-0.037416815757751465,
-0.09945356100797653,
0.013308568857610226,
-0.03386537358164787,
-0.05640838295221329,
0.0073243784718215466,
0.033092062920331955,
0.0006230089347809553,
0.004428642801940441,
0.016236085444688797,
-0.0120623130351305,
0.006819522008299828,
0.019183939322829247,
-0.03037768229842186,
-0.03018529713153839,
0.017569618299603462,
0.018225951120257378,
-0.12711262702941895,
-0.04299177601933479,
-0.015415952540934086,
-0.003290649503469467,
0.006315948907285929,
0.017026502639055252,
-0.03879765793681145,
-0.008710741065442562,
0.040453363209962845,
-0.032747022807598114,
-0.06704533100128174,
0.021710317581892014,
0.005554415285587311,
0.029848145321011543,
-0.01148166973143816,
0.013282760046422482,
0.055652372539043427,
0.04798043891787529,
0.005722988862544298,
0.05668780952692032,
-0.01671244390308857,
-0.01732478477060795,
0.003835574258118868,
0.026103850454092026,
-0.031931329518556595,
-0.03194165229797363,
0.006447406951338053,
0.007131973281502724,
0.006608320400118828,
0.003426127601414919,
0.004365747794508934,
0.01523582637310028,
0.02935849130153656,
0.021206526085734367,
0.07093750685453415,
-0.023424983024597168,
0.03919387608766556,
0.002355515956878662,
0.03623614087700844,
-0.007180207874625921,
0.1070314273238182,
0.008628400042653084,
-0.03135261312127113,
-0.002696466166526079,
-0.035030968487262726,
-0.006953689735382795,
0.007412964478135109,
-0.019524116069078445,
-0.0036317140329629183,
-0.034655191004276276,
0.025113364681601524,
0.04241600260138512,
-0.023243671283125877,
-0.014752695336937904,
0.024261323735117912,
0.01613641157746315,
0.012898694723844528,
-0.003925679251551628,
-0.08239580690860748,
0.03711123764514923,
-0.0009818901307880878,
-0.052071113139390945,
0.02954285591840744,
0.017575863748788834,
-0.056574270129203796,
0.014983370900154114,
-0.04033220186829567,
-0.04771234467625618,
0.0650799497961998,
-0.028318744152784348,
-0.06023544818162918,
-0.012280298396945,
0.053541336208581924,
-0.006608016788959503,
0.02296925149857998,
0.028950266540050507,
-0.07908844947814941,
0.032172027975320816,
-0.015455447137355804,
-0.014033157378435135,
0.04399117827415466,
-0.025999674573540688,
0.07265464216470718,
-0.027510283514857292,
-0.023792114108800888,
-0.0036650458350777626,
-0.033566802740097046,
-0.01387553196400404,
-0.005045301280915737,
0.00607699528336525,
0.07047147303819656,
-0.0012184091610834002,
-0.00795526709407568,
0.04107024520635605,
0.06495209783315659,
0.03662476688623428,
0.05403071641921997,
0.00045705900993198156,
0.03868838772177696,
0.01272814441472292,
-0.012005863711237907,
-0.0170271098613739,
0.01837736740708351,
-0.06554973125457764,
-0.026235103607177734,
0.013799351640045643,
-0.011595488525927067,
-0.019955478608608246,
0.017426559701561928,
-0.0036342726089060307,
-0.00007037056639092043,
0.03830334171652794,
0.020713884383440018,
0.002312840661033988,
-0.009010877460241318,
-0.05239007622003555,
0.032993920147418976,
0.021141832694411278,
-0.04282347112894058,
0.0007554832845926285,
-0.02658926509320736,
0.1001000627875328,
0.0619475394487381,
-0.026435459032654762,
-0.03279482573270798,
0.01172533631324768,
0.023023393005132675,
-0.024823255836963654,
0.005115243140608072,
-0.033294688910245895,
0.028062375262379646,
-0.04614170640707016,
0.0006502378382720053,
-0.04684680327773094,
0.044538773596286774,
-0.02874312363564968,
0.001041559618897736,
0.07174335420131683,
-0.024575671181082726,
0.03780369833111763,
-0.020138230174779892,
-0.01238551177084446,
0.044437337666749954,
0.019201746210455894,
-0.026908613741397858,
-0.024876629933714867,
-0.019736554473638535,
0.0012371239718049765,
0.02572767436504364,
-0.03594525158405304,
0.0266721174120903,
-0.055281851440668106,
-0.06494741886854172,
-0.027290992438793182,
0.056346967816352844,
0.05820978432893753,
0.02890901453793049,
0.05341831222176552,
0.0066660745069384575,
-0.04100454971194267,
-0.03402095288038254,
-0.10334447026252747,
-0.0010532779851928353,
-0.03198138624429703,
0.029878493398427963,
-0.012806335464119911,
0.03544290363788605,
-0.0030097973067313433,
0.025332318618893623,
-0.035545215010643005,
0.004531518090516329,
0.007787368260324001,
0.03381657227873802,
-0.008147291839122772,
-0.03782794252038002,
-0.019103510305285454,
-0.007335369475185871,
0.04630676284432411,
-0.000007968076715769712,
-0.046513330191373825,
-0.01291233766824007,
-0.03174840658903122,
-0.013081233017146587,
-0.010301950387656689,
0.0012867418117821217,
0.046703584492206573,
0.03279184177517891,
0.011693034321069717,
-0.0031983410008251667,
0.021801209077239037,
0.031161190941929817,
0.062394265085458755,
0.045115262269973755,
0.020292965695261955,
-0.030507629737257957,
0.03853123262524605,
-0.013835027813911438,
0.010300430469214916,
0.006953354924917221,
0.011094304732978344,
-0.003004021244123578,
-0.026478983461856842,
0.0035977421794086695,
-0.014549900777637959,
-0.26235976815223694,
-0.014024983160197735,
-0.022860929369926453,
-0.037511881440877914,
0.03809880465269089,
-0.028902148827910423,
0.07091110199689865,
-0.04215268790721893,
-0.01681675761938095,
-0.002046955283731222,
0.01766098104417324,
0.029027093201875687,
-0.013546546921133995,
0.028802353888750076,
0.034891266375780106,
0.02781881019473076,
-0.031237488612532616,
-0.008432203903794289,
0.015101169236004353,
0.054764751344919205,
0.004641224164515734,
-0.06110851839184761,
-0.03251544013619423,
0.07672843337059021,
-0.022626051679253578,
0.05097079277038574,
-0.0877433717250824,
-0.013563545420765877,
-0.011091814376413822,
-0.0017206532647833228,
-0.014183284714818,
-0.02218172885477543,
0.0012188463006168604,
0.03991876542568207,
-0.005775921978056431,
0.03652191907167435,
0.01920437254011631,
0.013037909753620625,
0.01863887533545494,
-0.0317772775888443,
0.02767726220190525,
-0.018759170547127724,
-0.01290749292820692,
0.03082163818180561,
0.049527108669281006,
-0.002976762829348445,
-0.061137855052948,
-0.015592928044497967,
-0.016003530472517014,
0.048205770552158356,
-0.006164866499602795,
-0.03447811305522919,
-0.003559740260243416,
0.025839563459157944,
0.026056937873363495,
-0.035584598779678345,
-0.0051622348837554455,
0.00009426616452401504,
0.01116962917149067,
-0.03673739358782768,
0.01447776798158884,
-0.03045830689370632,
-0.026541870087385178,
-0.00952681340277195,
-0.01856766641139984,
-0.04075664281845093,
-0.05732251703739166,
-0.044560715556144714,
0.02972136065363884,
0.04102633520960808,
-0.033276256173849106,
0.007853003218770027,
-0.001748955575749278,
-0.09653513133525848,
-0.005837847478687763,
-0.026256117969751358,
-0.03546031191945076,
-0.028745684772729874,
-0.00018876614922191948,
0.06136750429868698,
-0.04896872490644455,
-0.04611437767744064,
0.006207957863807678,
0.03211800381541252,
0.02092360518872738,
-0.043759118765592575,
0.004737046547234058,
-0.026487495750188828,
-0.017847200855612755,
-0.02621166594326496,
0.0563654750585556,
-0.0180938933044672,
0.0010316823609173298,
0.006969373673200607,
0.04080958291888237,
0.0086815869435668,
0.03168737515807152,
0.06867752969264984,
0.010467550717294216,
-0.017257247120141983,
0.02123979479074478,
-0.05674375221133232,
-0.03060559742152691,
-0.04461890459060669,
-0.008346046321094036,
0.03764021769165993,
-0.05585095286369324,
-0.034363407641649246,
0.04300067573785782,
0.006950992625206709,
-0.03340591490268707,
-0.028263432905077934,
0.0038351344410330057,
-0.019725488498806953,
-0.02358296327292919,
0.021044259890913963,
0.0069277030415833,
0.018727991729974747,
0.02890905924141407,
-0.02285693772137165,
-0.02046958915889263,
0.021157577633857727,
-0.00519808242097497,
0.036910008639097214,
0.03496023267507553,
-0.024548038840293884,
-0.025038056075572968,
-0.014104618690907955,
-0.01524145808070898,
-0.019469324499368668,
0.03075975552201271,
0.02593010850250721,
0.007827422581613064,
0.02244582213461399,
0.06893424689769745,
-0.009269333444535732,
-0.0020274000708013773,
0.00042531578219495714,
0.04032869264483452,
-0.033197399228811264,
0.001498983707278967,
-0.02011636085808277,
0.013977940194308758,
0.04426038637757301,
-0.005527674686163664,
0.012544267810881138,
0.01811755821108818,
-0.004451724234968424,
0.00852665863931179,
0.013570334762334824,
0.04716036841273308,
-0.06714887917041779,
-0.05461326986551285,
-0.03733775392174721,
0.018399210646748543,
-0.02561715431511402,
0.014497860334813595,
-0.015106867998838425,
0.01931019499897957,
-0.08793015033006668,
0.04881487414240837,
0.009419875219464302,
-0.022683147341012955,
0.001136574661359191,
0.021565107628703117,
0.03317109867930412,
-0.00923662818968296,
0.009384159930050373,
0.0641188845038414,
0.029101699590682983,
0.01012501586228609,
-0.031824350357055664,
-0.03078131563961506,
0.017104482278227806,
-0.017031624913215637,
0.028752099722623825,
-0.0036979743745177984,
0.0057399943470954895,
-0.03387846052646637,
0.06099843606352806,
0.020785903558135033,
-0.018351785838603973,
0.012274287641048431,
0.016158796846866608,
0.08980930596590042,
0.025789130479097366,
-0.013156459666788578,
-0.009477449581027031,
-0.036476925015449524,
0.013222639448940754,
-0.008244181051850319,
0.027913296595215797,
-0.01811189576983452,
-0.061223696917295456,
-0.023504728451371193,
-0.05264706537127495,
-0.012528843246400356,
0.00904777366667986,
-0.021694006398320198,
-0.0013814455596730113,
0.015472066588699818,
0.004195733927190304,
-0.022074729204177856,
0.009315391071140766,
0.03547364100813866,
-0.06335889548063278,
0.01953265257179737,
0.0184019822627306,
-0.027570871636271477,
0.01917240396142006,
-0.03858669102191925,
-0.007318335585296154,
-0.04696785286068916,
-0.01872210018336773,
0.015125211328268051,
0.017998112365603447,
-0.012369993142783642,
-0.02751617133617401,
0.01206179615110159,
-0.00660784961655736,
0.005982550792396069,
0.007369066588580608,
0.00012341012188699096,
-0.03561118617653847,
0.0022390587255358696,
0.03754422068595886,
-0.008665832690894604,
0.048126354813575745,
0.012941326014697552,
-0.029000280424952507,
0.004683075472712517,
-0.03709159418940544,
0.04663613811135292,
0.06481985002756119,
-0.02089395746588707,
-0.005962311755865812,
-0.043797679245471954,
0.04709336906671524,
0.026711178943514824,
0.01045710314065218,
0.023676427081227303,
-0.014158020727336407,
-0.03943786770105362,
0.04519079253077507,
0.008327077142894268,
0.06527740508317947,
0.03273897245526314,
0.04084932431578636,
-0.014313530176877975,
0.004462439101189375,
0.013648916967213154,
0.011418353766202927,
-0.03838213160634041,
-0.011253462173044682,
0.05559254437685013,
-0.00811754446476698,
-0.05439639464020729,
-0.06699072569608688,
-0.04898647591471672,
0.01603173092007637,
0.012060929089784622,
0.022456472739577293,
-0.04178457707166672,
0.040219586342573166,
0.0214008167386055,
0.025959739461541176,
0.010273363441228867,
-0.02245779149234295,
0.05779948830604553,
-0.02532019466161728,
0.0003773825301323086,
-0.06813861429691315,
-0.05375067517161369,
0.053167782723903656,
-0.021617664024233818,
-0.009224604815244675,
-0.022519076243042946,
-0.06350895762443542,
0.038386546075344086,
-0.007866772823035717,
-0.03928811848163605,
0.04725993424654007,
-0.02285580337047577,
0.0074989404529333115,
0.04685363546013832,
-0.03359342738986015,
0.005589765962213278,
-0.0434916615486145,
-0.03239583224058151,
-0.032687656581401825,
-0.007323296274989843,
0.056015122681856155,
-0.03185443952679634,
0.04736284166574478,
-0.023467721417546272,
0.004045751877129078,
0.013973216526210308,
0.06314833462238312,
0.027079788967967033,
0.01901973970234394,
-0.00819921214133501,
0.0720457136631012,
0.01782841421663761,
0.010347181931138039,
-0.008343575522303581,
-0.00906065758317709,
-0.0220275167375803,
-0.059011060744524,
0.04137450084090233,
0.029779769480228424,
0.009002757258713245,
-0.0814850777387619,
0.07131745666265488,
0.019997488707304,
-0.03549924120306969,
-0.006074226461350918,
0.01879427582025528,
-0.0571674108505249,
-0.013935507275164127,
-0.0019819026347249746,
-0.00473014498129487,
-0.02826770953834057,
0.06022705137729645,
0.042577024549245834,
0.060833558440208435,
0.09859203547239304,
-0.0346914567053318,
-0.007953980937600136,
0.013615988194942474,
0.061377085745334625,
0.04918097332119942,
0.05462544038891792,
0.01299904566258192,
0.07505807280540466,
-0.03042282909154892,
-0.03718225285410881,
0.06263818591833115,
0.04839581251144409,
-0.016601955518126488,
-0.06019534170627594,
0.013063762336969376,
0.0740293636918068,
-0.0010942565277218819,
0.06756990402936935,
-0.06211039423942566,
-0.008228190243244171,
0.0473368763923645,
0.03489736467599869,
0.012448973953723907,
0.024853695183992386,
0.02768985740840435,
0.004191994667053223,
-0.033350247889757156,
-0.020849790424108505,
-0.0050202105194330215,
-0.018291162326931953,
0.00006385362212313339,
0.019177397713065147,
-0.023652030155062675,
0.017173366621136665,
0.00937283132225275,
0.08536706119775772,
0.09302543848752975,
-0.004754295572638512,
-0.016681721433997154,
-0.003416710766032338,
-0.0037621089722961187,
0.011917456053197384,
0.05753757059574127,
-0.022487200796604156,
-0.004417146556079388,
0.004166221246123314,
-0.02664434351027012,
-0.0017128544859588146,
0.026925479993224144,
-0.010015473701059818,
-0.000974121387116611,
-0.01631784252822399,
-0.035289451479911804,
0.002346401335671544,
0.026402799412608147,
-0.049127835780382156,
-0.04276116192340851,
-0.03759549558162689,
-0.037782859057188034,
-0.05635962635278702,
-0.04568934813141823,
0.030949410051107407,
-0.011811605654656887,
-0.02080700732767582,
-0.005154475104063749,
-0.05044408142566681,
-0.007617735769599676,
-0.016164440661668777,
-0.028877519071102142,
0.013276277109980583,
0.020322412252426147,
-0.018021458759903908,
-0.012086769565939903,
0.04685447737574577,
0.0298747681081295,
-0.02630537375807762,
-0.0028286075685173273,
0.06022881716489792,
0.0234895758330822,
0.021651174873113632,
-0.017134113237261772,
-0.01797005906701088,
-0.09653881937265396,
0.009325052611529827,
0.027979936450719833,
-0.017510036006569862,
-0.0659928247332573,
0.017835814505815506,
-0.02060697227716446,
0.06829497963190079,
0.04998447373509407,
-0.026952266693115234,
0.014439092949032784,
-0.021449370309710503,
-0.027739178389310837,
-0.0093461312353611,
0.002674415474757552,
0.042599812150001526,
-0.005948056932538748,
0.05872819945216179,
0.06513279676437378,
-0.0009324811398983002,
-0.02806279808282852,
0.02602924220263958,
-0.005222586914896965,
0.0023869017604738474,
-0.029103051871061325,
-0.012682119384407997,
-0.038544319570064545,
-0.10436421632766724,
-0.03305351361632347,
0.04758857935667038,
-0.016616251319646835,
-0.040106918662786484,
0.0015528668882325292,
-0.030435223132371902,
-0.02277718298137188,
-0.02905981056392193,
-0.038077645003795624,
-0.010348793119192123,
-0.022527478635311127,
-0.04912922903895378,
-0.0869840756058693,
-0.0033027934841811657,
-0.04163380712270737,
-0.008993384428322315,
-0.04754034802317619,
-0.040372006595134735,
0.03285444527864456,
0.019467340782284737,
0.03236888721585274,
-0.008635999634861946,
0.00624356372281909,
-0.023289425298571587
] |
333 |
Robust Weight Initialization for Tanh Neural Networks with Fixed Point Analysis
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Es4RPNDtmq
|
[
"Hyun woo Lee",
"Hayoung Choi",
"Hyunju Kim"
] |
Poster
|
As a neural network's depth increases, it can improve generalization performance. However, training deep networks is challenging due to gradient and signal propagation issues. To address these challenges, extensive theoretical research and various methods have been introduced. Despite these advances, effective weight initialization methods for tanh neural networks remain insufficiently investigated. This paper presents a novel weight initialization method for neural networks with tanh activation function. Based on an analysis of the fixed points of the function $\tanh(ax)$, the proposed method aims to determine values of $a$ that mitigate activation saturation. A series of experiments on various classification datasets and physics-informed neural networks demonstrates that the proposed method outperforms Xavier initialization methods (with or without normalization) in terms of robustness across different network sizes, data efficiency, and convergence speed. Code is available at https://github.com/1HyunwooLee/Tanh-Init.
|
Weight initialization, Signal propagation, Physics informed neural networks
| null | 13,420 |
2410.02242
|
[
-0.02729954570531845,
0.005407868418842554,
-0.02280447818338871,
0.013757373206317425,
0.01591157168149948,
0.05312285199761391,
0.006602342706173658,
-0.016781995072960854,
-0.02659447304904461,
-0.03835340589284897,
-0.0007287350599654019,
-0.00884739775210619,
-0.04528888314962387,
0.0008854038314893842,
0.007704953197389841,
0.04206295311450958,
0.1013057753443718,
-0.018229080364108086,
-0.02645222470164299,
0.01561206765472889,
-0.025879697874188423,
-0.045489490032196045,
0.03644576296210289,
0.01641439087688923,
0.02585170790553093,
-0.036824773997068405,
0.004308636300265789,
0.0032701457384973764,
-0.01789185032248497,
0.018945563584566116,
0.018897872418165207,
0.0005334181478247046,
0.006706573534756899,
-0.039048388600349426,
0.019103001803159714,
0.044601213186979294,
-0.008906085044145584,
0.005736976396292448,
0.007030501961708069,
-0.0016083680093288422,
-0.03625406697392464,
-0.011282090097665787,
-0.0352831594645977,
0.027369145303964615,
-0.04008852690458298,
0.03592132404446602,
-0.09714028239250183,
-0.007848123088479042,
-0.018211787566542625,
-0.010548745281994343,
-0.10987354069948196,
0.054154932498931885,
0.0023748527746647596,
-0.047957614064216614,
-0.0025224376004189253,
0.02422192692756653,
0.008141146041452885,
-0.06128908693790436,
-0.010091045871376991,
-0.05977679044008255,
0.033758677542209625,
0.028057590126991272,
0.022520730271935463,
0.017632002010941505,
0.014060826040804386,
-0.006248542573302984,
0.014277408830821514,
0.030344108119606972,
-0.056548528373241425,
-0.01603059098124504,
-0.016580767929553986,
-0.01072890404611826,
-0.018389258533716202,
0.0019486189121380448,
-0.03314290940761566,
-0.062344204634428024,
0.0026727095246315002,
0.01592303067445755,
0.06301622092723846,
0.01608072966337204,
0.02443499118089676,
0.0079874312505126,
0.008684267289936543,
0.014115890488028526,
0.017076104879379272,
0.005502989515662193,
-0.014236688613891602,
-0.05355517193675041,
-0.0679311454296112,
0.05601820722222328,
-0.033540479838848114,
-0.00641773222014308,
0.01003189291805029,
0.03464829921722412,
0.019563738256692886,
-0.03430118411779404,
0.030476927757263184,
-0.0008060622494667768,
0.042278073728084564,
0.012455414980649948,
0.01871637813746929,
-0.03851574659347534,
0.009438810870051384,
0.011592026799917221,
-0.08993909507989883,
-0.029208939522504807,
-0.015201167203485966,
-0.0010641455883160233,
0.0011397828347980976,
0.0017691595712676644,
-0.05830281972885132,
0.020749228075146675,
0.025288207456469536,
-0.02948232740163803,
-0.12302479892969131,
-0.0018365838332101703,
-0.033376894891262054,
0.013953300192952156,
-0.015536215156316757,
-0.004060804843902588,
0.03818576782941818,
0.04845790937542915,
0.0007988009019754827,
0.051995232701301575,
-0.004777444526553154,
0.021224725991487503,
0.013393530622124672,
0.06681247800588608,
-0.029387854039669037,
-0.018641646951436996,
-0.000015585172150167637,
0.023358892649412155,
0.02986358106136322,
0.02161438763141632,
0.008908011019229889,
-0.02577962912619114,
-0.01926673948764801,
0.023883787915110588,
0.02695046178996563,
-0.002912855241447687,
-0.01178678311407566,
-0.05594814196228981,
0.07680217176675797,
-0.025616606697440147,
0.0280520748347044,
0.013486701063811779,
0.03433079645037651,
-0.024742888286709785,
-0.020151283591985703,
0.0011691945837810636,
-0.030597828328609467,
-0.0162504892796278,
-0.006122983992099762,
-0.05713764950633049,
-0.004246729891747236,
0.033461518585681915,
-0.0055105434730648994,
0.03075343184173107,
-0.013215207494795322,
0.020811788737773895,
0.00777542544528842,
-0.048845406621694565,
-0.014519136399030685,
0.00978115014731884,
0.01776915043592453,
-0.028382208198308945,
0.06400340795516968,
0.026650043204426765,
-0.005880272015929222,
-0.015272463671863079,
-0.01883656159043312,
-0.03863853961229324,
0.038682423532009125,
0.022191397845745087,
-0.0002911049814429134,
-0.009028550237417221,
0.04447086900472641,
-0.029261596500873566,
0.016254426911473274,
0.034122902899980545,
-0.07896620780229568,
0.07468647509813309,
0.0363055020570755,
0.03231848031282425,
0.016632817685604095,
-0.045752111822366714,
0.0688566118478775,
-0.06675241142511368,
0.03591075912117958,
0.006886435206979513,
-0.058593932539224625,
0.000998605159111321,
0.009434061124920845,
-0.025308769196271896,
0.05505019798874855,
0.010607757605612278,
0.005045953206717968,
0.01756278984248638,
-0.01690073125064373,
0.04230661317706108,
0.05968962982296944,
-0.03349369019269943,
0.05920189246535301,
0.007315033581107855,
-0.040183864533901215,
0.0037575112655758858,
0.020107153803110123,
-0.052239105105400085,
-0.0037676519714295864,
0.009860445745289326,
-0.01694190688431263,
-0.015897832810878754,
-0.007400908507406712,
0.026224836707115173,
0.005549383349716663,
-0.019663318991661072,
-0.030226856470108032,
0.020653197541832924,
0.004305973183363676,
-0.02694176882505417,
0.047908589243888855,
0.0009060211014002562,
-0.007556799799203873,
0.0027263194788247347,
-0.029030725359916687,
0.0967937558889389,
0.07302366942167282,
-0.03643029183149338,
-0.010314368642866611,
0.028866883367300034,
0.030571358278393745,
-0.009370805695652962,
0.033679887652397156,
0.0005172915989533067,
-0.011109794490039349,
-0.003672435414046049,
-0.002267922507598996,
-0.038714710623025894,
0.06341579556465149,
-0.056302182376384735,
0.020194871351122856,
0.08201158791780472,
-0.036193959414958954,
0.06546386331319809,
-0.012280142866075039,
-0.00015023570449557155,
0.017466912046074867,
-0.01822393201291561,
-0.024090783670544624,
-0.047105733305215836,
-0.04184653237462044,
0.005356008652597666,
0.01302547287195921,
-0.0039019694086164236,
-0.010326653718948364,
-0.04722484201192856,
-0.05627903714776039,
-0.010803550481796265,
0.07043306529521942,
0.06003338843584061,
0.0024945782497525215,
0.028676357120275497,
-0.0163615383207798,
-0.035846106708049774,
-0.04731195047497749,
-0.1322287768125534,
-0.018322577700018883,
0.016488581895828247,
0.033484574407339096,
0.02255409210920334,
0.0619833879172802,
-0.002511560684069991,
0.0006019743741489947,
-0.026630254462361336,
-0.04153063893318176,
-0.004756201058626175,
0.030187256634235382,
0.019893627613782883,
-0.0652967020869255,
-0.023424990475177765,
0.0016599925002083182,
0.07476332783699036,
-0.01822255179286003,
-0.038753535598516464,
-0.006752972025424242,
-0.027150046080350876,
-0.014122298918664455,
-0.015744876116514206,
-0.011947068385779858,
0.013750224374234676,
0.009625621140003204,
0.02842569909989834,
-0.038434948772192,
0.03045153245329857,
0.034877143800258636,
0.06423675268888474,
0.04664326831698418,
0.05465971305966377,
-0.02746153622865677,
0.025594094768166542,
-0.022872691974043846,
0.024362752214074135,
-0.014174232259392738,
0.05248740687966347,
-0.03668156638741493,
-0.0042172884568572044,
-0.010245522484183311,
0.0009103150223381817,
-0.2878262400627136,
-0.006158668547868729,
-0.01807377301156521,
-0.017398115247488022,
0.011843523941934109,
0.0011444042902439833,
0.023938409984111786,
-0.010227140039205551,
-0.05514564365148544,
0.012337855063378811,
-0.004968891851603985,
0.019253214821219444,
-0.0009329210733994842,
0.038334719836711884,
0.036745183169841766,
0.010271862149238586,
0.01943192631006241,
-0.01750243455171585,
0.005593681242316961,
0.0469500757753849,
-0.05181524157524109,
-0.07782869786024094,
0.001049446640536189,
0.030304236337542534,
-0.03664940968155861,
0.044145770370960236,
-0.08503828197717667,
0.013428210280835629,
-0.03901970013976097,
-0.013378893956542015,
-0.057791806757450104,
-0.04036730155348778,
-0.014151854440569878,
0.020247438922524452,
0.036512989550828934,
-0.033254679292440414,
0.009029759094119072,
-0.023353639990091324,
0.04580939561128616,
0.020061267539858818,
0.0019671046175062656,
-0.0011586406035348773,
0.005511441268026829,
0.03251976519823074,
0.08295153826475143,
0.0031751918140798807,
-0.013338708318769932,
0.006439846940338612,
-0.02008514292538166,
0.0176767036318779,
-0.01438263151794672,
-0.023348368704319,
-0.034548237919807434,
-0.013932637870311737,
-0.027625447139143944,
-0.026415128260850906,
-0.04060973599553108,
0.007944447919726372,
0.006392298731952906,
0.041968852281570435,
-0.026976453140378,
-0.03730810433626175,
-0.030707471072673798,
-0.02063557133078575,
-0.024933084845542908,
-0.032534655183553696,
-0.04535577818751335,
-0.08247185498476028,
0.041188936680555344,
0.016543930396437645,
0.00886838510632515,
0.0167985949665308,
-0.022748172283172607,
-0.08833970874547958,
0.012481681071221828,
-0.033651553094387054,
0.0042569818906486034,
-0.01590118184685707,
-0.043226804584264755,
0.04800144210457802,
-0.02871767245233059,
-0.07193171232938766,
0.033597566187381744,
0.014081699773669243,
-0.03062455728650093,
-0.019427143037319183,
0.013911478221416473,
-0.015917059034109116,
0.004645649343729019,
-0.036864638328552246,
0.04993598535656929,
0.0025931706186383963,
0.06261929124593735,
-0.009348702616989613,
0.05510420352220535,
0.02852051705121994,
0.017031794413924217,
0.02393507771193981,
0.055416032671928406,
-0.009428792633116245,
0.007315332535654306,
-0.05651690438389778,
0.010828070342540741,
-0.043466877192258835,
-0.02542361244559288,
0.03333180397748947,
-0.014398517087101936,
0.011678768321871758,
0.06449484080076218,
0.011445739306509495,
-0.029156984761357307,
-0.059293609112501144,
-0.04200047254562378,
-0.02019355446100235,
-0.022141242399811745,
-0.029765941202640533,
-0.009018303826451302,
0.012463606894016266,
0.01087062805891037,
-0.0011026773136109114,
-0.03405768796801567,
0.05037970095872879,
-0.03323609009385109,
-0.010562855750322342,
0.009929507039487362,
-0.007982502691447735,
-0.02752317115664482,
-0.026819774881005287,
0.011596067808568478,
-0.024377938359975815,
0.02981923148036003,
0.043230343610048294,
0.02732371911406517,
0.022281384095549583,
0.029823357239365578,
0.005164881236851215,
-0.03237343207001686,
-0.028274236246943474,
0.01639440469443798,
-0.03925953805446625,
0.016815947368741035,
0.03925246745347977,
0.0400770902633667,
0.00711088627576828,
0.032251711934804916,
0.03484802320599556,
0.014474732801318169,
-0.014345576986670494,
0.011256780475378036,
-0.026886507868766785,
0.021640002727508545,
-0.07270635664463043,
-0.0000993418725556694,
-0.019886188209056854,
-0.02964954823255539,
0.0024455685634166002,
0.0580788291990757,
-0.011126202531158924,
-0.033619411289691925,
-0.03839773312211037,
0.058392446488142014,
0.020670050755143166,
-0.051896028220653534,
-0.011277806013822556,
0.015156413428485394,
0.06559409201145172,
-0.01651332527399063,
-0.008443116210401058,
0.0007095719920471311,
0.01216934435069561,
0.015573778189718723,
-0.01731717400252819,
-0.053267549723386765,
-0.030001111328601837,
-0.009635083377361298,
0.003056285437196493,
0.0041289497166872025,
0.016123758628964424,
-0.026590686291456223,
0.013277350924909115,
0.0009827741887420416,
0.0009107000078074634,
-0.011344099417328835,
0.038074687123298645,
0.05421930178999901,
-0.0029437136836349964,
-0.028717543929815292,
-0.0051543922163546085,
-0.03657931089401245,
0.04923731088638306,
-0.0024614399299025536,
-0.007139682304114103,
0.010506446473300457,
-0.006229528225958347,
-0.021800680086016655,
-0.04045094922184944,
-0.015945158898830414,
0.017255308106541634,
0.021913761273026466,
-0.0029609419871121645,
-0.016498127952218056,
0.006395657081156969,
-0.03799644857645035,
0.022089045494794846,
0.03277469053864479,
-0.07415081560611725,
0.018048737198114395,
0.017542697489261627,
0.0049158623442053795,
0.026226114481687546,
0.00984986126422882,
-0.0511755496263504,
-0.030804146081209183,
-0.030722180381417274,
0.0021637852769345045,
0.016095658764243126,
-0.01947687938809395,
0.0008461234392598271,
0.016676057130098343,
-0.022457173094153404,
0.03208212926983833,
0.01138760894536972,
-0.004585521295666695,
-0.014517908915877342,
0.01268553826957941,
0.05203719437122345,
0.024417513981461525,
0.00299108331091702,
0.0029942640103399754,
-0.02468876540660858,
0.008928113617002964,
-0.020771516487002373,
0.043614618480205536,
0.02642025798559189,
-0.008391011506319046,
0.016034679487347603,
-0.05292839556932449,
0.010049006901681423,
-0.011012452654540539,
-0.0034395994152873755,
-0.015674684196710587,
0.024393118917942047,
0.007527852430939674,
0.018343277275562286,
-0.019594324752688408,
0.01093093678355217,
0.019695010036230087,
-0.004161169286817312,
0.007062977645546198,
0.01388695277273655,
0.03913009166717529,
0.026161542162299156,
-0.07665395736694336,
-0.03537049517035484,
0.03620193898677826,
-0.0173636507242918,
-0.0025532508734613657,
-0.0886329710483551,
-0.018579989671707153,
-0.003583692479878664,
-0.02532348223030567,
0.03691021725535393,
-0.03223487362265587,
0.049133118242025375,
0.015538383275270462,
0.0674150139093399,
-0.008573751896619797,
-0.046653036028146744,
0.02903584949672222,
-0.07351133972406387,
-0.039180148392915726,
-0.057551413774490356,
-0.0010598336812108755,
0.047988589853048325,
-0.009524602442979813,
0.021617747843265533,
0.002934705466032028,
0.009744544513523579,
0.02619098499417305,
-0.030755717307329178,
-0.03173474967479706,
0.017533505335450172,
-0.03679893910884857,
-0.0049203867092728615,
0.022965293377637863,
-0.0422544926404953,
-0.024515362456440926,
-0.008801248855888844,
-0.06774307787418365,
0.02117673121392727,
0.04265407845377922,
0.05750807374715805,
-0.003037553047761321,
0.009278696030378342,
-0.04793321341276169,
0.012052696198225021,
0.04529992863535881,
0.07972003519535065,
0.04019792750477791,
0.03702111914753914,
-0.06693395972251892,
0.10442889481782913,
0.06109141185879707,
0.01325796078890562,
-0.011836182326078415,
0.010589751414954662,
-0.004712269641458988,
-0.0732668861746788,
0.03942786529660225,
0.02030443213880062,
-0.026286939159035683,
-0.035063404589891434,
0.03994373232126236,
0.026696719229221344,
-0.018453022465109825,
-0.022983595728874207,
0.07574459165334702,
-0.03549569472670555,
0.020528176799416542,
0.010245442390441895,
-0.014451863244175911,
-0.0035724102053791285,
0.0750102773308754,
0.016099754720926285,
0.03518977761268616,
0.03920470178127289,
-0.010053972713649273,
-0.010085943154990673,
-0.018691536039114,
0.09656728804111481,
0.08478644490242004,
0.026830922812223434,
-0.011917282827198505,
0.026991674676537514,
-0.03406836465001106,
-0.05937047302722931,
-0.0058739567175507545,
-0.0024795369245111942,
-0.015646854415535927,
-0.009113563224673271,
-0.006010862533003092,
0.064753957092762,
-0.011506255716085434,
0.07357621937990189,
-0.030766358599066734,
0.032713718712329865,
0.013780415989458561,
0.05541003495454788,
0.002531492616981268,
0.02835116535425186,
0.0006114828865975142,
0.013392341323196888,
-0.0015578995225951076,
-0.05184868723154068,
-0.0178451556712389,
0.014320329762995243,
0.011316543444991112,
0.026114540174603462,
-0.03041612170636654,
0.02505815215408802,
0.016817664727568626,
0.0607520267367363,
0.09043870866298676,
-0.04491278529167175,
-0.037015266716480255,
0.0017445540288463235,
0.042790286242961884,
-0.000773058389313519,
0.0164939071983099,
0.025391438975930214,
-0.0014914068160578609,
0.031258199363946915,
-0.028031617403030396,
0.043851807713508606,
0.03402290865778923,
-0.00902585405856371,
0.022744791582226753,
-0.012847989797592163,
-0.05084999278187752,
0.010880127549171448,
0.011472595855593681,
-0.020132001489400864,
-0.04249749332666397,
-0.030073722824454308,
-0.06675469130277634,
-0.062281299382448196,
-0.04661727324128151,
0.0015413884539157152,
-0.020130770280957222,
-0.004105895757675171,
-0.019029973074793816,
-0.02231602370738983,
0.023771580308675766,
0.02935938537120819,
-0.053721942007541656,
0.02343663200736046,
0.03445552662014961,
0.037491004914045334,
0.002575572580099106,
0.0543520413339138,
0.02249915525317192,
0.013845304027199745,
-0.005983571521937847,
0.06936272978782654,
0.022051310166716576,
0.039628881961107254,
-0.015929127112030983,
0.004289612639695406,
-0.0924462154507637,
-0.0071128541603684425,
-0.0001000095289782621,
-0.022123834118247032,
-0.07491333782672882,
0.05062833055853844,
-0.023559406399726868,
-0.013268211856484413,
0.04753270372748375,
-0.00001631592749617994,
0.003611615626141429,
-0.04536539688706398,
-0.029391584917902946,
-0.004779108799993992,
-0.023332655429840088,
0.0823979452252388,
-0.009745421819388866,
0.058459289371967316,
0.047231074422597885,
-0.028817256912589073,
-0.01852351613342762,
0.02500957064330578,
-0.038716819137334824,
0.015909960493445396,
-0.023859169334173203,
-0.03537977486848831,
-0.02851959876716137,
-0.06936316937208176,
0.038087960332632065,
0.00597167806699872,
0.008410227485001087,
-0.015193549916148186,
0.00526727270334959,
0.01374912541359663,
0.016903670504689217,
-0.007794771809130907,
0.013204220682382584,
-0.025311846286058426,
-0.04179231449961662,
-0.052651625126600266,
-0.08569679409265518,
0.02454197034239769,
0.0058343918062746525,
-0.001224897219799459,
-0.03152352198958397,
-0.06227283552289009,
-0.01692938804626465,
-0.028109462931752205,
0.03895720839500427,
0.013316011987626553,
0.0032204033341258764,
-0.002444175537675619
] |
334 |
Stiefel Flow Matching for Moment-Constrained Structure Elucidation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=84WmbzikPP
|
[
"Austin Henry Cheng",
"Alston Lo",
"Kin Long Kelvin Lee",
"Santiago Miret",
"Alan Aspuru-Guzik"
] |
Poster
|
Molecular structure elucidation is a fundamental step in understanding chemical phenomena, with applications in identifying molecules in natural products, lab syntheses, forensic samples, and the interstellar medium.
We consider the task of predicting a molecule's all-atom 3D structure given only its molecular formula and moments of inertia, motivated by the ability of rotational spectroscopy to measure these moments.
While existing generative models can conditionally sample 3D structures with approximately correct moments, this soft conditioning fails to leverage the many digits of precision afforded by experimental rotational spectroscopy.
To address this, we first show that the space of $n$-atom point clouds with a fixed set of moments of inertia is embedded in the Stiefel manifold $\mathrm{St}(n, 4)$.
We then propose Stiefel Flow Matching as a generative model for elucidating 3D structure under exact moment constraints.
Additionally, we learn simpler and shorter flows by finding approximate solutions for equivariant optimal transport on the Stiefel manifold.
Empirically, enforcing exact moment constraints allows Stiefel Flow Matching to achieve higher success rates and faster sampling than Euclidean diffusion models, even on high-dimensional manifolds corresponding to large molecules in the GEOM dataset.
|
3D molecular generative models, flow matching, Stiefel manifold, structure elucidation
|
We propose Stiefel flow matching as a generative model on the Stiefel manifold and apply it for molecular structure elucidation by rotational spectroscopy.
| 13,419 |
2412.12540
|
[
-0.011332761496305466,
0.02743075042963028,
0.017476346343755722,
0.03741414472460747,
0.013177817687392235,
-0.012238109484314919,
0.019891008734703064,
-0.008431428112089634,
0.015019632875919342,
-0.03941009193658829,
-0.008745646104216576,
-0.02194867841899395,
-0.04508661851286888,
0.015286185778677464,
0.017901841551065445,
0.06619065254926682,
0.025376975536346436,
0.0004966746782884002,
0.0211696345359087,
0.021332863718271255,
-0.02348838374018669,
-0.0070588006637990475,
0.026265796273946762,
-0.002973470836877823,
0.07040168344974518,
0.005744409281760454,
-0.0007241858984343708,
-0.00037897087167948484,
-0.0317339189350605,
0.021156350150704384,
0.034519731998443604,
-0.007110625971108675,
-0.014909874647855759,
-0.08311140537261963,
-0.001735758502036333,
-0.030600398778915405,
-0.02909751795232296,
-0.009391067549586296,
-0.0028745955787599087,
0.011079050600528717,
-0.0581173300743103,
-0.014833551831543446,
0.0032739408779889345,
0.010868710465729237,
-0.04863104596734047,
0.01950063370168209,
-0.08529483526945114,
0.06288240849971771,
-0.019303271546959877,
-0.0613100603222847,
-0.06200164183974266,
0.04327675327658653,
0.00839861948043108,
0.005943762604147196,
-0.008511153981089592,
0.014305545017123222,
-0.0018960853340104222,
-0.03842359408736229,
-0.011525629088282585,
-0.06593341380357742,
-0.00814100168645382,
0.016255320981144905,
0.007849827408790588,
0.003268797881901264,
0.018366364762187004,
-0.030693521723151207,
0.01685870625078678,
0.04120831936597824,
-0.05761604383587837,
-0.012124337255954742,
0.0037833377718925476,
0.010379023849964142,
0.00546205835416913,
0.009776890277862549,
0.021855220198631287,
-0.017614761367440224,
0.01605718582868576,
0.02183431386947632,
0.03210005164146423,
0.016591493040323257,
0.026949970051646233,
0.025767002254724503,
-0.006789787206798792,
0.022702625021338463,
-0.006122255232185125,
0.001076294924132526,
-0.09198364615440369,
-0.004844373092055321,
-0.05086110904812813,
0.04559900984168053,
-0.0319182388484478,
-0.046270012855529785,
0.0029294693376868963,
0.04973718896508217,
0.050073444843292236,
-0.03914583846926689,
0.054646991193294525,
0.009369650855660439,
0.006138055119663477,
0.008715708740055561,
-0.0190581101924181,
-0.03882662579417229,
-0.002751169493421912,
0.0017850813455879688,
-0.08295431733131409,
-0.02150350622832775,
-0.020830607041716576,
-0.026764951646327972,
0.007175426930189133,
0.0025436384603381157,
-0.01442936435341835,
0.005623254459351301,
-0.0140535281971097,
0.020448049530386925,
-0.08558649569749832,
0.050104714930057526,
0.035288095474243164,
0.022960983216762543,
0.020520145073533058,
-0.01410005521029234,
0.05396478995680809,
0.07754763960838318,
0.003995412494987249,
0.06727324426174164,
0.0007231415365822613,
0.040876321494579315,
0.00710579939186573,
0.03460142761468887,
-0.03953086584806442,
-0.04084164649248123,
0.036506738513708115,
0.060482192784547806,
0.005667929537594318,
-0.027200426906347275,
0.00020648645295295864,
-0.05554831027984619,
0.0048556700348854065,
-0.00008728303509997204,
0.03989284485578537,
0.002173962537199259,
-0.004949554335325956,
-0.03064805455505848,
0.014670527540147305,
-0.006053078453987837,
0.06427695602178574,
0.008493974804878235,
-0.01538244541734457,
-0.03840824216604233,
-0.021405508741736412,
0.017190221697092056,
0.012893649749457836,
-0.006268535740673542,
0.0071658361703157425,
-0.03864600509405136,
0.0016047663521021605,
0.06566251814365387,
0.009977499954402447,
0.040940213948488235,
0.009107383899390697,
-0.028786838054656982,
0.015656311064958572,
-0.0004857399908360094,
-0.0000771210907259956,
0.0008329072734341025,
0.01504781935364008,
-0.03509986400604248,
0.028024423867464066,
0.07915402948856354,
-0.05870654433965683,
-0.01255929283797741,
-0.035277221351861954,
-0.045380912721157074,
0.06013210862874985,
-0.019994305446743965,
0.005087817087769508,
-0.008685147389769554,
0.03322961926460266,
-0.013796298764646053,
0.03808034583926201,
-0.004916580859571695,
-0.08205339312553406,
0.011546610854566097,
-0.008219783194363117,
-0.0025598853826522827,
0.00860284361988306,
0.010397937148809433,
0.10051943361759186,
0.010197483003139496,
-0.017613785341382027,
0.011731274425983429,
-0.06622929126024246,
-0.04222484678030014,
0.025125475600361824,
-0.021784570068120956,
0.04391370713710785,
-0.004679971840232611,
0.0028921253979206085,
0.05063788592815399,
0.0028352648951113224,
0.024226635694503784,
0.007965079508721828,
-0.0002684936916921288,
0.05206120386719704,
-0.04570135474205017,
-0.04673287644982338,
-0.04741884768009186,
0.055400241166353226,
-0.07433498650789261,
-0.011309376917779446,
-0.000052057923312531784,
0.0006830205675214529,
-0.0024139725137501955,
-0.004037697333842516,
-0.02825218066573143,
0.0053466008976101875,
-0.006602616515010595,
-0.004543537739664316,
0.0147201307117939,
-0.01389383990317583,
0.0033528006169945,
0.02169686183333397,
0.026690693572163582,
-0.04246009141206741,
0.020279549062252045,
-0.04773881658911705,
0.10508622229099274,
0.08858703076839447,
-0.02333354391157627,
-0.006307366769760847,
0.046088531613349915,
0.028178958222270012,
-0.029941823333501816,
0.028392480686306953,
-0.05067991092801094,
-0.021999206393957138,
-0.012470796704292297,
0.027184734120965004,
0.012248615734279156,
0.06055615097284317,
-0.06562848389148712,
0.007311308290809393,
0.03358093649148941,
0.0033560057636350393,
0.059607673436403275,
0.014193235896527767,
0.015139725990593433,
0.05266362056136131,
-0.01858191192150116,
-0.04764601215720177,
-0.03055797889828682,
-0.05544012784957886,
0.01298346184194088,
-0.033568497747182846,
-0.028041213750839233,
0.00021662330254912376,
-0.05962371826171875,
-0.033312082290649414,
0.023027831688523293,
0.09247168898582458,
0.057899367064237595,
0.008332587778568268,
-0.02042529173195362,
0.030458005145192146,
-0.009908710606396198,
-0.038540903478860855,
-0.09415018558502197,
-0.0592016763985157,
-0.028897225856781006,
0.039891935884952545,
0.009083576500415802,
0.050919629633426666,
0.02283487282693386,
-0.01143550407141447,
-0.04644852131605148,
-0.036278873682022095,
0.02063310518860817,
-0.0005903617711737752,
0.010092257522046566,
-0.026544496417045593,
0.0007033506990410388,
0.017506299540400505,
0.0823318138718605,
0.006086824461817741,
-0.025318367406725883,
-0.05709591880440712,
-0.02092701382935047,
-0.012464801780879498,
-0.005458415020257235,
0.0021831272169947624,
0.005715746898204088,
0.0009477656567469239,
-0.009380364790558815,
-0.04450533539056778,
0.010434470139443874,
0.030804907903075218,
0.06884326785802841,
0.042991362512111664,
0.017067531123757362,
-0.028276817873120308,
0.0013228077441453934,
0.009911480359733105,
0.0255806352943182,
-0.04333757981657982,
-0.004447305109351873,
-0.0009685218683443964,
0.01724640093743801,
0.016718387603759766,
0.007957515306770802,
-0.29244375228881836,
-0.028804173693060875,
0.007968735881149769,
-0.008986865170300007,
0.02536148950457573,
0.03911170735955238,
0.053109582513570786,
-0.05883967503905296,
-0.029481666162610054,
-0.0028946022503077984,
0.0003185700043104589,
0.029292050749063492,
-0.004638866521418095,
0.06969176977872849,
0.07176335901021957,
0.028600074350833893,
0.009465193375945091,
-0.03439180180430412,
0.019578518345952034,
0.02529195137321949,
-0.022504637017846107,
-0.03722439333796501,
-0.03192369267344475,
0.0019195752684026957,
0.004990313667804003,
0.00261709070764482,
-0.08943155407905579,
-0.016017328947782516,
-0.029633617028594017,
-0.009789390489459038,
-0.042313117533922195,
-0.0202229842543602,
-0.014513379894196987,
0.017840689048171043,
0.03401787951588631,
0.0025203695986419916,
0.028817903250455856,
-0.02895933762192726,
0.02261677011847496,
-0.01332557201385498,
-0.030682118609547615,
0.01646481640636921,
-0.022481825202703476,
0.0192367285490036,
0.054550670087337494,
-0.011896089650690556,
-0.0013993143802508712,
-0.02211972139775753,
-0.015956806018948555,
0.01570937968790531,
-0.028410371392965317,
-0.04312022030353546,
-0.012578131631016731,
-0.048953745514154434,
-0.006546898745000362,
-0.027887606993317604,
-0.00975871179252863,
0.0023364766966551542,
-0.021403830498456955,
0.022052176296710968,
0.010435297153890133,
-0.04873977228999138,
-0.0005783459055237472,
-0.02810872532427311,
-0.03617039695382118,
-0.03555971384048462,
-0.04636092856526375,
-0.029553774744272232,
0.03989911824464798,
0.015261593274772167,
0.00170483801048249,
0.034828267991542816,
-0.03476382791996002,
-0.07692091912031174,
0.060639262199401855,
-0.004819846712052822,
0.016174441203475,
-0.050151124596595764,
0.010957444086670876,
0.013890432193875313,
-0.03100001811981201,
-0.025128953158855438,
-0.00234218779951334,
0.055909112095832825,
0.01982569508254528,
-0.03023291751742363,
-0.003432633588090539,
-0.038411322981119156,
-0.040779948234558105,
-0.015322945080697536,
0.038989171385765076,
-0.0035647968761622906,
0.056730717420578,
-0.008312617428600788,
0.03589078038930893,
0.03385531157255173,
0.016965921968221664,
0.035391665995121,
0.03213902562856674,
0.009255114011466503,
0.0452241376042366,
-0.055693868547677994,
0.0060331313870847225,
-0.033066276460886,
-0.027926670387387276,
0.009476345032453537,
-0.04860524460673332,
0.010833979584276676,
0.041754644364118576,
0.006710072048008442,
-0.047147855162620544,
0.009287195280194283,
-0.002849660813808441,
-0.012227275408804417,
0.010258086025714874,
-0.019926665350794792,
0.03846989944577217,
0.04446934908628464,
0.033293358981609344,
-0.009151856414973736,
-0.019566591829061508,
0.034610815346241,
-0.02145257778465748,
-0.016854800283908844,
-0.020823711529374123,
-0.021639497950673103,
-0.01450187899172306,
0.016341688111424446,
0.012715455144643784,
0.03936474397778511,
0.015978200361132622,
0.055710569024086,
0.014803050085902214,
0.012052994221448898,
0.04475053772330284,
0.018495891243219376,
-0.03673580661416054,
-0.03541992977261543,
0.02501092106103897,
-0.033176764845848083,
0.030982309952378273,
-0.004368493799120188,
0.030482223257422447,
0.02946566417813301,
0.08122546225786209,
0.021659811958670616,
0.03956222906708717,
0.03826257213950157,
-0.00572512112557888,
-0.011796637438237667,
0.0018640614580363035,
-0.021601207554340363,
-0.003402748377993703,
-0.019953537732362747,
-0.0037251014728099108,
-0.03351011872291565,
0.01683362014591694,
0.01178573165088892,
0.0300239659845829,
-0.06398731470108032,
0.05856682360172272,
0.0010489010019227862,
-0.03356408327817917,
0.0044086226262152195,
0.00038770135142840445,
0.061331264674663544,
-0.010994929820299149,
0.05109206959605217,
-0.006711331196129322,
-0.004224192816764116,
0.0027414467185735703,
-0.02359817922115326,
-0.03917059302330017,
-0.01812250167131424,
-0.03570571914315224,
0.03436189517378807,
-0.00963408313691616,
0.014759795740246773,
-0.031266238540410995,
-0.01874707080423832,
0.01365702971816063,
-0.01853967271745205,
-0.027136119082570076,
-0.01155897881835699,
0.058600783348083496,
-0.011557107791304588,
-0.0018636531895026565,
-0.009000473655760288,
-0.008469893597066402,
0.0711858943104744,
0.015129221603274345,
0.008553830906748772,
-0.05202370509505272,
-0.020636431872844696,
-0.010152295231819153,
-0.0749153271317482,
0.015563204884529114,
0.022120188921689987,
-0.013260172680020332,
0.024386195465922356,
0.025392528623342514,
0.010152571834623814,
-0.05606206879019737,
0.009564222767949104,
0.03143134340643883,
-0.06387027353048325,
-0.006815975997596979,
0.060442421585321426,
0.0072661940939724445,
0.005478517152369022,
-0.03887029364705086,
-0.05608149990439415,
-0.05960293486714363,
0.011060133576393127,
0.0055993120186030865,
0.021906238049268723,
0.020230920985341072,
-0.00569892255589366,
0.010382224805653095,
-0.002475123153999448,
0.02521439827978611,
0.029462167993187904,
0.02939656935632229,
-0.009928232058882713,
0.03576049953699112,
0.02922051027417183,
-0.0303150936961174,
-0.002442769007757306,
-0.003969456069171429,
-0.004534726496785879,
0.015457083471119404,
-0.030869891867041588,
0.003002776764333248,
0.02075306884944439,
-0.02690311148762703,
0.012775633484125137,
-0.059906989336013794,
0.037519194185733795,
0.010468900203704834,
0.004408363718539476,
0.019995644688606262,
-0.01547967828810215,
0.0033827610313892365,
-0.001133123878389597,
-0.008048824965953827,
0.013833867385983467,
0.039672888815402985,
0.000016276339010801166,
-0.01881706342101097,
0.03611508384346962,
0.011105741374194622,
0.011283681727945805,
-0.03379247337579727,
-0.0502067469060421,
0.04369840770959854,
-0.014603217132389545,
-0.044849835336208344,
-0.06634815037250519,
-0.007338274735957384,
-0.004645918495953083,
-0.015846777707338333,
0.035661131143569946,
-0.06037943437695503,
0.010241558775305748,
-0.008016823790967464,
0.021983759477734566,
-0.0027492730878293514,
-0.07305214554071426,
0.05641067028045654,
-0.05033449828624725,
-0.008699002675712109,
-0.035445597022771835,
0.005195813253521919,
0.061512649059295654,
-0.025169719010591507,
0.01266193576157093,
0.006929982919245958,
-0.014440768398344517,
0.04300057888031006,
-0.04144109785556793,
-0.0813969299197197,
0.02562592923641205,
-0.01695319265127182,
0.020304009318351746,
0.04449557512998581,
-0.015550770796835423,
-0.07232189923524857,
-0.015105176717042923,
-0.04680168256163597,
0.009973613545298576,
0.03475198522210121,
0.03097829595208168,
-0.07765106111764908,
0.0037289627362042665,
-0.025913193821907043,
0.011531446129083633,
0.024762731045484543,
0.06612337380647659,
0.003079882822930813,
0.01438000425696373,
-0.029144663363695145,
0.065444216132164,
0.0900908038020134,
-0.015304171480238438,
0.020798318088054657,
0.002235840540379286,
0.02342834882438183,
-0.020140618085861206,
0.040726438164711,
-0.011962652206420898,
-0.0011989522026851773,
-0.0797538086771965,
0.05126069113612175,
0.02631465159356594,
-0.09088809788227081,
-0.022442780435085297,
0.07772988080978394,
-0.021225545555353165,
0.0004358413571026176,
0.021091163158416748,
0.001830254914239049,
-0.01258887443691492,
0.06208966299891472,
0.0059575969353318214,
0.03214119374752045,
0.04794764518737793,
0.02894986793398857,
-0.008693687617778778,
-0.03437229245901108,
0.08551979064941406,
0.05747633054852486,
0.037188973277807236,
-0.015990056097507477,
0.05194106698036194,
-0.03633194789290428,
-0.029072633013129234,
0.00047874546726234257,
0.010132109746336937,
-0.017904600128531456,
-0.012948594056069851,
0.02941971831023693,
0.08495090901851654,
-0.007819294929504395,
0.07390270382165909,
-0.019149838015437126,
0.003849911270663142,
0.007838393561542034,
0.015651414170861244,
0.010341784916818142,
0.03280775621533394,
-0.0037953422870486975,
0.030618401244282722,
-0.05590271204710007,
-0.01885477639734745,
-0.020460134372115135,
-0.04248393326997757,
0.03846089914441109,
0.0008849388104863465,
-0.027648283168673515,
0.021340645849704742,
-0.03896297141909599,
0.012945221737027168,
0.0961419939994812,
-0.02436484396457672,
-0.03517748415470123,
-0.0039006704464554787,
0.013716715388000011,
0.005743677727878094,
0.03443235903978348,
-0.006288775242865086,
-0.004965629894286394,
0.003886343678459525,
-0.08911555260419846,
0.00761683564633131,
0.035809703171253204,
-0.015521313063800335,
-0.009037944488227367,
-0.04454909265041351,
0.023908013477921486,
-0.025053799152374268,
0.026110853999853134,
-0.04078759625554085,
-0.08327672630548477,
-0.011819496750831604,
-0.057061437517404556,
-0.040074318647384644,
-0.04228519648313522,
0.004083042033016682,
-0.0030686345417052507,
-0.040201444178819656,
0.011603866703808308,
-0.02960801310837269,
0.03053019754588604,
0.02422282099723816,
-0.08087202161550522,
-0.04698117449879646,
0.09343885630369186,
0.013975818641483784,
-0.006840900518000126,
-0.002411206951364875,
0.047808706760406494,
-0.006158262491226196,
-0.00887291319668293,
0.0036251975689083338,
-0.014892805367708206,
0.05838499963283539,
-0.013858504593372345,
0.007816925644874573,
-0.09977686405181885,
0.016074901446700096,
0.019967596977949142,
-0.0398578867316246,
-0.08934099972248077,
-0.005611771252006292,
-0.02279410883784294,
-0.002488881116732955,
0.030005553737282753,
0.01947472244501114,
-0.006844107992947102,
-0.05972488597035408,
-0.012966208159923553,
0.03294721245765686,
0.006818332243710756,
0.072283536195755,
-0.045735958963632584,
0.061030980199575424,
0.013069897890090942,
-0.021344829350709915,
-0.03677252680063248,
0.019235040992498398,
0.03189742937684059,
0.00711320573464036,
-0.04360303655266762,
-0.006230123341083527,
-0.036930181086063385,
-0.093358114361763,
-0.00752928014844656,
0.03283197805285454,
0.0037800960708409548,
-0.01880425587296486,
0.009116516448557377,
0.02233901061117649,
-0.00235926266759634,
-0.008667982183396816,
0.008011181838810444,
0.005434928461909294,
-0.02050068974494934,
-0.026824483647942543,
-0.042071714997291565,
-0.012462208978831768,
0.01899103820323944,
-0.006432178895920515,
-0.039467550814151764,
-0.031675226986408234,
-0.007943764328956604,
-0.06383976340293884,
0.0038904743269085884,
0.036147769540548325,
0.03854800760746002,
0.02330053597688675
] |
335 |
Lawma: The Power of Specialization for Legal Annotation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=7El7K1DoyX
|
[
"Ricardo Dominguez-Olmedo",
"Vedant Nanda",
"Rediet Abebe",
"Stefan Bechtold",
"Christoph Engel",
"Jens Frankenreiter",
"Krishna P. Gummadi",
"Moritz Hardt",
"Michael Livermore"
] |
Poster
|
Annotation and classification of legal text are central components of empirical legal research. Traditionally, these tasks are often delegated to trained research assistants. Motivated by the advances in language modeling, empirical legal scholars are increasingly turning to commercial models, hoping that it will alleviate the significant cost of human annotation. In this work, we present a comprehensive analysis of large language models' current abilities to perform legal annotation tasks. To do so, we construct CaselawQA, a benchmark comprising 260 legal text classification tasks, nearly all new to the machine learning community. Starting from GPT-4 as a baseline, we show that it has non-trivial but highly varied accuracy, often exhibiting performance that may be insufficient for legal work. We then demonstrate that a lightly fine-tuned Llama 3 8B model vastly outperforms GPT-4 on almost all tasks, typically by double-digit percentage points. A few tens to hundreds of examples suffice to achieve high classification accuracy. Our work points to a viable alternative to the predominant practice of prompting commercial models. For concrete legal tasks with some available labeled data, researchers are better off using a specialized open-source model.
|
large language models, legal classification tasks, benchmarks
|
A lightly finetuned Llama-3 model outperforms GPT-4 on 260 new legal classification tasks
| 13,416 | null |
[
-0.0016242037527263165,
-0.06651726365089417,
-0.025116387754678726,
0.013327637687325478,
0.0391966849565506,
-0.011547732166945934,
0.031395044177770615,
-0.0067147146910429,
-0.013498829677700996,
0.021365579217672348,
-0.005008022766560316,
0.05553282052278519,
-0.06946439296007156,
-0.006196486763656139,
-0.02490031160414219,
0.05454857647418976,
0.02114555425941944,
0.006002108566462994,
0.032267775386571884,
-0.03323933854699135,
0.023402035236358643,
-0.007852346636354923,
0.043106429278850555,
0.038785118609666824,
0.02965916506946087,
0.013267656788229942,
0.024704713374376297,
0.03900337964296341,
-0.06729896366596222,
0.030789323151111603,
0.05841078236699104,
0.012641995213925838,
0.01084491703659296,
0.023610802367329597,
0.0171443372964859,
0.015226367861032486,
-0.03397609665989876,
0.022935986518859863,
0.034874189645051956,
0.016807474195957184,
-0.013573531992733479,
0.01518684346228838,
-0.038520392030477524,
0.01282948162406683,
-0.05792764201760292,
0.003499565878883004,
-0.09244029968976974,
0.0378548689186573,
-0.00012039594002999365,
-0.03403499722480774,
-0.08351163566112518,
0.013856287114322186,
-0.0592956505715847,
-0.015658225864171982,
0.009543434716761112,
0.03503924608230591,
0.021027779206633568,
-0.10177159309387207,
0.0007186342845670879,
-0.0282055102288723,
-0.014894681051373482,
-0.002659181598573923,
0.021248023957014084,
-0.0008518157992511988,
0.0014758012257516384,
-0.01240452378988266,
-0.03315811604261398,
0.013356387615203857,
-0.055420778691768646,
-0.036743175238370895,
-0.024221381172537804,
-0.0035407845862209797,
-0.028893442824482918,
0.003942461684346199,
0.012759179808199406,
-0.04141068831086159,
-0.005411590915173292,
0.04061507806181908,
0.03934399411082268,
0.010886363685131073,
0.017251795157790184,
0.00565181951969862,
0.029573356732726097,
0.043450333178043365,
0.02574153244495392,
-0.006924684625118971,
-0.047823622822761536,
-0.03466659039258957,
-0.08114004880189896,
0.04199063405394554,
0.010309452190995216,
-0.03579871356487274,
0.009715208783745766,
0.04117463901638985,
-0.0010747738415375352,
0.032859835773706436,
0.05044927820563316,
0.008404543623328209,
-0.010555963031947613,
0.013452866114675999,
-0.027981337159872055,
-0.01978905312716961,
0.04505020007491112,
0.04238181561231613,
-0.09761741012334824,
-0.02143789827823639,
0.011742713861167431,
-0.007814337499439716,
-0.02146858721971512,
-0.003527572611346841,
0.003041070420295,
-0.03400673717260361,
-0.019223304465413094,
0.01474476233124733,
-0.05259575694799423,
0.05008389800786972,
0.0018070907099172473,
-0.011082708835601807,
-0.016502995043992996,
-0.0006747011211700737,
0.03793444111943245,
0.007140988949686289,
0.01207037828862667,
0.07737696170806885,
0.026069507002830505,
-0.011582291685044765,
0.029745761305093765,
-0.0017046334687620401,
-0.021641841158270836,
-0.05078260228037834,
0.01211452018469572,
0.03874897584319115,
0.0023337556049227715,
0.006041687447577715,
0.0166060458868742,
0.003756739431992173,
0.010126976296305656,
0.007830265909433365,
0.07998789846897125,
-0.01939311996102333,
0.012984415516257286,
-0.01999404840171337,
0.025643233209848404,
-0.04868296533823013,
0.0880984216928482,
-0.021542992442846298,
-0.017484024167060852,
-0.016911501064896584,
-0.04584372788667679,
-0.010118797421455383,
0.02459736168384552,
0.024261143058538437,
-0.000694339454639703,
-0.007044197525829077,
0.05743775889277458,
0.046273328363895416,
0.029053380712866783,
-0.015081030316650867,
0.0063032303005456924,
0.00840809941291809,
-0.002783037256449461,
0.005493801087141037,
-0.02269887737929821,
0.033328693360090256,
0.00302786473184824,
-0.04331275820732117,
0.05451743304729462,
-0.005744653288275003,
-0.05982338637113571,
0.03367363288998604,
-0.056242670863866806,
-0.0328427329659462,
0.0696297213435173,
-0.018713360652327538,
-0.03204831853508949,
-0.00403232267126441,
0.05593673884868622,
0.013500269502401352,
0.04939112812280655,
0.04247873276472092,
-0.057780489325523376,
0.039373718202114105,
0.05146155506372452,
-0.03917444869875908,
0.008064832538366318,
0.012491585686802864,
0.09388871490955353,
-0.06483907252550125,
-0.0016168644651770592,
0.001294918591156602,
-0.06895963102579117,
-0.02684311755001545,
0.041482049971818924,
-0.0025887733791023493,
0.035717107355594635,
0.040724605321884155,
0.00807881634682417,
0.10508701950311661,
-0.006845937110483646,
0.0476185604929924,
0.026653330773115158,
0.029538117349147797,
0.06899067014455795,
-0.017124414443969727,
-0.04084723815321922,
0.005753364879637957,
0.03143393248319626,
-0.0363941416144371,
-0.06250306963920593,
0.017180031165480614,
-0.043877676129341125,
0.019223950803279877,
0.022503860294818878,
-0.022460972890257835,
-0.0049792705103755,
0.027176495641469955,
0.046641334891319275,
-0.0019429128151386976,
0.020279476419091225,
-0.04194061458110809,
0.04259924963116646,
-0.01850486733019352,
-0.02238020859658718,
0.0060382867231965065,
-0.03549070656299591,
0.10210185497999191,
0.04883337765932083,
0.007754036691039801,
0.006179378367960453,
0.021799148991703987,
-0.0023036880884319544,
0.001998104387894273,
0.043992575258016586,
-0.04484878480434418,
0.0188472718000412,
-0.005142748821526766,
-0.00300713162869215,
-0.01954185590147972,
0.04757183790206909,
-0.011564983986318111,
-0.005601692479103804,
0.05649188905954361,
-0.0021433494985103607,
0.051015328615903854,
-0.028480229899287224,
0.031985554844141006,
-0.015216752886772156,
-0.030284732580184937,
-0.026397626847028732,
-0.00525212287902832,
0.026330137625336647,
-0.008432723581790924,
-0.022995412349700928,
-0.02620229683816433,
0.010342407040297985,
-0.05092949420213699,
-0.07061000913381577,
-0.005227611865848303,
0.03474704548716545,
0.01430373266339302,
-0.008872794918715954,
0.004132681526243687,
0.0094715915620327,
-0.011271948926150799,
0.015710994601249695,
-0.0709187462925911,
0.00904768891632557,
-0.017939336597919464,
-0.006317934021353722,
0.022051673382520676,
0.05795705318450928,
0.0223152544349432,
0.02069012261927128,
-0.035898156464099884,
-0.01068054884672165,
0.027534568682312965,
0.03694411739706993,
-0.03193627670407295,
-0.056302089244127274,
-0.03850093111395836,
-0.0494304820895195,
0.03677261248230934,
-0.019414693117141724,
-0.05353197082877159,
-0.00396814476698637,
-0.0499623641371727,
0.03410112112760544,
-0.05313647538423538,
-0.01744111068546772,
0.059305332601070404,
0.02127739228308201,
0.0335015133023262,
-0.019138909876346588,
-0.01339713018387556,
0.03320257365703583,
0.045574385672807693,
0.028149953112006187,
-0.0048676058650016785,
-0.020647471770644188,
0.04019344598054886,
-0.01585262641310692,
0.017715439200401306,
0.02273288555443287,
0.027034197002649307,
0.013056746684014797,
-0.018458088859915733,
-0.018575457856059074,
0.03225398063659668,
-0.2632490396499634,
-0.004322708118706942,
-0.014389648102223873,
-0.02393616922199726,
0.05281045287847519,
-0.03410463407635689,
0.04396930709481239,
-0.024938946589827538,
0.015189087018370628,
-0.02060447633266449,
0.010167665779590607,
0.03420526906847954,
0.024074537679553032,
0.04048972204327583,
0.04636263847351074,
0.031666938215494156,
-0.023777034133672714,
-0.022145399823784828,
0.010701463557779789,
0.04410937428474426,
0.010611770674586296,
-0.05942072719335556,
-0.029312821105122566,
0.0383344367146492,
-0.012443899177014828,
0.027946712449193,
-0.07899388670921326,
-0.005708515644073486,
-0.04834512993693352,
-0.004289367236196995,
0.006789057981222868,
-0.012005356140434742,
-0.048755668103694916,
0.03471210226416588,
-0.014432840049266815,
0.010487502440810204,
0.08138870447874069,
0.011113007552921772,
0.017110716551542282,
0.02291647158563137,
0.02757897414267063,
-0.017349399626255035,
-0.03772052377462387,
-0.009840678423643112,
0.06863974034786224,
-0.019155221059918404,
-0.06257745623588562,
-0.016541682183742523,
-0.016571734100580215,
0.049033742398023605,
-0.030023401603102684,
-0.018512042239308357,
-0.040899310261011124,
0.01661079190671444,
0.005397184751927853,
-0.016257166862487793,
-0.013691517524421215,
-0.018947573378682137,
-0.024237675592303276,
-0.0000027320913886796916,
0.018832063302397728,
-0.06959425657987595,
-0.013240085914731026,
-0.06012565642595291,
-0.04973277449607849,
-0.03951093927025795,
-0.04740603268146515,
-0.06681973487138748,
0.07853841781616211,
0.05402030795812607,
-0.034326035529375076,
0.04081181436777115,
-0.026591910049319267,
-0.10384189337491989,
0.007933932356536388,
-0.02848340943455696,
-0.015955282375216484,
-0.009710344485938549,
-0.007842199876904488,
0.03878724202513695,
-0.013726470991969109,
-0.060013432055711746,
0.0033709341660141945,
-0.0013752318918704987,
-0.010076828300952911,
-0.039859939366579056,
-0.025576654821634293,
0.00670800032094121,
-0.035955313593149185,
-0.029461141675710678,
0.02252170443534851,
0.022681433707475662,
-0.04724818468093872,
0.02648729644715786,
0.036579880863428116,
0.027002882212400436,
-0.01458880864083767,
0.04280348867177963,
0.02072913385927677,
0.00819538813084364,
0.035021472722291946,
-0.0702451542019844,
-0.0156339630484581,
-0.07558970153331757,
-0.012730967253446579,
0.03174179792404175,
-0.060300834476947784,
-0.00947179552167654,
0.034514136612415314,
-0.008838631212711334,
-0.0352470763027668,
-0.0316166952252388,
0.018155070021748543,
0.0018559197196736932,
-0.01076294481754303,
-0.012298649176955223,
-0.011798642575740814,
0.02567620389163494,
0.05774032324552536,
-0.0020884189289063215,
-0.02805822528898716,
0.021816445514559746,
-0.02130722813308239,
-0.014090781100094318,
-0.04704540967941284,
-0.010163734667003155,
0.01989510841667652,
-0.01332146767526865,
0.002198964823037386,
-0.037069112062454224,
0.0008374418830499053,
-0.026242617517709732,
-0.014340327121317387,
0.018089910969138145,
0.03646942600607872,
-0.0015476957196369767,
-0.005713426508009434,
-0.020179877057671547,
-0.0046064057387411594,
-0.01657378114759922,
0.022141296416521072,
-0.0348295122385025,
0.07035862654447556,
0.03265244513750076,
0.07194504141807556,
-0.030445722863078117,
0.012712251394987106,
0.023164018988609314,
-0.01076500304043293,
0.027989612892270088,
0.030963052064180374,
-0.016776418313384056,
0.008394064381718636,
-0.03450097143650055,
0.03062230907380581,
-0.016725340858101845,
0.025346802547574043,
0.036908041685819626,
0.00925676990300417,
-0.061648450791835785,
0.057871319353580475,
-0.01371084339916706,
0.009232143871486187,
-0.012816534377634525,
0.019362499937415123,
0.029944472014904022,
-0.02499564178287983,
0.040261849761009216,
-0.0037578416522592306,
0.03169563040137291,
0.014791689813137054,
-0.036308832466602325,
-0.012282446026802063,
0.013992544263601303,
-0.028394116088747978,
0.013314277864992619,
0.01613936573266983,
0.01720096357166767,
-0.014360700733959675,
0.06697048991918564,
-0.016341563314199448,
-0.05755343288183212,
-0.03622045740485191,
0.009888703934848309,
0.057385023683309555,
0.008903625421226025,
0.03595650941133499,
-0.01271736528724432,
-0.053211383521556854,
-0.005390074569731951,
-0.020722588524222374,
0.003904632991179824,
0.003592028981074691,
-0.03191397339105606,
-0.034421972930431366,
-0.06256358325481415,
0.01794593408703804,
-0.026356767863035202,
0.01915714330971241,
-0.03597811236977577,
0.005522353574633598,
-0.01242078747600317,
-0.0805947557091713,
0.011071749962866306,
0.0013078474439680576,
-0.09052351862192154,
-0.0006618249462917447,
-0.0457848384976387,
-0.019480526447296143,
0.023538969457149506,
-0.033776041120290756,
-0.04653031751513481,
-0.03153899312019348,
0.008540408685803413,
0.011475506238639355,
-0.06135337054729462,
-0.020586993545293808,
-0.01912061870098114,
-0.03836395964026451,
-0.020540285855531693,
0.0056818327866494656,
-0.05162299796938896,
0.014174154959619045,
-0.005564133170992136,
0.0028554112650454044,
0.070424385368824,
-0.04243507236242294,
-0.0025260101538151503,
0.01272362656891346,
-0.027922164648771286,
0.050683390349149704,
-0.06573285162448883,
0.023506930097937584,
0.057030852884054184,
0.00378740718588233,
-0.003428008873015642,
-0.05088144540786743,
-0.01368294470012188,
0.010799603536725044,
0.013541661202907562,
0.015618492849171162,
0.013822758570313454,
-0.009150843136012554,
0.00408818107098341,
0.01567103900015354,
0.027219638228416443,
0.04189502075314522,
0.03089854307472706,
-0.04658329114317894,
0.014804932288825512,
-0.0015859269769862294,
0.022283431142568588,
-0.04149078577756882,
-0.004957861732691526,
0.07113557308912277,
-0.0311509408056736,
-0.024882586672902107,
-0.022922271862626076,
-0.03986755758523941,
0.038066018372774124,
0.026205824688076973,
0.027419762685894966,
-0.0498851053416729,
0.03178882598876953,
0.029991593211889267,
0.05099007487297058,
0.0007712568040005863,
-0.029698405414819717,
0.047718316316604614,
-0.028802046552300453,
-0.024296259507536888,
-0.0733211562037468,
-0.046515099704265594,
0.0673898383975029,
-0.0005985000170767307,
-0.0014326594537124038,
-0.002461433643475175,
-0.04783013090491295,
0.02696966752409935,
-0.005525229498744011,
-0.04887136444449425,
0.007925553247332573,
-0.02155640535056591,
-0.026091257110238075,
0.03758260980248451,
-0.017529074102640152,
0.03300150856375694,
0.03444394841790199,
-0.02192573808133602,
-0.032383356243371964,
-0.02670823223888874,
0.05011507123708725,
-0.027636349201202393,
0.04386929050087929,
-0.0027921039145439863,
-0.014127222821116447,
0.04268506169319153,
0.02526387758553028,
0.020619329065084457,
0.01719948835670948,
-0.01943967491388321,
0.05676839500665665,
0.016191629692912102,
-0.004823846742510796,
0.005219572689384222,
-0.0057683782652020454,
-0.047637131065130234,
-0.057990651577711105,
0.07318056374788284,
0.003663003444671631,
-0.037672922015190125,
-0.06094135344028473,
0.06895577907562256,
0.053150031715631485,
-0.03469109907746315,
-0.02861870266497135,
0.0030260381754487753,
-0.041195210069417953,
0.018207550048828125,
-0.035509027540683746,
0.02696784771978855,
0.002502018352970481,
0.04570171236991882,
0.017663823440670967,
0.07613382488489151,
0.05645744502544403,
-0.013548512943089008,
0.0052781663835048676,
0.0013257588725537062,
0.04612436518073082,
0.03607523441314697,
0.0737115889787674,
-0.0025382169988006353,
0.0543602854013443,
-0.02114729769527912,
-0.06336314976215363,
0.012028200551867485,
0.034937191754579544,
0.002905048429965973,
0.00392534164711833,
0.03990097716450691,
0.05911252647638321,
0.013408112339675426,
0.03881314396858215,
-0.0319269560277462,
0.001021124655380845,
0.04016480594873428,
-0.02732894755899906,
0.021467041224241257,
0.041965700685977936,
0.0025497761089354753,
0.025416968390345573,
-0.024744119495153427,
-0.021608775481581688,
-0.0013696887763217092,
-0.03318094089627266,
-0.008149568922817707,
0.0185396708548069,
-0.05770478770136833,
-0.023533128201961517,
-0.02722533978521824,
0.051802121102809906,
0.10977242141962051,
-0.01133077684789896,
-0.04890485480427742,
0.009189723059535027,
0.02707318216562271,
0.04074905440211296,
0.007040113676339388,
-0.011726586148142815,
-0.03517650440335274,
-0.01089966855943203,
-0.044323116540908813,
0.03650955855846405,
0.03635874763131142,
-0.04580892622470856,
0.06501439958810806,
-0.024300523102283478,
-0.015647057443857193,
0.01585407741367817,
0.04870763421058655,
-0.0643288716673851,
-0.03148038312792778,
-0.04229159280657768,
-0.01141264010220766,
-0.024061035364866257,
-0.03490807116031647,
0.03801419958472252,
0.012659880332648754,
-0.02850854955613613,
-0.03016807697713375,
-0.040824249386787415,
0.011592674069106579,
0.03634565323591232,
-0.05891482159495354,
0.01782679557800293,
0.013426067307591438,
0.021151619032025337,
-0.023764150217175484,
0.032073818147182465,
0.034460511058568954,
-0.03170713037252426,
-0.019143691286444664,
0.04082360491156578,
0.016012417152523994,
0.024601154029369354,
0.0026076112408190966,
0.012787786312401295,
-0.0953211709856987,
-0.00008544832235202193,
0.0037401835434138775,
-0.03035661205649376,
-0.07287081331014633,
0.04356116056442261,
-0.025955427438020706,
0.03996768221259117,
0.09357976168394089,
0.04712044820189476,
0.019038351252675056,
0.0052517554722726345,
-0.011377086862921715,
-0.025349663570523262,
0.007486841641366482,
0.000431534688686952,
-0.01411471702158451,
0.05828971043229103,
0.03130706027150154,
-0.015286733396351337,
-0.04184115678071976,
0.010481026954948902,
0.002124195219948888,
-0.017744841054081917,
-0.05069863796234131,
-0.0002254872815683484,
-0.004578425548970699,
-0.035475555807352066,
-0.031675998121500015,
0.04245656728744507,
-0.02481050230562687,
-0.019346043467521667,
-0.004520358517765999,
-0.02453908883035183,
-0.029745016247034073,
-0.02552340365946293,
-0.007760238368064165,
-0.0087850047275424,
-0.0173127893358469,
-0.011154885403811932,
-0.07300270348787308,
-0.005252074915915728,
-0.02572542615234852,
0.007398728746920824,
-0.00624966062605381,
-0.03514224663376808,
-0.027376584708690643,
-0.021244019269943237,
0.05354848504066467,
-0.008966553956270218,
-0.015663763508200645,
-0.029350047931075096
] |
336 |
OpenRCA: Can Large Language Models Locate the Root Cause of Software Failures?
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=M4qNIzQYpd
|
[
"Junjielong Xu",
"Qinan Zhang",
"Zhiqing Zhong",
"Shilin He",
"Chaoyun Zhang",
"Qingwei Lin",
"Dan Pei",
"Pinjia He",
"Dongmei Zhang",
"Qi Zhang"
] |
Poster
|
Large language models (LLMs) are driving substantial advancements in software engineering, with successful applications like Copilot and Cursor transforming real-world development practices. However, current research predominantly focuses on the early stages of development, such as code generation, while overlooking the post-development phases that are crucial to user experience. To explore the potential of LLMs in this direction, we propose OpenRCA, a benchmark dataset and evaluation framework for assessing LLMs’ ability to identify the root cause of software failures. OpenRCA includes 335 failures from three enterprise software systems, along with over 68 GB of telemetry data (logs, metrics, and traces). Given a failure case and its associated telemetry, the LLM is tasked to identify the root cause that triggered the failure, requiring comprehension of software dependencies and reasoning over heterogeneous, long-context telemetry data. Our results show substantial room for improvement, as current models can only handle the simplest cases. Even with the specially designed RCA-agent, the best-performing model, Claude 3.5, solved only 11.34% failure cases. Our work paves the way for future research in this direction.
|
Language models, Natural language processing, Software engineering
|
A novel benchmark for evaluating language models that introduces real-world root cause analysis as a task.
| 13,411 | null |
[
-0.014026380144059658,
-0.0019958345219492912,
-0.047572311013936996,
0.025122016668319702,
0.044096674770116806,
0.015322601422667503,
0.024635881185531616,
0.026388822123408318,
-0.014632077887654305,
-0.02975534461438656,
-0.0558302104473114,
0.03861496224999428,
-0.05730895325541496,
0.004473081789910793,
-0.019195275381207466,
0.03960508108139038,
0.053642600774765015,
-0.0376298725605011,
0.0354287326335907,
-0.001178225502371788,
-0.013172300532460213,
0.00774682592600584,
-0.027336562052369118,
0.02700924500823021,
0.002148493891581893,
0.0412449985742569,
0.026848861947655678,
0.01033927220851183,
-0.06516890227794647,
-0.004775785841047764,
0.057161785662174225,
0.008750963024795055,
0.020552342757582664,
-0.03834855929017067,
0.011056873947381973,
0.04963822290301323,
-0.04163046181201935,
0.021288437768816948,
-0.03157072886824608,
-0.01810554787516594,
0.007802866864949465,
0.04495326057076454,
-0.0044393399730324745,
0.02227574586868286,
-0.02775602973997593,
0.04456831514835358,
-0.07682056725025177,
0.03776774927973747,
0.0432523712515831,
-0.013140377588570118,
-0.10132599622011185,
0.015068085864186287,
-0.04036393761634827,
-0.04113555699586868,
0.015866931527853012,
0.04054752737283707,
0.09468990564346313,
-0.081498883664608,
0.00407434580847621,
-0.041544072329998016,
-0.048428840935230255,
0.006307356990873814,
-0.002742941491305828,
0.003880435135215521,
0.010452651418745518,
-0.03652771934866905,
0.0069184377789497375,
0.030003828927874565,
-0.04299308359622955,
-0.05500016361474991,
0.01647731103003025,
0.02010134793817997,
-0.05056842789053917,
-0.010525385849177837,
-0.005173041485249996,
-0.04115381836891174,
0.0006788414902985096,
0.026112206280231476,
0.029350101947784424,
0.015708385035395622,
0.009511623531579971,
0.02873268350958824,
0.006056135054677725,
0.03240067511796951,
0.021082116290926933,
-0.01360048446804285,
0.012309619225561619,
-0.049393460154533386,
-0.045663267374038696,
0.06327985227108002,
0.031087854877114296,
-0.039821166545152664,
0.03985758498311043,
0.05755443871021271,
0.0000653310926281847,
0.010032586753368378,
0.021013062447309494,
0.05593062564730644,
-0.013973402790725231,
0.001151351723819971,
-0.04476787522435188,
0.007724711671471596,
0.009639040566980839,
0.021115632727742195,
-0.09647668153047562,
-0.01734089106321335,
-0.030268950387835503,
-0.022376062348484993,
-0.007936196401715279,
-0.020900432020425797,
0.006943941116333008,
0.002161967335268855,
-0.024617541581392288,
0.01634380780160427,
-0.0972476676106453,
0.07368787378072739,
-0.006513846572488546,
0.01428657490760088,
0.04019112139940262,
-0.005980823189020157,
0.030832013115286827,
0.07691851258277893,
-0.005915903020650148,
0.06297872215509415,
-0.010658013634383678,
0.0355585515499115,
0.011694465763866901,
0.03279716148972511,
-0.0366242378950119,
-0.03202442452311516,
0.030641334131360054,
0.06322702020406723,
-0.022537793964147568,
-0.006449159234762192,
0.010819045826792717,
0.050049249082803726,
0.022419381886720657,
0.021218135952949524,
0.0368528813123703,
0.006625089794397354,
0.013355215080082417,
0.009116078726947308,
0.02184363640844822,
-0.022480828687548637,
0.0394589826464653,
0.04318103939294815,
-0.027510760352015495,
-0.012968753464519978,
-0.039882514625787735,
-0.0022164287511259317,
0.014929254539310932,
0.021640101447701454,
0.005476066377013922,
-0.050582244992256165,
0.03876357525587082,
0.049824636429548264,
-0.023227520287036896,
-0.017390158027410507,
0.009520987048745155,
0.002320443280041218,
0.004132049158215523,
-0.008653981611132622,
-0.054441772401332855,
0.007752205245196819,
-0.021986545994877815,
-0.030602706596255302,
0.03631487488746643,
-0.024215983226895332,
-0.027116091921925545,
0.025285854935646057,
-0.06586684286594391,
-0.017105573788285255,
0.06951719522476196,
-0.04452928528189659,
-0.011671529151499271,
0.012084472924470901,
0.06419872492551804,
0.011680185794830322,
0.014352613128721714,
0.05626232549548149,
-0.07194186002016068,
0.01813134364783764,
-0.008362583816051483,
-0.04814056307077408,
0.018635276705026627,
0.0062561738304793835,
0.1186276450753212,
-0.015618863515555859,
0.006108235567808151,
0.01506899669766426,
-0.1359892189502716,
-0.036810215562582016,
0.055355679243803024,
0.023927750065922737,
0.07012872397899628,
-0.04080254212021828,
-0.024944696575403214,
0.04517444968223572,
0.05056189000606537,
0.03797982633113861,
0.02673213742673397,
0.01978408917784691,
0.04234993830323219,
-0.017511829733848572,
-0.01602095551788807,
-0.009542515501379967,
0.04600583016872406,
-0.04235341399908066,
-0.07435628026723862,
0.005048724357038736,
-0.019294628873467445,
0.010059179738163948,
0.015206065960228443,
-0.01205343846231699,
0.027175910770893097,
0.01322016492486,
0.008359258063137531,
0.009816383011639118,
0.02104899287223816,
-0.08060504496097565,
0.01898021064698696,
-0.018092947080731392,
-0.007023028563708067,
0.002375616692006588,
-0.03916148841381073,
0.06974554061889648,
0.07102203369140625,
-0.008810528554022312,
0.006233165040612221,
0.025089025497436523,
-0.004996817093342543,
-0.0391349196434021,
-0.01425156369805336,
-0.02925807237625122,
0.006605250295251608,
-0.013755058869719505,
-0.010735588148236275,
-0.027486111968755722,
0.03167431056499481,
-0.01383682619780302,
-0.02654181607067585,
0.07263288646936417,
-0.03667474538087845,
0.05708250775933266,
-0.007513911928981543,
-0.014982301741838455,
0.016080578789114952,
-0.01497939508408308,
-0.014367548748850822,
-0.028276352211833,
0.002194290980696678,
0.007620719727128744,
0.006062496453523636,
-0.05001536011695862,
-0.014935014769434929,
-0.07498010247945786,
0.004588260315358639,
0.025562159717082977,
0.040153078734874725,
0.03731933608651161,
0.011434853076934814,
0.017711900174617767,
0.003114130347967148,
-0.029257768765091896,
0.02931508608162403,
-0.10386829823255539,
-0.042862724512815475,
-0.01144895888864994,
0.0126807177439332,
-0.013975509442389011,
0.012435698881745338,
-0.0005081766867078841,
0.005645474418997765,
-0.01249344926327467,
-0.0062146796844899654,
0.007514441851526499,
0.0450952872633934,
-0.003097614273428917,
-0.05065004527568817,
-0.006435696966946125,
-0.005125695839524269,
0.02558007836341858,
-0.03614583984017372,
-0.010110738687217236,
-0.041537754237651825,
-0.0034832514356821775,
-0.007907488383352757,
-0.050731103867292404,
-0.01832069270312786,
0.015446538105607033,
-0.006543382536619902,
-0.00030717236222699285,
-0.015248419716954231,
0.030550416558980942,
0.02625516802072525,
0.01696111634373665,
0.038393307477235794,
-0.005520530045032501,
-0.006355059798806906,
0.03321469947695732,
-0.002165390644222498,
-0.0008322595967911184,
-0.01870359480381012,
0.04277438297867775,
-0.023016920313239098,
0.0036135821137577295,
-0.000928761379327625,
-0.00959939043968916,
-0.2824353873729706,
-0.012196465395390987,
0.00898102018982172,
-0.054951027035713196,
0.0271668191999197,
0.018488341942429543,
0.0332786962389946,
-0.0026754895225167274,
-0.009873474016785622,
0.020102301612496376,
0.004321037791669369,
0.03147387132048607,
0.013411696068942547,
0.055102959275245667,
0.039615992456674576,
0.07096584886312485,
0.015286851674318314,
-0.013323018327355385,
0.004617150407284498,
0.040690913796424866,
0.0030215391889214516,
-0.06653178483247757,
-0.022963134571909904,
0.019494149833917618,
-0.03933270275592804,
0.02962329052388668,
-0.09373816102743149,
0.03864748030900955,
-0.014683504588901997,
0.006094681099057198,
-0.007251454051584005,
-0.03983626142144203,
-0.029944544658064842,
0.03430749475955963,
-0.021250616759061813,
0.026423804461956024,
0.010814731940627098,
0.03516672924160957,
-0.000459937728010118,
0.009101321920752525,
0.017467297613620758,
-0.032557662576436996,
-0.024110306054353714,
-0.00790791679173708,
0.07724982500076294,
-0.00488739088177681,
-0.0417417548596859,
-0.014742492698132992,
-0.01821116730570793,
0.05823079124093056,
-0.02961026318371296,
-0.04638485610485077,
-0.013217180967330933,
0.01974250003695488,
-0.012172923423349857,
-0.05886648967862129,
-0.005712665617465973,
0.008783796802163124,
-0.027798905968666077,
0.05500299856066704,
0.0053464737720787525,
-0.036005135625600815,
-0.07076641917228699,
-0.0431755967438221,
-0.036666762083768845,
-0.045071303844451904,
-0.04901525005698204,
-0.06456008553504944,
0.043067485094070435,
0.031201621517539024,
-0.02978372946381569,
0.025801362469792366,
-0.015538569539785385,
-0.08797582238912582,
0.004314583260565996,
-0.027341388165950775,
-0.012786688283085823,
-0.038705747574567795,
0.006811558268964291,
0.04585253447294235,
-0.036496806889772415,
-0.04594388231635094,
0.013633247464895248,
0.001493720686994493,
0.0043827835470438,
-0.013115077279508114,
-0.01325018797069788,
-0.01630612276494503,
-0.051147155463695526,
-0.04322989657521248,
0.03986957669258118,
-0.03757398948073387,
-0.024732455611228943,
0.043841276317834854,
0.05807558447122574,
-0.013912447728216648,
0.023164156824350357,
0.07128738611936569,
0.03644358366727829,
0.038968250155448914,
0.003858705749735236,
-0.08193955570459366,
0.004407971166074276,
-0.060638025403022766,
-0.011318657547235489,
0.019856812432408333,
-0.049395572394132614,
-0.02759438194334507,
0.05664237216114998,
0.009113389998674393,
0.01088651642203331,
-0.006338374689221382,
0.005655820015817881,
-0.020163903012871742,
-0.03685734048485756,
-0.0059132748283445835,
-0.008587117306888103,
0.032956354320049286,
0.0300531554967165,
-0.0012040084693580866,
-0.00932003278285265,
-0.0017845199909061193,
-0.022527344524860382,
0.027886779978871346,
0.0012327777221798897,
0.007057201582938433,
-0.020680509507656097,
-0.005362961441278458,
0.005913862958550453,
-0.007316137198358774,
-0.012157793156802654,
0.0458841435611248,
0.02595428377389908,
0.008841883391141891,
0.021088510751724243,
-0.017301466315984726,
-0.0056962985545396805,
0.0009796185186132789,
0.028264913707971573,
-0.028046872466802597,
0.02066219411790371,
0.017760993912816048,
0.040449921041727066,
0.041822947561740875,
0.0414007268846035,
-0.0034405032638460398,
0.018539564684033394,
-0.02404717169702053,
0.03899456188082695,
-0.014695286750793457,
0.019457070156931877,
-0.06006603315472603,
0.03979198634624481,
-0.031475841999053955,
-0.014062507078051567,
-0.07077409327030182,
0.04835997149348259,
-0.0012409547343850136,
0.013648496009409428,
-0.0435543991625309,
0.03249891847372055,
-0.011552807874977589,
-0.03282961994409561,
0.029008246958255768,
0.027558250352740288,
0.03746875375509262,
-0.002116336952894926,
0.008874558843672276,
0.026626715436577797,
-0.008527994155883789,
-0.01827581599354744,
-0.015834836289286613,
-0.023441968485713005,
-0.02080395631492138,
-0.035064976662397385,
0.04162728413939476,
0.011185744777321815,
-0.031912583857774734,
-0.016324054449796677,
0.05015089735388756,
-0.00227191299200058,
-0.030333207920193672,
-0.004940872546285391,
0.014334301464259624,
0.06086568906903267,
-0.031506966799497604,
0.005467149894684553,
-0.0006265650154091418,
-0.0348835363984108,
-0.010579241439700127,
-0.02530229277908802,
0.014460613019764423,
-0.006697820965200663,
0.0245400108397007,
-0.041402436792850494,
-0.080057293176651,
0.01831604354083538,
0.016169892624020576,
0.03128984943032265,
0.007116942200809717,
-0.020104868337512016,
0.0025032886769622564,
-0.02474130131304264,
-0.014243748970329762,
0.03195793181657791,
-0.07778627425432205,
-0.008058609440922737,
0.02465159446001053,
0.021450424566864967,
0.04546257108449936,
-0.053822558373212814,
-0.0491105355322361,
-0.051782216876745224,
0.009449305944144726,
0.00628510070964694,
-0.03731231018900871,
-0.03133563697338104,
-0.017077453434467316,
-0.03498417139053345,
-0.027822045609354973,
-0.027321267873048782,
0.009999188594520092,
-0.008074793964624405,
-0.028171375393867493,
-0.0012935264967381954,
0.02326829917728901,
-0.04281381517648697,
-0.034482795745134354,
-0.0035355486907064915,
-0.027224188670516014,
0.031386490911245346,
-0.04834926500916481,
0.007568074855953455,
0.0051726712845265865,
0.04003505781292915,
0.012853243388235569,
-0.002830233657732606,
0.02490435354411602,
0.035487499088048935,
-0.008189370855689049,
-0.014753716066479683,
0.03680390119552612,
0.03887685015797615,
-0.0037893967237323523,
0.009041090495884418,
0.058229949325323105,
-0.011195724830031395,
0.02335379645228386,
0.004652782808989286,
0.024565020576119423,
0.014563561417162418,
0.03229981288313866,
-0.03379691764712334,
-0.028852472081780434,
0.09891421347856522,
-0.027746643871068954,
-0.02643231488764286,
-0.08239934593439102,
-0.06653553992509842,
0.023914659395813942,
0.01744212582707405,
0.012032624334096909,
-0.02186630293726921,
0.06449556350708008,
-0.0040150657296180725,
0.041476763784885406,
-0.007330120541155338,
-0.062713623046875,
0.033801592886447906,
-0.059805743396282196,
0.003670858684927225,
-0.06117682158946991,
0.01672614924609661,
0.054704148322343826,
-0.05341995134949684,
0.02095937728881836,
-0.0014554178342223167,
0.007113483268767595,
0.02340320684015751,
-0.007010186556726694,
-0.04803142696619034,
-0.004928498063236475,
-0.02563534677028656,
-0.006506770383566618,
0.03631497174501419,
-0.021596776321530342,
0.003415747545659542,
-0.0005886235740035772,
-0.038608767092227936,
-0.007549875881522894,
-0.0017386010149493814,
0.039499640464782715,
-0.022152597084641457,
0.048633377999067307,
-0.029119733721017838,
-0.0038202800787985325,
-0.008792661130428314,
0.034181851893663406,
0.02471776306629181,
0.041869375854730606,
-0.027477381750941277,
0.06310221552848816,
0.06513676792383194,
0.019687190651893616,
-0.0007472865981981158,
-0.011685822159051895,
-0.017291510477662086,
-0.030550001189112663,
0.03235858678817749,
0.010143732652068138,
0.00388030125759542,
-0.031266652047634125,
0.056111373007297516,
0.042990121990442276,
-0.045306187123060226,
-0.0022302386350929737,
0.001293111708946526,
-0.0661003589630127,
0.03704129531979561,
-0.02445126511156559,
0.001185746630653739,
-0.006897297687828541,
0.07979598641395569,
0.03297670558094978,
0.06549900025129318,
0.09348833560943604,
-0.02453083172440529,
-0.015611999668180943,
0.005743624176830053,
0.07493910193443298,
0.057254668325185776,
0.004084036219865084,
-0.008403719402849674,
0.05849316716194153,
-0.06180363520979881,
-0.033910416066646576,
0.010600391775369644,
0.000009980475624615792,
0.01628126949071884,
-0.04352739080786705,
0.035636574029922485,
0.06258928775787354,
0.013861346058547497,
0.04144405946135521,
-0.03735578805208206,
0.007342905271798372,
0.033548012375831604,
0.029036352410912514,
0.020524887368083,
0.02913658879697323,
0.02606113627552986,
0.0057529122568666935,
-0.04194488748908043,
0.015340125188231468,
-0.007683506701141596,
-0.03498712554574013,
0.01259151753038168,
0.055989671498537064,
0.009191129356622696,
0.005879511591047049,
-0.020106615498661995,
0.017878765240311623,
0.10055844485759735,
-0.023595787584781647,
-0.010626205243170261,
-0.01068215910345316,
0.0417916402220726,
0.0034183338284492493,
0.03746390715241432,
-0.0007422261987812817,
-0.04007712006568909,
0.010299485176801682,
-0.04698377847671509,
-0.011445953510701656,
0.02522946335375309,
-0.035402193665504456,
0.03886331990361214,
-0.020251357927918434,
-0.038744304329156876,
-0.004204533062875271,
0.004689838271588087,
-0.07593876123428345,
-0.010364778339862823,
-0.032069917768239975,
-0.02771948091685772,
-0.02625088207423687,
-0.02000449039041996,
0.02045261301100254,
0.020724596455693245,
-0.0429290235042572,
0.007650627754628658,
-0.04362162575125694,
-0.012921874411404133,
0.03224390000104904,
-0.054818522185087204,
0.004834530875086784,
0.03544182702898979,
-0.01925700530409813,
-0.0004535238549578935,
0.05655959993600845,
0.016858035698533058,
-0.023653334006667137,
-0.021938147023320198,
0.009968452155590057,
-0.0019031615229323506,
0.0030407248996198177,
-0.011024395003914833,
0.0028679566457867622,
-0.07941444218158722,
0.012628663331270218,
0.0287310890853405,
0.002619936829432845,
-0.0646466538310051,
0.030238673090934753,
-0.03849482536315918,
-0.011278397403657436,
0.058103252202272415,
-0.02511647157371044,
0.038679733872413635,
-0.016692982986569405,
-0.0178377702832222,
-0.025001103058457375,
0.04288612678647041,
0.007687884382903576,
-0.00435959966853261,
0.057866863906383514,
0.06856739521026611,
-0.008966591209173203,
-0.049738559871912,
0.06966672092676163,
-0.009715700522065163,
-0.029263535514473915,
-0.036806557327508926,
-0.004624514374881983,
-0.0399942584335804,
-0.07327913492918015,
0.008198573254048824,
0.01764838770031929,
0.00846930406987667,
-0.0035994285717606544,
-0.009770839475095272,
-0.0033356384374201298,
-0.031931355595588684,
-0.019449418410658836,
-0.026473967358469963,
0.01745041273534298,
-0.0568891204893589,
-0.055417366325855255,
-0.03372626751661301,
-0.0007836669683456421,
0.0012892152881249785,
-0.03150311857461929,
-0.01821240223944187,
-0.052712470293045044,
0.035797055810689926,
-0.004098113160580397,
0.04260353744029999,
-0.00310304737649858,
0.026989014819264412,
-0.026542294770479202
] |
337 |
Wavelet-based Positional Representation for Long Context
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=OhauMUNW8T
|
[
"Yui Oka",
"Taku Hasegawa",
"Kyosuke Nishida",
"Kuniko Saito"
] |
Poster
|
In the realm of large-scale language models, a significant challenge arises when extrapolating sequences beyond the maximum allowable length.
This is because the model's position embedding mechanisms are limited to positions encountered during training, thus preventing effective representation of positions in longer sequences.
We analyzed conventional position encoding methods for long contexts and found the following characteristics.
(1) When the representation dimension is regarded as the time axis, Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE) can be interpreted as a restricted wavelet transform using Haar-like wavelets.
However, because it uses only a fixed scale parameter, it does not fully exploit the advantages of wavelet transforms, which capture the fine movements of non-stationary signals using multiple scales (window sizes).
This limitation could explain why RoPE performs poorly in extrapolation.
(2)
Previous research as well as our own analysis indicates that Attention with Linear Biases (ALiBi) functions similarly to windowed attention, using windows of varying sizes.
However, it has limitations in capturing deep dependencies because it restricts the receptive field of the model.
From these insights, we propose a new position representation method that captures multiple scales (i.e., window sizes) by leveraging wavelet transforms without limiting the model's attention field.
Experimental results show that this new method improves the performance of the model in both short and long contexts.
In particular, our method allows extrapolation of position information without limiting the model's attention field.
|
Positional Encoding, Extrapolation, Wavelet Transform, Transformers, RoPE, ALiBi, NLP
|
We found that RoPE can be interpreted as a restricted wavelet transform. And we propose a new position representation method that captures window sizes by leveraging wavelet transforms without limiting the model's attention field.
| 13,404 |
2502.02004
|
[
-0.04071628674864769,
-0.004029474221169949,
0.01609681360423565,
0.010170125402510166,
0.03105759620666504,
0.03707645460963249,
0.03363437205553055,
-0.0013636288931593299,
-0.056159134954214096,
-0.04062742739915848,
-0.04153625667095184,
0.005626941565424204,
-0.04032203182578087,
-0.005498155951499939,
0.007784758694469929,
0.056797709316015244,
0.04118701070547104,
-0.03394562378525734,
-0.027776800096035004,
-0.00997002050280571,
-0.007494187448173761,
-0.024455063045024872,
0.011213275603950024,
-0.006057523190975189,
0.021206600591540337,
-0.0023327097296714783,
-0.03182390332221985,
0.008909069001674652,
-0.03657473623752594,
-0.019353633746504784,
0.023034540936350822,
-0.0042707426473498344,
-0.01039076503366232,
-0.017016971483826637,
0.013486837968230247,
-0.024215316399931908,
-0.05931863188743591,
0.023258360102772713,
0.00870283879339695,
-0.010366527363657951,
-0.036306969821453094,
-0.010345641523599625,
-0.012986487708985806,
0.007099214009940624,
-0.0656353086233139,
-0.006442059297114611,
-0.11236893385648727,
0.030894959345459938,
-0.0006355032091960311,
-0.010527044534683228,
-0.10853300243616104,
0.06514100730419159,
-0.004561427049338818,
-0.027610959485173225,
0.02120482362806797,
0.010978984646499157,
0.02953457273542881,
-0.07956468313932419,
0.002150990068912506,
-0.05463749170303345,
-0.017039187252521515,
-0.007791695650666952,
0.03207746893167496,
0.011939816176891327,
-0.00590554578229785,
-0.049330491572618484,
-0.00790522713214159,
0.023571327328681946,
-0.057836100459098816,
-0.04255758970975876,
-0.009519684128463268,
-0.0032510212622582912,
-0.014712192118167877,
0.003584320656955242,
-0.004680728539824486,
-0.053839702159166336,
0.017595559358596802,
0.03793859854340553,
0.06482607871294022,
0.01761258766055107,
0.03709650784730911,
0.03555073216557503,
0.02702774666249752,
0.021911658346652985,
-0.007820088416337967,
0.04526470974087715,
-0.00650933338329196,
-0.05071860924363136,
-0.061634913086891174,
0.03203439712524414,
-0.0050047049298882484,
-0.05125594139099121,
-0.019130535423755646,
0.03210976719856262,
-0.009724580682814121,
0.01859755627810955,
0.01613888517022133,
0.015592201612889767,
0.011589383706450462,
0.030909890308976173,
-0.03242886811494827,
-0.019680526107549667,
0.039563123136758804,
-0.0005097304820083082,
-0.0897531658411026,
-0.028933139517903328,
-0.004539945628494024,
0.013896691612899303,
0.011380068026483059,
0.0018414282239973545,
-0.06130369380116463,
-0.005608758423477411,
0.027568910270929337,
-0.02613499015569687,
-0.07392328977584839,
-0.002209919737651944,
0.009028826840221882,
0.04124286398291588,
-0.031463686376810074,
0.002957221819087863,
0.07200900465250015,
0.03170296922326088,
-0.0034606822300702333,
0.07520053535699844,
-0.010400400497019291,
0.01018166821449995,
-0.008915145881474018,
0.03577005863189697,
-0.038613297045230865,
-0.03870655223727226,
0.015266858972609043,
0.017889074981212616,
-0.003073655068874359,
0.013190386816859245,
0.010148623958230019,
-0.008134648203849792,
0.0016389733646064997,
-0.012334254570305347,
0.04939038306474686,
-0.017737166956067085,
0.026854854077100754,
-0.03068285994231701,
0.04257867485284805,
-0.04910412058234215,
0.07993707060813904,
-0.0016658707754686475,
-0.05502532422542572,
-0.011968042701482773,
-0.023120224475860596,
-0.02570325694978237,
0.0012704720720648766,
-0.005696247331798077,
0.030498795211315155,
-0.0658903419971466,
0.009672108106315136,
0.05553120747208595,
-0.002253467682749033,
0.029743611812591553,
0.04140652343630791,
-0.010415656492114067,
-0.00013026972010266036,
-0.024736547842621803,
-0.03105156123638153,
0.052662212401628494,
-0.003143880283460021,
-0.05397820100188255,
0.03963138163089752,
0.022814631462097168,
-0.032299842685461044,
0.01973697356879711,
-0.01828126050531864,
-0.0003259509976487607,
0.0709042102098465,
-0.014305385760962963,
-0.04333322122693062,
0.00043694325722754,
0.04217918962240219,
-0.00029495946364477277,
0.041655004024505615,
0.014395873062312603,
-0.0779021829366684,
0.028846748173236847,
0.037209317088127136,
-0.01672794111073017,
0.036162372678518295,
-0.02781973034143448,
0.11675187945365906,
-0.018259167671203613,
-0.02896948531270027,
-0.004134426824748516,
-0.051531631499528885,
-0.022175651043653488,
0.013532700017094612,
-0.016033031046390533,
0.059204816818237305,
-0.012888489291071892,
-0.013043285347521305,
0.03451811894774437,
0.03716466948390007,
0.03337448462843895,
0.04881604015827179,
-0.017422344535589218,
0.04624394699931145,
0.027400119230151176,
-0.005376181099563837,
-0.0225529782474041,
0.03621154651045799,
-0.05546826869249344,
-0.01500101387500763,
0.019596293568611145,
-0.013191415928304195,
0.013504935428500175,
0.0025120030622929335,
0.032236646860837936,
-0.02719166874885559,
0.02088748849928379,
0.027711955830454826,
-0.010182993486523628,
0.0013824992347508669,
-0.05068223550915718,
0.01635545864701271,
0.008755452930927277,
-0.04751630872488022,
-0.020490635186433792,
-0.03889179229736328,
0.09413863718509674,
0.05989520996809006,
-0.01646522246301174,
-0.016169898211956024,
-0.004353528376668692,
0.010911839082837105,
-0.013568931259214878,
0.02959676831960678,
-0.012974686920642853,
-0.008500061929225922,
-0.025696847587823868,
0.0037703521084040403,
-0.03267376124858856,
0.036625057458877563,
-0.06630752235651016,
0.014465603977441788,
0.07456683367490768,
-0.001158794853836298,
0.041541844606399536,
-0.004951760172843933,
-0.010916792787611485,
0.0795736312866211,
0.006403761450201273,
-0.023917850106954575,
-0.018819699063897133,
-0.016136277467012405,
0.004173282999545336,
-0.009341659024357796,
-0.032582614570856094,
0.012853062711656094,
-0.021383395418524742,
-0.0368388332426548,
-0.016899744048714638,
0.0667140781879425,
0.05053111910820007,
0.06923192739486694,
0.05076723173260689,
0.014054525643587112,
-0.04708116129040718,
-0.032257623970508575,
-0.09784838557243347,
-0.04888002574443817,
-0.05219472199678421,
0.05001130327582359,
0.0013220260152593255,
0.049337808042764664,
0.0017609281931072474,
0.0175845418125391,
-0.031218454241752625,
-0.004180504009127617,
-0.0492129810154438,
0.029206054285168648,
-0.0017272804398089647,
-0.027126213535666466,
0.0031755990348756313,
0.006439190823584795,
0.057073112577199936,
0.020880918949842453,
-0.046425361186265945,
0.003555831965059042,
-0.02151951752603054,
-0.03518281131982803,
0.012064115144312382,
0.0009152891580015421,
0.010599100030958652,
-0.005064802709966898,
0.017195822671055794,
-0.008127858862280846,
0.02801620215177536,
0.008724210783839226,
0.059203822165727615,
0.06753617525100708,
-0.0029626397881656885,
-0.025687914341688156,
-0.004133195150643587,
-0.014644482173025608,
0.03530450165271759,
0.026127250865101814,
-0.02431565709412098,
0.0026499275118112564,
0.019828377291560173,
-0.0035454987082630396,
0.0060774595476686954,
-0.28358331322669983,
-0.013319402933120728,
-0.0036329044960439205,
-0.04837878793478012,
0.018670884892344475,
-0.035754237323999405,
0.05272504314780235,
-0.05353149399161339,
-0.04802578315138817,
0.010287449695169926,
0.014397895894944668,
0.011512531898915768,
0.012228399515151978,
0.03489819914102554,
0.02173486538231373,
0.0196473840624094,
-0.012080338783562183,
-0.000045891505578765646,
0.011327954940497875,
0.03200536221265793,
0.0021867197938263416,
-0.05556349456310272,
-0.013003136962652206,
0.06866137683391571,
-0.019016966223716736,
0.06744271516799927,
-0.07036309689283371,
0.01675921306014061,
-0.04230273514986038,
-0.022476626560091972,
-0.014804176054894924,
-0.01991821452975273,
0.008513184264302254,
0.032863255590200424,
-0.01263582706451416,
-0.005805652588605881,
0.0385454036295414,
0.012980894185602665,
0.01863538846373558,
-0.000012516026799858082,
0.00022174308833200485,
-0.041300516575574875,
-0.0016918755136430264,
0.01190728135406971,
0.06446033716201782,
0.010422303341329098,
-0.06057610735297203,
0.0029587370809167624,
-0.010762977413833141,
0.029975945129990578,
-0.011206703260540962,
-0.02737039513885975,
-0.002932723378762603,
-0.00682541960850358,
0.0021267333067953587,
-0.03433220088481903,
-0.0034894247073680162,
-0.029943156987428665,
-0.000496005523018539,
-0.011289950460195541,
0.0190157238394022,
-0.05273246020078659,
-0.024464258924126625,
-0.06346767395734787,
0.0016633878694847226,
-0.02758636325597763,
-0.06132492423057556,
-0.05994081869721413,
0.029376931488513947,
-0.01954444870352745,
-0.03536197170615196,
0.027454445138573647,
-0.015770303085446358,
-0.09572577476501465,
0.01826987974345684,
-0.00945574976503849,
0.01045630406588316,
-0.04814128950238228,
-0.010596384294331074,
0.04797610267996788,
-0.03749467059969902,
-0.06927112489938736,
0.016267210245132446,
0.024217849597334862,
0.02391071431338787,
-0.015243462286889553,
-0.014241494238376617,
-0.0537654310464859,
0.0042262207716703415,
-0.022461816668510437,
0.050347600132226944,
-0.005966848693788052,
0.009070380590856075,
0.04218507558107376,
0.04265144467353821,
0.037332601845264435,
0.023508822545409203,
0.02036445401608944,
0.027572685852646828,
-0.014709568582475185,
0.035199906677007675,
-0.06201761215925217,
-0.0038119724486023188,
-0.0232631117105484,
0.0003687687567435205,
0.058004364371299744,
-0.03400687128305435,
-0.003757847473025322,
0.03142723813652992,
0.016523199155926704,
-0.031066346913576126,
-0.008627250790596008,
0.003072533756494522,
-0.0072092171758413315,
-0.016463231295347214,
-0.018763914704322815,
0.01448332890868187,
0.03209421783685684,
0.020056957378983498,
-0.04682204872369766,
0.008002182468771935,
0.018654104322195053,
-0.03186636045575142,
0.007811825256794691,
0.0013820664025843143,
-0.005658732261508703,
-0.012659411877393723,
-0.0352075919508934,
-0.020322907716035843,
-0.017764471471309662,
0.04421088099479675,
0.037742383778095245,
0.022958699613809586,
0.0527166947722435,
0.07016311585903168,
0.007346943020820618,
-0.00043033852125518024,
0.0007306748302653432,
0.05432561784982681,
-0.01481375377625227,
-0.01201503537595272,
-0.008037322200834751,
0.006681485567241907,
0.04765453562140465,
-0.0035744463093578815,
0.002312665106728673,
0.02377297915518284,
-0.029565272852778435,
-0.020051447674632072,
-0.010473891161382198,
0.03803329914808273,
-0.027407944202423096,
-0.052058298140764236,
-0.013542384840548038,
-0.008345291018486023,
-0.008711390197277069,
0.0031129438430070877,
0.02407471463084221,
0.0014085763832554221,
-0.07451409101486206,
0.06125481799244881,
0.021906225010752678,
-0.014081889763474464,
-0.0005139326094649732,
0.010265442542731762,
0.0101272938773036,
-0.00952945090830326,
0.023980582132935524,
0.043742381036281586,
0.014260822907090187,
0.024683574214577675,
-0.0038957451470196247,
-0.027316438034176826,
-0.008858649991452694,
-0.006441748235374689,
0.009233293123543262,
-0.004534375853836536,
0.03200891241431236,
-0.048475585877895355,
0.05166717991232872,
0.05189845710992813,
0.024441203102469444,
0.005817883647978306,
0.036686286330223083,
0.05910049006342888,
0.012511960230767727,
-0.012224876321852207,
-0.01927226409316063,
-0.04238070547580719,
0.03150760382413864,
-0.0029521696269512177,
0.016917288303375244,
-0.042588841170072556,
-0.027972713112831116,
-0.03948948532342911,
-0.023282762616872787,
-0.006597437430173159,
0.029989318922162056,
-0.019108876585960388,
-0.002589937997981906,
-0.014249398373067379,
0.0028149958234280348,
-0.0286213718354702,
-0.01668495312333107,
0.010478589683771133,
-0.06139804422855377,
0.028871268033981323,
0.029305163770914078,
-0.03968369588255882,
0.03082852251827717,
-0.039300501346588135,
-0.02347414568066597,
-0.05752589553594589,
-0.0167197585105896,
-0.0005946593009866774,
-0.019113732501864433,
0.02859436720609665,
-0.08082365244626999,
-0.024215051904320717,
-0.030745811760425568,
0.06866155564785004,
0.003598251147195697,
-0.018686112016439438,
-0.0017292073462158442,
0.021498799324035645,
0.05546238273382187,
-0.027592288330197334,
0.024963796138763428,
0.048926085233688354,
-0.018219146877527237,
0.012726497836411,
-0.019250528886914253,
0.035403672605752945,
0.08591950684785843,
-0.0409417524933815,
-0.02034611627459526,
-0.058791711926460266,
0.02697058580815792,
0.01835065335035324,
0.027888409793376923,
0.03309537097811699,
0.01606077514588833,
-0.01519425492733717,
0.04310476407408714,
0.03990586847066879,
0.05665551498532295,
0.0013671882916241884,
-0.03860703855752945,
-0.015374748967587948,
0.04165511950850487,
0.03866518288850784,
0.013726256787776947,
-0.03138947859406471,
-0.016346227377653122,
0.0487433485686779,
-0.01553124189376831,
-0.05449509993195534,
-0.05857137590646744,
-0.03214368224143982,
0.02352129854261875,
0.008363233879208565,
0.03718973696231842,
-0.026813682168722153,
0.03727678582072258,
0.058924414217472076,
0.053950514644384384,
-0.003150841686874628,
-0.031109876930713654,
0.03192409873008728,
-0.03677136078476906,
0.013160827569663525,
-0.04572543874382973,
-0.026645727455615997,
0.061989400535821915,
-0.0010644745780155063,
0.0063525112345814705,
0.0018986138748005033,
-0.05300605669617653,
0.05419497564435005,
-0.030010312795639038,
-0.038105908781290054,
0.044451192021369934,
-0.020153319463133812,
-0.023559316992759705,
0.010975876823067665,
-0.028267310932278633,
0.010695848613977432,
-0.0336744524538517,
-0.047804251313209534,
-0.023346221074461937,
-0.022869208827614784,
0.05214777961373329,
-0.04441310465335846,
0.02744377590715885,
-0.05483272299170494,
0.013425169512629509,
0.017871789634227753,
0.08276893198490143,
0.005399021785706282,
0.017797084525227547,
-0.026388369500637054,
0.06958728283643723,
0.03160203993320465,
-0.02932926081120968,
-0.00935843214392662,
-0.03200707212090492,
0.006143257487565279,
-0.08051914721727371,
0.04571574926376343,
0.012593832798302174,
-0.029961207881569862,
-0.053892429918050766,
0.0608077347278595,
0.03258105739951134,
-0.013623888604342937,
-0.010713898576796055,
0.048875074833631516,
-0.011201449669897556,
0.0015407948521897197,
0.00909633468836546,
0.0015208995901048183,
-0.01604810170829296,
0.05263539031147957,
0.01598283089697361,
0.0589858703315258,
0.07968206703662872,
-0.02380681037902832,
0.009577303193509579,
0.0006803340511396527,
0.055788975208997726,
0.04990611970424652,
0.06114661693572998,
0.006096715573221445,
0.057372257113456726,
-0.040107760578393936,
-0.04720919206738472,
0.04250321164727211,
0.04086172580718994,
0.02353261597454548,
-0.05203711986541748,
-0.019448429346084595,
0.0658034011721611,
-0.01064348965883255,
0.09220771491527557,
-0.04256967455148697,
-0.016098685562610626,
0.0072052753530442715,
-0.0015884913736954331,
0.004272793419659138,
0.018946049734950066,
0.04447295889258385,
0.006630640476942062,
-0.03173369914293289,
-0.01351238414645195,
0.03767503425478935,
-0.03177173435688019,
0.0314117968082428,
0.025668373331427574,
0.0023685963824391365,
0.0041863988153636456,
-0.022091656923294067,
0.08096524327993393,
0.1025623232126236,
-0.027861759066581726,
-0.02929244004189968,
-0.0029930653981864452,
0.04044729098677635,
0.012824023142457008,
0.0534709170460701,
-0.017258454114198685,
0.018208961933851242,
0.013314067386090755,
-0.057691313326358795,
0.024308092892169952,
0.01372830756008625,
-0.012237794697284698,
0.005441287066787481,
-0.046802327036857605,
-0.04760860651731491,
0.0010770960943773389,
-0.012949958443641663,
-0.06517914682626724,
-0.05059683322906494,
-0.022142192348837852,
-0.06099414452910423,
-0.06918405741453171,
-0.04943385720252991,
0.0004419923643581569,
-0.0044859712943434715,
-0.029256349429488182,
-0.05468573421239853,
-0.048067912459373474,
0.01778370887041092,
-0.010507026687264442,
-0.03286634013056755,
0.024298375472426414,
0.04054820165038109,
0.004580733831971884,
-0.00808569137006998,
0.054644059389829636,
0.02968810684978962,
-0.029764583334326744,
-0.0012215821770951152,
0.0313306488096714,
0.02469514310359955,
0.025648484006524086,
-0.008781022392213345,
-0.04070926085114479,
-0.09156227111816406,
-0.003133172867819667,
0.01745213381946087,
0.0009718923829495907,
-0.08183092623949051,
0.014237900264561176,
-0.034391798079013824,
0.02962394617497921,
0.05363816022872925,
-0.05370248109102249,
0.041469473391771317,
-0.01360366865992546,
-0.006099261809140444,
0.0008326581446453929,
-0.012833583168685436,
0.055682163685560226,
-0.018091943114995956,
0.04504607617855072,
0.039416827261447906,
0.005663090385496616,
-0.047240130603313446,
0.0038027819246053696,
-0.022112809121608734,
0.027256987988948822,
-0.040883202105760574,
-0.0435902401804924,
-0.043554116040468216,
-0.07061542570590973,
-0.027113452553749084,
0.019806990399956703,
0.018982281908392906,
-0.04300486296415329,
0.00807543657720089,
-0.0005760829662904143,
-0.02126997895538807,
-0.02060520648956299,
-0.010364996269345284,
-0.002777980174869299,
-0.022439753636717796,
-0.02104436606168747,
-0.042334992438554764,
0.0403578095138073,
0.004216782283037901,
-0.0011702190386131406,
-0.006840321701020002,
-0.01585112139582634,
0.031511832028627396,
0.014884591102600098,
-0.01372706238180399,
0.02690603770315647,
0.02857217937707901,
-0.03247002139687538
] |
338 |
LiveCodeBench: Holistic and Contamination Free Evaluation of Large Language Models for Code
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=chfJJYC3iL
|
[
"Naman Jain",
"King Han",
"Alex Gu",
"Wen-Ding Li",
"Fanjia Yan",
"Tianjun Zhang",
"Sida Wang",
"Armando Solar-Lezama",
"Koushik Sen",
"Ion Stoica"
] |
Poster
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) applied to code-related applications have emerged as a prominent field, attracting significant interest from academia and industry. However, as new and improved LLMs are developed, existing evaluation benchmarks (e.g., HumanEvla, MBPP) are no longer sufficient for assessing their capabilities suffering from data contamination, overfitting, saturation, and focus on merely code generation. In this work, we propose LiveCodeBench, a comprehensive and contamination-free evaluation of LLMs for code, which collects new problems over time from contests across three competition platforms, Leetcode, Atcoder, and Codeforces. Notably, our benchmark also focuses on a broader range of code-related capabilities, such as self-repair, code execution, and test output prediction, beyond just code generation. Currently, LiveCodeBench hosts over six hundred coding problems that were published between May 2023 and Aug 2024. We evaluate over 50 LLMs on LiveCodeBench (LCB for brevity) presenting the largest evaluation study of code LLMs on competition problems. Based on the study, we present novel empirical findings on contamination, overfitting, and holistic evaluations. We demonstrate that time-segmented evaluations serve as a robust approach to evade contamination; they are successful at detecting contamination across a wide range of open and closed models including GPT-4O, Claude, Deepseek, and Codestral. Next, we highlight overfitting and saturation of traditional coding benchmarks like HumanEvla and demonstrate LCB allows more reliable evaluations. Finally, our holistic evaluation scenarios allow for measuring the different capabilities of programming agents in isolation.
|
Code LLMs; Evaluation; Contaminationl; Overfitting
|
We build evaluation of code LLMs on new problems highlighting challenges like contamination and overfitting
| 13,402 |
2403.07974
|
[
0.005137496627867222,
-0.006309365388005972,
-0.03368401899933815,
0.015292814001441002,
0.04004005342721939,
0.020919358357787132,
0.0039003323763608932,
0.020073682069778442,
-0.03179624676704407,
-0.011198241263628006,
-0.02287776581943035,
-0.008600975386798382,
-0.08399277925491333,
-0.010664120316505432,
-0.01415053941309452,
0.05149029940366745,
0.04307910427451134,
-0.02096611075103283,
0.05132153630256653,
0.036171071231365204,
0.011720264330506325,
-0.0082427728921175,
0.004346500616520643,
0.012558793649077415,
0.0005697024753317237,
0.05429723486304283,
0.024279475212097168,
0.012161526829004288,
-0.06463764607906342,
-0.001587134669534862,
0.06683148443698883,
-0.0011333482107147574,
0.05711613595485687,
-0.019434021785855293,
0.011403878219425678,
0.022698113694787025,
-0.07120127975940704,
0.05175962671637535,
-0.002634843112900853,
0.005346481688320637,
-0.011891120113432407,
0.03057793341577053,
0.0026046407874673605,
0.04257431998848915,
-0.05396934971213341,
0.038310542702674866,
-0.09882442653179169,
0.043295565992593765,
-0.0008313230937346816,
-0.012017526663839817,
-0.08923330903053284,
0.001936336513608694,
-0.013348179869353771,
-0.003070656443014741,
0.012490029446780682,
0.029316483065485954,
0.07483384758234024,
-0.09450535476207733,
-0.02722853235900402,
-0.04129423201084137,
-0.025734372437000275,
-0.011605114676058292,
0.02206433191895485,
0.010571173392236233,
0.01892518438398838,
0.00007969004946062341,
0.02670310251414776,
0.005529750604182482,
-0.06987476348876953,
-0.02488088794052601,
0.008378461003303528,
0.011224247515201569,
-0.056549109518527985,
-0.016851935535669327,
-0.005820854101330042,
-0.0515521802008152,
-0.007491375785320997,
0.06647712737321854,
0.061567600816488266,
0.024495679885149002,
0.028319427743554115,
0.012523665092885494,
0.009605418890714645,
0.03131229430437088,
0.025685137137770653,
0.024067677557468414,
-0.02432163991034031,
-0.041018106043338776,
-0.054617200046777725,
0.0249450895935297,
0.020456818863749504,
-0.029607530683279037,
0.03813339024782181,
0.028329716995358467,
0.025569157674908638,
0.025904536247253418,
0.019164664670825005,
0.03969473019242287,
-0.005162213928997517,
0.0023028196301311255,
-0.051375336945056915,
-0.014674197882413864,
0.005825940053910017,
-0.007379073649644852,
-0.0779101774096489,
0.002013919875025749,
-0.03886319324374199,
-0.033518362790346146,
-0.022533932700753212,
-0.029671451076865196,
-0.0009040863369591534,
-0.011732462793588638,
0.00409734109416604,
-0.029507508501410484,
-0.09049908071756363,
0.05503896623849869,
-0.0321623757481575,
0.005057082045823336,
0.025205159559845924,
0.004482327029109001,
0.05882128328084946,
0.06420295685529709,
-0.00033981041633524,
0.0954393669962883,
0.006425340659916401,
0.02414129488170147,
0.0371830090880394,
0.008803834207355976,
-0.013949460349977016,
-0.037905797362327576,
0.006579210516065359,
0.031591854989528656,
0.0006178365438245237,
-0.00642063794657588,
-0.006790475454181433,
0.03500181809067726,
0.025005949661135674,
0.015623297542333603,
0.02391342632472515,
0.025681424885988235,
0.0062892562709748745,
-0.03625078126788139,
0.08242584764957428,
-0.04576713964343071,
0.03797000274062157,
0.00003006735823873896,
-0.03456420451402664,
-0.016708500683307648,
-0.02717255987226963,
0.0023740010801702738,
0.012464756146073341,
0.0410810150206089,
-0.020653143525123596,
-0.06195073574781418,
0.026895562186837196,
0.05033522844314575,
-0.003141340333968401,
-0.002917611738666892,
-0.0035003379452973604,
-0.0061448910273611546,
0.0004256208485458046,
0.01361620333045721,
-0.06449446827173233,
0.01700829342007637,
-0.011192717589437962,
-0.028815772384405136,
0.03122807666659355,
-0.015606443397700787,
-0.039368387311697006,
-0.005285888910293579,
-0.039401642978191376,
-0.020933428779244423,
0.08348214626312256,
-0.012637652456760406,
-0.019112398847937584,
-0.013367517851293087,
0.05433784797787666,
0.0006358719547279179,
0.014993150718510151,
0.0380873903632164,
-0.06713253259658813,
0.013862162828445435,
0.006441025994718075,
-0.019578294828534126,
0.011304347775876522,
-0.014318924397230148,
0.11569662392139435,
-0.0467740073800087,
-0.008888471871614456,
0.015452120453119278,
-0.09301762282848358,
-0.009197324514389038,
0.017222942784428596,
0.019160190597176552,
0.0626399964094162,
-0.02594064362347126,
-0.00694248965010047,
0.029884127900004387,
0.022536909207701683,
0.03387586772441864,
0.02644309587776661,
0.021222254261374474,
0.0245426706969738,
-0.02406211942434311,
-0.03104303777217865,
0.0029473165050148964,
0.059002835303545,
-0.06893769651651382,
-0.07790935784578323,
-0.0013997395290061831,
-0.007262158673256636,
0.012921933084726334,
0.020158803090453148,
-0.0003548261593095958,
0.006794659420847893,
-0.004730117041617632,
0.0037830900400877,
-0.006408548913896084,
0.034090496599674225,
-0.07078253477811813,
0.030542995780706406,
0.019825290888547897,
-0.02633611299097538,
-0.014433801174163818,
-0.022962257266044617,
0.07704643160104752,
0.0631893053650856,
-0.04060974344611168,
0.0030979777220636606,
0.025432346388697624,
0.008555267937481403,
-0.01274039689451456,
-0.013634360395371914,
-0.06450788676738739,
0.012868455611169338,
-0.047371771186590195,
0.00820480939000845,
-0.016383811831474304,
0.04899340867996216,
-0.017048008739948273,
0.007829018868505955,
0.053274501115083694,
-0.01896447129547596,
0.02846076339483261,
-0.017935412004590034,
-0.017245441675186157,
0.0362732820212841,
-0.006359596736729145,
-0.027669845148921013,
-0.022303026169538498,
0.0066290730610489845,
0.0010079118655994534,
0.03108261339366436,
-0.03941589966416359,
-0.009232282638549805,
-0.06260422617197037,
-0.038697678595781326,
-0.023532738909125328,
0.03153107687830925,
0.04736686125397682,
0.012132437899708748,
-0.007417366839945316,
-0.007870853878557682,
-0.04797878488898277,
0.0024623170029371977,
-0.08719851821660995,
-0.037251267582178116,
0.009962828829884529,
0.019891789183020592,
-0.009357225149869919,
0.021831806749105453,
0.006855915300548077,
-0.019853828474879265,
-0.03823063150048256,
0.0063507407903671265,
0.013487674295902252,
0.049838513135910034,
-0.016734013333916664,
-0.06246371567249298,
-0.03210526704788208,
0.007146085612475872,
0.03375525400042534,
-0.03115006536245346,
-0.036526888608932495,
-0.03135572001338005,
-0.0007035062881186604,
0.002567133167758584,
-0.05365358665585518,
-0.0031627302523702383,
0.023537181317806244,
0.028750309720635414,
0.029928850010037422,
-0.0859885886311531,
0.010323541238904,
0.07786532491445541,
0.025655163452029228,
0.03427231311798096,
0.014662005938589573,
-0.03046327270567417,
0.036600563675165176,
0.037205833941698074,
0.020470989868044853,
-0.026246661320328712,
0.010617868043482304,
-0.034129947423934937,
0.007311548106372356,
0.012737080454826355,
-0.019397852942347527,
-0.2640189826488495,
0.0031447780784219503,
-0.006054003722965717,
-0.0483328141272068,
0.03683542087674141,
0.018832977861166,
0.024232173338532448,
-0.03348958492279053,
-0.01664784550666809,
0.00006739617674611509,
0.0018023926531895995,
0.014029286801815033,
0.012079967185854912,
0.06023228168487549,
0.034323737025260925,
0.04479262977838516,
-0.016642510890960693,
-0.03884116932749748,
-0.011646251194179058,
0.03853185102343559,
0.0030267999973148108,
-0.06829304993152618,
0.013799472711980343,
0.005607139319181442,
-0.008816715329885483,
0.033307407051324844,
-0.09697296470403671,
0.026684116572141647,
-0.023789476603269577,
-0.015619279816746712,
-0.027471555396914482,
-0.017329582944512367,
-0.02752440795302391,
0.010783380828797817,
-0.012466797605156898,
0.024368634447455406,
0.04004013165831566,
-0.004938222002238035,
0.01456736121326685,
0.030131176114082336,
0.012468874454498291,
-0.024854473769664764,
-0.051722511649131775,
-0.010087333619594574,
0.08121839910745621,
0.017701374366879463,
-0.05640682205557823,
-0.039899442344903946,
-0.01094756554812193,
0.04032139852643013,
-0.02117825113236904,
-0.018156876787543297,
-0.0059500569477677345,
0.033382710069417953,
-0.019892005249857903,
-0.022139810025691986,
-0.04079308733344078,
-0.006838079541921616,
-0.02656102180480957,
0.03755626454949379,
-0.01978357695043087,
-0.053957607597112656,
-0.03555937483906746,
-0.01660447008907795,
-0.014157624915242195,
-0.04551943764090538,
-0.04617641121149063,
-0.04871087148785591,
0.054664287716150284,
0.02434096485376358,
0.006281683687120676,
0.0026880695950239897,
-0.001654094085097313,
-0.1040424183011055,
-0.0009908699430525303,
-0.005840251222252846,
-0.0146353580057621,
-0.044651541858911514,
0.03212368115782738,
0.055048227310180664,
-0.039765216410160065,
-0.04030558094382286,
0.02033139020204544,
-0.0028539306949824095,
0.018723566085100174,
-0.048650458455085754,
-0.005861181300133467,
-0.029651537537574768,
-0.03783993050456047,
-0.051155995577573776,
0.06033075228333473,
-0.00025375766563229263,
-0.004879394080489874,
0.0014867386780679226,
0.04854584485292435,
0.02537771500647068,
0.032133542001247406,
0.03417463228106499,
0.01729441061615944,
0.04914999008178711,
0.012703738175332546,
-0.06035558879375458,
0.01158116478472948,
-0.05904848873615265,
0.009197128936648369,
0.024871399626135826,
-0.055454596877098083,
-0.017319926992058754,
0.03423180431127548,
0.029718484729528427,
0.003122687805444002,
-0.016502410173416138,
0.005217424593865871,
-0.02333945967257023,
-0.008075122721493244,
-0.022694382816553116,
0.028100693598389626,
0.013631420210003853,
0.01915193721652031,
-0.029927343130111694,
-0.03532351925969124,
0.022411424666643143,
-0.011388527229428291,
0.03316715732216835,
-0.021137457340955734,
-0.033988211303949356,
-0.014381478540599346,
0.008517591282725334,
-0.005578516982495785,
0.011823673732578754,
0.000713878485839814,
0.06702922284603119,
-0.001756613259203732,
-0.02040780521929264,
0.06726756691932678,
0.0004938893835060298,
-0.003992042969912291,
-0.0011908215237781405,
0.02281365357339382,
-0.025881577283143997,
0.027430448681116104,
-0.01278374157845974,
0.017925389111042023,
0.0194203220307827,
0.021712956950068474,
-0.0028571237344294786,
0.057548440992832184,
-0.011371237225830555,
-0.007143267896026373,
-0.008343267254531384,
0.03286898508667946,
-0.08392594009637833,
0.01728086546063423,
-0.03316006064414978,
0.0011040375102311373,
-0.031615883111953735,
0.009530859999358654,
0.009035819210112095,
0.006701475474983454,
-0.06443965435028076,
0.03723108768463135,
0.009062068536877632,
-0.01625339314341545,
-0.0026780024636536837,
0.014346593990921974,
0.04755514860153198,
-0.013440540060400963,
0.035027988255023956,
0.000552383076865226,
-0.004764319863170385,
-0.04595768079161644,
-0.02428753487765789,
-0.05070148780941963,
-0.004851922858506441,
-0.01835566572844982,
-0.004303393419831991,
0.015384518541395664,
-0.02568131312727928,
-0.036952223628759384,
0.043301038444042206,
0.015053769573569298,
-0.01956004649400711,
0.006102144718170166,
0.013701967895030975,
0.06478457897901535,
-0.024528905749320984,
0.029744571074843407,
-0.025040743872523308,
-0.019755100831389427,
0.0038890985306352377,
-0.0036604797933250666,
-0.018945148214697838,
0.015465953387320042,
-0.0018328557489439845,
-0.05053580552339554,
-0.06139620766043663,
0.015179118141531944,
0.04036720097064972,
-0.002086471300572157,
-0.04286827892065048,
-0.0019079172052443027,
0.013097218237817287,
-0.036346156150102615,
-0.0040505253709852695,
0.02649279125034809,
-0.06369801610708237,
0.0031605088151991367,
0.022816268727183342,
-0.008660438470542431,
0.026600440964102745,
-0.027996493503451347,
-0.056317541748285294,
-0.04977252706885338,
-0.013207964599132538,
-0.044724445790052414,
0.012522946111857891,
-0.013835806399583817,
0.007138316053897142,
-0.02493898756802082,
-0.010239608585834503,
-0.02566508762538433,
0.02131449058651924,
-0.000216698826989159,
-0.020022837445139885,
-0.017546825110912323,
0.05143740773200989,
-0.025557279586791992,
0.0006623080116696656,
0.030077697709202766,
-0.02261357381939888,
0.06374064087867737,
-0.055472929030656815,
0.046579282730817795,
0.04526669532060623,
0.00534064369276166,
0.006452903151512146,
-0.04700750857591629,
0.02990126423537731,
-0.00793908815830946,
-0.009811650030314922,
-0.00670614093542099,
0.015273978933691978,
0.014630422927439213,
-0.004469581879675388,
-0.018858518451452255,
0.05190625414252281,
-0.006098810583353043,
0.0133045744150877,
0.006474152207374573,
0.015764383599162102,
0.024270961061120033,
0.04517132788896561,
-0.009804954752326012,
0.007296879310160875,
0.08427870273590088,
-0.05690412223339081,
-0.03705389425158501,
-0.08187588304281235,
-0.053299546241760254,
-0.01333712786436081,
-0.014105292968451977,
0.024937402456998825,
-0.015020628459751606,
0.05590936169028282,
0.024871395900845528,
0.023546703159809113,
0.02293366752564907,
-0.05359074845910072,
0.031079692766070366,
-0.07795050740242004,
0.019023699685931206,
-0.07328198850154877,
0.023368533700704575,
0.055264126509428024,
-0.01842641271650791,
0.0022401930764317513,
0.00205376953817904,
-0.056526392698287964,
0.03166275471448898,
-0.008497357368469238,
-0.043700963258743286,
0.02130107395350933,
-0.028604382649064064,
-0.014645803719758987,
0.034326985478401184,
-0.03597313538193703,
0.004682861268520355,
0.004515524487942457,
-0.025648679584264755,
-0.02022961899638176,
0.0041039674542844296,
0.03399752452969551,
-0.008090591989457607,
0.04199109226465225,
-0.020225342363119125,
0.02069758251309395,
0.005222566891461611,
0.02334395796060562,
0.04387136921286583,
0.020158320665359497,
-0.02395222708582878,
0.08939417451620102,
0.044327329844236374,
0.0012022985611110926,
0.026812966912984848,
0.006141228601336479,
-0.0299247894436121,
-0.017137009650468826,
0.010197903029620647,
0.03327576816082001,
-0.04907306283712387,
-0.060254957526922226,
0.06965271383523941,
0.03139462694525719,
-0.053602900356054306,
-0.0011502974666655064,
0.013008205220103264,
-0.08493125438690186,
0.020983129739761353,
-0.020661726593971252,
-0.006205292418599129,
-0.02761920914053917,
0.06978411227464676,
0.03714628890156746,
0.006722730118781328,
0.06532072275876999,
-0.007151584140956402,
-0.006336728110909462,
-0.015019284561276436,
0.07447098940610886,
0.08729888498783112,
0.012909888289868832,
-0.007834093645215034,
0.04307965189218521,
-0.04409407824277878,
-0.02877478487789631,
-0.009169025346636772,
0.01698268949985504,
-0.05540698766708374,
-0.023275300860404968,
0.01798023097217083,
0.09398824721574783,
0.014742197468876839,
0.061994411051273346,
-0.04501146450638771,
0.02136537805199623,
0.04137880727648735,
-0.005070612300187349,
0.023139113560318947,
0.08262348920106888,
0.03407370299100876,
0.001793532632291317,
-0.01897292211651802,
-0.013665310107171535,
-0.022557564079761505,
-0.01786642149090767,
0.01619669236242771,
0.024531804025173187,
-0.003971921280026436,
-0.008342399261891842,
0.007275103125721216,
0.0410078689455986,
0.07757336646318436,
-0.0047446652315557,
-0.014030040241777897,
-0.0014789614360779524,
-0.000119294214528054,
0.0316137857735157,
0.04747162386775017,
-0.03819853439927101,
-0.01814381405711174,
-0.005940254312008619,
-0.04573435336351395,
-0.008849932812154293,
0.02041707932949066,
-0.014647225849330425,
0.053927693516016006,
-0.010639133863151073,
-0.03303249925374985,
0.020306522026658058,
0.027252232655882835,
-0.06892624497413635,
-0.021584605798125267,
-0.043295904994010925,
-0.05872943252325058,
-0.033016275614500046,
-0.05805554240942001,
0.011173218488693237,
0.020325688645243645,
-0.049645960330963135,
-0.00946162361651659,
-0.025739219039678574,
-0.005453854333609343,
0.04705126956105232,
-0.07448255270719528,
-0.015951689332723618,
0.058118872344493866,
0.002283181995153427,
-0.008878516964614391,
0.029640953987836838,
0.011262140236794949,
-0.018525930121541023,
-0.026844099164009094,
0.022692905738949776,
0.01807960495352745,
0.035161931067705154,
-0.012034953571856022,
-0.006609443109482527,
-0.08809249103069305,
0.01248306967318058,
0.049989454448223114,
-0.00037289076135493815,
-0.07302701473236084,
0.031166115775704384,
-0.04578785598278046,
0.038473036140203476,
0.07382242381572723,
-0.003932864870876074,
0.05671975389122963,
0.022650014609098434,
-0.01766284555196762,
-0.010496691800653934,
0.007673239801079035,
0.04672796651721001,
0.00014867381833028048,
0.0676918551325798,
0.03259158506989479,
-0.03935295343399048,
-0.05092833936214447,
0.04537461698055267,
-0.009663081727921963,
-0.03664127737283707,
-0.01740436628460884,
0.0067647588439285755,
-0.045342396944761276,
-0.07741179317235947,
0.03609898313879967,
0.037350233644247055,
0.008172307163476944,
-0.04445139318704605,
-0.008500995114445686,
0.005731372162699699,
-0.04495549574494362,
-0.0027323493268340826,
0.002886594505980611,
0.019980574026703835,
-0.008530382066965103,
-0.022469354793429375,
-0.033301468938589096,
-0.004717477597296238,
0.0011183898895978928,
0.01428892556577921,
-0.00946769304573536,
-0.03519760072231293,
0.014198483899235725,
0.020865118131041527,
0.067450150847435,
0.007845872081816196,
0.031659018248319626,
0.0004898775368928909
] |
339 |
ActionReasoningBench: Reasoning about Actions with and without Ramification Constraints
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=NUD03NBDOE
|
[
"Divij Handa",
"Pavel Dolin",
"Shrinidhi Kumbhar",
"Tran Cao Son",
"Chitta Baral"
] |
Poster
|
Reasoning about Actions and Change (RAC) has historically played a pivotal role in solving foundational AI problems, such as the frame problem. It has driven advancements in AI fields, such as non-monotonic and commonsense reasoning. RAC remains crucial for AI systems that operate in dynamic environments, engage in interactive scenarios, or rely on commonsense reasoning. Despite substantial advances made by Large Language Models (LLMs) in various AI domains, their performance in RAC remains underexplored. To address this gap, we introduce a new diagnostic benchmark, $\textbf{ActionReasoningBench}$, which encompasses 8 domains and includes questions for up to 19 action sequences. This benchmark rigorously evaluates LLMs across six key RAC dimensions: $\textit{Fluent Tracking}$, $\textit{State Tracking}$, $\textit{Action Executability}$, $\textit{Effects of Actions}$, $\textit{Numerical RAC}$, and $\textit{Composite Questions}$. LLMs demonstrate average accuracy rates of 73.55%, 65.63%, 58.73%, and 62.38% on the former four dimensions, which are frequently discussed in RAC literature. However, the performance on the latter two dimensions, which introduce complex and novel reasoning questions, the average performance of LLMs is lowered to 33.16% and 51.19%, respectively, reflecting a 17.9% performance decline. We also introduce new ramification constraints to capture the indirect effects of actions, providing deeper insights into RAC challenges. Our evaluation of state-of-the-art LLMs, including both open-source and commercial models, reveals challenges across all RAC dimensions, particularly in handling ramifications, with GPT-4o failing to solve any question and o1-preview achieving a score of only 18.4%.
|
Reasoning about Actions and Change (RAC), Benchmark, Large Language Models (LLMs)
|
The paper introduces ActionReasoningBench, a diagnostic benchmark for Reasoning about Actions and Change (RAC) covering novel complex questions and indirect effects of actions, known as ramifications.
| 13,401 |
2406.04046
|
[
-0.02555803209543228,
-0.034889690577983856,
-0.027766002342104912,
0.011118187569081783,
0.037912026047706604,
0.002209262689575553,
0.04245780035853386,
0.0065300846472382545,
-0.03321051597595215,
-0.01713055558502674,
-0.011043691076338291,
0.03433451056480408,
-0.03993565961718559,
-0.011344153434038162,
0.0037847012281417847,
0.07630528509616852,
0.02876904234290123,
-0.022250238806009293,
0.031423479318618774,
-0.0069208331406116486,
-0.0014292090199887753,
0.008092766627669334,
0.03121020644903183,
0.0021563624031841755,
0.05744369328022003,
0.03218955546617508,
0.043644458055496216,
0.0031781920697540045,
-0.023868253454566002,
-0.01861145719885826,
0.015945125371217728,
-0.01074673980474472,
0.04078393802046776,
-0.0322890430688858,
0.009919634088873863,
-0.01408297847956419,
-0.030492689460515976,
0.01738976500928402,
0.004146937746554613,
-0.02255905419588089,
-0.04300235956907272,
0.026561317965388298,
-0.025980722159147263,
-0.0019156388007104397,
-0.03101396933197975,
0.0037563468795269728,
-0.07959876209497452,
0.04463139921426773,
0.04823723062872887,
-0.004259094595909119,
-0.09565019607543945,
0.04835120216012001,
-0.028948403894901276,
-0.03183172270655632,
0.026916831731796265,
0.034080490469932556,
0.04153236001729965,
-0.07939784228801727,
0.003428478492423892,
-0.043817948549985886,
-0.019474484026432037,
0.023104099556803703,
0.014157627709209919,
-0.01019291952252388,
-0.019239863380789757,
-0.02515842393040657,
0.010961919091641903,
0.04840791970491409,
-0.03243514895439148,
-0.016001492738723755,
-0.0375235341489315,
0.00042151924571953714,
-0.0041233547963202,
0.0075604356825351715,
0.003587364451959729,
-0.03042062558233738,
0.04827525094151497,
0.0252998024225235,
0.06837712228298187,
-0.022882090881466866,
0.02836124785244465,
0.0330563448369503,
0.005078810732811689,
0.03120429255068302,
0.08051924407482147,
0.00488650519400835,
-0.010542069561779499,
-0.029604604467749596,
-0.07000146806240082,
0.000536261301022023,
0.00797402672469616,
-0.04845534265041351,
0.015957916155457497,
0.06518219411373138,
-0.001182922045700252,
0.024466024711728096,
0.0155640272423625,
0.015556350350379944,
0.029243044555187225,
-0.01169624924659729,
-0.01196917612105608,
-0.005467564798891544,
0.037401702255010605,
0.0009219852508977056,
-0.1035439670085907,
-0.0035003237426280975,
-0.04520010948181152,
-0.023291898891329765,
0.028648950159549713,
0.0018239200580865145,
-0.032316986471414566,
0.019019292667508125,
0.009012166410684586,
-0.028630614280700684,
-0.07354801148176193,
0.02304098941385746,
0.012223156169056892,
0.04580720514059067,
0.021378647536039352,
0.05218905955553055,
0.05667123198509216,
0.047954708337783813,
0.022609293460845947,
0.06501591950654984,
-0.016498619690537453,
-0.0002513407962396741,
-0.015248184092342854,
0.00688864104449749,
-0.0249690692871809,
-0.045553263276815414,
0.03205949813127518,
0.02618325687944889,
-0.0037526811938732862,
-0.01861150562763214,
-0.008634310215711594,
0.023509075865149498,
0.02574850618839264,
0.012436036951839924,
0.027513401582837105,
0.01925874687731266,
-0.015027673915028572,
-0.030999399721622467,
0.08959402143955231,
-0.03537890315055847,
0.08183717727661133,
0.0035758879967033863,
-0.009687144309282303,
-0.005099857226014137,
-0.05577114224433899,
0.01231446210294962,
0.006433871574699879,
0.028907909989356995,
-0.002232236322015524,
-0.045584045350551605,
0.01435899082571268,
0.05002666264772415,
-0.0009449268109165132,
-0.028879491612315178,
0.01708143949508667,
0.011729828082025051,
0.007972907274961472,
-0.004549728240817785,
-0.05784469470381737,
-0.003705178387463093,
0.004075437318533659,
-0.03618206828832626,
0.01888711377978325,
-0.020247161388397217,
-0.05015323683619499,
-0.0052418033592402935,
-0.05141525715589523,
-0.03020874410867691,
0.07663872838020325,
-0.028592726215720177,
-0.0017832532757893205,
0.0105628976598382,
0.06534244865179062,
-0.022353366017341614,
0.06338568776845932,
0.023633861914277077,
-0.06407762318849564,
0.025930188596248627,
-0.03389938920736313,
0.011576270684599876,
-0.008951951749622822,
-0.0041310787200927734,
0.06636624038219452,
-0.036619994789361954,
0.02180519700050354,
0.007613742258399725,
-0.08568621426820755,
-0.04873477295041084,
0.04756387323141098,
0.012791331857442856,
0.08046773821115494,
-0.02106967754662037,
-0.024285027757287025,
0.06970824301242828,
-0.017457347363233566,
0.0779869556427002,
0.0208221897482872,
0.011117973364889622,
0.030880160629749298,
-0.023856909945607185,
-0.00859002210199833,
0.012376377359032631,
0.055617693811655045,
-0.044129759073257446,
-0.043988943099975586,
0.024393191561102867,
-0.026448165997862816,
0.0021742586977779865,
0.014960293658077717,
0.00863852072507143,
0.00581462774425745,
0.02468905597925186,
-0.009032469242811203,
0.01330657210201025,
0.02316681668162346,
-0.04082530736923218,
0.01266056951135397,
-0.004073119256645441,
-0.03894959017634392,
-0.00893640797585249,
-0.04473734647035599,
0.07480964064598083,
0.04719344899058342,
-0.031058378517627716,
-0.025561200454831123,
0.03987909480929375,
-0.006475500296801329,
0.02456805482506752,
-0.0011252303374931216,
-0.027505945414304733,
0.023605497553944588,
-0.038637079298496246,
0.003920138347893953,
-0.0037715125363320112,
0.03536342829465866,
-0.02865007147192955,
-0.005316540133208036,
0.0645509585738182,
-0.002524573588743806,
0.0590471476316452,
-0.005491664167493582,
-0.0005474975914694369,
0.038753509521484375,
0.004975517746061087,
0.008886239491403103,
0.0033029518090188503,
-0.015099427662789822,
-0.0003565523657016456,
0.044518839567899704,
-0.01037556305527687,
-0.011876887641847134,
-0.05753085017204285,
-0.004095303360372782,
-0.04282592236995697,
0.053673066198825836,
0.040198829025030136,
0.021808946505188942,
0.013904889114201069,
0.009914402849972248,
-0.039128899574279785,
-0.0000170638995768968,
-0.10898640006780624,
-0.04444601386785507,
-0.0035910189617425203,
0.014682925306260586,
0.03376704081892967,
0.02884696237742901,
-0.006594948470592499,
0.03664390742778778,
-0.019120078533887863,
-0.026816468685865402,
0.0031187019776552916,
0.012067776173353195,
0.005069451872259378,
-0.028749072924256325,
-0.021267244592308998,
-0.007688350509852171,
0.04241533949971199,
-0.04564639925956726,
-0.013813318684697151,
0.013421865180134773,
-0.01794213429093361,
0.04539739713072777,
-0.04670146480202675,
-0.009055545553565025,
0.054147008806467056,
0.00806866679340601,
0.007840209640562534,
-0.06319084018468857,
0.017604650929570198,
0.05701746791601181,
0.04597233235836029,
0.03300226107239723,
-0.024279382079839706,
-0.013508975505828857,
0.019625790417194366,
-0.015323267318308353,
0.005957518704235554,
-0.00801700260490179,
0.0278004240244627,
-0.00867748074233532,
-0.006899509113281965,
-0.020001940429210663,
0.022289665415883064,
-0.26241713762283325,
-0.008417347446084023,
-0.010308333672583103,
-0.013509705662727356,
0.026023725047707558,
-0.003429038217291236,
0.05690895393490791,
-0.04456169903278351,
-0.038239751011133194,
0.007440509274601936,
0.041558071970939636,
-0.011469930410385132,
0.014706725254654884,
0.07659510523080826,
0.037152133882045746,
0.0401952750980854,
-0.01729939505457878,
-0.03742636740207672,
-0.0026056247297674417,
0.022557154297828674,
0.017668597400188446,
-0.06463190168142319,
-0.015375548042356968,
0.027305293828248978,
0.014360394328832626,
0.04580014944076538,
-0.10147301107645035,
-0.004460194613784552,
-0.014089108444750309,
-0.026324989274144173,
0.015078139491379261,
0.0031201455276459455,
-0.021172771230340004,
0.03243902698159218,
-0.00558478245511651,
0.019119566306471825,
0.05881361663341522,
-0.008349248208105564,
0.06458085030317307,
0.016982153058052063,
0.017565127462148666,
-0.0437297597527504,
0.001493660151027143,
0.004501736722886562,
0.06395738571882248,
-0.012396957725286484,
-0.058128997683525085,
-0.041131291538476944,
-0.02055373042821884,
0.033832941204309464,
-0.008549926802515984,
-0.015203933231532574,
-0.029688352718949318,
0.003434310434386134,
0.010042448528110981,
-0.06729649007320404,
0.0016761283623054624,
-0.01710493490099907,
0.008817892521619797,
0.012709913775324821,
-0.0007450630655512214,
-0.029576938599348068,
-0.018187141045928,
-0.025591176003217697,
-0.0400727204978466,
-0.060983601957559586,
-0.05036839470267296,
-0.05833662673830986,
0.06753012537956238,
0.04622659832239151,
-0.024898380041122437,
0.012084836140275002,
-0.025107553228735924,
-0.0945308730006218,
-0.03180467337369919,
-0.0065995994955301285,
-0.002619480947032571,
-0.03586890920996666,
0.008240575902163982,
0.036066070199012756,
-0.04543543979525566,
-0.03500926494598389,
-0.0196875911206007,
0.016726383939385414,
0.012146666646003723,
0.015892615541815758,
0.059099406003952026,
-0.031328316777944565,
-0.02813149057328701,
-0.005549540743231773,
0.04988515004515648,
-0.0033699350897222757,
-0.0026602917350828648,
-0.009619849734008312,
0.061870429664850235,
0.0018629913683980703,
0.03442918136715889,
0.02719016745686531,
0.03554259613156319,
0.004130431450903416,
-0.005481349304318428,
-0.07617557793855667,
0.0243168193846941,
-0.057561591267585754,
-0.030292758718132973,
0.007020978257060051,
-0.029354125261306763,
0.0028590208385139704,
0.031775932759046555,
0.030361203476786613,
-0.04045609384775162,
-0.016773857176303864,
0.00732335215434432,
0.0074087646789848804,
0.00785121787339449,
0.00016999577928800136,
-0.01705707237124443,
0.03435960412025452,
0.018844066187739372,
-0.0002985266619361937,
-0.05040518939495087,
0.013027445413172245,
-0.06270615011453629,
0.019026093184947968,
-0.035627443343400955,
-0.010574722662568092,
-0.022177500650286674,
-0.007283499930053949,
0.008889328688383102,
0.008597142063081264,
0.02395518496632576,
0.02720564417541027,
-0.014701765030622482,
0.01020018756389618,
0.03920774906873703,
-0.04157138988375664,
-0.004403824917972088,
0.005866948049515486,
0.007341936696320772,
-0.026421936228871346,
0.016941670328378677,
-0.040408581495285034,
0.027980316430330276,
0.036654189229011536,
0.03608746454119682,
-0.0028736612293869257,
0.029622646048665047,
0.00948026031255722,
0.014836856164038181,
-0.012086436152458191,
0.04678306356072426,
-0.06754650175571442,
0.028482705354690552,
-0.0351371131837368,
0.011770385317504406,
-0.04867387190461159,
-0.001013175118714571,
-0.042519427835941315,
0.017270507290959358,
-0.05077853426337242,
0.041555654257535934,
-0.0030076918192207813,
0.0008168842177838087,
-0.03641073778271675,
0.012063226662576199,
0.05814238265156746,
-0.03087117336690426,
-0.005175518337637186,
0.004815155174583197,
-0.008299686945974827,
-0.04525194689631462,
-0.0565006323158741,
-0.013648060150444508,
0.014390602707862854,
-0.017473747953772545,
0.02428555302321911,
-0.0000364413826901,
-0.04220861569046974,
-0.014006124809384346,
0.023988595232367516,
-0.005591512657701969,
-0.07458864152431488,
0.003564388258382678,
0.004679572302848101,
0.062317006289958954,
0.01536953542381525,
0.016172688454389572,
-0.021166715770959854,
-0.03739830479025841,
-0.007615501061081886,
-0.012825326062738895,
0.02698763832449913,
-0.006675281561911106,
-0.03903113305568695,
-0.047493476420640945,
-0.06637085974216461,
0.01690240018069744,
-0.0030533671379089355,
0.01265687681734562,
-0.005378587171435356,
-0.012603498063981533,
-0.007867330685257912,
-0.046905480325222015,
-0.002053268952295184,
0.032925985753536224,
-0.06119498983025551,
-0.0014225236373022199,
0.01610027812421322,
0.03185414895415306,
0.02814842201769352,
-0.05553737282752991,
-0.05582600459456444,
-0.04974820837378502,
-0.0328078418970108,
0.0018563782796263695,
0.0016508795088157058,
-0.017414560541510582,
-0.007171023637056351,
-0.04157072305679321,
-0.0016176843782886863,
0.004492050036787987,
-0.006758654024451971,
-0.01326900627464056,
-0.022596143186092377,
-0.021532660350203514,
0.017413247376680374,
0.00044445900130085647,
-0.031505286693573,
0.03002680093050003,
-0.01709556020796299,
0.0502016544342041,
-0.031648337841033936,
0.023872854188084602,
0.02366645447909832,
0.02556844800710678,
-0.015781894326210022,
-0.06865472346544266,
0.0438351184129715,
0.00946336705237627,
-0.033274032175540924,
0.0005492091877385974,
0.0015001196879893541,
0.007303479593247175,
0.012508749961853027,
-0.01808549277484417,
0.022748688235878944,
0.015710800886154175,
-0.014347623102366924,
0.009867411106824875,
0.008180460892617702,
0.019135816022753716,
-0.003849950386211276,
-0.029344910755753517,
-0.014763519167900085,
0.07043013721704483,
-0.05452913045883179,
-0.011745698750019073,
-0.03466447815299034,
-0.06872571259737015,
0.03546532243490219,
-0.005269987042993307,
0.01112185325473547,
-0.0377303808927536,
0.03478248417377472,
-0.0018354782368987799,
0.025910763069987297,
0.024328015744686127,
-0.04105599224567413,
0.05922410264611244,
-0.034872524440288544,
-0.0037886134814471006,
-0.07032956928014755,
-0.0020476561039686203,
0.07896871119737625,
-0.03752722591161728,
-0.03334999084472656,
0.004432692192494869,
-0.07008832693099976,
0.06792308390140533,
0.006029399577528238,
-0.04087702929973602,
0.04247556999325752,
-0.015011300332844257,
-0.020331183448433876,
0.022482343018054962,
-0.03710578754544258,
0.006413882598280907,
0.018706195056438446,
-0.032455578446388245,
0.018294114619493484,
-0.021052584052085876,
0.05822001397609711,
-0.004116194788366556,
0.044745415449142456,
-0.0196041502058506,
-0.006021922919899225,
0.03362036123871803,
0.0571463480591774,
0.039749499410390854,
0.056032001972198486,
-0.025019999593496323,
0.06561145186424255,
0.050481442362070084,
0.036028772592544556,
-0.01691393367946148,
0.007344343699514866,
-0.047307465225458145,
-0.038434598594903946,
0.04081523045897484,
0.03972768411040306,
-0.04033534228801727,
-0.06063979119062424,
0.08832822740077972,
0.009728847071528435,
-0.041952233761548996,
0.009089373983442783,
-0.0027083796449005604,
-0.05563459172844887,
-0.026849325746297836,
0.0013657776871696115,
-0.0010203670244663954,
0.021568819880485535,
0.043748367577791214,
-0.014989827759563923,
0.07436821609735489,
0.07681568711996078,
0.013126259669661522,
-0.006250402890145779,
-0.04110921919345856,
0.06812454760074615,
0.03626550734043121,
0.06354481726884842,
0.0007388097001239657,
0.07350686192512512,
-0.030347157269716263,
-0.054383762180805206,
0.055102765560150146,
0.03783676400780678,
-0.0028821767773479223,
-0.04997944459319115,
0.027417253702878952,
0.08367793262004852,
-0.02509879879653454,
0.03690432384610176,
-0.048875417560338974,
-0.013172507286071777,
0.07174449414014816,
0.01661181077361107,
-0.0004687383188866079,
0.054544396698474884,
0.029604364186525345,
0.002011326141655445,
0.0011281847255304456,
-0.02623923309147358,
-0.018823914229869843,
-0.023404624313116074,
-0.014247799292206764,
0.023167941719293594,
-0.024061115458607674,
0.003524746047332883,
-0.0030714147724211216,
0.0404636487364769,
0.11309250444173813,
-0.03665715456008911,
-0.011083167977631092,
0.03917215019464493,
0.025320257991552353,
0.02459917962551117,
0.03144809603691101,
0.007006182335317135,
-0.0447382889688015,
0.020584946498274803,
-0.03376002609729767,
0.014816753566265106,
0.03091895766556263,
-0.022806009277701378,
0.04252343997359276,
-0.04870671406388283,
-0.04801171272993088,
0.016309604048728943,
0.005091760773211718,
-0.023468589410185814,
-0.04377682879567146,
-0.044706180691719055,
-0.03456316888332367,
-0.03379150852560997,
-0.027306506410241127,
0.009265387430787086,
-0.0008663197513669729,
-0.04343514144420624,
-0.015020545572042465,
-0.03636324033141136,
0.02501450479030609,
0.017077211290597916,
-0.051204755902290344,
0.005126424133777618,
0.03562752902507782,
-0.006656115408986807,
-0.005282741505652666,
0.048323389142751694,
0.009446274489164352,
-0.017436785623431206,
-0.01109293568879366,
0.018184401094913483,
0.02219104766845703,
-0.01852165162563324,
-0.002115181414410472,
-0.057063426822423935,
-0.09112487733364105,
-0.021252648904919624,
0.0004731498484034091,
-0.019696395844221115,
-0.07350800186395645,
0.010112693533301353,
-0.043663185089826584,
-0.014356506988406181,
0.09212783724069595,
0.02310584858059883,
0.0553787536919117,
0.0032026050612330437,
-0.01139654591679573,
0.03768666461110115,
0.037994634360075,
0.035990867763757706,
-0.04316391050815582,
0.04955677688121796,
0.06657784432172775,
-0.04793262481689453,
-0.051948778331279755,
0.02824174240231514,
-0.017308177426457405,
-0.023964326828718185,
-0.005285579711198807,
-0.03775209188461304,
-0.04384462535381317,
-0.10641735047101974,
0.002620926359668374,
0.03302707523107529,
-0.007575251627713442,
-0.02637060359120369,
-0.01079458836466074,
-0.012743476778268814,
-0.01929069310426712,
0.005838272161781788,
-0.015669630840420723,
0.0017758543835952878,
-0.020751258358359337,
-0.05731150880455971,
-0.048165302723646164,
0.025517944246530533,
-0.019932253286242485,
-0.0034872801043093204,
-0.023449257016181946,
-0.033213455229997635,
0.009384253062307835,
0.004580935928970575,
0.042115796357393265,
-0.019149050116539,
0.01892048865556717,
-0.066382497549057
] |
340 |
No Preference Left Behind: Group Distributional Preference Optimization
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=bgpNJBD6Va
|
[
"Binwei Yao",
"Zefan Cai",
"Yun-Shiuan Chuang",
"Shanglin Yang",
"Ming Jiang",
"Diyi Yang",
"Junjie Hu"
] |
Poster
|
Preferences within a group of people are not uniform but follow a distribution. While existing alignment methods like Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) attempt to steer models to reflect human preferences, they struggle to capture the distributional pluralistic preferences within a group. These methods often skew toward dominant preferences, overlooking the diversity of opinions, especially when conflicting preferences arise. To address this issue, we propose Group Distributional Preference Optimization (GDPO), a novel framework that aligns language models with the distribution of preferences within a group by incorporating the concept of beliefs that shape individual preferences. GDPO calibrates a language model using statistical estimation of the group's belief distribution and aligns the model with belief-conditioned preferences, offering a more inclusive alignment framework than traditional methods. In experiments using both synthetic controllable opinion generation and real-world movie review datasets, we show that DPO fails to align with the targeted belief distributions, while GDPO consistently reduces this alignment gap during training. Additionally, our evaluation metrics demonstrate that GDPO outperforms existing approaches in aligning with group distributional preferences, marking a significant advance in pluralistic alignment.
|
preference alignment; large language model; fairness; group preferences
| null | 13,392 |
2412.20299
|
[
0.0014668211806565523,
0.01752849854528904,
0.015682481229305267,
0.04944256693124771,
0.018914926797151566,
0.05146140232682228,
0.0191258005797863,
0.01740862987935543,
-0.019629167392849922,
-0.02769724279642105,
-0.016199056059122086,
0.03496760502457619,
-0.09316069632768631,
-0.024240247905254364,
-0.02826116979122162,
0.03444243595004082,
-0.004764323588460684,
0.005606234539300203,
-0.036142945289611816,
-0.002361732767894864,
0.025893427431583405,
-0.03225532919168472,
-0.005892560817301273,
0.015093889087438583,
0.04945627972483635,
-0.007062320597469807,
0.05986248701810837,
-0.014466101303696632,
-0.026690002530813217,
-0.016043243929743767,
0.02567419968545437,
-0.00029094427009113133,
0.004646163899451494,
0.01632230542600155,
-0.042868178337812424,
-0.017583053559064865,
-0.029497791081666946,
0.0038909350987523794,
0.021686242893338203,
0.06038900837302208,
-0.011145791038870811,
-0.003026756923645735,
-0.01268583070486784,
-0.015061451122164726,
-0.026302101090550423,
0.017024902626872063,
-0.08705563843250275,
0.07018502801656723,
-0.034573107957839966,
-0.052217528223991394,
-0.10897853225469589,
0.027722639963030815,
0.022780634462833405,
-0.03251153603196144,
-0.010926885530352592,
0.030046094208955765,
0.028054112568497658,
-0.06771092861890793,
-0.026036487892270088,
-0.06998781859874725,
-0.030615203082561493,
0.041908882558345795,
0.02157340571284294,
-0.005977483466267586,
-0.0020001991651952267,
-0.016559511423110962,
-0.0037764636799693108,
0.03539657220244408,
-0.04240399971604347,
-0.04017509147524834,
-0.06804883480072021,
-0.03465103358030319,
0.03483286499977112,
0.010527756996452808,
-0.013819469138979912,
-0.04116882383823395,
0.011172483675181866,
0.033151380717754364,
0.05192311108112335,
0.002177428686991334,
0.0003404699091333896,
0.012300325557589531,
0.00817188061773777,
0.03806561231613159,
0.028753012418746948,
-0.009247180074453354,
0.009292267262935638,
-0.029628343880176544,
-0.07583920657634735,
0.04620400443673134,
-0.03538685292005539,
-0.06382787972688675,
0.01494919415563345,
0.02898995205760002,
0.03561943396925926,
0.01722324639558792,
0.03573278337717056,
0.021926848217844963,
-0.016639895737171173,
-0.026128975674510002,
-0.01827390491962433,
-0.029181284829974174,
0.026400621980428696,
-0.012811395339667797,
-0.10183025896549225,
-0.026416558772325516,
0.004703409969806671,
0.02826290763914585,
0.007019944489002228,
-0.00272972509264946,
-0.061913277953863144,
0.014967331662774086,
0.035364679992198944,
0.006380368024110794,
-0.050881847739219666,
0.03373602405190468,
-0.007853218354284763,
0.004406234715133905,
0.01670229062438011,
-0.018636930733919144,
0.04067118093371391,
0.019472921267151833,
0.004208259284496307,
0.0849699154496193,
-0.033392053097486496,
0.030914297327399254,
0.032226335257291794,
0.029213886708021164,
-0.044224128127098083,
-0.046874020248651505,
0.0033755567856132984,
0.01260207500308752,
-0.01600145734846592,
0.006875181570649147,
-0.024347802624106407,
-0.005383499898016453,
0.03730010986328125,
0.013765196315944195,
0.06832817196846008,
-0.00395280122756958,
-0.00669724028557539,
0.007013564929366112,
0.07563275098800659,
-0.008883325383067131,
0.0677974596619606,
-0.03047146275639534,
0.009497864171862602,
-0.03033488057553768,
-0.037722259759902954,
0.01422030758112669,
0.003430065466091037,
-0.00522331427782774,
0.024209460243582726,
-0.06589243561029434,
0.014085870236158371,
0.04482926055788994,
0.04585922881960869,
0.010609785094857216,
0.025171374902129173,
0.020010612905025482,
-0.013524492271244526,
0.007493297103792429,
-0.03812218829989433,
-0.00351702724583447,
0.013023247942328453,
-0.07124263793230057,
0.029396656900644302,
0.023859258741140366,
-0.033197931945323944,
-0.015154311433434486,
-0.03688427060842514,
-0.026325106620788574,
0.02828819677233696,
0.0024674374144524336,
0.023242568597197533,
0.0030468166805803776,
0.04915575683116913,
0.01584329828619957,
0.04606861248612404,
0.03312445431947708,
-0.07464180886745453,
0.026972079649567604,
0.012670229189097881,
0.0002456484653521329,
0.02173246443271637,
0.008056952618062496,
0.026020310819149017,
-0.013164632953703403,
0.020232602953910828,
0.060954492539167404,
-0.07460332661867142,
-0.03451753035187721,
0.04936068505048752,
-0.019183117896318436,
0.06835891306400299,
-0.00025928698596544564,
-0.02217824012041092,
0.05963928997516632,
0.043324604630470276,
0.036123376339673996,
0.020280154421925545,
-0.03618243336677551,
0.02308512292802334,
0.014690963551402092,
-0.03247900307178497,
0.008788625709712505,
0.013869138434529305,
-0.017695944756269455,
-0.02477838844060898,
0.02330680377781391,
-0.04106571152806282,
0.03145400434732437,
0.006907053291797638,
0.0025018576998263597,
0.026697026565670967,
-0.020304828882217407,
-0.024151500314474106,
0.012031645514070988,
0.015252762474119663,
-0.023673132061958313,
0.027360711246728897,
0.028304481878876686,
-0.010932210832834244,
-0.009932887740433216,
-0.027300119400024414,
0.08203484117984772,
0.07654713094234467,
-0.02181275188922882,
0.013976100832223892,
0.05747075006365776,
0.021352659910917282,
0.03941509872674942,
0.04990696161985397,
-0.02562842331826687,
0.029695741832256317,
-0.006065408233553171,
0.0005874884664081037,
-0.05708723142743111,
0.0725780576467514,
-0.01814298890531063,
0.0013147518038749695,
0.053508516401052475,
-0.02152557112276554,
0.0641811415553093,
-0.02146773412823677,
0.028986049816012383,
0.03302584961056709,
0.005540867801755667,
-0.03325163573026657,
-0.013918392360210419,
-0.04402273893356323,
0.01845061220228672,
0.018582411110401154,
-0.01706509105861187,
0.03341040387749672,
-0.03287874162197113,
0.0258933138102293,
0.00249869329854846,
0.0628783330321312,
0.04126810282468796,
0.0028031617403030396,
0.02831965498626232,
-0.012106044217944145,
-0.06068507954478264,
0.009544091299176216,
-0.08507498353719711,
-0.051692452281713486,
0.04583524540066719,
-0.0035240293946117163,
-0.008484039455652237,
0.04134811460971832,
-0.03691868484020233,
0.009440941736102104,
-0.037093739956617355,
-0.033720508217811584,
0.012945964932441711,
0.012810546904802322,
-0.00852807704359293,
-0.028371166437864304,
-0.02385666035115719,
0.003056126879528165,
0.04742893949151039,
-0.03301355242729187,
-0.0005111724603921175,
-0.02251630835235119,
-0.06496844440698624,
0.0013069725828245282,
-0.0494186207652092,
0.0003924919874407351,
0.04299847409129143,
0.06334830820560455,
0.004406975116580725,
0.012256301939487457,
-0.009024580009281635,
0.047567542642354965,
0.04452160745859146,
0.0656435489654541,
0.004775106441229582,
-0.0073463828302919865,
0.053723230957984924,
0.015404774807393551,
0.021982083097100258,
0.008096665143966675,
0.016200624406337738,
-0.003044546814635396,
-0.00842662900686264,
0.032127704471349716,
-0.008142870850861073,
-0.2690487504005432,
-0.012600352056324482,
-0.006462135352194309,
-0.007687316741794348,
0.025017056614160538,
-0.015717539936304092,
0.06267493963241577,
-0.05537305027246475,
-0.03936777263879776,
0.015279937535524368,
0.024210849776864052,
0.008723028935492039,
0.014267617836594582,
0.05253418907523155,
0.03565308451652527,
0.04829251021146774,
0.002465221332386136,
-0.018925102427601814,
0.011263800784945488,
0.028052713721990585,
-0.012348377145826817,
-0.09118535369634628,
-0.009098179638385773,
0.012462356127798557,
0.010448078624904156,
0.05802354961633682,
-0.05560125783085823,
-0.004651281051337719,
-0.037973012775182724,
-0.018500369042158127,
-0.01467095222324133,
-0.006352047435939312,
-0.022419027984142303,
0.016699928790330887,
0.0355539470911026,
-0.02791069820523262,
0.04907122254371643,
-0.011680440977215767,
0.012082093395292759,
0.0278946440666914,
-0.015346127562224865,
-0.005742577835917473,
-0.023124344646930695,
-0.000580267165787518,
0.05099666491150856,
0.02057644911110401,
-0.06263680011034012,
-0.023107286542654037,
-0.023306911811232567,
0.031393714249134064,
0.01355472020804882,
-0.011110583320260048,
-0.020855918526649475,
0.042285241186618805,
0.012034522369503975,
0.000458514696219936,
0.011244233697652817,
-0.02036406844854355,
-0.013586744666099548,
0.00017290136020164937,
0.0270168986171484,
-0.040512170642614365,
0.016463574022054672,
-0.012708811089396477,
-0.030633501708507538,
-0.031624291092157364,
-0.09725061804056168,
-0.03664439544081688,
0.021811360493302345,
0.04245351254940033,
-0.03970808535814285,
-0.00044247627374716103,
0.005701306276023388,
-0.08851101249456406,
-0.02113492414355278,
-0.03898662328720093,
0.017896408215165138,
-0.02022003009915352,
-0.009820906445384026,
0.03123742900788784,
-0.03059461899101734,
-0.02740027755498886,
0.013304139487445354,
0.015281454659998417,
0.030678432434797287,
-0.02557910792529583,
0.019832294434309006,
-0.03776972368359566,
-0.02936568483710289,
-0.0666407123208046,
0.03701426833868027,
-0.012614374980330467,
0.030274037271738052,
0.005315613467246294,
0.0676717758178711,
0.027239706367254257,
0.01299621257930994,
0.04331742972135544,
0.019418302923440933,
0.00524953892454505,
0.00007015575101831928,
-0.1001446396112442,
-0.042478639632463455,
-0.03998200595378876,
-0.03323827683925629,
0.048986949026584625,
-0.07120737433433533,
-0.026240766048431396,
0.023989565670490265,
-0.0025150710716843605,
-0.015148813836276531,
-0.03232179582118988,
-0.005986926611512899,
-0.0010072977747768164,
-0.02769399993121624,
-0.026052838191390038,
0.00023989634064491838,
0.04663200303912163,
0.033027347177267075,
0.00914035551249981,
0.01463604811578989,
0.035217225551605225,
-0.022199256345629692,
-0.003473420161753893,
-0.0681808739900589,
-0.0008569316123612225,
-0.009601108729839325,
-0.04627939686179161,
-0.014501938596367836,
-0.014334972016513348,
0.04113486036658287,
0.034891799092292786,
0.025457419455051422,
0.001371455960907042,
0.04299434274435043,
-0.0027122963219881058,
-0.016170570626854897,
-0.03880588710308075,
0.011365270242094994,
-0.013563643209636211,
0.010467775166034698,
-0.03826455399394035,
0.007305801846086979,
0.013870027847588062,
0.0073222690261900425,
0.003937544766813517,
0.019808320328593254,
0.037297967821359634,
-0.03174813091754913,
0.04909288510680199,
0.04477304592728615,
-0.02824878878891468,
-0.008765127509832382,
-0.0146868284791708,
0.011448531411588192,
0.025360651314258575,
0.02602204494178295,
0.01303962990641594,
-0.010976219549775124,
-0.061850737780332565,
0.024832462891936302,
-0.013487023301422596,
0.0021714074537158012,
0.00736139714717865,
0.03989941626787186,
0.02712204121053219,
-0.0379997082054615,
-0.02296561375260353,
-0.005183963105082512,
0.01821763627231121,
0.03704823926091194,
0.011313315480947495,
-0.009449737146496773,
-0.02502439357340336,
-0.04329528659582138,
-0.025108015164732933,
0.04284735023975372,
-0.02515103667974472,
-0.055790212005376816,
0.027834085747599602,
-0.0018324233824387193,
-0.03086337074637413,
-0.006309430580586195,
-0.01426198985427618,
0.06390735507011414,
0.03296538069844246,
-0.008976142853498459,
-0.01954008638858795,
-0.019711753353476524,
0.01517408061772585,
-0.01289614662528038,
0.00427612941712141,
-0.0493171401321888,
-0.05888831242918968,
-0.046593766659498215,
-0.04252566024661064,
-0.005759688559919596,
0.0002677110314834863,
-0.03417440131306648,
-0.019929353147745132,
-0.030709950253367424,
0.014914837665855885,
-0.06452557444572449,
-0.048974987119436264,
0.0516798198223114,
-0.06718391180038452,
0.02043505385518074,
0.0035073745530098677,
-0.016054468229413033,
0.04228811711072922,
-0.04314710199832916,
-0.07385804504156113,
-0.08346477150917053,
-0.018930720165371895,
0.04658600315451622,
-0.03219953551888466,
-0.033244162797927856,
-0.053607724606990814,
-0.008496376685798168,
0.024293093010783195,
-0.006671785376966,
-0.022705577313899994,
-0.006017574109137058,
0.02639053948223591,
-0.002770832506939769,
0.0441167950630188,
-0.036617785692214966,
-0.014168214984238148,
0.032875895500183105,
-0.011201969347894192,
0.018094200640916824,
-0.04883270710706711,
0.016292942687869072,
0.0564914345741272,
-0.008258096873760223,
0.04287054389715195,
-0.045099690556526184,
0.01911909505724907,
-0.02726633846759796,
-0.0050602746196091175,
-0.018906889483332634,
-0.025618478655815125,
-0.033573225140571594,
-0.03359036147594452,
-0.003578387899324298,
-0.006933470256626606,
-0.01394691877067089,
-0.01359509490430355,
0.010060761123895645,
0.04398244991898537,
0.017541086301207542,
0.011431027203798294,
-0.024413863196969032,
0.041904471814632416,
0.04434579610824585,
0.004576220642775297,
-0.04263954609632492,
-0.05697142705321312,
-0.03505028784275055,
0.005956167355179787,
-0.0104586873203516,
0.03151727840304375,
-0.005009481217712164,
0.011976604349911213,
0.008038250729441643,
0.0354948416352272,
0.04222334548830986,
-0.0023100567050278187,
0.018272344022989273,
-0.05115518718957901,
0.02369086444377899,
-0.06839443743228912,
0.012495742179453373,
0.02222963236272335,
-0.007055133115500212,
-0.010025414638221264,
-0.007780801970511675,
-0.048635125160217285,
0.07250101864337921,
-0.028495728969573975,
-0.05135407671332359,
-0.003841644385829568,
-0.03534778207540512,
-0.002312700729817152,
0.03721066564321518,
-0.04821323975920677,
-0.01478615403175354,
-0.02914404310286045,
-0.05058041960000992,
0.009701147675514221,
0.025139745324850082,
0.05939653515815735,
-0.0007345082121901214,
0.015364621765911579,
-0.044181227684020996,
0.030057130381464958,
0.05402127653360367,
0.05409612879157066,
0.0071937451139092445,
0.023870188742876053,
-0.04188177362084389,
0.06389925628900528,
0.04698469862341881,
0.033982034772634506,
0.0037358258850872517,
0.0032351401168853045,
-0.0032673354726284742,
-0.03673739358782768,
0.06792213022708893,
0.005301928147673607,
0.01966063864529133,
-0.061337780207395554,
0.06286295503377914,
0.02250593528151512,
-0.07093772292137146,
-0.025045009329915047,
0.044494759291410446,
-0.032146256417036057,
-0.00146866322029382,
-0.003269518492743373,
-0.001271235989406705,
-0.007358367554843426,
0.07390258461236954,
0.021462438628077507,
0.08632415533065796,
0.06214846298098564,
0.030293656513094902,
0.006639274302870035,
0.020469706505537033,
0.03751140087842941,
0.06591483950614929,
0.07090352475643158,
0.01639667898416519,
0.060548391193151474,
-0.013684871606528759,
-0.0482788048684597,
0.0016470275586470962,
0.03746616840362549,
-0.033388860523700714,
-0.031777556985616684,
0.004786317702382803,
0.052977606654167175,
-0.024160953238606453,
0.057803016155958176,
-0.022347137331962585,
-0.017936494201421738,
0.026129215955734253,
0.02495499514043331,
0.017385873943567276,
0.08144643157720566,
0.0193853247910738,
0.02416386641561985,
-0.017331350594758987,
0.004826684016734362,
0.015758251771330833,
-0.005740818101912737,
0.007705662399530411,
-0.00585467042401433,
-0.019070830196142197,
0.006089822854846716,
-0.0012813734356313944,
0.03558093681931496,
0.09555110335350037,
-0.07053671032190323,
-0.02769877389073372,
0.012157537043094635,
-0.0068221003748476505,
-0.0069497632794082165,
0.040759552270174026,
0.028447791934013367,
-0.017927611246705055,
-0.011406472884118557,
-0.06569461524486542,
-0.025040684267878532,
0.01076504122465849,
0.017440389841794968,
0.042717136442661285,
-0.03140823915600777,
0.006762712262570858,
0.016985982656478882,
0.0034495661966502666,
-0.059608783572912216,
-0.05663479119539261,
0.00010032998397946358,
-0.04075605049729347,
-0.020136462524533272,
-0.04289429634809494,
0.003947409335523844,
0.0168934166431427,
-0.02322310581803322,
0.033735718578100204,
-0.03543173149228096,
0.03528977558016777,
-0.006292184814810753,
-0.07026442885398865,
-0.0036291349679231644,
0.03776524215936661,
0.0020850312430411577,
0.012345679104328156,
0.00004468178303795867,
0.020010823383927345,
-0.006532301194965839,
-0.011371848173439503,
0.024226786568760872,
0.026311593130230904,
-0.01723378151655197,
-0.043923866003751755,
-0.027582047507166862,
-0.0927828997373581,
-0.016773974522948265,
0.011037906631827354,
-0.05346105247735977,
-0.09476828575134277,
0.015603169798851013,
-0.00009071131353266537,
0.030726615339517593,
0.09140941500663757,
0.05243820697069168,
-0.00840191263705492,
-0.017856940627098083,
-0.00559260556474328,
0.0026526530273258686,
-0.008584830909967422,
0.05301875248551369,
-0.0433853454887867,
0.051592327654361725,
0.04792654514312744,
-0.06770138442516327,
-0.06652335077524185,
0.0522347055375576,
-0.005212714895606041,
-0.00834852084517479,
0.011279745027422905,
-0.023973124101758003,
-0.012031996622681618,
-0.0643220990896225,
-0.014183358289301395,
0.0022874660789966583,
-0.05220315232872963,
-0.01857130602002144,
-0.025188449770212173,
-0.01874641887843609,
0.008130759932100773,
0.017308495938777924,
-0.039485227316617966,
-0.012522552162408829,
-0.017047962173819542,
-0.005625242833048105,
-0.09109356254339218,
0.0014453984331339598,
-0.05450114235281944,
0.0042234449647367,
-0.021990017965435982,
-0.03288830444216728,
-0.012866624630987644,
0.0013166781282052398,
0.05784346163272858,
-0.008011415600776672,
0.019480779767036438,
0.000679152028169483
] |
341 |
MagicDec: Breaking the Latency-Throughput Tradeoff for Long Context Generation with Speculative Decoding
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=CS2JWaziYr
|
[
"Ranajoy Sadhukhan",
"Jian Chen",
"Zhuoming Chen",
"Vashisth Tiwari",
"Ruihang Lai",
"Jinyuan Shi",
"Ian En-Hsu Yen",
"Avner May",
"Tianqi Chen",
"Beidi Chen"
] |
Poster
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become more prevalent in long-context applications such as interactive chatbots, document analysis, and agent workflows, but it is challenging to serve long-context requests with low latency and high throughput. Speculative decoding (SD) is a widely used technique to reduce latency losslessly, but the conventional wisdom suggests that its efficacy is limited to small batch sizes. In MagicDec, we show that surprisingly SD can achieve speedup even for a high throughput inference regime for moderate to long sequences. More interestingly, an intelligent drafting strategy can achieve better speedup with increasing batch size based on our rigorous analysis. MagicDec first identifies the bottleneck shifts with increasing batch size and sequence length, and uses these insights to deploy SD more effectively for high throughput inference. We leverage draft model with sparse KV cache to address the KV bottleneck, which scales with both sequence length and batch size. Additionally, we propose a theoretical model to select the optimal drafting strategy for maximum speedup. Our work highlights the broad applicability of speculative decoding in long-context serving, as it can enhance throughput and reduce latency without compromising accuracy. For moderate to long sequences, we demonstrate up to 2.51x speedup for LLaMA-3.1-8B when serving batch sizes ranging from 32 to 256 on various types of hardware and tasks.
