Unnamed: 0.1
int64
0
113k
Unnamed: 0
float64
0
113k
title
stringlengths
7
246
abstract
stringlengths
6
3.31k
embeddings
sequencelengths
512
512
0
0
Learning from compressed observations
The problem of statistical learning is to construct a predictor of a random variable $Y$ as a function of a related random variable $X$ on the basis of an i.i.d. training sample from the joint distribution of $(X,Y)$. Allowable predictors are drawn from some specified class, and the goal is to approach asymptotically the performance (expected loss) of the best predictor in the class. We consider the setting in which one has perfect observation of the $X$-part of the sample, while the $Y$-part has to be communicated at some finite bit rate. The encoding of the $Y$-values is allowed to depend on the $X$-values. Under suitable regularity conditions on the admissible predictors, the underlying family of probability distributions and the loss function, we give an information-theoretic characterization of achievable predictor performance in terms of conditional distortion-rate functions. The ideas are illustrated on the example of nonparametric regression in Gaussian noise.
[ 0.023913083598017693, -0.07156850397586823, 0.020479219034314156, -0.05435015633702278, 0.04470788687467575, -0.031266793608665466, 0.02528078854084015, 0.03892822191119194, -0.046625249087810516, -0.004673648159950972, -0.053453873842954636, 0.0041854893788695335, -0.054244235157966614, -0.039733417332172394, -0.00999539066106081, -0.011071066372096539, -0.023786339908838272, 0.00022861505567561835, 0.039751533418893814, -0.07327843457460403, 0.017712537199258804, 0.01644531637430191, -0.02903522551059723, -0.053561776876449585, 0.024443861097097397, 0.02421586401760578, -0.021246379241347313, 0.041168197989463806, -0.03735576942563057, -0.04079121723771095, -0.03273014724254608, -0.0030659050680696964, -0.04764622822403908, -0.008043437264859676, 0.0020499126985669136, -0.03711144998669624, 0.06675386428833008, -0.031433962285518646, -0.01409896556288004, 0.046254370361566544, 0.00554342707619071, -0.018706347793340683, 0.037711888551712036, 0.035342223942279816, 0.033501774072647095, 0.05736304447054863, -0.0036303368397057056, -0.045278944075107574, -0.045563746243715286, 0.0111625287681818, -0.0727546438574791, 0.0003957902663387358, -0.005955021362751722, -0.04967149347066879, 0.023227054625749588, -0.01296012382954359, -0.02603045105934143, -0.0474027544260025, -0.07018773257732391, -0.018904751166701317, -0.04974231496453285, 0.078789621591568, 0.0039117601700127125, -0.00849493220448494, 0.060624394565820694, 0.020163027569651604, -0.06806395947933197, 0.027570612728595734, 0.004185912664979696, -0.012819278985261917, 0.04236425831913948, -0.054024480283260345, 0.06338748335838318, 0.07266601175069809, -0.004996319301426411, -0.007112444844096899, -0.02950049191713333, 0.02887146919965744, 0.009927983395755291, 0.08541295677423477, -0.06468407064676285, 0.030311325564980507, 0.017165150493383408, 0.02954692207276821, 0.012514088302850723, 0.013851772993803024, -0.0403658002614975, 0.016528520733118057, -0.029957350343465805, -0.06370289623737335, -0.057670529931783676, 0.04455509036779404, -0.022653182968497276, 0.016228921711444855, -0.033508509397506714, 0.052064113318920135, 0.004769246559590101, -0.05692270025610924, 0.01303751952946186, 0.027506185695528984, 0.13430321216583252, -0.024470487609505653, 0.057011451572179794, 0.045556508004665375, -0.021996937692165375, 0.030580494552850723, -0.00823905412107706, 0.016800500452518463, 0.08333681523799896, -0.020775223150849342, 0.08264937251806259, -0.06685223430395126, -0.00588667206466198, -0.06275894492864609, -0.052163537591695786, 0.08996115624904633, 0.023522542789578438, 0.08377306163311005, 0.016625016927719116, 0.0902286246418953, 0.027874909341335297, 0.04029401019215584, -0.053361766040325165, 0.024338694289326668, 0.05792613700032234, -0.02081424929201603, -0.031216928735375404, -0.07350923120975494, 0.08794394880533218, 0.043827299028635025, -0.05297078937292099, 0.0039508771151304245, -0.0017609738279134035, -0.03159421682357788, -0.03652449697256088, 0.039479270577430725, 0.014070412144064903, 0.04346506670117378, -0.033795490860939026, -0.01789471134543419, -0.056815002113580704, -0.03865363076329231, -0.03762766346335411, -0.038138359785079956, 0.032989419996738434, 0.04796469211578369, 0.00012701500963885337, -0.04613577201962471, -0.027557823807001114, 0.03793224319815636, -0.0209087785333395, -0.034407082945108414, -0.0021435560192912817, 0.0526391938328743, 0.08916730433702469, -0.10128313302993774, -0.01659727282822132, -0.0475812666118145, -0.06874731928110123, 0.04054741561412811, -0.05511811748147011, 0.02824583649635315, 0.14078529179096222, 0.07443489134311676, -0.044032495468854904, -0.03779883310198784, 0.018066294491291046, -0.03681488707661629, -0.03858071193099022, -0.008184614591300488, -0.0617142915725708, 0.01580185256898403, -0.032430071383714676, -0.03260211646556854, -0.010782896541059017, -0.030915243551135063, 0.012192078866064548, 0.0062799639999866486, -0.02320447750389576, -0.05674415081739426, 0.014625324867665768, -0.0836603194475174, 0.011419716291129589, 0.039263851940631866, -0.009853764437139034, 0.07631991803646088, -0.020169084891676903, 0.0811506062746048, 0.07619483023881912, -0.05795087665319443, 0.07947659492492676, -0.06518857181072235, -0.021837208420038223, 0.023044630885124207, -0.08670924603939056, 0.019473601132631302, -0.08832035213708878, -0.04765116050839424, 0.010025684721767902, 0.049773167818784714, 0.02459160052239895, -0.021848496049642563, -0.02806152030825615, -0.05262402817606926, -0.10267861187458038, 0.04440789297223091, 0.019769588485360146, -0.06973294168710709, -0.005463680252432823, -0.0213000550866127, -0.0310076791793108, -0.0022079714108258486, 0.01635119505226612, -0.12266374379396439, -0.003467535600066185, -0.0696335956454277, -0.00120997941121459, -0.03481258824467659, 0.026109516620635986, -0.017404623329639435, 0.04752453789114952, 0.013002762570977211, -0.03991488739848137, -0.03860698640346527, -0.05160360038280487, 0.01692553609609604, 0.08436505496501923, -0.027737045660614967, -0.09453591704368591, 0.05331794545054436, 0.004532839171588421, -0.01978788711130619, -0.06923872977495193, 0.04217332974076271, 0.005365814547985792, 0.06787409633398056, -0.04708140715956688, -0.03363829851150513, -0.02511204034090042, -0.004062563646584749, -0.0762345939874649, 0.04138582572340965, -0.02854733355343342, 0.0596940815448761, -0.015918809920549393, -0.0760311707854271, 0.004265524446964264, 0.01908646523952484, -0.01688750647008419, -0.010751350782811642, 0.05997645482420921, -0.00017983322322834283, -0.020830130204558372, -0.09317352622747421, 0.05403468757867813, 0.006234150845557451, -0.014639146625995636, -0.02921932190656662, -0.005490369629114866, 0.03241819515824318, 0.0474710576236248, 0.05888017639517784, -0.07888287305831909, 0.046247031539678574, 0.07170246541500092, 0.01994248479604721, -0.06536567956209183, 0.007303508464246988, 0.07250290364027023, 0.029635114595294, -0.0053344001062214375, -0.04875270277261734, -0.03262593597173691, 0.04257626831531525, -0.09093164652585983, 0.05240076407790184, 0.04373341053724289, 0.0125648258253932, 0.0011687502264976501, -0.016272667795419693, -0.043482888489961624, 0.031713683158159256, 0.014747962355613708, 0.005665324162691832, -0.028991281986236572, 0.01877480372786522, -0.04262738302350044, 0.020467784255743027, 0.037936288863420486, 0.013900662772357464, -0.014674709178507328, 0.026835201308131218, -0.02785293385386467, 0.021388156339526176, -0.007922842167317867, -0.03424720838665962, 0.0313325859606266, 0.007493485230952501, 0.01743963360786438, -0.04584745690226555, 0.030190998688340187, -0.0704268366098404, 0.018043026328086853, 0.05125553533434868, 0.044595152139663696, 0.0827522799372673, 0.08102569729089737, 0.06222034618258476, -0.03363122045993805, -0.019593531265854836, -0.023574108257889748, -0.02494165673851967, -0.010897066444158554, -0.018171250820159912, -0.028528915718197823, -0.06992816179990768, -0.020518872886896133, -0.03322385251522064, -0.0318724624812603, -0.05129971727728844, 0.03621509671211243, -0.02942601405084133, -0.029033642262220383, 0.009753224439918995, -0.050473298877477646, -0.0315074548125267, 0.046197935938835144, 0.04177455976605415, -0.10252172499895096, 0.006368166301399469, -0.04748806729912758, -0.062426019459962845, -0.028972981497645378, 0.1436578780412674, -0.008975690230727196, 0.0700620636343956, -0.02715827338397503, -0.029262129217386246, 0.004448696505278349, 0.0013483291259035468, -0.04890771582722664, -0.08133246749639511, -0.06136920303106308, -0.048901088535785675, 0.0501527264714241, 0.03993649408221245, 0.10995739698410034, -0.04907040297985077, -0.0399530790746212, 0.06836476176977158, 0.03798980638384819, 0.046296194195747375, -0.023155780509114265, -0.027406154200434685, -0.0011705245124176145, 0.03427444398403168, 0.059498198330402374, -0.037821054458618164, 0.03716414049267769, 0.027925705537199974, -0.022617053240537643, 0.018292248249053955, -0.04161969572305679, -0.018846530467271805, 0.05501120910048485, 0.058476805686950684, 0.029806185513734818, -0.018675928935408592, -0.074226513504982, 0.001992759993299842, -0.027643483132123947, 0.025298452004790306, 0.015945173799991608, 0.041932251304388046, -0.002160499105229974, -0.0380660817027092, 0.056792400777339935, -0.04492434114217758, 0.0336591862142086, 0.0627003088593483, -0.002613120712339878, -0.035957347601652145, -0.041104868054389954, 0.010021989233791828, -0.05730334296822548, -0.09414996951818466, -0.09011965990066528, -0.00142296205740422, 0.060819998383522034, 0.014735453762114048, -0.028542758896946907, -0.029452957212924957, -0.0022477474994957447, -0.022746112197637558, 0.08297285437583923, 0.023178543895483017, -0.022054044529795647, -0.027421314269304276, -0.07459117472171783, -0.0013490644050762057, 0.027151690796017647, 0.0014151539653539658, 0.014918151311576366, -0.037022318691015244, -0.0813162624835968, 0.03226012364029884, 0.03548537194728851, 0.03741991147398949, 0.013410690240561962, 0.04786214232444763, 0.007911317981779575, 0.044858235865831375, -0.029806319624185562, 0.11795435845851898, -0.013518388383090496, 0.0004916383768431842, -0.01373739168047905, -0.0022323934826999903, -0.06642170995473862, -0.03096892684698105, 0.04486214369535446, 0.02075120247900486, 0.01881585828959942, 0.0035639500711113214, 0.04877951368689537, 0.03144213557243347, 0.05544910952448845, 0.050386689603328705, -0.042542632669210434, 0.05566424876451492, -0.019098754972219467, 0.002834693994373083, -0.05419529974460602, -0.012419349513947964, 0.025821710005402565, -0.06118224933743477, 0.0029963175766170025, -0.04250255227088928, -0.010480944998562336, 0.024772869423031807, -0.08212251216173172, 0.007352303713560104, -0.03127968683838844, 0.036102913320064545, 0.012342705391347408, 0.004226298071444035, 0.02942376211285591, -0.0011732216225937009, 0.06269258260726929, 0.03239794448018074, 0.04246236011385918, 0.03251084312796593, 0.033640507608652115, -0.0019737055990844965, 0.036594171077013016, -0.007973267696797848, -0.027705593034625053, -0.04130024462938309, 0.031105289235711098, 0.018579326570034027, -0.04171222075819969, -0.04317869618535042, 0.0074720378033816814, -0.016928449273109436, -0.07238070666790009, 0.03492812439799309, 0.016017045825719833, 0.0025627235881984234, 0.029774228110909462, 0.032382406294345856, -0.06901700794696808, 0.02929823100566864, -0.03674846887588501, -0.06365196406841278, 0.01058757584542036, 0.06677085906267166, -0.015173371881246567, -0.036648109555244446, -0.001104672090150416, -0.0004096886550541967, -0.010287327691912651, -0.05483075603842735, -0.009797714650630951, 0.05380786210298538, 0.0630507543683052, 0.020421115681529045, -0.04761134460568428, -0.015628410503268242, 0.06436791270971298, 0.027052249759435654, 0.0263269804418087, 0.021307436749339104, -0.01908688060939312, 0.04318889603018761, 0.06721372902393341, -0.043909259140491486, -0.023954059928655624, 0.006505132187157869, 0.019804639741778374, 0.05563398450613022, 0.01238494087010622, 0.030895359814167023, 0.03311249986290932, -0.026719240471720695, 0.05452115088701248, 0.03225927799940109, 0.018919266760349274, 0.006582301575690508, 0.0031264463905245066, 0.045894280076026917, -0.034814249724149704, 0.047110386192798615 ]
1
1
Sensor Networks with Random Links: Topology Design for Distributed Consensus
In a sensor network, in practice, the communication among sensors is subject to:(1) errors or failures at random times; (3) costs; and(2) constraints since sensors and networks operate under scarce resources, such as power, data rate, or communication. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is usually a main factor in determining the probability of error (or of communication failure) in a link. These probabilities are then a proxy for the SNR under which the links operate. The paper studies the problem of designing the topology, i.e., assigning the probabilities of reliable communication among sensors (or of link failures) to maximize the rate of convergence of average consensus, when the link communication costs are taken into account, and there is an overall communication budget constraint. To consider this problem, we address a number of preliminary issues: (1) model the network as a random topology; (2) establish necessary and sufficient conditions for mean square sense (mss) and almost sure (a.s.) convergence of average consensus when network links fail; and, in particular, (3) show that a necessary and sufficient condition for both mss and a.s. convergence is for the algebraic connectivity of the mean graph describing the network topology to be strictly positive. With these results, we formulate topology design, subject to random link failures and to a communication cost constraint, as a constrained convex optimization problem to which we apply semidefinite programming techniques. We show by an extensive numerical study that the optimal design improves significantly the convergence speed of the consensus algorithm and can achieve the asymptotic performance of a non-random network at a fraction of the communication cost.
[ -0.012652735225856304, -0.017086153849959373, -0.009166444651782513, -0.02785656228661537, -0.05627566576004028, 0.006543472874909639, -0.0056795766577124596, -0.09992441534996033, -0.0877322107553482, 0.0945844054222107, 0.050936125218868256, -0.07342370599508286, 0.07810107618570328, 0.015542910434305668, 0.04248419031500816, -0.05247601866722107, 0.01530107855796814, 0.07314040511846542, -0.0018047535559162498, -0.06616993993520737, -0.023284951224923134, 0.010585157200694084, 0.023240262642502785, 0.019730225205421448, -0.011357537470757961, 0.01086302101612091, 0.03632322698831558, 0.00012588300160132349, -0.015098177827894688, 0.03078935481607914, -0.04253242909908295, 0.06290078908205032, 0.06296810507774353, -0.029151542112231255, 0.030934523791074753, -0.01997237652540207, -0.004697936587035656, -0.04562007263302803, 0.01744554564356804, 0.03723817691206932, 0.045478079468011856, -0.05826820060610771, 0.025010541081428528, -0.06790129840373993, 0.04413682967424393, 0.01492333970963955, 0.008701324462890625, 0.012869776226580143, -0.006902470253407955, -0.053940340876579285, -0.019991101697087288, -0.009778749197721481, 0.03849576413631439, 0.017812898382544518, 0.031853534281253815, 0.010475613176822662, -0.04240161180496216, 0.014449995942413807, -0.011015024967491627, 0.010998625308275223, -0.021717559546232224, 0.0487859733402729, -0.043887969106435776, 0.008368507027626038, 0.04492328315973282, -0.03601079434156418, -0.06506331264972687, 0.059575457125902176, -0.02132446877658367, 0.022534165531396866, -0.014234144240617752, -0.0066061802208423615, 0.030119752511382103, 0.022071124985814095, 0.05681395158171654, -0.05904164910316467, 0.03190746158361435, 0.0029124354477971792, 0.04078811779618263, 0.06060652434825897, -0.07332660257816315, 0.049593813717365265, -0.035526175051927567, 0.059469278901815414, -0.02941122092306614, -0.00847368873655796, -0.007879063487052917, -0.030508827418088913, 0.0011590744834393263, -0.005132218822836876, -0.08827213197946548, 0.019490163773298264, -0.030443986877799034, 0.04360257089138031, -0.05719566345214844, 0.06329596042633057, -0.06993338465690613, 0.030982058495283127, -0.025841400027275085, 0.049131907522678375, -0.044961169362068176, -0.010951116681098938, 0.014927374199032784, 0.03846780210733414, -0.07894587516784668, -0.04059021174907684, -0.008684830740094185, 0.02845519781112671, -0.03286190330982208, -0.013703797943890095, 0.002818807028234005, -0.00034899337333627045, 0.011624638922512531, -0.011777335777878761, -0.0011639954755082726, 0.09412972629070282, 0.06884881108999252, 0.11434799432754517, -0.0062904441729187965, -0.007525680121034384, -0.10496973246335983, 0.01931091584265232, -0.0372280590236187, 0.07857634127140045, -0.011932644061744213, 0.000042317344195907936, -0.03763673081994057, 0.025940829887986183, 0.015631655231118202, 0.04263800382614136, -0.08656348288059235, 0.014616709202528, 0.036184970289468765, 0.0025525300297886133, -0.06597819179296494, 0.020286936312913895, 0.048212237656116486, 0.003899262985214591, -0.03093908540904522, 0.012537279166281223, 0.053465235978364944, 0.00017867132555693388, -0.06293357908725739, -0.03998507186770439, 0.06408360600471497, -0.022323329001665115, -0.008270359598100185, 0.04628116264939308, 0.019392594695091248, 0.05119820684194565, -0.031138557940721512, -0.053027257323265076, -0.0007855623262003064, 0.028029821813106537, -0.007507592439651489, -0.0370824858546257, -0.06372641772031784, 0.004153819289058447, -0.019993945956230164, 0.07461930811405182, -0.07809136062860489, 0.028102170675992966, 0.015376067720353603, -0.003494362346827984, -0.021869126707315445, 0.005313963163644075, -0.01848447509109974, -0.08918303996324539, -0.0051465947180986404, 0.017309071496129036, -0.04222629964351654, 0.01850099116563797, -0.02383130043745041, 0.049111414700746536, 0.006571517325937748, -0.012779764831066132, 0.006207400932908058, 0.008189387619495392, 0.022297663614153862, -0.06265092641115189, 0.08442356437444687, 0.014625446870923042, 0.05275477468967438, -0.013362005352973938, 0.02558542601764202, 0.14711333811283112, -0.023992037400603294, 0.035197045654058456, 0.010808929800987244, -0.048767223954200745, -0.023960689082741737, 0.00037470812094397843, -0.0015524611808359623, 0.0006071648094803095, -0.005064432043582201, -0.025632182136178017, -0.06403587013483047, 0.07263937592506409, 0.04656249284744263, 0.08322137594223022, 0.08221132308244705, -0.014013764448463917, -0.05115615203976631, -0.04173767939209938, -0.00665057310834527, -0.00041222141589969397, 0.06920117884874344, -0.014483971521258354, 0.02503233030438423, -0.007916495203971863, 0.010596306063234806, 0.026341887190937996, 0.0011896078940480947, 0.04821743816137314, 0.05956272408366203, 0.006308244075626135, 0.02207864820957184, -0.04006575793027878, -0.0015401883283630013, -0.07538671046495438, -0.01275851484388113, 0.07325305044651031, -0.043713610619306564, 0.021393269300460815, -0.033120036125183105, 0.04531615972518921, -0.036835189908742905, 0.013011721894145012, -0.0648006796836853, -0.029689330607652664, -0.04874059930443764, -0.031452592462301254, 0.01157456822693348, 0.0009713288163766265, -0.06501553952693939, 0.07608596235513687, -0.0028666651342064142, -0.01217654999345541, -0.029768427833914757, -0.02376950904726982, -0.06725126504898071, 0.03467147424817085, -0.039993446320295334, 0.008694604970514774, 0.09933535754680634, -0.004362972918897867, 0.07291564345359802, -0.02378040738403797, -0.08351875841617584, -0.020836764946579933, -0.04430368170142174, 0.0008264106581918895, 0.044536042958498, 0.02785840816795826, 0.05723699554800987, 0.05652620270848274, 0.05530252307653427, 0.02688148245215416, -0.004834486171603203, 0.05969453230500221, -0.03026547282934189, 0.07214462757110596, -0.04093398153781891, 0.03263270854949951, 0.05091361328959465, 0.022745858877897263, 0.020132625475525856, 0.07128456979990005, 0.001695311744697392, -0.02717241644859314, -0.027308082208037376, -0.004408169537782669, -0.05149377882480621, 0.08655419945716858, -0.05481597036123276, -0.0027484921738505363, 0.004307103808969259, 0.021365616470575333, -0.016600674018263817, 0.0627935454249382, -0.04554339498281479, 0.023102393373847008, 0.024037739261984825, -0.001582457683980465, -0.021076172590255737, -0.004654037766158581, -0.055820807814598083, 0.023684343323111534, -0.062340147793293, -0.011497934348881245, -0.08624952286481857, 0.01914696954190731, -0.041432324796915054, -0.020054427906870842, 0.05618714541196823, -0.07119669765233994, -0.019674615934491158, -0.0341336727142334, 0.07304488867521286, -0.04726452752947807, -0.05348142981529236, 0.019926123321056366, 0.04408853128552437, 0.02171877957880497, 0.02086043916642666, 0.017040302976965904, 0.022933583706617355, 0.005710856057703495, -0.02903675101697445, -0.029643787071108818, 0.02593444660305977, 0.002482555340975523, -0.038830142468214035, 0.0007913859444670379, 0.10574647039175034, -0.029812172055244446, -0.00478556752204895, -0.07000422477722168, -0.08300328999757767, 0.0638355240225792, -0.016400568187236786, 0.006117962300777435, -0.026826994493603706, -0.01123446598649025, -0.02553471177816391, -0.006893213838338852, 0.04967176169157028, 0.00011570472997846082, -0.03746355324983597, -0.021941371262073517, -0.032555364072322845, -0.012749062851071358, -0.0003828839398920536, 0.09929303079843521, -0.012787147425115108, 0.03777763992547989, -0.06035619601607323, -0.034313004463911057, 0.00315861776471138, 0.050535790622234344, -0.02534530684351921, -0.06477724760770798, 0.00973520614206791, -0.025293003767728806, 0.08611126989126205, 0.08546090126037598, 0.1236361563205719, -0.027637392282485962, 0.015535571612417698, -0.067619189620018, -0.04583122953772545, -0.002873428165912628, 0.040342483669519424, 0.00289098359644413, 0.011445899493992329, -0.07053399085998535, 0.03723767399787903, 0.02663422003388405, -0.039196934551000595, 0.0359380878508091, -0.07418349385261536, -0.0675426572561264, -0.0511326864361763, -0.02731429785490036, 0.015621447935700417, 0.04857654497027397, -0.052470460534095764, -0.0379827581346035, -0.017084553837776184, -0.00282269692979753, 0.025434201583266258, 0.021718082949519157, -0.006074562668800354, 0.001692344667389989, 0.055337488651275635, -0.034819841384887695, 0.08962780982255936, -0.02923302724957466, -0.02617585100233555, 0.033764734864234924, 0.048497043550014496, 0.03596846014261246, 0.03317156806588173, 0.015566656365990639, 0.030790725722908974, 0.025305021554231644, -0.03753490000963211, 0.024698209017515182, 0.09474793821573257, -0.02936544083058834, 0.0890732929110527, 0.028898252174258232, -0.0020129529293626547, 0.11231402307748795, 0.06302279978990555, -0.004481917712837458, 0.018332865089178085, 0.025751585140824318, 0.01791987381875515, 0.026349235326051712, -0.005981710273772478, -0.016691742464900017, -0.08078743517398834, 0.014623919501900673, -0.08326714485883713, -0.03078845515847206, -0.09811941534280777, 0.0014979263069108129, -0.023225393146276474, 0.07040886580944061, -0.01696959137916565, 0.02959488146007061, -0.10515254735946655, 0.06784503161907196, -0.024267597123980522, 0.007243797183036804, 0.02397460862994194, 0.05727018043398857, -0.012887348420917988, -0.0016214546049013734, 0.000001271192900276219, 0.007659628055989742, 0.015134704299271107, -0.04028116911649704, -0.038872964680194855, -0.022912969812750816, 0.02462807483971119, 0.005484917666763067, 0.005222054664045572, -0.00730275921523571, -0.04810480773448944, -0.043864719569683075, -0.09391704946756363, -0.011081326752901077, 0.017603186890482903, -0.06191984936594963, 0.02531430311501026, -0.05792941153049469, -0.07419856637716293, 0.016032589599490166, -0.011180310510098934, -0.03485037386417389, -0.05207972228527069, 0.0421164371073246, -0.04477405548095703, -0.046620260924100876, 0.11285270005464554, 0.005167105235159397, 0.06187274679541588, 0.03655431792140007, -0.08197250962257385, -0.007479000370949507, 0.0051577128469944, -0.0790843591094017, 0.02606264315545559, 0.014334178529679775, 0.03212973102927208, 0.01976800709962845, -0.02290896698832512, -0.03985687717795372, -0.03693012148141861, -0.014304134994745255, -0.07018715888261795, 0.018937384709715843, -0.02874613367021084, -0.051200684159994125, -0.012312882579863071, 0.015183390118181705, 0.10187644511461258, -0.02414860762655735, -0.04060224071145058, 0.04460795968770981, -0.01853833720088005, 0.010907827876508236, 0.00330008240416646, 0.0301655326038599, -0.003178606741130352, 0.006278849206864834, 0.010314883664250374, -0.03375778719782829, 0.0035362320486456156, 0.008221901953220367, 0.06627637892961502, -0.009649084880948067, 0.06052183732390404, 0.11626876890659332, -0.03528584539890289, 0.017764069139957428, 0.06447335332632065, 0.008022618480026722, -0.03191308677196503, -0.027338124811649323, -0.02930377796292305, 0.023996978998184204, -0.006273530423641205, 0.09626930952072144, 0.016967372968792915, -0.011796615086495876, 0.07770472764968872, -0.00020305487851146609, 0.05822386220097542, -0.01564730517566204, -0.03136990964412689, 0.011540190316736698, -0.02452576346695423, 0.03699992597103119, 0.07854276150465012, -0.019420068711042404, -0.004994848743081093, -0.002076169243082404, -0.1324607878923416, -0.029607124626636505 ]
2
2
The on-line shortest path problem under partial monitoring
The on-line shortest path problem is considered under various models of partial monitoring. Given a weighted directed acyclic graph whose edge weights can change in an arbitrary (adversarial) way, a decision maker has to choose in each round of a game a path between two distinguished vertices such that the loss of the chosen path (defined as the sum of the weights of its composing edges) be as small as possible. In a setting generalizing the multi-armed bandit problem, after choosing a path, the decision maker learns only the weights of those edges that belong to the chosen path. For this problem, an algorithm is given whose average cumulative loss in n rounds exceeds that of the best path, matched off-line to the entire sequence of the edge weights, by a quantity that is proportional to 1/\sqrt{n} and depends only polynomially on the number of edges of the graph. The algorithm can be implemented with linear complexity in the number of rounds n and in the number of edges. An extension to the so-called label efficient setting is also given, in which the decision maker is informed about the weights of the edges corresponding to the chosen path at a total of m << n time instances. Another extension is shown where the decision maker competes against a time-varying path, a generalization of the problem of tracking the best expert. A version of the multi-armed bandit setting for shortest path is also discussed where the decision maker learns only the total weight of the chosen path but not the weights of the individual edges on the path. Applications to routing in packet switched networks along with simulation results are also presented.
[ 0.000755675311665982, -0.006383625324815512, 0.06321606040000916, 0.018453117460012436, -0.04894636198878288, -0.0331275574862957, -0.019592666998505592, -0.06036412715911865, -0.02779497392475605, -0.01775413192808628, 0.03049515001475811, -0.057871170341968536, 0.030917175114154816, -0.01911981962621212, 0.05835353955626488, -0.0562300980091095, -0.02258506789803505, 0.003624147269874811, -0.0038403987418860197, 0.011673646047711372, -0.006344318389892578, 0.023747924715280533, 0.04779640957713127, -0.011825458146631718, 0.016416970640420914, 0.00808107852935791, -0.06367955356836319, 0.04332422837615013, -0.011242150329053402, -0.0024693377781659365, -0.0569402314722538, -0.010037719272077084, 0.005525107495486736, 0.04754243418574333, 0.07153097540140152, -0.01688057743012905, 0.06073844060301781, -0.06765896081924438, 0.03333820775151253, -0.022002890706062317, 0.0374084897339344, -0.023422980681061745, -0.02671946957707405, -0.0077416677959263325, 0.0791071355342865, -0.03704554960131645, 0.015944989398121834, 0.028978561982512474, -0.025806043297052383, 0.046772003173828125, 0.0014319135807454586, 0.00038830566336400807, -0.0330970324575901, -0.020298786461353302, 0.025769729167222977, 0.054751284420490265, -0.12098254263401031, -0.04106936231255531, 0.007776693440973759, -0.1475319117307663, -0.0004578062507789582, 0.08496168255805969, -0.04758843407034874, -0.025811709463596344, -0.052279770374298096, 0.029260531067848206, -0.0499851293861866, -0.02761666849255562, 0.030948422849178314, -0.004112571943551302, -0.009024920873343945, -0.031247030943632126, 0.0031329328194260597, 0.020450927317142487, -0.031365517526865005, 0.06234312430024147, -0.013039966113865376, 0.026879429817199707, 0.030022703111171722, 0.16592207551002502, -0.11793294548988342, 0.012796787545084953, -0.0998009517788887, 0.04368896409869194, 0.024284951388835907, -0.08167054504156113, 0.0017967516323551536, 0.04449939727783203, -0.005291348323225975, -0.02768305502831936, -0.030588077381253242, -0.009243211708962917, -0.07840288430452347, 0.02637273259460926, -0.057616546750068665, 0.057664044201374054, -0.07894470542669296, 0.031239880248904228, -0.03518124297261238, 0.03541569411754608, 0.02576501853764057, -0.0060469345189630985, 0.05551924556493759, 0.08406589180231094, -0.03768341988325119, -0.06488575786352158, 0.04344355687499046, 0.023046422749757767, 0.028866909444332123, -0.00852193497121334, -0.00046142356586642563, 0.08172767609357834, -0.038710515946149826, 0.014017272740602493, 0.0010121407685801387, -0.012562833726406097, -0.04329121112823486, 0.03487176075577736, -0.059553347527980804, -0.012547795660793781, -0.029883716255426407, 0.0410006120800972, -0.03896201029419899, -0.0051887123845517635, -0.024806244298815727, -0.026577886193990707, -0.013555283658206463, 0.009808612056076527, 0.05283631756901741, 0.043719105422496796, -0.07713320851325989, 0.06254244595766068, -0.040790215134620667, -0.08993641287088394, -0.068964384496212, 0.02354857139289379, 0.11509372293949127, 0.023279553279280663, 0.04009983316063881, 0.05386902391910553, 0.01056902576237917, -0.14038366079330444, -0.0514482781291008, -0.027106158435344696, 0.018147403374314308, 0.03658188879489899, 0.0038052017334848642, 0.03825213387608528, 0.018528662621974945, 0.019499756395816803, 0.027761507779359818, 0.01425376906991005, 0.019034693017601967, 0.026206977665424347, -0.01111263781785965, -0.034333936870098114, -0.027604088187217712, -0.042337555438280106, -0.01910768821835518, -0.009025448001921177, 0.006533617153763771, 0.009976753033697605, 0.01352870836853981, -0.04758913442492485, 0.08233033865690231, -0.008850916288793087, -0.007710752077400684, -0.019435882568359375, -0.0665293037891388, -0.0029210569337010384, 0.03973259776830673, -0.011391546577215195, -0.003542065154761076, 0.026927176862955093, 0.015793070197105408, -0.009705048985779285, 0.042916227132081985, 0.06755300611257553, 0.013583900406956673, 0.012983803637325764, 0.03993990644812584, -0.04846608266234398, 0.02225062996149063, -0.03044942207634449, 0.03877181187272072, -0.009989902377128601, 0.04417436569929123, 0.04430317133665085, 0.05675244331359863, 0.05179465934634209, -0.09839412569999695, 0.006125453859567642, 0.06802217662334442, -0.015940343961119652, 0.024638017639517784, 0.032990265637636185, -0.04969058930873871, -0.003439665073528886, 0.051621392369270325, -0.013698886148631573, 0.0035862887743860483, -0.017482850700616837, -0.03047266975045204, -0.024826601147651672, -0.04606606811285019, -0.03487090393900871, 0.004268800374120474, -0.11216747015714645, 0.027602218091487885, -0.06263240426778793, -0.017443036660552025, -0.012097054161131382, 0.022854166105389595, 0.03275125473737717, 0.030181629583239555, -0.02096615359187126, -0.005331427790224552, -0.012749331071972847, 0.02136279083788395, -0.037528544664382935, -0.014883426018059254, 0.03673234209418297, 0.006417800206691027, -0.0010535651817917824, -0.11256081610918045, 0.018830997869372368, 0.02227596752345562, 0.015072470530867577, -0.013831539079546928, 0.07942304015159607, -0.006458268966525793, -0.03309851884841919, -0.02011730894446373, 0.024606196209788322, -0.019063634797930717, 0.06836701929569244, -0.024562662467360497, -0.02769995853304863, -0.048316825181245804, -0.04970407485961914, -0.005067619029432535, 0.0938803032040596, -0.05707808956503868, -0.012696869671344757, 0.032375022768974304, 0.047365542501211166, 0.07569427043199539, 0.03617790713906288, -0.04013313725590706, -0.007143276743590832, -0.040643319487571716, 0.016377989202737808, -0.02339296042919159, -0.010921240784227848, 0.010775097645819187, 0.034113187342882156, -0.008958382532000542, 0.11510417610406876, 0.027835920453071594, 0.039237748831510544, 0.02248944714665413, -0.0010250563500449061, -0.0415060855448246, -0.025069184601306915, 0.05498937517404556, 0.016811827197670937, 0.007470899727195501, 0.024407658725976944, -0.0025709224864840508, -0.008444062434136868, 0.01614077389240265, -0.017346905544400215, -0.04058201238512993, 0.10780231654644012, 0.02687273733317852, -0.06196807324886322, -0.006162915378808975, 0.050892286002635956, 0.020786352455615997, 0.0011157507542520761, -0.05066310241818428, -0.06866061687469482, 0.08595830947160721, -0.04703976586461067, -0.06237165629863739, 0.0865415558218956, -0.014050540514290333, -0.06956330686807632, 0.04516960307955742, 0.03075048327445984, -0.07302644848823547, 0.00034062075428664684, -0.05475897341966629, -0.09571490436792374, 0.006641116924583912, -0.06294653564691544, -0.0073415907099843025, -0.02627652697265148, -0.02674260549247265, -0.05279459431767464, 0.03102737106382847, -0.04629432410001755, 0.03441951423883438, 0.09690175950527191, -0.013498043641448021, 0.07939748466014862, 0.06355221569538116, -0.03295355290174484, -0.05098465085029602, -0.02144237980246544, -0.006496097892522812, -0.005642291158437729, -0.10201814770698547, -0.009918482042849064, 0.023166758939623833, -0.003866249229758978, -0.07804848998785019, -0.0696587935090065, -0.0925254374742508, 0.03250258043408394, -0.05631760507822037, 0.004435619805008173, -0.017288129776716232, -0.014390894211828709, -0.04826314374804497, 0.0071830120868980885, -0.0038687153719365597, 0.046114787459373474, -0.024522719904780388, -0.02413739450275898, -0.053701020777225494, 0.022916683927178383, -0.04368916526436806, 0.07448606938123703, -0.09708251804113388, -0.02009315975010395, -0.027915390208363533, -0.026755504310131073, 0.022501077502965927, 0.021876420825719833, -0.027624405920505524, -0.04893098026514053, -0.020795201882719994, -0.029157418757677078, 0.07343368232250214, 0.09928997606039047, 0.01665298081934452, 0.021966278553009033, 0.00015009328490123153, -0.043567951768636703, -0.05366552248597145, -0.006397339049726725, -0.028511928394436836, 0.03439914062619209, -0.020793750882148743, -0.030822912231087685, 0.03290018066763878, -0.007701832335442305, -0.05765195190906525, 0.006599406246095896, -0.06520283967256546, -0.06266024708747864, -0.06849624961614609, -0.034012358635663986, 0.046228259801864624, 0.03434169664978981, 0.006157927680760622, -0.009921683929860592, -0.07376089692115784, -0.02841544710099697, 0.0021002141293138266, 0.01848112791776657, -0.012823209166526794, -0.026541272178292274, -0.026289623230695724, 0.0012700107181444764, 0.0498819462954998, -0.08484738320112228, -0.03717222437262535, 0.05355875566601753, -0.03301948681473732, 0.03312451392412186, 0.001717896549962461, -0.015776868909597397, 0.01931578479707241, -0.0007785090710967779, -0.020484991371631622, 0.011784755624830723, 0.11902842670679092, 0.001460293889977038, -0.023201748728752136, 0.007040086667984724, -0.007463008631020784, 0.013907144777476788, 0.02498519793152809, -0.013060217723250389, 0.006374866236001253, 0.042664915323257446, -0.030555782839655876, 0.02669762261211872, 0.001475870725698769, -0.05859677866101265, -0.039571184664964676, -0.05799895524978638, -0.04151485115289688, 0.02141704596579075, 0.06301920861005783, 0.008755308575928211, 0.005564652383327484, 0.05753412842750549, 0.041352707892656326, 0.05822364613413811, -0.030349798500537872, 0.04087459295988083, -0.02937178872525692, 0.0314411036670208, -0.009736779145896435, 0.03821693733334541, 0.01776450127363205, -0.04414759948849678, 0.014442209154367447, 0.041737526655197144, 0.01565929874777794, -0.015637079253792763, -0.0447048544883728, -0.041772134602069855, 0.018665123730897903, 0.04981716349720955, -0.022930774837732315, 0.07514137774705887, -0.07754366099834442, -0.024863259866833687, -0.044169604778289795, -0.009984426200389862, -0.009351675398647785, -0.006705140229314566, 0.04277745634317398, -0.07280094921588898, -0.017418181523680687, -0.009920971468091011, 0.016629789024591446, -0.004794432315975428, -0.007843484170734882, 0.03832802176475525, -0.023624015972018242, 0.02742978371679783, -0.027841152623295784, 0.030353112146258354, 0.03583087399601936, -0.025953073054552078, -0.008146942593157291, -0.024415310472249985, -0.022407421842217445, -0.01801176369190216, -0.00025001916219480336, -0.07427045702934265, 0.023615548387169838, -0.04235276207327843, 0.01254599541425705, -0.10205833613872528, -0.008248690515756607, -0.008146896958351135, -0.04981406778097153, -0.024006437510252, 0.0026635967660695314, 0.00315782125107944, 0.002545161871239543, -0.009198307991027832, 0.056476522237062454, 0.006912633776664734, -0.1241261288523674, -0.00574519531801343, 0.020823953673243523, -0.039376769214868546, -0.024053990840911865, 0.03529158979654312, -0.03350912779569626, 0.008077499456703663, 0.044290073215961456, 0.0708349198102951, 0.039880502969026566, 0.041596341878175735, 0.0030895574018359184, -0.006793066393584013, 0.05869060382246971, -0.02871518023312092, -0.049725491553545, 0.02115222066640854, 0.03422919288277626, 0.042364493012428284, 0.015836050733923912, -0.10793375223875046, -0.017929308116436005, 0.041702751070261, 0.04754454270005226, -0.020780470222234726, 0.02948181889951229, -0.04378805682063103, 0.06286173313856125, 0.01751275733113289, 0.07254871726036072, -0.02174423635005951, 0.066459521651268, 0.10560598969459534, -0.002516415435820818, -0.04333242028951645, 0.025929130613803864, 0.0007074668537825346, -0.034325011074543, 0.028957491740584373, 0.006740703713148832, 0.1262204945087433 ]
3
3
A neural network approach to ordinal regression
Ordinal regression is an important type of learning, which has properties of both classification and regression. Here we describe a simple and effective approach to adapt a traditional neural network to learn ordinal categories. Our approach is a generalization of the perceptron method for ordinal regression. On several benchmark datasets, our method (NNRank) outperforms a neural network classification method. Compared with the ordinal regression methods using Gaussian processes and support vector machines, NNRank achieves comparable performance. Moreover, NNRank has the advantages of traditional neural networks: learning in both online and batch modes, handling very large training datasets, and making rapid predictions. These features make NNRank a useful and complementary tool for large-scale data processing tasks such as information retrieval, web page ranking, collaborative filtering, and protein ranking in Bioinformatics.
[ -0.07906521111726761, -0.025648243725299835, 0.03470279648900032, -0.07104214280843735, 0.09014969319105148, 0.00525145698338747, 0.05112215131521225, 0.019955243915319443, -0.08313404768705368, -0.0481962151825428, -0.014733987860381603, -0.025386424735188484, -0.05720795691013336, -0.0330241359770298, 0.006368232890963554, -0.006383147090673447, -0.06038660183548927, -0.08626404404640198, 0.03441094607114792, -0.03905282914638519, 0.0024756700731813908, -0.03459915146231651, 0.04431571811437607, -0.08085383474826813, 0.0056191799230873585, 0.07581160962581635, -0.030388211831450462, -0.003995319362729788, 0.0017238825093954802, -0.019266633316874504, -0.02131645753979683, -0.02865460142493248, 0.0562906339764595, 0.04856426268815994, -0.008677135221660137, -0.028476223349571228, -0.0006549195386469364, 0.023174844682216644, -0.023840274661779404, -0.07023846358060837, -0.0016498197801411152, -0.056329671293497086, 0.019565587863326073, 0.004984864499419928, 0.043057143688201904, -0.05381698161363602, -0.02457827888429165, -0.0352240614593029, -0.024766990914940834, 0.09729195386171341, -0.07532055675983429, 0.03964684531092644, -0.028057845309376717, -0.023796861991286278, -0.03499295562505722, 0.05653778463602066, 0.01137747522443533, -0.03832090273499489, -0.026596028357744217, -0.06960022449493408, 0.013588669709861279, -0.0371982678771019, 0.04500691592693329, -0.02180326357483864, 0.04313841089606285, 0.014115624129772186, -0.023251628503203392, -0.06292033940553665, 0.03797121345996857, -0.016604555770754814, 0.02111956849694252, 0.0038332983385771513, -0.01354136597365141, 0.07339703291654587, 0.01618547923862934, -0.0026020794175565243, -0.046620164066553116, 0.01889362744987011, 0.07819586247205734, 0.010514255613088608, -0.05999254435300827, 0.11005115509033203, -0.01294850092381239, 0.04443173483014107, -0.02908371016383171, -0.033939555287361145, -0.031934954226017, -0.060081981122493744, -0.01948145031929016, 0.01815299317240715, -0.0499458871781826, -0.003983505070209503, -0.030595162883400917, 0.016169173642992973, -0.04856856167316437, -0.04937167465686798, -0.04095585644245148, -0.04076627641916275, -0.007925265468657017, -0.03645310550928116, 0.03604407608509064, -0.027249380946159363, -0.026938974857330322, 0.025580715388059616, -0.032815124839544296, 0.02387435920536518, -0.08394418656826019, 0.05388766899704933, 0.023121356964111328, 0.06570672988891602, 0.019819000735878944, 0.0665101706981659, 0.004753306042402983, 0.01824016124010086, -0.04474061727523804, 0.031706273555755615, -0.05124920979142189, 0.07747235894203186, -0.017322618514299393, -0.030834803357720375, -0.033855222165584564, 0.002025267109274864, -0.021475899964571, 0.02528846077620983, 0.04838303476572037, -0.04499300569295883, 0.01896740309894085, -0.04902093857526779, 0.05984613671898842, 0.022361768409609795, -0.0949750691652298, 0.13639655709266663, 0.006755908019840717, 0.003187582129612565, -0.0369398258626461, -0.033235229551792145, 0.08807463943958282, -0.015912938863039017, 0.002255298662930727, 0.006675479933619499, -0.060007233172655106, 0.010615602135658264, 0.0019811983220279217, 0.06083806976675987, -0.002984829479828477, 0.03742343559861183, -0.017328763380646706, 0.010667648166418076, 0.04157605022192001, -0.008721156977117062, -0.03086298517882824, -0.033729057759046555, 0.06305969506502151, 0.03128993138670921, 0.00824214331805706, -0.07635985314846039, -0.04961239919066429, -0.04729418084025383, -0.004503050819039345, 0.03033076599240303, -0.0016849532257765532, -0.015218417160212994, -0.01064461562782526, -0.009544612839818, 0.017176344990730286, -0.05834698677062988, -0.0732354074716568, 0.043506868183612823, -0.002732705557718873, -0.04348297789692879, -0.08463137596845627, 0.02757406234741211, -0.008660795167088509, 0.045622918754816055, 0.004313196055591106, -0.06157590448856354, 0.021666890010237694, -0.06223268061876297, -0.059841789305210114, 0.013029245659708977, 0.056096259504556656, -0.0707281306385994, -0.04941718280315399, 0.012962120585143566, 0.04808473959565163, 0.048813700675964355, -0.03139176964759827, 0.05248250812292099, 0.042481519281864166, 0.018324047327041626, 0.07160404324531555, -0.05049412325024605, 0.012403433211147785, 0.06673600524663925, -0.07856409251689911, 0.06926430761814117, -0.017836887389421463, -0.0481991209089756, 0.017131278291344643, 0.03356687352061272, 0.012732760980725288, 0.005845512263476849, -0.016568874940276146, -0.017888974398374557, -0.04429231584072113, 0.009572439827024937, 0.0415019653737545, -0.07149841636419296, -0.04198702052235603, 0.020176246762275696, -0.021496430039405823, 0.04636835306882858, -0.018327899277210236, 0.04954568296670914, -0.010213738307356834, -0.08834882825613022, -0.014350319281220436, -0.02232694998383522, 0.09850087016820908, 0.0748162493109703, -0.004493333399295807, 0.07926934212446213, -0.04470036178827286, 0.04334069788455963, -0.05179227888584137, 0.053993817418813705, 0.019660575315356255, -0.00916623417288065, -0.09516927599906921, -0.007031473331153393, -0.014826489612460136, -0.030820008367300034, 0.03499690815806389, -0.051517847925424576, 0.05736776441335678, 0.0845685601234436, -0.06064249202609062, -0.03797581046819687, -0.06908854842185974, -0.09858184307813644, -0.03294236585497856, -0.014734054915606976, -0.03322584927082062, 0.0015748519217595458, -0.0001742513559293002, -0.0321807861328125, -0.003361496841534972, -0.03153810650110245, -0.024779604747891426, -0.07421820610761642, 0.05627463385462761, 0.04469837620854378, -0.094297394156456, 0.007807796820998192, -0.0057780807837843895, 0.03491310402750969, -0.004103899467736483, -0.02283979393541813, 0.05201863870024681, 0.023013493046164513, -0.017845168709754944, -0.02898334339261055, 0.017482034862041473, 0.0003128977841697633, 0.04927295818924904, 0.009875763207674026, -0.11926960200071335, -0.02073494717478752, -0.05309445783495903, 0.036360371857881546, 0.04584668204188347, -0.0418776273727417, -0.04200276732444763, 0.08076178282499313, -0.00942738726735115, 0.04593309387564659, 0.010719752870500088, 0.033034730702638626, 0.04105331376194954, -0.023507164791226387, -0.021484823897480965, 0.023438112810254097, -0.04313059523701668, 0.044734083116054535, -0.016963178291916847, -0.004945675376802683, -0.04834189638495445, -0.06365694105625153, 0.04687989130616188, 0.005514005199074745, -0.05454961955547333, 0.12302221357822418, -0.09546707570552826, -0.03483431786298752, 0.09337598830461502, -0.05675412341952324, 0.07631181925535202, -0.05214594677090645, -0.01631489209830761, 0.027761338278651237, 0.016339868307113647, -0.02585994265973568, 0.07454715669155121, -0.03410934656858444, 0.015469050034880638, 0.06442543119192123, -0.016835160553455353, 0.0724356546998024, -0.04292694479227066, -0.02733762376010418, -0.002461671596392989, -0.0581301711499691, -0.012285744771361351, -0.014001323841512203, -0.013878613710403442, -0.02307731844484806, -0.04301382228732109, 0.021132836118340492, -0.06008833646774292, 0.02358788438141346, 0.0468045249581337, 0.03380502387881279, 0.007334393914788961, -0.037707388401031494, -0.012869663536548615, 0.012953431345522404, -0.039665114134550095, 0.05386389046907425, -0.08145983517169952, 0.02606331557035446, -0.08473938703536987, 0.015200109221041203, 0.006891197059303522, 0.0777430310845375, -0.011124571785330772, 0.009070002473890781, -0.06595267355442047, -0.03462495282292366, -0.02515271119773388, 0.034938447177410126, -0.06657063961029053, -0.034380953758955, -0.004587613977491856, 0.03413664177060127, 0.0225976649671793, 0.06612160056829453, 0.015865549445152283, -0.034756895154714584, 0.03296087682247162, 0.013403182849287987, -0.037544503808021545, 0.0825381800532341, -0.02159244380891323, 0.07312877476215363, -0.004949669819325209, 0.017315328121185303, 0.07742038369178772, -0.003421835834160447, 0.03268720582127571, 0.019373415037989616, 0.03253522515296936, 0.0626295879483223, 0.006969090551137924, -0.01976717822253704, 0.041053153574466705, 0.04179864749312401, 0.04712529480457306, 0.008238987997174263, -0.02908448874950409, 0.05210196226835251, 0.06774567812681198, 0.012548291124403477, 0.034127648919820786, -0.038664691150188446, -0.04361266270279884, -0.012375353835523129, -0.01895567774772644, 0.043000221252441406, 0.05345438793301582, 0.061867017298936844, -0.1295657753944397, 0.013229912146925926, 0.059271108359098434, 0.04889567941427231, 0.0016035321168601513, -0.017822332680225372, -0.00026138030807487667, -0.043205078691244125, 0.05659607797861099, -0.01573798432946205, -0.007576572243124247, -0.05170024186372757, -0.04658060520887375, 0.03573144972324371, 0.027251483872532845, -0.02849871851503849, 0.05724184960126877, -0.040525879710912704, -0.001091811922378838, 0.054787199944257736, -0.06932386755943298, -0.0591951422393322, 0.041410237550735474, -0.07320094108581543, -0.03236320614814758, -0.006484774872660637, 0.018519604578614235, 0.11348021030426025, 0.04973527416586876, -0.03275163471698761, 0.02953645959496498, 0.05296238139271736, -0.0048144506290555, -0.022827016189694405, 0.028530333191156387, 0.007693587802350521, 0.028917750343680382, -0.0447881706058979, -0.009899760596454144, -0.04437514767050743, -0.04997219145298004, 0.006228977348655462, 0.02336209826171398, 0.004554377868771553, -0.07338397949934006, 0.03723258152604103, 0.03468409553170204, 0.028262456879019737, 0.038644902408123016, -0.010924899950623512, -0.0089536402374506, 0.052130524069070816, -0.036067601293325424, 0.00023481421521864831, 0.07799819856882095, 0.04001638665795326, 0.022699151188135147, 0.030398957431316376, -0.006001634057611227, -0.017361057922244072, -0.036323726177215576, -0.06628597527742386, 0.010905943810939789, -0.003240165300667286, 0.04693009331822395, 0.0345749706029892, 0.07158011943101883, -0.04944857954978943, 0.03275341913104057, -0.018430285155773163, -0.0028727175667881966, -0.032309241592884064, 0.013635728508234024, -0.06606600433588028, -0.0550462044775486, -0.03363526985049248, 0.006037472747266293, -0.017544489353895187, 0.022296302020549774, -0.06869731098413467, -0.03323359414935112, -0.027491578832268715, -0.006375695578753948, -0.02776274085044861, -0.026307368651032448, -0.025136006996035576, 0.03688877075910568, 0.04600519314408302, 0.07884814590215683, 0.03542003780603409, -0.059481848031282425, 0.0008654920384287834, 0.0034751195926219225, -0.020819030702114105, 0.038254231214523315, -0.009955544024705887, 0.06610237807035446, -0.04821357503533363, -0.01434562262147665, -0.05773003026843071, 0.018851328641176224, 0.02656400203704834, 0.011917922645807266, 0.055457260459661484, 0.046222053468227386, -0.018848583102226257, -0.017773570492863655, 0.03734048083424568, -0.040251877158880234, 0.06963638961315155, -0.054784830659627914, -0.013077250681817532, 0.05460672453045845, 0.02630658447742462, -0.0007601210963912308, -0.008482896722853184, 0.038920361548662186, 0.02242748998105526, -0.041911035776138306, 0.06081891804933548, 0.000892630429007113, 0.0048988270573318005, 0.07873690873384476, -0.062119293957948685, 0.07137793302536011, 0.026151621714234352, 0.062091294676065445, -0.011101990938186646, -0.010772227309644222, 0.04084068909287453, -0.055963724851608276, -0.022506097331643105 ]
4
4
Parametric Learning and Monte Carlo Optimization
This paper uncovers and explores the close relationship between Monte Carlo Optimization of a parametrized integral (MCO), Parametric machine-Learning (PL), and `blackbox' or `oracle'-based optimization (BO). We make four contributions. First, we prove that MCO is mathematically identical to a broad class of PL problems. This identity potentially provides a new application domain for all broadly applicable PL techniques: MCO. Second, we introduce immediate sampling, a new version of the Probability Collectives (PC) algorithm for blackbox optimization. Immediate sampling transforms the original BO problem into an MCO problem. Accordingly, by combining these first two contributions, we can apply all PL techniques to BO. In our third contribution we validate this way of improving BO by demonstrating that cross-validation and bagging improve immediate sampling. Finally, conventional MC and MCO procedures ignore the relationship between the sample point locations and the associated values of the integrand; only the values of the integrand at those locations are considered. We demonstrate that one can exploit the sample location information using PL techniques, for example by forming a fit of the sample locations to the associated values of the integrand. This provides an additional way to apply PL techniques to improve MCO.
[ -0.025683250278234482, 0.013804095797240734, -0.037734080106019974, 0.04791690409183502, -0.005097192246466875, -0.06484774500131607, -0.0289395023137331, -0.010688052512705326, -0.061275664716959, -0.014997083693742752, 0.021075529977679253, -0.034898582845926285, -0.031338490545749664, 0.05389891192317009, -0.048169322311878204, 0.053703561425209045, -0.0004816179280169308, -0.001498573343269527, 0.031053537502884865, -0.027133073657751083, -0.040312863886356354, 0.07620763033628464, 0.0007852056296542287, 0.042090583592653275, -0.007525664754211903, -0.005798928439617157, -0.014177490957081318, -0.07064825296401978, -0.06264042854309082, 0.023615963757038116, -0.011145132593810558, 0.026024868711829185, 0.01756650023162365, 0.018569400534033775, 0.0219951793551445, 0.0490245521068573, 0.0497027263045311, -0.00898994691669941, -0.0518537238240242, -0.031149763613939285, -0.06156018003821373, -0.04408559203147888, 0.01910410262644291, 0.006822983268648386, -0.025837311521172523, 0.08088698238134384, 0.026092926040291786, -0.001144052715972066, -0.00033399928361177444, 0.05956794321537018, -0.07817953824996948, 0.045637160539627075, -0.06178805232048035, -0.010534513741731644, 0.03990453481674194, -0.029577048495411873, 0.03127628564834595, -0.025618113577365875, -0.027058029547333717, 0.027189388871192932, 0.03444748744368553, 0.09604685753583908, -0.01625792682170868, -0.0266634002327919, -0.0688423290848732, -0.03637244179844856, -0.03254937008023262, -0.05317328870296478, -0.03807253763079643, -0.03096160851418972, -0.0009795288788154721, -0.08137106895446777, 0.027395302429795265, 0.00489055085927248, 0.059334974735975266, 0.0026949369348585606, -0.013573580421507359, -0.005072882864624262, 0.030361969023942947, -0.033051326870918274, 0.02034146524965763, -0.05743024870753288, -0.028822019696235657, 0.06236347556114197, -0.0423290878534317, 0.002747434424236417, 0.004490711726248264, 0.008268713019788265, -0.04667355492711067, -0.04886578395962715, 0.0108496667817235, -0.007669544313102961, -0.040218841284513474, 0.04225979372859001, 0.0394386425614357, -0.00718487286940217, -0.07786887139081955, -0.034386008977890015, -0.03033011592924595, -0.0033854516223073006, -0.011037513613700867, -0.06203009560704231, 0.0518210269510746, 0.09398367255926132, -0.019322188571095467, 0.00466439314186573, -0.0376274511218071, 0.06742655485868454, 0.017287341877818108, 0.062424276024103165, -0.027995841577649117, -0.0789092630147934, 0.10912645608186722, 0.018627099692821503, -0.053561873733997345, 0.054897941648960114, -0.0758097916841507, -0.026073656976222992, -0.03770260512828827, -0.009447460062801838, 0.048311736434698105, 0.016337500885128975, -0.016761859878897667, -0.026165436953306198, 0.06053415685892105, 0.0031838652212172747, -0.029756924137473106, -0.04106863588094711, 0.07647282630205154, -0.048718929290771484, -0.015162982046604156, 0.10357788950204849, -0.02336234599351883, -0.040260329842567444, -0.06268025934696198, 0.002798721892759204, 0.029561934992671013, -0.02056337334215641, -0.07903160154819489, -0.013053552247583866, -0.05129654332995415, -0.0031267867889255285, -0.01582987979054451, 0.06770116835832596, 0.05784453824162483, 0.02270238660275936, -0.008452752605080605, 0.029771553352475166, -0.02802976965904236, 0.008589205332100391, -0.10312415659427643, 0.008388248272240162, 0.005859144032001495, 0.013326827436685562, -0.0006537666777148843, 0.01664799079298973, -0.00997339840978384, -0.039818938821554184, 0.021237533539533615, 0.09293046593666077, -0.07691282033920288, 0.019441897049546242, 0.01614406332373619, 0.013330548070371151, -0.04241802915930748, 0.05067472532391548, -0.047016043215990067, 0.023866187781095505, -0.0065192366018891335, -0.09142816066741943, -0.03415800631046295, -0.015060197561979294, -0.004309485666453838, -0.051860131323337555, 0.010124387219548225, 0.020750265568494797, -0.022782346233725548, 0.015279685147106647, -0.040721599012613297, -0.029542863368988037, 0.0027938068378716707, -0.021003372967243195, -0.010593432001769543, 0.0028477346058934927, -0.06620241701602936, 0.005392142571508884, -0.05683695524930954, 0.0023432725574821234, 0.03435709327459335, 0.04434865340590477, 0.012103823013603687, -0.014632203616201878, 0.009764746762812138, 0.01055824477225542, 0.06620609015226364, -0.0021848399192094803, 0.01896435022354126, -0.02932785078883171, -0.06486605852842331, 0.0364854522049427, 0.03297184780240059, -0.010893658734858036, -0.03156308829784393, 0.048490408807992935, -0.029223235324025154, 0.059716399759054184, 0.10184725373983383, -0.0017369880806654692, -0.013428925536572933, -0.06884563714265823, -0.016018487513065338, -0.01710733398795128, -0.055353473871946335, -0.04342352971434593, 0.011509502306580544, -0.0939745381474495, -0.006651182193309069, -0.03685140609741211, 0.02861558459699154, 0.02206386998295784, 0.0030778879299759865, 0.022576289251446724, 0.006511485204100609, 0.08896120637655258, 0.02358129993081093, -0.014291557483375072, 0.044496819376945496, -0.02066299505531788, -0.07790518552064896, -0.01602129451930523, 0.005811918061226606, -0.06981144100427628, -0.00603750254958868, 0.00876113586127758, -0.02758042700588703, 0.03140086308121681, -0.02629934996366501, -0.08159300684928894, 0.013505023904144764, -0.013453858904540539, -0.04963578283786774, 0.022840149700641632, 0.06074311211705208, 0.007267470471560955, 0.031732965260744095, -0.0035117489751428366, 0.07543843984603882, 0.06324728578329086, -0.0020753340795636177, -0.042919959872961044, -0.028427017852663994, -0.023374292999505997, 0.048832111060619354, -0.04171883314847946, -0.03428955003619194, -0.07083725184202194, 0.028857048600912094, 0.07812916487455368, 0.08367648720741272, 0.04413997009396553, -0.050742682069540024, -0.01763268932700157, -0.08755775541067123, -0.017058294266462326, 0.0632220059633255, 0.10202789306640625, 0.01596953719854355, 0.03501145914196968, 0.03159433603286743, -0.008717631921172142, -0.054299309849739075, 0.031198622658848763, -0.06405197083950043, 0.02347532846033573, 0.006162474863231182, -0.05259987339377403, 0.047841425985097885, -0.010454296134412289, -0.01358818169683218, -0.044002968817949295, -0.13822877407073975, 0.041788432747125626, -0.017471743747591972, -0.0006334344507195055, 0.034352581948041916, 0.045467209070920944, -0.06081985682249069, -0.004780609160661697, -0.00258009135723114, 0.07142094522714615, -0.042098209261894226, 0.0166952982544899, -0.11544723808765411, -0.05059187114238739, 0.024507803842425346, 0.0009240680956281722, 0.04002414271235466, -0.06071355566382408, -0.013154428452253342, -0.053834013640880585, 0.043509650975465775, 0.009108506143093109, 0.0560406893491745, 0.010665033012628555, -0.029613453894853592, 0.06842248886823654, 0.07640974223613739, 0.027931559830904007, -0.06457562744617462, -0.0073310681618750095, 0.12944674491882324, 0.044325072318315506, 0.018038950860500336, 0.005860757082700729, -0.046313222497701645, -0.03267456218600273, -0.007451650220900774, 0.04413462057709694, 0.05763030797243118, 0.05223396047949791, 0.023063737899065018, 0.02544439397752285, 0.02175983600318432, -0.049064792692661285, -0.06545955687761307, -0.02696049027144909, -0.013292595744132996, 0.02983609214425087, -0.03597436100244522, 0.037698112428188324, -0.0020049563609063625, -0.0009246588451787829, -0.04025061056017876, 0.07213137298822403, -0.016140764579176903, 0.017093004658818245, -0.02312786877155304, 0.02397928014397621, -0.03234446421265602, -0.047300513833761215, -0.054213039577007294, -0.1274331957101822, -0.0021317265927791595, 0.04885495826601982, -0.009595092386007309, 0.011810443364083767, 0.0972914770245552, 0.004089095629751682, 0.021611906588077545, -0.057921264320611954, 0.007092648651450872, -0.07380165159702301, -0.05653057247400284, 0.013078637421131134, -0.033948950469493866, -0.0033646265510469675, 0.0023950960021466017, -0.032010581344366074, 0.008561176247894764, 0.04927249625325203, -0.054486192762851715, 0.005176718812435865, -0.02942536026239395, -0.023706631734967232, 0.0023334131110459566, -0.036650508642196655, -0.011296117678284645, -0.004955870099365711, 0.01700950413942337, -0.023303568363189697, -0.03416794165968895, 0.05554194003343582, 0.020759213715791702, 0.10084038972854614, 0.059790145605802536, 0.012014971114695072, 0.028879189863801003, 0.05750679969787598, -0.07722116261720657, 0.06972858309745789, 0.01666847988963127, -0.026607876643538475, 0.043627701699733734, -0.00019414207781665027, -0.03672933205962181, -0.006170232314616442, -0.05694737657904625, 0.004618413280695677, 0.05183901637792587, 0.0016644244315102696, -0.1365816295146942, 0.040970370173454285, 0.013960842043161392, 0.029614411294460297, 0.09471330791711807, 0.0997982919216156, 0.01622205600142479, -0.028193192556500435, 0.05497157946228981, -0.00012413231888785958, 0.02614537440240383, -0.04894991219043732, -0.001064384006895125, -0.055368583649396896, -0.03527949005365372, 0.06200605258345604, 0.029522953554987907, 0.06612037867307663, -0.028626011684536934, 0.014342927373945713, -0.049914732575416565, 0.0640111044049263, -0.03384384140372276, 0.0045860083773732185, -0.03838624805212021, -0.0007073343149386346, -0.032802779227495193, -0.049184709787368774, -0.041502535343170166, -0.027861375361680984, 0.013219593092799187, -0.003916541114449501, -0.023953376337885857, -0.05092804133892059, 0.0630602091550827, -0.0014399311039596796, 0.06585913151502609, 0.024729521945118904, 0.018880100920796394, -0.014703895896673203, -0.040747277438640594, -0.04645828157663345, -0.03398649021983147, -0.02378779463469982, -0.03719760477542877, 0.014579818584024906, 0.04993756487965584, 0.1157679557800293, -0.015571441501379013, -0.027018500491976738, -0.014718315564095974, 0.018727092072367668, 0.06820888817310333, -0.01740594021975994, 0.012985480949282646, 0.08920034766197205, -0.020543627440929413, 0.040144529193639755, 0.07401883602142334, 0.05741865560412407, 0.013171914033591747, 0.04574611783027649, 0.06368029117584229, 0.0020305453799664974, 0.007809934206306934, 0.00371757335960865, -0.05315738543868065, -0.0936177670955658, 0.04427652806043625, 0.032720837742090225, 0.030341356992721558, -0.033958107233047485, -0.043450016528367996, 0.03290713578462601, -0.06577513366937637, 0.035847440361976624, -0.0298931784927845, -0.033772408962249756, 0.08738444745540619, -0.006359138526022434, 0.05023772642016411, -0.03871027007699013, 0.035653285682201385, -0.024138005450367928, -0.015684444457292557, -0.039678048342466354, 0.01894901879131794, -0.08884353190660477, 0.04435516148805618, -0.031454309821128845, 0.03546353802084923, 0.001067634206265211, -0.04316150024533272, 0.06760795414447784, -0.0011607151245698333, 0.031765952706336975, -0.08958233892917633, 0.03739026561379433, -0.01264012698084116, 0.055693160742521286, 0.007657770067453384, 0.02078809216618538, 0.09893409162759781, 0.03538797050714493, -0.023745127022266388, -0.002285626484081149, -0.023905349895358086, -0.005379526410251856, 0.05024222657084465, -0.026774024590849876, -0.01266256533563137, -0.050785407423973083, 0.008436327800154686, -0.04483947530388832, 0.024403993040323257, 0.016215022653341293, 0.047450900077819824, 0.012999662198126316, -0.08683814853429794, 0.025313137099146843, -0.027958760038018227, 0.003526505548506975 ]
5
5
Preconditioned Temporal Difference Learning
This paper has been withdrawn by the author. This draft is withdrawn for its poor quality in english, unfortunately produced by the author when he was just starting his science route. Look at the ICML version instead: http://icml2008.cs.helsinki.fi/papers/111.pdf
[ -0.10221751779317856, -0.040076520293951035, 0.051786910742521286, -0.06474457681179047, 0.02861255593597889, 0.007166793569922447, 0.039160363376140594, 0.027947042137384415, -0.04483644291758537, -0.02906694822013378, -0.026252850890159607, 0.04841038957238197, 0.008092854171991348, 0.015708046033978462, 0.032306116074323654, 0.01465432345867157, -0.01833985187113285, -0.04249144345521927, -0.02299913950264454, -0.033263351768255234, 0.07567524909973145, 0.030836137011647224, -0.02081243321299553, -0.05537329241633415, 0.07486514747142792, -0.07530435919761658, -0.019640494138002396, -0.0028879435267299414, -0.041594043374061584, -0.011216801591217518, -0.09241145849227905, 0.05701534077525139, 0.04079307243227959, 0.008038444444537163, 0.046283163130283356, -0.001678141881711781, 0.034083444625139236, -0.0019285480957478285, -0.07030922174453735, 0.034805841743946075, 0.05097079649567604, -0.01124725304543972, 0.0035161105915904045, -0.061373963952064514, 0.045535970479249954, 0.026484349742531776, 0.029510723426938057, -0.009641622193157673, 0.005191766656935215, 0.08071935921907425, -0.07903318107128143, -0.046491481363773346, -0.06831853091716766, -0.04153401032090187, -0.047851257026195526, 0.032757099717855453, -0.011209281161427498, 0.06867972761392593, 0.013998660258948803, 0.002193015068769455, 0.06909511983394623, 0.07323523610830307, -0.01767108403146267, -0.016989517956972122, -0.07427619397640228, -0.020680326968431473, -0.052061378955841064, -0.027576707303524017, -0.01831766404211521, -0.033933885395526886, 0.004705776460468769, 0.016751278191804886, -0.050759244710206985, 0.050873346626758575, 0.0330028310418129, -0.029516924172639847, -0.012756370939314365, 0.02540890872478485, 0.06530016660690308, 0.06261292845010757, -0.04684683680534363, -0.03119111992418766, -0.039974987506866455, -0.0413970984518528, -0.012420963495969772, 0.03975585848093033, 0.07647421211004257, -0.045967455953359604, 0.021863417699933052, -0.03592448681592941, -0.04196518287062645, -0.014602077193558216, -0.0914357453584671, 0.10037001222372055, -0.021987510845065117, 0.029782867059111595, -0.01673048920929432, -0.043406933546066284, -0.028290903195738792, 0.013535385020077229, 0.03707582503557205, -0.0018675196915864944, 0.06756480783224106, 0.04536422714591026, -0.00831577554345131, 0.06750303506851196, -0.021673420444130898, 0.007916107773780823, 0.008613335900008678, 0.05309367552399635, 0.026566507294774055, -0.008000234141945839, -0.0061381421983242035, 0.053834158927202225, 0.009639445692300797, 0.04498404264450073, 0.030819138512015343, 0.054777923971414566, 0.014456404373049736, -0.034906890243291855, -0.0323050282895565, 0.03242660313844681, -0.06230095028877258, 0.021682152524590492, 0.046187832951545715, 0.00560927065089345, -0.08653333783149719, -0.0501730740070343, 0.04709828644990921, -0.030374756082892418, -0.0639212504029274, 0.09886306524276733, -0.022354550659656525, -0.002407080726698041, -0.028605613857507706, 0.10686413198709488, 0.03166045621037483, -0.012318575754761696, -0.027230549603700638, 0.05862417444586754, -0.005727319046854973, -0.020535258576273918, -0.017422806471586227, 0.027401888743042946, 0.040059227496385574, 0.019600069150328636, -0.04243849962949753, -0.017121706157922745, 0.007409578189253807, -0.03855753690004349, -0.04325579106807709, -0.045347727835178375, 0.01666657067835331, 0.09753262251615524, 0.09513896703720093, -0.0439448207616806, -0.06991906464099884, -0.030589846894145012, -0.0463910810649395, 0.04790607467293739, -0.042570002377033234, 0.04001202806830406, -0.04474671930074692, 0.014541421085596085, -0.0014813377056270838, 0.011709192767739296, -0.003665714059025049, -0.04824899882078171, -0.022242998704314232, -0.035665955394506454, 0.009702556766569614, 0.03448322415351868, 0.0169820599257946, 0.0023458346258848906, -0.053478922694921494, 0.03952951729297638, -0.0603192038834095, 0.08285149931907654, -0.04298501834273338, 0.004780819173902273, 0.0417337492108345, -0.061696384102106094, -0.043899163603782654, 0.03667522594332695, 0.05443064495921135, 0.09406407177448273, 0.0842505544424057, 0.011191817931830883, 0.09562546014785767, 0.0390961654484272, 0.08040066808462143, -0.016611291095614433, -0.011901536956429482, -0.03359515592455864, 0.02628970518708229, 0.012435381300747395, -0.02084897644817829, -0.03638313338160515, -0.0010133624309673905, 0.08465774357318878, 0.016972847282886505, 0.022878576070070267, -0.03044874034821987, -0.07677549868822098, -0.0672031119465828, 0.07430925220251083, 0.09139687567949295, -0.060239408165216446, 0.04728696495294571, -0.053345806896686554, -0.014779770746827126, -0.03293360024690628, -0.01316686812788248, 0.07723688334226608, 0.0070295799523591995, 0.047051675617694855, -0.013979984447360039, -0.020357640460133553, 0.08768081665039062, 0.0164200346916914, -0.011723486706614494, 0.01114595402032137, -0.0019614859484136105, 0.059855587780475616, 0.0172885712236166, -0.022612523287534714, 0.02296322025358677, -0.02790030650794506, 0.0025728887412697077, 0.036849237978458405, -0.12333062291145325, -0.0719170942902565, -0.06451164931058884, -0.010081063024699688, -0.005524646490812302, -0.03811504691839218, -0.05165751650929451, 0.05687408149242401, 0.027620723471045494, -0.03174733743071556, -0.04950958862900734, 0.004099532030522823, -0.01529712975025177, 0.025118572637438774, -0.012685833498835564, -0.009798604995012283, 0.018585892394185066, 0.0598452091217041, -0.031279370188713074, 0.0165436752140522, -0.017026061192154884, -0.04573095589876175, -0.008662804961204529, 0.013323835097253323, -0.01331700012087822, 0.0732003003358841, -0.07285203784704208, 0.019919877871870995, 0.06278843432664871, 0.11060812324285507, -0.028577741235494614, 0.02049834281206131, -0.029565973207354546, -0.023480160161852837, 0.021972190588712692, 0.04514649510383606, 0.03410407900810242, 0.04934104532003403, -0.03555098548531532, 0.0005758373299613595, -0.03250739723443985, -0.051176268607378006, -0.09277363121509552, 0.042448192834854126, -0.06833270192146301, -0.048281069844961166, -0.02148526906967163, 0.03551243990659714, 0.006474171299487352, 0.004729143809527159, -0.011876430362462997, 0.01195119321346283, -0.020380215719342232, -0.04155392944812775, -0.09395196288824081, 0.01856059581041336, 0.045402415096759796, -0.08209329843521118, 0.02777007780969143, 0.06145649775862694, -0.037689343094825745, -0.005726915318518877, -0.04756488278508186, -0.030818361788988113, 0.0222883652895689, 0.06314820796251297, -0.02018854022026062, 0.030268359929323196, 0.005441753659397364, -0.02554095722734928, 0.01476203091442585, -0.02464628778398037, 0.021888820454478264, 0.056830763816833496, 0.0612432062625885, 0.007385558448731899, 0.016887348145246506, -0.0442420057952404, -0.05934586003422737, 0.026621835306286812, 0.022072404623031616, 0.04404537007212639, -0.01734006032347679, 0.037741418927907944, -0.0007790912641212344, -0.0973864495754242, -0.027288779616355896, 0.023689718917012215, 0.03190755099058151, -0.0030793563928455114, -0.01365644671022892, 0.04783634468913078, -0.01886148191988468, 0.019951075315475464, 0.012257516384124756, -0.021707724779844284, 0.01340605691075325, 0.005970717873424292, 0.018693840131163597, -0.03274032101035118, -0.039402179419994354, 0.026014765724539757, 0.05323518440127373, 0.007061896845698357, -0.002784623997285962, 0.02339930646121502, -0.04726359620690346, 0.0006068040383979678, -0.031389493495225906, 0.05436066910624504, -0.04289640486240387, 0.04264084994792938, -0.004131164867430925, 0.003444866742938757, 0.0010729692876338959, -0.023789776489138603, 0.04149752855300903, 0.034219298511743546, -0.021498413756489754, 0.004374408163130283, -0.0025624483823776245, 0.025970516726374626, -0.02162078022956848, 0.04360242560505867, 0.03962248936295509, 0.009341761469841003, 0.06608309596776962, 0.07364578545093536, 0.004204770550131798, 0.021239696070551872, -0.06384941190481186, 0.010471967980265617, 0.07151040434837341, -0.11989513039588928, -0.0008133187657222152, 0.09647016227245331, 0.019652893766760826, 0.03268451243638992, -0.022642415016889572, -0.03829577565193176, -0.01921077072620392, -0.0330447182059288, 0.036545462906360626, 0.07632368803024292, 0.05825766175985336, 0.10139086842536926, 0.09148366004228592, -0.05464567616581917, -0.02845478430390358, 0.07537370920181274, -0.06462699174880981, -0.05428050085902214, -0.01703709363937378, 0.008457222953438759, -0.04810071736574173, 0.015325220301747322, -0.037060413509607315, 0.013788571581244469, 0.0907357856631279, 0.009122071787714958, -0.021720154210925102, 0.014563420787453651, -0.0247636828571558, 0.08769548684358597, 0.03607935830950737, 0.02930290438234806, -0.02929588221013546, -0.04206337779760361, -0.04443764314055443, 0.004525425378233194, -0.04182572662830353, -0.0678999051451683, -0.04995689541101456, -0.003574295900762081, 0.02387790009379387, -0.06525629758834839, 0.007852686569094658, 0.06373381614685059, 0.02829929254949093, 0.02404283732175827, -0.011437547393143177, 0.017586564645171165, -0.0444403812289238, -0.019217289984226227, 0.048675328493118286, 0.07287365943193436, 0.06357269734144211, -0.05610920861363411, 0.0290328748524189, -0.13114798069000244, -0.04137851670384407, 0.05115947499871254, -0.027183005586266518, 0.027796274051070213, -0.05197161063551903, 0.021754397079348564, 0.0955839455127716, 0.036665018647909164, 0.049695536494255066, 0.024425912648439407, 0.016962794587016106, -0.021467650309205055, 0.008528380654752254, -0.060826949775218964, 0.05039568617939949, -0.07293282449245453, 0.008947594091296196, -0.028584638610482216, 0.05280102416872978, -0.028439495712518692, -0.04651380702853203, -0.06851603090763092, 0.03408965840935707, 0.022737998515367508, -0.03737975284457207, 0.005853384267538786, 0.0010674537625163794, -0.04495914280414581, 0.07713495939970016, 0.009569655172526836, -0.004780974704772234, 0.016417019069194794, -0.002079441212117672, -0.006264922209084034, -0.032355256378650665, 0.020918209105730057, -0.010340527631342411, 0.015785543248057365, 0.0359819121658802, -0.00337184383533895, -0.024711044505238533, 0.06998158246278763, 0.019110286608338356, 0.030918480828404427, -0.11870837211608887, 0.0010727827902883291, 0.03503363952040672, 0.04173946753144264, 0.04781639203429222, -0.004964308347553015, -0.00979562196880579, 0.04433821141719818, -0.014158191159367561, -0.02321864292025566, -0.03923208266496658, -0.010013758204877377, -0.03730589523911476, -0.05185427516698837, 0.03134319186210632, -0.0962827205657959, -0.025817355141043663, -0.004761809948831797, -0.02412586845457554, -0.028770864009857178, 0.0518307238817215, 0.008480371907353401, -0.05348458141088486, -0.055270999670028687, 0.007979311980307102, 0.057349320501089096, 0.06577944755554199, -0.043474115431308746, 0.003373343264684081, 0.0372924730181694, 0.019069861620664597, 0.032646603882312775, -0.010490675456821918, -0.0006669313297607005, 0.030302852392196655, 0.02765594609081745, 0.035602785646915436, 0.02020687237381935, 0.053258802741765976, 0.0012636675965040922, 0.06227310746908188, 0.017969205975532532, 0.026471173390746117, -0.07516905665397644, 0.039504099637269974, 0.05886148288846016, -0.01713506691157818, -0.018087906762957573 ]
6
6
A Note on the Inapproximability of Correlation Clustering
We consider inapproximability of the correlation clustering problem defined as follows: Given a graph $G = (V,E)$ where each edge is labeled either "+" (similar) or "-" (dissimilar), correlation clustering seeks to partition the vertices into clusters so that the number of pairs correctly (resp. incorrectly) classified with respect to the labels is maximized (resp. minimized). The two complementary problems are called MaxAgree and MinDisagree, respectively, and have been studied on complete graphs, where every edge is labeled, and general graphs, where some edge might not have been labeled. Natural edge-weighted versions of both problems have been studied as well. Let S-MaxAgree denote the weighted problem where all weights are taken from set S, we show that S-MaxAgree with weights bounded by $O(|V|^{1/2-\delta})$ essentially belongs to the same hardness class in the following sense: if there is a polynomial time algorithm that approximates S-MaxAgree within a factor of $\lambda = O(\log{|V|})$ with high probability, then for any choice of S', S'-MaxAgree can be approximated in polynomial time within a factor of $(\lambda + \epsilon)$, where $\epsilon > 0$ can be arbitrarily small, with high probability. A similar statement also holds for $S-MinDisagree. This result implies it is hard (assuming $NP \neq RP$) to approximate unweighted MaxAgree within a factor of $80/79-\epsilon$, improving upon a previous known factor of $116/115-\epsilon$ by Charikar et. al. \cite{Chari05}.
[ -0.019140047952532768, -0.03673176467418671, 0.027718400582671165, 0.05995643511414528, -0.005211443640291691, -0.012341849505901337, -0.0070815677754580975, -0.06979259103536606, -0.019784636795520782, -0.013893002644181252, 0.00830121897161007, 0.015757188200950623, 0.004675279837101698, 0.0807027742266655, 0.1318453699350357, -0.05600890889763832, -0.07191535085439682, 0.01923297718167305, -0.04530663788318634, -0.026149392127990723, -0.00923970341682434, -0.031270984560251236, 0.006591031327843666, -0.023165101185441017, 0.02436022460460663, -0.06529936194419861, -0.03025401569902897, 0.023947909474372864, -0.00003138604370178655, -0.011414928361773491, 0.003708720440044999, -0.05614107474684715, 0.021805783733725548, 0.02764274738729, 0.001784100430086255, 0.03503866493701935, 0.039284903556108475, 0.0364595390856266, -0.05556660518050194, -0.011241216212511063, 0.0634896382689476, -0.021912802010774612, -0.0051314993761479855, 0.009637972339987755, 0.0452636294066906, -0.05322630703449249, 0.06349731236696243, 0.09089893102645874, 0.041448406875133514, 0.07066429406404495, -0.02053169533610344, -0.00914256926625967, -0.014513300731778145, -0.032151058316230774, -0.03330409899353981, 0.019611995667219162, -0.06198669970035553, 0.01969233527779579, -0.02701936848461628, -0.018196485936641693, 0.06270024180412292, 0.09307114034891129, -0.07098831236362457, -0.009234919212758541, -0.058832574635744095, -0.05371617153286934, -0.024603277444839478, 0.019024228677153587, -0.05460449308156967, -0.035393744707107544, -0.0006798600661568344, -0.0493771992623806, 0.0551038533449173, 0.06644342094659805, -0.04900047183036804, 0.021196700632572174, 0.027492135763168335, 0.03719067573547363, -0.009261484257876873, 0.11085022985935211, -0.019738677889108658, -0.06570138782262802, -0.03197157382965088, -0.012597164139151573, -0.028913438320159912, 0.009080596268177032, 0.04859340563416481, 0.008507193997502327, -0.022926369681954384, 0.03854430839419365, -0.020651599392294884, 0.005150505807250738, -0.11800286918878555, 0.04943198710680008, -0.030787188559770584, 0.025361010804772377, -0.014312215149402618, 0.03305919095873833, 0.005158230196684599, 0.03412040323019028, -0.018704315647482872, -0.0628357008099556, -0.017726825550198555, 0.029689643532037735, -0.01507946103811264, 0.0008280130568891764, -0.023380037397146225, -0.02243059128522873, 0.05338510498404503, -0.10536165535449982, 0.03033312037587166, 0.014564597979187965, -0.027713961899280548, -0.0008407029090449214, 0.025248533114790916, 0.02111498825252056, -0.04717935994267464, 0.0462244488298893, 0.002573779784142971, 0.028856610879302025, -0.006344086490571499, -0.014404602348804474, -0.04264742508530617, 0.01614348031580448, -0.03137259930372238, -0.02469627931714058, -0.12261736392974854, -0.01810852438211441, 0.17198188602924347, 0.023568954318761826, -0.0941067487001419, -0.007666722871363163, -0.04782486334443092, 0.0004370272217784077, -0.10579368472099304, 0.05004185438156128, 0.084471195936203, -0.07634072750806808, -0.039182182401418686, 0.061011169105768204, 0.007372473832219839, -0.04438484460115433, 0.027068566530942917, -0.0007287834887392819, 0.06703048199415207, 0.035832662135362625, -0.007514056283980608, 0.06436124444007874, -0.018301334232091904, 0.024619203060865402, -0.0025832916144281626, -0.008965687826275826, -0.009659862145781517, 0.09236319363117218, 0.02831299789249897, -0.040285151451826096, -0.06581339240074158, -0.07388801872730255, 0.04948965832591057, 0.021689768880605698, -0.03549285605549812, -0.0362212210893631, 0.06724733859300613, -0.008839203044772148, -0.04280134290456772, 0.010207593441009521, -0.02457503043115139, -0.011923120357096195, -0.008086109533905983, -0.008291911333799362, 0.043718643486499786, 0.011957003735005856, -0.03469891473650932, 0.03882165998220444, 0.025997305288910866, 0.02815154381096363, 0.005151680205017328, 0.0029171511996537447, -0.019072044640779495, -0.015167864970862865, 0.06849607825279236, 0.006305150222033262, 0.004162010736763477, 0.004298471380025148, 0.06917928159236908, 0.1020030602812767, -0.002334336517378688, -0.005330965854227543, 0.008243738673627377, 0.025002244859933853, -0.0003330992185510695, -0.026616951450705528, -0.0007762053865008056, 0.02429216541349888, -0.01892664283514023, 0.0028739338740706444, -0.07966731488704681, -0.04382062703371048, 0.013426960445940495, 0.043095145374536514, 0.04553832486271858, -0.01632349006831646, -0.09447060525417328, -0.07247929275035858, -0.06325255334377289, 0.018503092229366302, -0.011766954325139523, -0.05947001278400421, -0.053707823157310486, -0.04764614254236221, 0.05108388513326645, 0.06354837119579315, 0.030699322000145912, 0.029300503432750702, -0.00042903871508315206, 0.008648646995425224, -0.0682508647441864, -0.05132945999503136, 0.0025897722225636244, -0.04892602562904358, -0.0026574928779155016, 0.014235801063477993, 0.010346552357077599, 0.06810300052165985, -0.10184302926063538, 0.028406286612153053, -0.03752810135483742, 0.023284582421183586, -0.0648430585861206, 0.019562406465411186, -0.09317024797201157, -0.06818600744009018, -0.09083972871303558, -0.04555340111255646, -0.03537137433886528, -0.013725331984460354, -0.0427774116396904, -0.027722729369997978, -0.0210736021399498, -0.006811163388192654, -0.03839559853076935, 0.02030792459845543, -0.0016673986101523042, -0.061981867998838425, 0.03831314668059349, -0.02424740046262741, 0.04266299679875374, 0.07847770303487778, -0.07103049010038376, 0.00035328141530044377, -0.07380497455596924, 0.023800352588295937, 0.018568679690361023, 0.011791247874498367, 0.07137417793273926, 0.021155377849936485, 0.011944631114602089, 0.13054488599300385, 0.017947962507605553, 0.02801336906850338, 0.053598783910274506, 0.08069413155317307, -0.0445510596036911, -0.11752147972583771, 0.029962537810206413, 0.01679069735109806, 0.06041679531335831, -0.011949770152568817, 0.028767602518200874, -0.03750986233353615, 0.011954646557569504, -0.10500263422727585, -0.06477396190166473, 0.05733688175678253, -0.021552229300141335, 0.04371148720383644, -0.007434537634253502, 0.04330112785100937, 0.006443982012569904, 0.05278430134057999, -0.06050269305706024, -0.049368053674697876, 0.0712750032544136, -0.056499890983104706, -0.026598520576953888, 0.005635259672999382, 0.06730008870363235, -0.025591645389795303, 0.0012719847727566957, 0.04002413898706436, -0.04392154887318611, 0.016044452786445618, 0.02307545579969883, -0.01717432588338852, 0.039185889065265656, -0.07004962116479874, -0.033687178045511246, 0.03843691200017929, 0.061572760343551636, -0.02124079316854477, -0.03680294752120972, 0.07319556921720505, 0.044735848903656006, 0.006284784991294146, 0.023276718333363533, -0.007841009646654129, 0.08357635885477066, 0.010921499691903591, -0.05243567377328873, -0.025312693789601326, -0.03496362268924713, 0.054857417941093445, -0.06342928111553192, 0.015189859084784985, 0.05520712211728096, 0.04835309833288193, -0.08223813027143478, 0.03473962843418121, -0.0440375916659832, 0.047241054475307465, -0.05381576716899872, -0.05163860693573952, 0.028304405510425568, 0.09523534774780273, -0.09691384434700012, 0.015177414752542973, 0.060122087597846985, 0.01012365147471428, -0.014651203528046608, 0.021381525322794914, -0.03050442598760128, 0.03508996590971947, -0.04651882126927376, 0.028089405968785286, 0.0696261003613472, 0.015329805202782154, -0.033350080251693726, -0.03406499698758125, -0.045715440064668655, 0.021854255348443985, -0.06861772388219833, -0.040816545486450195, -0.03226860612630844, 0.003736702958121896, 0.04069756343960762, 0.056897226721048355, 0.011157121509313583, 0.01940961927175522, 0.0410836786031723, -0.0407026968896389, -0.09587622433900833, 0.021948473528027534, 0.026797648519277573, 0.014035336673259735, 0.011693937703967094, 0.03827027603983879, 0.09228845685720444, -0.020948685705661774, -0.005089378450065851, -0.005677258595824242, -0.06813385337591171, -0.02283659763634205, -0.029848966747522354, 0.012714837677776814, 0.038533467799425125, 0.03637513518333435, -0.08211976289749146, 0.03585394471883774, 0.0344250462949276, -0.03063742071390152, 0.026632308959960938, 0.0499575138092041, -0.018613863736391068, 0.00503760389983654, -0.027964890003204346, -0.0942346528172493, -0.005528832785785198, -0.022231724113225937, 0.03394932299852371, 0.0006289632292464375, 0.015484772622585297, 0.004114321433007717, -0.040196072310209274, -0.00666556553915143, 0.04902902618050575, -0.009382916614413261, -0.039289455860853195, 0.03915316238999367, 0.08174236863851547, 0.02972065471112728, 0.029111139476299286, -0.11694826930761337, -0.030407654121518135, 0.02806362509727478, 0.03878356143832207, -0.0017616982804611325, 0.0012568073580041528, 0.04472513124346733, -0.02480478398501873, 0.0016495628515258431, 0.0434112511575222, -0.06439875811338425, -0.010056599974632263, -0.0502706803381443, -0.06442379206418991, -0.0010270075872540474, -0.0037594521418213844, 0.01950579509139061, -0.022519156336784363, 0.07782619446516037, 0.019142642617225647, 0.04660870507359505, -0.07219765335321426, 0.014078749343752861, 0.006062133237719536, 0.033378034830093384, -0.0003026778867933899, 0.001905805547721684, 0.03176956623792648, -0.056377261877059937, 0.005140536930412054, 0.02319798432290554, -0.00285370834171772, -0.015476668253540993, 0.028129642829298973, 0.008693606592714787, 0.03974786400794983, 0.042622365057468414, -0.05000697076320648, 0.06490527838468552, -0.008870048448443413, 0.0028095354791730642, -0.010597426444292068, 0.022009143605828285, 0.02775130420923233, 0.01886916160583496, 0.04549028351902962, -0.021482398733496666, -0.010803117416799068, -0.019111137837171555, -0.012896045111119747, 0.05803951993584633, -0.005342167802155018, 0.012971106916666031, 0.009756012819707394, -0.030905554071068764, -0.017375357449054718, 0.036147039383649826, 0.06732670962810516, 0.03837593272328377, 0.02580040693283081, 0.020396407693624496, -0.03640115633606911, -0.017233749851584435, 0.03048570267856121, -0.04816856607794762, 0.00238802726380527, -0.010794630274176598, 0.014691703021526337, -0.13620217144489288, -0.04056813567876816, 0.0227627195417881, -0.011055446229875088, 0.004405679646879435, -0.013597461394965649, -0.0025969273410737514, -0.0189267098903656, -0.012353625148534775, 0.009419906884431839, -0.025807568803429604, -0.025659075006842613, 0.03753027319908142, 0.035132065415382385, 0.054406650364398956, -0.04380687326192856, -0.009858328849077225, 0.005912815686315298, 0.0017291889525949955, 0.0538184717297554, 0.034910041838884354, 0.027265021577477455, 0.008860789239406586, -0.04022315517067909, -0.020641153678297997, 0.08758342266082764, 0.043048642575740814, -0.08138206601142883, 0.03727235645055771, -0.0003453513199929148, -0.03817913681268692, -0.0035112621262669563, 0.019950395449995995, -0.05307799205183983, -0.03635105863213539, -0.0500306598842144, 0.0014068048913031816, 0.08577059209346771, 0.03875686973333359, -0.02480333298444748, 0.03986218571662903, 0.03161878138780594, 0.01344546489417553, 0.03235520422458649, -0.007009197026491165, 0.025719625875353813, 0.026634342968463898, 0.04324629157781601, 0.016292020678520203, -0.06170082837343216, -0.023580104112625122, -0.04152316227555275, 0.008840744383633137 ]
7
7
Joint universal lossy coding and identification of stationary mixing sources
The problem of joint universal source coding and modeling, treated in the context of lossless codes by Rissanen, was recently generalized to fixed-rate lossy coding of finitely parametrized continuous-alphabet i.i.d. sources. We extend these results to variable-rate lossy block coding of stationary ergodic sources and show that, for bounded metric distortion measures, any finitely parametrized family of stationary sources satisfying suitable mixing, smoothness and Vapnik-Chervonenkis learnability conditions admits universal schemes for joint lossy source coding and identification. We also give several explicit examples of parametric sources satisfying the regularity conditions.
[ 0.010647578164935112, -0.04713501036167145, -0.006531601771712303, -0.06363498419523239, 0.056592103093862534, -0.0023407505359500647, 0.03246632218360901, 0.038568757474422455, -0.018913203850388527, -0.020008627325296402, -0.0875709131360054, -0.06246339902281761, -0.06189296022057533, -0.02129942551255226, -0.037768200039863586, -0.02591264434158802, -0.03911217302083969, -0.022080203518271446, 0.05328330025076866, -0.13160201907157898, -0.03631272539496422, 0.014788727276027203, -0.0047219302505254745, -0.11457354575395584, 0.06550826877355576, -0.01639690436422825, -0.005755781661719084, -0.03423387557268143, -0.061690591275691986, 0.052966661751270294, -0.06300880759954453, -0.04961633309721947, 0.01618589274585247, 0.08706709742546082, 0.0013985164696350694, 0.0032083659898489714, 0.035517368465662, -0.021429063752293587, -0.04153893142938614, -0.030144743621349335, 0.009593283757567406, -0.016817092895507812, 0.04560107737779617, -0.028883591294288635, 0.01108772587031126, 0.04073459655046463, -0.0066852206364274025, -0.0542331263422966, -0.012006865814328194, -0.024819064885377884, -0.0555175319314003, -0.003854810493066907, 0.042879194021224976, -0.0032095308415591717, -0.014724472537636757, 0.024770261719822884, -0.02829311043024063, 0.036959465593099594, 0.007017832249403, -0.029643356800079346, 0.03426079824566841, 0.11122021079063416, 0.03986514359712601, -0.0615529790520668, 0.006747965235263109, 0.007018544245511293, -0.029669318348169327, 0.04909581318497658, -0.045041218400001526, 0.016929779201745987, 0.04589751735329628, -0.009350351057946682, 0.0509069487452507, -0.05000608414411545, 0.036813076585531235, 0.07584081590175629, 0.002309564035385847, -0.038397226482629776, 0.005580618977546692, 0.11121095716953278, -0.036041248589754105, 0.00972064770758152, -0.11009901762008667, -0.03415315970778465, -0.04799516871571541, 0.04437255859375, -0.05720456689596176, 0.0074685802683234215, 0.003501701867207885, -0.0861576721072197, -0.03785482048988342, -0.03967265039682388, -0.1187109649181366, 0.03719335421919823, -0.03619631007313728, 0.047404222190380096, 0.021787719801068306, 0.03986959531903267, 0.004472901113331318, 0.02448064275085926, 0.04396200180053711, 0.022539643570780754, 0.09947550296783447, 0.054116182029247284, -0.052833590656518936, 0.059482429176568985, -0.04303239285945892, -0.06861289590597153, 0.039897095412015915, 0.02790249139070511, 0.01156676933169365, 0.01687929593026638, 0.00603081937879324, -0.0658564642071724, -0.015763603150844574, 0.05130475014448166, 0.004982825368642807, 0.02848115935921669, 0.0634005069732666, 0.06335703283548355, -0.05098147690296173, 0.04831935837864876, -0.07107746601104736, 0.04169584810733795, 0.07811282575130463, 0.024221094325184822, -0.09090515226125717, 0.014651394449174404, 0.057155679911375046, -0.024949099868535995, -0.009975466877222061, 0.016558147966861725, 0.016406193375587463, -0.013246933929622173, -0.007579548750072718, 0.045375920832157135, 0.007812662981450558, 0.06666234880685806, -0.07726780325174332, -0.0007817338337190449, -0.0035906718112528324, -0.011313684284687042, -0.029066408053040504, 0.07822112739086151, 0.03423505276441574, -0.028852567076683044, -0.04594478756189346, -0.014061499387025833, -0.0023208654019981623, 0.04117707535624504, -0.015145721845328808, -0.0011821836233139038, 0.013632846996188164, 0.049271341413259506, 0.027482420206069946, -0.061140455305576324, 0.040800467133522034, 0.014909789897501469, -0.04000874608755112, 0.037234097719192505, 0.005848436150699854, 0.08537173271179199, 0.08410679548978806, 0.10174497216939926, -0.00659253541380167, -0.06261203438043594, 0.0030011204071342945, -0.02834942378103733, -0.012693637982010841, 0.0031004317570477724, -0.07252872735261917, -0.0379214733839035, -0.008743425831198692, -0.005574854090809822, -0.01902114227414131, 0.029926080256700516, 0.07827772945165634, 0.04331880062818527, -0.023625001311302185, -0.014522669836878777, 0.006695887073874474, -0.014867139048874378, 0.012976017780601978, 0.08170869201421738, -0.004034019540995359, 0.011950839310884476, -0.056646257638931274, 0.021900398656725883, 0.0381619893014431, 0.04050770029425621, -0.013518750667572021, 0.0239876639097929, -0.06010088324546814, 0.018107937648892403, -0.11208944767713547, 0.0349087119102478, -0.05504709109663963, -0.029216226190328598, -0.029031002894043922, 0.09469036012887955, 0.044126659631729126, -0.0400644950568676, 0.015416021458804607, -0.08900436013936996, -0.09320893883705139, 0.047931477427482605, 0.05621083825826645, 0.00026869005523622036, -0.003516068449243903, -0.01095998752862215, -0.0923275426030159, 0.018237484619021416, 0.07590150088071823, -0.07127463817596436, 0.0005474273348227143, -0.0632970929145813, 0.05630706623196602, -0.057733867317438126, -0.02307484857738018, -0.02129766345024109, -0.0453527458012104, 0.07192855328321457, 0.0068247364833951, 0.06334713101387024, 0.018247639760375023, -0.02711469866335392, 0.06684140115976334, 0.055240385234355927, -0.07696059346199036, 0.016734950244426727, -0.0899730697274208, -0.09578989446163177, -0.06282483041286469, -0.05725701525807381, -0.036536891013383865, 0.05330125615000725, -0.050569646060466766, -0.0477544367313385, -0.002209525089710951, -0.01693832129240036, -0.01345663983374834, 0.04623623937368393, 0.030112603679299355, -0.003405223600566387, 0.009376986883580685, 0.005570457316935062, 0.04791076481342316, 0.03597220033407211, 0.021888216957449913, 0.025555457919836044, 0.04371421039104462, -0.026211228221654892, 0.08000996708869934, -0.03624559938907623, 0.0037848204374313354, -0.05469672381877899, 0.02106669545173645, -0.044675249606370926, -0.011622067540884018, 0.04377114772796631, 0.04385685175657272, 0.0072900983504951, -0.030223386362195015, 0.014876659028232098, 0.04774830862879753, 0.020787887275218964, -0.03342803940176964, 0.0085669020190835, 0.06049535796046257, -0.02244001440703869, 0.006500529125332832, -0.08369289338588715, -0.08939487487077713, 0.011531425639986992, -0.04778459295630455, -0.027239909395575523, 0.010531717911362648, -0.013283654116094112, -0.025730090215802193, 0.018322305753827095, -0.0466080941259861, 0.057278186082839966, -0.03870261088013649, -0.039143770933151245, 0.0023326773662120104, -0.013239873573184013, -0.08189702033996582, 0.04924307018518448, 0.001276881550438702, 0.03715064376592636, 0.068909652531147, 0.054145779460668564, -0.0467502661049366, 0.04875711724162102, 0.024109529331326485, 0.009047962725162506, 0.004632658325135708, 0.011840993538498878, 0.0022120641078799963, 0.013733325526118279, 0.001025946345180273, -0.06137674301862717, -0.04623087868094444, 0.0536101795732975, 0.01818721555173397, 0.03934120386838913, 0.0012821450363844633, 0.019966449588537216, -0.017819246277213097, -0.04676390811800957, 0.02388649247586727, 0.05551547184586525, -0.020007407292723656, 0.02645311877131462, 0.009350509382784367, -0.08771147578954697, 0.0290627870708704, 0.01046309806406498, -0.02040005661547184, 0.019222421571612358, 0.05384749174118042, 0.016673056408762932, -0.07984104007482529, 0.015026764944195747, -0.058981023728847504, -0.06169857829809189, -0.06961878389120102, -0.028531737625598907, -0.054226454347372055, 0.031744033098220825, 0.0034751982893794775, 0.01460428535938263, 0.014849765226244926, 0.03644685447216034, 0.06552273780107498, 0.04994482919573784, 0.029537230730056763, -0.01008655782788992, -0.03485601767897606, -0.008839137852191925, -0.018068790435791016, -0.056627046316862106, -0.02073737420141697, -0.03651225566864014, -0.008620072156190872, 0.0200563445687294, 0.08931993693113327, -0.010696947574615479, -0.03987777605652809, 0.012649575248360634, -0.05287151411175728, -0.011665824800729752, -0.04591949284076691, 0.007772977463901043, 0.020780418068170547, -0.01294070202857256, 0.03834517300128937, 0.05875323712825775, 0.04841809347271919, 0.0350269190967083, -0.01425272598862648, 0.005769281182438135, 0.0010653785429894924, -0.0011537796817719936, 0.049926068633794785, 0.06453344225883484, -0.036945901811122894, -0.004202245268970728, -0.017178917303681374, 0.04363231360912323, -0.04885898530483246, 0.09395528584718704, 0.06817135214805603, 0.020939456298947334, 0.028564557433128357, -0.039955984801054, 0.05441934987902641, -0.10768210142850876, -0.00010712923540268093, 0.02358013577759266, -0.06580393016338348, -0.008985410444438457, -0.014638684689998627, -0.02822970040142536, -0.035666026175022125, -0.007672017440199852, 0.01569485105574131, -0.012307446449995041, 0.0234393198043108, 0.027692103758454323, -0.03611794486641884, -0.02273978292942047, -0.04835790395736694, 0.008256692439317703, 0.041599150747060776, 0.011130666360259056, -0.030503781512379646, -0.04098102077841759, -0.01790224015712738, -0.08218397945165634, 0.0008351746364496648, 0.0030974592082202435, -0.057905275374650955, 0.01784711331129074, -0.0675288736820221, -0.020151721313595772, 0.11585532128810883, -0.056283287703990936, 0.027965731918811798, 0.029692696407437325, -0.030977798625826836, -0.00892595574259758, -0.03665618970990181, -0.015939468517899513, 0.0464712418615818, 0.10371597111225128, 0.028401322662830353, 0.027925435453653336, 0.009942878969013691, -0.0025001983158290386, 0.004041601438075304, -0.04077623784542084, -0.04885326325893402, -0.03864261507987976, -0.010657981969416142, 0.03230856731534004, 0.03818826377391815, 0.01130599807947874, -0.021915854886174202, 0.04313964396715164, -0.013094042427837849, -0.08318975567817688, 0.0024708460550755262, 0.016975633800029755, 0.03485831990838051, -0.11562886834144592, 0.023605255410075188, -0.04053708538413048, 0.01766628585755825, 0.015140821225941181, -0.04954979941248894, -0.02822991833090782, -0.009888949804008007, 0.007846490480005741, 0.07803713530302048, 0.018846139311790466, 0.04949643462896347, -0.0008836924098432064, 0.10979285836219788, 0.032021455466747284, 0.01655583269894123, -0.016704916954040527, 0.03333862125873566, 0.03906984627246857, 0.03843517601490021, 0.053403694182634354, -0.03782380372285843, -0.04898970574140549, 0.0881161168217659, -0.052525728940963745, -0.03989458829164505, -0.061028387397527695, 0.023663919419050217, 0.026162926107645035, -0.03773333504796028, 0.056933898478746414, 0.009977246634662151, -0.01537477970123291, 0.04083980247378349, -0.06757000833749771, -0.0359078086912632, 0.020840594545006752, 0.04040670394897461, -0.0247114896774292, 0.007094258442521095, 0.042457178235054016, 0.0049025872722268105, 0.017548421397805214, 0.0337815023958683, -0.01682417467236519, 0.028879009187221527, -0.010992029681801796, -0.002107338048517704, 0.09519800543785095, 0.022887231782078743, 0.0145051134750247, 0.014949260279536247, -0.019813088700175285, 0.01957901380956173, 0.002646432723850012, 0.04922334849834442, 0.04082540422677994, 0.008318306878209114, 0.0002554072707425803, 0.01785912737250328, 0.032840143889188766, -0.005386712029576302, -0.039049163460731506, -0.008548340760171413, 0.04079865664243698, 0.10669731348752975, 0.022189918905496597, -0.023659957572817802, 0.021140236407518387, 0.008510582149028778, 0.0625905841588974, 0.03088679164648056, -0.045412179082632065, -0.057412710040807724, 0.01589951477944851, 0.01823500543832779, 0.024591630324721336 ]
8
8
Supervised Feature Selection via Dependence Estimation
We introduce a framework for filtering features that employs the Hilbert-Schmidt Independence Criterion (HSIC) as a measure of dependence between the features and the labels. The key idea is that good features should maximise such dependence. Feature selection for various supervised learning problems (including classification and regression) is unified under this framework, and the solutions can be approximated using a backward-elimination algorithm. We demonstrate the usefulness of our method on both artificial and real world datasets.
[ 0.03267018869519234, -0.07348192483186722, 0.03964674100279808, 0.004539049230515957, 0.023046335205435753, -0.06033211201429367, -0.07539422810077667, 0.003812363836914301, -0.03798079490661621, 0.030872181057929993, 0.00036915787495672703, -0.018169984221458435, -0.015854232013225555, 0.013894153758883476, -0.010214220732450485, 0.007675863802433014, 0.02672937698662281, -0.06843073666095734, 0.053927380591630936, -0.034597259014844894, -0.015621085651218891, -0.005839483346790075, -0.031773265451192856, -0.05055161938071251, 0.013841909356415272, -0.01254525501281023, -0.012857737019658089, 0.024299217388033867, -0.028257999569177628, -0.008836989291012287, -0.0031917993910610676, 0.021211357787251472, 0.0298631489276886, -0.07291573286056519, 0.015495906583964825, -0.01557873748242855, 0.03931521996855736, 0.009956552647054195, -0.017850754782557487, 0.035112570971250534, 0.021991398185491562, 0.04351784288883209, 0.03767382353544235, -0.009602144360542297, 0.017455609515309334, 0.007464299444109201, 0.05949091911315918, -0.038754433393478394, 0.014587387442588806, 0.001231977716088295, -0.08128036558628082, -0.012187894433736801, -0.050511691719293594, 0.02843886986374855, 0.01823718100786209, 0.00298815849237144, -0.0728873685002327, 0.015328319743275642, 0.05906635522842407, 0.025173813104629517, -0.04310359060764313, 0.06661508232355118, -0.005209669936448336, 0.03430214151740074, -0.014794573187828064, 0.011873848736286163, -0.10173976421356201, -0.052037313580513, -0.0010087190894410014, -0.056962866336107254, -0.01761188544332981, -0.07511293888092041, 0.023624639958143234, 0.020825188606977463, 0.009671425446867943, 0.031143099069595337, 0.010491526685655117, 0.05628150328993797, 0.05619237199425697, 0.10032009333372116, -0.01973697729408741, 0.007352748420089483, 0.0325981006026268, 0.022490113973617554, 0.014484182000160217, -0.03713936731219292, 0.011323900893330574, 0.00399725092574954, 0.07030536234378815, 0.07504212111234665, -0.08309078961610794, 0.030113499611616135, -0.0566738061606884, -0.024761855602264404, -0.011355661787092686, 0.013935706578195095, 0.02576831728219986, 0.02780049666762352, 0.04564385488629341, 0.0069336844608187675, -0.023682894185185432, -0.0075734150595963, 0.07207487523555756, 0.010250771418213844, -0.07917145639657974, 0.040685269981622696, -0.06369049102067947, 0.006531862076371908, -0.03677002713084221, 0.035022132098674774, 0.04880303889513016, 0.012357785366475582, -0.014514178968966007, -0.016939615830779076, -0.05891593545675278, 0.008790213614702225, 0.004484899342060089, 0.0477987565100193, 0.05343589559197426, 0.020321466028690338, -0.03808259963989258, 0.06742843240499496, -0.05084256827831268, 0.03455900028347969, 0.06628737598657608, -0.030220963060855865, -0.019620751962065697, -0.015594113618135452, 0.12147878110408783, -0.006874742452055216, -0.14086389541625977, 0.04026377201080322, -0.0457845963537693, 0.020691005513072014, -0.045416414737701416, 0.05812642723321915, 0.011180252768099308, 0.046766865998506546, -0.03995509818196297, -0.017083479091525078, 0.006979066878557205, -0.042127449065446854, 0.07462846487760544, 0.02434251829981804, -0.035714395344257355, 0.0460796095430851, -0.005282956641167402, 0.002908329712226987, 0.0023111903574317694, 0.03842925652861595, 0.06551648676395416, -0.12113945186138153, 0.016774050891399384, 0.04097559303045273, -0.05905241519212723, -0.04451579973101616, 0.06356173753738403, -0.038017645478248596, -0.02846061810851097, -0.017906486988067627, -0.03205207362771034, 0.042271826416254044, 0.0487130768597126, -0.007116165943443775, -0.0387769378721714, -0.0094863036647439, 0.010210003703832626, -0.06280462443828583, -0.010593995451927185, -0.04818663373589516, -0.09125715494155884, 0.010465369559824467, -0.057737525552511215, 0.03561056777834892, 0.04206138476729393, 0.0033910763449966908, -0.029657404869794846, -0.008087151683866978, -0.025525636970996857, -0.04422865808010101, 0.09057958424091339, -0.032855890691280365, -0.045740433037281036, 0.061332546174526215, 0.05351216718554497, 0.005183119792491198, 0.018943367525935173, 0.05021778121590614, 0.0635865181684494, 0.045921411365270615, 0.01789778843522072, 0.006433242466300726, -0.0040940637700259686, 0.00805848091840744, -0.08488471060991287, 0.000696424045599997, 0.03634754568338394, -0.005956444423645735, 0.03559330850839615, 0.07212907075881958, 0.08052031695842743, 0.006917188875377178, -0.1047104075551033, -0.07425005733966827, -0.06101604551076889, 0.02068721316754818, 0.014814190566539764, -0.054542604833841324, -0.011199183762073517, -0.03718078136444092, -0.02298804186284542, 0.03026864118874073, 0.009200675413012505, -0.008884825743734837, 0.009371601045131683, 0.016875911504030228, -0.021985409781336784, -0.10123912990093231, 0.0345010831952095, 0.04303595796227455, 0.018752863630652428, 0.06589839607477188, -0.004828447010368109, 0.05199725180864334, -0.02068503573536873, 0.036516137421131134, 0.005955914035439491, -0.027171673253178596, -0.0317813940346241, 0.12065243721008301, -0.08669544011354446, -0.03857993707060814, -0.007512794341892004, -0.046204131096601486, 0.007052029948681593, 0.01524890586733818, -0.09180402010679245, -0.018978457897901535, 0.0011512283235788345, -0.01606590487062931, -0.07427103817462921, -0.01383680384606123, -0.006490898318588734, -0.01248999498784542, -0.024959802627563477, -0.049902480095624924, -0.03453272953629494, -0.009296035394072533, -0.02026696316897869, 0.0081456508487463, -0.06806386262178421, -0.01535129640251398, -0.04220505803823471, -0.045121930539608, 0.015816859900951385, 0.016670895740389824, -0.03286754712462425, 0.012315063737332821, 0.05291243642568588, 0.16934175789356232, 0.08330836892127991, 0.08147489279508591, -0.04999855160713196, -0.007859454490244389, 0.06227635592222214, 0.016746794804930687, 0.00932246819138527, 0.03547562286257744, 0.011102056130766869, 0.00804909411817789, -0.09289821982383728, -0.030929433181881905, -0.051221080124378204, 0.05561414733529091, 0.0001458280166843906, 0.06691420823335648, 0.04375425726175308, 0.045461975038051605, 0.022297391667962074, 0.0038544470444321632, -0.060484811663627625, -0.006796280853450298, 0.050181373953819275, 0.0015980156604200602, -0.020233741030097008, 0.005034817382693291, 0.014028336852788925, -0.06134594604372978, -0.011314102448523045, -0.015220019035041332, -0.049711763858795166, 0.10180641710758209, -0.061612796038389206, 0.11324658989906311, 0.02822178602218628, -0.1475498378276825, -0.0027563185431063175, 0.042724426835775375, 0.05101262778043747, 0.08310775458812714, -0.0071436879225075245, 0.04863543435931206, 0.035012293606996536, -0.0032680125441402197, 0.08579812943935394, 0.02006109431385994, 0.02183924801647663, -0.013787718489766121, -0.05711226910352707, -0.009453331120312214, -0.026409992948174477, 0.02289881743490696, -0.07606339454650879, -0.014247570186853409, 0.0074786837212741375, -0.03419242054224014, 0.020199066027998924, 0.018071796745061874, -0.07890839129686356, -0.020855188369750977, 0.015483436174690723, 0.05375441536307335, 0.04286597669124603, -0.04815961793065071, -0.0954744964838028, 0.02448544092476368, 0.0940234512090683, 0.05048343539237976, -0.16671143472194672, 0.005697465036064386, -0.0407613068819046, 0.011268886737525463, -0.006435127928853035, 0.02472505532205105, -0.0275080818682909, 0.04478306695818901, -0.015486557967960835, -0.022175461053848267, -0.0882948786020279, 0.010479273274540901, -0.03418240323662758, -0.09883078187704086, -0.0029862343799322844, -0.0376226082444191, -0.004173831082880497, -0.033989906311035156, 0.05664411187171936, -0.020402608439326286, -0.011360918171703815, 0.034157298505306244, -0.028187736868858337, 0.04009080305695534, -0.0387667678296566, -0.04724505916237831, -0.05120963230729103, 0.022646978497505188, 0.04825717210769653, 0.0003222119703423232, 0.01061276812106371, 0.02116796188056469, -0.025437837466597557, 0.008333759382367134, -0.05639055371284485, 0.048229463398456573, 0.05827685073018074, 0.026149757206439972, -0.059486374258995056, 0.019878916442394257, -0.09867211431264877, 0.005444907117635012, 0.0127705754712224, 0.024614820256829262, 0.03795778378844261, -0.003191328141838312, -0.004086564760655165, -0.01726088486611843, 0.006783653981983662, -0.033089134842157364, -0.04822726547718048, 0.061721816658973694, -0.03725658357143402, -0.020035937428474426, 0.007463047746568918, 0.04463927820324898, 0.009517290629446507, -0.04866264760494232, -0.051974475383758545, 0.0043542212806642056, 0.043307896703481674, -0.013612491078674793, -0.00650014728307724, -0.06703218817710876, -0.019218193367123604, -0.02025013230741024, 0.09801720827817917, 0.02742163836956024, -0.020723603665828705, -0.026692969724535942, 0.039731282740831375, 0.021731948480010033, -0.015729494392871857, 0.0031007209327071905, 0.0645209401845932, -0.08729477971792221, -0.04343107342720032, 0.070443294942379, 0.03340887278318405, 0.0631101056933403, -0.02905249036848545, 0.034831561148166656, -0.0053836083970963955, -0.005269995890557766, -0.041151370853185654, 0.0035942501854151487, -0.00011700018512783572, -0.018288318067789078, -0.04990475997328758, -0.03947308659553528, -0.0174062792211771, -0.0046480814926326275, 0.015796123072504997, 0.03765444457530975, 0.016026629135012627, 0.0018033894011750817, -0.0920582115650177, 0.038704946637153625, -0.020424170419573784, 0.0581514835357666, 0.01622685231268406, 0.05358362942934036, -0.06853532046079636, 0.007901557721197605, -0.04987769573926926, 0.04430245980620384, 0.046851687133312225, 0.034457672387361526, 0.051886655390262604, -0.0003217014018446207, -0.02169322408735752, -0.021249592304229736, -0.06842721998691559, 0.025076841935515404, 0.012308388017117977, 0.027612200006842613, -0.0329483337700367, 0.04323292151093483, -0.005913673900067806, -0.012682775966823101, 0.024955639615654945, -0.04187475144863129, -0.05679355561733246, -0.048250969499349594, 0.02577373757958412, 0.0012518115108832717, 0.01356328185647726, -0.034337274730205536, -0.027611395344138145, -0.005920409224927425, 0.0029068596195429564, -0.02854195609688759, -0.06889920681715012, -0.041132066398859024, 0.00779745914041996, 0.035512205213308334, -0.039653126150369644, 0.01239714864641428, 0.08370239287614822, 0.056091904640197754, 0.05786148086190224, 0.042043715715408325, -0.06708469986915588, 0.022564886137843132, -0.0504257008433342, 0.012572983279824257, 0.05310991033911705, -0.014446242712438107, -0.019058147445321083, -0.010041396133601665, -0.026470525190234184, -0.03368285670876503, -0.0004926653928123415, -0.045954521745443344, 0.04146994650363922, -0.01948549970984459, 0.06118304282426834, 0.09696070849895477, -0.0008749877451919019, -0.007946036756038666, 0.005739331711083651, 0.009668244048953056, 0.017506903037428856, 0.0016614104388281703, -0.027633486315608025, 0.029955698177218437, 0.013933037407696247, -0.02540404349565506, 0.004286275710910559, 0.018848692998290062, 0.023934882134199142, 0.026447147130966187, -0.007443463895469904, 0.02754637412726879, -0.0562526173889637, -0.017518920823931694, 0.07303080707788467, -0.02401033043861389, 0.07091153413057327, -0.013778410851955414, 0.040081143379211426, 0.004110519774258137, -0.0033976666163653135, 0.009359837509691715 ]
9
9
Equivalence of LP Relaxation and Max-Product for Weighted Matching in General Graphs
Max-product belief propagation is a local, iterative algorithm to find the mode/MAP estimate of a probability distribution. While it has been successfully employed in a wide variety of applications, there are relatively few theoretical guarantees of convergence and correctness for general loopy graphs that may have many short cycles. Of these, even fewer provide exact ``necessary and sufficient'' characterizations. In this paper we investigate the problem of using max-product to find the maximum weight matching in an arbitrary graph with edge weights. This is done by first constructing a probability distribution whose mode corresponds to the optimal matching, and then running max-product. Weighted matching can also be posed as an integer program, for which there is an LP relaxation. This relaxation is not always tight. In this paper we show that \begin{enumerate} \item If the LP relaxation is tight, then max-product always converges, and that too to the correct answer. \item If the LP relaxation is loose, then max-product does not converge. \end{enumerate} This provides an exact, data-dependent characterization of max-product performance, and a precise connection to LP relaxation, which is a well-studied optimization technique. Also, since LP relaxation is known to be tight for bipartite graphs, our results generalize other recent results on using max-product to find weighted matchings in bipartite graphs.
[ -0.056374359875917435, -0.0076802936382591724, -0.013179474510252476, -0.032016631215810776, 0.04337222874164581, -0.019710181280970573, 0.024374712258577347, -0.09262936562299728, -0.039843395352363586, 0.026753585785627365, 0.02016287110745907, -0.08178684115409851, 0.01178332045674324, 0.04223902150988579, 0.07419437915086746, -0.01584813743829727, -0.03621203452348709, 0.04638150334358215, 0.015254906378686428, -0.0056211575865745544, 0.047427330166101456, -0.0006509280065074563, -0.0016074696322903037, -0.019737208262085915, -0.017230909317731857, -0.004671139642596245, -0.03511869162321091, -0.00788029283285141, 0.005033352877944708, -0.04315917193889618, -0.10018006712198257, 0.00559131009504199, 0.03263048455119133, 0.028951067477464676, 0.025961821898818016, 0.036519959568977356, 0.02332647144794464, -0.025654498487710953, -0.01951943337917328, -0.009021828882396221, 0.04646266624331474, -0.04263358190655708, 0.018343007192015648, -0.02787928842008114, 0.05400077998638153, -0.012548199854791164, 0.0330946184694767, 0.13267959654331207, -0.00490065012127161, 0.020182665437459946, -0.08492507040500641, 0.05970946326851845, -0.04877835512161255, 0.027647724375128746, 0.012080572545528412, 0.03322282060980797, -0.013668938539922237, 0.013800605200231075, -0.0070167467929422855, 0.031341470777988434, 0.020154360681772232, 0.07437166571617126, -0.09829142689704895, -0.04179781302809715, -0.06608828157186508, -0.02294606901705265, -0.028463095426559448, 0.0057649859227240086, -0.09482385218143463, -0.007256416138261557, -0.014329170808196068, -0.06010883301496506, 0.06430225819349289, 0.04560332000255585, 0.09539031982421875, 0.008125006221234798, -0.03460865467786789, 0.028350189328193665, 0.026406560093164444, 0.0905328318476677, -0.08013821393251419, 0.1005113273859024, -0.02310507744550705, -0.013434239663183689, -0.12617364525794983, -0.026779402047395706, -0.028746340423822403, 0.02250058762729168, -0.07326721400022507, -0.1014661118388176, -0.015035147778689861, 0.060106873512268066, -0.04356328770518303, 0.07462511956691742, -0.05747926980257034, 0.03094310313463211, -0.029523145407438278, 0.018512949347496033, -0.03640672191977501, 0.013388682156801224, -0.08298397809267044, -0.0609637126326561, 0.03197627142071724, 0.010238428600132465, -0.047579746693372726, -0.028665583580732346, 0.0319971963763237, -0.014856296591460705, 0.017184756696224213, -0.01715628243982792, 0.007130709011107683, -0.0449308343231678, -0.028971891850233078, 0.0022675686050206423, -0.04743104428052902, 0.05771690607070923, -0.004862481262534857, 0.05538782477378845, 0.027489934116601944, 0.07078477740287781, -0.017517587170004845, -0.05382184311747551, 0.03514851629734039, 0.032821010798215866, 0.034123342484235764, -0.013595263473689556, 0.012900980189442635, -0.058872953057289124, 0.12034054845571518, -0.0128825344145298, -0.014962385408580303, 0.023369822651147842, -0.04277532547712326, -0.00728921964764595, -0.07902396470308304, 0.035704802721738815, 0.009344623424112797, 0.006052427925169468, 0.020960800349712372, 0.09565715491771698, -0.03689808025956154, -0.021655341610312462, 0.009251609444618225, 0.004839862696826458, 0.034605007618665695, 0.046281713992357254, -0.0421486459672451, 0.054119598120450974, -0.027654947713017464, -0.002863013418391347, 0.01140886265784502, -0.01920335926115513, -0.0045089409686625, 0.03779188171029091, -0.03956487029790878, 0.01948215626180172, -0.04577276483178139, -0.10894522070884705, -0.04692988470196724, 0.0032258224673569202, -0.0517926923930645, -0.019515790045261383, 0.024552274495363235, 0.002322391141206026, -0.0327482745051384, 0.03143114969134331, 0.013949175365269184, -0.000002489126700311317, -0.07804996520280838, -0.046844739466905594, 0.017393840476870537, -0.005159189458936453, -0.040331315249204636, 0.022270189598202705, 0.019346628338098526, -0.07875526696443558, 0.018649928271770477, 0.014829137362539768, 0.0020264950580894947, 0.02466946467757225, 0.0191324632614851, -0.05192205309867859, 0.08720658719539642, -0.019468555226922035, 0.012641068547964096, 0.02961352840065956, 0.04327499493956566, 0.015462556853890419, -0.01611221581697464, 0.09708286076784134, 0.03205479308962822, -0.005426799412816763, -0.005101596005260944, -0.03513156995177269, -0.03541470691561699, -0.018540550023317337, -0.037831321358680725, -0.05228310078382492, 0.008641673251986504, -0.013602602295577526, 0.06706161051988602, -0.06499376147985458, 0.0010762038873508573, -0.08911311626434326, -0.006277946755290031, -0.018175940960645676, 0.05580882728099823, -0.07973936945199966, -0.0348721407353878, -0.032057471573352814, 0.054265428334474564, 0.05478011816740036, -0.0025918385945260525, -0.0006398957339115441, 0.04564589262008667, 0.01198632549494505, 0.0342983640730381, -0.05610673129558563, -0.05942592769861221, -0.013895651325583458, 0.016718365252017975, 0.03328188881278038, 0.008794575929641724, 0.05020030215382576, -0.04498010501265526, -0.009325823746621609, -0.008985232561826706, 0.06956557184457779, -0.027700718492269516, 0.03324543684720993, -0.06144498288631439, -0.008827300742268562, -0.012986971065402031, -0.0023127926979213953, -0.07583127170801163, 0.009496895596385002, -0.05139007046818733, -0.04086064174771309, -0.02962263487279415, -0.0049276091158390045, 0.022553836926817894, 0.030962975695729256, 0.042397867888212204, -0.0720679759979248, 0.01537250354886055, 0.011138379573822021, -0.019054841250181198, 0.045310258865356445, -0.06500739604234695, 0.03229614719748497, 0.01273390930145979, 0.058899763971567154, 0.030094455927610397, 0.01339805219322443, 0.02188144437968731, -0.015216403640806675, 0.032734569162130356, 0.13755525648593903, -0.01609298400580883, 0.0233907587826252, 0.03665979206562042, -0.023431289941072464, -0.09731359779834747, -0.05146057903766632, 0.096696637570858, 0.015060213394463062, 0.037557996809482574, -0.015433237887918949, 0.018979044631123543, -0.00877339392900467, 0.040680285543203354, -0.039801035076379776, -0.07882904261350632, 0.10610974580049515, 0.030207829549908638, -0.04929642379283905, 0.024309348315000534, -0.007858885452151299, -0.04826431721448898, 0.010304269380867481, -0.06853383779525757, 0.016918251290917397, 0.08047085255384445, 0.007938556373119354, 0.009017922915518284, 0.036023661494255066, -0.08011968433856964, -0.0013290669303387403, -0.017400316894054413, 0.04073042795062065, -0.09431690722703934, 0.0022477174643427134, 0.04109214246273041, -0.06719889491796494, 0.08460036665201187, -0.06282713264226913, 0.020825091749429703, 0.002603347646072507, 0.005394103936851025, 0.04474935680627823, -0.05166669934988022, -0.03700823709368706, 0.058008771389722824, -0.048952192068099976, 0.006186939310282469, -0.007530874107033014, 0.019888581708073616, -0.0010733960662037134, -0.06879167258739471, -0.03943178430199623, 0.0064656720496714115, -0.02234446257352829, -0.039929598569869995, -0.03151550143957138, 0.08756435662508011, 0.013992900028824806, -0.11841146647930145, 0.006909295916557312, -0.058615460991859436, 0.05182233825325966, -0.025175791233778, 0.002538754139095545, 0.014287606813013554, 0.0052924794144928455, -0.03885684907436371, -0.07033908367156982, -0.035690322518348694, 0.0254447590559721, -0.029247844591736794, -0.041310060769319534, -0.05406033620238304, 0.043559346348047256, -0.09387177228927612, 0.04717575013637543, -0.01812896877527237, 0.022226084023714066, -0.04670794680714607, -0.008143140934407711, 0.02809634432196617, 0.025503503158688545, -0.037944063544273376, -0.05582541227340698, -0.04959523677825928, -0.03866855055093765, 0.051722511649131775, 0.14270150661468506, 0.0038354273419827223, 0.06943155825138092, -0.013574499636888504, -0.030889401212334633, -0.03197750449180603, 0.0034772122744470835, 0.0382346473634243, 0.045356471091508865, 0.03594827279448509, -0.012675264850258827, 0.07374193519353867, -0.022329339757561684, -0.049998000264167786, 0.05093859136104584, -0.09136153757572174, -0.028361858800053596, 0.06408552080392838, -0.0076666041277348995, 0.021712535992264748, 0.0736052393913269, -0.020532313734292984, -0.015222148969769478, 0.06918445974588394, 0.007947110570967197, -0.030341284349560738, 0.018586887046694756, 0.029958512634038925, -0.01250488217920065, 0.007477183826267719, -0.06522856652736664, 0.03425433114171028, -0.05903526023030281, -0.04267870634794235, 0.03005627915263176, 0.0373169481754303, 0.03596849367022514, -0.0725025087594986, -0.0015436217654496431, -0.024127881973981857, -0.017780840396881104, -0.08687449991703033, -0.007936031557619572, 0.07904570549726486, -0.03198638930916786, 0.03263267129659653, -0.0413106232881546, 0.06321525573730469, 0.04027450829744339, 0.012711279094219208, -0.06590572744607925, 0.03173866495490074, 0.032749783247709274, -0.03234371915459633, -0.05052690953016281, 0.02208939753472805, -0.03215895593166351, -0.005669767502695322, -0.05385372415184975, -0.07009284198284149, 0.015972932800650597, -0.013495475985109806, 0.012098561972379684, -0.04571983218193054, 0.07248824834823608, -0.03452417626976967, 0.03966731205582619, -0.09234648942947388, 0.003113902173936367, -0.0025252506602555513, 0.05174313485622406, 0.007194943260401487, 0.014556868001818657, -0.007350570987910032, -0.062148913741111755, 0.009692035615444183, -0.004769911989569664, -0.04097219929099083, -0.045103251934051514, -0.002480040304362774, -0.0372198149561882, 0.029882539063692093, 0.030812222510576248, 0.025158125907182693, 0.014597265981137753, -0.020030060783028603, -0.034658316522836685, -0.08723309636116028, -0.02277832105755806, -0.01214297953993082, 0.03901237994432449, 0.005386600270867348, -0.009268051013350487, -0.01855255477130413, 0.011096038855612278, 0.004678694531321526, 0.06295108795166016, 0.022342873737215996, -0.01869143359363079, 0.03047231025993824, 0.016445688903331757, 0.045742809772491455, 0.051008764654397964, 0.05234508961439133, 0.028798431158065796, 0.03460065275430679, 0.009984025731682777, -0.03453982621431351, -0.001319038332439959, -0.016101326793432236, 0.013833911158144474, -0.03982718288898468, 0.02320902794599533, 0.046922773122787476, -0.012687215581536293, 0.05509194731712341, -0.03902142122387886, 0.01457278337329626, 0.011472368612885475, -0.021306008100509644, 0.038100745528936386, -0.0319579541683197, 0.03288739547133446, 0.05569886043667793, -0.004093419294804335, -0.0240737646818161, -0.0403464213013649, -0.00015655973402317613, -0.042286552488803864, 0.0018976771971210837, 0.060883358120918274, -0.00956106185913086, -0.04100232571363449, 0.05497187376022339, -0.011560519225895405, 0.01898372545838356, 0.01646101474761963, -0.1137501671910286, -0.04663819819688797, 0.04509713500738144, 0.0742490366101265, -0.03276379778981209, 0.005705431569367647, 0.05350577086210251, 0.004764126613736153, 0.008821903727948666, -0.028833022341132164, 0.008381415158510208, -0.00925934873521328, 0.01993066631257534, 0.06044395640492439, 0.02768855355679989, -0.028568096458911896, 0.03266369551420212, -0.019980551674962044, 0.021751567721366882, -0.06453275680541992, -0.02131262980401516, 0.03115650825202465, 0.08133257180452347, -0.013433245941996574, -0.008853997103869915, 0.019754763692617416, -0.09887675940990448, 0.025104038417339325, -0.064680315554142, 0.02605942264199257 ]
10
10
HMM Speaker Identification Using Linear and Non-linear Merging Techniques
Speaker identification is a powerful, non-invasive and in-expensive biometric technique. The recognition accuracy, however, deteriorates when noise levels affect a specific band of frequency. In this paper, we present a sub-band based speaker identification that intends to improve the live testing performance. Each frequency sub-band is processed and classified independently. We also compare the linear and non-linear merging techniques for the sub-bands recognizer. Support vector machines and Gaussian Mixture models are the non-linear merging techniques that are investigated. Results showed that the sub-band based method used with linear merging techniques enormously improved the performance of the speaker identification over the performance of wide-band recognizers when tested live. A live testing improvement of 9.78% was achieved
[ 0.04140196368098259, -0.021705536171793938, 0.014915305189788342, 0.0132520766928792, -0.004835379775613546, 0.05874268338084221, -0.012666844762861729, -0.010421066544950008, -0.044633906334638596, -0.028446026146411896, -0.01199627760797739, -0.029645651578903198, 0.0037076075095683336, -0.033904220908880234, -0.045455798506736755, 0.005099878646433353, 0.06436579674482346, 0.07937227189540863, 0.0019542996305972338, -0.05422665551304817, -0.0310297179967165, -0.02586156688630581, -0.0007016743766143918, -0.03101043403148651, -0.004444567020982504, 0.08765407651662827, -0.025799477472901344, 0.06299354135990143, -0.041507937014102936, 0.0598880909383297, -0.08820604532957077, -0.04771013930439949, 0.0229802243411541, 0.0005633304244838655, 0.02624497003853321, -0.00840991735458374, 0.07073576748371124, -0.013770779594779015, -0.021081803366541862, 0.025916490703821182, 0.01848980225622654, 0.024595696479082108, 0.08758629113435745, -0.025581492111086845, 0.03957965597510338, -0.017563439905643463, 0.046401817351579666, -0.022007979452610016, 0.05094684287905693, 0.11612799763679504, -0.07358995079994202, -0.018122874200344086, 0.0025868925731629133, 0.017797255888581276, 0.02622099407017231, 0.06252836436033249, 0.0029125106520950794, -0.012264436110854149, 0.024193050339818, 0.022448411211371422, -0.04192301258444786, 0.07290148735046387, -0.01227783877402544, -0.0047788419760763645, -0.03867470100522041, -0.06181104853749275, -0.10097190737724304, 0.0580277256667614, -0.004684995859861374, 0.038214851170778275, -0.046000946313142776, 0.01565380208194256, 0.005697312299162149, -0.002950530732050538, -0.007579220924526453, 0.04521274194121361, -0.028052423149347305, 0.033052247017621994, 0.051254887133836746, 0.04348135367035866, -0.04398577660322189, -0.09213001281023026, 0.03721325099468231, 0.08483978360891342, -0.042834602296352386, -0.021761558949947357, -0.010715470649302006, 0.004420578479766846, 0.035608064383268356, 0.012684454210102558, -0.04058374464511871, 0.0037343103904277086, -0.08096566796302795, 0.004166501108556986, 0.015785718336701393, -0.02874784730374813, 0.020312143489718437, -0.02994312345981598, -0.06296434998512268, 0.01536076795309782, 0.012882178649306297, -0.04005257785320282, 0.07921649515628815, 0.0023587108589708805, -0.05234946683049202, 0.0006158557953312993, -0.021588554605841637, 0.020535273477435112, 0.019984310492873192, -0.019434543326497078, 0.0738999992609024, -0.10122957080602646, 0.050464991480112076, 0.0014601803850382566, -0.038086261600255966, 0.023719072341918945, -0.01017611101269722, 0.024075133726000786, 0.02971791848540306, -0.0013289704220369458, 0.022702021524310112, -0.002705192193388939, -0.020841121673583984, -0.018578246235847473, 0.026384327560663223, -0.0042778258211910725, 0.019459430128335953, -0.08258833736181259, 0.047341424971818924, -0.011850858107209206, -0.18046846985816956, 0.025902925059199333, -0.011454964987933636, 0.04814733937382698, -0.0910552516579628, -0.019233837723731995, 0.0431097187101841, -0.0003243736282456666, -0.09036453813314438, 0.06078913062810898, -0.03879436105489731, -0.03290259838104248, -0.022279152646660805, 0.012256378307938576, 0.08688125014305115, 0.06993728876113892, -0.017518769949674606, -0.04136249050498009, -0.07811300456523895, -0.03705954924225807, -0.013054444454610348, -0.02382294461131096, 0.017256764695048332, 0.008802337571978569, 0.0068565127439796925, -0.07999498397111893, -0.024004850536584854, -0.02562771551311016, 0.006553884129971266, 0.027131114155054092, -0.04605536535382271, 0.00549430213868618, 0.06339475512504578, 0.034025438129901886, -0.03214174136519432, 0.012002001516520977, -0.07373054325580597, -0.006181247532367706, -0.06501366943120956, -0.0318361259996891, -0.11988852918148041, 0.0339125357568264, -0.08396121114492416, 0.0071066259406507015, 0.03836279362440109, -0.04911430925130844, 0.006075871642678976, -0.012417417950928211, -0.077288918197155, 0.042471542954444885, 0.028816161677241325, -0.08820270746946335, 0.04134621471166611, 0.01669652946293354, 0.06492538005113602, 0.0004059251514263451, -0.05418975651264191, -0.003263607621192932, 0.06757353991270065, 0.013923803344368935, 0.06011921167373657, 0.015522011555731297, -0.0018654422601684928, -0.057050805538892746, -0.03056081384420395, 0.04552554711699486, -0.07388066500425339, 0.006878996733576059, 0.05544006824493408, 0.04689069092273712, 0.010707816109061241, -0.04549212008714676, -0.04951082170009613, -0.03569389879703522, 0.013637252151966095, -0.0100443409755826, 0.018552836030721664, -0.020830946043133736, 0.04068343713879585, -0.0134225282818079, 0.09084748476743698, -0.024289563298225403, 0.033352769911289215, -0.02656395547091961, 0.005153503268957138, -0.003956549800932407, -0.05546649172902107, 0.037216123193502426, -0.004416301380842924, 0.081843301653862, 0.02912943623960018, 0.03425239399075508, 0.06044492498040199, 0.02975684404373169, -0.009456711821258068, 0.020595356822013855, 0.06418941915035248, 0.010411524213850498, -0.040967464447021484, 0.06208394467830658, 0.00025682654813863337, -0.07727991044521332, -0.07974617928266525, -0.09345078468322754, -0.02027270756661892, 0.005558354780077934, 0.009520189836621284, -0.04850935935974121, 0.017415599897503853, -0.005411915946751833, 0.03281329572200775, -0.013914250768721104, -0.03747985512018204, -0.013392508029937744, 0.020292533561587334, -0.02856314927339554, -0.03672279790043831, 0.04758770018815994, -0.00045764879905618727, 0.043867673724889755, -0.016349371522665024, -0.01233062893152237, 0.052291903644800186, -0.007469181902706623, 0.0270003080368042, 0.0368930846452713, -0.010869859717786312, -0.05957191437482834, -0.029678435996174812, 0.06673644483089447, 0.01742134429514408, 0.0029775414150208235, -0.017628328874707222, -0.025928253307938576, 0.09729331731796265, -0.039198167622089386, 0.056257184594869614, 0.04810363054275513, 0.018931778147816658, 0.02225557342171669, -0.05141285061836243, -0.0717959925532341, -0.0014260787284001708, 0.0012742311228066683, -0.0053812130354344845, 0.05329792946577072, 0.025941478088498116, 0.045515917241573334, 0.06312520056962967, -0.031931072473526, 0.004292631056159735, 0.05820087715983391, 0.008539841510355473, 0.03487570211291313, 0.047301340848207474, -0.01219705305993557, 0.018761208280920982, 0.024321427568793297, -0.04715137928724289, 0.02638806402683258, 0.00040980923222377896, 0.06420666724443436, -0.079200878739357, -0.006917700171470642, 0.06841041892766953, -0.06673548370599747, -0.007627294864505529, 0.009593515656888485, 0.045273736119270325, -0.028869058936834335, -0.016964256763458252, 0.03256893903017044, 0.07540005445480347, 0.08527599275112152, -0.019908754155039787, 0.022745074704289436, 0.06948652118444443, 0.10254756361246109, 0.05542715638875961, 0.02505185827612877, 0.011523783206939697, -0.008859948255121708, -0.09408237040042877, -0.0901690274477005, -0.009142028167843819, -0.04045351222157478, 0.018386751413345337, 0.01738819293677807, -0.025940781459212303, 0.03483753278851509, 0.04121049493551254, 0.035088397562503815, -0.03919488564133644, -0.0729627013206482, -0.0381130650639534, -0.018854698166251183, -0.09055836498737335, 0.05595867335796356, -0.13897939026355743, -0.0052335262298583984, -0.06918289512395859, 0.07262139767408371, -0.009847443550825119, 0.16079477965831757, 0.028019040822982788, 0.007979278452694416, 0.027758300304412842, 0.0826987773180008, -0.051716189831495285, -0.01703459955751896, -0.013050328008830547, 0.052872974425554276, 0.024385124444961548, 0.01777174323797226, -0.02329171448945999, 0.03775943070650101, 0.044443827122449875, -0.010973915457725525, -0.005186524707823992, 0.020556101575493813, -0.01337447576224804, 0.07086784392595291, 0.06208137050271034, -0.046659428626298904, -0.0006348589668050408, 0.0952504575252533, 0.08363994210958481, -0.019002839922904968, -0.0671946257352829, 0.047537803649902344, -0.005403929390013218, -0.023759854957461357, 0.03205535560846329, 0.038048237562179565, 0.04429209604859352, 0.025745593011379242, -0.02390242926776409, -0.007714858744293451, -0.0017605590401217341, 0.025016644969582558, 0.04648282751441002, -0.010953194461762905, 0.07813604921102524, -0.007556552533060312, 0.02975667640566826, 0.007305582985281944, 0.04065723344683647, -0.06070592626929283, 0.028850007802248, -0.015637986361980438, -0.046131160110235214, 0.0012586230877786875, 0.022023050114512444, 0.054965559393167496, -0.029757481068372726, 0.006406016182154417, 0.04401051625609398, 0.05799451097846031, -0.030894378200173378, -0.01017537247389555, -0.04976651072502136, -0.0613778680562973, -0.061141181737184525, -0.017724601551890373, 0.035538289695978165, 0.004061778541654348, 0.01594376005232334, 0.01342631597071886, 0.01857674866914749, 0.008140364661812782, 0.0021294215694069862, -0.0466594360768795, -0.08842471987009048, -0.034093502908945084, -0.040474385023117065, 0.0011452161706984043, 0.022340696305036545, 0.024097589775919914, -0.036451809108257294, 0.042068079113960266, 0.04713357239961624, 0.04279208183288574, 0.0158220287412405, 0.01908811181783676, -0.04211832210421562, -0.007620215881615877, -0.029720434918999672, -0.029831072315573692, 0.06728045642375946, -0.06060617044568062, -0.0032665207982063293, -0.0033246176317334175, 0.07594329863786697, 0.051499444991350174, -0.03233369439840317, -0.006319664418697357, 0.02400599978864193, -0.022068645805120468, 0.035108063369989395, -0.00781863834708929, -0.12910562753677368, -0.0018686476396396756, -0.015382411889731884, 0.012811786495149136, 0.07067795842885971, 0.026066407561302185, 0.06318419426679611, -0.06037095934152603, -0.0662626177072525, 0.0690060406923294, -0.0689866840839386, -0.06741315126419067, -0.028703905642032623, -0.054209861904382706, -0.024708058685064316, -0.02884690649807453, 0.024851303547620773, -0.014260831288993359, 0.011421184055507183, -0.06153672933578491, 0.0009951533284038305, -0.01707696169614792, 0.01719314232468605, -0.0045483289286494255, 0.010692143812775612, -0.01870707795023918, 0.0009709599544294178, -0.034767407923936844, -0.03260497376322746, -0.047754302620887756, -0.020933130756020546, 0.04229993000626564, 0.00013082713121548295, -0.05617142468690872, -0.020845361053943634, 0.045287124812603, 0.012284894473850727, -0.024763036519289017, -0.011198780499398708, -0.030318908393383026, -0.04271445795893669, 0.005030130036175251, 0.009556630626320839, 0.0010212066117674112, 0.0629076436161995, -0.08627564460039139, 0.01861901581287384, -0.03535402938723564, -0.06872032582759857, -0.021953480318188667, 0.0066983397118747234, 0.015342961996793747, 0.03530292212963104, 0.06793487071990967, 0.026866143569350243, -0.013322978280484676, -0.034849636256694794, 0.011831622570753098, -0.04636964574456215, -0.037887513637542725, -0.0065498361364007, -0.006898156367242336, -0.01792432926595211, 0.02082172781229019, -0.038212742656469345, 0.036105088889598846, -0.029770392924547195, -0.03696715831756592, 0.03455236926674843, -0.06293902546167374, 0.05601734668016434, -0.0028302755672484636, -0.014095043763518333, 0.003995381761342287, 0.012140986509621143, 0.03679331764578819, 0.06120675057172775, -0.02201593853533268, -0.031189553439617157, 0.046450551599264145, -0.024213947355747223, -0.058901891112327576 ]
11
11
Statistical Mechanics of Nonlinear On-line Learning for Ensemble Teachers
We analyze the generalization performance of a student in a model composed of nonlinear perceptrons: a true teacher, ensemble teachers, and the student. We calculate the generalization error of the student analytically or numerically using statistical mechanics in the framework of on-line learning. We treat two well-known learning rules: Hebbian learning and perceptron learning. As a result, it is proven that the nonlinear model shows qualitatively different behaviors from the linear model. Moreover, it is clarified that Hebbian learning and perceptron learning show qualitatively different behaviors from each other. In Hebbian learning, we can analytically obtain the solutions. In this case, the generalization error monotonically decreases. The steady value of the generalization error is independent of the learning rate. The larger the number of teachers is and the more variety the ensemble teachers have, the smaller the generalization error is. In perceptron learning, we have to numerically obtain the solutions. In this case, the dynamical behaviors of the generalization error are non-monotonic. The smaller the learning rate is, the larger the number of teachers is; and the more variety the ensemble teachers have, the smaller the minimum value of the generalization error is.
[ -0.010856063105165958, -0.01992439664900303, 0.02881038561463356, -0.05488922819495201, 0.030243555083870888, -0.09898140281438828, 0.038973912596702576, -0.022214705124497414, -0.008795983158051968, -0.006761724129319191, -0.01707472652196884, 0.06610669195652008, 0.04525532200932503, 0.02151227928698063, 0.0799928829073906, -0.023623554036021233, 0.07010864466428757, 0.005882239900529385, -0.039881471544504166, 0.003554368857294321, 0.013319098390638828, -0.0022934547159820795, 0.05262060463428497, -0.08829651027917862, 0.07795896381139755, 0.027438342571258545, 0.0011593173258006573, 0.025896135717630386, -0.013716768473386765, -0.04065414518117905, -0.050785988569259644, 0.014892023988068104, -0.03467562422156334, 0.019386403262615204, 0.045247554779052734, -0.06458257883787155, 0.08414139598608017, 0.008250342682003975, 0.020537270233035088, 0.04549732804298401, 0.0051395888440310955, -0.07341957092285156, 0.048215799033641815, -0.07522175461053848, 0.05360671877861023, -0.04890492558479309, 0.021668462082743645, -0.03399226814508438, 0.047515708953142166, 0.047479115426540375, 0.0054151457734405994, 0.01925262250006199, -0.04182097315788269, 0.009677959606051445, -0.03825102746486664, -0.010374186560511589, -0.03324533998966217, -0.03262101858854294, -0.07341326028108597, -0.03492972254753113, 0.0009107050718739629, 0.03818409517407417, 0.004783898126333952, -0.012989654205739498, 0.023868057876825333, 0.029063237830996513, -0.08216707408428192, -0.026009362190961838, -0.0074584102258086205, 0.011028493754565716, 0.06389191746711731, 0.0021185611840337515, 0.04306289926171303, 0.06673883646726608, 0.06839808076620102, -0.08345842361450195, -0.09384582191705704, -0.0396115779876709, 0.08789637684822083, 0.005935259163379669, -0.04547283425927162, -0.01565103977918625, 0.03027082420885563, 0.08469217270612717, 0.004459248390048742, -0.028513124212622643, 0.004747137892991304, 0.01564526930451393, -0.014093698933720589, 0.0016353331739082932, -0.03017001785337925, 0.025470463559031487, -0.05410030856728554, 0.008043167181313038, 0.02822769433259964, -0.0027879492845386267, -0.023767642676830292, -0.09581059962511063, 0.021105840802192688, -0.036653947085142136, 0.04213652014732361, 0.016556259244680405, 0.0005317648174241185, 0.07607690244913101, 0.016967706382274628, 0.07171351462602615, -0.028316712006926537, 0.0499921515583992, 0.005750150885432959, 0.058901239186525345, 0.04715326055884361, 0.009492134675383568, 0.05933213606476784, 0.04293690249323845, 0.008788961917161942, 0.04393093287944794, -0.018445681780576706, 0.10230574756860733, 0.08866073936223984, -0.005358667578548193, 0.005404376890510321, 0.01794850453734398, -0.09060561656951904, 0.008989056572318077, 0.05601184070110321, -0.04958631098270416, 0.03676844760775566, -0.0614783801138401, 0.05790138989686966, -0.036163344979286194, -0.03884032368659973, 0.03221002221107483, 0.05162705481052399, -0.039469532668590546, 0.03243338316679001, 0.019046589732170105, 0.003274151822552085, -0.03202618286013603, -0.07699526101350784, -0.012671791948378086, -0.0036703713703900576, 0.0044622342102229595, -0.022387130185961723, 0.036213140934705734, 0.039017241448163986, 0.06522150337696075, 0.005564534105360508, -0.014308974146842957, 0.0688871443271637, -0.025150181725621223, 0.06648512184619904, -0.04603774845600128, 0.06053856015205383, 0.0070351953618228436, 0.045336563140153885, -0.06599371135234833, -0.042596496641635895, 0.07916073501110077, 0.04590551182627678, 0.024558210745453835, -0.028503401204943657, -0.060759536921978, -0.033609021455049515, 0.03479797765612602, -0.003967182710766792, -0.007739772088825703, -0.020997287705540657, -0.021520419046282768, -0.05139509215950966, -0.022583313286304474, -0.03864350914955139, -0.000825141672976315, 0.0012705704430118203, -0.041131433099508286, -0.05086053907871246, -0.04506581649184227, 0.031609658151865005, 0.05166875198483467, -0.002653051633387804, -0.004717821720987558, 0.07319153100252151, -0.06534726172685623, 0.0028402444440871477, 0.0082959970459342, 0.0544910654425621, 0.05498184263706207, -0.013464822433888912, 0.10139576345682144, -0.00424585398286581, -0.024530809372663498, 0.0606185644865036, -0.011900977231562138, -0.04107212647795677, 0.0017438132781535387, 0.03518727049231529, -0.02262638695538044, -0.03617871552705765, 0.01930074393749237, 0.0806584283709526, 0.07216385006904602, 0.05594199523329735, -0.029008662328124046, -0.0060192858800292015, -0.02821422554552555, -0.01834934577345848, 0.10551387816667557, 0.041730090975761414, -0.06937038153409958, -0.09190075844526291, 0.049814458936452866, -0.004458582494407892, 0.001258028787560761, -0.046690572053194046, 0.02771729975938797, -0.028537482023239136, -0.06982826441526413, -0.01728595606982708, -0.019536344334483147, 0.04988871514797211, 0.026962634176015854, -0.051435861736536026, 0.03971204534173012, -0.016897596418857574, 0.027842175215482712, -0.004342891275882721, -0.007232997100800276, 0.038210149854421616, 0.040716689079999924, -0.054038155823946, -0.022258562967181206, -0.08323530107736588, -0.04196657985448837, -0.039317741990089417, -0.006101786624640226, 0.040875401347875595, 0.05882859230041504, -0.08793678134679794, 0.013212714344263077, -0.013200969435274601, -0.00680119264870882, -0.01588267646729946, 0.018066784366965294, -0.010227374732494354, -0.01996704190969467, -0.013816190883517265, -0.07271812856197357, 0.018852662295103073, -0.006316218059509993, -0.0717029795050621, -0.08105012774467468, 0.010649074800312519, 0.031152738258242607, -0.006730394437909126, -0.0028860217425972223, -0.006575135514140129, 0.02211848273873329, -0.040896154940128326, -0.011040047742426395, -0.06927327066659927, 0.038108304142951965, -0.022534392774105072, 0.007739442866295576, -0.009406710043549538, -0.01421025488525629, 0.09148120880126953, -0.0012513126712292433, -0.06507688760757446, 0.031668297946453094, -0.021725855767726898, 0.03045598603785038, 0.026756346225738525, -0.04528043791651726, -0.049988679587841034, 0.03346738964319229, -0.04938867315649986, -0.018497208133339882, 0.03427986800670624, -0.011979751288890839, 0.07501782476902008, 0.01309885922819376, -0.026231342926621437, 0.0216783806681633, -0.046838708221912384, 0.019789911806583405, -0.04011121764779091, 0.003222487401217222, 0.06922347098588943, 0.03514226898550987, 0.03403790667653084, 0.054428890347480774, 0.01882641389966011, 0.025394322350621223, -0.048768021166324615, 0.008471464738249779, 0.021574124693870544, -0.07060812413692474, 0.02051457390189171, -0.03490370512008667, -0.023001303896307945, -0.0451028048992157, 0.048816557973623276, 0.031609173864126205, 0.0016866468358784914, -0.0285516194999218, 0.08256461471319199, 0.03949727863073349, -0.046579860150814056, 0.07495582103729248, -0.0309611726552248, 0.0033350849989801645, 0.08395732194185257, -0.10069095343351364, -0.03603257238864899, -0.01487212534993887, 0.020653193816542625, 0.019930565729737282, -0.10748229920864105, -0.028277317062020302, -0.017114482820034027, 0.008487810380756855, -0.0005484722787514329, -0.021983547136187553, -0.016323506832122803, -0.039108023047447205, -0.05284997448325157, 0.05385667458176613, 0.06452920287847519, 0.060401998460292816, -0.10447423160076141, 0.09665371477603912, -0.04136602580547333, -0.04066615179181099, -0.00022967063705436885, 0.06964961439371109, -0.0021239062771201134, 0.050185348838567734, -0.09633702039718628, -0.044441621750593185, -0.014215363189578056, 0.0811997577548027, -0.054397862404584885, -0.05305840075016022, 0.006967870984226465, -0.015839874744415283, -0.02689175121486187, 0.08404096215963364, 0.09299704432487488, -0.02074100263416767, -0.01844404637813568, 0.010839128866791725, 0.018481619656085968, -0.025966113433241844, -0.03229643031954765, 0.031887587159872055, -0.05477243289351463, 0.0007304609753191471, -0.0012124268105253577, 0.04696441441774368, 0.009085600264370441, 0.02975163236260414, -0.07103048264980316, 0.0812353566288948, -0.01715291291475296, -0.04770048335194588, 0.03870426118373871, 0.023269636556506157, 0.013678356073796749, 0.009163851849734783, -0.03242529183626175, -0.008172393776476383, -0.008598514832556248, -0.034377336502075195, 0.06598573178052902, 0.003366179997101426, -0.019243435934185982, -0.009693033993244171, 0.02145257405936718, -0.035889070481061935, -0.0013818745501339436, 0.06284473836421967, -0.050909373909235, 0.00022269973123911768, -0.01455257460474968, 0.07751770317554474, -0.04564865678548813, -0.024581344798207283, 0.018311936408281326, 0.003515636082738638, 0.04432858154177666, -0.06493163108825684, -0.04827241599559784, -0.04733423888683319, 0.0015216924948617816, 0.02203317917883396, 0.037298791110515594, 0.002990946639329195, 0.11527656018733978, -0.004491340834647417, -0.044470980763435364, 0.05904750898480415, -0.018605833873152733, -0.009176543913781643, 0.003556163515895605, -0.03891788795590401, -0.0444478914141655, -0.01992197521030903, 0.06932751089334488, 0.049300674349069595, 0.05186019837856293, 0.022937195375561714, 0.0681062713265419, 0.057461582124233246, -0.013418547809123993, -0.06631684303283691, -0.029391564428806305, 0.04258450120687485, 0.04454194754362106, -0.0033834793139249086, -0.025419073179364204, -0.08090056478977203, 0.06444786489009857, 0.05949373170733452, 0.0877331793308258, 0.041852373629808426, 0.004239149857312441, 0.03343115374445915, 0.056506507098674774, 0.0353284515440464, 0.05593511462211609, 0.025901826098561287, -0.05439175292849541, 0.001860849792137742, -0.0856173187494278, 0.018860159441828728, 0.01549726352095604, -0.0436602383852005, 0.01390421949326992, -0.04497638717293739, -0.01459494698792696, -0.05936149135231972, -0.031401149928569794, 0.01979970373213291, -0.006624388042837381, -0.011714503169059753, 0.014718065038323402, 0.09312310069799423, 0.04176745563745499, 0.003181362757459283, 0.08548465371131897, -0.008280046284198761, 0.042080432176589966, -0.016287337988615036, -0.027825720608234406, -0.06454034149646759, 0.004957163706421852, -0.03136622905731201, 0.005233425181359053, -0.027464060112833977, -0.0029079494997859, -0.003616705071181059, -0.029617376625537872, -0.006599785294383764, 0.003841330064460635, 0.010753867216408253, -0.1001250147819519, -0.06608682870864868, 0.03255731239914894, -0.008619957603514194, 0.023885268718004227, -0.010801157914102077, -0.030700286850333214, 0.020624902099370956, 0.014907367527484894, -0.04994502663612366, -0.020395034924149513, 0.07760277390480042, 0.028263606131076813, -0.035764314234256744, 0.04368607699871063, 0.009845202788710594, -0.014602091163396835, 0.04120207950472832, -0.06637245416641235, 0.15797698497772217, 0.03858267888426781, 0.01091173104941845, -0.043111223727464676, 0.07231179624795914, 0.05507369711995125, 0.05156383290886879, 0.00743128452450037, 0.013976529240608215, 0.017948323860764503, -0.013837713748216629, -0.028652187436819077, -0.008590064011514187, 0.0109620476141572, 0.00021572152036242187, -0.05271787568926811, 0.017076805233955383, 0.0338531918823719, 0.026801127940416336, 0.07035394757986069, 0.021273596212267876, 0.010910602286458015, 0.04523037001490593, 0.06764134764671326, -0.040403105318546295, 0.014802975580096245, -0.02092345803976059, -0.006485122721642256, 0.020397622138261795 ]
12
12
On the monotonization of the training set
We consider the problem of minimal correction of the training set to make it consistent with monotonic constraints. This problem arises during analysis of data sets via techniques that require monotone data. We show that this problem is NP-hard in general and is equivalent to finding a maximal independent set in special orgraphs. Practically important cases of that problem considered in detail. These are the cases when a partial order given on the replies set is a total order or has a dimension 2. We show that the second case can be reduced to maximization of a quadratic convex function on a convex set. For this case we construct an approximate polynomial algorithm based on convex optimization.
