Unnamed: 0.1
int64
0
113k
Unnamed: 0
float64
0
113k
title
stringlengths
7
246
abstract
stringlengths
6
3.31k
embeddings
sequencelengths
512
512
100
100
Dependence Structure Estimation via Copula
Dependence strucuture estimation is one of the important problems in machine learning domain and has many applications in different scientific areas. In this paper, a theoretical framework for such estimation based on copula and copula entropy -- the probabilistic theory of representation and measurement of statistical dependence, is proposed. Graphical models are considered as a special case of the copula framework. A method of the framework for estimating maximum spanning copula is proposed. Due to copula, the method is irrelevant to the properties of individual variables, insensitive to outlier and able to deal with non-Gaussianity. Experiments on both simulated data and real dataset demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method.
[ -0.03248808905482292, -0.09225430339574814, 0.006254770327359438, -0.02561417780816555, -0.02370353229343891, -0.029088838025927544, 0.05980999395251274, -0.04308988153934479, -0.08351018279790878, 0.039394427090883255, 0.00457364646717906, -0.016622522845864296, -0.018381768837571144, 0.0471932627260685, -0.013577867299318314, -0.03267078846693039, 0.04246245324611664, -0.0486190989613533, 0.014874722808599472, -0.06816451251506805, -0.021577931940555573, 0.03391801193356514, -0.036800552159547806, -0.0886119082570076, 0.04371824860572815, -0.0524599626660347, 0.007296237628906965, -0.04399906098842621, -0.0817704126238823, -0.00971444696187973, -0.06130937114357948, 0.042206063866615295, 0.01067274808883667, -0.020011423155665398, -0.010694306343793869, 0.018693553283810616, -0.06252869963645935, -0.010135672986507416, -0.09052226692438126, 0.028431210666894913, 0.034773826599121094, -0.03275875747203827, 0.04180995747447014, -0.02903219684958458, 0.014552483335137367, 0.02992875874042511, 0.08049794286489487, -0.0082757119089365, 0.042406369000673294, 0.05868858844041824, -0.09409398585557938, -0.04728316515684128, -0.011038952507078648, -0.004149004351347685, -0.006282652262598276, 0.06172569841146469, -0.03642263635993004, 0.007498199585825205, 0.012803272344172001, -0.03249071538448334, -0.011432619765400887, 0.07661042362451553, 0.009680342860519886, 0.06060188263654709, -0.02878226339817047, 0.030425867065787315, -0.062042515724897385, -0.012057582847774029, -0.055730048567056656, -0.07631664723157883, -0.019301217049360275, -0.023671982809901237, 0.007969495840370655, 0.039293572306632996, 0.016040358692407608, -0.015639422461390495, -0.0054394397884607315, 0.006023511756211519, -0.032986558973789215, 0.07770877331495285, 0.005603970494121313, 0.06084192916750908, 0.008319207467138767, -0.037246234714984894, -0.004498650785535574, -0.0014812943991273642, -0.013200008310377598, -0.011589079163968563, 0.05043052136898041, 0.04388067498803139, 0.03800443187355995, 0.05350008234381676, -0.041882000863552094, 0.0643579438328743, -0.0566638708114624, 0.03718824312090874, -0.08802451938390732, -0.006953430362045765, -0.004270779434591532, 0.033463653177022934, 0.0004267426556907594, -0.03984358534216881, 0.08241430670022964, 0.03698686510324478, -0.04232637956738472, 0.029718628153204918, -0.018878592178225517, -0.045381098985672, 0.05009099841117859, -0.08027110993862152, 0.021646419540047646, -0.07808715850114822, -0.06350910663604736, -0.008203347213566303, -0.08453819155693054, 0.05888383090496063, -0.03226253762841225, 0.09218435734510422, 0.08111383020877838, 0.017166130244731903, 0.005533382296562195, -0.03383484110236168, 0.00643794285133481, 0.005974710453301668, 0.0015464421594515443, 0.018168486654758453, -0.028535177931189537, -0.050240594893693924, 0.10560628026723862, -0.0019270856864750385, -0.041898906230926514, 0.013583352789282799, -0.05131508409976959, 0.005032151006162167, -0.047824032604694366, 0.026584215462207794, -0.036695268005132675, -0.03833694010972977, -0.005929944571107626, 0.032513510435819626, 0.016564074903726578, -0.05558321997523308, 0.007633402477949858, -0.00685438048094511, 0.054870568215847015, 0.10979148000478745, -0.0014545870944857597, 0.024181615561246872, 0.0690012201666832, 0.024052970111370087, -0.015961771830916405, -0.07356461882591248, 0.027097444981336594, 0.0443098247051239, 0.06209055706858635, -0.06568475067615509, -0.028196483850479126, -0.012248423881828785, -0.04041999951004982, 0.06246429309248924, -0.06455006450414658, 0.012105496600270271, 0.023582980036735535, -0.0007819955353625119, -0.02090524695813656, -0.05628478154540062, -0.047216303646564484, -0.022884629666805267, -0.024865299463272095, -0.022775525227189064, -0.023413104936480522, 0.025388507172465324, -0.018581261858344078, 0.027624305337667465, 0.02728554792702198, -0.023960961028933525, -0.03320348262786865, -0.028188571333885193, 0.08702342957258224, -0.062068644911050797, 0.08445532619953156, 0.006310215685516596, 0.013193943537771702, 0.034305915236473083, 0.06260985881090164, 0.093805693089962, -0.020908037200570107, 0.03585546463727951, 0.051386233419179916, 0.03709199279546738, 0.058423541486263275, 0.02599913440644741, 0.016202092170715332, -0.03217656537890434, -0.04443962872028351, 0.037736356258392334, -0.06863391399383545, 0.02717503160238266, 0.015033516101539135, 0.044400472193956375, 0.06410136818885803, 0.03112826868891716, -0.06764574348926544, -0.041974376887083054, -0.12098619341850281, 0.02645009756088257, 0.014938266947865486, -0.0074900309555232525, -0.07314728200435638, -0.0020690455567091703, -0.009785240516066551, 0.0383470319211483, 0.005579076241701841, -0.04154888167977333, 0.021494094282388687, -0.022664429619908333, -0.06814658641815186, -0.08718954026699066, 0.07026135176420212, 0.05689007788896561, 0.011133209802210331, 0.0656159296631813, -0.012276627123355865, 0.006536934059113264, -0.05044996738433838, -0.029511503875255585, -0.042868442833423615, 0.04368594288825989, -0.08477368205785751, 0.0179580170661211, -0.0017113619251176715, -0.09054965525865555, -0.022791529074311256, -0.03381619602441788, 0.051242101937532425, 0.037782590836286545, -0.016678329557180405, 0.03696969524025917, -0.012758425436913967, 0.01951013319194317, -0.05274900794029236, 0.05482034012675285, 0.030770665034651756, 0.04270150139927864, -0.024333374574780464, -0.020318632945418358, 0.028696022927761078, 0.09518885612487793, -0.023045094683766365, 0.005856876727193594, -0.023215781897306442, -0.07391947507858276, -0.026331301778554916, -0.04252542927861214, 0.013560658320784569, 0.00672141881659627, -0.036702584475278854, 0.06709494441747665, 0.09515827149152756, 0.08216942101716995, -0.008008037693798542, 0.003143476089462638, -0.052959900349378586, -0.008620954118669033, 0.07911468297243118, 0.0035536792129278183, -0.029432976618409157, 0.03549915552139282, 0.026786478236317635, 0.011303896084427834, -0.0074147870764136314, 0.007217729464173317, -0.027557827532291412, 0.0580727756023407, -0.03964901342988014, 0.03099500946700573, 0.05912007391452789, 0.061570655554533005, -0.03228574991226196, -0.06531206518411636, -0.03858792781829834, 0.03243181109428406, -0.012687843292951584, 0.0041136061772704124, 0.02026507444679737, 0.012201706878840923, -0.0333409458398819, 0.042377326637506485, 0.025625573471188545, 0.011027086526155472, -0.005497552454471588, 0.07681192457675934, -0.06093532219529152, -0.034592464566230774, 0.0050718230195343494, -0.07245779037475586, 0.043426331132650375, 0.03833785653114319, 0.07571882009506226, 0.0353345163166523, -0.016379641368985176, 0.07685983926057816, 0.024039391428232193, -0.059285178780555725, 0.0437750481069088, 0.012460775673389435, 0.052109453827142715, 0.0344473235309124, -0.03292178735136986, -0.031614407896995544, 0.014842049218714237, -0.09738980978727341, -0.03125552833080292, -0.02365748956799507, -0.04240806773304939, -0.057734858244657516, -0.03796541690826416, -0.05136176571249962, -0.03756194934248924, -0.05412537232041359, -0.022139720618724823, -0.0221489779651165, -0.05619577690958977, -0.026605963706970215, -0.05187295749783516, 0.04208386689424515, 0.07090054452419281, 0.010929740034043789, -0.0599597692489624, -0.05917654559016228, -0.05704343691468239, -0.03518266603350639, -0.022505536675453186, 0.10441900044679642, -0.0695069283246994, -0.0219879113137722, -0.04804835468530655, 0.020308202132582664, 0.012589051388204098, -0.015463035553693771, -0.0786527544260025, -0.06138663738965988, -0.0075447396375238895, -0.01964767463505268, 0.020281435921788216, 0.06358105689287186, 0.09951473027467728, -0.04586223512887955, -0.008020495995879173, 0.007177817169576883, -0.1240919828414917, -0.057603027671575546, 0.014648190699517727, -0.002557985717430711, -0.007459758780896664, 0.01617560163140297, 0.07578302174806595, -0.017875565215945244, 0.00819302722811699, -0.002462435280904174, -0.014535806141793728, 0.029807526618242264, 0.049481652677059174, -0.002085539512336254, 0.04888990893959999, 0.05220150202512741, -0.04961998015642166, 0.02104046195745468, -0.031043071299791336, -0.04213125258684158, 0.03735702484846115, 0.03198159858584404, 0.044678594917058945, 0.008978559635579586, 0.046908192336559296, -0.02718595787882805, 0.021024106070399284, -0.05194675177335739, -0.020963529124855995, 0.020165100693702698, -0.023912539705634117, -0.03774881735444069, -0.08750460296869278, -0.015857845544815063, -0.023944949731230736, -0.032986320555210114, -0.0552980862557888, -0.009332191199064255, 0.025858601555228233, 0.03142814710736275, 0.0037287049926817417, -0.02716015838086605, 0.03481271490454674, -0.012743702158331871, 0.04802810028195381, 0.01638682745397091, 0.042795754969120026, -0.010116382502019405, -0.03107733279466629, -0.023946022614836693, -0.012919355183839798, -0.01952955313026905, 0.066648468375206, -0.0645577535033226, -0.0015815825900062919, -0.004954093601554632, -0.05488423630595207, 0.0426265224814415, -0.03505684435367584, 0.05222861096262932, 0.02771596796810627, 0.05465029180049896, -0.05773530527949333, -0.01850857026875019, 0.05137661471962929, 0.04904497414827347, 0.028262067586183548, 0.024261021986603737, -0.009917933493852615, -0.03033350594341755, 0.03087783418595791, -0.012254356406629086, -0.06864263862371445, 0.03703734278678894, 0.04515094682574272, -0.010892881080508232, 0.045302681624889374, 0.03652526065707207, 0.026252474635839462, 0.07314755767583847, -0.06296476721763611, -0.00004035019446746446, -0.09072068333625793, 0.006965477019548416, 0.021008409559726715, -0.046191487461328506, -0.03920741751790047, -0.06694822013378143, 0.04961642622947693, -0.007290198002010584, 0.013069880194962025, 0.06967218220233917, 0.03962860628962517, 0.005455355159938335, -0.014501825906336308, 0.01847563497722149, 0.028522200882434845, 0.017812492325901985, 0.06693842262029648, 0.03705540671944618, 0.00862189568579197, 0.008665564469993114, 0.04489057511091232, 0.021608583629131317, 0.06816563755273819, -0.03418513014912605, -0.048567287623882294, -0.07932038605213165, 0.0034275332000106573, -0.06297551095485687, 0.01431433204561472, -0.028914323076605797, -0.05206459015607834, 0.03452485427260399, -0.08365548402070999, -0.05797238275408745, 0.038773227483034134, 0.06327500939369202, 0.0576586090028286, 0.019663434475660324, -0.03924333304166794, 0.038122862577438354, 0.044693488627672195, -0.04783652722835541, -0.02467666007578373, -0.009949525818228722, -0.02176549658179283, -0.07442134618759155, -0.01702549122273922, -0.06987407058477402, 0.02382558025419712, 0.03396150842308998, 0.0035718008875846863, -0.0021503048483282328, 0.03552434965968132, 0.07133834809064865, 0.04859357327222824, -0.047811344265937805, 0.03767525032162666, -0.019157864153385162, 0.04295319318771362, 0.012747478671371937, -0.06257041543722153, -0.01992531679570675, 0.016330642625689507, 0.03737654909491539, -0.03952392190694809, 0.002577341627329588, -0.042946308851242065, 0.05402474105358124, -0.031117867678403854, -0.06164965033531189, 0.04229898750782013, 0.06149163842201233, 0.04720145836472511, 0.013447960838675499, 0.06155507639050484, -0.01767471432685852, -0.05620715022087097, 0.04478711634874344, -0.004007083363831043, -0.0030336633790284395 ]
101
101
Introduction to Relational Networks for Classification
The use of computational intelligence techniques for classification has been used in numerous applications. This paper compares the use of a Multi Layer Perceptron Neural Network and a new Relational Network on classifying the HIV status of women at ante-natal clinics. The paper discusses the architecture of the relational network and its merits compared to a neural network and most other computational intelligence classifiers. Results gathered from the study indicate comparable classification accuracies as well as revealed relationships between data features in the classification data. Much higher classification accuracies are recommended for future research in the area of HIV classification as well as missing data estimation.
[ 0.013556123711168766, -0.07803411036729813, 0.03045733831822872, -0.017595482990145683, 0.028314661234617233, -0.03863275423645973, -0.045416928827762604, -0.014719625934958458, -0.01976633258163929, -0.0027999929152429104, 0.0030761854723095894, -0.02377372980117798, 0.027294030413031578, 0.021872686222195625, 0.06542123109102249, -0.004414036870002747, -0.010057671926915646, -0.04403524473309517, -0.004800004884600639, -0.008296685293316841, 0.016037514433264732, -0.0005007986910641193, -0.038688115775585175, -0.09253191202878952, 0.034099776297807693, 0.041101135313510895, -0.05648770183324814, 0.014720141887664795, -0.03923951834440231, -0.02613670378923416, -0.00677416380494833, -0.058177150785923004, 0.017092563211917877, 0.0009266617125831544, 0.02228373847901821, 0.0481928214430809, -0.05690816417336464, -0.021524984389543533, -0.0742182806134224, 0.06184941157698631, -0.07481876760721207, -0.08387042582035065, 0.054135117679834366, 0.010875473730266094, 0.027000270783901215, 0.013095509260892868, -0.03057684563100338, 0.06161748617887497, 0.03294419124722481, 0.021563608199357986, -0.10174796730279922, -0.0718819797039032, -0.008972549811005592, -0.012483322992920876, -0.0993405357003212, 0.014404138550162315, -0.03534046187996864, -0.04259416460990906, 0.02877921052277088, -0.030461324378848076, 0.042966727167367935, -0.022424357011914253, 0.023087630048394203, 0.013600444421172142, 0.07846857607364655, 0.054243091493844986, -0.02477363869547844, -0.008258446119725704, -0.03298464044928551, -0.0524369552731514, -0.02887958660721779, -0.09053593873977661, 0.013301311992108822, 0.04245579615235329, 0.018440958112478256, 0.01633124053478241, 0.03101254254579544, -0.008011930622160435, 0.02557636797428131, 0.04031621664762497, -0.02197340317070484, 0.012151514180004597, 0.0018479435238987207, -0.04805685207247734, 0.0295532438904047, 0.03132587671279907, 0.06572134792804718, -0.05583570525050163, 0.034647341817617416, 0.014869247563183308, -0.012421796098351479, 0.012911850586533546, -0.027808452025055885, 0.04465476796030998, -0.0010254810331389308, 0.01394034642726183, 0.033267516642808914, -0.030194133520126343, 0.010792858898639679, -0.028676293790340424, 0.03393992409110069, -0.050784286111593246, 0.025486009195446968, 0.03798617050051689, 0.0437147431075573, 0.020441394299268723, -0.03984539583325386, 0.03504372388124466, -0.06115278601646423, -0.03112492710351944, 0.0723123848438263, 0.04269794747233391, 0.014900299720466137, 0.056000228971242905, -0.0373094342648983, 0.05032709985971451, -0.01684771105647087, 0.06685332208871841, 0.001280532800592482, 0.021156713366508484, -0.06768210977315903, 0.04940858110785484, -0.0681820884346962, 0.042622894048690796, 0.047932736575603485, -0.04829313978552818, -0.015872163698077202, -0.06533148139715195, 0.0478704497218132, -0.033478252589702606, -0.07492908090353012, 0.09232081472873688, -0.029645219445228577, 0.051078859716653824, -0.033137328922748566, 0.012441026978194714, 0.011624149046838284, -0.022598136216402054, -0.007847245782613754, -0.06569455564022064, -0.023783989250659943, -0.06152667850255966, -0.011967521160840988, 0.02260381169617176, 0.012202966958284378, 0.020278483629226685, -0.005414940882474184, 0.05111023038625717, 0.03522733598947525, -0.013205530121922493, -0.008050917647778988, -0.038949672132730484, -0.03962444141507149, 0.025450261309742928, 0.014739176258444786, -0.08590362966060638, -0.10603117197751999, -0.052491214126348495, 0.020156502723693848, -0.0018671898869797587, -0.050383325666189194, 0.07604286819696426, -0.1024659052491188, 0.034198250621557236, -0.022573484107851982, 0.025007260963320732, -0.03551970049738884, 0.01028620358556509, 0.014905921183526516, -0.06177866458892822, -0.06756087392568588, 0.012830939143896103, 0.010738695971667767, 0.004739089403301477, 0.06179143115878105, 0.0023155612871050835, -0.0352751649916172, 0.022143786773085594, -0.07295382022857666, 0.05535436421632767, 0.023026306182146072, -0.06460154801607132, -0.0408732108771801, 0.005539261270314455, 0.09293559938669205, 0.10535375773906708, 0.03684566542506218, 0.03228975832462311, 0.033525049686431885, 0.009005192667245865, 0.09391313791275024, -0.0017463471740484238, 0.044823382049798965, 0.0027717098128050566, -0.04020550101995468, 0.04185973107814789, -0.004359779413789511, -0.04668460413813591, -0.02970205992460251, 0.03879818320274353, 0.04259144887328148, -0.04557085037231445, 0.03272032365202904, 0.03662307560443878, -0.042999278753995895, 0.03748009726405144, 0.00005601137672783807, 0.011620117351412773, -0.058772727847099304, 0.051596373319625854, 0.044800493866205215, 0.00755941029638052, 0.0718965232372284, 0.05873497575521469, -0.0027275048196315765, -0.007108201272785664, -0.05984046682715416, -0.042676061391830444, 0.021834837272763252, 0.07852298021316528, 0.03271709010004997, 0.018743503838777542, -0.09277969598770142, 0.0012341749388724566, -0.02685927227139473, 0.08061375468969345, -0.048825882375240326, -0.03299921751022339, -0.04861842095851898, 0.016626618802547455, -0.022740831598639488, -0.021390283480286598, -0.09115693718194962, -0.061507824808359146, 0.026567820459604263, 0.047573722898960114, -0.09419658780097961, 0.036387212574481964, -0.020816609263420105, -0.016738785430788994, -0.020273573696613312, 0.07559529691934586, -0.053135957568883896, -0.016551725566387177, 0.08226758241653442, -0.0400017611682415, 0.0061871507205069065, 0.03080434910953045, -0.036866579204797745, 0.03442295640707016, -0.031449053436517715, -0.01347044762223959, -0.02308793179690838, 0.014414776116609573, 0.06721538305282593, 0.0487443171441555, 0.0031859956216067076, 0.03144875168800354, 0.002967420732602477, 0.13231493532657623, 0.06197967752814293, -0.05784120038151741, 0.04110271483659744, -0.05868982896208763, 0.024027850478887558, -0.0262750331312418, -0.00046888121869415045, 0.03217320144176483, -0.05521092563867569, -0.0028128442354500294, -0.035789605230093, -0.029929079115390778, -0.01647992432117462, 0.057489972561597824, -0.06456927210092545, 0.02154618687927723, -0.00657836627215147, 0.006835994776338339, 0.040919993072748184, -0.038856375962495804, 0.014093110337853432, 0.04087885096669197, -0.007307786960154772, 0.013188406825065613, -0.027488190680742264, -0.02418813295662403, 0.05402635037899017, 0.018512608483433723, 0.05159911513328552, -0.07512641698122025, -0.03452519327402115, 0.028320904821157455, -0.050499286502599716, -0.022481052204966545, 0.0047409627586603165, -0.0851052850484848, 0.015821579843759537, 0.0014435810735449195, 0.09088767319917679, -0.05185398831963539, -0.03879333287477493, 0.07525128126144409, 0.0778409019112587, -0.04304797202348709, -0.021151509135961533, 0.044553324580192566, 0.019936295226216316, 0.04765107482671738, 0.012923989444971085, -0.046465374529361725, 0.01037647109478712, -0.06583021581172943, 0.027088714763522148, 0.012820983305573463, -0.018089886754751205, -0.03987900912761688, -0.016660770401358604, -0.01669139787554741, -0.04085629805922508, -0.013867760077118874, 0.0284490454941988, 0.020675668492913246, 0.028992919251322746, -0.015445713885128498, -0.021370189264416695, 0.061376072466373444, -0.03292515501379967, 0.026272987946867943, -0.08434593677520752, 0.036382291465997696, -0.11096569150686264, -0.041596874594688416, 0.006207776255905628, 0.08643040060997009, -0.011975356377661228, 0.052578989416360855, -0.042989715933799744, -0.005521504208445549, 0.01915007084608078, 0.036834798753261566, -0.07286028563976288, -0.05994293466210365, -0.03493047133088112, -0.002334943972527981, -0.016557665541768074, 0.04224885627627373, 0.058378636837005615, -0.05383284389972687, 0.004233238287270069, 0.05361054837703705, 0.026982495561242104, 0.10100814700126648, 0.04536182060837746, 0.06362004578113556, 0.011415909975767136, 0.0881681814789772, 0.0447203628718853, 0.06793331354856491, 0.016609808430075645, 0.02438155934214592, 0.016822628676891327, 0.05121234059333801, -0.03421427682042122, 0.02343278005719185, 0.041510675102472305, -0.0005298045580275357, 0.043033529072999954, 0.008220153860747814, 0.013953137211501598, -0.0475236214697361, 0.0839502364397049, -0.07691453397274017, 0.0467405840754509, 0.023641439154744148, 0.036465223878622055, -0.0009008609922602773, -0.014544029720127583, -0.006197031587362289, 0.06793590635061264, 0.01734301447868347, -0.09028609842061996, 0.04334935173392296, -0.020432166755199432, 0.02042839117348194, -0.0011679682647809386, -0.0009010466746985912, -0.021400190889835358, 0.003704085713252425, 0.057275936007499695, 0.018273940309882164, -0.003941103350371122, -0.0615864172577858, -0.09556559473276138, 0.01629544608294964, 0.05338247865438461, 0.04519560560584068, -0.018018407747149467, 0.02074451744556427, -0.03395036607980728, 0.03602077066898346, -0.0315588042140007, -0.021467890590429306, 0.034428082406520844, -0.020540928468108177, 0.02248130924999714, 0.004611603450030088, -0.08557489514350891, 0.0883186087012291, 0.024591615423560143, 0.012252755463123322, 0.05509931221604347, 0.08990165591239929, 0.005820970516651869, -0.05905993655323982, 0.02109971083700657, 0.010364165529608727, 0.041185297071933746, -0.07874581217765808, -0.00505655724555254, -0.09026584774255753, -0.013895443640649319, 0.012220088392496109, 0.0041393861174583435, 0.020763248205184937, -0.06368090212345123, -0.0039408644661307335, -0.007409384008497, -0.03883600980043411, 0.04239300265908241, -0.011047638021409512, -0.0118331303820014, 0.0172845721244812, -0.01754559390246868, -0.005346639081835747, 0.07954100519418716, -0.014753996394574642, 0.03429315984249115, -0.004767498467117548, 0.06349513679742813, -0.022003760561347008, -0.031869687139987946, 0.02162221074104309, 0.061154041439294815, 0.056197840720415115, -0.030307278037071228, 0.03339936211705208, 0.07709352672100067, -0.02808365225791931, 0.08948993682861328, -0.028470812365412712, 0.01039300486445427, -0.029054364189505577, -0.02108173631131649, -0.03419765830039978, -0.025791995227336884, -0.005261098500341177, -0.100840725004673, -0.0005820462829433382, 0.054290544241666794, -0.06178712472319603, -0.007457892410457134, 0.09075122326612473, 0.002439404372125864, -0.005024399608373642, -0.07384444773197174, -0.10370675474405289, 0.020129896700382233, -0.008491262793540955, 0.012199810706079006, 0.015863070264458656, -0.07057052105665207, -0.08127807825803757, 0.04764106869697571, -0.017124084755778313, 0.049397122114896774, 0.0005048979655839503, -0.020171785727143288, 0.021941760554909706, -0.04754383862018585, -0.0961855947971344, 0.0357174389064312, -0.009415177628397942, 0.045141641050577164, 0.029724208638072014, 0.013600800186395645, 0.00329155963845551, -0.05914735049009323, 0.042593877762556076, -0.0780494436621666, -0.029833605512976646, 0.013533037155866623, -0.04039514437317848, 0.011440016329288483, -0.011430260725319386, -0.034700095653533936, 0.039374057203531265, 0.012898653745651245, 0.05187532305717468, -0.002507884753867984, 0.025287862867116928, -0.0687638446688652, 0.026748767122626305, 0.04527394473552704, -0.040544964373111725, 0.06485766172409058, 0.02623026818037033, -0.0019733402878046036, 0.0014398038620129228, 0.0209812019020319, -0.007618911098688841, -0.04074179008603096, 0.015490752644836903 ]
102
102
The Effect of Structural Diversity of an Ensemble of Classifiers on Classification Accuracy
This paper aims to showcase the measure of structural diversity of an ensemble of 9 classifiers and then map a relationship between this structural diversity and accuracy. The structural diversity was induced by having different architectures or structures of the classifiers The Genetical Algorithms (GA) were used to derive the relationship between diversity and the classification accuracy by evolving the classifiers and then picking 9 classifiers out on an ensemble of 60 classifiers. It was found that as the ensemble became diverse the accuracy improved. However at a certain diversity measure the accuracy began to drop. The Kohavi-Wolpert variance method is used to measure the diversity of the ensemble. A method of voting is used to aggregate the results from each classifier. The lowest error was observed at a diversity measure of 0.16 with a mean square error of 0.274, when taking 0.2024 as maximum diversity measured. The parameters that were varied were: the number of hidden nodes, learning rate and the activation function.