|
LLM Inference, Speculative Decoding, Performance Analysis
|
Long-context serving, Speculative Decoding, Sparse KV Cache
| 13,385 |
2408.11049
|
[
-0.022959142923355103,
-0.010024920105934143,
-0.028866693377494812,
0.058704402297735214,
0.032954055815935135,
0.008411964401602745,
0.010485291481018066,
0.039197102189064026,
-0.029103325679898262,
-0.03397480025887489,
-0.02315429598093033,
0.002327872207388282,
-0.04873378574848175,
0.011975516565144062,
0.006903080269694328,
0.057575102895498276,
0.03072487562894821,
-0.04802483320236206,
0.04135473817586899,
-0.018897036090493202,
0.003996996209025383,
-0.03665865957736969,
0.02205502614378929,
0.022120801731944084,
0.023653609678149223,
0.0455271452665329,
-0.015135972760617733,
0.0058634099550545216,
-0.031365666538476944,
-0.020728079602122307,
0.028972160071134567,
-0.007249465212225914,
0.004083441104739904,
-0.025152435526251793,
0.02381087653338909,
-0.013433989137411118,
-0.054542575031518936,
0.02989444136619568,
-0.015401506796479225,
0.035960521548986435,
-0.04618624597787857,
-0.006814659107476473,
0.0032572068739682436,
0.03505333513021469,
-0.07127141207456589,
-0.0006504321936517954,
-0.09434591978788376,
0.01712958700954914,
-0.009355761110782623,
-0.019567355513572693,
-0.10635936260223389,
0.028707580640912056,
0.017297010868787766,
0.005080040544271469,
0.01764591969549656,
0.04579177871346474,
0.023384124040603638,
-0.0834186002612114,
-0.012210153043270111,
-0.020762545987963676,
-0.0331314317882061,
-0.02760492078959942,
0.026304496452212334,
0.012066547758877277,
0.009786208160221577,
-0.05068252980709076,
0.020918749272823334,
0.03280359506607056,
-0.057233959436416626,
-0.023508688434958458,
-0.005297419149428606,
0.05724705010652542,
-0.0177095178514719,
-0.0010312146041542292,
0.0031506421510130167,
-0.02374124526977539,
0.012519417330622673,
0.039532169699668884,
0.06584249436855316,
0.009603949263691902,
-0.020435482263565063,
-0.006301416549831629,
0.03079945407807827,
0.046029139310121536,
-0.005284830462187529,
0.026258202269673347,
-0.019007880240678787,
-0.01687007024884224,
-0.06706606596708298,
0.03726173937320709,
-0.019906505942344666,
-0.057797860354185104,
0.007791580632328987,
0.0041800979524850845,
-0.016732288524508476,
0.0015725231496617198,
0.017069092020392418,
0.027574170380830765,
-0.01871609315276146,
0.010976096615195274,
-0.0456470362842083,
-0.03874192759394646,
0.031661175191402435,
-0.002457673428580165,
-0.08452985435724258,
-0.0036042460706084967,
-0.03856448829174042,
-0.01627078652381897,
0.014117235317826271,
-0.017206260934472084,
-0.004611172713339329,
0.011132029816508293,
0.0318150520324707,
-0.00530557706952095,
-0.06227421388030052,
0.018084751442074776,
0.016209730878472328,
-0.009964657947421074,
-0.02386011928319931,
0.0009999744361266494,
0.0917409360408783,
0.08421339094638824,
-0.012226761318743229,
0.08962640911340714,
-0.02353261224925518,
-0.007068310398608446,
0.016782555729150772,
0.008079692721366882,
0.00871366262435913,
-0.026905298233032227,
0.010685044340789318,
0.04635683074593544,
-0.0029300875030457973,
-0.028071753680706024,
-0.014573784545063972,
0.020449088886380196,
-0.012368868105113506,
0.014905545860528946,
0.07702701538801193,
-0.006372175645083189,
-0.0031484775245189667,
-0.04123280569911003,
0.04155658558011055,
-0.030148519203066826,
0.07626783102750778,
-0.009717151522636414,
-0.015132484957575798,
-0.04264355078339577,
-0.006052721291780472,
0.0283432025462389,
-0.001818217453546822,
0.012189161032438278,
-0.025766335427761078,
-0.05303040146827698,
0.04887746274471283,
0.0584699772298336,
-0.014351683668792248,
0.0006233680760487914,
9.134837455349043e-7,
0.0031047894153743982,
-0.019572364166378975,
-0.004264652729034424,
-0.05781140178442001,
0.029349029064178467,
0.00260389712639153,
-0.054095666855573654,
0.04060168191790581,
0.018503505736589432,
-0.04068467393517494,
0.03014889732003212,
-0.014418062753975391,
-0.012340489774942398,
0.04571416601538658,
-0.03316768258810043,
-0.0228311475366354,
0.006078565958887339,
0.04418794810771942,
-0.0039748153649270535,
0.01996740698814392,
0.025997446849942207,
-0.08537769317626953,
0.03713395074009895,
0.027194397523999214,
-0.02583741955459118,
-0.03111615777015686,
-0.010386964306235313,
0.10933060944080353,
-0.02213629148900509,
-0.04258481040596962,
-0.004723887890577316,
-0.07397689670324326,
-0.03074389323592186,
0.02045920491218567,
-0.007546886336058378,
0.06806562095880508,
-0.028244314715266228,
0.003881776938214898,
0.05404776334762573,
0.07187864929437637,
0.028301957994699478,
0.06964446604251862,
0.0036960793659090996,
0.05429964140057564,
0.008000309579074383,
-0.0190623477101326,
-0.009214946068823338,
0.039863161742687225,
-0.038441531360149384,
-0.0266665518283844,
0.026467548683285713,
-0.02575424313545227,
-0.025387775152921677,
0.017660383135080338,
-0.006664979737251997,
-0.0077302162535488605,
-0.0006466133636422455,
0.01518623623996973,
-0.013212434016168118,
-0.006729733198881149,
-0.04925384372472763,
0.05776868388056755,
-0.012943140231072903,
-0.024600673466920853,
0.006751797161996365,
-0.035508498549461365,
0.12273060530424118,
0.043468475341796875,
-0.05655046924948692,
0.014872242696583271,
0.008851119317114353,
0.009620900265872478,
-0.009079675190150738,
0.0012308926088735461,
-0.039371442049741745,
-0.006696190219372511,
-0.016949186101555824,
-0.009144743904471397,
-0.023103833198547363,
0.05565064400434494,
-0.026255212724208832,
-0.01456380169838667,
0.03840716555714607,
-0.02256537601351738,
0.06265954673290253,
0.011875353753566742,
0.012661479413509369,
0.0023627898190170527,
-0.034858595579862595,
-0.041601214557886124,
-0.05115985870361328,
-0.004300793167203665,
-0.009039021097123623,
0.01241662073880434,
-0.011382867582142353,
0.008552140556275845,
-0.03904629871249199,
-0.02870362065732479,
-0.00919873546808958,
0.04622969403862953,
0.037676528096199036,
0.011818318627774715,
0.023729413747787476,
0.031820327043533325,
-0.04419289529323578,
0.019430773332715034,
-0.08760735392570496,
-0.0016594085609540343,
-0.02935492992401123,
0.032591626048088074,
-0.015853803604841232,
0.04426191374659538,
-0.002060206141322851,
0.006602694280445576,
-0.03158426657319069,
-0.01711428165435791,
-0.029501594603061676,
0.06895551830530167,
0.007687118835747242,
-0.014649934135377407,
-0.02931862697005272,
-0.0020254766568541527,
0.07775068283081055,
-0.026456275954842567,
0.006930854637175798,
-0.03986046463251114,
-0.014611192978918552,
-0.01670585572719574,
-0.04611062631011009,
-0.0038658971898257732,
0.007891694083809853,
0.004844781942665577,
0.02016732469201088,
-0.06519708782434464,
0.04082478955388069,
0.038500089198350906,
0.04253682866692543,
0.04177592322230339,
0.010807130485773087,
-0.04236845672130585,
0.0168161541223526,
0.00807413924485445,
0.012754986062645912,
-0.022620083764195442,
0.012341728433966637,
-0.020877672359347343,
-0.027281444519758224,
0.01520066149532795,
-0.024955058470368385,
-0.283584862947464,
0.009482594206929207,
-0.01306868251413107,
-0.03137310966849327,
0.03200804814696312,
-0.023762613534927368,
0.012332948856055737,
-0.03080231510102749,
0.014554176479578018,
-0.01697598770260811,
-0.012545726262032986,
0.033015958964824677,
-0.02520858868956566,
0.014873324893414974,
0.04494083672761917,
0.03248276934027672,
-0.020126258954405785,
-0.006432390306144953,
0.03328871726989746,
0.048252493143081665,
0.010079920291900635,
-0.06656735390424728,
-0.021404391154646873,
0.04204065725207329,
0.018769999966025352,
0.016998328268527985,
-0.08093767613172531,
0.001384429051540792,
-0.021189237013459206,
-0.014904865995049477,
0.03667127341032028,
-0.02197517454624176,
0.010777530260384083,
0.0707353875041008,
0.0073760016821324825,
0.021349620074033737,
0.0795680433511734,
0.0030990303494036198,
0.015458079986274242,
-0.03784516826272011,
0.019403355196118355,
-0.04961235821247101,
-0.025225089862942696,
-0.018592309206724167,
0.0638691782951355,
0.041364025324583054,
-0.055687978863716125,
-0.015814021229743958,
0.007082155905663967,
0.02349015511572361,
0.000741180032491684,
-0.045311491936445236,
-0.029453827068209648,
0.013397534377872944,
0.029274679720401764,
0.00016759688151068985,
-0.03349225968122482,
-0.014831268228590488,
-0.03834722936153412,
0.02184406854212284,
0.013072174042463303,
-0.04884348437190056,
-0.01834622211754322,
-0.010848738253116608,
-0.01697649247944355,
-0.055702295154333115,
-0.08200674504041672,
-0.03842365741729736,
0.036083098500967026,
0.008049458265304565,
-0.024185074493288994,
0.004928115289658308,
0.019106566905975342,
-0.07527860999107361,
0.03198997676372528,
0.012299442663788795,
-0.02591170370578766,
0.017308194190263748,
0.02720741182565689,
0.07442335784435272,
-0.031527742743492126,
-0.03506283462047577,
0.00016052565479185432,
0.0004905210225842893,
0.0482318215072155,
-0.013240202330052853,
0.007629504427313805,
-0.04878203570842743,
-0.01894233748316765,
-0.026478849351406097,
0.0496743805706501,
-0.014261484146118164,
0.001259867218323052,
0.004676894284784794,
0.040684767067432404,
0.02522662654519081,
0.025172850117087364,
0.058969639241695404,
0.011088233441114426,
0.018651746213436127,
0.020162779837846756,
-0.04460524395108223,
-0.009409214369952679,
-0.06372754275798798,
-0.0010363033507019281,
0.0199834406375885,
-0.034488826990127563,
-0.018325431272387505,
0.041752081364393234,
0.00798990298062563,
-0.042111072689294815,
0.020612256601452827,
0.0023609197232872248,
-0.005223687272518873,
-0.0167424026876688,
0.01677490957081318,
0.02765507623553276,
0.055092550814151764,
0.0006170172709971666,
-0.023250848054885864,
-0.02239043265581131,
0.043542567640542984,
-0.03771672025322914,
0.003111976897343993,
0.02416091039776802,
0.0014615905238315463,
-0.014781013131141663,
0.021871747449040413,
0.00691309105604887,
-0.039685457944869995,
0.005399046931415796,
0.03547137603163719,
-0.004903434310108423,
0.029664520174264908,
0.046912018209695816,
-0.0021808594465255737,
-0.009208405390381813,
0.013924411498010159,
0.02902418002486229,
-0.018678048625588417,
0.02144664339721203,
-0.03090537153184414,
0.03588547557592392,
0.030536731705069542,
0.0046102977357804775,
0.00837758556008339,
0.040041133761405945,
-0.0014612331287935376,
-0.03042585775256157,
-0.014528981409966946,
0.05118054524064064,
-0.04522227868437767,
-0.0011330278357490897,
-0.028651395812630653,
-0.011527758091688156,
-0.004602942615747452,
0.02739720605313778,
0.02695639245212078,
0.022470450028777122,
-0.09294547885656357,
0.0452137291431427,
-0.010271157138049603,
-0.0011661957250908017,
-0.008344756439328194,
-0.0026352107524871826,
0.03287821635603905,
-0.01381355058401823,
0.031672604382038116,
0.043994709849357605,
0.0014671001117676497,
0.002823276910930872,
0.01318892277777195,
-0.05098888278007507,
0.032153815031051636,
-0.0024955724366009235,
0.03692784532904625,
0.009107913821935654,
0.0006463939207606018,
-0.024183783680200577,
0.04096897318959236,
0.011473868042230606,
-0.0039604357443749905,
-0.009591727517545223,
0.026705296710133553,
0.08288630843162537,
-0.0028387035708874464,
0.025756077840924263,
0.0203687846660614,
-0.03186643123626709,
0.007783554960042238,
-0.015381349250674248,
0.015011966228485107,
-0.021251102909445763,
-0.02547929435968399,
-0.026676857843995094,
-0.040353722870349884,
0.03794172406196594,
0.045137885957956314,
-0.027617380023002625,
-0.015777243301272392,
0.020874543115496635,
-0.007754515390843153,
-0.05214064195752144,
-0.03669760748744011,
0.025292839854955673,
-0.07033559679985046,
0.0037894754204899073,
-0.010458597913384438,
0.005992554593831301,
0.03066614456474781,
-0.002616886980831623,
-0.0002761832729447633,
-0.0330897755920887,
-0.001121259992942214,
-0.0011282116174697876,
0.0005061138072051108,
0.0034828074276447296,
0.000630709866527468,
-0.01281774789094925,
-0.04644058644771576,
0.017513515427708626,
-0.0005667468067258596,
0.022242354229092598,
-0.0276210755109787,
-0.009254885837435722,
0.027515044435858727,
-0.031751275062561035,
0.008739372715353966,
-0.009645887650549412,
-0.03318949416279793,
0.05954986810684204,
-0.048553917557001114,
0.04367371276021004,
0.04837808385491371,
-0.01649639382958412,
0.025189507752656937,
-0.04260861501097679,
0.027014687657356262,
0.008408178575336933,
0.02265140414237976,
0.008749064989387989,
-0.04588622599840164,
-0.0319465808570385,
0.02748892456293106,
-0.025032484903931618,
0.060176458209753036,
-0.013226239942014217,
-0.012096071615815163,
-0.026970338076353073,
0.03752418980002403,
-0.005552604328840971,
0.01842307299375534,
-0.03604421764612198,
-0.009505351074039936,
0.0519123375415802,
-0.039097078144550323,
-0.03746732324361801,
-0.07795323431491852,
-0.06301601976156235,
0.004103416111320257,
0.015858149155974388,
0.015388873405754566,
-0.021177563816308975,
0.02510908618569374,
0.046809881925582886,
0.03983836621046066,
0.03337398171424866,
-0.036909423768520355,
0.02625063806772232,
-0.03464171662926674,
-0.0017384254606440663,
-0.06861462444067001,
0.003476574318483472,
0.06011322885751724,
-0.01613411121070385,
-0.012510164640843868,
-0.0025893005076795816,
-0.0512361004948616,
0.030063213780522346,
-0.006895003840327263,
-0.05031852424144745,
0.019327828660607338,
-0.0366227850317955,
-0.013600981794297695,
0.028112992644309998,
-0.044464122503995895,
-0.03974701464176178,
-0.037837907671928406,
-0.041496001183986664,
-0.01970093697309494,
0.016135897487401962,
0.03753908351063728,
0.00779962632805109,
0.02445376105606556,
-0.0219956636428833,
-0.04054757207632065,
0.021820928901433945,
0.04561803117394447,
0.02757015824317932,
0.015369248576462269,
-0.006897020153701305,
0.07458464801311493,
0.03562415391206741,
-0.013184971176087856,
0.026243001222610474,
-0.02139330841600895,
-0.013178103603422642,
-0.02615628018975258,
0.043598104268312454,
-0.020012060180306435,
-0.01994183287024498,
-0.0841422975063324,
0.07531110942363739,
0.028105231001973152,
-0.043159451335668564,
-0.0551597997546196,
0.006871846504509449,
-0.02984609454870224,
-0.008878638036549091,
-0.037191517651081085,
0.016064465045928955,
-0.00010872651910176501,
0.05630817264318466,
0.016748102381825447,
0.046128951013088226,
0.1070847287774086,
-0.0080775897949934,
-0.00019378430442884564,
-0.014741899445652962,
0.02941230498254299,
0.08505741506814957,
0.014027612283825874,
-0.0044191922061145306,
0.04538056626915932,
-0.008429964073002338,
-0.035948168486356735,
0.03390634059906006,
0.03132811188697815,
0.0010323247406631708,
-0.030353393405675888,
0.01707804761826992,
0.08704737573862076,
-0.003058935282751918,
0.08696796000003815,
-0.06460721790790558,
0.014445669949054718,
0.06553639471530914,
0.06051734834909439,
0.010348883457481861,
0.06365994364023209,
0.011896097101271152,
0.012677608989179134,
-0.03253081068396568,
-0.022269150242209435,
0.006655811797827482,
-0.041112545877695084,
-0.006148504558950663,
0.025735577568411827,
-0.023528089746832848,
0.004053245298564434,
-0.001463096821680665,
0.06705085188150406,
0.08163046836853027,
-0.008144083432853222,
-0.056844696402549744,
-0.009242898784577847,
-0.008165309205651283,
0.010439417324960232,
0.03488282859325409,
-0.008260533213615417,
-0.009890050627291203,
0.005988472606986761,
-0.04371769726276398,
0.012911717407405376,
-0.0364120677113533,
-0.015970692038536072,
0.04260261729359627,
-0.022217892110347748,
-0.0077246506698429585,
-0.0027849755715578794,
-0.0008325984235852957,
-0.08130975067615509,
-0.03918321803212166,
-0.02360428497195244,
-0.04136600345373154,
-0.0611015222966671,
-0.03187756612896919,
0.013402833603322506,
0.0037305811420083046,
-0.03130246698856354,
-0.003357240231707692,
-0.04566763713955879,
0.0009974652202799916,
0.005444342270493507,
-0.05677483603358269,
0.013264539651572704,
0.06932355463504791,
0.007203780114650726,
-0.028814900666475296,
0.04757623374462128,
0.030250605195760727,
-0.049473781138658524,
0.001822645659558475,
0.016802266240119934,
0.022448597475886345,
0.017456205561757088,
0.012713748961687088,
-0.026070689782500267,
-0.10212966799736023,
0.017793070524930954,
0.03751276060938835,
-0.004631132818758488,
-0.07704047113656998,
0.026770109310746193,
-0.04402806609869003,
0.022441474720835686,
0.06860552728176117,
-0.012736640870571136,
0.05153562128543854,
-0.04334285482764244,
-0.0071018654853105545,
0.032544322311878204,
-0.01266188733279705,
0.03093801997601986,
-0.002921432489529252,
0.06884342432022095,
0.04585748165845871,
-0.02282671630382538,
-0.027010930702090263,
0.022970668971538544,
-0.016576012596488,
-0.025986526161432266,
-0.010276180692017078,
0.0039081871509552,
-0.06723219901323318,
-0.0760309025645256,
-0.02868022955954075,
0.025740647688508034,
0.00819484144449234,
-0.05803715065121651,
0.01075791846960783,
-0.01845904439687729,
-0.039450354874134064,
-0.014163566753268242,
-0.028989100828766823,
-0.0062355767004191875,
-0.03640138730406761,
-0.06321044266223907,
-0.04773155227303505,
0.02261129580438137,
-0.011838140897452831,
-0.03304637223482132,
-0.02327888086438179,
-0.04282248020172119,
0.020665107294917107,
0.012167999520897865,
0.06396403908729553,
-0.0008672474650666118,
0.02387220412492752,
-0.04129365459084511
] |
342 |
Parameter Expanded Stochastic Gradient Markov Chain Monte Carlo
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=exgLs4snap
|
[
"Hyunsu Kim",
"Giung Nam",
"Chulhee Yun",
"Hongseok Yang",
"Juho Lee"
] |
Poster
|
Bayesian Neural Networks (BNNs) provide a promising framework for modeling predictive uncertainty and enhancing out-of-distribution robustness (OOD) by estimating the posterior distribution of network parameters. Stochastic Gradient Markov Chain Monte Carlo (SGMCMC) is one of the most powerful methods for scalable posterior sampling in BNNs, achieving efficiency by combining stochastic gradient descent with second-order Langevin dynamics. However, SGMCMC often suffers from limited sample diversity in practice, which affects uncertainty estimation and model performance. We propose a simple yet effective approach to enhance sample diversity in SGMCMC without the need for tempering or running multiple chains. Our approach reparameterizes the neural network by decomposing each of its weight matrices into a product of matrices, resulting in a sampling trajectory that better explores the target parameter space. This approach produces a more diverse set of samples, allowing faster mixing within the same computational budget. Notably, our sampler achieves these improvements without increasing the inference cost compared to the standard SGMCMC. Extensive experiments on image classification tasks, including OOD robustness, diversity, loss surface analyses, and a comparative study with Hamiltonian Monte Carlo, demonstrate the superiority of the proposed approach.
|
SGMCMC, Bayesian Neural Network, Parameter Expansion
| null | 13,380 |
2503.00699
|
[
-0.018103839829564095,
0.0033564893528819084,
-0.039292510598897934,
0.05159827321767807,
0.0276991818100214,
0.02981920726597309,
0.01837123930454254,
-0.012497659772634506,
-0.04259020462632179,
-0.05709878355264664,
0.00913987960666418,
0.012860054150223732,
-0.05754941329360008,
-0.016671279445290565,
0.03707481175661087,
0.04750308021903038,
0.029839392751455307,
-0.011151590384542942,
-0.01156885176897049,
0.03977055847644806,
-0.02745446190237999,
-0.04523861035704613,
0.05441761016845703,
0.01874348148703575,
-0.012230578809976578,
-0.01712854951620102,
0.03725382685661316,
0.0214192233979702,
-0.0164033230394125,
-0.01252301037311554,
0.038362856954336166,
-0.014719165861606598,
0.011409380473196507,
-0.024149121716618538,
0.029949769377708435,
0.016883939504623413,
-0.051874373108148575,
-0.03206389397382736,
-0.019501518458127975,
0.00428458396345377,
-0.044069498777389526,
0.012461656704545021,
0.0031990581192076206,
0.025778839364647865,
-0.020550386980175972,
0.02223089523613453,
-0.03943857178092003,
0.046434324234724045,
-0.006308176089078188,
-0.03568563610315323,
-0.07822847366333008,
0.0249436404556036,
-0.03178020194172859,
-0.010643885470926762,
0.008495506830513477,
0.04146149381995201,
0.04269133135676384,
-0.07013792544603348,
-0.01873040571808815,
-0.06428539007902145,
-0.01763181947171688,
-0.01253991387784481,
-0.0022769731003791094,
0.0305764302611351,
0.00024176540318876505,
-0.0010263202711939812,
0.03477170690894127,
0.07384192943572998,
-0.03239985927939415,
-0.0161160659044981,
-0.02226841263473034,
-0.0046256850473582745,
0.021662209182977676,
-0.014190408401191235,
0.003986395429819822,
-0.032488469034433365,
0.007998515851795673,
0.014198942109942436,
0.05744682997465134,
-0.026907818391919136,
0.032186441123485565,
0.010953368619084358,
-0.004621992819011211,
0.03970015421509743,
-0.014852375723421574,
0.01934235356748104,
-0.03120451420545578,
-0.029798360541462898,
-0.08178088068962097,
0.07088419795036316,
-0.023012256249785423,
-0.04690828546881676,
0.028288204222917557,
0.035425081849098206,
0.0029333855491131544,
-0.02375841699540615,
-0.004601975902915001,
-0.020273946225643158,
0.02072327584028244,
-0.019517797976732254,
-0.022724907845258713,
-0.03833869844675064,
0.02460359036922455,
-0.006337268743664026,
-0.12173168361186981,
-0.027963662520051003,
-0.014120714738965034,
-0.0032610862981528044,
-0.03031974285840988,
0.028411919251084328,
-0.023188499733805656,
-0.0009343100246042013,
-0.014447839930653572,
-0.0057199797593057156,
-0.06233780086040497,
0.010632538236677647,
-0.010683493688702583,
0.002976974006742239,
0.013170110061764717,
-0.042585406452417374,
0.03939554840326309,
0.04125223308801651,
-0.021745270118117332,
0.0368296317756176,
-0.004714755807071924,
0.005003583617508411,
0.0516541451215744,
0.01489531435072422,
-0.03524783253669739,
-0.008577341213822365,
-0.012811277993023396,
0.02853037603199482,
0.00717612449079752,
0.02664605714380741,
-0.0017811506986618042,
-0.04271150007843971,
-0.0034678529482334852,
0.026413440704345703,
-0.0024824945721775293,
-0.0025213148910552263,
0.018870018422603607,
-0.03609634190797806,
0.07020176947116852,
0.014041335321962833,
0.0760352686047554,
0.003350641578435898,
0.01090124063193798,
-0.03800567612051964,
-0.06012202426791191,
-0.0024258147459477186,
-0.0032440032809972763,
-0.02174472063779831,
0.005456910934299231,
-0.058395594358444214,
0.008999781683087349,
0.02250128611922264,
0.005548604764044285,
0.046495720744132996,
0.010714562609791756,
-0.00989420898258686,
0.02219550870358944,
-0.00008080953557509929,
-0.013983556069433689,
0.039304766803979874,
0.009905903600156307,
-0.05926314741373062,
0.04692202806472778,
0.04405026137828827,
-0.013462346978485584,
-0.01599857583642006,
-0.041141144931316376,
-0.07486177235841751,
0.030020978301763535,
-0.0024050709325820208,
-0.03175092488527298,
0.009706785902380943,
0.05644240975379944,
0.0007560256053693593,
0.04623550921678543,
0.01926944963634014,
-0.07141149044036865,
0.018124375492334366,
0.028143713250756264,
-0.008478052914142609,
-0.0021484149619936943,
-0.03285544365644455,
0.09875907003879547,
-0.019744498655200005,
-0.0077205318957567215,
0.0191635861992836,
-0.07913953810930252,
-0.01511714793741703,
0.006900401320308447,
0.0006384108564816415,
0.05585872754454613,
0.008957989513874054,
0.0046776034869253635,
0.030678289011120796,
0.030236689373850822,
0.011273388750851154,
0.05423274263739586,
-0.03059922717511654,
0.044782184064388275,
-0.0065188221633434296,
-0.048201948404312134,
-0.027169812470674515,
0.056379035115242004,
-0.052620578557252884,
0.012129925191402435,
0.02593129314482212,
-0.032220035791397095,
0.002511292463168502,
-0.007475127931684256,
-0.004438640084117651,
0.03778375685214996,
-0.013845139183104038,
-0.016269372776150703,
-0.010657558217644691,
0.003037775633856654,
-0.027460161596536636,
-0.009894287213683128,
0.014592149294912815,
0.00020162864529993385,
0.009312731213867664,
0.014505460858345032,
0.10013839602470398,
0.0782514363527298,
-0.016578540205955505,
-0.02376301772892475,
0.015345176681876183,
0.03770783171057701,
-0.000005335612513590604,
0.04011852666735649,
0.022000402212142944,
0.022078363224864006,
-0.006035765167325735,
-0.003401189809665084,
-0.03663036599755287,
0.0344218835234642,
-0.024041542783379555,
-0.018932832404971123,
0.0479489341378212,
-0.013983368873596191,
0.046071864664554596,
0.009918281808495522,
0.000024778606530162506,
0.03733440861105919,
0.008969521149992943,
-0.04528207331895828,
-0.029294993728399277,
-0.007902604527771473,
0.02250124327838421,
0.016028083860874176,
0.002521087881177664,
-0.004936041310429573,
-0.04991859942674637,
0.013249567709863186,
-0.012753458693623543,
0.07651988416910172,
0.06619258970022202,
0.028620487079024315,
0.011324293911457062,
0.02695615403354168,
-0.005828647408634424,
-0.05695756524801254,
-0.11530667543411255,
-0.04672897234559059,
-0.028173616155982018,
0.0402478463947773,
0.03077700361609459,
0.04048091173171997,
-0.024056613445281982,
0.01002284325659275,
-0.01716841757297516,
0.005231471266597509,
0.022576795890927315,
0.012199400924146175,
0.03308635577559471,
-0.021224627271294594,
-0.0009690409060567617,
-0.008969737216830254,
0.07558285444974899,
-0.03764835000038147,
-0.018109284341335297,
-0.006937425583600998,
-0.03651120886206627,
-0.027411311864852905,
-0.0075972178019583225,
0.010260126553475857,
0.0325881764292717,
0.001294005778618157,
0.011858232319355011,
-0.0012602793285623193,
0.036763012409210205,
0.0329156368970871,
0.035388778895139694,
0.049306996166706085,
0.01730397343635559,
-0.04323935508728027,
0.0405324250459671,
-0.03553155064582825,
-0.0008410607115365565,
0.005747262388467789,
-0.017432186752557755,
-0.018984029069542885,
0.005818626377731562,
0.026356318965554237,
0.015219729393720627,
-0.27152931690216064,
0.0015531133394688368,
0.02828489989042282,
-0.01886630803346634,
0.0240778848528862,
-0.023689690977334976,
0.05960443988442421,
-0.0463499054312706,
-0.02455798164010048,
0.024977831169962883,
0.017313644289970398,
0.003434662241488695,
-0.022056272253394127,
0.06301265954971313,
0.05996006354689598,
0.0037663716357201338,
-0.0003307658771518618,
-0.018106864765286446,
0.05106561258435249,
0.03345387801527977,
0.01406711246818304,
-0.07539188861846924,
-0.04386264085769653,
0.00989234633743763,
-0.03183751553297043,
0.056503888219594955,
-0.08271759003400803,
0.029387913644313812,
-0.02394673228263855,
0.032408587634563446,
-0.02574780024588108,
-0.030656423419713974,
-0.002932744100689888,
0.0127907395362854,
0.013524380512535572,
0.007537838537245989,
0.02959710918366909,
0.0026593217626214027,
0.013754308223724365,
-0.004036868456751108,
0.01318450178951025,
0.006496951915323734,
-0.03697333112359047,
0.024565154686570168,
0.07916537672281265,
0.006743399892002344,
-0.00558238010853529,
0.009742461144924164,
-0.013444547541439533,
0.027663635089993477,
-0.008816635236144066,
-0.02005430869758129,
-0.007093743421137333,
-0.011028665117919445,
-0.003487529931589961,
-0.030528362840414047,
0.014519446529448032,
-0.0031566505786031485,
-0.012953742407262325,
0.02791230008006096,
-0.013131208717823029,
-0.05484914407134056,
-0.01651162840425968,
-0.02264084294438362,
0.007466858718544245,
-0.03566957265138626,
-0.07136962562799454,
-0.05347807705402374,
0.030806558206677437,
0.034022923558950424,
-0.021166637539863586,
0.002354119438678026,
-0.03455900028347969,
-0.10438958555459976,
0.042485062032938004,
0.006537667475640774,
-0.022181781008839607,
-0.042667318135499954,
-0.012263782322406769,
0.024831412360072136,
-0.003097775625064969,
-0.0531826913356781,
0.004038816783577204,
0.022451242431998253,
0.057013873010873795,
-0.022800859063863754,
-0.006267108488827944,
-0.017651138827204704,
-0.023861004039645195,
-0.042175427079200745,
0.028283122926950455,
0.026243606582283974,
0.06820745766162872,
-0.01843143254518509,
0.04522605612874031,
0.04393670707941055,
0.024921655654907227,
0.03757309168577194,
0.03088344633579254,
0.007584043312817812,
0.035828184336423874,
-0.07343663275241852,
-0.03131812810897827,
-0.0707668885588646,
-0.06279395520687103,
0.009487270377576351,
-0.043581273406744,
-0.03226247802376747,
0.006720696110278368,
-0.012790985405445099,
-0.008602309972047806,
-0.02877003513276577,
-0.001152923796325922,
0.011879333294928074,
-0.0328797772526741,
-0.0060601504519581795,
-0.03508579730987549,
0.04292028397321701,
0.03920203819870949,
-0.018405433744192123,
-0.02448098734021187,
0.03633175790309906,
-0.0587969608604908,
0.0045882053673267365,
0.026992669329047203,
-0.035997722297906876,
0.01944165863096714,
0.00917229987680912,
-0.0015877929981797934,
-0.01628478802740574,
0.010561496019363403,
0.036196038126945496,
0.014605842530727386,
0.01787560060620308,
0.057203665375709534,
0.021153898909687996,
-0.016845665872097015,
0.0004442727367859334,
0.04164183884859085,
-0.017771590501070023,
0.015507220290601254,
0.000962502439506352,
0.03024362213909626,
0.0440739206969738,
0.006017144303768873,
0.01335807703435421,
0.025963004678487778,
0.034495458006858826,
0.01961289346218109,
-0.0222735945135355,
-0.008575115352869034,
-0.04730353131890297,
-0.033655256032943726,
0.016468027606606483,
0.00650918809697032,
-0.015310168266296387,
0.05167889967560768,
0.005142799112945795,
0.03470856696367264,
-0.0751873180270195,
0.06766526401042938,
0.049824897199869156,
-0.045986827462911606,
0.00815204344689846,
-0.02160932496190071,
0.052787162363529205,
-0.022088859230279922,
0.002873052377253771,
0.026338594034314156,
0.03327861428260803,
0.010380329564213753,
-0.048392537981271744,
-0.05207110196352005,
-0.0322190597653389,
-0.017471613362431526,
0.02832290530204773,
0.001296097761951387,
-0.0418860986828804,
-0.06558898836374283,
0.020814523100852966,
0.011348821222782135,
-0.03264138847589493,
-0.02119121327996254,
-0.0010517181362956762,
0.06796274334192276,
-0.008846028707921505,
-0.02579834870994091,
0.00911478977650404,
-0.04173348471522331,
0.045673076063394547,
0.005352316424250603,
0.014885137788951397,
-0.04256780073046684,
-0.0418412946164608,
0.0013187932781875134,
-0.03147878125309944,
-0.0026206071488559246,
0.017259329557418823,
0.0015285429544746876,
-0.02140304073691368,
0.016199592500925064,
0.031122401356697083,
-0.03794457018375397,
0.01739325001835823,
0.022598832845687866,
-0.07477135211229324,
0.021154368296265602,
0.042324766516685486,
-0.036241743713617325,
0.019848352298140526,
-0.03524128347635269,
-0.02281089872121811,
-0.02795994095504284,
-0.011586783453822136,
-0.00718431593850255,
-0.005348105914890766,
-0.037240028381347656,
-0.02525634504854679,
0.013825965113937855,
0.012252535670995712,
0.019553935155272484,
-0.002372568706050515,
0.03538607060909271,
-0.043092258274555206,
0.013070018030703068,
0.03906707093119621,
-0.014651879668235779,
0.013354598544538021,
0.019043538719415665,
-0.026771510019898415,
-0.003660451387986541,
-0.07068900763988495,
-0.0050545381382107735,
0.03429782763123512,
-0.006290083285421133,
-0.002587063703685999,
-0.04355517774820328,
0.050237033516168594,
-0.0015464823227375746,
-0.008078972809016705,
-0.011197156272828579,
0.025176627561450005,
-0.019409427419304848,
0.016401253640651703,
-0.017957691103219986,
0.004195480607450008,
0.03374772146344185,
0.043698567897081375,
0.023613449186086655,
0.01439331378787756,
-0.0017582022119313478,
-0.005748782306909561,
-0.08942092955112457,
0.026001546531915665,
0.052484337240457535,
-0.015606099739670753,
-0.03490191325545311,
-0.07986564189195633,
-0.021194331347942352,
-0.000370015884982422,
-0.026556789875030518,
0.016186464577913284,
-0.04054885357618332,
0.03247595205903053,
0.023961704224348068,
0.02793421596288681,
-0.016355011612176895,
-0.017821533605456352,
0.009814659133553505,
-0.04594095051288605,
0.034752897918224335,
-0.042639728635549545,
-0.029456041753292084,
0.08138427883386612,
-0.024707099422812462,
0.027236606925725937,
0.011823891662061214,
-0.03545888885855675,
0.04255150258541107,
-0.022854233160614967,
-0.05532684549689293,
0.0052865175530314445,
-0.040240783244371414,
-0.0008180209551937878,
0.021395793184638023,
-0.03763735666871071,
-0.006894287653267384,
-0.03165809437632561,
-0.048579245805740356,
0.036905981600284576,
0.04194509983062744,
0.061968397349119186,
-0.032220982015132904,
0.031193071976304054,
-0.02725011296570301,
0.009405027143657207,
0.04050518572330475,
0.06560724228620529,
0.008570066653192043,
0.041355572640895844,
-0.04856135696172714,
0.06124543026089668,
0.05273491516709328,
0.04245505481958389,
0.03928869590163231,
-0.012921036221086979,
-0.015155679546296597,
-0.06908801943063736,
0.035189323127269745,
0.020809181034564972,
-0.02724319137632847,
-0.050835900008678436,
0.03768779709935188,
-0.0045852456241846085,
-0.07265279442071915,
-0.04445669427514076,
0.02414543926715851,
-0.06307413429021835,
0.0026958021335303783,
-0.0045488798059523106,
0.0018775616772472858,
0.040333785116672516,
0.07627443969249725,
0.005308650899678469,
0.055748775601387024,
0.07724840193986893,
-0.005907211918383837,
-0.03072204627096653,
0.007390155922621489,
0.0541485920548439,
0.06925655156373978,
0.0480303056538105,
-0.01912573166191578,
0.07071710377931595,
-0.060060907155275345,
-0.03534495830535889,
-0.031883612275123596,
0.0208244901150465,
-0.013027898967266083,
-0.03244127333164215,
0.031026514247059822,
0.07852769643068314,
0.006906310096383095,
0.07607143372297287,
-0.03859618306159973,
-0.033710870891809464,
0.040403034538030624,
0.02348753623664379,
-0.03325225040316582,
-0.0036106454208493233,
0.0005499790422618389,
-0.0029763891361653805,
-0.013571723364293575,
-0.032499779015779495,
0.0024539311416447163,
-0.0005013790796510875,
-0.013093185611069202,
0.008727679029107094,
-0.02741013653576374,
-0.0025928711984306574,
0.022930199280381203,
0.033456314355134964,
0.10269609838724136,
-0.037191275507211685,
-0.031198853626847267,
0.002833071630448103,
0.009652091190218925,
-0.010962855070829391,
0.057143136858940125,
0.04764101654291153,
-0.014635702595114708,
-0.013171137310564518,
-0.01662246696650982,
-0.013826074078679085,
0.034872934222221375,
0.008605090901255608,
-0.0356980599462986,
-0.01141913328319788,
-0.020830828696489334,
0.0177069790661335,
0.003454678924754262,
-0.04114922136068344,
-0.04975300654768944,
-0.022930817678570747,
-0.07354333996772766,
-0.051871560513973236,
-0.054054949432611465,
0.04387225955724716,
-0.026007140055298805,
-0.010138203389942646,
0.023795604705810547,
-0.022893790155649185,
0.04233449324965477,
0.04958784207701683,
-0.0340767428278923,
0.006896790117025375,
0.044127680361270905,
0.0006086017820052803,
-0.005251656752079725,
0.04403246194124222,
0.005193502176553011,
0.005786027759313583,
-0.03855833783745766,
0.0931992307305336,
-0.01391036156564951,
0.024176310747861862,
-0.032368533313274384,
0.03804028034210205,
-0.09069379419088364,
-0.001644859672524035,
0.0420636348426342,
-0.04054083302617073,
-0.06788076460361481,
0.03846748545765877,
-0.01981860212981701,
0.04193670675158501,
0.046497076749801636,
-0.002648130524903536,
-0.007370661944150925,
-0.06668467819690704,
-0.038865335285663605,
-0.0465577207505703,
0.030012862756848335,
0.05044180154800415,
-0.03780243918299675,
0.05091884732246399,
0.030529117211699486,
-0.046726323664188385,
-0.0347449854016304,
0.009571781381964684,
0.015016148798167706,
0.0224351417273283,
-0.025081681087613106,
0.007091880775988102,
-0.026337016373872757,
-0.10886361449956894,
0.009106319397687912,
-0.003384179435670376,
-0.0016691782511770725,
-0.00114219740498811,
0.0047325799241662025,
-0.02304077334702015,
0.014571757055819035,
-0.027598600834608078,
-0.005203616339713335,
-0.03654401749372482,
-0.03562072664499283,
-0.046366218477487564,
-0.0807061642408371,
0.027110600844025612,
-0.008211741223931313,
0.010337059386074543,
-0.03901379927992821,
-0.06724532693624496,
-0.02786489948630333,
-0.009945770725607872,
0.0214201882481575,
0.013712177984416485,
0.015351577661931515,
-0.0368213914334774
] |
343 |
Hyperbolic Genome Embeddings
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=NkGDNM8LB0
|
[
"Raiyan R. Khan",
"Philippe Chlenski",
"Itsik Pe'er"
] |
Poster
|
Current approaches to genomic sequence modeling often struggle to align the inductive biases of machine learning models with the evolutionarily-informed structure of biological systems. To this end, we formulate a novel application of hyperbolic CNNs that exploits this structure, enabling more expressive DNA sequence representations. Our strategy circumvents the need for explicit phylogenetic mapping while discerning key properties of sequences pertaining to core functional and regulatory behavior. Across 37 out of 43 genome interpretation benchmark datasets, our hyperbolic models outperform their Euclidean equivalents. Notably, our approach even surpasses state-of-the-art performance on seven GUE benchmark datasets, consistently outperforming many DNA language models while using orders of magnitude fewer parameters and avoiding pretraining. Our results include a novel set of benchmark datasets - the Transposable Elements Benchmark - which explores a major but understudied component of the genome with deep evolutionary significance. We further motivate our work by exploring how our hyperbolic models recognize genomic signal under various data-generating conditions and by constructing an empirical method for interpreting the hyperbolicity of dataset embeddings. Throughout these assessments, we find persistent evidence highlighting the potential of our hyperbolic framework as a robust paradigm for genome representation learning. Our code and benchmark datasets are available at https://github.com/rrkhan/HGE.
|
genomics, representation learning, hyperbolic geometry
|
A hyperbolic geometry-based approach for genomic sequence representation learning
| 13,373 | null |
[
0.007945993915200233,
-0.01763206347823143,
-0.032625358551740646,
0.04945946857333183,
0.04632941260933876,
0.013092492707073689,
0.020577002316713333,
0.03035520389676094,
0.008318936452269554,
-0.04171060770750046,
0.03154091164469719,
-0.004979127552360296,
-0.07440261542797089,
0.01825387217104435,
-0.0021007643081247807,
0.04658066853880882,
-0.0018034118693321943,
0.005327907390892506,
0.0013215172803029418,
0.005567256361246109,
0.018419163301587105,
-0.04946223646402359,
-0.016516078263521194,
0.031324759125709534,
-0.010552903637290001,
-0.003209006506949663,
-0.006739097181707621,
-0.014234556816518307,
-0.02124580182135105,
0.008536889217793941,
0.025938868522644043,
-0.011257229372859001,
0.02141495794057846,
-0.013149662874639034,
0.026761772111058235,
0.0031147629488259554,
-0.06199031323194504,
0.018968449905514717,
0.025511832907795906,
-0.011078900657594204,
-0.04070914164185524,
-0.015604186803102493,
-0.03616997227072716,
0.042280230671167374,
-0.05069377273321152,
0.03848404064774513,
-0.1347748041152954,
0.0729578360915184,
-0.0043292054906487465,
-0.012236964888870716,
-0.057608336210250854,
0.013090860098600388,
0.0008646423812024295,
-0.014148297719657421,
0.011749010533094406,
0.05073627457022667,
0.043332215398550034,
-0.08256503194570541,
-0.0040429397486150265,
-0.06301392614841461,
-0.022589299827814102,
0.001993856392800808,
0.007219697814434767,
0.022561194375157356,
0.032021187245845795,
-0.022901233285665512,
-0.013336475938558578,
0.026054032146930695,
-0.06002836674451828,
-0.01805981621146202,
0.019769495353102684,
0.00132411764934659,
0.005408909171819687,
0.01985190622508526,
0.013176691718399525,
-0.06351076811552048,
-0.026928873732686043,
0.019316382706165314,
0.08377965539693832,
0.03762000799179077,
0.01437060534954071,
0.012558714486658573,
0.03146490082144737,
0.03157094493508339,
-0.018350614234805107,
0.025215592235326767,
-0.03289774805307388,
-0.018083103001117706,
-0.08449143916368484,
0.02870567888021469,
-0.025698300451040268,
-0.040701333433389664,
0.041098449379205704,
0.02470068633556366,
0.036596208810806274,
0.007109783124178648,
0.02482418902218342,
0.0237848162651062,
-0.011837614700198174,
0.008691143244504929,
-0.06924736499786377,
-0.02042723447084427,
0.0035225541796535254,
-0.01376954186707735,
-0.11783935129642487,
-0.02136530540883541,
-0.018969548866152763,
-0.037657879292964935,
0.010454045608639717,
-0.028456438332796097,
-0.023427210748195648,
-0.0012340274406597018,
-0.003570977132767439,
-0.0012121152831241488,
-0.07070323824882507,
0.06985922902822495,
0.02031889371573925,
-0.003397500840947032,
0.032441213726997375,
-0.029310088604688644,
0.03422876447439194,
0.023102840408682823,
-0.0152049008756876,
0.07475601881742477,
0.010962549597024918,
0.02286333590745926,
0.02331378683447838,
0.009548169560730457,
-0.028406037017703056,
-0.051075778901576996,
0.028083931654691696,
0.07460125535726547,
-0.02596084214746952,
-0.0062240250408649445,
0.014263846911489964,
-0.017949188128113747,
-0.006444862112402916,
-0.016654180362820625,
0.07768017798662186,
0.0035443492233753204,
0.00015055002586450428,
-0.022861583158373833,
0.0355273000895977,
-0.051192887127399445,
0.04559934511780739,
-0.027773967012763023,
-0.036526329815387726,
-0.03209516406059265,
-0.020138749852776527,
0.006554133258759975,
0.01646718569099903,
0.00991817843168974,
-0.016615772619843483,
-0.06807839125394821,
0.04027993232011795,
0.048369668424129486,
0.01651572249829769,
-0.001938770292326808,
-0.02361060306429863,
0.01248659286648035,
0.025662343949079514,
-0.03589511290192604,
-0.03454956039786339,
0.00901009514927864,
-0.00505537586286664,
-0.024453192949295044,
0.08667648583650589,
0.05136178061366081,
-0.06744863092899323,
-0.020228378474712372,
-0.04899887368083,
-0.058407388627529144,
0.07382770627737045,
0.022357532754540443,
0.013029388152062893,
-0.027641400694847107,
0.0568099170923233,
0.00047660706331953406,
0.05608261376619339,
0.010863358154892921,
-0.08122385293245316,
0.03113245964050293,
0.03313620388507843,
0.02637460269033909,
0.022719914093613625,
-0.0365300290286541,
0.09086471050977707,
-0.021781107410788536,
0.005863133352249861,
0.04454521834850311,
-0.08443833887577057,
-0.051568128168582916,
0.010468672960996628,
-0.012577567249536514,
0.042163070291280746,
-0.031484831124544144,
0.006527400109916925,
0.027285579591989517,
-0.005173245444893837,
0.03137143701314926,
0.011858980171382427,
0.008817625232040882,
0.04909969121217728,
-0.0393107607960701,
-0.05058758333325386,
-0.005236269440501928,
0.02166834846138954,
-0.049810562282800674,
-0.040668923407793045,
0.0003022715973202139,
0.005230045411735773,
-0.009694230742752552,
0.011393008753657341,
-0.019269095733761787,
0.03374489024281502,
-0.01817196235060692,
0.020401453599333763,
-0.005849932320415974,
-0.010910723358392715,
-0.046547431498765945,
0.03271947801113129,
0.0009883556049317122,
-0.02282540500164032,
-0.005131956189870834,
-0.013674636371433735,
0.1080111414194107,
0.08888023346662521,
0.0029253163374960423,
0.01206937339156866,
0.016663672402501106,
0.022512665018439293,
-0.042392417788505554,
-0.012504602782428265,
-0.02166481874883175,
0.015271778218448162,
0.04926048591732979,
0.00023935035278555006,
-0.03518937900662422,
0.05751439556479454,
-0.04125027358531952,
0.003852719208225608,
0.06499211490154266,
-0.05905112251639366,
0.021912964060902596,
0.0061986190266907215,
-0.008534460328519344,
0.01701999269425869,
-0.05890946462750435,
-0.08411067724227905,
-0.03467274457216263,
-0.01717621460556984,
0.0026593280490487814,
0.0027443396393209696,
0.00473395362496376,
-0.019404442980885506,
-0.050593968480825424,
-0.02139510214328766,
0.032447341829538345,
0.03881732001900673,
0.05465763807296753,
0.0019441032782196999,
0.01088469848036766,
0.00353199802339077,
-0.03437066450715065,
-0.01808037795126438,
-0.09294596314430237,
-0.04416557773947716,
-0.043205950409173965,
0.07005538046360016,
-0.003103393130004406,
0.02974565327167511,
0.027980981394648552,
0.01274834480136633,
-0.023510118946433067,
-0.030984124168753624,
-0.03717735782265663,
0.05059826001524925,
-0.02728692814707756,
-0.045982662588357925,
-0.017826303839683533,
0.004664167761802673,
0.053154949098825455,
-0.0656009241938591,
-0.004160794895142317,
-0.033433496952056885,
-0.04441671818494797,
-0.028319941833615303,
-0.022702885791659355,
-0.0016002757474780083,
0.032043613493442535,
0.010012579150497913,
0.01926352269947529,
-0.054923344403505325,
0.0034393842797726393,
0.04601392149925232,
0.023721296340227127,
0.032326433807611465,
-0.0023518737871199846,
-0.007790586911141872,
0.01446505542844534,
-0.01807168684899807,
0.013742742128670216,
0.006237804889678955,
-0.007872626185417175,
-0.0202194657176733,
0.04693051427602768,
0.025427930057048798,
-0.033524565398693085,
-0.24531826376914978,
-0.028348729014396667,
-0.01070066262036562,
-0.03415415436029434,
0.051723629236221313,
-0.021184174343943596,
0.0035646010655909777,
-0.01525246724486351,
-0.030229371041059494,
0.015548653900623322,
0.009960307739675045,
0.01455763541162014,
0.006105368956923485,
0.016983287408947945,
0.027315903455018997,
0.014629065059125423,
-0.04214303940534592,
-0.016982384026050568,
0.021756859496235847,
0.012532167136669159,
-0.005951046012341976,
-0.06139380484819412,
-0.01202897448092699,
0.03788246586918831,
-0.02204880304634571,
0.02287069894373417,
-0.06203879788517952,
0.0008557022665627301,
-0.06968900561332703,
-0.006488704588264227,
-0.006348329596221447,
-0.04892352968454361,
0.023886365815997124,
0.03115396574139595,
-0.028587227687239647,
-0.002821140456944704,
0.03628618270158768,
0.0017467017751187086,
0.012100745923817158,
-0.00580596923828125,
0.000999719137325883,
-0.06401200592517853,
-0.025963623076677322,
-0.027145227417349815,
0.06716449558734894,
-0.0013930376153439283,
-0.01624911278486252,
0.017101474106311798,
0.008050373755395412,
0.0420355349779129,
-0.005519025959074497,
-0.016916926950216293,
-0.015745099633932114,
0.03108120709657669,
0.01264884416013956,
-0.02235441654920578,
0.03937099501490593,
-0.0034050806425511837,
-0.03684648871421814,
-0.010631701909005642,
0.007915905676782131,
-0.0379866287112236,
-0.026860689744353294,
-0.04786410182714462,
-0.001783246174454689,
-0.012146604247391224,
-0.07921420782804489,
-0.060320280492305756,
-0.006888967007398605,
0.02069810964167118,
-0.0392908900976181,
0.04420015588402748,
-0.02036135084927082,
-0.100993812084198,
0.01016790047287941,
-0.010733084753155708,
-0.029220813885331154,
0.0043946816585958,
-0.007219525519758463,
0.017967430874705315,
-0.00874492060393095,
-0.04072022810578346,
-0.0162122193723917,
0.025773825123906136,
0.04052523523569107,
-0.05369279906153679,
0.004181018099188805,
-0.05547204241156578,
-0.035818833857774734,
-0.01574450172483921,
0.003721528686583042,
-0.03194144368171692,
0.021833140403032303,
-0.009431794285774231,
0.030987311154603958,
0.008314395323395729,
0.0135527728125453,
0.07206282764673233,
0.047838348895311356,
0.008623510599136353,
0.03946267068386078,
-0.045659102499485016,
-0.0093314778059721,
-0.021024461835622787,
-0.009927233681082726,
0.012513107620179653,
-0.039390161633491516,
-0.019832463935017586,
0.05708770453929901,
0.000001926960294440505,
-0.015012628398835659,
-0.019350476562976837,
0.014356435276567936,
-0.025933636352419853,
-0.010679256170988083,
-0.008281497284770012,
0.044910065829753876,
0.041168857365846634,
0.07614605873823166,
0.01715877093374729,
-0.018281910568475723,
0.07087210565805435,
-0.0272716972976923,
0.003319959156215191,
0.01670304872095585,
-0.019693119451403618,
0.013164491392672062,
-0.004640682600438595,
0.017679505050182343,
-0.013887978158891201,
0.026452509686350822,
0.05039321258664131,
-0.01847347617149353,
0.04931051656603813,
0.05259517952799797,
0.017982399091124535,
-0.015087111853063107,
-0.010900021530687809,
0.0066644479520618916,
-0.0016823277110233903,
-0.00736998300999403,
-0.000417509552789852,
0.026654347777366638,
0.027972538024187088,
0.0242080669850111,
0.03137033432722092,
0.02832912467420101,
0.0174390971660614,
0.02313895709812641,
-0.013281590305268764,
0.01859680749475956,
-0.014564364217221737,
0.030212031677365303,
-0.043966494500637054,
0.03612406551837921,
-0.006884411443024874,
0.060238052159547806,
0.038953013718128204,
0.005040949676185846,
-0.06658479571342468,
0.026879839599132538,
0.006760223302990198,
0.02341809868812561,
-0.01830216310918331,
-0.012548092752695084,
0.07866811752319336,
-0.024555446580052376,
-0.0014204852050170302,
-0.03085353784263134,
0.023643886670470238,
0.021761568263173103,
0.03866603225469589,
-0.01842433400452137,
-0.009921154007315636,
-0.05379742756485939,
0.0012380714761093259,
-0.024077147245407104,
0.017755938693881035,
-0.041715752333402634,
0.006990930996835232,
-0.006948914844542742,
-0.031042009592056274,
0.026194369420409203,
0.037412818521261215,
0.09636138379573822,
0.014452863484621048,
0.02641352452337742,
-0.017316991463303566,
-0.037784695625305176,
0.04143497347831726,
-0.026478465646505356,
0.013313427567481995,
-0.04315187782049179,
-0.03792513906955719,
-0.027375472709536552,
-0.0218629352748394,
0.02816222608089447,
0.023978084325790405,
-0.014203422702848911,
-0.033727943897247314,
0.0043971664272248745,
0.010731702670454979,
-0.033050328493118286,
-0.007776497397571802,
0.03125912696123123,
-0.061543162912130356,
-0.016687070950865746,
-0.007407682947814465,
-0.005373021587729454,
0.007449924945831299,
0.012092183344066143,
-0.05579952895641327,
-0.03356028348207474,
-0.017278293147683144,
-0.03109637275338173,
-0.014584464952349663,
-0.00975208729505539,
-0.002392192604020238,
-0.004492194391787052,
-0.010389646515250206,
0.0020703438203781843,
0.03174659609794617,
0.01532798819243908,
-0.04373838007450104,
-0.019816938787698746,
0.04981501027941704,
-0.024400997906923294,
0.03317389264702797,
-0.018247827887535095,
-0.011605784296989441,
0.020384155213832855,
-0.059791941195726395,
0.038837406784296036,
0.057036153972148895,
0.020174141973257065,
-0.05110251158475876,
-0.012701508589088917,
0.019123347476124763,
0.03401544317603111,
0.017067838460206985,
0.04286923632025719,
-0.008980455808341503,
-0.042350951582193375,
0.03668325021862984,
0.04446066543459892,
0.013802318833768368,
-0.0061500887386500835,
0.017613189294934273,
-0.017848266288638115,
0.03375568240880966,
0.030392970889806747,
0.03717273101210594,
-0.050689276307821274,
-0.004585559945553541,
0.048518456518650055,
-0.030846673995256424,
-0.045248329639434814,
-0.04915742203593254,
-0.03060690499842167,
0.0023237925488501787,
0.014340373687446117,
0.029561951756477356,
-0.020763281732797623,
0.06340300291776657,
0.05831170082092285,
0.028268864378333092,
-0.0030321436934173107,
-0.013280519284307957,
0.04952693730592728,
-0.023074565455317497,
-0.004142295569181442,
-0.048521701246500015,
-0.019307052716612816,
0.07675332576036453,
-0.019233712926506996,
0.0365501269698143,
-0.0015535680577158928,
-0.018010832369327545,
0.02783571556210518,
-0.04822221025824547,
-0.05275038257241249,
0.04669491946697235,
-0.05935489013791084,
-0.0043475208804011345,
-0.003976896870881319,
-0.038383640348911285,
0.008441084064543247,
-0.019864993169903755,
-0.01922168768942356,
-0.003105785232037306,
0.006863605231046677,
0.01954248547554016,
-0.04599496349692345,
0.01655077189207077,
0.00297651719301939,
0.02337367832660675,
0.048736680299043655,
0.037575703114271164,
0.01729569211602211,
0.015564917586743832,
-0.031231407076120377,
0.0897873044013977,
0.015362675301730633,
-0.004150346387177706,
-0.009145762771368027,
0.018167555332183838,
-0.000810654426459223,
-0.028595343232154846,
0.023861054331064224,
0.006742106284946203,
0.006449815351516008,
-0.027381733059883118,
0.08367607742547989,
0.037358738481998444,
-0.04635991156101227,
0.008370744064450264,
0.03854922577738762,
-0.03144052252173424,
-0.0015044801402837038,
0.0010401819599792361,
0.016692904755473137,
-0.02230595052242279,
0.05428975075483322,
0.0046786898747086525,
0.05371449515223503,
0.0871264860033989,
-0.00671949191018939,
0.00872239749878645,
0.010969283059239388,
0.09960096329450607,
0.04749317467212677,
0.008598010055720806,
0.011494508944451809,
0.061857834458351135,
-0.038922809064388275,
-0.03454034402966499,
-0.004924524575471878,
0.0445442758500576,
0.019258907064795494,
0.010550204664468765,
0.08893655240535736,
0.05875176936388016,
-0.019711578264832497,
0.060685038566589355,
-0.023076800629496574,
-0.003093090606853366,
0.004464167635887861,
0.02553420700132847,
0.011558158323168755,
0.035328950732946396,
0.04303422197699547,
0.004813382867723703,
-0.06495801359415054,
-0.032693278044462204,
-0.02395809255540371,
-0.0068432060070335865,
-0.009250120259821415,
0.00841607991605997,
0.010441441088914871,
0.012114849872887135,
-0.03336526080965996,
0.015228248201310635,
0.08742883056402206,
0.00307481293566525,
-0.028996771201491356,
0.021849870681762695,
0.02266595885157585,
0.01574215106666088,
0.028998730704188347,
-0.0059144943952560425,
-0.04241565242409706,
-0.026254847645759583,
-0.05685277283191681,
0.011759812012314796,
0.013431291095912457,
0.012823914177715778,
0.01473144069314003,
-0.012085742317140102,
-0.03935954347252846,
-0.0196823813021183,
0.007616390008479357,
-0.06735173612833023,
-0.03120136447250843,
-0.03130505979061127,
-0.0259108729660511,
-0.07124064862728119,
-0.036997340619564056,
-0.0053456686437129974,
-0.024198317900300026,
-0.03596090152859688,
-0.00795314833521843,
-0.03460094332695007,
0.03340776637196541,
0.009222746826708317,
-0.06905539333820343,
0.016273118555545807,
0.042369239032268524,
0.01925469934940338,
-0.00008712131239008158,
0.007048735860735178,
0.01800108142197132,
-0.017003541812300682,
-0.025129809975624084,
0.024824881926178932,
-0.0046254713088274,
0.024571964517235756,
0.002821644302457571,
-0.02133299596607685,
-0.10410912334918976,
0.03335283696651459,
0.02968168817460537,
-0.003977436106652021,
-0.10548771917819977,
0.030775172635912895,
-0.018647154793143272,
0.02775442786514759,
0.05155428126454353,
-0.02340156026184559,
0.01287993136793375,
-0.06011320650577545,
-0.02063760720193386,
-0.013887538574635983,
-0.014861841686069965,
0.06226051598787308,
-0.030292892828583717,
0.07502863556146622,
0.05835765227675438,
-0.02484966814517975,
-0.017476076260209084,
0.029310420155525208,
-0.014208510518074036,
0.02149447798728943,
-0.025320997461676598,
-0.04272617772221565,
-0.03993954509496689,
-0.10337531566619873,
0.007298777811229229,
0.036425910890102386,
-0.012143545784056187,
-0.04859970510005951,
0.003193959826603532,
-0.0111813610419631,
-0.02113112434744835,
-0.015278917737305164,
-0.012106107547879219,
0.013959534466266632,
0.003488664049655199,
-0.032218221575021744,
-0.08143049478530884,
-0.006887370720505714,
-0.008164462633430958,
0.03600829094648361,
-0.032849688082933426,
-0.03424469009041786,
-0.0013362235622480512,
-0.00908665917813778,
0.014596099965274334,
0.015625180676579475,
0.035927664488554,
0.02344781905412674
] |
344 |
Deep Distributed Optimization for Large-Scale Quadratic Programming
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hzuumhfYSO
|
[
"Augustinos D Saravanos",
"Hunter Kuperman",
"Alex Oshin",
"Arshiya Taj Abdul",
"Vincent Pacelli",
"Evangelos Theodorou"
] |
Poster
|
Quadratic programming (QP) forms a crucial foundation in optimization, appearing in a broad spectrum of domains and serving as the basis for more advanced algorithms. Consequently, as the scale and complexity of modern applications continue to grow, the development of efficient and reliable QP algorithms becomes increasingly vital. In this context, this paper introduces a novel deep learning-aided distributed optimization architecture designed for tackling large-scale QP problems. First, we combine the state-of-the-art Operator Splitting QP (OSQP) method with a consensus approach to derive **DistributedQP**, a new method tailored for network-structured problems, with convergence guarantees to optimality. Subsequently, we unfold this optimizer into a deep learning framework, leading to **DeepDistributedQP**, which leverages learned policies to accelerate reaching to desired accuracy within a restricted amount of iterations. Our approach is also theoretically grounded through Probably Approximately Correct (PAC)-Bayes theory, providing generalization bounds on the expected optimality gap for unseen problems. The proposed framework, as well as its centralized version **DeepQP**, significantly outperform their standard optimization counterparts on a variety of tasks such as randomly generated problems, optimal control, linear regression, transportation networks and others. Notably, DeepDistributedQP demonstrates strong generalization by training on small problems and scaling to solve much larger ones (up to 50K variables and 150K constraints) using the same policy. Moreover, it achieves orders-of-magnitude improvements in wall-clock time compared to OSQP. The certifiable performance guarantees of our approach are also demonstrated, ensuring higher-quality solutions over traditional optimizers.
|
Learning-to-Optimize, Distributed Optimization, Large-Scale Quadratic Programming
|
We propose DeepDistributedQP, a new deep learning-aided distributed optimization architecture for large-scale quadratic programming.
| 13,359 |
2412.12156
|
[
-0.04030890762805939,
-0.04240623116493225,
0.01210768986493349,
0.0451706200838089,
0.040862683206796646,
0.05614558234810829,
0.0015913713723421097,
-0.005995383020490408,
-0.0181796345859766,
-0.04013751074671745,
-0.015498592518270016,
0.004978114273399115,
-0.07124150544404984,
0.008070665411651134,
0.013837325386703014,
0.06536597013473511,
0.029251135885715485,
0.0015862503787502646,
-0.0207565575838089,
0.007535841781646013,
0.020273998379707336,
-0.04298638179898262,
0.028486669063568115,
0.03388834372162819,
0.024486806243658066,
-0.005345236975699663,
0.009188964031636715,
0.03432302549481392,
-0.012646119110286236,
-0.01480411272495985,
0.030804643407464027,
-0.013445145450532436,
0.0390617772936821,
-0.0246525127440691,
-0.0011522386921569705,
0.030381711199879646,
-0.013787501491606236,
0.009761965833604336,
-0.001766846515238285,
0.009084494784474373,
-0.015167313627898693,
0.014767124317586422,
-0.029365239664912224,
0.042454794049263,
-0.04052344337105751,
0.03151401877403259,
-0.09145345538854599,
0.011898337863385677,
-0.003892392385751009,
-0.048831697553396225,
-0.11096368730068207,
0.028987929224967957,
0.019140690565109253,
-0.011656427755951881,
-0.005153089761734009,
0.04886239767074585,
0.029609164223074913,
-0.10841447114944458,
-0.03250297158956528,
-0.07185773551464081,
-0.020818468183279037,
0.04271795600652695,
0.029231373220682144,
0.004890309181064367,
-0.002520996378734708,
0.011268737725913525,
0.011376217007637024,
0.046973541378974915,
-0.040183357894420624,
-0.011333893053233624,
-0.02029476873576641,
-0.00759801734238863,
0.01647697575390339,
-0.012227168306708336,
-0.027296891435980797,
-0.03908723220229149,
0.0035333773121237755,
0.020114222541451454,
0.06161365285515785,
-0.008730990812182426,
0.01857926696538925,
0.012232491746544838,
-0.030866285786032677,
0.05504798889160156,
-0.00562529219314456,
0.018931493163108826,
-0.057395853102207184,
-0.015261645428836346,
-0.08158060163259506,
0.06359867006540298,
-0.0011100559495389462,
-0.04273749515414238,
0.007086528930813074,
0.0425867885351181,
0.0027586077339947224,
0.006548060569912195,
0.04103856906294823,
-0.0016578431241214275,
0.020272281020879745,
0.00471953721717,
0.007289578672498465,
-0.04276558384299278,
0.019657479599118233,
-0.014286412857472897,
-0.09858442097902298,
-0.0153945442289114,
-0.028529584407806396,
-0.039270855486392975,
-0.009686972014605999,
-0.003777948208153248,
-0.044960252940654755,
0.025828730314970016,
0.006459221243858337,
-0.037100374698638916,
-0.08352609723806381,
0.03657936677336693,
0.007660580333322287,
0.012600068002939224,
0.0013687084428966045,
-0.012420721352100372,
0.02594289369881153,
0.03572792187333107,
-0.015067096799612045,
0.0713403970003128,
0.01587572507560253,
0.0419948548078537,
0.05578707531094551,
0.010204458609223366,
-0.04019249975681305,
-0.01835625432431698,
0.022498169913887978,
0.03004523366689682,
0.0089124059304595,
0.001306531485170126,
-0.021886590868234634,
-0.032432328909635544,
-0.006166186183691025,
0.004129049833863974,
0.026937566697597504,
0.011791949160397053,
-0.034260571002960205,
-0.020025519654154778,
0.0814167782664299,
-0.029885876923799515,
0.04124904423952103,
-0.007821876555681229,
0.026287894695997238,
-0.023056576028466225,
-0.03228350728750229,
0.007571640890091658,
-0.001094851060770452,
0.007799195591360331,
-0.0181215051561594,
-0.06714823096990585,
0.024892915040254593,
0.03552571311593056,
0.03175821900367737,
0.0290298443287611,
-0.00805679988116026,
0.030341651290655136,
0.03049238957464695,
-0.010976599529385567,
-0.056621063500642776,
-0.02043517865240574,
-0.03275055065751076,
-0.061078812927007675,
0.0424874871969223,
0.03301876410841942,
-0.01386695820838213,
-0.03708576783537865,
-0.031114649027585983,
-0.04919062554836273,
0.04923080652952194,
0.00021549662051256746,
0.003023423021659255,
-0.012883125804364681,
0.06382360309362411,
-0.0072781085036695,
0.030621429905295372,
0.057271748781204224,
-0.0900794193148613,
0.018785418942570686,
0.005279973149299622,
0.005669741425663233,
0.00486683938652277,
-0.018464358523488045,
0.0828719437122345,
-0.01972142979502678,
0.0127083295956254,
0.007339689414948225,
-0.07693024724721909,
-0.014909278601408005,
-0.0059374975971877575,
-0.013120382092893124,
0.05927359312772751,
0.01007179357111454,
-0.039251334965229034,
0.0272201057523489,
0.011729623191058636,
0.03957473114132881,
0.06954321265220642,
-0.045856934040784836,
0.030583864077925682,
-0.0099112493917346,
-0.05432786047458649,
0.014270732179284096,
0.045041751116514206,
-0.015023835934698582,
-0.018862802535295486,
0.004501483403146267,
-0.030818045139312744,
-0.009994392283260822,
-0.024125883355736732,
0.0013679139083251357,
0.05509543791413307,
-0.020957978442311287,
-0.018240418285131454,
0.01899101957678795,
0.02492736279964447,
-0.040752992033958435,
0.040792811661958694,
0.017330272123217583,
0.008359063416719437,
0.0377519316971302,
-0.04022404924035072,
0.08035748451948166,
0.06255035847425461,
-0.04811530187726021,
-0.001769124181009829,
0.028116287663578987,
0.030390586704015732,
0.04402964934706688,
0.01631719246506691,
-0.021828338503837585,
0.015528366900980473,
-0.008678155019879341,
-0.0025438403245061636,
-0.026403870433568954,
0.061865273863077164,
-0.02217603661119938,
-0.019319456070661545,
0.05667900666594505,
-0.006420101970434189,
0.07415919750928879,
-0.008925854228436947,
-0.015817996114492416,
0.045304231345653534,
0.009203310124576092,
-0.03526439890265465,
-0.0428750179708004,
-0.0423145517706871,
0.018096333369612694,
-0.0019176029600203037,
0.00411607138812542,
0.009684354066848755,
-0.08282265067100525,
0.023472534492611885,
0.0017192645464092493,
0.0801384299993515,
0.060318607836961746,
-0.0015337617369368672,
0.02640608698129654,
0.016987906768918037,
-0.027992162853479385,
-0.024900320917367935,
-0.12777787446975708,
-0.05210885778069496,
0.016035499051213264,
0.04644746705889702,
0.0004817064618691802,
0.0546099990606308,
-0.03175737336277962,
0.021657314151525497,
-0.04481642320752144,
-0.027061691507697105,
0.011547456495463848,
0.024029960855841637,
0.010691062547266483,
-0.014064231887459755,
-0.022456005215644836,
0.027594735845923424,
0.07661544531583786,
-0.02520674653351307,
-0.0012796109076589346,
-0.001442087348550558,
-0.04450121894478798,
0.0009706621640361845,
-0.05356767401099205,
0.024788450449705124,
0.006165959406644106,
0.004847257398068905,
0.0232748594135046,
-0.045412808656692505,
0.051068857312202454,
0.03748401254415512,
0.04860521852970123,
0.05249687656760216,
0.006622880231589079,
-0.01308393944054842,
0.009840973652899265,
-0.015319856815040112,
-0.004042911343276501,
-0.04019705206155777,
0.01732099987566471,
-0.031316470354795456,
-0.005922510754317045,
0.02582651749253273,
-0.012257152236998081,
-0.25968578457832336,
-0.00862998329102993,
0.01221265085041523,
0.038563694804906845,
0.06198114901781082,
-0.014784792438149452,
0.018467236310243607,
-0.01689828746020794,
-0.044670067727565765,
-0.011001985520124435,
-0.006794247776269913,
0.01502730417996645,
-0.0017670737579464912,
0.05683459714055061,
0.028979070484638214,
0.04516637697815895,
-0.016101302579045296,
-0.023890050128102303,
0.005330338142812252,
0.014528198167681694,
-0.0013749998761340976,
-0.09724476933479309,
-0.018726684153079987,
0.020294057205319405,
0.001685029943473637,
0.0625476986169815,
-0.07927922159433365,
-0.003891406813636422,
-0.021500373259186745,
0.008699765428900719,
-0.012658516876399517,
-0.02428390644490719,
-0.024608168751001358,
0.05133756250143051,
0.0124661261215806,
-0.0028692639898508787,
-0.0022492927964776754,
-0.03801535442471504,
0.040997352451086044,
0.03401736915111542,
-0.02218107134103775,
-0.011056788265705109,
-0.036780454218387604,
-0.017111551016569138,
0.05532824248075485,
0.0421927236020565,
-0.05164492130279541,
-0.02874266915023327,
-0.010394657962024212,
0.021331757307052612,
0.0448404885828495,
-0.03456113114953041,
0.008115892298519611,
0.00528223579749465,
0.015339662320911884,
-0.034799374639987946,
-0.022568318992853165,
-0.013821642845869064,
0.01753903366625309,
0.02082512155175209,
0.025631435215473175,
-0.027992092072963715,
-0.006418974604457617,
-0.051838845014572144,
-0.002127930521965027,
-0.027440393343567848,
-0.06921308487653732,
-0.07301194220781326,
0.025799015536904335,
0.04016747325658798,
0.008257313631474972,
-0.0013765052426606417,
-0.029185526072978973,
-0.09752433747053146,
-0.013737043365836143,
0.013333568349480629,
-0.014702103100717068,
-0.018875954672694206,
0.011851383373141289,
0.0475042499601841,
-0.03377697244286537,
-0.06764572113752365,
0.014178292825818062,
0.01206060592085123,
0.016509341076016426,
-0.04917682707309723,
0.022206442430615425,
-0.05274366959929466,
-0.017746243625879288,
-0.03963683545589447,
0.03912338241934776,
-0.02146410010755062,
0.059207431972026825,
-0.026815572753548622,
0.056524403393268585,
0.032194022089242935,
0.015091653913259506,
0.04323191940784454,
0.02117219753563404,
0.02543237805366516,
0.007928885519504547,
-0.06221143528819084,
-0.025942621752619743,
-0.05774104967713356,
-0.03934474661946297,
0.005704640876501799,
-0.033070970326662064,
-0.011520398780703545,
0.04307306557893753,
-0.0012463999446481466,
-0.010033195838332176,
-0.05328308790922165,
0.01607421226799488,
-0.05214507505297661,
-0.03851102292537689,
-0.01809472218155861,
0.0019290449563413858,
0.05421942099928856,
0.02695932425558567,
-0.009327523410320282,
-0.02135905809700489,
0.06834167242050171,
0.001443539746105671,
0.011882610619068146,
-0.017157627269625664,
0.01157043781131506,
-0.0008946325397118926,
-0.016060976311564445,
0.01473249588161707,
-0.007880335673689842,
0.022983543574810028,
0.05063268914818764,
0.0011557647958397865,
0.005675869062542915,
0.01190231554210186,
-0.02065109834074974,
-0.014677158556878567,
-0.021713901311159134,
0.03877640888094902,
0.003871927736327052,
0.05289729684591293,
0.01499913726001978,
0.012160832062363625,
-0.008831505663692951,
-0.0024928641505539417,
0.03348449245095253,
0.026168499141931534,
0.04050275683403015,
-0.02264506183564663,
-0.012440770864486694,
0.013372792862355709,
-0.0425463430583477,
-0.011040735989809036,
-0.004987014457583427,
0.01781405881047249,
-0.0072194370441138744,
0.06542859971523285,
-0.014802678488194942,
0.00810304842889309,
-0.057082466781139374,
0.02313629910349846,
0.005104684270918369,
-0.0018952690297737718,
0.0016915705054998398,
0.040532395243644714,
0.0609455369412899,
0.0010282712755724788,
-0.0012960756430402398,
-0.01690741814672947,
-0.00031631827005185187,
0.006679905112832785,
-0.028745552524924278,
-0.05084385722875595,
-0.023447314277291298,
-0.031141644343733788,
-0.0050230128690600395,
0.011598161421716213,
-0.05501474440097809,
-0.039112918078899384,
0.03517924249172211,
0.024947885423898697,
-0.019129952415823936,
0.006226418539881706,
0.02302372083067894,
0.06633643060922623,
0.0012193993898108602,
-0.009152396582067013,
0.023613542318344116,
-0.015605838038027287,
0.027212349697947502,
0.007528586313128471,
0.020240798592567444,
-0.035003408789634705,
-0.02509312704205513,
0.003505328670144081,
-0.01336679607629776,
0.017908966168761253,
0.04549894854426384,
-0.013912287540733814,
0.010754233226180077,
-0.036774590611457825,
0.012390793301165104,
-0.05292065441608429,
0.019661495462059975,
0.027053380385041237,
-0.069700688123703,
0.01398021075874567,
0.045695774257183075,
-0.006615309976041317,
0.029900632798671722,
-0.03544700890779495,
-0.047016918659210205,
-0.04397115856409073,
0.018810570240020752,
0.007185623049736023,
-0.010867033153772354,
-0.0052829766646027565,
0.026502780616283417,
-0.01915043778717518,
0.005125654861330986,
0.013219384476542473,
0.0037857748102396727,
0.00381458573974669,
-0.03628493845462799,
-0.03218449279665947,
0.08603822439908981,
-0.045747339725494385,
0.002385268220677972,
-0.002513563958927989,
0.013309287838637829,
0.016778212040662766,
-0.045663561671972275,
-0.005103718489408493,
0.03559716418385506,
-0.001800848520360887,
0.03848695382475853,
-0.06089012697339058,
0.030220432206988335,
-0.052552495151758194,
-0.0507553368806839,
-0.027795691043138504,
-0.0173215102404356,
-0.025645211338996887,
0.005475918296724558,
-0.02788669802248478,
0.020774569362401962,
0.012288165278732777,
0.034966062754392624,
0.03475203737616539,
-0.009590156376361847,
0.022691071033477783,
0.013828475959599018,
-0.061115752905607224,
-0.021536797285079956,
0.04201727733016014,
-0.0019103356171399355,
-0.02051578275859356,
-0.06111595034599304,
-0.012419585138559341,
0.022988731041550636,
-0.07367099076509476,
0.06206952780485153,
-0.0504375658929348,
0.03221845254302025,
0.02022215723991394,
0.050512585788965225,
0.010471033863723278,
-0.009526167064905167,
0.04927635192871094,
-0.037817467004060745,
0.006812324747443199,
-0.08176665008068085,
-0.003825940191745758,
0.04874679818749428,
-0.019647015258669853,
0.01858893223106861,
0.027767177671194077,
-0.03536617383360863,
0.05950717628002167,
-0.013330348767340183,
-0.05558598041534424,
0.025385471060872078,
-0.04416872560977936,
-0.0029897200874984264,
0.048056185245513916,
-0.04867091029882431,
-0.03310190886259079,
-0.003231869777664542,
-0.04597165808081627,
0.008243721909821033,
0.01333234366029501,
0.026929881423711777,
-0.00047784141497686505,
-0.010575590655207634,
-0.0340145006775856,
0.02251998521387577,
0.027054715901613235,
0.026658060029149055,
0.026360470801591873,
0.01134821493178606,
-0.021611293777823448,
0.05104954168200493,
0.04960402846336365,
0.044489216059446335,
-0.0027068271301686764,
0.028097959235310555,
-0.03779510781168938,
-0.04285234957933426,
0.03697708994150162,
-0.003664514049887657,
-0.0045655700378119946,
-0.058731935918331146,
0.015316205099225044,
0.02009252831339836,
-0.04040692374110222,
-0.0060908677987754345,
0.0034611832816153765,
-0.05500049516558647,
-0.013671756722033024,
0.008615732192993164,
0.008611204102635384,
0.016440751031041145,
0.06818794459104538,
0.030885091051459312,
0.0384720079600811,
0.07705127447843552,
0.03527235612273216,
-0.037258580327034,
0.020157145336270332,
0.08915069699287415,
0.044231344014406204,
0.036924105137586594,
-0.027009017765522003,
0.06460034102201462,
-0.04503976181149483,
-0.043512992560863495,
0.007780976127833128,
0.014716068282723427,
-0.04461849853396416,
-0.017583297565579414,
-0.013496643863618374,
0.07752985507249832,
-0.01441951934248209,
0.046972595155239105,
-0.04370861127972603,
-0.011506658978760242,
0.030476734042167664,
0.01604326069355011,
-0.013599068857729435,
0.06403438746929169,
0.015568898990750313,
0.04288840666413307,
-0.026886243373155594,
-0.038294028490781784,
0.0013450994156301022,
0.027674783021211624,
0.006075180601328611,
0.039237603545188904,
0.016445422545075417,
0.009098152630031109,
0.016531601548194885,
0.0017051880713552237,
0.09741447865962982,
-0.051190368831157684,
-0.03853869065642357,
-0.01019122451543808,
-0.004650217480957508,
-0.02311686798930168,
0.017428331077098846,
0.009261386469006538,
-0.06921949237585068,
0.012410142458975315,
-0.03052418678998947,
0.027516406029462814,
0.035638973116874695,
0.021764852106571198,
0.029858842492103577,
-0.032669052481651306,
0.011640530079603195,
0.02481616660952568,
0.025063592940568924,
-0.02096073515713215,
-0.050873540341854095,
-0.017824538052082062,
-0.068979911506176,
-0.032818328589200974,
-0.08140560239553452,
0.030891330912709236,
0.0071451906114816666,
-0.033690858632326126,
0.0002998221025336534,
-0.00552017567679286,
0.020255688577890396,
0.012794374488294125,
-0.0498664453625679,
0.002535840030759573,
0.03078056313097477,
-0.020597582682967186,
0.006690178997814655,
0.020077228546142578,
0.022504620254039764,
-0.01619747281074524,
0.004632068332284689,
0.03634819760918617,
0.013810543343424797,
-0.016311222687363625,
-0.013246426358819008,
-0.014176882803440094,
-0.07306994497776031,
-0.006517352536320686,
0.006949062924832106,
-0.06066915765404701,
-0.08392401039600372,
0.02893149107694626,
-0.0077757276594638824,
0.04728960990905762,
0.049316052347421646,
-0.006927365902811289,
0.02660258859395981,
-0.04044133424758911,
-0.020571408793330193,
-0.007684370037168264,
-0.005850519519299269,
0.026341119781136513,
-0.024997767060995102,
0.04009820520877838,
0.04405846446752548,
-0.022988587617874146,
-0.0395544096827507,
0.05290083959698677,
0.01356547512114048,
-0.010685602203011513,
0.0005300974007695913,
-0.015535825863480568,
-0.032831788063049316,
-0.10654773563146591,
-0.017300302162766457,
0.018471842631697655,
-0.042689356952905655,
-0.05166458338499069,
-0.000040237195207737386,
-0.0010556528577581048,
0.026661334559321404,
-0.01781986467540264,
-0.020414892584085464,
-0.03183368965983391,
-0.03228210285305977,
-0.015415335074067116,
-0.06724924594163895,
0.048118144273757935,
0.016813915222883224,
-0.008025900460779667,
-0.017849424853920937,
-0.07542568445205688,
-0.026343626901507378,
0.00023547736054752022,
0.04738740622997284,
0.009659603238105774,
0.021710794419050217,
-0.002249327953904867
] |
345 |
Dynamic Loss-Based Sample Reweighting for Improved Large Language Model Pretraining
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=gU4ZgQNsOC
|
[
"Daouda Sow",
"Herbert Woisetschläger",
"Saikiran Bulusu",
"Shiqiang Wang",
"Hans Arno Jacobsen",
"Yingbin Liang"
] |
Poster
|
Pretraining large language models (LLMs) on vast and heterogeneous datasets is crucial for achieving state-of-the-art performance across diverse downstream tasks. However, current training paradigms treat all samples equally, overlooking the importance or relevance of individual samples throughout the training process. Existing reweighting strategies, which primarily focus on group-level data importance, fail to leverage fine-grained instance-level information and do not adapt dynamically to individual sample importance as training progresses. In this paper, we introduce novel algorithms for dynamic, instance-level data reweighting aimed at improving both the efficiency and effectiveness of LLM pretraining. Our methods adjust the weight of each training sample based on its loss value in an online fashion, allowing the model to dynamically focus on more informative or important samples at the current training stage. In particular, our framework allows us to systematically devise reweighting strategies deprioritizing redundant or uninformative data, which we find tend to work best.
Furthermore, we develop a new theoretical framework for analyzing the impact of loss-based reweighting on the convergence of gradient-based optimization, providing the first formal characterization of how these strategies affect convergence bounds. We empirically validate our approach across a spectrum of tasks, from pretraining 7B and 1.4B parameter LLMs to smaller-scale language models and linear regression problems, demonstrating that our loss-based reweighting approach can lead to faster convergence and significantly improved performance.
|
sample reweighing, large language models, pretraining
|
We propose new loss-based sample reweighing techniques for improved efficiency and effectiveness of LLMs pretraining.
| 13,352 |
2502.06733
|
[
-0.03604428842663765,
-0.03326087072491646,
0.022672139108181,
0.044750895351171494,
0.031202487647533417,
0.04587535187602043,
0.0028622839599847794,
0.011651894077658653,
-0.02339542657136917,
-0.008691429160535336,
-0.031472109258174896,
0.027182430028915405,
-0.07025250792503357,
0.0038060275837779045,
0.004093109630048275,
0.048297543078660965,
0.04251269996166229,
-0.00765050295740366,
0.028782814741134644,
0.04419204965233803,
0.01913389191031456,
-0.03234034404158592,
0.03182932734489441,
0.013624358922243118,
0.03703819960355759,
-0.0021582588087767363,
0.04696542024612427,
0.0037681814283132553,
-0.03538846597075462,
-0.006262525916099548,
0.028428081423044205,
-0.0145806185901165,
0.03857293352484703,
0.0012525425991043448,
0.005295658949762583,
0.0033431751653552055,
-0.015521378256380558,
0.0061609563417732716,
0.01925741136074066,
0.0375874787569046,
-0.01920550875365734,
0.016398675739765167,
-0.012968954630196095,
0.03350941836833954,
-0.0558168888092041,
0.015341220423579216,
-0.12415461987257004,
0.01518989633768797,
0.014966625720262527,
-0.06327008455991745,
-0.12331069260835648,
0.04002758860588074,
0.005053963046520948,
-0.025381023064255714,
0.02258245460689068,
0.029386289417743683,
0.03196599334478378,
-0.10464859753847122,
-0.018478814512491226,
-0.031102316454052925,
-0.04152325168251991,
0.026569616049528122,
0.004287353251129389,
0.018585335463285446,
0.007587088271975517,
-0.026339352130889893,
0.03132903575897217,
0.041051674634218216,
-0.06402993947267532,
-0.05263042077422142,
-0.02353682368993759,
0.011272553354501724,
-0.025916224345564842,
0.023073835298419,
0.01745104044675827,
-0.03533458337187767,
-0.00905125867575407,
0.02364468015730381,
0.06947144865989685,
0.013218211010098457,
-0.009800058789551258,
0.01951012574136257,
0.01995886117219925,
0.0356844998896122,
0.03669816255569458,
0.016702335327863693,
-0.038328371942043304,
-0.057606153190135956,
-0.08488598465919495,
0.023180438205599785,
-0.024900421500205994,
-0.04715312644839287,
0.0263704564422369,
0.026318145915865898,
0.022471057251095772,
0.0061616129241883755,
0.021198695525527,
0.02661101520061493,
-0.011351390741765499,
-0.01752643659710884,
-0.03295091167092323,
-0.03549417853355408,
0.028510238975286484,
0.010120172053575516,
-0.11667940765619278,
-0.016096206381917,
-0.011892852373421192,
0.018321696668863297,
-0.012217470444738865,
-0.0058011263608932495,
-0.012121390551328659,
-0.007916390895843506,
0.01852906309068203,
-0.01715106889605522,
-0.07147129625082016,
-0.005610629916191101,
0.010499861091375351,
0.016663579270243645,
-0.019069408997893333,
0.011570438742637634,
0.04483398422598839,
0.043090879917144775,
0.02379903383553028,
0.07353484630584717,
-0.047391828149557114,
0.015036391094326973,
0.02793455682694912,
0.05019793286919594,
-0.04442116245627403,
-0.012989130802452564,
0.024554070085287094,
0.039860185235738754,
0.009929480031132698,
0.01788802072405815,
-0.007627447601407766,
-0.0009043628815561533,
0.004398199263960123,
0.023151759058237076,
0.0774373784661293,
0.02100393734872341,
-0.0012542030308395624,
-0.0054471129551529884,
0.056598588824272156,
-0.016607128083705902,
0.032779350876808167,
0.0015278421342372894,
-0.027858654037117958,
-0.021878808736801147,
-0.054322823882102966,
-0.012566603720188141,
0.032062068581581116,
0.00768738379701972,
-0.011907405219972134,
-0.05899830535054207,
0.018648356199264526,
0.05821247771382332,
-0.005685857031494379,
-0.0051058330573141575,
-0.006064704153686762,
0.035013869404792786,
0.006137211807072163,
0.010083658620715141,
-0.05228038132190704,
0.009366882964968681,
-0.014325838536024094,
-0.08121642470359802,
0.037321414798498154,
0.01817755214869976,
-0.03535904735326767,
-0.0012394163059070706,
-0.04899604991078377,
-0.04191499203443527,
0.0704398974776268,
-0.017586171627044678,
-0.0071523734368383884,
-0.021837301552295685,
0.06310485303401947,
0.02480621449649334,
0.020075814798474312,
0.037350211292505264,
-0.07635264843702316,
0.01493026502430439,
0.029925942420959473,
0.01034194603562355,
0.03259117528796196,
-0.018510891124606133,
0.08945533633232117,
-0.04425600916147232,
0.014531522057950497,
0.021888073533773422,
-0.08075353503227234,
-0.00508714048191905,
0.025088869035243988,
-0.001099580666050315,
0.05832589417695999,
0.013655038550496101,
0.020351290702819824,
0.04470951482653618,
0.021195387467741966,
0.029590504243969917,
0.0764988362789154,
-0.01784409023821354,
0.03837253525853157,
-0.017740923911333084,
-0.03624485060572624,
0.005695917643606663,
0.020556489005684853,
-0.061683524399995804,
-0.05300763621926308,
0.014655359089374542,
-0.02804412506520748,
0.013243974186480045,
0.01774693839251995,
0.0022973278537392616,
0.00945393554866314,
-0.016709187999367714,
0.009152404963970184,
0.014268143102526665,
0.0074490951374173164,
-0.045357391238212585,
0.06431135535240173,
0.02341718226671219,
-0.006884826812893152,
0.0009429016499780118,
-0.03275883197784424,
0.09065501391887665,
0.0645313486456871,
0.003350082552060485,
0.003459218190982938,
0.011264501139521599,
0.007141947280615568,
0.00811141636222601,
0.01796761341392994,
-0.035109441727399826,
0.0034234041813760996,
-0.010702897794544697,
-0.024344902485609055,
-0.048151299357414246,
0.03934665396809578,
-0.03789494186639786,
0.015904735773801804,
0.07463701069355011,
-0.014041797257959843,
0.052923668175935745,
-0.008546456694602966,
0.01799040101468563,
0.05040779709815979,
-0.0018254760652780533,
-0.018283898010849953,
-0.044108349829912186,
-0.001521265716291964,
0.007298874668776989,
-0.016772842034697533,
-0.014027685858309269,
-0.00660658348351717,
-0.02467092126607895,
-0.026418766006827354,
-0.013858948834240437,
0.06158408895134926,
0.05531923100352287,
0.0068210214376449585,
0.02870219014585018,
-0.0014055565698072314,
-0.053249772638082504,
-0.005853310227394104,
-0.1053004339337349,
-0.0374167263507843,
-0.0137014864012599,
0.04306349903345108,
-0.011322456412017345,
0.03993724659085274,
0.007402532733976841,
0.0059968470595777035,
-0.024156417697668076,
-0.022766606882214546,
-0.00040037636063061655,
0.031549856066703796,
0.0022729274351149797,
-0.042836084961891174,
-0.005917771719396114,
-0.007485631387680769,
0.040931254625320435,
-0.02209402620792389,
-0.039533719420433044,
-0.03568436577916145,
-0.049498774111270905,
-0.020251723006367683,
-0.04372585192322731,
0.021339217200875282,
0.00661097327247262,
0.019579634070396423,
0.016094163060188293,
-0.021947083994746208,
0.0007010846748016775,
0.045838307589292526,
0.04060668498277664,
0.061477139592170715,
0.017796741798520088,
0.0006470545777119696,
0.04029252752661705,
-0.033532433211803436,
0.00939946062862873,
0.00018197343160863966,
0.04618631303310394,
-0.026600094512104988,
-0.027339991182088852,
0.010719897225499153,
0.010984819382429123,
-0.24458715319633484,
-0.02528292126953602,
0.008012091740965843,
0.003458048915490508,
0.0497749038040638,
-0.02190268598496914,
0.05284687876701355,
-0.03353244811296463,
-0.03974366933107376,
0.02838711626827717,
0.006299805361777544,
0.048876989632844925,
0.012945633381605148,
0.03768730163574219,
0.059583880007267,
0.0643463134765625,
0.0010220966069027781,
0.002385273575782776,
0.009779232554137707,
0.037465400993824005,
-0.011587371118366718,
-0.0659407451748848,
0.0067971814423799515,
0.08303781598806381,
-0.020501574501395226,
0.1004209965467453,
-0.09090691059827805,
0.004935314413160086,
-0.023158399388194084,
-0.01283897366374731,
-0.008341250009834766,
-0.03544982895255089,
-0.012229475192725658,
0.02432793192565441,
0.007390302140265703,
0.011915720999240875,
0.03676527366042137,
0.023900676518678665,
0.03463354334235191,
0.020416010171175003,
0.015759902074933052,
-0.024642495438456535,
-0.026047056540846825,
-0.00422965781763196,
0.05652914568781853,
0.012746390886604786,
-0.06534915417432785,
-0.0029956893995404243,
-0.007649901323020458,
0.04118240624666214,
-0.0029585477896034718,
-0.03650438040494919,
-0.019162438809871674,
0.023356104269623756,
0.02863667532801628,
-0.016239410266280174,
-0.0017492426559329033,
-0.011549941264092922,
-0.011491852812469006,
0.012406745925545692,
-0.003147045150399208,
-0.04660855978727341,
-0.0039002641569823027,
-0.05842255428433418,
-0.022267479449510574,
-0.034990329295396805,
-0.06997368484735489,
-0.030008940026164055,
0.027859071269631386,
0.03905422240495682,
-0.033427510410547256,
0.02239854820072651,
0.0006458970601670444,
-0.07862453162670135,
0.010440202429890633,
0.0036864914000034332,
0.0083519471809268,
-0.0052921706810593605,
-0.013453036546707153,
0.062435686588287354,
-0.032188981771469116,
-0.029987942427396774,
-0.009119363501667976,
-0.019261281937360764,
0.019725870341062546,
-0.042276352643966675,
-0.0010002590715885162,
-0.018921757116913795,
-0.021034177392721176,
-0.048650097101926804,
0.02797362208366394,
0.014728986658155918,
0.01356643345206976,
0.016365734860301018,
0.03921916335821152,
0.021992221474647522,
0.010539899580180645,
0.0646379142999649,
0.039979953318834305,
-0.0012452409137040377,
0.002980452962219715,
-0.08801639825105667,
-0.03225115314126015,
-0.05613872408866882,
-0.00925176776945591,
0.02915223129093647,
-0.08249583840370178,
-0.018649449571967125,
0.015505746006965637,
-0.03032894991338253,
-0.02273309789597988,
-0.027491502463817596,
0.012335688807070255,
-0.01810402236878872,
-0.04355049878358841,
-0.013388021849095821,
-0.01707191951572895,
0.01890411786735058,
0.034444767981767654,
-0.013928987085819244,
-0.02192579209804535,
0.04721742123365402,
-0.024339502677321434,
-0.00023185052850749344,
0.000754904467612505,
-0.02990041859447956,
0.03092208318412304,
-0.01984073407948017,
-0.053897786885499954,
-0.006646020337939262,
0.028976531699299812,
0.02281798981130123,
-0.004566162824630737,
0.021760810166597366,
0.051428161561489105,
0.006207422818988562,
0.0025377150159329176,
-0.015364794991910458,
0.04599069803953171,
-0.010116265155375004,
0.007533874828368425,
-0.014415914192795753,
0.04001106321811676,
0.011869879439473152,
0.07031052559614182,
0.021364206448197365,
0.009235893376171589,
0.005279654171317816,
0.002845392795279622,
-0.004431936424225569,
0.023506030440330505,
-0.047855351120233536,
-0.0003151130222249776,
-0.015367203392088413,
0.029974691569805145,
0.017300529405474663,
0.032108843326568604,
-0.010015780106186867,
0.034448787569999695,
-0.06563367694616318,
0.06090755760669708,
0.0065451730042696,
-0.019338803365826607,
0.012136915698647499,
0.05183130502700806,
0.013922134414315224,
-0.012090795673429966,
-0.0014296233421191573,
0.034121762961149216,
0.03450683876872063,
0.00020157897961325943,
-0.02631296031177044,
-0.03939620032906532,
-0.005170502234250307,
-0.010204225778579712,
-0.009983141906559467,
0.02997676469385624,
-0.0006693067261949182,
-0.027516791597008705,
0.05538058653473854,
-0.006365887820720673,
-0.027804695069789886,
0.00024199522158596665,
0.018612075597047806,
0.09039325267076492,
0.015195020474493504,
-0.005675907712429762,
0.004578240215778351,
-0.05708896368741989,
0.03799187391996384,
-0.025293750688433647,
-0.026322849094867706,
-0.001327849691733718,
-0.04270152002573013,
-0.023780273273587227,
-0.046015337109565735,
0.006240807939320803,
0.010977931320667267,
-0.006948709487915039,
-0.0062942118383944035,
-0.03314913436770439,
0.00102987268473953,
-0.04341833293437958,
-0.02248491905629635,
0.026644714176654816,
-0.08234609663486481,
-0.005525047425180674,
0.004195197019726038,
-0.022577974945306778,
0.043598901480436325,
-0.017749853432178497,
-0.05334176495671272,
-0.045420579612255096,
-0.020009897649288177,
0.049601614475250244,
-0.04011722654104233,
-0.018870996311306953,
-0.008387082256376743,
0.025780530646443367,
-0.016133656725287437,
0.02002720534801483,
-0.009470227174460888,
-0.003821453545242548,
-0.0237277802079916,
0.004287633113563061,
0.07593096792697906,
-0.04283689707517624,
0.003231966868042946,
-0.003188760718330741,
-0.02307138592004776,
0.009406698867678642,
-0.05848170444369316,
0.01690325140953064,
0.06187555938959122,
-0.020423084497451782,
0.007801897823810577,
-0.037705156952142715,
0.048150863498449326,
0.02122373878955841,
-0.019406862556934357,
0.008888169191777706,
0.004057689104229212,
-0.012558884918689728,
0.017857152968645096,
-0.004898581653833389,
0.03021673858165741,
0.006522501818835735,
0.006386988330632448,
0.0206836499273777,
0.0096962321549654,
0.02587135136127472,
0.01793213188648224,
-0.051421236246824265,
-0.0004998689400963485,
0.060544341802597046,
-0.019783733412623405,
-0.04177621006965637,
-0.09622416645288467,
-0.03559324890375137,
-0.0025067985989153385,
-0.010852565988898277,
0.012653592973947525,
-0.020274849608540535,
0.05622202157974243,
0.019269084557890892,
0.044366784393787384,
0.009277372620999813,
-0.018894368782639503,
0.01790299452841282,
-0.05744333192706108,
-0.021990088745951653,
-0.05993456393480301,
-0.05095065385103226,
0.057737085968256,
-0.035255737602710724,
0.026331158354878426,
-0.02246907167136669,
-0.04673844575881958,
0.03077494166791439,
0.001051905914209783,
-0.05435507744550705,
-0.028609707951545715,
-0.03210993483662605,
-0.0007938605849631131,
0.040586818009614944,
-0.039095714688301086,
-0.0002635264245327562,
0.000029310309400898404,
-0.038833100348711014,
-0.01094871573150158,
0.003893272252753377,
0.04396957904100418,
-0.044036414474248886,
0.016048619523644447,
-0.056884463876485825,
-0.0009619775810278952,
-0.008006258867681026,
0.05787508934736252,
0.028353611007332802,
0.016813915222883224,
-0.03316837176680565,
0.0586390420794487,
0.011737534776329994,
-0.022295871749520302,
-0.0004344179469626397,
0.008660041727125645,
-0.01732523925602436,
-0.05586046352982521,
0.06131792813539505,
0.00934082455933094,
-0.012125527486205101,
-0.04593764245510101,
0.04786371812224388,
0.05262565240263939,
-0.046423014253377914,
-0.028618911281228065,
0.02765517309308052,
-0.0412314273416996,
0.000801568734459579,
-0.008633640594780445,
-0.012178007513284683,
-0.034814249724149704,
0.08318553119897842,
0.02897503785789013,
0.04377196356654167,
0.07045788317918777,
0.00006734700582455844,
-0.02145964838564396,
-0.007613255642354488,
0.07102607190608978,
0.07028644531965256,
0.057645730674266815,
-0.0062561724334955215,
0.05967188999056816,
-0.06624604761600494,
-0.06297789514064789,
0.028189711272716522,
0.0018061123555526137,
-0.031926851719617844,
-0.05023353174328804,
0.012290154583752155,
0.06801922619342804,
-0.0033617448061704636,
0.0664571151137352,
-0.04923482611775398,
-0.01737992651760578,
0.026719314977526665,
0.010125192813575268,
0.00860689952969551,
0.05858564004302025,
0.013813188299536705,
0.032636478543281555,
-0.03294553607702255,
-0.02630733698606491,
0.02259759046137333,
0.002025884110480547,
0.02018703706562519,
0.01049574464559555,
-0.010534334927797318,
0.005199546925723553,
-0.011146494187414646,
0.03679750859737396,
0.11080173403024673,
-0.024702439084649086,
-0.047370411455631256,
-0.01297918614000082,
0.016657419502735138,
-0.008456679061055183,
0.04310641437768936,
-0.0067273639142513275,
-0.03658772632479668,
-0.00045236069126985967,
-0.04585493355989456,
-0.008391994051635265,
0.0208295751363039,
-0.016968030482530594,
0.020085476338863373,
-0.02710990607738495,
-0.0243140310049057,
0.036175686866045,
0.039854247123003006,
-0.07195629179477692,
-0.041199423372745514,
-0.03615966811776161,
-0.05665550380945206,
-0.05329671874642372,
-0.050300776958465576,
0.038852084428071976,
0.032995063811540604,
0.021280931308865547,
0.010183143429458141,
-0.05682846158742905,
-0.010659505613148212,
0.023740021511912346,
-0.064987413585186,
-0.002022034488618374,
0.0313507616519928,
-0.02659342996776104,
-0.012067093513906002,
0.03388329595327377,
0.00419596116989851,
-0.017886830493807793,
-0.03359050676226616,
0.06013999879360199,
0.014519444666802883,
0.016595004126429558,
-0.011676729656755924,
0.0037271641194820404,
-0.09290444850921631,
0.0004654338408727199,
0.014974400401115417,
-0.06773484498262405,
-0.08131515234708786,
0.03561876714229584,
-0.00943493191152811,
0.049088336527347565,
0.04546036943793297,
0.010005548596382141,
0.016848094761371613,
-0.03134467080235481,
-0.04408200457692146,
-0.02233750931918621,
0.03329112380743027,
0.04194668307900429,
-0.004568137228488922,
0.04285794496536255,
0.038055770099163055,
-0.013513479381799698,
-0.03772420808672905,
-0.00932346936315298,
-0.012485748156905174,
-0.031086390838027,
-0.01965392753481865,
-0.01170018408447504,
-0.01808120682835579,
-0.07695524394512177,
-0.007662870921194553,
0.0019153985194861889,
0.013039522804319859,
-0.006824759766459465,
0.00848036166280508,
-0.032148439437150955,
-0.015788914635777473,
-0.013417426496744156,
-0.012503952719271183,
-0.02697961963713169,
-0.03243169188499451,
-0.035837430506944656,
-0.06803279370069504,
0.0067827836610376835,
-0.024493103846907616,
-0.0019728338811546564,
-0.01672903075814247,
-0.042540792375802994,
0.012333422899246216,
0.006255491636693478,
0.04461513087153435,
-0.003830868750810623,
-0.0009241935913451016,
-0.02090468257665634
] |
346 |
Frame-Voyager: Learning to Query Frames for Video Large Language Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=LNL7zKvm7e
|
[
"Sicheng Yu",
"CHENGKAI JIN",
"Huanyu Wang",
"Zhenghao Chen",
"Sheng Jin",
"ZHONGRONG ZUO",
"XU XIAOLEI",
"Zhenbang Sun",
"Bingni Zhang",
"Jiawei Wu",
"Hao Zhang",
"Qianru Sun"
] |
Poster
|
Video Large Language Models (Video-LLMs) have made remarkable progress in video understanding tasks. However, they are constrained by the maximum length of input tokens, making it impractical to input entire videos. Existing frame selection approaches, such as uniform frame sampling and text-frame retrieval, fail to account for the information density variations in the videos or the complex instructions in the tasks, leading to sub-optimal performance. In this paper, we propose Frame-Voyager that learns to query informative frame combinations, based on the given textual queries in the task. To train Frame-Voyager, we introduce a new data collection and labeling pipeline, by ranking frame combinations using a pre-trained Video-LLM. Given a video of M frames, we traverse its T-frame combinations, feed them into a Video-LLM, and rank them based on Video-LLM's prediction losses. Using this ranking as supervision, we train Frame-Voyager to query the frame combinations with lower losses. In experiments, we evaluate Frame-Voyager on four Video Question Answering benchmarks by plugging it into two different Video-LLMs. The experimental results demonstrate that Frame-Voyager achieves impressive results in all settings, highlighting its potential as a plug-and-play solution for Video-LLMs.
|
Video-LLM, Adaptive Frame Sampling
|
Frame-Voyager queries optimal frame combinations for Video-LLMs based on task-specific queries, outperforming existing SOTA methods and achieving best results in Video Question Answering benchmarks as a plug-and-play solution.
| 13,344 | null |
[
0.012050231918692589,
-0.0032149930484592915,
0.008856258355081081,
0.05638136342167854,
0.039485860615968704,
0.01733453758060932,
0.016226470470428467,
0.0182703398168087,
-0.008280111476778984,
-0.01170314010232687,
-0.02809492126107216,
0.02321479469537735,
-0.05676724761724472,
0.024854356423020363,
0.016896452754735947,
0.041788190603256226,
0.030600471422076225,
0.008757696487009525,
0.022221164777874947,
0.0092525789514184,
0.007356845773756504,
-0.021293779835104942,
0.043202806264162064,
-0.010042214766144753,
0.01623896136879921,
-0.015189786441624165,
-0.004284349735826254,
0.04955665022134781,
-0.04197691008448601,
-0.0057775769382715225,
0.030075136572122574,
-0.039753228425979614,
0.008422278799116611,
-0.024967128410935402,
0.018707487732172012,
-0.02559196949005127,
-0.0170130617916584,
0.015209287405014038,
0.01572497934103012,
0.003431977704167366,
-0.04326644167304039,
-0.0018747113645076752,
-0.0002560752909630537,
-0.008412246592342854,
-0.07350847870111465,
0.03231567144393921,
-0.07457063347101212,
0.028771165758371353,
0.013497605919837952,
-0.057274896651506424,
-0.08724591881036758,
0.05657721310853958,
-0.0007414749125018716,
-0.01690942607820034,
0.016444053500890732,
0.006953830365091562,
0.06538300961256027,
-0.11642172187566757,
0.005329515319317579,
-0.006996121723204851,
-0.00678974436596036,
0.04930226132273674,
0.038458582013845444,
0.023490004241466522,
0.013857215642929077,
-0.0633670836687088,
-0.029509641230106354,
0.048676036298274994,
-0.05237197130918503,
-0.04195808991789818,
-0.0005572965019382536,
0.012190575711429119,
-0.012457533739507198,
-0.002978324191644788,
0.024041619151830673,
-0.0074071637354791164,
0.0002945899323094636,
0.015445084311068058,
0.05774744600057602,
-0.034923624247312546,
0.004690709989517927,
0.04947486147284508,
0.03125293552875519,
0.06791011244058609,
-0.0027090422809123993,
0.04845740273594856,
-0.039916086941957474,
-0.04462527111172676,
-0.07006370276212692,
0.019724860787391663,
-0.03419680893421173,
-0.031900569796562195,
-0.011208943091332912,
0.025503305718302727,
-0.0004814344283659011,
-0.006151977926492691,
0.0041884626261889935,
0.02368125133216381,
0.039502326399087906,
-0.005749244708567858,
-0.059209469705820084,
-0.07200844585895538,
0.03795376792550087,
0.002445615828037262,
-0.10536416620016098,
-0.035134412348270416,
-0.0005368369165807962,
-0.010202622972428799,
0.030109122395515442,
0.006817798130214214,
-0.023821458220481873,
0.0009509176015853882,
0.028488315641880035,
-0.012056682258844376,
-0.042726919054985046,
0.0281794685870409,
0.0018504710169509053,
-0.002120557939633727,
-0.03454901650547981,
0.00490401778370142,
0.010194044560194016,
0.04146473854780197,
0.000015235011233016849,
0.07125876843929291,
-0.02497514709830284,
0.02558254636824131,
0.011600013822317123,
0.026313476264476776,
-0.052576109766960144,
-0.05247708410024643,
-0.0030463330913335085,
0.050713762640953064,
-0.012888743542134762,
0.032010797411203384,
-0.007818241603672504,
0.0015125463251024485,
0.024160580709576607,
-0.019739605486392975,
0.024090949445962906,
-0.03580961748957634,
0.0008664716733619571,
-0.003981785848736763,
0.02839468978345394,
-0.006556322798132896,
0.10788755863904953,
0.005412915255874395,
-0.0277452040463686,
-0.023990053683519363,
-0.05474090576171875,
-0.01868428662419319,
0.009306909516453743,
-0.005363833624869585,
0.03545770421624184,
-0.05132570117712021,
-0.007724630646407604,
0.030889669433236122,
-0.0054536801762878895,
0.0052397106774151325,
-0.00016424935893155634,
-0.024543600156903267,
-0.019744647666811943,
0.008335191756486893,
-0.023699991405010223,
0.026010312139987946,
-0.007163386791944504,
-0.06203734502196312,
0.03192427009344101,
0.014623238705098629,
-0.03367709368467331,
0.028903039172291756,
-0.022204702720046043,
-0.021513966843485832,
0.037766408175230026,
-0.01448619831353426,
-0.06847991794347763,
0.016946347430348396,
0.0727919340133667,
0.03469034656882286,
0.040713679045438766,
0.013028874062001705,
-0.0779179111123085,
0.023888351395726204,
-0.006314725615084171,
-0.01272501703351736,
0.02766207978129387,
-0.019141782075166702,
0.08114828914403915,
-0.03272656351327896,
-0.026975296437740326,
-0.00822142418473959,
-0.07003449648618698,
-0.017852390184998512,
-0.007103441748768091,
0.002311880001798272,
0.04121777415275574,
-0.01960686407983303,
0.036469411104917526,
0.03575339913368225,
0.0516420342028141,
0.032370030879974365,
0.037275876849889755,
0.0021230929996818304,
0.06379563361406326,
-0.0054873209446668625,
-0.009003492072224617,
0.009075300768017769,
0.04047427326440811,
-0.03787495568394661,
0.009636303409934044,
0.010714377276599407,
-0.006476875860244036,
0.03138488531112671,
0.021591000258922577,
0.005804457236081362,
0.007067230995744467,
0.023173976689577103,
-0.0134262191131711,
0.0018877408001571894,
0.028362149372696877,
-0.030722780153155327,
0.011402237229049206,
0.0016674025682732463,
-0.02967781387269497,
-0.02228131704032421,
-0.0804608166217804,
0.08769457042217255,
0.05282185971736908,
-0.02549789659678936,
-0.02872891165316105,
0.020101407542824745,
0.008900051936507225,
0.021277669817209244,
-0.003214470576494932,
-0.028848594054579735,
-0.01150369830429554,
-0.004872485529631376,
0.02493177354335785,
-0.04717050865292549,
0.03492843359708786,
-0.05124349892139435,
-0.010098546743392944,
0.05587133765220642,
0.016935205087065697,
0.0293563399463892,
0.01744811050593853,
-0.0010900021297857165,
0.05045715346932411,
0.011415698565542698,
0.0058347503654658794,
-0.030341172590851784,
0.005051633343100548,
-0.006890473421663046,
-0.014180559664964676,
-0.026922130957245827,
0.013120605610311031,
-0.021918701007962227,
-0.03479382395744324,
-0.0014216391136869788,
0.07075753062963486,
0.06617479771375656,
0.05239711329340935,
0.05002928897738457,
0.0022605767007917166,
-0.02054821327328682,
-0.023216208443045616,
-0.08583267033100128,
-0.036625418812036514,
-0.07802493870258331,
0.004404736682772636,
0.010948163457214832,
0.021749446168541908,
0.0052006128244102,
0.029113883152604103,
-0.02197396196424961,
-0.018275951966643333,
0.01713171787559986,
0.039970144629478455,
-0.006628260016441345,
-0.029827261343598366,
-0.006488804239779711,
0.027472449466586113,
0.05092610418796539,
0.003141099354252219,
-0.041220057755708694,
-0.045184437185525894,
-0.02504848502576351,
-0.008184639737010002,
-0.029501626268029213,
0.020756375044584274,
0.02526554837822914,
0.006773628760129213,
0.02770550549030304,
-0.0374363549053669,
0.015102752484381199,
0.04177433252334595,
0.057979900389909744,
0.06454910337924957,
0.0016975045436993241,
-0.017853232100605965,
0.044493939727544785,
-0.04775884747505188,
0.014302318915724754,
-0.009779214859008789,
0.027629388496279716,
-0.01543379295617342,
0.008766737766563892,
0.019254807382822037,
-0.0020039225928485394,
-0.25705069303512573,
-0.028724074363708496,
0.019330479204654694,
0.011871092021465302,
0.031066739931702614,
-0.05805574357509613,
0.030985349789261818,
-0.06552987545728683,
-0.018063515424728394,
0.015538250096142292,
0.0266224704682827,
0.05776350200176239,
-0.014501765370368958,
0.03595909848809242,
0.06652288883924484,
0.04684895649552345,
-0.04026639834046364,
-0.025320056825876236,
0.00314467865973711,
0.0338878333568573,
0.013573745265603065,
-0.066266268491745,
-0.03769276663661003,
0.021678650751709938,
-0.01904134638607502,
0.023400768637657166,
-0.07658792287111282,
0.01209761667996645,
-0.0017728926613926888,
-0.03213031217455864,
-0.011952031403779984,
-0.020350705832242966,
-0.021472403779625893,
0.025782236829400063,
-0.012626971118152142,
0.014958225190639496,
0.0719231441617012,
-0.031714458018541336,
0.036646950989961624,
0.017415726557374,
0.007618641946464777,
-0.016258884221315384,
-0.011571386829018593,
0.020363498479127884,
0.07955190539360046,
-0.013852952048182487,
-0.054400961846113205,
-0.0049843075685203075,
-0.010140297003090382,
0.024895576760172844,
-0.0015892719384282827,
-0.00594956474378705,
-0.006075351033359766,
-0.004258970730006695,
0.029056165367364883,
-0.02505928836762905,
0.014366903342306614,
-0.02704835683107376,
-0.02372538298368454,
-0.017288751900196075,
-0.001178996404632926,
-0.055621564388275146,
-0.03957511857151985,
-0.04288772493600845,
-0.019978465512394905,
-0.04425686225295067,
-0.043511781841516495,
-0.0019213462946936488,
0.015181072056293488,
-0.009594904258847237,
-0.03378202021121979,
0.05467750132083893,
0.008298837579786777,
-0.1066143736243248,
0.010492195375263691,
0.002746136160567403,
-0.015948055312037468,
-0.009073002263903618,
-0.002929547568783164,
0.03252334147691727,
-0.020739447325468063,
-0.042505744844675064,
0.005949266254901886,
0.013588638044893742,
0.04395771026611328,
-0.04831723868846893,
0.02561057358980179,
-0.054041583091020584,
-0.009775439277291298,
-0.05184219405055046,
0.0410236120223999,
-0.06378252059221268,
0.004302031360566616,
0.04587565362453461,
0.017770253121852875,
0.04697190225124359,
-0.0023441719822585583,
0.07385735213756561,
0.04813658446073532,
0.007523042615503073,
0.02027716301381588,
-0.04915546253323555,
-0.004332069307565689,
-0.045510806143283844,
-0.00888445507735014,
0.039299126714468,
-0.0338873453438282,
-0.012010792270302773,
0.03174254298210144,
-0.001974990125745535,
-0.054387837648391724,
0.009168731980025768,
0.005443037953227758,
0.009410465136170387,
-0.02067679539322853,
-0.010115549899637699,
-0.029120024293661118,
0.03969452902674675,
0.0482383668422699,
-0.04119747132062912,
-0.020376622676849365,
0.047135625034570694,
-0.03873738646507263,
0.02646363526582718,
-0.017486916854977608,
0.004182207863777876,
0.028334634378552437,
-0.012409307062625885,
-0.0012781167170032859,
0.012964836321771145,
0.009378527291119099,
0.0008001881651580334,
0.004520822316408157,
0.026873255148530006,
0.06857750564813614,
-0.023659193888306618,
0.010192281566560268,
0.0025679515674710274,
0.04878959804773331,
-0.022307395935058594,
-0.016106294468045235,
-0.005832910072058439,
0.02651294134557247,
0.033795420080423355,
0.013895454816520214,
0.025571350008249283,
0.018317297101020813,
0.038038741797208786,
-0.0233137384057045,
-0.0010833139531314373,
0.00814108271151781,
-0.05876408517360687,
-0.02964412234723568,
-0.02622160315513611,
0.021496295928955078,
-0.03255255147814751,
0.01736261695623398,
0.009014676325023174,
0.03660382702946663,
-0.07463067770004272,
0.06357555836439133,
0.01711214706301689,
-0.0009934214176610112,
0.032303303480148315,
0.055988822132349014,
0.011025940999388695,
-0.005649672355502844,
0.015331009402871132,
0.027162257581949234,
-0.002416458213701844,
-0.00811013113707304,
-0.0248627457767725,
-0.03214479237794876,
0.006734945345669985,
0.00173335918225348,
0.021477604284882545,
-0.0098392553627491,
0.007358815986663103,
-0.03631431236863136,
0.06551220268011093,
0.026420341804623604,
-0.022963881492614746,
0.027324257418513298,
-0.01922517456114292,
0.06188260018825531,
0.023940829560160637,
-0.01586882956326008,
0.019933469593524933,
-0.040658798068761826,
0.03279644995927811,
0.007238378748297691,
0.022044546902179718,
-0.017185639590024948,
-0.03754046559333801,
-0.029483206570148468,
-0.07664171606302261,
0.027355963364243507,
-0.008648366667330265,
-0.003037448972463608,
-0.005517148412764072,
-0.04249834641814232,
0.006837311666458845,
-0.03426284343004227,
0.04346340522170067,
-0.0016867048107087612,
-0.05421578139066696,
0.022091949358582497,
0.040109433233737946,
-0.002973292488604784,
0.014085102826356888,
-0.049596983939409256,
-0.04724355414509773,
-0.0480850487947464,
-0.05514417961239815,
-0.0013691415078938007,
-0.018358170986175537,
0.010703383013606071,
-0.022953005507588387,
0.023787323385477066,
-0.019118981435894966,
0.03950018063187599,
-0.022021494805812836,
-0.010323017835617065,
-0.0205954872071743,
0.005439539905637503,
0.05307852476835251,
-0.05960605666041374,
-0.05115838348865509,
0.026754366233944893,
-0.03277545049786568,
0.01412576250731945,
-0.02833147905766964,
0.03691970184445381,
0.06490184366703033,
-0.03227805346250534,
0.010990464128553867,
-0.0678856298327446,
0.0110990134999156,
0.004476708825677633,
0.004853306338191032,
0.04927419498562813,
-0.000020820476493099704,
-0.016636911779642105,
0.02695438824594021,
-0.028616223484277725,
0.019768783822655678,
0.03410615399479866,
0.01302837673574686,
0.0057721976190805435,
-0.0005960736889392138,
0.026951614767313004,
-0.0020361465867608786,
-0.0407010018825531,
-0.03258503973484039,
0.04690004140138626,
-0.04249439388513565,
-0.023991089314222336,
-0.06839638203382492,
-0.03246612474322319,
0.04152706265449524,
-0.004920798819512129,
-0.002816184191033244,
-0.048210736364126205,
0.035954494029283524,
0.013286501169204712,
0.03864109516143799,
0.016662752255797386,
-0.013280287384986877,
0.025356639176607132,
-0.0301161278039217,
-0.006323730573058128,
-0.05248938500881195,
-0.04474443197250366,
0.06098158285021782,
-0.007526647765189409,
0.01437067799270153,
-0.007984431460499763,
-0.04452931880950928,
0.019882624968886375,
-0.02310647815465927,
-0.062680184841156,
0.020037680864334106,
-0.03493678942322731,
0.0090921176597476,
0.032346177846193314,
-0.006047449540346861,
-0.022457340732216835,
-0.0022682661656290293,
-0.043172094970941544,
-0.013629819266498089,
-0.017026083543896675,
0.055630072951316833,
-0.05969706177711487,
0.012655835598707199,
-0.035833172500133514,
-0.02070629969239235,
0.006766634993255138,
0.05255903676152229,
0.014442728832364082,
0.025310903787612915,
-0.001100294291973114,
0.032568465918302536,
0.05028611794114113,
-0.009895583614706993,
0.0335395447909832,
-0.010928190313279629,
-0.012583543546497822,
-0.060671474784612656,
0.07561544328927994,
0.007669632323086262,
-0.008828418329358101,
-0.06423739343881607,
0.07432727515697479,
0.03711060434579849,
-0.05071302503347397,
-0.00601918762549758,
0.04240383580327034,
-0.031118160113692284,
-0.011402517557144165,
-0.0023063665721565485,
-0.012996806763112545,
0.006133303511887789,
0.0728793665766716,
0.01069114450365305,
0.06782328337430954,
0.07443574070930481,
0.010865823365747929,
-0.034457977861166,
-0.0026091395411640406,
0.054341621696949005,
0.051844239234924316,
0.05586749315261841,
-0.03600430488586426,
0.06989499181509018,
-0.054546624422073364,
-0.03770459070801735,
0.029832428321242332,
0.010303388349711895,
-0.014048201963305473,
-0.03896905854344368,
0.013288745656609535,
0.07721725106239319,
-0.02094227634370327,
0.037180010229349136,
-0.03766530379652977,
-0.029026243835687637,
0.04569576308131218,
0.002298363484442234,
0.008000115863978863,
0.02564011700451374,
0.024583633989095688,
-0.014387093484401703,
-0.023541580885648727,
-0.027542486786842346,
0.006274004466831684,
0.0010656240629032254,
0.006078849080950022,
0.00085334328468889,
0.014957429841160774,
0.00426335958763957,
-0.03929263353347778,
0.01952020637691021,
0.13523854315280914,
-0.051717571914196014,
-0.023905064910650253,
0.0002578234707470983,
-0.014297586865723133,
-0.019606810063123703,
0.056709516793489456,
0.012177381664514542,
-0.030688609927892685,
0.0007661861018277705,
-0.07487753033638,
0.01921912655234337,
0.044558800756931305,
-0.004089395049959421,
-0.01648639142513275,
-0.023552346974611282,
-0.023148786276578903,
0.025956861674785614,
0.029915016144514084,
-0.05101857706904411,
-0.04511097073554993,
-0.043501850217580795,
-0.05888054147362709,
-0.05444735288619995,
-0.04496371001005173,
0.019348910078406334,
0.006937558297067881,
-0.061968304216861725,
-0.034921932965517044,
-0.04618014022707939,
0.02890646457672119,
-0.00045602035243064165,
-0.07216545939445496,
-0.00508948415517807,
0.046331580728292465,
0.0015526532661169767,
-0.006725009065121412,
0.0633324384689331,
0.029418230056762695,
-0.030463170260190964,
-0.008316734805703163,
0.02730526588857174,
0.05792788788676262,
-0.007723340764641762,
-0.018878119066357613,
0.001670493627898395,
-0.10964849591255188,
0.007320775184780359,
0.030534235760569572,
-0.012700110673904419,
-0.06514455378055573,
-0.019745809957385063,
-0.0029120142571628094,
0.05376183241605759,
0.083583764731884,
0.03959588333964348,
0.04065084457397461,
-0.04132876545190811,
-0.01251654326915741,
-0.0031170914880931377,
0.008238877169787884,
0.05806355178356171,
-0.02440471202135086,
0.06037024036049843,
0.033121101558208466,
-0.01163390837609768,
-0.0472993366420269,
0.009007524698972702,
0.009724182076752186,
-0.008484120480716228,
-0.023433834314346313,
-0.04176422953605652,
-0.012471732683479786,
-0.10501006990671158,
-0.03719571977853775,
0.02670622430741787,
0.003682417795062065,
-0.01640072837471962,
0.0019409562228247523,
0.0044453986920416355,
-0.018284352496266365,
-0.0033756159245967865,
-0.039748892188072205,
-0.025669630616903305,
-0.006274739746004343,
-0.052000198513269424,
-0.050450462847948074,
0.014684469439089298,
-0.03372238203883171,
-0.015528763644397259,
-0.012504263781011105,
-0.048559725284576416,
-0.0026766483206301928,
0.009989669546484947,
0.030129533261060715,
0.025422247126698494,
0.022468479350209236,
-0.03686751052737236
] |
347 |
PN-GAIL: Leveraging Non-optimal Information from Imperfect Demonstrations
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=0e2pcSxQJS
|
[
"Qiang Liu",
"Huiqiao Fu",
"Kaiqiang Tang",
"Chunlin Chen",
"Daoyi Dong"
] |
Poster
|
Imitation learning aims at constructing an optimal policy by emulating expert demonstrations. However, the prevailing approaches in this domain typically presume that the demonstrations are optimal, an assumption that seldom holds true in the complexities of real-world applications. The data collected in practical scenarios often contains imperfections, encompassing both optimal and non-optimal examples. In this study, we propose Positive-Negative Generative Adversarial Imitation Learning (PN-GAIL), a novel approach that falls within the framework of Generative Adversarial Imitation Learning (GAIL). PN-GAIL innovatively leverages non-optimal information from imperfect demonstrations, allowing the discriminator to comprehensively assess the positive and negative risks associated with these demonstrations. Furthermore, it requires only a small subset of labeled confidence scores. Theoretical analysis indicates that PN-GAIL deviates from the non-optimal data while mimicking imperfect demonstrations. Experimental results demonstrate that PN-GAIL surpasses conventional baseline methods in dealing with imperfect demonstrations, thereby significantly augmenting the practical utility of imitation learning in real-world contexts. Our codes are available at https://github.com/QiangLiuT/PN-GAIL.
|
Generative adversarial imitation learning, imperfect demonstrations, reinforcement learning
|
We introduce a Positive-Negative Generative Adversarial Imitation Learning (PN-GAIL) method within the framework of Generative Adversarial Imitation Learning (GAIL) to leverage non-optimal information from imperfect demonstrations.
| 13,343 | null |
[
-0.0007793184486217797,
-0.044677745550870895,
-0.01066037081182003,
0.06097764894366264,
0.018351273611187935,
0.03472311422228813,
-0.003278924385085702,
-0.01727627031505108,
-0.029401881620287895,
-0.03910071402788162,
-0.009057155810296535,
0.011719237081706524,
-0.07369177788496017,
-0.01888944022357464,
-0.04113646596670151,
0.039666980504989624,
0.025191765278577805,
-0.002091895556077361,
0.01402267999947071,
0.03289341926574707,
-0.018966319039463997,
-0.004285816103219986,
0.02194586768746376,
0.010919670574367046,
0.03908313810825348,
0.01643122360110283,
0.042403943836688995,
0.005551810842007399,
-0.027561265975236893,
-0.02845676802098751,
0.027604570612311363,
-0.006709153298288584,
0.026976002380251884,
-0.03166348114609718,
0.020913628861308098,
0.003460003063082695,
-0.025385605171322823,
0.0030040524434298277,
-0.004061667248606682,
0.022990785539150238,
-0.04738636687397957,
-0.0009313231566920877,
-0.034748952835798264,
0.0027997014112770557,
-0.03869952633976936,
0.007329652085900307,
-0.08506300300359726,
0.04505086690187454,
0.023871980607509613,
-0.02755405567586422,
-0.1027965322136879,
0.035737473517656326,
0.03479059785604477,
-0.016923200339078903,
-0.02216188795864582,
0.0267531368881464,
0.04746342822909355,
-0.08036976307630539,
0.01388294156640768,
-0.07002250105142593,
-0.034372616559267044,
0.051814328879117966,
0.022052813321352005,
-0.022065455093979836,
0.0004579767701216042,
0.014655394479632378,
0.051638271659612656,
0.051780473440885544,
-0.022346390411257744,
-0.057596445083618164,
-0.05825009569525719,
-0.0020344036165624857,
0.02349083125591278,
-0.0019365056650713086,
0.025012116879224777,
-0.048392366617918015,
0.012696637772023678,
0.010061400942504406,
0.08657317608594894,
-0.0002578959974925965,
0.03022986277937889,
0.03642149269580841,
0.02003374882042408,
0.037923414260149,
0.003634478896856308,
0.024364281445741653,
-0.029231280088424683,
-0.024041015654802322,
-0.06808410584926605,
0.00945448037236929,
-0.025955073535442352,
-0.05015575885772705,
0.01460015494376421,
0.043266188353300095,
0.003761834232136607,
-0.002851495984941721,
0.03154447674751282,
-0.00561822485178709,
0.02570781111717224,
-0.01284666545689106,
-0.01664080284535885,
-0.03144223988056183,
-0.02601858600974083,
-0.013579107820987701,
-0.11018190532922745,
-0.030487127602100372,
-0.030606314539909363,
-0.0052085937932133675,
-0.0496741347014904,
0.005023259669542313,
-0.0642603188753128,
0.004113492090255022,
0.009450758807361126,
-0.0434427373111248,
-0.06189838424324989,
0.0314413346350193,
-0.00408180383965373,
0.006583297625184059,
-0.012897581793367863,
0.007278941106051207,
0.05388477444648743,
0.014669331721961498,
0.00041547443834133446,
0.07312827557325363,
-0.011377448216080666,
0.01681593246757984,
0.03321981802582741,
0.05475090816617012,
-0.029171990230679512,
-0.0057460651732981205,
0.010111291892826557,
0.02968502789735794,
-0.01769270747900009,
0.007230017334222794,
0.011164314113557339,
-0.028434202075004578,
0.008068216033279896,
0.028704877942800522,
0.011549203656613827,
0.007901049219071865,
0.008668163791298866,
0.011782683432102203,
0.09094469249248505,
0.00006681260856566951,
0.0991266667842865,
-0.02160799317061901,
0.016763899475336075,
-0.03654586896300316,
-0.06357042491436005,
0.0011181526351720095,
0.005311266053467989,
-0.024322902783751488,
-0.010101435706019402,
-0.04424940049648285,
-0.011442309245467186,
0.02631736360490322,
0.043101608753204346,
0.03821224346756935,
-0.01759253442287445,
-0.006620940286666155,
0.016780104488134384,
-0.00028026028303429484,
-0.03291428089141846,
-0.016060326248407364,
0.010763021185994148,
-0.08966870605945587,
0.03992351517081261,
0.032580163329839706,
-0.04297257959842682,
-0.0057983133010566235,
-0.05868304893374443,
-0.022117840126156807,
0.04636440798640251,
0.023563584312796593,
-0.02306940034031868,
0.01859547384083271,
0.032250840216875076,
-0.025000104680657387,
0.03388408198952675,
0.046512115746736526,
-0.0798630490899086,
0.03227132558822632,
0.024520525708794594,
0.003060180926695466,
-0.010109362192451954,
-0.025626694783568382,
0.06359662115573883,
-0.03819373995065689,
0.014727719128131866,
0.053337160497903824,
-0.060737837105989456,
0.007971702143549919,
0.01856696791946888,
-0.03358981013298035,
0.0692487582564354,
0.001141327666118741,
-0.008833390660583973,
0.04074149578809738,
0.04788075014948845,
0.07150858640670776,
0.035708434879779816,
-0.04177708923816681,
0.029151851311326027,
-0.018016256392002106,
-0.008985642343759537,
0.0075918883085250854,
0.03554830327630043,
-0.023118840530514717,
-0.03751474991440773,
0.02055559679865837,
-0.014382434077560902,
0.0026585261803120375,
-0.0023301434703171253,
0.014032253995537758,
0.0171307772397995,
0.010785408318042755,
-0.040228214114904404,
0.017574114724993706,
0.008980539627373219,
-0.02102510817348957,
0.013781559653580189,
0.04029230773448944,
-0.013985906727612019,
0.02128099836409092,
-0.012693087570369244,
0.08792633563280106,
0.06943065673112869,
-0.011317191645503044,
-0.003884345991536975,
0.03818773478269577,
-0.012967431917786598,
0.012250187806785107,
0.012487023137509823,
-0.01278104167431593,
0.02447451837360859,
-0.024586133658885956,
0.044281601905822754,
-0.03111017681658268,
0.08241049945354462,
-0.0407426543533802,
-0.023692553862929344,
0.05908931419253349,
-0.03634829446673393,
0.08972401171922684,
-0.0121841449290514,
0.024608328938484192,
0.009302989579737186,
0.028466297313570976,
0.0019880279432982206,
-0.00942377932369709,
-0.014883027411997318,
0.012082377448678017,
0.029116058722138405,
0.006408835761249065,
-0.017057135701179504,
-0.05521392822265625,
-0.033044490963220596,
-0.03377247229218483,
0.07944655418395996,
0.05980507656931877,
-0.0002122964506270364,
0.02622903324663639,
0.006638707593083382,
-0.020906871184706688,
-0.019535934552550316,
-0.1276852786540985,
-0.0129954619333148,
-0.008965333923697472,
0.03649834543466568,
0.021821822971105576,
0.03327547758817673,
0.007982339709997177,
0.018294477835297585,
-0.015289380215108395,
-0.012644516304135323,
0.0158925112336874,
0.009257171303033829,
0.018682539463043213,
-0.02904948964715004,
-0.025079134851694107,
-0.011224314570426941,
0.06813453137874603,
0.01185100432485342,
0.002350954804569483,
-0.027586448937654495,
-0.054612673819065094,
-0.015767736360430717,
-0.030730683356523514,
-0.011271286755800247,
0.0349670946598053,
-0.002722550183534622,
0.014707040973007679,
-0.012280449271202087,
0.025754166767001152,
0.013740906491875648,
0.03359465301036835,
0.028709299862384796,
0.01952912099659443,
-0.020556513220071793,
0.01848730258643627,
-0.011676009744405746,
0.02229994535446167,
-0.024494212120771408,
0.021086180582642555,
-0.007669978775084019,
-0.0013477255124598742,
0.03978222981095314,
0.003472818760201335,
-0.26941898465156555,
0.005735526327043772,
0.062371689826250076,
0.019176151603460312,
0.026465309783816338,
-0.031168736517429352,
0.06637889891862869,
-0.03116459958255291,
-0.041433755308389664,
0.00613737478852272,
-0.002316012280061841,
0.024658039212226868,
0.0009753164486028254,
0.0417383648455143,
0.03231482580304146,
0.028494039550423622,
0.008984040468931198,
-0.033212244510650635,
0.0028523930814117193,
0.005829347297549248,
-0.046820349991321564,
-0.05653505399823189,
-0.018102314323186874,
0.03619761765003204,
-0.014509967528283596,
0.05094278231263161,
-0.05621293559670448,
-0.04295254871249199,
-0.03899548947811127,
-0.00172656390350312,
-0.007657852489501238,
-0.01695892959833145,
-0.021496133878827095,
0.03964528441429138,
0.018941694870591164,
0.023009654134511948,
0.04162948951125145,
-0.036705609411001205,
0.051882073283195496,
0.01213787030428648,
-0.009290235117077827,
0.0026217936538159847,
-0.011074923910200596,
0.04295618459582329,
0.06582678109407425,
0.026034466922283173,
-0.023194583132863045,
-0.018365241587162018,
-0.02960001491010189,
0.021981937810778618,
0.03088134527206421,
-0.012602831237018108,
-0.0024002117570489645,
0.018388791009783745,
0.02739909291267395,
0.016654323786497116,
0.006170765496790409,
-0.009893431328237057,
-0.02168668620288372,
0.012320884503424168,
0.017954228445887566,
-0.05686067044734955,
-0.045237671583890915,
0.01124718226492405,
0.004258774220943451,
-0.03182678669691086,
-0.03582845255732536,
-0.07173493504524231,
0.058298785239458084,
0.017170878127217293,
-0.01199332159012556,
-0.031067654490470886,
-0.008435041643679142,
-0.0977649912238121,
0.05813002958893776,
0.0002605638583190739,
-0.029799532145261765,
-0.018586711958050728,
-0.008878619410097599,
0.007070138119161129,
-0.04231499135494232,
-0.04038987681269646,
0.01326044462621212,
0.014402064494788647,
0.0011777133913710713,
-0.014465872198343277,
0.056944627314805984,
-0.020878195762634277,
-0.012101811356842518,
-0.040394071489572525,
0.039997655898332596,
0.007677185349166393,
0.047345198690891266,
-0.03102351352572441,
0.023609692230820656,
0.030217381194233894,
0.08492966741323471,
0.04962409660220146,
0.033389974385499954,
0.011875134892761707,
0.005367605946958065,
-0.07766198366880417,
-0.025891797617077827,
-0.035690080374479294,
-0.023303251713514328,
0.03647158667445183,
-0.07976415753364563,
-0.005453888792544603,
0.07001500576734543,
-0.01457588654011488,
-0.030430564656853676,
-0.030176334083080292,
0.035494156181812286,
-0.0038315649144351482,
-0.015379181131720543,
-0.02779635787010193,
-0.012704181484878063,
0.04068722575902939,
0.03270385041832924,
-0.020781945437192917,
-0.052463874220848083,
0.05235723406076431,
-0.032148681581020355,
0.02886471524834633,
0.00483090803027153,
-0.03306005150079727,
0.014736034907400608,
0.00527366204187274,
-0.004769366234540939,
-0.04312870651483536,
0.04787429794669151,
0.03231291100382805,
-0.00997675210237503,
0.038589175790548325,
0.040122345089912415,
0.012800531461834908,
0.0083045344799757,
-0.013140525668859482,
0.04441572725772858,
-0.02790689468383789,
0.00668819947168231,
-0.0018527948996052146,
-0.012735406868159771,
0.02613609842956066,
0.033086296170949936,
0.009970996528863907,
0.05091350898146629,
0.02643594704568386,
0.005559053272008896,
0.007541012950241566,
0.048200301826000214,
-0.0649493858218193,
0.012467876076698303,
-0.02081013098359108,
0.025962620973587036,
-0.005318715237081051,
0.00428074412047863,
-0.024858174845576286,
0.029473688453435898,
-0.05451454967260361,
0.01836419478058815,
0.027641745284199715,
-0.017149673774838448,
-0.016220279037952423,
0.023043876513838768,
0.052741993218660355,
-0.009398935362696648,
-0.030316045507788658,
0.017654746770858765,
0.0046684630215168,
0.0180278979241848,
-0.0550810769200325,
-0.05279865488409996,
-0.038267191499471664,
-0.010351093485951424,
-0.012048940174281597,
0.012876013293862343,
-0.03690733760595322,
-0.04167943075299263,
0.0330996960401535,
-0.002582112094387412,
-0.06737156957387924,
0.015401345677673817,
-0.009397901594638824,
0.05951065570116043,
-0.020588479936122894,
-0.010507657192647457,
-0.02689466066658497,
-0.030774861574172974,
0.03707297891378403,
-0.03946608677506447,
0.0017974728252738714,
-0.03441648185253143,
-0.02739972062408924,
0.0013382205506786704,
-0.039046477526426315,
-0.020191332325339317,
-0.003796322736889124,
-0.020517360419034958,
-0.01236259751021862,
-0.018407678231596947,
0.004322669003158808,
-0.04676169157028198,
-0.005804470740258694,
0.02148563414812088,
-0.052223581820726395,
-0.0022505309898406267,
0.005671999882906675,
-0.006941529456526041,
0.035242874175310135,
-0.062005944550037384,
-0.025084063410758972,
-0.038969118148088455,
0.0010884538060054183,
0.015018744394183159,
-0.029750006273388863,
-0.0538318008184433,
0.002205047057941556,
-0.020426813513040543,
-0.013553368858993053,
0.03471558541059494,
-0.03408762440085411,
0.0010427121305838227,
-0.01480590645223856,
-0.002697507617995143,
0.020605364814400673,
-0.03810044005513191,
-0.030369918793439865,
0.03373643755912781,
-0.02288953959941864,
0.00695756496861577,
-0.03975421190261841,
0.02765144594013691,
0.02778637409210205,
-0.017580673098564148,
0.010816747322678566,
-0.04489726945757866,
0.07344001531600952,
-0.030066199600696564,
-0.025768877938389778,
-0.017093777656555176,
0.020472243428230286,
-0.050823356956243515,
0.0037432685494422913,
0.009119641035795212,
0.022275129333138466,
0.02558024786412716,
0.02224322408437729,
0.015810614451766014,
0.017476886510849,
0.03939441218972206,
0.01664208620786667,
-0.058278411626815796,
0.010122711770236492,
0.06890864670276642,
-0.06149866059422493,
0.015387623570859432,
-0.07542362809181213,
-0.005882564932107925,
0.0382598340511322,
-0.021253883838653564,
0.02958655171096325,
-0.031706247478723526,
0.005250887479633093,
-0.004729141481220722,
0.018035544082522392,
0.02063942700624466,
-0.04323417320847511,
-0.00076839211396873,
-0.05282899737358093,
0.010011612437665462,
-0.05912686139345169,
0.0038185077719390392,
0.045189980417490005,
-0.05152778699994087,
-0.017741717398166656,
0.009510570205748081,
-0.005386257544159889,
0.02951985038816929,
-0.047170400619506836,
-0.04085827246308327,
0.02445186674594879,
-0.03145923465490341,
-0.03356648609042168,
0.030081840232014656,
-0.0493660494685173,
-0.02769489400088787,
-0.013135608285665512,
-0.052864786237478256,
0.007236007135361433,
0.00688187824562192,
0.03323335200548172,
0.0015701840166002512,
-0.020899467170238495,
-0.017518099397420883,
0.028816284611821175,
0.037160277366638184,
0.044714752584695816,
0.019411548972129822,
0.022737521678209305,
-0.014029174111783504,
0.06460710614919662,
0.04124078154563904,
0.039817601442337036,
0.027196625247597694,
0.02354288473725319,
-0.03254115954041481,
-0.06550059467554092,
0.04543014615774155,
-0.01721184141933918,
-0.053777649998664856,
-0.05841365456581116,
0.040008075535297394,
0.00246592634357512,
-0.04154762253165245,
-0.025954606011509895,
0.008800951763987541,
-0.05151280760765076,
-0.03967128321528435,
0.001153410761617124,
-0.010617072694003582,
0.0031323896255344152,
0.06679833680391312,
0.0029975296929478645,
0.039996977895498276,
0.042742613703012466,
0.0306168794631958,
-0.005186636000871658,
0.014513468369841576,
0.03560135141015053,
0.05860498175024986,
0.04908982664346695,
0.0013597140787169337,
0.06374391913414001,
-0.015146980062127113,
-0.04671794921159744,
0.030980397015810013,
0.02576192282140255,
0.010056526400148869,
-0.05371158942580223,
0.006333019584417343,
0.06873028725385666,
0.004037179052829742,
0.05283033102750778,
-0.05301962420344353,
-0.025238852947950363,
0.04944821447134018,
0.02656056359410286,
-0.021119890734553337,
0.049962591379880905,
0.03379972651600838,
0.013349205255508423,
-0.009405456483364105,
-0.020890619605779648,
-0.01125428918749094,
-0.034764088690280914,
0.019099969416856766,
-0.02873304672539234,
-0.03277544677257538,
0.043772142380476,
0.02575969323515892,
-0.018359839916229248,
0.08425580710172653,
-0.05494638532400131,
-0.04894479364156723,
0.022956540808081627,
-0.011889544315636158,
0.039264529943466187,
0.038692355155944824,
0.013787400908768177,
0.02339496649801731,
-0.004287412855774164,
-0.02600543014705181,
0.027399729937314987,
0.040801167488098145,
0.05285285785794258,
0.027865080162882805,
-0.017108319327235222,
-0.01574571616947651,
0.031894855201244354,
0.009947567246854305,
-0.009890835732221603,
-0.05316007137298584,
-0.027708949521183968,
-0.04711015895009041,
-0.05275619775056839,
-0.0621022991836071,
0.012609598226845264,
-0.00815275777131319,
-0.037752579897642136,
0.0047060297802090645,
-0.004476574249565601,
0.03199402987957001,
0.05435677990317345,
-0.0667237937450409,
-0.006161699537187815,
0.047891538590192795,
0.01545004639774561,
0.017521239817142487,
0.020505616441369057,
0.002263094298541546,
0.008802749216556549,
-0.021836722269654274,
0.03635548800230026,
0.02463393472135067,
-0.009550364688038826,
-0.046269189566373825,
0.006596285384148359,
-0.09833835810422897,
-0.003425207221880555,
0.016400186344981194,
-0.05825895816087723,
-0.08467090129852295,
0.03208642452955246,
-0.04364204779267311,
0.027564123272895813,
0.0776209831237793,
0.023061638697981834,
-0.02906205877661705,
-0.04635058715939522,
-0.01186367403715849,
-0.021401584148406982,
-0.008018314838409424,
0.050685107707977295,
-0.0305118877440691,
0.04260949790477753,
0.05567193776369095,
-0.014098343439400196,
-0.04395104572176933,
0.035808905959129333,
-0.015668639913201332,
-0.023286936804652214,
-0.04783250764012337,
-0.054858677089214325,
-0.0005976963439024985,
-0.10527709126472473,
-0.03305196762084961,
0.0333186537027359,
-0.005682701710611582,
-0.06001732498407364,
-0.0031957896426320076,
-0.04823652654886246,
0.03091326542198658,
-0.003855555085465312,
-0.027107959613204002,
-0.027424661442637444,
-0.0128323407843709,
-0.014471740461885929,
-0.050701070576906204,
0.009083996526896954,
-0.02437564916908741,
0.024592595174908638,
-0.033561792224645615,
-0.04903491586446762,
-0.0008704469655640423,
0.0059636421501636505,
0.03671570494771004,
0.013391228392720222,
0.04299676790833473,
-0.005237191449850798
] |
348 |
Attributing Culture-Conditioned Generations to Pretraining Corpora
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=XrsOu4KgDE
|
[
"Huihan Li",
"Arnav Goel",
"Keyu He",
"Xiang Ren"
] |
Poster
|
In open-ended generative tasks like narrative writing or dialogue, large language models often exhibit cultural biases, showing limited knowledge and generating templated outputs for less prevalent cultures. Recent works show that these biases may stem from uneven cultural representation in pretraining corpora. This work investigates how pretraining leads to biased culture-conditioned generations
by analyzing how models associate entities with cultures based on pretraining data patterns. We propose the MEMOED framework (MEMOrization from prEtraining Document) to determine whether a generation for a culture arises from memorization. Using MEMOED on culture-conditioned generations about food and clothing for 110 cultures, we find that high-frequency cultures in pretraining data yield more generations with memorized symbols, while some low-frequency cultures produce none. Additionally, the model favors generating entities with extraordinarily high frequency regardless of the conditioned culture, reflecting biases toward frequent pretraining terms irrespective of relevance. We hope that the MEMOED framework and our insights will inspire more works on attributing model performance on pretraining data.
|
culture bias, pretraining data, memorization, generalization
|
We propose the MEMOED framework to determine whether a biased culture-conditioned generation arises from memorization of pretraining data patterns, or results from other associations made due to pretraining data.
| 13,342 |
2412.20760
|
[
0.0006770255276933312,
0.009591230191290379,
-0.03944483399391174,
0.05216353386640549,
0.03218099847435951,
0.007928266189992428,
0.02601546421647072,
0.04799693450331688,
-0.011844192631542683,
0.00016368518117815256,
-0.02987506613135338,
0.03768833354115486,
-0.07543976604938507,
0.005289111286401749,
-0.04142240807414055,
0.04961973428726196,
0.023345516994595528,
-0.004982687067240477,
-0.0037324416916817427,
-0.020963506773114204,
-0.029419267550110817,
-0.036074768751859665,
0.03950273245573044,
0.02474956400692463,
0.05349556729197502,
-0.0002696509473025799,
0.044971760362386703,
-0.04137411341071129,
-0.013310093432664871,
-0.0032045848201960325,
0.00033439332037232816,
-0.03273459151387215,
0.004648710135370493,
-0.00510095339268446,
0.002043660031631589,
-0.011705468408763409,
-0.03632384166121483,
-0.013612267561256886,
0.014290028251707554,
0.036200545728206635,
-0.04382431134581566,
0.0005295387236401439,
0.0166912954300642,
-0.008616271428763866,
-0.08284058421850204,
0.022706536576151848,
-0.12219082564115524,
0.034923870116472244,
-0.0024113385006785393,
-0.02092927321791649,
-0.1192818284034729,
0.011378765106201172,
0.03212061896920204,
-0.03025936894118786,
0.029971051961183548,
0.0435485914349556,
0.0008245736244134605,
-0.08105344325304031,
0.005249192472547293,
-0.03866330161690712,
-0.00800478458404541,
0.024335665628314018,
0.01959630660712719,
-0.018399158492684364,
0.015895290300250053,
-0.03676963225007057,
-0.02124202810227871,
0.023530326783657074,
-0.06665636599063873,
-0.041206665337085724,
-0.043600983917713165,
0.007724528666585684,
-0.01780780777335167,
-0.0003407129552215338,
-0.0019900717306882143,
-0.0572894811630249,
0.017590906471014023,
0.05121202394366264,
0.07508279383182526,
0.02122167870402336,
-0.014319752342998981,
0.007505018264055252,
0.029394008219242096,
0.011041654273867607,
0.01814900152385235,
0.016483653336763382,
-0.02545647695660591,
-0.02610504813492298,
-0.06577377021312714,
0.023096131160855293,
-0.017476804554462433,
-0.03258975222706795,
0.0046387058682739735,
0.03065316379070282,
0.003625681856647134,
0.012904500588774681,
0.043759867548942566,
0.014246919192373753,
0.004667884670197964,
0.018842436373233795,
-0.03586490452289581,
-0.01693105138838291,
0.026305774226784706,
0.021113326773047447,
-0.12034294754266739,
-0.03386658430099487,
-0.01042866799980402,
0.014900878071784973,
-0.0033818718511611223,
-0.011470329947769642,
-0.02628719061613083,
-0.0012001438299193978,
0.021985746920108795,
-0.0018766361754387617,
-0.03307771310210228,
0.015486588701605797,
-0.01601349376142025,
-0.0013406609650701284,
-0.017430106177926064,
0.0009447457268834114,
0.0515182800590992,
0.03685702383518219,
-0.002630924805998802,
0.059441883116960526,
-0.06372503936290741,
0.012055649422109127,
0.017352448776364326,
0.015109253115952015,
-0.03099670633673668,
-0.03339574113488197,
-0.005184534005820751,
0.018354829400777817,
-0.015781734138727188,
0.022491617128252983,
-0.016002018004655838,
-0.011212630197405815,
0.044375140219926834,
-0.005266016349196434,
0.0658760592341423,
0.03665333613753319,
0.020477352663874626,
-0.009614016860723495,
0.015462523326277733,
-0.012131075374782085,
0.07079097628593445,
-0.029729755595326424,
-0.04792546480894089,
-0.04880981892347336,
-0.0002672277332749218,
0.015240024775266647,
0.027623146772384644,
-0.0020259732846170664,
0.029798677191138268,
-0.05745107680559158,
0.002106844447553158,
0.0376092828810215,
0.009558250196278095,
0.023540357127785683,
0.014234673231840134,
-0.0028318644035607576,
-0.002353852381929755,
0.032222989946603775,
-0.031677089631557465,
0.02260592207312584,
0.008634036406874657,
-0.03519148752093315,
0.023722680285573006,
0.008341776207089424,
-0.05050187185406685,
0.02468368224799633,
-0.04753849655389786,
-0.04108177497982979,
0.052661627531051636,
-0.029048249125480652,
-0.03748098015785217,
-0.010149694979190826,
0.003954201005399227,
0.019190609455108643,
0.04865674301981926,
0.025079194456338882,
-0.07851667702198029,
0.038853514939546585,
0.03047637641429901,
-0.024033889174461365,
0.035445645451545715,
-0.019352568313479424,
0.05570187792181969,
-0.021848348900675774,
-0.0015361950499936938,
0.06275461614131927,
-0.057589903473854065,
-0.019822178408503532,
0.04926532134413719,
-0.029889924451708794,
0.047434136271476746,
-0.026899665594100952,
0.00874852854758501,
0.09124067425727844,
0.04678887128829956,
0.05161372199654579,
0.04563799127936363,
-0.03799557313323021,
0.04062661528587341,
-0.0032221965957432985,
-0.0018895533867180347,
0.024100083857774734,
0.019628288224339485,
-0.06390824913978577,
-0.024957740679383278,
0.012417186982929707,
-0.015720438212156296,
0.039585862308740616,
0.019955525174736977,
0.025525042787194252,
0.004974253010004759,
-0.004494978114962578,
-0.03216039761900902,
0.00103991967625916,
-0.0063080149702727795,
-0.060318831354379654,
0.04736584424972534,
0.012434558942914009,
-0.0143113499507308,
-0.04623105376958847,
-0.06524951010942459,
0.08560234308242798,
0.0477905310690403,
-0.02506047859787941,
0.013227231800556183,
0.0357203409075737,
-0.0040422286838293076,
0.017213651910424232,
0.00676459027454257,
0.006054095923900604,
0.0249693114310503,
-0.00543643394485116,
-0.0018949243240058422,
-0.017758678644895554,
0.057947687804698944,
-0.03420227766036987,
-0.011561807245016098,
0.04937833547592163,
-0.04254162684082985,
0.049254488199949265,
0.021044837310910225,
0.027484074234962463,
0.023405134677886963,
-0.02346228063106537,
-0.030714821070432663,
-0.029568152502179146,
-0.009084087796509266,
-0.0023153317160904408,
-0.008962753228843212,
-0.012704325839877129,
0.008843871764838696,
-0.03837709128856659,
-0.02404124103486538,
-0.0020801229402422905,
0.046363599598407745,
0.03324074670672417,
-0.0008801664807833731,
0.02753724716603756,
0.008648846298456192,
-0.03143089637160301,
0.014994034543633461,
-0.06997902691364288,
-0.00017623871099203825,
-0.03392275422811508,
0.028024427592754364,
-0.0018151014810428023,
0.05571412667632103,
-0.001658816123381257,
0.03770961984992027,
-0.006378722842782736,
-0.008988394401967525,
0.023531535640358925,
-0.004838273860514164,
-0.04508824273943901,
-0.03079194761812687,
-0.007872194051742554,
-0.04521871730685234,
0.05550205707550049,
-0.036315638571977615,
-0.028704645112156868,
-0.045275624841451645,
-0.08096616715192795,
-0.03848346322774887,
-0.021522166207432747,
0.003963371738791466,
0.018128978088498116,
0.010341169312596321,
-0.0008853950421325862,
0.000982387806288898,
-0.01171944197267294,
0.027039136737585068,
0.03927508369088173,
0.03515924885869026,
0.006809811107814312,
-0.013573982752859592,
0.028051510453224182,
-0.04421258345246315,
-0.008639129810035229,
0.012887486256659031,
0.02562403865158558,
0.011091480031609535,
0.023941433057188988,
0.012188250198960304,
-0.0038327923975884914,
-0.2762293517589569,
-0.014715569093823433,
0.001630796934477985,
-0.029923023656010628,
0.021571939811110497,
-0.02200024388730526,
0.06037968769669533,
-0.03710303455591202,
-0.030564364045858383,
0.02405051328241825,
0.003652615239843726,
0.03682839870452881,
0.005221684463322163,
0.05826932191848755,
0.005410775542259216,
0.03987056761980057,
0.0027663419023156166,
-0.013858068734407425,
-0.021358875557780266,
0.05501822382211685,
-0.01914089545607567,
-0.05616922304034233,
-0.06184345483779907,
0.04980524256825447,
0.01900351233780384,
0.04111690819263458,
-0.07113628834486008,
-0.00438205199316144,
-0.030906155705451965,
-0.0073633948341012,
-0.010061070322990417,
-0.03260376676917076,
0.04994465783238411,
0.030475012958049774,
-0.006945064757019281,
0.0070222592912614346,
0.06262749433517456,
0.010806000791490078,
0.02891046181321144,
0.015379933640360832,
0.004470521118491888,
-0.033528462052345276,
-0.017058059573173523,
0.013662346638739109,
0.044857993721961975,
0.002574583515524864,
-0.06682825088500977,
-0.027657724916934967,
-0.00917732622474432,
0.030031992122530937,
-0.024844979867339134,
-0.021754669025540352,
-0.021986190229654312,
0.021280111744999886,
0.008306020870804787,
-0.007836545817553997,
0.058487359434366226,
-0.020769961178302765,
-0.005948016885668039,
-0.03271786868572235,
0.02034282311797142,
-0.04827474057674408,
-0.008253895677626133,
-0.03892884775996208,
-0.0313032865524292,
-0.03278535231947899,
-0.09270118176937103,
-0.023857098072767258,
0.03533978387713432,
0.03094240091741085,
-0.06415658444166183,
0.03376466780900955,
-0.0017079109093174338,
-0.08902666717767715,
0.00008271270053228363,
-0.02082083560526371,
-0.03697846457362175,
-0.030301533639431,
0.011841964907944202,
0.017011700198054314,
0.006982368882745504,
-0.02364880032837391,
-0.016336075961589813,
0.004522708244621754,
0.03441455215215683,
-0.013163597323000431,
0.030487243086099625,
-0.04144592210650444,
-0.026748202741146088,
-0.040199097245931625,
0.04236363247036934,
0.042473502457141876,
0.008239765651524067,
0.01849997416138649,
0.047725290060043335,
0.03483353927731514,
0.022715827450156212,
0.06922328472137451,
0.05634017288684845,
-0.014810958877205849,
0.03496759757399559,
-0.07537643611431122,
-0.011053134687244892,
-0.012185698375105858,
-0.001294428831897676,
0.007551556918770075,
-0.08656053245067596,
0.00004758543218486011,
0.027523748576641083,
-0.016233934089541435,
-0.033139247447252274,
0.01671283319592476,
-0.02619653195142746,
0.01142495684325695,
-0.012586861848831177,
-0.014682786539196968,
0.03513162210583687,
0.025433553382754326,
0.035241201519966125,
-0.0033261612989008427,
-0.01232142373919487,
0.04558287933468819,
-0.050289906561374664,
0.01735539920628071,
-0.01205593440681696,
-0.06181067228317261,
0.00995741505175829,
-0.026660675182938576,
-0.055625636130571365,
-0.0076979356817901134,
0.01795985922217369,
-0.02237306348979473,
0.01780461147427559,
0.05637738108634949,
0.06379569321870804,
0.0027601115871220827,
0.003001651493832469,
-0.02607838064432144,
0.00494325440376997,
-0.010828678496181965,
0.027252092957496643,
-0.045820705592632294,
0.021914754062891006,
0.03795943409204483,
0.00404289411380887,
-0.0003446124610491097,
0.03315852954983711,
0.0046942527405917645,
-0.022099744528532028,
-0.008693401701748371,
0.09248089045286179,
-0.011564870364964008,
-0.010752164758741856,
-0.0392674021422863,
0.003863539081066847,
0.030647311359643936,
0.013589094392955303,
0.014316229149699211,
-0.0031888126395642757,
-0.06400775164365768,
0.06517650932073593,
-0.029154425486922264,
0.003013317473232746,
-0.0029135397635400295,
-0.0030102371238172054,
0.032486218959093094,
-0.0167197547852993,
-0.0005408376455307007,
0.027319082990288734,
0.019413167610764503,
0.020742513239383698,
-0.0010356497950851917,
-0.04574131593108177,
-0.0283743254840374,
-0.021914780139923096,
-0.01896621473133564,
0.014115900732576847,
-0.011359763331711292,
-0.03156694024801254,
0.04760518670082092,
0.02146134339272976,
0.01649068295955658,
0.03512851521372795,
0.0035050613805651665,
0.053565751761198044,
0.04619757458567619,
0.024633517488837242,
-0.002633423078805208,
-0.06933756917715073,
0.006123783532530069,
-0.029791444540023804,
-0.008944477885961533,
-0.023218510672450066,
-0.052167896181344986,
-0.04435262456536293,
-0.022350728511810303,
0.00227996613830328,
0.016436848789453506,
-0.015666844323277473,
0.01795794814825058,
0.0009532399126328528,
-0.0014889825833961368,
-0.047066956758499146,
-0.012971374206244946,
0.01160864345729351,
-0.07290506362915039,
-0.014355507679283619,
-0.013820596039295197,
-0.01884983666241169,
-0.008497243747115135,
-0.03197026997804642,
-0.030450116842985153,
-0.06768836081027985,
-0.06495345383882523,
0.030325092375278473,
-0.03986789658665657,
-0.013352720066905022,
-0.044473256915807724,
0.018066002056002617,
0.0069848415441811085,
0.02496182918548584,
-0.02063160017132759,
-0.01459580473601818,
-0.016460929065942764,
0.00504083139821887,
0.06162023916840553,
-0.03315601125359535,
-0.0065787481144070625,
-0.0029850201681256294,
-0.050001055002212524,
0.04969848692417145,
-0.040235526859760284,
0.051348354667425156,
0.044665999710559845,
-0.013564112596213818,
-0.01725454069674015,
0.007034135516732931,
0.03728645667433739,
0.05550902336835861,
0.013816499151289463,
0.04671793431043625,
-0.011055892333388329,
-0.023253941908478737,
0.022132502868771553,
0.0200539268553257,
0.03591880202293396,
-0.02420961670577526,
-0.0003706533170770854,
-0.01616295613348484,
0.04330022633075714,
0.016882481053471565,
0.016263963654637337,
-0.032539576292037964,
-0.0025461369659751654,
0.03614925220608711,
-0.033933427184820175,
-0.030268816277384758,
-0.07015107572078705,
-0.028207534924149513,
0.004958994686603546,
0.010297351516783237,
0.03902768716216087,
-0.022068407386541367,
0.05387749895453453,
0.008531049825251102,
0.04829207807779312,
0.023462025448679924,
-0.017610589042305946,
0.027413260191679,
-0.03342444449663162,
0.006721191108226776,
-0.07161449640989304,
-0.030009010806679726,
0.06554228067398071,
-0.02608468011021614,
-0.006220061797648668,
-0.048539068549871445,
-0.03796936944127083,
0.046670131385326385,
-0.0316404327750206,
-0.036846887320280075,
-0.015283886343240738,
-0.04249440133571625,
0.008965539745986462,
0.026884650811553,
-0.07759898155927658,
0.01192768756300211,
-0.028797809034585953,
-0.044844694435596466,
-0.018388140946626663,
-0.018993698060512543,
0.08076711744070053,
-0.01957317255437374,
0.00007469339470844716,
-0.006345123518258333,
0.0074141561053693295,
0.031414829194545746,
0.07923275977373123,
0.027855733409523964,
0.012859092094004154,
-0.021488778293132782,
0.06270046532154083,
0.021438702940940857,
0.00029165655723772943,
0.054360803216695786,
0.0036546271294355392,
-0.021297281607985497,
-0.0788055956363678,
0.03278863802552223,
0.006985773798078299,
-0.014983913861215115,
-0.041481707245111465,
0.057378072291612625,
0.02790122479200363,
-0.0499967597424984,
-0.03358705714344978,
0.024434993043541908,
-0.027479451149702072,
-0.014819824136793613,
-0.012382248416543007,
0.01637454889714718,
-0.021811190992593765,
0.06929593533277512,
0.033592380583286285,
0.07644422352313995,
0.07334151118993759,
0.009454239159822464,
-0.012635411694645882,
0.012999131344258785,
0.038951460272073746,
0.048950664699077606,
0.06554404646158218,
0.010051202960312366,
0.05856754258275032,
0.0015792526537552476,
-0.06941457092761993,
-0.004404403269290924,
0.03787332773208618,
0.013522534631192684,
-0.03519800677895546,
0.012122089974582195,
0.0719495490193367,
0.004350470844656229,
0.06088927015662193,
-0.00528567424044013,
0.011425020173192024,
0.017450958490371704,
0.033903155475854874,
-0.00041408033575862646,
0.025910547003149986,
0.037053484469652176,
-0.0010377602884545922,
-0.02924349531531334,
-0.037963155657052994,
0.017339518293738365,
-0.039807241410017014,
0.009620845317840576,
0.012307553552091122,
-0.013166150078177452,
0.01531972922384739,
-0.036180414259433746,
0.04200353845953941,
0.1145094484090805,
-0.04944323003292084,
-0.01261865720152855,
-0.0016972406301647425,
0.015691271051764488,
0.008122158236801624,
0.037703607231378555,
-0.006260308437049389,
-0.009005863219499588,
0.007967527955770493,
-0.07733175903558731,
0.0103651387616992,
0.028262417763471603,
0.007712738588452339,
0.015224814414978027,
-0.024309394881129265,
0.003883437253534794,
0.03641410544514656,
0.006992516573518515,
-0.04920385032892227,
-0.05233382061123848,
0.007903027348220348,
-0.03670908883213997,
-0.02302549034357071,
-0.02289135381579399,
0.05060768127441406,
-0.03768867999315262,
-0.02256220579147339,
-0.004811433143913746,
-0.025163250043988228,
0.024152034893631935,
0.0025777951814234257,
-0.06945353746414185,
0.0027767778374254704,
0.00680488720536232,
-0.009069373831152916,
0.0063428631983697414,
0.04263675957918167,
0.0189210195094347,
0.005947617813944817,
-0.0012779019307345152,
0.062086064368486404,
0.015871237963438034,
0.013685334473848343,
0.0018545486964285374,
-0.026970168575644493,
-0.11592768877744675,
0.004043502267450094,
0.02960798516869545,
-0.036814264953136444,
-0.07109112292528152,
0.024053413420915604,
-0.02114327810704708,
0.03207989037036896,
0.05841938406229019,
0.04588621109724045,
0.03510570526123047,
-0.035470250993967056,
-0.007975835353136063,
0.007827892899513245,
0.048102475702762604,
0.06546284258365631,
-0.02718310058116913,
0.07839511334896088,
0.05762125551700592,
-0.0038588223978877068,
-0.07613120973110199,
0.014177747070789337,
-0.020308909937739372,
-0.01340104453265667,
-0.002391642425209284,
-0.040453583002090454,
-0.008708098903298378,
-0.06606069207191467,
-0.019798383116722107,
0.017085827887058258,
-0.02101818285882473,
-0.047681622207164764,
0.009970554150640965,
-0.04062054678797722,
0.0019374667899683118,
-0.02523192949593067,
-0.0022010686807334423,
-0.013268155045807362,
-0.021548617631196976,
-0.023320067673921585,
-0.0528339147567749,
-0.006820250768214464,
-0.02184240333735943,
-0.0007552344468422234,
-0.03374703973531723,
-0.050412897020578384,
-0.010422461666166782,
-0.030389923602342606,
0.05825813114643097,
0.012965917587280273,
0.028808843344449997,
-0.024515485391020775
] |
349 |
Semi-Parametric Retrieval via Binary Bag-of-Tokens Index
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=l0fn10vSyM
|
[
"Jiawei Zhou",
"Li Dong",
"Furu Wei",
"Lei Chen"
] |
Poster
|
Information retrieval has transitioned from standalone systems into essential components across broader applications, with indexing efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and freshness becoming increasingly critical yet often overlooked. In this paper, we introduce SemI-parametric Disentangled Retrieval (SiDR), a bi-encoder retrieval framework that decouples retrieval index from neural parameters to enable efficient, low-cost, and parameter-agnostic indexing for emerging use cases. Specifically, in addition to using embeddings as indexes like existing neural retrieval methods, SiDR supports a non-parametric tokenization index for search, achieving BM25-like indexing complexity with significantly better effectiveness. Our comprehensive evaluation across 16 retrieval benchmarks demonstrates that SiDR outperforms both neural and term-based retrieval baselines under the same indexing workload: (i) When using an embedding-based index, SiDR exceeds the performance of conventional neural retrievers while maintaining similar training complexity; (ii) When using a tokenization-based index, SiDR drastically reduces indexing cost and time, matching the complexity of traditional term-based retrieval, while consistently outperforming BM25 on all in-domain datasets; (iii) Additionally, we introduce a late parametric mechanism that matches BM25 index preparation time while outperforming other neural retrieval baselines in effectiveness.
|
information retrieval, efficient retrieval, retrieval-agumented applications, RAG
|
A semi-parametric neural retrieval system that supports both parametric and non-parametric index
| 13,338 |
2405.01924
|
[
-0.019150404259562492,
-0.0606294684112072,
-0.033445294946432114,
0.04797846078872681,
0.015945056453347206,
0.00821398850530386,
0.0111414585262537,
-0.008734169416129589,
-0.007489088922739029,
-0.015936264768242836,
-0.033886443823575974,
-0.01585502177476883,
-0.04380129650235176,
0.018412435427308083,
0.013022800907492638,
0.07868696749210358,
0.005846449639648199,
-0.011891171336174011,
0.01283096894621849,
-0.00035059411311522126,
-0.004654222168028355,
-0.0364505834877491,
0.005770087242126465,
0.011834279634058475,
0.051172658801078796,
0.020398832857608795,
0.005224697291851044,
-0.016461197286844254,
-0.039220619946718216,
-0.0010005721123889089,
0.020057005807757378,
-0.0176494549959898,
0.002527092583477497,
-0.008258538320660591,
0.027851784601807594,
0.0023475356865674257,
-0.06913090497255325,
0.03254905343055725,
0.013462432660162449,
0.003613733919337392,
-0.03540826216340065,
0.005511712748557329,
0.01545034907758236,
-0.010965823195874691,
-0.04973561689257622,
0.013109828345477581,
-0.10046306997537613,
0.022918691858649254,
-0.017273029312491417,
-0.0018956768326461315,
-0.09151729196310043,
0.007731473073363304,
0.007575657218694687,
-0.004408037755638361,
0.026969078928232193,
0.029037581756711006,
0.027790481224656105,
-0.06746197491884232,
-0.004200410097837448,
-0.028996918350458145,
0.0024233160074800253,
0.03236383944749832,
0.0433935672044754,
-0.009245382621884346,
0.006933900993317366,
-0.02390848658978939,
-0.018030092120170593,
0.04221286252140999,
-0.059672534465789795,
-0.03612107038497925,
0.003307746723294258,
-0.009787548333406448,
0.005664253141731024,
0.02680947445333004,
-0.006263622548431158,
-0.012610532343387604,
0.013252517208456993,
0.019267691299319267,
0.0557846799492836,
0.016939979046583176,
0.0062901913188397884,
0.022490372881293297,
0.011534562334418297,
0.033280182629823685,
0.010592835955321789,
0.017375096678733826,
-0.09438581764698029,
-0.01658576913177967,
-0.06369920074939728,
0.03232691064476967,
-0.012254089117050171,
-0.02300041913986206,
0.03109760209918022,
0.008603393100202084,
-0.029888208955526352,
0.0405367910861969,
0.04700406640768051,
-0.030529147014021873,
0.02066056802868843,
0.010543875396251678,
-0.0055834646336734295,
-0.03713741898536682,
0.05127263441681862,
-0.00997419748455286,
-0.08701062947511673,
-0.013447819277644157,
-0.03226051852107048,
-0.015275017358362675,
0.01996374875307083,
-0.037743087857961655,
-0.04154754430055618,
0.0029925808776170015,
0.015931058675050735,
0.008550966158509254,
-0.04775356501340866,
0.019107460975646973,
-0.005219102371484041,
-0.0021448060870170593,
-0.01282914076000452,
0.027066053822636604,
0.03589116781949997,
0.0556035153567791,
0.010929589159786701,
0.060561370104551315,
0.006336099002510309,
0.0019157648785039783,
0.013359804637730122,
0.04115567356348038,
-0.04519882798194885,
-0.02899768203496933,
-0.037558961659669876,
0.03897738829255104,
0.008982161059975624,
0.003111854661256075,
-0.0203095655888319,
-0.012979185208678246,
-0.0049599395133554935,
0.020931607112288475,
0.0525301918387413,
-0.044605549424886703,
0.024738993495702744,
-0.05590381100773811,
-0.011721191927790642,
-0.03402017429471016,
0.07695598155260086,
-0.009810730814933777,
0.00657614367082715,
0.0016298829577863216,
-0.017366552725434303,
-0.010052765719592571,
-0.010222207754850388,
-0.031335245817899704,
0.01766747049987316,
-0.07038047909736633,
-0.00038118934025987983,
0.07796428352594376,
-0.002704320941120386,
-0.0015367509331554174,
0.024125561118125916,
0.005187933798879385,
-0.009919975884258747,
-0.01531819999217987,
-0.06011277437210083,
0.028644409030675888,
-0.011607510969042778,
-0.05263826623558998,
0.02138138748705387,
0.03416239097714424,
-0.03266033157706261,
0.014524037949740887,
-0.037650786340236664,
-0.03374497964978218,
0.061811573803424835,
-0.01232243049889803,
-0.0426715649664402,
-0.0037279583048075438,
0.0776023119688034,
0.027989106252789497,
0.04877927154302597,
0.009133015759289265,
-0.08909407258033752,
0.04830535501241684,
-0.012686360627412796,
0.006268262397497892,
0.013500266708433628,
-0.015876343473792076,
0.07370147109031677,
-0.030744312331080437,
0.005690878722816706,
0.03026697412133217,
-0.08065786957740784,
-0.008047687821090221,
-0.0051069101318717,
-0.003464475739747286,
0.04279739409685135,
0.019111065194010735,
0.04169655963778496,
0.05640697851777077,
0.01139106322079897,
-0.007968132384121418,
0.04216993972659111,
-0.02555856481194496,
0.04747390002012253,
-0.010769926942884922,
-0.05878717452287674,
0.002481624484062195,
0.010085877031087875,
-0.05958448722958565,
-0.03163713589310646,
-0.03188816085457802,
-0.002877019578590989,
0.02967224456369877,
-0.03176676109433174,
-0.02563982643187046,
-0.016873056069016457,
0.011255111545324326,
0.010203507728874683,
0.02694477140903473,
0.0051152827218174934,
-0.06753046065568924,
0.0676708072423935,
0.015951650217175484,
-0.009663417004048824,
0.0013242093846201897,
-0.05097980052232742,
0.10515297949314117,
0.05971142277121544,
-0.03441990166902542,
0.02559134177863598,
0.052294500172138214,
0.03028009459376335,
-0.037044182419776917,
0.005849550478160381,
-0.03507658466696739,
-0.03824968636035919,
-0.005480967462062836,
-0.04453945532441139,
-0.02872602641582489,
0.08895068615674973,
-0.031265828758478165,
-0.015168662182986736,
0.03405798226594925,
-0.034575656056404114,
0.04154065251350403,
0.029764968901872635,
0.009426563046872616,
0.025444377213716507,
-0.012763939797878265,
-0.032365161925554276,
-0.0616975836455822,
-0.028877854347229004,
0.0009299780940636992,
-0.05212843418121338,
-0.02729472517967224,
0.030061259865760803,
-0.02871839329600334,
-0.0012525172205641866,
-0.004906110931187868,
0.05338743329048157,
0.049550510942935944,
0.016809828579425812,
0.046641409397125244,
-0.021790260449051857,
-0.028499092906713486,
-0.02037869580090046,
-0.06361586600542068,
-0.0314478799700737,
-0.04748832806944847,
0.019856046885252,
0.01067759282886982,
0.03806120157241821,
0.009425150230526924,
0.01905469223856926,
0.01622319594025612,
-0.03262890875339508,
0.022105399519205093,
0.06812456995248795,
0.03244403377175331,
-0.0489080511033535,
-0.0479981005191803,
0.0065098535269498825,
0.033317599445581436,
-0.020932938903570175,
-0.02926390990614891,
-0.052364129573106766,
-0.055913493037223816,
-0.007564270403236151,
-0.0443064384162426,
-0.01696896366775036,
0.011084663681685925,
0.026231274008750916,
0.02401578798890114,
-0.005437376443296671,
0.010668720118701458,
0.06544160097837448,
0.028778713196516037,
0.028247710317373276,
0.0475274883210659,
-0.005097079556435347,
0.028732135891914368,
-0.040339574217796326,
0.02412455715239048,
0.01570415124297142,
0.01980830542743206,
-0.0010981897357851267,
-0.027868490666151047,
0.004340420942753553,
0.0025841370224952698,
-0.2582172751426697,
-0.009204751811921597,
0.005641346797347069,
-0.0063076503574848175,
0.01417228952050209,
-0.03865744546055794,
-0.014433406293392181,
-0.013858660124242306,
-0.0027665782254189253,
0.002469188068062067,
0.0439375638961792,
0.055378418415784836,
0.01770220883190632,
0.03666684031486511,
0.03839907795190811,
0.05234818160533905,
0.00039909794577397406,
-0.016670674085617065,
-0.00020625011529773474,
0.03851533308625221,
-0.007411270868033171,
-0.06025111302733421,
-0.02263963222503662,
0.03880593925714493,
-0.015358129516243935,
0.02952936477959156,
-0.09713944792747498,
-0.00407429039478302,
-0.018570998683571815,
-0.029834678396582603,
0.015635304152965546,
-0.02442675270140171,
-0.007785439491271973,
0.04635225981473923,
0.006628265604376793,
0.0007073073065839708,
0.0483565554022789,
-0.009053952991962433,
0.02563272975385189,
0.04207413271069527,
0.030846035107970238,
-0.01786278747022152,
-0.004601769614964724,
-0.011592105962336063,
0.07871583104133606,
-0.0050864797085523605,
-0.028256436809897423,
-0.03457506746053696,
-0.00406707264482975,
0.018613409250974655,
-0.02668021060526371,
-0.042085591703653336,
-0.060249827802181244,
0.006845469586551189,
0.0029782685451209545,
-0.04613311216235161,
0.009090224280953407,
-0.018782449886202812,
-0.02913874387741089,
0.010485945269465446,
0.026892023161053658,
-0.05111314356327057,
0.0007318041170947254,
-0.06163909286260605,
-0.023238327354192734,
-0.032519057393074036,
-0.04947745427489281,
-0.05479012802243233,
0.04990340396761894,
0.06088270992040634,
-0.010114265605807304,
0.04972779005765915,
-0.004550562705844641,
-0.0818776935338974,
0.02168220654129982,
0.01361599937081337,
0.02159235067665577,
0.01595795713365078,
-0.015206681564450264,
0.05905311554670334,
-0.039401181042194366,
-0.04852471500635147,
0.01753263734281063,
0.05019382759928703,
0.0055805472657084465,
-0.046357426792383194,
-0.006436826195567846,
-0.04130090773105621,
0.0005909189349040389,
-0.025225698947906494,
0.034023307263851166,
-0.018320931121706963,
0.011415543965995312,
0.013705303892493248,
0.052269093692302704,
0.03189031034708023,
0.03033662773668766,
0.04118660092353821,
0.05328110232949257,
0.02146584540605545,
0.007007055450230837,
-0.07041463255882263,
-0.015103927813470364,
-0.03287670388817787,
-0.0207988154143095,
0.05195654183626175,
-0.04918443039059639,
-0.010880735702812672,
0.05137956514954567,
-0.05102289095520973,
-0.0476498007774353,
-0.04934707283973694,
-0.006640397012233734,
-0.02393621951341629,
0.014042061753571033,
0.001828717184253037,
0.016365719959139824,
0.02997337467968464,
0.025977306067943573,
-0.003929018974304199,
-0.012475443072617054,
0.013925288803875446,
0.012400454841554165,
-0.006844320334494114,
-0.018302207812666893,
-0.031030600890517235,
-0.027590034529566765,
-0.007237040903419256,
0.03372828662395477,
-0.01652171090245247,
0.04307844862341881,
0.02966679260134697,
-0.018217938020825386,
0.02755044214427471,
0.04452010244131088,
-0.017782051116228104,
0.029275918379426003,
-0.013030256144702435,
0.06187077611684799,
-0.013365158811211586,
0.019660478457808495,
-0.031833358108997345,
0.012927358970046043,
0.03154265508055687,
0.0312375258654356,
0.026310143992304802,
0.010642456822097301,
0.002671419642865658,
0.001722247339785099,
0.016389820724725723,
-0.009441542439162731,
-0.045301418751478195,
-0.023191876709461212,
-0.044310539960861206,
-0.004607942420989275,
-0.004966028034687042,
0.04266543686389923,
0.0018312009051442146,
0.005954212509095669,
-0.07171575725078583,
0.05983753129839897,
-0.012852090410888195,
-0.008989382535219193,
-0.01756379008293152,
0.017080536112189293,
0.04579838365316391,
-0.016888322308659554,
0.02368730679154396,
0.03581184893846512,
0.016311252489686012,
-0.0014547489117830992,
-0.00010280079004587606,
0.01705181784927845,
0.013235678896307945,
-0.03913445770740509,
0.006096656899899244,
0.004594648722559214,
0.04049193114042282,
-0.030717281624674797,
0.04084188863635063,
0.00888113584369421,
0.007748360279947519,
-0.02871502935886383,
0.015527309849858284,
0.07964563369750977,
0.018573597073554993,
0.019500797614455223,
-0.012488028965890408,
-0.06083551049232483,
0.020180203020572662,
-0.02450738288462162,
-0.03162938728928566,
-0.02863110974431038,
-0.03239947929978371,
0.0073265875689685345,
-0.07338336110115051,
0.022271422669291496,
-0.011244343593716621,
-0.05238169804215431,
0.0019754611421376467,
-0.0016661247937008739,
0.012930097058415413,
-0.047410380095243454,
-0.02915824204683304,
-0.026687856763601303,
-0.09349925071001053,
0.016397247090935707,
0.016457440331578255,
-0.06905755400657654,
-0.019783366471529007,
-0.0014911770122125745,
-0.03391128405928612,
-0.04597226530313492,
0.024036087095737457,
0.01873382180929184,
0.005070948041975498,
-0.019213732331991196,
0.0011777594918385148,
0.023249180987477303,
-0.014866485260426998,
0.044888678938150406,
0.006357462611049414,
-0.008871144615113735,
0.009022037498652935,
0.011282972060143948,
0.08064382523298264,
-0.018344637006521225,
-0.014004077762365341,
-0.05510842427611351,
-0.02389509230852127,
0.006631703581660986,
-0.04204711690545082,
0.02533259615302086,
0.05773765966296196,
-0.035544201731681824,
-0.008554529398679733,
-0.03406500816345215,
-0.004116859752684832,
-0.018876805901527405,
-0.00015878555132076144,
0.029549233615398407,
-0.01139358151704073,
-0.018700651824474335,
-0.0034189014695584774,
-0.011556938290596008,
0.03267594426870346,
0.023815101012587547,
0.020998114719986916,
0.0273855309933424,
0.0004874622682109475,
0.03132632002234459,
0.02901134081184864,
-0.05968843773007393,
-0.020002329722046852,
0.06458301097154617,
-0.021564839407801628,
-0.018392717465758324,
-0.09278864413499832,
-0.053700100630521774,
0.018105575814843178,
0.025232598185539246,
0.07628349959850311,
-0.007325752172619104,
0.04367297515273094,
0.0190903153270483,
0.05332159250974655,
0.005621634423732758,
-0.0017174303065985441,
0.03171020746231079,
-0.025002019479870796,
-0.012745381332933903,
-0.027220124378800392,
-0.027803907170891762,
0.08562427759170532,
-0.02424389123916626,
0.027946837246418,
-0.004054472781717777,
-0.03857725113630295,
0.00014918341184966266,
-0.035693515092134476,
-0.05166345089673996,
-0.011562338098883629,
-0.014603138901293278,
0.00403195945546031,
0.01594654656946659,
-0.04658862575888634,
-0.0030307190027087927,
-0.021394476294517517,
-0.041058499366045,
-0.023123763501644135,
-0.010044117458164692,
0.07663118839263916,
-0.03622286766767502,
0.03481835126876831,
-0.029086772352457047,
-0.01699935272336006,
0.021558649837970734,
0.08787409216165543,
-0.01177375391125679,
0.04626764729619026,
-0.04548485577106476,
0.02345537580549717,
0.02828553318977356,
-0.03449457511305809,
0.008182909339666367,
-0.01189466193318367,
-0.014493140392005444,
-0.06305214762687683,
0.04059977829456329,
-0.024769175797700882,
-0.005752114113420248,
-0.04961564764380455,
0.09533681720495224,
0.024095935747027397,
-0.04952961578965187,
-0.047520097345113754,
0.04179735854268074,
-0.007757432758808136,
0.0053190262988209724,
-0.021822750568389893,
0.01105355191975832,
-0.01963070034980774,
0.06365352123975754,
0.01930352672934532,
0.02882854826748371,
0.07558302581310272,
-0.01583002135157585,
-0.0483737550675869,
0.006334507837891579,
0.06712449342012405,
0.06806844472885132,
0.03258388489484787,
-0.008534552529454231,
0.05996550992131233,
-0.024359483271837234,
-0.035377874970436096,
0.030434152111411095,
0.007373043801635504,
-0.00950219202786684,
-0.022831333801150322,
0.0016848673112690449,
0.07581758499145508,
-0.0035143981222063303,
0.07479040324687958,
-0.06859281659126282,
0.011885910294950008,
0.036083053797483444,
0.03947591036558151,
-0.011582913808524609,
0.015003642998635769,
0.007118283770978451,
0.0000563635585422162,
-0.04570331424474716,
-0.02560589089989662,
0.004927612375468016,
-0.020585469901561737,
0.010792178101837635,
-0.012951585464179516,
-0.03178277239203453,
0.01138309482485056,
-0.0359063595533371,
0.04929947480559349,
0.10707701742649078,
-0.01593460515141487,
-0.034374501556158066,
0.009535660967230797,
0.0229765884578228,
0.0198746956884861,
0.055480509996414185,
0.007339887320995331,
-0.01713564246892929,
0.01836288534104824,
-0.06526147574186325,
0.003725743154063821,
0.030363816767930984,
-0.01439282950013876,
0.0013638576492667198,
-0.01460258662700653,
-0.02693217806518078,
0.021966755390167236,
0.028252724558115005,
-0.02581162191927433,
-0.0586605928838253,
-0.04123877361416817,
-0.023337414488196373,
-0.049622733145952225,
-0.025181109085679054,
0.02973111718893051,
0.018724925816059113,
-0.017656825482845306,
-0.03619210049510002,
-0.05445856228470802,
0.019777754321694374,
0.03711564466357231,
-0.041979625821113586,
0.018925484269857407,
0.0110136354342103,
0.041963815689086914,
-0.005958088673651218,
0.01670164428651333,
0.028376268222928047,
-0.023573538288474083,
-0.008737602271139622,
0.04473724216222763,
0.04255037009716034,
0.008106098510324955,
-0.004198953043669462,
-0.044939666986465454,
-0.09606991708278656,
0.007831582799553871,
0.018057340756058693,
-0.006041352637112141,
-0.08065526932477951,
0.024958783760666847,
-0.018190870061516762,
0.04860576242208481,
0.056240372359752655,
0.0030667975079268217,
0.044262178242206573,
-0.04456506669521332,
-0.01330562774091959,
0.03373018279671669,
-0.006752286572009325,
0.055592652410268784,
-0.0008057786035351455,
0.0714225322008133,
0.05135773494839668,
0.053180109709501266,
-0.035472746938467026,
0.019008731469511986,
-0.0017489079618826509,
0.017101937904953957,
-0.04731656238436699,
-0.021694781258702278,
-0.07346595078706741,
-0.0877394899725914,
-0.04873223602771759,
0.03653052821755409,
-0.018547607585787773,
-0.03359758481383324,
0.011178994551301003,
0.025898750871419907,
0.02735324576497078,
-0.028721796348690987,
0.005568772554397583,
-0.025447331368923187,
-0.0005024154670536518,
-0.006939928513020277,
-0.07664366066455841,
0.01975177228450775,
-0.023145902901887894,
0.03347925469279289,
-0.023747913539409637,
-0.02696794643998146,
0.007279625162482262,
0.010707828216254711,
0.014150111004710197,
0.013515034690499306,
0.030298426747322083,
-0.00978992972522974
] |
350 |
RTop-K: Ultra-Fast Row-Wise Top-K Selection for Neural Network Acceleration on GPUs
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=PHg4rAXFVH
|
[
"Xi Xie",
"Yuebo Luo",
"Hongwu Peng",
"Caiwen Ding"
] |
Poster
|
Abstract Top-k selection algorithms are fundamental in a wide range of applications, including high-performance computing, information retrieval, big data processing, and neural network model training. In this paper, we present RTop-K, a highly efficient parallel row-wise top-k selection algorithm specifically designed for GPUs. RTop-K leverages a binary search-based approach to optimize row-wise top-k selection, providing a scalable and accelerated solution.