[ -0.04858744144439697, -0.013560586608946323, 0.06409855931997299, -0.0820610299706459, 0.03786415234208107, -0.005556214600801468, 0.01695830747485161, -0.03273327648639679, -0.0425533652305603, -0.0295061394572258, 0.00886557437479496, -0.01329678762704134, -0.04541435465216637, 0.03534726798534393, -0.000893238524440676, 0.0075382268987596035, -0.08907242864370346, 0.023111769929528236, -0.0420353040099144, -0.03969747945666313, 0.030771905556321144, -0.009599483571946621, -0.014590972103178501, -0.007075844332575798, -0.005400975700467825, -0.028127435594797134, -0.002866978757083416, 0.001568452687934041, -0.009425529278814793, -0.029002711176872253, 0.022042710334062576, 0.019328396767377853, -0.02845793403685093, -0.003343078773468733, -0.00932280346751213, -0.014250299893319607, 0.03217168524861336, 0.011104462668299675, 0.02304597571492195, -0.030947815626859665, 0.06511512398719788, 0.01990535296499729, 0.020131992176175117, -0.04160921648144722, 0.04572324454784393, -0.04321089759469032, 0.026572760194540024, -0.08349399268627167, -0.08954747021198273, 0.09504007548093796, -0.011961052194237709, 0.0655139908194542, -0.06688542664051056, -0.004862910136580467, -0.0017993319779634476, 0.03840451315045357, 0.013747635297477245, 0.009574170224368572, -0.053133927285671234, -0.05858657881617546, 0.03133060410618782, 0.08984920382499695, -0.012958087958395481, -0.02890956774353981, -0.047781236469745636, -0.027146078646183014, -0.041835129261016846, -0.031285837292671204, 0.03905189037322998, -0.019139401614665985, 0.03649896755814552, -0.06864915043115616, 0.03664383292198181, 0.027778973802924156, -0.008545231074094772, -0.04044905677437782, -0.02970295585691929, 0.04504303261637688, 0.014379190281033516, 0.07017936557531357, -0.07455030083656311, 0.03538408502936363, 0.00013047973334323615, 0.0850900411605835, -0.062330473214387894, 0.005748770199716091, 0.019652381539344788, 0.03001873940229416, -0.014075664803385735, -0.013458972796797752, 0.0022791812662035227, 0.06449025124311447, -0.06343886256217957, 0.08260627090930939, -0.020161034539341927, -0.000617629149928689, -0.062158070504665375, -0.027099275961518288, -0.07720164954662323, 0.06304123997688293, 0.03704115003347397, -0.005013452842831612, -0.046231940388679504, 0.02015504240989685, -0.056275852024555206, -0.025572268292307854, -0.07202985137701035, -0.014737250283360481, 0.048167966306209564, -0.08169151097536087, -0.016735097393393517, -0.02809644676744938, 0.04935721307992935, 0.03596564382314682, -0.04941548779606819, 0.024878036230802536, -0.02268812246620655, 0.07363461703062057, 0.007782961707562208, 0.020162183791399002, -0.04914596676826477, -0.05163342505693436, 0.040928035974502563, 0.0008790497668087482, 0.036329347640275955, -0.07007350027561188, -0.00015292635362129658, -0.0532270185649395, 0.07900306582450867, 0.07337552309036255, 0.009570017457008362, 0.07618626207113266, 0.05403872951865196, -0.08067291229963303, -0.06463184952735901, 0.10355244576931, -0.011345962062478065, -0.0031440849415957928, -0.008251919411122799, 0.02218984253704548, 0.025855816900730133, -0.062338296324014664, -0.015997998416423798, -0.0075024571269750595, 0.04048427566885948, 0.06007051095366478, -0.013369626365602016, -0.024105237796902657, 0.005031373351812363, 0.016481474041938782, -0.01293960027396679, -0.02060556784272194, 0.10637293756008148, 0.025574425235390663, 0.03479978069663048, -0.029477013275027275, 0.005956835579127073, -0.057560574263334274, -0.04928596690297127, 0.007327971048653126, 0.002764479024335742, -0.061931904405355453, 0.08737194538116455, 0.05778402090072632, -0.057752154767513275, -0.05623410642147064, 0.037836283445358276, -0.014761180616915226, -0.020206496119499207, 0.021907441318035126, 0.03485991433262825, -0.022318193688988686, -0.0004663557920139283, 0.08616796135902405, 0.0497310534119606, 0.034363701939582825, 0.02719188667833805, 0.07599233090877533, -0.03194120153784752, -0.01050331350415945, 0.05368943512439728, 0.012455706484615803, 0.020121335983276367, 0.05970268324017525, 0.024898791685700417, 0.03062623180449009, 0.01036868430674076, 0.0438833050429821, 0.09036384522914886, -0.016205403953790665, 0.08379162847995758, -0.08880525082349777, 0.03242054954171181, 0.06086156144738197, -0.014050285331904888, -0.04460582137107849, -0.07501120865345001, 0.02007199265062809, 0.015214482322335243, 0.04375946521759033, -0.006447839550673962, 0.009456134401261806, 0.037466030567884445, 0.0049081724137067795, -0.0458047054708004, -0.008193315006792545, 0.0013323803432285786, -0.0845579132437706, -0.05294707790017128, -0.05536404252052307, 0.02436242252588272, 0.01346638984978199, -0.04966394230723381, -0.018621761351823807, -0.032132457941770554, 0.0007959888316690922, 0.007136791944503784, -0.05920726805925369, 0.10515940189361572, -0.014449340291321278, 0.02357199601829052, 0.02034055069088936, -0.04596738889813423, -0.013192415237426758, -0.05713718384504318, 0.01297282986342907, 0.06147236004471779, -0.0007819703314453363, -0.03880903869867325, 0.006976792123168707, -0.08434735238552094, -0.017506645992398262, -0.037056393921375275, 0.037509601563215256, -0.015341711230576038, -0.004897048231214285, 0.034836672246456146, -0.012648389674723148, -0.10861663520336151, -0.04108094424009323, 0.009338495321571827, -0.05884777754545212, -0.0067166611552238464, 0.009582712315022945, 0.026234259828925133, -0.03329968824982643, 0.060192618519067764, 0.04445008933544159, -0.012373127974569798, -0.06946736574172974, -0.010299604386091232, 0.04848119989037514, 0.01026503462344408, 0.021295353770256042, 0.034086741507053375, -0.0515439510345459, -0.03429153934121132, 0.06011221185326576, 0.015241000801324844, 0.05726125091314316, -0.0017760624177753925, 0.034973256289958954, -0.07169881463050842, -0.002898293314501643, 0.016662614420056343, 0.03904528170824051, -0.027569685131311417, -0.009557655081152916, 0.012239361181855202, 0.052001822739839554, 0.06371406465768814, -0.04441950470209122, -0.016305483877658844, 0.055421292781829834, -0.023573152720928192, 0.04260943830013275, 0.02925151027739048, 0.04311171919107437, 0.03628493845462799, 0.020966997370123863, -0.0939883142709732, -0.010863165371119976, 0.003698283340781927, 0.024201050400733948, -0.04192952811717987, 0.02468930371105671, 0.06024429574608803, -0.03791721910238266, -0.01013666857033968, 0.035009317100048065, -0.05109703540802002, -0.005091887898743153, 0.0536041297018528, -0.017233682796359062, 0.008988969959318638, -0.019979659467935562, 0.03423386067152023, 0.02929193526506424, -0.003298515221104026, -0.007844780571758747, 0.036597780883312225, -0.027335675433278084, -0.011164502240717411, 0.03772227093577385, 0.04960091784596443, -0.013782770372927189, 0.09750111401081085, 0.02090453915297985, -0.03772680461406708, -0.06501000374555588, -0.04652465507388115, -0.027956292033195496, 0.011152300983667374, 0.014362135902047157, 0.014751000329852104, -0.009462619200348854, -0.014709319919347763, 0.005393044091761112, -0.03228691592812538, -0.027816390618681908, -0.024769866839051247, 0.07068252563476562, 0.03596581891179085, 0.03397052735090256, -0.06235887110233307, -0.008870919235050678, 0.0012897431151941419, -0.03280092775821686, -0.10757682472467422, -0.0123667661100626, -0.05213964730501175, 0.014348060823976994, -0.026831038296222687, 0.0880831629037857, -0.03141289949417114, 0.03400781378149986, -0.14143162965774536, -0.08011751621961594, -0.02842545695602894, 0.01572263054549694, -0.09797047823667526, -0.1078704223036766, 0.00005367515404941514, -0.03668271005153656, 0.09958850592374802, -0.014339759945869446, -0.007372019812464714, 0.08297018706798553, 0.03073969855904579, 0.016447966918349266, -0.06638330966234207, -0.04990432783961296, 0.011082482524216175, 0.050807371735572815, 0.015350034460425377, -0.007768551353365183, 0.03916812688112259, -0.040473293513059616, 0.007177939172834158, -0.016227353364229202, -0.07364916801452637, 0.031304772943258286, 0.02126879245042801, 0.0029902292881160975, -0.018997173756361008, 0.007847867906093597, -0.008148172870278358, -0.030788961797952652, -0.007173916790634394, -0.03758656606078148, -0.06840837746858597, 0.002779065165668726, -0.032588548958301544, -0.006860679015517235, 0.01066041924059391, 0.029894333332777023, 0.061824437230825424, -0.05520797148346901, -0.03546863794326782, 0.021339284256100655, -0.037678323686122894, -0.009173708036541939, -0.008536633104085922, 0.034982699900865555, 0.01666870154440403, -0.010694798082113266, -0.01995573192834854, -0.03841176629066467, 0.09877514839172363, -0.03942173719406128, 0.00587939377874136, -0.029713544994592667, -0.0374312549829483, -0.04708734527230263, 0.026090428233146667, -0.046857547014951706, -0.006139755714684725, -0.008254474960267544, -0.0553414560854435, -0.0069260247983038425, 0.058812279254198074, -0.08538704365491867, -0.012977583333849907, -0.09709475189447403, -0.023689649999141693, -0.03264709189534187, -0.0011310704285278916, 0.0619720034301281, 0.022905323654413223, 0.011813996359705925, -0.003548606298863888, 0.1008673682808876, -0.041417695581912994, 0.0785563513636589, -0.006698848679661751, 0.05709291622042656, 0.04834889993071556, 0.021839722990989685, 0.023340975865721703, -0.0016434190329164267, 0.05847756564617157, -0.044844336807727814, -0.013684999197721481, -0.06203661486506462, 0.024744266644120216, -0.07767236232757568, -0.026526661589741707, 0.044055838137865067, -0.08057824522256851, 0.011220009066164494, -0.09896082431077957, 0.020524663850665092, -0.028910797089338303, 0.014642108231782913, -0.036576658487319946, 0.024086536839604378, -0.017034556716680527, -0.028957506641745567, -0.011506564915180206, 0.011799534782767296, -0.041329555213451385, 0.059027936309576035, 0.007556750904768705, 0.011849627830088139, 0.003222860861569643, 0.020298020914196968, 0.026577003300189972, -0.02140781469643116, 0.024608874693512917, 0.004048546776175499, -0.012451034970581532, 0.010589064098894596, -0.010549959726631641, -0.05196404084563255, 0.0028641480021178722, 0.0008119086269289255, -0.030223356559872627, -0.04332669451832771, 0.025224871933460236, -0.08536797761917114, -0.0021184440702199936, -0.03987191617488861, 0.013924618251621723, -0.019665606319904327, -0.1114608570933342, -0.026843978092074394, -0.054862841963768005, 0.08703986555337906, 0.058409035205841064, 0.006300379056483507, -0.0743599459528923, -0.007369025144726038, -0.04453368857502937, 0.010905841365456581, -0.052779652178287506, 0.012599623762071133, 0.0016329264035448432, -0.05276242643594742, 0.02646288461983204, 0.01865929365158081, -0.01826968975365162, 0.005642950534820557, -0.010492140427231789, 0.032985057681798935, 0.08276524394750595, 0.013336289674043655, -0.07430590689182281, 0.057588811963796616, 0.07351724058389664, 0.0835331380367279, -0.05153421685099602, 0.03194404020905495, 0.06834406405687332, 0.023616276681423187, -0.04063764214515686, 0.007078193128108978, 0.08914320170879364, -0.03762992471456528, -0.00866029504686594, 0.055827848613262177, 0.013462799601256847, 0.046936340630054474, 0.02716691605746746, 0.04408550634980202, 0.0788755938410759, 0.1001029908657074, 0.07929269224405289, 0.03568197786808014, -0.030510805547237396, 0.04161134734749794, -0.018011372536420822, 0.008929206989705563 ]
13
13
Mixed membership stochastic blockmodels
Observations consisting of measurements on relationships for pairs of objects arise in many settings, such as protein interaction and gene regulatory networks, collections of author-recipient email, and social networks. Analyzing such data with probabilisic models can be delicate because the simple exchangeability assumptions underlying many boilerplate models no longer hold. In this paper, we describe a latent variable model of such data called the mixed membership stochastic blockmodel. This model extends blockmodels for relational data to ones which capture mixed membership latent relational structure, thus providing an object-specific low-dimensional representation. We develop a general variational inference algorithm for fast approximate posterior inference. We explore applications to social and protein interaction networks.
[ -0.010635217651724815, -0.12391140311956406, -0.027093473821878433, 0.029961083084344864, 0.022392822429537773, 0.0160419549793005, 0.023574991151690483, -0.037614114582538605, -0.0023610107600688934, 0.012157514691352844, -0.04679384455084801, -0.027782265096902847, -0.015148505568504333, 0.03262677043676376, 0.001474721939302981, 0.0019138760399073362, -0.05497368797659874, -0.03266994282603264, 0.015421226620674133, -0.029840387403964996, 0.003972642123699188, 0.00408039428293705, -0.0345754474401474, -0.026974011212587357, 0.0024630422703921795, -0.04640786349773407, -0.003227959154173732, -0.048010822385549545, 0.047707121819257736, -0.026384985074400902, -0.02928195148706436, -0.059213053435087204, 0.014487873762845993, 0.022328954190015793, 0.004764674697071314, -0.05639555677771568, -0.007266867905855179, -0.009015107527375221, -0.02477707341313362, 0.02370281331241131, 0.02829657308757305, -0.06375161558389664, 0.046883244067430496, -0.0375298336148262, -0.006831795908510685, -0.002036492107436061, -0.04861144721508026, 0.030718738213181496, -0.030790405347943306, 0.04446842893958092, -0.16420908272266388, -0.0044730245135724545, 0.017938736826181412, 0.05164559930562973, -0.06167766824364662, -0.01890006847679615, -0.022136496379971504, -0.009681912139058113, -0.024007610976696014, -0.008875624276697636, 0.05622341111302376, 0.008759735152125359, -0.07110630720853806, 0.00733434921130538, -0.05245650187134743, 0.10326938331127167, -0.020133929327130318, 0.011414198204874992, 0.023078415542840958, 0.0594448484480381, -0.05580578371882439, -0.043056368827819824, 0.018154816702008247, 0.06648658215999603, 0.021906545385718346, 0.029510904103517532, -0.021397003903985023, -0.0211658775806427, 0.07132302224636078, 0.02784232795238495, -0.07557392865419388, 0.022072376683354378, -0.021275406703352928, -0.04700415953993797, -0.052062682807445526, 0.013997894711792469, 0.043020494282245636, -0.06324518471956253, -0.010265279561281204, 0.0005040554678998888, 0.03245869278907776, 0.009893993847072124, -0.07341509312391281, 0.07079146057367325, -0.033337101340293884, -0.02885674498975277, 0.0033498702105134726, 0.03740614652633667, 0.015418351627886295, -0.058832328766584396, 0.037451501935720444, -0.05285998806357384, 0.0030932242516428232, 0.025674689561128616, -0.019524168223142624, -0.006486423779278994, -0.009371114894747734, 0.0749874860048294, 0.012438747100532055, -0.05115007609128952, 0.032417766749858856, -0.008687262423336506, 0.04784611612558365, 0.061705708503723145, -0.04297345131635666, 0.12771755456924438, 0.03869747370481491, 0.06691122055053711, -0.056543778628110886, 0.01235215738415718, 0.031903039664030075, 0.0012356649385765195, -0.08047661930322647, 0.00810716487467289, -0.015577291138470173, -0.04570602625608444, -0.09097377955913544, -0.0365731455385685, 0.046567633748054504, -0.057035110890865326, -0.040193699300289154, 0.013347516767680645, -0.009491102769970894, -0.07906851917505264, -0.01751878671348095, 0.02629292756319046, -0.048070624470710754, -0.036116793751716614, -0.051777273416519165, 0.014854125678539276, -0.0002611618547234684, -0.030456209555268288, -0.02601521648466587, -0.026418060064315796, 0.049395687878131866, 0.07227703183889389, -0.046587079763412476, 0.03854573145508766, -0.047642942517995834, 0.021727249026298523, -0.07556937634944916, -0.017261138185858727, -0.002976006595417857, -0.016701653599739075, 0.025783928111195564, -0.07747511565685272, -0.08296412974596024, 0.023289674893021584, -0.020029425621032715, 0.07691685855388641, -0.08445756137371063, 0.029972881078720093, 0.04508771747350693, -0.010389621369540691, -0.010385558940470219, 0.11077554523944855, -0.053226061165332794, -0.04178140312433243, 0.04029694199562073, 0.027031369507312775, -0.026397114619612694, 0.016064047813415527, 0.017146950587630272, 0.009115003049373627, 0.04172881692647934, 0.0038305374328047037, -0.05309716984629631, 0.025433721020817757, -0.03240693360567093, 0.03609197586774826, 0.016402846202254295, -0.06451128423213959, 0.010390917770564556, 0.05520966649055481, 0.010955088771879673, 0.07983813434839249, 0.006445958279073238, -0.010064943693578243, 0.04626002535223961, -0.03495030477643013, 0.021880803629755974, 0.057618897408246994, 0.011050021275877953, -0.00893449503928423, -0.03951798379421234, -0.014927247539162636, 0.030972061678767204, -0.03611418604850769, -0.0432264469563961, 0.030664315447211266, 0.007342097815126181, -0.0334322527050972, 0.004913769196718931, -0.03394496068358421, -0.020250972360372543, -0.011755996383726597, 0.01653883047401905, -0.05392074212431908, 0.015814736485481262, 0.06742289662361145, 0.02816184237599373, 0.008721478283405304, 0.017761558294296265, -0.0575827993452549, 0.008391148410737514, -0.07396327704191208, -0.01029505766928196, -0.07288086414337158, -0.02141709066927433, 0.05705632269382477, -0.050631046295166016, 0.11555201560258865, -0.0026918798685073853, -0.010223295539617538, -0.09499117732048035, -0.03491436690092087, 0.0027656147722154856, 0.014319146052002907, -0.08946900814771652, -0.03829221427440643, -0.060490939766168594, -0.06067512556910515, -0.07313299924135208, 0.024764567613601685, -0.01456355769187212, -0.007800981402397156, -0.09152930974960327, -0.043019916862249374, 0.02744113840162754, 0.039483442902565, -0.026492347940802574, 0.0432034432888031, 0.04426279664039612, -0.023524055257439613, -0.007763653062283993, -0.07346457242965698, 0.03397965803742409, 0.045603808015584946, -0.012102563865482807, -0.04064512997865677, 0.009219854138791561, -0.020071420818567276, -0.04484845697879791, 0.03348064422607422, 0.07615990936756134, -0.02209176868200302, 0.0038261408917605877, 0.06590338796377182, -0.03172248229384422, 0.019528303295373917, 0.03510111942887306, -0.009831962175667286, -0.028169706463813782, -0.004150299355387688, 0.08186992257833481, -0.006272908300161362, 0.03724193945527077, 0.03251019865274429, 0.05383685976266861, -0.05807997286319733, 0.004714293405413628, -0.05451573431491852, -0.03668386489152908, 0.01054559089243412, -0.062344990670681, -0.028826024383306503, -0.014734317548573017, 0.08219212293624878, -0.026424312964081764, -0.06690199673175812, -0.02615303359925747, 0.055064186453819275, 0.01081879436969757, 0.0036820159293711185, -0.04340549185872078, 0.009664143435657024, 0.05670548602938652, 0.05638206750154495, 0.023865723982453346, 0.004238281864672899, -0.04913157597184181, -0.0022071097046136856, -0.09682610630989075, 0.024432970210909843, 0.07206963747739792, -0.044657908380031586, 0.0136171979829669, -0.00018294162873644382, 0.07763486355543137, -0.051165346056222916, 0.010173515416681767, 0.002246253890916705, 0.08115158975124359, 0.008117767050862312, 0.004648948088288307, 0.04218236356973648, 0.047279465943574905, 0.07592456042766571, -0.006443398538976908, -0.030514657497406006, -0.03013366274535656, -0.034861065447330475, -0.04700738564133644, -0.008803343400359154, 0.02196533791720867, -0.04235513135790825, -0.03162936493754387, -0.03453429788351059, -0.05526287108659744, -0.066554956138134, 0.0117481779307127, -0.019145941361784935, 0.031008435413241386, -0.07056399434804916, -0.06489407271146774, -0.026604508981108665, -0.0031376935075968504, 0.006644417066127062, -0.014980624429881573, 0.0555841363966465, -0.07221079617738724, 0.0019970866851508617, 0.004574825521558523, 0.10110572725534439, -0.013153031468391418, 0.018129995092749596, -0.015177233144640923, -0.03795655816793442, 0.040628932416439056, 0.008447263389825821, -0.06261657923460007, -0.0878705307841301, 0.0438096821308136, 0.006619523279368877, -0.021414916962385178, 0.0968737080693245, 0.11938220262527466, -0.007870773784816265, 0.06279648095369339, 0.02270616963505745, -0.016758417710661888, 0.11218822747468948, -0.030365314334630966, 0.04467754438519478, -0.012806989252567291, 0.04055561497807503, 0.019899562001228333, 0.021284403279423714, 0.01477774791419506, 0.017633037641644478, 0.038862235844135284, -0.044278260320425034, -0.0049476707354187965, -0.015783850103616714, 0.06522262841463089, 0.03714631125330925, -0.023448554798960686, 0.0343274362385273, -0.021114978939294815, -0.012437463738024235, 0.08513351529836655, 0.007327741477638483, -0.04489489272236824, 0.056130025535821915, 0.013471673242747784, -0.062465496361255646, 0.0386909618973732, -0.06608801335096359, 0.024478159844875336, 0.07682140916585922, 0.03210845962166786, -0.03349153324961662, -0.005912950728088617, -0.02468223124742508, -0.03315444663167, -0.06840696930885315, 0.020762503147125244, 0.047657012939453125, 0.06326102465391159, -0.04381593316793442, -0.05583314597606659, 0.05924578383564949, 0.00082085479516536, -0.0007951455190777779, 0.024699809029698372, 0.007056994829326868, -0.0379822812974453, -0.0021291079465299845, -0.0436856783926487, -0.008975418284535408, -0.005081733223050833, -0.0401565283536911, 0.014779926277697086, -0.03500021994113922, -0.017704512923955917, -0.01300045382231474, -0.06298881769180298, 0.005492297001183033, -0.02437405101954937, 0.06630212068557739, -0.025365406647324562, 0.0042259530164301395, -0.047336395829916, 0.008767249993979931, -0.005745369475334883, -0.04665113985538483, 0.06379394233226776, 0.03195726498961449, -0.004715030547231436, 0.008593819104135036, -0.011865782551467419, 0.00809725932776928, -0.04519378021359444, -0.005108329933136702, -0.03448210284113884, -0.036697905510663986, 0.05207530036568642, 0.018974319100379944, 0.008990558795630932, -0.03611544147133827, 0.003912683110684156, 0.000953224312979728, -0.06339303404092789, -0.005927641876041889, 0.04941701516509056, 0.02624417096376419, -0.012639868073165417, -0.06773072481155396, 0.06688812375068665, 0.06161787733435631, -0.0008967266185209155, -0.0363677553832531, -0.01216136571019888, -0.0027925053145736456, 0.0827643945813179, 0.014461809769272804, 0.07253319770097733, 0.03750303015112877, 0.09852507710456848, 0.012419741600751877, 0.02828420326113701, 0.036262936890125275, 0.011564193293452263, 0.0013445165241137147, -0.04953507333993912, 0.02402520924806595, -0.04114801064133644, 0.009135585278272629, 0.0659133791923523, -0.07466596364974976, -0.02443220466375351, -0.03636495769023895, 0.01896326057612896, 0.01601279526948929, -0.062448374927043915, -0.025928257033228874, 0.07054603099822998, 0.024285579100251198, 0.10120048373937607, -0.039407748728990555, -0.015696469694375992, -0.027447810396552086, 0.0462653711438179, -0.056342583149671555, -0.0689534842967987, 0.08466099947690964, 0.044620171189308167, -0.009251700714230537, 0.011110812425613403, -0.0564752072095871, 0.08112215250730515, 0.06936349719762802, 0.029644545167684555, 0.0554228350520134, 0.009315687231719494, 0.0912134200334549, -0.022325726225972176, 0.010264863260090351, 0.003944543190300465, 0.03158141300082207, 0.0933568924665451, -0.03735274821519852, -0.02181687392294407, 0.0641138106584549, 0.010696003213524818, 0.0372626967728138, -0.0026249440852552652, 0.048339296132326126, 0.0353640541434288, 0.01360317599028349, 0.06907348334789276, 0.01624075137078762, 0.04686301201581955, 0.009422305971384048, 0.06996913999319077, 0.0953366607427597, 0.05694212764501572, -0.021921716630458832, -0.07248355448246002, 0.0036227942910045385, -0.044978294521570206, -0.02271171472966671 ]
14
14
Loop corrections for message passing algorithms in continuous variable models
In this paper we derive the equations for Loop Corrected Belief Propagation on a continuous variable Gaussian model. Using the exactness of the averages for belief propagation for Gaussian models, a different way of obtaining the covariances is found, based on Belief Propagation on cavity graphs. We discuss the relation of this loop correction algorithm to Expectation Propagation algorithms for the case in which the model is no longer Gaussian, but slightly perturbed by nonlinear terms.
[ 0.027709653601050377, -0.0420418344438076, -0.015427921898663044, -0.056565072387456894, 0.05065685138106346, -0.025232547894120216, -0.018157295882701874, -0.08670108020305634, 0.04084661230444908, 0.0015837979735806584, 0.03177899122238159, -0.0766133964061737, 0.025673821568489075, 0.01929818093776703, 0.09742076694965363, -0.05415051057934761, 0.024693435057997704, 0.08070504665374756, 0.0781327560544014, -0.07272577285766602, 0.007575290277600288, -0.046695880591869354, -0.030438104644417763, -0.06228010356426239, 0.05168997123837471, 0.031252555549144745, 0.012537790462374687, 0.0007265442400239408, 0.004926210734993219, -0.0523809939622879, -0.15268859267234802, 0.03239581361413002, -0.031778037548065186, 0.03529307246208191, 0.037054941058158875, 0.02023559994995594, -0.0281766839325428, 0.004014577716588974, -0.001211974653415382, 0.036306120455265045, 0.04779477044939995, -0.013002082705497742, 0.025803638622164726, -0.037309251725673676, 0.05202340707182884, 0.01820896565914154, 0.08174333721399307, 0.05410029739141464, -0.05239572376012802, 0.0008665074128657579, -0.03970816731452942, 0.008575938642024994, 0.003438869956880808, -0.007853241637349129, -0.029106318950653076, -0.004450890235602856, 0.01885252259671688, -0.0003240480145905167, -0.05287828668951988, -0.024678438901901245, 0.03345490247011185, 0.049926482141017914, -0.06029338389635086, -0.058689702302217484, -0.06833959370851517, 0.04162131994962692, -0.012125985696911812, 0.013426394201815128, -0.03428391367197037, 0.008130201138556004, 0.058594077825546265, 0.005259941332042217, 0.03712070360779762, 0.035518135875463486, 0.032875820994377136, -0.0359862744808197, -0.026192938908934593, -0.01005689799785614, 0.01454751193523407, 0.10628911852836609, -0.07218463718891144, 0.041340239346027374, 0.0033141274470835924, 0.04871389642357826, -0.04513532668352127, -0.014809302985668182, 0.01264280453324318, 0.006903187837451696, -0.011989738792181015, -0.030557170510292053, 0.03633855655789375, 0.04379730671644211, -0.030247163027524948, 0.11579778790473938, -0.05418829247355461, 0.03559139743447304, -0.016755402088165283, -0.009008950553834438, -0.030877212062478065, -0.04743601754307747, -0.0733778327703476, 0.021363290026783943, -0.03341647982597351, 0.04764143005013466, -0.0692983865737915, -0.03602593019604683, 0.035410068929195404, 0.014127989299595356, 0.0045689670369029045, -0.05928201228380203, 0.02483416721224785, -0.029924070462584496, -0.04768981784582138, -0.04184126853942871, -0.06998913735151291, 0.026860574260354042, 0.043883319944143295, 0.1199704185128212, 0.02151748165488243, 0.018177445977926254, 0.014459974132478237, -0.04192369058728218, -0.029615705832839012, 0.034961849451065063, 0.02655866928398609, -0.07799360901117325, 0.016437841579318047, -0.09098070859909058, 0.08586478978395462, -0.0468512661755085, 0.00248902989551425, -0.036928411573171616, 0.015422883443534374, -0.05955038592219353, -0.10735437273979187, 0.052738163620233536, -0.002130428794771433, -0.06112280860543251, -0.046801891177892685, 0.02743963897228241, -0.06214448809623718, -0.012960126623511314, -0.021945418789982796, 0.03424663096666336, 0.06334120035171509, 0.06509426981210709, 0.023694338276982307, 0.006508377380669117, -0.018295928835868835, -0.010745060630142689, 0.027345366775989532, 0.045448146760463715, -0.008020607754588127, 0.029226291924715042, 0.014773090369999409, -0.020652756094932556, -0.027548402547836304, 0.008570825681090355, -0.019140753895044327, 0.053263694047927856, -0.004761353135108948, 0.016355201601982117, 0.0162705909460783, 0.03358165919780731, -0.05461915582418442, 0.0072404430247843266, -0.0515914186835289, 0.02040954865515232, -0.07737848162651062, -0.022230790928006172, 0.029657032340765, 0.007628760766237974, 0.07832550257444382, 0.024228427559137344, 0.04779994487762451, 0.031607042998075485, 0.006477735936641693, 0.015519317239522934, 0.026355383917689323, -0.011632181704044342, 0.06172482296824455, -0.01626325398683548, 0.05193769931793213, -0.002248273929581046, 0.07464085519313812, 0.0003316035436000675, 0.008890141732990742, 0.020851681008934975, 0.005039686802774668, 0.02429317496716976, 0.054603178054094315, 0.06983283907175064, -0.033705875277519226, -0.031981460750103, -0.02796047553420067, 0.04687385633587837, 0.006793655455112457, -0.02641611360013485, -0.0030632687266916037, 0.026913383975625038, 0.06868703663349152, 0.04597379267215729, -0.022102033719420433, -0.04122572019696236, -0.0018471609801054, 0.0021678628399968147, -0.005938746500760317, -0.07654859870672226, -0.009139812551438808, -0.01193894911557436, -0.04515531659126282, 0.026623183861374855, -0.012337788939476013, -0.05222339555621147, -0.0014829097781330347, -0.0921844094991684, -0.001319507253356278, -0.08417608588933945, -0.027928955852985382, -0.016996990889310837, 0.01465807855129242, 0.010950512252748013, 0.04072045907378197, 0.0014079222455620766, -0.06542335450649261, -0.027051692828536034, -0.04482877254486084, -0.001109044998884201, -0.045694585889577866, 0.03326941281557083, -0.07155859470367432, -0.004788666032254696, 0.020732281729578972, 0.02277723141014576, -0.02325914427638054, 0.07281448692083359, -0.07078760117292404, 0.0021696181502193213, -0.05591881275177002, 0.002941044745966792, -0.08211573213338852, 0.059484027326107025, 0.009153764694929123, 0.007343682460486889, 0.033617693930864334, -0.03926949203014374, -0.020428495481610298, 0.05800092965364456, -0.027527444064617157, 0.07130458205938339, -0.027234381064772606, 0.06574131548404694, -0.07122431695461273, -0.031195154413580894, 0.014202114194631577, -0.003300847951322794, -0.06740269064903259, 0.055172111839056015, 0.047359030693769455, 0.019321942701935768, -0.034482087939977646, 0.005560998804867268, -0.018147775903344154, 0.0037013287656009197, 0.14722494781017303, -0.012226935476064682, -0.023042628541588783, 0.014195989817380905, -0.03301786631345749, 0.022276869043707848, 0.03973991796374321, -0.06216425448656082, -0.03561868146061897, 0.09803116321563721, 0.013372437097132206, -0.02080497331917286, 0.007636573631316423, 0.02853778563439846, -0.0006793627399019897, -0.007363048382103443, -0.035660870373249054, 0.008374381810426712, -0.004215390887111425, -0.05629679933190346, 0.004947284702211618, -0.018814817070961, -0.01894787885248661, 0.009313899092376232, 0.023571869358420372, -0.006102246697992086, -0.030805625021457672, -0.04148745536804199, 0.06476720422506332, 0.013327104039490223, -0.05045376345515251, -0.12489382922649384, 0.0394798219203949, -0.05547013506293297, -0.046991996467113495, 0.004309133626520634, 0.06269115209579468, 0.031023327261209488, 0.02286354824900627, -0.08390478044748306, 0.001875607413239777, 0.02497134916484356, 0.025678953155875206, 0.03861505910754204, -0.022387756034731865, 0.02637576125562191, 0.06604580581188202, -0.07240191102027893, -0.06362757831811905, 0.07392026484012604, 0.01380203291773796, 0.04573091119527817, -0.012243840843439102, -0.02993086352944374, -0.10269986093044281, -0.03317485377192497, -0.09199689328670502, -0.01492379978299141, 0.007639664690941572, 0.0020601775031536818, -0.014102728106081486, 0.020495997741818428, 0.016149282455444336, 0.04927787184715271, -0.029116811230778694, 0.01076448429375887, -0.06397227197885513, 0.021995332092046738, -0.04605740308761597, 0.08372557908296585, -0.06103626638650894, 0.05873678997159004, -0.05298934876918793, 0.03066924400627613, 0.07390934973955154, 0.0022937976755201817, 0.047238852828741074, -0.03620854765176773, 0.056109149008989334, 0.026567377150058746, 0.056709472090005875, 0.07081533223390579, 0.07780037075281143, -0.046038515865802765, -0.03475037217140198, -0.006841039750725031, 0.011181863024830818, 0.02457205206155777, -0.01411890797317028, 0.0018466577166691422, 0.037532635033130646, 0.06890179216861725, 0.02903580106794834, 0.017342111095786095, -0.03198425844311714, 0.03179219365119934, -0.07769215106964111, 0.08226232975721359, 0.04829414188861847, -0.03083130531013012, 0.013029118999838829, 0.006438856478780508, -0.0369584821164608, -0.025879498571157455, 0.0347900353372097, 0.003760666586458683, -0.056702908128499985, -0.01863955333828926, 0.06941209733486176, 0.04270053654909134, 0.04171106964349747, -0.010771448723971844, 0.09416013956069946, -0.016100972890853882, -0.027358321473002434, 0.040379904210567474, 0.03214966878294945, -0.021316872909665108, -0.045650776475667953, -0.04609386622905731, -0.008819700218737125, -0.0732235535979271, -0.013474399223923683, 0.01830456219613552, 0.07115892320871353, -0.016160909086465836, 0.002208941150456667, -0.029326267540454865, 0.06850531697273254, 0.016792666167020798, 0.016430668532848358, -0.04733512923121452, 0.02843618579208851, 0.04524846747517586, -0.012567936442792416, -0.05342533439397812, -0.0011628065258264542, -0.04658437892794609, 0.05847952514886856, -0.0393279492855072, -0.02485019341111183, -0.03362424671649933, -0.002845990238711238, 0.0055718026123940945, 0.056073375046253204, 0.1054397001862526, -0.029655085876584053, 0.031523171812295914, -0.00010951693548122421, 0.01143204141408205, 0.0073145669884979725, 0.08732109516859055, 0.0005280471523292363, 0.06135663390159607, -0.010030319914221764, -0.004691293463110924, 0.03769718110561371, 0.028614848852157593, -0.014792160131037235, 0.07350257784128189, 0.027470814064145088, 0.03147515654563904, 0.09153081476688385, 0.07032772898674011, -0.01866886019706726, 0.0397939495742321, -0.06681311130523682, 0.013601134531199932, -0.01783408783376217, 0.030163023620843887, 0.04270682483911514, -0.04665848985314369, -0.016282396391034126, 0.016325730830430984, 0.011445730924606323, -0.013837512582540512, 0.00951717421412468, -0.033191777765750885, -0.07606019824743271, 0.02629852667450905, 0.037775784730911255, 0.057486794888973236, 0.04331841319799423, -0.009555066004395485, 0.04145316779613495, 0.05353187397122383, -0.03288339078426361, 0.026979058980941772, -0.0647699162364006, -0.04618050158023834, -0.04814581573009491, 0.011259995400905609, 0.02881104312837124, 0.022898616269230843, 0.04356430843472481, 0.004425247199833393, 0.0857996866106987, -0.05779159069061279, -0.07549212127923965, -0.04201512411236763, -0.09052589535713196, 0.029426265507936478, -0.02231077291071415, -0.047977518290281296, 0.05820471793413162, -0.04868975654244423, -0.06750917434692383, -0.006852316204458475, -0.03182317689061165, -0.0578753687441349, -0.014588228426873684, 0.028128184378147125, 0.06660278141498566, 0.016577275469899178, 0.024495122954249382, 0.008097057230770588, 0.025729037821292877, -0.00021321457461453974, -0.08114205300807953, 0.03044368512928486, -0.022929105907678604, 0.04472297430038452, 0.03509049862623215, 0.07121484726667404, 0.03872503340244293, 0.0025185502599924803, 0.043638717383146286, 0.028509775176644325, -0.03683706745505333, -0.0126198036596179, 0.08175495266914368, 0.08710081875324249, -0.022270267829298973, 0.004241100512444973, 0.021418152377009392, 0.012501338496804237, -0.01139769796282053, -0.03679952025413513, 0.020593609660863876, 0.01842666231095791, 0.02945135533809662, 0.04237697273492813, 0.022786732763051987, -0.04707243666052818, -0.10135146975517273, 0.008953562937676907, -0.04067447409033775, -0.012558158487081528 ]
15
15
A Novel Model of Working Set Selection for SMO Decomposition Methods
In the process of training Support Vector Machines (SVMs) by decomposition methods, working set selection is an important technique, and some exciting schemes were employed into this field. To improve working set selection, we propose a new model for working set selection in sequential minimal optimization (SMO) decomposition methods. In this model, it selects B as working set without reselection. Some properties are given by simple proof, and experiments demonstrate that the proposed method is in general faster than existing methods.
[ 0.0366675965487957, -0.02453489787876606, -0.05348540097475052, 0.041742775589227676, 0.039725832641124725, -0.03781064227223396, -0.018007103353738785, 0.0075327493250370026, -0.05861390009522438, -0.018344063311815262, 0.019964702427387238, 0.019907502457499504, -0.06637956202030182, 0.0276274885982275, -0.031580038368701935, 0.005169996060431004, -0.0374021902680397, 0.011391746811568737, 0.02122195065021515, -0.07924608141183853, -0.009109394624829292, 0.026835905387997627, 0.06980818510055542, 0.0243676770478487, -0.0016172637697309256, 0.01510094478726387, -0.012695708312094212, -0.06564094871282578, 0.06943482160568237, 0.019587442278862, -0.07188158482313156, -0.03210461139678955, -0.001371523248963058, -0.013970298692584038, 0.010608849115669727, -0.04944544658064842, -0.010451494716107845, -0.008629852905869484, 0.005272579379379749, -0.06690552830696106, -0.034495607018470764, -0.025097856298089027, -0.017839651554822922, -0.0017119728727266192, 0.046695414930582047, 0.024964680895209312, 0.07396712899208069, 0.027521446347236633, -0.032882582396268845, 0.06614333391189575, 0.06503704190254211, 0.030101167038083076, -0.03903062269091606, 0.011453640647232533, -0.0026813214644789696, 0.022343987599015236, -0.04783107712864876, 0.019648747518658638, 0.03913439065217972, -0.11680584400892258, 0.060224585235118866, 0.07549714297056198, 0.048165664076805115, -0.002021373948082328, -0.016889017075300217, -0.002145785139873624, -0.04066050425171852, -0.07418912649154663, -0.038498517125844955, -0.007141841109842062, 0.015553340315818787, -0.11208967864513397, 0.0076089114882051945, -0.017150789499282837, 0.04624537378549576, 0.007503919303417206, 0.04344939813017845, 0.04485877603292465, 0.01519298367202282, 0.06268621981143951, -0.015565305016934872, 0.029775545001029968, 0.044559407979249954, 0.10213564336299896, -0.0283400546759367, 0.011090880259871483, -0.006062159314751625, 0.010023731738328934, 0.03870053216814995, -0.008509458042681217, -0.0017732285195961595, 0.036409590393304825, -0.07214958220720291, 0.04019249603152275, -0.059680040925741196, 0.007128449156880379, -0.024882372468709946, 0.060592975467443466, -0.019756976515054703, 0.016559073701500893, -0.0014195465482771397, -0.02047210931777954, -0.020168133080005646, 0.08175111562013626, -0.08716418594121933, -0.00491105392575264, -0.02896469458937645, 0.04465484991669655, 0.004827053286135197, 0.022257205098867416, -0.0005498625687323511, 0.0021003391593694687, 0.07034268975257874, 0.00018440499843563884, -0.02989841066300869, 0.039128437638282776, 0.008904866874217987, 0.05098194256424904, 0.008055433630943298, -0.04671015962958336, -0.004869487602263689, 0.030428064987063408, 0.008810307830572128, 0.012887482531368732, 0.03144637495279312, -0.06516110897064209, 0.01429914589971304, -0.014439285732805729, 0.10484350472688675, 0.014473125338554382, -0.10615379363298416, -0.022017143666744232, -0.04670366644859314, 0.01605616696178913, -0.0713912695646286, 0.026439672335982323, 0.09159621596336365, -0.05666721239686012, -0.031096510589122772, 0.07924561202526093, -0.02028699591755867, -0.010996843688189983, -0.03484733775258064, 0.004438899457454681, -0.03789062798023224, -0.013647617772221565, 0.025818107649683952, 0.02081066183745861, -0.05236053466796875, 0.03522002696990967, -0.04478238895535469, -0.0005849942681379616, 0.07246312499046326, 0.015343652106821537, 0.02970808930695057, -0.017166059464216232, 0.0006186513346619904, -0.06037600338459015, -0.045891016721725464, 0.06659600138664246, -0.02254335954785347, -0.01158247608691454, 0.06920158118009567, 0.03167068958282471, -0.006161376368254423, -0.032484862953424454, -0.01915714517235756, 0.034799881279468536, -0.033952075988054276, -0.03919316828250885, -0.046794019639492035, 0.02651839517056942, -0.021824534982442856, -0.03810625523328781, 0.10148311406373978, 0.032276224344968796, 0.027921291068196297, 0.09090100228786469, -0.03649535030126572, 0.023513728752732277, 0.010832305066287518, 0.0058129820972681046, 0.036932867020368576, -0.0049653504975140095, 0.013828568160533905, 0.06710655242204666, 0.0035610890481621027, 0.09658244997262955, 0.058204811066389084, 0.026936540380120277, 0.006136275362223387, 0.044816408306360245, 0.06917869299650192, -0.005246030166745186, -0.04570232331752777, -0.028670530766248703, -0.013399547897279263, 0.05115695670247078, 0.04824452847242355, 0.056950923055410385, 0.01033071894198656, 0.03345535323023796, 0.06836795061826706, -0.03999289125204086, -0.06186739727854729, -0.057733360677957535, 0.10040701180696487, 0.008650033734738827, 0.08263476192951202, -0.025351807475090027, 0.021731888875365257, 0.009954522363841534, -0.020037870854139328, -0.012454085983335972, 0.0069740163162350655, -0.037812333554029465, 0.02151172049343586, -0.07162155956029892, 0.02300531044602394, 0.06121131032705307, -0.01668981835246086, 0.06933386623859406, -0.01885979063808918, 0.06686727702617645, -0.031824443489313126, -0.012916392646729946, 0.044183507561683655, -0.029273346066474915, -0.12307891249656677, 0.047796644270420074, -0.015237424522638321, -0.08441107720136642, -0.07438816130161285, 0.05341063067317009, -0.0140278534963727, 0.011749320663511753, -0.0280118640512228, -0.10011813044548035, 0.025814441964030266, -0.045488230884075165, -0.005882006138563156, -0.0014361446956172585, -0.02832542173564434, -0.003868749598041177, 0.04173584654927254, -0.06951738893985748, -0.004623623564839363, 0.03378171846270561, -0.07215440273284912, -0.006110891234129667, 0.005195416044443846, 0.04239695891737938, -0.048315420746803284, 0.007973133586347103, 0.034366145730018616, -0.041012346744537354, -0.030362946912646294, 0.08119137585163116, 0.008139435201883316, 0.08041581511497498, 0.07195620983839035, 0.03640451282262802, -0.046212147921323776, -0.0226423479616642, 0.07922619581222534, -0.011681685224175453, -0.027311956509947777, 0.014883149415254593, 0.02840772271156311, -0.003680784022435546, -0.03625229001045227, -0.01892654225230217, -0.007935118861496449, 0.050862476229667664, -0.05136974900960922, 0.04214365407824516, 0.06761360913515091, 0.07391491532325745, 0.018601274117827415, -0.019811438396573067, -0.032246463000774384, 0.018039343878626823, 0.029708897694945335, -0.030834855511784554, -0.03053530678153038, -0.032402701675891876, -0.002551697427406907, 0.0032776971347630024, -0.04341468587517738, 0.020636141300201416, -0.03997347876429558, 0.07379930466413498, -0.03914034366607666, 0.007299869321286678, 0.04894830659031868, -0.020870978012681007, 0.03808138519525528, 0.0408143512904644, 0.030532030388712883, 0.00999811664223671, 0.0698326975107193, 0.022308504208922386, 0.01906239241361618, -0.010000383481383324, 0.00524234538897872, 0.039021868258714676, 0.07721329480409622, 0.020992498844861984, 0.011361651122570038, 0.044896047562360764, -0.04595198854804039, -0.011194941587746143, 0.005411303602159023, -0.13379307091236115, -0.02918916754424572, -0.09575030207633972, 0.0009392432402819395, -0.08197799324989319, -0.0056870076805353165, 0.013411459513008595, 0.06722333282232285, 0.027542276307940483, 0.029176484793424606, 0.03841342031955719, -0.08053067326545715, -0.010191981680691242, -0.047846242785453796, 0.04393400251865387, -0.04188002273440361, -0.003122161841019988, -0.054676350206136703, 0.004746914375573397, -0.0006353558273985982, 0.0728692039847374, 0.01625662110745907, -0.05370752513408661, 0.03686116263270378, -0.030882257968187332, 0.03331172838807106, -0.051976773887872696, -0.09726894646883011, -0.07219947129487991, 0.014434939250349998, -0.04431324824690819, 0.01706254668533802, 0.03045978769659996, 0.07717886567115784, 0.016605520620942116, 0.029313556849956512, 0.01630515791475773, -0.04767131432890892, 0.0206851027905941, 0.0056258803233504295, 0.08650603145360947, -0.05830825865268707, -0.03692842274904251, 0.027751537039875984, -0.04568902403116226, -0.03541091829538345, 0.06408869475126266, 0.004597060848027468, 0.03195999935269356, 0.01901196502149105, -0.03344189375638962, -0.001571410452015698, 0.015159773640334606, -0.011393642984330654, 0.006830407306551933, -0.08700819313526154, -0.0032587649766355753, -0.020374255254864693, 0.0761055201292038, 0.04200809448957443, 0.028272422030568123, 0.009937534108757973, -0.04846514016389847, 0.033332206308841705, 0.001782528473995626, -0.0840417742729187, 0.0980318933725357, -0.003279858035966754, 0.003628899110481143, -0.07091213762760162, 0.039061758667230606, 0.004638365935534239, -0.03758492320775986, -0.06250560283660889, -0.0014266675570979714, 0.06945417076349258, -0.000014193517017702106, -0.021544260904192924, -0.030021347105503082, 0.00592041015625, 0.005382057745009661, 0.030853064730763435, 0.0478062778711319, 0.015482474118471146, -0.06448059529066086, -0.0779276043176651, -0.027009718120098114, 0.041094571352005005, -0.025385038927197456, 0.03390493988990784, -0.15612758696079254, -0.052369460463523865, -0.0012025827309116721, -0.02366042695939541, 0.07524783909320831, 0.00703161396086216, 0.029326099902391434, 0.01821538805961609, 0.04607931897044182, -0.017284328117966652, 0.08562244474887848, 0.010236200876533985, 0.06300678104162216, 0.007715852465480566, -0.004404817242175341, 0.02032458409667015, -0.018310220912098885, -0.038131605833768845, -0.018464379012584686, -0.04952101409435272, -0.052131522446870804, 0.012809133157134056, 0.02583560161292553, 0.02424740605056286, 0.08612695336341858, -0.04443427175283432, 0.04982718825340271, -0.12471602857112885, -0.07962575554847717, -0.04515594616532326, -0.020203914493322372, 0.07444421201944351, 0.043277472257614136, 0.056181132793426514, 0.01823260635137558, 0.001500713056884706, 0.004619336687028408, -0.009790541604161263, 0.01729426346719265, 0.010402161628007889, 0.0004192246706224978, -0.009815904311835766, 0.026717057451605797, 0.004733876790851355, -0.013837248086929321, 0.05878831446170807, 0.026777358725667, -0.018049901351332664, -0.017653563991189003, 0.03142467886209488, -0.041134677827358246, 0.010153846815228462, 0.006883744616061449, -0.04966244474053383, -0.038592249155044556, 0.0038388126995414495, -0.018350724130868912, -0.049533333629369736, -0.011916708201169968, -0.041733454912900925, 0.05157158523797989, -0.04019908607006073, -0.02012358047068119, 0.008814401924610138, 0.004006672650575638, 0.054265983402729034, 0.05682182312011719, 0.00983542948961258, 0.019503947347402573, -0.03508846461772919, 0.017499852925539017, 0.03658602386713028, -0.015856774523854256, 0.04021579027175903, -0.0897052213549614, -0.021384036168456078, -0.019597748294472694, 0.011489937081933022, -0.024971669539809227, 0.007071533240377903, 0.05226629599928856, 0.021539974957704544, 0.034827958792448044, -0.10142508894205093, 0.037348370999097824, 0.027204280719161034, 0.036391731351614, -0.027551842853426933, -0.006706602405756712, 0.03263341262936592, -0.010079814121127129, -0.0602695494890213, -0.050726573914289474, -0.015339873731136322, 0.011106637306511402, 0.0672931894659996, 0.09310571849346161, 0.04437142238020897, -0.011149746365845203, 0.0428737998008728, 0.07309608906507492, 0.06422873586416245, -0.00249217776581645, 0.06257539987564087, 0.04381037503480911, -0.03474245220422745, 0.04438389465212822, 0.005299157928675413, -0.0655963122844696 ]
16
16
Getting started in probabilistic graphical models
Probabilistic graphical models (PGMs) have become a popular tool for computational analysis of biological data in a variety of domains. But, what exactly are they and how do they work? How can we use PGMs to discover patterns that are biologically relevant? And to what extent can PGMs help us formulate new hypotheses that are testable at the bench? This note sketches out some answers and illustrates the main ideas behind the statistical approach to biological pattern discovery.
[ -0.015159770846366882, -0.04016834869980812, 0.03451216220855713, -0.020208200439810753, 0.029150499030947685, 0.05273716524243355, -0.0029204459860920906, -0.009288436733186245, 0.015000835061073303, 0.031397346407175064, 0.04298253357410431, -0.14728838205337524, 0.005081556737422943, 0.002452259184792638, -0.0042792391031980515, 0.04610147699713707, -0.005338557064533234, -0.07493235915899277, -0.03659888356924057, -0.05245448276400566, 0.0018589867977425456, 0.08367613703012466, -0.013492043130099773, 0.02067621611058712, 0.050444621592760086, 0.07235459983348846, -0.03275551274418831, -0.004833178129047155, -0.012977438047528267, -0.10842730104923248, -0.09235019981861115, 0.028244229033589363, -0.029503077268600464, 0.004319247789680958, 0.047896046191453934, 0.04643167927861214, 0.004434711765497923, -0.005849228240549564, 0.030218157917261124, -0.02476002648472786, 0.03322242945432663, -0.1042720302939415, 0.007402500137686729, -0.00031176445190794766, 0.028278818354010582, 0.055031418800354004, 0.018471412360668182, 0.060174934566020966, 0.03844917565584183, 0.08106352388858795, -0.06163701042532921, 0.008086847141385078, 0.010434874333441257, 0.007598081137984991, -0.032877299934625626, -0.019810562953352928, -0.07345635443925858, 0.05612516403198242, 0.0019827692303806543, 0.03874906152486801, 0.05273619666695595, 0.03815029561519623, -0.02675044909119606, -0.014645108953118324, -0.04112162068486214, 0.04253886640071869, -0.027662504464387894, 0.008928335271775723, -0.025866668671369553, -0.06375247985124588, 0.10353842377662659, -0.012694906443357468, 0.05543140321969986, 0.018473463132977486, 0.01563432440161705, 0.04958607628941536, -0.04289494827389717, -0.08772795647382736, 0.06172794848680496, 0.15559236705303192, 0.023568008095026016, 0.005148954689502716, -0.01024028193205595, -0.0065895249135792255, -0.0049567269161343575, -0.009206436574459076, -0.030421538278460503, -0.02762720361351967, 0.0369044654071331, -0.02578906901180744, -0.07608389854431152, 0.009021135047078133, -0.003680865280330181, 0.06694039702415466, -0.017531445249915123, 0.038282010704278946, -0.06788847595453262, -0.05459028482437134, -0.022739069536328316, 0.02205616421997547, -0.07841051369905472, -0.07403043657541275, 0.0016257779207080603, 0.052629098296165466, -0.06625854969024658, 0.05769040063023567, -0.0648844763636589, 0.019490456208586693, -0.04261025786399841, -0.04244644194841385, 0.05418185144662857, -0.060887765139341354, 0.012031754478812218, 0.02731350250542164, -0.019022099673748016, 0.04690975323319435, 0.015949087217450142, 0.03978247940540314, 0.10016234219074249, -0.03646370768547058, 0.049728963524103165, -0.04288541525602341, -0.02401774376630783, -0.031513385474681854, -0.011305204592645168, -0.006918475031852722, -0.03633366897702217, -0.03847650811076164, 0.05591314658522606, -0.003546637250110507, 0.03608730807900429, 0.034789685159921646, -0.02332325652241707, -0.02147061564028263, -0.05306847766041756, -0.009786097332835197, -0.04480947554111481, -0.0333123654127121, -0.0074560195207595825, 0.028514783829450607, 0.004792922642081976, -0.05118560418486595, 0.019516298547387123, 0.05660662427544594, -0.040980417281389236, 0.09911592304706573, -0.03938879072666168, -0.034731362015008926, -0.023033741861581802, 0.025016380473971367, -0.016560159623622894, -0.07102230936288834, 0.022242115810513496, 0.01660127192735672, 0.028621533885598183, 0.011699806898832321, -0.01580534502863884, -0.019499393180012703, -0.007930610328912735, 0.053804248571395874, -0.07504936307668686, -0.049592893570661545, 0.021935954689979553, 0.014938999898731709, 0.01385378185659647, 0.0053740269504487514, -0.05579556152224541, 0.026257293298840523, -0.08500824868679047, 0.018848158419132233, -0.011294013820588589, 0.07572674006223679, 0.031360406428575516, -0.017863299697637558, 0.08478384464979172, -0.07054248452186584, 0.04493033513426781, 0.06681616604328156, 0.02128671482205391, -0.008814351633191109, 0.021021533757448196, -0.051243916153907776, 0.024575769901275635, 0.03389330953359604, 0.0055233025923371315, 0.0793519914150238, -0.054748401045799255, 0.0396512970328331, 0.03656283766031265, 0.022718923166394234, 0.0469583123922348, 0.02250334806740284, 0.04942459985613823, 0.020636631175875664, -0.05114024877548218, 0.01937825419008732, -0.01141741406172514, -0.017554812133312225, -0.014251122251152992, 0.015339615754783154, -0.004036338534206152, 0.025336895138025284, -0.02207588031888008, 0.01608261652290821, -0.03570965677499771, -0.0025387525092810392, 0.01625465229153633, 0.06943678110837936, -0.07462655752897263, -0.019817637279629707, 0.03792935609817505, 0.031242620199918747, -0.07890813797712326, -0.04588538408279419, 0.020035894587635994, -0.03863823786377907, 0.00014632113743573427, -0.05111149698495865, 0.04609965533018112, 0.05331410840153694, -0.017076877877116203, 0.04201240465044975, -0.045275479555130005, 0.024966014549136162, -0.022483069449663162, -0.01562739908695221, -0.04261941835284233, 0.03464827314019203, -0.01964990794658661, 0.042757440358400345, 0.021229775622487068, -0.0022779807914048433, 0.02410602755844593, -0.007733561098575592, 0.06871791929006577, 0.06168372556567192, -0.028287095949053764, -0.01861671917140484, 0.012767856940627098, 0.046196404844522476, -0.04136718064546585, 0.023710446432232857, 0.08349478244781494, -0.03458550572395325, 0.029665065929293633, 0.03220774233341217, 0.022443614900112152, 0.07995566725730896, -0.03211523965001106, 0.016024356707930565, -0.03164740651845932, 0.001315167872235179, -0.046154510229825974, 0.0006556289154104888, 0.03328178822994232, -0.025254063308238983, -0.07531815022230148, 0.032468412071466446, 0.006260295398533344, 0.05215774476528168, 0.06351969391107559, 0.025996806100010872, 0.019214030355215073, 0.022731732577085495, 0.05833250284194946, -0.015915144234895706, -0.033362820744514465, 0.014537395909428596, -0.009382892400026321, -0.025759221985936165, 0.04598965123295784, -0.06460003554821014, -0.039477791637182236, 0.13456249237060547, 0.010659946128726006, -0.00965938251465559, 0.052558451890945435, 0.02039041370153427, -0.012230313383042812, -0.02633731998503208, -0.09251674264669418, -0.046257924288511276, -0.013517412357032299, -0.030225340276956558, -0.004816834349185228, 0.0447697788476944, -0.04486682638525963, 0.013566744513809681, -0.008210352621972561, -0.07421937584877014, -0.054701220244169235, 0.012820624746382236, -0.09460747987031937, 0.01811913028359413, 0.029063433408737183, -0.011716741137206554, -0.0019022398628294468, -0.0012468716595321894, 0.08899631351232529, 0.011551428586244583, 0.002590705407783389, 0.06004851311445236, 0.03784288838505745, 0.02014850452542305, 0.015409382991492748, 0.02357078343629837, 0.017353611066937447, 0.041500113904476166, -0.05221660062670708, -0.014011824503540993, 0.025779033079743385, -0.02788437530398369, -0.019282758235931396, -0.025242242962121964, -0.03936474770307541, -0.04429762810468674, -0.047212135046720505, 0.018018146976828575, -0.07461873441934586, -0.03556341677904129, -0.022191572934389114, 0.06063191220164299, 0.01651294156908989, -0.02749396115541458, 0.01328134536743164, -0.032874953001737595, -0.011160344816744328, 0.09301625937223434, -0.027720225974917412, -0.02627740241587162, -0.05245038494467735, -0.03783534839749336, 0.028831584379076958, 0.10365546494722366, -0.06087636947631836, 0.007237166166305542, -0.03218098729848862, 0.001978021115064621, 0.017267588526010513, 0.03013100102543831, -0.06594302505254745, -0.06322348862886429, -0.0016693613724783063, 0.006920382380485535, -0.034413814544677734, 0.05504691228270531, 0.0275651253759861, -0.0024734807666391134, 0.0216279998421669, -0.002385452389717102, -0.018478933721780777, -0.00262765446677804, 0.0035090213641524315, 0.030922988429665565, -0.046228282153606415, 0.0838354229927063, -0.014809594489634037, -0.010823276825249195, 0.0033135961275547743, 0.0179423950612545, -0.01887340657413006, -0.017847957089543343, 0.05228415131568909, -0.033890459686517715, -0.06824737042188644, 0.01746358536183834, 0.03554554283618927, -0.022097647190093994, 0.002731476677581668, 0.058614473789930344, 0.04228030890226364, -0.028869643807411194, -0.009031115099787712, 0.011926703155040741, -0.01882428675889969, 0.03617607057094574, -0.01889411173760891, -0.08351630717515945, 0.013178528286516666, 0.06732738018035889, -0.03318120539188385, -0.009996721521019936, -0.07241321355104446, 0.013721146620810032, -0.05972650647163391, -0.09482899308204651, -0.037996165454387665, -0.018595492467284203, 0.014660824090242386, -0.04115648195147514, -0.06026862934231758, 0.019307946786284447, 0.023822015151381493, -0.028079142794013023, 0.050829824060201645, 0.020624417811632156, -0.015171742998063564, 0.05292471870779991, 0.06090433523058891, 0.04071721062064171, -0.0396902933716774, -0.036521073430776596, -0.059300508350133896, -0.09270213544368744, -0.032924145460128784, 0.021937204524874687, -0.04161557927727699, 0.07980217039585114, 0.03520361706614494, 0.03980884701013565, 0.032057054340839386, 0.014335459098219872, -0.0532321073114872, -0.02780267223715782, 0.05848734453320503, 0.010495498776435852, 0.030282562598586082, 0.044433362782001495, -0.08048699051141739, -0.02792474254965782, 0.07407260686159134, -0.04330278933048248, -0.024195559322834015, 0.030633743852376938, -0.012654408812522888, -0.04412199929356575, 0.08038857579231262, 0.13293081521987915, 0.041124604642391205, -0.014217532239854336, -0.013378799892961979, 0.05296070873737335, -0.07032256573438644, 0.10943125933408737, -0.053194720298051834, -0.015364696271717548, 0.028531327843666077, -0.006746263708919287, 0.05163262039422989, 0.06288496404886246, 0.02284599281847477, 0.017047030851244926, 0.003926181234419346, -0.0467308945953846, 0.04607589915394783, -0.04812970012426376, 0.005411042366176844, 0.004905113950371742, 0.11510380357503891, 0.04174897447228432, 0.014743346720933914, 0.01867186836898327, -0.0588005967438221, 0.014574727974832058, -0.03814549371600151, -0.018623383715748787, -0.05257692560553551, -0.043546441942453384, 0.02054988592863083, 0.05392908677458763, 0.05871032923460007, 0.03688487783074379, -0.0765218660235405, -0.038224440068006516, -0.0299102570861578, 0.01220729947090149, 0.051176778972148895, 0.05903102830052376, 0.1288956105709076, -0.014691472053527832, 0.028243469074368477, -0.04011393338441849, 0.05964010953903198, -0.05199994519352913, 0.02555250935256481, 0.021329350769519806, 0.024012921378016472, -0.06181635335087776, 0.0028118756599724293, -0.06946851313114166, 0.04740934818983078, -0.020523911342024803, 0.013113955967128277, 0.016235435381531715, -0.05719634145498276, 0.10645095258951187, -0.0032646639738231897, -0.05996766313910484, -0.02334420196712017, -0.006390073336660862, 0.0028487793169915676, -0.01704687625169754, 0.052986256778240204, 0.05207609757781029, 0.041105616837739944, -0.0032187181059271097, -0.061367105692625046, 0.027776194736361504, 0.06054658070206642, 0.018152348697185516, 0.01504958514124155, -0.0053984555415809155, 0.042816970497369766, 0.0306467954069376, 0.06217743456363678, -0.007082885131239891, -0.0023073717020452023, -0.0000697671712259762, 0.00937281921505928, -0.027865903452038765, -0.0077135637402534485, -0.053145717829465866 ]
17
17
A tutorial on conformal prediction
Conformal prediction uses past experience to determine precise levels of confidence in new predictions. Given an error probability $\epsilon$, together with a method that makes a prediction $\hat{y}$ of a label $y$, it produces a set of labels, typically containing $\hat{y}$, that also contains $y$ with probability $1-\epsilon$. Conformal prediction can be applied to any method for producing $\hat{y}$: a nearest-neighbor method, a support-vector machine, ridge regression, etc. Conformal prediction is designed for an on-line setting in which labels are predicted successively, each one being revealed before the next is predicted. The most novel and valuable feature of conformal prediction is that if the successive examples are sampled independently from the same distribution, then the successive predictions will be right $1-\epsilon$ of the time, even though they are based on an accumulating dataset rather than on independent datasets. In addition to the model under which successive examples are sampled independently, other on-line compression models can also use conformal prediction. The widely used Gaussian linear model is one of these. This tutorial presents a self-contained account of the theory of conformal prediction and works through several numerical examples. A more comprehensive treatment of the topic is provided in "Algorithmic Learning in a Random World", by Vladimir Vovk, Alex Gammerman, and Glenn Shafer (Springer, 2005).
[ -0.014211557805538177, -0.07417234778404236, -0.01402543019503355, -0.0248276237398386, 0.034434691071510315, -0.06287772208452225, 0.03858970105648041, -0.0505656898021698, -0.00478666927665472, 0.0670609399676323, -0.02432852052152157, 0.013699892908334732, 0.0037888686638325453, -0.013918710872530937, 0.010954991914331913, 0.0033021406270563602, -0.013670251704752445, 0.057817865163087845, -0.02353176288306713, -0.02956056408584118, -0.0018571545369923115, -0.05072471871972084, -0.02076907642185688, -0.017099380493164062, 0.06933567672967911, -0.038733646273612976, -0.016025647521018982, 0.012463124468922615, 0.004319556523114443, 0.013042285107076168, -0.052070897072553635, 0.010805180296301842, 0.060479529201984406, -0.014642697758972645, 0.043508514761924744, -0.015505652874708176, 0.023253656923770905, -0.004742368124425411, -0.02088376134634018, -0.04247172549366951, 0.02153164893388748, -0.06411004066467285, 0.055577345192432404, -0.008092823438346386, -0.02210768312215805, 0.014975746162235737, 0.0025181397795677185, -0.03597887232899666, -0.043042246252298355, 0.04160811007022858, 0.007302497047930956, -0.03184227645397186, -0.10920725017786026, -0.027568839490413666, 0.012124748900532722, -0.011997252702713013, -0.0025322979781776667, -0.010876191779971123, -0.023137710988521576, -0.06108788028359413, 0.028773916885256767, 0.12716443836688995, -0.009954467415809631, -0.033918023109436035, -0.07760940492153168, -0.000014276589354267344, -0.1029486432671547, -0.02099974825978279, 0.011646891012787819, -0.03266480192542076, 0.016679959371685982, 0.006184193771332502, -0.005828205496072769, 0.02761177532374859, 0.02071412093937397, -0.024735460057854652, -0.017218464985489845, -0.03301803395152092, 0.020207200199365616, 0.09647625684738159, -0.05079708248376846, 0.04673714563250542, 0.009842731058597565, -0.0037976582534611225, -0.015384679660201073, -0.03196534141898155, -0.012894682586193085, 0.02796071209013462, 0.03543126955628395, -0.03992357850074768, -0.08147145062685013, 0.038484107702970505, -0.058653637766838074, 0.042347874492406845, -0.0315077118575573, 0.03132554143667221, 0.05590107664465904, -0.0777885839343071, -0.022162504494190216, 0.04582666978240013, 0.00562359020113945, 0.011637586168944836, 0.0528155118227005, -0.009251538664102554, -0.01948852837085724, -0.019847281277179718, -0.05491212382912636, 0.01857062056660652, 0.05417005717754364, 0.000984642538242042, 0.052263882011175156, 0.02516956627368927, -0.018215766176581383, -0.016387073323130608, 0.029021529480814934, 0.011138170957565308, 0.062381260097026825, 0.05829719454050064, 0.042406871914863586, -0.00835947971791029, 0.06957505643367767, 0.032931819558143616, 0.03303740173578262, 0.006836205720901489, 0.03203866630792618, 0.015060774981975555, -0.06151094660162926, -0.058551546186208725, 0.05771750956773758, -0.027227601036429405, -0.008276771754026413, 0.06215980276465416, -0.028646940365433693, 0.023263465613126755, -0.10679703205823898, 0.02881949208676815, 0.00450840825214982, -0.05856440216302872, -0.08183231949806213, -0.0323551669716835, -0.04612041264772415, -0.07877988368272781, -0.009076837450265884, 0.022507082670927048, 0.042180128395557404, 0.07400796562433243, 0.009871793910861015, -0.051017966121435165, -0.052000440657138824, -0.02408973127603531, -0.07814183831214905, -0.008304901421070099, 0.04387906566262245, 0.01176389493048191, 0.1324424296617508, -0.025378255173563957, -0.06526195257902145, -0.008980954065918922, -0.04879719018936157, 0.023487959057092667, -0.008694589138031006, 0.012709305621683598, 0.012404637411236763, 0.05089160427451134, -0.06946807354688644, 0.02368113026022911, -0.03849613294005394, -0.007074384484440088, -0.09736954420804977, -0.13596893846988678, -0.0011866718996316195, -0.021514134481549263, 0.02764117904007435, -0.008523068390786648, 0.015061617828905582, 0.007164786569774151, 0.016686398535966873, 0.04573774337768555, -0.030180448666214943, 0.023331105709075928, 0.060778215527534485, -0.09342782199382782, -0.01917659491300583, 0.04757150635123253, 0.043957844376564026, 0.064944788813591, -0.005062534473836422, 0.01212947815656662, 0.011972000822424889, 0.01021300908178091, 0.05064191669225693, 0.021274508908391, -0.01078707817941904, 0.006227502599358559, -0.03807629272341728, 0.10092799365520477, -0.011940688826143742, -0.04953291267156601, -0.006710488349199295, 0.09075252711772919, 0.013122285716235638, -0.006000282242894173, -0.01209618616849184, -0.041211966425180435, -0.13108308613300323, 0.05328351631760597, 0.038335736840963364, -0.0034828227944672108, -0.010453840717673302, 0.010122088715434074, 0.045779190957546234, 0.03214716911315918, -0.0315457284450531, -0.06745421141386032, 0.00799967348575592, -0.04557259380817413, -0.016680743545293808, -0.10404343158006668, 0.07963693886995316, 0.03169884905219078, -0.0006804153090342879, 0.050351936370134354, -0.04189430549740791, 0.008328595198690891, -0.10881221294403076, -0.0019988941494375467, -0.003942616283893585, -0.01735883206129074, -0.06123313680291176, 0.03523382544517517, -0.0549030564725399, -0.0666310042142868, -0.04185046628117561, -0.020307136699557304, -0.015911942347884178, 0.01421916950494051, -0.028212198987603188, -0.00015828211326152086, -0.048779625445604324, -0.012270179577171803, -0.009608847089111805, 0.019091589376330376, 0.019104745239019394, -0.013706383295357227, -0.0025227239821106195, -0.041229914873838425, -0.029937049373984337, -0.004674637224525213, -0.01967901922762394, 0.004514188505709171, 0.05957046151161194, 0.030887451022863388, -0.07063073664903641, -0.02946888655424118, 0.038416143506765366, 0.015383255667984486, -0.010358007624745369, 0.020777175202965736, 0.10479086637496948, 0.03340122476220131, -0.05615879222750664, 0.03388826549053192, -0.08785523474216461, 0.08232872933149338, 0.12243150174617767, 0.018857521936297417, -0.04820570722222328, 0.04065103456377983, -0.02179647982120514, 0.06658157706260681, 0.03270696848630905, -0.029067179188132286, -0.01752687618136406, 0.045167338103055954, -0.016363179311156273, -0.043256793171167374, -0.002072723116725683, 0.04224192723631859, 0.030194299295544624, -0.09052572399377823, -0.10335162281990051, 0.01228218525648117, -0.010040434077382088, 0.05137518420815468, 0.02438235469162464, -0.00835125520825386, -0.04791639372706413, -0.026085544377565384, -0.002061756793409586, -0.010089226998388767, -0.02844259701669216, -0.004703626036643982, -0.07033829391002655, 0.001767730456776917, -0.017883416265249252, -0.054358985275030136, 0.010709159076213837, -0.008452366106212139, 0.008606192655861378, -0.0010549086146056652, 0.006849300116300583, -0.004429939202964306, 0.05034159496426582, 0.055641427636146545, 0.03369896113872528, 0.08828781545162201, 0.0430307574570179, 0.08587995916604996, -0.05054890736937523, -0.02244553528726101, 0.0010021817870438099, -0.08289970457553864, 0.052768219262361526, -0.02409709431231022, -0.037004027515649796, -0.06088847294449806, -0.0031059696339070797, -0.002479711314663291, -0.025895435363054276, 0.016292201355099678, 0.008634712547063828, -0.06659922003746033, 0.034336790442466736, -0.0065521434880793095, -0.05232430621981621, 0.0013918491313233972, 0.05489731952548027, 0.06041102856397629, -0.07552120089530945, 0.009314235299825668, -0.04477186128497124, -0.029291843995451927, -0.0413559265434742, 0.12160414457321167, -0.04581546038389206, 0.01637602038681507, -0.07471231371164322, 0.005444719921797514, 0.04605487361550331, 0.04602806642651558, -0.00013266086170915514, -0.026699529960751534, -0.01276584155857563, 0.008574244566261768, -0.007747750263661146, 0.07403060793876648, 0.1134611964225769, -0.034076251089572906, -0.02998238615691662, 0.011782268062233925, -0.013694196939468384, -0.02134723588824272, -0.001576755428686738, 0.024281717836856842, 0.005825384985655546, 0.06606587767601013, -0.004855870734900236, 0.02210046909749508, -0.005344006232917309, -0.020796513184905052, 0.01571088470518589, 0.03243128955364227, -0.08671720325946808, -0.08669614791870117, 0.024755634367465973, 0.06463085114955902, -0.00015903163875918835, 0.03761942312121391, -0.018489236012101173, 0.0026834835298359394, 0.010207469575107098, -0.020864587277173996, 0.03845755383372307, 0.02088405378162861, 0.06400923430919647, -0.04712536931037903, 0.09560370445251465, 0.01941244676709175, -0.013468245975673199, 0.060921985656023026, -0.014441178180277348, 0.02817467600107193, -0.03711399435997009, -0.02738962508738041, -0.018694037571549416, -0.03556235134601593, -0.045764658600091934, 0.0038491429295390844, 0.05085179954767227, 0.023266831412911415, -0.021812496706843376, -0.0295678973197937, -0.035718683153390884, 0.007637509144842625, -0.0005026404396630824, 0.01791868731379509, -0.011492299847304821, 0.05084991082549095, 0.010951565578579903, -0.0282770786434412, -0.06105899065732956, -0.031124543398618698, 0.016492247581481934, -0.023515548557043076, -0.03744146600365639, 0.038243286311626434, -0.019181929528713226, 0.08390726894140244, -0.024386102333664894, 0.02302178181707859, 0.019571801647543907, 0.08832085877656937, -0.0024262401275336742, 0.04503614455461502, 0.02290988899767399, 0.041860856115818024, 0.10722681879997253, 0.024451028555631638, -0.03256559371948242, -0.03250044211745262, -0.004726254381239414, 0.03555142506957054, 0.00012464160681702197, 0.07775788009166718, 0.07940009981393814, -0.02232293412089348, 0.09343905746936798, 0.05506289750337601, -0.02355821616947651, 0.05154814571142197, -0.04064429923892021, -0.004976714961230755, 0.02581102028489113, -0.004811097402125597, -0.009099745191633701, -0.02588965743780136, 0.028078099712729454, -0.04005151614546776, 0.022659985348582268, -0.02150130458176136, -0.10840459167957306, -0.03580678999423981, 0.011231170035898685, 0.05679941549897194, -0.05233749374747276, 0.07716230303049088, 0.02330220863223076, -0.002934840274974704, 0.041099026799201965, -0.0033006067387759686, 0.039571065455675125, 0.055145371705293655, -0.013231299817562103, -0.02435200661420822, 0.02613494172692299, -0.014081893488764763, -0.024384763091802597, -0.04941235110163689, 0.05804000794887543, -0.044556330889463425, -0.03992585465312004, -0.04608587548136711, 0.0006981287151575089, 0.011626568622887135, -0.07726458460092545, -0.02383372187614441, 0.044043995440006256, 0.03396148607134819, -0.0019210404716432095, -0.010820451192557812, -0.07448773831129074, 0.026710784062743187, 0.05701785907149315, -0.06287145614624023, -0.01117398776113987, -0.028964651748538017, 0.059941671788692474, -0.07635248452425003, -0.010941454209387302, 0.010190612636506557, 0.06313275545835495, -0.04959191754460335, -0.06478150188922882, 0.03460800647735596, 0.024380339309573174, 0.054392922669649124, -0.03445207700133324, 0.05564407631754875, 0.08353766053915024, 0.027900751680135727, 0.07324830442667007, -0.07449929416179657, -0.010684101842343807, 0.04294905439019203, 0.018604779615998268, 0.06322567909955978, -0.009453058242797852, 0.013376778922975063, -0.014112042263150215, 0.027163775637745857, 0.03536881133913994, 0.09208088368177414, 0.024886485189199448, 0.033782560378313065, 0.035886626690626144, 0.034138280898332596, 0.013840102590620518, 0.006225129589438438, 0.033416498452425, 0.013649294152855873, -0.06866638362407684, -0.013951292261481285 ]
18
18
Scale-sensitive Psi-dimensions: the Capacity Measures for Classifiers Taking Values in R^Q
Bounds on the risk play a crucial role in statistical learning theory. They usually involve as capacity measure of the model studied the VC dimension or one of its extensions. In classification, such "VC dimensions" exist for models taking values in {0, 1}, {1,..., Q} and R. We introduce the generalizations appropriate for the missing case, the one of models with values in R^Q. This provides us with a new guaranteed risk for M-SVMs which appears superior to the existing one.
[ -0.008276669308543205, -0.06894080340862274, 0.027650240808725357, -0.06947672367095947, 0.019545258954167366, 0.002181423595175147, -0.03267709165811539, 0.056921038776636124, -0.05872964486479759, 0.027649950236082077, -0.014939096756279469, -0.04492277279496193, 0.023518972098827362, 0.047117680311203, -0.007085001096129417, 0.008975733071565628, -0.008053517900407314, 0.005142431240528822, 0.031566936522722244, -0.13339225947856903, 0.01945943757891655, 0.025336774066090584, 0.06877811253070831, -0.019914044067263603, -0.021583355963230133, -0.008735977113246918, 0.02757975645363331, -0.0050485082902014256, 0.010702528059482574, 0.01276291161775589, -0.060283076018095016, 0.0132264019921422, -0.025363560765981674, -0.020460302010178566, -0.021462315693497658, -0.027623385190963745, -0.005626100115478039, -0.0035681219305843115, -0.08531039208173752, -0.05967438966035843, 0.03976438194513321, 0.044338714331388474, 0.018237724900245667, 0.025323545560240746, -0.0032209407072514296, -0.0031030504032969475, 0.03409231826663017, 0.024145839735865593, -0.060375697910785675, 0.02416062355041504, -0.042176734656095505, 0.07270536571741104, -0.02740888111293316, -0.10290713608264923, 0.04441552981734276, -0.045258644968271255, 0.024429984390735626, 0.0034500479232519865, -0.02325395680963993, -0.013706747442483902, 0.037444617599248886, 0.09589459747076035, 0.02705383487045765, -0.06681115925312042, 0.009562470018863678, 0.04107468202710152, -0.11360064148902893, -0.00779132591560483, 0.04856046289205551, 0.005767683032900095, -0.032371241599321365, -0.05004360154271126, 0.03783281520009041, 0.019389713183045387, 0.015056252479553223, 0.0009142240742221475, -0.043856747448444366, 0.00002572146877355408, 0.014664087444543839, 0.059122588485479355, -0.03200175613164902, -0.012658321298658848, 0.0789434164762497, 0.08276471495628357, 0.006131984759122133, 0.06499885767698288, -0.003149815136566758, -0.026829777285456657, -0.036927301436662674, -0.016994858160614967, 0.041193246841430664, -0.015248574316501617, 0.0009046625928021967, 0.07440204918384552, 0.000052156417950754985, 0.043142035603523254, -0.016526835039258003, -0.024912670254707336, -0.0031001109164208174, -0.018198762089014053, 0.01726801134645939, 0.036995939910411835, 0.08428039401769638, 0.024298500269651413, -0.02596617117524147, 0.025857945904135704, -0.03629482537508011, 0.029242046177387238, -0.10276194661855698, 0.011662290431559086, -0.013658683747053146, -0.11485867947340012, -0.001375134103000164, 0.05746336653828621, 0.06192224472761154, 0.09756216406822205, -0.01681186445057392, -0.003504913067445159, 0.06954000890254974, 0.0031855059787631035, -0.06746754050254822, 0.04886666685342789, -0.06969122588634491, 0.03306860476732254, -0.043358590453863144, 0.04350610822439194, 0.0019998105708509684, -0.039131395518779755, 0.13823843002319336, -0.05191781744360924, -0.03917929530143738, 0.001996093662455678, -0.00728351017460227, -0.03845469281077385, -0.027336541563272476, -0.042049624025821686, -0.023714080452919006, -0.026684843003749847, 0.003939671907573938, 0.0072844247333705425, -0.005470955278724432, 0.018135257065296173, 0.002329193288460374, 0.04074423760175705, 0.0170126985758543, 0.024041101336479187, 0.047825999557971954, 0.022648010402917862, 0.018511973321437836, 0.0154090765863657, -0.032456304877996445, 0.011617021635174751, 0.04956469312310219, 0.04386426508426666, 0.08912882208824158, -0.04949145019054413, 0.01757233589887619, -0.003642045659944415, -0.05025718733668327, 0.019458983093500137, -0.007829750888049603, 0.04596121981739998, -0.008735277689993382, 0.03631528839468956, -0.10868440568447113, -0.030679592862725258, -0.01138962060213089, 0.02311440370976925, -0.03936705365777016, -0.01874794252216816, -0.01462471392005682, -0.015501110814511776, 0.022318869829177856, -0.008062208071351051, 0.009850072674453259, -0.002070021815598011, 0.018642330542206764, 0.0807613804936409, -0.0066258469596505165, -0.076834537088871, -0.0045260218903422356, -0.0036439767573028803, 0.01685631088912487, 0.0649009644985199, 0.015016844496130943, 0.10150454193353653, -0.026932397857308388, -0.0067681665532290936, 0.009342526085674763, 0.010009306482970715, 0.037309132516384125, 0.0015679053030908108, 0.013679507188498974, -0.07452619075775146, -0.061961378902196884, 0.02250046655535698, -0.015332311391830444, 0.00030512872035615146, 0.05785062536597252, 0.01327353436499834, 0.011930934153497219, 0.015405283309519291, -0.06855453550815582, -0.008051706477999687, -0.03572215512394905, 0.01879436895251274, 0.03202362731099129, -0.05839741602540016, 0.02327140048146248, -0.00920907687395811, 0.06426528096199036, -0.03810396417975426, 0.08131985366344452, -0.03482289984822273, 0.034301627427339554, -0.07312119752168655, 0.045342348515987396, 0.01339948270469904, 0.06814977526664734, -0.0323934331536293, -0.03654811158776283, 0.0890636071562767, 0.004855944775044918, 0.03061993420124054, -0.06907474994659424, 0.039334073662757874, 0.02682480402290821, -0.05308501049876213, -0.07013223320245743, 0.05198819190263748, -0.0708080381155014, -0.08838523179292679, -0.023468011990189552, 0.00572537537664175, -0.017650481313467026, 0.030414197593927383, -0.03626364469528198, -0.01472051627933979, 0.096180260181427, 0.04899654537439346, 0.013496753759682178, 0.02823709324002266, -0.026263277977705002, -0.0376373752951622, 0.06307221949100494, -0.03237416222691536, 0.01978287287056446, 0.10311216861009598, -0.00630111712962389, 0.060866229236125946, 0.011296819895505905, 0.029760831966996193, -0.003833018010482192, -0.06572619080543518, 0.07805344462394714, -0.06226307153701782, 0.03510858491063118, 0.014776295982301235, 0.006469779647886753, 0.06494440883398056, -0.005382979288697243, 0.048627518117427826, -0.04620620980858803, 0.0032594683580100536, 0.0638769119977951, -0.02710265852510929, -0.0068433936685323715, 0.018440812826156616, 0.025260044261813164, -0.04977024346590042, -0.0070389630272984505, -0.022971654310822487, -0.020271586254239082, -0.0026896612253040075, -0.0629824548959732, 0.10340067744255066, 0.05763940140604973, 0.013465860858559608, 0.05420275405049324, -0.01400908175855875, -0.06340579688549042, 0.0015224136877804995, -0.014247315004467964, -0.02573276497423649, 0.05820539966225624, 0.025821184739470482, -0.03473152592778206, -0.023411566391587257, 0.045992232859134674, 0.006192565895617008, -0.0407932884991169, 0.012459437362849712, 0.0076324730180203915, -0.009607051499187946, 0.09269213676452637, 0.06635840982198715, 0.05094745382666588, 0.034853849560022354, 0.005480627994984388, -0.06943529844284058, 0.011110376566648483, 0.02843359485268593, 0.037175290286540985, -0.009956270456314087, -0.038913317024707794, 0.07206912338733673, 0.03581088408827782, -0.016324274241924286, -0.029999099671840668, 0.07344155013561249, -0.06573431193828583, -0.012579710222780704, 0.010988906025886536, -0.056511033326387405, -0.032730065286159515, -0.03134171664714813, 0.05209298059344292, -0.0642184242606163, 0.00006858773849671707, 0.024271907284855843, 0.0543176606297493, 0.009635334834456444, -0.021830929443240166, 0.006465904414653778, -0.05326589569449425, -0.05107702314853668, 0.02240435965359211, -0.029504502192139626, -0.06555230915546417, -0.010269037447869778, -0.08576428890228271, -0.08405276387929916, 0.040605343878269196, 0.03557170182466507, 0.041123248636722565, 0.10069852322340012, 0.027116362005472183, -0.01269919890910387, -0.03287091478705406, -0.01575472392141819, 0.03232966363430023, -0.14245174825191498, 0.04938659071922302, -0.01800418272614479, -0.02080005407333374, 0.021995414048433304, -0.025177057832479477, 0.027756817638874054, -0.047080736607313156, 0.012050085701048374, -0.10228016972541809, 0.02035318687558174, 0.0005428573931567371, 0.07092852145433426, -0.019751286134123802, 0.03812326490879059, 0.03574512153863907, 0.022412147372961044, -0.013716795481741428, -0.005501322913914919, 0.04102857783436775, -0.024374615401029587, -0.0803457647562027, 0.022762566804885864, 0.015122490003705025, 0.07335235923528671, 0.02311405912041664, -0.02232356183230877, -0.047970645129680634, -0.018477316945791245, -0.04478680342435837, 0.026017405092716217, 0.02121221274137497, 0.08302050828933716, 0.023012416437268257, -0.005439374130219221, -0.032750003039836884, -0.020502179861068726, 0.05465886741876602, 0.048229068517684937, -0.026611734181642532, 0.004062851425260305, 0.015683727338910103, 0.032019082456827164, -0.015905553475022316, -0.0577705092728138, -0.014915846288204193, 0.007181807421147823, 0.12627841532230377, -0.03129063546657562, -0.048241954296827316, -0.011132224462926388, 0.024756046012043953, -0.030764976516366005, 0.06805586814880371, 0.02722100168466568, 0.014178103767335415, -0.009961328469216824, -0.06201500445604324, 0.0066069550812244415, 0.026673056185245514, -0.043661072850227356, 0.019859084859490395, -0.06169584393501282, -0.052079446613788605, -0.017712093889713287, -0.01806826703250408, -0.011203273199498653, -0.040574170649051666, 0.023198941722512245, 0.04322124645113945, -0.03208494931459427, -0.00838843360543251, 0.022812793031334877, 0.06701603531837463, 0.013132574036717415, -0.008674131706357002, 0.04779934138059616, 0.011457731947302818, -0.11923489719629288, 0.05398421734571457, 0.008273662067949772, 0.034493472427129745, -0.04288419708609581, 0.005358781199902296, -0.03139529004693031, 0.03575233370065689, 0.0717582032084465, -0.022850824519991875, 0.042040396481752396, 0.03234764188528061, -0.022005632519721985, -0.03901638090610504, -0.018209151923656464, 0.06264252215623856, -0.046656426042318344, -0.01906857080757618, -0.04609711468219757, 0.017302755266427994, 0.05856010317802429, -0.05655348300933838, 0.048666104674339294, 0.004712328780442476, 0.023310506716370583, -0.029287947341799736, 0.0175588708370924, 0.0419621616601944, -0.04112820699810982, 0.01574612781405449, 0.036729395389556885, -0.009865286760032177, -0.0038396830204874277, 0.030019735917448997, -0.05499828979372978, 0.10940228402614594, 0.03915712982416153, 0.014608923345804214, -0.00039835061761550605, 0.025442831218242645, 0.014547756873071194, -0.03394825756549835, -0.017013177275657654, 0.03676733374595642, 0.030718009918928146, -0.11528605222702026, -0.0028808258939534426, 0.05007706582546234, -0.02800898626446724, 0.024795249104499817, 0.0010429916437715292, -0.04078303277492523, 0.060020312666893005, 0.026678316295146942, -0.04310591146349907, 0.021124202758073807, 0.041218675673007965, 0.018066011369228363, -0.06260396540164948, 0.024118924513459206, -0.07859677821397781, -0.016565371304750443, -0.14106814563274384, 0.007455633487552404, -0.045041270554065704, 0.01552582997828722, 0.040957093238830566, -0.04610750079154968, 0.11600400507450104, 0.023246997967362404, 0.047101788222789764, -0.07068042457103729, 0.00202569249086082, 0.05208491161465645, -0.06010790169239044, -0.01854523830115795, 0.005964766256511211, -0.0037493351846933365, -0.04124143719673157, -0.016251645982265472, 0.054372139275074005, 0.016298292204737663, 0.025930864736437798, 0.044116005301475525, -0.011917638592422009, 0.04771748185157776, -0.013209638185799122, 0.013892131857573986, -0.011975024826824665, 0.0335729606449604, 0.07586755603551865, 0.005674539599567652, -0.03516938537359238 ]
19
19
The Role of Time in the Creation of Knowledge
This paper I assume that in humans the creation of knowledge depends on a discrete time, or stage, sequential decision-making process subjected to a stochastic, information transmitting environment. For each time-stage, this environment randomly transmits Shannon type information-packets to the decision-maker, who examines each of them for relevancy and then determines his optimal choices. Using this set of relevant information-packets, the decision-maker adapts, over time, to the stochastic nature of his environment, and optimizes the subjective expected rate-of-growth of knowledge. The decision-maker's optimal actions, lead to a decision function that involves, over time, his view of the subjective entropy of the environmental process and other important parameters at each time-stage of the process. Using this model of human behavior, one could create psychometric experiments using computer simulation and real decision-makers, to play programmed games to measure the resulting human performance.
[ -0.07033994793891907, -0.04129624366760254, 0.02170054242014885, 0.04835250973701477, -0.056400325149297714, -0.1371433138847351, 0.04290514066815376, -0.013490088284015656, 0.00011198663560207933, 0.019849710166454315, -0.027452195063233376, -0.04125683754682541, 0.01642305590212345, 0.037988338619470596, 0.0022142515517771244, -0.09529925882816315, -0.04167339578270912, 0.0033595869317650795, -0.014003012329339981, -0.03108138218522072, -0.025602711364626884, 0.006942231208086014, 0.023541953414678574, 0.013383297249674797, -0.07173427194356918, -0.026964817196130753, -0.04288187623023987, 0.01955379545688629, -0.03615076467394829, -0.05017341673374176, -0.06843754649162292, 0.006075467448681593, -0.03240321949124336, -0.009539837948977947, 0.07664615660905838, -0.027027197182178497, 0.05006547272205353, -0.062214989215135574, -0.06559879332780838, -0.11706627905368805, 0.002275061560794711, 0.019750166684389114, 0.025130620226264, -0.03655261918902397, 0.03418179228901863, 0.04704403504729271, 0.010323530994355679, 0.03536778688430786, 0.014807278290390968, 0.06831273436546326, -0.0779816284775734, 0.012836559675633907, 0.00256211101077497, -0.04097378998994827, 0.00009797720122151077, 0.05158435180783272, -0.030729414895176888, 0.013131813146173954, -0.07047025114297867, -0.03665207698941231, -0.05010166019201279, 0.10060780495405197, -0.03843279927968979, 0.04079173505306244, 0.0245332233607769, 0.04800404608249664, -0.12592990696430206, -0.0023295432329177856, -0.009702358394861221, -0.01701759174466133, 0.016292177140712738, 0.012155898846685886, -0.009958344511687756, -0.04606027156114578, -0.016857927665114403, 0.028968501836061478, -0.0055460999719798565, 0.0476737879216671, -0.0027433824725449085, 0.1504712551832199, -0.0701407790184021, 0.08386518806219101, -0.043369490653276443, 0.04350684955716133, -0.0392548143863678, 0.0022243212442845106, -0.028308488428592682, -0.0169100072234869, -0.021089578047394753, -0.012296654284000397, 0.0015556910075247288, 0.04058323800563812, -0.017772208899259567, 0.008634024299681187, -0.01690622791647911, 0.13396281003952026, -0.062415968626737595, 0.02181999757885933, -0.02358326129615307, 0.054056566208601, -0.0004315717378631234, -0.010359924286603928, 0.06467608362436295, 0.053071849048137665, 0.04547065496444702, -0.005952903535217047, 0.032398488372564316, 0.045046351850032806, 0.03752013295888901, -0.03258916735649109, 0.020149290561676025, -0.01012911181896925, 0.039568379521369934, -0.03561868146061897, -0.0735500156879425, 0.04826075956225395, 0.00826953910291195, 0.04909472540020943, -0.014870917424559593, 0.060926537960767746, 0.04999218508601189, 0.027786049991846085, -0.05300063267350197, -0.059538643807172775, 0.044546566903591156, -0.04097389429807663, 0.011135599575936794, -0.07072191685438156, 0.11427649110555649, 0.0020327880047261715, -0.05417197197675705, -0.0649765357375145, -0.05105625465512276, -0.0694717988371849, -0.04600214958190918, 0.022026261314749718, 0.06643727421760559, -0.04054371640086174, -0.07997254282236099, 0.07477934658527374, 0.062088493257761, -0.07311660051345825, -0.04645107313990593, -0.018263420090079308, -0.0000878160644788295, 0.0004435812879819423, 0.0011332491412758827, 0.04597087949514389, 0.039884887635707855, -0.01928400620818138, -0.04834192246198654, 0.01751747354865074, 0.020544657483696938, 0.041206732392311096, -0.044139422476291656, 0.015564987435936928, -0.09380599856376648, 0.009819713421165943, -0.04858986288309097, 0.0038138790987432003, -0.004324594046920538, -0.009053733199834824, 0.004735039081424475, 0.03475469350814819, 0.020113356411457062, 0.002522093243896961, -0.04378419741988182, -0.006033712532371283, -0.032963186502456665, -0.03192787989974022, -0.024360299110412598, 0.022029347717761993, -0.03263171389698982, 0.024318542331457138, -0.013284409418702126, -0.08391009271144867, -0.02125765196979046, 0.033701714128255844, -0.017550243064761162, 0.02824259176850319, -0.0007614903151988983, -0.12125996500253677, -0.05615821108222008, -0.042700111865997314, 0.022862756624817848, 0.06942504644393921, 0.02768036723136902, 0.04369574412703514, 0.08009635657072067, 0.027023956179618835, -0.03651222214102745, 0.008634640835225582, 0.0317084826529026, -0.017697934061288834, 0.022266775369644165, -0.04357407987117767, -0.03109034337103367, 0.02570958621799946, 0.02915351279079914, 0.06991071999073029, 0.02480543963611126, 0.05710790678858757, -0.0653197392821312, -0.025351058691740036, -0.010424003936350346, -0.0024320005904883146, 0.020129835233092308, 0.006447708234190941, -0.02332278899848461, -0.09008485078811646, -0.0380067378282547, -0.039080750197172165, -0.0027919013518840075, -0.020390620455145836, 0.05376485362648964, -0.06740566343069077, -0.11050914227962494, -0.009041279554367065, -0.03136488050222397, 0.0025593596510589123, -0.0260865930467844, 0.07542427629232407, 0.016234057024121284, 0.06778448075056076, -0.09329985082149506, -0.08502943813800812, 0.016704048961400986, -0.005151029676198959, -0.006500392220914364, 0.024453774094581604, -0.040014948695898056, -0.041643884032964706, -0.04950764775276184, -0.0007313044625334442, -0.04177834838628769, 0.025195514783263206, 0.03002583049237728, -0.0024349349550902843, 0.005868471227586269, -0.029937852174043655, -0.0253093633800745, 0.07797688990831375, 0.008776764385402203, 0.012660509906709194, 0.02196683920919895, -0.021729761734604836, 0.06103827431797981, 0.03955475986003876, -0.035354167222976685, 0.030518749728798866, 0.010251911357045174, -0.002850027522072196, -0.04848875105381012, 0.0341610386967659, 0.04654876887798309, -0.045360006392002106, -0.006458083633333445, 0.030749566853046417, 0.0474102720618248, -0.012961061671376228, -0.0503765307366848, -0.0527210496366024, -0.013197786174714565, 0.037574462592601776, 0.004061675630509853, -0.0007627225131727755, -0.023113178089261055, 0.04292408376932144, 0.044578667730093, 0.011940629221498966, 0.05977899953722954, 0.034652601927518845, -0.018250787630677223, 0.09232568740844727, -0.05363377928733826, -0.006168960593640804, 0.03184065967798233, 0.029964879155158997, -0.03734935447573662, -0.09106215834617615, -0.012945057824254036, 0.01232619397342205, 0.02927367016673088, 0.0029492813628166914, -0.053087834268808365, 0.0289180725812912, 0.0039727226831018925, 0.04908318445086479, -0.013048517517745495, 0.04373672604560852, -0.05996193364262581, 0.03353102132678032, -0.09427299350500107, -0.02768317237496376, 0.013822633773088455, -0.03997904434800148, 0.060609884560108185, -0.03338946774601936, 0.010370631702244282, 0.0037055136635899544, -0.014438682235777378, -0.037671491503715515, 0.054427456110715866, 0.060346733778715134, 0.03321007266640663, 0.06337019801139832, 0.016304796561598778, 0.04337693750858307, -0.04459931701421738, 0.021938059478998184, 0.014351175166666508, 0.033696599304676056, -0.09953301399946213, 0.027143141254782677, 0.024146365001797676, 0.002136163180693984, -0.0024424383882433176, -0.0870676264166832, -0.032761938869953156, 0.01809840090572834, 0.003108182456344366, -0.07451706379652023, -0.022561591118574142, -0.005808096844702959, -0.07411203533411026, -0.008282775990664959, -0.00516644399613142, 0.022892391309142113, -0.03523110970854759, 0.03425271436572075, -0.04198770970106125, -0.07399854063987732, 0.06383861601352692, 0.14547044038772583, -0.09607764333486557, 0.01794210821390152, -0.010634672828018665, -0.016284983605146408, 0.008781188167631626, 0.04435880482196808, -0.030335944145917892, -0.14138951897621155, 0.013398763723671436, 0.017008071765303612, 0.05159478262066841, 0.03849320113658905, 0.10369668900966644, 0.0005669326055794954, 0.016227325424551964, -0.02362700179219246, 0.028584707528352737, -0.018609028309583664, -0.02633393183350563, 0.033706311136484146, -0.06841367483139038, 0.02459363453090191, -0.007490316405892372, -0.003778571030125022, 0.015297122299671173, 0.008289480581879616, 0.00590831134468317, -0.0165194571018219, -0.07677868753671646, -0.10393904894590378, 0.04635027423501015, 0.009516529738903046, 0.004038233309984207, -0.06160052865743637, -0.04206737130880356, -0.007294571027159691, -0.0029856415931135416, 0.009642661549150944, -0.03530988097190857, 0.017195887863636017, -0.0418124720454216, -0.059256136417388916, 0.02541525661945343, -0.011723711155354977, -0.0650642141699791, 0.06485612690448761, -0.006184065714478493, -0.017433471977710724, -0.018184371292591095, -0.0419684499502182, -0.05262008681893349, -0.005115147214382887, -0.0036404177080839872, -0.004547192715108395, 0.09701577574014664, -0.010270077735185623, -0.05844884365797043, -0.02698989026248455, -0.06472554802894592, 0.04350801557302475, 0.06562123447656631, -0.06081671267747879, 0.06536498665809631, 0.006724189501255751, -0.024636389687657356, -0.011158366687595844, 0.02079145796597004, -0.12026095390319824, -0.050725605338811874, -0.02149299532175064, 0.006036681123077869, 0.017166374251246452, 0.04417936131358147, -0.007778992876410484, -0.03005940094590187, 0.04795259237289429, 0.015095684677362442, -0.0008328271214850247, -0.022658471018075943, -0.03427944704890251, -0.0652279406785965, 0.04975954443216324, 0.054983463138341904, -0.0024314052425324917, 0.028362317010760307, -0.08061647415161133, 0.03325234353542328, 0.010771211236715317, -0.004182609263807535, 0.0019178342772647738, -0.007442351430654526, -0.043720442801713943, 0.02403005212545395, -0.01240879949182272, -0.008936289697885513, 0.0359681136906147, -0.056332871317863464, -0.04801643267273903, -0.02027149684727192, -0.0026744059287011623, 0.004491808824241161, -0.023632492870092392, 0.013069262728095055, -0.02319442667067051, 0.010371741838753223, 0.03734473139047623, -0.02011057920753956, -0.04448457434773445, 0.00010361125896451995, 0.008023395203053951, 0.0002921601990237832, 0.020959464833140373, 0.020473627373576164, -0.022521264851093292, -0.011213523335754871, -0.026601457968354225, -0.0058800941333174706, 0.016065964475274086, 0.0001003947836579755, -0.013360479846596718, 0.012124893255531788, -0.004250536672770977, 0.019137203693389893, 0.027524638921022415, 0.03802848234772682, -0.023154838010668755, 0.01972832903265953, -0.03863193094730377, 0.014836539514362812, 0.012926140800118446, -0.06158740445971489, -0.010671432130038738, 0.04580576345324516, -0.04666511341929436, 0.0712277740240097, 0.03517709672451019, -0.04861718416213989, -0.036611903458833694, -0.02319210208952427, -0.038927674293518066, 0.027305731549859047, 0.024012800306081772, 0.0045206318609416485, -0.039779745042324066, -0.06001327186822891, -0.07756603509187698, -0.00197068159468472, 0.05868036672472954, -0.053391799330711365, 0.0037067588418722153, 0.06050160154700279, -0.036226481199264526, 0.0460224524140358, 0.04399097338318825, 0.05326236039400101, 0.05355870723724365, -0.03245154023170471, -0.07948985695838928, -0.022555632516741753, -0.019303493201732635, 0.06225524842739105, -0.024248292669653893, -0.002734819194301963, 0.010407257825136185, 0.017727145925164223, 0.07415720820426941, 0.011277399025857449, 0.017326850444078445, 0.027679620310664177, 0.017609506845474243, 0.0101411622017622, 0.038227882236242294, 0.0727028176188469, 0.07805802673101425, -0.045758288353681564, -0.0008681247709318995, 0.006756605114787817, 0.061748258769512177 ]
20
20
Clustering and Feature Selection using Sparse Principal Component Analysis
In this paper, we study the application of sparse principal component analysis (PCA) to clustering and feature selection problems. Sparse PCA seeks sparse factors, or linear combinations of the data variables, explaining a maximum amount of variance in the data while having only a limited number of nonzero coefficients. PCA is often used as a simple clustering technique and sparse factors allow us here to interpret the clusters in terms of a reduced set of variables. We begin with a brief introduction and motivation on sparse PCA and detail our implementation of the algorithm in d'Aspremont et al. (2005). We then apply these results to some classic clustering and feature selection problems arising in biology.
[ 0.04723716527223587, 0.005349066108465195, 0.04346657544374466, 0.03579334169626236, 0.010850484482944012, -0.003969576675444841, -0.04168243706226349, -0.0011381999356672168, 0.0004288814670871943, 0.03978349268436432, 0.06139208376407623, -0.02155531384050846, 0.010902845300734043, 0.08778735995292664, -0.09357328712940216, 0.04343840852379799, -0.0476936474442482, -0.05039539933204651, 0.0027415005024522543, -0.03264845907688141, -0.015195488929748535, -0.0009438461274839938, 0.012120909057557583, -0.018963128328323364, 0.029278159141540527, -0.00044999163947068155, -0.034052327275276184, -0.02632914111018181, 0.01966136507689953, 0.0003039974544662982, -0.017047923058271408, 0.011671994812786579, 0.055699750781059265, 0.023211108520627022, 0.03373919427394867, -0.0826137512922287, 0.007787995971739292, 0.08534223586320877, -0.023746952414512634, -0.02009458653628826, -0.01087115053087473, 0.02379566989839077, 0.040385179221630096, 0.024747224524617195, 0.045097168534994125, -0.011872082948684692, 0.00579501548781991, 0.01097286120057106, 0.04920066148042679, 0.054945964366197586, -0.09910506755113602, -0.006637915037572384, -0.002527864184230566, 0.013423197902739048, -0.05385622754693031, -0.030625872313976288, -0.10491805523633957, -0.010950518772006035, 0.05613230913877487, -0.02085987851023674, 0.019866030663251877, 0.04250040650367737, -0.0013452627463266253, 0.019583595916628838, -0.04405781999230385, 0.0033203577622771263, 0.015659397467970848, 0.014283733442425728, -0.0357946939766407, -0.07057709246873856, 0.02237922139465809, -0.04363906383514404, -0.045504383742809296, 0.013481843285262585, 0.014287249185144901, 0.046699367463588715, 0.008565215393900871, 0.013027758337557316, -0.011774691753089428, 0.07666531205177307, 0.035950567573308945, 0.04428965598344803, 0.02991497330367565, 0.021850207820534706, -0.06329771131277084, -0.06533247232437134, 0.0336059108376503, -0.0872432291507721, -0.0017659856239333749, 0.050521254539489746, -0.03477887064218521, 0.04527876526117325, -0.012310819700360298, 0.018629180267453194, -0.02113388292491436, -0.018064254894852638, -0.06309791654348373, 0.04399201273918152, 0.015832774341106415, 0.0780496895313263, -0.027434060350060463, -0.011373873800039291, 0.02363346517086029, 0.08167295902967453, -0.020606350153684616, 0.04752834886312485, -0.0777781680226326, 0.07285230606794357, 0.010298863053321838, -0.014634673483669758, -0.0033787202555686235, 0.01197903510183096, 0.05542641133069992, -0.002179492264986038, -0.1002408117055893, 0.09577667713165283, 0.016736136749386787, 0.07773939520120621, 0.08935149759054184, -0.05803060904145241, 0.025739187374711037, -0.003220865037292242, -0.11791234463453293, 0.03605824336409569, 0.05621206387877464, -0.02920757234096527, -0.004597867373377085, -0.04075225070118904, 0.015858866274356842, 0.03764290735125542, -0.06736637651920319, 0.007442757487297058, -0.030742140486836433, 0.012714626267552376, -0.09507393836975098, 0.0006303975242190063, 0.0466277152299881, -0.07054798305034637, -0.0036723646335303783, 0.03311189264059067, -0.011553849093616009, -0.07803873717784882, -0.0360734686255455, -0.033316414803266525, 0.030793124809861183, 0.03576025366783142, 0.03871963545680046, 0.013166449032723904, -0.019402416422963142, 0.018448159098625183, -0.0030846991576254368, -0.06346669793128967, 0.072702556848526, 0.055713951587677, 0.056454453617334366, -0.05261659994721413, 0.025536635890603065, -0.054791368544101715, 0.015663111582398415, 0.022381428629159927, -0.07705961167812347, -0.017896631732583046, 0.03890671953558922, -0.0027562256436794996, 0.021365392953157425, -0.0005323052173480392, 0.011844564229249954, -0.014613297767937183, -0.05449303612112999, -0.053952306509017944, 0.0022735793609172106, 0.02512405812740326, 0.02920238859951496, -0.03549424931406975, 0.08985044807195663, 0.029027650132775307, 0.004686017520725727, 0.019087428227066994, -0.021741816774010658, -0.029555337503552437, 0.05154864117503166, -0.011460496112704277, -0.013121462427079678, -0.05688242241740227, 0.022647716104984283, 0.05818185582756996, 0.022866882383823395, 0.02422787807881832, 0.027527010068297386, -0.00009671912266639993, 0.05867048725485802, -0.013495153747498989, 0.033384762704372406, 0.001019414747133851, -0.006751628126949072, -0.005433826707303524, -0.026340652257204056, -0.06899713724851608, 0.08437536656856537, 0.07679390162229538, 0.03878830000758171, 0.06281120330095291, -0.04355238005518913, -0.0839705616235733, -0.060072965919971466, 0.010629409924149513, 0.02027953788638115, 0.07131750881671906, -0.026667121797800064, -0.0011625949991866946, 0.02268354222178459, 0.005891707725822926, 0.052194345742464066, -0.011055503971874714, -0.01298994105309248, 0.05765582621097565, -0.021464599296450615, -0.05415603145956993, 0.08558543771505356, 0.08143071830272675, -0.04621676728129387, -0.008815280161798, -0.042911168187856674, 0.037700314074754715, 0.016609512269496918, 0.0774102509021759, 0.021644718945026398, -0.05766897648572922, -0.06126245856285095, 0.03998466208577156, -0.03660722076892853, -0.04341939464211464, -0.08721773326396942, -0.01652560755610466, -0.0082077756524086, 0.04411207512021065, -0.028265193104743958, -0.004574690945446491, 0.041763972491025925, 0.018197814002633095, 0.029573136940598488, 0.0008919205283746123, 0.0026030961889773607, -0.026896100491285324, -0.0220037829130888, -0.0023396764881908894, 0.07329412549734116, 0.07099225372076035, 0.02639874629676342, 0.046286966651678085, -0.051633622497320175, -0.018970442935824394, -0.04340684041380882, 0.08804203569889069, 0.006453295238316059, 0.008578102104365826, -0.09391254186630249, 0.01334571186453104, 0.018624261021614075, 0.04828031733632088, 0.0021071413066238165, 0.08111874759197235, -0.006044895853847265, -0.036570705473423004, 0.07968686521053314, 0.001735370373353362, 0.04198557510972023, 0.0019959360361099243, -0.028631720691919327, 0.04277052730321884, -0.008834087289869785, -0.007361611817032099, -0.048751283437013626, 0.12284020334482193, -0.03745410963892937, 0.016625255346298218, 0.04569132998585701, 0.020380215719342232, -0.0020774686709046364, -0.03760653734207153, 0.0014064796268939972, -0.02606191299855709, 0.042287956923246384, -0.0006051811506040394, 0.01281170267611742, -0.04167387634515762, 0.022587159648537636, -0.0034033849369734526, -0.03792595863342285, 0.028862014412879944, -0.08361461758613586, 0.031717948615550995, -0.07824157178401947, 0.010676146484911442, 0.06073319911956787, -0.09495270252227783, 0.03901399299502373, 0.06745705008506775, 0.10656276345252991, -0.01130927074700594, 0.012575037777423859, -0.011209293268620968, -0.023060455918312073, -0.015703096985816956, 0.004249528981745243, 0.04173201322555542, 0.15818056464195251, 0.067088283598423, -0.022676769644021988, 0.029735419899225235, 0.061797406524419785, 0.060225531458854675, -0.05771792680025101, -0.03952915966510773, -0.04558120295405388, 0.03199111297726631, -0.0017051592003554106, 0.02887878753244877, 0.028893692418932915, -0.02728372998535633, 0.030650954693555832, 0.0634559839963913, 0.014680481515824795, -0.06206066906452179, -0.032364606857299805, -0.05369499698281288, -0.025367168709635735, 0.13511250913143158, -0.03881654143333435, -0.036662254482507706, -0.010654451325535774, -0.09036441147327423, -0.044355325400829315, 0.0038329530507326126, 0.04459543153643608, 0.022940443828701973, -0.07077806442975998, -0.0025092444848269224, -0.06935428828001022, -0.07009465247392654, -0.012907789088785648, -0.009729708544909954, -0.0029081301763653755, 0.006621181964874268, -0.023623226210474968, 0.017195377498865128, 0.0439847968518734, -0.03294462710618973, -0.032332729548215866, 0.06342281401157379, -0.05334457755088806, 0.06126951426267624, -0.03542332723736763, 0.010685097426176071, -0.0703250840306282, 0.10556523501873016, 0.0815357193350792, -0.038761693984270096, -0.044290490448474884, -0.038036786019802094, -0.021696317940950394, -0.006041283253580332, -0.00917151477187872, 0.06128287315368652, -0.0415198877453804, 0.042763851583004, 0.034047067165374756, -0.013485882431268692, -0.015559247694909573, -0.01048982422798872, 0.054285865277051926, -0.015745483338832855, 0.007203286048024893, -0.02156195603311062, -0.017070118337869644, -0.05254435911774635, 0.009762411005795002, -0.04435465484857559, -0.007213194854557514, 0.01604403741657734, -0.009492731653153896, -0.00011120544513687491, -0.06430124491453171, 0.04339531436562538, -0.0326731838285923, -0.09336486458778381, -0.030854560434818268, 0.04754244163632393, 0.0019082571379840374, 0.016951963305473328, 0.008359311148524284, -0.0983358770608902, 0.02872598171234131, -0.07146110385656357, 0.033179719001054764, -0.0034462143667042255, 0.041241686791181564, 0.03233994543552399, 0.00462069408968091, -0.024978669360280037, 0.06704182922840118, -0.036929093301296234, 0.016413036733865738, -0.09708607196807861, -0.04301642253994942, 0.023065827786922455, -0.042117487639188766, 0.07260957360267639, -0.018576668575406075, 0.021809205412864685, 0.05603278800845146, 0.037950821220874786, -0.042186982929706573, 0.019554980099201202, 0.01759924367070198, -0.031003257259726524, -0.023160943761467934, -0.031010594218969345, 0.07363531738519669, -0.00750836031511426, 0.052720293402671814, -0.013614078052341938, 0.04688006639480591, 0.018897803500294685, 0.038635749369859695, 0.04104730859398842, 0.09717869758605957, 0.06816866993904114, 0.057774271816015244, 0.03444536402821541, 0.03193634748458862, 0.030963970348238945, -0.06497827917337418, 0.06407275795936584, 0.023801572620868683, 0.0006494949921034276, 0.03400258719921112, -0.00562462629750371, 0.011285305954515934, 0.027342548593878746, 0.003229131456464529, 0.0020420504733920097, -0.03421425446867943, -0.007055218331515789, 0.01621588133275509, -0.0032692516688257456, -0.013666745275259018, -0.038775429129600525, 0.0822400152683258, 0.054972972720861435, -0.03058810718357563, -0.005577818490564823, 0.019009944051504135, -0.01755712553858757, -0.011102389544248581, -0.018602099269628525, 0.08273383229970932, -0.054968662559986115, 0.019008174538612366, -0.03449052572250366, 0.012760340236127377, 0.045026954263448715, -0.004338354337960482, 0.018786072731018066, -0.08050237596035004, 0.030881348997354507, 0.02326321229338646, 0.014948193915188313, 0.051712121814489365, 0.057902991771698, 0.020914217457175255, 0.06501340121030807, -0.07308023422956467, -0.04591454565525055, 0.02110244706273079, -0.04879293963313103, 0.048114076256752014, -0.021715112030506134, -0.046852320432662964, -0.011114954017102718, 0.049445923417806625, -0.01315648015588522, 0.04178497567772865, 0.07755818217992783, 0.058498483151197433, 0.045678574591875076, -0.046481817960739136, 0.015377256087958813, -0.012526944279670715, -0.03880854696035385, 0.016416627913713455, -0.01699448749423027, 0.016853252425789833, -0.011439425870776176, -0.03563109040260315, 0.014078340493142605, -0.005838959477841854, -0.023075243458151817, 0.03052096627652645, -0.0005589285865426064, -0.01226717233657837, -0.07946326583623886, 0.02155137248337269, -0.008058086968958378, 0.049597304314374924, 0.013033224269747734, 0.08729729801416397, -0.014078070409595966, -0.03400380164384842, 0.04341579228639603, -0.019493035972118378, -0.022945797070860863 ]
21
21
Model Selection Through Sparse Maximum Likelihood Estimation
We consider the problem of estimating the parameters of a Gaussian or binary distribution in such a way that the resulting undirected graphical model is sparse. Our approach is to solve a maximum likelihood problem with an added l_1-norm penalty term. The problem as formulated is convex but the memory requirements and complexity of existing interior point methods are prohibitive for problems with more than tens of nodes. We present two new algorithms for solving problems with at least a thousand nodes in the Gaussian case. Our first algorithm uses block coordinate descent, and can be interpreted as recursive l_1-norm penalized regression. Our second algorithm, based on Nesterov's first order method, yields a complexity estimate with a better dependence on problem size than existing interior point methods. Using a log determinant relaxation of the log partition function (Wainwright & Jordan (2006)), we show that these same algorithms can be used to solve an approximate sparse maximum likelihood problem for the binary case. We test our algorithms on synthetic data, as well as on gene expression and senate voting records data.
[ -0.043012458831071854, -0.023106390610337257, 0.03365079686045647, 0.019984673708677292, 0.008400469087064266, -0.0283865574747324, 0.09050223976373672, -0.01865842193365097, -0.00019946895190514624, 0.008072827942669392, 0.022630397230386734, -0.08672680705785751, -0.039877936244010925, 0.09484823793172836, 0.0064867474138736725, -0.00030507941846735775, -0.004807246848940849, -0.014754158444702625, 0.006477500312030315, -0.03986974060535431, 0.018716944381594658, 0.023582570254802704, 0.003083603223785758, -0.06136612594127655, 0.004342942964285612, -0.005729822441935539, -0.009395105764269829, 0.021910306066274643, -0.011572501622140408, -0.055621590465307236, -0.029358219355344772, 0.03450150042772293, -0.006660123821347952, 0.044925153255462646, -0.017973370850086212, -0.059571586549282074, 0.02648114785552025, 0.017948605120182037, -0.02317037433385849, -0.0022503824438899755, 0.011876449920237064, 0.0005357229383662343, 0.009736710228025913, -0.003588458290323615, 0.06336268037557602, 0.005092681851238012, 0.06275328248739243, -0.024044619873166084, -0.025173161178827286, 0.056081607937812805, -0.07849249243736267, -0.008930548094213009, -0.05255299434065819, -0.044061239808797836, -0.026331648230552673, -0.027641255408525467, -0.09280098974704742, -0.021975381299853325, -0.022663917392492294, 0.0010371619137004018, 0.04839947447180748, 0.04188621789216995, -0.055778615176677704, 0.029181070625782013, -0.011775664985179901, -0.01572715863585472, -0.035335395485162735, 0.017564421519637108, -0.025289613753557205, 0.008899741806089878, 0.08020320534706116, -0.049557872116565704, 0.017985288053750992, 0.07164254039525986, 0.032705459743738174, -0.043397609144449234, -0.03842371329665184, -0.01991269737482071, 0.024778902530670166, 0.11720641702413559, -0.07726219296455383, 0.01752367988228798, 0.03615548089146614, -0.011758212931454182, -0.07826462388038635, 0.0357980839908123, -0.01722266525030136, -0.06578938663005829, -0.023112395778298378, -0.023216860368847847, -0.04244658350944519, 0.06582368910312653, -0.03132510930299759, 0.07120881229639053, -0.0637006089091301, 0.05329236015677452, -0.016535205766558647, -0.00457377452403307, 0.06833459436893463, 0.028618915006518364, 0.0010601060930639505, -0.08780599385499954, 0.01645946130156517, 0.07889506965875626, -0.041839599609375, 0.036953289061784744, -0.052562691271305084, 0.05316200479865074, 0.017154555767774582, -0.06858959794044495, 0.05025075003504753, -0.04986715689301491, 0.08612578362226486, 0.01820170134305954, -0.08925798535346985, 0.03853590413928032, 0.008769026026129723, 0.08804228156805038, -0.06872929632663727, 0.0037453442346304655, 0.06693577766418457, -0.032755400985479355, -0.08210866898298264, 0.02785484865307808, -0.008701195940375328, -0.02739320695400238, 0.02082614041864872, -0.07988657057285309, 0.07068494707345963, -0.0181993767619133, -0.06840138882398605, 0.027983728796243668, -0.03138447552919388, 0.028114691376686096, -0.11846574395895004, -0.024844588711857796, 0.09580159932374954, -0.009942950680851936, 0.038827262818813324, 0.0902923047542572, -0.03784395381808281, -0.04213407635688782, 0.027570292353630066, 0.007634088397026062, 0.03753960132598877, 0.06872191280126572, 0.040982794016599655, 0.02822449617087841, -0.016669217497110367, 0.00915003102272749, -0.019346505403518677, -0.0622192807495594, 0.026885023340582848, -0.0057085976004600525, 0.039397213608026505, -0.06442737579345703, -0.008996662683784962, -0.00011731666018022224, 0.027725858613848686, 0.0342748798429966, -0.10186344385147095, -0.017873089760541916, 0.03344034031033516, 0.0014664408518001437, 0.008400361984968185, 0.002402581973001361, -0.01056718174368143, -0.02476886846125126, 0.03233198821544647, -0.03401721268892288, 0.034203462302684784, -0.025044871494174004, 0.010646000504493713, 0.010039187036454678, 0.03683793917298317, 0.0049577997997403145, 0.0195000059902668, -0.0047522373497486115, 0.004838299006223679, 0.026305338367819786, 0.06041324883699417, -0.027481531724333763, -0.008208226412534714, 0.014282920397818089, 0.06385786831378937, 0.08218242228031158, -0.0055507635697722435, -0.003925055731087923, 0.05352875217795372, 0.03036222606897354, 0.05953114852309227, 0.002212124178186059, 0.09696705639362335, 0.0035182866267859936, -0.013721568509936333, 0.03283464163541794, -0.053639527410268784, -0.06854192167520523, 0.003154757432639599, 0.016816671937704086, 0.04932117089629173, -0.0451577790081501, -0.005671253893524408, -0.046958211809396744, -0.061010148376226425, 0.053654614835977554, 0.0369904600083828, -0.025931045413017273, -0.004622195847332478, 0.03529461845755577, -0.008355812169611454, -0.01512790098786354, 0.02385457418859005, -0.03409375250339508, -0.04890701174736023, -0.018883347511291504, -0.011881762184202671, -0.0355975478887558, 0.002771410159766674, 0.028485655784606934, -0.04675312340259552, 0.038755789399147034, -0.0004798515292350203, 0.053814031183719635, -0.10692398250102997, 0.02922993153333664, -0.007417426910251379, 0.01682068035006523, -0.05894654244184494, 0.04010622203350067, 0.08190236240625381, -0.02709275111556053, -0.016160927712917328, -0.007132385391741991, -0.03547576069831848, 0.04748348519206047, -0.03243902698159218, -0.02567022480070591, 0.018628474324941635, -0.003843496320769191, -0.03944084420800209, 0.06053554639220238, -0.040005866438150406, -0.03250669687986374, 0.05551232397556305, -0.023226849734783173, 0.0861242339015007, 0.060304511338472366, 0.05460188537836075, 0.07183738052845001, -0.028938032686710358, 0.03197526931762695, -0.07554227113723755, 0.056158408522605896, 0.03077978640794754, 0.010870515368878841, -0.0230136439204216, 0.05323553830385208, 0.07311606407165527, 0.03781934082508087, -0.010404101572930813, 0.014105889946222305, -0.047518789768218994, -0.03446206822991371, 0.10328599810600281, 0.054953254759311676, 0.013603990897536278, -0.026272837072610855, 0.004166823346167803, 0.037457119673490524, 0.012040000408887863, -0.09280563145875931, -0.07288168370723724, 0.06624175608158112, 0.009398817084729671, 0.0295201875269413, 0.04503447934985161, 0.06816723942756653, -0.03398464247584343, -0.013779052533209324, -0.023294340819120407, 0.0086976308375597, 0.04261333867907524, -0.01742491126060486, 0.03239179775118828, 0.03898141533136368, -0.03351334109902382, 0.002366090891882777, 0.034992825239896774, 0.024316908791661263, -0.0613214336335659, 0.058572590351104736, -0.047386284917593, -0.06628672033548355, 0.019345881417393684, -0.06401779502630234, 0.0600561760365963, -0.029534418135881424, -0.008243018761277199, -0.016014162451028824, 0.004965317435562611, -0.030073411762714386, 0.08482222259044647, -0.020777050405740738, 0.03281494230031967, 0.06887160241603851, 0.05807265639305115, 0.0465368814766407, -0.0527668334543705, -0.029792914167046547, 0.010043078102171421, 0.03143928572535515, -0.11592479795217514, -0.0386122465133667, -0.014278036542236805, 0.023525120690464973, -0.028889266774058342, -0.013452314771711826, -0.049887221306562424, -0.019073285162448883, -0.05169767886400223, 0.018235940486192703, 0.012179662473499775, -0.020380405709147453, -0.01728072203695774, -0.052118875086307526, -0.007462581619620323, 0.04902658611536026, -0.008664782159030437, -0.011145256459712982, -0.03282182291150093, -0.023093335330486298, -0.09208521246910095, 0.10071244835853577, -0.036134328693151474, 0.04011622816324234, -0.05913976579904556, -0.00964801013469696, -0.014202447608113289, -0.03566683828830719, -0.03459819406270981, -0.012442322447896004, -0.003985668066889048, 0.0009410959319211543, -0.00041235375101678073, 0.07975407689809799, 0.07312508672475815, -0.04940976947546005, -0.05259544402360916, 0.0019495757296681404, -0.06260036677122116, 0.03608877584338188, -0.012253941036760807, 0.02140623703598976, 0.00897900015115738, 0.09467583149671555, 0.12459313124418259, -0.05588141083717346, -0.003176395781338215, 0.02185850776731968, -0.07709769904613495, 0.03534781560301781, 0.02427360787987709, 0.009975921362638474, 0.025244280695915222, 0.04995115473866463, -0.013616515323519707, -0.0008123922743834555, -0.008006544783711433, 0.04806051775813103, 0.053646448999643326, 0.04105093330144882, 0.025231676176190376, -0.04363025724887848, 0.03596828877925873, -0.0497596301138401, 0.009530399926006794, -0.057635918259620667, 0.0017547592287883162, 0.0644763931632042, -0.03934866189956665, 0.025565383955836296, -0.03510357066988945, 0.014451530762016773, 0.056540291756391525, -0.07856673747301102, -0.03503710404038429, 0.0012938171857967973, 0.08489985018968582, -0.030820747837424278, 0.0022777370177209377, -0.024078231304883957, -0.006943753454834223, 0.043344903737306595, 0.04609738290309906, 0.04532177746295929, -0.0024361899122595787, 0.03369179368019104, -0.018823806196451187, -0.026763856410980225, -0.01938267983496189, 0.022916996851563454, 0.03346918150782585, -0.07544354349374771, -0.021093418821692467, -0.0479891337454319, -0.041752636432647705, 0.023392872884869576, -0.06169026717543602, 0.09463083744049072, 0.08650588244199753, 0.011809430085122585, -0.004318063613027334, 0.0008353947778232396, -0.05824921280145645, -0.016579411923885345, -0.024486307054758072, 0.041135016828775406, -0.021130966022610664, -0.011723087169229984, -0.04989996179938316, 0.09303399175405502, -0.013160175643861294, -0.010112326592206955, -0.009632416069507599, -0.016456877812743187, 0.06688930094242096, 0.10471566766500473, -0.0211342703551054, 0.07626482099294662, -0.0978580191731453, -0.014552012085914612, -0.03123062290251255, -0.0041264621540904045, -0.014604930765926838, -0.002196270739659667, -0.023415865376591682, -0.01293252408504486, -0.012794899754226208, 0.0016065388917922974, 0.03468713536858559, -0.0013192846672609448, -0.03107965551316738, 0.00417025201022625, 0.030404800549149513, 0.038687072694301605, 0.06791765987873077, 0.026569513604044914, 0.08815544843673706, 0.0006140898331068456, -0.032899659126996994, 0.035685449838638306, 0.03300983086228371, 0.013464534655213356, -0.0565900094807148, 0.008482594974339008, 0.027589302510023117, -0.010194149799644947, 0.06117599830031395, -0.015284647233784199, 0.006521899718791246, -0.002611092058941722, -0.012918565422296524, -0.005945025943219662, -0.073701873421669, 0.044677700847387314, -0.015599971637129784, -0.003512338036671281, 0.07822875678539276, 0.00006315918290056288, -0.11454375833272934, 0.016893582418560982, 0.01549164392054081, -0.017206406220793724, -0.04494232311844826, 0.015299520455300808, 0.01433657854795456, -0.08708550781011581, -0.011744112707674503, -0.035106196999549866, -0.008162617683410645, -0.04754000902175903, -0.04042591527104378, -0.018627110868692398, 0.02451987937092781, 0.012948814779520035, 0.007034827023744583, 0.051778338849544525, 0.09792707860469818, 0.0006724511040374637, -0.04673793911933899, -0.029252542182803154, 0.00543641485273838, 0.06247732788324356, -0.02134763076901436, 0.02836996130645275, -0.0014216455165296793, 0.004985986743122339, 0.013040006160736084, -0.002910311333835125, 0.041599925607442856, -0.0006688470020890236, 0.0871666744351387, -0.009797494858503342, 0.04447939619421959, 0.11300286650657654, 0.004222224000841379, -0.06304968893527985, -0.08490871638059616, 0.0424872487783432, -0.02696215733885765, 0.005518646910786629 ]
22
22
Optimal Solutions for Sparse Principal Component Analysis
Given a sample covariance matrix, we examine the problem of maximizing the variance explained by a linear combination of the input variables while constraining the number of nonzero coefficients in this combination. This is known as sparse principal component analysis and has a wide array of applications in machine learning and engineering. We formulate a new semidefinite relaxation to this problem and derive a greedy algorithm that computes a full set of good solutions for all target numbers of non zero coefficients, with total complexity O(n^3), where n is the number of variables. We then use the same relaxation to derive sufficient conditions for global optimality of a solution, which can be tested in O(n^3) per pattern. We discuss applications in subset selection and sparse recovery and show on artificial examples and biological data that our algorithm does provide globally optimal solutions in many cases.
[ 0.044704534113407135, -0.018270811066031456, 0.03360775485634804, 0.000551476376131177, -0.002583972876891494, 0.004144920967519283, 0.01661212556064129, -0.03444699943065643, -0.06111166998744011, 0.04885000362992287, 0.054055355489254, 0.0038041379302740097, -0.014917755499482155, 0.058839183300733566, -0.07674844563007355, -0.026797879487276077, -0.09656547755002975, -0.03185521066188812, -0.017158864066004753, -0.07044927775859833, -0.022005241364240646, 0.02540803700685501, 0.027421709150075912, -0.010267217643558979, 0.0190763920545578, -0.018800264224410057, -0.07302747666835785, 0.015817677602171898, 0.026599233970046043, 0.020168770104646683, -0.05168082192540169, 0.006943438667804003, 0.017441509291529655, 0.0013430870603770018, -0.009915155358612537, -0.06281895935535431, 0.0552024245262146, 0.052959926426410675, -0.047359779477119446, -0.034086570143699646, -0.015735425055027008, 0.036048609763383865, 0.05560949444770813, -0.06223045662045479, 0.08479615300893784, 0.020136918872594833, 0.05613007768988609, -0.012080756016075611, 0.010604792274534702, 0.029855720698833466, -0.04350556805729866, 0.016269134357571602, -0.013684864155948162, -0.022097844630479813, -0.009794588200747967, 0.004925730172544718, -0.05319644883275032, 0.0026370298583060503, 0.03472526744008064, -0.004005911760032177, 0.04394415766000748, 0.05545817315578461, 0.004112367518246174, 0.00666012242436409, -0.06286785751581192, -0.01403869315981865, -0.07619243115186691, -0.0453137531876564, -0.07093631476163864, -0.040614042431116104, 0.02915002405643463, -0.07369211316108704, -0.008056591264903545, -0.0373024083673954, 0.04062509164214134, 0.0386938750743866, 0.008839147165417671, 0.029303710907697678, -0.004593376535922289, 0.034376341849565506, 0.024654904380440712, 0.05949600413441658, 0.02901073917746544, 0.03323305398225784, -0.08657003194093704, 0.012970170006155968, 0.014669586904346943, 0.0018524478655308485, -0.021818047389388084, -0.00007736459519946948, -0.010739265941083431, 0.046922799199819565, -0.05742715299129486, 0.06431505084037781, 0.024263406172394753, -0.002510285470634699, -0.03879387676715851, 0.020572736859321594, -0.0326775424182415, 0.014817647635936737, -0.0074076405726373196, -0.0009520722669549286, 0.06110401079058647, 0.0942564383149147, -0.013558494858443737, 0.04591085761785507, -0.0988258421421051, 0.041266635060310364, -0.02846336178481579, 0.006319629494100809, -0.0068307435140013695, -0.037364862859249115, 0.02637871541082859, -0.03309740498661995, -0.08963422477245331, 0.0621488019824028, 0.04976847767829895, 0.07464711368083954, 0.02549177035689354, -0.054645340889692307, 0.046122413128614426, 0.005683698691427708, -0.08728493750095367, 0.032107532024383545, 0.02747628279030323, -0.0484062023460865, 0.07948877662420273, -0.06290313601493835, 0.03988323733210564, 0.008943037129938602, -0.036643270403146744, -0.009684253484010696, 0.009023687802255154, -0.012470760382711887, -0.09534573554992676, 0.04373331367969513, 0.026319367811083794, -0.013532577082514763, -0.04199890047311783, 0.01235366053879261, 0.0049885655753314495, -0.008028127253055573, -0.03500046953558922, -0.015158680267632008, 0.038089171051979065, 0.025035930797457695, 0.0038195038214325905, 0.04533891752362251, -0.0813412070274353, -0.02716207318007946, 0.013600378297269344, 0.009780478663742542, -0.01291788648813963, 0.09876016527414322, 0.08065330982208252, -0.07393494248390198, 0.010854425840079784, -0.05505774915218353, 0.04643835872411728, 0.08016602694988251, -0.064982108771801, -0.024942779913544655, 0.006894152145832777, 0.07925873249769211, -0.02709890715777874, -0.0052670943550765514, 0.04101785272359848, 0.0007457395549863577, -0.07261930406093597, -0.024895576760172844, -0.030612971633672714, 0.0010859124595299363, 0.03374282270669937, 0.032474081963300705, 0.08428800851106644, 0.04040812328457832, -0.0067419926635921, 0.007425057236105204, -0.033350516110658646, -0.001626406330615282, 0.10162348300218582, 0.02198025956749916, -0.009677382186055183, -0.015293864533305168, 0.03384210914373398, 0.10199294984340668, 0.06793274730443954, 0.02149290405213833, 0.025847360491752625, 0.05720440298318863, 0.035063888877630234, -0.021737094968557358, 0.025113720446825027, 0.061082832515239716, -0.0037050123792141676, -0.0053764875046908855, -0.041688017547130585, -0.060994718223810196, 0.03495778143405914, 0.07411462813615799, 0.09792876988649368, 0.04954982548952103, -0.0274946428835392, -0.07319319993257523, -0.06523951143026352, 0.019022608175873756, 0.018661174923181534, 0.016023719683289528, 0.030218712985515594, -0.008995954878628254, 0.060831326991319656, 0.03582403436303139, 0.019896680489182472, -0.009134541265666485, -0.006292153615504503, -0.029089707881212234, -0.015655934810638428, -0.055085428059101105, 0.013246841728687286, 0.04330402985215187, -0.08080893009901047, 0.05116715282201767, 0.0031297921668738127, 0.0017837168416008353, -0.09608626365661621, 0.0007556346827186644, -0.006860243622213602, 0.0040388391353189945, -0.0990813747048378, 0.02368880994617939, -0.0501616969704628, -0.017800170928239822, -0.04733196645975113, -0.04539765790104866, -0.07916759699583054, 0.0342206247150898, 0.004482355900108814, -0.04752553254365921, 0.013941986486315727, -0.0033912339713424444, -0.01288040541112423, 0.014349349774420261, 0.02853098139166832, -0.06135284900665283, 0.03981989249587059, 0.008681176230311394, 0.04359760507941246, 0.009217784740030766, -0.08472461253404617, 0.012225192040205002, 0.011527899652719498, -0.0008435164927504957, -0.02811599150300026, 0.109153613448143, 0.051085252314805984, -0.01671731285750866, -0.04028988629579544, 0.04882089048624039, -0.03746132180094719, 0.015141728334128857, 0.049823977053165436, 0.0734676644206047, -0.0394870899617672, -0.0023711039684712887, 0.0866711288690567, 0.02152242511510849, 0.00932258740067482, 0.020189862698316574, -0.007676268462091684, 0.03971948102116585, -0.04087120294570923, -0.00986502319574356, -0.07202596217393875, 0.07569453120231628, -0.05123309791088104, 0.018646186217665672, 0.03435955196619034, 0.02228716015815735, 0.03598310053348541, 0.007674669846892357, -0.054210908710956573, 0.06486918777227402, 0.02284126915037632, -0.020420169457793236, 0.02055828832089901, 0.014924057759344578, -0.005322558339685202, 0.022621145471930504, -0.08908698707818985, 0.0552273765206337, -0.10129336267709732, 0.029288075864315033, -0.05658550560474396, 0.058143336325883865, 0.04072894528508186, -0.05859532579779625, 0.07111918926239014, 0.03981819748878479, 0.06111633777618408, 0.02632216364145279, 0.0067209466360509396, 0.020841706544160843, -0.023671623319387436, -0.02578818053007126, 0.03546997532248497, 0.01841703988611698, 0.1270485818386078, 0.027645675465464592, -0.011823926120996475, 0.06616632640361786, 0.030353112146258354, 0.00958209577947855, -0.05576278269290924, -0.05662485957145691, -0.033497873693704605, 0.03579449653625488, -0.03486063331365585, 0.007711599115282297, -0.0280844047665596, -0.015809863805770874, -0.01852075383067131, 0.053767282515764236, 0.07018628716468811, 0.008328876458108425, -0.06630741059780121, -0.062260039150714874, -0.019720349460840225, 0.06318355351686478, -0.0397992804646492, 0.03339878097176552, -0.05016012489795685, -0.028901485726237297, -0.0451478436589241, 0.07100166380405426, 0.011340310797095299, 0.00671164458617568, -0.06653713434934616, 0.024099381640553474, -0.0228244848549366, -0.02233605831861496, -0.0056387376971542835, -0.10634974390268326, -0.01525629498064518, -0.03415888175368309, 0.028844334185123444, 0.09856617450714111, 0.06405165046453476, -0.017317581921815872, -0.0346786268055439, 0.023847468197345734, -0.06435450166463852, 0.013811640441417694, -0.036785323172807693, 0.029828662052750587, -0.046836670488119125, 0.07934780418872833, 0.13376536965370178, -0.03582128509879112, -0.009497938677668571, -0.016502534970641136, -0.05994771420955658, -0.020030446350574493, -0.003021976910531521, 0.05962372198700905, -0.03935329243540764, -0.002872756915166974, -0.03206632286310196, 0.03586919978260994, 0.03397046774625778, 0.017189091071486473, 0.008993553929030895, 0.006036624312400818, 0.016974426805973053, 0.013903521932661533, 0.0016580357914790511, -0.016898607835173607, 0.05610724166035652, -0.018464254215359688, -0.07980183511972427, 0.04564247652888298, -0.03911665827035904, 0.04340321943163872, -0.014496823772788048, 0.005367592442780733, -0.0074757905676960945, -0.001805140869691968, -0.07520340383052826, 0.06932181119918823, 0.034477874636650085, -0.018088513985276222, -0.011741639114916325, -0.03305154666304588, 0.03980036452412605, 0.014280938543379307, 0.03171954303979874, 0.03144459053874016, 0.058705706149339676, -0.0046423752792179585, -0.029028674587607384, 0.015737365931272507, 0.05735670402646065, 0.014704976230859756, 0.061068665236234665, -0.1331186443567276, -0.025752367451786995, 0.01508405152708292, -0.01045081578195095, 0.04061495140194893, -0.011854136362671852, 0.042805977165699005, 0.020086955279111862, 0.02504066191613674, -0.037622805684804916, 0.039059437811374664, -0.01786179654300213, 0.05845925956964493, -0.034349553287029266, -0.018020350486040115, 0.04626401141285896, 0.003994377795606852, 0.056598301976919174, -0.04405741021037102, 0.007877805270254612, 0.01082320511341095, 0.07173777371644974, 0.02106969989836216, 0.06551087647676468, 0.07177390903234482, -0.0364738330245018, -0.023723620921373367, -0.037588201463222504, -0.017584674060344696, -0.042633071541786194, 0.08295060694217682, 0.04220675304532051, 0.027770882472395897, 0.0619344599545002, 0.026734091341495514, 0.010956295765936375, 0.02493125945329666, -0.026607658714056015, 0.0499889999628067, -0.04980858787894249, -0.03437131270766258, 0.006481433752924204, -0.019014211371541023, -0.015226432122290134, 0.02818664163351059, 0.09051305055618286, 0.07234545052051544, -0.014182529412209988, 0.007658463902771473, -0.04003247618675232, 0.005001078825443983, 0.0224304236471653, 0.039576511830091476, 0.03957941755652428, -0.029443753883242607, 0.015878792852163315, -0.027705185115337372, 0.00002951098394987639, -0.022149167954921722, -0.016927281394600868, 0.008227525278925896, -0.04116317257285118, -0.04849947988986969, -0.022604478523135185, 0.05437702313065529, 0.04741450026631355, 0.022720754146575928, -0.013075540773570538, 0.05838754028081894, -0.08521869778633118, -0.032290294766426086, 0.0104637136682868, -0.011678160168230534, 0.03863721713423729, -0.026794346049427986, -0.036664947867393494, -0.002154381712898612, 0.014264017343521118, 0.03355461731553078, 0.03277304023504257, 0.0513899028301239, 0.04895317554473877, 0.09818027913570404, -0.03361794352531433, -0.0013303373707458377, 0.04938122257590294, -0.031598590314388275, 0.0327422097325325, 0.017730435356497765, 0.035744257271289825, -0.009606466628611088, -0.06990990042686462, 0.048236947506666183, 0.04946024715900421, -0.0062894090078771114, 0.03514016419649124, 0.05901317670941353, -0.038917381316423416, -0.05747576802968979, -0.05226309224963188, 0.025062641128897667, 0.031207749620079994, 0.0324692577123642, 0.03930756449699402, -0.008358445949852467, -0.12006305158138275, 0.08308176696300507, -0.06485366821289062, 0.0019368124194443226 ]
23
23
A New Generalization of Chebyshev Inequality for Random Vectors
In this article, we derive a new generalization of Chebyshev inequality for random vectors. We demonstrate that the new generalization is much less conservative than the classical generalization.
[ -0.07726430147886276, -0.018880000337958336, 0.12270510941743851, -0.09128718078136444, 0.001836225506849587, -0.005051140207797289, 0.021954510360956192, -0.0393146350979805, -0.005138025153428316, 0.0270401444286108, 0.01872091367840767, -0.04800181835889816, 0.009028046391904354, 0.048832789063453674, -0.016240524128079414, -0.03813273832201958, -0.004422875586897135, 0.041849151253700256, 0.0660325214266777, -0.03381264582276344, 0.01255061011761427, 0.029477698728442192, 0.0035998148377984762, -0.03841111809015274, -0.008306282572448254, -0.017561521381139755, 0.017911147326231003, 0.04207800701260567, 0.040027178823947906, -0.009379050694406033, -0.043649930506944656, 0.1009790226817131, -0.010015743784606457, 0.07994487881660461, 0.021153345704078674, -0.022772183641791344, 0.04694356024265289, 0.04515477642416954, -0.0490475669503212, -0.028722060844302177, -0.013762741349637508, -0.038063231855630875, 0.030833950266242027, -0.03753983601927757, 0.07333109527826309, -0.06604642421007156, 0.00620058411732316, 0.07399743795394897, -0.08049573004245758, 0.007784887216985226, -0.03165460005402565, -0.0027653833385556936, -0.05107823759317398, -0.0321706086397171, -0.0008641572203487158, -0.010009465739130974, 0.044362735003232956, 0.06604573130607605, -0.04116484522819519, 0.029463710263371468, 0.08909177035093307, 0.04722367599606514, -0.01590358465909958, -0.0560421496629715, -0.042616695165634155, 0.030452808365225792, -0.05457045137882233, -0.005568322725594044, 0.09184636920690536, -0.06482446938753128, -0.0534646175801754, 0.0020800542552024126, 0.04414725676178932, 0.016945334151387215, -0.018797026947140694, -0.05129406228661537, -0.03233960270881653, 0.032846659421920776, 0.056322090327739716, 0.049860112369060516, -0.08200491964817047, -0.024407705292105675, 0.04640265926718712, 0.025556843727827072, -0.07334614545106888, -0.021096697077155113, -0.04116258770227432, 0.030614588409662247, -0.05976429954171181, -0.09835648536682129, -0.016413599252700806, -0.027106696739792824, -0.06234060972929001, 0.05746149644255638, -0.07291650027036667, 0.029458757489919662, 0.05366671457886696, -0.04793248325586319, -0.0024084493052214384, 0.0128586171194911, 0.09041589498519897, 0.0246577151119709, 0.021864408627152443, 0.0037577718030661345, 0.06668711453676224, 0.04266604408621788, -0.030751347541809082, 0.04911533370614052, -0.06409255415201187, 0.015795674175024033, -0.04639705270528793, -0.04233171418309212, 0.02013983204960823, 0.014404559507966042, -0.048637814819812775, 0.06136741116642952, -0.0037977821193635464, 0.045395709574222565, 0.019637983292341232, -0.024696944281458855, 0.05984875187277794, -0.037271883338689804, 0.006995971780270338, 0.08181741833686829, 0.03298167884349823, -0.039035648107528687, 0.0668332502245903, 0.008294900879263878, 0.12132050842046738, -0.026038359850645065, -0.05767141655087471, 0.06779523938894272, 0.06741711497306824, -0.03775704279541969, 0.0011734674917533994, -0.023253872990608215, -0.0375811904668808, -0.0075384811498224735, -0.07440179586410522, 0.07338646054267883, 0.039068836718797684, -0.009658732451498508, -0.04103677719831467, 0.02537890337407589, 0.02550375834107399, 0.05962597578763962, 0.057278696447610855, 0.021189380437135696, -0.036957357078790665, 0.04976228252053261, -0.024551108479499817, 0.005033415742218494, -0.01702248863875866, 0.03895754739642143, 0.018070103600621223, -0.07174172252416611, -0.05778193473815918, 0.031078381463885307, -0.026874542236328125, 0.004159353673458099, -0.015069142915308475, -0.0374397449195385, -0.01072524581104517, -0.0212801955640316, 0.027276210486888885, -0.041234876960515976, 0.03000118024647236, -0.06577794253826141, 0.020904505625367165, -0.038606781512498856, -0.023215992376208305, -0.0003195626486558467, -0.018676429986953735, 0.03340967372059822, -0.081263966858387, 0.016066592186689377, -0.016474071890115738, -0.035005226731300354, -0.021986745297908783, -0.08261432498693466, 0.014999894425272942, -0.0857536569237709, 0.018292399123311043, 0.10423129051923752, 0.004147189669311047, 0.11238213628530502, 0.0927029699087143, 0.004347372800111771, -0.0266894344240427, -0.05035431683063507, 0.0803820863366127, 0.004003656096756458, 0.03361763432621956, -0.03628869354724884, -0.06087711825966835, -0.027485890313982964, 0.043295785784721375, -0.10477970540523529, 0.054399676620960236, 0.019895251840353012, -0.005210313480347395, 0.07298609614372253, -0.1001080796122551, -0.032415710389614105, 0.07422889024019241, 0.09833145886659622, -0.012678592465817928, -0.07225973904132843, -0.015476981177926064, -0.039611171931028366, -0.026256617158651352, 0.012357290834188461, 0.00637161685153842, -0.028572531417012215, -0.017618954181671143, -0.028923634439706802, -0.013457992114126682, -0.016710223630070686, 0.04599269479513168, 0.0026475563645362854, 0.03657802194356918, 0.036389220505952835, -0.0326564721763134, -0.008985983207821846, -0.006267159711569548, -0.006173345725983381, 0.06563493609428406, 0.06231940910220146, -0.005559938494116068, 0.03492008149623871, -0.087422214448452, -0.02824762649834156, 0.027812549844384193, 0.008810823783278465, 0.02040001004934311, 0.07591411471366882, -0.022013157606124878, -0.05982911214232445, 0.002860858803614974, -0.007015173323452473, -0.010827247984707355, -0.05502854660153389, 0.002153355162590742, -0.01361329946666956, -0.004678360652178526, -0.00958058051764965, 0.09131845831871033, -0.0004972422611899674, -0.03709776699542999, 0.022312389686703682, -0.02441118098795414, 0.02883223071694374, -0.0067967879585921764, 0.008061702363193035, 0.026831967756152153, 0.002590038813650608, -0.07031655311584473, -0.027857687324285507, 0.02929680608212948, 0.0021351093892008066, -0.04253871738910675, 0.08017807453870773, -0.03376069292426109, 0.05889127776026726, 0.09769963473081589, 0.02151426486670971, -0.0029725059866905212, 0.0033679844345897436, 0.08725745975971222, 0.08041787892580032, -0.01353214867413044, -0.033256758004426956, -0.06977030634880066, 0.009323792532086372, -0.030263397842645645, 0.01421558577567339, 0.03046601638197899, 0.045049820095300674, -0.021647892892360687, 0.012279616668820381, 0.009920865297317505, 0.07772722840309143, 0.013293866999447346, 0.021914826706051826, 0.013705571182072163, 0.04091687873005867, -0.0002441465621814132, -0.016574813053011894, 0.014657482504844666, 0.08965200185775757, -0.07923589646816254, 0.030308928340673447, -0.033506397157907486, 0.005006655119359493, 0.021212123334407806, -0.03548170626163483, 0.021572476252913475, 0.026798082515597343, 0.020213596522808075, -0.009975298307836056, -0.01816781610250473, -0.043929871171712875, 0.08950603753328323, -0.013128655031323433, 0.010120178572833538, 0.022141052410006523, -0.05280255526304245, -0.0506635382771492, -0.020592067390680313, 0.04929162561893463, -0.07287279516458511, -0.024875536561012268, 0.003852172289043665, -0.012284829281270504, 0.010289952158927917, -0.005256905220448971, -0.014303338713943958, -0.07620657235383987, -0.012270580045878887, -0.017687594518065453, -0.027500808238983154, 0.012916134670376778, 0.006778238341212273, -0.026189301162958145, -0.11308729648590088, -0.012493353337049484, 0.06055077910423279, 0.03032330609858036, -0.061054013669490814, -0.016005588695406914, 0.0069235749542713165, 0.09586531668901443, -0.014920221641659737, 0.018942993134260178, 0.02645903453230858, 0.042945899069309235, -0.05038698390126228, -0.028017599135637283, 0.011138339526951313, 0.003909038379788399, 0.056204795837402344, -0.09441468864679337, -0.002676358912140131, -0.034207627177238464, 0.00920562818646431, 0.06596562266349792, 0.10523359477519989, 0.007916430942714214, -0.038014575839042664, 0.018003419041633606, -0.0182100310921669, -0.10708945989608765, -0.008485570549964905, 0.008579709567129612, -0.009032727219164371, 0.0446908101439476, 0.020519433543086052, 0.06372346729040146, -0.01123806182295084, 0.022154953330755234, 0.010036943480372429, 0.02461831271648407, -0.003947181161493063, -0.052902474999427795, -0.0071127451956272125, 0.009193358942866325, -0.0379096195101738, 0.006075079087167978, 0.002192453481256962, -0.00437204772606492, -0.03181472793221474, -0.028749734163284302, 0.03511609509587288, 0.04460601136088371, -0.010964352637529373, 0.006459197029471397, 0.055138152092695236, -0.039262935519218445, -0.040338221937417984, 0.01927628368139267, 0.01835530437529087, -0.02009578049182892, 0.03460660204291344, -0.018356867134571075, 0.06739696115255356, -0.013772298581898212, 0.015485669486224651, -0.027410447597503662, 0.05381859093904495, 0.005230991635471582, 0.0023902032990008593, -0.11476034671068192, 0.025142664089798927, 0.03301860764622688, 0.03257731720805168, 0.022913284599781036, 0.011816194280982018, -0.02351861260831356, 0.035527583211660385, -0.03590118885040283, -0.006965996697545052, -0.07668686658143997, 0.08449695259332657, 0.0035737494472414255, -0.05155541002750397, -0.012061361223459244, 0.008893885649740696, -0.01910390332341194, 0.05547357350587845, 0.022070588544011116, 0.05836058408021927, -0.0015333446208387613, -0.06817475706338882, -0.01682465150952339, 0.03910515084862709, 0.03640616312623024, -0.011553258635103703, -0.03851989656686783, -0.027820022776722908, -0.056606724858284, -0.08689671009778976, 0.036022912710905075, -0.016512474045157433, -0.010058491490781307, -0.028302928432822227, 0.044034309685230255, 0.049687039107084274, 0.07255653291940689, 0.03135224059224129, 0.03653232008218765, -0.0016244000289589167, -0.05116894841194153, -0.05204301327466965, -0.005559916608035564, 0.015861965715885162, -0.020586855709552765, 0.006422183942049742, -0.011995942331850529, -0.03139772638678551, -0.05470273271203041, -0.09593204408884048, -0.02046903967857361, -0.04618001729249954, 0.025321733206510544, 0.057049840688705444, 0.05453834310173988, 0.024812068790197372, -0.001269214553758502, 0.0012526195496320724, 0.02322641760110855, -0.0027937404811382294, -0.018359994515776634, -0.025479866191744804, 0.03577433153986931, 0.04118761047720909, 0.0375947467982769, -0.009004272520542145, 0.05368713289499283, 0.04763968661427498, -0.020653581246733665, -0.0327296257019043, -0.0597156397998333, 0.058468665927648544, 0.012092292308807373, -0.015203292481601238, -0.04085154086351395, -0.005388774909079075, -0.06450525671243668, 0.08429920673370361, -0.03400310128927231, -0.047227151691913605, 0.013908186927437782, 0.02798067405819893, -0.006704255938529968, -0.015537038445472717, 0.021617939695715904, 0.08022047579288483, -0.04014785960316658, 0.01724543608725071, 0.009406507015228271, -0.025731483474373817, -0.09493739157915115, -0.056787971407175064, -0.001266086706891656, 0.026148878037929535, 0.06334638595581055, -0.022854898124933243, 0.029239200055599213, 0.08091733604669571, -0.03186868503689766, 0.06210949271917343, 0.036636147648096085, -0.02994818054139614, 0.05800783261656761, 0.002620795974507928, -0.012735327705740929, 0.03773219883441925, 0.011826381087303162, -0.009601172059774399, 0.061356376856565475, 0.055241938680410385, 0.010038681328296661, 0.029977375641465187, -0.01543249562382698, -0.021808303892612457, 0.053980544209480286, 0.0860980674624443, -0.10718051344156265, 0.0040222168900072575, 0.052608806639909744, -0.00927782990038395, -0.0353693850338459 ]
24
24
Clusters, Graphs, and Networks for Analysing Internet-Web-Supported Communication within a Virtual Community
The proposal is to use clusters, graphs and networks as models in order to analyse the Web structure. Clusters, graphs and networks provide knowledge representation and organization. Clusters were generated by co-site analysis. The sample is a set of academic Web sites from the countries belonging to the European Union. These clusters are here revisited from the point of view of graph theory and social network analysis. This is a quantitative and structural analysis. In fact, the Internet is a computer network that connects people and organizations. Thus we may consider it to be a social network. The set of Web academic sites represents an empirical social network, and is viewed as a virtual community. The network structural properties are here analysed applying together cluster analysis, graph theory and social network analysis.
[ -0.027262143790721893, -0.0163239948451519, -0.005553720984607935, 0.05026818811893463, 0.0870172530412674, -0.015510046854615211, -0.022401144728064537, -0.0746462270617485, -0.06839137524366379, -0.02880726009607315, 0.007437644526362419, 0.026920976117253304, 0.015169003047049046, -0.011644094251096249, 0.027725862339138985, 0.04296859726309776, -0.014867095276713371, -0.04826871305704117, 0.00797745306044817, -0.0017361959908157587, -0.06922020018100739, 0.009934168308973312, -0.004724820610135794, 0.0076225618831813335, 0.033066000789403915, -0.0505477711558342, 0.0067448182962834835, -0.08194100856781006, -0.05954452604055405, 0.034390293061733246, -0.02501792274415493, 0.07581333816051483, 0.02365182526409626, 0.058209456503391266, 0.015706099569797516, -0.004966344218701124, -0.046071503311395645, 0.060790397226810455, -0.002301188185811043, 0.02421056106686592, 0.055151619017124176, 0.004942352883517742, -0.05011295899748802, -0.005067337304353714, 0.04455947130918503, -0.010009885765612125, 0.010907568037509918, -0.0005070309853181243, 0.05828578770160675, 0.008975558914244175, -0.12759418785572052, -0.0321185402572155, -0.031480640172958374, 0.0031560473144054413, -0.12432785332202911, 0.0651024729013443, -0.024821972474455833, 0.020957782864570618, -0.011283237487077713, -0.0054868063889443874, 0.06528414785861969, 0.01657485030591488, -0.04264404997229576, -0.0017099942779168487, 0.009076486341655254, -0.006410351023077965, 0.03923018276691437, 0.03245307505130768, -0.04979253187775612, -0.06995294243097305, 0.005323418416082859, 0.032957036048173904, 0.05549021437764168, 0.07489921152591705, 0.0332532562315464, -0.043814219534397125, -0.05227358266711235, -0.04864775389432907, 0.01370907947421074, 0.11410756409168243, -0.127162367105484, 0.0182592011988163, -0.006813880521804094, -0.06511444598436356, -0.03146335855126381, -0.018152743577957153, 0.06664475798606873, -0.07996993511915207, -0.010194250382483006, 0.0613279789686203, 0.0007157998625189066, -0.09204534441232681, -0.05377946421504021, 0.056380752474069595, -0.02560538426041603, 0.018698303028941154, -0.11004690825939178, 0.016497407108545303, 0.005521552637219429, -0.029021073132753372, -0.048108816146850586, -0.04087122902274132, 0.019855700433254242, -0.009854031726717949, -0.0011826322879642248, 0.055024031549692154, 0.02473396807909012, 0.04573071002960205, 0.047852031886577606, -0.02950865402817726, 0.037891045212745667, 0.03602497652173042, -0.06529153138399124, 0.048510320484638214, 0.011457673273980618, 0.015408891253173351, -0.005019194446504116, 0.1136593446135521, 0.0007315089460462332, -0.05933493748307228, 0.022868335247039795, 0.01454531867057085, -0.02174060419201851, -0.016433238983154297, 0.026891805231571198, -0.10016839951276779, -0.1230325773358345, 0.06007063388824463, 0.018116485327482224, 0.03574172407388687, -0.06853725016117096, 0.069839708507061, -0.029068855568766594, -0.009021647274494171, -0.042698685079813004, 0.007432559039443731, 0.05499469116330147, -0.015724074095487595, -0.007880195043981075, 0.0068936776369810104, 0.0631752610206604, -0.028164949268102646, -0.04916346073150635, 0.009668351151049137, 0.04532359912991524, 0.07740428298711777, -0.049907803535461426, -0.008560781367123127, 0.12341189384460449, 0.018708311021327972, -0.06724511831998825, -0.054687779396772385, 0.06448346376419067, 0.020152607932686806, 0.05673292279243469, 0.02317141368985176, -0.0946367084980011, -0.025400081649422646, 0.024447543546557426, 0.006341428030282259, 0.0018518224824219942, 0.0749334767460823, 0.033195700496435165, -0.061398379504680634, 0.00013136265624780208, -0.016074052080512047, -0.08355658501386642, -0.03443615883588791, -0.007247963920235634, -0.018811745569109917, 0.05232350528240204, 0.009816276840865612, 0.06912072002887726, 0.024591103196144104, 0.002104806015267968, -0.10247660428285599, -0.034072596579790115, 0.021968387067317963, 0.040459807962179184, -0.0780792161822319, 0.07712417840957642, -0.009692470543086529, -0.026494888588786125, 0.040738046169281006, 0.004026974085718393, 0.085740827023983, 0.062062133103609085, 0.059387851506471634, -0.02290479838848114, 0.013704393059015274, -0.002071766648441553, -0.01833232119679451, 0.09643147885799408, -0.011455788277089596, -0.011826880276203156, 0.032439831644296646, 0.017246879637241364, 0.029617324471473694, -0.0280904620885849, 0.06765399873256683, -0.03648357838392258, 0.024272732436656952, -0.022557249292731285, -0.05956118553876877, -0.06659161299467087, -0.00035731258685700595, 0.029437797144055367, -0.060052793473005295, -0.06061020866036415, 0.04239945113658905, -0.001208495581522584, -0.013969210907816887, 0.04538147151470184, -0.01869007758796215, 0.03256884962320328, 0.038443610072135925, -0.06861075013875961, -0.04809950292110443, 0.08062244951725006, 0.051996227353811264, -0.025828946381807327, 0.011349412612617016, -0.0037730943877249956, -0.00001526252344774548, 0.001259803888387978, 0.044559743255376816, -0.005994081497192383, 0.014488055370748043, -0.054874274879693985, 0.013520007953047752, -0.10996740311384201, -0.033165086060762405, -0.09505455195903778, -0.02543320320546627, 0.09932616353034973, 0.04002883657813072, 0.009702026844024658, 0.08048811554908752, 0.011290946044027805, 0.0006613215082325041, -0.03781164810061455, -0.020686449483036995, 0.0052066994830966, -0.014670477248728275, 0.034690290689468384, -0.04095175862312317, 0.01000870019197464, 0.016409344971179962, -0.016201218590140343, 0.003990612458437681, -0.010263321921229362, 0.00782584585249424, -0.048174817115068436, 0.048064809292554855, -0.01348902191966772, -0.00363176385872066, -0.04187449440360069, 0.009621511213481426, 0.025403615087270737, 0.06740057468414307, 0.012186209671199322, -0.03463447839021683, -0.04773876443505287, -0.02771848626434803, 0.06788340210914612, 0.010569357313215733, -0.026920808479189873, 0.10171715170145035, -0.06413881480693817, 0.00344085437245667, 0.029862428084015846, 0.0019398139556869864, -0.049949761480093, 0.012256051413714886, -0.05496710166335106, 0.07691720873117447, 0.003745496040210128, 0.0009121526964008808, -0.04883008822798729, -0.05306142941117287, 0.018245913088321686, -0.029918991029262543, 0.023196494206786156, -0.04581858590245247, -0.06663566827774048, 0.05240926519036293, -0.04753538593649864, 0.021377313882112503, -0.0030948847997933626, 0.030095716938376427, -0.016311366111040115, 0.02602795511484146, -0.05736431106925011, -0.00994278583675623, -0.02854161337018013, -0.11115559190511703, 0.02059296704828739, 0.05628236010670662, 0.02188970148563385, -0.023427287116646767, -0.05768498778343201, 0.007877965457737446, 0.019749674946069717, 0.07275278121232986, 0.0684729665517807, -0.011022557504475117, 0.006701345555484295, 0.04384680092334747, -0.056611619889736176, 0.02357289008796215, -0.0055591086857020855, -0.007628667633980513, 0.00907557550817728, -0.0029886101838201284, 0.030899858102202415, 0.0192722175270319, -0.03039846569299698, 0.018012622371315956, -0.03892897814512253, 0.02703249640762806, -0.029988521710038185, -0.04219665005803108, 0.027438214048743248, -0.035530176013708115, -0.010125287808477879, -0.015522590838372707, -0.008450159803032875, 0.04123082011938095, 0.013792269863188267, 0.002264223759993911, -0.09473254531621933, -0.02108701691031456, 0.047243863344192505, 0.09045656025409698, 0.04417654871940613, -0.02434609644114971, -0.019285589456558228, -0.003541694488376379, -0.01583302766084671, 0.033029261976480484, -0.025175709277391434, -0.03942815586924553, 0.0538310781121254, -0.029344230890274048, 0.06240239366889, 0.09497648477554321, -0.005731797311455011, 0.036016788333654404, -0.022707922384142876, -0.03280888497829437, -0.07753828167915344, 0.008526317775249481, -0.018128909170627594, 0.02610950730741024, -0.041864484548568726, 0.007953247986733913, 0.01921730861067772, 0.034476228058338165, 0.04706955701112747, -0.04887207970023155, -0.012564328499138355, -0.033728163689374924, 0.0024612995330244303, 0.029987089335918427, 0.005206983536481857, -0.0039704409427940845, -0.012599870562553406, 0.045655541121959686, -0.010446312837302685, -0.014986785128712654, 0.05775516480207443, 0.04820738360285759, -0.007252656854689121, -0.049237869679927826, -0.02596856653690338, -0.04403571039438248, -0.009050751104950905, -0.029974471777677536, -0.002967454493045807, 0.022357122972607613, 0.019151639193296432, 0.009830066002905369, -0.042002029716968536, 0.024806180968880653, 0.05360007286071777, -0.02341029979288578, 0.06884707510471344, 0.034232813864946365, 0.10133560746908188, 0.055701129138469696, 0.056160442531108856, 0.01357676275074482, -0.018206683918833733, -0.000560486747417599, 0.03672000765800476, -0.09175781905651093, -0.028315510600805283, 0.008433274924755096, -0.033686961978673935, -0.011867720633745193, -0.03214554861187935, -0.003866316517814994, -0.04104876518249512, -0.015916623175144196, -0.07005312293767929, -0.01658937893807888, -0.10627299547195435, 0.06798375397920609, 0.024003075435757637, -0.012406093999743462, 0.037587475031614304, 0.043288059532642365, -0.10024280101060867, -0.027473270893096924, 0.07209067046642303, 0.045915886759757996, 0.06349055469036102, 0.021885434165596962, 0.07553887367248535, -0.059018492698669434, 0.04297144338488579, -0.03118450567126274, -0.003982017282396555, 0.006492676213383675, 0.017577480524778366, 0.00013014388969168067, 0.05688406154513359, 0.01798339933156967, 0.060791004449129105, 0.021187545731663704, 0.06155338138341904, -0.03144621476531029, 0.01805071346461773, 0.033251140266656876, 0.060800690203905106, -0.036080021411180496, 0.03472578525543213, -0.00970341544598341, 0.038709308952093124, -0.041398074477910995, 0.0322524718940258, 0.005165604874491692, 0.03259112685918808, -0.008064392022788525, 0.039050597697496414, -0.00528637133538723, 0.023838385939598083, -0.03501620143651962, 0.030938562005758286, -0.017536111176013947, -0.07309698313474655, -0.01313797291368246, -0.010643052868545055, -0.030052615329623222, -0.05853627622127533, -0.03701317310333252, -0.012077998369932175, -0.03178348019719124, 0.10131612420082092, -0.05652138590812683, -0.0048223999328911304, 0.058970388025045395, -0.019463784992694855, -0.0413314625620842, -0.06439690291881561, 0.0008542120922356844, 0.06941013783216476, -0.013687394559383392, 0.04183296859264374, -0.023814847692847252, -0.09420382231473923, 0.004197393078356981, -0.005274314433336258, -0.0202215313911438, -0.005410186480730772, 0.03683707118034363, -0.044796913862228394, -0.03999599441885948, -0.044261615723371506, -0.08557844907045364, 0.010457883588969707, 0.026152193546295166, 0.0139074195176363, 0.029934486374258995, 0.005244614090770483, 0.010624355636537075, 0.04535992443561554, 0.019297536462545395, 0.016163593158125877, -0.014149724505841732, 0.024112865328788757, -0.051574792712926865, -0.07441240549087524, 0.02737255021929741, -0.012112022377550602, 0.03142806515097618, 0.031369954347610474, 0.018126048147678375, -0.007395890075713396, -0.026248406618833542, 0.011561797931790352, -0.015956899151206017, 0.04635147377848625, 0.008825425058603287, 0.03115946426987648, -0.017253104597330093, 0.07567080110311508, -0.013368002139031887, -0.016532117500901222, -0.0387452207505703, -0.03120051883161068, -0.08519009500741959 ]
25
25
Universal Reinforcement Learning
We consider an agent interacting with an unmodeled environment. At each time, the agent makes an observation, takes an action, and incurs a cost. Its actions can influence future observations and costs. The goal is to minimize the long-term average cost. We propose a novel algorithm, known as the active LZ algorithm, for optimal control based on ideas from the Lempel-Ziv scheme for universal data compression and prediction. We establish that, under the active LZ algorithm, if there exists an integer $K$ such that the future is conditionally independent of the past given a window of $K$ consecutive actions and observations, then the average cost converges to the optimum. Experimental results involving the game of Rock-Paper-Scissors illustrate merits of the algorithm.