[ -0.06751655042171478, -0.026538215577602386, -0.024167925119400024, 0.0018195167649537325, 0.03338393196463585, -0.03852543979883194, -0.0323418490588665, -0.002817489905282855, -0.034841712564229965, -0.05303867533802986, -0.031458087265491486, 0.04357175529003143, -0.026084452867507935, 0.004859906621277332, 0.02852824330329895, -0.026617029681801796, 0.000245838426053524, -0.028895461931824684, -0.0036626006476581097, -0.06125129386782646, -0.0077379741705954075, -0.0882967859506607, -0.012545634992420673, -0.07539547979831696, -0.007203697692602873, 0.0030875459779053926, -0.03927202895283699, 0.027181323617696762, 0.009768077172338963, -0.0029966949950903654, -0.022616777569055557, 0.005516698583960533, 0.04960915073752403, -0.005659856833517551, -0.02474820986390114, 0.02915477193892002, -0.08081258833408356, -0.06386183202266693, -0.07706689089536667, 0.05128410831093788, -0.012505586259067059, -0.008611364290118217, -0.014572628773748875, -0.0470522902905941, 0.0171038955450058, 0.050321824848651886, 0.02073519304394722, -0.08897259831428528, 0.0423424206674099, 0.05399411916732788, -0.06998878717422485, -0.009492751210927963, 0.04546663910150528, -0.058914244174957275, -0.052927423268556595, 0.05552241951227188, -0.02593967504799366, -0.02799593098461628, -0.007387107238173485, 0.010381161235272884, 0.0781940147280693, 0.06357075273990631, -0.030764276161789894, -0.028275486081838608, 0.025161370635032654, 0.02082614228129387, -0.01338813453912735, -0.016050998121500015, -0.04381551221013069, -0.038745637983083725, 0.059037744998931885, -0.05566481500864029, 0.008856147527694702, 0.0633748397231102, 0.039497047662734985, -0.04028824716806412, 0.08651382476091385, -0.002987787825986743, 0.004000579938292503, 0.03150045499205589, -0.0719393640756607, 0.011465061455965042, 0.05385302007198334, 0.021282443776726723, -0.015409429557621479, -0.008329438045620918, 0.018304364755749702, -0.05000469833612442, 0.06267420947551727, 0.07995303720235825, -0.0329311303794384, 0.014640930108726025, -0.09644678235054016, 0.09577950835227966, -0.006716573145240545, 0.029190076515078545, 0.002019764855504036, -0.019900789484381676, 0.05400477349758148, 0.037522271275520325, 0.006656044628471136, -0.008176577277481556, 0.04105100780725479, 0.01848398521542549, -0.01396868098527193, 0.00396841112524271, -0.0056598796509206295, 0.05685610696673393, 0.007935719564557076, -0.023991256952285767, 0.041734397411346436, -0.019432058557868004, -0.010980497114360332, 0.03842103108763695, 0.008786465041339397, 0.02368709072470665, -0.016731437295675278, 0.05662161484360695, 0.02289365418255329, -0.012811051681637764, 0.013838224112987518, -0.005405302159488201, -0.04807193577289581, 0.03540685400366783, 0.00717228464782238, -0.04236624017357826, 0.018089426681399345, -0.0343785397708416, 0.0698280781507492, -0.0037342640571296215, -0.05715225264430046, 0.053412895649671555, -0.02578134648501873, 0.05121608078479767, 0.02143477089703083, -0.034979112446308136, -0.021656451746821404, 0.014854513108730316, 0.011407206766307354, 0.034338030964136124, 0.034713611006736755, -0.043589748442173004, 0.0419103242456913, 0.037100307643413544, -0.00786091759800911, 0.04248972237110138, -0.000503864255733788, -0.007575517520308495, -0.014676562510430813, 0.05627879127860069, -0.017676709219813347, -0.1251325011253357, 0.07504037022590637, 0.043962638825178146, 0.08294348418712616, -0.039181001484394073, 0.01363078411668539, 0.045037489384412766, -0.008403338491916656, -0.033657439053058624, -0.010762631893157959, 0.011146093718707561, 0.00018084510520566255, 0.01728283427655697, 0.022342607378959656, 0.009741880930960178, -0.013250721618533134, 0.05122765898704529, -0.013437934219837189, -0.0062493691220879555, -0.003004173981025815, 0.021942907944321632, 0.008867863565683365, 0.03896809741854668, 0.06320832669734955, -0.017795056104660034, -0.016892770305275917, 0.09227403253316879, -0.018839312717318535, 0.01967565342783928, 0.07042384147644043, -0.0640890821814537, -0.08001020550727844, 0.015277468599379063, 0.027964312583208084, 0.048788297921419144, 0.02513430453836918, -0.0284219142049551, -0.06045548990368843, -0.0459655337035656, 0.037208810448646545, 0.010514432564377785, 0.012095156125724316, -0.003409183816984296, -0.02633555233478546, 0.023299772292375565, -0.04916737973690033, -0.03037206642329693, 0.014749480411410332, 0.07535355538129807, 0.04264412447810173, -0.0006249997531995177, 0.007617894094437361, -0.02491900697350502, -0.042041487991809845, 0.05662447214126587, 0.07393920421600342, -0.012744253501296043, 0.007836442440748215, -0.0018289893632754683, -0.030925871804356575, 0.01943507418036461, 0.036679599434137344, 0.012449163943529129, -0.00440110731869936, -0.010312876664102077, -0.0863162949681282, -0.08296428620815277, 0.07820761948823929, 0.06494653970003128, -0.003339051967486739, -0.012068062089383602, 0.009619154036045074, 0.005566504318267107, -0.05114789307117462, 0.04140815883874893, -0.019833793863654137, 0.06951373815536499, -0.08620436489582062, 0.05222490802407265, -0.10711706429719925, -0.035190779715776443, -0.06182926893234253, -0.10300889611244202, -0.02919592894613743, 0.05814764276146889, -0.06627058237791061, 0.013355686329305172, 0.07016347348690033, 0.016767019405961037, -0.03371211141347885, 0.04806891083717346, -0.05150565132498741, 0.004054130986332893, 0.06678502261638641, -0.05387613922357559, 0.04247665777802467, 0.02000299096107483, -0.09202868491411209, 0.0310497023165226, 0.024693256244063377, -0.04974851757287979, 0.005485684610903263, -0.03652527928352356, -0.009874030016362667, 0.09317561239004135, -0.05560922250151634, 0.03202822431921959, -0.006265169009566307, 0.0928984060883522, 0.06641336530447006, 0.08036662638187408, 0.07864675670862198, -0.08253350853919983, 0.06491690129041672, -0.019428033381700516, 0.020844995975494385, 0.04867877438664436, -0.04481950402259827, 0.02135477401316166, -0.01716926135122776, -0.06997344642877579, 0.018560608848929405, 0.025259139016270638, -0.11040575802326202, 0.05807152017951012, 0.05680641904473305, 0.06869619339704514, 0.021381033584475517, -0.03787052258849144, -0.0177644994109869, 0.06594432145357132, -0.009741724468767643, 0.03384272754192352, -0.040473658591508865, -0.034911174327135086, -0.04216703772544861, 0.019170820713043213, 0.01439427025616169, -0.027109751477837563, 0.004374060779809952, 0.02626763842999935, -0.09592042118310928, -0.01920030079782009, 0.009804541245102882, 0.005667467601597309, 0.04346272721886635, 0.07737130671739578, 0.06166934221982956, -0.06425263732671738, 0.01969062350690365, 0.034665804356336594, 0.06579282134771347, 0.013429331593215466, 0.058548908680677414, 0.028235673904418945, -0.01377866417169571, 0.06636030972003937, -0.05933995172381401, 0.00016531924484297633, 0.05796169117093086, -0.07047098875045776, 0.00486249104142189, -0.04149319976568222, -0.001980761531740427, -0.04550047218799591, -0.034095700830221176, 0.003479897743090987, 0.040306296199560165, -0.054059725254774094, 0.011059512384235859, -0.043675366789102554, 0.004004231654107571, -0.04291501268744469, -0.03137679398059845, -0.06790399551391602, -0.022817572578787804, -0.0028224708512425423, -0.09223781526088715, 0.07254727929830551, -0.0439130961894989, -0.05142620950937271, 0.03248530626296997, 0.09319133311510086, -0.05173105746507645, 0.02217629738152027, 0.020093576982617378, 0.08184567093849182, -0.06265479326248169, -0.03487278148531914, 0.05313057452440262, 0.03625057265162468, 0.019484631717205048, -0.016156308352947235, 0.0028156950138509274, 0.024216245859861374, 0.10316512733697891, -0.024469759315252304, 0.024105682969093323, -0.021501876413822174, 0.010932176373898983, 0.018549559637904167, -0.06999939680099487, 0.005603362340480089, -0.0023956699296832085, 0.047666192054748535, 0.025994203984737396, 0.005182335153222084, -0.0023532479535788298, -0.019616849720478058, -0.008627346716821194, 0.033718302845954895, 0.002279768930748105, 0.015847617760300636, 0.04820195958018303, 0.07351288944482803, -0.03030158206820488, 0.03928689286112785, 0.04739897698163986, -0.05396566912531853, 0.02053031697869301, 0.02830664813518524, 0.005276071839034557, 0.11424853652715683, 0.045547809451818466, -0.07349558174610138, 0.044467370957136154, -0.03344341367483139, -0.05867386981844902, 0.009614784270524979, -0.06709514558315277, 0.016441764310002327, 0.014139018021523952, 0.012786321341991425, 0.04956204444169998, -0.11298201978206635, 0.022947434335947037, 0.03770693764090538, 0.06944971531629562, 0.058039478957653046, 0.056499890983104706, -0.07246964424848557, -0.07238731533288956, -0.010402047075331211, 0.0003611248394008726, 0.038186561316251755, 0.025371965020895004, -0.021155953407287598, -0.031684719026088715, 0.007192288525402546, 0.0006347629241645336, -0.009564804844558239, 0.014339346438646317, -0.026068639010190964, -0.07321655005216599, -0.02336438186466694, -0.016944851726293564, 0.10489705950021744, 0.017841536551713943, 0.015210290439426899, 0.047404736280441284, -0.019041486084461212, 0.0016194302588701248, -0.06107335910201073, 0.04844789206981659, 0.04391365870833397, 0.03867987543344498, -0.012574106454849243, -0.026047412306070328, -0.07072760909795761, 0.001509654219262302, -0.017366353422403336, 0.022091813385486603, 0.031234566122293472, -0.004013512283563614, 0.0413641557097435, 0.021471288055181503, 0.06253629922866821, 0.009348304010927677, 0.08075670152902603, -0.044220466166734695, -0.002924232743680477, 0.014231382869184017, -0.023289768025279045, 0.06889139115810394, -0.014138157479465008, 0.03804609179496765, -0.08792495727539062, -0.006975402124226093, 0.001514958217740059, -0.1002836674451828, -0.017788046970963478, 0.04591323062777519, 0.05937614291906357, -0.035413749516010284, 0.04229322075843811, 0.018692826852202415, 0.010663153603672981, 0.042903829365968704, 0.0257909893989563, -0.03574863448739052, -0.026836423203349113, -0.01212986558675766, -0.06919063627719879, -0.029939590021967888, 0.0030241727363318205, -0.014456677250564098, -0.011118627153337002, 0.04952681064605713, -0.025158125907182693, -0.003484309883788228, -0.05984870344400406, 0.011409332975745201, -0.01905324123799801, -0.043264880776405334, -0.011288536712527275, 0.04172787442803383, -0.010818849317729473, 0.03322889283299446, 0.02109050378203392, -0.07689730823040009, 0.0011332278372719884, -0.021522587165236473, -0.043579526245594025, -0.03945586085319519, 0.008842304348945618, -0.05728137493133545, -0.08165334165096283, 0.0219524297863245, -0.04420123249292374, 0.03838798776268959, 0.03959769383072853, -0.014420690946280956, 0.1601293534040451, 0.019397234544157982, -0.03932756185531616, -0.028449878096580505, 0.07568930089473724, 0.03424309566617012, -0.02526683546602726, -0.010245705023407936, 0.05421010032296181, -0.038527827709913254, 0.05783459171652794, 0.011899440549314022, -0.016553934663534164, -0.05716404318809509, -0.0023582468274980783, 0.028719479218125343, -0.007636014837771654, 0.010075544007122517, 0.004197681322693825, 0.03787750005722046, 0.01694534160196781, -0.02205044962465763, -0.02957588993012905, 0.08029268682003021, 0.007289653178304434, 0.058856554329395294, 0.0012277921196073294, -0.0244966521859169, -0.06545625627040863 ]
103
103
A Quadratic Loss Multi-Class SVM
Using a support vector machine requires to set two types of hyperparameters: the soft margin parameter C and the parameters of the kernel. To perform this model selection task, the method of choice is cross-validation. Its leave-one-out variant is known to produce an estimator of the generalization error which is almost unbiased. Its major drawback rests in its time requirement. To overcome this difficulty, several upper bounds on the leave-one-out error of the pattern recognition SVM have been derived. Among those bounds, the most popular one is probably the radius-margin bound. It applies to the hard margin pattern recognition SVM, and by extension to the 2-norm SVM. In this report, we introduce a quadratic loss M-SVM, the M-SVM^2, as a direct extension of the 2-norm SVM to the multi-class case. For this machine, a generalized radius-margin bound is then established.
[ 0.06100742891430855, -0.044000811874866486, 0.021653661504387856, -0.03177330642938614, 0.006515142973512411, -0.07033943384885788, -0.04980548843741417, 0.03569860756397247, -0.1024845615029335, 0.020912310108542442, 0.06285059452056885, 0.004549231380224228, -0.04024805873632431, 0.04531416296958923, -0.038806185126304626, 0.05709199607372284, 0.09372460842132568, -0.022006182000041008, 0.02567700482904911, -0.07149625569581985, 0.03280927613377571, 0.02778470888733864, -0.0029124957509338856, -0.04605470970273018, 0.047779254615306854, 0.05924992635846138, -0.02225765772163868, -0.06548785418272018, -0.011872867122292519, 0.027322711423039436, -0.07371968030929565, 0.003882333170622587, -0.020166605710983276, -0.002145863836631179, -0.004946970846503973, -0.028528951108455658, 0.012705606408417225, -0.03739944100379944, -0.0513196736574173, -0.04099442437291145, -0.004394889809191227, 0.020247837528586388, 0.030466346070170403, -0.008891500532627106, -0.00331970676779747, 0.020810822024941444, 0.0026160182897001505, 0.06775126606225967, -0.010948898270726204, 0.06018051877617836, 0.007378572132438421, 0.013716032728552818, -0.03688952326774597, -0.021474801003932953, 0.07052315026521683, -0.046998582780361176, -0.00027215253794565797, -0.023362690582871437, 0.05552642047405243, 0.01502298004925251, 0.017757520079612732, 0.055927619338035583, 0.036452509462833405, -0.043749500066041946, -0.007163234520703554, -0.02633429877460003, -0.10209479182958603, -0.014841065742075443, -0.033727016299963, -0.003458865685388446, 0.03264671936631203, -0.06476330012083054, 0.06651418656110764, 0.05855928361415863, 0.021693354472517967, -0.03305017203092575, -0.026419557631015778, -0.0021394467912614346, 0.05041397362947464, 0.05740797892212868, -0.05055529624223709, -0.055789947509765625, 0.026540549471974373, 0.016936270520091057, 0.000291388132609427, 0.007723532617092133, -0.018314655870199203, 0.0015684397658333182, 0.02313198894262314, 0.0035836398601531982, 0.02794974111020565, 0.009177272208034992, -0.053629182279109955, 0.003150669392198324, -0.006665763910859823, -0.03577408939599991, -0.003945180680602789, -0.018725300207734108, -0.03062635287642479, 0.036655526608228683, 0.0058461688458919525, -0.00871461071074009, 0.04955119639635086, 0.07485014200210571, -0.05212780833244324, 0.020192986354231834, -0.055409025400877, 0.05595123767852783, -0.04916463792324066, -0.005605931393802166, 0.06418954581022263, -0.05472979694604874, 0.00026890987646766007, 0.04878496378660202, 0.011134610511362553, 0.044521234929561615, -0.026821285486221313, 0.027947526425123215, 0.11058606952428818, 0.022119494155049324, -0.051508430391550064, -0.0006290326709859073, -0.10442474484443665, 0.04404674470424652, -0.010103759355843067, -0.015826324000954628, 0.02179824374616146, -0.039002347737550735, 0.04898390546441078, -0.04831250011920929, -0.055290449410676956, 0.08784723281860352, -0.018200522288680077, 0.0808681920170784, -0.07810784131288528, 0.013315918855369091, -0.01721274107694626, -0.08247319608926773, -0.0782984122633934, 0.002382373670116067, -0.008605267852544785, 0.009450642392039299, -0.0038232423830777407, 0.04210399091243744, 0.0009327526204288006, -0.03794029355049133, 0.04437040165066719, 0.024910353124141693, 0.012975507415831089, 0.008128560148179531, -0.02665272168815136, -0.02846369706094265, -0.009359915740787983, 0.05102637782692909, 0.06360439956188202, -0.08565964549779892, -0.0241215992718935, -0.038738589733839035, -0.032607775181531906, 0.03144242241978645, -0.0038096841890364885, 0.0351758673787117, -0.009219164028763771, 0.0513734444975853, -0.04115718975663185, 0.007932704873383045, -0.02336876653134823, -0.04398687556385994, -0.00581329083070159, -0.0356503464281559, -0.05002643167972565, -0.010010479018092155, -0.0731210857629776, -0.01388290710747242, 0.004501441027969122, 0.0214060228317976, 0.0920250415802002, 0.029378442093729973, -0.05701947212219238, -0.01737830601632595, -0.017852509394288063, -0.018605180084705353, 0.04902913421392441, -0.012634132988750935, 0.07654803991317749, 0.10077208280563354, 0.01572936400771141, 0.005868022795766592, 0.06334922462701797, 0.01028804574161768, 0.017541266977787018, -0.05237707868218422, 0.06213819235563278, -0.12719348073005676, -0.07857201248407364, 0.01766250468790531, -0.023194527253508568, 0.0037771842908114195, 0.04044774919748306, 0.037818245589733124, 0.016608785837888718, -0.03842758387327194, -0.02025246061384678, -0.030453862622380257, 0.027703646570444107, -0.05453401803970337, 0.028947224840521812, 0.0020525092259049416, 0.04131066054105759, 0.009764238260686398, -0.046719569712877274, 0.0439242459833622, 0.09460271894931793, -0.027354542165994644, 0.02256797067821026, -0.05334635078907013, 0.03487783670425415, 0.04255284368991852, 0.053046371787786484, 0.04298669099807739, -0.05790189653635025, 0.02267945371568203, -0.017672978341579437, 0.027296125888824463, -0.064370296895504, 0.06347012519836426, -0.023548591881990433, -0.024390030652284622, -0.07113611698150635, 0.08501972258090973, -0.04222148284316063, -0.07398214936256409, 0.02125614695250988, 0.0028735524974763393, -0.06469951570034027, 0.04951299726963043, -0.05018429085612297, -0.012951738201081753, 0.05037938430905342, -0.015000740066170692, 0.031603727489709854, -0.0616571269929409, -0.04949856176972389, -0.016726350411772728, 0.009259413927793503, -0.0313095897436142, 0.04679976403713226, 0.057575780898332596, 0.015452153980731964, 0.005297414027154446, -0.00409578625112772, 0.09090866148471832, -0.04295716807246208, -0.08556319028139114, -0.004270934034138918, -0.037744808942079544, 0.03008999116718769, 0.01788298413157463, 0.025229990482330322, 0.09367170929908752, 0.03321234881877899, 0.0365871898829937, -0.06581979990005493, -0.016026252880692482, 0.119098000228405, -0.04698711261153221, 0.011827627196907997, -0.020302511751651764, 0.019071193411946297, 0.027117319405078888, -0.06079254299402237, -0.0987790897488594, -0.04295778647065163, 0.022204069420695305, -0.06186477094888687, 0.055833183228969574, 0.03534089773893356, -0.004839663859456778, -0.04221728444099426, -0.03658595308661461, -0.1004677340388298, -0.026448726654052734, -0.00950832013040781, -0.015652023255825043, 0.007212388329207897, -0.0009125830256380141, -0.04818357154726982, 0.004666764289140701, 0.05529622361063957, 0.011941182427108288, -0.04736141487956047, 0.039881426841020584, -0.027967382222414017, 0.006949292030185461, 0.05706547573208809, 0.00020143514848314226, 0.04532035440206528, 0.04455703869462013, 0.02850707247853279, 0.0166170671582222, 0.04907086119055748, 0.035606835037469864, -0.0011748436372727156, -0.024792935699224472, -0.04582371935248375, 0.06594856828451157, 0.07169003784656525, -0.06845264881849289, 0.009788560681045055, 0.0634133592247963, -0.013687023892998695, -0.01636342518031597, -0.035219017416238785, -0.058648765087127686, -0.04809970036149025, -0.010150295682251453, 0.031739577651023865, 0.019697455689311028, -0.02064826898276806, -0.01774834282696247, 0.07320141047239304, -0.01566247083246708, -0.004222035873681307, 0.006198217626661062, -0.0669037252664566, -0.03638264164328575, -0.04717065393924713, 0.06643194705247879, -0.0720672532916069, -0.04403684288263321, -0.0516003854572773, -0.010931099765002728, -0.029273848980665207, 0.04014475643634796, -0.0023674038238823414, 0.009041253477334976, 0.00012022107694065198, 0.0005902637494727969, -0.01181886438280344, -0.009431111626327038, -0.06318692117929459, -0.014702449552714825, 0.0486471988260746, -0.06474816799163818, 0.02512306533753872, 0.05440647527575493, -0.0031332827638834715, -0.041318029165267944, -0.08258573710918427, 0.03566644340753555, -0.03096753917634487, 0.04909151792526245, -0.04058508574962616, 0.044331394135951996, -0.03459204360842705, 0.023379450663924217, 0.03907124698162079, -0.043185971677303314, 0.007107854355126619, 0.03030669316649437, -0.040429163724184036, -0.0491345189511776, -0.07783158123493195, 0.1105501800775528, 0.02236316353082657, 0.030338134616613388, -0.008249404840171337, 0.012673110701143742, 0.008427189663052559, -0.017280887812376022, -0.06735602021217346, 0.07191114872694016, 0.014264784753322601, 0.01583496667444706, 0.03229699283838272, 0.006920543499290943, -0.040028490126132965, 0.006407490000128746, 0.00964330229908228, 0.049695972353219986, -0.031210882589221, -0.006345119792968035, -0.04683426767587662, 0.03220082074403763, -0.007691048085689545, -0.022308293730020523, -0.02542782388627529, -0.02144506759941578, 0.05894330143928528, -0.006579534616321325, -0.0019336219411343336, -0.03941122069954872, -0.031988080590963364, 0.04444935917854309, -0.0002999197749886662, 0.02904519997537136, 0.004134835675358772, -0.05011728033423424, -0.039995234459638596, -0.010040645487606525, 0.0018214092124253511, -0.0015836982056498528, -0.02574748359620571, -0.038790613412857056, -0.040429919958114624, -0.040775950998067856, -0.004463408142328262, 0.048758599907159805, -0.01224459707736969, 0.10916177183389664, -0.0012317383661866188, -0.025896262377500534, -0.011710907332599163, 0.04980536177754402, 0.05561039224267006, 0.04009911045432091, -0.04458247497677803, 0.009062089025974274, 0.01940835639834404, -0.07965298742055893, -0.02619875781238079, 0.10042732954025269, 0.02390001155436039, -0.001683137146756053, 0.056094735860824585, -0.010510058142244816, 0.06437402963638306, 0.11831708997488022, -0.033540401607751846, 0.018424183130264282, -0.07055315375328064, -0.009914752095937729, -0.08684911578893661, -0.02492847666144371, 0.011320922523736954, -0.0038338308222591877, 0.07827650010585785, -0.011112920008599758, 0.06134706735610962, 0.012194372713565826, -0.04638797789812088, 0.052546869963407516, 0.017121409997344017, -0.0056978254579007626, -0.006496064830571413, 0.02985580824315548, -0.0291436817497015, 0.009476551786065102, 0.05289054661989212, 0.12116758525371552, 0.0075348494574427605, 0.022534659132361412, 0.03297377750277519, -0.012637278996407986, 0.048017509281635284, 0.025938548147678375, 0.0017448236467316747, -0.06008921191096306, 0.03148859366774559, -0.00017727489466778934, -0.030644046142697334, -0.06444726139307022, 0.015769651159644127, 0.038673363626003265, -0.08422742038965225, 0.0440521277487278, -0.018849819898605347, 0.020056458190083504, -0.013273580931127071, 0.006252603139728308, -0.04419776424765587, 0.01889774762094021, -0.01690419390797615, -0.062048908323049545, 0.07908278703689575, -0.021402666345238686, 0.04469623044133186, -0.07819303125143051, 0.03242010995745659, -0.06317047029733658, 0.000969943474046886, -0.12614230811595917, -0.028200937435030937, -0.051419973373413086, -0.0028111233841627836, 0.023983927443623543, -0.06549525260925293, 0.11521503329277039, -0.0003024265170097351, -0.0009748468291945755, -0.035952769219875336, 0.0030947616323828697, -0.024169744923710823, -0.00901491567492485, -0.03773435577750206, -0.0016037129098549485, 0.05497313290834427, -0.041212406009435654, 0.016681361943483353, 0.00754876434803009, 0.04097353294491768, 0.051528461277484894, 0.07373654842376709, 0.03933537006378174, 0.09137380123138428, -0.013192245736718178, 0.03556865453720093, -0.03271472081542015, 0.021929841488599777, 0.07558555155992508, -0.06276107579469681, -0.040210992097854614 ]
104
104
On Recovery of Sparse Signals via $\ell_1$ Minimization
This article considers constrained $\ell_1$ minimization methods for the recovery of high dimensional sparse signals in three settings: noiseless, bounded error and Gaussian noise. A unified and elementary treatment is given in these noise settings for two $\ell_1$ minimization methods: the Dantzig selector and $\ell_1$ minimization with an $\ell_2$ constraint. The results of this paper improve the existing results in the literature by weakening the conditions and tightening the error bounds. The improvement on the conditions shows that signals with larger support can be recovered accurately. This paper also establishes connections between restricted isometry property and the mutual incoherence property. Some results of Candes, Romberg and Tao (2006) and Donoho, Elad, and Temlyakov (2006) are extended.