We conduct a detailed analysis of early stopping in our algorithm, showing that it effectively maintains the testing accuracy of neural network models while substantially improving performance. Our GPU implementation of RTop-K demonstrates superior performance over state-of-the-art row-wise top-k GPU implementations, achieving an average speed-up of up to 11.49× with early stopping and 7.29× without early stopping. Moreover, RTop-K accelerates the overall training workflow of MaxK-GNNs, delivering speed-ups ranging from 11.97% to 33.29% across different models and datasets.
|
row-wise topk selection, GPU, CUDA
| null | 13,337 | null |
[
-0.0354311428964138,
-0.03449159488081932,
0.012918174266815186,
0.030631475150585175,
0.012855465523898602,
0.05122945085167885,
-0.005048239137977362,
0.05062687024474144,
-0.02285471186041832,
-0.031160850077867508,
-0.001112080179154873,
-0.030543457716703415,
-0.06677407771348953,
0.00437881238758564,
0.024918988347053528,
0.04241710901260376,
0.0234853345900774,
-0.029679113999009132,
0.01594996638596058,
0.02140129916369915,
0.0068436493165791035,
-0.05058798938989639,
0.018531089648604393,
0.034500010311603546,
0.012000803835690022,
0.010974797420203686,
-0.0057999202981591225,
0.01971965841948986,
-0.01892566680908203,
0.006640406791120768,
0.031072551384568214,
0.014009520411491394,
-0.00652995565906167,
-0.030359314754605293,
0.04477658122777939,
0.009036093950271606,
-0.030191047117114067,
0.0006807249737903476,
0.013426312245428562,
0.0058090402744710445,
-0.009225398302078247,
-0.013349205255508423,
0.004863546695560217,
0.033909596502780914,
-0.040809910744428635,
0.04374196007847786,
-0.07433802634477615,
0.020995886996388435,
-0.01970757357776165,
-0.01954333484172821,
-0.07338552176952362,
0.028199128806591034,
0.01048020925372839,
-0.023004023358225822,
0.027575302869081497,
0.022914661094546318,
0.015769679099321365,
-0.025233406573534012,
0.00595545070245862,
-0.04988623410463333,
0.0010956396581605077,
-0.004289703909307718,
0.022914806380867958,
0.0258143562823534,
-0.006352263502776623,
0.0004116694035474211,
0.018775077536702156,
0.033661630004644394,
-0.031940411776304245,
-0.03975474834442139,
-0.024772144854068756,
0.002319919876754284,
0.012956020422279835,
0.021992754191160202,
-0.009785449132323265,
-0.016742480918765068,
0.004420979414135218,
0.042411983013153076,
0.06941776722669601,
-0.0015489476500079036,
0.03347514569759369,
-0.021308934316039085,
-0.017972145229578018,
0.06372277438640594,
-0.012896206229925156,
0.006091756280511618,
-0.01889941841363907,
-0.051188476383686066,
-0.08664995431900024,
0.026286372914910316,
-0.035768743604421616,
-0.006875017192214727,
0.0010764230974018574,
0.029850071296095848,
-0.024134403094649315,
0.007742523215711117,
-0.007511218078434467,
-0.013706325553357601,
-0.006554341409355402,
0.008494680747389793,
0.01031121239066124,
-0.07549050450325012,
0.021782102063298225,
0.01584288850426674,
-0.10000287741422653,
-0.01572788879275322,
-0.01306039746850729,
0.006956144236028194,
-0.01662307418882847,
0.02889544516801834,
-0.013372748158872128,
0.022332103922963142,
0.03273509442806244,
-0.01611078716814518,
-0.08377985656261444,
0.03458112105727196,
-0.00727086141705513,
-0.003513217670843005,
0.0032664353493601084,
-0.01607847400009632,
0.04680730029940605,
0.09244382381439209,
-0.02765689603984356,
0.0746479406952858,
0.03292611613869667,
0.015323001891374588,
0.013704981654882431,
0.03542386740446091,
-0.028545266017317772,
-0.06401096284389496,
-0.02152695693075657,
0.017934221774339676,
0.0047105769626796246,
0.010465207509696484,
-0.005627530161291361,
0.0028284993022680283,
-0.02651524357497692,
0.0173855759203434,
0.060406628996133804,
-0.023871419951319695,
0.0212901309132576,
-0.061229296028614044,
0.05608012154698372,
-0.03322972357273102,
0.04768664762377739,
-0.025587422773241997,
0.0239548496901989,
-0.014772395603358746,
-0.029636988416314125,
0.021007321774959564,
0.011047597974538803,
0.018029121682047844,
-0.02393507957458496,
-0.04440170153975487,
0.022342169657349586,
0.07480185478925705,
0.019433889538049698,
0.021722067147493362,
0.0007355964044108987,
0.027966942638158798,
0.034818507730960846,
-0.013790370896458626,
-0.042465467005968094,
-0.032739076763391495,
-0.04112362861633301,
-0.02467585727572441,
0.07231142371892929,
0.039581019431352615,
-0.036643534898757935,
0.010950397700071335,
-0.02896781824529171,
-0.05415661633014679,
0.03636045381426811,
0.008012793958187103,
-0.0060967253521084785,
-0.0025498047471046448,
0.05611257255077362,
-0.024706821888685226,
0.006075676530599594,
0.025921592488884926,
-0.08799510449171066,
0.03661515191197395,
0.014736009761691093,
0.004072083160281181,
-0.056185271590948105,
-0.02414267137646675,
0.07976153492927551,
-0.023508569225668907,
0.0007775602862238884,
-0.009759955108165741,
-0.08029551059007645,
-0.008517459034919739,
0.01852448470890522,
0.0011223010951653123,
0.07951419055461884,
0.03148835152387619,
-0.011876142583787441,
-0.013722773641347885,
0.004722112324088812,
0.031151220202445984,
0.07615673542022705,
-0.01247099693864584,
0.057488832622766495,
-0.040329329669475555,
-0.04830440878868103,
-0.03055865503847599,
0.049388252198696136,
-0.047212447971105576,
-0.05586744099855423,
-0.002018868224695325,
-0.01241842471063137,
-0.0071492502465844154,
-0.030953317880630493,
0.010092982091009617,
0.042475007474422455,
0.00632137805223465,
-0.0017961051780730486,
0.02947804518043995,
0.034694377332925797,
-0.051064588129520416,
0.04362606257200241,
0.004475011490285397,
0.009066968224942684,
-0.00069361028727144,
-0.037574995309114456,
0.10259351134300232,
0.03960578516125679,
-0.0438276082277298,
0.018257327377796173,
-0.0005587289924733341,
0.016817104071378708,
0.02507718838751316,
0.017937738448381424,
-0.03866089880466461,
-0.03544236719608307,
-0.04314206540584564,
0.011709949932992458,
-0.008821201510727406,
0.06472092121839523,
-0.03307926282286644,
-0.07840653508901596,
0.06271456182003021,
0.001854023546911776,
0.06857258826494217,
0.0316736213862896,
-0.02078237757086754,
0.046727169305086136,
-0.0191609188914299,
-0.026329556480050087,
-0.024651743471622467,
-0.007310300599783659,
0.006067479029297829,
-0.002630719682201743,
-0.014121481217443943,
-0.0020280585158616304,
-0.03540710359811783,
-0.010707048699259758,
-0.02317156083881855,
0.05290190875530243,
0.03636408597230911,
0.0008661315077915788,
0.009298806078732014,
0.027790293097496033,
-0.049533188343048096,
-0.03806545212864876,
-0.11668191105127335,
-0.031305644661188126,
0.012769991531968117,
0.0357099324464798,
0.00017888157162815332,
0.041781406849622726,
-0.027549752965569496,
-0.01679307222366333,
-0.043078821152448654,
-0.06911653280258179,
-0.011889252811670303,
0.01550870481878519,
0.030448274686932564,
-0.04185473173856735,
-0.036453381180763245,
0.03856969252228737,
0.07382441312074661,
-0.01953078806400299,
-0.0057725198566913605,
-0.0027544014155864716,
-0.05178441107273102,
0.003931001294404268,
-0.058273859322071075,
0.008133649826049805,
0.0010646573500707746,
-0.011542501859366894,
0.03660903498530388,
-0.07902560383081436,
0.003551058704033494,
0.046140726655721664,
0.08725182712078094,
0.030519044026732445,
-0.0026190453208982944,
-0.03384198620915413,
0.012828923761844635,
0.008730633184313774,
0.04497591406106949,
-0.01726209558546543,
0.012002527713775635,
-0.03610607981681824,
-0.01195974089205265,
-0.009111386723816395,
-0.00795314833521843,
-0.25059404969215393,
-0.04619705677032471,
-0.014385269954800606,
-0.0006893834215588868,
0.044102154672145844,
-0.01491495594382286,
0.01597357541322708,
0.013076386414468288,
-0.006067302078008652,
-0.007143176160752773,
0.013946974650025368,
0.010616328567266464,
-0.0027205359656363726,
0.04747893288731575,
0.04597720876336098,
0.03906741738319397,
0.027111101895570755,
-0.009827853180468082,
0.01938561722636223,
0.04939490184187889,
0.006158918607980013,
-0.10480023920536041,
-0.026861384510993958,
0.0064722513779997826,
-0.016397617757320404,
0.03951374441385269,
-0.09276733547449112,
-0.012941154651343822,
-0.03830902278423309,
-0.017371464520692825,
-0.021480554714798927,
-0.03414202108979225,
-0.006716274656355381,
0.0397803969681263,
0.01983136311173439,
-0.022885549813508987,
0.03774389997124672,
-0.01164236105978489,
0.004515474662184715,
0.007962176576256752,
0.019406244158744812,
-0.016038494184613228,
-0.03978860378265381,
0.02653391659259796,
0.07502737641334534,
0.02920728735625744,
-0.06420036405324936,
-0.01343069039285183,
-0.010370464995503426,
0.001509745605289936,
-0.006206736899912357,
-0.01490095630288124,
-0.04153678938746452,
0.01907084323465824,
-0.02185647562146187,
-0.02812282368540764,
-0.011963878758251667,
0.03773941099643707,
0.006611988414078951,
0.05233191326260567,
-0.030592061579227448,
-0.08267182856798172,
0.016730299219489098,
-0.007752151694148779,
-0.026699474081397057,
-0.04852566868066788,
-0.06602367758750916,
-0.045337799936532974,
0.015622028149664402,
0.053713273257017136,
0.001422123285010457,
0.02225329354405403,
-0.00032290114904753864,
-0.08202637732028961,
-0.009357876144349575,
0.018511610105633736,
-0.01137976162135601,
0.013815549202263355,
0.009891639463603497,
0.08763199299573898,
-0.04094134271144867,
-0.057141710072755814,
0.009346959181129932,
0.012605950236320496,
0.021160723641514778,
-0.04902909696102142,
-0.027958780527114868,
-0.037297509610652924,
0.008878353983163834,
0.004908327478915453,
0.04296313598752022,
-0.017013728618621826,
0.04321858286857605,
-0.05033152550458908,
0.05630255863070488,
0.02372637204825878,
0.03717348352074623,
0.045512277632951736,
0.017120178788900375,
0.022686976939439774,
0.015750624239444733,
-0.08620768040418625,
-0.023355089128017426,
-0.0412733256816864,
-0.03587588295340538,
0.023092031478881836,
-0.019861258566379547,
-0.02395492233335972,
0.05049889534711838,
0.032843396067619324,
-0.022620338946580887,
-0.05021357163786888,
0.02987796626985073,
-0.02975430339574814,
0.01199763361364603,
-0.0012794401263818145,
0.021431343629956245,
0.03742539882659912,
0.0034102387726306915,
0.009822078980505466,
-0.039276085793972015,
0.028946951031684875,
-0.03690771013498306,
-0.022576235234737396,
0.014085077680647373,
0.0012831015046685934,
-0.025061041116714478,
-0.024365311488509178,
-0.032131463289260864,
0.002891930751502514,
0.03916981816291809,
0.07033071666955948,
0.0032336341682821512,
0.0354849137365818,
0.019707636907696724,
-0.016421053558588028,
-0.00744938850402832,
-0.014892898499965668,
0.046099402010440826,
0.005948980338871479,
0.027757924050092697,
-0.0007896111346781254,
0.02506510354578495,
0.0068214694038033485,
0.002718286821618676,
0.03447730466723442,
-0.0021539272274821997,
0.00329160806722939,
0.0012990611139684916,
0.016860289499163628,
0.01572597213089466,
-0.03657327592372894,
-0.00520393718034029,
-0.04966304078698158,
0.03794262558221817,
0.003868883242830634,
0.05090335011482239,
-0.021473262459039688,
0.006193650420755148,
-0.07019961625337601,
0.05041626840829849,
0.01910969242453575,
-0.018875518813729286,
-0.01382372621446848,
0.0036681476049125195,
0.054250072687864304,
-0.00038302867324091494,
-0.011181277222931385,
0.012920795008540154,
0.023473378270864487,
0.0003613896551541984,
-0.013046672567725182,
-0.03740876540541649,
-0.014374510385096073,
-0.02119537629187107,
0.01967625319957733,
0.03465329855680466,
-0.0028254613280296326,
-0.013556856662034988,
-0.003650160739198327,
-0.003121600951999426,
0.01958524063229561,
-0.017589520663022995,
-0.007714531850069761,
0.09461776167154312,
0.042280130088329315,
-0.01831802725791931,
0.016616743057966232,
-0.004958390258252621,
0.04447123035788536,
-0.0060164593160152435,
0.02829303964972496,
-0.008979459293186665,
-0.026918204501271248,
-0.009730001911520958,
-0.01639968901872635,
0.0003960268513765186,
0.04491690918803215,
-0.0364922359585762,
-0.022930188104510307,
-0.019510162994265556,
0.03572675585746765,
-0.027470607310533524,
-0.010568056255578995,
0.0771523118019104,
-0.04563475027680397,
0.01394575648009777,
0.04733315855264664,
0.005455951206386089,
0.029095260426402092,
-0.018927793949842453,
-0.025400562211871147,
-0.02617371268570423,
0.003793829120695591,
0.0219601858407259,
-0.006640576291829348,
-0.0014865673147141933,
-0.009478896856307983,
-0.03380335122346878,
-0.0009468250791542232,
0.03185776248574257,
0.017499374225735664,
0.004931904375553131,
-0.02984922006726265,
0.008005987852811813,
0.05079803615808487,
-0.0026613324880599976,
-0.02442314848303795,
-0.01176848728209734,
-0.0034401798620820045,
0.017812609672546387,
-0.06192733347415924,
0.017802244052290916,
0.04061540961265564,
0.004203217104077339,
0.02650652453303337,
-0.03052373416721821,
0.037952788174152374,
-0.00663192942738533,
-0.017096934840083122,
0.00927130039781332,
-0.018234366551041603,
-0.05742223933339119,
0.0006535123684443533,
-0.02855050377547741,
-0.00808282196521759,
0.022080793976783752,
0.03474701568484306,
0.010915937833487988,
0.013728173449635506,
0.036225542426109314,
0.0031447240617126226,
-0.03756440430879593,
-0.0352272093296051,
0.051404595375061035,
-0.0392158105969429,
-0.018422437831759453,
-0.0550571009516716,
-0.053664058446884155,
0.03364543244242668,
-0.052049778401851654,
-0.004128088243305683,
-0.007280392572283745,
0.014740388840436935,
0.011634905822575092,
0.04845130816102028,
0.013807721436023712,
-0.028939906507730484,
0.050992660224437714,
-0.0400163009762764,
-0.0028228776063770056,
-0.06598582118749619,
-0.03171956539154053,
0.019348636269569397,
-0.07104075700044632,
0.007382378913462162,
0.014230532571673393,
-0.04002273455262184,
0.019874680787324905,
-0.012082133442163467,
-0.0688825324177742,
0.006727319676429033,
-0.010243521071970463,
-0.01869230903685093,
0.00939705315977335,
-0.020976100116968155,
0.029525378718972206,
0.011506058275699615,
-0.027316434308886528,
-0.0004887490067631006,
0.014407405629754066,
0.036928534507751465,
-0.024063989520072937,
0.023736663162708282,
-0.04366467520594597,
-0.01974966935813427,
0.05339911952614784,
0.06565459817647934,
-0.01566229574382305,
0.06616076827049255,
-0.05459568649530411,
0.06715834885835648,
0.055988553911447525,
0.007083897478878498,
0.001960359513759613,
0.018825672566890717,
0.009857784025371075,
-0.026348073035478592,
0.015115909278392792,
-0.017291761934757233,
-0.014517637901008129,
-0.07212571799755096,
0.05101634934544563,
0.029868649318814278,
-0.04919205233454704,
-0.032592255622148514,
0.028870748355984688,
-0.056631214916706085,
0.019142918288707733,
-0.043358560651540756,
0.018453536555171013,
0.0050635067746043205,
0.0806167721748352,
0.017881425097584724,
0.02391301654279232,
0.07851674407720566,
0.02654227800667286,
-0.026130935177206993,
-0.032581910490989685,
0.06820888072252274,
0.05897916853427887,
0.044096920639276505,
-0.060385897755622864,
0.03571491315960884,
-0.019282706081867218,
-0.03718818724155426,
0.04282532259821892,
0.020842095836997032,
-0.06516650319099426,
-0.014527086168527603,
0.02919555827975273,
0.06538064777851105,
-0.018143128603696823,
0.07675378769636154,
-0.053710367530584335,
0.023214418441057205,
0.0485205203294754,
0.006533578969538212,
-0.0418970063328743,
0.05442909896373749,
0.013513362966477871,
0.027271926403045654,
-0.032812513411045074,
-0.020610524341464043,
0.008259660564363003,
0.027539018541574478,
-0.007729735691100359,
-0.0039169820956885815,
-0.0273280069231987,
0.014659305103123188,
0.010013853199779987,
0.020474538207054138,
0.08157466351985931,
-0.024705391377210617,
-0.06456317752599716,
0.018580399453639984,
0.0335644856095314,
-0.008498633280396461,
0.04402322322130203,
-0.00812390074133873,
-0.02072145789861679,
0.009223632514476776,
-0.0319550484418869,
0.000853671517688781,
-0.013532347977161407,
0.0022129258140921593,
0.022955210879445076,
-0.023769821971654892,
-0.018814293667674065,
0.044712863862514496,
0.005055475514382124,
-0.03939858451485634,
-0.050688281655311584,
-0.028379522264003754,
-0.04080690070986748,
-0.035020168870687485,
-0.026707012206315994,
-0.0013702476862818003,
-0.022788867354393005,
-0.033755481243133545,
0.0026857401244342327,
-0.031185682862997055,
-0.014166702516376972,
0.03937511891126633,
-0.059968501329422,
-0.02711709775030613,
0.02777751162648201,
-0.01611102558672428,
-0.007358624134212732,
0.06099746376276016,
0.022030359134078026,
-0.03167081996798515,
-0.016957828775048256,
0.065071240067482,
0.022338252514600754,
0.0047791488468647,
0.005770761054009199,
-0.03311772644519806,
-0.11253656446933746,
0.020324770361185074,
0.009763001464307308,
-0.021654486656188965,
-0.05880897864699364,
-0.0329037681221962,
-0.054220546036958694,
0.006318457890301943,
0.06422682851552963,
-0.0005973104853183031,
0.040913816541433334,
-0.04464657977223396,
-0.024390652775764465,
0.006519826129078865,
0.0065014599822461605,
0.05015760660171509,
-0.033192358911037445,
0.06763353943824768,
0.07271403074264526,
-0.009814799763262272,
0.008867139928042889,
0.01981806382536888,
0.02527620457112789,
0.010726140812039375,
-0.02931028977036476,
0.013827954418957233,
-0.04918782785534859,
-0.1025657206773758,
0.017521029338240623,
0.019518103450536728,
0.0161336250603199,
-0.03904078155755997,
-0.008861834183335304,
-0.02191733382642269,
0.007956410758197308,
-0.012109572999179363,
-0.016302337870001793,
-0.01185799390077591,
-0.04801236465573311,
-0.020982129499316216,
-0.05787447467446327,
0.048537980765104294,
-0.05591024085879326,
0.0037897019647061825,
-0.016839537769556046,
-0.05261031538248062,
-0.01096030231565237,
-0.017786946147680283,
0.05274658277630806,
0.002708290470764041,
0.02767840027809143,
-0.008476050570607185
] |
351 |
DelTA: An Online Document-Level Translation Agent Based on Multi-Level Memory
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hoYFLRNbhc
|
[
"Yutong Wang",
"Jiali Zeng",
"Xuebo Liu",
"Derek F. Wong",
"Fandong Meng",
"Jie Zhou",
"Min Zhang"
] |
Poster
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved reasonable quality improvements in machine translation (MT).
However, most current research on MT-LLMs still faces significant challenges in maintaining translation consistency and accuracy when processing entire documents.
In this paper, we introduce DelTA, a Document-levEL Translation Agent designed to overcome these limitations.
DelTA features a multi-level memory structure that stores information across various granularities and spans, including Proper Noun Records, Bilingual Summary, Long-Term Memory, and Short-Term Memory, which are continuously retrieved and updated by auxiliary LLM-based components.
Experimental results indicate that DelTA significantly outperforms strong baselines in terms of translation consistency and quality across four open/closed-source LLMs and two representative document translation datasets, achieving an increase in consistency scores by up to 4.58 percentage points and in COMET scores by up to 3.16 points on average.
DelTA employs a sentence-by-sentence translation strategy, ensuring no sentence omissions and offering a memory-efficient solution compared to the mainstream method.
Furthermore, DelTA improves pronoun and context-dependent translation accuracy, and the summary component of the agent also shows promise as a tool for query-based summarization tasks.
The code and data of our approach are released at https://github.com/YutongWang1216/DocMTAgent.
|
Document-Level Translation, Large Language Models, Autonomous Agents, Natural Language Processing
|
We develop a document-level translation agent based on multi-level memory to address the challenges associated with the DocMT task.
| 13,334 |
2410.08143
|
[
-0.0075999666005373,
-0.009346417151391506,
-0.02579246461391449,
0.04268704727292061,
0.054807282984256744,
0.00568873668089509,
-0.006892431993037462,
0.022634340450167656,
-0.0023007914423942566,
-0.025161700323224068,
-0.023273317143321037,
0.02746162749826908,
-0.04449250176548958,
0.01085702981799841,
0.01708213984966278,
0.03937540948390961,
0.04486861452460289,
0.004325308371335268,
0.011906486935913563,
-0.034284722059965134,
-0.030486194416880608,
-0.0020717966835945845,
0.03665495291352272,
0.002632709452882409,
0.016845835372805595,
0.01214017253369093,
0.002955981530249119,
-0.0037655874621123075,
-0.040553998202085495,
0.03691655397415161,
0.016362549737095833,
-0.025964025408029556,
-0.005597501061856747,
0.023140890523791313,
0.02471316047012806,
-0.013070746324956417,
-0.058254826813936234,
0.03416268900036812,
0.012648933567106724,
-0.007041255012154579,
-0.014348803088068962,
0.018203172832727432,
-0.037561558187007904,
0.03028431348502636,
-0.04094846546649933,
0.0043473923578858376,
-0.0876435935497284,
0.003446794580668211,
-0.001963638234883547,
-0.014836462214589119,
-0.11609261482954025,
0.052236635237932205,
-0.013779291883111,
-0.01996232196688652,
0.013957113958895206,
0.0649065375328064,
0.03584501892328262,
-0.07457444816827774,
0.009471733123064041,
-0.02614518813788891,
-0.03646880388259888,
0.009456031024456024,
0.03456893935799599,
0.032891448587179184,
0.014267324469983578,
-0.03377110883593559,
-0.02746105194091797,
0.009342401288449764,
-0.058760691434144974,
-0.03566725179553032,
0.010382008738815784,
0.0014674915000796318,
-0.017518125474452972,
0.011567916721105576,
0.006420845165848732,
-0.018008725717663765,
0.006929363124072552,
0.028421055525541306,
0.062815360724926,
-0.004985968582332134,
-0.02852719835937023,
0.024400781840085983,
0.016532573848962784,
0.04493235424160957,
0.005584379658102989,
0.016900334507226944,
-0.041636377573013306,
-0.02110975794494152,
-0.07245142757892609,
0.01013810746371746,
-0.002025593537837267,
-0.056855008006095886,
0.030236724764108658,
0.03248779475688934,
0.0020081447437405586,
0.0065136137418448925,
0.024294625967741013,
0.053404126316308975,
-0.0007278204429894686,
0.009430057369172573,
-0.0671570897102356,
-0.042409155517816544,
0.05159406736493111,
0.003054501721635461,
-0.10159711539745331,
-0.028496256098151207,
-0.04721839353442192,
0.009003587998449802,
0.027005037292838097,
-0.010041600093245506,
-0.0072473627515137196,
-0.004427754785865545,
0.009610088542103767,
-0.004994222428649664,
-0.071615070104599,
0.006308787036687136,
0.014538564719259739,
0.028893988579511642,
-0.02952686697244644,
-0.002410752000287175,
0.07765799015760422,
0.026730673387646675,
-0.0012464114697650075,
0.06374480575323105,
-0.020865926519036293,
-0.01720624603331089,
0.02574729733169079,
0.0006547811208292842,
-0.0337805449962616,
-0.03988116979598999,
0.016043389216065407,
0.054742053151130676,
-0.010814102366566658,
0.02091928757727146,
-0.030924387276172638,
0.02277419902384281,
0.016006706282496452,
0.008442932739853859,
0.07888273149728775,
-0.03411354497075081,
0.02005953900516033,
-0.010903625749051571,
-0.00241166353225708,
-0.01941697672009468,
0.04432123154401779,
0.010777234099805355,
-0.0391174852848053,
-0.038113173097372055,
-0.043200794607400894,
-0.012912493199110031,
0.04859130084514618,
-0.00014861425734125078,
0.015557506121695042,
-0.050893865525722504,
0.034427348524332047,
0.062333766371011734,
0.03067384660243988,
0.013523977249860764,
0.008677683770656586,
0.0028986542019993067,
0.013087330386042595,
0.011632983572781086,
-0.05505877733230591,
0.02921552211046219,
-0.033236172050237656,
-0.06086338311433792,
0.012716107070446014,
0.017223985865712166,
-0.042032115161418915,
-0.001211925526149571,
-0.006519719026982784,
-0.03954634442925453,
0.052262336015701294,
-0.00020545349980238825,
-0.007304726168513298,
-0.022859342396259308,
0.04911193624138832,
0.015365217812359333,
0.016915980726480484,
0.04782634973526001,
-0.0667504370212555,
0.03631189838051796,
0.006464743986725807,
-0.024080704897642136,
0.03270057961344719,
0.015898745507001877,
0.09405209869146347,
0.014382884837687016,
-0.01098685897886753,
0.01595841720700264,
-0.08921526372432709,
-0.002614455996081233,
0.01923546940088272,
0.022139783948659897,
0.0576227568089962,
-0.013199800625443459,
0.010822411626577377,
0.10624124854803085,
0.003096570260822773,
0.06407717615365982,
0.062462590634822845,
0.009779461659491062,
0.03643263876438141,
-0.03236720710992813,
-0.0121919522061944,
0.00015262144734151661,
0.01489817351102829,
-0.016699573025107384,
-0.03380027413368225,
0.018073642626404762,
-0.03066905401647091,
0.039992742240428925,
0.022732805460691452,
0.0332324281334877,
-0.02605540305376053,
0.023703420534729958,
-0.010131916031241417,
-0.03465529903769493,
0.006168174557387829,
-0.050757620483636856,
0.057558007538318634,
0.011040566489100456,
-0.0005810479051433504,
-0.022633668035268784,
-0.06434881687164307,
0.09044062346220016,
0.032005492597818375,
-0.03592158108949661,
-0.05205461010336876,
0.015737202018499374,
-0.013127487152814865,
-0.006415817886590958,
0.022097386419773102,
-0.03342796117067337,
-0.016295062378048897,
-0.047044798731803894,
-0.000360894831828773,
-0.0404936745762825,
0.019040869548916817,
-0.04007473215460777,
-0.0019721018616110086,
0.053940631449222565,
-0.019523456692695618,
0.04913352057337761,
0.046109702438116074,
0.024171244353055954,
0.053440697491168976,
-0.019570929929614067,
0.020034752786159515,
-0.03271054849028587,
-0.0095989303663373,
-0.015354404225945473,
-0.015102561563253403,
-0.024448784068226814,
0.000489266705699265,
-0.05229118466377258,
-0.029912041500210762,
-0.016097668558359146,
0.05072673410177231,
0.07123915106058121,
0.0012180753983557224,
0.028509724885225296,
0.03318816050887108,
-0.043825164437294006,
0.012844987213611603,
-0.07752983272075653,
-0.0506778284907341,
-0.03101334162056446,
-0.0058069052174687386,
0.010384914465248585,
0.0400661900639534,
0.005322917830199003,
0.01052937749773264,
-0.028108593076467514,
-0.01682445779442787,
0.004217371344566345,
0.035360269248485565,
0.0033041792921721935,
-0.04496107995510101,
-0.023693066090345383,
0.0023883581161499023,
0.0470772460103035,
-0.01050333958119154,
-0.04468642547726631,
-0.025097807869315147,
-0.03968573734164238,
-0.02390477806329727,
-0.055281318724155426,
0.004472753964364529,
0.0074029481038451195,
0.007050730288028717,
-0.028575098142027855,
-0.03808072581887245,
-0.009154237806797028,
0.031924229115247726,
0.025240560993552208,
0.043848101049661636,
0.003818735247477889,
-0.0003465444315224886,
0.043741293251514435,
-0.003245452418923378,
-0.03575838729739189,
0.018451886251568794,
0.040359146893024445,
-0.0036995778791606426,
-0.021870359778404236,
-0.003409535624086857,
-0.01055061724036932,
-0.25938260555267334,
-0.004616111051291227,
-0.00703573040664196,
-0.03503920137882233,
0.04878287762403488,
-0.008538790047168732,
0.06288067996501923,
-0.03429199010133743,
-0.035613447427749634,
0.0013972033048048615,
0.012286235578358173,
0.0454203225672245,
0.020488981157541275,
0.04219423234462738,
0.0525364987552166,
0.04384083300828934,
-0.019328687340021133,
-0.002495800843462348,
0.016970282420516014,
0.03951586037874222,
-0.0005617202259600163,
-0.06411143392324448,
-0.028163166716694832,
0.06669796258211136,
-0.002752211643382907,
0.005351091735064983,
-0.09816745668649673,
-0.0022926153615117073,
-0.04066501185297966,
-0.020583275705575943,
-0.011718487367033958,
-0.02021835371851921,
-0.001938594738021493,
-0.01232310850173235,
-0.0073463269509375095,
0.003818521974608302,
0.085647352039814,
0.005987572483718395,
0.03761622682213783,
-0.0016096998006105423,
0.024449488148093224,
-0.004805682692676783,
-0.04356180131435394,
-0.029614893719553947,
0.0547373965382576,
0.002169639803469181,
-0.10489264130592346,
-0.03326794505119324,
0.011212225072085857,
0.0571013018488884,
-0.023415612056851387,
-0.029093816876411438,
-0.03948042169213295,
0.025618471205234528,
0.022853657603263855,
-0.009045860730111599,
-0.004532397724688053,
-0.022088412195444107,
-0.009893699549138546,
-0.03021414205431938,
0.007904328405857086,
-0.0014234749833121896,
-0.03606060519814491,
-0.030680863186717033,
-0.04065928980708122,
-0.01967836730182171,
-0.06613580137491226,
-0.0556672178208828,
0.017714187502861023,
0.03764999285340309,
-0.06451117247343063,
0.039055775851011276,
-0.018879082053899765,
-0.09376540035009384,
-0.013293272815644741,
-0.018136849626898766,
-0.028308141976594925,
-0.026141280308365822,
-0.013330777175724506,
0.04049258306622505,
-0.039080917835235596,
-0.042914848774671555,
-0.0023012415040284395,
0.013328783214092255,
0.0349666029214859,
-0.054680854082107544,
0.014040510170161724,
-0.02924436517059803,
-0.024707362055778503,
-0.06817087531089783,
0.069987952709198,
-0.012717554345726967,
0.013696284964680672,
0.01483116950839758,
0.05510934814810753,
0.004477126058191061,
0.013870376162230968,
0.0808505266904831,
0.03467310592532158,
-0.00010073876183014363,
0.00759883550927043,
-0.05081186071038246,
-0.009913486428558826,
-0.020912103354930878,
-0.008780618198215961,
0.029373010620474815,
-0.06678953766822815,
-0.004539111163467169,
0.02216186374425888,
0.02017899788916111,
-0.044081248342990875,
-0.005470973905175924,
0.022435080260038376,
0.002345216693356633,
-0.025481289252638817,
0.05800866335630417,
0.005239985417574644,
0.03714297339320183,
0.005849613808095455,
-0.03437333181500435,
-0.020503122359514236,
0.006630076561123133,
-0.025106484070420265,
0.004883928224444389,
0.015039931982755661,
-0.012547627091407776,
0.0012745786225423217,
0.006553354673087597,
-0.02240723744034767,
-0.029951119795441628,
0.009008853696286678,
0.022370824590325356,
-0.010801865719258785,
0.015499935485422611,
0.031313929706811905,
-0.036236099898815155,
-0.027547430247068405,
-0.004220971837639809,
0.03445133939385414,
0.0008430953603237867,
0.00033025065204128623,
-0.027796149253845215,
0.011404351331293583,
0.02349119447171688,
0.04983556270599365,
-0.017504552379250526,
0.03164694830775261,
0.025985077023506165,
0.020412329584360123,
0.022910308092832565,
0.037753745913505554,
-0.017951350659132004,
-0.0068489136174321175,
-0.019935114309191704,
-0.007254233583807945,
-0.0037372447550296783,
0.04607027396559715,
-0.008976482786238194,
0.02033204957842827,
-0.05095593258738518,
0.03959275782108307,
-0.013326367363333702,
0.004441578406840563,
0.008982847444713116,
0.01329729426652193,
0.01638621836900711,
-0.004788469523191452,
0.004792621824890375,
0.029766328632831573,
0.029005439952015877,
-0.009505524300038815,
-0.015025871805846691,
-0.0177901778370142,
-0.00013077545736450702,
-0.028398554772138596,
0.014764728024601936,
0.019314447417855263,
0.03545204922556877,
-0.029178263619542122,
0.08043311536312103,
0.017535237595438957,
-0.001087634009309113,
0.00752693647518754,
0.004051584284752607,
0.06853628158569336,
0.01661498099565506,
0.00028400152223184705,
0.027353573590517044,
-0.04252653941512108,
-0.014572995714843273,
-0.010145547799766064,
0.020257117226719856,
-0.030550789088010788,
-0.051015663892030716,
-0.03498738259077072,
-0.05443534627556801,
0.03337017446756363,
0.027195777744054794,
-0.013778239488601685,
0.03110448829829693,
-0.03372699022293091,
0.017653606832027435,
-0.059817370027303696,
-0.013024532236158848,
-0.00321813952177763,
-0.07142485678195953,
-0.01603221334517002,
0.0027644948568195105,
0.03755020350217819,
-0.0050728777423501015,
-0.05223984271287918,
-0.05395492538809776,
-0.06931488960981369,
-0.02892388589680195,
0.03883034735918045,
-0.017766514793038368,
0.022014932706952095,
-0.048236846923828125,
0.0020801248028874397,
-0.040378011763095856,
0.02804621495306492,
-0.0027961807791143656,
0.0017924405401572585,
0.0024302848614752293,
-0.003761796047911048,
0.03926253691315651,
-0.018326707184314728,
-0.012553262524306774,
-0.007916840724647045,
-0.030109291896224022,
0.05098911002278328,
-0.018351389095187187,
0.03251802921295166,
0.046192243695259094,
0.013598823919892311,
-0.00823348667472601,
-0.04325230419635773,
-0.003546592313796282,
0.022768795490264893,
-0.007429634686559439,
-0.0017901372630149126,
-0.04746250808238983,
-0.012554053217172623,
0.01958385482430458,
-0.010851122438907623,
0.031156718730926514,
-0.002513502724468708,
-0.008964167907834053,
-0.009505421854555607,
0.04309547692537308,
-0.0018872465007007122,
0.009933410212397575,
-0.048614826053380966,
-0.00694415345788002,
0.05807666480541229,
-0.026066182181239128,
-0.05056123062968254,
-0.06321834027767181,
-0.045649658888578415,
0.055495403707027435,
0.027958277612924576,
0.029614727944135666,
-0.05712404474616051,
0.06597389280796051,
0.03298940882086754,
0.035659294575452805,
0.00330627104267478,
-0.03298616781830788,
0.04018374904990196,
-0.05397621542215347,
0.008362259715795517,
-0.05097746104001999,
-0.039331503212451935,
0.07165265083312988,
-0.022522132843732834,
0.0011395402252674103,
0.0030986762139946222,
-0.016623979434370995,
0.024437816813588142,
-0.014434929005801678,
-0.046544257551431656,
0.04755794256925583,
0.022051965817809105,
0.018442479893565178,
0.01727418601512909,
-0.034202780574560165,
-0.01937713660299778,
-0.017673302441835403,
-0.02515874244272709,
-0.006442639045417309,
-0.03462103009223938,
0.06663371622562408,
-0.03865796700119972,
0.025196319445967674,
-0.06315717846155167,
-0.017817260697484016,
0.012292226776480675,
0.06474412232637405,
0.021307386457920074,
0.02785981260240078,
-0.0061917779967188835,
0.06694765388965607,
0.04132998362183571,
0.017855830490589142,
-0.006011121440678835,
0.009648767299950123,
-0.03622142970561981,
-0.04580468311905861,
0.05782075598835945,
0.010299098677933216,
-0.0027290310245007277,
-0.05572854354977608,
0.07341457903385162,
0.022524390369653702,
-0.022940482944250107,
-0.01128771249204874,
0.03576500713825226,
-0.04522265866398811,
-0.009821301326155663,
-0.05125772953033447,
0.03669169917702675,
-0.022753728553652763,
0.037234704941511154,
0.019319238141179085,
0.02745557762682438,
0.08996196836233139,
0.0025602274108678102,
-0.00495565589517355,
-0.005150792188942432,
0.07029807567596436,
0.052495118230581284,
0.0634588971734047,
-0.028304830193519592,
0.0750870481133461,
-0.02104140631854534,
-0.06533564627170563,
-0.0053186905570328236,
0.03926689922809601,
-0.00665283715352416,
-0.018065959215164185,
0.020128710195422173,
0.02595209889113903,
0.0021330302115529776,
0.09734982997179031,
-0.005196741316467524,
-0.005794302560389042,
0.03365715220570564,
0.021807435899972916,
0.024252410978078842,
0.032463617622852325,
0.016320491209626198,
0.0073531679809093475,
-0.03342139720916748,
0.00402455311268568,
0.02771466039121151,
-0.04628531634807587,
-0.019388560205698013,
-0.007271428592503071,
-0.023537278175354004,
0.011116046458482742,
-0.03361744061112404,
0.05701609328389168,
0.10006706416606903,
-0.03573836386203766,
-0.016886752098798752,
0.005353744141757488,
0.019823947921395302,
-0.014193844981491566,
0.021646004170179367,
-0.0028174198232591152,
-0.004598493687808514,
0.012986354529857635,
-0.08098694682121277,
0.04660480469465256,
0.05074828118085861,
-0.023801157251000404,
0.03115152381360531,
-0.028344085440039635,
-0.02602582611143589,
0.00729417335242033,
-0.005804249085485935,
-0.07916872948408127,
-0.028949208557605743,
-0.008037528023123741,
-0.02113138698041439,
-0.027390213683247566,
-0.01262352429330349,
0.03223314881324768,
0.03997211158275604,
-0.03150954097509384,
-0.007205823436379433,
-0.0702507272362709,
-0.027082931250333786,
-0.01182134635746479,
-0.05771632865071297,
0.04744790494441986,
0.01969151198863983,
0.011912080459296703,
-0.0414755716919899,
0.06240081787109375,
0.02008381299674511,
-0.03847210854291916,
-0.0073297698982059956,
0.055967897176742554,
0.03641810640692711,
0.026406578719615936,
-0.004336812533438206,
-0.020055582746863365,
-0.10043257474899292,
-0.0037544057704508305,
0.045119740068912506,
-0.030790960416197777,
-0.07796008884906769,
0.020563378930091858,
-0.007982050068676472,
0.032420262694358826,
0.053388502448797226,
0.006181537173688412,
0.05362987890839577,
-0.0030356482602655888,
0.006129847373813391,
-0.0025019559543579817,
0.0278472937643528,
0.05246221274137497,
-0.01898198388516903,
0.07515522837638855,
0.025801634415984154,
-0.009377500973641872,
-0.055975623428821564,
0.0045789629220962524,
-0.00028257720987312496,
-0.020586054772138596,
-0.010332259349524975,
-0.05194827914237976,
-0.05706100910902023,
-0.06449692696332932,
-0.05111421272158623,
0.07323450595140457,
-0.016857467591762543,
-0.0027830239851027727,
0.007127878721803427,
-0.014122391119599342,
-0.027404574677348137,
-0.0005484602879732847,
-0.029798384755849838,
-0.03868279233574867,
-0.04545314610004425,
-0.026181459426879883,
-0.05753885582089424,
-0.012740999460220337,
0.002641652710735798,
-0.003478314494714141,
-0.01733900047838688,
-0.018994426354765892,
0.042882006615400314,
0.01237433310598135,
0.036906275898218155,
0.015912562608718872,
0.0026538902893662453,
-0.03331374004483223
] |
352 |
Unveiling the Secret Recipe: A Guide For Supervised Fine-Tuning Small LLMs
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=eENHKMTOfW
|
[
"Aldo Pareja",
"Nikhil Shivakumar Nayak",
"Hao Wang",
"Krishnateja Killamsetty",
"Shivchander Sudalairaj",
"Wenlong Zhao",
"Seungwook Han",
"Abhishek Bhandwaldar",
"Guangxuan Xu",
"Kai Xu",
"Ligong Han",
"Luke Inglis",
"Akash Srivastava"
] |
Poster
|
The rise of large language models (LLMs) has created a significant disparity: industrial research labs with their computational resources, expert teams, and advanced infrastructures, can effectively fine-tune LLMs, while individual developers and small organizations face barriers due to limited resources to effectively explore the experiment space. In this paper, we aim to bridge this gap by presenting a comprehensive study on supervised fine-tuning of LLMs using instruction-tuning datasets spanning diverse knowledge domains and skills. We focus on small-sized LLMs (3B to 7B parameters) for their cost-efficiency and accessibility. We explore various training configurations and strategies across four open-source pre-trained models. We provide detailed documentation of these configurations, revealing findings that challenge several common training practices, including hyperparameter recommendations from TULU and phased training recommended by Orca. The code used for the experiments can be found here: https://github.com/instructlab/training.
Key insights from our work include: (i) larger batch sizes paired with lower learning rates lead to improved model performance on benchmarks such as MMLU, MTBench, and Open LLM Leaderboard; (ii) early-stage training dynamics, such as lower gradient norms and higher loss values, are strong indicators of better final model performance, allowing for early termination of sub-optimal runs and significant computational savings; (iii) through a thorough exploration of hyperparameters like warmup steps and learning rate schedules, we provide guidance for practitioners and find that certain simplifications do not compromise performance; and (iv) we observe no significant difference in performance between phased (sequentially training on data divided into phases) and stacked (training on the entire dataset at once) strategies, but stacked training is simpler and more sample efficient. With these findings holding robustly across datasets as well as model families and sizes, we hope this study serves as a guide for practitioners fine-tuning small LLMs and promotes a more inclusive research environment for LLM development.
|
Machine Learning, Generative Models, Large Language Models, Natural Language Processing, Transformers, Fine-Tuning, Instruction Tuning, Synthetic Data Generation, Knowledge Data, Skills Data, Model Generalization, Batch Size, Hyperparameter Optimization, Gradient Norm, MMLU, MTBench, Stacked Training, Phased Training, Compute Efficiency, Sample Efficiency, Flash Attention, Multipack Bucketing
|
We provide a guide for customizing small LLMs (3B-7B parameters) through instruction tuning on diverse knowledge and skills data, offering insights on training strategies, hyperparameters, and efficient tuning methods to improve performance.
| 13,333 |
2412.13337
|
[
-0.011131558567285538,
-0.025702759623527527,
-0.015358101576566696,
0.01908578723669052,
0.07338012754917145,
0.006966796703636646,
0.030941534787416458,
0.010459326207637787,
-0.038553640246391296,
-0.007429693825542927,
-0.01579669490456581,
0.024531560018658638,
-0.055067043751478195,
0.0029597687534987926,
-0.012594945728778839,
0.04231690615415573,
0.05172988772392273,
-0.028029073029756546,
0.02134815976023674,
0.025360824540257454,
0.011450282298028469,
-0.01119910180568695,
0.022845033556222916,
0.019216828048229218,
0.0015031800139695406,
0.022533128038048744,
0.04258597642183304,
-0.027066709473729134,
-0.04564129561185837,
0.014641744084656239,
0.038950640708208084,
-0.02906229719519615,
0.0420546755194664,
-0.030545344576239586,
0.011920097284018993,
0.01487911120057106,
-0.03787672519683838,
-0.0013048816472291946,
0.0021845579613000154,
0.022870369255542755,
-0.0445762537419796,
0.036645326763391495,
0.015390721149742603,
0.013646300882101059,
-0.0557246133685112,
0.0033347359858453274,
-0.1277635097503662,
0.02835576795041561,
0.017477933317422867,
-0.034340448677539825,
-0.11616223305463791,
0.036627255380153656,
0.009484351612627506,
-0.024342302232980728,
0.016372503712773323,
0.05456879734992981,
0.05876149237155914,
-0.07806500047445297,
0.007447137497365475,
-0.029411442577838898,
-0.039203010499477386,
0.0316428579390049,
0.006532562430948019,
0.0005703635397367179,
0.005399523768573999,
-0.037654466927051544,
-0.0016073291189968586,
0.025760425254702568,
-0.07777003198862076,
-0.03695611655712128,
-0.015715837478637695,
0.012834304943680763,
-0.029828408733010292,
-0.0014376327162608504,
0.011776382103562355,
-0.03538842871785164,
0.010444405488669872,
0.02877325750887394,
0.061741068959236145,
0.021797139197587967,
-0.019406581297516823,
0.003782056039199233,
0.03460492193698883,
0.02684846706688404,
0.01982630044221878,
0.018099062144756317,
-0.06222731992602348,
-0.04749537631869316,
-0.06267929822206497,
0.034405019134283066,
-0.006177521776407957,
-0.04452947527170181,
0.01902690716087818,
0.025874489918351173,
0.01983928494155407,
0.011148164980113506,
0.024797886610031128,
0.018228977918624878,
-0.007890701293945312,
0.012753576040267944,
-0.024903099983930588,
-0.01789247989654541,
0.03372568264603615,
0.025542505085468292,
-0.11666272580623627,
-0.020031265914440155,
-0.03811303526163101,
-0.021698275581002235,
-0.010881058871746063,
-0.024654632434248924,
-0.002972061512991786,
-0.022177862003445625,
-0.019488589838147163,
0.0020063589327037334,
-0.08942071348428726,
0.03692416846752167,
-0.009987124241888523,
0.03098439797759056,
-0.010573089122772217,
-0.010163934901356697,
0.0452299639582634,
0.06546400487422943,
0.021045520901679993,
0.07373351603746414,
-0.027609102427959442,
0.0008555524982511997,
0.008247378282248974,
0.039375416934490204,
-0.024674957618117332,
-0.03953356295824051,
0.010863483883440495,
0.0423893928527832,
0.023159336298704147,
-0.005832429975271225,
0.002858228050172329,
0.010417620651423931,
-0.0011222606990486383,
0.01758105494081974,
0.050476450473070145,
0.007838856428861618,
0.019926171749830246,
0.006073273718357086,
0.06302093714475632,
-0.0355444960296154,
0.0643111988902092,
-0.00027708770358003676,
-0.011905272491276264,
-0.030818121507763863,
-0.05822047218680382,
-0.004034297540783882,
0.050786085426807404,
0.03061729110777378,
-0.018888261169195175,
-0.06475479900836945,
0.05724942684173584,
0.06375685334205627,
-0.003431284800171852,
-0.01822436973452568,
0.018491964787244797,
-0.004331797827035189,
-0.009395159780979156,
0.013100085780024529,
-0.035127904266119,
-0.010757074691355228,
-0.0129466000944376,
-0.0435580275952816,
0.051672324538230896,
-0.0003966670483350754,
-0.04483344033360481,
0.022950084879994392,
-0.05158034339547157,
-0.012782256118953228,
0.0683979019522667,
-0.031900495290756226,
-0.030117737129330635,
-0.02187727391719818,
0.038674890995025635,
0.008199053816497326,
0.04952691122889519,
0.04623270407319069,
-0.07726401090621948,
0.027002448216080666,
0.033377714455127716,
-0.018630146980285645,
0.020558467134833336,
-0.01674037240445614,
0.10611765086650848,
-0.05272408574819565,
0.0056863767094910145,
0.017849162220954895,
-0.07402118295431137,
-0.012112422846257687,
0.04323560371994972,
-0.003674013540148735,
0.0663549080491066,
0.006782516371458769,
0.0008284480427391827,
0.06423766911029816,
0.0269736647605896,
0.062281373888254166,
0.050738852471113205,
0.0059858462773263454,
0.049455296248197556,
-0.024900443851947784,
-0.026771381497383118,
-0.0030047667678445578,
0.043343693017959595,
-0.05730988085269928,
-0.045984864234924316,
0.01169925183057785,
-0.03577366843819618,
-0.030108032748103142,
0.018692146986722946,
-0.0025393071118742228,
0.017542175948619843,
0.00782743375748396,
-0.020622363314032555,
0.0015754182823002338,
0.030174557119607925,
-0.05078043043613434,
0.03215235844254494,
0.021472521126270294,
-0.009315883740782738,
-0.0021169926039874554,
-0.045335207134485245,
0.08278928697109222,
0.055198077112436295,
-0.040690138936042786,
-0.003502469277009368,
0.02590639516711235,
0.014483829960227013,
-0.029811901971697807,
0.01137674879282713,
-0.02578294649720192,
0.027139032259583473,
-0.026031021028757095,
-0.01952992007136345,
-0.030664334073662758,
0.06462473422288895,
-0.03829780966043472,
-0.005094409920275211,
0.06604494154453278,
-0.02302449382841587,
0.07587127387523651,
0.006042639724910259,
0.006374070420861244,
0.027959901839494705,
-0.02785447984933853,
-0.012974737212061882,
-0.00971374660730362,
-0.005091418977826834,
0.006332104559987783,
0.004190878476947546,
-0.019819123670458794,
-0.02649335376918316,
-0.07226357609033585,
-0.04342441260814667,
-0.012636326253414154,
0.046225424855947495,
0.04171018674969673,
-0.007846707478165627,
0.042306382209062576,
0.02230837754905224,
-0.025239409878849983,
0.03763773292303085,
-0.10074340552091599,
-0.01732640713453293,
-0.03227189928293228,
0.040937747806310654,
0.005206715781241655,
0.023740503937005997,
0.003423669608309865,
0.008284456096589565,
-0.024975039064884186,
-0.007486680522561073,
0.004948995541781187,
0.01731039024889469,
-0.03338727727532387,
-0.08149947971105576,
-0.042976006865501404,
-0.000859095947816968,
0.037157587707042694,
-0.027233250439167023,
-0.027364129200577736,
-0.0542946457862854,
-0.040431324392557144,
-0.022222183644771576,
-0.0636618360877037,
-0.0093844560906291,
0.002908690134063363,
-0.023584062233567238,
0.0213270653039217,
-0.020634448155760765,
0.009257391095161438,
0.03287899121642113,
0.03607200086116791,
0.006735165137797594,
0.009114976041018963,
-0.013769165612757206,
0.04096350073814392,
-0.011002031154930592,
0.03210444003343582,
-0.008711952716112137,
0.02524527534842491,
-0.02137165702879429,
-0.0028091990388929844,
0.0027975733391940594,
-0.001407500123605132,
-0.2860150933265686,
-0.0122353695333004,
0.009330805391073227,
-0.015752192586660385,
0.03240004554390907,
-0.025112593546509743,
0.023762106895446777,
-0.033421773463487625,
-0.025356300175189972,
0.007862668484449387,
0.026280144229531288,
0.05936102569103241,
0.005459412466734648,
0.03807003051042557,
0.040966492146253586,
0.06428815424442291,
-0.003098218236118555,
-0.02809746563434601,
0.021272895857691765,
0.047644201666116714,
0.007756013888865709,
-0.06608039140701294,
-0.00751594640314579,
0.029832210391759872,
-0.006887863855808973,
0.0686272531747818,
-0.09097415953874588,
-0.0023131859488785267,
-0.031468819826841354,
-0.018688563257455826,
-0.0033105656038969755,
-0.013020372949540615,
-0.015826905146241188,
0.01851407065987587,
-0.00167269806843251,
0.005195051431655884,
0.04772314429283142,
-0.003962574526667595,
0.05846690759062767,
0.019979603588581085,
0.021485961973667145,
-0.02868007682263851,
-0.02368585206568241,
-0.001337979338131845,
0.06441680341959,
0.024966802448034286,
-0.07679849117994308,
-0.027131589129567146,
-0.021422382444143295,
0.047124218195676804,
-0.0014724059728905559,
-0.05183451622724533,
-0.013101959601044655,
0.01743173599243164,
0.006976746954023838,
-0.02342677116394043,
0.017254168167710304,
0.007776346057653427,
-0.006241308990865946,
-0.004736335948109627,
-0.004902221728116274,
-0.03571607172489166,
-0.040215034037828445,
-0.05489630252122879,
-0.03137972578406334,
-0.027674201875925064,
-0.042878370732069016,
-0.04621365666389465,
0.034138407558202744,
0.06315498799085617,
-0.019212685525417328,
0.015816250815987587,
-0.013673743233084679,
-0.09156987816095352,
0.0019510880811139941,
-0.0051118917763233185,
-0.013886622153222561,
-0.004853520076721907,
0.00899606291204691,
0.05223651975393295,
-0.05613941699266434,
-0.017560286447405815,
0.013105357997119427,
0.0038954976480454206,
0.044084805995225906,
-0.020375991240143776,
0.007087004370987415,
-0.01738031394779682,
-0.01492510549724102,
-0.04624294117093086,
0.025238636881113052,
0.012781081721186638,
-0.012935308739542961,
0.011341395787894726,
0.05280661955475807,
-0.0020713000558316708,
0.04243271425366402,
0.08104552328586578,
0.016562651842832565,
0.01994422636926174,
0.007973452098667622,
-0.060742031782865524,
-0.006718548014760017,
-0.047000251710414886,
0.0008168904460035264,
0.015641311183571815,
-0.061845067888498306,
-0.030907707288861275,
0.02980242855846882,
-0.007091617677360773,
-0.020793527364730835,
-0.03335420787334442,
-0.002344796434044838,
0.005126073956489563,
-0.030137088149785995,
-0.015208925120532513,
0.002660679165273905,
0.018188143149018288,
0.021115269511938095,
-0.017314041033387184,
-0.05729014798998833,
0.0344703309237957,
-0.024585774168372154,
0.00950026884675026,
-0.013064119964838028,
-0.04810202494263649,
0.02056853100657463,
-0.015462014824151993,
-0.017968518659472466,
-0.003279848722741008,
0.01909564808011055,
0.01961437426507473,
0.002318073296919465,
0.004206881392747164,
0.027326401323080063,
0.016233576461672783,
-0.012418525293469429,
0.012531114742159843,
0.012376454658806324,
-0.0055990745313465595,
0.014567346312105656,
0.0028570336289703846,
0.03885263204574585,
0.025934424251317978,
0.049242518842220306,
0.040505293756723404,
0.016817642375826836,
-0.0023201708681881428,
0.004288484342396259,
-0.0023112883791327477,
0.05010581389069557,
-0.045800842344760895,
0.013295919634401798,
-0.046534448862075806,
0.029380155727267265,
-0.016478072851896286,
0.028232602402567863,
0.008327564224600792,
0.032359205186367035,
-0.07935166358947754,
0.041387058794498444,
-0.022400714457035065,
-0.026878980919718742,
0.025227202102541924,
0.02618534304201603,
0.03988911956548691,
-0.006285002920776606,
0.03437747433781624,
0.016350213438272476,
-0.006857111118733883,
0.0028910604305565357,
-0.04539758712053299,
-0.04707380756735802,
-0.013729824684560299,
-0.013729977421462536,
-0.009443143382668495,
0.0210593119263649,
-0.007379686925560236,
-0.018188871443271637,
0.05528850108385086,
0.00857697706669569,
-0.03224823623895645,
0.0011391040170565248,
0.012485876679420471,
0.07489504665136337,
0.0005162809393368661,
-0.0058795674704015255,
0.006397435907274485,
-0.017693497240543365,
0.019853882491588593,
-0.005268246866762638,
0.004322602413594723,
0.007213153410702944,
-0.0016722108703106642,
-0.03410438448190689,
-0.06493513286113739,
0.0233693215996027,
0.04036789759993553,
0.0012940349988639355,
-0.020556697621941566,
-0.013638866133987904,
-0.0049021877348423,
-0.045863352715969086,
-0.015264184214174747,
0.02652137354016304,
-0.09313036501407623,
-0.007513674907386303,
0.021313771605491638,
0.013762188144028187,
0.04301721602678299,
-0.042668431997299194,
-0.05373745784163475,
-0.022178901359438896,
-0.004076024983078241,
0.01686231791973114,
-0.04057598486542702,
-0.01589067280292511,
0.016655411571264267,
0.027957623824477196,
-0.024642692878842354,
0.01383395865559578,
-0.010012414306402206,
-0.02512572892010212,
-0.011811453849077225,
0.0041174148209393024,
0.039012305438518524,
-0.035287369042634964,
-0.01569478213787079,
-0.002878678496927023,
-0.04603046923875809,
0.05321810767054558,
-0.05645386129617691,
0.03337555006146431,
0.0403914749622345,
0.012776566669344902,
0.007130180019885302,
-0.042238395661115646,
0.051947902888059616,
0.02696295641362667,
-0.018999973312020302,
-0.0031638829968869686,
0.003571154782548547,
-0.01605377160012722,
0.008718034252524376,
-0.010612722486257553,
0.05058774724602699,
-0.0057485285215079784,
0.016332441940903664,
-0.01856781169772148,
0.0028359824791550636,
0.016977457329630852,
0.012406162917613983,
-0.006282012909650803,
-0.024813337251544,
0.0756487101316452,
-0.019395804032683372,
-0.011307857930660248,
-0.06522819399833679,
-0.05450836569070816,
0.009168090298771858,
-0.009716839529573917,
0.03805414214730263,
-0.041757963597774506,
0.06253330409526825,
0.025461601093411446,
0.06376603245735168,
-0.015330134890973568,
-0.03863579034805298,
0.04768069460988045,
-0.07143127173185349,
0.009889014065265656,
-0.07554570585489273,
-0.02115217223763466,
0.06220579519867897,
-0.006885924842208624,
0.019871732220053673,
-0.011889724992215633,
-0.027950629591941833,
0.05020499601960182,
-0.02561415545642376,
-0.06594029068946838,
0.012349594384431839,
-0.01519866194576025,
-0.021452652290463448,
0.03218803182244301,
-0.04128500074148178,
-0.022282971069216728,
-0.012306291610002518,
-0.03531631454825401,
0.01625198684632778,
-0.014067240990698338,
0.04598388820886612,
-0.012245512567460537,
0.013504794798791409,
-0.04186252877116203,
-0.01537373661994934,
0.012547703459858894,
0.040242429822683334,
0.021256687119603157,
0.03439154475927353,
-0.017236264422535896,
0.05866127833724022,
0.03392399847507477,
-0.010270126163959503,
0.011853582225739956,
0.011082838289439678,
-0.026788488030433655,
-0.06352055817842484,
0.05774344876408577,
-0.002839184831827879,
-0.039434026926755905,
-0.04381046071648598,
0.05817679315805435,
0.03225746750831604,
-0.028414864093065262,
-0.03008994087576866,
0.021935736760497093,
-0.04003709927201271,
0.005608087871223688,
-0.0028239109087735415,
0.010408868081867695,
0.0002927446330431849,
0.07262364774942398,
0.01773654855787754,
0.05349366366863251,
0.05956842750310898,
0.02214767411351204,
-0.027011621743440628,
0.007922283373773098,
0.0554010234773159,
0.06122399494051933,
0.052276611328125,
0.008164317347109318,
0.062429267913103104,
-0.04772154986858368,
-0.059017084538936615,
0.003182078944519162,
0.016278043389320374,
-0.012105160392820835,
-0.04891680181026459,
0.03487888723611832,
0.07585860788822174,
0.0014802117366343737,
0.05514659360051155,
-0.027489598840475082,
-0.00858195312321186,
0.048995811492204666,
0.007166742347180843,
0.008705844171345234,
0.04551047086715698,
0.01726183481514454,
0.004205172415822744,
-0.03572358191013336,
-0.020973913371562958,
-0.0170001070946455,
-0.023743387311697006,
-0.001499970443546772,
0.007199358660727739,
-0.023226089775562286,
-0.003287630621343851,
-0.02559267356991768,
0.05279505252838135,
0.11926181614398956,
-0.036812618374824524,
-0.04364922642707825,
0.002747650258243084,
0.00369296595454216,
0.01681722328066826,
0.028112342581152916,
-0.017640290781855583,
-0.024488581344485283,
0.008727860637009144,
-0.0335770808160305,
-0.0023611283395439386,
0.023931648582220078,
-0.0019547301344573498,
0.02190585993230343,
-0.016711577773094177,
-0.03298039361834526,
0.022721605375409126,
0.04154829680919647,
-0.048662107437849045,
-0.03657028079032898,
-0.03314246982336044,
-0.0496378093957901,
-0.016718531027436256,
-0.04948410391807556,
0.012226552702486515,
-0.00766550749540329,
-0.02411143109202385,
0.00859968364238739,
-0.03241932764649391,
0.006789410952478647,
0.02668175660073757,
-0.08534631878137589,
-0.0042447964660823345,
0.01695352979004383,
-0.011775120161473751,
-0.01131613738834858,
0.058838214725255966,
0.009112007915973663,
-0.0185928326100111,
-0.004247774835675955,
0.041828807443380356,
0.00263161095790565,
0.017720011994242668,
0.003326664213091135,
0.01043347641825676,
-0.09726738929748535,
-0.005467789247632027,
-0.004106099251657724,
-0.012894978746771812,
-0.0789656862616539,
0.025401094928383827,
-0.021291637793183327,
0.042475376278162,
0.06950346380472183,
0.0076379310339689255,
0.04037630930542946,
-0.019703363999724388,
-0.0278504379093647,
-0.005208671558648348,
0.04616447165608406,
0.0559125654399395,
-0.02064846269786358,
0.08167016506195068,
0.0348639115691185,
-0.02632329985499382,
-0.03421779349446297,
0.016166849061846733,
-0.015088284388184547,
-0.026072172448039055,
-0.028352567926049232,
-0.016985230147838593,
-0.02027231827378273,
-0.08187205344438553,
-0.007069663610309362,
0.03757024556398392,
-0.018958503380417824,
-0.024766042828559875,
0.007440793793648481,
-0.009562380611896515,
-0.027380652725696564,
-0.004795439075678587,
-0.0064338017255067825,
-0.0034236940555274487,
-0.04053192585706711,
-0.04889512434601784,
-0.049301888793706894,
0.005520587787032127,
-0.0052357204258441925,
-0.019888585433363914,
-0.033813487738370895,
-0.033972010016441345,
0.006932387128472328,
0.0009196923347190022,
0.05710768699645996,
-0.0022704722359776497,
0.010152463801205158,
-0.0019352179951965809
] |
353 |
ManiSkill-HAB: A Benchmark for Low-Level Manipulation in Home Rearrangement Tasks
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=6bKEWevgSd
|
[
"Arth Shukla",
"Stone Tao",
"Hao Su"
] |
Poster
|
High-quality benchmarks are the foundation for embodied AI research, enabling significant advancements in long-horizon navigation, manipulation and rearrangement tasks. However, as frontier tasks in robotics get more advanced, they require faster simulation speed, more intricate test environments, and larger demonstration datasets. To this end, we present MS-HAB, a holistic benchmark for low-level manipulation and in-home object rearrangement. First, we provide a GPU-accelerated implementation of the Home Assistant Benchmark (HAB). We support realistic low-level control and achieve over 3x the speed of prior magical grasp implementations at a fraction of the GPU memory usage. Second, we train extensive reinforcement learning (RL) and imitation learning (IL) baselines for future work to compare against. Finally, we develop a rule-based trajectory filtering system to sample specific demonstrations from our RL policies which match predefined criteria for robot behavior and safety. Combining demonstration filtering with our fast environments enables efficient, controlled data generation at scale.
|
benchmark, dataset, simulation, reinforcement learning, imitation learning, robotics
|
We provide a GPU-accelerated implementation of the HAB which supports realistic low-level control, run extensive RL and IL baselines, and develop a rule-based trajectory filtering system which enables efficient, controlled data generation at scale.
| 13,307 | null |
[
-0.01871700957417488,
0.006954969838261604,
-0.012022040784358978,
0.007864183746278286,
0.026859840378165245,
0.022647593170404434,
0.01809634454548359,
0.005337883718311787,
-0.0595255121588707,
-0.04503248259425163,
-0.020256174728274345,
-0.0006686251144856215,
-0.07122603058815002,
-0.009685627184808254,
-0.012794251553714275,
0.04535680264234543,
0.019544031471014023,
-0.029263237491250038,
-0.0015110971871763468,
0.005729085300117731,
-0.027646126225590706,
-0.018320994451642036,
0.026583561673760414,
0.01697084866464138,
0.012751719914376736,
0.023608503863215446,
0.005646890494972467,
0.02107401378452778,
-0.03666510805487633,
-0.030316120013594627,
0.011545398272573948,
-0.03885728120803833,
0.025461232289671898,
-0.05174130201339722,
0.024426111951470375,
-0.027843452990055084,
-0.024318356066942215,
0.009157354943454266,
0.016527043655514717,
-0.02717401087284088,
-0.01007243525236845,
0.02758682332932949,
-0.014856331050395966,
-0.0021219616755843163,
-0.03155279904603958,
0.032640885561704636,
-0.09094569832086563,
0.03739400953054428,
0.01684439368546009,
-0.05832214653491974,
-0.0981784462928772,
0.02357400767505169,
0.027665970847010612,
-0.00958773959428072,
-0.020301319658756256,
0.01692209579050541,
0.043827224522829056,
-0.0625968724489212,
-0.0042218961752951145,
-0.03858077526092529,
-0.0024261290673166513,
0.02810095250606537,
0.0380282998085022,
0.023732353001832962,
0.02406819723546505,
-0.00493065407499671,
0.04647158458828926,
0.01570991426706314,
-0.026283012703061104,
0.015954619273543358,
-0.014272493310272694,
-0.048485010862350464,
-0.009173338301479816,
0.007615990936756134,
-0.004430846776813269,
-0.06312817335128784,
0.009222358465194702,
0.028038688004016876,
0.07818489521741867,
-0.01648656837642193,
0.03395743668079376,
0.025766778737306595,
-0.005713228136301041,
0.03728920593857765,
0.0204506516456604,
0.00619132723659277,
-0.04624167084693909,
-0.009117198176681995,
-0.06806372106075287,
0.0069520482793450356,
-0.03522452339529991,
-0.03469919040799141,
0.03765729069709778,
0.04845961183309555,
0.012390485033392906,
0.0017235273262485862,
0.012740612961351871,
0.054766397923231125,
0.009721018373966217,
-0.001920292153954506,
-0.028541630133986473,
-0.02509818971157074,
0.00718718720600009,
-0.021782321855425835,
-0.0761023610830307,
-0.025401156395673752,
-0.004185912664979696,
-0.004488002974539995,
0.015408869832754135,
-0.002143531572073698,
-0.038308124989271164,
0.006601672153919935,
0.008987010456621647,
-0.024606505408883095,
-0.06622562557458878,
0.04910384863615036,
-0.007040672469884157,
0.03695918992161751,
-0.006104337051510811,
0.026602735742926598,
0.05770708620548248,
0.07760254293680191,
0.002155791502445936,
0.05402316525578499,
0.013739900663495064,
-0.0033464895095676184,
-0.005082311574369669,
0.04666309431195259,
0.011720584705471992,
-0.05043438449501991,
0.03747180476784706,
0.05147367715835571,
0.02235955186188221,
-0.02172764576971531,
-0.027496160939335823,
0.008021121844649315,
0.03875662013888359,
0.028520997613668442,
0.04383485019207001,
0.01670287922024727,
0.015537881292402744,
-0.04508223384618759,
0.10277514904737473,
-0.05673842132091522,
0.06143227964639664,
-0.04043177515268326,
-0.015217198058962822,
-0.0018861249554902315,
-0.039203088730573654,
0.01936275325715542,
0.006767514627426863,
0.03372222185134888,
-0.03701970726251602,
-0.0594584085047245,
0.06065477430820465,
0.030022846534848213,
0.01623271033167839,
0.009226207621395588,
0.0005742720095440745,
0.01085092592984438,
-0.02883685939013958,
0.006313239224255085,
-0.042501095682382584,
-0.014902163296937943,
-0.013554326258599758,
-0.029681406915187836,
0.03576589375734329,
0.009747940115630627,
-0.04056123271584511,
-0.007124902680516243,
-0.04825019836425781,
-0.014894405379891396,
0.05387071520090103,
0.005637697875499725,
-0.04288230091333389,
-0.001205738284625113,
0.03706245869398117,
-0.02840663678944111,
0.028289606794714928,
0.024853331968188286,
-0.06336066871881485,
0.042396340519189835,
0.0025369066279381514,
0.00773603143170476,
-0.0027128425426781178,
-0.021570410579442978,
0.06650959700345993,
-0.03483957052230835,
-0.00549315894022584,
0.002711780834943056,
-0.06238770857453346,
-0.02731846459209919,
0.0020906315185129642,
0.020110031589865685,
0.05255366116762161,
0.010719445534050465,
-0.028256669640541077,
0.03735855966806412,
0.0388866662979126,
0.04251455143094063,
0.011027746833860874,
-0.03256252780556679,
0.01564384438097477,
-0.02043049968779087,
-0.008271681144833565,
-0.036188092082738876,
0.018282508477568626,
-0.05765273794531822,
-0.02227289415895939,
0.015049920417368412,
-0.00151877012103796,
-0.016982242465019226,
0.010987048968672752,
0.025465548038482666,
-0.013318543322384357,
0.023622501641511917,
0.006467157043516636,
0.013439508154988289,
-0.0034874179400503635,
-0.017886854708194733,
0.042520035058259964,
0.02840607613325119,
-0.023690858855843544,
-0.0019731037318706512,
-0.052053701132535934,
0.073868028819561,
0.05721179023385048,
-0.0429551936686039,
0.010999816469848156,
0.01594526693224907,
-0.010293712839484215,
0.0033454368822276592,
-0.022232094779610634,
0.005103937815874815,
-0.006017621606588364,
-0.007470124866813421,
0.010101254098117352,
-0.03924709931015968,
0.0770426094532013,
-0.038139548152685165,
-0.06513796001672745,
0.04751318320631981,
0.004306144081056118,
0.06848200410604477,
0.0396379716694355,
-0.0072822715155780315,
0.0340854711830616,
0.03194919228553772,
-0.003244582563638687,
-0.00279434397816658,
-0.028434552252292633,
-0.00413089245557785,
0.021647198125720024,
0.0339902900159359,
0.009322404861450195,
-0.04373818635940552,
-0.00890393741428852,
-0.03846198320388794,
0.05643957853317261,
0.0400083027780056,
0.0405222550034523,
0.05402340739965439,
-0.009265422821044922,
-0.02194136381149292,
-0.019346466287970543,
-0.1046835407614708,
-0.00718682399019599,
-0.013775828294456005,
0.04719498008489609,
0.005379239097237587,
0.042584069073200226,
-0.03611735999584198,
0.05271950364112854,
-0.016362149268388748,
0.0038237657863646746,
-0.008467525243759155,
0.033757589757442474,
-0.006116376258432865,
-0.03769759088754654,
-0.040917158126831055,
0.0045051188208162785,
0.0752255916595459,
-0.006008550990372896,
0.0052596041932702065,
0.00990800466388464,
-0.05127847194671631,
0.02644028514623642,
-0.042465031147003174,
-0.006177584640681744,
0.021352116018533707,
0.043759144842624664,
0.01384701393544674,
-0.0566435232758522,
0.003503473475575447,
-0.011289729736745358,
0.08588624000549316,
0.04142431169748306,
0.0171054620295763,
-0.05942077562212944,
0.005697545129805803,
0.0018757734214887023,
0.01563306152820587,
-0.039590105414390564,
0.005792758893221617,
0.0027207746170461178,
-0.02051718160510063,
-0.008634449914097786,
0.0034840693697333336,
-0.2768668234348297,
-0.027962524443864822,
-0.0055092195980250835,
-0.01260223239660263,
0.05009685084223747,
0.0020107105374336243,
0.03632773086428642,
-0.011923887766897678,
-0.009201840497553349,
0.005997995380312204,
0.04907785356044769,
-0.008621948771178722,
0.016776951029896736,
0.04035155102610588,
0.050937503576278687,
0.045737262815237045,
0.0023871471639722586,
-0.02872583642601967,
-0.016166720539331436,
0.00217638723552227,
-0.03557860851287842,
-0.08754862844944,
-0.02512807957828045,
0.0068379915319383144,
-0.019214529544115067,
0.03657577559351921,
-0.08010274171829224,
-0.030878199264407158,
-0.03737696260213852,
-0.0314236544072628,
-0.01398481149226427,
0.009875034913420677,
-0.07380577176809311,
0.025063468143343925,
0.02846471592783928,
-0.011370113119482994,
0.05161958932876587,
-0.026157904416322708,
0.0593014657497406,
-0.011142676696181297,
-0.012482323683798313,
0.017211906611919403,
-0.052757978439331055,
0.059128861874341965,
0.07514393329620361,
0.014033515937626362,
-0.03448544815182686,
-0.053169991821050644,
-0.012906753458082676,
0.025914760306477547,
0.007984654977917671,
-0.014692842029035091,
-0.023809675127267838,
0.03343581035733223,
0.023777414113283157,
-0.022117240354418755,
-0.012346187606453896,
0.03566885367035866,
-0.007190387696027756,
-0.010006731376051903,
-0.03277458995580673,
-0.021863088011741638,
-0.03213527053594589,
-0.029090285301208496,
-0.006635318510234356,
-0.04164867848157883,
-0.027116136625409126,
-0.054527848958969116,
0.04238332808017731,
-0.005995705723762512,
-0.022651009261608124,
-0.010559936054050922,
-0.024346690624952316,
-0.10971533507108688,
0.047183264046907425,
-0.007000770885497332,
-0.00872309971600771,
-0.04469253495335579,
-0.0040118456818163395,
0.019249729812145233,
-0.042238350957632065,
-0.059342872351408005,
-0.0023071710020303726,
0.0006807086756452918,
0.011973205953836441,
-0.026119202375411987,
0.026924915611743927,
-0.05347010865807533,
-0.008724101819097996,
-0.019449960440397263,
0.05274095758795738,
0.028272150084376335,
0.00354840443469584,
-0.028549611568450928,
0.06064874678850174,
0.04507860541343689,
0.03851006180047989,
0.025905415415763855,
0.04185536131262779,
0.008752084337174892,
0.034290462732315063,
-0.097933329641819,
0.006793914828449488,
-0.02473093941807747,
-0.0021487257909029722,
0.04390862211585045,
-0.04505942389369011,
-0.012192628346383572,
0.04575597122311592,
0.04186329245567322,
-0.03316309675574303,
-0.027291307225823402,
0.04950009286403656,
-0.0016599561786279082,
0.024863816797733307,
-0.01654943823814392,
0.009163917973637581,
0.0217574592679739,
0.0011842399835586548,
0.012568531557917595,
-0.0807868018746376,
0.044148657470941544,
-0.030507534742355347,
0.011586835607886314,
0.0016234752256423235,
-0.00030558102298527956,
-0.0026685178745537996,
0.03453463315963745,
0.03178343549370766,
-0.008399583399295807,
0.03135790303349495,
0.06042895466089249,
-0.02719748020172119,
0.020112350583076477,
0.028896262869238853,
0.0041244858875870705,
0.006660617887973785,
-0.01775406301021576,
0.03297823667526245,
-0.03516670688986778,
-0.001566777122206986,
-0.049713462591171265,
0.015067997388541698,
0.024003712460398674,
0.03552563115954399,
0.01945747807621956,
0.02553856000304222,
-0.0185884777456522,
0.004715804476290941,
0.021182911470532417,
0.03366290405392647,
-0.0915093645453453,
-0.027893241494894028,
-0.04778161644935608,
0.03543275594711304,
-0.049840956926345825,
0.0007838592282496393,
-0.0016858091112226248,
0.012567677535116673,
-0.07808693498373032,
0.0016031577251851559,
0.02483076974749565,
-0.022556185722351074,
-0.0157447662204504,
-0.0063331048004329205,
0.06312505900859833,
-0.005794147029519081,
0.004349797964096069,
0.012010076083242893,
0.003480675630271435,
-0.013809560798108578,
-0.03179454430937767,
-0.008428027853369713,
-0.017557019367814064,
-0.04504523426294327,
0.01710459589958191,
-0.001221776707097888,
-0.010445624589920044,
-0.007414977066218853,
0.018550101667642593,
0.001957149477675557,
-0.0351734533905983,
-0.006367027759552002,
-0.051965467631816864,
0.061236441135406494,
-0.016569944098591805,
0.01546321902424097,
-0.03313393518328667,
-0.008448926731944084,
0.0132689094170928,
0.0013724640011787415,
0.03771030157804489,
-0.0028517376631498337,
-0.026885896921157837,
-0.030752215534448624,
-0.04686379060149193,
0.02159331552684307,
0.0066252523101866245,
-0.038634128868579865,
-0.007904387079179287,
-0.010797125287353992,
-0.007570774294435978,
-0.0483720526099205,
0.004135755356401205,
0.059359077364206314,
-0.06942193955183029,
-0.0029232134111225605,
0.05520874634385109,
0.01862291805446148,
0.03850507363677025,
-0.06382442265748978,
-0.007748177740722895,
-0.007063162513077259,
-0.022422241047024727,
-0.0015433809021487832,
0.040814537554979324,
-0.011964200995862484,
-0.03358353674411774,
-0.026659883558750153,
0.005358635913580656,
-0.021126773208379745,
0.0003819506673607975,
-0.017957139760255814,
-0.02471156232059002,
-0.002070581540465355,
0.011613072827458382,
-0.03826189413666725,
-0.022209689021110535,
0.028799310326576233,
-0.013499227352440357,
0.0400896891951561,
-0.04083354398608208,
0.03840213268995285,
0.044920627027750015,
0.016163639724254608,
0.006993493065237999,
-0.04316694661974907,
0.006757419556379318,
0.013496005907654762,
-0.008578107692301273,
0.030651332810521126,
0.02261802740395069,
-0.021783186122775078,
0.0045562367886304855,
0.03026093915104866,
-0.015044291503727436,
0.011387130245566368,
-0.011333521455526352,
0.05200168490409851,
0.015284581109881401,
0.02205248922109604,
-0.01218779943883419,
-0.03227941691875458,
0.0055573065765202045,
0.057292189449071884,
-0.04692372307181358,
-0.0070873769000172615,
-0.03258726745843887,
-0.04787815362215042,
0.03150004893541336,
-0.03184295818209648,
0.03211193159222603,
-0.03481573611497879,
0.033760059624910355,
0.01094374805688858,
0.04160694777965546,
0.008675933815538883,
-0.03697851300239563,
0.0445149801671505,
-0.07433006912469864,
0.02573447860777378,
-0.04125853255391121,
-0.03217126429080963,
0.04280603304505348,
-0.03367459774017334,
-0.023761875927448273,
0.013841015286743641,
-0.01576494611799717,
0.0398390032351017,
-0.03686821088194847,
-0.03642470762133598,
0.0543949119746685,
-0.01266328152269125,
-0.025881759822368622,
0.018163535743951797,
-0.05247408151626587,
0.001606566016562283,
-0.03615328297019005,
-0.021758368238806725,
0.008424206636846066,
0.012685466557741165,
0.04519787058234215,
0.015963343903422356,
0.08156923949718475,
-0.026527438312768936,
0.03336472064256668,
0.019901635125279427,
0.042443014681339264,
-0.011339772492647171,
0.019283268600702286,
-0.05232852324843407,
0.0635417103767395,
0.018365617841482162,
0.03270087018609047,
-0.002515469677746296,
-0.012201813980937004,
-0.008503389544785023,
-0.0196243729442358,
0.02887839823961258,
-0.0039950343780219555,
-0.03215625882148743,
-0.06163318082690239,
0.05508659407496452,
-0.01199234090745449,
-0.032143209129571915,
0.0007320157601498067,
0.056241799145936966,
-0.08091085404157639,
-0.007306644227355719,
-0.0006735186325386167,
-0.03789844736456871,
-0.009515736252069473,
0.05040431395173073,
0.015271754004061222,
0.05284763127565384,
0.07512916624546051,
-0.002171814441680908,
-0.02492695301771164,
-0.024852372705936432,
0.07322106510400772,
0.03842522203922272,
0.052835434675216675,
-0.04051109403371811,
0.06667636334896088,
-0.024306798353791237,
-0.03532842546701431,
0.06375427544116974,
0.04164794832468033,
0.007543960586190224,
-0.04357500746846199,
0.0354570634663105,
0.09392876923084259,
-0.02653181552886963,
0.03238360956311226,
-0.04866764321923256,
-0.01857290416955948,
0.04734799265861511,
0.025056369602680206,
0.013199283741414547,
0.06251996755599976,
0.06134571507573128,
0.04708251729607582,
-0.02930605411529541,
-0.0298734363168478,
0.0053576319478452206,
-0.0024434479419142008,
0.032351430505514145,
0.020040737465023994,
-0.032585419714450836,
0.03883735090494156,
0.03884366154670715,
-0.002837142674252391,
0.08944465965032578,
-0.022068781778216362,
-0.04287765547633171,
0.009833530522882938,
-0.012842410244047642,
0.010377813130617142,
0.028991013765335083,
0.032581157982349396,
-0.02163553610444069,
0.03322571888566017,
-0.03236272558569908,
0.039720918983221054,
0.02231999859213829,
0.0067718615755438805,
0.07267536967992783,
-0.041444215923547745,
-0.038385797291994095,
0.03197486698627472,
0.013529844582080841,
-0.08010870218276978,
-0.012807296589016914,
-0.03390467166900635,
-0.05227374657988548,
-0.015439121052622795,
-0.03256820887327194,
0.010227741673588753,
-0.01885196566581726,
-0.054447077214717865,
0.013101362623274326,
0.00836930051445961,
0.015239796601235867,
0.03727461025118828,
-0.06797382980585098,
-0.0332847498357296,
0.012520111165940762,
-0.005707868374884129,
-0.019371245056390762,
0.06731793284416199,
0.03507683053612709,
-0.002813628176227212,
-0.03938238322734833,
0.021802473813295364,
0.01277894712984562,
0.020332567393779755,
-0.031933367252349854,
-0.03309906646609306,
-0.10869612544775009,
0.00775124691426754,
0.004643091466277838,
0.008256349712610245,
-0.07879877835512161,
-0.0001163928973255679,
-0.050458669662475586,
0.02720595896244049,
0.062469061464071274,
-0.0196303091943264,
0.013678105548024178,
-0.00860151369124651,
-0.017247669398784637,
0.020315516740083694,
-0.018849607557058334,
0.05134633928537369,
-0.04591852426528931,
0.06708801537752151,
0.04429176077246666,
-0.03789114952087402,
-0.04435788467526436,
0.02925851196050644,
-0.005499975755810738,
0.021869070827960968,
-0.024616891518235207,
-0.05245005339384079,
-0.01474840845912695,
-0.11571234464645386,
-0.008560632355511189,
0.043642107397317886,
0.015840871259570122,
-0.04403433948755264,
-0.004212644882500172,
-0.013396389782428741,
-0.013894692994654179,
-0.006240382324904203,
-0.016998859122395515,
-0.017612667754292488,
-0.025342652574181557,
-0.011627931147813797,
-0.028350675478577614,
-0.00902954488992691,
-0.04084910824894905,
-0.00020885016419924796,
-0.00991189293563366,
-0.005595275666564703,
0.023466574028134346,
0.005292912013828754,
-0.0005969746853224933,
-0.02571994438767433,
0.01511428039520979,
-0.00924818404018879
] |
354 |
How Gradient descent balances features: A dynamical analysis for two-layer neural networks
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=25j2ZEgwTj
|
[
"Zhenyu Zhu",
"Fanghui Liu",
"Volkan Cevher"
] |
Poster
|
This paper investigates the fundamental regression task of learning $k$ neurons (\emph{a.k.a.} teachers) from Gaussian input, using two-layer ReLU neural networks with width $m$ (\emph{a.k.a.} students) and $m, k= \mathcal{O}(1)$, trained via gradient descent under proper initialization and a small step-size. Our analysis follows a three-phase structure: \emph{alignment} after weak recovery, \emph{tangential growth}, and \emph{local convergence}, providing deeper insights into the learning dynamics of gradient descent (GD). We prove the global convergence at the rate of $\mathcal{O}(T^{-3})$ for the zero loss of excess risk. Additionally, our results show that GD automatically groups and balances student neurons, revealing an implicit bias toward achieving the minimum ``balanced'' $\ell_2$-norm in the solution. Our work extends beyond previous studies in exact-parameterization setting ($m = k = 1$, (Yehudai and Ohad, 2020)) and single-neuron setting ($m \geq k = 1$, (Xu and Du, 2023)). The key technical challenge lies in handling the interactions between multiple teachers and students during training, which we address by refining the alignment analysis in Phase 1 and introducing a new dynamic system analysis for tangential components in Phase 2. Our results pave the way for further research on optimizing neural network training dynamics and understanding implicit biases in more complex architectures.
|
learning theory, over-parameterization, learning dynamics
| null | 13,306 | null |
[
-0.038491345942020416,
-0.016565553843975067,
-0.0008983952575363219,
0.013074827380478382,
0.02278207056224346,
0.046902213245630264,
0.024393005296587944,
0.009242822416126728,
-0.04582057520747185,
-0.03180272877216339,
0.008913100697100163,
-0.009903482161462307,
-0.06526926159858704,
0.021380377933382988,
0.019644850865006447,
0.037751663476228714,
0.06410322338342667,
-0.0210883729159832,
-0.0016391228418797255,
0.01988794654607773,
-0.00378779205493629,
-0.02787434495985508,
0.03624118119478226,
-0.0023720916360616684,
0.025983896106481552,
-0.05273020640015602,
0.014742625877261162,
0.005751227494329214,
-0.0017777651082724333,
-0.0027760243974626064,
0.02790600247681141,
0.015206159092485905,
-0.0008900591055862606,
-0.025113731622695923,
0.026133550330996513,
0.03204099088907242,
-0.026034243404865265,
0.00768188526853919,
0.012602027505636215,
0.02549249306321144,
-0.04715738072991371,
0.015379787422716618,
-0.03744271397590637,
0.01591195911169052,
-0.05334635078907013,
0.03635987266898155,
-0.1238764226436615,
0.02711135894060135,
0.01921587809920311,
-0.055436816066503525,
-0.10684043169021606,
0.06679419428110123,
0.009357244707643986,
-0.0311820637434721,
-0.011231309734284878,
0.0332651250064373,
0.01379266008734703,
-0.047963742166757584,
-0.033384159207344055,
-0.0385282039642334,
-0.02526925504207611,
0.033191047608852386,
0.000550212396774441,
0.022334767505526543,
-0.018518006429076195,
0.0008688928792253137,
0.027636950835585594,
0.021056154742836952,
-0.05134168267250061,
-0.03061755932867527,
-0.04083666950464249,
0.01926589198410511,
0.008739853277802467,
0.012584652751684189,
-0.0022942195646464825,
-0.0534588024020195,
-0.003949017729610205,
0.027956180274486542,
0.07283347845077515,
0.013503693975508213,
0.007537582889199257,
0.010880270972847939,
0.02655094675719738,
0.041914328932762146,
-0.0016374763799831271,
0.017345435917377472,
-0.03924046456813812,
-0.039877999573946,
-0.07494108378887177,
0.03495454415678978,
-0.04005010798573494,
-0.040516436100006104,
0.022523047402501106,
0.04533226415514946,
-0.013411523774266243,
0.0027406930457800627,
0.02298937365412712,
-0.005387968849390745,
0.0313955657184124,
0.001776060787960887,
-0.00611321534961462,
-0.03854767605662346,
-0.003137173131108284,
-0.0012215449241921306,
-0.10275955498218536,
-0.033065587282180786,
-0.019518207758665085,
-0.0008976862882263958,
0.0002556490071583539,
0.02195289172232151,
-0.0473334826529026,
0.018221313133835793,
0.01916523650288582,
-0.008687146008014679,
-0.11255253851413727,
0.017816387116909027,
-0.0272653978317976,
0.016573376953601837,
-0.02232471853494644,
0.010457157157361507,
0.039192140102386475,
0.06354917585849762,
-0.008015092462301254,
0.06418856978416443,
-0.000437526818132028,
0.04896773397922516,
0.0060495492070913315,
0.04155399650335312,
-0.028216799721121788,
-0.01863056607544422,
0.018389025703072548,
0.010831878520548344,
0.03087211400270462,
0.03100564144551754,
0.002744553843513131,
-0.01990705542266369,
-0.0012403299333527684,
0.0287861917167902,
0.025444697588682175,
-0.0005619738949462771,
-0.012568213976919651,
-0.031662967056035995,
0.045070830732584,
-0.02729545719921589,
0.03902465105056763,
-0.019401049241423607,
0.0006598688196390867,
-0.04170939326286316,
-0.042827218770980835,
-0.02471972070634365,
-0.006318820174783468,
0.0012822484131902456,
-0.00601849565282464,
-0.08174490183591843,
-0.0052446844056248665,
0.07446052879095078,
0.007380725350230932,
0.01428820937871933,
0.014352258294820786,
-0.006379372905939817,
0.005622054450213909,
-0.002807638607919216,
0.012781582772731781,
0.02098529040813446,
-0.01686275191605091,
-0.04701664298772812,
0.052109017968177795,
0.030552227050065994,
-0.03186800703406334,
0.01583336479961872,
-0.03656904399394989,
-0.0379127636551857,
0.03153463825583458,
-0.005831573624163866,
0.00802203081548214,
-0.013602202758193016,
0.053448695689439774,
-0.002060006372630596,
0.01508585549890995,
0.014378761872649193,
-0.09270711243152618,
0.029891299083828926,
0.02294917032122612,
0.03235522657632828,
0.004268302582204342,
-0.012088208459317684,
0.0959714949131012,
-0.04516199231147766,
0.05581281706690788,
0.015389193780720234,
-0.05384184420108795,
0.010408839210867882,
0.016353202983736992,
-0.002055568154901266,
0.08020702004432678,
-0.000616975303273648,
-0.001343008247204125,
0.007374051492661238,
0.009832366369664669,
0.053606465458869934,
0.06550995260477066,
-0.060729749500751495,
0.0375782810151577,
-0.0029973993077874184,
-0.02650659903883934,
-0.004244656767696142,
0.0317411869764328,
-0.07899103313684464,
0.01498273853212595,
0.017382211983203888,
-0.00945428665727377,
-0.005995385814458132,
0.00655351672321558,
0.021806683391332626,
0.016909325495362282,
0.001545545645058155,
-0.018487228080630302,
0.00812255684286356,
0.015113829635083675,
-0.02496582828462124,
0.02354559674859047,
0.0071822586469352245,
-0.0029089327435940504,
0.01849832944571972,
-0.016580285504460335,
0.10523071140050888,
0.07901936769485474,
-0.005530190654098988,
-0.025983469560742378,
0.02326064370572567,
0.016725074499845505,
0.000184765609446913,
0.001974118407815695,
0.02216406911611557,
-0.01046665757894516,
0.002494672778993845,
-0.02829120308160782,
-0.034470316022634506,
0.07352635264396667,
-0.05292524769902229,
0.01754160411655903,
0.08649972081184387,
-0.0239596888422966,
0.05845312029123306,
-0.02238420583307743,
-0.0082824332639575,
0.03657335788011551,
0.004394079092890024,
-0.039781130850315094,
-0.032226841896772385,
-0.015569050796329975,
0.020016182214021683,
-0.004376009572297335,
-0.018905993551015854,
0.009279055520892143,
-0.06420758366584778,
-0.04364680498838425,
-0.021650714799761772,
0.08559267967939377,
0.03363935276865959,
0.03353550285100937,
0.022632166743278503,
0.007674200460314751,
-0.017619315534830093,
-0.008470442146062851,
-0.12316706776618958,
-0.0410316027700901,
0.015448477119207382,
0.05485697090625763,
0.011932272464036942,
0.048981305211782455,
0.0030195743311196566,
0.051966071128845215,
-0.034781794995069504,
-0.031145146116614342,
0.009764359332621098,
0.03726276382803917,
0.014898175373673439,
-0.03333486616611481,
-0.027094636112451553,
0.003045220160856843,
0.07291904091835022,
-0.010677576065063477,
-0.028574902564287186,
-0.024982934817671776,
-0.06361479312181473,
-0.010947812348604202,
-0.029523978009819984,
-0.005246920511126518,
-0.0036348255816847086,
-0.010813891887664795,
0.009675955399870872,
-0.027295686304569244,
0.005013581831008196,
0.007811151444911957,
0.07293696701526642,
0.0550682507455349,
0.003668535500764847,
-0.0021591586992144585,
0.019570980221033096,
-0.016998298466205597,
0.01174385379999876,
-0.0025308707263320684,
0.024889562278985977,
-0.03523555025458336,
0.000402339908760041,
0.015061498619616032,
-0.0061748274601995945,
-0.29961779713630676,
-0.017271270975470543,
0.017383508384227753,
0.0060074287466704845,
0.052472006529569626,
-0.013891183771193027,
0.04786224290728569,
-0.005251685157418251,
-0.016727827489376068,
0.004598243627697229,
-0.015504075214266777,
0.009491213597357273,
-0.006732692942023277,
0.048965707421302795,
0.005313134286552668,
0.0160785261541605,
0.013190202414989471,
-0.007234564051032066,
-0.013304539024829865,
0.0612325444817543,
-0.017524102702736855,
-0.09186460077762604,
-0.027703862637281418,
0.07030963152647018,
-0.009160385467112064,
0.0536324679851532,
-0.06007705628871918,
-0.01671624556183815,
-0.04669666662812233,
-0.0038177166134119034,
-0.037814486771821976,
-0.01543602254241705,
-0.03447853401303291,
0.06316093355417252,
0.025506824254989624,
-0.007402040529996157,
-0.0004366976791061461,
-0.005929742939770222,
0.01598810777068138,
0.045273520052433014,
-0.0063587999902665615,
-0.013940774835646152,
-0.011831505224108696,
0.04974926635622978,
0.08471424877643585,
0.04384162276983261,
-0.044458549469709396,
0.0003921972238458693,
-0.01861463114619255,
0.026855742558836937,
-0.001756282290443778,
-0.03430808335542679,
-0.023472610861063004,
0.015980476513504982,
-0.029964487999677658,
-0.008734440430998802,
-0.016520682722330093,
-0.018494652584195137,
0.022221803665161133,
0.025030467659235,
-0.00560226384550333,
-0.056844111531972885,
0.0007503289962187409,
-0.04642302170395851,
-0.0023147601168602705,
-0.03487292677164078,
-0.06976718455553055,
-0.0601024366915226,
0.04807444289326668,
0.02015117183327675,
-0.014090233482420444,
-0.019504757598042488,
-0.044119399040937424,
-0.09393917769193649,
0.013911208137869835,
-0.024028269574046135,
-0.009816987439990044,
-0.026462366804480553,
0.0057033696211874485,
0.050461217761039734,
-0.030119800940155983,
-0.040216006338596344,
0.016949111595749855,
0.007254266180098057,
0.011918633244931698,
-0.014055601321160793,
0.03599751740694046,
-0.004211558029055595,
-0.01627178303897381,
-0.0183597169816494,
0.036582332104444504,
-0.02166636846959591,
0.05578457936644554,
-0.03236331790685654,
0.05858158320188522,
0.003724823473021388,
0.010743099264800549,
0.03466547280550003,
0.041473958641290665,
0.0018136788858100772,
0.03501032292842865,
-0.08040662109851837,
-0.02866986207664013,
-0.05045265704393387,
-0.049173250794410706,
0.02179788611829281,
-0.05278691276907921,
0.009595545008778572,
0.0493597574532032,
0.008186346851289272,
-0.01142348162829876,
-0.07474807649850845,
-0.00988807249814272,
-0.006893421523272991,
-0.022126400843262672,
-0.023976674303412437,
-0.009333631955087185,
0.020820841193199158,
0.024713100865483284,
-0.008160167373716831,
-0.028024934232234955,
0.051942378282547,
-0.01894472911953926,
0.014090831391513348,
-0.01720147207379341,
-0.014957244507968426,
-0.02017766796052456,
-0.03591955453157425,
-0.021855629980564117,
0.00019297927792649716,
0.041897643357515335,
0.05236605927348137,
-0.004652931820601225,
0.02323860675096512,
0.04616953805088997,
0.004692964721471071,
0.005092515144497156,
-0.015401567332446575,
0.03742705285549164,
-0.017845118418335915,
0.027801496908068657,
0.022181443870067596,
0.019198082387447357,
-0.011659106239676476,
0.03578624874353409,
0.02132374420762062,
0.008972208015620708,
-0.027089295908808708,
0.004798571113497019,
-0.022138655185699463,
0.04179578647017479,
-0.06182025745511055,
-0.021476803347468376,
-0.0261659175157547,
0.0066914986819028854,
-0.0029383408837020397,
0.01582089439034462,
-0.002106624422594905,
-0.00619592284783721,
-0.02720595896244049,
0.06440399587154388,
0.0036814461927860975,
-0.05442221835255623,
0.004585636779665947,
0.0005468038725666702,
0.05181136727333069,
-0.012115336023271084,
-0.008295162580907345,
0.03846355900168419,
0.005523297470062971,
-0.006343861110508442,
0.009861337020993233,
-0.02680569887161255,
-0.061730071902275085,
-0.01940823532640934,
-0.012400761246681213,
0.027945416048169136,
-0.03528708964586258,
-0.020488422363996506,
0.01616598293185234,
0.026437636464834213,
-0.017609816044569016,
-0.00420015724375844,
0.042487747967243195,
0.08403796702623367,
0.024882765486836433,
-0.011891909874975681,
-0.01304274145513773,
-0.04125561565160751,
0.04306890442967415,
-0.009486107155680656,
0.006465150974690914,
-0.013908120803534985,
-0.03613266348838806,
-0.02504628151655197,
-0.035436008125543594,
-0.007443901617079973,
0.052019573748111725,
-0.003072568913921714,
-0.02003425732254982,
-0.03328688070178032,
0.04033876582980156,
-0.023087255656719208,
0.03086855262517929,
0.04203128442168236,
-0.08410739153623581,
0.018793722614645958,
0.029927143827080727,
-0.00982377678155899,
0.03757699579000473,
-0.00823315978050232,
-0.059822555631399155,
-0.057496845722198486,
-0.04309621453285217,
0.02091103419661522,
-0.022920526564121246,
-0.026883065700531006,
-0.039581939578056335,
0.00035300644231028855,
-0.018902458250522614,
0.009179378859698772,
-0.00285219494253397,
-0.019291650503873825,
-0.027564240619540215,
-0.0051274411380290985,
0.042951084673404694,
-0.016936471685767174,
0.02718239650130272,
-0.0026857228949666023,
-0.023470811545848846,
0.012188402004539967,
-0.04479071870446205,
0.010698662139475346,
0.05942431837320328,
-0.013513639569282532,
0.001211794326081872,
-0.031077878549695015,
0.0067276195622980595,
-0.013903442770242691,
-0.0011998711852356791,
-0.013588178902864456,
0.0035156041849404573,
-0.06680374592542648,
0.011536319740116596,
0.0004374745476525277,
0.05093182995915413,
0.022478673607110977,
-0.01469059381633997,
0.023195575922727585,
0.002244251314550638,
0.01961880549788475,
0.01402475405484438,
-0.0437810942530632,
0.01557428203523159,
0.059664055705070496,
-0.040474049746990204,
-0.04711509123444557,
-0.08122158795595169,
-0.013989722356200218,
0.0011197119019925594,
-0.01650986447930336,
0.000024705546820769086,
-0.029817048460245132,
0.054463159292936325,
0.016996173188090324,
0.05426446720957756,
0.0033305485267192125,
-0.008054819889366627,
0.022119829431176186,
-0.04999208822846413,
0.00607751589268446,
-0.07267027348279953,
-0.04475325718522072,
0.05980437621474266,
-0.0028481108602136374,
0.03459203243255615,
0.008960394188761711,
-0.030179092660546303,
0.0368950255215168,
-0.03283391892910004,
-0.04213406518101692,
0.013821778818964958,
-0.025027133524417877,
-0.007026677951216698,
0.02327112667262554,
-0.04980337992310524,
-0.004176919814199209,
-0.015068892389535904,
-0.06444613635540009,
0.001255892333574593,
0.006879492197185755,
0.04240918904542923,
0.017259715124964714,
0.01793992891907692,
-0.018969953060150146,
0.025574857369065285,
0.027559146285057068,
0.042273711413145065,
0.02357250079512596,
0.01746743731200695,
-0.04318472743034363,
0.06854594498872757,
0.033269256353378296,
0.025909317657351494,
-0.0050758603028953075,
0.03624237701296806,
0.005203130654990673,
-0.05038011446595192,
0.04750901460647583,
-0.007837087847292423,
-0.017842555418610573,
-0.037447333335876465,
0.03461480885744095,
0.017042234539985657,
-0.041309040039777756,
-0.006961797829717398,
0.03503253683447838,
-0.05204283073544502,
0.003889804007485509,
0.01481271255761385,
0.009196641854941845,
0.013207092881202698,
0.07731279730796814,
0.005459656473249197,
0.04005583003163338,
0.048369791358709335,
0.014062232337892056,
-0.03265812247991562,
0.03218315541744232,
0.07727033644914627,
0.06010718643665314,
0.023477042093873024,
-0.01654980145394802,
0.07259178906679153,
-0.03806460648775101,
-0.073267363011837,
0.02704121544957161,
0.012284022755920887,
-0.008093873038887978,
-0.025050625205039978,
0.02023857831954956,
0.06630191951990128,
0.03735920414328575,
0.06407422572374344,
-0.0197572223842144,
-0.017742054536938667,
0.036656107753515244,
0.019132068380713463,
-0.007749171927571297,
0.03943808376789093,
0.03380539268255234,
-0.0008883590926416218,
-0.025023026391863823,
-0.028196610510349274,
0.003514618147164583,
-0.008324130438268185,
0.021504344418644905,
0.007811539340764284,
-0.02237117290496826,
0.00916270725429058,
0.0074198320508003235,
0.04674508050084114,
0.09501174092292786,
-0.04803478345274925,
-0.01868387870490551,
-0.007342609576880932,
0.010458333417773247,
0.004998927470296621,
0.02749449759721756,
0.006998952478170395,
-0.037370871752500534,
-0.001105623901821673,
-0.04381715506315231,
0.031145742163062096,
0.005689735058695078,
0.013621564954519272,
-0.011019301600754261,
-0.04897050932049751,
0.003906587138772011,
0.037926748394966125,
0.04821465536952019,
-0.006426767911761999,
-0.05825220048427582,
-0.029576750472187996,
-0.05629020184278488,
-0.05984129756689072,
-0.051402490586042404,
0.03771593049168587,
-0.008252928033471107,
-0.026048948988318443,
0.004201993346214294,
-0.0075853075832128525,
0.017848769202828407,
0.0397946797311306,
-0.04119141027331352,
0.013852722942829132,
0.011739556677639484,
-0.003739679465070367,
0.0033897743560373783,
0.02304551936686039,
0.013964218087494373,
-0.012628351338207722,
-0.019392626360058784,
0.04974322393536568,
-0.021289005875587463,
0.008351746946573257,
-0.026712097227573395,
0.002844341332092881,
-0.1021391898393631,
-0.0187964029610157,
0.002703251549974084,
-0.06792270392179489,
-0.08496470004320145,
0.048945676535367966,
-0.010751936584711075,
0.04166369512677193,
0.0645870566368103,
-0.020473187789320946,
-0.00976934377104044,
-0.04722697660326958,
-0.02988435886800289,
-0.02876744046807289,
-0.006438685581088066,
0.05109964683651924,
-0.024915961548686028,
0.06410983204841614,
0.012610050849616528,
-0.016029847785830498,
-0.02519705891609192,
0.027354322373867035,
-0.03175323083996773,
-0.006215773057192564,
-0.006794492714107037,
-0.029771476984024048,
-0.004936710931360722,
-0.09651489555835724,
-0.013718838803470135,
0.003519897349178791,
0.0012002051807940006,
-0.030625998973846436,
0.007005411200225353,
-0.012608900666236877,
0.033918656408786774,
-0.03182264044880867,
-0.014684758149087429,
-0.0026923813857138157,
-0.02193705551326275,
-0.020282436162233353,
-0.045568373054265976,
0.017703494057059288,
-0.017721282318234444,
0.039685506373643875,
-0.008984231390058994,
-0.030089905485510826,
-0.010943226516246796,
-0.016357462853193283,
0.04740825667977333,
0.007355972658842802,
0.01642448455095291,
-0.00695841433480382
] |
355 |
A Common Pitfall of Margin-based Language Model Alignment: Gradient Entanglement
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=YaBiGjuDiC
|
[
"Hui Yuan",
"Yifan Zeng",
"Yue Wu",
"Huazheng Wang",
"Mengdi Wang",
"Liu Leqi"
] |
Poster
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has become the predominant approach for aligning language models (LMs) to be more helpful and less harmful.
At its core, RLHF uses a margin-based loss for preference optimization, which specifies the ideal LM behavior only in terms of the difference between preferred and dispreferred responses. In this paper, we identify a common pitfall of margin-based methods---the under-specification of ideal LM behavior on preferred and dispreferred responses individually, which results in two unintended consequences as the margin increases:
(1) The probability of dispreferred (e.g., unsafe) responses may increase, resulting in potential safety alignment failures.
(2) The probability of preferred responses may decrease, even when those responses are ideal.
We demystify the reasons behind these problematic behaviors: margin-based losses couple the change in the preferred probability with the gradient of the dispreferred one, and vice versa, often preventing the preferred probability from increasing while the dispreferred one decreases, and thus causing a synchronized increase or decrease in both probabilities. We term this effect, inherent in margin-based objectives, gradient entanglement.
Formally, we derive conditions for general margin-based alignment objectives under which gradient entanglement becomes concerning: the inner product between the gradient of preferred log-probability and the gradient of dispreferred log-probability is large relative to the individual gradient norms. Furthermore, we theoretically investigate why such inner products can be large when aligning language models and empirically validate our findings. Empirical implications of our framework further extend to explaining important differences in the training dynamics of various preference optimization algorithms and suggesting future directions for improvement.
|
Alignment, Preference Optimization, Large Language Model
| null | 13,302 |
2410.13828
|
[
-0.012976229190826416,
0.011569778434932232,
0.012509096413850784,
0.045211900025606155,
0.04153972119092941,
0.013836481608450413,
0.0441921167075634,
0.02078966051340103,
-0.019069785252213478,
-0.013665743172168732,
-0.012941014021635056,
0.04594287648797035,
-0.08879711478948593,
-0.02258794568479061,
-0.00397433852776885,
0.035748664289712906,
0.03960438445210457,
0.002540482906624675,
0.004399518482387066,
0.013448103331029415,
-0.006236033979803324,
-0.013316391967236996,
0.009127550758421421,
0.009012414142489433,
0.062445979565382004,
0.02695307321846485,
0.003313969122245908,
-0.0037911792751401663,
-0.04070805385708809,
-0.020981160923838615,
0.053446535021066666,
-0.015350250527262688,
0.01174564752727747,
-0.00827773753553629,
0.03130052238702774,
-0.024508362635970116,
-0.05937674269080162,
-0.004392682574689388,
0.02731732279062271,
0.03987542539834976,
-0.04067488759756088,
0.02689889445900917,
-0.020688515156507492,
0.0030471489299088717,
-0.05332159623503685,
0.015092290006577969,
-0.11132305860519409,
0.03237916901707649,
0.02575111947953701,
-0.0647343322634697,
-0.12125808745622635,
0.04868539795279503,
0.015448159538209438,
-0.01981295272707939,
-0.01828049123287201,
0.02740626223385334,
0.032324448227882385,
-0.07577589154243469,
0.0042571090161800385,
-0.03563190996646881,
-0.025386027991771698,
0.034994106739759445,
0.005244685336947441,
-0.011632431298494339,
-0.009441631846129894,
0.000750318868085742,
0.0077329520136117935,
0.035176463425159454,
-0.039034873247146606,
-0.04209180548787117,
-0.03161700814962387,
0.0020179387647658587,
0.03071046620607376,
0.027462733909487724,
-0.004050489980727434,
-0.02675171010196209,
0.006749128457158804,
0.0162114929407835,
0.0714656263589859,
-0.0031811129301786423,
-0.014358296990394592,
0.040694549679756165,
0.023662030696868896,
0.018237486481666565,
0.023077722638845444,
-0.022295678034424782,
-0.024444032460451126,
-0.036937467753887177,
-0.08777451515197754,
0.026285262778401375,
-0.025943640619516373,
-0.05410691350698471,
0.011156164109706879,
0.027131415903568268,
0.031247396022081375,
0.004097546450793743,
0.027845045551657677,
0.045422062277793884,
-0.009233036078512669,
-0.026486271992325783,
-0.03974702209234238,
-0.032787665724754333,
0.015673402696847916,
-0.0025796496775001287,
-0.09405309706926346,
-0.04832974821329117,
-0.0010468156542629004,
-0.00023646812769584358,
0.006101901642978191,
-0.001380785251967609,
-0.053431954234838486,
-0.00418271217495203,
0.028871865943074226,
-0.023431450128555298,
-0.06703022122383118,
0.016519419848918915,
-0.004247167147696018,
0.04849075525999069,
-0.02268141135573387,
-0.004376921337097883,
0.02423582412302494,
0.02900206297636032,
0.005134047009050846,
0.09160871058702469,
-0.021331965923309326,
0.01935301348567009,
-0.009188705123960972,
0.05445073917508125,
-0.06523899734020233,
-0.029590504243969917,
0.0035990197211503983,
0.0453651025891304,
-0.0360834002494812,
0.02645033225417137,
-0.012944219633936882,
0.016470706090331078,
0.03172674402594566,
0.03221696615219116,
0.05549061670899391,
0.0030903490260243416,
0.0015453246887773275,
-0.0008890996687114239,
0.06132255494594574,
-0.01298588328063488,
0.04698730260133743,
-0.008118463680148125,
-0.028908755630254745,
-0.024066373705863953,
-0.03739028424024582,
0.018395937979221344,
-0.0016249691834673285,
-0.013485499657690525,
0.01047348789870739,
-0.032926302403211594,
-0.0008561299182474613,
0.06574908643960953,
0.012051821686327457,
0.01156532857567072,
0.023680608719587326,
0.01486815232783556,
-0.02090860903263092,
-0.000845337868668139,
-0.03608214855194092,
0.005882514640688896,
-0.0013114135945215821,
-0.05835866928100586,
0.023480674251914024,
0.02240632474422455,
-0.028447357937693596,
0.02567315846681595,
-0.0431659109890461,
0.0067945425398647785,
0.059773001819849014,
-0.04636377841234207,
-0.030772071331739426,
-0.02506018616259098,
0.04080231115221977,
0.02341972477734089,
0.051065340638160706,
0.040492840111255646,
-0.08652829378843307,
0.055162861943244934,
0.016833843663334846,
0.02174297161400318,
0.007717125583440065,
-0.020407717674970627,
0.07600568234920502,
-0.02797923982143402,
0.01341298222541809,
0.05313381180167198,
-0.06955097615718842,
-0.008442736230790615,
0.04881463944911957,
-0.019171154126524925,
0.0830923467874527,
-0.04001966491341591,
0.003470453666523099,
0.03770910203456879,
0.045722316950559616,
0.05112955719232559,
0.028761813417077065,
-0.03711747005581856,
0.02549663372337818,
0.002052746480330825,
-0.002048583934083581,
0.008496247231960297,
0.016469134017825127,
-0.011137361638247967,
-0.028170637786388397,
0.027724122628569603,
-0.029048655182123184,
0.015227596275508404,
-0.00044515871559269726,
0.014346783049404621,
0.03232426941394806,
-0.000652408110909164,
-0.01662125624716282,
-0.03345777466893196,
0.0013320939615368843,
-0.05171988531947136,
0.04682271555066109,
0.009895858354866505,
0.0014565658057108521,
-0.010262459516525269,
-0.03215392306447029,
0.09432967752218246,
0.08342429250478745,
0.012819930911064148,
-0.012598858214914799,
0.04818443953990936,
-0.01478025782853365,
-0.011882031336426735,
0.02553500048816204,
-0.017489910125732422,
0.02403579093515873,
-0.01400249358266592,
-0.030916161835193634,
-0.013242012821137905,
0.05638730525970459,
-0.03754456341266632,
-0.005655962508171797,
0.05285235494375229,
-0.030166607350111008,
0.0447908416390419,
-0.02472316101193428,
0.02018044702708721,
0.04311005026102066,
0.012182595208287239,
-0.02644801139831543,
-0.011238506063818932,
-0.036795154213905334,
0.0037577738985419273,
0.010432049632072449,
-0.012036725878715515,
0.03410453721880913,
-0.05115647614002228,
-0.0024396947119385004,
-0.006810471881181002,
0.04068271070718765,
0.06541582196950912,
0.01480180025100708,
0.05314740538597107,
-0.013332591392099857,
-0.043873727321624756,
0.0041898987255990505,
-0.08523336052894592,
-0.039146918803453445,
-0.016215115785598755,
0.029617901891469955,
0.010065815411508083,
0.026071280241012573,
-0.009944543242454529,
0.029495729133486748,
-0.03072940744459629,
-0.0188521146774292,
0.026051627472043037,
0.028339991346001625,
-0.012009293772280216,
-0.04317934438586235,
0.013968382962048054,
-0.01777566224336624,
0.051988448947668076,
-0.04446492716670036,
-0.05240499973297119,
-0.020736433565616608,
-0.029953651130199432,
-0.008513379842042923,
-0.06288600713014603,
0.007729227188974619,
0.026119470596313477,
0.021618660539388657,
-0.0018031088402494788,
-0.019056284800171852,
0.0012249501887708902,
0.004604868125170469,
0.04421886429190636,
0.0514422282576561,
0.020247505977749825,
0.028318410739302635,
0.05070127919316292,
-0.0012479271972551942,
0.036678291857242584,
-0.005354553461074829,
0.012843566946685314,
-0.002473912900313735,
-0.008682304061949253,
0.008455323055386543,
0.01372496783733368,
-0.2932930588722229,
-0.029196783900260925,
0.01584162376821041,
0.00478361826390028,
0.029864905402064323,
-0.01581234484910965,
0.046961989253759384,
-0.045665193349123,
-0.027300599962472916,
0.006054822355508804,
-0.011139919050037861,
0.01461958047002554,
0.01651153527200222,
0.043112460523843765,
0.05351238697767258,
0.0065637980587780476,
-0.021607685834169388,
-0.026394372805953026,
-0.009660799987614155,
0.018250461667776108,
-0.04374892637133598,
-0.06726499646902084,
-0.026791803538799286,
0.05366537719964981,
0.018496951088309288,
0.06808160245418549,
-0.07097283750772476,
-0.023230910301208496,
-0.04337777569890022,
-0.01591680198907852,
-0.029110264033079147,
0.01212031114846468,
-0.02214202471077442,
0.006400784943252802,
0.010822859592735767,
0.006124623119831085,
0.018503338098526,
-0.012696871533989906,
0.049080006778240204,
0.027258355170488358,
0.009011264890432358,
-0.030900485813617706,
-0.002554042497649789,
-0.00636395625770092,
0.047276198863983154,
0.020793301984667778,
-0.03416453301906586,
-0.00582496915012598,
-0.00007480421481886879,
0.03908689692616463,
-0.007832658477127552,
-0.018997138366103172,
-0.006281298119574785,
0.038146499544382095,
0.022191200405359268,
-0.0038042133674025536,
0.0023051726166158915,
-0.024697870016098022,
-0.007104485761374235,
0.01652044616639614,
0.0004999778466299176,
-0.0652836337685585,
-0.03687139227986336,
-0.03776364028453827,
-0.008709530346095562,
-0.025194158777594566,
-0.07615621387958527,
-0.013711187057197094,
0.051451776176691055,
0.03783068433403969,
-0.03974105790257454,
0.020308718085289,
-0.014077932573854923,
-0.08687575906515121,
0.013310329988598824,
0.007028223481029272,
-0.018431667238473892,
-0.025939607992768288,
-0.0038182497955858707,
0.044292084872722626,
-0.04702922701835632,
-0.04945790767669678,
0.027031471952795982,
0.02629755437374115,
0.014526956714689732,
-0.03442927449941635,
0.04079583287239075,
0.0026538358069956303,
-0.01914263889193535,
-0.026376159861683846,
0.028526948764920235,
0.008508305996656418,
-0.010274204425513744,
0.0023243166506290436,
0.03733265772461891,
0.03212601691484451,
0.014858686365187168,
0.048340100795030594,
0.034651294350624084,
0.006774372421205044,
0.011955151334404945,
-0.09124676883220673,
-0.014633916318416595,
-0.04384228214621544,
-0.02930929884314537,
0.04218249022960663,
-0.07251124829053879,
-0.024595046415925026,
0.019795183092355728,
0.006331233307719231,
-0.020811777561903,
-0.026473356410861015,
0.014713320881128311,
0.0033097427804023027,
-0.06480515748262405,
-0.02019842155277729,
-0.007482154760509729,
0.034960657358169556,
0.01515026856213808,
0.006233393680304289,
0.010207300074398518,
0.042732417583465576,
-0.02195563167333603,
0.006897087208926678,
-0.008509339764714241,
-0.003388017416000366,
-0.01679042913019657,
-0.016434794291853905,
-0.013760439120233059,
0.020963912829756737,
0.026027509942650795,
0.05376572534441948,
0.019172685220837593,
0.01109001412987709,
0.06627403944730759,
0.002296959049999714,
0.0013888069661334157,
-0.004872956778854132,
0.023818783462047577,
-0.024548405781388283,
0.04663359746336937,
-0.021190708503127098,
0.025595836341381073,
0.02995866909623146,
0.00034839921863749623,
-0.007129746489226818,
0.023046676069498062,
0.0033641366753727198,
-0.0029349771793931723,
0.015667269006371498,
0.029732057824730873,
-0.04599732160568237,
0.008628059178590775,
-0.031104931607842445,
0.01797444000840187,
-0.0008352576405741274,
0.013150579296052456,
0.004999569151550531,
0.004453685600310564,
-0.05229682847857475,
0.051799509674310684,
0.028904590755701065,
-0.030766917392611504,
0.015061665326356888,
0.029350735247135162,
0.015381154604256153,
-0.054042570292949677,
-0.002866755472496152,
0.027114760130643845,
0.015030913054943085,
0.006316722836345434,
-0.021429525688290596,
-0.03189505636692047,
-0.009162346832454205,
-0.04178428649902344,
-0.005180727690458298,
0.01997833140194416,
-0.042558278888463974,
-0.02206083945930004,
0.022377196699380875,
0.015922151505947113,
-0.03328784555196762,
0.011714230291545391,
-0.009398341178894043,
0.07296553999185562,
-0.007986701093614101,
-0.012260460294783115,
-0.008428056724369526,
-0.023217082023620605,
0.02962363138794899,
-0.009933779016137123,
-0.015223192982375622,
-0.03412806615233421,
-0.010999046266078949,
-0.032219380140304565,
-0.027463773265480995,
-0.00438415864482522,
-0.0015235445462167263,
0.002250771038234234,
0.008878427557647228,
-0.01716826669871807,
0.03209127113223076,
-0.02602914720773697,
-0.005587897263467312,
0.03332304209470749,
-0.08428648859262466,
-0.00963764451444149,
0.028740011155605316,
-0.0013921307399868965,
0.032558877021074295,
-0.031662192195653915,
-0.06484896689653397,
-0.07267490774393082,
-0.03523118421435356,
0.042110905051231384,
-0.02906779944896698,
-0.057137783616781235,
-0.04789706692099571,
-0.011776888743042946,
0.007314622402191162,
0.04390522465109825,
-0.020577261224389076,
-0.0004024097870569676,
-0.00874715019017458,
0.0017760880291461945,
0.0313076488673687,
-0.043469205498695374,
0.01413313951343298,
0.019571810960769653,
-0.019816959276795387,
0.038598135113716125,
-0.047173723578453064,
0.048218611627817154,
0.04180920869112015,
0.01251025777310133,
0.021830886602401733,
-0.05991331860423088,
0.051696013659238815,
-0.018071070313453674,
-0.03383557125926018,
0.034664738923311234,
0.002249643672257662,
-0.022491659969091415,
0.00969487801194191,
-0.03767992556095123,
0.061355315148830414,
0.027618123218417168,
0.01799108274281025,
0.009193900972604752,
0.001325881341472268,
0.008745417930185795,
0.017883799970149994,
-0.03495560586452484,
0.01879294030368328,
0.06745962798595428,
-0.006178943440318108,
-0.037296805530786514,
-0.06872180849313736,
-0.05005265027284622,
0.02180408127605915,
-0.0025627673603594303,
0.0008802401716820896,
-0.0286418404430151,
0.05254121124744415,
0.011972527019679546,
0.03907177224755287,
0.0056694624945521355,
-0.02246052585542202,
0.03150084242224693,
-0.06241803243756294,
0.007653853856027126,
-0.0548076331615448,
-0.00488165533170104,
0.06280583888292313,
-0.050543222576379776,
-0.0011937833623960614,
-0.021594103425741196,
-0.04758872464299202,
0.015176870860159397,
-0.0300112497061491,
-0.05692660063505173,
-0.011004175990819931,
-0.022071629762649536,
-0.006747148465365171,
0.015135057270526886,
-0.043727289885282516,
-0.034790389239788055,
-0.037598732858896255,
-0.050276532769203186,
-0.016737036406993866,
0.019077491015195847,
0.04596714302897453,
-0.03511950373649597,
0.018539125099778175,
-0.04255881905555725,
0.024272190406918526,
0.009606542065739632,
0.07772998511791229,
0.04188770055770874,
-0.002235326450318098,
-0.04510749876499176,
0.06266545504331589,
0.04503503814339638,
0.03206128254532814,
0.0006813784711994231,
0.021709401160478592,
0.007221688982099295,
-0.05675867199897766,
0.05831180512905121,
0.0024629198014736176,
-0.004392324481159449,
-0.027767332270741463,
0.06959579139947891,
0.02482905052602291,
-0.059526123106479645,
-0.017671436071395874,
0.04534729942679405,
-0.029042469337582588,
-0.021993596106767654,
0.008617108687758446,
0.02483845129609108,
-0.01320867333561182,
0.07283131033182144,
0.03693515062332153,
0.037312544882297516,
0.08594941347837448,
0.01524948887526989,
-0.020204368978738785,
0.02845146134495735,
0.07722383737564087,
0.043016571551561356,
0.07493451982736588,
-0.007316255010664463,
0.05170685052871704,
-0.04740417003631592,
-0.06689218431711197,
0.01719382405281067,
0.030158819630742073,
-0.021276501938700676,
-0.027629654854536057,
0.022909780964255333,
0.04469864442944527,
-0.01666944846510887,
0.06413748115301132,
-0.05137878283858299,
-0.00013353572285268456,
0.043567150831222534,
0.017309222370386124,
-0.012461076490581036,
0.041790179908275604,
0.012546999379992485,
0.002749290317296982,
-0.0005004799459129572,
0.010106081143021584,
0.012713276781141758,
0.00009618219337426126,
0.034203920513391495,
-0.018441108986735344,
-0.039645202457904816,
0.0028563777450472116,
-0.002607710426673293,
0.04000978544354439,
0.1154831200838089,
-0.04687955230474472,
-0.02050355263054371,
0.02479369565844536,
-0.017330095171928406,
-0.00003838331758743152,
0.0371377095580101,
0.001754619413986802,
-0.03406590223312378,
-0.02975078672170639,
-0.07530245929956436,
-0.026279566809535027,
0.021469933912158012,
0.020141219720244408,
0.0483018159866333,
-0.028677962720394135,
0.02147766575217247,
0.03831794857978821,
0.03944659233093262,
-0.06685498356819153,
-0.046479806303977966,
-0.038630448281764984,
-0.0718168169260025,
-0.0487627349793911,
-0.06362514197826385,
0.019697090610861778,
0.009827839210629463,
-0.0196292195469141,
0.032712776213884354,
-0.035477641969919205,
0.03267987072467804,
0.012573333457112312,
-0.057750679552555084,
0.017379427328705788,
0.046411365270614624,
0.00391158415004611,
-0.008961605839431286,
0.02720438688993454,
0.02171446569263935,
0.011083587072789669,
-0.021933289244771004,
0.050802167505025864,
0.0004442340286914259,
-0.007375260349363089,
-0.028322696685791016,
0.00004744598118122667,
-0.09600242972373962,
-0.026479478925466537,
0.014482597820460796,
-0.020635752007365227,
-0.09619425237178802,
0.023312494158744812,
-0.02050413005053997,
0.010494865477085114,
0.07468903809785843,
0.012515762820839882,
0.014493908733129501,
-0.012085597030818462,
-0.02422109618782997,
-0.01528539601713419,
0.008836581371724606,
0.03249064460396767,
0.00022954649466555566,
0.04609864205121994,
0.027556821703910828,
-0.016098497435450554,
-0.06115260720252991,
0.023269779980182648,
-0.003448658622801304,
-0.034156013280153275,
-0.020964130759239197,
-0.03420790284872055,
-0.021921560168266296,
-0.09260449558496475,
-0.02931216172873974,
0.014063541777431965,
-0.024448707699775696,
-0.03332909196615219,
-0.017481932416558266,
-0.02809387445449829,
-0.01149508636444807,
0.001985239563509822,
-0.01152658462524414,
-0.04331506788730621,
-0.046574316918849945,
-0.029329344630241394,
-0.07236716151237488,
0.010519006289541721,
-0.04538797214627266,
-0.007562622427940369,
-0.02533811703324318,
-0.02562064304947853,
0.011246010661125183,
0.0009951378451660275,
0.03309832140803337,
-0.01149283442646265,
0.013524104841053486,
-0.009371688589453697
] |
356 |
Model Editing as a Robust and Denoised variant of DPO: A Case Study on Toxicity
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=lOi6FtIwR8
|
[
"Rheeya Uppaal",
"Apratim Dey",
"Yiting He",
"Yiqiao Zhong",
"Junjie Hu"
] |
Poster
|
Recent alignment algorithms such as direct preference optimization (DPO) have been developed to improve the safety of large language models (LLMs) by training these models to match human behaviors exemplified by preference data. However, these methods are
both computationally intensive and lacking in controllability and transparency, inhibiting their widespread use. Furthermore, these tuning-based methods require large-scale preference data for training and are susceptible to noisy preference data. In this paper, we introduce a tuning-free alignment alternative, ProFS (Projection Filter for Subspaces), and demonstrate its effectiveness under the use case of toxicity reduction. Grounded on theory from factor analysis, ProFS is a sample-efficient model editing approach that identifies a toxic subspace in the model parameter space and reduces model toxicity by projecting away the detected subspace. The toxic subspace is identified by extracting preference data embeddings from the language model, and removing non-toxic information from these embeddings. We show that ProFS is more sample-efficient than DPO, further showcasing greater robustness to noisy data. Finally, we attempt to connect tuning based alignment with editing, by establishing both theoretical and empirical connections between ProFS and DPO, showing that ProFS can be interpreted as a denoised version of a single DPO step.
|
model editing, mechanistic interpretability, ai safety, alignment, toxicity, llms
|
We present model editing based sample-efficient and noise robust replacement to DPO, for reducing model toxicity.
| 13,296 |
2405.13967
|
[
-0.013706354424357414,
0.015709562227129936,
-0.027907289564609528,
0.047248873859643936,
0.044155482202768326,
0.027770765125751495,
0.048594165593385696,
0.0029021252412348986,
0.002615602919831872,
-0.03966554254293442,
-0.008497452363371849,
0.034179650247097015,
-0.10968796163797379,
-0.008387814275920391,
-0.00586142810061574,
0.04185957461595535,
0.000006419407327484805,
0.005645375233143568,
0.009614220820367336,
0.009793415665626526,
0.01871485821902752,
-0.02123240940272808,
0.016199035570025444,
0.024073408916592598,
0.01861364021897316,
0.033989500254392624,
0.014560737647116184,
0.0055306451395154,
-0.025119950994849205,
-0.007009041495621204,
0.014821280725300312,
-0.009985556825995445,
0.003820777637884021,
-0.029643960297107697,
-0.011311665177345276,
0.019094601273536682,
-0.07323521375656128,
0.01202854048460722,
0.009653335437178612,
0.0520554818212986,
-0.06527505069971085,
0.024387193843722343,
-0.025882763788104057,
0.0032082973048090935,
-0.04655444622039795,
-0.005830265115946531,
-0.11175338923931122,
0.04141361266374588,
0.017113644629716873,
-0.05802667886018753,
-0.11394192278385162,
0.042308758944272995,
0.008213598281145096,
-0.01767280511558056,
-0.019725704565644264,
0.04588194191455841,
0.056008096784353256,
-0.06721404939889908,
-0.020670747384428978,
-0.050495363771915436,
-0.04979827255010605,
0.03526029363274574,
0.006785320118069649,
0.004458469804376364,
0.01846754364669323,
0.004257628694176674,
-0.030302057042717934,
0.036760326474905014,
-0.030052758753299713,
-0.012819699943065643,
0.005052073393017054,
0.0027183268684893847,
0.010894098319113255,
0.010176165960729122,
0.024035928770899773,
-0.04831946641206741,
0.011368654668331146,
0.045326147228479385,
0.047088753432035446,
0.016450827941298485,
0.03576762229204178,
0.0014086220180615783,
0.015044000931084156,
0.025400666519999504,
0.02311575971543789,
0.00116011593490839,
-0.005637513939291239,
-0.028032157570123672,
-0.07475773990154266,
0.01578734628856182,
0.0035718604922294617,
-0.05815691500902176,
0.010424457490444183,
0.02268417738378048,
0.04250591993331909,
0.045746833086013794,
0.02117128297686577,
0.013711818493902683,
-0.04506346583366394,
0.001009714906103909,
-0.019126618281006813,
-0.03144759312272072,
0.015863869339227676,
-0.0033226690720766783,
-0.10800235718488693,
-0.065984807908535,
-0.019019097089767456,
0.00953608937561512,
0.005724121350795031,
0.035839587450027466,
-0.047872789204120636,
0.009031636640429497,
0.014077048748731613,
-0.02154012769460678,
-0.08805885910987854,
0.04942001774907112,
-0.009567055851221085,
0.03540174290537834,
0.015125960111618042,
-0.010840083472430706,
0.027037182822823524,
0.014377256855368614,
0.016064796596765518,
0.09752027690410614,
-0.022118497639894485,
0.030859243124723434,
0.03776916116476059,
0.024827424436807632,
-0.027478249743580818,
-0.04527930170297623,
0.021356355398893356,
0.028431614860892296,
-0.007771430537104607,
-0.005539287347346544,
-0.012129146605730057,
-0.014142816886305809,
0.01794026419520378,
0.019490927457809448,
0.06252815574407578,
-0.0051661767065525055,
0.0023196744732558727,
0.005303202662616968,
0.05153954401612282,
-0.02638867311179638,
0.07470518350601196,
-0.014721664600074291,
-0.005885306745767593,
-0.02028210088610649,
-0.053194910287857056,
-0.0014397799968719482,
0.025049643591046333,
0.017181042581796646,
-0.004313684068620205,
-0.08107735216617584,
0.03895964100956917,
0.0681694746017456,
0.0342722125351429,
0.015424208715558052,
0.003559551667422056,
0.011189505457878113,
-0.010043137706816196,
-0.006443982943892479,
-0.05042070895433426,
-0.008151988498866558,
-0.00526251969859004,
-0.05503104254603386,
0.02077953703701496,
-0.01046024076640606,
-0.040346380323171616,
-0.0099035007879138,
-0.030055059120059013,
-0.01654919609427452,
0.05174575746059418,
-0.026530606672167778,
0.0213383249938488,
-0.015768665820360184,
0.027430107817053795,
0.0010080989450216293,
0.0397423692047596,
0.04459725692868233,
-0.08355102688074112,
0.006929436698555946,
-0.010856352746486664,
-0.006081503350287676,
0.026377925649285316,
-0.01503076683729887,
0.07754705101251602,
-0.009181913919746876,
0.031021134927868843,
0.045184049755334854,
-0.08911041170358658,
-0.037433624267578125,
0.052995093166828156,
-0.0011684286873787642,
0.07744000107049942,
0.005529505666345358,
-0.018056444823741913,
0.053485509008169174,
0.04650234058499336,
0.06010417640209198,
0.04210210591554642,
-0.005818344186991453,
0.023015981540083885,
-0.008740037679672241,
-0.04029861092567444,
-0.032604068517684937,
0.024247916415333748,
-0.029930895194411278,
-0.053904078900814056,
0.019761040806770325,
-0.027877775952219963,
-0.0010869817342609167,
0.012964682653546333,
-0.005441764835268259,
0.03337079659104347,
-0.006972776260226965,
-0.024208607152104378,
-0.011219145730137825,
0.004757631570100784,
-0.06072993949055672,
0.030725834891200066,
0.01409528311342001,
-0.018550816923379898,
-0.017576830461621284,
-0.033364128321409225,
0.11183004081249237,
0.08019249141216278,
-0.01545399148017168,
0.00992395170032978,
0.01690850965678692,
0.009078103117644787,
0.029074931517243385,
0.023707645013928413,
-0.012060745619237423,
0.024610696360468864,
-0.020166149362921715,
-0.016420593485236168,
0.00255396100692451,
0.059792958199977875,
-0.03460546210408211,
0.005638330243527889,
0.05932493507862091,
-0.027966180816292763,
0.04392008110880852,
-0.018762333318591118,
0.038819294422864914,
0.046953000128269196,
0.0017066225409507751,
-0.05215846747159958,
0.007529420778155327,
-0.021949846297502518,
0.020729929208755493,
0.012893172912299633,
-0.0196764525026083,
0.01891416683793068,
-0.03569941595196724,
-0.007763805333524942,
-0.004291568882763386,
0.06500115990638733,
0.03418516367673874,
0.0018887327751144767,
0.017974628135561943,
-0.010387766174972057,
-0.053980886936187744,
0.03905986249446869,
-0.08361760526895523,
-0.03590288385748863,
0.0037398142740130424,
0.022476334124803543,
-0.015826893970370293,
0.011908397078514099,
0.0027450015768408775,
-0.0011058576637879014,
-0.03452764451503754,
-0.011663428507745266,
0.009707069024443626,
0.03171354532241821,
0.009685251861810684,
-0.03686755895614624,
-0.01949911192059517,
0.0040215617045760155,
0.04568985104560852,
-0.03247208893299103,
-0.01961536705493927,
-0.05593327805399895,
-0.040117133408784866,
-0.00026679670554585755,
-0.033282261341810226,
-0.0169202983379364,
0.03111310862004757,
0.030991028994321823,
-0.014176339842379093,
-0.03631335124373436,
0.014075526967644691,
0.031920481473207474,
-0.0006578468601219356,
0.049286358058452606,
0.03901032358407974,
-0.009869429282844067,
0.05535736307501793,
0.026003394275903702,
0.05044126510620117,
0.0013165881391614676,
0.003106636693701148,
-0.006595741957426071,
0.025478420779109,
0.01197570189833641,
-0.018150463700294495,
-0.2792959213256836,
-0.019984953105449677,
-0.008301260881125927,
-0.018878130242228508,
0.040736448019742966,
0.008812983520328999,
0.043100714683532715,
-0.044684987515211105,
-0.029848886653780937,
0.009586966596543789,
0.004131660331040621,
0.02863440476357937,
0.031480275094509125,
0.07825309783220291,
0.07466151565313339,
0.028245000168681145,
-0.018750427290797234,
-0.026958316564559937,
-0.0037260123062878847,
0.013533181510865688,
0.0055841440334916115,
-0.0525006465613842,
-0.02377936989068985,
0.03506355732679367,
-0.018888864666223526,
0.0672178640961647,
-0.06560143083333969,
-0.008239504881203175,
-0.03146466240286827,
-0.03574415296316147,
-0.007301592733711004,
-0.021584833040833473,
-0.02825792506337166,
0.004886604845523834,
0.02736680582165718,
-0.00422609644010663,
0.02810652181506157,
0.02006402425467968,
0.028951385989785194,
0.036960892379283905,
-0.009021908044815063,
-0.05579536035656929,
-0.03435441851615906,
-0.029781682416796684,
0.03839031606912613,
0.05157431215047836,
-0.04101784527301788,
0.013620100915431976,
-0.023654038086533546,
0.03293425589799881,
0.04593437910079956,
-0.05168423056602478,
-0.00397604051977396,
0.044482067227363586,
0.017927205190062523,
-0.033945489674806595,
0.04033884406089783,
0.016615232452750206,
-0.016711797565221786,
-0.004350233823060989,
-0.009392894804477692,
-0.04577692225575447,
-0.026848820969462395,
-0.03425643593072891,
-0.03416247293353081,
-0.024816080927848816,
-0.06612781435251236,
-0.048893362283706665,
0.020847266539931297,
0.029838927090168,
-0.03723754361271858,
0.014299596659839153,
0.024058692157268524,
-0.0975707545876503,
-0.0029826927930116653,
-0.006327140145003796,
-0.008265604265034199,
-0.026573611423373222,
-0.022140974178910255,
0.016678286716341972,
-0.06458025425672531,
-0.01689130812883377,
0.04160286858677864,
0.0007828428060747683,
0.013456307351589203,
-0.04849221929907799,
0.020478051155805588,
-0.01853717677295208,
-0.031909290701150894,
-0.07384912669658661,
0.024076929315924644,
-0.02628631331026554,
0.006146278697997332,
0.011815973557531834,
0.03450067713856697,
0.02945076674222946,
0.030104663223028183,
0.03883036598563194,
0.03114791214466095,
0.01461799070239067,
0.01861400343477726,
-0.06597711145877838,
-0.011737547814846039,
-0.06120409071445465,
-0.024553801864385605,
0.038907188922166824,
-0.07818081974983215,
-0.043477464467287064,
0.016856597736477852,
-0.02091243304312229,
-0.011330381967127323,
-0.0210726261138916,
0.03654475882649422,
-0.016453100368380547,
-0.010530746541917324,
-0.01673862896859646,
0.02435917966067791,
0.023054134100675583,
0.02949625998735428,
-0.004130274523049593,
-0.023464515805244446,
0.03947170451283455,
-0.02525165304541588,
0.012918706052005291,
-0.006438576616346836,
0.0011514660436660051,
0.014360270462930202,
0.00006140949699329212,
-0.005579063668847084,
0.004611671436578035,
0.03172343224287033,
0.05759192630648613,
0.004117833916097879,
0.02093788981437683,
0.052987098693847656,
0.013193218037486076,
-0.02514249086380005,
0.011198358610272408,
0.040608495473861694,
-0.014957573264837265,
-0.005310318898409605,
-0.013899597339332104,
-0.0035984038840979338,
0.006208863575011492,
0.01602700538933277,
0.004229628015309572,
0.029245924204587936,
0.002348084934055805,
0.021652372553944588,
0.0164822768419981,
0.04548154026269913,
-0.04914446547627449,
-0.01084717083722353,
-0.04447074979543686,
0.011229123920202255,
-0.005694559309631586,
0.032781124114990234,
-0.01607258804142475,
0.02042645774781704,
-0.04141654819250107,
0.016049712896347046,
0.00802603643387556,
-0.024814676493406296,
-0.006453478708863258,
0.03171342611312866,
0.042144421488046646,
-0.02684447169303894,
0.0005946727469563484,
0.0018456429243087769,
-0.013087539933621883,
0.0176223311573267,
0.012286649085581303,
-0.026157088577747345,
-0.017820537090301514,
-0.0032347317319363356,
-0.02325209230184555,
0.025711553171277046,
0.016441503539681435,
-0.039302606135606766,
0.049161408096551895,
0.02265262044966221,
-0.05492585524916649,
0.001082874252460897,
0.008916000835597515,
0.07213642448186874,
0.030821681022644043,
-0.0013004473876208067,
-0.0439387783408165,
0.002419165102764964,
-0.001071201404556632,
-0.02976563200354576,
0.028580840677022934,
-0.0427725650370121,
-0.030282190069556236,
-0.04042254760861397,
-0.042265258729457855,
0.024982651695609093,
0.022472351789474487,
-0.009446504525840282,
-0.0077765947207808495,
-0.014370902441442013,
0.0033497491385787725,
-0.04059899225831032,
-0.044846922159194946,
0.032246433198451996,
-0.09154180437326431,
-0.017658410593867302,
0.035454679280519485,
-0.02539527788758278,
0.036914728581905365,
-0.036062002182006836,
-0.06560666114091873,
-0.055265557020902634,
-0.0407467857003212,
0.006612336728721857,
-0.0003221053921151906,
-0.02029888890683651,
-0.03988443687558174,
-0.024989008903503418,
0.018086271360516548,
-0.010889193043112755,
-0.005431730300188065,
-0.02137095108628273,
0.003920567687600851,
-0.01805419847369194,
0.044656477868556976,
-0.03176303207874298,
0.007852754555642605,
0.01507422886788845,
-0.017117105424404144,
0.040569424629211426,
-0.02691410668194294,
0.02351272851228714,
0.04906325042247772,
0.007892808876931667,
0.004467903170734644,
-0.04486202821135521,
0.05355969816446304,
-0.011105292476713657,
-0.009526435285806656,
0.022931929677724838,
-0.017689146101474762,
-0.03164961189031601,
-0.007908785715699196,
-0.02111835777759552,
0.05073457583785057,
-0.014460093341767788,
-0.022831805050373077,
-0.004048952367156744,
0.023492194712162018,
0.024157481268048286,
0.03170805796980858,
-0.05686724931001663,
0.005747167393565178,
0.05534806102514267,
-0.012693102471530437,
-0.03216371685266495,
-0.06400207430124283,
-0.04966113716363907,
0.01866837590932846,
0.0009192604920826852,
0.06387516856193542,
-0.013731719925999641,
0.03950294107198715,
0.045024704188108444,
0.04261917248368263,
0.023556789383292198,
-0.008856352418661118,
0.03864794969558716,
-0.05028557777404785,
0.00006592662975890562,
-0.06904489547014236,
0.024881649762392044,
0.06795806437730789,
-0.03898395597934723,
0.003896365873515606,
-0.0165752824395895,
-0.019542615860700607,
0.04799056798219681,
-0.02816871553659439,
-0.050943873822689056,
0.012343843467533588,
-0.01368311233818531,
-0.02750738337635994,
0.029509179294109344,
-0.0545261949300766,
-0.0028881817124783993,
-0.026158446446061134,
-0.04156871885061264,
-0.01663121022284031,
0.03198667988181114,
0.03620915487408638,
-0.035412807017564774,
0.006538011133670807,
-0.0490921288728714,
0.029831048101186752,
0.012457260861992836,
0.04797326400876045,
-0.0012716708006337285,
0.006080191116780043,
-0.024402553215622902,
0.04802974686026573,
0.02571891061961651,
0.04824735224246979,
-0.025948407128453255,
0.009481593035161495,
0.0022709742188453674,
-0.04360853508114815,
0.043915268033742905,
0.028409091755747795,
-0.011124931275844574,
-0.05399717018008232,
0.07549718767404556,
0.04439200088381767,
-0.0464947335422039,
-0.01391268614679575,
0.03592882677912712,
-0.02623760886490345,
0.015666082501411438,
-0.014313174411654472,
0.020172618329524994,
-0.02981136366724968,
0.07936219871044159,
0.018757933750748634,
0.03786233067512512,
0.05279088765382767,
0.004397157579660416,
0.019524019211530685,
0.025055982172489166,
0.05080610141158104,
0.09689439833164215,
0.06985216587781906,
-0.0038182339631021023,
0.051314011216163635,
-0.029118549078702927,
-0.04568297415971756,
0.012353911064565182,
0.015104326419532299,
-0.04072706773877144,
-0.04009753465652466,
0.00559145025908947,
0.05973103642463684,
-0.010965609923005104,
0.06574682891368866,
-0.025367358699440956,
-0.023813869804143906,
0.0235883891582489,
-0.010650837793946266,
-0.0037415120750665665,
0.03214822709560394,
0.0251544788479805,
0.035493943840265274,
-0.012716654688119888,
0.00046676816418766975,
-0.01750521920621395,
0.0016349955694749951,
0.014289856888353825,
-0.006279242690652609,
-0.0371672697365284,
0.033578649163246155,
-0.023179588839411736,
0.050729792565107346,
0.08724205195903778,
-0.054291240870952606,
-0.030222171917557716,
0.00982067920267582,
-0.006128789857029915,
0.010873916558921337,
0.048735857009887695,
-0.01913994923233986,
-0.02835499309003353,
0.0001509197027189657,
-0.04347486421465874,
-0.0009185251547023654,
0.025447864085435867,
-0.027701515704393387,
0.033807020634412766,
-0.0358777716755867,
0.015792205929756165,
0.016093410551548004,
0.01923198066651821,
-0.05480435490608215,
-0.04396660625934601,
-0.0423058457672596,
-0.038016874343156815,
-0.030215365812182426,
-0.04842253774404526,
0.008603096008300781,
-0.0036198734305799007,
-0.030646979808807373,
0.04473214969038963,
-0.04441143572330475,
0.03130163252353668,
0.04954123869538307,
-0.07615503668785095,
0.0056374697014689445,
0.04219447076320648,
0.0005373135791160166,
-0.01386952679604292,
0.01985773630440235,
0.020466307178139687,
-0.008198276162147522,
-0.028902996331453323,
0.04576077684760094,
0.005872389301657677,
0.01790030673146248,
-0.049365829676389694,
-0.007213371805846691,
-0.09205028414726257,
-0.008717228658497334,
0.03654878959059715,
-0.026437902823090553,
-0.09789829701185226,
0.02827836014330387,
0.005349711049348116,
0.04432627558708191,
0.05485190823674202,
0.03324577957391739,
0.0038192966021597385,
-0.010807609185576439,
-0.004233608953654766,
-0.019995134323835373,
0.0026399167254567146,
0.03362226113677025,
-0.045665159821510315,
0.06210402399301529,
0.015763944014906883,
-0.04436369612812996,
-0.03405124694108963,
0.035902608186006546,
-0.01595083810389042,
-0.012381392531096935,
-0.023402804508805275,
-0.023035738617181778,
-0.03909052908420563,
-0.074961818754673,
-0.012470659799873829,
0.03277451545000076,
-0.03297353908419609,
-0.032829806208610535,
-0.029302900657057762,
0.0036686479579657316,
-0.035735759884119034,
-0.007019555661827326,
-0.028990833088755608,
-0.010565576143562794,
-0.04853864386677742,
-0.019321469590067863,
-0.08361852914094925,
0.00024007822503335774,
-0.02920505590736866,
0.0044604637660086155,
-0.056847065687179565,
-0.026835376396775246,
0.006057900842279196,
0.004903746303170919,
0.06067327409982681,
-0.013847973197698593,
0.03904726356267929,
0.008418331854045391
] |
357 |
Should VLMs be Pre-trained with Image Data?
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Pj4Aid3XqL
|
[
"Sedrick Keh",
"Jean Mercat",
"Samir Yitzhak Gadre",
"Kushal Arora",
"Igor Vasiljevic",
"Benjamin Burchfiel",
"Shuran Song",
"Russ Tedrake",
"Thomas Kollar",
"Ludwig Schmidt",
"Achal Dave"
] |
Poster
|
Pre-trained LLMs that are further trained with image data perform well on vision-language tasks.
While adding images during a second training phase effectively unlocks this capability, it is unclear how much of a gain or loss this two-step pipeline gives over VLMs which integrate images earlier into the training process.
To investigate this, we train models spanning various datasets, scales, image-text ratios, and amount of pre-training done before introducing vision tokens.
We then fine-tune these models and evaluate their downstream performance on a suite of vision-language and text-only tasks.
We find that pre-training with a mixture of image and text data allows models to perform better on vision-language tasks while maintaining strong performance on text-only evaluations.
On an average of 6 diverse tasks, we find that for a 1B model, introducing visual tokens 80\% of the way through pre-training results in a 2\% average improvement over introducing visual tokens to a fully pre-trained model.
|
vision language models, pre-training, fine-tuning
|
We vary amount of image data used in pre-training VLMs, questioning the conventional formula of fine-tuning pre-trained LLMs into VLMs
| 13,294 |
2503.07603
|
[
0.03386640176177025,
-0.00770255271345377,
0.03206273168325424,
0.050091762095689774,
0.06137152016162872,
0.007171969395130873,
0.036064401268959045,
0.01831682212650776,
-0.03622182458639145,
-0.027013108134269714,
-0.05699809268116951,
0.035059113055467606,
-0.07429709285497665,
-0.016877545043826103,
-0.003949915524572134,
0.061818040907382965,
0.04884787276387215,
0.029624592512845993,
0.018088042736053467,
0.03953985124826431,
-0.027276189997792244,
-0.024608179926872253,
0.038148343563079834,
0.018614504486322403,
0.0026878376957029104,
-0.014959189109504223,
0.04417646303772926,
-0.00476931082084775,
-0.04796653985977173,
-0.015258252620697021,
0.028871187940239906,
-0.06344027817249298,
0.013449115678668022,
-0.014634824357926846,
0.03811969235539436,
0.01907982863485813,
-0.05187172442674637,
-0.019261356443166733,
0.022913280874490738,
0.011555715464055538,
-0.05945964157581329,
0.0340714231133461,
-0.007255760487169027,
-0.02216969057917595,
-0.05406757816672325,
-0.012823197059333324,
-0.1031985804438591,
0.02652820385992527,
0.01760832592844963,
-0.013413705863058567,
-0.0955929383635521,
0.012427611276507378,
0.009289691224694252,
0.025333235040307045,
0.024842768907546997,
0.013598487712442875,
0.014182950370013714,
-0.07094334810972214,
-0.013218364678323269,
-0.052556272596120834,
0.011409363709390163,
0.004430907312780619,
0.008998032659292221,
0.011150321923196316,
0.02076512761414051,
-0.05963869392871857,
0.0015086752828210592,
0.043780479580163956,
-0.051661890000104904,
-0.0518699586391449,
0.012417366728186607,
-0.006751091219484806,
-0.006718705408275127,
0.011232802644371986,
-0.004921729676425457,
-0.03173500671982765,
0.006895881611853838,
-0.006636743899434805,
0.05926409736275673,
-0.031323108822107315,
0.005311076529324055,
0.026978928595781326,
0.03629519045352936,
0.023418914526700974,
-0.004314763005822897,
0.021335219964385033,
-0.02176007442176342,
-0.03441675007343292,
-0.05969221517443657,
0.04536205530166626,
-0.02545969747006893,
-0.04141909256577492,
0.02332558110356331,
0.04502693563699722,
0.02693973295390606,
0.003100424539297819,
0.012500018812716007,
0.029973704367876053,
0.003687006188556552,
0.009395632892847061,
-0.009852753952145576,
-0.01941561885178089,
0.03196638822555542,
0.006512566935271025,
-0.10963892936706543,
-0.04382995888590813,
-0.034387219697237015,
0.002714155474677682,
-0.01174946129322052,
0.015719445422291756,
-0.03569863364100456,
-0.03972332552075386,
0.0007784247281961143,
-0.03436275199055672,
-0.08484789729118347,
0.026485882699489594,
0.014976663514971733,
0.020433319732546806,
-0.02029659040272236,
-0.0018899638671427965,
0.06762629002332687,
0.04705970734357834,
0.014807150699198246,
0.04576611891388893,
-0.025775544345378876,
0.008337489329278469,
0.014445933513343334,
0.04767804965376854,
-0.033802058547735214,
-0.016134951263666153,
0.029669519513845444,
0.028250940144062042,
-0.00717932777479291,
0.024117110297083855,
-0.004819758236408234,
-0.0015689559513702989,
0.015081205405294895,
-0.021762581542134285,
0.03472660109400749,
-0.005825394298881292,
0.01687828078866005,
-0.011800370179116726,
0.04057219251990318,
-0.011307230219244957,
0.07067501544952393,
-0.00048708822578191757,
0.011774144135415554,
-0.018205979838967323,
-0.07200311124324799,
-0.000004071603143529501,
0.03169737011194229,
-0.018099253997206688,
-0.006207160651683807,
-0.07830677926540375,
0.021970391273498535,
0.07442405819892883,
0.03189295157790184,
0.012132294476032257,
0.014644766226410866,
0.006724464241415262,
0.01587858982384205,
0.0019694131333380938,
-0.00872758962213993,
0.026969319209456444,
-0.038282472640275955,
-0.0396566204726696,
0.02143360674381256,
-0.003601823002099991,
0.0007875252049416304,
0.04801364243030548,
-0.03857274353504181,
-0.0521618016064167,
0.033988650888204575,
-0.013504265807569027,
-0.04012100026011467,
0.01845100335776806,
0.06550921499729156,
0.02241559326648712,
0.019761791452765465,
0.013364211656153202,
-0.07728788256645203,
0.027739280834794044,
0.01791904680430889,
-0.010916642844676971,
0.02442755736410618,
-0.027140548452734947,
0.10233896225690842,
-0.028179116547107697,
-0.02702796272933483,
0.002520587993785739,
-0.06681671738624573,
-0.009452645666897297,
0.03755011036992073,
-0.03263029456138611,
0.04306517541408539,
-0.007810279726982117,
-0.0005847079446539283,
0.027736350893974304,
0.03163035586476326,
0.06506042182445526,
0.052788518369197845,
-0.00826436560600996,
0.04377962276339531,
-0.02020997926592827,
-0.019730111584067345,
0.019222702831029892,
0.038430675864219666,
-0.057479534298181534,
-0.050715237855911255,
0.024399980902671814,
-0.002502636518329382,
-0.028025612235069275,
0.0034585772082209587,
0.04394398257136345,
0.05464544892311096,
0.008284674026072025,
-0.009974488988518715,
-0.010687051340937614,
0.007445815019309521,
-0.04934012144804001,
0.042457398027181625,
0.037545621395111084,
-0.04142986983060837,
-0.009578114375472069,
-0.03370773792266846,
0.0841672345995903,
0.07018724828958511,
-0.04681997001171112,
-0.028535952791571617,
-0.013215448707342148,
0.02274349331855774,
-0.0009134759893640876,
-0.006323622073978186,
-0.013904165476560593,
-0.0034530756529420614,
-0.06089466065168381,
-0.005469463299959898,
-0.024030858650803566,
0.046581827104091644,
-0.02887089177966118,
-0.01063097920268774,
0.05327539145946503,
-0.007348757702857256,
0.05201339349150658,
0.0039814310148358345,
0.006339365150779486,
0.03308640420436859,
-0.016752636060118675,
0.00419375766068697,
-0.02550349198281765,
-0.01357846986502409,
0.004186888225376606,
-0.0039733354933559895,
-0.02269081398844719,
-0.004286888055503368,
-0.030705304816365242,
-0.051806095987558365,
-0.049311086535453796,
0.048994872719049454,
0.04416891187429428,
0.03004048764705658,
0.07951048761606216,
0.008943485096096992,
-0.007362668868154287,
-0.008993568830192089,
-0.09352190047502518,
-0.04409187659621239,
-0.030079413205385208,
0.05052684247493744,
0.038051359355449677,
0.05332908406853676,
0.025744030252099037,
0.014934010803699493,
-0.022845426574349403,
-0.01298729982227087,
0.02539798431098461,
0.0341394878923893,
0.016188975423574448,
-0.03276248648762703,
-0.025290006771683693,
-0.009900079108774662,
0.07024087756872177,
0.0037509461399167776,
-0.016618896275758743,
-0.047373395413160324,
-0.024295823648571968,
-0.02573041059076786,
-0.057996466755867004,
-0.021947761997580528,
-0.011335688643157482,
0.00473023671656847,
0.03428247198462486,
0.011903413571417332,
0.00010168687003897503,
0.010056574828922749,
0.05886472389101982,
0.028336413204669952,
-0.012501907534897327,
-0.028993090614676476,
0.0461164265871048,
-0.017995469272136688,
0.020596971735358238,
0.027985811233520508,
-0.013048773631453514,
-0.022366788238286972,
0.014144458808004856,
0.019575348123908043,
0.007949425838887691,
-0.2796059846878052,
-0.01296919584274292,
0.00016508916451130062,
-0.013994134962558746,
0.024351805448532104,
-0.043426480144262314,
0.03666684404015541,
-0.03880760818719864,
-0.030942847952246666,
0.03062509186565876,
0.03785587474703789,
0.02632511593401432,
0.005500624421983957,
0.02815079502761364,
0.04068528488278389,
0.04380151629447937,
0.0192888006567955,
-0.03905803710222244,
0.035262834280729294,
0.04920445382595062,
-0.031231701374053955,
-0.07863705605268478,
-0.007870668545365334,
0.07577957957983017,
-0.015751566737890244,
0.08213376253843307,
-0.08075099438428879,
0.011343300342559814,
-0.02347848191857338,
0.004822388291358948,
-0.006538098677992821,
-0.026627998799085617,
-0.005810888949781656,
0.038598936051130295,
-0.003418196691200137,
-0.015435141511261463,
0.06006689369678497,
-0.010612845420837402,
0.015924638137221336,
-0.01932050846517086,
0.012801909819245338,
-0.024657124653458595,
-0.035153016448020935,
0.018952444195747375,
0.06388194859027863,
-0.001338120549917221,
-0.08906509727239609,
-0.015833212062716484,
0.0071525271050632,
0.034489113837480545,
-0.02510550059378147,
-0.022283341735601425,
-0.024827836081385612,
0.03682221099734306,
-0.006580169778317213,
-0.0352495014667511,
0.021932357922196388,
-0.005032760091125965,
-0.01627637818455696,
0.009389027953147888,
-0.011246368288993835,
-0.055025819689035416,
-0.04362750053405762,
-0.04323684796690941,
-0.024441367015242577,
-0.011442265473306179,
-0.03403814509510994,
-0.05551346018910408,
0.045377880334854126,
0.01659328117966652,
-0.013319633901119232,
0.024582065641880035,
-0.02956927940249443,
-0.09715466946363449,
0.03801294416189194,
0.009664222598075867,
-0.0014302544295787811,
-0.028402220457792282,
-0.009608209133148193,
0.052743930369615555,
0.0016923529328778386,
-0.0700269490480423,
0.03297397866845131,
-0.014605516567826271,
-0.0055158925242722034,
-0.0234113410115242,
-0.002508543897420168,
-0.0045584337785840034,
0.007499404717236757,
-0.03439071774482727,
0.07366372644901276,
0.010579834692180157,
0.016962094232439995,
0.026853438466787338,
0.036159079521894455,
0.004658383317291737,
0.0479176826775074,
0.03141547739505768,
0.02803049422800541,
0.013080534525215626,
0.03570191562175751,
-0.06401382386684418,
-0.015638835728168488,
-0.017531434074044228,
-0.004337407648563385,
0.02014705166220665,
-0.04706507548689842,
-0.0029167593456804752,
0.05322393402457237,
-0.019948609173297882,
-0.036853279918432236,
-0.018780333921313286,
0.015731174498796463,
0.02192978374660015,
-0.022524569183588028,
-0.02185852825641632,
0.026193931698799133,
-0.004205087199807167,
0.03205481916666031,
-0.03850641846656799,
-0.03484189137816429,
0.01959672011435032,
-0.035118065774440765,
0.009370459243655205,
-0.006791181396692991,
-0.015201344154775143,
-0.003752673976123333,
0.0024428071919828653,
-0.05740247666835785,
0.014492223039269447,
0.024821579456329346,
0.02562226913869381,
0.005892383400350809,
0.023832321166992188,
0.053230252116918564,
-0.013563857413828373,
-0.003021581331267953,
-0.011106420308351517,
0.04332175850868225,
-0.023246057331562042,
0.015140481293201447,
-0.018302302807569504,
0.03879532217979431,
0.05494115501642227,
0.048413220793008804,
0.0133632468059659,
0.02179577760398388,
-0.017867933958768845,
-0.01577085442841053,
0.0037301117554306984,
0.05438931658864021,
-0.04813087731599808,
-0.01065867394208908,
-0.034183159470558167,
0.012635860592126846,
-0.023839130997657776,
-0.010800552554428577,
-0.028725415468215942,
0.04503747075796127,
-0.06351812183856964,
0.055153075605630875,
0.007290152367204428,
-0.029647111892700195,
0.0077522797510027885,
0.012004373595118523,
0.022783931344747543,
0.022536320611834526,
-0.02145746909081936,
0.020970681682229042,
0.023362813517451286,
0.02562674507498741,
-0.06266697496175766,
-0.025993268936872482,
-0.01407025195658207,
-0.020543484017252922,
0.011979794129729271,
0.012798890471458435,
-0.009345214813947678,
-0.024582117795944214,
0.03793395683169365,
0.006160539574921131,
0.007202253211289644,
-0.0017514053033664823,
0.0076952772215008736,
0.06514700502157211,
0.019773252308368683,
0.01455333549529314,
-0.025702649727463722,
-0.03199243173003197,
0.01272538397461176,
-0.008826044388115406,
0.017892537638545036,
0.008020272478461266,
-0.009278899058699608,
-0.06171291321516037,
-0.04447009414434433,
0.0010324408067390323,
0.01145867258310318,
0.018343675881624222,
-0.017093999311327934,
-0.025617903098464012,
0.007638349663466215,
-0.01852569729089737,
-0.010814580135047436,
0.011457646265625954,
-0.06814241409301758,
-0.0006400560378096998,
0.044497452676296234,
-0.05330120399594307,
-0.018157944083213806,
-0.03823887184262276,
-0.0031745978631079197,
-0.055384743958711624,
-0.025619778782129288,
-0.010496982373297215,
-0.04532652720808983,
-0.04043076932430267,
-0.00462316581979394,
0.010840012691915035,
-0.01630929857492447,
-0.002226410200819373,
0.0007381460745818913,
-0.02156011573970318,
-0.0009034349350258708,
-0.013938874937593937,
0.048166319727897644,
-0.02065890282392502,
0.0021179369650781155,
0.03589398041367531,
-0.029149888083338737,
0.01762089878320694,
-0.049068693071603775,
0.02239076793193817,
0.08310060203075409,
-0.008088618516921997,
0.03240719437599182,
-0.05589026212692261,
0.04713289439678192,
0.029877919703722,
0.006266002543270588,
0.011622263118624687,
0.022700339555740356,
-0.055059388279914856,
0.019029520452022552,
0.021350368857383728,
0.03766772150993347,
-0.008634218946099281,
-0.031122514978051186,
0.0005137548432685435,
0.007505001500248909,
0.005594796501100063,
0.005643007345497608,
-0.006501418072730303,
-0.006575882900506258,
0.05513017997145653,
-0.02084408327937126,
-0.021375520154833794,
-0.056535035371780396,
-0.047820426523685455,
0.01920943707227707,
-0.005928051192313433,
0.024560635909438133,
-0.0317060761153698,
0.07217229157686234,
0.03281974792480469,
0.049737803637981415,
0.0010715587995946407,
-0.009310975670814514,
0.022845273837447166,
-0.03500625863671303,
0.025531094521284103,
-0.05219124257564545,
-0.03577454388141632,
0.06493477523326874,
-0.020329823717474937,
0.010383030399680138,
-0.03721100091934204,
-0.0516497977077961,
0.024693099781870842,
-0.03200871869921684,
-0.06128603592514992,
-0.007764281705021858,
-0.029508166015148163,
-0.03264869749546051,
0.016357379034161568,
-0.049419648945331573,
0.024928754195570946,
-0.014919002540409565,
-0.032118864357471466,
-0.0014455962227657437,
-0.022217513993382454,
0.045483268797397614,
-0.019757302477955818,
0.013016227632761002,
-0.025125928223133087,
0.00017528492026031017,
0.019699782133102417,
0.07480361312627792,
0.002472393913194537,
0.003601027885451913,
-0.007609945256263018,
0.08689820766448975,
0.0351809561252594,
-0.0316062830388546,
0.011799351312220097,
0.01304520945996046,
-0.01979895494878292,
-0.04024534299969673,
0.05002116039395332,
0.0010653685312718153,
-0.048920173197984695,
-0.056661613285541534,
0.07041491568088531,
0.03342070430517197,
-0.039554692804813385,
-0.04169624298810959,
0.03960174322128296,
-0.045076191425323486,
-0.014861754141747952,
-0.034752488136291504,
0.004615179728716612,
-0.01287356112152338,
0.047901686280965805,
0.0020820137578994036,
0.012663870118558407,
0.06183174252510071,
0.005516375415027142,
-0.0026032403111457825,
0.04274755343794823,
0.06359473615884781,
0.05955827236175537,
0.0820043757557869,
0.011774182319641113,
0.08311387896537781,
-0.04271389916539192,
-0.04087599739432335,
0.016540396958589554,
-0.024425094947218895,
0.010691394098103046,
-0.033471547067165375,
0.02509758621454239,
0.08949421346187592,
0.023156318813562393,
0.04768102988600731,
-0.03986833617091179,
-0.012162195518612862,
0.03730091452598572,
0.016384482383728027,
-0.004872860852628946,
0.01184865366667509,
0.021248886361718178,
-0.031988371163606644,
-0.014507723040878773,
0.0002537823747843504,
0.00871854368597269,
-0.049565788358449936,
0.01928219012916088,
0.0002570004726294428,
-0.024985793977975845,
0.0002953073417302221,
-0.06578714400529861,
0.0492381788790226,
0.12980397045612335,
-0.04282427579164505,
-0.04226801171898842,
-0.0060414462350308895,
0.01815933734178543,
0.03815728425979614,
0.059019118547439575,
-0.008904888294637203,
-0.0424589104950428,
0.02365824766457081,
-0.038573917001485825,
0.017941901460289955,
0.030841857194900513,
-0.018265925347805023,
0.014140424318611622,
-0.04735792428255081,
-0.03796736150979996,
0.02991379238665104,
0.0042593530379235744,
-0.03513200208544731,
-0.029236897826194763,
-0.03348970413208008,
-0.04946279153227806,
-0.04342601075768471,
-0.04824250191450119,
0.023897238075733185,
0.017614606767892838,
-0.03663511574268341,
-0.0378824844956398,
-0.011737282387912273,
-0.012854342348873615,
0.019772080704569817,
-0.06752335280179977,
0.0013081840006634593,
0.021590495482087135,
-0.004383944906294346,
-0.016297629103064537,
0.01381461601704359,
0.0116729149594903,
-0.024474328383803368,
-0.007512870244681835,
0.041210245341062546,
-0.007377740927040577,
0.024251943454146385,
-0.0022141162771731615,
-0.000979123986326158,
-0.10677919536828995,
0.009428373537957668,
0.0054811155423521996,
-0.037489525973796844,
-0.06375803798437119,
0.0016393890837207437,
0.0016233110800385475,
0.03097529709339142,
0.06758692115545273,
-0.007773159071803093,
0.02913293056190014,
-0.020785829052329063,
-0.015217071399092674,
-0.03604716807603836,
0.03752366080880165,
0.06096561253070831,
-0.008844518102705479,
0.06829981505870819,
0.04107382521033287,
0.014069359749555588,
-0.004192035179585218,
-0.01210889220237732,
-0.005963608622550964,
0.0030254372395575047,
-0.03141498565673828,
-0.022339094430208206,
-0.02694113180041313,
-0.08038395643234253,
-0.008589321747422218,
0.03808597847819328,
-0.0073128631338477135,
-0.05552059784531593,
-0.0298500657081604,
-0.0396711565554142,
-0.03280055895447731,
0.0022041399497538805,
0.03209926560521126,
-0.020270632579922676,
-0.01914035901427269,
-0.04364724084734917,
-0.052675019949674606,
0.029982754960656166,
-0.010472540743649006,
-0.005025137215852737,
-0.021231623366475105,
-0.03939720615744591,
-0.0030484956223517656,
0.00859946757555008,
0.025932176038622856,
0.007801320869475603,
0.03664001449942589,
-0.017026731744408607
] |
358 |
DynaMath: A Dynamic Visual Benchmark for Evaluating Mathematical Reasoning Robustness of Vision Language Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=VOAMTA8jKu
|
[
"Chengke Zou",
"Xingang Guo",
"Rui Yang",
"Junyu Zhang",
"Bin Hu",
"Huan Zhang"
] |
Poster
|
The rapid advancements in Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have shown great potential in tackling mathematical reasoning tasks that involve visual context. Unlike humans who can reliably apply solution steps to similar problems with minor modifications, we found that state-of-the-art VLMs like GPT-4o can consistently fail in these scenarios, revealing limitations in their mathematical reasoning capabilities. In this paper, we investigate the **mathematical reasoning robustness** in VLMs and evaluate how well these models perform under different variants of the same question, such as changes in visual numerical values or function graphs.