[ -0.003426265437155962, -0.06412411481142044, -0.0029750193934887648, 0.008724776096642017, -0.019674690440297127, -0.08365000784397125, -0.011142339557409286, -0.037052202969789505, -0.03704913333058357, 0.07980092614889145, -0.029851626604795456, -0.010976221412420273, -0.03187095746397972, 0.03541252389550209, 0.011518506333231926, -0.027093689888715744, -0.018342601135373116, 0.03543873503804207, -0.023133743554353714, -0.05038042366504669, 0.044239453971385956, -0.014154074713587761, -0.013549292460083961, 0.01959618553519249, -0.04435598477721214, -0.0633501261472702, -0.019074639305472374, 0.013010433875024319, -0.042564112693071365, 0.005589725449681282, -0.04384368658065796, 0.020948275923728943, 0.060762178152799606, -0.01819165237247944, 0.08302738517522812, -0.009469350799918175, 0.08339378237724304, -0.026808636263012886, -0.01550497766584158, -0.09184708446264267, -0.04251720756292343, 0.044952936470508575, 0.0021779548842459917, -0.021461909636855125, 0.013614324852824211, 0.07577534019947052, -0.024033382534980774, -0.049625713378190994, -0.05891380459070206, 0.031529106199741364, -0.09098552167415619, -0.031111236661672592, 0.0042098104022443295, -0.02665933594107628, 0.023997917771339417, 0.07953748852014542, -0.046794239431619644, -0.03056861087679863, 0.059701379388570786, -0.1177818551659584, 0.052304890006780624, 0.13334961235523224, -0.0397413969039917, 0.038023535162210464, -0.0023949432652443647, 0.046729277819395065, -0.032625265419483185, -0.08739032596349716, -0.06922382861375809, 0.01899039000272751, 0.057639967650175095, -0.008684263564646244, 0.007953647524118423, -0.04844238981604576, 0.039165277034044266, 0.0018023664597421885, -0.035310663282871246, 0.016104068607091904, 0.018085595220327377, 0.08307851850986481, -0.0739254355430603, 0.04573587700724602, -0.03533776104450226, 0.047275837510824203, -0.055686213076114655, -0.031120095402002335, -0.02467918209731579, -0.009712456725537777, -0.013519886881113052, 0.004168370272964239, -0.01124490424990654, -0.02028346061706543, -0.0378011129796505, -0.027472933754324913, -0.05255720019340515, 0.040202777832746506, 0.023316742852330208, 0.027711620554327965, 0.005306944251060486, 0.04201445356011391, 0.051620643585920334, 0.001793000614270568, 0.02973688207566738, 0.10080010443925858, -0.04025392234325409, 0.018247881904244423, -0.004273995757102966, 0.0001543976104585454, 0.1187376007437706, 0.004437556024640799, -0.02436930499970913, 0.019995614886283875, 0.00005028522718930617, 0.027547722682356834, -0.06899537891149521, 0.054147519171237946, -0.027157772332429886, 0.024940818548202515, -0.048746511340141296, 0.0377347506582737, 0.009938978590071201, 0.021488085389137268, -0.014969093725085258, 0.04831518977880478, 0.06334183365106583, -0.04311511665582657, -0.022808996960520744, -0.06455251574516296, 0.10232304036617279, 0.014582392759621143, -0.048007652163505554, -0.026897167786955833, -0.001891162944957614, -0.08407110720872879, -0.06076659634709358, 0.08576060831546783, 0.03892666846513748, -0.024075418710708618, 0.012937810271978378, 0.050324685871601105, -0.013409275561571121, 0.01974487490952015, -0.01556379720568657, 0.061907730996608734, 0.0007404693169519305, -0.0029893317259848118, -0.0028762544970959425, 0.01863367296755314, 0.00890650786459446, 0.09089243412017822, 0.022004030644893646, 0.04394399747252464, 0.02055676095187664, 0.032470621168613434, -0.006324381101876497, -0.074641652405262, -0.03447257727384567, 0.04057842120528221, -0.0952635332942009, 0.02602989971637726, 0.0013733095256611705, 0.08665315806865692, -0.02809779718518257, -0.0312759093940258, 0.01626950316131115, 0.00518260570243001, 0.018694667145609856, -0.010194472968578339, -0.07001156359910965, -0.03914253041148186, -0.01348246168345213, -0.02595079503953457, -0.03513212502002716, 0.033468469977378845, -0.0040192133747041225, 0.008531049825251102, -0.09633571654558182, 0.016864731907844543, 0.05385251343250275, 0.05726686492562294, 0.07312047481536865, -0.01304398663341999, -0.04233637452125549, 0.01740981452167034, 0.07885153591632843, 0.06934554129838943, 0.06268945336341858, 0.02653253637254238, 0.04254297539591789, -0.010595100000500679, -0.030131515115499496, 0.05005572363734245, 0.02229163609445095, 0.002966086147353053, 0.015030067414045334, 0.03601326420903206, 0.0195588581264019, -0.06915193051099777, -0.0014024878619238734, 0.04075593501329422, 0.055897291749715805, 0.0681762769818306, -0.08574238419532776, 0.0028703156858682632, -0.05831652134656906, -0.008610191754996777, -0.019608303904533386, -0.03440053015947342, -0.03019937127828598, -0.014291161671280861, -0.03062947280704975, -0.03220698609948158, -0.007009344175457954, -0.03955025225877762, 0.019524572417140007, -0.03273392841219902, 0.020250516012310982, 0.009469746612012386, 0.006112275179475546, -0.010745675303041935, -0.04837543144822121, 0.08375272899866104, 0.019389506429433823, 0.04353109002113342, 0.01704700104892254, -0.01409891340881586, 0.037596117705106735, 0.04262017458677292, -0.01817976124584675, 0.002850460819900036, -0.021253496408462524, -0.07391636818647385, 0.018226781859993935, 0.011208025738596916, -0.013507178984582424, 0.10648232698440552, -0.014648407697677612, -0.04645116627216339, -0.02444084733724594, 0.03657251596450806, -0.007629262283444405, 0.02790021151304245, 0.007009922992438078, 0.018647246062755585, 0.08660789579153061, 0.047036539763212204, 0.0223129503428936, -0.015103258192539215, -0.13366013765335083, -0.042790502309799194, 0.06306076049804688, -0.03721773624420166, 0.005838144104927778, 0.01907930336892605, -0.009804405272006989, 0.03166411444544792, -0.015464314259588718, 0.05573892965912819, 0.09522387385368347, 0.0016879428876563907, -0.06791632622480392, 0.059745628386735916, -0.07192885130643845, 0.07380557805299759, 0.017807304859161377, 0.004388079512864351, -0.018534008413553238, 0.03593217581510544, 0.07511607557535172, 0.04204742610454559, -0.02985081635415554, 0.041339725255966187, -0.02687411569058895, 0.09070345759391785, -0.021270381286740303, -0.08665722608566284, -0.007438753731548786, -0.020850583910942078, 0.005224882625043392, -0.061386074870824814, -0.06114479526877403, 0.04118702933192253, 0.011432040482759476, 0.012720256112515926, 0.01982615888118744, 0.018207818269729614, -0.02599511481821537, 0.011214366182684898, 0.055886320769786835, 0.06516492366790771, -0.11118040978908539, 0.014022639952600002, -0.03527482971549034, 0.007565092295408249, -0.041481293737888336, -0.04514288529753685, 0.05416090786457062, -0.0035871933214366436, 0.03166615590453148, 0.021905560046434402, 0.00799972377717495, -0.018606388941407204, 0.045357488095760345, 0.010041393339633942, 0.03383621573448181, 0.08294305950403214, 0.04594334587454796, 0.05043850466609001, -0.01626761257648468, 0.015172706916928291, 0.07644882053136826, 0.004148842766880989, -0.048048194497823715, -0.01984880492091179, 0.043853551149368286, 0.04131796211004257, -0.013691875152289867, -0.025437818840146065, -0.04993605241179466, -0.01653570495545864, 0.019093036651611328, -0.06560060381889343, 0.07113522291183472, 0.06590687483549118, -0.08345266431570053, 0.00017944132559932768, -0.025876495987176895, -0.011857796460390091, -0.019211379811167717, 0.05190924555063248, -0.04006519168615341, -0.001211324823088944, -0.02855795808136463, -0.015640661120414734, -0.07322993874549866, 0.0010923604713752866, -0.09763434529304504, 0.03626084700226784, 0.012260711751878262, 0.02277137152850628, -0.01776006817817688, -0.08226525038480759, -0.0301226694136858, -0.04206283763051033, -0.039461515843868256, 0.06316005438566208, 0.17985866963863373, 0.023323887959122658, -0.028397778049111366, 0.08006112277507782, -0.02528187446296215, -0.04799124225974083, -0.06630377471446991, -0.04781993851065636, -0.06998847424983978, 0.02582079917192459, 0.021096698939800262, 0.00466657942160964, -0.015968935564160347, -0.009238205850124359, -0.01983506605029106, 0.0016332853119820356, -0.02950519323348999, -0.011635962873697281, 0.0433647520840168, 0.06675059348344803, -0.023766081780195236, -0.019671710208058357, -0.09492561966180801, -0.06286009401082993, 0.006621079053729773, -0.05167539790272713, 0.022806178778409958, -0.00460099009796977, 0.09767818450927734, -0.038176801055669785, 0.054329436272382736, -0.10467305034399033, -0.05590549483895302, 0.05782926082611084, -0.01537394244223833, -0.024010758846998215, -0.03418782725930214, -0.061374977231025696, -0.05652432516217232, 0.009460089728236198, -0.01371346041560173, -0.030857879668474197, 0.051787346601486206, -0.027561532333493233, -0.03529379889369011, -0.021786263212561607, 0.018753187730908394, -0.01633758470416069, 0.052238207310438156, -0.054245688021183014, -0.008389460854232311, -0.0005774024757556617, -0.02082010917365551, -0.02675425447523594, 0.047794658690690994, -0.05190565809607506, 0.04711395502090454, -0.04006350412964821, -0.07869045436382294, -0.025995921343564987, 0.04485389217734337, 0.08464477211236954, 0.0011811649892479181, 0.031200332567095757, 0.014072414487600327, -0.019850077107548714, -0.01964612305164337, -0.02090580016374588, -0.07919812947511673, 0.012482119724154472, -0.049845121800899506, 0.018107160925865173, -0.008176316507160664, -0.09208796173334122, 0.023249981924891472, -0.008525539189577103, 0.01143178902566433, -0.003812618087977171, -0.027575857937335968, -0.020656559616327286, 0.011571377515792847, 0.0055068437941372395, -0.009638846851885319, 0.011512045748531818, -0.04006924107670784, -0.021955939009785652, -0.00399599876254797, 0.010362562723457813, -0.004612501244992018, -0.009503470733761787, 0.0015972967958077788, 0.04011871665716171, -0.05884787440299988, 0.04171525686979294, -0.00875515304505825, -0.0042601460590958595, -0.03796205297112465, 0.03734583407640457, -0.016002239659428596, 0.06473375111818314, -0.02651989832520485, 0.013966377824544907, 0.07034829258918762, -0.027085406705737114, -0.028583649545907974, 0.026218853890895844, 0.08925280719995499, -0.016411731019616127, -0.016791239380836487, -0.006505120079964399, 0.019718099385499954, 0.012388404458761215, 0.08962616324424744, -0.0304915439337492, -0.03568501025438309, -0.002019269159063697, 0.023080283775925636, 0.02274985797703266, -0.05088665708899498, -0.05226512998342514, 0.03648131713271141, 0.019947072491049767, 0.05765992030501366, 0.019427208229899406, 0.024965589866042137, 0.0376020222902298, -0.002253857674077153, -0.053018003702163696, 0.008375289849936962, 0.02537962608039379, 0.06272222101688385, 0.009034191258251667, 0.04100758209824562, 0.023304563015699387, 0.00003280209784861654, 0.03322889283299446, -0.016916325315833092, -0.037454552948474884, 0.06883653998374939, 0.05330025032162666, -0.03942102566361427, -0.023214289918541908, 0.02664189599454403, -0.025637703016400337, 0.006918418221175671, -0.03585891053080559, -0.002762573305517435, -0.0008501446573063731, 0.05199924111366272, -0.021526681259274483, 0.0059354244731366634, 0.005273324437439442, 0.005999805871397257, 0.06558293104171753, 0.04889659211039543, -0.011341950856149197, -0.030698195099830627, 0.030275538563728333, 0.038300469517707825, -0.010058693587779999, 0.03866024687886238, 0.05674133822321892, 0.028859103098511696, -0.006702360697090626, -0.048461973667144775, 0.08453202247619629 ]
26
26
Consistency of the group Lasso and multiple kernel learning
We consider the least-square regression problem with regularization by a block 1-norm, i.e., a sum of Euclidean norms over spaces of dimensions larger than one. This problem, referred to as the group Lasso, extends the usual regularization by the 1-norm where all spaces have dimension one, where it is commonly referred to as the Lasso. In this paper, we study the asymptotic model consistency of the group Lasso. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for the consistency of group Lasso under practical assumptions, such as model misspecification. When the linear predictors and Euclidean norms are replaced by functions and reproducing kernel Hilbert norms, the problem is usually referred to as multiple kernel learning and is commonly used for learning from heterogeneous data sources and for non linear variable selection. Using tools from functional analysis, and in particular covariance operators, we extend the consistency results to this infinite dimensional case and also propose an adaptive scheme to obtain a consistent model estimate, even when the necessary condition required for the non adaptive scheme is not satisfied.
[ 0.016298791393637657, -0.028347063809633255, -0.02176639996469021, 0.0013148722937330604, -0.0075245508924126625, -0.06120482459664345, 0.029137006029486656, -0.018899569287896156, 0.021471962332725525, 0.05489915981888771, 0.04573247954249382, -0.04480714350938797, -0.02837175503373146, 0.0552181750535965, -0.01235999632626772, 0.023436270654201508, 0.04036571830511093, -0.002014272380620241, 0.04659948870539665, -0.08906309306621552, 0.01093860063701868, -0.018063988536596298, 0.05583469569683075, -0.08998531848192215, 0.06341173499822617, -0.042943671345710754, 0.01427239179611206, 0.03873911499977112, -0.0037831368390470743, 0.04360445961356163, -0.05478362366557121, 0.02361229620873928, 0.01873232237994671, 0.015686631202697754, 0.021128296852111816, -0.044709380716085434, 0.02551259472966194, 0.07798189669847488, -0.027857352048158646, 0.016895901411771774, 0.03934147208929062, 0.007524596527218819, 0.0773024782538414, -0.03230002522468567, -0.010131423361599445, -0.014796752482652664, 0.06734292954206467, -0.031816136091947556, -0.0032020804937928915, 0.005078406538814306, -0.012653756886720657, 0.03868761286139488, -0.051059503108263016, -0.017037391662597656, 0.05129045993089676, -0.029071133583784103, -0.12150821089744568, -0.046633075922727585, -0.05428224056959152, 0.015116984955966473, 0.04862219840288162, 0.019881242886185646, 0.011795001104474068, -0.11462338268756866, 0.011025000363588333, 0.03210107609629631, -0.10257180780172348, 0.009706515818834305, -0.030836764723062515, -0.04855956882238388, -0.010981236584484577, -0.0496688038110733, 0.02604338526725769, 0.008685596287250519, 0.08262921124696732, 0.04984140396118164, -0.027741944417357445, -0.0371139720082283, 0.0011024493724107742, 0.09681801497936249, -0.010597333312034607, -0.014830803498625755, -0.012258115224540234, -0.002990043954923749, -0.02726140059530735, 0.03732066601514816, -0.010250309482216835, -0.03554896265268326, 0.03547656536102295, 0.0004980238736607134, -0.002997947856783867, 0.018099673092365265, -0.025761913508176804, 0.057565003633499146, 0.008086551912128925, 0.035126473754644394, 0.022423019632697105, 0.0018895205575972795, -0.03413793444633484, -0.02544822357594967, 0.04009484499692917, 0.011625503189861774, 0.06759055703878403, 0.054574962705373764, -0.013325820676982403, 0.05954520031809807, -0.02989034168422222, 0.006254338193684816, -0.012246904894709587, -0.02934993989765644, 0.0009080662857741117, -0.05345757678151131, 0.033911287784576416, -0.027703266590833664, -0.0006906616617925465, 0.10770983248949051, -0.02510129101574421, 0.11776375025510788, -0.021470442414283752, 0.0351085290312767, 0.021656842902302742, 0.025370744988322258, -0.060783252120018005, 0.04636993259191513, -0.043881990015506744, 0.0447152741253376, -0.003848664229735732, -0.07928530871868134, 0.0645163282752037, -0.012627312913537025, -0.04470398649573326, 0.0062361788004636765, 0.03743577003479004, -0.03425954282283783, -0.028361786156892776, 0.04751167073845863, -0.050130557268857956, -0.012707320973277092, -0.08265405893325806, 0.04362205043435097, -0.05103779584169388, 0.02177596464753151, -0.01106744259595871, 0.031122060492634773, 0.007362158969044685, 0.009580199606716633, 0.07204597443342209, -0.039117470383644104, 0.026173463091254234, 0.030725453048944473, 0.022729305550456047, -0.03510934114456177, 0.008584248833358288, 0.04545941203832626, 0.08636762201786041, -0.09998054057359695, -0.01800231821835041, 0.07829409837722778, -0.044392723590135574, -0.0005700179608538747, -0.007717124652117491, 0.016394177451729774, 0.013117617927491665, 0.033269722014665604, -0.031227141618728638, -0.08211580663919449, -0.017339549958705902, 0.05217212438583374, -0.055875882506370544, 0.018206560984253883, -0.10500368475914001, 0.04904782399535179, -0.012027005665004253, -0.018957478925585747, 0.009025905281305313, 0.00026004938990809023, 0.06833972036838531, 0.028544673696160316, -0.012671773321926594, -0.04576965793967247, -0.016979392617940903, 0.06934299319982529, 0.02198837324976921, 0.01827201060950756, 0.010199676267802715, 0.06858181953430176, -0.012965735979378223, -0.013067449443042278, 0.08049663156270981, -0.031882502138614655, 0.0775585025548935, -0.057255811989307404, -0.04650254547595978, -0.0163415540009737, -0.06814918667078018, 0.07302646338939667, -0.036605365574359894, 0.009567834436893463, -0.0015713585307821631, 0.040478892624378204, 0.006636281032115221, -0.017073584720492363, 0.08066156506538391, -0.07773877680301666, -0.059934552758932114, -0.004454852547496557, 0.09267081320285797, -0.051515690982341766, 0.004442903213202953, -0.005356816574931145, -0.03994105011224747, -0.004973015747964382, -0.07889401167631149, -0.08261723816394806, -0.008002989925444126, -0.08546396344900131, 0.09327591210603714, -0.07512568682432175, 0.0025589698925614357, 0.0278276689350605, -0.02478441409766674, 0.10518859326839447, 0.024001551792025566, -0.008244192227721214, -0.04787399619817734, 0.000293962424620986, 0.025580234825611115, -0.04138268530368805, -0.003383149392902851, 0.046540308743715286, -0.07723329216241837, -0.08079053461551666, -0.02057056501507759, 0.00022428238298743963, -0.012379624880850315, 0.013592636212706566, -0.0438305102288723, -0.038387712091207504, -0.0016945140669122338, -0.04160047695040703, 0.0024165655486285686, -0.03229746222496033, -0.014712072908878326, -0.06280448287725449, -0.07291151583194733, -0.03697769343852997, 0.05944725498557091, 0.026215841993689537, -0.023049021139740944, 0.0021825660951435566, 0.029548179358243942, 0.03237687796354294, -0.024022504687309265, 0.05378485471010208, -0.047686778008937836, 0.03509392589330673, -0.025392549112439156, -0.04240697622299194, -0.00776013545691967, 0.06705731153488159, 0.029335252940654755, 0.06365934014320374, -0.0936274379491806, -0.04219364374876022, 0.037961605936288834, -0.007632709573954344, -0.019450990483164787, -0.005420143250375986, 0.01768871210515499, 0.04375620558857918, 0.009451904334127903, -0.08522890508174896, -0.044806305319070816, -0.010247056372463703, -0.058528609573841095, 0.03426573425531387, -0.012893954291939735, 0.043240442872047424, 0.051349934190511703, -0.006290378049015999, 0.03767918422818184, 0.06483428180217743, -0.04618394374847412, -0.1281384974718094, -0.06491421908140182, -0.06520373374223709, 0.041530974209308624, 0.02529720403254032, -0.04301401600241661, 0.006527937017381191, -0.08157184720039368, 0.044762901961803436, -0.005681783426553011, 0.024578237906098366, 0.01772053726017475, -0.014720323495566845, 0.061544716358184814, -0.023085622116923332, 0.015465069562196732, 0.03050057776272297, -0.003946778364479542, -0.02840302512049675, 0.04304296150803566, -0.041844312101602554, 0.003749484894797206, 0.06080152094364166, 0.02191036194562912, 0.11698330193758011, -0.06259310990571976, 0.05948043242096901, 0.010560162365436554, 0.0030011062044650316, 0.02221725508570671, -0.03317591920495033, 0.028649579733610153, -0.09200207144021988, 0.04833733290433884, -0.03065428137779236, -0.019895410165190697, -0.01586565189063549, 0.011465640738606453, -0.05398298054933548, 0.015140841715037823, -0.007036763709038496, -0.05674099549651146, -0.06532764434814453, 0.009520416148006916, 0.007781512103974819, 0.00715055363252759, 0.019327914342284203, 0.001858265371993184, -0.0200229212641716, 0.02136322297155857, 0.06692999601364136, -0.016868628561496735, 0.00763674546033144, -0.07584845274686813, -0.0954858735203743, -0.07677587121725082, 0.022685691714286804, 0.0012512672692537308, -0.05558086931705475, 0.016417445614933968, -0.027812231332063675, -0.017203425988554955, 0.022614261135458946, 0.08355377614498138, -0.034691423177719116, -0.10968206822872162, 0.034287381917238235, -0.10639563947916031, 0.027426673099398613, -0.023377707228064537, 0.0396432988345623, -0.013382612727582455, 0.019722893834114075, 0.11276102066040039, -0.0266254935413599, -0.045492250472307205, 0.008182046934962273, -0.019824635237455368, 0.008180331438779831, -0.023817185312509537, 0.029690267518162727, 0.027041032910346985, 0.08173259347677231, 0.022524703294038773, 0.024128422141075134, -0.05919593572616577, 0.07234480232000351, -0.017168482765555382, 0.09939394146203995, 0.08585981279611588, -0.013512100093066692, -0.006136596668511629, -0.008799351751804352, 0.046506986021995544, 0.04329006373882294, 0.03307247906923294, -0.004764232784509659, -0.001975532853975892, -0.06619729101657867, -0.02448001131415367, 0.012189014814794064, 0.02149367332458496, -0.041957005858421326, 0.022000038996338844, -0.04355144500732422, 0.08875049650669098, -0.027268823236227036, -0.05431804433465004, -0.018810994923114777, -0.04628332331776619, 0.02369707264006138, 0.08069627732038498, -0.00015037217235658318, 0.0029054968617856503, -0.043547503650188446, -0.050694044679403305, -0.007436787709593773, -0.005408983211964369, 0.026782667264342308, -0.002522681839764118, -0.08924020826816559, -0.022687269374728203, -0.019083376973867416, 0.041432663798332214, 0.022964907810091972, -0.013388292863965034, 0.04881628602743149, 0.010555696673691273, -0.03466745465993881, -0.0023893441539257765, 0.05040084943175316, 0.04438288137316704, 0.05131516233086586, -0.025706565007567406, -0.008206713013350964, 0.019791698083281517, -0.06549128890037537, 0.07048872858285904, 0.04510991647839546, 0.026830749586224556, -0.009669876657426357, 0.024067450314760208, -0.017454711720347404, 0.021972905844449997, 0.014482731930911541, 0.025827007368206978, 0.013274582102894783, -0.009740782901644707, -0.009187731891870499, -0.06756515055894852, -0.015087387524545193, 0.008199803531169891, -0.029622748494148254, 0.02675756625831127, 0.010384995490312576, -0.0296776220202446, 0.003198746358975768, -0.011850869283080101, -0.031730249524116516, -0.048733364790678024, 0.011216745711863041, 0.03323497623205185, 0.05256817489862442, 0.023343535140156746, 0.04150942340493202, 0.07588618248701096, -0.0007161753601394594, -0.0671168714761734, -0.04273359104990959, -0.011804698035120964, -0.013003862462937832, 0.018844028934836388, 0.07469923794269562, 0.02101506106555462, -0.06723977625370026, 0.04000365734100342, -0.02885744534432888, -0.04845667630434036, -0.06673014163970947, 0.0464380718767643, 0.03163410350680351, -0.07919623702764511, -0.011553679592907429, -0.007288586348295212, 0.03716342896223068, 0.02336982823908329, 0.0008619200671091676, -0.06146828085184097, -0.0032295503187924623, -0.07300970703363419, -0.01278945617377758, 0.059997960925102234, -0.010080154985189438, 0.041325949132442474, -0.0889812484383583, 0.045872319489717484, 0.035448234528303146, 0.0024507874622941017, -0.06969013810157776, 0.008916012942790985, 0.06790705025196075, 0.019471919164061546, 0.03753066807985306, -0.0036821968387812376, -0.00004900818021269515, 0.027873724699020386, -0.007075565401464701, -0.013275581412017345, 0.08284422755241394, 0.018247870728373528, -0.0032554329372942448, 0.0007506203255616128, 0.0310343150049448, -0.024605071172118187, -0.017535902559757233, 0.025011586025357246, 0.07657092064619064, -0.02464442513883114, -0.02517969161272049, -0.006126681342720985, 0.002009958028793335, 0.05837298929691315, 0.051254648715257645, 0.016697527840733528, -0.05377901345491409, -0.056611303240060806, 0.019745705649256706, -0.009414158761501312, -0.02279164083302021 ]
27
27
Quantum Algorithms for Learning and Testing Juntas
In this article we develop quantum algorithms for learning and testing juntas, i.e. Boolean functions which depend only on an unknown set of k out of n input variables. Our aim is to develop efficient algorithms: - whose sample complexity has no dependence on n, the dimension of the domain the Boolean functions are defined over; - with no access to any classical or quantum membership ("black-box") queries. Instead, our algorithms use only classical examples generated uniformly at random and fixed quantum superpositions of such classical examples; - which require only a few quantum examples but possibly many classical random examples (which are considered quite "cheap" relative to quantum examples). Our quantum algorithms are based on a subroutine FS which enables sampling according to the Fourier spectrum of f; the FS subroutine was used in earlier work of Bshouty and Jackson on quantum learning. Our results are as follows: - We give an algorithm for testing k-juntas to accuracy $\epsilon$ that uses $O(k/\epsilon)$ quantum examples. This improves on the number of examples used by the best known classical algorithm. - We establish the following lower bound: any FS-based k-junta testing algorithm requires $\Omega(\sqrt{k})$ queries. - We give an algorithm for learning $k$-juntas to accuracy $\epsilon$ that uses $O(\epsilon^{-1} k\log k)$ quantum examples and $O(2^k \log(1/\epsilon))$ random examples. We show that this learning algorithms is close to optimal by giving a related lower bound.
[ -0.037179023027420044, 0.019072502851486206, 0.07980947196483612, -0.04875374957919121, 0.030846884474158287, -0.048675667494535446, -0.0018405639566481113, 0.027480473741889, -0.07087225466966629, 0.021284276619553566, -0.01578623056411743, 0.006570739205926657, 0.036538127809762955, 0.08756473660469055, 0.010162423364818096, 0.019862966611981392, 0.024962034076452255, 0.0757516622543335, 0.0664176419377327, -0.03342965245246887, 0.015179394744336605, -0.012973655015230179, 0.07662419974803925, 0.028539393097162247, 0.021680042147636414, 0.02204250916838646, 0.03850911557674408, -0.018367353826761246, -0.020611131563782692, 0.010311656631529331, -0.055214881896972656, -0.01041909959167242, -0.006566483527421951, 0.03020339086651802, 0.03472461551427841, -0.052994467318058014, 0.05039931833744049, -0.028489641845226288, -0.014272519387304783, -0.016296030953526497, 0.0010191502515226603, 0.012669620104134083, 0.029829876497387886, 0.012897072359919548, 0.06501635909080505, -0.0022389355581253767, 0.023337457329034805, -0.0471080020070076, -0.01089488621801138, 0.02620994672179222, -0.07232943922281265, 0.0064975060522556305, 0.0024362774565815926, -0.02396339923143387, 0.018148362636566162, -0.004954449366778135, -0.0028568690177053213, 0.06352318823337555, -0.006700435653328896, 0.005274517461657524, 0.021190622821450233, 0.1431017816066742, 0.10779676586389542, -0.06613650172948837, -0.019884781911969185, -0.02798345312476158, -0.02984634041786194, -0.044718045741319656, -0.0063047646544873714, 0.013289252296090126, -0.009253703989088535, -0.04060685262084007, -0.006959903985261917, 0.07955288141965866, 0.037172168493270874, 0.035705503076314926, -0.06792452186346054, 0.0021253537852317095, 0.020644407719373703, 0.016292624175548553, -0.001922289957292378, -0.033950552344322205, 0.003012820379808545, 0.01658967323601246, -0.025537051260471344, 0.038076937198638916, -0.004310012795031071, 0.005907944403588772, -0.026096085086464882, 0.009472222998738289, -0.07725770771503448, 0.024252168834209442, -0.052615683525800705, -0.05948484688997269, 0.034474506974220276, 0.07756146788597107, -0.03313298523426056, -0.022053655236959457, -0.044986698776483536, -0.020941415801644325, 0.018551459535956383, -0.04384812340140343, 0.10073167085647583, 0.0939415991306305, -0.04424601048231125, -0.0022766951005905867, -0.05720416083931923, -0.004374632146209478, 0.05017808824777603, -0.008664166554808617, -0.021219903603196144, -0.02424824796617031, 0.038603268563747406, 0.027800774201750755, -0.0463937409222126, 0.09688688069581985, -0.02105698361992836, 0.07047625631093979, 0.032125212252140045, 0.05864862725138664, 0.002815247280523181, 0.02731527015566826, -0.015106156468391418, 0.024723820388317108, 0.08805863559246063, -0.0308110062032938, -0.032803282141685486, -0.056976739317178726, 0.12614043056964874, 0.09299183636903763, -0.005597556009888649, -0.01778106950223446, -0.01012451946735382, -0.018888182938098907, -0.005818224046379328, -0.0041151028126478195, 0.013321245089173317, 0.05308397859334946, 0.013508321717381477, 0.001121789333410561, 0.0047330912202596664, -0.041467856615781784, -0.051084909588098526, -0.011865693144500256, 0.03933176398277283, -0.03546632081270218, -0.018265709280967712, -0.04091392084956169, -0.0025034244172275066, 0.036544665694236755, 0.020753266289830208, -0.0046323747374117374, -0.010306134819984436, 0.0242308396846056, 0.06098143011331558, 0.06388386338949203, -0.047196485102176666, 0.07215050607919693, -0.020504143089056015, 0.1025356575846672, 0.06062436103820801, -0.03720330819487572, 0.03346642479300499, 0.041330188512802124, 0.057648804038763046, -0.01817832887172699, -0.02431000955402851, 0.02490803226828575, -0.03183571249246597, 0.0182968657463789, 0.05806868523359299, -0.03684427589178085, -0.042620621621608734, 0.016914648935198784, 0.0407247394323349, 0.015593613497912884, -0.018653372302651405, -0.055434782058000565, -0.024031342938542366, -0.05768806114792824, -0.04070219770073891, -0.13562974333763123, -0.050082407891750336, 0.007177731022238731, 0.049354370683431625, 0.0693855956196785, -0.04094782471656799, 0.023674722760915756, 0.09030593931674957, -0.04571196809411049, 0.01886368729174137, 0.014917813241481781, 0.04944559559226036, -0.008346283808350563, -0.042257387191057205, -0.007553724106401205, -0.07554403692483902, -0.05589957535266876, 0.03300698846578598, 0.11372864246368408, 0.05149708688259125, 0.013097085990011692, 0.0034566393587738276, -0.024026712402701378, -0.015626011416316032, 0.01864469051361084, -0.026381809264421463, -0.018757712095975876, -0.029767876490950584, -0.02348075434565544, 0.0742790624499321, -0.03556625172495842, 0.01307915523648262, -0.03446098417043686, 0.07199802994728088, -0.05639519542455673, -0.03756015747785568, -0.08113789558410645, 0.03867004066705704, 0.0017719169845804572, -0.04132671654224396, -0.006080856081098318, 0.006584113463759422, 0.052114151418209076, -0.032737620174884796, -0.018044672906398773, 0.045407768338918686, -0.0065542347729206085, -0.034247852861881256, -0.01415259949862957, -0.06169496849179268, -0.016518544405698776, -0.07040516287088394, 0.00784824974834919, 0.023324254900217056, 0.05552622675895691, 0.018474522978067398, 0.01626814715564251, -0.018611883744597435, 0.04997620731592178, -0.0170281995087862, 0.022918688133358955, -0.03266933187842369, -0.05991683900356293, 0.0019371811067685485, -0.040536459535360336, 0.031537946313619614, 0.058465078473091125, 0.025315407663583755, -0.006926039233803749, -0.006473027169704437, -0.024910105392336845, -0.02863125130534172, 0.00030267902184277773, 0.02967144176363945, 0.051453158259391785, 0.0063387127593159676, 0.003624848322942853, 0.038908280432224274, 0.06763873249292374, 0.045845866203308105, 0.03397861495614052, -0.07886289060115814, -0.0651700347661972, 0.027529427781701088, 0.004922369495034218, -0.028474975377321243, 0.043780367821455, -0.11893807351589203, 0.01580217108130455, 0.011394391767680645, -0.056885041296482086, 0.008036755956709385, 0.061103783547878265, -0.031080564484000206, -0.01311950758099556, 0.023165006190538406, 0.056700725108385086, 0.054186418652534485, 0.02851732447743416, -0.03238215669989586, -0.025376159697771072, -0.033817108720541, 0.06056912615895271, 0.03584669530391693, 0.05802500620484352, -0.0277409628033638, -0.05888153240084648, -0.007610993459820747, -0.03473528102040291, -0.022915469482541084, -0.03951844200491905, -0.08729245513677597, -0.007974856533110142, 0.00848146341741085, -0.08956384658813477, 0.07528122514486313, -0.02991173230111599, -0.07910531014204025, -0.04174058139324188, -0.0254537183791399, -0.03958260640501976, -0.021640464663505554, 0.089969702064991, 0.0784429982304573, -0.026313696056604385, 0.019000131636857986, -0.010566012002527714, -0.1378614455461502, 0.0838274359703064, 0.0611407645046711, -0.008284107781946659, 0.07635115832090378, 0.0009755936916917562, 0.021921027451753616, -0.015627659857273102, 0.06977270543575287, -0.03192304074764252, 0.015534166246652603, 0.07280045002698898, 0.02672649174928665, -0.002827542135491967, 0.003057178808376193, -0.06704811751842499, -0.07400330156087875, -0.024383438751101494, 0.0652669221162796, 0.0332343764603138, -0.03004925698041916, 0.06397773325443268, -0.041374463587999344, 0.0635954961180687, 0.05804574489593506, 0.11487475037574768, 0.02268514782190323, -0.049943339079618454, 0.015879245474934578, -0.033013977110385895, -0.004205918870866299, 0.007027029991149902, -0.016370413824915886, -0.039567314088344574, -0.01496689859777689, -0.021154742687940598, 0.047884080559015274, 0.008643780834972858, 0.09937836229801178, -0.04894818738102913, -0.06584478914737701, 0.06879667192697525, -0.05734243988990784, 0.0416535809636116, -0.042829204350709915, 0.026479871943593025, -0.012583491392433643, 0.05124925449490547, 0.09275715798139572, 0.02082071639597416, 0.00805648323148489, 0.019800283014774323, -0.059829823672771454, 0.06200612708926201, -0.039640508592128754, -0.002950672758743167, 0.002201696624979377, 0.018898731097579002, -0.0405716747045517, -0.02717316336929798, -0.029937978833913803, -0.01636243797838688, -0.004722232930362225, 0.03045426681637764, 0.04332144185900688, 0.04106553643941879, 0.012041249312460423, -0.02854345180094242, 0.026465894654393196, -0.0207495279610157, 0.008763216435909271, 0.014661280438303947, -0.034525033086538315, -0.013104143552482128, -0.07205608487129211, -0.01788373291492462, -0.013509427197277546, 0.003353648819029331, -0.0068782027810812, 0.00816316157579422, -0.002807404613122344, 0.06227527931332588, -0.01534377969801426, -0.05791535973548889, -0.0008463526610285044, -0.015779081732034683, 0.037071842700242996, -0.02048427425324917, 0.04864450544118881, -0.012685516849160194, -0.04064696654677391, -0.07284583896398544, 0.004344940185546875, -0.07850721478462219, 0.0022906665690243244, -0.03341272845864296, -0.10220766067504883, 0.012948491610586643, 0.1008506640791893, 0.027092985808849335, -0.04870511591434479, 0.028070496395230293, -0.01754535362124443, 0.044342100620269775, -0.017323993146419525, 0.06010310724377632, -0.003581672441214323, -0.02197800762951374, 0.010521397925913334, -0.047792043536901474, -0.04578043147921562, -0.06945839524269104, -0.0018235334428027272, -0.02367451973259449, 0.04435122385621071, -0.03997000306844711, 0.03738875314593315, 0.051576606929302216, -0.015629757195711136, 0.011201794259250164, 0.04059186205267906, 0.05302796512842178, -0.060661595314741135, -0.006432184483855963, -0.00405258871614933, 0.032081205397844315, 0.00929755438119173, -0.005794555880129337, -0.030621763318777084, 0.010908653028309345, -0.04016809165477753, -0.038298819214105606, -0.038032855838537216, -0.04395649582147598, -0.002749287523329258, -0.009374630637466908, 0.044752828776836395, 0.008318225853145123, -0.006434525828808546, -0.05885498225688934, 0.04175852611660957, 0.021537428721785545, 0.04660658538341522, 0.012629828415811062, 0.015361486934125423, -0.05637834221124649, 0.028757119551301003, 0.037881433963775635, 0.03125408664345741, -0.025994211435317993, 0.06908214092254639, 0.054592669010162354, -0.031358443200588226, -0.028123527765274048, 0.026147855445742607, 0.0423906184732914, -0.04450204223394394, 0.030668364837765694, -0.00859279278665781, 0.03708217665553093, 0.01783054694533348, -0.10450956970453262, 0.003142828121781349, 0.057035181671381, -0.05237318575382233, -0.09644300490617752, -0.052073173224925995, 0.004237198270857334, 0.008215713314712048, -0.03295440971851349, 0.11562863737344742, -0.06700862944126129, 0.040558941662311554, 0.02116643823683262, -0.035783421248197556, 0.013311916030943394, 0.07898734509944916, 0.019002512097358704, -0.030719036236405373, 0.09974034130573273, 0.00866042822599411, 0.0027363630943000317, -0.019440416246652603, -0.04677382484078407, 0.06302204728126526, -0.04497900232672691, -0.04856729879975319, -0.017595790326595306, -0.01058798935264349, 0.009989744983613491, 0.06713409721851349, 0.003080960363149643, 0.03237832710146904, 0.023244859650731087, -0.024831177666783333, 0.00510058319196105, 0.01611929200589657, 0.022584078833460808, 0.06033914536237717, -0.08042843639850616, -0.027108484879136086, 0.06851574033498764, 0.00017033558106049895, -0.0034739284310489893 ]
28
28
Virtual screening with support vector machines and structure kernels
Support vector machines and kernel methods have recently gained considerable attention in chemoinformatics. They offer generally good performance for problems of supervised classification or regression, and provide a flexible and computationally efficient framework to include relevant information and prior knowledge about the data and problems to be handled. In particular, with kernel methods molecules do not need to be represented and stored explicitly as vectors or fingerprints, but only to be compared to each other through a comparison function technically called a kernel. While classical kernels can be used to compare vector or fingerprint representations of molecules, completely new kernels were developed in the recent years to directly compare the 2D or 3D structures of molecules, without the need for an explicit vectorization step through the extraction of molecular descriptors. While still in their infancy, these approaches have already demonstrated their relevance on several toxicity prediction and structure-activity relationship problems.
[ -0.0036044621374458075, -0.1125234067440033, -0.0229966938495636, 0.03777569904923439, 0.058678947389125824, -0.048023030161857605, -0.0024202889762818813, 0.0008432726026512682, -0.08815650641918182, 0.0037727204617112875, 0.06443996727466583, -0.06511400640010834, -0.008369557559490204, 0.03538520261645317, -0.019123835489153862, 0.05207838863134384, 0.0485822968184948, -0.03663182258605957, 0.016108229756355286, -0.024334702640771866, 0.03456524387001991, -0.003983987495303154, -0.004616679158061743, -0.015517124906182289, -0.013128094375133514, 0.007775956764817238, -0.030323460698127747, 0.001135398168116808, 0.02937513217329979, 0.07366164773702621, -0.00168136996217072, -0.008848065510392189, 0.057666439563035965, -0.020229775458574295, 0.022467270493507385, -0.023755408823490143, 0.023412834852933884, 0.013911133632063866, -0.010200459510087967, 0.0105595039203763, 0.021875429898500443, -0.004517188295722008, -0.015212779864668846, 0.009132690727710724, 0.028299428522586823, 0.018972501158714294, -0.017243964597582817, 0.03191487863659859, 0.038244523108005524, 0.10737023502588272, -0.08996133506298065, 0.034432850778102875, -0.01483626663684845, 0.01748940907418728, -0.04923083633184433, -0.016956733539700508, -0.020039772614836693, 0.027186984196305275, 0.030465256422758102, 0.031844720244407654, 0.01226387545466423, 0.051288507878780365, -0.02540011703968048, -0.01622757501900196, 0.02664542943239212, -0.02207280695438385, -0.011385669931769371, -0.07710933685302734, 0.03261709213256836, -0.03889556601643562, -0.014240452088415623, -0.0485878512263298, 0.005866993684321642, -0.026903323829174042, 0.04218665882945061, 0.017678018659353256, 0.00039204565109685063, 0.04138144478201866, 0.05919407680630684, 0.08001600950956345, -0.06637894362211227, 0.02194341830909252, 0.020289843901991844, 0.07696240395307541, 0.008693922311067581, 0.034700971096754074, -0.0021305724512785673, -0.046356406062841415, -0.01841091923415661, 0.06207302585244179, 0.0162661075592041, 0.02587836980819702, -0.0061273700557649136, -0.0008798789349384606, -0.01052747294306755, -0.016777651384472847, -0.046130139380693436, -0.018619900569319725, 0.053612224757671356, -0.015114879235625267, 0.006336139049381018, 0.006713723763823509, 0.039668284356594086, 0.04961590841412544, 0.020235933363437653, 0.021234897896647453, -0.03660013899207115, 0.0400536023080349, -0.07547303289175034, 0.0411076694726944, 0.008863096125423908, -0.06651923805475235, -0.0007292738300748169, 0.04651275649666786, -0.01069169957190752, 0.0354919359087944, 0.03954115882515907, 0.06392587721347809, 0.0244130901992321, 0.011528770439326763, -0.01090651098638773, 0.0007215359946712852, -0.09677981585264206, 0.006984018720686436, 0.11321446299552917, -0.05908830836415291, -0.06126844510436058, -0.04241478815674782, 0.013927309773862362, -0.01166938804090023, -0.07587800174951553, 0.025517035275697708, -0.01622452773153782, 0.06234682723879814, 0.009628616273403168, -0.06520715355873108, 0.01764732412993908, -0.07435070723295212, -0.056301701813936234, -0.05996793136000633, 0.06879726052284241, 0.012196311727166176, 0.009495960548520088, 0.019109902903437614, 0.02814149111509323, -0.01139903161674738, -0.007432220503687859, 0.022356314584612846, 0.04852190986275673, -0.04304150119423866, -0.04861564561724663, -0.07030341774225235, 0.026656778529286385, -0.00023399267229251564, -0.022894658148288727, -0.05838027596473694, -0.1041334867477417, 0.0045000119134783745, -0.04581441357731819, 0.06636132299900055, -0.013937704265117645, -0.07672104239463806, -0.051447413861751556, -0.003612726926803589, 0.008592067286372185, -0.0020057184156030416, -0.03737705945968628, -0.08509483188390732, 0.00029461283702403307, -0.03185015544295311, -0.04692309722304344, 0.049558497965335846, -0.0012666990514844656, 0.0052618407644331455, -0.0019437375012785196, 0.012864694930613041, -0.06867585331201553, 0.04350222647190094, -0.010287981480360031, -0.04531576484441757, -0.007874351926147938, -0.01567281223833561, -0.05584602802991867, 0.07935959845781326, 0.05165686085820198, 0.11344505101442337, -0.002590371062979102, -0.025202423334121704, 0.010471303015947342, -0.022912679240107536, 0.09518345445394516, 0.01830330304801464, 0.03041137382388115, -0.04012437164783478, -0.04962572082877159, 0.02404828742146492, 0.056048981845378876, -0.06273546069860458, 0.047537993639707565, 0.059735335409641266, 0.04637933522462845, 0.01661800779402256, -0.03382626920938492, 0.008284482173621655, -0.010947603732347488, 0.04367925971746445, 0.10169900208711624, -0.018368251621723175, -0.012359093874692917, -0.005636547692120075, 0.03448714315891266, 0.07199084013700485, 0.03003050945699215, -0.009102236479520798, 0.0074328170157969, -0.03834746405482292, 0.04799768701195717, 0.00034551325370557606, 0.09677942842245102, 0.0368850901722908, 0.002225713338702917, 0.030173545703291893, -0.04342437535524368, 0.067281074821949, -0.11394054442644119, 0.02486424520611763, -0.0674154981970787, -0.02298736199736595, -0.005094741936773062, 0.022149089723825455, -0.04288475960493088, -0.06304488331079483, -0.05992657318711281, -0.05173139646649361, 0.10062485933303833, 0.008027524687349796, -0.03458233177661896, -0.022555381059646606, 0.03969018533825874, 0.04585796594619751, -0.005542455241084099, 0.022265514358878136, 0.03349241614341736, -0.08913445472717285, 0.006933473516255617, -0.05473260208964348, 0.014060205779969692, 0.09676772356033325, -0.030208656564354897, 0.023857615888118744, 0.00761096877977252, 0.002067922381684184, -0.03183368965983391, -0.030307888984680176, 0.07039521634578705, 0.038895945996046066, 0.00114472268614918, 0.03623977676033974, -0.051284849643707275, 0.03316079452633858, 0.022912612184882164, 0.033305972814559937, -0.0000979291507974267, -0.04588741436600685, 0.04534409940242767, -0.061756666749715805, -0.01924051158130169, 0.036471717059612274, 0.01684243604540825, 0.0441964752972126, -0.06878432631492615, -0.051364555954933167, -0.03616328537464142, 0.05611032620072365, -0.05133040249347687, 0.033669427037239075, 0.07477361708879471, 0.0770130455493927, -0.04174930602312088, -0.09388633072376251, -0.036775797605514526, -0.014813044108450413, -0.015307358466088772, 0.020726200193166733, -0.08839459717273712, 0.005233569070696831, -0.017717525362968445, -0.06730614602565765, -0.005772887263447046, -0.041758932173252106, -0.0771457701921463, 0.12012654542922974, -0.07847800850868225, -0.026218796148896217, 0.08005937933921814, -0.019588781520724297, 0.0017687532817944884, 0.05952842906117439, 0.08425882458686829, -0.03562285378575325, 0.05172101408243179, 0.06883078813552856, 0.020524175837635994, -0.018586445599794388, 0.04094679653644562, 0.03746771439909935, 0.011300823651254177, -0.029053987935185432, 0.017289644107222557, 0.032770492136478424, -0.03644268214702606, 0.013821350410580635, 0.011293328367173672, -0.05152524635195732, 0.021129649132490158, -0.009381948038935661, 0.02687656693160534, 0.005504900589585304, 0.005638086702674627, 0.018900727853178978, 0.010843188501894474, 0.08006058633327484, 0.06314560770988464, -0.042965278029441833, -0.03583183139562607, -0.01817486807703972, -0.04098110646009445, 0.021643079817295074, -0.09570997953414917, -0.02503071166574955, -0.10147044062614441, -0.01929728500545025, 0.013988030143082142, 0.06638734042644501, -0.02032732591032982, -0.012814866378903389, 0.02128738723695278, 0.04097357392311096, -0.020915301516652107, -0.03797338902950287, -0.09698929637670517, -0.058250267058610916, 0.04707451909780502, -0.015898730605840683, -0.03010638803243637, 0.05414286255836487, 0.052854426205158234, 0.03449677675962448, -0.06793852895498276, 0.01138013694435358, -0.022167183458805084, -0.015577751211822033, -0.00812077522277832, -0.014464838430285454, -0.06682029366493225, 0.05896151438355446, 0.02118752896785736, -0.009762554429471493, 0.03591708838939667, -0.0024319193325936794, 0.04379623010754585, 0.017613818868994713, -0.04843435436487198, 0.0320037379860878, -0.018062017858028412, 0.06831618398427963, -0.00941480603069067, 0.050919074565172195, 0.023524142801761627, 0.029455160722136497, -0.03175269067287445, 0.005108332727104425, 0.05968010053038597, 0.007703137584030628, -0.007876403629779816, -0.0696883499622345, 0.018229758366942406, -0.0025588732678443193, 0.0009409285266883671, -0.03680237755179405, -0.05714872106909752, 0.017944278195500374, -0.033358581364154816, -0.0021516417618840933, -0.08952046185731888, -0.018634583801031113, -0.028043484315276146, 0.05237460881471634, 0.012004020623862743, 0.02228461019694805, -0.08099066466093063, 0.04012903571128845, -0.05920841172337532, -0.005154031794518232, 0.00945079606026411, -0.013716237619519234, -0.019927440211176872, -0.0294413510710001, -0.0044609238393604755, -0.008507093414664268, -0.051119107753038406, -0.05026308447122574, 0.014949269592761993, -0.04834577068686485, -0.04720362275838852, 0.03129540756344795, -0.05566634237766266, 0.06513792276382446, -0.03394085913896561, -0.022615086287260056, 0.016106044873595238, -0.06691358238458633, -0.036242131143808365, -0.0530969612300396, 0.051426324993371964, -0.012344191782176495, -0.07989417016506195, -0.03705620393157005, 0.0663420557975769, -0.1113198772072792, 0.0035666287876665592, 0.0699087455868721, 0.0011194150429219007, 0.02238941192626953, -0.04658805578947067, 0.019237913191318512, 0.06148906797170639, 0.08743052184581757, 0.0047329445369541645, -0.010199019685387611, 0.009769642725586891, 0.04856232926249504, -0.08065929263830185, 0.06674935668706894, 0.06922274827957153, -0.01136696431785822, 0.04840606823563576, -0.06931072473526001, 0.02574070915579796, -0.012765522114932537, -0.013359644450247288, -0.059076886624097824, 0.039418499916791916, -0.03505871444940567, -0.000780566711910069, 0.0085735023021698, -0.025582974776625633, -0.013187999837100506, 0.05818374827504158, 0.008605786599218845, -0.02523449808359146, 0.020428691059350967, 0.024705920368433, 0.05087241902947426, -0.036737844347953796, -0.023736733943223953, -0.04446747526526451, -0.05832144245505333, 0.029101012274622917, -0.04418367147445679, 0.004902547691017389, -0.011787613853812218, -0.04295096546411514, 0.016583938151597977, -0.06604616343975067, 0.06062682345509529, 0.0324336513876915, 0.07019394636154175, 0.027081096544861794, -0.022279931232333183, -0.033972080796957016, -0.03084828332066536, 0.04666133224964142, -0.03057841584086418, 0.025885753333568573, 0.03661727160215378, -0.02890118956565857, -0.09181322157382965, -0.04779696837067604, -0.08891500532627106, -0.019033992663025856, -0.03158009424805641, -0.018321411684155464, -0.01443706639111042, -0.05337986722588539, 0.0038553301710635424, 0.025080936029553413, -0.020451819524168968, -0.04068802669644356, -0.044561717659235, -0.017855985090136528, -0.030716191977262497, -0.08976467698812485, 0.021666189655661583, -0.03701692447066307, -0.0649847611784935, -0.04334776848554611, -0.04018838703632355, 0.02053523063659668, -0.0031237280927598476, 0.009938492439687252, 0.031003018841147423, 0.024334412068128586, 0.03735481575131416, 0.09205770492553711, 0.013048936612904072, 0.08292297273874283, -0.0049907006323337555, 0.06880267709493637, 0.0682581216096878, -0.037267304956912994, -0.04527987539768219 ]
29
29
Structure or Noise?
We show how rate-distortion theory provides a mechanism for automated theory building by naturally distinguishing between regularity and randomness. We start from the simple principle that model variables should, as much as possible, render the future and past conditionally independent. From this, we construct an objective function for model making whose extrema embody the trade-off between a model's structural complexity and its predictive power. The solutions correspond to a hierarchy of models that, at each level of complexity, achieve optimal predictive power at minimal cost. In the limit of maximal prediction the resulting optimal model identifies a process's intrinsic organization by extracting the underlying causal states. In this limit, the model's complexity is given by the statistical complexity, which is known to be minimal for achieving maximum prediction. Examples show how theory building can profit from analyzing a process's causal compressibility, which is reflected in the optimal models' rate-distortion curve--the process's characteristic for optimally balancing structure and noise at different levels of representation.
[ 0.011753398925065994, -0.06562095135450363, -0.037247397005558014, -0.06846988946199417, 0.01311519742012024, -0.038015756756067276, 0.038606107234954834, 0.0019250294426456094, 0.043716710060834885, -0.023680925369262695, -0.02125725895166397, -0.024752961471676826, -0.05841975286602974, -0.05904822796583176, -0.03548021242022514, -0.06376069784164429, -0.06147008761763573, -0.02383272722363472, 0.021774185821413994, -0.010220294818282127, -0.043730728328228, 0.015065888874232769, -0.02548931911587715, -0.024248894304037094, -0.030950170010328293, -0.022054824978113174, 0.03012576699256897, -0.05016102269291878, 0.047738805413246155, -0.012269885279238224, -0.07142510265111923, 0.027368420735001564, 0.029612896963953972, -0.026041341945528984, 0.031780749559402466, -0.03834310546517372, -0.024295389652252197, -0.055657707154750824, -0.022326361387968063, -0.048927728086709976, 0.04492456465959549, -0.03988524153828621, -0.020744793117046356, -0.04227545112371445, 0.07897907495498657, 0.022269997745752335, 0.0021617133170366287, 0.06681051105260849, 0.014161642640829086, 0.031081996858119965, -0.050691209733486176, 0.05670888349413872, 0.02536141686141491, -0.07220880687236786, -0.03785702586174011, 0.004921364597976208, -0.0715661272406578, -0.08090411871671677, -0.017225243151187897, -0.05220992863178253, -0.0024913870729506016, 0.045376621186733246, -0.043030742555856705, -0.050012342631816864, 0.03026626817882061, 0.07974710315465927, -0.045688796788454056, 0.02395429089665413, -0.03682079538702965, 0.0207494106143713, 0.007261979393661022, 0.006805592216551304, 0.037147436290979385, -0.02539691887795925, -0.0047630611807107925, -0.014906045980751514, -0.010271704755723476, -0.012001528404653072, -0.0059090228751301765, 0.07663311809301376, -0.062519371509552, 0.09614173322916031, -0.0321677029132843, 0.02013174258172512, -0.06051022186875343, 0.07733489573001862, 0.022230438888072968, -0.042312800884246826, -0.005495910532772541, -0.08125082403421402, 0.003798824269324541, 0.021271537989377975, -0.060924138873815536, 0.06606002151966095, -0.09362262487411499, 0.06662742048501968, 0.017420047894120216, -0.02773081324994564, -0.04817468300461769, 0.030933301895856857, 0.05536437779664993, 0.031678128987550735, 0.10422232747077942, 0.08319520205259323, -0.020237093791365623, 0.02742849476635456, 0.033720966428518295, 0.052225902676582336, -0.009308534674346447, 0.0073637147434055805, 0.013220458291471004, -0.022221308201551437, 0.013649788685142994, 0.005861983168870211, -0.05801836773753166, 0.05167994648218155, 0.0398029200732708, 0.08645521849393845, 0.049237899482250214, -0.02752789668738842, -0.0019112793961539865, -0.003982224967330694, -0.020684825256466866, 0.02675638534128666, 0.03804710879921913, -0.04345392808318138, -0.024231214076280594, -0.020977942273020744, 0.09852483123540878, -0.06482701748609543, -0.00675247935578227, -0.015779780223965645, -0.004205022472888231, -0.013817732222378254, -0.051765646785497665, 0.0850052461028099, -0.00612485408782959, -0.030405201017856598, 0.014518052339553833, 0.10507748275995255, -0.019734391942620277, -0.043221037834882736, -0.030107498168945312, 0.004741529934108257, 0.022126678377389908, 0.05624718219041824, 0.02882353775203228, -0.10026626288890839, -0.012918941676616669, -0.030603446066379547, -0.057977668941020966, -0.050342857837677, -0.006685409229248762, 0.029419125989079475, 0.005668018478900194, -0.0049196104519069195, -0.05959966033697128, -0.0232720747590065, -0.08379058539867401, 0.03577663376927376, -0.03799561411142349, -0.00991210900247097, 0.04761848971247673, 0.06655830144882202, -0.02370995283126831, -0.025043006986379623, -0.030102986842393875, -0.0388684906065464, -0.03406703472137451, -0.056867003440856934, -0.14934951066970825, -0.031842637807130814, -0.005017329938709736, 0.09950283169746399, 0.04660721868276596, 0.0012188226683065295, -0.006882736459374428, 0.02800862304866314, -0.027896780520677567, -0.06885328143835068, 0.0030190092511475086, -0.02828017622232437, -0.012543776072561741, 0.035568058490753174, -0.014143993146717548, 0.05199131369590759, -0.13138701021671295, 0.05961206555366516, 0.07143617421388626, 0.030609266832470894, 0.03934232518076897, 0.04212300479412079, -0.08199885487556458, 0.0009792500641196966, -0.030382409691810608, -0.03727176412940025, -0.017350153997540474, 0.0292563047260046, 0.0017087847227230668, 0.09111298620700836, 0.026453962549567223, 0.0343993678689003, -0.08175100386142731, -0.10664854198694229, -0.06026535481214523, 0.03593131899833679, 0.047145355492830276, -0.020267188549041748, -0.029133401811122894, -0.07438500970602036, 0.028256170451641083, -0.06289441883563995, -0.04096033051609993, 0.019284214824438095, 0.03069731779396534, 0.010314060375094414, -0.010637574829161167, -0.04395333677530289, 0.061877910047769547, -0.03746597841382027, 0.01700611039996147, 0.0839502364397049, -0.018897132948040962, 0.03037315234541893, -0.06386058032512665, -0.06226740777492523, 0.0930527076125145, 0.02870761789381504, -0.06327354162931442, 0.045666731894016266, -0.06759615242481232, -0.02839878760278225, -0.049656059592962265, 0.054075874388217926, -0.028784550726413727, 0.026664096862077713, 0.028823236003518105, -0.05175481736660004, 0.013489262200891972, -0.044119320809841156, -0.07723921537399292, 0.07004611194133759, -0.04245708882808685, -0.023240627720952034, 0.044497303664684296, -0.0010303060989826918, -0.0029952574986964464, 0.01336277462542057, -0.03937884792685509, -0.0004273410886526108, 0.026502802968025208, -0.004365300759673119, -0.031881723552942276, -0.004373377654701471, 0.05379898473620415, 0.0521836094558239, -0.07463749498128891, 0.006486960221081972, 0.029486609622836113, 0.0821133479475975, -0.024188710376620293, 0.014752501621842384, -0.05681928992271423, 0.061470404267311096, 0.019245052710175514, -0.009111926890909672, -0.056775566190481186, 0.0529380701482296, 0.10534290969371796, -0.004063175525516272, 0.016149260103702545, -0.028280116617679596, -0.05067455396056175, 0.03945544734597206, -0.06315303593873978, -0.004816505126655102, -0.019050490111112595, -0.01641956903040409, 0.01274879276752472, -0.03646337240934372, -0.04788440093398094, 0.04893253743648529, -0.03897271305322647, -0.03404514119029045, -0.05499053746461868, 0.03054785542190075, -0.017913799732923508, 0.03926868736743927, 0.005777718964964151, 0.007716430351138115, -0.10188473761081696, 0.019092220813035965, -0.01326752733439207, -0.047136835753917694, 0.026073608547449112, -0.04094929248094559, 0.032607246190309525, 0.039755262434482574, 0.059037309139966965, 0.08776038885116577, -0.01029493473470211, -0.000008676147444930393, 0.09702315926551819, 0.035178542137145996, 0.04503386840224266, 0.07954660058021545, 0.08712468296289444, 0.049481794238090515, -0.059014465659856796, -0.013147211633622646, -0.03650009632110596, 0.024252118542790413, -0.016867687925696373, -0.0657365694642067, 0.00805684830993414, -0.02568279206752777, -0.03985166922211647, -0.0255239550024271, -0.03183623403310776, -0.02482113428413868, -0.01366809755563736, -0.04238119721412659, -0.04507151618599892, 0.03131037577986717, -0.049963030964136124, -0.00283734779804945, 0.06082473322749138, 0.026567893102765083, -0.024396752938628197, 0.04904135316610336, -0.038816891610622406, -0.07224428653717041, 0.005983231123536825, 0.06643231213092804, -0.01718856953084469, 0.01289020199328661, -0.05076058954000473, 0.008496447466313839, -0.010571696795523167, -0.0034058953169733286, -0.05362406745553017, -0.11326371878385544, -0.03477589786052704, -0.030210036784410477, 0.04057677090167999, 0.06806300580501556, 0.0718952938914299, 0.018848244100809097, -0.0021996386349201202, 0.006168512627482414, -0.04001133516430855, -0.08488167822360992, -0.022876892238855362, 0.0013364576734602451, -0.0019419605378061533, -0.0008918680250644684, 0.018509110435843468, -0.012566489167511463, 0.04574750363826752, 0.054003313183784485, 0.037356071174144745, -0.015225181356072426, -0.0076026334427297115, 0.01836239919066429, 0.022594094276428223, 0.061824727803468704, -0.0317499004304409, 0.03044905699789524, -0.04236860200762749, -0.03487934544682503, 0.023647351190447807, 0.03893965482711792, -0.040877267718315125, 0.01312717329710722, 0.020841868594288826, -0.01724405772984028, 0.03224784880876541, -0.07254768908023834, -0.03948022052645683, 0.0028849400114268064, 0.010697929188609123, -0.04008184000849724, -0.039529699832201004, 0.01650894060730934, -0.033029649406671524, -0.06815195828676224, -0.08104197680950165, -0.0043939161114394665, 0.045994993299245834, -0.015985732898116112, 0.009722367860376835, -0.00943796243518591, 0.01797083206474781, -0.003475252538919449, 0.015281463973224163, -0.028711557388305664, 0.017075281590223312, -0.045103639364242554, -0.03668881580233574, 0.0047720493748784065, -0.007315116468816996, -0.08549966663122177, -0.013384995050728321, -0.015085197985172272, -0.02355629950761795, 0.004104932304471731, -0.012308669276535511, -0.027962423861026764, 0.0625833123922348, 0.011131498962640762, 0.02316913567483425, -0.01100145373493433, 0.06555873900651932, 0.04589425027370453, -0.06218532845377922, 0.06073037162423134, 0.04694461449980736, 0.0015901938313618302, -0.0016131290467455983, -0.07079127430915833, 0.0573028028011322, -0.050291355699300766, -0.030643280595541, 0.049536168575286865, 0.0149998739361763, -0.029352210462093353, 0.06361053138971329, 0.02091510221362114, -0.02793772704899311, 0.04193061962723732, -0.021516060456633568, -0.028769567608833313, -0.09742823243141174, 0.07190541177988052, -0.025204626843333244, -0.06376820057630539, -0.03822992742061615, -0.08298956602811813, 0.008042585104703903, 0.015921076759696007, -0.007780157495290041, 0.020048031583428383, -0.030048299580812454, 0.029888300225138664, 0.02069862186908722, -0.017559176310896873, 0.026997067034244537, 0.003277849406003952, 0.04323112964630127, 0.019652362912893295, -0.023301968351006508, 0.07767502963542938, 0.03249134123325348, -0.016350528225302696, -0.01471199281513691, -0.03666352853178978, 0.0272847730666399, 0.017283260822296143, 0.08337067812681198, -0.050311263650655746, 0.01701398752629757, -0.007483897265046835, -0.01601453125476837, 0.04619332402944565, -0.06279602646827698, -0.05701172351837158, 0.03347892686724663, 0.07650290429592133, 0.06136603280901909, 0.08144216984510422, -0.01227922085672617, 0.07091905176639557, -0.010423632338643074, -0.03082641400396824, 0.006801375653594732, -0.03564992547035217, 0.040003981441259384, -0.022328071296215057, -0.0417851060628891, -0.007882391102612019, 0.04772413149476051, 0.02372475154697895, -0.03325314074754715, -0.03855789825320244, 0.02567199431359768, 0.05051587522029877, -0.010725144296884537, 0.022370891645550728, 0.06697410345077515, 0.0015047540655359626, 0.015715032815933228, -0.013060425408184528, -0.03008364513516426, -0.011800095438957214, 0.06745358556509018, 0.01692078448832035, 0.00338159641250968, 0.03971154987812042, 0.04343468323349953, 0.06331099569797516, 0.022548198699951172, -0.010289286263287067, 0.04489309340715408, 0.006804834119975567, 0.059844743460416794, 0.07314509898424149, 0.01290139090269804, 0.003570985049009323, -0.0010817311704158783, -0.0034206979908049107, -0.02264014631509781, 0.03247915208339691 ]
30
30
Cost-minimising strategies for data labelling : optimal stopping and active learning
Supervised learning deals with the inference of a distribution over an output or label space $\CY$ conditioned on points in an observation space $\CX$, given a training dataset $D$ of pairs in $\CX \times \CY$. However, in a lot of applications of interest, acquisition of large amounts of observations is easy, while the process of generating labels is time-consuming or costly. One way to deal with this problem is {\em active} learning, where points to be labelled are selected with the aim of creating a model with better performance than that of an model trained on an equal number of randomly sampled points. In this paper, we instead propose to deal with the labelling cost directly: The learning goal is defined as the minimisation of a cost which is a function of the expected model performance and the total cost of the labels used. This allows the development of general strategies and specific algorithms for (a) optimal stopping, where the expected cost dictates whether label acquisition should continue (b) empirical evaluation, where the cost is used as a performance metric for a given combination of inference, stopping and sampling methods. Though the main focus of the paper is optimal stopping, we also aim to provide the background for further developments and discussion in the related field of active learning.
[ -0.016448041424155235, -0.039029285311698914, 0.0368749164044857, -0.0046551707200706005, 0.023091187700629234, -0.0952993631362915, -0.03856923058629036, 0.056443952023983, -0.06125558540225029, 0.0041932412423193455, -0.0367354080080986, 0.049957629293203354, 0.009843937121331692, -0.01541932299733162, 0.026871846988797188, 0.03158740699291229, -0.03139716759324074, -0.02079373225569725, 0.016358017921447754, -0.0228520967066288, -0.008167089894413948, -0.01655319705605507, 0.044903580099344254, 0.06443856656551361, 0.00976549182087183, -0.009024285711348057, 0.026913318783044815, 0.02739087864756584, -0.019911594688892365, -0.024204157292842865, -0.05707745999097824, 0.0007058544433675706, -0.032430943101644516, -0.03183058276772499, -0.0005279644974507391, -0.09259622544050217, 0.0806407630443573, -0.05494893342256546, -0.041277796030044556, -0.08916139602661133, 0.037960685789585114, 0.007197082508355379, 0.002305251080542803, -0.012964561581611633, 0.04292459040880203, 0.08221220970153809, 0.003746338188648224, -0.029474729672074318, -0.012886058539152145, 0.06782371550798416, -0.06962049752473831, -0.030094055458903313, -0.0034073959104716778, 0.05624410882592201, 0.03323013335466385, 0.02373620681464672, -0.028863856568932533, 0.013276905752718449, -0.03139599412679672, -0.09548171609640121, 0.01011241227388382, 0.10596250742673874, 0.022518938407301903, 0.06235482171177864, -0.0594555027782917, 0.03012099117040634, -0.06795842200517654, -0.06874243915081024, -0.031318631023168564, 0.08420972526073456, 0.038410332053899765, -0.10327973961830139, -0.021947409957647324, -0.005028382409363985, 0.08064349740743637, 0.04657605290412903, -0.08338762819766998, 0.04386775568127632, -0.006043683271855116, 0.04072974994778633, -0.04908660799264908, 0.006797277834266424, -0.03583911806344986, 0.07586004585027695, -0.050791967660188675, -0.03624097257852554, 0.03260137140750885, -0.011552689597010612, 0.01712626963853836, 0.036620303988456726, 0.0521203987300396, 0.03706842288374901, -0.011995800770819187, -0.010983535088598728, 0.0012518961448222399, 0.02595941722393036, 0.03501641005277634, -0.03645709529519081, -0.007168225012719631, 0.07647757232189178, 0.049652788788080215, -0.0013607736909762025, 0.04811741039156914, 0.09414885193109512, -0.07816239446401596, -0.011527251452207565, -0.009863262064754963, 0.056111522018909454, 0.06702939420938492, 0.0021051184739917517, 0.09609021991491318, 0.021619776263833046, 0.01738443784415722, 0.08167477697134018, -0.06284857541322708, 0.02107747457921505, -0.0671095922589302, 0.020597949624061584, -0.0038613430224359035, -0.02883448638021946, -0.011398996226489544, 0.006577140651643276, -0.06230049580335617, -0.024602925404906273, 0.0001831188128562644, -0.009610007517039776, -0.005298163741827011, -0.05283414572477341, 0.06539259850978851, 0.02450760081410408, -0.05185716599225998, 0.04581630602478981, -0.06969371438026428, -0.11694347113370895, -0.04125262051820755, 0.0647205114364624, 0.054266899824142456, -0.02255260944366455, 0.019852513447403908, 0.003924448508769274, -0.019912997260689735, 0.023355334997177124, -0.016833290457725525, 0.05527991056442261, 0.02490585297346115, 0.003597525879740715, -0.04428093880414963, 0.010025124996900558, 0.028926048427820206, -0.029456987977027893, 0.04804610833525658, 0.002628814661875367, 0.03649245202541351, 0.024527793750166893, 0.04385075345635414, -0.05156378075480461, 0.03307192400097847, 0.013517615385353565, -0.039532676339149475, -0.015564527362585068, -0.015074150636792183, 0.07649610191583633, 0.025726953521370888, 0.012794501148164272, -0.030728714540600777, -0.04349912330508232, 0.009680105373263359, -0.018990781158208847, -0.0659109503030777, -0.046531062573194504, -0.054324474185705185, 0.01852281764149666, -0.0190281942486763, 0.02619817852973938, 0.02496771141886711, 0.033021148294210434, -0.00008516271191183478, 0.020380984991788864, 0.015887035056948662, 0.02430422231554985, 0.08035485446453094, -0.007094383239746094, -0.023456024006009102, -0.01908644288778305, 0.09888775646686554, 0.007374688051640987, 0.0025411678943783045, 0.05336891859769821, 0.1221003532409668, 0.035707537084817886, -0.002064917702227831, 0.03320997580885887, 0.01131038460880518, 0.050739530473947525, -0.01125215645879507, 0.03212178125977516, 0.06014345958828926, 0.011793681420385838, 0.02714681066572666, 0.024351375177502632, 0.034792255610227585, -0.012579056434333324, -0.044904813170433044, 0.012532909400761127, -0.026375804096460342, -0.0056640091352164745, 0.044370606541633606, -0.02845904789865017, -0.02115185186266899, -0.06058743596076965, 0.022581808269023895, -0.0020104963332414627, 0.011751039884984493, -0.031613875180482864, 0.007961466908454895, 0.03944401443004608, 0.006292789708822966, 0.016376862302422523, 0.0644347071647644, 0.07133810222148895, -0.002562442561611533, 0.018545830622315407, -0.012816168367862701, 0.013609776273369789, -0.07100102305412292, -0.01828090101480484, 0.05653192475438118, -0.05902109667658806, -0.023785851895809174, 0.06606131792068481, -0.022833997383713722, -0.04316181316971779, -0.05724909529089928, 0.027466649189591408, 0.016926340758800507, 0.020191045477986336, -0.008483578450977802, -0.001550997025333345, -0.019713547080755234, -0.03335270658135414, -0.04851105436682701, 0.07577437162399292, -0.016217458993196487, -0.05706433951854706, -0.013551957905292511, -0.02196192368865013, 0.06650236994028091, -0.09607172757387161, -0.10253125429153442, -0.04215163737535477, 0.012479961849749088, 0.007684074807912111, -0.027561942115426064, -0.05653966963291168, -0.008780458942055702, -0.03601238876581192, 0.05454869568347931, 0.05126999691128731, 0.043098777532577515, 0.0679076686501503, 0.00024165523063857108, 0.06905078142881393, -0.025064900517463684, 0.029701540246605873, 0.08795641362667084, 0.016499266028404236, 0.010414371266961098, 0.032039400190114975, 0.04134054109454155, 0.013598497025668621, -0.09256480634212494, -0.061246756464242935, -0.029116082936525345, 0.06007064878940582, -0.022688817232847214, -0.04929301142692566, 0.06323612481355667, -0.006144100334495306, 0.041068147867918015, -0.05551891401410103, -0.07212599366903305, -0.030363989993929863, 0.06687313318252563, -0.00946536473929882, -0.019069621339440346, -0.0037138357292860746, -0.025710269808769226, -0.13013096153736115, 0.027499312534928322, -0.009369404055178165, -0.04300002381205559, 0.03503129631280899, -0.04978068545460701, 0.05142250657081604, 0.04955053701996803, -0.07109816372394562, 0.035251881927251816, 0.03784453868865967, -0.020396459847688675, -0.018631642684340477, 0.06365436315536499, 0.0794440433382988, 0.08206316083669662, -0.013267556205391884, -0.009455142542719841, 0.033705320209264755, 0.08768225461244583, 0.03952351212501526, -0.03241782262921333, 0.009525053203105927, 0.02153744548559189, -0.008094321005046368, -0.052185505628585815, -0.0037342451978474855, -0.029604753479361534, 0.027928728610277176, -0.020547471940517426, -0.09187184274196625, -0.07835245877504349, -0.00800839439034462, 0.08257569372653961, -0.01610533520579338, 0.045445557683706284, 0.009814142249524593, -0.032115813344717026, -0.027633311226963997, 0.05149257183074951, 0.021023226901888847, -0.05976857244968414, -0.005632678512483835, -0.07242778688669205, 0.021349165588617325, 0.008893209509551525, 0.08653169870376587, -0.02899647317826748, -0.010663548484444618, -0.0866110771894455, 0.023209095001220703, -0.03486426919698715, -0.020799795165657997, -0.10890848934650421, -0.13177761435508728, -0.03011477179825306, -0.0022585291881114244, -0.06145135313272476, 0.001474267803132534, 0.07832924276590347, -0.01776251010596752, -0.05409795045852661, 0.06055925041437149, -0.06565424799919128, -0.00012337235966697335, -0.05888080224394798, 0.001625464647077024, -0.05496266111731529, -0.09080114215612411, 0.03256315365433693, -0.035026807337999344, 0.012579708360135555, -0.01243249885737896, -0.07016227394342422, 0.024302154779434204, 0.01081768050789833, -0.01601223461329937, -0.032195281237363815, 0.00016823904297780246, -0.04140626639127731, 0.009928928688168526, -0.052936285734176636, -0.005975928623229265, -0.02144835703074932, 0.028571661561727524, 0.022866392508149147, -0.04410821199417114, 0.07154753804206848, 0.012443792074918747, 0.018375881016254425, -0.023296203464269638, -0.01698342338204384, 0.070452019572258, -0.05619404464960098, 0.012919138185679913, 0.006403302773833275, -0.009700054302811623, -0.08506830036640167, -0.018485965207219124, -0.046189796179533005, 0.0028129308484494686, 0.09282409399747849, 0.06774120032787323, 0.012861027382314205, -0.03307031840085983, 0.00015213913866318762, -0.009626944549381733, -0.012413806281983852, 0.015094530768692493, -0.04526352509856224, -0.02206304296851158, -0.03182769566774368, 0.026944857090711594, -0.004211497958749533, 0.006309147458523512, 0.04072732850909233, -0.07860510051250458, -0.06686234474182129, -0.015744242817163467, 0.04495400935411453, 0.09333354234695435, 0.03578387200832367, 0.01647961512207985, 0.022745080292224884, 0.0165555402636528, -0.02083679474890232, 0.09026999026536942, -0.06703007966279984, 0.015575307421386242, -0.010878878645598888, 0.027408333495259285, 0.010519717819988728, -0.10009107738733292, 0.015783097594976425, -0.024623584002256393, 0.024277089163661003, -0.02832356095314026, 0.045161172747612, -0.06599684804677963, 0.03219681978225708, 0.024026893079280853, 0.017783964052796364, 0.044999029487371445, -0.0050549376755952835, -0.00838686153292656, -0.04172631353139877, 0.025843339040875435, 0.02544446662068367, 0.014657807536423206, 0.024986444041132927, 0.007537396624684334, 0.04119701683521271, 0.03420550003647804, -0.0010594159830361605, 0.03233174979686737, 0.04147404059767723, -0.037843797355890274, -0.03658151999115944, 0.08454413712024689, 0.04661621153354645, 0.0256771482527256, 0.040004268288612366, 0.0014588782796636224, -0.009897134266793728, 0.03597153350710869, 0.012942388653755188, 0.0028869356028735638, 0.023154834285378456, -0.005751405376940966, 0.04068418964743614, -0.08517830818891525, 0.002318920800462365, -0.056943364441394806, 0.02421295829117298, -0.026986705139279366, -0.0014762341743335128, -0.01055293157696724, -0.051693107932806015, 0.044690847396850586, -0.011873329989612103, 0.008362077176570892, 0.016791298985481262, -0.015139943920075893, -0.029815882444381714, 0.051179189234972, -0.044127337634563446, -0.04808991774916649, 0.007685661315917969, 0.058961011469364166, 0.004124395549297333, -0.050442714244127274, 0.06485578417778015, -0.06804293394088745, 0.007053535897284746, -0.025868989527225494, -0.03920824080705643, -0.0014610628131777048, -0.010551050305366516, 0.0362267829477787, -0.03469090536236763, 0.028792761266231537, -0.004348711110651493, 0.011979597620666027, -0.02506405860185623, -0.05616861954331398, -0.015793364495038986, 0.028547534719109535, -0.003222898580133915, -0.08741411566734314, -0.01723400317132473, -0.01648414134979248, 0.03945761173963547, 0.04590150713920593, 0.00921606831252575, -0.024176934733986855, 0.039923861622810364, 0.06614706665277481, 0.04531097784638405, 0.007509712129831314, 0.018207496032118797, 0.04860115051269531, -0.02262740768492222, 0.027364395558834076, -0.04126370698213577, 0.11946490406990051 ]
31
31
Defensive forecasting for optimal prediction with expert advice
The method of defensive forecasting is applied to the problem of prediction with expert advice for binary outcomes. It turns out that defensive forecasting is not only competitive with the Aggregating Algorithm but also handles the case of "second-guessing" experts, whose advice depends on the learner's prediction; this paper assumes that the dependence on the learner's prediction is continuous.
[ -0.008686969056725502, -0.046220697462558746, -0.012947085313498974, -0.06746696680784225, -0.006151502951979637, -0.0573917031288147, -0.03781122714281082, 0.005794565659016371, 0.015184378251433372, -0.017775867134332657, 0.021775051951408386, -0.03728247806429863, -0.07108894735574722, 0.020168565213680267, 0.10377427190542221, -0.0442618764936924, -0.017355777323246002, 0.04404588043689728, -0.07320579886436462, -0.0555536113679409, 0.07540793716907501, -0.036144498735666275, 0.033053766936063766, -0.06448724120855331, -0.03999930992722511, -0.03965125232934952, 0.04349542409181595, -0.0033059408888220787, -0.025137076154351234, 0.013327829539775848, -0.08195358514785767, -0.01397410687059164, 0.004597245249897242, 0.03362081199884415, 0.037767380475997925, 0.013143285177648067, 0.0017391794826835394, -0.032156575471162796, -0.054609332233667374, -0.0013521717628464103, 0.0035484391264617443, 0.005942525342106819, 0.011343535035848618, -0.0325130820274353, -0.05578742176294327, -0.0059096175245940685, 0.045206014066934586, -0.03992149233818054, -0.049800507724285126, 0.04871426150202751, -0.015007003210484982, -0.027508730068802834, -0.025804441422224045, -0.005700427573174238, 0.01939031109213829, 0.016437547281384468, -0.021403487771749496, -0.02722603641450405, -0.0012711039744317532, -0.06691490858793259, 0.0020804067607969046, 0.08787289261817932, -0.04892803356051445, -0.06254956126213074, 0.014552208594977856, 0.006615784484893084, -0.12264186888933182, 0.04356028139591217, 0.03944655507802963, 0.020220810547471046, -0.017425555735826492, -0.0008946430752985179, 0.06598764657974243, -0.00791118759661913, -0.028203291818499565, -0.035419315099716187, 0.020743845030665398, 0.01829293929040432, -0.029183415696024895, 0.066665880382061, -0.08005264401435852, 0.025394119322299957, 0.022571993991732597, 0.02976137585937977, 0.0599188506603241, -0.031055180355906487, -0.0007907210383564234, 0.0003280641103629023, 0.0036335308104753494, -0.03197665512561798, 0.049536801874637604, 0.04107637330889702, -0.060621146112680435, 0.013705152086913586, 0.011889352463185787, 0.046053484082221985, -0.003670359030365944, -0.03871535882353783, 0.08418717980384827, -0.019449234008789062, 0.006402708124369383, 0.010381543077528477, 0.023144593462347984, 0.05504673719406128, -0.0821896344423294, 0.015333124436438084, -0.012383755296468735, 0.02631293423473835, 0.07642094790935516, -0.0038366513326764107, -0.01265462301671505, -0.0010182337136939168, -0.011964326724410057, -0.00580848753452301, -0.006979259662330151, 0.03922523930668831, -0.000925267580896616, 0.064010851085186, 0.0038732655812054873, 0.019619649276137352, 0.0390017032623291, 0.0218725074082613, -0.032048989087343216, 0.04669402912259102, -0.005931795109063387, -0.06013260409235954, -0.005815460346639156, -0.04854016751050949, 0.0789419487118721, -0.001623068586923182, -0.043108727782964706, 0.0698375478386879, -0.05479193106293678, 0.016383815556764603, -0.03818031772971153, 0.03232668712735176, 0.018890999257564545, 0.001039041206240654, -0.029583262279629707, -0.007310012821108103, 0.0006864694296382368, -0.04553953558206558, 0.001478300429880619, 0.031575094908475876, 0.01511823758482933, 0.020393719896674156, 0.013747519813477993, -0.00455270754173398, -0.06351935118436813, -0.05122924968600273, -0.01878998428583145, 0.024666832759976387, 0.0033367446158081293, 0.08101819455623627, 0.029819784685969353, -0.025869378820061684, -0.08231883496046066, -0.027269791811704636, -0.02510245516896248, 0.028263119980692863, 0.014677179977297783, 0.036298610270023346, 0.07569349557161331, 0.044046252965927124, 0.014793549664318562, 0.037809088826179504, -0.004680600482970476, 0.02500775456428528, -0.07690362632274628, -0.09878905862569809, 0.0022865047212690115, -0.02081262320280075, -0.005463171750307083, -0.04892600327730179, -0.03759925439953804, -0.04974706470966339, -0.03359537571668625, -0.008288486860692501, 0.04696589335799217, 0.0003551214176695794, 0.03138837590813637, -0.05223379284143448, -0.05316692218184471, -0.039533644914627075, 0.076242595911026, 0.11128000915050507, -0.03044312819838524, 0.06983043253421783, 0.05950484052300453, 0.05909086763858795, 0.04285771772265434, -0.0072876205667853355, -0.07341698557138443, -0.025570476427674294, 0.010917983949184418, 0.0328170470893383, -0.03125332295894623, -0.027942154556512833, -0.06655265390872955, 0.044289443641901016, 0.03319714590907097, 0.0468045212328434, 0.010308549739420414, 0.011327485553920269, -0.10264424234628677, -0.021221810951828957, 0.03908352181315422, -0.03369520977139473, 0.054369933903217316, -0.040350984781980515, 0.07602350413799286, -0.05521060526371002, -0.010372454300522804, 0.03652191162109375, 0.0021259645000100136, -0.0237917248159647, -0.03171708807349205, -0.0941331759095192, 0.04025028273463249, -0.008074641227722168, 0.030349422246217728, 0.022863706573843956, 0.014519277028739452, -0.03355458006262779, -0.06778579950332642, -0.05143294483423233, -0.016998035833239555, 0.03728155419230461, -0.0920233428478241, 0.03656016290187836, -0.035850703716278076, -0.060036517679691315, 0.006373730953782797, 0.00679397489875555, 0.03413698449730873, 0.030790388584136963, 0.04900677874684334, -0.10297614336013794, -0.053981419652700424, 0.010296995751559734, 0.006922358646988869, 0.06988649070262909, -0.027887532487511635, -0.04041996970772743, 0.007622044533491135, -0.033921290189027786, 0.017632348462939262, 0.024703925475478172, -0.03820418193936348, -0.0049517652951180935, 0.03769712150096893, 0.05432293936610222, -0.003156316466629505, 0.02854679338634014, 0.01761065609753132, 0.02607492357492447, 0.02247701771557331, 0.08749991655349731, 0.07837314158678055, 0.0515173077583313, 0.008913672529160976, 0.04093378037214279, -0.012471500784158707, 0.035760052502155304, -0.007238639984279871, 0.012387576512992382, -0.03571002557873726, -0.004874201025813818, -0.02285338006913662, -0.018491705879569054, -0.04016507416963577, -0.02917860448360443, -0.0236617811024189, 0.07612533122301102, 0.006097954697906971, -0.0574675090610981, 0.0173778235912323, 0.023444443941116333, 0.06201692670583725, -0.012586783617734909, -0.01712903566658497, 0.06406094133853912, -0.03280483931303024, -0.01047413982450962, -0.0009847012115642428, -0.08910837024450302, -0.026715047657489777, 0.0011140673886984587, 0.006389109883457422, 0.023898381739854813, -0.07277963310480118, -0.007707610726356506, -0.05426836386322975, -0.010424557141959667, 0.012002241797745228, -0.06877755373716354, 0.0027233532164245844, 0.032185617834329605, -0.01427405048161745, 0.009285456500947475, -0.02662305347621441, 0.04660207778215408, 0.058576904237270355, 0.031093334779143333, 0.06561540812253952, 0.07401326298713684, 0.051737647503614426, 0.06748497486114502, 0.0037916311994194984, -0.008637688122689724, -0.003376081818714738, -0.06478061527013779, 0.04010540992021561, 0.00029534095665439963, 0.025576235726475716, 0.051058489829301834, -0.09493894875049591, 0.005786379333585501, -0.01915787160396576, 0.04445021227002144, -0.02802952378988266, -0.06459824740886688, 0.03192947804927826, 0.03800474479794502, -0.08466975390911102, 0.03579830005764961, 0.03784434497356415, 0.03305839002132416, -0.0796654224395752, 0.08463452756404877, -0.022520633414387703, 0.0296703539788723, -0.004877808503806591, 0.07304456830024719, -0.1629699319601059, -0.012660878710448742, -0.02940112166106701, -0.009011703543365002, 0.039944734424352646, 0.04110824316740036, -0.07187682390213013, -0.052104610949754715, -0.008819665759801865, 0.0008347295806743205, -0.006536121014505625, 0.07181524485349655, 0.1057397872209549, -0.031300824135541916, -0.013266084715723991, 0.047159042209386826, -0.019831111654639244, -0.03572342172265053, 0.04848947748541832, 0.012408297508955002, -0.012273265980184078, 0.036599431186914444, 0.001920728012919426, 0.005241200793534517, -0.042158618569374084, 0.013294760137796402, 0.007907071150839329, 0.01656387373805046, -0.04188508912920952, -0.08073568344116211, 0.022126497700810432, 0.07407375425100327, -0.0032900534570217133, 0.014486785046756268, -0.010280043818056583, -0.03150461986660957, 0.012310197576880455, 0.025013627484440804, 0.08347194641828537, -0.06606803834438324, 0.04866967350244522, -0.01839531771838665, 0.0395347997546196, -0.0808868408203125, 0.0223812535405159, 0.09436628222465515, -0.019672585651278496, 0.0029983199201524258, -0.028525158762931824, -0.06042337417602539, -0.0030615925788879395, -0.00436427490785718, -0.056210752576589584, -0.003791215131059289, 0.10995203256607056, 0.002001824788749218, -0.010805903933942318, -0.05073236674070358, -0.05312682315707207, 0.06850041449069977, 0.00884737353771925, 0.022774716839194298, 0.0790661871433258, -0.029235122725367546, -0.055880237370729446, 0.009649712592363358, -0.030436191707849503, -0.0024393871426582336, 0.01790093258023262, -0.05831826478242874, -0.04292501509189606, 0.04523848369717598, 0.0802820473909378, 0.05740109086036682, 0.0316571444272995, -0.0015847489703446627, 0.06838515400886536, 0.03414641693234444, -0.05407928675413132, -0.012884373776614666, -0.013725618831813335, 0.039040323346853256, 0.01655074954032898, -0.0015432380605489016, -0.013057905249297619, -0.027683837339282036, -0.009579941630363464, 0.09523563086986542, -0.04394981265068054, -0.00005399899237090722, 0.08952631056308746, -0.01951317861676216, 0.0568431094288826, 0.06782805919647217, -0.09854670614004135, 0.010418464429676533, -0.09625557065010071, -0.03318031132221222, -0.10273027420043945, -0.04995482414960861, 0.0573609434068203, -0.027732910588383675, 0.08018326014280319, -0.026414180174469948, -0.007467285729944706, -0.02968108467757702, -0.07773338258266449, -0.03233926743268967, 0.062432363629341125, 0.03247321397066116, -0.019028829410672188, 0.11777561902999878, -0.04249052330851555, -0.012374487705528736, 0.03631008043885231, -0.029215699061751366, 0.0363813079893589, -0.01444217562675476, -0.028881840407848358, -0.03678550198674202, 0.09038770198822021, -0.04648011177778244, -0.04970404878258705, -0.025937462225556374, 0.005667697172611952, -0.08961788564920425, -0.007481919135898352, -0.042596396058797836, -0.011531271040439606, 0.03762182593345642, 0.0033611077815294266, -0.01193814817816019, 0.030360614880919456, 0.0004221402923576534, 0.0604512058198452, -0.0640287920832634, -0.027361832559108734, -0.06128069385886192, 0.03453562781214714, -0.0615774430334568, -0.057649001479148865, -0.034997083246707916, -0.030947690829634666, -0.001764969201758504, -0.012525061145424843, 0.01631488837301731, 0.032526955008506775, 0.01899002492427826, -0.038272079080343246, 0.018059389665722847, 0.03614283353090286, 0.021311193704605103, 0.014129974879324436, 0.05782873556017876, 0.02624642476439476, 0.02436554804444313, 0.013448362238705158, 0.019789671525359154, -0.00664564548060298, -0.007890559732913971, 0.04832777753472328, 0.08545059710741043, 0.03699275478720665, -0.07022356986999512, 0.004178781993687153, 0.0771423801779747, 0.013601917773485184, 0.0009240303188562393, -0.02680995687842369, 0.021004844456911087, -0.027990857139229774, -0.0020545979496091604, 0.05495423078536987, 0.016918472945690155, 0.044298507273197174, 0.04355070739984512, 0.06547784060239792, 0.011663539335131645 ]
32
32
Optimal Causal Inference: Estimating Stored Information and Approximating Causal Architecture
We introduce an approach to inferring the causal architecture of stochastic dynamical systems that extends rate distortion theory to use causal shielding---a natural principle of learning. We study two distinct cases of causal inference: optimal causal filtering and optimal causal estimation. Filtering corresponds to the ideal case in which the probability distribution of measurement sequences is known, giving a principled method to approximate a system's causal structure at a desired level of representation. We show that, in the limit in which a model complexity constraint is relaxed, filtering finds the exact causal architecture of a stochastic dynamical system, known as the causal-state partition. From this, one can estimate the amount of historical information the process stores. More generally, causal filtering finds a graded model-complexity hierarchy of approximations to the causal architecture. Abrupt changes in the hierarchy, as a function of approximation, capture distinct scales of structural organization. For nonideal cases with finite data, we show how the correct number of underlying causal states can be found by optimal causal estimation. A previously derived model complexity control term allows us to correct for the effect of statistical fluctuations in probability estimates and thereby avoid over-fitting.
[ 0.02742060460150242, -0.0868435651063919, -0.025396160781383514, 0.0023510486353188753, 0.013639804907143116, 0.010427920147776604, -0.0011153470259159803, -0.03276007995009422, 0.029970234259963036, 0.020157771185040474, -0.04407718405127525, -0.029206130653619766, -0.09742635488510132, -0.051682014018297195, -0.006572558078914881, -0.08736532926559448, -0.10367030650377274, 0.03200768679380417, 0.09496524184942245, -0.02606687881052494, -0.023236559703946114, 0.0028625158593058586, -0.024936391040682793, 0.01526420097798109, 0.007454211357980967, -0.02365436777472496, -0.007833653129637241, 0.01752670295536518, 0.011652235873043537, 0.021823134273290634, -0.059658899903297424, 0.04263975843787193, 0.03053010068833828, -0.053961072117090225, 0.06721951812505722, -0.06090942397713661, 0.004696962423622608, -0.05051692947745323, -0.03599231317639351, 0.00641379039734602, 0.028243418782949448, 0.02337312139570713, -0.016084743663668633, -0.026348359882831573, 0.00652310810983181, -0.004117333330214024, 0.030978819355368614, -0.0037813426461070776, 0.013346761465072632, 0.019291961565613747, -0.11293494701385498, 0.014126095920801163, -0.01638186350464821, -0.007684702053666115, -0.0940423384308815, 0.06820203363895416, -0.05696450546383858, -0.0680709183216095, -0.024147698655724525, 0.010483763180673122, -0.007786328438669443, 0.07367170602083206, -0.032995887100696564, -0.014518219977617264, -0.05822126194834709, -0.010476253926753998, -0.08197740465402603, 0.011377108283340931, -0.05279690399765968, -0.028698893263936043, -0.002000706270337105, -0.008756873197853565, -0.00823426153510809, 0.03316287696361542, -0.0201957356184721, 0.018413476645946503, 0.04394681006669998, 0.10063652694225311, 0.013720604591071606, 0.09828183799982071, -0.11907331645488739, 0.06060364842414856, -0.009384766221046448, -0.02205602638423443, -0.048622094094753265, 0.01973307877779007, 0.033840011805295944, 0.014834897592663765, 0.03330288082361221, -0.005809575319290161, -0.016484173014760017, 0.02847255766391754, 0.0017410899745300412, -0.0006102373008616269, -0.12203332036733627, 0.014176895841956139, -0.014057650230824947, 0.014302127994596958, -0.043192848563194275, 0.012507179751992226, 0.0395338200032711, -0.0062172445468604565, 0.09206406772136688, 0.11107209324836731, 0.024035325273871422, -0.024026110768318176, 0.0419205017387867, 0.029009589925408363, 0.05788087472319603, -0.02083345130085945, -0.003050963394343853, -0.03152362257242203, -0.06786781549453735, -0.03133850544691086, -0.07670533657073975, 0.05093468725681305, 0.01775103062391281, 0.03593158721923828, -0.026630232110619545, -0.008827668614685535, -0.002469383180141449, 0.00004298120620660484, -0.049948327243328094, 0.008040827699005604, 0.014535683207213879, -0.06955104321241379, -0.030849196016788483, -0.031051725149154663, 0.11951211094856262, -0.009553024545311928, -0.00972666870802641, 0.002848688280209899, 0.016130492091178894, -0.06484533101320267, 0.014823822304606438, 0.055658258497714996, -0.013939271681010723, -0.032784756273031235, 0.03049324080348015, 0.030833691358566284, -0.03780317306518555, -0.03106590546667576, -0.035168640315532684, 0.0026121202390640974, -0.024685965850949287, 0.03160341829061508, 0.05184614285826683, 0.00985164288431406, 0.012139617465436459, -0.017191149294376373, 0.01770465075969696, 0.024983471259474754, 0.0067484634928405285, 0.10163231939077377, -0.03274087980389595, -0.08032596856355667, -0.06060050055384636, 0.02506115660071373, -0.03856484219431877, 0.014485616236925125, 0.0033417290542274714, 0.016329901292920113, 0.0367889367043972, 0.06564883142709732, -0.02105872519314289, 0.012591361999511719, 0.017772484570741653, 0.006477407179772854, -0.026007702574133873, -0.025372177362442017, -0.029692035168409348, -0.005034984089434147, 0.023962458595633507, 0.10482631623744965, 0.04428005963563919, -0.027223369106650352, 0.01843889243900776, 0.012316578067839146, 0.021274738013744354, -0.009249129332602024, 0.03125141188502312, 0.03056149184703827, -0.003410901175811887, -0.005221667233854532, 0.0444059893488884, 0.045508161187171936, -0.06055091321468353, 0.08711330592632294, 0.054210029542446136, 0.052267029881477356, -0.007466677576303482, 0.07962353527545929, -0.016480587422847748, -0.011154026724398136, -0.019002806395292282, -0.02931467816233635, 0.01840834692120552, -0.016533300280570984, 0.017754551023244858, 0.04925993084907532, 0.06917251646518707, 0.02842356264591217, -0.07717745751142502, -0.0050818766467273235, -0.08862055838108063, 0.02256680838763714, 0.02735205739736557, -0.08080633729696274, -0.0629962608218193, -0.01273281965404749, 0.00892370194196701, -0.004686653148382902, -0.01185538899153471, -0.004210233688354492, 0.0726955458521843, 0.0032955261413007975, -0.021849961951375008, -0.04888878017663956, 0.038326382637023926, 0.01227010041475296, 0.020152395591139793, 0.05678901821374893, -0.04277903214097023, 0.02868427336215973, -0.1051919087767601, -0.03780710697174072, 0.022576574236154556, 0.0061241816729307175, -0.043612040579319, 0.0523594431579113, -0.09299173206090927, -0.0665508359670639, -0.036176398396492004, 0.059003911912441254, 0.029308127239346504, 0.008928338065743446, 0.05099746957421303, -0.02823829837143421, -0.012325511313974857, -0.05356937274336815, -0.06793572008609772, 0.06138744205236435, -0.02399030514061451, 0.009066219441592693, -0.015896202996373177, -0.010540665127336979, 0.04320636764168739, 0.06881942600011826, -0.031896959990262985, -0.02964639477431774, 0.04300324618816376, 0.02250615879893303, -0.02599417231976986, -0.0109731275588274, -0.0013935848837718368, 0.009635357186198235, -0.10201951861381531, 0.07555003464221954, -0.008757403120398521, 0.060370732098817825, 0.06741407513618469, 0.013226625509560108, -0.08074752986431122, 0.061301346868276596, 0.05865446850657463, 0.036581095308065414, -0.007008824031800032, 0.06779326498508453, 0.0661666989326477, 0.01743663102388382, 0.015861395746469498, -0.03540350869297981, -0.0746953934431076, 0.11739785224199295, -0.02562999166548252, 0.028298264369368553, 0.020875317975878716, 0.00035090441815555096, 0.042000435292720795, -0.03750878944993019, 0.018649419769644737, 0.03661699965596199, -0.05821974575519562, -0.06583639979362488, -0.03488977625966072, 0.06573773920536041, -0.0066854157485067844, 0.04615643620491028, -0.024538377299904823, -0.007584617473185062, -0.09219551831483841, 0.009686879813671112, -0.05731711909174919, -0.010987617075443268, -0.015267902985215187, -0.028503358364105225, -0.00001646671626076568, 0.03003842756152153, 0.10911308974027634, -0.02154535986483097, -0.030561603605747223, 0.02436344511806965, 0.07402738928794861, 0.01185059454292059, 0.0605304017663002, 0.0031664129346609116, 0.026584094390273094, 0.04636969417333603, -0.01981521211564541, 0.06470399349927902, -0.013568637892603874, 0.024930479004979134, -0.03994787484407425, -0.04797878861427307, 0.07899431884288788, 0.0007552565657533705, -0.10808856040239334, -0.08224157243967056, -0.02495824359357357, -0.04267680644989014, -0.007631510961800814, 0.0378536581993103, -0.03417830169200897, 0.026086710393428802, -0.03460106998682022, 0.05276060849428177, 0.0683925449848175, 0.04239432141184807, -0.0009134270949289203, 0.025057122111320496, -0.007322145160287619, -0.0040024928748607635, -0.019031215459108353, 0.07123761624097824, -0.0027142430189996958, -0.03848551958799362, -0.009937440045177937, 0.028781360015273094, -0.018926402553915977, 0.04499827325344086, -0.01962185837328434, -0.09383074194192886, -0.013306534849107265, -0.00022553361486643553, 0.04543038457632065, 0.07037575542926788, 0.09088736027479172, 0.0031711009796708822, -0.0013797004939988256, -0.003402834525331855, -0.029933877289295197, -0.06735249608755112, -0.009028102271258831, -0.03995086997747421, -0.00689084455370903, 0.026652194559574127, 0.09049292653799057, 0.04067429527640343, 0.08565440028905869, -0.008049455471336842, 0.0010926604736596346, 0.015970850363373756, -0.006516914814710617, 0.029782110825181007, 0.007594373542815447, 0.002349567599594593, -0.0706821158528328, -0.00888802483677864, -0.04904791712760925, 0.0050946492701768875, 0.0675179660320282, 0.04321468994021416, -0.004871444310992956, 0.012480931356549263, 0.008236667141318321, -0.05102815106511116, 0.0147275784984231, -0.06773446500301361, -0.07256745547056198, 0.019343135878443718, -0.019267786294221878, -0.005659269168972969, 0.034579869359731674, -0.027107523754239082, -0.05108093470335007, -0.04520343989133835, -0.04758460819721222, 0.05714558809995651, 0.0019329894566908479, 0.04461928457021713, -0.029738200828433037, 0.006331379991024733, 0.062336262315511703, 0.03419763967394829, 0.06657125800848007, -0.05734098702669144, 0.002711797831580043, -0.0495837926864624, -0.051344774663448334, -0.007316955365240574, 0.03652026131749153, -0.06023211032152176, -0.002529480727389455, -0.08633076399564743, -0.07461580634117126, 0.07530234754085541, -0.014729807153344154, -0.026084238663315773, 0.10550501942634583, -0.006834822241216898, -0.02607368864119053, -0.049705784767866135, 0.05018731206655502, 0.04934375360608101, -0.02897864766418934, -0.014092258177697659, 0.021960778161883354, 0.006508666556328535, 0.030134031549096107, -0.06192650645971298, 0.061101283878088, -0.033006295561790466, 0.01979181356728077, -0.033352214843034744, -0.033454298973083496, 0.004270750097930431, -0.011641510762274265, 0.015478871762752533, -0.04760981351137161, 0.021448858082294464, -0.01610632985830307, -0.08004363626241684, -0.11029182374477386, 0.040790822356939316, 0.018537282943725586, -0.004987802822142839, -0.05691144987940788, -0.009898275136947632, 0.004586829338222742, 0.02428385801613331, -0.020357923582196236, 0.026571765542030334, -0.0025827200151979923, 0.06781185418367386, 0.018626689910888672, -0.029232501983642578, 0.013341166079044342, 0.01192806102335453, 0.031188128516077995, -0.03221151977777481, -0.023127365857362747, 0.041910748928785324, 0.031612247228622437, -0.018331043422222137, -0.022847002372145653, -0.005097746383398771, 0.018969694152474403, 0.008548607118427753, 0.08181222528219223, 0.003132820362225175, 0.03834771364927292, 0.00546968262642622, 0.031225189566612244, 0.000051310209528310224, -0.009676891379058361, -0.04546813666820526, 0.03168907016515732, 0.06326694786548615, 0.10700198262929916, -0.012681215070188046, -0.04932788759469986, 0.06329803913831711, -0.07057155668735504, 0.017910169437527657, 0.002033540513366461, 0.002325768116861582, 0.026226280257105827, -0.014243490993976593, -0.043565817177295685, 0.02864881232380867, 0.06054290011525154, 0.010326214134693146, -0.00429894682019949, -0.04587838053703308, 0.0796838030219078, 0.071852907538414, 0.01412517111748457, 0.0027574554551392794, 0.09051701426506042, 0.022360170260071754, 0.026012422516942024, -0.030052104964852333, -0.06111735850572586, -0.005089440383017063, 0.005722885951399803, 0.009949558414518833, 0.0021598779130727053, 0.016849996522068977, -0.013862555846571922, 0.010720155201852322, -0.008275897242128849, -0.004686279222369194, 0.038890574127435684, 0.042829692363739014, 0.1486099511384964, 0.012760447338223457, 0.01237487979233265, 0.003066824283450842, -0.005262238439172506, -0.007881742902100086, 0.007282590493559837, -0.03396185487508774 ]
33
33
On Semimeasures Predicting Martin-Loef Random Sequences
Solomonoff's central result on induction is that the posterior of a universal semimeasure M converges rapidly and with probability 1 to the true sequence generating posterior mu, if the latter is computable. Hence, M is eligible as a universal sequence predictor in case of unknown mu. Despite some nearby results and proofs in the literature, the stronger result of convergence for all (Martin-Loef) random sequences remained open. Such a convergence result would be particularly interesting and natural, since randomness can be defined in terms of M itself. We show that there are universal semimeasures M which do not converge for all random sequences, i.e. we give a partial negative answer to the open problem. We also provide a positive answer for some non-universal semimeasures. We define the incomputable measure D as a mixture over all computable measures and the enumerable semimeasure W as a mixture over all enumerable nearly-measures. We show that W converges to D and D to mu on all random sequences. The Hellinger distance measuring closeness of two distributions plays a central role.
[ -0.0880618467926979, -0.03984933719038963, -0.0014619845896959305, -0.07946589589118958, -0.023859115317463875, -0.01599944196641445, 0.026741741225123405, 0.03708777576684952, -0.009301098063588142, -0.013090654276311398, -0.0519135557115078, -0.04628477618098259, -0.0312546007335186, 0.03161754086613655, 0.036377016454935074, -0.03485611826181412, -0.06189051643013954, 0.03603389859199524, -0.058804456144571304, -0.05844815447926521, 0.0013278797268867493, 0.033590033650398254, 0.04718455299735069, 0.015358460135757923, 0.047308679670095444, 0.06024913862347603, -0.0700521394610405, 0.06147235259413719, -0.03626404330134392, -0.01848793216049671, -0.08062335848808289, -0.0003727881994564086, 0.028087245300412178, -0.03583720326423645, 0.009720914997160435, 0.01518497709184885, 0.05746445432305336, 0.000030400906325667165, -0.08611509203910828, -0.04658788815140724, -0.022961311042308807, -0.06941122561693192, 0.03760700300335884, -0.007494690362364054, 0.007878796197474003, 0.051869336515665054, 0.05128476396203041, -0.0215406846255064, -0.043638963252305984, 0.06779402494430542, 0.011034409515559673, 0.02400323376059532, 0.0023234356194734573, 0.0222296305000782, -0.017452480271458626, 0.05637677013874054, -0.008279001340270042, -0.010121726430952549, -0.051858723163604736, 0.021066512912511826, 0.014332584105432034, 0.11477714031934738, 0.002989287255331874, 0.0023434499744325876, -0.0363791361451149, -0.06845943629741669, -0.11961708217859268, 0.0008340601343661547, 0.07723492383956909, -0.017145352438092232, -0.07086136192083359, -0.08857019245624542, 0.01652209274470806, -0.016690032556653023, 0.0335533581674099, 0.02657351642847061, 0.016384346410632133, 0.06562252342700958, 0.02964945323765278, 0.09251943230628967, -0.09199666976928711, 0.01808909885585308, -0.014527748338878155, -0.033298708498477936, -0.0017900678794831038, -0.036164090037345886, 0.02218174934387207, 0.021032804623246193, -0.03822916001081467, -0.08078700304031372, -0.029265187680721283, 0.03348536789417267, -0.12768618762493134, 0.10779818892478943, -0.07852867245674133, 0.05938529968261719, 0.01888171024620533, 0.031142983585596085, 0.058399785310029984, -0.020433714613318443, 0.03009183518588543, -0.011329765431582928, 0.03464619070291519, -0.0017330502159893513, 0.008380153216421604, -0.00806755293160677, -0.0593717023730278, -0.033628687262535095, 0.000007144852588680806, 0.01908545382320881, -0.01755654811859131, 0.03036588430404663, 0.042830031365156174, -0.03002987802028656, -0.02252502739429474, 0.0812775120139122, 0.017715884372591972, -0.0015220299828797579, -0.009475317783653736, -0.024296507239341736, 0.022395135834813118, -0.00636310875415802, -0.004120908677577972, 0.05689194053411484, 0.021024448797106743, 0.043423909693956375, -0.04237450286746025, -0.004285270813852549, 0.14147470891475677, -0.0703091248869896, -0.026395872235298157, -0.045567989349365234, 0.004850984551012516, -0.030397234484553337, -0.05522890016436577, 0.011185646057128906, 0.006607012823224068, 0.04104360565543175, -0.002027523936703801, 0.04490891844034195, -0.036240071058273315, -0.06204899027943611, 0.03246220573782921, 0.003897305577993393, 0.03582102805376053, 0.10200125724077225, -0.09029470384120941, -0.006859155837446451, 0.0008576513500884175, -0.0011783626396209002, -0.042464014142751694, -0.030480612069368362, -0.013001457788050175, 0.045220885425806046, 0.006489449646323919, -0.11140670627355576, 0.009248103015124798, 0.03475778549909592, -0.030362624675035477, 0.059665095061063766, -0.0998881384730339, -0.00837880838662386, -0.0028589158318936825, 0.04379265382885933, -0.030929915606975555, 0.013024449348449707, -0.029539529234170914, -0.022306455299258232, 0.014290419407188892, 0.016952786594629288, -0.0029857545159757137, 0.027001651003956795, -0.027239026501774788, -0.006947566755115986, 0.025027168914675713, 0.003777130739763379, 0.020949656143784523, 0.0876961350440979, -0.006003046408295631, -0.06702441722154617, -0.006958835292607546, -0.08803033083677292, 0.0030382999684661627, 0.027111241593956947, -0.018259741365909576, 0.06263074278831482, -0.016278067603707314, 0.007754267659038305, 0.053850896656513214, 0.010076822713017464, 0.06408533453941345, -0.0037188087590038776, -0.03617925941944122, -0.09094930440187454, -0.06557563692331314, -0.0660097599029541, -0.07637295126914978, 0.0028592199087142944, 0.018905386328697205, 0.01498982310295105, 0.003112765261903405, 0.014326715841889381, -0.013258871622383595, -0.03477856516838074, -0.04430168494582176, -0.02616303041577339, 0.010824332945048809, -0.03443453833460808, 0.0310196690261364, -0.03324519470334053, -0.005971333011984825, 0.04180961847305298, -0.0077591161243617535, -0.056471459567546844, 0.06312458217144012, -0.10779362916946411, 0.0346607007086277, -0.040967702865600586, -0.03428393602371216, 0.0024889931082725525, 0.03063018247485161, 0.07206698507070541, -0.038306694477796555, 0.09017486870288849, 0.024184443056583405, -0.008831779472529888, 0.014871216379106045, 0.021483423188328743, -0.03281235694885254, 0.04491004720330238, -0.07520423829555511, -0.03916194662451744, -0.047153912484645844, -0.07279317826032639, -0.04621630534529686, -0.005041809286922216, -0.026223091408610344, -0.05583270266652107, 0.04771638661623001, 0.01980595476925373, -0.051363591104745865, 0.02624770626425743, 0.026147495955228806, 0.020774250850081444, -0.05139562115073204, -0.02641022391617298, -0.005736112594604492, -0.02065052092075348, 0.009785502217710018, 0.0633314847946167, 0.0035514505580067635, 0.010116464458405972, 0.021177401766180992, -0.04335864260792732, 0.07355101406574249, -0.01285987626761198, -0.04426470771431923, 0.02345358207821846, 0.0038788707461208105, -0.008791671134531498, -0.014143218286335468, 0.056027889251708984, -0.013877429999411106, 0.010638068430125713, 0.017255498096346855, -0.0133587047457695, -0.00305307493545115, -0.01958879642188549, -0.010125501081347466, -0.06305485218763351, 0.08015935122966766, -0.04840604215860367, -0.07835382223129272, 0.045351069420576096, -0.05544276162981987, -0.07899913936853409, 0.09646991640329361, 0.05348103493452072, 0.03126347437500954, -0.030728569254279137, -0.024547019973397255, -0.001791293965652585, -0.06851298362016678, -0.0516543872654438, -0.019600875675678253, -0.002222834387794137, 0.05405636876821518, -0.0714910477399826, -0.018764331936836243, 0.01624874584376812, 0.03975478187203407, 0.039504170417785645, -0.00726167531684041, -0.0723869577050209, 0.007230585440993309, 0.012376649305224419, -0.029934551566839218, -0.09176263213157654, 0.05303868651390076, -0.02072356455028057, -0.033359095454216, 0.02596447244286537, 0.04866725951433182, 0.04535586014389992, 0.01039878185838461, -0.008827500976622105, -0.0307677760720253, 0.006784460972994566, 0.006014413200318813, -0.01350486557930708, -0.007284412160515785, -0.024601934477686882, 0.010038729757070541, 0.060631539672613144, 0.07569310069084167, -0.12306555360555649, 0.007718125823885202, -0.02786427177488804, -0.00018471870862413198, 0.00010318137356080115, 0.03296574950218201, 0.008252772502601147, -0.024870960041880608, 0.0033433842472732067, -0.11085724085569382, -0.007947085425257683, 0.072895348072052, -0.04312467202544212, -0.1136685311794281, -0.0060852267779409885, 0.07155217975378036, 0.05866742879152298, 0.0032122773118317127, 0.06498976051807404, -0.01438985113054514, 0.018063032999634743, -0.02635766938328743, -0.008789614774286747, 0.023775702342391014, 0.0012681143125519156, -0.036055441945791245, -0.03142647445201874, -0.017863014712929726, -0.007807379122823477, 0.04380996152758598, 0.05145738646388054, 0.10556313395500183, -0.016651220619678497, 0.037328556180000305, 0.022691328078508377, -0.032015662640333176, -0.01988629624247551, 0.007620153017342091, 0.025134408846497536, -0.05221933498978615, 0.03648295998573303, 0.014443743973970413, 0.0897941067814827, 0.026187032461166382, 0.06942308694124222, 0.04855828732252121, -0.018336426466703415, -0.006614245939999819, -0.021776298061013222, 0.05181306228041649, 0.014221648685634136, -0.030370062217116356, -0.07296426594257355, -0.05120692029595375, 0.06387564539909363, -0.03238482028245926, 0.013194110244512558, 0.030790138989686966, 0.050022684037685394, 0.002032454824075103, -0.0030113612301647663, 0.1074894517660141, -0.022844627499580383, -0.015965327620506287, 0.03497931733727455, 0.01137420441955328, -0.04163990914821625, -0.01467259880155325, 0.07747776061296463, -0.011865871027112007, -0.0005892122280783951, 0.03233357146382332, 0.01303865760564804, 0.11781641095876694, -0.0015838253311812878, -0.07096964865922928, -0.0031001977622509003, 0.02631296217441559, 0.023415111005306244, 0.07042447477579117, 0.03233756124973297, -0.00829186663031578, -0.03575176000595093, -0.12148401886224747, -0.04664815962314606, 0.010057076811790466, -0.03646446391940117, 0.013497745618224144, -0.02986445277929306, -0.026970067992806435, -0.006929267663508654, -0.009667559526860714, 0.028395531699061394, -0.01872599497437477, 0.05574190616607666, 0.024554520845413208, -0.008243894204497337, -0.05710314214229584, 0.019387107342481613, -0.0019162321696057916, 0.05848563089966774, 0.007388666272163391, 0.03153662756085396, 0.01376879308372736, -0.05423706769943237, -0.049007073044776917, 0.05633596330881119, -0.07084440439939499, -0.05201994255185127, -0.026960665360093117, -0.042675331234931946, 0.012929642572999, 0.03801436722278595, 0.04301607236266136, -0.020989876240491867, -0.0563102550804615, 0.008557790890336037, -0.05393736809492111, -0.005347209516912699, 0.056716784834861755, -0.04440240189433098, -0.05188059061765671, -0.03637164086103439, -0.023269232362508774, 0.0446615032851696, -0.05222034826874733, 0.06585235893726349, -0.01558760553598404, 0.018833283334970474, -0.015328430570662022, -0.01079293992370367, 0.02925177663564682, 0.04558126628398895, 0.05413087457418442, -0.006114591378718615, 0.04048991575837135, -0.022024961188435555, -0.0017754341242834926, -0.00713043287396431, 0.005667544435709715, -0.0013772585662081838, -0.005401991307735443, -0.04257095977663994, 0.025993522256612778, -0.02067692019045353, -0.10428386926651001, -0.048800840973854065, 0.04328078404068947, 0.021998582407832146, -0.010565891861915588, 0.00811129529029131, 0.02374079078435898, 0.014626759104430676, 0.048568449914455414, 0.04075447842478752, 0.013090870343148708, -0.002038840902969241, -0.011221815831959248, 0.05987561121582985, 0.005732295569032431, 0.01572844199836254, -0.0001294541434617713, 0.008653052151203156, 0.06934889405965805, 0.0017975920345634222, 0.057935819029808044, 0.026564955711364746, -0.08614589273929596, -0.026260826736688614, 0.02638605237007141, 0.11562700569629669, -0.07403325289487839, -0.040020737797021866, 0.02961410954594612, 0.039527300745248795, 0.06668392568826675, 0.025499017909169197, -0.04241481050848961, 0.014422458596527576, 0.04106607288122177, 0.038679540157318115, -0.032700542360544205, 0.007026879116892815, -0.0050034429877996445, 0.007665515411645174, -0.002986186882480979, 0.021952170878648758, -0.00046989202382974327, -0.05860539525747299, 0.047444310039281845, -0.07485993951559067, 0.006080022547394037, -0.023333808407187462, -0.059538763016462326, 0.012315540574491024, 0.01218485739082098, 0.0005199961015023291 ]
34
34
Continuous and randomized defensive forecasting: unified view
Defensive forecasting is a method of transforming laws of probability (stated in game-theoretic terms as strategies for Sceptic) into forecasting algorithms. There are two known varieties of defensive forecasting: "continuous", in which Sceptic's moves are assumed to depend on the forecasts in a (semi)continuous manner and which produces deterministic forecasts, and "randomized", in which the dependence of Sceptic's moves on the forecasts is arbitrary and Forecaster's moves are allowed to be randomized. This note shows that the randomized variety can be obtained from the continuous variety by smearing Sceptic's moves to make them continuous.
[ -0.034150827676057816, -0.07232476025819778, 0.003166787326335907, -0.06287772953510284, 0.011283636093139648, -0.04452262446284294, -0.0317181795835495, 0.08096432685852051, -0.0012908265925943851, 0.020580535754561424, 0.026702919974923134, -0.040392257273197174, -0.08161263912916183, 0.02964453399181366, 0.02144182100892067, -0.03472718596458435, 0.006774518638849258, 0.06585662811994553, -0.031041309237480164, -0.023366451263427734, 0.018805496394634247, -0.032654955983161926, -0.02127280831336975, -0.016690004616975784, -0.015204482711851597, -0.01736634410917759, 0.03852635622024536, 0.0010158136719837785, 0.004485404118895531, 0.04720770940184593, -0.14130890369415283, 0.03951939195394516, -0.023256193846464157, 0.002549247583374381, 0.04847799614071846, -0.0038176877424120903, -0.02792304754257202, -0.02434661239385605, -0.04336170107126236, 0.028510143980383873, -0.001969387987628579, -0.016817264258861542, -0.013335173949599266, -0.008074784651398659, -0.023610707372426987, 0.03365272283554077, -0.01172456331551075, -0.04622303321957588, -0.06615912169218063, -0.005966446828097105, -0.07625962793827057, -0.018338892608880997, 0.004789397120475769, -0.0245046503841877, 0.0031994374003261328, 0.02133793756365776, -0.06812583655118942, 0.020883837714791298, 0.012409432791173458, -0.07698622345924377, -0.013873526826500893, 0.058723084628582, -0.07092545926570892, -0.07203147560358047, -0.03227267786860466, -0.02838698774576187, -0.09493377059698105, -0.005834855604916811, 0.026680640876293182, 0.009103501215577126, -0.02068238891661167, 0.011130140163004398, 0.01329111959785223, -0.020290497690439224, -0.08382365107536316, -0.0033174145501106977, -0.038946185261011124, 0.05890956521034241, -0.02262418158352375, 0.042374301701784134, -0.06216324493288994, 0.05867864564061165, 0.06320345401763916, 0.04818636551499367, 0.060260120779275894, -0.06005162000656128, 0.025339990854263306, 0.008736631833016872, -0.03468460589647293, -0.07224106788635254, 0.0020739182364195585, 0.04164552316069603, -0.0493704229593277, -0.010746152140200138, -0.03967810422182083, 0.11919376999139786, 0.008737010881304741, -0.0718512162566185, -0.008329398930072784, 0.02386157028377056, 0.024411983788013458, 0.03317050635814667, 0.10415299236774445, 0.07039359956979752, -0.08095543831586838, 0.0018587370868772268, 0.004281939938664436, 0.021313795819878578, 0.04400171339511871, 0.03040163964033127, -0.03613531216979027, -0.011083698831498623, 0.008132027462124825, 0.012118889018893242, -0.04545196145772934, 0.04701996594667435, -0.0051931533962488174, 0.09087244421243668, 0.05220470204949379, -0.040149882435798645, 0.09170002490282059, 0.06847726553678513, 0.05334728956222534, 0.014491651207208633, 0.027416903525590897, 0.0009363368735648692, -0.008294057101011276, -0.009102956391870975, 0.03346654027700424, -0.036952726542949677, -0.05470045655965805, 0.04240844026207924, -0.07972874492406845, 0.009762014262378216, -0.0017082092817872763, 0.002901358064264059, 0.02645530179142952, 0.0434870570898056, -0.038162726908922195, -0.01899235136806965, 0.013261422514915466, -0.0626552477478981, -0.021142708137631416, -0.026649074628949165, 0.02330373227596283, 0.05717102065682411, 0.05812361463904381, -0.041709356009960175, -0.029747288674116135, -0.002184992888942361, -0.032235804945230484, -0.01100862119346857, 0.018627546727657318, 0.023090830072760582, 0.024887749925255775, 0.01909433864057064, -0.030543344095349312, 0.009993997402489185, -0.1053592786192894, 0.044929761439561844, 0.017829881981015205, 0.006194690708070993, 0.028617050498723984, 0.05104305222630501, 0.028668701648712158, 0.04197002574801445, 0.041793014854192734, 0.045376986265182495, -0.07151667028665543, -0.08564040809869766, -0.026594553142786026, -0.014849561266601086, 0.014864141121506691, -0.04343974590301514, -0.033976960927248, -0.020981917157769203, 0.011747227981686592, 0.010321651585400105, 0.026120595633983612, -0.014637447893619537, 0.014893068931996822, -0.10131104290485382, -0.06522436439990997, 0.016640961170196533, 0.028277374804019928, 0.09876281023025513, -0.04364879056811333, 0.05915213003754616, 0.1442738026380539, 0.033365216106176376, -0.03981778025627136, 0.002997609321027994, -0.06903751194477081, -0.030248891562223434, -0.006799032911658287, -0.0389554463326931, -0.03218337893486023, 0.008625542744994164, 0.01291265245527029, 0.06882553547620773, 0.009091372601687908, 0.034885160624980927, -0.0452050119638443, -0.015375804156064987, -0.11044689267873764, 0.028265325352549553, 0.03731447458267212, -0.009449584409594536, 0.03615432605147362, -0.06406733393669128, 0.028513122349977493, -0.06259720772504807, -0.10205256193876266, -0.03896057978272438, 0.057965073734521866, -0.017794471234083176, -0.011583304964005947, -0.05374230071902275, 0.04347730427980423, -0.011806736700236797, -0.02546049654483795, 0.03937160596251488, -0.024323003366589546, -0.023829976096749306, -0.07918605208396912, -0.04271893575787544, 0.03173482418060303, 0.042474307119846344, -0.10745438188314438, 0.03637968376278877, -0.056374747306108475, -0.0322132408618927, 0.05329367518424988, 0.06932947784662247, -0.02866905927658081, 0.03178562968969345, 0.10622189939022064, -0.02517233043909073, 0.036851394921541214, 0.006534535437822342, -0.04103899747133255, 0.012239309027791023, 0.05261678993701935, 0.02739809639751911, 0.03778726980090141, -0.05304157733917236, 0.01788315363228321, 0.002759332302957773, -0.0011475319042801857, 0.007750306278467178, 0.02874894067645073, 0.002098475582897663, -0.008423104882240295, -0.06782329827547073, 0.039670489728450775, -0.02111661806702614, 0.014387357980012894, 0.0024561348836869, 0.06809957325458527, -0.00024381076218560338, -0.009971719235181808, 0.05038439854979515, -0.030533846467733383, 0.08944229036569595, 0.02541283890604973, 0.043133705854415894, -0.035224296152591705, -0.0245109461247921, -0.004325816873461008, -0.021470198407769203, -0.05039261654019356, 0.0007099714130163193, -0.048125408589839935, 0.027340136468410492, -0.044666871428489685, -0.05252915248274803, 0.06281822174787521, 0.003917537163943052, 0.04787897318601608, -0.08125820755958557, -0.008589443750679493, 0.047175969928503036, -0.02169644832611084, -0.02127990499138832, 0.022886348888278008, -0.04502971097826958, -0.0765576958656311, -0.029202308505773544, -0.027086835354566574, 0.041664157062768936, -0.07769909501075745, -0.032757777720689774, -0.08610374480485916, 0.0011422850657254457, 0.01517417747527361, -0.038406550884246826, -0.029260000213980675, 0.021597955375909805, 0.03882845863699913, 0.03045026771724224, -0.013067077845335007, 0.03391413763165474, 0.011007452383637428, 0.05631402134895325, 0.04887404665350914, 0.06023862957954407, 0.019831527024507523, 0.039226796478033066, 0.027869030833244324, 0.047530096024274826, -0.01220559049397707, -0.06981517374515533, 0.021138465031981468, -0.06228460371494293, -0.06693491339683533, -0.025022780522704124, -0.06197177246212959, -0.009512856602668762, -0.03153112158179283, 0.02369372546672821, -0.017438378185033798, -0.023260869085788727, -0.012318328022956848, 0.025802796706557274, -0.012085561640560627, -0.045591164380311966, 0.05549371987581253, 0.0729217678308487, -0.052635252475738525, 0.05705316364765167, -0.00928149651736021, 0.028225794434547424, 0.037367451936006546, 0.07030399143695831, -0.08535322546958923, -0.008853167295455933, 0.003726346418261528, -0.0048644887283444405, 0.054860103875398636, 0.035171136260032654, -0.016684385016560555, -0.03886868432164192, -0.03296123072504997, -0.023403560742735863, -0.004552538972347975, 0.035813044756650925, 0.12574872374534607, -0.046994250267744064, -0.0018538476433604956, -0.010937264189124107, -0.037930771708488464, -0.025323152542114258, 0.02003014273941517, 0.03104681335389614, -0.0598880760371685, 0.030895482748746872, -0.04601195827126503, 0.0014449446462094784, -0.00977796409279108, 0.008535097353160381, 0.03930991515517235, -0.03519726172089577, -0.08398521691560745, -0.05435315519571304, 0.02429402992129326, 0.08425721526145935, 0.00195467215962708, 0.0012846979079768062, -0.04980803653597832, -0.07921752333641052, 0.0202866829931736, 0.008556542918086052, 0.03903739154338837, 0.09230838716030121, 0.03857806697487831, -0.0157733466476202, 0.06457370519638062, -0.12281307578086853, -0.03199698403477669, 0.09421797841787338, 0.060403939336538315, 0.027259238064289093, -0.06727594137191772, -0.07086674124002457, -0.02222694829106331, 0.007741967681795359, -0.03402739763259888, -0.05433908849954605, 0.004905627109110355, -0.02415185235440731, -0.06091383844614029, 0.007128164172172546, 0.03171607106924057, -0.02893708273768425, 0.0452151894569397, -0.010282830335199833, 0.06855344772338867, -0.053978271782398224, -0.007658890914171934, -0.030920283868908882, -0.013950743712484837, -0.05025927722454071, 0.038023289293050766, -0.007983781397342682, -0.1050780639052391, -0.020952817052602768, 0.07090665400028229, 0.005822728853672743, 0.007203391287475824, 0.019379183650016785, 0.02900354564189911, 0.017886165529489517, -0.03617522865533829, 0.01757613569498062, -0.021251289173960686, 0.040041130036115646, 0.07107093930244446, -0.01567869260907173, -0.015276714228093624, 0.01572728529572487, -0.01697646640241146, 0.03581000491976738, -0.026632150635123253, -0.027192290872335434, 0.0673343762755394, -0.03196392580866814, 0.018328383564949036, 0.0068948399275541306, -0.09590480476617813, 0.031631387770175934, -0.10537037253379822, -0.060800470411777496, -0.07894815504550934, -0.048658762127161026, 0.04062993824481964, -0.02245762012898922, -0.002173871733248234, -0.11084775626659393, -0.033143702894449234, -0.031720686703920364, -0.03068445809185505, -0.03683050721883774, 0.014082866720855236, 0.06803189963102341, 0.005313918925821781, 0.031126894056797028, -0.02367204986512661, 0.030310694128274918, -0.026973996311426163, 0.02361942268908024, 0.017712412402033806, -0.0066028316505253315, 0.021384533494710922, -0.059186168015003204, 0.09749333560466766, -0.005732047371566296, -0.02085801213979721, 0.016370709985494614, 0.025747137144207954, -0.006639531813561916, -0.052537571638822556, -0.0557185634970665, -0.0024266100954264402, 0.047892335802316666, -0.03994803503155708, -0.04172150045633316, 0.004026153590530157, 0.012760450132191181, 0.036239106208086014, -0.003083126386627555, -0.0032381946220993996, -0.032607562839984894, 0.04317906126379967, -0.06758146733045578, -0.029304835945367813, 0.001297112787142396, -0.014569523744285107, 0.03484044596552849, -0.0019434901187196374, 0.023746395483613014, 0.061277687549591064, 0.011309911496937275, 0.009675833396613598, 0.007284360472112894, 0.009674888104200363, -0.016703065484762192, -0.009759089909493923, 0.03974231705069542, 0.02711714245378971, 0.020589757710695267, 0.040440984070301056, -0.020905062556266785, -0.020206348970532417, 0.02329358272254467, 0.05254509672522545, 0.01227874681353569, 0.03574962168931961, -0.032884202897548676, -0.03375452384352684, 0.0688997134566307, 0.04182791709899902, 0.024575570598244667, -0.028501156717538834, -0.01836423948407173, -0.03473005071282387, 0.018144525587558746, 0.08177350461483002, -0.008778980001807213, 0.07480441778898239, 0.02890431322157383, 0.055856358259916306, 0.010472197085618973 ]
35
35
A Dichotomy Theorem for General Minimum Cost Homomorphism Problem
In the constraint satisfaction problem ($CSP$), the aim is to find an assignment of values to a set of variables subject to specified constraints. In the minimum cost homomorphism problem ($MinHom$), one is additionally given weights $c_{va}$ for every variable $v$ and value $a$, and the aim is to find an assignment $f$ to the variables that minimizes $\sum_{v} c_{vf(v)}$. Let $MinHom(\Gamma)$ denote the $MinHom$ problem parameterized by the set of predicates allowed for constraints. $MinHom(\Gamma)$ is related to many well-studied combinatorial optimization problems, and concrete applications can be found in, for instance, defence logistics and machine learning. We show that $MinHom(\Gamma)$ can be studied by using algebraic methods similar to those used for CSPs. With the aid of algebraic techniques, we classify the computational complexity of $MinHom(\Gamma)$ for all choices of $\Gamma$. Our result settles a general dichotomy conjecture previously resolved only for certain classes of directed graphs, [Gutin, Hell, Rafiey, Yeo, European J. of Combinatorics, 2008].
[ 0.039124615490436554, -0.002178543247282505, 0.0022795747499912977, -0.005782740190625191, -0.05228841304779053, -0.08482860773801804, 0.03376612067222595, -0.031695686280727386, -0.06308183073997498, -0.016018830239772797, 0.047745753079652786, -0.014971580356359482, 0.005417545326054096, 0.04448332637548447, 0.005221825558692217, -0.022861963137984276, -0.03814036771655083, -0.018679067492485046, 0.018042994663119316, -0.0754871517419815, 0.040935683995485306, 0.024206863716244698, 0.0040854900144040585, -0.0031599742360413074, -0.059528615325689316, -0.013938848860561848, -0.07484644651412964, -0.01883121393620968, 0.012202144600450993, 0.005605820566415787, -0.07537031918764114, -0.0006939348531886935, -0.04416205361485481, 0.0016420349711552262, 0.05240510031580925, -0.07736590504646301, -0.0291269663721323, 0.008122245781123638, 0.013106029480695724, -0.04072604328393936, 0.028192052617669106, 0.05241190269589424, -0.0003641740186139941, -0.0580139085650444, 0.050385892391204834, -0.010924424976110458, 0.005683009512722492, 0.025763167068362236, -0.008190495893359184, -0.007575388997793198, -0.028910452499985695, 0.03884247690439224, -0.00414587277919054, 0.002624063054099679, 0.025809358805418015, 0.021806800737977028, -0.09039098769426346, 0.04115933179855347, 0.05531863123178482, 0.018018828704953194, 0.07957524061203003, 0.04827115684747696, -0.0256278607994318, 0.05630924180150032, -0.06500744819641113, 0.0030838288366794586, 0.037421368062496185, -0.03931497037410736, -0.03626353293657303, 0.058587707579135895, 0.02375631593167782, -0.011655563488602638, 0.026648346334695816, 0.010921296663582325, 0.05396968871355057, -0.02377682738006115, 0.011074521578848362, 0.014734162949025631, -0.029392020776867867, 0.06847962737083435, 0.02687736600637436, 0.09503916651010513, -0.01885019801557064, -0.02590003050863743, -0.03239450231194496, -0.016358688473701477, 0.043907925486564636, 0.009613622911274433, -0.02438163012266159, 0.021950596943497658, 0.0016064211959019303, 0.017377611249685287, -0.10352493077516556, 0.03359122946858406, -0.07125037908554077, 0.03094649314880371, 0.007088107522577047, 0.03017694503068924, 0.03737063705921173, -0.00649405037984252, 0.014477130025625229, -0.008355662226676941, 0.020175976678729057, 0.05842921510338783, -0.05573992803692818, 0.03127925470471382, -0.06952855736017227, 0.05002055689692497, -0.03436058387160301, -0.06290823221206665, -0.05869895964860916, 0.0719013661146164, 0.033773891627788544, -0.029463058337569237, -0.05405594781041145, 0.024860801175236702, -0.041705142706632614, 0.03532818332314491, -0.008490465581417084, -0.03165840730071068, -0.0440615639090538, 0.0004169615567661822, 0.007671061437577009, -0.04781068116426468, 0.030911821871995926, -0.014647241681814194, -0.02229122258722782, -0.030467186123132706, 0.05184418335556984, 0.07818088680505753, -0.04293135181069374, 0.033896997570991516, -0.010732353664934635, 0.012638481333851814, -0.08356248587369919, 0.0773661732673645, 0.019761718809604645, -0.01032545231282711, -0.06435045599937439, 0.05415327474474907, 0.061003465205430984, 0.010222661308944225, 0.019733108580112457, -0.002562138484790921, 0.06575823575258255, 0.05171217769384384, 0.005939937196671963, 0.049003440886735916, 0.02981315739452839, 0.01639542728662491, 0.026826689019799232, -0.014716648496687412, 0.0012772965710610151, -0.0034860887099057436, 0.02640916220843792, -0.008097583428025246, 0.026601411402225494, -0.06430122256278992, -0.0290352925658226, 0.07103637605905533, 0.01671653613448143, -0.068467877805233, 0.04309415817260742, 0.022404154762625694, -0.018429700285196304, 0.018044263124465942, 0.07829808443784714, -0.027376526966691017, -0.04522693157196045, 0.01844591274857521, -0.017468230798840523, -0.02326006442308426, 0.0551612451672554, 0.0838804543018341, 0.01703757233917713, 0.018659500405192375, -0.0037380391731858253, 0.061137422919273376, -0.012086648494005203, -0.024282487109303474, 0.012886753305792809, -0.0023028722498565912, 0.005140893626958132, -0.00003531712354742922, 0.016906047239899635, 0.0581410676240921, 0.07289095222949982, -0.008832862600684166, 0.016186630353331566, -0.04882325977087021, -0.03583241254091263, 0.04835173487663269, 0.020089639350771904, 0.06664841622114182, 0.014746718108654022, -0.08280567824840546, -0.013494938611984253, 0.04598519578576088, 0.002567424438893795, 0.010591592639684677, 0.04006556421518326, -0.03290584683418274, -0.023333141580224037, 0.014546106569468975, -0.01985476352274418, -0.010839232243597507, -0.00025339555577374995, -0.024939537048339844, -0.08731663972139359, -0.062281399965286255, 0.011871101334691048, -0.009334813803434372, 0.019573088735342026, -0.006465258542448282, -0.024260515347123146, 0.02011255919933319, -0.013720963150262833, -0.08663962781429291, 0.018206369131803513, 0.009622763842344284, -0.02265228144824505, 0.06918622553348541, 0.09164711833000183, -0.07580402493476868, -0.06377262622117996, -0.04210532456636429, -0.008672982454299927, -0.006772027350962162, -0.033257316797971725, 0.024421995505690575, -0.06648816913366318, -0.01439259946346283, -0.0030681760981678963, 0.035556234419345856, 0.020462511107325554, 0.04484512656927109, -0.06971398741006851, -0.011996252462267876, -0.08060383796691895, 0.0568830743432045, -0.016279997304081917, 0.04423689842224121, -0.04023303836584091, -0.05207129940390587, 0.030637158080935478, 0.018242890015244484, 0.05617103353142738, -0.05382306128740311, -0.05117232725024223, 0.007088910788297653, -0.07996028661727905, 0.03662184253334999, 0.020766684785485268, -0.031544193625450134, 0.005503903143107891, -0.05325913801789284, -0.037342414259910583, 0.06826884299516678, 0.09610362350940704, 0.04016811028122902, -0.04781264066696167, 0.044222645461559296, -0.05386980623006821, -0.033711496740579605, -0.032255541533231735, 0.041856005787849426, 0.014334326609969139, 0.012784491293132305, 0.01379262376576662, -0.028549212962388992, -0.008850734680891037, -0.04802168160676956, -0.0704374834895134, 0.10375318676233292, -0.01870940439403057, 0.01971447467803955, 0.020335035398602486, 0.054898541420698166, -0.042512446641922, 0.056094199419021606, -0.059852827340364456, -0.016091113910079002, 0.1110522598028183, -0.042842380702495575, 0.004361053463071585, 0.03235382214188576, 0.017987176775932312, 0.02532881870865822, 0.005027058068662882, 0.03173923119902611, -0.09333780407905579, 0.02060636132955551, -0.0347212553024292, 0.03251577913761139, 0.026946809142827988, 0.007590290158987045, 0.028007889166474342, 0.09625673294067383, 0.03203875198960304, -0.07384660094976425, -0.013029223307967186, -0.011654273606836796, 0.007696108426898718, 0.005610671825706959, 0.027293235063552856, 0.03758470341563225, 0.10680224746465683, -0.06519271433353424, -0.055534638464450836, -0.012197977863252163, -0.02785515785217285, 0.005821979604661465, 0.0019520813366398215, -0.06927339732646942, 0.01344284787774086, -0.02538328804075718, 0.0032305195927619934, -0.014365045353770256, -0.09086000174283981, -0.029826929792761803, -0.07907675206661224, 0.015255441889166832, 0.01954961009323597, 0.055192627012729645, -0.07225274294614792, -0.007504425477236509, 0.01825537532567978, -0.025829171761870384, -0.034088846296072006, 0.051480188965797424, -0.08295249193906784, -0.03599710017442703, -0.02519787847995758, 0.028235193341970444, -0.05906061455607414, 0.06280024349689484, -0.01692006178200245, -0.05276104807853699, -0.07386758178472519, -0.04280773550271988, -0.09574811160564423, -0.14508990943431854, -0.07527269423007965, -0.034207455813884735, 0.06413644552230835, 0.07494965940713882, 0.09142071008682251, 0.0022598649375140667, -0.047407299280166626, 0.005130771081894636, -0.07293067127466202, -0.03640943393111229, -0.02608969248831272, 0.07575951516628265, -0.00729250255972147, -0.04311854764819145, 0.029566891491413116, -0.012880510650575161, -0.010508046485483646, -0.006236230954527855, 0.0316426157951355, -0.07333410531282425, 0.003586703212931752, 0.016234228387475014, 0.018062615767121315, -0.004723092541098595, -0.019964732229709625, -0.010423975996673107, -0.11235517263412476, 0.005062468349933624, -0.0033459675032645464, 0.010071245953440666, -0.01842477172613144, 0.026891594752669334, 0.027746113017201424, -0.024536121636629105, 0.09184780716896057, -0.07148198038339615, -0.014221002347767353, 0.044915568083524704, -0.04630426689982414, 0.06924499571323395, -0.06370282173156738, 0.03852442279458046, -0.0017492451006546617, -0.07682299613952637, 0.00418177992105484, 0.02018597535789013, 0.10975746810436249, 0.017585640773177147, -0.014908342622220516, -0.012967780232429504, 0.019032223150134087, -0.04597809910774231, 0.03732636198401451, 0.006284586153924465, 0.02908785454928875, -0.003869342152029276, -0.01872403360903263, 0.029475385323166847, 0.09008552879095078, -0.02814938686788082, 0.01256571151316166, -0.09728310257196426, -0.057123664766550064, 0.0028925396036356688, 0.0630922019481659, 0.032820165157318115, -0.04910188168287277, 0.03488275781273842, 0.08347880840301514, 0.07612358033657074, -0.12760251760482788, 0.06053424999117851, 0.022701412439346313, -0.003963296301662922, 0.03328010067343712, 0.024612367153167725, -0.07009429484605789, 0.05102230980992317, 0.02583361230790615, -0.033036503940820694, -0.03994829207658768, -0.025626882910728455, 0.04003581404685974, -0.07762227952480316, 0.018448052927851677, 0.006218654103577137, 0.026603523641824722, -0.007581750862300396, -0.03970741108059883, -0.02876858599483967, -0.07940135151147842, 0.06122586503624916, -0.002707206178456545, 0.018497299402952194, 0.026180550456047058, 0.014190380461513996, 0.01632486656308174, -0.03882579505443573, -0.005654985085129738, 0.1066812127828598, -0.023259302601218224, -0.005194368306547403, 0.003739366540685296, -0.02766290120780468, 0.012470731511712074, 0.015617347322404385, 0.05416081100702286, -0.01937616989016533, -0.12049518525600433, 0.004946692381054163, 0.0237034410238266, -0.028468092903494835, -0.03659501299262047, 0.008241234347224236, 0.03470870479941368, -0.030199753120541573, 0.016012582927942276, -0.004522813018411398, 0.005289564374834299, -0.041107770055532455, -0.024600505828857422, 0.04296951740980148, -0.04687047377228737, -0.0341666005551815, 0.008307169191539288, 0.030738184228539467, 0.026005864143371582, 0.04910547286272049, -0.07714226096868515, 0.04833263158798218, -0.03805249184370041, 0.016751617193222046, 0.004407177679240704, 0.0584816075861454, -0.01245349831879139, -0.04756307601928711, 0.051366355270147324, -0.008982106111943722, 0.0204280037432909, 0.0042140306904911995, -0.0871618315577507, -0.050889335572719574, 0.07289816439151764, 0.043390903621912, -0.03155635669827461, 0.05408034473657608, 0.0513860248029232, -0.007697290740907192, -0.0356643944978714, -0.027739306911826134, -0.0038703728932887316, -0.017907554283738136, 0.0019281329587101936, -0.015597719699144363, 0.0013516085455194116, -0.0277608260512352, 0.05215037986636162, 0.00922770332545042, 0.02460544742643833, 0.003084735479205847, -0.007927846163511276, 0.10905477404594421, 0.03842604532837868, 0.01493585854768753, 0.09019549936056137, -0.015562735497951508, -0.0012727660359814763, 0.06506060063838959, -0.02120359241962433, 0.009880879893898964 ]
36
36
Filtering Additive Measurement Noise with Maximum Entropy in the Mean
The purpose of this note is to show how the method of maximum entropy in the mean (MEM) may be used to improve parametric estimation when the measurements are corrupted by large level of noise. The method is developed in the context on a concrete example: that of estimation of the parameter in an exponential distribution. We compare the performance of our method with the bayesian and maximum likelihood approaches.
[ -0.014401936903595924, -0.034466102719306946, -0.061158403754234314, -0.03181526064872742, 0.01636921986937523, -0.03003619983792305, 0.03452060744166374, 0.000512989703565836, -0.04163621738553047, -0.041206978261470795, 0.0049188402481377125, -0.04016637057065964, 0.002479146933183074, 0.010146530345082283, -0.005479474551975727, -0.026745488867163658, 0.02537940815091133, -0.02816998027265072, 0.010736766271293163, -0.048387132585048676, -0.0004986097919754684, 0.04967968538403511, 0.02081967703998089, -0.05416402965784073, -0.041492246091365814, 0.02257568947970867, 0.016595374792814255, -0.02296701818704605, -0.015749553218483925, -0.025886379182338715, -0.03760046884417534, 0.04135808348655701, 0.01859704963862896, -0.002789338817819953, 0.07443879544734955, 0.01055876910686493, 0.0793190449476242, -0.008326287381350994, -0.0131559818983078, -0.0004533995524980128, 0.04378136992454529, 0.01346997357904911, 0.03746383637189865, -0.0060339430347085, 0.05045697093009949, 0.024025920778512955, 0.04028177633881569, 0.009477727115154266, -0.005669439677149057, 0.06490837782621384, -0.06120718643069267, 0.011963768862187862, 0.0038729971274733543, -0.03442723676562309, 0.01204650942236185, 0.03952084481716156, 0.017970051616430283, 0.028097091242671013, -0.10753625631332397, -0.022629249840974808, 0.00684579461812973, 0.08780866116285324, -0.007867473177611828, 0.01354853343218565, 0.00492316298186779, 0.020717699080705643, -0.13281141221523285, 0.0344335213303566, -0.0366668663918972, -0.028407607227563858, -0.013149883598089218, -0.044877976179122925, -0.04130852594971657, -0.01953333616256714, -0.02910175547003746, -0.06746171414852142, -0.02213166281580925, -0.018926125019788742, 0.060863979160785675, 0.06312935799360275, -0.06345946341753006, -0.006162179168313742, -0.021859286352992058, 0.1057620719075203, -0.017215827479958534, 0.01533451583236456, -0.06523774564266205, -0.010496425442397594, -0.038058891892433167, -0.04699182137846947, -0.05818449333310127, 0.022283703088760376, -0.07025761157274246, 0.05904146283864975, -0.035344094038009644, 0.09840337932109833, 0.01784292235970497, 0.008915136568248272, -0.01965956948697567, -0.020170284435153008, 0.0653744488954544, -0.048277322202920914, 0.044077299535274506, 0.06328890472650528, -0.03052300028502941, -0.04158506914973259, -0.026267526671290398, 0.046135470271110535, 0.027788816019892693, -0.08534646034240723, 0.03128682076931, -0.11137933284044266, 0.0331265851855278, -0.03345035761594772, -0.06513699889183044, 0.027986722066998482, -0.012271411716938019, -0.011798445135354996, 0.024371221661567688, 0.05908651277422905, 0.11009078472852707, -0.02990657649934292, -0.011844041757285595, 0.009760911576449871, 0.06190251559019089, 0.020992305129766464, 0.024392016232013702, -0.046648070216178894, 0.13083530962467194, -0.06532812118530273, -0.030834833160042763, -0.0038154320791363716, 0.04087444767355919, -0.02614775486290455, -0.01603068970143795, 0.02814558334648609, 0.04798681288957596, -0.014542641118168831, -0.0072446768172085285, 0.037620581686496735, -0.03876150771975517, 0.02481931820511818, 0.042844172567129135, 0.04784861207008362, 0.0262994933873415, 0.060322731733322144, 0.03482901304960251, 0.02524750865995884, -0.07651351392269135, -0.02242797613143921, -0.05968701094388962, -0.012963501736521721, 0.00351458671502769, 0.03744565695524216, 0.0362137146294117, -0.08021661639213562, -0.032470185309648514, 0.0005913965869694948, -0.01031482219696045, 0.08950311690568924, -0.1098247617483139, 0.05975199490785599, 0.11393234133720398, -0.00986866932362318, -0.025151582434773445, -0.006651983130723238, -0.04226363077759743, -0.01337304525077343, -0.02265019714832306, -0.07398538291454315, -0.01754407398402691, 0.04458455368876457, -0.019198276102542877, -0.018944215029478073, -0.049263279885053635, -0.0027897371910512447, 0.03503565490245819, -0.029195498675107956, 0.029434269294142723, -0.015383047051727772, -0.0017896563513204455, 0.01003317441791296, -0.03527028486132622, 0.0030085472390055656, 0.08228695392608643, -0.011932073161005974, -0.07419579476118088, 0.02153937891125679, 0.01722349412739277, 0.001156604615971446, 0.10170711576938629, -0.0743805542588234, 0.06143771857023239, -0.0626368522644043, -0.013589221052825451, -0.0046649957075715065, -0.06175462156534195, 0.00650112796574831, 0.0013486741809174418, 0.009416111744940281, 0.0316091813147068, -0.0445675365626812, -0.05699050426483154, -0.0537324994802475, -0.022095099091529846, 0.023769790306687355, 0.0019153041066601872, -0.023323306813836098, 0.05875440686941147, -0.025172127410769463, -0.0559118278324604, 0.018466537818312645, 0.003632600186392665, -0.13104431331157684, 0.03438860550522804, -0.07345987111330032, 0.023609722033143044, 0.027275126427412033, -0.06444835662841797, 0.010518723167479038, -0.04474491626024246, 0.029800865799188614, -0.021674826741218567, 0.08997456729412079, -0.03936683014035225, -0.015303365886211395, -0.015912191942334175, 0.03920846804976463, -0.03874234855175018, 0.04191398620605469, 0.01120840199291706, -0.02467002347111702, -0.0584556870162487, -0.0884273573756218, -0.07103021442890167, -0.00019185351266060024, -0.025213981047272682, -0.037381675094366074, 0.03706085681915283, 0.020293332636356354, 0.0258150827139616, 0.08105776458978653, 0.07010771334171295, 0.0417243167757988, -0.053974635899066925, -0.08241445571184158, 0.012765721417963505, 0.08110197633504868, -0.029723728075623512, 0.07339134067296982, 0.059703029692173004, 0.03147271275520325, -0.03496512025594711, 0.015527119860053062, 0.000993624678812921, 0.0005799519130960107, -0.02079043909907341, 0.04737726226449013, -0.002701785182580352, 0.046679697930812836, -0.01421345118433237, -0.011283384636044502, -0.007067965809255838, 0.031996943056583405, 0.06607078015804291, -0.04077408090233803, -0.020144369453191757, 0.029797470197081566, 0.07083726674318314, 0.00961303897202015, 0.043420687317848206, 0.015948722139000893, -0.03708142414689064, 0.08238115161657333, -0.012136873789131641, 0.04000728204846382, 0.0704810619354248, 0.06996100395917892, 0.06162676215171814, -0.05131634324789047, -0.07693034410476685, 0.05275917053222656, 0.004116477444767952, 0.06308750063180923, -0.012968633323907852, 0.060718100517988205, 0.006373937241733074, 0.024675246328115463, -0.061758995056152344, -0.012783696874976158, -0.004390799440443516, 0.07248704880475998, -0.08117041736841202, -0.06114162504673004, 0.029009833931922913, 0.003477276535704732, 0.045832693576812744, -0.05392448976635933, 0.014881684444844723, -0.00715000182390213, 0.00117869779933244, -0.01531725749373436, 0.07975572347640991, 0.014787555672228336, 0.0007552638999186456, 0.05897844582796097, 0.1171957403421402, 0.0409214086830616, -0.015020864084362984, -0.02963176555931568, 0.060193583369255066, -0.06065983325242996, -0.030554309487342834, 0.025831235572695732, -0.010798312723636627, -0.05270911008119583, -0.05871857330203056, -0.023119349032640457, -0.011352485977113247, -0.021813826635479927, -0.04447488486766815, 0.0377725251019001, 0.04423625022172928, -0.048339441418647766, -0.004684051964432001, -0.02325541153550148, 0.005440200213342905, -0.017655232921242714, -0.027762513607740402, 0.007651137188076973, -0.028873588889837265, -0.0010434992145746946, -0.06570149958133698, 0.11178984493017197, 0.01491014938801527, 0.04775018244981766, -0.032386429607868195, -0.010264669544994831, 0.0044785235077142715, -0.021297741681337357, -0.07369013875722885, 0.003042079508304596, -0.03758508339524269, 0.05356171354651451, 0.05932459980249405, 0.0372510701417923, 0.05700433626770973, 0.037297170609235764, -0.03819350153207779, -0.018501123413443565, -0.007788360584527254, -0.018081555142998695, 0.052485089749097824, -0.05491488054394722, -0.018946832045912743, 0.07225050777196884, 0.014191743917763233, 0.03626067936420441, -0.007983691059052944, 0.054480209946632385, -0.01223744172602892, 0.004474336747080088, -0.05028991773724556, 0.007945496588945389, 0.034342870116233826, 0.06803445518016815, -0.0064828828908503056, -0.01547086052596569, -0.05977420136332512, 0.03478328138589859, -0.05124815180897713, 0.04924619197845459, 0.0507713258266449, -0.0006490755476988852, 0.020780371502041817, -0.009141528978943825, 0.04292622208595276, -0.010260112583637238, -0.03535237908363342, 0.03965270146727562, -0.03245463967323303, -0.017878418788313866, -0.056187503039836884, -0.006727978587150574, -0.0020874764304608107, -0.01473886426538229, -0.028413796797394753, 0.0016683428548276424, 0.07280603796243668, -0.02312954142689705, -0.03987788408994675, 0.005855240859091282, -0.025630736723542213, 0.04150253161787987, 0.0969519093632698, 0.05688456818461418, 0.052171364426612854, 0.0014138275291770697, 0.009143928997218609, -0.031544432044029236, 0.006424720399081707, 0.04840720072388649, -0.06079098954796791, -0.09592356532812119, -0.0006892346427775919, -0.06516379863023758, -0.05260851979255676, -0.02751496061682701, -0.010173150338232517, 0.032363083213567734, 0.004971672780811787, -0.06278767436742783, -0.06871449947357178, 0.0075696129351854324, 0.015311474911868572, 0.020800087600946426, 0.0026133216451853514, -0.04228317737579346, -0.005998107139021158, -0.0735468789935112, -0.02502068318426609, 0.07601767778396606, 0.018382534384727478, -0.02104968950152397, -0.0471307672560215, 0.05436452850699425, 0.002668702509254217, 0.03874717280268669, -0.04214579239487648, 0.007582332007586956, -0.10031063109636307, 0.015087622217833996, 0.012525892816483974, -0.04054543375968933, -0.024531669914722443, -0.05757935345172882, 0.08386292308568954, 0.0040740203112363815, -0.09273878484964371, 0.0030901338905096054, -0.0637051910161972, 0.013673999346792698, -0.0029163009021431208, -0.009979180991649628, -0.03139195963740349, -0.010122093372046947, 0.0898771584033966, -0.003950949292629957, 0.0539594367146492, 0.01422992441803217, -0.017271002754569054, 0.05616629868745804, -0.06401144713163376, -0.02674347348511219, 0.03480022773146629, 0.0010390852112323046, -0.015564425848424435, 0.010161103680729866, 0.046675194054841995, -0.046681176871061325, 0.037443362176418304, -0.022670568898320198, -0.022008955478668213, 0.02218555472791195, -0.05783291161060333, -0.02979220822453499, -0.0011131236096844077, 0.05003190040588379, 0.045821499079465866, 0.028492065146565437, -0.06038316339254379, 0.003271020483225584, -0.026872960850596428, 0.03980523347854614, -0.00891845766454935, 0.02636827528476715, 0.012317395769059658, -0.02947916090488434, 0.027799246832728386, 0.007717962842434645, -0.037371207028627396, 0.01462109386920929, 0.0023087095469236374, 0.06633380800485611, 0.04909014701843262, 0.05793864652514458, -0.046411801129579544, 0.03747567534446716, 0.02996300347149372, 0.06379693001508713, 0.006759741809219122, 0.06728452444076538, -0.005708370357751846, 0.006154900882393122, -0.06232417747378349, 0.07832865417003632, -0.06765296310186386, 0.030995899811387062, 0.03626132383942604, 0.013798480853438377, 0.04090328514575958, -0.0528378039598465, 0.0952412486076355, -0.025107428431510925, 0.0285925455391407, 0.047251418232917786, -0.017854321748018265, 0.03733598440885544, -0.04770995303988457, 0.0348438024520874, -0.028516458347439766, -0.04593421518802643 ]
37
37
On Universal Prediction and Bayesian Confirmation
The Bayesian framework is a well-studied and successful framework for inductive reasoning, which includes hypothesis testing and confirmation, parameter estimation, sequence prediction, classification, and regression. But standard statistical guidelines for choosing the model class and prior are not always available or fail, in particular in complex situations. Solomonoff completed the Bayesian framework by providing a rigorous, unique, formal, and universal choice for the model class and the prior. We discuss in breadth how and in which sense universal (non-i.i.d.) sequence prediction solves various (philosophical) problems of traditional Bayesian sequence prediction. We show that Solomonoff's model possesses many desirable properties: Strong total and weak instantaneous bounds, and in contrast to most classical continuous prior densities has no zero p(oste)rior problem, i.e. can confirm universal hypotheses, is reparametrization and regrouping invariant, and avoids the old-evidence and updating problem. It even performs well (actually better) in non-computable environments.