[ 0.0766468271613121, -0.0014807163970544934, -0.031793221831321716, -0.02247135527431965, -0.05919057875871658, -0.06614967435598373, -0.006286881398409605, -0.07107095420360565, -0.06927202641963959, 0.08205358684062958, 0.06816421449184418, -0.0465729646384716, 0.004047819878906012, 0.11599833518266678, -0.021062850952148438, -0.028492553159594536, 0.05210808292031288, -0.008096273988485336, -0.008488895371556282, -0.0950651541352272, -0.035469673573970795, -0.002716310089454055, -0.020812463015317917, -0.06972194463014603, -0.04944245144724846, 0.028069589287042618, -0.016181664541363716, -0.029587816447019577, 0.03493494167923927, 0.0043928357772529125, -0.04607166722416878, 0.0012465929612517357, 0.012894242070615292, -0.04789232090115547, -0.04053513705730438, -0.004463283345103264, 0.05850077047944069, -0.0028124467935413122, 0.015070588327944279, 0.021919162943959236, 0.027190348133444786, 0.028524203225970268, 0.02106715738773346, -0.06926009804010391, 0.031584545969963074, 0.005158901680260897, 0.03238191455602646, -0.034091390669345856, 0.010842181742191315, -0.015780700370669365, -0.005506871733814478, -0.024622717872262, -0.016180386766791344, -0.027424544095993042, -0.008766820654273033, 0.05616099014878273, -0.01670554094016552, 0.012741679325699806, 0.04095577448606491, 0.00364607572555542, 0.06437048316001892, 0.008723219856619835, -0.015217822045087814, -0.004615728743374348, 0.02418125607073307, -0.04889806732535362, -0.05054870992898941, 0.02749587409198284, 0.024664225056767464, 0.0011717270826920867, -0.040630631148815155, -0.05676403269171715, 0.04333965852856636, -0.02838524430990219, 0.05706419795751572, -0.045013800263404846, 0.0050070881843566895, 0.021760065108537674, -0.02734801359474659, 0.1298505812883377, -0.012555701658129692, -0.03214842081069946, 0.013461523689329624, 0.06723058968782425, -0.01148256380110979, 0.02754232846200466, 0.007881361991167068, -0.005543407052755356, -0.014818290248513222, 0.002404248807579279, -0.04268466308712959, 0.04112273454666138, -0.08693747967481613, 0.003765708301216364, 0.04720745235681534, -0.005286408122628927, -0.016891727223992348, 0.030028104782104492, -0.0066148689948022366, -0.008163628168404102, -0.031130928546190262, -0.047940049320459366, 0.02210278809070587, 0.04634993150830269, -0.04632318392395973, -0.013497349806129932, -0.15461309254169464, 0.00879763439297676, -0.03849988430738449, -0.04780124872922897, -0.027491506189107895, 0.01770002394914627, 0.023262398317456245, -0.03780803084373474, 0.00012336968211457133, 0.04169965907931328, 0.013244698755443096, 0.06204243749380112, -0.023522179573774338, 0.036065950989723206, 0.013720008544623852, -0.0573054701089859, 0.01782113127410412, 0.015458821319043636, 0.017902331426739693, 0.03920726105570793, -0.005705068353563547, -0.06473726034164429, 0.13088126480579376, 0.00021334170014597476, -0.09809485077857971, 0.0059301345609128475, -0.03312820568680763, 0.011736717075109482, -0.12483759969472885, 0.06929801404476166, 0.01753726601600647, -0.002350746188312769, -0.07022763043642044, 0.08597522228956223, -0.01843581162393093, -0.02691546082496643, 0.046611033380031586, -0.0222259983420372, -0.02781696431338787, -0.03570082411170006, 0.04368038848042488, 0.031312331557273865, -0.08109797537326813, -0.03781720623373985, 0.050185155123472214, -0.027549032121896744, 0.08529765903949738, 0.04884018376469612, 0.03822823613882065, -0.0562029592692852, -0.029300443828105927, -0.03755539655685425, 0.010868762619793415, 0.04728202521800995, -0.10041170567274094, -0.025442026555538177, 0.03063380718231201, 0.06965702772140503, -0.06577566266059875, -0.08523188531398773, -0.017670437693595886, -0.04792395979166031, -0.06404464691877365, 0.019195692613720894, -0.04054054245352745, -0.011169631034135818, 0.03610710799694061, 0.06091112643480301, 0.003553482238203287, 0.08617153018712997, -0.011057818308472633, 0.049081820994615555, 0.0273481085896492, 0.01734599843621254, 0.03501502797007561, 0.007237136829644442, 0.005252694245427847, 0.08421575278043747, 0.06921150535345078, 0.07115156948566437, -0.0166915450245142, 0.054643820971250534, 0.06876066327095032, -0.028945080935955048, 0.04748764634132385, -0.005463197827339172, -0.012800171971321106, 0.019689327105879784, -0.03675189986824989, 0.04375481605529785, -0.04507531225681305, 0.0706864595413208, 0.02307550050318241, 0.044096894562244415, 0.001448953291401267, 0.013351742178201675, -0.041237760335206985, -0.04967675358057022, -0.0965857207775116, 0.08993346989154816, 0.0864156186580658, -0.020704464986920357, -0.03802318871021271, -0.009528952650725842, 0.01898382231593132, 0.017794746905565262, 0.050557512789964676, -0.003391534322872758, 0.050502192229032516, -0.06405609846115112, 0.00928837526589632, -0.03218216076493263, 0.012228274717926979, 0.0072173867374658585, -0.10129644721746445, 0.04088779538869858, 0.016084522008895874, 0.024340424686670303, -0.0009512125398032367, -0.010618906468153, 0.029936054721474648, -0.055062200874090195, -0.08676549792289734, 0.011266489513218403, -0.01585698127746582, 0.0041495757177472115, -0.09526509791612625, -0.08705116808414459, -0.041921187192201614, -0.013339660130441189, -0.009127202443778515, 0.0018822218989953399, -0.016500597819685936, 0.04244177043437958, -0.0017114937072619796, -0.032286688685417175, 0.000662829028442502, 0.003653639229014516, -0.005281724967062473, -0.029958197847008705, 0.07222240418195724, 0.0855444148182869, 0.019574308767914772, 0.09239953756332397, -0.05268895626068115, 0.03688022121787071, 0.0736934244632721, 0.006766712758690119, -0.04628346115350723, 0.025522781535983086, -0.010867864824831486, -0.02779201790690422, 0.08523117750883102, 0.040550049394369125, -0.03615126013755798, 0.05319788679480553, -0.06952527165412903, -0.01471748761832714, 0.06332758814096451, 0.02718261256814003, 0.004497927613556385, 0.07616099715232849, -0.01044707465916872, 0.01850789040327072, 0.01718951016664505, -0.09115840494632721, -0.03519929572939873, -0.0013998260255903006, -0.09539135545492172, 0.06128789484500885, 0.058405641466379166, 0.03939586132764816, -0.027528107166290283, 0.04764948785305023, -0.1031152531504631, 0.02055363915860653, -0.031164567917585373, -0.05053679272532463, 0.026104062795639038, 0.017040308564901352, 0.06312666833400726, 0.04576792195439339, -0.062471695244312286, 0.02437974512577057, 0.003515407908707857, 0.008123639039695263, 0.0005211709067225456, 0.02696654386818409, 0.029679033905267715, -0.06689240038394928, -0.038393452763557434, -0.017719052731990814, 0.028709756210446358, -0.013182282447814941, 0.03783250227570534, -0.021774811670184135, -0.03160155937075615, -0.08474183827638626, 0.04241378232836723, -0.019746676087379456, 0.12081322818994522, 0.028664061799645424, -0.02250407263636589, 0.013901414349675179, 0.01810385100543499, 0.007763986475765705, -0.050361767411231995, -0.03051275759935379, -0.010465567000210285, -0.030951499938964844, 0.018194636330008507, -0.010090491734445095, 0.011024150997400284, -0.06239987164735794, -0.0019424199126660824, 0.031396832317113876, -0.0333217978477478, 0.0046302638947963715, -0.06820894777774811, -0.004815933294594288, -0.041995786130428314, -0.007951878942549229, -0.08266095072031021, 0.019484184682369232, -0.018158555030822754, 0.00488780764862895, -0.04557710513472557, 0.061616502702236176, -0.057663630694150925, 0.0007125027477741241, -0.03578656539320946, -0.06517372280359268, -0.07232485711574554, -0.029460029676556587, 0.006917595863342285, -0.0067950342781841755, -0.016692308709025383, 0.0008832690655253828, 0.04768594726920128, 0.04114256054162979, 0.0716564729809761, 0.012274193577468395, -0.025258008390665054, 0.04279959574341774, -0.022584218531847, 0.03539959713816643, 0.02710912935435772, 0.04165774583816528, 0.03846611827611923, 0.0695379301905632, 0.02782439813017845, 0.02949020080268383, -0.08745341002941132, 0.11519531160593033, -0.05964978411793709, 0.029335105791687965, -0.02249281108379364, 0.03910859301686287, 0.006540212314575911, 0.08184187859296799, 0.01582507975399494, 0.010595183819532394, -0.059538789093494415, 0.07339709997177124, -0.022177666425704956, 0.06135895103216171, 0.03158651292324066, 0.0019033377757295966, 0.04321268945932388, 0.023599447682499886, 0.01261468417942524, -0.07523462176322937, -0.01799728535115719, -0.01891298219561577, -0.007409302517771721, -0.0002754754095803946, -0.041872747242450714, 0.03037828952074051, 0.01715046353638172, 0.017390623688697815, -0.05122515559196472, 0.04640752077102661, 0.009194488637149334, 0.007338117342442274, -0.03630438074469566, -0.06967955082654953, 0.013594839721918106, 0.0318734273314476, -0.005962759256362915, 0.016928549855947495, -0.012384805828332901, 0.07063138484954834, 0.04027163237333298, -0.02164740115404129, -0.017866110429167747, 0.044830795377492905, -0.05711507052183151, -0.05829228088259697, -0.04417627677321434, -0.07082299143075943, 0.04671194404363632, -0.0019661455880850554, -0.01368684321641922, 0.10588154941797256, 0.04974809288978577, -0.045625608414411545, -0.022473007440567017, 0.0006556890439242125, -0.014191070571541786, 0.0890791267156601, -0.04647020995616913, 0.003904506331309676, -0.006296795327216387, -0.009559974074363708, 0.01198207214474678, 0.04217659309506416, -0.03699274733662605, -0.016527444124221802, 0.0278369951993227, 0.031746506690979004, 0.06361982971429825, 0.03324494510889053, -0.04329831525683403, 0.04676467180252075, -0.0946471318602562, -0.035642798990011215, -0.013745827600359917, 0.016758937388658524, 0.03582685440778732, -0.024454975500702858, 0.07364775985479355, -0.025803513824939728, -0.024770841002464294, 0.012475413270294666, -0.021269962191581726, -0.08663176745176315, -0.027566097676753998, 0.043110985308885574, 0.024748794734477997, 0.013912592083215714, 0.06009300425648689, -0.047358088195323944, 0.0711439698934555, 0.00960057508200407, -0.07449210435152054, 0.0030456618405878544, 0.0307391956448555, 0.023616556078195572, 0.004160181153565645, 0.03530656918883324, 0.014077880419790745, -0.010118323378264904, 0.043614115566015244, -0.00839243084192276, -0.05323503911495209, -0.015234134159982204, 0.03217248618602753, -0.017327668145298958, -0.04062327742576599, -0.033861394971609116, -0.06262198835611343, 0.02988026849925518, 0.05407171696424484, 0.03515452891588211, -0.04725579917430878, 0.019951798021793365, 0.03851773962378502, -0.012504731304943562, -0.009057818911969662, -0.051459550857543945, -0.015466060489416122, -0.006799548398703337, 0.01850377582013607, 0.053265281021595, -0.024318449199199677, -0.039087925106287, -0.019479291513562202, -0.013389903120696545, 0.04055983945727348, 0.0708915963768959, -0.03233341500163078, 0.024147232994437218, 0.01964334025979042, -0.020309723913669586, -0.006144976243376732, -0.026514988392591476, 0.03609658032655716, 0.004722378682345152, -0.048574384301900864, -0.009417694993317127, 0.04997989162802696, -0.02029241994023323, 0.09011315554380417, -0.020017115399241447, 0.04181407019495964, -0.017580082640051842, -0.038543760776519775, -0.028625046834349632, 0.035552892833948135, 0.0730653777718544, 0.020100062713027, 0.002151144901290536, -0.015057524666190147, 0.02372700907289982, 0.016927136108279228, -0.010392483323812485 ]
105
105
On-line Learning of an Unlearnable True Teacher through Mobile Ensemble Teachers
On-line learning of a hierarchical learning model is studied by a method from statistical mechanics. In our model a student of a simple perceptron learns from not a true teacher directly, but ensemble teachers who learn from the true teacher with a perceptron learning rule. Since the true teacher and the ensemble teachers are expressed as non-monotonic perceptron and simple ones, respectively, the ensemble teachers go around the unlearnable true teacher with the distance between them fixed in an asymptotic steady state. The generalization performance of the student is shown to exceed that of the ensemble teachers in a transient state, as was shown in similar ensemble-teachers models. Further, it is found that moving the ensemble teachers even in the steady state, in contrast to the fixed ensemble teachers, is efficient for the performance of the student.
[ -0.038588881492614746, -0.06842313706874847, 0.04635259881615639, -0.03189342841506004, 0.026698743924498558, -0.08225078135728836, -0.006114909891039133, 0.017523005604743958, -0.07451492547988892, -0.011875515803694725, -0.03986641392111778, 0.05739564821124077, 0.047875627875328064, 0.03264117240905762, 0.08775258809328079, -0.06308384239673615, 0.05103408917784691, 0.031039055436849594, -0.04699983447790146, -0.028507249429821968, 0.029954252764582634, -0.0007363652694039047, 0.07438988983631134, -0.07322390377521515, 0.05141590163111687, 0.025344932451844215, -0.011113137006759644, 0.025262687355279922, 0.041534602642059326, -0.01679294742643833, -0.02788904868066311, -0.024163169786334038, -0.025512192398309708, 0.029851235449314117, 0.051691602915525436, -0.02445238269865513, 0.045159656554460526, -0.002503352239727974, 0.018909074366092682, 0.03979416936635971, -0.038143567740917206, -0.053709715604782104, 0.0019145141122862697, -0.041841793805360794, 0.04283015802502632, -0.04003916680812836, -0.01042806077748537, 0.004088270477950573, -0.04695192351937294, 0.05491166561841965, 0.0003594523877836764, 0.054647047072649, -0.0543246828019619, -0.007886135950684547, -0.05783938616514206, 0.03572620451450348, -0.05323637276887894, -0.001412724144756794, -0.04863579571247101, -0.04442533105611801, -0.033151641488075256, 0.02208036743104458, 0.001324926852248609, -0.012814945541322231, 0.016431698575615883, 0.03887884318828583, -0.05573626607656479, -0.024923017248511314, 0.02227676287293434, -0.0486757755279541, 0.02044547162950039, -0.0008617024286650121, 0.04172370582818985, 0.07540535926818848, 0.03632603585720062, -0.042076289653778076, -0.03237919509410858, -0.029701324179768562, 0.058617472648620605, -0.0044073848985135555, -0.08428781479597092, 0.02343590371310711, -0.011087756603956223, 0.07148658484220505, 0.045233286917209625, -0.04249955713748932, -0.0009818262187764049, -0.009522116743028164, 0.0063183484598994255, -0.007286726031452417, -0.01042186189442873, 0.01557319238781929, -0.08144281059503555, 0.007050055544823408, -0.0072998302057385445, 0.03770574927330017, -0.056459732353687286, -0.06495387852191925, -0.015681950375437737, 0.030181607231497765, 0.009384792298078537, -0.010672363452613354, 0.034405093640089035, 0.08787238597869873, 0.03172052651643753, 0.03998571261763573, -0.007100780960172415, 0.03717353567481041, 0.05342414975166321, 0.05606437101960182, 0.061615291982889175, 0.011476020328700542, 0.03128371387720108, 0.03294944018125534, -0.037365563213825226, 0.06363162398338318, -0.06580260396003723, 0.08715466409921646, 0.021345270797610283, 0.052758097648620605, -0.016174940392374992, 0.00038788182428106666, -0.09320331364870071, 0.04902758076786995, 0.03559977188706398, -0.021607283502817154, -0.027653496712446213, -0.006422475911676884, 0.08575403690338135, -0.020086348056793213, -0.04458366334438324, 0.037441279739141464, 0.02653454802930355, -0.01299712061882019, 0.015262887813150883, -0.025479404255747795, -0.04056629166007042, 0.027254289016127586, -0.05904771760106087, 0.0022347127087414265, -0.028845276683568954, 0.0052824364975094795, -0.039404869079589844, 0.011201266199350357, 0.021224848926067352, 0.019064385443925858, -0.017623472958803177, -0.019047975540161133, 0.060365624725818634, -0.044997505843639374, 0.06446634978055954, -0.009231249801814556, 0.04650028422474861, 0.01799463853240013, 0.01778002828359604, -0.048539791256189346, -0.04196425899863243, 0.08267658203840256, 0.042047545313835144, 0.06429685652256012, -0.006251615006476641, 0.02092711441218853, -0.04127158224582672, -0.008729848079383373, 0.0338292121887207, 0.003481585066765547, 0.0009139471803791821, 0.040803395211696625, 0.004583178553730249, -0.026406317949295044, -0.02409706637263298, 0.02057928591966629, -0.014645364135503769, -0.013128858059644699, 0.01063853781670332, -0.027894433587789536, -0.019230296835303307, 0.014780281111598015, -0.006513966713100672, 0.030624253675341606, 0.0541873574256897, -0.08600617200136185, 0.046702876687049866, 0.01874844916164875, 0.042995866388082504, 0.08961115032434464, -0.01857968233525753, 0.1684713065624237, 0.011478218249976635, -0.03789568692445755, 0.028133751824498177, -0.0294065922498703, 0.008329424075782299, 0.011000797152519226, -0.012596708722412586, -0.015888718888163567, -0.0001012223947327584, 0.03817209228873253, 0.07398302108049393, 0.05009016394615173, 0.06075570359826088, -0.012423177249729633, -0.0064748432487249374, -0.04257666692137718, -0.02862134762108326, 0.08686014264822006, 0.05728329345583916, -0.04722117260098457, -0.04912417009472847, 0.022914428263902664, -0.011230194009840488, -0.020466620102524757, -0.052790772169828415, 0.034533511847257614, -0.00041518337093293667, -0.08955010026693344, -0.01863572560250759, -0.03160574659705162, 0.06244150549173355, 0.05213944986462593, -0.03682903200387955, 0.05134519562125206, -0.010588976554572582, 0.04452268034219742, 0.031155012547969818, -0.025994034484028816, 0.07456441223621368, 0.005742376204580069, -0.043355025351047516, 0.04180435091257095, -0.1172824278473854, 0.00046270419261418283, -0.02720465138554573, -0.014074699021875858, 0.0037353860680013895, 0.04627055674791336, -0.07685916125774384, 0.03692806139588356, -0.008490991778671741, -0.01636410504579544, -0.04875635728240013, 0.037704598158597946, -0.02992650307714939, -0.018623726442456245, 0.031432393938302994, -0.07831965386867523, -0.02727428637444973, -0.02532295696437359, -0.09114719182252884, -0.040773432701826096, 0.03498608246445656, 0.008482973091304302, 0.01481221616268158, -0.001412697834894061, -0.024989053606987, 0.06320570409297943, -0.027339011430740356, 0.019315820187330246, -0.04496513679623604, 0.053932346403598785, -0.014951013028621674, -0.028448384255170822, 0.006643518339842558, 0.01612900011241436, 0.09218084067106247, -0.03283112123608589, -0.0505635030567646, 0.043207015842199326, -0.02273310348391533, -0.018637875095009804, 0.06523091346025467, -0.034506868571043015, -0.033719759434461594, 0.014983801171183586, -0.0016636439831927419, 0.004406303633004427, 0.04129617661237717, -0.00871051475405693, 0.049980562180280685, -0.02748696133494377, -0.07133955508470535, -0.004354654811322689, -0.11285334825515747, -0.027440542355179787, -0.06985784322023392, 0.027027353644371033, 0.03532678261399269, -0.001433244557119906, 0.04037351533770561, 0.04432029277086258, 0.027196550741791725, 0.018908878788352013, -0.054542217403650284, -0.011237438768148422, 0.003019547089934349, -0.07843060791492462, 0.013493746519088745, -0.026232561096549034, -0.00149114103987813, -0.040427472442388535, 0.0752422884106636, 0.011717518791556358, 0.004546199459582567, -0.017691561952233315, 0.02385561540722847, 0.030424227938055992, 0.0052130259573459625, 0.092618927359581, -0.06239258497953415, 0.04523209482431412, 0.07377446442842484, -0.0749613419175148, -0.009736449457705021, 0.01381992269307375, 0.03437523916363716, -0.03941945359110832, -0.06981891393661499, -0.04006657004356384, -0.03152081370353699, 0.008444621227681637, 0.04226591810584068, -0.04732160270214081, -0.008847348392009735, -0.026599397882819176, -0.10019916296005249, 0.048459380865097046, 0.07088833302259445, 0.03720161318778992, -0.0852351114153862, 0.07376814633607864, -0.03211129084229469, -0.027399374172091484, -0.06227193772792816, 0.1014048308134079, -0.00481345783919096, 0.019455119967460632, -0.05477163940668106, -0.021361729130148888, 0.016427868977189064, 0.10688859969377518, -0.03732959181070328, -0.04271188750863075, 0.06752816587686539, -0.02452622354030609, -0.05958293750882149, 0.05034031346440315, 0.12645253539085388, -0.04466516897082329, -0.022294852882623672, 0.025822697207331657, -0.020840508863329887, 0.007445090916007757, -0.09052792191505432, 0.06686533987522125, -0.06043592095375061, -0.027875171974301338, 0.006779917515814304, 0.020364269614219666, 0.04007057100534439, 0.009333965368568897, -0.06589297950267792, 0.0512675903737545, -0.003163908375427127, -0.04034106060862541, 0.00941187608987093, 0.04022005945444107, -0.0025871878024190664, -0.008863048627972603, -0.04455374926328659, -0.01805284060537815, -0.044382065534591675, -0.040877457708120346, 0.04345189034938812, -0.0015724034747108817, 0.0027303744573146105, 0.005816596560180187, 0.023725401610136032, -0.03252923861145973, -0.011015756987035275, 0.032017018646001816, -0.06975153833627701, -0.09096940606832504, -0.013618255034089088, 0.04845554754137993, -0.0033169984817504883, -0.052212201058864594, 0.027423955500125885, 0.029999326914548874, 0.03927014768123627, -0.0506325401365757, -0.04811272770166397, -0.017997024580836296, -0.0014544150326400995, 0.024256037548184395, -0.0020178668200969696, 0.01030233409255743, 0.11894939094781876, 0.024385275319218636, -0.06150781735777855, 0.0018505100160837173, 0.021198447793722153, 0.025799207389354706, 0.0000013208764357841574, -0.0733816847205162, -0.02727210335433483, -0.019755754619836807, 0.015675680711865425, 0.06508811563253403, 0.04276589676737785, 0.03750349208712578, 0.05892965570092201, 0.07617558538913727, 0.014941194094717503, -0.028220467269420624, -0.06154022365808487, -0.003480006940662861, 0.029848525300621986, -0.06134309619665146, 0.05737604200839996, -0.08634782582521439, -0.04119674861431122, 0.028145387768745422, 0.07211639732122421, 0.02703394740819931, -0.06776700168848038, 0.03481786325573921, 0.05375850573182106, 0.03765342757105827, 0.08644941449165344, 0.04889870434999466, -0.09957318007946014, -0.040337543934583664, -0.07259060442447662, -0.007367688696831465, 0.04109742492437363, -0.02864721044898033, -0.019118506461381912, -0.03231139853596687, 0.019116315990686417, -0.0003271331952419132, -0.016902146860957146, 0.02374708093702793, 0.024711309000849724, 0.004383866209536791, -0.025136256590485573, 0.12413044273853302, -0.010932578705251217, -0.025600386783480644, 0.09016742557287216, -0.04870854690670967, 0.0015778278466314077, -0.06328246742486954, 0.012234373949468136, -0.05982600525021553, -0.010779422707855701, -0.03588241711258888, 0.026403503492474556, -0.019700603559613228, -0.016304519027471542, -0.04166712984442711, -0.028065655380487442, -0.0005506615852937102, 0.018967226147651672, 0.024137025699019432, -0.0667080506682396, -0.058768823742866516, 0.062163256108760834, 0.013131897896528244, -0.000828397402074188, 0.04374882951378822, -0.014979026280343533, 0.04383792355656624, -0.029557639732956886, -0.05599643290042877, 0.03166627883911133, 0.04778337478637695, 0.04249986633658409, 0.0028675789944827557, 0.003010108135640621, 0.005837644450366497, 0.00009245843102689832, 0.03515796735882759, -0.03443177789449692, 0.11361987888813019, 0.08982367068529129, 0.02367989718914032, -0.05647736042737961, 0.07217063754796982, 0.034508053213357925, 0.06391260027885437, -0.0023299092426896095, -0.01305589359253645, 0.05968603864312172, -0.016377700492739677, -0.023566681891679764, -0.019090838730335236, -0.010380512103438377, 0.005482163745909929, -0.03558104485273361, 0.017287351191043854, 0.012703490443527699, -0.021342910826206207, 0.09093489497900009, 0.007418544963002205, 0.03451349213719368, 0.03500865399837494, 0.025260237976908684, -0.022156383842229843, -0.03953774273395538, 0.0014963295543566346, -0.016120020300149918, -0.007647582795470953 ]
106
106
Rollout Sampling Approximate Policy Iteration
Several researchers have recently investigated the connection between reinforcement learning and classification. We are motivated by proposals of approximate policy iteration schemes without value functions which focus on policy representation using classifiers and address policy learning as a supervised learning problem. This paper proposes variants of an improved policy iteration scheme which addresses the core sampling problem in evaluating a policy through simulation as a multi-armed bandit machine. The resulting algorithm offers comparable performance to the previous algorithm achieved, however, with significantly less computational effort. An order of magnitude improvement is demonstrated experimentally in two standard reinforcement learning domains: inverted pendulum and mountain-car.