While several vision-based math benchmarks have been developed to assess VLMs' problem-solving capabilities, these benchmarks contain only static sets of problems and cannot easily evaluate mathematical reasoning robustness.
To fill this gap, we introduce **DynaMath**, a dynamic visual math benchmark designed for in-depth assessment of VLMs. **DynaMath** includes 501 high-quality, multi-topic *seed* questions, *each represented as a Python program*. Those programs are carefully designed and annotated to enable the automatic generation of a much larger set of *concrete* questions, including many different types of visual and textual variations.
**DynaMath** allows us to evaluate the generalization ability of VLMs, by assessing their performance under varying input conditions of a seed question. We evaluated 14 state-of-the-art VLMs with 5,010 generated concrete questions (10 per seed question). Our results show that the worst-case model accuracy, defined as the percentage of correctly answered seed questions in all 10 variants, is significantly lower than the average-case accuracy. In addition, many models show high consistency in answering these questions -- the incorrectness of a certain variant of a seed question is not only due to inherent randomness. Our analysis emphasizes the need to study the robustness of VLMs' reasoning abilities, and **DynaMath** provides valuable insights to guide the development of more reliable models for mathematical reasoning.
|
Visual Mathematical Benchmark, Vision Language Models
|
We introduce DYNAMATH, a dynamic visual math benchmark designed for an in-depth assessment of the reasoning robustness of VLMs.
| 13,293 |
2411.00836
|
[
0.0005754237645305693,
0.023560965433716774,
-0.0010315824765712023,
0.0546417161822319,
0.036386795341968536,
0.031435538083314896,
0.007466295268386602,
0.01154468022286892,
-0.04128675535321236,
-0.013448536396026611,
0.002987862331792712,
0.034931447356939316,
-0.06165789067745209,
0.009610696695744991,
0.009087550453841686,
0.07687743008136749,
0.052094314247369766,
0.012025535106658936,
0.0024509562645107508,
0.006516036577522755,
-0.005725794937461615,
-0.03495241701602936,
0.008881287649273872,
0.004029803443700075,
0.00707594770938158,
0.011360150761902332,
0.054722387343645096,
0.0007622113334946334,
-0.0305817611515522,
-0.01253456249833107,
0.024254068732261658,
-0.023057881742715836,
0.014353500679135323,
-0.019642112776637077,
0.009535502642393112,
-0.0017821447690948844,
-0.04027484729886055,
0.025499116629362106,
0.025031596422195435,
0.009470406919717789,
-0.020403143018484116,
0.031029384583234787,
-0.017771942541003227,
-0.018110882490873337,
-0.07536354660987854,
0.0019087162800133228,
-0.08709597587585449,
0.05015762522816658,
0.006863108836114407,
-0.013833591714501381,
-0.1254151612520218,
0.038415078073740005,
-0.015380307100713253,
-0.006351238116621971,
-0.00707575399428606,
0.03937537595629692,
0.05053180083632469,
-0.10243277251720428,
0.0013011775445193052,
-0.07298552244901657,
-0.02303176559507847,
0.026465823873877525,
0.017983241006731987,
0.01010156236588955,
-0.002764865756034851,
-0.021104445680975914,
-0.007973053492605686,
0.038500089198350906,
-0.05425387620925903,
-0.02491234801709652,
0.0062283179722726345,
-0.008179833181202412,
-0.0007047410472296178,
-0.018287822604179382,
-0.021082710474729538,
-0.05333707481622696,
0.02125992439687252,
0.02320423722267151,
0.05848168954253197,
-0.044151268899440765,
0.008862962946295738,
0.028370635583996773,
0.01237474288791418,
0.037012919783592224,
0.018890157341957092,
0.018612079322338104,
-0.023093469440937042,
-0.02753806859254837,
-0.08634858578443527,
0.03454646095633507,
0.0028544121887534857,
-0.04924725368618965,
0.02947353757917881,
0.03614667057991028,
0.046356201171875,
0.02112436108291149,
0.015518269501626492,
0.026716722175478935,
0.012047983705997467,
0.021237989887595177,
-0.008562961593270302,
-0.06614166498184204,
0.04381088539958,
-0.005908485036343336,
-0.11376289278268814,
-0.018282316625118256,
-0.021598758175969124,
-0.012675587087869644,
-0.003844605293124914,
0.03313291445374489,
-0.04861462116241455,
0.031324129551649094,
0.025272013619542122,
-0.027879223227500916,
-0.09140268713235855,
0.03957980498671532,
0.011162831448018551,
0.03826029598712921,
-0.02065986767411232,
0.03395345062017441,
0.06144379824399948,
0.016633331775665283,
0.004429041873663664,
0.06342203170061111,
-0.002338443649932742,
0.029810728505253792,
0.008282802999019623,
0.0338425487279892,
-0.033918630331754684,
0.012787551619112492,
0.022690074518322945,
0.035202980041503906,
0.02693934366106987,
0.0066467151045799255,
0.007038803771138191,
-0.0009787539020180702,
0.00530443899333477,
-0.017566557973623276,
0.017774395644664764,
0.006011460442095995,
0.028233937919139862,
-0.011816448532044888,
0.060765545815229416,
-0.028376812115311623,
0.05070072412490845,
0.017806461080908775,
0.02678370103240013,
0.005208131857216358,
-0.02485605701804161,
-0.012622611597180367,
-0.008896376006305218,
-0.005369576625525951,
-0.002460184507071972,
-0.08783677220344543,
0.04171651229262352,
0.05514286458492279,
0.035649072378873825,
0.005945350509136915,
0.016485437750816345,
0.0035507373977452517,
-0.005187442526221275,
-0.009004989638924599,
-0.0396186001598835,
0.022089695557951927,
-0.016278820112347603,
-0.039956118911504745,
0.034211210906505585,
0.024419067427515984,
-0.05342710018157959,
0.010669897310435772,
-0.0611996166408062,
-0.07246315479278564,
0.056416768580675125,
-0.007805583067238331,
-0.0018169600516557693,
0.0031752169597893953,
0.056439585983753204,
-0.007009013555943966,
0.03809858486056328,
0.008608677424490452,
-0.07933879643678665,
0.020112983882427216,
-0.015160927549004555,
-0.001024529105052352,
0.007066173944622278,
-0.03747823089361191,
0.10163719207048416,
-0.05799165368080139,
0.003921762574464083,
-0.007510062772780657,
-0.07563600689172745,
-0.008435503579676151,
0.02066446840763092,
-0.003713158657774329,
0.0545058436691761,
-0.0021968865767121315,
-0.016682399436831474,
0.016684025526046753,
0.021898359060287476,
0.06529398262500763,
0.05819365009665489,
-0.006971768569201231,
0.051965463906526566,
-0.016793590039014816,
-0.030429091304540634,
0.004465156700462103,
0.06860264390707016,
-0.050641514360904694,
-0.053866758942604065,
0.013181662186980247,
-0.012033148668706417,
-0.0029232180677354336,
-0.001619917806237936,
0.00015915697440505028,
0.02602882869541645,
0.023919856175780296,
-0.0017800373025238514,
-0.0037556274328380823,
0.00435071112588048,
-0.037069063633680344,
0.03134594485163689,
0.0035629253834486008,
-0.019014643505215645,
-0.027652261778712273,
-0.035043053328990936,
0.08233541250228882,
0.0676552876830101,
-0.02109980396926403,
-0.04068206995725632,
0.03172491863369942,
-0.018141023814678192,
0.028360217809677124,
0.00027079976280219853,
-0.04794522002339363,
-0.02180127054452896,
-0.03871719911694527,
0.023705830797553062,
-0.003934613894671202,
0.08202647417783737,
-0.02652314305305481,
0.003831756766885519,
0.0550040528178215,
0.0030369674786925316,
0.05386768653988838,
0.00627677608281374,
0.0054485308937728405,
0.04486988112330437,
0.016339242458343506,
-0.004498980939388275,
-0.01271669939160347,
-0.025395318865776062,
0.009779264219105244,
-0.0038602235727012157,
-0.026490943506360054,
-0.004384716972708702,
-0.04851425811648369,
-0.015895873308181763,
-0.022873587906360626,
0.07403134554624557,
0.044411465525627136,
0.029391521587967873,
0.02423681877553463,
0.03658398240804672,
-0.032908517867326736,
-0.005059145390987396,
-0.10900547355413437,
-0.04431081935763359,
0.00978404562920332,
0.02741669863462448,
0.01798185333609581,
0.041501596570014954,
0.0053056515753269196,
0.018008576706051826,
-0.015062235295772552,
-0.02414933778345585,
-0.0026165887247771025,
0.01240717526525259,
-0.017760712653398514,
-0.07026664912700653,
-0.026191767305135727,
0.01966204307973385,
0.07572763413190842,
-0.0386393703520298,
-0.010287717916071415,
-0.003020787611603737,
-0.00883579719811678,
0.003723644884303212,
-0.0466928705573082,
0.009663298726081848,
0.009992786683142185,
0.016159523278474808,
0.0112984674051404,
-0.03369411453604698,
0.015322588384151459,
0.03825969621539116,
0.06189176067709923,
0.03734254464507103,
-0.027543984353542328,
-0.02927379123866558,
0.02161652036011219,
0.010513774119317532,
0.022171368822455406,
-0.011924270540475845,
0.03166903555393219,
-0.026022743433713913,
0.007362713105976582,
-0.01906657963991165,
-0.008034522645175457,
-0.2738630473613739,
-0.013167038559913635,
-0.002130336593836546,
0.003351026214659214,
0.04082472622394562,
-0.017159685492515564,
0.05745028704404831,
-0.01748933270573616,
-0.033372100442647934,
-0.0014153746888041496,
0.04676966741681099,
-0.0040871803648769855,
-0.023686440661549568,
0.08371153473854065,
0.05607966333627701,
0.013372003100812435,
0.00994274765253067,
-0.0463431142270565,
0.015666181221604347,
0.031292837113142014,
-0.01098049245774746,
-0.08847848325967789,
-0.0039942506700754166,
0.06797485053539276,
-0.014063737355172634,
0.061559706926345825,
-0.08823185414075851,
-0.011085242964327335,
-0.0385751947760582,
0.008713447488844395,
-0.01186255645006895,
-0.021734224632382393,
-0.03197674825787544,
0.04930421710014343,
0.017233606427907944,
0.023464255034923553,
0.05451282486319542,
-0.036994948983192444,
0.052800919860601425,
0.029790500178933144,
0.019955763593316078,
-0.020885925740003586,
-0.02598339132964611,
0.015346006490290165,
0.07041802257299423,
-0.003457932732999325,
-0.046599820256233215,
-0.029911059886217117,
-0.015260874293744564,
0.025376854464411736,
-0.022992370650172234,
-0.015316233970224857,
-0.03534203767776489,
0.0036327471025288105,
-0.02262619324028492,
-0.03662794828414917,
-0.009000962600111961,
-0.010971336625516415,
-0.008211735635995865,
0.014797738753259182,
-0.006634809076786041,
-0.01305787917226553,
-0.022439396008849144,
-0.018868908286094666,
-0.021898072212934494,
-0.04654889926314354,
-0.05293525755405426,
-0.058546487241983414,
0.03246382623910904,
0.01930498331785202,
-0.017519906163215637,
-0.016004757955670357,
-0.04566773399710655,
-0.09373236447572708,
0.003946148790419102,
0.006315887905657291,
-0.0008565958123654127,
-0.04328051581978798,
0.004383304622024298,
0.03543425351381302,
-0.025348899886012077,
-0.05985752493143082,
-0.00042367129935882986,
0.009951026178896427,
0.012726168148219585,
-0.03587401285767555,
-0.01893826201558113,
-0.042596619576215744,
0.01794939674437046,
-0.025710929185152054,
0.06374942511320114,
-0.014168101362884045,
0.033783018589019775,
-0.00602897210046649,
0.053554024547338486,
0.021500350907444954,
0.04891810193657875,
0.04492606595158577,
0.03978773206472397,
0.028582323342561722,
-0.002377019729465246,
-0.08366155624389648,
0.0035092723555862904,
-0.029828108847141266,
-0.0455503836274147,
-0.0009397640824317932,
-0.041278451681137085,
0.0008183687459677458,
0.033532943576574326,
-0.03026118315756321,
-0.052567776292562485,
-0.027541080489754677,
0.013987117446959019,
-0.0014003212563693523,
-0.01706530712544918,
0.0001457611215300858,
0.02320037968456745,
0.01434354204684496,
0.014180231839418411,
-0.015674009919166565,
-0.05002970993518829,
0.009548748843371868,
-0.0379677414894104,
0.0031902939081192017,
-0.028353845700621605,
-0.00210255803540349,
-0.020754318684339523,
-0.016364727169275284,
-0.012659848667681217,
0.009144783951342106,
-0.004262625705450773,
0.041442472487688065,
-0.012741143815219402,
0.04210442677140236,
0.05999069660902023,
-0.022758278995752335,
-0.013539323583245277,
-0.014266816899180412,
0.015349521301686764,
-0.0325438529253006,
0.03137233853340149,
-0.0013559182407334447,
0.024432890117168427,
0.027497490867972374,
0.041590020060539246,
-0.014211061410605907,
0.018231811001896858,
0.0013421159237623215,
0.00017680865130387247,
0.0011544986627995968,
0.04654140770435333,
-0.08280546963214874,
0.0006129227112978697,
-0.03817281499505043,
-0.0020231720991432667,
-0.025044137611985207,
0.006291423458606005,
-0.007801113650202751,
-0.00013415909779723734,
-0.0545254722237587,
0.042897313833236694,
0.03207095339894295,
-0.02423379383981228,
-0.014278755523264408,
0.025443745777010918,
0.04111035168170929,
0.02480926178395748,
0.007364232093095779,
0.012282762676477432,
0.009549127891659737,
0.0075161955319345,
-0.023873796686530113,
-0.02790599875152111,
-0.010665788315236568,
-0.016500702127814293,
0.030805381014943123,
0.021472379565238953,
-0.033219464123249054,
-0.04811537638306618,
0.035930413752794266,
-0.006936873774975538,
-0.046335842460393906,
-0.011281793937087059,
0.005975391250103712,
0.06887595355510712,
0.010199927724897861,
-0.001299852505326271,
-0.02492331899702549,
-0.054423607885837555,
0.04304524138569832,
-0.009914347901940346,
0.009328593499958515,
-0.00962695013731718,
-0.025303220376372337,
-0.0623374879360199,
-0.06413353979587555,
0.010407705791294575,
0.012009003199636936,
0.007854191586375237,
-0.022620536386966705,
-0.004141945391893387,
0.04278436675667763,
-0.049663688987493515,
0.0005472589400596917,
0.029816312715411186,
-0.07062751054763794,
-0.004790924023836851,
0.029194887727499008,
0.011950223706662655,
0.014510040171444416,
-0.03771546855568886,
-0.020753173157572746,
-0.039097052067518234,
-0.04641270264983177,
-0.004404320381581783,
-0.0018663578666746616,
-0.014222586527466774,
-0.005760597065091133,
-0.010043902322649956,
-0.03639663755893707,
0.018659792840480804,
0.005784778390079737,
-0.006155455484986305,
0.0009092952823266387,
0.002650453010573983,
0.029116962105035782,
-0.00662637734785676,
-0.008603675290942192,
-0.0030603252816945314,
-0.022789521142840385,
0.020480159670114517,
-0.05059752240777016,
-0.005770318675786257,
0.03939862176775932,
-0.005517740733921528,
-0.008795006200671196,
-0.055049654096364975,
0.017425723373889923,
-0.012891405262053013,
-0.015670889988541603,
-0.009205160662531853,
-0.0013118869392201304,
-0.022926315665245056,
0.023754576221108437,
0.002536592772230506,
0.037450164556503296,
0.04474063590168953,
-0.015054984018206596,
0.03268643841147423,
-0.0002774643653538078,
0.011582110077142715,
0.01425221934914589,
-0.040012966841459274,
-0.018096430227160454,
0.038758859038352966,
-0.02450511045753956,
-0.0013878055615350604,
-0.07334060966968536,
-0.02888406813144684,
0.010918887332081795,
-0.02612878940999508,
0.019003544002771378,
-0.03905005007982254,
0.06188680976629257,
-0.005551520735025406,
0.045336879789829254,
0.025939002633094788,
-0.029360739514231682,
0.06351437419652939,
-0.05216769874095917,
0.015273204073309898,
-0.0642220750451088,
-0.019100001081824303,
0.06630927324295044,
-0.01572459563612938,
0.0004682927392423153,
-0.004151131957769394,
-0.045502059161663055,
0.048999518156051636,
-0.016213491559028625,
-0.03618541732430458,
0.009003300219774246,
-0.015649521723389626,
-0.010902420617640018,
-0.0046518598683178425,
-0.026328478008508682,
0.006433222442865372,
-0.0038053770549595356,
-0.03068588301539421,
0.024557026103138924,
-0.017311424016952515,
0.04799169301986694,
-0.032440606504678726,
0.03208542615175247,
-0.03557500243186951,
0.014056773856282234,
0.03431486338376999,
0.05306746065616608,
0.016049815341830254,
0.024443067610263824,
-0.0100672896951437,
0.09846249222755432,
0.048832111060619354,
0.015722619369626045,
0.013049540109932423,
0.01981452852487564,
-0.01399905327707529,
-0.052715569734573364,
0.06468429416418076,
0.01558547280728817,
-0.037509821355342865,
-0.07284418493509293,
0.07646825909614563,
0.02417256124317646,
-0.014503221027553082,
-0.010135366581380367,
0.034620098769664764,
-0.03449507802724838,
0.009453161619603634,
-0.0289935190230608,
-0.005152264144271612,
-0.01021689921617508,
0.04397532343864441,
-0.008210480213165283,
0.03767034038901329,
0.06930606812238693,
0.022769873961806297,
-0.006737047806382179,
0.025312427431344986,
0.06246418505907059,
0.05574492737650871,
0.05093589052557945,
-0.013651545159518719,
0.07634851336479187,
-0.049742378294467926,
-0.042248159646987915,
0.013283010572195053,
0.021016057580709457,
-0.01281045563519001,
-0.04499175399541855,
0.0352478064596653,
0.07757063955068588,
0.006028805859386921,
0.03682319074869156,
-0.03505273163318634,
-0.003566950326785445,
0.02956797182559967,
0.02618592232465744,
-0.006207125727087259,
0.04469011351466179,
0.03599771484732628,
0.0155597273260355,
-0.02518882043659687,
-0.009733024053275585,
-0.008772984147071838,
-0.030521003529429436,
-0.013011094182729721,
-0.004739182535558939,
-0.018179547041654587,
0.01586148887872696,
-0.02454398386180401,
0.044621799141168594,
0.12326912581920624,
-0.03874778375029564,
-0.04411802440881729,
0.041245486587285995,
0.025227630510926247,
0.02992972545325756,
0.026605412364006042,
-0.0022789286449551582,
-0.010493094101548195,
-0.009130358695983887,
-0.036493800580501556,
0.021338706836104393,
0.035823408514261246,
-0.018604861572384834,
0.027874905616044998,
-0.04835594817996025,
-0.049050964415073395,
0.03983696550130844,
0.007170986384153366,
-0.04281114041805267,
-0.03357559069991112,
-0.014432717114686966,
-0.0509209968149662,
-0.060935523360967636,
-0.014384754002094269,
0.0456695556640625,
-0.02312084101140499,
-0.038522522896528244,
-0.016535650938749313,
-0.008187823928892612,
0.004699793178588152,
0.036653392016887665,
-0.05576026067137718,
-0.014719092287123203,
0.022581396624445915,
0.01224384643137455,
-0.01013993564993143,
0.032600078731775284,
0.017004501074552536,
-0.05241696164011955,
-0.022074341773986816,
0.013314644806087017,
0.007242918945848942,
0.013748597353696823,
0.015850696712732315,
-0.01871507056057453,
-0.10805275291204453,
-0.016607575118541718,
0.025541720911860466,
-0.02220355160534382,
-0.07423640787601471,
0.02526824176311493,
-0.04335898533463478,
0.02608421817421913,
0.08870084583759308,
0.013225965201854706,
0.043641116470098495,
-0.040911611169576645,
-0.021991172805428505,
-0.00845207180827856,
0.02302779257297516,
0.06696964055299759,
-0.035125453025102615,
0.053787924349308014,
0.01650678925216198,
-0.03817296400666237,
-0.02601684257388115,
0.009114966727793217,
-0.013224408961832523,
0.011239896528422832,
-0.028040852397680283,
-0.019743317738175392,
-0.05903870239853859,
-0.1021827757358551,
-0.0016878170426934958,
0.02470564655959606,
-0.013417176902294159,
-0.04060380160808563,
-0.013652719557285309,
-0.003050263272598386,
-0.024622386321425438,
0.024002395570278168,
-0.010620230808854103,
-0.022119462490081787,
-0.04559091106057167,
-0.03029746748507023,
-0.046224676072597504,
0.01783035695552826,
-0.027135372161865234,
0.039409708231687546,
-0.02289576269686222,
-0.018511807546019554,
-0.012324100360274315,
0.011472737416625023,
0.013163432478904724,
0.0045264530926942825,
0.036892831325531006,
-0.0006523074698634446
] |
359 |
MetaDesigner: Advancing Artistic Typography through AI-Driven, User-Centric, and Multilingual WordArt Synthesis
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Mv3GAYJGcW
|
[
"Jun-Yan He",
"Zhi-Qi Cheng",
"Chenyang Li",
"Jingdong Sun",
"Qi He",
"Wangmeng Xiang",
"Hanyuan Chen",
"Jin-Peng Lan",
"Xianhui Lin",
"kang zhu",
"Bin Luo",
"Yifeng Geng",
"Xuansong Xie",
"Alexander G Hauptmann"
] |
Poster
|
MetaDesigner introduces a transformative framework for artistic typography synthesis, powered by Large Language Models (LLMs) and grounded in a user-centric design paradigm. Its foundation is a multi-agent system comprising the Pipeline, Glyph, and Texture agents, which collectively orchestrate the creation of customizable WordArt, ranging from semantic enhancements to intricate textural elements. A central feedback mechanism leverages insights from both multimodal models and user evaluations, enabling iterative refinement of design parameters. Through this iterative process, MetaDesigner dynamically adjusts hyperparameters to align with user-defined stylistic and thematic preferences, consistently delivering WordArt that excels in visual quality and contextual resonance. Empirical evaluations underscore the system's versatility and effectiveness across diverse WordArt applications, yielding outputs that are both aesthetically compelling and context-sensitive.
|
MetaDesigner
| null | 13,291 |
2406.19859
|
[
0.036813922226428986,
0.017014240846037865,
0.01263967715203762,
0.034284740686416626,
0.03266223147511482,
0.04760188236832619,
0.011068697087466717,
0.03319915756583214,
-0.02846333384513855,
-0.0482608862221241,
-0.02974318340420723,
0.019506165757775307,
-0.04821820184588432,
0.012007977813482285,
0.013877049088478088,
0.04066351056098938,
0.01666085608303547,
0.023967090994119644,
-0.02869831770658493,
-0.013604164123535156,
-0.00017891409515868872,
-0.03220187872648239,
0.026599857956171036,
0.021287601441144943,
0.01898602582514286,
0.013414410874247551,
0.03584422916173935,
0.020901160314679146,
-0.031924884766340256,
0.009916265495121479,
0.05708186328411102,
-0.01592029258608818,
0.022096462547779083,
-0.05803569406270981,
0.014115728437900543,
-0.01192599069327116,
-0.07121263444423676,
0.015569028444588184,
0.014927365817129612,
-0.014970554038882256,
-0.03848550096154213,
0.06108081713318825,
0.006860547699034214,
-0.02872350439429283,
-0.014669599942862988,
0.003937561064958572,
-0.10633369535207748,
0.03371720761060715,
-0.017293240875005722,
-0.0004432187997736037,
-0.08975617587566376,
0.010760243982076645,
0.019069641828536987,
0.005117296241223812,
-0.015389556996524334,
0.05039899796247482,
0.04371955990791321,
-0.05624852329492569,
-0.016904812306165695,
-0.04853879287838936,
-0.02090219222009182,
0.013984116725623608,
0.010283839888870716,
0.0006297825602814555,
0.006300665438175201,
-0.013890337198972702,
-0.020311396569013596,
0.023750685155391693,
-0.03831956163048744,
-0.022518916055560112,
-0.019519653171300888,
-0.01614595390856266,
0.024119950830936432,
-0.04039401933550835,
-0.04467117041349411,
-0.042005784809589386,
0.003268865402787924,
0.02812553383409977,
0.0637107864022255,
-0.000017266038412344642,
0.0005357887712307274,
0.02278953231871128,
0.007347790524363518,
0.04698077589273453,
-0.01741383783519268,
0.001002566539682448,
-0.016547251492738724,
0.016591979190707207,
-0.041003502905368805,
0.021295884624123573,
0.003797774901613593,
-0.07768343389034271,
0.038248784840106964,
0.028688177466392517,
0.055958133190870285,
0.004036515951156616,
-0.0019633297342807055,
0.04069552570581436,
-0.03403720259666443,
0.013000978156924248,
-0.016264917328953743,
-0.058145154267549515,
-0.02096005715429783,
0.030503584071993828,
-0.06013922393321991,
0.0028045244980603456,
-0.03536026552319527,
-0.03613158315420151,
0.015810979530215263,
0.022667692974209785,
-0.009128812700510025,
-0.011371161788702011,
0.029020028188824654,
-0.020018383860588074,
-0.051308006048202515,
0.05211731418967247,
0.03345727548003197,
0.04450644552707672,
-0.03508879989385605,
0.048527657985687256,
0.06714382022619247,
0.05571705847978592,
0.037053074687719345,
0.05243707820773125,
-0.03310316801071167,
-0.01098290178924799,
0.023019608110189438,
0.018115894868969917,
-0.03193634748458862,
-0.01999286189675331,
0.004646216053515673,
0.06471816450357437,
-0.018673483282327652,
-0.0006910345982760191,
-0.001211936236359179,
0.023676954209804535,
0.00809871219098568,
-0.007542608305811882,
0.01532068196684122,
0.016505766659975052,
-0.015124528668820858,
0.008851317688822746,
0.02394351176917553,
-0.06248382851481438,
0.04518096148967743,
-0.011338614858686924,
0.03494754061102867,
-0.04135569557547569,
-0.026002736762166023,
-0.007096066139638424,
0.030854230746626854,
-0.017854901030659676,
0.003920009359717369,
-0.018899081274867058,
0.03032885678112507,
0.04276645928621292,
0.04761363938450813,
0.03848141059279442,
0.0226594265550375,
-0.0025477115996181965,
-0.021687783300876617,
-0.013533458113670349,
-0.029524004086852074,
-0.008590803481638432,
0.008145558647811413,
-0.02756204828619957,
-0.024800799787044525,
0.022882306948304176,
-0.007557696662843227,
-0.0167671088129282,
-0.046243663877248764,
-0.03908253461122513,
0.02965303510427475,
-0.009988877922296524,
0.0223355982452631,
-0.004391067195683718,
0.06639346480369568,
0.022281741723418236,
0.019078582525253296,
0.04827994480729103,
-0.08765306323766708,
0.022398239001631737,
-0.004572877660393715,
0.0018275569891557097,
0.02881506271660328,
-0.02452903613448143,
0.07654988020658493,
0.009085472673177719,
0.016133829951286316,
0.019453871995210648,
-0.09544692933559418,
-0.03256895765662193,
0.04501606151461601,
-0.002014850964769721,
0.039249956607818604,
0.010312444530427456,
-0.05878503620624542,
0.054653022438287735,
0.050388153642416,
0.05697053670883179,
0.050361599773168564,
-0.0032245388720184565,
0.03088443912565708,
-0.009389773942530155,
-0.02255203388631344,
-0.06610057502985,
0.052984628826379776,
-0.03675559535622597,
-0.019577980041503906,
0.02289239689707756,
-0.009280998259782791,
-0.027910763397812843,
0.034826915711164474,
0.013519748114049435,
0.019818248227238655,
0.0027831229381263256,
0.006356530357152224,
0.015505916438996792,
-0.030419647693634033,
-0.060249995440244675,
0.039388541132211685,
0.009917530231177807,
0.014320014975965023,
0.002666774205863476,
-0.06939959526062012,
0.10405489057302475,
0.01198031660169363,
-0.09407857060432434,
-0.0010792671237140894,
-0.010084095411002636,
-0.021352754905819893,
0.023083653301000595,
0.012506074272096157,
-0.03120269998908043,
-0.045163094997406006,
-0.024808691814541817,
-0.0015899176942184567,
-0.000534808961674571,
0.08580832183361053,
-0.035439468920230865,
-0.014409559778869152,
0.03953786566853523,
-0.04785047844052315,
0.056179504841566086,
-0.004971889313310385,
0.052691735327243805,
0.004323186352849007,
0.007777687627822161,
-0.003414008067920804,
0.0038505950942635536,
0.024653809145092964,
-0.0016025579534471035,
-0.021136188879609108,
-0.02759300358593464,
-0.014956320635974407,
-0.047602858394384384,
-0.0031719468533992767,
-0.04325488209724426,
0.04948664829134941,
0.04884742200374603,
0.0012353468919172883,
-0.013362931087613106,
0.022358089685440063,
-0.0045175193808972836,
0.023024139925837517,
-0.10100854188203812,
-0.001458959188312292,
0.004980145953595638,
0.02065318636596203,
-0.00781648326665163,
0.04980902373790741,
0.02305907942354679,
-0.009314936585724354,
-0.024288278073072433,
-0.005957202985882759,
0.04209434986114502,
0.020410338416695595,
0.024019788950681686,
-0.04103660210967064,
-0.007043630350381136,
-0.009955596178770065,
0.07946343719959259,
-0.006091048941016197,
-0.023654237389564514,
-0.0024419385008513927,
-0.01340094581246376,
-0.012604070827364922,
-0.04127660021185875,
-0.013237659819424152,
0.0016809229273349047,
-0.010216888971626759,
0.02148132584989071,
-0.017962416633963585,
0.001771910465322435,
0.030679132789373398,
0.010521367192268372,
0.021993685513734818,
-0.04522954672574997,
-0.055295880883932114,
0.031235195696353912,
-0.008895689621567726,
-0.0067583657801151276,
0.022651895880699158,
0.02736561931669712,
-0.002312677213922143,
0.010022764094173908,
0.034931402653455734,
0.013426325283944607,
-0.2583218812942505,
-0.0022994314786046743,
0.019456196576356888,
0.004058836959302425,
-0.010632246732711792,
0.015152135863900185,
0.05386685952544212,
-0.015146693214774132,
-0.0206818375736475,
-0.04631008207798004,
-0.004685952328145504,
0.034699808806180954,
-0.024660522118210793,
0.0656929463148117,
0.027730347588658333,
0.04933681711554527,
-0.021535323932766914,
-0.007792607881128788,
-0.04348136857151985,
0.03206375241279602,
-0.018666941672563553,
-0.060745760798454285,
-0.01618446223437786,
0.051846105605363846,
0.01997416280210018,
0.007851934060454369,
-0.10973669588565826,
0.006389934103935957,
0.008957598358392715,
0.008421224541962147,
0.009085484780371189,
-0.025263579562306404,
-0.01728970743715763,
0.011760452762246132,
0.032060787081718445,
-0.01889270544052124,
0.0514073520898819,
-0.010898974724113941,
0.015318313613533974,
-0.008051524870097637,
0.029279721900820732,
0.0002916887460742146,
-0.05456285551190376,
-0.03840801492333412,
0.04519663006067276,
-0.0019961786456406116,
-0.05725318565964699,
-0.01855987124145031,
-0.021794501692056656,
0.04804648831486702,
-0.03255102410912514,
-0.03888179361820221,
-0.034219253808259964,
0.04258106276392937,
0.009892307221889496,
-0.01648736372590065,
0.012053883634507656,
-0.028562359511852264,
-0.034887056797742844,
-0.033106159418821335,
0.008039920590817928,
-0.022346902638673782,
-0.021646827459335327,
-0.006614734418690205,
0.01914847455918789,
-0.027590656653046608,
-0.09847423434257507,
-0.027940206229686737,
0.05720404163002968,
0.06099503114819527,
0.00019470205006655306,
-0.017702894285321236,
-0.014504590071737766,
-0.09157273173332214,
0.015387173742055893,
0.008394732140004635,
0.010134274140000343,
-0.04409726709127426,
0.0020161864813417196,
0.02617184817790985,
-0.020696600899100304,
-0.025013979524374008,
-0.017142245545983315,
-0.02397715486586094,
0.016999205574393272,
0.004540630150586367,
0.024346664547920227,
-0.031094100326299667,
-0.030443992465734482,
-0.011712470091879368,
0.0367080494761467,
-0.016240302473306656,
-0.029426012188196182,
-0.032365649938583374,
0.052927859127521515,
-0.014582634903490543,
0.09584037959575653,
0.02606104500591755,
0.018098970875144005,
0.02552740089595318,
0.029206791892647743,
-0.10832943022251129,
-0.01903693936765194,
0.016600586473941803,
-0.02250755950808525,
0.0053344774059951305,
-0.04576300457119942,
-0.03482292592525482,
0.07623428106307983,
-0.008801867254078388,
-0.032659005373716354,
-0.054072305560112,
0.009894942864775658,
-0.03868379071354866,
-0.020924251526594162,
-0.01870761066675186,
0.014104852452874184,
0.06530352681875229,
0.004945771303027868,
-0.011779086664319038,
-0.012459925375878811,
0.04280563071370125,
-0.055695440620183945,
0.031777359545230865,
0.007079070899635553,
0.01525542140007019,
0.0019841957837343216,
-0.01295627560466528,
-0.007458728272467852,
-0.02254733443260193,
0.017123015597462654,
-0.02038433402776718,
-0.023343650624155998,
-0.0025155420880764723,
0.060794223099946976,
-0.004036470782011747,
-0.03694210574030876,
-0.026670046150684357,
0.03304452821612358,
-0.01746542751789093,
0.01914406567811966,
-0.005103584844619036,
0.04248156398534775,
0.003105642506852746,
0.08084553480148315,
-0.0015564418863505125,
0.012970739044249058,
0.014410261064767838,
0.0009101492469199002,
0.014494853094220161,
0.021014707162976265,
-0.0406377911567688,
-0.027678417041897774,
-0.015080476179718971,
0.017591863870620728,
-0.030527491122484207,
-0.012232351116836071,
-0.01936652511358261,
0.04389201104640961,
-0.034435804933309555,
0.0706310048699379,
-0.012975011952221394,
-0.01816708967089653,
-0.008022905327379704,
0.018844734877347946,
0.02226157858967781,
-0.011825691908597946,
-0.009787660092115402,
0.012663551606237888,
-0.010106492787599564,
0.004077836871147156,
0.0019335632678121328,
-0.034960128366947174,
-0.01971527375280857,
-0.061964310705661774,
0.019461248070001602,
-0.00016233710630331188,
-0.014024523086845875,
-0.036855299025774,
0.05603714659810066,
-0.02371332235634327,
-0.020116334781050682,
0.008620570413768291,
0.0020667007192969322,
0.061182137578725815,
-0.009753470309078693,
0.004713773727416992,
0.009894173592329025,
-0.04091234877705574,
-0.019707102328538895,
0.0024715426843613386,
0.06180376932024956,
-0.037796761840581894,
-0.0506509505212307,
-0.06920375674962997,
-0.05783841386437416,
-0.028145557269454002,
0.049171075224876404,
0.028269784525036812,
0.009328226558864117,
0.00020301200856920332,
0.055225372314453125,
-0.03478897362947464,
-0.043867625296115875,
0.017479456961154938,
-0.09681566059589386,
0.0256390068680048,
-0.008020952343940735,
0.017362136393785477,
0.03242496773600578,
-0.05125740170478821,
-0.03718884661793709,
-0.04926811158657074,
-0.04266248643398285,
0.004470968618988991,
-0.012124030850827694,
-0.02430928498506546,
-0.06611592322587967,
0.012455306015908718,
0.0015482216840609908,
-0.0014083782443776727,
0.013051049783825874,
-0.023328213021159172,
0.0008154560928232968,
0.013859165832400322,
0.0035598878748714924,
-0.016904309391975403,
-0.055433932691812515,
-0.0067408643662929535,
-0.04672051966190338,
0.07505235075950623,
-0.05072382092475891,
0.0033737083431333303,
0.01494642160832882,
-0.004854935221374035,
0.014578134752810001,
-0.019715815782546997,
-0.03702578693628311,
0.007293811999261379,
-0.020814795047044754,
-0.006392274517565966,
-0.023198062554001808,
-0.048304688185453415,
0.012920579873025417,
0.036694012582302094,
0.07328543066978455,
-0.02835308201611042,
0.013923626393079758,
-0.010823683813214302,
0.028403157368302345,
-0.025540582835674286,
0.0020348818507045507,
-0.04982864111661911,
-0.04599505662918091,
0.048676397651433945,
-0.03838961943984032,
-0.006661906838417053,
-0.008479880169034004,
-0.03382813185453415,
0.03497747704386711,
0.0031342285219579935,
0.04933716729283333,
-0.0046693747863173485,
0.047122079879045486,
0.018487276509404182,
0.009631802327930927,
0.013915469869971275,
-0.029645109549164772,
0.02190207876265049,
-0.0447063148021698,
0.003872969187796116,
-0.03416890650987625,
0.02312178537249565,
0.0626443549990654,
-0.022253287956118584,
-0.02763371728360653,
0.004030363168567419,
-0.04706588387489319,
0.05778124928474426,
-0.0125958900898695,
-0.05023159086704254,
0.008879347704350948,
-0.019283290952444077,
0.020742233842611313,
0.013244474306702614,
-0.055427052080631256,
0.03622767701745033,
-0.026254110038280487,
-0.041762202978134155,
-0.019395453855395317,
0.0022667371667921543,
0.04690205678343773,
0.0004886917886324227,
0.048736974596977234,
0.015887634828686714,
0.000421652861405164,
0.013581577688455582,
0.046114128082990646,
0.005724703893065453,
0.014842860400676727,
-0.02092662639915943,
0.07674216479063034,
0.06237131729722023,
0.044787485152482986,
0.03326062113046646,
0.015672065317630768,
-0.023297041654586792,
-0.013047540560364723,
0.07514122128486633,
-0.01740375906229019,
-0.048109330236911774,
-0.06782189756631851,
0.03264680877327919,
-0.01066525001078844,
-0.02786247618496418,
-0.02043844945728779,
0.03335458040237427,
-0.03944312781095505,
0.03781126067042351,
-0.045205578207969666,
0.037486482411623,
-0.0023767107632011175,
0.04431970417499542,
-0.006742815487086773,
0.04481091722846031,
0.080203577876091,
-0.005581346340477467,
-0.005866948515176773,
-0.03945541009306908,
0.03798159956932068,
0.07454589754343033,
0.05997350811958313,
-0.027924420312047005,
0.06123360991477966,
-0.03452908992767334,
-0.036096177995204926,
-0.0017405758844688535,
0.04238690808415413,
0.00589034054428339,
-0.017658494412899017,
0.024126360192894936,
0.07606588304042816,
0.009910691529512405,
0.04565215855836868,
-0.012373093515634537,
-0.04759596288204193,
-0.004263586830347776,
0.02452888898551464,
-0.007519611623138189,
0.0015160891925916076,
0.03875357285141945,
0.01702864095568657,
-0.011559640988707542,
-0.01658802293241024,
0.005534028634428978,
-0.06249239668250084,
0.014384864829480648,
0.00622789328917861,
-0.011829179711639881,
-0.002861187793314457,
-0.02558165043592453,
0.05252889171242714,
0.11598716676235199,
-0.032275911420583725,
-0.06407973170280457,
0.019417479634284973,
0.00020074888016097248,
-0.0015350979520007968,
0.03090730309486389,
0.01877112127840519,
0.02474912256002426,
0.005383683368563652,
-0.05438204109668732,
0.04574236273765564,
0.0403592512011528,
0.03152572363615036,
0.06156604737043381,
-0.04045812040567398,
-0.03492845594882965,
0.025096053257584572,
-0.003208933863788843,
-0.06499890238046646,
-0.03472409397363663,
-0.009780011139810085,
-0.044901445508003235,
-0.02818976528942585,
0.029046541079878807,
0.018294062465429306,
-0.0491863377392292,
-0.057233620434999466,
-0.010714823380112648,
-0.0029941252432763577,
-0.0020835669711232185,
0.03312000259757042,
-0.07199955731630325,
-0.00862758420407772,
0.04779411852359772,
0.023501254618167877,
-0.03934188187122345,
0.03928405046463013,
0.026401884853839874,
0.003159140469506383,
0.017323080450296402,
0.016276618465781212,
0.008505535311996937,
0.005479838233441114,
0.017804788425564766,
-0.003674387466162443,
-0.1144471988081932,
-0.0017470101593062282,
0.0363774336874485,
-0.028900397941470146,
-0.07034870982170105,
0.022987617179751396,
-0.035808805376291275,
0.016750728711485863,
0.05530620738863945,
0.06250057369470596,
0.05379750207066536,
-0.02552306093275547,
0.01756071299314499,
0.021679705008864403,
0.010981892235577106,
0.06358780711889267,
-0.054899584501981735,
0.06810673326253891,
-0.007609597407281399,
-0.03635898977518082,
0.004007082432508469,
0.039728209376335144,
-0.018279600888490677,
-0.008204459212720394,
-0.021761255338788033,
-0.00277091097086668,
-0.03451726585626602,
-0.09224452823400497,
-0.015713363885879517,
0.032254137098789215,
-0.027116267010569572,
-0.04963858798146248,
0.005398541688919067,
-0.00428237859159708,
-0.0360192246735096,
0.012564717791974545,
-0.028330931439995766,
-0.010499175637960434,
-0.03563210740685463,
0.003344848984852433,
-0.04717457294464111,
-0.010983753018081188,
0.013712716288864613,
0.011599070392549038,
-0.043356072157621384,
-0.02229093573987484,
0.004693000111728907,
0.0023951681796461344,
0.02767377905547619,
-0.010446044616401196,
0.0375550203025341,
-0.007219236344099045
] |
360 |
Adaptive Rank Allocation: Speeding Up Modern Transformers with RaNA Adapters
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=uAtDga3q0r
|
[
"Roberto Garcia",
"Jerry Weihong Liu",
"Daniel Sorvisto",
"Sabri Eyuboglu"
] |
Poster
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are computationally intensive, particularly during inference. Neuron-adaptive techniques, which selectively activate neurons in Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) layers, offer some speedups but suffer from limitations in modern Transformers. These include reliance on sparse activations, incompatibility with attention layers, and the use of costly neuron masking techniques. To address these issues, we propose the Adaptive Rank Allocation framework and introduce the Rank and Neuron Allocator (RaNA) adapter. RaNA adapters leverage rank adapters, which operate on linear layers by applying both low-rank matrix decompositions and adaptive masking to efficiently allocate compute without depending on activation sparsity. This enables RaNA to be generally applied to MLPs and linear components of attention modules, while eliminating the need for expensive maskers found in neuron-adaptive methods. Notably, when compared to neuron adapters, RaNA improves perplexity by up to 7 points and increases accuracy by up to 8 percentage-points when reducing FLOPs by $\sim$44\% in state-of-the-art Transformer architectures. These results position RaNA as a robust solution for improving inference efficiency in modern Transformer architectures.
|
Large Language Models, Adaptive compute, Rank adapters, Neuron adapters
| null | 13,289 |
2503.18216
|
[
-0.02644328586757183,
-0.03241368383169174,
-0.029572725296020508,
0.012673740275204182,
0.026123300194740295,
0.04153554514050484,
0.007654353976249695,
-0.01877526566386223,
-0.03659920021891594,
-0.01552173588424921,
-0.025678252801299095,
0.018596522510051727,
-0.05837126821279526,
0.007858632132411003,
-0.02267921343445778,
0.041166067123413086,
0.02132631652057171,
0.00019649601017590612,
0.025100329890847206,
0.010356348939239979,
-0.005994212813675404,
-0.03255947679281235,
0.03734253719449043,
0.009635957889258862,
0.02430267632007599,
-0.0030896631069481373,
0.0240903552621603,
0.034567344933748245,
-0.004930428229272366,
0.0033671241253614426,
0.03541867434978485,
-0.02415519766509533,
-0.005549220368266106,
-0.006519911345094442,
0.024013012647628784,
-0.007170040160417557,
-0.03705299645662308,
-0.016867898404598236,
0.012172822840511799,
0.007453368976712227,
-0.013871950097382069,
0.015981698408722878,
-0.0283509474247694,
0.0233903918415308,
-0.05803690478205681,
0.00348601839505136,
-0.09424518793821335,
0.007599401753395796,
0.010668803937733173,
-0.022377649322152138,
-0.126083642244339,
0.02785278670489788,
-0.022589867934584618,
-0.021269742399454117,
0.03435049206018448,
0.007336159702390432,
0.010155882686376572,
-0.06187231093645096,
-0.006476431153714657,
-0.028865596279501915,
-0.02144467458128929,
-0.026623612269759178,
0.02708876132965088,
0.017153386026620865,
0.0014412830350920558,
-0.0267043299973011,
0.0057471757754683495,
0.017973676323890686,
-0.07487476617097855,
-0.031821440905332565,
-0.03940318152308464,
0.024674957618117332,
-0.017224321141839027,
0.02202015556395054,
0.0010690402705222368,
-0.04663175716996193,
0.02280392311513424,
0.034048087894916534,
0.09692342579364777,
0.006958005018532276,
0.02044212631881237,
0.01174263283610344,
0.017788877710700035,
0.05030972510576248,
0.027845589444041252,
0.0018996335566043854,
-0.03931158781051636,
-0.03798414394259453,
-0.06634677201509476,
-0.004265354946255684,
-0.03913193941116333,
-0.04080890491604805,
-0.001984881702810526,
0.02690202184021473,
0.005254034418612719,
0.03670590743422508,
0.026840675622224808,
-0.009525089524686337,
0.03134452924132347,
0.009734982624650002,
-0.017614901065826416,
-0.031724877655506134,
0.04092753678560257,
-0.01853456348180771,
-0.13577456772327423,
-0.01262875646352768,
-0.006421562284231186,
-0.01857132464647293,
-0.004434044938534498,
0.024433020502328873,
-0.024210812523961067,
-0.017344700172543526,
0.029257796704769135,
-0.049035195261240005,
-0.09328240156173706,
0.018820196390151978,
0.018354885280132294,
0.04021875932812691,
-0.027934275567531586,
-0.009388774633407593,
0.06113547459244728,
0.04871116578578949,
-0.013574919663369656,
0.08056509494781494,
-0.01443980261683464,
0.0010959660867229104,
0.0016109803691506386,
0.013400418683886528,
-0.016583440825343132,
-0.04832133650779724,
0.005353943444788456,
0.03194088116288185,
0.01756664365530014,
0.024505872279405594,
-0.0023419251665472984,
-0.01835310272872448,
-0.00270288810133934,
0.025624800473451614,
0.07328580319881439,
-0.0111038563773036,
0.010610167868435383,
-0.00461175013333559,
0.049073465168476105,
-0.029005810618400574,
0.07559533417224884,
-0.013905487023293972,
-0.03210831061005592,
-0.019873006269335747,
-0.0016515610041096807,
-0.004022631328552961,
0.008657494559884071,
0.00028913721325807273,
-0.0019208885496482253,
-0.0830659568309784,
0.02817436493933201,
0.058283731341362,
0.0328439436852932,
0.010988308116793633,
0.011124901473522186,
0.013038423843681812,
-0.0021930704824626446,
-0.024172089993953705,
-0.05024397000670433,
0.02002459391951561,
-0.01666206680238247,
-0.07414472848176956,
0.004294815007597208,
0.01787162385880947,
-0.031614482402801514,
-0.01170444954186678,
-0.02502882108092308,
-0.042693715542554855,
0.054438516497612,
0.014909372664988041,
-0.01951763406395912,
-0.02960074134171009,
0.05181565135717392,
0.005958106368780136,
0.04013434052467346,
0.008262078277766705,
-0.08428598940372467,
0.04189292713999748,
-0.00462122680619359,
0.025307903066277504,
0.01187194511294365,
-0.01720651425421238,
0.0849900096654892,
-0.028508296236395836,
-0.004479884169995785,
0.014135577715933323,
-0.08663509786128998,
-0.006346674170345068,
-0.003697373438626528,
-0.0008075982332229614,
0.09847570210695267,
0.005569827742874622,
-0.001791514689102769,
0.023673348128795624,
0.02878415957093239,
0.0575157105922699,
0.08052688091993332,
-0.022642968222498894,
0.03545983508229256,
-0.022282777354121208,
-0.05234481394290924,
-0.013306104578077793,
0.035886410623788834,
-0.03898637741804123,
-0.03337458521127701,
0.019813505932688713,
0.008081821724772453,
0.03521545231342316,
0.013263323344290257,
0.0018168645910918713,
-0.011207998730242252,
0.0056425123475492,
-0.015104648657143116,
-0.006623005028814077,
0.03989773988723755,
-0.047127850353717804,
0.03797387704253197,
0.029561053961515427,
-0.031034156680107117,
0.015027825720608234,
-0.03260171040892601,
0.09713965654373169,
0.027033766731619835,
-0.029604656621813774,
-0.020799577236175537,
0.03675246983766556,
0.0062591275200247765,
0.003982210531830788,
0.0007530879229307175,
-0.005085700657218695,
-0.0060224514454603195,
-0.04703862592577934,
-0.017214670777320862,
-0.06505107134580612,
0.055704399943351746,
-0.027049602940678596,
-0.03939679265022278,
0.07959441840648651,
0.0035415308084338903,
0.05372252315282822,
0.0035496398340910673,
0.01789628341794014,
0.049780890345573425,
-0.03378966078162193,
-0.005682792514562607,
-0.03760308027267456,
-0.011285321786999702,
-0.004707016050815582,
0.009940912015736103,
-0.007265676278620958,
0.033675871789455414,
-0.023845823481678963,
-0.02657998539507389,
-0.00246943486854434,
0.07268722355365753,
0.05386270210146904,
0.044653456658124924,
0.03448982536792755,
-0.020059511065483093,
-0.02783132717013359,
-0.03770456463098526,
-0.10306856036186218,
-0.026228835806250572,
-0.014145560562610626,
0.03902958333492279,
0.002429401269182563,
0.06417105346918106,
0.018030310049653053,
0.03229321539402008,
-0.05906060338020325,
0.0006662706728093326,
-0.025383785367012024,
0.013680932112038136,
0.00146259437315166,
-0.0042100511491298676,
-0.025353526696562767,
0.009905301965773106,
0.05321292579174042,
-0.007304473780095577,
-0.0053276075050234795,
-0.012650134973227978,
-0.0615263357758522,
0.001697810017503798,
-0.05583175644278526,
0.02822260931134224,
0.00031358120031654835,
0.037743642926216125,
0.034909117966890335,
-0.00788986124098301,
0.024640461429953575,
0.018456703051924706,
0.06684727966785431,
0.035788897424936295,
0.012099599465727806,
-0.02910376712679863,
0.020243853330612183,
-0.02640669234097004,
0.014923605136573315,
0.002447719220072031,
0.012172586284577847,
-0.024733539670705795,
-0.014229248277842999,
0.00382618373259902,
0.001609046128578484,
-0.2709024250507355,
0.015183689072728157,
0.016010884195566177,
-0.016204645857214928,
0.03702319785952568,
-0.03977283835411072,
0.027711739763617516,
-0.012118148617446423,
-0.0005694368155673146,
0.035875096917152405,
-0.013108206912875175,
0.06259175390005112,
0.00669308053329587,
0.022790327668190002,
0.01946786418557167,
0.016447260975837708,
0.006185473874211311,
-0.004659639671444893,
0.02144746109843254,
0.05846397951245308,
0.007263961248099804,
-0.0590970516204834,
-0.03121333196759224,
0.05525723472237587,
-0.015911392867565155,
0.05745778605341911,
-0.073639877140522,
0.015388823114335537,
-0.026490459218621254,
-0.012964801862835884,
-0.020542526617646217,
-0.02897472307085991,
0.03378332406282425,
0.03078453801572323,
-0.005564586259424686,
-0.0003286967403255403,
0.02768375352025032,
0.014447483234107494,
0.038885701447725296,
0.029999325051903725,
0.003880340838804841,
-0.049135610461235046,
-0.014846601523458958,
0.008568796329200268,
0.056420233100652695,
0.026253752410411835,
-0.05886290594935417,
-0.0005491667543537915,
0.00870547816157341,
0.027959130704402924,
0.004231032449752092,
-0.03737909719347954,
0.015638696029782295,
-0.002897736383602023,
0.010630103759467602,
-0.020401163026690483,
-0.004218874499201775,
-0.02095557004213333,
-0.008010896854102612,
0.04115599766373634,
-0.011252179741859436,
-0.04216693341732025,
-0.008022586815059185,
-0.05222238972783089,
-0.02163088507950306,
-0.036406125873327255,
-0.048395637422800064,
-0.05771582946181297,
0.05408153682947159,
0.00673625199124217,
-0.030911242589354515,
0.05943433567881584,
-0.006967516615986824,
-0.09672007709741592,
-0.0027168761007487774,
0.005406484007835388,
-0.04264960438013077,
0.02306831255555153,
-0.02441496029496193,
0.04652024805545807,
-0.05260700359940529,
-0.0739903450012207,
-0.016299454495310783,
0.010465648956596851,
0.015497495420277119,
-0.04012630507349968,
0.009912412613630295,
-0.04340948164463043,
0.015164077281951904,
-0.03271732106804848,
0.043564699590206146,
-0.01658208668231964,
-0.005562928505241871,
0.005309734493494034,
0.060863032937049866,
0.03316905349493027,
0.003908272832632065,
0.05254390835762024,
0.02059801109135151,
0.01845238357782364,
0.029094448313117027,
-0.06972015649080276,
-0.030658498406410217,
-0.026850474998354912,
-0.017703952267766,
0.025922568514943123,
-0.0459480807185173,
-0.043978311121463776,
0.03996315598487854,
-0.008651213720440865,
-0.022365055978298187,
-0.049308065325021744,
0.018584921956062317,
-0.015479142777621746,
-0.01827644743025303,
0.0016353940591216087,
0.02843397483229637,
0.03292493894696236,
0.019115334376692772,
-0.011502014473080635,
-0.027092786505818367,
0.02459028735756874,
-0.024530161172151566,
-0.015417505986988544,
0.01175544410943985,
-0.004998988471925259,
-0.014608451165258884,
-0.01992516964673996,
-0.015837332233786583,
-0.04406938701868057,
0.044807590544223785,
0.03641834855079651,
-0.014196384698152542,
-0.006421809084713459,
0.033566635102033615,
-0.023377778008580208,
-0.015076383017003536,
0.00228945747949183,
0.028566021472215652,
0.009207741357386112,
-0.010408064350485802,
-0.00020446641428861767,
0.010365890339016914,
0.008510268293321133,
0.01617298647761345,
0.012213868089020252,
0.019731387495994568,
0.008172234520316124,
-0.006101039703935385,
0.003464719746261835,
0.030019067227840424,
-0.0489603690803051,
-0.020696653053164482,
-0.028813250362873077,
0.017103292047977448,
-0.005445781163871288,
0.0448966845870018,
-0.0347326397895813,
0.004100643564015627,
-0.07034549862146378,
0.04690030589699745,
0.023496730253100395,
-0.0024485804606229067,
0.00011047375301131979,
0.0530339777469635,
0.04247036203742027,
-0.020635923370718956,
-0.006469255778938532,
0.03921786695718765,
-0.004370564594864845,
-0.0351526215672493,
-0.025330375880002975,
-0.02670499123632908,
-0.031704701483249664,
-0.008304805494844913,
-0.009029243141412735,
0.03523961082100868,
0.018718456849455833,
-0.009082094766199589,
0.04928378760814667,
0.03612849861383438,
-0.048533011227846146,
-0.015118875540792942,
0.027253353968262672,
0.08192958682775497,
0.006917966995388269,
0.036048103123903275,
0.004258820787072182,
-0.015358497388660908,
0.014529256150126457,
-0.012298530898988247,
-0.0009307098225690424,
-0.029488304629921913,
-0.053073253482580185,
-0.051813721656799316,
-0.032046448439359665,
-0.010961947031319141,
0.02197514846920967,
-0.02125665172934532,
-0.03702265024185181,
-0.03739434853196144,
0.0043999142944812775,
-0.031741611659526825,
-0.017266210168600082,
0.02411738410592079,
-0.09015309065580368,
-0.006601754110306501,
0.04838636517524719,
-0.020442349836230278,
0.03653918206691742,
-0.002172582084313035,
-0.024175172671675682,
-0.004816780332475901,
-0.00133857736364007,
0.044910650700330734,
-0.0078803775832057,
-0.030719922855496407,
-0.019056411460042,
-0.0033275126479566097,
-0.023195695132017136,
0.0016915027517825365,
-0.01681523397564888,
0.022282134741544724,
-0.011022847145795822,
-0.00427996926009655,
0.024307386949658394,
-0.028707128018140793,
0.022197844460606575,
-0.0256215650588274,
-0.0418892540037632,
0.014659279957413673,
-0.05210632458329201,
0.04052561894059181,
0.09276688098907471,
0.012019927613437176,
-0.0007897146861068904,
-0.04799282178282738,
0.01580238714814186,
0.00972380768507719,
0.0010735898977145553,
0.0249742791056633,
-0.018660789355635643,
-0.059656426310539246,
0.02169596590101719,
-0.021245453506708145,
0.04508736729621887,
0.009778291918337345,
0.015251120552420616,
-0.0024533586110919714,
0.013077951967716217,
0.03965824842453003,
0.04869149252772331,
-0.03840722516179085,
-0.002051516203209758,
0.05500331148505211,
-0.045486245304346085,
-0.03621731325984001,
-0.055276595056056976,
-0.06675337255001068,
0.01851363107562065,
-0.010715478099882603,
0.05325121805071831,
-0.04973047599196434,
0.051412079483270645,
0.04395260289311409,
0.04115733876824379,
0.0015544507186859846,
0.0010711054783314466,
0.016818007454276085,
-0.03706884756684303,
0.0005427784053608775,
-0.06218894198536873,
-0.056469012051820755,
0.046305954456329346,
-0.02180635556578636,
0.03231413662433624,
-0.00494889821857214,
-0.04984040930867195,
0.021028954535722733,
-0.013724508695304394,
-0.033659882843494415,
0.030588213354349136,
-0.021576587110757828,
-0.015445776283740997,
0.052061859518289566,
-0.0426006019115448,
0.024069134145975113,
-0.023285310715436935,
-0.031006895005702972,
0.013447058387100697,
0.004574253689497709,
0.06453187763690948,
0.003186882007867098,
0.03549226373434067,
-0.04188276454806328,
0.007399551570415497,
0.030483074486255646,
0.07379183918237686,
0.0028160924557596445,
0.017754962667822838,
-0.036176130175590515,
0.061181824654340744,
0.04425649717450142,
0.015286755748093128,
-0.004622878506779671,
0.02809932827949524,
-0.0051671103574335575,
-0.05592342093586922,
0.049987077713012695,
-0.0021347394213080406,
-0.03601184859871864,
-0.07149683684110641,
0.06624554842710495,
0.03911234438419342,
-0.0669049322605133,
-0.029186507686972618,
0.016696037724614143,
-0.027659105136990547,
0.008779676631093025,
-0.03719211742281914,
0.006222620140761137,
-0.027051415294408798,
0.04505239799618721,
0.0016769642243161798,
0.03947842866182327,
0.07792196422815323,
0.00000921124046726618,
-0.03773963078856468,
0.0068196929059922695,
0.08106088638305664,
0.0634978637099266,
0.0579405203461647,
-0.04222029447555542,
0.05695050209760666,
-0.018838347867131233,
-0.07581827044487,
0.05114274471998215,
0.029089665040373802,
0.03198292851448059,
-0.05409419536590576,
0.03131559118628502,
0.07624410092830658,
-0.0027534884866327047,
0.0668213814496994,
-0.042681269347667694,
-0.0011227212380617857,
0.024918245151638985,
-0.025024764239788055,
0.018162136897444725,
0.05808373540639877,
0.04973692446947098,
0.015651574358344078,
-0.024246077984571457,
-0.024878881871700287,
-0.004527556709945202,
-0.01947164349257946,
0.01599002815783024,
-0.0019085207022726536,
0.0017288470407947898,
0.011808625422418118,
-0.004858024884015322,
0.026034966111183167,
0.08788300305604935,
-0.03472999855875969,
0.001672114129178226,
0.0036355480551719666,
0.015172945335507393,
-0.00425482215359807,
0.03432285040616989,
-0.019671300426125526,
-0.037646859884262085,
-0.02693338692188263,
-0.04398038983345032,
0.008121651597321033,
0.031171007081866264,
0.01161214429885149,
0.031045671552419662,
-0.028522655367851257,
-0.0266812015324831,
-0.003908626735210419,
0.035792458802461624,
-0.034752801060676575,
-0.06145584583282471,
-0.036127083003520966,
-0.0425192192196846,
-0.04137146845459938,
-0.04905327782034874,
0.025944797322154045,
0.009816457517445087,
-0.023883679881691933,
-0.028835883364081383,
-0.04581887274980545,
-0.011230218224227428,
0.02680392377078533,
-0.06974951922893524,
0.029761705547571182,
0.019128095358610153,
0.011723106727004051,
-0.022325318306684494,
0.055184341967105865,
0.0376727320253849,
0.0038652231451123953,
-0.01617252454161644,
0.0351688414812088,
0.037114471197128296,
0.020450890064239502,
-0.0011196318082511425,
-0.02633633092045784,
-0.09396941214799881,
0.003054592292755842,
0.020609499886631966,
-0.03722956031560898,
-0.07603573054075241,
0.02445192262530327,
-0.016880016773939133,
0.05748317763209343,
0.05890370532870293,
0.013176591135561466,
-0.016555536538362503,
-0.017208514735102654,
0.009421203285455704,
0.0007785544148646295,
-0.017091384157538414,
0.02778744511306286,
-0.021896587684750557,
0.05970952659845352,
0.03597839176654816,
0.0008843647665344179,
-0.04904334619641304,
0.017234593629837036,
-0.02562962844967842,
0.0370524562895298,
-0.03334512189030647,
-0.03627534955739975,
-0.030370907858014107,
-0.10258007794618607,
-0.023643527179956436,
0.016045061871409416,
-0.02273000404238701,
-0.023133734241127968,
0.00520833907648921,
-0.010087699629366398,
-0.002291210927069187,
-0.012832967564463615,
-0.02259865589439869,
-0.029424961656332016,
-0.03116876818239689,
-0.007916494272649288,
-0.06568588316440582,
0.036986302584409714,
-0.04338616505265236,
0.03368327394127846,
-0.01184476725757122,
-0.035770561546087265,
0.01122572273015976,
0.004054581746459007,
0.03267057612538338,
0.014544453471899033,
0.016344821080565453,
-0.013261252082884312
] |
361 |
EFFICIENT JAILBREAK ATTACK SEQUENCES ON LARGE LANGUAGE MODELS VIA MULTI-ARMED BANDIT-BASED CONTEXT SWITCHING
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=jCDF7G3LpF
|
[
"Aditya Ramesh",
"Shivam Bhardwaj",
"Aditya Saibewar",
"Manohar Kaul"
] |
Poster
|
Content warning: This paper contains examples of harmful language and content.
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have made them increasingly vulnerable to jailbreaking attempts, where malicious users manipulate models into generating harmful content. While existing approaches rely on either single-step attacks that trigger immediate safety responses or multi-step methods that inefficiently iterate prompts using other LLMs, we introduce ``Sequence of Context" (SoC) attacks that systematically alter conversational context through strategically crafted context-switching queries (CSQs). We formulate this as a multi-armed bandit (MAB) optimization problem, automatically learning optimal sequences of CSQs that gradually weaken the model's safety boundaries. Our theoretical analysis provides tight bounds on both the expected sequence length until successful jailbreak and the convergence of cumulative rewards. Empirically, our method achieves a 95\% attack success rate, surpassing PAIR by 63.15\%, AutoDAN by 60\%, and ReNeLLM by 50\%. We evaluate our attack across multiple open-source LLMs including Llama and Mistral variants. Our findings highlight critical vulnerabilities in current LLM safeguards and emphasize the need for defenses that consider sequential attack patterns rather than relying solely on static prompt filtering or iterative refinement.
|
JailBreak, AI Security, LLM Vunlnerability
|
We propose a novel multi-step attack methodology to automatically generate an optimal sequence of prompts that gradually steers the LLM towards eliciting harmful/unsafe responses using a Multi Armed Bandit Framework.
| 13,287 | null |
[
-0.026140529662370682,
-0.02732519805431366,
-0.036514151841402054,
0.04832708463072777,
0.03374162316322327,
0.0059457262977957726,
0.0657503679394722,
0.0066507793962955475,
-0.026114892214536667,
-0.010314902290701866,
-0.04095557704567909,
0.014685889706015587,
-0.06012160703539848,
-0.029598405584692955,
-0.0009652190492488444,
0.046814631670713425,
0.026117028668522835,
-0.024136781692504883,
0.04782198742032051,
0.01990436762571335,
0.010859454050660133,
0.03465023636817932,
0.034329794347286224,
0.02879524603486061,
0.03521893918514252,
0.022614099085330963,
0.011006077751517296,
0.029041791334748268,
-0.06100026145577431,
-0.008568773046135902,
0.0487687811255455,
0.009388189762830734,
0.01613723859190941,
-0.026260890066623688,
0.027067577466368675,
0.03219195827841759,
-0.04023706167936325,
-0.0037047069054096937,
0.014544854871928692,
0.03889304772019386,
-0.04918469116091728,
-0.007217065431177616,
-0.01743999309837818,
0.0014221412129700184,
-0.06408221274614334,
-0.02024414762854576,
-0.07955953478813171,
0.050264328718185425,
0.009032743982970715,
-0.03258989751338959,
-0.10723710805177689,
0.057247694581747055,
0.01080968789756298,
-0.03516349941492081,
0.044239748269319534,
0.018223969265818596,
0.05853072181344032,
-0.1107577309012413,
0.02357255108654499,
-0.03756258264183998,
-0.050038471817970276,
0.024353453889489174,
0.029596956446766853,
-0.01296077948063612,
-0.028327621519565582,
-0.015523359179496765,
0.012269304133951664,
0.057589296251535416,
-0.06538913398981094,
-0.0505695641040802,
-0.016084512695670128,
0.03469398245215416,
-0.0040834397077560425,
-0.005369591061025858,
0.019657570868730545,
-0.032932624220848083,
0.012832991778850555,
0.014548725448548794,
0.03501752391457558,
0.018753813579678535,
0.00626291474327445,
0.017981916666030884,
0.03158213570713997,
0.04065433144569397,
-0.006362082436680794,
-0.007765474729239941,
-0.02669680118560791,
-0.02089569717645645,
-0.06007901579141617,
0.014181254431605339,
-0.01781635358929634,
-0.039554353803396225,
0.02075665444135666,
0.02951703406870365,
0.016162406653165817,
0.0033958826679736376,
0.014601939357817173,
0.04747707396745682,
-0.010728556662797928,
0.04229874908924103,
0.012454528361558914,
-0.03201555833220482,
-0.0024543614126741886,
-0.017243532463908195,
-0.12404849380254745,
-0.0005391509621404111,
-0.020435579121112823,
-0.0030478809494525194,
-0.0038412543945014477,
-0.018047193065285683,
-0.009573462419211864,
0.00720893545076251,
0.01708301156759262,
0.005477395374327898,
-0.07255236059427261,
0.05295325070619583,
-0.007326052989810705,
0.03126111999154091,
-0.0027087104972451925,
-0.0018859562696889043,
0.025367118418216705,
0.02653511054813862,
0.00915462989360094,
0.08592747151851654,
0.013934512622654438,
-0.006850391160696745,
0.014543178491294384,
0.017639579251408577,
0.014796311035752296,
-0.038764748722314835,
0.02423388697206974,
0.022135842591524124,
0.0022910747211426497,
-0.008042339235544205,
-0.01235132198780775,
0.005874242167919874,
-0.005829771514981985,
0.05232366546988487,
0.06288271397352219,
0.00615488039329648,
-0.004305204376578331,
-0.030635138973593712,
0.06164759024977684,
-0.02442532777786255,
0.07039661705493927,
-0.0025169237051159143,
-0.04735209047794342,
0.0011717781890183687,
0.00265119899995625,
0.007333972025662661,
0.027747225016355515,
-0.018282508477568626,
0.002481280593201518,
-0.06745714694261551,
0.032076042145490646,
0.04639822244644165,
0.027166059240698814,
0.027982119470834732,
-0.039344917982816696,
0.00885866116732359,
0.004383736290037632,
0.0046904184855520725,
-0.0661366805434227,
0.006773544475436211,
0.006483638659119606,
-0.03977477550506592,
0.02183634415268898,
0.02672143653035164,
-0.023524988442659378,
0.0077049811370670795,
-0.04235013201832771,
-0.024829057976603508,
0.059622425585985184,
-0.04622422158718109,
-0.03131447732448578,
-0.0004754436085931957,
0.055235907435417175,
-0.006043668836355209,
0.04178344085812569,
0.031088097020983696,
-0.0772365927696228,
0.022772638127207756,
0.02472127042710781,
0.03089803270995617,
-0.003724233713001013,
0.004364893771708012,
0.0767417922616005,
-0.01609216071665287,
0.00014367816038429737,
0.03549812361598015,
-0.08211230486631393,
-0.007860157638788223,
0.029176782816648483,
0.006877876352518797,
0.06776170432567596,
-0.007124795112758875,
0.005480642896145582,
0.03400106355547905,
0.025699518620967865,
0.04394371062517166,
0.024274634197354317,
-0.0018484576139599085,
0.03727749362587929,
-0.02600461058318615,
-0.05342632159590721,
0.0013819627929478884,
0.03715808689594269,
-0.046139344573020935,
-0.030327320098876953,
0.014441045932471752,
-0.022669509053230286,
0.015165400691330433,
0.013302672654390335,
-0.004999762866646051,
-0.0036290145944803953,
-0.025599008426070213,
-0.014764483086764812,
-0.0006498229340650141,
0.026620827615261078,
-0.06398710608482361,
0.008343962021172047,
-0.022766321897506714,
-0.021629106253385544,
0.013487433083355427,
-0.03514238819479942,
0.1323247104883194,
0.046076636761426926,
-0.015820588916540146,
0.026678308844566345,
-0.015048744156956673,
0.00205413531512022,
-0.018583856523036957,
-0.003382809227332473,
-0.03872852027416229,
0.019164208322763443,
0.020991357043385506,
0.004979870282113552,
-0.0164148211479187,
0.04642747715115547,
-0.03207249194383621,
0.005578275769948959,
0.09343920648097992,
-0.05116095393896103,
0.05982433259487152,
-0.026719357818365097,
-0.004269927274435759,
0.015859367325901985,
-0.01168786734342575,
-0.034676067531108856,
-0.03389263525605202,
-0.011543679982423782,
-0.00610623462125659,
0.027946162968873978,
-0.031256504356861115,
0.043593842536211014,
-0.03485233336687088,
-0.025036880746483803,
-0.025878850370645523,
0.036975324153900146,
0.042993634939193726,
0.012422202154994011,
0.03874986991286278,
-0.007102032192051411,
-0.04107600823044777,
-0.004696797113865614,
-0.08185268938541412,
-0.020391222089529037,
-0.013972871005535126,
0.022413721308112144,
-0.007983209565281868,
0.026310788467526436,
0.0016278617549687624,
0.009884493425488472,
-0.017415694892406464,
-0.006656910292804241,
0.00920221395790577,
0.021229468286037445,
0.01960054226219654,
-0.027807526290416718,
-0.009704168885946274,
-0.029166962951421738,
0.042637765407562256,
-0.007148328702896833,
-0.04032571613788605,
-0.03182576224207878,
-0.04086844250559807,
-0.002493548672646284,
-0.03798263892531395,
-0.04143773391842842,
0.03956080973148346,
-0.006504185032099485,
0.03912259265780449,
-0.03728126734495163,
0.048579342663288116,
0.01743878424167633,
0.05319056659936905,
0.02129208669066429,
0.042427029460668564,
-0.0013818141305819154,
0.04848504438996315,
-0.0013186370488256216,
-0.002766589866951108,
-0.0245831198990345,
0.021734409034252167,
-0.01727535016834736,
-0.0019427125807851553,
0.013319483958184719,
0.0006712032482028008,
-0.2971664369106293,
-0.00031366728944703937,
0.012069536373019218,
-0.03043314442038536,
0.01156686246395111,
0.008152704685926437,
0.040482085198163986,
-0.0409921295940876,
-0.019199859350919724,
0.011329186148941517,
-0.005311037413775921,
0.02307332120835781,
0.010384665802121162,
0.00906419288367033,
0.02660721354186535,
0.0323510505259037,
-0.04015982896089554,
-0.024639880284667015,
-0.0019016999285668135,
0.03020150400698185,
-0.008368290960788727,
-0.06756654381752014,
0.004917467944324017,
0.0090218810364604,
-0.01881217025220394,
0.05233960971236229,
-0.07031893730163574,
-0.006640050560235977,
-0.018877379596233368,
0.0028576699551194906,
-0.01787818782031536,
-0.053166989237070084,
0.005820862017571926,
0.01720190979540348,
-0.011625234968960285,
0.02200593426823616,
0.04843219742178917,
0.016548065468668938,
0.006345560774207115,
0.010514287278056145,
0.017474690452218056,
-0.04036552831530571,
0.012766926549375057,
0.01251294370740652,
0.08845818787813187,
-0.0021697613410651684,
-0.04532894864678383,
-0.004734923597425222,
-0.013381725177168846,
0.031138459220528603,
-0.006576809566468,
-0.0770128145813942,
-0.026185249909758568,
0.0338636189699173,
0.018482115119695663,
-0.015930289402604103,
-0.028418023139238358,
-0.04109871760010719,
-0.023552976548671722,
0.011537584476172924,
0.02685319073498249,
-0.019386550411581993,
-0.025328870862722397,
-0.02805580198764801,
0.007476715371012688,
-0.050505250692367554,
-0.05867483466863632,
-0.05399201437830925,
0.046467721462249756,
0.03568514063954353,
-0.032901961356401443,
0.02072720043361187,
0.014632383361458778,
-0.0933665782213211,
0.0028758076950907707,
-0.012649808079004288,
-0.010873504914343357,
-0.006188896484673023,
0.025472491979599,
0.050367321819067,
-0.0814426988363266,
-0.02744310162961483,
-0.00455429358407855,
-0.006685155443847179,
0.024538084864616394,
-0.02896783873438835,
-0.00045700586633756757,
-0.012102419510483742,
-0.003934889566153288,
-0.014756407588720322,
0.0468691848218441,
0.014576409943401814,
-0.011308331973850727,
-0.0005164609174244106,
0.064094677567482,
0.02873286046087742,
0.04291065037250519,
0.023305725306272507,
0.0438489131629467,
0.004416704643517733,
0.03320372849702835,
-0.0662359818816185,
0.01606924459338188,
-0.05725409835577011,
-0.007557817734777927,
0.0435207225382328,
-0.059454672038555145,
-0.029635541141033173,
0.02260185219347477,
-0.02880154363811016,
-0.035384420305490494,
-0.030354250222444534,
-0.011460183188319206,
-0.007779051084071398,
-0.009172366000711918,
-0.021683543920516968,
0.0163600891828537,
0.0355006568133831,
0.041292350739240646,
-0.03298566862940788,
-0.05751784145832062,
0.06431381404399872,
-0.0006800490082241595,
0.020427433773875237,
-0.01768203265964985,
-0.044817548245191574,
-0.00011851159069919959,
0.02544264681637287,
0.02330484613776207,
-0.02802424505352974,
0.0061730882152915,
0.03482509031891823,
-0.023579925298690796,
0.007729344069957733,
0.048197414726018906,
0.0010409828973934054,
-0.005617924500256777,
-0.0326119065284729,
0.011827744543552399,
-0.002994097303599119,
0.02791515737771988,
-0.011699015274643898,
0.031140442937612534,
0.024999422952532768,
0.008021502755582333,
-0.008054548874497414,
0.0258476659655571,
-0.00262011238373816,
-0.01005413569509983,
0.015550157986581326,
0.029608119279146194,
-0.06478084623813629,
0.017252258956432343,
-0.029026271775364876,
0.017356891185045242,
0.005570778623223305,
0.033960048109292984,
0.008477403782308102,
-0.020780859515070915,
-0.05950856953859329,
0.07442276924848557,
-0.008988858200609684,
0.008717917837202549,
-0.0072805010713636875,
-0.0033029017504304647,
0.04416161775588989,
-0.055394046008586884,
0.010546778328716755,
0.0056878323666751385,
0.0058911521919071674,
-0.00021760650270152837,
-0.005244100466370583,
-0.055906884372234344,
0.011499078013002872,
0.001108151045627892,
-0.0104524539783597,
-0.0016234632348641753,
0.01223671156913042,
-0.03104153461754322,
0.00848914310336113,
-0.000040228584111901,
-0.022982148453593254,
0.023235823959112167,
0.02624003402888775,
0.09087206423282623,
0.0007687238976359367,
0.001802767044864595,
-0.0003393935039639473,
-0.03975400701165199,
0.02959979884326458,
-0.0161848533898592,
0.022060595452785492,
-0.009362075477838516,
-0.02709375135600567,
-0.02064780704677105,
-0.05853258818387985,
-0.03082025982439518,
0.03475688770413399,
0.012257339432835579,
0.0038146632723510265,
0.011145333759486675,
-0.014122465625405312,
-0.010871579870581627,
0.004572332836687565,
0.022712690755724907,
-0.07064642757177353,
0.02977888658642769,
0.010979085229337215,
-0.020153135061264038,
0.047041479498147964,
-0.023457137867808342,
-0.04639623314142227,
-0.032499875873327255,
-0.02260631136596203,
0.013280176557600498,
-0.022976331412792206,
-0.059454116970300674,
0.004474007990211248,
-0.021800560876727104,
-0.010942316614091396,
0.018826084211468697,
-0.04201490432024002,
-0.00046638952335342765,
-0.008503135293722153,
-0.00026528985472396016,
0.057416871190071106,
-0.03664514049887657,
-0.019161760807037354,
0.04383176937699318,
-0.020779266953468323,
0.059554025530815125,
-0.030583545565605164,
0.06420139968395233,
0.012743954546749592,
-0.04474111273884773,
0.009481050074100494,
-0.071713387966156,
0.04414408653974533,
-0.015023987740278244,
-0.002614345634356141,
-0.008333585225045681,
0.00011220339365536347,
-0.029302138835191727,
-0.005608643405139446,
0.011870762333273888,
0.0328340008854866,
0.01832112856209278,
0.0340372733771801,
0.005615190602838993,
0.012464954517781734,
0.01728498749434948,
0.05104605853557587,
-0.031425174325704575,
0.00009890288492897525,
0.052874188870191574,
-0.03846532478928566,
-0.0384991392493248,
-0.06491251289844513,
-0.04515812546014786,
0.0053386748768389225,
-0.010621841996908188,
0.030630173161625862,
-0.019252698868513107,
0.015963518992066383,
0.019345717504620552,
0.024250183254480362,
0.02148132584989071,
-0.024445049464702606,
0.0358898751437664,
-0.03013526275753975,
-0.0062567139975726604,
-0.09249329566955566,
0.06715736538171768,
0.06557901948690414,
-0.05312420055270195,
0.014836940914392471,
-0.003053580643609166,
-0.03379857540130615,
0.025279255583882332,
-0.00950646959245205,
-0.05123324319720268,
0.011641845107078552,
-0.046168193221092224,
-0.026930777356028557,
0.05962172895669937,
-0.05690263584256172,
-0.0165242962539196,
-0.02026396617293358,
-0.04457538574934006,
-0.022753365337848663,
0.016915546730160713,
0.041596706956624985,
-0.002689854707568884,
0.01832919754087925,
-0.01737862452864647,
0.013293001800775528,
0.012518675997853279,
0.023268762975931168,
0.04531171917915344,
0.014346657320857048,
-0.021320221945643425,
0.0343586727976799,
0.041500937193632126,
0.004475490190088749,
-0.008871868252754211,
-0.027524104341864586,
-0.032045576721429825,
-0.0665249451994896,
0.0761876180768013,
-0.001394809689372778,
-0.02030995301902294,
-0.030227359384298325,
0.08576954156160355,
0.032145675271749496,
-0.04070194065570831,
-0.005689392797648907,
0.02144097350537777,
-0.08187858760356903,
-0.036526165902614594,
0.0005345904501155019,
-0.0019052834250032902,
-0.020325221121311188,
0.07429755479097366,
0.03694063052535057,
0.06445547938346863,
0.067774698138237,
-0.00643480708822608,
-0.02614014409482479,
-0.008208820596337318,
0.05471242219209671,
0.048702362924814224,
0.04394357278943062,
-0.003108903067186475,
0.05908382683992386,
-0.060457728803157806,
-0.042008351534605026,
0.036367177963256836,
0.014447241090238094,
-0.01899888552725315,
-0.051035914570093155,
0.016612349078059196,
0.05583181977272034,
-0.03866393491625786,
0.06791331619024277,
-0.04978586360812187,
0.0029639576096087694,
0.048377372324466705,
0.02258913591504097,
0.017055239528417587,
0.05253847315907478,
0.042225975543260574,
0.018369076773524284,
-0.036516524851322174,
-0.028878502547740936,
0.02253347635269165,
-0.011875002644956112,
-0.006869306787848473,
0.021221794188022614,
-0.02587355673313141,
0.004269294906407595,
-0.018322141841053963,
0.030407093465328217,
0.11437175422906876,
-0.0006613781442865729,
-0.01813487522304058,
0.044570304453372955,
-0.0009866352193057537,
0.056410737335681915,
0.06187766417860985,
-0.005784626584500074,
-0.023349126800894737,
-0.007126637268811464,
-0.010539033450186253,
-0.0034800120629370213,
0.0013295309618115425,
-0.03841917961835861,
0.020360887050628662,
0.006629426032304764,
-0.02476090006530285,
-0.00014223858306650072,
-0.000570974312722683,
-0.037924714386463165,
-0.059461940079927444,
-0.0357937254011631,
-0.06131939962506294,
-0.03817477449774742,
-0.07574647665023804,
-0.0022313143126666546,
-0.003019763622432947,
-0.03638015687465668,
0.026872530579566956,
-0.03432374820113182,
0.02605544775724411,
-0.015174598433077335,
-0.06521368026733398,
0.01801222562789917,
0.045662593096494675,
0.02720080316066742,
0.02196747623383999,
0.022193092852830887,
0.02133714221417904,
-0.01817595586180687,
-0.028006142005324364,
0.020053578540682793,
0.0366746261715889,
0.022692248225212097,
0.001226159860379994,
-0.014674291014671326,
-0.0928167775273323,
0.00809620413929224,
0.047994401305913925,
-0.01552419550716877,
-0.07112817466259003,
0.02014375664293766,
-0.04070700705051422,
0.029545843601226807,
0.07389786094427109,
-0.01305629126727581,
0.0200957003980875,
-0.027590660378336906,
0.022703640162944794,
0.004373547155410051,
-0.0020380232017487288,
0.02446415275335312,
-0.014352724887430668,
0.055330656468868256,
0.02318488247692585,
-0.03929669409990311,
-0.04610063508152962,
0.021228540688753128,
0.00031771903741173446,
-0.016569731757044792,
-0.012048205360770226,
0.003107154741883278,
-0.03203240782022476,
-0.0765109658241272,
-0.011950545944273472,
0.03797141835093498,
0.0005359312053769827,
-0.025152817368507385,
0.00016343689640052617,
-0.004030429758131504,
-0.02550567500293255,
-0.01638736017048359,
-0.018343936651945114,
0.00392738776281476,
-0.04595653712749481,
-0.011675789020955563,
-0.05926778167486191,
-0.001091243582777679,
-0.07520727813243866,
-0.01354187447577715,
-0.031424861401319504,
-0.045246344059705734,
-0.00305883283726871,
0.023275157436728477,
0.06396256387233734,
-0.014859970659017563,
-0.021410787478089333,
-0.03837414085865021
] |
362 |
A Little Goes a Long Way: Efficient Long Context Training and Inference with Partial Contexts
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=TrKRpaOk8y
|
[
"Suyu Ge",
"Xihui Lin",
"Yunan Zhang",
"Jiawei Han",
"Hao Peng"
] |
Poster
|
Training and serving long-context large language models (LLMs) incurs substantial overhead.
To address this, two critical steps are often required: a pretrained LLM typically undergoes a separate stage for context length extension by training on long-context data, followed by architectural modifications to reduce the overhead of KV cache during serving.
This paper argues that integrating length extension with a GPU-friendly KV cache reduction architecture not only reduces training overhead during length extension, but also achieves better long-context performance.
This leads to our proposed LongGen, which finetunes a pretrained LLM into an efficient architecture during length extension.
LongGen builds on three key insights:
(1) Sparse attention patterns, such as window attention (attending to recent tokens), attention sink (initial ones), and blockwise sparse attention (strided token blocks) are well-suited for building efficient long-context models, primarily due to their GPU-friendly memory access patterns, enabling efficiency gains not just theoretically but in practice as well.
(2) It is essential for the model to have direct access to all tokens.
A hybrid architecture with 1/3 full attention layers and 2/3 efficient ones achieves a balanced trade-off between efficiency and long-context performance.
(3) Lightweight training on 5B long-context data is sufficient to extend the hybrid model's context length from 4K to 128K.
We evaluate LongGen on both Llama-2 7B and Llama-2 70B, demonstrating its effectiveness across different scales.
During training with 128K-long contexts, LongGen achieves 1.55x training speedup and reduces wall-clock time by 36%, compared to a full-attention baseline.
During inference, LongGen reduces KV cache memory by 62%, achieving 1.67x prefilling speedup and 1.41x decoding speedup.
Compared to baselines that apply KV-cache reduction techniques to full-attention long-context LLMs, LongGen achieves substantially stronger performance not only on the Needle-in-a-Haystack retrieval task, but also on more challenging long-context reasoning tasks, including BABILong and RULER.
|
Long-Context LLM, Efficient LLM, Context Extension, KV Cache Reduction
|
This paper argues that integrating length extension with a GPU-friendly KV cache reduction architecture not only reduces training and inference overhead, but also achieve better long-context performance.
| 13,286 |
2410.01485
|
[
-0.019826902076601982,
-0.022277461364865303,
-0.010185115039348602,
0.015133699402213097,
0.014833073131740093,
0.0164947547018528,
0.023277437314391136,
0.03402523323893547,
-0.028450002893805504,
-0.0055938721634447575,
-0.034971997141838074,
0.02188463881611824,
-0.04619692265987396,
0.011521462351083755,
0.007267087697982788,
0.05233699455857277,
0.054804958403110504,
-0.03101666085422039,
0.013433144427835941,
0.02351505681872368,
0.018265947699546814,
-0.016013970598578453,
0.04164733365178108,
0.023173503577709198,
0.025366341695189476,
0.0175635889172554,
0.010038641281425953,
0.017245925962924957,
-0.04118672385811806,
-0.002854711841791868,
0.038872357457876205,
-0.023639222607016563,
0.00824611447751522,
-0.009233707562088966,
0.031738899648189545,
-0.02093382366001606,
-0.06301704049110413,
-0.013263696804642677,
0.014067241922020912,
0.020036447793245316,
-0.02138451114296913,
0.004231587518006563,
-0.020821018144488335,
-0.0013807348441332579,
-0.06520888209342957,
0.010749845765531063,
-0.10407498478889465,
0.01871965266764164,
-0.021141717210412025,
-0.04690828546881676,
-0.11240702867507935,
0.03916036710143089,
0.002795520005747676,
-0.014449069276452065,
0.03576919063925743,
0.04272695630788803,
0.044751375913619995,
-0.08159303665161133,
0.002582909306511283,
-0.024952543899416924,
-0.04933661222457886,
-0.004178303759545088,
0.026377933099865913,
0.012225357815623283,
0.004362890496850014,
-0.024733372032642365,
0.0025968013796955347,
0.026777127757668495,
-0.0793362632393837,
-0.05735495686531067,
-0.016550516709685326,
0.01717674359679222,
-0.020129453390836716,
0.01558314822614193,
-0.009893853217363358,
-0.024580033496022224,
0.002449910854920745,
0.026140177622437477,
0.07586771249771118,
-0.002465091412886977,
-0.005107996053993702,
0.0059163859114050865,
0.012522721663117409,
0.048336442559957504,
-0.0008936939993873239,
0.035062890499830246,
-0.04042966291308403,
-0.024149619042873383,
-0.06091771647334099,
0.02839101105928421,
-0.022960759699344635,
-0.04887168109416962,
-0.0009656158508732915,
0.030316784977912903,
-0.004829274956136942,
-0.003530203364789486,
0.01465670671314001,
0.016703935340046883,
-0.0031820586882531643,
0.01110951229929924,
-0.01693134382367134,
-0.04620818793773651,
0.029653353616595268,
0.0029295559506863356,
-0.11017335951328278,
-0.024507896974682808,
-0.04841718077659607,
-0.0066119227558374405,
0.0036860851105302572,
-0.00814905110746622,
-0.021897831931710243,
-0.00942117627710104,
0.017152676358819008,
0.007154129911214113,
-0.07446656376123428,
0.009612902998924255,
0.009272035211324692,
-0.0007614098722115159,
0.010863656178116798,
0.0058165425434708595,
0.05110148340463638,
0.062086742371320724,
0.02717830054461956,
0.0727432519197464,
0.008841991424560547,
0.03217902034521103,
-0.001398749533109367,
0.027185987681150436,
-0.029130300506949425,
-0.049078505486249924,
0.016618812456727028,
0.01616203971207142,
0.025389499962329865,
0.0042309993878006935,
-0.004008385352790356,
0.0014895827043801546,
0.008439510129392147,
0.010958717204630375,
0.08614598959684372,
-0.04147399589419365,
0.018607070669531822,
-0.04518483206629753,
0.062443528324365616,
-0.05468035116791725,
0.09828440845012665,
-0.007409106940031052,
-0.018490901216864586,
-0.032852835953235626,
-0.02194204553961754,
-0.003170283744111657,
0.027469834312796593,
-0.004000434651970863,
-0.004151840228587389,
-0.06262541562318802,
0.044586047530174255,
0.07676707953214645,
-0.01694989763200283,
-0.017400484532117844,
0.013098032213747501,
0.028195353224873543,
0.001869653002358973,
-0.0036057860124856234,
-0.07457171380519867,
0.015536345541477203,
-0.016544800251722336,
-0.040425293147563934,
0.032476890832185745,
0.027945294976234436,
-0.06243547797203064,
0.03460800647735596,
-0.01834314875304699,
-0.022015580907464027,
0.07443640381097794,
-0.04906652495265007,
-0.029324810951948166,
-0.0007560218218713999,
0.06357236951589584,
-0.0127740278840065,
0.028564898297190666,
0.04590648412704468,
-0.07318882644176483,
0.025323517620563507,
0.03144073486328125,
-0.024395592510700226,
0.013575495220720768,
-0.012149972841143608,
0.08503375947475433,
-0.01778685674071312,
-0.016388222575187683,
-0.006605823058634996,
-0.07296302914619446,
0.010460281744599342,
-0.011543132364749908,
-0.0023920058738440275,
0.0785350427031517,
-0.013732018880546093,
0.009103820659220219,
0.04074983298778534,
0.034995485097169876,
0.047839075326919556,
0.06398928910493851,
-0.016550933942198753,
0.05691439285874367,
-0.011487419717013836,
-0.032916709780693054,
0.0015394592192023993,
0.01547180861234665,
-0.03127389773726463,
-0.033928561955690384,
0.0204550139605999,
-0.01994803547859192,
-0.005219995975494385,
0.0013332258677110076,
0.02280307747423649,
-0.019060391932725906,
-0.006661418825387955,
0.009293860755860806,
-0.01351245492696762,
0.016323965042829514,
-0.05807409808039665,
0.0475781112909317,
0.008046077564358711,
-0.020327668637037277,
0.026089370250701904,
-0.03868785873055458,
0.10162652283906937,
0.04773005098104477,
-0.040034934878349304,
0.005909059662371874,
-0.0008280239417217672,
0.03224649280309677,
-0.0022632870823144913,
0.003483782522380352,
-0.03511660546064377,
-0.0025745949242264032,
-0.03493519127368927,
-0.011007354594767094,
-0.04370613768696785,
0.06895304471254349,
-0.0474434494972229,
-0.022178739309310913,
0.06626613438129425,
-0.016446644440293312,
0.05436183139681816,
-0.023959524929523468,
-0.016439810395240784,
0.03757110610604286,
-0.027912745252251625,
-0.03196733072400093,
-0.03998187184333801,
-0.016654348000884056,
0.006563479080796242,
-0.003868689062073827,
-0.007631432730704546,
0.019568834453821182,
-0.04945722222328186,
-0.04338223487138748,
-0.01487816497683525,
0.03923848643898964,
0.048505526036024094,
0.0073414635844528675,
0.03421361371874809,
0.041716016829013824,
-0.0474177710711956,
-0.003026881953701377,
-0.09803183376789093,
-0.013680616393685341,
-0.045251209288835526,
0.024328865110874176,
-0.02973855286836624,
0.022861268371343613,
-0.0018172546988353133,
0.004639823921024799,
-0.05868438631296158,
-0.02864210680127144,
-0.012315601110458374,
0.05985962972044945,
-0.006995636038482189,
-0.04509282857179642,
-0.027315564453601837,
-0.003517214674502611,
0.05524270981550217,
-0.013953213579952717,
-0.023141784593462944,
-0.01705930382013321,
-0.041155166923999786,
-0.026305587962269783,
-0.03955678641796112,
0.013757769949734211,
0.01476969663053751,
-0.002853048499673605,
0.007072800770401955,
-0.05872943624854088,
0.019078681245446205,
0.039009980857372284,
0.06758078187704086,
0.054382383823394775,
-0.0069182803854346275,
-0.03267368674278259,
0.018162311986088753,
-0.011563516221940517,
0.024443980306386948,
0.005379816517233849,
0.044542767107486725,
-0.0088582718744874,
-0.01728670485317707,
-0.006694789510220289,
-0.012472915463149548,
-0.24947188794612885,
0.0014069013996049762,
-0.009564063511788845,
-0.02772083878517151,
0.0524640828371048,
-0.02560477703809738,
0.03216256573796272,
-0.04136594384908676,
-0.01578245684504509,
-0.00499319052323699,
0.008214520290493965,
0.0414050929248333,
-0.005067138001322746,
0.025131477043032646,
0.036144498735666275,
0.045444685965776443,
-0.019224386662244797,
-0.008851013146340847,
0.017504459246993065,
0.0336729995906353,
0.03268874064087868,
-0.08394581824541092,
-0.01628398336470127,
0.04730357229709625,
0.008722029626369476,
0.036195334047079086,
-0.08801144361495972,
0.011975515633821487,
-0.029815785586833954,
0.01354283932596445,
0.0007280143909156322,
-0.017079830169677734,
0.016376275569200516,
0.030034463852643967,
-0.02605237253010273,
0.026816215366125107,
0.050819288939237595,
-0.005616634152829647,
0.03254608437418938,
-0.018066706135869026,
0.029092444106936455,
-0.03405441343784332,
0.0008193171815946698,
0.014835868962109089,
0.06226157769560814,
0.004883934743702412,
-0.08536610007286072,
-0.05202816426753998,
0.002035638550296426,
0.020459841936826706,
-0.01342265959829092,
-0.01821047253906727,
-0.03843735530972481,
0.037935055792331696,
0.00630598422139883,
-0.03513632342219353,
0.0011597595876082778,
-0.025110458955168724,
-0.0025808128993958235,
-0.014478886500000954,
0.013165493495762348,
-0.05084395036101341,
-0.022473560646176338,
-0.029606392607092857,
-0.012043574824929237,
-0.03753596171736717,
-0.06198061630129814,
-0.059234242886304855,
0.011049884371459484,
0.045422572642564774,
-0.013181683607399464,
0.02402423322200775,
-0.0008037416846491396,
-0.08443627506494522,
-0.009049727581441402,
-0.02432497777044773,
-0.023858657106757164,
-0.0024210242554545403,
0.013025054708123207,
0.06919112056493759,
-0.03387504443526268,
-0.05448921024799347,
0.018560582771897316,
0.03150319680571556,
0.04669618234038353,
-0.037479009479284286,
-0.022351078689098358,
-0.03530252352356911,
0.01567317545413971,
-0.00700418883934617,
0.05317330360412598,
0.016680393368005753,
-0.014171588234603405,
0.0011443160474300385,
0.040732093155384064,
-0.009303403086960316,
0.04139193519949913,
0.10224756598472595,
0.022954609245061874,
0.002173664513975382,
0.02483903244137764,
-0.06701615452766418,
-0.02788717672228813,
-0.0461139939725399,
-0.013537589460611343,
0.01799784041941166,
-0.03988691046833992,
-0.011861060746014118,
0.03446909040212631,
0.02471616305410862,
-0.040670037269592285,
-0.02580816112458706,
0.019770517945289612,
-0.0055776252411305904,
-0.039545800536870956,
0.0053713819943368435,
0.01754079759120941,
0.04757625237107277,
0.01758592575788498,
-0.023954128846526146,
-0.018106205388903618,
0.03361769765615463,
-0.02359202317893505,
-0.004094135016202927,
0.03503386303782463,
-0.02086116559803486,
-0.009810912422835827,
-0.026834683492779732,
-0.03760744258761406,
-0.00903293862938881,
-0.006123701110482216,
0.026982465758919716,
0.009544553235173225,
0.024277465417981148,
0.03894830867648125,
-0.03353865444660187,
0.02323732152581215,
0.00324808107689023,
0.02622653730213642,
0.002238087123259902,
0.009007168002426624,
-0.013002282939851284,
0.02848334237933159,
0.060872822999954224,
0.006074950098991394,
0.036778390407562256,
0.04005567729473114,
-0.018134964630007744,
0.00007223658758448437,
0.008661339059472084,
0.04977210611104965,
-0.04906030371785164,
-0.010934596881270409,
-0.017404036596417427,
0.015740571543574333,
-0.02355514094233513,
0.005054398439824581,
0.01159922406077385,
0.003243919461965561,
-0.08135173469781876,
0.05689745768904686,
-0.0043702879920601845,
-0.01128135435283184,
-0.004009682685136795,
0.007778587285429239,
0.01770527847111225,
-0.0019637811928987503,
0.027833350002765656,
0.03816788271069527,
0.015255472622811794,
0.019530195742845535,
-0.016243377700448036,
-0.04436034709215164,
-0.002164249774068594,
-0.01490105502307415,
0.025972863659262657,
0.012659863568842411,
-0.00860058143734932,
-0.0017227248754352331,
0.047954145818948746,
0.024062136188149452,
-0.0017024046974256635,
0.026469513773918152,
0.022583220154047012,
0.099022276699543,
0.01997648924589157,
-0.01838347315788269,
0.031760506331920624,
-0.04265323281288147,
0.000069133318902459,
-0.006276007741689682,
-0.006274155806750059,
-0.002361835213378072,
-0.02221965231001377,
-0.034774038940668106,
-0.051908399909734726,
0.01015707291662693,
0.03219016268849373,
-0.021158164367079735,
-0.0025065289810299873,
0.0011495487997308373,
-0.00690104067325592,
-0.056595392525196075,
-0.021758954972028732,
0.017524776980280876,
-0.06375910341739655,
0.006577130872756243,
0.0006644432432949543,
-0.019863704219460487,
0.021725332364439964,
-0.03715723007917404,
-0.03655627742409706,
-0.02999863587319851,
-0.004023839719593525,
0.01826626807451248,
-0.025204181671142578,
-0.009927283972501755,
-0.0018032942898571491,
0.010261730290949345,
-0.027457308024168015,
0.016519639641046524,
-0.019968798384070396,
-0.00902728084474802,
-0.024029769003391266,
-0.011977134272456169,
0.04366188496351242,
-0.024119220674037933,
-0.0006152976420708001,
0.006730696186423302,
-0.05756652355194092,
0.033190250396728516,
-0.049932945519685745,
0.0481569766998291,
0.0722607970237732,
-0.03057199902832508,
0.01633940450847149,
-0.03790730983018875,
0.02627613954246044,
0.02889709733426571,
0.002408017171546817,
0.019976666197180748,
-0.029764370992779732,
-0.04488862305879593,
0.04120488092303276,
-0.00007816454308340326,
0.060034915804862976,
0.007146209012717009,
0.019294336438179016,
-0.0460079051554203,
0.008011330850422382,
0.0037451854441314936,
0.0045600952580571175,
-0.013049909844994545,
-0.009561458602547646,
0.06341581791639328,
-0.03761739656329155,
-0.0389372855424881,
-0.08651691675186157,
-0.053476154804229736,
0.01810864917933941,
-0.005366629455238581,
0.018205802887678146,
-0.020159337669610977,
0.03814231976866722,
0.04514092579483986,
0.04833656921982765,
0.02169710025191307,
-0.02607869729399681,
0.046221647411584854,
-0.03153069317340851,
-0.000733766530174762,
-0.06439171731472015,
-0.04170754551887512,
0.04920215532183647,
-0.03881964832544327,
-0.013028421439230442,
-0.002087143249809742,
-0.052142564207315445,
0.061384376138448715,
-0.010235944762825966,
-0.042334217578172684,
0.030221713706851006,
-0.024063577875494957,
0.0060393973253667355,
0.039066068828105927,
-0.015710625797510147,
-0.018888983875513077,
-0.03359493240714073,
-0.04545854404568672,
-0.02629898115992546,
-0.019670836627483368,
0.034564998000860214,
-0.02294471114873886,
0.024272408336400986,
-0.0256635844707489,
-0.004417248070240021,
0.0212858896702528,
0.05891764909029007,
0.029319340363144875,
0.03444916009902954,
-0.023330148309469223,
0.07873030751943588,
0.013018426485359669,
-0.016213655471801758,
-0.008822123520076275,
-0.01842898689210415,
-0.009568368084728718,
-0.048568956553936005,
0.05649377033114433,
0.01329441275447607,
-0.008501166477799416,
-0.07047940790653229,
0.07658781111240387,
0.03893193602561951,
-0.026924854144454002,
-0.03564000502228737,
0.02352970838546753,
-0.026491878554224968,
-0.016491876915097237,
-0.01810198463499546,
-0.0044944086112082005,
0.00330162956379354,
0.08681079000234604,
0.017742132768034935,
0.04234021529555321,
0.11749196797609329,
0.022055108100175858,
-0.021836981177330017,
0.010303344577550888,
0.05696646124124527,
0.04963333159685135,
0.03719088062644005,
0.007148712873458862,
0.07554341107606888,
-0.027970297262072563,
-0.03348879516124725,
0.036024242639541626,
0.008696227334439754,
-0.013769598677754402,
-0.036350637674331665,
0.05862538516521454,
0.07758588343858719,
0.0027726709377020597,
0.0825178399682045,
-0.06022602692246437,
-0.0140891307964921,
0.037369854748249054,
0.008665774017572403,
0.026640888303518295,
0.054767657071352005,
0.020380165427923203,
0.020443720743060112,
-0.03573692962527275,
-0.026841431856155396,
-0.00006878580461489037,
-0.015711739659309387,
0.004188891500234604,
0.006942273583263159,
-0.014485450461506844,
-0.013327346183359623,
0.011527030728757381,
0.049567192792892456,
0.09539230167865753,
-0.02039465866982937,
-0.0599697045981884,
-0.01046045683324337,
0.00225087464787066,
0.012819966301321983,
0.05669894814491272,
-0.02696293592453003,
-0.02207828499376774,
-0.0017453638138249516,
-0.028816362842917442,
-0.012292603962123394,
0.015053877606987953,
0.008415261283516884,
0.02231341227889061,
-0.008071400225162506,
-0.028880050405859947,
0.009641343727707863,
0.0197403896600008,
-0.10154803097248077,
-0.03970104455947876,
-0.04445737972855568,
-0.04220445081591606,
-0.04066629707813263,
-0.027867566794157028,
0.007868999615311623,
0.00711252074688673,
-0.025604112073779106,
-0.006646071095019579,
-0.03922443464398384,
0.0073754373006522655,
-0.0031212172470986843,
-0.05762849748134613,
0.0006985150394029915,
0.020869387313723564,
0.00008982742292573676,
-0.015241919085383415,
0.05166370049118996,
0.01971837691962719,
-0.027412082999944687,
0.018260646611452103,
0.050594624131917953,
0.024344854056835175,
0.013465930707752705,
-0.009212288074195385,
-0.022572701796889305,
-0.10295496881008148,
0.01592615619301796,
0.02464377135038376,
-0.02107655443251133,
-0.07328950613737106,
0.013512304052710533,
-0.02287837117910385,
0.03936120867729187,
0.06337353587150574,
0.008776925504207611,
0.032910242676734924,
-0.02716139517724514,
-0.01532740518450737,
0.02836759202182293,
0.0341210663318634,
0.03384104743599892,
0.006173693574965,
0.05270334333181381,
0.04086221382021904,
0.017391985282301903,
-0.02146533504128456,
0.03017057664692402,
-0.013072163797914982,
0.020872950553894043,
-0.02689746394753456,
0.00637534586712718,
-0.05545075982809067,
-0.09926275908946991,
-0.016685862094163895,
0.02810380794107914,
-0.006737465504556894,
-0.0450325645506382,
0.007294226437807083,
-0.03190356492996216,
-0.03855523839592934,
-0.017217788845300674,
-0.017749959602952003,
0.010216661728918552,
-0.020316239446401596,
-0.0409671850502491,
-0.0404108501970768,
0.0041913483291864395,
-0.032755278050899506,
-0.022891074419021606,
-0.014226134866476059,
-0.027219872921705246,
0.016150711104273796,
-0.002814128529280424,
0.04618937522172928,
0.002322101267054677,
0.006727338768541813,
-0.034514397382736206
] |
363 |
What Secrets Do Your Manifolds Hold? Understanding the Local Geometry of Generative Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=etif9j1CnG
|
[
"Ahmed Imtiaz Humayun",
"Ibtihel Amara",
"Cristina Nader Vasconcelos",
"Deepak Ramachandran",
"Candice Schumann",
"Junfeng He",
"Katherine A Heller",
"Golnoosh Farnadi",
"Negar Rostamzadeh",
"Mohammad Havaei"
] |
Poster
|
Deep Generative Models are frequently used to learn continuous representations of complex data distributions using a finite number of samples. For any generative model, including pre-trained foundation models with GAN, Transformer or Diffusion architectures, generation performance can vary significantly based on which part of the learned data manifold is sampled. In this paper we study the post-training local geometry of the learned manifold and its relationship to generation outcomes for models ranging from toy settings to the latent decoder of the near state-of-the-art Stable Diffusion 1.4 Text-to-Image model. Building on the theory of continuous piecewise-linear (CPWL) generators, we characterize the local geometry in terms of three geometric descriptors - scaling ($\psi$), rank ($\nu$), and complexity ($\delta$). We provide quantitative and qualitative evidence showing that for a given latent, the local descriptors are indicative of generation aesthetics, artifacts, diversity, and memorization. Finally we demonstrate that training a reward model using the local geometry allows us to control the log-likelihood of a generated sample under the learned distribution, and improve the qualitative aspects of an image.
|
Geometry, Diffusion models, VAE, Generative Models, Guidance, Memorization, Out-of-Distribution Detection
|
We show that the local geometry of generative models is indicative of generation aesthetics, artifacts, diversity, and memorization.
| 13,284 |
2408.08307
|
[
-0.002909871283918619,
-0.021656179800629616,
0.0018811512272804976,
0.06962262839078903,
0.01777089759707451,
0.03962907940149307,
0.006871164310723543,
-0.006575451232492924,
-0.005555568262934685,
-0.05685121566057205,
0.00476309796795249,
-0.02409175969660282,
-0.061433106660842896,
0.03205592930316925,
-0.018766852095723152,
0.038671236485242844,
0.03186573460698128,
0.004460734315216541,
-0.006704431027173996,
0.04676993563771248,
-0.019479496404528618,
-0.023707060143351555,
0.016784299165010452,
0.0006423957529477775,
0.04089478403329849,
-0.00903960969299078,
0.023595863953232765,
0.004283740650862455,
0.008606459945440292,
0.002804212039336562,
-0.015172885730862617,
-0.013931282795965672,
0.004581792745739222,
-0.05345945060253143,
0.004695414565503597,
-0.038960836827754974,
-0.06153316795825958,
0.00751277431845665,
0.010860038921236992,
0.014640039764344692,
-0.04712191969156265,
-0.0036556145641952753,
0.012502491474151611,
0.021889090538024902,
-0.04543200135231018,
-0.02183503657579422,
-0.12606145441532135,
0.022391363978385925,
0.024007242172956467,
-0.02121977135539055,
-0.06931766122579575,
0.040435224771499634,
0.003875748021528125,
0.017954139038920403,
0.0016354540130123496,
0.016004128381609917,
0.07286884635686874,
-0.05612136423587799,
-0.008382684551179409,
-0.06493432074785233,
-0.04693472385406494,
0.038357190787792206,
0.005499935243278742,
0.00405163737013936,
-0.015035411342978477,
0.013875791803002357,
0.0008421424427069724,
0.04278608039021492,
-0.04748585820198059,
-0.038923587650060654,
-0.008949922397732735,
0.010815509594976902,
0.010263623669743538,
0.015693146735429764,
-0.005968193057924509,
-0.02192625217139721,
0.003350836457684636,
0.009706654585897923,
0.06571256369352341,
-0.010966147296130657,
0.008301634341478348,
0.02456839010119438,
0.017725951969623566,
0.044929973781108856,
-0.01583385467529297,
0.01714993081986904,
-0.052938707172870636,
0.014834927394986153,
-0.051645465195178986,
0.05558837577700615,
-0.03973190486431122,
-0.05900494009256363,
0.010185032151639462,
0.03103245235979557,
0.027705051004886627,
-0.01640993542969227,
0.040931060910224915,
0.023997046053409576,
0.011211896315217018,
-0.00885012000799179,
-0.012787927873432636,
-0.04153195768594742,
-0.019509119912981987,
0.002020238433033228,
-0.09246639907360077,
-0.023748507723212242,
-0.008900980465114117,
-0.03492865338921547,
-0.0023144895676523447,
-0.011752299964427948,
-0.0437704436480999,
-0.009614295326173306,
0.010859949514269829,
-0.014108111150562763,
-0.08007419109344482,
0.02764943242073059,
0.03515706956386566,
0.0027697915211319923,
-0.00035970352473668754,
0.025187915191054344,
0.04549888148903847,
0.039436131715774536,
-0.004690248053520918,
0.08018750697374344,
-0.021755551919341087,
0.010169317945837975,
0.028477415442466736,
0.019074779003858566,
-0.04635809361934662,
-0.021632056683301926,
0.025210866704583168,
0.037956081330776215,
0.014931285753846169,
0.0143834063783288,
0.03284955024719238,
-0.07578138262033463,
0.007651733234524727,
0.005802655592560768,
0.026710014790296555,
-0.025201188400387764,
0.009123739786446095,
-0.009486515074968338,
0.03609996661543846,
-0.022630149498581886,
0.07283661514520645,
-0.03806554153561592,
-0.007852059789001942,
-0.03972828760743141,
-0.024989591911435127,
-0.008332012221217155,
0.04664096236228943,
0.010211491957306862,
0.0097557557746768,
-0.06772366911172867,
0.0036600835155695677,
0.044319525361061096,
0.0019371481612324715,
0.06365518271923065,
0.005910513456910849,
-0.009400599636137486,
0.018300505355000496,
-0.006562459748238325,
-0.015711642801761627,
0.017996003851294518,
-0.0012554003624245524,
-0.06017865985631943,
0.046029288321733475,
0.0416746586561203,
-0.02218875288963318,
-0.013772150501608849,
-0.04401881992816925,
-0.03789937496185303,
0.031223833560943604,
0.0011366201797500253,
-0.035931747406721115,
-0.021206505596637726,
0.038181863725185394,
0.01803513802587986,
0.03615615516901016,
0.028639651834964752,
-0.08837971836328506,
0.025837592780590057,
0.033062007278203964,
-0.04622020944952965,
0.034586403518915176,
-0.05567736178636551,
0.09629513323307037,
0.0071321879513561726,
0.010313985869288445,
0.009430979378521442,
-0.05061065033078194,
-0.011179007589817047,
0.023185444995760918,
0.0032602595165371895,
0.05086086317896843,
0.018303995952010155,
-0.014511254616081715,
0.04482688754796982,
0.05896149203181267,
0.04665546491742134,
0.04566440358757973,
-0.0468357652425766,
0.056762292981147766,
-0.03686349093914032,
0.000256337778409943,
-0.024835145100951195,
0.05344616249203682,
-0.0699499249458313,
-0.048120543360710144,
0.013512984849512577,
-0.008470455184578896,
-0.025525689125061035,
-0.001335642416961491,
-0.01899164915084839,
0.006811518222093582,
0.013757348991930485,
-0.00043914318666793406,
-0.00022384400654118508,
0.024926548823714256,
-0.025054115802049637,
0.04568836838006973,
0.043908461928367615,
-0.029518509283661842,
0.0005759168998338282,
-0.01071595586836338,
0.10838771611452103,
0.07229231297969818,
-0.03644689545035362,
-0.002929529407992959,
0.010155139490962029,
-0.00028255468350835145,
0.024803468957543373,
-0.003969346173107624,
-0.023463493213057518,
0.0006891675875522196,
-0.005858400836586952,
0.018111810088157654,
-0.01514644455164671,
0.09741830825805664,
-0.06725193560123444,
-0.012876934371888638,
0.04355378821492195,
-0.0012673866003751755,
0.04502672702074051,
0.012098440900444984,
0.04538567736744881,
0.040089450776576996,
-0.014650978147983551,
-0.03016849420964718,
-0.02861679531633854,
-0.026996413245797157,
-0.003349610837176442,
-0.025145452469587326,
-0.008256755769252777,
0.027590466663241386,
-0.04383005201816559,
-0.017780613154172897,
-0.011275052092969418,
0.04845280572772026,
0.043233953416347504,
0.020043794065713882,
-0.0012455713003873825,
0.0007524937391281128,
-0.014698187820613384,
-0.032805755734443665,
-0.11224061250686646,
-0.023087339475750923,
-0.03340446203947067,
0.05975736677646637,
0.020934702828526497,
0.0593695305287838,
0.0057472591288387775,
0.026666564866900444,
-0.0428311713039875,
-0.027683362364768982,
0.008322863839566708,
0.023046737536787987,
-0.0020269646774977446,
-0.0437949076294899,
-0.016994347795844078,
0.020939139649271965,
0.05584963411092758,
-0.028070606291294098,
-0.0008021689718589187,
-0.03688923269510269,
-0.028625542297959328,
0.004097532015293837,
-0.019166283309459686,
-0.004217894282191992,
-0.0037272456102073193,
0.005162753164768219,
0.016456155106425285,
-0.013434145599603653,
0.014179373160004616,
0.029625214636325836,
0.0710580050945282,
0.030070524662733078,
-0.02785688452422619,
-0.02867054007947445,
0.011466036550700665,
0.001997321145609021,
0.048766180872917175,
-0.01825224794447422,
0.007264317013323307,
-0.025883104652166367,
0.012559499591588974,
0.014580974355340004,
-0.0072721512988209724,
-0.2903641164302826,
0.001272750087082386,
0.02918340638279915,
0.0033805235289037228,
0.021464787423610687,
0.017760809510946274,
0.0330418162047863,
-0.025627490133047104,
-0.023055141791701317,
0.013804261572659016,
-0.03924855589866638,
0.019682131707668304,
-0.005892359185963869,
0.054017823189496994,
0.040907081216573715,
0.0198539849370718,
-0.006440678145736456,
-0.0023368040565401316,
0.016487764194607735,
0.03700553625822067,
-0.05482058227062225,
-0.07866395264863968,
-0.05777955800294876,
0.048543695360422134,
-0.04117944464087486,
0.02193571999669075,
-0.05829577147960663,
-0.06234617158770561,
-0.021914798766374588,
0.01091883983463049,
-0.0018925460753962398,
-0.01646798849105835,
0.009151507169008255,
0.07183407247066498,
-0.017134739086031914,
0.004083536099642515,
0.011855022981762886,
-0.021834226325154305,
0.03121005930006504,
0.01392108853906393,
-0.01081084180623293,
0.008832649327814579,
-0.029155729338526726,
0.04785661771893501,
0.06059033423662186,
-0.027863414958119392,
-0.024337811395525932,
-0.02146804891526699,
-0.02684919163584709,
0.011923879384994507,
0.034101881086826324,
-0.04002460092306137,
-0.017966223880648613,
0.024994321167469025,
-0.004339045844972134,
-0.00946285855025053,
-0.011744935065507889,
-0.0061400942504405975,
-0.030607795342803,
0.010612467303872108,
0.03441431000828743,
-0.055105261504650116,
-0.016228310763835907,
-0.039983123540878296,
-0.022934982553124428,
-0.03903539478778839,
-0.08546093851327896,
-0.052467815577983856,
0.02944178506731987,
0.04126190394163132,
-0.02299617789685726,
0.05352560430765152,
-0.03348490223288536,
-0.0873815044760704,
0.03926078602671623,
0.018869267776608467,
-0.005103470291942358,
-0.02255241945385933,
0.021211784332990646,
0.02051975578069687,
-0.02755463682115078,
-0.035712722688913345,
0.03668569400906563,
0.026583177968859673,
0.007315945811569691,
0.005084083881229162,
0.0314570777118206,
-0.04269789159297943,
-0.036851685494184494,
-0.03579346090555191,
0.060775838792324066,
0.0023579781409353018,
0.039146892726421356,
-0.01644064672291279,
0.05458885431289673,
0.02637474238872528,
0.045092951506376266,
0.03944002836942673,
0.02782290428876877,
0.006407684646546841,
0.056983981281518936,
-0.06703709810972214,
-0.027873685583472252,
-0.004540088586509228,
-0.04435035213828087,
0.025623871013522148,
-0.04679473116993904,
0.014138401485979557,
0.04779655113816261,
-0.010591688565909863,
-0.03708777204155922,
-0.02923457697033882,
0.010002846829593182,
0.027330003678798676,
0.002765152370557189,
-0.03446383401751518,
0.013064373284578323,
0.01765996590256691,
0.02762560546398163,
-0.03762248530983925,
-0.029695000499486923,
0.043938905000686646,
-0.03356529772281647,
0.015537941828370094,
0.0018906586337834597,
0.020331338047981262,
-0.01088282186537981,
-0.007498966064304113,
0.0071709295734763145,
0.009032444097101688,
0.03654852509498596,
0.03519700467586517,
0.006159619893878698,
0.006789386738091707,
0.06291297823190689,
0.01118331030011177,
-0.005918673239648342,
-0.014772838912904263,
0.022003458812832832,
-0.002984269754961133,
0.05149196460843086,
0.014069433324038982,
0.049074672162532806,
0.015215104445815086,
0.025825994089245796,
0.0001293038367293775,
0.0033745199907571077,
0.00021883500448893756,
-0.01130952499806881,
-0.042445406317710876,
0.05216636508703232,
-0.05881095305085182,
-0.006610009353607893,
-0.045880768448114395,
0.0022447488736361265,
-0.016036735847592354,
0.0029435232281684875,
-0.00998825952410698,
0.009544658474624157,
-0.039660900831222534,
0.08022641390562057,
0.027489639818668365,
-0.0752352625131607,
0.0017190242651849985,
-0.0011427848367020488,
0.05464569479227066,
-0.006885715760290623,
-0.020583394914865494,
0.025400036945939064,
-0.01774066500365734,
0.03686080127954483,
-0.019673943519592285,
-0.031741973012685776,
-0.041082270443439484,
-0.017269372940063477,
0.013148808851838112,
0.009815054014325142,
-0.009593622758984566,
-0.0394759401679039,
0.03327453136444092,
0.019001973792910576,
0.009198625572025776,
0.023471105843782425,
-0.0007142028189264238,
0.05819066986441612,
0.009450643323361874,
-0.024191122502088547,
-0.007894033566117287,
-0.04591938108205795,
0.057014912366867065,
-0.004773226100951433,
0.012939510866999626,
-0.06563519686460495,
-0.02047080174088478,
-0.011791751720011234,
-0.04075181856751442,
0.019945601001381874,
0.02430075593292713,
-0.008184987120330334,
0.0056278761476278305,
-0.0070758843794465065,
0.04254404455423355,
-0.029002025723457336,
0.018026184290647507,
0.03430933132767677,
-0.06520289927721024,
0.0243093091994524,
0.0417761467397213,
-0.022044608369469643,
-0.008502913638949394,
-0.008724100887775421,
-0.011814526282250881,
-0.09127865731716156,
-0.06251227110624313,
0.00044609204633161426,
-0.02141876332461834,
-0.034486498683691025,
-0.028706973418593407,
0.003791241440922022,
-0.005896884016692638,
0.012474310584366322,
-0.0002926259476225823,
-0.013850362040102482,
-0.01720796339213848,
0.006210319232195616,
0.03811183571815491,
-0.039284203201532364,
-0.030071096494793892,
-0.023462902754545212,
-0.034555062651634216,
0.015434127300977707,
-0.02397342585027218,
0.02010781690478325,
0.04995183274149895,
-0.030197013169527054,
-0.003748892107978463,
-0.031258657574653625,
0.029866455122828484,
0.007064732722938061,
0.0002100497658830136,
0.012399211525917053,
0.004902018699795008,
-0.02766609750688076,
0.009713574312627316,
0.029416093602776527,
0.03563351556658745,
0.008653363212943077,
0.014341006055474281,
0.0013487053802236915,
0.01211800891906023,
0.020275019109249115,
-0.0037229740992188454,
-0.029703157022595406,
-0.04249202460050583,
0.045417021960020065,
-0.030664769932627678,
-0.0028496584855020046,
-0.08067215979099274,
0.013377755880355835,
0.025332238525152206,
-0.027426516637206078,
0.01855573244392872,
-0.05477553606033325,
0.005056404042989016,
0.01518048532307148,
0.01729465462267399,
-0.0033654586877673864,
-0.0011446132557466626,
0.033450283110141754,
-0.056297559291124344,
-0.017616096884012222,
-0.04112878441810608,
-0.013236943632364273,
0.04420711472630501,
-0.027597561478614807,
-0.010768881998956203,
-0.0003728361916728318,
-0.016089152544736862,
0.05357648432254791,
-0.0602729357779026,
-0.08068829029798508,
0.026336446404457092,
-0.02217145450413227,
-0.019365618005394936,
0.018880512565374374,
-0.040123261511325836,
-0.015127778053283691,
-0.009276775643229485,
-0.06555226445198059,
-0.0021090868394821882,
0.00525342533364892,
-0.0008311081328429282,
-0.010664175264537334,
-0.00013152946485206485,
0.020970860496163368,
0.03305229917168617,
0.05451914295554161,
0.06996592879295349,
0.041066475212574005,
0.004356628283858299,
-0.028842782601714134,
0.06567690521478653,
0.03982289880514145,
-0.006567150354385376,
0.0419858954846859,
0.015200452879071236,
-0.0039571737870574,
-0.05956423282623291,
0.035582609474658966,
-0.0032380863558501005,
-0.033071983605623245,
-0.06544402241706848,
0.029518665745854378,
0.01916932500898838,
-0.08266401290893555,
-0.04052446410059929,
0.03685571625828743,
-0.037533946335315704,
-0.002799812937155366,
-0.01784302480518818,
-0.0055097900331020355,
0.031546927988529205,
0.07420056313276291,
0.03053673915565014,
0.045931845903396606,
0.049585286527872086,
0.005310396663844585,
-0.017943069338798523,
0.004390062298625708,
0.07365169376134872,
0.06476104259490967,
0.03212421014904976,
-0.01514210645109415,
0.06080362945795059,
-0.0027698276098817587,
-0.05445151776075363,
0.00867544487118721,
0.011606509797275066,
-0.005456296727061272,
-0.08407095074653625,
0.012007087469100952,
0.07062595337629318,
0.024601036682724953,
0.05933107063174248,
-0.04436175152659416,
-0.010024580173194408,
0.018740005791187286,
0.026530956849455833,
-0.008612548001110554,
0.009352760389447212,
0.05570890009403229,
-0.014008836820721626,
-0.020585421472787857,
-0.002996201626956463,
-0.019476143643260002,
-0.028586192056536674,
0.026840511709451675,
0.03672534599900246,
-0.021057449281215668,
0.011400480754673481,
0.004126421641558409,
0.033048368990421295,
0.10527872294187546,
-0.04847290366888046,
-0.05670332536101341,
0.012297430075705051,
0.009525508619844913,
0.021925944834947586,
0.04830756410956383,
0.002118828007951379,
-0.009881512261927128,
0.010508731007575989,
-0.037823304533958435,
0.028379937633872032,
0.018988920375704765,
-0.009675736539065838,
-0.00033569306833669543,
-0.022490816190838814,
-0.00846952386200428,
0.0036467029713094234,
0.03201896324753761,
-0.007519070990383625,
-0.047199547290802,
-0.011652751825749874,
-0.03952735289931297,
-0.04322299733757973,
-0.046613581478595734,
0.037179749459028244,
-0.011440734378993511,
-0.039074137806892395,
0.001994060119614005,
0.009073518216609955,
0.015368427149951458,
0.03705752640962601,
-0.07420717179775238,
-0.015592933632433414,
0.05334730073809624,
0.019813114777207375,
0.006442733574658632,
0.021442530676722527,
0.019617000594735146,
-0.03670884296298027,
-0.01290288195014,
0.03074130229651928,
0.00024636805756017566,
0.005571522284299135,
-0.007114722393453121,
0.007554973475635052,
-0.11498839408159256,
0.023670991882681847,
0.018551593646407127,
-0.033161863684654236,
-0.09500811249017715,
0.03336131200194359,
-0.03539565950632095,
0.02407321147620678,
0.05573156103491783,
0.02522430382668972,
0.022381415590643883,
-0.055608268827199936,
0.005216849036514759,
0.007351376116275787,
-0.01586620695888996,
0.06035236641764641,
-0.013062738813459873,
0.06041339412331581,
0.039403051137924194,
0.006165030412375927,
-0.017076367512345314,
0.02856019139289856,
-0.030580278486013412,
0.0350613035261631,
-0.034235697239637375,
-0.026105396449565887,
-0.011161554604768753,
-0.10636875033378601,
-0.03646482527256012,
0.024072622880339622,
-0.0035151001065969467,
-0.036229800432920456,
-0.02084672823548317,
-0.05070020630955696,
-0.019383730366826057,
-0.004631991498172283,
-0.02524373307824135,
-0.0022602251265197992,
-0.024431101977825165,
-0.002050406066700816,
-0.06487727910280228,
0.01944490522146225,
0.002187819452956319,
0.03003026358783245,
-0.030446857213974,
-0.038087133318185806,
-0.030125554651021957,
-0.03606140986084938,
0.038212817162275314,
-0.010843608528375626,
0.02478749491274357,
0.012776914983987808
] |
364 |
L-WISE: Boosting Human Visual Category Learning Through Model-Based Image Selection and Enhancement
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=AoIKgHu9Si
|
[
"Morgan Bruce Talbot",
"Gabriel Kreiman",
"James J. DiCarlo",
"Guy Gaziv"
] |
Poster
|
The currently leading artificial neural network models of the visual ventral stream - which are derived from a combination of performance optimization and robustification methods - have demonstrated a remarkable degree of behavioral alignment with humans on visual categorization tasks. We show that image perturbations generated by these models can enhance the ability of humans to accurately report the ground truth class. Furthermore, we find that the same models can also be used out-of-the-box to predict the proportion of correct human responses to individual images, providing a simple, human-aligned estimator of the relative difficulty of each image. Motivated by these observations, we propose to augment visual learning in humans in a way that improves human categorization accuracy at test time. Our learning augmentation approach consists of (i) selecting images based on their model-estimated recognition difficulty, and (ii) applying image perturbations that aid recognition for novice learners. We find that combining these model-based strategies leads to categorization accuracy gains of 33-72% relative to control subjects without these interventions, on unmodified, randomly selected held-out test images. Beyond the accuracy gain, the training time for the augmented learning group was also shortened by 20-23%, despite both groups completing the same number of training trials. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach in a fine-grained categorization task with natural images, as well as two tasks in clinically relevant image domains - histology and dermoscopy - where visual learning is notoriously challenging. To the best of our knowledge, our work is the first application of artificial neural networks to increase visual learning performance in humans by enhancing category-specific image features.
|
Human-aligned models, robust neural networks, visual perception, perceptual learning, medical machine learning
|
Robust artificial neural networks can be used to design effective training strategies for enhancing visual category learning in human subjects, resulting in significant improvements in human accuracy and efficiency across multiple image domains.
| 13,281 | null |
[
0.0019360003061592579,
-0.005360879935324192,
0.015367163345217705,
-0.004435042385011911,
0.060504063963890076,
0.007182312663644552,
0.022480087354779243,
0.014404305256903172,
-0.057037122547626495,
-0.050114572048187256,
-0.03031974658370018,
0.03089985065162182,
-0.05712766572833061,
-0.0026387337129563093,
0.004002408590167761,
0.050120797008275986,
0.03929901495575905,
0.013421932235360146,
0.0028610636945813894,
0.032590243965387344,
-0.011142666451632977,
-0.03539760410785675,
0.004335802048444748,
0.012780159711837769,
-0.007863057777285576,
-0.014289231970906258,
0.025355195626616478,
-0.011286417953670025,
-0.007316190283745527,
0.008791619911789894,
0.03277073800563812,
-0.024246124550700188,
0.0054121301509439945,
-0.03217118978500366,
0.015111724846065044,
0.013540455140173435,
-0.015867015346884727,
-0.001355653046630323,
0.017428847029805183,
0.01041423436254263,
-0.04651164636015892,
-0.004191706422716379,
-0.016302550211548805,
0.0032260490115731955,
-0.05893538147211075,
0.007160671520978212,
-0.12009318172931671,
0.019473668187856674,
0.027388766407966614,
-0.03358691930770874,
-0.06765268743038177,
0.018486663699150085,
0.001287996768951416,
0.003916436340659857,
0.006143456790596247,
0.04079943150281906,
0.019897812977433205,
-0.06408074498176575,
-0.011432944796979427,
-0.0637597069144249,
-0.0006409983616322279,
0.019756382331252098,
0.017045680433511734,
0.001660126494243741,
0.0095420703291893,
-0.010627835988998413,
-0.028008582070469856,
0.024389736354351044,
-0.0402999185025692,
-0.01826820708811283,
-0.0003700800007209182,
-0.015045884996652603,
-0.011266589164733887,
0.003293226705864072,
-0.004461432341486216,
-0.03422408178448677,
-0.011771228164434433,
-0.0018769194139167666,
0.07545686513185501,
-0.04124191403388977,
0.0388592891395092,
0.031999677419662476,
0.024408498778939247,
0.043957021087408066,
0.002995793242007494,
0.022048862650990486,
-0.001019878895021975,
-0.04683653637766838,
-0.07419808208942413,
0.030465498566627502,
-0.030678508803248405,
-0.053738679736852646,
0.016897078603506088,
0.05835801735520363,
0.02477552741765976,
0.012679065577685833,
0.0105055570602417,
-0.011078675277531147,
0.010239149443805218,
0.0025761104188859463,
-0.018748896196484566,
-0.037530068308115005,
0.010382667183876038,
-0.0032737969886511564,
-0.1022680252790451,
-0.015878330916166306,
0.020260704681277275,
-0.014899645000696182,
-0.02607940509915352,
0.011126305907964706,
-0.04931892827153206,
-0.03311826288700104,
0.00878030713647604,
-0.012326966971158981,
-0.09540151804685593,
0.019639290869235992,
-0.0012420447310432792,
0.03494720160961151,
-0.01859637163579464,
-0.0017544549191370606,
0.03134675323963165,
0.03764486312866211,
-0.009211177937686443,
0.049311477690935135,
0.004601957276463509,
-0.019115375354886055,
0.025151096284389496,
0.028908606618642807,
-0.0013683147262781858,
-0.033760152757167816,
0.009862732142210007,
0.019624633714556694,
0.00738116167485714,
0.010394939221441746,
0.007180091459304094,
0.008516167290508747,
0.00535462936386466,
-0.03161783143877983,
0.010446952655911446,
0.01142842136323452,
0.0060966224409639835,
-0.04365362972021103,
0.06410609185695648,
-0.04703027382493019,
0.06848550587892532,
-0.03494562208652496,
0.009214123710989952,
0.00884316861629486,
-0.02811432257294655,
0.0009170965058729053,
0.00411736685782671,
-0.03175568953156471,
0.0004647458263207227,
-0.08394341915845871,
0.033804651349782944,
0.0973481759428978,
0.02270864136517048,
-0.003199144499376416,
0.007632318884134293,
-0.007054135203361511,
0.0009314764174632728,
-0.026949843391776085,
-0.006441654171794653,
0.016784539446234703,
-0.002099190838634968,
-0.05006936937570572,
0.01940334215760231,
0.016202598810195923,
-0.044739771634340286,
0.016892019659280777,
-0.03854299709200859,
-0.024079473689198494,
0.024074427783489227,
-0.011694400571286678,
-0.022443238645792007,
0.01168678980320692,
0.06834753602743149,
0.009681898169219494,
0.030977807939052582,
0.02688247337937355,
-0.10612868517637253,
0.03081410564482212,
-0.0024572699330747128,
-0.026582876220345497,
0.033651530742645264,
-0.03402810916304588,
0.07880351692438126,
-0.040568262338638306,
0.01064365915954113,
0.014233991503715515,
-0.0606224350631237,
0.004187770653516054,
0.022716036066412926,
-0.006734255701303482,
0.05947699397802353,
0.02242944948375225,
-0.02518065646290779,
0.051507700234651566,
0.0371910035610199,
0.050609465688467026,
0.0613379068672657,
-0.04006592184305191,
0.03779684752225876,
-0.01865497976541519,
-0.037059735506772995,
0.0055396161042153835,
0.01733759418129921,
-0.013773705810308456,
-0.016345109790563583,
0.012109187431633472,
-0.013340194709599018,
0.0019408187363296747,
-0.011851046234369278,
0.05080733820796013,
0.03141826018691063,
0.0073188175447285175,
0.0028715322259813547,
0.03737513720989227,
-0.010355083271861076,
-0.06515369564294815,
0.02397395670413971,
0.035614799708127975,
-0.01850486360490322,
-0.012079085223376751,
-0.012229732237756252,
0.09728071093559265,
0.03891175612807274,
-0.044952359050512314,
-0.013180773705244064,
0.00011070838809246197,
0.031069615855813026,
0.03277801349759102,
0.009455498307943344,
0.0037592623848468065,
-0.013843671418726444,
-0.013756448403000832,
0.02530207298696041,
-0.02032124064862728,
0.08284231275320053,
-0.04630565643310547,
0.00834691058844328,
0.051818251609802246,
-0.02036123536527157,
0.03418658673763275,
0.0017426004633307457,
0.015463004820048809,
0.03310496732592583,
0.004032499622553587,
-0.028258416801691055,
-0.01473965123295784,
-0.012372884899377823,
0.00981263816356659,
-0.015706567093729973,
-0.0033695867750793695,
0.04119643196463585,
-0.07444804906845093,
-0.03377613425254822,
-0.03181605413556099,
0.06412076950073242,
0.038076091557741165,
0.02343141660094261,
0.04645178094506264,
-0.02202226221561432,
0.0013481213245540857,
-0.02670316770672798,
-0.0813608169555664,
-0.031265921890735626,
-0.008516216650605202,
0.04508458077907562,
-0.023876113817095757,
0.04102640599012375,
0.010277415625751019,
0.03833990916609764,
-0.0578160434961319,
-0.006888810079544783,
0.03271768242120743,
0.05126825347542763,
0.013673191890120506,
-0.04597369581460953,
-0.01690581813454628,
0.0005073504289612174,
0.061629392206668854,
0.006441664882004261,
-0.025835253298282623,
-0.005795711185783148,
-0.060389477759599686,
-0.04395207017660141,
-0.03213886171579361,
-0.02756870537996292,
0.02611924521625042,
-0.0006313924095593393,
0.030988864600658417,
0.0069795651361346245,
-0.01338928285986185,
0.002795735839754343,
0.057883840054273605,
0.055872637778520584,
-0.006067000795155764,
-0.036819860339164734,
0.02482498064637184,
0.0005339158233255148,
0.043063219636678696,
0.01091853342950344,
0.0024972253013402224,
-0.011926330626010895,
-0.007390402257442474,
0.03343941271305084,
0.010575762018561363,
-0.2763819396495819,
-0.020362690091133118,
0.021481093019247055,
0.008991748094558716,
0.009843528270721436,
-0.0740603655576706,
0.04031258448958397,
-0.01962340623140335,
-0.005112490151077509,
0.010631877928972244,
0.006453966721892357,
0.029099805280566216,
-0.007543165702372789,
0.06965892761945724,
0.061401840299367905,
0.032779254019260406,
0.01957770250737667,
0.00022793616517446935,
-0.005584576167166233,
0.06571295857429504,
-0.029147973284125328,
-0.06784949451684952,
-0.03325791656970978,
0.06602492183446884,
-0.03652849420905113,
0.05920920521020889,
-0.05972539633512497,
-0.013721211813390255,
-0.0345853716135025,
-0.025239484384655952,
0.01989554986357689,
-0.025009635835886,
-0.010000653564929962,
0.0511043481528759,
0.018449882045388222,
0.0072256941348314285,
0.038540951907634735,
-0.04910345375537872,
0.02613336592912674,
-0.0019548870623111725,
-0.0051131462678313255,
-0.008904690854251385,
-0.015292879194021225,
0.028967753052711487,
0.06959129869937897,
0.0016301096184179187,
-0.054108984768390656,
-0.04664255678653717,
0.014261709526181221,
0.025567281991243362,
-0.025420695543289185,
-0.001276723574846983,
-0.029913878068327904,
0.04121752828359604,
-0.009226962924003601,
-0.0062438445165753365,
0.017825372517108917,
-0.0032751404214650393,
-0.02888486534357071,
-0.010323106311261654,
-0.015713613480329514,
-0.024565597996115685,
-0.02757147140800953,
-0.03791487589478493,
0.003841893980279565,
-0.015534977428615093,
-0.054829031229019165,
-0.05328579992055893,
0.024093929678201675,
0.042564138770103455,
-0.007648696191608906,
0.004983237013220787,
-0.038921501487493515,
-0.09754183143377304,
0.023653266951441765,
0.005373977590352297,
-0.028570132330060005,
-0.018279943615198135,
-0.018805919215083122,
0.03568341210484505,
0.00875779241323471,
-0.06926747411489487,
0.032762560993433,
-0.0022284581791609526,
0.0009793658973649144,
-0.010865768417716026,
0.02820960059762001,
-0.007968692108988762,
-0.0019618780352175236,
-0.02369474619626999,
0.05206134542822838,
0.015685761347413063,
0.014601355418562889,
-0.014930304139852524,
0.011858409270644188,
0.03905969485640526,
0.03672544285655022,
0.05563291162252426,
0.07162147015333176,
-0.0239885151386261,
0.0028676276560872793,
-0.07895076274871826,
-0.02005183883011341,
-0.02191275916993618,
-0.04473920539021492,
0.01307743601500988,
-0.053424593061208725,
-0.013666730374097824,
0.07344628125429153,
-0.042235828936100006,
-0.01637248694896698,
-0.018244238570332527,
0.024183964356780052,
-0.008155549876391888,
-0.009487705305218697,
-0.017670266330242157,
0.015572847798466682,
-0.006495242472738028,
0.03578983247280121,
0.0007460146443918347,
-0.012368442490696907,
0.0428716205060482,
-0.024402471259236336,
0.03407645970582962,
-0.0013285096501931548,
-0.033155061304569244,
0.0016992344753816724,
-0.025351405143737793,
-0.05363771691918373,
0.016457682475447655,
0.06513240933418274,
0.03970557451248169,
0.0007763842586427927,
0.023793900385499,
0.060342852026224136,
-0.002240248490124941,
0.006654378958046436,
0.0021126403007656336,
0.03622125834226608,
-0.04021523520350456,
0.025543661788105965,
0.0029208799824118614,
0.041696883738040924,
0.03454044833779335,
0.006978711113333702,
0.025359608232975006,
0.0004958697827532887,
-0.013539178296923637,
-0.033593978732824326,
0.01043333113193512,
0.0025100100319832563,
-0.058239080011844635,
-0.05660929158329964,
-0.01955578662455082,
0.014152162708342075,
0.008190869353711605,
0.016491858288645744,
-0.008633543737232685,
0.009841484017670155,
-0.07243312895298004,
0.023232629522681236,
0.02964099682867527,
-0.023195547983050346,
0.010597212240099907,
0.015641871839761734,
0.04283728450536728,
0.011434201151132584,
-0.059142082929611206,
0.023973727598786354,
0.026744099333882332,
0.017804056406021118,
-0.018230704590678215,
-0.012734469026327133,
-0.024892909452319145,
-0.04190683737397194,
-0.009673599153757095,
0.025038380175828934,
-0.022171474993228912,
-0.037466295063495636,
0.08484168350696564,
0.0065033757127821445,
-0.036122050136327744,
0.0010061071952804923,
-0.005097260233014822,
0.08390150219202042,
0.039579831063747406,
-0.031800445169210434,
0.0013315357500687242,
-0.04242784157395363,
0.0017811838770285249,
-0.010314999148249626,
-0.0025771702639758587,
-0.028531212359666824,
-0.021546605974435806,
-0.036260977387428284,
-0.029738903045654297,
0.006554043851792812,
-0.006000831723213196,
0.010895236395299435,
-0.011889531277120113,
-0.012271587736904621,
0.03149016574025154,
-0.0005025690188631415,
-0.021772190928459167,
0.010822281241416931,
-0.09475141018629074,
0.015291105955839157,
0.022753281518816948,
-0.04056992381811142,
0.012785824947059155,
-0.018027065321803093,
-0.025065813213586807,
-0.0328836627304554,
-0.06233565881848335,
-0.01646110601723194,
-0.0048459903337061405,
-0.023788217455148697,
-0.04344082251191139,
-0.01586231403052807,
-0.03110198862850666,
0.0070633538998663425,
-0.010470325127243996,
-0.019055498763918877,
0.003014909103512764,
0.013180340640246868,
0.033046480268239975,
-0.016103439033031464,
-0.03776838630437851,
0.01665402762591839,
-0.02178093045949936,
0.024412337690591812,
-0.046468354761600494,
0.00060217862483114,
0.06666088104248047,
-0.016279570758342743,
0.025180477648973465,
0.009390163235366344,
0.03869597986340523,
0.06627556681632996,
-0.02482886239886284,
0.03264395520091057,
0.018071316182613373,
-0.04447629675269127,
0.02546553872525692,
0.023982973769307137,
0.03349091485142708,
0.024952085688710213,
0.01588958501815796,
0.017074773088097572,
0.024091873317956924,
-0.007958845235407352,
-0.018661485984921455,
-0.00014221109449863434,
-0.015255140140652657,
0.04163877293467522,
-0.008682923391461372,
-0.034736085683107376,
-0.034985288977622986,
-0.0322503000497818,
0.03393765166401863,
0.004103017970919609,
0.05201784148812294,
-0.044087015092372894,
0.06791941076517105,
0.02209685556590557,
0.026610974222421646,
-0.031126277521252632,
0.016466332599520683,
0.02688777819275856,
-0.04634306579828262,
0.0013317555421963334,
-0.03256221488118172,
-0.0802508294582367,
0.05501627177000046,
-0.03384067863225937,
-0.01765764132142067,
-0.001690240460447967,
-0.05307482182979584,
0.06274740397930145,
-0.053788866847753525,
-0.03917548432946205,
0.006394143681973219,
-0.03298427164554596,
0.015565692447125912,
0.014633400365710258,
-0.05093511566519737,
0.022112851962447166,
-0.031194256618618965,
-0.04050039127469063,
-0.027731819078326225,
-0.004250157158821821,
0.040692053735256195,
-0.027498295530676842,
0.008055427111685276,
-0.0033055897802114487,
0.03242616727948189,
0.031697049736976624,
0.08085037022829056,
-0.00420473562553525,
-0.029218275099992752,
-0.03264181315898895,
0.07030072808265686,
0.014766073785722256,
0.020325275138020515,
-0.00009153622522717342,
0.0352633111178875,
-0.0015222457004711032,
-0.04191845655441284,
0.03642558678984642,
0.020004555583000183,
-0.00541958911344409,
-0.08508402109146118,
0.05255328491330147,
0.0345013402402401,
-0.03232442960143089,
-0.007135903462767601,
0.047317132353782654,
-0.03918161615729332,
0.01926175132393837,
0.0074278367683291435,
-0.002541112946346402,
0.0013184050330892205,
0.0551316924393177,
0.019364068284630775,
0.03649289906024933,
0.06885524839162827,
0.004436998162418604,
-0.020498650148510933,
0.02601342462003231,
0.05837806686758995,
0.05468713864684105,
0.05215928703546524,
0.0020548824686557055,
0.11185398697853088,
-0.02073020301759243,
-0.05238339677453041,
0.02161397598683834,
0.022720957174897194,
-0.019184807315468788,
-0.04105595126748085,
0.00022504624212160707,
0.06338068842887878,
0.019013138487935066,
0.043325480073690414,
-0.055279441177845,
0.023415707051753998,
0.047963947057724,
0.011311889626085758,
-0.011864054016768932,
-0.015971770510077477,
0.034655485302209854,
-0.016014747321605682,
-0.030678361654281616,
-0.007719287183135748,
-0.011991921812295914,
-0.00397565308958292,
0.018910827115178108,
-0.007500903680920601,
-0.04443872720003128,
-0.018000662326812744,
-0.01622149534523487,
0.05635838583111763,
0.11163772642612457,
-0.005130431614816189,
-0.031291477382183075,
-0.01717475987970829,
0.02500995621085167,
0.010716570541262627,
0.05091552808880806,
-0.0037264495622366667,
-0.004989125300198793,
-0.009923750534653664,
-0.02504582144320011,
0.03299662098288536,
0.034437261521816254,
0.02546248771250248,
0.030533846467733383,
-0.06999294459819794,
-0.040384210646152496,
0.04781794548034668,
0.01357532013207674,
-0.07031018286943436,
-0.0348944365978241,
-0.020894987508654594,
-0.04465965926647186,
-0.0468749925494194,
-0.04216935858130455,
0.043902426958084106,
-0.007964998483657837,
-0.02722681127488613,
-0.02349042519927025,
-0.00023151194909587502,
0.012257170863449574,
0.03585115820169449,
-0.07910200953483582,
-0.003918074537068605,
0.03345206379890442,
0.018208667635917664,
-0.023626120761036873,
0.0293880607932806,
0.010387546382844448,
-0.022200917825102806,
-0.022210443392395973,
0.04698433727025986,
-0.02830354869365692,
0.0036443951539695263,
-0.03736308589577675,
-0.011811461299657822,
-0.11047347635030746,
-0.005845055449754,
0.024735132232308388,
-0.04255640506744385,
-0.07602895796298981,
0.055967167019844055,
0.012143464758992195,
0.07409803569316864,
0.05880891904234886,
0.011819791980087757,
0.015971047803759575,
-0.05237547308206558,
-0.029866322875022888,
-0.03911265358328819,
0.034663669764995575,
0.042989011853933334,
-0.01822655089199543,
0.0680711567401886,
0.023671954870224,
-0.006929777096956968,
-0.022884326055645943,
0.030729439109563828,
-0.019809653982520103,
0.0031011945102363825,
-0.04248268902301788,
-0.025650233030319214,
-0.040342364460229874,
-0.10239335149526596,
-0.01927298866212368,
0.014515732415020466,
0.018253590911626816,
-0.034378111362457275,
-0.034003425389528275,
-0.03202081471681595,
-0.003991597797721624,
-0.018280278891324997,
0.01245999988168478,
-0.034926269203424454,
-0.043022532016038895,
-0.04325662925839424,
-0.05004935339093208,
0.01214885339140892,
-0.022728824988007545,
0.036594778299331665,
-0.008363648317754269,
-0.04809943214058876,
-0.004474006127566099,
0.006390690803527832,
0.04662209749221802,
0.008230072446167469,
0.03187592327594757,
-0.0399128682911396
] |
365 |
Predictive Uncertainty Quantification for Bird's Eye View Segmentation: A Benchmark and Novel Loss Function
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=k3y0oyK7sn
|
[
"Linlin Yu",
"Bowen Yang",
"Tianhao Wang",
"Kangshuo Li",
"Feng Chen"
] |
Poster
|
The fusion of raw sensor data to create a Bird's Eye View (BEV) representation is critical for autonomous vehicle planning and control. Despite the growing interest in using deep learning models for BEV semantic segmentation, anticipating segmentation errors and enhancing the explainability of these models remain underexplored. This paper introduces a comprehensive benchmark for predictive uncertainty quantification in BEV segmentation, evaluating multiple uncertainty quantification methods across three popular datasets with three representative network architectures. Our study focuses on the effectiveness of quantified uncertainty in detecting misclassified and out-of-distribution (OOD) pixels while also improving model calibration. Through empirical analysis, we uncover challenges in existing uncertainty quantification methods and demonstrate the potential of evidential deep learning techniques, which capture both aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty. To address these challenges, we propose a novel loss function, Uncertainty-Focal-Cross-Entropy (UFCE), specifically designed for highly imbalanced data, along with a simple uncertainty-scaling regularization term that improves both uncertainty quantification and model calibration for BEV segmentation.
|
Uncertainty Quantification, Evidential Deep Learning, Bird's Eye View (BEV) Segmentation
| null | 13,279 |
2405.20986
|
[
0.009136172011494637,
0.005590626038610935,
-0.023418284952640533,
0.015585298649966717,
0.03144880756735802,
0.050197068601846695,
0.03100401535630226,
0.007406400982290506,
-0.02549896016716957,
-0.05436992645263672,
-0.05277600139379501,
0.01009567454457283,
-0.06297595053911209,
-0.022765351459383965,
-0.012794341892004013,
0.05227154865860939,
0.03137905150651932,
-0.000028346601538942195,
0.03118034079670906,
0.04173332080245018,
0.010984426364302635,
-0.055481329560279846,
-0.005363766103982925,
0.010213211178779602,
0.04829763248562813,
-0.04977010563015938,
0.020997341722249985,
0.016837837174534798,
-0.017945008352398872,
0.009775148704648018,
0.029802970588207245,
-0.018761401996016502,
-0.010721257887780666,
-0.057785701006650925,
0.010815739631652832,
0.028403956443071365,
-0.026643211022019386,
0.01644926331937313,
-0.015911761671304703,
0.008874006569385529,
-0.048523128032684326,
-0.0032951480243355036,
-0.020844249054789543,
-0.016818027943372726,
-0.049886006861925125,
-0.006657249294221401,
-0.07015176862478256,
0.03151635825634003,
0.005476727616041899,
-0.011422045528888702,
-0.06999921053647995,
0.01768573373556137,
-0.024479735642671585,
0.00898245070129633,
0.011725329793989658,
0.03742964193224907,
0.051185399293899536,
-0.08792774379253387,
-0.02753930166363716,
-0.05289279669523239,
0.02068239077925682,
0.007985313422977924,
0.020808247849345207,
0.0018187196692451835,
-0.0273998212069273,
-0.02565094456076622,
-0.011840256862342358,
0.05298119783401489,
-0.040720537304878235,
-0.008348711766302586,
0.0017330643022432923,
-0.011078800074756145,
0.013708465732634068,
0.031106945127248764,
-0.012641681358218193,
-0.0366876944899559,
0.002574095968157053,
0.04793001711368561,
0.05281917005777359,
-0.034635938704013824,
0.08256104588508606,
0.008204986341297626,
-0.0007688231999054551,
0.01775497943162918,
0.02723807655274868,
0.02119825966656208,
0.00098619912751019,
-0.050934843719005585,
-0.07786836475133896,
0.04031383618712425,
0.006064415443688631,
-0.054833512753248215,
0.024240538477897644,
0.02537819929420948,
-0.004144035279750824,
0.005421906244009733,
0.02974936179816723,
0.004622012842446566,
0.01479276455938816,
-0.04648364707827568,
0.015191919170320034,
-0.007635296788066626,
0.03077266924083233,
-0.009365584701299667,
-0.09663789719343185,
-0.0350373312830925,
-0.04916644096374512,
-0.023683005943894386,
-0.017614994198083878,
0.01759323664009571,
-0.03397149592638016,
-0.003513502888381481,
0.004253542050719261,
-0.016044313088059425,
-0.08344469219446182,
0.009792671538889408,
-0.012188290245831013,
-0.0062767439521849155,
-0.00017102353740483522,
-0.007062291260808706,
0.03955896571278572,
0.08698152750730515,
0.008494537323713303,
0.05388691648840904,
-0.014273406937718391,
0.027038857340812683,
-0.017143798992037773,
0.03405122458934784,
-0.04740215092897415,
-0.024610936641693115,
-0.0157921239733696,
0.026046598330140114,
-0.03573702275753021,
-0.01881059817969799,
0.009050399996340275,
-0.05031484737992287,
0.013746694661676884,
0.004015469923615456,
0.011719122529029846,
0.0067192488349974155,
0.00572016928344965,
-0.06158578395843506,
0.06081017479300499,
0.01254731323570013,
0.05618886277079582,
-0.02051117643713951,
0.03840484097599983,
0.008121526800096035,
-0.07219462841749191,
-0.006271976977586746,
-0.022956810891628265,
-0.035323552787303925,
-0.028025111183524132,
-0.07815622538328171,
0.000806047348305583,
0.0312397088855505,
0.045182134956121445,
0.014038784429430962,
0.0027000638656318188,
0.0268519539386034,
0.01593206077814102,
-0.0017518042586743832,
-0.012973797507584095,
0.02159200794994831,
-0.01130550168454647,
-0.0701005607843399,
0.07716406881809235,
0.024272404611110687,
-0.03395950421690941,
0.02264120988547802,
-0.022534020245075226,
-0.08095229417085648,
0.06289912760257721,
0.009484185837209225,
0.020864233374595642,
0.012012479826807976,
0.06798592209815979,
-0.03824002295732498,
0.024546049535274506,
0.05725507810711861,
-0.07588402181863785,
0.025673096999526024,
0.0033620947506278753,
-0.014535553753376007,
0.010541399009525776,
-0.03318026289343834,
0.06408044695854187,
-0.028751322999596596,
-0.02111315354704857,
0.007811434101313353,
-0.06639380753040314,
-0.018816104158759117,
0.016227105632424355,
-0.0041551748290658,
0.058923110365867615,
-0.031076019629836082,
0.007122326176613569,
0.01004508975893259,
0.017469799146056175,
0.049414750188589096,
0.02426309324800968,
-0.04904213920235634,
0.053272902965545654,
-0.0029339008033275604,
-0.020836612209677696,
-0.001124728936702013,
0.0568014420568943,
0.006793436128646135,
-0.053536154329776764,
0.03960647061467171,
-0.006052609533071518,
0.010179738514125347,
0.0006062880274839699,
0.03040616773068905,
0.02911410480737686,
-0.002584052737802267,
-0.005126246716827154,
0.002951244357973337,
0.004346371162682772,
-0.03836071491241455,
0.018282493576407433,
0.04356374591588974,
-0.01708458550274372,
-0.014243317767977715,
-0.01636006310582161,
0.07782276719808578,
0.08256237208843231,
-0.03279612213373184,
-0.0056866854429244995,
-0.01117592304944992,
-0.0063739679753780365,
0.039963554590940475,
0.0016912195133045316,
-0.04696935787796974,
0.008625916205346584,
-0.02702174335718155,
0.03978281468153,
-0.03087712451815605,
0.07640843838453293,
-0.04553353413939476,
-0.009482848457992077,
0.03114047646522522,
0.008202320896089077,
0.039561677724123,
0.007165284361690283,
-0.009741878136992455,
0.09311884641647339,
-0.011378680355846882,
-0.021203240379691124,
-0.035726550966501236,
-0.023407788947224617,
0.01726425066590309,
0.0009692407329566777,
-0.018163491040468216,
-0.012449720874428749,
-0.04366830736398697,
0.023200733587145805,
-0.012754150666296482,
0.07933004200458527,
0.053558915853500366,
0.031144991517066956,
0.021149400621652603,
0.009902458637952805,
-0.010508887469768524,
-0.01865510083734989,
-0.1276947408914566,
-0.08870435506105423,
-0.01569633185863495,
0.05129701644182205,
0.022035950794816017,
0.048565566539764404,
0.00951702706515789,
0.060780856758356094,
-0.004790583625435829,
0.030519718304276466,
0.042125970125198364,
0.01561097614467144,
0.022699886932969093,
0.014075970277190208,
0.007062740158289671,
0.02172875963151455,
0.07393813133239746,
0.0074335201643407345,
-0.030229490250349045,
0.02438710257411003,
-0.026614610105752945,
0.036292869597673416,
-0.018405651673674583,
-0.0172656811773777,
-0.007773918565362692,
0.0235630851238966,
0.018054531887173653,
-0.002463586162775755,
0.030889062210917473,
0.025438811630010605,
0.045157793909311295,
0.04867427051067352,
-0.00923202559351921,
-0.04088211804628372,
0.03493253141641617,
-0.0020136067178100348,
0.035467199981212616,
0.014497492462396622,
-0.03345222398638725,
-0.006917951628565788,
0.006393087562173605,
0.033433400094509125,
0.005356504116207361,
-0.26682212948799133,
0.0027599267195910215,
0.011877498589456081,
-0.01913941279053688,
0.024262428283691406,
-0.026064619421958923,
0.03946784511208534,
-0.02724115364253521,
-0.01074516586959362,
0.020883124321699142,
0.036838214844465256,
-0.013712923973798752,
0.015736563131213188,
0.06962650269269943,
0.038674600422382355,
0.039230022579431534,
0.02772761695086956,
-0.006749819032847881,
0.022740188986063004,
0.023176906630396843,
-0.037510063499212265,
-0.07128120213747025,
-0.027744309976696968,
0.032577063888311386,
-0.009063417091965675,
0.025089483708143234,
-0.05563695728778839,
0.0050908648408949375,
-0.028068946674466133,
0.005174056626856327,
0.033412326127290726,
-0.004879920277744532,
-0.010131790302693844,
0.022023504599928856,
0.014315915293991566,
-0.014093473553657532,
0.027745777741074562,
-0.041031062602996826,
0.00013258376566227525,
0.003358901245519519,
-0.005644646473228931,
0.023943904787302017,
-0.0137970931828022,
0.015633853152394295,
0.07673347741365433,
-0.0028985864482820034,
-0.01981453411281109,
-0.03226977214217186,
-0.00901889894157648,
0.009808989241719246,
0.007630945183336735,
0.011226155795156956,
-0.009355918504297733,
0.010826585814356804,
-0.0011780399363487959,
-0.0030100024305284023,
0.01293540745973587,
-0.03048723004758358,
-0.02443999983370304,
0.000621868995949626,
-0.010496175847947598,
-0.06921157985925674,
-0.04037681967020035,
-0.01688750833272934,
0.01613013632595539,
-0.06677648425102234,
-0.05008107051253319,
-0.06089881435036659,
0.04675363749265671,
-0.0025392791721969843,
-0.002818350913003087,
0.011289652436971664,
-0.04661897197365761,
-0.09620728343725204,
0.042623743414878845,
-0.0018193406285718083,
0.02200966887176037,
-0.04542339965701103,
-0.01575254462659359,
0.03655826300382614,
-0.029467729851603508,
-0.036723293364048004,
0.05728575587272644,
0.03548068180680275,
0.029295148327946663,
-0.009233460761606693,
0.0029410170391201973,
-0.016464276239275932,
-0.03025587648153305,
-0.04442776367068291,
0.06778141111135483,
0.016668835654854774,
0.005973380524665117,
-0.004259074106812477,
0.020764848217368126,
0.04638921469449997,
0.03811993449926376,
0.04342362657189369,
0.051389873027801514,
-0.004422290716320276,
0.029894383624196053,
-0.06668490171432495,
0.002760982373729348,
-0.027378683909773827,
-0.05843793973326683,
0.011099735274910927,
0.002067608991637826,
0.006003082729876041,
0.04137197509407997,
-0.0011291210539638996,
-0.013209882192313671,
-0.016843445599079132,
0.006944613065570593,
0.00884645339101553,
-0.016090333461761475,
-0.022866996005177498,
-0.010167825035750866,
0.022419575601816177,
0.023661937564611435,
-0.006824907381087542,
-0.01676219515502453,
0.022804297506809235,
-0.046558212488889694,
0.005013637710362673,
-0.03850153088569641,
-0.005159047897905111,
-0.00373813952319324,
-0.015146368183195591,
-0.048994068056344986,
0.00244429474696517,
0.034641120582818985,
0.05247625708580017,
-0.0068076010793447495,
0.03227805718779564,
0.04863489046692848,
-0.020695867016911507,
0.011543627828359604,
-0.01582443341612816,
0.041155893355607986,
-0.036816008388996124,
0.025361450389027596,
0.004167552106082439,
0.06933743506669998,
0.04091564938426018,
0.017467807978391647,
0.022607257589697838,
-0.02200474590063095,
-0.026685340330004692,
-0.02231118083000183,
-0.026032796129584312,
0.004518503323197365,
-0.05355767533183098,
-0.024658650159835815,
-0.030091997236013412,
0.021651655435562134,
-0.02107686549425125,
0.01907571405172348,
-0.03858489543199539,
0.0007584072300232947,
-0.04971278831362724,
0.05404142662882805,
0.07166449725627899,
0.002279682317748666,
-0.03169426694512367,
-0.00009659294300945476,
0.03357720747590065,
0.024902407079935074,
-0.028125949203968048,
0.01800544001162052,
0.00743032805621624,
-0.0008354961755685508,
-0.07332690805196762,
-0.03091239370405674,
-0.03586050868034363,
-0.02406422793865204,
0.0037998021580278873,
-0.0018522964091971517,
-0.04880141466856003,
-0.05496823415160179,
0.027484960854053497,
0.012225824408233166,
0.011579054407775402,
0.028246385976672173,
-0.028136877343058586,
0.049540773034095764,
0.006802866701036692,
-0.014095191843807697,
-0.014845206402242184,
-0.007462747860699892,
0.020282011479139328,
-0.01713280938565731,
0.03848432004451752,
-0.05997993052005768,
0.009573735296726227,
-0.03640452399849892,
-0.05156554654240608,
0.004060809966176748,
0.011144508607685566,
-0.02221512421965599,
-0.048674918711185455,
-0.03626466169953346,
-0.005488651338964701,
-0.02726709097623825,
0.0007675198721699417,
0.014665002934634686,
-0.05724533647298813,
0.023287145420908928,
0.07082746922969818,
-0.02862297184765339,
0.04282994195818901,
-0.04587913677096367,
-0.029235651716589928,
-0.052559543401002884,
-0.03409048169851303,
0.009870097041130066,
0.008957541547715664,
-0.02125789225101471,
-0.0242838803678751,
0.003010378684848547,
0.0026364782825112343,
0.0018305310513824224,
-0.04490625113248825,
0.01471935585141182,
-0.038105763494968414,
0.027014944702386856,
0.06622849404811859,
-0.03147147223353386,
-0.012372717261314392,
0.022536499425768852,
-0.018455171957612038,
-0.017076198011636734,
-0.013196283020079136,
0.021282440051436424,
0.042844921350479126,
-0.030507946386933327,
0.016813788563013077,
-0.03992244973778725,
0.029056061059236526,
-0.0006046429043635726,
0.0050481460057199,
-0.015968168154358864,
0.042863067239522934,
-0.016334492713212967,
0.007082101423293352,
-0.007246250286698341,
0.010297449305653572,
0.0010810979874804616,
0.022292304784059525,
0.003919555339962244,
0.013809003867208958,
-0.018147725611925125,
0.0006260082591325045,
-0.041059914976358414,
0.020793654024600983,
0.05199125036597252,
-0.019426388666033745,
-0.03974675014615059,
-0.054592251777648926,
-0.03632141649723053,
0.005146382376551628,
-0.020533885806798935,
0.027818096801638603,
-0.02184794843196869,
-0.00035900171496905386,
-0.0014928292948752642,
0.021209925413131714,
-0.037558555603027344,
-0.03595846891403198,
0.029841523617506027,
-0.06314506381750107,
0.054328348487615585,
-0.06548977643251419,
-0.02168479561805725,
0.06527434289455414,
-0.03772253543138504,
0.005315334536135197,
-0.008335797116160393,
-0.04496853053569794,
0.021514814347028732,
-0.03822264075279236,
-0.05347403883934021,
0.003911793231964111,
-0.02338409423828125,
-0.0199356060475111,
0.00011658739822451025,
-0.020751651376485825,
0.02059001475572586,
-0.01363018061965704,
-0.0274631530046463,
-0.002999047515913844,
0.03775477409362793,
0.011191212572157383,
-0.025183571502566338,
-0.0011299926554784179,
-0.04660160839557648,
0.0198033656924963,
0.04471698775887489,
0.058612845838069916,
0.03046388365328312,
0.007076691836118698,
-0.05399060249328613,
0.06744761765003204,
0.028232239186763763,
0.02387848123908043,
0.018546806648373604,
0.005541632417589426,
-0.009660937823355198,
-0.060344990342855453,
0.05869382619857788,
0.011599145829677582,
0.004635551478713751,
-0.07080411911010742,
0.04189717397093773,
0.05212485417723656,
-0.05143290385603905,
0.014678101055324078,
0.009685673750936985,
-0.04061461240053177,
0.00226429826579988,
0.022435912862420082,
-0.03095129318535328,
-0.006681255530565977,
0.034814056009054184,
0.023796383291482925,
0.03898203745484352,
0.04821152612566948,
0.02077511139214039,
-0.005604378413408995,
0.006519901100546122,
0.07537614554166794,
0.06696843355894089,
0.06537266075611115,
-0.005103943403810263,
0.06185922399163246,
-0.04927583038806915,
-0.055139120668172836,
0.031254298985004425,
0.003406904172152281,
0.007066870108246803,
-0.03035399504005909,
-0.002669003326445818,
0.09435230493545532,
0.05666803941130638,
0.0481303334236145,
-0.0681270882487297,
0.017071740701794624,
0.021444592624902725,
0.02542985789477825,
0.0019639208912849426,
0.03500797599554062,
0.024468526244163513,
0.01669492945075035,
-0.0005241894396021962,
-0.006627998314797878,
-0.025367645546793938,
-0.010262700729072094,
0.008939199149608612,
-0.010434686206281185,
-0.03531548008322716,
-0.011860793456435204,
-0.017222309485077858,
0.02404213510453701,
0.08936987817287445,
-0.04678582400083542,
-0.07775858789682388,
0.01571432501077652,
-0.009356416761875153,
-0.008010106161236763,
0.06250956654548645,
0.048624005168676376,
-0.028111832216382027,
0.0036720428615808487,
-0.02621200494468212,
0.021994013339281082,
-0.0035228568594902754,
0.0015166805824264884,
-0.016556574031710625,
-0.02477656863629818,
-0.05143493413925171,
0.03234807774424553,
0.006815994158387184,
-0.045478735119104385,
-0.042262330651283264,
-0.04633602127432823,
-0.046807169914245605,
-0.04061689227819443,
-0.07696983218193054,
0.017814626917243004,
-0.0011165199102833867,
-0.02264019288122654,
-0.02405785396695137,
-0.0188082754611969,
0.020747965201735497,
0.03218422085046768,
-0.03462944179773331,
0.0037159796338528395,
0.08899122476577759,
-0.022212056443095207,
-0.01779756136238575,
0.03578450530767441,
0.036497022956609726,
0.010126670822501183,
-0.00933638121932745,
0.03828015550971031,
0.013028336688876152,
0.0024001398123800755,
-0.015213499777019024,
0.00570661062374711,
-0.07090230286121368,
0.0058134193532168865,
0.04799939692020416,
-0.04096363112330437,
-0.06986591964960098,
0.0629655197262764,
-0.028525426983833313,
-0.002692628186196089,
0.07290074229240417,
-0.0028406651690602303,
0.05511420965194702,
-0.014121653512120247,
-0.037586625665426254,
-0.04787863418459892,
-0.021762637421488762,
0.03273363783955574,
-0.03125326707959175,
0.03503884747624397,
0.035221412777900696,
0.017395731061697006,
-0.025961291044950485,
0.05507242679595947,
0.01620340906083584,
0.021525872871279716,
-0.026841534301638603,
-0.016379037871956825,
-0.05345676839351654,
-0.11500891298055649,
0.020984619855880737,
0.0008768313564360142,
0.004675122909247875,
-0.014256303198635578,
-0.012415332719683647,
0.01393156684935093,
0.0015787252923473716,
0.009094818495213985,
0.0031790214125066996,
-0.01931939460337162,
-0.028454389423131943,
-0.05210534855723381,
-0.09440285712480545,
0.04611111059784889,
-0.01789005845785141,
0.0042899721302092075,
-0.009570203721523285,
-0.0805148035287857,
-0.007841619662940502,
-0.00913102924823761,
0.025776555761694908,
0.014552359469234943,
0.007782997563481331,
-0.017135120928287506
] |
366 |
DiscoveryBench: Towards Data-Driven Discovery with Large Language Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=vyflgpwfJW
|
[
"Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder",
"Harshit Surana",
"Dhruv Agarwal",
"Bhavana Dalvi Mishra",
"Abhijeetsingh Meena",
"Aryan Prakhar",
"Tirth Vora",
"Tushar Khot",
"Ashish Sabharwal",
"Peter Clark"
] |
Poster
|
Can the rapid advances in code generation, function calling, and data analysis using large language models (LLMs) help automate the search and verification of hypotheses purely from a set of provided datasets? To evaluate this question, we present DiscoveryBench, the first comprehensive benchmark that formalizes the multi-step process of data-driven discovery. The benchmark is designed to systematically assess current model capabilities in discovery tasks and provide a useful resource for improving them. Our benchmark contains 264 tasks collected across 6 diverse domains, such as sociology and engineering, by manually deriving discovery workflows from published papers to approximate the real-world challenges faced by researchers, where each task is defined by a dataset, its metadata, and a discovery goal in natural language. We additionally provide 903 synthetic tasks to conduct controlled evaluations on data-driven workflows that are not covered in the manually collected split. Furthermore, our structured formalism of data-driven discovery enables a facet-based evaluation that provides useful insights into different failure modes. We evaluate several popular LLM-based reasoning frameworks using both open and closed LLMs as baselines on DiscoveryBench and find that even the best system scores only 25%. Our benchmark, thus, illustrates the challenges in autonomous data-driven discovery and serves as a valuable resource for the community to make progress.
|
scientific discovery, data-driven discovery, data analysis, large language models, hypothesis generation, hypothesis verification
|
We present DiscoveryBench, the first comprehensive benchmark that formalizes the multi-step process of data-driven discovery designed to systematically assess current LLM capabilities in discovery tasks.
| 13,276 |
2407.01725
|
[
-0.0304252952337265,
-0.02368338592350483,
-0.03129073977470398,
0.025721292942762375,
0.038970697671175,
0.026534872129559517,
0.041885264217853546,
0.004640522878617048,
-0.02590363100171089,
-0.00461885379627347,
-0.01784992218017578,
0.023085635155439377,
-0.03333015367388725,
-0.011716368608176708,
-0.011505083180963993,
0.049889203161001205,
0.021602539345622063,
-0.005770625546574593,
0.05321088805794716,
-0.003180181607604027,
0.002005071844905615,
0.00003970746911363676,
0.0055040232837200165,
0.05232932046055794,
0.024006491526961327,
0.02712222933769226,
0.03148793801665306,
-0.002615751698613167,
-0.043493643403053284,
0.013601532205939293,
0.04799877107143402,
-0.03165798261761665,
0.034823328256607056,
-0.012523788958787918,
0.002861569868400693,
-0.0022239212412387133,
-0.03406396880745888,
0.01438083965331316,
0.010416659526526928,
0.011003007180988789,
-0.031041152775287628,
0.031376127153635025,
-0.007819338701665401,
0.03702227398753166,
-0.0569622740149498,
0.037519149482250214,
-0.1157943606376648,
0.03696190565824509,
0.01850983500480652,
-0.0014213868416845798,
-0.09044225513935089,
0.009413733147084713,
0.0011156642576679587,
-0.01577949896454811,
0.0021472452208399773,
0.05154256895184517,
0.052951883524656296,
-0.0873182937502861,
-0.0012824893929064274,
-0.04383689910173416,
-0.0059062037616968155,
0.028726251795887947,
0.01173015870153904,
0.007260690443217754,
0.0036669427063316107,
-0.012306833639740944,
-0.017294229939579964,
0.02658579684793949,
-0.07204148918390274,
-0.010395797900855541,
-0.023709628731012344,
-0.013697942718863487,
-0.030986493453383446,
0.018749229609966278,
-0.0028082102071493864,
-0.04323824495077133,
0.002627842826768756,
0.03503303602337837,
0.048044778406620026,
0.010957164689898491,
0.0056815058924257755,
0.03221280500292778,
0.03118596039712429,
0.04431227222084999,
0.02589264325797558,
0.008588268421590328,
-0.05593600496649742,
-0.04037649556994438,
-0.07986220717430115,
0.024959126487374306,
0.011165725998580456,
-0.04757941514253616,
0.024695072323083878,
0.04045630246400833,
0.04843087121844292,
0.04805925861001015,
0.02863844484090805,
0.011471381410956383,
-0.035174619406461716,
0.008805929683148861,
-0.06160636618733406,
-0.03809785097837448,
-0.003355354769155383,
0.026314018294215202,
-0.11211629956960678,
-0.009557033888995647,
-0.01144437026232481,
-0.015926074236631393,
0.0011756535386666656,
-0.014161569997668266,
-0.0005715676234103739,
-0.009992929175496101,
-0.0007514284807257354,
-0.012135690078139305,
-0.0741184875369072,
0.061593372374773026,
0.005363641306757927,
-0.002648118883371353,
0.009531764313578606,
-0.003132946789264679,
0.03936194255948067,
0.04614659398794174,
0.01910215988755226,
0.059924233704805374,
-0.016182532534003258,
0.015310020186007023,
0.023003311827778816,
0.0029807505197823048,
-0.01477810088545084,
-0.03113577514886856,
0.025681212544441223,
0.050111718475818634,
0.015281639993190765,
-0.00022321050346363336,
0.006124051287770271,
0.003914411645382643,
0.01875624619424343,
0.025393616408109665,
0.046049684286117554,
0.012915849685668945,
0.030839944258332253,
-0.02952929213643074,
0.04967053234577179,
-0.04613427445292473,
0.05877998471260071,
-0.0008331850403919816,
-0.019935261458158493,
-0.017592834308743477,
-0.05601814389228821,
-0.009925429709255695,
0.027536356821656227,
0.020458992570638657,
-0.02590448595583439,
-0.04634047672152519,
0.05001823604106903,
0.07444272190332413,
0.010853398591279984,
-0.011890005320310593,
0.014086837880313396,
0.03127868101000786,
0.028264297172427177,
0.006562708877027035,
-0.06370759010314941,
-0.025819631293416023,
-0.020456528291106224,
-0.04436530917882919,
0.048393625766038895,
0.010883926413953304,
-0.05029776319861412,
0.0060425722040236,
-0.03476480022072792,
-0.03887029364705086,
0.08053860068321228,
-0.007138054817914963,
-0.003936113324016333,
-0.019884536042809486,
0.0572989247739315,
-0.0035325144417583942,
0.03058214858174324,
0.061123427003622055,
-0.07765582948923111,
0.018051916733384132,
-0.012992946431040764,
-0.027422865852713585,
0.018563268706202507,
-0.01349154394119978,
0.10248703509569168,
-0.018734917044639587,
0.017559591680765152,
0.02735869772732258,
-0.08445834368467331,
-0.042097434401512146,
0.026218460872769356,
0.036732446402311325,
0.03103935718536377,
-0.00713014043867588,
-0.015777740627527237,
0.05742913857102394,
-0.004780811257660389,
0.06378425657749176,
0.045130662620067596,
0.00014028785517439246,
0.030409149825572968,
-0.012504788115620613,
-0.04431137070059776,
-0.004571616183966398,
0.01923353038728237,
-0.060598261654376984,
-0.0738883763551712,
-0.00379031035117805,
-0.001142837223596871,
0.00549803301692009,
0.018803441897034645,
-0.007561198435723782,
0.020639700815081596,
0.013644584454596043,
0.0024855751544237137,
0.008912641555070877,
-0.010271700099110603,
-0.053589534014463425,
0.05332867056131363,
0.021065276116132736,
0.00570668512955308,
-0.0017782733775675297,
-0.01545407809317112,
0.0915687158703804,
0.07037312537431717,
-0.02450193464756012,
-0.0023515718057751656,
0.048940278589725494,
0.0067685446701943874,
0.012214231304824352,
0.0032146491575986147,
-0.06575112044811249,
0.014974829740822315,
-0.013855061493813992,
0.00976760033518076,
-0.018980054184794426,
0.031781718134880066,
-0.019240016117691994,
0.009004360064864159,
0.04093533754348755,
-0.022618243470788002,
0.05938233807682991,
0.009047726169228554,
0.006672699004411697,
0.042229555547237396,
-0.024194587022066116,
-0.02641718089580536,
-0.03310271352529526,
-0.008756715804338455,
0.004543267656117678,
-0.0009072985267266631,
-0.025340158492326736,
-0.01103970967233181,
-0.05177251622080803,
-0.005826284643262625,
-0.01922518014907837,
0.03806150332093239,
0.056463368237018585,
-0.01091955229640007,
0.006832826416939497,
-0.016158543527126312,
-0.04879799857735634,
0.05688690394163132,
-0.11885931342840195,
-0.023818327113986015,
-0.025185856968164444,
0.027416985481977463,
-0.005335780326277018,
0.034726887941360474,
-0.010311019606888294,
0.016456635668873787,
-0.027379387989640236,
-0.020433470606803894,
0.012281781993806362,
0.026046644896268845,
-0.03496637940406799,
-0.05656828358769417,
-0.030864333733916283,
-0.011569024063646793,
0.05629107356071472,
-0.027408219873905182,
-0.007412368897348642,
-0.01863343082368374,
-0.027139633893966675,
-0.0015978311421349645,
-0.05964864417910576,
0.013084380887448788,
0.039496663957834244,
0.021862978115677834,
0.015792369842529297,
-0.019469764083623886,
0.007591234520077705,
0.052697110921144485,
0.04621635377407074,
0.04652305319905281,
0.015820052474737167,
-0.03172793611884117,
0.044661011546850204,
0.002130204811692238,
0.006477337796241045,
-0.02123270183801651,
0.009748985059559345,
0.007158555556088686,
0.01724131591618061,
0.012970763258635998,
0.0011005375999957323,
-0.24686001241207123,
-0.03822707384824753,
-0.010592146776616573,
-0.025463338941335678,
0.03560667112469673,
-0.0069603086449205875,
0.0454450361430645,
-0.002031265990808606,
-0.020996125414967537,
-0.022990453988313675,
-0.01827131025493145,
0.03135129064321518,
0.007365132216364145,
0.07774895429611206,
0.045947007834911346,
0.07145320624113083,
-0.026844652369618416,
-0.02245120145380497,
-0.0052858623676002026,
0.04199376702308655,
-0.013070447370409966,
-0.06041984632611275,
-0.017192739993333817,
0.05487120896577835,
-0.003658061847090721,
0.03867112100124359,
-0.09076845645904541,
-0.004598292522132397,
-0.046339523047208786,
-0.012014641426503658,
0.0016172750620171428,
-0.026783492416143417,
-0.02344195917248726,
0.012978293001651764,
0.00360669381916523,
0.016453923657536507,
0.05600050464272499,
0.030034611001610756,
0.0367707721889019,
0.023431459441781044,
0.012953203171491623,
-0.027491886168718338,
-0.07396674156188965,
-0.016752280294895172,
0.05616648867726326,
-0.0037827608175575733,
-0.036365263164043427,
-0.025600850582122803,
-0.016006823629140854,
0.024813905358314514,
-0.018512649461627007,
-0.03113069385290146,
-0.034073784947395325,
0.009474428370594978,
0.017286259680986404,
-0.031168507412075996,
-0.00706557696685195,
0.010543045587837696,
-0.03593343123793602,
-0.006816237233579159,
0.013091698288917542,
-0.02225792221724987,
-0.020827041938900948,
-0.03737359866499901,
-0.03780542314052582,
-0.04991950839757919,
-0.0709257498383522,
-0.06357017159461975,
0.04551882669329643,
0.039026662707328796,
-0.014545397832989693,
0.01743088662624359,
-0.00304210651665926,
-0.10518179833889008,
-0.01880744844675064,
-0.01463503297418356,
-0.011571771465241909,
-0.02327256090939045,
0.009746146388351917,
0.054178062826395035,
-0.035244304686784744,
-0.03732440620660782,
-0.013844677247107029,
-0.011003146879374981,
0.01696408912539482,
-0.0359739251434803,
-0.008674639277160168,
-0.03451896086335182,
-0.026213819161057472,
-0.021566001698374748,
0.023565134033560753,
0.0018680559005588293,
-0.003620500909164548,
0.0158400759100914,
0.04002626985311508,
0.026002977043390274,
0.024462031200528145,
0.058958571404218674,
0.03635555878281593,
0.034415747970342636,
0.012219983153045177,
-0.07589270174503326,
-0.006480546202510595,
-0.053593557327985764,
-0.01484764739871025,
0.014730232767760754,
-0.04446759819984436,
-0.03594718873500824,
0.0407998152077198,
-0.0032091655302792788,
-0.02533368580043316,
-0.059343598783016205,
-0.0011183300521224737,
-0.031755633652210236,
0.0018431456992402673,
-0.01967514120042324,
-0.004288331139832735,
0.02954445593059063,
0.04865710437297821,
-0.01257293950766325,
-0.026838183403015137,
0.023056233301758766,
0.012306726537644863,
-0.013722865842282772,
-0.0013537261402234435,
-0.023291919380426407,
0.021641263738274574,
-0.015473187901079655,
-0.0002039693936239928,
0.01733389124274254,
0.028449121862649918,
0.01564280316233635,
-0.02205141820013523,
0.005454457364976406,
0.035871151834726334,
-0.0006659646169282496,
-0.012545201927423477,
-0.0039251153357326984,
0.011135872453451157,
-0.02918848767876625,
-0.0039426470175385475,
-0.028519144281744957,
0.031324852257966995,
0.03077450767159462,
0.06250428408384323,
0.02889142744243145,
0.020151907578110695,
0.027514614164829254,
0.015879452228546143,
0.017112772911787033,
0.015268831513822079,
-0.04014534130692482,
0.0029060919769108295,
-0.03197241947054863,
0.013660512864589691,
-0.02537606470286846,
0.02520277537405491,
0.000539857370313257,
0.005672961473464966,
-0.07839024811983109,
0.04749460518360138,
-0.04137022793292999,
0.022367296740412712,
-0.0002495335356798023,
0.0015829673502594233,
0.04644019901752472,
-0.03935719281435013,
0.024364827200770378,
0.008170927874743938,
0.0004906475078314543,
-0.015320275910198689,
-0.029704442247748375,
-0.027686050161719322,
0.015338367782533169,
-0.015867948532104492,
0.015306596644222736,
0.01076685730367899,
-0.017178839072585106,
-0.032776664942502975,
0.03997959941625595,
-0.013118256814777851,
-0.030174609273672104,
-0.011349579319357872,
0.023280097171664238,
0.0769089013338089,
0.03730533644556999,
0.0328049398958683,
0.001985521288588643,
-0.048978183418512344,
0.0051613436080515385,
-0.013663239777088165,
0.005149317905306816,
0.016717419028282166,
-0.034893330186605453,
-0.030403751879930496,
-0.06978786736726761,
0.04992219805717468,
0.0012696424964815378,
-0.007993138395249844,
-0.03969087824225426,
-0.026740174740552902,
-0.0072738840244710445,
-0.04460113123059273,
0.005810469388961792,
0.040278758853673935,
-0.08966554701328278,
-0.0056550027802586555,
0.013846645131707191,
-0.00050834019202739,
0.045085348188877106,
-0.010791066102683544,
-0.055426277220249176,
-0.080717071890831,
-0.01694781333208084,
0.010833543725311756,
0.01824573427438736,
0.03370005637407303,
-0.03512972593307495,
0.01262421254068613,
0.00039244157960638404,
-0.01350279152393341,
0.017522308975458145,
0.017382847145199776,
-0.026417719200253487,
0.005623404402285814,
0.03293415904045105,
-0.026859335601329803,
-0.02564118802547455,
-0.003762343665584922,
-0.03387279808521271,
0.034131571650505066,
-0.05290656164288521,
0.0348714143037796,
0.012655701488256454,
0.018321217969059944,
0.0009510180098004639,
-0.02571536786854267,
0.020900726318359375,
0.017935441806912422,
-0.024471431970596313,
0.0029550727922469378,
0.006890084128826857,
0.00293233641423285,
-0.009254300966858864,
-0.012276438996195793,
0.015759842470288277,
0.014384232461452484,
0.006130144465714693,
0.004992800764739513,
0.003914629574865103,
0.02107931114733219,
0.008927189745008945,
-0.01333365123718977,
-0.02144467644393444,
0.06412769109010696,
-0.02540666051208973,
-0.01279461570084095,
-0.07405133545398712,
-0.0496780127286911,
0.002952443202957511,
-0.021940220147371292,
0.02205737866461277,
-0.030534084886312485,
0.08730333298444748,
0.002156293485313654,
0.04218306019902229,
0.00044283177703619003,
-0.026063555851578712,
0.0715809017419815,
-0.0723404809832573,
-0.004146009683609009,
-0.09151177853345871,
-0.04375893250107765,
0.08279155194759369,
-0.05850118771195412,
-0.00032222442678175867,
0.00029007482226006687,
-0.024209236726164818,
0.029722295701503754,
-0.003769020549952984,
-0.062395889312028885,
0.0048131197690963745,
-0.023637894541025162,
-0.003533856710419059,
0.005808921530842781,
-0.028618209064006805,
0.002948701148852706,
-0.011581922881305218,
-0.024044228717684746,
-0.0228898823261261,
0.001991347875446081,
0.04525105655193329,
-0.02848881483078003,
0.028088172897696495,
-0.006885379087179899,
-0.014363052323460579,
0.02701006829738617,
0.0460459403693676,
0.0343954935669899,
0.045827485620975494,
-0.029557019472122192,
0.07021313160657883,
0.05450155958533287,
0.005822217091917992,
0.0010966291883960366,
0.017641250044107437,
-0.01338191982358694,
-0.03419363498687744,
0.021102510392665863,
0.021397454664111137,
-0.011667616665363312,
-0.06274733692407608,
0.08445227891206741,
0.05655469372868538,
-0.050577081739902496,
-0.021261099725961685,
-0.002020567888393998,
-0.05208766832947731,
0.019497109577059746,
-0.0012544378405436873,
-0.009917394258081913,
-0.021997442469000816,
0.06331542879343033,
0.04070359840989113,
0.04861859232187271,
0.07182175666093826,
-0.0009439045679755509,
-0.031494271010160446,
-0.018488094210624695,
0.08200520277023315,
0.06793152540922165,
0.03286459669470787,
-0.0006324335699900985,
0.07243689894676208,
-0.04910605028271675,
-0.053660210222005844,
0.014878416433930397,
0.02147715352475643,
-0.01660013757646084,
-0.002297293394804001,
0.02252437174320221,
0.10354169458150864,
0.010830600745975971,
0.04639503359794617,
-0.04079616069793701,
-0.005323830526322126,
0.028857968747615814,
-0.0028031333349645138,
0.02966378442943096,
0.06779412925243378,
0.016145383939146996,
0.026847733184695244,
-0.006619147956371307,
-0.009379548951983452,
-0.026368997991085052,
-0.022099852561950684,
0.004015097860246897,
0.03325042128562927,
-0.013354907743632793,
-0.015208260156214237,
-0.014694022946059704,
0.08000633120536804,
0.12049330770969391,
-0.018809860572218895,
-0.018125290051102638,
0.010847678408026695,
0.005954009480774403,
0.017956580966711044,
0.0581403449177742,
-0.017445383593440056,
0.0028932224959135056,
0.007708058692514896,
-0.05407838895916939,
0.002649900270625949,
0.009451769292354584,
-0.043170105665922165,
0.027899211272597313,
-0.04825859144330025,
-0.04030509293079376,
0.024333283305168152,
0.050427354872226715,
-0.031096337363123894,
-0.04713737592101097,
-0.02348361909389496,
-0.03256869688630104,
-0.06526647508144379,
-0.042377058416604996,
0.030019165948033333,
0.017556006088852882,
-0.024306602776050568,
0.00543895224109292,
-0.026390161365270615,
0.009015915915369987,
0.0066115520894527435,
-0.06125739589333534,
0.004888772964477539,
0.0580948069691658,
-0.011959085240960121,
-0.004504165146499872,
0.0413021445274353,
0.016310840845108032,
-0.02954203635454178,
-0.02978142350912094,
0.01753896474838257,
0.023784765973687172,
0.013126273639500141,
0.005300107877701521,
-0.017737682908773422,
-0.09129262715578079,
-0.008685709908604622,
-0.009348629973828793,
-0.008897379040718079,
-0.08237522095441818,
0.02621864154934883,
-0.012148709036409855,
0.05121287330985069,
0.06272303313016891,
0.027643276378512383,
0.026414571329951286,
-0.006039423402398825,
-0.0041905902326107025,
-0.009824887849390507,
-0.014816932380199432,
0.02269253507256508,
-0.02032303810119629,
0.05551377683877945,
0.04358004033565521,
-0.03649335727095604,
-0.05272264406085014,
0.0073455460369586945,
-0.01567596197128296,
-0.02873474918305874,
-0.02964259497821331,
-0.02799740992486477,
-0.03002873994410038,
-0.10555773228406906,
-0.010902740992605686,
0.02059261128306389,
-0.0361986979842186,
-0.035331375896930695,
0.016193263232707977,
0.0057623134925961494,
-0.043296098709106445,
-0.009441116824746132,
-0.024944499135017395,
-0.01148239802569151,
-0.02985440380871296,
-0.04880217835307121,
-0.06396041810512543,
-0.00992466788738966,
-0.02061440423130989,
0.013509002514183521,
-0.043611232191324234,
-0.03931111469864845,
0.0018269328866153955,
-0.0006938527803868055,
0.06778186559677124,
0.00154881679918617,
0.010105849243700504,
-0.015386630780994892
] |
367 |
Optimizing (L0,L1)-Smooth Functions by Gradient Methods
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=GQ1Tc3vHbt
|
[
"Daniil Vankov",
"Anton Rodomanov",
"Angelia Nedich",
"Lalitha Sankar",
"Sebastian U Stich"
] |
Poster
|
We study gradient methods for optimizing $(L_0, L_1)$-smooth functions, a
class that generalizes Lipschitz-smooth functions and has gained attention for
its relevance in machine learning.