[ -0.0025481591001152992, -0.0659177154302597, -0.023927031084895134, -0.017207514494657516, 0.021250184625387192, 0.016952160745859146, 0.04455083608627319, 0.020229026675224304, 0.026540229097008705, 0.005005162209272385, -0.03008410707116127, -0.049179770052433014, -0.04260599613189697, 0.007557273842394352, -0.03572705388069153, -0.009437241591513157, -0.01221227552741766, 0.016813891008496284, -0.030035261064767838, -0.07343143969774246, 0.023949453607201576, 0.000908685673493892, 0.019682027399539948, 0.0029931836761534214, 0.0141840148717165, 0.029844585806131363, -0.02972501330077648, -0.0035213492810726166, 0.05909059941768646, 0.020873304456472397, -0.07973861694335938, 0.033544525504112244, -0.050194405019283295, -0.011970585212111473, 0.08732355386018753, -0.009611711837351322, -0.058328788727521896, -0.049616776406764984, -0.062488436698913574, -0.10129152983427048, 0.0322665311396122, -0.09755381941795349, 0.009418962523341179, 0.06980330497026443, 0.044322047382593155, 0.04067635163664818, 0.06493806838989258, 0.03418859466910362, -0.02557249926030636, -0.008487989194691181, -0.012365982867777348, 0.04045826569199562, -0.060049254447221756, -0.04036452993750572, -0.008803640492260456, 0.045710064470767975, 0.007149098441004753, -0.05754559859633446, 0.013362678699195385, 0.01365168858319521, 0.009798268787562847, 0.03767900541424751, 0.04749223589897156, -0.015441074967384338, -0.05184704065322876, -0.026868989691138268, -0.0848342701792717, -0.007055043242871761, 0.024686604738235474, -0.06519520282745361, -0.04353998601436615, -0.05745987594127655, -0.05071984604001045, -0.015636416152119637, 0.07821185141801834, -0.009084178134799004, -0.033533740788698196, 0.035164788365364075, -0.003461359068751335, 0.0490119606256485, -0.06079047918319702, 0.02878604084253311, 0.01493776310235262, 0.034780897200107574, -0.029238073155283928, -0.025998324155807495, 0.013869446702301502, 0.006881644483655691, -0.025106389075517654, -0.0643802359700203, -0.04595322906970978, 0.035504382103681564, -0.06606041640043259, 0.03023395501077175, -0.058482278138399124, 0.01617215760052204, 0.014230716042220592, 0.07327952235937119, -0.01750071346759796, -0.03714488446712494, -0.01659558340907097, 0.02714378945529461, 0.0601145438849926, 0.060062557458877563, -0.06186005473136902, -0.00822367426007986, -0.04500112310051918, 0.027028460055589676, -0.03482552617788315, -0.022649487480521202, 0.040790170431137085, 0.003950588405132294, 0.017683325335383415, -0.0035101869143545628, -0.04107261076569557, 0.04081219434738159, -0.02645092085003853, 0.033721886575222015, 0.04827733337879181, -0.013015175238251686, 0.02912195213139057, 0.06513400375843048, -0.033004939556121826, 0.02477973699569702, 0.04151473194360733, -0.02302713133394718, 0.0152901541441679, -0.048201799392700195, 0.13027137517929077, -0.08520516008138657, -0.0681590735912323, -0.00747264176607132, -0.009363196790218353, -0.016277041286230087, -0.003952473402023315, 0.012738286517560482, 0.03830260783433914, 0.039749305695295334, -0.03864540904760361, 0.0093619329854846, -0.009023865684866905, -0.08352365344762802, -0.019651420414447784, 0.007181610446423292, -0.04155280441045761, 0.061861857771873474, -0.0031862526666373014, -0.022427648305892944, 0.012932967394590378, 0.006456540431827307, -0.06460630893707275, -0.0636826604604721, -0.0150792570784688, 0.04507296532392502, 0.010574492625892162, -0.023714138194918633, -0.00973333977162838, -0.027743307873606682, -0.00298563321121037, 0.08980191498994827, -0.02397407777607441, -0.005354525987058878, 0.03641081228852272, 0.08306889981031418, 0.022051846608519554, -0.00875120423734188, -0.005137067288160324, 0.0598943792283535, -0.06158536672592163, -0.025275005027651787, -0.028476588428020477, -0.0347214974462986, 0.015070227906107903, 0.032917510718107224, 0.06296762079000473, -0.06355070322751999, 0.004883039742708206, 0.02412876859307289, -0.04338541999459267, -0.05239307880401611, 0.018618144094944, -0.020487122237682343, -0.033289458602666855, 0.04346663877367973, 0.003294330323114991, 0.09436756372451782, -0.030130423605442047, 0.018154537305235863, 0.10473407804965973, 0.03753647208213806, 0.022782322019338608, 0.07806626707315445, -0.020899437367916107, -0.034667715430259705, -0.05647146701812744, -0.03283942863345146, -0.07677048444747925, -0.008985304273664951, -0.04633038491010666, 0.032542139291763306, 0.03184472769498825, 0.012371895834803581, -0.02534726820886135, -0.030987029895186424, -0.06173774227499962, 0.05227726325392723, 0.0214888546615839, -0.056531429290771484, 0.03038422204554081, -0.04942477121949196, -0.0023823261726647615, 0.03401609882712364, -0.01773647964000702, -0.03867881000041962, 0.0898425504565239, -0.15167605876922607, 0.0057561397552490234, -0.0922127366065979, 0.02662341110408306, -0.0066840616054832935, -0.005234126001596451, 0.07202281802892685, -0.022718600928783417, 0.05169764906167984, -0.02461535856127739, -0.011046760715544224, -0.033317070454359055, -0.07781919836997986, -0.07323102653026581, 0.07573685795068741, -0.040423180907964706, -0.08384917676448822, -0.06683197617530823, -0.03653774783015251, 0.05130649730563164, 0.0516606904566288, -0.040064167231321335, -0.015447105281054974, 0.04324483126401901, -0.004262149799615145, -0.03715858981013298, 0.018722709268331528, 0.00641679996624589, -0.03933997452259064, 0.02459421195089817, -0.06840093433856964, 0.03297549858689308, -0.027010653167963028, -0.030377740040421486, 0.06337642669677734, 0.00037510175025090575, -0.023240024223923683, -0.12106024473905563, 0.0648765116930008, 0.044712863862514496, 0.016711300238966942, -0.11922536790370941, 0.059852007776498795, 0.044917140156030655, 0.00861308816820383, 0.007856053300201893, 0.03157602250576019, -0.06018703058362007, 0.004452311899513006, 0.010154069401323795, -0.014879756607115269, -0.003684660419821739, 0.0353512316942215, -0.02745009772479534, -0.04808920621871948, 0.06780755519866943, 0.002111084759235382, -0.0937613993883133, 0.06258503347635269, -0.07183832675218582, -0.06409572809934616, 0.02376892976462841, 0.022819815203547478, 0.04307444766163826, -0.01683153212070465, -0.007719588931649923, 0.056277599185705185, -0.007732827216386795, -0.03888937458395958, -0.027657095342874527, 0.03098664991557598, 0.010819386690855026, -0.014720814302563667, 0.010776108130812645, -0.04521375894546509, -0.06017935648560524, 0.026901917532086372, -0.00004822230766876601, -0.01860174909234047, 0.04908161237835884, -0.021021218970417976, 0.05614268407225609, -0.020505711436271667, -0.008328608237206936, 0.0031412525568157434, -0.07332851737737656, 0.05531739071011543, 0.08278926461935043, 0.03143467754125595, 0.021095795556902885, 0.061199843883514404, -0.02207951806485653, 0.003080749185755849, -0.009137414395809174, 0.02445225790143013, 0.0019321980653330684, -0.02543673850595951, -0.025329262018203735, 0.09570392966270447, 0.03673338517546654, -0.024016225710511208, -0.0001039452399709262, -0.030430223792791367, -0.02153307944536209, 0.051399778574705124, 0.04196231812238693, -0.017234236001968384, -0.0010826485231518745, 0.015120694413781166, -0.08208047598600388, -0.006465289741754532, 0.0341399647295475, 0.025889387354254723, -0.0574953518807888, 0.03934242203831673, -0.02262077108025551, -0.023698709905147552, -0.011425367556512356, 0.06855890154838562, -0.06612617522478104, 0.008277160115540028, -0.03784617781639099, 0.06823951750993729, 0.030583424493670464, 0.0501825213432312, -0.026581179350614548, -0.05659691244363785, -0.029356900602579117, 0.05339927226305008, -0.0057429163716733456, 0.011318101547658443, 0.06674877554178238, -0.028475163504481316, 0.003432981437072158, 0.04296416789293289, -0.09525271505117416, -0.0016921476926654577, -0.03602483496069908, 0.09500164538621902, -0.08469843119382858, 0.032433975487947464, 0.06393738836050034, -0.025306951254606247, 0.012138275429606438, 0.04776318743824959, 0.05088433995842934, 0.0038269429933279753, 0.006135026924312115, -0.038230519741773605, -0.016875101253390312, 0.024053918197751045, -0.035574253648519516, 0.05583685636520386, -0.001334978616796434, 0.025279343128204346, 0.032380878925323486, -0.04506560415029526, 0.014778701588511467, 0.025225846096873283, 0.07790722697973251, -0.01749442145228386, 0.034069109708070755, -0.036392174661159515, -0.07321593910455704, 0.015668202191591263, -0.0018800582038238645, 0.030340347439050674, -0.08868597447872162, -0.052397072315216064, 0.024369679391384125, -0.07581508159637451, -0.0008965505403466523, -0.004446579609066248, 0.11512638628482819, -0.00445110397413373, -0.003283980768173933, -0.0027162842452526093, 0.010657903738319874, 0.08375439047813416, 0.012059856206178665, 0.0018163126660510898, 0.033148761838674545, -0.03319397568702698, -0.07190632075071335, -0.06264770030975342, 0.016299398615956306, -0.0195347610861063, 0.05061016231775284, -0.04605305194854736, -0.0340709313750267, 0.026631610468029976, -0.005619076080620289, 0.05690964311361313, -0.004988125991076231, 0.04101931303739548, 0.05308741331100464, 0.09757865220308304, 0.04055985063314438, -0.025200553238391876, -0.023711679503321648, 0.049932751804590225, 0.08798370510339737, -0.010777226649224758, -0.007567114196717739, -0.05979212000966072, 0.0005603130557574332, -0.013567104004323483, -0.0919908881187439, -0.019417639821767807, -0.025523444637656212, -0.03590371832251549, 0.02470606379210949, 0.05250198021531105, 0.012691577896475792, 0.0027754802722483873, -0.053853511810302734, -0.08850633352994919, -0.039811212569475174, -0.004940166603773832, 0.007378838956356049, -0.031079763546586037, 0.0005240258760750294, 0.024895373731851578, -0.03280223160982132, -0.000661768950521946, -0.08155116438865662, 0.05337366834282875, 0.05088157579302788, -0.006204015109688044, -0.0037945632357150316, -0.0019291018834337592, 0.009838148951530457, 0.001187497633509338, 0.0413234569132328, -0.038651369512081146, -0.02846524678170681, 0.002863485598936677, 0.0027425563894212246, -0.05697169527411461, -0.022874725982546806, 0.022711629047989845, -0.00043181097134947777, -0.08271294832229614, 0.03973064199090004, -0.08998559415340424, -0.03554714098572731, -0.02678149938583374, 0.025387264788150787, 0.03385980799794197, -0.07110364735126495, -0.013031922280788422, 0.05592754855751991, 0.009009462781250477, 0.06180596724152565, -0.028582416474819183, -0.1068500205874443, 0.014577124267816544, 0.0066476366482675076, 0.030093565583229065, -0.0029832760337740183, 0.024030089378356934, 0.013929866254329681, -0.0068009113892912865, 0.020305156707763672, -0.08883758634328842, 0.06183420866727829, 0.056787312030792236, -0.06186121702194214, -0.005392533261328936, 0.054529208689928055, 0.13575570285320282, -0.09076447784900665, -0.044674333184957504, 0.019122669473290443, 0.04948581010103226, 0.019931720569729805, 0.02000662498176098, -0.0021781360264867544, 0.029941344633698463, 0.03922688215970993, 0.03785262629389763, -0.021269069984555244, -0.010742240585386753, 0.0035367750097066164, 0.021394032984972, -0.006874667946249247, 0.026030419394373894, 0.009470213204622269, 0.015261461958289146, 0.05690693110227585, -0.04205242171883583, 0.04165118932723999, 0.019027911126613617, 0.0010324012255296111, -0.01998762972652912, -0.03603344038128853, 0.01846088282763958 ]
38
38
Learning for Dynamic Bidding in Cognitive Radio Resources
In this paper, we model the various wireless users in a cognitive radio network as a collection of selfish, autonomous agents that strategically interact in order to acquire the dynamically available spectrum opportunities. Our main focus is on developing solutions for wireless users to successfully compete with each other for the limited and time-varying spectrum opportunities, given the experienced dynamics in the wireless network. We categorize these dynamics into two types: one is the disturbance due to the environment (e.g. wireless channel conditions, source traffic characteristics, etc.) and the other is the impact caused by competing users. To analyze the interactions among users given the environment disturbance, we propose a general stochastic framework for modeling how the competition among users for spectrum opportunities evolves over time. At each stage of the dynamic resource allocation, a central spectrum moderator auctions the available resources and the users strategically bid for the required resources. The joint bid actions affect the resource allocation and hence, the rewards and future strategies of all users. Based on the observed resource allocation and corresponding rewards from previous allocations, we propose a best response learning algorithm that can be deployed by wireless users to improve their bidding policy at each stage. The simulation results show that by deploying the proposed best response learning algorithm, the wireless users can significantly improve their own performance in terms of both the packet loss rate and the incurred cost for the used resources.
[ -0.017141852527856827, -0.03160450980067253, -0.013729098252952099, 0.004529294092208147, 0.048300400376319885, -0.09600719809532166, -0.014398126862943172, 0.012073715217411518, -0.0767722949385643, -0.018045540899038315, -0.004585017450153828, -0.04015092924237251, -0.009406167082488537, -0.033804766833782196, 0.06215690076351166, -0.05774596706032753, -0.0007803954067640007, -0.00012399557454045862, 0.014271542429924011, -0.019006000831723213, -0.024315886199474335, 0.007279847748577595, -0.02059473842382431, 0.016312548890709877, -0.03162068501114845, -0.025210021063685417, -0.0796055942773819, -0.004326576832681894, 0.05235779285430908, 0.011793400160968304, -0.12305689603090286, -0.00184586551040411, -0.034835126250982285, 0.026014981791377068, 0.03843937814235687, -0.04307495802640915, 0.0587274469435215, -0.09527616202831268, -0.03207032009959221, 0.005242325831204653, -0.019831355661153793, -0.028712769970297813, -0.08387630432844162, -0.0030843443237245083, 0.050775595009326935, 0.022918272763490677, 0.028836766257882118, -0.038229286670684814, 0.04742184281349182, -0.01079398114234209, -0.07536531984806061, -0.05875669792294502, -0.005906447768211365, 0.021011142060160637, 0.00577748566865921, 0.05080703645944595, -0.03893586993217468, -0.0275798961520195, -0.02961304597556591, -0.07385370135307312, -0.008614331483840942, 0.09090465307235718, -0.08772207796573639, -0.01181535143405199, -0.04306937754154205, -0.010812874883413315, -0.08794313669204712, -0.018449964001774788, -0.05202965438365936, 0.10783831030130386, 0.009112625382840633, 0.03494942933320999, 0.01776028610765934, 0.005484574008733034, 0.0354042686522007, 0.003516414202749729, -0.044432736933231354, 0.023117946460843086, 0.018505800515413284, 0.035168033093214035, -0.10534273833036423, 0.008000736124813557, -0.03789261355996132, 0.045497093349695206, -0.023496797308325768, 0.01374968234449625, -0.01734369806945324, 0.015009663999080658, -0.04887405410408974, -0.004475732333958149, -0.02577258087694645, 0.01130229514092207, -0.05871416628360748, 0.00671013817191124, 0.012110771611332893, 0.045165084302425385, -0.013507937081158161, 0.0700136125087738, 0.020540770143270493, 0.07896959036588669, -0.007067542988806963, -0.001824762555770576, 0.027874814346432686, 0.0208198893815279, 0.0014138220576569438, 0.05714571475982666, 0.013201993890106678, 0.024087633937597275, 0.001953519880771637, 0.0029232935048639774, 0.03401127830147743, -0.025580275803804398, -0.039345115423202515, 0.0077539668418467045, -0.03614825755357742, 0.03133517876267433, 0.004594095982611179, 0.012879032641649246, -0.004244228824973106, 0.07069289684295654, 0.04170083999633789, -0.008826002478599548, -0.061299484223127365, -0.03533772751688957, 0.03198907524347305, 0.019609704613685608, 0.02941768430173397, -0.027574006468057632, 0.025358086451888084, 0.016179637983441353, -0.05610321834683418, -0.016998475417494774, 0.0017264890484511852, -0.034819670021533966, 0.00006256433698581532, 0.05209816247224808, 0.014462025836110115, -0.007089346181601286, -0.011281789280474186, -0.037216708064079285, 0.06224551424384117, 0.03412869572639465, -0.057304512709379196, 0.03993773087859154, 0.0463416688144207, -0.05071910470724106, 0.08794181048870087, 0.023193858563899994, -0.02870577946305275, -0.003209412796422839, -0.07447750866413116, -0.017773935571312904, -0.0056969053111970425, 0.0728328600525856, -0.027720674872398376, -0.06161008030176163, -0.03721614181995392, -0.04597243294119835, -0.04721245914697647, 0.0454011894762516, 0.013936109840869904, 0.03320256620645523, 0.01039598323404789, 0.033218301832675934, -0.017817359417676926, 0.05557264760136604, -0.09867015480995178, 0.05118541419506073, -0.03935154899954796, 0.0004060473875142634, -0.0342024527490139, -0.007574369199573994, -0.022950554266572, 0.03598450869321823, -0.04700448736548424, -0.07981837540864944, -0.009035605937242508, -0.03938407823443413, -0.03803413733839989, 0.011708335019648075, -0.003924025222659111, -0.08173517137765884, -0.00429143849760294, 0.0040184869430959225, 0.013377889059484005, 0.0347592867910862, 0.059236884117126465, 0.1363556832075119, 0.10930802673101425, 0.03565983474254608, -0.06865736842155457, 0.007096810266375542, -0.018436601385474205, -0.014711479656398296, -0.02326153963804245, -0.005085564684122801, -0.021615156903862953, 0.050337016582489014, 0.041086964309215546, 0.005494498182088137, 0.03813648223876953, -0.01650884561240673, -0.13106802105903625, 0.06042931228876114, -0.011438587680459023, -0.035441771149635315, 0.03956597298383713, -0.06395144760608673, 0.020382262766361237, 0.01880127750337124, 0.005040672142058611, -0.004669531714171171, 0.05169970542192459, 0.01150303054600954, 0.06344910711050034, 0.033609308302402496, -0.017109977081418037, 0.0005972962826490402, -0.014890110120177269, -0.02726176753640175, -0.041499461978673935, 0.08041668683290482, 0.050435870885849, 0.009976301342248917, -0.05229814350605011, -0.0003088869561906904, 0.0689099058508873, -0.018338847905397415, -0.10255648195743561, 0.032445527613162994, 0.0480538085103035, -0.054263606667518616, 0.022227952256798744, 0.02001657709479332, -0.030334874987602234, 0.06098438426852226, -0.0035662706941366196, -0.06639427691698074, -0.02458219975233078, -0.06984920799732208, 0.020394885912537575, -0.016124993562698364, 0.05299282819032669, 0.0029657334089279175, 0.1361318677663803, 0.035653360188007355, 0.00039857462979853153, 0.014546751976013184, -0.13073955476284027, -0.028780711814761162, 0.04296588897705078, -0.05423387512564659, -0.035231757909059525, 0.047586191445589066, 0.035237111151218414, 0.012014096602797508, 0.05493084341287613, -0.01019197702407837, 0.023088745772838593, 0.01707129180431366, -0.035267457365989685, -0.022762436419725418, -0.08414091914892197, 0.03510122001171112, 0.03448563814163208, -0.0031621758826076984, 0.006592257879674435, 0.08040819317102432, -0.02129370905458927, 0.017530759796500206, -0.012803598307073116, -0.03795915096998215, 0.001908535254187882, 0.03931291028857231, 0.022858215495944023, -0.0031602284871041775, -0.0020938562229275703, 0.023486794903874397, 0.005510594695806503, -0.04255189001560211, 0.02059120312333107, 0.032070014625787735, 0.04040015861392021, 0.007448479067534208, -0.0031122416257858276, 0.013204787857830524, -0.06909482181072235, 0.047212887555360794, 0.06302912533283234, 0.01560494676232338, -0.018252475187182426, 0.0006800643168389797, -0.03334366902709007, 0.00879746489226818, 0.022184398025274277, -0.06299513578414917, -0.05892978608608246, 0.03099585883319378, -0.0306068267673254, -0.03902817517518997, 0.020443953573703766, 0.018575359135866165, 0.002520025474950671, 0.0728970393538475, -0.021167566999793053, 0.09145047515630722, -0.004035130608826876, 0.041218921542167664, -0.06044100597500801, 0.013163016177713871, -0.024999547749757767, 0.08493443578481674, -0.11800116300582886, -0.07457948476076126, 0.059541698545217514, 0.04568018019199371, 0.007565584033727646, 0.013075512833893299, -0.044503144919872284, 0.0434681698679924, 0.03941977396607399, -0.07388068735599518, 0.02419111877679825, 0.010169906541705132, -0.05423653498291969, 0.02269362471997738, -0.009647402912378311, 0.025661738589406013, -0.057247113436460495, 0.0835975855588913, -0.11064224690198898, 0.009575987234711647, 0.002806355245411396, 0.0930808037519455, -0.05623803660273552, 0.04989190399646759, -0.10915400832891464, 0.050774991512298584, -0.015228258445858955, 0.08330712467432022, -0.026164911687374115, -0.057545144110918045, -0.08406972140073776, -0.014324285089969635, 0.03894413635134697, 0.10071549564599991, 0.0915331244468689, 0.003433830803260207, -0.04539233818650246, 0.014952758327126503, 0.0013549416325986385, -0.011660288088023663, -0.03034394048154354, -0.048078928142786026, -0.036835674196481705, -0.058632586151361465, 0.03412782773375511, 0.025505565106868744, 0.03780677542090416, 0.01107819378376007, -0.018732808530330658, -0.06818298995494843, -0.07866661250591278, -0.05158311128616333, 0.011030236259102821, 0.038923922926187515, -0.03991501033306122, -0.015104382298886776, -0.07119003683328629, -0.04979705065488815, 0.03983379527926445, -0.013856588862836361, -0.008147979155182838, 0.0453752763569355, 0.038008540868759155, -0.02570471353828907, 0.051433365792036057, -0.09274976700544357, -0.026537492871284485, 0.060102835297584534, -0.007327057886868715, 0.00036284717498347163, 0.06193068251013756, -0.057007502764463425, 0.043636251240968704, -0.005447132047265768, -0.030602162703871727, -0.00712213758379221, 0.030199268832802773, -0.00493778008967638, -0.04560287296772003, -0.00008254506246885285, -0.008189254440367222, -0.005745064001530409, 0.046095386147499084, 0.01670357584953308, 0.00710630277171731, -0.009820950217545033, -0.017812134698033333, 0.034929707646369934, 0.03193042427301407, -0.025738470256328583, -0.019541237503290176, -0.050323039293289185, -0.05957011133432388, -0.016994094476103783, 0.06487898528575897, 0.023907212540507317, 0.014195747673511505, 0.038308147341012955, 0.02380782552063465, 0.03886345401406288, 0.013094156980514526, -0.0123582249507308, -0.07329639047384262, -0.008002018555998802, -0.004858086351305246, 0.002095740521326661, -0.01467953808605671, -0.12689489126205444, 0.028872115537524223, 0.05025649070739746, 0.010544884018599987, -0.03397635743021965, -0.03488563746213913, 0.0416310615837574, 0.02622567117214203, 0.011614376679062843, -0.050191719084978104, 0.02666412480175495, -0.031919896602630615, -0.10015293955802917, -0.04668261855840683, -0.026722267270088196, -0.04449110105633736, 0.003662636037915945, 0.05154825374484062, -0.024355661123991013, 0.003985614515841007, 0.014086520299315453, 0.03646126762032509, -0.06289144605398178, 0.014863060787320137, 0.029882187023758888, 0.05354265868663788, 0.026163270696997643, 0.05414346233010292, -0.00906700175255537, 0.061107974499464035, -0.04813845455646515, -0.033607449382543564, 0.01777602732181549, 0.08305958658456802, -0.052404697984457016, -0.03488406166434288, 0.025892022997140884, 0.06262635439634323, -0.015741214156150818, 0.021154111251235008, -0.0216058436781168, -0.04234939068555832, -0.033482301980257034, 0.0067229182459414005, 0.03452886641025543, -0.00015854364028200507, -0.015625573694705963, 0.003803787985816598, -0.047993194311857224, 0.060044605284929276, -0.050456881523132324, 0.003091188846156001, 0.045983314514160156, 0.007818453945219517, -0.05227542668581009, -0.0025337543338537216, 0.060796868056058884, 0.05123508349061012, -0.013104884885251522, 0.016588609665632248, -0.011154954321682453, 0.04595639184117317, 0.02775316685438156, -0.02134818769991398, 0.03578777238726616, 0.03872760385274887, -0.050466060638427734, 0.0294246356934309, 0.04352517053484917, 0.08631739020347595, 0.048190679401159286, -0.037531305104494095, -0.06165298819541931, -0.024275219067931175, -0.02868434600532055, 0.019396226853132248, 0.038402218371629715, 0.07336888462305069, 0.00435467716306448, 0.02985093928873539, 0.027592020109295845, 0.019249752163887024, -0.00434755627065897, 0.054991498589515686, 0.04704777151346207, 0.019824661314487457, -0.028871268033981323, 0.10119166225194931, 0.044752173125743866, 0.04883622005581856, -0.03627950698137283, -0.06710267066955566, 0.012471374124288559 ]
39
39
Mutual information for the selection of relevant variables in spectrometric nonlinear modelling
Data from spectrophotometers form vectors of a large number of exploitable variables. Building quantitative models using these variables most often requires using a smaller set of variables than the initial one. Indeed, a too large number of input variables to a model results in a too large number of parameters, leading to overfitting and poor generalization abilities. In this paper, we suggest the use of the mutual information measure to select variables from the initial set. The mutual information measures the information content in input variables with respect to the model output, without making any assumption on the model that will be used; it is thus suitable for nonlinear modelling. In addition, it leads to the selection of variables among the initial set, and not to linear or nonlinear combinations of them. Without decreasing the model performances compared to other variable projection methods, it allows therefore a greater interpretability of the results.
[ 0.03982657194137573, -0.013103739358484745, -0.005500444211065769, -0.004895548801869154, 0.034211620688438416, 0.0062944162636995316, 0.02014206536114216, 0.01734541356563568, -0.0552864670753479, -0.0035071067977696657, 0.041076142340898514, -0.012353291735053062, -0.0336148664355278, -0.03546265885233879, -0.07005622982978821, -0.04654637724161148, 0.04374817758798599, -0.019518520683050156, 0.09361444413661957, -0.03304518759250641, -0.03385056555271149, 0.052432332187891006, -0.013056566007435322, -0.028407251462340355, 0.0070062121376395226, 0.04017991945147514, -0.05262892320752144, -0.08085478842258453, 0.010578508488833904, 0.04725109413266182, -0.0885642021894455, 0.019797632470726967, 0.02037465013563633, -0.005168788600713015, 0.02818608470261097, -0.07978273928165436, 0.03979723900556564, 0.007767198607325554, -0.012158908881247044, -0.044979795813560486, -0.013752407394349575, -0.07886878401041031, 0.013691182248294353, -0.05467347055673599, 0.039560701698064804, 0.014967293478548527, 0.03763621672987938, 0.0355982668697834, -0.00776239950209856, 0.059267330914735794, -0.07249366492033005, 0.009526749141514301, 0.006274506449699402, -0.015349458903074265, 0.03608376160264015, 0.006376081146299839, 0.05074962228536606, 0.00669232988730073, 0.03807399421930313, -0.0037306915037333965, 0.03531436249613762, 0.10177793353796005, -0.06787601113319397, -0.05071912333369255, 0.009754935279488564, 0.019106941297650337, -0.08850262314081192, -0.042920343577861786, -0.052771445363759995, 0.03365345299243927, 0.00570479454472661, -0.06543324142694473, -0.05925915762782097, -0.018088215962052345, 0.05747382342815399, -0.004775726702064276, -0.007439357228577137, 0.00333403586409986, -0.007510744966566563, 0.02344376966357231, -0.09669940173625946, -0.00680505158379674, -0.03422101214528084, 0.06730178743600845, -0.03216511383652687, -0.015821153298020363, 0.06161836162209511, 0.02229861170053482, 0.0017753980355337262, -0.0006612064316868782, 0.032440558075904846, 0.028673332184553146, 0.0013149507576599717, 0.08761508762836456, -0.046184416860342026, 0.015113770961761475, -0.06879991292953491, -0.05590795353055, 0.0352613627910614, -0.020687058568000793, 0.018010875210165977, -0.02977844700217247, 0.06183251738548279, 0.0278469268232584, -0.06356413662433624, -0.012219013646245003, -0.08297856152057648, 0.08642442524433136, -0.06352103501558304, 0.03934306651353836, 0.028030579909682274, -0.022077685222029686, 0.07859200239181519, 0.04958546906709671, -0.07475895434617996, 0.0011646891944110394, 0.019957398995757103, 0.05138559639453888, 0.05702277645468712, -0.0015778817469254136, 0.00503032561391592, 0.03158358111977577, -0.06350700557231903, 0.0034447694197297096, 0.019084382802248, -0.04839528352022171, 0.05639120191335678, -0.06870371103286743, 0.06882954388856888, 0.0070495991967618465, -0.060597244650125504, 0.017293652519583702, -0.011041694320738316, -0.01460044365376234, -0.014095427468419075, 0.024045361205935478, -0.035558875650167465, -0.0426304005086422, 0.037668898701667786, -0.0022925727535039186, 0.05534229800105095, 0.0031187189742922783, -0.03160287067294121, 0.005501641426235437, 0.026606455445289612, 0.06622183322906494, -0.03097555600106716, -0.0004041822103317827, -0.030444147065281868, -0.026688680052757263, -0.06239354610443115, -0.0944710224866867, 0.05528181418776512, 0.01165967807173729, 0.02649637684226036, -0.02698540687561035, -0.021525340154767036, -0.014154571108520031, -0.030192989856004715, 0.05047732964158058, -0.003771336516365409, -0.04386834800243378, 0.07345177978277206, 0.0750834196805954, -0.030767107382416725, 0.026687923818826675, -0.08042557537555695, -0.019211947917938232, 0.009944862686097622, 0.016374288126826286, -0.03491288423538208, 0.022368893027305603, -0.059630103409290314, -0.007838169112801552, 0.027384264394640923, 0.005522612016648054, -0.017200591042637825, 0.018942521885037422, -0.025520531460642815, 0.006091207731515169, -0.05337703600525856, -0.09452399611473083, -0.06520075350999832, 0.03208538144826889, 0.033870648592710495, 0.0479380302131176, -0.030199632048606873, 0.06493837386369705, 0.04799297824501991, -0.025830693542957306, 0.08954895287752151, 0.036503586918115616, 0.023900434374809265, -0.0783846527338028, 0.048142701387405396, 0.03649241477251053, -0.005224084481596947, 0.020659146830439568, 0.01602993905544281, 0.056685589253902435, 0.07622414827346802, 0.0068120649084448814, -0.03846094384789467, -0.023664534091949463, 0.0014981124550104141, -0.009629912674427032, -0.0033446780871599913, -0.033837366849184036, 0.058807797729969025, -0.037357136607170105, 0.024083783850073814, -0.043653082102537155, 0.07329642027616501, -0.002929855603724718, 0.08085422962903976, -0.016530858352780342, -0.07929070293903351, 0.024124620482325554, -0.01291964203119278, 0.06211737170815468, -0.03728967905044556, 0.048965711146593094, -0.031153341755270958, 0.0396292619407177, -0.03060624562203884, 0.010076078586280346, -0.00009677581692812964, -0.032068882137537, -0.07816290855407715, 0.018299253657460213, 0.00042480273987166584, -0.048339519649744034, -0.09717785567045212, -0.03958219289779663, -0.007683058734983206, 0.040279269218444824, -0.02195993810892105, -0.006904145702719688, 0.046459998935461044, 0.008929233066737652, -0.009272677823901176, 0.04505506902933121, 0.007883867248892784, -0.01332983747124672, -0.016204454004764557, -0.04303461313247681, 0.058505620807409286, 0.11044805496931076, 0.008963767439126968, 0.01958557963371277, -0.019718710333108902, -0.029593007639050484, -0.027976704761385918, -0.042605891823768616, 0.009029225446283817, 0.011693726293742657, 0.044274356216192245, -0.0681801289319992, 0.043007370084524155, 0.018275555223226547, -0.03719233721494675, -0.013524455949664116, -0.027778878808021545, -0.03836233168840408, 0.06238984689116478, -0.06259911507368088, -0.009388240054249763, 0.06237072870135307, -0.01340723317116499, -0.009553168900310993, -0.05468561872839928, -0.02655070275068283, -0.00889694131910801, -0.004391429014503956, -0.055542223155498505, 0.0036130722146481276, 0.04060833528637886, 0.09283838421106339, 0.0405411459505558, -0.03045472875237465, -0.008556729182600975, 0.011544284410774708, -0.0012328600278124213, 0.015676651149988174, -0.03056913986802101, 0.028324246406555176, 0.03155446797609329, 0.0032312318217009306, -0.019875049591064453, -0.04361969605088234, -0.027387041598558426, -0.03394583612680435, -0.06329560279846191, 0.014225929975509644, 0.00653879577293992, -0.04946324601769447, -0.015327010303735733, 0.044794317334890366, 0.04114358872175217, -0.06931145489215851, -0.005447526462376118, 0.010785077698528767, 0.014556466601788998, -0.004828589502722025, 0.05869339779019356, 0.061915453523397446, 0.09443029016256332, -0.013929875567555428, -0.039919376373291016, -0.05692834407091141, -0.0007904566591605544, -0.06154649332165718, -0.026963122189044952, -0.04090442508459091, -0.009394952096045017, -0.004303701221942902, -0.011866839602589607, -0.021638652309775352, -0.04686940088868141, -0.06712781637907028, -0.023870380595326424, 0.04207754135131836, 0.04494281858205795, -0.0784226730465889, -0.013632186688482761, -0.01677110604941845, -0.07265936583280563, 0.027862394228577614, -0.07666295766830444, -0.006827262695878744, -0.04613393172621727, -0.01757996901869774, 0.026141678914427757, 0.14471319317817688, 0.0031067263334989548, 0.0033403539564460516, -0.03645225614309311, 0.0053441282361745834, -0.0075189522467553616, -0.05260718986392021, -0.08236684650182724, -0.08490235358476639, -0.011046726256608963, 0.0006169285043142736, 0.03219502419233322, 0.008348392322659492, 0.09531115740537643, 0.01563957706093788, -0.04464796930551529, 0.014129084534943104, 0.003579122945666313, 0.01186100859194994, -0.006685442291200161, 0.017816338688135147, -0.04133732616901398, 0.09444044530391693, 0.04495573043823242, 0.05061980336904526, 0.04432101920247078, 0.051871106028556824, -0.06015133112668991, 0.03353778272867203, -0.02684192545711994, 0.023039601743221283, 0.017110642045736313, -0.02504691109061241, -0.0012862907024100423, 0.028692001476883888, -0.018571393564343452, 0.05779074877500534, 0.04583774879574776, 0.012502669356763363, 0.04866321012377739, 0.035486746579408646, 0.005336673930287361, 0.029514815658330917, -0.008366402238607407, -0.016077851876616478, 0.008718935772776604, -0.019520185887813568, 0.004687150474637747, -0.04856391251087189, -0.05403944104909897, 0.019667714834213257, -0.058431077748537064, -0.047211289405822754, -0.044988956302404404, -0.025671280920505524, 0.006928993389010429, 0.003964168485254049, -0.12790484726428986, 0.015094401314854622, -0.018749594688415527, -0.023174230009317398, 0.03491302579641342, 0.05391416326165199, -0.0017496623331680894, -0.04233868420124054, -0.02346477285027504, -0.0053708236664533615, 0.03018205612897873, -0.06240630894899368, -0.01440969668328762, -0.11484518647193909, -0.08184938877820969, -0.015573490411043167, -0.002044276101514697, 0.011026367545127869, -0.021543273702263832, -0.02270038239657879, -0.019965682178735733, -0.042972978204488754, -0.02915497124195099, -0.01962934248149395, 0.023533426225185394, 0.03227108344435692, -0.02777850069105625, 0.03945017606019974, 0.011202415451407433, -0.07910627871751785, 0.09269797801971436, 0.050658758729696274, -0.0653473287820816, -0.02969278208911419, -0.022213226184248924, -0.005355445668101311, 0.011620726436376572, 0.07941341400146484, 0.005720740184187889, 0.06078110262751579, -0.03532347455620766, -0.01921321079134941, 0.02875535748898983, 0.019378960132598877, 0.03340050205588341, 0.07324214279651642, 0.029513634741306305, -0.004406638443470001, 0.05450541153550148, 0.027479983866214752, -0.02137792482972145, -0.037155721336603165, -0.03524698689579964, -0.004614565055817366, -0.009946567006409168, 0.03658366948366165, 0.07299823313951492, -0.005000276956707239, 0.05709866061806679, 0.044740013778209686, -0.06285698711872101, 0.0006986819207668304, 0.006059261038899422, -0.02188153751194477, 0.02104419469833374, 0.10798943042755127, -0.005881281569600105, -0.06294556707143784, 0.08218885958194733, 0.07373320311307907, -0.00633392995223403, -0.04546106606721878, 0.0028740146663039923, -0.007580324076116085, -0.17624667286872864, 0.02219664491713047, 0.023266909644007683, -0.0007617415394634008, 0.05835243687033653, -0.012662503868341446, -0.0373595654964447, -0.04742361605167389, -0.018902748823165894, -0.0632055476307869, 0.02005837671458721, 0.08953163772821426, 0.018506549298763275, -0.016425495967268944, -0.00498949596658349, -0.08991097658872604, 0.10621927678585052, 0.007516065612435341, 0.002851036610081792, 0.07848417013883591, -0.0052064647898077965, 0.08560115844011307, -0.047948915511369705, 0.01635899767279625, -0.0197927113622427, 0.002623405074700713, 0.02321791835129261, -0.03284484148025513, -0.07038974016904831, -0.010941394604742527, -0.04475763440132141, 0.003829030320048332, -0.04687638580799103, 0.05308735370635986, 0.06124664470553398, 0.007805802393704653, -0.0007254708907566965, -0.04174965247511864, 0.02027091756463051, -0.05444588139653206, 0.07145454734563828, 0.030579837039113045, 0.08859691768884659, 0.03720560669898987, -0.044391654431819916, 0.0683010071516037, -0.0027963784523308277, 0.022668635472655296 ]
40
40
Fast Algorithm and Implementation of Dissimilarity Self-Organizing Maps
In many real world applications, data cannot be accurately represented by vectors. In those situations, one possible solution is to rely on dissimilarity measures that enable sensible comparison between observations. Kohonen's Self-Organizing Map (SOM) has been adapted to data described only through their dissimilarity matrix. This algorithm provides both non linear projection and clustering of non vector data. Unfortunately, the algorithm suffers from a high cost that makes it quite difficult to use with voluminous data sets. In this paper, we propose a new algorithm that provides an important reduction of the theoretical cost of the dissimilarity SOM without changing its outcome (the results are exactly the same as the ones obtained with the original algorithm). Moreover, we introduce implementation methods that result in very short running times. Improvements deduced from the theoretical cost model are validated on simulated and real world data (a word list clustering problem). We also demonstrate that the proposed implementation methods reduce by a factor up to 3 the running time of the fast algorithm over a standard implementation.
[ -0.020866340026259422, -0.003844452789053321, -0.022978389635682106, 0.006442004814743996, -0.028350375592708588, 0.03597560152411461, -0.049279309809207916, -0.04320173338055611, -0.028798235580325127, -0.022277774289250374, 0.006254648324102163, 0.016164913773536682, -0.03801748529076576, 0.07256103307008743, -0.03318529576063156, 0.021926915273070335, -0.06055069342255592, 0.021666763350367546, 0.005355993285775185, -0.03405635803937912, -0.017701534554362297, -0.002844118047505617, -0.021261587738990784, -0.02182585932314396, 0.001322430558502674, -0.03273791819810867, -0.0635647103190422, 0.025784596800804138, -0.010294986888766289, 0.01357233989983797, -0.02367565408349037, 0.031010253354907036, 0.06300555914640427, 0.03318905085325241, -0.022936508059501648, -0.05631546676158905, 0.05449345335364342, 0.011422502808272839, 0.03241683542728424, -0.07393394410610199, 0.0400867760181427, 0.041389670222997665, -0.026166720315814018, 0.0028016429860144854, 0.02385023981332779, 0.035784315317869186, 0.06477886438369751, 0.01544853113591671, 0.03648883476853371, 0.048604268580675125, -0.04463817924261093, 0.015966597944498062, 0.01741109788417816, 0.046937908977270126, -0.06771833449602127, 0.05138370394706726, -0.06700633466243744, 0.031900521367788315, 0.02695017121732235, -0.07898729294538498, 0.05438246950507164, 0.0944535881280899, -0.007407722063362598, 0.0021776852663606405, -0.011835234239697456, -0.07382728159427643, -0.01854432001709938, -0.048393506556749344, -0.03762470558285713, -0.05765574425458908, 0.019539570435881615, -0.09670702368021011, -0.0383555069565773, -0.07450293004512787, -0.004607097711414099, 0.0010450094705447555, 0.0199256744235754, 0.05140836909413338, 0.04595174267888069, 0.09991954267024994, -0.03620942682027817, 0.007534641306847334, -0.010746901854872704, -0.009318969212472439, -0.02786741405725479, -0.018546897917985916, -0.017823008820414543, -0.007976594381034374, 0.038305968046188354, 0.03399293124675751, -0.06373699009418488, -0.019157718867063522, -0.06371378898620605, 0.07081042975187302, -0.03697395324707031, -0.027814136818051338, 0.021167559549212456, 0.04764271154999733, 0.043700121343135834, 0.011363864876329899, 0.014756320044398308, 0.06262954324483871, 0.007569275796413422, 0.05693160369992256, -0.060963135212659836, 0.028013087809085846, -0.0637008473277092, 0.042481835931539536, 0.0005796710029244423, -0.03686082735657692, 0.015836860984563828, 0.01013904344290495, 0.005584039259701967, -0.02712247148156166, -0.000583140121307224, 0.03280621021986008, -0.000415962451370433, 0.03110341727733612, -0.058633677661418915, -0.04964311420917511, -0.024347493425011635, 0.01945599727332592, 0.006436940748244524, 0.01814676634967327, -0.0013952204026281834, 0.0076292576268315315, -0.04801315441727638, 0.013646828010678291, 0.06249453127384186, 0.00964212417602539, -0.15011867880821228, 0.018458222970366478, -0.049593355506658554, 0.03324555233120918, -0.07181031256914139, -0.023476172238588333, 0.06885350495576859, -0.03982355818152428, -0.006067130248993635, 0.06536410003900528, 0.09281836450099945, 0.003241942496970296, -0.07365573942661285, -0.01663155108690262, 0.0468314103782177, 0.006421022117137909, -0.04902057722210884, -0.005042326636612415, 0.06380131840705872, 0.01896589621901512, 0.024341734126210213, -0.04653488099575043, 0.05776261165738106, -0.04454217851161957, -0.03592122346162796, -0.07887006551027298, 0.019029472023248672, -0.08005021512508392, 0.009123996831476688, 0.03881700336933136, -0.05891604721546173, 0.003289558459073305, 0.012078815139830112, -0.016025105491280556, 0.050035323947668076, -0.048112694174051285, 0.014970129355788231, -0.07160399854183197, -0.039010293781757355, -0.012633037753403187, 0.07038012146949768, 0.03507513552904129, 0.00743776373565197, 0.05259689688682556, -0.005492886528372765, -0.005269971676170826, -0.06745117157697678, 0.020090796053409576, 0.024784237146377563, -0.05833430215716362, -0.05014342814683914, -0.0076476894319057465, 0.00627801613882184, 0.003749731695279479, 0.01968025043606758, 0.08719341456890106, -0.006064537446945906, 0.018984269350767136, 0.07139209657907486, -0.012273507192730904, 0.0835508331656456, 0.047417838126420975, 0.058536019176244736, -0.030479878187179565, -0.007851035334169865, 0.05172528699040413, 0.011883190833032131, -0.04752688854932785, 0.037665002048015594, 0.05747009068727493, 0.02622959017753601, 0.026900721713900566, -0.027945198118686676, -0.09447010606527328, -0.03707034885883331, -0.012075605802237988, 0.013859166763722897, -0.0012769921449944377, 0.023389920592308044, -0.02172086015343666, 0.05393613502383232, -0.008222208358347416, -0.027865784242749214, -0.046104248613119125, 0.04566487297415733, -0.04054052755236626, 0.008639674633741379, -0.0028591053560376167, 0.026672042906284332, 0.030047820881009102, -0.08446880429983139, 0.03761586174368858, 0.0010040916968137026, 0.09141983091831207, -0.0018590318504720926, -0.0072844671085476875, 0.011597448959946632, -0.057248953729867935, -0.08902419358491898, 0.026065150275826454, -0.045675911009311676, -0.023310720920562744, -0.06318006664514542, -0.02784590795636177, 0.0687069222331047, 0.08656325191259384, -0.07071556895971298, -0.015727289021015167, 0.03488960117101669, -0.027273904532194138, -0.028153154999017715, 0.023472778499126434, -0.028870265930891037, -0.029701057821512222, 0.04841136932373047, -0.02844587340950966, 0.026177959516644478, 0.012680042535066605, -0.02718011848628521, -0.021407781168818474, 0.00836173351854086, -0.007302047219127417, -0.02577926404774189, -0.013774022459983826, 0.04596911370754242, 0.02713380753993988, -0.07674086093902588, 0.020763246342539787, 0.07595410197973251, 0.11095791310071945, -0.016460534185171127, 0.10506987571716309, 0.012035726569592953, 0.013957557268440723, 0.07806535065174103, 0.003986002877354622, 0.017912207171320915, 0.05380699783563614, 0.07191939651966095, -0.004545335192233324, 0.01606534980237484, -0.06748101860284805, -0.057910121977329254, 0.09095951914787292, -0.10953238606452942, -0.05277123302221298, 0.002889729104936123, 0.09668141603469849, -0.061554308980703354, -0.06177084892988205, -0.02493491768836975, 0.038180552423000336, -0.0099894804880023, -0.059316229075193405, -0.05718294158577919, -0.0017924853600561619, 0.04047819599509239, -0.03595251217484474, 0.00046078531886450946, 0.014861357398331165, 0.012539805844426155, 0.059146977961063385, -0.12843570113182068, -0.022384217008948326, -0.007390917278826237, -0.0672040730714798, 0.0183804240077734, 0.007544843479990959, 0.06330984830856323, -0.001730079180561006, 0.022308988496661186, 0.022309686988592148, 0.10879829525947571, -0.027215056121349335, 0.0277678444981575, 0.0024382073897868395, 0.12133646756410599, 0.02230176329612732, -0.0036411962937563658, 0.04520776495337486, -0.05402388423681259, 0.009246592409908772, -0.06439722329378128, -0.02551005594432354, -0.01996959187090397, -0.019586514681577682, -0.023405302315950394, -0.00302698602899909, -0.02962491475045681, 0.007301698438823223, 0.05202830955386162, -0.010596687905490398, 0.04300761595368385, -0.056151993572711945, -0.013929127715528011, -0.03299732506275177, 0.017538564279675484, -0.010331553407013416, -0.0392676517367363, -0.015110231004655361, -0.06457366794347763, 0.030272850766777992, -0.05679970234632492, -0.02489626221358776, 0.03217879310250282, -0.011153765954077244, -0.037410639226436615, 0.049485329538583755, -0.04120916873216629, -0.0036633512936532497, -0.05902516841888428, -0.046469975262880325, -0.027267377823591232, -0.018336785957217216, 0.01455540768802166, -0.0069366502575576305, 0.0682765543460846, 0.024942826479673386, 0.004794329404830933, -0.0004375602293293923, -0.07263866811990738, 0.057732343673706055, -0.029199939221143723, -0.08846454322338104, 0.047607552260160446, 0.006931896787136793, 0.01874326914548874, -0.007257948163896799, 0.016544759273529053, 0.014244277030229568, 0.014425358735024929, 0.03331523761153221, -0.008152919821441174, 0.028443051502108574, 0.03192245215177536, -0.004384853411465883, -0.057760339230298996, 0.07233639061450958, -0.01745523139834404, 0.053711872547864914, 0.08869153261184692, 0.010579685680568218, 0.003778464626520872, -0.03628162294626236, 0.025887547060847282, -0.02434978261590004, 0.034743186086416245, -0.03379073739051819, 0.0013610239839181304, -0.029468553140759468, 0.026740925386548042, -0.05648841708898544, -0.05236904323101044, 0.008064966648817062, -0.030823612585663795, 0.0025093466974794865, 0.04415144398808479, 0.0577843002974987, 0.010189620777964592, 0.06763598322868347, 0.020108064636588097, -0.0031289372127503157, 0.000624097534455359, -0.021043401211500168, 0.05045987665653229, -0.0394953116774559, -0.014297683723270893, -0.11595061421394348, -0.04081457108259201, -0.07056504487991333, -0.0009416203247383237, -0.015048617497086525, -0.05074434354901314, -0.10971084982156754, -0.08623678982257843, 0.06618744879961014, 0.0010634622303768992, 0.07465431839227676, 0.002380535239353776, 0.020174387842416763, 0.012388447299599648, -0.00423903064802289, -0.06438177078962326, -0.019712498411536217, 0.01363718044012785, 0.008098140358924866, -0.018478823825716972, -0.05032087862491608, 0.04518118500709534, -0.045209936797618866, -0.04601740464568138, 0.02345103770494461, -0.03898264467716217, -0.02123171091079712, -0.100465789437294, 0.06966052204370499, -0.004688098561018705, 0.017389988526701927, 0.05548068881034851, 0.029707878828048706, -0.031117450445890427, 0.0036025349982082844, -0.008834543637931347, 0.047565292567014694, 0.08624888956546783, -0.01368520688265562, -0.004996640607714653, -0.05384436994791031, -0.03839768469333649, 0.056937795132398605, 0.05237717553973198, -0.016204779967665672, -0.04577983543276787, -0.03457503765821457, 0.007255771663039923, -0.08059881627559662, 0.0424964614212513, -0.013093901798129082, 0.03904404118657112, -0.03632308542728424, -0.06211461126804352, 0.016815485432744026, 0.05415688082575798, 0.015527965500950813, -0.026618657633662224, -0.009280537255108356, -0.013653247617185116, 0.016959499567747116, -0.006428118795156479, -0.05841793119907379, -0.0671859011054039, 0.03433236852288246, -0.010127916000783443, 0.0238984115421772, -0.052249398082494736, 0.041789259761571884, 0.0035303093027323484, 0.04498102888464928, 0.0664166510105133, 0.03990892693400383, -0.04372280463576317, 0.019544651731848717, 0.003905264427885413, -0.0267079696059227, -0.012137682177126408, 0.0916174054145813, 0.07512310147285461, -0.05394398421049118, -0.012690206989645958, -0.03487683832645416, 0.010709687136113644, 0.0038977654185146093, 0.0036287489347159863, 0.028157277032732964, 0.05433955043554306, 0.037727851420640945, -0.08778367191553116, -0.033491529524326324, 0.030395472422242165, -0.050314512103796005, 0.020637445151805878, -0.028848368674516678, -0.04670533165335655, 0.04028577357530594, -0.08817582577466965, -0.006272569764405489, -0.09453751146793365, 0.05345151200890541, 0.025100547820329666, 0.035975757986307144, 0.012316218577325344, -0.00505893025547266, -0.04209575429558754, 0.04227105528116226, 0.015294026583433151, -0.02356530912220478, 0.041778407990932465, -0.05969205126166344, -0.019812218844890594, 0.09675030410289764, -0.03178059309720993, 0.021059652790427208 ]
41
41
Une adaptation des cartes auto-organisatrices pour des donn\'ees d\'ecrites par un tableau de dissimilarit\'es
Many data analysis methods cannot be applied to data that are not represented by a fixed number of real values, whereas most of real world observations are not readily available in such a format. Vector based data analysis methods have therefore to be adapted in order to be used with non standard complex data. A flexible and general solution for this adaptation is to use a (dis)similarity measure. Indeed, thanks to expert knowledge on the studied data, it is generally possible to define a measure that can be used to make pairwise comparison between observations. General data analysis methods are then obtained by adapting existing methods to (dis)similarity matrices. In this article, we propose an adaptation of Kohonen's Self Organizing Map (SOM) to (dis)similarity data. The proposed algorithm is an adapted version of the vector based batch SOM. The method is validated on real world data: we provide an analysis of the usage patterns of the web site of the Institut National de Recherche en Informatique et Automatique, constructed thanks to web log mining method.
[ -0.06362615525722504, -0.06221112608909607, -0.008295400068163872, -0.023830736055970192, 0.03468702360987663, 0.014971701428294182, -0.05332878977060318, -0.052910562604665756, -0.030232097953557968, -0.08098376542329788, 0.0407010093331337, 0.003100202651694417, -0.0003106882213614881, 0.054258376359939575, 0.023915721103549004, 0.008217022754251957, -0.05375414341688156, -0.025483328849077225, -0.026497211307287216, -0.078083336353302, -0.04028579220175743, 0.07506312429904938, -0.03828347101807594, -0.04015006870031357, 0.019676033407449722, -0.023443156853318214, -0.05102091655135155, -0.018443360924720764, -0.02452930621802807, -0.009318976663053036, -0.03171459212899208, -0.015506354160606861, 0.03053221106529236, 0.08896113932132721, 0.021318428218364716, -0.0294537004083395, 0.0377642959356308, 0.01956368423998356, 0.015372166410088539, -0.012999018654227257, 0.026839375495910645, 0.03858073055744171, -0.01339439395815134, -0.008537258952856064, 0.06304378807544708, 0.07594464719295502, 0.05813179537653923, 0.012084116227924824, 0.06883257627487183, 0.0391574501991272, -0.04723109304904938, 0.028622975572943687, -0.006635919213294983, 0.01446013618260622, -0.04927042871713638, 0.09473616629838943, 0.011570981703698635, 0.06771323084831238, 0.025964271277189255, -0.039590395987033844, 0.01706039160490036, 0.09946615993976593, 0.04660234972834587, -0.037316761910915375, -0.022094275802373886, -0.04603125900030136, -0.1011202484369278, -0.04494320601224899, -0.04507937654852867, -0.03249305859208107, 0.0527157336473465, -0.0598687119781971, 0.0058953226543962955, -0.03607657924294472, 0.02545471116900444, 0.010447369888424873, 0.018268682062625885, 0.029265213757753372, 0.03959060460329056, 0.12700219452381134, -0.05173533782362938, 0.051847364753484726, -0.03432169556617737, -0.005852787755429745, -0.030664101243019104, -0.03261931985616684, 0.046824075281620026, -0.002539576031267643, 0.02181939408183098, 0.033562544733285904, -0.047978006303310394, -0.02134888246655464, -0.08544280380010605, 0.010617434978485107, -0.0772518590092659, -0.0045692045241594315, -0.002700189361348748, 0.023141702637076378, 0.026843411847949028, -0.057401347905397415, 0.036781445145606995, 0.02039055898785591, 0.030454708263278008, 0.0162885170429945, -0.0543864481151104, 0.016632556915283203, -0.04680338501930237, 0.04977810010313988, -0.028555234894156456, -0.02369699254631996, 0.01275893859565258, 0.00578480726107955, 0.013874764554202557, -0.013361371122300625, 0.016313545405864716, 0.03316592052578926, 0.030541615560650826, 0.060416463762521744, -0.04466429352760315, -0.0659957081079483, 0.017818771302700043, 0.00904780812561512, 0.012651031836867332, -0.013335265219211578, 0.02851301059126854, -0.020850999280810356, -0.008456841111183167, -0.022855019196867943, 0.04031693562865257, -0.003533950773999095, -0.12367044389247894, 0.06790219992399216, -0.05241797864437103, 0.0654589831829071, -0.11525716632604599, -0.06002870574593544, 0.05191580206155777, -0.02647850662469864, -0.012052482925355434, 0.02404935657978058, 0.0645715519785881, 0.04931894317269325, -0.0680966004729271, -0.0591718852519989, -0.012348401360213757, 0.040382493287324905, 0.011227909475564957, 0.02013552002608776, 0.056782595813274384, 0.005706405267119408, -0.008745871484279633, -0.04855165258049965, 0.05092800408601761, -0.02223970554769039, -0.040946852415800095, -0.0749371126294136, 0.013069462962448597, -0.038364239037036896, -0.02677842788398266, 0.04620810225605965, -0.0001423526555299759, 0.005638958886265755, 0.030688567087054253, -0.014196149073541164, 0.019115280359983444, -0.05604833737015724, -0.006905179470777512, -0.04062561318278313, -0.030808383598923683, -0.019238557666540146, 0.020071741193532944, 0.015632769092917442, 0.03849492222070694, 0.05537398159503937, -0.0385272391140461, -0.0308400709182024, -0.04928717762231827, 0.09617140144109726, 0.02731182985007763, -0.04402514174580574, -0.06895928084850311, -0.02044099010527134, -0.02842489443719387, 0.04704153165221214, 0.043495625257492065, 0.09806719422340393, 0.011873933486640453, 0.01980619505047798, 0.06893514841794968, -0.0024074274115264416, 0.12107434868812561, 0.079019695520401, 0.052982963621616364, -0.017184361815452576, 0.012405935674905777, 0.04066214710474014, 0.02946891076862812, -0.05896134302020073, 0.005280761048197746, 0.07050730288028717, 0.001257873373106122, 0.00959522370249033, -0.011604838073253632, -0.08249742537736893, -0.07617806643247604, 0.005344222765415907, -0.02403501607477665, -0.023845281451940536, -0.02841993235051632, 0.04276134818792343, 0.08811747282743454, 0.011296282522380352, -0.033888768404722214, -0.044126905500888824, 0.08272737264633179, -0.04962267354130745, -0.015443888492882252, -0.0011552354553714395, 0.060463953763246536, 0.03544566407799721, -0.0778796523809433, 0.05052083358168602, 0.0020310694817453623, 0.08479943126440048, -0.03937282785773277, -0.0030438483227044344, -0.011280209757387638, -0.05095860734581947, -0.08566515147686005, 0.021212253719568253, -0.09839894622564316, -0.07665213197469711, -0.10153787583112717, -0.04881083965301514, 0.0918089747428894, 0.08113754540681839, -0.10675238072872162, 0.002353673567995429, 0.044900164008140564, -0.005319535732269287, -0.019326476380228996, -0.006673951167613268, -0.008249640464782715, 0.002140316879376769, 0.036010559648275375, -0.04348820820450783, 0.022503921762108803, 0.02173667773604393, -0.045952484011650085, 0.005646414123475552, 0.02050931006669998, -0.04839496314525604, 0.007816341705620289, 0.008600430563092232, 0.01232557836920023, 0.05905088037252426, -0.09605946391820908, -0.020011138170957565, 0.0508473701775074, 0.06092076376080513, -0.004987397696822882, 0.049733247607946396, -0.021496938541531563, 0.02530096285045147, 0.07564052194356918, 0.021585118025541306, 0.015316654928028584, 0.02590470016002655, 0.07547427713871002, 0.021968398243188858, -0.012085932306945324, -0.08145199716091156, -0.046369392424821854, 0.044684939086437225, -0.08554188907146454, -0.01814054325222969, -0.013517874293029308, 0.07420850545167923, -0.006874032784253359, -0.0761367529630661, -0.042186636477708817, -0.004221021663397551, 0.0009650624706409872, -0.04826788231730461, -0.04870549589395523, -0.015835337340831757, 0.021696753799915314, -0.03243734687566757, 0.0026387269608676434, 0.020500732585787773, 0.03910941258072853, 0.07634269446134567, -0.1220579743385315, -0.007895936258137226, 0.0020092977210879326, -0.0673690065741539, 0.0012174040311947465, -0.020851299166679382, 0.054367903620004654, -0.027528682723641396, -0.0007281855796463788, 0.026016749441623688, 0.07891588658094406, -0.023681215941905975, 0.028918782249093056, 0.008474357426166534, 0.05295670032501221, 0.04162594676017761, -0.0015833518700674176, 0.04227009043097496, -0.015442300587892532, 0.002812727354466915, -0.046816386282444, -0.06566427648067474, -0.03070848062634468, -0.03554153069853783, -0.06460931152105331, -0.027375653386116028, -0.03821404278278351, 0.006116166710853577, 0.0023209655191749334, -0.002420988632366061, 0.033394116908311844, -0.02590017020702362, 0.029831595718860626, 0.010768134146928787, -0.040698129683732986, 0.015838921070098877, -0.04416247084736824, 0.0043050367385149, -0.043949730694293976, 0.034623030573129654, 0.01887837052345276, 0.047539617866277695, -0.003488342510536313, 0.003934851847589016, -0.01775025576353073, -0.010325388982892036, -0.035802002996206284, 0.012165257707238197, -0.07993463426828384, -0.0777808353304863, 0.018139207735657692, -0.04535665363073349, 0.05031236261129379, 0.01656476967036724, 0.0955950990319252, 0.06636840105056763, -0.029683634638786316, -0.0050575016066432, -0.008349522948265076, 0.026403049007058144, 0.010191189125180244, -0.029711181297898293, -0.006046950817108154, 0.038006123155355453, -0.007504072971642017, 0.06665661931037903, 0.014347382821142673, 0.028526820242404938, 0.01872965320944786, 0.026567906141281128, -0.035304680466651917, 0.019327539950609207, 0.048728689551353455, -0.050336677581071854, -0.019306616857647896, 0.08816517144441605, -0.058942846953868866, 0.04366188868880272, 0.11531716585159302, 0.057252734899520874, 0.05411159619688988, -0.024722101166844368, -0.06723709404468536, -0.043688055127859116, -0.008829220198094845, -0.02514873631298542, 0.009585888125002384, 0.004198121838271618, 0.005974885076284409, -0.05270862951874733, 0.025485021993517876, 0.012106784619390965, -0.040591999888420105, 0.01619381085038185, -0.04052427038550377, 0.02143171988427639, 0.03235697001218796, 0.017282212153077126, -0.017322663217782974, 0.0014375526225194335, -0.005574873182922602, -0.04106764867901802, 0.06540626287460327, -0.018498433753848076, 0.011617623269557953, -0.06786604970693588, -0.05825985595583916, -0.03449495509266853, -0.008063046261668205, -0.05977747216820717, -0.056809041649103165, -0.09943153709173203, -0.09792488813400269, 0.08393999934196472, 0.013138871639966965, 0.07636461406946182, 0.038594916462898254, 0.021567797288298607, 0.06575337052345276, -0.012490076012909412, -0.01660616509616375, -0.038038332015275955, 0.02904016524553299, 0.019758770242333412, 0.004263098817318678, -0.027617277577519417, 0.008000083267688751, -0.06246271729469299, -0.013599720783531666, -0.0031515099108219147, -0.027067244052886963, -0.05895771458745003, -0.09969740360975266, 0.01158402394503355, 0.014584694989025593, 0.03821752592921257, 0.057438723742961884, 0.04159296303987503, -0.04248349368572235, -0.023276150226593018, -0.03657011687755585, 0.1334550678730011, 0.04509805142879486, -0.009880888275802135, 0.005504489876329899, -0.026383373886346817, -0.01984098181128502, -0.00071993179153651, 0.034160394221544266, 0.018251044675707817, 0.007737120613455772, -0.008043655194342136, 0.06547664105892181, -0.0556722991168499, 0.017215756699442863, 0.0035672043450176716, 0.047253042459487915, -0.021010583266615868, -0.018215272575616837, 0.013810733333230019, 0.013663963414728642, -0.006337156053632498, -0.04039119929075241, 0.018526894971728325, -0.07004113495349884, -0.04006125032901764, 0.05315516144037247, -0.012645109556615353, -0.02139531448483467, 0.03942260146141052, 0.0282910019159317, -0.010333871468901634, -0.05731786787509918, 0.012336873449385166, 0.04216183349490166, 0.028992803767323494, 0.05287003889679909, 0.02179260365664959, -0.04765598103404045, 0.007514298893511295, 0.008669796399772167, 0.007504069246351719, 0.0023789117112755775, 0.03181323781609535, 0.03464250639081001, -0.07287643104791641, -0.04809147119522095, -0.031296905130147934, 0.03668652102351189, -0.00449020741507411, -0.006069896277040243, 0.03751968964934349, 0.024297261610627174, 0.04997503384947777, -0.03309367224574089, -0.05170172452926636, 0.05151142179965973, -0.013641069643199444, 0.07526330649852753, -0.034829482436180115, -0.05899016559123993, 0.03446429595351219, -0.027247825637459755, -0.03181018307805061, -0.044895850121974945, 0.029196908697485924, 0.015125623904168606, -0.013523740693926811, 0.04248230531811714, -0.03841325640678406, -0.02866554819047451, 0.009182760491967201, 0.031102268025279045, -0.008577060885727406, 0.03157954290509224, -0.030184661969542503, 0.027756590396165848, 0.06406456977128983, -0.0226079560816288, -0.01331253256648779 ]
42
42
Self-organizing maps and symbolic data
In data analysis new forms of complex data have to be considered like for example (symbolic data, functional data, web data, trees, SQL query and multimedia data, ...). In this context classical data analysis for knowledge discovery based on calculating the center of gravity can not be used because input are not $\mathbb{R}^p$ vectors. In this paper, we present an application on real world symbolic data using the self-organizing map. To this end, we propose an extension of the self-organizing map that can handle symbolic data.
[ -0.04831993952393532, -0.012723402120172977, 0.028620904311537743, -0.03043990395963192, 0.03964993357658386, -0.016621265560388565, -0.05020188167691231, -0.026578785851597786, -0.07523270696401596, 0.019575316458940506, 0.04023141413927078, 0.0032207295298576355, -0.01982390321791172, 0.06365309655666351, 0.025751108303666115, 0.026593465358018875, -0.019874785095453262, 0.029645618051290512, -0.01410041656345129, -0.07633771002292633, 0.06384039670228958, 0.05548999086022377, 0.009030140936374664, -0.025313613936305046, -0.015842624008655548, 0.016113566234707832, -0.016833985224366188, -0.01714118756353855, -0.0212689321488142, -0.016081998124718666, -0.019624032080173492, 0.013874980621039867, 0.030576758086681366, 0.07451845705509186, -0.007923935540020466, 0.02339251898229122, 0.011887640692293644, 0.01350056566298008, -0.03003232181072235, -0.03297612816095352, 0.013957200571894646, 0.0040002306923270226, -0.027820879593491554, -0.01654389500617981, 0.03315027430653572, 0.05578452721238136, 0.006681028287857771, -0.029400518164038658, 0.015162189491093159, 0.08279620110988617, -0.08568554371595383, 0.06553211063146591, -0.009664718061685562, -0.006499822251498699, -0.024461640045046806, 0.04814834147691727, 0.014858393929898739, 0.0949542224407196, 0.04381507262587547, 0.029339807108044624, 0.09003451466560364, 0.0928279310464859, 0.06095173582434654, -0.07401251792907715, -0.009894153103232384, -0.005262361373752356, -0.014512864872813225, -0.009401255287230015, -0.03213668614625931, -0.015988625586032867, 0.04493363946676254, 0.004066908732056618, 0.033978573977947235, -0.02891385182738304, 0.023622047156095505, 0.020145049318671227, -0.07683717459440231, -0.036833979189395905, 0.015561914071440697, 0.09247207641601562, -0.021694079041481018, 0.02073073759675026, -0.05532635748386383, 0.0019197467481717467, 0.002850577002391219, -0.007820582017302513, 0.01041544508188963, 0.030607467517256737, 0.014042934402823448, 0.015543926507234573, -0.03847610577940941, 0.010867433622479439, -0.04713664948940277, -0.009239855222404003, -0.015420744195580482, 0.022257063537836075, -0.0633014366030693, -0.05208267644047737, -0.010647331364452839, -0.03247334808111191, 0.005255945958197117, -0.018044333904981613, 0.004958791192620993, 0.07224558293819427, -0.029314935207366943, 0.04434782639145851, -0.04635811224579811, 0.040107570588588715, 0.01726642996072769, -0.018188487738370895, 0.044843707233667374, -0.03287200257182121, -0.0015803148271515965, 0.045416705310344696, 0.009673765860497952, 0.02139207161962986, 0.0500902384519577, 0.1166173443198204, -0.04240189865231514, -0.037052735686302185, 0.05304807424545288, 0.006346453446894884, 0.019795605912804604, 0.022380823269486427, 0.014684478752315044, 0.02061406895518303, 0.005045139696449041, -0.02405177429318428, 0.0655042752623558, 0.07136150449514389, -0.09976154565811157, 0.09790729731321335, -0.038870956748723984, 0.059044186025857925, -0.07052581757307053, -0.03458457812666893, -0.018355360254645348, -0.03637438267469406, -0.03400833159685135, 0.00753070879727602, 0.07602553814649582, -0.028021270409226418, -0.013605291955173016, -0.009153173305094242, -0.016241831704974174, 0.1055568978190422, 0.014848629012703896, 0.01807316206395626, 0.07248950004577637, 0.017052005976438522, 0.0539315789937973, -0.05700615793466568, 0.0206492617726326, 0.013049467466771603, 0.0026596831157803535, 0.027229635044932365, -0.05239012837409973, -0.04720623418688774, 0.0044997818768024445, 0.014242840930819511, 0.012500714510679245, -0.006546712480485439, 0.011656955815851688, 0.05956697836518288, 0.017309552058577538, -0.024813249707221985, -0.05362900719046593, -0.061533112078905106, 0.024258766323328018, -0.054658193141222, 0.08454977720975876, 0.025082645937800407, 0.031134793534874916, 0.0600699745118618, 0.014108998700976372, -0.053723156452178955, -0.028595635667443275, -0.005246714688837528, -0.005215279292315245, -0.09384395182132721, -0.015203787945210934, -0.041232701390981674, -0.007188604678958654, 0.07591192424297333, -0.0009996432345360518, 0.16035403311252594, 0.01653595082461834, 0.05214119702577591, 0.06243501976132393, 0.03782495856285095, 0.026227490976452827, 0.041350673884153366, 0.05296317860484123, -0.02511133998632431, -0.027512576431035995, 0.05169064179062843, 0.017884450033307076, -0.022979913279414177, -0.04042920470237732, 0.03148018941283226, 0.009292000904679298, 0.06836851686239243, -0.062085188925266266, -0.08948108553886414, -0.05751863494515419, -0.049881480634212494, 0.03966116905212402, -0.028439316898584366, -0.059980735182762146, -0.024264147505164146, 0.038649238646030426, 0.013675238005816936, -0.01969780959188938, -0.02425907365977764, 0.09836685657501221, -0.05022294446825981, -0.02871374413371086, -0.041762594133615494, 0.05551358312368393, 0.016116565093398094, -0.06555724143981934, 0.06906025111675262, -0.023584788665175438, 0.07844217121601105, -0.008510731160640717, 0.0036823716945946217, 0.01735292747616768, -0.04586831107735634, -0.05603080987930298, 0.011921846307814121, -0.10313893109560013, -0.07758448272943497, -0.06141802668571472, 0.021752366796135902, 0.08571673929691315, 0.08323204517364502, -0.0049242982640862465, 0.03742637112736702, -0.03708276152610779, 0.03908484801650047, -0.03962664306163788, 0.04508974403142929, -0.0068175396881997585, -0.03494282066822052, 0.021347466856241226, -0.02141067199409008, -0.04638253152370453, 0.04119157791137695, 0.01845303364098072, -0.03136974573135376, -0.04635544493794441, -0.020326564088463783, -0.014318102970719337, -0.01808645948767662, 0.04526467248797417, 0.02210596390068531, -0.050592001527547836, -0.048669733107089996, 0.10192771255970001, 0.12145113945007324, -0.0003264720435254276, 0.034568317234516144, -0.005349418614059687, 0.007711755111813545, 0.022841157391667366, 0.05762781202793121, 0.016113733872771263, 0.029113344848155975, 0.010437141172587872, 0.002959554549306631, 0.046829745173454285, -0.03255784884095192, -0.051096562296152115, 0.005136671010404825, -0.05899226292967796, 0.024982165545225143, 0.04033399000763893, 0.004143877420574427, -0.037710633128881454, -0.08954021334648132, -0.017017530277371407, -0.024896759539842606, -0.060638170689344406, -0.05956661328673363, 0.012048307806253433, 0.020663363859057426, -0.004119114484637976, -0.03310674428939819, 0.03866278752684593, 0.051156528294086456, -0.012052073143422604, 0.02544623799622059, -0.11564074456691742, -0.029439609497785568, 0.03392918035387993, -0.14322197437286377, 0.01902852952480316, -0.033499494194984436, 0.021730953827500343, -0.0051474724896252155, -0.01815570704638958, 0.028767641633749008, 0.01430300809442997, -0.04558466747403145, 0.042939718812704086, 0.03337923064827919, 0.013828439638018608, 0.056575365364551544, 0.02870059572160244, 0.022718999534845352, -0.024970177561044693, 0.04002213850617409, -0.016574304550886154, -0.01690412126481533, -0.06670333445072174, -0.040981389582157135, -0.0072648972272872925, 0.0017696672584861517, -0.029341964051127434, 0.018772350624203682, -0.04684537649154663, 0.05308998376131058, 0.03304265812039375, -0.06870416551828384, 0.03568338602781296, -0.018939681351184845, -0.07296264171600342, 0.02394929528236389, -0.05584898218512535, 0.024824298918247223, -0.06918459385633469, 0.018590902909636497, -0.014526153914630413, 0.10194011777639389, -0.02522602304816246, 0.041538141667842865, -0.023301446810364723, 0.01821126416325569, -0.05522264540195465, 0.02715361677110195, -0.0925837829709053, -0.013535133562982082, 0.06099948287010193, -0.043200261890888214, 0.08055005967617035, 0.06331903487443924, 0.05684097483754158, 0.12193325906991959, -0.020662307739257812, 0.05007864162325859, 0.018314920365810394, -0.009053593501448631, -0.041142821311950684, 0.025772197172045708, -0.0022783454041928053, 0.015300218015909195, -0.025019992142915726, 0.012197881005704403, 0.04001738876104355, 0.033767689019441605, 0.032893404364585876, 0.019451109692454338, -0.015036381781101227, 0.044726017862558365, 0.00045730540296062827, 0.0024481602013111115, 0.026774395257234573, 0.039994094520807266, -0.021977320313453674, -0.019918711856007576, 0.04211035743355751, 0.030558478087186813, 0.005609139800071716, 0.015514240600168705, -0.03567177429795265, -0.002163419034332037, 0.06287312507629395, -0.08995339274406433, -0.02573847584426403, 0.00008668623922858387, -0.002197612076997757, -0.051886335015296936, -0.016461452469229698, 0.004664876498281956, -0.043206457048654556, 0.06271392852067947, 0.05160319432616234, 0.0009522030013613403, 0.032236531376838684, 0.008788315579295158, -0.0256417915225029, 0.07481109350919724, 0.07377567142248154, -0.01871306076645851, 0.03221313655376434, -0.08303669095039368, -0.004149508196860552, -0.04763054475188255, -0.01135068479925394, -0.026138944551348686, -0.039728712290525436, -0.06779314577579498, -0.07586297392845154, -0.0727473571896553, -0.04364330321550369, -0.010926253162324429, 0.017829377204179764, 0.059589873999357224, 0.001194111304357648, 0.04817505180835724, 0.01792122609913349, -0.01687191054224968, -0.07159159332513809, -0.09986680746078491, 0.02344488352537155, 0.03851975500583649, 0.04538591206073761, 0.043511565774679184, -0.013098807074129581, -0.018391907215118408, -0.033769845962524414, 0.0004907318507321179, -0.04253267124295235, -0.020036255940794945, -0.06110219284892082, 0.004235174041241407, 0.06187383458018303, 0.04969135299324989, 0.06506825983524323, -0.00948433019220829, -0.0003816710377577692, -0.004728488624095917, -0.044704634696245193, 0.06308185309171677, 0.0861193835735321, 0.022012747824192047, 0.03482968732714653, -0.04266897588968277, 0.04134628176689148, 0.059730347245931625, 0.05991789698600769, 0.031825415790081024, 0.08021658658981323, -0.025324661284685135, 0.05519615113735199, -0.015074040740728378, -0.004830550868064165, 0.0030843038111925125, 0.05651337653398514, 0.0019414317794144154, -0.06169837340712547, 0.0030140765011310577, 0.03526940569281578, 0.0009907283820211887, 0.014104682020843029, 0.019862256944179535, -0.0127449631690979, 0.0038759566377848387, 0.05696234852075577, -0.023393427953124046, -0.006173497997224331, -0.011878876015543938, -0.016889039427042007, 0.003524104366078973, -0.06395970284938812, -0.022656314074993134, -0.03338427469134331, 0.05611855536699295, 0.06918463855981827, 0.03336946293711662, -0.06434642523527145, 0.015392015688121319, 0.06337802112102509, 0.0002543640439398587, -0.007386863697320223, 0.032186076045036316, 0.05524517223238945, -0.07947039604187012, -0.05397043749690056, -0.0537920705974102, 0.03178778290748596, 0.019419152289628983, -0.001401076908223331, -0.004996141418814659, -0.019156038761138916, 0.06876356899738312, -0.07041836529970169, -0.061873335391283035, 0.05844499543309212, 0.03099619597196579, 0.03696870431303978, -0.023431653156876564, -0.02374982088804245, 0.030355319380760193, -0.002157562179490924, -0.006744988262653351, -0.08783556520938873, 0.024215690791606903, -0.03813449665904045, 0.03351879119873047, 0.03421138972043991, -0.026615161448717117, 0.03632596880197525, 0.012353011406958103, 0.04753856733441353, -0.005283174104988575, 0.07814063876867294, -0.024283260107040405, 0.015240647830069065, 0.021461961790919304, -0.06413819640874863, -0.06235283613204956 ]
43
43
Fast Selection of Spectral Variables with B-Spline Compression
The large number of spectral variables in most data sets encountered in spectral chemometrics often renders the prediction of a dependent variable uneasy. The number of variables hopefully can be reduced, by using either projection techniques or selection methods; the latter allow for the interpretation of the selected variables. Since the optimal approach of testing all possible subsets of variables with the prediction model is intractable, an incremental selection approach using a nonparametric statistics is a good option, as it avoids the computationally intensive use of the model itself. It has two drawbacks however: the number of groups of variables to test is still huge, and colinearities can make the results unstable. To overcome these limitations, this paper presents a method to select groups of spectral variables. It consists in a forward-backward procedure applied to the coefficients of a B-Spline representation of the spectra. The criterion used in the forward-backward procedure is the mutual information, allowing to find nonlinear dependencies between variables, on the contrary of the generally used correlation. The spline representation is used to get interpretability of the results, as groups of consecutive spectral variables will be selected. The experiments conducted on NIR spectra from fescue grass and diesel fuels show that the method provides clearly identified groups of selected variables, making interpretation easy, while keeping a low computational load. The prediction performances obtained using the selected coefficients are higher than those obtained by the same method applied directly to the original variables and similar to those obtained using traditional models, although using significantly less spectral variables.
[ 0.008439148776233196, -0.014272695407271385, -0.023969516158103943, 0.013102774508297443, 0.09497655928134918, 0.010780254378914833, -0.0071828425861895084, -0.02866050973534584, -0.06575850397348404, -0.08237691968679428, 0.04560496285557747, -0.008437142707407475, -0.05040643736720085, 0.010462310165166855, -0.03384116664528847, -0.03824066370725632, -0.002671595895662904, -0.06743951886892319, 0.056387122720479965, -0.04606480523943901, -0.017572039738297462, 0.04865078255534172, -0.021977994590997696, -0.039555471390485764, 0.01568089798092842, 0.019433490931987762, -0.017925765365362167, -0.030927041545510292, 0.028584295883774757, 0.014841215685009956, -0.04291917011141777, 0.012748884968459606, 0.010366753675043583, 0.005032870452851057, 0.027128517627716064, -0.04614110663533211, -0.017718873918056488, -0.003058449598029256, -0.04574500396847725, -0.04553975909948349, 0.003806518390774727, -0.06330329924821854, 0.029209163039922714, 0.004243645817041397, -0.005223855841904879, -0.007633608765900135, 0.056382011622190475, -0.07341845333576202, 0.013643682934343815, 0.039556294679641724, -0.0024476968683302402, 0.04237222671508789, -0.040878672152757645, 0.009679727256298065, -0.008572632446885109, 0.0077426377683877945, -0.024688081815838814, 0.019767338410019875, 0.06475134938955307, 0.039979077875614166, 0.013106937520205975, 0.08422860503196716, -0.0002879469539038837, 0.018949802964925766, -0.016014300286769867, -0.0559406578540802, -0.04355987161397934, -0.06649661064147949, -0.012482043355703354, -0.01707013137638569, -0.00621805340051651, -0.07926627993583679, -0.06106708198785782, -0.0061233327724039555, -0.051036469638347626, -0.005181825719773769, 0.037844233214855194, 0.016216136515140533, -0.0056737447157502174, 0.03786545619368553, -0.05305139347910881, 0.04985520616173744, 0.09175916016101837, 0.004979619290679693, -0.03486204519867897, -0.028040684759616852, 0.02488165721297264, 0.02613045834004879, -0.0014653366524726152, 0.059922121465206146, -0.010550451464951038, 0.028201688081026077, -0.015097229741513729, -0.009906564839184284, -0.03895442932844162, -0.030960598960518837, -0.04294837638735771, 0.012095507234334946, 0.005047462414950132, 0.036591678857803345, 0.014088070951402187, -0.09578711539506912, 0.07434438914060593, 0.044873081147670746, -0.05150448530912399, -0.011055320501327515, -0.054066963493824005, 0.02906792238354683, -0.05129759758710861, 0.017744028940796852, -0.001377663342282176, 0.008045516908168793, 0.05210976302623749, 0.02736416459083557, -0.04782596230506897, -0.030385056510567665, 0.05617763474583626, 0.07189085334539413, 0.08105908334255219, 0.01578533463180065, 0.006335401441901922, 0.0422198586165905, -0.12156569212675095, 0.0049710748717188835, 0.07436762750148773, 0.0017432122258469462, 0.09620918333530426, -0.05007430911064148, 0.044046320021152496, 0.05243402346968651, -0.057347629219293594, 0.06811196357011795, -0.03943146392703056, 0.05258316174149513, -0.044834401458501816, 0.008564372546970844, 0.058594245463609695, -0.035390980541706085, 0.019691267982125282, 0.01561758853495121, -0.041678838431835175, -0.07015745341777802, 0.04527575522661209, -0.02561599761247635, -0.0030742648523300886, 0.04706550016999245, 0.011475637555122375, 0.04753268137574196, -0.04859655350446701, 0.007719046901911497, -0.021498363465070724, -0.10834401845932007, 0.0009100217139348388, 0.0816376730799675, 0.04520172253251076, -0.035913094878196716, -0.020009243860840797, -0.03274359181523323, 0.001153747783973813, 0.021273748949170113, 0.007120863534510136, -0.08043977618217468, 0.05501380190253258, 0.06126701459288597, -0.021052217110991478, 0.03511456772685051, -0.061715174466371536, 0.027748186141252518, -0.014544820412993431, -0.05350867286324501, -0.011731893755495548, 0.0070103844627738, -0.027474423870444298, -0.006667259614914656, 0.028027070686221123, 0.01729511469602585, 0.01693568378686905, -0.003642873838543892, -0.04079500958323479, -0.031542956829071045, 0.026743829250335693, -0.05398602411150932, -0.05119713395833969, 0.061068128794431686, 0.04067710414528847, 0.060691580176353455, -0.0383182018995285, 0.044091273099184036, 0.035489752888679504, 0.02232391946017742, 0.0698428750038147, 0.08301223069429398, -0.009775852784514427, -0.0025551856961101294, -0.05215505138039589, 0.026757389307022095, 0.07632225006818771, 0.0017406080150976777, 0.060282912105321884, 0.06101018935441971, 0.05550234764814377, 0.027480535209178925, -0.030435798689723015, -0.0016338765854015946, -0.01103896927088499, 0.01843518204987049, 0.00781654566526413, -0.030927810817956924, 0.05103423073887825, -0.03633946552872658, 0.007070255000144243, 0.02608872577548027, -0.04068153351545334, 0.014755606651306152, 0.022740287706255913, -0.04688958823680878, -0.053668003529310226, -0.06615006923675537, 0.08158206939697266, 0.04918839409947395, -0.03183022886514664, 0.026746490970253944, 0.0029283780604600906, -0.014203912578523159, -0.13277173042297363, 0.048692718148231506, -0.02725970931351185, -0.0556812658905983, -0.1133817657828331, 0.06979958713054657, 0.03676712140440941, -0.10532356798648834, -0.03614810109138489, -0.01246322225779295, 0.036307428032159805, -0.007939117960631847, -0.005595705006271601, -0.028710070997476578, 0.006588986609131098, -0.030407464131712914, 0.00400098692625761, 0.02311009168624878, 0.007065382786095142, -0.017743311822414398, -0.011956080794334412, -0.01752946712076664, 0.009207174181938171, 0.09722495824098587, 0.0044166091829538345, 0.05591053143143654, 0.014910245314240456, -0.058465082198381424, -0.1073598563671112, 0.06198151409626007, 0.04599911719560623, 0.05722144618630409, -0.04057265445590019, 0.000838782696519047, 0.027931436896324158, 0.020300155505537987, 0.0016479295445606112, -0.010911379009485245, -0.07005234807729721, -0.012239143252372742, 0.049801766872406006, -0.06986338645219803, -0.005902410019189119, -0.04469483718276024, -0.028777606785297394, 0.025676345452666283, 0.003658156143501401, -0.014397988095879555, -0.051609717309474945, -0.003586122766137123, -0.0171649307012558, -0.027235671877861023, 0.1307491660118103, 0.06739631295204163, 0.04090634733438492, -0.04016514867544174, -0.04126625880599022, -0.030359553173184395, 0.023811236023902893, 0.010152253322303295, 0.006041554268449545, 0.025580881163477898, -0.01314447820186615, -0.063473179936409, -0.012119580060243607, 0.003547447733581066, -0.059237513691186905, 0.05936049297451973, -0.08331599831581116, 0.06112879142165184, 0.012126104906201363, -0.05626553297042847, -0.011057031340897083, 0.0750642642378807, 0.05799552798271179, -0.014807679690420628, 0.04978945851325989, 0.051798608154058456, -0.0032028264831751585, -0.010766747407615185, 0.10134582966566086, 0.08361103385686874, 0.12377256155014038, 0.05166329815983772, -0.005258218385279179, -0.04499231278896332, -0.006445998791605234, -0.027479130774736404, -0.012173304334282875, -0.04592660441994667, -0.04699380323290825, -0.03662862628698349, -0.007640515919774771, -0.04911953955888748, 0.016942016780376434, -0.029932904988527298, 0.00028896689764223993, 0.08418150246143341, 0.06786379218101501, -0.0736810564994812, -0.031918175518512726, 0.0368017703294754, -0.02233186736702919, 0.08422261476516724, -0.09970729053020477, -0.023137668147683144, -0.03191428259015083, -0.015554248355329037, -0.02713051252067089, 0.10775298625230789, 0.006680716294795275, -0.009111030958592892, -0.06425467133522034, 0.03880269452929497, 0.012981947511434555, 0.010178019292652607, -0.009321634657680988, -0.02656697854399681, -0.021162124350667, -0.05672556534409523, 0.027633458375930786, 0.03417549654841423, 0.08085524290800095, -0.04308796301484108, 0.0003319617244414985, 0.020085882395505905, -0.04199370741844177, -0.028439465910196304, -0.05328025296330452, 0.03138387203216553, -0.09109166264533997, 0.0832539051771164, 0.06456547975540161, 0.060152847319841385, 0.031922630965709686, 0.07934699207544327, -0.024213694036006927, 0.017169799655675888, -0.004465610720217228, 0.05667320638895035, -0.005482655484229326, 0.03832392767071724, -0.022168725728988647, -0.000503272283822298, -0.02580903097987175, 0.06112783029675484, 0.0018703499808907509, 0.014096305705606937, 0.017395390197634697, 0.04439398646354675, -0.019300278276205063, -0.016127925366163254, -0.032808125019073486, -0.03612805902957916, -0.04750755429267883, 0.028674636036157608, -0.05943615734577179, -0.0010289658093824983, -0.07395169138908386, -0.012136131525039673, -0.004473219159990549, -0.032050538808107376, -0.06815705448389053, 0.004061148967593908, -0.10925331711769104, 0.029229803010821342, -0.049768876284360886, 0.004773707594722509, -0.009359757415950298, -0.01854586787521839, 0.03579965606331825, 0.07877466827630997, 0.012225784361362457, -0.04379864037036896, 0.007205435074865818, 0.000990708009339869, 0.04593050852417946, 0.044176388531923294, -0.04350729659199715, -0.08728158473968506, -0.04178676754236221, 0.027005374431610107, 0.03250430151820183, 0.04311799257993698, -0.04029494896531105, 0.034854013472795486, 0.04233128949999809, 0.016978492960333824, 0.02498374879360199, -0.026180217042565346, 0.002856400329619646, 0.015303008258342743, -0.034357909113168716, 0.03629138693213463, -0.020243527367711067, -0.004953906871378422, 0.0010353127727285028, 0.012530745938420296, -0.07313872128725052, 0.04746256396174431, -0.006189324893057346, -0.007067507598549128, 0.0679638460278511, 0.030586296692490578, -0.06741606444120407, 0.053584810346364975, -0.05117266997694969, -0.02799365296959877, -0.00860472023487091, 0.05340766906738281, 0.04062633961439133, -0.005677389912307262, -0.006191662512719631, -0.046890802681446075, 0.033420585095882416, -0.038040705025196075, -0.0127381831407547, 0.030729318037629128, -0.026070311665534973, -0.026186618953943253, 0.060746464878320694, 0.010209177620708942, 0.0036985278129577637, -0.011895021423697472, 0.02196693792939186, 0.0018898195121437311, -0.060992009937763214, -0.01839226298034191, 0.00445301691070199, 0.0589156411588192, -0.0033358235377818346, 0.022798072546720505, -0.02731253206729889, -0.0756450816988945, 0.05094102397561073, -0.051870591938495636, 0.003245991887524724, -0.05672188848257065, -0.027577700093388557, 0.024802513420581818, -0.04806653782725334, 0.0489187091588974, 0.009198839776217937, 0.05203327536582947, -0.012508004903793335, -0.031364165246486664, -0.06565739959478378, 0.05752672255039215, -0.05031656473875046, 0.009552812203764915, -0.022105159237980843, 0.042508941143751144, 0.025779392570257187, -0.02191074565052986, -0.0557403489947319, -0.013217615894973278, 0.0871133804321289, -0.026392050087451935, 0.01974106766283512, 0.057557590305805206, 0.1061280220746994, 0.09591599553823471, 0.0032288634683936834, 0.016141965985298157, 0.05063481256365776, -0.008061126805841923, 0.017410820350050926, -0.031100405380129814, -0.07004072517156601, -0.02550860121846199, -0.009880881756544113, -0.009700404480099678, -0.025799477472901344, -0.0189182348549366, 0.06218582019209862, 0.013344605453312397, -0.03703848272562027, -0.0700656846165657, 0.04224244877696037, -0.012297463603317738, 0.06720495969057083, -0.02163192257285118, 0.08284775912761688, -0.0037927115336060524, -0.03182048723101616, 0.03695329278707504, 0.000668266206048429, -0.07170959562063217 ]
44
44
Resampling methods for parameter-free and robust feature selection with mutual information
Combining the mutual information criterion with a forward feature selection strategy offers a good trade-off between optimality of the selected feature subset and computation time. However, it requires to set the parameter(s) of the mutual information estimator and to determine when to halt the forward procedure. These two choices are difficult to make because, as the dimensionality of the subset increases, the estimation of the mutual information becomes less and less reliable. This paper proposes to use resampling methods, a K-fold cross-validation and the permutation test, to address both issues. The resampling methods bring information about the variance of the estimator, information which can then be used to automatically set the parameter and to calculate a threshold to stop the forward procedure. The procedure is illustrated on a synthetic dataset as well as on real-world examples.
[ 0.06461036205291748, -0.058123283088207245, 0.05425918474793434, -0.0077053760178387165, -0.015777789056301117, -0.04584166035056114, 0.013540515676140785, -0.002951685804873705, -0.08898790925741196, 0.005716925021260977, 0.017032118514180183, -0.031056569889187813, -0.014378353022038937, -0.030667835846543312, -0.054230403155088425, 0.017201589420437813, 0.013592397794127464, -0.018940947949886322, 0.035273704677820206, -0.07835981994867325, -0.022450992837548256, -0.008245120756328106, 0.0636470764875412, 0.004572735633701086, 0.030748724937438965, 0.05135444924235344, -0.021595729514956474, -0.05252267047762871, -0.09448027610778809, 0.07127683609724045, -0.06967053562402725, -0.04716482385993004, 0.02336607500910759, -0.04561659321188927, -0.01106798555701971, -0.049173809587955475, 0.02273106575012207, 0.02633184939622879, 0.0016434264834970236, -0.049237512052059174, 0.01825459860265255, -0.041477154940366745, -0.014676439575850964, 0.0027775855269283056, -0.005092903506010771, 0.025119125843048096, 0.04718215391039848, 0.02163122594356537, -0.025121981278061867, 0.028381984680891037, -0.030706433579325676, 0.039834585040807724, 0.03362103924155235, 0.0003659302310552448, 0.026146911084651947, 0.038399044424295425, -0.04735662415623665, 0.021227532997727394, 0.06497042626142502, 0.002470462815836072, 0.04651383310556412, 0.11045850813388824, 0.005653054919093847, 0.025456780567765236, -0.044953055679798126, 0.0007514178869314492, -0.08237527310848236, -0.06751805543899536, -0.07179271429777145, -0.06766775995492935, -0.0015497043495997787, 0.0018029846251010895, -0.06320465356111526, 0.044524215161800385, 0.006591759156435728, 0.000051735889428528026, -0.02944597601890564, 0.0073648183606565, 0.05793994292616844, 0.06195336952805519, -0.051947221159935, 0.04757120460271835, 0.019368723034858704, 0.023541990667581558, -0.052418217062950134, -0.02725382335484028, 0.017596550285816193, 0.02351289987564087, 0.050174739211797714, 0.029371608048677444, -0.035211946815252304, 0.011189866811037064, -0.07358665019273758, 0.02493353933095932, -0.006079384125769138, -0.017681898549199104, -0.0666152685880661, 0.005640787538141012, 0.07177364081144333, -0.0007617471273988485, -0.0359342023730278, -0.010697386227548122, 0.07572568953037262, 0.018548283725976944, -0.055319055914878845, 0.01842750608921051, -0.06576452404260635, 0.03856612741947174, -0.02002931572496891, -0.02811869978904724, -0.025779755786061287, -0.09880901128053665, 0.010080990381538868, 0.014491843059659004, -0.09386501461267471, 0.02354147657752037, -0.044801853597164154, -0.018977699801325798, -0.03872331604361534, -0.024706730619072914, 0.01292205136269331, 0.04987943544983864, -0.010093157179653645, -0.02513928711414337, 0.039847128093242645, -0.05183406174182892, 0.021552620455622673, -0.10303547978401184, 0.15628139674663544, 0.04958534240722656, -0.09497303515672684, 0.06843939423561096, -0.01211459469050169, -0.004594804719090462, -0.04177217185497284, 0.03643760457634926, 0.04013887792825699, 0.07916268706321716, 0.029979676008224487, 0.03300642967224121, -0.021650411188602448, -0.0011686364887282252, -0.037456583231687546, -0.00022482927306555212, -0.027746954932808876, 0.011510436423122883, -0.0018856067908927798, 0.014785009436309338, -0.10568447411060333, -0.005750330165028572, 0.0071289935149252415, -0.050797268748283386, 0.023648468777537346, 0.044075220823287964, 0.03745971992611885, -0.053605735301971436, 0.03855864703655243, -0.036884479224681854, -0.002920790808275342, 0.0642290711402893, 0.0035247753839939833, 0.041622862219810486, 0.004466240294277668, 0.005359156988561153, 0.005374724045395851, 0.042147643864154816, -0.029664531350135803, -0.037967532873153687, -0.021262696012854576, -0.024550464004278183, -0.008136223070323467, 0.020706571638584137, -0.04356659948825836, -0.015892058610916138, 0.044328782707452774, 0.02044985070824623, -0.030533086508512497, 0.05860039219260216, -0.026644155383110046, 0.05086023733019829, -0.008244659751653671, -0.0382392480969429, -0.037843331694602966, -0.016770675778388977, 0.03596813976764679, 0.051166851073503494, 0.011543805710971355, 0.0005349977291189134, 0.057151999324560165, 0.02092093601822853, 0.05340444669127464, 0.01417151652276516, -0.013519038446247578, -0.05265868455171585, -0.01763262413442135, 0.08290234953165054, -0.033562254160642624, -0.028230808675289154, 0.04097384586930275, 0.07469427585601807, 0.06005758047103882, -0.04263097420334816, 0.05159376189112663, -0.03134666010737419, -0.031029248610138893, -0.01756061241030693, 0.02506563626229763, -0.06115442514419556, 0.07798152416944504, -0.06284511089324951, 0.009523778222501278, -0.03212294727563858, 0.01902601681649685, -0.05109620839357376, 0.054893698543310165, -0.021447695791721344, -0.04980450123548508, -0.011645329184830189, 0.03329368680715561, 0.045867301523685455, -0.07315206527709961, 0.008305912837386131, -0.06145436316728592, 0.09360489994287491, -0.05983811244368553, 0.03234434127807617, 0.03991564363241196, 0.012007292360067368, -0.0964951291680336, 0.011057958006858826, 0.04494575411081314, -0.06671588122844696, -0.02602047473192215, -0.06108741834759712, -0.04944687709212303, 0.000900543644092977, -0.057568784803152084, -0.05358424782752991, 0.01223441306501627, 0.013759354129433632, -0.00985096488147974, 0.04385080933570862, -0.027777880430221558, -0.024773206561803818, -0.024211548268795013, -0.01578548550605774, 0.06229304522275925, 0.05503133311867714, -0.009206878952682018, -0.0443614237010479, 0.030048038810491562, 0.007277356460690498, 0.02067214623093605, -0.004450180102139711, -0.022654052823781967, 0.010946711525321007, 0.024697277694940567, 0.03636673465371132, 0.0627807229757309, 0.0649632140994072, 0.05412212014198303, 0.034823838621377945, -0.02958516590297222, -0.07797273248434067, 0.08933448791503906, -0.06580353528261185, 0.020777875557541847, 0.052763182669878006, -0.06336051225662231, 0.08272969722747803, -0.0967407301068306, -0.06144934520125389, -0.0561160184442997, 0.09688568115234375, -0.0007974408799782395, -0.016831934452056885, 0.06276873499155045, 0.06344015896320343, 0.06193988770246506, -0.028976162895560265, 0.028765222057700157, 0.04231000691652298, 0.01531373430043459, 0.07158111780881882, -0.037838827818632126, 0.05876351147890091, -0.047189872711896896, -0.015361152589321136, -0.017164381220936775, 0.0005218228907324374, -0.060211002826690674, 0.08788833022117615, -0.07361731678247452, 0.0088108005002141, 0.029244311153888702, -0.014280946925282478, 0.03552054613828659, 0.07244069874286652, 0.030614430084824562, -0.006018363405019045, 0.054915688931941986, 0.020671047270298004, 0.055501654744148254, 0.042944636195898056, 0.07374824583530426, 0.04376738891005516, 0.1183699518442154, 0.0014528777683153749, -0.07517341524362564, -0.021223578602075577, 0.027206046506762505, -0.03829289227724075, -0.03684981167316437, -0.06851616501808167, -0.0008954044315032661, -0.05356030538678169, -0.023144036531448364, 0.059536345303058624, -0.02034010924398899, -0.017435632646083832, 0.024293730035424232, 0.03647465631365776, 0.03032097965478897, -0.05731077119708061, -0.029654374346137047, -0.02342376299202442, -0.016414016485214233, -0.014596735127270222, -0.04834785312414169, -0.014659385196864605, -0.04578616842627525, -0.007245558779686689, -0.01327278558164835, 0.10053275525569916, -0.016199352219700813, -0.046046849340200424, -0.06809995323419571, -0.0038709621876478195, 0.004703869577497244, -0.029076915234327316, -0.06219063326716423, -0.051120832562446594, -0.004078014753758907, -0.026196200400590897, -0.025866376236081123, 0.07123350352048874, 0.10110025852918625, -0.03002932295203209, 0.02928176149725914, -0.0040476140566170216, 0.011301303282380104, 0.03315583989024162, -0.01812230609357357, -0.018358830362558365, -0.03122667782008648, 0.10878880321979523, 0.03929147869348526, -0.009948601014912128, 0.05556167662143707, 0.02738795056939125, 0.0014573745429515839, 0.023867996409535408, -0.04117145761847496, 0.10066553205251694, 0.003214363008737564, -0.01763303205370903, -0.034884221851825714, 0.0015834439545869827, -0.04069697484374046, 0.033570095896720886, 0.04042439162731171, 0.03802579641342163, 0.09632861614227295, 0.023008372634649277, 0.006523326504975557, -0.0655854269862175, 0.02730834111571312, 0.014270731247961521, -0.047379378229379654, 0.0689108818769455, -0.0542847104370594, -0.03785811364650726, 0.01573072373867035, -0.018678156659007072, -0.024218056350946426, -0.03268822282552719, -0.03485900163650513, 0.05733279138803482, 0.010097699239850044, 0.01599368453025818, -0.06647077947854996, -0.03546464070677757, -0.04471239820122719, -0.0036040451377630234, 0.03425605222582817, 0.07924383878707886, -0.000938820478040725, -0.04145196080207825, -0.03768043965101242, -0.046816386282444, 0.029942361637949944, 0.0023045239504426718, -0.003662001807242632, -0.08438622206449509, -0.08869586139917374, 0.014901550486683846, -0.04771744832396507, 0.05342698469758034, -0.041120972484350204, 0.005689137615263462, -0.009698273614048958, -0.036369744688272476, 0.0028923095669597387, -0.005693571642041206, -0.005289419088512659, 0.03753199800848961, -0.017979230731725693, 0.01388399489223957, -0.04447248950600624, -0.04037272185087204, -0.02820349857211113, 0.006714974995702505, 0.008711086586117744, -0.03895214572548866, -0.012082276865839958, 0.051477186381816864, -0.0017211035592481494, -0.0019630955066531897, 0.006645774934440851, 0.021665019914507866, -0.06624665856361389, -0.015173684805631638, -0.008477814495563507, 0.003983460832387209, 0.05480010434985161, 0.003422534791752696, 0.05899910628795624, 0.018214041367173195, 0.04967090114951134, -0.03588200733065605, -0.05175833776593208, -0.0009134679567068815, -0.008284932002425194, 0.03563550487160683, -0.06309841573238373, 0.007940561510622501, 0.020420532673597336, 0.021276213228702545, 0.044670697301626205, 0.05116197094321251, -0.0590520016849041, -0.025473807007074356, 0.04546664282679558, -0.024320321157574654, 0.022953107953071594, 0.029287146404385567, 0.02349785342812538, -0.02534099668264389, 0.05367564037442207, 0.03161456063389778, -0.041947249323129654, -0.06574511528015137, 0.04129061475396156, 0.0663737803697586, -0.11935395747423172, 0.04763038083910942, 0.00858328863978386, 0.03171176090836525, 0.09521694481372833, 0.005150653887540102, -0.025559939444065094, -0.0137272784486413, -0.04822622984647751, -0.014655757695436478, 0.060549430549144745, -0.007993746548891068, 0.030278945341706276, -0.01808224432170391, -0.03732265159487724, -0.05733723193407059, 0.03219833970069885, -0.03072017803788185, -0.02160204015672207, 0.002352427924051881, 0.07251345366239548, 0.022783106192946434, -0.023913508281111717, 0.0046156723983585835, 0.041215963661670685, 0.030136629939079285, -0.01702430285513401, -0.03333975002169609, -0.060117315500974655, 0.029448894783854485, 0.018216829746961594, 0.03073110245168209, -0.009514492005109787, 0.004386271350085735, 0.12715090811252594, 0.08053887635469437, 0.012019746005535126, -0.030138147994875908, -0.03110705502331257, -0.0282831322401762, 0.08917875587940216, 0.0044717020355165005, 0.024704428389668465, 0.017506171017885208, 0.014655811712145805, 0.05196070298552513, -0.01974422112107277, 0.022122681140899658 ]
45
45
Evolving Classifiers: Methods for Incremental Learning
The ability of a classifier to take on new information and classes by evolving the classifier without it having to be fully retrained is known as incremental learning. Incremental learning has been successfully applied to many classification problems, where the data is changing and is not all available at once. In this paper there is a comparison between Learn++, which is one of the most recent incremental learning algorithms, and the new proposed method of Incremental Learning Using Genetic Algorithm (ILUGA). Learn++ has shown good incremental learning capabilities on benchmark datasets on which the new ILUGA method has been tested. ILUGA has also shown good incremental learning ability using only a few classifiers and does not suffer from catastrophic forgetting. The results obtained for ILUGA on the Optical Character Recognition (OCR) and Wine datasets are good, with an overall accuracy of 93% and 94% respectively showing a 4% improvement over Learn++.MT for the difficult multi-class OCR dataset.
[ -0.07459166646003723, -0.1038789302110672, 0.033514354377985, -0.015010278671979904, 0.05498713254928589, -0.021459752693772316, -0.0030490567442029715, 0.05740581080317497, -0.061938319355249405, -0.0192301906645298, -0.050408054143190384, 0.0033070221543312073, -0.03678496554493904, 0.07190665602684021, 0.044662512838840485, 0.007568891625851393, 0.026391055434942245, -0.03272606059908867, 0.011924625374376774, -0.08766993135213852, 0.029154116287827492, -0.07660048454999924, 0.00845776591449976, -0.043092887848615646, -0.024620363488793373, -0.0069122714921832085, -0.036256998777389526, 0.008333615027368069, -0.0375654436647892, 0.05507594347000122, 0.01620202139019966, -0.04401547089219093, 0.02013184316456318, 0.03279668465256691, 0.02342500537633896, 0.0897926315665245, 0.019945887848734856, -0.0061073084361851215, -0.08770035207271576, 0.02876434475183487, -0.017077868804335594, -0.02977498434484005, 0.005031358450651169, 0.021272705867886543, 0.01856342703104019, 0.024297093972563744, 0.028209391981363297, -0.09618186950683594, -0.08076034486293793, 0.07620978355407715, -0.053890787065029144, -0.02360481210052967, -0.01719587855041027, 0.009553850628435612, 0.016665782779455185, 0.02728663757443428, -0.013406932353973389, -0.003303384641185403, -0.04915185272693634, -0.012098091654479504, 0.005692210979759693, 0.10411013662815094, 0.03993061184883118, -0.0038136537186801434, -0.03091009333729744, 0.004175152163952589, -0.016283001750707626, -0.019352411851286888, -0.028912298381328583, -0.025679130107164383, -0.013413620181381702, -0.060741543769836426, 0.05454394593834877, -0.012961959466338158, 0.02570505253970623, 0.03361792862415314, -0.0066048260778188705, 0.02064618282020092, -0.003986628260463476, 0.004691694863140583, 0.031341303139925, -0.06082600727677345, -0.0323420986533165, -0.04097943753004074, 0.007979299873113632, 0.009908122010529041, 0.017431067302823067, 0.05616099759936333, 0.03530403599143028, -0.01709592156112194, -0.020000526681542397, -0.046184517443180084, -0.04800790920853615, 0.03146931156516075, -0.06393015384674072, -0.0027599006425589323, -0.030533792451024055, -0.08714565634727478, 0.046975281089544296, 0.02260696329176426, -0.003110539400950074, -0.009580911137163639, 0.00248916819691658, 0.02165706641972065, -0.000199255533516407, 0.0017635308904573321, -0.06868568062782288, 0.004974414128810167, 0.07279004156589508, 0.007721944246441126, 0.020980874076485634, 0.04649925231933594, 0.008043943904340267, 0.02450878731906414, -0.008591821417212486, -0.015426421537995338, -0.0237696785479784, 0.036267951130867004, 0.05255638808012009, -0.04561043903231621, 0.03947482630610466, -0.005727051291614771, -0.07075831294059753, 0.056582096964120865, 0.05918839946389198, 0.000741595053113997, -0.07467976957559586, -0.07121694087982178, 0.10410936176776886, -0.009532229974865913, -0.022174905985593796, 0.06735212355852127, -0.000366732245311141, -0.009283771738409996, -0.03142034262418747, 0.0019041539635509253, -0.019155610352754593, -0.02346820943057537, -0.016558989882469177, 0.01772898994386196, 0.02544742077589035, -0.02451978251338005, 0.04650318995118141, 0.057637687772512436, -0.04301605001091957, 0.017147745937108994, -0.03297020122408867, 0.02711103856563568, 0.03509848564863205, 0.05930017679929733, -0.033019889146089554, -0.009660393930971622, -0.01093331165611744, 0.0876234844326973, 0.009687424637377262, -0.03729013353586197, -0.02019554004073143, -0.006487468723207712, 0.0376434363424778, 0.004276653286069632, 0.012757196091115475, 0.015638308599591255, -0.017479492351412773, -0.003888104809448123, 0.012340663000941277, 0.00844502728432417, -0.0025992351584136486, -0.04714294523000717, -0.046077288687229156, -0.02409384585916996, 0.0414486825466156, 0.051154397428035736, -0.0016493498114868999, 0.10316569358110428, 0.040183987468481064, -0.011119965463876724, 0.002213933039456606, -0.008467821404337883, 0.008014174178242683, 0.0055889529176056385, 0.0907924473285675, -0.060959912836551666, -0.03744850680232048, 0.008524239994585514, 0.046209584921598434, 0.10799381136894226, 0.012749350629746914, 0.07079923152923584, 0.024993782863020897, 0.013378774747252464, -0.03371231630444527, 0.030730606988072395, 0.04467270150780678, -0.0011499813990667462, -0.1126730740070343, 0.1301412731409073, -0.04582146555185318, -0.0725226029753685, -0.03119654953479767, 0.032677825540304184, 0.02543431892991066, -0.03233634680509567, 0.03684625402092934, -0.012648974545300007, -0.05231757089495659, 0.036707501858472824, 0.05646928399801254, -0.05696936324238777, -0.0279903132468462, -0.009855898097157478, 0.0008765141828916967, 0.06008429080247879, 0.015121765434741974, -0.0037949723191559315, -0.062048133462667465, -0.06913845986127853, -0.10949500650167465, -0.029898429289460182, 0.05877776816487312, 0.08091147243976593, -0.033689334988594055, -0.024243099614977837, 0.03556693717837334, 0.058562472462654114, -0.007983457297086716, 0.05753432586789131, 0.022601012140512466, 0.062000617384910583, -0.03317635878920555, 0.0742836520075798, -0.029102377593517303, -0.0913952961564064, -0.06251133978366852, -0.06760073453187943, -0.0015803782735019922, 0.01601761020720005, -0.05090813711285591, -0.007395549211651087, 0.000557818915694952, 0.014921051450073719, 0.010870157741010189, 0.04611540213227272, 0.005199709441512823, -0.08625166863203049, 0.06190315634012222, 0.00934763252735138, 0.04487452656030655, 0.05329926311969757, -0.0758831724524498, -0.047660794109106064, 0.050934575498104095, 0.031520552933216095, -0.029149549081921577, 0.010107380338013172, 0.010870764032006264, 0.022714467719197273, -0.05149601027369499, 0.07121673226356506, 0.014025412499904633, 0.04512950778007507, -0.0003896952257491648, 0.005903367884457111, 0.00040806562174111605, -0.033971551805734634, 0.04473268985748291, 0.03289816156029701, -0.049861811101436615, -0.011119465343654156, 0.007731289602816105, 0.01827656477689743, 0.009446950629353523, -0.07692886888980865, 0.002838995074853301, 0.02489088475704193, -0.02375858835875988, 0.00944212730973959, 0.04387517273426056, -0.051635731011629105, 0.04167850315570831, -0.020535163581371307, -0.06424879282712936, 0.03354135528206825, 0.034659743309020996, -0.03841961547732353, 0.05551699548959732, 0.06222011521458626, -0.027459586039185524, -0.025545634329319, 0.029386984184384346, -0.03947826847434044, -0.02145344391465187, -0.010951721109449863, -0.0710252970457077, 0.011550473980605602, 0.012870712205767632, -0.05102500692009926, 0.028481289744377136, -0.06977623701095581, 0.0068650622852146626, 0.009854936972260475, 0.004725893959403038, 0.0008566566393710673, 0.04868118464946747, 0.06486765295267105, -0.020628780126571655, 0.04836678132414818, -0.05087440833449364, 0.13751259446144104, -0.12210758775472641, -0.00957764033228159, 0.06523288041353226, -0.019427886232733727, 0.0023034231271594763, -0.03380493447184563, 0.013729666359722614, 0.03180520609021187, 0.020762626081705093, 0.06608685851097107, -0.023007327690720558, -0.07153759896755219, 0.030823063105344772, -0.003652050159871578, 0.002700753277167678, 0.024539902806282043, -0.08983501046895981, -0.04645983874797821, -0.03181279078125954, 0.012911811470985413, -0.05966002121567726, 0.05575045198202133, -0.02140115201473236, -0.004417932592332363, 0.03155030310153961, 0.056684836745262146, -0.019819919019937515, 0.012136907316744328, 0.05302814021706581, 0.0566873624920845, -0.030359476804733276, -0.02897125855088234, -0.05966680869460106, -0.03452600538730621, 0.008727358654141426, -0.008712985552847385, -0.04126735404133797, -0.02041424624621868, 0.03980085626244545, -0.03857551887631416, 0.04260483756661415, 0.11272653192281723, -0.016247045248746872, -0.041843779385089874, -0.09549553692340851, 0.0108031639829278, -0.054595835506916046, 0.03991685062646866, 0.035525958985090256, 0.03505619987845421, 0.01647265814244747, 0.045422933995723724, 0.024759940803050995, 0.04072585329413414, -0.06907258927822113, -0.07971790432929993, -0.007505965419113636, 0.07344026118516922, 0.01726633682847023, 0.008094926364719868, 0.03617214038968086, -0.01574079506099224, 0.011394990608096123, 0.011811874806880951, -0.04202431067824364, 0.011104792356491089, 0.07088466733694077, -0.05895251780748367, 0.020618321374058723, -0.04007142782211304, -0.08956755697727203, 0.04443962499499321, -0.11309600621461868, 0.040922343730926514, 0.024208351969718933, -0.04419192299246788, 0.033659275621175766, -0.024133101105690002, -0.06415820121765137, 0.06129629909992218, 0.03809736669063568, 0.0020261858589947224, -0.01974763162434101, -0.0674811452627182, -0.0434378907084465, 0.06198985502123833, 0.07707992941141129, 0.04770796746015549, -0.028245415538549423, 0.001180078717879951, 0.006004395429044962, 0.0413285531103611, -0.03464265540242195, -0.019503306597471237, 0.034287504851818085, -0.036159224808216095, -0.08064471930265427, -0.023233484476804733, -0.010003210976719856, 0.10672096908092499, 0.055040694773197174, 0.022297358140349388, -0.025950372219085693, 0.04192638024687767, -0.059916120022535324, -0.04632009193301201, -0.01225242204964161, 0.07541590929031372, 0.016561556607484818, -0.00346342078410089, -0.004256747663021088, -0.1006721779704094, -0.019971614703536034, 0.020018182694911957, 0.02406900003552437, 0.03889536112546921, -0.02837558276951313, -0.01862080581486225, 0.04437539353966713, 0.0062288446351885796, -0.037756193429231644, 0.057583972811698914, -0.09299469739198685, 0.057117920368909836, -0.027842102572321892, -0.02911440096795559, 0.05057910084724426, -0.017229244112968445, 0.07152406126260757, 0.03262542188167572, -0.06963259726762772, 0.012964323163032532, -0.11287536472082138, 0.012316985055804253, 0.0010843389900401235, 0.03279951214790344, -0.03880615159869194, 0.03739330917596817, -0.01020046416670084, -0.0018474876414984465, 0.026803066954016685, 0.0054169269278645515, -0.008089587092399597, 0.014214329421520233, 0.002686479827389121, -0.01040496863424778, -0.03261508047580719, -0.0035519995726644993, -0.020529842004179955, -0.04542703554034233, 0.10336817800998688, -0.06414107978343964, -0.06798780709505081, 0.003180412109941244, -0.03462342917919159, -0.04091736674308777, 0.002661727136000991, -0.03467072173953056, 0.010164112783968449, -0.03544490784406662, 0.05736790597438812, -0.01123145129531622, -0.04990896210074425, -0.008563526906073093, 0.0053358981385827065, 0.01526708249002695, -0.007508506067097187, -0.017047753557562828, 0.005200025159865618, -0.11020766943693161, -0.0445888377726078, -0.039305392652750015, 0.028861381113529205, 0.042925748974084854, 0.004102496430277824, 0.0774376168847084, 0.06049919128417969, -0.04336300119757652, -0.007628167979419231, -0.0014896513894200325, 0.02581535279750824, 0.03572908416390419, 0.014252242632210255, 0.037785883992910385, 0.04161720350384712, 0.012476136907935143, -0.014993191696703434, 0.006880021654069424, 0.049926552921533585, -0.0038164628203958273, 0.01857372559607029, 0.057847537100315094, 0.11870789527893066, 0.016711708158254623, 0.0025897242594510317, -0.047130972146987915, 0.019125333055853844, 0.014251552522182465, 0.0626394972205162, 0.03777299076318741, -0.0013967716367915273, -0.006864848546683788, -0.06212697923183441, -0.020951898768544197 ]
46
46
Classification of Images Using Support Vector Machines
Support Vector Machines (SVMs) are a relatively new supervised classification technique to the land cover mapping community. They have their roots in Statistical Learning Theory and have gained prominence because they are robust, accurate and are effective even when using a small training sample. By their nature SVMs are essentially binary classifiers, however, they can be adopted to handle the multiple classification tasks common in remote sensing studies. The two approaches commonly used are the One-Against-One (1A1) and One-Against-All (1AA) techniques. In this paper, these approaches are evaluated in as far as their impact and implication for land cover mapping. The main finding from this research is that whereas the 1AA technique is more predisposed to yielding unclassified and mixed pixels, the resulting classification accuracy is not significantly different from 1A1 approach. It is the authors conclusions that ultimately the choice of technique adopted boils down to personal preference and the uniqueness of the dataset at hand.
[ 0.01891842857003212, -0.044548045843839645, -0.023684872314333916, 0.01650305651128292, 0.003652463899925351, -0.021937239915132523, -0.08118234574794769, 0.05672655627131462, -0.07250811904668808, 0.04552174732089043, 0.06093275174498558, 0.05167260393500328, -0.01733408123254776, 0.010659287683665752, 0.01548717450350523, 0.03851587325334549, 0.07196297496557236, -0.025466972962021828, 0.02149377577006817, -0.03246501088142395, -0.00739690475165844, 0.0302128829061985, -0.01925637014210224, -0.0375799685716629, 0.01869875006377697, -0.009837769903242588, 0.04089609533548355, 0.003044784301891923, -0.08232531696557999, 0.0508851483464241, -0.024109667167067528, -0.028735162690281868, 0.019556734710931778, 0.033651262521743774, -0.001272538211196661, -0.04320656135678291, 0.03601560369133949, -0.05673300847411156, -0.0818965956568718, 0.03374713286757469, -0.061840228736400604, 0.03224015235900879, 0.0037589832209050655, -0.05448088049888611, 0.03958573937416077, 0.06007993221282959, -0.003650503233075142, -0.019309712573885918, -0.014604523777961731, -0.011849071830511093, -0.028956424444913864, 0.0032071718014776707, -0.004525786265730858, 0.0206966083496809, 0.011259586550295353, -0.02372320182621479, -0.008530696853995323, -0.04395374283194542, 0.051909033209085464, -0.01893656700849533, 0.06694024801254272, 0.08789914101362228, 0.009378441609442234, -0.013555974699556828, -0.01007075421512127, -0.05462832748889923, -0.051907919347286224, -0.04787939041852951, 0.018687129020690918, -0.007713464088737965, -0.012762743979692459, -0.07176196575164795, 0.02509334310889244, 0.05725885555148125, 0.04317092522978783, 0.031191347166895866, 0.022519022226333618, 0.012780765071511269, 0.024250244721770287, 0.02223307266831398, -0.023664137348532677, -0.027028802782297134, 0.06871268153190613, -0.004125930834561586, 0.03260929882526398, 0.03483201563358307, -0.055287111550569534, -0.000854333455208689, 0.059534359723329544, 0.0798979327082634, 0.018039409071207047, -0.052742134779691696, -0.007405315525829792, -0.001670893863774836, -0.007859420962631702, 0.0026903999969363213, 0.0036242909263819456, -0.008254880085587502, 0.04394013434648514, 0.08792255073785782, -0.023994486778974533, 0.005243826657533646, 0.05990777164697647, 0.05243690684437752, -0.023819806054234505, 0.05277610942721367, 0.000038517169741680846, 0.02884918637573719, -0.011202468536794186, 0.04430560767650604, 0.033967796713113785, -0.03725368529558182, -0.01988251879811287, 0.049164798110723495, 0.013804873451590538, -0.024757912382483482, -0.1445353776216507, 0.07551644742488861, 0.07699868083000183, -0.03999246284365654, -0.0527547188103199, -0.025636842474341393, 0.026578573510050774, 0.04758096858859062, 0.022887734696269035, 0.008975516073405743, 0.01992090605199337, -0.03964800760149956, -0.003267499152570963, -0.0199070256203413, -0.10814063996076584, 0.0007294283132068813, -0.045643147081136703, 0.09684216976165771, -0.1027866080403328, -0.037443723529577255, -0.04319467023015022, -0.08291482925415039, 0.005399508401751518, 0.007027775049209595, 0.00912452396005392, -0.04363011568784714, -0.006398250814527273, 0.05673353374004364, 0.03599504753947258, 0.057340431958436966, 0.04617873579263687, 0.00788749661296606, 0.012249005027115345, -0.005005107261240482, -0.008359006606042385, -0.043814484030008316, 0.058797258883714676, 0.05500533804297447, 0.05809525027871132, -0.06080162897706032, -0.03748160973191261, -0.02659904956817627, 0.01914975792169571, 0.057246219366788864, 0.008547374978661537, 0.12289971858263016, 0.01927381381392479, 0.08581288903951645, 0.006323943845927715, 0.029646223410964012, 0.01336895115673542, 0.0005025098798796535, 0.018108109012246132, -0.07554581761360168, -0.0008698218152858317, 0.0332007072865963, -0.033969998359680176, -0.06634283065795898, 0.00814749114215374, 0.02271896041929722, -0.014044096693396568, 0.014031327329576015, -0.039607200771570206, 0.015898045152425766, -0.03469883278012276, -0.08262421935796738, -0.03881223872303963, 0.023522693663835526, 0.08643016219139099, 0.07402864098548889, -0.004365229047834873, 0.0032256038393825293, 0.06584352254867554, 0.007404202129691839, 0.03315969929099083, -0.026616808027029037, 0.02740206941962242, -0.09850943088531494, -0.03364880755543709, 0.01602761447429657, 0.021466409787535667, -0.032994333654642105, 0.015086007304489613, 0.021060192957520485, -0.05061378329992294, -0.04624241963028908, -0.0412273183465004, 0.025876354426145554, 0.004992570728063583, 0.03131178766489029, 0.028708945959806442, -0.014451433904469013, 0.041564907878637314, -0.030279112979769707, -0.0009165976662188768, 0.0074612535536289215, 0.014054445549845695, 0.027329154312610626, 0.0014329073019325733, -0.04472469910979271, 0.002720651915296912, -0.015996810048818588, 0.029490431770682335, -0.005235558841377497, -0.03806457668542862, 0.023639367893338203, -0.04001821205019951, 0.10206474363803864, -0.00010964884131681174, 0.03196599707007408, -0.03466051071882248, -0.043300479650497437, -0.007811791729182005, 0.08390174061059952, -0.08847694844007492, -0.08487650007009506, -0.09160437434911728, -0.03823032230138779, -0.027840053662657738, 0.05435124412178993, -0.05132712796330452, -0.0564035065472126, 0.09878270328044891, -0.03266843780875206, 0.07364339381456375, 0.024807071313261986, -0.04183423891663551, -0.004891266580671072, 0.06591710448265076, -0.05528144910931587, 0.026430338621139526, 0.04188445210456848, -0.005397265311330557, 0.016743570566177368, 0.018908245489001274, -0.0134422667324543, -0.008763383142650127, -0.04769230633974075, 0.011610561050474644, -0.011799982748925686, 0.005843005608767271, -0.04227115586400032, 0.025656597688794136, 0.05258260294795036, -0.008612072095274925, 0.043276697397232056, -0.019422583281993866, -0.012374252080917358, 0.023994093760848045, 0.06745544821023941, 0.03723954036831856, -0.06474503129720688, 0.029324060305953026, 0.02096906304359436, -0.024760916829109192, -0.05534029006958008, 0.01652955450117588, 0.022105753421783447, -0.017292216420173645, 0.02819686010479927, 0.06392597407102585, 0.02535882778465748, -0.02694433555006981, -0.022578947246074677, -0.020098138600587845, -0.03728007152676582, -0.047192446887493134, 0.0025379203725606203, -0.03609919920563698, -0.052807170897722244, -0.03859993815422058, -0.016518186777830124, 0.00799480453133583, -0.04104219004511833, 0.028341302648186684, 0.04703288525342941, -0.05935661494731903, 0.006810768507421017, 0.028590254485607147, -0.030940918251872063, -0.03774726018309593, -0.027557510882616043, 0.1185326799750328, -0.02882934920489788, 0.0369664803147316, 0.04588335379958153, 0.008280225098133087, -0.00006458396092057228, -0.0361759252846241, 0.03114030510187149, 0.05680106207728386, 0.06020346283912659, -0.08857358247041702, 0.0030809645541012287, -0.019152041524648666, 0.003890375141054392, -0.0906953290104866, -0.09666545689105988, -0.003047530073672533, -0.09044190496206284, 0.023454925045371056, 0.025756383314728737, -0.015149040147662163, 0.003680119989439845, 0.04582297056913376, 0.0023714741691946983, 0.021186700090765953, -0.01800357922911644, -0.027371900156140327, -0.007621678989380598, -0.028902387246489525, 0.022463465109467506, -0.06509759277105331, -0.013093467801809311, -0.03471674025058746, 0.01487461943179369, 0.03518551215529442, 0.07546474784612656, -0.0075665125623345375, -0.02022845856845379, 0.042379945516586304, 0.07782965898513794, -0.03834429383277893, -0.02476658672094345, -0.04707285016775131, 0.0650104358792305, 0.025664621964097023, 0.009364401921629906, -0.004856473300606012, -0.0017174558015540242, 0.09062958508729935, -0.024297291412949562, -0.05282139778137207, 0.02524292655289173, -0.023594804108142853, 0.047319792211055756, -0.07117348909378052, 0.04898757487535477, -0.040211886167526245, 0.031601667404174805, 0.010059930384159088, -0.0017356611788272858, -0.05267324298620224, -0.016461707651615143, -0.09592171013355255, -0.049276888370513916, -0.06107901409268379, 0.017010966315865517, 0.005443991627544165, 0.05272524058818817, 0.009769626893103123, 0.019845256581902504, 0.044396333396434784, -0.09611235558986664, -0.032301291823387146, 0.03914652392268181, -0.007880390621721745, 0.0025954435113817453, 0.06293972581624985, -0.0013005022192373872, -0.0014773228904232383, 0.00870757270604372, 0.04047601670026779, 0.08399603515863419, -0.0041650733910501, 0.005457650870084763, 0.017902424558997154, 0.01794964075088501, -0.017847273498773575, -0.0039055997040122747, -0.03419574350118637, -0.015987558290362358, 0.04770964756608009, 0.0009745145216584206, -0.06600990891456604, -0.030586903914809227, -0.09389734268188477, 0.016981326043605804, 0.02342016063630581, 0.04463108256459236, -0.03833071514964104, -0.06585721671581268, 0.008907697163522243, 0.013619956560432911, 0.0026858863420784473, 0.04286152124404907, -0.044002290815114975, -0.13477200269699097, -0.048649441450834274, 0.06923895329236984, 0.0032691587693989277, 0.10000398010015488, 0.007225373759865761, 0.00947573222219944, 0.07894785702228546, 0.05429225414991379, 0.018199551850557327, 0.0022512420546263456, 0.12751275300979614, 0.04113338515162468, -0.008170755580067635, 0.00013284473970998079, 0.026466110721230507, -0.03454316779971123, -0.003862817771732807, 0.04181749373674393, 0.009545656852424145, 0.01987244375050068, -0.013246426358819008, -0.002125324448570609, 0.0013221846893429756, 0.10727021098136902, 0.00042549436329863966, 0.0150484973564744, -0.051321107894182205, 0.04349662363529205, -0.009180834516882896, 0.027928950265049934, 0.057725127786397934, 0.0760602056980133, 0.08282479643821716, -0.1190994456410408, -0.013400503434240818, 0.026990916579961777, -0.027454880997538567, 0.025111963972449303, -0.0015389941399917006, -0.01384940929710865, 0.011132242158055305, 0.047597795724868774, 0.0159250870347023, 0.07265084981918335, 0.039441145956516266, -0.007574247196316719, -0.048595212399959564, 0.011806613765656948, -0.02928038500249386, 0.006581546273082495, -0.042040400207042694, -0.009678022004663944, -0.03832520544528961, -0.09415692090988159, 0.05082001909613609, -0.009669875726103783, -0.04735678434371948, -0.01127687469124794, -0.04487009719014168, -0.0002439060335746035, -0.07053367048501968, -0.00404907064512372, -0.008753654547035694, -0.01993333175778389, 0.04010333493351936, 0.02319224365055561, -0.057350121438503265, -0.03636825829744339, -0.04023964703083038, -0.03587452322244644, 0.10761456191539764, -0.03784553334116936, 0.020627213642001152, -0.05420437827706337, 0.005467369686812162, -0.10211770236492157, 0.035973090678453445, -0.09425313025712967, 0.04937857761979103, 0.002617479534819722, 0.04853145033121109, -0.02795547991991043, -0.10419707000255585, 0.04271511361002922, 0.028133632615208626, -0.07844172418117523, 0.013509257696568966, -0.024599283933639526, 0.027884898707270622, 0.048016298562288284, -0.026234161108732224, -0.04840078204870224, -0.033859893679618835, 0.026205964386463165, 0.05113612860441208, 0.009026408195495605, 0.010040601715445518, -0.037596818059682846, 0.0232093408703804, 0.04095581918954849, 0.038031015545129776, -0.04271817207336426, 0.0035675587132573128, -0.05820317938923836, 0.03872861713171005, 0.04383942112326622, -0.03479524701833725, -0.0338563472032547 ]
47
47
Prediction with expert advice for the Brier game
We show that the Brier game of prediction is mixable and find the optimal learning rate and substitution function for it. The resulting prediction algorithm is applied to predict results of football and tennis matches. The theoretical performance guarantee turns out to be rather tight on these data sets, especially in the case of the more extensive tennis data.
[ -0.028988005593419075, -0.000299970677588135, 0.020752284675836563, -0.0738707184791565, 0.06858018040657043, -0.038180798292160034, 0.02840944565832615, -0.04483989626169205, -0.05663608759641647, -0.003757864935323596, -0.06262160837650299, -0.044548746198415756, -0.0010530243162065744, 0.022951390594244003, 0.07419025152921677, 0.01904102973639965, 0.011490768752992153, -0.03335881605744362, 0.012169157154858112, 0.01759004406630993, -0.02986985258758068, 0.03227688744664192, -0.019116021692752838, -0.03587215021252632, 0.022449908778071404, 0.056955087929964066, 0.07889709621667862, 0.006932626012712717, 0.010264000855386257, 0.0629974752664566, -0.11267693340778351, -0.02829810604453087, 0.02615945227444172, 0.010365558788180351, 0.026744533330202103, -0.022322693839669228, 0.05250170826911926, -0.07776402682065964, -0.04533485695719719, -0.009102722629904747, -0.03124329261481762, 0.015911487862467766, 0.09110171347856522, -0.014996075071394444, 0.06563517451286316, 0.03314448893070221, 0.0033103141468018293, -0.01741422712802887, 0.006236685439944267, 0.042122576385736465, -0.1104409471154213, -0.0019592700991779566, 0.03301382437348366, -0.015712060034275055, -0.0023749973624944687, 0.06297246366739273, -0.026228077709674835, 0.003699549240991473, -0.022478075698018074, -0.057896263897418976, -0.01277628168463707, 0.11859622597694397, 0.04369929060339928, -0.01652858778834343, -0.04662897437810898, -0.0077675944194197655, -0.03976834937930107, -0.06574884802103043, 0.01909816823899746, -0.04078489542007446, 0.01897672563791275, -0.03138161078095436, 0.05061935633420944, 0.028598744422197342, 0.0008352355216629803, -0.04644440859556198, 0.026006419211626053, 0.007103791460394859, 0.011957802809774876, -0.011098888702690601, -0.10291282087564468, 0.055251047015190125, 0.043074335902929306, 0.07433350384235382, 0.01060908380895853, 0.018956415355205536, 0.05478537827730179, 0.02853432297706604, 0.032396405935287476, 0.007173692807555199, -0.01767202466726303, -0.024953795596957207, -0.12854482233524323, 0.029264699667692184, -0.0008631105883978307, 0.03660863637924194, -0.029573943465948105, 0.02508726716041565, -0.0048158071003854275, 0.027491575106978416, 0.002887886017560959, -0.049029167741537094, 0.05507829412817955, 0.038968175649642944, -0.010321580804884434, 0.014273087494075298, 0.018384508788585663, 0.025396591052412987, 0.02588941529393196, 0.007943770848214626, 0.0599694699048996, -0.02225496992468834, -0.026999473571777344, 0.00901504885405302, 0.03016340732574463, 0.10756438970565796, -0.049512479454278946, 0.0921563133597374, 0.03137526288628578, -0.01881682500243187, 0.04336340352892876, 0.07158096134662628, -0.0825229361653328, -0.014979504980146885, 0.053207844495773315, -0.04238502308726311, -0.03532956540584564, -0.048960644751787186, 0.04484293982386589, -0.055812399834394455, -0.07088295370340347, 0.07734303921461105, -0.01823318749666214, -0.050773512572050095, -0.049197904765605927, 0.05742567777633667, -0.03363805264234543, -0.010658579878509045, -0.055135328322649, 0.024062544107437134, -0.05580523610115051, 0.015420614741742611, -0.04933459311723709, -0.0053453329019248486, 0.02588404342532158, 0.054558396339416504, 0.02439802698791027, 0.04936666041612625, -0.06643901020288467, 0.025325391441583633, 0.005051341839134693, -0.02793324552476406, 0.016811560839414597, 0.09093858301639557, 0.016333382576704025, -0.07629004120826721, -0.06589562445878983, -0.009360071271657944, -0.08472643047571182, -0.003049310063943267, 0.023143203929066658, 0.02795243449509144, 0.07095301151275635, -0.009387633763253689, -0.05365220457315445, -0.003109443001449108, -0.006161478813737631, 0.006768582854419947, -0.0024424062576144934, -0.012379723601043224, -0.09598831832408905, -0.03593180328607559, -0.07725217193365097, -0.03150126338005066, -0.04901188611984253, -0.033345919102430344, 0.01905830204486847, 0.006095679942518473, -0.08954734355211258, -0.0011974239023402333, 0.05288591980934143, -0.057152215391397476, 0.01165566686540842, 0.012852557003498077, 0.05401599407196045, 0.05599487945437431, 0.052976466715335846, 0.001959644490852952, 0.08855099976062775, 0.025453194975852966, 0.05341316759586334, 0.041908662766218185, 0.01959843561053276, 0.019302353262901306, 0.01647740788757801, -0.020190399140119553, -0.059058889746665955, -0.0177014097571373, -0.0062482841312885284, 0.007493727840483189, 0.015296205878257751, 0.027939286082983017, -0.009059947915375233, 0.021420642733573914, -0.014436562545597553, 0.03960682079195976, 0.011326619423925877, -0.09844041615724564, -0.02038293145596981, -0.011239706538617611, 0.04344934970140457, -0.025660747662186623, -0.07747020572423935, -0.026445580646395683, -0.03181442245841026, 0.043877605348825455, -0.04335228353738785, -0.020411690697073936, 0.0365200936794281, 0.008759349584579468, 0.026815516874194145, 0.07377973943948746, -0.01088061835616827, -0.012930703349411488, -0.01384558156132698, 0.017915550619363785, 0.057060278952121735, 0.012227706611156464, -0.08272349089384079, 0.06444446742534637, 0.014064038172364235, -0.029841842129826546, 0.05128365382552147, -0.018759125843644142, -0.015429914928972721, 0.03315884247422218, -0.010890667326748371, -0.08187969774007797, 0.0207492895424366, -0.03953968361020088, -0.11090979725122452, 0.07412867993116379, -0.041609760373830795, -0.023354602977633476, -0.010630892589688301, -0.07359330356121063, 0.05935870110988617, 0.0016432908596470952, -0.060095157474279404, -0.0488797165453434, 0.06429335474967957, -0.05645718425512314, -0.0599902868270874, -0.09945069998502731, 0.026412170380353928, 0.03557009994983673, 0.03585408255457878, 0.04765396565198898, 0.030243372544646263, 0.04446578770875931, -0.012213916517794132, 0.0359821543097496, -0.016302313655614853, 0.007923971861600876, 0.06964236497879028, 0.01665003038942814, -0.000604217522777617, -0.0026195852551609278, -0.00192207470536232, 0.009033704176545143, 0.020155441015958786, -0.03650534152984619, 0.015112492255866528, 0.04348933324217796, -0.10396560281515121, -0.022124385461211205, 0.06288976967334747, -0.028973253443837166, 0.09229643642902374, -0.018113695085048676, -0.02184750698506832, 0.046146735548973083, -0.03872727230191231, 0.06666211783885956, -0.002289922209456563, 0.02299564890563488, -0.004522009752690792, 0.07126089185476303, 0.030096447095274925, 0.043263982981443405, -0.06168406084179878, 0.024730155244469643, -0.0389409177005291, 0.03282623365521431, -0.002324719214811921, 0.0033584742341190577, 0.05080312490463257, 0.0006233197636902332, -0.0028351556975394487, 0.01261726301163435, -0.008428470231592655, 0.07354562729597092, 0.050398919731378555, 0.06757229566574097, 0.04505658894777298, 0.03676960617303848, -0.0019989446736872196, 0.06189017370343208, 0.017127085477113724, -0.013346236199140549, -0.027591850608587265, -0.06542524695396423, -0.012124544940888882, -0.02715953253209591, -0.0006066228379495442, -0.07220163941383362, -0.0367487370967865, -0.013524016365408897, 0.0404098778963089, 0.017939912155270576, 0.011368552222847939, 0.06135138124227524, -0.022208092734217644, 0.026014598086476326, -0.001227891305461526, 0.000534035440068692, -0.07508914917707443, -0.0036721285432577133, -0.0684574544429779, 0.041475918143987656, -0.0717298686504364, -0.0678199902176857, 0.00010497904440853745, 0.09560234099626541, -0.06764627248048782, 0.06819489598274231, -0.02344663441181183, -0.04211733490228653, 0.08565264195203781, 0.055889155715703964, -0.05329770967364311, -0.06455249339342117, -0.026211809366941452, -0.023567795753479004, -0.009971512481570244, 0.12097220867872238, 0.06959183514118195, 0.02235128916800022, -0.010481588542461395, -0.002956945216283202, -0.015931691974401474, -0.005772992502897978, -0.023239441215991974, 0.018261194229125977, -0.04673684388399124, -0.0025153812021017075, 0.06520693004131317, 0.0019048030953854322, 0.00822749175131321, -0.02401229925453663, -0.016587719321250916, 0.0377953015267849, -0.0029045091941952705, -0.013694687746465206, 0.04607163369655609, 0.08713111281394958, -0.0428079329431057, 0.0019612747710198164, -0.015743756666779518, 0.017552586272358894, -0.022087879478931427, 0.00025218489463441074, 0.06687197089195251, 0.03507059067487717, 0.01634022779762745, 0.012667566537857056, 0.05832302197813988, -0.06911031156778336, -0.020748844370245934, 0.09948164969682693, -0.023853400722146034, 0.0040332479402422905, -0.010826659388840199, -0.023700088262557983, 0.026987764984369278, -0.007172624114900827, -0.07969684153795242, 0.027250880375504494, 0.0981876403093338, 0.05672011151909828, -0.05289554223418236, -0.06289872527122498, 0.030415700748562813, 0.040155768394470215, 0.01236112229526043, -0.015456347726285458, 0.025663848966360092, -0.08248712122440338, -0.0735379308462143, 0.02006879821419716, 0.056937552988529205, -0.0501590296626091, -0.06006340682506561, -0.06980700045824051, -0.07901864498853683, 0.01217329315841198, 0.06496331840753555, 0.005594249814748764, -0.06059771031141281, 0.03984415531158447, 0.028293374925851822, 0.06305306404829025, -0.024816853925585747, 0.019428927451372147, 0.002737793605774641, -0.06645836681127548, 0.022211913019418716, -0.00958190392702818, -0.027246979996562004, -0.03953630477190018, 0.02989080548286438, -0.024725129827857018, 0.06893200427293777, -0.01752893440425396, 0.08561671525239944, -0.04493573680520058, -0.0056703113950788975, -0.005242818966507912, -0.028029726818203926, 0.026159292086958885, 0.03565791994333267, -0.002821579109877348, -0.054814454168081284, -0.016750570386648178, 0.029354043304920197, -0.010522546246647835, 0.05329225957393646, -0.030021868646144867, -0.0752522274851799, 0.021742019802331924, -0.12092730402946472, 0.012264704331755638, 0.03319302201271057, 0.020055701956152916, -0.040691886097192764, 0.031685709953308105, 0.03308127820491791, 0.010950894095003605, 0.000776866334490478, -0.014084083028137684, 0.024071836844086647, -0.024396082386374474, -0.0048828087747097015, -0.03458193689584732, 0.031033815816044807, -0.003332389984279871, -0.050843000411987305, -0.008400622755289078, 0.05344545096158981, -0.04824589192867279, -0.0414448082447052, -0.04928477481007576, 0.0211504977196455, 0.03943748399615288, -0.08106520026922226, 0.04823113605380058, -0.014954237267374992, -0.046805232763290405, 0.02834233082830906, 0.04412711784243584, -0.028899116441607475, 0.004697845783084631, -0.011351848021149635, -0.04877492040395737, -0.003493493190035224, 0.04234525188803673, 0.004028704483062029, -0.03175460919737816, -0.011102602817118168, 0.0009793946519494057, 0.052999772131443024, 0.011346823535859585, 0.036892034113407135, 0.020473266020417213, 0.06886796653270721, -0.017872828990221024, -0.1287303864955902, 0.023959383368492126, 0.00031659414526075125, 0.04442930966615677, -0.01856856979429722, -0.05849267914891243, -0.035577207803726196, 0.024104129523038864, 0.043460045009851456, -0.004444986116141081, 0.029475806280970573, 0.0022594549227505922, 0.015568755567073822, 0.01167891826480627, 0.0020155548118054867, 0.01121132355183363, 0.001874313922598958, -0.06782394647598267, 0.04626176133751869, 0.01772964559495449, 0.0623171404004097, -0.0029756936710327864, -0.00925629585981369, 0.04178072512149811, -0.035241689532995224, 0.03466831520199776 ]
48
48
Association Rules in the Relational Calculus
One of the most utilized data mining tasks is the search for association rules. Association rules represent significant relationships between items in transactions. We extend the concept of association rule to represent a much broader class of associations, which we refer to as \emph{entity-relationship rules.} Semantically, entity-relationship rules express associations between properties of related objects. Syntactically, these rules are based on a broad subclass of safe domain relational calculus queries. We propose a new definition of support and confidence for entity-relationship rules and for the frequency of entity-relationship queries. We prove that the definition of frequency satisfies standard probability axioms and the Apriori property.
[ 0.013682104647159576, -0.030590342357754707, 0.11556418240070343, -0.0247942004352808, 0.004167033825069666, -0.052022628486156464, -0.053845927119255066, -0.023078540340065956, -0.003993383143097162, 0.026785511523485184, 0.014422265812754631, -0.04420533776283264, 0.07541189342737198, 0.04036148265004158, 0.039038702845573425, -0.04273122921586037, -0.06312690675258636, -0.0019042572239413857, -0.02181832492351532, -0.0637056976556778, 0.005322097335010767, -0.05206861346960068, 0.028299177065491676, -0.1253286600112915, 0.02822008915245533, -0.10794220864772797, -0.015100665390491486, 0.05260631442070007, 0.021150365471839905, -0.019064920023083687, -0.015053747221827507, 0.0064920177683234215, 0.05622047185897827, -0.01630990393459797, 0.040308356285095215, 0.05299309641122818, 0.016772957518696785, -0.0023665493354201317, -0.023713693022727966, -0.0049588484689593315, 0.00899868831038475, -0.003767878981307149, 0.01758640818297863, 0.02362116426229477, 0.0444968156516552, 0.06284318119287491, 0.06292923539876938, 0.059321168810129166, 0.04355979338288307, 0.016626017168164253, -0.0847950354218483, -0.0021425995510071516, 0.040373295545578, 0.02824815921485424, -0.011920234188437462, -0.0018170542316511273, 0.015537678264081478, -0.020291795954108238, -0.005709880031645298, 0.012460682541131973, 0.1100098267197609, 0.07343097776174545, -0.03969647362828255, -0.03562286123633385, -0.027338188141584396, 0.00063083361601457, 0.020771890878677368, 0.06234469264745712, -0.015447105281054974, -0.032850481569767, -0.05805060639977455, 0.0036959683056920767, -0.016117656603455544, 0.014663180336356163, 0.004201602656394243, -0.022839248180389404, -0.03300558030605316, -0.03639110177755356, -0.007988613098859787, 0.05759285390377045, -0.04611748084425926, -0.013125303201377392, -0.07050128281116486, -0.03252695873379707, -0.06389062106609344, 0.021143026649951935, 0.06953196227550507, -0.054490137845277786, -0.0010036308085545897, -0.014033680781722069, -0.027087204158306122, 0.04458292946219444, -0.11249487102031708, 0.017821649089455605, -0.016150930896401405, 0.06149563938379288, -0.009774185717105865, 0.030519671738147736, 0.04783940687775612, -0.014981266111135483, -0.0008912024204619229, -0.02182442881166935, 0.0447133332490921, -0.013448229059576988, -0.01334503572434187, -0.0020877227652817965, 0.0647369772195816, 0.018750252202153206, 0.0005712825804948807, -0.02561553753912449, 0.004026343580335379, -0.030971543863415718, -0.050424300134181976, 0.0433240570127964, -0.053606171160936356, 0.05900245159864426, -0.01640867069363594, 0.022513924166560173, -0.004206523299217224, -0.026904815807938576, -0.027163062244653702, -0.0005701053887605667, -0.1009194552898407, 0.013738717883825302, 0.017730914056301117, -0.019060349091887474, -0.04693073034286499, -0.02964114397764206, 0.032249175012111664, -0.0024573791306465864, -0.06730232387781143, 0.02399308606982231, -0.11387478560209274, -0.0063493759371340275, -0.035723358392715454, 0.0045742918737232685, -0.006150121800601482, 0.034833986312150955, 0.06828221678733826, 0.016035212203860283, -0.06091994419693947, -0.02397649548947811, 0.016124067828059196, -0.0343845970928669, 0.036325983703136444, 0.07686085253953934, -0.009008395485579967, 0.020217128098011017, 0.044751085340976715, -0.05657413974404335, 0.020399775356054306, -0.004943475592881441, -0.0255760345607996, 0.006750394590198994, 0.045452848076820374, -0.013464178889989853, -0.015747852623462677, 0.0018711583688855171, -0.03333433344960213, 0.040157247334718704, -0.012326749972999096, 0.0019441242329776287, 0.03523797541856766, 0.017218995839357376, -0.05646490305662155, 0.00453888438642025, -0.018870048224925995, -0.02146230824291706, 0.015329336747527122, -0.06432103365659714, -0.045219697058200836, 0.06465878337621689, 0.015706947073340416, -0.043549682945013046, 0.01499238982796669, -0.0031070879194885492, -0.055220238864421844, -0.07490509003400803, -0.03567415103316307, -0.038048312067985535, 0.008850841782987118, -0.019076764583587646, 0.05450272560119629, 0.017352724447846413, 0.046448901295661926, 0.0992441326379776, -0.011269072070717812, -0.0294794924557209, -0.03903920203447342, -0.025790482759475708, 0.025156334042549133, -0.016956979408860207, -0.07784944027662277, 0.018787339329719543, 0.0016551663866266608, -0.07816287130117416, -0.008536598645150661, -0.02123626135289669, 0.02645411342382431, 0.07459715753793716, -0.03917485848069191, 0.010716755874454975, -0.020514117553830147, -0.015178834088146687, 0.026093104854226112, -0.08933396637439728, -0.02214912138879299, 0.0581895112991333, -0.045935023576021194, -0.049735937267541885, 0.06514161080121994, 0.013623066246509552, -0.0068939500488340855, -0.09038196504116058, 0.08142119646072388, -0.0353294312953949, -0.024767467752099037, -0.07943137735128403, 0.027760958299040794, 0.05208352953195572, 0.06183717027306557, 0.00943363830447197, 0.013668663799762726, 0.05205489322543144, -0.05276903510093689, 0.026675701141357422, 0.0468374602496624, -0.007021711207926273, -0.026971498504281044, -0.016574624925851822, -0.06425172835588455, -0.0004309190553613007, -0.010850553400814533, 0.020978350192308426, 0.02421613596379757, -0.03664928674697876, -0.03167184442281723, -0.0051320381462574005, -0.07845280319452286, 0.01755646802484989, -0.006530848331749439, 0.0520077608525753, 0.03334123641252518, -0.03583141416311264, -0.024745460599660873, -0.07900414615869522, 0.017821868881583214, -0.047475747764110565, -0.012665130198001862, 0.02752181701362133, -0.028783518821001053, -0.0711531713604927, 0.035132791846990585, -0.02160782366991043, 0.044526711106300354, 0.09742972254753113, -0.010423436760902405, 0.10724025219678879, 0.023972518742084503, 0.012583525851368904, 0.020819781348109245, 0.009307926520705223, -0.05218254402279854, 0.0908646285533905, 0.04410284385085106, 0.03594588488340378, 0.009260755963623524, 0.030010119080543518, 0.0024459329433739185, -0.0977509468793869, -0.028867585584521294, -0.023121550679206848, 0.02984156273305416, 0.06386446207761765, -0.002132093533873558, 0.007392469327896833, 0.02921464666724205, -0.007878422737121582, -0.004182885866612196, -0.010079349391162395, -0.030347099527716637, -0.04073838144540787, 0.05337288975715637, 0.0006335300276987255, -0.017518945038318634, -0.035600315779447556, -0.019464675337076187, -0.053353261202573776, 0.06279958784580231, -0.03465721011161804, -0.05317700654268265, -0.04926283285021782, 0.024255990982055664, -0.04424458369612694, 0.04605850949883461, -0.01013842225074768, 0.058784522116184235, -0.019244415685534477, 0.05214538425207138, 0.021941307932138443, -0.09813867509365082, 0.10156267136335373, 0.07069329172372818, -0.0032780535984784365, 0.03793840482831001, 0.05758463218808174, 0.022961532697081566, 0.0716218650341034, -0.025660162791609764, 0.014766170643270016, -0.07516080886125565, -0.07286393642425537, 0.02774384245276451, 0.011785317212343216, 0.052043382078409195, 0.002453442430123687, 0.008928034454584122, -0.06862574070692062, -0.07803221791982651, -0.000955526134930551, -0.00402418989688158, 0.026811789721250534, 0.007743034046143293, -0.019456058740615845, -0.07056896388530731, 0.028784671798348427, 0.039207469671964645, -0.08246638625860214, -0.022402290254831314, 0.06364608556032181, -0.019165705889463425, 0.03657675161957741, 0.0003284810809418559, 0.08978734165430069, -0.03549542278051376, 0.050846997648477554, -0.08736243098974228, -0.007245620246976614, -0.017455562949180603, 0.035928986966609955, -0.011913115158677101, 0.0033456527162343264, -0.08376213163137436, 0.03872568532824516, 0.029565885663032532, -0.0000021032280983490637, 0.09585791081190109, 0.03009667433798313, -0.03728629648685455, 0.018053624778985977, -0.05491512268781662, 0.044557683169841766, 0.04500765725970268, 0.007353323511779308, 0.008487536571919918, 0.068326435983181, 0.006171127315610647, 0.05741775780916214, -0.014071249403059483, 0.012343312613666058, 0.12200221419334412, 0.003360162954777479, 0.05833907052874565, -0.02757321111857891, 0.05895866081118584, 0.06849002838134766, 0.0010056126629933715, -0.03329826518893242, -0.03355257958173752, 0.00045952838263474405, 0.010412435047328472, -0.0005126955220475793, 0.03441354259848595, 0.02738962322473526, -0.0362810343503952, -0.0005889307940378785, 0.06203562766313553, -0.024632977321743965, 0.07186399400234222, 0.038700904697179794, -0.041564103215932846, -0.03984972462058067, -0.10076943039894104, -0.04612590745091438, -0.07197105884552002, -0.05563890188932419, 0.017288750037550926, -0.022459590807557106, 0.0569789819419384, 0.010839009657502174, 0.045609042048454285, -0.020362980663776398, 0.11809317767620087, -0.0028664974961429834, 0.043362200260162354, -0.02566191554069519, -0.00030585788772441447, -0.030509911477565765, -0.019486714154481888, -0.033466994762420654, -0.0004132034373469651, -0.12658526003360748, -0.03279601037502289, 0.020382409915328026, 0.0016004216158762574, 0.04712839797139168, -0.014545062556862831, 0.03342793881893158, -0.02423783950507641, 0.03388596698641777, 0.020606646314263344, 0.009552471339702606, -0.07924763858318329, -0.04853155463933945, 0.011526303365826607, 0.01262234803289175, 0.03231186047196388, -0.026882212609052658, -0.06712429225444794, 0.015807969495654106, -0.0667465329170227, -0.0020453084725886583, 0.011378059163689613, -0.033247340470552444, -0.0035491434391587973, -0.014613336883485317, 0.024090711027383804, -0.0179241131991148, 0.036542996764183044, -0.0025318011175841093, 0.06103578582406044, -0.037389785051345825, -0.08563417196273804, 0.030100159347057343, 0.020226042717695236, 0.03355949744582176, -0.0006098821759223938, 0.015250411815941334, 0.07298942655324936, -0.02761402726173401, -0.03974544256925583, -0.029297413304448128, 0.0407695397734642, 0.03359203040599823, 0.08276936411857605, -0.0002490707265678793, 0.06740271300077438, -0.020252712070941925, 0.14596423506736755, 0.04735679551959038, 0.0026809091214090586, -0.015962908044457436, -0.0012601504568010569, 0.009368007071316242, -0.06754716485738754, 0.01527752447873354, -0.013752144761383533, -0.04371204599738121, 0.009639566764235497, -0.043197985738515854, 0.012114728800952435, -0.04182463139295578, -0.03757776692509651, -0.034269191324710846, -0.0826459750533104, -0.08406100422143936, 0.06229672580957413, 0.056500740349292755, 0.08032292872667313, -0.04419391602277756, -0.08652537316083908, 0.0053925421088933945, 0.04534289985895157, -0.017832137644290924, -0.05556728318333626, 0.028054526075720787, 0.007025762461125851, 0.045859601348638535, -0.01314892340451479, -0.03059306927025318, -0.0226924829185009, -0.02936295047402382, -0.011777753941714764, -0.03298497572541237, 0.049133531749248505, 0.10261901468038559, -0.002768576145172119, -0.01546743605285883, -0.021781690418720245, -0.0615123026072979, -0.004492602776736021, -0.04408824443817139, -0.006167982704937458, -0.017937595024704933, 0.09105100482702255, -0.005571275483816862, 0.03559950739145279, -0.006035563535988331, 0.013637586496770382, -0.03715875372290611, 0.002029102761298418, -0.017887039110064507, -0.004317303653806448, 0.017405003309249878, 0.06870787590742111, 0.046615730971097946, 0.0027423398569226265, -0.011926624923944473, -0.053356632590293884, 0.015279250219464302, -0.015454438515007496, -0.09354130923748016 ]
49
49
The structure of verbal sequences analyzed with unsupervised learning techniques
Data mining allows the exploration of sequences of phenomena, whereas one usually tends to focus on isolated phenomena or on the relation between two phenomena. It offers invaluable tools for theoretical analyses and exploration of the structure of sentences, texts, dialogues, and speech. We report here the results of an attempt at using it for inspecting sequences of verbs from French accounts of road accidents. This analysis comes from an original approach of unsupervised training allowing the discovery of the structure of sequential data. The entries of the analyzer were only made of the verbs appearing in the sentences. It provided a classification of the links between two successive verbs into four distinct clusters, allowing thus text segmentation. We give here an interpretation of these clusters by applying a statistical analysis to independent semantic annotations.
[ 0.0038673877716064453, -0.03126806765794754, 0.06403941661119461, 0.039915356785058975, 0.04246505722403526, -0.0742039903998375, -0.12728078663349152, -0.07463059574365616, -0.04813840240240097, -0.027308467775583267, -0.029115891084074974, -0.001552488305605948, 0.02738211676478386, -0.01821046508848667, 0.05808481574058533, 0.013391564600169659, -0.06405710428953171, -0.03411729633808136, -0.02575371041893959, -0.09691230207681656, -0.022778471931815147, 0.017572464421391487, -0.011045893654227257, -0.03450143709778786, 0.05325113981962204, 0.012465903535485268, -0.027214616537094116, 0.003814511001110077, -0.05014749988913536, -0.03287883475422859, -0.04602068290114403, 0.003955419175326824, 0.09426882117986679, -0.013703490607440472, 0.04749086871743202, 0.024362849071621895, -0.033624835312366486, 0.036599285900592804, -0.08247460424900055, 0.009452980943024158, 0.0004887694376520813, -0.02868221327662468, 0.0196473840624094, 0.008096421137452126, 0.039535973221063614, 0.03608192875981331, 0.03592513129115105, -0.05105561763048172, 0.018387895077466965, 0.06480230391025543, -0.06078476831316948, 0.03730079531669617, 0.01621287874877453, 0.005618961527943611, -0.03633411228656769, 0.03269403055310249, -0.03248056769371033, 0.049837034195661545, -0.006466499529778957, -0.025377221405506134, 0.026251956820487976, 0.020786482840776443, 0.04054417461156845, -0.013275530189275742, -0.04757869988679886, 0.0389951728284359, -0.04866347089409828, -0.049272891134023666, 0.03249669447541237, -0.037743303924798965, -0.023342082276940346, 0.02756875939667225, -0.019812989979982376, -0.03397803381085396, -0.02684929594397545, 0.02216382510960102, -0.027695994824171066, -0.06249888613820076, 0.028361260890960693, 0.12478552758693695, -0.019189944490790367, 0.018372809514403343, -0.013093539513647556, -0.018623732030391693, -0.019873367622494698, -0.08652730286121368, 0.004953907337039709, 0.004987106658518314, 0.03839905187487602, -0.004647388122975826, -0.07938974350690842, -0.0466093011200428, -0.09034976363182068, 0.05778692290186882, -0.11226389557123184, 0.024156799539923668, -0.021526314318180084, -0.09456051141023636, 0.08215764909982681, 0.02249029651284218, -0.0392330139875412, -0.02138935960829258, 0.058895472437143326, -0.01517016626894474, -0.03081994317471981, -0.04473843425512314, 0.010436766780912876, 0.04771300032734871, 0.05490865185856819, 0.03828682750463486, 0.030976202338933945, 0.034390419721603394, -0.008698105812072754, 0.0073012192733585835, 0.010072222910821438, 0.08127444982528687, 0.017961997538805008, 0.10930168628692627, 0.011513800360262394, -0.03383012115955353, 0.06277307122945786, 0.03365546837449074, -0.001446432899683714, -0.01250609289854765, 0.03295908495783806, -0.07103896886110306, -0.049380313605070114, -0.014668808318674564, 0.0587947703897953, -0.03135746344923973, -0.08808819204568863, -0.00493583595380187, -0.031749263405799866, 0.050397008657455444, -0.07461739331483841, -0.031053952872753143, 0.04406609758734703, -0.04433242976665497, -0.00310703506693244, 0.013592461124062538, 0.003784338477998972, 0.0027190684340894222, -0.02674252726137638, -0.047105513513088226, -0.0319741852581501, 0.06395220011472702, -0.0015574105782434344, 0.012685396708548069, 0.08135997503995895, 0.04361884295940399, -0.04424476623535156, -0.10610707104206085, 0.04143913835287094, 0.021521296352148056, 0.08290629088878632, -0.04557481408119202, -0.06202637031674385, -0.02491891197860241, 0.004487891681492329, 0.045105382800102234, -0.03275485709309578, -0.01197228953242302, 0.05516429245471954, -0.002793979598209262, -0.0389351025223732, -0.056176647543907166, 0.0007909865234978497, 0.003135529113933444, 0.011919356882572174, -0.06388840079307556, 0.013277672231197357, 0.021217601373791695, 0.055091556161642075, 0.04180712625384331, 0.02569960057735443, -0.05653129518032074, -0.08471354842185974, 0.040822237730026245, -0.0016208632150664926, 0.030039042234420776, -0.018792955204844475, -0.057932298630476, 0.047052569687366486, 0.021631944924592972, 0.045199837535619736, 0.12680412828922272, 0.003566346364095807, 0.09671259671449661, 0.0036859670653939247, -0.04074127972126007, 0.020703110843896866, 0.02238977700471878, 0.027184803038835526, 0.0073252576403319836, -0.10972417891025543, 0.03072989545762539, 0.005896938964724541, 0.01577913947403431, 0.002085356041789055, 0.054966945201158524, -0.0568900890648365, 0.02112741768360138, 0.00349833769723773, -0.02034997008740902, 0.029124725610017776, -0.04136144742369652, 0.02003234252333641, -0.006272797007113695, 0.004633170552551746, 0.04351378232240677, 0.008114419877529144, -0.03233823552727699, -0.002481066156178713, 0.02817556820809841, 0.04452905431389809, -0.022618865594267845, -0.011619187891483307, -0.03058820590376854, 0.095579132437706, 0.05243738368153572, -0.053037695586681366, -0.02520403079688549, -0.06822139024734497, 0.04745054990053177, -0.05663129687309265, 0.03795027732849121, 0.012211664579808712, -0.04906102642416954, 0.018828781321644783, 0.04747862368822098, -0.08076826483011246, -0.11227348446846008, -0.10078717768192291, -0.046877287328243256, 0.060755666345357895, 0.04872778430581093, 0.023043224588036537, 0.031096402555704117, -0.0009184450027532876, 0.021510940045118332, -0.06934936344623566, 0.0010113506577908993, 0.05765543505549431, -0.027835236862301826, -0.019323239102959633, -0.073390893638134, 0.06066592410206795, 0.06347786635160446, -0.007735118269920349, -0.036402005702257156, 0.011086978018283844, -0.00877501629292965, 0.0093623585999012, 0.07485213130712509, -0.006221712566912174, -0.006700153928250074, -0.04050923138856888, 0.0010323321912437677, 0.0021029128693044186, 0.08526995033025742, 0.018872948363423347, 0.04310682415962219, -0.01830943487584591, 0.039061255753040314, 0.12927278876304626, 0.027815314009785652, -0.0462413989007473, 0.0136823495849967, 0.0388001948595047, -0.031568218022584915, -0.0022294470109045506, -0.09457724541425705, -0.021992547437548637, 0.051458872854709625, -0.04725098982453346, -0.009785043075680733, 0.04137733206152916, 0.008022026158869267, -0.012573514133691788, -0.00411927280947566, -0.005731878336519003, -0.0030209911055862904, 0.1109175980091095, 0.025754885748028755, -0.022170426324009895, -0.035660576075315475, 0.05724690109491348, 0.0029708249494433403, -0.018386757001280785, 0.011530694551765919, -0.03530461713671684, 0.032577384263277054, -0.028479035943746567, 0.010419824160635471, 0.08989059925079346, -0.05210120975971222, -0.005820040125399828, 0.01828549988567829, 0.04544767737388611, -0.055722977966070175, 0.00935313105583191, 0.03264318406581879, 0.10331275314092636, 0.013359563425183296, 0.02683483064174652, 0.06369372457265854, 0.037319477647542953, 0.0743233934044838, 0.06642288714647293, -0.0016864757053554058, -0.02274182252585888, -0.030993664637207985, 0.0166186336427927, -0.018901277333498, -0.014322669245302677, -0.06496305763721466, -0.005754332989454269, 0.026449721306562424, -0.016192177310585976, 0.010270345024764538, -0.013505872339010239, 0.06312264502048492, -0.010523485019803047, -0.005363035947084427, 0.06914030015468597, -0.00820471066981554, -0.00043347172322683036, 0.0018890865612775087, -0.08691895008087158, -0.017033670097589493, -0.0076184868812561035, -0.007564764004200697, 0.0749623253941536, 0.15259505808353424, 0.016418995335698128, -0.030591387301683426, 0.03148059919476509, -0.00308500649407506, 0.01310688629746437, 0.04470936581492424, -0.05261749401688576, -0.04481003060936928, 0.06814051419496536, -0.025516381487250328, -0.02518848516047001, 0.026868050917983055, 0.011629662476480007, 0.041031550616025925, 0.03510065749287605, -0.004398676101118326, -0.03757490962743759, -0.06147138401865959, -0.03820288926362991, 0.027219632640480995, -0.014351706951856613, 0.025303570553660393, 0.023614825680851936, 0.040612343698740005, 0.0037278649397194386, -0.010064007714390755, 0.07648307830095291, -0.00959271751344204, -0.00042680074693635106, 0.009429745376110077, -0.021680427715182304, 0.04516099765896797, -0.019672086462378502, -0.02016109600663185, -0.030102429911494255, -0.023231446743011475, 0.0047948239371180534, 0.006278845947235823, 0.02790580689907074, -0.013770847581326962, 0.019861767068505287, -0.028196200728416443, 0.001634042477235198, -0.09721289575099945, -0.055084165185689926, 0.023586466908454895, -0.03745525702834129, -0.00902699027210474, -0.028359616175293922, 0.03636874258518219, -0.030628597363829613, -0.037084270268678665, 0.0031191143207252026, 0.03505648300051689, 0.01767624169588089, 0.05063728615641594, -0.03887731581926346, 0.007070478517562151, -0.01696772687137127, -0.0029044656548649073, 0.05638599023222923, -0.03466852009296417, -0.002819232176989317, 0.0038425137754529715, -0.036359574645757675, 0.0053829471580684185, -0.010569789446890354, -0.07062891870737076, -0.07280457019805908, -0.032046351581811905, -0.03569650650024414, -0.04291534423828125, -0.057400744408369064, 0.0017342359060421586, 0.034172818064689636, 0.014824050478637218, 0.10685180127620697, 0.05221300572156906, 0.00408150115981698, -0.050915639847517014, -0.01299042534083128, 0.07408921420574188, 0.021118687465786934, 0.029949424788355827, 0.02710821107029915, -0.06650219112634659, -0.004709253553301096, 0.048266198486089706, -0.00999588705599308, 0.018076755106449127, -0.03114316798746586, -0.03270769491791725, 0.1071653664112091, 0.026763159781694412, -0.018140759319067, 0.009969753213226795, 0.002590806921944022, -0.07502431422472, -0.05446513742208481, -0.001457707490772009, 0.009389449842274189, -0.002906396985054016, 0.021328868344426155, -0.049927275627851486, -0.05520389974117279, 0.03819100186228752, -0.07949088513851166, 0.01707644760608673, 0.03406720608472824, -0.021036546677350998, 0.033184390515089035, -0.003855983028188348, 0.009601620957255363, 0.0022975734900683165, 0.03279876336455345, -0.03143228590488434, 0.00742902560159564, 0.05102881044149399, -0.011525891721248627, 0.006860931869596243, 0.004569042474031448, -0.049663346260786057, -0.03728652745485306, -0.05910357087850571, 0.011964562349021435, -0.09965134412050247, -0.0013233235804364085, 0.03358793258666992, -0.013289757072925568, -0.04102202504873276, -0.031769610941410065, -0.01082561258226633, 0.06374223530292511, 0.015467611141502857, 0.06290145218372345, -0.015347222797572613, -0.06469838321208954, -0.015058768913149834, -0.021847616881132126, 0.035892218351364136, -0.01375153474509716, -0.014089422300457954, -0.01823274791240692, -0.04956105723977089, -0.09743095189332962, -0.05446155369281769, 0.026852617040276527, 0.008124002255499363, 0.004720598924905062, 0.04736827686429024, 0.08528665453195572, -0.029134321957826614, -0.00380843598395586, -0.0564776286482811, 0.005293093156069517, 0.028209010139107704, 0.05313489958643913, -0.07312789559364319, -0.05978338420391083, 0.043680526316165924, 0.032502301037311554, -0.010276922956109047, 0.04184304177761078, -0.033545974642038345, -0.011929699219763279, 0.026695137843489647, 0.07409810274839401, -0.05853946506977081, 0.033265210688114166, 0.014142139814794064, 0.09067218005657196, 0.01456365454941988, 0.017420269548892975, 0.00761194434016943, 0.004375216085463762, 0.012278554029762745, -0.03128137066960335, -0.09563043713569641 ]
50
50
Consistency of trace norm minimization
Regularization by the sum of singular values, also referred to as the trace norm, is a popular technique for estimating low rank rectangular matrices. In this paper, we extend some of the consistency results of the Lasso to provide necessary and sufficient conditions for rank consistency of trace norm minimization with the square loss. We also provide an adaptive version that is rank consistent even when the necessary condition for the non adaptive version is not fulfilled.