[ -0.09703045338392258, -0.05006727948784828, 0.06396732479333878, 0.060993582010269165, -0.028246194124221802, -0.11774946749210358, -0.05767206847667694, 0.03616791218519211, -0.10615593940019608, 0.015608826652169228, -0.015606628730893135, -0.011640419252216816, 0.047909606248140335, 0.025363784283399582, 0.08266966789960861, 0.022161012515425682, -0.03142794966697693, -0.029196372255682945, 0.007490789983421564, -0.02843165583908558, 0.08551990985870361, -0.018363915383815765, 0.04137697070837021, -0.004513053223490715, 0.041700202971696854, 0.012147046625614166, -0.002792694140225649, -0.015810202807188034, -0.08109210431575775, 0.0674324557185173, -0.006135412026196718, -0.017105350270867348, -0.003986225463449955, 0.02177754044532776, -0.016995040699839592, -0.019447915256023407, 0.04158448800444603, -0.05803872272372246, -0.03665607422590256, 0.004733825568109751, -0.07996725291013718, 0.0036100507713854313, -0.0025914604775607586, 0.01631780155003071, 0.06249703839421272, 0.04904307797551155, 0.010131618939340115, -0.025403236970305443, -0.04807355999946594, 0.12259569764137268, -0.12563000619411469, 0.01483247708529234, -0.028465433046221733, -0.0570203997194767, -0.011610142886638641, 0.05030229687690735, -0.04460407793521881, -0.004533650353550911, -0.056858986616134644, -0.029252542182803154, 0.021091291680932045, 0.09921829402446747, 0.00756056746467948, -0.0037365828175097704, -0.04051879793405533, -0.027030430734157562, 0.011073585599660873, -0.032102156430482864, -0.06724648177623749, -0.03930554911494255, 0.09772234410047531, -0.06148356944322586, -0.011130813509225845, 0.007048524916172028, 0.00039647897938266397, 0.033076126128435135, 0.10258497297763824, 0.006688408087939024, 0.012720534577965736, 0.012454859912395477, -0.030571911484003067, 0.018773289397358894, 0.0007188530871644616, 0.08144621551036835, -0.01970609650015831, -0.02677903324365616, 0.021405771374702454, 0.02475428208708763, 0.010789011605083942, 0.005554462783038616, -0.012666204944252968, 0.04028594493865967, -0.06494766473770142, -0.00026584684383124113, -0.021449794992804527, 0.024026362225413322, 0.00686365133151412, -0.00457547465339303, -0.022658314555883408, 0.04242890328168869, 0.04670879244804382, -0.011891250498592854, 0.046752531081438065, 0.08444070816040039, -0.024368679150938988, -0.03505992144346237, 0.08488281816244125, -0.03267352655529976, 0.0032669352367520332, 0.010262977331876755, 0.031914666295051575, -0.009402564726769924, 0.021997647359967232, 0.031586479395627975, -0.08564974367618561, 0.05285077169537544, -0.06977048516273499, 0.07123304903507233, 0.016606265679001808, 0.03291483595967293, 0.009477604180574417, -0.020695069804787636, -0.0010448319371789694, -0.016052905470132828, 0.06250592321157455, -0.026389671489596367, -0.016719946637749672, -0.03213822841644287, 0.10023517906665802, -0.05873013287782669, -0.04321267083287239, 0.027530327439308167, -0.04115038737654686, -0.09990286082029343, -0.002701748860999942, 0.03738688677549362, -0.02800609916448593, -0.08131740242242813, -0.01694190502166748, 0.040277134627103806, -0.0026044086553156376, -0.07011726498603821, -0.03298160806298256, 0.003906102618202567, -0.00033141340827569366, -0.016872240230441093, 0.02222474105656147, 0.029533497989177704, 0.05706652253866196, 0.06156378239393234, -0.007750954478979111, -0.047598592936992645, -0.02960156835615635, 0.053191233426332474, 0.037182677537202835, -0.04934833198785782, -0.02404768019914627, 0.005327655468136072, -0.06388220191001892, 0.08300348371267319, 0.017029253765940666, 0.043289657682180405, 0.0004253984661772847, 0.020574115216732025, 0.02540094032883644, 0.024611741304397583, 0.026882078498601913, 0.07261718809604645, -0.010251026600599289, -0.09624620527029037, -0.06978116929531097, 0.020324233919382095, -0.012384137138724327, 0.02166827768087387, 0.004762960597872734, -0.01158541813492775, -0.06251233071088791, 0.008551490493118763, -0.010328041389584541, 0.0015057421987876296, -0.06419335305690765, -0.08601736277341843, 0.02571897953748703, 0.00631793262436986, 0.029682187363505363, 0.054949112236499786, 0.02213561162352562, 0.014154097065329552, 0.004255140665918589, 0.009539037011563778, -0.052151646465063095, -0.023475700989365578, -0.008395886979997158, -0.01321154460310936, -0.04036528617143631, -0.0025780617725104094, -0.01238341722637415, -0.037161119282245636, 0.02521759457886219, 0.01763889193534851, 0.043715137988328934, 0.012032547034323215, -0.04322561249136925, -0.005338299088180065, -0.016247719526290894, 0.0637146607041359, 0.003844972001388669, -0.002185442950576544, -0.024165451526641846, -0.020531507208943367, 0.029594454914331436, 0.020947223529219627, -0.020694566890597343, 0.0013432332780212164, 0.04106708616018295, -0.05635121092200279, -0.04111997410655022, -0.0054364800453186035, 0.05210883170366287, 0.03695189952850342, 0.016566528007388115, 0.06217486411333084, -0.0610971637070179, 0.06643757969141006, -0.06076071038842201, 0.03340693563222885, 0.04310429468750954, -0.03518242761492729, -0.057421114295721054, 0.04757821187376976, -0.021505586802959442, -0.061740417033433914, 0.004548512399196625, 0.003001280827447772, -0.05181996151804924, 0.07028276473283768, -0.04564966261386871, 0.0026198416016995907, -0.010104866698384285, -0.06073826178908348, -0.043741509318351746, 0.09954710304737091, 0.026856781914830208, -0.07862983644008636, 0.038892269134521484, -0.016538942232728004, -0.0011792979203164577, 0.0443594790995121, -0.0483289510011673, -0.014503765851259232, 0.05178169161081314, -0.015348723158240318, -0.08355686068534851, 0.007794505450874567, 0.037970367819070816, -0.045972298830747604, -0.009760032407939434, 0.08123249560594559, 0.00888890866190195, 0.008976656012237072, -0.018278667703270912, 0.02193375863134861, -0.02880486287176609, 0.0328778512775898, 0.06095508858561516, 0.04634875804185867, -0.03800162672996521, 0.02511938475072384, 0.04398147016763687, -0.03090275451540947, -0.05113484337925911, 0.040649693459272385, -0.002611179370433092, 0.08451396971940994, 0.03333114832639694, -0.06558843702077866, 0.041973307728767395, 0.005678645335137844, 0.029800374060869217, -0.05035809800028801, -0.05536810681223869, 0.004132766742259264, 0.014307058416306973, -0.024168258532881737, 0.02211693488061428, 0.04264438897371292, 0.04745306819677353, -0.016775455325841904, -0.016548601910471916, 0.060498274862766266, -0.003088959725573659, 0.037412576377391815, -0.006613736506551504, -0.02041945606470108, 0.09842480719089508, -0.06642857193946838, -0.006918937899172306, 0.044278282672166824, 0.05369122698903084, -0.017428578808903694, 0.018652325496077538, -0.03980495035648346, 0.12251006811857224, 0.06066638231277466, 0.014299454167485237, 0.09460359066724777, 0.02830447070300579, 0.10109893232584, -0.09649312496185303, 0.018830275163054466, 0.07869924604892731, -0.013152485713362694, -0.002150651765987277, -0.048500243574380875, 0.02921178936958313, -0.012796887196600437, 0.031335145235061646, 0.03018888831138611, -0.04903118684887886, 0.04910476133227348, 0.02576865628361702, 0.021606646478176117, 0.04189680516719818, 0.04695970192551613, -0.09171666949987411, -0.023855851963162422, 0.015977652743458748, 0.04004307836294174, 0.011664443649351597, 0.014482072554528713, -0.06380452960729599, -0.0020384415984153748, -0.0023391698487102985, 0.05329721048474312, -0.049309637397527695, -0.03111460991203785, -0.03584926202893257, 0.024978987872600555, 0.042394958436489105, 0.042912498116493225, -0.06586786359548569, -0.09222026914358139, 0.004354297183454037, 0.004595456179231405, -0.0335351824760437, 0.03131983056664467, 0.015925198793411255, -0.07026985287666321, -0.011278549209237099, 0.04057304188609123, -0.03811824694275856, 0.012247554026544094, -0.08481301367282867, 0.09693365544080734, -0.08167368173599243, 0.022096911445260048, 0.02070021629333496, -0.02456321194767952, 0.01883799210190773, -0.02942301519215107, -0.04761003702878952, -0.011314534582197666, -0.06636861711740494, 0.09079285711050034, -0.07182502001523972, 0.051080767065286636, -0.009818220511078835, 0.014225856401026249, -0.04621896147727966, -0.08536213636398315, -0.04566947743296623, -0.02779293991625309, 0.06256603449583054, 0.004681041929870844, 0.0641503855586052, -0.032237324863672256, 0.0312955416738987, 0.02263004519045353, -0.010014821775257587, 0.09739036858081818, -0.02293970435857773, 0.016150623559951782, 0.04055589810013771, -0.07331833243370056, -0.009258664213120937, -0.047650691121816635, -0.030302559956908226, 0.05915096029639244, 0.09496024996042252, -0.05377962067723274, -0.04654764384031296, -0.027894647791981697, -0.009614693932235241, -0.024238046258687973, -0.029049115255475044, -0.011027347296476364, 0.012104162946343422, -0.032473281025886536, -0.009202967397868633, 0.0026482148095965385, -0.009691094979643822, -0.04139268770813942, 0.01559288427233696, -0.06736747920513153, -0.07414286583662033, 0.020716145634651184, -0.052602119743824005, 0.11056945472955704, -0.01016327179968357, 0.06104114279150963, -0.003249790985137224, 0.01487873774021864, -0.028668582439422607, -0.03842996433377266, -0.04909807816147804, 0.01856812834739685, -0.011848165653645992, 0.03814265877008438, 0.037713997066020966, -0.07107577472925186, -0.017100578173995018, 0.009937449358403683, 0.05016010254621506, 0.03622068092226982, -0.010800832882523537, 0.0196208618581295, 0.02516784332692623, 0.0035148216411471367, -0.03334106504917145, -0.029361553490161896, -0.0064813136123120785, 0.07402115315198898, -0.04964166507124901, -0.11422131210565567, 0.025613712146878242, 0.008823307231068611, -0.01872311718761921, 0.028554998338222504, 0.01336525846272707, -0.033866383135318756, -0.006166660226881504, 0.02082938514649868, 0.02708764187991619, -0.011895604431629181, 0.04675259068608284, 0.08768146485090256, 0.029210949316620827, 0.012709800153970718, 0.04707992076873779, 0.07750186324119568, 0.04194869101047516, -0.03090488538146019, 0.040942296385765076, -0.012923937290906906, -0.008575569838285446, -0.011755088344216347, -0.01150447130203247, -0.03982497751712799, 0.005180255975574255, -0.04937024414539337, -0.009537571109831333, -0.03747457638382912, 0.005331138148903847, 0.025703156366944313, -0.050766926258802414, 0.07178107649087906, 0.023525487631559372, -0.01725616678595543, 0.05716446042060852, 0.04367036744952202, -0.11328309774398804, -0.015266019850969315, -0.016821976751089096, -0.006706122308969498, -0.0315990224480629, 0.042790487408638, 0.004177535884082317, -0.044760506600141525, -0.012205059640109539, 0.030026771128177643, 0.033082131296396255, -0.013411187566816807, -0.056959524750709534, 0.03714122623205185, 0.037740178406238556, -0.05355926603078842, -0.024429624900221825, -0.005599860101938248, -0.0161193385720253, -0.024904586374759674, 0.016613321378827095, -0.030524389818310738, -0.024689368903636932, 0.056786540895700455, 0.02478807605803013, 0.016486121341586113, -0.012475022114813328, -0.0035692397505044937, 0.008662071079015732, 0.04965214431285858, 0.06414074450731277, -0.009376218542456627, 0.04464365169405937, -0.010631651617586613, 0.07212934643030167, 0.005303245037794113, 0.001800120109692216, 0.031138749793171883, 0.029267191886901855, 0.06233121454715729, -0.06226305663585663, 0.01834797114133835 ]
107
107
An optimization problem on the sphere
We prove existence and uniqueness of the minimizer for the average geodesic distance to the points of a geodesically convex set on the sphere. This implies a corresponding existence and uniqueness result for an optimal algorithm for halfspace learning, when data and target functions are drawn from the uniform distribution.
[ 0.04714639484882355, -0.044070787727832794, 0.04566871374845505, -0.04496004432439804, -0.03596658632159233, -0.09051700681447983, 0.03327682614326477, -0.035992931574583054, -0.07137548178434372, 0.003857239382341504, 0.07004496455192566, -0.005893736612051725, -0.06614013016223907, 0.07357538491487503, 0.013920605182647705, 0.017535166814923286, -0.03291246294975281, 0.04083751514554024, 0.03147582337260246, -0.01675097458064556, 0.03611287847161293, -0.009648970328271389, -0.00361774698831141, -0.01213306188583374, -0.018056252971291542, -0.03378741815686226, 0.005857693962752819, 0.015596083365380764, -0.012158768251538277, -0.04415192827582359, -0.019170790910720825, -0.005635879468172789, -0.01677621155977249, 0.040702711790800095, 0.00572882778942585, 0.05480065941810608, 0.05388716235756874, 0.014914054423570633, -0.06967123597860336, 0.008049042895436287, 0.004201236180961132, 0.046257514506578445, 0.02555285207927227, -0.044966477900743484, 0.030219564214348793, 0.04344630986452103, -0.014056405052542686, 0.006829468533396721, -0.05717035382986069, 0.044418029487133026, 0.012342915870249271, -0.0008558386471122503, -0.03731771185994148, -0.008424585685133934, 0.0007465553935617208, 0.021629024296998978, 0.0235171839594841, 0.00600970396772027, 0.0222791638225317, 0.00831071101129055, 0.043047040700912476, 0.0626298263669014, -0.07739514857530594, 0.008215001784265041, 0.004513407126069069, -0.0018979491433128715, -0.03626585751771927, -0.013067077845335007, 0.05368327721953392, 0.057114437222480774, -0.0351000651717186, -0.07579702883958817, 0.014763138256967068, 0.07159385830163956, 0.057361241430044174, -0.07327824085950851, -0.007542823441326618, 0.027636198326945305, 0.027136538177728653, 0.08892076462507248, -0.015871837735176086, 0.009824021719396114, 0.00900926161557436, -0.005895765032619238, -0.04678134620189667, -0.042994555085897446, -0.0006238108617253602, 0.03080919198691845, -0.013541002757847309, -0.018668850883841515, 0.05683303251862526, 0.02691207267343998, -0.08268371969461441, 0.0738191306591034, -0.07398172467947006, 0.06946422904729843, 0.033189624547958374, -0.03549572080373764, 0.049649760127067566, 0.06714357435703278, -0.02419547736644745, 0.04900717735290527, 0.04958954453468323, -0.02373442053794861, -0.07566823065280914, 0.048783738166093826, -0.04910093918442726, -0.03880170360207558, 0.009182033129036427, -0.005627509206533432, 0.018300335854291916, 0.08625174313783646, 0.05438601225614548, 0.037816062569618225, -0.07357676327228546, 0.07887663692235947, 0.009470193646848202, 0.06193964183330536, 0.002952365204691887, 0.025523429736495018, -0.011968252249062061, 0.037251874804496765, 0.025757238268852234, -0.008799347095191479, 0.0008780138450674713, 0.028859395533800125, -0.003930198960006237, -0.046665288507938385, 0.10340587049722672, 0.017127586528658867, -0.03002062812447548, 0.010739803314208984, 0.010512210428714752, -0.019160516560077667, -0.081878662109375, 0.043073318898677826, -0.019969942048192024, 0.07741592824459076, -0.034689418971538544, 0.07283554971218109, 0.027517450973391533, -0.040223509073257446, -0.03572250157594681, 0.020849546417593956, 0.08450920879840851, 0.049500592052936554, 0.008989553898572922, 0.021608784794807434, -0.050142113119363785, 0.036436136811971664, 0.02735300175845623, 0.041357289999723434, 0.04391968250274658, -0.01828562468290329, 0.04163088649511337, -0.03144102916121483, 0.02477347105741501, 0.0532265305519104, 0.0233183391392231, 0.04150901734828949, 0.06327490508556366, -0.028449123725295067, 0.04951758310198784, -0.014093946665525436, 0.017655910924077034, -0.045468997210264206, 0.059887342154979706, -0.1460171490907669, 0.015485526993870735, -0.07584575563669205, -0.01294358354061842, -0.10144782811403275, 0.05413544923067093, 0.03711245208978653, -0.003311166539788246, 0.054504260420799255, -0.016733234748244286, 0.05087476968765259, -0.0063042594119906425, -0.03270532935857773, -0.018113721162080765, 0.008001195266842842, 0.014727845788002014, 0.06521289050579071, -0.023067103698849678, 0.06426066905260086, 0.10074684023857117, 0.04644053801894188, 0.03317400813102722, 0.01682562194764614, 0.03750737011432648, -0.012587468139827251, 0.053241271525621414, -0.021194014698266983, -0.045983538031578064, 0.0159308984875679, -0.030523881316184998, -0.01681968756020069, 0.0694645419716835, 0.02629494108259678, 0.030019253492355347, 0.002395673654973507, -0.039473894983530045, 0.044027622789144516, -0.022305648773908615, -0.04596954584121704, -0.021958310157060623, -0.07400302588939667, 0.00495463190600276, -0.043008506298065186, -0.06505367159843445, -0.02890513278543949, -0.025413179770112038, -0.02543138712644577, -0.06706324219703674, 0.08223921805620193, 0.013372096233069897, -0.03004099242389202, 0.04340370371937752, -0.017431722953915596, -0.018797341734170914, -0.00009093793050851673, -0.05180331692099571, -0.0055055455304682255, -0.008598988875746727, 0.03738680109381676, -0.011242150329053402, 0.016723114997148514, -0.10627715289592743, 0.012861456722021103, -0.03876678645610809, -0.025163505226373672, 0.0012657991610467434, -0.008528057485818863, -0.030882837250828743, -0.004944012500345707, 0.019678307697176933, 0.011422254145145416, -0.05656268075108528, -0.023570949211716652, -0.001246122526936233, 0.05077313631772995, 0.027807602658867836, 0.014369918964803219, 0.06299357116222382, 0.0013579981168732047, 0.028277717530727386, -0.04393717274069786, 0.001531776855699718, 0.007580767385661602, -0.02284565195441246, 0.05121777951717377, 0.032473646104335785, -0.08504465967416763, 0.0037829054053872824, -0.00008232941763708368, -0.05589018017053604, -0.027499273419380188, 0.05788363888859749, 0.05905480310320854, 0.021050836890935898, 0.08328388631343842, -0.021983927115797997, 0.054362837225198746, 0.02646990679204464, -0.07198426872491837, 0.015285036526620388, 0.05807259678840637, -0.025845970958471298, 0.0014561312273144722, 0.032850559800863266, -0.08428982645273209, -0.10293512791395187, 0.033992305397987366, 0.010241985321044922, 0.04587934538722038, 0.10865283757448196, 0.056206002831459045, 0.01520545594394207, 0.008635155856609344, -0.10044251382350922, 0.0005318851908668876, 0.05041146278381348, -0.03654414042830467, -0.03200303018093109, 0.0016842549666762352, -0.018767857924103737, -0.024449963122606277, 0.005289446096867323, -0.012116978876292706, 0.013571985065937042, -0.07397010922431946, -0.028333311900496483, -0.054558165371418, 0.045951806008815765, -0.01843804121017456, 0.02779979445040226, 0.0059287953190505505, -0.024032194167375565, -0.023503361269831657, -0.0640600323677063, -0.053766731172800064, 0.025519315153360367, 0.06481961160898209, -0.011554633267223835, -0.026825521141290665, 0.013559054583311081, -0.004060689359903336, -0.07266932725906372, 0.005706715397536755, 0.028189891949295998, -0.003929093945771456, -0.007161534857004881, -0.03023700788617134, 0.061384011059999466, -0.04728150740265846, 0.016928892582654953, 0.03687489405274391, -0.031591132283210754, -0.03492128849029541, 0.0018590956460684538, -0.03476286306977272, 0.07163134217262268, -0.01067409012466669, -0.13909195363521576, 0.003099908586591482, 0.02331596612930298, -0.01789047010242939, -0.11138932406902313, 0.011329976841807365, 0.003885160433128476, 0.04540636017918587, -0.044621791690588, 0.054063815623521805, -0.05369501933455467, 0.026108387857675552, -0.06917545199394226, -0.03462083265185356, -0.06048550829291344, -0.023536967113614082, -0.02545640431344509, -0.05481243133544922, 0.009128148667514324, -0.09077973663806915, 0.017084790393710136, 0.03165498003363609, 0.029813867062330246, 0.02439502440392971, -0.0524919368326664, 0.11695974320173264, -0.07364778220653534, -0.025368453934788704, -0.07356489449739456, 0.004976619500666857, -0.034162335097789764, 0.01992034539580345, 0.023487932980060577, 0.020924683660268784, -0.02304399013519287, 0.04806763678789139, -0.04840981960296631, 0.054956696927547455, -0.0445820651948452, -0.019524266943335533, 0.005878389813005924, 0.06336847692728043, -0.06142449006438255, -0.015130185522139072, -0.09560881555080414, -0.04388651251792908, -0.06404991447925568, 0.03688020631670952, 0.044800661504268646, -0.03539315238595009, 0.07293087244033813, 0.013469042256474495, 0.08573652803897858, -0.01018386147916317, -0.03182712942361832, 0.03782930597662926, 0.03449839726090431, 0.020989129319787025, -0.008709552697837353, -0.01808561198413372, 0.01205382589250803, -0.006151281762868166, 0.03363712504506111, 0.03849681094288826, 0.08104762434959412, 0.011009123176336288, 0.04031580314040184, -0.05736298859119415, 0.015073326416313648, 0.022090580314397812, 0.011946884915232658, -0.03355548158288002, 0.019273078069090843, 0.04687819257378578, -0.017382126301527023, 0.01646466553211212, 0.0028502969071269035, 0.013139630667865276, -0.006659562699496746, -0.0017663657199591398, -0.04725146293640137, 0.014643704518675804, -0.006844960153102875, 0.01097205001860857, -0.0068451473489403725, 0.008752466179430485, 0.008698301389813423, 0.03684293478727341, 0.0002765968383755535, 0.11077116429805756, 0.0013644944410771132, 0.02918878383934498, -0.04087674245238304, 0.04545732960104942, 0.022545110434293747, 0.022042294964194298, -0.018842890858650208, -0.00972403772175312, -0.005633099935948849, 0.01762363314628601, 0.06236047297716141, -0.03313802555203438, -0.031732428818941116, 0.11332125216722488, 0.04379793629050255, 0.051735855638980865, -0.04156661033630371, -0.07178924977779388, -0.03787117078900337, 0.008239813148975372, 0.024118490517139435, -0.03690556436777115, 0.012153145857155323, -0.06208837404847145, -0.02399294264614582, 0.0006187199032865465, -0.027103617787361145, 0.1048649400472641, -0.02623472362756729, -0.027455298230051994, -0.07831989973783493, 0.04264188930392265, 0.007725690957158804, -0.0040188999846577644, 0.09424681961536407, 0.008062504231929779, -0.020066140219569206, -0.0015655081951990724, -0.004140457604080439, 0.035113245248794556, 0.07523249834775925, -0.02674940787255764, -0.008408969268202782, -0.007336937822401524, 0.014244175516068935, -0.061540424823760986, -0.0614289864897728, -0.011732597835361958, 0.008493547327816486, 0.054772548377513885, -0.051190655678510666, 0.03932072967290878, -0.018169626593589783, 0.041721150279045105, 0.05203718692064285, -0.025924520567059517, -0.1002345010638237, 0.039644863456487656, -0.017805516719818115, -0.05436364933848381, 0.029884953051805496, -0.04113398864865303, 0.007997649721801281, -0.00835737306624651, 0.008248432539403439, 0.031933318823575974, -0.006706474348902702, 0.0061571961268782616, -0.10073372721672058, -0.004300931002944708, 0.06294361501932144, 0.07524046301841736, -0.017411859706044197, 0.054909598082304, 0.0719306692481041, -0.019842762500047684, -0.0008421586826443672, 0.028436005115509033, -0.08104237914085388, -0.03564576432108879, -0.04859159514307976, -0.007492257747799158, 0.03281717374920845, -0.07120907306671143, 0.1075829342007637, -0.01217513345181942, -0.010616746731102467, -0.007604789454489946, -0.020017089322209358, 0.030647531151771545, 0.07384345680475235, -0.004260578658431768, 0.034546997398138046, 0.02700459398329258, -0.05422397702932358, 0.08292695879936218, 0.01526910811662674, 0.07345408201217651 ]
108
108
A Kernel Method for the Two-Sample Problem
We propose a framework for analyzing and comparing distributions, allowing us to design statistical tests to determine if two samples are drawn from different distributions. Our test statistic is the largest difference in expectations over functions in the unit ball of a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS). We present two tests based on large deviation bounds for the test statistic, while a third is based on the asymptotic distribution of this statistic. The test statistic can be computed in quadratic time, although efficient linear time approximations are available. Several classical metrics on distributions are recovered when the function space used to compute the difference in expectations is allowed to be more general (eg. a Banach space). We apply our two-sample tests to a variety of problems, including attribute matching for databases using the Hungarian marriage method, where they perform strongly. Excellent performance is also obtained when comparing distributions over graphs, for which these are the first such tests.