We provide new insights into the structure of this function class and develop
a principled framework for analyzing optimization methods in this setting.
While our convergence rate estimates recover existing results for minimizing
the gradient norm in nonconvex problems, our approach significantly improves
the best-known complexity bounds for convex objectives.
Moreover, we show that the gradient method with Polyak stepsizes and the
normalized gradient method achieve nearly the same complexity guarantees as
methods that rely on explicit knowledge of $(L_0, L_1)$.
Finally, we demonstrate that a carefully designed accelerated gradient
method can be applied to $(L_0, L_1)$-smooth functions, further improving all
previous results.
|
$(L_0, L_1)$-smoothness, gradient methods, convex optimization, worst-case complexity bounds, acceleration, Polyak stepsizes, nonconvex optimization
| null | 13,268 | null |
[
-0.03827084228396416,
-0.024997079744935036,
0.04222456365823746,
0.03234575316309929,
0.03953607752919197,
0.06244531273841858,
0.020626908168196678,
-0.01107842568308115,
-0.006414167582988739,
-0.044233568012714386,
-0.019841551780700684,
0.015336657874286175,
-0.0669504851102829,
-0.008257150650024414,
0.012712778523564339,
0.061007265001535416,
0.03329724445939064,
-0.014927653595805168,
0.025903157889842987,
0.022436847910284996,
0.005091104190796614,
0.005679200403392315,
0.03935205936431885,
0.027249297127127647,
0.037675097584724426,
-0.004953625146299601,
-0.008999277837574482,
0.021418670192360878,
-0.0487787090241909,
0.008438949473202229,
0.04165339469909668,
0.027768917381763458,
0.001920795999467373,
-0.04472413286566734,
0.012713112868368626,
0.03365037217736244,
-0.006493073422461748,
0.012635022401809692,
0.013302476145327091,
0.03346686065196991,
-0.015115566551685333,
-0.008901174180209637,
-0.026277095079421997,
0.04087778180837631,
-0.05396368354558945,
0.013781162910163403,
-0.12521500885486603,
-0.004495458211749792,
0.004687857814133167,
-0.044370703399181366,
-0.08639305830001831,
0.03293817117810249,
0.01036131288856268,
-0.04574113339185715,
-0.021063899621367455,
0.06078081578016281,
0.004883692599833012,
-0.0411345399916172,
-0.0108284130692482,
-0.05902218446135521,
-0.04188225045800209,
0.03470650315284729,
0.004710264038294554,
-0.005126426462084055,
0.012528995983302593,
0.011135241948068142,
-0.0036962705198675394,
0.03440665081143379,
-0.06546185165643692,
-0.04099789261817932,
-0.038102176040410995,
-0.01375405304133892,
0.02177121303975582,
0.009794735349714756,
-0.0017148400656878948,
-0.04918290674686432,
0.014275548979640007,
0.00648741889744997,
0.04733532667160034,
0.01170372311025858,
0.02217331901192665,
0.00711216451600194,
0.04362154006958008,
0.03467357158660889,
-0.029030881822109222,
0.002691446803510189,
-0.00815350841730833,
-0.0061203190125525,
-0.06948884576559067,
0.0531391017138958,
-0.030564242973923683,
-0.0565737821161747,
0.019982710480690002,
0.018889714032411575,
0.031353238970041275,
-0.01058314647525549,
0.03339441865682602,
0.017259130254387856,
0.024559609591960907,
-0.0018054303945973516,
-0.03948340564966202,
-0.03647409752011299,
-0.010365141555666924,
-0.0061556994915008545,
-0.10358445346355438,
-0.0381825752556324,
-0.021336495876312256,
0.004181019030511379,
-0.004829053767025471,
0.004147532861679792,
-0.03876035660505295,
0.019638672471046448,
-0.007009783294051886,
-0.022537043318152428,
-0.0824204683303833,
0.02060837857425213,
0.007813965901732445,
0.014578365720808506,
-0.016000714153051376,
0.00042470928747206926,
0.04114193469285965,
0.05373779684305191,
0.002869608113542199,
0.07316192239522934,
0.025861507281661034,
0.013336501084268093,
0.030464978888630867,
0.06241428479552269,
-0.020223569124937057,
-0.050238240510225296,
0.01553342305123806,
0.04783337935805321,
0.01705164834856987,
0.022263530641794205,
-0.022261515259742737,
-0.018229611217975616,
-0.03309205546975136,
0.024387430399656296,
0.016665972769260406,
-0.014382376335561275,
-0.01659787818789482,
-0.017805717885494232,
0.07906627655029297,
-0.020730428397655487,
0.044493332505226135,
-0.07162243127822876,
0.014707239344716072,
-0.03333089128136635,
-0.04633951559662819,
-0.020087478682398796,
0.013758870773017406,
-0.005093125626444817,
-0.00423203082755208,
-0.05639604106545448,
0.007533377502113581,
0.055537592619657516,
0.016161255538463593,
0.029736759141087532,
-0.01719484105706215,
0.016749192029237747,
0.020037010312080383,
0.0076608541421592236,
-0.024892371147871017,
-0.00034330235212109983,
0.00011469131277408451,
-0.05951603502035141,
0.0762195810675621,
0.06898923218250275,
-0.013089778833091259,
0.03222651779651642,
-0.03002302721142769,
-0.02292764186859131,
0.046520818024873734,
0.00501879770308733,
0.0015162158524617553,
0.0014305170625448227,
0.08354063332080841,
-0.010353169403970242,
0.0640752986073494,
0.021913593634963036,
-0.09432309120893478,
0.04333755373954773,
0.03413796424865723,
0.006814890541136265,
0.016901355236768723,
-0.028499014675617218,
0.08822783082723618,
-0.010940109379589558,
0.020574083551764488,
0.01203375868499279,
-0.08114940673112869,
-0.02139902114868164,
0.015650568529963493,
-0.04204195737838745,
0.06282327324151993,
0.011729723773896694,
-0.01082337275147438,
-0.0046990420669317245,
-0.00845743715763092,
0.03861921280622482,
0.06824798136949539,
-0.04256242886185646,
0.02576339617371559,
0.009238747879862785,
-0.04449009150266647,
-0.003415330545976758,
0.027302274480462074,
-0.06024111062288284,
-0.003352701896801591,
0.011998084373772144,
-0.003767671762034297,
0.010887564159929752,
0.004419608507305384,
0.022956954315304756,
0.03535717353224754,
-0.01215256005525589,
-0.004524830728769302,
-0.001450353884138167,
0.03854097053408623,
-0.06241230294108391,
0.04842441901564598,
0.020150121301412582,
-0.003291735425591469,
0.036180220544338226,
-0.0025232143234461546,
0.08676190674304962,
0.10782963037490845,
-0.03167502209544182,
-0.00575649831444025,
-0.017002446576952934,
-0.013610274530947208,
0.02110692672431469,
0.0312708243727684,
-0.009376134723424911,
-0.0026785696391016245,
0.009284554049372673,
0.030888652428984642,
-0.032960791140794754,
0.0842011421918869,
-0.05249788239598274,
-0.017461290583014488,
0.06974495202302933,
-0.002796345157548785,
0.04895663261413574,
-0.010498641058802605,
-0.003715594531968236,
0.011050382629036903,
0.022791489958763123,
-0.011670906096696854,
-0.021545518189668655,
-0.01837019808590412,
-0.0026157048996537924,
0.012724027968943119,
-0.028717314824461937,
0.009456909261643887,
-0.03896499052643776,
0.014438946731388569,
0.00044121925020590425,
0.06878358870744705,
0.06749678403139114,
0.05056691914796829,
-0.006918895989656448,
0.002077594166621566,
-0.037605538964271545,
-0.02852816693484783,
-0.1155993863940239,
-0.031872592866420746,
-0.017347821965813637,
0.08904500305652618,
0.022074932232499123,
0.03533245250582695,
-0.018962735310196877,
0.031238948926329613,
-0.017131198197603226,
-0.03594249486923218,
0.005830883048474789,
0.03909290209412575,
0.013377177529036999,
-0.06577892601490021,
-0.04275538772344589,
0.03522837162017822,
0.07681500911712646,
0.02099474146962166,
-0.007525431923568249,
-0.04112360253930092,
-0.06193876639008522,
-0.02307133376598358,
-0.07234981656074524,
-0.012424550950527191,
0.010523053817451,
-0.011964461766183376,
0.011602691374719143,
-0.029280461370944977,
0.03385458141565323,
0.0015608083922415972,
0.039742905646562576,
0.04968734458088875,
0.012169638648629189,
-0.015193022787570953,
-0.0021489798091351986,
0.0009874517563730478,
0.02574172243475914,
-0.022085227072238922,
-0.0038619169499725103,
-0.024782035499811172,
0.021712318062782288,
0.0060552265495061874,
-0.0018513969844207168,
-0.25548499822616577,
-0.008672347292304039,
-0.002982781734317541,
0.006551841273903847,
0.03342288359999657,
-0.012075105682015419,
0.023762090131640434,
-0.030636664479970932,
-0.0309393722563982,
0.010796153917908669,
-0.02426188811659813,
0.0579458624124527,
-0.007912833243608475,
0.05773353949189186,
0.053330130875110626,
0.001265289611183107,
-0.023031998425722122,
-0.004229991231113672,
-0.009028563275933266,
0.027678994461894035,
-0.0031807373743504286,
-0.09551914036273956,
0.0055639492347836494,
0.006153030786663294,
-0.01328242477029562,
0.039816778153181076,
-0.05925247445702553,
-0.040022432804107666,
-0.04671130329370499,
-0.03264149650931358,
-0.04778921231627464,
-0.01791629195213318,
-0.030911002308130264,
0.017793141305446625,
0.023866010829806328,
0.017303405329585075,
0.014137824065983295,
-0.015774257481098175,
0.030357148498296738,
0.03751957416534424,
0.009137359447777271,
-0.012946756556630135,
-0.024160441011190414,
0.011454262770712376,
0.04450015723705292,
0.04400327801704407,
-0.02813672088086605,
-0.0163250882178545,
0.003616495057940483,
0.040678199380636215,
0.007907021790742874,
-0.03896763175725937,
-0.026461532339453697,
0.014654242433607578,
0.019216131418943405,
-0.01337151788175106,
0.015290575101971626,
-0.01970389299094677,
0.01404372788965702,
0.011353110894560814,
-0.00876599084585905,
-0.06183309480547905,
-0.014550943858921528,
-0.046014636754989624,
-0.005707844626158476,
-0.03252188861370087,
-0.09102150052785873,
-0.06939496845006943,
0.03391031175851822,
0.0393989235162735,
0.0216202475130558,
0.01258809957653284,
-0.023542821407318115,
-0.08167705684900284,
0.009392693638801575,
-0.0051984963938593864,
0.0008340707863681018,
-0.00004925846224068664,
-0.0048163821920752525,
0.07106313109397888,
-0.028650591149926186,
-0.03790932521224022,
0.0011362854856997728,
0.005454280413687229,
-0.001508350600488484,
-0.033713504672050476,
0.037392958998680115,
-0.01987900398671627,
0.010505663231015205,
-0.068224236369133,
0.027776289731264114,
0.020264066755771637,
0.03893836960196495,
-0.018511254340410233,
0.043513961136341095,
0.01621268317103386,
0.016616998240351677,
0.04397350549697876,
0.028564833104610443,
-0.04062638059258461,
0.005840823985636234,
-0.07600705325603485,
-0.02012891322374344,
-0.017299266532063484,
-0.006672760006040335,
0.003694737795740366,
-0.04457191005349159,
-0.04723212495446205,
0.06663414090871811,
0.01924336515367031,
-0.007906272076070309,
-0.03594620153307915,
0.008894942700862885,
-0.03781398758292198,
-0.014783216640353203,
-0.015636328607797623,
-0.026814008131623268,
0.03024674579501152,
0.04182641580700874,
-0.012750094756484032,
-0.014466204680502415,
0.042873308062553406,
-0.028576919808983803,
-0.014925815165042877,
-0.0034995859023183584,
0.037551071494817734,
-0.008200593292713165,
-0.04722706601023674,
-0.014153381809592247,
-0.008439167402684689,
0.040285009890794754,
0.04985743388533592,
0.028485963121056557,
0.0017747938400134444,
0.06031141057610512,
0.006050438154488802,
-0.017304806038737297,
-0.033880818635225296,
0.04324430227279663,
-0.017183104529976845,
0.038544151932001114,
0.008452513255178928,
0.04045647010207176,
0.0176573283970356,
0.019792761653661728,
0.03634965792298317,
0.010419770143926144,
-0.013112768530845642,
0.0027195755392313004,
0.01359566580504179,
0.01972413994371891,
-0.045319102704524994,
-0.02323351427912712,
-0.03534794971346855,
0.04049352928996086,
0.019123362377285957,
0.03623923286795616,
0.0013858528109267354,
0.014256008900702,
-0.06537604331970215,
0.05940823629498482,
0.03926769644021988,
-0.04053381085395813,
-0.0015156291192397475,
0.03240165859460831,
0.04585862159729004,
-0.009387282654643059,
-0.005305003374814987,
-0.005253252573311329,
-0.019651487469673157,
0.030930327251553535,
-0.016699010506272316,
-0.024308720603585243,
-0.03237728402018547,
-0.00893398653715849,
-0.032270029187202454,
0.034022603183984756,
-0.019342873245477676,
-0.04225851222872734,
0.012437645345926285,
0.004100933205336332,
-0.04088432341814041,
-0.014601298607885838,
0.034245334565639496,
0.08420047909021378,
-0.002238383749499917,
-0.005840289872139692,
-0.021367326378822327,
-0.01542146597057581,
0.02451099269092083,
-0.025912893936038017,
-0.013237097300589085,
-0.028398314490914345,
-0.025486251339316368,
-0.002890682080760598,
-0.03168993815779686,
0.03149392455816269,
0.01742614433169365,
-0.029229652136564255,
-0.008741234429180622,
-0.027476271614432335,
0.005589345004409552,
-0.033387232571840286,
0.01666904054582119,
0.01777595467865467,
-0.08219283819198608,
0.010998603887856007,
0.026016995310783386,
-0.008119931444525719,
0.03156491741538048,
-0.026936836540699005,
-0.03586777299642563,
-0.026763878762722015,
-0.009566668421030045,
0.014533908106386662,
-0.011231730692088604,
-0.016397494822740555,
0.007540999911725521,
0.010890396311879158,
-0.024466875940561295,
-0.022952649742364883,
-0.01128771249204874,
-0.005098278168588877,
-0.02954685688018799,
0.004087002016603947,
0.06458452343940735,
-0.036179423332214355,
-0.029237257316708565,
0.017738811671733856,
-0.013735027983784676,
0.035227395594120026,
-0.06708194315433502,
0.016001934185624123,
0.036545101553201675,
0.02559739723801613,
0.04412895813584328,
-0.05415970832109451,
0.03052305243909359,
-0.04650871083140373,
-0.009670550934970379,
-0.02152913436293602,
0.021457375958561897,
-0.03399871289730072,
-0.012171617709100246,
-0.0004663902218453586,
0.049909185618162155,
0.009133505634963512,
-0.011769715696573257,
-0.01989023946225643,
0.026398787274956703,
0.001520030782558024,
0.03166216239333153,
-0.0580463707447052,
-0.009935750626027584,
0.04091973975300789,
-0.02792760357260704,
-0.010235415771603584,
-0.038863666355609894,
0.0156118618324399,
0.050180476158857346,
-0.05930174142122269,
0.03684983029961586,
-0.02031940035521984,
0.05040271580219269,
0.005351027008146048,
0.04991234838962555,
0.005255237687379122,
-0.016098037362098694,
0.03807007893919945,
-0.061024025082588196,
-0.01385546661913395,
-0.06942541152238846,
-0.02074565179646015,
0.029418857768177986,
-0.02616768702864647,
0.01425995398312807,
0.024355890229344368,
-0.014783721417188644,
0.02110074646770954,
-0.032941412180662155,
-0.05198771134018898,
0.012168492190539837,
-0.049078937619924545,
-0.008217432536184788,
0.01376713253557682,
-0.0536453053355217,
-0.01722749136388302,
0.00828847661614418,
-0.046925466507673264,
0.014365672133862972,
0.012686632573604584,
0.04226308315992355,
0.007026835810393095,
-0.017967836931347847,
-0.02260148897767067,
0.018583403900265694,
0.04168377071619034,
0.03354114666581154,
0.018952522426843643,
-0.017854761332273483,
-0.05027476325631142,
0.04696767032146454,
0.0373510867357254,
0.021282339468598366,
0.00429349672049284,
0.049051158130168915,
0.004092872142791748,
-0.04603741690516472,
0.03522995486855507,
-0.008801514282822609,
-0.025806177407503128,
-0.05298163369297981,
0.02653493359684944,
0.022994505241513252,
-0.008371641859412193,
-0.05149868130683899,
0.0012346443254500628,
-0.052569787949323654,
0.01900678128004074,
-0.006873531267046928,
-0.024722427129745483,
0.026984350755810738,
0.08206590265035629,
-0.0057240817695856094,
-0.008515595458447933,
0.047095343470573425,
-0.014188713394105434,
-0.006485642399638891,
-0.0473095178604126,
0.08095064014196396,
0.07773328572511673,
0.04133138433098793,
-0.021527182310819626,
0.06089525297284126,
-0.03264926001429558,
-0.05298907309770584,
-0.00899646244943142,
0.010601931251585484,
-0.02736647240817547,
-0.013913681730628014,
0.0017660852754488587,
0.08300196379423141,
0.006821314804255962,
0.06448152661323547,
-0.04535552114248276,
0.007001213729381561,
0.04045504331588745,
-0.027889642864465714,
-0.016823001205921173,
0.035976164042949677,
0.015552780590951443,
0.034524012356996536,
-0.013359117321670055,
-0.02475551888346672,
-0.004933950956910849,
0.0171005018055439,
0.01278585847467184,
-0.01534416526556015,
-0.017504941672086716,
0.00942554697394371,
0.009032647125422955,
0.0046545895747840405,
0.09849461913108826,
-0.0596807636320591,
-0.03860193490982056,
0.0059935967437922955,
0.025261739268898964,
0.00980488583445549,
0.051057685166597366,
0.013524290174245834,
-0.033546797931194305,
0.02006925642490387,
-0.034269727766513824,
0.0358411967754364,
0.03754722699522972,
0.004275349900126457,
0.01869102381169796,
-0.01762998476624489,
-0.0038675579708069563,
0.01908946968615055,
0.03254811838269234,
-0.029771100729703903,
-0.04906592145562172,
-0.039851993322372437,
-0.06964735686779022,
-0.07237128168344498,
-0.07521438598632812,
0.020126743242144585,
0.0038898922502994537,
-0.045921262353658676,
0.014752879738807678,
-0.0033245328813791275,
0.02764701656997204,
0.0018174377037212253,
-0.044965747743844986,
0.00040171161526814103,
0.03852546587586403,
-0.011258711107075214,
0.036334432661533356,
0.02824162133038044,
0.03301442041993141,
-0.007919765077531338,
-0.017824284732341766,
0.029755355790257454,
-0.022005440667271614,
0.030040690675377846,
-0.021311739459633827,
0.005014213267713785,
-0.07588602602481842,
-0.0006853516679257154,
0.020098647102713585,
-0.03433837741613388,
-0.07316470146179199,
0.03015959821641445,
-0.033370308578014374,
0.01387842372059822,
0.06499659270048141,
0.0038695086259394884,
0.0010415016440674663,
-0.06184688210487366,
-0.030261358246207237,
-0.05955206975340843,
0.001342878327704966,
0.0274248905479908,
0.017517471686005592,
0.03444091975688934,
-0.0010992394527420402,
-0.022687427699565887,
-0.048484787344932556,
0.03992488980293274,
-0.042679429054260254,
0.019199319183826447,
-0.03012041188776493,
-0.0003341908159200102,
-0.005586073733866215,
-0.12076642364263535,
-0.02281089313328266,
0.042123399674892426,
-0.005783414002507925,
-0.03071228228509426,
0.018019793555140495,
0.006475113332271576,
0.002827380085363984,
0.019809691235423088,
-0.010295513086020947,
-0.006707682739943266,
-0.0704629048705101,
-0.0252512339502573,
-0.0689343735575676,
0.03024754673242569,
-0.009101423434913158,
-0.010160420089960098,
-0.023222969844937325,
-0.0532071627676487,
-0.032172054052352905,
-0.004444290418177843,
0.030035387724637985,
0.04127072915434837,
0.02567894756793976,
0.009727081283926964
] |
368 |
Compute-Optimal LLMs Provably Generalize Better with Scale
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=MF7ljU8xcf
|
[
"Marc Anton Finzi",
"Sanyam Kapoor",
"Diego Granziol",
"Anming Gu",
"Christopher De Sa",
"J Zico Kolter",
"Andrew Gordon Wilson"
] |
Poster
|
Why do larger language models generalize better? To explore this question, we develop generalization bounds on the pretraining objective of large language models (LLMs) in the compute-optimal regime, as described by the Chinchilla scaling laws. We introduce a novel, fully empirical Freedman-type martingale concentration inequality that tightens existing bounds by accounting for the variance of the loss function. The generalization bound can be broken into three contributions: the number of parameters per token, the loss variance, and the quantization error at a fixed bitrate. As language models are scaled up, the number of parameters per data point stays constant; however, both the loss variance and the quantization error decrease, implying that larger models should have \emph{smaller} generalization gaps. We examine why larger models tend to be more quantizable from an information theoretic perspective, showing that the rate at which they can integrate new information grows slower than their capacity on the compute optimal frontier. From these findings we produce a scaling law for the generalization gap, showing that our bounds decrease in a predictable way.
|
generalization bounds, language models, scaling laws
|
We construct a generalization bound for LLMs which gets better as the models get bigger.
| 13,266 | null |
[
-0.03774474561214447,
-0.01279423013329506,
0.008610593155026436,
0.03449461981654167,
0.050922032445669174,
0.03757810220122337,
0.04181959480047226,
0.01742851920425892,
-0.03979010879993439,
0.018421482294797897,
-0.0026250563096255064,
0.009763648733496666,
-0.08007459342479706,
-0.010222156532108784,
-0.015584534965455532,
0.07548295706510544,
0.05245131999254227,
-0.014822267927229404,
0.00843619555234909,
0.01911970227956772,
-0.009532680734992027,
0.007335353642702103,
0.046797022223472595,
0.0033339736983180046,
0.04162536561489105,
0.012702877633273602,
0.0043318928219377995,
0.014626913703978062,
-0.026218321174383163,
-0.0016955361934378743,
0.05055488273501396,
0.01925906352698803,
0.024699022993445396,
0.004087286069989204,
0.019006481394171715,
0.009416375309228897,
-0.038528453558683395,
0.007380268070846796,
0.018254542723298073,
0.028689734637737274,
-0.04227866977453232,
0.0041622621938586235,
-0.03370959684252739,
0.02818332426249981,
-0.0861639529466629,
0.014095677994191647,
-0.12487639486789703,
-0.005289782304316759,
0.011738666333258152,
-0.04532334581017494,
-0.10451256483793259,
0.0357612781226635,
-0.013930556364357471,
-0.008764267899096012,
-0.013854850083589554,
0.03863906487822533,
0.04542550817131996,
-0.10255595296621323,
-0.009598865173757076,
-0.03279593214392662,
-0.029572395607829094,
0.017602169886231422,
0.0017430383013561368,
-0.0009017765405587852,
-0.009589913301169872,
-0.0029086654540151358,
0.006002518348395824,
0.031191807240247726,
-0.06703151762485504,
-0.05111141875386238,
-0.03362045809626579,
0.010451584123075008,
-0.009899125434458256,
0.03851470723748207,
-0.002339557046070695,
-0.04549326375126839,
0.005589174572378397,
0.039767902344465256,
0.04260310158133507,
0.0011328047839924693,
-0.0143630625680089,
0.02933996357023716,
0.04329267889261246,
0.04838419333100319,
0.013808066956698895,
0.015901315957307816,
-0.03144952282309532,
-0.043441951274871826,
-0.09512970596551895,
0.03616081923246384,
-0.013498357497155666,
-0.04803410917520523,
-0.011234174482524395,
0.010063134133815765,
-0.0013234890066087246,
0.0001516733318567276,
0.025129172950983047,
0.022429028525948524,
0.00420489301905036,
-0.0015956670977175236,
-0.043253060430288315,
-0.03686361387372017,
0.02232915535569191,
0.0062243398278951645,
-0.11586050689220428,
-0.017484115436673164,
-0.012278269045054913,
0.007057876326143742,
0.006795200984925032,
-0.017986811697483063,
-0.02414398454129696,
-0.007732064928859472,
0.014730283990502357,
-0.009045574814081192,
-0.07670573890209198,
0.02869519591331482,
0.0009917665738612413,
0.010995673015713692,
-0.008237014524638653,
-0.007200267631560564,
0.03648189455270767,
0.058811865746974945,
-0.0035033749882131815,
0.08755083382129669,
-0.01641455665230751,
0.01583116129040718,
0.032942552119493484,
0.03350509703159332,
-0.03364348039031029,
-0.03754349425435066,
0.009084162302315235,
0.0458349883556366,
0.014071851037442684,
0.01928253285586834,
-0.004333450458943844,
-0.006516877096146345,
0.021694745868444443,
0.012386956252157688,
0.051096074283123016,
-0.005954360123723745,
0.019267797470092773,
-0.02090427652001381,
0.05288390442728996,
-0.015037654899060726,
0.05576500669121742,
-0.01578635722398758,
-0.011004162020981312,
-0.027436809614300728,
-0.039784133434295654,
-0.007848352193832397,
0.017644939944148064,
-0.008150765672326088,
-0.008777841925621033,
-0.057151298969984055,
0.039227500557899475,
0.039801351726055145,
-0.0005028810119256377,
0.006379998289048672,
0.014309539459645748,
0.030015990138053894,
-0.0077364384196698666,
0.005597445648163557,
-0.0435519702732563,
-0.0014899844536557794,
-0.0034818321000784636,
-0.05344861373305321,
0.055608440190553665,
0.039776820689439774,
-0.039153337478637695,
0.0008895042701624334,
-0.04265142232179642,
-0.022245999425649643,
0.0659715086221695,
-0.0015686415135860443,
-0.024792419746518135,
-0.00829489715397358,
0.05721326172351837,
0.019051579758524895,
0.054712455719709396,
0.03190892934799194,
-0.08451593667268753,
0.007877073250710964,
0.04277709499001503,
0.00999542511999607,
0.015759771689772606,
-0.03338221460580826,
0.09228330105543137,
-0.03960929438471794,
0.0027999705635011196,
0.019005492329597473,
-0.06807281076908112,
0.007091570645570755,
0.026185380294919014,
-0.006596106570214033,
0.06883762776851654,
-0.01006401889026165,
0.004328697919845581,
0.030730227008461952,
0.033967893570661545,
0.02909584902226925,
0.05788892135024071,
-0.044127825647592545,
0.047118037939071655,
0.022695669904351234,
-0.045508261770009995,
0.025015830993652344,
0.011678996495902538,
-0.05698820948600769,
-0.049685847014188766,
0.030825722962617874,
-0.029065828770399094,
0.006345656234771013,
0.013453125953674316,
0.0038372515700757504,
0.013312073424458504,
-0.012009987607598305,
0.01519799791276455,
-0.017339356243610382,
0.029860271140933037,
-0.04445711150765419,
0.03640593960881233,
0.020145369693636894,
-0.0006284500123001635,
0.013740645721554756,
-0.000012247758604644332,
0.08664797246456146,
0.09425336122512817,
-0.016186147928237915,
-0.007839202880859375,
0.012572964653372765,
-0.0020598778501152992,
-0.011339854449033737,
0.008890636265277863,
-0.03161582350730896,
0.019810544326901436,
-0.02022615820169449,
-0.002433439716696739,
-0.04193563014268875,
0.047446444630622864,
-0.04383854195475578,
-0.012660672888159752,
0.05367395281791687,
-0.016451958566904068,
0.07152710109949112,
-0.02774862013757229,
0.02020040899515152,
0.03643106296658516,
-0.030754810199141502,
-0.014561144635081291,
-0.0526680052280426,
-0.011120717041194439,
0.0038358308374881744,
0.004728042054921389,
-0.01634697988629341,
0.0038173336070030928,
-0.03190508112311363,
-0.00648724427446723,
-0.003123394213616848,
0.0727175921201706,
0.05455702170729637,
-0.0010625651339069009,
0.017855821177363396,
0.0007769395597279072,
-0.03171537071466446,
0.0000873656608746387,
-0.10023210197687149,
-0.03074992634356022,
-0.020326076075434685,
0.04417678341269493,
0.001337299938313663,
0.03174661472439766,
-0.011452652513980865,
0.0361303947865963,
-0.02904597669839859,
-0.024334868416190147,
-0.009427973069250584,
0.029313605278730392,
-0.02343258634209633,
-0.045196425169706345,
-0.016533171758055687,
0.0063547310419380665,
0.06030464172363281,
-0.021911824122071266,
-0.021885352209210396,
-0.026717811822891235,
-0.0551045797765255,
-0.029165437445044518,
-0.07235034555196762,
0.014557160437107086,
0.00010402335465187207,
0.010066897608339787,
0.03258981928229332,
-0.012280110269784927,
0.008944636210799217,
0.02737700380384922,
0.04457291215658188,
0.06281702220439911,
-0.011509139090776443,
-0.009986920282244682,
0.024468230083584785,
-0.025602642446756363,
0.0023085870780050755,
0.005260963458567858,
0.048591166734695435,
-0.015343471430242062,
-0.012043126858770847,
0.02244470827281475,
0.005031968932598829,
-0.25946304202079773,
-0.006228173151612282,
0.003454046556726098,
-0.005777984857559204,
0.03374101221561432,
-0.008421768434345722,
0.03535477817058563,
-0.02618941105902195,
-0.03455057367682457,
0.02055308409035206,
-0.01614638790488243,
0.005011821631342173,
-0.020972153171896935,
0.053627099841833115,
0.06347844749689102,
0.039966974407434464,
-0.01019336935132742,
-0.010340004228055477,
0.009118224494159222,
0.043570056557655334,
-0.012417505495250225,
-0.06592220067977905,
-0.004604495130479336,
0.05496079847216606,
0.0006719296798110008,
0.0717228502035141,
-0.06871143728494644,
-0.01914890855550766,
-0.04740069806575775,
0.0019091001013293862,
-0.04570328816771507,
-0.0347493477165699,
-0.0027021346613764763,
0.012348678894340992,
-0.010454602539539337,
0.015619756653904915,
0.0230549406260252,
-0.007145531941205263,
0.02534865215420723,
0.04031604155898094,
0.01584644243121147,
-0.021851375699043274,
-0.020187392830848694,
0.005853486247360706,
0.051664456725120544,
0.015395858325064182,
-0.03761202469468117,
-0.010130064561963081,
-0.01345016248524189,
0.035881757736206055,
-0.0172019861638546,
-0.036277927458286285,
-0.02979145012795925,
0.02137966826558113,
0.030858850106596947,
0.005505650769919157,
-0.010816119611263275,
-0.03838652744889259,
-0.014656205661594868,
0.007250381167978048,
0.01995958760380745,
-0.048205070197582245,
-0.029438603669404984,
-0.03637322038412094,
-0.0014787196414545178,
-0.03349187597632408,
-0.06711169332265854,
-0.037628352642059326,
0.044563814997673035,
0.029072973877191544,
-0.0009392768261022866,
0.007986919954419136,
-0.002658214420080185,
-0.07924026250839233,
-0.021499235183000565,
-0.0018981455359607935,
-0.009834302589297295,
0.010190862230956554,
0.012984787113964558,
0.06141648814082146,
-0.04106820002198219,
-0.05002686008810997,
0.0006422051228582859,
0.004634276032447815,
0.03533286228775978,
-0.03145843744277954,
-0.004670274443924427,
-0.02892410382628441,
-0.02681511454284191,
-0.02153373323380947,
0.010799949057400227,
0.021265199407935143,
0.028731724247336388,
0.007426714524626732,
0.05031636729836464,
0.0075763254426419735,
0.02267361432313919,
0.06786374747753143,
0.027757233008742332,
0.0015121693722903728,
0.04045625030994415,
-0.07573290914297104,
-0.04478004202246666,
-0.04168004170060158,
-0.039059754461050034,
0.03708204999566078,
-0.0703563392162323,
-0.026168663054704666,
0.0222758911550045,
-0.01535835675895214,
-0.03071427345275879,
-0.04435866326093674,
0.014589122496545315,
-0.019529258832335472,
-0.03733809292316437,
-0.012699269689619541,
-0.010700315237045288,
0.04054554924368858,
0.036376308649778366,
-0.015483375638723373,
-0.009519888088107109,
0.053432539105415344,
-0.034253478050231934,
0.0024550175294280052,
0.011254607699811459,
0.0019040735205635428,
0.0021706398110836744,
-0.019798727706074715,
-0.03336850181221962,
-0.014757015742361546,
0.01608077809214592,
0.028077170252799988,
0.006140544544905424,
-0.014835060574114323,
0.04856691136956215,
-0.004902385640889406,
0.028280824422836304,
-0.015369806438684464,
0.038568414747714996,
0.004345928318798542,
0.02732330560684204,
-0.015668688341975212,
0.05064709112048149,
0.01900901272892952,
0.03697958216071129,
0.028689218685030937,
0.027607718482613564,
-0.0020402383524924517,
-0.007693527266383171,
0.010061049833893776,
0.03910539671778679,
-0.03667201101779938,
0.008457720279693604,
-0.012919954024255276,
0.022842910140752792,
0.015351714566349983,
0.025254439562559128,
-0.01966232992708683,
-0.004470575135201216,
-0.07066531479358673,
0.05359407886862755,
-0.0044864811934530735,
-0.019962819293141365,
0.0008698981837369502,
0.02333974279463291,
0.042637888342142105,
-0.03797752037644386,
0.007413454819470644,
0.024005813524127007,
0.02861059457063675,
0.016016274690628052,
-0.025967221707105637,
-0.03718113899230957,
0.0018925517797470093,
0.003735603764653206,
0.007209663279354572,
0.01742318831384182,
-0.007676530629396439,
-0.024472419172525406,
0.04009932652115822,
0.02535589225590229,
-0.02460508421063423,
-0.010928945615887642,
0.026388023048639297,
0.08402476459741592,
0.009604259394109249,
0.02969801425933838,
0.011320382356643677,
-0.05097547173500061,
0.03038850426673889,
-0.02867876924574375,
-0.0226806178689003,
-0.01211437676101923,
-0.03102800063788891,
-0.025429539382457733,
-0.031012065708637238,
0.025698546320199966,
0.022941237315535545,
0.0003359871625434607,
-0.015062411315739155,
0.018453072756528854,
0.004445717670023441,
-0.0502026341855526,
-0.00999738834798336,
0.04334862530231476,
-0.08511848747730255,
0.0033886234741657972,
0.017190180718898773,
-0.025418149307370186,
0.03318750485777855,
-0.02940463088452816,
-0.029021089896559715,
-0.06464088708162308,
0.007182194385677576,
0.05510218068957329,
-0.022176194936037064,
-0.033304885029792786,
-0.015258865430951118,
0.010531993582844734,
-0.015324234962463379,
0.00877629965543747,
-0.028711501508951187,
0.0200398750603199,
-0.023287469521164894,
-0.0010736598633229733,
0.05536229908466339,
-0.057136449962854385,
-0.006973860319703817,
0.014176707714796066,
-0.058239251375198364,
0.028969312086701393,
-0.06713306903839111,
0.019584612920880318,
0.06700548529624939,
-0.009015409275889397,
0.023055549710989,
-0.04806705564260483,
0.03740810602903366,
-0.01746927946805954,
-0.02130141854286194,
0.0024078870192170143,
0.017558274790644646,
-0.017595455050468445,
0.017135322093963623,
-0.00003614643355831504,
0.04787231609225273,
0.015870893374085426,
-0.019859429448843002,
-0.023840103298425674,
-0.0099656255915761,
0.013864344917237759,
0.02231312170624733,
-0.026170773431658745,
-0.0009029664215631783,
0.05899864807724953,
-0.026371579617261887,
-0.043800752609968185,
-0.07787724584341049,
-0.035662516951560974,
0.0147972097620368,
-0.032611288130283356,
0.03556772321462631,
-0.051053546369075775,
0.05797616019845009,
0.013885078020393848,
0.05412789061665535,
0.02557244338095188,
-0.014140751212835312,
0.0453919917345047,
-0.04523485153913498,
-0.02639956586062908,
-0.07179885357618332,
-0.06256403774023056,
0.034695450216531754,
-0.032243162393569946,
-0.00017003521497827023,
-0.00322538404725492,
-0.039251670241355896,
0.02539302036166191,
-0.018079299479722977,
-0.047886572778224945,
0.015852995216846466,
-0.010867209173738956,
-0.03241359815001488,
0.03636649623513222,
-0.053032245486974716,
-0.026693174615502357,
-0.006102629005908966,
-0.0507826991379261,
0.008711383678019047,
0.016128327697515488,
0.041141197085380554,
-0.012016399763524532,
0.004689401015639305,
-0.03227265924215317,
-0.007013872265815735,
0.04192422702908516,
0.06005839630961418,
0.031006159260869026,
0.028627745807170868,
-0.03071259707212448,
0.05846633389592171,
0.03296303749084473,
0.003926187288016081,
0.012350158765912056,
0.011478344909846783,
-0.0318908765912056,
-0.08164117485284805,
0.04661765694618225,
-0.0177706778049469,
-0.019392184913158417,
-0.04097162187099457,
0.06844083219766617,
0.034836623817682266,
-0.03602450713515282,
-0.05018441379070282,
0.02561941184103489,
-0.05539430305361748,
0.006072772201150656,
-0.022047948092222214,
-0.008065495640039444,
-0.00559306750074029,
0.08016615360975266,
0.028973691165447235,
0.04230808466672897,
0.08417746424674988,
0.007427911274135113,
-0.016288215294480324,
0.000025663104679551907,
0.0910051241517067,
0.052806396037340164,
0.06041936203837395,
0.0025641717948019505,
0.0544578954577446,
-0.0501411072909832,
-0.05179908499121666,
0.011255141347646713,
-0.017696749418973923,
-0.025039179250597954,
-0.04754895344376564,
0.01869669184088707,
0.08600359410047531,
0.0019309906056150794,
0.07594985514879227,
-0.06228304281830788,
-0.006416036747395992,
0.03982202336192131,
-0.00745618250221014,
0.00827118381857872,
0.07061097770929337,
0.0278283953666687,
0.01202336698770523,
-0.00929646473377943,
-0.019028427079319954,
0.014118601568043232,
-0.00012580926704686135,
0.008642282336950302,
0.008402119390666485,
0.010261951014399529,
0.0010420040925964713,
0.0010333629325032234,
0.042100727558135986,
0.1183270663022995,
-0.04889179766178131,
-0.03482430428266525,
0.0016140707302838564,
0.01065110694617033,
-0.00016628617595415562,
0.0482063814997673,
0.007010851986706257,
-0.041928596794605255,
-0.014299397356808186,
-0.03930079936981201,
0.01834266260266304,
0.023601144552230835,
-0.011469235643744469,
0.03178941458463669,
-0.030549749732017517,
-0.027317961677908897,
0.01652889885008335,
0.047480084002017975,
-0.060771603137254715,
-0.038678012788295746,
-0.05399850755929947,
-0.0391991101205349,
-0.04446597769856453,
-0.04176544025540352,
0.01192938070744276,
0.009762312285602093,
-0.017022695392370224,
0.003743005683645606,
-0.023644067347049713,
0.004781651310622692,
-0.002806413220241666,
-0.05519476160407066,
-0.012050251476466656,
0.04979835823178291,
-0.006784074008464813,
-0.007928969338536263,
0.04213358461856842,
0.0256421510130167,
-0.03410963714122772,
-0.01867487095296383,
0.03546666353940964,
0.020268619060516357,
0.006951724644750357,
-0.007782511878758669,
-0.008293252438306808,
-0.09705862402915955,
0.025171227753162384,
-0.003953165374696255,
-0.05187549442052841,
-0.08499758690595627,
0.034895751625299454,
-0.012678912840783596,
0.02416214905679226,
0.056654538959264755,
0.01748921163380146,
0.03139859065413475,
-0.03518341854214668,
-0.025107115507125854,
-0.015401399694383144,
0.007069828454405069,
0.043868523091077805,
0.014154734089970589,
0.06419908255338669,
0.04738412797451019,
-0.00621957890689373,
-0.03312940150499344,
0.010525896213948727,
-0.036674726754426956,
0.0009649437270127237,
-0.011924277991056442,
-0.026602519676089287,
-0.021246375516057014,
-0.10196495801210403,
-0.028565969318151474,
0.013891888782382011,
-0.020560884848237038,
-0.029316511005163193,
0.02089870348572731,
-0.014192367903888226,
-0.04370121285319328,
0.006898983381688595,
-0.01468889694660902,
-0.03993392735719681,
-0.01564052142202854,
-0.041541989892721176,
-0.06047847494482994,
0.0221769567579031,
-0.024451831355690956,
-0.0036442046985030174,
-0.035541508346796036,
-0.048064153641462326,
-0.021176517009735107,
-0.0009920911397784948,
0.047029729932546616,
0.0075121913105249405,
0.01272781565785408,
-0.01688939332962036
] |
369 |
Safety-Prioritizing Curricula for Constrained Reinforcement Learning
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=f3QR9TEERH
|
[
"Cevahir Koprulu",
"Thiago D. Simão",
"Nils Jansen",
"ufuk topcu"
] |
Poster
|
Curriculum learning aims to accelerate reinforcement learning (RL) by generating curricula, i.e., sequences of tasks of increasing difficulty.
Although existing curriculum generation approaches provide benefits in sample efficiency, they overlook safety-critical settings where an RL agent must adhere to safety constraints.
Thus, these approaches may generate tasks that cause RL agents to violate safety constraints during training and behave suboptimally after.
We develop a safe curriculum generation approach (SCG) that aligns the objectives of constrained RL and curriculum learning: improving safety during training and boosting sample efficiency.
SCG generates sequences of tasks where the RL agent can be safe and performant by initially generating tasks with minimum safety violations over high-reward ones.
We empirically show that compared to the state-of-the-art curriculum learning approaches and their naively modified safe versions, SCG achieves optimal performance and the lowest amount of constraint violations during training.
|
curriculum learning, constrained reinforcement learning
|
We propose a safe curriculum generation method that reduces safety constraint violations during training while boosting the learning speed of constrained RL agents.
| 13,261 | null |
[
-0.025879237800836563,
-0.0325695276260376,
-0.017098836600780487,
0.07014651596546173,
0.05950120463967323,
-0.00696555944159627,
0.023336827754974365,
-0.0047423336654901505,
-0.035325538367033005,
-0.016977131366729736,
-0.042594458907842636,
0.03934594243764877,
-0.06278801709413528,
-0.020460398867726326,
0.005173311103135347,
0.05566589906811714,
0.016524994745850563,
-0.012656630016863346,
-0.012358560226857662,
0.007107207551598549,
-0.025715027004480362,
0.005974531173706055,
0.027895929291844368,
0.03448432311415672,
0.05211881920695305,
0.03885728865861893,
0.06440608948469162,
0.022165890783071518,
-0.01794574409723282,
0.008240104652941227,
0.048863139003515244,
-0.009877477772533894,
0.012986433692276478,
-0.01253476645797491,
0.01348319835960865,
0.03079606033861637,
-0.028067685663700104,
0.007428498473018408,
-0.015426361933350563,
0.0013029435649514198,
-0.02651011198759079,
0.019743572920560837,
-0.03762269765138626,
-0.031045589596033096,
-0.03753504157066345,
0.012719892896711826,
-0.07458166778087616,
0.018694253638386726,
0.04581797495484352,
-0.06247969716787338,
-0.106378473341465,
0.047897614538669586,
0.028674663975834846,
-0.01862211897969246,
-0.005645019002258778,
0.01977144367992878,
0.05563591048121452,
-0.08585984259843826,
0.015154583379626274,
-0.08729372173547745,
-0.03196689486503601,
0.024584591388702393,
0.0008335812017321587,
0.03844781965017319,
-0.010009735822677612,
-0.003822434926405549,
0.0015821827109903097,
0.0376206710934639,
-0.035257738083601,
-0.01951918564736843,
-0.04060880467295647,
-0.00935389380902052,
-0.001147725502960384,
0.013356016017496586,
-0.002920083934441209,
-0.04403407499194145,
0.009807080961763859,
0.00847745779901743,
0.04144085943698883,
0.0030908382032066584,
0.03814763203263283,
0.01892881467938423,
0.0030045511666685343,
0.013044888153672218,
0.008495134301483631,
-0.004000136628746986,
-0.03218383714556694,
-0.028844954445958138,
-0.0762740969657898,
0.03585370257496834,
-0.033676572144031525,
-0.05023316666483879,
-0.025524646043777466,
0.04222426936030388,
0.027254533022642136,
0.007524430751800537,
0.008073209784924984,
0.0054913111962378025,
-0.007528846617788076,
-0.001175824087113142,
-0.024196289479732513,
-0.021306337788701057,
0.0008157683187164366,
-0.024955233559012413,
-0.12156186997890472,
0.0084653589874506,
-0.02124323509633541,
-0.023340923711657524,
-0.016385521739721298,
0.022881729528307915,
-0.02795913629233837,
-0.011224583722651005,
0.024800149723887444,
-0.03194710239768028,
-0.06502673029899597,
0.06478773802518845,
0.024464230984449387,
0.034315381199121475,
0.0006820712005719543,
0.004421473480761051,
0.020477773621678352,
0.010662544518709183,
0.0024194344878196716,
0.06579217314720154,
0.0031462362967431545,
0.023723021149635315,
0.02237449586391449,
0.02326013706624508,
-0.018443698063492775,
-0.05048917606472969,
0.04347031190991402,
0.051701273769140244,
-0.013817745260894299,
-0.004282733891159296,
-0.016612548381090164,
0.01566898450255394,
0.008272014558315277,
0.024177052080631256,
0.01363697275519371,
0.01430543139576912,
-0.012353222817182541,
-0.031750909984111786,
0.08535967767238617,
-0.03199608251452446,
0.07778921723365784,
-0.019997000694274902,
-0.007564682047814131,
-0.014324132353067398,
-0.05024898052215576,
0.019681038334965706,
0.004947174806147814,
-0.036336593329906464,
0.00022573313617613167,
-0.05612247809767723,
0.02589198760688305,
0.050870638340711594,
0.037293240427970886,
0.013344659470021725,
-0.020175473764538765,
-0.012952853925526142,
-0.007626724895089865,
-0.013758908957242966,
-0.02805229276418686,
-0.017656385898590088,
-0.005955996457487345,
-0.05641951411962509,
0.0327368900179863,
0.010159328579902649,
-0.025513792410492897,
-0.028115125373005867,
-0.04836476966738701,
-0.03921955078840256,
0.027877353131771088,
-0.02724488079547882,
-0.025153333321213722,
0.006073785480111837,
0.05575006455183029,
-0.02482786774635315,
0.03565250709652901,
0.0326993502676487,
-0.0681862086057663,
0.019131440669298172,
-0.0013650893233716488,
-0.00635160319507122,
0.0042067766189575195,
-0.050629448145627975,
0.09164021909236908,
-0.04613729938864708,
-0.0032638530246913433,
0.026187099516391754,
-0.0886978805065155,
0.002461699303239584,
0.04344211518764496,
-0.02859477326273918,
0.0354757085442543,
0.005558352917432785,
0.008693748153746128,
0.039919931441545486,
-0.002808572491630912,
0.07342469692230225,
0.05174253135919571,
0.006408688612282276,
0.041708074510097504,
-0.025226781144738197,
-0.016789957880973816,
0.014465585350990295,
0.02186933532357216,
-0.04097874090075493,
-0.02986161783337593,
0.02216532453894615,
-0.007394779473543167,
0.0057613300159573555,
-0.005548039451241493,
0.004162212368100882,
0.032740939408540726,
-0.01920035481452942,
-0.013777755200862885,
0.019037403166294098,
0.0489104762673378,
-0.052264463156461716,
0.02771470881998539,
-0.026640795171260834,
-0.012524035759270191,
0.013961787335574627,
-0.048319581896066666,
0.09904414415359497,
0.0749751552939415,
-0.02120393142104149,
0.0023216791450977325,
0.03665629029273987,
0.0012699710205197334,
-0.011346904560923576,
0.0096672298386693,
-0.001114228623919189,
0.0016925845993682742,
-0.003923272248357534,
-0.0007378631853498518,
-0.014890013262629509,
0.06350818276405334,
-0.04598817601799965,
0.002051277318969369,
0.08479758352041245,
-0.020081767812371254,
0.07093074917793274,
0.015783214941620827,
0.011108354665338993,
0.03750233352184296,
0.0051032318733632565,
-0.0268916804343462,
-0.02302452363073826,
-0.0210622176527977,
-0.0052576931193470955,
0.034649550914764404,
0.005235033575445414,
-0.02425982803106308,
-0.06204661726951599,
-0.024521123617887497,
-0.024586930871009827,
0.06261222064495087,
0.031183259561657906,
0.017089063301682472,
0.021709388121962547,
0.0052925581112504005,
-0.01446126215159893,
-0.01660122163593769,
-0.09943254292011261,
-0.023320026695728302,
-0.022136569023132324,
0.014761688187718391,
0.012272719293832779,
0.01605704240500927,
-0.043822865933179855,
0.021092215552926064,
-0.013366727158427238,
-0.038737230002880096,
0.004981268662959337,
0.032763540744781494,
0.011913193389773369,
-0.01776297390460968,
-0.007063265424221754,
0.008594139479100704,
0.07357700169086456,
-0.005839086137712002,
0.013772654347121716,
0.005753799807280302,
-0.020029257982969284,
0.012594635598361492,
-0.04080016165971756,
-0.029232310131192207,
0.038613561540842056,
0.0043647862039506435,
0.0017573650693520904,
-0.03346182778477669,
0.01284988597035408,
0.029211152344942093,
0.018912116065621376,
0.04050740227103233,
0.013430444523692131,
0.01295302715152502,
0.027445346117019653,
-0.006918639875948429,
0.020577970892190933,
-0.026804989203810692,
0.014556750655174255,
-0.004905478097498417,
0.012750962749123573,
0.03217817470431328,
0.008801290765404701,
-0.2743658125400543,
-0.030793650075793266,
0.024345817044377327,
0.010157277807593346,
0.044677648693323135,
0.028096163645386696,
0.04994373023509979,
-0.04949188232421875,
-0.05249699950218201,
0.017228364944458008,
0.042823437601327896,
0.031208444386720657,
0.038766030222177505,
0.05520208552479744,
0.05306301638484001,
0.025733215734362602,
0.00043958090827800333,
-0.04253175109624863,
0.005699582397937775,
0.0323120653629303,
-0.02015342377126217,
-0.08044711500406265,
-0.04722995311021805,
0.020844249054789543,
0.00859266147017479,
0.043830543756484985,
-0.07249455153942108,
-0.007766543421894312,
-0.03032907098531723,
-0.016762515529990196,
-0.017186928540468216,
-0.023461325094103813,
-0.012513426132500172,
0.009024804458022118,
0.021140573546290398,
0.023162296041846275,
0.03575175628066063,
0.006194144021719694,
0.027678832411766052,
0.01197213027626276,
0.015115389600396156,
-0.04814108461141586,
-0.022410418838262558,
0.04045301675796509,
0.038753245025873184,
0.026860322803258896,
-0.043265074491500854,
-0.028901010751724243,
-0.006374710239470005,
0.036753349006175995,
0.0156709011644125,
-0.023420093581080437,
0.00977299828082323,
-0.015382475219666958,
0.03083871304988861,
0.001654693391174078,
-0.004279433749616146,
-0.009024441242218018,
-0.02387974038720131,
0.005900523159652948,
0.016879647970199585,
-0.02119436115026474,
-0.04108922928571701,
-0.014887564815580845,
0.010432220995426178,
-0.03144299238920212,
-0.03869526460766792,
-0.06045348197221756,
0.018782412633299828,
0.03186497464776039,
-0.02553066797554493,
-0.03290171921253204,
-0.01267425250262022,
-0.10460826754570007,
0.00576385110616684,
0.0034309367183595896,
-0.01573672518134117,
-0.027432506904006004,
0.009475011378526688,
0.03856276720762253,
-0.05134189501404762,
-0.017857756465673447,
-0.0011732992716133595,
0.029139559715986252,
0.018866125494241714,
-0.0015404574805870652,
0.032112691551446915,
-0.037550050765275955,
-0.030383793637156487,
-0.036361612379550934,
0.027609005570411682,
0.02967444248497486,
0.038784727454185486,
-0.009491423144936562,
0.058073800057172775,
0.04149588197469711,
0.0034553862642496824,
0.0457066185772419,
0.05305325984954834,
-0.03583955019712448,
0.017298119142651558,
-0.08501388132572174,
-0.012193622998893261,
-0.039413224905729294,
-0.0479205958545208,
0.03809225559234619,
-0.04646795243024826,
-0.03401755169034004,
0.0716175064444542,
0.02928813174366951,
-0.005228610243648291,
-0.024850519374012947,
0.02951640635728836,
-0.008373494260013103,
-0.013954076915979385,
0.0017274066340178251,
0.018884722143411636,
0.04709139093756676,
0.028291767463088036,
-0.006299061235040426,
-0.05390327423810959,
0.024660596624016762,
-0.027114536613225937,
0.022275010123848915,
-0.00023900260566733778,
-0.017469225451350212,
0.03318572789430618,
-0.01193871907889843,
0.018055984750390053,
-0.024153679609298706,
0.04227309674024582,
0.025249755010008812,
0.011003212071955204,
0.02001173421740532,
0.03348312899470329,
-0.03099079057574272,
-0.031716473400592804,
-0.004734809510409832,
0.033667974174022675,
-0.010795612819492817,
-0.0017823613015934825,
0.0117171136662364,
0.034351982176303864,
0.009456880390644073,
0.04641401395201683,
0.017032142728567123,
0.020159684121608734,
0.014901128597557545,
0.008610528893768787,
-0.03292575478553772,
0.0396636463701725,
-0.06409195810556412,
0.019935477524995804,
-0.028573518618941307,
0.03783821687102318,
-0.025547437369823456,
0.024002984166145325,
-0.03151524439454079,
0.02702326513826847,
-0.06969211250543594,
0.04305615648627281,
-0.0017811853904277086,
-0.015208903700113297,
-0.004876264836639166,
0.018903179094195366,
0.062342945486307144,
-0.044826690107584,
-0.015333767049014568,
-0.041711628437042236,
-0.014661891385912895,
0.01490212231874466,
-0.07550262659788132,
-0.04938144609332085,
0.007447835057973862,
-0.02303791046142578,
-0.009713680483400822,
0.01239844411611557,
-0.07788447290658951,
-0.052765849977731705,
0.0015204009832814336,
0.005511092953383923,
-0.014402534812688828,
0.005215826909989119,
-0.01353203784674406,
0.059840671718120575,
-0.004272981081157923,
0.006727875210344791,
-0.0034410173539072275,
-0.027687763795256615,
0.0002849430020432919,
0.01564275659620762,
0.027930673211812973,
-0.017260240390896797,
-0.0033397283405065536,
-0.01986619271337986,
-0.03792910277843475,
0.00543755479156971,
-0.0053587136790156364,
0.019215421751141548,
0.0011382449883967638,
-0.020667212083935738,
0.0013036198215559125,
-0.03613949194550514,
0.010461660102009773,
-0.004273583181202412,
-0.057833414524793625,
-0.028166553005576134,
0.040357474237680435,
0.030924716964364052,
0.015058843418955803,
-0.057458195835351944,
-0.03176619112491608,
-0.03992011398077011,
-0.017835702747106552,
-0.01330419909209013,
-0.029216218739748,
-0.05254160985350609,
-0.025714198127388954,
-0.03873289003968239,
-0.0017123337602242827,
0.006783721968531609,
-0.013440226204693317,
0.017034070566296577,
-0.044762685894966125,
0.010331304743885994,
0.0518663115799427,
-0.030079789459705353,
-0.028732359409332275,
0.042945001274347305,
-0.012144222855567932,
0.010310162790119648,
-0.04210531339049339,
0.015371767804026604,
0.001034561195410788,
-0.011767006479203701,
0.0195535309612751,
-0.042880307883024216,
0.06534717231988907,
-0.005848010070621967,
-0.03596561774611473,
-0.006787656340748072,
0.00903324969112873,
-0.01427868939936161,
-0.022192342206835747,
-0.01052853837609291,
0.02770381048321724,
0.034846823662519455,
0.021968785673379898,
0.03306426852941513,
-0.0007700497517362237,
0.026345696300268173,
-0.007033671252429485,
-0.037548769265413284,
0.003850220702588558,
0.06666252017021179,
-0.014058793894946575,
-0.024067392572760582,
-0.06342550367116928,
-0.03220903500914574,
0.028539303690195084,
-0.016644246876239777,
0.03980887308716774,
-0.07910218089818954,
0.010165151208639145,
-0.0029041289817541838,
0.05294695869088173,
0.01779383048415184,
-0.07121481746435165,
0.049853499978780746,
-0.0716107189655304,
0.010442475788295269,
-0.05029455944895744,
0.023876816034317017,
0.06910275667905807,
-0.0456063374876976,
-0.02637624368071556,
0.029208052903413773,
-0.029078146442770958,
0.04210621863603592,
-0.025184808298945427,
-0.07383651286363602,
0.038876354694366455,
-0.07085524499416351,
-0.05384664982557297,
0.036878108978271484,
-0.04238297417759895,
-0.016110815107822418,
-0.0023333996068686247,
-0.03892625495791435,
0.04447319731116295,
0.013865523040294647,
0.05077742040157318,
-0.032399728894233704,
-0.0015479899011552334,
-0.017887160181999207,
0.02682698331773281,
0.01593318209052086,
0.03341371566057205,
0.024650517851114273,
0.025578780099749565,
-0.055192332714796066,
0.06309996545314789,
0.06572061777114868,
0.04567470774054527,
0.02143263630568981,
-0.0009369099279865623,
-0.015778250992298126,
-0.022528253495693207,
0.05703899264335632,
-0.0018188039539381862,
-0.00035456058685667813,
-0.060822270810604095,
0.046034738421440125,
0.02686268836259842,
-0.0742039829492569,
-0.028348661959171295,
0.020756926387548447,
-0.06989450752735138,
-0.017875127494335175,
0.03281407803297043,
-0.001709563541226089,
0.028490440919995308,
0.08773903548717499,
-0.00347832846455276,
0.057101596146821976,
0.06136371195316315,
0.026444265618920326,
-0.01607844978570938,
-0.006111777853220701,
0.04824690520763397,
0.04305003583431244,
0.04365614056587219,
0.003367803292348981,
0.09973644465208054,
-0.08111919462680817,
-0.06163922697305679,
0.03892761841416359,
-0.0020404821261763573,
-0.015811676159501076,
-0.022578777745366096,
0.03248798847198486,
0.035567156970500946,
0.009658465161919594,
0.057149965316057205,
-0.028588345274329185,
-0.017565051093697548,
0.06654305756092072,
0.0061121415346860886,
-0.004829264711588621,
0.04017796367406845,
0.014598771929740906,
0.018704436719417572,
-0.01793738640844822,
-0.018925661221146584,
-0.0040748571045696735,
-0.0012832214124500751,
0.02880760096013546,
-0.012239343486726284,
-0.033705003559589386,
-0.005195091012865305,
0.021196065470576286,
-0.0096981730312109,
0.1345011442899704,
-0.04314957931637764,
-0.006321244407445192,
-0.017794162034988403,
0.00893133319914341,
0.018419425934553146,
0.009251601062715054,
0.03313624486327171,
-0.019667567685246468,
0.010401444509625435,
-0.06393472105264664,
0.03190980851650238,
0.023575151339173317,
0.0052148401737213135,
0.04139801487326622,
-0.0015696868067607284,
-0.0022935557644814253,
0.026899922639131546,
0.0174929890781641,
-0.005018554162234068,
-0.061273206025362015,
-0.03883100301027298,
-0.050862330943346024,
-0.024391714483499527,
-0.013888955116271973,
0.022722452878952026,
-0.004718958865851164,
-0.04062490165233612,
0.01665983349084854,
-0.007868632674217224,
0.013734924606978893,
0.007439550943672657,
-0.07193596661090851,
-0.01834695227444172,
0.0656353086233139,
-0.009126240387558937,
0.0368214026093483,
0.0380999930202961,
0.020057247951626778,
0.003743536304682493,
-0.029443541541695595,
0.02194368466734886,
0.016684211790561676,
0.0008507578750140965,
-0.022543620318174362,
-0.007841411046683788,
-0.08725331723690033,
-0.007436766289174557,
0.01487876009196043,
-0.017076218500733376,
-0.06530965864658356,
0.03997056931257248,
-0.049791086465120316,
0.025115180760622025,
0.07595356553792953,
-0.016008220613002777,
0.012984143570065498,
-0.018070172518491745,
-0.015020112507045269,
-0.001663674833253026,
0.025434117764234543,
0.025017524138092995,
-0.04650931805372238,
0.040912527590990067,
0.05236732214689255,
-0.03932779282331467,
-0.05412775278091431,
0.04273777827620506,
0.006673723924905062,
-0.022941024973988533,
-0.01738862693309784,
-0.01900416426360607,
-0.01966708153486252,
-0.10286160558462143,
-0.01151721365749836,
0.035349778831005096,
0.026122938841581345,
-0.042935192584991455,
0.00809510052204132,
-0.023815425112843513,
-0.007151545956730843,
-0.015770478174090385,
-0.023623818531632423,
-0.018424442037940025,
-0.026104219257831573,
-0.029923154041171074,
-0.029986975714564323,
0.022864146158099174,
-0.050269853323698044,
0.008883757516741753,
-0.0371997132897377,
-0.035476211458444595,
0.015235714614391327,
-0.014577626250684261,
0.024441180750727654,
0.00945946667343378,
0.00880445260554552,
0.014647324569523335
] |
370 |
Generalized Behavior Learning from Diverse Demonstrations
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Q7EjHroO1w
|
[
"Varshith Sreeramdass",
"Rohan R Paleja",
"Letian Chen",
"Sanne van Waveren",
"Matthew Gombolay"
] |
Poster
|
Diverse behavior policies are valuable in domains requiring quick test-time adaptation or personalized human-robot interaction. Human demonstrations provide rich information regarding task objectives and factors that govern individual behavior variations, which can be used to characterize \textit{useful} diversity and learn diverse performant policies.
However, we show that prior work that builds naive representations of demonstration heterogeneity fails in generating successful novel behaviors that generalize over behavior factors.
We propose Guided Strategy Discovery (GSD), which introduces a novel diversity formulation based on a learned task-relevance measure that prioritizes behaviors exploring modeled latent factors.
We empirically validate across three continuous control benchmarks for generalizing to in-distribution (interpolation) and out-of-distribution (extrapolation) factors that GSD outperforms baselines in novel behavior discovery by $\sim$21\%.
Finally, we demonstrate that GSD can generalize striking behaviors for table tennis in a virtual testbed while leveraging human demonstrations collected in the real world.
Code is available at https://github.com/CORE-Robotics-Lab/GSD.
|
Behavior Discovery, Demonstrator Heterogeneity
|
We propose an imitation learning approach that utilizes a new diversity formulation to generate novel behaviors that generalize over demonstrators' latent preferences.
| 13,253 | null |
[
-0.013113439083099365,
-0.028228329494595528,
-0.021428553387522697,
0.04333630949258804,
0.04945053532719612,
0.014186974614858627,
0.037695180624723434,
0.012012275867164135,
-0.041661497205495834,
-0.03442588448524475,
-0.012930897995829582,
0.01243254542350769,
-0.07160690426826477,
-0.029168879613280296,
-0.031291838735342026,
0.05220476910471916,
0.009348695166409016,
-0.013881063088774681,
-0.005015346687287092,
-0.009356128983199596,
-0.01795041561126709,
-0.01596153900027275,
0.0389675498008728,
0.015014497563242912,
0.05127346143126488,
0.0019483183277770877,
0.04871223494410515,
0.020791102200746536,
-0.00957147590816021,
-0.022319907322525978,
0.02201850339770317,
-0.022428233176469803,
0.05811883136630058,
-0.03243984654545784,
0.007118403911590576,
-0.026099395006895065,
-0.0403364934027195,
0.014687011949717999,
0.01594686321914196,
0.004766102414578199,
-0.048266202211380005,
0.023010842502117157,
-0.026422668248414993,
0.0023276889696717262,
-0.02703980728983879,
0.03591806814074516,
-0.08448176085948944,
0.01952858828008175,
0.049563392996788025,
0.0002493075735401362,
-0.06806056946516037,
0.03252848982810974,
0.03974895551800728,
-0.01233220286667347,
-0.0021359461825340986,
0.029176779091358185,
0.05972044914960861,
-0.07204515486955643,
-0.03228946402668953,
-0.052108973264694214,
-0.029746990650892258,
0.05243198201060295,
0.0032844056840986013,
0.006923748645931482,
0.008805181831121445,
0.0043282718397676945,
0.02951662242412567,
0.03909486532211304,
-0.00179487734567374,
0.010798106901347637,
-0.04854628071188927,
-0.024424126371741295,
0.01397748477756977,
0.021744970232248306,
0.020597310736775398,
-0.027498478069901466,
0.030752353370189667,
0.030429596081376076,
0.05558409541845322,
-0.018770113587379456,
0.02514144964516163,
0.029421277344226837,
0.01282960083335638,
0.02758038230240345,
0.03857214376330376,
0.037017859518527985,
-0.022863656282424927,
-0.015233056619763374,
-0.07354966551065445,
0.02595710940659046,
-0.021952692419290543,
-0.05352474004030228,
-0.006825674790889025,
0.05969424918293953,
0.027483826503157616,
-0.004291132558137178,
0.011711725033819675,
-0.009774207137525082,
0.021661212667822838,
-0.014716485515236855,
-0.05401473492383957,
-0.013502892106771469,
-0.0026066810823976994,
0.007592613808810711,
-0.1076948493719101,
-0.028523750603199005,
0.019306745380163193,
-0.03112553060054779,
-0.03748700022697449,
0.024729833006858826,
-0.053843677043914795,
-0.017785482108592987,
0.01083673071116209,
-0.032106004655361176,
-0.07567593455314636,
0.058526549488306046,
0.002800723072141409,
0.02274814248085022,
0.01293610967695713,
0.012310061603784561,
0.037227973341941833,
0.015771916136145592,
-0.008808977901935577,
0.048341456800699234,
-0.04120054468512535,
-0.009838473051786423,
0.0108512993901968,
0.03735053539276123,
-0.00019301037536934018,
-0.02939319610595703,
0.02673368528485298,
0.0310913547873497,
0.00037554584559984505,
0.020867155864834785,
-0.021051719784736633,
-0.021638669073581696,
0.022748855873942375,
0.011017943732440472,
0.007171822711825371,
0.017611965537071228,
0.0033831200562417507,
-0.008306979201734066,
0.0756491869688034,
-0.044869598001241684,
0.07173500955104828,
-0.024808278307318687,
-0.012626742012798786,
-0.028616877272725105,
-0.05103490874171257,
0.005184150766581297,
0.013633225113153458,
-0.012835579924285412,
0.014583613723516464,
-0.05200715735554695,
0.008482315577566624,
0.03049672767519951,
0.02600480057299137,
0.0203157477080822,
-0.002881124382838607,
-0.000781564274802804,
-0.022800439968705177,
-0.016541706398129463,
-0.048171140253543854,
-0.030034543946385384,
0.022257624194025993,
-0.050574079155921936,
0.038947734981775284,
0.032488368451595306,
-0.0403544083237648,
-0.013606719672679901,
-0.04028927907347679,
-0.0023186642210930586,
0.029376016929745674,
0.012393063865602016,
-0.014645472168922424,
0.0038686231710016727,
0.03181908652186394,
-0.008230669423937798,
0.03241302818059921,
0.021819671615958214,
-0.06817539036273956,
0.00740590738132596,
0.03839430212974548,
-0.027042899280786514,
0.011761564761400223,
-0.0351748950779438,
0.04995618015527725,
-0.04578506574034691,
-0.014808659441769123,
0.026658641174435616,
-0.07728688418865204,
-0.033975277096033096,
0.040158286690711975,
0.0023275245912373066,
0.059234678745269775,
0.009487580507993698,
-0.014632525853812695,
0.031340405344963074,
0.04274029657244682,
0.06314555555582047,
0.031157391145825386,
-0.03632553294301033,
0.04028655216097832,
0.0034738006070256233,
-0.02805134281516075,
-0.017055708914995193,
0.02423149161040783,
-0.031962718814611435,
-0.053553927689790726,
0.0038284570910036564,
0.010003084316849709,
0.02451455406844616,
-0.0003162240027450025,
0.00892329216003418,
0.035509418696165085,
0.016273414716124535,
0.006856347434222698,
0.01941514015197754,
0.01959688402712345,
-0.045307569205760956,
0.005730437580496073,
0.012072725221514702,
-0.021956535056233406,
-0.0011594495736062527,
-0.0296990517526865,
0.08497463911771774,
0.05662115290760994,
-0.043630264699459076,
0.01292333658784628,
0.04754558950662613,
0.004795250482857227,
0.03864467889070511,
0.023402268067002296,
-0.01979793980717659,
0.024555154144763947,
-0.015957895666360855,
0.016878796741366386,
-0.05461777001619339,
0.0493258461356163,
-0.05682780593633652,
-0.029246222227811813,
0.08687248826026917,
-0.016172349452972412,
0.075071781873703,
-0.02359422855079174,
0.020440170541405678,
0.02955159731209278,
0.022109972313046455,
0.00025326883769594133,
-0.035127002745866776,
-0.0159229077398777,
0.002936447039246559,
0.043874144554138184,
-0.019935116171836853,
-0.01979023776948452,
-0.037289947271347046,
-0.00920876394957304,
-0.04957607761025429,
0.06626394391059875,
0.0369868278503418,
0.011755477637052536,
0.030045226216316223,
-0.01039195153862238,
-0.02459845133125782,
-0.011416741646826267,
-0.115727998316288,
-0.050035398453474045,
-0.004735182970762253,
-0.009003469720482826,
0.005438471678644419,
0.014757119119167328,
-0.005606064572930336,
0.02703825756907463,
-0.02641795016825199,
-0.04112602397799492,
0.013811183162033558,
0.000277147424640134,
0.01546937320381403,
-0.016190843656659126,
-0.01496728602796793,
0.0021210520062595606,
0.08208227157592773,
-0.035003308206796646,
-0.00810285098850727,
-0.027221109718084335,
-0.05236814543604851,
-0.03338892385363579,
-0.053679633885622025,
-0.011628063395619392,
0.041625846177339554,
0.02404237724840641,
0.039596885442733765,
-0.010492566041648388,
0.013533098623156548,
0.03523150458931923,
0.0692855566740036,
0.015615989454090595,
0.013811229728162289,
-0.016416963189840317,
0.026225514709949493,
-0.020661460235714912,
0.01329641230404377,
-0.013115180656313896,
0.007113253232091665,
-0.001015300047583878,
-0.03639444708824158,
0.013316907919943333,
0.008201263844966888,
-0.26007017493247986,
-0.03473421558737755,
0.0005405794363468885,
0.036836858838796616,
0.009064720012247562,
-0.011104291304945946,
0.06750862300395966,
-0.01926877349615097,
-0.026249157264828682,
-0.0005554335657507181,
0.014931929297745228,
0.01714964210987091,
0.022209208458662033,
0.056783441454172134,
0.06581250578165054,
0.04184255748987198,
0.0031347470358014107,
-0.016019463539123535,
-0.004258146975189447,
0.044750865548849106,
-0.034792639315128326,
-0.06362196058034897,
-0.04596525430679321,
0.022370854392647743,
-0.014207202941179276,
0.038005758076906204,
-0.05826834216713905,
-0.01532625313848257,
-0.03593842685222626,
-0.004984335508197546,
0.00030873779905959964,
-0.006302982103079557,
-0.06593279540538788,
0.017978612333536148,
0.007508798502385616,
0.01776835508644581,
0.04012266919016838,
-0.03440678492188454,
0.012594877742230892,
0.03595077618956566,
0.027021244168281555,
-0.014656574465334415,
-0.06186375021934509,
0.030349846929311752,
0.07140201330184937,
0.00871138833463192,
-0.04950304701924324,
-0.023334234952926636,
-0.004395090043544769,
0.024383986368775368,
0.03029751218855381,
-0.004476676695048809,
-0.011194058693945408,
0.01474989764392376,
0.008015383034944534,
-0.0012092019896954298,
0.0404864065349102,
-0.03194655105471611,
0.002812234917655587,
0.0013231445336714387,
0.02657635509967804,
-0.04689954221248627,
-0.04561658203601837,
-0.027466315776109695,
-0.010408666916191578,
-0.05184206739068031,
-0.054383598268032074,
-0.0854969397187233,
0.028220495209097862,
0.021483708173036575,
-0.030766235664486885,
0.0022443151101469994,
-0.013541394844651222,
-0.10974064469337463,
0.023848561570048332,
0.043118979781866074,
-0.01257790345698595,
-0.04533760994672775,
0.024526411667466164,
0.053018711507320404,
-0.004681115970015526,
-0.04702287167310715,
-0.029611162841320038,
-0.007677590474486351,
0.05918336659669876,
-0.011357354000210762,
0.021376274526119232,
-0.05201389640569687,
-0.02944779582321644,
-0.006719186902046204,
0.025628721341490746,
-0.00442289374768734,
0.021567203104496002,
-0.005328999366611242,
0.06503841280937195,
0.04052428901195526,
0.031144248321652412,
0.048151303082704544,
0.015857072547078133,
0.0006544729694724083,
0.02511604130268097,
-0.12032058835029602,
-0.0044547091238200665,
-0.021089306101202965,
-0.014017987996339798,
0.01956816017627716,
-0.04578789323568344,
-0.02356235310435295,
0.06020762771368027,
0.01582615077495575,
0.011393358930945396,
-0.03564712777733803,
-0.005251365248113871,
0.012631462886929512,
0.014156095683574677,
-0.022040385752916336,
-0.005984962452203035,
0.0246241744607687,
0.04715615138411522,
-0.0004395062569528818,
-0.03761675953865051,
0.021863987669348717,
-0.03384220972657204,
0.02381422370672226,
-0.011157001368701458,
-0.030252007767558098,
0.012498218566179276,
-0.01111389510333538,
0.003102862974628806,
-0.01831468567252159,
0.05197575315833092,
0.02444649673998356,
0.003000763012096286,
0.024570100009441376,
0.03744439408183098,
0.0031892701517790556,
0.0014383040834218264,
0.003217122983187437,
0.006739145610481501,
-0.04576974734663963,
-0.012052965350449085,
-0.01691909320652485,
0.03861156851053238,
0.031888991594314575,
0.0056955828331410885,
-0.0011831012088805437,
0.013399635441601276,
0.02317456342279911,
0.016138872131705284,
0.021295201033353806,
0.06794539093971252,
-0.06665168702602386,
0.005814332515001297,
-0.01498604565858841,
0.0353655107319355,
-0.0476890429854393,
0.04279325157403946,
-0.005083650816231966,
0.033274564892053604,
-0.05289466679096222,
0.02863076515495777,
0.008008340373635292,
-0.036885280162096024,
-0.014608188532292843,
0.03231590613722801,
0.05989693105220795,
-0.033521030098199844,
-0.024894393980503082,
0.0068029058165848255,
0.0032428952399641275,
0.017455067485570908,
-0.05416754633188248,
-0.01773105375468731,
-0.031955234706401825,
-0.03529815375804901,
-0.010097470134496689,
0.002094994066283107,
-0.036437731236219406,
-0.03838935121893883,
0.027579139918088913,
0.016158968210220337,
-0.026710251346230507,
0.003806132124736905,
-0.011988203041255474,
0.04847639054059982,
0.017689159139990807,
0.019704684615135193,
0.005783583968877792,
-0.0016250322805717587,
0.0005765072419308126,
0.003927725832909346,
0.014751769602298737,
-0.009261093102395535,
-0.041133373975753784,
-0.0409562774002552,
-0.04819350317120552,
0.018243972212076187,
0.03636913374066353,
-0.030550073832273483,
-0.03374462574720383,
-0.01284889318048954,
0.006772742606699467,
-0.023713495582342148,
0.012939195148646832,
0.04564840346574783,
-0.07455791532993317,
0.014583036303520203,
0.025843720883131027,
-0.0045481352135539055,
0.0349748320877552,
-0.05909823253750801,
-0.07000118494033813,
-0.0389726497232914,
-0.03691672906279564,
0.0101238451898098,
-0.035487186163663864,
-0.011990071274340153,
-0.04661906883120537,
-0.022801442071795464,
0.033127378672361374,
0.037900011986494064,
-0.000939561054110527,
-0.011700911447405815,
-0.02337428368628025,
-0.004755521658807993,
0.024558862671256065,
-0.05315542593598366,
-0.03871431201696396,
0.033728424459695816,
-0.03946965932846069,
0.03548691049218178,
-0.029902473092079163,
0.025494419038295746,
0.020139917731285095,
-0.010245317593216896,
0.027106091380119324,
-0.0508621446788311,
0.05401561036705971,
0.011188114061951637,
-0.03954179584980011,
-0.02446748875081539,
-0.02734820358455181,
-0.02593708224594593,
0.013285931199789047,
0.02202773652970791,
-0.02436773292720318,
0.0028919812757521868,
0.004725856240838766,
0.0033310111612081528,
0.011080182157456875,
0.012967139482498169,
0.02308468706905842,
-0.02892754226922989,
0.021027471870183945,
0.05221142992377281,
-0.046790920197963715,
0.01701235957443714,
-0.05471761152148247,
-0.029228297993540764,
0.021399518474936485,
-0.023571515455842018,
0.041817549616098404,
-0.04669522866606712,
0.028224419802427292,
-0.00950233917683363,
0.020734639838337898,
0.005346312187612057,
-0.04089312255382538,
0.0382111482322216,
-0.09019714593887329,
0.0026241440791636705,
-0.0696343407034874,
0.007445053663104773,
0.05087878927588463,
-0.060098763555288315,
-0.026875296607613564,
0.023833706974983215,
-0.01361593883484602,
0.04441388323903084,
-0.02459978684782982,
-0.05978202819824219,
0.00893948134034872,
-0.038682498037815094,
-0.017500998452305794,
0.028234174475073814,
-0.05736377090215683,
-0.021561991423368454,
-0.020836854353547096,
-0.06052305921912193,
0.00798399094492197,
0.018486635759472847,
0.03688696771860123,
-0.008445092476904392,
0.00450407899916172,
-0.025579946115612984,
0.0122500229626894,
0.039565812796354294,
0.0277730543166399,
0.02121719717979431,
0.043290793895721436,
-0.03683086857199669,
0.06814934313297272,
0.038483280688524246,
0.01733473688364029,
0.0128215616568923,
-0.016104690730571747,
0.00005268775930744596,
-0.04973575845360756,
0.026305902749300003,
0.005204501561820507,
-0.04125872999429703,
-0.04219403862953186,
0.0640893206000328,
0.008355344645678997,
-0.061075687408447266,
-0.01093303132802248,
0.01768014393746853,
-0.08156294375658035,
0.01864154450595379,
0.013423604890704155,
-0.008518697693943977,
0.023827403783798218,
0.08294195681810379,
0.026979433372616768,
0.0659528598189354,
0.04613153636455536,
0.048816218972206116,
-0.02052840031683445,
-0.007932404056191444,
0.0727560743689537,
0.04347163066267967,
0.055796653032302856,
0.006451789289712906,
0.059115249663591385,
-0.033049196004867554,
-0.04673931002616882,
0.05359794571995735,
0.030016746371984482,
-0.02262333407998085,
-0.024433903396129608,
0.024676091969013214,
0.061419080942869186,
0.002529085846617818,
0.052636414766311646,
-0.031364139169454575,
-0.03435613587498665,
0.04328775033354759,
0.0185958594083786,
-0.008347718045115471,
0.05419973284006119,
0.04283064976334572,
0.03307151049375534,
-0.0031518833711743355,
-0.005172464996576309,
-0.0036320772487670183,
-0.05091187730431557,
0.049174144864082336,
0.012554185464978218,
-0.01877817139029503,
0.007356841582804918,
0.014662462286651134,
0.02257484756410122,
0.13232707977294922,
-0.058956578373909,
0.009312941692769527,
0.013739634305238724,
0.003740680171176791,
0.001940353075042367,
0.05866234377026558,
-0.004538900218904018,
0.005582300014793873,
-0.016676513478159904,
-0.0417289212346077,
0.034117523580789566,
0.037658970803022385,
0.00828251801431179,
0.03530043736100197,
-0.049699876457452774,
-0.02678711712360382,
0.02737395651638508,
0.022853123024106026,
-0.01577800326049328,
-0.03970889374613762,
-0.025435591116547585,
-0.03920697420835495,
-0.0397198460996151,
-0.03550644963979721,
0.04150288924574852,
-0.02344411239027977,
-0.04499676823616028,
-0.003796208184212446,
-0.02362864278256893,
0.03335784375667572,
-0.0028415026608854532,
-0.055716875940561295,
-0.014293868094682693,
0.03786564990878105,
0.0142494086176157,
0.03296677768230438,
0.03750641271471977,
0.03441149368882179,
-0.0004358721198514104,
0.009897627867758274,
-0.004588147159665823,
0.005332957487553358,
-0.004800889641046524,
-0.037877753376960754,
-0.016181353479623795,
-0.08209419250488281,
0.01850820519030094,
0.0022649073507636786,
-0.00447137001901865,
-0.061199359595775604,
0.0011814885074272752,
-0.06438431888818741,
0.06397048383951187,
0.08561571687459946,
0.0037906398065388203,
0.008049776777625084,
-0.056658241897821426,
0.013877825811505318,
0.018174825236201286,
0.007651356980204582,
0.04568634182214737,
-0.04230022802948952,
0.0423402301967144,
0.05943494290113449,
-0.056127648800611496,
-0.03924063965678215,
0.03008502908051014,
0.007230543997138739,
-0.0024502906017005444,
-0.008664238266646862,
-0.056620463728904724,
-0.024954169988632202,
-0.13231468200683594,
-0.01766318827867508,
0.029727190732955933,
0.028143689036369324,
-0.01465823594480753,
-0.0016016503795981407,
-0.011377977207303047,
0.023345299065113068,
-0.017266230657696724,
-0.05151267349720001,
0.0030802451074123383,
-0.02990889921784401,
-0.023190908133983612,
-0.04739779233932495,
0.012361922301352024,
-0.08658510446548462,
-0.004408272914588451,
-0.028292015194892883,
-0.02325390838086605,
0.010860342532396317,
-0.02006658725440502,
-0.002120296936482191,
0.0032538322266191244,
0.025246351957321167,
-0.013133018277585506
] |
371 |
Neural Stochastic Differential Equations for Uncertainty-Aware Offline RL
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=hxUMQ4fic3
|
[
"Cevahir Koprulu",
"Franck Djeumou",
"ufuk topcu"
] |
Poster
|
Offline model-based reinforcement learning (RL) offers a principled approach to using a learned dynamics model as a simulator to optimize a control policy.
Despite the near-optimal performance of existing approaches on benchmarks with high-quality datasets, most struggle on datasets with low state-action space coverage or suboptimal demonstrations.
We develop a novel offline model-based RL approach that particularly shines in low-quality data regimes while maintaining competitive performance on high-quality datasets.
Neural Stochastic Differential Equations for Uncertainty-aware, Offline RL (NUNO) learns a dynamics model as neural stochastic differential equations (SDE),
where its drift term can leverage prior physics knowledge as inductive bias.
In parallel, its diffusion term provides distance-aware estimates of model uncertainty by matching the dynamics' underlying stochasticity near the training data regime while providing high but bounded estimates beyond it.
To address the so-called model exploitation problem in offline model-based RL, NUNO builds on existing studies by penalizing and adaptively truncating neural SDE's rollouts according to uncertainty estimates.
Our empirical results in D4RL and NeoRL MuJoCo benchmarks evidence that NUNO outperforms state-of-the-art methods in low-quality datasets by up to 93% while matching or surpassing their performance by up to 55% in some high-quality counterparts.
|
neural stochastic differential equations, offline reinforcement learning, physics-informed machine learning
|
We develop an uncertainty-aware, offline model-based reinforcement learning approach with neural stochastic differential equations that outperforms the state-of-the-art in continuous control benchmarks, particularly in low-quality datasets.
| 13,251 | null |
[
-0.0431692935526371,
-0.008374219760298729,
-0.004577289801090956,
0.05639658123254776,
0.038631193339824677,
0.050348348915576935,
0.004975097253918648,
0.015771472826600075,
-0.04045598953962326,
-0.04088909551501274,
-0.014419076032936573,
0.01957876607775688,
-0.06054399535059929,
-0.011938600800931454,
0.03895977884531021,
0.050588030368089676,
0.030334772542119026,
-0.03876448795199394,
0.0006584670045413077,
0.036075688898563385,
-0.012522838078439236,
-0.005870820954442024,
0.032085075974464417,
0.019599201157689095,
-0.0007072383887134492,
-0.01622171327471733,
0.014289204962551594,
0.010835593566298485,
-0.01747002638876438,
-0.011080509051680565,
0.02009594812989235,
-0.009512249380350113,
-0.0031210847664624453,
-0.02610691450536251,
-0.008908738382160664,
0.019422659650444984,
-0.011351551860570908,
-0.02463037148118019,
-0.0257872361689806,
0.012217418290674686,
-0.05058224871754646,
-0.007426480296999216,
-0.026476392522454262,
-0.012096120044589043,
0.002318869112059474,
0.018390940502285957,
-0.03377966210246086,
0.014602399431169033,
0.017540020868182182,
-0.03873208165168762,
-0.11256885528564453,
0.024992527440190315,
0.017229558899998665,
-0.02274443581700325,
-0.025529537349939346,
0.020958974957466125,
0.05463812127709389,
-0.07582831382751465,
-0.012114415876567364,
-0.08763627707958221,
0.014559578150510788,
0.01036329660564661,
0.008795829489827156,
0.01033092476427555,
-0.0037784615997225046,
0.011368146166205406,
0.0325939767062664,
0.0435333289206028,
-0.03858179971575737,
-0.006367557682096958,
-0.021326478570699692,
-0.018583333119750023,
0.009726070798933506,
-0.002547556534409523,
0.009100147522985935,
-0.07477089762687683,
0.03056587651371956,
0.02616252563893795,
0.05582728609442711,
0.014066047966480255,
0.040566980838775635,
-0.006894836667925119,
0.025987179949879646,
0.033235371112823486,
0.020272422581911087,
0.003834773087874055,
-0.025626130402088165,
-0.0370478592813015,
-0.08134040236473083,
0.054998353123664856,
-0.045853711664676666,
-0.03962865471839905,
0.003464621491730213,
0.047366153448820114,
0.009983510710299015,
0.01231017429381609,
0.03203525394201279,
0.022402353584766388,
-0.005985698197036982,
-0.010015049949288368,
0.003399058012291789,
-0.026722898706793785,
0.007761067245155573,
-0.04175221920013428,
-0.09495927393436432,
-0.04479491710662842,
-0.003942104987800121,
-0.02185427024960518,
-0.020411035045981407,
0.006173320114612579,
-0.06679391860961914,
0.019117888063192368,
0.010695907287299633,
-0.03229312598705292,
-0.08390042185783386,
0.0049886563792824745,
0.0023828528355807066,
0.045135218650102615,
0.01646268740296364,
-0.005931176710873842,
0.043232712894678116,
0.009928582236170769,
-0.009478338994085789,
0.051213204860687256,
-0.001324342330917716,
0.03557397052645683,
-0.008983875624835491,
0.017778001725673676,
-0.0048269908875226974,
-0.06739746779203415,
0.03311730921268463,
0.027533410117030144,
0.002209889004006982,
0.0026820460334420204,
0.003932966385036707,
-0.002145026810467243,
0.00895742792636156,
0.024119215086102486,
0.031021656468510628,
0.03983080014586449,
-0.010292048566043377,
-0.032272838056087494,
0.08900544792413712,
-0.0070068142376840115,
0.05554812029004097,
-0.004493200685828924,
0.01613847352564335,
-0.04194604977965355,
-0.049835823476314545,
0.00029131927294656634,
0.008319152519106865,
-0.011556760407984257,
-0.03836309164762497,
-0.06162315979599953,
0.016832448542118073,
0.03235927224159241,
0.025325573980808258,
0.01691667176783085,
0.004433722235262394,
0.008066818118095398,
0.02026362344622612,
-0.0009616689058020711,
-0.006883928552269936,
0.010661541484296322,
0.01184347178786993,
-0.09238516539335251,
0.06678826361894608,
0.0030495519749820232,
-0.007137265056371689,
-0.03479002043604851,
-0.03460263833403587,
-0.023322464898228645,
0.03540248051285744,
-0.014009113423526287,
-0.010662599466741085,
0.0015752855688333511,
0.05389442294836044,
-0.025088680908083916,
0.04738641157746315,
0.012669643387198448,
-0.08010614663362503,
0.0296175517141819,
0.015426786616444588,
-0.010587863624095917,
-0.028293190523982048,
-0.04796470329165459,
0.08447194844484329,
-0.005597500596195459,
-0.019469870254397392,
0.03232534974813461,
-0.07709352672100067,
-0.005681524518877268,
0.006588233634829521,
-0.016191205009818077,
0.0659555196762085,
0.007245159242302179,
-0.021411411464214325,
0.05011483281850815,
0.025835780426859856,
0.04344409331679344,
0.03156188130378723,
-0.04814688116312027,
0.03594736382365227,
-0.011589344590902328,
-0.026051927357912064,
-0.022503474727272987,
0.05533097684383392,
-0.016128841787576675,
0.006398907396942377,
-0.006763046607375145,
-0.04861733689904213,
-0.012028390541672707,
-0.015456978231668472,
-0.015390032902359962,
0.024104924872517586,
-0.019255105406045914,
-0.027961784973740578,
0.023207277059555054,
0.016088275238871574,
-0.03018192946910858,
-0.0007812196272425354,
0.018398836255073547,
-0.014565001241862774,
-0.00964839942753315,
-0.02249225042760372,
0.09808368980884552,
0.054504651576280594,
-0.03293481469154358,
-0.01227913610637188,
0.02652093768119812,
0.025377389043569565,
0.004187219776213169,
0.021287018433213234,
-0.023647645488381386,
0.030258212238550186,
0.017665069550275803,
-0.0033217507880181074,
-0.026138292625546455,
0.06070243939757347,
-0.0010342791210860014,
-0.002737457398325205,
0.07299435883760452,
-0.006158532574772835,
0.053782425820827484,
0.00935422908514738,
0.015259025618433952,
0.05459975451231003,
0.017721980810165405,
-0.033385273069143295,
-0.03505325689911842,
-0.02552192658185959,
0.0098376190289855,
0.025493595749139786,
0.006939455401152372,
0.005891059059649706,
-0.05081240460276604,
-0.03817588463425636,
-0.009010301902890205,
0.06754520535469055,
0.03657626733183861,
0.037386201322078705,
0.02925538457930088,
0.012330652214586735,
-0.014872335828840733,
-0.038181353360414505,
-0.11432346701622009,
-0.0464702732861042,
-0.005537798162549734,
0.03416908159852028,
0.04609697312116623,
0.010627605020999908,
-0.016547013074159622,
0.06278330087661743,
-0.01819474622607231,
-0.04197892174124718,
0.006848640274256468,
0.009842022322118282,
0.0309651680290699,
-0.03304973617196083,
-0.027262069284915924,
0.02115957997739315,
0.07474154233932495,
0.007437245920300484,
-0.016412606462836266,
0.027004333212971687,
-0.04565073922276497,
0.003461887128651142,
-0.005942907650023699,
-0.013546840287744999,
0.020839715376496315,
0.011597571894526482,
-0.01729508675634861,
-0.0472838319838047,
0.05489536374807358,
-0.00009918952855514362,
0.08186233043670654,
0.047843825072050095,
0.040585752576589584,
-0.01000915002077818,
0.034301094710826874,
-0.010615814477205276,
-0.007264136336743832,
-0.03539704903960228,
0.018737787380814552,
0.007347132544964552,
-0.006129696033895016,
0.017157763242721558,
0.023326950147747993,
-0.2568395733833313,
-0.042649753391742706,
-0.006443698890507221,
0.01328346412628889,
0.048533845692873,
0.0035958047956228256,
0.05448858067393303,
-0.012804596684873104,
-0.025415664538741112,
0.02801978774368763,
0.02172374539077282,
0.010494913905858994,
-0.007933810353279114,
0.07360035181045532,
0.038963016122579575,
0.013860617764294147,
0.008294248953461647,
-0.023640379309654236,
-0.00441889651119709,
0.0012673435267060995,
-0.030952176079154015,
-0.08433457463979721,
-0.029555361717939377,
0.045373979955911636,
0.013130332343280315,
0.06178159639239311,
-0.07660683244466782,
-0.020198186859488487,
-0.04077974706888199,
0.012027764692902565,
-0.040880270302295685,
-0.016755815595388412,
-0.03303428739309311,
0.006115020718425512,
0.0357084646821022,
0.0221302080899477,
0.012949585914611816,
-0.0004835925064980984,
0.01911899447441101,
0.027682404965162277,
-0.03210040181875229,
0.00519117247313261,
-0.020039789378643036,
0.02574053220450878,
0.06691241264343262,
0.017798863351345062,
-0.06372286379337311,
0.011196618899703026,
-0.015413948334753513,
0.049085583537817,
-0.01271407026797533,
-0.009628303349018097,
0.026112938299775124,
0.0003968101227656007,
0.018668025732040405,
-0.032510723918676376,
-0.010045194067060947,
-0.015497131273150444,
-0.00450899126008153,
0.02886078879237175,
0.011639094911515713,
-0.04235026612877846,
-0.03293062373995781,
-0.019879436120390892,
-0.019027143716812134,
-0.029227610677480698,
-0.04409334808588028,
-0.041947390884160995,
0.03775923699140549,
0.04770819470286369,
-0.03620504215359688,
-0.01975998841226101,
-0.03125160187482834,
-0.10078290104866028,
0.031222892925143242,
0.0021749886218458414,
-0.013961654156446457,
-0.07038059085607529,
0.024465035647153854,
0.047007981687784195,
-0.03776140138506889,
-0.04880048334598541,
-0.011173143982887268,
0.02407483570277691,
0.02099810354411602,
0.008221674710512161,
0.030083198100328445,
-0.04216727986931801,
-0.03503084182739258,
-0.019562410190701485,
0.03490791842341423,
0.020431464537978172,
0.07520054280757904,
-0.03358939662575722,
0.04375563561916351,
0.059112824499607086,
0.021821599453687668,
0.013350018300116062,
0.0195548664778471,
-0.023833490908145905,
0.0035414190497249365,
-0.08273044973611832,
-0.0023121447302401066,
-0.07875979691743851,
-0.014823103323578835,
0.009632888250052929,
-0.0469515435397625,
-0.01090187206864357,
-0.0034295774530619383,
0.0188174806535244,
-0.0017997024115175009,
-0.0471484437584877,
-0.008313752710819244,
0.006222336087375879,
-0.04824430122971535,
-0.01322045736014843,
-0.018929123878479004,
0.04876052588224411,
0.004253807943314314,
-0.007774017751216888,
-0.052911244332790375,
0.028098123148083687,
-0.03456408903002739,
-0.025897324085235596,
-0.009865357540547848,
-0.01092391088604927,
0.021749287843704224,
-0.005961175542324781,
0.012385565787553787,
-0.024820581078529358,
0.030475808307528496,
0.05613401532173157,
0.012489955872297287,
0.027459993958473206,
0.023156950250267982,
0.00414498895406723,
-0.018653953447937965,
0.011335370130836964,
0.057667553424835205,
-0.0019573825411498547,
-0.009869719855487347,
0.012129278853535652,
0.04849870502948761,
0.014711105264723301,
-0.0034190441947430372,
0.04796071723103523,
0.04302758350968361,
0.009236592799425125,
0.020174462348222733,
-0.017540378496050835,
0.035741861909627914,
-0.07197938859462738,
-0.025538811460137367,
-0.03177309408783913,
0.0052695986814796925,
-0.032290730625391006,
0.07012064754962921,
-0.0312848761677742,
0.010269317775964737,
-0.04715210944414139,
0.024440504610538483,
0.013610731810331345,
-0.05900173634290695,
0.021166644990444183,
-0.014119351282715797,
0.06742388755083084,
-0.03839212283492088,
-0.014246919192373753,
0.05083424970507622,
0.008347857743501663,
0.012359513901174068,
-0.04855230078101158,
-0.022201674059033394,
-0.0357990488409996,
-0.031736791133880615,
0.0009297604556195438,
0.008267457596957684,
-0.05996818095445633,
-0.03591267764568329,
0.013414377346634865,
0.021153802052140236,
-0.030930370092391968,
-0.02770870365202427,
-0.005221518687903881,
0.04468898847699165,
-0.029293512925505638,
0.006745427846908569,
0.00028897117590531707,
-0.019110057502985,
0.025961166247725487,
0.0145474374294281,
0.04045575112104416,
-0.053014472126960754,
-0.0366976372897625,
-0.0089036263525486,
-0.03441036492586136,
0.006938192993402481,
0.03839962184429169,
-0.006141201127320528,
0.012298805639147758,
0.02037224732339382,
-0.006612951401621103,
-0.04485577717423439,
0.00907342229038477,
0.032191626727581024,
-0.05975789204239845,
0.008097255602478981,
0.06355446577072144,
-0.007008812390267849,
0.01625249534845352,
-0.07039439678192139,
-0.02992638573050499,
-0.022984353825449944,
-0.009088466875255108,
0.007600298151373863,
0.01227174699306488,
-0.018469201400876045,
-0.019593972712755203,
-0.0215702336281538,
0.01275158766657114,
0.03856294974684715,
0.003664733376353979,
-0.01296806987375021,
-0.029423242434859276,
0.006502196658402681,
0.02643115073442459,
-0.04024108499288559,
-0.005912908352911472,
-0.01850217394530773,
-0.0006877600681036711,
0.020518984645605087,
-0.0483212023973465,
0.014560135081410408,
0.036433521658182144,
-0.016313865780830383,
0.03501218929886818,
-0.05963296815752983,
0.06088715046644211,
-0.021124910563230515,
-0.04151146858930588,
-0.01804295927286148,
0.03278563916683197,
-0.033584948629140854,
-0.007819819264113903,
-0.02572786621749401,
0.029865646734833717,
0.022758662700653076,
0.02128935232758522,
0.053346965461969376,
0.01600090228021145,
0.045917462557554245,
-0.021821197122335434,
-0.05708308517932892,
0.040657754987478256,
0.07074659317731857,
-0.015734262764453888,
-0.006738246418535709,
-0.0745982751250267,
-0.026907090097665787,
0.003070194274187088,
-0.03771592304110527,
0.017854969948530197,
-0.07088303565979004,
0.0238577239215374,
0.01613752916455269,
0.03603862598538399,
0.026239171624183655,
-0.014080039225518703,
0.0497458390891552,
-0.08404148370027542,
0.037388768047094345,
-0.05724107101559639,
0.015873700380325317,
0.06569260358810425,
-0.027186548337340355,
0.025625547394156456,
0.02274773083627224,
-0.021186091005802155,
0.03193224221467972,
-0.0424407459795475,
-0.06324662268161774,
0.03929087519645691,
-0.031226035207509995,
-0.04197422042489052,
0.03398694843053818,
-0.03789612278342247,
-0.02541075460612774,
0.001550287939608097,
-0.03513626381754875,
0.0035885463003069162,
0.005189626943320036,
0.04044424369931221,
-0.026363784447312355,
-0.0161884892731905,
-0.054930463433265686,
0.02732798643410206,
0.02148190699517727,
0.036136090755462646,
0.005838340613991022,
0.04124151170253754,
-0.056670621037483215,
0.061388082802295685,
0.023947453126311302,
0.05626005679368973,
0.032761186361312866,
0.009762205183506012,
0.005963498260825872,
-0.03365074098110199,
0.039425067603588104,
0.014678564853966236,
-0.011520355939865112,
-0.053811609745025635,
0.020330866798758507,
0.025535812601447105,
-0.038351211696863174,
0.01156651508063078,
0.005503700580447912,
-0.05252743139863014,
-0.020155560225248337,
0.028620678931474686,
0.027368534356355667,
0.017672063782811165,
0.06448832154273987,
0.02950221486389637,
0.05464811623096466,
0.0649338960647583,
0.018753357231616974,
-0.039405208081007004,
0.024922819808125496,
0.06290934979915619,
0.05536773055791855,
0.026977663859725,
-0.031189315021038055,
0.07607156783342361,
-0.021384915336966515,
-0.05019371956586838,
0.053903017193078995,
0.022907961159944534,
-0.020865630358457565,
-0.07638636976480484,
0.006142111029475927,
0.07065635174512863,
-0.007735687308013439,
0.05628199130296707,
-0.054466139525175095,
-0.02678053267300129,
0.06565213948488235,
0.005937172099947929,
-0.027232995256781578,
0.010404041968286037,
0.010070850141346455,
0.020240362733602524,
0.015805186703801155,
-0.026252076029777527,
-0.020746318623423576,
-0.02122426964342594,
0.024384811520576477,
-0.010860014706850052,
-0.02664986625313759,
-0.027205098420381546,
0.02810031920671463,
0.05496745929121971,
0.11061836034059525,
-0.05472817271947861,
-0.008610240183770657,
-0.0010626957518979907,
-0.006558354012668133,
0.008037775754928589,
0.02256905473768711,
0.031029026955366135,
0.013275858014822006,
0.0215774979442358,
-0.006627138704061508,
0.024022875353693962,
0.017149288207292557,
-0.009255783632397652,
0.00026652426458895206,
-0.03682409226894379,
-0.016728194430470467,
0.009600133635103703,
0.0011238256702199578,
-0.00024632527492940426,
-0.059453085064888,
-0.026323232799768448,
-0.02332756668329239,
-0.07415299117565155,
-0.06980063021183014,
0.018193760886788368,
-0.009459766559302807,
-0.02603333815932274,
0.03469831496477127,
-0.02748127654194832,
0.024186372756958008,
0.021884923800826073,
-0.04192541912198067,
0.000006702834525640355,
0.041007623076438904,
-0.02312879078090191,
-0.01066352054476738,
0.044396236538887024,
0.027100002393126488,
0.01927546225488186,
-0.030721286311745644,
0.035641029477119446,
-0.011392861604690552,
0.01824810542166233,
-0.02359342761337757,
0.012148871086537838,
-0.07520774006843567,
0.030139027163386345,
0.054618850350379944,
-0.03522748500108719,
-0.07114730775356293,
0.05539943650364876,
-0.0537368580698967,
0.013928675092756748,
0.0597897432744503,
-0.013341724872589111,
0.02188040316104889,
-0.02382546104490757,
-0.039296697825193405,
0.005495373159646988,
0.018861902877688408,
0.028561068698763847,
-0.03907998278737068,
0.03916347026824951,
0.044581614434719086,
-0.02192973718047142,
-0.05862006917595863,
0.03891602158546448,
0.027779515832662582,
-0.010810144245624542,
-0.017528872936964035,
-0.002013419521972537,
-0.01833381876349449,
-0.0782385915517807,
-0.03731061890721321,
0.02729378268122673,
-0.006768899969756603,
-0.02824043110013008,
-0.0051268478855490685,
-0.004047496244311333,
0.02057775668799877,
-0.001877168077044189,
-0.027149345725774765,
-0.04322288930416107,
-0.053787827491760254,
-0.05607706680893898,
-0.05631598085165024,
0.043106481432914734,
-0.014991017989814281,
0.01568189077079296,
-0.04654354602098465,
-0.07645265758037567,
-0.016596084460616112,
-0.007477641571313143,
0.012973670847713947,
-0.006616526283323765,
0.00371099216863513,
-0.001975648570805788
] |
372 |
Towards Optimal Multi-draft Speculative Decoding
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=9KxnxWOBA5
|
[
"Zhengmian Hu",
"Tong Zheng",
"Vignesh Viswanathan",
"Ziyi Chen",
"Ryan A. Rossi",
"Yihan Wu",
"Dinesh Manocha",
"Heng Huang"
] |
Poster
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become an indispensable part of natural language processing tasks. However, autoregressive sampling has become an efficiency bottleneck. Multi-Draft Speculative Decoding (MDSD) is a recent approach where, when generating each token, a small draft model generates multiple drafts, and the target LLM verifies them in parallel, ensuring that the final output conforms to the target model distribution. The two main design choices in MDSD are the draft sampling method and the verification algorithm. For a fixed draft sampling method, the optimal acceptance rate is a solution to an optimal transport problem, but the complexity of this problem makes it difficult to solve for the optimal acceptance rate and measure the gap between existing verification algorithms and the theoretical upper bound. This paper discusses the dual of the optimal transport problem, providing a way to efficiently compute the optimal acceptance rate. For the first time, we measure the theoretical upper bound of MDSD efficiency for vocabulary sizes in the thousands and quantify the gap between existing verification algorithms and this bound. We also compare different draft sampling methods based on their optimal acceptance rates. Our results show that the draft sampling method strongly influences the optimal acceptance rate, with sampling without replacement outperforming sampling with replacement. Additionally, existing verification algorithms do not reach the theoretical upper bound for both without replacement and with replacement sampling. Our findings suggest that carefully designed draft sampling methods can potentially improve the optimal acceptance rate and enable the development of verification algorithms that closely match the theoretical upper bound.
|
speculative sampling
|
we compute maximal acceptance rate for multi-draft speculative decoding
| 13,244 |
2502.18779
|
[
-0.028297198936343193,
0.0026574512012302876,
-0.021792348474264145,
0.07203646004199982,
0.06697762757539749,
0.04183472692966461,
-0.0014671795070171356,
0.023199420422315598,
-0.03590230271220207,
-0.04474996030330658,
-0.012706070207059383,
0.021891329437494278,
-0.05420168116688728,
-0.0033944298047572374,
0.02335394360125065,
0.055372390896081924,
0.04687774181365967,
-0.01087106578052044,
0.04373014718294144,
0.005665229633450508,
0.021866872906684875,
-0.004367731977254152,
0.03740548714995384,
0.01155951339751482,
0.061035409569740295,
0.008696368895471096,
0.007249224931001663,
0.010403953492641449,
-0.017089523375034332,
-0.008441583253443241,
0.030026966705918312,
-0.006037214305251837,
-0.0003968192613683641,
0.012586785480380058,
-0.01125031616538763,
-0.009986493736505508,
-0.06759873032569885,
0.011167597025632858,
0.00994690228253603,
0.03677021712064743,
-0.038491249084472656,
0.004399345256388187,
0.007510476280003786,
0.027043206617236137,
-0.07802102714776993,
0.005087933037430048,
-0.10494191199541092,
0.021110432222485542,
-0.0036639582831412554,
-0.04849253594875336,
-0.10300973802804947,
0.027139633893966675,
0.016192112118005753,
-0.01705876737833023,
0.01796155795454979,
0.05618973448872566,
0.046282943338155746,
-0.0836414247751236,
0.008875424042344093,
-0.03239243105053902,
-0.0343359112739563,
-0.018190380185842514,
0.02920570783317089,
0.022042404860258102,
-0.00042439388926140964,
-0.03198333829641342,
-0.010549684055149555,
0.028762757778167725,
-0.04879969730973244,
-0.019392894580960274,
-0.0051549216732382774,
0.04048008844256401,
-0.02500183880329132,
0.01510675996541977,
0.00010350611410103738,
-0.0623057521879673,
0.04371261969208717,
0.06399448961019516,
0.03860953450202942,
-0.007285033818334341,
-0.014869199134409428,
0.010785427875816822,
0.006995065603405237,
0.05757923424243927,
-0.021407585591077805,
-0.01972840167582035,
-0.04076167568564415,
-0.038870807737112045,
-0.06813500076532364,
0.020928824320435524,
-0.0127393314614892,
-0.055551692843437195,
-0.002706072526052594,
0.015295063145458698,
0.0039061340503394604,
0.015528795309364796,
0.019477758556604385,
0.04446552321314812,
0.003247933927923441,
0.010879024863243103,
-0.022865671664476395,
-0.022770805284380913,
0.049970924854278564,
0.003239477053284645,
-0.09653614461421967,
-0.02465043216943741,
-0.03793599456548691,
-0.02976975217461586,
0.00132695899810642,
-0.00018513237591832876,
-0.00004670990165323019,
0.005915374495089054,
0.017368927597999573,
-0.008093676529824734,
-0.06584547460079193,
0.02653522416949272,
-0.00023681002494413406,
0.011479785665869713,
-0.019759036600589752,
0.004752535838633776,
0.05151171237230301,
0.04796560853719711,
-0.01217853557318449,
0.08448059111833572,
-0.034857891499996185,
0.0026918454095721245,
0.00881846435368061,
0.02939916029572487,
-0.010984117165207863,
-0.046146657317876816,
0.0015857390826568007,
0.04340045526623726,
-0.0032890026923269033,
0.008708811365067959,
-0.007886294275522232,
0.00121493695769459,
0.006975747644901276,
0.008715227246284485,
0.08078188449144363,
-0.001941327820532024,
-0.02706989459693432,
-0.017579149454832077,
0.030197329819202423,
-0.01763952523469925,
0.03642227128148079,
0.018257658928632736,
-0.030215883627533913,
-0.0431920550763607,
-0.05362113192677498,
0.005177862476557493,
0.005890279542654753,
-0.011452645994722843,
-0.013398664072155952,
-0.0325196273624897,
0.024836156517267227,
0.05459834262728691,
0.00045158580178394914,
0.034098513424396515,
0.022844668477773666,
0.006050639785826206,
0.007732676342129707,
0.01930338144302368,
-0.030720291659235954,
0.0039509679190814495,
-0.009703830815851688,
-0.060479097068309784,
0.03754384070634842,
0.03787655755877495,
-0.03826551139354706,
0.018490705639123917,
-0.02549006976187229,
-0.03716602921485901,
0.08555883169174194,
-0.023157700896263123,
-0.017400726675987244,
0.0009153637802228332,
0.03858651965856552,
0.024996647611260414,
0.037715449929237366,
0.04317916929721832,
-0.08119025081396103,
-0.004881234373897314,
0.0129998829215765,
0.018254203721880913,
0.0038716846611350775,
-0.01853344403207302,
0.09685947746038437,
0.009369462728500366,
-0.020649628713726997,
0.018211062997579575,
-0.09241190552711487,
-0.017450856044888496,
0.021303854882717133,
-0.008960247971117496,
0.030123060569167137,
-0.025816287845373154,
0.009958518669009209,
0.057568807154893875,
0.04436292126774788,
0.033274997025728226,
0.0867711752653122,
-0.017946328967809677,
0.040514297783374786,
-0.012980774976313114,
-0.015941359102725983,
0.011883496306836605,
0.041967060416936874,
-0.049271661788225174,
-0.04800865799188614,
0.04058777913451195,
-0.027048839256167412,
0.007780759129673243,
0.004385904408991337,
-0.020429641008377075,
0.012352599762380123,
-0.012446023523807526,
0.02835504338145256,
0.008598590269684792,
0.01527110394090414,
-0.049056947231292725,
0.07636664807796478,
0.013201510533690453,
-0.015512061305344105,
-0.0043050870299339294,
-0.030892563983798027,
0.11477550864219666,
0.06475763767957687,
-0.004829401150345802,
0.00794550683349371,
0.01493065431714058,
-0.015177024528384209,
-0.018360726535320282,
-0.0030233520083129406,
-0.03517501428723335,
0.011464365758001804,
-0.009855174459517002,
-0.010197466239333153,
-0.012266947887837887,
0.0515095517039299,
-0.03474242240190506,
0.005591138266026974,
0.037307608872652054,
-0.022821081802248955,
0.04310332611203194,
-0.010675455443561077,
-0.008791163563728333,
0.005277235526591539,
-0.02091587334871292,
-0.015272194519639015,
-0.03483690693974495,
0.00003318711242172867,
-0.0011683980701491237,
-0.016615863889455795,
-0.04381638765335083,
-0.028110409155488014,
-0.04391917213797569,
0.0022754359524697065,
0.003767428919672966,
0.07619433850049973,
0.0641140341758728,
0.023086242377758026,
0.006722612772136927,
0.012451756745576859,
-0.05113924294710159,
-0.002855537226423621,
-0.1031864807009697,
-0.022625096142292023,
-0.006886374671012163,
0.02013429068028927,
0.01482804212719202,
0.053044844418764114,
0.007101654075086117,
0.00719496700912714,
-0.022026261314749718,
-0.02693077176809311,
0.0003138540487270802,
0.051698390394449234,
-0.015873640775680542,
-0.033036258071660995,
-0.0038167573511600494,
-0.006567624397575855,
0.07679133117198944,
-0.030126169323921204,
-0.02034841850399971,
-0.03239654749631882,
-0.04430370032787323,
-0.005160644184798002,
-0.027767658233642578,
0.011105860583484173,
0.015548914670944214,
0.0034633325412869453,
-0.009394143708050251,
-0.022421445697546005,
-0.006611240096390247,
0.06136883422732353,
0.03644581511616707,
0.039379797875881195,
0.010457475669682026,
-0.01622459664940834,
-0.004723881836980581,
-0.008272567763924599,
0.004391438793390989,
-0.012471770867705345,
0.006764926947653294,
-0.02008083648979664,
-0.014339931309223175,
0.020711885765194893,
0.005059015937149525,
-0.2537078857421875,
-0.031141823157668114,
-0.007444716524332762,
-0.03316868469119072,
0.019299522042274475,
0.0010179892415180802,
0.05575702339410782,
-0.04431316629052162,
-0.01242753490805626,
0.006370654795318842,
-0.0038087889552116394,
0.014111891388893127,
-0.0000664500257698819,
0.05714672431349754,
0.026327768340706825,
0.018925469368696213,
-0.02015015482902527,
-0.01692538522183895,
0.015566234476864338,
0.04028957709670067,
0.03123622201383114,
-0.0773305892944336,
-0.023743415251374245,
0.034995999187231064,
0.012603254057466984,
0.04099751636385918,
-0.07470378279685974,
-0.01325011346489191,
-0.031554512679576874,
-0.0036013980861753225,
-0.01289847306907177,
-0.04008147120475769,
0.030852606520056725,
0.03886442631483078,
0.01169874519109726,
0.017028160393238068,
0.048862066119909286,
0.008424129337072372,
0.0214203130453825,
0.01313979271799326,
0.012872671708464622,
-0.040319815278053284,
-0.02168373204767704,
-0.011951200664043427,
0.078157439827919,
0.039586447179317474,
-0.05192960798740387,
0.008777836337685585,
-0.017173636704683304,
0.0385749489068985,
-0.003259568242356181,
-0.027902808040380478,
-0.03365051746368408,
0.006029251962900162,
-0.012466298416256905,
-0.0003031700325664133,
-0.015444109216332436,
-0.03376902639865875,
-0.039919767528772354,
0.005109105724841356,
0.01418234221637249,
-0.03083665668964386,
0.001953625585883856,
-0.0407559908926487,
-0.03028070367872715,
-0.0644390881061554,
-0.07967957854270935,
-0.020754823461174965,
0.04121239483356476,
0.030885791406035423,
-0.013506654649972916,
0.020719019696116447,
0.02069241739809513,
-0.08580990880727768,
0.029639186337590218,
-0.02498805895447731,
-0.02258848026394844,
0.006136425770819187,
0.0042268079705536366,
0.044713642448186874,
-0.030246343463659286,
-0.03803325071930885,
-0.010252069681882858,
0.02318590320646763,
0.02537565305829048,
-0.04360144957900047,
0.019515439867973328,
-0.004301562439650297,
-0.05208521708846092,
-0.04476476088166237,
0.018571244552731514,
0.001132013276219368,
0.016908809542655945,
0.00808771699666977,
0.03910109028220177,
0.0282820463180542,
-0.014407346025109291,
0.07735256850719452,
0.04193053022027016,
0.03041752055287361,
0.0396597757935524,
-0.05552717670798302,
-0.0066571226343512535,
-0.03419467806816101,
-0.040612101554870605,
0.03319292515516281,
-0.06301025301218033,
-0.015548065304756165,
0.03745917230844498,
0.004538281820714474,
-0.047886740416288376,
-0.0006614862359128892,
-0.0037292977795004845,
-0.01578514464199543,
-0.003249104367569089,
0.0038288342766463757,
0.01851072534918785,
0.03669137880206108,
-0.023188665509223938,
-0.04147999361157417,
-0.013528791256248951,
0.052857544273138046,
-0.01847432553768158,
-0.004068017937242985,
0.02541041187942028,
-0.00844738818705082,
-0.00038116416544653475,
-0.015176977962255478,
-0.03146219998598099,
-0.018542222678661346,
0.007231061812490225,
0.024209918454289436,
-0.02475673146545887,
-0.007889320142567158,
0.056043967604637146,
0.0034061060287058353,
-0.019378958269953728,
0.00323533290065825,
0.04308038204908371,
-0.01735375076532364,
0.01596510224044323,
-0.007870436646044254,
0.0349058136343956,
0.017451012507081032,
0.03204932063817978,
-0.021869119256734848,
0.04839227348566055,
-0.009850237518548965,
-0.0016863440396264195,
-0.010230019688606262,
0.04102122038602829,
-0.0665077418088913,
0.0012661332730203867,
-0.008983158506453037,
-0.013463979586958885,
0.03084256872534752,
0.021209537982940674,
0.004859166219830513,
0.008778094314038754,
-0.08665456622838974,
0.05203206464648247,
-0.010456322692334652,
0.0010474289301782846,
0.00255168741568923,
0.027481820434331894,
0.03750718757510185,
-0.04517259821295738,
0.0153493108227849,
0.03464573621749878,
0.0031868903897702694,
-0.004382049664855003,
-0.016375605016946793,
-0.0471494160592556,
0.020292913541197777,
-0.01813514344394207,
0.005999700166285038,
0.02333187870681286,
-0.012725435197353363,
-0.02964559569954872,
0.020016128197312355,
0.009838096797466278,
-0.01411667000502348,
-0.0017997691174969077,
0.021708287298679352,
0.08871342986822128,
0.021165404468774796,
0.006995415315032005,
0.01952544040977955,
-0.036159854382276535,
0.030187802389264107,
-0.04543963447213173,
0.007739609107375145,
-0.015925947576761246,
-0.03634579852223396,
-0.021893488243222237,
-0.03224543109536171,
-0.016594398766756058,
0.041299499571323395,
-0.0023458246141672134,
0.01421558391302824,
0.008735477924346924,
-0.017800752073526382,
-0.05465130880475044,
-0.03468676283955574,
0.029036356136202812,
-0.06556427478790283,
0.009293920360505581,
0.025117475539445877,
0.0058090705424547195,
0.023468701168894768,
-0.02965416945517063,
-0.027943994849920273,
-0.048308394849300385,
-0.0026810334529727697,
0.028411874547600746,
-0.009311338886618614,
-0.036766573786735535,
-0.009711787104606628,
-0.004425975494086742,
-0.0010994041804224253,
0.006418243981897831,
-0.0027105899062007666,
0.011353995651006699,
-0.0020945039577782154,
0.021012524142861366,
0.04366355016827583,
-0.04654663801193237,
-0.020198509097099304,
-0.009695922024548054,
-0.02643870934844017,
0.033091332763433456,
-0.039120595902204514,
0.04564925283193588,
0.03465571254491806,
-0.009648719802498817,
0.0019329134374856949,
-0.03466501459479332,
0.04102819785475731,
-0.019176507368683815,
0.0249511506408453,
0.0012935224222019315,
-0.04194103553891182,
-0.03425506502389908,
0.006800288334488869,
-0.040656231343746185,
0.05697009339928627,
0.012407255358994007,
0.01804444007575512,
0.011693929322063923,
0.025921758264303207,
0.019400203600525856,
0.025157982483506203,
-0.0704612284898758,
-0.00001539322329335846,
0.06682461500167847,
0.009783723391592503,
-0.043139662593603134,
-0.08925297111272812,
-0.036273516714572906,
0.010836439207196236,
0.011621594429016113,
0.028933312743902206,
-0.014594504609704018,
0.05211411044001579,
0.03105807863175869,
0.0329010933637619,
0.027775274589657784,
-0.011666074395179749,
0.02820792980492115,
-0.037319913506507874,
0.002976336982101202,
-0.07516559958457947,
0.007595445029437542,
0.0783538743853569,
-0.036022283136844635,
0.02509683184325695,
-0.0066865189000964165,
-0.07217278331518173,
0.04810981824994087,
-0.008003355003893375,
-0.05701218545436859,
0.024138204753398895,
-0.02248784713447094,
0.005853821057826281,
0.029802802950143814,
-0.05616946145892143,
-0.04163191467523575,
-0.014449972659349442,
-0.04052504524588585,
-0.02470496855676174,
0.03471750766038895,
0.04716856777667999,
-0.029305357486009598,
0.015017976984381676,
-0.03986305370926857,
-0.01560815330594778,
0.029200054705142975,
0.04659334942698479,
0.028654983267188072,
0.03344099596142769,
-0.009482696652412415,
0.05035211518406868,
0.041969384998083115,
-0.018506696447730064,
0.026555104181170464,
0.014247511513531208,
-0.03810528665781021,
-0.05273836851119995,
0.05896351486444473,
-0.024984518066048622,
0.0018533869879320264,
-0.06970880180597305,
0.07910732179880142,
0.038335103541612625,
-0.05529285594820976,
-0.03666985407471657,
0.026580385863780975,
-0.044154975563287735,
-0.019187932834029198,
-0.017736289650201797,
0.008536012843251228,
-0.01633506827056408,
0.05194391682744026,
0.011241517961025238,
0.05494467169046402,
0.09008898586034775,
-0.024356577545404434,
-0.02888728305697441,
-0.010199683718383312,
0.06203127279877663,
0.06312163919210434,
0.04927828535437584,
0.0001494510070187971,
0.05146167054772377,
-0.04135427996516228,
-0.040357597172260284,
0.015539942309260368,
0.009758145548403263,
-0.02962551824748516,
-0.017685942351818085,
-0.003953245002776384,
0.06762319058179855,
-0.007735029328614473,
0.08618179708719254,
-0.02213185653090477,
-0.00683946767821908,
0.041299592703580856,
0.028175294399261475,
0.017295384779572487,
0.05560450628399849,
0.015466555953025818,
0.0047143809497356415,
-0.029072638601064682,
-0.01805085875093937,
0.02276747301220894,
-0.009285380132496357,
-0.013700515031814575,
0.004630116745829582,
-0.030656784772872925,
0.04948607087135315,
-0.010713406838476658,
0.055002301931381226,
0.10117979347705841,
-0.045227911323308945,
-0.04666748270392418,
-0.01559517253190279,
-0.002650621347129345,
0.003926954232156277,
0.04664881154894829,
0.0061271218582987785,
-0.012377886101603508,
-0.004485368728637695,
-0.06767534464597702,
0.016925310716032982,
0.0195930078625679,
-0.013206928968429565,
0.01566403917968273,
-0.015727069228887558,
-0.007674808148294687,
0.006561909802258015,
0.03643197938799858,
-0.07541879266500473,
-0.052861787378787994,
-0.020745478570461273,
-0.05708080530166626,
-0.07044863700866699,
-0.06556926667690277,
0.015205202624201775,
0.002803954528644681,
-0.0006337098893709481,
-0.003847498446702957,
-0.04925304651260376,
0.0012188078835606575,
0.002069335663691163,
-0.07691095769405365,
-0.01913408562541008,
0.05781884863972664,
-0.009294302202761173,
-0.016536634415388107,
0.03190033882856369,
-0.00009809921175474301,
-0.03744598478078842,
-0.016216427087783813,
0.022198256105184555,
0.027110768482089043,
0.03743106871843338,
0.023338448256254196,
-0.004609489347785711,
-0.0972893089056015,
0.02558838576078415,
0.014421188272535801,
-0.006873800419270992,
-0.0805521085858345,
0.018610024824738503,
-0.029376516118645668,
0.00900803878903389,
0.07572612911462784,
0.010007457807660103,
0.03812558203935623,
-0.034286025911569595,
-0.011347737163305283,
0.023006582632660866,
-0.007548548746854067,
0.036132633686065674,
-0.039534978568553925,
0.09392716735601425,
0.046858809888362885,
-0.01831034943461418,
-0.05427204445004463,
0.01417828630656004,
-0.0075894733890891075,
-0.02020670846104622,
-0.007822302170097828,
-0.0070773581974208355,
-0.04582875221967697,
-0.07748088240623474,
-0.003823417006060481,
0.034115519374608994,
-0.01362993661314249,
-0.05618327856063843,
0.024835646152496338,
-0.026440318673849106,
-0.04481760784983635,
-0.0005356278270483017,
-0.018620552495121956,
-0.03642898052930832,
-0.038538090884685516,
-0.05219428613781929,
-0.07676554471254349,
0.025753920897841454,
-0.005122211761772633,
0.0031640094239264727,
-0.04726051539182663,
-0.06828221678733826,
-0.005751246586441994,
0.0274801068007946,
0.04470871016383171,
0.014820258133113384,
0.011030900292098522,
-0.03172044828534126
] |
373 |
Diffusion Generative Modeling for Spatially Resolved Gene Expression Inference from Histology Images
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=FtjLUHyZAO
|
[
"Sichen Zhu",
"Yuchen Zhu",
"Molei Tao",
"Peng Qiu"
] |
Poster
|
Spatial Transcriptomics (ST) allows a high-resolution measurement of RNA sequence abundance by systematically connecting cell morphology depicted in Hematoxylin and eosin (H\&E) stained histology images to spatially resolved gene expressions. ST is a time-consuming, expensive yet powerful experimental technique that provides new opportunities to understand cancer mechanisms at a fine-grained molecular level, which is critical for uncovering new approaches for disease diagnosis and treatments. Here, we present $\textbf{Stem}$ ($\underline{\textbf{S}}$pa$\underline{\textbf{T}}$ially resolved gene $\underline{\textbf{E}}$xpression inference with diffusion $\underline{\textbf{M}}$odel), a novel computational tool that leverages a conditional diffusion generative model to enable in silico gene expression inference from H&E stained images. Through better capturing the inherent stochasticity and heterogeneity in ST data, $\textbf{Stem}$ achieves state-of-the-art performance on spatial gene expression prediction and generates biologically meaningful gene profiles for new H&E stained images at test time. We evaluate the proposed algorithm on datasets with various tissue sources and sequencing platforms, where it demonstrates clear improvement over existing approaches. $\textbf{Stem}$ generates high-fidelity gene expression predictions that share similar gene variation levels as ground truth data, suggesting that our method preserves the underlying biological heterogeneity. Our proposed pipeline opens up the possibility of analyzing existing, easily accessible H&E stained histology images from a genomics point of view without physically performing gene expression profiling and empowers potential biological discovery from H&E stained histology images. Code is available at: https://github.com/SichenZhu/Stem.
|
Gene Expression Prediction, Diffusion Model, Spatial Transcriptomics, H&E
| null | 13,234 |
2501.15598
|
[
0.0057144127786159515,
0.00025166317936964333,
-0.01849767379462719,
0.04672391340136528,
0.054994821548461914,
0.04620245844125748,
0.01155374851077795,
-0.010089951567351818,
0.02176380343735218,
-0.052474576979875565,
0.008403847925364971,
-0.026967499405145645,
-0.017131967470049858,
0.041543442755937576,
-0.016238810494542122,
0.04282573610544205,
0.027275631204247475,
-0.030684754252433777,
0.016559254378080368,
0.053649891167879105,
0.006071696523576975,
-0.029596591368317604,
0.005955426953732967,
0.03597013279795647,
0.0423390194773674,
-0.030258558690547943,
0.0030314254108816385,
-0.00010374977864557877,
-0.04133084416389465,
0.011756266467273235,
0.0009678056230768561,
-0.004030117765069008,
0.008090191520750523,
-0.04481931030750275,
0.006550229620188475,
0.022767508402466774,
-0.017258787527680397,
0.005277424585074186,
-0.030566450208425522,
-0.013640105724334717,
-0.07334449142217636,
0.023398708552122116,
-0.021840965375304222,
0.05523878335952759,
-0.028311435133218765,
0.0052719200029969215,
-0.1274692714214325,
0.04728037863969803,
0.0125621622428298,
0.020086582750082016,
-0.07797462493181229,
0.03847635164856911,
-0.006199113558977842,
0.0014445966808125377,
0.013445563614368439,
0.044057928025722504,
0.03659271448850632,
-0.06225539371371269,
-0.02618364244699478,
-0.06516551226377487,
-0.01357469242066145,
-0.0039688763208687305,
-0.012411690317094326,
0.043888092041015625,
0.02155611664056778,
-0.01784958876669407,
0.009873406030237675,
0.018383214250206947,
-0.04014991596341133,
-0.0614805594086647,
-0.021899087354540825,
0.018231941387057304,
0.012976017780601978,
0.0095855463296175,
0.02311987243592739,
-0.01103066373616457,
0.004739245865494013,
0.006997755263000727,
0.06454558670520782,
-0.009471667930483818,
0.026641104370355606,
-0.012192805297672749,
-0.018806101754307747,
0.030124012380838394,
-0.02909156307578087,
-0.0025277824606746435,
-0.0488600991666317,
-0.029061168432235718,
-0.04169192165136337,
0.02957271970808506,
-0.01616603694856167,
-0.033953920006752014,
0.011220368556678295,
0.03420593962073326,
0.07731658220291138,
0.004985789302736521,
0.01698702573776245,
0.009150256402790546,
-0.022847197949886322,
-0.007117183413356543,
-0.045592714101076126,
-0.012024575844407082,
0.025789553299546242,
-0.015832161530852318,
-0.10736377537250519,
-0.018856054171919823,
-0.03264894708991051,
-0.03425779193639755,
0.011514058336615562,
-0.0006438360433094203,
0.022744620218873024,
-0.011169700883328915,
0.007322349119931459,
-0.0018829735927283764,
-0.0919807180762291,
0.05940605327486992,
0.043614305555820465,
0.012556292116641998,
0.04758251830935478,
-0.047133080661296844,
0.03630140796303749,
0.050837405025959015,
-0.024117151275277138,
0.0756603330373764,
-0.021611440926790237,
0.034109506756067276,
0.017120180651545525,
-0.006676624994724989,
-0.0345018096268177,
0.00008931910997489467,
0.0015490431105718017,
0.05349054932594299,
-0.017479760572314262,
-0.0037114350125193596,
0.017635256052017212,
-0.023447178304195404,
0.029710164293646812,
-0.01600225828588009,
0.06700399518013,
-0.030568666756153107,
0.012791603803634644,
-0.020293748006224632,
0.0004862967471126467,
-0.01437517162412405,
0.0474618561565876,
-0.03869883343577385,
-0.005162708926945925,
-0.01679335907101631,
-0.017652960494160652,
0.005982490722090006,
0.02559630386531353,
-0.0016394512495025992,
0.04697585478425026,
-0.060953136533498764,
-0.006247860845178366,
0.07723423838615417,
0.009031616151332855,
0.016504932194948196,
0.01746232807636261,
0.007225086912512779,
0.0582234188914299,
-0.004118709824979305,
0.007810387760400772,
-0.003784274449571967,
-0.01708582043647766,
-0.01301239337772131,
0.06773368269205093,
0.004648284986615181,
-0.05968508869409561,
-0.04121951386332512,
-0.04750409722328186,
-0.052704643458127975,
0.04093919321894646,
0.01651857979595661,
0.024975402280688286,
-0.024940934032201767,
0.034158021211624146,
0.002033899538218975,
0.0245711337774992,
0.01669086329638958,
-0.08301007747650146,
0.021518554538488388,
0.0005225833738222718,
-0.001929321326315403,
0.05036110058426857,
-0.021603094413876534,
0.08962308615446091,
-0.006676872726529837,
0.024510890245437622,
0.05205909535288811,
-0.08223894238471985,
-0.07510346919298172,
0.04609464481472969,
-0.015419913455843925,
0.028152350336313248,
0.016670726239681244,
-0.0008912883349694312,
0.028629152104258537,
0.00030862638959661126,
0.02010512165725231,
0.029335543513298035,
-0.04304549843072891,
0.06645473837852478,
-0.0193038247525692,
-0.06751474738121033,
-0.02659141644835472,
0.0388818234205246,
-0.02414538711309433,
-0.0008347645052708685,
0.017742643132805824,
-0.014963602647185326,
0.00948081724345684,
-0.010338661260902882,
-0.02674460969865322,
0.04606578126549721,
-0.004007838200777769,
-0.009652401320636272,
0.018823841586709023,
-0.0224736537784338,
-0.06820520013570786,
0.015665654093027115,
0.023694388568401337,
-0.04504965990781784,
0.02279607765376568,
0.0077890679240226746,
0.10578641295433044,
0.0870015099644661,
-0.033146996051073074,
0.009077398106455803,
0.03856179490685463,
-0.004114215727895498,
-0.007005759980529547,
0.016440005972981453,
0.002269009593874216,
-0.004941877909004688,
-0.0005820175283588469,
0.015128761529922485,
-0.018078526481986046,
0.026752017438411713,
-0.058315277099609375,
0.030354570597410202,
0.044693831354379654,
-0.00826043076813221,
0.022250482812523842,
0.008529356680810452,
0.011514067649841309,
0.0435807928442955,
-0.02742956019937992,
-0.06252263486385345,
-0.03716565668582916,
0.008063146844506264,
0.019292524084448814,
-0.0005617354763671756,
0.0043019880540668964,
0.0012490605004131794,
-0.029558729380369186,
-0.003588201943784952,
0.023548156023025513,
0.05660106986761093,
0.04957703873515129,
0.003596315160393715,
0.00982558075338602,
0.011764539405703545,
-0.06231037527322769,
-0.050723280757665634,
-0.09020063281059265,
-0.023560456931591034,
-0.043216999620199203,
0.06382128596305847,
0.003908829763531685,
0.0629197210073471,
0.007302004843950272,
-0.028845272958278656,
-0.054069116711616516,
-0.046831164509058,
-0.014325440861284733,
0.03305321931838989,
0.004307350609451532,
-0.023792380467057228,
-0.02095738612115383,
0.014693237841129303,
0.06790108233690262,
-0.026593711227178574,
-0.0007990241283550858,
-0.008648592978715897,
-0.044121865183115005,
-0.004901867359876633,
0.012683005072176456,
-0.011054065078496933,
0.0412505641579628,
-0.0022226704750210047,
0.013629582710564137,
-0.04390222206711769,
0.009167421609163284,
0.05555902421474457,
0.03487679362297058,
0.02295967936515808,
-0.016892626881599426,
-0.02519887499511242,
-0.03247154876589775,
0.006574688013643026,
0.028896693140268326,
-0.02126701921224594,
-0.023173799738287926,
-0.021440669894218445,
0.023461468517780304,
0.015866154804825783,
-0.03276412934064865,
-0.24412670731544495,
0.0048023974522948265,
-0.004096961114555597,
0.0049331882037222385,
0.041773129254579544,
-0.032073698937892914,
0.019503580406308174,
-0.02451919950544834,
-0.0350298136472702,
-0.0025047629605978727,
-0.0442950613796711,
0.037904612720012665,
-0.017332924529910088,
0.061219558119773865,
0.04613574594259262,
0.006134204566478729,
-0.056105948984622955,
-0.04237779602408409,
0.0553194098174572,
0.0021197122987359762,
-0.03679211437702179,
-0.052876293659210205,
-0.019527999684214592,
0.049130577594041824,
-0.015108911320567131,
0.05475015565752983,
-0.06213529035449028,
0.00877708662301302,
-0.018575245514512062,
-0.01619667373597622,
-0.010001903399825096,
-0.06850486993789673,
0.004021173343062401,
0.04894084483385086,
-0.014725691638886929,
0.02326277457177639,
0.029257994145154953,
0.02854061685502529,
0.016812296584248543,
0.019706308841705322,
0.01894811913371086,
-0.0018978462321683764,
-0.04683380946516991,
-0.02288060449063778,
0.046010881662368774,
-0.012598192319273949,
-0.005296808667480946,
0.03251815214753151,
-0.01687716692686081,
0.03196408599615097,
0.017815683037042618,
-0.014346795156598091,
-0.024403318762779236,
-0.005068660713732243,
-0.017455020919442177,
-0.043110668659210205,
-0.0077540092170238495,
0.0011579790152609348,
-0.029738057404756546,
-0.010660757310688496,
-0.0123243797570467,
-0.044284410774707794,
-0.045404788106679916,
-0.05608244612812996,
-0.003157916711643338,
-0.019687596708536148,
-0.08583630621433258,
-0.03697583079338074,
0.05591757968068123,
0.007796821650117636,
-0.01464908104389906,
-0.002842518500983715,
-0.006631423719227314,
-0.11053407937288284,
-0.009428387507796288,
0.00975570734590292,
-0.03773074597120285,
-0.004741069860756397,
-0.005876775830984116,
0.042787302285432816,
-0.013661541044712067,
-0.040283095091581345,
0.005615358240902424,
0.03710120543837547,
-0.015501173213124275,
-0.029358135536313057,
0.025489216670393944,
-0.02258978597819805,
-0.015248140320181847,
-0.01440250501036644,
0.013604587875306606,
-0.030583737418055534,
0.029393412172794342,
-0.000825568160507828,
0.022525399923324585,
0.0365157388150692,
0.008017306216061115,
0.05124903470277786,
0.035357460379600525,
-0.024345530197024345,
0.05962866544723511,
-0.04956682026386261,
-0.02730381302535534,
-0.04132548347115517,
0.007861818186938763,
0.015638679265975952,
-0.05694451555609703,
-0.01861027628183365,
0.0395008809864521,
0.009721585549414158,
-0.024851253256201744,
0.011497794650495052,
0.00981417577713728,
-0.023078124970197678,
0.03626936674118042,
-0.030024578794836998,
-0.025636805221438408,
0.038639530539512634,
0.07020904868841171,
-0.017387427389621735,
-0.005754630081355572,
0.02167411521077156,
-0.03942255675792694,
-0.016012370586395264,
0.03868619725108147,
-0.012055449187755585,
-0.01533799059689045,
0.00821519922465086,
0.010038037784397602,
0.009537778794765472,
0.06551340967416763,
0.011855135671794415,
0.0256044864654541,
0.02130577154457569,
0.05445633456110954,
0.006717226468026638,
-0.04644393548369408,
-0.02700679562985897,
0.020889589563012123,
-0.007240268401801586,
0.026256004348397255,
-0.014172578230500221,
0.04764914885163307,
0.013777807354927063,
0.05979543179273605,
0.007685062941163778,
-0.010200989432632923,
0.07506128400564194,
0.003625394543632865,
-0.05269048362970352,
0.0026772930286824703,
-0.014042863622307777,
-0.03450881317257881,
-0.021371595561504364,
-0.0035592420026659966,
-0.007490608375519514,
0.04626071825623512,
-0.016850048676133156,
0.027928952127695084,
-0.047461338341236115,
0.0451897531747818,
0.02534329704940319,
-0.05019284784793854,
0.004361732397228479,
-0.02290201745927334,
0.028277698904275894,
0.0005910855252295732,
0.04270540550351143,
-0.006424407009035349,
-0.0024161520414054394,
0.016796108335256577,
-0.01829349435865879,
-0.028787460178136826,
-0.026155227795243263,
-0.053810104727745056,
0.018737182021141052,
-0.003723287023603916,
-0.022014686837792397,
-0.042473290115594864,
0.056388337165117264,
-0.00038932194001972675,
-0.03942035511136055,
0.02512323297560215,
0.025122469291090965,
0.08865496516227722,
0.04645009711384773,
0.0348813533782959,
-0.0544656440615654,
-0.04125811904668808,
0.03235263004899025,
-0.03234728053212166,
0.004668838810175657,
-0.04618019238114357,
0.014004422351717949,
-0.0372936986386776,
-0.03378080949187279,
-0.009814692661166191,
0.014512673020362854,
-0.012823816388845444,
-0.017030028626322746,
0.013982368633151054,
-0.016261370852589607,
-0.006738516502082348,
0.011048771440982819,
0.049825605005025864,
-0.055783212184906006,
0.008746720850467682,
0.04734097793698311,
-0.049960196018218994,
-0.0006072758114896715,
0.0007960220682434738,
-0.04162101447582245,
-0.014699478633701801,
0.01316357683390379,
-0.0226754117757082,
-0.0124182915315032,
0.001469710492528975,
-0.047333478927612305,
0.0018136254511773586,
0.02844507433474064,
-0.012969846837222576,
0.03132593259215355,
-0.03189823031425476,
-0.041049111634492874,
-0.04243556410074234,
0.030071789398789406,
-0.05300474166870117,
-0.030809851363301277,
0.02236698381602764,
-0.01525233406573534,
0.011242247186601162,
-0.03574823960661888,
0.021049832925200462,
0.06752113252878189,
0.015674129128456116,
0.00013652147026732564,
-0.04236149787902832,
0.017211923375725746,
0.027159031480550766,
0.03670405596494675,
0.04467281699180603,
-0.010643740184605122,
-0.03906412050127983,
0.013538732193410397,
0.009648224338889122,
0.045958731323480606,
-0.01450306549668312,
-0.0024928494822233915,
0.01554909348487854,
0.030728425830602646,
0.027610549703240395,
0.021971814334392548,
-0.02549557387828827,
0.014863324351608753,
0.05851719528436661,
-0.027499277144670486,
-0.0245486069470644,
-0.05369680002331734,
-0.0628589615225792,
0.006604548543691635,
-0.02035256288945675,
0.015261287800967693,
0.0033484504092484713,
0.03761453926563263,
0.06628493219614029,
0.006270759738981724,
-0.03562665730714798,
-0.008968573063611984,
0.03281285986304283,
-0.05057752877473831,
-0.017420604825019836,
-0.06604377180337906,
-0.01543346606194973,
0.054397303611040115,
-0.043405331671237946,
0.01831844262778759,
-0.0029254481196403503,
0.006085383240133524,
0.010761447250843048,
-0.056046001613140106,
-0.06796211004257202,
0.0019357397686690092,
-0.004992096219211817,
-0.02072073332965374,
-0.01089215837419033,
-0.03613551706075668,
-0.002288319868966937,
0.0008194998954422772,
-0.01685195229947567,
0.017497051507234573,
0.044880110770463943,
0.01655331440269947,
-0.047153666615486145,
-0.006840839516371489,
0.01686783693730831,
0.01610266976058483,
0.03613018989562988,
0.06774681806564331,
0.010443802922964096,
0.04380324110388756,
-0.05626838281750679,
0.07090988755226135,
0.06099589169025421,
-0.01096144039183855,
0.014710409566760063,
0.009594102390110493,
0.025571417063474655,
-0.006220073904842138,
-0.009330347180366516,
0.032048992812633514,
0.0068367463536560535,
-0.08030631393194199,
0.08104904741048813,
0.012415388599038124,
-0.06542661041021347,
-0.03028855100274086,
0.045531265437603,
-0.01763417012989521,
0.021626058965921402,
-0.016042502596974373,
0.006285811308771372,
0.027145609259605408,
0.03819078207015991,
0.012889456935226917,
0.02804512158036232,
0.06452133506536484,
0.016562998294830322,
0.019521981477737427,
0.013322094455361366,
0.06610830128192902,
0.09193498641252518,
0.009034993126988411,
0.01028301939368248,
0.09259728342294693,
-0.038263045251369476,
-0.027730554342269897,
0.021661829203367233,
0.024172209203243256,
-0.029384037479758263,
-0.01994839496910572,
0.05018698424100876,
0.0985909178853035,
-0.026438863947987556,
0.03443324193358421,
-0.04289131611585617,
-0.008280805312097073,
0.016276925802230835,
0.045488156378269196,
0.007067329250276089,
0.014325547032058239,
0.024849724024534225,
0.032668814063072205,
-0.03694470226764679,
0.007521594408899546,
-0.027029234915971756,
-0.02248440682888031,
0.0000490437560074497,
0.013126527890563011,
-0.02763191983103752,
-0.011021245270967484,
-0.002926402259618044,
-0.00014277453010436147,
0.06410038471221924,
-0.016392938792705536,
-0.0034620300866663456,
0.004935997072607279,
0.05895303189754486,
0.010708275251090527,
0.06156481057405472,
0.015508940443396568,
-0.015926707535982132,
-0.001139473868533969,
-0.023266442120075226,
0.003042730502784252,
-0.007447400595992804,
-0.0076897102408111095,
0.007712934631854296,
-0.035724539309740067,
0.016843529418110847,
0.0002451043401379138,
-0.019521787762641907,
-0.08105979114770889,
-0.04990621283650398,
-0.031396571546792984,
-0.07803429663181305,
-0.07164452970027924,
-0.05992461368441582,
0.0253225639462471,
-0.00584963895380497,
-0.01964796520769596,
0.002660803496837616,
-0.032745540142059326,
0.032428182661533356,
0.04297317937016487,
-0.04178823530673981,
-0.01355746015906334,
0.04719623550772667,
-0.01861388050019741,
-0.005143386777490377,
0.019935185089707375,
-0.015142921358346939,
-0.011673196218907833,
-0.03427431359887123,
0.043190211057662964,
-0.005803938489407301,
0.04510943964123726,
-0.00499039376154542,
-0.02370181493461132,
-0.10623268783092499,
0.0241436455398798,
0.03784073516726494,
0.0022001233883202076,
-0.09561993181705475,
0.027650315314531326,
-0.012807199731469154,
0.04348659887909889,
0.05345698446035385,
0.0015298703219741583,
0.015834422782063484,
-0.04265662282705307,
-0.016627980396151543,
-0.01057292427867651,
-0.004764207173138857,
0.051394056528806686,
-0.03745100274682045,
0.08383046835660934,
0.05493240803480148,
-0.014747245237231255,
-0.029041679576039314,
0.0433596707880497,
-0.0011327125830575824,
0.01964433304965496,
-0.019782034680247307,
-0.0029204159509390593,
-0.051530320197343826,
-0.09355409443378448,
-0.04308849573135376,
-0.004290287382900715,
-0.048172712326049805,
-0.038007933646440506,
-0.0027163252234458923,
-0.030486535280942917,
-0.003782011102885008,
-0.022041602060198784,
-0.0056885103695094585,
0.025032194331288338,
-0.024060919880867004,
-0.04385096952319145,
-0.07128977030515671,
-0.008974292315542698,
-0.01433630008250475,
0.016818564385175705,
0.0066227419301867485,
-0.04010419547557831,
-0.04036574810743332,
-0.008815663866698742,
-0.0171266570687294,
0.00594713119789958,
0.0028195958584547043,
0.021671729162335396
] |
374 |
Diffusion State-Guided Projected Gradient for Inverse Problems
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=kRBQwlkFSP
|
[
"Rayhan Zirvi",
"Bahareh Tolooshams",
"Anima Anandkumar"
] |
Poster
|
Recent advancements in diffusion models have been effective in learning data priors for solving inverse problems. They leverage diffusion sampling steps for inducing a data prior while using a measurement guidance gradient at each step to impose data consistency. For general inverse problems, approximations are needed when an unconditionally trained diffusion model is used since the measurement likelihood is intractable, leading to inaccurate posterior sampling. In other words, due to their approximations, these methods fail to preserve the generation process on the data manifold defined by the diffusion prior, leading to artifacts in applications such as image restoration. To enhance the performance and robustness of diffusion models in solving inverse problems, we propose Diffusion State-Guided Projected Gradient (DiffStateGrad), which projects the measurement gradient onto a subspace that is a low-rank approximation of an intermediate state of the diffusion process. DiffStateGrad, as a module, can be added to a wide range of diffusion-based inverse solvers to improve the preservation of the diffusion process on the prior manifold and filter out artifact-inducing components. We highlight that DiffStateGrad improves the robustness of diffusion models in terms of the choice of measurement guidance step size and noise while improving the worst-case performance. Finally, we demonstrate that DiffStateGrad improves upon the state-of-the-art on linear and nonlinear image restoration inverse problems. Our code is available at https://github.com/Anima-Lab/DiffStateGrad.
|
Diffusion models, Inverse problems, Robustness, Subspace, Projection, Box inpainting, Phase retrieval
|
We can improve the performance and robustness of diffusion-based models in solving inverse problems by adding a Diffusion State-Guided Projected Gradient step.