[ 0.09937112778425217, -0.026048805564641953, 0.009743263944983482, -0.04192323237657547, -0.04608079791069031, 0.006210322957485914, -0.01398637518286705, 0.01786687783896923, 0.003059508977457881, 0.020636392757296562, 0.041731998324394226, -0.03282466530799866, -0.06352970004081726, 0.05133061483502388, -0.011302118189632893, -0.015759123489260674, -0.03181037679314613, 0.006443329155445099, 0.00830344669520855, -0.0498359315097332, -0.0005687155644409359, -0.024204272776842117, 0.09778276830911636, -0.06468569487333298, 0.09169840067625046, 0.04523461312055588, 0.001959793269634247, -0.009358814917504787, 0.048693858087062836, 0.05153047293424606, -0.06470923870801926, 0.0009221112704835832, 0.05545387044548988, -0.06481484323740005, -0.021594945341348648, -0.003351782914251089, 0.06491522490978241, 0.07537483423948288, 0.0016519048949703574, 0.03905561566352844, -0.0004502020892687142, 0.11710052937269211, 0.029192989692091942, -0.016940109431743622, 0.02362672984600067, 0.012448081746697426, 0.08170362561941147, -0.05997392162680626, 0.04499773681163788, 0.06077108532190323, 0.032539136707782745, 0.07141727954149246, 0.01860664039850235, -0.05889393389225006, 0.04309224709868431, -0.01566408947110176, -0.02596939727663994, -0.053298622369766235, -0.00476455595344305, -0.008307010866701603, 0.018103409558534622, 0.029092401266098022, 0.05678974464535713, -0.1099989265203476, 0.012302328832447529, 0.0531405471265316, -0.09464070200920105, -0.0826345905661583, -0.014218781143426895, -0.04996461793780327, -0.06222258880734444, 0.007352727465331554, 0.040888939052820206, 0.01615944691002369, 0.03477777540683746, -0.01707489602267742, 0.01418160367757082, -0.05636550858616829, 0.044742606580257416, 0.002199700800701976, -0.031528860330581665, 0.06613697856664658, -0.055820416659116745, -0.017979733645915985, -0.054989974945783615, 0.02705087512731552, -0.06417206674814224, -0.010819811373949051, 0.08428031951189041, -0.044584449380636215, 0.02046153135597706, -0.005464924965053797, -0.05247665196657181, -0.010157688520848751, -0.026715965941548347, 0.0012376619270071387, 0.01997264288365841, 0.019551018252968788, -0.0723976269364357, -0.031982190907001495, 0.043918006122112274, 0.0337849035859108, 0.06728466600179672, 0.026821807026863098, -0.036617912352085114, 0.03412392735481262, -0.06135298311710358, 0.030857253819704056, -0.0145293939858675, 0.014660568907856941, -0.054877445101737976, -0.08501166850328445, -0.018593542277812958, -0.036910928785800934, -0.01821904256939888, 0.02244764007627964, 0.027694566175341606, 0.03557686507701874, -0.0032704253681004047, -0.050452057272195816, 0.02807433158159256, 0.018909359350800514, -0.0194871723651886, 0.004290337674319744, -0.014324735850095749, 0.02070651762187481, -0.02943876013159752, -0.1468166559934616, 0.04228032007813454, -0.04467852786183357, -0.026334615424275398, 0.008215830661356449, 0.011649509891867638, -0.03718782961368561, -0.1081426590681076, 0.08844774961471558, -0.031838953495025635, -0.045422352850437164, -0.08403396606445312, 0.0743582546710968, -0.010599134489893913, 0.026038073003292084, -0.02527659386396408, 0.05096834525465965, -0.0012843969743698835, 0.004782482516020536, 0.03988543897867203, -0.04673207178711891, -0.03540952876210213, 0.012992443516850471, 0.053184229880571365, -0.027879497036337852, 0.039128560572862625, 0.02499561384320259, 0.08159398287534714, -0.0904497280716896, 0.009692908264696598, -0.07266317307949066, -0.0396612174808979, -0.03744778037071228, -0.010706458240747452, -0.006513538304716349, -0.013860153034329414, 0.021161362528800964, -0.053467802703380585, -0.10941238701343536, 0.029456790536642075, 0.015258959494531155, -0.04097659885883331, -0.0076531656086444855, -0.09582165628671646, 0.01696653664112091, -0.01095455139875412, 0.006046146620064974, -0.02309676632285118, 0.023756496608257294, 0.07094476372003555, -0.00107932451646775, -0.016548704355955124, -0.01729513704776764, 0.042271003127098083, 0.06972260773181915, -0.025701865553855896, -0.001223720726557076, 0.053270772099494934, 0.08321669697761536, -0.07093755155801773, 0.015554259531199932, -0.021804079413414, 0.0587601475417614, 0.04524765908718109, 0.011164721101522446, -0.09629885852336884, 0.009561572223901749, -0.048821840435266495, 0.06933638453483582, -0.0033816287759691477, 0.004824218340218067, 0.0229281447827816, 0.05640529468655586, 0.02630663849413395, 0.004019460175186396, 0.015374965965747833, -0.05259108543395996, -0.013497731648385525, -0.03666076809167862, -0.009852183051407337, -0.04475736245512962, 0.018268946558237076, 0.024928243830800056, 0.0031003744807094336, 0.012062886729836464, 0.030446302145719528, -0.11534590274095535, 0.022809632122516632, -0.03491321951150894, 0.048590488731861115, -0.038341302424669266, -0.019601132720708847, 0.02846975438296795, -0.03801789507269859, 0.060418300330638885, -0.023302273824810982, 0.026883063837885857, -0.011141885071992874, -0.02132430672645569, 0.005428970791399479, -0.0014018536312505603, -0.05702973157167435, 0.007758313324302435, -0.03212559223175049, -0.03928738087415695, 0.021882174536585808, 0.005610149819403887, 0.0006138497847132385, 0.03105824626982212, -0.0934019684791565, 0.003468742361292243, -0.015146061778068542, 0.004334290977567434, -0.04959239438176155, -0.012173319235444069, -0.0636439248919487, -0.044935163110494614, -0.06848641484975815, -0.0641716867685318, 0.08178836107254028, 0.06529179960489273, 0.025003358721733093, -0.031296513974666595, 0.011611255817115307, 0.038231901824474335, -0.027229279279708862, -0.015185290947556496, -0.013494095765054226, 0.02161218598484993, -0.0032667366322129965, -0.01949135772883892, -0.01831676997244358, 0.06105390936136246, 0.02568097598850727, 0.10967151075601578, -0.06423833221197128, 0.002933183219283819, 0.004091337323188782, 0.03298386558890343, -0.07364138960838318, -0.0055011482909321785, 0.013034536503255367, 0.05451388657093048, -0.07069380581378937, 0.00045357990893535316, 0.024139702320098877, 0.026228388771414757, -0.01863075979053974, 0.023218408226966858, 0.025942830368876457, 0.07278507202863693, 0.04565208777785301, -0.0048768543638288975, -0.04954332485795021, -0.007604301907122135, -0.019783692434430122, -0.11653587967157364, 0.012053396552801132, -0.031840115785598755, -0.017958348616957664, -0.026221096515655518, 0.00968001876026392, -0.002934493822976947, -0.06821835041046143, 0.08506745100021362, -0.017493370920419693, 0.028071556240320206, 0.07171225547790527, 0.03290567919611931, 0.0725344866514206, -0.01623305305838585, 0.001144103822298348, 0.06996971368789673, 0.019550126045942307, -0.017766984179615974, -0.058315254747867584, -0.045275263488292694, -0.03580661863088608, -0.0002000783133553341, 0.0756494477391243, -0.03322456032037735, -0.029960228130221367, 0.019274596124887466, 0.025393282994627953, -0.033166565001010895, -0.04769597202539444, -0.10576601326465607, 0.05948909372091293, -0.044739436358213425, -0.031527116894721985, -0.07231076061725616, 0.03214258328080177, -0.026211105287075043, 0.031041791662573814, 0.017427515238523483, -0.021172190085053444, -0.004093989264219999, -0.041591085493564606, -0.0029406226240098476, -0.045555271208286285, 0.025648318231105804, -0.049459125846624374, -0.04780493676662445, 0.0010743095772340894, -0.002031950047239661, 0.013344241306185722, 0.06604407727718353, 0.05172843858599663, -0.0345291942358017, -0.07175448536872864, -0.08139819651842117, -0.0716555118560791, 0.01603255607187748, -0.030957842245697975, -0.0781901478767395, -0.012512488290667534, 0.026644378900527954, 0.045295823365449905, 0.031818024814128876, 0.04064074158668518, -0.08206256479024887, -0.1036735475063324, -0.010909023694694042, -0.10439930856227875, 0.004283871967345476, 0.02719394490122795, 0.007218464277684689, 0.009725271724164486, -0.0005661459290422499, 0.027088964357972145, 0.004848713055253029, -0.06936098635196686, 0.024483822286128998, 0.007599017582833767, 0.030094262212514877, 0.0008001474197953939, -0.023741036653518677, 0.021554244682192802, 0.11688701063394547, 0.0031631020829081535, -0.010501137003302574, -0.009853613562881947, 0.08154226094484329, -0.029750803485512733, 0.05727175623178482, 0.033846575766801834, 0.025556620210409164, -0.00891557615250349, 0.0072728306986391544, 0.036567434668540955, 0.03744127228856087, 0.009657854214310646, -0.024892784655094147, 0.008404656313359737, -0.028204595670104027, -0.002735705580562353, 0.007397239562124014, -0.00980543252080679, 0.014645188115537167, 0.03070206195116043, -0.044703397899866104, 0.04215715080499649, 0.03606092929840088, 0.02212553098797798, -0.04178803786635399, -0.03989729285240173, 0.02280154824256897, 0.0011971956118941307, -0.016536228358745575, -0.005353353451937437, -0.010475234128534794, -0.05135830491781235, -0.023805862292647362, -0.016681773588061333, 0.023401359096169472, 0.01697169616818428, -0.013898343779146671, -0.08340896666049957, -0.07946965098381042, 0.055704038590192795, 0.01837243139743805, -0.014618377201259136, 0.0582403801381588, -0.07651549577713013, -0.013593056239187717, -0.0037244611885398626, 0.03274114057421684, 0.04454781487584114, 0.030914010480046272, -0.05397491157054901, 0.021370641887187958, -0.005016525741666555, -0.021256398409605026, 0.05772819370031357, -0.013420063070952892, 0.0034329332411289215, 0.001172260963357985, 0.010492557659745216, -0.04882018268108368, 0.03804173693060875, 0.08620819449424744, 0.027915844693779945, -0.039965759962797165, -0.018047040328383446, 0.0009739777306094766, -0.0896059051156044, -0.0030101395677775145, -0.013534494675695896, -0.035396307706832886, -0.001445252331905067, 0.01261088065803051, -0.07898225635290146, 0.011344574391841888, -0.018594931811094284, -0.008774847723543644, -0.03637421503663063, 0.04873194545507431, 0.026121025905013084, 0.06675567477941513, 0.07217490673065186, -0.06467898190021515, 0.09220271557569504, 0.0325932614505291, -0.025135450065135956, -0.029892796650528908, -0.04113253206014633, -0.009240197949111462, 0.01852823980152607, -0.01399002131074667, 0.08531545847654343, -0.0012682538945227861, 0.01565961353480816, -0.03894321247935295, -0.07084467262029648, -0.05116003379225731, -0.033159490674734116, -0.004483981989324093, -0.09353071451187134, -0.011922096833586693, -0.03495068475604057, 0.03665798157453537, 0.01428113505244255, 0.053559064865112305, -0.04663302004337311, -0.03898267447948456, 0.007198425941169262, 0.006841579452157021, -0.007110312581062317, -0.008401165716350079, -0.0029168121982365847, -0.05686376616358757, 0.0015016959514468908, 0.04840995743870735, -0.021675681695342064, -0.06924851983785629, 0.07693164795637131, 0.019100215286016464, -0.05257001146674156, 0.03975442796945572, -0.013230947777628899, 0.0029676659032702446, 0.044508352875709534, 0.019836027175188065, 0.011122758500277996, 0.04376988112926483, -0.026694631204009056, -0.022025642916560173, 0.019604170694947243, -0.003935419023036957, 0.041700586676597595, 0.02265549637377262, 0.022244147956371307, 0.0030687928665429354, -0.043250128626823425, -0.007271535228937864, -0.0003890181251335889, 0.04545745998620987, 0.058163002133369446, 0.03412797302007675, -0.01693808287382126, -0.11890184134244919, -0.046994421631097794, 0.050761036574840546, -0.09068099409341812, -0.034737154841423035 ]
51
51
An efficient reduction of ranking to classification
This paper describes an efficient reduction of the learning problem of ranking to binary classification. The reduction guarantees an average pairwise misranking regret of at most that of the binary classifier regret, improving a recent result of Balcan et al which only guarantees a factor of 2. Moreover, our reduction applies to a broader class of ranking loss functions, admits a simpler proof, and the expected running time complexity of our algorithm in terms of number of calls to a classifier or preference function is improved from $\Omega(n^2)$ to $O(n \log n)$. In addition, when the top $k$ ranked elements only are required ($k \ll n$), as in many applications in information extraction or search engines, the time complexity of our algorithm can be further reduced to $O(k \log k + n)$. Our reduction and algorithm are thus practical for realistic applications where the number of points to rank exceeds several thousands. Much of our results also extend beyond the bipartite case previously studied. Our rediction is a randomized one. To complement our result, we also derive lower bounds on any deterministic reduction from binary (preference) classification to ranking, implying that our use of a randomized reduction is essentially necessary for the guarantees we provide.
[ -0.0033147763460874557, -0.023626964539289474, 0.10065194964408875, -0.020147666335105896, 0.027095304802060127, -0.017145445570349693, 0.02499298006296158, 0.03982815146446228, -0.08036485314369202, -0.02872685343027115, -0.025061726570129395, -0.01113311480730772, -0.05004727095365524, 0.0036742270458489656, 0.017971809953451157, -0.02440248243510723, -0.0442809984087944, -0.04597243294119835, 0.012900457717478275, -0.08244079351425171, 0.011284143663942814, -0.019444430246949196, -0.0006501358584500849, -0.042278826236724854, -0.002577498322352767, -0.04080875962972641, 0.004213569685816765, 0.01615818776190281, -0.03424886614084244, 0.011199106462299824, -0.03662693500518799, -0.04676692560315132, 0.006362282205373049, -0.005396374501287937, -0.014882873743772507, -0.07003585249185562, -0.011312724091112614, -0.0651019811630249, -0.04359009861946106, -0.03808216750621796, -0.017834825441241264, -0.06484941393136978, -0.008971452713012695, 0.05070185288786888, 0.02107507921755314, 0.001479978789575398, 0.03006650134921074, -0.05189355090260506, 0.02207929454743862, 0.05429677292704582, -0.06438495963811874, 0.0786614641547203, -0.021505096927285194, -0.041482113301754, 0.0730588436126709, -0.010178355500102043, -0.02710607461631298, -0.01824249140918255, -0.03452417626976967, -0.039622560143470764, 0.04076475650072098, 0.09490788727998734, 0.016508234664797783, -0.027222584933042526, -0.042264144867658615, 0.012207319028675556, -0.028658172115683556, 0.00900163222104311, -0.02140221931040287, 0.0034998494666069746, -0.01737336628139019, -0.048628393560647964, 0.04766125604510307, 0.06001925840973854, -0.006263808347284794, -0.0049646650440990925, 0.060351621359586716, -0.015639865770936012, 0.0658128634095192, 0.0528363473713398, -0.04527208209037781, 0.08277936279773712, -0.007352054584771395, 0.015375758521258831, -0.03180868551135063, -0.02810017019510269, 0.057887569069862366, -0.06541875749826431, 0.027581684291362762, -0.009394886903464794, -0.06784451007843018, -0.06474025547504425, -0.07566845417022705, 0.01865413412451744, -0.0745927020907402, 0.01894187368452549, -0.024718057364225388, -0.009344574995338917, 0.04218411073088646, 0.0824202299118042, 0.04257013648748398, -0.02123463712632656, -0.030309829860925674, 0.0572916679084301, -0.060420576483011246, 0.017251743003726006, -0.044440507888793945, 0.029653998091816902, 0.0408533550798893, -0.002877825405448675, 0.06014145910739899, -0.04717985540628433, -0.0011468016309663653, 0.007391242776066065, -0.004829748533666134, -0.028922853991389275, -0.04826194420456886, 0.045011572539806366, -0.03843197599053383, 0.002255620900541544, 0.040618330240249634, -0.007840350270271301, -0.07648324966430664, 0.00710030272603035, -0.004160847514867783, -0.11091211438179016, -0.06485775113105774, -0.0653979554772377, 0.07282742112874985, 0.030691420659422874, -0.09193872660398483, 0.0955347940325737, -0.05514977127313614, 0.016787957400083542, -0.07285276055335999, 0.004662619438022375, 0.09390962868928909, -0.030505914241075516, 0.017060410231351852, 0.10658710449934006, -0.048978012055158615, 0.04814755544066429, -0.04192563146352768, -0.011534417979419231, -0.007329228799790144, 0.019283819943666458, 0.010744176805019379, -0.010740887373685837, 0.0008059127721935511, -0.00006298022344708443, -0.030735516920685768, -0.02957683429121971, 0.027133015915751457, 0.0843735784292221, 0.03202709183096886, -0.017514284700155258, -0.05531235784292221, -0.00924154743552208, -0.02996826171875, 0.05839231610298157, 0.015943992882966995, -0.05816350132226944, 0.07913248986005783, 0.05195774510502815, -0.01710130088031292, 0.0409272164106369, -0.024592971429228783, 0.01837361976504326, 0.020113201811909676, -0.03488745912909508, 0.008308148011565208, 0.013894205912947655, -0.032714031636714935, 0.06717756390571594, 0.021596750244498253, -0.06077776849269867, 0.009089420549571514, -0.02204027958214283, -0.016455773264169693, -0.009479520842432976, 0.04947672411799431, -0.05267273262143135, -0.01720311865210533, 0.030087651684880257, 0.0276601854711771, 0.08848588168621063, 0.02272416092455387, 0.06256230175495148, 0.030087430030107498, 0.00163350161164999, 0.024521606042981148, -0.07754512131214142, 0.01878642663359642, 0.01580047234892845, -0.06976240873336792, 0.020320672541856766, -0.0013126775156706572, -0.03674162179231644, 0.01139969564974308, 0.009287397377192974, 0.04775496572256088, -0.002221528207883239, -0.08818651735782623, -0.022637121379375458, -0.02558191865682602, 0.005921574309468269, 0.044642332941293716, -0.059106286615133286, 0.005967321339994669, -0.07786128669977188, 0.03371032327413559, 0.03888556361198425, 0.02641468308866024, 0.012348762713372707, -0.027445679530501366, -0.08266174793243408, -0.048611268401145935, -0.06244518235325813, 0.07963915914297104, 0.05664679780602455, -0.0013831040123477578, 0.07828835397958755, -0.03650856018066406, 0.026526888832449913, -0.09732616692781448, 0.0034540363121777773, 0.08799385279417038, -0.01738067716360092, -0.07570943236351013, 0.06670497357845306, 0.004040576051920652, -0.04117927327752113, -0.019651910290122032, 0.033437371253967285, 0.004702853504568338, 0.011666737496852875, -0.08748980611562729, -0.03531181439757347, -0.04809337481856346, -0.06020567938685417, 0.015548928640782833, 0.05268754065036774, -0.04573032259941101, -0.036779534071683884, 0.03050917387008667, 0.01981479488313198, 0.04771546274423599, -0.01849489100277424, 0.020233629271388054, -0.01881449669599533, 0.021109815686941147, -0.01126083917915821, -0.006774046458303928, -0.03991834446787834, 0.054429225623607635, 0.03542713820934296, 0.02824229933321476, 0.06617768108844757, 0.05467488244175911, 0.04883907362818718, 0.016621747985482216, 0.013934359885752201, -0.037486542016267776, 0.0480811633169651, 0.017688019201159477, -0.007629911880940199, -0.05067502334713936, -0.024461830034852028, 0.01893814466893673, -0.027925344184041023, -0.008986327797174454, -0.06738343834877014, -0.05527468025684357, 0.0729609951376915, -0.04449474439024925, 0.031009014695882797, -0.006259751971811056, -0.021200720220804214, 0.06773260980844498, -0.01577545329928398, -0.12236499786376953, 0.042647432535886765, 0.07359720766544342, 0.057905830442905426, -0.011498666368424892, 0.010913312435150146, -0.0019711321219801903, -0.020660316571593285, 0.09298044443130493, 0.03113597072660923, -0.08750640600919724, 0.03019632026553154, -0.051100123673677444, -0.011634563095867634, 0.07636754959821701, -0.02887648344039917, 0.010019877925515175, 0.022863492369651794, 0.033350151032209396, 0.03396223857998848, -0.018520906567573547, -0.01526692882180214, 0.0927099958062172, 0.0816146656870842, 0.02523866668343544, 0.06800587475299835, 0.026479411870241165, 0.0006690289592370391, 0.0159212127327919, 0.00037638566573150456, 0.0010812857653945684, 0.008166326209902763, -0.010004347190260887, 0.04679913818836212, 0.018567828461527824, 0.01640459895133972, 0.015883686020970345, -0.04767787456512451, -0.02677224576473236, 0.0455884113907814, 0.033433519303798676, 0.028390150517225266, 0.02189071662724018, 0.028737366199493408, -0.08477755635976791, 0.0016741580329835415, 0.02663319744169712, 0.025595679879188538, -0.08189181983470917, 0.021065382286906242, -0.05466634780168533, -0.03251876309514046, 0.036229852586984634, 0.03205909579992294, -0.033609144389629364, 0.0698123574256897, -0.07248709350824356, -0.03016948327422142, 0.027940018102526665, 0.03221410512924194, -0.02513814903795719, -0.04866425693035126, -0.02657020464539528, 0.00484481593593955, 0.027577228844165802, 0.02740626037120819, 0.0461152158677578, -0.01030745729804039, 0.014521063305437565, 0.06243148446083069, -0.05655534937977791, 0.0432903878390789, -0.03169351816177368, 0.038102440536022186, 0.009915407747030258, 0.03408380225300789, 0.052704762667417526, -0.002633407711982727, 0.06671731173992157, 0.05668000131845474, 0.00986847747117281, 0.019179603084921837, -0.014645171351730824, 0.020528091117739677, 0.014682821929454803, 0.02794729173183441, -0.01141811441630125, -0.0035798223689198494, -0.04639631137251854, 0.05417579039931297, 0.04185064136981964, 0.036553263664245605, 0.011124907992780209, -0.028746040537953377, 0.015473793260753155, -0.054326821118593216, -0.039262183010578156, -0.024453500285744667, 0.03516257554292679, 0.07614477723836899, -0.0815642774105072, 0.04212718456983566, -0.019159749150276184, 0.008860738947987556, 0.029144667088985443, -0.026231836527585983, -0.03327033668756485, 0.004035311285406351, 0.12410993129014969, 0.018128305673599243, 0.10680388659238815, -0.08673078566789627, -0.006674169097095728, 0.05000852793455124, 0.04516680911183357, 0.007363605313003063, 0.027689987793564796, -0.0441911555826664, -0.029866335913538933, 0.0007603065459989011, 0.017084522172808647, -0.10373743623495102, -0.01657457835972309, -0.09177179634571075, -0.07108581811189651, 0.07743723690509796, 0.014541227370500565, 0.07191085070371628, -0.023920932784676552, -0.004350044298917055, -0.01097430381923914, 0.029087096452713013, -0.07177836447954178, -0.009524838998913765, -0.03637463599443436, 0.008702367544174194, 0.042285121977329254, -0.028182893991470337, -0.034574512392282486, -0.021430712193250656, 0.026215363293886185, 0.027936553582549095, 0.022335227578878403, -0.027341734617948532, -0.02236422523856163, 0.050461988896131516, 0.030086779966950417, 0.017657941207289696, -0.005589904263615608, 0.053643349558115005, 0.028791027143597603, -0.007604638114571571, -0.04113328456878662, -0.006695589516311884, 0.08939987421035767, -0.04704058915376663, 0.05063624680042267, 0.013245795853435993, -0.09037986397743225, -0.04530542716383934, -0.07838570326566696, -0.020541973412036896, 0.029957391321659088, 0.010766139253973961, 0.02899818681180477, 0.0714723989367485, 0.05727981775999069, -0.043665215373039246, 0.0678362026810646, 0.016777586191892624, 0.06068168580532074, -0.014247101731598377, 0.048092156648635864, -0.033463090658187866, -0.06543099135160446, -0.07258345931768417, 0.0034024349879473448, -0.01503440085798502, 0.03523493558168411, -0.07457069307565689, -0.055068716406822205, -0.053071603178977966, 0.04344773292541504, 0.015240337699651718, 0.0038498048670589924, -0.010353432036936283, 0.03494863212108612, -0.016051527112722397, 0.11152936518192291, -0.0023789589758962393, -0.07150212675333023, 0.05044307932257652, -0.007782898843288422, -0.04663585126399994, -0.027889855206012726, -0.005151405464857817, -0.015028754249215126, -0.025734946131706238, -0.016786769032478333, -0.014160187914967537, 0.003611526684835553, -0.040169984102249146, -0.00399992149323225, 0.01902453601360321, 0.1075035110116005, -0.04561811313033104, -0.03406943008303642, 0.0602557435631752, 0.0237850584089756, 0.04681035876274109, -0.010920881293714046, 0.010561754927039146, 0.05930456519126892, 0.0033124787732958794, 0.03202911093831062, -0.014447920024394989, 0.0634823888540268, 0.03175213187932968, -0.007510888855904341, 0.09672793000936508, -0.008018271997570992, 0.005810991395264864, 0.01975247822701931, 0.01978810876607895, 0.06348596513271332, 0.05517188459634781, 0.024123966693878174, -0.005350110121071339, 0.03660448640584946, 0.03590237349271774, -0.011736057698726654, -0.07206860184669495 ]
52
52
Combining haplotypers
Statistically resolving the underlying haplotype pair for a genotype measurement is an important intermediate step in gene mapping studies, and has received much attention recently. Consequently, a variety of methods for this problem have been developed. Different methods employ different statistical models, and thus implicitly encode different assumptions about the nature of the underlying haplotype structure. Depending on the population sample in question, their relative performance can vary greatly, and it is unclear which method to choose for a particular sample. Instead of choosing a single method, we explore combining predictions returned by different methods in a principled way, and thereby circumvent the problem of method selection. We propose several techniques for combining haplotype reconstructions and analyze their computational properties. In an experimental study on real-world haplotype data we show that such techniques can provide more accurate and robust reconstructions, and are useful for outlier detection. Typically, the combined prediction is at least as accurate as or even more accurate than the best individual method, effectively circumventing the method selection problem.
[ 0.03578975051641464, -0.05006498470902443, -0.0015279630897566676, -0.00482373870909214, -0.014016153290867805, 0.06309997290372849, 0.03725148364901543, -0.0719473585486412, 0.030531665310263634, 0.017950495705008507, 0.005016442388296127, -0.06015867367386818, -0.031085655093193054, -0.026579977944493294, -0.041845712810754776, 0.06331460922956467, -0.06984780728816986, -0.055974606424570084, 0.08583231270313263, 0.03011644072830677, -0.005628994666039944, 0.022784903645515442, -0.07110130786895752, 0.014415666460990906, 0.019017554819583893, 0.08240364491939545, 0.012448457069694996, 0.0322992280125618, -0.04297608882188797, 0.0701562687754631, -0.008742359466850758, -0.0008471079054288566, 0.05722936987876892, -0.009810714982450008, 0.01263524778187275, -0.019660228863358498, 0.03364088013768196, 0.005318177863955498, -0.004295684397220612, -0.022908473387360573, 0.006411660462617874, -0.0952715277671814, -0.0055199842900037766, -0.02680790424346924, -0.05272503197193146, 0.0017017436912283301, 0.03171389549970627, 0.05649944022297859, 0.014814725145697594, 0.04404304921627045, -0.02480250597000122, -0.006462497636675835, -0.024221519008278847, 0.022064438089728355, -0.026806168258190155, 0.046146053820848465, -0.06239793822169304, -0.005818606819957495, -0.04161512106657028, 0.01936337910592556, 0.04005580395460129, 0.09154529869556427, -0.011493666097521782, -0.021764276549220085, -0.035822927951812744, 0.012487522326409817, -0.06620384752750397, -0.021178411319851875, -0.08105208724737167, -0.030002444982528687, 0.04180941358208656, -0.025115102529525757, 0.06894443929195404, -0.011281879618763924, 0.044679440557956696, -0.026826484128832817, 0.05944802239537239, -0.01542752981185913, 0.0037008142098784447, 0.05336485058069229, -0.045219093561172485, 0.029511546716094017, 0.04984874278306961, -0.00690351240336895, -0.02149258926510811, 0.018717465922236443, 0.030431093648076057, -0.01972009614109993, 0.05170895531773567, 0.0014241302851587534, -0.04230489209294319, -0.037069857120513916, -0.03417699784040451, 0.07066737860441208, -0.0352458581328392, -0.024542950093746185, 0.017363034188747406, 0.03494644537568092, 0.019383840262889862, 0.027644434943795204, -0.036059826612472534, -0.05784093588590622, 0.0359608419239521, 0.038436152040958405, -0.03921201080083847, 0.0400189533829689, -0.06984687596559525, 0.08658384531736374, -0.062442462891340256, -0.04583122208714485, 0.012759952805936337, -0.04605767875909805, 0.007495544385164976, -0.008471229113638401, -0.0032554760109633207, 0.05727437883615494, -0.04347681626677513, 0.04531744495034218, 0.00026358148897998035, -0.028672903776168823, 0.01571175642311573, -0.010521763935685158, 0.009121331386268139, 0.026574160903692245, 0.06307824701070786, -0.03764747828245163, -0.011326467618346214, -0.04029853641986847, 0.018937332555651665, -0.018830763176083565, -0.051065776497125626, 0.11191228032112122, -0.023371757939457893, -0.009221806190907955, -0.05598833039402962, 0.017843183130025864, -0.009813115000724792, -0.006295251194387674, -0.0043356409296393394, 0.03751255199313164, -0.013204156421124935, 0.0474439337849617, -0.029856322333216667, 0.022216882556676865, -0.008699056692421436, -0.01995980180799961, -0.030688507482409477, -0.004546004813164473, -0.05885409936308861, 0.027928918600082397, -0.013460194692015648, -0.08220280706882477, 0.02640669234097004, 0.039411935955286026, -0.012683128006756306, 0.01928112469613552, -0.04618317633867264, -0.01624470390379429, -0.0015486158663406968, 0.04784804955124855, -0.04982883110642433, 0.033220432698726654, -0.017215585336089134, 0.023693526163697243, 0.027822524309158325, 0.06005297973752022, -0.029103679582476616, -0.03189811110496521, -0.01736290194094181, -0.02896009013056755, 0.03711957857012749, 0.013261492364108562, -0.005113731138408184, 0.02533865161240101, 0.0460374541580677, 0.020858364179730415, 0.027600711211562157, -0.00010921043576672673, -0.03957754746079445, 0.030702080577611923, -0.026421234011650085, -0.0927048996090889, -0.05026879534125328, -0.031062506139278412, 0.03402389585971832, 0.13421951234340668, 0.02046247199177742, -0.03328501805663109, 0.0008107901085168123, 0.009064439684152603, -0.010761949233710766, 0.09725762158632278, -0.028305018320679665, -0.017999982461333275, -0.04600149393081665, 0.004615836776793003, -0.04262736067175865, 0.002895695623010397, 0.005628828424960375, -0.004840184934437275, 0.018328651785850525, -0.04869483411312103, -0.01087123341858387, -0.029771065339446068, 0.015182139351963997, 0.09801314771175385, 0.0222114659845829, -0.054826442152261734, 0.005212591029703617, -0.048409249633550644, 0.07434076815843582, -0.0029835014138370752, 0.03803050518035889, -0.04125436767935753, -0.009569349698722363, -0.02246895432472229, -0.03206798806786537, -0.08688995242118835, 0.029297789558768272, 0.007784578017890453, 0.001680175308138132, 0.0630180835723877, -0.05249553918838501, 0.059429723769426346, -0.03516107425093651, -0.002192419720813632, -0.026938388124108315, 0.030253233388066292, -0.03180265054106712, -0.10411254316568375, -0.028333334252238274, -0.07096435129642487, -0.031320564448833466, -0.0634644404053688, -0.08054322004318237, 0.036350179463624954, -0.12024948000907898, -0.00047221564454957843, 0.009323421865701675, 0.009706143289804459, -0.02183869294822216, 0.03821874409914017, -0.033738188445568085, -0.01515820063650608, 0.004234877415001392, 0.015747297555208206, -0.013582107611000538, 0.00776444049552083, 0.03557562455534935, 0.01790568418800831, 0.05385587736964226, 0.007245243061333895, -0.06697956472635269, -0.00425488967448473, 0.05058380216360092, -0.051717713475227356, 0.01019434817135334, -0.034461162984371185, 0.009655997157096863, 0.13716654479503632, 0.005359522067010403, 0.046311430633068085, -0.01993945799767971, -0.036138229072093964, 0.05372436344623566, -0.025367243215441704, -0.07512078434228897, 0.025701265782117844, -0.06265562027692795, 0.047190070152282715, 0.04184349998831749, -0.10679804533720016, -0.03547903150320053, 0.020753374323248863, -0.06908706575632095, -0.08965382725000381, 0.09511912614107132, 0.00832265242934227, 0.026703815907239914, -0.014980845153331757, -0.10263941437005997, -0.01056451816111803, 0.02574826218187809, 0.03269674628973007, -0.02292533405125141, -0.053940221667289734, -0.06273721158504486, 0.008711853995919228, -0.04391328990459442, 0.011610923334956169, -0.038484662771224976, 0.04279503971338272, -0.07492431998252869, -0.01197388581931591, 0.05107739940285683, -0.03282773867249489, 0.006836426444351673, -0.01981050707399845, 0.12453868240118027, -0.022552570328116417, -0.018710201606154442, 0.0014925553696230054, -0.04711780697107315, -0.0046124206855893135, 0.04159049689769745, 0.04443962499499321, 0.05582619085907936, 0.0035666092298924923, -0.017831167206168175, -0.13169346749782562, 0.015214458107948303, -0.0883006677031517, -0.03268803656101227, 0.003056089859455824, 0.013581378385424614, -0.13767214119434357, -0.07671736925840378, 0.038339763879776, 0.04651419818401337, -0.002542920410633087, -0.0018521635793149471, -0.01930093578994274, -0.016635192558169365, -0.016621151939034462, 0.014131070114672184, -0.03944716975092888, -0.028678899630904198, 0.020610596984624863, -0.00732665928080678, 0.022893136367201805, -0.08832305669784546, -0.019986512139439583, -0.029542231932282448, 0.13047535717487335, -0.05356227979063988, -0.041571471840143204, 0.043558936566114426, 0.03787403926253319, -0.0018722766544669867, 0.0312839113175869, -0.05243484675884247, -0.017058974131941795, 0.04533025249838829, 0.044237326830625534, -0.0046032024547457695, 0.04125693067908287, 0.11967232078313828, 0.03749200329184532, 0.05926433578133583, -0.05015520751476288, -0.007576391100883484, -0.02561836689710617, 0.008028759621083736, 0.04084103927016258, 0.02506054751574993, 0.0324799083173275, 0.0022354312241077423, -0.003726878436282277, 0.028672663494944572, 0.10326634347438812, -0.03993264213204384, -0.011027093045413494, -0.04362141713500023, 0.05114848539233208, 0.05074615404009819, 0.06603078544139862, 0.015604903921484947, 0.0006041268352419138, 0.0029338307213038206, 0.058428023010492325, -0.02140713855624199, 0.006416566204279661, -0.012940595857799053, 0.00763917900621891, -0.04238825663924217, -0.012628048658370972, -0.004425605293363333, 0.008839646354317665, 0.032417625188827515, 0.0777282640337944, -0.045383092015981674, 0.05679499730467796, 0.004315026104450226, 0.005955872125923634, 0.028420310467481613, 0.008046897128224373, -0.07806844264268875, 0.01327804010361433, 0.019009999930858612, 0.030009282752871513, -0.07064958661794662, -0.018468666821718216, -0.09591534733772278, 0.048083312809467316, 0.02260250225663185, 0.0527198426425457, -0.017628483474254608, -0.038689129054546356, -0.000005931788109592162, -0.018170438706874847, -0.03822684660553932, -0.04443272575736046, 0.007036006543785334, -0.06783722341060638, -0.09496921300888062, 0.005214242730289698, -0.011813678778707981, 0.09752845019102097, -0.043226804584264755, 0.03672609478235245, -0.016442207619547844, 0.0713999941945076, -0.028097419068217278, 0.04205288738012314, 0.054178476333618164, 0.04107314348220825, -0.010899879969656467, -0.021076321601867676, -0.07224075496196747, -0.030912239104509354, 0.060691799968481064, -0.04341891407966614, 0.006224936805665493, -0.0075211599469184875, 0.012499862350523472, -0.0403716042637825, 0.06175931170582771, -0.07648415863513947, 0.022412771359086037, 0.013024811632931232, 0.029112089425325394, -0.032376788556575775, -0.029633546248078346, 0.026400865986943245, 0.09064020961523056, 0.019916698336601257, 0.037981756031513214, -0.09821876138448715, -0.005994564387947321, 0.07207625359296799, -0.07372979074716568, 0.01582447998225689, -0.06177467107772827, 0.02130110003054142, -0.04984693229198456, 0.022152351215481758, 0.021347714588046074, 0.032969579100608826, 0.008575177751481533, 0.002600585576146841, 0.023085035383701324, 0.07262012362480164, -0.03829626739025116, 0.01270652562379837, -0.01097171101719141, -0.010904824361205101, -0.029401719570159912, -0.021654080599546432, 0.08254864811897278, -0.006796734873205423, -0.03861838951706886, -0.06298898905515671, -0.03050636127591133, -0.03993698209524155, -0.026572512462735176, -0.03466692939400673, -0.030660727992653847, 0.023724284023046494, 0.09012150764465332, 0.04408848285675049, -0.031842753291130066, 0.012896247208118439, 0.04683041200041771, -0.026064256206154823, 0.05232197418808937, -0.02086189016699791, 0.04851941391825676, -0.022139322012662888, 0.016773542389273643, -0.013081900775432587, 0.03001421131193638, 0.02457992173731327, 0.043432753533124924, -0.02867467887699604, 0.04658428952097893, 0.042727820575237274, -0.10213438421487808, -0.039491672068834305, 0.04487661272287369, -0.0008001311798579991, -0.021909411996603012, 0.03269077092409134, 0.0412398986518383, -0.02668665535748005, 0.017069246619939804, 0.044622503221035004, -0.09064362198114395, 0.01267282385379076, 0.01878190040588379, -0.03148858994245529, -0.018826773390173912, -0.03702154755592346, 0.004347243811935186, 0.03160348907113075, 0.059416916221380234, 0.042951419949531555, -0.029651692137122154, -0.01802685298025608, -0.06782269477844238, -0.025082221254706383, -0.0777478963136673, -0.030334990471601486 ]
53
53
A Tutorial on Spectral Clustering
In recent years, spectral clustering has become one of the most popular modern clustering algorithms. It is simple to implement, can be solved efficiently by standard linear algebra software, and very often outperforms traditional clustering algorithms such as the k-means algorithm. On the first glance spectral clustering appears slightly mysterious, and it is not obvious to see why it works at all and what it really does. The goal of this tutorial is to give some intuition on those questions. We describe different graph Laplacians and their basic properties, present the most common spectral clustering algorithms, and derive those algorithms from scratch by several different approaches. Advantages and disadvantages of the different spectral clustering algorithms are discussed.
[ 0.008244630880653858, -0.039867810904979706, 0.006940506398677826, 0.013794087804853916, -0.020365163683891296, -0.002862974302843213, 0.07425487041473389, -0.053423602133989334, -0.05260717123746872, 0.04484042897820473, 0.011492777615785599, -0.048286713659763336, -0.053048793226480484, 0.12201109528541565, -0.004954923875629902, 0.02509443834424019, -0.008400858379900455, 0.03568059951066971, 0.043713100254535675, -0.013847018592059612, 0.018961653113365173, -0.018369168043136597, 0.027538681402802467, -0.051485173404216766, 0.062044672667980194, 0.0050428928807377815, -0.01426729280501604, -0.003845539642497897, -0.009464624337852001, 0.03507624939084053, -0.02933521382510662, 0.042000893503427505, 0.027461888268589973, -0.0008978149853646755, 0.011546771973371506, 0.017450330778956413, 0.03836001828312874, 0.020557826384902, -0.05332150682806969, -0.006913383025676012, 0.007957341149449348, 0.013105783611536026, 0.010186533443629742, -0.000987908337265253, 0.007308633532375097, -0.013336936943233013, -0.016071395948529243, -0.022837979719042778, 0.042543426156044006, 0.03644769266247749, -0.09041713923215866, 0.015460100956261158, -0.09711366146802902, 0.009974731132388115, -0.03204422816634178, -0.03111184574663639, 0.007660905830562115, 0.018340827897191048, -0.01515357755124569, -0.001741649815812707, 0.06139371544122696, 0.07235092669725418, -0.0398591123521328, -0.02559274062514305, -0.07125812023878098, -0.08763729780912399, 0.03634187951683998, -0.06390562653541565, -0.07895468920469284, -0.04949791356921196, -0.009302850812673569, -0.03144622594118118, -0.019297871738672256, 0.07814951241016388, -0.022517837584018707, 0.05809096246957779, -0.02162998728454113, -0.001630918588489294, -0.018462641164660454, 0.08396567404270172, 0.03155720606446266, 0.019261455163359642, 0.07440439611673355, -0.018028350546956062, -0.12196805328130722, -0.030170880258083344, 0.05479150265455246, 0.013436809182167053, 0.01623278483748436, 0.029519448056817055, -0.05631664767861366, -0.04403417184948921, -0.008037320338189602, 0.057469144463539124, -0.03676525503396988, 0.015648040920495987, -0.050983279943466187, -0.06001870706677437, 0.03684522956609726, 0.07653617113828659, -0.10181273519992828, -0.038137584924697876, 0.06220349669456482, 0.08621759712696075, -0.023030005395412445, 0.03847244009375572, -0.0704355463385582, 0.0046072485856711864, 0.030051449313759804, 0.04552559182047844, -0.022521018981933594, -0.004157297313213348, -0.02251676842570305, 0.040657732635736465, -0.024929098784923553, 0.014023900963366032, -0.046748727560043335, 0.11707187443971634, 0.01146222185343504, 0.026928560808300972, -0.0018946941709145904, 0.004259001929312944, -0.0835421234369278, -0.014930873177945614, 0.0382537879049778, -0.02096509002149105, -0.006163064856082201, 0.0053095826879143715, 0.02098298817873001, 0.016565529629588127, -0.00033957406412810087, -0.017905624583363533, -0.07176247984170914, 0.018534135073423386, -0.08554921299219131, -0.0387059785425663, 0.04915459826588631, -0.03505256772041321, 0.02141411602497101, 0.051521774381399155, 0.00019138162315357476, -0.04289605841040611, -0.04084440693259239, -0.0020720355678349733, 0.09592464566230774, 0.03627800568938255, -0.01583552174270153, 0.050547607243061066, 0.041545480489730835, 0.023551829159259796, -0.023799695074558258, -0.0911562517285347, -0.005617040209472179, 0.03567810356616974, 0.023607276380062103, -0.003888216568157077, -0.013415823690593243, -0.04112064465880394, 0.017250053584575653, 0.04321785643696785, -0.05914444476366043, 0.04625806584954262, -0.023356931284070015, 0.01761053502559662, 0.06331808120012283, 0.05707786977291107, -0.056484900414943695, -0.008968234062194824, 0.006627366412431002, -0.05916426703333855, 0.06256090104579926, -0.017473911866545677, -0.028861507773399353, 0.010976984165608883, 0.006526010110974312, -0.009415552020072937, 0.004372183699160814, -0.014882861636579037, 0.03100663051009178, -0.029519066214561462, 0.06852114945650101, 0.015294874086976051, -0.03686589002609253, 0.024320289492607117, -0.0036653003189712763, 0.13118945062160492, 0.0124979168176651, 0.008378819562494755, 0.0612831711769104, 0.052494920790195465, 0.03940267115831375, -0.012442476116120815, 0.006240490823984146, -0.0052042677998542786, -0.030130485072731972, 0.04257752746343613, -0.029128026217222214, -0.06877551227807999, 0.006618749815970659, 0.036356739699840546, 0.045550763607025146, 0.004636385012418032, -0.043115001171827316, -0.06448667496442795, -0.04232119396328926, -0.00079274334711954, -0.011540592648088932, -0.016871368512511253, -0.0672406256198883, 0.015202024951577187, 0.027479812502861023, 0.028902053833007812, 0.03178700432181358, 0.03668108209967613, -0.04611713066697121, 0.04064829647541046, -0.06374658644199371, -0.038682617247104645, 0.04280342906713486, 0.06620730459690094, -0.0394866019487381, 0.05497602000832558, 0.019096439704298973, 0.011574767529964447, -0.0512557327747345, 0.02179357409477234, -0.023799333721399307, 0.026545846834778786, -0.0624096654355526, -0.02137826941907406, -0.06438776850700378, -0.000367353786714375, -0.040673792362213135, 0.030494583770632744, 0.06455348432064056, 0.03603406623005867, -0.00025100898346863687, 0.03799278661608696, -0.004146748688071966, 0.051501449197530746, 0.03192988038063049, -0.007749918382614851, 0.0049026645720005035, -0.06219707429409027, -0.0010495983297005296, 0.03991452604532242, -0.018029818311333656, 0.07598807662725449, 0.004502860829234123, -0.006507894489914179, -0.05609281733632088, 0.016654526814818382, -0.053819794207811356, 0.004127483814954758, 0.03388825058937073, -0.029754778370261192, -0.05069562792778015, 0.04491313919425011, 0.18204212188720703, 0.10110421478748322, -0.06156076863408089, 0.011774652637541294, -0.013875269331037998, 0.00200387230142951, 0.08783647418022156, 0.08112195134162903, 0.03183022886514664, 0.008335357531905174, -0.08081788569688797, 0.06636149436235428, 0.05540788173675537, -0.08883148431777954, -0.06103203445672989, 0.06757035106420517, -0.0024598930031061172, -0.016655033454298973, 0.0546758733689785, 0.06066302955150604, -0.03153742849826813, -0.047314759343862534, -0.06510800868272781, 0.005297218915075064, 0.009573416784405708, -0.04875965788960457, 0.0015242876252159476, 0.01204778254032135, -0.00041918078204616904, -0.08751945942640305, 0.032512422651052475, 0.028383634984493256, 0.042363639920949936, 0.04302544146776199, -0.0630304142832756, 0.03227467089891434, -0.032609723508358, -0.09748705476522446, 0.03352632373571396, 0.014542394317686558, 0.07360286265611649, -0.04463360458612442, 0.0440589003264904, 0.007263549137860537, 0.00521467998623848, 0.04603900760412216, 0.03586682677268982, 0.04741532728075981, 0.0908346101641655, 0.031472980976104736, -0.036168914288282394, -0.024667516350746155, 0.06902411580085754, -0.031079240143299103, -0.03587557375431061, 0.014957111328840256, -0.015765419229865074, -0.0154188247397542, -0.012722162529826164, 0.03241497278213501, -0.048601265996694565, 0.024851642549037933, 0.046048879623413086, 0.06891199946403503, 0.012670300900936127, -0.05112600699067116, -0.00496037257835269, 0.004334670025855303, 0.07538767904043198, 0.05940680205821991, -0.07342945784330368, -0.045992571860551834, -0.0576733723282814, -0.05473487079143524, 0.04064236953854561, 0.07092399150133133, 0.07937102764844894, -0.054929468780756, -0.09641707688570023, -0.0017669780645519495, 0.022672127932310104, 0.004164379555732012, 0.0016222894191741943, 0.03810534253716469, -0.033976513892412186, 0.012417018413543701, 0.051592834293842316, 0.04972917586565018, 0.058049947023391724, -0.07675721496343613, -0.02776360511779785, 0.021468717604875565, -0.14620576798915863, 0.02449585311114788, -0.04632135108113289, 0.0020580573473125696, 0.023858701810240746, 0.02461359091103077, 0.029596956446766853, 0.011992575600743294, -0.00944632850587368, 0.017074277624487877, 0.019479844719171524, -0.029286742210388184, -0.008522520773112774, 0.0898023247718811, 0.014320285059511662, 0.09216216951608658, 0.007527498994022608, 0.006517374888062477, -0.043413497507572174, -0.02560942806303501, 0.0814579650759697, -0.014991655014455318, -0.021924611181020737, 0.0069568282924592495, 0.06884568184614182, -0.03120926208794117, -0.03980332612991333, -0.05811788886785507, -0.06032942980527878, 0.007296395022422075, -0.046740103513002396, 0.0780339241027832, -0.07182266563177109, -0.005657673347741365, -0.0029452615417540073, 0.07571227848529816, -0.0023826470132917166, -0.01713337004184723, -0.03064081445336342, 0.05260040983557701, 0.02033218927681446, -0.03935590386390686, -0.045159973204135895, -0.013245029374957085, 0.0843580812215805, -0.004033314995467663, -0.019136719405651093, -0.025938279926776886, 0.00444462476298213, 0.028802145272493362, 0.00001706567854853347, 0.03830510005354881, -0.030614368617534637, -0.07954517751932144, -0.046872902661561966, 0.05185232684016228, -0.007159782107919455, 0.012416061013936996, 0.01799056865274906, 0.05729962885379791, -0.01852131262421608, 0.04028036817908287, -0.040994010865688324, 0.036674197763204575, 0.06484828889369965, 0.012738835997879505, -0.010325425304472446, 0.02472054585814476, 0.03610909357666969, -0.019671019166707993, 0.034269288182258606, -0.018160337582230568, -0.013488111086189747, -0.03508875146508217, -0.016345428302884102, -0.021577676758170128, 0.033200182020664215, 0.06421495229005814, 0.026955150067806244, 0.057570893317461014, -0.036275506019592285, -0.008940926752984524, -0.0637957975268364, 0.018085766583681107, 0.10324226319789886, -0.02250143513083458, 0.0060282135382294655, -0.06777041405439377, -0.0002680987527128309, 0.0006620762869715691, 0.010998125188052654, 0.04105669632554054, -0.058962833136320114, -0.04474137723445892, -0.04133591428399086, 0.08281110227108002, 0.06669524312019348, -0.008790992200374603, 0.036184754222631454, 0.06025387719273567, 0.008482195436954498, 0.015943506732583046, 0.025960152968764305, 0.04057532176375389, -0.02909887209534645, -0.022534623742103577, 0.02511969767510891, -0.05308876186609268, 0.043060775846242905, -0.05653688684105873, -0.02022763155400753, 0.0029902274254709482, -0.01729556918144226, -0.019045893102884293, -0.022202305495738983, 0.02038719318807125, -0.061627354472875595, 0.05593612790107727, -0.023120703175663948, -0.03039952740073204, -0.022366562858223915, 0.015428461134433746, -0.006937673781067133, -0.012529612518846989, 0.005751314107328653, 0.035049352794885635, 0.0017970898188650608, -0.03111852891743183, -0.03442719951272011, -0.005124391056597233, 0.02925133891403675, 0.018845975399017334, 0.03283762186765671, 0.032596707344055176, 0.040647152811288834, 0.030776768922805786, 0.014163767918944359, 0.014246199280023575, 0.050687938928604126, -0.042847830802202225, 0.05169830098748207, -0.02693154290318489, -0.024199815467000008, -0.023576579988002777, -0.09097916632890701, 0.04002853482961655, 0.008997507393360138, -0.01944868639111519, -0.012696424499154091, -0.005111318547278643, -0.013935782015323639, -0.07242706418037415, 0.04459597170352936, 0.06466206163167953, -0.03304233402013779, -0.0012363826390355825, 0.05562708154320717, 0.012555072084069252, -0.040802963078022, 0.05611418932676315, -0.040623050183057785, -0.06552371382713318 ]
54
54
Building Rules on Top of Ontologies for the Semantic Web with Inductive Logic Programming
Building rules on top of ontologies is the ultimate goal of the logical layer of the Semantic Web. To this aim an ad-hoc mark-up language for this layer is currently under discussion. It is intended to follow the tradition of hybrid knowledge representation and reasoning systems such as $\mathcal{AL}$-log that integrates the description logic $\mathcal{ALC}$ and the function-free Horn clausal language \textsc{Datalog}. In this paper we consider the problem of automating the acquisition of these rules for the Semantic Web. We propose a general framework for rule induction that adopts the methodological apparatus of Inductive Logic Programming and relies on the expressive and deductive power of $\mathcal{AL}$-log. The framework is valid whatever the scope of induction (description vs. prediction) is. Yet, for illustrative purposes, we also discuss an instantiation of the framework which aims at description and turns out to be useful in Ontology Refinement. Keywords: Inductive Logic Programming, Hybrid Knowledge Representation and Reasoning Systems, Ontologies, Semantic Web. Note: To appear in Theory and Practice of Logic Programming (TPLP)
[ -0.050167929381132126, -0.0366603285074234, 0.09161526709794998, 0.009944495745003223, -0.003001070348545909, -0.04364808276295662, -0.007067567203193903, -0.04285888373851776, -0.008100014179944992, -0.023979002609848976, -0.001773857744410634, -0.00829998403787613, -0.0023612745571881533, 0.060802608728408813, 0.0232198815792799, 0.040403977036476135, 0.019252890720963478, 0.01901364140212536, 0.004730354528874159, 0.016145795583724976, 0.0007428873796015978, 0.020051384344697, -0.05486472696065903, -0.040309466421604156, -0.012947513721883297, 0.02494843862950802, -0.05687011405825615, -0.01870386116206646, 0.015935814008116722, -0.012620268389582634, -0.09673307090997696, -0.0008806873229332268, 0.04397773742675781, 0.01335027627646923, 0.01416134461760521, 0.03880976885557175, -0.0297956932336092, 0.013318846002221107, -0.04995815455913544, 0.014765006490051746, 0.06162482872605324, -0.0035002899821847677, -0.009956222958862782, 0.03828359767794609, 0.023857740685343742, 0.04868758097290993, -0.01590011455118656, -0.0847427025437355, 0.008644680492579937, 0.06711678206920624, -0.04907062649726868, 0.06822703778743744, -0.06914538890123367, 0.0035526170395314693, -0.03805996850132942, 0.014243791811168194, 0.015156973153352737, 0.03443334251642227, 0.024692082777619362, 0.03508759289979935, -0.02004450187087059, 0.07491691410541534, -0.014194367453455925, -0.027618734166026115, -0.086366668343544, 0.00514642521739006, 0.013967961072921753, 0.004054197110235691, -0.024011189118027687, 0.02819797210395336, -0.048626869916915894, -0.03604097664356232, 0.06769824773073196, 0.07256782799959183, 0.05066300928592682, 0.028730588033795357, -0.019757352769374847, -0.011457158252596855, -0.05129391700029373, 0.03681965917348862, -0.0040415613912045956, 0.04303251951932907, -0.03374006226658821, -0.07438750565052032, -0.03923063725233078, 0.035416606813669205, 0.04904374107718468, -0.07182081788778305, -0.009986734949052334, -0.04097559675574303, -0.020410628989338875, 0.004324642475694418, -0.004836350213736296, 0.0215905848890543, -0.047883134335279465, 0.0481843501329422, -0.036563530564308167, -0.005776910576969385, -0.004613117780536413, -0.0028753571677953005, 0.03402518853545189, 0.009960625320672989, 0.038454242050647736, -0.011046825908124447, -0.033907148987054825, 0.022585542872548103, 0.05275988578796387, -0.019629424437880516, -0.0002145327889593318, 0.002618307713419199, 0.0473257377743721, 0.03300128132104874, 0.05483900010585785, 0.013042922131717205, -0.0298321433365345, 0.03442196547985077, -0.04304846003651619, 0.11034760624170303, 0.05427175387740135, 0.04611503705382347, -0.08703193068504333, 0.033311907202005386, 0.014228036627173424, -0.0018172370037063956, 0.06175321713089943, -0.0364454910159111, -0.11691050976514816, -0.039100855588912964, 0.06831827014684677, -0.0421152338385582, -0.023449743166565895, 0.03414870426058769, -0.09069440513849258, 0.029564663767814636, -0.06453607976436615, -0.019747400656342506, 0.018892092630267143, 0.011283257976174355, -0.006538596004247665, -0.03792232647538185, 0.004001924768090248, -0.007873130030930042, -0.0006031623343005776, -0.10188710689544678, 0.0072221914306283, 0.03660624101758003, -0.05703608691692352, -0.04178624600172043, 0.09354624152183533, -0.0520164892077446, -0.06771282106637955, 0.010296311229467392, 0.06258244812488556, 0.05047405883669853, 0.000475341803394258, -0.01184176653623581, 0.0006986827356740832, 0.03088429570198059, -0.04087857902050018, -0.0037085518706589937, 0.0006462372839450836, 0.03136036545038223, -0.05616646260023117, 0.07045609503984451, 0.05189340561628342, 0.04166068136692047, -0.04611023887991905, -0.038649626076221466, -0.01843257248401642, -0.09317047148942947, -0.0007513369782827795, 0.06009071692824364, 0.04772903397679329, 0.008410542272031307, 0.06776618957519531, -0.07076914608478546, 0.0017157911788672209, -0.036887697875499725, -0.08015977591276169, -0.078610859811306, 0.025344543159008026, -0.05235446244478226, 0.014201406389474869, -0.019273929297924042, -0.010788417421281338, 0.04869157448410988, -0.016735099256038666, 0.0873662456870079, 0.013531683944165707, 0.05462926626205444, -0.014175907708704472, 0.05792606621980667, -0.004235969856381416, 0.029160823673009872, -0.08852322399616241, -0.057902418076992035, -0.008252917788922787, 0.06738518178462982, -0.0483788438141346, 0.005807920824736357, 0.0007702868897467852, -0.02031916007399559, -0.08813955634832382, -0.045022111386060715, -0.050172291696071625, 0.010515318252146244, 0.04451087862253189, -0.03432142361998558, -0.05749151483178139, -0.007846556603908539, 0.016771884635090828, 0.02997090294957161, -0.04920026659965515, -0.025208162143826485, 0.02641461417078972, -0.058795396238565445, -0.07070890814065933, -0.034001078456640244, 0.13978521525859833, 0.024783631786704063, 0.003391850972548127, 0.04927424341440201, 0.014637022279202938, 0.09127833694219589, -0.03447090834379196, -0.030798926949501038, -0.03961929678916931, -0.10764234513044357, -0.016755361109972, -0.008090319111943245, -0.03776823356747627, 0.0008491516928188503, -0.0692920982837677, -0.01331738568842411, 0.05191245675086975, 0.018160635605454445, 0.0731888934969902, 0.012679710052907467, -0.040474165230989456, 0.025564057752490044, -0.01374142151325941, 0.006804381962865591, -0.056004445999860764, -0.023742511868476868, 0.006960321683436632, -0.0011972873471677303, 0.0009871204383671284, -0.0012906959746032953, -0.022456180304288864, -0.073367178440094, -0.027681905776262283, -0.03239358961582184, -0.09667971730232239, 0.03506723791360855, 0.015653397887945175, 0.11346889287233353, -0.04010044410824776, 0.04581819474697113, 0.053725507110357285, 0.09746266156435013, -0.06243973970413208, -0.010812344029545784, -0.09152108430862427, -0.010412054136395454, 0.012932867743074894, 0.046564459800720215, -0.0024634464643895626, 0.01085606124252081, 0.008304452523589134, 0.007634501438587904, -0.013427557423710823, -0.042127713561058044, -0.015421953983604908, -0.0064326184801757336, -0.02466028369963169, 0.001339030684903264, -0.017803838476538658, -0.025066174566745758, -0.029309505596756935, -0.01870758831501007, -0.08139336854219437, -0.10688693821430206, 0.08859676122665405, -0.017915790900588036, -0.0035642539151012897, 0.033608175814151764, 0.0025518322363495827, -0.07588700950145721, 0.05233532190322876, 0.04462842270731926, -0.013324946165084839, -0.06749460101127625, -0.0048707472160458565, -0.005584557540714741, 0.042748548090457916, -0.14487284421920776, 0.012240166775882244, -0.09985410422086716, -0.0003975625731982291, 0.021452751010656357, 0.0010040926281362772, -0.012054125778377056, 0.07061319798231125, 0.030073421075940132, -0.04170236736536026, -0.016222860664129257, 0.007704193703830242, 0.06097310036420822, -0.07996556162834167, -0.018437856808304787, 0.056444186717271805, 0.047035109251737595, 0.0677277147769928, 0.008561092428863049, -0.014861985109746456, -0.021744733676314354, -0.021191328763961792, -0.04100930690765381, -0.03767470270395279, 0.0024289123248308897, -0.016014039516448975, 0.02167530357837677, -0.04462811350822449, 0.01603550836443901, -0.06999701261520386, -0.016861453652381897, 0.0073976884596049786, -0.02288609929382801, -0.07384280115365982, -0.004717102739959955, 0.02678542584180832, -0.0038900859653949738, 0.012442716397345066, 0.04937306419014931, -0.014701972715556622, 0.022335438057780266, -0.038347307592630386, 0.010537193156778812, -0.05544624105095863, 0.0011948305182158947, -0.019518762826919556, -0.05909736454486847, -0.0024527295026928186, -0.004909462761133909, -0.020437343046069145, -0.0167160052806139, -0.00006367420428432524, -0.000792831415310502, -0.053706470876932144, 0.035181328654289246, -0.06186412647366524, -0.04827744513750076, -0.03601858392357826, 0.10138716548681259, -0.029196349903941154, -0.02953348495066166, 0.00931634847074747, -0.01801273226737976, 0.010330762714147568, 0.06167043000459671, 0.062059104442596436, -0.04107031598687172, 0.04889335855841637, -0.029360976070165634, 0.040706004947423935, 0.010039454326033592, 0.008167453110218048, -0.007731243036687374, 0.0032914765179157257, 0.03236769139766693, 0.07680179178714752, 0.06542005389928818, -0.04544839635491371, 0.026286430656909943, -0.0015070905210450292, -0.00003881159864249639, 0.02880195342004299, 0.00030031270580366254, -0.0029659890569746494, 0.041450534015893936, -0.05992721766233444, 0.012538664042949677, 0.02060692012310028, -0.005229398142546415, 0.0016672037309035659, -0.012253660708665848, -0.07036181539297104, -0.052301209419965744, 0.052026208490133286, 0.020178617909550667, 0.009152903221547604, 0.04626228287816048, 0.05591510981321335, 0.02470475248992443, 0.0220946054905653, -0.05771525204181671, -0.06472810357809067, -0.034342583268880844, -0.04223259538412094, 0.009867459535598755, -0.0431513786315918, -0.16235820949077606, 0.04342886805534363, -0.020070279017090797, -0.006902263965457678, 0.03078286163508892, -0.05634874477982521, 0.08290863037109375, -0.02903829701244831, 0.01905347779393196, 0.03832538053393364, 0.08970359712839127, -0.019372673705220222, 0.01287024561315775, -0.036614108830690384, 0.04863720387220383, 0.04400604963302612, 0.01795101910829544, 0.0008686066139489412, -0.0383404977619648, -0.01858476735651493, 0.01115900557488203, -0.005281328223645687, -0.03136387839913368, -0.05821683257818222, -0.052759185433387756, 0.09202320128679276, 0.07104887068271637, 0.01493257936090231, -0.05157911777496338, 0.002442642580717802, -0.05645349621772766, -0.06460915505886078, 0.024784989655017853, 0.02201218158006668, 0.01962185837328434, 0.007823384366929531, -0.04882899671792984, -0.050316352397203445, -0.028818948194384575, 0.012804869562387466, 0.06391686946153641, 0.07300743460655212, 0.003510089125484228, 0.022610846906900406, 0.04734235256910324, 0.008328978903591633, -0.039298541843891144, 0.016870155930519104, -0.03878576681017876, 0.0034794455859810114, 0.038823943585157394, 0.11852286010980606, -0.0006007672636769712, -0.05867162346839905, 0.05634881928563118, -0.00892439391463995, -0.040051039308309555, 0.08798779547214508, -0.08651188015937805, -0.01762772910296917, 0.0010869496036320925, -0.019551295787096024, -0.03924107551574707, -0.04009438678622246, -0.049244508147239685, 0.03272056579589844, 0.03233978524804115, 0.031132081523537636, 0.021040789783000946, -0.07704577594995499, -0.015261420980095863, 0.02068261057138443, -0.017105959355831146, -0.0017812445294111967, 0.039209842681884766, 0.054169367998838425, -0.011267431080341339, 0.003011248540133238, -0.0143719632178545, -0.02432618848979473, 0.03131093829870224, -0.031687501817941666, -0.021319091320037842, 0.03941028192639351, 0.07573078572750092, 0.04803960397839546, -0.051729556173086166, 0.03784407302737236, 0.026765815913677216, 0.0012694193283095956, -0.05639300122857094, 0.05090790241956711, -0.0015226046089082956, 0.028286248445510864, 0.05811674892902374, 0.07660941034555435, -0.03430435433983803, 0.014721734449267387, -0.003022433491423726, 0.06065300107002258, -0.004081333056092262, -0.032968807965517044, 0.012008674442768097, 0.07952544838190079, 0.012080570682883263, 0.045787692070007324, 0.039769064635038376, -0.020969051867723465, 0.03138083592057228, -0.02872421406209469, 0.017840076237916946 ]
55
55
Empirical Evaluation of Four Tensor Decomposition Algorithms
Higher-order tensor decompositions are analogous to the familiar Singular Value Decomposition (SVD), but they transcend the limitations of matrices (second-order tensors). SVD is a powerful tool that has achieved impressive results in information retrieval, collaborative filtering, computational linguistics, computational vision, and other fields. However, SVD is limited to two-dimensional arrays of data (two modes), and many potential applications have three or more modes, which require higher-order tensor decompositions. This paper evaluates four algorithms for higher-order tensor decomposition: Higher-Order Singular Value Decomposition (HO-SVD), Higher-Order Orthogonal Iteration (HOOI), Slice Projection (SP), and Multislice Projection (MP). We measure the time (elapsed run time), space (RAM and disk space requirements), and fit (tensor reconstruction accuracy) of the four algorithms, under a variety of conditions. We find that standard implementations of HO-SVD and HOOI do not scale up to larger tensors, due to increasing RAM requirements. We recommend HOOI for tensors that are small enough for the available RAM and MP for larger tensors.
[ 0.0033351837191730738, 0.02998577244579792, 0.023491406813263893, -0.006888736039400101, 0.0030031632632017136, -0.02519725263118744, -0.010033278726041317, -0.04251497983932495, -0.019935091957449913, -0.04197679087519646, 0.022316090762615204, -0.00040463628829456866, -0.05565416067838669, 0.021619629114866257, -0.04722078889608383, -0.051836613565683365, -0.07432185113430023, -0.016362974420189857, 0.06474807113409042, -0.012270528823137283, -0.01511266827583313, -0.013040917925536633, -0.01221298985183239, -0.07661039382219315, 0.003393188351765275, 0.023153427988290787, -0.018091978505253792, 0.01626473106443882, 0.07568797469139099, 0.002815169282257557, -0.04013248533010483, 0.00950036570429802, 0.06828030198812485, -0.043963558971881866, -0.03729742020368576, 0.046957336366176605, 0.060753725469112396, -0.010252107866108418, -0.048468057066202164, -0.0820154920220375, -0.03392409160733223, 0.008316370658576488, 0.035319216549396515, -0.0021185020450502634, 0.019835930317640305, 0.02758490853011608, 0.007885773666203022, -0.0006567520322278142, -0.0009448974160477519, 0.0815281867980957, -0.0773543119430542, 0.04077110067009926, -0.07380292564630508, 0.01832643896341324, -0.03903277963399887, 0.05529534071683884, -0.018257124349474907, 0.026535674929618835, 0.05530725046992302, -0.015832407400012016, 0.02219350077211857, 0.007720451336354017, -0.01424191240221262, -0.008858543820679188, 0.00044999062083661556, 0.018102411180734634, -0.048659905791282654, -0.046123430132865906, -0.02553650364279747, -0.028222957625985146, 0.024833209812641144, -0.05592275410890579, 0.022923273965716362, -0.013353710062801838, 0.09378484636545181, 0.008687363006174564, 0.03454647585749626, 0.03862493857741356, 0.07585179060697556, 0.1030702143907547, -0.014611190184950829, 0.0853625014424324, 0.035251639783382416, -0.005250190384685993, -0.09558676928281784, -0.018506618216633797, -0.04351593926548958, -0.008810268715023994, -0.006784564815461636, 0.03149593248963356, -0.0031448588706552982, -0.02107551135122776, -0.06792600452899933, 0.08963224291801453, -0.01275607943534851, -0.026888208463788033, -0.03440932556986809, -0.008254592306911945, -0.01999972201883793, -0.006329815369099379, 0.04020341858267784, 0.006236029323190451, 0.007405834272503853, 0.07616380602121353, -0.03286169469356537, 0.046334635466337204, -0.04385725408792496, 0.10509394109249115, -0.02032451145350933, -0.024012867361307144, -0.08003043383359909, 0.03565043583512306, -0.0075059924274683, -0.04646792262792587, 0.03250862658023834, 0.08178795874118805, -0.05497843772172928, 0.07554259896278381, -0.0019520960049703717, 0.030796043574810028, -0.01518282201141119, 0.0003384938172530383, 0.02785375528037548, 0.005747095216065645, 0.05390404164791107, -0.07519801706075668, 0.010572494007647038, -0.04523447901010513, 0.062367767095565796, 0.0535467155277729, -0.13573971390724182, -0.02973499335348606, -0.029377005994319916, 0.05495816841721535, -0.05823666602373123, -0.0001860964111983776, 0.024624740704894066, -0.04407528042793274, -0.0019618060905486345, 0.03580062463879585, 0.05751756578683853, 0.005414122715592384, -0.028429100289940834, -0.020617453381419182, -0.01556098647415638, 0.000948593660723418, -0.026828477159142494, 0.012771802954375744, 0.001438060076907277, -0.011073711328208447, 0.07642966508865356, -0.057111769914627075, 0.0530264675617218, 0.032030243426561356, -0.032451219856739044, -0.0524284765124321, -0.02678930200636387, -0.10460299253463745, 0.0192730575799942, 0.018291525542736053, -0.020028376951813698, 0.044776562601327896, -0.0642160028219223, -0.05304259806871414, 0.04838421195745468, -0.06127529591321945, 0.0015700041549280286, -0.058619119226932526, -0.021679401397705078, -0.016484495252370834, -0.025533277541399002, -0.04055311903357506, -0.03756454959511757, 0.06120551750063896, 0.004042083863168955, 0.0124344602227211, -0.0479399636387825, 0.014431731775403023, -0.002292964607477188, -0.03071926161646843, 0.004512889310717583, 0.02319345623254776, -0.008047104813158512, -0.03620065376162529, 0.013466794975101948, 0.04017334058880806, -0.024180928245186806, 0.01917598396539688, 0.071391761302948, -0.048018891364336014, 0.06240088865160942, -0.03281622380018234, 0.02232208661735058, 0.02129809372127056, -0.04355919361114502, -0.006566288881003857, 0.0018656651955097914, -0.031602151691913605, -0.006955479737371206, 0.13882838189601898, 0.0478859469294548, -0.015258755534887314, 0.028355423361063004, -0.027689781039953232, 0.002937298733741045, -0.004896669648587704, 0.07761720567941666, -0.022275719791650772, -0.0575343482196331, 0.07522301375865936, -0.034465242177248, -0.043525081127882004, 0.005768617149442434, 0.0692429468035698, 0.024891987442970276, -0.028850136324763298, 0.007005602121353149, -0.0818256214261055, 0.03758138418197632, 0.02725176326930523, -0.08129415661096573, 0.08225007355213165, -0.017747284844517708, 0.09190003573894501, 0.008881848305463791, 0.027796007692813873, -0.006289757322520018, -0.06167489290237427, 0.003949632402509451, -0.06753065437078476, -0.034410133957862854, 0.0037490790709853172, -0.004025997593998909, 0.05904683098196983, 0.05688768997788429, 0.06975403428077698, -0.09921862185001373, -0.043203968554735184, 0.010293243452906609, 0.03711400926113129, -0.0013670790940523148, -0.034627605229616165, 0.014624880626797676, 0.03391997516155243, -0.01784883812069893, -0.04590625688433647, -0.039029888808727264, 0.03561823442578316, 0.04012076556682587, -0.04517380893230438, 0.05168202891945839, -0.0010299815330654383, -0.046460650861263275, -0.041730452328920364, 0.045065559446811676, 0.036098625510931015, -0.002496583154425025, 0.042330916970968246, 0.058921199291944504, 0.07186257094144821, -0.009472120553255081, -0.030943578109145164, -0.04482926055788994, -0.013776732608675957, 0.030399465933442116, 0.002839334076270461, -0.10998288542032242, 0.0632331371307373, -0.047402121126651764, 0.04719007387757301, -0.0048127914778888226, 0.0018498336430639029, -0.060971830040216446, 0.07136117666959763, -0.04587661847472191, -0.0006633979501202703, 0.07655849307775497, 0.13804695010185242, -0.07067295163869858, -0.026039447635412216, -0.048720840364694595, -0.031036803498864174, -0.04198445752263069, -0.010181838646531105, -0.029925016686320305, 0.041582174599170685, -0.04859251528978348, -0.015402252785861492, -0.09060236066579819, 0.057272668927907944, -0.027983305975794792, 0.11194552481174469, -0.11908946186304092, 0.02092435210943222, 0.024342002347111702, -0.09179654717445374, 0.05322137102484703, 0.021784314885735512, 0.006033380050212145, 0.046370264142751694, 0.0038701894227415323, -0.021671976894140244, 0.034359049052000046, -0.03585348650813103, 0.018170416355133057, 0.00821127649396658, 0.06976538151502609, -0.009951715357601643, -0.07002412527799606, 0.0055817002430558205, 0.07808039337396622, 0.01778479665517807, -0.07832727581262589, -0.022567905485630035, 0.013695498928427696, -0.028609449043869972, 0.030775444582104683, 0.023012084886431694, 0.019893281161785126, -0.0629279613494873, 0.027941793203353882, 0.010156819596886635, -0.019414784386754036, -0.0672406554222107, -0.006734324619174004, -0.07100731879472733, -0.029133936390280724, -0.05063096061348915, -0.01650417596101761, -0.012636094354093075, -0.12735426425933838, 0.07009832561016083, -0.0042777713388204575, 0.04834914952516556, 0.09223416447639465, -0.03574072942137718, 0.024980667978525162, -0.02254788763821125, -0.09075310081243515, 0.023277347907423973, -0.05030940845608711, -0.05199075862765312, 0.02557756006717682, -0.06144288182258606, 0.027234185487031937, -0.028266068547964096, 0.0400729775428772, -0.019717946648597717, -0.008685200475156307, 0.04434208571910858, 0.024520982056856155, 0.00453276326879859, -0.008601653389632702, 0.05127035453915596, 0.07216500490903854, 0.0658637136220932, -0.04609697684645653, -0.04036765173077583, -0.035215750336647034, 0.027920421212911606, 0.004522101953625679, 0.05643661692738533, -0.024818917736411095, 0.010900466702878475, 0.05351120978593826, 0.054949283599853516, -0.06198713555932045, 0.008832216262817383, -0.002557892818003893, -0.031714893877506256, -0.0425136499106884, 0.05612384155392647, 0.07236355543136597, 0.05365842208266258, 0.016408221796154976, -0.0008348007686436176, -0.0025498243048787117, 0.02493095211684704, -0.02537473663687706, 0.05867622420191765, -0.020906861871480942, 0.03497545048594475, -0.0706610232591629, 0.020897749811410904, -0.025607235729694366, 0.010064579546451569, -0.009010078385472298, 0.06339254230260849, -0.022017287090420723, 0.03569674864411354, 0.002320445142686367, 0.0005948049365542829, -0.08040613681077957, 0.019746610894799232, -0.006106811575591564, 0.019457459449768066, 0.06135910749435425, -0.08319099247455597, -0.06471361219882965, -0.02332778088748455, 0.020375002175569534, -0.038931168615818024, 0.021504059433937073, -0.021662581712007523, -0.030046772211790085, -0.05002405121922493, 0.016520023345947266, 0.08199378103017807, -0.030848894268274307, 0.03362752124667168, 0.01749458909034729, -0.032503191381692886, 0.03040170855820179, 0.06353235244750977, 0.009407559409737587, 0.040620107203722, -0.054557543247938156, -0.033725667744874954, 0.03323192521929741, 0.03510499373078346, 0.032164882868528366, -0.019441472366452217, 0.0022287240717560053, 0.007124711759388447, -0.05582427233457565, -0.04983031377196312, 0.013315179385244846, 0.04627235233783722, 0.006572880782186985, -0.027576155960559845, -0.11507830023765564, -0.02096083015203476, 0.0052421423606574535, -0.0013775817351415753, 0.07579430192708969, 0.08408895134925842, 0.037282828241586685, -0.04887596517801285, -0.07918089628219604, -0.04295582324266434, -0.0056226602755486965, -0.01670139841735363, -0.011487875133752823, -0.030075853690505028, 0.01718014106154442, 0.016014128923416138, 0.006901867222040892, 0.016797760501503944, -0.002308822236955166, 0.0126259233802557, -0.04745025187730789, 0.012975995428860188, 0.01656000129878521, 0.01411241851747036, -0.003241575788706541, 0.03296313434839249, -0.028175631538033485, -0.016609715297818184, 0.038922619074583054, 0.025884056463837624, -0.0324154868721962, -0.002407267689704895, -0.05026090890169144, 0.06393621116876602, 0.002267834497615695, -0.04457179084420204, 0.02069656178355217, 0.07722461223602295, 0.017260894179344177, 0.06119609251618385, -0.036219097673892975, -0.025630226358771324, -0.04855548217892647, -0.03605329245328903, 0.049605075269937515, 0.03318048641085625, -0.00926518440246582, -0.08074367046356201, -0.003582171630114317, -0.02156422846019268, -0.03721899911761284, 0.046073295176029205, 0.02799984999001026, 0.034631434828042984, 0.012564272619783878, 0.0299072228372097, -0.06529037654399872, 0.03411387652158737, 0.022758543491363525, -0.010185829363763332, -0.013757472857832909, -0.04556502029299736, 0.00840048398822546, 0.022769581526517868, -0.013339802622795105, -0.08009056001901627, -0.004534054547548294, -0.0382593534886837, 0.007588245440274477, 0.03945330157876015, -0.01843494176864624, 0.02754335105419159, -0.021753475069999695, 0.04439583420753479, 0.056901201605796814, 0.032613739371299744, 0.08823496103286743, 0.007779148872941732, 0.03670767322182655, 0.03431646525859833, 0.01616010256111622, -0.02665077894926071 ]
56
56
Inverse Sampling for Nonasymptotic Sequential Estimation of Bounded Variable Means
In this paper, we consider the nonasymptotic sequential estimation of means of random variables bounded in between zero and one. We have rigorously demonstrated that, in order to guarantee prescribed relative precision and confidence level, it suffices to continue sampling until the sample sum is no less than a certain bound and then take the average of samples as an estimate for the mean of the bounded random variable. We have developed an explicit formula and a bisection search method for the determination of such bound of sample sum, without any knowledge of the bounded variable. Moreover, we have derived bounds for the distribution of sample size. In the special case of Bernoulli random variables, we have established analytical and numerical methods to further reduce the bound of sample sum and thus improve the efficiency of sampling. Furthermore, the fallacy of existing results are detected and analyzed.
[ -0.047112274914979935, 0.03328682854771614, -0.01300041377544403, -0.03534768521785736, 0.03489274904131889, -0.09954995661973953, 0.023809904232621193, -0.025569727644324303, -0.09579837322235107, 0.06256482005119324, 0.003431066870689392, -0.031201669946312904, -0.0034830905497074127, 0.050155989825725555, 0.044822875410318375, -0.056957174092531204, -0.023380372673273087, 0.02718348801136017, -0.01930428110063076, -0.0932975634932518, -0.03764703869819641, -0.022646114230155945, 0.10113570839166641, 0.01479518786072731, 0.05604126304388046, -0.025016728788614273, 0.055565375834703445, 0.018749719485640526, -0.08926025778055191, -0.004623947199434042, -0.04904523491859436, 0.04606351628899574, -0.03571899235248566, 0.005075471941381693, 0.10114456713199615, -0.015734687447547913, -0.024814510717988014, -0.08876541256904602, -0.042513035237789154, -0.07510315626859665, -0.024824878200888634, -0.0454719103872776, -0.03081570565700531, -0.011606324464082718, 0.07221545279026031, 0.07218306511640549, 0.07122134417295456, 0.030869832262396812, -0.005514503922313452, -0.011225256137549877, -0.023371368646621704, 0.03749009594321251, -0.008396441116929054, -0.003246334381401539, 0.043084766715765, 0.0414157435297966, -0.004871160723268986, 0.010410516522824764, -0.07146885991096497, -0.004785460419952869, -0.0247072521597147, 0.01440133061259985, 0.0788431167602539, -0.03714258223772049, -0.0014536269009113312, 0.032422762364149094, -0.12670230865478516, -0.008672279305756092, 0.006077935919165611, -0.07822641730308533, 0.011964729987084866, -0.039755385369062424, -0.0029485980048775673, 0.031257037073373795, 0.04788168519735336, -0.047740910202264786, -0.010057675652205944, -0.008026902563869953, 0.05638837441802025, 0.032508280128240585, -0.03384200856089592, 0.050545018166303635, 0.01813318394124508, 0.009736847132444382, -0.05263232812285423, -0.024391602724790573, -0.03221337869763374, 0.00722333462908864, 0.014661712571978569, -0.046946898102760315, -0.06845060735940933, -0.020927777513861656, -0.09620365500450134, 0.03850436955690384, -0.04422937333583832, 0.09008802473545074, 0.05263238772749901, -0.019181834533810616, -0.023311063647270203, -0.042170267552137375, 0.049850475043058395, -0.1125888004899025, 0.06148001551628113, -0.004043888300657272, 0.01651947572827339, 0.034714583307504654, -0.014674981124699116, -0.027018947526812553, 0.026572659611701965, -0.015528411604464054, 0.018130162730813026, -0.06585270166397095, -0.005048627965152264, 0.006368829868733883, -0.0951269343495369, 0.0637158527970314, 0.021948756650090218, -0.0008548564510419965, 0.01706448197364807, -0.014809198677539825, 0.08809589594602585, 0.037715401500463486, -0.004949790891259909, 0.040148258209228516, 0.06150001659989357, -0.0672229751944542, 0.002667779102921486, -0.06989512592554092, 0.1306452453136444, -0.0688018649816513, -0.02695304900407791, 0.004390568006783724, 0.01492918562144041, 0.06519732624292374, -0.09452766180038452, 0.017280321568250656, 0.006367501802742481, 0.018316779285669327, -0.03164287656545639, 0.009951045736670494, -0.033250000327825546, -0.022816192358732224, 0.010035905055701733, 0.03678081929683685, 0.019665956497192383, 0.03578593581914902, -0.023521102964878082, 0.008046247996389866, -0.05976100638508797, 0.010771775618195534, 0.0015760567039251328, -0.013517309911549091, -0.04934591054916382, 0.030285635963082314, 0.059943344444036484, -0.05948292091488838, -0.010580342262983322, -0.004330950789153576, -0.027483370155096054, 0.03910667821764946, -0.07647914439439774, -0.0011765359668061137, -0.0018914493266493082, 0.020034059882164, -0.04615597054362297, -0.0039025265723466873, -0.016382712870836258, 0.031988102942705154, 0.009234271943569183, -0.028802787885069847, -0.02221083641052246, 0.03684091195464134, -0.027641845867037773, -0.006066419184207916, -0.03217326104640961, -0.04312997683882713, 0.018980147317051888, -0.02711471915245056, 0.00951479747891426, -0.03194599971175194, -0.005859349854290485, -0.04840512201189995, -0.048946402966976166, -0.054978661239147186, 0.004639310762286186, 0.08454741537570953, -0.046564891934394836, 0.09284188598394394, -0.05251084640622139, -0.06384256482124329, 0.023377085104584694, 0.039207007735967636, -0.03415566310286522, -0.07916773855686188, -0.0468490831553936, 0.0001754375552991405, -0.03471500054001808, 0.05488819628953934, 0.03747417777776718, 0.05771269649267197, -0.022634530439972878, 0.002477918053045869, -0.024672046303749084, -0.019135650247335434, 0.012979328632354736, -0.012711823917925358, -0.025222329422831535, -0.02388782985508442, 0.043891262263059616, -0.0383857786655426, -0.03531145676970482, 0.009373887442052364, -0.0482080802321434, -0.11724284291267395, 0.05884113907814026, -0.107180655002594, -0.0005396924098022282, -0.022753214463591576, -0.00012194230657769367, 0.012489904649555683, -0.040834005922079086, 0.004435325041413307, -0.0205114483833313, 0.10866944491863251, -0.02215699478983879, -0.015501923859119415, 0.031609680503606796, 0.011708480305969715, 0.03721068799495697, 0.03565175086259842, -0.029754478484392166, -0.08533426374197006, 0.04000699147582054, -0.028183672577142715, -0.051199186593294144, 0.03151611238718033, 0.01543418224900961, 0.015612860210239887, -0.013654621317982674, 0.0022859512828290462, -0.00994253158569336, 0.023286975920200348, 0.011150330305099487, -0.03308568522334099, -0.016345812007784843, -0.023312922567129135, 0.10060650110244751, -0.00519165676087141, 0.008737783879041672, 0.0679120346903801, 0.07014834880828857, -0.020909694954752922, -0.06882097572088242, -0.010971568524837494, -0.01979328691959381, 0.05158242583274841, -0.02109334245324135, 0.040741927921772, 0.05443790927529335, 0.007879513315856457, 0.00010974358883686364, 0.05121191218495369, -0.05790022388100624, 0.05530896410346031, 0.031409747898578644, 0.04300329461693764, -0.0425613708794117, 0.030587399378418922, 0.03540262207388878, -0.04714271053671837, -0.0027452067006379366, 0.04248717054724693, -0.06261402368545532, 0.06047791242599487, -0.07434104382991791, -0.04104175418615341, 0.005752280354499817, -0.011788029223680496, 0.037708308547735214, -0.06244482100009918, -0.017323413863778114, 0.04127073287963867, 0.04009537398815155, 0.018426470458507538, -0.006860464345663786, -0.008979548700153828, -0.016952943056821823, -0.03022853285074234, -0.06783100962638855, 0.05547422170639038, -0.029988201335072517, 0.00825281161814928, -0.04022064432501793, -0.06328331679105759, 0.042251069098711014, 0.035671524703502655, 0.028708135709166527, -0.07386865466833115, 0.013527796603739262, 0.006007419899106026, -0.02273651584982872, 0.0374043844640255, 0.11242928355932236, 0.021922241896390915, -0.027818845584988594, -0.0005326643586158752, 0.06439097225666046, 0.05657927691936493, -0.03178084269165993, 0.047314852476119995, -0.04150458425283432, -0.042169079184532166, -0.03295714780688286, -0.02296234481036663, -0.002430401975288987, -0.016065310686826706, -0.05418172851204872, -0.1180044561624527, 0.02012944035232067, 0.05467041954398155, 0.05680388957262039, -0.01592285744845867, 0.01300651766359806, -0.028179794549942017, -0.08208970725536346, -0.022974366322159767, 0.014221918769180775, 0.06246989592909813, -0.0033252337016165257, -0.043045397847890854, 0.012982059270143509, 0.03962288796901703, -0.026264967396855354, 0.11069447547197342, -0.029226234182715416, 0.04514613002538681, -0.05198344588279724, -0.031145280227065086, 0.0021733660250902176, 0.009961809031665325, 0.011405184864997864, -0.01739976927638054, 0.052743230015039444, -0.03596602752804756, 0.02665828913450241, 0.043598853051662445, 0.14101417362689972, 0.013122523203492165, -0.060308072715997696, -0.05943743884563446, -0.07207421958446503, -0.07130901515483856, -0.016640493646264076, 0.050962284207344055, -0.005668080411851406, 0.007424368988722563, 0.06778112798929214, 0.04283876344561577, -0.020753638818860054, 0.06092957779765129, -0.04703767970204353, -0.00344396592117846, 0.020388919860124588, -0.0060910810716450214, 0.021332647651433945, -0.021562838926911354, -0.024124469608068466, -0.04342610761523247, -0.047204338014125824, 0.05910951644182205, -0.027631113305687904, 0.052665211260318756, 0.06522785127162933, -0.025213414803147316, 0.02699091099202633, -0.05825807526707649, 0.009188446216285229, 0.11250078678131104, -0.04175163060426712, 0.013980591669678688, 0.024044010788202286, 0.0052581592462956905, 0.03858480602502823, -0.002408831613138318, -0.030476387590169907, -0.06082359701395035, -0.005953061394393444, 0.053083386272192, 0.042357031255960464, 0.0068341693840920925, 0.06605515629053116, -0.08552098274230957, 0.018679941073060036, 0.08155528455972672, 0.04840237647294998, 0.078969307243824, 0.023414621129631996, 0.025165073573589325, 0.004355223849415779, -0.05215466767549515, 0.05381853133440018, -0.0869382843375206, -0.0384807251393795, -0.08619333803653717, -0.027178891003131866, -0.020571859553456306, -0.0029060489032417536, 0.0049748714081943035, -0.009837481193244457, 0.08330553025007248, -0.015560803934931755, 0.013147041201591492, -0.03574496507644653, 0.0025183623656630516, -0.0529448501765728, 0.033081453293561935, -0.0033695742022246122, -0.019302546977996826, 0.000469015387352556, -0.04241817817091942, -0.02365763671696186, 0.0247515756636858, -0.009623045101761818, -0.009766798466444016, -0.006552490405738354, -0.0016331598162651062, 0.013647486455738544, 0.011096821166574955, -0.04482518136501312, -0.0418558269739151, -0.05617823451757431, -0.04749316722154617, 0.0047519211657345295, -0.03480471670627594, -0.02201026864349842, -0.024220189079642296, -0.008909223601222038, 0.023335611447691917, -0.05164213478565216, 0.07337129861116409, -0.03975323215126991, -0.002280635293573141, -0.022300221025943756, 0.01215407531708479, -0.02591623179614544, 0.005840873345732689, 0.04804056137800217, -0.0013994453474879265, 0.020224679261446, 0.02837170660495758, -0.010140924714505672, 0.01497010700404644, -0.041113853454589844, -0.07278130203485489, 0.06650537252426147, 0.03635068237781525, 0.0024472482036799192, -0.04355158656835556, 0.05826517567038536, -0.05745302885770798, -0.07756330817937851, -0.07067237794399261, 0.00380088877864182, 0.02089739218354225, -0.06989427655935287, 0.03369509056210518, -0.03392784669995308, 0.00964241474866867, 0.06843609362840652, -0.03940485790371895, -0.03946135938167572, 0.04279155284166336, -0.10620380938053131, 0.011804837733507156, 0.02938678301870823, -0.042768049985170364, 0.04750990495085716, -0.0009935683337971568, -0.00018268756684847176, -0.009707415476441383, -0.023930007591843605, -0.031503643840551376, -0.07877057790756226, -0.0038289192598313093, 0.008430139161646366, 0.023011233657598495, 0.014660734683275223, 0.02208803780376911, 0.03511467203497887, 0.05158472806215286, -0.017600657418370247, -0.01961127668619156, 0.0018228305270895362, -0.035421811044216156, 0.032004013657569885, 0.009965571574866772, -0.04986719414591789, 0.031908031553030014, 0.022347578778862953, 0.07168496400117874, 0.018232788890600204, -0.040371984243392944, 0.018089810386300087, -0.019673017784953117, 0.06323766708374023, 0.006303560920059681, -0.03725902736186981, -0.036566637456417084, -0.03948577493429184, 0.03302305191755295, -0.022687753662467003, -0.019048037007451057 ]
57
57
Image Classification Using SVMs: One-against-One Vs One-against-All
Support Vector Machines (SVMs) are a relatively new supervised classification technique to the land cover mapping community. They have their roots in Statistical Learning Theory and have gained prominence because they are robust, accurate and are effective even when using a small training sample. By their nature SVMs are essentially binary classifiers, however, they can be adopted to handle the multiple classification tasks common in remote sensing studies. The two approaches commonly used are the One-Against-One (1A1) and One-Against-All (1AA) techniques. In this paper, these approaches are evaluated in as far as their impact and implication for land cover mapping. The main finding from this research is that whereas the 1AA technique is more predisposed to yielding unclassified and mixed pixels, the resulting classification accuracy is not significantly different from 1A1 approach. It is the authors conclusion therefore that ultimately the choice of technique adopted boils down to personal preference and the uniqueness of the dataset at hand.
[ 0.018778787925839424, -0.04413403570652008, -0.021802514791488647, 0.018321778625249863, 0.003463348373770714, -0.023736508563160896, -0.08037331700325012, 0.055718548595905304, -0.07128133624792099, 0.047730036079883575, 0.06177124008536339, 0.052392296493053436, -0.015390681102871895, 0.011087880469858646, 0.014292746782302856, 0.037697359919548035, 0.06779119372367859, -0.02909007854759693, 0.020337510854005814, -0.03270919620990753, -0.009132360108196735, 0.029927527531981468, -0.018880007788538933, -0.036378856748342514, 0.019557133316993713, -0.010072906501591206, 0.04269862174987793, 0.0031273963395506144, -0.08295464515686035, 0.049796897917985916, -0.022420842200517654, -0.029619842767715454, 0.020872604101896286, 0.03366338089108467, -0.00012552551925182343, -0.04219722002744675, 0.03691074624657631, -0.056443922221660614, -0.08217807859182358, 0.03151648864150047, -0.061325859278440475, 0.03249354287981987, 0.005269332323223352, -0.053999196738004684, 0.035819005221128464, 0.05810974910855293, -0.005959675647318363, -0.020234595984220505, -0.013434619642794132, -0.011374924331903458, -0.026695970445871353, 0.0025159840006381273, -0.0046957628801465034, 0.021555768325924873, 0.010018661618232727, -0.02338472753763199, -0.01101954560726881, -0.04557577148079872, 0.04780328646302223, -0.02086184360086918, 0.06613898277282715, 0.08900786936283112, 0.009943748824298382, -0.014703787863254547, -0.01198527216911316, -0.05471476539969444, -0.05228566378355026, -0.04655502736568451, 0.01735587790608406, -0.005779230501502752, -0.01261267252266407, -0.07257284969091415, 0.023403896018862724, 0.05591999366879463, 0.04253634810447693, 0.03207935020327568, 0.02436019480228424, 0.01299428753554821, 0.024093186482787132, 0.021302983164787292, -0.02561708353459835, -0.02512180805206299, 0.06849677115678787, -0.004375487100332975, 0.03388940542936325, 0.03389081731438637, -0.05667790398001671, -0.001384039525873959, 0.05958638712763786, 0.08042120933532715, 0.01607932709157467, -0.0541524775326252, -0.006872212514281273, -0.0011619351571425796, -0.008610484190285206, 0.0022286863531917334, 0.0046090916730463505, -0.006990151479840279, 0.0464162603020668, 0.0877673327922821, -0.024808162823319435, 0.0053453510627150536, 0.060278791934251785, 0.052334096282720566, -0.02347514219582081, 0.052719105035066605, 0.0010194499045610428, 0.0309074018150568, -0.012841136194765568, 0.043936192989349365, 0.032443419098854065, -0.037030063569545746, -0.018154000863432884, 0.0485231950879097, 0.013364299200475216, -0.025610236451029778, -0.14660899341106415, 0.07606261223554611, 0.07547105848789215, -0.04105605557560921, -0.053902361541986465, -0.025505362078547478, 0.02604137547314167, 0.046322837471961975, 0.0220577921718359, 0.008075390011072159, 0.019238581880927086, -0.039446379989385605, -0.0033441628329455853, -0.02074526809155941, -0.11073166131973267, 0.001594845438376069, -0.04607681557536125, 0.09426429867744446, -0.10361892729997635, -0.03798910230398178, -0.04271230101585388, -0.08331473916769028, 0.00748298317193985, 0.007783630397170782, 0.010657119564712048, -0.046026017516851425, -0.006181991193443537, 0.055041808634996414, 0.03627367690205574, 0.057441696524620056, 0.04817752167582512, 0.009624010883271694, 0.013200102373957634, -0.006921062245965004, -0.009086749516427517, -0.04508831351995468, 0.05971689894795418, 0.05595547705888748, 0.05764441564679146, -0.06210446357727051, -0.03760303556919098, -0.026104437187314034, 0.020089175552129745, 0.05568728968501091, 0.007750411052256823, 0.12281923741102219, 0.020013883709907532, 0.0863293781876564, 0.007211475167423487, 0.031532224267721176, 0.014125834219157696, 0.0006348267197608948, 0.017687372863292694, -0.07440029084682465, -0.001798435696400702, 0.03350186347961426, -0.03497057780623436, -0.06614843010902405, 0.008206244558095932, 0.021172624081373215, -0.015027910470962524, 0.014473529532551765, -0.039147909730672836, 0.014954891055822372, -0.03345787897706032, -0.08543188869953156, -0.038893766701221466, 0.023968715220689774, 0.08460314571857452, 0.07074353098869324, -0.0027132669929414988, 0.0033743761014193296, 0.0659390389919281, 0.008997694589197636, 0.03217068314552307, -0.026139816269278526, 0.02775050699710846, -0.09931131452322006, -0.03148191049695015, 0.014929902739822865, 0.022162865847349167, -0.03430349752306938, 0.013634707778692245, 0.02116268314421177, -0.052797429263591766, -0.046260278671979904, -0.04184018820524216, 0.02450910024344921, 0.003293911460787058, 0.03195725008845329, 0.028696345165371895, -0.01453243475407362, 0.041192688047885895, -0.032222047448158264, -0.0023291518446058035, 0.008141486905515194, 0.014173201285302639, 0.025751421228051186, 0.0014468022854998708, -0.045535970479249954, -0.00044716690899804235, -0.015543313696980476, 0.02713218331336975, -0.005781271494925022, -0.039052050560712814, 0.024000920355319977, -0.03872581943869591, 0.1016601175069809, -0.001265383092686534, 0.030053406953811646, -0.034017518162727356, -0.04077151417732239, -0.007952908053994179, 0.08453302085399628, -0.09011278301477432, -0.08381479978561401, -0.09189295023679733, -0.037678636610507965, -0.027648556977510452, 0.0527065172791481, -0.050664905458688736, -0.05682825669646263, 0.09845118224620819, -0.03476434573531151, 0.07551413774490356, 0.02687717042863369, -0.04115903005003929, -0.00377664715051651, 0.06399516761302948, -0.0549112968146801, 0.026864061132073402, 0.04240195453166962, -0.005520292092114687, 0.01827922649681568, 0.018122779205441475, -0.014170167036354542, -0.007799255661666393, -0.04831758141517639, 0.011555665172636509, -0.013090509921312332, 0.005680914502590895, -0.04144908860325813, 0.026668580248951912, 0.05361313000321388, -0.007774293422698975, 0.04356063902378082, -0.020779641345143318, -0.011241424828767776, 0.02644231729209423, 0.06800229102373123, 0.037364114075899124, -0.06401514261960983, 0.030228685587644577, 0.020565057173371315, -0.023744361475110054, -0.05588112398982048, 0.013058248907327652, 0.02165420912206173, -0.017136085778474808, 0.02882625348865986, 0.06591001152992249, 0.023968013003468513, -0.025969404727220535, -0.024505622684955597, -0.02138027921319008, -0.039027050137519836, -0.04445796087384224, 0.004021133296191692, -0.03447141498327255, -0.0521375872194767, -0.04075552150607109, -0.015731407329440117, 0.008477502502501011, -0.040476713329553604, 0.028495507314801216, 0.048216670751571655, -0.060691338032484055, 0.0075170197524130344, 0.027468599379062653, -0.030831683427095413, -0.03615167737007141, -0.028376378118991852, 0.12036764621734619, -0.028458595275878906, 0.03623683750629425, 0.04516618326306343, 0.0074222455732524395, 0.002149487379938364, -0.035344284027814865, 0.03184050694108009, 0.05657145753502846, 0.0601167157292366, -0.08764614164829254, 0.0002764108357951045, -0.017715686932206154, 0.004741612821817398, -0.08999159932136536, -0.09548669308423996, -0.0031746486201882362, -0.09209470450878143, 0.02344871684908867, 0.024493150413036346, -0.014816860668361187, 0.005018978845328093, 0.04463185742497444, 0.002234136685729027, 0.0219303946942091, -0.018814610317349434, -0.02684910036623478, -0.009048606269061565, -0.029056785628199577, 0.023186929523944855, -0.06701646745204926, -0.012489057146012783, -0.033864669501781464, 0.014849768951535225, 0.035051751881837845, 0.07823872566223145, -0.009438518434762955, -0.018625609576702118, 0.04010549560189247, 0.0792519599199295, -0.03731957823038101, -0.024036552757024765, -0.04738885909318924, 0.0642668604850769, 0.024473128840327263, 0.012469682842493057, -0.004205853678286076, 0.00006146573286969215, 0.09222801774740219, -0.024485228583216667, -0.0524529293179512, 0.025402246043086052, -0.023931218311190605, 0.04756653681397438, -0.07161625474691391, 0.04601683467626572, -0.04238102212548256, 0.03391554579138756, 0.009858972392976284, -0.001048106118105352, -0.05059787631034851, -0.01630174182355404, -0.09674510359764099, -0.048503849655389786, -0.06076466664671898, 0.015114955604076385, 0.00551689462736249, 0.05480538681149483, 0.010612917132675648, 0.01649029180407524, 0.04537037014961243, -0.09487129002809525, -0.03206038475036621, 0.039189837872982025, -0.007603283505886793, 0.002077885437756777, 0.06264431029558182, -0.002947002649307251, -0.00271214684471488, 0.007501000538468361, 0.04132381081581116, 0.08418644219636917, -0.002364925341680646, 0.0056577641516923904, 0.018597325310111046, 0.01626702770590782, -0.016893744468688965, -0.0028272271156311035, -0.03553520143032074, -0.015225746668875217, 0.0463566817343235, 0.0017772947903722525, -0.06702814996242523, -0.03195427730679512, -0.09104663878679276, 0.018857553601264954, 0.02580862119793892, 0.041811175644397736, -0.03822632133960724, -0.06528186053037643, 0.008334617130458355, 0.014193184673786163, 0.004905346781015396, 0.04373523220419884, -0.041418060660362244, -0.13534194231033325, -0.051611438393592834, 0.06896407157182693, 0.003945792093873024, 0.10052473098039627, 0.005808017682284117, 0.008754495531320572, 0.08021357655525208, 0.05552467703819275, 0.016233639791607857, -0.0005209650262258947, 0.12634482979774475, 0.04198012501001358, -0.006041575223207474, -0.00033288513077422976, 0.02464713156223297, -0.03265330567955971, -0.0018611281411722302, 0.040118567645549774, 0.007763941306620836, 0.020066620782017708, -0.012179822660982609, -0.003163621760904789, -0.001123745576478541, 0.10477064549922943, 0.0004641184932552278, 0.01686342991888523, -0.049692727625370026, 0.043406084179878235, -0.007790613453835249, 0.029559927061200142, 0.05729522183537483, 0.07743440568447113, 0.08387016505002975, -0.12027723342180252, -0.011842066422104836, 0.025791877880692482, -0.02783610112965107, 0.026087205857038498, -0.0011632367968559265, -0.01325973216444254, 0.009291996248066425, 0.047604650259017944, 0.018544502556324005, 0.07392866164445877, 0.0376184806227684, -0.007060632109642029, -0.04809141904115677, 0.01190092135220766, -0.028246648609638214, 0.0060230703093111515, -0.043162085115909576, -0.008978620171546936, -0.03675229102373123, -0.09426224231719971, 0.05270301550626755, -0.01143994927406311, -0.0484146848320961, -0.011092038825154305, -0.04368411377072334, -0.0021654367446899414, -0.07083350419998169, -0.0028129175771027803, -0.007731321267783642, -0.02135133370757103, 0.04238046705722809, 0.025317898020148277, -0.057627465575933456, -0.03446214646100998, -0.04059991613030434, -0.036130912601947784, 0.1076521947979927, -0.03663908317685127, 0.018042420968413353, -0.05349581688642502, 0.004048813600093126, -0.1025375947356224, 0.03466470167040825, -0.09258265048265457, 0.05077916383743286, 0.0020885237026959658, 0.05137816071510315, -0.02925514057278633, -0.10369901359081268, 0.04200242459774017, 0.029807886108756065, -0.0793411135673523, 0.012232800014317036, -0.024937111884355545, 0.028897559270262718, 0.04696764051914215, -0.025839000940322876, -0.0474579781293869, -0.030989451333880424, 0.024970347061753273, 0.05236421525478363, 0.010529309511184692, 0.009279617108404636, -0.03824306279420853, 0.02487245388329029, 0.03839370608329773, 0.036519475281238556, -0.04349536448717117, 0.003946567419916391, -0.05756869167089462, 0.03809225186705589, 0.041824501007795334, -0.0308518186211586, -0.03394143655896187 ]
58
58
Clustering with Transitive Distance and K-Means Duality
Recent spectral clustering methods are a propular and powerful technique for data clustering. These methods need to solve the eigenproblem whose computational complexity is $O(n^3)$, where $n$ is the number of data samples. In this paper, a non-eigenproblem based clustering method is proposed to deal with the clustering problem. Its performance is comparable to the spectral clustering algorithms but it is more efficient with computational complexity $O(n^2)$. We show that with a transitive distance and an observed property, called K-means duality, our algorithm can be used to handle data sets with complex cluster shapes, multi-scale clusters, and noise. Moreover, no parameters except the number of clusters need to be set in our algorithm.
[ 0.0025805451441556215, 0.009631361812353134, 0.010958351194858551, 0.003642527386546135, -0.049636032432317734, -0.016776910051703453, 0.016767485067248344, -0.03017464652657509, -0.03928196430206299, -0.019961785525083542, -0.01166324783116579, -0.03451912850141525, -0.09195762127637863, 0.0307028628885746, -0.0676458403468132, 0.028085043653845787, 0.013447897508740425, 0.03683088719844818, 0.03280987590551376, -0.045609187334775925, -0.00923251360654831, -0.030500248074531555, -0.0087678087875247, -0.047544531524181366, 0.03540024161338806, 0.05080661550164223, 0.0010307917837053537, -0.07795173674821854, -0.03989889845252037, -0.04894086346030235, 0.0028495173901319504, -0.03214903920888901, 0.02780868113040924, -0.02398999035358429, -0.000561143213417381, -0.03674823418259621, -0.017202848568558693, 0.041302390396595, -0.029697539284825325, -0.027750879526138306, -0.01366051658987999, 0.006197274196892977, -0.008467362262308598, -0.016516776755452156, 0.034957870841026306, -0.0007469846750609577, 0.03582126274704933, -0.03696228563785553, 0.044089220464229584, 0.0677688792347908, -0.13769254088401794, 0.041733771562576294, -0.04416044428944588, 0.05621383711695671, -0.023209406062960625, -0.025009142234921455, 0.028920527547597885, 0.01093235332518816, -0.006493330933153629, 0.01632069982588291, 0.05455953627824783, 0.047153037041425705, -0.010926994495093822, 0.003958460874855518, -0.021530216559767723, -0.09929744154214859, -0.019976286217570305, -0.07380713522434235, -0.07732472568750381, -0.02317194826900959, -0.050729818642139435, -0.0015275062760338187, -0.04435785487294197, 0.04948456957936287, 0.015209376811981201, 0.039056699723005295, 0.00029607879696413875, 0.01698138378560543, -0.0056240977719426155, 0.06844253093004227, 0.009275086224079132, -0.004489321727305651, -0.025766722857952118, -0.026231056079268456, -0.0548170730471611, -0.0035507718566805124, 0.04216476157307625, -0.003110108431428671, 0.013249793089926243, 0.027745991945266724, -0.0052512590773403645, -0.03338451683521271, -0.10414248704910278, 0.00010742192534962669, -0.028852686285972595, -0.007697378285229206, -0.03263531252741814, -0.022232048213481903, 0.09108468145132065, 0.06217186897993088, -0.05634406581521034, -0.005535719450563192, 0.11250888556241989, 0.0508924163877964, 0.022713860496878624, 0.02380376122891903, -0.10284222662448883, 0.015569117851555347, -0.020374510437250137, -0.01484823040664196, 0.0022705579176545143, -0.03914603590965271, -0.012322558090090752, -0.026732295751571655, -0.007158816792070866, 0.010849698446691036, -0.010386691428720951, 0.07740533351898193, -0.008368117734789848, -0.011311802081763744, 0.012038719840347767, 0.0126640060916543, -0.07808160781860352, 0.010980328544974327, 0.043508123606443405, -0.011208978481590748, 0.0016605292912572622, 0.007506562862545252, 0.10175476968288422, 0.0563480369746685, -0.08286121487617493, -0.025798866525292397, -0.09137298166751862, -0.0021710058208554983, -0.09148053824901581, -0.05000092834234238, 0.03367199748754501, 0.020765893161296844, 0.036379288882017136, 0.07548283040523529, 0.03409852832555771, -0.02207372523844242, -0.029324637725949287, -0.07021181285381317, 0.08946379274129868, -0.034418441355228424, -0.028019802644848824, 0.07650146633386612, 0.02072955295443535, 0.061755456030368805, 0.007063307333737612, -0.07917837053537369, 0.024906085804104805, 0.03586461767554283, 0.02209480293095112, -0.036818716675043106, -0.050253741443157196, -0.0388462170958519, 0.05182323232293129, 0.044534023851156235, -0.07035286724567413, 0.028241844847798347, 0.003103520954027772, 0.0362812802195549, 0.030920224264264107, 0.061524104326963425, -0.014516429975628853, -0.015449274331331253, 0.023691531270742416, -0.01536026131361723, -0.002722131321206689, 0.023973725736141205, -0.009737841784954071, 0.023458119481801987, 0.07488308101892471, -0.01078076846897602, -0.029659593477845192, -0.02850845642387867, 0.019459741190075874, -0.04727022722363472, 0.06091977283358574, -0.025524061173200607, -0.028222469612956047, 0.05517979711294174, 0.022438980638980865, 0.09531132131814957, -0.012420373037457466, 0.009974283166229725, 0.0678555816411972, -0.0225225742906332, 0.07388634234666824, -0.015430592931807041, -0.053658172488212585, -0.01973196491599083, -0.026655834168195724, 0.018046878278255463, -0.031386248767375946, -0.08145223557949066, 0.010953626595437527, 0.03233163058757782, 0.010476595722138882, 0.012044248171150684, -0.00875851046293974, -0.04955732077360153, -0.023887451738119125, -0.006503257434815168, 0.03688298538327217, 0.009662825614213943, -0.016468606889247894, -0.04410127177834511, 0.018519634380936623, -0.022871090099215508, 0.042463771998882294, -0.008119028992950916, 0.01162256021052599, -0.02234135940670967, -0.10179613530635834, -0.015061181038618088, 0.00333104794844985, 0.07607636600732803, -0.0628034844994545, -0.023181216791272163, -0.005264125764369965, 0.03353242203593254, -0.05050364136695862, -0.007600362878292799, 0.004570858087390661, -0.006002183072268963, -0.0844574123620987, -0.0026519885286688805, -0.060663074254989624, -0.029052386060357094, -0.05680885910987854, -0.005756989121437073, 0.07339257001876831, 0.01971716433763504, 0.0029174566734582186, 0.05582604557275772, 0.047254614531993866, 0.021852266043424606, -0.01854659989476204, 0.014548998326063156, -0.0867755189538002, -0.07225742191076279, -0.007715926039963961, -0.06148804351687431, 0.054340723901987076, 0.06347490102052689, 0.025808284059166908, 0.035597722977399826, -0.07978429645299911, 0.057276636362075806, 0.045336417853832245, 0.03064642660319805, 0.04916820302605629, 0.0019515741150826216, -0.043123986572027206, 0.045245397835969925, 0.10306525230407715, 0.06320253014564514, -0.0068644145503640175, 0.06528772413730621, -0.027555150911211967, -0.03376509249210358, 0.060700997710227966, -0.009314289316534996, 0.009226186200976372, 0.04116477444767952, -0.042455822229385376, 0.021548712626099586, 0.02215113677084446, -0.07336694002151489, -0.05112180486321449, 0.04771524295210838, -0.06874028593301773, -0.04301600530743599, 0.01675483211874962, 0.06663347035646439, -0.05435461923480034, -0.056927021592855453, -0.04500730708241463, -0.025033334270119667, -0.02208143286406994, -0.03195085749030113, 0.045487456023693085, -0.00790344551205635, 0.07253152132034302, -0.08658202737569809, 0.0166263896971941, 0.017944946885108948, 0.036062829196453094, 0.10831217467784882, -0.04260295629501343, -0.01337013766169548, 0.015869203954935074, -0.06509484350681305, 0.05825907364487648, 0.033566247671842575, 0.05153973028063774, -0.06648796796798706, 0.039999913424253464, 0.04386414587497711, -0.0344502218067646, 0.0007679876289330423, -0.013001441955566406, 0.08979836106300354, 0.1024141013622284, 0.04982621967792511, -0.05369458347558975, -0.009497635997831821, 0.04054611176252365, 0.0294570904225111, -0.03344538435339928, -0.0007084844401106238, -0.0176553912460804, 0.016420291736721992, 0.004943797364830971, 0.0027776951901614666, 0.042984738945961, -0.023768506944179535, 0.04017000272870064, 0.06678159534931183, 0.020713502541184425, -0.05907498300075531, -0.053425248712301254, -0.054270002990961075, 0.028086788952350616, -0.037205420434474945, -0.061486538499593735, -0.029734307900071144, -0.041550543159246445, 0.005076427944004536, -0.015873800963163376, 0.08125755190849304, 0.07823827862739563, -0.049458809196949005, -0.04855000972747803, -0.04060749337077141, 0.0036942618899047375, -0.005700445268303156, -0.01362192165106535, -0.0016740306746214628, -0.020852090790867805, 0.004531792365014553, -0.027415774762630463, 0.06383455544710159, 0.06425758451223373, -0.050768785178661346, 0.04378288984298706, 0.0432131290435791, -0.13060882687568665, 0.04219973459839821, -0.022179050371050835, -0.07206348329782486, 0.023075150325894356, 0.0013926997780799866, 0.06514237076044083, 0.04742901027202606, 0.05497612804174423, 0.038477636873722076, 0.035992980003356934, 0.04164668172597885, 0.028652003034949303, 0.10354246944189072, 0.030949275940656662, 0.09812720119953156, -0.043059807270765305, -0.0018894510576501489, -0.021789727732539177, -0.03833923116326332, 0.05466538667678833, -0.0048041497357189655, -0.028028959408402443, 0.013705006800591946, 0.019924353808164597, -0.05750957503914833, 0.007992131635546684, -0.04631751403212547, -0.028936142101883888, -0.04544448480010033, -0.02211817353963852, -0.012473338283598423, -0.03750311955809593, 0.03912990912795067, -0.000770783459302038, 0.004157210234552622, -0.04653726518154144, -0.0033473579678684473, -0.01490770187228918, 0.05487130209803581, 0.020448943600058556, -0.02311881072819233, -0.031012805178761482, 0.00366316270083189, -0.017299039289355278, 0.03168318048119545, -0.03333159163594246, -0.03222344443202019, 0.055591437965631485, 0.04663316532969475, 0.02333173342049122, 0.025670170783996582, -0.00764174060896039, -0.040035050362348557, -0.08714529871940613, 0.08451934158802032, -0.05279102921485901, 0.035126373171806335, -0.09664179384708405, 0.04309501498937607, 0.04185250401496887, -0.0204011257737875, -0.01966250315308571, 0.018968544900417328, -0.03386516124010086, 0.0332341305911541, -0.03592894598841667, -0.030847588554024696, 0.06351976096630096, -0.06985196471214294, 0.001611734856851399, 0.003667171113193035, 0.011674431152641773, -0.0003294319612905383, -0.01699095033109188, 0.035303469747304916, -0.0014856384368613362, 0.003476048819720745, 0.050493642687797546, 0.0862453505396843, -0.0003972031408920884, 0.04791038855910301, -0.02635125070810318, -0.02796749398112297, 0.07780280709266663, -0.013554011471569538, 0.009093624539673328, -0.09133885055780411, 0.010290969163179398, 0.015270312316715717, 0.000981403747573495, 0.06495630741119385, -0.05360673367977142, 0.007593238260596991, 0.0010192317422479391, 0.039040952920913696, 0.07081210613250732, -0.045577701181173325, 0.056413136422634125, 0.03582295775413513, -0.01982557773590088, 0.04444396495819092, 0.06740124523639679, 0.006139251869171858, 0.033630844205617905, 0.03947119414806366, -0.005442365072667599, -0.001215119264088571, 0.02482319250702858, -0.038041483610868454, -0.039238493889570236, 0.024542532861232758, -0.04325806349515915, -0.05199625715613365, 0.024150073528289795, 0.04009179025888443, -0.04134616628289223, 0.07784442603588104, -0.010349101386964321, -0.025602199137210846, -0.026792382821440697, 0.09532418102025986, 0.01737024635076523, -0.002879022154957056, 0.001268572174012661, 0.05381576716899872, -0.048825014382600784, -0.0010066727409139276, -0.01577046327292919, 0.04542776942253113, -0.01777511276304722, 0.025619029998779297, -0.006554549094289541, 0.014818933792412281, 0.08563634753227234, 0.021144654601812363, 0.007320212200284004, 0.00966202188283205, 0.05760177969932556, -0.0543053112924099, 0.02477029152214527, -0.00673698540776968, -0.09921825677156448, -0.0309365876019001, -0.11979740113019943, -0.018190348520874977, -0.01803608238697052, -0.0018881504656746984, -0.01293948758393526, 0.049926213920116425, -0.02681894041597843, -0.09531392902135849, 0.021740185096859932, 0.03096422739326954, 0.0378270298242569, -0.024831270799040794, 0.03830457851290703, -0.02272943966090679, 0.01797722652554512, 0.05760326236486435, -0.016387777402997017, -0.07831568270921707 ]
59
59
Derivations of Normalized Mutual Information in Binary Classifications
This correspondence studies the basic problem of classifications - how to evaluate different classifiers. Although the conventional performance indexes, such as accuracy, are commonly used in classifier selection or evaluation, information-based criteria, such as mutual information, are becoming popular in feature/model selections. In this work, we propose to assess classifiers in terms of normalized mutual information (NI), which is novel and well defined in a compact range for classifier evaluation. We derive close-form relations of normalized mutual information with respect to accuracy, precision, and recall in binary classifications. By exploring the relations among them, we reveal that NI is actually a set of nonlinear functions, with a concordant power-exponent form, to each performance index. The relations can also be expressed with respect to precision and recall, or to false alarm and hitting rate (recall).
[ -0.027268679812550545, -0.059660714119672775, 0.02224131114780903, 0.037634894251823425, 0.049336906522512436, -0.07444260269403458, -0.01655002497136593, -0.004297183360904455, -0.027714025229215622, 0.00326391845010221, 0.026936916634440422, 0.04697481542825699, -0.06322697550058365, 0.001748856739141047, 0.015444080345332623, 0.015155741944909096, 0.018082208931446075, -0.048959337174892426, 0.008889718912541866, -0.07295334339141846, -0.025171291083097458, 0.01047742459923029, -0.006675905082374811, -0.06570826470851898, -0.020420078188180923, 0.009037288837134838, -0.051438506692647934, 0.03285202383995056, -0.10373818129301071, 0.03911186009645462, 0.04755815491080284, -0.049148079007864, 0.05780884250998497, -0.033131491392850876, -0.035596542060375214, 0.013530346564948559, 0.030283760279417038, -0.026164764538407326, -0.06574742496013641, 0.017223257571458817, -0.04449312761425972, 0.04205457493662834, -0.03737335279583931, 0.0008061890257522464, 0.037252262234687805, 0.043594229966402054, -0.006899109110236168, 0.039518676698207855, 0.03989551216363907, 0.031848762184381485, -0.04170578718185425, -0.05585120618343353, 0.0433865524828434, -0.008306152187287807, -0.0017203155439347029, 0.016065645962953568, 0.0132986381649971, -0.051243096590042114, 0.04266108199954033, -0.009278222918510437, 0.04060717672109604, 0.11146430671215057, -0.03503955155611038, -0.032162878662347794, 0.008379853330552578, -0.051996540278196335, -0.04744821786880493, -0.02406613528728485, 0.014914646744728088, -0.06608784198760986, 0.024742987006902695, -0.04285726696252823, -0.00971287116408348, -0.02571341209113598, 0.028304079547524452, -0.06578143686056137, 0.004779106471687555, 0.0043832724913954735, 0.003479848150163889, 0.032916679978370667, -0.07997499406337738, 0.02536150813102722, -0.014777159318327904, -0.009682715870440006, -0.04597226530313492, -0.03648001328110695, 0.03259968385100365, -0.08321083337068558, 0.03928464278578758, 0.03919975087046623, 0.031254980713129044, -0.011842799372971058, -0.05284806713461876, 0.03840089216828346, -0.02715717814862728, -0.017866266891360283, 0.006015479099005461, -0.004125714767724276, 0.12939393520355225, -0.0027722606901079416, 0.014386492781341076, -0.01761193573474884, 0.04614831134676933, 0.040036655962467194, -0.07395541667938232, -0.02554081380367279, -0.034899599850177765, 0.007209603674709797, 0.00620146794244647, -0.015927251428365707, 0.10760881006717682, -0.034780073910951614, 0.017044344916939735, 0.029701322317123413, 0.019990846514701843, 0.01753092370927334, -0.04198061302304268, 0.04217979684472084, 0.01749376393854618, 0.024419795721769333, -0.025919105857610703, 0.02524460293352604, -0.06324835866689682, 0.034844040870666504, -0.0015940387966111302, -0.021001508459448814, -0.086652971804142, -0.06890086084604263, 0.04999777302145958, -0.03966284170746803, -0.06593797355890274, 0.07600145041942596, -0.04137825220823288, 0.029637375846505165, -0.07663971930742264, 0.02226676046848297, 0.012956947088241577, -0.025921206921339035, 0.05063192546367645, 0.06953900307416916, -0.050250064581632614, -0.025617027655243874, 0.032410699874162674, 0.0029337783344089985, 0.036096133291721344, 0.09901826828718185, 0.027362754568457603, 0.0019617974758148193, 0.013315970078110695, -0.022878777235746384, 0.00989625882357359, -0.06213333457708359, 0.08436429500579834, 0.047548748552799225, 0.007658503018319607, -0.020812252536416054, -0.04434758052229881, -0.05028913542628288, -0.06301133334636688, -0.03044174239039421, -0.029711080715060234, -0.059015821665525436, 0.032790567725896835, 0.07958213984966278, -0.06688638776540756, -0.0029627683106809855, -0.09008760005235672, 0.01886252872645855, -0.010808287188410759, -0.009190456010401249, -0.07629124075174332, 0.012657178565859795, -0.08769671618938446, -0.009613017551600933, 0.030383333563804626, -0.05917876958847046, -0.10800307989120483, -0.005891504231840372, -0.05252944305539131, 0.0031496533192694187, 0.03737113997340202, -0.13984158635139465, 0.02344292402267456, 0.06664784997701645, 0.07713357359170914, 0.07880440354347229, -0.06126239895820618, -0.04817064851522446, 0.015159142203629017, 0.025145839899778366, 0.05980250611901283, 0.005665426608175039, -0.055964019149541855, -0.014515640214085579, -0.0076131210662424564, 0.012849119491875172, 0.035894330590963364, -0.01559299137443304, 0.06086580455303192, 0.0308813638985157, 0.061073049902915955, -0.013592716306447983, -0.031411416828632355, 0.02643272839486599, -0.024983571842312813, -0.023118680343031883, -0.004156914073973894, -0.04592746123671532, -0.027746038511395454, -0.06260038912296295, 0.046943843364715576, -0.015555989928543568, 0.07970128953456879, 0.02302180416882038, 0.0006170380511321127, -0.07085833698511124, -0.025990985333919525, 0.03322259709239006, 0.03171772509813309, 0.05798158422112465, -0.03595269098877907, 0.021003302186727524, -0.06711648404598236, 0.04046124219894409, -0.05918888747692108, -0.00012113535194657743, -0.004908857401460409, -0.018491972237825394, -0.08391477912664413, 0.08685129135847092, -0.002817700384184718, -0.02372516319155693, -0.06702591478824615, -0.05165915936231613, 0.024303290992975235, 0.004073201213032007, -0.07920072227716446, 0.023606836795806885, -0.013917944394052029, -0.003951745573431253, -0.014502427540719509, 0.0915575698018074, -0.039252329617738724, -0.009313009679317474, 0.01146052498370409, -0.055106133222579956, 0.06663760542869568, 0.08924535661935806, 0.03919461742043495, 0.010350538417696953, -0.045678723603487015, -0.02487891912460327, 0.006742167752236128, -0.0643107071518898, 0.052613649517297745, 0.05742352455854416, -0.06028857082128525, 0.02273484878242016, 0.025515250861644745, 0.03858884796500206, -0.014189708977937698, 0.04886990040540695, 0.03096790611743927, -0.010511943139135838, 0.057020992040634155, -0.025708509609103203, -0.03569288179278374, 0.033385019749403, -0.017570462077856064, -0.047240324318408966, -0.0909404456615448, -0.0842985212802887, 0.010674845427274704, 0.062485139816999435, 0.004526485688984394, -0.014548528008162975, 0.03451443463563919, -0.015946004539728165, 0.08524451404809952, -0.01507773157209158, -0.06841521710157394, 0.014338448643684387, -0.0043457988649606705, -0.014246305450797081, -0.046166397631168365, -0.020835459232330322, -0.029120642691850662, -0.02126213163137436, 0.059018395841121674, -0.01358746737241745, -0.05246342346072197, 0.03342301771044731, -0.045284077525138855, -0.062741219997406, 0.05057656764984131, -0.04794764518737793, 0.004641346167773008, 0.035880621522665024, 0.06687718629837036, -0.03422496095299721, -0.04565320163965225, 0.029660100117325783, 0.035947952419519424, 0.05687151476740837, 0.043957386165857315, 0.02307618409395218, 0.03380922973155975, 0.0017448592698201537, -0.006450272630900145, -0.02910885401070118, 0.07345177233219147, -0.06400753557682037, 0.029309216886758804, 0.017113223671913147, 0.02678823471069336, 0.022138608619570732, 0.0034132509026676416, 0.01050582341849804, -0.05420143902301788, -0.006080589722841978, -0.010039581917226315, 0.01598982699215412, -0.011053360067307949, -0.03721337020397186, -0.045440901070833206, 0.006439760327339172, 0.011885183863341808, -0.036519188433885574, -0.11858168244361877, 0.057277433574199677, -0.051052700728178024, -0.054142437875270844, 0.056021373718976974, 0.11338888108730316, -0.04163489118218422, 0.05809688940644264, -0.04520249739289284, 0.019221192225813866, -0.026893284171819687, 0.00014366500545293093, -0.0705377608537674, -0.047231610864400864, -0.00026676408015191555, -0.023107003420591354, -0.023445384576916695, 0.05407304689288139, 0.04082607105374336, -0.0446661114692688, -0.06809324026107788, 0.03011416271328926, -0.019198263064026833, 0.06573040783405304, -0.05647015571594238, 0.07090262323617935, -0.053166862577199936, 0.11691787838935852, 0.0669364184141159, 0.003710936289280653, -0.002118436386808753, 0.02561580203473568, 0.025308191776275635, 0.05729474127292633, -0.05507374927401543, 0.0076842899434268475, 0.0640331357717514, 0.07869420945644379, -0.0072014667093753815, -0.003975787665694952, -0.03371022269129753, 0.0008831294253468513, -0.002902297070249915, 0.007394677493721247, 0.06195344775915146, -0.03260355815291405, 0.041909340769052505, 0.003096560249105096, -0.005589168053120375, 0.0010651008924469352, 0.05712100863456726, 0.024512330070137978, -0.08947813510894775, 0.0012129200622439384, -0.02587682008743286, 0.037129804491996765, -0.04675084352493286, -0.018556667491793633, -0.021452033892273903, 0.02217920497059822, 0.061432741582393646, 0.013058030046522617, 0.012346003204584122, -0.07471966743469238, -0.03376328572630882, 0.01655120588839054, 0.047058142721652985, 0.03080446645617485, 0.014503927901387215, 0.010872972197830677, -0.0944414734840393, -0.04121760278940201, -0.006739459931850433, -0.08407296240329742, -0.056544721126556396, -0.07044251263141632, -0.07424567639827728, -0.009733940474689007, -0.058653343468904495, 0.11010400205850601, -0.04842337965965271, -0.007742234040051699, 0.027392681688070297, -0.0008110872586257756, -0.034121230244636536, -0.02730746380984783, 0.0466323047876358, 0.0027445335872471333, 0.044235844165086746, -0.029692310839891434, -0.012506749480962753, -0.03839820250868797, 0.0384264700114727, 0.01923404633998871, 0.005237070377916098, 0.03452782705426216, -0.0011416553752496839, 0.028617912903428078, 0.028694018721580505, 0.015886757522821426, 0.00852882582694292, 0.015506002120673656, -0.029291938990354538, 0.051780540496110916, -0.032844170928001404, 0.015901906415820122, 0.034352514892816544, -0.03193618357181549, 0.08418241888284683, 0.007855217903852463, 0.008922811597585678, -0.043631404638290405, -0.040382269769907, -0.03006701171398163, 0.02506263181567192, 0.0646379366517067, 0.037074342370033264, 0.042697563767433167, 0.09761544317007065, -0.02638094313442707, 0.0447421558201313, 0.02587735839188099, -0.05188922584056854, -0.0858856588602066, -0.024455601349473, -0.0439457930624485, -0.05708744376897812, -0.0503067746758461, -0.021731005981564522, -0.08976377546787262, 0.02230810560286045, -0.03834407776594162, -0.02651863917708397, -0.06710182130336761, 0.015558406710624695, -0.025901975110173225, -0.10133176296949387, 0.013451885432004929, 0.053860001266002655, -0.027969947084784508, -0.009809468872845173, -0.004076496697962284, -0.061464205384254456, -0.035002052783966064, 0.04157979413866997, -0.03913973271846771, 0.01585991680622101, -0.024835141375660896, -0.030812039971351624, -0.017325464636087418, -0.05448168143630028, -0.030975285917520523, 0.032783426344394684, -0.04217340797185898, -0.012026370503008366, 0.04134826362133026, 0.04857712611556053, -0.02793114259839058, -0.0022860185708850622, 0.07535909861326218, -0.044016283005476, -0.022014465183019638, -0.018624041229486465, 0.0064454167149960995, -0.06063995882868767, 0.024738173931837082, 0.03747871145606041, 0.01802419312298298, -0.006273308768868446, 0.020647568628191948, -0.004303292371332645, 0.024042021483182907, 0.006030612625181675, -0.019165093079209328, 0.02916468121111393, -0.01771736703813076, 0.028420954942703247, 0.017572330310940742, -0.0006624764646403491, 0.05631345883011818, 0.021255528554320335, -0.004337911959737539, -0.0016053958097472787, -0.031743403524160385 ]
60
60
Covariance and PCA for Categorical Variables
Covariances from categorical variables are defined using a regular simplex expression for categories. The method follows the variance definition by Gini, and it gives the covariance as a solution of simultaneous equations. The calculated results give reasonable values for test data. A method of principal component analysis (RS-PCA) is also proposed using regular simplex expressions, which allows easy interpretation of the principal components. The proposed methods apply to variable selection problem of categorical data USCensus1990 data. The proposed methods give appropriate criterion for the variable selection problem of categorical
[ 0.059359874576330185, -0.0049548642709851265, 0.02254830300807953, 0.015627339482307434, -0.010840298607945442, 0.004348565824329853, -0.019714821130037308, 0.020105374976992607, 0.012722707353532314, 0.023100847378373146, 0.05438465625047684, 0.022083867341279984, -0.022615451365709305, 0.09126362949609756, -0.05244402214884758, -0.016533704474568367, -0.0837092399597168, 0.007526456378400326, 0.04649459198117256, -0.06646935641765594, -0.05037194862961769, 0.05073222517967224, -0.055474359542131424, -0.0686705932021141, 0.023802440613508224, -0.004186281003057957, -0.009538437239825726, 0.01832619681954384, 0.005128706805408001, -0.03068467043340206, -0.07388874143362045, -0.021662412211298943, 0.006377113983035088, -0.000831671291962266, 0.05427498370409012, -0.036188989877700806, -0.03037615306675434, 0.054591692984104156, -0.052546001970767975, -0.02240084484219551, -0.03502814844250679, 0.03303862735629082, 0.04885883256793022, 0.002219177084043622, 0.03437933325767517, -0.03523724153637886, 0.043510518968105316, 0.030584273859858513, -0.03894111141562462, 0.002597200218588114, -0.03169062361121178, -0.0033128017093986273, 0.05725898593664169, 0.004800299648195505, 0.0033199707977473736, 0.02395443432033062, 0.005381969269365072, -0.03590979427099228, 0.04482037574052811, -0.0702323243021965, 0.010967331007122993, 0.06466078013181686, 0.04141790419816971, 0.005521522369235754, -0.04881616309285164, 0.021138515323400497, -0.09535156935453415, -0.03549781069159508, -0.03652708977460861, -0.03878428041934967, 0.06699098646640778, -0.016661306843161583, -0.021757131442427635, 0.0010147987632080913, -0.042116422206163406, 0.007931538857519627, 0.02134566754102707, 0.04720442369580269, -0.05794103071093559, 0.05946522206068039, -0.02263660915195942, 0.0523059219121933, 0.001717635546810925, -0.012574143707752228, -0.08857530355453491, -0.04052874073386192, 0.05384763330221176, -0.06274043023586273, 0.04573742672801018, 0.056539300829172134, -0.021545974537730217, -0.027582118287682533, -0.06536678224802017, 0.029199613258242607, 0.025226552039384842, 0.012925063259899616, -0.005771130323410034, -0.00940533634275198, -0.01865973509848118, -0.020610369741916656, -0.002609724411740899, -0.08989883214235306, 0.035416241735219955, 0.05166678503155708, -0.033066850155591965, 0.04551896080374718, -0.04348345100879669, 0.08532731235027313, -0.01985764503479004, -0.033157043159008026, 0.009023833088576794, 0.06061224639415741, 0.04195282608270645, -0.027990302070975304, -0.0561390295624733, 0.08389797806739807, 0.05291203036904335, 0.08961724489927292, 0.02137162536382675, -0.06383251398801804, 0.0050565083511173725, 0.04214537888765335, -0.07643860578536987, 0.03809639811515808, 0.03226107731461525, 0.010187435895204544, 0.02585865929722786, -0.0701213926076889, 0.05972922220826149, 0.012084771879017353, -0.07846593111753464, 0.08244112133979797, -0.06820107996463776, -0.0064252871088683605, -0.1055329218506813, 0.054054856300354004, 0.004217991139739752, -0.07012763619422913, -0.025491775944828987, -0.0015379528049379587, -0.06314361840486526, -0.13031697273254395, -0.018042990937829018, 0.014896469190716743, 0.045027509331703186, 0.0760357528924942, 0.018452776595950127, 0.009764631278812885, -0.07524262368679047, -0.028505833819508553, -0.0004380555765237659, -0.006439163815230131, 0.014544062316417694, 0.10744492709636688, 0.021277517080307007, -0.06103799119591713, -0.011458128690719604, -0.06529949605464935, 0.002167439553886652, 0.023603513836860657, 0.02563963457942009, 0.009638926945626736, 0.03686995059251785, 0.0631125271320343, -0.029929710552096367, 0.030737722292542458, -0.03501437231898308, -0.034132253378629684, 0.027480317279696465, -0.05333198234438896, -0.05888676270842552, 0.008766794577240944, 0.003606001380831003, 0.029547594487667084, 0.01752372644841671, 0.06061415374279022, -0.016813335940241814, 0.02216522954404354, -0.06618595123291016, -0.019253060221672058, 0.08344319462776184, -0.02957065962255001, -0.036129359155893326, -0.028186213225126266, 0.012695807963609695, 0.08562666177749634, 0.013548566959798336, 0.027714431285858154, 0.039518751204013824, 0.013103346340358257, 0.0760330930352211, -0.014546684920787811, 0.03185822442173958, 0.04448194429278374, 0.005292153917253017, -0.004249605815857649, -0.03524420037865639, -0.07827582955360413, 0.029710544273257256, 0.0610680989921093, 0.02999216876924038, 0.0029061196837574244, -0.05546679347753525, -0.02799852006137371, -0.05940486490726471, 0.025869149714708328, 0.01573123410344124, -0.005161256063729525, 0.032564591616392136, -0.037766773253679276, -0.01108100637793541, 0.003633383894339204, 0.0036116319242864847, -0.0733959898352623, 0.00597496097907424, 0.021896755322813988, -0.012645011767745018, 0.016675950959324837, 0.024327561259269714, 0.026414984837174416, -0.0329609178006649, 0.02231716178357601, -0.03479432687163353, -0.03547042980790138, -0.043528202921152115, 0.012006592936813831, 0.03219763934612274, -0.024082666262984276, -0.08856691420078278, 0.00984065979719162, -0.015004346147179604, -0.08179548382759094, -0.004188099410384893, -0.03788335248827934, -0.041271235793828964, 0.03769415616989136, -0.015269927680492401, -0.03158416971564293, 0.026896608993411064, -0.007317266892641783, -0.036496929824352264, 0.08319587260484695, -0.08913639187812805, 0.0204229224473238, -0.01599649339914322, -0.061399489641189575, 0.0025285689625889063, 0.07150110602378845, 0.0033022225834429264, 0.07804244011640549, -0.07612522691488266, -0.01826588809490204, 0.007215674500912428, -0.02136414125561714, 0.003438383573666215, -0.014345861971378326, -0.11644915491342545, 0.004848044365644455, 0.037109922617673874, 0.055128779262304306, -0.023781361058354378, 0.03962366655468941, 0.011253617703914642, -0.03222288563847542, 0.07446072995662689, -0.02118823491036892, 0.027640450745821, 0.029182353988289833, 0.030831586569547653, 0.0344979353249073, -0.06333068013191223, -0.041563037782907486, -0.03849213197827339, 0.04077612981200218, -0.020898571237921715, 0.0008369694696739316, 0.01371875498443842, 0.07666216045618057, -0.05585610866546631, -0.039986178278923035, 0.01672470197081566, 0.07493941485881805, -0.010839659720659256, -0.003528330009430647, 0.07068592309951782, -0.04925701394677162, -0.02404361218214035, 0.044468387961387634, -0.039935607463121414, 0.06495971232652664, -0.10121094435453415, 0.017627662047743797, -0.04402292147278786, 0.032528817653656006, 0.009348717518150806, -0.0465247742831707, 0.021224185824394226, 0.018845101818442345, 0.066893070936203, -0.05314476042985916, -0.03425561264157295, 0.08058673143386841, -0.013108733110129833, -0.03797776997089386, 0.02965095266699791, 0.03851385787129402, 0.08443736284971237, 0.022149307653307915, 0.04541957378387451, -0.018882811069488525, 0.0027074473910033703, -0.02273326925933361, -0.0617494098842144, -0.02497536689043045, -0.04814590513706207, 0.03009631298482418, 0.022594153881072998, -0.0023051192983984947, 0.0066294497810304165, 0.0048687998205423355, -0.06281016021966934, 0.005850078538060188, 0.0625787228345871, -0.006577552296221256, -0.009049258194863796, 0.04505978897213936, -0.0000818679400254041, 0.04091963544487953, -0.09286825358867645, 0.027122629806399345, -0.03782171383500099, 0.003614787943661213, -0.042150676250457764, 0.08522956073284149, -0.012747619301080704, 0.03974466398358345, -0.043318185955286026, 0.02015032060444355, -0.05260559171438217, -0.06738294661045074, 0.02087281085550785, -0.08381164819002151, -0.03712097555398941, -0.005744868889451027, -0.046664271503686905, 0.05491314083337784, 0.10688196867704391, -0.03534093126654625, -0.10655506700277328, -0.014683675952255726, -0.05737050622701645, 0.01997392438352108, 0.010616935789585114, 0.03083004616200924, -0.04574833810329437, 0.060550034046173096, 0.09628935903310776, 0.006661430932581425, -0.02730061672627926, 0.04754061996936798, -0.07676156610250473, -0.020676009356975555, -0.039244119077920914, 0.03487672284245491, 0.005455601494759321, 0.015205125324428082, -0.002466669538989663, 0.03177693113684654, 0.022736696526408195, 0.013690787367522717, 0.014596597291529179, -0.019235994666814804, -0.004535295069217682, 0.035072196274995804, 0.031776461750268936, 0.0259022805839777, 0.08685444295406342, -0.026154937222599983, -0.05808477848768234, 0.042506180703639984, -0.009995718486607075, 0.011725213378667831, 0.006359549704939127, 0.007708980701863766, -0.00774276303127408, -0.04581892862915993, 0.002111535519361496, 0.03821711614727974, 0.07106588780879974, 0.02574414573609829, -0.0503743477165699, -0.06541112065315247, 0.04943262040615082, -0.005552883259952068, 0.04591171815991402, 0.05033203214406967, 0.015031307004392147, -0.024506300687789917, 0.026757055893540382, -0.02411656267940998, 0.046355899423360825, -0.00719790905714035, 0.03890109807252884, -0.07935615628957748, 0.03078703209757805, -0.008001375943422318, -0.009564289823174477, -0.008515332825481892, 0.016601111739873886, 0.006812472362071276, -0.010871177539229393, 0.059307921677827835, -0.06680081784725189, -0.017369117587804794, -0.023368822410702705, 0.06470245867967606, 0.05275449901819229, 0.06182656064629555, 0.015124009922146797, -0.022994225844740868, 0.03859368711709976, -0.0173331405967474, -0.010724264197051525, 0.03651467338204384, 0.0778995156288147, -0.02168496884405613, 0.06041007861495018, 0.035702988505363464, -0.017606055364012718, -0.021004242822527885, 0.005913177505135536, -0.022087277844548225, 0.002956933109089732, 0.06593745946884155, 0.061272960156202316, 0.012981227599084377, 0.000042053055949509144, -0.01882748492062092, 0.08123873919248581, -0.005536839831620455, -0.026276497170329094, -0.04402438923716545, 0.005514825694262981, 0.004834719933569431, 0.04679345712065697, -0.003333714324980974, 0.021447546780109406, 0.012025379575788975, 0.04038028046488762, 0.04088357836008072, -0.07517717033624649, -0.023695262148976326, -0.00241256901063025, -0.045547254383563995, 0.05461932718753815, 0.02682051621377468, 0.039799220860004425, -0.11165766417980194, 0.050697747617959976, -0.07698510587215424, 0.028754811733961105, 0.004850868135690689, -0.02918844483792782, 0.021074442192912102, -0.10894164443016052, -0.00010270650091115385, 0.041103266179561615, 0.009626495651900768, 0.061277300119400024, 0.04438921436667442, -0.0402543731033802, 0.03332994133234024, -0.07553260028362274, -0.0014039326924830675, 0.007175439968705177, -0.03588232398033142, -0.019728880375623703, 0.057474687695503235, 0.001311705680564046, -0.050133466720581055, 0.026125168427824974, -0.03930453211069107, -0.02545321173965931, 0.048962801694869995, 0.09326884895563126, 0.058329880237579346, -0.01417301595211029, 0.04053250327706337, 0.010773117654025555, -0.01699548400938511, -0.04643790051341057, -0.027632826939225197, -0.10211300104856491, -0.009829490445554256, -0.005045501049607992, 0.08930417895317078, -0.04572141170501709, 0.030286312103271484, 0.0396508052945137, 0.012146461755037308, -0.06260519474744797, -0.062018558382987976, 0.08625838160514832, 0.0004203032294753939, 0.05455328896641731, 0.03201781585812569, 0.09545040130615234, -0.020763907581567764, -0.02893180213868618, 0.05960056185722351, -0.006078327540308237, -0.01436270959675312 ]
61
61
On the Relationship between the Posterior and Optimal Similarity
For a classification problem described by the joint density $P(\omega,x)$, models of $P(\omega\eq\omega'|x,x')$ (the ``Bayesian similarity measure'') have been shown to be an optimal similarity measure for nearest neighbor classification. This paper analyzes demonstrates several additional properties of that conditional distribution. The paper first shows that we can reconstruct, up to class labels, the class posterior distribution $P(\omega|x)$ given $P(\omega\eq\omega'|x,x')$, gives a procedure for recovering the class labels, and gives an asymptotically Bayes-optimal classification procedure. It also shows, given such an optimal similarity measure, how to construct a classifier that outperforms the nearest neighbor classifier and achieves Bayes-optimal classification rates. The paper then analyzes Bayesian similarity in a framework where a classifier faces a number of related classification tasks (multitask learning) and illustrates that reconstruction of the class posterior distribution is not possible in general. Finally, the paper identifies a distinct class of classification problems using $P(\omega\eq\omega'|x,x')$ and shows that using $P(\omega\eq\omega'|x,x')$ to solve those problems is the Bayes optimal solution.
[ -0.025542527437210083, -0.05749480426311493, -0.058040183037519455, 0.03510023653507233, 0.053347937762737274, -0.056288108229637146, -0.00663476437330246, -0.013558286242187023, -0.05156936123967171, 0.037241991609334946, -0.06495070457458496, -0.020670512691140175, -0.028218435123562813, -0.030066248029470444, 0.05450604110956192, -0.018834644928574562, -0.05987704545259476, -0.06736479699611664, 0.06158788129687309, -0.0973270833492279, 0.025923416018486023, -0.023041408509016037, -0.032570697367191315, -0.011469938792288303, 0.02228633128106594, 0.002100342186167836, -0.017077051103115082, 0.042084887623786926, -0.022981924936175346, 0.020924638956785202, 0.05406253784894943, -0.0321563296020031, -0.059967558830976486, 0.042910173535346985, 0.0746326893568039, -0.040691111236810684, 0.005845906678587198, -0.03380637988448143, -0.06995538622140884, -0.019273674115538597, -0.04491465538740158, -0.0015541823813691735, 0.041610077023506165, 0.01632864773273468, 0.0831003189086914, 0.027997266501188278, 0.061401888728141785, 0.011357671581208706, 0.002093811985105276, 0.09383141249418259, -0.07284459471702576, 0.05002681165933609, 0.027794864028692245, 0.0014905830612406135, -0.01249436940997839, 0.046349361538887024, 0.040370531380176544, -0.024312477558851242, -0.09180832654237747, -0.0441705584526062, 0.017584633082151413, 0.040778111666440964, -0.034374870359897614, 0.010505941696465015, -0.023410921916365623, 0.004129459150135517, -0.06298784911632538, -0.023253196850419044, 0.027737433090806007, -0.00643299100920558, -0.01302277110517025, -0.08963601291179657, -0.043390221893787384, 0.02681490033864975, -0.01984379068017006, 0.031120840460062027, 0.05916691571474075, 0.03503400832414627, -0.03746648505330086, 0.07349739968776703, -0.061012718826532364, -0.009315650910139084, -0.012162243016064167, 0.05524645373225212, -0.03484781086444855, 0.04040783271193504, -0.047304198145866394, -0.023380590602755547, -0.00036139876465313137, 0.022277120500802994, -0.043149519711732864, 0.024055669084191322, -0.056605782359838486, 0.023925838991999626, -0.022691242396831512, 0.024826832115650177, 0.008907375857234001, -0.0018459149869158864, -0.03624580055475235, 0.043877582997083664, -0.004171842709183693, -0.05622630938887596, -0.010547534562647343, 0.0660444125533104, -0.003482616739347577, 0.01840977929532528, -0.054171591997146606, 0.01960509642958641, 0.01653284579515457, 0.01596864126622677, 0.04258155822753906, -0.0717463493347168, 0.004139193799346685, -0.00850310456007719, -0.03088242933154106, 0.04556477069854736, -0.023725636303424835, 0.10603870451450348, -0.03479236736893654, 0.06343678385019302, 0.013294260017573833, 0.019404975697398186, -0.08774714916944504, 0.09863832592964172, 0.06204868480563164, 0.008206268772482872, 0.012671203352510929, 0.002598994644358754, 0.14068914949893951, 0.01737438142299652, -0.07912172377109528, 0.04418538883328438, 0.04255407303571701, -0.029626529663801193, -0.1033652126789093, -0.0016900199698284268, 0.09285515546798706, -0.028846068307757378, -0.030295846983790398, 0.11690323799848557, -0.05294690653681755, -0.031328774988651276, -0.003008953295648098, 0.059683505445718765, 0.037567202001810074, 0.05703408643603325, -0.006740383803844452, 0.03566550463438034, -0.059062469750642776, 0.014651178382337093, -0.062426190823316574, -0.09331333637237549, 0.03743639215826988, 0.0929131805896759, 0.06502348929643631, -0.04482366144657135, 0.023851292207837105, -0.025639990344643593, 0.0587434358894825, 0.06244436651468277, -0.04801168665289879, 0.008143862709403038, 0.035464808344841, 0.06714995205402374, -0.04171063378453255, 0.02338232286274433, 0.014663907699286938, 0.023124799132347107, 0.00330745498649776, -0.07856161147356033, -0.03128428757190704, -0.04996579885482788, -0.06404855102300644, 0.006644619628787041, -0.032416973263025284, -0.028375497087836266, -0.04123741760849953, -0.02964620850980282, -0.03969592601060867, 0.011802807450294495, 0.026286747306585312, -0.05236480012536049, -0.013983129523694515, 0.04828641936182976, 0.004433057736605406, 0.08760559558868408, -0.026518013328313828, 0.04182273522019386, 0.04543457552790642, -0.024041563272476196, 0.025350075215101242, -0.045359525829553604, 0.012761542573571205, -0.017910854890942574, -0.03702235966920853, 0.011241716332733631, -0.05499716475605965, -0.0023033113684505224, 0.02552514337003231, -0.003973308019340038, 0.018846634775400162, -0.043877921998500824, -0.019791781902313232, 0.004926848690956831, -0.02550014667212963, 0.07869865745306015, 0.06076543778181076, -0.06574779748916626, -0.03172967582941055, -0.04594775289297104, -0.011223585344851017, 0.022099725902080536, -0.007421695161610842, -0.014267200604081154, 0.03260539844632149, -0.051430631428956985, -0.054948266595602036, -0.0445859432220459, -0.01955166645348072, 0.007467169780284166, -0.045867931097745895, 0.0027092539239674807, -0.04490722343325615, 0.0792471244931221, -0.06338179856538773, -0.004324376583099365, 0.012432253919541836, -0.0470874160528183, -0.061736442148685455, 0.06916846334934235, -0.07139376550912857, -0.08746407181024551, -0.05444918945431709, -0.01975257135927677, 0.02759644016623497, 0.035435862839221954, -0.09951535612344742, 0.036622386425733566, 0.007352342363446951, -0.01161618810147047, -0.08067451417446136, 0.08256787061691284, 0.014440356753766537, -0.049176231026649475, 0.00952086877077818, -0.0819997638463974, -0.026051703840494156, -0.006519005633890629, 0.016633227467536926, 0.03934180736541748, -0.030459992587566376, 0.037208233028650284, -0.009228166192770004, -0.012644592672586441, 0.020861437544226646, -0.03243940323591232, -0.03551797941327095, 0.022487986832857132, 0.046700213104486465, 0.08117807656526566, 0.03514203056693077, 0.02742929570376873, -0.013297044672071934, -0.053919099271297455, 0.027103180065751076, 0.06761393696069717, 0.029700221493840218, 0.03112075664103031, -0.013441752642393112, -0.04452746734023094, 0.05514160543680191, -0.03846791014075279, -0.035139065235853195, 0.05279891937971115, -0.03641004115343094, 0.006895827129483223, -0.019031446427106857, 0.0597064383327961, 0.025171086192131042, -0.08459030091762543, -0.08068104088306427, 0.10050207376480103, 0.0015721609815955162, -0.03071395307779312, -0.055386561900377274, -0.04035463556647301, 0.05770333483815193, 0.023249173536896706, -0.023707151412963867, -0.023851823061704636, -0.04483513906598091, 0.06681763380765915, 0.023678550496697426, -0.024317875504493713, 0.03626757487654686, -0.09341815859079361, 0.07749195396900177, -0.020631810650229454, 0.033606067299842834, -0.013735285960137844, -0.061283908784389496, -0.003860162105411291, 0.04115338996052742, 0.010700984857976437, 0.022096479311585426, 0.07452180236577988, 0.009108411148190498, 0.03703320026397705, -0.051740046590566635, -0.005723109468817711, -0.015320983715355396, -0.024448204785585403, -0.03085731342434883, 0.10194415599107742, 0.06637194007635117, -0.06149781495332718, -0.002640075283125043, -0.014759862795472145, 0.006323712412267923, 0.030320068821310997, 0.023967798799276352, -0.024792781099677086, 0.030842360109090805, 0.044003020972013474, -0.07887929677963257, -0.05097389966249466, 0.04168982431292534, 0.06165454164147377, -0.09665372967720032, 0.032225947827100754, -0.03527731075882912, -0.004067257046699524, -0.03050297684967518, 0.05765159800648689, -0.02048763632774353, 0.03424942120909691, -0.004474423360079527, -0.016986846923828125, -0.0350395143032074, 0.04744888097047806, -0.01127349678426981, -0.029959075152873993, -0.03560549393296242, -0.009269773960113525, 0.002220056252554059, 0.0004431009292602539, 0.03398370370268822, -0.02821309119462967, -0.004137183073908091, 0.007300284691154957, -0.06649040430784225, 0.06960875540971756, 0.004298357758671045, 0.05646933242678642, -0.05553092062473297, 0.03722942993044853, 0.10885286331176758, 0.012108292430639267, 0.018398676067590714, 0.0039717354811728, -0.014489110559225082, 0.04708041250705719, -0.07041489332914352, -0.03762294724583626, -0.017535878345370293, 0.027757469564676285, -0.0447821170091629, 0.06707116961479187, 0.0014092199271544814, -0.01948738843202591, 0.0022311334032565355, -0.02658003568649292, 0.06894417852163315, 0.037143684923648834, 0.02851661667227745, -0.04390963166952133, -0.0007356695714406669, -0.00754890963435173, -0.019364578649401665, 0.00751294381916523, -0.025050606578588486, 0.01269505824893713, 0.0036211921833455563, 0.00023563131981063634, -0.029682807624340057, -0.014868246391415596, -0.046021685004234314, -0.01077961828559637, 0.11439201980829239, -0.0012445508036762476, 0.00856364518404007, -0.11129529774188995, -0.04599171131849289, 0.04349993169307709, 0.022374963387846947, 0.01945040188729763, 0.026673564687371254, 0.06409235298633575, -0.05727655813097954, 0.034012407064437866, -0.004605877213180065, -0.03427199274301529, 0.007564322557300329, -0.11321330815553665, -0.06238400191068649, 0.044321827590465546, 0.01948373019695282, 0.11007314175367355, -0.043631382286548615, -0.0002929136680904776, -0.008099091239273548, 0.038739707320928574, -0.056517377495765686, 0.027041826397180557, 0.027310673147439957, 0.03521876037120819, 0.014913711696863174, -0.064333476126194, 0.024695996195077896, -0.08927539736032486, 0.061583712697029114, 0.005819625686854124, 0.008543276228010654, 0.0036332467570900917, 0.025299714878201485, 0.05394342541694641, 0.006222966127097607, 0.009558727033436298, -0.027196474373340607, 0.08865519613027573, -0.02206353284418583, -0.01601053588092327, -0.05064113438129425, -0.03145847097039223, 0.01814534142613411, 0.012700742110610008, 0.03795747458934784, 0.04725072532892227, 0.005903651472181082, 0.018137158825993538, -0.022142091765999794, 0.032351985573768616, 0.020807985216379166, -0.007666188757866621, 0.02449776418507099, -0.013566676527261734, 0.041519228368997574, 0.05975873023271561, 0.039344653487205505, 0.05830686539411545, -0.0019355518743395805, 0.003542819991707802, -0.011832937598228455, -0.04978213459253311, -0.001900428906083107, -0.024311048910021782, -0.0035972895566374063, -0.08720666170120239, 0.03106924332678318, -0.07547105103731155, -0.050580184906721115, -0.0106124896556139, 0.00907849334180355, -0.024813691154122353, -0.04129721224308014, 0.06663020700216293, 0.08412040024995804, -0.018459424376487732, -0.02314877323806286, 0.0024893207009881735, -0.038760703057050705, -0.007175251841545105, 0.004087348468601704, -0.02847854234278202, 0.011225223541259766, -0.03615456819534302, -0.029411138966679573, -0.0396980345249176, -0.009653117507696152, -0.021156804636120796, 0.030195163562893867, 0.060162246227264404, -0.03741297870874405, 0.03883982077240944, 0.011881950311362743, 0.003834935836493969, -0.012233692221343517, -0.0026105446740984917, 0.018003663048148155, 0.02314157597720623, 0.006233457941561937, 0.02236115001142025, -0.01157633401453495, 0.026933155953884125, 0.012114547193050385, -0.05162116140127182, -0.04943447560071945, 0.02966330014169216, 0.03241810202598572, -0.016489531844854355, -0.01589333266019821, -0.03764985501766205, 0.031145213171839714, -0.059268105775117874, 0.015952635556459427, 0.0027869383338838816, -0.0837147906422615, 0.0007874739239923656, -0.055138297379016876, 0.03294825926423073, -0.1084102988243103, 0.0004416510637383908 ]
62
62
A Reactive Tabu Search Algorithm for Stimuli Generation in Psycholinguistics
The generation of meaningless "words" matching certain statistical and/or linguistic criteria is frequently needed for experimental purposes in Psycholinguistics. Such stimuli receive the name of pseudowords or nonwords in the Cognitive Neuroscience literatue. The process for building nonwords sometimes has to be based on linguistic units such as syllables or morphemes, resulting in a numerical explosion of combinations when the size of the nonwords is increased. In this paper, a reactive tabu search scheme is proposed to generate nonwords of variables size. The approach builds pseudowords by using a modified Metaheuristic algorithm based on a local search procedure enhanced by a feedback-based scheme. Experimental results show that the new algorithm is a practical and effective tool for nonword generation.