[ -0.0410514734685421, -0.03889549523591995, 0.11353568732738495, -0.03755082190036774, -0.009269866161048412, -0.010654279962182045, -0.025457290932536125, -0.012657571583986282, -0.010190022177994251, 0.03667313605546951, 0.039369773119688034, -0.03708130493760109, -0.0029333720449358225, 0.11990107595920563, 0.026309562847018242, 0.014591001905500889, 0.032561399042606354, -0.0071642035618424416, 0.022224729880690575, 0.0034157675690948963, 0.03604055196046829, 0.05174224078655243, 0.01493573933839798, -0.06470196694135666, -0.038119543343782425, -0.015358328819274902, 0.02901681326329708, 0.045947395265102386, -0.08960512280464172, -0.02515219897031784, -0.05608673393726349, 0.058436207473278046, 0.026317523792386055, -0.011440929025411606, -0.0095448549836874, 0.039382386952638626, 0.014371776022017002, -0.021497366949915886, -0.08085095882415771, -0.002486343029886484, 0.0345822274684906, -0.06515999883413315, -0.022021260112524033, 0.05781063437461853, 0.020657749846577644, 0.037932075560092926, -0.022878378629684448, 0.07863906770944595, 0.06488948315382004, 0.06175974756479263, -0.09212256968021393, 0.016581518575549126, -0.0006524359923787415, 0.050133172422647476, -0.059297993779182434, 0.08584385365247726, -0.006334755569696426, 0.08045504987239838, 0.032723620533943176, 0.007628508377820253, 0.04486365243792534, 0.11433517187833786, -0.002021506894379854, 0.01416600588709116, 0.044453538954257965, -0.05430914834141731, -0.07629543542861938, -0.01958915963768959, -0.004372991155833006, -0.07494045794010162, 0.04499758780002594, -0.034046102315187454, -0.02714141272008419, 0.09551522880792618, 0.01920274645090103, -0.0022244215942919254, -0.04121404141187668, 0.030613461509346962, 0.020975707098841667, 0.10384175926446915, -0.001036743400618434, 0.06145976111292839, -0.039788778871297836, -0.07091392576694489, -0.030168315395712852, 0.002628610236570239, 0.03574216365814209, 0.010142468847334385, 0.010117674246430397, 0.0055772396735847, -0.0690762996673584, -0.013602781109511852, -0.05047113820910454, 0.0562405101954937, -0.02084181271493435, 0.06304843723773956, -0.009158381260931492, 0.01631072536110878, 0.028341230005025864, 0.02869226597249508, 0.0077722081914544106, -0.1074473187327385, 0.03322182968258858, 0.023590030148625374, -0.0022423211485147476, 0.02396015264093876, 0.007068451028317213, 0.043585944920778275, -0.04293190315365791, -0.08117841929197311, 0.05874108150601387, -0.01747736521065235, -0.006058334838598967, -0.0030350126326084137, -0.04076651483774185, 0.12359986454248428, -0.0060057444497942924, 0.08196938782930374, 0.018399305641651154, 0.08000354468822479, -0.033733487129211426, -0.04721461981534958, -0.010893234051764011, 0.0033866036683321, 0.07323813438415527, -0.035069841891527176, -0.03511752933263779, -0.04261741042137146, 0.053597383201122284, -0.0010017526801675558, -0.05281218886375427, 0.0005994006642140448, -0.0699734091758728, 0.0010722886072471738, -0.028221145272254944, -0.0031748958863317966, -0.0060737174935638905, 0.08813219517469406, 0.024075988680124283, 0.06193827465176582, 0.01323936227709055, 0.011607053689658642, -0.0002853416372090578, 0.026708608493208885, 0.02675192430615425, 0.018852628767490387, -0.03758910298347473, 0.012817212380468845, 0.008570854552090168, -0.02770945243537426, 0.05318367853760719, -0.08026503771543503, -0.01041423249989748, 0.0445636510848999, -0.01970824785530567, -0.05291060730814934, -0.07326765358448029, 0.0018937693675979972, -0.043205685913562775, 0.04755125939846039, 0.06904469430446625, -0.0377618744969368, 0.003982472233474255, -0.05268656089901924, 0.034722425043582916, -0.017104458063840866, 0.0393676683306694, -0.005832482594996691, -0.02030208520591259, -0.044116586446762085, -0.03562062233686447, -0.014308414421975613, -0.020627349615097046, -0.004394330084323883, 0.029312336817383766, -0.039535488933324814, -0.018223505467176437, -0.0021616925951093435, -0.0020681798923760653, -0.0657670646905899, 0.03550746291875839, -0.0874057188630104, -0.028062336146831512, 0.02550729177892208, -0.03408592566847801, 0.06483162194490433, -0.01867755316197872, 0.03697573393583298, 0.029228851199150085, 0.03982913866639137, 0.06898248940706253, 0.03219417855143547, 0.06442702561616898, -0.06390306353569031, -0.08844829350709915, -0.01112067885696888, -0.05155063420534134, -0.021742884069681168, 0.0357726514339447, 0.01584579050540924, 0.05276481434702873, -0.06658372282981873, -0.07821260392665863, -0.02051226980984211, 0.0017356335883960128, 0.084884412586689, -0.014955160208046436, -0.028096865862607956, -0.04636184126138687, -0.052948497235774994, -0.012798313051462173, -0.015052903443574905, -0.07335599511861801, -0.08346375823020935, 0.02551213651895523, -0.03284838795661926, -0.040028270334005356, -0.011573659256100655, -0.00009434554522158578, -0.052886687219142914, -0.032763924449682236, 0.03400490805506706, -0.03546695038676262, 0.08114262670278549, -0.0524616464972496, -0.0050032734870910645, -0.034954652190208435, -0.0033971990924328566, 0.022449340671300888, 0.0028835709672421217, -0.054557718336582184, 0.0028299761470407248, -0.009162061847746372, -0.0045662615448236465, -0.02198120206594467, 0.003681719535961747, -0.054081667214632034, -0.006176456343382597, 0.03626209869980812, 0.014986330643296242, -0.028302840888500214, 0.056453604251146317, -0.02047850377857685, -0.00843719020485878, -0.07435358315706253, -0.023770395666360855, -0.0015156222507357597, 0.07992468774318695, -0.03350247070193291, 0.0174055527895689, -0.008695683442056179, -0.053948935121297836, -0.005310745909810066, -0.06511489301919937, -0.0045394026674330235, 0.04758083447813988, -0.011184873059391975, 0.037031140178442, -0.020617986097931862, 0.0909026488661766, 0.08064910769462585, 0.03166819363832474, -0.06478483974933624, -0.036792829632759094, 0.045825909823179245, -0.03564061224460602, 0.01966021955013275, 0.05608882009983063, 0.003639998845756054, -0.012688894756138325, -0.000981516088359058, -0.18366733193397522, -0.01622513309121132, 0.08520626276731491, -0.024144932627677917, -0.048463452607393265, 0.1022416353225708, 0.0772596225142479, -0.035138122737407684, -0.03170264884829521, -0.009639590047299862, -0.021083595231175423, -0.0018526592757552862, 0.045067597180604935, -0.04432162269949913, 0.04374491423368454, -0.05628614500164986, 0.008457565680146217, -0.007000071927905083, -0.06880085170269012, 0.01703774742782116, 0.023763956502079964, -0.10809484124183655, -0.06353068351745605, 0.018488937988877296, 0.018879108130931854, 0.026456443592905998, -0.003147643990814686, 0.06632103025913239, 0.002962922677397728, -0.022790901362895966, 0.05414751172065735, 0.04841196537017822, 0.0032335245050489902, 0.039624009281396866, -0.03640175238251686, 0.0011072535999119282, 0.0018183873035013676, -0.03890395164489746, 0.022159067913889885, -0.017788037657737732, -0.0761844590306282, 0.009748341515660286, -0.02182672545313835, 0.01776699908077717, -0.12114834040403366, 0.002743274439126253, 0.00929955579340458, 0.021273240447044373, 0.07149497419595718, 0.018224993720650673, -0.025369413197040558, 0.02785843051970005, -0.0015436311950907111, -0.06235892325639725, 0.004760148003697395, 0.08368442207574844, 0.012897479347884655, -0.062365759164094925, -0.002878437517210841, -0.059245798736810684, 0.04778270795941353, 0.006412755697965622, 0.1102558821439743, -0.03215036168694496, 0.004462916869670153, -0.006062941160053015, -0.017539646476507187, 0.0033998070284724236, 0.04547777399420738, -0.028557531535625458, -0.07452453672885895, 0.017692651599645615, -0.036616742610931396, 0.03498345613479614, 0.09983095526695251, 0.04409560188651085, -0.049557026475667953, -0.07097543030977249, -0.0079498877748847, -0.046837218105793, 0.013785019516944885, 0.027335790917277336, -0.04191355034708977, -0.01664878986775875, 0.050850480794906616, 0.016744859516620636, -0.030695803463459015, 0.04997161403298378, 0.10188891738653183, -0.03728046268224716, 0.04358207434415817, -0.013826352544128895, 0.09379050135612488, 0.029894178733229637, -0.022498372942209244, -0.05960987135767937, 0.059048786759376526, -0.028070267289876938, 0.06443695724010468, 0.012039847671985626, 0.052565958350896835, 0.08056589961051941, 0.03772936761379242, -0.006471088621765375, 0.02425076626241207, -0.015470101498067379, -0.010953960008919239, -0.06402568519115448, 0.06064538657665253, -0.0699152946472168, 0.046701379120349884, -0.015361638739705086, 0.02750556170940399, 0.03317661210894585, 0.01307162456214428, 0.008623545989394188, 0.04758251830935478, -0.01107251551002264, 0.031242527067661285, 0.030817221850156784, -0.04281584545969963, 0.027769623324275017, 0.02185233309864998, 0.04489368200302124, 0.06797698885202408, 0.010034140199422836, -0.025990713387727737, -0.07259170711040497, -0.0308701004832983, 0.02581825479865074, -0.0792422741651535, -0.051531821489334106, -0.05787593126296997, -0.06476311385631561, 0.03188640996813774, 0.020883634686470032, 0.0462997704744339, -0.011476093903183937, 0.023628827184438705, -0.02994435466825962, -0.04587391018867493, -0.0874173492193222, 0.04991380125284195, 0.014144607819616795, -0.03211895748972893, 0.002715658163651824, 0.01159292459487915, -0.04987797886133194, -0.01171131432056427, 0.042417000979185104, 0.04449930787086487, 0.06462032347917557, -0.01634008064866066, -0.05802374705672264, -0.03806537389755249, 0.016418682411313057, 0.03239351138472557, 0.0718097910284996, 0.01258769165724516, -0.005475601647049189, -0.03032534196972847, -0.051023148000240326, 0.04767370596528053, -0.0021675757598131895, -0.04578109830617905, 0.049976710230112076, -0.023625606670975685, -0.015470143407583237, -0.06580528616905212, -0.049078986048698425, -0.007151713594794273, 0.03448642045259476, 0.02769758738577366, 0.005836512893438339, 0.009643781930208206, -0.0006492069805972278, 0.022185077890753746, 0.023983445018529892, 0.03264246881008148, 0.04100353270769119, 0.007471439894288778, -0.00880222674459219, -0.00942910835146904, -0.011907077394425869, -0.026281943544745445, -0.0013034564908593893, 0.027012642472982407, 0.024295177310705185, 0.013037524186074734, -0.015735765919089317, -0.07320288568735123, -0.013198524713516235, 0.10561178624629974, -0.03633538633584976, 0.028644897043704987, 0.024977892637252808, 0.037867214530706406, 0.08740875869989395, 0.007769764866679907, -0.04221326857805252, -0.0280536450445652, -0.014080083929002285, -0.008797852322459221, -0.018217185512185097, -0.0016006657388061285, -0.009763033129274845, -0.042763326317071915, 0.05862455070018768, -0.08425815403461456, 0.02061307802796364, 0.025454487651586533, -0.006337404251098633, -0.05976240336894989, 0.05734500288963318, 0.0021733560133725405, -0.009528273716568947, 0.002674135146662593, 0.011441776528954506, -0.04591459408402443, 0.0034430217929184437, 0.022727809846401215, -0.04743144288659096, 0.0066575417295098305, -0.05995279923081398, 0.006836196407675743, -0.011708651669323444, -0.020615728572010994, -0.007418058346956968, -0.013906847685575485, 0.007431633770465851, 0.024373285472393036, -0.01910432055592537, 0.013286714442074299, 0.03804145008325577, 0.024114158004522324, 0.024087686091661453, -0.017505047842860222, 0.013641750440001488, 0.032500360161066055, 0.04486365243792534, 0.02302812971174717 ]
109
109
The Margitron: A Generalised Perceptron with Margin
We identify the classical Perceptron algorithm with margin as a member of a broader family of large margin classifiers which we collectively call the Margitron. The Margitron, (despite its) sharing the same update rule with the Perceptron, is shown in an incremental setting to converge in a finite number of updates to solutions possessing any desirable fraction of the maximum margin. Experiments comparing the Margitron with decomposition SVMs on tasks involving linear kernels and 2-norm soft margin are also reported.
[ -0.029822466894984245, -0.09335525333881378, 0.08799915015697479, -0.014639199711382389, 0.023060686886310577, -0.051820747554302216, 0.0016837631119415164, 0.04509153962135315, -0.099642314016819, -0.02015681192278862, 0.027159860357642174, -0.0044593834318220615, -0.062195006757974625, 0.05962982028722763, 0.058070532977581024, 0.05286134406924248, 0.024923808872699738, -0.05021267384290695, -0.08689245581626892, -0.07230078428983688, 0.044316936284303665, -0.04415963590145111, 0.015472511760890484, -0.08161228150129318, 0.03372315317392349, 0.06038947403430939, -0.046231985092163086, -0.00668037123978138, -0.006941625382751226, -0.014549721963703632, -0.016143757849931717, -0.02013089507818222, -0.012559279799461365, 0.012652917765080929, 0.0044204615987837315, 0.005959539674222469, 0.016811903566122055, -0.02724963240325451, -0.06456594169139862, -0.03626164421439171, -0.01698984205722809, -0.028403760865330696, -0.007444649934768677, -0.0022202397231012583, 0.031293727457523346, 0.03707831725478172, 0.027066925540566444, -0.027648430317640305, 0.003157866420224309, 0.09935162216424942, 0.017933350056409836, 0.014845273457467556, -0.06475280970335007, -0.04038800671696663, 0.017357422038912773, -0.009514717385172844, -0.045709870755672455, -0.04273311048746109, 0.00900245364755392, -0.013264440931379795, 0.012930171564221382, 0.0541946105659008, 0.006604701746255159, -0.024329345673322678, -0.02765745110809803, -0.07542528957128525, -0.04407748952507973, -0.02414058707654476, 0.02829417586326599, -0.027066664770245552, 0.04131161794066429, -0.07857195287942886, 0.06522052735090256, 0.10368825495243073, 0.03275818005204201, 0.0017879136139526963, -0.04159373790025711, -0.00036502143484540284, 0.06199285015463829, 0.05060262233018875, -0.04163578525185585, -0.038264837116003036, 0.006103075575083494, 0.06473561376333237, 0.04096788913011551, -0.030118661001324654, 0.010640080086886883, 0.016498392447829247, -0.05560127645730972, -0.09050086885690689, -0.007697048597037792, 0.009427306242287159, -0.06578154116868973, 0.019269539043307304, -0.024120545014739037, -0.020270653069019318, 0.006791942752897739, -0.024785466492176056, 0.007695899344980717, -0.007305149920284748, -0.031708456575870514, 0.03369693085551262, 0.030297741293907166, 0.05816510319709778, -0.0245038028806448, -0.024168064817786217, -0.06548570096492767, -0.027545105665922165, -0.0025574483443051577, 0.02380366623401642, 0.024705609306693077, 0.007829457521438599, 0.002420647768303752, 0.016955461353063583, -0.032207638025283813, 0.07602829486131668, -0.041715748608112335, -0.0035443443339318037, 0.07148312777280807, 0.019054092466831207, -0.03938589245080948, -0.0009468427742831409, -0.03288111463189125, 0.06717757135629654, 0.005637770052999258, -0.05882854759693146, -0.028767917305231094, -0.05890979617834091, 0.0967973992228508, -0.052349645644426346, -0.06984329968690872, 0.062166426330804825, 0.04668924957513809, 0.027158614248037338, -0.06121181696653366, 0.04121524468064308, 0.020269013941287994, -0.10844459384679794, -0.07652710378170013, 0.04795731231570244, -0.03476567938923836, 0.03641996905207634, -0.0024495127145200968, -0.019178885966539383, 0.01985597424209118, 0.041976574808359146, 0.026713307946920395, 0.01863154023885727, 0.050368573516607285, 0.0004861963680014014, 0.008785619400441647, -0.012113911099731922, 0.025687428191304207, 0.03363025560975075, 0.06888397783041, -0.059559695422649384, 0.018360646441578865, -0.0378277450799942, 0.0028436463326215744, 0.034561704844236374, -0.06660190224647522, -0.014074794016778469, 0.03396131098270416, 0.03273225948214531, -0.024315020069479942, -0.05092326179146767, 0.010835330002009869, -0.02957872673869133, -0.04360601305961609, -0.06383539736270905, -0.04690059274435043, -0.02896822802722454, -0.011747661046683788, 0.02743702568113804, 0.012566843070089817, -0.018782803788781166, 0.01129373162984848, 0.029457639902830124, -0.01982458122074604, -0.0569649375975132, 0.024671437218785286, -0.002289014169946313, -0.009611367247998714, 0.008312040008604527, 0.09252212196588516, 0.0968838483095169, 0.02831103838980198, 0.09967438876628876, 0.058932315558195114, -0.0006215716130100191, 0.05304187163710594, -0.04365233704447746, 0.006482921075075865, 0.0004567445139400661, -0.07515446841716766, 0.005398248787969351, -0.025593191385269165, -0.027837557718157768, -0.009091190993785858, 0.10131913423538208, 0.043294284492731094, -0.05469060316681862, 0.016278240829706192, -0.0497828871011734, 0.008239395916461945, 0.03294985368847847, 0.033490780740976334, -0.021408524364233017, 0.023246129974722862, -0.005335901398211718, -0.03158922120928764, 0.03842373564839363, 0.0022848094813525677, -0.018734097480773926, -0.018539639189839363, -0.08589240908622742, 0.013849237933754921, 0.010681193321943283, 0.07558464258909225, 0.059171389788389206, 0.010461168363690376, 0.05399045720696449, -0.011583403684198856, 0.0564766451716423, -0.02762901782989502, 0.08161307126283646, 0.004432675428688526, -0.053702957928180695, -0.09316370636224747, 0.0802660807967186, -0.03785596787929535, -0.07465529441833496, -0.003021382261067629, -0.03408464789390564, -0.03813626617193222, 0.07399392873048782, -0.1040349006652832, 0.009655187837779522, -0.004259136039763689, -0.020954405888915062, -0.016932811588048935, -0.010311998426914215, 0.002547969575971365, -0.05415918678045273, -0.024148287251591682, -0.0032329573296010494, -0.009650662541389465, 0.040322743356227875, -0.025984209030866623, -0.029141847044229507, 0.051061589270830154, 0.06052515655755997, -0.03343198448419571, -0.04458816722035408, -0.008123014122247696, 0.02248808741569519, 0.028889061883091927, 0.040139179676771164, 0.04185806214809418, 0.07758965343236923, -0.018873827531933784, -0.023119056597352028, -0.06188078224658966, -0.04233211651444435, 0.04392116516828537, 0.035717759281396866, -0.07191586494445801, 0.0029619529377669096, -0.013683777302503586, -0.026167502626776695, -0.011869877576828003, -0.08685553818941116, -0.01654585637152195, 0.03657931834459305, -0.010660952888429165, 0.09213698655366898, 0.008340490981936455, -0.014207452535629272, 0.020775940269231796, 0.020753847435116768, -0.05497261509299278, -0.024427732452750206, -0.0529828779399395, -0.051787856966257095, -0.012733924202620983, 0.053773727267980576, -0.02024620771408081, -0.02070428989827633, 0.033410072326660156, 0.035533081740140915, -0.03736766800284386, 0.06512557715177536, -0.03147348016500473, 0.007266041357070208, -0.03484571352601051, -0.08166186511516571, 0.03548027202486992, -0.051936063915491104, 0.024158336222171783, -0.0006003691232763231, 0.041414812207221985, 0.0165595393627882, 0.06409881263971329, 0.016673849895596504, 0.003761607687920332, 0.0175362266600132, 0.047066543251276016, 0.03812810778617859, -0.07466958463191986, 0.024199314415454865, 0.0344223752617836, -0.018772702664136887, 0.0013638571836054325, -0.07967614382505417, -0.004943032283335924, -0.00579718966037035, -0.011555947363376617, -0.002064245520159602, -0.03429272025823593, -0.014542666263878345, 0.03710868954658508, -0.04326798394322395, -0.017539702355861664, 0.034659191966056824, -0.08981597423553467, -0.04787787050008774, -0.005692791659384966, 0.06889749318361282, -0.12066082656383514, 0.017494596540927887, -0.05557790398597717, -0.0363420732319355, -0.01767917349934578, 0.02285044454038143, 0.043897856026887894, 0.013010064139962196, 0.034575995057821274, -0.010880157351493835, 0.006600844208151102, 0.008843916468322277, -0.06263436377048492, -0.05289020761847496, 0.034596554934978485, -0.0025749094784259796, -0.026599617674946785, 0.009580026380717754, 0.04680129140615463, -0.03431103378534317, -0.03314783796668053, 0.01130019873380661, -0.043958794325590134, 0.09831657260656357, -0.07253842800855637, 0.06947440654039383, -0.010250390507280827, -0.005429192911833525, 0.11534056812524796, -0.03821370378136635, 0.007946436293423176, 0.01066101435571909, -0.0005983735900372267, 0.016938576474785805, -0.08075349777936935, -0.0005718526663258672, 0.003534420160576701, 0.03718426451086998, 0.006729493383318186, -0.020749954506754875, -0.02142866514623165, 0.02561681903898716, -0.057092223316431046, 0.027203906327486038, 0.04070828855037689, 0.02259811758995056, 0.027923863381147385, -0.042600952088832855, 0.03824407979846001, 0.042346369475126266, 0.01306950207799673, 0.05145373195409775, -0.04041481390595436, -0.0063708508387207985, -0.006042960565537214, 0.09879571199417114, -0.019002636894583702, -0.006121106445789337, -0.05136328935623169, 0.02422105334699154, 0.09363242238759995, 0.026913564652204514, -0.03718525543808937, -0.05507969856262207, -0.02220182679593563, 0.03466183692216873, -0.0062073152512311935, 0.030931124463677406, 0.02214987948536873, -0.00403759628534317, -0.06340347975492477, -0.09808337688446045, 0.03079400397837162, -0.020853783935308456, 0.039713162928819656, -0.06525775045156479, -0.0761299803853035, -0.025335252285003662, -0.041259199380874634, 0.07291191816329956, 0.053271498531103134, 0.10256762057542801, 0.07148084044456482, 0.06271412968635559, -0.04190368205308914, -0.01810583472251892, -0.004682205617427826, 0.013278855010867119, 0.006281699985265732, -0.024926917627453804, 0.0028324751183390617, -0.08144757896661758, -0.012522852048277855, 0.09511659294366837, 0.10081419348716736, 0.006844744086265564, -0.027007559314370155, 0.025949282571673393, 0.03151016682386398, 0.14261090755462646, 0.030631253495812416, -0.030874894931912422, -0.08347450941801071, 0.10700727999210358, -0.037524349987506866, -0.03829911723732948, 0.03987358883023262, -0.04562278091907501, 0.05446934700012207, 0.06222643330693245, 0.01057637482881546, -0.0129051823168993, -0.017561648041009903, 0.03336640074849129, -0.025162961333990097, -0.03774769976735115, 0.02736411802470684, 0.04408600926399231, 0.033712536096572876, -0.03613204509019852, 0.0514666847884655, 0.02740810252726078, 0.030801985412836075, 0.019630195572972298, 0.04254503175616264, -0.049361616373062134, -0.06376881897449493, -0.022181667387485504, -0.030972104519605637, -0.04448924586176872, 0.018742220476269722, 0.022993803024291992, -0.019235847517848015, -0.010022003203630447, -0.014657069928944111, 0.0025513372384011745, -0.058712877333164215, -0.012627742253243923, -0.013771927915513515, 0.04977406561374664, -0.023040741682052612, 0.07255130261182785, -0.023022916167974472, 0.030100949108600616, 0.014907526783645153, -0.02463824301958084, 0.039177361875772476, -0.0166932400316, 0.05463416129350662, -0.04839349910616875, -0.014759929850697517, -0.031446557492017746, -0.01045168936252594, -0.060039155185222626, -0.00030061218421906233, 0.023466849699616432, 0.0038167997263371944, -0.045418426394462585, -0.037509918212890625, 0.08095205575227737, 0.05173052102327347, 0.04071149602532387, -0.0443824827671051, 0.017867248505353928, 0.09410832077264786, 0.0182968620210886, -0.00632547028362751, -0.016956541687250137, 0.044253669679164886, -0.0034533338621258736, -0.059413596987724304, 0.04479150101542473, 0.035498179495334625, 0.038817279040813446, 0.0775166004896164, 0.004476549103856087, 0.044843580573797226, -0.00903602410107851, 0.0036264050286263227, 0.01473241951316595, 0.008341524749994278, 0.03464994579553604, -0.07863595336675644, -0.06330195814371109 ]
110
110
Sample Selection Bias Correction Theory
This paper presents a theoretical analysis of sample selection bias correction. The sample bias correction technique commonly used in machine learning consists of reweighting the cost of an error on each training point of a biased sample to more closely reflect the unbiased distribution. This relies on weights derived by various estimation techniques based on finite samples. We analyze the effect of an error in that estimation on the accuracy of the hypothesis returned by the learning algorithm for two estimation techniques: a cluster-based estimation technique and kernel mean matching. We also report the results of sample bias correction experiments with several data sets using these techniques. Our analysis is based on the novel concept of distributional stability which generalizes the existing concept of point-based stability. Much of our work and proof techniques can be used to analyze other importance weighting techniques and their effect on accuracy when using a distributionally stable algorithm.