| 13,232 |
2410.03463
|
[
-0.00790506973862648,
-0.024994907900691032,
-0.01850685104727745,
0.05545689910650253,
0.07677259296178818,
0.03687408193945885,
0.025841446593403816,
-0.026181135326623917,
-0.01332686934620142,
-0.07343117147684097,
0.01811956614255905,
-0.013991638086736202,
-0.03485981374979019,
0.018514484167099,
0.018188271671533585,
0.05356631055474281,
0.03816697746515274,
-0.038476139307022095,
0.007043773308396339,
0.07678892463445663,
0.00518382340669632,
-0.032767679542303085,
0.0004112701572012156,
0.028127571567893028,
0.004858708009123802,
0.00010434454452479258,
0.03739536926150322,
0.007499047555029392,
-0.0362955778837204,
-0.046421121805906296,
0.0028971517458558083,
0.004405016079545021,
-0.007910717278718948,
-0.03873509168624878,
0.012210859917104244,
0.02867983654141426,
-0.0485803447663784,
0.011069745756685734,
-0.022690702229738235,
0.014174513518810272,
-0.04854524880647659,
0.008059058338403702,
-0.02926933392882347,
0.007231773808598518,
-0.03158799931406975,
-0.0024300937075167894,
-0.08834731578826904,
-0.0035636108368635178,
0.0009704431868158281,
-0.03468750789761543,
-0.10424023121595383,
0.019045526161789894,
0.005816894583404064,
-0.000046648176066810265,
-0.040118537843227386,
0.033606644719839096,
0.050264690071344376,
-0.05812174454331398,
-0.02444394677877426,
-0.033922746777534485,
-0.003006428014487028,
0.009638230316340923,
-0.0383126363158226,
-0.011600028723478317,
0.02252420037984848,
-0.011477610096335411,
0.011061948724091053,
0.05814114958047867,
-0.015308915637433529,
-0.03331003338098526,
-0.017062542960047722,
-0.005736216437071562,
0.014557247050106525,
-0.001037375652231276,
0.007080237381160259,
-0.014448837377130985,
0.01851743832230568,
0.014648974873125553,
0.05701228603720665,
-0.001966041512787342,
0.020522847771644592,
0.005875449161976576,
-0.0014147005276754498,
0.012766499072313309,
-0.01711880788207054,
-0.004288065247237682,
-0.020840443670749664,
-0.016399037092924118,
-0.05949889123439789,
0.04321134090423584,
-0.02982369437813759,
-0.06089596450328827,
0.016339754685759544,
0.02024216391146183,
0.06404473632574081,
-0.04931507259607315,
0.04127057269215584,
0.0029749427922070026,
0.017544612288475037,
-0.02849949337542057,
-0.02509889006614685,
-0.0356350913643837,
0.004736260045319796,
0.01371661014854908,
-0.06455492228269577,
-0.02629922144114971,
-0.0568588525056839,
0.0027881511487066746,
-0.047967057675123215,
-0.003786602057516575,
-0.016410518437623978,
0.01877087913453579,
-0.021825270727276802,
-0.020077966153621674,
-0.09526830166578293,
0.01755702868103981,
0.03708357736468315,
-0.0079890051856637,
0.02529561147093773,
0.0011062901467084885,
0.04433275759220123,
0.04658987745642662,
0.013514658436179161,
0.04702819883823395,
-0.0049162376672029495,
0.05480797961354256,
0.06497620046138763,
0.022685157135128975,
-0.07273898273706436,
-0.046163443475961685,
-0.004358936101198196,
0.036881837993860245,
0.020643949508666992,
-0.0012710770824924111,
0.016822917386889458,
-0.0481933131814003,
0.004080498591065407,
0.009674996137619019,
0.040287718176841736,
-0.003533670213073492,
0.01469297707080841,
-0.019754018634557724,
0.044065989553928375,
-0.028361475095152855,
0.030233249068260193,
-0.048196133226156235,
0.03139881044626236,
-0.020571254193782806,
-0.06346310675144196,
0.05052248761057854,
0.02023005671799183,
0.003301970660686493,
0.04627538099884987,
-0.051230404525995255,
-0.019674191251397133,
0.022695178166031837,
-0.02956305257976055,
0.019579842686653137,
-0.024991996586322784,
-0.011653661727905273,
0.03928443044424057,
-0.02976098842918873,
-0.008073968812823296,
-0.009767475537955761,
0.004793729167431593,
-0.04876892268657684,
0.057960331439971924,
0.02616860345005989,
-0.012445691972970963,
-0.03864526376128197,
-0.039874982088804245,
-0.03199034556746483,
0.04597783088684082,
0.013360042124986649,
0.0018419468542560935,
0.01904606819152832,
0.014300295151770115,
0.021306252107024193,
0.013574007898569107,
0.030854355543851852,
-0.0884423702955246,
0.029872708022594452,
0.008181966841220856,
-0.039957866072654724,
0.03121400997042656,
-0.026394424960017204,
0.0874834731221199,
-0.043006181716918945,
0.018918337300419807,
0.03833157196640968,
-0.09375498443841934,
-0.010735470801591873,
0.019308261573314667,
-0.019633686169981956,
0.05800256133079529,
0.05180785432457924,
-0.024553421884775162,
0.005693316459655762,
0.03888928145170212,
0.05274878814816475,
0.05228334292769432,
-0.033235494047403336,
0.04606238380074501,
-0.007460391148924828,
0.00008120469283312559,
-0.008488940075039864,
0.06998839974403381,
-0.035178981721401215,
-0.011860167607665062,
0.04388059303164482,
-0.012094692327082157,
-0.028921183198690414,
-0.006781777832657099,
-0.0027886524330824614,
0.05029899626970291,
-0.007427719887346029,
-0.02822767198085785,
-0.006592152174562216,
0.03284768387675285,
-0.0544792078435421,
0.03755555301904678,
0.034201301634311676,
-0.011264566332101822,
0.030130930244922638,
-0.008899382315576077,
0.09326472878456116,
0.08238891512155533,
-0.02618539147078991,
-0.009844274260103703,
0.021998602896928787,
0.009025475941598415,
-0.00909495446830988,
0.024822838604450226,
-0.03439794480800629,
0.030404018238186836,
-0.017367247492074966,
0.015164443291723728,
-0.023182829841971397,
0.09336462616920471,
-0.039519377052783966,
-0.0029402736108750105,
0.040987078100442886,
0.001104249618947506,
0.07012158632278442,
0.0007079929928295314,
0.026753751561045647,
0.08398031443357468,
-0.0034616091288626194,
-0.0679258182644844,
-0.0052064708434045315,
-0.012040352448821068,
0.0361136719584465,
0.013116537593305111,
-0.03732447698712349,
0.03388300910592079,
-0.04469066858291626,
-0.00870182178914547,
-0.008767914026975632,
0.05209686979651451,
0.06449267268180847,
0.012609248049557209,
0.022402066737413406,
0.01653458923101425,
-0.04992111027240753,
-0.0096670463681221,
-0.0930272713303566,
-0.037390466779470444,
-0.018734842538833618,
0.01410808227956295,
0.007966253906488419,
0.052180156111717224,
-0.02003643848001957,
0.021289967000484467,
-0.01174146868288517,
-0.019977940246462822,
0.009867182932794094,
0.02042534202337265,
0.01056904811412096,
-0.03478299826383591,
-0.0032086374703794718,
0.040681857615709305,
0.07090356945991516,
-0.046254128217697144,
-0.0006658467464148998,
-0.03874684497714043,
-0.06916256994009018,
-0.004229723941534758,
0.025584006682038307,
-0.003633926622569561,
0.019523244351148605,
0.01187555119395256,
0.0063273417763412,
-0.005884766113013029,
0.03498203679919243,
0.009894868358969688,
0.045316122472286224,
0.03190305456519127,
0.0002404791011940688,
-0.004390142858028412,
0.0023007828276604414,
-0.006766655948013067,
0.006283095106482506,
0.0027963321190327406,
0.020555106922984123,
-0.03573207929730415,
-0.015873411670327187,
0.04485560581088066,
-0.02823624201118946,
-0.25183746218681335,
0.01720474660396576,
0.01601504720747471,
0.0043196058832108974,
0.04919957369565964,
-0.009257168509066105,
0.03434957191348076,
-0.023769740015268326,
-0.051099278032779694,
0.039997681975364685,
0.002284243470057845,
0.041816893965005875,
0.02343456633388996,
0.0730038657784462,
0.051919400691986084,
-0.009809822775423527,
0.019547341391444206,
-0.01175689697265625,
-0.005499208811670542,
0.04348831623792648,
-0.030325714498758316,
-0.07337044179439545,
-0.0026746594812721014,
0.008971475064754486,
-0.0007234092918224633,
0.0047700670547783375,
-0.05913761630654335,
0.014715269207954407,
-0.04285343736410141,
-0.017285585403442383,
-0.031465064734220505,
-0.02511473186314106,
-0.0002086877793772146,
0.05518321320414543,
-0.018444405868649483,
-0.01432576309889555,
0.024551451206207275,
0.03847573697566986,
0.032064590603113174,
-0.03235471248626709,
-0.006595872808247805,
-0.001751767355017364,
-0.04705074056982994,
0.010600483976304531,
0.04505487531423569,
0.020908400416374207,
-0.003800266655161977,
-0.01061183586716652,
0.027643853798508644,
0.02788904309272766,
0.02741265296936035,
0.01316283643245697,
0.000010083319466502871,
-0.0004806301440112293,
-0.00948586966842413,
-0.027251651510596275,
0.012610048055648804,
0.018393466249108315,
-0.005212492309510708,
0.03856167942285538,
-0.02179129235446453,
-0.04631494730710983,
-0.01770670898258686,
-0.03423595800995827,
0.0029493761248886585,
-0.043223265558481216,
-0.07173669338226318,
-0.058474041521549225,
0.04267187789082527,
0.016807958483695984,
-0.015175748616456985,
-0.006478835362941027,
-0.023000415414571762,
-0.10790590941905975,
0.04372372478246689,
-0.0020419673528522253,
-0.009935499168932438,
-0.06330232322216034,
-0.02119646966457367,
0.02901821956038475,
-0.03849804028868675,
-0.037597451359033585,
0.03260466456413269,
0.04812362417578697,
-0.01932106725871563,
-0.0052583119831979275,
0.025585992261767387,
-0.04315345361828804,
-0.017809884622693062,
-0.053044747561216354,
0.04027636721730232,
-0.004504850599914789,
0.024044280871748924,
-0.006706970278173685,
0.015885433182120323,
0.06629998236894608,
0.0179787278175354,
0.05706895887851715,
0.02873133309185505,
-0.021115193143486977,
0.038754794746637344,
-0.08267375081777573,
-0.02955351211130619,
-0.04912946745753288,
-0.021069617941975594,
0.018533645197749138,
-0.04965855926275253,
-0.03497305512428284,
0.04746076092123985,
0.007714267820119858,
-0.040442511439323425,
0.011829965747892857,
0.006985613144934177,
0.001355900545604527,
-0.028846928849816322,
-0.009529725648462772,
-0.011555707082152367,
0.03811116889119148,
0.019128158688545227,
-0.01588674820959568,
0.0034527729731053114,
0.029005492106080055,
-0.030481144785881042,
0.006162161473184824,
0.0008824276155792177,
0.00559597834944725,
-0.020743155851960182,
0.007452182471752167,
0.0120858671143651,
-0.0017697860021144152,
0.07969002425670624,
0.06168676167726517,
0.025276385247707367,
0.050444260239601135,
0.039047714322805405,
0.0034393067471683025,
-0.009049861691892147,
-0.026659276336431503,
0.04299548640847206,
-0.038065355271101,
0.01792360283434391,
-0.016494562849402428,
0.05408301576972008,
0.006480411626398563,
0.037661995738744736,
0.03144729137420654,
0.018373601138591766,
0.028941210359334946,
-0.0057661826722323895,
-0.0408947616815567,
0.04207181558012962,
-0.049521662294864655,
-0.058781541883945465,
-0.018051335588097572,
0.024941187351942062,
-0.03676830604672432,
0.030022431164979935,
-0.043757397681474686,
0.039999086409807205,
-0.07707544416189194,
0.017418820410966873,
0.043491411954164505,
-0.05336534604430199,
-0.007283126004040241,
-0.01495265495032072,
0.04038430005311966,
-0.012742956168949604,
-0.004893070552498102,
0.021056929603219032,
-0.005512936040759087,
0.023562463000416756,
-0.03134331852197647,
-0.04106239974498749,
-0.03663843497633934,
-0.020533882081508636,
0.00807451643049717,
0.005998905282467604,
-0.024147095158696175,
-0.049557242542505264,
0.03841531649231911,
0.04120820015668869,
-0.037126023322343826,
-0.014701314270496368,
0.016752392053604126,
0.05667249485850334,
-0.03134884312748909,
0.00487641803920269,
-0.01107342541217804,
-0.014572125859558582,
0.04422619566321373,
-0.014805898070335388,
-0.003773579839617014,
-0.07007535547018051,
-0.028358159586787224,
-0.02601742185652256,
-0.04245183244347572,
-0.003583190031349659,
0.03778805956244469,
-0.014950927346944809,
0.0016471061389893293,
-0.019441010430455208,
0.025413399562239647,
-0.022214362397789955,
-0.002169386250898242,
0.017664210870862007,
-0.06585311889648438,
-0.004097572062164545,
0.04760299623012543,
-0.0251759123057127,
0.0027516523841768503,
-0.013423205353319645,
-0.039312541484832764,
-0.07687390595674515,
-0.010371267795562744,
0.011384692043066025,
-0.01538681611418724,
-0.007347614038735628,
-0.021512383595108986,
0.028262779116630554,
0.009457290172576904,
0.008664257824420929,
0.027883486822247505,
-0.008618990890681744,
-0.009968163445591927,
-0.005969650112092495,
0.025828732177615166,
-0.03488445654511452,
0.006005961447954178,
0.0075030154548585415,
-0.017529062926769257,
0.01845153048634529,
-0.0353398472070694,
0.0013436534209176898,
0.04935543239116669,
0.02904277853667736,
0.024044344201683998,
-0.04677196964621544,
0.024133728817105293,
-0.06462978571653366,
-0.01034002099186182,
0.0018675066530704498,
0.011992375366389751,
-0.009152556769549847,
-0.0017942817648872733,
-0.004983339458703995,
0.01932516135275364,
0.008805868215858936,
-0.01437686663120985,
0.011156857945024967,
0.056134939193725586,
0.02129025012254715,
0.007759394124150276,
-0.07257839292287827,
-0.010021980851888657,
0.06908339262008667,
-0.018361754715442657,
-0.009420502930879593,
-0.09099636971950531,
-0.028171230107545853,
0.025034194812178612,
0.008494679816067219,
0.01872280053794384,
-0.02302597090601921,
0.008517870679497719,
0.03180300444364548,
-0.01650855503976345,
-0.00969462189823389,
0.009548353031277657,
0.04075303301215172,
-0.061527956277132034,
-0.0035669170320034027,
-0.046187639236450195,
0.014309406280517578,
0.05148026719689369,
-0.057116467505693436,
0.027725225314497948,
0.01605989784002304,
0.015568750910460949,
0.038787633180618286,
-0.03170549124479294,
-0.07919448614120483,
0.007146558258682489,
-0.0406428687274456,
-0.025708885863423347,
0.016815979033708572,
-0.047054506838321686,
-0.0019037413876503706,
-0.015405322425067425,
-0.05656545236706734,
-0.002759466180577874,
0.050742898136377335,
0.020797280594706535,
-0.011916586197912693,
-0.01725369319319725,
-0.010007510893046856,
0.012677052058279514,
0.021443551406264305,
0.07981593906879425,
0.014390995725989342,
0.011448580771684647,
-0.03651995584368706,
0.05022639036178589,
0.04687493294477463,
0.03610389679670334,
0.02056020498275757,
0.01552102155983448,
-0.014466389082372189,
-0.03336836025118828,
0.03954053670167923,
0.028382286429405212,
-0.005414870567619801,
-0.08416961878538132,
0.020494641736149788,
0.04544371739029884,
-0.02646554820239544,
-0.04150257259607315,
0.05890566110610962,
-0.036834027618169785,
-0.002257696120068431,
0.008716020733118057,
0.03159993514418602,
0.013529544696211815,
0.05497019365429878,
-0.002838642569258809,
0.028670594096183777,
0.02850997820496559,
-0.015965912491083145,
0.02905033715069294,
-0.005129044409841299,
0.07028085738420486,
0.06250004470348358,
0.026154890656471252,
0.010534797795116901,
0.07138355076313019,
-0.026055296882987022,
-0.033608198165893555,
0.019436325877904892,
0.004285890143364668,
-0.03603772446513176,
-0.04274987801909447,
-0.00374413188546896,
0.11255485564470291,
-0.006495845504105091,
0.0570983961224556,
-0.045785799622535706,
0.01084125880151987,
0.0295766219496727,
0.027276471257209778,
-0.009141366928815842,
-0.02403441071510315,
-0.005164517555385828,
-0.0007256194367073476,
0.006050834432244301,
-0.008628915064036846,
-0.0334487147629261,
-0.02620646543800831,
0.05130458623170853,
-0.006245276425033808,
-0.010412809439003468,
0.037239544093608856,
0.014005563221871853,
-0.013534790836274624,
0.0772714912891388,
-0.04607699438929558,
-0.03690392151474953,
-0.041685864329338074,
-0.03402698412537575,
0.01392293069511652,
0.03202774375677109,
0.008157077245414257,
-0.013994608074426651,
0.008329980075359344,
-0.03408387303352356,
0.009506957605481148,
0.06795019656419754,
-0.02598622627556324,
0.021317414939403534,
-0.019883066415786743,
0.008685009554028511,
0.03320926055312157,
0.006088724359869957,
-0.034277237951755524,
-0.05302440747618675,
-0.06965301930904388,
-0.0471782386302948,
-0.057984527200460434,
-0.0213603675365448,
0.07543003559112549,
0.019857116043567657,
-0.06546276062726974,
0.00831582397222519,
-0.04573899880051613,
-0.009588047862052917,
0.014811242930591106,
-0.06246710568666458,
-0.026949165388941765,
0.06791924685239792,
-0.013423280790448189,
-0.013889530673623085,
0.0017331913113594055,
0.02038540318608284,
-0.02019023895263672,
0.0009173710132017732,
0.01879114657640457,
-0.018303805962204933,
0.036627184599637985,
-0.048126380890607834,
0.0030395998619496822,
-0.0766809806227684,
-0.0044530886225402355,
0.04683680459856987,
-0.02336769737303257,
-0.07905884087085724,
0.015229030512273312,
-0.03273466229438782,
0.006792631931602955,
0.04647369682788849,
-0.00946827046573162,
-0.013187329284846783,
-0.04748636111617088,
-0.04062340408563614,
-0.049513377249240875,
0.00571444584056735,
0.05048539116978645,
-0.019428087398409843,
0.08110880851745605,
0.0633588656783104,
-0.012870565056800842,
-0.030019227415323257,
0.04111632704734802,
-0.010877697728574276,
0.010424145497381687,
-0.022421805188059807,
0.006934927776455879,
-0.04403166100382805,
-0.10069786757230759,
-0.04140127822756767,
0.019994504749774933,
-0.03849411755800247,
-0.036823563277721405,
0.000678663607686758,
0.0004484897362999618,
0.03363778069615364,
-0.012383746914565563,
-0.010124796070158482,
-0.002675820840522647,
-0.0394306518137455,
-0.03483280912041664,
-0.039422620087862015,
0.02888825349509716,
-0.001560502452775836,
0.009422516450285912,
-0.009969125501811504,
-0.044030677527189255,
-0.01652611419558525,
-0.003394701983779669,
0.037472959607839584,
0.006596861872822046,
0.0385952964425087,
-0.020418155938386917
] |
375 |
MADGEN: Mass-Spec attends to De Novo Molecular generation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=78tc3EiUrN
|
[
"Yinkai Wang",
"Xiaohui Chen",
"Liping Liu",
"Soha Hassoun"
] |
Poster
|
The annotation (assigning structural chemical identities) of MS/MS spectra remains a significant challenge due to the enormous molecular diversity in biological samples and the limited scope of reference databases. Currently, the vast majority of spectral measurements remain in the "dark chemical space" without structural annotations. To improve annotation, we propose MADGEN (Mass-spec Attends to De Novo Molecular GENeration), a scaffold-based method for de novo molecular structure generation guided by mass spectrometry data. MADGEN operates in two stages: scaffold retrieval and spectra-conditioned molecular generation starting with the scaffold. In the first stage, given an MS/MS spectrum, we formulate scaffold retrieval as a ranking problem and employ contrastive learning to align mass spectra with candidate molecular scaffolds. In the second stage, starting from the retrieved scaffold, we employ the MS/MS spectrum to guide an attention-based generative model to generate the final molecule. Our approach constrains the molecular generation search space, reducing its complexity and improving generation accuracy. We evaluate MADGEN on three datasets (NIST23, CANOPUS, and MassSpecGym) and evaluate MADGEN's performance with a predictive scaffold retriever and with an oracle retriever. We demonstrate the effectiveness of using attention to integrate spectral information throughout the generation process to achieve strong results with the oracle retriever.
|
AI4Science, Biology Discovery, Metabolomics, MS/MS spectra
|
A novel framework for De Novo molecule generation with classifier-free guidance from mass spectra.
| 13,230 |
2501.01950
|
[
-0.02423747070133686,
-0.017390454187989235,
-0.018348854035139084,
0.026463061571121216,
0.06156689301133156,
-0.012710502371191978,
0.025728635489940643,
0.0014524176949635148,
-0.03662616014480591,
-0.02472587674856186,
-0.019040832296013832,
0.01372136827558279,
-0.044370707124471664,
-0.012521132826805115,
0.03410990536212921,
0.06446045637130737,
0.04421265050768852,
0.023243887349963188,
0.03417026996612549,
0.013091529719531536,
-0.024888835847377777,
-0.009215329773724079,
0.056467194110155106,
0.018697010353207588,
0.05244166776537895,
-0.008304781280457973,
-0.0043636225163936615,
-0.004698721691966057,
-0.05205725133419037,
-0.01672407239675522,
0.016611212864518166,
-0.018908893689513206,
0.010321415960788727,
-0.02300526760518551,
0.017162883654236794,
0.013586153276264668,
-0.06489159911870956,
0.003241549711674452,
-0.012460540980100632,
0.005162152461707592,
-0.04645437002182007,
0.011280139908194542,
-0.006797144655138254,
0.007601618766784668,
-0.06738967448472977,
0.03945654630661011,
-0.08143743127584457,
0.04199051856994629,
-0.04331280291080475,
-0.03862141817808151,
-0.06289934366941452,
0.03247165307402611,
0.010296053253114223,
-0.02066217176616192,
-0.007648475468158722,
0.05596642568707466,
0.02384069934487343,
-0.03772025555372238,
-0.023587241768836975,
-0.04352260008454323,
-0.03402075916528702,
-0.0007601773831993341,
0.011788281612098217,
0.03084646537899971,
0.026120027527213097,
-0.015461694449186325,
0.020073628053069115,
0.0009925247868523002,
-0.07079920917749405,
0.00015518775035161525,
0.006912339013069868,
-0.04757954925298691,
-0.004243534989655018,
0.008736362680792809,
0.04880348592996597,
-0.04413535073399544,
0.008148700930178165,
-0.0006113940617069602,
0.02141067385673523,
0.04107053205370903,
-0.029141180217266083,
0.024744557216763496,
-0.0037926326040178537,
0.034503452479839325,
-0.055428396910429,
-0.006737345829606056,
-0.05682005733251572,
0.015258333645761013,
-0.05884686857461929,
0.055654529482126236,
-0.013906768523156643,
-0.0369006022810936,
0.017383567988872528,
0.014080586843192577,
0.048243168741464615,
-0.03203972801566124,
0.02130970172584057,
0.00238358904607594,
-0.021623289212584496,
0.005168216768652201,
-0.022758154198527336,
-0.01997167244553566,
0.013167904689908028,
-0.016291841864585876,
-0.08338625729084015,
-0.010760149918496609,
-0.04262731224298477,
-0.03915557637810707,
-0.005838602781295776,
0.0010114029282703996,
-0.0009472474921494722,
-0.0012526287464424968,
-0.012555924244225025,
0.03361210972070694,
-0.06929811090230942,
0.06901902705430984,
0.025885310024023056,
-0.01792960800230503,
0.019595608115196228,
0.016660446301102638,
0.05326413735747337,
0.08861803263425827,
-0.023152051493525505,
0.07998501509428024,
-0.01697489246726036,
-0.0016584953991696239,
0.020690610632300377,
0.02245946414768696,
-0.0214666910469532,
-0.017296168953180313,
0.003912948537617922,
0.04507557675242424,
-0.030712081119418144,
-0.00518615311011672,
0.029546227306127548,
-0.018964452669024467,
0.03535952419042587,
0.009286237880587578,
0.09030766040086746,
0.019228987395763397,
0.007112652529031038,
-0.034874558448791504,
-0.014299659989774227,
-0.045433953404426575,
0.04027291014790535,
-0.009409538470208645,
-0.025446858257055283,
-0.036961764097213745,
-0.026513950899243355,
0.037162356078624725,
0.023728670552372932,
-0.0018875120440497994,
0.007429418154060841,
-0.021619966253638268,
0.05202672630548477,
0.0937701016664505,
-0.0005967245670035481,
-0.003514121985062957,
-0.003160845721140504,
0.0072864871472120285,
-0.009427325800061226,
-0.014457286335527897,
-0.020824868232011795,
0.020852498710155487,
0.012504979968070984,
-0.012971197254955769,
0.0033472198992967606,
0.04034597799181938,
-0.033381883054971695,
-0.013638784177601337,
-0.04358905553817749,
-0.07832253724336624,
0.07317949086427689,
-0.04707778990268707,
-0.011111309751868248,
-0.01718272641301155,
0.034558363258838654,
0.017053158953785896,
0.020353088155388832,
0.011731973849236965,
-0.08857414871454239,
0.04114685580134392,
0.005011638160794973,
-0.03306102752685547,
0.004483745899051428,
-0.0051500131376087666,
0.10481578856706619,
0.024908341467380524,
-0.004046993795782328,
0.04872636869549751,
-0.06090022996068001,
-0.061673250049352646,
0.06354621052742004,
0.01094773132354021,
0.050607360899448395,
-0.01580476574599743,
-0.00041059954673983157,
0.03671502694487572,
0.005542859435081482,
-0.005535401403903961,
-0.015985600650310516,
0.02186177857220173,
0.09406761825084686,
-0.06471181660890579,
-0.032323792576789856,
-0.026350170373916626,
0.020153820514678955,
-0.06681001931428909,
-0.015308383852243423,
-0.006310697644948959,
-0.014098004437983036,
-0.00204786891117692,
0.009658333845436573,
-0.016138870269060135,
0.023505043238401413,
-0.01525056827813387,
0.0037526474334299564,
-0.0007095414330251515,
-0.06240350008010864,
-0.005170062649995089,
0.05359529331326485,
0.019219787791371346,
0.004172586835920811,
-0.0025023948401212692,
-0.03002176806330681,
0.10780270397663116,
0.07729770243167877,
-0.03875814005732536,
0.019034728407859802,
0.04059552401304245,
0.035881318151950836,
-0.02132968045771122,
0.007130634970963001,
-0.021495383232831955,
-0.03394708409905434,
-0.02566698007285595,
0.021307649090886116,
0.014495407231152058,
0.048660364001989365,
-0.0662691593170166,
0.02113267593085766,
0.038762349635362625,
-0.017120881006121635,
0.052302055060863495,
-0.025048617273569107,
-0.009038906544446945,
0.03691879287362099,
-0.014147922396659851,
-0.08158357441425323,
-0.006223005708307028,
-0.0056068929843604565,
-0.00013969589781481773,
-0.012661419808864594,
-0.030550453811883926,
0.007446330972015858,
-0.06847178936004639,
-0.06176333129405975,
-0.02031286619603634,
0.050320517271757126,
0.05286158621311188,
-0.02084285393357277,
0.014179810881614685,
0.009330673143267632,
-0.037740882486104965,
-0.03443220630288124,
-0.08893299847841263,
-0.02657306380569935,
-0.020185338333249092,
0.028107572346925735,
0.015652814880013466,
0.06516185402870178,
0.005590318236500025,
-0.025783859193325043,
-0.010812273249030113,
-0.02115330845117569,
0.030235186219215393,
0.006137470249086618,
0.0090281181037426,
-0.0769302025437355,
0.0013389422092586756,
-0.003291952656581998,
0.08295241743326187,
-0.007781391032040119,
-0.017968768253922462,
-0.05809945985674858,
-0.06351407617330551,
-0.021694017574191093,
-0.02043522521853447,
0.008511628955602646,
0.051395636051893234,
0.009087908081710339,
0.018187616020441055,
-0.04001999273896217,
0.02487289346754551,
0.04590628668665886,
-0.008398786187171936,
0.012688259594142437,
0.06344596296548843,
-0.015573822893202305,
0.026971757411956787,
-0.0017699407180771232,
0.03274916112422943,
-0.037015002220869064,
-0.01707102172076702,
0.024097470566630363,
0.006449337583035231,
0.008915252983570099,
-0.02271432988345623,
-0.24907958507537842,
-0.030894283205270767,
0.006072214338928461,
0.011433360166847706,
0.05830058082938194,
-0.025415947660803795,
0.012245964258909225,
-0.03445184975862503,
-0.012117580510675907,
-0.0026851268485188484,
0.01937757432460785,
0.02158481813967228,
0.010214568115770817,
0.03844879940152168,
0.03530065715312958,
0.03805530443787575,
-0.0033995078410953283,
-0.04487316682934761,
0.0495540127158165,
0.03482656925916672,
-0.011754331178963184,
-0.04186301305890083,
-0.018641814589500427,
0.053998518735170364,
-0.030841104686260223,
-0.01271169725805521,
-0.07714451104402542,
-0.010368552058935165,
-0.03163708746433258,
0.007807548623532057,
-0.010271185077726841,
-0.024618232622742653,
-0.015439994633197784,
0.015461116097867489,
0.048955101519823074,
-0.022487174719572067,
0.035277169197797775,
-0.018659474328160286,
-0.00723275076597929,
-0.031042233109474182,
-0.005032590590417385,
-0.014947721734642982,
-0.051867932081222534,
0.012152187526226044,
0.043003540486097336,
0.03140062093734741,
-0.016891691833734512,
-0.011287009343504906,
-0.018583044409751892,
0.05705556273460388,
-0.004588140640407801,
-0.0326295904815197,
-0.022572869434952736,
0.008425644598901272,
0.03960929438471794,
-0.0035532235633581877,
0.03664083033800125,
0.014112698845565319,
-0.04248753935098648,
0.010211963206529617,
0.017907598987221718,
-0.029988514259457588,
0.00007199412357294932,
-0.03045954555273056,
-0.044173210859298706,
-0.030042901635169983,
-0.04792527109384537,
-0.04083900898694992,
0.03287262097001076,
0.0324370376765728,
-0.025685379281640053,
0.01717858389019966,
-0.021831436082720757,
-0.07792066037654877,
0.04430270567536354,
-0.02031692862510681,
-0.033193595707416534,
-0.024146107956767082,
0.005110236816108227,
0.020434200763702393,
-0.01045318879187107,
0.0024655426386743784,
0.013354068621993065,
0.05847783014178276,
0.006233070977032185,
-0.0500444695353508,
-0.023601163178682327,
-0.007680297363549471,
-0.007189386524260044,
-0.020594168454408646,
0.025287602096796036,
-0.03829794004559517,
0.024582458660006523,
-0.02349201589822769,
0.02250373549759388,
0.034451138228178024,
0.017225366085767746,
0.06059196963906288,
0.05086725950241089,
0.015177895314991474,
0.04366728663444519,
-0.03952431678771973,
0.008254959248006344,
-0.01947168819606304,
-0.013626006431877613,
-0.024463355541229248,
-0.06747160851955414,
-0.022383248433470726,
0.05948372930288315,
-0.01494520716369152,
-0.05865445360541344,
-0.016330905258655548,
-0.02536284178495407,
-0.026977982372045517,
0.009233667515218258,
-0.015644865110516548,
0.03677831217646599,
0.03118055872619152,
0.04284253716468811,
-0.0206660907715559,
-0.021074747666716576,
0.033513735979795456,
0.01201922819018364,
-0.02029320038855076,
0.008461298421025276,
-0.03290287405252457,
-0.013013459742069244,
-0.001150053576566279,
0.003442205023020506,
-0.004714469891041517,
0.01606527902185917,
0.02987338788807392,
-0.012640945613384247,
0.016227426007390022,
0.0683780163526535,
0.03135177120566368,
-0.033534612506628036,
-0.015154894441366196,
0.019551342353224754,
-0.01796398125588894,
-0.014511396177113056,
-0.038406360894441605,
0.03630879521369934,
0.04711361601948738,
0.06208429113030434,
0.025602517649531364,
0.056562088429927826,
0.05801650136709213,
0.01998058520257473,
-0.008421910926699638,
0.007773905526846647,
-0.04417303204536438,
-0.010396843776106834,
-0.020519625395536423,
0.029048636555671692,
-0.015204773284494877,
0.03736264631152153,
0.0156514011323452,
0.012924542650580406,
-0.08854729682207108,
0.018859118223190308,
0.004595991224050522,
-0.014123174361884594,
-0.007371561601758003,
-0.04828422889113426,
0.07270555943250656,
-0.011790809221565723,
0.010071270167827606,
-0.008279207162559032,
0.00788804516196251,
0.01279835682362318,
-0.05005476623773575,
-0.04189934581518173,
0.010860676877200603,
-0.04688020423054695,
0.019982721656560898,
0.020845232531428337,
0.012717455625534058,
-0.03161711245775223,
0.004371080081909895,
-0.007289741653949022,
-0.012348764576017857,
0.004145966377109289,
-0.03053896874189377,
0.07465726137161255,
0.003442110726609826,
-0.021000463515520096,
-0.024817267432808876,
-0.03393369913101196,
0.002567076124250889,
-0.012997705489397049,
0.002920597093179822,
-0.030386116355657578,
-0.01907910779118538,
-0.03610653057694435,
-0.05075709894299507,
0.01705281436443329,
0.020668331533670425,
0.005016365088522434,
-0.02885454334318638,
0.052554622292518616,
0.030320510268211365,
-0.024782994762063026,
0.00960035715252161,
0.05147434398531914,
-0.07039142400026321,
0.004250548779964447,
0.06121303141117096,
0.0037493796553462744,
0.00595083786174655,
-0.020267991349101067,
0.008472046814858913,
-0.021913236007094383,
0.021763794124126434,
0.00720487255603075,
0.00862185563892126,
0.01208424847573042,
0.004986768122762442,
0.012831924483180046,
-0.00792792346328497,
0.02748718112707138,
0.028894897550344467,
0.017673498019576073,
-0.03580565005540848,
0.010542052797973156,
0.04731176793575287,
0.02003040909767151,
0.026226302608847618,
0.016889013350009918,
-0.015070811845362186,
0.03796667605638504,
-0.04602566361427307,
0.04024585336446762,
0.00568843400105834,
0.020236559212207794,
-0.01712140254676342,
-0.016932262107729912,
0.03399999812245369,
0.004091103561222553,
0.021423084661364555,
0.023813089355826378,
-0.02572791278362274,
-0.009239360690116882,
0.03179563209414482,
-0.009975649416446686,
0.02512519061565399,
0.011649828404188156,
0.006740124896168709,
0.010349978692829609,
0.042594391852617264,
-0.0002552900114096701,
0.02153564803302288,
-0.031213272362947464,
-0.033217791467905045,
0.042745862156152725,
-0.02740706317126751,
-0.07213623821735382,
-0.06816801428794861,
-0.032603852450847626,
0.0013345733750611544,
0.0036155676934868097,
0.061725303530693054,
-0.0336797833442688,
0.031754616647958755,
0.03432594612240791,
-0.0004890080890618265,
-0.04528092220425606,
-0.058656737208366394,
0.044555407017469406,
-0.06974935531616211,
0.008365077897906303,
-0.04331790283322334,
-0.0012970437528565526,
0.12036266177892685,
-0.014026422053575516,
0.012764018960297108,
-0.027894631028175354,
-0.05182060971856117,
0.007870854809880257,
-0.011979548260569572,
-0.08830033987760544,
0.052151117473840714,
-0.01146947592496872,
0.019936030730605125,
0.04743456095457077,
-0.06159351021051407,
-0.030206842347979546,
-0.015894725918769836,
-0.013003889471292496,
-0.027806349098682404,
0.03936532512307167,
0.04327275604009628,
-0.058446623384952545,
-0.01356147788465023,
-0.0060861497186124325,
0.014008373953402042,
0.002089491579681635,
0.03234761953353882,
0.015504548326134682,
0.016636546701192856,
-0.04044432193040848,
0.07772303372621536,
0.08547336608171463,
-0.024805432185530663,
0.013470597565174103,
0.01461764145642519,
0.0007948827696964145,
-0.01802998222410679,
0.027136024087667465,
-0.0008783121593296528,
0.010523051954805851,
-0.0520116426050663,
0.06806854158639908,
0.029392244294285774,
-0.08319903910160065,
-0.0465787909924984,
0.05352160334587097,
-0.02666517347097397,
0.0292418971657753,
0.005198946222662926,
0.01722727343440056,
-0.02792475000023842,
0.058052416890859604,
0.007051967550069094,
0.024813136085867882,
0.07858604192733765,
0.010925806127488613,
0.006673773750662804,
-0.018895244225859642,
0.0504201278090477,
0.07051845639944077,
0.01867850311100483,
0.02164670079946518,
0.08060815930366516,
-0.033705759793519974,
-0.03513401374220848,
0.0014495144132524729,
0.006992652080953121,
-0.03586842492222786,
-0.005276616662740707,
0.0340166911482811,
0.08264261484146118,
-0.0069140177220106125,
0.07045204937458038,
-0.03258797898888588,
0.020720599219202995,
0.013037237338721752,
0.005404287483543158,
0.02573029324412346,
0.01042308658361435,
-0.009790543466806412,
0.01810394786298275,
-0.03811025619506836,
-0.02696327678859234,
-0.0199039988219738,
-0.010715321637690067,
0.0013264201115816832,
-0.021850576624274254,
-0.03238857164978981,
0.013432193547487259,
-0.046620819717645645,
0.017488829791545868,
0.08614176511764526,
0.025144221261143684,
-0.05578812584280968,
0.003319059032946825,
0.01792003959417343,
-0.007726294919848442,
0.019684432074427605,
-0.0069745006039738655,
0.012001297436654568,
-0.0026976466178894043,
-0.045310404151678085,
0.016838474199175835,
-0.006274838000535965,
0.0007848207606002688,
0.009931255131959915,
-0.02152879536151886,
-0.032699305564165115,
-0.016245488077402115,
0.009113850072026253,
-0.0624736025929451,
-0.057956159114837646,
-0.028588229790329933,
-0.05433103069663048,
-0.047890953719615936,
-0.03589514270424843,
0.01448813732713461,
-0.009499488398432732,
-0.016994228586554527,
0.03062095306813717,
-0.029461616650223732,
0.0050201755948364735,
0.00519907521083951,
-0.10097260028123856,
-0.040014054626226425,
0.08348627388477325,
-0.021442372351884842,
-0.018019333481788635,
0.024904176592826843,
0.02799210324883461,
0.009433516301214695,
-0.02049545757472515,
0.08210444450378418,
-0.008471488021314144,
0.0370941199362278,
-0.0028064539656043053,
-0.003441168460994959,
-0.0809989869594574,
0.03274768963456154,
0.022490408271551132,
-0.02279781736433506,
-0.06171366199851036,
0.018179405480623245,
-0.012757639400660992,
0.0073422593995928764,
0.030539287254214287,
0.014691823162138462,
0.007401723880320787,
-0.041619379073381424,
0.013847699388861656,
0.0247206874191761,
0.00030858052195981145,
0.027866624295711517,
-0.03139832988381386,
0.061555828899145126,
0.018784238025546074,
-0.0021597177255898714,
-0.009453417733311653,
0.0003368169127497822,
0.004931055009365082,
-0.005909539293497801,
-0.04438937455415726,
-0.019978921860456467,
-0.04826050251722336,
-0.088194839656353,
-0.010832672007381916,
0.06092436611652374,
-0.02484559454023838,
-0.04680216684937477,
0.00007804613414919004,
0.01445467583835125,
0.00015144480857998133,
-0.01785934902727604,
0.006232357583940029,
-0.03246080502867699,
-0.016554640606045723,
-0.06696649640798569,
-0.06240033358335495,
-0.03576706349849701,
0.007667485624551773,
0.01730194129049778,
-0.047604452818632126,
-0.039737097918987274,
-0.010963990353047848,
0.003629149869084358,
0.053054749965667725,
0.03263404220342636,
0.011847180314362049,
0.005618802271783352
] |
376 |
Towards Federated RLHF with Aggregated Client Preference for LLMs
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=mqNKiEB6pd
|
[
"Feijie Wu",
"Xiaoze Liu",
"Haoyu Wang",
"Xingchen Wang",
"Lu Su",
"Jing Gao"
] |
Poster
|
Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) fine-tunes a pretrained large language model (LLM) using user preference data, enabling it to generate content aligned with human preferences. However, due to privacy concerns, users may be reluctant to share sensitive preference data. To address this, we propose utilizing Federated Learning (FL) techniques, allowing large-scale preference collection from diverse real-world users without requiring them to transmit data to a central server. Our federated RLHF methods (i.e., FedBis and FedBiscuit) encode each client’s preferences into binary selectors and aggregate them to capture common preferences. In particular, FedBiscuit overcomes key challenges, such as preference heterogeneity and reward hacking, through innovative solutions like grouping clients with similar preferences to reduce heterogeneity and using multiple binary selectors to enhance LLM output quality. To evaluate the performance of the proposed methods, we establish the first federated RLHF benchmark with a heterogeneous human preference dataset. Experimental results show that by integrating the LLM with aggregated client preferences, FedBis and FedBiscuit significantly enhance the professionalism and readability of the generated content.
|
Federated learning, RLHF, LLM
| null | 13,225 |
2407.03038
|
[
-0.005714695900678635,
-0.03892197832465172,
0.012403443455696106,
0.04822123423218727,
0.05363955721259117,
0.01477439422160387,
-0.005766973365098238,
0.009076702408492565,
-0.019229155033826828,
-0.01626920886337757,
-0.014591149054467678,
0.026817599311470985,
-0.07378754764795303,
-0.011608586646616459,
0.004927640315145254,
0.04784001410007477,
0.044062141329050064,
-0.004749537445604801,
0.03335362300276756,
0.027028921991586685,
-0.008467688225209713,
-0.00857352651655674,
0.00475512258708477,
-0.004843386821448803,
0.024439793080091476,
0.02579808421432972,
0.023928401991724968,
0.004281980451196432,
-0.02617562934756279,
0.00011691365943988785,
0.051599353551864624,
-0.018407944589853287,
0.03901166096329689,
0.008466015569865704,
-0.006044554524123669,
-0.016058407723903656,
-0.021196274086833,
0.0032025370746850967,
0.02017674408853054,
0.027143152430653572,
-0.017051374539732933,
0.03217858448624611,
0.010405896231532097,
0.014951605349779129,
-0.043833762407302856,
0.01287628710269928,
-0.11288900673389435,
0.023691341280937195,
0.027449792250990868,
-0.04828619956970215,
-0.10625112056732178,
0.005427534691989422,
0.009592813439667225,
-0.0035051859449595213,
0.030567241832613945,
0.03683764114975929,
0.04753904044628143,
-0.09094260632991791,
0.0026327609084546566,
-0.022014310583472252,
-0.03394155949354172,
0.021566657349467278,
0.0411478653550148,
0.014803478494286537,
-0.002078801626339555,
-0.006288119591772556,
0.006156423594802618,
0.03367600217461586,
-0.038253169506788254,
-0.017228158190846443,
-0.01118443999439478,
0.00604778528213501,
-0.005287411622703075,
-0.010879584588110447,
0.005077556241303682,
-0.05352456122636795,
-0.0032367308158427477,
0.03722427785396576,
0.05503922328352928,
-0.025434166193008423,
-0.030593199655413628,
0.025965673848986626,
0.00608423724770546,
0.044714029878377914,
0.003895088564604521,
-0.009217892773449421,
-0.003560687182471156,
-0.019396908581256866,
-0.08065066486597061,
0.04749423637986183,
-0.04886796325445175,
-0.04273863136768341,
0.010015723295509815,
0.014702138490974903,
0.034201495349407196,
-0.031878016889095306,
0.021099334582686424,
0.035512860864400864,
-0.008342375047504902,
0.020793039351701736,
-0.023667506873607635,
-0.009353086352348328,
0.01353110745549202,
-0.01841990277171135,
-0.10109967738389969,
0.003941764589399099,
-0.03459751978516579,
-0.03961559757590294,
-0.008388158865272999,
-0.0146689647808671,
-0.02372587099671364,
-0.003283356549218297,
0.04001575708389282,
0.0025359985884279013,
-0.07199514657258987,
0.027417384088039398,
0.01263682171702385,
0.029035767540335655,
0.006612126715481281,
0.01196952722966671,
0.048303671181201935,
0.03699013590812683,
-0.0027299351058900356,
0.06631456315517426,
-0.0038842542562633753,
0.0008756851311773062,
0.01312737725675106,
0.02905569225549698,
-0.02078344114124775,
-0.062259264290332794,
0.010399218648672104,
0.04440733417868614,
-0.0346263162791729,
0.018461300060153008,
-0.011694448068737984,
0.031970180571079254,
0.01070065051317215,
0.0061608836986124516,
0.05985884740948677,
-0.000675244489684701,
0.010170767083764076,
-0.00040334550430998206,
0.04866804555058479,
-0.04362713545560837,
0.06413081288337708,
0.025768065825104713,
0.0010260834824293852,
-0.011937231756746769,
-0.0636104941368103,
-0.0036231414414942265,
0.013173381797969341,
0.01220774743705988,
0.0033470834605395794,
-0.04606903716921806,
0.028762295842170715,
0.05669870600104332,
0.0206807442009449,
-0.041347261518239975,
-0.003211795585229993,
0.01797262206673622,
-0.023758165538311005,
0.014841617085039616,
-0.04554176703095436,
-0.026867700740695,
0.0000948996384977363,
-0.04775092378258705,
0.03720076382160187,
-0.0028804293833673,
-0.0037995344027876854,
0.00731734000146389,
-0.03553919494152069,
-0.01384050864726305,
0.02804998867213726,
-0.01974242553114891,
-0.018948912620544434,
-0.008242721669375896,
0.07391112297773361,
-0.00935081671923399,
0.03652624040842056,
0.040217962116003036,
-0.06928546726703644,
0.014514822512865067,
0.012564103119075298,
-0.0004202643467579037,
0.0006649249116890132,
-0.011160442605614662,
0.08377810567617416,
-0.020670048892498016,
0.017022375017404556,
0.039717867970466614,
-0.07097220420837402,
-0.007040427532047033,
0.037629563361406326,
-0.008597258478403091,
0.06968677043914795,
0.00643167644739151,
0.020635133609175682,
0.05580614507198334,
0.00716772535815835,
0.043446917086839676,
0.06485456973314285,
-0.018857894465327263,
0.032193467020988464,
-0.004360113758593798,
-0.031566135585308075,
-0.0002018615195993334,
0.042324360460042953,
-0.01666361466050148,
-0.05406901240348816,
-0.0035276133567094803,
-0.05241215229034424,
0.031105292961001396,
0.021587619557976723,
-0.013814830221235752,
0.037949543446302414,
-0.03006725013256073,
-0.007613220252096653,
0.036830052733421326,
0.006664097309112549,
-0.040724728256464005,
0.048379383981227875,
-0.0020410604774951935,
-0.0030389821622520685,
0.009858861565589905,
-0.06979851424694061,
0.08788211643695831,
0.06850355118513107,
-0.025647295638918877,
0.0000660792356939055,
0.03527330234646797,
0.006519610993564129,
-0.010228895582258701,
0.03141706809401512,
-0.04180809482932091,
0.022750619798898697,
-0.014718888327479362,
-0.012398326769471169,
-0.03988960012793541,
0.05071627348661423,
-0.02112923562526703,
-0.01008364837616682,
0.06452994793653488,
-0.018984515219926834,
0.04674048721790314,
-0.010836678557097912,
0.020595205947756767,
0.02299419976770878,
0.03255772590637207,
0.025308875367045403,
-0.03297194093465805,
-0.028412120416760445,
0.004063466563820839,
0.0007760882726870477,
-0.02035246230661869,
0.01780230924487114,
-0.05175357311964035,
0.01346626877784729,
0.011194305494427681,
0.041530631482601166,
0.06623458862304688,
0.0041953944601118565,
0.006724389269948006,
-0.0510166771709919,
-0.06373874098062515,
-0.004261523485183716,
-0.12621541321277618,
-0.008993858471512794,
-0.024379534646868706,
0.0238084364682436,
0.011817580088973045,
0.023487187922000885,
-0.010003753006458282,
0.009065674617886543,
-0.01824585534632206,
-0.008830232545733452,
0.03294725716114044,
0.04260804504156113,
-0.00946810469031334,
-0.03897128626704216,
-0.029931914061307907,
-0.012301895767450333,
0.05704650655388832,
-0.006112661678344011,
-0.023773014545440674,
-0.020102951675653458,
-0.04265443980693817,
0.007522678468376398,
-0.04783376678824425,
0.01127956435084343,
-0.011432052589952946,
0.0012323986738920212,
0.02625279501080513,
0.004376848693937063,
0.004583957605063915,
0.0221733245998621,
0.04366080090403557,
0.031208856031298637,
0.02327147126197815,
-0.038878653198480606,
0.03793993592262268,
-0.03430435061454773,
-0.007490953430533409,
0.0030670303385704756,
0.018873432651162148,
0.017950134351849556,
-0.03176338970661163,
0.015685269609093666,
0.010503551922738552,
-0.27416765689849854,
-0.03157959505915642,
0.02314652130007744,
0.001817252952605486,
0.04466407746076584,
0.003971788100898266,
0.05522898957133293,
-0.03678351640701294,
-0.020608030259609222,
0.006114525254815817,
0.010034933686256409,
0.03836875036358833,
0.02823055163025856,
0.05245489999651909,
0.04842011630535126,
0.060573410242795944,
-0.04324045404791832,
-0.06006607785820961,
0.017408916726708412,
0.003994431812316179,
-0.022189844399690628,
-0.07646358758211136,
-0.009469077922403812,
0.027824033051729202,
0.011212899349629879,
0.05515028536319733,
-0.045409224927425385,
0.0006209031562320888,
-0.019841359928250313,
-0.010194387286901474,
-0.011437475681304932,
-0.0172922071069479,
-0.0332779586315155,
0.02915530651807785,
0.023994382470846176,
-0.01383771188557148,
0.034436795860528946,
0.014896797016263008,
0.045854389667510986,
0.023106545209884644,
0.012376311235129833,
-0.010468129068613052,
-0.027259495109319687,
-0.004498916212469339,
0.08349516242742538,
0.00959315337240696,
-0.09665071964263916,
-0.027008257806301117,
-0.025190221145749092,
0.01875661127269268,
0.005409216042608023,
-0.03873169422149658,
-0.03284362703561783,
0.03685212880373001,
-0.00798559095710516,
-0.03392838314175606,
-0.02555801346898079,
-0.005136601626873016,
0.0007369995582848787,
0.02711647003889084,
-0.015630412846803665,
-0.04154931753873825,
-0.03425772860646248,
-0.027546318247914314,
-0.031203269958496094,
-0.06084555387496948,
-0.06472668051719666,
-0.04849735647439957,
0.05213559418916702,
0.044642262160778046,
-0.018306072801351547,
-0.006164263933897018,
-0.004391473717987537,
-0.10395223647356033,
0.006784558761864901,
-0.006226133555173874,
-0.006882855203002691,
-0.03553706407546997,
0.016391867771744728,
0.07442210614681244,
-0.031013427302241325,
-0.03740043193101883,
-0.013061530888080597,
-0.012605604715645313,
0.023081736639142036,
-0.006051512435078621,
0.04175184667110443,
-0.01068198960274458,
-0.02786257117986679,
-0.05302084982395172,
0.027887992560863495,
-0.013811232522130013,
0.017911802977323532,
0.02174563892185688,
0.05389340966939926,
0.02989816479384899,
-0.0014718333259224892,
0.054879579693078995,
0.01826414465904236,
0.022115983068943024,
0.008028808049857616,
-0.09414704144001007,
-0.02195722423493862,
-0.05829437077045441,
0.0021651035640388727,
0.03075273521244526,
-0.07179773598909378,
-0.030743174254894257,
0.03878665342926979,
0.018519464880228043,
-0.02928021177649498,
-0.016691964119672775,
-0.004314939491450787,
-0.009290752001106739,
-0.03912368789315224,
-0.025658458471298218,
-0.009446564130485058,
0.033696938306093216,
0.04166482388973236,
0.01025343406945467,
-0.030135856941342354,
0.03959554061293602,
-0.0009188888943754137,
0.013533761724829674,
-0.015187154524028301,
-0.00027761454111896455,
-0.028498947620391846,
-0.04193701595067978,
0.02420547977089882,
0.0021619212348014116,
0.022768372669816017,
0.00918625108897686,
-0.010774120688438416,
0.008154011331498623,
0.05806981027126312,
-0.013438630849123001,
-0.005199764855206013,
-0.008879473432898521,
0.02297965995967388,
-0.03143436089158058,
0.031131211668252945,
-0.020230136811733246,
0.04024425148963928,
0.015500077977776527,
0.025454914197325706,
-0.001368384575471282,
0.021299010142683983,
0.017884211614727974,
0.005895303096622229,
-0.0006398387486115098,
0.01734170690178871,
-0.04512254521250725,
-0.02387813664972782,
-0.01729479804635048,
0.013622487895190716,
-0.04058600962162018,
0.030123384669423103,
-0.0037120666820555925,
-0.005922660231590271,
-0.07472706586122513,
0.007706186268478632,
0.0037383069284260273,
-0.01802300289273262,
0.023915326222777367,
0.046343494206666946,
0.05175939202308655,
-0.03160717338323593,
0.020890912041068077,
0.02306780219078064,
0.01032103132456541,
0.008752631954848766,
-0.0362822562456131,
-0.00042797517380677164,
-0.025932645425200462,
-0.04278898611664772,
-0.002177545567974448,
0.04018421843647957,
-0.06273610889911652,
-0.031118318438529968,
0.05977603420615196,
-0.03242215886712074,
-0.019296087324619293,
0.01786411739885807,
0.010016941465437412,
0.08194568008184433,
0.02394946478307247,
0.0055036768317222595,
0.003077401779592037,
-0.006594736594706774,
0.027843456715345383,
-0.011548923328518867,
0.04472382739186287,
-0.010593860410153866,
-0.0035762879997491837,
-0.04686152935028076,
-0.048056863248348236,
0.0023215252440422773,
-0.01568492129445076,
0.01435240637511015,
-0.033508118242025375,
-0.03744546324014664,
0.009926099330186844,
-0.021654903888702393,
-0.01933063194155693,
0.006066243629902601,
-0.07333965599536896,
0.01379349548369646,
0.01916760765016079,
-0.01152119506150484,
0.03416658937931061,
-0.06564505398273468,
-0.03733372688293457,
-0.04445342719554901,
-0.01684739999473095,
0.011252161115407944,
-0.03486604616045952,
-0.035901617258787155,
-0.013679750263690948,
-0.034099213778972626,
0.005421141162514687,
0.005303255748003721,
-0.05598746985197067,
-0.02924482524394989,
-0.004534443840384483,
-0.008878940716385841,
0.03766912221908569,
-0.059344999492168427,
-0.04618307575583458,
0.0006785673904232681,
0.022513100877404213,
0.03621401637792587,
-0.041094064712524414,
0.049851689487695694,
0.033124856650829315,
-0.03390020877122879,
0.04901522770524025,
-0.051314402371644974,
0.026765597984194756,
-0.012189650908112526,
-0.023787537589669228,
0.0019022650085389614,
-0.013937104493379593,
-0.026657918468117714,
-0.03985360637307167,
-0.02023949846625328,
0.01564486138522625,
0.025844601914286613,
0.026432976126670837,
0.02272435463964939,
0.00007349124643951654,
0.0028543206863105297,
0.0001881586213130504,
-0.02064971812069416,
0.016582699492573738,
0.06345491111278534,
0.006443621590733528,
0.005611230153590441,
-0.0843580961227417,
-0.032215334475040436,
0.01100259181112051,
-0.03751817345619202,
0.0295120719820261,
-0.03731689229607582,
0.05179239436984062,
0.01700100116431713,
0.0319041945040226,
0.026274889707565308,
-0.03954816982150078,
0.035752635449171066,
-0.05316132679581642,
-0.006709448527544737,
-0.045121368020772934,
-0.014220661483705044,
0.036957066506147385,
-0.035201627761125565,
0.013019663281738758,
0.020405078306794167,
-0.05613807961344719,
0.05101529508829117,
-0.004168893210589886,
-0.06952951103448868,
0.013608553446829319,
-0.02946910262107849,
-0.00514142494648695,
0.0676778182387352,
-0.04915245622396469,
-0.04269176721572876,
-0.03519018739461899,
-0.030367136001586914,
-0.008589651435613632,
0.023680225014686584,
0.02937679924070835,
-0.01263662800192833,
0.030330386012792587,
-0.03642131760716438,
0.004545747302472591,
-0.0018181857885792851,
0.040585748851299286,
-0.012335126288235188,
0.041906487196683884,
-0.03607034683227539,
0.05489572510123253,
0.02832627296447754,
0.004355643410235643,
0.02274131216108799,
-0.0031161331571638584,
-0.020357921719551086,
-0.023195696994662285,
0.06867429614067078,
0.012823767028748989,
-0.011527548544108868,
-0.05710691586136818,
0.06239449605345726,
0.012584499083459377,
-0.026655998080968857,
-0.016893036663532257,
0.04951654374599457,
-0.05236640200018883,
-0.0020367668475955725,
0.01872752420604229,
0.015449702739715576,
-0.007684454321861267,
0.08268912881612778,
0.02499757520854473,
0.04926611855626106,
0.08309917151927948,
0.02513630874454975,
-0.006620723754167557,
0.057464927434921265,
0.0700344666838646,
0.05705742910504341,
0.042782675474882126,
-0.0014289745595306158,
0.0891433134675026,
-0.0539269782602787,
-0.07632727921009064,
-0.007601557299494743,
0.04697179049253464,
-0.03527701646089554,
-0.02313006855547428,
0.010296770371496677,
0.052457544952631,
-0.01787514053285122,
0.04313810542225838,
-0.046945974230766296,
0.003397259395569563,
0.0550537034869194,
0.03493687883019447,
0.011635026894509792,
0.041748132556676865,
-0.001154359895735979,
0.017451724037528038,
-0.04094129428267479,
-0.00722739240154624,
0.018071670085191727,
-0.013149598613381386,
0.02239811234176159,
0.01105148158967495,
-0.007791962008923292,
0.03698574751615524,
0.0063207256607711315,
0.02969883754849434,
0.08487488329410553,
-0.05201972275972366,
-0.029360774904489517,
0.025278836488723755,
0.000585984147619456,
0.021933814510703087,
0.009175249375402927,
0.003903492819517851,
-0.025102021172642708,
0.008484749123454094,
-0.028004059568047523,
-0.013544147834181786,
0.03422018513083458,
0.02311946451663971,
0.034863878041505814,
-0.05215354636311531,
0.005400888156145811,
0.037863556295633316,
0.01627899706363678,
-0.0857110321521759,
-0.03503667190670967,
-0.02551736868917942,
-0.06176029518246651,
-0.03827761486172676,
-0.06307706236839294,
-0.00040507171070203185,
0.020883504301309586,
-0.04167133942246437,
0.038690462708473206,
-0.030909638851881027,
0.010812776163220406,
-0.007087687496095896,
-0.07766620069742203,
-0.010617444291710854,
0.037691861391067505,
-0.016696760430932045,
0.04123889282345772,
0.02129274792969227,
0.02658670023083687,
-0.0234869085252285,
-0.025841040536761284,
0.00959453172981739,
-0.013717737048864365,
0.0071816956624388695,
-0.018737562000751495,
-0.028167573735117912,
-0.10664267838001251,
0.018582412973046303,
0.01107990462332964,
-0.015479057095944881,
-0.072930246591568,
0.02770799770951271,
-0.014856952242553234,
0.03638221323490143,
0.08973154425621033,
0.03316856920719147,
-0.004412329755723476,
-0.031088486313819885,
-0.04659847915172577,
0.006480066105723381,
0.047449853271245956,
0.05952967330813408,
-0.00996505469083786,
0.05940701439976692,
0.03854776918888092,
-0.0484599806368351,
-0.059784092009067535,
0.02587776444852352,
0.0036300483625382185,
-0.05037863925099373,
-0.0080509502440691,
-0.048110757023096085,
-0.022003114223480225,
-0.08117538690567017,
0.004108910448849201,
0.029068080708384514,
-0.013023830950260162,
-0.01827254891395569,
-0.007512786891311407,
0.011745613999664783,
-0.011907116509974003,
-0.011661851778626442,
-0.016560658812522888,
-0.01871711015701294,
-0.018756741657853127,
-0.0432579331099987,
-0.07556623965501785,
0.016680721193552017,
-0.0031227213330566883,
0.0018985859351232648,
0.0029141244012862444,
-0.06448830664157867,
0.005897659808397293,
0.02267352119088173,
0.026384377852082253,
0.026905499398708344,
0.0017429396975785494,
-0.016490023583173752
] |
377 |
Overcoming Slow Decision Frequencies in Continuous Control: Model-Based Sequence Reinforcement Learning for Model-Free Control
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=w3iM4WLuvy
|
[
"Devdhar Patel",
"Hava T Siegelmann"
] |
Poster
|
Reinforcement learning (RL) is rapidly reaching and surpassing human-level control capabilities. However, state-of-the-art RL algorithms often require timesteps and reaction times significantly faster than human capabilities, which is impractical in real-world settings and typically necessitates specialized hardware. We introduce Sequence Reinforcement Learning (SRL), an RL algorithm designed to produce a sequence of actions for a given input state, enabling effective control at lower decision frequencies. SRL addresses the challenges of learning action sequences by employing both a model and an actor-critic architecture operating at different temporal scales. We propose a "temporal recall" mechanism, where the critic uses the model to estimate intermediate states between primitive actions, providing a learning signal for each individual action within the sequence. Once training is complete, the actor can generate action sequences independently of the model, achieving model-free control at a slower frequency. We evaluate SRL on a suite of continuous control tasks, demonstrating that it achieves performance comparable to state-of-the-art algorithms while significantly reducing actor sample complexity. To better assess performance across varying decision frequencies, we introduce the Frequency-Averaged Score (FAS) metric. Our results show that SRL significantly outperforms traditional RL algorithms in terms of FAS, making it particularly suitable for applications requiring variable decision frequencies. Furthermore, we compare SRL with model-based online planning, showing that SRL achieves comparable FAS while leveraging the same model during training that online planners use for planning.
|
Decision Frequency, Action Sequence Generation, Model-Based Training, Model-Free Control, Efficient Learning, Reinforcement Learning
|
We introduce an algorithm that achieves competitive continuous control at extremely slow control frequencies using action sequences
| 13,222 |
2410.08979
|
[
-0.01868542470037937,
-0.012588189914822578,
-0.019861850887537003,
0.022632945328950882,
0.04794275015592575,
-0.007036742754280567,
0.007875427603721619,
0.01631801202893257,
-0.03249713405966759,
-0.0349227711558342,
-0.014963868074119091,
0.03653169050812721,
-0.06646762043237686,
-0.006521293893456459,
0.02225024811923504,
0.06027200073003769,
0.02795015461742878,
-0.02320893295109272,
-0.009177652187645435,
0.0017731254920363426,
-0.02548804134130478,
0.013394506648182869,
0.04233713075518608,
0.02966151386499405,
0.03671202436089516,
0.028643473982810974,
0.027748413383960724,
0.012936834245920181,
-0.0015281656524166465,
-0.014203548431396484,
0.019475260749459267,
-0.03866534307599068,
-0.0005442429101094604,
-0.05183582380414009,
0.01103221159428358,
0.0022185277193784714,
-0.02406562864780426,
0.004141902085393667,
-0.012346344999969006,
-0.021116282790899277,
-0.0236352551728487,
-0.005729991011321545,
-0.01023185160011053,
-0.017265498638153076,
-0.014985039830207825,
0.028847794979810715,
-0.07661204040050507,
0.008907982148230076,
0.0479029081761837,
-0.05455416440963745,
-0.09050483256578445,
0.04304782673716545,
0.03667839244008064,
-0.04778074845671654,
0.013218377716839314,
0.029371721670031548,
0.01827443204820156,
-0.0733446478843689,
-0.014868946745991707,
-0.0831725150346756,
0.01860416866838932,
0.003918426111340523,
0.03724682331085205,
0.0018289081053808331,
0.00234945653937757,
0.00897299312055111,
0.029766280204057693,
0.050392743200063705,
-0.0008941565174609423,
0.0008402816019952297,
-0.052557166665792465,
-0.004708062391728163,
-0.0020544668659567833,
0.018061581999063492,
-0.01472505647689104,
-0.046523887664079666,
0.013727525249123573,
0.024405820295214653,
0.06503549963235855,
0.03213076293468475,
0.032707978039979935,
0.03675539791584015,
0.008644601330161095,
0.02861715666949749,
0.02719462849199772,
0.04063370078802109,
-0.01645977608859539,
-0.029642300680279732,
-0.07408396154642105,
0.03488825261592865,
-0.04350610077381134,
-0.05941416323184967,
0.009035486727952957,
0.04892377927899361,
0.009670867584645748,
-0.00815203133970499,
0.015478924848139286,
0.03522002696990967,
0.00401637377217412,
0.007497353479266167,
-0.02780596725642681,
-0.027578303590416908,
0.0157928466796875,
-0.01049042772501707,
-0.09927688539028168,
-0.028088724240660667,
-0.00915116909891367,
0.006559443194419146,
-0.005577663891017437,
0.05660263076424599,
-0.07047855854034424,
-0.003963585942983627,
0.029410578310489655,
-0.034861572086811066,
-0.08086011558771133,
0.03140118718147278,
-0.02013998292386532,
0.04395487904548645,
-0.002443341538310051,
0.0037966312374919653,
0.042327385395765305,
0.005011167377233505,
-0.00123406492639333,
0.057777997106313705,
-0.0319373793900013,
-0.003738969098776579,
0.025530092418193817,
0.021165570244193077,
-0.025620611384510994,
-0.07890930771827698,
0.04892522841691971,
0.0243237242102623,
-0.028274819254875183,
-0.007298704236745834,
-0.0183392483741045,
0.02806604467332363,
0.024004865437746048,
0.011862999759614468,
0.018690628930926323,
0.014680870808660984,
-0.0024776123464107513,
-0.023320497944951057,
0.08887061476707458,
-0.039726853370666504,
0.06592617183923721,
0.004097118508070707,
-0.020460505038499832,
-0.02242055907845497,
-0.049238137900829315,
-0.01421553734689951,
0.0032278657890856266,
-0.009040514007210732,
-0.0244070366024971,
-0.07340382784605026,
0.021632546558976173,
0.03616141900420189,
0.026170168071985245,
0.00990842841565609,
0.00020195814431644976,
0.01758665218949318,
0.00106185267213732,
-0.007123169023543596,
-0.04041234776377678,
-0.0017282497137784958,
0.021502802148461342,
-0.08725117892026901,
0.04425088316202164,
0.035072941333055496,
-0.02538551576435566,
-0.0443650521337986,
-0.038593389093875885,
-0.01131284236907959,
0.003963508643209934,
-0.0033632926642894745,
-0.02372453361749649,
0.01863527111709118,
0.03475726768374443,
-0.01883089914917946,
0.049740154296159744,
-0.012386709451675415,
-0.07734443992376328,
0.009424078278243542,
0.0020564538426697254,
-0.005414881277829409,
-0.016253357753157616,
-0.06460391730070114,
0.07247057557106018,
-0.023470645770430565,
-0.0015914862742647529,
0.012645980343222618,
-0.06297106295824051,
-0.00796443223953247,
0.02252640388906002,
-0.018400438129901886,
0.06124383211135864,
0.008107221685349941,
-0.022881438955664635,
0.028443649411201477,
0.02912394143640995,
0.07719157636165619,
0.03788430616259575,
-0.01813550665974617,
0.03144165873527527,
-0.01836661621928215,
-0.01640377938747406,
-0.018505845218896866,
0.01664355769753456,
-0.05051657184958458,
-0.028573065996170044,
-0.002388373017311096,
-0.031324684619903564,
0.0188017375767231,
0.023965977132320404,
-0.011580248363316059,
0.03302605077624321,
0.0013138789217919111,
-0.01049256045371294,
0.012450247071683407,
0.01877620816230774,
-0.06838030368089676,
0.003383232746273279,
-0.00023012954625301063,
-0.03778007626533508,
0.0028473620768636465,
-0.06429434567689896,
0.08714822679758072,
0.05273164063692093,
-0.04715043306350708,
-0.02556251548230648,
0.04097708687186241,
-0.02046557143330574,
0.02431538514792919,
-0.011948999017477036,
-0.042906906455755234,
0.03575877100229263,
-0.001734066754579544,
0.0036245593801140785,
-0.03740149736404419,
0.01693836599588394,
-0.013339375145733356,
-0.001008266001008451,
0.08146650344133377,
-0.0305878184735775,
0.06228313222527504,
-0.0038960969541221857,
0.010097464546561241,
0.026382388547062874,
0.03169481083750725,
-0.020245172083377838,
-0.0191048476845026,
-0.05045581981539726,
0.0023246770724654198,
0.05190105363726616,
-0.004409230314195156,
-0.019110647961497307,
-0.04568395018577576,
-0.025352127850055695,
-0.026027875021100044,
0.05381518229842186,
0.04231353849172592,
0.041934069246053696,
0.044392187148332596,
-0.0007373616681434214,
-0.0035793865099549294,
-0.04371773079037666,
-0.10061102360486984,
-0.03554866462945938,
0.011336500756442547,
0.009049168787896633,
0.045752767473459244,
0.012745976448059082,
-0.0011818988714367151,
0.06484334170818329,
-0.01754879578948021,
-0.04946039617061615,
0.01893589086830616,
0.01395143661648035,
0.03286205604672432,
-0.021129384636878967,
-0.003688853932544589,
0.02173682674765587,
0.07473065704107285,
0.0018554923590272665,
-0.013524075038731098,
-0.02152787521481514,
-0.019353071227669716,
0.01665804162621498,
-0.02948516234755516,
-0.009620281867682934,
0.01460998971015215,
-0.010549597442150116,
0.019534865394234657,
-0.03916947916150093,
0.02643468603491783,
0.020195437595248222,
0.0657241940498352,
0.045413389801979065,
0.035292886197566986,
0.030938483774662018,
0.011464985087513924,
-0.01688075065612793,
-0.016338679939508438,
-0.028439205139875412,
0.025527074933052063,
-0.012228384613990784,
-0.015928002074360847,
0.010293473489582539,
0.014839761890470982,
-0.26318585872650146,
-0.036759261041879654,
0.00009417619730811566,
0.0026188071351498365,
0.020804481580853462,
0.015893302857875824,
0.04699047654867172,
-0.04944644868373871,
-0.0028160810470581055,
0.03714834526181221,
0.0443262904882431,
0.038865696638822556,
0.02254151552915573,
0.0673825666308403,
0.05355110764503479,
0.031205659732222557,
0.008960305713117123,
-0.015086960047483444,
-0.014367401599884033,
0.053787000477313995,
-0.023616580292582512,
-0.09436886012554169,
-0.031222645193338394,
0.017216810956597328,
-0.005054621025919914,
0.05275726318359375,
-0.08924268186092377,
-0.0128633426502347,
-0.04031705856323242,
-0.009852112270891666,
-0.02172865904867649,
-0.023017186671495438,
-0.030741406604647636,
0.014943469315767288,
0.015479943715035915,
0.00585253955796361,
0.029864532873034477,
0.013951679691672325,
0.03995640575885773,
0.006863471120595932,
-0.02774820849299431,
-0.015213949605822563,
-0.024814018979668617,
0.041096281260252,
0.05138057842850685,
0.03010828234255314,
-0.05807746946811676,
0.010319714434444904,
0.009291981346905231,
0.04447796195745468,
-0.004050318617373705,
-0.018019016832113266,
0.02482774667441845,
-0.008564453572034836,
0.024278724566102028,
-0.028820913285017014,
0.015802739188075066,
-0.022145790979266167,
0.0015347821172326803,
0.02305160090327263,
-0.011890565045177937,
-0.03241012245416641,
-0.032249633222818375,
-0.012116905301809311,
-0.008548961021006107,
-0.03610574081540108,
-0.03738972917199135,
-0.04766181483864784,
0.00874460767954588,
0.035208627581596375,
-0.008421539328992367,
-0.004547460004687309,
-0.032295845448970795,
-0.10756225883960724,
0.020327813923358917,
-0.0005814352189190686,
0.0024736220948398113,
-0.05178707465529442,
0.013037342578172684,
0.049797091633081436,
-0.025677086785435677,
-0.06381956487894058,
-0.02883737161755562,
0.004564660135656595,
0.05081488564610481,
0.011938787065446377,
0.05378538742661476,
-0.046066008508205414,
-0.007927232421934605,
-0.049577947705984116,
0.03219834715127945,
0.00894822459667921,
0.02695927396416664,
-0.023982137441635132,
0.058316558599472046,
0.029425714164972305,
0.005129602737724781,
0.03520747646689415,
0.03471976891160011,
-0.02848047763109207,
0.03215552493929863,
-0.08957937359809875,
0.0120152048766613,
-0.057187359780073166,
-0.011673537082970142,
0.015314284712076187,
-0.05577447637915611,
-0.03929297253489494,
0.028862658888101578,
0.044205352663993835,
-0.011032138019800186,
-0.024924064055085182,
0.024905066937208176,
-0.006007342599332333,
-0.016145600005984306,
-0.021614719182252884,
-0.015775011852383614,
0.024174170568585396,
0.007077840622514486,
-0.015983933582901955,
-0.07080906629562378,
0.06009817123413086,
-0.05104455351829529,
0.024597445502877235,
0.005704762414097786,
-0.01595197431743145,
0.012808750383555889,
-0.005520319100469351,
-0.007307460065931082,
-0.021323829889297485,
0.03860687091946602,
0.06827857345342636,
-0.01609712466597557,
0.036078326404094696,
0.037175752222537994,
-0.0010210579494014382,
-0.02204003930091858,
0.004049248527735472,
0.031568221747875214,
-0.01707155629992485,
-0.0033067266922444105,
-0.003653460182249546,
0.032463397830724716,
0.03665526211261749,
0.013706314377486706,
0.01909603551030159,
0.02513187564909458,
0.006506204605102539,
0.028035232797265053,
0.013601123355329037,
0.07243894785642624,
-0.05519513040781021,
0.0025961631909012794,
-0.0325109027326107,
0.021334204822778702,
-0.04970560222864151,
0.025920722633600235,
-0.027448054403066635,
0.023448403924703598,
-0.0578363798558712,
0.024222757667303085,
0.003957556094974279,
-0.03755369782447815,
-0.006242656614631414,
0.012814663350582123,
0.05844249203801155,
-0.030768724158406258,
-0.007207647897303104,
0.031013043597340584,
0.0008984722080640495,
0.0019609699957072735,
-0.054627321660518646,
-0.006496618036180735,
-0.009714126586914062,
-0.030017804354429245,
-0.01822817511856556,
0.0024425105657428503,
-0.05767984315752983,
-0.03316906839609146,
0.028835032135248184,
0.008546515367925167,
-0.02830374613404274,
-0.004452155437320471,
0.014694834128022194,
0.04959605261683464,
-0.018440235406160355,
0.001157351303845644,
-0.013375962153077126,
-0.028367426246404648,
-0.001568160834722221,
0.011820938438177109,
0.03306150808930397,
-0.005754786543548107,
-0.0453464575111866,
-0.03560097888112068,
-0.01760854758322239,
0.01969015598297119,
0.015331931412220001,
-0.01873103715479374,
-0.0018582117045298219,
-0.009610816836357117,
-0.023009685799479485,
-0.027265889570116997,
-0.023615704849362373,
0.0331965833902359,
-0.05178017541766167,
-0.014481530524790287,
0.043982360512018204,
0.010599748231470585,
0.03450325131416321,
-0.06703300774097443,
-0.049141496419906616,
-0.02822590433061123,
-0.030058322474360466,
-0.02057734876871109,
-0.015822218731045723,
-0.015940189361572266,
-0.018851907923817635,
-0.015108998864889145,
0.0019261284032836556,
0.029289398342370987,
-0.004329964518547058,
-0.011916421353816986,
-0.027872171252965927,
-0.010014756582677364,
0.05232572928071022,
-0.03610711172223091,
-0.03412028029561043,
0.04909566044807434,
0.009544670581817627,
0.02271178923547268,
-0.041594672948122025,
0.0101915393024683,
0.03124699369072914,
-0.003430923679843545,
0.014107516966760159,
-0.04355860501527786,
0.06295579671859741,
0.015986580401659012,
-0.03940698504447937,
-0.01753208227455616,
0.03103974089026451,
-0.04690144211053848,
0.006137102376669645,
0.0006372950738295913,
0.00695555517449975,
0.035178717225790024,
-0.0019829715602099895,
0.020002389326691628,
0.03459566831588745,
0.01318786758929491,
0.004888608586043119,
-0.03206542506814003,
0.013343111611902714,
0.05391474440693855,
-0.044277988374233246,
0.0024149951059371233,
-0.07397906482219696,
-0.009051302447915077,
0.044286347925662994,
-0.03409918025135994,
0.00821459200233221,
-0.03693240508437157,
0.027948565781116486,
0.023807989433407784,
0.041849974542856216,
0.03438302129507065,
-0.01568618230521679,
0.029831113293766975,
-0.038088712841272354,
0.029309572651982307,
-0.07123497873544693,
0.0024350504390895367,
0.08717118203639984,
-0.05015446990728378,
0.023858845233917236,
0.015744082629680634,
-0.017044486477971077,
0.06147245317697525,
-0.02158305235207081,
-0.058705396950244904,
0.01951807178556919,
-0.013921757228672504,
-0.03966322913765907,
0.053284648805856705,
-0.06640144437551498,
-0.04404821619391441,
-0.004506728146225214,
-0.05125361680984497,
0.021438229829072952,
0.009865254163742065,
0.024514416232705116,
-0.01667063683271408,
-0.00346497748978436,
-0.04886258393526077,
0.034312330186367035,
0.020794590935111046,
0.02912377007305622,
0.00044168095337226987,
0.038669660687446594,
-0.051324427127838135,
0.08632887154817581,
0.03459019958972931,
0.0455033965408802,
-0.023056689649820328,
-0.005753007717430592,
0.009071748703718185,
-0.017268894240260124,
0.04788316413760185,
-0.005628612823784351,
-0.01563052274286747,
-0.05659809336066246,
0.0355147086083889,
0.02856101281940937,
-0.04158596694469452,
0.007777688559144735,
0.014754042960703373,
-0.06561177968978882,
-0.016841396689414978,
0.021189959719777107,
0.016139212995767593,
-0.0018068397184833884,
0.06927800178527832,
0.038985975086688995,
0.05363783985376358,
0.07667925953865051,
0.02964956872165203,
-0.01863122172653675,
0.0007904111407697201,
0.051846764981746674,
0.07164379209280014,
0.04100407660007477,
-0.03673454374074936,
0.07549916207790375,
-0.035644784569740295,
-0.0388043038547039,
0.06444140523672104,
0.01798364333808422,
-0.017307160422205925,
-0.06486467272043228,
0.029929982498288155,
0.039427801966667175,
0.011289441026747227,
0.05888023599982262,
-0.047826167196035385,
-0.01813616417348385,
0.08347433060407639,
0.0012462366139516234,
-0.025598526000976562,
0.019198110327124596,
0.030983757227659225,
0.020925398916006088,
-0.01101602241396904,
-0.0036389799788594246,
0.0036952004302293062,
-0.0004471409774851054,
0.021279653534293175,
-0.00845422875136137,
-0.021013334393501282,
0.022621212527155876,
0.004348465707153082,
0.03561217710375786,
0.11614423990249634,
-0.03601252660155296,
0.0023816577158868313,
0.007340824231505394,
-0.025570975616574287,
-0.010557251051068306,
0.015193386003375053,
0.017626380547881126,
-0.0207704845815897,
0.033819615840911865,
-0.030148399993777275,
-0.002979645738378167,
0.05740439519286156,
0.004165017046034336,
0.007056788541376591,
-0.05083960294723511,
-0.009057434275746346,
0.017301369458436966,
-0.005369554739445448,
-0.023981327190995216,
-0.04797913879156113,
-0.04543348029255867,
-0.04661395400762558,
-0.04738254100084305,
-0.04207979515194893,
0.0402320958673954,
-0.016436906531453133,
-0.03819112479686737,
-0.00866504292935133,
-0.006036684848368168,
0.015375327318906784,
-0.010892404243350029,
-0.05524643510580063,
-0.01728917472064495,
0.032164860516786575,
0.00807907897979021,
0.026478834450244904,
0.02994753234088421,
0.05494079738855362,
0.00883160624653101,
-0.013847620226442814,
-0.01955128088593483,
0.020858624950051308,
-0.008150790818035603,
-0.004387732595205307,
-0.02002127282321453,
-0.0722731277346611,
0.008020334877073765,
0.020642006769776344,
-0.023925306275486946,
-0.06703504920005798,
0.0043736114166677,
-0.05423763766884804,
0.021626560017466545,
0.08432408422231674,
-0.00826950278133154,
0.022419018670916557,
-0.06987463682889938,
0.011515972204506397,
0.012324630282819271,
0.019797034561634064,
0.042217254638671875,
-0.05534067004919052,
0.024652330204844475,
0.05157005786895752,
-0.03287435322999954,
-0.04995131865143776,
0.06274279206991196,
0.010085823945701122,
-0.01379453670233488,
0.017260177060961723,
-0.0667465552687645,
-0.040710993111133575,
-0.10351195931434631,
0.002760289004072547,
0.04629584401845932,
0.036811791360378265,
-0.0332564041018486,
0.01228009257465601,
-0.009978493675589561,
-0.010849636048078537,
-0.01814676634967327,
-0.03832489252090454,
-0.033563777804374695,
-0.03859489783644676,
-0.052374910563230515,
-0.030210210010409355,
0.038041505962610245,
-0.03580572083592415,
0.013655266724526882,
-0.0161697119474411,
-0.03794446960091591,
-0.006938039790838957,
0.0063781109638512135,
0.024557320401072502,
0.010077724233269691,
0.010982701554894447,
-0.039030659943819046
] |
378 |
Physics of Language Models: Part 3.2, Knowledge Manipulation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=oDbiL9CLoS
|
[
"Zeyuan Allen-Zhu",
"Yuanzhi Li"
] |
Poster
|
Language models can store vast factual knowledge, yet their ability to flexibly use this knowledge for downstream tasks (e.g., via instruction finetuning) remains questionable. This paper investigates four fundamental knowledge manipulation tasks: \textbf{retrieval} (e.g., "What is person A's attribute X?"), \textbf{classification} (e.g., "Is A's attribute X even or odd?"), \textbf{comparison} (e.g., "Is A greater than B in attribute X?"), and \textbf{inverse search} (e.g., "Which person's attribute X equals T?").
We show that language models excel in knowledge retrieval but struggle even in the simplest classification or comparison tasks unless Chain of Thoughts (CoTs) are employed during both training and inference. Moreover, their performance in inverse knowledge search is virtually 0\%, regardless of the prompts.
Our primary contribution is a \emph{controlled, synthetic experiment} that confirms these weaknesses are \emph{inherent} to language models: they cannot efficiently manipulate knowledge from pre-training data, even when such knowledge is perfectly stored in the models, despite adequate training and sufficient model size. Our findings also apply to modern pretrained language models such as GPT-4, thus giving rise to many Turing tests to distinguish Humans from contemporary AIs.
|
knowledge manipulation, language models, generative models, reversal curse
| null | 13,219 |
2309.14402
|
[
-0.03610936179757118,
0.018066320568323135,
-0.027337154373526573,
0.041403185576200485,
0.056325312703847885,
-0.010677661746740341,
0.054491136223077774,
0.019725440070033073,
-0.009502249769866467,
0.0018758823862299323,
-0.033383920788764954,
0.07299167662858963,
-0.047035396099090576,
-0.0018944184994325042,
-0.004561843350529671,
0.05153513699769974,
0.022982249036431313,
-0.005190602503716946,
0.026482010260224342,
0.015525873750448227,
-0.017277495935559273,
-0.006066829897463322,
0.02550218254327774,
0.013177599757909775,
0.0326848030090332,
0.00587829016149044,
-0.014426765032112598,
-0.012965700589120388,
-0.015077783726155758,
0.003945889882743359,
-0.009129359386861324,
0.002512604696676135,
0.002252045553177595,
-0.031133947893977165,
-0.017706776037812233,
-0.025972047820687294,
-0.06017719581723213,
0.03266816586256027,
0.014773155562579632,
0.017937907949090004,
-0.05725373327732086,
0.0400811992585659,
-0.005980808287858963,
-0.007205277215689421,
-0.07722429186105728,
0.004857179243117571,
-0.09582580626010895,
0.03505736589431763,
0.02492445334792137,
-0.014657284133136272,
-0.11616016924381256,
0.014311961829662323,
0.021887900307774544,
-0.024289069697260857,
0.002050381153821945,
0.05105087161064148,
0.022194260731339455,
-0.08512028306722641,
0.013296927325427532,
-0.03422686830163002,
0.003139327047392726,
0.01218153815716505,
0.003081641159951687,
-0.013373106718063354,
-0.010456951335072517,
-0.0542144812643528,
-0.002638439182192087,
0.01336027029901743,
-0.05675521120429039,
-0.024510780349373817,
-0.027088185772299767,
-0.00022835296113044024,
-0.006244510877877474,
0.007201429456472397,
0.008960378356277943,
-0.03840799257159233,
0.010540775954723358,
0.034389372915029526,
0.06207124888896942,
-0.008713603019714355,
-0.00445967260748148,
0.04167070612311363,
0.03430149331688881,
0.022417357191443443,
0.02006661519408226,
-0.001005257829092443,
-0.022164156660437584,
-0.020465731620788574,
-0.06481318175792694,
0.047562651336193085,
-0.015470858663320541,
-0.06394645571708679,
0.005039620213210583,
0.026959020644426346,
0.0009756963117979467,
0.042193345725536346,
0.02842775732278824,
0.005842698737978935,
-0.018822602927684784,
-0.007003952749073505,
-0.021895481273531914,
-0.04062383249402046,
0.017739906907081604,
0.01637839339673519,
-0.10364186018705368,
-0.002988545224070549,
-0.013078800402581692,
-0.000318935519317165,
0.031236952170729637,
0.006800894159823656,
-0.0557171069085598,
-0.01523799542337656,
-0.02691612020134926,
-0.004367573652416468,
-0.10494702309370041,
0.017145030200481415,
-0.004212147556245327,
0.026202324777841568,
0.000954624789301306,
0.039650753140449524,
0.03794403746724129,
0.01526118814945221,
0.017016027122735977,
0.047457195818424225,
0.011474056169390678,
0.008067751303315163,
-0.009109493345022202,
0.026789480820298195,
-0.03743409737944603,
-0.04911934584379196,
0.02459586225450039,
0.0392644926905632,
0.004251392558217049,
0.008445337414741516,
-0.013803192414343357,
0.009491046890616417,
0.003375742118805647,
0.017755160108208656,
-0.007074582390487194,
0.0358203686773777,
0.0022792865056544542,
-0.012341374531388283,
0.043927524238824844,
-0.004960819613188505,
0.06044500321149826,
-0.01854139193892479,
-0.03129475563764572,
0.008294195868074894,
0.0009896340779960155,
0.0018957931315526366,
-0.000620270031504333,
0.010797183960676193,
0.015438234433531761,
-0.07699643820524216,
0.039870161563158035,
0.07596886157989502,
0.012945486232638359,
-0.0006751790060661733,
0.03091415949165821,
-0.007683554198592901,
0.005997948348522186,
0.004943274427205324,
-0.01784447766840458,
-0.002189107472077012,
0.028527691960334778,
-0.04426932334899902,
-0.0022033860441297293,
0.029147738590836525,
-0.03362974897027016,
0.02800208143889904,
-0.020630888640880585,
-0.009252195246517658,
0.05675210431218147,
-0.03403005003929138,
-0.03663601726293564,
0.019860463216900826,
0.05109642818570137,
0.00015651856665499508,
0.05394582450389862,
-0.0008160812431015074,
-0.06533563137054443,
0.03539010509848595,
-0.00822722539305687,
0.012507469393312931,
0.0033663806971162558,
-0.026306234300136566,
0.07298789918422699,
-0.032357893884181976,
0.032040853053331375,
0.01440279558300972,
-0.0797036811709404,
-0.02947136200964451,
0.04089725390076637,
0.004045798443257809,
0.09074395895004272,
-0.0060797566547989845,
0.008825358003377914,
0.06228010356426239,
0.0293450765311718,
0.04602837562561035,
0.048357196152210236,
-0.008385157212615013,
0.04590931907296181,
-0.006932329852133989,
-0.020353272557258606,
0.02545282430946827,
0.02347196638584137,
-0.07518860697746277,
-0.04132506251335144,
0.05609511584043503,
-0.024841945618391037,
-0.018861252814531326,
-0.005907020531594753,
-0.01248483918607235,
-0.029427913948893547,
0.01708870381116867,
-0.01773872971534729,
-0.005868976470082998,
0.0480399951338768,
-0.045932356268167496,
0.024485129863023758,
0.02353556454181671,
0.028087563812732697,
-0.013736655004322529,
-0.03338656574487686,
0.08418086916208267,
0.058930013328790665,
-0.015266972593963146,
0.006782155949622393,
0.027736056596040726,
0.028756383806467056,
-0.01985883340239525,
0.04255560040473938,
0.003254551440477371,
0.0154335992410779,
-0.004259361419826746,
-0.029010090976953506,
-0.01119974348694086,
0.061680156737565994,
-0.03233727812767029,
-0.031868111342191696,
0.08629957586526871,
-0.06482511013746262,
0.07324125617742538,
-0.0047890376299619675,
0.013127065263688564,
0.05220372602343559,
-0.012627300806343555,
-0.021903470158576965,
-0.023301128298044205,
-0.021313542500138283,
-0.006345653906464577,
0.008525349199771881,
-0.009442898444831371,
-0.008825044147670269,
-0.0500229075551033,
-0.0024040064308792353,
-0.026579808443784714,
0.06599682569503784,
0.03989754617214203,
-0.004446734208613634,
0.03443222492933273,
0.002775582717731595,
-0.015652120113372803,
0.00022613895998802036,
-0.07323094457387924,
-0.004629615694284439,
-0.03985220938920975,
0.031122665852308273,
0.0028525132220238447,
0.05502955615520477,
-0.020268766209483147,
0.041238974779844284,
-0.016051912680268288,
-0.01911408081650734,
-0.002919187769293785,
0.02741130255162716,
-0.013613502494990826,
-0.052885450422763824,
0.005978703964501619,
-0.029637690633535385,
0.05421622842550278,
-0.018914492800831795,
-0.05077048018574715,
-0.030304159969091415,
-0.03957149758934975,
-0.010532514192163944,
-0.05783657729625702,
-0.03467249497771263,
0.0429290235042572,
0.0004048135888297111,
0.0033946516923606396,
-0.02476474456489086,
-0.015067007392644882,
0.05297563970088959,
0.046554747968912125,
0.029521066695451736,
-0.004389935173094273,
-0.00671255961060524,
0.050967149436473846,
-0.031106632202863693,
0.04673900082707405,
-0.004440067335963249,
0.04485325142741203,
0.0035411296412348747,
-0.014182795770466328,
0.025341404601931572,
0.017982229590415955,
-0.2942521274089813,
0.015782715752720833,
-0.0025522983632981777,
-0.0425226129591465,
0.020307831466197968,
0.0034370834473520517,
0.0416671559214592,
-0.038056518882513046,
-0.026295777410268784,
0.012141251936554909,
0.027233386412262917,
0.019339444115757942,
-0.012710769660770893,
0.06664200872182846,
0.04225747287273407,
0.022848747670650482,
0.00924481451511383,
-0.045217692852020264,
-0.009616013616323471,
0.04934270307421684,
-0.008666356094181538,
-0.031769875437021255,
-0.03312588855624199,
0.057844240218400955,
0.020244328305125237,
0.05344570055603981,
-0.08952488005161285,
-0.013949144631624222,
-0.047971438616514206,
0.03049592301249504,
-0.0018456861143931746,
-0.004221789073199034,
-0.0046896482817828655,
0.05400482565164566,
0.00966620072722435,
-0.001125082839280367,
0.03821524977684021,
0.010598482564091682,
0.022409388795495033,
0.023180998861789703,
-0.018454143777489662,
-0.03369395434856415,
-0.010641886852681637,
0.02377314306795597,
0.06678417325019836,
-0.004008662421256304,
-0.05882706865668297,
-0.039678387343883514,
-0.00004734186950372532,
0.04448161646723747,
-0.04010065272450447,
-0.0481586754322052,
-0.02616102062165737,
0.028809284791350365,
0.01675051636993885,
-0.014807535335421562,
0.03463083133101463,
-0.030766872689127922,
-0.029181841760873795,
-0.020221790298819542,
0.01345408707857132,
-0.02729067951440811,
-0.0034401847515255213,
-0.0324130654335022,
0.0027509224601089954,
-0.03590776398777962,
-0.060813311487436295,
-0.04984794929623604,
0.05632800981402397,
0.008778470568358898,
-0.05661844462156296,
0.03172139450907707,
-0.027071254327893257,
-0.09384959936141968,
-0.009350592270493507,
0.0010398027952760458,
-0.019840050488710403,
-0.0399126373231411,
0.00954390224069357,
0.038178734481334686,
-0.05567309632897377,
-0.045153409242630005,
-0.012159750796854496,
0.003976382780820131,
0.01191268302500248,
-0.027592001482844353,
0.025702176615595818,
-0.014730283990502357,
-0.010534209199249744,
-0.008318218402564526,
0.03193657472729683,
0.021551253274083138,
-0.004457787144929171,
0.004987708758562803,
0.037625622004270554,
0.039746277034282684,
0.02324535697698593,
0.026413653045892715,
0.06433989107608795,
0.019255636259913445,
0.02642788365483284,
-0.05227932706475258,
0.024250226095318794,
-0.024093762040138245,
-0.03422627970576286,
0.027772484347224236,
-0.053629059344530106,
-0.010488460771739483,
0.030908528715372086,
-0.0118239875882864,
-0.045024774968624115,
-0.012266634963452816,
0.0013233940117061138,
0.021779688075184822,
-0.01125546544790268,
-0.005686705466359854,
-0.008216112852096558,
0.031009692698717117,
0.006693372502923012,
-0.02895890735089779,
-0.04755489155650139,
0.05118272081017494,
-0.045129820704460144,
0.02113916724920273,
-0.04791583493351936,
-0.03313256800174713,
0.014142231084406376,
-0.024553092196583748,
-0.014447768218815327,
-0.007222224026918411,
0.021907126531004906,
0.012063904665410519,
-0.004933483898639679,
0.013212236575782299,
0.0509968064725399,
-0.010005411691963673,
0.013681670650839806,
0.001246885396540165,
-0.008410214446485043,
-0.03276510909199715,
-0.0017614266835153103,
-0.02239931933581829,
0.023778047412633896,
0.047727685421705246,
0.027244234457612038,
0.011678089387714863,
-0.00473768450319767,
-0.03185100853443146,
-0.002324278699234128,
-0.000005002517809771234,
0.04510599002242088,
-0.047070592641830444,
0.03078838251531124,
-0.055809058248996735,
-0.0027280249632894993,
0.004593074321746826,
0.0556466206908226,
0.0026399902999401093,
0.017513878643512726,
-0.04762053117156029,
0.03481657803058624,
-0.011589493602514267,
0.010584437288343906,
0.006811901461333036,
0.02599693275988102,
0.03209753334522247,
-0.04695110768079758,
0.003342767944559455,
0.029455339536070824,
0.04792126268148422,
0.006530274637043476,
-0.02449836954474449,
-0.04680554196238518,
-0.0097685931250453,
-0.02386658452451229,
-0.004072658251971006,
0.005390596576035023,
0.000459624279756099,
-0.01883724331855774,
0.01631929911673069,
0.01570822112262249,
-0.01487349346280098,
-0.042655427008867264,
0.011210822500288486,
0.0528024397790432,
0.013884363695979118,
0.02473440021276474,
-0.006800015922635794,
-0.06329617649316788,
-0.013185557909309864,
-0.04316786676645279,
0.005411652382463217,
0.026088081300258636,
-0.0205069612711668,
-0.036662403494119644,
-0.03925376012921333,
0.034569814801216125,
-0.019636960700154305,
-0.005905483849346638,
0.009896814823150635,
-0.013690901920199394,
-0.017564134672284126,
-0.03286205232143402,
-0.011044014245271683,
0.013200592249631882,
-0.0826142281293869,
-0.013193667866289616,
-0.012081307359039783,
0.009409517049789429,
0.03171627223491669,
-0.03314400836825371,
-0.004281859379261732,
-0.06761915981769562,
-0.01603875309228897,
0.009916223585605621,
-0.02878640592098236,
-0.04431533440947533,
-0.018325617536902428,
-0.02801770344376564,
0.007199425715953112,
0.020747704431414604,
-0.007829055190086365,
-0.025242522358894348,
-0.05967293307185173,
0.022898780182003975,
0.019389156252145767,
0.007364755030721426,
0.00269535044208169,
0.02220153994858265,
-0.05251980945467949,
0.03769978880882263,
-0.036971788853406906,
0.028550151735544205,
0.06481325626373291,
-0.012162567116320133,
-0.03452159836888313,
-0.003553045680746436,
0.051351599395275116,
0.006876002531498671,
-0.019386984407901764,
0.048615023493766785,
-0.006865156814455986,
-0.03344219923019409,
0.007221714593470097,
0.006883995607495308,
0.036049727350473404,
0.02409840188920498,
-0.03151027113199234,
-0.0011995587265118957,
0.03248467296361923,
0.010862539522349834,
0.010861373506486416,
-0.056420136243104935,
-0.004594236146658659,
0.06747012585401535,
-0.021329518407583237,
-0.05802726373076439,
-0.06309400498867035,
-0.044381484389305115,
0.0013806861825287342,
0.003943976480513811,
0.013957779854536057,
-0.037874486297369,
0.04761442542076111,
0.008879239670932293,
0.049456819891929626,
-0.01196919847279787,
-0.003208218375220895,
0.024993393570184708,
-0.03573237359523773,
-0.0081959068775177,
-0.074204221367836,
-0.04114739969372749,
0.05070182681083679,
-0.0002445419959258288,
-0.013746964745223522,
-0.027034156024456024,
-0.021907184273004532,
0.05082700401544571,
-0.019206803292036057,
-0.032175272703170776,
0.027972757816314697,
-0.00758100813254714,
-0.019025558605790138,
0.0198078490793705,
-0.061356883496046066,
-0.02449456974864006,
-0.017424438148736954,
-0.04314643517136574,
-0.035319894552230835,
-0.01504847127944231,
0.04263674095273018,
-0.022876424714922905,
0.017676301300525665,
-0.006081575993448496,
-0.01617521420121193,
0.007841505110263824,
0.06256802380084991,
0.020259711891412735,
0.018724769353866577,
-0.02873673290014267,
0.0654684379696846,
0.04321675002574921,
0.014617915265262127,
0.005344653036445379,
0.02509152702987194,
-0.03906340152025223,
-0.07400859892368317,
0.046240221709012985,
-0.02420421876013279,
-0.004590795375406742,
-0.025790726765990257,
0.07474487274885178,
0.02529923804104328,
-0.03065396286547184,
-0.028634728863835335,
0.03631037473678589,
-0.0406644269824028,
-0.0166526697576046,
0.02321154996752739,
0.008735607378184795,
-0.02979143336415291,
0.0493040569126606,
0.04249415546655655,
0.059501033276319504,
0.07710482180118561,
-0.00805433839559555,
-0.023436464369297028,
0.007985946722328663,
0.05797171592712402,
0.05639532208442688,
0.09659960865974426,
0.051665499806404114,
0.06858687847852707,
-0.005707683973014355,
-0.039370689541101456,
-0.0018040576251223683,
0.04304982349276543,
0.01714864745736122,
-0.025873228907585144,
-0.0018130552489310503,
0.04723730310797691,
-0.012089570984244347,
0.0472797155380249,
-0.04566708207130432,
0.0062808082439005375,
0.0518050380051136,
0.06032401695847511,
-0.029275229200720787,
0.05869525671005249,
0.02378990687429905,
-0.005284000653773546,
-0.05418797954916954,
-0.044119954109191895,
-0.009584268555045128,
-0.03614675998687744,
0.0008430462912656367,
0.006213350687175989,
-0.021488722413778305,
-0.014269182458519936,
-0.015425185672938824,
0.061467669904232025,
0.12322206050157547,
-0.0526072196662426,
-0.0003384880837984383,
0.021758442744612694,
0.021036531776189804,
-0.0011971567291766405,
0.05314425006508827,
0.037562236189842224,
-0.015107190236449242,
0.0033158105798065662,
-0.0486115887761116,
0.009033141657710075,
0.0073250941932201385,
-0.015458853915333748,
0.02963690087199211,
-0.03113555535674095,
-0.025086533278226852,
0.014914526604115963,
0.027903826907277107,
-0.048782702535390854,
-0.07488381117582321,
-0.02971184067428112,
-0.03326261788606644,
-0.027435820549726486,
-0.028633808717131615,
0.0652693510055542,
-0.014517555944621563,
-0.025563491508364677,
0.01689285598695278,
-0.02647821418941021,
-0.004049478564411402,
0.024530911818146706,
-0.05702327564358711,
-0.0033646041993051767,
0.013098519295454025,
0.01815257966518402,
-0.024821683764457703,
0.050765883177518845,
0.04992328956723213,
-0.02155790477991104,
0.006572931073606014,
0.0500548779964447,
0.00010866595403058454,
0.01836303621530533,
-0.00017622133600525558,
-0.014653480611741543,
-0.09788248687982559,
-0.034829434007406235,
-0.022531740367412567,
-0.04464239999651909,
-0.07083939760923386,
0.00978767964988947,
-0.03383185714483261,
0.03612648695707321,
0.05653386190533638,
0.03847527503967285,
0.02576121874153614,
-0.014872130937874317,
-0.02122890017926693,
0.012874186970293522,
-0.007469505071640015,
0.04756223037838936,
-0.018719365820288658,
0.1033000573515892,
0.03970646858215332,
-0.012779739685356617,
-0.05108985677361488,
0.00009383833821630105,
-0.007261007092893124,
-0.005546968430280685,
-0.04889320209622383,
-0.03526242449879646,
-0.0005107162287458777,
-0.09767406433820724,
-0.022370824590325356,
0.022961115464568138,
-0.016834817826747894,
-0.031079823151230812,
0.010141420178115368,
-0.04168049618601799,
0.012958226725459099,
0.017520850524306297,
-0.017399555072188377,
-0.013082848861813545,
-0.022458810359239578,
-0.0398060642182827,
-0.02944623865187168,
-0.020259035751223564,
-0.009424683637917042,
-0.008404484018683434,
-0.04113560542464256,
-0.04133908078074455,
0.00823216326534748,
-0.016842929646372795,
0.055197443813085556,
-0.008055676706135273,
0.03346457704901695,
-0.0061131855472922325
] |
379 |
Logic-Logit: A Logic-Based Approach to Choice Modeling
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=vJgJSrYPe1
|
[
"Shuhan Zhang",
"Wendi Ren",
"Shuang Li"
] |
Poster
|
In this study, we propose a novel rule-based interpretable choice model, {\bf Logic-Logit}, designed to effectively learn and explain human choices. Choice models have been widely applied across various domains—such as commercial demand forecasting, recommendation systems, and consumer behavior analysis—typically categorized as parametric, nonparametric, or deep network-based. While recent innovations have favored neural network approaches for their computational power, these flexible models often involve large parameter sets and lack interpretability, limiting their effectiveness in contexts where transparency is essential.
Previous empirical evidence shows that individuals usually use {\it heuristic decision rules} to form their consideration sets, from which they then choose. These rules are often represented as {\it disjunctions of conjunctions} (i.e., OR-of-ANDs). These rules-driven, {\it consider-then-choose} decision processes enable people to quickly screen numerous alternatives while reducing cognitive and search costs. Motivated by this insight, our approach leverages logic rules to elucidate human choices, providing a fresh perspective on preference modeling. We introduce a unique combination of column generation techniques and the Frank-Wolfe algorithm to facilitate efficient rule extraction for preference modeling—a process recognized as NP-hard. Our empirical evaluation, conducted on both synthetic datasets and real-world data from commercial and healthcare domains, demonstrates that Logic-Logit significantly outperforms baseline models in terms of interpretability and accuracy.
|
Choice Model, Preference Learning, Interpretability, Rule Learning
| null | 13,216 | null |
[
-0.00886025745421648,
-0.007494085468351841,
-0.008690827526152134,
0.02225104719400406,
0.07384025305509567,
0.021855877712368965,
-0.008321298286318779,
0.015332140028476715,
0.0012716349447146058,
-0.050496406853199005,
-0.028007101267576218,
0.026289701461791992,
-0.06472457200288773,
-0.032694194465875626,
0.031079784035682678,
0.05577719956636429,
0.022409094497561455,
0.010928274132311344,
0.02695619873702526,
-0.04450078308582306,
-0.002543725771829486,
-0.01813032664358616,
0.007539071142673492,
0.006918253842741251,
0.07089099287986755,
-0.012781510129570961,
0.026015102863311768,
-0.03311757743358612,
-0.033234819769859314,
0.025119369849562645,
0.038704339414834976,
-0.002620602725073695,
-0.014875569380819798,
0.004262110684067011,
-0.052046533674001694,
0.027736270800232887,
-0.02578432857990265,
-0.0038010720163583755,
-0.01645459234714508,
0.02188839763402939,
-0.041722122579813004,
0.03175666183233261,
0.03647974878549576,
0.023489944636821747,
-0.061792854219675064,
0.008298502303659916,
-0.091396264731884,
0.026554899290204048,
0.0070613655261695385,
-0.042437709867954254,
-0.08011583238840103,
0.033303484320640564,
-0.012596076354384422,
-0.009378299117088318,
0.02340851165354252,
0.056749556213617325,
0.06091047078371048,
-0.08023751527070999,
-0.010197714902460575,
-0.06848998367786407,
-0.005326516460627317,
0.05741225183010101,
0.021493934094905853,
0.005208597984164953,
-0.009676937013864517,
-0.03264712914824486,
-0.005525275599211454,
0.010492544621229172,
-0.032145626842975616,
-0.011487560346722603,
-0.08107790350914001,
-0.007092404644936323,
0.003226168919354677,
-0.016236385330557823,
-0.014877630397677422,
-0.02521342784166336,
0.0018285897094756365,
0.04465647414326668,
0.022198135033249855,
-0.030590729787945747,
0.005313340108841658,
0.026387346908450127,
0.03337276726961136,
0.04493948072195053,
0.030723368749022484,
0.016756940633058548,
-0.007580806501209736,
-0.02525685355067253,
-0.07864231616258621,
0.030144527554512024,
-0.0033156496938318014,
-0.05268239229917526,
0.028403352946043015,
0.05118579789996147,
-0.000567873939871788,
0.001622385112568736,
0.031148934736847878,
-0.005510582122951746,
0.009375181049108505,
-0.010947370901703835,
-0.009510642848908901,
-0.038319990038871765,
0.04620625451207161,
0.0073191518895328045,
-0.103883296251297,
-0.043032366782426834,
0.00364302727393806,
-0.0197849553078413,
0.023978235200047493,
0.011421730741858482,
-0.0484614260494709,
0.005237934645265341,
0.04310930147767067,
0.02575279213488102,
-0.07527270168066025,
0.03898726403713226,
-0.017959674820303917,
0.025648854672908783,
0.012819284573197365,
0.01999068446457386,
0.040919527411460876,
0.010141716338694096,
-0.0354282520711422,
0.06239458546042442,
-0.009527141228318214,
-0.031214166432619095,
0.01918681710958481,
0.033209752291440964,
-0.008830737322568893,
-0.03333957865834236,
-0.01731729879975319,
0.025704381987452507,
-0.021467620506882668,
-0.011494659818708897,
-0.03194231539964676,
0.003349588019773364,
-0.0008310109842568636,
-0.01636781543493271,
0.04821767657995224,
0.00421789288520813,
0.0015371679328382015,
-0.041114404797554016,
0.06110316142439842,
-0.04432152956724167,
0.082964688539505,
-0.044996824115514755,
0.03219575434923172,
0.0004914124147035182,
-0.017058108001947403,
-0.02455657161772251,
0.016482196748256683,
0.013450351543724537,
0.02047358825802803,
-0.024006925523281097,
0.016034338623285294,
0.06814195960760117,
0.010433152318000793,
-0.015908075496554375,
-0.0037363118026405573,
0.011984041891992092,
0.028819117695093155,
0.0006820196285843849,
-0.008206658065319061,
-0.030106717720627785,
0.01682579703629017,
-0.06142236664891243,
0.03620379418134689,
0.032122403383255005,
-0.01547170989215374,
0.004797848407179117,
-0.012992904521524906,
-0.03736524656414986,
0.03746098279953003,
0.0072904787957668304,
-0.012980769388377666,
0.03293398395180702,
0.05230480059981346,
-0.01578543335199356,
0.05049550533294678,
0.007032886613160372,
-0.07083990424871445,
0.03789974004030228,
-0.012426611967384815,
-0.00019358184363227338,
0.02867990918457508,
-0.016209430992603302,
0.058184914290905,
-0.03149654343724251,
0.03875238820910454,
-0.006790796294808388,
-0.05985948443412781,
-0.047533582895994186,
0.01431756466627121,
0.023378558456897736,
0.060354091227054596,
0.005921345669776201,
-0.02630501240491867,
0.06160343065857887,
0.03979553282260895,
0.0699545294046402,
0.025573810562491417,
-0.020910494029521942,
0.05023099482059479,
-0.005912658758461475,
-0.015089285559952259,
-0.0012626752723008394,
0.04869668930768967,
-0.044323354959487915,
-0.013410333544015884,
0.01971409283578396,
-0.020873626694083214,
-0.0026654074899852276,
0.01667661778628826,
-0.026513462886214256,
0.031221317127346992,
0.001305204932577908,
0.018965065479278564,
0.011651906184852123,
0.01600106805562973,
-0.03779067099094391,
0.013529226183891296,
0.01861550472676754,
-0.010011161677539349,
-0.011443129740655422,
-0.04227558150887489,
0.059987373650074005,
0.06254175305366516,
-0.023763583973050117,
-0.019177697598934174,
0.04815772548317909,
0.011331776157021523,
0.04206805303692818,
0.03889107704162598,
-0.00542013393715024,
0.05334863439202309,
-0.042803626507520676,
0.0026743796188384295,
-0.010022453963756561,
0.05245298519730568,
-0.04326590523123741,
-0.0001465654349885881,
0.048553865402936935,
-0.03236722573637962,
0.05887366458773613,
-0.027220500633120537,
0.0060764700174331665,
-0.0005322182551026344,
0.006729769054800272,
-0.010151690803468227,
-0.008095888420939445,
-0.002779501723125577,
-0.006976285949349403,
0.02999931573867798,
0.03007054701447487,
-0.0036864569410681725,
-0.06510739773511887,
0.019403299316763878,
0.015317993238568306,
0.07001565396785736,
0.04422641173005104,
0.009188791736960411,
0.025750180706381798,
-0.009538071230053902,
-0.030315274372696877,
-0.004489694256335497,
-0.10365883260965347,
-0.06060332804918289,
0.011964233592152596,
0.011085930280387402,
0.03721736744046211,
0.030082281678915024,
-0.033940643072128296,
0.014650988392531872,
0.00013725899043492973,
-0.03122163936495781,
0.03438743203878403,
0.052350256592035294,
0.05117584392428398,
-0.03600730746984482,
0.008735914714634418,
0.0037260730750858784,
0.07802141457796097,
-0.002333085285499692,
-0.012240632437169552,
0.006794013548642397,
-0.051794104278087616,
-0.006471652537584305,
-0.0407039150595665,
0.005588599015027285,
0.047730449587106705,
0.038977619260549545,
0.019680313766002655,
0.017520293593406677,
0.00636721309274435,
0.07125438004732132,
0.03178437054157257,
0.033030543476343155,
0.021842455491423607,
0.004156874492764473,
0.02439066581428051,
-0.007741629146039486,
0.010950376279652119,
0.014731448143720627,
0.02766946330666542,
0.05051204934716225,
0.012981067411601543,
0.025029392912983894,
0.017292987555265427,
-0.2589960992336273,
-0.016363684087991714,
0.03903063386678696,
-0.009516366757452488,
0.00039908639155328274,
-0.05533638224005699,
0.058871492743492126,
-0.0343734472990036,
-0.0019576968625187874,
0.03728507459163666,
0.014025905169546604,
0.00749776279553771,
-0.026386233046650887,
0.05900987237691879,
0.04643941670656204,
0.053710367530584335,
-0.004998736549168825,
-0.0334276482462883,
-0.012626809068024158,
0.04799359291791916,
0.012369012460112572,
-0.09615007787942886,
-0.03163257613778114,
0.033202700316905975,
-0.003269381821155548,
0.05126935988664627,
-0.03724944218993187,
-0.03548048064112663,
-0.046672273427248,
-0.0023604442831128836,
0.021745305508375168,
-0.031829651445150375,
-0.03078213334083557,
0.03370717167854309,
0.056759919971227646,
-0.018146712332963943,
0.040674783289432526,
-0.022395480424165726,
0.0366649366915226,
0.053090017288923264,
-0.0082596680149436,
0.005445584189146757,
-0.012240147218108177,
0.017360791563987732,
0.06354939937591553,
0.023781457915902138,
-0.0507374182343483,
-0.028801720589399338,
-0.011791505850851536,
0.019672522321343422,
0.0034832321107387543,
0.00011636983981588855,
-0.021951895207166672,
-0.008284827694296837,
-0.0004981384263373911,
-0.003232011804357171,
0.014546755701303482,
-0.025730174034833908,
-0.044678445905447006,
-0.00035361049231141806,
0.002715049311518669,
-0.009810728020966053,
-0.008613462559878826,
-0.022899940609931946,
-0.014921562746167183,
-0.03549519553780556,
-0.09318365156650543,
-0.04038926586508751,
0.0410008579492569,
0.051188062876462936,
-0.011630017310380936,
0.007417366374284029,
0.01725257746875286,
-0.09192687273025513,
-0.020520301535725594,
-0.0035782617051154375,
0.0010059723863378167,
-0.01985771954059601,
0.017757227644324303,
0.005422632675617933,
-0.019780555739998817,
-0.021392235532402992,
-0.006425547879189253,
0.0165086816996336,
0.03910156339406967,
-0.006427624262869358,
0.016136547550559044,
0.0069238184951245785,
-0.06743025034666061,
-0.04604296013712883,
0.017957543954253197,
0.011382638476788998,
-0.013249256648123264,
-0.021393997594714165,
0.04535004869103432,
0.06223194673657417,
-0.0018759398953989148,
0.029829826205968857,
0.008379779756069183,
-0.006737899966537952,
-0.001061479328200221,
-0.06267385929822922,
-0.016660071909427643,
-0.03118729405105114,
-0.06234235316514969,
0.02737944945693016,
-0.05333125963807106,
-0.024074580520391464,
0.027579791843891144,
-0.019811095669865608,
2.0656823096487642e-7,
0.006258183624595404,
-0.024781707674264908,
-0.0212479867041111,
-0.023453952744603157,
-0.017927689477801323,
-0.032944388687610626,
0.011438707821071148,
0.018196022137999535,
0.011495111510157585,
0.0014657739084213972,
0.02806401439011097,
-0.04668343439698219,
-0.009047514759004116,
-0.04992450401186943,
-0.018348881974816322,
-0.03493376448750496,
-0.04007913917303085,
-0.003246262203902006,
-0.02439897693693638,
0.043951984494924545,
0.04150513932108879,
-0.013867842964828014,
0.04251457005739212,
0.028022995218634605,
-0.001871766522526741,
-0.010952845215797424,
0.009724103845655918,
-0.0018526458879932761,
-0.03600168228149414,
0.027530750259757042,
-0.03727085515856743,
0.05518478900194168,
0.028168680146336555,
-0.009107858873903751,
-0.012622777372598648,
-0.011576471850275993,
0.03100612200796604,
-0.011147864162921906,
0.007088312413543463,
0.007692857179790735,
-0.026468859985470772,
-0.010785703547298908,
-0.013519948348402977,
0.017202220857143402,
-0.01401546411216259,
0.04488814249634743,
0.02434973046183586,
-0.0014710914110764861,
-0.11022446304559708,
0.04350140318274498,
-0.010919093154370785,
0.01604483649134636,
-0.013203524984419346,
0.0253025833517313,
0.07550638914108276,
-0.03078770637512207,
-0.03029683604836464,
-0.0035477748606354,
0.01794176548719406,
0.02141578309237957,
-0.01215648278594017,
-0.0040429928340017796,
0.01620187796652317,
-0.03658208250999451,
-0.004468835424631834,
0.02048886939883232,
-0.06990322470664978,
-0.04870688170194626,
0.03136866167187691,
-0.039547234773635864,
-0.05277455598115921,
-0.0012533580884337425,
-0.015563376247882843,
0.0737239420413971,
0.01476142555475235,
0.015590118244290352,
0.01454644463956356,
-0.04697621986269951,
-0.00443677045404911,
-0.031207023188471794,
0.01763400249183178,
-0.033848054707050323,
-0.05374883487820625,
-0.053504105657339096,
-0.04161210358142853,
0.007633313070982695,
-0.03160012513399124,
-0.04393897205591202,
0.010216685943305492,
-0.005670464131981134,
-0.03705611824989319,
-0.0560745894908905,
-0.02391422912478447,
0.02852834016084671,
-0.06778137385845184,
0.01072041504085064,
0.04862399399280548,
0.008920343592762947,
0.05847065523266792,
-0.04840856045484543,
-0.0280939731746912,
-0.05209613963961601,
-0.07143642753362656,
-0.008179035037755966,
-0.02599022537469864,
-0.025074446573853493,
-0.03088398650288582,
-0.023163678124547005,
0.014573092572391033,
-0.004740889184176922,
-0.015464873053133488,
-0.02356692962348461,
-0.019985061138868332,
0.0037540828343480825,
0.060737863183021545,
-0.021198216825723648,
-0.06672026216983795,
0.013438282534480095,
-0.006680546328425407,
-0.010522843338549137,
-0.04083545506000519,
0.002502002054825425,
0.04647988826036453,
-0.004560652654618025,
0.012491690926253796,
-0.028925271704792976,
0.01802329532802105,
0.016055874526500702,
0.00015384757716674358,
-0.04089361056685448,
-0.01966756209731102,
-0.035516157746315,
-0.0172413382679224,
0.022256867960095406,
0.03500567749142647,
0.04717440903186798,
-0.0029133232310414314,
0.018030453473329544,
0.006178292445838451,
-0.021630583330988884,
-0.004329801071435213,
-0.021133102476596832,
-0.0012233566958457232,
0.06000154837965965,
-0.015778526663780212,
-0.03059449978172779,
-0.03735636547207832,
-0.010011895559728146,
0.015403004363179207,
-0.030219823122024536,
0.017010178416967392,
-0.016589147970080376,
0.05161309242248535,
0.016399452462792397,
0.04125198349356651,
-0.00040939426980912685,
-0.005543784238398075,
0.031081074848771095,
-0.06437289714813232,
0.03331257030367851,
-0.059903834015131,
-0.016695747151970863,
0.04817650094628334,
-0.015195087529718876,
-0.022629231214523315,
0.009983298368752003,
-0.038394369184970856,
0.0539141520857811,
-0.0037176464684307575,
-0.030174022540450096,
0.01799839362502098,
-0.0034989614505320787,
0.006545857060700655,
0.050852540880441666,
-0.06258001178503036,
-0.05009842291474342,
-0.02079126611351967,
-0.03286046162247658,
0.01959851197898388,
0.002786074997857213,
0.04787604883313179,
-0.022279229015111923,
-0.012437690980732441,
-0.02645697444677353,
0.020371558144688606,
0.024792836979031563,
0.06375552713871002,
0.014503934420645237,
-0.0017090965993702412,
-0.02685368061065674,
0.04122955724596977,
0.03268008306622505,
0.05659478157758713,
-0.032569289207458496,
0.018870322033762932,
-0.016004091128706932,
-0.0663922131061554,
0.03633148595690727,
-0.01766311191022396,
0.012297667562961578,
-0.07461923360824585,
0.07748543471097946,
0.015777112916111946,
-0.0495564229786396,
0.008020912297070026,
-0.00709682609885931,
-0.05959539860486984,
0.015825139358639717,
0.014857890084385872,
-0.014851292595267296,
0.0435028076171875,
0.0605776384472847,
0.007857113145291805,
0.08534900844097137,
0.07865482568740845,
0.015596278943121433,
0.0033682144712656736,
0.013483800925314426,
0.050909653306007385,
0.051478639245033264,
0.07463543862104416,
0.015140902251005173,
0.08939538896083832,
-0.010946196503937244,
-0.050105758011341095,
0.008738487027585506,
0.009345347061753273,
-0.03010847046971321,
-0.029234595596790314,
-0.0028172077145427465,
0.05284971371293068,
-0.002756612142547965,
0.040466323494911194,
-0.02919880859553814,
0.03332662209868431,
0.060195598751306534,
0.0165045615285635,
-0.006295154336839914,
0.0511910542845726,
0.01852596364915371,
-0.030773505568504333,
-0.05048896744847298,
-0.010037212632596493,
0.018040653318166733,
-0.03564837947487831,
-0.004664215259253979,
0.004536033608019352,
-0.014604328200221062,
0.008371856063604355,
-0.03101612627506256,
0.07785079628229141,
0.09792905300855637,
-0.051133301109075546,
-0.01433751080185175,
0.04809027165174484,
0.016672659665346146,
-0.0005711022531613708,
0.031013717874884605,
0.02300775796175003,
0.010664532892405987,
0.022709472104907036,
-0.04873435199260712,
0.006788811646401882,
0.028337031602859497,
0.02432706020772457,
-0.0016011111438274384,
-0.0410914309322834,
-0.028300078585743904,
0.03433861956000328,
0.0102110980078578,
-0.04668956995010376,
-0.05244848132133484,
-0.0014196017291396856,
-0.02289082668721676,
-0.06421392410993576,
-0.04448845610022545,
0.01923416554927826,
0.003085331991314888,
-0.026235003024339676,
0.013419442810118198,
0.013816972263157368,
0.007968767546117306,
0.017733272165060043,
-0.06352965533733368,
0.03872785344719887,
0.04152151569724083,
0.014518385753035545,
-0.0040394002571702,
-0.0036441690754145384,
0.018671758472919464,
-0.03354943171143532,
-0.019490431994199753,
0.013230729848146439,
-0.007040528580546379,
-0.006848259828984737,
0.003328957362100482,
-0.0502961128950119,
-0.0757666602730751,
-0.03799572214484215,
0.01658431813120842,
-0.03179168328642845,
-0.0749012678861618,
0.03318912908434868,
-0.01761726103723049,
0.05471457540988922,
0.08600257337093353,
0.018707584589719772,
-0.016981951892375946,
-0.0509682334959507,
-0.02567615732550621,
0.03319155052304268,
0.005209359806030989,
0.032628610730171204,
-0.05248819664120674,
0.05367963761091232,
0.005802980158478022,
-0.05846782028675079,
-0.05798524245619774,
0.04841776564717293,
-0.022904837504029274,
-0.031564828008413315,
-0.012251188047230244,
-0.035012900829315186,
-0.009422431699931622,
-0.09780960530042648,
0.00442472705617547,
0.03813774511218071,
-0.03338449448347092,
-0.03082934208214283,
-0.005838929209858179,
-0.019850367680191994,
-0.00323957996442914,
0.03610823303461075,
-0.0664246529340744,
-0.019679788500070572,
-0.021072283387184143,
-0.04292859137058258,
-0.060501787811517715,
0.024372316896915436,
-0.0038482488598674536,
0.016337597742676735,
-0.019847003743052483,
-0.045845113694667816,
-0.03962145000696182,
-0.04522814229130745,
0.018359750509262085,
0.024165859445929527,
0.030479446053504944,
-0.05129308998584747
] |
380 |
On Calibration of LLM-based Guard Models for Reliable Content Moderation
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=wUbum0nd9N
|
[
"Hongfu Liu",
"Hengguan Huang",
"Xiangming Gu",
"Hao Wang",
"Ye Wang"
] |
Poster
|
Large language models (LLMs) pose significant risks due to the potential for generating harmful content or users attempting to evade guardrails. Existing studies have developed LLM-based guard models designed to moderate the input and output of threat LLMs, ensuring adherence to safety policies by blocking content that violates these protocols upon deployment. However, limited attention has been given to the reliability and calibration of such guard models. In this work, we empirically conduct comprehensive investigations of confidence calibration for 9 existing LLM-based guard models on 12 benchmarks in both user input and model output classification. Our findings reveal that current LLM-based guard models tend to 1) produce overconfident predictions, 2) exhibit significant miscalibration when subjected to jailbreak attacks, and 3) demonstrate limited robustness to the outputs generated by different types of response models. Additionally, we assess the effectiveness of post-hoc calibration methods to mitigate miscalibration. We demonstrate the efficacy of temperature scaling and, for the first time, highlight the benefits of contextual calibration for confidence calibration of guard models, particularly in the absence of validation sets. Our analysis and experiments underscore the limitations of current LLM-based guard models and provide valuable insights for the future development of well-calibrated guard models toward more reliable content moderation. We also advocate for incorporating reliability evaluation of confidence calibration when releasing future LLM-based guard models.
|
Content Moderation, LLM-based Guard Models, Calibration, Safety
| null | 13,206 |
2410.10414
|
[
-0.008625770919024944,
-0.022808782756328583,
-0.009156093932688236,
0.03182625770568848,
0.04802333563566208,
-4.7472576625295915e-7,
0.061279553920030594,
0.005419624969363213,
-0.036824632436037064,
-0.01277761161327362,
-0.01642608642578125,
0.017544414848089218,
-0.0501733236014843,
-0.008605281822383404,
-0.0008560845744796097,
0.05085945129394531,
0.02460123598575592,
0.00569190876558423,
0.054902803152799606,
0.010752192698419094,
0.019195931032299995,
-0.006953697185963392,
0.03749890998005867,
-0.0019158554496243596,
0.052441708743572235,
0.005921678151935339,
0.04064546898007393,
0.01593467965722084,
-0.05460558459162712,
0.0036281279753893614,
0.044082049280405045,
0.015645509585738182,
0.008841787464916706,
-0.014920285902917385,
0.02126261033117771,
0.05013112723827362,
-0.04997044801712036,
0.019638042896986008,
-0.000543055881280452,
0.034362222999334335,
-0.025615908205509186,
0.018787318840622902,
-0.03201660141348839,
-0.010964537039399147,
-0.08324972540140152,
-0.012606587260961533,
-0.07867712527513504,
0.04581190645694733,
0.042213473469018936,
-0.015552965924143791,
-0.11759516596794128,
0.05288161709904671,
-0.04894547536969185,
0.003634506603702903,
0.03522595763206482,
0.01709231734275818,
0.06019933149218559,
-0.10143549740314484,
0.0016432154225185513,
-0.03259984403848648,
-0.0419464111328125,
0.02012873999774456,
0.013291322626173496,
-0.015872517600655556,
-0.031787317246198654,
-0.018996864557266235,
0.03196685388684273,
0.013750036247074604,
-0.06213019788265228,
-0.04644034802913666,
0.009352006018161774,
0.014939278364181519,
0.0005483939312398434,
-0.01528990175575018,
-0.004805316682904959,
-0.04904821515083313,
-0.018305156379938126,
0.03568711131811142,
0.04073465242981911,
0.005117001011967659,
0.009139598347246647,
-0.00012844194134231657,
0.02909010276198387,
0.04673570394515991,
0.007829058915376663,
0.02163163758814335,
-0.02079707197844982,
-0.028108641505241394,
-0.05818764120340347,
0.01751186139881611,
0.012692240066826344,
-0.02755690924823284,
0.024729494005441666,
0.02349761500954628,
0.0171518437564373,
0.00596319604665041,
0.015491419471800327,
0.03325951471924782,
-0.011160626076161861,
0.01430151890963316,
0.005566743202507496,
-0.019683143123984337,
-0.003200596896931529,
-0.011782292276620865,
-0.12638884782791138,
-0.019657175987958908,
-0.026135511696338654,
-0.016266824677586555,
-0.0257517509162426,
-0.017205245792865753,
-0.0114616509526968,
0.008277242071926594,
0.012889370322227478,
-0.0038755217101424932,
-0.07165639102458954,
0.050632890313863754,
-0.0115260761231184,
0.0015069462824612856,
0.029205482453107834,
0.01922297477722168,
0.02426714263856411,
0.0720839872956276,
0.004154579248279333,
0.07147920876741409,
-0.021034831181168556,
0.011179224587976933,
0.005245380103588104,
0.02127556875348091,
-0.008338338695466518,
-0.009281965903937817,
0.01229122094810009,
0.028563909232616425,
0.0013648252934217453,
0.0061935498379170895,
-0.0094381645321846,
0.002119607524946332,
-0.014618691988289356,
0.05874888598918915,
0.04895266145467758,
0.014136893674731255,
0.008072808384895325,
-0.03252905234694481,
0.0644136518239975,
-0.02258814498782158,
0.06347111612558365,
-0.0011623194441199303,
-0.005148125346750021,
-0.029836824163794518,
-0.03421996533870697,
0.004590529948472977,
0.0364835262298584,
-0.026133572682738304,
-0.02482157200574875,
-0.054002564400434494,
0.022252950817346573,
0.03267519921064377,
0.06156470254063606,
0.003315924433991313,
-0.03413795679807663,
-0.006686402019113302,
-0.018021339550614357,
-0.01122137438505888,
-0.06636819988489151,
0.027735797688364983,
0.0029749528039246798,
-0.039423905313014984,
0.0043760063126683235,
-0.00168297765776515,
-0.014941292814910412,
0.015155503526329994,
-0.04395732283592224,
-0.007073597051203251,
0.04628743603825569,
-0.01239343173801899,
-0.02488405629992485,
0.011067796498537064,
0.049817826598882675,
0.0062721059657633305,
0.017491135746240616,
0.03709452599287033,
-0.0753057524561882,
0.019032355397939682,
0.031806580722332,
0.03262977674603462,
0.017718514427542686,
-0.005092468112707138,
0.09826532751321793,
-0.056412819772958755,
-0.023586373776197433,
0.015702037140727043,
-0.09746183454990387,
0.0013024529907852411,
0.053682249039411545,
0.001781821483746171,
0.06747512519359589,
-0.01416813861578703,
-0.00019132740271743387,
0.03720327094197273,
0.02045108750462532,
0.03639206662774086,
0.042598623782396317,
0.004470030777156353,
0.045719731599092484,
-0.01375119574368,
-0.04649725183844566,
0.003980419598519802,
0.02776263654232025,
-0.040300339460372925,
-0.039197586476802826,
0.008543985895812511,
-0.016589324921369553,
0.004547991324216127,
0.000864151690620929,
-0.015441332012414932,
0.014721116982400417,
-0.014365484938025475,
-0.025454910472035408,
-0.0038309155497699976,
0.027097610756754875,
-0.06057071313261986,
0.047377340495586395,
0.011285468935966492,
-0.011316782794892788,
0.03768984228372574,
-0.05453210324048996,
0.09020335227251053,
0.07156135886907578,
-0.03511133790016174,
-0.007732700556516647,
0.007742292247712612,
-0.009937349706888199,
-0.028451116755604744,
-0.0044791195541620255,
-0.01980120874941349,
0.013304876163601875,
0.0029256646521389484,
0.013375164940953255,
-0.02230299822986126,
0.05582490935921669,
-0.03181576728820801,
-0.0031542922370135784,
0.0755143091082573,
-0.006180493626743555,
0.05848504230380058,
-0.045805297791957855,
0.03707600757479668,
0.050912126898765564,
-0.036339737474918365,
-0.01457769051194191,
-0.030093714594841003,
-0.008145319297909737,
-0.005464443936944008,
0.054927755147218704,
-0.04961848258972168,
0.018217800185084343,
-0.04403376951813698,
-0.02387630194425583,
-0.0023032829631119967,
0.04116293042898178,
0.05865897983312607,
0.018452763557434082,
0.019106533378362656,
-0.01662679761648178,
-0.02322082407772541,
-0.016145028173923492,
-0.09491637349128723,
-0.04373433440923691,
-0.01649801805615425,
0.024227170273661613,
0.021427355706691742,
0.0275703277438879,
-0.013361869379878044,
0.011142806150019169,
-0.019666142761707306,
0.024169212207198143,
0.01628565974533558,
0.01617465168237686,
0.020667357370257378,
-0.02484573982656002,
-0.018443461507558823,
-0.018200941383838654,
0.037976574152708054,
0.01967574656009674,
-0.029840650036931038,
-0.022754384204745293,
-0.019503092393279076,
0.004761600401252508,
-0.06498683989048004,
-0.03180545195937157,
0.004062180407345295,
-0.013762164860963821,
-0.012464695610105991,
-0.013373754918575287,
0.04060603305697441,
0.01736936718225479,
0.06563179939985275,
0.015745442360639572,
0.02773411199450493,
0.0021830741316080093,
0.06701236218214035,
-0.00928913988173008,
0.009431656450033188,
-0.013876775279641151,
0.014749481342732906,
-0.014532907865941525,
-0.012153537943959236,
0.004091307986527681,
0.0034770024940371513,
-0.2869408428668976,
-0.0020390418358147144,
0.03328583016991615,
-0.04215693846344948,
-0.0014757417375221848,
-0.005586595740169287,
0.062479060143232346,
-0.025485925376415253,
-0.04060989245772362,
0.008113459683954716,
0.023458685725927353,
0.010372260585427284,
0.031023986637592316,
0.021641751751303673,
0.032647453248500824,
0.04029589891433716,
0.011432409286499023,
-0.046489764004945755,
0.04702310636639595,
0.011641504243016243,
-0.034567464143037796,
-0.06848321855068207,
0.0041460865177214146,
0.010944299399852753,
-0.021719520911574364,
0.04526188224554062,
-0.05957407504320145,
0.012727780267596245,
-0.031553611159324646,
0.023413093760609627,
-0.004019756335765123,
-0.03214584290981293,
-0.014367281459271908,
-0.0027909311465919018,
-0.0055488646030426025,
-0.001879366347566247,
0.05027863383293152,
0.019956311210989952,
0.025446956977248192,
0.013746177777647972,
0.03891874849796295,
-0.031027665361762047,
-0.004416037350893021,
0.006047324277460575,
0.07485239952802658,
0.023698123171925545,
-0.06895680725574493,
-0.018361050635576248,
-0.029901955276727676,
0.019313037395477295,
0.003189465729519725,
-0.05970948934555054,
-0.03230169042944908,
0.0002120604331139475,
-0.021624376997351646,
-0.008030230179429054,
-0.015169927850365639,
-0.04391145706176758,
-0.01909598521888256,
0.018599772825837135,
-0.001486616674810648,
-0.01950780674815178,
-0.035220447927713394,
-0.021945226937532425,
-0.011775719001889229,
-0.030204297974705696,
-0.05355115979909897,
-0.05662776529788971,
0.048168476670980453,
0.047567714005708694,
-0.02205076441168785,
0.03189452365040779,
-0.005291363690048456,
-0.09475336223840714,
-0.01355170551687479,
-0.009686757810413837,
-0.011549382470548153,
-0.012957916595041752,
0.013141704723238945,
0.03879272937774658,
-0.07558787614107132,
-0.024958834052085876,
0.0013359352014958858,
-0.0023138185497373343,
0.04538986459374428,
-0.010553951375186443,
0.012979207560420036,
0.010244556702673435,
-0.0004824099305551499,
-0.04137822240591049,
0.05094415321946144,
-0.005913960747420788,
-0.016937369480729103,
0.00714263878762722,
0.06023174151778221,
0.00626399228349328,
0.0391729362308979,
0.047261953353881836,
0.055836401879787445,
0.00898547563701868,
0.019938655197620392,
-0.04780082032084465,
0.03040989860892296,
-0.06275021284818649,
-0.014159001410007477,
0.0378054641187191,
-0.050748310983181,
-0.02991497330367565,
0.032335080206394196,
-0.03665970638394356,
-0.03833424672484398,
-0.004155862610787153,
0.0013811737298965454,
-0.011011824943125248,
-0.027170216664671898,
-0.020613454282283783,
-0.006212115287780762,
0.0139024518430233,
0.05644776299595833,
-0.049829863011837006,
-0.05734262615442276,
0.02525162883102894,
-0.0013642440317198634,
0.014151177369058132,
-0.008760610595345497,
-0.030308080837130547,
0.00682363985106349,
0.003491033799946308,
0.004951093345880508,
-0.028926758095622063,
0.003416360355913639,
0.04146898165345192,
0.018364517018198967,
-0.0013750651851296425,
0.043184373527765274,
0.00400044210255146,
0.015283769927918911,
0.0015522303292527795,
0.027744140475988388,
-0.005221010185778141,
0.008843012154102325,
-0.011166430078446865,
0.03752399981021881,
0.0403730608522892,
0.03968394920229912,
-0.007837929762899876,
0.042494505643844604,
0.0029627985786646605,
0.00017199417925439775,
0.007381024770438671,
0.03382532298564911,
-0.06574182957410812,
0.024724483489990234,
-0.04339766874909401,
0.037835054099559784,
0.0083784069865942,
0.037352532148361206,
0.008578910492360592,
-0.004039638210088015,
-0.05973223224282265,
0.07818035781383514,
0.01786738820374012,
-0.012689586728811264,
-0.0006254574400372803,
0.010677682235836983,
0.03799205645918846,
-0.06712339073419571,
-0.007924174889922142,
0.009558415040373802,
-0.006417904049158096,
-0.013889388181269169,
-0.050965066999197006,
-0.022553134709596634,
0.0005862562684342265,
-0.029531186446547508,
0.004788465332239866,
-0.0020636538974940777,
-0.021604739129543304,
-0.040587473660707474,
0.017408419400453568,
-0.01828225888311863,
-0.015048613771796227,
-0.006194297224283218,
0.018010059371590614,
0.05800272151827812,
-0.019608698785305023,
-0.00883240532130003,
-0.023661425337195396,
-0.029209278523921967,
0.02789149433374405,
-0.004121121950447559,
0.007826012559235096,
-0.014678625389933586,
-0.029681319370865822,
-0.03072398342192173,
-0.0754186362028122,
0.00962026882916689,
0.026024769991636276,
0.00043946944060735404,
-0.036795228719711304,
0.01731012761592865,
-0.002713265363126993,
-0.03717063367366791,
0.005900047719478607,
-0.006832493469119072,
-0.09335172921419144,
0.022140968590974808,
0.045828599482774734,
-0.009509076364338398,
0.02517317421734333,
-0.05174494534730911,
-0.04268535226583481,
-0.04001381993293762,
-0.027336223050951958,
0.043518032878637314,
-0.05706162378191948,
-0.07176230847835541,
-0.0008449376909993589,
-0.0038256344851106405,
-0.005006791558116674,
0.007755466736853123,
-0.024657297879457474,
-0.0028378416318446398,
-0.0058348882012069225,
0.003693348029628396,
0.03618360683321953,
-0.022147608920931816,
0.008586069568991661,
0.02258213981986046,
-0.033576782792806625,
0.0611729621887207,
-0.02992814965546131,
0.05543019250035286,
0.03026355803012848,
-0.025513947010040283,
0.007889949716627598,
-0.06589130312204361,
0.03067568503320217,
-0.027520231902599335,
-0.007052905857563019,
-0.020132508128881454,
0.004393392708152533,
-0.009029841981828213,
0.004110998474061489,
0.02542410045862198,
0.026984484866261482,
-0.0010864436626434326,
0.027977926656603813,
-0.009711228311061859,
0.0016040494665503502,
-0.012056064791977406,
0.037021808326244354,
-0.02486974559724331,
0.01144626084715128,
0.05676877871155739,
-0.046837057918310165,
-0.005171732045710087,
-0.0582791306078434,
-0.02884666435420513,
-0.0017274897545576096,
0.001827383879572153,
0.04281657934188843,
-0.036797042936086655,
0.01636909320950508,
0.026346750557422638,
0.014099691063165665,
0.006095045246183872,
-0.05135326832532883,
0.03157011419534683,
-0.07231608033180237,
-0.002346451859921217,
-0.06752782315015793,
0.04081673175096512,
0.07614851742982864,
-0.03507503867149353,
0.027204029262065887,
0.017922868952155113,
-0.043702781200408936,
0.016718652099370956,
-0.022451935335993767,
-0.07304161041975021,
0.007072395645081997,
-0.03500247746706009,
-0.03190748021006584,
0.049206577241420746,
-0.044901106506586075,
0.015249771997332573,
-0.019279861822724342,
-0.047479297965765,
0.00859814789146185,
0.007861155085265636,
0.026011930778622627,
-0.023432908579707146,
0.009273653849959373,
-0.030746661126613617,
0.011751028709113598,
-0.013548457995057106,
0.021253040060400963,
0.026768920943140984,
0.012192989699542522,
-0.006641973741352558,
0.06841596215963364,
0.04396433383226395,
-0.0036704842932522297,
0.02980671264231205,
-0.011446209624409676,
-0.020234186202287674,
-0.07589402049779892,
0.08417929708957672,
-0.0016357925487682223,
-0.019594691693782806,
-0.0260311346501112,
0.07593543082475662,
0.02763880230486393,
-0.08268285542726517,
-0.021027129143476486,
0.016285035759210587,
-0.04073894023895264,
-0.011842049658298492,
-0.007059287745505571,
0.006566411815583706,
-0.004204785451292992,
0.07466325908899307,
0.020275903865695,
0.054815873503685,
0.05067644268274307,
-0.0006846379837952554,
-0.03157912194728851,
0.004362135194242001,
0.06180015578866005,
0.06123123690485954,
0.0466761589050293,
0.01089986227452755,
0.06580151617527008,
-0.05692829564213753,
-0.06673993170261383,
0.0406835712492466,
0.029609315097332,
-0.012196158990263939,
-0.035086724907159805,
0.01648278348147869,
0.07546786963939667,
-0.0005922168493270874,
0.0775151178240776,
-0.041024334728717804,
0.02885160595178604,
0.04099274054169655,
0.02356637828052044,
0.028317727148532867,
0.040127597749233246,
0.030684933066368103,
-0.023449396714568138,
-0.022858629003167152,
-0.0020886389538645744,
-0.007588968146592379,
-0.03762238845229149,
-0.01214071735739708,
-0.0016280276468023658,
-0.023332322016358376,
-0.030524134635925293,
-0.03782946616411209,
0.02449207566678524,
0.11674037575721741,
-0.02415929175913334,
-0.026300398632884026,
0.028200846165418625,
0.015664992853999138,
0.031002569943666458,
0.03217815235257149,
0.007294824346899986,
-0.011157944798469543,
-0.011033695191144943,
-0.019455436617136,
0.023938685655593872,
-0.0171317458152771,
-0.029514266178011894,
0.02052987366914749,
0.0021007703617215157,
-0.030035099014639854,
0.01353420875966549,
0.030929304659366608,
-0.031292375177145004,
-0.03868623822927475,
-0.026745283976197243,
-0.06400389224290848,
-0.023696977645158768,
-0.059778306633234024,
0.011981493793427944,
0.0035253746900707483,
-0.04313802346587181,
0.023271653801202774,
-0.04883423075079918,
-0.002308834344148636,
0.009076477028429508,
-0.04688658565282822,
0.03722977638244629,
0.08169570565223694,
0.005853045731782913,
0.005846303887665272,
0.03945901617407799,
0.0003441481676418334,
0.011109987273812294,
-0.030258186161518097,
0.023489229381084442,
-0.013066336512565613,
0.039021652191877365,
-0.007671324536204338,
-0.009370913729071617,
-0.09633848071098328,
0.0038563564885407686,
0.04630283638834953,
-0.03160736337304115,
-0.07821710407733917,
0.04229678586125374,
-0.051152415573596954,
0.01904986798763275,
0.07734131813049316,
-0.01961410790681839,
0.030837949365377426,
-0.02613939717411995,
-0.006315858568996191,
-0.019733618944883347,
0.018052268773317337,
0.046832237392663956,
0.0026845140382647514,
0.07627104967832565,
0.014147114008665085,
-0.026355205103754997,
-0.03306623548269272,
0.034973591566085815,
-0.00693392613902688,
-0.04076993092894554,
-0.029528355225920677,
0.014217105694115162,
-0.014710437506437302,
-0.08167451620101929,
0.007353614084422588,
0.03178979828953743,
0.0002830496523529291,
-0.006710447836667299,
0.013122770003974438,
-0.014524329453706741,
-0.011753899976611137,
-0.041188016533851624,
-0.012776648625731468,
-0.019069282338023186,
-0.03838077187538147,
-0.03240459784865379,
-0.056495990604162216,
0.009886669926345348,
-0.025489656254649162,
-0.003660733113065362,
-0.01608283445239067,
-0.07277823239564896,
0.0031005109194666147,
0.029403531923890114,
0.04648040980100632,
-0.006706109270453453,
-0.004546616226434708,
-0.019124068319797516
] |
381 |
Unified Convergence Analysis for Score-Based Diffusion Models with Deterministic Samplers
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=HrdVqFSn1e
|
[
"Runjia Li",
"Qiwei Di",
"Quanquan Gu"
] |
Poster
|
Score-based diffusion models have emerged as powerful techniques for generating samples from high-dimensional data distributions. These models involve a two-phase process: first, injecting noise to transform the data distribution into a known prior distribution, and second, sampling to recover the original data distribution from noise. Among the various sampling methods, deterministic samplers stand out for their enhanced efficiency. However, analyzing these deterministic samplers presents unique challenges, as they preclude the use of established techniques such as Girsanov's theorem, which are only applicable to stochastic samplers. Furthermore, existing analysis for deterministic samplers usually focuses on specific examples, lacking a generalized approach for general forward processes and various deterministic samplers. Our paper addresses these limitations by introducing a unified convergence analysis framework. To demonstrate the power of our framework, we analyze the variance-preserving (VP) forward process with the exponential integrator (EI) scheme, achieving iteration complexity of $\tilde{O}(d^2/\epsilon)$.
Additionally, we provide a detailed analysis of Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models (DDIM)-type samplers, which have been underexplored in previous research, achieving polynomial iteration complexity.
|
Diffusion Models, Probability Flow ODEs, Unified Framework, Deterministic Samplers
|
A unified framework for convergence analysis of diffusion models with deterministic samplers.
| 13,205 |
2410.14237
|
[
-0.01162042748183012,
-0.03067697212100029,
0.020600315183401108,
0.03446609899401665,
0.06182098016142845,
0.027455197647213936,
0.013957981951534748,
-0.004061784129589796,
-0.007638608105480671,
-0.07687174528837204,
0.033721234649419785,
-0.024436095729470253,
-0.05516772344708443,
0.010337648913264275,
0.039956893771886826,
0.07328617572784424,
0.03566419333219528,
-0.02650064416229725,
-0.021033642813563347,
0.0342763215303421,
-0.01912670210003853,
-0.007352286484092474,
0.04674448072910309,
0.036910466849803925,
0.004138557706028223,
-0.016066882759332657,
0.018106305971741676,
-0.02133685164153576,
-0.04640025272965431,
0.010791477747261524,
0.0413564033806324,
0.022699717432260513,
0.0024044972378760576,
-0.025112565606832504,
-0.008187257684767246,
0.015057428739964962,
-0.027762725949287415,
-0.0030594023410230875,
0.014288444072008133,
-0.0006457098643295467,
-0.04638470336794853,
-0.0027426262386143208,
-0.03283349797129631,
0.028098013252019882,
-0.06345696747303009,
-0.016019633039832115,
-0.08631011098623276,
0.02826455980539322,
0.017398925498127937,
0.0024151597172021866,
-0.08619963377714157,
0.012583496049046516,
0.022102447226643562,
-0.035345207899808884,
-0.004507143050432205,
0.046637874096632004,
0.04629654809832573,
-0.07162695378065109,
0.013624750077724457,
-0.05876715108752251,
-0.024106083437800407,
0.00862887967377901,
-0.007520278450101614,
-0.005538083612918854,
-0.003792992327362299,
-0.01656678318977356,
0.01411524973809719,
0.044899504631757736,
-0.055001452565193176,
-0.03633279353380203,
-0.029139935970306396,
-0.0065176221542060375,
-0.008080275729298592,
-0.011495105922222137,
-0.007098184898495674,
-0.0678812637925148,
0.029331013560295105,
0.04026129096746445,
0.051449622958898544,
0.02017402835190296,
0.019215527921915054,
-0.014087182469666004,
0.010611249133944511,
0.03721299767494202,
-0.008388842456042767,
-0.02860254794359207,
-0.02656748704612255,
-0.03502888232469559,
-0.08874797075986862,
0.0786154642701149,
-0.0480099581182003,
-0.059196699410676956,
0.020294101908802986,
0.026693399995565414,
0.006282047368586063,
-0.018002066761255264,
0.038885243237018585,
0.015128293074667454,
0.016434798017144203,
-0.021091941744089127,
-0.01840021274983883,
-0.01877363584935665,
0.0038763564079999924,
-0.004351699259132147,
-0.0745249092578888,
-0.03605348616838455,
-0.03130808472633362,
-0.0032283177133649588,
-0.028834380209445953,
0.023317258805036545,
-0.012897510081529617,
0.005837453529238701,
-0.0025622958783060312,
-0.009454709477722645,
-0.08672922104597092,
0.05035655200481415,
-0.004176547285169363,
0.01172580849379301,
0.011623439379036427,
-0.012659833766520023,
0.05812821164727211,
0.05115007236599922,
-0.02182183600962162,
0.06556021422147751,
-0.03815370425581932,
0.04806586727499962,
0.05072616785764694,
0.039050739258527756,
-0.01719612069427967,
-0.033574704080820084,
0.025199037045240402,
0.033894822001457214,
-0.007573791313916445,
0.013691708445549011,
-0.024297529831528664,
-0.032940592616796494,
0.0034790581557899714,
0.011616748757660389,
0.037757791578769684,
-0.0037936221342533827,
0.000849636213388294,
-0.010408371686935425,
0.02300306409597397,
-0.021690277382731438,
0.009304088540375233,
-0.012742525897920132,
0.014669048599898815,
-0.019144412130117416,
-0.05742053687572479,
-0.01767081394791603,
0.0297632347792387,
0.04223101586103439,
0.03238921985030174,
-0.03846424072980881,
-0.007767717353999615,
0.029347941279411316,
0.026558686047792435,
0.01646125316619873,
-0.00868161115795374,
0.00465366430580616,
0.04987183213233948,
-0.008024862967431545,
0.005257305223494768,
-0.015895700082182884,
-0.010813425295054913,
-0.06440584361553192,
0.08498764038085938,
0.01741202175617218,
-0.03110596351325512,
-0.03093193843960762,
-0.03661828115582466,
0.012880700640380383,
0.05984026938676834,
0.02033149264752865,
0.016859145835042,
0.007155181374400854,
0.017914285883307457,
0.04975155368447304,
0.06279721111059189,
0.018186774104833603,
-0.09022717922925949,
0.0032461080700159073,
0.01141224056482315,
0.0074103521183133125,
0.0165325365960598,
0.0029706882778555155,
0.09552165120840073,
0.002274635247886181,
0.0009442511363886297,
0.0213147159665823,
-0.07748144865036011,
-0.02355053834617138,
0.03387926146388054,
-0.006890988443046808,
0.05277590826153755,
0.012058458290994167,
0.013194352388381958,
0.01699789986014366,
0.027115970849990845,
0.01766732707619667,
0.04819898307323456,
-0.04574255645275116,
0.03867899253964424,
-0.019814589992165565,
-0.03396949917078018,
-0.014882599003612995,
0.04886811599135399,
-0.05533521622419357,
-0.034883465617895126,
0.024608155712485313,
-0.04024224355816841,
-0.009211575612425804,
0.015633070841431618,
0.025874681770801544,
0.018142888322472572,
-0.0003987773379776627,
0.005594206973910332,
0.012421165592968464,
0.00508904317393899,
-0.04724757745862007,
0.02408219687640667,
0.007664283271878958,
-0.03084968589246273,
0.02911125309765339,
0.03624918311834335,
0.08678307384252548,
0.08891739696264267,
-0.032079219818115234,
-0.004209985490888357,
0.02253691852092743,
0.0014501548139378428,
0.004264643881469965,
0.03141511604189873,
-0.01250003557652235,
0.013405680656433105,
0.00792603101581335,
-0.011531584896147251,
-0.015099907293915749,
0.07194269448518753,
-0.04759012907743454,
0.01521883811801672,
0.0621354877948761,
-0.006487149279564619,
0.07405740022659302,
-0.012631515972316265,
0.0184337105602026,
0.021239176392555237,
0.008379628881812096,
-0.020912503823637962,
-0.03038584068417549,
-0.020736338570713997,
0.0150767145678401,
0.028172021731734276,
-0.0393713116645813,
-0.002243208000436425,
-0.0532708615064621,
0.021973077207803726,
0.035001009702682495,
0.06959418207406998,
0.021720116958022118,
0.03590939939022064,
0.0005411439924500883,
0.027576087042689323,
-0.061742015182971954,
-0.006621782202273607,
-0.12343091517686844,
-0.06865908950567245,
0.020316841080784798,
0.053022902458906174,
-0.0025451043620705605,
0.04134663566946983,
-0.02225167490541935,
0.008769337087869644,
-0.005383736453950405,
-0.025597795844078064,
-0.00389072741381824,
0.0011595941614359617,
-0.00004628809983842075,
-0.03508278355002403,
-0.008831130340695381,
0.003978448454290628,
0.07625571638345718,
-0.02672937884926796,
-0.03382887691259384,
-0.013690418563783169,
-0.03368585556745529,
-0.012555032968521118,
-0.010728894732892513,
0.0023718520533293486,
0.025338664650917053,
0.01988191157579422,
0.04698667302727699,
-0.02010083571076393,
0.018561869859695435,
0.02960030548274517,
0.03490355238318443,
0.02275872603058815,
0.0058680372312664986,
-0.005815418902784586,
-0.0017362794606015086,
0.006687651854008436,
-0.0020061545073986053,
0.024867620319128036,
0.022007251158356667,
-0.03070780821144581,
-0.04603011533617973,
0.029662610962986946,
-0.014200510457158089,
-0.2875480353832245,
0.008051476441323757,
0.012926534749567509,
0.006282607093453407,
0.03789597004652023,
-0.025184959173202515,
0.05840025097131729,
-0.024461667984724045,
-0.021556610241532326,
0.041560493409633636,
-0.006579034961760044,
0.031940918415784836,
-0.023837869986891747,
0.07965265959501266,
0.0321134515106678,
0.02790721133351326,
0.01799224503338337,
-0.03076353669166565,
0.018744241446256638,
0.017470942810177803,
0.010492771863937378,
-0.08120068162679672,
-0.013924223370850086,
0.027964144945144653,
-0.007178697269409895,
0.026087937876582146,
-0.06380245834589005,
0.00980598945170641,
-0.046256378293037415,
0.012230651453137398,
-0.016909997910261154,
-0.0419037863612175,
-0.031010936945676804,
0.022226441651582718,
0.016838878393173218,
-0.010777749121189117,
0.020145399495959282,
0.03337843716144562,
-0.031985051929950714,
0.013324243016541004,
0.023608272895216942,
0.001345598022453487,
-0.04368282109498978,
0.017777366563677788,
0.046052832156419754,
0.015342206694185734,
-0.01820925995707512,
0.0009784629801288247,
0.005866150837391615,
0.05166393145918846,
-0.009589162655174732,
-0.019399235025048256,
-0.01506064087152481,
-0.01007738895714283,
-0.026920700445771217,
-0.05201634764671326,
-0.018594153225421906,
-0.020920557901263237,
-0.010299041867256165,
0.047315772622823715,
0.005430125631392002,
-0.04142932966351509,
-0.0071844859048724174,
-0.04186692088842392,
-0.04409269988536835,
-0.03035072423517704,
-0.07883509248495102,
-0.04379407688975334,
0.034220609813928604,
0.016016703099012375,
-0.022107113152742386,
-0.006147521547973156,
-0.016261033713817596,
-0.09128935635089874,
0.006248434539884329,
-0.01303701288998127,
0.02837647870182991,
-0.018831776455044746,
-0.010743601247668266,
0.05302487313747406,
-0.03506742790341377,
-0.00014745659427717328,
0.011185458861291409,
0.017463726922869682,
0.0012246610131114721,
0.003892366075888276,
-0.015211529098451138,
-0.017780525609850883,
-0.051473699510097504,
-0.06142139807343483,
0.037712447345256805,
0.032795533537864685,
0.0497601218521595,
-0.018688958138227463,
0.042284172028303146,
0.035645175725221634,
0.005430331453680992,
0.06225263327360153,
0.03127538040280342,
-0.025526035577058792,
0.0634182021021843,
-0.08561169356107712,
-0.04575834795832634,
-0.05930096656084061,
-0.017988283187150955,
0.003979470115154982,
-0.07609601318836212,
-0.002610883442685008,
0.017794612795114517,
-0.031862229108810425,
-0.00549481762573123,
-0.022835809737443924,
-0.026856424286961555,
-0.02764362283051014,
-0.0058519658632576466,
-0.037334538996219635,
-0.01708587445318699,
0.06237319856882095,
0.02424260973930359,
-0.0019354999531060457,
-0.018854765221476555,
0.020107164978981018,
-0.024236395955085754,
0.0014796847244724631,
0.007427205331623554,
0.009322901256382465,
-0.019858255982398987,
0.0022386617492884398,
-0.01584039069712162,
-0.008384031243622303,
0.06194158270955086,
0.04597681388258934,
-0.001573398127220571,
0.02262228913605213,
0.06020701304078102,
0.0141137121245265,
-0.0264568068087101,
0.003740658750757575,
0.018520329147577286,
-0.016229577362537384,
0.01294800266623497,
0.010538240894675255,
0.031656164675951004,
0.011971613392233849,
0.05076713114976883,
0.0068208519369363785,
-0.0026770674157887697,
0.017681576311588287,
0.01844482123851776,
-0.04604126885533333,
0.03775963932275772,
-0.03123295307159424,
-0.011741090565919876,
-0.016980955377221107,
-0.006128939334303141,
-0.007944622077047825,
0.02776188775897026,
-0.021469153463840485,
0.00043264692067168653,
-0.0718424916267395,
0.05586306378245354,
0.02587144635617733,
-0.03985487297177315,
-0.005449746269732714,
0.011629367247223854,
0.046784333884716034,
-0.036622680723667145,
0.020520376041531563,
0.013997552916407585,
-0.0028718081302940845,
0.03815634548664093,
-0.0077822390012443066,
-0.02820977196097374,
-0.04723374545574188,
-0.015513809397816658,
0.024483850225806236,
0.016590822488069534,
0.003182337386533618,
-0.04666946083307266,
0.046130046248435974,
0.008065114729106426,
-0.053694043308496475,
-0.03642509505152702,
0.024227574467658997,
0.06830863654613495,
0.03176945820450783,
0.011227362789213657,
-0.008056551218032837,
-0.06551199406385422,
0.04060954228043556,
-0.04625355079770088,
-0.0018562921322882175,
-0.01467803679406643,
-0.07634691148996353,
-0.020449409261345863,
-0.03934935852885246,
-0.017576202750205994,
0.055151887238025665,
-0.029083266854286194,
0.008532575331628323,
0.006759571842849255,
-0.019747575744986534,
-0.02334139309823513,
-0.005774768069386482,
0.021183816716074944,
-0.06518441438674927,
0.012099120765924454,
0.03266129270195961,
-0.03449006751179695,
0.034382473677396774,
-0.021869972348213196,
-0.08174551278352737,
-0.060525521636009216,
-0.01881074346601963,
-0.00034024857450276613,
-0.027523502707481384,
-0.03971855714917183,
-0.03175298497080803,
0.021609095856547356,
0.0343761146068573,
0.017115933820605278,
0.010976350866258144,
0.026214923709630966,
0.0027809320017695427,
-0.016003398224711418,
0.04060371220111847,
-0.05126114562153816,
-0.032811038196086884,
-0.03378870710730553,
-0.01552718598395586,
0.02035311609506607,
-0.0565432533621788,
-0.020823627710342407,
0.03596988692879677,
0.01815844513475895,
0.002603931352496147,
-0.05953456088900566,
0.05044005438685417,
0.0069949752651154995,
0.006518329028040171,
-0.031102700158953667,
0.017134174704551697,
-0.013285919092595577,
-0.0020824105013161898,
-0.0016734483651816845,
0.0482601523399353,
0.022683734074234962,
-0.0003375819360371679,
0.02546861581504345,
0.06424884498119354,
0.0024404858704656363,
0.038277290761470795,
-0.07752325385808945,
0.009564707055687904,
0.05155576020479202,
-0.020911335945129395,
-0.01473974622786045,
-0.07355925440788269,
-0.03512865677475929,
0.05099225416779518,
-0.020937711000442505,
0.02433924190700054,
-0.008028917945921421,
0.03115765191614628,
0.028581766411662102,
0.024396266788244247,
0.027618272230029106,
0.010295100510120392,
0.03835736960172653,
-0.05726241320371628,
0.010685873217880726,
-0.08219815045595169,
0.012287239544093609,
0.06270188838243484,
-0.029759369790554047,
0.03872615844011307,
0.03086860477924347,
-0.018700096756219864,
0.0485578328371048,
-0.03910805657505989,
-0.06660210341215134,
-0.01053883321583271,
-0.024179717525839806,
-0.018736207857728004,
0.033398762345314026,
-0.04770016297698021,
-0.03279297798871994,
-0.012842285446822643,
-0.041810620576143265,
0.009227462112903595,
0.0183576587587595,
0.029084570705890656,
-0.019466940313577652,
-0.004871320445090532,
-0.04635221138596535,
0.02286311239004135,
0.031781744211912155,
0.04432693123817444,
0.002100448589771986,
0.027822284027934074,
-0.020277105271816254,
0.052273813635110855,
0.022076861932873726,
0.026349304243922234,
0.030627712607383728,
0.004145998973399401,
0.005022790748625994,
-0.039642903953790665,
0.03456168994307518,
-0.012791969813406467,
0.010238065384328365,
-0.07395302504301071,
0.03967640921473503,
0.036215804517269135,
-0.058805111795663834,
-0.03742918372154236,
0.026113515719771385,
-0.02739034779369831,
0.03873245418071747,
-0.0038389116525650024,
0.013751068152487278,
0.02007797546684742,
0.07078123092651367,
0.008922706358134747,
0.0757131576538086,
0.04872899875044823,
0.00687923189252615,
-0.008951499126851559,
0.008925126865506172,
0.07372631877660751,
0.0660487562417984,
0.058556437492370605,
-0.007636754773557186,
0.05435490980744362,
-0.04218050837516785,
-0.06904038786888123,
-0.009101583622395992,
-0.028364721685647964,
-0.01019352301955223,
-0.04324619844555855,
-0.00040321823325939476,
0.07791285961866379,
0.006106171756982803,
0.06356190890073776,
-0.04359652101993561,
-0.015084673650562763,
0.020739685744047165,
0.01922188699245453,
0.0004568923031911254,
0.00659013818949461,
0.008894792757928371,
-0.00022690666082780808,
-0.034602731466293335,
-0.0016431836411356926,
0.01916644163429737,
-0.003984772600233555,
0.04765051603317261,
0.014466903172433376,
0.00910975132137537,
0.03993391990661621,
0.02177317440509796,
0.010608779266476631,
0.08732647448778152,
-0.07707790285348892,
-0.03208526223897934,
-0.014566951431334019,
0.027256442233920097,
0.01338460948318243,
0.025796370580792427,
0.03654353693127632,
0.0026668028440326452,
0.0026307690422981977,
-0.02815018966794014,
-0.0006787031888961792,
0.06945022195577621,
-0.02288215421140194,
0.007171951234340668,
-0.036343980580568314,
0.02082200162112713,
0.010364395566284657,
-0.01774045079946518,
-0.02926015481352806,
-0.05007689818739891,
-0.021207110956311226,
-0.061234500259160995,
-0.04009963944554329,
-0.03841668739914894,
0.03865145146846771,
0.005859738681465387,
-0.02967999316751957,
-0.0018472170922905207,
-0.021822800859808922,
0.017718063667416573,
0.02878454141318798,
-0.05224063992500305,
-0.04509609937667847,
0.040356751531362534,
-0.00016139823128469288,
-0.0047417148016393185,
0.003595623653382063,
0.02589418552815914,
-0.00042965819011442363,
-0.021908409893512726,
0.02780047431588173,
0.014899864792823792,
0.05152204632759094,
-0.03182152658700943,
0.016032833606004715,
-0.07064138352870941,
0.01738096959888935,
0.04167698696255684,
-0.012925665825605392,
-0.08419284969568253,
0.035972144454717636,
-0.03387407585978508,
-0.0234377384185791,
0.026565274223685265,
-0.01719781383872032,
-0.01404582243412733,
-0.05605331063270569,
-0.03370290994644165,
-0.0006260948139242828,
0.007736113853752613,
0.0199568010866642,
-0.02532397024333477,
0.05965036526322365,
0.016363998875021935,
-0.027527272701263428,
-0.059641096740961075,
0.06748117506504059,
-0.002829223871231079,
0.022312002256512642,
-0.019052425399422646,
-0.004354339558631182,
-0.033003952354192734,
-0.08042772859334946,
-0.008455006405711174,
0.021724866703152657,
-0.03386871889233589,
-0.012606160715222359,
0.014917673543095589,
-0.009974641725420952,
0.0005537527613341808,
-0.02622159570455551,
-0.019034435972571373,
-0.03134571760892868,
-0.03367722034454346,
-0.025315871462225914,
-0.0659463182091713,
0.015192024409770966,
-0.03371450677514076,
-0.018905431032180786,
0.0013902813661843538,
-0.04337102174758911,
-0.016494864597916603,
-0.013266077265143394,
0.016160637140274048,
0.0036640039179474115,
0.006339562125504017,
-0.01194396149367094
] |
382 |
Optimizing Neural Network Representations of Boolean Networks
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=1H90Gb9rJ9
|
[
"Joshua Russell",
"Ignacio Gavier",
"Devdhar Patel",
"Edward Rietman",
"Hava T Siegelmann"
] |
Poster
|
Neural networks are known to be universal computers for Boolean functions. Recent advancements in hardware have significantly reduced matrix multiplication times, making neural network simulation both fast and efficient. Consequently, functions defined by complex Boolean networks are increasingly viable candidates for simulation through their neural network representation. Prior research has introduced a general method for deriving neural network representations of Boolean networks. However, the resulting neural networks are often suboptimal in terms of the number of neurons and connections, leading to slower simulation performance. Optimizing them while preserving functional equivalence --lossless optimization-- is an NP-hard problem, and current methods only provide lossy solutions. In this paper, we present a deterministic algorithm to optimize such neural networks in terms of neurons and connections while preserving functional equivalence. Moreover, to accelerate the compression of the neural network, we introduce an objective-aware algorithm that exploits representations that are shared among subproblems of the overall optimization. We demonstrate experimentally that we are able to reduce connections and neurons by up to 70% and 60%, respectively, in comparison to state-of-the-art. We also find that our objective-aware algorithm results in consistent speedups in optimization time, achieving up to 34.3x and 5.9x speedup relative to naive and caching solutions, respectively. Our methods are of practical relevance to applications such as high-throughput circuit simulation and placing neurosymbolic systems on the same hardware architecture.
|
Neural Networks, Boolean Networks, Lossless Optimization, Integer Linear Programming, NPN Classification
| null | 13,203 | null |
[
-0.047334544360637665,
0.00034938225871883333,
-0.0022414785344153643,
0.029436415061354637,
0.041127219796180725,
0.04154002666473389,
-0.010856770910322666,
-0.02222079038619995,
-0.042114339768886566,
-0.026212958618998528,
0.016233446076512337,
-0.0055967457592487335,
-0.04322640597820282,
0.016896676272153854,
-0.004601075313985348,
0.03160784766077995,
0.0370425246655941,
-0.02674916759133339,
0.04672694951295853,
0.024822555482387543,
-0.0026719665620476007,
-0.03157350793480873,
0.012414849363267422,
0.054028771817684174,
0.028749307617545128,
0.00190295884385705,
0.012801431119441986,
-0.00019946279644500464,
-0.01848733052611351,
0.022717755287885666,
0.04611808434128761,
-0.006359404418617487,
0.015788765624165535,
-0.0197666734457016,
-0.011817870661616325,
0.025340992957353592,
-0.06083391606807709,
0.03085312992334366,
-0.01619277521967888,
0.03571401908993721,
-0.0531911700963974,
0.009619143791496754,
-0.0060840630903840065,
0.03176897391676903,
-0.04268863797187805,
0.04126305133104324,
-0.11099288612604141,
0.014034035615622997,
-0.011847439222037792,
0.011860336177051067,
-0.11617771536111832,
0.037287794053554535,
-0.003417732659727335,
0.004799638409167528,
-0.006892676930874586,
0.011319522745907307,
0.021660223603248596,
-0.02909727394580841,
-0.014758951030671597,
-0.06826193630695343,
-0.023670367896556854,
0.0030150713864713907,
0.018269812688231468,
0.0340820737183094,
-0.008238207548856735,
-0.0208089929074049,
0.030820192769169807,
0.028868157416582108,
-0.05873805284500122,
0.01756962202489376,
-0.05619769170880318,
0.014171181246638298,
0.008976913057267666,
0.0011957588139921427,
0.02309897541999817,
-0.038581568747758865,
0.0327320471405983,
0.006609282456338406,
0.06978945434093475,
0.001567506929859519,
0.04063774645328522,
0.032350677996873856,
0.044527534395456314,
0.03754064813256264,
0.018084140494465828,
0.004596906714141369,
-0.06696091592311859,
-0.02864205650985241,
-0.07824019342660904,
0.031013673171401024,
-0.04521413519978523,
0.006980258505791426,
0.022542331367731094,
0.03153708949685097,
-0.005004456266760826,
0.0014444220578297973,
0.020122012123465538,
0.0061820936389267445,
0.03174470737576485,
0.028423191979527473,
0.010182719677686691,
-0.016614481806755066,
-0.00327778491191566,
-0.018795141950249672,
-0.07992658764123917,
-0.012813687324523926,
-0.02529633231461048,
-0.02269485592842102,
0.0014036218635737896,
0.019010692834854126,
-0.021261505782604218,
-0.009515303187072277,
0.034178800880908966,
-0.010708311572670937,
-0.09637226909399033,
0.02211061120033264,
-0.009292448870837688,
0.018696779385209084,
-0.013446902856230736,
0.01546537596732378,
0.07472152262926102,
0.07176915556192398,
-0.01773902401328087,
0.06802170723676682,
0.03219085559248924,
-0.00008635804988443851,
0.020841151475906372,
0.04961249232292175,
-0.039415568113327026,
-0.0398947037756443,
-0.030331891030073166,
0.039512790739536285,
0.0005181923042982817,
0.018435494974255562,
0.007711762562394142,
-0.03141232207417488,
-0.006991021800786257,
0.004027371760457754,
0.02796909026801586,
-0.003869397798553109,
-0.007826070301234722,
-0.030440770089626312,
0.07919815182685852,
-0.05785759538412094,
0.07825023680925369,
-0.026387585327029228,
0.010195039212703705,
-0.008044817484915257,
-0.01338588260114193,
-0.00504273409023881,
-0.04006967321038246,
0.018951771780848503,
-0.024449601769447327,
-0.0831301137804985,
0.02851802296936512,
0.06388135999441147,
0.008542456664144993,
0.025509949773550034,
-0.004436780698597431,
0.00881587527692318,
0.00047777467989362776,
-0.031909845769405365,
-0.014882153831422329,
-0.0025111157447099686,
-0.02513977140188217,
-0.04378405213356018,
0.056324806064367294,
0.08135717362165451,
-0.007910920307040215,
0.021496925503015518,
-0.009057706221938133,
-0.03609015792608261,
0.0444791316986084,
0.01761312037706375,
-0.02649037167429924,
-0.006041981745511293,
0.05833786353468895,
-0.022392770275473595,
0.010283926501870155,
-0.020473545417189598,
-0.08444637805223465,
0.03147114813327789,
0.011522341519594193,
0.03352616727352142,
-0.023628341034054756,
-0.031766120344400406,
0.0757773369550705,
-0.0452602282166481,
0.03552328050136566,
-0.010217087343335152,
-0.058125004172325134,
-0.020369235426187515,
0.004575950093567371,
-0.02812422625720501,
0.050641078501939774,
0.003630588762462139,
-0.0059642246924340725,
-0.007127850782126188,
-0.006223008036613464,
0.03580087795853615,
0.04928964748978615,
-0.0201294906437397,
0.033680789172649384,
-0.02011462301015854,
-0.052074335515499115,
0.0012178797041997313,
0.04545172303915024,
-0.06700623780488968,
-0.02789130248129368,
0.001803525839932263,
-0.007325729355216026,
-0.02187238074839115,
0.027137110009789467,
-0.01958346925675869,
0.037808142602443695,
-0.04553655534982681,
0.011981627903878689,
-0.013112671673297882,
0.03618454933166504,
-0.06098756194114685,
0.0467916764318943,
0.020368730649352074,
-0.004033975303173065,
0.026724033057689667,
0.0021903659217059612,
0.1030011922121048,
0.062416281551122665,
-0.057248372584581375,
-0.0070902761071920395,
0.009920487180352211,
-0.006171857938170433,
-0.011107577942311764,
-0.00023591147328261286,
0.00610796082764864,
0.013974050991237164,
-0.0012460422003641725,
-0.02273513190448284,
-0.014753906987607479,
0.05303416773676872,
-0.06707758456468582,
-0.007882816717028618,
0.06302915513515472,
-0.021915866062045097,
0.06767961382865906,
-0.015163125470280647,
0.018268518149852753,
0.05102824792265892,
-0.03945419564843178,
-0.013923370279371738,
-0.007510586641728878,
-0.04932323843240738,
-0.006409702822566032,
0.03384314849972725,
0.01637684367597103,
-0.0015260436339303851,
-0.07512683421373367,
-0.011438424699008465,
0.009144246578216553,
0.07284203916788101,
0.036964189261198044,
-0.015105469152331352,
0.006240699905902147,
0.00365944835357368,
-0.03961943835020065,
-0.008176349103450775,
-0.11738338321447372,
-0.046680595725774765,
0.02070838212966919,
0.050628408789634705,
0.0054150656796991825,
0.020729655399918556,
-0.00216278457082808,
0.02156798541545868,
-0.01390589214861393,
-0.04393291100859642,
-0.00913037545979023,
0.019558796659111977,
-0.00961198192089796,
-0.030334580689668655,
-0.02028796263039112,
0.02554595284163952,
0.07669858634471893,
-0.0073973326943814754,
-0.01830451935529709,
-0.019956141710281372,
-0.07637994736433029,
-0.00440765917301178,
-0.03531176596879959,
0.025719542056322098,
0.023074232041835785,
0.020547382533550262,
0.032103944569826126,
-0.028421983122825623,
0.016891194507479668,
0.05612558498978615,
0.0621735118329525,
0.046110622584819794,
0.024396555498242378,
-0.022888658568263054,
-0.01323920488357544,
0.0029925559647381306,
0.02134958654642105,
-0.02714436501264572,
0.018075421452522278,
-0.017212264239788055,
0.0329161137342453,
0.035233888775110245,
-0.0071134367026388645,
-0.2549946904182434,
-0.004143921192735434,
-0.0028226752765476704,
-0.025261014699935913,
0.03868060186505318,
-0.004173791967332363,
0.025016827508807182,
-0.016473205760121346,
-0.008877950720489025,
0.013026495464146137,
-0.0019433160778135061,
-0.003270328277722001,
-0.02203311398625374,
0.037719786167144775,
0.047362070530653,
0.012909209355711937,
-0.006571487057954073,
-0.029989687725901604,
-0.01090768538415432,
0.026514308527112007,
-0.006680293474346399,
-0.08839142322540283,
-0.019545162096619606,
0.015360437333583832,
0.012295529246330261,
0.03888872638344765,
-0.11043592542409897,
-0.018346747383475304,
-0.0503162145614624,
-0.017358414828777313,
-0.036422379314899445,
-0.019793670624494553,
-0.016392959281802177,
0.02994590625166893,
0.02607455477118492,
0.0072325742803514,
0.012978571467101574,
-0.023662758991122246,
0.008519367314875126,
0.05203024670481682,
0.016433674842119217,
-0.018358590081334114,
-0.03170804679393768,
0.029498083516955376,
0.07811290770769119,
0.026907414197921753,
-0.0579921118915081,
-0.004178776405751705,
-0.01689855195581913,
0.004643470048904419,
-0.02737586200237274,
-0.010188139043748379,
-0.0019420323660597205,
0.007927232421934605,
-0.0425298810005188,
0.0037985786329954863,
-0.006985117215663195,
-0.009471872821450233,
0.0049919551238417625,
0.00901133194565773,
-0.03198808804154396,
-0.04464094713330269,
-0.0027664548251777887,
-0.011146101169288158,
-0.0017212550155818462,
-0.01877407915890217,
-0.09095007181167603,
-0.03224189579486847,
0.05203167349100113,
0.047471947968006134,
0.0005282057682052255,
0.01023144368082285,
-0.03212568908929825,
-0.06864236295223236,
0.0026216895785182714,
0.016707992181181908,
-0.03456682711839676,
-0.011768573895096779,
-0.001774144358932972,
0.05628158524632454,
-0.024414677172899246,
-0.028531773015856743,
-0.01829223334789276,
0.02110598422586918,
0.03776303678750992,
-0.03840678185224533,
-0.000025954281227313913,
-0.018946491181850433,
-0.02057776413857937,
-0.018454482778906822,
0.036931805312633514,
0.046691350638866425,
0.05001675337553024,
-0.06192869320511818,
0.049726542085409164,
0.011085237376391888,
0.08332721889019012,
0.032770708203315735,
0.028354264795780182,
0.010598359629511833,
0.00958582479506731,
-0.05034744367003441,
-0.0284518301486969,
-0.05633009970188141,
-0.05579327791929245,
0.05127479135990143,
-0.0454750694334507,
-0.0013431882252916694,
0.05372583121061325,
0.009519689716398716,
-0.022275779396295547,
-0.061589691787958145,
0.018788719549775124,
-0.03856085613369942,
0.006675737909972668,
0.0013017036253586411,
0.01800643466413021,
0.01820249855518341,
-0.0019870130345225334,
-0.003660927526652813,
-0.038764603435993195,
0.04185617342591286,
-0.0124531714245677,
0.005785822868347168,
0.0017841396620497108,
-0.011218441650271416,
-0.02118518576025963,
-0.01187457237392664,
-0.007031006272882223,
-0.027146505191922188,
0.060379818081855774,
0.045882418751716614,
-0.014545567333698273,
0.037658073008060455,
0.04761534556746483,
-0.002746651181951165,
-0.005264498759061098,
-0.0004855708684772253,
0.0055342488922178745,
0.007567237596958876,
0.02902796119451523,
-0.008247081190347672,
0.045069653540849686,
0.003103510942310095,
-0.025810405611991882,
0.04687833786010742,
0.004236472770571709,
-0.009429201483726501,
0.004294709302484989,
-0.006793508306145668,
0.0027431738562881947,
-0.07178903371095657,
-0.009772518649697304,
-0.0529383085668087,
-0.005553022027015686,
-0.0038265769835561514,
0.04752300679683685,
-0.01848706230521202,
0.01596480794250965,
-0.05572659149765968,
0.038737691938877106,
0.02946850284934044,
-0.026067981496453285,
-0.005254358518868685,
-0.0017877379432320595,
0.06931565701961517,
-0.021840550005435944,
-0.01796441338956356,
0.021079381927847862,
0.013027421198785305,
-0.008001023903489113,
-0.01926398277282715,
-0.05313875153660774,
-0.025986764580011368,
-0.0037291711196303368,
0.02378089353442192,
0.02245345711708069,
-0.03651249036192894,
-0.019824229180812836,
-0.02924060821533203,
-0.008180220611393452,
0.0021932520903646946,
-0.004640016704797745,
-0.003072242485359311,
0.0637209564447403,
-0.013917477801442146,
0.018370946869254112,
0.024549024179577827,
-0.0355164110660553,
0.021988507360219955,
0.006123457569628954,
0.0035873749293386936,
-0.030187828466296196,
-0.028209127485752106,
-0.02346990443766117,
-0.012259003706276417,
0.0029314772691577673,
0.04713955149054527,
-0.03889259696006775,
-0.028737980872392654,
0.028159959241747856,
-0.01749948039650917,
-0.047492556273937225,
-0.03287718445062637,
0.02693902887403965,
-0.05689218267798424,
0.0403856597840786,
0.03328194096684456,
0.0013362579047679901,
0.027811085805296898,
-0.012528232298791409,
-0.00253794202581048,
-0.05653020739555359,
0.013534637168049812,
0.02282656356692314,
0.00445536058396101,
-0.026540350168943405,
-0.0012760867830365896,
-0.013226786628365517,
-0.01101890578866005,
-0.0009444589377380908,
-0.011669802479445934,
0.002408005530014634,
-0.04659029841423035,
-0.013275206089019775,
0.05727478489279747,
0.009179207496345043,
0.01745966263115406,
0.002675949828699231,
-0.025996362790465355,
0.01991420052945614,
-0.04275793582201004,
0.009310497902333736,
0.03307892009615898,
-0.0005408089491538703,
-0.010065370239317417,
-0.056650109589099884,
0.03697432950139046,
-0.017213890329003334,
0.010133498348295689,
-0.013277020305395126,
-0.0015303154941648245,
-0.07786224037408829,
0.012634050101041794,
-0.0030144539196044207,
0.022091848775744438,
0.016543960198760033,
0.007776860147714615,
-0.010526568628847599,
0.013414004817605019,
0.015427717007696629,
0.004932126495987177,
-0.07540134340524673,
0.004077081568539143,
0.07059361785650253,
-0.022874854505062103,
-0.024728497490286827,
-0.05386964976787567,
-0.007547379937022924,
-0.00422061700373888,
-0.054864030331373215,
0.041229039430618286,
-0.026080694049596786,
0.06566492468118668,
0.005134812090545893,
0.048585906624794006,
0.0009982428746297956,
-0.04725458845496178,
0.0326562374830246,
-0.02498556300997734,
0.02492782287299633,
-0.05137557536363602,
-0.037474654614925385,
0.08295943588018417,
0.0013056250754743814,
0.022813279181718826,
-0.004832082893699408,
-0.01338285394012928,
0.014842914417386055,
-0.034075260162353516,
-0.030902042984962463,
0.03445902094244957,
-0.007703285664319992,
-0.017199479043483734,
0.05368949845433235,
-0.050856512039899826,
-0.014963868074119091,
-0.028294453397393227,
-0.03542933985590935,
0.020215468481183052,
0.02181852236390114,
0.04729712754487991,
-0.009262789972126484,
-0.00937593262642622,
-0.004126945976167917,
0.004981888458132744,
0.022176450118422508,
0.048409078270196915,
0.036043934524059296,
0.042315006256103516,
-0.059792570769786835,
0.04430672153830528,
0.0537911020219326,
0.044944558292627335,
-0.01588725857436657,
0.03397459536790848,
-0.016002502292394638,
-0.04715416207909584,
-0.008389762602746487,
-0.008877841755747795,
-0.02664986252784729,
-0.059112798422575,
0.04004884511232376,
0.02568608894944191,
-0.05221185088157654,
-0.015124207362532616,
0.03324199840426445,
-0.07242676615715027,
0.014913327060639858,
-0.009843255393207073,
-0.007534391712397337,
-0.020040782168507576,
0.0817931517958641,
-0.00579761853441596,
0.022930990904569626,
0.08705923706293106,
0.0137745700776577,
-0.03633792698383331,
-0.011308511719107628,
0.08375765383243561,
0.06323981285095215,
0.013702359981834888,
0.004195617511868477,
0.07874470204114914,
-0.027915433049201965,
-0.04590911045670509,
-0.0058492631651461124,
-0.0007759591680951416,
-0.04308846965432167,
0.002030306961387396,
0.027541643008589745,
0.0733504444360733,
-0.006325144786387682,
0.09314876794815063,
-0.038022544234991074,
0.012275703251361847,
0.0599079430103302,
0.022391820326447487,
-0.013946055434644222,
0.07678968459367752,
0.012074481695890427,
0.022030174732208252,
-0.012566115707159042,
-0.014972837641835213,
-0.005758786108344793,
-0.007197260390967131,
0.02163458615541458,
0.020616132766008377,
0.0039519392885267735,
0.02753414958715439,
0.0040191891603171825,
0.050115860998630524,
0.07159723341464996,
-0.029086202383041382,
-0.027937764301896095,
0.001417161663994193,
0.005234733689576387,
-0.014832663349807262,
0.00424842769280076,
-0.007973144762217999,
-0.0036164887715131044,
-0.014310985803604126,
-0.0475672222673893,
0.023103319108486176,
0.003496101126074791,
0.029705341905355453,
-0.0023894442711025476,
-0.03570127487182617,
-0.04283275455236435,
-0.024233972653746605,
0.017914706841111183,
-0.04485500976443291,
-0.049989253282547,
-0.053700972348451614,
-0.040526602417230606,
-0.0658617913722992,
-0.04438558593392372,
-0.03340400010347366,
-0.03389822691679001,
-0.053271159529685974,
-0.016512097790837288,
-0.006833790801465511,
0.01944935880601406,
0.03669650852680206,
-0.057905156165361404,
0.01070900447666645,
0.06224040687084198,
0.010933472774922848,
0.002760899718850851,
0.03806927055120468,
0.04056202992796898,
-0.018165364861488342,
-0.02578086219727993,
0.05640535056591034,
0.0032252753153443336,
0.021441567689180374,
0.01085672713816166,
-0.006379975937306881,
-0.11184558272361755,
0.007437639869749546,
0.016642939299345016,
-0.05164264142513275,
-0.06630045920610428,
0.027015019208192825,
-0.015544452704489231,
0.0447307787835598,
0.07638929039239883,
-0.028311563655734062,
-0.0020275257993489504,
-0.04521120339632034,
-0.00012102680921088904,
-0.010013295337557793,
-0.0183050949126482,
0.05900507792830467,
-0.03765825182199478,
0.05488019809126854,
0.04587298259139061,
-0.024994652718305588,
-0.014390057884156704,
0.028230873867869377,
-0.01677844300866127,
-0.008427740074694157,
-0.04177475348114967,
-0.03696906194090843,
-0.02850974351167679,
-0.10460890829563141,
0.004908666014671326,
-0.0004121678648516536,
0.005215068347752094,
-0.043108876794576645,
0.010987456887960434,
0.04037683829665184,
0.002958516124635935,
-0.015446655452251434,
-0.014956507831811905,
-0.006430727895349264,
-0.032834719866514206,
-0.030788008123636246,
-0.03750070556998253,
0.04920342192053795,
-0.023371977731585503,
0.018739109858870506,
-0.027712125331163406,
-0.04704910144209862,
-0.021837744861841202,
0.01708131842315197,
0.037216588854789734,
0.013780281879007816,
0.018605541437864304,
0.015276714228093624
] |
383 |
Causal Order: The Key to Leveraging Imperfect Experts in Causal Inference
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=9juyeCqL0u
|
[
"Aniket Vashishtha",
"Abbavaram Gowtham Reddy",
"Abhinav Kumar",
"Saketh Bachu",
"Vineeth N. Balasubramanian",
"Amit Sharma"
] |
Poster
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently been used as experts to infer causal graphs, often by repeatedly applying a pairwise prompt that asks about the causal relationship of each variable pair. However, such experts, including human domain experts, cannot distinguish between direct and indirect effects given a pairwise prompt. Therefore, instead of the graph, we propose that causal order be used as a more stable output interface for utilizing expert knowledge. When querying a perfect expert with a pairwise prompt, we show that the inferred graph can have significant errors whereas the causal order is always correct. In practice, however, LLMs are imperfect experts and we find that pairwise prompts lead to multiple cycles and do not yield a valid order. Hence, we propose a prompting strategy that introduces an auxiliary variable for every variable pair and instructs the LLM to avoid cycles within this triplet. We show, both theoretically and empirically, that such a triplet prompt leads to fewer cycles than the pairwise prompt. Across multiple real-world graphs, the triplet prompt yields a more accurate order using both LLMs and human annotators as experts. By querying the expert with different auxiliary variables for the same variable pair, it also increases robustness---triplet method with much smaller models such as Phi-3 and Llama-3 8B outperforms a pairwise prompt with GPT-4. For practical usage, we show how the estimated causal order from the triplet method can be used to reduce error in downstream discovery and effect inference tasks.