[ 0.048199042677879333, -0.03980434313416481, -0.010705864056944847, -0.04775131866335869, 0.010103926993906498, -0.06170743331313133, 0.0024864247534424067, -0.012770306318998337, -0.01903470978140831, -0.0409511998295784, -0.03206982463598251, -0.010178552009165287, -0.015374064445495605, 0.061885613948106766, -0.005207911133766174, 0.02205582708120346, 0.008838578127324581, 0.04846731945872307, 0.04662827402353287, -0.048175591975450516, -0.01803072914481163, 0.01610538177192211, -0.056686967611312866, -0.017778810113668442, 0.01144555862993002, 0.03579239174723625, -0.047033995389938354, -0.013174518942832947, 0.026335829868912697, -0.03792206570506096, -0.04489760845899582, 0.05917076766490936, 0.07803550362586975, 0.063560850918293, 0.04723711684346199, -0.018067503347992897, -0.02834426611661911, 0.032060086727142334, -0.027972079813480377, -0.05771659314632416, 0.0381760410964489, -0.08504509925842285, 0.04871774837374687, 0.03796777129173279, 0.08062513172626495, 0.0467086061835289, 0.015399307943880558, 0.03346262872219086, 0.03661277890205383, 0.02956467494368553, -0.02775886468589306, 0.012843845412135124, 0.11023019254207611, -0.006781342905014753, -0.00032917517819441855, 0.04508711025118828, -0.02188793756067753, 0.03768642991781235, 0.043905939906835556, -0.04509029909968376, -0.04028196632862091, 0.10057259351015091, -0.0014601133298128843, -0.01106291450560093, -0.03508574143052101, -0.05590972676873207, -0.010873335413634777, -0.025634758174419403, -0.00202556443400681, 0.03066449798643589, 0.07355815172195435, -0.06579257547855377, 0.029992438852787018, -0.02179018408060074, -0.010424354113638401, 0.030838139355182648, -0.0289386548101902, -0.0010316928382962942, 0.060604460537433624, 0.11667759716510773, -0.06349789351224899, 0.02699112519621849, -0.03819730877876282, -0.08577419817447662, -0.01265688706189394, -0.02719867043197155, -0.033445801585912704, -0.03576933965086937, 0.005121959839016199, -0.02595401369035244, -0.030888423323631287, -0.0011682066833600402, 0.011615773662924767, -0.007861277088522911, 0.01740998588502407, 0.0504348948597908, -0.03130747005343437, 0.011322562582790852, 0.010820099152624607, -0.003362976713106036, 0.01812376268208027, -0.09851197898387909, -0.02916092984378338, -0.0007573543698526919, -0.10514313727617264, -0.005885319318622351, -0.07485157251358032, -0.02461627684533596, 0.017283935099840164, 0.02064494602382183, 0.03509998694062233, 0.04604748263955116, 0.01418683398514986, 0.012871824204921722, -0.04376925900578499, 0.056289274245500565, 0.049390360713005066, 0.05629633367061615, 0.06990063935518265, 0.0057465373538434505, 0.01972918212413788, 0.05197317153215408, 0.0036763963289558887, -0.0032789031974971294, -0.00536337960511446, -0.022938383743166924, 0.030644938349723816, -0.03749074414372444, 0.07940821349620819, 0.012627417221665382, -0.020192908123135567, -0.03167685866355896, -0.0912206843495369, -0.02055957354605198, 0.020534837618470192, 0.04763905704021454, 0.025835484266281128, -0.023014508187770844, 0.024479981511831284, 0.042787838727235794, 0.018571529537439346, -0.045575156807899475, 0.0011021677637472749, 0.0009363271528854966, -0.005315224174410105, 0.07223089784383774, -0.07015884667634964, -0.03204168379306793, 0.024476308375597, -0.020336277782917023, -0.07268515229225159, -0.02962465211749077, 0.05558714643120766, -0.010766672901809216, 0.0007426532101817429, -0.05144164338707924, -0.08420970290899277, -0.025623995810747147, -0.004491478204727173, 0.00004970555892214179, -0.03716069832444191, -0.011542370542883873, 0.026675891131162643, 0.02107686921954155, -0.023654211312532425, -0.008514216169714928, -0.1439964920282364, 0.013400512747466564, -0.04354112967848778, -0.07404128462076187, 0.05169408768415451, 0.02485949732363224, -0.037720467895269394, 0.0661345049738884, -0.010088917799293995, -0.03720995411276817, -0.05233133211731911, -0.04633455350995064, -0.007244522217661142, -0.029974782839417458, -0.04088347777724266, -0.10618417710065842, 0.030610457062721252, -0.014753589406609535, 0.013418181799352169, 0.08349817991256714, 0.010638350620865822, 0.05457337573170662, 0.09167134016752243, -0.028242938220500946, 0.08560779690742493, -0.00044949250877834857, -0.013403385877609253, -0.0034873036202043295, -0.06503359228372574, -0.03310113027691841, -0.02372964657843113, 0.01379669550806284, 0.02909829281270504, 0.03535314276814461, -0.0252627432346344, 0.025854552164673805, -0.03550490364432335, 0.01649991236627102, 0.004685870371758938, -0.05731940641999245, 0.003252193098887801, -0.043837156146764755, 0.00866671372205019, -0.036090027540922165, 0.02520117163658142, 0.05461746081709862, -0.005084157921373844, -0.053710661828517914, 0.02595795877277851, 0.008921214379370213, 0.00830460898578167, 0.03460879623889923, 0.0754743441939354, 0.05990639328956604, -0.07115698605775833, 0.013495814986526966, 0.019605237990617752, 0.05889543890953064, 0.03389490395784378, -0.04118919372558594, 0.036645419895648956, -0.01747906394302845, 0.006503210868686438, 0.024094656109809875, -0.025050681084394455, -0.03672272711992264, -0.02392582781612873, -0.08612294495105743, -0.017123214900493622, 0.004725317470729351, 0.0018526631174609065, -0.05070618540048599, 0.001260471879504621, -0.044259119778871536, -0.012706650421023369, 0.03615013137459755, -0.010413860902190208, 0.01732165552675724, 0.03472159802913666, -0.0516681969165802, 0.034580525010824203, -0.05534929409623146, -0.051019929349422455, 0.017066070809960365, 0.0455043688416481, -0.07835206389427185, -0.06176260858774185, 0.013011532835662365, 0.06345661729574203, 0.06542026251554489, 0.001921502873301506, 0.014567106030881405, -0.05447157099843025, 0.022652218118309975, -0.0235500056296587, 0.03811309114098549, -0.06112823262810707, -0.006136733572930098, 0.08057190477848053, -0.06281504780054092, -0.06823544949293137, -0.02773388661444187, 0.04736557975411415, -0.00779732596129179, 0.1043337807059288, 0.023895442485809326, -0.03308262676000595, 0.04144299030303955, -0.04592916741967201, -0.01620025560259819, 0.07961910218000412, 0.06639409810304642, 0.016869567334651947, -0.052505552768707275, -0.09646108001470566, 0.03043953701853752, -0.009541369043290615, 0.03805791959166527, 0.0394708514213562, 0.049613047391176224, 0.02934931591153145, -0.05647086724638939, -0.012395348399877548, -0.04155832529067993, -0.04626072570681572, -0.004336009733378887, -0.0473022498190403, -0.0008346475660800934, 0.08654352277517319, -0.06514222174882889, 0.011682482436299324, -0.06550642848014832, -0.020442092791199684, 0.03809106722474098, 0.009229808114469051, -0.04039549455046654, 0.03422565385699272, 0.004368896596133709, 0.01858222857117653, 0.07107138633728027, 0.020532025024294853, 0.045353345572948456, 0.01680557057261467, 0.04727545753121376, 0.05397353321313858, -0.008512183092534542, -0.030840685591101646, -0.017163945361971855, -0.013252687640488148, 0.001877118949778378, 0.0064324080012738705, -0.04839569702744484, -0.018326416611671448, -0.0334005206823349, -0.017498396337032318, 0.023222098127007484, 0.03283659368753433, 0.0008324963855557144, -0.04929919168353081, -0.041771095246076584, -0.04897615313529968, -0.008163731545209885, -0.1257772445678711, -0.005993968341499567, -0.014627876691520214, 0.02088501863181591, -0.04950134456157684, 0.08448775857686996, -0.001338269212283194, 0.004160641226917505, -0.008961733430624008, 0.05666995793581009, -0.03255322203040123, 0.034545689821243286, -0.0180391613394022, -0.03900806978344917, -0.01738797128200531, 0.0636497288942337, -0.001438512117601931, 0.04053451120853424, 0.08752714842557907, 0.01646229438483715, 0.012214233167469501, 0.021254753693938255, -0.0364837646484375, -0.05503141134977341, 0.0017744279466569424, 0.05392541363835335, -0.06544222682714462, 0.08651427179574966, 0.054450925439596176, -0.016992608085274696, 0.05310358479619026, 0.020275205373764038, 0.04948177933692932, 0.0010603012051433325, 0.017885662615299225, -0.03162393346428871, 0.017687566578388214, 0.04607372358441353, -0.010416963137686253, -0.059043824672698975, -0.051288120448589325, 0.02167842723429203, -0.031241467222571373, 0.013111160136759281, 0.07851343601942062, -0.002155159367248416, -0.045538030564785004, -0.04971328005194664, 0.11664044111967087, -0.10807672142982483, -0.025619082152843475, 0.07429155707359314, 0.00931540597230196, -0.025887208059430122, -0.002362255472689867, -0.02783881686627865, -0.039477407932281494, 0.03478043153882027, -0.054127614945173264, -0.0015430399216711521, 0.011707574129104614, 0.0020398441702127457, 0.01613331399857998, -0.06336198002099991, 0.014163890853524208, 0.028958691284060478, 0.015888536348938942, -0.03611708804965019, -0.07063541561365128, -0.07314503192901611, 0.028952963650226593, -0.07712671905755997, -0.0718872994184494, -0.055298592895269394, -0.03858807310461998, 0.02225980907678604, -0.02580632083117962, 0.02110566943883896, 0.05933724716305733, 0.08081559091806412, -0.04458341374993324, 0.020639091730117798, 0.022679951041936874, 0.07379641383886337, -0.022367361932992935, 0.022781705483794212, -0.05039316788315773, 0.03420846164226532, 0.0056035080924630165, -0.06686628609895706, 0.01323849055916071, -0.07879359275102615, -0.06447072327136993, 0.003760162740945816, -0.05255979672074318, 0.08201295882463455, -0.030431194230914116, -0.057872042059898376, 0.06851083785295486, -0.0023481843527406454, 0.0023582761641591787, -0.033604156225919724, -0.06348317116498947, -0.04314069449901581, -0.01031967531889677, 0.02430165745317936, -0.007258906029164791, -0.010023318231105804, -0.03446982055902481, 0.04914466664195061, -0.017449650913476944, 0.011290723457932472, -0.0355873629450798, -0.0007480157073587179, 0.04929318651556969, 0.0428939051926136, -0.017994796857237816, -0.08178428560495377, -0.004528227727860212, -0.10432565957307816, 0.022465748712420464, -0.029805904254317284, -0.02027861587703228, -0.0005465500289574265, 0.04152515158057213, -0.07011591643095016, -0.019575979560613632, -0.012050150893628597, 0.013526435010135174, 0.07625802606344223, 0.0394882932305336, 0.02027946338057518, -0.05815554037690163, 0.07979504019021988, 0.03634661063551903, 0.055844470858573914, -0.06800471991300583, -0.029538586735725403, 0.07207779586315155, 0.034197285771369934, -0.018872888758778572, 0.010705901309847832, 0.05424172058701515, 0.06088149547576904, 0.07518242299556732, -0.03972523659467697, -0.036454033106565475, 0.04324446618556976, 0.08029872179031372, 0.005956097040325403, 0.027228664606809616, -0.057908739894628525, 0.00723289605230093, 0.010513431392610073, -0.05965367704629898, 0.016630282625555992, 0.06589575856924057, 0.056814562529325485, -0.03246922418475151, 0.07716845721006393, 0.03498212620615959, -0.022883661091327667, 0.009156336076557636, -0.023401785641908646, 0.034140508621931076, 0.013079210184514523, 0.04311675950884819, 0.00934172049164772, 0.037350647151470184, 0.027437644079327583, 0.0451522059738636, 0.022413145750761032, 0.09474847465753555, -0.033188290894031525, -0.0739932507276535, 0.08031676709651947, 0.008723260834813118, 0.017986681312322617, 0.01625399850308895, 0.010864874348044395, -0.001530430861748755, 0.057499129325151443, -0.0427188016474247, 0.022803816944360733 ]
63
63
Equations of States in Singular Statistical Estimation
Learning machines which have hierarchical structures or hidden variables are singular statistical models because they are nonidentifiable and their Fisher information matrices are singular. In singular statistical models, neither the Bayes a posteriori distribution converges to the normal distribution nor the maximum likelihood estimator satisfies asymptotic normality. This is the main reason why it has been difficult to predict their generalization performances from trained states. In this paper, we study four errors, (1) Bayes generalization error, (2) Bayes training error, (3) Gibbs generalization error, and (4) Gibbs training error, and prove that there are mathematical relations among these errors. The formulas proved in this paper are equations of states in statistical estimation because they hold for any true distribution, any parametric model, and any a priori distribution. Also we show that Bayes and Gibbs generalization errors are estimated by Bayes and Gibbs training errors, and propose widely applicable information criteria which can be applied to both regular and singular statistical models.
[ 0.014532585628330708, -0.0650821402668953, 0.0006925607449375093, -0.057431526482105255, 0.03523225709795952, -0.053369712084531784, 0.024487419053912163, 0.05262705311179161, 0.025627970695495605, 0.01820511370897293, -0.014791581779718399, -0.03159787133336067, -0.011139465495944023, -0.013535908423364162, -0.0075953989289700985, -0.017538249492645264, 0.03148831054568291, 0.04873254522681236, 0.04127458855509758, -0.024568399414420128, 0.06245669350028038, 0.08334729075431824, 0.0605444610118866, -0.06893322616815567, 0.030755026265978813, 0.06596992909908295, -0.030375542119145393, 0.04530055820941925, 0.004235114436596632, 0.029267841950058937, -0.0761742889881134, 0.05384855717420578, -0.01889200322329998, -0.06542432308197021, 0.051179952919483185, -0.029724298045039177, -0.017405472695827484, 0.022222131490707397, -0.058848943561315536, 0.04707292467355728, -0.020560750737786293, -0.0039002355188131332, 0.027179403230547905, 0.029476957395672798, 0.0708615630865097, 0.0008045100257731974, 0.10025111585855484, 0.0074926503002643585, 0.04253612831234932, 0.052253227680921555, -0.05134234204888344, 0.007589869201183319, -0.06890835613012314, -0.05486512929201126, -0.024416528642177582, 0.04181189090013504, 0.00298125809058547, 0.03334156796336174, -0.015174475498497486, -0.046214982867240906, 0.00198459648527205, 0.06344383955001831, -0.009790843352675438, -0.0021656020544469357, -0.02150113321840763, 0.006453807465732098, -0.14080262184143066, -0.03387882187962532, 0.002652061404660344, -0.002597747603431344, 0.06849411129951477, -0.07070649415254593, 0.08888411521911621, 0.07176511734724045, 0.02869935892522335, -0.04591640457510948, -0.020702827721834183, -0.050981853157281876, -0.03683827072381973, 0.06239735335111618, -0.05667741596698761, 0.013631355948746204, 0.008909348398447037, 0.046589482575654984, -0.05422353371977806, 0.028322404250502586, 0.0012885156320407987, -0.052462782710790634, 0.027902105823159218, 0.012727850116789341, 0.03200381621718407, 0.024229394271969795, -0.037514686584472656, -0.011560333892703056, 0.0107783954590559, 0.05252830684185028, -0.04472332447767258, 0.004784099292010069, -0.014973199926316738, -0.037801243364810944, -0.029698602855205536, -0.03690255805850029, -0.0026640144642442465, 0.0764012560248375, -0.011676397174596786, 0.02169245481491089, -0.0194989163428545, 0.09311621636152267, 0.026954518631100655, 0.0026530276518315077, 0.04342303052544594, -0.038854628801345825, 0.05496412515640259, 0.005265616811811924, -0.01854105293750763, 0.10889723151922226, -0.030155716463923454, 0.06418441236019135, 0.01662137173116207, 0.04939047992229462, 0.061886265873909, -0.008638586848974228, -0.07412461936473846, 0.06951820105314255, 0.056711725890636444, -0.05743388086557388, -0.0017415678594261408, -0.06366265565156937, 0.10882936418056488, -0.024617305025458336, 0.014527445659041405, 0.006449894513934851, 0.02715587243437767, -0.058744583278894424, -0.04651970416307449, 0.08048802614212036, -0.013491112738847733, -0.0435679629445076, -0.022288108244538307, 0.03654428943991661, -0.013696170412003994, 0.013961618766188622, 0.041351500898599625, 0.05213211476802826, -0.06501491367816925, 0.11838982999324799, 0.03291923925280571, -0.007980366237461567, -0.017144566401839256, 0.09258877485990524, 0.05901593342423439, -0.009073941968381405, 0.0499417744576931, 0.08025145530700684, 0.08950161188840866, 0.022824570536613464, -0.024538962170481682, 0.032323725521564484, 0.0063851079903542995, -0.0032445306424051523, 0.00867677852511406, -0.037229012697935104, -0.017454035580158234, 0.031521186232566833, -0.007226645480841398, -0.059996746480464935, -0.016920071095228195, 0.005340345669537783, 0.026569640263915062, -0.022390080615878105, -0.05927934870123863, -0.029668783769011497, 0.0006812755018472672, 0.007227552123367786, -0.0777064636349678, -0.029742054641246796, 0.018933502957224846, -0.0029133299831300974, -0.0047140480019152164, 0.07521463185548782, 0.014418788254261017, -0.06084533780813217, 0.026088884100317955, -0.023547396063804626, 0.09204964339733124, 0.04656727612018585, 0.01637106202542782, 0.0431118868291378, 0.05911077558994293, -0.030080432072281837, 0.04356415942311287, -0.026651615276932716, -0.009806256741285324, -0.02954993210732937, -0.061578065156936646, 0.036871735006570816, -0.05737384408712387, 0.000986637780442834, 0.07304337620735168, 0.05577061325311661, 0.019117070361971855, 0.021981580182909966, -0.013108210638165474, -0.02598208747804165, -0.00849930103868246, 0.01804693415760994, 0.08016198873519897, -0.029476702213287354, -0.014934414066374302, 0.0818355455994606, 0.03653509542346001, 0.032313887029886246, -0.04657123610377312, 0.01026997622102499, -0.003046733560040593, -0.10668685287237167, -0.0006380814011208713, -0.04614115506410599, 0.08956141769886017, 0.001545447506941855, -0.03332559019327164, 0.05131062865257263, -0.011700408533215523, -0.024434523656964302, -0.05380045995116234, -0.010185230523347855, 0.012182902544736862, -0.005495806690305471, -0.030139366164803505, 0.08881355077028275, -0.036550331860780716, -0.05442110076546669, -0.05622876435518265, -0.012369672767817974, 0.06811466813087463, 0.046371940523386, -0.0670081079006195, -0.0014659902080893517, 0.01100002508610487, 0.06665527820587158, -0.0368838831782341, 0.03790491446852684, -0.004875543527305126, 0.028887348249554634, 0.008161991834640503, -0.04355403035879135, 0.0179357398301363, -0.014919238165020943, 0.02282872051000595, -0.03225088119506836, 0.00036658323369920254, -0.007260542828589678, -0.02235335297882557, -0.04116300120949745, 0.01109590008854866, 0.024813169613480568, -0.06349889934062958, 0.041312240064144135, -0.026755962520837784, 0.10745269060134888, 0.019247472286224365, 0.03298329561948776, -0.03270312398672104, -0.007757646031677723, 0.11004146188497543, -0.018945880234241486, 0.0212725680321455, 0.026658866554498672, -0.01801149919629097, 0.002782967174425721, -0.06843309849500656, -0.03805255889892578, 0.020641611889004707, 0.07640937715768814, -0.04164768382906914, -0.0009549157693982124, 0.029944593086838722, 0.04609019309282303, 0.026778122410178185, -0.025423863902688026, -0.046224333345890045, 0.06824313849210739, -0.051897961646318436, -0.04948939383029938, 0.01717519387602806, 0.02039491944015026, 0.028410254046320915, 0.019358128309249878, -0.03595553711056709, -0.05126473680138588, -0.0058325896970927715, 0.01064238604158163, -0.04611029848456383, -0.01379930879920721, 0.0314064547419548, -0.000768277735915035, 0.021120110526680946, 0.04632565751671791, 0.0383620411157608, -0.028200356289744377, -0.0021382072009146214, -0.017155075445771217, 0.01983468234539032, -0.010439334437251091, 0.0481451041996479, 0.024494491517543793, -0.05975954979658127, 0.03410641476511955, -0.0524434894323349, -0.02132224477827549, 0.09044553339481354, -0.05250896140933037, -0.020322483032941818, 0.016258493065834045, 0.03912122920155525, -0.041802480816841125, -0.031210225075483322, -0.06369049102067947, -0.012566041201353073, -0.07811358571052551, -0.011246534995734692, 0.01713339053094387, -0.01727375015616417, -0.023777099326252937, -0.05708260461688042, 0.012304142117500305, 0.0311778262257576, -0.016782572492957115, -0.03724801912903786, 0.05546481907367706, -0.05104045942425728, -0.07917613536119461, -0.02455436810851097, 0.11382335424423218, -0.043023400008678436, 0.020765213295817375, -0.027588823810219765, 0.048129476606845856, 0.00887268502265215, 0.002475741319358349, 0.004659534431993961, -0.0443357490003109, 0.006894116755574942, -0.03872489929199219, -0.01921561174094677, 0.04317864775657654, 0.09091703593730927, -0.04009008780121803, -0.07936521619558334, 0.054113149642944336, 0.020636623725295067, -0.00940567534416914, -0.004163944628089666, 0.09333979338407516, -0.028832625597715378, -0.004631980787962675, -0.0024594541173428297, 0.0215164702385664, 0.005163601599633694, 0.026257846504449844, -0.0027765824925154448, 0.0672542080283165, -0.01813218742609024, -0.07896853983402252, 0.022572387009859085, 0.053828414529561996, -0.039337046444416046, 0.006507754325866699, -0.03207916021347046, -0.0017989688785746694, -0.006392162758857012, -0.040884774178266525, 0.05752820521593094, 0.05719488114118576, 0.06133989989757538, -0.0046496400609612465, -0.013372264802455902, 0.0007624884601682425, -0.006332117132842541, 0.04727543145418167, -0.10128769278526306, -0.03199812397360802, -0.10794088244438171, 0.02228914573788643, -0.0149454390630126, -0.06524918228387833, 0.01345808431506157, 0.006559750065207481, 0.030826866626739502, 0.005925881676375866, 0.01576995849609375, -0.024865873157978058, -0.0027487888000905514, 0.025868143886327744, -0.022114627063274384, 0.07032531499862671, 0.011393489316105843, 0.02095421589910984, -0.05268077924847603, 0.047312747687101364, -0.016291700303554535, -0.0016876633744686842, 0.031792689114809036, -0.03258981555700302, -0.007377667352557182, -0.028259489685297012, 0.01360549870878458, 0.05785428732633591, -0.008318759500980377, 0.03964577242732048, 0.038756441324949265, 0.06047477200627327, -0.030877629294991493, -0.029060250148177147, 0.008971399627625942, 0.011563313193619251, 0.043133076280355453, -0.027960365638136864, -0.044157832860946655, -0.023188961669802666, 0.022372927516698837, 0.035804279148578644, -0.0016355677507817745, -0.019688665866851807, 0.015291424468159676, -0.008855558931827545, -0.022767147049307823, 0.07941494882106781, 0.04613042622804642, 0.07293499261140823, -0.07969465851783752, -0.07702077180147171, -0.13098880648612976, -0.02831968665122986, 0.034485794603824615, -0.022402340546250343, -0.013601739890873432, -0.07413342595100403, 0.008201354183256626, -0.0018804515711963177, -0.02980596385896206, -0.012287359684705734, 0.06143708527088165, 0.04211849719285965, -0.02806130424141884, 0.09269320219755173, 0.05590426176786423, 0.0028640986420214176, 0.10124148428440094, 0.05250073969364166, 0.01443074643611908, 0.02441352605819702, -0.005130480509251356, -0.02040545456111431, 0.042088259011507034, 0.018969979137182236, -0.03690074011683464, -0.006936443969607353, -0.005184384528547525, 0.0001853456487879157, 0.014957920648157597, -0.0368393249809742, -0.0027275297325104475, 0.015526392497122288, -0.11856988072395325, -0.05628494545817375, 0.06929107755422592, 0.023187097162008286, 0.03965241461992264, -0.003294436726719141, -0.015729710459709167, -0.0712796226143837, 0.0041654822416603565, -0.029736198484897614, -0.017224090173840523, 0.043150972574949265, 0.010624611750245094, -0.07056757062673569, 0.008793708868324757, -0.08000732213258743, -0.026871198788285255, -0.025965584442019463, -0.04739612340927124, 0.03494057431817055, -0.005400505848228931, 0.08810819685459137, 0.01103605329990387, 0.015574295073747635, 0.04761521890759468, -0.016845636069774628, 0.088863305747509, 0.0022350677754729986, -0.025038225576281548, -0.04053938388824463, -0.0014694473939016461, 0.024607645347714424, -0.016785552725195885, -0.012183758430182934, 0.02516358532011509, -0.009769147261977196, 0.0008635579724796116, 0.02708500437438488, 0.05014504864811897, 0.09810598194599152, 0.10056754946708679, 0.05276753753423691, -0.007466195151209831, -0.03612929582595825, 0.03507474064826965, 0.08781623095273972, -0.022366251796483994, -0.03436527028679848 ]
64
64
A Universal Kernel for Learning Regular Languages
We give a universal kernel that renders all the regular languages linearly separable. We are not able to compute this kernel efficiently and conjecture that it is intractable, but we do have an efficient $\eps$-approximation.
[ -0.039788782596588135, -0.0662393644452095, 0.08915626257658005, -0.049278415739536285, 0.001065408461727202, -0.040966302156448364, 0.019407417625188828, -0.009164695627987385, 0.01893549971282482, 0.030835416167974472, 0.016434133052825928, 0.036654941737651825, -0.08107465505599976, 0.11076106876134872, -0.009882882237434387, 0.03317808359861374, 0.01380362082272768, 0.034684889018535614, -0.008710001595318317, -0.01812240667641163, -0.028435230255126953, 0.0006178235053084791, -0.00883652362972498, -0.059176452457904816, 0.05017456039786339, 0.053388964384794235, -0.05849146842956543, 0.06605719774961472, 0.0111146355047822, 0.02572234533727169, -0.09125711768865585, 0.0023653339594602585, 0.041080743074417114, 0.009941632859408855, 0.0022731402423232794, 0.049415312707424164, 0.06822729855775833, 0.08705763518810272, -0.08109159767627716, 0.05572287365794182, -0.028053123503923416, -0.0405631847679615, 0.024958400055766106, 0.03744788467884064, 0.009305802173912525, 0.008996264077723026, -0.029251225292682648, -0.043020255863666534, -0.036326438188552856, 0.0479842945933342, -0.053052764385938644, 0.004268030170351267, -0.036670323461294174, -0.0033650039695203304, -0.05232824757695198, 0.008792825974524021, -0.05368876829743385, -0.022413797676563263, 0.016944605857133865, 0.012182977050542831, 0.057966671884059906, 0.04904486984014511, -0.018942974507808685, -0.031207943335175514, -0.023512614890933037, -0.0815955325961113, -0.07261478155851364, -0.03913438692688942, 0.022888464853167534, 0.037835367023944855, -0.0013202449772506952, -0.06918510794639587, 0.023318074643611908, 0.009517444297671318, 0.06618930399417877, -0.005841338541358709, 0.027146829292178154, -0.024332154542207718, -0.013283831998705864, 0.07389631122350693, -0.05496947094798088, 0.021695611998438835, -0.09892185032367706, -0.017735138535499573, 0.0022122336085885763, 0.005437782499939203, 0.029257552698254585, -0.006064209621399641, 0.02032024785876274, -0.0736936628818512, -0.03528831899166107, -0.006493056658655405, -0.05064762383699417, 0.03833363577723503, -0.07910144329071045, -0.00636568246409297, 0.02088446542620659, -0.047823961824178696, -0.07672525197267532, -0.010492710396647453, 0.05256520211696625, 0.018495144322514534, 0.055211979895830154, 0.02966199442744255, -0.030852938070893288, 0.08984708786010742, 0.00467129098251462, -0.06465412676334381, 0.0346195325255394, 0.011726444587111473, -0.0014707898953929543, 0.011937357485294342, 0.0005289670662023127, -0.044163744896650314, -0.030749617144465446, 0.09880392998456955, 0.053977448493242264, 0.06796253472566605, 0.07630336284637451, 0.04100468382239342, -0.05787127837538719, 0.025732774287462234, -0.027219902724027634, 0.01796610839664936, 0.020196279510855675, -0.043117910623550415, -0.06878185272216797, -0.026343505829572678, 0.08203911781311035, -0.014743940904736519, -0.03461028262972832, -0.01772908866405487, 0.06252435594797134, 0.03066966123878956, -0.07235780358314514, 0.09061523526906967, 0.01653202809393406, -0.00638125604018569, -0.03953097015619278, 0.05218084901571274, 0.021968960762023926, 0.048865560442209244, 0.021392088383436203, -0.023397129029035568, 0.06681700050830841, 0.05962810665369034, -0.012997586280107498, -0.05618453398346901, 0.04514380916953087, -0.014197008684277534, -0.02607054077088833, 0.03497562184929848, 0.03087448887526989, 0.06354488432407379, 0.03340557590126991, -0.11481533199548721, -0.0329931378364563, 0.016865136101841927, 0.021534515544772148, 0.02699512057006359, -0.013888862915337086, -0.034943532198667526, -0.024780523031949997, 0.08509333431720734, 0.010806280188262463, -0.012209002859890461, 0.0429954007267952, -0.006409867201000452, 0.00531331030651927, -0.05800338089466095, -0.0037642319221049547, -0.04299004748463631, -0.056259073317050934, 0.054905783385038376, 0.027966979891061783, 0.05853568762540817, 0.04089343920350075, 0.03410329297184944, -0.06689903885126114, -0.09813422709703445, 0.12416626513004303, -0.12395406514406204, 0.0020886133424937725, 0.05277255177497864, 0.030624017119407654, -0.005105978809297085, -0.010921696200966835, 0.030427008867263794, -0.00306735560297966, 0.028303910046815872, 0.09039273858070374, 0.034814488142728806, 0.0005198198487050831, 0.007104136515408754, -0.05872035399079323, -0.02589115872979164, -0.015719441697001457, -0.015495614148676395, -0.001338826259598136, 0.02238835208117962, 0.09127713739871979, -0.014464343897998333, -0.022180184721946716, -0.1624969094991684, -0.08003464341163635, 0.03273380175232887, 0.016313988715410233, -0.008243244141340256, -0.037626467645168304, 0.012997516430914402, -0.010415256023406982, 0.012990285642445087, -0.00206900667399168, -0.006383481435477734, -0.061564523726701736, -0.024184461683034897, 0.06256826221942902, 0.006860650144517422, 0.01726957969367504, 0.036805763840675354, 0.0201388169080019, 0.07732931524515152, 0.003290052991360426, 0.017910486087203026, -0.026520663872361183, -0.004711061250418425, 0.013544282875955105, -0.020896168425679207, -0.048908039927482605, -0.011838315054774284, -0.0686725527048111, -0.033778075128793716, -0.05229265242815018, -0.0702628567814827, -0.024062996730208397, 0.06489107757806778, -0.04062843322753906, -0.02616436779499054, 0.030562901869416237, -0.03273859992623329, -0.004107282031327486, 0.05015954002737999, 0.056852035224437714, 0.03822885453701019, -0.024874525144696236, -0.023557113483548164, -0.043088916689157486, -0.00992202665656805, -0.04282241687178612, 0.02893911674618721, 0.007339731324464083, -0.03473474085330963, 0.012258923612535, -0.04443935304880142, 0.025262298062443733, 0.012648627161979675, -0.03856189548969269, -0.029309559613466263, -0.020956775173544884, 0.0789918601512909, 0.020589599385857582, 0.0075055817142128944, -0.013071111403405666, 0.0026535959914326668, 0.04248756915330887, -0.010844103060662746, -0.021616104990243912, -0.012294868938624859, 0.029594799503684044, 0.05106506869196892, 0.0338367223739624, -0.09626366943120956, -0.09718913584947586, 0.041205476969480515, 0.011342477984726429, -0.009405058808624744, -0.0043361675925552845, 0.00552251935005188, -0.0361802913248539, 0.0019210688769817352, -0.0165504552423954, 0.019176170229911804, -0.05480482801795006, -0.08422549813985825, -0.03653258830308914, -0.015565559267997742, 0.008700702339410782, -0.013062664307653904, 0.046268071979284286, 0.10314246267080307, -0.03299063444137573, 0.01891203410923481, -0.039277371019124985, -0.03784520551562309, 0.021190250292420387, -0.03416482359170914, -0.02963029220700264, -0.05744270980358124, 0.05244533345103264, 0.03681306168437004, 0.04887133091688156, -0.027461791411042213, -0.005326798651367426, -0.04318465664982796, 0.05645236000418663, -0.027381207793951035, -0.016530048102140427, 0.01841595396399498, 0.04849893972277641, -0.01924305595457554, 0.002676008502021432, -0.010138674639165401, 0.04639815911650658, -0.015761105343699455, 0.0365985706448555, -0.11889132857322693, -0.009339801035821438, 0.003440580563619733, -0.04315813258290291, 0.060322828590869904, 0.055938687175512314, 0.016452349722385406, -0.008470982313156128, -0.05154286324977875, -0.10729187726974487, -0.043380722403526306, 0.002281344495713711, 0.06019211560487747, -0.09858478605747223, -0.017688553780317307, 0.018248947337269783, 0.016964631155133247, 0.007900715805590153, 0.020315172150731087, 0.10518963634967804, -0.005194417666643858, -0.07287953794002533, -0.009646009653806686, -0.05014340952038765, -0.0188437607139349, -0.011074379086494446, -0.03640981763601303, 0.019442321732640266, -0.06926243007183075, 0.0394180603325367, 0.06067962944507599, 0.044939395040273666, -0.05007527396082878, -0.06833061575889587, 0.08345276117324829, -0.04416012763977051, -0.02495851367712021, -0.0011834143660962582, -0.015145855024456978, -0.050155092030763626, 0.04016144946217537, 0.02528800629079342, -0.032501161098480225, -0.019020358100533485, 0.06487870216369629, -0.003914272878319025, 0.02402656339108944, -0.002951105125248432, 0.04065315052866936, 0.01460080873221159, 0.08361226320266724, -0.061945606023073196, -0.09079079329967499, -0.02496338076889515, 0.05292445048689842, -0.04920282959938049, 0.009781510569155216, 0.09472960233688354, -0.017848815768957138, -0.035199254751205444, -0.039945077151060104, 0.0608481802046299, -0.024705572053790092, -0.042468417435884476, -0.003809564048424363, -0.047505803406238556, -0.01638038270175457, -0.04184965416789055, 0.04788488894701004, -0.0011494152713567019, -0.04481237009167671, 0.06843136250972748, 0.0011830145958811045, 0.04631549119949341, 0.008702648803591728, -0.06283862143754959, -0.05835603177547455, 0.03501862287521362, 0.037048276513814926, 0.07012122869491577, -0.03060138411819935, 0.01755400002002716, 0.01118159107863903, -0.04012279212474823, -0.025304554030299187, -0.008256002329289913, 0.0041413502767682076, -0.00911717303097248, 0.0580512173473835, -0.057707469910383224, -0.0779319778084755, 0.006623421795666218, -0.049400437623262405, -0.008064940571784973, 0.06925269961357117, 0.05426473543047905, 0.030942069366574287, -0.042587969452142715, 0.006131999660283327, 0.0058332388289272785, 0.05554557591676712, -0.03175047039985657, -0.015252857469022274, 0.00680899154394865, -0.10941272228956223, 0.014832841232419014, 0.03677044436335564, 0.06993712484836578, -0.021182600408792496, -0.0617627277970314, -0.027056200429797173, 0.03799107298254967, 0.005815926473587751, 0.01755005493760109, -0.022109821438789368, -0.018299980089068413, -0.02557404339313507, -0.05419743433594704, -0.01954563893377781, 0.0815449208021164, -0.021306516602635384, -0.06274998933076859, 0.005278059747070074, 0.013970070518553257, 0.014881580136716366, -0.0027758257929235697, 0.044011618942022324, 0.01154459547251463, 0.0019257100066170096, 0.0755588561296463, 0.09233228862285614, 0.07455599308013916, -0.037866026163101196, 0.05770580470561981, 0.05164799094200134, 0.05683434009552002, 0.010525031015276909, -0.04173170030117035, -0.04226285591721535, -0.03432946279644966, -0.032942745834589005, 0.019487913697957993, 0.013198313303291798, 0.026612648740410805, -0.04209446161985397, -0.026287050917744637, -0.018148411065340042, 0.02164454385638237, 0.05648893117904663, -0.10179640352725983, -0.020644942298531532, -0.0014803847298026085, -0.014581775292754173, 0.01845628023147583, -0.038885753601789474, -0.04495524987578392, 0.04525067284703255, 0.03871826082468033, 0.013748276978731155, -0.011824862100183964, -0.0357581190764904, 0.0519733801484108, 0.03185024484992027, 0.020038314163684845, 0.01354831550270319, 0.03543061017990112, -0.009813372045755386, -0.037007395178079605, -0.015364241786301136, -0.025224804878234863, -0.00977553054690361, 0.06475424766540527, -0.059422824531793594, 0.017677897587418556, -0.017814883962273598, 0.014189221896231174, 0.061515580862760544, -0.00024390334147028625, -0.019472496584057808, -0.006142915692180395, -0.008253151550889015, 0.04191657155752182, -0.008304985240101814, -0.06300583481788635, -0.035778697580099106, -0.014062403701245785, -0.0361236110329628, -0.035282548516988754, 0.025443192571401596, 0.041624732315540314, 0.040396593511104584, -0.006781457923352718, -0.0008745199884288013, -0.04498592019081116, -0.03632407635450363, 0.013673326000571251, -0.030552852898836136 ]
65
65
Automatic Pattern Classification by Unsupervised Learning Using Dimensionality Reduction of Data with Mirroring Neural Networks
This paper proposes an unsupervised learning technique by using Multi-layer Mirroring Neural Network and Forgy's clustering algorithm. Multi-layer Mirroring Neural Network is a neural network that can be trained with generalized data inputs (different categories of image patterns) to perform non-linear dimensionality reduction and the resultant low-dimensional code is used for unsupervised pattern classification using Forgy's algorithm. By adapting the non-linear activation function (modified sigmoidal function) and initializing the weights and bias terms to small random values, mirroring of the input pattern is initiated. In training, the weights and bias terms are changed in such a way that the input presented is reproduced at the output by back propagating the error. The mirroring neural network is capable of reducing the input vector to a great degree (approximately 1/30th the original size) and also able to reconstruct the input pattern at the output layer from this reduced code units. The feature set (output of central hidden layer) extracted from this network is fed to Forgy's algorithm, which classify input data patterns into distinguishable classes. In the implementation of Forgy's algorithm, initial seed points are selected in such a way that they are distant enough to be perfectly grouped into different categories. Thus a new method of unsupervised learning is formulated and demonstrated in this paper. This method gave impressive results when applied to classification of different image patterns.
[ -0.048097945749759674, -0.0453726090490818, 0.04324106127023697, -0.005041399039328098, 0.005353482440114021, -0.07974746078252792, 0.013417322188615799, -0.007810679264366627, -0.049133602529764175, 0.024694141000509262, -0.01011408120393753, -0.006178973242640495, -0.034590911120176315, 0.006354370154440403, 0.049486130475997925, 0.050344571471214294, 0.01822749525308609, -0.04892381653189659, -0.03215324878692627, -0.03989802673459053, -0.03286651149392128, -0.0488816574215889, -0.019731370732188225, -0.04495234787464142, 0.0636226236820221, -0.0063650463707745075, 0.00217218860052526, -0.020662005990743637, -0.08389569073915482, -0.004332682583481073, 0.03140970319509506, -0.08322101831436157, -0.020219383761286736, 0.046706680208444595, 0.05941898748278618, 0.035551927983760834, -0.030132148414850235, -0.027457818388938904, -0.014309156686067581, -0.019007880240678787, -0.011732750572264194, 0.02401629649102688, -0.0006722670514136553, -0.03575170412659645, 0.02050825208425522, 0.09667552262544632, -0.036288581788539886, -0.055445294827222824, 0.00751342112198472, 0.09445007890462875, -0.11019807308912277, 0.06818521022796631, -0.019518019631505013, 0.005789389833807945, 0.04180122911930084, 0.024330351501703262, -0.049633122980594635, -0.03542168065905571, -0.003869899781420827, -0.004400278441607952, 0.022895220667123795, 0.08866741508245468, 0.008753178641200066, 0.012085060589015484, -0.033338166773319244, -0.034650348126888275, 0.00820884108543396, 0.0019000089960172772, -0.008143201470375061, -0.05213627964258194, 0.008832580409944057, -0.06622511148452759, 0.0490204319357872, 0.05140117183327675, -0.006498347967863083, 0.019370274618268013, 0.009450046345591545, 0.02105942741036415, 0.035022806376218796, 0.057798054069280624, -0.027563566341996193, -0.00489992368966341, 0.04498065635561943, -0.04037456959486008, 0.012774533592164516, 0.0017048794543370605, 0.0038429207634180784, -0.023533405736088753, -0.01804344914853573, 0.03992418199777603, -0.0646185502409935, -0.046083610504865646, -0.013878620229661465, 0.030900130048394203, -0.003375010332092643, 0.004389867652207613, -0.0029567324090749025, -0.047194354236125946, -0.03581637889146805, 0.036502741277217865, -0.008288504555821419, -0.040127888321876526, 0.002684693317860365, 0.09618860483169556, -0.023702407255768776, -0.01832101121544838, -0.024475712329149246, 0.0130442650988698, 0.07176099717617035, -0.04408661648631096, 0.03503546118736267, -0.019204914569854736, -0.007869965396821499, -0.007709572557359934, -0.05193423852324486, -0.01889202557504177, -0.10966496914625168, 0.09130651503801346, 0.020141147077083588, -0.036098673939704895, -0.022946104407310486, -0.050327982753515244, 0.021747397258877754, -0.004885378759354353, -0.012410962954163551, -0.018683504313230515, -0.011703851632773876, 0.0049160076305270195, 0.09504213184118271, -0.01372368261218071, -0.02462766505777836, 0.10668880492448807, -0.06004178524017334, 0.04990607127547264, -0.011783008463680744, -0.004214977379888296, 0.009192670695483685, -0.0151680838316679, -0.0396028496325016, 0.002800137270241976, 0.028026441112160683, -0.08948337286710739, 0.020084548741579056, -0.015304505825042725, -0.01678706705570221, 0.06845955550670624, 0.030796131119132042, -0.011660916730761528, 0.024801844730973244, -0.06155950948596001, 0.016025200486183167, -0.1054462194442749, 0.02731388434767723, 0.10019610822200775, 0.09986138343811035, -0.016863036900758743, -0.008713889867067337, -0.028080157935619354, 0.02530617080628872, 0.10668448358774185, -0.05416182428598404, 0.10479290038347244, 0.03020503744482994, 0.06292782723903656, 0.04874812811613083, 0.011894023045897484, -0.00942047405987978, 0.03643805906176567, -0.03719668835401535, -0.06723368912935257, 0.006338870152831078, 0.0048388889990746975, -0.022134821861982346, 0.018282361328601837, 0.024044141173362732, -0.02233050763607025, -0.0780731663107872, 0.06390179693698883, -0.0023573311045765877, 0.0679321214556694, -0.021415092051029205, -0.04959520697593689, -0.02988077513873577, 0.035138409584760666, 0.07951540499925613, 0.077754907310009, -0.00685733649879694, 0.02691677398979664, 0.04108426719903946, -0.010202552191913128, 0.029099268838763237, -0.061872728168964386, 0.08453679829835892, -0.0016760993748903275, -0.032791607081890106, 0.08775241672992706, -0.019309941679239273, -0.01108467672020197, 0.0013942699879407883, -0.016745885834097862, -0.002621966879814863, -0.010135291144251823, 0.044535133987665176, -0.05739382654428482, -0.03881844878196716, 0.013659480959177017, -0.022673793137073517, -0.020080871880054474, 0.008529024198651314, 0.003031133208423853, 0.023313160985708237, 0.09289723634719849, 0.0578061118721962, 0.06304923444986343, -0.03012576326727867, -0.027199795469641685, -0.04814821854233742, -0.0422353632748127, 0.09402365237474442, 0.10137277841567993, -0.0278216153383255, -0.004681967198848724, -0.04535728320479393, 0.03028297796845436, -0.09102504700422287, 0.0751640573143959, 0.017557550221681595, -0.0024563574697822332, -0.05471108853816986, 0.04146755486726761, -0.11039713770151138, -0.07600964605808258, -0.0623287707567215, -0.07818182557821274, 0.036234110593795776, 0.03729402646422386, -0.08479680866003036, -0.03669309988617897, 0.032766181975603104, 0.013082225807011127, 0.0437961146235466, 0.02789458818733692, -0.053887780755758286, -0.016499854624271393, -0.018562443554401398, -0.006716746371239424, 0.02536412701010704, -0.02128712460398674, 0.011383157223463058, -0.039892975240945816, 0.004801663104444742, 0.1157689243555069, -0.07922618836164474, 0.04826964810490608, -0.05913178622722626, 0.016052300110459328, 0.01428780984133482, -0.010662306100130081, 0.06574369221925735, 0.05016887187957764, 0.03128645941615105, -0.012168576940894127, 0.0334419310092926, -0.013775777071714401, 0.1155674085021019, 0.044743284583091736, 0.07606039196252823, -0.07563384622335434, -0.003622516291216016, 0.017054777592420578, 0.016387896612286568, -0.03297768160700798, -0.050818607211112976, 0.07264116406440735, -0.03781597316265106, 0.0438191182911396, -0.014120131731033325, 0.057702451944351196, 0.041732072830200195, -0.06792549043893814, -0.0529300719499588, 0.052951596677303314, 0.008097571320831776, 0.019465193152427673, -0.0441281832754612, -0.03668586537241936, -0.0007762235472910106, -0.00463264063000679, 0.010601388290524483, 0.034570127725601196, -0.0456632561981678, 0.03215634450316429, -0.04878155142068863, 0.01160797756165266, -0.0012313080951571465, -0.09858150035142899, 0.08447166532278061, -0.016948891803622246, 0.0018445032183080912, -0.010991228744387627, 0.06223797798156738, -0.06562761962413788, 0.026864929124712944, 0.053468357771635056, -0.018141604959964752, 0.04943959414958954, 0.018964719027280807, 0.02818278968334198, -0.057703208178281784, -0.020921802148222923, -0.010499449446797371, -0.03931688889861107, 0.006682475563138723, -0.0706268772482872, 0.0020493126939982176, 0.01623477227985859, 0.051844656467437744, 0.03178706765174866, -0.044529810547828674, 0.017257552593946457, 0.03169122710824013, -0.005297735799103975, -0.019902106374502182, 0.03171617537736893, -0.09100006520748138, -0.0327601283788681, -0.03254833072423935, 0.047728054225444794, -0.07699143886566162, -0.012041478417813778, -0.024501102045178413, -0.09027967602014542, -0.018426336348056793, 0.03939100727438927, -0.046032167971134186, -0.0007902815123088658, -0.0034272160846740007, -0.0032715541310608387, -0.005081611685454845, -0.02449840120971203, -0.07982927560806274, 0.005350606516003609, -0.044091664254665375, -0.09478701651096344, -0.07946477085351944, -0.010381637141108513, 0.02045152150094509, -0.026011507958173752, 0.03180583566427231, 0.04749390855431557, 0.016383294016122818, 0.07970565557479858, -0.004669020883738995, -0.025435566902160645, -0.02253161557018757, 0.050234027206897736, 0.09255583584308624, 0.023778846487402916, 0.008209816180169582, -0.006618345621973276, -0.04096532613039017, 0.031545329838991165, -0.03660859167575836, 0.019647033885121346, 0.053386539220809937, 0.07801368087530136, 0.00805884599685669, 0.06196239963173866, -0.010867331176996231, -0.07713742554187775, -0.011532023549079895, -0.0006012311787344515, 0.020128190517425537, -0.013629383407533169, 0.03408900648355484, -0.07997120916843414, -0.02311159297823906, -0.046928368508815765, 0.04562443867325783, 0.037663768976926804, -0.05183162912726402, -0.03248852863907814, 0.023760154843330383, -0.008867235854268074, 0.022910503670573235, 0.010336143895983696, -0.010632434859871864, 0.06346549093723297, 0.049032099545001984, -0.04943934828042984, -0.0035388304386287928, -0.02184823341667652, -0.04851192235946655, -0.007516849786043167, 0.032321441918611526, -0.005296522285789251, -0.061428558081388474, -0.006491953041404486, 0.041605595499277115, -0.014581449329853058, -0.005052452906966209, 0.029351674020290375, -0.023842746391892433, -0.08374694734811783, -0.09311264753341675, 0.013493921607732773, -0.035295356065034866, 0.015131257474422455, -0.006099632475525141, 0.03187574818730354, 0.04813655465841293, 0.03752857819199562, 0.0353085920214653, -0.026424992829561234, 0.04051559418439865, 0.04219476506114006, -0.010104626417160034, 0.026241745799779892, 0.04141458868980408, -0.034772783517837524, -0.08290999382734299, 0.02706289291381836, 0.02373357117176056, -0.027968630194664, -0.01855533942580223, -0.05288334935903549, -0.00180947280023247, 0.07359441369771957, -0.038445793092250824, 0.06419835984706879, -0.08458276093006134, 0.04292437061667442, -0.030305689200758934, -0.06294050812721252, 0.04055715724825859, 0.020032605156302452, -0.0010688799666240811, -0.018084559589624405, -0.02372896671295166, -0.011375047266483307, -0.0037897254806011915, 0.04127627983689308, 0.04516850784420967, 0.018839510157704353, 0.023141823709011078, 0.04004906117916107, 0.010801832191646099, -0.028586750850081444, 0.05469777062535286, 0.03489925339818001, -0.019368786364793777, -0.02506890520453453, -0.0018232346046715975, -0.060131482779979706, 0.027659334242343903, -0.007576265837997198, 0.008517383597791195, -0.051184382289648056, -0.02546324022114277, -0.05113125219941139, -0.015943123027682304, -0.04025275260210037, 0.04948386549949646, 0.06242233142256737, -0.05831315368413925, -0.01786469668149948, 0.05203821137547493, 0.0475640743970871, -0.01433614082634449, 0.024375787004828453, -0.06194161996245384, 0.0059127495624125, 0.0267076026648283, -0.07249825447797775, 0.01896287314593792, -0.014164223335683346, 0.0400773324072361, -0.06303069740533829, -0.009497972205281258, -0.04981712996959686, 0.084642194211483, -0.007130573503673077, 0.014149495400488377, 0.031924985349178314, -0.018794890493154526, -0.023496108129620552, 0.035900115966796875, 0.08281746506690979, 0.006586825009435415, -0.04116753861308098, 0.043946970254182816, 0.004598637111485004, -0.013421492651104927, 0.04032832011580467, 0.03269927203655243, -0.037436433136463165, -0.014378044754266739, 0.024227669462561607, 0.023294981569051743, 0.014191419817507267, 0.04847005009651184, 0.003476793644949794, 0.009315872564911842, 0.07017918676137924, 0.06523434072732925, -0.014658570289611816, 0.032573502510786057, -0.07000061124563217, -0.05150992050766945, 0.09480514377355576, -0.04070987179875374, 0.04802374169230461 ]
66
66
Reconstruction of Markov Random Fields from Samples: Some Easy Observations and Algorithms
Markov random fields are used to model high dimensional distributions in a number of applied areas. Much recent interest has been devoted to the reconstruction of the dependency structure from independent samples from the Markov random fields. We analyze a simple algorithm for reconstructing the underlying graph defining a Markov random field on $n$ nodes and maximum degree $d$ given observations. We show that under mild non-degeneracy conditions it reconstructs the generating graph with high probability using $\Theta(d \epsilon^{-2}\delta^{-4} \log n)$ samples where $\epsilon,\delta$ depend on the local interactions. For most local interaction $\eps,\delta$ are of order $\exp(-O(d))$. Our results are optimal as a function of $n$ up to a multiplicative constant depending on $d$ and the strength of the local interactions. Our results seem to be the first results for general models that guarantee that {\em the} generating model is reconstructed. Furthermore, we provide explicit $O(n^{d+2} \epsilon^{-2}\delta^{-4} \log n)$ running time bound. In cases where the measure on the graph has correlation decay, the running time is $O(n^2 \log n)$ for all fixed $d$. We also discuss the effect of observing noisy samples and show that as long as the noise level is low, our algorithm is effective. On the other hand, we construct an example where large noise implies non-identifiability even for generic noise and interactions. Finally, we briefly show that in some simple cases, models with hidden nodes can also be recovered.
[ -0.07145003229379654, -0.04312373325228691, 0.0030645199585705996, -0.08906278014183044, 0.05744263529777527, -0.06797672063112259, 0.04533785954117775, 0.016400368884205818, -0.12311628460884094, 0.023613791912794113, -0.017135079950094223, -0.053848739713430405, -0.033588193356990814, -0.005932456813752651, -0.024334650486707687, -0.03857867047190666, -0.021558523178100586, -0.013494372367858887, 0.03661932796239853, -0.05763085186481476, -0.057294514030218124, -0.02671182155609131, 0.03459765389561653, -0.03578439727425575, -0.034070756286382675, -0.012236380949616432, 0.007528979331254959, -0.049475885927677155, -0.032831788063049316, -0.0069386884570121765, 0.010052040219306946, 0.07888150215148926, 0.03396676108241081, -0.006691365037113428, -0.07368707656860352, 0.003755751298740506, 0.059230316430330276, -0.0018529898952692747, -0.04819507896900177, -0.013996806927025318, -0.029619237408041954, -0.03774559870362282, -0.03664083033800125, -0.029805174097418785, 0.08268518000841141, 0.0946543738245964, 0.056750476360321045, 0.04227140173316002, 0.005805363412946463, 0.05728893727064133, -0.007821733132004738, 0.051603369414806366, 0.009634163230657578, 0.004429935943335295, -0.11383308470249176, 0.05402059480547905, -0.013587762601673603, 0.060004863888025284, -0.0443725660443306, -0.02347194030880928, 0.027882136404514313, 0.017289120703935623, -0.05646853148937225, -0.04923468828201294, -0.022952083498239517, -0.011757397092878819, 0.013711118139326572, 0.08309370279312134, -0.03490149602293968, -0.0018419681582599878, 0.0043603102676570415, -0.07462959736585617, 0.015777211636304855, 0.035782989114522934, 0.017995040863752365, 0.025029128417372704, -0.014098727144300938, 0.00904699508100748, 0.04927854239940643, 0.1310775727033615, -0.09087342023849487, 0.032117459923028946, 0.03603783994913101, -0.010719609446823597, 0.02255099266767502, 0.054730404168367386, -0.0019381724996492267, -0.04990674927830696, -0.047485142946243286, -0.006429317872971296, -0.04701638221740723, 0.0418633371591568, -0.0678374320268631, 0.08161763846874237, -0.03529348969459534, 0.074953593313694, -0.03741901367902756, -0.008349036797881126, 0.02590562403202057, 0.07370651513338089, -0.020723111927509308, -0.025335228070616722, 0.0637664720416069, 0.03541278839111328, 0.005447445437312126, -0.06257802993059158, -0.020895903930068016, 0.001578587107360363, 0.07212863862514496, -0.08313604444265366, 0.07388239353895187, -0.037306349724531174, -0.024249395355582237, 0.03740217536687851, -0.049006618559360504, 0.0466892346739769, -0.06020558625459671, 0.08360925316810608, -0.028030989691615105, -0.0007118968642316759, -0.008785801008343697, -0.052075598388910294, -0.059371110051870346, 0.013769879937171936, 0.03568727895617485, -0.03472615033388138, -0.017146434634923935, 0.0022801628801971674, 0.09321796894073486, -0.027884064242243767, -0.06875789165496826, -0.039009906351566315, -0.012453990057110786, -0.06279552727937698, -0.12814493477344513, -0.009213551878929138, 0.042217690497636795, -0.04555075988173485, -0.0138475950807333, 0.05812670290470123, 0.018539950251579285, -0.010717478580772877, 0.0334792323410511, -0.08646132797002792, -0.03327398747205734, 0.06176663562655449, -0.009416216984391212, 0.006861392874270678, -0.039808858186006546, -0.02163284830749035, -0.02014722302556038, -0.0680508241057396, 0.018204445019364357, 0.003336496651172638, 0.07859386503696442, -0.024135122075676918, -0.025110693648457527, -0.002963750157505274, -0.010185775347054005, 0.015340260230004787, -0.10288813710212708, 0.05433084815740585, -0.00346875237300992, 0.0355667769908905, -0.005603034980595112, -0.028272559866309166, -0.05666462704539299, -0.03907260298728943, -0.03224385157227516, -0.030791178345680237, 0.023445017635822296, 0.009603799320757389, 0.048726145178079605, 0.06071783974766731, 0.010802916251122952, -0.002098567085340619, -0.022522419691085815, -0.003189199371263385, 0.019801205024123192, -0.007320732343941927, 0.012770491652190685, -0.029265042394399643, 0.01232496090233326, -0.002295448910444975, -0.04274170100688934, 0.04181907698512077, -0.056583259254693985, 0.047059305012226105, 0.03110329806804657, 0.04424560070037842, 0.026885269209742546, -0.0028275437653064728, 0.0792902261018753, -0.03840920329093933, -0.06335070729255676, -0.0016284442972391844, -0.1020624116063118, 0.040351502597332, 0.06535323709249496, 0.05813054367899895, 0.023317204788327217, 0.010173249989748001, -0.07225871086120605, -0.07466744631528854, -0.04689779877662659, -0.005078782327473164, 0.04886915907263756, -0.05025404319167137, 0.004600550513714552, -0.08195487409830093, 0.06274724006652832, 0.009344751015305519, -0.03921371325850487, -0.06529192626476288, 0.08812680840492249, -0.0625738874077797, -0.0274432972073555, -0.047269485890865326, 0.0698588639497757, -0.01649090088903904, -0.04554012417793274, 0.04687816649675369, -0.062117885798215866, 0.046897899359464645, -0.08737636357545853, 0.011805577203631401, 0.03156479820609093, 0.06452703475952148, -0.07723812758922577, -0.031908005475997925, -0.009965047240257263, 0.007424490991979837, -0.051585327833890915, 0.009881874546408653, 0.02078653685748577, 0.053526587784290314, 0.0073515865951776505, -0.007943776436150074, 0.0007347727078013122, 0.05058407038450241, 0.02270565554499626, 0.057999275624752045, 0.013973644003272057, -0.02774369716644287, 0.033700186759233475, -0.06715045124292374, 0.03517594188451767, 0.02618081122636795, 0.002283624839037657, 0.04556071013212204, -0.008337420411407948, 0.015460559166967869, -0.05325925350189209, 0.0036874429788440466, 0.03721483424305916, -0.004331679083406925, 0.009144460782408714, 0.05795637145638466, -0.010192843154072762, 0.03650316968560219, 0.0029735469724982977, -0.007324123289436102, -0.11058036237955093, 0.07476769387722015, 0.09430231899023056, 0.08321738988161087, 0.035102713853120804, 0.004982955753803253, 0.012433993630111217, -0.006844323594123125, 0.05727528780698776, -0.051747508347034454, -0.03930841013789177, 0.08728247135877609, -0.03676854819059372, 0.0504479743540287, 0.09535650908946991, 0.07300389558076859, -0.06241672486066818, -0.05555993318557739, -0.0814046561717987, 0.014558298513293266, -0.02111341990530491, 0.0007682316936552525, 0.028268760070204735, 0.0743689015507698, -0.05276116728782654, 0.03431709110736847, -0.0417928509414196, 0.03164788708090782, -0.07221992313861847, 0.018136169761419296, -0.020772941410541534, -0.03095574490725994, -0.011686346493661404, -0.06273327022790909, 0.04076053574681282, -0.05463925004005432, 0.055272165685892105, 0.02771037630736828, -0.03529142960906029, -0.035002391785383224, 0.06584804505109787, 0.02925044484436512, 0.06784486770629883, -0.020752696320414543, -0.020916946232318878, 0.012258508242666721, -0.025879360735416412, -0.03716069087386131, -0.02890695631504059, -0.012525991536676884, -0.06923970580101013, 0.000056192260672105476, 0.0842757299542427, -0.01411175075918436, 0.005830662790685892, -0.06159331649541855, -0.010596483014523983, -0.053385645151138306, -0.021319355815649033, -0.009336820803582668, 0.03161798045039177, 0.037880681455135345, -0.038708969950675964, -0.019908923655748367, 0.037429969757795334, 0.04953792318701744, 0.0068298885598778725, -0.024644097313284874, -0.020084664225578308, 0.015220368281006813, -0.013656355440616608, 0.06589356064796448, 0.019831690937280655, -0.07248715311288834, -0.025865642353892326, -0.02287939190864563, -0.04963945597410202, 0.03957182541489601, -0.029761001467704773, -0.08205246180295944, -0.017431894317269325, 0.002749864012002945, 0.14055974781513214, 0.07819799333810806, 0.01428860705345869, -0.027571404352784157, 0.09528861194849014, 0.007014830596745014, 0.006450945511460304, 0.011344162747263908, 0.05362997204065323, 0.007169353310018778, 0.043233275413513184, 0.10363897681236267, 0.07977432757616043, 0.0026297643780708313, -0.022524643689393997, 0.056479454040527344, -0.011696026660501957, -0.013429958373308182, -0.03622456267476082, 0.00914119090884924, -0.00528924772515893, 0.006147464737296104, -0.02571444772183895, 0.04831815883517265, -0.019152488559484482, -0.012722010724246502, 0.0311213918030262, -0.009422375820577145, 0.004481671843677759, 0.0469113327562809, -0.009103299118578434, -0.017415832728147507, 0.01101982593536377, -0.03994472324848175, 0.029969923198223114, 0.04790385439991951, -0.059378571808338165, 0.004720274358987808, -0.022083908319473267, -0.004148026928305626, -0.005044960882514715, -0.008195349015295506, -0.08155589550733566, 0.0714385136961937, 0.06214817613363266, 0.049972329288721085, -0.047744620591402054, 0.05324152484536171, 0.02593764290213585, 0.016113268211483955, 0.0015091177774593234, 0.012263641692698002, 0.05067334696650505, 0.0005409620353020728, -0.03947814553976059, -0.01638083904981613, 0.044194165617227554, -0.03075339086353779, -0.011880706064403057, -0.023866860195994377, -0.029956763610243797, 0.0034445978235453367, -0.09781868755817413, 0.016195837408304214, 0.01213807426393032, 0.02460002899169922, 0.022660337388515472, -0.011410145089030266, -0.04605567455291748, 0.024028507992625237, -0.026262585073709488, 0.06896413117647171, -0.039416395127773285, -0.010463520884513855, 0.031051302328705788, 0.015787789598107338, 0.004581499844789505, 0.00739121250808239, -0.01656024158000946, -0.013375677168369293, -0.04796174168586731, 0.00011192889360245317, 0.09249573945999146, 0.034976422786712646, -0.00958450697362423, -0.005697508808225393, -0.030385036021471024, -0.03021191991865635, 0.01208980567753315, -0.015449739061295986, 0.0038610929623246193, -0.04418262094259262, -0.008387625217437744, -0.07834605127573013, -0.004870872478932142, 0.03179241716861725, 0.007633783854544163, 0.026058390736579895, -0.04200776293873787, 0.013388861902058125, 0.03602970018982887, 0.023780496791005135, 0.039326563477516174, 0.008220287971198559, 0.06187939643859863, 0.03294092416763306, 0.01140920165926218, 0.09410779923200607, 0.004707475658506155, 0.014271560125052929, -0.0027932242956012487, -0.012474109418690205, 0.057804837822914124, 0.04713951423764229, 0.06193703040480614, -0.022964000701904297, -0.0019405425991863012, -0.04701688513159752, -0.025355074554681778, 0.023840587586164474, -0.03368046134710312, -0.01546861045062542, 0.04043596237897873, 0.03133029490709305, 0.026488710194826126, 0.027794387191534042, -0.07160712778568268, 0.07263171672821045, 0.007940980605781078, -0.023851187899708748, 0.017597682774066925, 0.018861966207623482, 0.013200003653764725, -0.04504222422838211, -0.014284366741776466, -0.009050903841853142, 0.031892139464616776, 0.07406798750162125, -0.017758246511220932, -0.04313062131404877, 0.021577712148427963, 0.066631980240345, 0.04907986521720886, 0.021560849621891975, 0.06263688206672668, -0.001252824324183166, 0.0216915812343359, -0.019121497869491577, -0.007083768956363201, 0.048006217926740646, -0.04644451290369034, -0.0067637329921126366, -0.006059996783733368, 0.005587062332779169, 0.012709581293165684, 0.03052331879734993, 0.057160958647727966, -0.02686438150703907, -0.003472517244517803, -0.003630130784586072, 0.0350249819457531, 0.05755485221743584, -0.015325277112424374, -0.050320446491241455, -0.08034609258174896, 0.06712109595537186, -0.036479707807302475, 0.012456225231289864 ]
67
67
A New Theoretic Foundation for Cross-Layer Optimization
Cross-layer optimization solutions have been proposed in recent years to improve the performance of network users operating in a time-varying, error-prone wireless environment. However, these solutions often rely on ad-hoc optimization approaches, which ignore the different environmental dynamics experienced at various layers by a user and violate the layered network architecture of the protocol stack by requiring layers to provide access to their internal protocol parameters to other layers. This paper presents a new theoretic foundation for cross-layer optimization, which allows each layer to make autonomous decisions individually, while maximizing the utility of the wireless user by optimally determining what information needs to be exchanged among layers. Hence, this cross-layer framework does not change the current layered architecture. Specifically, because the wireless user interacts with the environment at various layers of the protocol stack, the cross-layer optimization problem is formulated as a layered Markov decision process (MDP) in which each layer adapts its own protocol parameters and exchanges information (messages) with other layers in order to cooperatively maximize the performance of the wireless user. The message exchange mechanism for determining the optimal cross-layer transmission strategies has been designed for both off-line optimization and on-line dynamic adaptation. We also show that many existing cross-layer optimization algorithms can be formulated as simplified, sub-optimal, versions of our layered MDP framework.
[ 0.001269289292395115, -0.06332622468471527, 0.007478158455342054, 0.014996048994362354, -0.03491185978055, -0.053435955196619034, 0.0415053553879261, -0.04489568620920181, -0.04952139034867287, 0.05001562833786011, -0.009723812341690063, -0.05224587395787239, 0.03194611892104149, -0.04775232821702957, -0.008211611770093441, -0.010427463799715042, 0.04046168178319931, 0.03227724879980087, 0.011178780347108841, -0.044435638934373856, -0.04076490178704262, -0.039658259600400925, -0.057814933359622955, -0.018040675669908524, 0.02835582196712494, -0.020848456770181656, -0.049346923828125, -0.005211507901549339, 0.003801237093284726, 0.009316721931099892, -0.08453556895256042, 0.02721436694264412, 0.006894771941006184, -0.0014969068579375744, 0.011795025318861008, 0.00016141402011271566, 0.03426108509302139, -0.05122508853673935, -0.0602334626019001, 0.006496571935713291, -0.0003287103900220245, -0.03173614293336868, -0.016012195497751236, -0.05441489443182945, 0.06679948419332504, 0.10651125758886337, 0.01433862466365099, 0.02029101736843586, -0.016930483281612396, 0.0072147436439991, -0.04945779964327812, 0.040283478796482086, -0.03678354248404503, 0.025374889373779297, 0.015175706706941128, 0.05765121057629585, -0.003616273170337081, -0.025686468929052353, 0.014955239370465279, -0.04223144054412842, 0.023331372067332268, 0.06307889521121979, -0.08984347432851791, -0.009342599660158157, -0.10690531134605408, -0.0019558786880224943, -0.04382706806063652, -0.012023549526929855, -0.002791694598272443, 0.010923944413661957, 0.0452115498483181, 0.004008916672319174, -0.017413901165127754, 0.035394079983234406, 0.041732512414455414, 0.029163915663957596, -0.0036885987501591444, -0.0019293654477223754, 0.017211323603987694, 0.07466135174036026, -0.08371569216251373, 0.029780074954032898, -0.05754999816417694, 0.08881158381700516, 0.023401573300361633, 0.011186760850250721, -0.03115767613053322, -0.03443380072712898, -0.01920914091169834, -0.0119764544069767, -0.01891312748193741, 0.033012717962265015, -0.08084918558597565, -0.04073863476514816, 0.004035685211420059, 0.03944261744618416, -0.07930449396371841, 0.01624356396496296, -0.006145504768937826, 0.03966595605015755, -0.024947717785835266, 0.0008838073699735105, 0.05584333837032318, 0.059075646102428436, 0.050553448498249054, 0.010282586328685284, 0.007298939861357212, 0.07331868261098862, -0.00033691615681163967, -0.01815897226333618, 0.009732747450470924, -0.07229765504598618, 0.007527013309299946, -0.07921907305717468, -0.05782553553581238, 0.06672587990760803, -0.01745673082768917, 0.01809702254831791, -0.0727572962641716, 0.029466480016708374, -0.0015107952058315277, 0.03757810220122337, -0.039703622460365295, -0.04907187446951866, 0.0784955620765686, 0.02427288331091404, -0.016731860116124153, -0.05519940331578255, 0.07242842763662338, 0.018525172024965286, -0.05319308862090111, 0.0715564638376236, 0.041760943830013275, 0.00006156429299153388, 0.007403234951198101, 0.05316461995244026, 0.03009074367582798, 0.013196020387113094, -0.07552700489759445, -0.020064054057002068, 0.030953776091337204, 0.03371761366724968, -0.06599090248346329, -0.02726941555738449, 0.03240180388092995, -0.032633863389492035, 0.003995646256953478, 0.02586614154279232, -0.01955752819776535, 0.019815875217318535, -0.030813850462436676, -0.04165426641702652, 0.054227981716394424, 0.05860716104507446, -0.04510967805981636, -0.039560798555612564, -0.056080032140016556, -0.05454415827989578, -0.015325851738452911, 0.017570871859788895, -0.016249725595116615, 0.05452604219317436, 0.0031088716350495815, 0.011863898485898972, 0.01698763482272625, -0.012801283039152622, -0.0711662545800209, 0.03195655718445778, -0.08192367106676102, -0.07751073688268661, -0.021484017372131348, -0.010008575394749641, -0.02365833707153797, 0.08297988772392273, 0.054466284811496735, -0.008057421073317528, -0.03576606139540672, -0.056802283972501755, -0.06251119822263718, 0.018657002598047256, 0.030864164233207703, 0.01969454437494278, -0.03018178604543209, -0.029526090249419212, -0.017371544614434242, 0.006065845023840666, 0.08294138312339783, 0.05124836042523384, 0.09521603584289551, 0.034070901572704315, -0.01649460382759571, 0.01816699281334877, -0.013439418748021126, 0.006865137722343206, 0.03772870451211929, -0.04513458535075188, -0.06052985414862633, 0.0400034599006176, 0.06346426159143448, -0.03972198814153671, 0.06971721351146698, -0.07292702049016953, -0.046355318278074265, -0.04345627874135971, -0.0016357532003894448, 0.04312318190932274, 0.03626609966158867, -0.05325816944241524, -0.017199577763676643, -0.04021101072430611, -0.07771052420139313, -0.0544840544462204, -0.007531569339334965, 0.004445870406925678, 0.032165687531232834, -0.06090698391199112, -0.06688548624515533, 0.03304864838719368, -0.018771355971693993, -0.05543174222111702, -0.030133787542581558, 0.08775116503238678, -0.008763541467487812, 0.0517626516520977, -0.014990557916462421, -0.02859375812113285, -0.004347825888544321, 0.019634485244750977, -0.07103211432695389, -0.01135027315467596, -0.004340360872447491, -0.08445696532726288, -0.022423148155212402, 0.05840558931231499, -0.041037797927856445, 0.03756412863731384, -0.042499277740716934, -0.09116017818450928, 0.02966390736401081, -0.04214395210146904, 0.019960863515734673, 0.05241062492132187, 0.013976526446640491, -0.007693170104175806, 0.16450126469135284, 0.017603987827897072, 0.07308316975831985, -0.041507381945848465, -0.055287234485149384, -0.03373632952570915, 0.02490474097430706, -0.0254018884152174, 0.03890654072165489, 0.062000811100006104, 0.02712760679423809, 0.02575688250362873, 0.0304532740265131, 0.02799868956208229, 0.014221347868442535, 0.06198281794786453, -0.0579272024333477, -0.06654968112707138, -0.05981628969311714, -0.002295311540365219, 0.044686608016490936, 0.07465656101703644, 0.04962366074323654, 0.07638228684663773, 0.00207224627956748, 0.030435115098953247, -0.003451255615800619, -0.03442847356200218, -0.008162809535861015, 0.0923599973320961, -0.012350342236459255, 0.028902297839522362, 0.055848125368356705, 0.048230018466711044, -0.004286083858460188, -0.07366529852151871, -0.02268882468342781, 0.018702972680330276, -0.015452975407242775, 0.02972782775759697, 0.0027762101963162422, -0.014439653605222702, -0.00861554965376854, 0.04694082587957382, 0.024193719029426575, 0.04157961905002594, -0.11137574166059494, 0.052351463586091995, -0.06665699928998947, -0.028934668749570847, 0.042790308594703674, -0.0066119590774178505, -0.0014420193620026112, -0.03572825714945793, -0.008369908668100834, -0.003381355432793498, 0.04581500589847565, -0.06902996450662613, 0.007579514756798744, 0.027222495526075363, -0.0728110671043396, 0.06807511299848557, -0.023872526362538338, -0.014941247180104256, -0.06376462429761887, -0.008699500933289528, 0.05564457178115845, 0.034754347056150436, -0.07786387205123901, 0.008016795851290226, 0.10236313194036484, -0.03156490623950958, -0.05286974459886551, -0.04625948891043663, -0.030293425545096397, 0.026710014790296555, 0.02759418450295925, -0.02591898664832115, 0.08760427683591843, -0.05045238882303238, -0.019220784306526184, 0.03191829472780228, -0.019978370517492294, -0.02683863416314125, -0.030614089220762253, 0.002747604623436928, -0.09396111220121384, -0.014664414338767529, -0.040289174765348434, 0.0412432886660099, -0.04476345703005791, -0.015235263854265213, -0.11301443725824356, -0.017824679613113403, 0.046256497502326965, 0.08261101692914963, -0.03561624139547348, -0.07269790768623352, -0.009329911321401596, -0.02230081707239151, 0.05146737024188042, 0.09017494320869446, 0.018831128254532814, 0.033874861896038055, -0.056608378887176514, 0.013617618009448051, 0.036894090473651886, -0.024482328444719315, -0.09369195997714996, -0.07734178006649017, 0.013453865423798561, -0.026238515973091125, 0.03743264451622963, -0.036851637065410614, 0.04857431724667549, -0.004751210100948811, -0.0014679102459922433, -0.02568049170076847, -0.004769913386553526, -0.01692184805870056, 0.006502942647784948, 0.01210073009133339, -0.0224924199283123, 0.0032632043585181236, -0.010125701315701008, 0.002295008162036538, -0.05253925174474716, 0.027443476021289825, -0.03712752088904381, 0.011150086298584938, 0.01648743823170662, -0.03075721487402916, 0.09616552293300629, -0.05821153149008751, -0.05282359570264816, 0.03843599557876587, -0.014034534804522991, -0.03262709081172943, 0.03760791942477226, -0.0618182048201561, 0.006924242712557316, -0.023723265156149864, -0.011663051322102547, -0.003248776076361537, 0.08725596219301224, -0.037667710334062576, -0.07390204071998596, 0.023378031328320503, -0.10084168612957001, 0.03724520280957222, 0.04328101500868797, 0.02326018549501896, 0.04126057028770447, 0.0016741312574595213, -0.07800359278917313, 0.04996350035071373, 0.03695293888449669, -0.07234082370996475, -0.01873755268752575, -0.040173258632421494, -0.07100579887628555, -0.045531611889600754, -0.01810000091791153, 0.006319467909634113, -0.04014148563146591, 0.023478928953409195, -0.0014423674438148737, -0.004186917562037706, 0.014527512714266777, -0.028209926560521126, -0.04132182523608208, 0.03346448764204979, 0.0039945002645254135, 0.0033165160566568375, 0.010079259984195232, -0.06956446170806885, -0.04585821554064751, 0.017310990020632744, 0.049971140921115875, -0.05292734503746033, -0.01977008767426014, -0.001647081458941102, 0.012793737463653088, 0.09133192896842957, -0.04735366255044937, 0.004155284259468317, -0.0776577740907669, -0.04662704840302467, -0.06834116578102112, -0.04340488463640213, -0.03430311754345894, 0.027792586013674736, 0.07267548888921738, -0.02791021764278412, -0.008393090218305588, -0.045704446732997894, 0.005403012968599796, -0.04213227331638336, 0.06180967763066292, 0.04603720083832741, 0.014546788297593594, 0.019185837358236313, 0.07947663217782974, 0.04791765660047531, 0.0330815315246582, -0.025997363030910492, -0.007728592026978731, 0.07706938683986664, 0.09359901398420334, -0.023970087990164757, -0.010134336538612843, -0.024368809536099434, 0.018002750352025032, -0.019877521321177483, 0.025616608560085297, -0.0021739171352237463, -0.022176524624228477, -0.0002560408029239625, 0.02713966555893421, -0.014042737893760204, -0.0208356324583292, -0.0700853168964386, -0.02135917916893959, -0.025287652388215065, 0.05645115301012993, -0.029319239780306816, -0.05123965069651604, 0.03448109328746796, 0.03491625934839249, -0.04933077096939087, -0.00771491089835763, 0.007458953186869621, -0.013066506013274193, 0.03236306086182594, -0.03644890338182449, -0.017789049074053764, 0.029238851740956306, 0.06788866966962814, 0.03433038666844368, 0.012791306711733341, 0.030246619135141373, -0.004008276388049126, -0.03704485297203064, 0.030780937522649765, 0.00464064022526145, 0.04059063270688057, -0.03316739946603775, -0.06111416220664978, 0.011947817169129848, 0.020516667515039444, 0.00813224446028471, 0.055637288838624954, 0.009946920908987522, -0.02548498474061489, 0.10312395542860031, 0.008653685450553894, -0.043623343110084534, -0.0009793923236429691, 0.027195971459150314, 0.05610308423638344, 0.06153014674782753, 0.04792877659201622, 0.05901702493429184, 0.0966295674443245, 0.009474028833210468, -0.01759749837219715, -0.06856228411197662, 0.04347251355648041 ]
68
68
Density estimation in linear time
We consider the problem of choosing a density estimate from a set of distributions F, minimizing the L1-distance to an unknown distribution (Devroye, Lugosi 2001). Devroye and Lugosi analyze two algorithms for the problem: Scheffe tournament winner and minimum distance estimate. The Scheffe tournament estimate requires fewer computations than the minimum distance estimate, but has strictly weaker guarantees than the latter. We focus on the computational aspect of density estimation. We present two algorithms, both with the same guarantee as the minimum distance estimate. The first one, a modification of the minimum distance estimate, uses the same number (quadratic in |F|) of computations as the Scheffe tournament. The second one, called ``efficient minimum loss-weight estimate,'' uses only a linear number of computations, assuming that F is preprocessed. We also give examples showing that the guarantees of the algorithms cannot be improved and explore randomized algorithms for density estimation.
[ 0.009546920657157898, -0.004600611515343189, 0.01907944865524769, -0.037048280239105225, -0.002231772057712078, -0.053167253732681274, 0.08721160143613815, -0.04697045683860779, -0.06773990392684937, 0.09564784169197083, -0.025609390810132027, -0.0451338030397892, -0.08033148944377899, 0.028943156823515892, -0.011689314618706703, -0.002091479254886508, -0.0444549024105072, -0.003368527628481388, 0.044434141367673874, -0.022998595610260963, 0.027655282989144325, 0.00839921087026596, 0.007314375136047602, -0.01355813816189766, -0.0577409565448761, 0.029180875048041344, 0.06425666064023972, 0.053752731531858444, -0.0800015777349472, -0.020620184019207954, -0.06176714971661568, 0.08457005023956299, 0.01889828033745289, 0.03826087340712547, 0.00677449582144618, -0.024518344551324844, 0.07877805083990097, -0.042610786855220795, -0.05359037220478058, -0.11075695604085922, -0.03294098377227783, 0.005419938359409571, -0.025530092418193817, -0.0036770987790077925, 0.015070200897753239, 0.013837264850735664, 0.03437693044543266, 0.03738617151975632, -0.0005250461981631815, -0.015311636961996555, 0.01866060495376587, 0.016837211325764656, -0.025419002398848534, -0.020614320412278175, 0.0045517561957240105, 0.029189707711338997, -0.052177175879478455, -0.01904003508388996, -0.02263096533715725, -0.09087883681058884, 0.06131667643785477, 0.05814359709620476, -0.062042877078056335, -0.0018688120180740952, -0.040146488696336746, -0.0246663149446249, -0.0286545529961586, -0.01444120705127716, 0.017098499462008476, -0.014932848513126373, 0.0047846329398453236, -0.09068406373262405, 0.03615030646324158, 0.06405448913574219, 0.016409857198596, -0.029305724427103996, -0.031000817194581032, 0.07405591011047363, 0.10290082544088364, 0.05948646366596222, -0.0921143889427185, 0.05323638394474983, -0.02933378703892231, 0.02451145462691784, -0.014333116821944714, 0.022523492574691772, -0.016891218721866608, 0.0032439923379570246, 0.020863879472017288, -0.07368750125169754, -0.05680389329791069, -0.005292776972055435, -0.06665772199630737, 0.011639474891126156, -0.07870567589998245, 0.06036262586712837, -0.0312250554561615, -0.02300991676747799, 0.013355795294046402, 0.07367292791604996, 0.008106479421257973, -0.04494981840252876, 0.1011226624250412, 0.031824804842472076, 0.01152039971202612, -0.002541287336498499, -0.012234075926244259, 0.04068208113312721, 0.02401236817240715, -0.026993725448846817, -0.07453643530607224, -0.038164932280778885, -0.01562329288572073, 0.014639358967542648, -0.021990584209561348, 0.05542709305882454, 0.05426434054970741, 0.03534321114420891, 0.017131755128502846, 0.023113125935196877, 0.08226276934146881, 0.04862146079540253, 0.05689077451825142, -0.01923038810491562, 0.039733514189720154, 0.010264608077704906, -0.022726312279701233, -0.09324637055397034, 0.0950949564576149, -0.00006433726230170578, -0.0069616795517504215, -0.012906372547149658, -0.029946042224764824, 0.000008074476681940723, -0.05877935513854027, 0.007166644092649221, 0.07456644624471664, 0.0075086564756929874, 0.055475715547800064, 0.12784495949745178, -0.007318972144275904, 0.053920771926641464, -0.03305521979928017, -0.021104557439684868, 0.045329827815294266, -0.017676476389169693, 0.040743738412857056, 0.007437969092279673, -0.04935845360159874, 0.009317946620285511, -0.013103358447551727, -0.034953773021698, 0.04692981019616127, 0.0032162806019186974, -0.018911154940724373, -0.08424952626228333, -0.03963043540716171, 0.001941041206009686, -0.03507603704929352, 0.03421684354543686, 0.01035225298255682, -0.03534497693181038, 0.009126170538365841, -0.001046308083459735, 0.014674244448542595, 0.054051440209150314, 0.023224227130413055, -0.013552653603255749, 0.008145620115101337, -0.0061400942504405975, 0.03559371083974838, -0.03493988513946533, 0.007714856881648302, 0.022022277116775513, -0.02643110603094101, 0.02659233659505844, 0.05754200741648674, 0.031527142971754074, -0.005433231126517057, -0.02879256010055542, 0.05078307166695595, -0.05042145773768425, -0.01384242344647646, 0.010421634651720524, -0.015234346501529217, 0.04731693118810654, 0.0006791764171794057, 0.02882205881178379, -0.02153405174612999, -0.01200934685766697, 0.011987438425421715, 0.03879772871732712, 0.03807532414793968, -0.032578855752944946, -0.03704270347952843, 0.021807914599776268, -0.02110309526324272, -0.018567649647593498, 0.05706535652279854, 0.04180921986699104, 0.0871681496500969, 0.001427104463800788, -0.04919194057583809, 0.005525152664631605, -0.07383111864328384, 0.01870795339345932, 0.013959451578557491, -0.034656696021556854, 0.09423620998859406, -0.03739481791853905, 0.009921539574861526, -0.03727376088500023, 0.04598521813750267, -0.055680036544799805, 0.03910185396671295, 0.08199258148670197, -0.04005984589457512, -0.07568386942148209, 0.00760906096547842, -0.0012091125827282667, 0.010879840701818466, -0.012722661718726158, -0.05855580419301987, 0.05595007911324501, -0.08397068828344345, 0.03498861566185951, 0.007259481120854616, 0.002137772273272276, 0.0009769159369170666, -0.02912745624780655, -0.0037147337570786476, 0.0174721572548151, 0.021802833303809166, -0.01442778017371893, -0.0712219700217247, 0.011157541535794735, -0.06855473667383194, -0.027787739410996437, -0.02677738666534424, -0.00014442972315009683, 0.02099452167749405, 0.07122474163770676, 0.02558024600148201, -0.03451903164386749, 0.016936836764216423, -0.03768402338027954, 0.019556032493710518, -0.010423523373901844, -0.01498162280768156, 0.09688969701528549, -0.01874312199652195, 0.03073478676378727, 0.06583042442798615, -0.041198424994945526, 0.025162233039736748, -0.02679423615336418, 0.054668743163347244, 0.0527682900428772, 0.057506632059812546, 0.025610486045479774, -0.01633351854979992, 0.03723350912332535, -0.07200866937637329, -0.03174511343240738, 0.002300285967066884, -0.025331467390060425, -0.0560639314353466, 0.06899728626012802, 0.027970025315880775, 0.04764499515295029, 0.005842486396431923, -0.05472816154360771, -0.04711061716079712, 0.10659710317850113, -0.01716776192188263, -0.05474155768752098, 0.054296769201755524, 0.035355933010578156, -0.0017378105549141765, -0.04031888768076897, -0.039698339998722076, 0.06347711384296417, 0.0381588377058506, 0.027306323871016502, 0.013652550056576729, 0.05779913812875748, -0.03986911475658417, -0.01972332037985325, -0.01400704588741064, 0.007184491027146578, -0.023103393614292145, 0.04975877329707146, -0.021539142355322838, -0.09889693558216095, 0.04750671237707138, 0.07902204245328903, 0.05721420794725418, -0.040500760078430176, 0.026140108704566956, 0.03917665034532547, -0.03737401217222214, 0.020737960934638977, 0.040421951562166214, 0.048178400844335556, 0.08838712424039841, -0.01706971973180771, 0.05784673988819122, 0.011125224642455578, -0.01136152446269989, 0.013555766083300114, -0.04555477574467659, 0.04203757643699646, -0.06781583279371262, -0.043717268854379654, 0.04146697372198105, -0.07986096292734146, 0.04243538901209831, -0.031470708549022675, 0.030604783445596695, -0.0368780642747879, 0.018670234829187393, -0.01880233734846115, 0.04875415563583374, 0.023206666111946106, -0.0850096121430397, -0.06087429076433182, 0.003500371240079403, 0.030511580407619476, -0.05507715418934822, -0.02757258340716362, -0.0688599944114685, 0.0479486919939518, -0.07223854213953018, 0.061556626111269, -0.009469435550272465, 0.047022733837366104, -0.019630277529358864, -0.029241571202874184, -0.04736830294132233, -0.04252399504184723, -0.012071712873876095, 0.011127922683954239, -0.10857728868722916, -0.08235500007867813, 0.09068349748849869, 0.07170277833938599, 0.08193940669298172, -0.005117577034980059, -0.011563305743038654, 0.006924323737621307, -0.04067085683345795, 0.0020525965373963118, 0.03697405382990837, 0.01850476674735546, 0.038476619869470596, 0.029269002377986908, 0.016320936381816864, -0.031318001449108124, -0.01644633337855339, 0.06403862684965134, -0.03510470315814018, 0.08228663355112076, -0.010518082417547703, 0.013201352208852768, 0.034368354827165604, 0.04632219299674034, -0.08528418093919754, 0.0024973852559924126, -0.09703004360198975, 0.04382571950554848, -0.03841343894600868, 0.03387458249926567, 0.09833650290966034, 0.014645705930888653, 0.04392346367239952, -0.014947835355997086, 0.10931634902954102, -0.0314713791012764, -0.08456782251596451, 0.05073012039065361, 0.008170478977262974, 0.028547318652272224, -0.012702352367341518, -0.05106614530086517, -0.024669483304023743, -0.04293446987867355, 0.010067392140626907, -0.004228777252137661, 0.05788537487387657, 0.004238571505993605, -0.014310560189187527, -0.06802759319543839, -0.019827794283628464, 0.024417275562882423, 0.0600375235080719, 0.02867317944765091, 0.04320985823869705, -0.0015844785375520587, -0.05479228124022484, -0.06808505207300186, 0.08284702152013779, -0.01674419827759266, 0.03755077347159386, -0.03594338893890381, -0.10209683328866959, -0.0590316578745842, 0.005909513682126999, 0.007270905189216137, -0.06586902588605881, 0.03599245101213455, 0.029002830386161804, -0.05024314299225807, 0.008174611255526543, 0.01753663457930088, 0.04021060839295387, 0.03666934370994568, 0.02448035590350628, 0.0066655948758125305, -0.029900329187512398, -0.10999108850955963, -0.016475724056363106, 0.07815630733966827, 0.013335064984858036, -0.03790402412414551, 0.0043570613488554955, -0.016133155673742294, -0.024595970287919044, -0.023106688633561134, -0.015507237054407597, 0.11214273422956467, -0.025945940986275673, -0.046644121408462524, -0.05308017134666443, -0.047501340508461, 0.032829899340867996, -0.04965278506278992, -0.00976362731307745, -0.07589443027973175, -0.05746296048164368, 0.025645175948739052, -0.006646262481808662, 0.04056375101208687, 0.024087488651275635, 0.05282588675618172, -0.033840361982584, 0.006853152997791767, 0.06693725287914276, 0.03711215406656265, 0.05309320613741875, -0.03758908063173294, 0.05758512020111084, 0.054176218807697296, 0.030244560912251472, 0.012605349533259869, 0.011565270833671093, 0.02642325684428215, 0.03659231588244438, 0.038021959364414215, 0.08039391040802002, -0.0365261435508728, -0.052516475319862366, -0.048026345670223236, 0.012664001435041428, -0.001264552236534655, -0.03830793872475624, 0.02507176250219345, -0.03018997050821781, -0.0026925320271402597, 0.05688443407416344, 0.004629123490303755, -0.07302234321832657, 0.03919964283704758, -0.012446093373000622, -0.0333995595574379, 0.0048256246373057365, 0.006458794232457876, -0.04683879762887955, -0.03186556696891785, 0.023000376299023628, -0.032992441207170486, -0.03338855132460594, 0.044656090438365936, -0.08223707973957062, -0.007294459268450737, 0.05146453529596329, -0.010599852539598942, 0.0006436335388571024, -0.01768876053392887, 0.043201934546232224, -0.02215815708041191, -0.005895924288779497, -0.00776288378983736, -0.06865246593952179, 0.048757560551166534, -0.0655655488371849, -0.010922087356448174, 0.030694833025336266, -0.0059354593977332115, 0.044579919427633286, -0.01694619283080101, 0.026470713317394257, -0.02498857118189335, 0.00832357071340084, -0.020182684063911438, 0.05587383359670639, 0.02512703277170658, 0.049121588468551636, -0.024418480694293976, 0.012722263112664223, 0.0005897784139961004, 0.004683367442339659, 0.05784164369106293 ]
69
69
Graph kernels between point clouds
Point clouds are sets of points in two or three dimensions. Most kernel methods for learning on sets of points have not yet dealt with the specific geometrical invariances and practical constraints associated with point clouds in computer vision and graphics. In this paper, we present extensions of graph kernels for point clouds, which allow to use kernel methods for such ob jects as shapes, line drawings, or any three-dimensional point clouds. In order to design rich and numerically efficient kernels with as few free parameters as possible, we use kernels between covariance matrices and their factorizations on graphical models. We derive polynomial time dynamic programming recursions and present applications to recognition of handwritten digits and Chinese characters from few training examples.
[ -0.04499754309654236, -0.05398731306195259, 0.010084439069032669, -0.05460279434919357, -0.014264661818742752, -0.04222271591424942, 0.060306448489427567, 0.017805667594075203, -0.06487003713846207, 0.02833544835448265, 0.002888395683839917, 0.015322245657444, -0.021314449608325958, 0.08149342238903046, 0.027660012245178223, 0.051326461136341095, 0.0542026087641716, -0.03973689302802086, 0.04582197591662407, -0.07529754936695099, 0.078464575111866, 0.02913353219628334, -0.03107730858027935, -0.0351959764957428, 0.09251448512077332, 0.02675625868141651, 0.08418046683073044, -0.05631714686751366, 0.05561982840299606, 0.032649338245391846, -0.031221982091665268, 0.026001133024692535, 0.03325251117348671, -0.01032005250453949, -0.04528100788593292, -0.01587410271167755, -0.02348591946065426, -0.0022865335922688246, -0.03552645817399025, -0.03964933007955551, -0.006270187441259623, -0.03225978836417198, 0.00047740875743329525, -0.009628137573599815, -0.0026811438146978617, 0.01358737237751484, -0.03565904498100281, 0.02219664864242077, 0.09201841801404953, 0.12604084610939026, -0.07241696864366531, -0.004419864621013403, -0.09491633623838425, 0.017540080472826958, 0.021054383367300034, 0.02261614240705967, -0.005790289491415024, -0.0037698023952543736, -0.07420910894870758, 0.010171942412853241, 0.018028143793344498, 0.019853146746754646, 0.034802455455064774, 0.016228312626481056, -0.004628560971468687, -0.04270937293767929, -0.016831250861287117, -0.006037901155650616, -0.033841583877801895, 0.00500203762203455, -0.012682989239692688, -0.04107999429106712, 0.00357861933298409, 0.020761191844940186, -0.020166628062725067, 0.05322139337658882, -0.0451926589012146, -0.013904589228332043, 0.042005755007267, 0.06641241163015366, -0.006966631859540939, 0.032656703144311905, -0.014330483973026276, 0.02677449956536293, -0.018617816269397736, 0.017683859914541245, -0.008066010661423206, -0.038258038461208344, 0.0022907620295882225, 0.0635644868016243, -0.0539836585521698, 0.019202813506126404, -0.03922468051314354, 0.09126546233892441, -0.03104931302368641, -0.02739509753882885, -0.04180771857500076, -0.01724935509264469, -0.046656977385282516, 0.09605415165424347, -0.03830660879611969, -0.006121402140706778, 0.008901809342205524, 0.049822550266981125, 0.03016965463757515, 0.030264880508184433, -0.03823653236031532, 0.018744459375739098, 0.009358485229313374, -0.05520835146307945, 0.03639915585517883, -0.0026530965697020292, -0.04128888249397278, 0.0180247500538826, -0.09424339234828949, 0.045213863253593445, 0.025843271985650063, 0.0811111107468605, 0.03519481420516968, -0.018298886716365814, -0.014701356180012226, 0.0428655780851841, -0.05511004477739334, -0.013055204413831234, 0.100071020424366, -0.05499417334794998, 0.010181009769439697, 0.0024646474048495293, -0.04054199904203415, -0.0008196811540983617, -0.005941420327872038, 0.06491769105195999, -0.008314419537782669, 0.0030417211819440126, -0.052728474140167236, -0.0061666700057685375, -0.0017358025070279837, -0.046611860394477844, -0.0538090355694294, 0.021179286763072014, 0.041195567697286606, -0.014810957945883274, -0.01789811998605728, -0.017441703006625175, 0.04152664542198181, 0.037734504789114, -0.008320125751197338, -0.005823511630296707, -0.0029081800021231174, -0.0873417779803276, 0.02225649170577526, -0.0891234427690506, 0.0031276217196136713, 0.006365986540913582, 0.05099138244986534, -0.03233107924461365, -0.04199917986989021, 0.019308729097247124, 0.031494252383708954, 0.11170635372400284, -0.03454863652586937, -0.008277789689600468, 0.015421302989125252, 0.020849019289016724, 0.012603373266756535, 0.004336714744567871, 0.014440328814089298, 0.0258401557803154, -0.04006965085864067, -0.0329664908349514, -0.044524434953927994, 0.02875734120607376, -0.045000217854976654, -0.052776824682950974, -0.012184309773147106, 0.0043542152270674706, 0.020943673327565193, 0.018074223771691322, -0.07669083029031754, -0.0945613905787468, 0.08700532466173172, -0.018401075154542923, -0.01409247238188982, 0.06712495535612106, -0.021597443148493767, 0.05720793828368187, -0.003160826163366437, 0.03546231985092163, 0.024657217785716057, 0.022670354694128036, 0.00824454054236412, -0.0021479474380612373, 0.0668988823890686, 0.024066004902124405, -0.04379976540803909, 0.10991570353507996, -0.044883910566568375, -0.05273997038602829, -0.01832333765923977, 0.10284838825464249, 0.03334977105259895, -0.02938864193856716, -0.05496687814593315, -0.0318107083439827, -0.04329116642475128, 0.011868517845869064, 0.08042283356189728, -0.03983566537499428, -0.03605047985911369, -0.019705262035131454, 0.04897814616560936, 0.028389209881424904, -0.02165336161851883, -0.016605468466877937, -0.06879828870296478, -0.02826375514268875, -0.04193635284900665, -0.04869535192847252, 0.03629416599869728, 0.0637330710887909, -0.06561757624149323, 0.02648286335170269, -0.033352285623550415, 0.05678210407495499, -0.07793818414211273, -0.027778444811701775, -0.019216489046812057, -0.03296273946762085, -0.09797395765781403, 0.027492014691233635, -0.0902964249253273, 0.02176819182932377, -0.039710987359285355, 0.04444991052150726, -0.024704694747924805, 0.02769157662987709, -0.06346014142036438, -0.01591942459344864, -0.027451124042272568, -0.014495604671537876, -0.05001412704586983, 0.04288345202803612, -0.02020760253071785, -0.03785175085067749, -0.028502967208623886, -0.005605508107692003, -0.014077232219278812, 0.05678466707468033, 0.022954724729061127, -0.0045363749377429485, -0.022263050079345703, 0.00015347886073868722, 0.0204131118953228, -0.043962400406599045, 0.0037475500721484423, -0.0017872065072879195, 0.00033449361217208207, 0.014298674650490284, 0.12234906852245331, -0.016729364171624184, 0.031740594655275345, -0.0186652522534132, -0.021992914378643036, -0.05558625981211662, 0.04443071037530899, 0.05332328751683235, 0.0039388081058859825, 0.04412945732474327, -0.020505568012595177, 0.09818459302186966, 0.06870003044605255, -0.11860787123441696, -0.09873446822166443, 0.08510413020849228, -0.0021527607459574938, 0.004655071068555117, -0.00551222451031208, 0.030431000515818596, -0.05097809433937073, -0.010392126627266407, -0.057974837720394135, 0.004832022823393345, -0.008430331014096737, -0.07184311747550964, -0.002328583737835288, 0.1114201545715332, -0.047008320689201355, 0.014101567678153515, 0.018391728401184082, 0.018596969544887543, -0.014832631684839725, 0.07952669262886047, -0.07223773747682571, -0.04765314236283302, 0.05239399895071983, -0.05193851888179779, 0.12680841982364655, -0.012561358511447906, -0.052271343767642975, -0.03153751790523529, 0.0022886197548359632, 0.0148441968485713, 0.017857741564512253, -0.015486766584217548, 0.01778530888259411, 0.050812773406505585, 0.022832175716757774, 0.022679807618260384, -0.043604347854852676, 0.00962100736796856, 0.059975363314151764, -0.07412219792604446, -0.03366284817457199, -0.015161127783358097, -0.06841596215963364, 0.03959961608052254, -0.0010765099432319403, 0.002704200567677617, -0.004095269832760096, 0.02325156331062317, -0.02216026932001114, -0.029989399015903473, -0.06786096841096878, -0.05175308138132095, 0.03315816447138786, -0.04793112352490425, 0.01259224209934473, 0.03247334063053131, -0.062383029609918594, -0.08699102699756622, -0.0998111292719841, -0.05053182318806648, -0.01413281261920929, 0.10877243429422379, 0.06500176340341568, 0.018694259226322174, 0.027226733043789864, 0.0219462551176548, -0.0204938855022192, -0.022007940337061882, -0.022539611905813217, -0.04717594012618065, -0.00953248143196106, -0.095878466963768, -0.023265143856406212, 0.07004763931035995, 0.011124728247523308, -0.06263907998800278, -0.05545945465564728, 0.06196405366063118, -0.08998668938875198, 0.04999832436442375, -0.03597280755639076, 0.0289032980799675, -0.03355002403259277, 0.029475141316652298, 0.06243879720568657, -0.06762108951807022, -0.0023256659042090178, -0.014215569011867046, -0.015716584399342537, 0.0071103922091424465, 0.0032907098066061735, 0.00844990462064743, 0.03737742453813553, 0.06805811822414398, -0.06165459379553795, 0.021502142772078514, 0.06506216526031494, -0.04932883381843567, -0.022241944447159767, 0.010824810713529587, 0.0336519218981266, 0.0561264343559742, 0.047922682017087936, -0.03251089155673981, 0.015618160367012024, 0.04077332094311714, 0.08513405174016953, 0.06675709784030914, -0.048551201820373535, 0.049241021275520325, -0.017641087993979454, -0.025825239717960358, -0.012937670573592186, -0.013960001990199089, 0.035932619124650955, 0.03793598338961601, 0.034800656139850616, 0.03748561441898346, 0.026237694546580315, -0.05642268434166908, 0.06441805511713028, 0.01626354455947876, 0.04407534375786781, -0.03971068561077118, 0.03457086160778999, 0.009488454088568687, 0.07670778036117554, 0.035125482827425, -0.028278302401304245, -0.00945376604795456, -0.006529763340950012, 0.0037199528887867928, -0.07946386188268661, -0.026939405128359795, -0.010804920457303524, 0.05723443627357483, 0.02929345704615116, 0.009671715088188648, 0.01970871351659298, 0.026732545346021652, -0.03869517520070076, -0.010806569829583168, 0.0675312727689743, 0.039850909262895584, -0.011050369590520859, 0.01708727516233921, 0.017722489312291145, -0.05275203287601471, 0.012477230280637741, 0.011772185564041138, 0.02247186191380024, 0.02565017342567444, -0.03401025012135506, -0.06943591684103012, 0.07155609130859375, 0.057289283722639084, -0.0002887891314458102, -0.010589826852083206, 0.002047027926892042, -0.01937139593064785, -0.06056440994143486, 0.023661768063902855, 0.043334830552339554, -0.018723446875810623, 0.056392934173345566, -0.053715649992227554, 0.007226640824228525, 0.04562325403094292, 0.009757147170603275, 0.0019066081149503589, -0.03368221968412399, -0.07130920886993408, -0.040805451571941376, 0.018930407240986824, -0.0017981315031647682, -0.017298223450779915, 0.08165548741817474, 0.08545640856027603, 0.002098070690408349, 0.03593062236905098, 0.005160871427506208, -0.0561472587287426, 0.004206749144941568, 0.03946688771247864, 0.023581253364682198, -0.01201128214597702, -0.012584653683006763, -0.08881381154060364, -0.003761307569220662, -0.026588300243020058, 0.014563016593456268, 0.02779400534927845, -0.04111694172024727, 0.02562234364449978, -0.010921109467744827, -0.025044698268175125, -0.017278192564845085, -0.029846642166376114, -0.02972937934100628, 0.007945137098431587, 0.05761520192027092, -0.0851074606180191, 0.04020427167415619, -0.034735824912786484, 0.017310358583927155, -0.02671203948557377, 0.051255952566862106, -0.07089944928884506, 0.008988281711935997, 0.03732788935303688, -0.049415282905101776, 0.07465234398841858, 0.0022239217069000006, -0.035586919635534286, 0.012201585806906223, -0.04287932068109512, 0.06721430271863937, -0.015300804749131203, -0.029293470084667206, 0.021180402487516403, 0.056877437978982925, 0.01782105676829815, -0.06717919558286667, -0.00489343935623765, 0.014859604649245739, 0.016812093555927277, 0.009324554353952408, 0.05207104980945587, 0.0063579692505300045, -0.0012874567182734609, -0.01512995921075344, 0.053073450922966, 0.09790501743555069, 0.019204074516892433, 0.04884980991482735, -0.0628587156534195, -0.022542132064700127, 0.07341820746660233, -0.04833250120282173, 0.03280562534928322 ]
70
70
Improving the Performance of PieceWise Linear Separation Incremental Algorithms for Practical Hardware Implementations
In this paper we shall review the common problems associated with Piecewise Linear Separation incremental algorithms. This kind of neural models yield poor performances when dealing with some classification problems, due to the evolving schemes used to construct the resulting networks. So as to avoid this undesirable behavior we shall propose a modification criterion. It is based upon the definition of a function which will provide information about the quality of the network growth process during the learning phase. This function is evaluated periodically as the network structure evolves, and will permit, as we shall show through exhaustive benchmarks, to considerably improve the performance(measured in terms of network complexity and generalization capabilities) offered by the networks generated by these incremental models.
[ -0.05883786454796791, -0.06952225416898727, -0.014840865507721901, 0.01901770569384098, 0.03560721501708031, -0.06641247123479843, 0.03386588394641876, -0.003536886302754283, -0.025428742170333862, 0.002378215081989765, -0.019113054499030113, 0.009998168796300888, -0.018161864951252937, 0.011044248938560486, -0.011489641852676868, 0.020114798098802567, -0.024585260078310966, -0.028331277891993523, 0.030529530718922615, -0.09095162153244019, -0.04106839373707771, -0.040537718683481216, 0.037352487444877625, -0.029123680666089058, 0.030437806621193886, 0.0015420709969475865, -0.005704205948859453, 0.010265066288411617, 0.06373800337314606, 0.04779398441314697, -0.043386902660131454, 0.007842261344194412, 0.001448242925107479, 0.020210959017276764, 0.028306040912866592, -0.0011587990447878838, 0.016656486317515373, -0.0030969225335866213, -0.03009928949177265, -0.007106935605406761, 0.006716148927807808, -0.04592821002006531, 0.04525846615433693, 0.004238400608301163, 0.05539528280496597, -0.028688941150903702, -0.013843514956533909, 0.0037036871071904898, -0.01737266406416893, 0.04937697574496269, -0.040071018040180206, 0.049860890954732895, 0.02967732399702072, -0.06522728502750397, -0.018331626430153847, 0.022480433806777, -0.1367749273777008, -0.044820379465818405, -0.059567347168922424, -0.015676528215408325, 0.03680478408932686, 0.053453247994184494, -0.007913677953183651, -0.007302389480173588, 0.015986189246177673, -0.039448969066143036, -0.029769370332360268, -0.016173021867871284, -0.04982362687587738, -0.08023952692747116, 0.043002787977457047, -0.03115043230354786, 0.029336370527744293, -0.0007170527242124081, -0.000020389325072756037, -0.04661364108324051, 0.051438190042972565, 0.03078593499958515, 0.011876647360622883, 0.021667789667844772, -0.043069977313280106, -0.019469240680336952, 0.03625158593058586, 0.010574903339147568, -0.0455038957297802, 0.0008866791031323373, 0.016819654032588005, -0.04148522764444351, 0.06237221509218216, -0.05395088344812393, -0.025057340040802956, 0.03490004315972328, -0.020403029397130013, -0.004898150451481342, -0.07661393284797668, -0.0007350790547206998, -0.03339793160557747, -0.00045612675603479147, 0.03379248455166817, 0.048364754766225815, 0.04878592863678932, 0.011294929310679436, 0.04863877594470978, 0.049033548682928085, -0.01182581577450037, 0.0072457450442016125, -0.04670824483036995, 0.008969898335635662, 0.03531667962670326, 0.05764540284872055, 0.06402843445539474, -0.054733697324991226, 0.005244620610028505, 0.023254727944731712, 0.007551044691354036, 0.07150684297084808, -0.027959827333688736, 0.07022731751203537, 0.022486183792352676, -0.012469402514398098, -0.018580617383122444, 0.04525155574083328, -0.04069126024842262, 0.03651314973831177, 0.012322659604251385, -0.024796390905976295, -0.013755746185779572, -0.04378870874643326, 0.07616760581731796, -0.046376507729291916, -0.059440068900585175, 0.08663462102413177, 0.006839565467089415, -0.06349338591098785, 0.015833621844649315, 0.08970935642719269, 0.08024176955223083, -0.08570323139429092, -0.012243722565472126, 0.0704745352268219, -0.029364287853240967, -0.024165010079741478, -0.0013678537216037512, -0.010177433490753174, 0.006117283832281828, 0.041745539754629135, 0.08430838584899902, 0.005787741392850876, 0.027133338153362274, 0.06380903720855713, 0.03323708474636078, -0.011800996959209442, 0.023923538625240326, -0.011921422556042671, 0.029894260689616203, 0.013032682240009308, 0.014216646552085876, -0.027674714103341103, 0.03613758087158203, 0.040380120277404785, -0.03143083304166794, -0.01742570288479328, 0.0011577625991776586, 0.05384474992752075, -0.051184333860874176, -0.08356739580631256, -0.002756008878350258, -0.029963316395878792, -0.08755487203598022, -0.05721266195178032, -0.02263275906443596, -0.0025968237314373255, -0.07203919440507889, 0.05406854674220085, 0.030278930440545082, 0.010309659875929356, 0.005159016698598862, -0.011895794421434402, -0.019672315567731857, -0.04464530199766159, 0.07376576215028763, -0.0074387891218066216, -0.0025277091190218925, 0.06596872955560684, 0.08159025013446808, 0.05059442296624184, -0.02797115035355091, 0.052772171795368195, 0.04176705703139305, 0.05690322816371918, 0.025106890127062798, 0.05035196617245674, -0.011919653043150902, 0.018921861425042152, -0.027688244357705116, 0.07387027889490128, -0.01838536560535431, -0.04839280992746353, 0.010491130873560905, 0.06911516934633255, 0.08349048346281052, -0.01796279288828373, -0.03471628203988075, -0.0660359188914299, -0.07105936110019684, 0.05985765904188156, 0.08077340573072433, -0.09132429957389832, -0.04107871279120445, -0.012984990142285824, 0.061986044049263, 0.062110692262649536, -0.02137964963912964, 0.03373806178569794, -0.0651116743683815, -0.03600095584988594, 0.00360884633846581, -0.016241051256656647, 0.05478263273835182, 0.057932838797569275, 0.03914312645792961, -0.01521356962621212, -0.01740901544690132, 0.05325621739029884, -0.03994746506214142, -0.022502416744828224, 0.032218050211668015, 0.0011981124989688396, -0.05528783053159714, 0.01827709935605526, -0.040780533105134964, 0.010058614425361156, -0.04788356274366379, -0.018426528200507164, -0.010278056375682354, 0.05264589935541153, -0.07549484074115753, -0.03535028174519539, -0.020735418424010277, -0.04415517672896385, -0.044756047427654266, 0.09093315154314041, -0.06197783723473549, -0.015868477523326874, 0.03497528284788132, -0.03817730396986008, 0.09470608830451965, 0.003803405910730362, -0.10859208554029465, -0.0467497780919075, 0.03422825038433075, 0.0397803969681263, -0.055235087871551514, -0.0011500929249450564, 0.027978481724858284, 0.014548877254128456, -0.05647941678762436, 0.03226374462246895, 0.01296956930309534, 0.05342332646250725, 0.04747931286692619, -0.008500101044774055, 0.01521238125860691, -0.025468237698078156, 0.002385983243584633, 0.03735923767089844, 0.01892029494047165, 0.03543108329176903, -0.009111665189266205, 0.05161449685692787, 0.08757687360048294, -0.039241109043359756, -0.004338308237493038, 0.13172389566898346, -0.01055360957980156, 0.0076391915790736675, 0.023393386974930763, -0.012261356227099895, 0.08110212534666061, 0.018790921196341515, 0.000868396193254739, 0.004118184559047222, -0.007042264100164175, 0.04794510826468468, -0.04479176923632622, 0.10101557523012161, -0.040752530097961426, -0.028743337839841843, 0.039651673287153244, -0.005180738400667906, -0.061119042336940765, 0.02982809767127037, -0.03387841582298279, -0.008576870895922184, 0.01275966688990593, -0.09272795170545578, 0.036109793931245804, 0.023433923721313477, -0.007241302635520697, -0.024262594059109688, 0.04318850487470627, -0.018401406705379486, 0.09851257503032684, -0.01920025795698166, -0.0306039247661829, 0.09811500459909439, -0.016254376620054245, 0.08912026137113571, -0.05350013077259064, 0.034827668219804764, 0.033895205706357956, -0.010099095292389393, -0.04216744750738144, -0.03586142137646675, -0.007831759750843048, 0.0033117260318249464, -0.04787110909819603, 0.014840836636722088, -0.08939576894044876, -0.06340345740318298, -0.0032565330620855093, 0.029693949967622757, 0.06300204247236252, -0.04813004285097122, -0.11350607872009277, -0.032978154718875885, 0.054359398782253265, 0.06415864080190659, -0.02673707902431488, 0.053714826703071594, -0.012510217726230621, -0.000015069196706463117, 0.01674933172762394, 0.04590298607945442, 0.009591327980160713, 0.011475807055830956, 0.0026276945136487484, -0.004881987348198891, -0.00020722171757370234, 0.04914103075861931, -0.01000726968050003, -0.05210166797041893, 0.03856153041124344, -0.0519704669713974, 0.02164141833782196, 0.05057629570364952, 0.0263797827064991, -0.0349600724875927, -0.02667267434298992, 0.09051963686943054, -0.008983590640127659, -0.006501872092485428, -0.04898088425397873, -0.005852789618074894, -0.008287329226732254, 0.05078195035457611, 0.05508987978100777, -0.0008959791739471257, 0.03372376784682274, 0.05633092671632767, 0.0013104698155075312, 0.020231151953339577, -0.018375292420387268, -0.10337739437818527, -0.002802357543259859, 0.05738258361816406, 0.0006818642723374069, -0.006493500433862209, 0.0014041831018403172, -0.03595850616693497, 0.005913174711167812, -0.030671924352645874, 0.07027117162942886, 0.04184532165527344, 0.03732224181294441, -0.08772464841604233, 0.05512700974941254, -0.06438534706830978, -0.05060712993144989, 0.07801523059606552, -0.07356085628271103, -0.0031168931163847446, -0.031002091243863106, 0.03260628506541252, 0.053756143897771835, -0.035742174834012985, -0.0032719126902520657, 0.06395304948091507, 0.049927085638046265, -0.048944856971502304, -0.03145146742463112, -0.05331873893737793, -0.07259087264537811, 0.09264445304870605, 0.042204633355140686, 0.004904024302959442, 0.015915798023343086, 0.018772799521684647, -0.05418272688984871, 0.05568104609847069, -0.018655572086572647, -0.05903508886694908, -0.015277383849024773, 0.0020213653333485126, -0.13465894758701324, -0.0648653507232666, -0.04312383010983467, 0.057831667363643646, 0.06255574524402618, 0.0527007058262825, -0.017916815355420113, -0.018506675958633423, 0.019115181639790535, -0.011422937735915184, -0.0001215797892655246, -0.0018895097309723496, 0.013715678825974464, 0.0289051104336977, -0.05723317340016365, -0.08892181515693665, 0.021566517651081085, -0.01095204520970583, 0.01791331171989441, -0.0141981840133667, -0.00469315005466342, -0.04350903630256653, 0.004454108886420727, 0.03887024149298668, -0.007697611581534147, 0.01443349476903677, -0.11618687957525253, 0.09230515360832214, -0.06212723255157471, -0.008464203216135502, -0.0055359783582389355, -0.05608440190553665, 0.0413832888007164, -0.009915737435221672, -0.030895283445715904, -0.05748974159359932, -0.018900904804468155, -0.005285953171551228, 0.011990544386208057, 0.014343217015266418, -0.007893134839832783, 0.009685441851615906, 0.060642607510089874, 0.023783352226018906, 0.05254053324460983, -0.0024932229425758123, -0.02674023248255253, -0.005808844696730375, 0.0012516715796664357, -0.020363211631774902, -0.053298451006412506, 0.017030352726578712, 0.04045023024082184, 0.008452360518276691, 0.047506701201200485, -0.07121175527572632, -0.03688691928982735, -0.02995060570538044, 0.047931987792253494, -0.02482607029378414, -0.08292810618877411, -0.07389295101165771, 0.05643168464303017, -0.027739467099308968, 0.019096624106168747, 0.07853935658931732, -0.06694871932268143, -0.0012951138196513057, -0.0007076716283336282, -0.03831764683127403, -0.05668378248810768, -0.000007224032742669806, -0.0035282173193991184, -0.09652252495288849, -0.037439215928316116, 0.018228892236948013, 0.07646641880273819, -0.027442464604973793, -0.012788779102265835, 0.1223793774843216, 0.005820801481604576, -0.06911546736955643, -0.04497920349240303, 0.011465160176157951, 0.0024266212712973356, -0.017270933836698532, 0.06233818829059601, -0.01772184856235981, 0.028008073568344116, 0.00037321916897781193, -0.009342706762254238, -0.0459413155913353, 0.025725090876221657, -0.051790956407785416, 0.03415074199438095, 0.041033368557691574, 0.06422092020511627, 0.019553346559405327, 0.0413760170340538, -0.008972004987299442, -0.008609035052359104, 0.05546347796916962, -0.016153423115611076, 0.029787082225084305, 0.023067086935043335, -0.03292987495660782, 0.03638654574751854, 0.0012026461772620678 ]
71
71
Improved Collaborative Filtering Algorithm via Information Transformation
In this paper, we propose a spreading activation approach for collaborative filtering (SA-CF). By using the opinion spreading process, the similarity between any users can be obtained. The algorithm has remarkably higher accuracy than the standard collaborative filtering (CF) using Pearson correlation. Furthermore, we introduce a free parameter $\beta$ to regulate the contributions of objects to user-user correlations. The numerical results indicate that decreasing the influence of popular objects can further improve the algorithmic accuracy and personality. We argue that a better algorithm should simultaneously require less computation and generate higher accuracy. Accordingly, we further propose an algorithm involving only the top-$N$ similar neighbors for each target user, which has both less computational complexity and higher algorithmic accuracy.
[ 0.024101141840219498, -0.04285338521003723, -0.03126246854662895, 0.0028043778147548437, -0.006601494271308184, -0.04156138747930527, -0.03736894577741623, -0.013286280445754528, -0.042422764003276825, 0.007797985803335905, 0.03767166659235954, -0.028762120753526688, 0.02470187097787857, 0.04479006305336952, -0.012346284464001656, -0.03081965632736683, -0.014957070350646973, 0.020309146493673325, 0.060045041143894196, -0.04233013093471527, 0.005495020188391209, -0.06657416373491287, -0.012275299988687038, -0.07615146040916443, -0.0020913679618388414, -0.0009462589514441788, -0.05191929265856743, 0.020458372309803963, 0.048437099903821945, 0.024450503289699554, 0.011461461894214153, -0.04176536947488785, 0.03360898420214653, 0.06535685807466507, 0.018447019159793854, -0.07395464181900024, 0.008806088007986546, -0.020274892449378967, 0.050109218806028366, -0.003718235529959202, -0.007563383784145117, -0.04552769288420677, 0.03068649023771286, -0.011374390684068203, 0.057063840329647064, -0.0009643668890930712, 0.012718590907752514, 0.07403942942619324, 0.004000399261713028, 0.04635346680879593, -0.10100596398115158, -0.07359849661588669, 0.006044657435268164, 0.04002885892987251, 0.030930569395422935, 0.022272679954767227, -0.020385615527629852, 0.03560603782534599, 0.08324898779392242, 0.03247895464301109, 0.02886061929166317, 0.147688090801239, -0.051709435880184174, -0.020946986973285675, -0.055318739265203476, -0.05611872673034668, 0.004229304380714893, -0.017618540674448013, -0.049724943935871124, -0.027865886688232422, 0.012817752547562122, -0.02523624897003174, -0.029193026944994926, 0.024353325366973877, 0.06615359336137772, -0.0001653272775001824, -0.04269653558731079, 0.058772940188646317, 0.020929953083395958, 0.10337961465120316, -0.06161322817206383, 0.04283034801483154, 0.012818574905395508, -0.0059395525604486465, -0.03724147379398346, -0.04572577401995659, 0.0027165946085006, -0.01452089287340641, 0.021523769944906235, 0.05943060666322708, 0.014654755592346191, 0.030777525156736374, -0.09151484817266464, 0.01839156076312065, -0.06859505921602249, -0.09122508764266968, 0.0013099757488816977, 0.10403401404619217, 0.08423777669668198, 0.015008745715022087, -0.02062019519507885, -0.035401828587055206, 0.08428528159856796, 0.042224958539009094, -0.011942384764552116, 0.05766900256276131, -0.022091764956712723, 0.05179214105010033, 0.01326096709817648, -0.007695202250033617, 0.03150632604956627, -0.002958691446110606, -0.06691475212574005, 0.047346584498882294, -0.028728941455483437, 0.09585118293762207, -0.04810184985399246, 0.08916888386011124, -0.02609795704483986, -0.021565282717347145, 0.009263281710445881, 0.007711191661655903, -0.08699881285429001, -0.03138546645641327, -0.04763082414865494, 0.005843852646648884, -0.039740171283483505, 0.015354884788393974, 0.027381781488656998, 0.010436438955366611, -0.09015501290559769, 0.092185378074646, -0.08826594799757004, -0.0059092785231769085, -0.02805425599217415, -0.01667901501059532, 0.008871805854141712, -0.028809156268835068, -0.05810577794909477, 0.068516306579113, 0.002187274396419525, 0.01604689657688141, -0.015897994861006737, 0.012475751340389252, 0.08168120682239532, -0.04278591647744179, 0.031053775921463966, 0.029532091692090034, 0.02436220459640026, -0.02234862931072712, -0.019269807264208794, -0.013910732232034206, -0.0067234281450510025, 0.06007964536547661, -0.012227296829223633, -0.05253954604268074, -0.07641720026731491, -0.05673341825604439, -0.016771167516708374, 0.0213312990963459, -0.0002506783639546484, 0.018444854766130447, 0.06396564096212387, -0.05366453900933266, 0.019198570400476456, 0.016590764746069908, -0.0636654794216156, 0.017116880044341087, 0.022510208189487457, -0.019533414393663406, -0.01208899449557066, 0.01686728373169899, -0.05820450931787491, -0.015312191098928452, 0.03676822781562805, -0.049170151352882385, -0.01854567788541317, -0.047615353018045425, -0.004685310646891594, -0.06284733861684799, 0.030756110325455666, 0.002123785438016057, -0.0019669311586767435, 0.017197035253047943, 0.01156584732234478, 0.06363435089588165, 0.013520914129912853, 0.006466463208198547, 0.05391881242394447, -0.00727839907631278, 0.06572925299406052, 0.025222530588507652, -0.006787145975977182, -0.002666742540895939, -0.040033239871263504, -0.01471556443721056, 0.05976809561252594, -0.1085464134812355, 0.011104963719844818, 0.0568842738866806, 0.008862470276653767, -0.03574615344405174, -0.10492254048585892, -0.04856717586517334, -0.04801805689930916, -0.01696625165641308, -0.04778437688946724, -0.06837514787912369, -0.048135560005903244, -0.007554390002042055, 0.046106014400720596, 0.04724592715501785, 0.035916540771722794, -0.010576881468296051, -0.0199552271515131, 0.04988643899559975, -0.04751911759376526, -0.03796074539422989, 0.05459634214639664, 0.11699974536895752, -0.02346392348408699, 0.03810318559408188, -0.012935618869960308, 0.07471314817667007, -0.029107537120580673, 0.014278154820203781, -0.0170600488781929, 0.00494845537468791, -0.0656670555472374, 0.03917345777153969, -0.06660516560077667, -0.04654615372419357, -0.05792832002043724, -0.015923475846648216, 0.027838092297315598, 0.028137067332863808, -0.07674942165613174, -0.020280100405216217, -0.01581469550728798, -0.019015483558177948, -0.009133993647992611, 0.02991826832294464, 0.0026227969210594893, 0.03705912455916405, 0.025882568210363388, -0.07930143177509308, 0.014759325422346592, 0.02255122736096382, -0.056102048605680466, 0.03716309741139412, 0.012098132632672787, -0.05084741488099098, -0.01610599085688591, 0.027663910761475563, 0.043438930064439774, 0.07501938939094543, -0.012752106413245201, 0.022344881668686867, 0.06453287601470947, 0.03472228720784187, 0.013584477826952934, 0.03762037679553032, 0.028440816327929497, 0.019496215507388115, -0.012927996926009655, 0.00011296623415546492, 0.05563797429203987, 0.04896879568696022, 0.02330932579934597, 0.003365880809724331, 0.03960471972823143, -0.11070425808429718, -0.006430809386074543, 0.08084920048713684, -0.040411327034235, 0.00048634043196216226, 0.03367915749549866, 0.04841722920536995, 0.010275284759700298, -0.09153677523136139, -0.040805645287036896, -0.012940878048539162, -0.012302531860768795, 0.016860846430063248, 0.015488455072045326, -0.015151550993323326, -0.028100917115807533, -0.02481827512383461, -0.02996993064880371, 0.006572455167770386, -0.10970796644687653, 0.07736346870660782, -0.023546544834971428, 0.06070265546441078, 0.012794477865099907, -0.11284931749105453, -0.015997888520359993, 0.02017570286989212, 0.09580674767494202, 0.005792701616883278, -0.01666577346622944, 0.02331721968948841, 0.028863845393061638, 0.03207504004240036, 0.055259328335523605, 0.063520647585392, 0.024822821840643883, 0.05536498874425888, -0.020592832937836647, -0.028316937386989594, 0.015475155785679817, 0.04774301499128342, -0.05129685997962952, -0.06400324404239655, 0.004902046173810959, 0.048365265130996704, -0.0030042200814932585, -0.028115928173065186, -0.077370785176754, 0.02380024641752243, -0.0029331715777516365, -0.054959725588560104, 0.05649663507938385, 0.019252583384513855, -0.06156649813055992, -0.0334792286157608, -0.002445942023769021, 0.03605335205793381, -0.061110418289899826, 0.03529394045472145, -0.12255799025297165, 0.01814834401011467, -0.08740667253732681, 0.04544086009263992, -0.049412041902542114, -0.030712513253092766, -0.10006088018417358, -0.06797672808170319, -0.0070689707063138485, -0.05049968138337135, 0.016130125150084496, -0.03950701281428337, 0.032021693885326385, 0.009780407883226871, 0.05149019882082939, 0.015958912670612335, 0.10184511542320251, 0.004136878531426191, -0.034924160689115524, -0.005153701640665531, -0.03849055618047714, 0.08322777599096298, -0.008785681799054146, -0.06711360067129135, -0.009137521497905254, 0.0807466059923172, 0.0687345638871193, 0.027959998697042465, 0.006724850740283728, -0.04984563961625099, 0.006409935187548399, 0.01104113832116127, -0.017431657761335373, -0.0082391994073987, 0.052658017724752426, 0.06614933907985687, -0.02773679420351982, 0.00567649956792593, -0.06771188229322433, -0.0017763124778866768, 0.05665018409490585, 0.05777164548635483, 0.05387451872229576, -0.032247599214315414, 0.007647250778973103, -0.04000511392951012, 0.03962796926498413, -0.04853292927145958, 0.002929997630417347, 0.10206011682748795, 0.030209379270672798, -0.022992724552750587, -0.052094269543886185, -0.07348071783781052, -0.012487133033573627, -0.024463104084134102, -0.024845197796821594, -0.012710564769804478, -0.004649666603654623, 0.07071308046579361, 0.01276631560176611, -0.07927762717008591, 0.03825516998767853, 0.01419718749821186, -0.0042031751945614815, 0.02366325631737709, 0.05897749960422516, -0.06032887101173401, -0.05266938731074333, 0.04271818324923515, -0.029471727088093758, -0.021112337708473206, -0.05312775820493698, -0.0012599235633388162, -0.07341200113296509, 0.005588964559137821, 0.04113376885652542, 0.06583254784345627, 0.027634503319859505, 0.01705033890902996, -0.003007114864885807, -0.02721136063337326, -0.017917506396770477, 0.03549053892493248, -0.006556381471455097, -0.014742138795554638, -0.0560290664434433, -0.08441490679979324, -0.024794265627861023, -0.03072793409228325, -0.03621139004826546, 0.04254227504134178, -0.014445324428379536, 0.03093910589814186, 0.017857640981674194, 0.052673641592264175, 0.05897819623351097, -0.018705036491155624, 0.01372403185814619, 0.02944336272776127, 0.020702505484223366, -0.03538590669631958, 0.023488158360123634, -0.007605411112308502, -0.01291760616004467, -0.010692515410482883, 0.05753069370985031, -0.003499526996165514, 0.033111684024333954, -0.0021501057781279087, 0.008373080752789974, -0.004613323602825403, -0.019098037853837013, -0.008247348479926586, 0.06874101608991623, -0.005856672767549753, 0.0199104193598032, 0.004141591489315033, 0.08572926372289658, 0.045013636350631714, -0.02254902943968773, -0.07700524479150772, -0.008834155276417732, -0.024658912792801857, -0.15196524560451508, 0.039436206221580505, 0.04147426038980484, -0.03915124386548996, 0.05568893626332283, -0.07136084884405136, -0.010893130674958229, 0.007511232513934374, -0.015026758424937725, 0.029853014275431633, -0.009454256854951382, 0.014423239976167679, -0.007153545971959829, -0.0033625271171331406, 0.044847264885902405, 0.019505901262164116, -0.04377337917685509, 0.0696299597620964, 0.006680463906377554, -0.07570696622133255, -0.008954375050961971, 0.03271869942545891, 0.020588664337992668, -0.006509674247354269, -0.04594353586435318, -0.05362614989280701, 0.029321961104869843, -0.016126364469528198, -0.03613753616809845, -0.011095017194747925, 0.025866977870464325, 0.009510336443781853, 0.0019731188658624887, 0.09456324577331543, 0.0056009492836892605, 0.015384146012365818, 0.015473539009690285, -0.008125442080199718, -0.0513424389064312, -0.008311777375638485, 0.046593841165304184, -0.004441822879016399, 0.019008103758096695, 0.02431437373161316, 0.0235820971429348, -0.007596112787723541, -0.02960297279059887, -0.06274764239788055, 0.03372516855597496, 0.03446501865983009, -0.003297386923804879, 0.0596502386033535, 0.006012921221554279, 0.03213442862033844, -0.014991643838584423, -0.03452455624938011, -0.09256438165903091, 0.005092512350529432 ]
72
72
Online EM Algorithm for Latent Data Models
In this contribution, we propose a generic online (also sometimes called adaptive or recursive) version of the Expectation-Maximisation (EM) algorithm applicable to latent variable models of independent observations. Compared to the algorithm of Titterington (1984), this approach is more directly connected to the usual EM algorithm and does not rely on integration with respect to the complete data distribution. The resulting algorithm is usually simpler and is shown to achieve convergence to the stationary points of the Kullback-Leibler divergence between the marginal distribution of the observation and the model distribution at the optimal rate, i.e., that of the maximum likelihood estimator. In addition, the proposed approach is also suitable for conditional (or regression) models, as illustrated in the case of the mixture of linear regressions model.
[ -0.044457655400037766, -0.13660404086112976, -0.007728985045105219, -0.03721681982278824, 0.07163182646036148, -0.05206035077571869, 0.06668677181005478, 0.04617012292146683, -0.027750201523303986, 0.016315843909978867, 0.018946848809719086, 0.00797062274068594, 0.003485312918201089, 0.03218403086066246, 0.05473276600241661, -0.01195849571377039, 0.013795777224004269, 0.025024903938174248, -0.010095171630382538, -0.015393400564789772, 0.009193946607410908, -0.033429473638534546, 0.014079778455197811, -0.03746318072080612, 0.0010381145402789116, 0.002456492045894265, -0.016445452347397804, -0.02214016765356064, -0.03106735087931156, -0.003454177873209119, -0.09224429726600647, 0.021059593185782433, -0.021535346284508705, 0.026815446093678474, 0.015124375000596046, -0.03432534262537956, 0.04163215681910515, 0.0031589430291205645, -0.06766612827777863, -0.023419512435793877, 0.04083845019340515, 0.025217842310667038, -0.06180674210190773, -0.032967567443847656, 0.05900551751255989, 0.013557130470871925, 0.055670786648988724, 0.07252626866102219, -0.027476279065012932, 0.06199120357632637, -0.05421152710914612, 0.0029643126763403416, -0.0654509961605072, -0.046118300408124924, 0.021056344732642174, 0.02949575148522854, -0.022908125072717667, 0.05775371938943863, -0.03388204425573349, -0.09050552546977997, 0.044808052480220795, 0.0931062251329422, -0.010780669748783112, -0.006106531713157892, -0.05094463378190994, 0.046387795358896255, -0.04087508097290993, -0.011356966570019722, 0.016414053738117218, -0.047875285148620605, -0.017635801807045937, -0.03077862225472927, 0.02421974390745163, 0.018789084628224373, 0.05317041650414467, 0.000999815994873643, -0.032930899411439896, -0.04092353582382202, 0.021297777071595192, 0.0026569648180156946, -0.027496010065078735, -0.013576881028711796, -0.043009571731090546, 0.054735973477363586, 0.023787925019860268, 0.05077692121267319, -0.009718884713947773, 0.0049283429980278015, -0.07188871502876282, -0.09004760533571243, -0.024480700492858887, 0.01188786793500185, -0.05602613836526871, 0.03502274304628372, -0.021632926538586617, 0.06537166237831116, -0.03327518701553345, 0.03145989403128624, -0.020769933238625526, -0.013335507363080978, 0.033459726721048355, 0.009833590127527714, 0.07738387584686279, 0.03245004266500473, 0.0325968861579895, -0.01082646008580923, -0.054143477231264114, 0.03600486367940903, 0.07843339443206787, 0.005224518943578005, 0.020044201985001564, -0.00540597178041935, 0.06569650769233704, 0.009852642193436623, -0.02473154291510582, 0.039074432104825974, -0.011977034620940685, 0.07964454591274261, 0.034383270889520645, 0.07589569687843323, 0.043751928955316544, -0.011443478986620903, -0.031923893839120865, -0.014127897098660469, 0.06733676791191101, 0.0031519606709480286, -0.04006734490394592, -0.013930165208876133, 0.09328880161046982, -0.06414330005645752, 0.022869931533932686, -0.018449028953909874, -0.022547826170921326, -0.032778460532426834, -0.0906471535563469, -0.004602254368364811, -0.024384643882513046, 0.007871339097619057, -0.020438184961676598, 0.042942747473716736, 0.010219232179224491, 0.028135530650615692, -0.04925745353102684, 0.006660258863121271, 0.01325180009007454, -0.03196125850081444, 0.011928651481866837, -0.01136909518390894, -0.025925885885953903, -0.03475884720683098, -0.07416843622922897, -0.002697113435715437, -0.02951570227742195, 0.002349483547732234, 0.017448367550969124, -0.1059831753373146, -0.07031182944774628, 0.052984386682510376, 0.027087075635790825, 0.059764713048934937, -0.015213759616017342, 0.08153136074542999, 0.013218114152550697, -0.010875886306166649, -0.021760208532214165, 0.019208963960409164, 0.009196951985359192, -0.022705037146806717, 0.009174025617539883, -0.12302489578723907, -0.028688522055745125, -0.019203724339604378, 0.03396041691303253, -0.006915256846696138, 0.020385168492794037, 0.00792298000305891, -0.01564149186015129, -0.00963110662996769, -0.058876313269138336, 0.04486020654439926, 0.040886618196964264, -0.0479961633682251, -0.006418490316718817, -0.023318029940128326, 0.10729989409446716, 0.041875287890434265, 0.0033584339544177055, 0.06724211573600769, 0.03948089852929115, 0.03265998139977455, 0.0625067874789238, 0.006431040354073048, 0.012271517887711525, -0.033007483929395676, -0.024397848173975945, 0.027553942054510117, -0.04122639074921608, 0.06425593793392181, 0.04203446954488754, -0.005241015460342169, -0.011007419787347317, 0.010931488126516342, 0.010315018706023693, -0.06996295601129532, -0.09093151986598969, 0.12212353944778442, -0.00910672452300787, -0.030280232429504395, 0.04905072599649429, -0.007458249107003212, 0.010604804381728172, 0.01851714216172695, -0.031843725591897964, -0.0935707837343216, 0.04065662994980812, -0.09642177075147629, -0.05553288757801056, 0.01845824159681797, -0.01395118422806263, 0.01229125540703535, -0.024672778323292732, 0.03913081809878349, -0.05581265315413475, 0.08249152451753616, -0.033765215426683426, -0.028520463034510612, 0.026091713458299637, -0.0013031382113695145, -0.0683475062251091, 0.042767833918333054, -0.021673692390322685, -0.06877662986516953, -0.0829198807477951, -0.05087434872984886, -0.1036546602845192, -0.032507721334695816, -0.06654856353998184, -0.05184256285429001, 0.05176214873790741, -0.03600640594959259, -0.014234067872166634, 0.052375663071870804, 0.0878797397017479, 0.007046325132250786, -0.01506519503891468, 0.017541004344820976, 0.002129065105691552, -0.00007194703357527032, -0.11440179497003555, 0.036399707198143005, 0.06592856347560883, 0.041497811675071716, -0.030237829312682152, -0.012404276058077812, 0.012526614591479301, 0.03795180097222328, -0.05246987193822861, 0.13534857332706451, 0.014732052572071552, 0.10463730990886688, 0.046045105904340744, 0.027667904272675514, -0.04570708051323891, -0.03185131028294563, 0.08188717067241669, 0.006390715949237347, 0.011954732239246368, 0.025142773985862732, 0.05903332307934761, -0.009124282747507095, -0.04186204448342323, -0.029841499403119087, -0.1024806946516037, 0.035564929246902466, -0.03759708255529404, 0.00944413710385561, 0.006502243690192699, 0.018613673746585846, 0.031316906213760376, -0.03550334274768829, -0.0812235176563263, 0.014557029120624065, -0.020203640684485435, -0.04398258030414581, -0.013671319000422955, 0.021586665883660316, 0.006761719938367605, 0.00034343585139140487, -0.032518643885850906, 0.018484219908714294, -0.019224125891923904, 0.04539082944393158, 0.009560532867908478, 0.01711462251842022, -0.017543062567710876, -0.019431425258517265, 0.028277942910790443, 0.015090440399944782, -0.0002814943727571517, 0.027289267629384995, 0.01851744018495083, -0.01523594930768013, 0.08048335462808609, 0.019627733156085014, -0.03200006112456322, 0.0624811016023159, 0.027606191113591194, 0.08959100395441055, -0.05081266164779663, -0.008150525391101837, 0.023074202239513397, -0.04146017134189606, -0.005319596268236637, 0.01670428179204464, 0.023226264864206314, -0.024878783151507378, -0.06873548775911331, -0.04889492690563202, -0.030035872012376785, -0.022255925461649895, 0.03517555817961693, 0.005210385657846928, 0.04673925042152405, -0.010235229507088661, -0.06046729162335396, -0.023062782362103462, 0.006107470486313105, 0.021894946694374084, -0.015464520081877708, 0.015468030236661434, -0.02391694486141205, 0.0021414379589259624, -0.06722135096788406, 0.030525466427206993, -0.015060171484947205, 0.007941434159874916, -0.04229021817445755, -0.024309756234288216, 0.10713102668523788, 0.03810512647032738, -0.021984193474054337, -0.025811143219470978, -0.0490146242082119, -0.017651593312621117, 0.03083626925945282, 0.08578693121671677, 0.0909419134259224, 0.016341956332325935, 0.00266616465523839, 0.07297750562429428, -0.025801125913858414, 0.01550404541194439, -0.08829754590988159, -0.022667381912469864, -0.037629444152116776, 0.005984766408801079, 0.10518778860569, 0.01810644194483757, 0.026473794132471085, 0.012569342739880085, -0.0551137775182724, 0.017834588885307312, 0.007311203517019749, -0.07783574610948563, 0.07946786284446716, 0.03622589632868767, 0.023280713707208633, -0.0021373252384364605, 0.02156422659754753, -0.03095151111483574, -0.044222623109817505, 0.01689504086971283, 0.07292761653661728, 0.0008548255427740514, 0.05140182748436928, 0.03168566897511482, 0.06807957589626312, 0.020439492538571358, -0.016524018719792366, 0.043726928532123566, -0.10429242998361588, -0.08175922930240631, -0.018645063042640686, -0.035443246364593506, -0.007674910128116608, -0.04317927733063698, -0.016004174947738647, -0.0379379503428936, 0.023976009339094162, -0.0550491139292717, -0.052990008145570755, -0.004207844380289316, 0.05309154465794563, 0.05595572292804718, -0.022000016644597054, 0.05740157887339592, 0.022966520860791206, -0.011112766340374947, -0.06801553815603256, -0.03489139676094055, -0.03970983996987343, 0.05285558104515076, 0.07762879878282547, -0.06400249153375626, 0.021001888439059258, -0.04415198788046837, -0.007756222505122423, 0.008037522435188293, -0.008266926743090153, 0.05385211482644081, 0.008132187649607658, 0.0341167189180851, -0.04869581386446953, 0.0324881337583065, 0.008595609106123447, 0.02394108660519123, 0.0452876053750515, 0.04305325448513031, 0.00521222734823823, -0.11744314432144165, -0.023483172059059143, 0.05778872221708298, 0.007873466238379478, 0.03695988655090332, -0.019793253391981125, 0.04978761821985245, 0.013642477802932262, 0.05590750649571419, 0.00483342818915844, 0.041355255991220474, -0.09454655647277832, 0.008613022975623608, 0.0060026864521205425, -0.012502867728471756, 0.0008165081962943077, 0.015283708460628986, 0.008464877493679523, -0.012511354871094227, 0.03353571146726608, 0.05389003828167915, 0.056493282318115234, 0.06923209875822067, -0.029399117454886436, 0.0313023142516613, -0.030427729710936546, 0.09530344605445862, -0.03570503741502762, 0.004124599043279886, 0.05405699089169502, 0.04751679301261902, 0.10364080965518951, 0.008349437266588211, 0.05006872117519379, -0.004964624531567097, -0.004102618899196386, 0.010742704384028912, -0.007619740441441536, -0.020910760387778282, 0.05600319802761078, -0.0700746402144432, -0.05265426263213158, -0.04858096316456795, -0.021176394075155258, -0.01889299787580967, -0.06949006021022797, -0.026347950100898743, -0.007519202772527933, 0.02690086141228676, 0.024434400722384453, 0.0820469930768013, -0.057707466185092926, 0.02797595225274563, 0.03146263584494591, -0.03932322934269905, -0.033147264271974564, -0.02361265942454338, 0.029379786923527718, 0.011647949926555157, 0.005728781223297119, 0.013986791484057903, 0.045904599130153656, 0.06822483986616135, -0.014347107149660587, 0.058355096727609634, 0.011365284211933613, 0.04510880634188652, 0.05591324344277382, 0.027935104444622993, 0.039829738438129425, 0.007282728794962168, 0.0631832405924797, -0.006965862587094307, -0.020239805802702904, 0.019076721742749214, -0.07096689194440842, 0.05497259646654129, -0.0022597212810069323, -0.005500968545675278, 0.01911328174173832, 0.05828074365854263, 0.014366177842020988, -0.06752382218837738, 0.04121243953704834, -0.013195705600082874, 0.038860294967889786, 0.025171831250190735, -0.021847641095519066, 0.029591526836156845, -0.08325793594121933, 0.07423608005046844, -0.022708598524332047, -0.02071448415517807 ]
73
73
Staring at Economic Aggregators through Information Lenses
It is hard to exaggerate the role of economic aggregators -- functions that summarize numerous and / or heterogeneous data -- in economic models since the early XX$^{th}$ century. In many cases, as witnessed by the pioneering works of Cobb and Douglas, these functions were information quantities tailored to economic theories, i.e. they were built to fit economic phenomena. In this paper, we look at these functions from the complementary side: information. We use a recent toolbox built on top of a vast class of distortions coined by Bregman, whose application field rivals metrics' in various subfields of mathematics. This toolbox makes it possible to find the quality of an aggregator (for consumptions, prices, labor, capital, wages, etc.), from the standpoint of the information it carries. We prove a rather striking result. From the informational standpoint, well-known economic aggregators do belong to the \textit{optimal} set. As common economic assumptions enter the analysis, this large set shrinks, and it essentially ends up \textit{exactly fitting} either CES, or Cobb-Douglas, or both. To summarize, in the relevant economic contexts, one could not have crafted better some aggregator from the information standpoint. We also discuss global economic behaviors of optimal information aggregators in general, and present a brief panorama of the links between economic and information aggregators. Keywords: Economic Aggregators, CES, Cobb-Douglas, Bregman divergences
[ -0.027739986777305603, -0.0639771968126297, -0.03050532564520836, 0.03559666499495506, 0.10105521976947784, -0.02752278931438923, -0.0403730645775795, -0.030428072437644005, -0.018137751147150993, -0.005113419611006975, 0.061448775231838226, -0.015916036441922188, -0.0511857308447361, 0.03512699529528618, 0.10541607439517975, -0.03062479756772518, 0.01095229759812355, -0.014777358621358871, 0.02864471636712551, -0.00787297822535038, -0.004647185560315847, 0.07672128826379776, 0.01231924444437027, 0.012028458528220654, -0.013491863384842873, -0.03780004382133484, -0.026534967124462128, 0.003643390955403447, -0.03916618227958679, 0.015373495407402515, -0.06893216818571091, 0.006749036256223917, 0.043443817645311356, -0.05878071114420891, 0.004954361356794834, -0.025850875303149223, -0.004195232409983873, 0.023063480854034424, -0.04005129262804985, -0.027687540277838707, 0.06607219576835632, -0.046322669833898544, -0.01100021693855524, -0.03288286551833153, 0.02124798111617565, -0.004611562937498093, 0.0820562019944191, 0.011147039011120796, 0.008659366518259048, 0.05650841444730759, -0.05100240558385849, -0.012475504539906979, -0.04325494542717934, -0.008045082911849022, -0.015323496423661709, 0.12166084349155426, 0.03380779176950455, 0.030808454379439354, 0.01377535704523325, 0.02135601080954075, 0.0688561350107193, 0.06507039815187454, -0.0504891611635685, 0.004640024155378342, -0.0182332843542099, -0.008419682271778584, -0.11510364711284637, 0.01024951133877039, -0.006519791204482317, -0.026222510263323784, 0.013160733506083488, 0.02392962947487831, 0.004098991863429546, -0.020406901836395264, 0.009209087118506432, -0.04168761521577835, -0.02458946593105793, 0.009797198697924614, -0.07999565452337265, 0.06760861724615097, -0.14181417226791382, 0.037398114800453186, -0.0026509978342801332, 0.026761963963508606, -0.021607251837849617, -0.007538324687629938, 0.024872630834579468, -0.0168131235986948, -0.0169416144490242, -0.03853394463658333, 0.005866630934178829, -0.04434777423739433, -0.09318462759256363, 0.014729705639183521, -0.033910103142261505, 0.06376578658819199, -0.07679219543933868, -0.0023392520379275084, 0.04654422029852867, -0.07016762346029282, 0.027365610003471375, 0.0037929913960397243, 0.03392129763960838, 0.042541954666376114, -0.06509266793727875, 0.005486213602125645, -0.04094620421528816, 0.05999703332781792, -0.013315072283148766, -0.021389802917838097, 0.04836225137114525, 0.03938401862978935, -0.06052020564675331, 0.01856912672519684, -0.02400193177163601, 0.04242682084441185, -0.055198244750499725, 0.06452102214097977, -0.016923584043979645, -0.029454251751303673, -0.011156036518514156, 0.003480274463072419, 0.04011319577693939, 0.05099903419613838, 0.06928449124097824, -0.003095324384048581, -0.01031723152846098, -0.0007167408475652337, 0.07890951633453369, 0.055119745433330536, -0.02121071331202984, -0.003978129476308823, 0.015606420114636421, -0.0035542792174965143, -0.044311027973890305, 0.08064980059862137, 0.06462596356868744, -0.06350866705179214, 0.004483608063310385, -0.00028701775590889156, -0.002344804350286722, 0.020856283605098724, 0.03733362630009651, 0.004253314808011055, 0.00882609561085701, 0.09683233499526978, 0.025504181161522865, 0.00043649532017298043, -0.06203499436378479, -0.031472500413656235, 0.008207224309444427, 0.0674499124288559, 0.0053517515771090984, 0.050075653940439224, 0.0005927914753556252, 0.008187259547412395, -0.03324787691235542, 0.022366534918546677, -0.04296432435512543, 0.0187978632748127, -0.0349217988550663, -0.025474926456809044, 0.1139560118317604, -0.014938682317733765, -0.007390090264379978, -0.012513848952949047, 0.004467427264899015, -0.04213390126824379, -0.04829347878694534, -0.0857849195599556, -0.09883938729763031, -0.027253776788711548, 0.007686366327106953, 0.03544749692082405, 0.051520563662052155, -0.04839129000902176, 0.030432024970650673, 0.027196891605854034, -0.04433223232626915, -0.03221634030342102, 0.05521898716688156, -0.031633686274290085, -0.039813607931137085, 0.001900006434880197, -0.001577295595780015, 0.03363267332315445, -0.043470170348882675, -0.009957442991435528, 0.024820499122142792, 0.13911563158035278, 0.08180303126573563, 0.007331933360546827, -0.017028285190463066, 0.029448436573147774, -0.02197120152413845, -0.013369834050536156, -0.004896711558103561, -0.010405576787889004, -0.018301397562026978, 0.06524141877889633, 0.021703654900193214, 0.01540529727935791, -0.032800961285829544, -0.01228373497724533, -0.07863257080316544, 0.022518498823046684, 0.014988239854574203, -0.06143322214484215, 0.0020814610179513693, -0.04375889524817467, 0.03348918631672859, -0.055511657148599625, -0.03568466752767563, 0.009445538744330406, 0.12448043376207352, -0.02432813122868538, -0.016443543136119843, -0.07464875280857086, -0.027063723653554916, -0.0712173655629158, -0.0026638363488018513, 0.04996392875909805, 0.007254855241626501, 0.00787945557385683, 0.00915983784943819, -0.019503355026245117, -0.0376892127096653, 0.04570956528186798, -0.03872838243842125, 0.021296044811606407, -0.05486904829740524, 0.0022989457938820124, -0.0603095144033432, -0.012947067618370056, 0.033573903143405914, 0.05003338307142258, -0.03252372518181801, -0.08541180938482285, -0.0033158385194838047, -0.006076415069401264, -0.11280293017625809, 0.08813595026731491, 0.0004185237630736083, -0.04210178181529045, -0.008794303052127361, -0.0023353651631623507, -0.033625781536102295, 0.049441348761320114, -0.04879172518849373, 0.01350048091262579, 0.04594767838716507, 0.07381458580493927, 0.03411930426955223, -0.022151712328195572, -0.09206437319517136, -0.018864477053284645, -0.07461505383253098, 0.022341186180710793, 0.04119500145316124, 0.01761084608733654, -0.071806401014328, 0.058297283947467804, -0.039984576404094696, -0.02359757013618946, 0.06091564521193504, 0.03668447583913803, 0.039099935442209244, 0.0559682697057724, 0.017710888758301735, 0.027040423825383186, -0.030599601566791534, -0.013914041221141815, -0.09081920236349106, 0.06246111914515495, -0.027458909898996353, -0.0101929334923625, 0.04434290900826454, 0.008521214127540588, 0.016699431464076042, -0.05997748672962189, -0.035165175795555115, 0.05806697905063629, -0.06206813082098961, -0.004551717080175877, 0.020644981414079666, -0.010111155919730663, 0.0027069717179983854, 0.04061036556959152, 0.0006211986765265465, 0.00020788794790860265, -0.07334185391664505, 0.007024293765425682, -0.05398689582943916, -0.010808664374053478, -0.02103523537516594, -0.05563684180378914, -0.017974115908145905, -0.017141027376055717, 0.06292687356472015, 0.041176892817020416, 0.005978520959615707, 0.07037283480167389, 0.0760674923658371, -0.057300154119729996, 0.025937655940651894, 0.06634839624166489, 0.03941906988620758, 0.03990689292550087, -0.04647914320230484, -0.027201781049370766, 0.028506143018603325, 0.0012900509173050523, -0.011466849595308304, -0.025722047314047813, 0.05190637335181236, 0.02924974448978901, -0.055911995470523834, -0.01274795737117529, 0.020092008635401726, -0.029672857373952866, -0.06797754764556885, -0.03417696803808212, -0.02975180558860302, 0.022016802802681923, -0.016808999702334404, 0.035039301961660385, 0.007290293462574482, -0.005511462222784758, -0.03719543665647507, 0.03517632558941841, -0.07672695070505142, 0.007892875000834465, 0.039068859070539474, 0.06370942294597626, -0.07387246936559677, 0.07594677060842514, -0.0009732668986544013, -0.012345491908490658, 0.016412226483225822, -0.03507662191987038, -0.03153581544756889, -0.03508229926228523, 0.06036274880170822, -0.03738223761320114, 0.038403235375881195, 0.04896581918001175, 0.11027031391859055, 0.0196167454123497, -0.03894716128706932, 0.07553031295537949, -0.01607336848974228, 0.01563933864235878, -0.048726364970207214, -0.0015420394483953714, -0.021525081247091293, -0.014910100027918816, 0.004028633236885071, 0.08130627870559692, 0.04769900441169739, 0.027513893321156502, -0.026956254616379738, 0.02621542289853096, -0.026744551956653595, -0.03077143430709839, 0.0878501683473587, 0.05553308129310608, -0.01483653113245964, 0.029874250292778015, -0.07025940716266632, 0.017849896103143692, -0.009489941410720348, 0.02044178545475006, -0.04013100638985634, -0.030122041702270508, -0.024694319814443588, 0.009149386547505856, 0.0005603583413176239, 0.05431599169969559, -0.041261717677116394, 0.014432366006076336, 0.03133222088217735, -0.02819923497736454, -0.008854642510414124, 0.003977624699473381, -0.047877464443445206, -0.04028327390551567, 0.02917885035276413, 0.007618431001901627, 0.0607428215444088, -0.0020198426209390163, -0.00455821817740798, 0.028963938355445862, 0.014072832651436329, -0.01139923557639122, 0.10368819534778595, 0.03207000717520714, 0.05140669271349907, -0.03131772205233574, -0.023984825238585472, 0.08551786839962006, 0.028308117762207985, 0.015211196616292, -0.0028574573807418346, -0.14352118968963623, -0.07885367423295975, -0.01649448275566101, -0.003091775579378009, 0.08370024710893631, 0.07035787403583527, -0.03422442451119423, 0.010715344920754433, -0.08272548019886017, -0.027569087222218513, 0.0407571867108345, 0.016225924715399742, -0.0016970400465652347, 0.028819836676120758, -0.019960975274443626, -0.03423718735575676, -0.02855207398533821, 0.004033931065350771, -0.02015426568686962, -0.004822311922907829, 0.010999714024364948, -0.08964675664901733, -0.040672823786735535, 0.03314075618982315, 0.04408872500061989, 0.03640507906675339, 0.05693979561328888, -0.03758392110466957, -0.09683499485254288, -0.0659758672118187, 0.062170833349227905, 0.000812981859780848, 0.003807385917752981, 0.022109270095825195, 0.0020565574523061514, -0.020412826910614967, -0.0352296382188797, 0.09332142025232315, 0.06710692495107651, -0.04200858250260353, -0.001400441862642765, 0.01262983214110136, -0.02363002859055996, 0.0041186874732375145, 0.011507710441946983, 0.043942976742982864, 0.009550358168780804, -0.056908294558525085, 0.028057947754859924, -0.020104624330997467, -0.03029361367225647, -0.004909935873001814, -0.07746246457099915, -0.004644634667783976, 0.00753273768350482, 0.08187633007764816, -0.06353355944156647, -0.020207425579428673, -0.06300519406795502, -0.06269687414169312, 0.013708786107599735, -0.06351903825998306, 0.009166598320007324, 0.04119814187288284, -0.032949138432741165, 0.12472215294837952, 0.008669926784932613, 0.056771691888570786, -0.03546827659010887, -0.007572495844215155, -0.03109079599380493, 0.05931208282709122, 0.01657779887318611, 0.034090835601091385, -0.037897590547800064, -0.054429229348897934, -0.03130681812763214, 0.01601373590528965, 0.04619691148400307, -0.08163383603096008, 0.0373067706823349, 0.0649402067065239, 0.031895846128463745, -0.011910523287951946, -0.052635304629802704, -0.0095038628205657, -0.03143804892897606, 0.03029443882405758, -0.0009502384928055108, -0.03316668048501015, -0.06117594242095947, -0.0360717698931694, -0.03775089234113693, -0.012353725731372833, -0.030681105330586433, 0.04585791751742363, -0.0043978001922369, -0.017628278583288193, -0.07202513515949249, 0.03284107893705368, 0.046592745929956436, 0.033751554787158966, -0.045070093125104904, 0.0861949771642685, -0.002653087256476283, -0.0343557670712471, 0.008990049362182617, 0.01571083441376686, 0.008093742653727531 ]
74
74
Online variants of the cross-entropy method
The cross-entropy method is a simple but efficient method for global optimization. In this paper we provide two online variants of the basic CEM, together with a proof of convergence.
[ 0.03364039212465286, -0.053877588361501694, -0.005716843064874411, -0.03407314792275429, 0.009111287072300911, -0.09344033151865005, 0.01922227069735527, -0.016030726954340935, -0.023656465113162994, 0.020723853260278702, 0.03844180330634117, 0.010214680805802345, 0.031565625220537186, 0.023726822808384895, 0.04952983558177948, -0.04018495976924896, 0.026321442797780037, 0.026409108191728592, -0.021522944793105125, -0.02312573790550232, 0.04495019465684891, 0.0027848936151713133, -0.005648469086736441, -0.011461489833891392, 0.02105352282524109, 0.01834012381732464, -0.03488795831799507, 0.039335768669843674, -0.03877118602395058, 0.0404479093849659, -0.12929289042949677, -0.0025640728417783976, 0.041532061994075775, 0.059769388288259506, -0.02133221924304962, -0.08768215030431747, 0.033143334090709686, 0.018746018409729004, 0.0032295610290020704, -0.04932007938623428, 0.04559570178389549, 0.026832686737179756, -0.067478246986866, -0.03303590416908264, 0.026655085384845734, -0.01805206388235092, 0.037249937653541565, 0.05692879110574722, -0.0727824866771698, 0.05299846827983856, -0.022084712982177734, 0.031589362770318985, 0.000641561986412853, 0.0056560346856713295, 0.024884454905986786, 0.06533567607402802, 0.015501976013183594, -0.012739034369587898, 0.022848647087812424, -0.08479739725589752, 0.020551875233650208, 0.018122518435120583, 0.005092209205031395, 0.013726627454161644, -0.11489330977201462, -0.0011301098857074976, -0.0959688350558281, 0.005494131240993738, 0.04529017210006714, -0.036152925342321396, 0.009790629148483276, -0.017580917105078697, 0.021821051836013794, 0.023455219343304634, 0.040495194494724274, -0.02385922148823738, -0.043417785316705704, -0.05364665016531944, 0.08257387578487396, 0.038073454052209854, 0.009741476736962795, 0.03004598058760166, -0.05855501443147659, 0.0769064873456955, -0.016497334465384483, -0.053572315722703934, -0.07843398302793503, -0.02927580662071705, 0.010281257331371307, -0.029302095994353294, -0.03708188608288765, 0.022906998172402382, -0.10050582885742188, 0.0575389564037323, -0.06323735415935516, 0.03514443337917328, -0.10910790413618088, 0.014315987005829811, -0.017684470862150192, -0.045647408813238144, 0.07204029709100723, 0.017972435802221298, 0.055606186389923096, 0.06795715540647507, -0.005271324422210455, 0.028456782922148705, -0.05866537615656853, 0.07843189686536789, 0.032317597419023514, -0.015960557386279106, -0.010624735616147518, -0.00412126025184989, 0.034657590091228485, -0.027933860197663307, -0.026771971955895424, -0.023194395005702972, -0.02855556085705757, 0.08066961169242859, 0.03992238640785217, -0.05018245801329613, 0.01595015451312065, 0.028823383152484894, -0.009446962736546993, 0.015738695859909058, 0.06364930421113968, 0.03431713581085205, -0.02750886231660843, -0.004552025813609362, 0.12436012923717499, -0.004542923532426357, 0.026118967682123184, 0.08947066217660904, 0.061636101454496384, 0.04168015345931053, -0.0516226664185524, -0.013904040679335594, 0.02094344235956669, 0.06100626662373543, -0.022567206993699074, -0.027385922148823738, -0.05134065821766853, -0.02121523767709732, 0.015030698850750923, 0.052122753113508224, 0.0659976676106453, 0.01105105597525835, 0.009622294455766678, 0.041149526834487915, -0.060686055570840836, 0.01829586550593376, 0.018854394555091858, 0.026425091549754143, 0.004580586217343807, 0.015430492348968983, -0.00008397804776905105, -0.09433911740779877, -0.09202518314123154, -0.0038518307264894247, 0.0005162096349522471, 0.05253242701292038, 0.06443764269351959, 0.029462769627571106, 0.017737336456775665, -0.047806959599256516, -0.04079630598425865, 0.007464222609996796, -0.027366487309336662, -0.0604543574154377, -0.019867995753884315, -0.05481836944818497, -0.02711545117199421, 0.02273251675069332, -0.03590855747461319, 0.010759024880826473, -0.004352578427642584, 0.11783254146575928, -0.0159548819065094, -0.015479574911296368, -0.08141028136014938, 0.020361270755529404, 0.05866509675979614, -0.05141574516892433, 0.019598281010985374, -0.0235032606869936, 0.06653179228305817, 0.047989290207624435, 0.035231057554483414, 0.06021150201559067, 0.03606289625167847, 0.062463775277137756, -0.00007222774002002552, 0.006952020339667797, 0.03332415223121643, -0.028434135019779205, -0.01639311946928501, 0.017543183639645576, -0.034169040620326996, 0.05060925334692001, -0.027631282806396484, 0.029352596029639244, 0.10412823408842087, 0.0068336897529661655, -0.011981246061623096, -0.053112708032131195, -0.03944338858127594, 0.048869166523218155, 0.07225081324577332, -0.03672280162572861, 0.07094895839691162, -0.06503934413194656, -0.021311886608600616, 0.006239341571927071, -0.013069839216768742, -0.039005912840366364, 0.009761028923094273, -0.08436936885118484, 0.02499670721590519, 0.020524119958281517, -0.04043183475732803, -0.018729137256741524, -0.009099891409277916, 0.026264889165759087, -0.0656469315290451, 0.06608106940984726, -0.037410326302051544, -0.001836759620346129, -0.027025043964385986, 0.07831405848264694, -0.08765491843223572, 0.0494980588555336, -0.040265582501888275, -0.05343310907483101, 0.02829795330762863, -0.07434326410293579, -0.07762899994850159, 0.0022529379930347204, -0.03700859472155571, 0.007202441338449717, -0.023734766989946365, -0.07359842956066132, -0.04215395078063011, 0.0634889155626297, 0.039382774382829666, 0.0035214980598539114, -0.008679243735969067, 0.007292282767593861, -0.02696796879172325, -0.03393469378352165, -0.029832065105438232, -0.020240789279341698, -0.012614107690751553, 0.06016913428902626, -0.027719728648662567, -0.008605006150901318, 0.00955609604716301, 0.003741538617759943, -0.015544756315648556, 0.1359710544347763, 0.03525545820593834, 0.11990399658679962, -0.0466361865401268, -0.002352437237277627, 0.03010423853993416, -0.07615673542022705, 0.04391295090317726, -0.042185913771390915, -0.005799402482807636, -0.03098335862159729, 0.04348757863044739, 0.04269488900899887, -0.027150584384799004, 0.00015083893958944827, -0.05797813832759857, 0.07975417375564575, 0.013359318487346172, 0.002108529908582568, 0.01655256375670433, 0.02876853197813034, -0.0017240087036043406, -0.05309530720114708, -0.07545540481805801, 0.057887349277734756, -0.01826409064233303, 0.02537347376346588, 0.03773261979222298, 0.03240129351615906, -0.0503959059715271, 0.005581703037023544, -0.02823629230260849, 0.05478394776582718, -0.06344806402921677, 0.07907957583665848, -0.10082963854074478, 0.024576060473918915, -0.0024896464310586452, -0.03430918976664543, 0.09941335767507553, -0.006653889082372189, -0.02646934986114502, 0.02251746505498886, 0.04400619864463806, -0.05201191455125809, 0.04002612829208374, 0.0341949500143528, -0.03239831328392029, 0.12225840985774994, -0.049026910215616226, 0.02231309935450554, -0.04680376127362251, 0.03280061483383179, 0.053106654435396194, -0.0628875270485878, -0.001190705574117601, 0.0028684933204203844, 0.01843734085559845, 0.014301801100373268, -0.02836528606712818, 0.002241116715595126, 0.002271946519613266, -0.017702287063002586, -0.020305214449763298, -0.002790851518511772, 0.0794144794344902, -0.04737496376037598, -0.06843265146017075, -0.009015155956149101, -0.0359509252011776, -0.03177206963300705, -0.01882980577647686, 0.02385633811354637, -0.035313524305820465, 0.03532316908240318, -0.0477714017033577, 0.017338061705231667, -0.02315959334373474, 0.02034992352128029, -0.038708582520484924, -0.007721718400716782, 0.0023922394029796124, -0.012634534388780594, -0.12117653340101242, -0.012718512676656246, 0.031187627464532852, 0.01537469681352377, 0.037084441632032394, 0.0699663832783699, 0.06313125044107437, 0.04452741891145706, -0.08249670267105103, 0.04632268473505974, -0.009964637458324432, -0.04774189367890358, -0.057101570069789886, -0.040054500102996826, -0.04636174440383911, -0.007036376278847456, 0.03964179754257202, 0.012312429957091808, -0.0037721083499491215, 0.021921107545495033, -0.022670170292258263, 0.054782435297966, -0.019512789323925972, -0.01888219825923443, 0.0543973445892334, 0.06198551133275032, -0.011024955660104752, 0.00048296834575012326, -0.014841132797300816, 0.049102190881967545, -0.0623510517179966, 0.004608106333762407, 0.054012447595596313, 0.0026169372722506523, -0.025690849870443344, 0.012387044727802277, 0.10459806025028229, -0.04169623181223869, -0.0652085691690445, 0.09646731615066528, -0.06903373450040817, -0.015467091463506222, 0.0100461570546031, -0.03958117589354515, 0.0023973460774868727, -0.009684616699814796, 0.05534304305911064, -0.004364399239420891, 0.10011544823646545, -0.0003162416396662593, -0.08729858696460724, -0.009440910071134567, 0.020494284108281136, 0.027536666020751, 0.040036723017692566, -0.008335105143487453, 0.07794070243835449, 0.004977684933692217, 0.008801334537565708, -0.031756848096847534, 0.007274881936609745, 0.02162926271557808, 0.01631670631468296, -0.052310001105070114, -0.053424786776304245, -0.013658159412443638, -0.018783088773489, 0.052751071751117706, -0.011858304962515831, -0.016987774521112442, 0.024866579100489616, -0.031337521970272064, -0.017099177464842796, 0.012522375211119652, 0.024778440594673157, 0.05058920755982399, 0.03231452405452728, 0.0014915559440851212, -0.029208092018961906, -0.0732356607913971, -0.06908291578292847, 0.025535376742482185, 0.005109231919050217, 0.031667664647102356, -0.021165115758776665, 0.07915998995304108, 0.08594442903995514, 0.01716008223593235, -0.00804827455431223, 0.029486697167158127, -0.10427047312259674, -0.019580597057938576, -0.03929661586880684, -0.006117914337664843, -0.009188218973577023, -0.009026126936078072, 0.06569050252437592, 0.011366872116923332, 0.01399090327322483, -0.028507519513368607, -0.03221839666366577, 0.08338187634944916, 0.026154857128858566, 0.02242223173379898, -0.045411694794893265, 0.10143942385911942, -0.02097332663834095, -0.0035490416921675205, 0.03128134831786156, 0.02618095837533474, 0.01494463998824358, -0.0021435206290334463, -0.02718779817223549, 0.00046906655188649893, -0.0008630210068076849, -0.02587977983057499, -0.011100421659648418, -0.007533625233918428, 0.05585135892033577, -0.09416889399290085, -0.03499699756503105, -0.05744098126888275, -0.0025584001559764147, -0.019529812037944794, -0.037285491824150085, -0.02813415788114071, -0.015662850812077522, -0.008273066021502018, 0.04361940547823906, 0.032488156110048294, -0.030564792454242706, 0.024905920028686523, 0.016045480966567993, -0.0504019558429718, -0.003675936721265316, 0.01667656935751438, 0.01943127065896988, -0.017737336456775665, 0.01202361285686493, 0.013809234835207462, 0.001701784785836935, 0.07788471132516861, -0.03602355346083641, 0.008099342696368694, 0.005076510366052389, 0.027320856228470802, -0.04573455825448036, 0.003616257105022669, 0.05389196053147316, 0.07294012606143951, 0.019050342962145805, 0.004739841911941767, -0.008982435800135136, 0.03618498519062996, -0.03472458943724632, 0.03054720163345337, -0.008336405269801617, -0.007830385118722916, 0.07691026479005814, 0.03915684297680855, -0.007905378937721252, -0.0023682895116508007, 0.11172862350940704, 0.07371910661458969, 0.022380053997039795, -0.016725247725844383, 0.04274331405758858, -0.018910380080342293, -0.010422734543681145, -0.026854321360588074, -0.0435790978372097, -0.014766138978302479 ]
75
75
Factored Value Iteration Converges
In this paper we propose a novel algorithm, factored value iteration (FVI), for the approximate solution of factored Markov decision processes (fMDPs). The traditional approximate value iteration algorithm is modified in two ways. For one, the least-squares projection operator is modified so that it does not increase max-norm, and thus preserves convergence. The other modification is that we uniformly sample polynomially many samples from the (exponentially large) state space. This way, the complexity of our algorithm becomes polynomial in the size of the fMDP description length. We prove that the algorithm is convergent. We also derive an upper bound on the difference between our approximate solution and the optimal one, and also on the error introduced by sampling. We analyze various projection operators with respect to their computation complexity and their convergence when combined with approximate value iteration.