[ -0.009086388163268566, -0.031066639348864555, 0.02095191553235054, -0.030963214114308357, -0.007962426170706749, -0.03645433858036995, -0.010970819741487503, -0.043392449617385864, -0.04821678251028061, 0.015764828771352768, 0.021364424377679825, -0.019246572628617287, -0.018330583348870277, 0.016179408878087997, 0.001374998246319592, -0.016999341547489166, 0.030578473582863808, -0.03296152502298355, 0.021635353565216064, -0.03212074935436249, -0.03665873408317566, 0.004925603978335857, 0.017421063035726547, -0.030688200145959854, -0.007797467987984419, 0.027250975370407104, 0.019591523334383965, -0.049755726009607315, -0.07602008432149887, 0.06806132942438126, -0.026053188368678093, 0.059760138392448425, -0.03986545652151108, -0.015147591009736061, 0.0019902281928807497, -0.04944293946027756, 0.021192440763115883, 0.011411427520215511, -0.01131085678935051, -0.03854726254940033, 0.06468475610017776, -0.052446577697992325, 0.0037341092247515917, 0.009260604158043861, 0.04822881892323494, 0.027041422203183174, 0.08677978068590164, -0.0009800293482840061, -0.015268987976014614, 0.018498437479138374, -0.06396054476499557, 0.02074829861521721, -0.022634610533714294, 0.0001510825240984559, 0.01209284644573927, 0.017124569043517113, 0.0012176857562735677, 0.007162701338529587, -0.03437976911664009, 0.011617254465818405, 0.05789487808942795, 0.112278051674366, -0.00378962280228734, -0.09095995873212814, -0.009761475957930088, -0.051794055849313736, -0.042365219444036484, -0.022843310609459877, -0.02970423735678196, -0.0815470889210701, 0.02144550532102585, -0.03394629433751106, 0.02578173205256462, 0.08660811930894852, 0.02237367443740368, -0.026295771822333336, -0.018680602312088013, 0.05142159387469292, 0.10485024005174637, 0.05233065038919449, -0.033966682851314545, 0.0333586186170578, 0.0007004781509749591, 0.022133246064186096, -0.06324184685945511, 0.018250280991196632, -0.03605077415704727, 0.012889563106000423, 0.06193718686699867, 0.025377260521054268, -0.04939083009958267, 0.040419649332761765, -0.020588478073477745, -0.02473384700715542, -0.059977710247039795, 0.041211385279893875, -0.014774897135794163, 0.027611056342720985, -0.00005568445340031758, 0.05950048193335533, -0.06115220487117767, -0.0848393663764, 0.02798219956457615, 0.08260355144739151, 0.011450457386672497, 0.014681180939078331, -0.011034446768462658, 0.07746993005275726, 0.012964725494384766, 0.004303994122892618, 0.029399951919913292, -0.09969596564769745, -0.013662930577993393, -0.010070514865219593, -0.08223401010036469, 0.03928595781326294, -0.01634865067899227, 0.019015248864889145, 0.032474614679813385, 0.024195684120059013, 0.061019230633974075, -0.007345146499574184, -0.0570230595767498, 0.006539774127304554, 0.04815872758626938, -0.03171088546514511, 0.020438438281416893, -0.11981458216905594, 0.07163651287555695, -0.0566701665520668, -0.07534971088171005, 0.01804623194038868, -0.06183597072958946, -0.0056983474642038345, -0.012806602753698826, 0.05165472999215126, -0.0010942593216896057, -0.036553844809532166, 0.003244121093302965, 0.050092265009880066, -0.02256922610104084, -0.007087681908160448, -0.03245944529771805, 0.02038842812180519, -0.00020703920745290816, -0.004983997438102961, 0.03460278362035751, -0.0024752572644501925, -0.04387260228395462, 0.010861080139875412, 0.010760074481368065, -0.006277174688875675, 0.04480332136154175, 0.057509444653987885, 0.04715809226036072, -0.061510566622018814, -0.019570080563426018, 0.002813026076182723, -0.05131463706493378, 0.07281912863254547, 0.009318828582763672, 0.04621647670865059, 0.08328794687986374, -0.04568610340356827, -0.02521950751543045, 0.035420503467321396, -0.008922413922846317, 0.04747716709971428, -0.014980796724557877, -0.046946775168180466, -0.018630292266607285, 0.10797933489084244, -0.03106846660375595, -0.03241095691919327, 0.022155240178108215, 0.0004236304957885295, 0.0038809694815427065, 0.037372808903455734, -0.007882297039031982, 0.015504192560911179, -0.002652228344231844, -0.06247701868414879, -0.0068595330230891705, 0.013335081748664379, 0.029444443061947823, 0.08523906767368317, -0.003732978831976652, 0.07307235151529312, 0.02256162092089653, 0.0438648946583271, 0.007546492852270603, -0.03490357846021652, -0.025698311626911163, -0.08342219144105911, -0.07851661741733551, 0.04028385877609253, -0.016923120245337486, -0.00577920489013195, 0.045630503445863724, 0.06429573148488998, 0.04870540648698807, 0.0024456214159727097, 0.006599840708076954, -0.05768638476729393, -0.04494743421673775, 0.0006205143872648478, 0.09492917358875275, -0.09930246323347092, 0.014651162549853325, -0.07606565207242966, 0.04322291165590286, 0.007818907499313354, 0.07136766612529755, -0.060899827629327774, -0.0006940726889297366, -0.029226213693618774, -0.0365082249045372, -0.039651814848184586, 0.10049445182085037, 0.0014870529994368553, -0.06856472790241241, 0.010243602097034454, -0.05051269382238388, 0.08154536038637161, -0.058631546795368195, -0.012409732677042484, 0.05536002665758133, -0.04201311618089676, -0.0267619788646698, 0.04981568083167076, -0.079751156270504, -0.06240573897957802, -0.036402348428964615, -0.03227170184254646, -0.06130566820502281, -0.05960158258676529, -0.046552591025829315, 0.0013308821944519877, -0.030969422310590744, -0.030041847378015518, -0.014101404696702957, -0.030973952263593674, 0.02008974738419056, -0.07126644998788834, -0.04962524399161339, -0.03481525182723999, 0.06393700838088989, 0.03925463557243347, -0.005002547986805439, -0.01018985453993082, 0.038353126496076584, 0.043809693306684494, -0.030906643718481064, 0.004625599831342697, -0.01419366430491209, -0.010857272893190384, -0.013190191239118576, -0.009673716500401497, 0.04218793660402298, 0.07310982793569565, 0.04284355044364929, 0.045928601175546646, -0.042301345616579056, -0.017188504338264465, 0.08221796900033951, -0.04582979902625084, -0.07124179601669312, 0.06418828666210175, 0.012271237559616566, 0.058902379125356674, -0.07338331639766693, -0.09914903342723846, -0.03083300217986107, 0.13634082674980164, -0.08936934173107147, -0.047417789697647095, 0.054367758333683014, -0.021130669862031937, 0.021284401416778564, 0.01728103496134281, -0.032813943922519684, 0.009157748892903328, 0.008245996199548244, 0.017441991716623306, -0.004122069571167231, 0.054222650825977325, -0.054771557450294495, 0.014902157709002495, -0.03154582530260086, -0.009223113767802715, -0.003874403890222311, 0.05540325865149498, -0.05881592631340027, -0.0065035088919103146, 0.03374602645635605, -0.048917852342128754, 0.061841387301683426, 0.048867933452129364, 0.05383673682808876, 0.01541427057236433, 0.008232427760958672, 0.040882062166929245, -0.0016004156786948442, 0.018040141090750694, 0.01183281373232603, -0.0006218889029696584, 0.08066392689943314, 0.04673164337873459, -0.0528656430542469, 0.04688981547951698, 0.006129037123173475, -0.0461420975625515, -0.040802955627441406, -0.041415952146053314, -0.04732666164636612, -0.019205553457140923, -0.014738786965608597, -0.028916778042912483, 0.002835911698639393, 0.006416219286620617, 0.03242214396595955, 0.006876347120851278, 0.022042162716388702, -0.02312508411705494, -0.1081748679280281, 0.0051780883222818375, 0.02928299829363823, 0.009800379164516926, -0.07297311723232269, -0.05017250403761864, -0.04860040917992592, 0.023538660258054733, -0.016047082841396332, 0.09039320796728134, -0.06226230785250664, 0.02230336330831051, -0.08368588984012604, -0.011103530414402485, -0.03789089247584343, -0.009464536793529987, -0.05234535038471222, -0.031580161303281784, -0.00409358274191618, -0.015791069716215134, 0.05122741311788559, 0.06690137088298798, 0.12100590765476227, -0.019199073314666748, -0.017844080924987793, -0.041424792259931564, -0.05141060799360275, 0.055351413786411285, -0.0189182348549366, 0.0341683030128479, -0.045036982744932175, 0.05141308531165123, -0.013314674608409405, -0.03185185045003891, 0.06524672359228134, 0.005379870068281889, -0.025758085772395134, 0.0703936517238617, -0.06292877346277237, 0.03698515519499779, 0.012988356873393059, 0.008806043304502964, 0.006591903977096081, 0.009866036474704742, -0.031438231468200684, 0.024786436930298805, 0.01500218827277422, 0.04259459674358368, 0.036103375256061554, 0.04766486957669258, 0.032507698982954025, -0.014598481357097626, 0.051720909774303436, -0.03209242597222328, -0.0157499760389328, 0.10236486792564392, -0.031945474445819855, -0.005916101858019829, -0.026743842288851738, 0.010037221945822239, 0.01244374644011259, -0.01739727333188057, -0.061540376394987106, -0.04617787525057793, 0.03213103860616684, -0.0039526233449578285, 0.007029521744698286, -0.07159878313541412, -0.0005806780536659062, 0.04949456825852394, 0.025306042283773422, -0.01014556735754013, 0.020417021587491035, -0.04897182807326317, -0.010898815467953682, -0.046877000480890274, 0.012545079924166203, -0.03514570742845535, -0.012779091484844685, -0.1330718994140625, -0.1362583488225937, -0.03669574484229088, -0.033332038670778275, 0.05901837721467018, 0.011832482181489468, 0.03731071949005127, -0.05221553519368172, -0.013151885941624641, -0.0508345291018486, 0.02215547300875187, 0.040050920099020004, 0.05443650856614113, 0.04532994329929352, -0.04277538135647774, -0.018846802413463593, -0.045243918895721436, 0.02106235735118389, 0.030798286199569702, 0.060710638761520386, -0.038711026310920715, 0.04052022844552994, 0.0378069169819355, 0.03493327647447586, 0.01909339427947998, 0.020945316180586815, 0.08174536377191544, 0.012891597114503384, -0.03667353093624115, -0.06739187985658646, -0.035884756594896317, 0.030747810378670692, -0.035146672278642654, 0.025517618283629417, -0.027209242805838585, -0.01519796997308731, 0.005584327504038811, -0.024929972365498543, -0.0023092341143637896, -0.004115674644708633, -0.02860831283032894, 0.004249281249940395, 0.07425957918167114, -0.008429479785263538, -0.04421023279428482, 0.03237558528780937, 0.0429467111825943, 0.009822530671954155, -0.04401610791683197, 0.009156506508588791, -0.08101870119571686, -0.001692529651336372, 0.01552444975823164, -0.07089266180992126, -0.05380064249038696, 0.005899904761463404, -0.03695829212665558, -0.013722172938287258, -0.03600839152932167, 0.026179229840636253, 0.029419315978884697, -0.08157136291265488, -0.003478869330137968, -0.03583051264286041, 0.01564919948577881, 0.07716894149780273, -0.02335377223789692, -0.08327110856771469, -0.011897257529199123, -0.03139219060540199, -0.030145803466439247, -0.03405855968594551, 0.009143523871898651, -0.01139545626938343, -0.09777157008647919, 0.023287471383810043, -0.006937454454600811, 0.02403753623366356, -0.0680902972817421, -0.02916109189391136, 0.049324680119752884, 0.088968425989151, -0.029393760487437248, -0.04506951943039894, 0.06215999275445938, 0.06195737048983574, 0.01664097234606743, 0.00384459737688303, 0.03166259080171585, -0.023459210991859436, 0.06634243577718735, -0.09343252331018448, 0.03813204541802406, -0.015486174263060093, 0.040663786232471466, 0.01759856939315796, 0.02175559289753437, 0.017871495336294174, -0.024973111227154732, 0.09149806201457977, 0.01940171606838703, 0.06910526007413864, 0.028035327792167664, -0.004976904951035976, -0.0027780095115303993, 0.012271462008357048, 0.043225765228271484, -0.011491185054183006, -0.05933012068271637 ]
111
111
Learning Low-Density Separators
We define a novel, basic, unsupervised learning problem - learning the lowest density homogeneous hyperplane separator of an unknown probability distribution. This task is relevant to several problems in machine learning, such as semi-supervised learning and clustering stability. We investigate the question of existence of a universally consistent algorithm for this problem. We propose two natural learning paradigms and prove that, on input unlabeled random samples generated by any member of a rich family of distributions, they are guaranteed to converge to the optimal separator for that distribution. We complement this result by showing that no learning algorithm for our task can achieve uniform learning rates (that are independent of the data generating distribution).
[ -0.0250935647636652, -0.02306029386818409, 0.049703449010849, -0.010571151971817017, -0.012141591869294643, -0.11473461240530014, 0.013087913393974304, -0.04105813428759575, -0.04236713424324989, 0.0352446511387825, -0.04023117944598198, -0.008790609426796436, -0.02936716191470623, 0.06328127533197403, -0.00017272766854148358, -0.017763972282409668, -0.051776837557554245, 0.026050589978694916, -0.030702242627739906, -0.03763989359140396, 0.016718871891498566, -0.017888372763991356, 0.034891556948423386, -0.05852721631526947, -0.015794353559613228, -0.01677456684410572, -0.004682562313973904, 0.0809202715754509, -0.008156124502420425, -0.037231653928756714, -0.041870083659887314, -0.007694569416344166, 0.004758902825415134, 0.015553190372884274, 0.07137735188007355, -0.03737488016486168, 0.010109927505254745, -0.007155212108045816, -0.03576295077800751, 0.008083810098469257, -0.017935816198587418, 0.012824770994484425, 0.05690570920705795, -0.010503857396543026, 0.012356521561741829, 0.07217838615179062, -0.022031662985682487, -0.031063305214047432, -0.0129407849162817, 0.06252328306436539, -0.07597696036100388, 0.020891616120934486, -0.057553481310606, -0.018424170091748238, -0.013958335854113102, -0.046805690973997116, -0.07620932906866074, 0.038688067346811295, -0.05459976941347122, -0.027984440326690674, -0.005155513063073158, 0.09868668019771576, -0.05883422866463661, 0.03858935087919235, 0.01689792051911354, -0.10910740494728088, -0.07268628478050232, 0.0331248976290226, 0.021369993686676025, -0.009541825391352177, 0.05579506233334541, -0.021412916481494904, 0.035630255937576294, 0.042681530117988586, 0.04580853879451752, -0.0033429572358727455, 0.009924608282744884, 0.06678501516580582, -0.03017137572169304, 0.03187217563390732, -0.07823485136032104, -0.002171881031244993, 0.03843201696872711, 0.03472130745649338, -0.10477237403392792, -0.0005621550371870399, -0.04457833245396614, -0.05137013643980026, 0.00797052588313818, -0.03999895974993706, -0.047122303396463394, 0.012266846373677254, -0.03445444256067276, 0.019579365849494934, -0.0373651497066021, 0.029604755342006683, 0.044235896319150925, -0.03477497398853302, 0.06514476239681244, 0.07551933825016022, 0.020435526967048645, -0.038434721529483795, 0.09867855161428452, 0.03701828047633171, 0.04816042259335518, 0.03132358193397522, -0.0375543050467968, 0.013881050981581211, 0.0186464861035347, -0.013147586956620216, 0.042419567704200745, 0.010181092657148838, 0.002417770680040121, -0.028649577870965004, -0.018203094601631165, 0.070699542760849, -0.01308759767562151, 0.09850477427244186, -0.01867072843015194, 0.07313753664493561, 0.020479634404182434, -0.0054681007750332355, -0.06207025796175003, -0.03447604179382324, 0.020576082170009613, -0.00861990638077259, -0.05094919726252556, -0.07410844415426254, 0.03903862461447716, -0.007191269192844629, -0.07493272423744202, 0.018744327127933502, -0.010718467645347118, 0.0109012546017766, -0.07204599678516388, 0.04049113392829895, -0.009987923316657543, -0.009083487093448639, 0.019124750047922134, 0.017939316108822823, -0.023926280438899994, 0.001360496156848967, 0.024277547374367714, 0.01630435138940811, 0.04815660044550896, 0.0033263282384723425, -0.012598748318850994, 0.055127277970314026, -0.010115817189216614, 0.008543066680431366, -0.024498598650097847, -0.03146378695964813, 0.04091831296682358, 0.03495600074529648, 0.10409163683652878, -0.0834532305598259, 0.036478981375694275, 0.04918460175395012, -0.023355649784207344, 0.11616113781929016, -0.07883298397064209, 0.008458038792014122, 0.05496954545378685, 0.023962918668985367, 0.019349142909049988, 0.007394874468445778, 0.06768476963043213, -0.0354890450835228, 0.01097286120057106, -0.079879991710186, -0.029429841786623, -0.051304206252098083, 0.018459845334291458, -0.04217652231454849, 0.029232153668999672, -0.012750862166285515, -0.04788792505860329, 0.06999792903661728, 0.0011737265158444643, 0.03328050300478935, 0.07762034237384796, 0.009312842041254044, -0.014158837497234344, -0.004150405991822481, -0.0029963019769638777, 0.11213737726211548, 0.019022511318325996, 0.025407686829566956, 0.05925466865301132, 0.025659311562776566, 0.01527244970202446, -0.050112973898649216, 0.02523050829768181, -0.007457629311829805, -0.0884144976735115, 0.024132458493113518, -0.06099114194512367, -0.030518913641572, 0.04167460277676582, 0.06088213622570038, 0.041076235473155975, 0.05662491172552109, -0.036233507096767426, -0.0678904727101326, -0.010719867423176765, 0.018734581768512726, 0.030009960755705833, -0.035116709768772125, 0.0018033765954896808, -0.05181640759110451, -0.040978360921144485, -0.013358641415834427, 0.05407818406820297, -0.03937120735645294, -0.018622497096657753, -0.059228356927633286, -0.03974480181932449, -0.105099156498909, 0.037784233689308167, 0.06522788107395172, -0.042564064264297485, 0.022599829360842705, 0.02972272038459778, 0.033081285655498505, -0.10179877281188965, 0.017073549330234528, 0.09053327143192291, -0.015597865916788578, -0.07541465014219284, 0.04762224853038788, -0.059280239045619965, -0.05716425180435181, -0.010860797949135303, -0.006390449590981007, 0.03941825404763222, 0.004341104533523321, -0.01560231950134039, -0.01956896483898163, -0.030402397736907005, -0.000978603377006948, -0.037941936403512955, 0.054190777242183685, -0.024115735664963722, -0.008046374656260014, -0.034359682351350784, -0.009737079031765461, 0.01191704161465168, 0.004405008163303137, -0.0367441400885582, 0.023279506713151932, 0.044297922402620316, 0.023807574063539505, -0.04594280943274498, 0.013275130651891232, -0.018645094707608223, -0.03841268643736839, -0.004215157125145197, 0.03518346697092056, 0.07644072920084, 0.03052608296275139, 0.07379510998725891, 0.03463123366236687, 0.017855191603302956, 0.022660749033093452, 0.07644837349653244, 0.08656523376703262, -0.028936725109815598, -0.007607229053974152, -0.03123377077281475, 0.030546367168426514, 0.035627108067274094, -0.07283195108175278, -0.07502993196249008, 0.04190878942608833, -0.02010662667453289, 0.011964522302150726, 0.06641175597906113, 0.030591890215873718, 0.019599879160523415, -0.018119418993592262, -0.06535328924655914, 0.036768581718206406, -0.0035043146926909685, -0.007207130081951618, -0.010546206496655941, 0.0321965292096138, 0.0207873173058033, 0.02870015799999237, 0.0047060176730155945, 0.09007333964109421, 0.022399723529815674, 0.06511200964450836, -0.04224694147706032, -0.04819074273109436, 0.04255544766783714, -0.0488593615591526, 0.09936357289552689, -0.04752438887953758, 0.031176023185253143, -0.015598053112626076, 0.009517263621091843, 0.005648894235491753, -0.009155169129371643, 0.03431615233421326, 0.055655598640441895, 0.04962100833654404, 0.046184051781892776, -0.010738334618508816, -0.04425879567861557, 0.0024989917874336243, 0.03811923786997795, 0.008268087171018124, -0.014203258790075779, -0.0030044331215322018, 0.00990342628210783, -0.03423530235886574, 0.03595898672938347, 0.0006555362488143146, -0.02392611652612686, 0.005216522142291069, 0.026104899123311043, -0.02556118182837963, 0.016564805060625076, -0.003108695847913623, -0.10085560381412506, -0.09330552071332932, 0.037833236157894135, 0.035139165818691254, -0.0936269611120224, 0.016680430620908737, -0.033321987837553024, -0.030422911047935486, -0.07840646803379059, 0.09293553233146667, -0.03900165855884552, 0.014193261973559856, -0.050914324820041656, -0.011532014235854149, -0.005533979739993811, 0.044472288340330124, -0.02294047176837921, -0.07199060916900635, -0.006856616120785475, -0.009741473011672497, -0.015817854553461075, 0.06641821563243866, 0.05154535919427872, -0.03536264970898628, -0.049549855291843414, -0.010685183107852936, -0.0889725610613823, -0.01688048243522644, -0.03840826451778412, 0.04395595192909241, -0.0005713344435207546, -0.022491084411740303, 0.08977529406547546, -0.005350284278392792, 0.008033272810280323, 0.0891033187508583, -0.05603204667568207, 0.0330219566822052, -0.013076364062726498, 0.01794707030057907, -0.024612803012132645, 0.052144188433885574, 0.0359632708132267, -0.010124176740646362, -0.04833570867776871, -0.012991443276405334, -0.0704830139875412, 0.02665293961763382, 0.04962688311934471, -0.010362480767071247, 0.013709480874240398, -0.08299501240253448, 0.06114456057548523, -0.06692509353160858, -0.013222070410847664, 0.058447834104299545, 0.005853491369634867, -0.013772143982350826, 0.03014758601784706, 0.027845600619912148, -0.024906100705266, -0.0324140340089798, -0.0365694984793663, 0.041599441319704056, 0.14640721678733826, -0.011463421396911144, 0.023300565779209137, -0.0743832215666771, -0.02188372239470482, 0.06414784491062164, 0.00996189285069704, 0.021688498556613922, 0.04286154359579086, -0.0009358380339108407, -0.017792358994483948, -0.012318165972828865, 0.05199550837278366, -0.00025038616149686277, 0.047925613820552826, -0.05011923611164093, -0.04158703237771988, -0.01961533911526203, 0.017056109383702278, 0.08729230612516403, -0.029151124879717827, 0.04671654477715492, 0.03035907819867134, 0.0841485932469368, -0.028453923761844635, 0.030477585271000862, -0.027910474687814713, 0.012374350801110268, -0.00967892725020647, -0.001420772634446621, 0.04184378683567047, -0.050108831375837326, -0.0321514792740345, 0.03343205526471138, 0.006529089063405991, -0.05068931728601456, 0.04231175780296326, -0.01932331919670105, 0.024297336116433144, 0.06261556595563889, -0.0002794901665765792, 0.10160357505083084, -0.042244087904691696, -0.06675142794847488, -0.02440723590552807, -0.023215552791953087, 0.08367316424846649, -0.07131698727607727, -0.016008511185646057, 0.017327699810266495, 0.006267296615988016, 0.05777579918503761, -0.06760375201702118, 0.0708119124174118, -0.03581450879573822, 0.004899409133940935, -0.02219783328473568, 0.0968441441655159, 0.06879916787147522, -0.01684584654867649, 0.00779799185693264, 0.015410040505230427, 0.011670954525470734, 0.011953403241932392, 0.02858527936041355, -0.018836481496691704, 0.02741474099457264, 0.0007756224949844182, 0.06811155378818512, -0.05513893440365791, 0.043913278728723526, -0.051298510283231735, -0.07453896105289459, -0.01969437301158905, 0.008598574437201023, 0.0353434681892395, 0.02374638430774212, 0.017909204587340355, 0.023187601938843727, 0.015840904787182808, 0.028864886611700058, 0.018154161050915718, -0.04969104006886482, 0.0838685929775238, -0.025225508958101273, -0.00975754763931036, 0.008885391056537628, -0.028722209855914116, 0.07603313028812408, -0.07186025381088257, -0.02765936776995659, -0.046616073697805405, 0.04027441516518593, 0.0018439225386828184, -0.06534093618392944, -0.032654449343681335, 0.05949597433209419, 0.09009765088558197, 0.0024398500099778175, -0.013048786669969559, 0.06907679885625839, 0.0023763845674693584, 0.04878143221139908, 0.006033717654645443, 0.022640151903033257, 0.049118611961603165, -0.013218551874160767, -0.00850729737430811, -0.03051096946001053, -0.005994019098579884, 0.017496636137366295, 0.004726969171315432, -0.00910894200205803, -0.0581996850669384, 0.07687053829431534, -0.0370296873152256, 0.07970999926328659, -0.022902535274624825, -0.017801709473133087, -0.04515716806054115, -0.057488664984703064, 0.0504051074385643, 0.003294007619842887, 0.02271907590329647 ]
112
112
From Data Topology to a Modular Classifier
This article describes an approach to designing a distributed and modular neural classifier. This approach introduces a new hierarchical clustering that enables one to determine reliable regions in the representation space by exploiting supervised information. A multilayer perceptron is then associated with each of these detected clusters and charged with recognizing elements of the associated cluster while rejecting all others. The obtained global classifier is comprised of a set of cooperating neural networks and completed by a K-nearest neighbor classifier charged with treating elements rejected by all the neural networks. Experimental results for the handwritten digit recognition problem and comparison with neural and statistical nonmodular classifiers are given.