|
Causal Order, Imperfect Experts, Causal Inference, LLMs
| null | 13,202 | null |
[
-0.022782230749726295,
-0.021991051733493805,
-0.025530191138386726,
0.03650236502289772,
0.026842966675758362,
0.009786820970475674,
0.051769327372312546,
0.011796746402978897,
-0.01834525354206562,
-0.019398340955376625,
-0.007477336097508669,
0.06413518637418747,
-0.05502980202436447,
-0.007434234954416752,
-0.008453914895653725,
0.041505973786115646,
0.03162520378828049,
-0.014466071501374245,
0.013723516836762428,
0.020367803052067757,
0.021792113780975342,
-0.02189561538398266,
0.00907325278967619,
0.03175784647464752,
0.04869333282113075,
0.0014392234152182937,
0.04065680503845215,
-0.01395820826292038,
-0.043031562119722366,
0.006684004794806242,
0.0597335621714592,
0.012286167591810226,
-0.002603312488645315,
-0.04194897040724754,
-0.005400441121309996,
0.03602353855967522,
-0.03466204181313515,
0.010033564642071724,
-0.01835249550640583,
0.033693574368953705,
-0.07449136674404144,
-0.007258732337504625,
-0.028796426951885223,
-0.002290576696395874,
-0.06481357663869858,
0.01791500858962536,
-0.10444821417331696,
0.04395383968949318,
0.035260725766420364,
-0.0381535179913044,
-0.11045821756124496,
0.021110260859131813,
0.02797422744333744,
0.002921542851254344,
0.0006799523252993822,
0.040002621710300446,
0.05484527722001076,
-0.09840217977762222,
0.01184527575969696,
-0.05876363068819046,
-0.04561961069703102,
0.02900359034538269,
0.01752777025103569,
-0.019982634112238884,
-0.008653889410197735,
-0.01657692715525627,
-0.0051393769681453705,
0.0573108084499836,
-0.06305354088544846,
-0.04906216263771057,
-0.046459075063467026,
-0.000036571731470758095,
-0.01997586525976658,
0.021741703152656555,
0.004646813031286001,
-0.016082212328910828,
0.014883200637996197,
0.010950006544589996,
0.04766814783215523,
0.029261555522680283,
-0.010998313315212727,
0.005543746519833803,
0.003803204046562314,
0.020449332892894745,
0.028140448033809662,
0.004378802143037319,
-0.005441590212285519,
-0.06640931963920593,
-0.05936552956700325,
0.012101306580007076,
-0.029117604717612267,
-0.057650864124298096,
-0.008707718923687935,
0.026379698887467384,
-0.018887938931584358,
-0.009481001645326614,
0.061179906129837036,
0.014414618723094463,
-0.026975300163030624,
-0.006760735530406237,
-0.0031493159476667643,
-0.04539789259433746,
0.013120212592184544,
0.031184019520878792,
-0.10128069669008255,
-0.03363819792866707,
-0.018241679295897484,
-0.05420203134417534,
0.0019765510223805904,
0.003439719323068857,
-0.024319810792803764,
-0.0006868384080007672,
0.006221265532076359,
0.013924225233495235,
-0.07025451213121414,
0.07905463874340057,
-0.01086570043116808,
0.03100627101957798,
0.022896258160471916,
0.02490815334022045,
0.03828401491045952,
0.021779213100671768,
0.0055974205024540424,
0.08601510524749756,
-0.03116586245596409,
0.028131259605288506,
0.028391588479280472,
0.003991665318608284,
-0.021290248259902,
-0.047455932945013046,
0.02436242066323757,
0.02644839696586132,
-0.005110437050461769,
-0.013558262959122658,
-0.005488235037773848,
-0.0031396348495036364,
0.030802512541413307,
0.0454837791621685,
0.028928259387612343,
0.029215114191174507,
0.02716841734945774,
-0.02754557877779007,
0.06880515813827515,
-0.053492337465286255,
0.06038554385304451,
-0.014901609160006046,
-0.02837245911359787,
-0.011599637567996979,
-0.02672727033495903,
0.013189568184316158,
0.024280114099383354,
0.005825120490044355,
0.03217775747179985,
-0.05455555394291878,
0.018192661926150322,
0.0666939988732338,
0.02752239815890789,
0.0052101765759289265,
-0.022165007889270782,
0.008440147154033184,
0.0277772918343544,
0.004271152429282665,
-0.015489581041038036,
0.022727619856595993,
0.005896610673516989,
-0.06164778023958206,
0.028293881565332413,
0.024880392476916313,
-0.07039839774370193,
-0.0005879402160644531,
-0.05123819038271904,
-0.03469448909163475,
0.06396832317113876,
-0.03647923097014427,
-0.0004971747985109687,
-0.01318741962313652,
0.060975123196840286,
-0.021478498354554176,
0.05047775059938431,
0.038672611117362976,
-0.06764478236436844,
0.024750420823693275,
-0.013254271820187569,
0.0046567595563828945,
0.014758545905351639,
-0.01312790997326374,
0.06914466619491577,
-0.031336769461631775,
0.010495181195437908,
0.04109499976038933,
-0.0709574744105339,
-0.021168317645788193,
0.02874026820063591,
-0.0007853548740968108,
0.07340580970048904,
0.01659579947590828,
0.0007503452361561358,
0.06770535558462143,
0.014432745985686779,
0.022433092817664146,
0.04388703778386116,
-0.01532419491559267,
0.03016662411391735,
-0.008248887956142426,
-0.0613943412899971,
0.01685798540711403,
0.024777105078101158,
-0.025246359407901764,
-0.05458864942193031,
0.03930516913533211,
-0.026834595948457718,
0.013740124180912971,
-0.011023025028407574,
0.0006282607209868729,
0.015139964409172535,
-0.004346176516264677,
-0.016465604305267334,
0.006948717869818211,
-0.005912721622735262,
-0.02851044572889805,
0.04334403574466705,
0.029803350567817688,
-0.005205655470490456,
0.01728489249944687,
-0.013185017742216587,
0.10657933354377747,
0.07221594452857971,
0.0016347431810572743,
0.013085871934890747,
0.040096573531627655,
0.022305455058813095,
0.007970222271978855,
0.019794972613453865,
-0.026535402983427048,
0.01679934188723564,
-0.012173058465123177,
-0.013789227232336998,
-0.025089973583817482,
0.04348365589976311,
-0.02693195454776287,
0.026462813839316368,
0.05474778264760971,
-0.04865352436900139,
0.07802588492631912,
-0.010678219608962536,
0.005568403284996748,
0.001907218131236732,
-0.0016826239880174398,
-0.06892924755811691,
0.0029783269856125116,
-0.011424926109611988,
0.010897337459027767,
0.02528000809252262,
0.0104362852871418,
-0.0008547349134460092,
-0.022746475413441658,
-0.016762537881731987,
0.003339374205097556,
0.06464345753192902,
0.046658631414175034,
0.01101576630026102,
0.0401993989944458,
-0.013213715516030788,
-0.05978904664516449,
-0.0023742448538541794,
-0.09732448309659958,
-0.026468252763152122,
-0.016704553738236427,
0.025738338008522987,
-0.03011859953403473,
0.0460328683257103,
-0.0487707182765007,
0.03920919820666313,
0.0050558471120893955,
-0.027258140966296196,
0.020713860169053078,
0.02853338047862053,
0.006584896706044674,
-0.03525388985872269,
-0.008806554600596428,
-0.001449591014534235,
0.03919074684381485,
-0.009758505038917065,
-0.008224457502365112,
-0.05351382866501808,
-0.05453084036707878,
-0.011715834029018879,
-0.0325632318854332,
-0.009623214602470398,
0.03477345034480095,
0.011285868473351002,
-0.001204000087454915,
-0.010763107798993587,
0.000018402450223220512,
0.03076022118330002,
0.037236716598272324,
0.030028896406292915,
0.007754291407763958,
-0.0008683123742230237,
0.04460568726062775,
-0.017199287191033363,
0.0409783273935318,
0.0018277966883033514,
0.021550055593252182,
-0.004851152189075947,
0.016545753926038742,
0.00046983148786239326,
0.028909597545862198,
-0.27480757236480713,
0.010935090482234955,
0.025107279419898987,
-0.02735164389014244,
0.043102338910102844,
-0.023046018555760384,
0.10234113037586212,
-0.02898493967950344,
-0.04675162211060524,
0.02726258523762226,
0.0259991642087698,
0.05897869914770126,
-0.005487459246069193,
0.04092938452959061,
0.03454259783029556,
0.06158159673213959,
-0.03734200820326805,
-0.04781484603881836,
0.010334272868931293,
0.06432519108057022,
0.009894034825265408,
-0.039214443415403366,
-0.061674319207668304,
0.024121137335896492,
-0.0034441135358065367,
0.02543112076818943,
-0.08791112154722214,
0.002683088416233659,
-0.036866482347249985,
-0.031142421066761017,
0.0016490328125655651,
-0.023485694080591202,
-0.01118931733071804,
0.039671748876571655,
0.007649024948477745,
-0.0019405438797548413,
0.05791888013482094,
0.00788264162838459,
0.01867324858903885,
0.014736700803041458,
-0.0034411598462611437,
-0.03882545605301857,
0.00706490920856595,
-0.0205179825425148,
0.042180441319942474,
0.015751322731375694,
-0.010581637732684612,
-0.007010520435869694,
0.0025980870705097914,
0.04772672429680824,
-0.015735160559415817,
-0.015426999889314175,
-0.0069059813395142555,
-0.007140963338315487,
0.011220135726034641,
-0.013507163152098656,
0.003639250760897994,
-0.02808551862835884,
-0.05755801126360893,
-0.005845754407346249,
0.006924400106072426,
-0.014990721829235554,
0.01148658525198698,
-0.050927795469760895,
0.009545478969812393,
-0.04154607281088829,
-0.05443830415606499,
-0.058577895164489746,
0.038698337972164154,
0.000959609227720648,
-0.018265359103679657,
0.0008605156908743083,
0.02681887149810791,
-0.11399777978658676,
-0.030947212129831314,
-0.0067045302130281925,
-0.00985332578420639,
-0.002156150294467807,
-0.000731895153876394,
0.004565034061670303,
-0.02040231041610241,
-0.01645410992205143,
-0.017408685758709908,
0.028504977002739906,
0.020668072625994682,
0.0041740695014595985,
0.014719221740961075,
-0.04033598303794861,
-0.033632200211286545,
-0.035768166184425354,
-0.006795023567974567,
0.00431889109313488,
0.018951743841171265,
0.03770754113793373,
0.05138930678367615,
0.03668065741658211,
0.016514398157596588,
0.057476889342069626,
0.06307928264141083,
-0.007333145011216402,
0.028476791456341743,
-0.08300978690385818,
-0.01275128684937954,
-0.02580355294048786,
-0.02626214362680912,
0.041940055787563324,
-0.053990717977285385,
-0.014104422181844711,
0.03215743601322174,
-0.03879282996058464,
-0.03117719665169716,
-0.010770118795335293,
0.02099667675793171,
-0.0031158914789557457,
-0.010466891340911388,
-0.022044165059924126,
-0.0011249538511037827,
0.016458434984087944,
0.019716277718544006,
-0.013483380898833275,
-0.04524439573287964,
0.021439768373966217,
-0.023591741919517517,
0.0007685250020585954,
-0.015036270953714848,
-0.009712106548249722,
-0.0008051326149143279,
-0.051982760429382324,
0.02575654536485672,
0.00986118707805872,
0.0067724669352173805,
0.030545048415660858,
0.022098058834671974,
0.025884754955768585,
0.03415723890066147,
-0.03301631659269333,
-0.012067392468452454,
-0.015985677018761635,
0.0023284032940864563,
-0.020928096026182175,
0.00030048706685192883,
-0.026251576840877533,
-0.0024579716846346855,
-0.006530097220093012,
0.043626800179481506,
-0.020998233929276466,
-0.013566097244620323,
-0.01998641900718212,
-0.010207620449364185,
-0.005598654970526695,
0.06764955073595047,
-0.0165229644626379,
-0.011407403275370598,
-0.012599070556461811,
0.013967148959636688,
-0.007486748043447733,
0.0442064143717289,
-0.005325889680534601,
0.0024974055122584105,
-0.07957827299833298,
0.04255719855427742,
-0.02785685658454895,
0.02295193448662758,
0.008288908749818802,
0.006268518045544624,
0.04496263712644577,
-0.03824634477496147,
0.012212605215609074,
0.002036146819591522,
-0.00031608829158358276,
0.015778927132487297,
-0.030316324904561043,
-0.04490511119365692,
0.007827519439160824,
-0.019273703917860985,
0.019175909459590912,
0.009072626940906048,
-0.038040030747652054,
-0.007113568484783173,
0.04702093452215195,
-0.006548971403390169,
-0.05003858357667923,
-0.004548904951661825,
0.011698109097778797,
0.07715343683958054,
0.011014198884367943,
0.01833619922399521,
-0.007365648169070482,
-0.03680271655321121,
0.032960306853055954,
-0.004309400450438261,
0.014942510984838009,
-0.010557407513260841,
-0.01407776027917862,
-0.04716634750366211,
-0.05101285129785538,
-0.006617806851863861,
0.0021503677126020193,
-0.013734753243625164,
0.007879978977143764,
-0.0032872820738703012,
-0.005439579952508211,
-0.04936729744076729,
-0.01719660684466362,
0.022521911188960075,
-0.07211446762084961,
-0.029080672189593315,
0.02158813364803791,
-0.01412892248481512,
0.0211308766156435,
-0.0431814007461071,
-0.0376737080514431,
-0.04412413388490677,
-0.01713956706225872,
0.010677896440029144,
-0.008309566415846348,
-0.01165993232280016,
-0.004509627353399992,
-0.0021423823200166225,
0.003693502163514495,
0.013051972724497318,
-0.023199278861284256,
0.019505128264427185,
-0.016404859721660614,
0.013777628540992737,
0.04277754947543144,
-0.03445173799991608,
-0.026323020458221436,
0.03479934111237526,
-0.04763500392436981,
0.014949369244277477,
-0.02861040085554123,
0.013288685120642185,
0.05363846570253372,
0.015909845009446144,
-0.004066739231348038,
-0.024093465879559517,
0.04462837055325508,
0.005048692692071199,
-0.033537618815898895,
-0.001999521628022194,
-0.031546320766210556,
-0.024645749479532242,
-0.004474419169127941,
0.03149726986885071,
0.034744005650281906,
0.0006041920860297978,
0.010337162762880325,
0.02332060970366001,
0.019918732345104218,
-0.004621830303221941,
0.035265784710645676,
-0.025899477303028107,
0.018010297790169716,
0.06414997577667236,
-0.020628107711672783,
-0.05251017212867737,
-0.07342322170734406,
-0.03642366826534271,
0.01998707838356495,
-0.01805221289396286,
0.050651781260967255,
-0.02680930681526661,
0.03952580317854881,
0.00983863603323698,
0.05317462608218193,
0.0009818210965022445,
-0.0010512609733268619,
0.04115245118737221,
-0.07651492953300476,
0.00735953776165843,
-0.07200124859809875,
0.025074684992432594,
0.04310230165719986,
-0.05489406734704971,
-0.027221716940402985,
0.007279053330421448,
-0.004949676804244518,
0.017510229721665382,
-0.017027223482728004,
-0.03055460751056671,
-0.028932981193065643,
-0.03750525787472725,
-0.00831530336290598,
0.03952561691403389,
-0.05314058065414429,
-0.034901201725006104,
-0.0044992100447416306,
-0.058382030576467514,
-0.015286670997738838,
-0.018710484728217125,
0.04707535728812218,
0.009161311201751232,
0.029731519520282745,
-0.007617129944264889,
0.013967911712825298,
0.0040210033766925335,
0.07573464512825012,
0.016077162697911263,
0.013723449781537056,
-0.0272210780531168,
0.04319215193390846,
0.030439358204603195,
0.03829456865787506,
-0.018206235021352768,
0.005562047008424997,
-0.032886356115341187,
-0.0556417852640152,
0.07417894154787064,
0.016278883442282677,
-0.001091910875402391,
-0.060107309371232986,
0.0865451991558075,
0.014400286599993706,
-0.05029325187206268,
-0.008988690562546253,
0.01397177018225193,
-0.04391827434301376,
-0.004234600812196732,
0.0003112324920948595,
-0.0036219940520823,
0.01522023044526577,
0.07643136382102966,
0.005408830475062132,
0.06980499625205994,
0.07347174733877182,
0.026346338912844658,
-0.006095229182392359,
-0.02049645595252514,
0.053938671946525574,
0.06049225851893425,
0.06200351193547249,
0.03465832769870758,
0.07810194045305252,
-0.032391928136348724,
-0.019793666899204254,
0.010905896313488483,
0.0032144838478416204,
0.007191993296146393,
-0.03237219527363777,
0.0427311547100544,
0.08320402354001999,
-0.012161296792328358,
0.06932923942804337,
-0.034548088908195496,
-0.01412141788750887,
0.04801314324140549,
0.024936135858297348,
0.010238188318908215,
0.058153800666332245,
0.019694088026881218,
0.02924622967839241,
-0.018538758158683777,
-0.030070777982473373,
-0.0191063042730093,
-0.03580723702907562,
0.012411216273903847,
-0.006901165004819632,
-0.02495284378528595,
0.0013074427843093872,
0.01987081952393055,
0.004879766143858433,
0.11299366503953934,
-0.0211440771818161,
-0.0162680521607399,
0.024783900007605553,
0.020062768831849098,
-0.009136518463492393,
0.06696252524852753,
0.022016773000359535,
-0.02175455540418625,
-0.019087068736553192,
-0.036908555775880814,
0.026239152997732162,
0.02683991566300392,
-0.017683541402220726,
0.048054955899715424,
-0.01723542809486389,
-0.020325390622019768,
0.02322055585682392,
0.009411263279616833,
-0.049581874161958694,
-0.08106495440006256,
-0.012028571218252182,
-0.07108796387910843,
-0.045393116772174835,
-0.037541862577199936,
0.03019755892455578,
-0.02366000972688198,
-0.026727963238954544,
0.02446010336279869,
-0.026747914031147957,
0.025230536237359047,
0.0233671423047781,
-0.07249698787927628,
-0.010334036312997341,
0.04522480070590973,
0.0007989583536982536,
-0.0035618303809314966,
0.024857303127646446,
0.015307433903217316,
-0.01857946440577507,
-0.019518250599503517,
-0.002687838627025485,
0.04383049160242081,
0.015482690185308456,
-0.005497546400874853,
-0.03547019883990288,
-0.08603154122829437,
-0.001903519849292934,
-0.029866604134440422,
-0.03755034878849983,
-0.08898909389972687,
0.02590465173125267,
-0.005454865749925375,
0.031094830483198166,
0.04634411633014679,
0.011562343686819077,
0.03662128746509552,
-0.03204646334052086,
0.0022142434027045965,
0.01400825660675764,
0.019612645730376244,
0.025622088462114334,
-0.03970656543970108,
0.06390494853258133,
0.04162543639540672,
-0.022907499223947525,
-0.0537167526781559,
0.022711124271154404,
-0.01308531779795885,
-0.028968941420316696,
-0.03413273021578789,
-0.03808770701289177,
-0.013935170136392117,
-0.1065298318862915,
-0.0034116965252906084,
0.019576426595449448,
-0.013086942955851555,
-0.032348863780498505,
-0.016522467136383057,
-0.03969072923064232,
-0.03738098964095116,
-0.003083806950598955,
-0.030394209548830986,
-0.005007964558899403,
-0.037628885358572006,
-0.041598666459321976,
-0.051305126398801804,
-0.003895894158631563,
-0.015417398884892464,
0.00574574014171958,
-0.06442530453205109,
-0.05177803337574005,
-0.0188884474337101,
0.007219030521810055,
0.003667527809739113,
-0.009267758578062057,
0.04976368322968483,
-0.03575515002012253
] |
384 |
Physics of Language Models: Part 2.2, How to Learn From Mistakes on Grade-School Math Problems
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=zpDGwcmMV4
|
[
"Tian Ye",
"Zicheng Xu",
"Yuanzhi Li",
"Zeyuan Allen-Zhu"
] |
Poster
|
Language models have demonstrated remarkable performance in solving reasoning tasks; however, even the strongest models still occasionally make reasoning mistakes. Recently, there has been active research aimed at improving reasoning accuracy, particularly by using pretrained language models to "self-correct'' their mistakes via multi-round prompting. In this paper, we follow this line of work but focus on understanding the usefulness of incorporating ``error-correction'' data directly into the pretraining stage. This data consists of erroneous solution steps immediately followed by their corrections. Using a synthetic math dataset, we show promising results: this type of pretrain data can help language models achieve higher reasoning accuracy directly (i.e., through simple auto-regression, without multi-round prompting) compared to pretraining on the same amount of error-free data. We also delve into many details, such as (1) how this approach differs from beam search, (2) how such data can be prepared, (3) whether masking is needed on the erroneous tokens, (4) the amount of error required, (5) whether such data can be deferred to the fine-tuning stage, and many others.
|
pretraining, language model, error correction, error detection
| null | 13,200 |
2408.16293
|
[
-0.014204099774360657,
0.010706483386456966,
-0.021317869424819946,
0.054304126650094986,
0.07216950505971909,
0.02908112108707428,
0.03906874731183052,
0.02009068988263607,
-0.03549305722117424,
-0.008689813315868378,
-0.019061332568526268,
0.04653683677315712,
-0.023258371278643608,
-0.004195686895400286,
-0.020411891862750053,
0.043902311474084854,
0.04517177492380142,
0.015113712288439274,
0.021559813991189003,
0.02825937047600746,
-0.011321001686155796,
-0.03881942108273506,
0.034206125885248184,
0.02954862080514431,
0.03459692373871803,
0.005360191687941551,
0.02757716178894043,
0.01109479833394289,
-0.0258099976927042,
-0.015313850715756416,
0.0365338958799839,
0.0005175273981876671,
0.007441429886966944,
-0.01394979190081358,
-0.009981305338442326,
-0.004035796504467726,
-0.036401886492967606,
-0.00014453681069426239,
0.018034802749753,
0.0014759815530851483,
-0.06644809991121292,
0.027603833004832268,
-0.013418016955256462,
-0.03615033999085426,
-0.07314039021730423,
0.009091830812394619,
-0.07965197414159775,
0.0018858524272218347,
0.008119650185108185,
-0.050398483872413635,
-0.11842889338731766,
0.04725264012813568,
0.036659322679042816,
-0.03837766870856285,
-0.020267177373170853,
0.0446317195892334,
0.03375319764018059,
-0.09276854991912842,
0.013455849140882492,
-0.02809869684278965,
-0.0166685339063406,
0.039204247295856476,
-0.031155243515968323,
-0.01352586317807436,
-0.00532670458778739,
-0.03496107459068298,
-0.015610625967383385,
0.040810950100421906,
-0.07402464747428894,
-0.043080028146505356,
-0.02782980166375637,
0.011320259422063828,
-0.012544522993266582,
0.006545518524944782,
-0.005343228112906218,
-0.02545783855021,
0.0045710280537605286,
0.04183977097272873,
0.05457017570734024,
-0.01793755404651165,
0.013072863221168518,
0.012973073869943619,
0.04442594572901726,
0.01869591325521469,
0.024202687665820122,
0.012077162973582745,
-0.02725406363606453,
-0.04697846993803978,
-0.043898992240428925,
0.05435118451714516,
0.011921858415007591,
-0.040622126311063766,
0.021300863474607468,
0.045445770025253296,
0.018787425011396408,
0.0392976738512516,
0.02780129201710224,
-0.00014092893979977816,
-0.009195118211209774,
0.001098251435905695,
-0.039873119443655014,
-0.06154515966773033,
0.05373939499258995,
0.036822907626628876,
-0.09604210406541824,
-0.00981989037245512,
-0.0009715401101857424,
-0.03079954907298088,
0.010747230611741543,
0.0010605001589283347,
-0.029691318050026894,
-0.005081131123006344,
0.017024241387844086,
-0.030468687415122986,
-0.11137311160564423,
0.04390116408467293,
0.01690475083887577,
0.03398388996720314,
-0.013256961479783058,
0.03574399650096893,
0.016808444634079933,
0.02565201185643673,
0.03734798729419708,
0.06006914749741554,
-0.027314668521285057,
0.042432527989149094,
0.009395708329975605,
0.04037841781973839,
-0.03299219533801079,
-0.023356163874268532,
-0.004868764895945787,
0.05866909399628639,
0.021548118442296982,
0.026351729407906532,
0.0005643972544930875,
-0.004502252675592899,
-0.011077545583248138,
-0.0024333293549716473,
0.018149856477975845,
0.038119781762361526,
0.027332652360200882,
0.024355867877602577,
0.06972398608922958,
-0.014057488180696964,
0.05608401820063591,
-0.0033754254691302776,
-0.04571525752544403,
0.007262466941028833,
-0.02793664112687111,
-0.009651726111769676,
0.005653977859765291,
-0.0035416781902313232,
0.000728177314158529,
-0.06240873783826828,
0.026242589578032494,
0.048850275576114655,
0.012726553715765476,
0.03659223020076752,
0.008372108452022076,
0.011405046097934246,
0.016102956607937813,
0.02975296974182129,
-0.014957612380385399,
-0.007855184376239777,
-0.02682480216026306,
-0.04679179936647415,
0.02987668849527836,
0.007878540083765984,
-0.06356455385684967,
0.019801540300250053,
-0.032602496445178986,
-0.048067279160022736,
0.08429798483848572,
-0.042986851185560226,
-0.021949492394924164,
-0.022520683705806732,
0.043348800390958786,
0.005029727704823017,
0.05851980298757553,
0.01976599730551243,
-0.07558565586805344,
0.03728676587343216,
-0.001329237362369895,
0.041140466928482056,
0.03418467566370964,
-0.028577037155628204,
0.09593264758586884,
-0.039337579160928726,
0.025819018483161926,
0.012983105145394802,
-0.07197255641222,
-0.033273495733737946,
0.03218662366271019,
-0.011766677722334862,
0.06884479522705078,
-0.013691609725356102,
-0.0054415203630924225,
0.03875203803181648,
0.02623673342168331,
0.06899090856313705,
0.055065300315618515,
0.005541007965803146,
0.056388478726148605,
-0.013998099602758884,
-0.017486106604337692,
0.005516496486961842,
0.042225826531648636,
-0.04777958616614342,
-0.03454264625906944,
0.0359930545091629,
-0.03626798465847969,
-0.015862323343753815,
0.023927360773086548,
-0.002837204374372959,
-0.01452952902764082,
0.019562192261219025,
0.009058545343577862,
-0.007619164884090424,
-0.0028895768336951733,
-0.048742640763521194,
0.027698181569576263,
0.005279268138110638,
-0.015483302995562553,
-0.01881752535700798,
-0.038468774408102036,
0.09326419234275818,
0.07405145466327667,
0.001241938560269773,
-0.011665199883282185,
0.010958795435726643,
0.014009715989232063,
0.030448561534285545,
0.014537245035171509,
-0.0043816338293254375,
0.018964949995279312,
-0.025865770876407623,
-0.016518978402018547,
-0.018677091225981712,
0.06607338786125183,
-0.04488392919301987,
-0.008321641944348812,
0.0768854096531868,
-0.040677521377801895,
0.07231246680021286,
-0.005237314384430647,
0.012092621996998787,
0.02980373613536358,
-0.013035877607762814,
-0.027354758232831955,
-0.03668810799717903,
-0.020645543932914734,
0.003899320727214217,
-0.0018707321723923087,
-0.005653636530041695,
-0.027970630675554276,
-0.03845897689461708,
-0.02376660145819187,
-0.03328220546245575,
0.0840681791305542,
0.04811760410666466,
0.011222049593925476,
0.019701309502124786,
0.02807738073170185,
-0.045052189379930496,
0.025921355932950974,
-0.10113413631916046,
-0.019109955057501793,
-0.006926568225026131,
0.020812802016735077,
0.0037165824323892593,
0.04745766520500183,
0.002713251393288374,
0.04179835692048073,
-0.0210247989743948,
-0.03088272549211979,
-0.008935665711760521,
0.047170739620923996,
-0.027654260396957397,
-0.06410861760377884,
-0.010720441117882729,
-0.015260959975421429,
0.0718262791633606,
-0.02611697092652321,
-0.02283732406795025,
0.0018869516206905246,
-0.030992643907666206,
-0.007248402573168278,
-0.05378156155347824,
-0.002378514502197504,
0.02370442822575569,
-0.012103531509637833,
0.011059194803237915,
-0.015831343829631805,
-0.021822884678840637,
0.056549832224845886,
0.07918600738048553,
0.02417418546974659,
-0.01002157386392355,
0.002488628728315234,
0.050988439470529556,
-0.023097388446331024,
0.04262128844857216,
-0.019885290414094925,
0.05405507981777191,
-0.0016820774180814624,
0.004347981419414282,
-0.009468580596148968,
0.0019443049095571041,
-0.27035602927207947,
-0.010221712291240692,
0.0033969467040151358,
-0.019992681220173836,
0.02063523605465889,
0.00453336164355278,
0.041921500116586685,
-0.02242443896830082,
-0.040476568043231964,
0.015996528789401054,
0.019365740939974785,
0.03294346481561661,
-0.00007075723260641098,
0.05269267410039902,
0.058120809495449066,
0.013878234662115574,
0.006973966024816036,
-0.03512187674641609,
-0.0027577076107263565,
0.03397229313850403,
0.00453903479501605,
-0.03408139944076538,
-0.03281870856881142,
0.0813489556312561,
0.01323089562356472,
0.04982925206422806,
-0.07856915891170502,
-0.017969734966754913,
-0.05956168845295906,
-0.0003701120149344206,
-0.00289025716483593,
-0.03342132270336151,
0.004662827122956514,
0.02079128846526146,
0.01624797284603119,
-0.005916053894907236,
0.025643831118941307,
-0.011854349635541439,
0.058866024017333984,
0.0380096398293972,
0.003209845395758748,
-0.03469668701291084,
0.00032575460500083864,
-0.006809933576732874,
0.05500300973653793,
0.01495927944779396,
-0.05648605525493622,
-0.02911876142024994,
-0.02335949055850506,
0.04985560476779938,
-0.01729283109307289,
-0.032068971544504166,
-0.005862036719918251,
-0.008432291448116302,
0.0063258009031414986,
-0.0302041694521904,
0.021954573690891266,
-0.012760089710354805,
-0.027057530358433723,
-0.0034683262929320335,
0.011667918413877487,
-0.017829105257987976,
-0.040962498635053635,
-0.04990512132644653,
-0.026736117899417877,
-0.05042170733213425,
-0.06455787271261215,
-0.0370170995593071,
0.06458106637001038,
0.033808495849370956,
-0.017422223463654518,
0.030153078958392143,
-0.00561173539608717,
-0.09147988259792328,
0.0013593187322840095,
0.007022217381745577,
-0.0008419346413575113,
-0.02107977494597435,
0.0008894175989553332,
0.05428757891058922,
-0.05978861823678017,
-0.0524003803730011,
-0.003962278366088867,
0.02045568823814392,
0.022148434072732925,
-0.006024605594575405,
0.005688508972525597,
-0.04626673087477684,
-0.007582628633826971,
-0.021878167986869812,
0.056813862174749374,
0.008419910445809364,
0.006544685922563076,
0.009125614538788795,
0.05058685317635536,
0.06215878576040268,
-0.0040067024528980255,
0.039971865713596344,
0.07160705327987671,
-0.009869102388620377,
-0.0010656042722985148,
-0.05481025576591492,
0.030476082116365433,
-0.04059996083378792,
-0.020097505301237106,
0.0028129981365054846,
-0.027908284217119217,
-0.01904994808137417,
0.020283518359065056,
-0.02312842197716236,
-0.032632362097501755,
-0.0016460118349641562,
-0.0025757593102753162,
0.012911715544760227,
-0.02066713757812977,
-0.021935585886240005,
0.011860431171953678,
0.040912263095378876,
-0.008565258234739304,
-0.015129114501178265,
-0.04190054535865784,
0.0354810394346714,
-0.0678366869688034,
0.002769406419247389,
-0.02825113758444786,
-0.034504927694797516,
0.017627254128456116,
-0.009344649501144886,
-0.02130233868956566,
-0.003884997684508562,
-0.006877705454826355,
0.02556704916059971,
-0.0057244994677603245,
0.03074837289750576,
0.040504928678274155,
-0.009252565912902355,
-0.016615228727459908,
-0.009749324060976505,
0.0019389800727367401,
-0.028092816472053528,
0.018247433006763458,
-0.007676507346332073,
0.030396392568945885,
0.02611667849123478,
0.0458618700504303,
0.009264047257602215,
-0.02589929662644863,
-0.00497443089261651,
-0.013155000284314156,
0.005890170577913523,
0.04046616330742836,
-0.045704908668994904,
0.03150253742933273,
-0.039710596203804016,
0.004805467557162046,
0.01524561271071434,
0.02971980720758438,
-0.008580014109611511,
0.014088254421949387,
-0.050401754677295685,
0.05826481431722641,
-0.010794296860694885,
-0.011149987578392029,
0.014644990675151348,
0.012047295458614826,
0.03480800241231918,
-0.04552609473466873,
0.027881726622581482,
0.02392006106674671,
0.023580998182296753,
0.03404373303055763,
-0.03273983672261238,
-0.014371462166309357,
0.004708097781985998,
-0.012998607009649277,
0.025937777012586594,
0.025666307657957077,
-0.0435008630156517,
-0.00495438277721405,
-0.0071349190548062325,
-0.004746736027300358,
-0.029146375134587288,
-0.018215643242001534,
0.024236809462308884,
0.06666639447212219,
0.01117829978466034,
0.02161908708512783,
-0.018533335998654366,
-0.03595423698425293,
0.010819347575306892,
-0.02034110203385353,
-0.013878650963306427,
0.021600905805826187,
-0.009090699255466461,
-0.05536241829395294,
-0.04707464203238487,
0.004326746799051762,
0.006289187353104353,
-0.0007256684475578368,
-0.004213929176330566,
-0.008214152418076992,
-0.015470750629901886,
-0.04898689314723015,
-0.006688323337584734,
0.023971175774931908,
-0.10202676802873611,
-0.020525505766272545,
0.0103187570348382,
0.031187305226922035,
0.030799731612205505,
-0.0216082613915205,
-0.02258380688726902,
-0.07759541273117065,
-0.04472525790333748,
0.007018107455223799,
-0.04446770250797272,
-0.02467595599591732,
-0.010022846050560474,
-0.007678704801946878,
-0.013086146675050259,
0.015216371975839138,
-0.013177859596908092,
-0.018867092207074165,
-0.04028591886162758,
0.004162615165114403,
0.01356305181980133,
-0.03722230717539787,
-0.007331508211791515,
0.021311547607183456,
-0.052836526185274124,
0.031483832746744156,
-0.03446008265018463,
0.019494839012622833,
0.05939309298992157,
0.02339135855436325,
-0.03441803529858589,
-0.05577951297163963,
0.03861258924007416,
0.01362936943769455,
-0.013977167196571827,
0.014380122534930706,
-0.03655825927853584,
-0.03569340333342552,
0.017919227480888367,
-0.004217635374516249,
0.02961801551282406,
0.023656729608774185,
-0.011961904354393482,
0.014599921181797981,
0.0058372728526592255,
0.03285432979464531,
0.0003013618115801364,
-0.035702481865882874,
0.0009494400001130998,
0.05714736133813858,
-0.008551987819373608,
-0.029135484248399734,
-0.07521255314350128,
-0.05170252546668053,
0.031938567757606506,
-0.038355324417352676,
0.019560346379876137,
-0.06168748065829277,
0.06329797208309174,
-0.0030252293217927217,
0.04427685961127281,
0.029605116695165634,
-0.01951223984360695,
0.046830449253320694,
-0.04396139830350876,
0.0028147934935986996,
-0.08894625306129456,
-0.02559245005249977,
0.06586315482854843,
-0.024612411856651306,
0.005961035378277302,
-0.018122058361768723,
-0.04024915769696236,
0.0395544059574604,
-0.031185731291770935,
-0.031552452594041824,
0.01344043854624033,
-0.005839679855853319,
-0.02137105166912079,
0.026604069396853447,
-0.04409850388765335,
-0.0288073793053627,
0.003620917908847332,
-0.04696846008300781,
-0.0035106437280774117,
-0.009412627667188644,
0.06039370968937874,
-0.03697618842124939,
0.015935765579342842,
-0.018206648528575897,
0.0064321658574044704,
0.0030874991789460182,
0.08741249144077301,
0.046434205025434494,
0.01907825656235218,
-0.03846166655421257,
0.07565046101808548,
0.04792572930455208,
0.01789660006761551,
0.005719194188714027,
0.016600124537944794,
-0.02301575243473053,
-0.051340531557798386,
0.05166634917259216,
-0.015784434974193573,
-0.026311520487070084,
-0.04217500239610672,
0.06734669953584671,
0.024636540561914444,
-0.04327882453799248,
-0.027694663032889366,
0.0206031184643507,
-0.025392651557922363,
-0.02080477774143219,
-0.00608071917667985,
0.006877925246953964,
-0.017483720555901527,
0.043986909091472626,
0.023306433111429214,
0.04174741357564926,
0.0644441694021225,
0.019673341885209084,
-0.015228619799017906,
-0.005935618653893471,
0.05914763733744621,
0.061523471027612686,
0.06659841537475586,
0.02240584045648575,
0.046583183109760284,
-0.04554907605051994,
-0.040800441056489944,
0.00881141610443592,
0.008201244287192822,
-0.006263319402933121,
-0.05028017982840538,
0.017827484756708145,
0.06622495502233505,
-0.0029551354236900806,
0.0251438207924366,
-0.023881319910287857,
-0.009995218366384506,
0.00822441279888153,
0.04431580379605293,
-0.0035526861902326345,
0.04021802544593811,
0.01571148820221424,
-0.002845817245543003,
-0.035843633115291595,
-0.04791894555091858,
-0.015754645690321922,
-0.02855834923684597,
0.0013377695577219129,
-0.00787702389061451,
-0.027759838849306107,
-0.0058601005002856255,
-0.030504480004310608,
0.04611247777938843,
0.11063046753406525,
-0.06115763261914253,
-0.03841983154416084,
0.05277414619922638,
0.026298293843865395,
0.005312170833349228,
0.061060771346092224,
0.0072980960831046104,
-0.04751614108681679,
-0.0006015975959599018,
-0.023279588669538498,
0.007306292187422514,
0.005136205814778805,
-0.013376167975366116,
0.01893136464059353,
-0.03839646652340889,
-0.05549248307943344,
0.039171937853097916,
0.006841994356364012,
-0.04120771959424019,
-0.07054989039897919,
-0.013682452030479908,
-0.01471538096666336,
-0.050323110073804855,
-0.008283265866339207,
0.02415422908961773,
-0.04293535277247429,
0.005111016798764467,
0.0030796080827713013,
-0.04080186039209366,
0.0029372782446444035,
0.008665992878377438,
-0.07310156524181366,
-0.007254826370626688,
0.043611373752355576,
-0.001333668828010559,
-0.025546763092279434,
0.041149482131004333,
0.010667204856872559,
-0.02818489447236061,
0.0029154233634471893,
0.034634314477443695,
-0.0068360487930476665,
0.021406223997473717,
0.037601932883262634,
0.003900492563843727,
-0.09076928347349167,
-0.011408449150621891,
0.014469565823674202,
-0.017821907997131348,
-0.06908081471920013,
0.015820102766156197,
-0.031458210200071335,
0.035457611083984375,
0.060474902391433716,
0.03944799676537514,
0.011393100954592228,
-0.015703024342656136,
-0.00601566256955266,
0.01176708098500967,
0.013521768152713776,
0.060224536806344986,
-0.03685325011610985,
0.06279956549406052,
0.024665623903274536,
-0.008493209257721901,
-0.04688834771513939,
0.001133445417508483,
0.005602639634162188,
-0.03401963785290718,
-0.020357264205813408,
-0.027615036815404892,
-0.011710266582667828,
-0.08752032369375229,
-0.027607714757323265,
0.0270729698240757,
-0.024086635559797287,
-0.05093645676970482,
0.009846169501543045,
-0.04864002391695976,
-0.008977542631328106,
0.01712775230407715,
0.006048157811164856,
-0.009699645452201366,
-0.0349409393966198,
-0.0242549329996109,
-0.05026386305689812,
0.00041770399548113346,
-0.008715799078345299,
-0.0005682106129825115,
-0.04351658746600151,
-0.03827054798603058,
0.015772374346852303,
-0.014993022195994854,
0.04304942116141319,
-0.0050911265425384045,
0.021355604752898216,
-0.012330951169133186
] |
385 |
Reasoning of Large Language Models over Knowledge Graphs with Super-Relations
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=rTCJ29pkuA
|
[
"Song Wang",
"Junhong Lin",
"Xiaojie Guo",
"Julian Shun",
"Jundong Li",
"Yada Zhu"
] |
Poster
|
While large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in processing and reasoning over knowledge graphs, current methods suffer from a high non-retrieval rate. This limitation reduces the accuracy of answering questions based on these graphs. Our analysis reveals that the combination of greedy search and forward reasoning is a major contributor to this issue. To overcome these challenges, we introduce the concept of super-relations, which enables both forward and backward reasoning by summarizing and connecting various relational paths within the graph. This holistic approach not only expands the search space, but also significantly improves retrieval efficiency. In this paper, we propose the ReKnoS framework, which aims to Reason over Knowledge Graphs with Super-Relations. Our framework’s key advantages include the inclusion of multiple relation paths through super-relations, enhanced forward and backward reasoning capabilities, and increased efficiency in querying LLMs. These enhancements collectively lead to a substantial improvement in the successful retrieval rate and overall reasoning performance. We conduct extensive experiments on a variety of datasets to evaluate ReKnoS, and the results demonstrate the superior performance of ReKnoS over existing state-of-the-art baselines, with an average accuracy gain of 2.92% across nine real-world datasets.
|
Knowledge Graphs, Large Language Models, Question Answering
| null | 13,191 | null |
[
-0.045773670077323914,
-0.010700063779950142,
0.019015740603208542,
0.0349191315472126,
0.05914054438471794,
0.0010455907322466373,
0.01595309190452099,
-0.0018139941385015845,
-0.009922010824084282,
0.00019343204621691257,
-0.020578784868121147,
0.05299744755029678,
-0.05046441778540611,
0.016479551792144775,
0.013960516080260277,
0.050258565694093704,
0.017073476687073708,
0.019672736525535583,
0.02444022335112095,
-0.000040914110286394134,
0.00893128477036953,
0.006935542915016413,
0.006408606190234423,
0.018372023478150368,
0.046874988824129105,
0.029882827773690224,
0.0035288557410240173,
0.007745339535176754,
-0.02324298396706581,
-0.004284617491066456,
0.03769489377737045,
-0.018531931564211845,
-0.000918088888283819,
-0.04635224863886833,
-0.01602466031908989,
-0.012285538017749786,
-0.04295619949698448,
0.016704270616173744,
0.004389814101159573,
-0.00834791362285614,
-0.04628988355398178,
0.035630688071250916,
0.001400601351633668,
0.005462219472974539,
-0.05110953375697136,
0.016068395227193832,
-0.12027816474437714,
0.03751913085579872,
0.018645258620381355,
-0.010865338146686554,
-0.11226202547550201,
0.03113955818116665,
-0.021454911679029465,
0.00236233021132648,
0.0036374360788613558,
0.041443582624197006,
0.03597237542271614,
-0.0831386148929596,
0.017948802560567856,
-0.020858807489275932,
-0.02876654826104641,
0.026085397228598595,
0.00021535591804422438,
-0.0013147311983630061,
-0.040256962180137634,
-0.04820789396762848,
-0.018622299656271935,
0.04335161671042442,
-0.0447331964969635,
-0.03639140725135803,
0.013140405528247356,
0.004748700186610222,
-0.018968744203448296,
0.03611323982477188,
0.020165055990219116,
-0.032868195325136185,
0.003420664928853512,
0.0015906842891126871,
0.049003321677446365,
0.019943201914429665,
-0.014481952413916588,
0.029766397550702095,
-0.01728462241590023,
0.03113802894949913,
0.03904184326529503,
0.012978233397006989,
-0.02934875339269638,
-0.05203275755047798,
-0.08290597051382065,
0.023030180484056473,
-0.0053231255151331425,
-0.06463080644607544,
0.006131690461188555,
0.022760342806577682,
-0.005450483411550522,
0.0074632675386965275,
0.03553984314203262,
0.024578547105193138,
0.017524942755699158,
-0.006935001350939274,
0.0001508866553194821,
-0.045427169650793076,
0.028736820444464684,
-0.00521943811327219,
-0.09359081089496613,
-0.02256443351507187,
-0.009093917906284332,
-0.006722243968397379,
0.022993246093392372,
-0.020563552156090736,
-0.026624945923686028,
0.0028671971522271633,
0.006556178908795118,
0.018916673958301544,
-0.055101245641708374,
0.0377531498670578,
-0.0004674744268413633,
0.00727763632312417,
0.007932719774544239,
0.02743491344153881,
0.03460443392395973,
0.0037430599331855774,
0.007777099497616291,
0.07815158367156982,
-0.012737293727695942,
0.006724954582750797,
-0.03094284050166607,
0.016696445643901825,
-0.03940813988447189,
-0.05192309617996216,
0.03230994939804077,
0.04534386843442917,
-0.004293079953640699,
0.001700241002254188,
-0.011223976500332355,
0.01587587222456932,
0.021507613360881805,
0.02270743064582348,
0.023873377591371536,
0.0048279226757586,
0.0361662358045578,
-0.014359070919454098,
0.04011484608054161,
-0.013606740161776543,
0.09181296825408936,
0.007370149251073599,
-0.032823897898197174,
0.014169919304549694,
-0.00970962829887867,
-0.022450441494584084,
0.005771716590970755,
0.004980357363820076,
-0.01447969675064087,
-0.055698201060295105,
0.03160048648715019,
0.0957065224647522,
0.006320183631032705,
-0.027767611667513847,
0.015271477401256561,
0.013236227445304394,
0.029259560629725456,
-0.0006471776869148016,
-0.052170153707265854,
0.009427681565284729,
-0.00478277588263154,
-0.09435246139764786,
0.005426693242043257,
0.03158603608608246,
-0.06583680957555771,
0.03314311429858208,
-0.015676619485020638,
-0.05964306741952896,
0.06361978501081467,
-0.05916184186935425,
-0.03583459183573723,
-0.0005161172593943775,
0.07518330216407776,
-0.0029587557073682547,
0.05628129094839096,
0.009018776938319206,
-0.05468098446726799,
0.01998627930879593,
-0.028043614700436592,
-0.030505642294883728,
-0.011322999373078346,
0.014288382604718208,
0.07930118590593338,
-0.019098075106739998,
0.01765168458223343,
-0.0014581308932974935,
-0.10157624632120132,
-0.034625086933374405,
0.024670153856277466,
0.0036380779929459095,
0.06088554859161377,
0.006756606511771679,
0.012833815068006516,
0.058143194764852524,
-0.02956978790462017,
0.033678263425827026,
0.06672292947769165,
0.012122463434934616,
0.046973660588264465,
-0.02776525914669037,
-0.023333702236413956,
0.031887248158454895,
0.0179311353713274,
-0.06623677909374237,
-0.02847084030508995,
0.03316153585910797,
-0.010233694687485695,
0.0003301754186395556,
0.017244333401322365,
-0.05205604434013367,
-0.025834113359451294,
-0.005161879118531942,
-0.0005070469342172146,
-0.016067419201135635,
0.02765522338449955,
-0.032071515917778015,
0.08369853347539902,
0.005905484780669212,
0.00020628474885597825,
0.008539959788322449,
-0.02805790863931179,
0.08398963510990143,
0.07369888573884964,
0.016856711357831955,
-0.01263605896383524,
0.03968076407909393,
0.03426076099276543,
0.03330438584089279,
0.028534943237900734,
-0.022994613274931908,
0.03450794890522957,
-0.05217496678233147,
0.0032727844081819057,
-0.03893696516752243,
0.04140663892030716,
-0.03320033475756645,
-0.010664581321179867,
0.05992724746465683,
-0.030564557760953903,
0.055943481624126434,
-0.0026703071780502796,
-0.00009624605445424095,
0.04331226274371147,
0.03075464814901352,
-0.0064568049274384975,
-0.01029069721698761,
-0.009224887937307358,
0.007266240194439888,
0.007869924418628216,
-0.004506130702793598,
0.01824047602713108,
-0.007270416244864464,
0.0233173705637455,
-0.018078451976180077,
0.04848117753863335,
0.059443190693855286,
0.020953621715307236,
-0.0035420365165919065,
0.010636293329298496,
-0.045751508325338364,
-0.007282900158315897,
-0.0936625525355339,
-0.030743146315217018,
-0.030939549207687378,
0.024627598002552986,
0.012868037447333336,
0.014716950245201588,
-0.02532230131328106,
0.07433273643255234,
-0.005746211390942335,
-0.023260533809661865,
0.02904072217643261,
0.01826576143503189,
-0.011322252452373505,
-0.03504335880279541,
-0.02054555155336857,
-0.008358792401850224,
0.042512357234954834,
-0.044233500957489014,
-0.05493583530187607,
-0.03371412679553032,
-0.042978089302778244,
0.026437466964125633,
-0.03134479746222496,
0.023181429132819176,
0.016766918823122978,
0.03403845056891441,
0.01417165994644165,
-0.0445311963558197,
-0.011423845775425434,
0.07227795571088791,
0.04449048638343811,
0.0522332638502121,
-0.008674121461808681,
-0.0029682451859116554,
0.03933942690491676,
-0.054876573383808136,
0.011569440364837646,
0.009774770587682724,
0.049778569489717484,
-0.0008073131903074682,
-0.006518067326396704,
-0.0071380906738340855,
-0.004021500702947378,
-0.2527698278427124,
0.005581968929618597,
-0.015108789317309856,
-0.03452632576227188,
0.04376182705163956,
-0.017570562660694122,
0.062495093792676926,
-0.05562836304306984,
-0.043167948722839355,
-0.001513939700089395,
0.05083565413951874,
0.02936318702995777,
0.009557651355862617,
0.040914151817560196,
0.04843577742576599,
0.0494135245680809,
-0.0229802168905735,
-0.031882163137197495,
-0.02727978676557541,
0.028743572533130646,
0.013171094469726086,
-0.05893123522400856,
-0.053254351019859314,
0.05318952724337578,
0.00004352541145635769,
0.03311491757631302,
-0.10560660809278488,
-0.013435534201562405,
-0.03995615616440773,
-0.03246466815471649,
0.019663143903017044,
-0.01425615232437849,
-0.019867420196533203,
0.026896916329860687,
-0.02011920139193535,
0.024193258956074715,
0.04831480607390404,
-0.01534680463373661,
0.02785293012857437,
0.0015969877131283283,
0.0033301457297056913,
-0.03869045525789261,
-0.024069659411907196,
-0.007225521374493837,
0.0481390655040741,
-0.003468529786914587,
-0.05727458745241165,
-0.019718416035175323,
-0.007045314647257328,
0.04139818251132965,
-0.03725426644086838,
-0.01691928133368492,
-0.02267465367913246,
-0.012927589938044548,
-0.0007078334456309676,
-0.05047597363591194,
0.024281078949570656,
-0.021661780774593353,
-0.0355178602039814,
-0.023444516584277153,
0.0363069586455822,
-0.05308295413851738,
-0.001628402154892683,
-0.05296488478779793,
-0.04001959040760994,
-0.027139315381646156,
-0.049756672233343124,
-0.04115772619843483,
0.008302624337375164,
0.01289772056043148,
-0.054304108023643494,
0.038461022078990936,
-0.012989001348614693,
-0.08695337176322937,
-0.03617257997393608,
-0.0006737564690411091,
-0.02237238548696041,
-0.023026663810014725,
0.036084480583667755,
0.017239566892385483,
-0.04640806466341019,
-0.05279374122619629,
-0.050631724298000336,
0.028493449091911316,
0.02268744818866253,
0.00448260735720396,
0.02847515046596527,
-0.05685259401798248,
-0.021754514425992966,
-0.01868656650185585,
0.0027912845835089684,
0.005688469856977463,
-0.014800184406340122,
0.02442735992372036,
0.03779178485274315,
0.032070089131593704,
0.014491541311144829,
0.05318276211619377,
0.03595734387636185,
0.009417667984962463,
0.027716180309653282,
-0.05325854942202568,
0.007286752574145794,
-0.010051106102764606,
-0.021084172651171684,
0.007082405034452677,
-0.047419771552085876,
-0.008193210698664188,
0.019133178517222404,
-0.019396068528294563,
-0.04656163603067398,
-0.012720214203000069,
0.014459812082350254,
-0.019044924527406693,
-0.03390338271856308,
-0.020073236897587776,
-0.018116163089871407,
0.05051518604159355,
0.03177409991621971,
-0.006028575357049704,
-0.04309481754899025,
0.055308081209659576,
-0.01517687551677227,
0.007587879430502653,
-0.037493281066417694,
-0.026774289086461067,
0.004831122234463692,
-0.037936169654130936,
0.0037458515726029873,
0.02019800804555416,
-0.006519704591482878,
0.01594368927180767,
-0.0234188511967659,
-0.007601198274642229,
0.054582636803388596,
-0.03711323067545891,
0.005983742419630289,
-0.01345062255859375,
0.010199468582868576,
-0.005873440764844418,
-0.029730185866355896,
-0.014341373927891254,
0.003517411183565855,
0.03892630711197853,
0.008797320537269115,
0.014450681395828724,
0.021234752610325813,
0.017956223338842392,
0.0435289591550827,
0.033845312893390656,
0.0044290898367762566,
-0.03372364118695259,
0.004780803341418505,
-0.03259892761707306,
0.012388141825795174,
0.001116211642511189,
0.056258268654346466,
-0.015093301422894001,
0.028000425547361374,
-0.05776054784655571,
0.03484388813376427,
-0.03761781007051468,
0.021598175168037415,
-0.01342394296079874,
0.012187675572931767,
0.04080630838871002,
-0.04010898247361183,
0.007577074225991964,
0.0258681308478117,
0.008800158277153969,
0.02268020249903202,
-0.013503453694283962,
-0.006550345104187727,
0.012780830264091492,
-0.017598038539290428,
0.03906626254320145,
-0.004968496970832348,
0.000524048344232142,
-0.01122326496988535,
0.03282889723777771,
-0.002014729892835021,
-0.019005561247467995,
-0.015433773398399353,
0.006620276719331741,
0.062487173825502396,
0.03540680930018425,
0.007939115166664124,
-0.0077694132924079895,
-0.062072016298770905,
0.025438951328396797,
0.005617125425487757,
0.01188491191715002,
-0.011538246646523476,
-0.03515436872839928,
-0.03263550624251366,
-0.0631936565041542,
0.028825897723436356,
0.01258228998631239,
-0.01782325655221939,
0.019961006939411163,
-0.016364658251404762,
-0.02223956398665905,
-0.06606388092041016,
-0.003880840726196766,
0.024553004652261734,
-0.05336717516183853,
-0.003608117811381817,
0.009318282827734947,
0.031256794929504395,
0.0035650143399834633,
-0.036035992205142975,
-0.02269977517426014,
-0.06337685883045197,
-0.020987262949347496,
0.03892778605222702,
-0.012434041127562523,
0.004577143583446741,
0.0001815271971281618,
0.0026359527837485075,
0.010814955458045006,
0.029607417061924934,
-0.004326800350099802,
-0.002092620125040412,
-0.031031768769025803,
0.031096164137125015,
0.08293436467647552,
-0.02593493089079857,
-0.02016710303723812,
-0.003521149978041649,
-0.04913469776511192,
0.030454006046056747,
-0.06464404612779617,
0.015433409251272678,
0.04187720641493797,
0.0015697367489337921,
0.038832344114780426,
-0.03490666672587395,
0.045819129794836044,
0.04446989297866821,
-0.02737412229180336,
0.03461124002933502,
-0.013623609207570553,
0.006245709955692291,
-0.0117479357868433,
-0.006888220552355051,
0.03533471003174782,
0.04168825224041939,
0.01848480850458145,
0.00926973670721054,
0.0021039419807493687,
0.005580788478255272,
-0.0015629930421710014,
-0.03984714299440384,
0.007597720716148615,
0.05197719857096672,
-0.030395226553082466,
-0.05311466380953789,
-0.07205785065889359,
-0.057486750185489655,
0.010133225470781326,
-0.02744029089808464,
0.0079626040533185,
-0.015509795397520065,
0.060906436294317245,
0.033784352242946625,
0.04640892893075943,
-0.008856517262756824,
0.013613482005894184,
0.028826361522078514,
-0.03250584006309509,
0.027331611141562462,
-0.06453457474708557,
-0.007345416583120823,
0.05688260868191719,
-0.03211541101336479,
-0.0042845760472118855,
-0.02089739218354225,
-0.060969796031713486,
0.008466117084026337,
-0.001660854322835803,
-0.03443419933319092,
-0.009098943322896957,
-0.01402391865849495,
0.0025644260458648205,
0.049421656876802444,
-0.03256046772003174,
-0.03729894757270813,
0.005742466077208519,
-0.03639264032244682,
-0.015929922461509705,
-0.029648611322045326,
0.06008332222700119,
-0.030901215970516205,
0.036949522793293,
-0.007123646326363087,
-0.005193785298615694,
0.017875203862786293,
0.07024931162595749,
0.016181305050849915,
0.04478306323289871,
0.000984400394372642,
0.025731272995471954,
0.04877029359340668,
0.03772861137986183,
-0.003254298120737076,
0.030615169554948807,
-0.027858791872859,
-0.06486602127552032,
0.10311279445886612,
0.02197454124689102,
0.010840287432074547,
-0.05879037454724312,
0.09028355032205582,
0.02256975695490837,
-0.047378476709127426,
-0.014498583041131496,
0.017187917605042458,
-0.05675257742404938,
-0.013469078578054905,
-0.006985723972320557,
-0.00047968910075724125,
-0.007256876677274704,
0.06592662632465363,
0.011816437356173992,
0.05257011577486992,
0.059165362268686295,
-0.00035454577300697565,
-0.008146029897034168,
-0.030371248722076416,
0.07345602661371231,
0.03417934104800224,
0.07517565786838531,
0.008616672828793526,
0.06929387152194977,
-0.03132633492350578,
-0.03063635714352131,
0.03497589752078056,
0.03897165507078171,
-0.00975444819778204,
-0.036907996982336044,
0.012737823650240898,
0.049154896289110184,
-0.04228349030017853,
0.062114160507917404,
-0.03023006208240986,
0.002006860915571451,
0.05490913242101669,
-0.009149523451924324,
0.0049593085423111916,
0.07646995782852173,
0.018355824053287506,
0.033791862428188324,
-0.05581008270382881,
-0.006115608382970095,
-0.003609092440456152,
-0.02281394973397255,
-0.00789678655564785,
-0.009998247027397156,
-0.0067902738228440285,
-0.0033209400717169046,
0.015347962267696857,
0.05064156651496887,
0.1322590559720993,
-0.057274799793958664,
-0.024520309641957283,
0.009212732315063477,
0.008268647827208042,
0.015466876327991486,
0.05916227027773857,
0.020607447251677513,
-0.03337863087654114,
-0.00581453088670969,
-0.05004965141415596,
-0.009134208783507347,
-0.02043810859322548,
-0.017020482569932938,
0.02225213497877121,
-0.027321727946400642,
-0.06077655032277107,
0.022553354501724243,
0.017490845173597336,
-0.04767123982310295,
-0.056308530271053314,
-0.03101513348519802,
-0.02644062601029873,
-0.054517000913619995,
-0.03543703258037567,
0.00972664263099432,
-0.0080826785415411,
0.00404028594493866,
0.006377954501658678,
-0.04543085768818855,
-0.022949302569031715,
0.0069228424690663815,
-0.04846935719251633,
0.017581699416041374,
0.03880104050040245,
0.01912841387093067,
-0.035225432366132736,
0.0709940493106842,
0.011806334368884563,
-0.038096990436315536,
0.0027756907511502504,
0.04894639179110527,
0.05265863239765167,
-0.003287843195721507,
0.00961187481880188,
-0.04181470721960068,
-0.09075784683227539,
-0.008729437366127968,
0.0005638230941258371,
-0.04575983062386513,
-0.06386539340019226,
-0.007210472598671913,
-0.00012233780580572784,
0.023386597633361816,
0.04204151779413223,
0.023728441447019577,
0.02200494147837162,
-0.007230381015688181,
0.006684691179543734,
0.031551141291856766,
0.017672160640358925,
0.03120322898030281,
-0.027834996581077576,
0.07006289064884186,
0.04449722543358803,
-0.009900441393256187,
-0.037051763385534286,
0.0025515391025692225,
-0.004767512436956167,
-0.02537301369011402,
-0.02133561111986637,
-0.020934389904141426,
-0.02427666075527668,
-0.09125103056430817,
-0.040682945400476456,
0.002240280155092478,
-0.02941768802702427,
-0.05452067777514458,
-0.021363336592912674,
-0.014561113901436329,
-0.012589562684297562,
0.02974710613489151,
-0.03813444450497627,
0.018565356731414795,
-0.015037162229418755,
-0.03586185723543167,
-0.06278068572282791,
-0.004150634631514549,
-0.011937171220779419,
0.005937530193477869,
-0.035923589020967484,
-0.039974700659513474,
-0.0071290344931185246,
0.006350290961563587,
0.05554765835404396,
-0.02292637899518013,
0.016597772017121315,
-0.03186317905783653
] |
386 |
Physics of Language Models: Part 2.1, Grade-School Math and the Hidden Reasoning Process
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Tn5B6Udq3E
|
[
"Tian Ye",
"Zicheng Xu",
"Yuanzhi Li",
"Zeyuan Allen-Zhu"
] |
Poster
|
Recent advances in language models have demonstrated their capability to solve mathematical reasoning problems, achieving near-perfect accuracy on grade-school level math benchmarks like GSM8K. In this paper, we formally study how language models solve these problems. We design a series of controlled experiments to address several fundamental questions: (1) Can language models truly develop reasoning skills, or do they simply memorize templates? (2) What is the model's hidden (mental) reasoning process? (3) Do models solve math questions using skills similar to or different from humans? (4) Do models trained on GSM8K-like datasets develop reasoning skills beyond those necessary for solving GSM8K problems? (5) What mental process causes models to make reasoning mistakes? (6) How large or deep must a model be to effectively solve GSM8K-level math questions?
Our study uncovers many hidden mechanisms by which language models solve mathematical questions, providing insights that extend beyond current understandings of LLMs.
|
linear probing, language model, grade math problems, logic following, reasoning
|
Probing reveals that LLMs develop some "level-2" reasoning skill beyond Humans on solving grade-school level math problems
| 13,188 |
2407.20311
|
[
-0.02253885008394718,
0.013587095774710178,
-0.021906951442360878,
0.050104912370443344,
0.0678105354309082,
0.004540503025054932,
0.03353587165474892,
0.011686908081173897,
-0.04064592719078064,
-0.004798027686774731,
-0.015725145116448402,
0.03680217266082764,
-0.016627857461571693,
0.0065070753917098045,
-0.025023916736245155,
0.07434573769569397,
0.03623485565185547,
0.016793731600046158,
0.024394189938902855,
0.0031143929809331894,
-0.01581324078142643,
-0.018911119550466537,
0.033441945910453796,
0.023993903771042824,
0.03752732276916504,
0.00967459473758936,
0.028802355751395226,
0.01878913678228855,
-0.020205475389957428,
-0.012197944335639477,
0.04595723748207092,
-0.01574046164751053,
0.013016101904213428,
-0.015459486283361912,
-0.022880451753735542,
0.00040965533116832376,
-0.051203653216362,
0.017063243314623833,
0.015248904936015606,
-0.004614753648638725,
-0.038501422852277756,
0.040252283215522766,
-0.016838790848851204,
-0.01948678307235241,
-0.07805342227220535,
0.004854015074670315,
-0.0834694355726242,
0.024140402674674988,
0.002391508314758539,
-0.026563165709376335,
-0.1138286143541336,
0.053471360355615616,
0.008217278867959976,
-0.012636840343475342,
-0.00697670504450798,
0.04233651980757713,
0.026082366704940796,
-0.09527819603681564,
0.015538905747234821,
-0.04410339891910553,
0.00408935034647584,
0.03079594112932682,
-0.03289176896214485,
-0.022585617378354073,
-0.02993934415280819,
-0.03705933690071106,
-0.016665641218423843,
0.022507140412926674,
-0.07705803960561752,
-0.03280932083725929,
-0.026393622159957886,
0.004709834698587656,
-0.0032719115260988474,
-0.009848357178270817,
-0.01993834599852562,
-0.03264496847987175,
0.009756762534379959,
0.05694642663002014,
0.034228209406137466,
-0.014468099921941757,
-0.02110608108341694,
0.01480152364820242,
0.045145709067583084,
0.027337439358234406,
0.021569915115833282,
0.017778489738702774,
-0.019493497908115387,
-0.030508657917380333,
-0.05812878534197807,
0.05396433547139168,
0.00584732461720705,
-0.04186267405748367,
0.0015043035382404923,
0.03387451171875,
0.032635148614645004,
0.02778211049735546,
0.015290234237909317,
-0.0009565025102347136,
0.0021443176083266735,
0.014622312039136887,
-0.01812322810292244,
-0.06260981410741806,
0.06127917766571045,
0.0174080953001976,
-0.08821327239274979,
-0.015229630284011364,
0.015087678097188473,
-0.05359775573015213,
-0.0031821371521800756,
-0.0002560097782406956,
-0.03319540247321129,
-0.012232834473252296,
-0.01846982352435589,
-0.027534784749150276,
-0.08344318717718124,
0.057355452328920364,
0.020681845024228096,
0.03763348236680031,
-0.02210332825779915,
0.04227618873119354,
0.034379225224256516,
0.022222300991415977,
0.01796046644449234,
0.05621945112943649,
-0.007289806380867958,
0.0390150286257267,
-0.0009779944084584713,
0.02000286988914013,
-0.0365663506090641,
-0.024829423055052757,
0.024772386997938156,
0.05383814498782158,
0.01766006276011467,
0.014765224419534206,
0.011294130235910416,
-0.014314833097159863,
0.012476859614253044,
-0.0026917161885648966,
0.006563474424183369,
0.033698197454214096,
0.026549220085144043,
0.021194342523813248,
0.07349278032779694,
-0.027202997356653214,
0.0508725643157959,
-0.0062113418243825436,
-0.019743578508496284,
-0.009886927902698517,
-0.012746860273182392,
-0.02996704913675785,
-0.0023012671153992414,
-0.00832122378051281,
0.014420568011701107,
-0.06538268178701401,
0.03711184859275818,
0.03981512412428856,
0.009347078390419483,
0.018746811896562576,
0.021551167592406273,
-0.0035519185476005077,
-0.003960657864809036,
0.006528180558234453,
-0.015250599943101406,
0.007283997721970081,
-0.004834500141441822,
-0.03944220021367073,
0.04276318475604057,
0.045171335339546204,
-0.061653200536966324,
0.011387942358851433,
-0.04626745358109474,
-0.05109810084104538,
0.0752740353345871,
-0.028283772990107536,
-0.01847689598798752,
-0.009927892126142979,
0.04943371191620827,
0.01021632645279169,
0.057717230170965195,
0.0011461710091680288,
-0.07683271169662476,
0.0184337068349123,
-0.01986863650381565,
0.022809118032455444,
0.01247759535908699,
-0.03553832322359085,
0.09621888399124146,
-0.034763507544994354,
0.004482382442802191,
0.011846330948174,
-0.06772349029779434,
-0.027214104309678078,
0.04917195811867714,
0.004929575137794018,
0.08775360137224197,
0.004275719169527292,
-0.0004992156755179167,
0.02869260497391224,
0.029919328168034554,
0.07828514277935028,
0.054221298545598984,
-0.00017145201854873449,
0.05699441581964493,
0.005358184687793255,
-0.017298102378845215,
0.011392790824174881,
0.0473642535507679,
-0.04845559224486351,
-0.03852579742670059,
0.027296673506498337,
-0.03306223079562187,
-0.018136005848646164,
0.02685624733567238,
-0.03594549745321274,
-0.010350236669182777,
-0.0005903976270928979,
0.003623121650889516,
-0.0197390578687191,
0.02141825668513775,
-0.04373561590909958,
0.011315799318253994,
-0.0006209760904312134,
0.0043480489403009415,
-0.019661085680127144,
-0.044892776757478714,
0.08628355711698532,
0.07386225461959839,
0.0031366716139018536,
-0.011486435309052467,
0.049024078994989395,
0.00699874572455883,
0.015765881165862083,
0.010674462653696537,
-0.020765405148267746,
0.020466145128011703,
-0.03581590950489044,
-0.02414955385029316,
-0.029581695795059204,
0.05905500426888466,
-0.038507379591464996,
0.004581436514854431,
0.08610344678163528,
-0.01664023846387863,
0.07077743858098984,
-0.008503719232976437,
0.024875449016690254,
0.028867308050394058,
-0.007493101060390472,
-0.0279831625521183,
-0.020329944789409637,
-0.029801050201058388,
0.0027314028702676296,
0.0002493977372068912,
0.0038570468313992023,
-0.00959464255720377,
-0.04904555156826973,
-0.016092663630843163,
-0.02765548788011074,
0.08190895617008209,
0.04137619584798813,
0.012861724011600018,
0.02714509889483452,
0.014622434973716736,
-0.029589738696813583,
-0.008481298573315144,
-0.10490251332521439,
-0.003113359911367297,
-0.01830730400979519,
0.03026476316154003,
0.01796669512987137,
0.051309071481227875,
-0.005381057504564524,
0.03495403379201889,
-0.019744621589779854,
-0.0287455003708601,
0.001490215421654284,
0.024211755022406578,
-0.038891155272722244,
-0.0640178695321083,
-0.02020893059670925,
-0.00809556059539318,
0.08419615775346756,
-0.021951060742139816,
-0.036520879715681076,
-0.00028123336960561574,
-0.025594562292099,
0.007995383813977242,
-0.06402461975812912,
-0.00044506299309432507,
0.028274621814489365,
-0.0032096118666231632,
-0.008828823454678059,
-0.014900324866175652,
-0.004766582511365414,
0.05045287683606148,
0.05603568255901337,
0.02010520175099373,
-0.03288837894797325,
0.0126497196033597,
0.05037527158856392,
-0.03373805060982704,
0.03565917909145355,
-0.03222006931900978,
0.04845999553799629,
-0.015836719423532486,
0.00011002780956914648,
0.0013786416966468096,
0.0006779413088224828,
-0.30695584416389465,
0.002356630517169833,
-0.006537659093737602,
-0.034504905343055725,
0.004082710947841406,
0.0013473373837769032,
0.04595854878425598,
-0.01760127581655979,
-0.042209453880786896,
0.02487732283771038,
0.019154857844114304,
0.021170610561966896,
-0.003038279013708234,
0.05046776682138443,
0.038734957575798035,
0.002822133246809244,
-0.0023469228763133287,
-0.045261599123477936,
-0.0018715769983828068,
0.026749184355139732,
-0.001369836856611073,
-0.04217015206813812,
-0.03231579437851906,
0.07854343205690384,
0.012007581070065498,
0.05234536528587341,
-0.06747879087924957,
-0.015870127826929092,
-0.05263976380228996,
-0.005930024199187756,
-0.0023118185345083475,
-0.04187794402241707,
0.0032816878519952297,
0.029490431770682335,
0.009549072943627834,
-0.0009360022959299386,
0.03984583914279938,
-0.0010150185553357005,
0.03308921307325363,
0.05873912200331688,
0.016998887062072754,
-0.02848180942237377,
-0.01634966768324375,
-0.01606261357665062,
0.04586583375930786,
0.012837446294724941,
-0.04177019000053406,
-0.028741421177983284,
-0.01904245838522911,
0.046126917004585266,
-0.015560758300125599,
-0.026895519345998764,
-0.006054644472897053,
-0.010143771767616272,
-0.008319524116814137,
0.011303376406431198,
0.006634147837758064,
-0.022774342447519302,
-0.03884144872426987,
-0.013738637790083885,
0.03195534646511078,
-0.017083102837204933,
-0.03794455900788307,
-0.06325189024209976,
-0.01695047691464424,
-0.036685820668935776,
-0.05705414339900017,
-0.03871569782495499,
0.05595344677567482,
0.03602047637104988,
-0.02830176241695881,
0.006188724655658007,
-0.011161066591739655,
-0.08858676254749298,
-0.023923370987176895,
0.012232519686222076,
-0.009146606549620628,
-0.029746929183602333,
0.023277727887034416,
0.044840529561042786,
-0.04884401336312294,
-0.03796997666358948,
-0.01026866678148508,
0.03404347598552704,
0.010569709353148937,
-0.006250352133065462,
-0.016589967533946037,
-0.03778796270489693,
-0.01825191080570221,
-0.028967756778001785,
0.062947578728199,
0.014019947499036789,
0.00906000193208456,
0.02617456205189228,
0.05749300867319107,
0.05224158242344856,
0.011909070424735546,
0.017064889892935753,
0.05879533290863037,
0.004805073142051697,
0.013216321356594563,
-0.05721521005034447,
0.027515185996890068,
-0.008550766855478287,
-0.027858110144734383,
-0.007178287487477064,
-0.04054009169340134,
-0.02287360094487667,
0.032993119210004807,
-0.03280532732605934,
-0.03789704665541649,
-0.013659194111824036,
-0.02385624870657921,
0.007574018556624651,
-0.03783746063709259,
-0.0024624729994684458,
0.009779914282262325,
0.04143121838569641,
0.00846006628125906,
-0.023969344794750214,
-0.03894249349832535,
0.041796308010816574,
-0.058384865522384644,
0.0075029293075203896,
-0.05676185339689255,
-0.0017444142140448093,
-0.011811323463916779,
-0.017691252753138542,
-0.012386562302708626,
0.004376269411295652,
0.001202823012135923,
0.013525865972042084,
-0.0033836334478110075,
0.012696703895926476,
0.03875066712498665,
0.0040094503201544285,
-0.012871162965893745,
-0.010161277838051319,
-0.0026598642580211163,
-0.03305201232433319,
0.016683509573340416,
-0.008027779869735241,
0.038022805005311966,
0.02312910556793213,
0.04005606472492218,
-0.004073321353644133,
-0.010776298120617867,
0.0036819647066295147,
-0.004036800004541874,
0.008448915556073189,
0.046105287969112396,
-0.06652099639177322,
0.014657855033874512,
-0.03940511494874954,
-0.002319557126611471,
-0.0015336301876232028,
0.02352316305041313,
0.012188642285764217,
0.0007271016365848482,
-0.050326209515333176,
0.04640427231788635,
0.0037372878286987543,
-0.02633056603372097,
0.018537860363721848,
-0.016105741262435913,
0.06588880717754364,
-0.05572735145688057,
0.020185761153697968,
0.042143452912569046,
0.005533955059945583,
0.033775243908166885,
-0.05368999019265175,
-0.01639205776154995,
0.02167649380862713,
-0.003015955211594701,
0.010244597680866718,
0.020717699080705643,
-0.04417460784316063,
-0.036890190094709396,
0.002077676821500063,
0.00952901877462864,
-0.05207420513033867,
0.00022419457673095167,
0.012569221667945385,
0.05563391000032425,
0.0092002646997571,
0.04154562950134277,
-0.013574773445725441,
-0.04784563556313515,
0.017280565574765205,
-0.01453474722802639,
-0.0028198633808642626,
0.0029283580370247364,
-0.011153613217175007,
-0.05867929011583328,
-0.05978849530220032,
0.01269810926169157,
0.0020010885782539845,
0.019989624619483948,
-0.012330980971455574,
0.002677180105820298,
-0.00530247250571847,
-0.036739055067300797,
0.02174532227218151,
0.0056817540898919106,
-0.09352999180555344,
0.009810498915612698,
0.025316698476672173,
0.03241434320807457,
0.01923125982284546,
-0.02722892351448536,
-0.013789279386401176,
-0.07968451827764511,
-0.03387679159641266,
0.02254633605480194,
-0.007781493477523327,
-0.022154156118631363,
-0.006574507337063551,
-0.011897973716259003,
-0.00192451907787472,
0.009889239445328712,
0.010211230255663395,
-0.023687679320573807,
-0.05102654546499252,
0.007800541818141937,
0.009118509478867054,
-0.01807587966322899,
-0.012555614113807678,
0.011782221496105194,
-0.06072722747921944,
0.04575061798095703,
-0.04973471164703369,
0.028213826939463615,
0.04781099036335945,
0.004923944361507893,
-0.012777040712535381,
-0.03111255168914795,
0.023571087047457695,
-0.00863664597272873,
-0.0056932284496724606,
0.02011704631149769,
-0.0372307188808918,
-0.04042443260550499,
0.007286710664629936,
-0.005254706367850304,
0.054105330258607864,
0.04695311561226845,
-0.027499094605445862,
0.01662774756550789,
0.005835236981511116,
0.03570947051048279,
0.002636553253978491,
-0.014738094992935658,
0.006865000817924738,
0.07029134780168533,
-0.02506028115749359,
-0.033826883882284164,
-0.037402763962745667,
-0.042008355259895325,
-0.00005454921119962819,
-0.04661611467599869,
0.01365009043365717,
-0.049527451395988464,
0.06324220448732376,
-0.0017589578637853265,
0.044584229588508606,
0.02132214605808258,
0.004622351378202438,
0.06964631378650665,
-0.044111140072345734,
0.02364056371152401,
-0.0804843083024025,
-0.014009715989232063,
0.047189537435770035,
-0.016522236168384552,
0.019677190110087395,
-0.013309888541698456,
-0.03474855050444603,
0.042091041803359985,
-0.03561042994260788,
-0.03578278422355652,
0.030725877732038498,
-0.003509888891130686,
-0.02594263292849064,
0.022625409066677094,
-0.05740491673350334,
-0.024108394980430603,
-0.020074082538485527,
-0.04497578367590904,
0.007789721712470055,
-0.011288379319012165,
0.04656372591853142,
-0.016659867018461227,
0.012810184620320797,
0.011853596195578575,
0.01742619276046753,
0.011848224326968193,
0.06807389855384827,
0.05445298179984093,
0.015281667932868004,
-0.023763202130794525,
0.07829999178647995,
0.04348987340927124,
0.026193026453256607,
0.0012827289756387472,
0.03128943592309952,
-0.021147707477211952,
-0.061364758759737015,
0.05209099501371384,
-0.006404637824743986,
-0.011223718523979187,
-0.05981103703379631,
0.05954857915639877,
0.02425081841647625,
-0.03439084812998772,
-0.016794556751847267,
0.027574677020311356,
-0.04101546108722687,
-0.0012697105994448066,
0.008936557918787003,
0.003558100899681449,
0.0005433596088550985,
0.05660640075802803,
0.010563955642282963,
0.04385806620121002,
0.053466495126485825,
0.001342104165814817,
-0.03738425299525261,
0.0113222636282444,
0.058024607598781586,
0.059171728789806366,
0.07678452134132385,
0.0416526272892952,
0.05359732359647751,
-0.03294496610760689,
-0.04360911250114441,
-0.002938698511570692,
0.022418910637497902,
-0.004636549390852451,
-0.026639243587851524,
0.04564594104886055,
0.0602039210498333,
-0.023466890677809715,
0.024944273754954338,
-0.0302997138351202,
-0.012234276160597801,
0.0480928011238575,
0.037769343703985214,
0.0006806384772062302,
0.04510393738746643,
0.024833159521222115,
-0.009471053257584572,
-0.0505191832780838,
-0.029052279889583588,
-0.01719413697719574,
-0.041341960430145264,
-0.01285299938172102,
0.0014284393982961774,
-0.014356831088662148,
-0.0044015985913574696,
-0.03173426538705826,
0.06853203475475311,
0.12084916979074478,
-0.0358399823307991,
-0.014426585286855698,
0.046742361038923264,
0.03609723225235939,
0.01415003277361393,
0.03592425212264061,
0.03030283935368061,
-0.029035700485110283,
0.009205592796206474,
-0.017648780718445778,
0.020800041034817696,
-0.020311959087848663,
-0.023950893431901932,
0.00385230197571218,
-0.020244061946868896,
-0.04522096365690231,
0.021221309900283813,
0.021514559164643288,
-0.03695937991142273,
-0.06354150921106339,
-0.027159729972481728,
-0.03564448654651642,
-0.05255240574479103,
-0.006999204400926828,
0.054966628551483154,
-0.03347918763756752,
-0.021514326333999634,
0.014375152066349983,
-0.04259968549013138,
-0.005307497922331095,
0.007891666144132614,
-0.07320833951234818,
-0.0064973668195307255,
0.04694544896483421,
-0.009791230782866478,
-0.014524758793413639,
0.03768566623330116,
0.038071002811193466,
-0.028385819867253304,
-0.002782487543299794,
0.00635632686316967,
-0.02946636825799942,
-0.004531660582870245,
0.03144973888993263,
-0.027345869690179825,
-0.08565135300159454,
-0.019127044826745987,
0.009883728809654713,
-0.02576562575995922,
-0.06202542781829834,
0.021691568195819855,
-0.02240315079689026,
0.0321924053132534,
0.07533016800880432,
0.0029761665500700474,
0.013739373534917831,
-0.007712409365922213,
-0.023791328072547913,
0.010885782539844513,
0.008260154165327549,
0.05693415179848671,
-0.02496935799717903,
0.07463604211807251,
0.015498504042625427,
-0.025486087426543236,
-0.0452648401260376,
-0.001807125867344439,
-0.01924300380051136,
0.0025207207072526217,
-0.02488541044294834,
-0.018147330731153488,
-0.006761433091014624,
-0.09649362415075302,
-0.03286713734269142,
0.018734119832515717,
-0.01819305680692196,
-0.03979426622390747,
0.02530934289097786,
-0.030329756438732147,
0.01495026983320713,
0.028758931905031204,
-0.03238175809383392,
-0.028358094394207,
-0.03381843864917755,
-0.031625326722860336,
-0.04544944688677788,
-0.02027169242501259,
-0.012204978615045547,
-0.011105868965387344,
-0.024429146200418472,
-0.04061814770102501,
0.0007772516692057252,
-0.000487385579617694,
0.03546322509646416,
-0.015056672506034374,
0.01970323920249939,
-0.005327852442860603
] |
387 |
Agent-Oriented Planning in Multi-Agent Systems
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=EqcLAU6gyU
|
[
"Ao Li",
"Yuexiang Xie",
"Songze Li",
"Fugee Tsung",
"Bolin Ding",
"Yaliang Li"
] |
Poster
|
Through the collaboration of multiple LLM-empowered agents possessing diverse expertise and tools, multi-agent systems achieve impressive progress in solving real-world problems. Given the user queries, the meta-agents, serving as the brain within multi-agent systems, are required to decompose the queries into multiple sub-tasks that can be allocated to suitable agents capable of solving them, so-called agent-oriented planning. In this study, we identify three critical design principles of agent-oriented planning, including solvability, completeness, and non-redundancy, to ensure that each sub-task can be effectively resolved, resulting in satisfactory responses to user queries. These principles further inspire us to propose AOP, a novel framework for agent-oriented planning in multi-agent systems, leveraging a fast task decomposition and allocation process followed by an effective and efficient evaluation via a reward model. According to the evaluation results, the meta-agent is also responsible for promptly making necessary adjustments to sub-tasks and scheduling. Besides, we integrate a feedback loop into AOP to further enhance the effectiveness and robustness of such a problem-solving process. Extensive experiments demonstrate the advancement of AOP in solving real-world problems compared to both single-agent systems and existing planning strategies for multi-agent systems. The source code is available at https://github.com/lalaliat/Agent-Oriented-Planning
|
Multi-Agent System; Planning
| null | 13,187 |
2410.02189
|
[
-0.027122309431433678,
-0.024021267890930176,
0.0022352184168994427,
-0.0027550857048481703,
0.0436745285987854,
0.002975928131490946,
0.019213544204831123,
0.0012423605658113956,
-0.014261732809245586,
-0.04770830646157265,
-0.03985387086868286,
0.022808292880654335,
-0.07461297512054443,
-0.016873102635145187,
-0.011537352576851845,
0.06373864412307739,
0.0038731975946575403,
-0.023424336686730385,
0.014047151431441307,
0.001682487316429615,
-0.015460298396646976,
0.0013474476290866733,
0.03325057402253151,
0.04326905310153961,
0.036326196044683456,
0.022249368950724602,
0.05293629318475723,
0.019647814333438873,
-0.01697804406285286,
-0.02727823704481125,
0.03160397335886955,
-0.025102803483605385,
0.013965053483843803,
-0.05045757815241814,
-0.01134646125137806,
0.018985409289598465,
-0.03408096730709076,
0.03065740503370762,
-0.0019533829763531685,
0.004173151217401028,
-0.04336616396903992,
0.07184496521949768,
-0.01636396162211895,
0.003217362565919757,
-0.01762927882373333,
0.019585026428103447,
-0.07628067582845688,
0.03430940583348274,
0.02849060297012329,
-0.01651083119213581,
-0.09718699753284454,
0.009381269104778767,
0.010976838879287243,
-0.017551783472299576,
-0.002582200337201357,
0.03533560782670975,
0.046677619218826294,
-0.08742406219244003,
-0.01773867756128311,
-0.02691403217613697,
-0.03655816987156868,
0.004788343794643879,
0.029421670362353325,
0.009502864442765713,
-0.01145469956099987,
-0.012131033465266228,
0.029738320037722588,
0.041075870394706726,
-0.020815329626202583,
0.01875322312116623,
-0.05270887538790703,
-0.012125009670853615,
-0.0466417521238327,
-0.03561309352517128,
-0.0025390302762389183,
-0.030558286234736443,
0.04564841464161873,
0.0402560792863369,
0.04692921042442322,
0.003766861744225025,
0.0075510041788220406,
0.043989211320877075,
0.00030672235880047083,
0.020675430074334145,
0.0503934808075428,
0.025640707463026047,
-0.016312483698129654,
-0.015881523489952087,
-0.05192646011710167,
0.03890417888760567,
0.004976735450327396,
-0.09728159010410309,
0.0017329183174297214,
0.04351792111992836,
0.04565566033124924,
-0.02257908508181572,
0.0219828300178051,
0.02955665998160839,
0.007101858966052532,
0.0026415155734866858,
0.01596655510365963,
-0.0062861074693500996,
-0.008405805565416813,
0.0030225729569792747,
-0.07717687636613846,
-0.023385651409626007,
-0.0173357967287302,
-0.056144509464502335,
-0.01723870076239109,
-0.0001470057322876528,
-0.030776776373386383,
-0.01816108077764511,
0.04380883648991585,
-0.034428857266902924,
-0.08057815581560135,
0.05936560779809952,
0.00982086081057787,
0.039595361799001694,
0.015363638289272785,
0.06628429889678955,
0.037814948707818985,
0.06191800534725189,
0.003107669297605753,
0.05955104902386665,
-0.0351150743663311,
0.013598224148154259,
0.01058916375041008,
0.02006661333143711,
-0.02376062050461769,
-0.03573720529675484,
0.03736511990427971,
0.024584846571087837,
-0.020156526938080788,
-0.007451173849403858,
-0.0005887012230232358,
-0.0036615952849388123,
-0.005882643163204193,
0.014812599867582321,
0.017199059948325157,
0.025127584114670753,
-0.030624188482761383,
-0.017406482249498367,
0.066278837621212,
-0.01312826294451952,
0.05820609629154205,
0.01038908027112484,
0.012706242501735687,
-0.023300573229789734,
-0.08607605844736099,
-0.03361284360289574,
-0.006397682707756758,
-0.010716385208070278,
-0.009099500253796577,
-0.04049506038427353,
0.03198118880391121,
0.0897212028503418,
0.04346400499343872,
0.02665366232395172,
-0.0127462949603796,
-0.00947139784693718,
-0.002951640635728836,
0.005353921093046665,
-0.04445751756429672,
-0.0018973761470988393,
-0.012740710750222206,
-0.030702756717801094,
0.016763897612690926,
0.03419801965355873,
0.04121933877468109,
0.0057607791386544704,
-0.03677932918071747,
-0.06010422855615616,
0.036512020975351334,
-0.02553907223045826,
0.007429191842675209,
-0.024907954037189484,
0.07398688793182373,
-0.018178625032305717,
0.05667417496442795,
0.01659766398370266,
-0.05800411105155945,
-0.0013154050102457404,
-0.004582104738801718,
-0.028161711990833282,
0.009670301340520382,
0.007632851134985685,
0.06610894948244095,
-0.015435030683875084,
-0.008217951282858849,
0.0037147612310945988,
-0.06585625559091568,
-0.019764507189393044,
0.058964524418115616,
0.0016488867113366723,
0.07041186094284058,
0.008565600030124187,
-0.04326987266540527,
0.052961066365242004,
-0.005244487896561623,
0.06731373071670532,
0.04246094077825546,
0.016068920493125916,
0.0447714701294899,
0.01672729291021824,
-0.009840823709964752,
-0.0019082779763266444,
0.04643743112683296,
-0.03091426193714142,
-0.01290197018533945,
0.03485798463225365,
-0.011459185741841793,
-0.0015367746818810701,
0.027466699481010437,
-0.0045934985391795635,
0.04443865641951561,
-0.009243011474609375,
-0.020485127344727516,
-0.017705649137496948,
0.02587822824716568,
-0.06928427517414093,
0.03816988319158554,
0.009264093823730946,
-0.008092258125543594,
0.011867874301970005,
-0.026279080659151077,
0.08477529138326645,
0.04875901713967323,
-0.07014529407024384,
-0.021779179573059082,
0.016692794859409332,
0.00796109065413475,
0.03519533574581146,
0.013601193204522133,
-0.015055838041007519,
0.01324883010238409,
-0.036455895751714706,
-0.008881410583853722,
-0.0011560830753296614,
0.028336187824606895,
-0.027896739542484283,
-0.03402068093419075,
0.06634500622749329,
-0.005795017350465059,
0.0795527920126915,
-0.0018061116570606828,
0.02639363519847393,
0.007894742302596569,
0.0036158894654363394,
0.033371176570653915,
0.027755284681916237,
-0.025082025676965714,
-0.0074153561145067215,
0.007830987684428692,
-0.033649977296590805,
-0.03471270576119423,
-0.07173091918230057,
-0.006944442633539438,
-0.010665150359272957,
0.055334433913230896,
0.05221018195152283,
-0.010079875588417053,
0.022194722667336464,
0.019461849704384804,
0.004745517857372761,
-0.006640972103923559,
-0.12490406632423401,
-0.019339213147759438,
0.01242069248110056,
-0.017314201220870018,
0.0516212023794651,
0.03044441156089306,
-0.009450539946556091,
0.05582066997885704,
-0.02868400514125824,
-0.01810416579246521,
0.011676322668790817,
0.013667178340256214,
0.012652846053242683,
-0.008897608146071434,
-0.005763969384133816,
0.027907278388738632,
0.05612316355109215,
0.010006027296185493,
-0.02727556601166725,
-0.022631986066699028,
-0.035573482513427734,
0.0031574200838804245,
-0.08172351866960526,
-0.015432201325893402,
-0.02208128198981285,
0.016503136605024338,
0.017511684447526932,
-0.020827796310186386,
0.0015904102474451065,
0.043111030012369156,
0.031341277062892914,
-0.0015656965551897883,
0.00940177496522665,
-0.011783314868807793,
0.004296399652957916,
-0.012694044969975948,
-0.007126114331185818,
-0.028820525854825974,
-0.01668328233063221,
-0.022444134578108788,
-0.01506718434393406,
0.01711832359433174,
0.014998379163444042,
-0.26883530616760254,
-0.020780621096491814,
0.0165860578417778,
-0.008465791121125221,
0.028136400505900383,
0.0167916938662529,
0.08428721874952316,
-0.02527208998799324,
-0.03966067358851433,
-0.03844316303730011,
0.0058771115727722645,
0.02801230177283287,
0.055138297379016876,
0.07561894506216049,
0.05650092288851738,
0.027773458510637283,
-0.010243352502584457,
-0.013675830326974392,
-0.009838827885687351,
0.025810258463025093,
-0.021373623982071877,
-0.0745498314499855,
-0.015612057410180569,
0.014962160028517246,
0.022141022607684135,
0.04011480510234833,
-0.06362096220254898,
-0.01243631076067686,
-0.001782769220881164,
0.008257919922471046,
-0.010493626818060875,
-0.01713939756155014,
-0.03571481257677078,
-0.004851962439715862,
0.01726209744811058,
-0.016859522089362144,
0.08714914321899414,
0.019700730219483376,
0.022745618596673012,
-0.006605161353945732,
0.028376011177897453,
-0.014143365435302258,
-0.08659205585718155,
-0.0038243811577558517,
0.025665849447250366,
0.03653379902243614,
-0.0689033716917038,
0.005550991743803024,
-0.0050661698915064335,
0.02721342258155346,
0.014940372668206692,
-0.019741106778383255,
-0.009275748394429684,
-0.022324176505208015,
0.0269785113632679,
-0.03544376790523529,
0.007010961417108774,
-0.02491792105138302,
0.010835567489266396,
0.02990875020623207,
-0.013199198059737682,
-0.029792170971632004,
-0.029839379712939262,
-0.012315263040363789,
0.006873029749840498,
-0.02901577576994896,
-0.031265903264284134,
-0.0784466341137886,
0.031008196994662285,
-0.004823919385671616,
-0.010777688585221767,
-0.021888555958867073,
-0.030041538178920746,
-0.11183001101016998,
-0.014215361326932907,
0.02281222864985466,
-0.010046030394732952,
-0.044631775468587875,
0.01864529587328434,
0.033998824656009674,
-0.03966828063130379,
-0.03243575245141983,
-0.028300048783421516,
0.018176008015871048,
0.03157443553209305,
-0.0025391096714884043,
0.017105787992477417,
-0.0609046034514904,
-0.027287403121590614,
-0.02434724196791649,
0.0396852046251297,
0.007069032173603773,
0.014475230127573013,
0.011713366024196148,
0.09104979038238525,
0.003579157404601574,
0.0389418788254261,
0.03139515221118927,
0.010911645367741585,
0.015359405428171158,
0.017264386638998985,
-0.07381447404623032,
0.0332464762032032,
0.0272940993309021,
-0.03239075094461441,
-0.004135069902986288,
-0.03601854294538498,
0.0012103327317163348,
0.06857035309076309,
0.025501854717731476,
-0.010492249391973019,
-0.04477216303348541,
0.013815121725201607,
0.0005441074026748538,
-0.010135222226381302,
-0.009973349049687386,
-0.012940632179379463,
0.057978205382823944,
-0.005121302790939808,
0.013438860885798931,
-0.07929401099681854,
0.010226648300886154,
-0.05002450942993164,
0.022524714469909668,
-0.009020688943564892,
0.008681479841470718,
-0.011250557377934456,
-0.014113192446529865,
0.018391896039247513,
0.014687897637486458,
0.005335625261068344,
0.031078694388270378,
-0.01684466376900673,
-0.017516503110527992,
0.02304324321448803,
-0.027004361152648926,
-0.029616516083478928,
-0.017059583216905594,
0.0260135680437088,
-0.004157972522079945,
0.027636263519525528,
-0.00862294901162386,
0.016616448760032654,
0.014134017750620842,
0.013584325090050697,
0.00480236392468214,
0.025023242458701134,
-0.029722679406404495,
0.031313616782426834,
0.02093212865293026,
0.0205397829413414,
-0.05143196880817413,
0.026613490656018257,
-0.027328941971063614,
0.01346760243177414,
-0.08993713557720184,
0.004504045471549034,
-0.009482434950768948,
0.030265765264630318,
-0.049258869141340256,
-0.007710705511271954,
-0.033573612570762634,
-0.008755872026085854,
-0.007186261937022209,
0.023715350776910782,
0.06992196291685104,
-0.05071701854467392,
-0.01339919026941061,
0.005588237661868334,
-0.010987178422510624,
0.003951404709368944,
-0.044445645064115524,
-0.057606883347034454,
-0.030405890196561813,
-0.017788264900445938,
-0.021816888824105263,
0.05245056748390198,
-0.03855974227190018,
-0.04446147382259369,
0.03995879739522934,
-0.032741885632276535,
-0.030992791056632996,
-0.012981907464563847,
-0.013776520267128944,
0.055466800928115845,
-0.022143838927149773,
0.023295525461435318,
0.01305656973272562,
-0.013617588207125664,
-0.0059153796173632145,
0.00921865738928318,
0.028718359768390656,
0.0037736573722213507,
-0.04965725541114807,
-0.030046511441469193,
-0.0625927597284317,
0.0588257722556591,
-0.0004005023802164942,
-0.0003636042238213122,
0.0011693515116348863,
-0.0012995997676625848,
0.028567496687173843,
-0.05754783749580383,
-0.037754692137241364,
0.014461841434240341,
-0.08210373669862747,
0.022170327603816986,
0.007747807539999485,
0.04247020557522774,
0.05279185250401497,
-0.05337337777018547,
-0.009462198242545128,
-0.06055581197142601,
0.011730097234249115,
0.0013306299224495888,
-0.04100404307246208,
-0.00942976213991642,
-0.01706705614924431,
-0.02745191380381584,
-0.013080431148409843,
0.015446944162249565,
-0.015404044650495052,
-0.024734122678637505,
-0.03786279261112213,
-0.002230205340310931,
0.038792550563812256,
-0.002597363665699959,
-0.03280028700828552,
0.004795770160853863,
-0.03476564213633537,
0.036482878029346466,
-0.06336425989866257,
-0.006817234214395285,
-0.0176693182438612,
-0.004185401368886232,
0.018383802846074104,
-0.03775433450937271,
0.0034970343112945557,
-0.007484946865588427,
-0.035445086658000946,
-0.03260763734579086,
0.005150303244590759,
-0.00962987169623375,
-0.03447940945625305,
0.03797058388590813,
0.044830769300460815,
-0.0025572774466127157,
-0.02549727074801922,
-0.012092774733901024,
0.027976956218481064,
-0.010143238119781017,
-0.002291550626978278,
-0.01852359063923359,
0.010990687645971775,
0.04176528751850128,
-0.030837468802928925,
-0.04513359069824219,
-0.014814453199505806,
-0.04556865245103836,
0.020349040627479553,
-0.021937455981969833,
0.0013993497705087066,
-0.03949455916881561,
0.031825654208660126,
0.019497012719511986,
0.0227249413728714,
-0.011627357453107834,
-0.02892405167222023,
0.013324793428182602,
-0.0560697503387928,
0.05794781818985939,
-0.07720328122377396,
0.030762676149606705,
0.022667380049824715,
-0.0041322531178593636,
-0.023164166137576103,
0.032546691596508026,
-0.03970840945839882,
0.05528970807790756,
-0.006012582685798407,
-0.046103332191705704,
0.04241001605987549,
-0.003262082114815712,
0.0009416458196938038,
0.07546935230493546,
-0.04480856657028198,
-0.039308786392211914,
-0.014071682468056679,
-0.05495983734726906,
0.01870626024901867,
-0.004611710552126169,
0.05186832696199417,
0.002235572785139084,
0.04398210346698761,
-0.018657643347978592,
0.029036136344075203,
0.017828160896897316,
0.03576777130365372,
-0.010508148930966854,
0.0473109595477581,
-0.02779746800661087,
0.05937400460243225,
0.043243154883384705,
0.069963239133358,
0.02120005525648594,
0.008880428038537502,
-0.039647381752729416,
-0.004645583685487509,
0.057271525263786316,
0.004808884579688311,
-0.02366754226386547,
-0.06575015187263489,
0.0517856702208519,
0.017713570967316628,
-0.043540824204683304,
0.023600250482559204,
-0.0017230662051588297,
-0.1221565306186676,
0.0073212930001318455,
-0.003938412759453058,
0.03152938932180405,
0.04036308079957962,
0.05644473806023598,
0.01828128844499588,
0.0698695182800293,
0.05468698590993881,
0.03048391081392765,
-0.009531514719128609,
-0.012094846926629543,
0.06760482490062714,
0.0559023842215538,
0.0454886332154274,
-0.013283627107739449,
0.06089535728096962,
-0.03679538890719414,
-0.04483571648597717,
0.01332591101527214,
-0.007313166279345751,
-0.024563388898968697,
-0.016418324783444405,
0.03190499544143677,
0.04707956686615944,
0.004719431046396494,
0.05219181627035141,
-0.024487610906362534,
-0.024699946865439415,
0.06997936218976974,
0.0166205745190382,
0.011457765474915504,
0.027149640023708344,
0.0407448410987854,
0.04086770862340927,
-0.056938908994197845,
-0.03644118830561638,
0.008189420215785503,
-0.03932525962591171,
-0.011292925104498863,
0.018289951607584953,
0.01953112706542015,
-0.006602164823561907,
-0.024232184514403343,
0.035679880529642105,
0.09260688722133636,
-0.022570155560970306,
-0.003216040087863803,
-0.010273127816617489,
-0.013150219805538654,
-0.00014547814498655498,
0.02131299488246441,
0.04664117097854614,
0.0005778809427283704,
0.018587926402688026,
-0.047038737684488297,
0.04090153053402901,
0.04025257006287575,
0.011094439774751663,
0.0748710036277771,
-0.0353093259036541,
-0.028415996581315994,
-0.016582811251282692,
0.032248008996248245,
-0.053186167031526566,
-0.01792127452790737,
-0.03307303786277771,
-0.054440438747406006,
-0.020214468240737915,
0.0020124062430113554,
0.053804557770490646,
-0.0030487056355923414,
-0.03913076967000961,
-0.004316294565796852,
-0.002172060776501894,
0.006569631863385439,
-0.0007459565531462431,
-0.0522024966776371,
-0.003974204417318106,
0.05341919884085655,
0.013315214775502682,
0.04087047651410103,
0.025990566238760948,
0.03196690231561661,
-0.0032240371219813824,
0.01276450790464878,
-0.014973808079957962,
0.021318919956684113,
-0.01343455445021391,
-0.017210666090250015,
-0.00948197953402996,
-0.08014275133609772,
-0.010792403481900692,
0.02018417790532112,
-0.046771008521318436,
-0.07628984749317169,
0.0077735185623168945,
-0.02036917209625244,
0.030739380046725273,
0.07316794991493225,
0.012418510392308235,
0.03681154176592827,
-0.006145978346467018,
0.026903264224529266,
0.014855465851724148,
-0.015006831847131252,
0.02374398335814476,
-0.04299625754356384,
0.05079564452171326,
0.029855135828256607,
-0.06381469964981079,
-0.040073130279779434,
0.0660969540476799,
0.016675138846039772,
-0.028859056532382965,
-0.007094327826052904,
-0.045470230281353,
-0.02272152341902256,
-0.09921535104513168,
-0.03251701593399048,
0.013382889330387115,
0.02250497415661812,
-0.037163302302360535,
0.0058730063028633595,
-0.0018911324441432953,
-0.05936915799975395,
-0.0046456134878098965,
-0.05199269950389862,
0.029499204829335213,
-0.012528556399047375,
-0.019517960026860237,
-0.05515739694237709,
0.005695087369531393,
-0.029771501198410988,
-0.03055417537689209,
-0.02110709249973297,
-0.05419864133000374,
0.0034868225920945406,
-0.004245067480951548,
0.0190319512039423,
0.0021303400862962008,
0.009577590972185135,
-0.009703338146209717
] |
388 |
Context Clues: Evaluating Long Context Models for Clinical Prediction Tasks on EHR Data
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=zg3ec1TdAP
|
[
"Michael Wornow",
"Suhana Bedi",
"Miguel Angel Fuentes Hernandez",
"Ethan Steinberg",
"Jason Alan Fries",
"Christopher Re",
"Sanmi Koyejo",
"Nigam Shah"
] |
Poster
|
Foundation Models (FMs) trained on Electronic Health Records (EHRs) have achieved state-of-the-art results on numerous clinical prediction tasks. However, prior EHR FMs typically have context windows of $<$1k tokens, which prevents them from modeling full patient EHRs which can exceed 10k's of events. For making clinical predictions, both model performance and robustness to the unique properties of EHR data are crucial. Recent advancements in subquadratic long-context architectures (e.g. Mamba) offer a promising solution. However, their application to EHR data has not been well-studied. We address this gap by presenting the first systematic evaluation of the effect of context length on modeling EHR data. We find that longer context models improve predictive performance -- our Mamba-based model surpasses the prior state-of-the-art on 9/14 tasks on the EHRSHOT prediction benchmark. Additionally, we measure robustness to three unique, previously underexplored properties of EHR data: (1) the prevalence of ``copy-forwarded" diagnoses which create artificial token repetition in EHR sequences; (2) the irregular time intervals between EHR events which can lead to a wide range of timespans within a context window; and (3) the natural increase in disease complexity over time which makes later tokens in the EHR harder to predict than earlier ones. Stratifying our EHRSHOT results, we find that higher levels of each property correlate negatively with model performance (e.g., a 14% higher Brier loss between the least and most irregular patients), but that longer context models are more robust to more extreme levels of these properties. Our work highlights the potential for using long-context architectures to model EHR data, and offers a case study on how to identify and quantify new challenges in modeling sequential data motivated by domains outside of natural language. We release all of our model checkpoints and code.
|
ehr, foundation model, long context, clinical prediction making, healthcare
|
An analysis of the impact of context length on foundation models trained on structured electronic health record (EHR) data for clinical prediction tasks.
| 13,179 | null |
[
-0.015518803149461746,
-0.0026362575590610504,
-0.029086703434586525,
0.026029961183667183,
0.0586828887462616,
0.012611321173608303,
0.021966984495520592,
0.02604801021516323,
-0.022938262671232224,
-0.04492855444550514,
-0.010958087630569935,
0.020892731845378876,
-0.052123866975307465,
0.0009734627674333751,
-0.008566243574023247,
0.04126135632395744,
0.04752305522561073,
-0.007086386904120445,
0.04871078208088875,
-0.004029148258268833,
-0.006830866914242506,
-0.029709622263908386,
0.035458751022815704,
0.035722941160202026,
0.007942634634673595,
0.04149280861020088,
-0.007329086773097515,
-0.0251479335129261,
-0.07447768747806549,
0.024714555591344833,
0.06623242795467377,
-0.01864423044025898,
-0.010126263834536076,
-0.02556772157549858,
0.023037346079945564,
0.03817300498485565,
-0.03737810626626015,
0.02659798040986061,
-0.0013078016927465796,
-0.021216847002506256,
-0.05493641272187233,
0.02219359576702118,
0.005155172199010849,
0.019134940579533577,
-0.05618667230010033,
0.013997701928019524,
-0.1119518056511879,
0.03316187113523483,
-0.006960802245885134,
0.00012119141319999471,
-0.09445101767778397,
0.03734127804636955,
0.005165336653590202,
0.012109139002859592,
0.009343458339571953,
0.06189682334661484,
0.07439602166414261,
-0.05250847712159157,
0.00558986933901906,
-0.010865111835300922,
-0.03631476312875748,
0.013503649272024632,
0.025564251467585564,
0.015225721523165703,
-0.010172054171562195,
-0.04347466677427292,
-0.012010665610432625,
0.0579615943133831,
-0.035322342067956924,
0.0005988709162920713,
-0.02522270195186138,
-0.004942791070789099,
0.006434950511902571,
-0.02870679274201393,
0.013074424117803574,
-0.02233678475022316,
-0.0010218166280537844,
0.000014225555787561461,
0.05071263387799263,
0.012134019285440445,
0.003425322938710451,
-0.027185922488570213,
0.048196326941251755,
0.025954874232411385,
-0.010117107070982456,
-0.0002919651160482317,
-0.05650261044502258,
-0.04668594151735306,
-0.0658004879951477,
0.05907527729868889,
0.0010860487818717957,
-0.041744980961084366,
0.0309000127017498,
0.006238807924091816,
-0.008424763567745686,
0.010740535333752632,
0.030719270929694176,
-0.0006964412750676274,
-0.030295871198177338,
0.0011797748738899827,
-0.011582110077142715,
-0.04327467456459999,
0.013043743558228016,
0.014391805045306683,
-0.10898751020431519,
-0.017733795568346977,
-0.01300763338804245,
-0.01689101755619049,
-0.003081557573750615,
-0.03634629398584366,
-0.0421636588871479,
0.014176656492054462,
-0.008601190522313118,
-0.0011166577460244298,
-0.06838902831077576,
0.06145041435956955,
0.020464491099119186,
0.02865263633430004,
0.021494263783097267,
-0.01709582656621933,
0.04399384185671806,
0.04671487584710121,
0.0006390582420863211,
0.05704059824347496,
-0.006289089098572731,
0.024628277868032455,
0.0010515972971916199,
0.006120646838098764,
-0.017709486186504364,
-0.03755250945687294,
-0.017017913982272148,
0.02817375399172306,
-0.020621784031391144,
-0.01279309019446373,
0.01454269327223301,
0.04944998025894165,
0.0005105034215375781,
-0.005011586472392082,
0.07203575223684311,
0.014104087837040424,
0.048096664249897,
-0.04253211244940758,
0.01305769570171833,
-0.030994638800621033,
0.06173524633049965,
-0.011354452930390835,
-0.02328638918697834,
-0.006674361415207386,
-0.02197691611945629,
-0.013687570579349995,
0.00854956079274416,
-0.015221214853227139,
0.024101177230477333,
-0.06780148297548294,
0.054465826600790024,
0.05439263582229614,
0.004761727061122656,
-0.024000106379389763,
0.0071327039040625095,
0.0018833114299923182,
0.027295811101794243,
0.011512349359691143,
-0.05628819763660431,
0.009014659561216831,
0.004188885912299156,
-0.04293191060423851,
0.054449498653411865,
0.022979693487286568,
-0.03607477247714996,
0.050546761602163315,
-0.03387947380542755,
-0.05509302392601967,
0.06701196730136871,
-0.02655237354338169,
0.010541933588683605,
0.043011050671339035,
0.06400879472494125,
-0.008138241246342659,
0.048889316618442535,
0.0144051443785429,
-0.08752655982971191,
0.028238946571946144,
0.003724083537235856,
-0.02803112380206585,
0.026065204292535782,
-0.010129792615771294,
0.08049163222312927,
-0.03496158868074417,
-0.00015581129991915077,
0.024382593110203743,
-0.08137108385562897,
-0.03810352087020874,
0.037518832832574844,
0.010423749685287476,
0.048917826265096664,
-0.023275677114725113,
0.009955189190804958,
0.08201538771390915,
-0.015226432122290134,
0.02180398255586624,
0.05969772860407829,
0.006585756316781044,
0.03375467285513878,
0.0007274873787537217,
-0.04675325006246567,
-0.0043884036131203175,
0.03628234937787056,
-0.060835547745227814,
-0.059870969504117966,
0.038611434400081635,
-0.017006969079375267,
0.0069237216375768185,
0.021354161202907562,
-0.013591552153229713,
-0.006521479692310095,
0.02603134699165821,
0.01562916673719883,
-0.0017998659750446677,
-0.034359756857156754,
-0.06970265507698059,
0.03657305985689163,
-0.0013794827973470092,
-0.023086044937372208,
0.031573519110679626,
-0.009248516522347927,
0.08883314579725266,
0.07097779214382172,
-0.016197387129068375,
-0.0017631895607337356,
-0.0027811832260340452,
0.0399012453854084,
-0.008310859091579914,
0.01043684035539627,
-0.056812942028045654,
0.030453218147158623,
-0.026994064450263977,
-0.0006166734383441508,
-0.031091788783669472,
0.05385250970721245,
-0.030621912330389023,
-0.006587464362382889,
0.053905319422483444,
-0.050728119909763336,
0.0385131761431694,
0.02679494395852089,
-0.024909328669309616,
-0.0015621697530150414,
0.02252662181854248,
-0.06694162636995316,
-0.017746705561876297,
-0.024823777377605438,
0.004546220880001783,
-0.020190412178635597,
-0.008545535616576672,
0.057472746819257736,
-0.048717666417360306,
-0.005831674672663212,
0.03635112941265106,
0.02826826460659504,
0.03382075950503349,
0.016816267743706703,
0.029347138479351997,
0.025691833347082138,
-0.041250187903642654,
0.03455124795436859,
-0.07866229116916656,
-0.03900584205985069,
-0.05032190680503845,
0.019603697583079338,
-0.03721773996949196,
0.0403054915368557,
-0.0035894413013011217,
0.02902216836810112,
-0.011375942267477512,
0.0013077728217467666,
-0.019593264907598495,
0.05621207132935524,
0.02171548269689083,
-0.056525517255067825,
0.008424017578363419,
0.010121452622115612,
0.03991724178195,
0.03472607955336571,
-0.043012991547584534,
-0.0040568201802670956,
-0.03589711710810661,
-0.001594212488271296,
-0.021765965968370438,
-0.006959871854633093,
0.04568902403116226,
-0.01417324785143137,
0.0449613593518734,
-0.03505806252360344,
0.029435208067297935,
0.05762408673763275,
0.07003726065158844,
0.04168228060007095,
0.04840578883886337,
-0.020360928028821945,
0.021871058270335197,
-0.002912644064053893,
0.03319830819964409,
0.03699597716331482,
-0.017207609489560127,
-0.015130328945815563,
-0.006369364447891712,
-0.04874725267291069,
-0.01141264010220766,
-0.28113821148872375,
0.017427191138267517,
0.018737588077783585,
-0.04745927453041077,
0.0331554040312767,
-0.006276758387684822,
0.04351416230201721,
-0.0020640625152736902,
-0.007922525517642498,
-0.0028923579957336187,
0.03587529435753822,
0.05703652650117874,
0.012845518067479134,
0.03234317898750305,
0.018636377528309822,
0.05424836277961731,
-0.016932660713791847,
-0.033379990607500076,
-0.013162917457520962,
0.023600706830620766,
0.01735072396695614,
-0.05926285311579704,
-0.026125766336917877,
0.02928072214126587,
-0.032436858862638474,
0.03529612347483635,
-0.07899004966020584,
0.023830052465200424,
-0.04079980030655861,
-0.005478764418512583,
0.030281182378530502,
-0.03620736300945282,
-0.0018443794688209891,
0.018194518983364105,
0.0034521433990448713,
-0.0005330260610207915,
0.04381837323307991,
0.03199117258191109,
-0.0033224294893443584,
-0.02552126720547676,
0.007439482491463423,
-0.01167689636349678,
-0.038076452910900116,
-0.020938441157341003,
0.06384872645139694,
-0.0074578700587153435,
-0.00943586602807045,
-0.03312011435627937,
-0.01078519131988287,
0.02731049433350563,
-0.018199482932686806,
-0.022967413067817688,
-0.04411135986447334,
0.02555432729423046,
0.012193622067570686,
-0.05328534543514252,
-0.0016607185825705528,
0.0391143262386322,
-0.0101581159979105,
-0.01033265795558691,
0.005587263498455286,
-0.04305417463183403,
-0.00010103957902174443,
-0.07053889334201813,
-0.023377571254968643,
-0.07379043102264404,
-0.07925156503915787,
-0.05152907967567444,
0.025330692529678345,
0.027775632217526436,
-0.01899023912847042,
0.034799735993146896,
-0.0043219770304858685,
-0.09387385845184326,
-0.01773911528289318,
-0.04626322165131569,
0.024558117613196373,
-0.01472984254360199,
0.004023776389658451,
0.015755649656057358,
-0.028369853273034096,
-0.03933103755116463,
0.002569868927821517,
0.028125809505581856,
0.03341803327202797,
-0.006177565082907677,
-0.00011944035213673487,
-0.03762013837695122,
-0.01714267022907734,
-0.006916910409927368,
0.027528190985322,
-0.01660812646150589,
0.0031358490232378244,
0.03764045611023903,
0.018498361110687256,
0.024350259453058243,
0.0009060563752427697,
0.05150474235415459,
0.024995241314172745,
0.0134199857711792,
0.007592068985104561,
-0.07104942947626114,
-0.009234963916242123,
-0.09090378880500793,
-0.014043222181499004,
0.01972365751862526,
-0.03678058460354805,
-0.049065716564655304,
0.03137679770588875,
-0.018511613830924034,
-0.01008501648902893,
0.0008433472830802202,
0.014224587939679623,
-0.060226358473300934,
-0.012760401703417301,
-0.029550474137067795,
0.013783331960439682,
0.02070755511522293,
0.05850793421268463,
-0.000937855860684067,
-0.00885223038494587,
0.03479527682065964,
-0.013888784684240818,
0.004664730746299028,
-0.0001953952305484563,
-0.009866254404187202,
0.011641968972980976,
0.004993821494281292,
0.007866613566875458,
-0.011745343916118145,
0.019495761021971703,
0.047490447759628296,
0.004550588317215443,
0.04721815511584282,
0.04788767918944359,
-0.017803847789764404,
-0.016963722184300423,
0.007824978791177273,
0.005428561475127935,
-0.0285396259278059,
0.0025004770141094923,
-0.011499622836709023,
0.026013312861323357,
0.041033390909433365,
0.047315310686826706,
-0.006197407376021147,
0.024549348279833794,
-0.004716469906270504,
0.034035805612802505,
0.010777058079838753,
0.007832415401935577,
-0.040032826364040375,
-0.04588647186756134,
-0.040011875331401825,
-0.01990671455860138,
-0.007837455719709396,
0.035286594182252884,
-0.0052313897758722305,
-0.00001616104600543622,
-0.09260112047195435,
0.0337112694978714,
-0.01590592786669731,
-0.017498379573225975,
-0.02961159497499466,
-0.0009362472337670624,
0.03781774640083313,
-0.0019926256500184536,
0.03558097779750824,
0.010604889132082462,
0.008199806325137615,
0.030426280573010445,
-0.0276050828397274,
-0.026488468050956726,
0.01941385120153427,
-0.06185862421989441,
0.01044060941785574,
-0.02170049399137497,
0.019330807030200958,
-0.021293198689818382,
0.03512114658951759,
0.024444686248898506,
-0.023031188175082207,
-0.015697449445724487,
0.006607255432754755,
0.06262490153312683,
0.01995065249502659,
0.03087899647653103,
-0.006136392708867788,
-0.043347880244255066,
-0.011243264190852642,
-0.009331298060715199,
0.013844413682818413,
0.0007883988437242806,
-0.024015294387936592,
-0.027683323249220848,
-0.0719972550868988,
0.009018942713737488,
-0.015814315527677536,
-0.0019532067235559225,
0.02742857113480568,
-0.005123163107782602,
-0.005803569685667753,
-0.031757887452840805,
0.01793239824473858,
0.017951253801584244,
-0.066681869328022,
-0.004674982745200396,
0.002754454966634512,
-0.010204617865383625,
0.029739676043391228,
-0.03913502022624016,
-0.051976241171360016,
-0.038427844643592834,
-0.006832444109022617,
-0.00041001755744218826,
-0.02585824392735958,
-0.013645120896399021,
-0.02630392648279667,
0.005436985287815332,
-0.009503857232630253,
0.00024937905254773796,
0.006053203716874123,
-0.011548499576747417,
0.008785102516412735,
-0.015521886758506298,
0.030325205996632576,
-0.00014107707829680294,
-0.03713250532746315,
0.010585496202111244,
-0.02991626039147377,
-0.017190491780638695,
-0.038511380553245544,
0.04013482481241226,
0.03756970912218094,
-0.03684646263718605,
0.010066977702081203,
-0.02556663379073143,
0.0327267199754715,
0.026875074952840805,
0.01028389297425747,
-0.010834707878530025,
-0.028210831806063652,
-0.026745278388261795,
0.0010118548525497317,
0.014829435385763645,
0.049056749790906906,
0.03462839126586914,
0.0026049967855215073,
0.0054460265673696995,
0.061440613120794296,
0.003607689868658781,
0.02616836689412594,
-0.004934933502227068,
-0.01641852967441082,
0.04778463765978813,
0.002772302133962512,
-0.0351274311542511,
-0.05109658092260361,
-0.041247207671403885,
0.0097512723878026,
-0.010414380580186844,
0.009825470857322216,
0.025317611172795296,
0.02876809798181057,
0.042429033666849136,
0.042159486562013626,
0.003488091751933098,
-0.027111655101180077,
0.07062438875436783,
-0.03611697629094124,
0.01596120186150074,
-0.06659869104623795,
0.013459624722599983,
0.041606355458498,
-0.03350470960140228,
0.0006219944916665554,
0.005836830474436283,
-0.026754267513751984,
0.026584697887301445,
0.008770841173827648,
-0.07828092575073242,
-0.007284719962626696,
-0.02666991762816906,
0.019146794453263283,
0.04441022500395775,
-0.02437027543783188,
-0.007715254090726376,
-0.020557649433612823,
-0.03823821619153023,
-0.024410197511315346,
0.005002423655241728,
0.07778522372245789,
-0.025959640741348267,
0.03294145688414574,
-0.03448556736111641,
0.0019296142272651196,
0.012384450994431973,
0.07579388469457626,
0.017636338248848915,
0.024050917476415634,
-0.047137536108493805,
0.10174700617790222,
0.003950541839003563,
-0.003540086094290018,
-0.03790638968348503,
-0.0264044888317585,
-0.029667656868696213,
-0.011693647131323814,
0.04593440145254135,
0.028084557503461838,
-0.024041641503572464,
-0.08599641919136047,
0.09094589203596115,
0.044572047889232635,
-0.03642009571194649,
-0.007981915026903152,
-0.005811054725199938,
-0.04810057953000069,
-0.00479154335334897,
0.025965385138988495,
-0.027225133031606674,
-0.04386657848954201,
0.06302091479301453,
0.03734871745109558,
0.039063986390829086,
0.08665428310632706,
0.001028137980028987,
-0.006432958412915468,
0.027142489328980446,
0.09399702399969101,
0.10014838725328445,
0.053808070719242096,
0.038224078714847565,
0.05923506245017052,
-0.03275071829557419,
-0.04037634655833244,
0.003242714796215296,
0.010260005481541157,
-0.019494380801916122,
-0.019618095830082893,
0.03567855805158615,
0.07134594023227692,
0.051789071410894394,
0.057339370250701904,
-0.04578985646367073,
0.012876770459115505,
0.023924455046653748,
0.03430832922458649,
0.04251876473426819,
-0.013300608843564987,
0.00001951944977918174,
0.010627060197293758,
-0.05593107268214226,
0.00152057153172791,
-0.017194435000419617,
0.007387705612927675,
-0.0066053420305252075,
0.052866432815790176,
-0.01666443608701229,
-0.0027378799859434366,
-0.03377304598689079,
0.025162776932120323,
0.07581853866577148,
0.009276282042264938,
-0.00351740256883204,
0.013657885603606701,
0.0006041474989615381,
0.018010128289461136,
0.05253688246011734,
-0.008814724162220955,
-0.022886080667376518,
-0.029696909710764885,
-0.02206253446638584,
0.004535961896181107,
0.005569308064877987,
-0.04616621509194374,
0.003946435637772083,
-0.02589595317840576,
-0.03513697534799576,
0.04001498967409134,
-0.00883494969457388,
-0.056932609528303146,
-0.0507960245013237,
-0.04218089580535889,
-0.0394647978246212,
-0.06373317539691925,
-0.05784333497285843,
0.023795418441295624,
0.0279803816229105,
-0.010836894623935223,
-0.01485337782651186,
-0.011058054864406586,
0.04691182076931,
-0.014210151508450508,
-0.05011996626853943,
-0.0035054837353527546,
0.02958041802048683,
-0.006954632233828306,
0.007162026129662991,
0.03700197860598564,
0.013255851343274117,
-0.029752500355243683,
-0.01589878275990486,
0.014605235308408737,
0.005950460210442543,
0.038516756147146225,
-0.005855940748006105,
-0.006505118682980537,
-0.07662934809923172,
0.003665441880002618,
0.03396362438797951,
0.010158531367778778,
-0.08362938463687897,
0.021031979471445084,
-0.008560648187994957,
0.009992302395403385,
0.06043433025479317,
0.0024941572919487953,
-0.038999877870082855,
-0.043484482914209366,
-0.0014055990613996983,
-0.007779539097100496,
0.014965936541557312,
0.016187241300940514,
-0.009619902819395065,
0.05823245272040367,
0.04280110448598862,
-0.03701157867908478,
-0.00987254548817873,
0.03011292777955532,
-0.011587442830204964,
0.01674494333565235,
-0.021318411454558372,
-0.03526690602302551,
-0.06267739832401276,
-0.08030375093221664,
-0.009581370279192924,
-0.011836820282042027,
-0.008537279441952705,
-0.04273177683353424,
-0.0003160125052090734,
-0.00075372657738626,
-0.03460466489195824,
-0.0003244639083277434,
-0.00830486137419939,
0.03587102144956589,
-0.057617004960775375,
-0.06787016987800598,
-0.07424532622098923,
0.007853672839701176,
-0.054990530014038086,
-0.024934783577919006,
0.0035469273570924997,
-0.047028928995132446,
-0.0073316036723554134,
-0.013072879053652287,
0.01360095851123333,
0.0069342306815087795,
0.02560257911682129,
-0.040248822420835495
] |
389 |
Plastic Learning with Deep Fourier Features
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=NIkfix2eDQ
|
[
"Alex Lewandowski",
"Dale Schuurmans",
"Marlos C. Machado"
] |
Poster
|
Deep neural networks can struggle to learn continually in the face of non-stationarity, a
phenomenon known as loss of plasticity.
In this paper, we identify underlying principles that lead to plastic algorithms.
We provide theoretical results showing that linear function approximation, as well as a special case of deep linear networks, do not suffer from loss of plasticity.
We then propose deep Fourier features, which are the concatenation of a sine and cosine in every layer, and we show that this combination provides a dynamic balance between the trainability obtained through linearity and the effectiveness obtained through the nonlinearity of neural networks.
Deep networks composed entirely of deep Fourier features are highly trainable and sustain their trainability over the course of learning.
Our empirical results show that continual learning performance can be improved by replacing ReLU activations with deep Fourier features combined with regularization.
These results hold for different continual learning scenarios (e.g., label noise, class incremental learning, pixel permutations)
on all major supervised learning datasets used for continual learning research, such as CIFAR10, CIFAR100, and tiny-ImageNet.
|
Fourier, plasticity, neural networks, continual learning
| null | 13,172 |
2410.20634
|
[
-0.0018269098363816738,
-0.01903514936566353,
-0.0033765602856874466,
0.027885982766747475,
0.03818664327263832,
0.043615490198135376,
0.01734205149114132,
0.006075464189052582,
-0.048758894205093384,
-0.04047467187047005,
0.001317863934673369,
0.004552419763058424,
-0.042011525481939316,
0.021633248776197433,
0.00871643889695406,
0.05167683959007263,
0.07067199051380157,
-0.008847483433783054,
-0.00817782897502184,
0.03837591037154198,
-0.014365121722221375,
-0.014371710829436779,
0.02075299434363842,
-0.0010389351518824697,
0.011027766391634941,
-0.045675136148929596,
0.017215905711054802,
0.004188031889498234,
-0.01788553223013878,
0.019534951075911522,
0.029268257319927216,
-0.005636594258248806,
-0.002309671835973859,
-0.026066742837429047,
0.02551068551838398,
0.027629591524600983,
-0.026928279548883438,
-0.04161639139056206,
0.004550646059215069,
0.010460148565471172,
-0.006806032732129097,
-0.012201303616166115,
-0.017222994938492775,
0.02297312766313553,
-0.07189098745584488,
0.02960033528506756,
-0.13538172841072083,
0.014647324569523335,
-0.008640388026833534,
-0.040914881974458694,
-0.0828947126865387,
0.04671573266386986,
0.018718386068940163,
-0.05970809981226921,
0.015249359421432018,
0.03399783745408058,
0.007483583875000477,
-0.05702425539493561,
-0.027786193415522575,
-0.03825188800692558,
0.0012849337654188275,
0.009687664918601513,
0.030002858489751816,
-0.014228342100977898,
-0.014967028051614761,
-0.02608266845345497,
0.0061060176230967045,
0.04360700771212578,
-0.04058757424354553,
-0.023941021412611008,
-0.02895374596118927,
-0.0036497407127171755,
-0.007323687896132469,
-0.0062694670632481575,
-0.027797598391771317,
-0.058937929570674896,
-0.013901671394705772,
0.01802944950759411,
0.08333403617143631,
0.014751885086297989,
0.004847262054681778,
0.05017130821943283,
0.04325947165489197,
0.028364552184939384,
-0.004425556864589453,
0.009748375043272972,
-0.01871163211762905,
0.0018873483641073108,
-0.07530693709850311,
0.05056897550821304,
0.008466886356472969,
-0.03895016014575958,
0.04294645041227341,
0.06295114755630493,
0.022843465209007263,
-0.029969407245516777,
0.013976960442960262,
-0.0025863652117550373,
0.02570713311433792,
0.020840877667069435,
-0.015492429956793785,
-0.033961374312639236,
-0.002735625486820936,
0.01576702669262886,
-0.06912912428379059,
-0.03774091228842735,
-0.026203308254480362,
-0.05019855499267578,
-0.021481335163116455,
0.008266420103609562,
-0.05493416637182236,
0.010801469907164574,
0.02931974083185196,
-0.023044662550091743,
-0.09218151867389679,
0.014508920721709728,
0.003377403598278761,
-0.004231566563248634,
-0.038552142679691315,
-0.010025683790445328,
0.06951478868722916,
0.06262437254190445,
-0.014266316778957844,
0.05085894837975502,
0.009625044651329517,
-0.0037390347570180893,
0.020985208451747894,
0.032711345702409744,
-0.019619952887296677,
-0.04515177756547928,
-0.016175713390111923,
0.02597406506538391,
-0.03078247793018818,
0.01483532041311264,
0.0166464876383543,
-0.024068346247076988,
-0.006762337405234575,
0.008518551476299763,
0.03538822382688522,
-0.005246452987194061,
0.018395377323031425,
-0.03897564858198166,
0.034802939742803574,
-0.038139574229717255,
0.05873238295316696,
-0.023556899279356003,
0.003610950894653797,
-0.03433353453874588,
-0.02581842802464962,
-0.021403197199106216,
0.009191500954329967,
0.015485736541450024,
0.020979953929781914,
-0.060030605643987656,
0.001709708827547729,
0.008513971231877804,
-0.022292394191026688,
0.040077656507492065,
0.011604508385062218,
-0.00007819119491614401,
0.004022460430860519,
-0.034243348985910416,
-0.01908714324235916,
0.0069501325488090515,
-0.010856621898710728,
-0.0853760689496994,
0.046297214925289154,
0.04534637928009033,
-0.022685319185256958,
0.011556271463632584,
-0.01854458451271057,
-0.017195507884025574,
0.03576372191309929,
0.02741103060543537,
0.014024178497493267,
-0.02326248772442341,
0.046144694089889526,
0.01815842092037201,
0.005805255379527807,
0.05109883099794388,
-0.09616279602050781,
0.01959904097020626,
0.021740609779953957,
0.01824549026787281,
0.026068031787872314,
-0.023883938789367676,
0.08209561556577682,
-0.06272562593221664,
0.02415214478969574,
-0.0020172889344394207,
-0.048081427812576294,
0.0004705224419012666,
0.005240376573055983,
-0.03401532024145126,
0.05801312252879143,
-0.021333761513233185,
-0.018564052879810333,
0.0027826265431940556,
0.03269456699490547,
0.05636560544371605,
0.04671342298388481,
-0.04231642559170723,
0.032528478652238846,
-0.0120261674746871,
-0.026384497061371803,
-0.009873883798718452,
0.06174943223595619,
-0.051407501101493835,
-0.016558915376663208,
0.01911504566669464,
-0.009770061820745468,
-0.01792100816965103,
0.008733011782169342,
0.023404931649565697,
-0.0004382637271191925,
-0.005716064479202032,
0.010370759293437004,
0.020955320447683334,
0.011767689138650894,
-0.03968321159482002,
0.00393710657954216,
0.03223913535475731,
-0.014662292785942554,
0.005543726496398449,
-0.03343687951564789,
0.12461806833744049,
0.0611332468688488,
-0.041953638195991516,
0.02426307275891304,
-0.009935949929058552,
0.020795118063688278,
0.006840874906629324,
-0.008938349783420563,
-0.011171803809702396,
0.014282158575952053,
0.008254705928266048,
-0.0046820929273962975,
-0.036370906978845596,
0.04771346226334572,
-0.05088876187801361,
-0.012191416695713997,
0.05378648638725281,
-0.009291580878198147,
0.046799808740615845,
-0.003189198672771454,
0.0016706323949620128,
0.049995966255664825,
-0.015174844302237034,
-0.02903217263519764,
-0.04170285537838936,
0.005382515490055084,
0.010053913109004498,
-0.01532823033630848,
-0.03973434120416641,
-0.021513625979423523,
-0.07252614200115204,
-0.059962790459394455,
0.002202895935624838,
0.0811680480837822,
0.05694116652011871,
-0.01943308301270008,
0.035109855234622955,
0.004699502140283585,
-0.046003557741642,
-0.0297259334474802,
-0.1276952624320984,
-0.03179806098341942,
-0.025077005848288536,
0.07786086201667786,
0.005794306751340628,
0.039788175374269485,
0.05134625360369682,
0.0034147745463997126,
-0.01446230337023735,
-0.054214559495449066,
0.00041282211896032095,
0.03997764736413956,
-0.006913305725902319,
-0.044718675315380096,
-0.05279574915766716,
0.01796511374413967,
0.08824221044778824,
0.02030554972589016,
-0.017936037853360176,
-0.044805485755205154,
-0.05219418182969093,
-0.033032651990652084,
-0.021310746669769287,
0.00811735913157463,
-0.012928115203976631,
-0.018345681950449944,
0.035379763692617416,
-0.024329576641321182,
0.03582930192351341,
0.0006705547566525638,
0.08236711472272873,
0.05074983462691307,
0.000574981386307627,
0.0014447798021137714,
0.018200747668743134,
0.0013851365074515343,
-0.000042586765630403534,
0.007702291011810303,
0.021797699853777885,
-0.006886494345963001,
0.012302820570766926,
0.00009864630555966869,
-0.007698902394622564,
-0.2716377377510071,
-0.018802300095558167,
0.030414871871471405,
-0.011421708390116692,
0.03361903503537178,
0.0013944681268185377,
0.02088111639022827,
-0.01908806525170803,
-0.0017747011734172702,
0.01957898773252964,
0.0007567007560282946,
0.03666554391384125,
0.0075808335095644,
0.04891861975193024,
0.01693541742861271,
0.0005415278719738126,
0.02381759136915207,
-0.023122576996684074,
-0.006256504915654659,
0.06941516697406769,
-0.009026629850268364,
-0.07292773574590683,
0.009984239004552364,
0.06520019471645355,
-0.045667052268981934,
0.025270842015743256,
-0.05877361074090004,
0.0019056459423154593,
-0.06433497369289398,
-0.02648811973631382,
-0.03582872077822685,
-0.017504682764410973,
0.016928622499108315,
0.04559880122542381,
0.017564717680215836,
0.021375756710767746,
0.016526462510228157,
-0.017824973911046982,
-0.00037036213325336576,
0.008655528537929058,
0.005649880040436983,
-0.009062200784683228,
0.01064910925924778,
0.012224693782627583,
0.09169504046440125,
0.022157378494739532,
-0.05662428215146065,
-0.019164307042956352,
-0.03420013189315796,
0.015110797248780727,
0.016640961170196533,
-0.028457120060920715,
-0.009333879686892033,
0.011914828792214394,
-0.009663349948823452,
-0.026050228625535965,
0.0009330807370133698,
-0.008563884533941746,
-0.009709901176393032,
0.018183376640081406,
0.008224986493587494,
-0.06323908269405365,
-0.01905120350420475,
-0.03235345333814621,
-0.041797708719968796,
-0.031091025099158287,
-0.07757095992565155,
-0.07597572356462479,
0.038412902504205704,
0.05085993558168411,
0.005939523223787546,
0.020140662789344788,
-0.03680478781461716,
-0.08974077552556992,
0.04623597487807274,
-0.01600039191544056,
-0.01589033752679825,
-0.013438940979540348,
0.00647618155926466,
0.046495236456394196,
-0.012428863905370235,
-0.06988316774368286,
0.03548615053296089,
-0.0016625429270789027,
0.020552873611450195,
-0.013192204758524895,
0.01125636138021946,
-0.0037213070318102837,
-0.04837481677532196,
-0.03439401835203171,
0.04392324388027191,
0.008114572614431381,
0.020805329084396362,
-0.023006068542599678,
0.030983638018369675,
0.02961258590221405,
0.014729078859090805,
0.0471670888364315,
0.03361811116337776,
-0.0005897673545405269,
0.028492292389273643,
-0.05359539017081261,
-0.019599320366978645,
-0.05652904137969017,
-0.045900747179985046,
0.007497175596654415,
-0.04944688826799393,
-0.015460608527064323,
0.06067836657166481,
0.011986148543655872,
-0.030209509655833244,
-0.027853140607476234,
0.003736116224899888,
-0.010947572998702526,
-0.015533149242401123,
-0.014764438383281231,
-0.004625838715583086,
0.022096233442425728,
0.035733047872781754,
-0.03534821420907974,
-0.03481823578476906,
0.07206951826810837,
-0.01935623213648796,
0.025097381323575974,
0.009268448688089848,
-0.02547437511384487,
-0.017772935330867767,
-0.004241658840328455,
-0.008088517934083939,
0.011072634719312191,
0.01582961715757847,
0.02116158977150917,
-0.01628929376602173,
0.02154749259352684,
0.0493970662355423,
0.017984790727496147,
-0.021234098821878433,
-0.007075149565935135,
0.04481878876686096,
-0.03195035457611084,
0.04498067870736122,
0.014045481570065022,
0.049403589218854904,
0.01860079914331436,
0.013752108439803123,
0.043702565133571625,
0.0070679765194654465,
-0.0033077222760766745,
-0.00887275394052267,
-0.0088462820276618,
0.01623985916376114,
-0.05363880842924118,
-0.03162001445889473,
-0.0023832160513848066,
-0.0038151293992996216,
0.006822141818702221,
0.04478264972567558,
0.009729171171784401,
0.0009570152615197003,
-0.06253635883331299,
0.057470712810754776,
0.04151030257344246,
-0.012018880806863308,
-0.020238254219293594,
0.004933089483529329,
0.0574282743036747,
-0.01803378388285637,
-0.03037535957992077,
0.03670075535774231,
-0.006865505129098892,
0.012751874513924122,
0.006526706274598837,
-0.008126883767545223,
-0.011162017472088337,
-0.0004997231881134212,
-0.002898037200793624,
-0.0005386691773310304,
-0.0192550215870142,
-0.01514681987464428,
0.014630225487053394,
0.028943125158548355,
0.01109603326767683,
-0.0042599574662745,
0.05363616719841957,
0.08252837508916855,
0.009467458352446556,
-0.0030646405648440123,
-0.00728467246517539,
-0.04679333418607712,
0.03703462332487106,
-0.010806390084326267,
0.012686940841376781,
-0.041735511273145676,
-0.021977033466100693,
-0.02537422627210617,
-0.02495306357741356,
0.010323847644031048,
0.057504504919052124,
-0.008556709624826908,
-0.030875543132424355,
-0.03681248798966408,
0.0013153809122741222,
-0.0320146270096302,
0.0038977223448455334,
0.01834101974964142,
-0.07688276469707489,
0.014949679374694824,
0.029355261474847794,
-0.030580565333366394,
-0.006400492042303085,
-0.025519415736198425,
-0.035106465220451355,
-0.059045739471912384,
-0.03980359435081482,
-0.02828807197511196,
-0.0009610068518668413,
0.009895768016576767,
0.0028581919614225626,
-0.006284368224442005,
-0.022775888442993164,
0.010138086974620819,
-0.005613900721073151,
0.0006417251424863935,
-0.013333309441804886,
-0.012719777412712574,
0.0568167082965374,
-0.009973538108170033,
0.017531631514430046,
0.01976516656577587,
-0.017157403752207756,
0.02830454520881176,
-0.037551045417785645,
0.018847577273845673,
0.06303467601537704,
-0.026525016874074936,
-0.0004195398942101747,
-0.03710908442735672,
0.04947918653488159,
-0.03258175775408745,
0.002902843290939927,
-0.020837418735027313,
0.006809679325670004,
-0.05554753541946411,
0.016019560396671295,
-0.02035616524517536,
0.02401827834546566,
0.013707541860640049,
0.018276439979672432,
-0.017413834109902382,
0.018095731735229492,
0.010225063189864159,
0.01695692352950573,
-0.04183793067932129,
-0.030405789613723755,
0.030459679663181305,
-0.04920655116438866,
-0.01406679768115282,
-0.08528883755207062,
-0.0066644055768847466,
0.015377961099147797,
-0.022418728098273277,
0.024751367047429085,
-0.038917288184165955,
0.0528191402554512,
0.050130732357501984,
0.05749191716313362,
-0.007533148862421513,
-0.011379178613424301,
0.03582382947206497,
-0.040324967354536057,
-0.0333213284611702,
-0.06553589552640915,
-0.029209254309535027,
0.05939967930316925,
-0.0028288811445236206,
0.029123226180672646,
-0.0020658858120441437,
-0.014786990359425545,
0.05665747448801994,
-0.04313477501273155,
-0.04600364342331886,
0.025695662945508957,
-0.04925444349646568,
-0.00973539613187313,
0.012941937893629074,
-0.05318840965628624,
-0.025366198271512985,
-0.023251917213201523,
-0.043733928352594376,
-0.011100873351097107,
0.03184852376580238,
0.03596005216240883,
-0.0060273585841059685,
0.012489872984588146,
-0.003941682167351246,
0.023576509207487106,
-0.0018112377729266882,
0.055406566709280014,
0.024671336635947227,
0.04914180561900139,
-0.04769866168498993,
0.0919070765376091,
0.035570282489061356,
0.02045215666294098,
0.004608032759279013,
0.030919592827558517,
0.011511165648698807,
-0.06579424440860748,
0.041864052414894104,
0.0005896014627069235,
-0.036006130278110504,
-0.05262083187699318,
-0.0032044851686805487,
0.017383713275194168,
-0.03949550911784172,
-0.02903146669268608,
0.053140994161367416,
-0.036565572023391724,
0.014469990506768227,
0.033876702189445496,
-0.015449505299329758,
-0.025454003363847733,
0.06680261343717575,
0.00843701884150505,
0.01670880801975727,
0.07366906851530075,
0.011250248178839684,
-0.002783491974696517,
0.015476087108254433,
0.08044007420539856,
0.06126801669597626,
0.018459677696228027,
0.007149866316467524,
0.06077153608202934,
-0.025094540789723396,
-0.06460586190223694,
0.01273970678448677,
0.0227675698697567,
0.0026982855051755905,
-0.040625203400850296,
0.02311316505074501,
0.09276732802391052,
0.05240164324641228,
0.06482996046543121,
-0.03673981875181198,
0.004040003288537264,
-0.01237558014690876,
-0.008920946158468723,
0.0042367964051663876,
0.04942120611667633,
0.03472962602972984,
0.0023342547938227654,
-0.03238461911678314,
-0.054432597011327744,
0.004607627168297768,
-0.029532337561249733,
0.014446381479501724,
0.01947912946343422,
-0.008099926635622978,
0.018350999802350998,
0.010977862402796745,
0.07830338925123215,
0.09194821119308472,
-0.03844437375664711,
-0.06845008581876755,
0.0009908111533150077,
0.019219236448407173,
0.019100556150078773,
0.009555613622069359,
0.01695101521909237,
-0.004805696662515402,
0.0367908775806427,
-0.020274104550480843,
0.02993037737905979,
0.032996173948049545,
-0.007068482227623463,
0.019432425498962402,
-0.04997379332780838,
-0.047941677272319794,
0.03326468914747238,
0.030724644660949707,
-0.0246895644813776,
-0.0570547953248024,
-0.0334719717502594,
-0.04259951412677765,
-0.06355887651443481,
-0.04550784453749657,
0.033575624227523804,
-0.014040553011000156,
-0.05409747734665871,
-0.03891606256365776,
0.012116644531488419,
0.0048026698641479015,
0.026004865765571594,
-0.061060525476932526,
-0.012384440749883652,
0.058883558958768845,
0.016737641766667366,
-0.005450117401778698,
-0.014215659350156784,
0.017226319760084152,
-0.016085386276245117,
-0.01172710582613945,
0.0500602088868618,
-0.007917802780866623,
0.02013549581170082,
-0.014560016803443432,
-0.006807201076298952,
-0.07672004401683807,
0.023309392854571342,
0.029999295249581337,
-0.027283981442451477,
-0.08641833066940308,
0.05359106510877609,
-0.043751996010541916,
0.00768365478143096,
0.050914715975522995,
-0.004515858832746744,
0.016859928146004677,
-0.056450266391038895,
0.007347882259637117,
-0.00162409245967865,
0.006027444265782833,
0.07620254904031754,
0.005860605277121067,
0.04813206568360329,
0.04002799466252327,
-0.00813339464366436,
0.004346730653196573,
0.006228371523320675,
-0.026490330696105957,
-0.006707251071929932,
-0.017544744536280632,
-0.040768951177597046,
-0.022587662562727928,
-0.0943855494260788,
-0.028344539925456047,
0.004517269320785999,
-0.004996000789105892,
-0.05061996728181839,
0.007407724391669035,
0.015301589854061604,
-0.00014160657883621752,
-0.00808027759194374,
0.005559074692428112,
-0.003551075467839837,
-0.015099316835403442,
-0.026498908177018166,
-0.052602529525756836,
0.03823581710457802,
0.019278325140476227,
0.04594625160098076,
-0.012075918726623058,
-0.045890454202890396,
0.002819063840433955,
-0.014999110251665115,
0.027673305943608284,
0.02239312417805195,
-0.0013323689345270395,
-0.027782468125224113
] |
390 |
STAFF: Speculative Coreset Selection for Task-Specific Fine-tuning
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=FAfxvdv1Dy
|
[
"Xiaoyu Zhang",
"Juan Zhai",
"Shiqing Ma",
"Chao Shen",
"Tianlin Li",
"Weipeng Jiang",
"Yang Liu"
] |
Poster
|
Task-specific fine-tuning is essential for the deployment of large language models (LLMs), but it requires significant computational resources and time. Existing solutions have proposed coreset selection methods to improve data efficiency and reduce model training overhead, but they still have limitations: ❶ Overlooking valuable samples at high pruning rates, which degrades the coreset’s performance.
❷ Requiring high time overhead during coreset selection to fine-tune and evaluate the target LLM. In this paper, we introduce STAFF, a speculative coreset selection method. STAFF leverages a small model from the same family as the target LLM to efficiently estimate data scores and then verifies the scores on the target LLM to accurately identify and allocate more selection budget to important regions while maintaining coverage of easy regions. We evaluate STAFF on three LLMs and three downstream tasks and show that STAFF improves the performance of SOTA methods by up to 54.3% and reduces selection overhead by up to 70.5% at different pruning rates. Furthermore, we observe that the coreset selected by STAFF at low pruning rates (i.e., 20%) can even obtain better fine-tuning performance than the full dataset.
|
Task-specific fine-tuning, coreset selection, speculative execution
|
We propose STAFF, a speculative coreset selection method for task-specific fine-tuning that outperforms SOTA methods with much lower selection overhead.
| 13,170 | null |
[
-0.020651688799262047,
-0.031398702412843704,
-0.012151814065873623,
0.03962309658527374,
0.044507913291454315,
0.06011755019426346,
0.006957234349101782,
0.026421520859003067,
-0.02113073132932186,
-0.022845255210995674,
-0.03458124399185181,
0.02561315894126892,
-0.05378905311226845,
-0.02350315824151039,
-0.01905757188796997,
0.062111858278512955,
0.03373539075255394,
-0.0270951259881258,
0.030065692961215973,
-0.027947044000029564,
0.02470688335597515,
-0.004684037994593382,
0.057820942252874374,
0.020718006417155266,
0.00500250980257988,
0.007064783480018377,
0.008455046452581882,
0.004558801185339689,
-0.02351219579577446,
-0.019649958238005638,
0.018806450068950653,
-0.010404030792415142,
0.01254875585436821,
-0.016515549272298813,
-0.013225284405052662,
-0.018279699608683586,
-0.018758466467261314,
0.031182648614048958,
0.015472037717700005,
0.01889771595597267,
-0.02839934267103672,
0.02896609529852867,
0.0067846206948161125,
0.03892970085144043,
-0.0416879840195179,
0.027171555906534195,
-0.10442662239074707,
0.021091528236865997,
0.017340954393148422,
-0.053578395396471024,
-0.11852450668811798,
0.03828281909227371,
0.019526615738868713,
-0.03331845998764038,
0.030607324093580246,
0.027017001062631607,
0.03230196237564087,
-0.11022982001304626,
-0.010615584440529346,
-0.03677049279212952,
-0.06961754709482193,
0.0070597524754703045,
-0.005447979550808668,
0.02247471548616886,
0.01147844735532999,
-0.03836739435791969,
-0.014018268324434757,
0.019320130348205566,
-0.07639037817716599,
-0.01356446836143732,
0.002299393294379115,
0.028134586289525032,
0.006645177956670523,
0.005716286133974791,
0.027184156700968742,
-0.03599562123417854,
0.015422522090375423,
0.052139103412628174,
0.08873678743839264,
0.003936656750738621,
-0.0047781807370483875,
0.006423476617783308,
0.019518468528985977,
0.04787594825029373,
0.014043023809790611,
0.008798038586974144,
-0.06816422939300537,
-0.03156260773539543,
-0.07244960218667984,
0.04761301353573799,
0.009210389107465744,
-0.07062181085348129,
0.01629236713051796,
0.024936692789196968,
0.003470944706350565,
0.05344367399811745,
0.013294845819473267,
0.027387140318751335,
-0.004448849242180586,
0.02503111958503723,
-0.03219321742653847,
-0.042758915573358536,
0.039719801396131516,
0.04474480077624321,
-0.12296060472726822,
-0.022859355434775352,
-0.020754771307110786,
-0.005031585693359375,
-0.0069894939661026,
0.007602010387927294,
-0.030338549986481667,
-0.01715910993516445,
0.007085834164172411,
0.0094813983887434,
-0.07568471133708954,
0.021014492958784103,
-0.0033096899278461933,
0.015107746236026287,
-0.00798862800002098,
-0.009277849458158016,
0.06572850793600082,
0.06149671599268913,
-0.012120959348976612,
0.05099571496248245,
-0.02665967121720314,
0.009577589109539986,
0.011440850794315338,
0.007116291206330061,
-0.025531092658638954,
-0.05051962286233902,
0.028837917372584343,
0.05534420162439346,
0.02474479004740715,
-0.030045276507735252,
-0.022996123880147934,
0.010811436921358109,
-0.008216808550059795,
0.013013423420488834,
0.07381045073270798,
0.018376849591732025,
0.003202560357749462,
-0.012565799988806248,
0.02463117241859436,
-0.005639706738293171,
0.057603493332862854,
-0.0069307140074670315,
-0.050599344074726105,
-0.012697989121079445,
-0.020323118194937706,
-0.00019452253764029592,
0.03015713393688202,
0.01991530880331993,
-0.012404819950461388,
-0.04539470002055168,
0.04284894838929176,
0.05968731269240379,
0.03375685587525368,
-0.009637883864343166,
0.012512662447988987,
0.007334793917834759,
0.010111445561051369,
0.01922798901796341,
-0.053217560052871704,
-0.004156781826168299,
0.011589940637350082,
-0.056245192885398865,
0.02917311154305935,
0.004890833515673876,
-0.014293728396296501,
0.03306964039802551,
-0.055013108998537064,
-0.014215866103768349,
0.046620648354291916,
-0.02600955031812191,
-0.02238321304321289,
0.004408333450555801,
0.037587106227874756,
-0.006357988342642784,
0.05435382202267647,
0.054448314011096954,
-0.061938297003507614,
0.006154804956167936,
0.017020508646965027,
-0.020096002146601677,
-0.011290795169770718,
-0.011251718737185001,
0.09488669037818909,
-0.023302922025322914,
0.006600706838071346,
-0.006346320733428001,
-0.06550901383161545,
-0.0271120835095644,
0.024651972576975822,
0.020713109523057938,
0.03697096183896065,
0.016015099361538887,
-0.0019467760575935245,
0.07151192426681519,
0.03248187527060509,
0.07034886628389359,
0.06844697147607803,
-0.021359961479902267,
0.03017650917172432,
-0.03676548972725868,
-0.03379814699292183,
-0.01181931421160698,
0.014718088321387768,
-0.05569608137011528,
-0.03229257091879845,
0.035687368363142014,
-0.004642846994102001,
0.013951319269835949,
0.032836876809597015,
-0.009346382692456245,
0.00014029732847120613,
0.00596199557185173,
-0.008711542934179306,
-0.01941540651023388,
0.010675961151719093,
-0.06868570297956467,
0.032895393669605255,
0.0590243935585022,
-0.008409839123487473,
-0.009437148459255695,
-0.026345135644078255,
0.07988374680280685,
0.04371443763375282,
-0.019221028313040733,
-0.017253119498491287,
0.02985493466258049,
0.020874284207820892,
-0.0106584457680583,
0.02001025341451168,
-0.033604323863983154,
0.015449746511876583,
-0.023913316428661346,
-0.022091280668973923,
-0.025329554453492165,
0.026468880474567413,
-0.04379208758473396,
-0.00012902537127956748,
0.07334230095148087,
-0.014476973563432693,
0.06434564292430878,
0.029227351769804955,
-0.0025883265770971775,
0.012418613769114017,
-0.02739500254392624,
-0.027741210535168648,
-0.028019379824399948,
-0.01972411386668682,
-0.006170797161757946,
-0.04163021594285965,
-0.04430919885635376,
-0.019841475412249565,
-0.04402150958776474,
-0.015164408832788467,
-0.010392794385552406,
0.052299339324235916,
0.03461042419075966,
-0.006665242835879326,
-0.0029611466452479362,
0.008670615032315254,
-0.05506392568349838,
0.023136254400014877,
-0.10511228442192078,
0.007071124855428934,
-0.03376809135079384,
0.033563390374183655,
-0.019190719351172447,
0.031169001013040543,
-0.028122616931796074,
0.013752557337284088,
-0.032772574573755264,
-0.03264894708991051,
-0.017970891669392586,
0.011553864926099777,
0.005544883664697409,
-0.028868388384580612,
-0.02378380298614502,
0.00892256386578083,
0.04824981093406677,
-0.0154899125918746,
-0.04554145783185959,
-0.05653377249836922,
-0.04077763855457306,
0.006411826238036156,
-0.07358291745185852,
0.0008573728846386075,
0.00614183209836483,
0.021453583613038063,
-0.005500181578099728,
-0.029367296025156975,
-0.00807854626327753,
0.04012513905763626,
0.02575026825070381,
0.03702632710337639,
0.02583705075085163,
-0.033601559698581696,
0.005891754757612944,
-0.03338731825351715,
0.0328974723815918,
-0.011835750192403793,
0.03465548902750015,
-0.015984229743480682,
0.007839703001081944,
0.019718090072274208,
-0.003897542366757989,
-0.27914148569107056,
-0.03134678304195404,
0.004083654843270779,
-0.018322300165891647,
0.024653827771544456,
-0.011778507381677628,
0.04995500668883324,
-0.023571129888296127,
0.0015609066467732191,
-0.004937827121466398,
0.015425676479935646,
0.03931117430329323,
-0.008589656092226505,
0.06612301617860794,
0.03496197983622551,
0.031484391540288925,
-0.009361947886645794,
-0.028820514678955078,
0.01425773836672306,
0.028133701533079147,
0.020009230822324753,
-0.06324989348649979,
0.006587454117834568,
0.041808951646089554,
-0.003151078475639224,
0.07158900797367096,
-0.09364479780197144,
0.004365043714642525,
-0.03424973413348198,
0.005111023783683777,
-0.00559266610071063,
-0.021020106971263885,
-0.00008435192285105586,
0.02240632474422455,
0.005234662443399429,
-0.017628394067287445,
0.06725147366523743,
0.020900428295135498,
0.056541793048381805,
0.032921332865953445,
0.021562427282333374,
-0.048493918031454086,
-0.03831220790743828,
0.0017349496483802795,
0.06599211692810059,
-0.006009167060256004,
-0.0875597596168518,
-0.03808777406811714,
-0.004073204938322306,
0.02777671441435814,
-0.005845281295478344,
-0.03205743432044983,
-0.02244764193892479,
0.01027920376509428,
-0.0042374012991786,
0.017027735710144043,
0.006061657331883907,
-0.018064552918076515,
-0.028962252661585808,
0.007046072743833065,
0.007423193659633398,
-0.06325037032365799,
0.008960799314081669,
-0.06605120748281479,
-0.04218025133013725,
-0.02826450765132904,
-0.06995633989572525,
-0.022164130583405495,
0.031007694080471992,
0.023030323907732964,
-0.018551183864474297,
-0.0021010327618569136,
0.031649135053157806,
-0.09361439198255539,
-0.009758852422237396,
-0.019441615790128708,
-0.0026142450515180826,
-0.011255624704062939,
-0.0002787995617836714,
0.0647498369216919,
-0.017135323956608772,
-0.028486967086791992,
0.003538663499057293,
0.03137071058154106,
0.0656575858592987,
-0.041533175855875015,
-0.005210301373153925,
-0.020517976954579353,
0.0021504766773432493,
-0.02987796440720558,
0.0311043169349432,
0.02202140912413597,
0.01878451369702816,
0.01691552996635437,
0.058038000017404556,
0.02993260882794857,
0.0227889996021986,
0.06210413947701454,
0.018257347866892815,
0.017464814707636833,
0.022980812937021255,
-0.07296839356422424,
-0.006480788812041283,
-0.04163176193833351,
-0.04126574471592903,
0.034386709332466125,
-0.05499707907438278,
-0.019999228417873383,
0.01518717035651207,
0.0007670971099287271,
-0.013550973497331142,
-0.03462183102965355,
0.013036114163696766,
0.004063352942466736,
-0.0046895039267838,
0.00048514126683585346,
0.023250995203852654,
0.03690282255411148,
0.021740922704339027,
0.007065332029014826,
-0.04730712249875069,
0.02179737575352192,
-0.015528564341366291,
-0.012271435000002384,
-0.010204081423580647,
-0.03528188169002533,
0.014215472154319286,
-0.024652212858200073,
-0.031537462025880814,
-0.013744787313044071,
0.03540922328829765,
0.025564678013324738,
0.0009741478133946657,
0.018077988177537918,
0.048067063093185425,
-0.0024121846072375774,
0.007956732995808125,
0.007620318327099085,
0.01718795672059059,
-0.021154189482331276,
-0.004097719676792622,
0.002601546933874488,
0.051489703357219696,
0.028333768248558044,
0.04503647983074188,
0.015025301836431026,
0.026242733001708984,
-0.03944339230656624,
0.0023517273366451263,
0.02723887749016285,
0.028308000415563583,
-0.025477085262537003,
-0.001729177893139422,
-0.03187767416238785,
0.009884702041745186,
0.014437422156333923,
0.0017372261499986053,
0.0030534889083355665,
0.020850801840424538,
-0.058737896382808685,
0.04590067267417908,
-0.02749641425907612,
0.0011743165086954832,
-0.012056735344231129,
0.04261166974902153,
0.0020190845243632793,
-0.01754378341138363,
0.02250799350440502,
0.012737713754177094,
0.028627630323171616,
-0.00017541684792377055,
-0.019167402759194374,
-0.043670594692230225,
0.01725005730986595,
-0.00011686309153446928,
0.010887504555284977,
0.029480936005711555,
0.00492116017267108,
-0.019628114998340607,
0.06575723737478256,
-0.007465166039764881,
0.03511630371212959,
-0.018694717437028885,
0.014397481456398964,
0.07994800806045532,
0.03570821136236191,
-0.008490473963320255,
0.02766283228993416,
-0.013921843841671944,
0.009135603904724121,
-0.017105061560869217,
-0.01649627275764942,
0.0017708969535306096,
-0.006902990397065878,
-0.040767602622509,
-0.03661121800541878,
0.017718546092510223,
0.008172235451638699,
0.001765094231814146,
-0.019221631810069084,
-0.027317039668560028,
-0.00604749983176589,
-0.06069890782237053,
-0.011802846565842628,
0.03389333188533783,
-0.05983765795826912,
0.011126485653221607,
0.02480206824839115,
0.002705252030864358,
0.04021965712308884,
-0.04390024393796921,
-0.030226396396756172,
-0.03435778245329857,
-0.005131208337843418,
0.03152013197541237,
-0.07898245751857758,
-0.01976901665329933,
-0.027319319546222687,
-0.010942164808511734,
-0.014550221152603626,
-0.015922006219625473,
-0.017562540248036385,
0.015327902510762215,
-0.016685446724295616,
-0.004962929058820009,
0.05692368745803833,
-0.0025741334538906813,
-0.019904809072613716,
-0.005480890162289143,
-0.04657876119017601,
0.04024609550833702,
-0.048538222908973694,
0.03080066666007042,
0.019856667146086693,
0.003093855921179056,
0.001887898426502943,
-0.019864708185195923,
0.038072679191827774,
0.07058066129684448,
-0.015613092109560966,
0.013057257980108261,
-0.003053522203117609,
-0.01092084776610136,
-0.003061513416469097,
-0.046445805579423904,
0.006990526802837849,
0.012197262607514858,
0.008429175242781639,
-0.011068075895309448,
-0.0007149442099034786,
-0.006843418348580599,
0.03067232482135296,
-0.04597406089305878,
-0.016654103994369507,
0.05412859842181206,
-0.020470594987273216,
-0.04930562898516655,
-0.0933602973818779,
-0.051730845123529434,
0.0018571029650047421,
-0.029526421800255775,
0.01422161515802145,
-0.012471258640289307,
0.022609446197748184,
0.019740618765354156,
0.05039108172059059,
-0.018095212057232857,
-0.058172281831502914,
0.047028329223394394,
-0.03389614075422287,
0.0006479511503130198,
-0.07067123055458069,
-0.048419009894132614,
0.05345863476395607,
-0.0272915568202734,
-0.0014590491773560643,
0.0042797294445335865,
-0.028003834187984467,
0.03440951183438301,
-0.0028638041112571955,
-0.04334469512104988,
0.009792394936084747,
-0.018140757456421852,
0.021893581375479698,
0.03259226679801941,
-0.02673356980085373,
0.004829420708119869,
-0.020906491205096245,
-0.022007329389452934,
0.004227597266435623,
0.0048358566127717495,
0.05911005288362503,
-0.05414659529924393,
0.019461501389741898,
-0.08243194967508316,
-0.003515486139804125,
0.0080812256783247,
0.06593338400125504,
0.02680223621428013,
0.040936823934316635,
-0.012260830029845238,
0.0549258328974247,
0.05981402471661568,
-0.022338205948472023,
-0.027653824537992477,
-0.020326832309365273,
-0.028119530528783798,
-0.0490487739443779,
0.018814586102962494,
-0.02207273244857788,
-0.004684634506702423,
-0.045723870396614075,
0.08428923785686493,
0.032841067761182785,
-0.0579117052257061,
-0.02544216625392437,
0.007900821976363659,
-0.02801622822880745,
0.013261640444397926,
-0.023492733016610146,
0.007829824462532997,
-0.01312556117773056,
0.07513817399740219,
0.05807218328118324,
0.03424004837870598,
0.09404831379652023,
-0.005323632620275021,
-0.006926135625690222,
-0.004995410796254873,
0.059703949838876724,
0.04173240438103676,
0.0565568171441555,
-0.010949968360364437,
0.0459698885679245,
-0.05854683369398117,
-0.06174727529287338,
0.023949436843395233,
0.033287663012742996,
-0.0030895820818841457,
-0.02381858043372631,
0.029618460685014725,
0.05755200982093811,
-0.0064545078203082085,
0.0725875273346901,
-0.02396075613796711,
-0.008277438580989838,
0.042512379586696625,
0.020266879349946976,
0.01950789801776409,
0.0726999044418335,
0.005422021262347698,
0.03406919538974762,
-0.029290758073329926,
-0.0001346917124465108,
0.033563580363988876,
-0.026728520169854164,
-0.028393397107720375,
0.007884753867983818,
-0.02661731094121933,
-0.002212432213127613,
-0.02546326443552971,
0.036980994045734406,
0.1020062118768692,
-0.011865463107824326,
-0.05174092575907707,
0.018549161031842232,
0.0265082698315382,
0.03033534064888954,
0.06523288041353226,
-0.015865659341216087,
-0.006305026821792126,
-0.02957216650247574,
-0.03234803304076195,
-0.003432763973250985,
-0.006854453589767218,
-0.025025345385074615,
0.025480842217803,
-0.036136265844106674,
-0.027563096955418587,
0.016770673915743828,
0.0057338327169418335,
-0.09136661142110825,
-0.03423963859677315,
-0.006758912932127714,
-0.032952453941106796,
-0.03092472068965435,
-0.05040089786052704,
-0.016231834888458252,
0.006271533668041229,
0.012913495302200317,
-0.01910468190908432,
-0.04933829978108406,
-0.0006585668888874352,
0.024926049634814262,
-0.0481911301612854,
-0.0029465132392942905,
0.026960892602801323,
-0.01718262769281864,
-0.025981657207012177,
0.06005972623825073,
0.035349078476428986,
-0.010001867078244686,
0.008613813668489456,
0.060978878289461136,
0.020702561363577843,
0.03461142256855965,
0.016344912350177765,
0.018255800008773804,
-0.08093223720788956,
-0.009860942140221596,
0.027777211740612984,
-0.008443108759820461,
-0.07829353213310242,
0.019130975008010864,
-0.03031458891928196,
0.03687817603349686,
0.06386345624923706,
0.03519554063677788,
0.031200934201478958,
-0.00569152319803834,
-0.014982934109866619,
0.02490227483212948,
0.029221713542938232,
0.03695353493094444,
-0.03144849091768265,
0.07680951058864594,
0.04081078618764877,
-0.026846950873732567,
-0.05603714659810066,
0.027988146990537643,
-0.02084398828446865,
-0.002059022430330515,
-0.02650594338774681,
-0.01971546746790409,
-0.04327518492937088,
-0.0778181180357933,
-0.027795104309916496,
0.02723725140094757,
0.006528779864311218,
-0.03642825782299042,
0.0015287284040823579,
-0.03777544945478439,
-0.047492966055870056,
0.007000092417001724,
-0.0037776678800582886,
-0.014402458444237709,
-0.03576534986495972,
-0.009721807204186916,
-0.03996742144227028,
-0.0044031147845089436,
-0.04272421821951866,
-0.01742645353078842,
-0.03284674510359764,
-0.029565000906586647,
-0.01583864353597164,
0.007298476994037628,
0.060686443001031876,
0.0009660492651164532,
-0.004640865605324507,
-0.017504291608929634
] |
391 |
Time-to-Event Pretraining for 3D Medical Imaging
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=zcTLpIfj9u
|
[
"Zepeng Frazier Huo",
"Jason Alan Fries",
"Alejandro Lozano",
"Jeya Maria Jose Valanarasu",
"Ethan Steinberg",
"Louis Blankemeier",
"Akshay S Chaudhari",
"Curtis Langlotz",
"Nigam Shah"
] |
Poster
|
With the rise of medical foundation models and the growing availability of imaging data, scalable pretraining techniques offer a promising way to identify imaging biomarkers predictive of future disease risk. While current self-supervised methods for 3D medical imaging models capture local structural features like organ morphology, they fail to link pixel biomarkers with long-term health outcomes due to a missing context problem. Current approaches lack the temporal context necessary to identify biomarkers correlated with disease progression, as they rely on supervision derived only from images and concurrent text descriptions. To address this, we introduce time-to-event pretraining, a pretraining framework for 3D medical imaging models that leverages large-scale temporal supervision from paired, longitudinal electronic health records (EHRs). Using a dataset of 18,945 CT scans (4.2 million 2D images) and time-to-event distributions across thousands of EHR-derived tasks, our method improves outcome prediction, achieving an average AUROC increase of 23.7% and a 29.4% gain in Harrell’s C-index across 8 benchmark tasks. Importantly, these gains are achieved without sacrificing diagnostic classification performance. This study lays the foundation for integrating longitudinal EHR and 3D imaging data to advance clinical risk prediction.
|
Multimodal learning, medical imaging, Electronic Health Records
| null | 13,164 |
2411.09361
|
[
0.014970590360462666,
-0.0054167830385267735,
-0.026716310530900955,
0.018091801553964615,
0.039486002177000046,
0.010381730273365974,
0.027120983228087425,
0.009744839742779732,
-0.007567288354039192,
-0.04632898420095444,
0.008292890153825283,
0.0067906370386481285,
-0.04239460453391075,
0.02363119088113308,
0.025899238884449005,
0.04205857589840889,
0.060214679688215256,
-0.022282248362898827,
0.005061138421297073,
0.026133548468351364,
-0.017865145578980446,
-0.062250182032585144,
0.00986552331596613,
0.012798595242202282,
0.0028340553399175406,
0.017034858465194702,
0.013683152385056019,
-0.021008623763918877,
-0.033426810055971146,
0.015431517735123634,
0.04853937402367592,
-0.023151516914367676,
-0.002041690982878208,
-0.05738680437207222,
0.03358336165547371,
0.028832651674747467,
-0.019326310604810715,
0.0036227258387953043,
0.001976779429242015,
-0.014737552031874657,
-0.04903673753142357,
-0.000476678746053949,
-0.022538922727108,
-0.0017991333734244108,
-0.0794643685221672,
0.024999437853693962,
-0.08969023078680038,
0.02367306314408779,
0.02869906835258007,
-0.009800687432289124,
-0.07101447880268097,
0.006681011989712715,
0.0038827715907245874,
-0.011522294022142887,
0.02161410078406334,
0.035101644694805145,
0.06038523465394974,
-0.053496699780225754,
-0.03616177290678024,
-0.03338651359081268,
0.008823852986097336,
0.01552276685833931,
-0.003007739782333374,
-0.0010110759176313877,
0.0024828603491187096,
-0.02645302191376686,
-0.0002472424821462482,
0.06933874636888504,
-0.03008825145661831,
-0.02770521491765976,
-0.01385823730379343,
0.006839668843895197,
-0.0012488801730796695,
0.02125660702586174,
0.007706142961978912,
-0.03728871047496796,
-0.028294965624809265,
-0.03980230167508125,
0.07132060080766678,
0.0003180391213390976,
0.04362800717353821,
-0.009672009386122227,
0.02466205507516861,
0.013806191273033619,
-0.012406483292579651,
0.0037664195988327265,
-0.020871477201581,
-0.04092508181929588,
-0.06446918100118637,
0.053449008613824844,
0.0020005174446851015,
-0.021233683452010155,
0.023699849843978882,
0.02162676490843296,
0.041808128356933594,
0.01107060443609953,
0.012793658301234245,
-0.01025417074561119,
-0.02231760323047638,
-0.03151024132966995,
-0.017199069261550903,
-0.026795757934451103,
-0.001950500882230699,
-0.006417912896722555,
-0.09298425167798996,
-0.004265278112143278,
-0.03409827873110771,
-0.01668851636350155,
-0.010151650756597519,
-0.012623680755496025,
-0.035216234624385834,
0.009730092249810696,
-0.011204131878912449,
-0.011416204273700714,
-0.06269010156393051,
0.027306120842695236,
0.007163997273892164,
0.012358726933598518,
0.007210737094283104,
-0.06457872688770294,
0.039494600147008896,
0.05918838083744049,
0.0030928300693631172,
0.05436147376894951,
-0.008858250454068184,
0.024534590542316437,
0.027791429311037064,
-0.0029031981248408556,
-0.035563141107559204,
-0.005994508974254131,
-0.018830638378858566,
0.034350086003541946,
0.008685567416250706,
-0.003129475051537156,
0.016582181677222252,
0.01344539225101471,
0.01287604495882988,
-0.010482769459486008,
0.046086132526397705,
0.00020791837596334517,
0.05274353176355362,
-0.031197456642985344,
0.03633476421236992,
-0.024322710931301117,
0.06402630358934402,
-0.034542858600616455,
-0.018098052591085434,
-0.005135773681104183,
-0.028819615021348,
0.04408831521868706,
0.014346279203891754,
0.008775170892477036,
0.01692814752459526,
-0.07551009207963943,
0.02413594163954258,
0.04661576449871063,
0.017101559787988663,
0.0009271877934224904,
0.011186056770384312,
-0.005313055589795113,
0.02452988363802433,
0.013843893073499203,
-0.02911701612174511,
0.024225041270256042,
-0.023895515128970146,
-0.037513941526412964,
0.044954393059015274,
-0.007875262759625912,
-0.03712015971541405,
0.009148240089416504,
-0.046158477663993835,
-0.06427409499883652,
0.05395578220486641,
-0.013748069293797016,
-0.006035833619534969,
0.0034023646730929613,
0.053657740354537964,
-0.016995642334222794,
0.024570923298597336,
0.0020585251040756702,
-0.08597538620233536,
0.027234679087996483,
0.00880531594157219,
-0.020212356001138687,
0.044742099940776825,
-0.05273347720503807,
0.09975650161504745,
-0.034741003066301346,
-0.011806489899754524,
0.0668075755238533,
-0.07175841182470322,
-0.020754491910338402,
0.04547369107604027,
-0.02253926731646061,
0.05458179488778114,
0.0014742650091648102,
-0.003022710559889674,
0.06388553977012634,
-0.00548166036605835,
0.04575921967625618,
0.029070567339658737,
-0.005757548380643129,
0.031089043244719505,
0.008434141054749489,
-0.041534051299095154,
-0.013610939495265484,
0.0265729408711195,
-0.06361746788024902,
-0.036161646246910095,
0.01243077777326107,
0.004288800526410341,
0.005538993515074253,
-0.004485800862312317,
0.03880241513252258,
0.031346045434474945,
0.047561027109622955,
0.028880642727017403,
0.03586513176560402,
-0.037081122398376465,
-0.07742730528116226,
0.02320995181798935,
-0.003024815581738949,
-0.027070296928286552,
0.01705164648592472,
-0.012911374680697918,
0.10889381170272827,
0.0643262043595314,
-0.028940744698047638,
-0.004672227893024683,
-0.0201099943369627,
0.03834548965096474,
0.020220400765538216,
0.007930424995720387,
-0.018776455894112587,
0.020570632070302963,
-0.008138542994856834,
0.0055995299480855465,
-0.024225806817412376,
0.026735279709100723,
-0.030803771689534187,
0.002128021791577339,
0.034867431968450546,
-0.025501945987343788,
0.03803558275103569,
0.025430263951420784,
-0.0061099231243133545,
0.040904898196458817,
-0.004344251938164234,
-0.06988009810447693,
-0.05401310324668884,
0.0036771835293620825,
0.0071346936747431755,
-0.03634661063551903,
0.011072248220443726,
0.024491053074598312,
-0.08213631063699722,
0.004079164005815983,
0.015748418867588043,
0.04232260212302208,
0.03498900309205055,
0.023802947252988815,
0.042258668690919876,
0.011478175409138203,
-0.03433087468147278,
0.012211198918521404,
-0.11199259757995605,
-0.04361824691295624,
-0.047092538326978683,
0.025466788560152054,
-0.023956622928380966,
0.06078575924038887,
-0.016340462490916252,
0.0030712501611560583,
-0.013876122422516346,
-0.03727828338742256,
0.0021986414212733507,
0.019417166709899902,
0.015875596553087234,
-0.06524793803691864,
0.00927202869206667,
0.02172531746327877,
0.06142178922891617,
-0.024470007047057152,
-0.030568592250347137,
-0.027756843715906143,
-0.036364465951919556,
-0.020589478313922882,
-0.0351700559258461,
-0.006130955182015896,
0.010731901973485947,
-0.017620328813791275,
0.045543260872364044,
-0.009562315419316292,
0.0209015142172575,
0.05142269283533096,
0.05456665903329849,
0.036675043404102325,
0.02284497581422329,
-0.03491876274347305,
0.014761384576559067,
-0.026607822626829147,
0.02053305134177208,
0.014112873934209347,
-0.022635526955127716,
-0.003542659804224968,
-0.015798745676875114,
0.00865944568067789,
-0.016920261085033417,
-0.2665526866912842,
-0.006328945513814688,
-0.00345276459120214,
-0.028219349682331085,
0.03674779459834099,
-0.024531621485948563,
0.02857114002108574,
-0.03406624495983124,
-0.02908466011285782,
-0.006627099122852087,
0.03435317426919937,
0.04068804159760475,
0.028051460161805153,
0.04220861569046974,
0.03712625056505203,
0.049792904406785965,
0.029861224815249443,
-0.010891418904066086,
0.010661376640200615,
0.03940717503428459,
-0.012997758574783802,
-0.038297440856695175,
-0.01643706113100052,
0.03474215418100357,
-0.03497438132762909,
0.04585239291191101,
-0.06497682631015778,
0.04291173815727234,
-0.029510268941521645,
-0.020163752138614655,
0.034474581480026245,
-0.029728533700108528,
0.016463199630379677,
0.0314643420279026,
0.002317203674465418,
-0.009938579052686691,
0.03626939281821251,
0.01961023546755314,
0.009076048620045185,
-0.05783332884311676,
-0.004445212893188,
-0.02003953605890274,
-0.043681032955646515,
-0.0017117873067036271,
0.08150853216648102,
-0.004218167159706354,
-0.01304890401661396,
-0.030759641900658607,
-0.006687423679977655,
0.0227068904787302,
0.00271979090757668,
-0.03265620023012161,
-0.028235020115971565,
0.01006664801388979,
-0.033917345106601715,
-0.07345276325941086,
0.012237999588251114,
0.04579590633511543,
-0.03680483251810074,
-0.007584958802908659,
-0.0265013687312603,
-0.027660483494400978,
-0.003733402118086815,
-0.055317722260951996,
-0.011266377754509449,
-0.04083966463804245,
-0.0696142166852951,
-0.06085379794239998,
0.034445714205503464,
0.0266831424087286,
-0.022392243146896362,
0.041685570031404495,
-0.06437815725803375,
-0.09947509318590164,
0.0018518716096878052,
-0.0024845011066645384,
0.0055806986056268215,
-0.03159100562334061,
-0.02092183195054531,
0.05706290528178215,
-0.01860591024160385,
-0.05745796859264374,
0.02374407649040222,
0.012078674510121346,
0.032834988087415695,
-0.025622515007853508,
0.024049462750554085,
-0.024472158402204514,
-0.002015735488384962,
-0.041673045605421066,
0.0396958626806736,
0.0001764225889928639,
0.03450619429349899,
0.014166564680635929,
0.014293191023170948,
0.04278428852558136,
0.024196786805987358,
0.07500907778739929,
0.04419998079538345,
-0.03963497281074524,
0.01825772598385811,
-0.06315040588378906,
-0.03317490220069885,
-0.08408402651548386,
0.013078054413199425,
-0.00036615776480175555,
-0.026686202734708786,
-0.042010776698589325,
0.036698631942272186,
-0.003182864049449563,
-0.008902397006750107,
0.03543626889586449,
0.04580641910433769,
-0.01619713380932808,
0.024410247802734375,
-0.04288100078701973,
0.009641557931900024,
0.022336920723319054,
0.06668683141469955,
0.007154695224016905,
-0.030857689678668976,
0.01619216427206993,
-0.01744232326745987,
0.007293532136827707,
0.039285484701395035,
-0.0017615400720387697,
0.02856108546257019,
-0.005303971003741026,
-0.0017882977845147252,
0.011139622889459133,
0.053909722715616226,
0.03256259858608246,
0.0074546076357364655,
0.05325682833790779,
0.02963201142847538,
-0.02098454162478447,
-0.007519604172557592,
-0.02143891528248787,
0.01973007433116436,
-0.01690857671201229,
0.03987647220492363,
-0.02435060776770115,
0.010715453885495663,
0.015154963359236717,
0.039471372961997986,
0.002934715012088418,
-0.01916602998971939,
0.01333736814558506,
0.00651498744264245,
-0.019399171695113182,
-0.0008942157146520913,
-0.040468424558639526,
-0.03524866700172424,
-0.030433805659413338,
0.01132283452898264,
0.009379598312079906,
0.04290059581398964,
-0.04685816913843155,
0.04409437254071236,
-0.07154329121112823,
0.026054827496409416,
-0.010353485122323036,
-0.01179337315261364,
-0.04508925974369049,
0.011367637664079666,
0.030135830864310265,
0.010178560391068459,
-0.014454270713031292,
0.016618026420474052,
0.008469795808196068,
0.0380743183195591,
-0.024936096742749214,
-0.007712641265243292,
-0.008614849299192429,
-0.048910532146692276,
0.006529666483402252,
-0.019881470128893852,
-0.00636977469548583,
-0.012422438710927963,
0.02788117341697216,
0.015865983441472054,
-0.01351708173751831,
0.008604797534644604,
0.004021732602268457,
0.09443654119968414,
0.018985658884048462,
-0.0002624871558509767,
-0.015319441445171833,
-0.07182281464338303,
0.05842822790145874,
-0.008977539837360382,
-0.006266574840992689,
-0.03554310277104378,
-0.017003944143652916,
-0.008637373335659504,
-0.06257074326276779,
-0.014591043815016747,
-0.0050065964460372925,
0.013464566320180893,
-0.006415116135030985,
-0.015993651002645493,
-0.0025476389564573765,
-0.04195107892155647,
0.002433408983051777,
0.02281142584979534,
-0.06352850794792175,
-0.024457283318042755,
0.033182915300130844,
-0.03419484943151474,
0.02022792026400566,
-0.03187255188822746,
-0.02667866088449955,
-0.022359361872076988,
-0.03481919690966606,
-0.005003346595913172,
-0.010987542569637299,
-0.011362642049789429,
-0.023232802748680115,
0.007155602797865868,
-0.008406043983995914,
0.039506006985902786,
0.03710096329450607,
-0.03091723844408989,
-0.024128122255206108,
0.0041221799328923225,
0.05973361060023308,
-0.017340466380119324,
-0.02530568838119507,
0.03484703600406647,
-0.029781155288219452,
-0.007874047383666039,
-0.040992621332407,
0.007204266265034676,
0.050008341670036316,
-0.016423415392637253,
-0.023628342896699905,
-0.03516101837158203,
0.04476536437869072,
0.0392821729183197,
0.020680176094174385,
-0.012150566093623638,
0.027270549908280373,
-0.01608358882367611,
0.03196796029806137,
0.003700588596984744,
0.04684038460254669,
0.01827692613005638,
0.0087380176410079,
0.034977518022060394,
0.06150929257273674,
0.023579642176628113,
0.007897437550127506,
-0.028026346117258072,
-0.025348523631691933,
0.035315610468387604,
-0.014778529293835163,
-0.022502105683088303,
-0.06101350113749504,
-0.06866107136011124,
0.012584483250975609,
0.012814585119485855,
0.008896208368241787,
-0.018549544736742973,
0.02429492585361004,
0.0274397861212492,
0.050775498151779175,
0.0009267832501791418,
-0.027841845527291298,
0.043263234198093414,
-0.024344131350517273,
-0.02508499100804329,
-0.047433797270059586,
-0.003341544885188341,
0.047717440873384476,
-0.04341309517621994,
-0.009256338700652122,
-0.014920304529368877,
-0.012976066209375858,
0.026713451370596886,
-0.02885979786515236,
-0.06691639870405197,
-0.014871647581458092,
-0.029841726645827293,
-0.02122066169977188,
-0.000896952289622277,
-0.044690750539302826,
0.020037712529301643,
-0.009543923661112785,
-0.055450454354286194,
0.002747987862676382,
0.028855033218860626,
0.02809918113052845,
-0.04668112099170685,
-0.005941925570368767,
-0.02267492562532425,
0.030493464320898056,
0.02820955030620098,
0.07348031550645828,
-0.011806182563304901,
0.00580308074131608,
-0.038829609751701355,
0.10909634828567505,
0.027294503524899483,
-0.006683972664177418,
-0.020827632397413254,
-0.0007858231547288597,
0.018720045685768127,
-0.01750515028834343,
0.02110639400780201,
0.004457294940948486,
-0.025158461183309555,
-0.06637789309024811,
0.04742339625954628,
0.014667380601167679,
-0.05263954773545265,
-0.03617411479353905,
0.026105958968400955,
-0.023776357993483543,
-0.016299238428473473,
0.014800118282437325,
-0.0441814661026001,
-0.023598330095410347,
0.05524998530745506,
0.0209086611866951,
0.02459798753261566,
0.07926596701145172,
0.015106366015970707,
0.0025421183090656996,
-0.009343860670924187,
0.07611841708421707,
0.05879788473248482,
0.01751825213432312,
0.014691152609884739,
0.09170818328857422,
-0.03514387831091881,
-0.052111219614744186,
0.032847557216882706,
0.0025062388740479946,
0.002936069155111909,
-0.020993219688534737,
0.03640337660908699,
0.10522386431694031,
0.047602422535419464,
0.030881425365805626,
-0.02696218714118004,
0.009819362312555313,
-0.0029705874621868134,
0.042623769491910934,
0.011651820503175259,
-0.01573653146624565,
0.05416468530893326,
0.007441024295985699,
-0.012053253129124641,
-0.000997108523733914,
-0.030593857169151306,
0.010836015455424786,
0.028659099712967873,
0.057322531938552856,
-0.013216533698141575,
-0.0028656478971242905,
-0.045039959251880646,
-0.006058785133063793,
0.06873318552970886,
0.025365395471453667,
-0.01257308479398489,
-0.028819812461733818,
0.01618042401969433,
0.0032995129004120827,
0.03825143724679947,
-0.006165390368551016,
-0.05057424306869507,
0.003588058054447174,
-0.0648188591003418,
0.018531417474150658,
0.019723443314433098,
-0.03336774930357933,
0.04038858041167259,
-0.04275807365775108,
-0.018787380307912827,
0.031428299844264984,
-0.03268497809767723,
-0.05202322453260422,
-0.044202517718076706,
-0.03291104733943939,
-0.054204218089580536,
-0.04352349042892456,
-0.04536541551351547,
0.04553773254156113,
0.03899252414703369,
-0.00012306270946282893,
-0.03254406154155731,
0.011776003055274487,
0.06347460299730301,
0.012643629685044289,
-0.06574145704507828,
-0.04592045769095421,
0.04985389858484268,
-0.043105337768793106,
0.03320940211415291,
0.04025804251432419,
0.02340565249323845,
-0.0026171014178544283,
-0.024763543158769608,
0.041277289390563965,
-0.0054494100622832775,
0.01634596660733223,
-0.005025333724915981,
-0.010045659728348255,
-0.10244694352149963,
0.01385476253926754,
0.04283319413661957,
-0.026993248611688614,
-0.07674592733383179,
0.059835270047187805,
0.007153141777962446,
0.026147549971938133,
0.04491322860121727,
0.009328039363026619,
0.013989095576107502,
-0.04022522643208504,
-0.026028381660580635,
-0.03209558129310608,
0.04376090317964554,
0.06205887347459793,
-0.023987267166376114,
0.06719806045293808,
0.08701001107692719,
-0.013616576790809631,
0.01054345816373825,
0.01123633049428463,
-0.01930510625243187,
-0.01880400814116001,
-0.031719453632831573,
-0.06516025960445404,
-0.07297807931900024,
-0.1116514503955841,
-0.00003363778887433,
-0.0023261685855686665,
0.007557480596005917,
-0.041203662753105164,
-0.011775069870054722,
-0.0031611034646630287,
0.0010867142118513584,
-0.024388020858168602,
0.04266101121902466,
0.00719127431511879,
-0.02769274078309536,
-0.06347808241844177,
-0.048653703182935715,
0.0013199473032727838,
-0.007905418053269386,
0.021590208634734154,
-0.010095447301864624,
-0.03203214332461357,
-0.02284928224980831,
-0.03789569437503815,
0.03468240424990654,
0.05589162930846214,
0.05233762040734291,
-0.011392724700272083
] |
392 |
ExACT: Teaching AI Agents to Explore with Reflective-MCTS and Exploratory Learning
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=GBIUbwW9D8
|
[
"Xiao Yu",
"Baolin Peng",
"Vineeth Vajipey",
"Hao Cheng",
"Michel Galley",
"Jianfeng Gao",
"Zhou Yu"
] |
Poster
|
Autonomous agents have demonstrated significant potential in automating complex multistep decision-making tasks. However, even state-of-the-art vision-language models (VLMs), such as GPT-4o, still fall short of human-level performance, particularly in intricate web environments and long-horizon planning tasks. To address these limitations, we introduce Reflective Monte Carlo Tree Search (R-MCTS), a novel test-time algorithm designed to enhance the ability of AI agents, e.g., powered by GPT-4o, to explore decision space on the fly.