[ -0.0023471605964004993, -0.036127086728811264, 0.02645067498087883, -0.020590556785464287, 0.014465708285570145, -0.020787499845027924, 0.01917334645986557, -0.010218311101198196, -0.017172031104564667, 0.0589374378323555, 0.05146052688360214, 0.012064166367053986, 0.0039586033672094345, 0.04769330099225044, -0.011447938159108162, -0.008188728243112564, -0.033155977725982666, 0.017045574262738228, 0.0014435553457587957, -0.01304643228650093, 0.07521343976259232, -0.060116201639175415, 0.011181103996932507, 0.035361193120479584, -0.0035939516965299845, 0.040986739099025726, 0.04914858192205429, -0.04591907560825348, 0.07106554508209229, 0.008222401142120361, -0.09606223553419113, -0.011391641572117805, 0.025276927277445793, 0.031163368374109268, -0.04973968490958214, -0.05990169197320938, 0.013251257129013538, 0.003551825415343046, -0.0602671280503273, -0.09897730499505997, -0.04652295634150505, 0.04688601195812225, -0.02447270229458809, 0.012334536761045456, 0.020106442272663116, 0.08790906518697739, 0.04659228399395943, 0.025609588250517845, -0.03907495737075806, 0.07412706315517426, -0.04917673394083977, 0.050846513360738754, -0.04589935392141342, -0.02231769636273384, 0.0027020913548767567, 0.002422748366370797, -0.027839941903948784, -0.01744670607149601, 0.04273959994316101, -0.009320341981947422, 0.03917444497346878, 0.05570172518491745, 0.04495156556367874, -0.04542212188243866, -0.107457734644413, -0.022876953706145287, 0.01129907462745905, -0.02526542730629444, -0.08395490795373917, -0.02611491084098816, 0.06184566020965576, -0.06337926536798477, 0.036105699837207794, -0.0009469939395785332, 0.037954408675432205, 0.0005184822366572917, 0.0321611724793911, 0.019262952730059624, 0.09669340401887894, 0.09781058877706528, 0.02280259132385254, 0.02138681896030903, 0.03920082002878189, 0.044799502938985825, -0.04750462993979454, 0.013356920331716537, -0.010422897525131702, -0.013545379973948002, -0.009154551662504673, -0.010922460816800594, 0.0023869371507316828, 0.08261463791131973, -0.04068906977772713, 0.03308989852666855, -0.066055066883564, 0.011856762692332268, -0.03489607572555542, 0.03723316267132759, -0.005504007916897535, -0.021936791017651558, -0.014795741997659206, 0.032944206148386, 0.09388311207294464, 0.028520941734313965, 0.010937578976154327, -0.03085162304341793, -0.016675177961587906, 0.01792849227786064, -0.0067056454718112946, -0.056200236082077026, 0.02257765457034111, -0.023869818076491356, 0.07787205278873444, 0.007732422556728125, -0.04529064893722534, 0.05681836977601051, 0.01267136912792921, 0.015507861971855164, 0.025505386292934418, -0.00803434569388628, -0.08452349156141281, 0.010601039975881577, 0.05771635100245476, 0.06295201182365417, 0.06254137307405472, -0.025651833042502403, 0.02817464806139469, -0.045373640954494476, 0.08088748157024384, 0.008089767768979073, 0.03532020002603531, -0.006764090619981289, 0.037933483719825745, -0.036033373326063156, -0.04711631312966347, 0.02643517777323723, 0.04460165277123451, -0.060487471520900726, -0.07037479430437088, 0.11838321387767792, -0.022076651453971863, 0.0034165745601058006, -0.0043073841370642185, -0.06272410601377487, 0.019257070496678352, -0.014054781757295132, -0.01330050453543663, -0.024821927770972252, -0.04743513837456703, 0.033671874552965164, -0.016726858913898468, -0.027894126251339912, 0.07533019036054611, -0.017783811315894127, 0.015431376174092293, -0.0501936674118042, 0.03883456066250801, 0.03250272944569588, 0.05353594571352005, -0.019233230501413345, -0.0443124920129776, -0.038268331438302994, -0.021322155371308327, -0.011916766874492168, 0.1289607435464859, 0.005222012754529715, 0.005007150582969189, -0.0008432296453975141, -0.03085530921816826, -0.05256355181336403, -0.030329782515764236, -0.028873028233647346, 0.03390750288963318, 0.08115598559379578, 0.05886376276612282, 0.026472747325897217, -0.051164090633392334, 0.03422700613737106, -0.04496323689818382, 0.01569848507642746, -0.02550124004483223, -0.0636715367436409, -0.06300291419029236, -0.05375685542821884, 0.05983468145132065, -0.01905778981745243, 0.022282466292381287, 0.036426424980163574, 0.06309789419174194, 0.003314624074846506, 0.024969443678855896, 0.0535619892179966, -0.03442509472370148, -0.006655426695942879, 0.012646944262087345, 0.006346401758491993, -0.028825851157307625, -0.030450865626335144, 0.015304308384656906, 0.030709635466337204, 0.081288181245327, 0.012594925239682198, -0.06017613410949707, -0.06514973938465118, -0.03864777833223343, -0.0065366062335669994, 0.018727928400039673, -0.012668992392718792, 0.012225626036524773, -0.041863128542900085, 0.013873171992599964, -0.08031059056520462, -0.03847884014248848, 0.0431394949555397, 0.09584663808345795, -0.07774368673563004, -0.019063256680965424, -0.011619329452514648, -0.0027915623504668474, 0.006483714561909437, 0.01200320478528738, 0.0047537521459162235, -0.013927263207733631, 0.12275999039411545, -0.046360984444618225, -0.02890498749911785, -0.013677123934030533, -0.04097730293869972, -0.018890703096985817, -0.020992686972022057, -0.008518803864717484, -0.02644321322441101, 0.00328131509013474, 0.025729363784193993, -0.06016400083899498, 0.0875014066696167, 0.02907354012131691, -0.06868043541908264, -0.010419058613479137, 0.0035359992180019617, -0.03585182502865791, 0.030595609918236732, -0.07002681493759155, -0.06856009364128113, 0.03584248572587967, 0.016516517847776413, -0.008104350417852402, 0.021523112431168556, -0.009292746894061565, -0.033258479088544846, 0.0048507279716432095, -0.00243962649255991, -0.02938450686633587, 0.027754858136177063, 0.05200081691145897, -0.04082728177309036, -0.04885968565940857, 0.11861331015825272, 0.036222998052835464, 0.0022689132019877434, -0.035179849714040756, 0.002776485402137041, -0.00517795467749238, 0.03179362043738365, 0.0751282200217247, 0.07162223011255264, 0.010432040318846703, 0.0556422583758831, -0.0052080824971199036, 0.025276442989706993, -0.03268289566040039, -0.03175477311015129, -0.048951197415590286, 0.08694565296173096, 0.002280364977195859, -0.031199024990200996, 0.04285920038819313, 0.046650297939777374, -0.00716375932097435, -0.0349029004573822, -0.016870593652129173, -0.010839401744306087, -0.008693178184330463, -0.023586202412843704, 0.039146874099969864, 0.03607279807329178, -0.004069440066814423, -0.007695031352341175, -0.053965698927640915, -0.020535964518785477, -0.11543070524930954, -0.021426761522889137, -0.04505420848727226, -0.0018958147848024964, 0.034785207360982895, -0.038603343069553375, 0.026506995782256126, 0.029858514666557312, 0.05041024833917618, 0.009984001517295837, 0.03827010095119476, -0.005748213268816471, 0.06087135151028633, -0.02246677502989769, 0.039765048772096634, -0.015138818882405758, 0.05648668110370636, -0.0073912073858082294, -0.059145621955394745, 0.060444217175245285, 0.010708588175475597, 0.020560910925269127, -0.05009353905916214, -0.04259663447737694, 0.06487661600112915, -0.00980738177895546, -0.033465780317783356, -0.03215987980365753, -0.0480736568570137, 0.05224792659282684, -0.010721084661781788, -0.01562850922346115, 0.05730901658535004, 0.03950722515583038, -0.08379339426755905, -0.0038198684342205524, -0.004946529865264893, 0.018456876277923584, 0.021718829870224, -0.011095092631876469, -0.0073989820666611195, 0.07988496869802475, -0.09992214292287827, -0.003687943099066615, -0.04783284664154053, -0.049698080867528915, -0.07876714318990707, -0.05448248237371445, -0.04466105252504349, -0.030953451991081238, -0.10592810064554214, -0.08973433822393417, -0.008729778230190277, 0.002947673201560974, 0.04347731173038483, 0.00851482804864645, 0.056318894028663635, -0.004975621122866869, 0.054571572691202164, 0.011295606382191181, -0.062063414603471756, 0.052998609840869904, 0.024333057925105095, -0.013457847759127617, 0.013666106387972832, 0.09231389313936234, 0.034785524010658264, -0.03839307278394699, -0.028770051896572113, -0.01442700158804655, -0.03855578973889351, -0.0247713141143322, 0.001131343888118863, 0.08045383542776108, -0.03610348328948021, 0.026483779773116112, -0.03908328339457512, -0.00809689611196518, -0.005810141563415527, 0.017278674989938736, -0.04751407727599144, 0.05607426539063454, 0.06599210947751999, 0.04456520453095436, 0.06941906362771988, -0.0433809831738472, 0.051062457263469696, -0.04008140787482262, 0.0026864330284297466, 0.03931191563606262, -0.03139406442642212, -0.038578521460294724, 0.0028370374348014593, -0.11536074429750443, -0.03894906863570213, -0.008881721645593643, -0.0057843890972435474, 0.049057383090257645, 0.007526998873800039, -0.07470614463090897, -0.07816913723945618, -0.0030141498427838087, -0.06804105639457703, 0.02422361634671688, 0.01923808827996254, -0.019027672708034515, 0.08284087479114532, -0.006872891914099455, -0.017618611454963684, -0.036312222480773926, -0.016363848000764847, -0.06583330780267715, 0.0005264508654363453, -0.05739913508296013, -0.07727885991334915, -0.03100825846195221, -0.024559976533055305, 0.011932588182389736, -0.007765495218336582, 0.1540851891040802, 0.02984786219894886, -0.030570324510335922, -0.017558131366968155, 0.07407961040735245, 0.05681869015097618, 0.035918883979320526, -0.05244668200612068, 0.04009166732430458, 0.0226795244961977, -0.04179666191339493, 0.012766839936375618, -0.011065846309065819, -0.007457065861672163, 0.005536653101444244, -0.04862523078918457, -0.09635809063911438, 0.019667241722345352, 0.09187178313732147, -0.06773092597723007, -0.01061034481972456, -0.012874641455709934, 0.03157774358987808, -0.013914568349719048, -0.04152272269129753, 0.009178425185382366, -0.011172830127179623, -0.03266730532050133, 0.0038279895670711994, 0.036525219678878784, -0.06183292716741562, 0.005251595750451088, 0.017955390736460686, -0.05495178699493408, -0.03352225199341774, 0.05704633891582489, 0.029096398502588272, 0.039622943848371506, -0.026693450286984444, 0.03772556036710739, 0.0407482273876667, 0.007491519674658775, 0.011868673376739025, 0.037199199199676514, 0.009119898080825806, 0.039471935480833054, 0.056115370243787766, 0.010359279811382294, 0.041287824511528015, 0.02852017804980278, -0.004114811774343252, -0.020860586315393448, -0.05199272185564041, 0.03491642326116562, 0.015046470798552036, -0.08772251754999161, -0.021126314997673035, -0.02181246317923069, 0.02370430715382099, 0.06423307210206985, 0.014070886187255383, -0.06999793648719788, 0.006713300943374634, 0.0031582119408994913, -0.01001664437353611, -0.05633486807346344, -0.00640986580401659, 0.05200672149658203, 0.011232443153858185, 0.002163994126021862, -0.02773180790245533, 0.03911778703331947, -0.016359344124794006, -0.01199397724121809, -0.004094548523426056, 0.034697435796260834, 0.0370880588889122, 0.01035767886787653, -0.08048746734857559, 0.0978422686457634, -0.04987524822354317, -0.014468147419393063, -0.022358989343047142, -0.01014628354460001, 0.08634200692176819, -0.09533580392599106, -0.04328818619251251, 0.029560469090938568, 0.042689837515354156, 0.07259153574705124, -0.02356676198542118, 0.025748027488589287, -0.047757796943187714, 0.014523971825838089, 0.06142072379589081, 0.0614234022796154, 0.01524421852082014, 0.04121488705277443, -0.05409340560436249, -0.033563174307346344, 0.09257123619318008, 0.010006070137023926, 0.07406985759735107 ]
76
76
The optimal assignment kernel is not positive definite
We prove that the optimal assignment kernel, proposed recently as an attempt to embed labeled graphs and more generally tuples of basic data to a Hilbert space, is in fact not always positive definite.
[ -0.011344324797391891, -0.030643686652183533, -0.045031651854515076, -0.06901273131370544, 0.002878314582630992, -0.050012897700071335, 0.010313074104487896, -0.0334307961165905, -0.032251112163066864, -0.044927824288606644, -0.01166823972016573, -0.030683547258377075, 0.029681289568543434, 0.012658965773880482, 0.03759508952498436, 0.08908425271511078, 0.020711185410618782, 0.03879384696483612, -0.034715160727500916, 0.026084013283252716, 0.04790673777461052, 0.05329475551843643, 0.06239815428853035, 0.018218807876110077, -0.014913413673639297, -0.03708762675523758, 0.05336308479309082, 0.03900307044386864, -0.006505059078335762, -0.02655958943068981, -0.07100728154182434, 0.0470852293074131, -0.007934192195534706, 0.008556741289794445, -0.022101180627942085, -0.004935310687869787, 0.022696979343891144, 0.08771760761737823, -0.06257923692464828, 0.009046979248523712, 0.053593140095472336, 0.003757525235414505, 0.022545769810676575, -0.05699818208813667, -0.021804694086313248, 0.0005582381272688508, -0.018753651529550552, 0.03378356248140335, 0.04043762385845184, 0.007594510912895203, -0.10088147222995758, 0.10119371116161346, -0.0540192648768425, -0.00715953204780817, -0.013980533927679062, 0.02501954510807991, -0.010735501535236835, 0.028710683807730675, 0.09040269255638123, 0.051203399896621704, 0.11159447580575943, 0.10118365287780762, -0.07003012299537659, 0.02603769861161709, 0.013494139537215233, -0.005779406521469355, 0.02715759165585041, -0.0039412397891283035, -0.03410244733095169, 0.0003500139864627272, 0.008017010055482388, -0.01841473951935768, 0.012525337748229504, 0.059270281344652176, 0.0522879883646965, 0.009355471469461918, -0.024186553433537483, -0.03886142373085022, -0.0035027971025556326, 0.06159961223602295, -0.10748238861560822, 0.012677662074565887, -0.006198287010192871, -0.021073536947369576, -0.06128585338592529, 0.08206423372030258, -0.007223119493573904, 0.006571920122951269, 0.019806254655122757, 0.006382819730788469, -0.030077854171395302, -0.02209586650133133, -0.021642403677105904, 0.02787698246538639, -0.020421329885721207, 0.0008672526455484331, 0.008314160630106926, 0.00786126870661974, 0.05927004665136337, -0.03637545183300972, -0.014374678954482079, -0.017855411395430565, 0.02866470254957676, 0.057922378182411194, -0.036188866943120956, 0.06291557848453522, -0.012321004644036293, -0.04753356799483299, 0.006411861628293991, -0.06799229979515076, -0.0012868328485637903, 0.04348335415124893, -0.011416714638471603, 0.022552838549017906, -0.0007887889514677227, 0.062018342316150665, -0.07336057722568512, 0.03421633690595627, 0.008903907611966133, 0.05774623528122902, -0.03633767366409302, 0.03793627768754959, -0.02794075757265091, -0.010501202195882797, 0.042167194187641144, -0.01162296999245882, -0.023061253130435944, -0.0985276997089386, 0.011503458954393864, 0.06293874233961105, -0.035081591457128525, -0.04247981682419777, -0.048185765743255615, -0.002021786291152239, -0.004234713967889547, 0.05816951394081116, -0.02244720794260502, -0.004708105232566595, -0.03021518513560295, 0.06680066138505936, -0.03871792554855347, -0.030984967947006226, 0.0011408671271055937, 0.0581277571618557, 0.06037323549389839, 0.09268005937337875, -0.03092849999666214, 0.0008948228787630796, 0.02336912788450718, -0.0504935048520565, 0.02314211241900921, 0.01866709440946579, 0.0029511074535548687, 0.0433865487575531, -0.03615279868245125, -0.06773567944765091, -0.04804198443889618, 0.030789462849497795, -0.035051129758358, -0.03479507192969322, -0.03436875343322754, -0.018300188705325127, 0.07517658919095993, 0.024552417919039726, 0.014746331609785557, -0.00874702725559473, 0.038716405630111694, -0.013172217644751072, 0.015110012143850327, 0.025647634640336037, 0.03098648600280285, -0.06350266933441162, 0.03793361783027649, 0.04035088047385216, -0.029619839042425156, -0.0012227711267769337, -0.023209115490317345, 0.04374339431524277, -0.09120103716850281, -0.047231387346982956, 0.0788860097527504, 0.012991516850888729, -0.014398501254618168, 0.060256313532590866, 0.014305397868156433, 0.10050421953201294, -0.02274193987250328, -0.027534939348697662, 0.013727467507123947, 0.07463573664426804, 0.018292713910341263, 0.017174316570162773, 0.012052119709551334, 0.09109322726726532, -0.15579208731651306, -0.05979354679584503, -0.02750077284872532, 0.05847739055752754, 0.012604868970811367, 0.024794047698378563, 0.07909661531448364, 0.022512979805469513, -0.05105724558234215, -0.04895763471722603, -0.05813070014119148, 0.00007288793858606368, 0.03716753423213959, -0.051133930683135986, -0.014847916550934315, -0.08963698893785477, -0.0010247494792565703, -0.005230469163507223, -0.024135401472449303, 0.07236628979444504, -0.0025221791584044695, -0.060016386210918427, -0.0018831284251064062, -0.00688487384468317, 0.01269484031945467, 0.0025960635393857956, -0.00950694177299738, 0.006411481648683548, 0.02665344998240471, -0.0005557705881074071, -0.0030299746431410313, 0.004829205572605133, 0.022180309519171715, -0.031497176736593246, -0.001246165600605309, -0.006991548463702202, -0.08387883752584457, -0.00837048701941967, -0.07255235314369202, -0.009121960029006004, 0.0022122629452496767, -0.0014566199388355017, -0.03805813565850258, 0.013978920876979828, -0.028804024681448936, 0.016578400507569313, -0.061471108347177505, -0.007884995080530643, -0.06528405845165253, -0.04920964688062668, -0.019148211926221848, -0.06350115686655045, -0.011928235180675983, 0.022514592856168747, -0.044202741235494614, 0.027034973725676537, -0.096162348985672, -0.04976576566696167, 0.02125794067978859, 0.01958104409277439, 0.028857553377747536, -0.04824650287628174, -0.028631580993533134, 0.02668602764606476, 0.0782770961523056, 0.10876807570457458, 0.02357744798064232, -0.009981852024793625, -0.03651534393429756, -0.021994126960635185, -0.03111100383102894, 0.019023753702640533, 0.03912828117609024, -0.05280447006225586, 0.005036101210862398, 0.05655345320701599, 0.003691660473123193, -0.04989957809448242, -0.08342784643173218, 0.060144320130348206, -0.04444100335240364, -0.024526413530111313, 0.022735200822353363, -0.013037830591201782, -0.018753841519355774, 0.04481431841850281, -0.01105604786425829, -0.016701210290193558, 0.03921608626842499, -0.05299731716513634, -0.006793288979679346, 0.013332989066839218, 0.08981583267450333, -0.04619045555591583, 0.02169402688741684, 0.08672602474689484, 0.012870036996901035, -0.008696727454662323, -0.006923500448465347, -0.016833817586302757, 0.05059182643890381, -0.07154710590839386, 0.04180483892560005, -0.017773494124412537, 0.02776964195072651, -0.014320203103125095, -0.004965491127222776, 0.03528497740626335, 0.05045250430703163, -0.015532344579696655, 0.01351653691381216, -0.05850016698241234, 0.04028842970728874, 0.02746129222214222, -0.027655281126499176, 0.00621447991579771, 0.04197453334927559, 0.01764305867254734, 0.029953908175230026, -0.003759423503652215, 0.02781624160706997, -0.08099407702684402, -0.03744746372103691, -0.041806358844041824, -0.07567743211984634, 0.024077696725726128, 0.002449718303978443, 0.0031932133715599775, 0.07278107851743698, -0.009723944589495659, -0.08011144399642944, -0.027330322191119194, 0.03064102865755558, 0.053525540977716446, -0.14341767132282257, -0.018758395686745644, -0.00018573139095678926, 0.04531959816813469, -0.019547635689377785, 0.052069325000047684, 0.006338024046272039, -0.005297283176332712, -0.07797718793153763, -0.06937451660633087, -0.06782527267932892, 0.03662694990634918, -0.05536513403058052, -0.10969901084899902, 0.02304929308593273, 0.04263128340244293, 0.039840854704380035, 0.03223089873790741, 0.08681029826402664, 0.03269138187170029, 0.0010187228908762336, 0.037165068089962006, -0.08632969856262207, 0.032208167016506195, -0.02196565456688404, 0.06940754503011703, -0.05050944536924362, -0.02681650035083294, 0.06423773616552353, -0.03384657949209213, -0.005976811517030001, 0.03698364645242691, -0.02636265754699707, -0.015963219106197357, 0.06481009721755981, -0.006220530718564987, 0.09248948097229004, 0.0066263494081795216, -0.005887409672141075, -0.004092923831194639, -0.06654593348503113, 0.08977668732404709, 0.024393165484070778, 0.0012540902243927121, 0.056701600551605225, 0.07378841191530228, 0.002796695102006197, -0.017025718465447426, 0.04915304854512215, -0.059152740985155106, -0.018981045112013817, 0.026620423421263695, -0.04992026835680008, -0.01335776038467884, 0.007563547696918249, 0.10666771233081818, -0.042729370296001434, 0.014101444743573666, 0.041913602501153946, 0.01567271165549755, 0.12982861697673798, -0.022520476952195168, 0.019126679748296738, -0.0358540378510952, 0.012243656441569328, 0.032959017902612686, 0.0718388482928276, -0.017844069749116898, 0.08037186414003372, 0.018471019342541695, -0.04675913229584694, 0.03838840872049332, 0.058211226016283035, -0.04440223425626755, 0.03899960592389107, -0.09047519415616989, -0.052162714302539825, 0.03200539946556091, 0.05613662302494049, 0.05531283840537071, 0.038398660719394684, 0.02469121851027012, -0.05171266570687294, 0.06343737989664078, -0.14059020578861237, 0.015969293192029, 0.045387595891952515, 0.010105988942086697, -0.03009285032749176, -0.017964789643883705, 0.014726069755852222, -0.03562474250793457, 0.05870915204286575, 0.003949805162847042, 0.0009503726614639163, -0.03576216474175453, 0.01106955949217081, -0.05192582681775093, 0.00043144350638613105, 0.010023990646004677, 0.026946140453219414, -0.0242595374584198, -0.03112770803272724, -0.04064309597015381, -0.10779975354671478, -0.03752058744430542, 0.11331645399332047, 0.019313257187604904, 0.010465731844305992, 0.07381726801395416, -0.022359374910593033, 0.06419320404529572, 0.018291765823960304, 0.005145718343555927, -0.038019195199012756, -0.0027434052899479866, 0.012055551633238792, 0.02255084551870823, -0.006113001611083746, -0.012530652806162834, 0.0608145147562027, 0.02241389825940132, 0.015572585165500641, -0.05130893737077713, 0.03220906853675842, -0.012317636050283909, -0.03237895295023918, 0.03282462805509567, 0.021097594872117043, -0.018949631601572037, 0.01323257852345705, -0.07768089324235916, -0.06269663572311401, -0.023774471133947372, 0.014735228382050991, -0.030766306445002556, -0.010905289091169834, -0.014347536489367485, 0.01932935044169426, 0.02009628899395466, 0.015064457431435585, -0.026355445384979248, -0.01111541222780943, 0.006583155132830143, -0.02788969874382019, -0.0019064752850681543, 0.07298474758863449, 0.020945793017745018, -0.02172478288412094, -0.002712608315050602, 0.025995371863245964, -0.029108675196766853, 0.03263671696186066, 0.056461963802576065, -0.10799563676118851, -0.050717100501060486, 0.025754878297448158, 0.09113138169050217, -0.01641022600233555, -0.00921614933758974, 0.020512927323579788, -0.025420144200325012, 0.0018609203398227692, 0.0508292093873024, -0.01913023740053177, -0.009455027058720589, -0.004155182279646397, -0.013382909819483757, 0.005153025966137648, 0.036825112998485565, 0.009705674834549427, 0.04474921151995659, 0.003359583904966712, -0.02056564763188362, 0.035509902983903885, -0.012400820851325989, 0.06554370373487473, 0.032649241387844086, 0.012762223370373249, -0.0011121105635538697, -0.02633020095527172, 0.0637393668293953, 0.045346930623054504, -0.012521161697804928 ]
77
77
Information Width
Kolmogorov argued that the concept of information exists also in problems with no underlying stochastic model (as Shannon's information representation) for instance, the information contained in an algorithm or in the genome. He introduced a combinatorial notion of entropy and information $I(x:\sy)$ conveyed by a binary string $x$ about the unknown value of a variable $\sy$. The current paper poses the following questions: what is the relationship between the information conveyed by $x$ about $\sy$ to the description complexity of $x$ ? is there a notion of cost of information ? are there limits on how efficient $x$ conveys information ? To answer these questions Kolmogorov's definition is extended and a new concept termed {\em information width} which is similar to $n$-widths in approximation theory is introduced. Information of any input source, e.g., sample-based, general side-information or a hybrid of both can be evaluated by a single common formula. An application to the space of binary functions is considered.
[ -0.053480762988328934, 0.008096263743937016, 0.01982593536376953, -0.02800271473824978, 0.004691296257078648, -0.05396315082907677, 0.0522158108651638, -0.009237358346581459, -0.04458877816796303, 0.008966673165559769, 0.04098723083734512, -0.04541497305035591, -0.02351369895040989, 0.000324597698636353, -0.0723414421081543, -0.029799312353134155, 0.004683570936322212, -0.003566367318853736, 0.052010346204042435, -0.0440245196223259, -0.02143813669681549, 0.10564214736223221, -0.02966955490410328, -0.021432656794786453, -0.0011982995783910155, -0.02261793240904808, -0.033920768648386, 0.026554640382528305, -0.07801253348588943, -0.018019508570432663, -0.09399466961622238, 0.048221196979284286, 0.029921215027570724, 0.06797364354133606, 0.007858757860958576, 0.020210349932312965, -0.008537236601114273, -0.022403186187148094, -0.008634859696030617, -0.04201185330748558, -0.015666691586375237, 0.0398995503783226, 0.004039011895656586, -0.0012218960328027606, 0.017582479864358902, -0.0021850827615708113, 0.01829797402024269, 0.03642453998327255, 0.061776336282491684, 0.070108562707901, -0.10432126373052597, 0.03373286500573158, -0.020350003615021706, -0.07567623257637024, 0.01826818846166134, 0.08309449255466461, 0.017769981175661087, -0.020701939240098, -0.008832803927361965, 0.014188083820044994, 0.01877552643418312, 0.11959442496299744, 0.017917096614837646, 0.006714478600770235, -0.033045049756765366, -0.03593921661376953, -0.14361129701137543, -0.016011876985430717, -0.01799475960433483, -0.027354411780834198, -0.03472156822681427, -0.02972700633108616, 0.07774944603443146, 0.08553081005811691, 0.040761858224868774, 0.012580922804772854, 0.020952356979250908, 0.018007824197411537, -0.0371861532330513, 0.10987482964992523, -0.06313543766736984, 0.07407724857330322, -0.04393860697746277, -0.07451219856739044, -0.13903595507144928, 0.01779145747423172, -0.018252728506922722, -0.02214233949780464, 0.040384311228990555, -0.008409878239035606, 0.00296148844063282, 0.049136046320199966, 0.004064172971993685, 0.02394258789718151, 0.016415180638432503, 0.09900475293397903, -0.03915915638208389, -0.05125315487384796, 0.021400336176156998, -0.03248681128025055, 0.01997119002044201, -0.09524468332529068, 0.07569454610347748, -0.023938974365592003, -0.00957989040762186, -0.015017978847026825, -0.0367765873670578, 0.05109569430351257, 0.013141506351530552, -0.06712277978658676, -0.026385266333818436, -0.025272004306316376, -0.0450580008327961, 0.008208978921175003, -0.08013126254081726, 0.030621206387877464, 0.008208605460822582, 0.03981639817357063, 0.03287636488676071, 0.023638516664505005, 0.047528449445962906, 0.042555175721645355, 0.0027375726494938135, 0.06158261001110077, -0.01691032573580742, -0.05616951361298561, -0.0018277891213074327, -0.017834631726145744, 0.13373447954654694, 0.031661804765462875, -0.06262076646089554, 0.002397677628323436, 0.01976451836526394, -0.0032967180013656616, -0.03232673183083534, 0.048394396901130676, 0.11742877215147018, -0.00665557524189353, 0.009825725108385086, -0.029026295989751816, 0.00656380457803607, -0.03487074002623558, -0.009525001980364323, -0.06982533633708954, 0.04333825409412384, 0.12018173187971115, 0.01980486698448658, 0.038212209939956665, 0.05459781363606453, -0.024184444919228554, -0.053578492254018784, 0.023793144151568413, 0.006064269226044416, 0.03580138087272644, 0.031850047409534454, -0.0528574213385582, -0.07203899323940277, -0.013217629864811897, -0.00017564005975145847, -0.013650924898684025, -0.07304470986127853, -0.0018725390546023846, 0.0612974539399147, 0.04908685013651848, -0.018139753490686417, 0.0304269902408123, -0.0635831356048584, -0.06956283003091812, 0.016369108110666275, 0.03911840543150902, -0.011580567806959152, -0.03140231594443321, 0.022041568532586098, 0.04589815065264702, -0.002706189639866352, 0.049180466681718826, -0.0385221429169178, 0.0009343386627733707, 0.021368181332945824, -0.015555021353065968, 0.0026107176672667265, -0.058027442544698715, -0.028112681582570076, -0.0011796996695920825, 0.010193920694291592, 0.07359322160482407, -0.003725798334926367, 0.007877543568611145, 0.03636816516518593, 0.007593902759253979, 0.0910087525844574, 0.02065957523882389, 0.028830869123339653, 0.012053417041897774, 0.015362482517957687, 0.01728389598429203, -0.016990747302770615, -0.018734484910964966, -0.06608476489782333, 0.027300704270601273, 0.028905926272273064, 0.048863478004932404, -0.01076891552656889, 0.01169745996594429, -0.03589217737317085, 0.0011255756253376603, 0.01980537734925747, 0.005605724174529314, 0.025268953293561935, -0.0055940477177500725, -0.016924206167459488, 0.026570836082100868, 0.03147938475012779, 0.010447082109749317, 0.057612258940935135, -0.05585220083594322, -0.005083546508103609, 0.03611929342150688, 0.00475463829934597, 0.03617674857378006, 0.07396191358566284, -0.0010704302694648504, -0.0029459816869348288, 0.03931952640414238, -0.05733171105384827, 0.009784070774912834, 0.020658450201153755, -0.04557414352893829, -0.04667149484157562, 0.03366635739803314, 0.030432110652327538, -0.09497324377298355, -0.08012162894010544, -0.07264372706413269, 0.03388197720050812, 0.04223603382706642, 0.01604391820728779, 0.02363511733710766, -0.0039562927559018135, 0.05349772796034813, -0.06109358370304108, 0.14165247976779938, -0.010977713391184807, 0.024170564487576485, 0.03428257629275322, 0.038074396550655365, 0.0736396312713623, 0.042048897594213486, 0.033821120858192444, -0.04095803201198578, 0.004424429498612881, 0.005761940497905016, 0.0023810449056327343, -0.02094808965921402, 0.0835752859711647, -0.006194150075316429, -0.021152591332793236, -0.013470637612044811, 0.05038847774267197, 0.01745891012251377, -0.04324430599808693, 0.01525523979216814, -0.03663775324821472, 0.01434638537466526, 0.009194016456604004, 0.01325304340571165, 0.0011823131935670972, 0.005328659433871508, 0.059059228748083115, 0.037221722304821014, 0.03175677731633186, 0.02202961966395378, -0.041626572608947754, 0.08299095183610916, -0.025463471189141273, -0.0060577415861189365, 0.036131806671619415, 0.029928935691714287, -0.07875111699104309, -0.09904001653194427, -0.03285118192434311, 0.015109336003661156, -0.05489697679877281, -0.04850718006491661, -0.020276598632335663, 0.05944286659359932, -0.036828357726335526, 0.010613502934575081, 0.0248763095587492, 0.04556507244706154, -0.0451250784099102, 0.005722926929593086, -0.10634264349937439, -0.04096116125583649, -0.0038873653393238783, -0.01886914297938347, 0.03182673826813698, -0.02112649939954281, -0.013929408974945545, -0.07029592245817184, 0.007351818028837442, -0.04312584176659584, 0.06770727783441544, -0.004493211396038532, 0.03212430700659752, -0.0026388210244476795, 0.049942776560783386, 0.028207486495375633, -0.06692826002836227, 0.04978388175368309, 0.006592780817300081, 0.026509646326303482, -0.04660593718290329, 0.02210286073386669, -0.01491065789014101, 0.014941064640879631, -0.037450212985277176, 0.005569105967879295, -0.019244849681854248, -0.02688354253768921, -0.008930901065468788, -0.008551073260605335, -0.014054098166525364, -0.07999546080827713, -0.09113088995218277, 0.03773874789476395, -0.05217736214399338, -0.03489803150296211, -0.07720822840929031, 0.01891903579235077, -0.12030496448278427, -0.021266117691993713, 0.013487090356647968, 0.12137698382139206, -0.03740759193897247, -0.014921987429261208, -0.025386502966284752, 0.04231322184205055, -0.07759392261505127, 0.006731140892952681, -0.005955033469945192, -0.10063471645116806, -0.018087074160575867, 0.050205159932374954, 0.025758378207683563, 0.005491658113896847, 0.05300154164433479, -0.04762822017073631, 0.04397633671760559, -0.013204335235059261, -0.017766578122973442, 0.07548452913761139, -0.05172443017363548, 0.03637108579277992, 0.04240747541189194, 0.07699988782405853, 0.06572236120700836, 0.04611887037754059, 0.06597165018320084, 0.009465079754590988, 0.04264034330844879, 0.03680349886417389, 0.018179388716816902, -0.023976383730769157, 0.00002050189686997328, 0.02716413326561451, -0.020839635282754898, 0.005192416254431009, 0.005102550145238638, 0.07675787061452866, 0.038964394479990005, 0.04298523813486099, 0.06261257082223892, -0.06558490544557571, 0.008833365514874458, -0.03928056359291077, 0.04671541973948479, -0.028817489743232727, 0.04734176769852638, 0.017294542863965034, -0.07815154641866684, -0.002493692096322775, 0.001495333039201796, -0.052485473453998566, -0.016005562618374825, -0.00364639307372272, -0.027501527220010757, -0.008948731236159801, 0.08069752901792526, 0.016122106462717056, -0.0031334434170275927, 0.028348296880722046, -0.034015215933322906, -0.004234356805682182, 0.04925314337015152, -0.016073264181613922, 0.00596854230388999, -0.024334751069545746, 0.04331384226679802, -0.019433518871665, -0.06075244024395943, -0.06956178694963455, 0.012140153907239437, -0.017049893736839294, -0.07185784727334976, 0.015164898708462715, 0.07075464725494385, -0.003132629906758666, -0.04221552982926369, -0.025991810485720634, 0.030910253524780273, -0.029544647783041, -0.01623731479048729, 0.0553147979080677, 0.03723752498626709, -0.01132920291274786, 0.04797259345650673, 0.00997396744787693, 0.006383606232702732, -0.04217704385519028, -0.002317578997462988, -0.013040700927376747, -0.08096686750650406, -0.030169030651450157, 0.02422521449625492, 0.01711978204548359, 0.08635970950126648, 0.04397045075893402, -0.04848681017756462, 0.027115250006318092, -0.03163732960820198, -0.058118436485528946, -0.01863848604261875, -0.005721921566873789, 0.042044829577207565, 0.039579860866069794, -0.0031477559823542833, -0.0435219332575798, -0.027280502021312714, -0.042515117675065994, -0.009565029293298721, 0.05893257260322571, 0.08821410685777664, 0.06534899026155472, 0.034045517444610596, -0.048485539853572845, 0.010804250836372375, 0.004471023101359606, 0.04126293212175369, 0.02744564786553383, -0.051288753747940063, -0.04533914104104042, 0.05431962013244629, -0.02588743343949318, 0.027604885399341583, -0.03933386132121086, -0.04755894094705582, -0.000911373586859554, 0.04010568559169769, 0.012748174369335175, 0.025716228410601616, -0.01616068184375763, -0.010714540258049965, 0.005566757638007402, -0.07845602929592133, -0.01932607777416706, 0.02900952287018299, -0.03342093899846077, 0.05629541352391243, 0.010028141550719738, -0.06018789857625961, -0.07585649192333221, 0.03243241459131241, -0.01969897747039795, 0.04314403980970383, 0.046162571758031845, -0.006667095236480236, -0.08398453146219254, -0.005358879454433918, -0.07725822180509567, 0.008438164368271828, -0.01027445588260889, -0.03447853401303291, 0.023346181958913803, 0.0436711311340332, 0.027024151757359505, 0.0011585219763219357, -0.01846172846853733, 0.01983746513724327, 0.003283150028437376, 0.09705948084592819, -0.06561093777418137, -0.05841453745961189, -0.04355236515402794, 0.034974344074726105, 0.02797754481434822, -0.040211908519268036, 0.021329695358872414, 0.0035023479722440243, 0.054661545902490616, -0.005464046727865934, 0.053224701434373856, 0.005589958280324936, 0.02704884298145771, 0.024972476065158844, 0.009623564779758453, 0.10420925170183182, -0.041325606405735016, -0.01184525154531002, -0.007357330527156591, 0.008684980683028698, 0.01626054383814335 ]
78
78
On the Complexity of Binary Samples
Consider a class $\mH$ of binary functions $h: X\to\{-1, +1\}$ on a finite interval $X=[0, B]\subset \Real$. Define the {\em sample width} of $h$ on a finite subset (a sample) $S\subset X$ as $\w_S(h) \equiv \min_{x\in S} |\w_h(x)|$, where $\w_h(x) = h(x) \max\{a\geq 0: h(z)=h(x), x-a\leq z\leq x+a\}$. Let $\mathbb{S}_\ell$ be the space of all samples in $X$ of cardinality $\ell$ and consider sets of wide samples, i.e., {\em hypersets} which are defined as $A_{\beta, h} = \{S\in \mathbb{S}_\ell: \w_{S}(h) \geq \beta\}$. Through an application of the Sauer-Shelah result on the density of sets an upper estimate is obtained on the growth function (or trace) of the class $\{A_{\beta, h}: h\in\mH\}$, $\beta>0$, i.e., on the number of possible dichotomies obtained by intersecting all hypersets with a fixed collection of samples $S\in\mathbb{S}_\ell$ of cardinality $m$. The estimate is $2\sum_{i=0}^{2\lfloor B/(2\beta)\rfloor}{m-\ell\choose i}$.
[ -0.07669923454523087, -0.052398547530174255, 0.02056529000401497, 0.04523633420467377, -0.038429103791713715, -0.06726998835802078, -0.06623934954404831, -0.032174285501241684, -0.06479452550411224, -0.01863967999815941, 0.0038760118186473846, -0.03523457795381546, -0.008779069408774376, 0.1164383664727211, -0.05433553457260132, 0.012805348262190819, -0.048686232417821884, 0.025328466668725014, 0.06107383221387863, -0.036779530346393585, -0.012334735132753849, 0.0052847061306238174, -0.022717829793691635, -0.017873339354991913, 0.021656090393662453, -0.026037568226456642, -0.030472179874777794, 0.023951435461640358, -0.021150322631001472, 0.01230684109032154, -0.03712484613060951, 0.022439051419496536, -0.023761311545968056, 0.017177632078528404, -0.03507278114557266, 0.012265713885426521, 0.0027415649965405464, -0.056893445551395416, -0.01407491322606802, 0.004862275905907154, -0.005823057144880295, 0.01959979720413685, -0.0025814448017627, -0.051458414644002914, 0.028731800615787506, 0.0869913399219513, 0.029400719329714775, 0.023191962391138077, -0.013451472856104374, 0.028823258355259895, -0.11774315685033798, 0.005894154775887728, -0.06841278821229935, -0.07058011740446091, -0.014923788607120514, 0.06423274427652359, 0.002226229989901185, 0.05211834982037544, -0.0567086897790432, 0.052223123610019684, 0.015056357719004154, 0.08868272602558136, -0.06438574939966202, -0.05356530845165253, 0.0416848249733448, -0.05037987604737282, -0.12623271346092224, -0.01344098150730133, 0.022253762930631638, -0.08376584947109222, -0.05471101030707359, -0.0635201558470726, 0.020952532067894936, 0.03724203258752823, -0.0014221317833289504, -0.04876355826854706, -0.012283950112760067, 0.09503129124641418, -0.023371141403913498, 0.07204015552997589, -0.06074192374944687, -0.011756721884012222, 0.025437284260988235, 0.0017350184498354793, -0.10887783020734787, -0.03100159578025341, 0.04238036647439003, 0.030101008713245392, 0.027340702712535858, -0.017180372029542923, 0.01935580186545849, 0.0646897405385971, -0.07571584731340408, 0.012657803483307362, -0.0788707360625267, 0.10541509091854095, -0.044770341366529465, 0.07194078713655472, -0.02488662302494049, -0.014371687546372414, 0.007406935095787048, -0.060746755450963974, 0.03323739394545555, -0.05459447577595711, 0.06386715918779373, 0.014532042667269707, -0.00903930701315403, 0.06038789451122284, -0.026995940133929253, -0.04324645176529884, 0.04845723137259483, -0.050643227994441986, -0.058550309389829636, 0.05618123337626457, -0.07757791876792908, 0.024137673899531364, 0.03863755613565445, 0.03435822203755379, -0.0012969911331310868, 0.041129082441329956, 0.011929602362215519, 0.05793595686554909, 0.04918085038661957, 0.04131684824824333, -0.01408934872597456, -0.00815369188785553, 0.03523062542080879, 0.009480373933911324, 0.09142820537090302, -0.032484978437423706, -0.05680929496884346, -0.026891687884926796, -0.03840091824531555, 0.033958494663238525, -0.07387829571962357, 0.03444188833236694, 0.04611906781792641, 0.05912729725241661, 0.02346663735806942, 0.03342683985829353, -0.05289789289236069, -0.0485694445669651, 0.03640887513756752, 0.034293193370103836, 0.02235523983836174, 0.04000579193234444, 0.015137331560254097, 0.05442877858877182, 0.013402129523456097, -0.02248539589345455, -0.0143521036952734, -0.033074505627155304, 0.015583234839141369, -0.016731759533286095, 0.0667046308517456, -0.020352952182292938, 0.04242447018623352, 0.10049671679735184, 0.003439101856201887, -0.01433464977890253, -0.0862477570772171, -0.01828342117369175, 0.10643894970417023, 0.0230900589376688, -0.0029794068541377783, 0.0013237616512924433, -0.008765866048634052, -0.021785536780953407, 0.03220820054411888, 0.00850958563387394, -0.03697163611650467, -0.0010599946836009622, -0.0025442640762776136, -0.0016445042565464973, -0.017261436209082603, 0.05763508751988411, 0.032818395644426346, 0.03182896599173546, -0.02440810576081276, 0.030170099809765816, 0.02854877896606922, -0.02633197419345379, -0.061605293303728104, 0.010106312111020088, 0.0644100084900856, 0.053363390266895294, 0.003971300087869167, 0.05914236232638359, 0.06040848046541214, -0.02361851930618286, 0.04945385083556175, -0.0007694827509112656, -0.03622429445385933, -0.07429899275302887, -0.012917117215692997, -0.04576347768306732, -0.04824018105864525, -0.0221165269613266, 0.007032454013824463, 0.02915211208164692, -0.029564978554844856, -0.03580154478549957, -0.01781974546611309, -0.02750471793115139, 0.006978996098041534, 0.011671412736177444, -0.04228322207927704, -0.007518152240663767, 0.009559256955981255, -0.013812834396958351, -0.02091488428413868, 0.028794990852475166, 0.07017556577920914, -0.02937307022511959, 0.026463206857442856, -0.028279095888137817, -0.00701240124180913, -0.016588682308793068, -0.00846032239496708, 0.06557469815015793, 0.0035646443720906973, 0.013512866571545601, -0.04261677339673042, 0.0019582374952733517, -0.0955178514122963, 0.04680221155285835, -0.017222197726368904, -0.048997171223163605, -0.013656227849423885, 0.0950997993350029, -0.058143578469753265, -0.02260766364634037, -0.049549952149391174, -0.08655790984630585, 0.009961271658539772, 0.01772838644683361, -0.027297228574752808, 0.07382091134786606, -0.007806502282619476, 0.015231143683195114, -0.035404499620199203, 0.04207862168550491, -0.0074049630202353, -0.026916533708572388, -0.023649372160434723, -0.09732475876808167, 0.07224137336015701, 0.025699637830257416, 0.010479922406375408, 0.025450825691223145, 0.022185251116752625, 0.017623750492930412, -0.03103938139975071, -0.022068502381443977, 0.008023749105632305, 0.07027073204517365, 0.0070421588607132435, 0.048727426677942276, 0.059060122817754745, 0.05846302583813667, 0.08544982969760895, 0.04041670262813568, -0.00982937403023243, 0.03047366999089718, 0.06882458180189133, 0.05763890966773033, -0.0018544401973485947, -0.0039623798802495, -0.01156618632376194, 0.04097085818648338, 0.04314293712377548, -0.015220089815557003, 0.005994912702590227, 0.04373101145029068, 0.0017846475820988417, 0.02232491411268711, 0.06504800170660019, 0.03138227388262749, 0.029716243967413902, -0.08586865663528442, 0.009797568432986736, 0.032664213329553604, -0.011290526948869228, -0.053631510585546494, 0.0036303906235843897, 0.1048690676689148, 0.004292821511626244, -0.015263649635016918, 0.004004452843219042, 0.00980833638459444, 0.0008050105534493923, -0.005997887346893549, -0.028134914115071297, 0.04391612857580185, 0.0661955177783966, 0.023137984797358513, 0.06967848539352417, 0.00420268764719367, 0.028049057349562645, 0.017096053808927536, -0.017207469791173935, 0.07870934903621674, 0.07554922252893448, -0.0003004575555678457, 0.025038793683052063, 0.06607278436422348, -0.0005905668367631733, -0.008961337618529797, -0.04378529265522957, 0.07745108008384705, 0.009184077382087708, -0.07896237820386887, -0.045696571469306946, -0.05195231735706329, 0.012239720672369003, -0.030053284019231796, -0.012763743288815022, -0.017165962606668472, -0.012791577726602554, 0.0015336439246311784, 0.02926461026072502, -0.02911369502544403, -0.013230890966951847, -0.050084855407476425, -0.08655097335577011, -0.018762357532978058, 0.023267891258001328, 0.00774031225591898, -0.10717403143644333, 0.009287796914577484, 0.006564711686223745, 0.0003921327879652381, -0.007260803133249283, 0.1213146448135376, -0.04958019033074379, 0.048582304269075394, -0.027525773271918297, 0.03830070048570633, -0.07714971154928207, -0.041218288242816925, 0.004690922796726227, -0.021577958017587662, -0.00025322005967609584, 0.0023178793489933014, 0.0011972340289503336, -0.02647419460117817, 0.07010585069656372, 0.04736100509762764, -0.03728456795215607, -0.028490057215094566, -0.13632932305335999, 0.10626335442066193, -0.06288781762123108, 0.0344647541642189, -0.006134514231234789, 0.04441756382584572, 0.05912824720144272, 0.02504006028175354, 0.02054901421070099, 0.0094121303409338, -0.033118005841970444, 0.023714255541563034, -0.016107363626360893, -0.008998826146125793, -0.005871403496712446, 0.0509696900844574, -0.0590091347694397, -0.03013572283089161, -0.018777845427393913, 0.007140778005123138, -0.012261549942195415, 0.004415315575897694, 0.028094638139009476, 0.00930855330079794, 0.04758734256029129, -0.010372796095907688, -0.002814620966091752, -0.009107972495257854, -0.005094490945339203, 0.026052536442875862, 0.0022088068071752787, -0.021452538669109344, -0.06025188788771629, 0.024606291204690933, 0.002181799616664648, -0.005154192913323641, -0.020168015733361244, 0.07763920724391937, 0.08936404436826706, -0.00617827195674181, -0.000044312342652119696, -0.09288164228200912, 0.0017672221874818206, 0.04142676293849945, -0.01180367823690176, 0.06562835723161697, 0.010737678967416286, -0.019619883969426155, -0.010664446279406548, -0.04648060351610184, -0.06381586939096451, -0.07148775458335876, -0.0029792555142194033, -0.012557520531117916, -0.090367391705513, 0.012195132672786713, 0.09284629672765732, 0.00841938704252243, -0.07454010099172592, 0.06218031793832779, 0.021014023572206497, -0.051592327654361725, -0.030935795977711678, 0.06600010395050049, 0.011777177453041077, -0.0007812497788108885, -0.010809899307787418, -0.05133530870079994, -0.020781775936484337, -0.06170225515961647, -0.03727520629763603, 0.05937441810965538, -0.07382647693157196, -0.01932835578918457, -0.02736402116715908, -0.0178091861307621, -0.026119189336895943, 0.07407976686954498, -0.06385994702577591, 0.03855344280600548, -0.0638749971985817, -0.10818109661340714, -0.020600829273462296, -0.004277275875210762, 0.034309349954128265, -0.007597673684358597, -0.03498445078730583, -0.031215069815516472, -0.04470907151699066, -0.012178178876638412, -0.10215116292238235, 0.00013068574480712414, -0.005419631488621235, 0.014834120869636536, -0.004835876170545816, 0.04549400508403778, 0.030699042603373528, -0.027905292809009552, 0.0469186007976532, 0.017484676092863083, -0.00971231423318386, 0.025765156373381615, -0.03275357559323311, -0.032207757234573364, -0.045542798936367035, -0.008542648516595364, -0.0024489732459187508, -0.00014313274004962295, 0.05214129015803337, 0.018938502296805382, 0.002989106811583042, -0.09065824002027512, 0.02655458077788353, 0.04047611728310585, -0.10052715986967087, 0.0059678563848137856, -0.014017450623214245, -0.03510785847902298, -0.0015790049219503999, -0.01808135025203228, -0.062208183109760284, 0.007916525937616825, -0.01922951266169548, -0.03742476925253868, 0.04001544415950775, -0.005163714289665222, -0.040868211537599564, -0.0948321744799614, 0.024567950516939163, -0.04032106325030327, -0.0025534534361213446, -0.024776067584753036, -0.042819585651159286, -0.012579974718391895, 0.03993203863501549, -0.021797440946102142, 0.05902857333421707, 0.08054818212985992, -0.05814993008971214, 0.010574921034276485, 0.005359705537557602, -0.02887365035712719, -0.010242948308587074, 0.019324108958244324, 0.07017000019550323, -0.003241176949813962, -0.015606752596795559, 0.008641033433377743, 0.07464519888162613, -0.004785237368196249, -0.023296693339943886, 0.006207064259797335, 0.08096496015787125, 0.009860454127192497, 0.02170826680958271, 0.05970746651291847, 0.002830518875271082, -0.04978952929377556, -0.02984648011624813, -0.018013184890151024, 0.08411578088998795, -0.022850675508379936 ]
79
79
New Estimation Procedures for PLS Path Modelling
Given R groups of numerical variables X1, ... XR, we assume that each group is the result of one underlying latent variable, and that all latent variables are bound together through a linear equation system. Moreover, we assume that some explanatory latent variables may interact pairwise in one or more equations. We basically consider PLS Path Modelling's algorithm to estimate both latent variables and the model's coefficients. New "external" estimation schemes are proposed that draw latent variables towards strong group structures in a more flexible way. New "internal" estimation schemes are proposed to enable PLSPM to make good use of variable group complementarity and to deal with interactions. Application examples are given.
[ 0.013772674836218357, 0.009392429143190384, -0.0373537614941597, 0.002000621287152171, 0.0703650489449501, 0.03130219504237175, 0.05035829171538353, -0.06257249414920807, 0.029956715181469917, -0.018894759938120842, 0.018333418294787407, -0.009898175485432148, -0.024575892835855484, 0.026165606454014778, -0.06344597041606903, 0.011112944222986698, 0.011017593555152416, 0.024450963363051414, 0.03690442815423012, -0.008592134341597557, 0.056133873760700226, 0.014765952713787556, 0.0421597920358181, -0.053490426391363144, 0.1265256404876709, -0.07607035338878632, -0.030673382803797722, -0.024949416518211365, 0.021477147936820984, -0.006908328738063574, -0.05020694434642792, 0.09058358520269394, -0.002665615640580654, -0.025600945577025414, 0.02910405769944191, -0.07602262496948242, 0.03025858849287033, 0.062227584421634674, -0.07646302878856659, 0.0033447768073529005, -0.00885128416121006, -0.008917570114135742, 0.0009529138915240765, -0.004557283595204353, 0.047532953321933746, 0.005427307449281216, 0.01442127674818039, 0.010333400219678879, 0.01865995302796364, 0.025552742183208466, -0.07856327295303345, 0.004732987843453884, -0.03687221556901932, 0.014835139736533165, 0.013127194717526436, -0.04953773319721222, 0.0016145899426192045, -0.001312391017563641, -0.04102924466133118, -0.002645602449774742, 0.06126151978969574, 0.07332747429609299, -0.03568507358431816, 0.017989888787269592, -0.07759322971105576, -0.01383591815829277, 0.00174501514993608, -0.04958010092377663, -0.05086681991815567, -0.08600172400474548, 0.03201049193739891, -0.024731071665883064, 0.0019587476272135973, -0.023081611841917038, 0.037916477769613266, -0.01595504954457283, -0.013020007871091366, -0.07797076553106308, 0.013672973029315472, 0.06360508501529694, 0.005810887552797794, -0.010198953561484814, -0.050470009446144104, 0.023159366101026535, -0.08861236274242401, -0.012380814179778099, 0.026639580726623535, -0.023811113089323044, 0.03338645398616791, -0.10658960044384003, -0.0433756560087204, 0.04835851863026619, -0.022124912589788437, 0.044259458780288696, -0.02654998004436493, 0.00272105704061687, -0.04429217800498009, -0.01352183148264885, -0.0635288879275322, 0.02161349542438984, 0.022907070815563202, 0.03845369070768356, 0.027308233082294464, 0.05630126968026161, -0.008626535534858704, 0.07131516933441162, -0.08244770765304565, 0.07320784777402878, -0.018847540020942688, 0.05183976888656616, 0.03828788176178932, -0.03130471333861351, 0.05976909026503563, 0.046555906534194946, -0.0695808157324791, 0.13061915338039398, 0.014928369782865047, 0.057046592235565186, -0.01758407987654209, 0.05670745670795441, 0.008577338419854641, -0.03597800433635712, -0.07560388743877411, -0.006768134422600269, -0.029570385813713074, -0.04482388123869896, -0.03106507658958435, -0.04548175632953644, 0.017033688724040985, -0.04033344238996506, -0.08349570631980896, 0.007761653978377581, -0.02803518995642662, -0.012974846176803112, -0.01580493524670601, 0.09266888350248337, 0.01006649062037468, 0.018598387017846107, -0.04896719008684158, 0.030972134321928024, -0.033477842807769775, -0.0003141878405585885, -0.012792850844562054, -0.0008256462751887739, 0.04890883341431618, 0.0064183506183326244, 0.03146153315901756, -0.024506721645593643, -0.006413592025637627, -0.014155914075672626, -0.0021930611692368984, -0.010902783833444118, 0.05398135632276535, -0.0018828280735760927, 0.0044771768152713776, -0.0364406444132328, -0.0640590712428093, -0.07502816617488861, 0.02275608852505684, 0.05495699495077133, -0.005504869390279055, -0.014432580210268497, 0.027571214362978935, 0.046504564583301544, -0.03737204149365425, -0.03375737741589546, -0.058843716979026794, -0.010824975557625294, -0.04467490315437317, -0.09260733425617218, -0.04384202882647514, 0.014348182827234268, -0.03032989613711834, -0.03356621786952019, 0.0503496415913105, -0.08672427386045456, 0.016074156388640404, 0.05913121998310089, -0.017158009111881256, 0.03071196936070919, 0.05404497683048248, -0.03787534683942795, -0.00472084479406476, 0.002710908418521285, 0.036738425493240356, 0.042044494301080704, 0.02171233668923378, 0.0036074675153940916, -0.00012240120850037783, -0.01893967017531395, -0.0037967124953866005, 0.02816249243915081, -0.05820135027170181, -0.026450155302882195, -0.04297751560807228, 0.04461059719324112, 0.0035987095907330513, -0.03080902062356472, 0.04712161049246788, 0.03070957027375698, 0.046356201171875, 0.014807716943323612, -0.09001202881336212, -0.0737408772110939, -0.036482423543930054, 0.05914934724569321, -0.00722959078848362, -0.03406389430165291, -0.00381093705072999, 0.010676967911422253, 0.027469925582408905, -0.0014259967720136046, -0.035746391862630844, -0.10385293513536453, 0.002557093510404229, -0.025295350700616837, -0.019385671243071556, -0.04611668363213539, 0.04383384436368942, 0.026645442470908165, -0.0021604348439723253, 0.06063215062022209, -0.013421976007521152, 0.02744635008275509, -0.07301277667284012, -0.04908888041973114, 0.0352320559322834, -0.07004938274621964, -0.11057732254266739, -0.03460456430912018, 0.00501297228038311, -0.011418415233492851, -0.01561158150434494, 0.034159254282712936, 0.0009588681859895587, 0.05810851231217384, -0.07428275793790817, -0.08041706681251526, 0.024826504290103912, 0.013570287264883518, -0.019559534266591072, 0.061903584748506546, 0.0506015419960022, -0.02324141561985016, 0.02021392248570919, -0.07921408116817474, 0.010964909568428993, 0.0256603192538023, -0.09626010060310364, 0.092350535094738, 0.034289706498384476, -0.012924772687256336, -0.020266210660338402, -0.036692019551992416, -0.006536959670484066, 0.030240381136536598, -0.04729687422513962, 0.014837261289358139, -0.018838586285710335, 0.09137824922800064, 0.024580875411629677, 0.04114486649632454, -0.023811819031834602, 0.003772784024477005, 0.06290284544229507, 0.0066311974078416824, 0.054788555949926376, 0.018981831148266792, 0.01128251850605011, 0.017463207244873047, -0.020042290911078453, -0.03299695625901222, -0.1178540512919426, -0.0036757446359843016, 0.00003299074887763709, -0.002922275336459279, 0.014290951192378998, 0.09034323692321777, 0.019875280559062958, -0.07685253024101257, -0.054783958941698074, 0.022741341963410378, 0.010186774656176567, -0.0724475085735321, -0.0008126052562147379, 0.050363652408123016, 0.002175381174311042, 0.004731729160994291, 0.013101599179208279, 0.027760639786720276, -0.03316406160593033, 0.01548248901963234, -0.03236813470721245, 0.07892956584692001, 0.010500278323888779, -0.0008228820515796542, 0.008445960469543934, 0.07712753117084503, 0.0010411236435174942, -0.019818754866719246, 0.00013892138667870313, 0.02761108987033367, 0.030624480918049812, 0.006429068744182587, 0.02115476317703724, 0.08451893925666809, 0.09445975720882416, 0.10739501565694809, 0.008963077329099178, -0.06785496324300766, 0.02630518190562725, -0.05087972432374954, -0.05940202623605728, -0.0037358247209340334, -0.03611726313829422, -0.06291879713535309, -0.04306568577885628, -0.06377438455820084, -0.03866687789559364, -0.023540835827589035, -0.011711759492754936, -0.018228843808174133, 0.06893832981586456, -0.08605163544416428, -0.002335034077987075, -0.007020620163530111, 0.005957526620477438, 0.08171632140874863, -0.008855892345309258, 0.06875891238451004, -0.017274826765060425, 0.012268186546862125, -0.0400814451277256, 0.04918123781681061, -0.004466078709810972, -0.021951822564005852, -0.07138913124799728, 0.02585475891828537, 0.03612498193979263, -0.015534386038780212, 0.021333618089556694, -0.07545431703329086, -0.020026396960020065, 0.0041159153915941715, -0.021928859874606133, 0.05878984183073044, 0.09381451457738876, -0.05288657173514366, -0.03968704491853714, -0.05135876685380936, -0.044579748064279556, -0.05472440645098686, -0.09517697989940643, 0.047500934451818466, -0.035264287143945694, 0.037889957427978516, 0.038333598524332047, 0.014673348516225815, 0.008959760889410973, 0.06057935953140259, -0.0696350485086441, 0.0020052464678883553, 0.03245355188846588, -0.02754754200577736, -0.0013643770944327116, 0.025116033852100372, -0.023109007626771927, -0.00305169983766973, 0.03630939871072769, -0.03450937569141388, 0.06023316830396652, -0.023364296182990074, 0.12128347903490067, -0.0349888801574707, -0.009920974262058735, -0.005887135397642851, 0.026216402649879456, -0.045718107372522354, -0.010453423485159874, 0.036681730300188065, -0.01394989900290966, -0.05437496677041054, -0.08364862203598022, 0.0014541861601173878, 0.024363506585359573, -0.08520188927650452, 0.0003321277617942542, 0.015585591085255146, -0.0265936478972435, -0.006302239373326302, -0.07457450777292252, -0.018102526664733887, 0.0744585171341896, -0.013667280785739422, 0.01540082786232233, 0.12144006043672562, -0.02175035886466503, -0.007366630714386702, -0.046835530549287796, -0.04522120952606201, -0.017836017534136772, 0.06346309930086136, -0.010799974203109741, -0.08096062391996384, -0.03559330850839615, 0.007225006818771362, 0.010275282897055149, -0.0034590219147503376, 0.030033305287361145, 0.026078905910253525, -0.0569504052400589, 0.07961125671863556, -0.04848164692521095, -0.012459217570722103, -0.017054952681064606, -0.01954697258770466, 0.02138659916818142, 0.09654280543327332, 0.00807404238730669, -0.07324621081352234, -0.0042494796216487885, 0.016351697966456413, 0.016512813046574593, 0.036186542361974716, 0.03794458508491516, -0.03512737527489662, 0.03393096104264259, 0.05308011919260025, 0.0015246628317981958, -0.028469525277614594, 0.025253821164369583, -0.028248636052012444, -0.014368620701134205, 0.05407389625906944, 0.012898916378617287, -0.04747040197253227, -0.024112002924084663, -0.056582409888505936, 0.09164722263813019, 0.036878522485494614, 0.005771446507424116, 0.014983202330768108, -0.007478833664208651, -0.025783542543649673, -0.020943930372595787, 0.07219256460666656, 0.012334883213043213, 0.003898529103025794, 0.1028677225112915, 0.09718593955039978, 0.041053980588912964, 0.04774642363190651, -0.008482429198920727, 0.05577835813164711, 0.04678831622004509, 0.034042906016111374, 0.006057352758944035, -0.014701993204653263, 0.04418357089161873, -0.016566812992095947, -0.03005770593881607, -0.04230150580406189, -0.04275602102279663, 0.029590828344225883, -0.08220035582780838, -0.015006191097199917, 0.0010305525502189994, 0.04457121342420578, 0.02451351471245289, 0.010784415528178215, -0.03399080038070679, 0.05062241107225418, -0.032070696353912354, -0.0007756170234642923, -0.026134103536605835, 0.019573058933019638, 0.06959616392850876, 0.030150258913636208, 0.026638545095920563, 0.005219350103288889, 0.08394136279821396, 0.009432217106223106, 0.03933774307370186, 0.07024206966161728, 0.024897683411836624, 0.06526699662208557, 0.03453192487359047, 0.008072823286056519, 0.05299434810876846, -0.021547483280301094, -0.000719512056093663, -0.05973323807120323, -0.03270898014307022, -0.007616592105478048, 0.03605230897665024, 0.05857621878385544, -0.08242099732160568, 0.007071607280522585, 0.030467059463262558, 0.04610355570912361, -0.03519374877214432, -0.04134110361337662, 0.0417855866253376, 0.04192366078495979, 0.025528639554977417, 0.06313451379537582, 0.040016695857048035, -0.03385121002793312, -0.07174991816282272, 0.006291912402957678, -0.033626582473516464, -0.01377743761986494 ]
80
80
Learning Balanced Mixtures of Discrete Distributions with Small Sample
We study the problem of partitioning a small sample of $n$ individuals from a mixture of $k$ product distributions over a Boolean cube $\{0, 1\}^K$ according to their distributions. Each distribution is described by a vector of allele frequencies in $\R^K$. Given two distributions, we use $\gamma$ to denote the average $\ell_2^2$ distance in frequencies across $K$ dimensions, which measures the statistical divergence between them. We study the case assuming that bits are independently distributed across $K$ dimensions. This work demonstrates that, for a balanced input instance for $k = 2$, a certain graph-based optimization function returns the correct partition with high probability, where a weighted graph $G$ is formed over $n$ individuals, whose pairwise hamming distances between their corresponding bit vectors define the edge weights, so long as $K = \Omega(\ln n/\gamma)$ and $Kn = \tilde\Omega(\ln n/\gamma^2)$. The function computes a maximum-weight balanced cut of $G$, where the weight of a cut is the sum of the weights across all edges in the cut. This result demonstrates a nice property in the high-dimensional feature space: one can trade off the number of features that are required with the size of the sample to accomplish certain tasks like clustering.
[ 0.0062258802354335785, 0.04585720971226692, 0.058010540902614594, -0.005526327062398195, 0.01857660710811615, -0.020180320367217064, -0.0024430237244814634, 0.010500445030629635, -0.003157207276672125, -0.00910197477787733, -0.006223645061254501, -0.06099250912666321, 0.011438454501330853, 0.019008003175258636, 0.0339413546025753, 0.022525297477841377, -0.08670463413000107, 0.03872865065932274, 0.005559589713811874, -0.01614382490515709, 0.010456199757754803, -0.011399166658520699, 0.01746033877134323, 0.04973772168159485, -0.08954732865095139, -0.014072694815695286, 0.015176409855484962, 0.004624820780009031, -0.08032187819480896, 0.01543484628200531, -0.049216702580451965, -0.009349622763693333, -0.05745415762066841, 0.001564999227412045, 0.05858142301440239, -0.03918268159031868, -0.00012206668907310814, 0.04687223955988884, 0.008820898830890656, -0.026157544925808907, 0.017477966845035553, -0.005007539410144091, -0.011754732578992844, -0.003980020992457867, 0.05137135833501816, -0.022078143432736397, 0.007064041681587696, 0.03351682424545288, 0.011854696087539196, 0.052120089530944824, -0.1445523351430893, 0.0411694161593914, -0.03410984203219414, 0.04753655940294266, -0.0592757873237133, -0.02201085351407528, -0.03458065167069435, 0.060624219477176666, 0.06662724912166595, 0.042187683284282684, 0.06670193374156952, 0.08562953025102615, -0.11676251888275146, 0.00728906225413084, -0.07058709114789963, -0.0582331158220768, -0.049435876309871674, 0.0048070913180708885, -0.015461350791156292, -0.0018761142855510116, 0.006603548768907785, -0.02137123793363571, 0.03059588372707367, 0.1274832934141159, 0.03614158183336258, 0.002559076761826873, -0.042414285242557526, 0.031956661492586136, -0.02913074754178524, 0.07988564670085907, -0.06667735427618027, 0.01524240244179964, 0.005583943799138069, -0.05693361535668373, -0.057170987129211426, 0.04059070348739624, 0.00904320739209652, -0.011842544190585613, -0.018418675288558006, -0.01965179666876793, -0.04363227263092995, -0.0018185439985245466, -0.08770238608121872, 0.06501145660877228, -0.06572979688644409, 0.08084539324045181, 0.0008674931013956666, 0.01727231591939926, 0.05014730244874954, 0.013480940833687782, -0.026206042617559433, -0.062353335320949554, 0.011259523220360279, 0.0037121903151273727, -0.0023209743667393923, 0.011272072792053223, -0.07784701138734818, 0.10115227848291397, 0.022579913958907127, -0.0895119309425354, 0.016517676413059235, -0.05875544622540474, 0.07275309413671494, 0.0016547898994758725, -0.0038489727303385735, 0.04813653975725174, 0.045368555933237076, 0.04726773500442505, -0.00993984006345272, 0.012966356240212917, 0.0177946574985981, -0.01523025706410408, -0.03942405804991722, -0.016234613955020905, 0.018681518733501434, -0.04125246778130531, -0.038731880486011505, -0.0182114839553833, 0.07218168675899506, -0.020301301032304764, -0.13954541087150574, 0.08689374476671219, -0.08172576874494553, -0.006254487205296755, -0.08765359967947006, -0.02138899266719818, 0.1002591997385025, 0.036070361733436584, 0.03564084693789482, 0.12874697148799896, 0.002807356882840395, -0.04481927305459976, -0.009728814475238323, 0.011850982904434204, 0.07476319372653961, -0.019557416439056396, -0.016665257513523102, 0.05500083416700363, 0.001250633504241705, 0.0023714485578238964, -0.019358975812792778, -0.09261830151081085, 0.02994571067392826, -0.029723932966589928, 0.05327724665403366, 0.015776298940181732, -0.03349783271551132, -0.025887852534651756, 0.01663747988641262, 0.020150864496827126, -0.07141997665166855, 0.018039662390947342, 0.05104207247495651, -0.072312131524086, 0.0013174505438655615, 0.08958050608634949, -0.015434728935360909, 0.0025796552654355764, -0.025354279205203056, -0.004004337824881077, 0.029790831729769707, -0.04747415706515312, -0.026084087789058685, -0.027103479951620102, -0.008402812294661999, -0.014820980839431286, -0.04058156907558441, -0.026559289544820786, 0.009611881338059902, 0.016532933339476585, 0.020857997238636017, -0.034741342067718506, 0.04280204698443413, 0.08063039928674698, 0.02067847177386284, 0.056208398193120956, 0.004176325164735317, -0.016340982168912888, 0.048184771090745926, 0.08222021907567978, 0.09701770544052124, 0.01607297733426094, 0.02864421159029007, -0.03564917668700218, -0.015182382427155972, 0.011389371939003468, -0.0400225892663002, -0.06155439838767052, 0.026612412184476852, 0.07608368247747421, 0.05821848660707474, 0.0026086983270943165, -0.04411650449037552, -0.0551193468272686, -0.04064728692173958, 0.004163641016930342, 0.05663159117102623, -0.04900990426540375, 0.01279105432331562, -0.07603674381971359, 0.006095082499086857, 0.001271149842068553, 0.026609621942043304, -0.019053835421800613, 0.04255102574825287, -0.011990420520305634, -0.03266457840800285, -0.01884458027780056, -0.00753100635483861, 0.01808319054543972, -0.03273461386561394, -0.010045035742223263, -0.05446309596300125, 0.07284940779209137, -0.10129359364509583, 0.07369838654994965, 0.016020681709051132, 0.030605759471654892, -0.021618608385324478, 0.04984791576862335, -0.036130018532276154, 0.02059612236917019, -0.06090817600488663, -0.05121053010225296, -0.02455182559788227, 0.057899609208106995, -0.02789524756371975, 0.02510320022702217, -0.053420472890138626, 0.027615897357463837, -0.021145861595869064, 0.018780510872602463, -0.07908374071121216, -0.014455891214311123, -0.01721392199397087, -0.016372865065932274, 0.025013796985149384, 0.09950170665979385, 0.03290940448641777, 0.03149402514100075, -0.024158725515007973, 0.016949355602264404, -0.017360467463731766, 0.002201232360675931, 0.023861190304160118, -0.017218006774783134, 0.009710688143968582, 0.07865970581769943, 0.0537492036819458, 0.08686468005180359, 0.055178433656692505, 0.06290657818317413, -0.01912897452712059, -0.10024064034223557, 0.06888017803430557, 0.028510792180895805, 0.02749752253293991, 0.03203627094626427, -0.016140492632985115, 0.03867373242974281, 0.006447962019592524, -0.10272766649723053, -0.04773806035518646, 0.09618303924798965, -0.04601999372243881, 0.006109677255153656, -0.01942441612482071, 0.0827462449669838, 0.05260505527257919, -0.0729142501950264, -0.013217777013778687, 0.00779208866879344, 0.03578387200832367, 0.014470439404249191, 0.04863226041197777, 0.024551166221499443, -0.03582324460148811, -0.028038358315825462, -0.02602325938642025, 0.021584022790193558, -0.053771164268255234, 0.04406217485666275, -0.039385836571455, 0.0198067557066679, -0.010428202338516712, -0.05174688249826431, 0.06507373601198196, 0.036491453647613525, 0.059963926672935486, -0.008546729572117329, -0.026351433247327805, 0.0019148417050018907, 0.043112438172101974, 0.06308604776859283, 0.029758572578430176, 0.08436185866594315, 0.03723147138953209, -0.04706336557865143, -0.10767471045255661, 0.0008923832210712135, 0.030468855053186417, 0.03952798992395401, 0.002095280447974801, -0.03417787700891495, -0.02579597197473049, 0.016482632607221603, -0.0072352089919149876, 0.0008041452965699136, -0.01943347603082657, 0.03369814530014992, -0.0562438927590847, 0.01043888833373785, 0.03101440519094467, -0.027419136837124825, -0.03613492101430893, -0.09371637552976608, 0.0647168830037117, 0.051767829805612564, -0.04837702214717865, -0.021139245480298996, -0.04706275835633278, -0.016187703236937523, -0.06251311302185059, 0.06343388557434082, -0.025418685749173164, -0.0005254787392914295, -0.018595226109027863, 0.0008204541518352926, 0.011434301733970642, 0.007586031220853329, 0.04324128478765488, -0.025183437392115593, -0.010515431873500347, 0.024805614724755287, 0.04538804292678833, 0.09068884700536728, 0.05583052709698677, 0.010684059001505375, 0.040433190762996674, 0.045045312494039536, -0.09442731738090515, 0.07434254884719849, -0.06614566594362259, -0.026452653110027313, -0.003853860776871443, 0.09349405020475388, 0.08852574229240417, 0.0009491276578046381, 0.032573603093624115, 0.0013985108816996217, -0.0629701167345047, -0.00005511704148375429, 0.005933868233114481, 0.0653621032834053, -0.006430082488805056, 0.008774349465966225, -0.027479447424411774, -0.0007351067033596337, -0.045463576912879944, 0.01139232236891985, 0.058098066598176956, -0.011480709537863731, 0.004530549049377441, 0.046447448432445526, -0.038919080048799515, -0.025518298149108887, 0.004830257035791874, -0.05183067172765732, -0.012444688007235527, 0.05339311435818672, -0.007188102230429649, 0.014398893341422081, -0.030881589278578758, 0.02815348282456398, -0.004156284499913454, -0.04846261441707611, -0.04819251596927643, 0.01443345844745636, 0.06466573476791382, 0.030964478850364685, 0.008201283402740955, -0.035421423614025116, -0.020034413784742355, 0.00005457225415739231, 0.0645735040307045, -0.019915461540222168, -0.006599158979952335, 0.03882632777094841, -0.009963109157979488, 0.010199754498898983, 0.016348857432603836, -0.0407172329723835, 0.01826154999434948, -0.0991167351603508, -0.0657147690653801, 0.0848727747797966, 0.003914711996912956, 0.033610887825489044, -0.03248928114771843, 0.04285922273993492, 0.011733154766261578, 0.022964075207710266, -0.039111435413360596, 0.05098956450819969, 0.012035800144076347, -0.012156723067164421, -0.02436881698668003, -0.004321501590311527, -0.020294351503252983, -0.07779917120933533, 0.01659066043794155, 0.015427688136696815, -0.01693848893046379, -0.07071223855018616, -0.0263229850679636, 0.03006315417587757, 0.050788793712854385, -0.02925966866314411, 0.04569537192583084, 0.09542157500982285, -0.039803795516490936, -0.038887619972229004, -0.01563846692442894, 0.009641099721193314, 0.038706764578819275, -0.030030647292733192, -0.0014089499600231647, -0.055842988193035126, 0.04653128236532211, 0.002287683542817831, -0.03627067804336548, 0.001957250526174903, -0.025276975706219673, 0.017306555062532425, -0.004027877934277058, 0.02790004387497902, 0.014181728474795818, -0.02709895186126232, 0.014755848795175552, 0.025948544964194298, 0.0545271597802639, 0.0359068401157856, 0.07783253490924835, -0.06293876469135284, -0.04364672303199768, 0.0010675023077055812, 0.032688748091459274, 0.014038828201591969, 0.00700012780725956, -0.02930673584342003, -0.03615850210189819, -0.06482526659965515, 0.029541296884417534, -0.02372242882847786, -0.05474492162466049, 0.08268299698829651, 0.008799291215837002, 0.00013058894546702504, 0.03226202726364136, 0.048761703073978424, 0.010505354963243008, 0.08579832315444946, -0.029271146282553673, -0.08276345580816269, 0.025169912725687027, 0.026665376499295235, 0.025844059884548187, -0.03552572801709175, 0.03734079748392105, -0.04149167612195015, 0.06905794888734818, 0.0038094744086265564, -0.04296434298157692, -0.05956115573644638, 0.011828672140836716, 0.025998668745160103, 0.014131711795926094, 0.02680181711912155, 0.015792233869433403, 0.0047473665326833725, 0.028538452461361885, -0.04078909009695053, 0.025115158408880234, -0.020323310047388077, -0.022680530324578285, 0.02312628924846649, 0.055184490978717804, 0.029205026105046272, 0.03185460716485977, -0.0018316248897463083, 0.02840167097747326, -0.07165978848934174, 0.0446120910346508, -0.014671619050204754, 0.011203188449144363, -0.02144540473818779, 0.020653942599892616, -0.04833242669701576, -0.07967892289161682, -0.0075374809093773365, 0.009265624918043613, -0.01368155237287283 ]
81
81
Bayesian Nonlinear Principal Component Analysis Using Random Fields
We propose a novel model for nonlinear dimension reduction motivated by the probabilistic formulation of principal component analysis. Nonlinearity is achieved by specifying different transformation matrices at different locations of the latent space and smoothing the transformation using a Markov random field type prior. The computation is made feasible by the recent advances in sampling from von Mises-Fisher distributions.
[ 0.010473595932126045, -0.09425429999828339, 0.05518582835793495, -0.04689455404877663, -0.010593844577670097, -0.044066645205020905, 0.02627171203494072, 0.0026156206149607897, -0.00013810362725052983, -0.004998289979994297, -0.028078436851501465, 0.02228640578687191, -0.02875378541648388, 0.03830156475305557, -0.06970872730016708, 0.01692959852516651, 0.0001868243853095919, 0.013179521076381207, 0.0168545413762331, -0.03203020617365837, -0.04316628724336624, -0.009450835175812244, -0.060069601982831955, 0.02195078693330288, 0.043113138526678085, -0.005312301684170961, -0.0848497673869133, -0.06352967023849487, -0.007611079141497612, 0.010876437649130821, -0.05218705162405968, -0.0018703507957980037, -0.0191502645611763, -0.015700412914156914, -0.0363742932677269, -0.0582432858645916, -0.012227491475641727, 0.006758545059710741, -0.04703742638230324, -0.04025145247578621, -0.010355770587921143, 0.006304625887423754, 0.03715337812900543, 0.004094019066542387, 0.04392753913998604, 0.06278648227453232, 0.016253933310508728, -0.033381152898073196, -0.007495677098631859, -0.004851772449910641, -0.08046110719442368, 0.06845052540302277, -0.022372787818312645, -0.017304878681898117, 0.00004403304046718404, 0.008180770091712475, -0.03634579852223396, 0.023114606738090515, 0.024085916578769684, -0.03194742277264595, 0.02703375741839409, 0.12110813707113266, -0.05369165539741516, 0.029989002272486687, -0.019313808530569077, 0.013476585038006306, 0.00943144503980875, -0.04806975647807121, -0.048636287450790405, -0.03721313178539276, 0.023999137803912163, -0.026171717792749405, -0.07132172584533691, 0.06686006486415863, -0.03303763270378113, 0.035856932401657104, -0.055027078837156296, -0.01961902342736721, 0.033938560634851456, 0.10289531201124191, 0.0030096792615950108, 0.05187329277396202, 0.024971842765808105, -0.023864274844527245, 0.032561272382736206, 0.04046394303441048, 0.018311530351638794, -0.08870403468608856, 0.0075211417861282825, -0.08424173295497894, -0.02667933516204357, -0.00753686623647809, -0.05075598135590553, 0.018628371879458427, -0.09620460867881775, 0.004995130002498627, -0.03651978448033333, 0.010048381984233856, 0.01582113467156887, 0.022993702441453934, -0.012193676084280014, 0.02037908136844635, 0.015857266262173653, 0.031090276315808296, -0.0015940908342599869, 0.018309738487005234, -0.033173102885484695, 0.033541589975357056, 0.03825349360704422, -0.020949404686689377, 0.05862503871321678, -0.019688036292791367, 0.02273116260766983, -0.03690388798713684, -0.06462259590625763, 0.085171177983284, 0.015888448804616928, 0.05169231444597244, -0.004350080154836178, 0.034010469913482666, -0.0052873361855745316, 0.010530322790145874, 0.005826582200825214, 0.00028110569110140204, 0.04967580363154411, -0.021745791658759117, -0.029264064505696297, -0.06809209287166595, 0.07883072644472122, -0.04577202722430229, -0.0750158503651619, 0.011778472922742367, -0.012230812571942806, -0.06099376827478409, -0.05625084042549133, 0.059964679181575775, 0.04009092226624489, 0.0002461847325321287, -0.08232566714286804, 0.051788121461868286, -0.03669153153896332, -0.006131126545369625, -0.03742271289229393, -0.05766431987285614, 0.006284920033067465, 0.04612750560045242, -0.0340782031416893, -0.0020282587502151728, 0.021590515971183777, -0.03065384365618229, -0.03512983396649361, 0.012212400324642658, 0.007940273731946945, -0.01632235385477543, 0.08371123671531677, -0.05141837149858475, -0.013890211470425129, -0.030618133023381233, -0.016464274376630783, 0.06452325731515884, -0.036630745977163315, -0.005666462238878012, -0.027557138353586197, 0.043893780559301376, 0.005208013113588095, -0.040011707693338394, 0.006662262137979269, 0.00987203884869814, -0.06959164142608643, -0.08856424689292908, -0.029993031173944473, -0.032738037407398224, -0.010149562731385231, 0.014825203455984592, -0.0005576947587542236, -0.02833431400358677, -0.0603010356426239, 0.028451981022953987, 0.06395048648118973, -0.02220139466226101, 0.02777737006545067, 0.04733499139547348, -0.015990788117051125, 0.04302122816443443, 0.03681623190641403, -0.007886865176260471, -0.03617851436138153, -0.000540895969606936, 0.0638078823685646, -0.003664144314825535, 0.024150056764483452, -0.0015365739818662405, 0.00425737863406539, -0.059920329600572586, 0.004252440761774778, -0.028422795236110687, 0.03366033360362053, -0.0010381473693996668, 0.06942567229270935, 0.10322018712759018, 0.06374119967222214, 0.03168145567178726, -0.07845529168844223, -0.12999986112117767, -0.07507443428039551, 0.06766108423471451, 0.0728110522031784, -0.03060528077185154, 0.05104885622859001, 0.005745389964431524, -0.0066673182882368565, -0.04247073829174042, -0.03257957845926285, -0.041984979063272476, 0.02981157973408699, -0.09143956005573273, -0.008744298480451107, -0.002862990368157625, 0.0409560464322567, 0.12803207337856293, -0.06371475756168365, 0.08498737215995789, -0.04156297445297241, 0.10820603370666504, -0.059441231191158295, -0.024567486718297005, 0.025730464607477188, -0.08979285508394241, -0.05469028651714325, 0.033418286591768265, 0.02105211280286312, -0.022923201322555542, -0.03475891053676605, -0.025719786062836647, 0.012462403625249863, 0.047205448150634766, -0.06317666918039322, -0.011233923025429249, 0.03165322542190552, -0.0035937491338700056, 0.011110153049230576, 0.06856703013181686, 0.04784981533885002, -0.04411747306585312, -0.08189892768859863, -0.03622254729270935, 0.06521224975585938, 0.10418859869241714, 0.011564848013222218, 0.009579131379723549, -0.00833035632967949, -0.01917443983256817, 0.02033567987382412, -0.058626938611269, -0.018573936074972153, 0.008399197831749916, -0.06959132105112076, 0.03620145097374916, 0.04771222174167633, 0.030082151293754578, -0.01436151284724474, 0.024640778079628944, -0.04893379285931587, 0.058349888771772385, 0.06288192421197891, 0.029859766364097595, 0.06930937618017197, 0.05010559782385826, -0.007109966594725847, -0.01909814588725567, 0.0123634347692132, -0.045669637620449066, -0.02921897917985916, 0.04102204367518425, -0.04207240790128708, 0.03419492393732071, 0.05647563934326172, 0.03842783719301224, 0.07065954059362411, -0.08571196347475052, -0.01809934340417385, 0.059722285717725754, -0.004334094002842903, 0.006877122446894646, 0.03771704062819481, 0.04558862745761871, 0.07121633738279343, 0.0706411674618721, 0.0026767454110085964, 0.06663315743207932, -0.0480840802192688, 0.08687255531549454, -0.04340557008981705, 0.06085115671157837, 0.03441993519663811, -0.05968984216451645, 0.05080138146877289, 0.03410714492201805, 0.0020504859276115894, -0.0017441047821193933, 0.08385902643203735, -0.010075975209474564, 0.03100389428436756, 0.01752733811736107, 0.03553192690014839, 0.042858682572841644, 0.10959845036268234, 0.023267267271876335, -0.019089166074991226, 0.023688169196248055, 0.042048051953315735, 0.04813843593001366, -0.031166860833764076, -0.028440076857805252, 0.0004039873310830444, -0.05298757553100586, -0.024002747610211372, -0.061805322766304016, -0.056872252374887466, -0.039853695780038834, 0.003980203531682491, 0.06551318615674973, 0.015448855236172676, -0.015363264828920364, -0.00036763769458048046, 0.034738484770059586, 0.003320504678413272, 0.07312139123678207, -0.0947660505771637, -0.005421646870672703, -0.0173430647701025, -0.021343277767300606, -0.01495307870209217, 0.07135406881570816, 0.022706499323248863, -0.018654996529221535, -0.06510695815086365, -0.017239410430192947, 0.006544384174048901, -0.006932675372809172, -0.029182422906160355, -0.11112748086452484, -0.030130503699183464, -0.030339187011122704, -0.012104609049856663, 0.0807003378868103, 0.07022785395383835, -0.039573535323143005, 0.0337090827524662, 0.01184912770986557, -0.005210541654378176, 0.02286262810230255, -0.010851087048649788, 0.033092934638261795, 0.051123201847076416, 0.09442000836133957, 0.10439285635948181, -0.02130962163209915, -0.00997798703610897, 0.055101342499256134, 0.004841527435928583, 0.022232891991734505, 0.01183224655687809, -0.024062396958470345, 0.04860241711139679, 0.028776170685887337, -0.04871360585093498, 0.03986981138586998, -0.04577487334609032, 0.020779354497790337, 0.07237645983695984, -0.021613402292132378, 0.06759261339902878, 0.09427432715892792, 0.09601941704750061, -0.015933744609355927, 0.049993619322776794, -0.06364133208990097, 0.0028024185448884964, 0.003622296964749694, -0.028584185987710953, -0.03359489142894745, -0.005129849538207054, -0.0383915975689888, -0.030759764835238457, -0.05226932838559151, 0.020023657009005547, 0.05962684750556946, -0.016126468777656555, -0.037113532423973083, -0.000861672917380929, 0.013917495496571064, -0.004701449070125818, -0.010250533930957317, 0.045159779489040375, 0.022852515801787376, 0.07365924119949341, -0.011267243884503841, -0.03214764967560768, -0.0013868564274162054, 0.052474744617938995, 0.0154532790184021, 0.03556373715400696, -0.12222223728895187, -0.07079317420721054, 0.027708448469638824, -0.054304055869579315, 0.013714422471821308, 0.02165193110704422, 0.014462062157690525, 0.016378922387957573, -0.011426521465182304, -0.010948676615953445, 0.03299486264586449, 0.017378132790327072, 0.044176358729600906, 0.009293288923799992, -0.040732722729444504, 0.0285574272274971, -0.041931044310331345, 0.0634722039103508, -0.014902761206030846, 0.03404154255986214, 0.05065000802278519, -0.026447635143995285, -0.0016898468602448702, -0.041196174919605255, 0.044003650546073914, 0.02043996937572956, 0.022197287529706955, -0.06884555518627167, -0.005212579388171434, 0.007759216707199812, 0.03641427308320999, 0.05105399340391159, -0.05239754170179367, -0.006343773566186428, -0.022768348455429077, 0.020530352368950844, -0.042409297078847885, 0.020933272317051888, -0.005877884104847908, -0.06693896651268005, 0.008586231619119644, 0.014713039621710777, -0.014622099697589874, 0.05997321009635925, -0.04892618581652641, 0.06271400302648544, -0.01265248004347086, 0.02772817574441433, 0.04816003143787384, 0.052044983953237534, -0.050884708762168884, -0.01048249751329422, 0.011368530802428722, 0.012550773099064827, 0.005032407585531473, -0.00735775800421834, -0.01973857544362545, 0.017599575221538544, -0.01745794154703617, -0.026096686720848083, 0.0393613763153553, -0.09069373458623886, -0.04231027141213417, 0.04926185682415962, 0.05186497047543526, 0.06171148642897606, 0.06951847672462463, -0.023580219596624374, 0.08742812275886536, 0.05466143786907196, 0.004128150176256895, -0.025900382548570633, -0.004693100228905678, 0.057760920375585556, -0.0016362277092412114, -0.04950625076889992, -0.05341102182865143, 0.05696695297956467, -0.019347254186868668, -0.012162916362285614, 0.05323547124862671, 0.012249822728335857, 0.02623821422457695, -0.014801948331296444, 0.0394306406378746, 0.07928686589002609, -0.006084512919187546, 0.0380387008190155, 0.021560439839959145, 0.006230029743164778, 0.03688599541783333, -0.030002932995557785, 0.032847292721271515, -0.087480328977108, 0.04048844054341316, 0.015810757875442505, 0.04876332730054855, 0.0281611829996109, -0.03126224875450134, 0.014828046783804893, 0.05554067716002464, 0.05902397260069847, 0.04464294761419296, 0.00048402108950540423, -0.04784289747476578, 0.02336416207253933, 0.10364914685487747, 0.0027634946163743734, -0.022977767512202263 ]
82
82
A New Approach to Collaborative Filtering: Operator Estimation with Spectral Regularization
We present a general approach for collaborative filtering (CF) using spectral regularization to learn linear operators from "users" to the "objects" they rate. Recent low-rank type matrix completion approaches to CF are shown to be special cases. However, unlike existing regularization based CF methods, our approach can be used to also incorporate information such as attributes of the users or the objects -- a limitation of existing regularization based CF methods. We then provide novel representer theorems that we use to develop new estimation methods. We provide learning algorithms based on low-rank decompositions, and test them on a standard CF dataset. The experiments indicate the advantages of generalizing the existing regularization based CF methods to incorporate related information about users and objects. Finally, we show that certain multi-task learning methods can be also seen as special cases of our proposed approach.
[ 0.047951992601156235, -0.0666986033320427, 0.03756134957075119, -0.016904231160879135, 0.02772192284464836, -0.0666353702545166, 0.05126331001520157, 0.0029994973447173834, -0.0418202169239521, 0.0030688634142279625, 0.038649920374155045, -0.0016470327973365784, -0.039504438638687134, 0.06989061832427979, -0.00838848389685154, -0.01454968936741352, 0.01585102081298828, -0.020663542672991753, 0.04267406091094017, -0.029667571187019348, -0.010347639210522175, -0.059970833361148834, -0.04084504395723343, -0.06003420427441597, -0.012738252058625221, 0.0020443820394575596, -0.08103722333908081, 0.001548789907246828, 0.01262475736439228, -0.02935834228992462, -0.03709414228796959, -0.03206789121031761, -0.034987758845090866, 0.01895984634757042, 0.010615166276693344, 0.0055669997818768024, 0.07121262699365616, 0.027288086712360382, -0.04341962933540344, 0.01303428690880537, -0.00998343713581562, 0.023251349106431007, 0.028476044535636902, -0.02922997623682022, 0.04104125127196312, -0.032617803663015366, 0.016100753098726273, -0.05158410221338272, 0.050459325313568115, 0.03448431193828583, -0.10095730423927307, -0.005244689527899027, -0.021369673311710358, -0.0007239783881232142, -0.04092026501893997, 0.02107958123087883, 0.0223575197160244, 0.005954117048531771, 0.10250592231750488, 0.000721184944268316, 0.0661158412694931, 0.06682112067937851, -0.00852403324097395, -0.029300980269908905, -0.021688289940357208, -0.02797219157218933, -0.024223674088716507, -0.0014916036743670702, -0.044663555920124054, 0.04777466878294945, 0.012885194271802902, -0.03510705381631851, 0.021616356447339058, 0.051122650504112244, 0.058744482696056366, 0.06935691088438034, -0.021872416138648987, 0.02691304124891758, 0.014014992862939835, 0.06192215159535408, -0.05638016387820244, 0.04556877538561821, -0.030733706429600716, 0.02355889417231083, -0.09667147696018219, 0.02260483242571354, 0.004684449639171362, 0.014699810184538364, 0.022358782589435577, 0.07875583320856094, -0.002960046986117959, -0.011156794615089893, -0.048156313598155975, 0.022974655032157898, 0.023772452026605606, -0.08118126541376114, -0.013754514046013355, 0.003465923946350813, 0.04373779892921448, 0.005876199342310429, 0.019877802580595016, 0.012482900172472, 0.06957507133483887, 0.03245503827929497, -0.027721397578716278, 0.01853076182305813, -0.04128206893801689, 0.0380711667239666, 0.04958319291472435, 0.005851945839822292, 0.018051182851195335, -0.0011787815019488335, -0.03163442015647888, 0.03833544999361038, 0.0031716444063931704, 0.028213275596499443, -0.0072600445710122585, 0.0986550897359848, -0.024689890444278717, 0.024258628487586975, -0.015990864485502243, -0.06174936890602112, -0.06190720200538635, -0.044342488050460815, -0.018349455669522285, -0.016653945669531822, 0.023367946967482567, -0.04741819202899933, 0.01769627258181572, 0.014215867966413498, -0.025639202445745468, 0.011542084626853466, -0.0030837301164865494, -0.015991127118468285, -0.06392382085323334, 0.021617919206619263, -0.005620000883936882, -0.05474194884300232, -0.04999065771698952, 0.034149132668972015, -0.0005762340733781457, 0.05843212455511093, -0.037696488201618195, -0.036028023809194565, 0.09674682468175888, -0.03170613944530487, 0.04901430755853653, -0.01873037777841091, -0.012854543514549732, -0.07386156916618347, -0.05416717007756233, -0.016447005793452263, 0.022245945408940315, 0.006623408291488886, 0.0032000290229916573, -0.018119726330041885, -0.05423421040177345, -0.08111266046762466, 0.02052580751478672, 0.08016782253980637, 0.010620255954563618, -0.022373123094439507, 0.0073877135291695595, 0.017774244770407677, -0.03160642832517624, -0.0026246001943945885, -0.09922238439321518, 0.004465670790523291, -0.036212384700775146, -0.06296131014823914, -0.09375952929258347, -0.024740051478147507, -0.025692913681268692, 0.037212226539850235, 0.01426555123180151, -0.06369242072105408, -0.01556469313800335, 0.007810566108673811, -0.05447498708963394, -0.06862154603004456, 0.028790399432182312, -0.0586019903421402, -0.04468411207199097, 0.025626711547374725, 0.04103417322039604, 0.0691620409488678, 0.017154060304164886, -0.0031309411861002445, 0.02122909389436245, 0.03794126585125923, 0.061307817697525024, 0.046449292451143265, -0.046987224370241165, 0.016180768609046936, -0.08243612945079803, 0.049806054681539536, 0.040820758789777756, -0.029468344524502754, -0.007382752373814583, 0.0786796510219574, 0.04988185316324234, -0.05223289504647255, 0.016646146774291992, -0.06453920155763626, -0.1282263547182083, -0.04679356515407562, 0.009052477777004242, -0.031340889632701874, -0.04887635260820389, 0.0027708597481250763, 0.05756515637040138, 0.013665738515555859, 0.034833140671253204, -0.02546612359583378, -0.021030636504292488, -0.01482338085770607, -0.03415030986070633, -0.031871676445007324, 0.05426298826932907, 0.12155947089195251, -0.011155320331454277, 0.03614695742726326, -0.018669718876481056, 0.013691142201423645, -0.06826171278953552, -0.039635468274354935, 0.013937502168118954, -0.04462051019072533, -0.13007642328739166, -0.007088796701282263, -0.03752420097589493, -0.05837903916835785, -0.049758873879909515, 0.03744735196232796, 0.05618870630860329, 0.007735625375062227, -0.08589709550142288, -0.05555223301053047, -0.08357559889554977, -0.043801579624414444, 0.011066436767578125, 0.032874640077352524, 0.045024849474430084, 0.016168074682354927, -0.015382741577923298, -0.018328102305531502, -0.05630013346672058, 0.02842460200190544, -0.014660542830824852, -0.05236443877220154, 0.02296009659767151, -0.03685043007135391, -0.018038062378764153, 0.04185590147972107, 0.07465093582868576, 0.0586509145796299, -0.02753179334104061, 0.012439189478754997, 0.07706903666257858, 0.02539963647723198, 0.028438204899430275, -0.0597265250980854, -0.0195008534938097, 0.044349975883960724, -0.01786968670785427, -0.021078241989016533, -0.01155782025307417, 0.03562139719724655, 0.013962334021925926, 0.022905336692929268, -0.0031539953779429197, -0.06516299396753311, -0.06403758376836777, 0.012473213486373425, -0.01876644603908062, -0.014679832383990288, -0.030208662152290344, 0.053744591772556305, -0.02696111984550953, -0.06675341725349426, -0.027162235230207443, 0.012676121667027473, -0.024147192016243935, -0.014547168277204037, -0.01034336257725954, -0.03183163329958916, 0.017815381288528442, -0.021248716861009598, 0.03289317712187767, 0.03170604258775711, -0.07153309881687164, 0.03224897384643555, -0.009835328906774521, 0.09551694989204407, 0.0021969322115182877, -0.11115007847547531, -0.017558924853801727, 0.05611100792884827, 0.04965721815824509, 0.021962052211165428, 0.04303848743438721, 0.015811922028660774, -0.032859839498996735, 0.025408655405044556, 0.11009985953569412, 0.06266651302576065, 0.10029499977827072, 0.08618748933076859, 0.03676208108663559, -0.0017720948671922088, -0.03480473905801773, -0.021020028740167618, -0.00790915172547102, -0.08738040924072266, 0.03127892687916756, 0.020615173503756523, 0.028709566220641136, 0.006016376428306103, -0.07641571015119553, -0.0019435286521911621, 0.038153812289237976, -0.030848026275634766, 0.023234203457832336, 0.035932496190071106, -0.07979171723127365, -0.015387697145342827, 0.020775657147169113, 0.02092316374182701, -0.07325603067874908, 0.018081901594996452, -0.14146359264850616, -0.003910982050001621, -0.0035002485383301973, 0.09471248090267181, 0.046147529035806656, -0.05012192204594612, -0.05159381777048111, -0.07360747456550598, 0.0004302102024666965, -0.015614693984389305, 0.0070796990767121315, -0.10509389638900757, -0.030071446672081947, 0.007093377877026796, 0.08253980427980423, 0.024868424981832504, 0.06210498884320259, -0.02148975059390068, -0.045257750898599625, -0.0065778992138803005, -0.08166632801294327, 0.02212642878293991, -0.033224646002054214, -0.024437949061393738, 0.02375255525112152, 0.028171928599476814, 0.07197744399309158, 0.045009929686784744, -0.0029645198956131935, -0.0014798197662457824, -0.012032849714159966, 0.04472194239497185, -0.026481807231903076, 0.018499530851840973, 0.03569779545068741, 0.03454212099313736, -0.00410370621830225, 0.00974968820810318, -0.049397412687540054, -0.010904676280915737, 0.06332717090845108, 0.024011829867959023, 0.04489307478070259, 0.0033809312153607607, -0.0034949544351547956, -0.05694020166993141, 0.04941076040267944, -0.02506696619093418, -0.03221195191144943, 0.07267463952302933, 0.04689973592758179, 0.025175301358103752, -0.021215444430708885, 0.0010425046784803271, 0.0017256384016945958, -0.040422577410936356, -0.01772306300699711, -0.046084318310022354, 0.03203307092189789, 0.09982897341251373, -0.035435229539871216, -0.058139823377132416, -0.025569889694452286, -0.031469862908124924, 0.026546094566583633, -0.00960559118539095, 0.011257726699113846, -0.030940411612391472, -0.020985694602131844, 0.022173769772052765, -0.05361150950193405, 0.016936589032411575, -0.03510228171944618, -0.048323921859264374, -0.06086219847202301, 0.033344559371471405, 0.009764913469552994, 0.07105531543493271, -0.009605010971426964, 0.06747648864984512, 0.025792714208364487, 0.015312460251152515, -0.0035418455954641104, 0.026013152673840523, -0.007950243540108204, -0.01352770160883665, 0.0019711307249963284, 0.0165006835013628, -0.03150865063071251, -0.05575919151306152, -0.0030031308997422457, -0.009161156602203846, -0.01277497410774231, 0.0404544472694397, 0.027631213888525963, 0.0013090851716697216, 0.09194973111152649, 0.03859514370560646, 0.009652617387473583, 0.09172647446393967, 0.023878064006567, 0.002886537928134203, -0.02150365523993969, 0.060484640300273895, 0.0170369241386652, -0.010184187442064285, 0.010105523280799389, -0.0062193055637180805, 0.042139969766139984, 0.02418406307697296, -0.029246853664517403, -0.0157804973423481, -0.04699156805872917, -0.015704121440649033, 0.14183492958545685, 0.07892262935638428, 0.060801099985837936, -0.014972090721130371, 0.07255949825048447, 0.008032888174057007, -0.0019455398432910442, -0.07062351703643799, 0.09465982019901276, 0.012285236269235611, -0.09642372280359268, -0.02346121333539486, 0.058222152292728424, -0.014493565075099468, 0.08311556279659271, -0.06577029824256897, -0.013786013238132, -0.003829708555713296, 0.01855599321424961, 0.039444100111722946, -0.06366240233182907, -0.003152210498228669, -0.021421700716018677, 0.018738681450486183, 0.02447262592613697, 0.03295961767435074, -0.03726368397474289, 0.052880387753248215, 0.04682370275259018, -0.031228426843881607, -0.002197039080783725, 0.035792626440525055, 0.05933903530240059, -0.02539016865193844, -0.07075165957212448, -0.02401614375412464, 0.03144422546029091, -0.017689209431409836, 0.018569936975836754, -0.041343480348587036, -0.012502443045377731, 0.03598833829164505, 0.061868175864219666, 0.049689628183841705, 0.019808441400527954, 0.04872588440775871, -0.032673679292201996, 0.032910846173763275, 0.01735304854810238, 0.00103596574626863, -0.014122387394309044, -0.06126050278544426, 0.054890260100364685, 0.005212055519223213, -0.0214377474039793, 0.06868130713701248, -0.04176875948905945, -0.058567944914102554, 0.03784003481268883, 0.05659071356058121, 0.07344662398099899, 0.0740949958562851, 0.06009327620267868, -0.01735268160700798, 0.011861439794301987, 0.0538657046854496, -0.08808808773756027, 0.000816619663964957 ]
83
83
Combining Expert Advice Efficiently
We show how models for prediction with expert advice can be defined concisely and clearly using hidden Markov models (HMMs); standard HMM algorithms can then be used to efficiently calculate, among other things, how the expert predictions should be weighted according to the model. We cast many existing models as HMMs and recover the best known running times in each case. We also describe two new models: the switch distribution, which was recently developed to improve Bayesian/Minimum Description Length model selection, and a new generalisation of the fixed share algorithm based on run-length coding. We give loss bounds for all models and shed new light on their relationships.
[ -0.05330757424235344, -0.03876396641135216, 0.021614156663417816, -0.019840147346258163, -0.04082368686795235, -0.02709237113595009, -0.014166486449539661, 0.016224583610892296, 0.06735359877347946, 0.0036529190838336945, -0.01668817363679409, -0.09871441125869751, -0.023256246000528336, -0.04199366271495819, -0.003095166990533471, -0.028538648039102554, -0.024780916050076485, -0.010426673106849194, -0.024529561400413513, -0.03728843107819557, 0.004032900556921959, 0.05611058324575424, 0.026365214958786964, -0.10413876175880432, -0.03938724473118782, -0.06428799778223038, 0.027019010856747627, 0.02049574814736843, 0.013814035803079605, 0.04617170989513397, -0.0532250851392746, 0.023237671703100204, 0.05844401568174362, -0.00793367251753807, 0.0300001073628664, -0.0077445013448596, 0.09826283901929855, -0.05581852048635483, -0.049029234796762466, -0.07644551992416382, 0.013982691802084446, 0.013806408271193504, 0.06073109805583954, 0.018136730417609215, 0.009508498013019562, 0.04039788991212845, 0.004027077928185463, 0.05846649035811424, 0.04977073892951012, 0.02583760768175125, -0.060676854103803635, 0.03485362231731415, -0.06569141894578934, -0.02270783856511116, 0.05195971205830574, 0.051083650439977646, -0.0669611319899559, -0.02406526729464531, 0.04029460251331329, -0.07032854855060577, 0.014032389037311077, 0.05219889059662819, -0.07852095365524292, -0.033745862543582916, -0.013264261186122894, 0.01899123564362526, -0.08900412917137146, 0.049071572721004486, 0.021840259432792664, -0.018843358382582664, 0.03819989040493965, -0.026560846716165543, 0.04729091376066208, -0.00016474664153065532, -0.017038067802786827, 0.013513193465769291, -0.037798576056957245, 0.03709029406309128, 0.03971878066658974, 0.10663542151451111, -0.05875721201300621, 0.017987573519349098, -0.004712487105280161, -0.009365832433104515, 0.05497153475880623, -0.018330438062548637, -0.02307235077023506, -0.018453290686011314, -0.050179529935121536, -0.0670633316040039, 0.029256345704197884, 0.006455768831074238, -0.03798936679959297, 0.045306477695703506, -0.08522942662239075, 0.10565469413995743, 0.0017064863350242376, 0.003597133792936802, 0.021938417106866837, 0.031601887196302414, -0.016272734850645065, 0.001154232886619866, 0.05230223014950752, 0.05715237930417061, 0.0008941027917899191, 0.03463250398635864, 0.022329121828079224, 0.10039293020963669, -0.01857614703476429, -0.059642352163791656, 0.060545459389686584, -0.008549858815968037, 0.026359103620052338, -0.010185211896896362, -0.026735061779618263, 0.07470940798521042, 0.028274184092879295, 0.025519169867038727, -0.02855013869702816, 0.0023212602827697992, -0.03998265787959099, 0.002968544838950038, -0.043219804763793945, 0.06861948221921921, 0.0380021370947361, -0.010714886710047722, -0.04408033564686775, -0.03881028667092323, 0.06180983781814575, -0.052595872431993484, -0.02223033271729946, -0.03450513631105423, -0.03388601541519165, -0.025171032175421715, -0.049873799085617065, 0.058805037289857864, 0.08758414536714554, -0.017259705811738968, -0.054122235625982285, 0.06221069023013115, -0.030024228617548943, 0.012963520362973213, -0.008364260196685791, 0.03672260046005249, -0.007552124094218016, 0.029209092259407043, 0.04413784295320511, 0.014833258464932442, -0.04262595623731613, 0.01396457850933075, -0.008830650709569454, 0.012073284946382046, 0.07470101863145828, 0.030810197815299034, 0.020833320915699005, 0.011404238641262054, -0.02840922214090824, -0.03881850838661194, -0.03781328722834587, 0.009479516185820103, 0.013856564648449421, 0.04142092168331146, 0.04701639339327812, 0.0493740476667881, 0.021200809627771378, 0.005419101100414991, -0.04312095418572426, 0.029381122440099716, 0.030878279358148575, -0.06343338638544083, -0.07261310517787933, -0.05957440286874771, -0.03250511735677719, -0.06605107337236404, -0.00572993466630578, -0.06945057958364487, 0.013964593410491943, 0.05488268658518791, 0.0075215185061097145, 0.060558021068573, 0.01720668002963066, -0.06603127717971802, -0.01606377586722374, -0.04895016923546791, 0.02475889027118683, 0.03462117910385132, 0.028686102479696274, 0.035419948399066925, 0.05256709083914757, 0.05965939164161682, 0.020225295796990395, -0.013258267194032669, 0.01546726655215025, -0.012009628117084503, -0.04838790372014046, -0.023105008527636528, -0.02108793705701828, -0.001545462990179658, 0.012919803149998188, 0.06436246633529663, 0.003328672843053937, -0.06143311783671379, -0.05911325290799141, -0.03728377819061279, -0.03263326361775398, 0.008227551355957985, 0.05746299773454666, -0.01944005861878395, 0.047174468636512756, -0.04766659438610077, 0.02330702170729637, -0.03025202825665474, -0.012938592582941055, -0.02844315767288208, 0.019603855907917023, -0.06614524871110916, -0.015168185345828533, -0.09889957308769226, 0.029919717460870743, 0.07501205056905746, 0.04559290036559105, 0.055393315851688385, 0.021518701687455177, -0.003127771196886897, -0.11530299484729767, -0.01251431554555893, 0.016401823610067368, -0.024183960631489754, -0.07546638697385788, 0.043851763010025024, 0.02452603355050087, -0.027565909549593925, -0.04077371954917908, 0.03208326920866966, -0.003939040470868349, 0.025435790419578552, -0.005911871325224638, -0.04786341264843941, -0.02300761453807354, 0.012764099054038525, -0.005040959920734167, 0.033751342445611954, -0.04926643520593643, -0.019429178908467293, -0.02050126902759075, -0.02919183298945427, 0.04995063692331314, 0.011644967831671238, -0.007307684980332851, 0.03163408860564232, 0.022306839004158974, 0.04626649618148804, -0.025275414809584618, 0.008158301934599876, 0.004785056225955486, -0.019943946972489357, 0.01838708110153675, 0.06235524266958237, 0.020494520664215088, 0.06379591673612595, -0.024690743535757065, 0.004080699756741524, -0.03697993978857994, 0.019737036898732185, 0.04654758423566818, -0.005618328228592873, -0.023569580167531967, 0.02610333077609539, 0.021790670230984688, -0.06782380491495132, 0.04265264421701431, -0.0821237564086914, 0.033757954835891724, 0.11743210256099701, -0.028301240876317024, -0.0009107068181037903, 0.006876314524561167, 0.07580269873142242, 0.027866968885064125, -0.016710277646780014, -0.014848518185317516, 0.05483349412679672, -0.01479378528892994, -0.04549071937799454, -0.030679376795887947, -0.012935487553477287, -0.06798691302537918, 0.01040632463991642, -0.021750425919890404, -0.013738587498664856, -0.11268667876720428, 0.05718658119440079, -0.055568959563970566, 0.0002810109290294349, 0.052918463945388794, -0.031329866498708725, 0.048634592443704605, 0.039470307528972626, 0.011833100579679012, -0.01218256913125515, -0.05408904328942299, 0.028162462636828423, 0.0673614889383316, 0.06450533121824265, -0.011554325930774212, 0.09892722964286804, 0.10545188933610916, 0.024028658866882324, -0.06943869590759277, -0.0008964747539721429, 0.006087370682507753, -0.009987902827560902, -0.019869856536388397, 0.060310155153274536, 0.014683009125292301, -0.010020585730671883, -0.01960701495409012, -0.028518881648778915, -0.04654345288872719, -0.03968726471066475, 0.03877969831228256, -0.054406240582466125, 0.04215723276138306, 0.034809257835149765, -0.029801921918988228, -0.04488250985741615, 0.056494586169719696, 0.029987569898366928, -0.07456905394792557, 0.08857032656669617, -0.0708170235157013, -0.014643562026321888, -0.04863470420241356, 0.0763595849275589, -0.06688747555017471, 0.026439528912305832, -0.028846189379692078, 0.028148215264081955, 0.018414530903100967, -0.048831596970558167, -0.07259318232536316, -0.09339220076799393, -0.0484561026096344, -0.060159437358379364, 0.035004593431949615, 0.029922131448984146, 0.08814124017953873, 0.0009364394936710596, -0.03966984525322914, 0.004493615590035915, -0.012368879280984402, -0.006927683018147945, -0.01977824792265892, 0.05905451625585556, 0.0021063995081931353, 0.04538324475288391, -0.012159007601439953, -0.00540729146450758, -0.010138057172298431, 0.018605971708893776, 0.04766169190406799, 0.005134373903274536, -0.00940751563757658, -0.09077753126621246, 0.02939246967434883, 0.07625073194503784, -0.04983758553862572, 0.041224155575037, -0.031050143763422966, -0.007037097122520208, -0.010908011347055435, 0.05021374300122261, 0.04141782596707344, -0.01268278993666172, 0.030317753553390503, 0.030786575749516487, 0.05173104628920555, -0.06417471170425415, 0.050767526030540466, 0.08298783004283905, -0.004999917466193438, -0.013477081432938576, -0.07400324940681458, -0.04112059250473976, -0.06282568722963333, -0.06519117206335068, -0.030512746423482895, 0.009293722920119762, 0.07569927722215652, -0.030809694901108742, -0.04286778345704079, -0.01221721526235342, -0.0665452852845192, 0.056295327842235565, 0.019059276208281517, -0.0033488136250525713, 0.016829805448651314, -0.03126034513115883, -0.03560413792729378, -0.0052794599905610085, -0.009785274975001812, -0.06523127853870392, -0.023723172023892403, -0.05572625994682312, -0.02748733200132847, -0.021121367812156677, 0.06317414343357086, 0.007403640542179346, -0.005421411246061325, 0.054365936666727066, 0.0027239981573075056, 0.012789400294423103, -0.013018249534070492, 0.010387282818555832, 0.045316196978092194, 0.055467866361141205, -0.015341024845838547, 0.01828811690211296, -0.025478610768914223, -0.08732831478118896, 0.010963127948343754, 0.058097805827856064, -0.043413128703832626, 0.006793993059545755, 0.011072006076574326, -0.0598294734954834, 0.03595370799303055, 0.03511107712984085, -0.08382677286863327, 0.06711376458406448, -0.01052282564342022, -0.052585288882255554, -0.058139581233263016, -0.06641991436481476, 0.002068130997940898, -0.021476726979017258, 0.10913174599409103, -0.04873545467853546, 0.030399121344089508, 0.006772381253540516, -0.10186265408992767, -0.06727252155542374, 0.05557350069284439, -0.0006484311888925731, -0.016211703419685364, 0.008670015260577202, 0.01801225356757641, -0.03395811468362808, 0.06175650656223297, -0.025334153324365616, 0.028274523094296455, 0.0240158773958683, -0.04821298271417618, -0.06629704684019089, -0.02685597538948059, -0.008698195219039917, -0.057190991938114166, -0.0226262416690588, 0.071504607796669, -0.01363902073353529, -0.002122241538017988, -0.05855770409107208, -0.004239753354340792, 0.07508629560470581, -0.08520656079053879, 0.0011420062510296702, 0.03764389082789421, 0.0349324606359005, 0.08578971028327942, 0.013557412661612034, -0.11634251475334167, -0.08934328705072403, 0.0791347473859787, -0.042439885437488556, 0.005370266269892454, 0.0644511878490448, 0.03079714998602867, 0.02232016623020172, -0.03426416963338852, -0.012922749854624271, 0.0449800044298172, 0.017766820266842842, -0.04473952576518059, 0.035191912204027176, -0.05709538236260414, 0.056016791611909866, 0.06057252734899521, 0.023027267307043076, 0.02419321984052658, 0.01126575656235218, -0.0110385213047266, -0.0030958426650613546, -0.01570751518011093, 0.0560731440782547, 0.0003580724005587399, 0.015192991122603416, 0.04639507085084915, -0.028734518215060234, -0.018095334991812706, 0.04405737295746803, 0.026271890848875046, 0.03146683797240257, 0.022861028090119362, 0.024812743067741394, 0.11416580528020859, 0.04593579098582268, 0.02334022894501686, 0.0038082064129412174, -0.03572748228907585, 0.039085354655981064, 0.009414883330464363, 0.047261931002140045 ]
84
84
A Radar-Shaped Statistic for Testing and Visualizing Uniformity Properties in Computer Experiments
In the study of computer codes, filling space as uniformly as possible is important to describe the complexity of the investigated phenomenon. However, this property is not conserved by reducing the dimension. Some numeric experiment designs are conceived in this sense as Latin hypercubes or orthogonal arrays, but they consider only the projections onto the axes or the coordinate planes. In this article we introduce a statistic which allows studying the good distribution of points according to all 1-dimensional projections. By angularly scanning the domain, we obtain a radar type representation, allowing the uniformity defects of a design to be identified with respect to its projections onto straight lines. The advantages of this new tool are demonstrated on usual examples of space-filling designs (SFD) and a global statistic independent of the angle of rotation is studied.
[ -0.00486411340534687, -0.019046641886234283, 0.026276344433426857, -0.0437895767390728, -0.029027750715613365, -0.06635858118534088, -0.05836217850446701, 0.03184192255139351, -0.04456726461648941, 0.09947477281093597, 0.03029770590364933, -0.0025282506830990314, -0.06707578152418137, 0.03436187282204628, 0.01902485080063343, -0.005781750660389662, -0.004162237513810396, 0.033545371145009995, 0.024007564410567284, -0.05089851841330528, 0.008630745112895966, 0.0248892642557621, -0.015179544687271118, 0.0035842526704072952, 0.018687095493078232, -0.005896530579775572, 0.015634771436452866, -0.00013060745550319552, -0.06474308669567108, -0.038271840661764145, -0.033023133873939514, 0.08007468283176422, 0.04504653438925743, 0.018622007220983505, -0.027930378913879395, -0.008502659387886524, 0.03407899662852287, 0.03755905106663704, -0.02629014104604721, 0.012845491990447044, -0.0037570702843368053, 0.02685588411986828, -0.015529957599937916, 0.005369083024561405, 0.06408938765525818, 0.025378305464982986, -0.05672318860888481, -0.029586343094706535, 0.027778824791312218, -0.040183816105127335, -0.052927739918231964, 0.0718887522816658, -0.05306297913193703, 0.05287032946944237, -0.004108941648155451, 0.05026707798242569, -0.017421917989850044, 0.045588940382003784, 0.014937118627130985, 0.0006416398100554943, 0.02869248017668724, 0.0558847039937973, -0.04766988381743431, -0.04992346093058586, 0.020427873358130455, -0.058285512030124664, -0.04168055206537247, -0.08817616105079651, 0.0027098250575363636, -0.02602473646402359, 0.019065210595726967, 0.012284023687243462, -0.07328474521636963, 0.011633056215941906, 0.07584895938634872, 0.010638505220413208, -0.050594184547662735, -0.034141432493925095, -0.008313029073178768, 0.09845448285341263, -0.036360494792461395, 0.07955484092235565, -0.01615026220679283, -0.06315716356039047, -0.05733175948262215, 0.021634332835674286, 0.0061563774943351746, 0.014071610756218433, 0.01717555709183216, -0.0035603486467152834, -0.02141605131328106, -0.018450532108545303, -0.07795212417840958, 0.06052951142191887, -0.00769372982904315, 0.06361033767461777, -0.056256573647260666, -0.023787740617990494, -0.010060478933155537, 0.05013195052742958, 0.011556882411241531, -0.025812286883592606, 0.11358856409788132, 0.08892267197370529, -0.023433687165379524, 0.06541668623685837, -0.07433683425188065, 0.0333516001701355, -0.03425979241728783, -0.017695700749754906, 0.01707426644861698, 0.0181843563914299, -0.011681484058499336, -0.0016952244332060218, 0.0077132899314165115, 0.054787419736385345, -0.03206569328904152, 0.044334158301353455, 0.07291979342699051, -0.04538092389702797, 0.0323786661028862, 0.08901078253984451, 0.02055772766470909, -0.01981458254158497, 0.07225977629423141, 0.03932938724756241, 0.036297060549259186, -0.02568187192082405, 0.11943948268890381, 0.03638638183474541, -0.0026327657978981733, 0.032258041203022, -0.033105943351984024, 0.0460062213242054, -0.020050212740898132, 0.04512176290154457, 0.004259719979017973, 0.05603873357176781, 0.01581696979701519, 0.01616973616182804, 0.045354291796684265, -0.060005154460668564, -0.02103426307439804, 0.06773953884840012, 0.04981017857789993, -0.005309309810400009, -0.005722518544644117, 0.05438849702477455, 0.039297960698604584, 0.002351670525968075, 0.012150963768362999, -0.0569436214864254, 0.08487024903297424, -0.046675290912389755, 0.033871013671159744, 0.019699029624462128, -0.012642065063118935, 0.08129823207855225, -0.011285356245934963, 0.02958517335355282, -0.026671821251511574, 0.019024165347218513, -0.04833926260471344, 0.020746754482388496, 0.021586470305919647, -0.011338088661432266, 0.06188487261533737, -0.052954744547605515, -0.07835649698972702, -0.010577435605227947, -0.03946330025792122, -0.03148946911096573, -0.03575591370463371, 0.03139503300189972, 0.013689197599887848, 0.02435031533241272, -0.013091150671243668, 0.013616145588457584, 0.0015964150661602616, -0.06628984957933426, -0.012811566703021526, 0.02015392668545246, -0.06989026814699173, 0.06775128096342087, 0.02012462168931961, 0.07965146005153656, -0.011361747980117798, -0.007625855039805174, 0.06244475767016411, 0.06425615400075912, 0.0429062619805336, -0.046184197068214417, 0.06755603104829788, -0.03521270677447319, -0.03784428909420967, 0.08833848685026169, 0.00603289483115077, -0.03810910880565643, 0.045402441173791885, 0.010473293252289295, 0.09181176126003265, -0.020816819742321968, -0.04679025709629059, -0.09653907269239426, -0.015492042526602745, 0.019168416038155556, -0.00976080447435379, -0.027493389323353767, -0.020023973658680916, -0.06759621948003769, -0.04347555711865425, 0.0022129991557449102, 0.00514210993424058, -0.0246963519603014, 0.030931862071156502, 0.036085255444049835, 0.0574495904147625, -0.051691822707653046, 0.0804062932729721, -0.009184413589537144, -0.06931808590888977, 0.041646599769592285, -0.03822198137640953, -0.00836305133998394, -0.05180814117193222, 0.03001963347196579, 0.025315644219517708, -0.017679966986179352, -0.05552256107330322, 0.012053076177835464, -0.039198607206344604, -0.004726930055767298, -0.06277859956026077, 0.01348800677806139, -0.03588477149605751, 0.0647716298699379, 0.026468774303793907, 0.053703904151916504, 0.006064507178962231, -0.02793199010193348, -0.07934832572937012, 0.033238887786865234, -0.043675195425748825, 0.01112882886081934, 0.00018836600065696985, -0.02667652629315853, 0.024455925449728966, 0.08847947418689728, 0.0010582166723906994, 0.03376613184809685, 0.0005605528713203967, -0.11276029795408249, -0.02141333371400833, -0.038137469440698624, -0.032310403883457184, 0.03153269737958908, -0.029383808374404907, -0.05601165443658829, 0.09448953717947006, -0.007749082054942846, 0.05460337549448013, 0.053004324436187744, -0.03714863583445549, 0.011781563051044941, -0.0022640558890998363, 0.03189314901828766, -0.04604176804423332, 0.034311842173337936, 0.06033126637339592, 0.05500927194952965, 0.048298534005880356, -0.0817813128232956, -0.08160517364740372, 0.0508640818297863, -0.03232819214463234, -0.030523674562573433, 0.04900099337100983, 0.03776630014181137, -0.07690759003162384, -0.026657743379473686, -0.06520209461450577, 0.0052664331160485744, -0.06131771206855774, 0.0014394184108823538, -0.003145999740809202, 0.06126650795340538, 0.04839000105857849, -0.004473269451409578, -0.017485173419117928, 0.017741814255714417, -0.02270660176873207, 0.02516462467610836, -0.10587078332901001, 0.004393298178911209, 0.043592847883701324, -0.008016349747776985, 0.034403227269649506, -0.032002970576286316, 0.007200141437351704, 0.01146470196545124, 0.035001665353775024, -0.04975903779268265, 0.019469590857625008, -0.043714769184589386, 0.03734740987420082, -0.00003899846342392266, 0.1314108818769455, 0.031766120344400406, -0.05618088319897652, 0.04596146568655968, 0.039001014083623886, 0.00025962648214772344, -0.05574692040681839, -0.035513851791620255, 0.01095806434750557, -0.08854939788579941, -0.04017665982246399, -0.027256598696112633, -0.015534571371972561, 0.05119568854570389, 0.031162457540631294, -0.04307424649596214, 0.02443925477564335, -0.01725783199071884, -0.016354942694306374, 0.03663249313831329, 0.020006198436021805, -0.011751273646950722, -0.04373537376523018, -0.013174477964639664, -0.035018064081668854, -0.0031955435406416655, 0.014231198467314243, 0.12538594007492065, -0.006186732091009617, 0.04374747723340988, -0.0964527577161789, -0.07380311191082001, -0.06552790105342865, -0.013751251623034477, 0.007279976271092892, -0.07858975976705551, -0.006994876079261303, -0.068079374730587, 0.014179994352161884, 0.06445176899433136, 0.06837687641382217, 0.018021488562226295, -0.06218712404370308, -0.07056529074907303, -0.03759016841650009, -0.008732966147363186, -0.007907848805189133, 0.014080897904932499, -0.050301846116781235, 0.02973255142569542, 0.0347641222178936, 0.013066033832728863, 0.023099571466445923, 0.054458677768707275, -0.10842405259609222, 0.0003964891948271543, -0.027115341275930405, -0.004519748501479626, -0.01684480905532837, 0.08197851479053497, -0.03205365315079689, 0.023813726380467415, -0.06814735382795334, -0.01146902609616518, -0.04728631302714348, 0.03107752650976181, 0.030512822791934013, 0.021279769018292427, 0.003625054145231843, -0.022456778213381767, 0.002503038151189685, -0.005327235441654921, -0.045434605330228806, 0.08430782705545425, -0.04582754895091057, -0.02722291089594364, -0.016160091385245323, 0.04965488240122795, -0.016195004805922508, 0.014702548272907734, 0.03946230560541153, -0.08112684637308121, 0.05294833332300186, -0.013061163946986198, -0.0018607779638841748, -0.060772720724344254, 0.057691846042871475, 0.028797201812267303, 0.04704258218407631, -0.007151382975280285, 0.008412722498178482, -0.05710156634449959, 0.04394115135073662, 0.004854442086070776, 0.023815395310521126, 0.006281662732362747, -0.06103559210896492, -0.05430682376027107, -0.08439644426107407, -0.032849472016096115, 0.0008837874047458172, -0.005387162324041128, -0.05266423895955086, 0.004248273093253374, -0.04882535710930824, -0.04546665400266647, -0.0181826651096344, 0.07589394599199295, 0.030356423929333687, 0.05743073672056198, -0.013282226398587227, -0.04838981851935387, -0.0001685276220086962, -0.043865978717803955, 0.021464088931679726, -0.05088645964860916, 0.03859102353453636, -0.009875497780740261, 0.034900616854429245, -0.052405308932065964, -0.018065836280584335, 0.07839513570070267, 0.011198443360626698, 0.10770190507173538, -0.018346751108765602, 0.01737387105822563, -0.021335236728191376, 0.07088915258646011, -0.02188543789088726, -0.028867244720458984, 0.011344884522259235, -0.11052843183279037, 0.019913041964173317, 0.0048337047919631, -0.02349945344030857, 0.02122705988585949, -0.040150176733732224, 0.008545399643480778, 0.05770842358469963, -0.039629701524972916, 0.022499846294522285, 0.0009890201035887003, 0.05022604390978813, 0.01930624060332775, -0.05001852288842201, 0.011150352656841278, 0.003255638526752591, -0.03306339308619499, 0.0342136025428772, 0.060283053666353226, 0.08126182854175568, 0.0009332036133855581, 0.0213002972304821, 0.034066908061504364, -0.03347797691822052, -0.03533570468425751, 0.02155015617609024, 0.06562750786542892, -0.1117653176188469, 0.0286864060908556, 0.02455822564661503, 0.04680628329515457, 0.04823048412799835, -0.013664447702467442, -0.0695618987083435, 0.028601055964827538, -0.016126731410622597, -0.002602608175948262, 0.0013395308051258326, -0.03287149965763092, 0.06487489491701126, -0.025857597589492798, -0.010544994845986366, -0.09978889673948288, 0.026354055851697922, -0.07725918292999268, 0.005703416187316179, 0.020712560042738914, 0.0028407254721969366, -0.005585940089076757, -0.01711496338248253, 0.005410739686340094, 0.04139101132750511, -0.02166076749563217, 0.03794022649526596, -0.023185970261693, -0.006207011174410582, 0.044995564967393875, -0.06912046670913696, -0.04289507493376732, 0.0140158636495471, 0.009208785369992256, 0.027941010892391205, 0.008653821423649788, -0.005813511088490486, -0.007237389218062162, 0.03322423994541168, -0.001024283585138619, -0.005234826356172562, 0.07281789183616638, 0.036421872675418854, -0.06732039153575897, -0.043868083506822586, 0.0651264414191246, 0.043041642755270004, 0.0515759214758873 ]
85
85
Compressed Counting
Counting is among the most fundamental operations in computing. For example, counting the pth frequency moment has been a very active area of research, in theoretical computer science, databases, and data mining. When p=1, the task (i.e., counting the sum) can be accomplished using a simple counter. Compressed Counting (CC) is proposed for efficiently computing the pth frequency moment of a data stream signal A_t, where 0<p<=2. CC is applicable if the streaming data follow the Turnstile model, with the restriction that at the time t for the evaluation, A_t[i]>= 0, which includes the strict Turnstile model as a special case. For natural data streams encountered in practice, this restriction is minor. The underly technique for CC is what we call skewed stable random projections, which captures the intuition that, when p=1 a simple counter suffices, and when p = 1+/\Delta with small \Delta, the sample complexity of a counter system should be low (continuously as a function of \Delta). We show at small \Delta the sample complexity (number of projections) k = O(1/\epsilon) instead of O(1/\epsilon^2). Compressed Counting can serve a basic building block for other tasks in statistics and computing, for example, estimation entropies of data streams, parameter estimations using the method of moments and maximum likelihood. Finally, another contribution is an algorithm for approximating the logarithmic norm, \sum_{i=1}^D\log A_t[i], and logarithmic distance. The logarithmic distance is useful in machine learning practice with heavy-tailed data.
[ 0.01762915588915348, -0.0000355755073542241, 0.03266969695687294, -0.07233309745788574, 0.03545438498258591, 0.03746389225125313, 0.006399211939424276, -0.011700011789798737, -0.02094324491918087, 0.03803998976945877, -0.019085919484496117, -0.001737247221171856, -0.07515458762645721, -0.022415999323129654, 0.004108287859708071, -0.06571201980113983, -0.07900281250476837, 0.0085703544318676, 0.0031475950963795185, -0.05663182958960533, -0.10080757737159729, -0.04817217215895653, -0.039628032594919205, -0.04628646373748779, 0.030438654124736786, -0.012514729052782059, 0.03486648574471474, 0.06199043616652489, -0.08490899950265884, -0.03907288610935211, -0.05909016355872154, -0.0009517499129287899, 0.06686196476221085, -0.016670309007167816, 0.007718589156866074, -0.07111389189958572, 0.013250191695988178, 0.024829093366861343, -0.018016286194324493, -0.059546276926994324, 0.0008458419470116496, -0.04888070002198219, -0.048070017248392105, -0.041178129613399506, 0.02292957529425621, -0.018041597679257393, 0.052157651633024216, 0.030483584851026535, -0.012881414964795113, 0.05795523151755333, -0.06419805437326431, 0.016609059646725655, -0.021205220371484756, -0.015480076894164085, 0.008813361637294292, -0.003599289571866393, -0.008408529683947563, -0.019181478768587112, -0.03507450968027115, -0.09258679300546646, -0.015391021966934204, 0.09367229789495468, -0.027330227196216583, -0.024961289018392563, -0.06085768714547157, 0.005630392115563154, -0.06814055889844894, 0.0021704882383346558, -0.05760935693979263, -0.019480155780911446, 0.0000992883724393323, -0.06216505914926529, -0.027076413854956627, 0.022926632314920425, -0.02815268188714981, 0.01535981334745884, -0.06437418609857559, 0.04838229715824127, 0.032881565392017365, 0.01778183877468109, -0.016134053468704224, 0.0361788235604763, -0.09020618349313736, -0.04428192973136902, -0.09464562684297562, -0.006740975193679333, 0.03458918258547783, 0.030026830732822418, 0.035730812698602676, -0.08003520965576172, -0.12025583535432816, -0.019669922068715096, -0.13507741689682007, 0.03080274723470211, -0.08338679373264313, 0.07287878543138504, -0.010483288206160069, 0.01881331391632557, -0.03734458610415459, 0.01499398797750473, 0.02751467004418373, -0.017010174691677094, 0.05790720507502556, 0.07352043688297272, 0.026387488469481468, -0.007449790835380554, -0.023708146065473557, 0.018769392743706703, 0.09355763345956802, 0.010935134254395962, 0.06392304599285126, -0.006548270117491484, -0.0024178510066121817, -0.029400035738945007, 0.02344534732401371, 0.047368284314870834, 0.06884285062551498, 0.006986308842897415, -0.008062212727963924, -0.022652840241789818, 0.05041078105568886, 0.008356191217899323, 0.0712231770157814, -0.0006107980152592063, 0.06385501474142075, -0.0072883013635873795, -0.03443547710776329, -0.029566289857029915, 0.0774189904332161, -0.013802051544189453, -0.02575589343905449, 0.024073531851172447, -0.018665499985218048, 0.04004291072487831, -0.07090294361114502, 0.07578852027654648, 0.09694376587867737, -0.005467172246426344, 0.012839896604418755, 0.04765857383608818, -0.058565404266119, -0.04495002701878548, -0.04809166118502617, 0.017822198569774628, 0.04213951528072357, 0.03283511474728584, 0.02688957378268242, -0.0043980879709124565, 0.012952444143593311, -0.0032100414391607046, 0.009580530226230621, -0.004732929170131683, -0.029605815187096596, -0.04212755709886551, -0.014254789799451828, -0.049197617918252945, -0.027594640851020813, 0.033383842557668686, -0.00016480431077070534, 0.06459641456604004, -0.09139294177293777, 0.025505710393190384, 0.006145389284938574, 0.0026946845464408398, -0.02756498008966446, 0.023124586790800095, -0.06656759232282639, -0.002721028635278344, -0.014415622688829899, -0.0450357124209404, 0.01114482432603836, 0.039573512971401215, -0.03396974503993988, -0.009699092246592045, 0.003437827806919813, -0.018371548503637314, 0.03134685382246971, -0.028090771287679672, 0.01896168664097786, -0.045181140303611755, 0.03452301397919655, -0.04996465519070625, -0.04451040178537369, 0.05081690102815628, 0.04222266003489494, 0.11582423001527786, -0.026538031175732613, 0.07226516306400299, 0.05801873281598091, 0.056781522929668427, 0.01850781962275505, 0.031023496761918068, 0.036050889641046524, 0.007454996462911367, 0.010748873464763165, 0.040319088846445084, -0.041405580937862396, -0.04909754917025566, -0.024753496050834656, 0.10000140964984894, 0.0596681647002697, -0.008045542985200882, -0.07421296089887619, -0.02046683244407177, -0.06608767807483673, 0.010610590688884258, 0.02565286122262478, -0.04652509465813637, 0.03382240980863571, -0.07657171785831451, 0.004177764058113098, 0.0031194009352475405, -0.0005760958883911371, -0.06605924665927887, 0.023119203746318817, -0.031796496361494064, -0.02283385396003723, -0.014028413221240044, 0.0023279355373233557, 0.0739634558558464, 0.027756160125136375, 0.022230777889490128, -0.03951992839574814, 0.09367255866527557, -0.006854882463812828, -0.02142130769789219, 0.013042802922427654, 0.02816854603588581, 0.017476290464401245, -0.05773050710558891, -0.06485618650913239, -0.022561101242899895, -0.017120812088251114, -0.014576276764273643, -0.04072244092822075, 0.07245294749736786, -0.022790739312767982, -0.04071108624339104, -0.06525861471891403, -0.009659417904913425, -0.07247104495763779, 0.04935769364237785, -0.0009748332086019218, 0.06180029362440109, 0.012829562649130821, -0.009838704951107502, -0.057244665920734406, 0.047103699296712875, -0.017321547493338585, -0.0016129127470776439, 0.00537356361746788, 0.0060409498400986195, 0.01273871399462223, -0.020526153966784477, 0.010655563324689865, 0.01284471433609724, -0.022788286209106445, 0.07835870236158371, 0.03017321601510048, 0.029233671724796295, -0.028050662949681282, 0.03262033686041832, -0.06282554566860199, 0.08539355546236038, -0.06884496659040451, 0.011218953877687454, -0.06458790600299835, 0.020913057029247284, 0.03413994237780571, -0.001911597908474505, 0.04027038440108299, 0.0132366344332695, -0.0488714799284935, 0.040179263800382614, 0.036141786724328995, -0.062145497649908066, 0.00997183658182621, 0.049148231744766235, 0.04012448713183403, -0.06040217727422714, -0.07160139083862305, 0.005598629359155893, -0.0312998965382576, -0.0050882925279438496, 0.015328958630561829, 0.013626745902001858, -0.013448570854961872, 0.00777939660474658, -0.010780691169202328, -0.02779020369052887, -0.009097025729715824, 0.049469634890556335, -0.034860000014305115, -0.012320143170654774, 0.00910826213657856, -0.03867105022072792, 0.07006081193685532, -0.03314370661973953, 0.09764517843723297, 0.0516999177634716, -0.020459242165088654, 0.006053614430129528, 0.07472941279411316, 0.04311525821685791, -0.017368905246257782, 0.08378554880619049, 0.09011171013116837, 0.04134451970458031, -0.0615597739815712, 0.03177012875676155, 0.0106516657397151, 0.027770889922976494, -0.0722355768084526, -0.022217458114027977, -0.018716230988502502, -0.005401100963354111, -0.012496881186962128, -0.07261659950017929, -0.0020811615977436304, -0.014692013151943684, -0.029441045597195625, 0.03813982009887695, -0.012693370692431927, -0.0006035810220055282, -0.01866883784532547, 0.03399746119976044, 0.055720195174217224, 0.013532369397580624, -0.0173722542822361, 0.03075898066163063, 0.004086571279913187, 0.029744373634457588, -0.04362870380282402, 0.10729023814201355, 0.03870121017098427, 0.017657028511166573, 0.006173127796500921, -0.032187093049287796, 0.04281099885702133, 0.021584447473287582, -0.05672193691134453, 0.02438640594482422, 0.018030108883976936, -0.00811863411217928, 0.04840591922402382, 0.026844896376132965, 0.1160537376999855, 0.02894933708012104, -0.019833054393529892, -0.03073076903820038, -0.049856554716825485, 0.04786107689142227, 0.022575728595256805, -0.05748632550239563, 0.028349019587039948, 0.1465774029493332, 0.04416828230023384, 0.01857200637459755, 0.012105855159461498, 0.00817874912172556, 0.03049122914671898, -0.007623670157045126, 0.03998439386487007, -0.06871238350868225, 0.036101579666137695, 0.06180411949753761, -0.04605735093355179, -0.05094631016254425, -0.053945932537317276, -0.03845759108662605, 0.01383421290665865, 0.047276828438043594, 0.0006712862523272634, 0.05163538455963135, 0.027482736855745316, -0.0008460648823529482, 0.08833688497543335, -0.021877938881516457, -0.01578073762357235, 0.020261500030755997, -0.055017054080963135, -0.08460386842489243, -0.04856574907898903, 0.07641447335481644, -0.027640167623758316, 0.03418385609984398, 0.01573723740875721, -0.029264068230986595, 0.06542032957077026, 0.001542337704449892, -0.06584279239177704, 0.00007726554031250998, -0.0318012461066246, -0.004394331946969032, 0.07931259274482727, -0.015607030130922794, -0.03238430991768837, -0.07121814042329788, 0.06400161981582642, -0.04933495819568634, 0.05739970877766609, -0.06016995757818222, -0.04449055716395378, -0.05314796045422554, -0.10193948447704315, -0.019665773957967758, -0.022895021364092827, 0.05127239599823952, -0.025777947157621384, -0.006051088683307171, 0.0697532594203949, -0.046193983405828476, -0.04639806970953941, 0.08796436339616776, 0.001625441713258624, -0.0016525936080142856, 0.014651382341980934, -0.0868573933839798, -0.03362276405096054, -0.07393330335617065, -0.006978953257203102, 0.04040148854255676, 0.04073100909590721, -0.010441165417432785, 0.03286539763212204, -0.06733209639787674, 0.05902515724301338, 0.02537829987704754, -0.006829542573541403, 0.008155574090778828, -0.035504668951034546, 0.022874625399708748, -0.008470796048641205, 0.09700252115726471, 0.011967994272708893, -0.022035330533981323, -0.019414901733398438, 0.00566020468249917, 0.014052852056920528, 0.003893208457157016, 0.020017672330141068, -0.00797497108578682, -0.027236850932240486, 0.04381043091416359, -0.01219109259545803, -0.051098741590976715, -0.0018613309366628528, -0.014101819135248661, 0.028765300288796425, -0.025812987238168716, 0.0325445719063282, 0.005944625940173864, 0.08055924624204636, -0.07793611288070679, -0.039066944271326065, 0.033781252801418304, 0.0029313794802874327, 0.03940410166978836, 0.12827324867248535, 0.025524698197841644, -0.03612237423658371, -0.03256331756711006, -0.02397824265062809, 0.02968367375433445, -0.04667142033576965, -0.022263284772634506, -0.014688320457935333, 0.05210212618112564, 0.04645659402012825, 0.0005349270068109035, -0.008626996539533138, 0.05769127607345581, -0.03731231391429901, -0.011815288104116917, 0.026928232982754707, 0.01750566065311432, 0.055679548531770706, -0.01925244927406311, 0.06294073164463043, -0.03213837370276451, -0.009717438369989395, -0.012161564081907272, -0.03958643600344658, 0.011217139661312103, 0.09310439229011536, -0.005600621923804283, 0.03941858187317848, -0.061249662190675735, -0.012656308710575104, 0.05795720964670181, 0.043636880815029144, -0.023415016010403633, 0.07679039239883423, -0.009937186725437641, 0.01260231900960207, 0.007350032217800617, 0.014882775023579597, 0.042324498295784, -0.038859862834215164, 0.059691693633794785, 0.07258522510528564, -0.016277942806482315, 0.03673841804265976, 0.03512532636523247, 0.0028257572557777166, 0.05059120059013367, 0.03270510956645012, -0.0670531690120697, -0.006682826671749353, -0.014098592102527618, 0.04978780075907707, 0.004065128043293953 ]
86
86
Sign Language Tutoring Tool
In this project, we have developed a sign language tutor that lets users learn isolated signs by watching recorded videos and by trying the same signs. The system records the user's video and analyses it. If the sign is recognized, both verbal and animated feedback is given to the user. The system is able to recognize complex signs that involve both hand gestures and head movements and expressions. Our performance tests yield a 99% recognition rate on signs involving only manual gestures and 85% recognition rate on signs that involve both manual and non manual components, such as head movement and facial expressions.
[ -0.010169487446546555, 0.018300039693713188, 0.011909178458154202, 0.057216424494981766, -0.020356833934783936, -0.12902601063251495, -0.042632490396499634, 0.08465564250946045, -0.0560162216424942, 0.03366968780755997, 0.020359491929411888, 0.06202615052461624, 0.015361212193965912, 0.06445559859275818, 0.05798601359128952, -0.05230449140071869, 0.08111827075481415, -0.0085481908172369, -0.01448462251573801, -0.08081343024969101, 0.08833366632461548, -0.0271970983594656, -0.02809043414890766, -0.014952572993934155, 0.09708911180496216, 0.03636733815073967, 0.07284988462924957, -0.0248623788356781, 0.018176201730966568, -0.0615464448928833, -0.012496727518737316, -0.04148060828447342, 0.061764705926179886, 0.03633957728743553, 0.0524728037416935, 0.01240342017263174, 0.05709746107459068, 0.04517681524157524, 0.00676688551902771, -0.03491906076669693, -0.003207174828276038, -0.05679754167795181, -0.03460036963224411, 0.022258786484599113, 0.03065052069723606, -0.03889872133731842, -0.05188200622797012, -0.006494450848549604, 0.043906230479478836, 0.08892962336540222, -0.06807626783847809, -0.04460131749510765, -0.0032923808321356773, 0.03501685708761215, -0.009826691821217537, 0.022772397845983505, 0.004458819981664419, -0.014111854135990143, -0.07273556292057037, -0.017066657543182373, -0.05072084814310074, 0.09730278700590134, 0.07954861223697662, 0.057909637689590454, 0.002986070467159152, -0.01041860319674015, -0.07577838748693466, -0.03827064484357834, -0.058841872960329056, 0.021804455667734146, 0.09332910180091858, 0.005352412816137075, -0.00922130886465311, 0.004366966430097818, 0.030175505205988884, -0.01973341405391693, -0.027829671278595924, -0.012144574895501137, -0.007656993344426155, 0.07187996804714203, 0.07773897796869278, -0.017888164147734642, 0.020081249997019768, -0.05735065042972565, -0.016446169465780258, -0.007003231439739466, -0.023668818175792694, 0.020677827298641205, 0.08074814081192017, -0.0070649441331624985, -0.08167961239814758, -0.023892100900411606, -0.01146372314542532, 0.049115706235170364, -0.014955537393689156, 0.01722768321633339, 0.006867139134556055, -0.07797576487064362, -0.03690365329384804, 0.04120677337050438, 0.018385980278253555, -0.02596491202712059, 0.02599347196519375, 0.007954712957143784, 0.00359333585947752, -0.01065481174737215, -0.03134441003203392, -0.06213531270623207, 0.05371348559856415, 0.021437564864754677, 0.0417318232357502, -0.0010094838216900826, 0.03592370077967644, -0.03202785551548004, 0.05605951324105263, -0.011684197001159191, -0.02611980028450489, 0.08730088919401169, 0.1096523329615593, -0.008390912786126137, -0.024235140532255173, 0.07762308418750763, -0.015603527426719666, -0.073016457259655, 0.05926595628261566, -0.07810518145561218, -0.019571740180253983, -0.025773368775844574, 0.05458427220582962, 0.0005300880293361843, -0.08685405552387238, -0.01900460198521614, -0.02856070175766945, 0.05331987142562866, -0.03318334370851517, 0.049476370215415955, -0.027079487219452858, -0.007767403498291969, -0.061658378690481186, -0.00789558794349432, 0.01484078448265791, 0.00309988996013999, 0.0016740243881940842, 0.019893566146492958, 0.05784960836172104, -0.01309947855770588, -0.04297448322176933, -0.0054963319562375546, 0.01499295886605978, -0.023719653487205505, 0.08665470778942108, -0.057057660073041916, 0.030207199975848198, 0.04273071140050888, 0.006218833848834038, 0.0011697286972776055, -0.006929704919457436, -0.017799416556954384, 0.033294741064310074, 0.03513055294752121, 0.026471253484487534, -0.005682400893419981, 0.0462610125541687, 0.03502950072288513, 0.04088654741644859, 0.0013481754576787353, -0.08201373368501663, -0.0517275407910347, -0.016225291416049004, -0.06608036905527115, -0.08047878742218018, 0.03158840164542198, -0.026031702756881714, 0.03022448532283306, -0.0022253552451729774, -0.05468139052391052, -0.014427068643271923, 0.07493231445550919, -0.060701884329319, 0.008835580199956894, -0.052745942026376724, -0.09962388873100281, -0.042278438806533813, 0.0011241068132221699, 0.052033931016922, 0.037465665489435196, 0.07533247023820877, 0.09864722192287445, 0.07414964586496353, -0.023860454559326172, 0.03350904956459999, 0.06370590627193451, 0.019687050953507423, -0.01996619813144207, 0.03587975725531578, 0.013606660068035126, 0.0354468859732151, 0.02096768282353878, -0.07639212906360626, 0.03454260155558586, 0.06667886674404144, -0.07481767237186432, -0.047990839928388596, 0.021480988711118698, -0.04352673143148422, -0.01361451018601656, -0.001298032351769507, -0.01116955280303955, 0.018477318808436394, 0.03350675106048584, -0.016824519261717796, 0.06268627941608429, -0.00035138888051733375, -0.04673486948013306, -0.06872063130140305, 0.007413349114358425, -0.01410670392215252, -0.08572351187467575, 0.046166736632585526, 0.028437169268727303, -0.0227358415722847, 0.050853926688432693, -0.006843892857432365, 0.0091914227232337, -0.02011125534772873, -0.03544685244560242, 0.03881564363837242, -0.042800821363925934, -0.034562502056360245, 0.012311244383454323, -0.029162822291254997, -0.04260144755244255, -0.10197462886571884, -0.029450949281454086, -0.002840237459167838, 0.030031537637114525, -0.006129920482635498, -0.011154885403811932, -0.022313419729471207, -0.014329161494970322, -0.00589396245777607, 0.024190165102481842, -0.030186360701918602, 0.05699789151549339, -0.007752678822726011, -0.00839223712682724, -0.024346748366951942, 0.06132540479302406, 0.005335030611604452, -0.032542500644922256, 0.058218058198690414, -0.013019763864576817, 0.0030358098447322845, -0.044150352478027344, -0.00424490449950099, 0.045575518161058426, -0.006873230915516615, -0.06523452699184418, 0.0324166901409626, 0.058052461594343185, 0.008233245462179184, -0.038907136768102646, -0.009621984325349331, -0.08052840828895569, 0.05689377337694168, -0.00992171186953783, -0.0323835089802742, -0.031177962198853493, 0.027017196640372276, -0.03427598997950554, 0.00914347730576992, -0.07030155509710312, -0.030584977939724922, -0.03934534266591072, -0.028040895238518715, 0.003288406878709793, -0.05666588246822357, 0.04443472623825073, -0.06279613077640533, -0.033610496670007706, -0.004311201628297567, 0.0018653884762898088, 0.05370156839489937, 0.0001946273259818554, -0.008098986931145191, 0.05651968717575073, 0.07870762050151825, 0.053884271532297134, -0.016290394589304924, -0.0034335972741246223, 0.009408085606992245, 0.01279741246253252, -0.12443556636571884, 0.030196279287338257, 0.037657201290130615, -0.09199655801057816, -0.040011294186115265, -0.06193438917398453, -0.007255489006638527, 0.06504345685243607, -0.022377731278538704, 0.0027567516081035137, 0.03585749864578247, 0.0959271639585495, -0.03299475833773613, -0.028664784505963326, -0.04470677301287651, 0.028181398287415504, -0.02213895320892334, -0.020240675657987595, 0.04588034749031067, -0.024961819872260094, -0.05614067614078522, 0.020985372364521027, -0.027089187875390053, -0.009592955932021141, 0.03378644958138466, -0.014618436805903912, -0.0472414530813694, 0.0602828711271286, 0.0125645836815238, -0.017756786197423935, -0.02346031367778778, -0.0023461654782295227, 0.03683631867170334, -0.005317987874150276, -0.0473531112074852, -0.0032865814864635468, -0.03712470829486847, 0.01961936429142952, 0.04487849026918411, 0.04008229821920395, 0.037537042051553726, 0.06527494639158249, -0.02548997476696968, 0.015841109678149223, 0.07441367208957672, -0.04722709208726883, -0.017863841727375984, 0.011772884987294674, -0.10920996218919754, -0.011145628988742828, 0.026325508952140808, -0.009260176680982113, -0.010950128547847271, 0.002797137713059783, 0.13995519280433655, -0.026113305240869522, -0.010172056034207344, -0.000984896905720234, 0.08359581232070923, -0.008157643489539623, -0.08121357858181, -0.029658976942300797, -0.00519444840028882, 0.009202787652611732, 0.00686568534001708, -0.019136060029268265, -0.01960621401667595, 0.019726257771253586, 0.041418395936489105, 0.011225867085158825, -0.007887042127549648, 0.006765948608517647, -0.0010855464497581124, 0.03130795434117317, -0.0014390434371307492, -0.0253444891422987, -0.057121437042951584, -0.030600978061556816, -0.07107341289520264, 0.021596474573016167, 0.053617220371961594, -0.04990937188267708, -0.03612882271409035, 0.00964400265365839, 0.01388123445212841, -0.031564775854349136, 0.036350980401039124, 0.03749535232782364, -0.019672593101859093, -0.0060139806009829044, -0.01284976489841938, 0.028088495135307312, -0.022618092596530914, 0.059748679399490356, -0.0038609078619629145, 0.06717343628406525, -0.024176467210054398, -0.04519166052341461, -0.05666278302669525, -0.07140818983316422, -0.05733777582645416, 0.05870378389954567, 0.054841116070747375, -0.012501356191933155, 0.04020097479224205, -0.04210527986288071, 0.052463408559560776, 0.025228790938854218, -0.08885237574577332, -0.0910809189081192, -0.06258311867713928, 0.029906438663601875, 0.004666633438318968, 0.020633580163121223, 0.0155791025608778, 0.021286118775606155, -0.011859860271215439, 0.0070434436202049255, 0.004336742218583822, 0.062021318823099136, -0.022264622151851654, -0.028640616685152054, -0.023105209693312645, 0.025583229959011078, -0.035189419984817505, -0.022482145577669144, 0.03999293968081474, -0.047589804977178574, 0.011098458431661129, 0.004226403776556253, -0.0019682247657328844, 0.0297795869410038, -0.04917803406715393, -0.019712768495082855, 0.1107030063867569, 0.02498195320367813, 0.022368313744664192, 0.0809461921453476, -0.01780003122985363, 0.05458882823586464, 0.0024184465873986483, 0.006473567336797714, -0.0004457947507034987, -0.03073228895664215, -0.009211326017975807, -0.0690130814909935, 0.015816861763596535, -0.002819785848259926, -0.09576374292373657, 0.032638005912303925, -0.008372625336050987, -0.024307316169142723, -0.09666980803012848, 0.007430731318891048, -0.02493775635957718, -0.003977748099714518, 0.051216188818216324, -0.023932423442602158, -0.02154119499027729, -0.04756253585219383, 0.03219912573695183, 0.002074990887194872, 0.045429155230522156, 0.011952157132327557, -0.033737726509571075, -0.06558333337306976, 0.05339301750063896, 0.05222770944237709, -0.04433496668934822, -0.049888480454683304, 0.0015082082245498896, 0.07770437002182007, -0.033350929617881775, 0.05646544322371483, 0.0631941705942154, 0.005231255199760199, 0.00973745621740818, -0.007717365399003029, -0.11982080340385437, 0.006407399196177721, 0.005781503859907389, 0.0013115373440086842, 0.008646328002214432, 0.07899044454097748, 0.03419218212366104, -0.07098730653524399, -0.09795811772346497, 0.017567375674843788, -0.01330854743719101, 0.06928563863039017, 0.05932259187102318, 0.03041529841721058, 0.0729224905371666, 0.01651466265320778, 0.04450371116399765, 0.01962556689977646, 0.04122047498822212, 0.05079169571399689, 0.026393014937639236, 0.00796694215387106, 0.023043369874358177, 0.04976017773151398, -0.004166943486779928, 0.0019527347758412361, 0.015375945717096329, 0.020897235721349716, -0.02374543808400631, -0.0028588310815393925, 0.06869644671678543, 0.03385891765356064, 0.02332303300499916, 0.04291829839348793, -0.0222544576972723, 0.04382222518324852, 0.04172566905617714, -0.02410293184220791, 0.028853103518486023, -0.04589637741446495, -0.11045797914266586, 0.06383717805147171 ]
87
87
Pure Exploration for Multi-Armed Bandit Problems
We consider the framework of stochastic multi-armed bandit problems and study the possibilities and limitations of forecasters that perform an on-line exploration of the arms. These forecasters are assessed in terms of their simple regret, a regret notion that captures the fact that exploration is only constrained by the number of available rounds (not necessarily known in advance), in contrast to the case when the cumulative regret is considered and when exploitation needs to be performed at the same time. We believe that this performance criterion is suited to situations when the cost of pulling an arm is expressed in terms of resources rather than rewards. We discuss the links between the simple and the cumulative regret. One of the main results in the case of a finite number of arms is a general lower bound on the simple regret of a forecaster in terms of its cumulative regret: the smaller the latter, the larger the former. Keeping this result in mind, we then exhibit upper bounds on the simple regret of some forecasters. The paper ends with a study devoted to continuous-armed bandit problems; we show that the simple regret can be minimized with respect to a family of probability distributions if and only if the cumulative regret can be minimized for it. Based on this equivalence, we are able to prove that the separable metric spaces are exactly the metric spaces on which these regrets can be minimized with respect to the family of all probability distributions with continuous mean-payoff functions.