[ -0.03029327280819416, -0.05896645039319992, -0.037938669323921204, 0.006686188280582428, 0.019273409619927406, -0.07083218544721603, -0.019983254373073578, 0.009968213737010956, -0.06996720284223557, 0.032612837851047516, -0.06277129054069519, 0.02685246802866459, -0.03291231393814087, 0.03120674565434456, 0.012208749540150166, 0.00940712634474039, 0.05284586176276207, 0.02662019617855549, -0.0238618366420269, -0.010922019369900227, 0.005308046936988831, -0.0672655999660492, 0.01845385506749153, -0.01013717520982027, 0.041829098016023636, -0.014091591350734234, -0.054818782955408096, -0.02504011057317257, -0.016661781817674637, 0.04048585146665573, -0.03062979318201542, -0.01386991050094366, 0.07256986945867538, -0.010464423336088657, 0.02616182342171669, -0.07774416357278824, -0.021547501906752586, -0.0176260806620121, -0.02489837445318699, -0.044294100254774094, 0.007104023825377226, -0.06957420706748962, 0.003952495753765106, 0.01175671350210905, 0.028340792283415794, 0.04018757492303848, 0.009944488294422626, 0.07675006240606308, 0.04373271390795708, 0.02613632008433342, -0.08574563264846802, 0.0011890360619872808, -0.026054594665765762, 0.03363114967942238, -0.05767245218157768, 0.006450260058045387, -0.0193509291857481, -0.040289055556058884, -0.04965388774871826, 0.013924122788012028, 0.0663633644580841, 0.04845747351646423, -0.02563306875526905, 0.04719141498208046, 0.008337740786373615, -0.05285115912556648, -0.009447070769965649, -0.009687688201665878, -0.0382610559463501, -0.024506477639079094, 0.060151368379592896, -0.028155513107776642, -0.03027821145951748, 0.05159274861216545, 0.0372568741440773, 0.01830458827316761, 0.01745358295738697, -0.0380534827709198, 0.022812828421592712, 0.09264009445905685, -0.016193697229027748, 0.0007174788042902946, -0.014188394881784916, -0.005754340440034866, -0.03981634974479675, -0.004101933445781469, -0.039280664175748825, -0.04677020013332367, 0.014466308988630772, 0.0495293028652668, -0.060096658766269684, 0.019285842776298523, -0.02984142117202282, 0.04712546244263649, -0.027600795030593872, -0.06041840836405754, 0.012375297956168652, -0.03246546536684036, 0.04612255468964577, 0.0846649557352066, -0.005652386695146561, -0.02364765852689743, -0.011562039144337177, 0.08020636439323425, -0.007605496793985367, 0.0304251741617918, -0.05294905602931976, 0.030805418267846107, 0.025963636115193367, -0.04373136907815933, 0.0907314121723175, 0.01852390170097351, 0.01592557691037655, 0.02021450363099575, -0.026542944833636284, 0.04744784161448479, -0.058250974863767624, 0.025974245741963387, -0.005222495645284653, -0.041829925030469894, -0.011159844696521759, -0.012514930218458176, -0.012747555039823055, -0.026807032525539398, 0.07278382778167725, -0.04906541109085083, -0.016371354460716248, -0.02194368466734886, 0.1060275062918663, 0.011496901512145996, -0.07962450385093689, 0.011523076333105564, -0.0025687813758850098, 0.039322033524513245, -0.05628643184900284, 0.03051789477467537, 0.02496407739818096, -0.02478139102458954, -0.005761282052844763, 0.007256605196744204, 0.007940229959785938, -0.06022290885448456, 0.03618351370096207, -0.006954308599233627, 0.041014909744262695, 0.04636850580573082, -0.048722464591264725, 0.018872134387493134, 0.004033132456243038, 0.008219366893172264, 0.015569516457617283, -0.10588975250720978, 0.054486263543367386, -0.006585289724171162, 0.06977760791778564, -0.07573841512203217, -0.019034693017601967, -0.05447390303015709, 0.0002404588449280709, 0.10463803261518478, -0.08047910779714584, 0.050653185695409775, -0.006984893232584, 0.09408904612064362, 0.0010640020482242107, 0.026335658505558968, -0.07443872839212418, 0.025365127250552177, 0.007264052052050829, -0.0636260062456131, -0.030657930299639702, 0.022608408704400063, -0.08428804576396942, -0.010003641247749329, 0.02609371766448021, 0.004592666402459145, -0.03120557777583599, 0.00754521694034338, -0.030665982514619827, 0.001094302162528038, 0.04336865618824959, -0.03880509361624718, -0.0005373462336137891, 0.024278413504362106, 0.04328959062695503, 0.05496741831302643, -0.013796786777675152, 0.06278812885284424, 0.01628836803138256, 0.020072178915143013, 0.03013470582664013, -0.022202754393219948, 0.0799235999584198, -0.03378213196992874, -0.07481540739536285, 0.07714062184095383, -0.0325140580534935, -0.06922362744808197, 0.009207524359226227, 0.029555363580584526, 0.053091879934072495, -0.001438048086129129, -0.002669607289135456, -0.07805119454860687, -0.046952564269304276, -0.01155531033873558, 0.07447832822799683, -0.05684049427509308, -0.009468204341828823, 0.009275976568460464, 0.06117042154073715, 0.012247859500348568, 0.03609200194478035, 0.08191888779401779, 0.04780549556016922, -0.036164265125989914, -0.06035684421658516, -0.05967075005173683, 0.05702554062008858, 0.08828435093164444, -0.0656144917011261, -0.0014373972080647945, -0.05493127927184105, 0.002463837154209614, 0.01803898811340332, 0.03331642970442772, 0.05188471078872681, 0.011087608523666859, -0.07684782147407532, 0.001496809534728527, -0.058421023190021515, -0.037057336419820786, -0.03352903947234154, -0.07873638719320297, 0.06123517453670502, -0.0013413118431344628, -0.050994884222745895, 0.029109012335538864, -0.043040674179792404, -0.002409766661003232, -0.01041494682431221, 0.01843508519232273, -0.07571639120578766, -0.09194858372211456, 0.01191040500998497, -0.017367662861943245, 0.007341672666370869, 0.048378780484199524, 0.031824883073568344, 0.023512348532676697, 0.06290170550346375, 0.03284548968076706, -0.018499376252293587, 0.02008799836039543, -0.0422411784529686, 0.042494505643844604, -0.014188629575073719, 0.056984856724739075, 0.07089637964963913, 0.058377575129270554, 0.061524003744125366, -0.006535669323056936, 0.021195828914642334, -0.09387191385030746, 0.055570393800735474, 0.018631737679243088, 0.01641256920993328, -0.0004663224390242249, -0.06877326220273972, 0.02752825990319252, -0.00805390253663063, -0.0841025561094284, -0.017315732315182686, 0.02928546443581581, -0.006866717245429754, 0.011781181208789349, -0.04043358936905861, 0.09816881269216537, 0.010914059355854988, -0.07438643276691437, -0.002069836715236306, 0.044551070779561996, -0.06867194920778275, 0.01925067976117134, 0.009877540171146393, 0.02474175952374935, 0.025427881628274918, 0.04691396653652191, 0.030472828075289726, 0.02169424295425415, 0.02288162149488926, 0.15100806951522827, -0.12143257260322571, -0.042762838304042816, -0.0027871374040842056, -0.09659215062856674, 0.06336801499128342, -0.011104892939329147, 0.022270014509558678, 0.011979476548731327, 0.04269742965698242, -0.05703054741024971, 0.032923802733421326, 0.04899153113365173, 0.02934085950255394, -0.025061801075935364, -0.022564681246876717, 0.08132875710725784, -0.0638352707028389, -0.027566326782107353, 0.04544076323509216, -0.00860243383795023, -0.031239591538906097, -0.048745058476924896, -0.004198480863124132, -0.029646482318639755, 0.06176896393299103, 0.07361524552106857, 0.005451474338769913, 0.027151940390467644, -0.012497879564762115, -0.06266849488019943, 0.01681499183177948, -0.052356936037540436, -0.038250844925642014, -0.017713168635964394, -0.003101569367572665, 0.007289117202162743, -0.12634819746017456, -0.026759572327136993, 0.005252269096672535, 0.02477317862212658, -0.012437235563993454, 0.0834750309586525, 0.009332593530416489, 0.034417927265167236, -0.02069024369120598, 0.1121605858206749, -0.0522967204451561, 0.04348098114132881, -0.04082580283284187, -0.03844800963997841, 0.015527722425758839, 0.002565008122473955, -0.053925156593322754, 0.12807749211788177, -0.0037083167117089033, -0.03622657433152199, -0.00045942311407998204, 0.02022724226117134, -0.015122412703931332, 0.0719643086194992, -0.030214091762900352, 0.04495370388031006, -0.0034171943552792072, 0.0362585224211216, 0.05081143602728844, -0.03023071400821209, 0.01659325882792473, -0.04058782011270523, -0.030070684850215912, 0.08352869004011154, 0.0005382602103054523, 0.06940731406211853, 0.056112781167030334, 0.0807090699672699, -0.025813331827521324, 0.021412821486592293, 0.0065980334766209126, -0.03896484524011612, 0.03804059326648712, -0.005934405140578747, 0.019068557769060135, -0.006243688054382801, 0.05113287270069122, -0.0748569518327713, -0.004891662858426571, -0.013027663342654705, 0.08431489765644073, 0.014126677997410297, -0.03159615024924278, 0.045743443071842194, 0.012028077617287636, 0.04969200864434242, 0.03272203356027603, 0.010135311633348465, 0.03438873589038849, 0.008662371896207333, 0.028509555384516716, 0.00927173811942339, 0.04683976620435715, -0.03518046438694, -0.04965200275182724, 0.023146526888012886, -0.011586222797632217, -0.01768571324646473, -0.020002245903015137, -0.008173794485628605, -0.006872359197586775, 0.01993159018456936, -0.06478423625230789, -0.043579891324043274, -0.02033843658864498, -0.09307847917079926, -0.05679195746779442, -0.02075892500579357, -0.09786497801542282, 0.11091341823339462, -0.028920724987983704, 0.018518468365073204, 0.0380064956843853, 0.050993237644433975, 0.014677214436233044, -0.02436136081814766, 0.05531570315361023, 0.0032433457672595978, 0.008720618672668934, -0.02861146628856659, 0.014790477231144905, -0.08332526683807373, -0.07829415798187256, 0.0462091825902462, 0.016458716243505478, -0.0011577189434319735, -0.06449805200099945, 0.030900131911039352, 0.06623739004135132, 0.01709424890577793, 0.01677924394607544, 0.02784539945423603, -0.07760543376207352, 0.03339824080467224, -0.014999590814113617, -0.04973423108458519, 0.05030325427651405, 0.006998634431511164, 0.024140028282999992, -0.046699557453393936, 0.01005961187183857, 0.047298021614551544, -0.01653563417494297, -0.015840040519833565, 0.05795866623520851, 0.02246789075434208, -0.023969408124685287, 0.07635732740163803, 0.0422370545566082, -0.01505876425653696, 0.016714205965399742, -0.0019523634109646082, -0.039235781878232956, 0.00765658775344491, 0.08435916900634766, -0.05718657001852989, -0.03453025966882706, 0.01152377761900425, -0.009100663475692272, -0.04583631828427315, -0.014051646925508976, -0.07071716338396072, -0.04115748777985573, -0.04624980688095093, 0.015636006370186806, 0.0019534898456186056, -0.02674960531294346, -0.024410367012023926, 0.07191619277000427, 0.02485244907438755, -0.050987888127565384, 0.026967238634824753, -0.051100973039865494, -0.00831453874707222, 0.05632570758461952, -0.01922443136572838, -0.008231164887547493, -0.06963571161031723, 0.026249825954437256, -0.05296669527888298, -0.02281178906559944, -0.06148398295044899, 0.020146876573562622, 0.04438882693648338, -0.08942613750696182, 0.03108067251741886, 0.012119745835661888, -0.025030823424458504, 0.01862390711903572, 0.08010987192392349, 0.008636034093797207, -0.014003671705722809, -0.002212375169619918, 0.0034366403706371784, -0.00871888268738985, 0.026898575946688652, -0.0789581909775734, -0.02207271009683609, 0.051289722323417664, 0.02492598071694374, 0.022912774235010147, -0.010076026432216167, 0.006843777373433113, -0.010428564622998238, 0.04588586837053299, 0.012913864105939865, -0.0032204571180045605, -0.026701094582676888, 0.017235957086086273, -0.057881224900484085, 0.050683293491601944, 0.047665975987911224, -0.05407804995775223, -0.017445333302021027 ]
113
113
Utilisation des grammaires probabilistes dans les t\^aches de segmentation et d'annotation prosodique
Nous pr\'esentons dans cette contribution une approche \`a la fois symbolique et probabiliste permettant d'extraire l'information sur la segmentation du signal de parole \`a partir d'information prosodique. Nous utilisons pour ce faire des grammaires probabilistes poss\'edant une structure hi\'erarchique minimale. La phase de construction des grammaires ainsi que leur pouvoir de pr\'ediction sont \'evalu\'es qualitativement ainsi que quantitativement. ----- Methodologically oriented, the present work sketches an approach for prosodic information retrieval and speech segmentation, based on both symbolic and probabilistic information. We have recourse to probabilistic grammars, within which we implement a minimal hierarchical structure. Both the stages of probabilistic grammar building and its testing in prediction are explored and quantitatively and qualitatively evaluated.
[ -0.015875207260251045, -0.018820004537701607, 0.0021503514144569635, -0.025150487199425697, 0.03288112208247185, -0.050473883748054504, -0.01679336093366146, -0.04392637312412262, -0.03481293097138405, -0.018110055476427078, -0.005439540836960077, -0.01763051003217697, -0.0844370424747467, -0.011280423030257225, -0.026370296254754066, -0.03543916344642639, -0.015130607411265373, 0.002939945552498102, 0.0046533579006791115, -0.020546145737171173, -0.03275156766176224, 0.0043794396333396435, -0.051342424005270004, -0.030580593273043633, 0.04657112434506416, 0.08163923025131226, -0.08411508053541183, 0.031283315271139145, -0.007241703569889069, -0.05204470455646515, -0.11720729619264603, 0.012791689485311508, -0.010895504616200924, 0.008704365231096745, 0.04545077681541443, 0.017479512840509415, -0.005892197601497173, 0.025164419785141945, -0.07689634710550308, -0.016698453575372696, 0.07225871831178665, -0.07371615618467331, 0.008597484789788723, -0.008656447753310204, 0.017527354881167412, 0.01332563441246748, 0.06179865822196007, -0.047009583562612534, -0.005911175161600113, 0.040392134338617325, -0.04805599898099899, -0.019615614786744118, 0.02287173643708229, -0.01999100297689438, 0.008266906253993511, 0.0028297961689531803, -0.014152394607663155, 0.00229401676915586, -0.07157078385353088, 0.014881988987326622, -0.048998601734638214, 0.05617043375968933, -0.0183264072984457, -0.0019495263695716858, -0.06579079478979111, -0.003939663525670767, -0.12329849600791931, 0.03292321786284447, -0.022708365693688393, 0.005789392162114382, -0.0002468973398208618, 0.03448718041181564, -0.02399246022105217, -0.015537559054791927, -0.00734753767028451, -0.012398893013596535, -0.07814519107341766, -0.022233426570892334, -0.029658734798431396, 0.12380031496286392, -0.034962669014930725, 0.03807888180017471, 0.01907336339354515, 0.0210521649569273, -0.03609546646475792, -0.04025789350271225, 0.004982645157724619, -0.0032415378373116255, 0.09382446110248566, -0.05759941041469574, -0.05249602720141411, 0.008613744750618935, -0.054022591561079025, 0.07032568752765656, -0.06736346334218979, 0.05646836385130882, -0.04322975128889084, -0.005921013653278351, 0.00007525405817432329, -0.025256630033254623, -0.0637877881526947, -0.05830034986138344, -0.0043239109218120575, 0.004163581412285566, -0.06297691911458969, 0.029571497812867165, 0.013112245127558708, 0.013564685359597206, 0.018129512667655945, -0.04356592148542404, 0.08913766592741013, -0.02672724798321724, 0.02163519151508808, -0.03791811689734459, 0.0014814097667112947, 0.1185150071978569, 0.017374524846673012, 0.09320187568664551, 0.023207299411296844, 0.04067663475871086, 0.04295980930328369, 0.04955616593360901, -0.014327919110655785, 0.0012190263951197267, 0.0214524082839489, -0.07998383045196533, -0.06763491779565811, -0.1115494966506958, 0.08861293643712997, 0.03362756595015526, -0.10208740085363388, 0.03247194364666939, -0.001378206186927855, 0.06160397455096245, -0.07431959360837936, 0.0812801718711853, 0.032040007412433624, -0.042436666786670685, -0.034609295427799225, 0.04443376138806343, 0.04170335829257965, -0.021052030846476555, -0.010690090246498585, -0.04828554391860962, 0.0031270773615688086, 0.04042071849107742, -0.050532251596450806, -0.05402566120028496, -0.0030681337229907513, 0.00939223077148199, -0.03528184816241264, -0.07670148462057114, 0.0640265941619873, 0.028977368026971817, 0.06788191199302673, -0.03876689821481705, -0.012350184842944145, -0.08389569818973541, -0.0037364333402365446, 0.08391519635915756, -0.08785460144281387, -0.0489487461745739, 0.10472091287374496, 0.09842082858085632, -0.06622975319623947, -0.027095599099993706, -0.04425056278705597, 0.03681320324540138, -0.02407238446176052, -0.07257998734712601, 0.0166099164634943, 0.03943245857954025, 0.00819255318492651, 0.026348544284701347, 0.04313082993030548, -0.10067371279001236, -0.040723565965890884, 0.027839116752147675, 0.004179324954748154, 0.025959353893995285, 0.0587843656539917, -0.08382361382246017, -0.004770121071487665, 0.0050105564296245575, -0.005645778030157089, 0.02462192438542843, -0.03804073855280876, 0.06404044479131699, 0.07474181056022644, -0.007589532528072596, 0.006391399540007114, 0.06140755116939545, 0.03903627395629883, 0.024487081915140152, -0.0835089460015297, 0.03208354115486145, 0.007453830912709236, 0.034410715103149414, -0.01230440940707922, 0.0674792230129242, 0.01617288962006569, -0.0017515721265226603, -0.08010489493608475, -0.09526272118091583, -0.0356314443051815, -0.014100040309131145, 0.024342680349946022, -0.02437565103173256, 0.009952204301953316, 0.053772225975990295, 0.02908886782824993, -0.016498539596796036, -0.03791804611682892, -0.024666402488946915, 0.006225007586181164, -0.00946720503270626, -0.03893369808793068, -0.010171229019761086, 0.031870681792497635, 0.046735845506191254, -0.0082695996388793, 0.07714136689901352, 0.03553152456879616, -0.02242269180715084, -0.01687689498066902, -0.026570718735456467, 0.05055579915642738, -0.049538422375917435, 0.010929596610367298, 0.04547450691461563, 0.06445790827274323, -0.04415025934576988, -0.026779253035783768, -0.08578232675790787, 0.05674527585506439, 0.10524221509695053, 0.03847826272249222, 0.02648628130555153, 0.0007326402701437473, 0.02882051281630993, -0.12187620997428894, 0.05288328975439072, 0.022683026269078255, 0.025224719196558, -0.008991314098238945, -0.05191957578063011, 0.05747338384389877, 0.06342744082212448, -0.07289644330739975, 0.0010720064165070653, 0.032434653490781784, -0.021901540458202362, 0.02225174382328987, -0.027363566681742668, 0.003755382262170315, -0.0024360769893974066, -0.017907466739416122, -0.0064697558991611, 0.02842111513018608, 0.10118941217660904, -0.004922210704535246, 0.003827060339972377, -0.01776483654975891, 0.02021881751716137, 0.03741573542356491, -0.05763711407780647, 0.012998158112168312, 0.019090434536337852, 0.07186391949653625, -0.029726775363087654, -0.0046188258565962315, -0.05106055736541748, -0.003781299339607358, 0.015898430719971657, -0.01620340533554554, 0.03055354580283165, 0.05693427473306656, -0.02462359145283699, -0.02528190426528454, 0.007457401603460312, -0.024223124608397484, -0.0011392191518098116, 0.0418965108692646, -0.012784557417035103, 0.025312088429927826, 0.06389649212360382, -0.01011235173791647, -0.03761684522032738, 0.01343251671642065, 0.04167057201266289, -0.012687725946307182, 0.07422693818807602, -0.0373653918504715, 0.016785982996225357, 0.06112866848707199, -0.08254871517419815, -0.015097096562385559, -0.022958308458328247, 0.06691953539848328, 0.007145210634917021, -0.050604552030563354, 0.005189386662095785, 0.08020438253879547, -0.013059860095381737, 0.008449158631265163, 0.07796702533960342, -0.01098069828003645, 0.04098978638648987, -0.02539324201643467, 0.039235617965459824, 0.023103926330804825, -0.009899364784359932, -0.02323768474161625, 0.01152719184756279, -0.021692823618650436, -0.027439646422863007, 0.004916965961456299, -0.017516160383820534, -0.016022441908717155, 0.02624349854886532, -0.009326248429715633, -0.0034758145920932293, -0.05357912555336952, -0.01954675279557705, -0.0007209973991848528, 0.0027789752930402756, -0.0055040884763002396, 0.04100422561168671, -0.12651978433132172, -0.025748049840331078, 0.043916452676057816, -0.00735202431678772, 0.0004409928515087813, 0.2084629088640213, -0.06190981715917587, 0.015525324270129204, -0.038095127791166306, 0.059837885200977325, 0.018278975039720535, 0.045227449387311935, -0.01668025739490986, -0.012023456394672394, 0.05213036388158798, -0.015524151735007763, 0.02030733972787857, 0.01019100658595562, 0.004062227439135313, 0.01868310756981373, 0.07755136489868164, -0.011914683505892754, -0.012341399677097797, 0.018862998113036156, -0.005011042580008507, 0.08154135197401047, 0.018809456378221512, 0.03943045809864998, 0.02413136139512062, -0.0007625319994986057, 0.023496584966778755, 0.03468174859881401, 0.05543099343776703, -0.0032883561216294765, 0.01875486597418785, 0.009653820656239986, -0.004194926470518112, 0.040153928101062775, -0.03835628181695938, -0.07292518764734268, -0.04895360395312309, 0.028246378526091576, 0.009915482252836227, 0.0016398666193708777, 0.07669743150472641, -0.04579727724194527, 0.005166008602827787, -0.012514760717749596, 0.06269534677267075, -0.08928462862968445, 0.006401498802006245, 0.029753370210528374, -0.015463009476661682, -0.08654391020536423, -0.04522329941391945, 0.02988632209599018, 0.01287660002708435, -0.07528340071439743, 0.02131405659019947, 0.035661958158016205, 0.025101736187934875, 0.04937963932752609, -0.05146026983857155, -0.012643166817724705, -0.05327485874295235, 0.028421401977539062, 0.007192512508481741, -0.04143257439136505, -0.00998787209391594, -0.028692424297332764, -0.0008059907704591751, 0.007845032028853893, -0.02834090031683445, -0.09563496708869934, -0.017884958535432816, 0.01829966902732849, -0.0635097548365593, -0.04562609642744064, -0.010226084850728512, 0.014089462347328663, -0.048626821488142014, 0.033591169863939285, 0.06322111189365387, 0.06311383098363876, 0.0005942534771747887, -0.03710399940609932, 0.01267579011619091, 0.06654749810695648, 0.05671027675271034, -0.05383840575814247, 0.0008199333096854389, -0.07906565815210342, 0.04621659591794014, -0.009221943095326424, -0.013153846375644207, 0.029830891638994217, -0.014458884485065937, -0.060679841786623, 0.04988100752234459, 0.040057387202978134, -0.033274486660957336, -0.017030004411935806, -0.07330627739429474, -0.04213772714138031, -0.026130981743335724, 0.0075017246417701244, 0.05500149726867676, 0.010533382184803486, -0.004414317198097706, -0.0034413132816553116, -0.022705262526869774, 0.04183248430490494, -0.0632537305355072, -0.06332515925168991, 0.023575127124786377, -0.014650161378085613, -0.00626157782971859, -0.05607058107852936, 0.04993542283773422, -0.024417832493782043, -0.015679901465773582, -0.02580287493765354, -0.023114988580346107, 0.007983963936567307, 0.03286205604672432, -0.011790706776082516, -0.024090150371193886, 0.0034370843786746264, -0.05823548138141632, -0.015000373125076294, 0.047773994505405426, -0.002172175794839859, -0.03498702496290207, 0.002218896523118019, -0.03526327386498451, -0.019171660766005516, -0.0391029454767704, -0.052600231021642685, 0.08724923431873322, 0.07540389895439148, 0.05197781324386597, 0.0007771794334985316, -0.025437021628022194, -0.011583332903683186, -0.03535996749997139, 0.025829538702964783, -0.005772450473159552, -0.00767594575881958, 0.033976584672927856, -0.030179210007190704, -0.033943694084882736, -0.0569831058382988, -0.02960413694381714, 0.00616726279258728, -0.06554710119962692, 0.011756746098399162, 0.03348567709326744, 0.029028108343482018, -0.026788193732500076, -0.05276503786444664, -0.04495969042181969, 0.04260263964533806, 0.010640674270689487, -0.033399928361177444, 0.015365040861070156, 0.053763989359140396, 0.040951699018478394, 0.02369074337184429, -0.009721258655190468, -0.029237713664770126, -0.029492376372218132, -0.012676181271672249, 0.05237662047147751, -0.02937024086713791, 0.04552619159221649, 0.02288614585995674, 0.049283649772405624, 0.028923099860548973, 0.05990060791373253, -0.013295207172632217, 0.024623405188322067, -0.0017662697937339544, -0.0414062924683094, -0.06558237969875336 ]
114
114
Belief Propagation and Beyond for Particle Tracking
We describe a novel approach to statistical learning from particles tracked while moving in a random environment. The problem consists in inferring properties of the environment from recorded snapshots. We consider here the case of a fluid seeded with identical passive particles that diffuse and are advected by a flow. Our approach rests on efficient algorithms to estimate the weighted number of possible matchings among particles in two consecutive snapshots, the partition function of the underlying graphical model. The partition function is then maximized over the model parameters, namely diffusivity and velocity gradient. A Belief Propagation (BP) scheme is the backbone of our algorithm, providing accurate results for the flow parameters we want to learn. The BP estimate is additionally improved by incorporating Loop Series (LS) contributions. For the weighted matching problem, LS is compactly expressed as a Cauchy integral, accurately estimated by a saddle point approximation. Numerical experiments show that the quality of our improved BP algorithm is comparable to the one of a fully polynomial randomized approximation scheme, based on the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method, while the BP-based scheme is substantially faster than the MCMC scheme.