R-MCTS extends traditional MCTS by 1) incorporating contrastive reflection, allowing agents to learn from past interactions and dynamically improve their search efficiency; and 2) using multi-agent debate to provide reliable state evaluation. Moreover, we improve the agent's performance by fine-tuning GPT-4o through self-learning, using R-MCTS generated tree traversals without any human-provided labels. On the challenging VisualWebArena benchmark, our GPT-4o-based R-MCTS agent achieves a 6% to 30% relative improvement across various tasks compared to the previous state-of-the-art. Additionally, we show that the knowledge gained from test-time search can be effectively transferred back to GPT-4o via fine-tuning. The fine-tuned GPT-4o matches 97\% of R-MCTS's performance while reducing compute usage by a factor of four at test time. Furthermore, qualitative results reveal that the fine-tuned GPT-4o model demonstrates the ability to explore the environment, evaluate a state, and backtrack to viable ones when it detects that the current state cannot lead to success. Moreover, our work demonstrates the compute scaling properties in both training - data collection with R-MCTS - and testing time. These results suggest a promising research direction to enhance VLMs' reasoning and planning capabilities for agentic applications via test-time search and self-learning.
|
AI agent, tree search, self-improvement
| null | 13,162 |
2410.02052
|
[
-0.00456717424094677,
-0.029386816546320915,
0.034513480961322784,
0.06283131241798401,
0.02983040362596512,
0.01347331702709198,
0.04310780018568039,
0.003310740925371647,
-0.00949199590831995,
-0.03700990974903107,
-0.03627823293209076,
0.021639250218868256,
-0.06644005328416824,
-0.020341312512755394,
0.020269552245736122,
0.06935521215200424,
0.029794154688715935,
-0.01674625277519226,
0.009224536828696728,
-0.03098459169268608,
-0.007191778160631657,
0.010881803929805756,
0.03738780319690704,
0.017391163855791092,
0.021847842261195183,
0.014645147137343884,
0.07404613494873047,
0.014724723063409328,
-0.016551967710256577,
-0.01292866375297308,
0.011657639406621456,
-0.017082132399082184,
0.02095344290137291,
0.0034750087652355433,
-0.018010782077908516,
0.005495873279869556,
-0.022102346643805504,
-0.010719109326601028,
0.013055074028670788,
-0.023294003680348396,
-0.04964069649577141,
0.008961129933595657,
-0.002216191729530692,
0.009135967120528221,
-0.03410365432500839,
0.03240637108683586,
-0.08573471009731293,
0.029590122401714325,
0.03499032184481621,
-0.02930697426199913,
-0.08813956379890442,
0.04180449619889259,
0.0112508749589324,
-0.005309646017849445,
-0.02348482981324196,
0.04924631491303444,
0.058110374957323074,
-0.11030677706003189,
-0.014404172077775002,
-0.05493466183543205,
-0.03456772118806839,
0.0003679786459542811,
0.009498651139438152,
0.02920243889093399,
-0.01177887711673975,
-0.01069928240031004,
0.02511489763855934,
0.017429450526833534,
-0.041792746633291245,
-0.032600246369838715,
-0.04124068841338158,
-0.02471202053129673,
-0.013329963199794292,
0.011798348277807236,
-0.0020669277291744947,
-0.01182330772280693,
0.013028781861066818,
0.02021431177854538,
0.04263382405042648,
0.006451819092035294,
-0.0007591667235828936,
0.023318827152252197,
0.0005249924724921584,
0.0499100536108017,
0.03734695911407471,
0.00868250522762537,
-0.027363279834389687,
-0.00993557833135128,
-0.09955094009637833,
0.04919671267271042,
-0.010515537112951279,
-0.06019076332449913,
0.008817382156848907,
0.04086577892303467,
0.035749197006225586,
0.008223949000239372,
0.011608647182583809,
-0.007989993318915367,
0.024705905467271805,
-0.01983962021768093,
-0.0128604331985116,
-0.04970425367355347,
0.005562784615904093,
-0.0016466380329802632,
-0.12098488956689835,
-0.008314084261655807,
-0.023955965414643288,
-0.02367319166660309,
-0.010240361094474792,
0.018875079229474068,
-0.06499971449375153,
-0.024696117267012596,
0.010855637490749359,
-0.00973850954324007,
-0.09091772884130478,
0.03590768203139305,
0.025851121172308922,
0.04742405563592911,
-0.004875343292951584,
0.028398113325238228,
0.04314814507961273,
0.024550730362534523,
-0.013428539037704468,
0.05618100240826607,
-0.003258536569774151,
0.022677181288599968,
0.028710568323731422,
0.009841084480285645,
-0.02553611993789673,
-0.044917937368154526,
0.020069226622581482,
0.01814575493335724,
0.0012476908741518855,
0.03032282553613186,
-0.008184605278074741,
-0.028602302074432373,
0.0015065427869558334,
-0.016845643520355225,
0.04442168399691582,
0.02167923003435135,
-0.01644832454621792,
-0.04193032905459404,
0.09369298070669174,
-0.00990801490843296,
0.07296285778284073,
-0.002650979207828641,
-0.022976238280534744,
-0.014550600200891495,
-0.05896153301000595,
0.011503714136779308,
-0.01650382950901985,
-0.012511655688285828,
0.01883404329419136,
-0.055008042603731155,
0.023089280351996422,
0.05757526680827141,
0.0315963514149189,
0.009761233814060688,
0.0027657158207148314,
-0.0040459176525473595,
0.027664396911859512,
0.02292097918689251,
-0.05238465964794159,
-0.03520865738391876,
-0.0008043586276471615,
-0.04971559718251228,
0.007317409384995699,
0.019314151257276535,
-0.012662047520279884,
-0.012581279501318932,
-0.032407037913799286,
-0.03498357906937599,
0.04226332902908325,
-0.028992999345064163,
-0.03883394971489906,
-0.0013518781634047627,
0.05969035252928734,
-0.05900175869464874,
0.03632102161645889,
0.025371607393026352,
-0.07667336612939835,
0.019819019362330437,
-0.02147970162332058,
-0.02209453098475933,
-0.007548617664724588,
-0.036851916462183,
0.0684284046292305,
-0.020991260185837746,
-0.010518277995288372,
0.007527745794504881,
-0.07463978976011276,
-0.028057973831892014,
0.059254370629787445,
-0.019853632897138596,
0.06848197430372238,
-0.01521169114857912,
-0.0423407256603241,
0.024669889360666275,
0.012138762511312962,
0.05934622138738632,
0.02814321219921112,
0.006595153361558914,
0.027416594326496124,
-0.008145696483552456,
-0.016179656609892845,
-0.020780766382813454,
0.06120581552386284,
-0.0513877347111702,
-0.013701164163649082,
0.01979895867407322,
0.0025412896648049355,
0.014370636083185673,
0.017688585445284843,
0.014789821580052376,
0.013974182307720184,
0.04545224830508232,
-0.022168228402733803,
-0.001246115774847567,
0.052062273025512695,
-0.05257613584399223,
0.016576489433646202,
0.0179936271160841,
-0.0045278179459273815,
0.001448188559152186,
-0.03081519715487957,
0.08666292577981949,
0.05002246052026749,
-0.0612746886909008,
-0.01353971753269434,
0.026962311938405037,
0.009662916883826256,
0.01852191612124443,
0.008243457414209843,
-0.02066902443766594,
0.009953618980944157,
-0.03740832954645157,
0.0017868393333628774,
-0.0001171606345451437,
0.043208811432123184,
-0.022051304578781128,
-0.04160245135426521,
0.04685728996992111,
-0.008519073016941547,
0.04709655046463013,
0.022691912949085236,
-0.009444724768400192,
0.04550693556666374,
-0.014673594385385513,
-0.0044135646894574165,
-0.024967193603515625,
-0.0455438606441021,
-0.00563255837187171,
0.00797697901725769,
-0.004148745443671942,
-0.0073035224340856075,
-0.058735672384500504,
-0.010717309080064297,
-0.03236815705895424,
0.08059649914503098,
0.059168312698602676,
0.009626222774386406,
0.03769116476178169,
0.03132049739360809,
-0.008250819519162178,
0.021822385489940643,
-0.118239626288414,
-0.025911202654242516,
-0.000615796132478863,
0.026569455862045288,
0.016387637704610825,
0.024444863200187683,
-0.0219829473644495,
0.0358286127448082,
-0.030939700081944466,
-0.03613608330488205,
0.01472913846373558,
0.017898552119731903,
0.041609086096286774,
-0.012048070318996906,
0.0015731576131656766,
0.016687573865056038,
0.059980619698762894,
-0.018307290971279144,
-0.020784156396985054,
-0.026155613362789154,
-0.04184383153915405,
-0.011530314572155476,
-0.06592031568288803,
0.020754091441631317,
0.019318435341119766,
0.005272048991173506,
0.020499715581536293,
-0.016821764409542084,
0.025611622259020805,
0.04770088195800781,
0.05756280571222305,
0.04152810573577881,
-0.0045670028775930405,
-0.04567762464284897,
0.00861458107829094,
-0.026011263951659203,
0.005478127393871546,
-0.01367923617362976,
0.022705409675836563,
0.017963770776987076,
0.017543239519000053,
0.029543250799179077,
0.015975307673215866,
-0.25421079993247986,
-0.07546801120042801,
0.03230833262205124,
0.02850729413330555,
0.02638661116361618,
-0.03501126542687416,
0.08839236944913864,
-0.046201590448617935,
-0.025370685383677483,
-0.0103765232488513,
0.023320235311985016,
0.02336633950471878,
-0.007363115902990103,
0.06990361213684082,
0.049566399306058884,
0.019300607964396477,
-0.01738201081752777,
-0.021928980946540833,
-0.001997971208766103,
0.05067332461476326,
0.0017171251820400357,
-0.08170149475336075,
-0.027236422523856163,
0.03165974095463753,
0.023892555385828018,
0.06188065931200981,
-0.09036456793546677,
-0.005588463973253965,
-0.019561024382710457,
-0.001474088290706277,
-0.02259877324104309,
0.0003434286336414516,
-0.0028179308865219355,
0.03955959901213646,
0.024285370483994484,
-0.0016695027006790042,
0.07392081618309021,
-0.013072993606328964,
0.039852436631917953,
0.012971493415534496,
-0.017915373668074608,
-0.015370463952422142,
-0.039686985313892365,
0.025519680231809616,
0.05743669718503952,
-0.0039911759085953236,
-0.05730042979121208,
-0.027746843174099922,
-0.018094796687364578,
0.04034304618835449,
0.005603828001767397,
0.0008784205419942737,
0.007022303529083729,
-0.0010850561084225774,
0.018827442079782486,
-0.0486472062766552,
0.010157373733818531,
-0.011358758434653282,
-0.0058932532556355,
0.00010944935638690367,
-0.0009930399246513844,
-0.038741856813430786,
-0.02151808701455593,
-0.009517768397927284,
0.01209795568138361,
-0.03813008591532707,
-0.06070893630385399,
-0.05032181739807129,
0.022151539102196693,
-0.007617378607392311,
-0.015845315530896187,
-0.034291092306375504,
-0.03356559947133064,
-0.09791885316371918,
-0.004304985050112009,
0.019484154880046844,
0.008391276933252811,
-0.04240924119949341,
0.009826510213315487,
0.038325436413288116,
-0.0352703295648098,
-0.05666111782193184,
-0.00859180185943842,
0.014208867214620113,
0.052902255207300186,
-0.01274301391094923,
0.020172102376818657,
-0.05346645787358284,
-0.02283862791955471,
-0.016032984480261803,
0.023025335744023323,
-0.012304599396884441,
0.03611428663134575,
-0.02287837117910385,
0.06130434200167656,
0.02679530717432499,
0.04528597742319107,
0.030814433470368385,
0.026925377547740936,
0.023791395127773285,
0.007442836184054613,
-0.08325400948524475,
-0.0022084456868469715,
-0.016709908843040466,
-0.05367637053132057,
-0.002007456962019205,
-0.043257854878902435,
-0.003220247570425272,
0.051634274423122406,
0.026449553668498993,
0.0039991335943341255,
-0.014642180874943733,
0.006119624245911837,
0.017424507066607475,
-0.012877524830400944,
0.0023573595099151134,
0.021579574793577194,
0.025538774207234383,
0.05225326493382454,
-0.04113921523094177,
-0.03469077870249748,
0.0008215653360821307,
-0.06427278369665146,
0.017051683738827705,
-0.006533389911055565,
-0.02839120477437973,
0.04583542421460152,
-0.009268045425415039,
0.010912546887993813,
-0.0010716354008764029,
0.02039598673582077,
0.019617339596152306,
0.0038941712118685246,
0.04005309194326401,
0.06025845557451248,
-0.0271199569106102,
-0.010643156245350838,
0.0284150168299675,
0.05150965228676796,
-0.044980503618717194,
0.028525087982416153,
-0.015708856284618378,
0.016270752996206284,
0.02283596619963646,
0.0097457654774189,
0.007312519941478968,
0.02533966302871704,
0.015123451128602028,
0.013673028908669949,
0.0023158846888691187,
0.06055252626538277,
-0.0373053178191185,
0.02668243646621704,
-0.02301224321126938,
0.0072395759634673595,
-0.06049104779958725,
0.02313806861639023,
-0.04927060008049011,
0.04517827555537224,
-0.05710187554359436,
0.045449674129486084,
0.00023679844161961228,
0.0010051705176010728,
-0.01091995183378458,
0.025185171514749527,
0.021122919395565987,
-0.006266937591135502,
0.024524252861738205,
-0.010663757100701332,
0.018758241087198257,
0.0007257013348862529,
-0.07166676968336105,
-0.02896646223962307,
-0.022412709891796112,
-0.03705543279647827,
0.01870795339345932,
0.017821529880166054,
-0.048245642334222794,
-0.06192797049880028,
0.029662514105439186,
-0.010032343678176403,
-0.01436503604054451,
-0.023786034435033798,
-0.02892320416867733,
0.06193968281149864,
-0.027616707608103752,
0.025625253096222878,
0.015155640430748463,
0.006502946373075247,
0.02222001552581787,
-0.010633988305926323,
0.03322918713092804,
-0.004095785785466433,
-0.038676247000694275,
-0.05974334850907326,
-0.044484611600637436,
0.010944225825369358,
-0.0033265529200434685,
0.004346789792180061,
0.011835820972919464,
-0.009467230178415775,
0.003309454070404172,
-0.03984206169843674,
-0.004880718886852264,
0.04780706390738487,
-0.056788887828588486,
-0.017937302589416504,
0.02968950755894184,
0.04592091590166092,
0.03291606530547142,
-0.07970594614744186,
-0.03698992729187012,
-0.05332612991333008,
-0.03591196611523628,
-0.043288346379995346,
-0.020198924466967583,
-0.009984907694160938,
-0.009501320309937,
0.0025065757799893618,
-0.004113766830414534,
0.01805838942527771,
0.006616097409278154,
-0.017652712762355804,
-0.017289400100708008,
-0.00562477670609951,
0.047671057283878326,
-0.017376655712723732,
-0.010197445750236511,
-0.015278027392923832,
-0.028681665658950806,
0.010351174511015415,
-0.044882919639348984,
-0.011922343634068966,
0.039052702486515045,
0.007905030623078346,
-0.026287518441677094,
-0.025789348408579826,
0.05926837772130966,
0.019824093207716942,
-0.02624697983264923,
-0.01553377602249384,
-0.002458698581904173,
-0.03966860845685005,
-0.003005419159308076,
0.009549887850880623,
0.02476372942328453,
0.013366504572331905,
-0.008171006105840206,
-0.00037527058157138526,
0.025302529335021973,
0.018842147663235664,
0.022015469148755074,
-0.03529755398631096,
0.008331870660185814,
0.05581243708729744,
-0.014104137197136879,
-0.023297438398003578,
-0.030069896951317787,
-0.033060554414987564,
0.03662273287773132,
-0.02664967067539692,
0.0011995334643870592,
-0.06140512228012085,
0.0026993779465556145,
0.022891400381922722,
0.029663115739822388,
-0.009437684901058674,
-0.04104875773191452,
0.018318545073270798,
-0.0793226808309555,
0.06022728979587555,
-0.059849582612514496,
-0.012209605425596237,
0.047609832137823105,
-0.03867501765489578,
-0.03144417330622673,
0.004697746131569147,
-0.038375239819288254,
0.03127870336174965,
-0.00641216617077589,
-0.06633805483579636,
0.05277925729751587,
-0.014244944788515568,
0.005773863755166531,
0.024303453043103218,
-0.04039893299341202,
-0.032570093870162964,
-0.02952110394835472,
-0.02293030545115471,
-0.012509902007877827,
0.004376974422484636,
0.049943290650844574,
-0.035966917872428894,
0.008285364136099815,
-0.02312322147190571,
0.020969834178686142,
-0.016179194673895836,
0.05364228039979935,
0.020978687331080437,
0.07004699856042862,
-0.025090079754590988,
0.07160378247499466,
0.0781221017241478,
0.04122662916779518,
0.02114957384765148,
-0.004562649875879288,
-0.020754655823111534,
-0.01836366392672062,
0.06489037722349167,
-0.004890470765531063,
-0.027944456785917282,
-0.04832104220986366,
0.06979458034038544,
0.000872005068231374,
-0.05506366863846779,
0.02739887870848179,
0.005230331793427467,
-0.0801079198718071,
-0.01417927723377943,
0.0001969488221220672,
0.007618608418852091,
0.036885395646095276,
0.055708736181259155,
0.02487317845225334,
0.06120908632874489,
0.08388266712427139,
0.012408004142343998,
-0.021252481266856194,
0.011450685560703278,
0.04737916588783264,
0.06737974286079407,
0.049817901104688644,
-0.024784183129668236,
0.06398161500692368,
-0.06061927229166031,
-0.030450647696852684,
0.0448404997587204,
-0.0025468487292528152,
-0.0191219262778759,
-0.014627560041844845,
0.032528381794691086,
0.042170386761426926,
-0.014777498319745064,
0.04206915944814682,
-0.06247955188155174,
-0.01271797064691782,
0.056081220507621765,
-0.020882273092865944,
0.007124874275177717,
0.05220629274845123,
0.050534214824438095,
0.028710581362247467,
-0.039951954036951065,
-0.01825222373008728,
0.0046269590966403484,
-0.03526776283979416,
0.002166340360417962,
-0.018770573660731316,
-0.04054002836346626,
-0.005351163446903229,
-0.017873406410217285,
0.04331372678279877,
0.0977160632610321,
-0.03987931087613106,
-0.0003029982326552272,
0.02420158125460148,
0.009820065461099148,
0.016481194645166397,
0.05584980174899101,
0.02093503437936306,
-0.00006981879414524883,
0.00901953224092722,
-0.016226453706622124,
0.04266646131873131,
0.03247159719467163,
0.01858815737068653,
0.01876552775502205,
-0.04357825219631195,
-0.026021957397460938,
0.025997616350650787,
0.003275411669164896,
-0.020532023161649704,
-0.04389938339591026,
-0.04196644946932793,
-0.0317867211997509,
-0.033963892608881,
-0.04534238949418068,
0.007636035792529583,
0.003694254904985428,
-0.05028166249394417,
-0.01072610728442669,
0.009124243631958961,
0.024768304079771042,
0.007519016042351723,
-0.052417147904634476,
0.02085324563086033,
0.025136951357126236,
-0.00030107825295999646,
-0.0028518943581730127,
0.04992596060037613,
0.01769556663930416,
0.005288310814648867,
-0.0008711135014891624,
0.012085546739399433,
0.006758933421224356,
0.015229344367980957,
-0.03222110494971275,
-0.01635861024260521,
-0.07447974383831024,
-0.03081621043384075,
0.04346894100308418,
-0.024589426815509796,
-0.07955408841371536,
-0.002573697827756405,
-0.05073168873786926,
0.030251426622271538,
0.04749426990747452,
0.01956399530172348,
0.026915982365608215,
-0.012345628812909126,
0.01398061029613018,
0.0441875085234642,
0.00006628916889894754,
0.04923103749752045,
-0.038985274732112885,
0.06421639770269394,
0.015227355062961578,
-0.05097176507115364,
-0.054416146129369736,
0.04785579815506935,
0.032347649335861206,
-0.01369143184274435,
-0.031397171318531036,
-0.03115537390112877,
-0.012691671960055828,
-0.11796878278255463,
-0.015003017149865627,
0.04932866245508194,
0.00793937873095274,
-0.03684064745903015,
-0.019283415749669075,
-0.0282463189214468,
0.0020028625149279833,
0.01556430384516716,
-0.041657865047454834,
-0.0017110472545027733,
-0.018352085724473,
-0.02805435284972191,
-0.046520885080099106,
0.011747242882847786,
-0.04178520664572716,
0.027230342850089073,
-0.02602430433034897,
-0.05430243909358978,
-0.005980541463941336,
-0.01509516965597868,
0.026034148409962654,
-0.0028548382688313723,
0.00914163887500763,
-0.01777065545320511
] |
393 |
TOMATO: Assessing Visual Temporal Reasoning Capabilities in Multimodal Foundation Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=fCi4o83Mfs
|
[
"Ziyao Shangguan",
"Chuhan Li",
"Yuxuan Ding",
"Yanan Zheng",
"Yilun Zhao",
"Tesca Fitzgerald",
"Arman Cohan"
] |
Poster
|
Existing benchmarks often highlight the remarkable performance achieved by state-of-the-art Multimodal Foundation Models (MFMs) in leveraging temporal context for video understanding.
However, *how well do the models truly perform visual temporal reasoning?*
Our study of existing benchmarks shows that this capability of MFMs is likely overestimated as many questions can be solved by using a single, few, or out-of-order frames.
To systematically examine current visual temporal reasoning tasks, we propose three principles with corresponding metrics:
(1) *Multi-Frame Gain*,
(2) *Frame Order Sensitivity*,
and (3) *Frame Information Disparity*.
Following these principles, we introduce **TOMATO**, **T**emp**O**ral Reasoning **M**ultimod**A**l Evalua**T**i**O**n, a novel benchmark crafted to rigorously assess MFMs' temporal reasoning capabilities in video understanding.
TOMATO comprises 1,484 carefully curated, *human-annotated* questions spanning *six* tasks (i.e. *action count, direction, rotation, shape & trend, velocity & frequency, and visual cues*), applied to 1,417 videos, including 805 self-recorded and -generated videos, that encompass human-centric, real-world, and simulated scenarios.
Our comprehensive evaluation reveals a human-model performance gap of 57.3% with the best-performing model.
Moreover, our in-depth analysis uncovers more fundamental limitations beyond this gap in current MFMs. While they can accurately recognize events in isolated frames, they fail to interpret these frames as a continuous sequence.
We believe TOMATO will serve as a crucial testbed for evaluating the next-generation MFMs and as a call to the community to develop AI systems capable of comprehending the human world dynamics through the video modality.
|
visual temporal reasoning, video understanding, benchmark, vision-language benchmark, video-language models, evaluation
| null | 13,155 |
2410.23266
|
[
0.024321990087628365,
-0.013590150512754917,
-0.004495935048907995,
0.03076559491455555,
0.04166793450713158,
0.025919970124959946,
0.018173301592469215,
0.04022477939724922,
-0.043510738760232925,
-0.021755559369921684,
0.014446201734244823,
0.03167378902435303,
-0.06511955708265305,
0.002961120568215847,
-0.01970727927982807,
0.046420156955718994,
0.014204773120582104,
-0.012113142758607864,
0.006879265885800123,
0.011018055491149426,
-0.011814123019576073,
-0.021461447700858116,
0.0406697615981102,
-0.003686952870339155,
0.0182594433426857,
0.00033276149770244956,
0.018727893009781837,
0.00942903384566307,
-0.03786005452275276,
0.0036928136833012104,
0.017972972244024277,
-0.02897505834698677,
-0.00008595792314736173,
-0.0583241730928421,
-0.009206628426909447,
0.00024734155158512294,
-0.03061734512448311,
0.04309765622019768,
0.006239643320441246,
0.0017715294379740953,
-0.02298564277589321,
0.01376209408044815,
0.023211369290947914,
-0.03786947578191757,
-0.07177218794822693,
0.009498507715761662,
-0.05563891679048538,
0.05617249011993408,
0.038571905344724655,
-0.012509758584201336,
-0.07066704332828522,
0.027906509116292,
-0.021270545199513435,
-0.013185324147343636,
0.004794433247298002,
0.02281819097697735,
0.03716650605201721,
-0.10248306393623352,
-0.014284761622548103,
-0.03503897041082382,
-0.023211738094687462,
0.010946650989353657,
0.06112145632505417,
-0.01840958371758461,
-0.017334891483187675,
-0.023874735459685326,
-0.012314950115978718,
0.051923878490924835,
-0.02409932389855385,
0.006317585706710815,
0.01912972331047058,
-0.00022211104806046933,
-0.005213640630245209,
0.024921640753746033,
0.01107180118560791,
-0.03939703851938248,
0.035391636192798615,
0.0030814537312835455,
0.042159222066402435,
-0.03667081147432327,
0.012638160958886147,
0.018249519169330597,
0.018146995455026627,
0.04845449700951576,
0.011754738166928291,
0.03744236007332802,
-0.017097918316721916,
-0.019501110538840294,
-0.06559830158948898,
0.02304818108677864,
0.003882313845679164,
-0.03994198888540268,
0.022768976166844368,
0.04850795865058899,
0.011335916817188263,
0.023869797587394714,
-0.0204462930560112,
0.023037899285554886,
0.0231596902012825,
0.014183378778398037,
-0.009889855049550533,
-0.01846175268292427,
0.022257288917899132,
0.010689680464565754,
-0.09298092126846313,
-0.0356069914996624,
-0.027317579835653305,
-0.006636294536292553,
0.00402143644168973,
0.016251593828201294,
-0.0610850565135479,
0.011636625975370407,
0.04590846970677376,
-0.017962632700800896,
-0.049014996737241745,
0.032400816679000854,
0.0044634235091507435,
0.04781974479556084,
-0.02440125308930874,
0.03568680211901665,
0.08039309829473495,
0.032298605889081955,
-0.016405878588557243,
0.05690072476863861,
-0.002101348713040352,
0.021128639578819275,
-0.012160656973719597,
0.008628473617136478,
-0.013203326612710953,
-0.021221796050667763,
0.02334454469382763,
0.004018332343548536,
-0.015160880982875824,
-0.016250023618340492,
-0.0027221576310694218,
-0.0053599076345562935,
0.018550746142864227,
-0.024769658222794533,
0.030446480959653854,
-0.005018741358071566,
0.010113799944519997,
-0.022889474406838417,
0.06752956658601761,
-0.031521208584308624,
0.09386987239122391,
-0.007694203406572342,
-0.0140535244718194,
-0.0034250698518007994,
-0.04647368565201759,
-0.014306852594017982,
-0.0018171011470258236,
-0.015139828436076641,
0.002172006294131279,
-0.09193667024374008,
0.03186310455203056,
0.07208524644374847,
0.03860004246234894,
-0.006699359975755215,
0.021387018263339996,
0.013136083260178566,
-0.0040841661393642426,
-0.003405243856832385,
-0.02087818644940853,
0.037091296166181564,
0.005970553960651159,
-0.05253002792596817,
0.01486244611442089,
0.017774786800146103,
-0.04962754622101784,
0.009916543960571289,
-0.04465097188949585,
-0.03842778131365776,
0.04096561297774315,
-0.010914941318333149,
-0.030526427552103996,
0.015519296750426292,
0.05670702084898949,
0.00876376312226057,
0.018759481608867645,
-0.007425031159073114,
-0.07895228266716003,
0.006745203398168087,
-0.016234353184700012,
-0.006084810476750135,
0.015380585566163063,
-0.04355628788471222,
0.0670311227440834,
-0.05213295295834541,
-0.025471005588769913,
-0.014479557052254677,
-0.055480118840932846,
-0.018756067380309105,
-0.011029500514268875,
-0.003950163256376982,
0.05824610963463783,
0.023488270118832588,
-0.016418730840086937,
0.024672826752066612,
0.036601774394512177,
0.06770973652601242,
0.046877626329660416,
-0.03186715021729469,
0.05316508561372757,
-0.017331073060631752,
-0.0041960459202528,
-0.001975041115656495,
0.05944216251373291,
-0.059320226311683655,
-0.012516822665929794,
0.010066482238471508,
-0.022475630044937134,
0.001521016238257289,
0.014993707649409771,
0.012185356579720974,
0.029409313574433327,
0.03683215379714966,
0.01725262962281704,
0.004893460776656866,
-0.003633380401879549,
-0.06236474961042404,
0.02151471935212612,
0.00512809818610549,
-0.0413958840072155,
-0.02710118144750595,
-0.054412841796875,
0.06900787353515625,
0.05664215609431267,
-0.04749874770641327,
-0.017315343022346497,
-0.008477296680212021,
-0.012258581817150116,
0.03463900834321976,
-0.01794506423175335,
-0.021196642890572548,
0.00199777539819479,
-0.032561514526605606,
0.026372479274868965,
-0.019284158945083618,
0.02220066264271736,
-0.04284166917204857,
-0.011451312340795994,
0.05443797633051872,
-0.0059095947071909904,
0.041561309248209,
-0.010638915933668613,
-0.005087175872176886,
0.04903145879507065,
0.016431111842393875,
-0.0020282811019569635,
0.031705342233181,
-0.008955500088632107,
-0.010654432699084282,
0.010751527734100819,
-0.03257798030972481,
0.011576215736567974,
-0.05114114657044411,
0.005421627312898636,
-0.02810347080230713,
0.0710863471031189,
0.047193702310323715,
0.041489433497190475,
0.059898436069488525,
-0.003377803135663271,
-0.007129254750907421,
-0.03926708921790123,
-0.11215566843748093,
-0.0619652159512043,
-0.0347277857363224,
-0.005968680139631033,
0.04090185835957527,
0.0455496683716774,
-0.026461036875844002,
0.04620242118835449,
-0.010751420632004738,
-0.0005921567790210247,
0.007017702329903841,
0.030655236914753914,
-0.005871148779988289,
-0.037277597934007645,
-0.00216154963709414,
0.014675665646791458,
0.0629299208521843,
-0.01442109514027834,
-0.02576374262571335,
-0.029835170134902,
-0.01730935461819172,
0.025918927043676376,
-0.014315469190478325,
0.002724869642406702,
0.008587853983044624,
0.012551218271255493,
0.014623402617871761,
-0.01429633516818285,
0.040305912494659424,
0.03703862801194191,
0.083601213991642,
0.03433408588171005,
-0.01724453642964363,
-0.018135426566004753,
0.020752783864736557,
0.005576657131314278,
0.024103140458464622,
0.004756671376526356,
-0.0028326730243861675,
-0.01743285544216633,
0.023583468049764633,
0.002702439669519663,
0.0012305696727707982,
-0.25504735112190247,
-0.026955360546708107,
0.010049082338809967,
-0.014170548878610134,
0.04041282460093498,
-0.029649298638105392,
0.047298409044742584,
-0.047245092689991,
-0.014031819067895412,
0.013696565292775631,
0.04659740626811981,
0.038019005209207535,
0.012868422083556652,
0.07195472717285156,
0.0564020611345768,
-0.0036183837801218033,
-0.017738185822963715,
-0.035257745534181595,
0.0077143083326518536,
0.0473688468337059,
-0.016523020341992378,
-0.08105379343032837,
-0.03464960306882858,
0.03934343159198761,
-0.047357749193906784,
0.05821662396192551,
-0.059335894882678986,
-0.02807205729186535,
-0.009051763452589512,
-0.02201629802584648,
0.012990093789994717,
-0.029162568971514702,
-0.0073407781310379505,
0.03461281210184097,
0.030133908614516258,
0.005428816191852093,
0.055239807814359665,
-0.013517487794160843,
0.049829427152872086,
-0.01748986914753914,
0.019391724839806557,
-0.02117110788822174,
-0.02130131796002388,
0.03022032044827938,
0.0746871829032898,
-0.0005915308138355613,
-0.05118231847882271,
-0.02611885406076908,
-0.028284823521971703,
0.03331713005900383,
-0.0027247543912380934,
-0.02789900079369545,
-0.022309834137558937,
-0.023521125316619873,
-0.017380669713020325,
-0.047315891832113266,
0.04580818489193916,
-0.006461241282522678,
0.012931523844599724,
-0.019958995282649994,
-0.032160259783267975,
-0.016124876216053963,
-0.011058910749852657,
-0.017361175268888474,
-0.004484171979129314,
-0.04778897389769554,
-0.06444749981164932,
-0.026728155091404915,
0.03794657066464424,
0.00227348692715168,
-0.00044920711661688983,
0.00364145846106112,
-0.036052122712135315,
-0.1101398691534996,
-0.000003818522145593306,
0.030581237748265266,
-0.02872472070157528,
-0.042578764259815216,
0.006275867111980915,
0.0382278710603714,
-0.03151713311672211,
-0.04406869038939476,
0.01549860741943121,
-0.008737779222428799,
0.02968871220946312,
-0.012022336013615131,
0.03738431632518768,
-0.047436393797397614,
0.00849974900484085,
-0.024896521121263504,
0.04958318546414375,
-0.02218206413090229,
0.01001411397010088,
0.025470634922385216,
0.059564899653196335,
0.028487637639045715,
0.04710090160369873,
0.05842997878789902,
0.07281946390867233,
0.01209214236587286,
-0.0015437162946909666,
-0.09331681579351425,
0.008793731220066547,
-0.02626061625778675,
-0.039308324456214905,
-0.0013471732381731272,
-0.014341451227664948,
0.002821950474753976,
0.03612846881151199,
0.009895244613289833,
-0.012482047080993652,
-0.0009344398276880383,
0.0012431507930159569,
0.0075767007656395435,
-0.009843817912042141,
-0.01090595219284296,
0.011989964172244072,
0.007418564986437559,
0.018250254914164543,
0.010959758423268795,
-0.029758764430880547,
0.028328826650977135,
-0.03425617143511772,
0.047088317573070526,
-0.00191277707926929,
-0.02803698740899563,
-0.03549151495099068,
-0.03051292523741722,
-0.0016557954950258136,
0.0036180943716317415,
0.014157109893858433,
0.03179914131760597,
-0.012626041658222675,
0.04145778343081474,
0.06740055233240128,
-0.028985098004341125,
-0.00478117261081934,
-0.003742824774235487,
0.0327279195189476,
-0.04261472076177597,
0.020249424502253532,
-0.021517017856240273,
0.026310652494430542,
0.04133770614862442,
-0.004634807351976633,
-0.0043094707652926445,
0.0015706801787018776,
0.009325163438916206,
-0.038525551557540894,
0.006083269603550434,
0.03907088190317154,
-0.05683865770697594,
-0.048996228724718094,
-0.03871611878275871,
-0.015690965577960014,
-0.02565336413681507,
-0.0031685454305261374,
-0.020621737465262413,
0.01988384872674942,
-0.08092902600765228,
0.03860029950737953,
0.020318714901804924,
-0.02553827501833439,
-0.020330049097537994,
0.00291459821164608,
0.042458564043045044,
0.030702978372573853,
-0.018032114952802658,
0.024528631940484047,
0.0002714135334827006,
-0.01930788904428482,
-0.03424856439232826,
-0.03175078704953194,
-0.017797110602259636,
-0.018962550908327103,
0.00637185899540782,
0.01662728376686573,
-0.033061012625694275,
-0.03773012012243271,
0.05596577003598213,
-0.002413067501038313,
-0.04853207617998123,
0.02177847921848297,
-0.008279010653495789,
0.06121537461876869,
0.002405666746199131,
-0.019000837579369545,
-0.029559727758169174,
-0.031177358701825142,
0.025416787713766098,
0.01957487314939499,
0.031562067568302155,
-0.010854102671146393,
-0.05504784360527992,
-0.03420129790902138,
-0.040116313844919205,
0.008995698764920235,
-0.0070040966384112835,
0.0030696187168359756,
-0.012313107028603554,
-0.021727968007326126,
0.0035090032033622265,
-0.036769382655620575,
-0.0019484699005261064,
0.036449115723371506,
-0.049049440771341324,
0.024902209639549255,
0.07999490201473236,
-0.021910719573497772,
0.0030137801077216864,
-0.06037265062332153,
-0.02307906374335289,
-0.04147941991686821,
-0.05016886070370674,
-0.009558630175888538,
-0.02205643430352211,
-0.007060653530061245,
-0.03378743678331375,
-0.009879925288259983,
-0.009103817865252495,
0.0027989535592496395,
-0.006494586821645498,
-0.03128606081008911,
0.0011294285068288445,
0.021565020084381104,
0.0504893884062767,
-0.006786552257835865,
-0.01550219301134348,
0.0208530705422163,
-0.013764397241175175,
0.003286106511950493,
-0.03770876303315163,
0.01307152584195137,
0.0535762719810009,
-0.025948701426386833,
-0.03127710148692131,
-0.03178218752145767,
0.041525401175022125,
0.02178151346743107,
0.0016212438931688666,
0.020232150331139565,
0.012226385064423084,
-0.022601716220378876,
0.016006164252758026,
0.017393052577972412,
0.03436543047428131,
0.045406438410282135,
0.0011766835814341903,
0.034897178411483765,
0.020061522722244263,
0.017078015953302383,
-0.003077856032177806,
-0.03333454951643944,
-0.0024855262599885464,
0.04148285090923309,
-0.08052133023738861,
0.00815889798104763,
-0.049742959439754486,
-0.021005310118198395,
0.025511855259537697,
-0.023372964933514595,
0.00794624350965023,
-0.015321697108447552,
0.016989311203360558,
0.0023062482941895723,
0.03537924960255623,
0.050318583846092224,
-0.027500394731760025,
0.055758144706487656,
-0.04713970422744751,
0.028445633128285408,
-0.07613256573677063,
-0.02075503021478653,
0.05685563385486603,
-0.028480416163802147,
-0.010287432000041008,
-0.0019434808054938912,
-0.03726008161902428,
0.049777545034885406,
-0.030619069933891296,
-0.049396514892578125,
0.01409129612147808,
-0.06239333003759384,
-0.00010683199798222631,
0.005827566608786583,
-0.038655295968055725,
0.017315758392214775,
-0.001095668412744999,
-0.046692200005054474,
0.004056204576045275,
-0.022004321217536926,
0.05111291632056236,
-0.011733661405742168,
0.015452656894922256,
-0.022566109895706177,
0.01691092550754547,
0.012210161425173283,
0.05427740886807442,
0.011870610527694225,
0.021130893379449844,
-0.0134743582457304,
0.05990045145153999,
0.048367660492658615,
0.006291551515460014,
0.01488635316491127,
-0.004458910785615444,
-0.010937383398413658,
-0.057293981313705444,
0.047880299389362335,
0.01974528655409813,
-0.05438818410038948,
-0.0869569256901741,
0.08002942055463791,
0.01534556970000267,
-0.03121194802224636,
0.0068391491658985615,
0.030469531193375587,
-0.05327536538243294,
0.0018491422524675727,
-0.0013140664668753743,
-0.002570335753262043,
-0.015252618119120598,
0.06255453079938889,
0.0262279212474823,
0.08747778832912445,
0.0833490714430809,
0.03452209755778313,
-0.02989259362220764,
0.007496850099414587,
0.03645578399300575,
0.05435879901051521,
0.06601046025753021,
-0.011082306504249573,
0.10105762630701065,
-0.017848653718829155,
-0.03076421655714512,
0.04402833804488182,
0.018033592030405998,
-0.027486909180879593,
-0.03477614000439644,
0.0035921158269047737,
0.09352857619524002,
0.015651723369956017,
0.04349300265312195,
-0.05212480574846268,
-0.017447294667363167,
0.056157223880290985,
0.005207499023526907,
-0.005693865939974785,
0.021984683349728584,
0.06584435701370239,
-0.0020453077740967274,
-0.018738724291324615,
-0.01698584482073784,
0.013564366847276688,
-0.007977086119353771,
0.012786950916051865,
0.007494115270674229,
-0.002461255993694067,
0.03651146590709686,
-0.02134573832154274,
0.04472736269235611,
0.09976564347743988,
-0.030264079570770264,
-0.008738118223845959,
0.020501721650362015,
-0.007153984624892473,
0.01987241581082344,
0.0360349677503109,
0.021638348698616028,
0.01421706099063158,
0.018678389489650726,
-0.07141498476266861,
0.03504825755953789,
0.03651609644293785,
-0.0035721471067517996,
0.016810595989227295,
-0.05800802633166313,
-0.04377103969454765,
0.02486032247543335,
-0.009203676134347916,
-0.023530058562755585,
-0.028162866830825806,
-0.022805271670222282,
-0.07413439452648163,
-0.07968731224536896,
-0.03469531238079071,
0.05370188504457474,
0.002415373921394348,
-0.059410300105810165,
-0.034833479672670364,
0.010877244174480438,
0.014968235976994038,
0.007532493676990271,
-0.07459632307291031,
-0.026469901204109192,
0.026734059676527977,
-0.016122974455356598,
-0.0002464879653416574,
0.039605025202035904,
0.0334903858602047,
-0.02037319354712963,
-0.025849005207419395,
-0.005579647142440081,
0.0018117747968062758,
0.013970504514873028,
-0.005346859339624643,
-0.04379895329475403,
-0.10986059904098511,
0.0024446407333016396,
0.02183631621301174,
-0.020931031554937363,
-0.07348661869764328,
-0.0053637162782251835,
-0.06691574305295944,
0.03789824619889259,
0.08510426431894302,
-0.008400879800319672,
0.048026278614997864,
-0.056548308581113815,
-0.008638662286102772,
-0.015995385125279427,
0.005319789983332157,
0.05548454076051712,
-0.045235104858875275,
0.056227847933769226,
0.040603820234537125,
-0.014498289674520493,
-0.029757967218756676,
0.03374408558011055,
0.010065666399896145,
-0.006793573964387178,
0.011679116636514664,
-0.06047828495502472,
-0.05085184797644615,
-0.12820351123809814,
-0.018954966217279434,
0.02707645483314991,
0.019736703485250473,
-0.06047739088535309,
-0.0030592158436775208,
-0.01988852582871914,
-0.018628044053912163,
-0.05959297716617584,
-0.007944529876112938,
-0.013903515413403511,
-0.017490055412054062,
-0.019432032480835915,
-0.07855550944805145,
0.019856682047247887,
-0.037373945116996765,
0.0015059186844155192,
-0.030110718682408333,
-0.0359441302716732,
-0.021293852478265762,
0.01843871921300888,
0.013303890824317932,
0.016056716442108154,
0.06337324529886246,
-0.013003896921873093
] |
394 |
Attention in Large Language Models Yields Efficient Zero-Shot Re-Rankers
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=yzloNYH3QN
|
[
"Shijie Chen",
"Bernal Jimenez Gutierrez",
"Yu Su"
] |
Poster
|
Information retrieval (IR) systems have played a vital role in modern digital life and have cemented their continued usefulness in this new era of generative AI via retrieval-augmented generation. With strong language processing capabilities and remarkable versatility, large language models (LLMs) have become popular choices for zero-shot re-ranking in IR systems. So far, LLM-based re-ranking methods rely on strong generative capabilities, which restricts their use to either specialized or powerful proprietary models. Given these restrictions, we ask: is autoregressive generation necessary and optimal for LLMs to perform re-ranking? We hypothesize that there are abundant signals relevant to re-ranking within LLMs that might not be used to their full potential via generation. To more directly leverage such signals, we propose in-context re-ranking (ICR), a novel method that leverages the change in attention pattern caused by the search query for accurate and efficient re-ranking. We assume that more relevant documents should receive more attention weights when an LLM is processing the query tokens, and leverage such signals for re-ranking. To mitigate the intrinsic biases in LLMs, we propose a calibration method using a content-free query. Due to the absence of generation, ICR only requires two ($O(1)$) forward passes to re-rank $N$ documents, making it substantially more efficient than generative re-ranking methods that require at least $O(N)$ forward passes. Our novel design also enables ICR to be applied to any LLM without specialized training while guaranteeing a well-formed ranking. Extensive experiments with two popular open-weight LLMs on standard single-hop and multi-hop information retrieval benchmarks show that ICR outperforms RankGPT while cutting the latency by more than 60% in practice. Through detailed analyses, we show that ICR's performance is specially strong on tasks that require more complex re-ranking signals, such as handling contextualization and contradiction between the query and passages, as well as information integration across multiple passages. Our findings call for further exploration on novel ways of utilizing open-weight LLMs beyond text generation.
|
Large Language Model, Information Retrieval
|
We propose an efficient LLM-based re-ranking method that outperforms RankGPT while only requiring two forward passes without specialized training.
| 13,153 |
2410.02642
|
[
-0.02811243198812008,
-0.013998755253851414,
0.004584420472383499,
0.05450473725795746,
0.024980705231428146,
0.001708565279841423,
0.01711416244506836,
0.03123624064028263,
-0.0194445438683033,
-0.006830176338553429,
-0.03618377447128296,
0.02340954728424549,
-0.04879986494779587,
0.006406483240425587,
0.01150543987751007,
0.06091532111167908,
0.023742973804473877,
-0.009509432129561901,
0.014880149625241756,
-0.000137107286718674,
0.003077751025557518,
0.019265197217464447,
0.013344311155378819,
0.0011406649136915803,
0.0663408413529396,
0.005370298866182566,
0.01093134842813015,
0.004205330274999142,
-0.05015116557478905,
0.0074182553216814995,
0.012222379446029663,
-0.03953240066766739,
0.0009159927722066641,
-0.004411215893924236,
0.010669977404177189,
-0.0063241031020879745,
-0.03146027401089668,
0.004993055481463671,
0.022321626543998718,
-0.007854248397052288,
-0.04539081081748009,
-0.0010048706317320466,
-0.02711915411055088,
0.010900980792939663,
-0.07005634903907776,
0.021322349086403847,
-0.12225617468357086,
0.01780020445585251,
0.029515599831938744,
-0.019131062552332878,
-0.11330661922693253,
0.03977294638752937,
-0.0100712226703763,
-0.025622796267271042,
0.011333585716784,
0.024942003190517426,
0.04314517602324486,
-0.057816989719867706,
0.005424168426543474,
-0.019246721640229225,
-0.01915203407406807,
0.01485600695014,
0.028412455692887306,
0.054406050592660904,
-0.009970799088478088,
-0.05010542273521423,
-0.0038381617050617933,
0.0323542058467865,
-0.04764622822403908,
-0.05875217169523239,
-0.03370312228798866,
-0.007635446731001139,
-0.015490869991481304,
0.04333425313234329,
-0.0011363155208528042,
-0.0323413610458374,
0.019274214282631874,
0.04805624857544899,
0.035196591168642044,
0.019287308678030968,
0.013628019019961357,
0.020402519032359123,
0.015803223475813866,
0.03297038376331329,
-0.001887318561784923,
0.015472901053726673,
-0.039580222219228745,
-0.04193216562271118,
-0.05164829269051552,
0.014985661022365093,
-0.019140148535370827,
-0.05677847936749458,
0.011828533373773098,
0.04628441110253334,
-0.00699806772172451,
0.0164655614644289,
0.04103128984570503,
-0.026632849127054214,
-0.022224396467208862,
0.005241455044597387,
-0.020307376980781555,
-0.03032846748828888,
0.05981452763080597,
-0.0065926373936235905,
-0.10026369988918304,
-0.019949762150645256,
-0.016104355454444885,
0.012765767984092236,
0.007950241677463055,
-0.02147899754345417,
-0.039524637162685394,
-0.0014589227503165603,
-0.0017445326084271073,
0.010775895789265633,
-0.07234187424182892,
0.011110011488199234,
-0.002410931047052145,
0.01396151538938284,
0.01573069393634796,
0.023737411946058273,
0.03412709757685661,
0.04165118932723999,
0.01032401341944933,
0.06788258254528046,
-0.019913095980882645,
0.011201637797057629,
0.005087926052510738,
0.015240172855556011,
-0.06937996298074722,
-0.018343312665820122,
0.01835956610739231,
0.03933711349964142,
-0.0003909986116923392,
0.018943950533866882,
-0.033691637217998505,
0.010413032956421375,
0.011847540736198425,
0.029947949573397636,
0.0860985517501831,
-0.004402225837111473,
0.01449500024318695,
-0.03393132984638214,
0.03575193136930466,
-0.03552575409412384,
0.07122155278921127,
-0.011117513291537762,
-0.0369374044239521,
-0.006357643287628889,
-0.020421676337718964,
-0.0008964465814642608,
0.04044761136174202,
-0.003923915792256594,
0.021616080775856972,
-0.06790214031934738,
0.004310635384172201,
0.07840681821107864,
0.023402322083711624,
-0.006929733790457249,
0.0279886145144701,
0.008134841918945312,
0.016947085037827492,
0.0019019563915207982,
-0.05967441946268082,
0.013161592185497284,
-0.018253309652209282,
-0.054012399166822433,
0.012387431226670742,
0.026118943467736244,
-0.04037965089082718,
0.014355351217091084,
-0.018314043059945107,
-0.026727519929409027,
0.054632894694805145,
-0.03107093833386898,
-0.023187540471553802,
0.014418386854231358,
0.06715875118970871,
0.01667589321732521,
0.03439788147807121,
0.019231142476201057,
-0.07459251582622528,
0.017152464017271996,
-0.007448348216712475,
-0.010422596707940102,
0.024773716926574707,
-0.008919546380639076,
0.08195403218269348,
-0.0044579883106052876,
0.01197373028844595,
0.0177439134567976,
-0.10333171486854553,
0.016438620164990425,
0.007390451151877642,
0.00802761409431696,
0.07698667794466019,
0.0006778165115974844,
0.027708927169442177,
0.09140119701623917,
0.030528195202350616,
0.03445719555020332,
0.06291233748197556,
0.0008442173711955547,
0.043779969215393066,
-0.022870775312185287,
-0.0385618582367897,
-0.02390296757221222,
0.004590251483023167,
-0.05581791326403618,
-0.046093396842479706,
0.024747513234615326,
-0.014974775724112988,
0.03261181712150574,
-0.00446810619905591,
0.005573918577283621,
-0.025998765602707863,
0.005689979996532202,
0.007753385696560144,
-0.0013546828413382173,
0.007221288047730923,
-0.02546665631234646,
0.08740966022014618,
0.02823997661471367,
0.004081165883690119,
0.0019122364465147257,
-0.06118212640285492,
0.09893648326396942,
0.06444540619850159,
-0.016649404540657997,
-0.0052474550902843475,
0.03194340690970421,
0.03718266263604164,
-0.00990647729486227,
0.009605204686522484,
-0.03494652360677719,
-0.007742865476757288,
-0.031908996403217316,
-0.007023942656815052,
-0.016879472881555557,
0.034546419978141785,
-0.03980528935790062,
-0.029651110991835594,
0.05527156963944435,
-0.02479396015405655,
0.044117532670497894,
0.01083284243941307,
-0.0015957943396642804,
0.029781097546219826,
-0.03799144923686981,
-0.01881265453994274,
-0.061922356486320496,
-0.019089823588728905,
0.0049265241250395775,
-0.007793821860104799,
-0.033042848110198975,
0.030508683994412422,
-0.019766755402088165,
-0.03848884627223015,
0.008931641466915607,
0.056433819234371185,
0.0583588108420372,
0.018451688811182976,
0.030034290626645088,
0.009340319782495499,
-0.041536346077919006,
-0.0006256775814108551,
-0.07451368123292923,
-0.04696573689579964,
-0.05948144942522049,
0.0219112541526556,
0.0036367885768413544,
0.02270357683300972,
0.0253486018627882,
0.023718969896435738,
-0.026872552931308746,
-0.03646138682961464,
0.005938172806054354,
0.013312120921909809,
0.0212797112762928,
-0.014218233525753021,
-0.019605087116360664,
-0.022728824988007545,
0.03059881366789341,
-0.016002031043171883,
-0.032788485288619995,
-0.05228733643889427,
-0.04264695569872856,
-0.042193640023469925,
-0.05899583175778389,
0.01789562962949276,
0.009140572510659695,
0.0025977164041250944,
0.012821068987250328,
-0.004498171154409647,
0.033207401633262634,
0.05683965981006622,
0.027305008843541145,
0.04598727449774742,
-0.005236632656306028,
-0.02534090168774128,
0.04410155117511749,
-0.04638401418924332,
-0.006830863654613495,
0.03323039785027504,
0.040535688400268555,
-0.02309489995241165,
-0.01341175939887762,
0.006424094550311565,
-0.003975961823016405,
-0.27770471572875977,
-0.012809365056455135,
0.026575716212391853,
-0.030338352546095848,
0.032820120453834534,
-0.008310052566230297,
0.02771780453622341,
-0.04038485512137413,
-0.02511761151254177,
0.02854309417307377,
0.007691377308219671,
0.05280829221010208,
0.0035795734729617834,
0.03530823066830635,
0.02552686259150505,
0.06597667932510376,
0.0242758896201849,
0.004687846638262272,
-0.005312272813171148,
0.05220545828342438,
0.02137560211122036,
-0.06198979914188385,
-0.028461936861276627,
0.05840468406677246,
-0.014435249380767345,
0.0506708137691021,
-0.08953416347503662,
0.0053095887415111065,
-0.015822570770978928,
-0.008343867026269436,
0.0003821821592282504,
-0.027859028428792953,
0.01055811159312725,
0.027276750653982162,
-0.012260382995009422,
0.014120209962129593,
0.07519973069429398,
-0.0022008544765412807,
0.010384289547801018,
0.019690919667482376,
0.00007806401117704809,
-0.020736588165163994,
-0.017034480348229408,
-0.004775779787451029,
0.05839326232671738,
0.01747022569179535,
-0.07120287418365479,
-0.004691736306995153,
-0.00965913850814104,
0.02731168456375599,
-0.03663453087210655,
-0.055944621562957764,
-0.01681872271001339,
0.022601738572120667,
0.013988851569592953,
-0.04191594943404198,
-0.0006331270560622215,
-0.03067484125494957,
-0.010067996568977833,
-0.0196144487708807,
0.016183026134967804,
-0.041994769126176834,
-0.019142474979162216,
-0.02198115549981594,
-0.04392503574490547,
-0.04584922268986702,
-0.05762491375207901,
-0.0258327629417181,
0.03705402836203575,
0.04025523364543915,
-0.037903547286987305,
0.05381949618458748,
-0.01154776755720377,
-0.07854638993740082,
-0.022889044135808945,
-0.006428125314414501,
-0.015730632469058037,
0.02368500456213951,
-0.022148048505187035,
0.04201085865497589,
-0.04828023910522461,
-0.04804722219705582,
-0.01973862200975418,
0.0294342003762722,
0.01856173574924469,
-0.03511204943060875,
-0.015111476182937622,
-0.02543102577328682,
-0.02071223594248295,
-0.047611482441425323,
0.03340325504541397,
-0.03234422579407692,
0.0061009288765490055,
0.02523639239370823,
0.05754762515425682,
0.012367145158350468,
0.026531612500548363,
0.043365392833948135,
0.06869200617074966,
0.02910103276371956,
0.03480546548962593,
-0.03944838047027588,
0.0020090152975171804,
-0.02126421220600605,
-0.013325948268175125,
0.033525943756103516,
-0.06513923406600952,
0.007519869599491358,
0.01074792817234993,
-0.018803825601935387,
-0.06396019458770752,
-0.026507368311285973,
-0.011538288556039333,
-0.008968942798674107,
-0.02719222381711006,
-0.009035379625856876,
0.007878855802118778,
0.03982536122202873,
0.023975471034646034,
-0.028002068400382996,
-0.023188091814517975,
0.04490308091044426,
-0.02318618632853031,
-0.0013166675344109535,
-0.01312535721808672,
-0.005459186155349016,
0.021445011720061302,
-0.02332586795091629,
0.0010151031892746687,
0.0011278103338554502,
0.018540162593126297,
0.008161724545061588,
-0.02541658654808998,
-0.0010635959915816784,
0.044122207909822464,
-0.040966443717479706,
0.04878285899758339,
-0.01849481649696827,
0.045220017433166504,
0.014400413259863853,
-0.006962487008422613,
-0.012414798140525818,
0.002178675727918744,
0.05227724835276604,
0.03063831850886345,
-0.00411398708820343,
0.019832823425531387,
0.010520752519369125,
0.022565217688679695,
0.005796697922050953,
0.002097153104841709,
-0.059647832065820694,
-0.0056235333904623985,
-0.03832234442234039,
0.03439144045114517,
-0.013931642286479473,
0.03200172632932663,
-0.01605144888162613,
-0.00831473246216774,
-0.05690206587314606,
0.06385558843612671,
-0.008910851553082466,
-0.004109074827283621,
-0.00994229968637228,
0.04110855609178543,
0.023075982928276062,
0.002958915429189801,
0.03387358784675598,
0.05412224680185318,
-0.00256118131801486,
0.001644592615775764,
-0.027438702061772346,
-0.01135938335210085,
-0.010134590789675713,
-0.02783093973994255,
0.0035298271104693413,
0.009222524240612984,
0.04051898419857025,
-0.03142491728067398,
0.054277218878269196,
0.028560837730765343,
-0.009633071720600128,
-0.018325256183743477,
0.04172532632946968,
0.081845223903656,
0.0007779368897899985,
0.015076440759003162,
0.00041097289067693055,
-0.0467076301574707,
-0.009539149701595306,
-0.01447862759232521,
-0.003236636519432068,
-0.03138582780957222,
-0.047538455575704575,
-0.02427925355732441,
-0.06846042722463608,
0.014263777993619442,
-0.00486005749553442,
-0.011015882715582848,
0.005585852544754744,
-0.01448512077331543,
-0.004168527666479349,
-0.06271551549434662,
-0.03043062798678875,
0.021608896553516388,
-0.07419079542160034,
-0.008211949840188026,
-0.005462642293423414,
-0.007967811077833176,
0.010297790169715881,
-0.025136632844805717,
-0.05670946091413498,
-0.04023974388837814,
0.001762285246513784,
0.056503329426050186,
-0.01265048049390316,
-0.016265500336885452,
-0.01362549141049385,
-0.009889698587357998,
-0.015252567827701569,
0.0427825041115284,
-0.006620846688747406,
0.01670457050204277,
-0.008501549251377583,
0.01816180907189846,
0.06723415106534958,
-0.01472291350364685,
-0.017880871891975403,
-0.023274533450603485,
-0.05530021712183952,
0.034465644508600235,
-0.027090853080153465,
0.05005311593413353,
0.0653434470295906,
-0.008028106763958931,
0.01130004320293665,
-0.048982858657836914,
0.02537294290959835,
0.014174317941069603,
0.01921294815838337,
-0.0006065552006475627,
-0.014527486637234688,
-0.004841676447540522,
0.02636423520743847,
0.002940902253612876,
0.02369268797338009,
0.001198840094730258,
0.0019290236523374915,
0.007587916683405638,
0.0327644906938076,
0.019882116466760635,
0.029838332906365395,
-0.04392951354384422,
-0.025801004841923714,
0.05891180410981178,
-0.042702943086624146,
-0.03192712366580963,
-0.0895318016409874,
-0.07536031305789948,
0.03882550820708275,
0.01807408779859543,
0.021157914772629738,
-0.06293535232543945,
0.05351010337471962,
0.02861127257347107,
0.0605861097574234,
-0.007508539129048586,
-0.01012851670384407,
0.03684686869382858,
-0.04271018132567406,
-0.0060126567259430885,
-0.06756383925676346,
-0.04427405074238777,
0.08017461746931076,
-0.005842127371579409,
0.028581157326698303,
-0.020360374823212624,
-0.03373390808701515,
0.006112435832619667,
-0.014991645701229572,
-0.04473530501127243,
-0.02008826844394207,
-0.025274423882365227,
-0.01865057460963726,
0.053450219333171844,
-0.04220496118068695,
-0.009592506103217602,
-0.01222870871424675,
-0.030636105686426163,
-0.010926511138677597,
-0.01203775405883789,
0.06025056540966034,
-0.034881919622421265,
0.03999059274792671,
-0.04257768765091896,
-0.006872991099953651,
-0.01099475473165512,
0.06421497464179993,
-0.017068957909941673,
0.05143530294299126,
-0.006840397138148546,
0.03337952867150307,
0.03224877268075943,
-0.017385389655828476,
0.02041793428361416,
-0.00885856058448553,
-0.01022457703948021,
-0.03540355712175369,
0.05635710433125496,
-0.012666907161474228,
-0.000058337707741884515,
-0.04949243366718292,
0.10127709060907364,
0.035058096051216125,
-0.06014266237616539,
-0.02271271124482155,
0.023136548697948456,
-0.042527053505182266,
-0.0017091510817408562,
-0.036537375301122665,
0.004008997697383165,
-0.026255471631884575,
0.06091178208589554,
0.03829913213849068,
0.04669978469610214,
0.048978935927152634,
-0.004853105638176203,
-0.02559507079422474,
-0.015263626351952553,
0.06026313826441765,
0.0642155185341835,
0.0754421055316925,
-0.029186801984906197,
0.05289321020245552,
-0.01569245383143425,
-0.05200064182281494,
0.003961647395044565,
0.005647127982228994,
0.004751408472657204,
-0.037958160042762756,
-0.0023726527579128742,
0.06763165444135666,
-0.011913172900676727,
0.07013509422540665,
-0.036243878304958344,
0.0032657410483807325,
0.048369742929935455,
-0.013793382793664932,
0.005396696738898754,
0.05629701539874077,
0.03353479132056236,
0.040943749248981476,
-0.07196059077978134,
-0.01673867739737034,
-0.007179007865488529,
-0.019504588097333908,
0.0022442396730184555,
0.008473544381558895,
0.000931864429730922,
-0.020131448283791542,
-0.04109957441687584,
0.030708136036992073,
0.12505587935447693,
-0.03077572025358677,
-0.03356494382023811,
0.0026049369480460882,
0.01600552909076214,
0.013430413790047169,
0.031699858605861664,
-0.0004632301570381969,
-0.00909294281154871,
-0.002116153482347727,
-0.046035975217819214,
-0.0011470067547634244,
0.03564843907952309,
-0.020852956920862198,
0.018486058339476585,
-0.009565980173647404,
-0.03147731348872185,
0.021958401426672935,
0.05810011550784111,
-0.04974165931344032,
-0.03810176998376846,
-0.038062430918216705,
-0.03154163435101509,
-0.02246958017349243,
-0.038000963628292084,
0.04669663682579994,
0.023834552615880966,
0.0010585824493318796,
-0.004851612728089094,
-0.06122585013508797,
-0.01079200766980648,
0.02094324678182602,
-0.043367352336645126,
0.04006915166974068,
0.0327187106013298,
-0.004227500408887863,
-0.04256395250558853,
0.03928321599960327,
0.00232524867169559,
-0.016733603551983833,
0.001847195322625339,
0.05776641145348549,
0.026531295850872993,
0.025253131985664368,
-0.0032918096985667944,
-0.042669426649808884,
-0.09005431830883026,
0.009204269386827946,
-0.0006160035845823586,
-0.05453885719180107,
-0.08051419258117676,
0.016638491302728653,
0.0010442135389894247,
0.01772226206958294,
0.03665507957339287,
0.002874736674129963,
0.035009436309337616,
-0.029480844736099243,
0.003148338757455349,
0.02317674830555916,
0.01995101198554039,
0.053019776940345764,
-0.0022111772559583187,
0.0617058165371418,
0.021807093173265457,
0.022687241435050964,
-0.02531840279698372,
-0.013191087171435356,
-0.005318989045917988,
-0.029032902792096138,
-0.027258433401584625,
-0.026059996336698532,
-0.043462447822093964,
-0.08477193117141724,
-0.04615551605820656,
0.03274896740913391,
-0.007198285777121782,
-0.014841574244201183,
0.011133336462080479,
-0.024415073916316032,
0.0003449977084528655,
-0.03061664290726185,
-0.013714351691305637,
-0.004224991891533136,
-0.011838078498840332,
-0.03126175329089165,
-0.06805070489645004,
-0.007942849770188332,
-0.029437927529215813,
-0.005729787051677704,
-0.02221507951617241,
-0.019678698852658272,
0.01714959368109703,
-0.016698790714144707,
0.05676828324794769,
0.0018626615637913346,
0.024606816470623016,
-0.03958892822265625
] |
395 |
Inspection and Control of Self-Generated-Text Recognition Ability in Llama3-8b-Instruct
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=wWnsoLhHwt
|
[
"Christopher Ackerman",
"Nina Panickssery"
] |
Poster
|
It has been reported that LLMs can recognize their own writing. As this has potential implications for AI safety, yet is relatively understudied, we investigate the phenomenon, seeking to establish: whether it robustly occurs at the behavioral level, how the observed behavior is achieved, and whether it can be controlled. First, we find that the Llama3-8b–Instruct chat model - but not the base Llama3-8b model - can reliably distinguish its own outputs from those of humans, and present evidence that the chat model is likely using its experience with its own outputs, acquired during post-training, to succeed at the writing recognition task. Second, we identify a vector in the residual stream of the model that is differentially activated when the model makes a correct self-written-text recognition judgment, show that the vector activates in response to information relevant to self-authorship, present evidence that the vector is related to the concept of ``self'' in the model, and demonstrate that the vector is causally related to the model’s ability to perceive and assert self-authorship. Finally, we show that the vector can be used to control both the model’s behavior and its perception, steering the model to claim or disclaim authorship by applying the vector to the model’s output as it generates it, and steering the model to believe or disbelieve it wrote arbitrary texts by applying the vector to them as the model reads them.
|
LLM, Interpretability, AI, Activation Steering, Representation Engineering, Control
| null | 13,146 |
2410.02064
|
[
-0.022211145609617233,
0.0008336296305060387,
-0.01877513900399208,
0.02699396014213562,
0.06561433523893356,
-0.03136816993355751,
0.035292964428663254,
0.03305240720510483,
-0.030266527086496353,
-0.0012212133733555675,
-0.02564902789890766,
0.06625901907682419,
-0.03883478045463562,
-0.01113248709589243,
0.003088203025981784,
0.05889100953936577,
0.029931383207440376,
0.00771303242072463,
0.018326900899410248,
-0.0015027628978714347,
-0.005499956663697958,
-0.00533345015719533,
0.01895102672278881,
0.016821252182126045,
0.02473462000489235,
0.004819250199943781,
0.015292448922991753,
-0.00037017089198343456,
-0.01987895742058754,
0.014526711776852608,
0.04789135977625847,
-0.02716178074479103,
0.008579901419579983,
-0.031420208513736725,
0.019108349457383156,
0.0010674494551494718,
-0.06958645582199097,
0.0016188484150916338,
-0.010137585923075676,
0.016772080212831497,
-0.0321357399225235,
0.02382589876651764,
-0.033965613692998886,
-0.015079349279403687,
-0.08207911252975464,
0.003606912912800908,
-0.12579725682735443,
0.01086374931037426,
0.034448977559804916,
0.002779398811981082,
-0.12803532183170319,
0.04723796993494034,
-0.019394434988498688,
-0.006810896564275026,
0.03746385872364044,
0.03456432744860649,
0.017785901203751564,
-0.0903952419757843,
-0.009845004417002201,
-0.025985997170209885,
-0.012160173617303371,
-0.014370751567184925,
-0.010638241656124592,
-0.007232150994241238,
-0.03781053423881531,
-0.028197679668664932,
0.030367720872163773,
0.0010813575936481357,
-0.06812424957752228,
-0.025347178801894188,
-0.030945859849452972,
0.030237974599003792,
-0.027754420414566994,
-0.01148836500942707,
-0.002723141573369503,
-0.08529190719127655,
0.018024295568466187,
0.0426340252161026,
0.055724676698446274,
0.00034148397389799356,
0.014835772104561329,
0.03592062368988991,
0.008525986224412918,
0.044247228652238846,
-0.0063554816879332066,
0.0007755637052468956,
-0.012317784130573273,
-0.02929934859275818,
-0.04664160683751106,
0.006124325096607208,
-0.02330419234931469,
-0.05480882152915001,
0.012421331368386745,
0.048155881464481354,
0.023196114227175713,
0.01060881745070219,
0.024742454290390015,
0.033383920788764954,
-0.013746993616223335,
0.008897277526557446,
-0.011697028763592243,
-0.03556031733751297,
0.011208507232367992,
0.03296450898051262,
-0.09537452459335327,
-0.021279234439134598,
-0.008275718428194523,
-0.022371022030711174,
-0.009669691324234009,
0.003964842762798071,
-0.01829700544476509,
-0.04615526646375656,
0.018390681594610214,
0.0002856313658412546,
-0.08111680299043655,
0.024827582761645317,
0.003755443962290883,
0.04815089330077171,
0.01165736373513937,
0.0331893265247345,
0.04795752465724945,
0.04434094950556755,
-0.007223464548587799,
0.05757063254714012,
-0.01281782053411007,
-0.007723117247223854,
0.013433746062219143,
0.046177301555871964,
0.004780384711921215,
-0.0367576964199543,
0.0023995726369321346,
0.053362779319286346,
0.01272161491215229,
0.04220356047153473,
0.006562080699950457,
0.009342165663838387,
0.004928250797092915,
0.008604027330875397,
0.03403215482831001,
0.04175916314125061,
0.0008104940643534064,
-0.002317422768101096,
0.04850190877914429,
-0.011670159175992012,
0.09415692090988159,
0.002533406252041459,
-0.018090231344103813,
0.004967541433870792,
-0.050558459013700485,
-0.021165521815419197,
0.02621493861079216,
-0.044997554272413254,
0.0029025841504335403,
-0.06267416477203369,
0.022450048476457596,
0.04209582880139351,
0.030161187052726746,
0.028139641508460045,
0.0017870094161480665,
-0.00827552005648613,
-0.0034428369253873825,
0.015958638861775398,
-0.03551048785448074,
0.01949559710919857,
-0.03204807639122009,
-0.030685892328619957,
0.010921226814389229,
0.00023295868595596403,
-0.029609689489006996,
0.015587086789309978,
-0.0338774099946022,
-0.04090037941932678,
0.046233437955379486,
-0.009178844280540943,
-0.03739340603351593,
-0.016659166663885117,
0.03228563442826271,
-0.0008277152664959431,
0.031876157969236374,
0.03811337426304817,
-0.07172920554876328,
0.03575434163212776,
-0.002132764318957925,
0.009254525415599346,
0.019302183762192726,
-0.01825912855565548,
0.08153919130563736,
-0.03140467405319214,
-0.015036951750516891,
-0.010961676947772503,
-0.06901761889457703,
0.0037557785399258137,
0.02183019369840622,
0.012154408730566502,
0.06466216593980789,
-0.008662890642881393,
-0.004292930010706186,
0.0461064912378788,
0.03571968153119087,
0.06785383075475693,
0.05548045039176941,
-0.02466975525021553,
0.06367899477481842,
-0.009807843714952469,
-0.030708450824022293,
-0.01665092259645462,
0.02791726402938366,
-0.04545251280069351,
-0.01735345833003521,
0.009821023792028427,
-0.036190226674079895,
0.016282135620713234,
0.022236105054616928,
0.02287295088171959,
0.0013641681289300323,
0.012299574911594391,
-0.0028965878300368786,
0.00008968507609097287,
0.01637202687561512,
-0.06720585376024246,
0.035022538155317307,
0.026132050901651382,
-0.012083974666893482,
-0.012033291161060333,
-0.0180263239890337,
0.11358314007520676,
0.055641137063503265,
-0.06621173024177551,
-0.012820188887417316,
-0.0023231259547173977,
-0.009846408851444721,
0.0014071083860471845,
0.020132098346948624,
0.007444063201546669,
-0.012082037515938282,
-0.02157568372786045,
0.006929910741746426,
-0.036526601761579514,
0.05235891044139862,
-0.014249776490032673,
-0.01778395287692547,
0.07907019555568695,
-0.03291039913892746,
0.05580439046025276,
-0.02945186011493206,
0.030072713270783424,
0.031775716692209244,
-0.014652151614427567,
-0.014149004593491554,
-0.009610408917069435,
-0.021550606936216354,
-0.00044638701365329325,
-0.011283333413302898,
-0.034056056290864944,
0.018973246216773987,
-0.05173705145716667,
-0.04714292660355568,
-0.03214334324002266,
0.07413465529680252,
0.03625323623418808,
-0.005306979641318321,
0.043413080275058746,
-0.0010510123101994395,
-0.00296603562310338,
0.008337745442986488,
-0.09114640951156616,
-0.011289226822555065,
0.0140690878033638,
0.0003187841211911291,
0.00944566074758768,
0.044451043009757996,
-0.012189913541078568,
0.023624196648597717,
-0.024324318394064903,
0.016547791659832,
0.032657139003276825,
0.023392627015709877,
-0.01912732422351837,
-0.023634251207113266,
-0.013057566247880459,
-0.028616411611437798,
0.06504403799772263,
-0.013937631621956825,
-0.027146389707922935,
-0.030877510085701942,
-0.05111423134803772,
-0.01941499672830105,
-0.029047489166259766,
-0.035687051713466644,
-0.01927322894334793,
-0.025520645081996918,
0.021869273856282234,
0.008201539516448975,
0.05468619242310524,
0.008903931826353073,
0.06760191172361374,
0.034458305686712265,
0.0007676383247599006,
-0.017032425850629807,
0.0386468879878521,
-0.011721287854015827,
0.018942534923553467,
0.02118200808763504,
0.0119761498644948,
0.00466469582170248,
-0.003333033062517643,
0.008966335095465183,
-0.002303631976246834,
-0.29666852951049805,
-0.006704291328787804,
0.021649260073900223,
-0.04186872020363808,
0.028459910303354263,
-0.004515327047556639,
0.05644797906279564,
-0.014891651459038258,
-0.018338985741138458,
0.020954757928848267,
-0.0025288392789661884,
0.047796644270420074,
0.02023981884121895,
0.03680283576250076,
0.03249990567564964,
0.021115900948643684,
-0.02837919071316719,
-0.04825148731470108,
0.0045097521506249905,
0.040475524961948395,
-0.009080340154469013,
-0.04628187045454979,
-0.057895757257938385,
0.05077560245990753,
-0.0022813654504716396,
0.08160964399576187,
-0.06632881611585617,
-0.0011598924174904823,
-0.01369168609380722,
0.026505708694458008,
-0.03536789491772652,
-0.004151047673076391,
-0.009868293069303036,
0.048655226826667786,
-0.005775243043899536,
-0.003313404740765691,
0.043683119118213654,
-0.014252838678658009,
0.015633538365364075,
0.012921508401632309,
0.03787095099687576,
-0.032591063529253006,
0.0036906457971781492,
-0.0013414043933153152,
0.06267271935939789,
0.0220639668405056,
-0.05342430993914604,
-0.024368809536099434,
0.022222526371479034,
0.026641126722097397,
-0.03200124204158783,
-0.04227358102798462,
-0.029343919828534126,
0.0075010089203715324,
-0.0019860786851495504,
-0.021443547680974007,
-0.006220537703484297,
-0.012544655241072178,
-0.03970455378293991,
0.008492358028888702,
-0.025160521268844604,
-0.01681174896657467,
-0.05055273696780205,
-0.04479784518480301,
-0.00971626490354538,
-0.03327009454369545,
-0.03597506508231163,
-0.057931579649448395,
0.06234800070524216,
0.030894652009010315,
-0.005812262184917927,
0.02744889445602894,
-0.05128060653805733,
-0.09086363762617111,
0.025102974846959114,
-0.015981055796146393,
-0.02295299991965294,
-0.01727912947535515,
-0.02291911654174328,
0.02528349868953228,
-0.041418954730033875,
-0.04691551998257637,
-0.008084678091108799,
-0.019908122718334198,
0.014298781752586365,
-0.0064391945488750935,
0.008485392667353153,
-0.003217471530660987,
-0.006689324043691158,
-0.037382010370492935,
0.06240450218319893,
0.028422461822628975,
-0.01599184237420559,
0.005051355343312025,
0.06553207337856293,
0.037071410566568375,
0.045695893466472626,
0.03158876672387123,
0.053634751588106155,
0.013902366161346436,
0.044216547161340714,
-0.08122289925813675,
0.002780251670628786,
-0.027131782844662666,
-0.02099427580833435,
0.030126484110951424,
-0.04972359165549278,
-0.035804253071546555,
0.052709441632032394,
-0.006752266548573971,
-0.030271193012595177,
-0.024187030270695686,
0.010139195248484612,
-0.012556212022900581,
-0.005882071331143379,
-0.02413824200630188,
0.030100833624601364,
0.0023820661008358,
0.020685527473688126,
-0.04873913526535034,
-0.03711174800992012,
0.02947067655622959,
-0.012482281774282455,
0.00020358093024697155,
-0.009800195693969727,
-0.0219844002276659,
-0.0013651950284838676,
-0.006445796228945255,
-0.009290610440075397,
-0.011435321532189846,
0.018957264721393585,
0.004492352716624737,
0.017793772742152214,
0.020535599440336227,
0.05556866526603699,
-0.010580284520983696,
-0.007432561833411455,
0.005611915607005358,
0.017481589689850807,
-0.034564632922410965,
-0.006301425397396088,
-0.03622814267873764,
0.045823272317647934,
0.02689996175467968,
0.0353897400200367,
-0.026448503136634827,
-0.00033965386683121324,
-0.02749697118997574,
-0.04034629091620445,
-0.01546922791749239,
0.07017029821872711,
-0.05311857536435127,
-0.030105996876955032,
-0.01779050938785076,
0.008744960650801659,
-0.016605254262685776,
0.005264336243271828,
0.017413992434740067,
0.020730474963784218,
-0.04621473699808121,
0.048771221190690994,
0.018288390710949898,
0.002361751627177,
0.005457001738250256,
0.03133726119995117,
0.04276077821850777,
-0.029133357107639313,
0.005050249397754669,
0.055144742131233215,
0.03924189880490303,
0.003266557352617383,
-0.03391777351498604,
-0.027021735906600952,
-0.01999529078602791,
-0.01764042302966118,
0.021634085103869438,
0.022707264870405197,
-0.034588493406772614,
-0.02253822237253189,
0.03901328146457672,
0.0023242186289280653,
-0.05158747360110283,
0.006009587086737156,
0.00039807800203561783,
0.09289661794900894,
0.030096663162112236,
0.021860763430595398,
-0.018457943573594093,
-0.04510730132460594,
0.023844726383686066,
-0.024061916396021843,
-0.0005713492282666266,
-0.03279457986354828,
-0.02812275104224682,
-0.05881297588348389,
-0.04715941846370697,
-0.006792347878217697,
-0.005007009953260422,
0.035926513373851776,
-0.02068413607776165,
-0.016557659953832626,
0.0006808458128944039,
-0.047134626656770706,
-0.0518752783536911,
0.010677664540708065,
-0.08537493646144867,
0.003719875356182456,
0.005369368940591812,
-0.02970295026898384,
0.04121691361069679,
-0.050934214144945145,
-0.029674341902136803,
-0.02935131825506687,
-0.017366603016853333,
0.03307022154331207,
-0.015305154025554657,
-0.05432546138763428,
-0.04645724222064018,
-0.027369456365704536,
0.006817599292844534,
0.0022254055365920067,
-0.005359793081879616,
-0.02105489932000637,
-0.00007275310053955764,
-0.014977890066802502,
0.02471509575843811,
-0.007345238234847784,
-0.028447482734918594,
0.035039596259593964,
-0.04590767249464989,
0.043717604130506516,
-0.032988548278808594,
0.01350940577685833,
0.04095710068941116,
-0.025118833407759666,
-0.02586517296731472,
-0.03569858893752098,
0.033432137221097946,
0.0067587727680802345,
-0.0022584490943700075,
0.020920757204294205,
-0.017750725150108337,
-0.02643958106637001,
0.015822475776076317,
0.027248086407780647,
0.038642145693302155,
-0.01471682358533144,
0.01627586968243122,
-0.003287598490715027,
0.040204040706157684,
0.017500681802630424,
0.00544818164780736,
-0.019635027274489403,
-0.004775491077452898,
0.05185924097895622,
-0.00994941033422947,
-0.011493459343910217,
-0.03413184732198715,
-0.034690432250499725,
0.015252399258315563,
0.0020803650841116905,
0.0227699913084507,
-0.05962858721613884,
0.045357007533311844,
0.02498554438352585,
0.028841789811849594,
-0.00037793457158841193,
0.007857821881771088,
0.05048166960477829,
-0.04895426332950592,
0.008961313404142857,
-0.05303267762064934,
-0.02409781888127327,
0.05629265680909157,
-0.06324061006307602,
0.010083786211907864,
-0.003486924571916461,
-0.022928250953555107,
0.0550776943564415,
-0.012362140230834484,
-0.032449040561914444,
0.02195580117404461,
-0.00751110352575779,
-0.020687071606516838,
0.023170066997408867,
-0.05308663845062256,
0.013203473761677742,
-0.040779486298561096,
-0.04234490916132927,
-0.004405401647090912,
0.0027768509462475777,
0.06095333769917488,
-0.012300172820687294,
0.01162544172257185,
-0.0017108275787904859,
-0.011630288325250149,
0.011128370650112629,
0.06296306848526001,
0.004223147872835398,
0.02102569118142128,
-0.026938986033201218,
0.09340113401412964,
0.0333169586956501,
0.04280936345458031,
0.019597411155700684,
-0.000028769956770702265,
-0.03307999297976494,
-0.05302056670188904,
0.03654550760984421,
-0.010479435324668884,
-0.03169163689017296,
-0.0363878533244133,
0.07143072783946991,
0.03774335980415344,
-0.036838844418525696,
-0.04334092140197754,
0.036304835230112076,
-0.034970756620168686,
-0.02767445705831051,
-0.0022089756093919277,
0.014167473651468754,
-0.006686489563435316,
0.05865132063627243,
0.011331169866025448,
0.0459103137254715,
0.05555228143930435,
-0.0324622243642807,
0.003513153176754713,
0.03740311041474342,
0.06587795168161392,
0.06648395210504532,
0.05914294347167015,
0.021062491461634636,
0.06996382772922516,
-0.029926782473921776,
-0.05499602481722832,
0.02992060035467148,
0.03252849355340004,
0.005399154964834452,
-0.0110803646966815,
0.026313714683055878,
0.06420376896858215,
-0.02330176904797554,
0.05190945044159889,
-0.05678365379571915,
-0.012363878078758717,
0.05224141851067543,
0.03520826995372772,
-0.02348407730460167,
0.0021332665346562862,
0.041886381804943085,
-0.014918433502316475,
-0.04028598219156265,
-0.027865344658493996,
-0.010571768507361412,
-0.058718159794807434,
-0.008650681935250759,
0.00845172069966793,
-0.024543508887290955,
0.02073276787996292,
-0.053587183356285095,
0.09417220950126648,
0.10944782942533493,
-0.01625983417034149,
-0.0009812701027840376,
0.009032348170876503,
0.01949126459658146,
0.033138714730739594,
0.06834229081869125,
-0.018076756969094276,
0.003431407967582345,
-0.00277055730111897,
-0.02589990943670273,
0.036270271986722946,
0.02000868134200573,
0.007131068967282772,
0.0362040139734745,
-0.006808276288211346,
-0.04590858519077301,
0.018425285816192627,
0.024073204025626183,
-0.05066246539354324,
-0.03162344917654991,
-0.017781170085072517,
-0.037773240357637405,
-0.036548543721437454,
-0.0203942209482193,
0.04616197198629379,
0.004087872803211212,
-0.04621599242091179,
0.006428783759474754,
-0.018368523567914963,
0.02003108151257038,
0.025436222553253174,
-0.07470877468585968,
0.008127926848828793,
0.02667142078280449,
0.010232668370008469,
-0.01803068444132805,
0.05119462311267853,
0.02191147767007351,
-0.007316793780773878,
-0.01653028465807438,
0.004703687969595194,
-0.015858924016356468,
0.02661663293838501,
0.007676252163946629,
-0.03227725997567177,
-0.10081332921981812,
-0.01966332085430622,
0.024611471220850945,
-0.041786499321460724,
-0.07564658671617508,
0.03123362362384796,
-0.034676071256399155,
0.034564800560474396,
0.07040882855653763,
0.008432116359472275,
0.005427067168056965,
-0.006440047174692154,
-0.017250649631023407,
-0.009831171482801437,
0.04089595749974251,
0.08222126215696335,
0.005474457982927561,
0.0734277293086052,
0.037144653499126434,
-0.03156431391835213,
-0.03058118000626564,
0.00572319608181715,
-0.0006263784016482532,
-0.01441702339798212,
-0.02108418010175228,
-0.028520645573735237,
-0.009025117382407188,
-0.09915971755981445,
-0.00601992616429925,
0.03611758351325989,
0.003362056100741029,
-0.05101999267935753,
0.005292169284075499,
-0.03509341925382614,
0.00911468081176281,
-0.01579400897026062,
-0.014066698029637337,
-0.017601214349269867,
-0.03541284054517746,
-0.054796066135168076,
-0.058231696486473083,
-0.008350390940904617,
-0.013752453029155731,
0.010775579139590263,
-0.03463675454258919,
-0.04781433939933777,
0.003834781004115939,
0.0191075149923563,
0.01019496563822031,
-0.02390659600496292,
0.005888151936233044,
-0.02162032201886177
] |
396 |
Towards Learning High-Precision Least Squares Algorithms with Sequence Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=snocoXIQXz
|
[
"Jerry Weihong Liu",
"Jessica Grogan",
"Owen M Dugan",
"Ashish Rao",
"Simran Arora",
"Atri Rudra",
"Christopher Re"
] |
Poster
|
This paper investigates whether sequence models can learn to perform numerical algorithms, e.g. gradient descent, on the fundamental problem of least squares. Our goal is to inherit two properties of standard algorithms from numerical analysis: (1) machine precision, i.e. we want to obtain solutions that are accurate to near floating point error, and (2) numerical generality, i.e. we want them to apply broadly across problem instances. We find that prior approaches using Transformers fail to meet these criteria, and identify limitations present in existing architectures and training procedures. First, we show that softmax Transformers struggle to perform high-precision multiplications, which prevents them from precisely learning numerical algorithms. Second, we identify an alternate class of architectures, comprised entirely of polynomials, that can efficiently represent high-precision gradient descent iterates. Finally, we investigate precision bottlenecks during training and address them via a high-precision training recipe that reduces stochastic gradient noise. Our recipe enables us to train two polynomial architectures, gated convolutions and linear attention, to perform gradient descent iterates on least squares problems. For the first time, we demonstrate the ability to train to near machine precision. Applied iteratively, our models obtain $100,000\times$ lower MSE than standard Transformers trained end-to-end and they incur a $10,000\times$ smaller generalization gap on out-of-distribution problems. We make progress towards end-to-end learning of numerical algorithms for least squares.
|
high precision, least squares, algorithm learning, Transformers, gated convolutions, linear regression, in-context learning
|
This work uncovers limitations of Transformers for high-precision numerical tasks, and makes progress towards training gated convolutional models to machine precision as an alternative.
| 13,145 |
2503.12295
|
[
-0.028269384056329727,
-0.010221931152045727,
-0.003761169034987688,
0.030111366882920265,
0.03511389344930649,
0.032621532678604126,
0.016033153980970383,
0.008142584934830666,
-0.018623661249876022,
-0.0034993612207472324,
-0.013368544168770313,
0.024295661598443985,
-0.05907832831144333,
0.012989879585802555,
-0.021555589511990547,
0.05759122967720032,
0.03287116438150406,
-0.011423267424106598,
0.000020906196368741803,
0.03220205381512642,
-0.0102061927318573,
-0.028607042506337166,
0.032952480018138885,
0.003922902047634125,
0.006486113183200359,
0.0029602013528347015,
-0.0023618212435394526,
0.003238462843000889,
-0.05149592086672783,
-0.01910870335996151,
0.02494962140917778,
-0.02238570712506771,
0.00419658562168479,
-0.02462165616452694,
0.03093835338950157,
0.025427555665373802,
-0.04523035138845444,
0.018658122047781944,
0.004143238998949528,
0.01879390887916088,
-0.017672786489129066,
-0.027510542422533035,
-0.02822873182594776,
0.02589084953069687,
-0.07624493539333344,
0.010192709043622017,
-0.10738835483789444,
0.0031567334663122892,
-0.01217582542449236,
-0.044690899550914764,
-0.10270626842975616,
0.07283173501491547,
0.04059668257832527,
-0.025482919067144394,
0.017493927851319313,
0.03787994757294655,
0.02836737036705017,
-0.06834520399570465,
-0.013483710587024689,
-0.03782226890325546,
-0.01764753647148609,
0.013392261229455471,
0.00907402765005827,
-0.02565857023000717,
0.014730546623468399,
-0.031871043145656586,
0.0022635050117969513,
0.0365811251103878,
-0.054932158440351486,
-0.03136212006211281,
-0.020145751535892487,
0.01735617034137249,
0.00429246760904789,
0.01468160841614008,
-0.004442780278623104,
-0.031781312078237534,
0.01016192976385355,
0.028095006942749023,
0.07775327563285828,
0.012608879245817661,
-0.014033883810043335,
0.005727170035243034,
0.03475750610232353,
0.03481149300932884,
-0.0002517013344913721,
0.029978560283780098,
-0.016859067603945732,
-0.03142896294593811,
-0.07420989125967026,
0.03868237882852554,
-0.013127447105944157,
-0.07634662091732025,
0.01196860522031784,
0.01648048497736454,
0.004509820602834225,
0.022775888442993164,
0.01297912746667862,
0.036668457090854645,
0.013215606100857258,
0.022148532792925835,
-0.03636539354920387,
-0.04644913971424103,
0.04780424013733864,
-0.00800922978669405,
-0.0999867171049118,
-0.02889362722635269,
0.0015404870500788093,
0.002544780494645238,
0.03313225135207176,
0.006291581783443689,
-0.0350041426718235,
0.006305645685642958,
0.003270829562097788,
-0.0386163592338562,
-0.0869235098361969,
0.02517862059175968,
-0.014758151955902576,
0.006951373070478439,
-0.028138170018792152,
-0.0292985737323761,
0.06777618080377579,
0.03038598783314228,
-0.0007894961163401604,
0.0838177427649498,
-0.017349105328321457,
0.0183123666793108,
0.02521846815943718,
0.055103790014982224,
-0.02970604971051216,
-0.04383613169193268,
-0.013642392121255398,
0.0326199047267437,
-0.011510034091770649,
0.0319804884493351,
-0.008729346096515656,
0.010597605258226395,
-0.045107848942279816,
0.007043611258268356,
0.040554873645305634,
0.007921825163066387,
0.028429634869098663,
-0.0021110246889293194,
0.0645880401134491,
-0.04448620229959488,
0.05644289776682854,
-0.029082395136356354,
-0.01563710905611515,
-0.01861233077943325,
-0.033481255173683167,
-0.02932247705757618,
0.013260181993246078,
-0.008919959887862206,
-0.020818013697862625,
-0.11426432430744171,
0.03332919627428055,
0.04855293780565262,
0.009981727227568626,
0.04682593047618866,
-0.018055126070976257,
0.015531839802861214,
0.009468849748373032,
-0.016368910670280457,
-0.03104759007692337,
0.002476524328812957,
-0.027567772194743156,
-0.0826760083436966,
0.06562057137489319,
0.053428009152412415,
-0.036308251321315765,
0.004761276766657829,
-0.019230758771300316,
-0.04227832332253456,
0.04993945732712746,
-0.010582256130874157,
-0.012539826333522797,
-0.008044817484915257,
0.04231317341327667,
0.0016902502393350005,
0.07189561426639557,
0.027709651738405228,
-0.09563209116458893,
0.04202261194586754,
0.02542961947619915,
-0.005270966794341803,
0.008500994183123112,
-0.040007513016462326,
0.09038932621479034,
-0.026331068947911263,
0.0053686778992414474,
0.00759849464520812,
-0.07922177016735077,
-0.023676635697484016,
-0.01901688426733017,
-0.03424135223031044,
0.054611749947071075,
0.019316086545586586,
-0.008686810731887817,
-0.037097953259944916,
0.01088231336325407,
0.03673579916357994,
0.05172751843929291,
-0.02579624392092228,
0.06069357320666313,
0.008402887731790543,
-0.05124960094690323,
0.003454764373600483,
0.02314181439578533,
-0.05285286903381348,
-0.0228872187435627,
0.008215404115617275,
-0.01549626886844635,
-0.007799383718520403,
0.024768942967057228,
-0.016075752675533295,
-0.008291478268802166,
-0.005577209871262312,
-0.024352965876460075,
-0.010847275145351887,
0.0412856824696064,
-0.06343182176351547,
0.001959489192813635,
0.027143025770783424,
-0.009487412869930267,
0.01623936928808689,
-0.04145580902695656,
0.09166017919778824,
0.06549518555402756,
-0.028749944642186165,
-0.017219899222254753,
0.016734249889850616,
0.03159444406628609,
-0.014169489033520222,
-0.0029006025288254023,
-0.032737091183662415,
0.019422493875026703,
0.0020987209863960743,
0.000244349503191188,
-0.044261664152145386,
0.05880181863903999,
-0.03717299550771713,
-0.007435995154082775,
0.07648471742868423,
-0.0341373085975647,
0.0625542551279068,
0.010232080705463886,
0.0027311600279062986,
-0.002776278415694833,
-0.013854057528078556,
-0.028659585863351822,
-0.028006507083773613,
-0.04001406580209732,
-0.0022255750373005867,
-0.006105301436036825,
-0.002589890966191888,
-0.022574886679649353,
-0.01732465624809265,
-0.06904773414134979,
-0.004820894915610552,
0.08707094937562943,
0.042763400822877884,
0.015830742195248604,
-0.008247245103120804,
0.03466131165623665,
-0.027450069785118103,
-0.011839628219604492,
-0.09641050547361374,
-0.044114675372838974,
-0.04215840995311737,
0.05055943876504898,
0.005861995276063681,
0.04321373254060745,
0.01911848597228527,
0.02710156887769699,
-0.006946526002138853,
-0.031111203134059906,
-0.023385467007756233,
0.05400910973548889,
0.011632423847913742,
-0.05792246758937836,
-0.03506268560886383,
0.012265635654330254,
0.07475855201482773,
-0.03434590995311737,
-0.03489561751484871,
-0.04401267692446709,
-0.039245761930942535,
-0.011961299926042557,
-0.033018290996551514,
-0.0006623970111832023,
-0.00040569150587543845,
-0.0188741497695446,
0.03849554434418678,
-0.04390101507306099,
0.016573181375861168,
0.04417886584997177,
0.07460751384496689,
0.05845068022608757,
0.004451753571629524,
-0.00021566821669694036,
0.02141083963215351,
-0.008799859322607517,
0.018352773040533066,
-0.012495098635554314,
0.0173226036131382,
-0.02805197238922119,
-0.013581697829067707,
0.00948644895106554,
-0.0072809201665222645,
-0.27024534344673157,
-0.02229922264814377,
-0.03634180128574371,
-0.009394047781825066,
0.0535111129283905,
-0.032995350658893585,
0.035888638347387314,
-0.01066815946251154,
-0.017963144928216934,
0.00837491825222969,
0.015248177573084831,
0.032965730875730515,
0.015920331701636314,
0.05088711902499199,
0.030759477987885475,
-0.0021430368069559336,
-0.0018188313115388155,
-0.001822244026698172,
0.004494319204241037,
0.03341914713382721,
0.008645998314023018,
-0.08324241638183594,
0.005646275822073221,
0.0321430079638958,
-0.01436831895262003,
0.040213923901319504,
-0.08447432518005371,
-0.007175263483077288,
-0.03668951988220215,
-0.02291025035083294,
-0.032934047281742096,
-0.019854629412293434,
-0.015383308753371239,
0.047036536037921906,
-0.006801314651966095,
0.011804170906543732,
0.03599027544260025,
-0.007930178195238113,
0.017638780176639557,
0.020682815462350845,
0.007007623091340065,
-0.01509481854736805,
0.005750809796154499,
0.023962711915373802,
0.0908203274011612,
0.007407165132462978,
-0.026007816195487976,
-0.024103311821818352,
-0.013374747708439827,
0.03541230410337448,
-0.018287695944309235,
-0.02674148790538311,
0.006493505090475082,
0.014003007672727108,
-0.0028233728371560574,
-0.020288852974772453,
-0.006841273978352547,
-0.02142651565372944,
0.0008489832398481667,
0.011109212413430214,
-0.00021123762417118996,
-0.056117311120033264,
-0.010610139928758144,
-0.039067141711711884,
-0.029338259249925613,
-0.012183156795799732,
-0.052269868552684784,
-0.06682206690311432,
0.018047695979475975,
0.012706263922154903,
-0.02275330387055874,
0.05308859795331955,
-0.013154597021639347,
-0.07086340337991714,
-0.0007987167919054627,
-0.01723933033645153,
0.00948930624872446,
-0.020312171429395676,
-0.00011019739031326026,
0.049378544092178345,
-0.03294402360916138,
-0.07913681864738464,
0.02166411653161049,
0.006953763775527477,
0.047240257263183594,
-0.005853213835507631,
0.02250904031097889,
-0.03031284548342228,
0.013262191787362099,
-0.03841459006071091,
0.04049510881304741,
-0.008089922368526459,
0.03507353365421295,
-0.015784474089741707,
0.08063650131225586,
0.02714942768216133,
0.008443686179816723,
0.0812983289361,
0.04364526644349098,
-0.006750304717570543,
0.024327639490365982,
-0.06297348439693451,
0.0022490955889225006,
-0.058535318821668625,
-0.001582550466991961,
0.00001947511191247031,
-0.034156933426856995,
-0.03215270861983299,
0.040594492107629776,
0.004525912459939718,
-0.015602882951498032,
-0.036179445683956146,
-0.008422568440437317,
-0.016681499779224396,
-0.02938264235854149,
-0.014603598043322563,
0.022536925971508026,
-0.004361836239695549,
0.03168962150812149,
-0.005429363809525967,
-0.006178251001983881,
0.051337141543626785,
-0.05266572907567024,
-0.021150175482034683,
-0.006743317004293203,
-0.016894441097974777,
-0.0014067142037674785,
-0.0064734797924757,
-0.023525206372141838,
-0.011138921603560448,
0.021591700613498688,
0.06717288494110107,
-0.008104459382593632,
0.02691272459924221,
0.08405081182718277,
0.04653500020503998,
0.010197379626333714,
-0.0015584318898618221,
0.031026313081383705,
-0.007617187686264515,
0.01871061883866787,
-0.014900573529303074,
0.024847259745001793,
0.03184213116765022,
0.02061285637319088,
0.027594612911343575,
0.045987553894519806,
-0.00003800655031227507,
-0.01755804382264614,
-0.021564483642578125,
0.0446259006857872,
-0.03595643863081932,
0.007134316489100456,
-0.010621362365782261,
0.010463504120707512,
-0.005664692260324955,
0.047859176993370056,
-0.0171298049390316,
-0.019115397706627846,
-0.054365839809179306,
0.06369902193546295,
0.04312620684504509,
-0.02876683510839939,
0.004030787851661444,
0.02146737650036812,
0.02788027934730053,
-0.02614959329366684,
-0.011517559178173542,
0.002722213976085186,
0.02895914763212204,
0.02397448569536209,
-0.012941657565534115,
-0.030012255534529686,
-0.019894495606422424,
-0.02234882116317749,
-0.005254953633993864,
0.0023375533055514097,
0.02439267374575138,
-0.022099241614341736,
0.016766253858804703,
0.02593049593269825,
-0.0017039814265444875,
-0.012885657139122486,
0.03675337880849838,
0.06697309017181396,
0.01344324741512537,
-0.012260676361620426,
-0.027609607204794884,
-0.0440407432615757,
0.06046406179666519,
-0.039354048669338226,
-0.0021659580525010824,
0.00013164972187951207,
-0.02551371231675148,
-0.02951519750058651,
-0.02057695761322975,
0.0031792984809726477,
0.04000435769557953,
-0.0028217772487550974,
-0.012437225319445133,
0.019964830949902534,
0.013854012824594975,
-0.02094903029501438,
-0.005466244649142027,
0.01869971863925457,
-0.08033646643161774,
0.0030457493849098682,
0.028539972379803658,
0.001535747549496591,
0.006138669326901436,
-0.03198831528425217,
-0.04252728447318077,
-0.006030075717717409,
-0.008212077431380749,
-0.018351778388023376,
-0.032737087458372116,
-0.018172619864344597,
0.027950704097747803,
0.025914449244737625,
-0.04196399077773094,
0.005525398533791304,
0.010468387976288795,
0.026877252385020256,
-0.03018687479197979,
0.01229392271488905,
0.04245610907673836,
-0.027125708758831024,
0.03080320544540882,
0.02401777170598507,
-0.021985819563269615,
0.03362317383289337,
-0.0527460053563118,
0.021910175681114197,
0.048610955476760864,
0.01758473552763462,
0.007825508713722229,
-0.0651034489274025,
0.022865215316414833,
-0.031173421069979668,
-0.002563724759966135,
0.004031698685139418,
-0.00593832042068243,
-0.03499395027756691,
0.02105954848229885,
-0.0014226373750716448,
0.04314711317420006,
0.03808417171239853,
-0.01454240269958973,
-0.016883609816432,
0.013842885382473469,
0.030434921383857727,
0.054624538868665695,
-0.03910750150680542,
-0.007088021840900183,
0.07592113316059113,
-0.026399556547403336,
-0.010141699574887753,
-0.07613769918680191,
-0.02944101206958294,
0.007574145682156086,
-0.036970023065805435,
0.05856931209564209,
-0.029375245794653893,
0.03025202825665474,
0.05515345558524132,
0.05411967635154724,
0.017442042008042336,
-0.0065146940760314465,
0.040630023926496506,
-0.028829606249928474,
-0.01667187735438347,
-0.06720685958862305,
-0.013503551483154297,
0.0857035294175148,
-0.00490543432533741,
0.0383855476975441,
0.025793347507715225,
-0.030712665989995003,
0.01800587773323059,
-0.024405382573604584,
-0.055215924978256226,
0.0074567534029483795,
-0.019408369436860085,
0.0021164207719266415,
0.007374362088739872,
-0.04186762869358063,
-0.03395712375640869,
0.009118737652897835,
-0.06013628467917442,
-0.0005833593313582242,
-0.018048882484436035,
0.04650972783565521,
-0.020550495013594627,
-0.012077453546226025,
-0.04227802902460098,
0.00742468424141407,
0.031140562146902084,
0.0766836479306221,
0.033563144505023956,
0.00938582606613636,
-0.03312001749873161,
0.08745906502008438,
0.03545081242918968,
0.007647530175745487,
-0.004837575368583202,
0.017422473058104515,
0.003908481914550066,
-0.05145276337862015,
0.05012793838977814,
-0.017030930146574974,
-0.051799558103084564,
-0.030982857570052147,
0.035124972462654114,
0.04035264998674393,
-0.02736218459904194,
-0.02500290609896183,
0.017940420657396317,
-0.04818423464894295,
-0.013889063149690628,
-0.023060571402311325,
0.011578724719583988,
-0.02780076302587986,
0.07956962287425995,
0.02031979151070118,
0.022758208215236664,
0.0533863827586174,
0.01778971031308174,
-0.023494187742471695,
0.017772069200873375,
0.07639029622077942,
0.060768116265535355,
0.02783842943608761,
-0.0022335131652653217,
0.04095284268260002,
-0.043596647679805756,
-0.04754764959216118,
0.03081531450152397,
-0.006610113196074963,
-0.006682605482637882,
-0.032447803765535355,
0.010691703297197819,
0.04029816389083862,
0.013658630661666393,
0.06441657990217209,
-0.049590084701776505,
0.01445525512099266,
0.029038384556770325,
-0.0017821594374254346,
0.01659449376165867,
0.02946302480995655,
0.019798483699560165,
0.010354090481996536,
-0.019800085574388504,
-0.02012002281844616,
0.0007541212835349143,
-0.008441908285021782,
0.025768887251615524,
0.009583664126694202,
-0.015638289973139763,
-0.000024901530196075328,
-0.0018904883181676269,
0.0520566925406456,
0.11403916031122208,
-0.06516709923744202,
-0.04242861643433571,
0.013334760442376137,
0.032626405358314514,
-0.003185741137713194,
0.04468021169304848,
-0.014827514067292213,
-0.05875565856695175,
0.020233798772096634,
-0.06892905384302139,
0.027332575991749763,
0.047309406101703644,
-0.008415166288614273,
0.014781356789171696,
-0.012455708347260952,
-0.04854995757341385,
-0.0019193210173398256,
0.02496872842311859,
-0.037995390594005585,
-0.06933372467756271,
-0.022268448024988174,
-0.04529236629605293,
-0.062453869730234146,
-0.030426274985074997,
-0.006655851379036903,
-0.02254755236208439,
-0.028618447482585907,
-0.02478223294019699,
-0.04454083740711212,
0.02138526178896427,
0.009873137809336185,
-0.0734289363026619,
0.015419794246554375,
0.023730318993330002,
0.006161140277981758,
-0.01657463051378727,
0.04766654968261719,
0.020342007279396057,
-0.015132052823901176,
0.000783891009632498,
0.0254298634827137,
0.011734602972865105,
0.027725301682949066,
0.018842091783881187,
0.001532314345240593,
-0.0985536202788353,
0.04068782553076744,
0.03423023223876953,
-0.02454676851630211,
-0.07567784190177917,
0.01967562362551689,
-0.05231662839651108,
0.024587959051132202,
0.04565737396478653,
0.0025718959514051676,
-0.003221082966774702,
-0.035237573087215424,
-0.01207207702100277,
-0.006866666488349438,
0.010528787970542908,
0.04627581685781479,
-0.003640204668045044,
0.04059251770377159,
0.05478307977318764,
0.01600908860564232,
-0.030959276482462883,
0.021352509036660194,
-0.007139351684600115,
0.019001565873622894,
-0.0061412169598042965,
-0.03966057673096657,
-0.016502533107995987,
-0.09664978832006454,
-0.009123752824962139,
0.008578396402299404,
-0.0020374839659780264,
-0.05996584892272949,
0.017102882266044617,
-0.015165433287620544,
0.00240773125551641,
0.011569675989449024,
0.001307650818489492,
-0.014081417582929134,
-0.05250871554017067,
-0.035053007304668427,
-0.061092860996723175,
0.023447971791028976,
-0.006918448023498058,
0.046325910836458206,
-0.018645979464054108,
-0.03772415965795517,
-0.020764190703630447,
0.0017076570075005293,
0.023614369332790375,
0.008884644135832787,
0.010775246657431126,
-0.007718466222286224
] |
397 |
Learning Efficient Positional Encodings with Graph Neural Networks
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=AWg2tkbydO
|
[
"Charilaos Kanatsoulis",
"Evelyn Choi",
"Stefanie Jegelka",
"Jure Leskovec",
"Alejandro Ribeiro"
] |
Poster
|
Positional encodings (PEs) are essential for effective graph representation learning because they provide position awareness in inherently position-agnostic transformer architectures and increase the expressive capacity of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs). However, designing powerful and efficient PEs for graphs poses significant challenges due to the absence of canonical node ordering and the scale of the graph. In this work, we identify four key properties that graph PEs should satisfy: stability, expressive power, scalability, and genericness. We find that existing eigenvector-based PE methods often fall short of jointly satisfying these criteria. To address this gap, we introduce PEARL, a novel framework of learnable PEs for graphs. Our primary insight is that message-passing GNNs function as nonlinear mappings of eigenvectors, enabling the design of GNN architectures for generating powerful and efficient PEs. A crucial challenge lies in initializing node features in a manner that is both expressive and permutation equivariant. We tackle this by initializing GNNs with random node inputs or standard basis vectors, thereby unlocking the expressive power of message-passing operations, while employing statistical pooling functions to maintain permutation equivariance. Our analysis demonstrates that PEARL approximates equivariant functions of eigenvectors with linear complexity, while rigorously establishing its stability and high expressive power. Experimental evaluations show that PEARL outperforms lightweight versions of eigenvector-based PEs and achieves comparable performance to full eigenvector-based PEs, but with one or two orders of magnitude lower complexity. Our code is available at https://github.com/ehejin/Pearl-PE.
|
positional encodings, graph neural networks, graph transformers
| null | 13,142 |
2502.01122
|
[
-0.02061809040606022,
-0.02530434913933277,
-0.008185395039618015,
0.0646720826625824,
0.010352971963584423,
0.0532364621758461,
0.013002906925976276,
0.019761133939027786,
-0.017198994755744934,
-0.024828677996993065,
0.02248276211321354,
-0.04141639545559883,
-0.07790420949459076,
0.00035707413917407393,
0.018213937059044838,
0.02742174081504345,
0.028605179861187935,
-0.013703098520636559,
-0.007461445406079292,
0.007002027239650488,
-0.00021905302128288895,
0.005527953151613474,
0.027806170284748077,
0.006883345544338226,
0.04423043131828308,
-0.006465009413659573,
0.014472510665655136,
0.005132441874593496,
-0.01993248239159584,
0.00485227769240737,
0.017242373898625374,
0.00258644949644804,
0.019652998074889183,
-0.026963042095303535,
0.021579161286354065,
-0.005274732131510973,
-0.051921118050813675,
0.024051913991570473,
0.002123850164934993,
0.01862049661576748,
-0.051659632474184036,
0.002343494677916169,
0.016752520576119423,
0.022620288655161858,
-0.04327498376369476,
0.018816642463207245,
-0.12043611705303192,
0.04789242893457413,
0.0003506281937006861,
-0.037100985646247864,
-0.12506245076656342,
0.05761425942182541,
0.002839821856468916,
-0.0047945864498615265,
0.019360706210136414,
-0.0029278050642460585,
0.03618428483605385,
-0.05454472824931145,
-0.03229227289557457,
-0.06640109419822693,
-0.027025695890188217,
0.013519307598471642,
0.02962498553097248,
0.016539039090275764,
0.0039255958981812,
-0.021956918761134148,
0.004362133331596851,
0.05535377562046051,
-0.05572479963302612,
-0.07562290877103806,
-0.027997950091958046,
0.011360474862158298,
-0.01879555732011795,
0.007527608890086412,
0.012581256218254566,
-0.027409575879573822,
-0.014292601495981216,
0.025213170796632767,
0.0856981948018074,
0.004577683284878731,
-0.008246655575931072,
0.07157070934772491,
-0.015477935783565044,
0.03481432422995567,
-0.017529133707284927,
0.028092142194509506,
-0.041624296456575394,
-0.0715826004743576,
-0.061215609312057495,
0.0395720899105072,
-0.0644548162817955,
-0.05555202439427376,
-0.008165935985744,
0.0360964797437191,
-0.0051657939329743385,
-0.014000363647937775,
0.0000770239275880158,
0.01794315315783024,
0.018032830208539963,
-0.0063294717110693455,
-0.028037674725055695,
-0.04083516076207161,
0.014427008107304573,
-0.034770023077726364,
-0.09800729900598526,
-0.024397708475589752,
-0.0006726887077093124,
-0.0002821595990099013,
0.030050724744796753,
-0.003819184610620141,
-0.041867054998874664,
-0.017168084159493446,
0.008607042953372002,
-0.017986055463552475,
-0.07660079747438431,
0.028352340683341026,
0.01928863301873207,
-0.008419295772910118,
-0.0303437951952219,
-0.007640133146196604,
0.05824192240834236,
0.03737633675336838,
0.0001892537111416459,
0.09855330735445023,
-0.009531067684292793,
0.02306967042386532,
-0.0047475360333919525,
0.037689607590436935,
-0.036456748843193054,
-0.03882880136370659,
-0.016700206324458122,
0.04794526472687721,
0.010648993775248528,
0.024011628702282906,
0.00013842136831954122,
-0.03307516500353813,
-0.003312788438051939,
0.012644371949136257,
0.05129725858569145,
-0.026082776486873627,
0.00021849064796697348,
-0.04429959878325462,
0.05082590505480766,
-0.051838431507349014,
0.09809016436338425,
-0.03207755461335182,
-0.027833817526698112,
-0.0022981008514761925,
0.0066584935411810875,
-0.0018148071831092238,
-0.00026384645025245845,
-0.010197591036558151,
0.01744413748383522,
-0.05953929200768471,
-0.003490633564069867,
0.04987477883696556,
0.009917822666466236,
0.05749335512518883,
-0.0157132837921381,
0.0035781441256403923,
0.0018428214825689793,
-0.023976417258381844,
0.004008423537015915,
0.03935207054018974,
-0.01548099610954523,
-0.07371696829795837,
0.03231818601489067,
0.042284030467271805,
-0.04554334655404091,
-0.031026391312479973,
0.002263985574245453,
-0.012055203318595886,
0.03880956768989563,
0.01650298573076725,
-0.023903265595436096,
-0.020044978708028793,
0.0423758439719677,
-0.035770539194345474,
0.030423330143094063,
-0.009537562727928162,
-0.07800775021314621,
0.047295209020376205,
0.032235462218523026,
0.003111907048150897,
0.0003427901247050613,
-0.02648644894361496,
0.07970111072063446,
-0.01242482103407383,
0.001846284489147365,
0.0036412314511835575,
-0.07687966525554657,
-0.007630940526723862,
0.03309532254934311,
-0.04129355773329735,
0.06226430833339691,
0.012582692317664623,
-0.003221613820642233,
-0.001636042259633541,
0.024457639083266258,
0.011382751166820526,
0.02674730122089386,
-0.021852200850844383,
0.046101972460746765,
-0.005321076139807701,
-0.04054170474410057,
0.010320650413632393,
0.03857423737645149,
-0.04006420075893402,
-0.07642500102519989,
0.010605018585920334,
0.005395250860601664,
-0.009392655454576015,
0.012321908958256245,
-0.031988490372896194,
-0.007744982372969389,
-0.024623779579997063,
-0.019922489300370216,
0.01509073842316866,
0.036909319460392,
-0.058532603085041046,
0.02948528155684471,
0.00012028820492560044,
-0.02272489108145237,
0.015921900048851967,
-0.05356172099709511,
0.11106955260038376,
0.044589314609766006,
-0.004380505066365004,
0.0045770760625600815,
0.039181217551231384,
0.039266590029001236,
-0.00493624759837985,
0.03764154389500618,
-0.013032184913754463,
-0.002958905417472124,
0.01127174124121666,
-0.005705208983272314,
-0.022188792005181313,
0.051376380026340485,
-0.042172253131866455,
0.007563035003840923,
0.06370587646961212,
-0.025376172736287117,
0.019596481695771217,
0.00942204985767603,
0.017126666381955147,
0.04730988293886185,
-0.06417632848024368,
-0.016845421865582466,
-0.023346370086073875,
-0.01903308555483818,
-0.000540248875040561,
0.009568745270371437,
-0.022757329046726227,
0.03165648132562637,
-0.015595153905451298,
0.009161856956779957,
-0.008681563660502434,
0.07840005308389664,
0.03478364646434784,
0.03648803383111954,
0.007037600502371788,
-0.029567215591669083,
-0.033980779349803925,
-0.04928676784038544,
-0.09973612427711487,
-0.02617473155260086,
-0.035602595657110214,
0.050814419984817505,
0.01283915713429451,
0.062415555119514465,
-0.002061466919258237,
0.013741107657551765,
-0.02525719255208969,
-0.015325500629842281,
-0.018121305853128433,
0.033338937908411026,
-0.01618683710694313,
-0.03261224180459976,
-0.014307526871562004,
0.02797548659145832,
0.061591994017362595,
-0.009797676466405392,
-0.01334115955978632,
-0.04815743863582611,
-0.029221972450613976,
0.004431362729519606,
-0.02026040107011795,
-0.004188867751508951,
0.031155461445450783,
0.031916577368974686,
0.017991557717323303,
-0.04660790041089058,
0.0033317150082439184,
0.04643658176064491,
0.05569344013929367,
0.061650823801755905,
-0.018895067274570465,
-0.011282731778919697,
0.00457344576716423,
0.002781866118311882,
0.07285509258508682,
0.008978552184998989,
0.0018619514303281903,
-0.04766518622636795,
0.0014488600427284837,
0.01198085118085146,
-0.006000081077218056,
-0.2655235826969147,
0.01721172407269478,
-0.014145024120807648,
-0.05419876426458359,
0.025981957092881203,
-0.025607669726014137,
0.029238689690828323,
-0.027096709236502647,
-0.0016564992256462574,
0.009837809950113297,
0.025151200592517853,
-0.0063788206316530704,
-0.011597398668527603,
0.012487933970987797,
0.06282679736614227,
0.021803976967930794,
-0.026430409401655197,
-0.01274186559021473,
0.022072933614253998,
0.05080081522464752,
-0.010232766158878803,
-0.07809851318597794,
-0.019913461059331894,
0.013051532208919525,
-0.004907187540084124,
0.03321771323680878,
-0.12076758593320847,
0.01325626578181982,
-0.0362948440015316,
-0.030680201947689056,
-0.03729948773980141,
-0.01681855507194996,
-0.025721218436956406,
0.04707515984773636,
-0.02208879590034485,
-0.00530493026599288,
0.01402497012168169,
-0.0030092489905655384,
0.012392205186188221,
0.037426356226205826,
0.008731000125408173,
-0.03427119925618172,
-0.03844357281923294,
0.03248776122927666,
0.07860054820775986,
-0.0027376189827919006,
-0.02059137262403965,
0.023764919489622116,
-0.014452164061367512,
0.03236525505781174,
-0.012080729007720947,
-0.05139254033565521,
0.005317056551575661,
-0.002827491145581007,
-0.006064654793590307,
-0.029874814674258232,
-0.01256278995424509,
0.007622462697327137,
-0.020078253000974655,
0.016433117911219597,
0.02967800572514534,
-0.08349156379699707,
0.000504673516843468,
-0.04453245922923088,
-0.020810842514038086,
-0.014613858424127102,
-0.07500822842121124,
-0.05538838729262352,
0.035139020532369614,
0.015038185752928257,
-0.008154802955687046,
0.041701339185237885,
-0.022058816626667976,
-0.07905694097280502,
0.040943022817373276,
0.019521689042448997,
0.0033298220951110125,
0.00401411484926939,
0.00026194288511760533,
0.03596271201968193,
-0.010526811704039574,
-0.05612508952617645,
-0.007459573447704315,
0.029766496270895004,
0.03183922544121742,
0.01468037161976099,
0.00892568938434124,
-0.048060059547424316,
-0.023720134049654007,
-0.021960454061627388,
0.030303174629807472,
-0.012565428391098976,
0.04707847163081169,
0.009683125652372837,
0.06043846905231476,
0.06387433409690857,
0.034520555287599564,
0.0295413751155138,
0.015636751428246498,
-0.01939496025443077,
0.04028647392988205,
-0.04715002328157425,
-0.016639143228530884,
-0.011937453411519527,
-0.026223057880997658,
0.06554753333330154,
-0.0678183063864708,
-0.02735503949224949,
0.02079632878303528,
0.017730116844177246,
-0.03791091591119766,
-0.040343139320611954,
0.014190969057381153,
-0.004476011730730534,
-0.023785533383488655,
-0.012467016465961933,
0.004425324033945799,
0.035224296152591705,
0.02894115447998047,
-0.024172434583306313,
-0.012936470098793507,
0.04535173252224922,
-0.033394861966371536,
0.02619265764951706,
-0.0016434683930128813,
-0.012427511624991894,
-0.0004133418551646173,
-0.03554720804095268,
-0.012897797860205173,
0.017572691664099693,
0.05673505365848541,
0.05132884532213211,
-0.005911564454436302,
0.0022539871279150248,
0.05562201142311096,
0.02735220640897751,
-0.014867202378809452,
-0.02625112794339657,
0.03381246328353882,
-0.003521657781675458,
0.021333890035748482,
0.001802684972062707,
0.020497966557741165,
0.020300252363085747,
0.04886874556541443,
-0.0018719523213803768,
0.03831865265965462,
-0.007821681909263134,
-0.011907336302101612,
-0.0026508294977247715,
0.013322683051228523,
-0.057635948061943054,
-0.021473247557878494,
-0.03653336688876152,
0.027405643835663795,
-0.025995466858148575,
0.04059761390089989,
-0.011367903091013432,
-0.0015461683506146073,
-0.03982321172952652,
0.0850922167301178,
0.001822956488467753,
-0.012850997969508171,
-0.017154013738036156,
0.01964225433766842,
0.04224503040313721,
-0.00603365758433938,
0.0039240154437720776,
0.001668195822276175,
-0.015414650551974773,
-0.0047208755277097225,
0.01902623102068901,
-0.018791763111948967,
-0.006095187738537788,
-0.00454605370759964,
-0.018479740247130394,
-0.003618698799982667,
0.027688043192029,
-0.03148797154426575,
0.015614486299455166,
-0.005258599761873484,
-0.010099000297486782,
-0.030270962044596672,
0.04567345976829529,
0.08463054895401001,
0.036869022995233536,
-0.0052622342482209206,
0.004590250086039305,
-0.054827336221933365,
0.03881406411528587,
-0.009134102612733841,
0.010345971211791039,
-0.04757668823003769,
-0.02680707536637783,
-0.02677975594997406,
-0.030376210808753967,
-0.014694822020828724,
0.007556484080851078,
-0.019146200269460678,
-0.02590709552168846,
-0.013947524130344391,
0.03722865507006645,
-0.04602782800793648,
0.005057838745415211,
0.03401486948132515,
-0.033308498561382294,
-0.006219443865120411,
0.011578898876905441,
-0.0055465553887188435,
0.02070446126163006,
-0.008979485370218754,
-0.0012620821362361312,
-0.01318484079092741,
-0.005516505800187588,
0.03449318930506706,
0.006323075387626886,
-0.01567257195711136,
-0.023503219708800316,
-0.04305857792496681,
-0.002530868863686919,
0.03040385991334915,
-0.0019436064176261425,
0.004253065213561058,
-0.04798464477062225,
0.018562952056527138,
0.045287907123565674,
-0.01808665134012699,
0.016407765448093414,
0.0005548076587729156,
0.0047836825251579285,
0.022968478500843048,
-0.016843322664499283,
0.04297443479299545,
0.07074743509292603,
-0.005740953143686056,
0.017206670716404915,
-0.06195458397269249,
0.0322200208902359,
-0.003815887263044715,
0.021624384447932243,
0.03538382425904274,
-0.013032622635364532,
-0.041891735047101974,
0.006758043076843023,
0.0004533289757091552,
0.03437165915966034,
0.040604233741760254,
0.005779847968369722,
0.0009751407196745276,
0.0013191382167860866,
0.015089540742337704,
0.038415100425481796,
-0.030485156923532486,
-0.027926655486226082,
0.045838262885808945,
-0.037868682295084,
-0.044752106070518494,
-0.06589097529649734,
-0.025859221816062927,
0.008204703219234943,
-0.011399848386645317,
0.018870601430535316,
0.011672294698655605,
0.035613492131233215,
0.03689553216099739,
0.06313115358352661,
0.0024698260240256786,
-0.05164877697825432,
0.015135273337364197,
-0.014972921460866928,
0.007259675767272711,
-0.042265258729457855,
-0.0070245349779725075,
0.05913214758038521,
-0.027246704325079918,
-0.015502016060054302,
-0.02834220975637436,
-0.02438380941748619,
0.011709973216056824,
0.00018378475215286016,
-0.05534668639302254,
0.029772985726594925,
-0.012805641628801823,
0.0018681802321225405,
0.017007168382406235,
-0.04687224701046944,
-0.012020750902593136,
-0.029054826125502586,
-0.058265525847673416,
-0.003977602813392878,
-0.013399733230471611,
0.015656230971217155,
-0.04748254641890526,
0.014163961634039879,
-0.014811952598392963,
0.0011646392522379756,
0.046254560351371765,
0.06762693077325821,
0.00012260093353688717,
0.04233674332499504,
-0.05191334709525108,
0.06363280117511749,
0.03654071316123009,
-0.008695450611412525,
0.033693745732307434,
0.025205332785844803,
-0.01664465293288231,
-0.050819046795368195,
0.01717727817595005,
-0.0024855085648596287,
-0.04658592492341995,
-0.05655662715435028,
0.09617888182401657,
0.01832774467766285,
-0.04531397297978401,
-0.05275983735918999,
0.04799634963274002,
-0.02468806691467762,
-0.010450167581439018,
-0.02507312409579754,
-0.00010878848115680739,
-0.020635271444916725,
0.0754750445485115,
0.027036968618631363,
0.04902233928442001,
0.08519526571035385,
0.02345888875424862,
-0.0166055578738451,
-0.022162044420838356,
0.07847829908132553,
0.07144493609666824,
0.03662629425525665,
-0.02056754194200039,
0.07318325340747833,
-0.046216245740652084,
-0.04398966580629349,
0.004128840286284685,
0.03849852830171585,
0.0011485680006444454,
-0.000790070160292089,
0.031839847564697266,
0.06755495816469193,
-0.01482184138149023,
0.08101259917020798,
-0.05277558043599129,
0.003791442373767495,
0.056852780282497406,
0.021268228068947792,
-0.00881983432918787,
0.029443543404340744,
0.03493553027510643,
0.017026064917445183,
-0.04828859493136406,
0.005083979107439518,
-0.028721295297145844,
-0.013220592401921749,
0.03233105689287186,
0.009409399703145027,
-0.005320462863892317,
0.02263994887471199,
-0.007468454074114561,
0.012693705037236214,
0.10166798532009125,
-0.05334411934018135,
-0.06203259527683258,
-0.009220127947628498,
0.01685282029211521,
-0.014198883436620235,
0.04172171652317047,
-0.01702064462006092,
0.0005394081235863268,
-0.008102231658995152,
-0.044021397829055786,
0.03792569041252136,
0.003532115602865815,
-0.030950531363487244,
0.005050502251833677,
-0.012154090218245983,
-0.02776752971112728,
-0.006415040697902441,
0.008274304680526257,
-0.030347758904099464,
-0.040643110871315,
-0.018303241580724716,
-0.06505303829908371,
-0.07420183718204498,
-0.07107099145650864,
-0.0174203272908926,
-0.012969616800546646,
-0.0455545037984848,
-0.014747179113328457,
-0.01865718886256218,
0.020827066153287888,
0.012248564511537552,
-0.05383245646953583,
0.030729234218597412,
0.02452748827636242,
0.04430471733212471,
-0.009829280897974968,
0.02871101349592209,
0.014344739727675915,
-0.01113385334610939,
0.012177513912320137,
0.06646451354026794,
0.02271144837141037,
-0.008862188085913658,
-0.007724088616669178,
-0.022751761600375175,
-0.10536883771419525,
0.010184730403125286,
0.033801790326833725,
-0.030622055754065514,
-0.09180543571710587,
0.0006354384822770953,
-0.009807044640183449,
0.020536992698907852,
0.0621832013130188,
0.020996738225221634,
0.012529348954558372,
-0.03130273520946503,
0.007613400463014841,
-0.0010668692411854863,
-0.03387843072414398,
0.04190082103013992,
-0.028110800310969353,
0.06918060779571533,
0.052691638469696045,
-0.019019167870283127,
-0.015883570536971092,
0.019834954291582108,
-0.02125643379986286,
0.00669091148301959,
-0.02400924451649189,
-0.0328187420964241,
-0.001808962319046259,
-0.09316517412662506,
-0.01844152621924877,
-0.005539212375879288,
-0.008215141482651234,
-0.020556030794978142,
-0.01647265814244747,
0.00449119508266449,
-0.006355024874210358,
-0.007920677773654461,
-0.01767824776470661,
0.01599961332976818,
0.0015588264213874936,
-0.012979879043996334,
-0.048485610634088516,
0.01917925663292408,
-0.02308991178870201,
0.02765831910073757,
-0.047759391367435455,
-0.03494943305850029,
0.0016116040060296655,
-0.012067846953868866,
0.034684017300605774,
0.010382583364844322,
0.01874128170311451,
0.018103796988725662
] |
398 |
Scale-Aware Contrastive Reverse Distillation for Unsupervised Medical Anomaly Detection
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=HNOo4UNPBF
|
[
"Chunlei Li",
"Yilei Shi",
"Jingliang Hu",
"Xiao Xiang Zhu",
"Lichao Mou"
] |
Poster
|
Unsupervised anomaly detection using deep learning has garnered significant research attention due to its broad applicability, particularly in medical imaging where labeled anomalous data are scarce. While earlier approaches leverage generative models like autoencoders and generative adversarial networks (GANs), they often fall short due to overgeneralization. Recent methods explore various strategies, including memory banks, normalizing flows, self-supervised learning, and knowledge distillation, to enhance discrimination. Among these, knowledge distillation, particularly reverse distillation, has shown promise. Following this paradigm, we propose a novel scale-aware contrastive reverse distillation model that addresses two key limitations of existing reverse distillation methods: insufficient feature discriminability and inability to handle anomaly scale variations. Specifically, we introduce a contrastive student-teacher learning approach to derive more discriminative representations by generating and exploring out-of-normal distributions. Further, we design a scale adaptation mechanism to softly weight contrastive distillation losses at different scales to account for the scale variation issue. Extensive experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate state-of-the-art performance, validating the efficacy of the proposed method. The code will be made publicly available.
|
unsupervised anomaly detection, medical images, contrastive reverse distillation, student-teacher
| null | 13,123 |
2503.13828
|
[
0.006155182607471943,
-0.026818575337529182,
-0.01205980870872736,
0.028697926551103592,
0.052014198154211044,
-0.02408127672970295,
0.047210924327373505,
-0.01646522432565689,
-0.020807014778256416,
-0.02458191104233265,
-0.00903725903481245,
-0.002713755238801241,
-0.027515895664691925,
0.0482252761721611,
0.012905563227832317,
0.058731649070978165,
0.07694584131240845,
-0.012403336353600025,
0.026885269209742546,
0.048808928579092026,
-0.011279289610683918,
-0.07702016830444336,
0.0004551556194201112,
-0.005914357956498861,
0.0021699145436286926,
0.022145282477140427,
0.010567402467131615,
0.01050314586609602,
-0.04339197278022766,
0.01308551337569952,
0.06544757634401321,
0.0005731677520088851,
0.02049502171576023,
-0.029636166989803314,
0.04716869443655014,
0.014346172101795673,
-0.06720016151666641,
0.02642687037587166,
0.0016153809847310185,
-0.0038198940455913544,
-0.03366251662373543,
-0.020589206367731094,
-0.025882158428430557,
0.01805458776652813,
-0.056407347321510315,
-0.01127118431031704,
-0.1492755264043808,
0.036848269402980804,
-0.02413826249539852,
-0.0014999881386756897,
-0.0682511031627655,
0.018605001270771027,
0.020348817110061646,
-0.005027132108807564,
0.014568186365067959,
0.05961613357067108,
0.04094896838068962,
-0.061312805861234665,
-0.012832529842853546,
-0.05603070184588432,
-0.011081811040639877,
0.04444969817996025,
0.022816285490989685,
0.015835558995604515,
0.018596064299345016,
-0.00964699499309063,
0.0131433866918087,
0.03359265252947807,
-0.027373692020773888,
-0.05438487231731415,
-0.006663755513727665,
-0.0010998457437381148,
0.000700856267940253,
0.014191809110343456,
0.00746186263859272,
-0.024219278246164322,
0.018246842548251152,
-0.004084483720362186,
0.06657665222883224,
0.004021686501801014,
0.0412338450551033,
0.014567140489816666,
0.04510834440588951,
0.02159210294485092,
0.0002248363452963531,
-0.011347737163305283,
-0.021847987547516823,
-0.0007389199454337358,
-0.015578903257846832,
0.015816347673535347,
-0.0434378944337368,
-0.03341178968548775,
0.020184548571705818,
0.01764996536076069,
0.051397424191236496,
-0.012825035490095615,
0.039951495826244354,
-0.04766272380948067,
-0.008119656704366207,
-0.030820012092590332,
-0.014632896520197392,
-0.034444551914930344,
0.014861098490655422,
0.012963543646037579,
-0.07218639552593231,
0.015785707160830498,
-0.021272310987114906,
-0.012329384684562683,
-0.02638472244143486,
-0.013148128986358643,
-0.05931166931986809,
0.012650947086513042,
0.01738939806818962,
-0.00714714964851737,
-0.0789995864033699,
0.01661635935306549,
0.011142109520733356,
0.021548690274357796,
-0.015443150885403156,
-0.03370148688554764,
0.048804111778736115,
0.04965668171644211,
0.01786530576646328,
0.07106702774763107,
-0.009173142723739147,
-0.009197317063808441,
0.023598648607730865,
0.05207844078540802,
-0.021414823830127716,
-0.01772669516503811,
-0.026568980887532234,
0.04079635813832283,
0.02408192679286003,
-0.005017031449824572,
0.01768588088452816,
-0.010639416985213757,
-0.0032450149301439524,
0.010397347621619701,
0.03335295990109444,
-0.01067926362156868,
0.03198202699422836,
-0.029648277908563614,
0.0264027900993824,
-0.03422420099377632,
0.04632500186562538,
-0.045046236366033554,
0.009158688597381115,
-0.004685305058956146,
-0.03298451378941536,
0.035864319652318954,
0.003789763431996107,
0.017932457849383354,
0.016904888674616814,
-0.0609913095831871,
0.023747719824314117,
0.07075130194425583,
-0.030321072787046432,
0.01819506473839283,
0.018033413216471672,
-0.008927907794713974,
0.021461738273501396,
-0.00011605834151851013,
-0.0529470331966877,
-0.02207314595580101,
0.003272261004894972,
-0.03405294567346573,
0.03686162084341049,
0.04256763309240341,
-0.03877626359462738,
0.020755989477038383,
-0.04561060294508934,
-0.054094575345516205,
0.04955238476395607,
-0.024840664118528366,
-0.024639667943120003,
0.027798740193247795,
0.03283686563372612,
0.01683546043932438,
0.041915666311979294,
0.037269216030836105,
-0.10174468159675598,
0.039064742624759674,
0.004892018623650074,
-0.03772662207484245,
-0.005390878766775131,
-0.017292795702815056,
0.09611765295267105,
-0.04511586204171181,
-0.00033333784085698426,
0.042068254202604294,
-0.07867036014795303,
-0.020611830055713654,
0.027814142405986786,
0.006757036782801151,
0.04418976604938507,
0.0484047569334507,
-0.0035150940530002117,
0.038607291877269745,
0.011014794930815697,
0.024784037843346596,
0.05260401591658592,
-0.02713734470307827,
0.07380921393632889,
-0.013017518445849419,
-0.01708107441663742,
-0.021120192483067513,
0.04472934827208519,
-0.07772526144981384,
-0.05108150094747543,
-0.016335071995854378,
-0.01684032566845417,
-0.00402026018127799,
-0.012218189425766468,
-0.007731156889349222,
0.012914162129163742,
0.03363369032740593,
0.014409037306904793,
-0.008493037894368172,
0.011348119005560875,
-0.04955311119556427,
0.060245905071496964,
0.0014870251761749387,
0.01344411913305521,
0.0485343374311924,
0.017010753974318504,
0.10041254013776779,
0.07895448803901672,
-0.016010882332921028,
0.022602079436182976,
-0.0022256842348724604,
0.02481023408472538,
-0.0008083665743470192,
0.025406524538993835,
-0.01834452524781227,
0.02223733253777027,
-0.018024401739239693,
0.020932862535119057,
-0.006839957553893328,
0.07835668325424194,
-0.06920013576745987,
-0.027212008833885193,
0.058143019676208496,
-0.03912617266178131,
0.05783509463071823,
0.012423538602888584,
0.032496292144060135,
0.05658094212412834,
0.01053987443447113,
-0.03273490071296692,
-0.09261112660169601,
0.0049496297724545,
0.01680990867316723,
-0.001825640443712473,
-0.01205318234860897,
0.03624747321009636,
-0.06477333605289459,
-0.005864098202437162,
0.005919985007494688,
0.04418996348977089,
0.067083939909935,
-0.025539858266711235,
0.018663834780454636,
0.010084309615194798,
-0.07121114432811737,
0.001630999380722642,
-0.1040564477443695,
-0.05062541365623474,
-0.01510999258607626,
0.03555378317832947,
-0.05440887063741684,
0.030936207622289658,
-0.00860570278018713,
0.01924835704267025,
-0.025516962632536888,
-0.013435124419629574,
0.007810130249708891,
0.019184885546565056,
0.02678065560758114,
-0.038112856447696686,
0.011114615947008133,
0.01854558102786541,
0.06546864658594131,
0.0041932715103030205,
-0.010324268601834774,
-0.026969285681843758,
-0.05662261322140694,
-0.023753497749567032,
-0.016036970540881157,
-0.00228042621165514,
0.025441737845540047,
0.031827040016651154,
0.042499445378780365,
0.0012619011104106903,
0.021169202402234077,
0.025781549513339996,
0.046474553644657135,
0.05154263973236084,
0.048404570668935776,
0.000036426652513910085,
0.041037190705537796,
-0.03889515623450279,
0.03413621336221695,
0.0027342448011040688,
0.017966222018003464,
-0.027301359921693802,
-0.02638334408402443,
0.048071183264255524,
-0.009264116175472736,
-0.27386754751205444,
-0.004451903514564037,
0.014762037433683872,
-0.0020869204308837652,
0.04508485645055771,
-0.021017024293541908,
0.017070915549993515,
-0.039352111518383026,
-0.026985876262187958,
0.02313557080924511,
0.004938493017107248,
0.03584405407309532,
-0.0027421656996011734,
0.06177986040711403,
0.05386657267808914,
0.03810132294893265,
-0.00008161005825968459,
-0.006761323194950819,
0.024209944531321526,
0.03769724443554878,
-0.005850125104188919,
-0.02522650733590126,
-0.025402503088116646,
0.05949748679995537,
-0.003859959775581956,
0.036771710962057114,
-0.06935353577136993,
0.02210795134305954,
-0.02590804547071457,
-0.03800388053059578,
0.008061244152486324,
-0.0053763436153531075,
-0.013289835304021835,
0.040215179324150085,
-0.015541788190603256,
0.009294730611145496,
0.004007080569863319,
0.0035039125941693783,
0.046487387269735336,
-0.01743912510573864,
-0.002358071506023407,
-0.034650299698114395,
-0.025820882990956306,
0.027907535433769226,
0.04840270057320595,
0.03459952026605606,
-0.02067578211426735,
0.001930782338604331,
-0.010045667178928852,
0.02039477601647377,
-0.008774437010288239,
-0.01657119207084179,
-0.050190139561891556,
0.003689371282234788,
-0.0015779940877109766,
0.012117783538997173,
-0.022400077432394028,
0.01665721833705902,
-0.020874856039881706,
0.014386911876499653,
-0.014332265593111515,
-0.053360845893621445,
-0.0012928145006299019,
-0.04018445685505867,
-0.012490840628743172,
-0.04424683004617691,
-0.05002724751830101,
-0.07056231796741486,
0.030514951795339584,
0.02341456711292267,
-0.030185360461473465,
0.016990482807159424,
-0.02727741003036499,
-0.08413027226924896,
0.04484185576438904,
-0.005640125367790461,
-0.002700751181691885,
-0.025964180007576942,
-0.015295833349227905,
0.03716127946972847,
-0.03581060469150543,
-0.05624977499246597,
0.02365398034453392,
0.027193021029233932,
-0.007015787996351719,
0.0004752311506308615,
0.020537156611680984,
-0.013157018460333347,
-0.03159203380346298,
-0.019382581114768982,
0.029351040720939636,
0.03217588737607002,
0.031550273299217224,
0.006970541086047888,
0.01140156015753746,
0.06047593429684639,
0.040756240487098694,
0.047988854348659515,
0.023897061124444008,
-0.01397674810141325,
0.023339780047535896,
-0.07556183636188507,
-0.057542432099580765,
-0.07094782590866089,
-0.025074385106563568,
0.011376003734767437,
-0.05042801424860954,
-0.02774600125849247,
0.04797724261879921,
-0.021348129957914352,
-0.031325437128543854,
-0.05556580051779747,
0.021977383643388748,
-0.01293318159878254,
-0.010774102993309498,
0.005007969215512276,
0.0025478051975369453,
0.029442936182022095,
0.06167326867580414,
-0.048398565500974655,
0.008247718214988708,
0.06747672706842422,
-0.018084639683365822,
0.017794720828533173,
0.029530126601457596,
-0.02761906385421753,
-0.009748256765305996,
-0.0002308892726432532,
0.015480192378163338,
-0.010510880500078201,
0.04083893820643425,
0.02301884815096855,
0.009013570845127106,
0.030480477958917618,
0.07516594231128693,
-0.006819508038461208,
0.00489161117002368,
-0.004215281922370195,
0.017659559845924377,
-0.0002900097460951656,
0.048362262547016144,
-0.02748400904238224,
0.0422026589512825,
-0.005783542059361935,
0.033905401825904846,
-0.008008158765733242,
0.03341267630457878,
0.00975750107318163,
-0.0011193201644346118,
-0.01794586516916752,
0.008793714456260204,
-0.045825857669115067,
-0.03227519243955612,
-0.016335563734173775,
0.00521486159414053,
0.014512138441205025,
0.04237855225801468,
0.004365978296846151,
0.011672827415168285,
-0.06096556782722473,
0.036910977214574814,
0.03361940011382103,
-0.031139131635427475,
-0.03658676519989967,
-0.004035267513245344,
0.02025090530514717,
-0.03205655515193939,
-0.011462952941656113,
0.04120500013232231,
-0.004039857070893049,
0.018615104258060455,
-0.027753621339797974,
-0.05510397255420685,
0.005561960861086845,
-0.01343582198023796,
0.007283364422619343,
-0.007754751481115818,
-0.012093247845768929,
-0.054993193596601486,
0.051076602190732956,
0.03610723093152046,
0.0027102252934128046,
0.0016943271039053798,
0.02250196784734726,
0.0935017466545105,
0.03342890366911888,
-0.021407557651400566,
-0.018390607088804245,
-0.035692062228918076,
0.06901539862155914,
-0.06305986642837524,
-0.023310290649533272,
-0.05364745855331421,
-0.03566485643386841,
0.007002030499279499,
-0.048502981662750244,
-0.018524527549743652,
0.013794905506074429,
-0.008174914866685867,
-0.02169905975461006,
0.00725649343803525,
0.019585156813263893,
-0.025988053530454636,
-0.035051628947257996,
0.007660356815904379,
-0.07851327955722809,
0.007409704849123955,
0.014508458785712719,
-0.02989732101559639,
0.03494347259402275,
0.013284511864185333,
-0.01139372680336237,
-0.08354996889829636,
-0.03299986943602562,
-0.0029275324195623398,
-0.011595454066991806,
-0.018615631386637688,
-0.027044983580708504,
0.021864023059606552,
-0.020061543211340904,
0.04169970750808716,
-0.003109041601419449,
0.01289977878332138,
-0.010853658430278301,
0.01429695449769497,
0.029841821640729904,
-0.038531795144081116,
0.0007649451727047563,
-0.013238269835710526,
-0.016864057630300522,
-0.013247620314359665,
-0.02865544520318508,
0.004614050965756178,
0.017430484294891357,
-0.041218649595975876,
0.010234803892672062,
-0.0039267875254154205,
0.0077128056436777115,
-0.01572667621076107,
-0.007350419647991657,
-0.022420022636651993,
0.00009367033635498956,
-0.03501645848155022,
0.017768844962120056,
0.026647962629795074,
0.04215820133686066,
0.01899932697415352,
-0.016772562637925148,
0.008731652051210403,
-0.002210051752626896,
0.03845669701695442,
-0.0028637538198381662,
-0.04554322734475136,
0.013590896502137184,
0.068503238260746,
-0.07246637344360352,
0.003930020611733198,
-0.10185310244560242,
-0.05858844146132469,
-0.00269592204131186,
0.0047821602784097195,
0.009337261319160461,
-0.023933857679367065,
0.006482214201241732,
0.032002709805965424,
0.022441228851675987,
-0.01673973724246025,
-0.008543318137526512,
0.02725926600396633,
-0.05896953493356705,
-0.0029524113051593304,
-0.05091169476509094,
-0.011150620877742767,
0.05521175637841225,
-0.03981713578104973,
-0.004637567792087793,
-0.003758498700335622,
-0.04877983033657074,
-0.000012395988051139284,
-0.027405211701989174,
-0.04353606328368187,
0.009898155927658081,
-0.013726165518164635,
-0.00235559931024909,
-0.009327409788966179,
-0.02993427775800228,
-0.014165525324642658,
-0.023769250139594078,
-0.0689597949385643,
-0.002382236998528242,
0.03283591568470001,
0.04204403609037399,
-0.004574249032884836,
-0.0028647903818637133,
-0.020197881385684013,
0.008952991105616093,
0.01885451003909111,
0.07392022013664246,
0.011342690326273441,
0.01937154121696949,
-0.038756612688302994,
0.06032957136631012,
0.03663758933544159,
-0.015482601709663868,
0.023435402661561966,
0.006687695160508156,
-0.017534255981445312,
-0.042142320424318314,
0.0253154244273901,
-0.009515753947198391,
0.0041031441651284695,
-0.08458279073238373,
0.014125735498964787,
0.009304044768214226,
-0.02942902408540249,
-0.021467648446559906,
0.04850173741579056,
-0.029438138008117676,
-0.009666282683610916,
0.011136120185256004,
-0.033826492726802826,
-0.006617279723286629,
0.05854026600718498,
-0.011539504863321781,
0.03764064610004425,
0.041209567338228226,
0.014475243166089058,
0.02367858774960041,
0.0011269226670265198,
0.0726730227470398,
0.03554600104689598,
0.05625525489449501,
-0.006245734170079231,
0.0627269297838211,
-0.023728400468826294,
-0.026907222345471382,
0.007766753900796175,
0.014534832909703255,
-0.036639511585235596,
-0.06488198041915894,
0.002398467157036066,
0.09474046528339386,
0.0024673931766301394,
0.060140371322631836,
-0.04101807251572609,
-0.013328437693417072,
0.03923288360238075,
0.016197444871068,
-0.008142338134348392,
0.026171652600169182,
-0.018592923879623413,
0.019666599109768867,
-0.02768671326339245,
-0.009966466575860977,
-0.017788372933864594,
-0.02135545387864113,
0.027431868016719818,
0.0038337267469614744,
-0.01099223829805851,
0.03234509751200676,
0.002002523047849536,
0.006378902122378349,
0.08207372575998306,
-0.02854638360440731,
-0.03677278012037277,
0.01636102795600891,
0.039546430110931396,
-0.006036386825144291,
0.026401640847325325,
0.0030949462670832872,
-0.011807022616267204,
-0.009988456033170223,
-0.062291331589221954,
0.03113243356347084,
0.021708404645323753,
0.0008607264026068151,
0.019527701660990715,
-0.027073301374912262,
-0.02293248474597931,
0.034424539655447006,
0.03295217081904411,
-0.04720965027809143,
-0.04875509440898895,
-0.05861801281571388,
-0.04330603405833244,
-0.055554818361997604,
-0.05856490880250931,
0.06255801022052765,
0.03287442401051521,
-0.001834148890338838,
-0.009685366414487362,
-0.02214282564818859,
0.02081221342086792,
0.028742076829075813,
-0.04878198727965355,
0.009517728351056576,
0.054960910230875015,
-0.01787455379962921,
-0.03302354738116264,
0.01901905983686447,
-0.00218683248385787,
-0.05400332063436508,
-0.013852518051862717,
0.0310839731246233,
0.0005169704672880471,
0.0083955442532897,
-0.03758363053202629,
-0.02410552091896534,
-0.09780305624008179,
-0.00384441576898098,
0.00465675164014101,
-0.07729744166135788,
-0.07766035944223404,
0.0663423165678978,
-0.012792343273758888,
0.032272715121507645,
0.0511319562792778,
-0.020871024578809738,
-0.0027086022309958935,
-0.02907509356737137,
-0.04262864589691162,
-0.02021203376352787,
0.017143070697784424,
0.042807627469301224,
-0.010517824441194534,
0.04739493131637573,
0.06468264013528824,
0.011399769224226475,
-0.005097098648548126,
0.018994027748703957,
-0.037949685007333755,
-0.00427017780020833,
-0.0022740743588656187,
-0.050628457218408585,
-0.049787238240242004,
-0.09194312989711761,
-0.0241338349878788,
0.025841763243079185,
-0.015711836516857147,
-0.024232637137174606,
0.00953307468444109,
-0.008783914148807526,
0.002528072101995349,
-0.026247994974255562,
0.010651668533682823,
-0.0019432506524026394,
-0.04015031084418297,
-0.050428617745637894,
-0.028734643012285233,
0.0004933645250275731,
0.01567225158214569,
0.023387331515550613,
-0.026044758036732674,
-0.05551016703248024,
0.0005429909797385335,
-0.03348962962627411,
0.04915415123105049,
0.011327952146530151,
0.01730111427605152,
0.012921935878694057
] |
399 |
Scalable Influence and Fact Tracing for Large Language Model Pretraining
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=gLa96FlWwn
|
[
"Tyler A. Chang",
"Dheeraj Rajagopal",
"Tolga Bolukbasi",
"Lucas Dixon",
"Ian Tenney"
] |
Poster
|
Training data attribution (TDA) methods aim to attribute model outputs back to specific training examples, and the application of these methods to large language model (LLM) outputs could significantly advance model transparency and data curation. However, it has been challenging to date to apply these methods to the full scale of LLM pretraining. In this paper, we refine existing gradient-based methods to work effectively at scale, allowing us to retrieve influential examples for an 8B-parameter language model from a pretraining corpus of over 160B tokens with no need for subsampling or pre-filtering. Our method combines several techniques, including optimizer state correction, a task-specific Hessian approximation, and normalized encodings, which we find to be critical for performance at scale. In quantitative evaluations on a fact tracing task, our method performs best at identifying examples that influence model predictions, but classical, model-agnostic retrieval methods such as BM25 still perform better at finding passages which explicitly contain relevant facts. These results demonstrate a misalignment between factual *attribution* and causal *influence*. With increasing model size and training tokens, we find that influence more closely aligns with factual attribution. Finally, we examine different types of examples identified as influential by our method, finding that while many directly entail a particular fact, others support the same output by reinforcing priors on relation types, common entities, and names. We release our prompt set and model outputs, along with a web-based visualization tool to explore influential examples for factual predictions, commonsense reasoning, arithmetic, and open-ended generation for an 8B-parameter LLM.
|
training data attribution, LLM pretraining, influence functions, factual knowledge
|
We present a gradient-based influence method that scales to LLM pretraining, and we demonstrate its ability to retrieve examples that influence LLM factual predictions.
| 13,120 |
2410.17413
|
[
-0.00567755289375782,
-0.010087684728205204,
-0.01712881773710251,
0.024004481732845306,
0.024357834830880165,
0.01776714064180851,
0.02072007954120636,
0.024753248319029808,
-0.025931626558303833,
-0.017392471432685852,
-0.02641325257718563,
0.016536887735128403,
-0.044555697590112686,
0.0018053040839731693,
-0.0023149794433265924,
0.05308908596634865,
0.039883192628622055,
-0.0032579954713582993,
0.01797928474843502,
0.01747501827776432,
0.014010163024067879,
-0.03295658156275749,
0.005818251520395279,
0.005669033154845238,
0.032769396901130676,
0.009863296523690224,
0.0530044361948967,
-0.018396973609924316,
-0.02464533969759941,
0.033112913370132446,
0.018840981647372246,
-0.03598653897643089,
0.02219441346824169,
0.006504610646516085,
-0.007411188445985317,
-0.0008278344757854939,
-0.014448247849941254,
0.011872091330587864,
0.014741376973688602,
-0.0008571256184950471,
-0.048751045018434525,
0.003910666797310114,
-0.03264684975147247,
0.002115004463121295,
-0.059362154453992844,
-0.012532941997051239,
-0.10474443435668945,
0.03743681684136391,
0.036119494587183,
-0.02717120386660099,
-0.11106362193822861,
0.029407629743218422,
-0.012122662737965584,
-0.005946551449596882,
0.025690246373414993,
0.05570926144719124,
0.038172896951436996,
-0.11721327900886536,
-0.01685842126607895,
-0.03602296859025955,
-0.03339501842856407,
0.02143113873898983,
0.004729774780571461,
0.006557914428412914,
0.03249724954366684,
-0.02224418707191944,
-0.04109491780400276,
0.02660166099667549,
-0.04011958837509155,
-0.044675786048173904,
-0.027125738561153412,
0.009987417608499527,
-0.03100578486919403,
0.009523547254502773,
-0.0076541299931705,
-0.03468543663620949,
0.00227556680329144,
0.029173247516155243,
0.0547511950135231,
0.009612750262022018,
-0.00014010797895025462,
-0.024741586297750473,
0.03293060138821602,
0.00892891176044941,
0.028773490339517593,
0.02581583708524704,
-0.00673392741009593,
-0.06135927140712738,
-0.0757131353020668,
-0.006619735155254602,
0.006618476938456297,
-0.05263848602771759,
-0.0016271122731268406,
0.011390309780836105,
-0.006086303386837244,
-0.017267849296331406,
0.03139033913612366,
0.025195511057972908,
-0.03475550562143326,
-0.03565900772809982,
-0.03222067654132843,
-0.038015492260456085,
0.026646530255675316,
0.03858165070414543,
-0.11935165524482727,
-0.01394395250827074,
-0.013719912618398666,
0.009031565859913826,
0.004161868244409561,
0.01960104890167713,
-0.02255072444677353,
-0.0050729489885270596,
-0.008231701329350471,
-0.016560815274715424,
-0.08970171213150024,
0.002319599036127329,
-0.007279785815626383,
0.0055335466749966145,
0.004094362258911133,
0.029219359159469604,
0.04712289571762085,
0.035663094371557236,
0.05113030970096588,
0.07870832830667496,
-0.028116313740611076,
0.023347267881035805,
0.0038130595348775387,
0.014237112365663052,
-0.02458001673221588,
-0.04439803212881088,
0.028818711638450623,
0.02451600320637226,
0.02230791561305523,
-0.013602087274193764,
0.004540814086794853,
0.005005162674933672,
0.005107157863676548,
0.026980413123965263,
0.04321648180484772,
0.003195484634488821,
0.022531485185027122,
0.004711040761321783,
0.06307283043861389,
-0.02997354418039322,
0.044254470616579056,
-0.01088804192841053,
-0.056564003229141235,
-0.0012015877291560173,
-0.05754975229501724,
0.014759557321667671,
0.052795618772506714,
0.024089930579066277,
0.020836783573031425,
-0.0420914925634861,
0.031345028430223465,
0.053974248468875885,
-0.004190471023321152,
-0.03235001489520073,
0.006579945329576731,
0.0313744843006134,
0.03650134429335594,
0.04065413028001785,
-0.04902729392051697,
0.021255385130643845,
0.006295826286077499,
-0.059325214475393295,
0.008111106231808662,
-0.01242874376475811,
-0.05689287930727005,
0.004846691153943539,
-0.051325105130672455,
-0.025863569229841232,
0.07713120430707932,
-0.035327158868312836,
-0.02591179683804512,
0.011131244711577892,
0.03898606449365616,
-0.0034753838554024696,
0.03070996142923832,
0.049494560807943344,
-0.0627552792429924,
0.049692876636981964,
0.0151438619941473,
-0.032291997224092484,
0.019541412591934204,
-0.010675030760467052,
0.07233826816082001,
-0.01258100476115942,
0.003856977913528681,
0.048361677676439285,
-0.06409164518117905,
-0.0012393379583954811,
0.04994705691933632,
0.0031284219585359097,
0.0513492077589035,
-0.014861887320876122,
0.025959547609090805,
0.05034800246357918,
0.0523955412209034,
0.033315397799015045,
0.0340605266392231,
-0.00738164409995079,
0.0341043695807457,
-0.005835305899381638,
-0.01943696103990078,
-0.004388940986245871,
0.0187519658356905,
-0.05257273092865944,
-0.058438993990421295,
0.056255877017974854,
-0.039051901549100876,
0.004994716960936785,
0.002736809430643916,
0.02929132804274559,
-0.015529381111264229,
-0.000570703879930079,
-0.0244855135679245,
0.02006509155035019,
0.009496440179646015,
-0.03759035840630531,
0.05174223706126213,
0.01638517715036869,
-0.007371577899903059,
-0.006766253150999546,
-0.047174204140901566,
0.09581112116575241,
0.04742036759853363,
0.005187724716961384,
-0.005937386304140091,
0.024616790935397148,
0.0004941163933835924,
0.017033379524946213,
0.02086026966571808,
-0.04207640141248703,
0.02844417281448841,
-0.033016134053468704,
0.007016817573457956,
-0.024571847170591354,
0.054050952196121216,
-0.031874194741249084,
0.004556380677968264,
0.0549590066075325,
-0.008784368634223938,
0.05757549777626991,
-0.02493857406079769,
0.03091030940413475,
0.03982170671224594,
0.0009410995990037918,
-0.017498165369033813,
-0.025870632380247116,
0.019735543057322502,
0.007061656564474106,
-0.014075123704969883,
-0.03638904169201851,
-0.014075754210352898,
-0.009873266331851482,
-0.04646547511219978,
-0.003682836890220642,
0.031647007912397385,
0.0374276265501976,
-0.012846574187278748,
0.015570871531963348,
-0.008842570707201958,
-0.06651383638381958,
0.02702755481004715,
-0.08897767215967178,
-0.023136436939239502,
-0.03526945784687996,
0.02077287621796131,
0.007887548767030239,
0.05674918740987778,
-0.02352718450129032,
0.002958923578262329,
-0.04691644012928009,
-0.009143714793026447,
0.03072909452021122,
0.028056731447577477,
0.009722169488668442,
-0.040333669632673264,
-0.00943777710199356,
-0.04572295397520065,
0.0604768767952919,
-0.010167374275624752,
-0.029024632647633553,
-0.02276669628918171,
-0.05145568028092384,
-0.015791485086083412,
-0.028289688751101494,
0.014508973807096481,
0.028718331828713417,
-0.003250539768487215,
-0.0034611474256962538,
-0.017599783837795258,
-0.003256685333326459,
0.02682032436132431,
0.05664238706231117,
0.052150506526231766,
0.0020195753313601017,
-0.003602564102038741,
0.010901364497840405,
-0.02793842926621437,
0.014984752982854843,
-0.012739853002130985,
0.04929324984550476,
-0.009830825962126255,
-0.01680808700621128,
0.01696997880935669,
0.01342925988137722,
-0.2804184556007385,
0.01356598176062107,
-0.0036902076099067926,
-0.016932087019085884,
0.04260975494980812,
-0.026636868715286255,
0.05049166828393936,
-0.051454681903123856,
-0.048747576773166656,
-0.006289584096521139,
0.03217287361621857,
0.04021598771214485,
-0.0025051364209502935,
0.04603748768568039,
0.01973900943994522,
0.05869473144412041,
0.006390738766640425,
-0.019762281328439713,
0.009333721362054348,
0.0476018488407135,
0.012060298584401608,
-0.03148533031344414,
-0.02377462200820446,
0.08999679982662201,
-0.0026198076084256172,
0.052602656185626984,
-0.10425713658332825,
0.011562956497073174,
-0.03524868190288544,
-0.0021679135970771313,
0.021083975210785866,
0.006454742979258299,
-0.03109629824757576,
-0.007603530306369066,
0.0016261375276371837,
-0.0337308794260025,
0.05449691042304039,
0.02389971725642681,
0.034917838871479034,
-0.004973419010639191,
0.025530023500323296,
-0.01185852661728859,
-0.028394322842359543,
-0.0071991607546806335,
0.06060348451137543,
0.017319023609161377,
-0.051111381500959396,
-0.027005504816770554,
-0.03212999179959297,
0.03428465500473976,
-0.03185543045401573,
0.0026615378446877003,
-0.041258953511714935,
-0.01659756526350975,
0.006117949262261391,
-0.018407978117465973,
0.008405775763094425,
-0.03403754532337189,
-0.03653152287006378,
0.0002942067221738398,
0.003589734435081482,
-0.03400931879878044,
-0.01835772767663002,
-0.0518699549138546,
-0.016534848138689995,
-0.03493689373135567,
-0.05729192867875099,
-0.04524896293878555,
0.01732136867940426,
0.04404469206929207,
-0.034477755427360535,
0.04005828872323036,
-0.019002901390194893,
-0.10177578777074814,
-0.0020870245061814785,
-0.011673958040773869,
-0.014803551137447357,
-0.020959781482815742,
0.011872924864292145,
0.032226305454969406,
-0.02789025567471981,
-0.02595633827149868,
-0.016814183443784714,
-0.0011111776111647487,
-0.0037399150896817446,
-0.025527650490403175,
0.011501133441925049,
-0.011156348511576653,
-0.012609533965587616,
-0.05312170833349228,
0.04353948310017586,
0.014657742343842983,
0.009932415559887886,
0.01809634454548359,
0.03975124657154083,
0.014509840868413448,
0.007236506324261427,
0.08035194873809814,
0.04258226603269577,
-0.009987691417336464,
0.008546003140509129,
-0.0635400041937828,
-0.004252650775015354,
-0.07277809828519821,
-0.021575238555669785,
0.03200758248567581,
-0.05239798501133919,
-0.03065924160182476,
-0.002968178829178214,
-0.01964283362030983,
-0.028277089819312096,
-0.03579585999250412,
-0.007162633817642927,
0.004626169800758362,
-0.021803421899676323,
-0.005240506958216429,
-0.00958207342773676,
0.02036198228597641,
0.019544845446944237,
-0.01711563766002655,
-0.02944452501833439,
0.029446745291352272,
-0.03274648264050484,
-0.005075691733509302,
0.0011559613049030304,
-0.022608976811170578,
0.0005041841650381684,
-0.025572383776307106,
-0.017263345420360565,
0.021986223757267,
0.01746251992881298,
0.02236359380185604,
0.003598908195272088,
0.029004549607634544,
0.04278745874762535,
-0.003217977937310934,
0.020340971648693085,
-0.0232606939971447,
0.013925246894359589,
-0.005362353287637234,
-0.02063819207251072,
-0.011602804064750671,
0.02060815319418907,
0.011520219966769218,
0.06495032459497452,
-0.023857856169342995,
-0.006565345451235771,
0.013142645359039307,
0.0048188637010753155,
-0.007130855694413185,
0.0627133771777153,
-0.03303186222910881,
-0.004868323914706707,
-0.015607929788529873,
0.03731639310717583,
0.009861337020993233,
0.03979025036096573,
-0.005612254608422518,
0.02227264828979969,
-0.07746084779500961,
0.02181459218263626,
-0.043006546795368195,
-0.0025112382136285305,
0.027991583570837975,
0.012013955973088741,
0.005347761325538158,
-0.03486228734254837,
0.00865202397108078,
0.0527082234621048,
0.004950556438416243,
0.00959034450352192,
-0.024757571518421173,
-0.04381011426448822,
0.01843840815126896,
-0.047162752598524094,
-0.005038542672991753,
0.013939905911684036,
-0.006374203134328127,
0.011731310747563839,
0.04493121802806854,
0.0039002413395792246,
-0.024703318253159523,
-0.01367658469825983,
0.008644354529678822,
0.09095371514558792,
0.03041849285364151,
-0.008763089776039124,
0.0069368695840239525,
-0.04165910556912422,
0.037504833191633224,
0.001030478859320283,
-0.019511833786964417,
-0.01743619330227375,
-0.04422767832875252,
-0.03553502634167671,
-0.03232242166996002,
0.017359793186187744,
0.03071633167564869,
-0.005379322916269302,
-0.0030697262845933437,
-0.02988908439874649,
-0.011162119917571545,
-0.0649847686290741,
-0.0037321008276194334,
0.010299385525286198,
-0.06844516843557358,
-0.006659131031483412,
0.021437395364046097,
-0.02140960283577442,
0.03403909504413605,
-0.023314842954277992,
-0.053566720336675644,
-0.08207117766141891,
-0.025222832337021828,
0.023600423708558083,
-0.05376715585589409,
-0.01866627112030983,
-0.025070134550333023,
0.02387581765651703,
-0.005424910224974155,
0.045804213732481,
-0.0038731687236577272,
0.004485915880650282,
-0.013707688078284264,
0.020766908302903175,
0.04471425339579582,
-0.014433770440518856,
0.006856003310531378,
0.009743824601173401,
-0.04912500083446503,
0.024952946230769157,
-0.036436375230550766,
0.02665192261338234,
0.05449827015399933,
0.007907419465482235,
0.01244606077671051,
-0.0590355359017849,
0.06070340797305107,
0.03912881389260292,
-0.029893185943365097,
-0.01263152901083231,
0.01474690716713667,
-0.003291028318926692,
0.0018006390891969204,
-0.012069782242178917,
0.013438960537314415,
-0.006677823141217232,
0.024883698672056198,
0.007082234602421522,
0.012812122702598572,
0.03110676072537899,
0.01724768802523613,
-0.03742802143096924,
-0.0043320623226463795,
0.060311347246170044,
-0.047905150800943375,
-0.04298509284853935,
-0.07899346947669983,
-0.05085784196853638,
0.008276735432446003,
0.007311677560210228,
0.03132423385977745,
-0.031931616365909576,
0.021521346643567085,
0.028329597786068916,
0.01603243127465248,
-0.0008228746592067182,
0.0002586453047115356,
0.023065367713570595,
-0.03198998421430588,
-0.008001779206097126,
-0.05863289535045624,
-0.02207018807530403,
0.049341559410095215,
-0.03588135540485382,
-0.013610491529107094,
0.01434040255844593,
-0.041204001754522324,
0.025562360882759094,
-0.03342916816473007,
-0.035337407141923904,
0.017801782116293907,
-0.028522759675979614,
-0.01126774400472641,
0.03992246836423874,
-0.04961495101451874,
0.008343616500496864,
0.01581268571317196,
-0.03180705010890961,
0.012228313833475113,
-0.03595452383160591,
0.053198400884866714,
-0.020549388602375984,
-0.02381817065179348,
-0.036299992352724075,
0.02916634827852249,
0.01910395547747612,
0.055974896997213364,
0.050966303795576096,
0.03673085570335388,
-0.03018398955464363,
0.08289092779159546,
0.0033857962116599083,
-0.008212569169700146,
0.00017194698739331216,
0.015084423124790192,
-0.04210119694471359,
-0.06275805085897446,
0.08242851495742798,
0.007923386991024017,
-0.018659373745322227,
-0.0362711101770401,
0.07316574454307556,
0.05463433638215065,
-0.02849446050822735,
-0.021197644993662834,
0.03931666538119316,
-0.009961866773664951,
-0.019008265808224678,
0.0022518071345984936,
0.017957717180252075,
-0.01978812739253044,
0.065940722823143,
0.040511347353458405,
0.06363464891910553,
0.04537804052233696,
0.0047306399792432785,
0.005209391470998526,
-0.046585988253355026,
0.06916416436433792,
0.062464404851198196,
0.07212655991315842,
0.01173652708530426,
0.06074497103691101,
-0.02942551113665104,
-0.05143420398235321,
0.02826119400560856,
0.04227988421916962,
-0.017787130549550056,
-0.046015553176403046,
0.018403897061944008,
0.08921436220407486,
0.025020083412528038,
0.04994039237499237,
-0.016842395067214966,
-0.010041008703410625,
0.02261068858206272,
0.002717220224440098,
-0.000213779610930942,
0.044263243675231934,
0.0005086625460535288,
0.037516798824071884,
-0.027400635182857513,
-0.030833851546049118,
0.030279239639639854,
-0.01688099466264248,
0.02331894263625145,
0.01864941045641899,
-0.04401054605841637,
-0.008190054446458817,
-0.020113630220294,
0.04646740108728409,
0.1180533692240715,
-0.037937480956315994,
-0.02457900531589985,
0.010861373506486416,
0.008583709597587585,
-0.005039536859840155,
0.0644984170794487,
-0.0013468613615259528,
-0.019919557496905327,
-0.0007931383443064988,
-0.06532175838947296,
-0.005777076352387667,
0.005718731787055731,
-0.021346155554056168,
0.03194265812635422,
-0.05399760231375694,
-0.024065641686320305,
0.030076447874307632,
0.01992056705057621,
-0.06650494784116745,
-0.0462954118847847,
-0.005093325395137072,
-0.05555121973156929,
-0.0408211275935173,
-0.06597761809825897,
0.028848282992839813,
0.033521585166454315,
-0.017090488225221634,
-0.01420244388282299,
-0.05728224292397499,
0.01086372509598732,
0.024949567392468452,
-0.07608673721551895,
-0.00014962667773943394,
0.03372723609209061,
0.0006924339686520398,
-0.043838802725076675,
0.03374128416180611,
-0.009307018481194973,
0.001406508614309132,
0.004917087033390999,
0.02823462523519993,
0.043679431080818176,
0.018261965364217758,
-0.00923117995262146,
-0.00019915394659619778,
-0.10008637607097626,
0.012916370294988155,
-0.006293673068284988,
-0.050865158438682556,
-0.08168388158082962,
0.020034071058034897,
-0.02354106865823269,
0.021860267966985703,
0.06512483954429626,
0.03053200989961624,
0.015385572798550129,
-0.009437826462090015,
-0.01814749650657177,
0.03997665271162987,
0.023993363603949547,
0.06168309599161148,
-0.013885198161005974,
0.07596346735954285,
0.06555997580289841,
-0.017427068203687668,
-0.05386766046285629,
0.0077515579760074615,
-0.004517991561442614,
-0.03937101736664772,
0.004870133008807898,
-0.0363287627696991,
-0.010308885015547276,
-0.07096176594495773,
0.004719014745205641,
0.03658030554652214,
-0.02596208266913891,
-0.033506639301776886,
-0.012263098731637001,
-0.04177403822541237,
-0.026142679154872894,
0.016428157687187195,
0.021038316190242767,
0.023788820952177048,
-0.01992502249777317,
-0.0471356138586998,
-0.046499546617269516,
0.0038813878782093525,
-0.0036181695759296417,
-0.002101281890645623,
-0.048313722014427185,
-0.04067806899547577,
0.014151697978377342,
0.001510922098532319,
0.08181033283472061,
-0.0038768434897065163,
0.03565547242760658,
-0.021395305171608925
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.