[ 0.010211818851530552, -0.02796155959367752, 0.04647572711110115, 0.0032211553771048784, -0.006844547111541033, -0.0004355287819635123, -0.04548271745443344, 0.004622488282620907, -0.05765966698527336, 0.029906494542956352, 0.02319313958287239, -0.0015147076919674873, -0.01272466778755188, 0.035616785287857056, 0.03861555457115173, -0.06625297665596008, -0.06009702757000923, -0.012295377440750599, -0.04810576140880585, -0.07450444996356964, 0.062085095793008804, 0.03361211344599724, 0.06761927157640457, 0.014047965407371521, 0.010514050722122192, 0.016122711822390556, 0.02945435233414173, 0.007983277551829815, -0.045508064329624176, -0.03736079856753349, -0.06821446120738983, -0.022252744063735008, 0.00813355203717947, 0.02256334200501442, 0.05682968348264694, -0.04244893789291382, 0.0189483854919672, -0.06271646916866302, -0.042001329362392426, -0.019616279751062393, -0.014846794307231903, -0.04241514950990677, -0.07913222908973694, -0.010883009992539883, 0.0377342626452446, 0.06272400170564651, 0.0255696102976799, -0.06024957820773125, -0.0007548463763669133, 0.027327710762619972, -0.02436831407248974, 0.026007182896137238, -0.026086049154400826, -0.039251890033483505, -0.019280830398201942, 0.07235787063837051, -0.06938283890485764, -0.012946505099534988, -0.002299020066857338, -0.01501257810741663, -0.053635306656360626, 0.04641498625278473, 0.011133743450045586, 0.013001780956983566, -0.01862257346510887, 0.007400738541036844, -0.1415000855922699, 0.005066299811005592, 0.0020017654169350863, -0.05767782777547836, 0.06042972207069397, -0.05048046633601189, -0.014842132106423378, 0.006120495498180389, 0.016728872433304787, 0.031523291021585464, 0.0041188751347362995, -0.015142465941607952, -0.022405274212360382, 0.06302238255739212, -0.07338287681341171, 0.0539124421775341, -0.03225839138031006, 0.0844929963350296, 0.01939110830426216, -0.07974051684141159, 0.009686042554676533, -0.015495846047997475, 0.025437526404857635, -0.02309442311525345, 0.0181904174387455, -0.03785707801580429, -0.052393581718206406, 0.07055171579122543, 0.021146686747670174, 0.07175347954034805, -0.03222421929240227, -0.004803384188562632, 0.011864065192639828, -0.005911568645387888, 0.048440977931022644, 0.010290432721376419, 0.04878930002450943, 0.08305486291646957, -0.07259951531887054, -0.03685573488473892, 0.07018706947565079, 0.05933569744229317, 0.058404989540576935, -0.024905437603592873, 0.010109543800354004, -0.06249642372131348, 0.044705189764499664, -0.014053639024496078, -0.0041143218986690044, -0.009965200908482075, -0.05827935412526131, -0.03490307927131653, 0.030007442459464073, -0.020909659564495087, 0.048016518354415894, -0.013582145795226097, 0.002785378834232688, 0.04707200452685356, 0.021990139037370682, -0.0657823234796524, -0.039565108716487885, -0.0397607795894146, 0.12329684942960739, 0.01454161573201418, -0.04045572504401207, 0.058935943990945816, -0.024722877889871597, -0.03956346958875656, -0.06058768555521965, 0.05468250438570976, 0.08877777308225632, 0.037785857915878296, 0.03404589369893074, 0.055537451058626175, -0.028168559074401855, -0.018825137987732887, -0.031142668798565865, -0.0030024799052625895, -0.044874828308820724, -0.01065027341246605, 0.016108466312289238, 0.02420204132795334, -0.006955285090953112, 0.05867248401045799, -0.02540571801364422, 0.005943881813436747, 0.023667190223932266, 0.05031588301062584, 0.00820546131581068, -0.028183115646243095, -0.0554460808634758, 0.023479057475924492, -0.09189087152481079, 0.04091794416308403, -0.0058623068034648895, -0.01859930157661438, 0.046567462384700775, 0.044082820415496826, 0.025545228272676468, 0.017548024654388428, -0.01873946376144886, 0.08017686009407043, -0.0336560495197773, -0.09216206520795822, -0.02691236510872841, -0.02012109011411667, 0.027654828503727913, 0.026346886530518532, -0.011363458819687366, 0.02954689785838127, 0.00211677816696465, -0.02743208035826683, -0.039577677845954895, -0.05207240581512451, -0.0022958568297326565, -0.08569177985191345, 0.03046649508178234, -0.012679672800004482, 0.11999937146902084, 0.031918901950120926, 0.01177618745714426, 0.0023717181757092476, 0.08208833634853363, 0.04506624490022659, -0.06634534895420074, 0.05312376096844673, -0.0075234235264360905, -0.04365476593375206, 0.003917755093425512, -0.014707880094647408, -0.01780102029442787, -0.04037323221564293, -0.012892268598079681, 0.017645355314016342, -0.010598327964544296, 0.00930098257958889, -0.02684052102267742, 0.013761647045612335, -0.033145833760499954, -0.0074720666743814945, 0.057866357266902924, 0.020857878029346466, 0.05064493790268898, -0.07634080201387405, -0.0023407803382724524, -0.07344992458820343, -0.0520734079182148, 0.0045557026751339436, 0.0534113273024559, -0.07404659688472748, 0.008756089024245739, -0.034371960908174515, 0.054651327431201935, 0.028828108683228493, -0.05596672371029854, 0.09605249017477036, 0.01665567047894001, 0.026506341993808746, -0.088691845536232, 0.000924577412661165, 0.03131147846579552, -0.016891183331608772, -0.06661804020404816, 0.014920314773917198, 0.011068624444305897, -0.04349222406744957, 0.007907021790742874, 0.046180739998817444, -0.08795507252216339, 0.08491190522909164, -0.06331606954336166, -0.10215626657009125, 0.014739511534571648, -0.017687702551484108, -0.051378585398197174, -0.013537988997995853, -0.021398363634943962, -0.039751552045345306, -0.010197291150689125, 0.00245087081566453, 0.07070057094097137, 0.024787312373518944, -0.0023250309750437737, -0.07907166332006454, 0.0448257178068161, -0.03962903097271919, -0.06987357139587402, -0.009112662635743618, 0.03532407060265541, -0.014855602756142616, 0.06430422514677048, 0.05810863897204399, 0.07201220840215683, -0.06226825714111328, -0.028461843729019165, 0.016865545883774757, -0.06092327460646629, 0.03725529834628105, -0.020392300561070442, -0.022169452160596848, -0.02146020345389843, 0.01627529412508011, 0.0207577645778656, -0.05415051802992821, 0.0060266852378845215, -0.06160857528448105, -0.05535512417554855, 0.10362844169139862, -0.0002879185776691884, -0.054912202060222626, 0.022915687412023544, 0.0014201373560354114, 0.042603861540555954, -0.0015770791796967387, -0.07989035546779633, 0.016393620520830154, 0.007669062353670597, -0.04437161982059479, -0.024663560092449188, 0.019849633798003197, -0.04723701998591423, -0.023534025996923447, -0.03867596015334129, -0.024051673710346222, -0.012699010781943798, 0.054749373346567154, -0.04342840239405632, -0.003297135466709733, 0.0507601797580719, 0.02272728830575943, 0.0024047407787293196, 0.020884031429886818, 0.0028415031265467405, -0.025885319337248802, 0.021279724314808846, 0.003359577152878046, 0.07446696609258652, -0.02018575929105282, 0.03814765065908432, 0.07507319003343582, 0.03158658370375633, 0.12131594866514206, -0.0015130469109863043, -0.010312029160559177, 0.03262700140476227, -0.01896936446428299, -0.017135579138994217, -0.028195485472679138, 0.03951059654355049, 0.0016561222728341818, 0.04760600998997688, -0.023497989401221275, -0.0417390875518322, 0.08559975028038025, -0.0639144778251648, -0.03639658913016319, 0.027587883174419403, 0.04117820784449577, -0.10649814456701279, -0.05721781402826309, -0.02975454181432724, 0.016986435279250145, 0.007305143401026726, 0.011248280294239521, -0.03854785114526749, 0.005424620117992163, -0.05429475009441376, 0.11435430496931076, -0.12486467510461807, 0.027747180312871933, -0.06910298019647598, -0.014088914729654789, 0.02766154706478119, 0.015051312744617462, -0.05327776446938515, -0.03114589862525463, -0.04483863711357117, -0.022693637758493423, 0.0001727066992316395, 0.12105809897184372, 0.06436781585216522, 0.004352613817900419, -0.006295636761933565, 0.047928910702466965, -0.03541921451687813, -0.03979971259832382, 0.00613573519513011, 0.0848860889673233, -0.052799563854932785, -0.005929386708885431, 0.0017451171297580004, -0.028690146282315254, 0.005200015380978584, 0.0026217703707516193, -0.09822845458984375, -0.06351996213197708, 0.004315938334912062, 0.037216685712337494, 0.0706900879740715, 0.06717928498983383, 0.018549105152487755, 0.01916254498064518, -0.12034932523965836, -0.05454130843281746, -0.028865601867437363, 0.05180004984140396, 0.035624243319034576, -0.009829072281718254, 0.01451809797435999, -0.03366036340594292, 0.049608293920755386, -0.04053829237818718, -0.05221124365925789, 0.05350491404533386, 0.007139492779970169, -0.03474486246705055, -0.06773654371500015, -0.07257702201604843, -0.06700663268566132, -0.04974107816815376, -0.026949051767587662, -0.029482631012797356, 0.06305305659770966, -0.01776401326060295, -0.03621679171919823, -0.009068571962416172, 0.026789851486682892, -0.00024257757468149066, 0.02140030451118946, 0.0504835806787014, 0.10503184050321579, -0.042450059205293655, -0.0661398395895958, 0.0413578636944294, 0.023319561034440994, -0.04020504653453827, -0.023976188153028488, -0.06378232687711716, -0.044294293969869614, 0.024284524843096733, 0.024551941081881523, 0.05434458330273628, -0.053147464990615845, 0.047586891800165176, 0.012764934450387955, 0.048887256532907486, 0.04063323140144348, 0.010622288100421429, 0.0037913531996309757, 0.006212704814970493, 0.05168185010552406, -0.02419138327240944, 0.010260814800858498, -0.0193747878074646, 0.02382926270365715, -0.03240540251135826, -0.03223637118935585, -0.005295369308441877, 0.03553354740142822, -0.10708684474229813, -0.008003666996955872, 0.05704681947827339, -0.07961951941251755, 0.006382593419402838, -0.08449407666921616, -0.0004758820286951959, -0.047632500529289246, -0.019114775583148003, 0.024455085396766663, -0.0688157007098198, -0.041959621012210846, 0.011734324507415295, -0.04311780631542206, 0.019822845235466957, -0.05623502656817436, 0.011745473369956017, 0.020502066239714622, 0.04514851048588753, -0.006448034662753344, 0.04381823167204857, 0.02758830413222313, -0.009200891479849815, -0.0020496156066656113, -0.01049108523875475, -0.0022852637339383364, 0.040491845458745956, 0.03058028779923916, -0.04615186154842377, -0.025298219174146652, 0.005635727662593126, 0.023994604125618935, 0.015587146393954754, -0.0536421537399292, -0.021300069987773895, 0.01061160583049059, -0.0706232339143753, 0.08122372627258301, 0.0272158645093441, -0.049024034291505814, -0.0016573300817981362, 0.04022670164704323, 0.02582850493490696, 0.012064289301633835, -0.03142569586634636, -0.07878454029560089, 0.0204605832695961, -0.007966257631778717, -0.045766498893499374, -0.025706687942147255, -0.01893593929708004, 0.04381858557462692, -0.041478481143713, 0.013277910649776459, 0.02778228372335434, 0.008068913593888283, 0.00010520415526116267, -0.01645546779036522, -0.05572335049510002, 0.016926977783441544, -0.03375730663537979, -0.08974157273769379, 0.03166641667485237, 0.014050710014998913, 0.014376521110534668, 0.01609881781041622, -0.014153484255075455, 0.0014593403320759535, 0.011803572066128254, 0.05376772955060005, -0.034165482968091965, 0.011361542157828808, -0.03954799845814705, 0.03998735547065735, 0.09983432292938232, -0.0015551373362541199, -0.01133379153907299, 0.03119666501879692, 0.04668452590703964, 0.05890857055783272, -0.028972411528229713, 0.050191495567560196, 0.020408881828188896, 0.017883604392409325, 0.004921434912830591, 0.0004329229413997382, 0.05346060171723366 ]
88
88
Knowledge Technologies
Several technologies are emerging that provide new ways to capture, store, present and use knowledge. This book is the first to provide a comprehensive introduction to five of the most important of these technologies: Knowledge Engineering, Knowledge Based Engineering, Knowledge Webs, Ontologies and Semantic Webs. For each of these, answers are given to a number of key questions (What is it? How does it operate? How is a system developed? What can it be used for? What tools are available? What are the main issues?). The book is aimed at students, researchers and practitioners interested in Knowledge Management, Artificial Intelligence, Design Engineering and Web Technologies. During the 1990s, Nick worked at the University of Nottingham on the application of AI techniques to knowledge management and on various knowledge acquisition projects to develop expert systems for military applications. In 1999, he joined Epistemics where he worked on numerous knowledge projects and helped establish knowledge management programmes at large organisations in the engineering, technology and legal sectors. He is author of the book "Knowledge Acquisition in Practice", which describes a step-by-step procedure for acquiring and implementing expertise. He maintains strong links with leading research organisations working on knowledge technologies, such as knowledge-based engineering, ontologies and semantic technologies.
[ 0.00549371587112546, 0.005890586879104376, -0.0034463347401469946, -0.05667597055435181, 0.04854383319616318, -0.074134461581707, -0.019097931683063507, -0.04160008952021599, -0.004727383144199848, -0.04108123853802681, 0.0197253730148077, -0.020806001499295235, 0.0012313525658100843, 0.022037699818611145, 0.0019868796225637197, 0.026139363646507263, 0.051346346735954285, -0.01918008364737034, -0.02477966621518135, 0.0125912269577384, -0.022928284481167793, 0.024230685085058212, -0.09466659277677536, -0.03854387626051903, -0.07570352405309677, -0.041135746985673904, -0.035418082028627396, 0.0005226443172432482, -0.03211723640561104, 0.03427085280418396, -0.0695224478840828, 0.02266884036362171, 0.007686216849833727, 0.00027014303486794233, 0.03453650698065758, 0.04027457535266876, -0.052866287529468536, 0.018919097259640694, -0.0351184606552124, 0.04634981229901314, 0.07896686345338821, 0.03292209282517433, -0.03963857889175415, 0.030604617670178413, 0.0693291574716568, -0.004930662456899881, 0.02574997767806053, -0.0053726062178611755, -0.03171603009104729, -0.03810858726501465, -0.0805702731013298, 0.03445896878838539, 0.030221370980143547, 0.10008346289396286, -0.04380489140748978, 0.014253170229494572, 0.05151287093758583, -0.027762774378061295, 0.014777528122067451, 0.04030042141675949, -0.0004965597181580961, 0.0331629179418087, 0.0066101644188165665, -0.032867349684238434, -0.010228700935840607, 0.07801226526498795, -0.036648496985435486, -0.027601420879364014, -0.009254835546016693, 0.0012070635566487908, -0.034762490540742874, -0.02586452104151249, 0.09954482316970825, -0.052302952855825424, 0.08794332295656204, 0.06521723419427872, -0.04429393634200096, 0.015474113635718822, 0.03215062990784645, 0.09338035434484482, -0.009351378306746483, 0.030833106487989426, -0.017834261059761047, 0.02068803273141384, 0.03604942932724953, 0.03529495373368263, 0.05877889692783356, 0.01362144947052002, -0.0033355194609612226, 0.08153093606233597, 0.015303430147469044, -0.018264560028910637, -0.04202131927013397, 0.03874769061803818, -0.033616840839385986, 0.00042962373117916286, -0.03825603798031807, -0.032485928386449814, 0.0032694535329937935, -0.012459204532206059, -0.0313057042658329, -0.04544009268283844, 0.051532600075006485, -0.014906778931617737, -0.0039864531718194485, 0.05022426322102547, 0.0076834410429000854, 0.03413233160972595, 0.029906438663601875, 0.021479787304997444, 0.020573191344738007, 0.011898445896804333, 0.0006219793576747179, 0.045805688947439194, -0.03615622594952583, -0.08799325674772263, 0.04758129268884659, 0.09388826787471771, -0.01721600629389286, 0.00000736909805709729, 0.04339049756526947, 0.04291674494743347, -0.0387561209499836, -0.05019627884030342, 0.10897821933031082, -0.08087553083896637, -0.06248912587761879, 0.0008116306271404028, 0.050479646772146225, 0.0018918212736025453, -0.029129868373274803, -0.028854170814156532, -0.05559328570961952, 0.046243514865636826, -0.018799949437379837, -0.018310388550162315, 0.022356828674674034, -0.04525470733642578, 0.002092682756483555, 0.00943545252084732, 0.028526661917567253, -0.04146984964609146, -0.037214495241642, 0.023689422756433487, -0.009218565188348293, 0.013906233012676239, -0.071571484208107, -0.005691567435860634, 0.08434712141752243, -0.0811934843659401, -0.0368727371096611, 0.0032728423830121756, -0.0001901471259770915, 0.040636200457811356, -0.03689403086900711, -0.006152502726763487, -0.050773344933986664, -0.030930403620004654, 0.0004144621780142188, -0.0049098520539700985, 0.04771886765956879, 0.10154543817043304, -0.04959602653980255, 0.03123517893254757, 0.001913403277285397, -0.0635049119591713, -0.10689492523670197, -0.06859134882688522, 0.04748190566897392, -0.04878492280840874, 0.01825105957686901, 0.0493030920624733, 0.044379521161317825, 0.014070143923163414, 0.0004851093690376729, -0.03885364904999733, -0.025583570823073387, 0.002912376541644335, -0.03857753798365593, -0.07025785744190216, -0.02226436883211136, -0.06852497905492783, 0.0024273644667118788, 0.031688809394836426, -0.008303935639560223, 0.011331620626151562, 0.05852271988987923, 0.030748598277568817, 0.03258085623383522, 0.06567583978176117, -0.050095465034246445, -0.024906761944293976, 0.01793452724814415, -0.028817525133490562, -0.0050090909935534, 0.02084956504404545, 0.013467621989548206, 0.04358706623315811, 0.011354711838066578, 0.04658984765410423, -0.040467940270900726, -0.04304500296711922, -0.010114171542227268, 0.012201834470033646, -0.0657954066991806, -0.034698352217674255, 0.012256464920938015, -0.021399855613708496, -0.005269011948257685, 0.020936384797096252, 0.030552107840776443, -0.027903104200959206, -0.007120183669030666, 0.05634874477982521, 0.029455702751874924, -0.05782375484704971, -0.03753924369812012, -0.053587134927511215, 0.08108089864253998, 0.03257007524371147, -0.03671945631504059, 0.04924781247973442, -0.012811794877052307, 0.042607631534338, -0.0006474240799434483, -0.0777239203453064, 0.06238629296422005, -0.03759352117776871, 0.03520740568637848, 0.0298830047249794, -0.1706344336271286, -0.02393251843750477, -0.10099702328443527, -0.008593914099037647, 0.05140690878033638, -0.01321560051292181, 0.04407570883631706, 0.044868722558021545, -0.0660805031657219, 0.013482630252838135, 0.0477554053068161, 0.001399888307787478, 0.011586272157728672, 0.006695519667118788, 0.07804299890995026, -0.023921046406030655, -0.03054141253232956, 0.005301082041114569, -0.025937309488654137, 0.012706807814538479, -0.015531517565250397, 0.018304284662008286, -0.005007508210837841, 0.04328710585832596, 0.048228342086076736, 0.06012595072388649, -0.00358001422137022, -0.015697693452239037, 0.03342206031084061, 0.059018947184085846, -0.014506461098790169, -0.03448328748345375, -0.015541503205895424, -0.004914806690067053, 0.06144673377275467, 0.014957604929804802, -0.0634986013174057, 0.08608142286539078, -0.06943006813526154, -0.01935628242790699, 0.017422635108232498, -0.0038120283279567957, 0.023729387670755386, 0.05099736154079437, -0.09893479198217392, -0.009160151705145836, -0.05024917796254158, 0.037945251911878586, -0.023469703271985054, -0.031220730394124985, -0.09992368519306183, -0.05143106356263161, -0.028118539601564407, -0.010977225378155708, -0.06475041806697845, 0.023573605343699455, -0.02951984293758869, -0.02896817773580551, -0.01090632937848568, -0.038075994700193405, -0.024955427274107933, -0.013620365411043167, -0.053294144570827484, -0.03132731467485428, 0.0008297634776681662, -0.11819306761026382, 0.05476782098412514, -0.03153979778289795, -0.049007948487997055, 0.01738794706761837, 0.025395069271326065, 0.0005120912683196366, 0.01747603714466095, 0.07546693831682205, 0.012678933329880238, 0.03927265852689743, 0.007619448937475681, 0.11144859343767166, -0.0557829923927784, 0.02863858826458454, -0.009475918486714363, 0.0035945731215178967, 0.04190421476960182, 0.04960070922970772, -0.027415698394179344, 0.06697191298007965, -0.026493875309824944, -0.023048028349876404, 0.0029174762312322855, 0.05105001479387283, -0.00391353340819478, -0.039456453174352646, -0.016175320371985435, -0.06725192815065384, 0.003138359170407057, -0.010638093575835228, 0.006306109018623829, 0.010014035739004612, -0.0022626114077866077, -0.04432351887226105, -0.05020815134048462, 0.0072922599501907825, 0.06968846172094345, 0.05154423043131828, -0.020574459806084633, -0.006095193792134523, -0.011038552038371563, 0.03671226650476456, 0.0007817146251909435, 0.032385725528001785, -0.01724504865705967, 0.023690717294812202, 0.0306228119879961, 0.00010435740841785446, 0.0873575285077095, 0.03318073973059654, 0.024042386561632156, 0.002722512697800994, -0.042164016515016556, 0.004549572244286537, 0.037834715098142624, 0.03625800460577011, 0.00009752993355505168, 0.037048567086458206, -0.050847820937633514, 0.023396344855427742, 0.029274148866534233, 0.015011699870228767, -0.012462334707379341, -0.00515078566968441, 0.037756286561489105, -0.02796011045575142, -0.033969879150390625, -0.05983918160200119, 0.0050088390707969666, 0.038369398564100266, -0.018153637647628784, -0.02644924819469452, 0.056000933051109314, -0.1100556030869484, 0.05349592864513397, 0.027991678565740585, -0.020731525495648384, -0.0307109747081995, -0.053981613367795944, -0.07532817125320435, 0.0015296927886083722, 0.03969632089138031, 0.039165884256362915, 0.03671696037054062, -0.028191162273287773, -0.06222153455018997, -0.010662331245839596, 0.026258498430252075, -0.04879474639892578, -0.005464903078973293, 0.0014289871323853731, 0.015975315123796463, 0.10289496183395386, 0.07907366752624512, -0.03458976373076439, 0.06508135795593262, -0.020847395062446594, -0.04847652092576027, 0.011555545963346958, -0.02644481509923935, -0.05540275573730469, -0.019245263189077377, -0.0025611124001443386, 0.019523849710822105, -0.051526471972465515, -0.07756505906581879, -0.05443761870265007, -0.11858785897493362, -0.026456311345100403, 0.026437904685735703, -0.05527549609541893, 0.11912184208631516, -0.009618180803954601, 0.024938929826021194, -0.0040086000226438046, -0.03043237514793873, -0.01252614613622427, -0.07441852241754532, 0.07173501700162888, 0.05446022003889084, 0.051679253578186035, 0.02999943308532238, 0.02245870791375637, -0.1595439910888672, 0.0042104474268853664, 0.02020447887480259, 0.03512589633464813, -0.012335624545812607, 0.019817624241113663, 0.042374830693006516, 0.04704587906599045, -0.005558740813285112, -0.04976200312376022, -0.006590859964489937, 0.03315822407603264, -0.03182428330183029, -0.00919115636497736, -0.0014458918012678623, 0.04711642488837242, 0.02846716344356537, 0.017742538824677467, -0.027692699804902077, 0.03134151175618172, 0.004561025183647871, 0.012732532806694508, -0.0410926528275013, 0.08917289972305298, -0.03745189681649208, -0.039040952920913696, 0.020192261785268784, -0.047916073352098465, -0.0374789759516716, -0.0321771502494812, 0.009629019536077976, -0.02555708773434162, 0.03211421146988869, 0.0022805812768638134, -0.057664379477500916, -0.025832073763012886, 0.0048334188759326935, -0.07436393201351166, 0.013198130764067173, 0.07438361644744873, -0.07672616094350815, 0.044307515025138855, 0.09304776787757874, -0.01820039004087448, 0.004947624634951353, -0.026797736063599586, -0.016445400193333626, -0.007242697756737471, 0.0619988776743412, 0.048891741782426834, -0.08406643569469452, -0.060592591762542725, -0.052451811730861664, 0.012732496485114098, 0.022633420303463936, -0.050020694732666016, 0.03124825842678547, 0.0018389674369245768, 0.011096704751253128, -0.04536205902695656, -0.07370587438344955, -0.07122986763715744, 0.07690893858671188, -0.04027698561549187, 0.03396449238061905, -0.045606136322021484, 0.016569439321756363, 0.11770829558372498, 0.01940293423831463, 0.006329845171421766, -0.02521386370062828, 0.006982289254665375, -0.08398690819740295, 0.029868457466363907, -0.01795288361608982, -0.011511275544762611, 0.01657615602016449, 0.037928346544504166, -0.03164183720946312, 0.04058850184082985, -0.010398026555776596, 0.05801600590348244, -0.054142165929079056, -0.03399225324392319, 0.07062097638845444, 0.06685332953929901, -0.026702774688601494, 0.08371014893054962, 0.014096844010055065, -0.009911086410284042, -0.007511666975915432, -0.010132258757948875, -0.06273044645786285 ]
89
89
What Can We Learn Privately?
Learning problems form an important category of computational tasks that generalizes many of the computations researchers apply to large real-life data sets. We ask: what concept classes can be learned privately, namely, by an algorithm whose output does not depend too heavily on any one input or specific training example? More precisely, we investigate learning algorithms that satisfy differential privacy, a notion that provides strong confidentiality guarantees in contexts where aggregate information is released about a database containing sensitive information about individuals. We demonstrate that, ignoring computational constraints, it is possible to privately agnostically learn any concept class using a sample size approximately logarithmic in the cardinality of the concept class. Therefore, almost anything learnable is learnable privately: specifically, if a concept class is learnable by a (non-private) algorithm with polynomial sample complexity and output size, then it can be learned privately using a polynomial number of samples. We also present a computationally efficient private PAC learner for the class of parity functions. Local (or randomized response) algorithms are a practical class of private algorithms that have received extensive investigation. We provide a precise characterization of local private learning algorithms. We show that a concept class is learnable by a local algorithm if and only if it is learnable in the statistical query (SQ) model. Finally, we present a separation between the power of interactive and noninteractive local learning algorithms.
[ 0.0025869314558804035, 0.015734421089291573, 0.002486415905877948, 0.003223463660106063, -0.01586255617439747, -0.019179144874215126, -0.03654460608959198, -0.019394880160689354, -0.05053142458200455, 0.06294932216405869, 0.027192004024982452, -0.03463055565953255, -0.02592332847416401, 0.07785610109567642, -0.05670718103647232, -0.006280406843870878, -0.00938034150749445, 0.039803601801395416, 0.0347045473754406, -0.1176074668765068, 0.014021522365510464, 0.028977368026971817, 0.05319110304117203, -0.03366623446345329, 0.03568588197231293, -0.05572911351919174, 0.020129648968577385, 0.03820682689547539, 0.03195250779390335, -0.021658306941390038, -0.05366510525345802, -0.03660988807678223, -0.040156248956918716, 0.014157283119857311, -0.008663749322295189, -0.006739298813045025, 0.008318540640175343, -0.011224795132875443, 0.05227343365550041, 0.019975963979959488, -0.00018668758275453, -0.027893558144569397, 0.025001924484968185, 0.02149624563753605, 0.04753126576542854, -0.029702402651309967, 0.03174818307161331, 0.01115285325795412, 0.009182583540678024, 0.07376132160425186, -0.08075234293937683, -0.07842542976140976, 0.0035563872661441565, 0.004470527172088623, -0.012984370812773705, -0.05921394005417824, -0.024122783914208412, -0.031235022470355034, -0.034176453948020935, 0.018185773864388466, 0.020751100033521652, 0.045212190598249435, -0.004424635786563158, 0.007113353349268436, 0.021245207637548447, -0.026890072971582413, -0.042342208325862885, 0.007150921504944563, 0.0014266003854572773, -0.0609242208302021, 0.0738617479801178, -0.09051354229450226, 0.03900212049484253, 0.005750120151787996, -0.014580060727894306, 0.02301103062927723, 0.02283707819879055, -0.03112104907631874, 0.010962815955281258, 0.047018010169267654, -0.016462964937090874, 0.031216369941830635, 0.02522280439734459, 0.040290117263793945, -0.046018507331609726, -0.08980629593133926, 0.0761573389172554, -0.01710139773786068, -0.05023735761642456, -0.009457191452383995, -0.09186030179262161, 0.027211762964725494, -0.008837912231683731, 0.014112569391727448, 0.0034858558792620897, 0.08071412891149521, -0.04571688920259476, -0.05253949016332626, 0.04742972552776337, 0.03533057123422623, 0.05832616239786148, -0.045851487666368484, 0.05053042247891426, 0.059119995683431625, -0.020920077338814735, 0.056966982781887054, -0.004433510359376669, -0.013271819800138474, 0.03438883274793625, 0.02538011223077774, 0.021040819585323334, -0.016355007886886597, -0.034733548760414124, 0.0053522768430411816, -0.06920386105775833, 0.02294500730931759, -0.06669406592845917, 0.08049623668193817, 0.010129806585609913, -0.03635147586464882, 0.03150390833616257, 0.03236079588532448, -0.04840042442083359, -0.020517587661743164, 0.07088861614465714, -0.028826572000980377, -0.047231342643499374, -0.06625964492559433, 0.1318332999944687, -0.03540625423192978, -0.029430808499455452, -0.01779530569911003, -0.04309357702732086, -0.03784524276852608, 0.02149795927107334, 0.019462917000055313, -0.02235029824078083, -0.03720175102353096, -0.05312883481383324, -0.046404797583818436, -0.07196716219186783, -0.012531109154224396, -0.07367205619812012, -0.08090000599622726, 0.017107127234339714, 0.047457255423069, 0.019024953246116638, 0.04599617049098015, 0.04899350181221962, -0.009136069566011429, 0.027757858857512474, -0.03970590978860855, -0.007363876793533564, 0.029801640659570694, 0.08301213383674622, -0.030649734660983086, 0.039712436497211456, -0.03232277184724808, -0.018232734873890877, 0.11603715270757675, 0.01605844683945179, 0.012585170567035675, -0.004465886857360601, 0.057995930314064026, 0.012579536065459251, -0.012699475511908531, -0.04633098840713501, -0.018892506137490273, -0.0856260284781456, 0.02222427725791931, 0.0007844094652682543, -0.009959220886230469, -0.04685060307383537, -0.015849608927965164, 0.053500354290008545, -0.01659943349659443, 0.0071219466626644135, 0.03423820808529854, 0.011513091623783112, -0.03877680003643036, 0.019780684262514114, -0.003292129375040531, -0.015886519104242325, -0.0653468668460846, -0.03149162232875824, 0.06351615488529205, 0.07569825649261475, 0.07848914712667465, 0.1051853597164154, -0.036438070237636566, 0.012835408560931683, -0.0029532983899116516, 0.019827723503112793, 0.06062811240553856, -0.07415304332971573, 0.041639965027570724, -0.01210890430957079, -0.12167554348707199, -0.026041289791464806, 0.0006551331025548279, 0.05140265077352524, -0.011739710345864296, 0.0013313788222149014, -0.035845428705215454, -0.07210758328437805, 0.03414696455001831, -0.011978608556091785, -0.013961012475192547, -0.02201307937502861, 0.05491424351930618, 0.030064014717936516, 0.06784390658140182, -0.024045711383223534, -0.01513186376541853, -0.0024616310838609934, -0.10031132400035858, -0.04234376177191734, -0.024713240563869476, -0.00694317789748311, 0.01563880406320095, -0.01715557835996151, 0.021143214777112007, 0.03129043057560921, 0.012821558862924576, 0.017404675483703613, 0.026855507865548134, 0.08981429785490036, 0.008635096251964569, -0.039454683661460876, 0.011264410801231861, -0.0950096845626831, -0.035324305295944214, -0.06739344447851181, 0.03969167545437813, 0.029658621177077293, 0.03595125302672386, -0.05359362065792084, -0.031097333878278732, -0.025937799364328384, 0.05328214168548584, -0.008998841047286987, 0.0752858966588974, -0.002875635400414467, -0.020023256540298462, 0.06320780515670776, -0.0051883733831346035, 0.02058209851384163, 0.039945218712091446, -0.05875028297305107, 0.02092069946229458, 0.052106790244579315, 0.01791970245540142, -0.06165001541376114, -0.012584258802235126, 0.08773133158683777, -0.012774861417710781, -0.048952724784612656, 0.027833983302116394, 0.03843820467591286, 0.03246258944272995, -0.019172681495547295, 0.02474145218729973, 0.009371480904519558, 0.011807258240878582, 0.07898326218128204, 0.030695553869009018, -0.016814449802041054, -0.0013935969909653068, -0.00865792017430067, -0.00021982064936310053, 0.05334632098674774, -0.07131203263998032, -0.027373790740966797, 0.12096839398145676, -0.1145222932100296, 0.030108269304037094, 0.03292202576994896, 0.03105977550148964, -0.0018810423789545894, -0.0135068129748106, -0.0549636073410511, -0.018798457458615303, -0.049766287207603455, 0.04048048332333565, -0.06183819845318794, 0.08412527292966843, -0.00015912269009277225, -0.009251991286873817, 0.032468680292367935, 0.03180214762687683, -0.06725005060434341, -0.007562617305666208, -0.07784382253885269, -0.011767785996198654, 0.027273762971162796, -0.06044421344995499, 0.010935268364846706, -0.01446730736643076, 0.028921162709593773, -0.04292670637369156, -0.01860525831580162, 0.0003759031242225319, 0.014617737382650375, 0.06466589868068695, 0.05267621949315071, 0.008330593816936016, 0.05958535522222519, 0.03763628751039505, -0.08975152671337128, 0.014907809905707836, 0.0442604161798954, 0.05541788414120674, -0.01934158243238926, -0.006857222877442837, -0.008424277417361736, -0.030038755387067795, 0.08086112886667252, 0.06503911316394806, 0.02201808989048004, -0.05649387463927269, 0.01495947502553463, -0.024954913184046745, 0.027806110680103302, -0.021323267370462418, -0.1042638048529625, -0.017020968720316887, 0.00690124649554491, -0.04285373166203499, -0.0720282644033432, 0.058755192905664444, -0.05679740756750107, -0.01192620862275362, 0.03409704193472862, -0.022675026208162308, -0.05427470803260803, 0.04573356360197067, -0.02350650355219841, 0.023355521261692047, -0.01356244646012783, 0.04090148210525513, -0.06377145648002625, -0.08194877207279205, 0.006797140929847956, -0.010877968743443489, -0.0047648074105381966, 0.02865700051188469, 0.08158152550458908, -0.008389958180487156, 0.012469744309782982, 0.015714969485998154, -0.03720739111304283, 0.038407642394304276, -0.012655578553676605, 0.018019115552306175, -0.030863706022500992, 0.07579859346151352, -0.012198101729154587, -0.02201549895107746, 0.024707963690161705, 0.042298443615436554, 0.07321087270975113, 0.04238433390855789, -0.05437444895505905, -0.018626444041728973, -0.03581475093960762, 0.04064955189824104, -0.01626002974808216, -0.009601525031030178, -0.052371758967638016, -0.04407396912574768, 0.018363602459430695, -0.05422363057732582, 0.04528794065117836, 0.018511049449443817, -0.000748491904232651, -0.021154185757040977, 0.009426009841263294, -0.05383512005209923, 0.04810292273759842, 0.08933793008327484, -0.057336773723363876, 0.00388621655292809, 0.008792189881205559, 0.01724107563495636, 0.00014181491860654205, 0.005240897182375193, -0.002707204082980752, 0.026485200971364975, 0.09130781143903732, 0.0561145544052124, -0.07304704934358597, -0.06675361841917038, -0.03743521869182587, -0.030205490067601204, 0.05719040334224701, 0.026403721421957016, -0.011343956924974918, 0.03600931540131569, -0.016729913651943207, 0.00016769029025454074, -0.029905928298830986, -0.005984846502542496, 0.07264216989278793, -0.037167735397815704, -0.10067471116781235, 0.021536914631724358, 0.04440087080001831, 0.0687907263636589, -0.03559044003486633, 0.0340217724442482, 0.00801603589206934, 0.04001432657241821, -0.05203208699822426, -0.041641440242528915, -0.0031064266804605722, 0.03984813392162323, -0.0006111763650551438, -0.06513985991477966, 0.0042590671218931675, 0.002186479978263378, -0.003093061037361622, 0.0066375392489135265, 0.046717319637537, -0.06924934685230255, 0.04256221652030945, -0.024824846535921097, 0.000273364334134385, 0.06908796727657318, -0.006958019454032183, -0.028412118554115295, -0.04953370243310928, 0.0075776707381010056, -0.008973260410130024, -0.027202583849430084, -0.008308833464980125, -0.04378221556544304, 0.02594330720603466, -0.03843846172094345, 0.006925361230969429, 0.03028634376823902, -0.10344227403402328, 0.031384434551000595, 0.02352198399603367, 0.030284851789474487, 0.08875980228185654, 0.014929925091564655, 0.006998894270509481, -0.01001746952533722, 0.10749682039022446, 0.08714143186807632, 0.07394777983427048, -0.008632214739918709, 0.030752720311284065, -0.03756139427423477, -0.023543620482087135, -0.015474304556846619, 0.024858100339770317, -0.015479755587875843, 0.09553005546331406, 0.006303397938609123, -0.0737469345331192, 0.013887539505958557, 0.025937240570783615, 0.03863786533474922, -0.033397428691387177, -0.007614823989570141, 0.03429216891527176, 0.04275813698768616, 0.03923725336790085, 0.012201919220387936, -0.00002371910886722617, 0.0009329039603471756, -0.03665035963058472, -0.12092890590429306, -0.04330195486545563, 0.013026654720306396, 0.09613201767206192, -0.05212448164820671, 0.038517698645591736, -0.03896544873714447, -0.02382555976510048, 0.03716057911515236, -0.05287085473537445, 0.04185398668050766, 0.06399410963058472, -0.0052126385271549225, -0.05979308858513832, 0.027353152632713318, 0.017473610118031502, 0.03068075142800808, 0.01812688633799553, -0.07646240293979645, 0.05787189304828644, 0.03174671158194542, -0.016206488013267517, 0.027001522481441498, 0.04354460537433624, 0.0012843534350395203, 0.037957362830638885, 0.02921394631266594, 0.025336790829896927, 0.004541248083114624, 0.013144331984221935, 0.0267140232026577, 0.07163095474243164, 0.03899398073554039, 0.04901930317282677, -0.028006568551063538, -0.049920666962862015, 0.06858007609844208, -0.030442524701356888, 0.11704637110233307 ]
90
90
Privacy Preserving ID3 over Horizontally, Vertically and Grid Partitioned Data
We consider privacy preserving decision tree induction via ID3 in the case where the training data is horizontally or vertically distributed. Furthermore, we consider the same problem in the case where the data is both horizontally and vertically distributed, a situation we refer to as grid partitioned data. We give an algorithm for privacy preserving ID3 over horizontally partitioned data involving more than two parties. For grid partitioned data, we discuss two different evaluation methods for preserving privacy ID3, namely, first merging horizontally and developing vertically or first merging vertically and next developing horizontally. Next to introducing privacy preserving data mining over grid-partitioned data, the main contribution of this paper is that we show, by means of a complexity analysis that the former evaluation method is the more efficient.
[ -0.014140415005385876, 0.024365879595279694, 0.02075956016778946, -0.008876131847500801, -0.06050114706158638, -0.023859690874814987, -0.0008596453699283302, -0.014062234200537205, -0.041851580142974854, 0.013338962569832802, -0.08067180961370468, -0.08768892288208008, -0.0261817816644907, -0.0005870002787560225, 0.0012992514530196786, 0.04065549746155739, -0.014960954897105694, 0.07815147936344147, -0.005461565218865871, -0.061123669147491455, 0.05046643689274788, -0.0000564842157473322, 0.02175811305642128, -0.029338054358959198, -0.03245639055967331, 0.008720316924154758, -0.0003368584730196744, -0.014988873153924942, -0.0492364801466465, 0.0012279560323804617, -0.027561107650399208, -0.007626603823155165, -0.0005229159141890705, 0.006658889818936586, -0.02424975112080574, -0.06748746335506439, 0.013644492253661156, -0.040191035717725754, 0.01063850149512291, 0.02482931688427925, -0.023719146847724915, 0.014119566418230534, -0.007948451675474644, -0.000019230694306315854, -0.00482891546562314, -0.0002725454105529934, -0.004358959384262562, 0.04731583967804909, 0.08019957691431046, 0.09671106934547424, -0.10019506514072418, 0.007837383076548576, -0.06115398928523064, 0.01799280196428299, -0.022771844640374184, 0.013545548543334007, -0.039911139756441116, 0.02855648659169674, 0.11771660298109055, -0.056756965816020966, 0.06098105385899544, 0.047655850648880005, -0.020234523341059685, 0.00043324995203875005, -0.050845254212617874, -0.02201501466333866, -0.0314764566719532, -0.03799082711338997, -0.042100630700588226, -0.05050453916192055, 0.0572391152381897, -0.059781208634376526, 0.006481362972408533, 0.03445569425821304, -0.007205976638942957, 0.0020562205463647842, 0.060692574828863144, -0.012047101743519306, -0.0019111930159851909, 0.07696390151977539, -0.047449741512537, 0.04534418135881424, 0.03770330175757408, -0.026030996814370155, -0.03302447870373726, -0.038122862577438354, 0.05453777313232422, -0.03650915250182152, 0.030201612040400505, -0.01219004113227129, 0.02549564093351364, 0.03832416608929634, -0.110565684735775, 0.07019893825054169, -0.010453304275870323, -0.030568784102797508, -0.11972106993198395, -0.018093358725309372, 0.03694465011358261, 0.044787049293518066, 0.0057021924294531345, -0.038671430200338364, -0.002561817644163966, 0.03021608665585518, 0.029893139377236366, 0.0610395111143589, -0.02636934630572796, 0.10526477545499802, 0.02838745526969433, -0.09314598888158798, -0.008961322717368603, -0.031136509031057358, -0.03228982165455818, 0.02398870885372162, -0.04242010414600372, 0.0783492773771286, -0.0477948933839798, 0.06164442002773285, -0.11719860881567001, -0.005540802143514156, 0.008125456050038338, 0.042112961411476135, -0.017785094678401947, -0.05542219430208206, 0.005989813711494207, -0.05216696113348007, -0.011947057209908962, -0.04668991267681122, 0.01528867520391941, 0.026711637154221535, -0.052717044949531555, 0.09694892913103104, -0.07011929899454117, 0.005976991727948189, -0.01750904694199562, 0.03209441155195236, 0.03869025409221649, 0.013726110570132732, -0.026731310412287712, 0.04868883267045021, -0.016945432871580124, -0.017957940697669983, -0.0072997803799808025, -0.027365969493985176, 0.04163825884461403, 0.07880700379610062, 0.0037596365436911583, 0.05246692895889282, 0.027683712542057037, 0.011413765139877796, 0.11147291213274002, -0.06473758816719055, 0.028187107294797897, 0.07303711026906967, 0.005010250490158796, -0.061017684638500214, -0.010087192989885807, -0.012928655371069908, 0.03563138470053673, 0.04309267923235893, -0.018913067877292633, 0.04994293674826622, 0.027010677382349968, 0.027214860543608665, 0.0161913875490427, 0.002138599520549178, -0.037183500826358795, 0.01607031561434269, -0.05499684438109398, -0.047330860048532486, -0.020998705178499222, -0.06126249581575394, -0.022372521460056305, -0.022616392001509666, 0.07180094718933105, -0.03336775302886963, -0.05274694040417671, -0.0034089083783328533, 0.023394569754600525, 0.06498870998620987, 0.055352672934532166, 0.01930508203804493, -0.008108415640890598, -0.016538945958018303, 0.041794318705797195, 0.06531831622123718, 0.005622622091323137, 0.07312969118356705, 0.10170704871416092, 0.0018585302168503404, 0.007370954845100641, -0.0489678680896759, 0.014049760065972805, 0.03958122059702873, -0.041186243295669556, 0.06202113255858421, -0.07740692794322968, -0.06360171735286713, -0.033087488263845444, 0.0326690711081028, 0.021092627197504044, 0.009094059467315674, -0.01470528170466423, -0.007712163031101227, -0.0012258854694664478, 0.02524971216917038, 0.05972839519381523, -0.03318757563829422, 0.02724786475300789, 0.0016637078952044249, 0.03513443097472191, -0.014477892778813839, -0.09686924517154694, -0.016300275921821594, 0.006314052268862724, -0.014750858768820763, -0.10720065236091614, -0.06929704546928406, 0.03511315584182739, 0.06903315335512161, -0.04357658699154854, -0.023467253893613815, -0.060604676604270935, 0.08523924648761749, -0.04349002614617348, 0.021798476576805115, 0.12559756636619568, -0.016140075400471687, -0.039734166115522385, 0.013136658817529678, 0.013481132686138153, -0.04107312485575676, -0.03337262198328972, -0.01399147603660822, -0.008724594488739967, 0.07212398201227188, -0.009544029831886292, -0.03145160898566246, 0.018519967794418335, 0.02586468867957592, -0.008624101057648659, 0.016264349222183228, -0.06018921732902527, 0.032757870852947235, 0.01166258379817009, -0.007789947092533112, -0.004449531901627779, 0.05876621976494789, -0.00908693764358759, 0.041595157235860825, -0.046811699867248535, -0.017711862921714783, -0.015118848532438278, 0.034882478415966034, -0.01802532561123371, -0.06086619570851326, -0.04207952320575714, 0.047544222325086594, 0.09809742122888565, 0.08142660558223724, 0.04901690036058426, -0.030279085040092468, 0.0057095871306955814, 0.004668155685067177, 0.09596992284059525, 0.06865828484296799, 0.06985902041196823, -0.03448813408613205, -0.029783252626657486, 0.03456103056669235, -0.01786852814257145, -0.06895803660154343, -0.02765064500272274, 0.09097550809383392, -0.031732503324747086, 0.02094493992626667, 0.039378583431243896, 0.07984631508588791, 0.062958724796772, -0.061727482825517654, -0.04954219609498978, 0.024578412994742393, 0.027579957619309425, -0.039885014295578, 0.025989428162574768, 0.030906587839126587, -0.015049160458147526, -0.03699193149805069, 0.025738760828971863, 0.10987518727779388, -0.08212248980998993, -0.0063089667819440365, -0.009678917936980724, -0.027981434017419815, 0.0016395595157518983, -0.06303277611732483, 0.034398239105939865, 0.03233950585126877, 0.014202137477695942, -0.06881570816040039, 0.047736141830682755, 0.02816738560795784, 0.10910620540380478, 0.012912197038531303, 0.014933431521058083, 0.05157610401511192, 0.036415889859199524, 0.024362720549106598, -0.0448412224650383, -0.04793695732951164, 0.040375467389822006, 0.05764200910925865, -0.036552704870700836, -0.038136087357997894, -0.05602305755019188, -0.007152805104851723, 0.01585770584642887, -0.008111830800771713, -0.011710984632372856, -0.004207437392324209, -0.08206641674041748, -0.006665414199233055, -0.010138050653040409, -0.017068812623620033, -0.03491883724927902, -0.011705411598086357, -0.034824177622795105, 0.046433866024017334, -0.04052247107028961, 0.018713584169745445, -0.0879058837890625, -0.005801251623779535, -0.0011830447474494576, 0.06708770990371704, -0.049230191856622696, -0.03452356904745102, -0.018433215096592903, 0.0021162808407098055, -0.05970918759703636, 0.07939687371253967, -0.06776801496744156, -0.08372340351343155, 0.10305614769458771, -0.04394727572798729, -0.013928806409239769, 0.08380265533924103, 0.07190961390733719, 0.002150315325707197, 0.09693785756826401, 0.051364436745643616, -0.05228083208203316, 0.0009151478298008442, 0.007630355190485716, -0.025083763524889946, 0.010440315119922161, 0.05036512017250061, 0.05658698454499245, -0.021334074437618256, -0.004637337755411863, 0.07575760781764984, -0.012792838737368584, 0.0211622416973114, -0.0050992281176149845, 0.00303231505677104, 0.009748302400112152, 0.004130493849515915, -0.05679714307188988, 0.004541050177067518, -0.015137340873479843, -0.01185770146548748, -0.034039080142974854, 0.0002068906178465113, 0.029410777613520622, 0.05077564716339111, 0.045888692140579224, -0.0073525928892195225, -0.000721674645319581, -0.05690613389015198, -0.014238115400075912, 0.08925765007734299, -0.043051909655332565, 0.021100642159581184, 0.03422187641263008, 0.006036474835127592, 0.05686861276626587, -0.002395078307017684, 0.038919247686862946, 0.010935244150459766, 0.07911950349807739, 0.01749826781451702, -0.020587528124451637, -0.04778984561562538, 0.012275693006813526, -0.06901068240404129, 0.05555209890007973, -0.005725433584302664, 0.004248538985848427, 0.0021097236312925816, 0.017486147582530975, -0.041864458471536636, -0.0003264457918703556, -0.026234714314341545, 0.003973869606852531, -0.06899145990610123, 0.014841764234006405, 0.027234919369220734, 0.005326331127434969, 0.09504780173301697, 0.010962543077766895, -0.011833440512418747, 0.06798598915338516, 0.017854593694210052, 0.004002846777439117, 0.02169441431760788, -0.02462811768054962, 0.00598195381462574, -0.03273456543684006, 0.013971155509352684, -0.002317822305485606, 0.03406532108783722, 0.027675731107592583, -0.018616847693920135, 0.024840261787176132, -0.047271277755498886, 0.00700940378010273, -0.019389180466532707, 0.03620775789022446, 0.03927295655012131, -0.01106374803930521, 0.02393258735537529, -0.10535631328821182, -0.022180702537298203, 0.04188278689980507, -0.0025631447788327932, 0.09512786567211151, 0.02939278446137905, 0.008322583511471748, -0.00937771238386631, 0.02494587004184723, -0.008588447235524654, -0.033633701503276825, 0.06860295683145523, 0.01032148115336895, 0.04168105497956276, -0.051825862377882004, 0.07416883856058121, -0.007356145419180393, 0.009120527654886246, 0.019485004246234894, -0.002447302918881178, -0.018951188772916794, -0.017408300191164017, 0.04530828073620796, 0.02639096975326538, 0.025398267433047295, -0.0321781188249588, 0.020543653517961502, -0.007624030113220215, 0.015321129932999611, -0.11064209043979645, -0.004901435226202011, -0.046337999403476715, -0.03869050368666649, -0.00550180533900857, -0.011154755018651485, -0.04713528975844383, 0.037734195590019226, 0.020786678418517113, 0.06569074839353561, 0.02323562279343605, -0.08274037390947342, 0.010135751217603683, -0.013917358592152596, -0.0523676760494709, -0.022716501727700233, -0.009964261204004288, -0.023098258301615715, -0.002237174892798066, -0.04816469922661781, -0.010937481187283993, -0.021622832864522934, -0.05520384758710861, -0.03570321202278137, 0.02217983826994896, 0.04048531502485275, 0.004599283449351788, -0.0034805117174983025, -0.014295498840510845, 0.0533900260925293, -0.0666089877486229, -0.03312600031495094, -0.03678565472364426, 0.01835004985332489, 0.029536204412579536, 0.030373120680451393, 0.04702790454030037, 0.07011277973651886, 0.03810957074165344, 0.027789734303951263, 0.04971172660589218, 0.03891418129205704, -0.009744111448526382, 0.05857343599200249, -0.009429656900465488, 0.06927743554115295, 0.06641453504562378, 0.08888065069913864, -0.07403931766748428, 0.0643589049577713, 0.05906655266880989, -0.004508146084845066, -0.04247879236936569 ]
91
91
Figuring out Actors in Text Streams: Using Collocations to establish Incremental Mind-maps
The recognition, involvement, and description of main actors influences the story line of the whole text. This is of higher importance as the text per se represents a flow of words and expressions that once it is read it is lost. In this respect, the understanding of a text and moreover on how the actor exactly behaves is not only a major concern: as human beings try to store a given input on short-term memory while associating diverse aspects and actors with incidents, the following approach represents a virtual architecture, where collocations are concerned and taken as the associative completion of the actors' acting. Once that collocations are discovered, they become managed in separated memory blocks broken down by the actors. As for human beings, the memory blocks refer to associative mind-maps. We then present several priority functions to represent the actual temporal situation inside a mind-map to enable the user to reconstruct the recent events from the discovered temporal results.
[ 0.024535274133086205, 0.04925096780061722, 0.05570764094591141, 0.024469276890158653, 0.02227461338043213, -0.051755886524915695, -0.07981202751398087, -0.041752271354198456, 0.01821630634367466, 0.010619303211569786, 0.02630670554935932, 0.057515859603881836, -0.04529974237084389, 0.041425563395023346, -0.026725701987743378, 0.00939355231821537, -0.03192409500479698, 0.0061820806004107, -0.04174669831991196, -0.04500395432114601, 0.025354769080877304, 0.030292857438325882, -0.003517292207106948, 0.016266431659460068, -0.026602033525705338, -0.020077520981431007, -0.02651139721274376, 0.008252480067312717, 0.03511614352464676, 0.03954844921827316, -0.05660437047481537, -0.007266712374985218, 0.0025098028127104044, 0.05767318233847618, 0.023755719885230064, 0.02314690314233303, 0.03683597594499588, -0.07003281265497208, -0.1014365702867508, -0.022014427930116653, -0.0459219329059124, -0.010134803131222725, -0.07333274930715561, -0.013368306681513786, -0.03707960993051529, -0.007209927309304476, -0.024219440296292305, -0.017515655606985092, 0.07204150408506393, -0.0018738012295216322, -0.024435970932245255, -0.038809847086668015, 0.026461245492100716, 0.03804956376552582, -0.0838434025645256, 0.02164428122341633, -0.01705644279718399, -0.010734188370406628, 0.030599284917116165, 0.009072362445294857, 0.06361795216798782, 0.054152712225914, -0.02664220705628395, 0.029565325006842613, -0.040751632302999496, 0.058869268745183945, 0.01958398148417473, -0.005936674308031797, 0.01761881448328495, -0.03841361775994301, -0.07110627740621567, 0.049940429627895355, 0.042275361716747284, -0.05958150699734688, -0.009073328226804733, 0.032399892807006836, -0.0413130559027195, -0.024777229875326157, 0.019045401364564896, 0.11573907732963562, -0.02972099930047989, 0.08726788312196732, -0.012630295939743519, -0.03237522020936012, -0.04033965989947319, 0.02041495591402054, 0.014673243276774883, -0.017962466925382614, -0.00509544275701046, 0.007452107034623623, -0.02671889401972294, -0.06539767235517502, -0.026187479496002197, 0.05357944965362549, -0.02810445800423622, 0.01395947765558958, 0.016290558502078056, 0.028688890859484673, 0.021803226321935654, 0.05891110748052597, 0.008423811756074429, -0.059716254472732544, 0.0036776589695364237, 0.015952736139297485, -0.0624387264251709, -0.022925496101379395, 0.002810576232150197, 0.029602358117699623, 0.09311805665493011, 0.011317595839500427, 0.016052816063165665, -0.009460175409913063, -0.008851492777466774, 0.051635824143886566, -0.06148174777626991, 0.06558376550674438, -0.030709251761436462, 0.07051338255405426, -0.031031347811222076, 0.02483752742409706, 0.003426577430218458, 0.03315267711877823, 0.025723474100232124, -0.014125616289675236, -0.0022247617598623037, -0.024266816675662994, -0.00733843632042408, -0.0020569360349327326, 0.026747653260827065, -0.02005840465426445, -0.01730743609368801, -0.022600997239351273, -0.02623472362756729, -0.02897774986922741, -0.007491744589060545, 0.013566157780587673, -0.016825513914227486, -0.13029317557811737, -0.10218773782253265, 0.005991082172840834, 0.05452347919344902, 0.04293888434767723, 0.018268346786499023, 0.04776675999164581, 0.04779629781842232, 0.09184452891349792, -0.022939102724194527, -0.024698475375771523, 0.04257355257868767, -0.0890667587518692, 0.05613933131098747, -0.05066706985235214, 0.010466891340911388, -0.011201715096831322, 0.02797035127878189, 0.02280443161725998, -0.007868247106671333, -0.07438454777002335, 0.032949190586805344, -0.036245569586753845, -0.029270965605974197, -0.052767179906368256, -0.010975095443427563, 0.08972718566656113, 0.014780472964048386, 0.00013619328092318028, -0.06613434851169586, -0.013639939948916435, -0.09600944072008133, 0.01107326801866293, 0.018022816628217697, 0.006395503878593445, 0.034258972853422165, 0.063294418156147, -0.032292768359184265, -0.040900785475969315, -0.041064128279685974, -0.005004862789064646, -0.06296813488006592, -0.04974353685975075, -0.026203326880931854, -0.07547307014465332, 0.02580379508435726, -0.03672971576452255, 0.05739615112543106, 0.05961040034890175, -0.04396801069378853, 0.06413501501083374, 0.09658944606781006, -0.056393325328826904, 0.03161880001425743, 0.007946861907839775, -0.007676730398088694, 0.015110570006072521, -0.015757163986563683, -0.02765599638223648, 0.03235510364174843, 0.07306777685880661, 0.03601590916514397, -0.021911075338721275, 0.017750151455402374, -0.00018270904547534883, -0.001973335165530443, -0.0034874139819294214, 0.0370265394449234, -0.04449004679918289, -0.02156645432114601, -0.025113927200436592, -0.008829270489513874, -0.017567144706845284, 0.04955767095088959, -0.018471509218215942, -0.03238365799188614, 0.07444925606250763, 0.04510146379470825, -0.05307864025235176, 0.04256414622068405, -0.041378047317266464, 0.023554909974336624, 0.07867038995027542, -0.07341358065605164, 0.03052208013832569, 0.013374272733926773, 0.05265478417277336, -0.016209350898861885, -0.09828565269708633, 0.027596335858106613, -0.03275303170084953, -0.008357850834727287, 0.00362495263107121, -0.038051243871450424, -0.024255335330963135, -0.07452746480703354, -0.017627833411097527, 0.0623527355492115, 0.04024115949869156, 0.028944671154022217, 0.006495668087154627, -0.010202665813267231, -0.007941591553390026, -0.08541086316108704, 0.005272315815091133, 0.010574479587376118, 0.037272859364748, 0.0062467302195727825, -0.0011092995991930366, 0.003375245491042733, -0.014778459444642067, -0.06894133985042572, -0.028825052082538605, 0.0056531126610934734, -0.01735425926744938, -0.017077157273888588, 0.1361793726682663, 0.09919162094593048, 0.03195616602897644, -0.06666048616170883, 0.022900737822055817, 0.06021931394934654, 0.05616789683699608, -0.05444227531552315, -0.014168045483529568, -0.024543892592191696, 0.050505898892879486, 0.02189638465642929, 0.05513930320739746, -0.02619129791855812, 0.02869502827525139, 0.011743954382836819, -0.031166568398475647, 0.05632316693663597, 0.005762244574725628, -0.020236274227499962, 0.032221727073192596, 0.012276383116841316, -0.01255381666123867, -0.03539913892745972, -0.06703457236289978, -0.049602821469306946, -0.027974093332886696, 0.02298942394554615, -0.03118658997118473, 0.0007529397844336927, -0.03234635666012764, -0.09747173637151718, 0.06333877146244049, 0.10316610336303711, 0.06163894385099411, 0.033793896436691284, 0.06837420910596848, -0.06366587430238724, -0.03642261400818825, -0.034216322004795074, 0.025003934279084206, 0.02031615376472473, -0.1090560257434845, -0.03200496733188629, 0.004170466214418411, 0.031570229679346085, -0.03928755968809128, -0.036688387393951416, 0.070919468998909, 0.09011421352624893, 0.026501324027776718, 0.008706005290150642, 0.029937375336885452, 0.06536649167537689, 0.041757214814424515, 0.02126844972372055, 0.05373255908489227, -0.07097109407186508, 0.004364930093288422, -0.028653915971517563, 0.035605717450380325, -0.03616730123758316, -0.012032275088131428, 0.0256179329007864, -0.07132504880428314, 0.003499492770060897, 0.007656930014491081, 0.011492057703435421, -0.024274509400129318, -0.07442203909158707, -0.052300892770290375, -0.01690397784113884, 0.0034307034220546484, 0.007814980112016201, -0.0309190321713686, 0.028505535796284676, 0.004818829242140055, -0.03349577262997627, 0.015295582823455334, 0.02917550504207611, 0.032335828989744186, 0.0202987939119339, 0.004779947455972433, 0.06477652490139008, 0.018899865448474884, -0.00805425364524126, 0.06758768856525421, -0.06667071580886841, -0.0337500125169754, 0.03374688699841499, -0.02004231885075569, -0.0029306896030902863, 0.020581673830747604, 0.10413859039545059, 0.07597343623638153, 0.024598518386483192, -0.06011698395013809, 0.015240772627294064, 0.026181332767009735, -0.10163430869579315, -0.008818479254841805, 0.02553638443350792, 0.10119491070508957, 0.007633064407855272, 0.05970963090658188, -0.008898166008293629, -0.033921897411346436, 0.019641296938061714, 0.010638836771249771, 0.023441927507519722, -0.04029669612646103, -0.0019421883625909686, 0.03133996203541756, 0.022325869649648666, -0.008634379133582115, -0.024986501783132553, -0.009008911438286304, 0.05797048658132553, -0.0017420344520360231, 0.0069281370379030704, -0.06275536119937897, 0.0479748360812664, -0.018794825300574303, 0.03168141469359398, -0.08432254940271378, 0.026650380343198776, 0.06644510477781296, 0.01904674433171749, -0.041385285556316376, -0.08265353739261627, 0.006103483960032463, -0.0881502777338028, -0.014363170601427555, 0.007145139388740063, -0.044070515781641006, 0.009116793051362038, -0.035662099719047546, -0.11894823610782623, -0.0056017981842160225, 0.03467865288257599, 0.0426340214908123, 0.029882829636335373, -0.06249150633811951, 0.04471390321850777, -0.06643255800008774, -0.11131805926561356, 0.005436345003545284, 0.06894101947546005, -0.029804503545165062, 0.008729636669158936, 0.011662916280329227, -0.005329005885869265, 0.03187013790011406, 0.04924667999148369, 0.0983288362622261, 0.02139413170516491, 0.029682805761694908, 0.0866369903087616, -0.007132981438189745, 0.02959330379962921, 0.016017280519008636, -0.017714178189635277, 0.08061183989048004, 0.0402776338160038, -0.014751327224075794, 0.02019050531089306, 0.030401058495044708, -0.03200611472129822, -0.016139786690473557, 0.0502932146191597, 0.015023448504507542, -0.06461196392774582, -0.015937769785523415, 0.12037535011768341, -0.02446475438773632, 0.08237940818071365, -0.04022122919559479, 0.040881961584091187, -0.014612329192459583, 0.0112654073163867, 0.0134989432990551, -0.0015954137779772282, 0.04966810718178749, 0.03532632440328598, -0.037574462592601776, 0.0022803815081715584, 0.01207537017762661, 0.03308987617492676, -0.004492735490202904, 0.0782177746295929, -0.01643676869571209, 0.007250218186527491, -0.036906931549310684, -0.009619548916816711, -0.019879229366779327, 0.04954845458269119, -0.08045587688684464, -0.03914135321974754, -0.006911898031830788, 0.08482227474451065, 0.014344102703034878, -0.0906076580286026, -0.019023926928639412, 0.006628395523875952, 0.018476221710443497, -0.0037447232753038406, -0.05561990663409233, 0.04521886631846428, 0.03995535150170326, 0.0054044476710259914, 0.0855061337351799, -0.034018270671367645, -0.04832654818892479, 0.015381758101284504, -0.030314937233924866, 0.03448772057890892, 0.019570544362068176, -0.08793117105960846, -0.011826924048364162, 0.05978245288133621, 0.021412471309304237, -0.012673980556428432, -0.009342812933027744, 0.06998717784881592, -0.03277696669101715, -0.006914201192557812, -0.06228027120232582, 0.07526381313800812, 0.03862199932336807, 0.015473622828722, 0.021114813163876534, 0.04022572934627533, 0.020769178867340088, -0.020976167172193527, -0.03427177667617798, 0.059947796165943146, 0.039315808564424515, -0.04693994298577309, -0.08255599439144135, 0.006893784739077091, -0.0066018737852573395, -0.025794794782996178, -0.016913583502173424, -0.05063540115952492, 0.01923898421227932, -0.0016504472587257624, 0.05020797625184059, 0.03641078993678093, 0.0144905224442482, 0.004466218873858452, 0.060636118054389954, 0.034008484333753586, 0.042825959622859955, 0.08999219536781311, 0.012254483997821808, 0.02762104570865631, -0.04283200949430466, -0.08322204649448395, 0.048964109271764755 ]
92
92
Robustness and Regularization of Support Vector Machines
We consider regularized support vector machines (SVMs) and show that they are precisely equivalent to a new robust optimization formulation. We show that this equivalence of robust optimization and regularization has implications for both algorithms, and analysis. In terms of algorithms, the equivalence suggests more general SVM-like algorithms for classification that explicitly build in protection to noise, and at the same time control overfitting. On the analysis front, the equivalence of robustness and regularization, provides a robust optimization interpretation for the success of regularized SVMs. We use the this new robustness interpretation of SVMs to give a new proof of consistency of (kernelized) SVMs, thus establishing robustness as the reason regularized SVMs generalize well.
[ 0.0024471855722367764, -0.02161397784948349, -0.009266499429941177, -0.005444493610411882, 0.04592793807387352, -0.03777383640408516, -0.021525314077734947, 0.024345433339476585, -0.02895778976380825, 0.06787490099668503, 0.04397228732705116, 0.00344460760243237, -0.007028587628155947, -0.0009121430921368301, 0.012390806339681149, 0.04158107563853264, 0.10505540668964386, 0.057540830224752426, 0.015814485028386116, -0.06207937374711037, 0.031174594536423683, 0.00025604377151466906, -0.006430956535041332, -0.06333751231431961, -0.01844802312552929, 0.058583952486515045, 0.00772061524912715, 0.010166995227336884, -0.017588810995221138, 0.011478317901492119, -0.04095147177577019, 0.03179432824254036, 0.006051875185221434, -0.04248340055346489, 0.01246662251651287, 0.010059071704745293, 0.01577676273882389, -0.00009363637218484655, -0.037500571459531784, 0.016292765736579895, -0.011275079101324081, 0.04678811877965927, 0.003939035814255476, -0.017215348780155182, 0.041818298399448395, 0.04431618005037308, 0.0036900260020047426, 0.04768211767077446, -0.00819416157901287, 0.033818915486335754, -0.04346086084842682, 0.003967222757637501, -0.045920778065919876, -0.01393116731196642, 0.029760168865323067, -0.014929896220564842, 0.04280471429228783, -0.007385784760117531, 0.03247211501002312, 0.0013781721936538815, 0.053205933421850204, 0.04812345653772354, -0.038027212023735046, -0.06925094872713089, 0.020024456083774567, -0.01304386742413044, -0.03596160560846329, -0.04031095281243324, 0.043978381901979446, -0.039016854017972946, -0.0206574909389019, -0.08252175897359848, 0.05721493065357208, 0.07018045336008072, 0.09377525001764297, -0.022955305874347687, -0.011993467807769775, -0.03279659524559975, -0.009227924980223179, 0.031527016311883926, -0.051507674157619476, -0.005262354854494333, 0.011201328597962856, 0.055241912603378296, -0.04376191645860672, -0.028428275138139725, -0.040394920855760574, -0.00998752936720848, 0.06857249140739441, -0.0007586859865114093, 0.09497209638357162, -0.014761416241526604, -0.027641091495752335, 0.0030385025311261415, -0.0003026432532351464, 0.0015741420211270452, 0.035728711634874344, -0.1039002314209938, 0.015209291130304337, 0.046176981180906296, 0.026156574487686157, 0.05904465168714523, 0.06917671859264374, 0.1001969501376152, -0.08485029637813568, -0.010222791694104671, 0.003912674263119698, 0.02947588823735714, -0.041094135493040085, 0.01600993238389492, -0.019142042845487595, -0.062448207288980484, 0.032274581491947174, -0.04740985482931137, -0.031968265771865845, 0.05821488797664642, -0.02899749018251896, 0.016847115010023117, 0.05801285430788994, 0.008535967208445072, 0.030369296669960022, -0.0055913543328642845, -0.018527131527662277, 0.026874789968132973, 0.006324345711618662, -0.05343223363161087, -0.04255106300115585, -0.0495767667889595, 0.08714045584201813, -0.04891599714756012, -0.06676091998815536, -0.013980713672935963, -0.011177955195307732, 0.01639224775135517, -0.07155503332614899, 0.013812159188091755, 0.0057778386399149895, -0.01110212691128254, -0.1042185053229332, 0.03684376925230026, 0.06766480952501297, 0.06361035257577896, 0.029361622408032417, 0.03121243230998516, 0.005680806469172239, 0.05927338823676109, 0.05322162061929703, -0.06744185835123062, -0.004520239774137735, 0.018512718379497528, -0.02878815494477749, 0.016956234350800514, 0.001223903615027666, 0.05593270808458328, 0.05108003318309784, -0.08941700309515, -0.031123006716370583, 0.001348506542854011, -0.02825024537742138, 0.056906141340732574, -0.035282425582408905, 0.07539628446102142, 0.02482142113149166, 0.038696255534887314, -0.006616012658923864, -0.06126747652888298, 0.03407590091228485, -0.014415810815989971, -0.03496742993593216, -0.03473334386944771, -0.08499643206596375, -0.015814578160643578, -0.01921587996184826, 0.004504751414060593, -0.06562711298465729, 0.009659374132752419, 0.005112265236675739, -0.0214169193059206, -0.06843918561935425, -0.10334289073944092, 0.07032619416713715, -0.05236361548304558, -0.02490762062370777, 0.06338097900152206, 0.0623091459274292, 0.1583786904811859, -0.015978217124938965, 0.014313874766230583, -0.0046274797059595585, 0.02077343873679638, 0.030762366950511932, -0.0909392237663269, -0.019003912806510925, -0.04331726208329201, -0.03422868624329567, 0.03118159808218479, -0.03321035951375961, -0.014527426101267338, 0.051236942410469055, 0.09059575945138931, 0.04758225381374359, 0.018521269783377647, -0.037506286054849625, -0.07141754776239395, 0.0027340289670974016, 0.003468160517513752, 0.09658107161521912, -0.05679093301296234, -0.0171505194157362, 0.007941795513033867, -0.0461462028324604, 0.0003162688226439059, 0.03670382499694824, -0.07330915331840515, -0.0022239501122385263, -0.036598168313503265, 0.036619674414396286, -0.0033392291516065598, 0.10981554538011551, -0.006154628936201334, -0.008636786602437496, 0.036841537803411484, -0.07686226814985275, 0.03924458101391792, -0.018801629543304443, 0.018849490210413933, -0.0020648811478167772, 0.015513094142079353, -0.019266922026872635, 0.04548107460141182, -0.06547316908836365, -0.04647456854581833, -0.003436359344050288, -0.05432240292429924, 0.0152520053088665, 0.039644449949264526, -0.04872213304042816, -0.08990869671106339, 0.056207794696092606, -0.04187360405921936, 0.008963242173194885, -0.011762372218072414, 0.042977768927812576, -0.03385375440120697, 0.047002557665109634, -0.08843369036912918, 0.0060364436358213425, 0.012742742896080017, 0.009325078688561916, -0.0014287662925198674, 0.053221698850393295, 0.09251268953084946, 0.009259432554244995, -0.1016293540596962, 0.05100499838590622, -0.05432986468076706, 0.010633253492414951, 0.023623764514923096, 0.024419983848929405, 0.07135111838579178, 0.018778109923005104, 0.04976725950837135, -0.042684465646743774, 0.018746139481663704, 0.07944393903017044, -0.039625294506549835, -0.05708707496523857, 0.022465892136096954, 0.005875619128346443, 0.055759113281965256, -0.11813212931156158, -0.0357031486928463, -0.04625604301691055, 0.03429412096738815, -0.038546591997146606, 0.016023332253098488, 0.06096001714468002, 0.011721629649400711, -0.015541174449026585, 0.01030179113149643, -0.048476289957761765, 0.02185717225074768, 0.010014648549258709, 0.007479271851480007, -0.018435198813676834, -0.019917378202080727, -0.060101062059402466, -0.01128713134676218, -0.02327876351773739, 0.014224612154066563, -0.08330381661653519, 0.04048068821430206, -0.0358767993748188, -0.04743475466966629, 0.08950766921043396, -0.029138484969735146, 0.013742156326770782, 0.04846423491835594, 0.09242147207260132, 0.054264891892671585, 0.07964584976434708, -0.0061762710101902485, -0.029636021703481674, -0.017268335446715355, -0.031382154673337936, 0.06023556366562843, 0.04667845740914345, -0.015523643232882023, -0.011384832672774792, 0.018060898408293724, 0.00852477177977562, -0.08709034323692322, 0.022160498425364494, -0.11293863505125046, -0.046254344284534454, -0.020697852596640587, 0.024715973064303398, -0.01248855795711279, -0.02931125834584236, -0.008618287742137909, 0.010988877154886723, -0.036806438118219376, 0.0214166771620512, 0.010620636865496635, -0.11881021410226822, -0.06860987842082977, -0.06375303864479065, 0.027678536251187325, -0.08954428136348724, -0.046590209007263184, -0.0017878285143524408, -0.02113921009004116, -0.01321127638220787, 0.057851988822221756, -0.000014804078091401607, 0.023012422025203705, 0.0004706777399405837, -0.012276413850486279, -0.05234934017062187, -0.0006850743084214628, -0.06013402342796326, -0.05731646716594696, 0.020505214110016823, 0.03427165374159813, -0.026071133092045784, 0.04632694274187088, 0.015042624436318874, -0.05688275024294853, -0.07598549127578735, 0.05311611294746399, -0.08340825140476227, -0.002856508130207658, -0.011938165873289108, 0.0367218516767025, -0.057553719729185104, -0.03860178589820862, 0.018822751939296722, -0.045421335846185684, -0.0019385888008400798, 0.0158370491117239, 0.04898406192660332, 0.0031373940873891115, -0.08181589096784592, 0.05312016233801842, -0.036712292581796646, 0.058513984084129333, -0.02958538942039013, 0.037066973745822906, 0.009778893552720547, -0.0017115920782089233, -0.047254402190446854, 0.013069837354123592, 0.027411488816142082, 0.02277749590575695, 0.05392087996006012, -0.03951496630907059, -0.0009203883819282055, 0.01855488494038582, -0.08793355524539948, -0.006377826910465956, -0.00766926072537899, 0.04078797623515129, -0.04314074292778969, -0.014103837311267853, 0.014201508834958076, -0.053194668143987656, -0.04838928207755089, -0.040219251066446304, 0.05727948993444443, -0.017369665205478668, 0.0104759456589818, -0.019339220598340034, -0.03910587728023529, 0.02313198149204254, -0.0004239192930981517, 0.010171760804951191, 0.02026405557990074, -0.06373000890016556, 0.06128353998064995, -0.07000400125980377, 0.02716255933046341, -0.05254710093140602, 0.018335087224841118, -0.02941526286303997, -0.030736180022358894, -0.06436484307050705, 0.0016992079326882958, 0.04846892133355141, 0.026117881760001183, 0.021504178643226624, 0.030027000233530998, 0.030063722282648087, -0.08360220491886139, 0.029040485620498657, 0.0647541806101799, 0.030972665175795555, 0.002256021834909916, -0.019189024344086647, 0.03252466022968292, -0.0700085386633873, -0.003018639050424099, 0.04472045227885246, 0.035722631961107254, -0.001980816712602973, -0.004495380911976099, 0.03471599891781807, 0.08181577920913696, 0.1450280249118805, -0.027651451528072357, 0.0066081564873456955, -0.025043096393346786, 0.005113695282489061, -0.10318010300397873, -0.0353102833032608, 0.04216310381889343, 0.01919611357152462, 0.06745309382677078, 0.0492887869477272, 0.01881934516131878, -0.008976059965789318, -0.0355970561504364, 0.049999337643384933, -0.020417125895619392, -0.02787020243704319, 0.023460527881979942, 0.06789468228816986, 0.0027562924660742283, 0.011511656455695629, 0.056397974491119385, 0.054325442761182785, -0.014395640231668949, 0.006711991969496012, -0.013212986290454865, -0.062115516513586044, 0.03881988674402237, -0.021706975996494293, -0.02928064949810505, -0.050751231610774994, 0.0637916773557663, -0.016769222915172577, 0.020042086020112038, -0.024361317977309227, -0.05487323924899101, 0.026015106588602066, -0.07388989627361298, 0.010044549591839314, 0.03327372297644615, 0.01334820780903101, 0.006082047242671251, 0.019701413810253143, -0.003339827759191394, -0.049152106046676636, 0.01901552826166153, -0.017480693757534027, 0.043827224522829056, -0.053587656468153, 0.03902942314743996, -0.08228760957717896, -0.01351909339427948, -0.04508044570684433, -0.06065297871828079, -0.1147276908159256, -0.021014492958784103, 0.0004717062402050942, 0.029025062918663025, 0.03176151588559151, -0.005698764696717262, 0.060705676674842834, 0.01257138792425394, -0.009211214259266853, -0.0037194613832980394, -0.0014791616704314947, 0.00029905737028457224, 0.021954311057925224, -0.0021475355606526136, -0.00918805506080389, 0.01864607073366642, -0.003971386700868607, -0.032781507819890976, -0.0020644983742386103, -0.004569544922560453, -0.025284502655267715, -0.045770708471536636, 0.015780888497829437, 0.019245002418756485, 0.04787492752075195, 0.018061770126223564, -0.010193925350904465, 0.09027494490146637, 0.022847367450594902, -0.054833464324474335, -0.07302752882242203 ]
93
93
Recorded Step Directional Mutation for Faster Convergence
Two meta-evolutionary optimization strategies described in this paper accelerate the convergence of evolutionary programming algorithms while still retaining much of their ability to deal with multi-modal problems. The strategies, called directional mutation and recorded step in this paper, can operate independently but together they greatly enhance the ability of evolutionary programming algorithms to deal with fitness landscapes characterized by long narrow valleys. The directional mutation aspect of this combined method uses correlated meta-mutation but does not introduce a full covariance matrix. These new methods are thus much more economical in terms of storage for problems with high dimensionality. Additionally, directional mutation is rotationally invariant which is a substantial advantage over self-adaptive methods which use a single variance per coordinate for problems where the natural orientation of the problem is not oriented along the axes.
[ 0.0530775785446167, -0.016665494069457054, 0.022575370967388153, -0.0035081151872873306, -0.04544079676270485, -0.03360948711633682, 0.009080084972083569, 0.05036191642284393, -0.0684184655547142, 0.04779043421149254, 0.017636293545365334, -0.017976801842451096, -0.043758079409599304, 0.01582537218928337, -0.019924970343708992, 0.0032799174077808857, -0.024066485464572906, -0.007547629065811634, 0.02887129783630371, -0.009528817608952522, -0.02276109717786312, -0.015780605375766754, 0.02196722850203514, -0.044576775282621384, -0.030501650646328926, 0.0680474191904068, 0.005017902236431837, -0.031595628708601, 0.006305028218775988, -0.01715724915266037, -0.05584730952978134, -0.07405781000852585, -0.0340857170522213, 0.03329057991504669, 0.014174791052937508, -0.05155004933476448, 0.06879479438066483, 0.02464069239795208, -0.033882372081279755, -0.025033166632056236, -0.0055196648463606834, -0.012258498929440975, 0.00034079450415447354, 0.011642846278846264, 0.003657451132312417, -0.009073070250451565, 0.01525749173015356, 0.0036119837313890457, -0.11589378118515015, 0.10060583055019379, -0.06328181177377701, 0.06618833541870117, 0.05510471388697624, 0.0020626375917345285, -0.004402576945722103, 0.026851996779441833, -0.011930234730243683, -0.028635993599891663, 0.03422355651855469, 0.013882994651794434, 0.0714997723698616, 0.1063399463891983, -0.018170557916164398, 0.032333578914403915, -0.045376699417829514, -0.013017096556723118, -0.019099842756986618, -0.002776870969682932, -0.08505228906869888, 0.04576763138175011, -0.022378509864211082, 0.06622790545225143, 0.029890667647123337, 0.020752079784870148, 0.00836847722530365, -0.005537684075534344, 0.006308874115347862, -0.028072519227862358, 0.036578353494405746, 0.034375641494989395, -0.060952652245759964, 0.06364096701145172, -0.031017668545246124, -0.018925298005342484, -0.044063862413167953, 0.004617169499397278, -0.03629673644900322, 0.03560495004057884, -0.06811340898275375, -0.0072798714973032475, 0.07522069662809372, 0.028034906834363937, -0.08565693348646164, 0.06546782702207565, -0.029067598283290863, 0.06722231954336166, -0.006199722643941641, -0.04178810864686966, 0.043518006801605225, 0.04090492054820061, 0.04469685256481171, -0.011915716342628002, 0.09144264459609985, -0.024455593898892403, 0.02949753776192665, 0.023601539433002472, -0.05114000290632248, 0.04840603470802307, -0.010082516819238663, -0.010574430227279663, -0.05484125018119812, -0.048311781138181686, 0.05877332016825676, 0.024068914353847504, -0.1091126874089241, -0.00205182284116745, -0.06397943198680878, 0.04867076128721237, -0.026436829939484596, -0.09230522811412811, 0.0535343736410141, -0.008193165063858032, 0.008539628237485886, -0.046697989106178284, 0.04206147789955139, 0.0573413260281086, 0.04220724478363991, -0.05296996235847473, 0.09123483300209045, 0.014447610825300217, -0.006152028683573008, 0.046585533767938614, -0.02823753096163273, -0.025262540206313133, -0.029183469712734222, 0.019901396706700325, -0.009620518423616886, 0.020298268646001816, -0.009048298932611942, 0.059102099388837814, -0.010463947430253029, -0.03890570253133774, -0.02723533660173416, 0.03693442419171333, -0.017628824338316917, -0.009228190407156944, -0.0064522884786129, 0.08429329842329025, -0.056132953613996506, 0.012710745446383953, -0.006031977478414774, -0.05303060635924339, 0.07267601788043976, 0.025143643841147423, 0.036192964762449265, -0.05235009640455246, 0.0025490799453109503, -0.011913157068192959, 0.06218649446964264, 0.054432984441518784, 0.0194214079529047, 0.03626495227217674, -0.05446276068687439, -0.032441746443510056, -0.010962847620248795, 0.03378351405262947, -0.05551699548959732, -0.08865576982498169, -0.04983515292406082, 0.00020189618226140738, -0.03177237510681152, 0.02420158125460148, -0.062385644763708115, 0.014749353751540184, 0.06089073792099953, 0.02170688472688198, 0.0048910449258983135, 0.05524212121963501, -0.006222615484148264, 0.07690141350030899, 0.0035832307767122984, 0.02059723623096943, -0.004076887853443623, 0.022643299773335457, 0.06329896301031113, 0.08206348866224289, -0.00509292958304286, 0.05977173522114754, 0.12945102155208588, 0.0015688539715483785, -0.008379588834941387, 0.02003788761794567, -0.02233547903597355, -0.012224288657307625, 0.024629894644021988, 0.06746760755777359, -0.057066529989242554, -0.02929219789803028, 0.021440159529447556, -0.004242150578647852, 0.05649862438440323, -0.004085823427885771, -0.07124178856611252, -0.0337301529943943, -0.009474776685237885, 0.01628730818629265, 0.05681939050555229, -0.06984928250312805, 0.006019925698637962, -0.07391438633203506, 0.007852191105484962, -0.008265420794487, -0.031291935592889786, -0.00203900714404881, 0.014183929190039635, -0.03551676869392395, -0.05669019743800163, -0.05203936621546745, 0.028187599033117294, 0.017805268988013268, -0.05164862424135208, 0.03709842637181282, -0.08049280941486359, 0.09436346590518951, 0.0010989538859575987, 0.0027665053494274616, 0.034108713269233704, 0.07669935375452042, 0.017319751903414726, -0.0070226616226136684, -0.01613963395357132, -0.03803401067852974, -0.07317312061786652, -0.015975698828697205, -0.10467663407325745, 0.053976234048604965, -0.03452875837683678, -0.012075644917786121, 0.02102162130177021, 0.033356718719005585, 0.021555228158831596, 0.06499458104372025, -0.01632194221019745, -0.010629151947796345, 0.01912640407681465, -0.028980029746890068, 0.11449244618415833, 0.06996316462755203, -0.020529264584183693, -0.06149119511246681, 0.058569636195898056, -0.024773919954895973, 0.016294222325086594, 0.07501295208930969, 0.01994321495294571, -0.0617627277970314, -0.027555637061595917, 0.03038475476205349, 0.050197456032037735, -0.0068069929257035255, -0.033477772027254105, 0.010379979386925697, 0.018860548734664917, -0.020380059257149696, 0.06845564395189285, 0.07237951457500458, 0.0381493866443634, -0.012795919552445412, -0.007394647225737572, -0.030790431424975395, -0.018401114270091057, -0.05600130185484886, -0.038428738713264465, 0.0020869814325124025, -0.008081341162323952, -0.08149130642414093, 0.13014456629753113, 0.055923204869031906, 0.07772023230791092, -0.04280999302864075, -0.011462484486401081, 0.025306642055511475, -0.04725998640060425, 0.05125420168042183, -0.04070743918418884, 0.02367500029504299, -0.05586832016706467, -0.03175777941942215, -0.03177431970834732, 0.019437018781900406, -0.06844944506883621, 0.004374730866402388, 0.010253742337226868, -0.024686675518751144, 0.06536461412906647, -0.02529902197420597, 0.04664069414138794, -0.001411072094924748, -0.044417452067136765, -0.008615839295089245, 0.07192441821098328, -0.019872058182954788, 0.003136323532089591, 0.038881611078977585, 0.012037282809615135, 0.09106890857219696, -0.0020274987909942865, 0.0339023619890213, -0.13540787994861603, -0.02582658641040325, 0.08717893809080124, 0.006330977659672499, -0.10099777579307556, -0.06687450408935547, -0.01433911919593811, 0.041545599699020386, -0.03520271182060242, 0.02981642261147499, 0.001812258386053145, -0.013516486622393131, 0.014208335429430008, 0.009166350588202477, 0.01631404645740986, -0.04547921568155289, -0.08640387654304504, -0.08749303966760635, -0.021485377103090286, -0.0669461041688919, 0.004391268827021122, 0.03751480579376221, -0.027620729058980942, 0.017600473016500473, -0.041419513523578644, 0.06472424417734146, -0.06396064162254333, -0.01941748894751072, -0.05412483960390091, 0.012856394052505493, -0.052638404071331024, 0.0006384537555277348, 0.05504927411675453, -0.06125539913773537, 0.023550186306238174, 0.024427447468042374, -0.025734486058354378, 0.06318913400173187, 0.10190439224243164, 0.023900026455521584, 0.08416309952735901, 0.0063383630476891994, -0.012220337986946106, -0.08888765424489975, -0.040793851017951965, 0.024419937282800674, 0.006672059651464224, 0.037557438015937805, -0.008978166617453098, 0.03995191305875778, 0.04061504825949669, 0.05032288283109665, 0.014117800630629063, -0.010066937655210495, 0.03715469688177109, 0.020337441936135292, -0.041481826454401016, 0.05945734679698944, -0.00375745608471334, 0.04445677995681763, 0.027451155707240105, -0.06404915452003479, -0.07589413970708847, 0.007302816957235336, 0.023454545065760612, 0.03320733457803726, -0.029401101171970367, 0.002011926844716072, 0.07730533927679062, -0.056753337383270264, -0.0863289088010788, 0.07751079648733139, -0.0553852804005146, 0.01824413426220417, 0.04589309170842171, -0.035040512681007385, -0.0510111041367054, 0.036341458559036255, -0.06382803618907928, 0.062120623886585236, -0.016269881278276443, -0.00497592706233263, -0.08453711122274399, -0.007203068118542433, -0.04404362663626671, 0.055890511721372604, -0.0063849142752587795, 0.0646636039018631, 0.0328303799033165, -0.0038773503620177507, -0.03156525269150734, 0.0032947829458862543, -0.04421470686793327, -0.04078800976276398, 0.033296138048172, -0.017423326149582863, -0.023231839761137962, 0.013254417106509209, 0.0074396259151399136, 0.04576564580202103, -0.04272394999861717, 0.04801654815673828, 0.026929298415780067, -0.006363370455801487, -0.031123967841267586, 0.012536577880382538, -0.0033824932761490345, 0.07503010332584381, -0.03936721384525299, 0.0399039052426815, 0.025343652814626694, -0.06957334280014038, -0.0006523590418510139, -0.04909158870577812, 0.004617546685039997, 0.039485201239585876, 0.011293735355138779, -0.023729752749204636, 0.049731120467185974, -0.02170371823012829, -0.040835220366716385, 0.025753850117325783, -0.06379305571317673, 0.06513005495071411, -0.04346093535423279, -0.006735627073794603, 0.0039862897247076035, 0.017020149156451225, 0.01124219037592411, -0.053867679089307785, 0.03798869252204895, -0.0189732126891613, -0.056269362568855286, 0.05875541269779205, -0.05174786224961281, -0.0009009051136672497, -0.013153758831322193, 0.048429761081933975, 0.006854284554719925, 0.03361019492149353, 0.050043608993291855, -0.018928149715065956, -0.0659586489200592, -0.005272231996059418, 0.014745534397661686, -0.0019500097259879112, -0.009211558848619461, -0.014234272763133049, 0.025734618306159973, 0.025867732241749763, 0.03844904527068138, -0.04605734348297119, -0.01592377945780754, -0.034211378544569016, -0.010604001581668854, 0.008985091932117939, -0.032513733953237534, -0.015354434959590435, -0.02021067403256893, 0.022372666746377945, 0.025753388181328773, 0.06251365691423416, 0.029122240841388702, -0.026343869045376778, -0.012213225476443768, -0.05749243125319481, -0.0029791484121233225, 0.0036126314662396908, 0.017488418146967888, -0.0587916374206543, -0.030358392745256424, 0.03249491751194, 0.05492304265499115, 0.042674969881772995, 0.05464857444167137, -0.0009916458511725068, -0.007863999344408512, 0.0307626873254776, -0.034084953367710114, 0.006881358567625284, 0.11398155987262726, 0.023944977670907974, 0.02128632180392742, -0.005055566318333149, 0.052185095846652985, 0.062125712633132935, 0.022073807194828987, 0.009733928367495537, 0.07541116327047348, 0.004850326105952263, 0.1171107143163681, 0.04100392013788223, 0.06419385224580765, 0.027028966695070267, -0.005527009256184101, 0.006727293133735657, 0.0374215766787529, 0.05186069756746292, 0.0517621785402298, -0.03790116310119629, -0.08506618440151215, -0.013568290509283543, 0.01070256344974041, 0.01344919204711914 ]
94
94
Support Vector Machine Classification with Indefinite Kernels
We propose a method for support vector machine classification using indefinite kernels. Instead of directly minimizing or stabilizing a nonconvex loss function, our algorithm simultaneously computes support vectors and a proxy kernel matrix used in forming the loss. This can be interpreted as a penalized kernel learning problem where indefinite kernel matrices are treated as a noisy observations of a true Mercer kernel. Our formulation keeps the problem convex and relatively large problems can be solved efficiently using the projected gradient or analytic center cutting plane methods. We compare the performance of our technique with other methods on several classic data sets.
[ -0.02320197783410549, -0.09568457305431366, -0.00871055107563734, -0.01606435328722, 0.0070109558291733265, -0.050939206033945084, 0.03769002482295036, 0.03395804017782211, -0.07775692641735077, -0.01269482634961605, 0.022874975576996803, 0.02673483081161976, -0.008555659092962742, 0.0030956685077399015, -0.01805305853486061, 0.05404143035411835, 0.03642916679382324, -0.025227759033441544, 0.025539958849549294, -0.08012252300977707, 0.09044000506401062, -0.011929800733923912, 0.04091440513730049, -0.057418059557676315, 0.026414604857563972, 0.05793097987771034, -0.0322236530482769, -0.05443289875984192, 0.030693257227540016, 0.05489421263337135, -0.06193903833627701, 0.018521785736083984, -0.009453855454921722, -0.022200951352715492, -0.008690263144671917, -0.0725800096988678, 0.010430227033793926, 0.012644783593714237, -0.05301985889673233, -0.044096484780311584, 0.0140615776181221, 0.03994720056653023, 0.010767936706542969, 0.0014680118765681982, 0.06157325208187103, 0.08947116881608963, -0.0012610311387106776, -0.030903790146112442, -0.015537172555923462, 0.09151291102170944, -0.08995118737220764, -0.015625737607479095, -0.04389664903283119, -0.02157018706202507, 0.06893856823444366, 0.0023348720278590918, 0.002119038486853242, -0.03736709803342819, 0.007608118467032909, -0.043599218130111694, 0.0005505302106030285, 0.08517632633447647, -0.012370388954877853, 0.021772019565105438, -0.0277414508163929, -0.044812656939029694, -0.013934600166976452, -0.09497468918561935, -0.020267201587557793, 0.01316314097493887, 0.020711654797196388, -0.1177656278014183, 0.005138144362717867, 0.0261741504073143, 0.0025889850221574306, 0.012543879449367523, -0.05265846475958824, 0.018898652866482735, 0.029357627034187317, 0.045235127210617065, -0.03277843818068504, -0.01191037893295288, 0.05102403089404106, 0.08234276622533798, 0.011387505568563938, 0.008326820097863674, -0.035615913569927216, -0.033037539571523666, -0.05826020613312721, -0.032348260283470154, 0.03259993717074394, 0.03196755051612854, -0.06708164513111115, 0.0024652043357491493, -0.026508228853344917, -0.033487118780612946, -0.004158726427704096, -0.02208707295358181, 0.04457918554544449, -0.01761200651526451, 0.013956611976027489, 0.024851098656654358, 0.08965977281332016, 0.08171435445547104, -0.04714884236454964, 0.004344440996646881, -0.039787400513887405, 0.013112354092299938, -0.02607048861682415, 0.013239385560154915, 0.024515097960829735, -0.018927957862615585, 0.035573963075876236, 0.05405554175376892, -0.06868752837181091, 0.03812022507190704, -0.04539818316698074, 0.06873653084039688, -0.004620281048119068, 0.029553767293691635, 0.032824110239744186, 0.05217450112104416, -0.1160326674580574, 0.11848312616348267, 0.10007625073194504, -0.0391734279692173, -0.005206939298659563, -0.0682733952999115, 0.03712688386440277, 0.012402163818478584, -0.04311878979206085, 0.006474348250776529, -0.01297102589160204, 0.012736654840409756, -0.014431926421821117, 0.06530480086803436, 0.060074836015701294, -0.026513153687119484, -0.05102142319083214, 0.06735309958457947, -0.010031287558376789, 0.026123417541384697, -0.0037948759272694588, 0.056434161961078644, 0.051670778542757034, -0.0010709242196753621, -0.0174152422696352, 0.03846295550465584, 0.023973798379302025, -0.0038131524343043566, -0.029672835022211075, -0.0197589173913002, 0.057279132306575775, 0.02321632020175457, 0.009884596802294254, -0.10512937605381012, -0.03060797043144703, -0.01899121329188347, 0.03355465084314346, 0.05539938062429428, -0.04166632145643234, -0.0054136840626597404, 0.028596896678209305, 0.05292408913373947, -0.021211596205830574, -0.07364490628242493, 0.07557794451713562, -0.02739241160452366, -0.014437966048717499, -0.06335077434778214, -0.04291939362883568, 0.02386246621608734, -0.05823064595460892, 0.01903793215751648, -0.0705755427479744, 0.004002392757683992, -0.0344504788517952, 0.0223991721868515, -0.03975308686494827, -0.05601850524544716, 0.05247673764824867, -0.029350850731134415, -0.017764994874596596, -0.010062518529593945, 0.09903080016374588, 0.051778655499219894, -0.0022464413195848465, 0.027238307520747185, 0.030282625928521156, 0.022822286933660507, 0.04843972250819206, -0.03734350576996803, 0.028039734810590744, -0.04403064027428627, -0.0718323141336441, 0.04507000744342804, -0.015975257381796837, -0.061866771429777145, 0.0016796248964965343, 0.09655154496431351, 0.06591039150953293, -0.03578638285398483, 0.0030959430150687695, -0.0467442087829113, -0.0803779810667038, 0.0004472800064831972, 0.0764344111084938, -0.00497790751978755, 0.04191670939326286, 0.03089759685099125, -0.029248131439089775, 0.018281880766153336, 0.0371086448431015, 0.0010278605623170733, -0.05112170800566673, -0.06285838782787323, 0.05430561304092407, 0.08717510104179382, 0.036359064280986786, 0.021952098235487938, -0.013026057742536068, 0.027299830690026283, -0.06792445480823517, 0.04335286468267441, -0.06347155570983887, 0.045033909380435944, -0.035509608685970306, -0.037706032395362854, -0.0705246776342392, 0.09589216858148575, -0.0401119738817215, -0.08532381057739258, -0.048269301652908325, -0.01215048972517252, -0.030750520527362823, 0.029636943712830544, -0.012372396886348724, -0.03520709648728371, 0.02631857804954052, -0.034466058015823364, -0.01849234849214554, 0.017157435417175293, -0.04913213104009628, -0.09266269207000732, 0.06502226740121841, -0.05651739239692688, 0.060158561915159225, 0.016832895576953888, 0.02014843001961708, 0.0014858206268399954, -0.012443173676729202, 0.06175703555345535, 0.0004445863887667656, -0.008357908576726913, 0.02785516530275345, -0.04030866175889969, 0.020791642367839813, 0.040104083716869354, 0.017589567229151726, 0.00478292815387249, 0.00025231775362044573, -0.0022913021966814995, 0.011584536172449589, -0.005678003188222647, 0.04805203527212143, 0.027172699570655823, -0.03277374431490898, -0.010235643945634365, 0.026365382596850395, 0.01860213093459606, -0.0796908587217331, -0.045823607593774796, -0.06618467718362808, 0.07402976602315903, -0.04133667051792145, 0.015944579616189003, 0.052619174122810364, 0.0018145310459658504, -0.022757597267627716, -0.009740976616740227, -0.00974535197019577, 0.009586376138031483, -0.013802440837025642, -0.05418192595243454, 0.002315716352313757, -0.0027091752272099257, 0.012180307880043983, -0.06329111009836197, 0.014813100919127464, 0.03755670040845871, -0.001953534549102187, 0.07901257276535034, -0.05039554089307785, 0.00030760583467781544, 0.056519586592912674, -0.07948057353496552, 0.046090926975011826, 0.03697679564356804, 0.013518734835088253, 0.006446866784244776, 0.08454322814941406, 0.07217558473348618, 0.023324066773056984, -0.03067857027053833, 0.04006633907556534, 0.0624665766954422, 0.04221252724528313, -0.051335737109184265, 0.009029600769281387, 0.01644916459918022, 0.02851860411465168, 0.016156606376171112, -0.03427335247397423, -0.000826996227260679, 0.003281631972640753, -0.005161413457244635, -0.005028134677559137, 0.002973665716126561, -0.05956541374325752, -0.012959539890289307, 0.04340595006942749, 0.0037199044600129128, 0.026504678651690483, -0.040113143622875214, -0.08499571681022644, -0.007043828256428242, -0.009676313027739525, 0.07497140765190125, -0.09692712128162384, -0.0660691112279892, -0.04820911958813667, 0.008958914317190647, -0.036175571382045746, 0.0455814003944397, 0.02102220430970192, 0.0017361073987558484, 0.01764795184135437, 0.04785316437482834, -0.04241202771663666, -0.03369283676147461, -0.0745370090007782, -0.0631653368473053, -0.01678348332643509, -0.01866866648197174, -0.03969478979706764, 0.0068857790902256966, 0.0848398432135582, -0.03881244733929634, -0.036653902381658554, 0.06683582067489624, -0.07368484884500504, 0.05154905468225479, -0.07825624197721481, 0.05616965517401695, -0.07329531759023666, 0.05670996010303497, 0.0623328760266304, -0.054232846945524216, 0.03813909739255905, -0.03292097523808479, 0.03677825629711151, -0.0455552414059639, -0.054509520530700684, 0.03470724821090698, 0.058023106306791306, 0.0445777103304863, -0.027534330263733864, -0.007829510606825352, -0.01499097514897585, -0.00881474930793047, -0.0009483040194027126, 0.07907924801111221, 0.057858049869537354, -0.010530137456953526, 0.03678971529006958, -0.06016096472740173, 0.009607273153960705, -0.028422029688954353, 0.009371931664645672, 0.0811520665884018, -0.020219167694449425, 0.0019070908892899752, 0.028272833675146103, 0.05481336638331413, -0.0248587504029274, -0.03427594155073166, -0.005861375480890274, -0.015478970482945442, 0.06396334618330002, -0.03411488980054855, -0.029849963262677193, 0.03504451736807823, -0.04689081758260727, 0.06643808633089066, 0.022985218092799187, -0.002444993471726775, -0.007314254995435476, -0.0010185356950387359, 0.00896963756531477, -0.01314669568091631, -0.046928610652685165, -0.022762136533856392, 0.04653085023164749, -0.028062283992767334, -0.036145955324172974, -0.02044634148478508, -0.0320747084915638, 0.02664320357143879, 0.014244401827454567, 0.0644802451133728, -0.003146023955196142, 0.008542229421436787, -0.02948630601167679, 0.0041873096488416195, -0.015649447217583656, 0.04820011183619499, -0.10022249817848206, -0.005474706646054983, 0.04335133731365204, -0.09357351809740067, 0.021334880962967873, 0.08093678951263428, -0.020810049027204514, 0.042908649891614914, -0.0548289492726326, 0.03759390115737915, -0.012022786773741245, 0.07568575441837311, -0.061312947422266006, -0.020404426380991936, -0.1337471902370453, 0.039777111262083054, -0.09588094800710678, -0.008937330916523933, 0.10209761559963226, -0.010354592464864254, 0.11814890801906586, -0.03580257669091225, -0.006398505996912718, 0.011322343721985817, -0.028008615598082542, -0.0018936226842924953, -0.014291830360889435, -0.016952840611338615, 0.006179343909025192, 0.02359696477651596, -0.008475755341351032, -0.03090737573802471, 0.05999365076422691, -0.004828188102692366, -0.027420857921242714, 0.06919639557600021, 0.013087066821753979, -0.01616971381008625, 0.03451275825500488, 0.03171059116721153, 0.012032742612063885, -0.0406402051448822, -0.019156349822878838, -0.0314006507396698, -0.027486052364110947, -0.026331909000873566, -0.004992310423403978, 0.001893365290015936, -0.0632595345377922, 0.0030937984120100737, 0.0008083981228992343, 0.0021787872537970543, 0.03530259057879448, -0.007496363949030638, -0.0296191219240427, 0.013493981212377548, 0.015521732158958912, -0.025904711335897446, 0.04787927493453026, -0.03425282984972, -0.02129368670284748, -0.04438088834285736, -0.003741153283044696, -0.015481550246477127, -0.02212611213326454, -0.080698162317276, -0.058152373880147934, 0.005308151710778475, 0.05085575580596924, -0.03985901176929474, -0.017166772857308388, 0.013462383300065994, 0.03149839863181114, -0.002247749362140894, -0.01933474838733673, 0.09363101422786713, -0.005498730577528477, 0.07544555515050888, -0.07109306007623672, -0.043252475559711456, 0.028508946299552917, -0.007648917380720377, -0.048343293368816376, 0.04443921521306038, -0.021799609065055847, 0.01040472462773323, 0.06551981717348099, 0.03822608292102814, 0.09768596291542053, 0.010049594566226006, -0.009608152322471142, -0.007527652196586132, -0.0024587190710008144, 0.07384371757507324, -0.011461460962891579, 0.008643125183880329 ]
95
95
A Unified Semi-Supervised Dimensionality Reduction Framework for Manifold Learning
We present a general framework of semi-supervised dimensionality reduction for manifold learning which naturally generalizes existing supervised and unsupervised learning frameworks which apply the spectral decomposition. Algorithms derived under our framework are able to employ both labeled and unlabeled examples and are able to handle complex problems where data form separate clusters of manifolds. Our framework offers simple views, explains relationships among existing frameworks and provides further extensions which can improve existing algorithms. Furthermore, a new semi-supervised kernelization framework called ``KPCA trick'' is proposed to handle non-linear problems.
[ 0.019089769572019577, -0.04773654416203499, 0.05136479437351227, 0.007988243363797665, -0.007508597336709499, -0.07851505279541016, -0.018809108063578606, -0.0073261265642941, -0.01050899550318718, -0.03807252272963524, -0.004656119272112846, -0.00462330924347043, -0.07352059334516525, 0.031058624386787415, -0.04023081064224243, 0.07495329529047012, 0.013740727677941322, -0.023699326440691948, 0.0030704722739756107, -0.048071980476379395, 0.004509333521127701, -0.013234722428023815, 0.01314508356153965, -0.05394190922379494, 0.07027602195739746, 0.00002478256465110462, -0.057222019881010056, -0.026424366980791092, -0.01397506520152092, 0.03350856900215149, -0.041873782873153687, -0.03623879328370094, -0.0175500325858593, 0.025782611221075058, -0.05441855266690254, -0.050356630235910416, -0.015406538732349873, 0.02318902313709259, -0.06544270366430283, -0.022315312176942825, 0.004907409660518169, 0.04530363902449608, 0.0071286666207015514, 0.009980658069252968, 0.030923327431082726, 0.07081840932369232, 0.05981668829917908, -0.10105788707733154, 0.024584146216511726, 0.060264695435762405, -0.12183055281639099, 0.04321688041090965, -0.04689157381653786, 0.007766347378492355, 0.005593401379883289, 0.013051002286374569, 0.00723480898886919, 0.017747847363352776, 0.02137809805572033, 0.020535307005047798, 0.012112775817513466, 0.08249920606613159, -0.006608199793845415, -0.0006330444011837244, -0.04378877952694893, -0.03654224053025246, -0.02104998379945755, -0.0762571394443512, 0.0010841133771464229, -0.017303666099905968, -0.013134907931089401, -0.013360013253986835, -0.05113576725125313, 0.07988087087869644, 0.016329070553183556, 0.07468210905790329, -0.058999594300985336, 0.0392337366938591, 0.0274592787027359, 0.07254117727279663, 0.03356964886188507, 0.016986370086669922, 0.02083682082593441, 0.02211429737508297, 0.00805769395083189, -0.042176030576229095, 0.018908074125647545, -0.019779721274971962, -0.025110771879553795, -0.010534553788602352, 0.018887020647525787, 0.03468682989478111, -0.045697201043367386, -0.014567708596587181, -0.01111685298383236, 0.015933142974972725, -0.08243060111999512, -0.07945217937231064, 0.0038631102070212364, 0.039752136915922165, -0.028925839811563492, 0.028494175523519516, 0.016859371215105057, 0.04174690321087837, 0.022751450538635254, 0.07196995615959167, -0.09190592914819717, 0.057374533265829086, -0.007041746284812689, 0.006853264756500721, 0.02752557583153248, -0.04935261234641075, 0.010036311112344265, -0.016516607254743576, -0.014030858874320984, 0.024236489087343216, -0.036042626947164536, 0.06818122416734695, 0.05162833631038666, 0.049147650599479675, -0.005120305344462395, -0.013144543394446373, -0.004062172956764698, -0.02983004041016102, 0.06520000845193863, -0.06105895712971687, -0.06624124199151993, -0.04072653129696846, 0.0666312724351883, 0.03292325884103775, -0.03637489676475525, 0.03604048117995262, -0.015761561691761017, -0.01022016815841198, -0.07281190156936646, -0.012028345838189125, 0.04186512529850006, -0.007525220513343811, -0.059862565249204636, 0.017066771164536476, 0.0015073145041242242, 0.008004025556147099, 0.009260858409106731, -0.05386640504002571, 0.09010821580886841, 0.012355774641036987, -0.011702848598361015, 0.02914033643901348, 0.022384561598300934, -0.047223951667547226, -0.016727687790989876, -0.032819442451000214, 0.055716466158628464, 0.07510919123888016, 0.05011753737926483, -0.06644710153341293, 0.02489647828042507, -0.004331161733716726, 0.010846983641386032, 0.025142522528767586, -0.012301846407353878, -0.023565644398331642, -0.001825527986511588, 0.08853188157081604, 0.05626335367560387, -0.04191891476511955, -0.02033345028758049, -0.00863146036863327, 0.011287516914308071, -0.04173032566905022, -0.028926895931363106, 0.009735526517033577, -0.012320728972554207, -0.0030686489772051573, 0.08345157653093338, -0.051512230187654495, -0.04851267859339714, 0.025757862254977226, 0.03656749054789543, -0.03998391330242157, -0.019909478724002838, 0.06482617557048798, 0.0010416267905384302, 0.01885010302066803, -0.018105963245034218, -0.02197883464396, -0.010424632579088211, -0.008409019559621811, 0.0630260705947876, 0.0032428198028355837, 0.06726516038179398, -0.01708723045885563, -0.030071184039115906, -0.033159926533699036, -0.023585643619298935, 0.009558414109051228, 0.02996855601668358, -0.04875057190656662, 0.08050300925970078, 0.07490815222263336, 0.004809731151908636, -0.00168752227909863, -0.06460104882717133, -0.09855599701404572, -0.050280556082725525, 0.03958545997738838, 0.03562406077980995, 0.041206903755664825, -0.009296910837292671, -0.005842019338160753, 0.026258356869220734, 0.00407119607552886, -0.03225566819310188, -0.032127607613801956, 0.015014669857919216, -0.09918507188558578, -0.008640443906188011, -0.045362915843725204, 0.07137243449687958, 0.09533706307411194, -0.06169433146715164, 0.015693707391619682, -0.03845316916704178, 0.06868235021829605, -0.10125093162059784, -0.018990110605955124, 0.024832360446453094, -0.07526960223913193, -0.029577363282442093, 0.020074868574738503, -0.08956187218427658, -0.0709313303232193, -0.06487371027469635, -0.004229126963764429, 0.06346771866083145, 0.011856667697429657, -0.016730260103940964, -0.0007167474250309169, 0.010067529045045376, 0.04170301556587219, 0.0664219930768013, 0.004869771655648947, 0.040276605635881424, -0.014129691757261753, -0.05996747687458992, -0.019103892147541046, 0.05923505872488022, 0.07810945808887482, -0.0009424221934750676, -0.006227914709597826, -0.016944047063589096, 0.03288639709353447, 0.041097741574048996, 0.053730450570583344, 0.011336819268763065, 0.009470189921557903, -0.052334241569042206, 0.0284530408680439, 0.05957554280757904, 0.04314086586236954, 0.04341030865907669, -0.002449283143505454, -0.020782209932804108, -0.04177185520529747, 0.07961197197437286, 0.025095803663134575, 0.026426101103425026, 0.026977233588695526, -0.055163055658340454, 0.008215370588004589, -0.023188617080450058, -0.06583371013402939, -0.03930097818374634, 0.034757424145936966, 0.006930661853402853, 0.013956312090158463, 0.005022379569709301, 0.11421574652194977, 0.012833507731556892, -0.014866568148136139, -0.03980822488665581, -0.015300333499908447, -0.06225353851914406, -0.009836037643253803, 0.002114074770361185, -0.04568025842308998, 0.08328419923782349, -0.03703013435006142, 0.03210226446390152, 0.07383989542722702, -0.027956416830420494, 0.053451769053936005, -0.059625133872032166, 0.015305527485907078, 0.09406498074531555, -0.09052117168903351, 0.02918197400867939, -0.012902550399303436, 0.019159097224473953, 0.027872037142515182, 0.11492642015218735, 0.03559838607907295, -0.026567554101347923, -0.010739232413470745, 0.047273799777030945, 0.049360401928424835, 0.09132242202758789, 0.028571294620633125, 0.0029158948455005884, -0.004961017053574324, 0.053450535982847214, 0.071495920419693, 0.022501083090901375, -0.024191947653889656, -0.01582116074860096, 0.008401717990636826, -0.005108640529215336, 0.07096565514802933, -0.028697384521365166, 0.029833851382136345, 0.01487206295132637, 0.046991199254989624, 0.002667458727955818, -0.018833115696907043, -0.0738590657711029, -0.04108031839132309, 0.06107747182250023, 0.05286616086959839, -0.15744146704673767, -0.03627771511673927, -0.031177159398794174, -0.03724512457847595, -0.005459061358124018, 0.05352519452571869, 0.03759254142642021, -0.03518880903720856, -0.08469736576080322, -0.04398185759782791, 0.01151494961231947, -0.037928346544504166, -0.07361510396003723, -0.058193106204271317, -0.023576980456709862, -0.018251648172736168, -0.015379759483039379, 0.023189900442957878, 0.038959987461566925, -0.032980773597955704, -0.10076473653316498, 0.05645290017127991, -0.07117944955825806, -0.02995462901890278, -0.04903027415275574, 0.0648256465792656, 0.026704946532845497, 0.02006494253873825, 0.10192754864692688, -0.032788753509521484, 0.01274298969656229, -0.010621688328683376, 0.0239707138389349, 0.03716592863202095, -0.026362445205450058, 0.05284256488084793, -0.02075696550309658, 0.051603734493255615, 0.009411830455064774, 0.012812172994017601, -0.017099639400839806, -0.08798572421073914, 0.05232943966984749, -0.02103409357368946, 0.012941312044858932, 0.018643448129296303, 0.04020024836063385, -0.007860114797949791, 0.06387747824192047, -0.04064558818936348, -0.0149788036942482, -0.024733491241931915, -0.01835942454636097, 0.025168029591441154, -0.018842866644263268, 0.03604473918676376, -0.038348015397787094, -0.015670303255319595, 0.00019189162412658334, 0.03731527924537659, 0.03528589382767677, 0.010058718733489513, -0.011064263992011547, 0.0028943130746483803, 0.01895427331328392, -0.031014984473586082, 0.018317846581339836, -0.031541433185338974, 0.031046796590089798, 0.01341769564896822, 0.006372080650180578, 0.0009443113813176751, 0.02988486737012863, -0.033918190747499466, 0.05051887780427933, -0.043668728321790695, -0.06869541853666306, -0.01204462070018053, -0.017172833904623985, 0.07324251532554626, -0.033255089074373245, 0.016324153169989586, 0.049688100814819336, 0.025615965947508812, 0.018231960013508797, 0.015155858360230923, 0.004181430675089359, 0.01117408275604248, 0.008220716379582882, -0.03790973499417305, 0.07406855374574661, -0.09735364466905594, 0.03176804631948471, -0.0059075807221233845, 0.00827404297888279, -0.02566090226173401, -0.019009852781891823, 0.016751907765865326, 0.006421736441552639, 0.08930853754281998, 0.04768858104944229, 0.05114547163248062, -0.023428672924637794, -0.014728301204741001, -0.07364863902330399, 0.035889770835638046, 0.09355335682630539, -0.05236154794692993, 0.028139464557170868, -0.08731699734926224, 0.018770474940538406, -0.052595265209674835, -0.04567568376660347, 0.04690775275230408, 0.014479641802608967, 0.0034043067134916782, -0.014621264301240444, 0.07770536839962006, 0.04004919156432152, -0.06814795732498169, 0.027206813916563988, 0.02357231080532074, 0.028441673144698143, 0.02315819263458252, 0.11206841468811035, -0.001491342787630856, 0.04769706353545189, -0.04201380908489227, 0.0681104063987732, -0.0808921605348587, -0.021064240485429764, -0.06286013126373291, 0.02518235333263874, -0.00846421904861927, -0.015739526599645615, 0.02366015501320362, -0.015712305903434753, 0.03473195433616638, -0.0028184144757688046, 0.11312538385391235, 0.0043406118638813496, 0.009871446527540684, -0.017433660104870796, 0.06025073677301407, 0.0004401586193125695, 0.044859081506729126, 0.004275149200111628, -0.05714285373687744, 0.006445479579269886, -0.053348708897829056, -0.035982172936201096, -0.02019006945192814, 0.019190266728401184, -0.016260134056210518, -0.04263511672616005, 0.02666650153696537, 0.04977826401591301, 0.050960972905159, 0.03814332187175751, 0.02003793977200985, -0.00224697170779109, -0.0054850648157298565, 0.05247112363576889, 0.016515616327524185, -0.04658351466059685, 0.02055276371538639, -0.04708627611398697, -0.00318634370341897, 0.01887843944132328, -0.05675332620739937, -0.04661201313138008, 0.07448510080575943, -0.05132941156625748, -0.09212831407785416, 0.04078279808163643, 0.0580221563577652, 0.07960037142038345, 0.02250923402607441, 0.009987868368625641, -0.00490028178319335, 0.036765843629837036, 0.10864827781915665, -0.01983902044594288, -0.056953370571136475 ]
96
96
Bolasso: model consistent Lasso estimation through the bootstrap
We consider the least-square linear regression problem with regularization by the l1-norm, a problem usually referred to as the Lasso. In this paper, we present a detailed asymptotic analysis of model consistency of the Lasso. For various decays of the regularization parameter, we compute asymptotic equivalents of the probability of correct model selection (i.e., variable selection). For a specific rate decay, we show that the Lasso selects all the variables that should enter the model with probability tending to one exponentially fast, while it selects all other variables with strictly positive probability. We show that this property implies that if we run the Lasso for several bootstrapped replications of a given sample, then intersecting the supports of the Lasso bootstrap estimates leads to consistent model selection. This novel variable selection algorithm, referred to as the Bolasso, is compared favorably to other linear regression methods on synthetic data and datasets from the UCI machine learning repository.
[ -0.02238384261727333, -0.05372322350740433, -0.03939032554626465, 0.0013453321298584342, 0.032768454402685165, -0.06049889698624611, 0.037415530532598495, 0.009387719444930553, 0.05363825708627701, 0.08586770296096802, 0.013571057468652725, -0.014101515524089336, 0.0057892086915671825, 0.04419948160648346, -0.04982386901974678, -0.054457880556583405, -0.02150927484035492, -0.049144256860017776, 0.027141502127051353, -0.05458465591073036, -0.06165642663836479, -0.00315392785705626, 0.05855720117688179, -0.0618046410381794, 0.06107878312468529, -0.008277983404695988, 0.022360578179359436, 0.06689473241567612, -0.009539570659399033, 0.01019174326211214, -0.046074144542217255, 0.061420634388923645, 0.03285573795437813, -0.01875978894531727, 0.05213479697704315, -0.06906033307313919, 0.02679024636745453, 0.052733588963747025, -0.006293065380305052, -0.03788135573267937, 0.04031548649072647, -0.04962444305419922, 0.07824870198965073, 0.026614006608724594, 0.03265400603413582, -0.047957804054021835, 0.05689984932541847, 0.04516712948679924, -0.0607483945786953, 0.010846665129065514, -0.018089687451720238, 0.04983006417751312, -0.05383433401584625, -0.03522402420639992, 0.06201629713177681, 0.012319454923272133, -0.08420448005199432, -0.010783795267343521, -0.06084619089961052, -0.026784110814332962, 0.02958749234676361, 0.07980108261108398, 0.04194687679409981, -0.0610332190990448, -0.006744489539414644, 0.04399527981877327, -0.0774504542350769, -0.009554468095302582, -0.05817614495754242, -0.0475594699382782, 0.03783241659402847, -0.08163109421730042, -0.0016784288454800844, 0.02632252499461174, 0.060450479388237, -0.00754160201177001, 0.025371525436639786, -0.019267959520220757, -0.01781442202627659, 0.021619651466608047, -0.02432049810886383, -0.03154689446091652, 0.02460329420864582, 0.04701737314462662, -0.02886717952787876, -0.010466390289366245, 0.03047545813024044, -0.031044676899909973, 0.03421809524297714, -0.01747147925198078, -0.018498655408620834, 0.02755802497267723, -0.02871764823794365, 0.008699852041900158, -0.01973211206495762, 0.06320617347955704, 0.046701639890670776, 0.017715342342853546, -0.026364276185631752, 0.0346992127597332, 0.06496074795722961, 0.016497107222676277, 0.03844726085662842, 0.048653118312358856, -0.04727127030491829, 0.024676311761140823, 0.01722142845392227, 0.010731056332588196, 0.049188874661922455, -0.0026415782049298286, -0.021861480548977852, -0.022758230566978455, 0.05451930686831474, -0.0010469298576936126, -0.02879670262336731, 0.05799298360943794, 0.006324104964733124, 0.08719243109226227, 0.027579857036471367, -0.04656057804822922, 0.02758486196398735, 0.05392814055085182, -0.04058985412120819, 0.02121194265782833, -0.02587408572435379, -0.010413957759737968, 0.003836503252387047, -0.09601741284132004, 0.07600463926792145, -0.04695764183998108, -0.04739726334810257, -0.01885947585105896, -0.029986988753080368, 0.012769456021487713, -0.06281330436468124, 0.01506313867866993, -0.03134149685502052, -0.048140402883291245, -0.0485633984208107, 0.05552644655108452, -0.06350664049386978, 0.017708484083414078, -0.03862574324011803, 0.06737777590751648, -0.01964709721505642, -0.0005628559156320989, 0.02259073406457901, -0.01012235414236784, -0.034318968653678894, -0.03572123870253563, 0.006365056149661541, -0.05248422920703888, -0.013354713097214699, 0.03907950967550278, 0.08961088955402374, -0.0656219944357872, -0.0007992380997166038, 0.02109936997294426, -0.0374450720846653, 0.06515311449766159, -0.012816477566957474, 0.012021584436297417, 0.021305395290255547, 0.004032617434859276, -0.0783710926771164, -0.049818575382232666, -0.03027128241956234, 0.03732791170477867, -0.03137340024113655, 0.04026511311531067, -0.04841642826795578, 0.03463219478726387, -0.10961960256099701, -0.03819923475384712, 0.060441166162490845, 0.02864702045917511, 0.10780534148216248, 0.026974093168973923, -0.06840408593416214, -0.059501249343156815, 0.014939055778086185, 0.015033974312245846, 0.004101963713765144, 0.016482627019286156, -0.013578572310507298, 0.09103687107563019, -0.007567570079118013, 0.022902440279722214, 0.03830203041434288, -0.05337141454219818, 0.07795187085866928, -0.0008784913807176054, 0.006709794979542494, 0.04806771129369736, 0.015279272571206093, 0.042262963950634, -0.03027065470814705, 0.0012638353509828448, 0.01665349304676056, 0.008584488183259964, 0.03958376124501228, -0.001001466065645218, 0.0011031003668904305, -0.048516497015953064, -0.02925310656428337, -0.0006656720652244985, 0.05391636863350868, -0.08057132363319397, -0.0005700617912225425, -0.01971220038831234, -0.019964085891842842, 0.024386882781982422, -0.056766003370285034, -0.053765006363391876, 0.003745355410501361, 0.00911285076290369, 0.012406296096742153, -0.09304308891296387, 0.03271489217877388, 0.04147694259881973, 0.005075105000287294, 0.08885294944047928, 0.0737040787935257, 0.012173447757959366, -0.06531126797199249, 0.011526255868375301, 0.03911139816045761, 0.009149867109954357, 0.007453709840774536, 0.04968114197254181, -0.01276596449315548, -0.06168784946203232, -0.005724312271922827, 0.024113358929753304, -0.05319793522357941, 0.033983565866947174, 0.013747221790254116, -0.04719889909029007, 0.05803818628191948, -0.01551792211830616, -0.023776838555932045, 0.0319339893758297, 0.009825882501900196, -0.06769049912691116, -0.048183489590883255, 0.02198972925543785, 0.04879843816161156, 0.015301763080060482, -0.057315658777952194, 0.004925726447254419, -0.008403435349464417, -0.005743685178458691, -0.05478238686919212, -0.00559008726850152, 0.0018201193306595087, -0.021594321355223656, -0.05343284085392952, -0.004631166346371174, -0.041659075766801834, 0.07002510130405426, 0.04871143773198128, 0.1178821250796318, -0.0920698270201683, -0.01763997972011566, 0.04547920823097229, -0.036947544664144516, 0.00045029574539512396, -0.014564345590770245, 0.007445046212524176, 0.014355998486280441, 0.02010560967028141, -0.05876987800002098, -0.036854565143585205, 0.02950950711965561, -0.046256475150585175, -0.015137887559831142, 0.042598895728588104, -0.0044513875618577, 0.06739698350429535, -0.00560535304248333, 0.018034065142273903, 0.055124737322330475, 0.030494172126054764, -0.07875821739435196, -0.09881346672773361, -0.05383296683430672, 0.01867734268307686, 0.06310770660638809, -0.031841475516557693, -0.004344040062278509, -0.10399653017520905, 0.01872585341334343, 0.009600857272744179, 0.019015472382307053, -0.0262396689504385, -0.014124608598649502, 0.07976961880922318, -0.036374036222696304, 0.06858936697244644, 0.0641305223107338, -0.02721855789422989, 0.012261136434972286, 0.04394349455833435, 0.008586601354181767, 0.006667991168797016, 0.02440214529633522, 0.05009855329990387, 0.036864519119262695, -0.03297305479645729, 0.026169130578637123, -0.014274616725742817, -0.018140509724617004, -0.059529777616262436, -0.05349274352192879, -0.03302532806992531, -0.035503871738910675, -0.0244655292481184, -0.0684039443731308, 0.06919852644205093, 0.05320284143090248, 0.07062814384698868, 0.028327371925115585, 0.03250626474618912, 0.04720311239361763, -0.08119087666273117, -0.046958766877651215, -0.004832389298826456, 0.07687468081712723, 0.03751615434885025, 0.015861134976148605, -0.0008222382166422904, -0.053161557763814926, -0.020577816292643547, 0.04506717994809151, -0.021293463185429573, 0.028942624107003212, -0.07448064535856247, -0.05134858936071396, -0.042986877262592316, -0.017795151099562645, -0.022850362583994865, -0.026734735816717148, -0.03219295293092728, -0.004226224031299353, 0.006238712463527918, -0.03329085931181908, 0.06578212976455688, -0.04824189096689224, -0.06636655330657959, -0.005974182393401861, -0.054895151406526566, 0.012658979743719101, -0.013020172715187073, 0.034380823373794556, -0.04973176494240761, 0.052040956914424896, 0.07637471705675125, 0.0001316383422818035, -0.03629691153764725, 0.04010356590151787, -0.0017956455703824759, 0.03151598945260048, -0.00701801385730505, -0.02066798135638237, -0.0028658455703407526, 0.06933790445327759, -0.015184173360466957, 0.05317426472902298, -0.02222585864365101, 0.08786489814519882, -0.019937997683882713, 0.06246383115649223, 0.008323648013174534, 0.02669207938015461, -0.0027051237411797047, -0.025815783068537712, 0.04702572897076607, 0.019925599917769432, 0.013794410042464733, 0.045555662363767624, 0.0006507489015348256, -0.06892123073339462, -0.02419901266694069, -0.00030025735031813383, 0.0027255192399024963, -0.04963308572769165, -0.017704393714666367, -0.027377333492040634, 0.0971834659576416, 0.007726828567683697, -0.005375722888857126, -0.046739209443330765, 0.00016187063010875136, 0.035673368722200394, 0.13993552327156067, 0.08378390967845917, -0.023850083351135254, -0.0748840719461441, -0.01261775754392147, -0.05538628622889519, 0.0008607230265624821, -0.012048622593283653, 0.033098526298999786, -0.09723608940839767, -0.0664619505405426, -0.008878407999873161, 0.016104979440569878, 0.025196406990289688, -0.021406449377536774, 0.010119957849383354, 0.022629059851169586, 0.020521381869912148, -0.05203951895236969, 0.05675766244530678, 0.01970384642481804, 0.027782607823610306, 0.011593719944357872, -0.027329344302415848, -0.008190054446458817, -0.06992444396018982, 0.06082746013998985, 0.056220076978206635, 0.0115206902846694, 0.014427593909204006, 0.03013475053012371, -0.002071922644972801, 0.033090438693761826, 0.0543154776096344, -0.009649286046624184, 0.09071529656648636, -0.027985209599137306, -0.004374312702566385, -0.10728772729635239, -0.0018350753234699368, -0.06108465790748596, 0.025103414431214333, 0.0036538715939968824, 0.03909403830766678, -0.07273218035697937, 0.015753155574202538, -0.020853785797953606, -0.06831640750169754, -0.010377077385783195, 0.020659156143665314, 0.03615759685635567, 0.09189494699239731, 0.00767013942822814, 0.05575422942638397, 0.1062328964471817, 0.052463993430137634, -0.0010959834326058626, -0.003823417704552412, -0.06416982412338257, -0.05376945808529854, 0.021440163254737854, 0.009581522084772587, -0.01787852868437767, -0.07708683609962463, 0.04441408812999725, -0.02261078916490078, -0.027355356141924858, -0.1054496020078659, 0.033126894384622574, 0.049478162080049515, -0.04648802429437637, 0.024836748838424683, -0.0320158526301384, 0.004260227084159851, 0.01721695251762867, 0.009996812790632248, -0.035194624215364456, 0.007978217676281929, -0.07187320291996002, 0.008374173194169998, 0.047098446637392044, -0.05930091440677643, 0.07891834527254105, -0.12339798361063004, 0.011324167251586914, 0.05480049178004265, 0.01692919246852398, -0.04553386941552162, 0.053941644728183746, 0.056460972875356674, 0.053985148668289185, 0.027150344103574753, -0.03873235732316971, -0.02015318162739277, -0.009587385691702366, 0.03434201329946518, -0.03949252516031265, 0.04200847074389458, 0.042292945086956024, -0.01696903258562088, 0.025251857936382294, 0.0672750473022461, -0.00708803441375494, 0.034923963248729706, 0.04112756624817848, 0.04626394063234329, 0.030383678153157234, -0.042561840265989304, 0.04132926091551781, -0.019541442394256592, 0.03629579395055771, 0.044202324002981186, 0.043245598673820496, -0.041169047355651855, -0.0706646740436554, -0.02962600253522396, -0.07197665423154831, 0.003296553622931242 ]
97
97
On Kernelization of Supervised Mahalanobis Distance Learners
This paper focuses on the problem of kernelizing an existing supervised Mahalanobis distance learner. The following features are included in the paper. Firstly, three popular learners, namely, "neighborhood component analysis", "large margin nearest neighbors" and "discriminant neighborhood embedding", which do not have kernel versions are kernelized in order to improve their classification performances. Secondly, an alternative kernelization framework called "KPCA trick" is presented. Implementing a learner in the new framework gains several advantages over the standard framework, e.g. no mathematical formulas and no reprogramming are required for a kernel implementation, the framework avoids troublesome problems such as singularity, etc. Thirdly, while the truths of representer theorems are just assumptions in previous papers related to ours, here, representer theorems are formally proven. The proofs validate both the kernel trick and the KPCA trick in the context of Mahalanobis distance learning. Fourthly, unlike previous works which always apply brute force methods to select a kernel, we investigate two approaches which can be efficiently adopted to construct an appropriate kernel for a given dataset. Finally, numerical results on various real-world datasets are presented.
[ 0.019405821338295937, -0.08349848538637161, 0.047812946140766144, -0.06415844708681107, -0.023588920012116432, -0.08040725439786911, 0.021049248054623604, -0.001867478247731924, -0.08483665436506271, 0.02846166118979454, 0.01492062583565712, 0.03400604426860809, -0.028298232704401016, 0.03672861307859421, 0.011839737184345722, 0.025171630084514618, 0.050618868321180344, -0.019840767607092857, 0.04909791052341461, -0.06481941789388657, -0.003132737474516034, -0.026698697358369827, -0.032885678112506866, -0.05205865576863289, 0.006560780107975006, 0.03570156544446945, -0.013456849381327629, -0.03170091286301613, -0.01548024546355009, 0.0050054630264639854, -0.004262630827724934, -0.005393877159804106, 0.03563649207353592, 0.04240007326006889, -0.03556482121348381, -0.019126536324620247, 0.04935601353645325, 0.034856196492910385, -0.0851018875837326, 0.0034654876217246056, 0.006540697067975998, -0.02677738666534424, 0.012739484198391438, -0.0017122209537774324, -0.02584129571914673, 0.05170507729053497, -0.011595332995057106, 0.02485022507607937, 0.001557037583552301, 0.05410178750753403, -0.053186651319265366, 0.011740082874894142, -0.05574902519583702, 0.007154312450438738, -0.04904286190867424, -0.006191939581185579, -0.04221436381340027, -0.06649652868509293, -0.030588073655962944, 0.011417516507208347, 0.065198615193367, 0.06070868298411369, -0.018301742151379585, 0.004887761082500219, 0.046626895666122437, -0.017532076686620712, 0.000054620129958493635, -0.012326300144195557, 0.013600423000752926, -0.08049693703651428, -0.01415394339710474, -0.059268128126859665, 0.029362844303250313, 0.06818043440580368, 0.024010250344872475, 0.009619130752980709, -0.07206407189369202, 0.028403151780366898, 0.04388172924518585, 0.09874337911605835, 0.02746441960334778, 0.0048538497649133205, 0.053162671625614166, 0.01930709183216095, 0.010619043372571468, 0.009704588912427425, -0.04070059582591057, 0.003580347402021289, -0.03144334629178047, 0.02615487575531006, 0.011826022528111935, 0.04463627189397812, -0.06737745553255081, -0.04634861275553703, -0.015572343952953815, -0.02237340249121189, -0.03788766264915466, -0.05590851977467537, 0.06695246696472168, 0.045012544840574265, -0.019506296142935753, 0.05566352978348732, 0.028659062460064888, 0.09757261723279953, 0.013616710901260376, 0.046712882816791534, -0.022160163149237633, 0.01660827361047268, -0.053263403475284576, 0.004059630911797285, 0.008990410715341568, -0.04890093207359314, 0.009294346906244755, -0.014800362288951874, -0.0745907872915268, 0.08029170334339142, -0.030909795314073563, 0.10708746314048767, 0.030208397656679153, 0.042925793677568436, -0.038611866533756256, -0.005881249904632568, -0.043409109115600586, -0.0249323770403862, 0.0392911434173584, -0.02349664457142353, -0.012421845458447933, -0.05143292248249054, 0.10570695251226425, -0.0009710828890092671, -0.08145038038492203, 0.03331204503774643, -0.010733059607446194, -0.05842652544379234, -0.10931182652711868, -0.008244622498750687, 0.040974538773298264, -0.04604966193437576, -0.08347401767969131, 0.07657649368047714, -0.03512826934456825, -0.013316302560269833, 0.0074998061172664165, -0.021896077319979668, 0.052130088210105896, -0.012554804794490337, -0.053199056535959244, -0.02923767827451229, 0.0790226086974144, -0.07298868894577026, -0.023661945015192032, -0.037859831005334854, -0.01357567310333252, -0.0010060579515993595, 0.07087281346321106, -0.09134812653064728, 0.008525154553353786, -0.012687083333730698, 0.04178545996546745, 0.06679820269346237, 0.0007803309126757085, 0.010164833627641201, -0.03230416402220726, 0.02436874434351921, 0.0016169676091521978, -0.027930518612265587, -0.0385209284722805, -0.03659118711948395, 0.010796995833516121, -0.05103135481476784, -0.02695484459400177, 0.006283709779381752, -0.009253403171896935, -0.02278321608901024, 0.022392867133021355, -0.04458994045853615, -0.005947587545961142, -0.021062778308987617, 0.013315181247889996, -0.03434671461582184, 0.010675881989300251, 0.025992533192038536, 0.0067539457231760025, 0.014971575699746609, 0.0405082032084465, 0.04965272918343544, 0.05648193880915642, 0.0012988329399377108, 0.049855031073093414, 0.04450950399041176, 0.07458549737930298, -0.03608137369155884, 0.02477261610329151, -0.05512475594878197, -0.018988147377967834, 0.04588590934872627, -0.017234759405255318, -0.06761982291936874, 0.047342412173748016, 0.058901939541101456, 0.04322071373462677, -0.021485866978764534, -0.07962601631879807, -0.057475052773952484, -0.026692679151892662, 0.034859322011470795, 0.06710207462310791, -0.02861499972641468, -0.022859694436192513, -0.03797498345375061, -0.04120896756649017, 0.04198261722922325, 0.022919535636901855, -0.014374337159097195, -0.04410039633512497, -0.09275314211845398, -0.0005510235205292702, -0.023486055433750153, 0.05090150609612465, 0.04933542758226395, -0.06416817009449005, 0.017082510516047478, -0.06362590193748474, 0.06737039983272552, -0.035444170236587524, 0.02018255926668644, -0.003225873224437237, -0.04288077354431152, -0.060297198593616486, 0.024709738790988922, -0.013085061684250832, -0.06269847601652145, 0.015123216435313225, -0.09846388548612595, -0.005624530371278524, 0.02290588617324829, -0.08719152957201004, 0.003602581098675728, 0.012538539245724678, -0.012370207346975803, 0.0006744696293026209, 0.019161103293299675, 0.014875438064336777, -0.016210518777370453, -0.04450481757521629, -0.02237221971154213, 0.008083195425570011, 0.03224825859069824, -0.005005426239222288, -0.044334448873996735, -0.02282683737576008, 0.023376988247036934, 0.02177436836063862, -0.025295469909906387, -0.008086174726486206, -0.011704448610544205, -0.04265806823968887, 0.0074867852963507175, 0.013891469687223434, 0.04941527545452118, 0.026036351919174194, 0.03418896719813347, -0.011362715624272823, -0.01292511261999607, 0.10717993229627609, -0.03409924730658531, 0.007652237080037594, 0.03340660408139229, -0.02711758017539978, 0.018848145380616188, 0.02100973017513752, -0.0972558930516243, -0.030007408931851387, 0.07008235901594162, -0.044922132045030594, 0.027698736637830734, 0.028823796659708023, 0.024259109050035477, -0.01714789681136608, -0.08564866334199905, -0.04979294165968895, 0.02061317302286625, 0.00033297608024440706, -0.028887586668133736, -0.040142085403203964, -0.050795912742614746, 0.029021231457591057, -0.029917694628238678, 0.048333726823329926, 0.05858335271477699, -0.07189931720495224, 0.041145678609609604, -0.03361690416932106, -0.048135705292224884, 0.04447147622704506, -0.07609591633081436, 0.07219111174345016, -0.024777958169579506, 0.048864565789699554, -0.02362409420311451, 0.044674914330244064, 0.042395107448101044, 0.010610009543597698, 0.0075418055057525635, 0.021734898909926414, 0.04381181299686432, 0.10337397456169128, 0.01653437130153179, -0.02951018325984478, -0.0031062604393810034, 0.07709585875272751, 0.010583482682704926, -0.010123403742909431, 0.033963918685913086, 0.04711160063743591, -0.019876813516020775, 0.04837115854024887, 0.01528477668762207, -0.00033848441671580076, 0.02367224730551243, 0.058799900114536285, 0.03542182967066765, 0.027558589354157448, -0.01832979917526245, -0.0969938412308693, 0.005474921781569719, 0.007639954797923565, 0.006294364109635353, -0.15557213127613068, -0.03480242192745209, -0.0446728877723217, -0.025637967512011528, -0.06063505634665489, 0.02758868783712387, -0.00596683518961072, 0.026363736018538475, -0.06742081791162491, 0.00033294493914581835, -0.042324647307395935, -0.025600159540772438, -0.08346597850322723, -0.08290930092334747, -0.003218456171452999, 0.015367100946605206, 0.002256989711895585, 0.04012579843401909, 0.020458830520510674, -0.022944923490285873, -0.03962887451052666, 0.05780116841197014, -0.07161788642406464, 0.05032265931367874, -0.05793215334415436, 0.014394710771739483, -0.04558670148253441, 0.10287873446941376, 0.09015065431594849, -0.06085088104009628, 0.005533963907510042, -0.04512074217200279, 0.06148746609687805, 0.06398425251245499, -0.04927876219153404, 0.09867595881223679, -0.03729519248008728, 0.023060819134116173, -0.052014466375112534, -0.022992057725787163, -0.029307236894965172, -0.04359963908791542, 0.009436490945518017, -0.030274149030447006, 0.07176624983549118, -0.00085098558338359, 0.05368572100996971, -0.0191295575350523, 0.03843246027827263, 0.0007096373592503369, 0.007049777545034885, 0.0373522974550724, -0.046835802495479584, 0.07771461457014084, 0.013090711086988449, 0.031950581818819046, -0.05015915632247925, -0.051073912531137466, 0.010892348363995552, 0.04608374089002609, 0.034045349806547165, 0.029508167877793312, -0.02174869179725647, -0.05152673274278641, 0.014013498090207577, 0.0690612718462944, 0.007919560186564922, -0.03441111743450165, 0.04869680851697922, -0.002010850701481104, -0.02067813277244568, -0.002502076793462038, -0.005858197342604399, 0.028014816343784332, 0.022333895787596703, -0.06742218881845474, -0.05014587193727493, 0.011748871766030788, -0.0463043637573719, 0.07937216758728027, -0.03921544551849365, -0.019191768020391464, 0.07090380787849426, 0.00676287617534399, -0.060791149735450745, -0.01728314720094204, 0.028189396485686302, 0.06612458825111389, -0.03873793035745621, -0.10744722187519073, 0.062303464859724045, -0.13267743587493896, 0.002526176394894719, 0.024326888844370842, 0.03837161511182785, -0.01763344369828701, -0.03849935531616211, 0.04372314363718033, 0.05428353697061539, 0.06047430634498596, 0.09407499432563782, 0.03441264480352402, -0.0009859106503427029, 0.016748087480664253, -0.06965450197458267, -0.04858651012182236, 0.09927379339933395, 0.015578990802168846, 0.053764160722494125, -0.0020936508662998676, -0.0006160384509712458, 0.04299807548522949, -0.002754051936790347, 0.013849026523530483, 0.02806892804801464, -0.020409807562828064, -0.0396270677447319, 0.10214978456497192, 0.009343019686639309, -0.0024156179279088974, 0.05437447503209114, 0.013578694313764572, 0.010784300975501537, -0.01611173152923584, 0.08189205825328827, -0.05911560356616974, 0.031786996871232986, -0.014726676978170872, 0.018879961222410202, -0.06800142675638199, -0.027966877445578575, -0.03538711369037628, 0.014783038757741451, 0.005845759063959122, -0.04324909299612045, 0.007646382320672274, -0.07598456740379333, 0.05049389228224754, 0.032005228102207184, 0.014908196404576302, -0.0008623760077171028, 0.03656885772943497, -0.09130778908729553, -0.002888611052185297, 0.006052467506378889, -0.017279386520385742, -0.0004996665520593524, -0.0567883662879467, -0.031015170738101006, 0.010610357858240604, -0.025604955852031708, -0.016785863786935806, -0.01676449179649353, -0.02381543256342411, -0.03893940523266792, 0.03628212958574295, 0.0820855051279068, 0.0027698783669620752, 0.041373103857040405, 0.006199592724442482, 0.03338303416967392, -0.043303925544023514, 0.017145032063126564, 0.04934660717844963, -0.02784482017159462, -0.0029118277598172426, -0.03217018023133278, 0.014874310232698917, -0.013862282037734985, -0.051311980932950974, -0.002022061962634325, 0.037589915096759796, -0.033216822892427444, -0.03854205086827278, 0.041760969907045364, -0.011851759627461433, 0.10848984867334366, 0.00882100872695446, 0.029080867767333984, -0.010286148637533188, 0.019939744845032692, 0.10584977269172668, -0.06405002623796463, -0.02083708718419075 ]
98
98
Isotropic PCA and Affine-Invariant Clustering
We present a new algorithm for clustering points in R^n. The key property of the algorithm is that it is affine-invariant, i.e., it produces the same partition for any affine transformation of the input. It has strong guarantees when the input is drawn from a mixture model. For a mixture of two arbitrary Gaussians, the algorithm correctly classifies the sample assuming only that the two components are separable by a hyperplane, i.e., there exists a halfspace that contains most of one Gaussian and almost none of the other in probability mass. This is nearly the best possible, improving known results substantially. For k > 2 components, the algorithm requires only that there be some (k-1)-dimensional subspace in which the emoverlap in every direction is small. Here we define overlap to be the ratio of the following two quantities: 1) the average squared distance between a point and the mean of its component, and 2) the average squared distance between a point and the mean of the mixture. The main result may also be stated in the language of linear discriminant analysis: if the standard Fisher discriminant is small enough, labels are not needed to estimate the optimal subspace for projection. Our main tools are isotropic transformation, spectral projection and a simple reweighting technique. We call this combination isotropic PCA.
[ 0.004707605578005314, 0.028187284246087074, 0.07089603692293167, 0.04491038620471954, 0.013271019794046879, 0.004280749708414078, -0.014387650415301323, -0.04090997949242592, -0.028897561132907867, 0.025896592065691948, 0.009935745038092136, -0.02169528417289257, -0.032055821269750595, 0.11079465597867966, -0.02909882366657257, 0.05433012917637825, -0.02538488246500492, 0.04749540239572525, -0.021563785150647163, -0.034564681351184845, -0.015242379158735275, -0.0020028024446219206, -0.027664272114634514, 0.011915726587176323, 0.014153470285236835, -0.0020766956731677055, -0.008888001553714275, -0.020048838108778, -0.05045374110341072, 0.05211549252271652, -0.022396093234419823, 0.001680436311289668, 0.019714703783392906, 0.008812828920781612, 0.012061174027621746, -0.006821724120527506, -0.028576133772730827, 0.031110528856515884, -0.05333106964826584, -0.05431194603443146, -0.024579595774412155, 0.015485615469515324, -0.0007064509554766119, -0.00682569295167923, -0.013998015783727169, 0.00625636288896203, -0.005054012406617403, 0.025653427466750145, -0.0043939752504229546, 0.03308796137571335, -0.07697439938783646, 0.05458265542984009, -0.05041298642754555, -0.018790606409311295, -0.0045579965226352215, -0.008841151371598244, -0.0030694559682160616, 0.06600704044103622, -0.025407563894987106, -0.04876873269677162, 0.10451828688383102, 0.08866876363754272, -0.034799981862306595, 0.03365349769592285, -0.0004907891270704567, -0.10603423416614532, -0.05605057626962662, -0.023659978061914444, -0.041854631155729294, -0.06658172607421875, -0.03593048080801964, -0.00177378102671355, 0.04648091271519661, 0.06612393260002136, -0.028774335980415344, 0.044837579131126404, 0.031138699501752853, -0.04338677600026131, -0.029449766501784325, 0.08096317201852798, 0.01564418151974678, -0.04735463857650757, -0.020278384909033775, -0.021850714460015297, -0.08750828355550766, 0.033091410994529724, 0.028087150305509567, -0.032025035470724106, 0.0049062264151871204, -0.030521078035235405, -0.019527185708284378, -0.03375842422246933, -0.09079262614250183, 0.03649917244911194, -0.05414586141705513, 0.026826510205864906, -0.0030899550765752792, -0.08071860671043396, 0.004972126800566912, 0.1043187826871872, -0.03036593645811081, 0.06012076139450073, 0.08738178759813309, 0.0783459022641182, 0.023552794009447098, 0.03453677147626877, -0.08910121768712997, 0.039648234844207764, -0.02613695152103901, -0.020464356988668442, -0.007084538694471121, -0.02435746230185032, 0.01798669807612896, 0.008838978596031666, -0.023379776626825333, 0.044551782310009, 0.01128918956965208, 0.11981997638940811, 0.025733374059200287, 0.05827037990093231, -0.0007002096972428262, 0.01363601814955473, -0.021400989964604378, 0.0022201838437467813, 0.0022374975960701704, 0.05195268243551254, -0.056415122002363205, -0.03661293908953667, 0.1036323681473732, -0.0561593696475029, -0.13315343856811523, 0.009447136893868446, -0.03578448295593262, -0.035262007266283035, -0.092104971408844, 0.007625843398272991, -0.011145382188260555, 0.004303465597331524, 0.008997024968266487, 0.09078077971935272, -0.020594898611307144, -0.07381673902273178, -0.0051772138103842735, -0.003281609620898962, 0.102835513651371, -0.029893197119235992, -0.006148625165224075, 0.0425763837993145, 0.04320305585861206, 0.027109073475003242, -0.042287759482860565, -0.01051296480000019, 0.01257318165153265, 0.042527806013822556, 0.04689853638410568, -0.029695730656385422, -0.022056201472878456, 0.012980980798602104, -0.02090473473072052, 0.0328635610640049, -0.07960660755634308, 0.03892732784152031, -0.010082668624818325, -0.010217608883976936, 0.017519967630505562, 0.037708599120378494, -0.00760647002607584, -0.07381276041269302, -0.02336801588535309, -0.032355401664972305, -0.008272889070212841, 0.005771717522293329, -0.043888743966817856, -0.019933974370360374, 0.011135677807033062, -0.010545182973146439, -0.020295601338148117, -0.025317059829831123, -0.06022258847951889, -0.035665545612573624, 0.028914814814925194, 0.00005044723002356477, 0.006222948431968689, 0.07008139044046402, -0.02479628100991249, 0.09180745482444763, -0.000810148601885885, 0.012867147102952003, 0.07692720741033554, 0.07069354504346848, 0.03767978772521019, 0.034123461693525314, 0.030377892777323723, -0.07301800698041916, -0.0473746620118618, 0.04412374645471573, -0.020995590835809708, -0.039645370095968246, 0.043649621307849884, 0.06350135058164597, 0.045348089188337326, 0.045533329248428345, -0.07222999632358551, -0.06237657740712166, -0.0447351299226284, 0.01047925278544426, 0.06391174346208572, -0.014170661568641663, 0.04629421979188919, -0.10312982648611069, 0.030301768332719803, -0.02448432333767414, 0.026402609422802925, -0.03672312945127487, -0.03176737576723099, 0.004102728795260191, -0.04147801548242569, -0.07501419633626938, 0.034449394792318344, 0.029977427795529366, -0.03796748071908951, 0.02716919593513012, -0.06625591218471527, 0.07628251612186432, -0.053868480026721954, 0.06819586455821991, 0.054801344871520996, -0.004829052835702896, -0.08352748304605484, 0.021771568804979324, -0.052262455224990845, 0.0029300167225301266, -0.01130919624119997, -0.015370282344520092, -0.010421525686979294, 0.029219724237918854, -0.03914441540837288, 0.01272849552333355, -0.0030432543717324734, -0.016015751287341118, -0.005776059813797474, 0.06561572104692459, 0.023962223902344704, -0.027382442727684975, -0.05645126476883888, -0.009596874937415123, 0.038405027240514755, 0.1342010498046875, 0.031656648963689804, 0.10906834155321121, -0.01748410053551197, 0.015235237777233124, 0.014433303847908974, -0.02068602479994297, 0.030366938561201096, 0.017273951321840286, -0.003425166942179203, 0.02208695560693741, 0.05490981414914131, 0.08907826244831085, 0.012689630500972271, 0.05588746815919876, -0.013349789194762707, -0.0768553614616394, 0.102230504155159, 0.04199913889169693, -0.002249697223305702, -0.008159011602401733, -0.0329463854432106, 0.01408891100436449, 0.006627797149121761, -0.08397603780031204, -0.022036857903003693, 0.06450205296278, 0.002493790816515684, -0.03043757751584053, -0.00882777851074934, 0.06653054058551788, -0.022176936268806458, -0.018988002091646194, -0.059973202645778656, 0.022400161251425743, 0.014021283946931362, -0.033469587564468384, -0.0031554594170302153, 0.006167273037135601, 0.031185589730739594, -0.028468146920204163, -0.021444888785481453, 0.05958643555641174, -0.0039010823238641024, 0.06223364174365997, -0.06101386994123459, -0.012354372069239616, -0.0009358400711789727, -0.056597255170345306, 0.04943912476301193, 0.07708105444908142, 0.04231796786189079, -0.03698398172855377, -0.000051782397349597886, -0.013955107890069485, -0.0056633721105754375, 0.039234548807144165, 0.02762412466108799, 0.016444602981209755, 0.13688699901103973, 0.05665771663188934, -0.05579964444041252, 0.016078950837254524, -0.021251872181892395, -0.03712060675024986, 0.020716451108455658, -0.01777723990380764, -0.013522337190806866, 0.015035183168947697, -0.005502915941178799, 0.003664543153718114, -0.017476698383688927, 0.022968413308262825, 0.09370243549346924, -0.005789975170046091, 0.05631794035434723, -0.07243087887763977, -0.04054626449942589, -0.0346316434442997, 0.07563416659832001, 0.019381428137421608, -0.08619755506515503, 0.0107311075553298, -0.037904392927885056, -0.025374194607138634, -0.03878358006477356, 0.06737600266933441, 0.0051757534965872765, -0.05483274161815643, 0.0003702667891047895, -0.005430400371551514, 0.006866790819913149, -0.02137528359889984, 0.015617039985954762, -0.01615649089217186, 0.011163981631398201, -0.008460928685963154, -0.043302468955516815, 0.045558080077171326, 0.026920713484287262, -0.044437699019908905, -0.03689795359969139, 0.004889416508376598, -0.12308460474014282, 0.07570280134677887, -0.057216744869947433, 0.03484007343649864, 0.007594837807118893, 0.09538417309522629, 0.09105580300092697, 0.007177138701081276, 0.011369542218744755, 0.004205103497952223, 0.015279904939234257, 0.039068009704351425, -0.019534731283783913, 0.05699330195784569, 0.026269642636179924, 0.06761985272169113, -0.022380895912647247, 0.019375789910554886, -0.04691016301512718, -0.03322603926062584, 0.05162303149700165, -0.012882787734270096, 0.01779639534652233, 0.01371648721396923, 0.007279085461050272, -0.012510129250586033, 0.02579873986542225, -0.06487486511468887, 0.0145657854154706, 0.017592748627066612, 0.025522230193018913, -0.004044169094413519, -0.03666747733950615, 0.012496165931224823, 0.001666117343120277, 0.03728514909744263, 0.013933454640209675, 0.058193400502204895, -0.009217068552970886, 0.04263034090399742, 0.023359250277280807, -0.03719528391957283, 0.06837043166160583, 0.0626496821641922, 0.04100802168250084, 0.036690983921289444, 0.025809962302446365, 0.0015809377655386925, 0.034247174859046936, -0.030643360689282417, 0.03399970009922981, -0.014167184010148048, -0.021714869886636734, -0.08592287451028824, -0.059861280024051666, 0.05111607536673546, -0.014937187545001507, 0.0609036348760128, -0.04253818094730377, 0.044137775897979736, 0.03464458882808685, 0.0015317372744902968, -0.05390814691781998, 0.0213177427649498, 0.04739440977573395, -0.0399627685546875, -0.022723395377397537, 0.01666233129799366, 0.045213885605335236, -0.05208945646882057, -0.01591724529862404, 0.002997815841808915, 0.027318455278873444, -0.04769814386963844, 0.019124018028378487, 0.04958018660545349, 0.058338314294815063, 0.005043058656156063, 0.08449410647153854, 0.08924825489521027, -0.013491250574588776, -0.021604124456644058, -0.023243406787514687, 0.014526799321174622, 0.1329955905675888, -0.05287666246294975, 0.023917339742183685, -0.07076498866081238, 0.033119987696409225, -0.030975455418229103, -0.05957537144422531, 0.03144450858235359, -0.058214861899614334, 0.011611555702984333, -0.0511266253888607, 0.06599163264036179, 0.06777767091989517, -0.01622205227613449, 0.04021202400326729, 0.03882504999637604, -0.004659999627619982, 0.05694684758782387, 0.028000198304653168, -0.01945551298558712, 0.027418002486228943, 0.034543540328741074, 0.010629511438310146, -0.057228121906518936, 0.005452234763652086, -0.10858982801437378, -0.03581453859806061, -0.03422308713197708, -0.020633850246667862, 0.013473703525960445, -0.04994964972138405, -0.029147136956453323, 0.005153190344572067, 0.027404557913541794, 0.007622254081070423, 0.013752537779510021, -0.045926064252853394, 0.033248502761125565, 0.028179990127682686, -0.035060815513134, 0.04454401507973671, 0.010072286240756512, -0.001910177175886929, -0.00016594934277236462, 0.027600426226854324, -0.0152120441198349, 0.030042529106140137, -0.06166400387883186, -0.023352893069386482, 0.024421654641628265, 0.041069984436035156, 0.013130693696439266, -0.029290886595845222, 0.03189470246434212, 0.018677081912755966, -0.005830226931720972, 0.0390414223074913, 0.05265190452337265, -0.05429590493440628, -0.01684536412358284, -0.009052840992808342, 0.03421090170741081, -0.0023469259031116962, 0.04304930567741394, -0.009909543208777905, -0.009081968106329441, -0.02166764996945858, -0.09904103726148605, 0.07594168931245804, -0.043697625398635864, 0.011821526102721691, 0.027834920212626457, 0.08780369162559509, -0.03307267650961876, -0.05134803056716919, 0.08833064138889313, 0.026784932240843773, 0.022352011874318123 ]
99
99
Multiple Random Oracles Are Better Than One
We study the problem of learning k-juntas given access to examples drawn from a number of different product distributions. Thus we wish to learn a function f : {-1,1}^n -> {-1,1} that depends on k (unknown) coordinates. While the best known algorithms for the general problem of learning a k-junta require running time of n^k * poly(n,2^k), we show that given access to k different product distributions with biases separated by \gamma>0, the functions may be learned in time poly(n,2^k,\gamma^{-k}). More generally, given access to t <= k different product distributions, the functions may be learned in time n^{k/t} * poly(n,2^k,\gamma^{-k}). Our techniques involve novel results in Fourier analysis relating Fourier expansions with respect to different biases and a generalization of Russo's formula.
[ -0.05608738586306572, 0.01877652481198311, 0.07922295480966568, -0.053514670580625534, 0.11132572591304779, -0.0381871797144413, -0.031235694885253906, 0.018840257078409195, 0.016212454065680504, 0.050380639731884, -0.056187424808740616, 0.010016612708568573, 0.028811771422624588, 0.09144590049982071, 0.029846148565411568, 0.009282553568482399, -0.0323040708899498, 0.015360555611550808, 0.008169707842171192, -0.02453514188528061, 0.03928341716527939, -0.012646600604057312, 0.0288448054343462, -0.01972399465739727, 0.052196402102708817, -0.030329449102282524, 0.025457654148340225, -0.011580721475183964, 0.042756445705890656, -0.017956450581550598, -0.06490492820739746, -0.05467725172638893, 0.0034540367778390646, 0.05498674511909485, -0.018605418503284454, -0.04150133952498436, 0.03870442509651184, 0.0057523795403540134, -0.04277430847287178, 0.0021160051692277193, 0.005132482387125492, 0.03100861795246601, 0.05380936339497566, 0.008309481665492058, 0.03159771114587784, 0.026106076315045357, 0.023935673758387566, -0.06901761889457703, -0.05538366362452507, 0.06864297389984131, -0.10478996485471725, 0.021059375256299973, -0.016475265845656395, -0.04696309193968773, 0.03713185712695122, 0.02661486528813839, 0.0412103645503521, 0.01923670619726181, -0.05038660764694214, -0.009362190961837769, 0.023548206314444542, 0.15173032879829407, 0.018817730247974396, -0.021623210981488228, 0.0020277209114283323, -0.017718898132443428, -0.08050181716680527, -0.028362108394503593, -0.018021199852228165, 0.0031424451153725386, 0.013393149711191654, -0.02728644572198391, 0.020874829962849617, 0.06346268951892853, 0.02413809671998024, 0.02345247007906437, 0.03304513916373253, 0.03987917676568031, -0.002384508727118373, 0.04915502667427063, -0.09076470881700516, 0.010601422749459743, -0.01669137552380562, -0.019189966842532158, -0.013332217931747437, 0.018116308376193047, 0.03384760394692421, -0.06683387607336044, -0.04839172586798668, 0.009927988052368164, -0.04267790913581848, -0.0032840038184076548, -0.09347739070653915, -0.01718192920088768, -0.05364891141653061, 0.05638042092323303, -0.015003976412117481, -0.009915806353092194, -0.005584188736975193, 0.012667657807469368, 0.0024033733643591404, -0.0004998502554371953, 0.09795822948217392, 0.09504571557044983, 0.05114085227251053, 0.021546708419919014, -0.022626904770731926, 0.004580607637763023, 0.023074336349964142, -0.044117894023656845, -0.005733013618737459, -0.01833638921380043, 0.018694352358579636, -0.010520369745790958, -0.03345664590597153, 0.04618348181247711, 0.0005002933903597295, 0.06966206431388855, 0.0470183901488781, 0.06474517285823822, -0.012204525992274284, -0.014798814430832863, 0.020996876060962677, 0.00837773084640503, 0.05936909094452858, -0.02932657115161419, 0.0522930808365345, -0.07754357159137726, 0.12331056594848633, 0.037430278956890106, -0.04528515785932541, 0.060804348438978195, 0.02102675288915634, -0.0075958361849188805, -0.029406342655420303, 0.040899235755205154, 0.015656115487217903, 0.04655543342232704, 0.027310891076922417, 0.011860760860145092, -0.02257297746837139, -0.062269389629364014, -0.051578816026449203, -0.04127867519855499, 0.015324593521654606, -0.019647426903247833, 0.0003914663102477789, 0.0015897805569693446, 0.012285486795008183, -0.022866610437631607, 0.03649989515542984, -0.01984836533665657, 0.015140886418521404, 0.07467414438724518, 0.07571379095315933, 0.07620852440595627, 0.044797856360673904, 0.06143684685230255, -0.02025023102760315, 0.07166790217161179, 0.005615426693111658, -0.024557359516620636, 0.025782760232686996, 0.04362989217042923, 0.08732681721448898, 0.00016073834558483213, -0.03103111870586872, -0.04743681848049164, 0.008015114814043045, -0.011971722356975079, -0.03497426584362984, -0.02693169377744198, -0.07403230667114258, -0.030393317341804504, 0.005487975664436817, 0.01769707351922989, -0.01390439085662365, -0.03553604334592819, -0.04940372332930565, -0.04281480982899666, -0.044175442308187485, -0.12575000524520874, -0.0303641464561224, 0.08119362592697144, 0.006482671480625868, 0.034425102174282074, -0.02908577024936676, -0.03611913323402405, 0.1177804246544838, 0.04720492660999298, 0.08518711477518082, 0.03017633780837059, 0.017610017210245132, 0.035317424684762955, -0.016416117548942566, 0.07177437096834183, 0.00901784747838974, -0.10917218029499054, -0.01609664037823677, 0.1514042317867279, 0.05388224869966507, 0.000890884140972048, -0.02394423447549343, -0.07334091514348984, -0.06775228679180145, 0.007637008558958769, 0.004229102749377489, -0.03698569908738136, 0.003654517699033022, -0.00043202514643780887, 0.017518742009997368, -0.0428198017179966, -0.02664644457399845, -0.027207328006625175, 0.028064705431461334, -0.07966279238462448, -0.048920098692178726, -0.060957059264183044, 0.040323641151189804, 0.05484483391046524, -0.04817704111337662, 0.02012859843671322, 0.04112060368061066, 0.035960011184215546, -0.06868880242109299, -0.0028732174541801214, -0.0023508623708039522, -0.015041975304484367, -0.03266456723213196, -0.06117422878742218, -0.05331913381814957, -0.025809073820710182, -0.013638594187796116, 0.017585514113307, -0.006833041086792946, 0.05589874088764191, -0.0322381854057312, -0.01286232564598322, -0.03344641625881195, 0.048251692205667496, 0.015262526459991932, 0.01627328433096409, -0.040480632334947586, -0.01902177184820175, -0.06244150921702385, -0.01704348437488079, 0.0722510814666748, 0.13437774777412415, 0.058192528784275055, -0.013901639729738235, -0.0017473518382757902, -0.050115685909986496, -0.06718158721923828, -0.013853206299245358, -0.0042482889257371426, 0.02828430011868477, -0.051149625331163406, -0.014884410426020622, 0.04010867699980736, -0.014855987392365932, -0.05172494798898697, -0.00762370228767395, -0.05866146832704544, -0.017745623365044594, 0.07189195603132248, 0.043931931257247925, -0.0038361407350748777, -0.01168685220181942, -0.06742557138204575, 0.059269051998853683, 0.08943600207567215, -0.09195821732282639, -0.010838409885764122, 0.0707562118768692, -0.05115363001823425, -0.048988088965415955, 0.01027214527130127, 0.005477285478264093, 0.03190167248249054, -0.024364052340388298, -0.02895406447350979, 0.027720129117369652, -0.07425115257501602, 0.047549642622470856, -0.01853627897799015, 0.009035919792950153, 0.009733560495078564, -0.07625433057546616, 0.029608434066176414, 0.031463053077459335, -0.0019456790760159492, 0.07022707909345627, -0.06932523101568222, 0.025205258280038834, -0.010846392251551151, -0.08550326526165009, 0.08166374266147614, -0.034766845405101776, -0.1046033501625061, -0.021000703796744347, -0.014028271660208702, -0.08835574239492416, -0.04889930039644241, 0.0131464758887887, 0.060992732644081116, 0.038747552782297134, 0.025776848196983337, 0.057339563965797424, -0.07471484690904617, 0.026553925126791, 0.05433650687336922, -0.057969093322753906, 0.024990078061819077, 0.02397475391626358, 0.044564854353666306, -0.001746608642861247, 0.03661391884088516, 0.04245830699801445, -0.0028616380877792835, 0.07129842042922974, 0.018085632473230362, -0.01648946851491928, -0.03584163635969162, -0.0528598390519619, 0.02573300711810589, -0.02766251377761364, -0.0018007262842729688, 0.002886534435674548, -0.062232524156570435, -0.014478160068392754, 0.00360710802488029, 0.015556694008409977, 0.03119458630681038, 0.08698732405900955, -0.04524025693535805, -0.03240831941366196, -0.012084425427019596, -0.004142405465245247, -0.021918199956417084, -0.021746128797531128, 0.0024090807419270277, -0.045954033732414246, -0.03118542954325676, -0.09226918965578079, 0.04118317365646362, 0.052172426134347916, 0.04628053307533264, 0.013238519430160522, -0.040960751473903656, 0.022855455055832863, -0.02465238980948925, -0.020493967458605766, 0.008308133110404015, -0.012489425018429756, -0.052628133445978165, 0.1001279354095459, 0.0508427768945694, -0.007453623693436384, -0.02028513327240944, -0.04847095534205437, -0.013166896067559719, 0.07595983892679214, -0.05971008911728859, -0.01931675896048546, 0.029234422370791435, 0.05281255766749382, 0.005415869876742363, -0.010454429313540459, -0.022434037178754807, 0.020115241408348083, -0.03737354651093483, -0.02675693668425083, 0.052059680223464966, 0.016874980181455612, -0.01895022764801979, -0.055774908512830734, 0.05504139885306358, -0.0436650775372982, 0.020925071090459824, -0.006807898636907339, 0.02820112742483616, -0.03651393949985504, -0.03639160096645355, -0.0259880181401968, -0.05552757531404495, -0.006333612836897373, -0.02456117980182171, 0.024589646607637405, 0.00007802086474839598, 0.015951815992593765, -0.07469327002763748, -0.0376601405441761, 0.01097945962101221, 0.011810804717242718, 0.017176415771245956, -0.0015164995566010475, 0.04728307947516441, -0.0166649017482996, -0.01151951402425766, -0.0689675509929657, 0.01748327910900116, -0.07238522171974182, -0.04921294003725052, -0.0667680874466896, -0.05865119770169258, 0.009741690941154957, 0.07527286559343338, 0.019677937030792236, -0.03333929181098938, 0.04554053768515587, -0.014611044898629189, -0.02631361410021782, -0.04162760078907013, 0.05999411270022392, -0.014892084524035454, 0.012883604504168034, -0.025475921109318733, -0.030114194378256798, -0.009781808592379093, -0.09876468777656555, -0.008815104141831398, -0.027468398213386536, 0.025487655773758888, -0.04710787534713745, -0.027178242802619934, -0.030188120901584625, 0.013673042878508568, 0.0197749063372612, -0.02812599204480648, 0.035546716302633286, -0.08211939036846161, -0.06250117719173431, -0.00048403633991256356, 0.011817513033747673, 0.013314739800989628, -0.013416099362075329, -0.014106486923992634, -0.0012684821849688888, 0.016759034246206284, -0.04105047509074211, -0.07049927115440369, -0.0534454807639122, 0.012740922160446644, -0.05391325056552887, 0.05952461063861847, 0.018840590491890907, 0.012525818310678005, -0.053341880440711975, 0.0317549966275692, 0.030676621943712234, 0.03078983537852764, -0.02762116678059101, 0.00053552066674456, -0.07006215304136276, -0.027367256581783295, 0.060896992683410645, -0.009984362870454788, 0.03419363498687744, 0.06226744130253792, 0.043854426592588425, -0.0003389497578609735, -0.057625412940979004, 0.02756229229271412, 0.06430324912071228, -0.06887177377939224, -0.03049420565366745, 0.07006943225860596, 0.03660663589835167, 0.01025136187672615, -0.06433426588773727, 0.012732266448438168, 0.028175001963973045, 0.009998896159231663, -0.09525749087333679, -0.03822297602891922, 0.02799556963145733, 0.0440870001912117, -0.07175126671791077, 0.04520147293806076, -0.00987674668431282, 0.04244691878557205, 0.0012242671800777316, -0.06459898501634598, 0.015409759245812893, 0.04006426781415939, 0.02943211793899536, 0.03138427808880806, 0.043470367789268494, 0.046027425676584244, 0.03453563526272774, -0.021511783823370934, 0.0008214349509216845, 0.04876081645488739, -0.011853032745420933, 0.02392537146806717, -0.02134397067129612, -0.0425073467195034, 0.0017318298341706395, 0.023151421919465065, 0.029182160273194313, 0.032544203102588654, -0.02848108671605587, 0.050925012677907944, 0.06353644281625748, -0.007282390724867582, 0.00099628372117877, 0.056244444102048874, -0.051501285284757614, -0.003953438252210617, 0.04514787718653679, 0.043060947209596634, 0.02801554463803768 ]