[ 0.026553925126791, -0.05722585693001747, 0.010458669625222683, 0.039722878485918045, 0.043905653059482574, -0.07153383642435074, -0.03925333172082901, 0.027681348845362663, -0.04290144145488739, 0.039036404341459274, -0.03826737776398659, -0.0035534852650016546, 0.012529618106782436, -0.01906217448413372, 0.0680345818400383, -0.03806375712156296, 0.01936829276382923, 0.009526271373033524, -0.0012140325270593166, -0.044075239449739456, 0.05775013193488121, 0.0006434971000999212, 0.022508736699819565, -0.007448587100952864, 0.05565158277750015, -0.0024069412611424923, 0.005716478917747736, 0.05364423617720604, 0.024302056059241295, -0.016503309831023216, -0.031068105250597, -0.00217942101880908, 0.01998690888285637, -0.012943832203745842, 0.07823611795902252, 0.044163789600133896, 0.020887110382318497, -0.03682902827858925, -0.03183121979236603, -0.015227730385959148, -0.02132362499833107, -0.0486828088760376, 0.06523000448942184, 0.026889028027653694, -0.013223505578935146, 0.050708040595054626, 0.053468868136405945, 0.08798666298389435, -0.013951331377029419, 0.09974971413612366, -0.08350091427564621, 0.03701876848936081, -0.04452313482761383, 0.03710508719086647, -0.0469285286962986, 0.035634227097034454, -0.02484179474413395, -0.008577317930758, -0.14938823878765106, -0.03469334915280342, -0.008085179142653942, 0.13224218785762787, 0.008460583165287971, -0.0250611063092947, -0.005074488464742899, -0.011085113510489464, 0.004987919703125954, -0.04237519949674606, -0.061788368970155716, -0.02030652016401291, -0.023905374109745026, -0.03934861719608307, -0.008405362255871296, -0.004364774562418461, 0.04802253097295761, 0.016282187774777412, 0.029326433315873146, 0.05967630818486214, 0.09064946323633194, 0.0366174690425396, -0.04940619319677353, -0.025983110070228577, 0.03526674211025238, 0.07913671433925629, -0.06753987818956375, -0.04884897544980049, -0.010040863417088985, 0.029710307717323303, 0.041538484394550323, -0.03048895299434662, -0.06495644152164459, 0.024686014279723167, -0.04313618317246437, 0.039818163961172104, -0.10594585537910461, 0.038294319063425064, -0.04427596554160118, -0.08265426009893417, -0.022949080914258957, 0.06895172595977783, 0.00905158556997776, -0.021803440526127815, 0.062057334929704666, 0.08808101713657379, 0.051442939788103104, -0.025513624772429466, 0.038308583199977875, 0.03915489837527275, 0.0284802857786417, -0.004471638705581427, 0.10067585855722427, -0.044345635920763016, -0.043600793927907944, 0.01642291247844696, -0.0829797238111496, 0.03188636153936386, -0.000991626875475049, 0.09757526218891144, -0.02207239903509617, 0.019316039979457855, 0.054940562695264816, -0.012891626916825771, -0.0668981596827507, -0.04834675416350365, 0.040100548416376114, -0.022373132407665253, -0.057385027408599854, -0.06081167608499527, 0.049642860889434814, -0.01583472080528736, -0.008439688943326473, -0.026328807696700096, -0.001966537209227681, -0.04309319332242012, -0.027545496821403503, -0.023772073909640312, -0.00904592964798212, -0.022376064211130142, -0.051996730268001556, 0.038843002170324326, -0.010326620191335678, -0.03431583568453789, -0.04771794006228447, 0.018103662878274918, 0.012293120846152306, 0.023920884355902672, 0.014280002564191818, 0.048787713050842285, -0.01586245372891426, 0.04872932657599449, 0.025109432637691498, -0.03810958191752434, -0.039367616176605225, -0.022695841267704964, 0.06416528671979904, -0.0349886380136013, -0.055861618369817734, -0.006875169929116964, -0.09533367305994034, 0.1259286105632782, -0.024643676355481148, 0.02833816595375538, 0.016422513872385025, -0.03441084176301956, -0.02913309819996357, -0.015275298617780209, 0.020956723019480705, 0.02438705787062645, -0.06417592614889145, -0.02195853181183338, 0.021443460136651993, 0.054896969348192215, 0.000470103434054181, -0.02242286503314972, 0.022526785731315613, -0.06305813044309616, -0.03277222812175751, 0.04469666630029678, 0.034130021929740906, -0.0003611724532674998, 0.011831913143396378, -0.046112436801195145, -0.03702561557292938, 0.001991966040804982, 0.00663236528635025, 0.047933049499988556, -0.02364974096417427, 0.0846446305513382, 0.039035968482494354, 0.02336495742201805, -0.016514025628566742, 0.06147579103708267, -0.023227719590067863, -0.04483528435230255, -0.04271489009261131, 0.06605978310108185, 0.004420065321028233, -0.04365697130560875, 0.04616697505116463, 0.05013159289956093, 0.09192804247140884, 0.006688331253826618, -0.0829334557056427, -0.006013730075210333, -0.04470337554812431, 0.01621345803141594, 0.021443357691168785, -0.07666565477848053, -0.00826933141797781, 0.0004066282999701798, 0.031184805557131767, -0.052936851978302, -0.026514200493693352, -0.08020944148302078, -0.005617555696517229, -0.053460974246263504, -0.050244830548763275, -0.09261300414800644, -0.0018608755199238658, 0.03657214716076851, -0.02349075675010681, 0.018811646848917007, -0.042115919291973114, 0.094868965446949, -0.0887632891535759, -0.044649045914411545, 0.00805994588881731, -0.013091618195176125, -0.02941269427537918, 0.03503149002790451, -0.022196976467967033, -0.04330245405435562, 0.015617933124303818, 0.03317656368017197, -0.01755083166062832, 0.020899977535009384, -0.0013815740821883082, -0.045191120356321335, -0.037143073976039886, 0.0004370367096271366, -0.07341696321964264, 0.0822262167930603, 0.049140557646751404, 0.03188939020037651, 0.008383293636143208, -0.05874481424689293, -0.015656286850571632, 0.05428921803832054, -0.04392834007740021, 0.04629543423652649, 0.034949447959661484, 0.001580221694894135, -0.030174724757671356, -0.01969110034406185, 0.02231297641992569, -0.017906347289681435, 0.0465770959854126, 0.0417914018034935, 0.011393727734684944, 0.018788274377584457, 0.01492049265652895, -0.0034404576290398836, -0.06925589591264725, 0.07245282083749771, 0.08332029730081558, 0.0005212048999965191, -0.028593484312295914, 0.01597924716770649, 0.023945217952132225, -0.01801043376326561, 0.022432535886764526, -0.026722004637122154, -0.07375594973564148, 0.06582723557949066, 0.06551330536603928, -0.050161752849817276, 0.025589577853679657, 0.05080288276076317, -0.022132497280836105, -0.07155067473649979, -0.08070021867752075, -0.02489042840898037, 0.07979156821966171, 0.004961191210895777, 0.014420063234865665, 0.07712751626968384, 0.01124266441911459, -0.01369516085833311, 0.009434709325432777, -0.00495018158107996, -0.0524144321680069, 0.02563517540693283, -0.08985655009746552, -0.02942182868719101, 0.007074269466102123, -0.06288737058639526, -0.014476349577307701, -0.07449734210968018, -0.004268080927431583, 0.036711834371089935, 0.029960421845316887, -0.024502338841557503, 0.03269954025745392, -0.003443680005148053, 0.03942878544330597, 0.014126835390925407, 0.060569923371076584, 0.05172881856560707, -0.03860382363200188, 0.06491489708423615, 0.044477131217718124, -0.01093300897628069, -0.04570421203970909, 0.010274490341544151, 0.004398238379508257, -0.06764928996562958, -0.03269176557660103, -0.02785537764430046, -0.07519350200891495, -0.00020937151566613466, 0.004892187658697367, -0.015433842316269875, 0.009237288497388363, 0.009908302687108517, -0.027086488902568817, 0.013112328015267849, 0.018221799284219742, 0.10218481719493866, -0.05350726842880249, 0.03453168645501137, 0.041649919003248215, -0.0003036445123143494, 0.0056781587190926075, 0.09619127213954926, -0.014088508673012257, -0.04401624575257301, 0.00032350674155168235, -0.029938742518424988, 0.05766432732343674, 0.018249137327075005, -0.03526606783270836, -0.07699982821941376, 0.04505917429924011, 0.008853326551616192, 0.01679384708404541, 0.08082307875156403, 0.11846378445625305, -0.04648416489362717, 0.03307875245809555, -0.04231249541044235, -0.03469814732670784, -0.012067517265677452, -0.02317802421748638, -0.008686624467372894, -0.05613099783658981, 0.03279924392700195, 0.03370063006877899, 0.031146014109253883, 0.04652305692434311, 0.04644259065389633, 0.0013119743671268225, 0.03740045800805092, 0.0067192730493843555, -0.023045510053634644, -0.041137393563985825, -0.003965694457292557, -0.06035194173455238, -0.0007188242743723094, -0.003872504225000739, -0.017059700563549995, 0.021487992256879807, -0.0037039516028016806, 0.0588160902261734, 0.08082693070173264, 0.023659810423851013, -0.03998083248734474, -0.01596507802605629, -0.033411603420972824, -0.05626410245895386, 0.0870460644364357, -0.022444846108555794, 0.006694432348012924, 0.012426493689417839, -0.011983977630734444, -0.06096479296684265, 0.014645946212112904, -0.06156130135059357, 0.04218766465783119, 0.026664966717362404, -0.021537449210882187, -0.05927187576889992, -0.0649941936135292, 0.004268445540219545, 0.020475776866078377, 0.054832182824611664, 0.03509313613176346, 0.042655110359191895, 0.014645162969827652, -0.0420716367661953, -0.003942152950912714, 0.07928620278835297, -0.10076048970222473, -0.07032212615013123, -0.09959498792886734, -0.09136158972978592, 0.02919701486825943, 0.012087003327906132, 0.03339751809835434, 0.0689433366060257, 0.06052076816558838, -0.00705305952578783, 0.05127573013305664, -0.02253633551299572, 0.023998213931918144, -0.04341711103916168, -0.0343022495508194, -0.022425832226872444, 0.048737891018390656, 0.017157569527626038, -0.04969172552227974, 0.0042161718010902405, 0.03894684463739395, 0.0003281568642705679, -0.002429829677566886, -0.037307009100914, -0.000450938125140965, 0.045856717973947525, 0.002895342418923974, 0.024184977635741234, 0.04384315013885498, -0.10673754662275314, 0.017432374879717827, -0.02864394150674343, -0.008682656101882458, -0.01757003925740719, -0.04833535477519035, -0.011675956659018993, 0.00363182439468801, -0.06602680683135986, -0.004045377019792795, -0.03891535848379135, -0.06244679540395737, 0.026387587189674377, 0.005989422556012869, 0.036923497915267944, 0.06423130631446838, 0.00834416039288044, 0.03153938427567482, 0.05931389331817627, 0.03481563925743103, 0.012583746574819088, -0.006575361359864473, 0.0033360044471919537, 0.042507920414209366, -0.03905762359499931, -0.01837645098567009, 0.006635954137891531, 0.007508228532969952, 0.09629948437213898, -0.009825943037867546, 0.027090104296803474, -0.03894524276256561, -0.007835017517209053, -0.002231437712907791, -0.03500039130449295, 0.03804219141602516, -0.004081806633621454, 0.003756121266633272, 0.0835692286491394, -0.044726453721523285, -0.04051109030842781, -0.0064034126698970795, -0.0748806968331337, -0.024408357217907906, -0.02616647444665432, 0.005353985354304314, 0.014703291468322277, -0.017300982028245926, 0.012108877301216125, -0.02099832147359848, 0.01104468572884798, 0.022326266393065453, -0.003519759513437748, 0.03029061108827591, -0.006245742551982403, 0.06968025863170624, 0.04283373802900314, 0.0018679550848901272, 0.05776466056704521, 0.044333092868328094, 0.05634181201457977, -0.03893397003412247, 0.05288649722933769, -0.003717802930623293, 0.03060784563422203, -0.06185317412018776, 0.019055841490626335, 0.07801425457000732, -0.00305383512750268, -0.027863793075084686, 0.04719322919845581, -0.021634815260767937, 0.002552532125264406, -0.0008853812469169497, 0.1163027286529541, 0.02720230259001255, -0.007641488686203957, -0.07061135023832321, -0.09402433782815933, 0.012419321574270725, -0.03964538499712944, -0.004358543548732996 ]
115
115
Decoding Beta-Decay Systematics: A Global Statistical Model for Beta^- Halflives
Statistical modeling of nuclear data provides a novel approach to nuclear systematics complementary to established theoretical and phenomenological approaches based on quantum theory. Continuing previous studies in which global statistical modeling is pursued within the general framework of machine learning theory, we implement advances in training algorithms designed to improved generalization, in application to the problem of reproducing and predicting the halflives of nuclear ground states that decay 100% by the beta^- mode. More specifically, fully-connected, multilayer feedforward artificial neural network models are developed using the Levenberg-Marquardt optimization algorithm together with Bayesian regularization and cross-validation. The predictive performance of models emerging from extensive computer experiments is compared with that of traditional microscopic and phenomenological models as well as with the performance of other learning systems, including earlier neural network models as well as the support vector machines recently applied to the same problem. In discussing the results, emphasis is placed on predictions for nuclei that are far from the stability line, and especially those involved in the r-process nucleosynthesis. It is found that the new statistical models can match or even surpass the predictive performance of conventional models for beta-decay systematics and accordingly should provide a valuable additional tool for exploring the expanding nuclear landscape.
[ -0.07882639765739441, -0.11819475144147873, 0.02539127506315708, -0.05551633983850479, 0.07686124742031097, 0.025413889437913895, 0.06045098230242729, 0.01991431973874569, -0.0046834154054522514, 0.03037012182176113, -0.028396887704730034, -0.0360574834048748, -0.001442293985746801, -0.019648391753435135, -0.0035730290692299604, -0.030240898951888084, 0.036007001996040344, -0.059311848133802414, 0.010518345050513744, -0.024385062977671623, -0.0267373975366354, -0.030620025470852852, 0.04504871368408203, 0.028137490153312683, 0.014462186023592949, 0.01747201941907406, -0.005303711164742708, -0.01709688827395439, 0.013940934091806412, -0.0036251822020858526, -0.009107059799134731, 0.022369900718331337, -0.03009515069425106, 0.059761568903923035, 0.03171719238162041, -0.051811423152685165, 0.021561695262789726, -0.02979959174990654, -0.05188737064599991, -0.06870090961456299, -0.022052530199289322, -0.07762138545513153, 0.02561626024544239, -0.023000389337539673, 0.027420006692409515, 0.015016683377325535, 0.056043121963739395, -0.00982929952442646, -0.06314295530319214, 0.01596115529537201, -0.016799114644527435, 0.025479374453425407, 0.045728325843811035, 0.031288594007492065, -0.06776870042085648, 0.06660345196723938, -0.06127794459462166, -0.0221713837236166, -0.005373603664338589, 0.04951081797480583, 0.010650763288140297, 0.046736471354961395, 0.03352281078696251, 0.003899178234860301, -0.04732414707541466, 0.0182090625166893, -0.04350266233086586, -0.029921406880021095, -0.05875404179096222, 0.03648946061730385, 0.027821827679872513, 0.03066455014050007, -0.024742508307099342, 0.03054385632276535, 0.005849774926900864, -0.04103829339146614, 0.008200185373425484, -0.00775956641882658, 0.04144400730729103, 0.07759691774845123, -0.03414006158709526, 0.05074214190244675, -0.009923014789819717, 0.04864572733640671, 0.003642912022769451, 0.01802198775112629, 0.014056289568543434, 0.02044852450489998, -0.025019032880663872, -0.06394284963607788, 0.01719750463962555, 0.06164640933275223, -0.034581951797008514, -0.00874126236885786, -0.05280767008662224, 0.030328258872032166, -0.09771369397640228, -0.08278730511665344, 0.0024115757551044226, -0.021039968356490135, 0.03380845859646797, 0.036148786544799805, 0.008150334469974041, 0.029403580352663994, -0.10001317411661148, 0.06491760909557343, -0.017769750207662582, 0.04328419268131256, 0.010093974880874157, -0.0017598235281184316, 0.04082167521119118, 0.020255666226148605, 0.04823293909430504, 0.0266951322555542, -0.022081313654780388, 0.04062396660447121, -0.009765139780938625, 0.05019226297736168, 0.059321802109479904, 0.004297394305467606, 0.01751578599214554, 0.01538919284939766, -0.04716823250055313, 0.016628006473183632, 0.042342767119407654, -0.053279586136341095, -0.023332737386226654, -0.07554388791322708, 0.10874839127063751, -0.026642248034477234, -0.02555084228515625, -0.0011572372168302536, 0.03424949198961258, -0.030406594276428223, 0.028143608942627907, -0.016990819945931435, -0.021396784111857414, 0.00019724032608792186, -0.00819096714258194, -0.002959390403702855, 0.019168632104992867, -0.0816228985786438, 0.02517627738416195, 0.03662872314453125, 0.015885448083281517, 0.007387853693217039, 0.02295747958123684, 0.016235945746302605, -0.03175884485244751, 0.0530473031103611, 0.037314172834157944, -0.038758404552936554, -0.00940690841525793, 0.009526258334517479, 0.022871848195791245, -0.04997524619102478, -0.12658803164958954, 0.031155481934547424, -0.005183914210647345, 0.0044991434551775455, 0.07690922915935516, 0.02405979484319687, -0.015290293842554092, 0.026643285527825356, -0.04847581684589386, 0.02313130721449852, -0.052493445575237274, 0.013918829150497913, 0.02233246900141239, 0.006917211227118969, -0.04296774044632912, 0.031511396169662476, -0.036629531532526016, 0.004102647770196199, 0.02903004176914692, 0.02454601600766182, 0.05946934223175049, 0.03947030007839203, -0.016257287934422493, 0.016781099140644073, 0.04379454627633095, -0.05535804107785225, -0.04449821636080742, 0.046824172139167786, 0.0867183655500412, 0.04693806543946266, 0.010809589177370071, 0.07077307999134064, 0.053501468151807785, -0.010366158559918404, 0.02619078755378723, 0.005826734937727451, 0.044587984681129456, -0.04154163599014282, -0.008546003140509129, 0.04759065434336662, 0.011320761404931545, -0.014891115948557854, 0.09328370541334152, 0.09765145182609558, 0.08494196087121964, 0.024148473516106606, -0.02529137022793293, -0.000762155104894191, -0.0490485243499279, 0.002903563668951392, 0.042508166283369064, -0.11622979491949081, -0.021680502220988274, 0.048460643738508224, -0.002317868871614337, 0.006722460966557264, -0.08020243793725967, 0.0328071229159832, -0.02354424260556698, -0.026447605341672897, -0.0571238249540329, -0.06192298233509064, 0.007718068081885576, 0.007912584580481052, 0.012349855154752731, 0.058210354298353195, -0.023998083546757698, 0.0359899066388607, -0.04998568445444107, 0.06683118641376495, 0.043583888560533524, -0.0035605551674962044, -0.09195203334093094, 0.03432651236653328, 0.00489200372248888, -0.05759846046566963, 0.03101658634841442, -0.047449514269828796, 0.04206716641783714, 0.032202474772930145, 0.01639551669359207, -0.010668762028217316, 0.0012623319635167718, 0.01454490702599287, -0.027339201420545578, 0.0346217155456543, -0.056440357118844986, 0.004280104301869869, 0.04194982349872589, -0.022087590768933296, -0.018839998170733452, 0.027297887951135635, -0.06007104367017746, 0.009898589923977852, 0.04519462212920189, 0.012441462837159634, -0.04280791059136391, 0.012260457500815392, 0.0761241614818573, -0.06074370816349983, -0.005786442197859287, -0.012955483980476856, 0.012529764324426651, 0.07806450873613358, 0.03954460844397545, 0.01677812449634075, -0.005377153865993023, -0.016814282163977623, 0.09138929843902588, -0.0546240471303463, -0.06728704273700714, 0.00027183949714526534, -0.02039513550698757, 0.047930825501680374, -0.015483415685594082, -0.017771320417523384, 0.02088983729481697, 0.040919333696365356, -0.01719486340880394, -0.042838066816329956, 0.0271158367395401, 0.0055764419957995415, 0.07581251859664917, 0.004780660383403301, 0.00763557106256485, -0.009709959849715233, -0.02070222608745098, -0.020755356177687645, -0.07328774034976959, -0.011825768277049065, -0.06589998304843903, 0.037152837961912155, 0.025586038827896118, -0.006711216643452644, -0.047202978283166885, 0.011499675922095776, -0.02881542593240738, 0.011386572383344173, 0.05124121159315109, 0.0013401645701378584, 0.040951695293188095, 0.014379680156707764, -0.02381616085767746, -0.016233043745160103, 0.031136982142925262, -0.01614036224782467, 0.10010791569948196, 0.041343554854393005, -0.025792714208364487, 0.06075714901089668, -0.007022719830274582, 0.06055512651801109, -0.0675339326262474, -0.018832262605428696, 0.01255833264440298, 0.07212945818901062, -0.017717881128191948, -0.0024462107103317976, -0.00514138163998723, -0.04524177685379982, -0.02399897389113903, 0.028513969853520393, 0.03068464808166027, -0.04315081611275673, 0.04130319878458977, -0.01421863492578268, 0.03275904804468155, -0.04135589301586151, -0.058653026819229126, -0.00503173191100359, 0.012668825685977936, 0.15332968533039093, 0.024746013805270195, 0.08452904969453812, 0.01432870700955391, -0.03602103888988495, -0.018946699798107147, 0.13484244048595428, -0.022022094577550888, 0.06059785932302475, -0.05422991141676903, 0.0068829916417598724, 0.022348949685692787, 0.035865895450115204, -0.09511782974004745, -0.0556727759540081, 0.06268775463104248, -0.01611398719251156, 0.008762119337916374, 0.07800882309675217, 0.05069461092352867, -0.05184362083673477, -0.00916703138500452, 0.047947488725185394, 0.01895928382873535, -0.026084816083312035, -0.018590020015835762, 0.07804544270038605, -0.08870440721511841, 0.09899154305458069, 0.008933309465646744, 0.005228566005825996, 0.072993203997612, 0.03939369320869446, -0.03382839262485504, 0.041276805102825165, 0.004304653964936733, -0.0843009501695633, -0.028524722903966904, 0.06109228357672691, -0.029031742364168167, 0.007149138487875462, -0.028557345271110535, -0.02736850082874298, -0.04152464494109154, -0.01485159806907177, 0.029622411355376244, 0.03301342576742172, -0.05358332023024559, -0.0017641547601670027, 0.029534053057432175, 0.014943858608603477, 0.07182218134403229, 0.023011377081274986, -0.09098224341869354, -0.0365462563931942, -0.03542597219347954, 0.00785424467176199, -0.04555809125304222, 0.044491853564977646, -0.0813368484377861, -0.08380645513534546, 0.040929000824689865, -0.037672869861125946, -0.07564514875411987, 0.005944989155977964, -0.05160413682460785, 0.01730082742869854, 0.022109877318143845, -0.020838556811213493, -0.0038776991423219442, 0.020555753260850906, -0.03655758872628212, 0.0029270441737025976, -0.06052573397755623, -0.09733524173498154, 0.01772751659154892, -0.005393680185079575, -0.06352625042200089, -0.006813147105276585, 0.03634946793317795, 0.023885909467935562, 0.03948633000254631, -0.01186465471982956, 0.047124531120061874, 0.0022094964515417814, 0.055403076112270355, 0.01671280711889267, 0.02142859250307083, 0.04454750940203667, 0.025805383920669556, -0.03232387453317642, -0.07354109734296799, -0.07882502675056458, 0.0374230220913887, -0.049340032041072845, 0.045341216027736664, 0.03724240884184837, -0.044356558471918106, -0.004698594566434622, 0.019527405500411987, 0.017474036663770676, -0.04379833862185478, -0.00372235756367445, -0.008282603695988655, 0.00588896032422781, -0.0778820738196373, -0.035474494099617004, 0.0024462181609123945, -0.07796560227870941, 0.01120516937226057, -0.0699145644903183, 0.01716313138604164, 0.009455072693526745, -0.0023519503884017467, -0.07242920249700546, 0.0011165509931743145, 0.029290365055203438, 0.037027839571237564, 0.02914023958146572, 0.05789536237716675, -0.000004225702923577046, 0.08337865769863129, 0.02376072108745575, 0.00930915866047144, 0.0293849166482687, 0.01472262479364872, -0.06990648061037064, 0.01791992597281933, 0.022376827895641327, -0.022221878170967102, -0.015450574457645416, 0.12259696424007416, 0.033507898449897766, 0.008458562195301056, -0.09877344965934753, -0.015235107392072678, 0.030326485633850098, -0.10003862529993057, -0.015810679644346237, -0.022158488631248474, 0.060116834938526154, -0.003956778906285763, -0.06554456800222397, -0.015287159942090511, 0.06615757942199707, -0.03723480924963951, -0.06615007668733597, -0.034074533730745316, -0.004446352832019329, 0.02179209142923355, -0.08745952695608139, 0.026898164302110672, -0.04983121156692505, 0.08936066925525665, 0.014710107818245888, 0.025303388014435768, 0.06646072119474411, -0.08450977504253387, 0.07621178776025772, 0.033356428146362305, 0.011559607461094856, 0.00377272698096931, 0.08139647543430328, 0.053195688873529434, 0.015889108180999756, -0.032458607107400894, 0.0018612707499414682, -0.028277413919568062, -0.03305508568882942, 0.004252116195857525, 0.010048996657133102, 0.02766893431544304, 0.04853898286819458, 0.04686162620782852, 0.06322623044252396, 0.06086195632815361, -0.01496891863644123, 0.1033995971083641, -0.054823823273181915, 0.05408678948879242, 0.007596350274980068, -0.030718263238668442, 0.04024660214781761, -0.01156021747738123, -0.06947236508131027 ]
116
116
Learning Graph Matching
As a fundamental problem in pattern recognition, graph matching has applications in a variety of fields, from computer vision to computational biology. In graph matching, patterns are modeled as graphs and pattern recognition amounts to finding a correspondence between the nodes of different graphs. Many formulations of this problem can be cast in general as a quadratic assignment problem, where a linear term in the objective function encodes node compatibility and a quadratic term encodes edge compatibility. The main research focus in this theme is about designing efficient algorithms for approximately solving the quadratic assignment problem, since it is NP-hard. In this paper we turn our attention to a different question: how to estimate compatibility functions such that the solution of the resulting graph matching problem best matches the expected solution that a human would manually provide. We present a method for learning graph matching: the training examples are pairs of graphs and the `labels' are matches between them. Our experimental results reveal that learning can substantially improve the performance of standard graph matching algorithms. In particular, we find that simple linear assignment with such a learning scheme outperforms Graduated Assignment with bistochastic normalisation, a state-of-the-art quadratic assignment relaxation algorithm.
[ -0.032115619629621506, -0.047799114137887955, 0.03204024210572243, 0.01353605929762125, -0.017854968085885048, -0.04000328481197357, 0.055906008929014206, -0.05039888620376587, -0.01645311713218689, 0.06774263083934784, -0.019617782905697823, -0.03287405148148537, 0.003648951184004545, 0.04929396137595177, 0.07284371554851532, 0.06822525709867477, -0.022874964401125908, -0.03718035668134689, -0.012600389309227467, -0.03176309913396835, 0.05474507063627243, 0.006234999280422926, -0.014811703003942966, -0.029348153620958328, 0.06852863729000092, 0.01014359388500452, -0.004956462420523167, 0.026982011273503304, 0.025010453537106514, 0.005049639847129583, -0.013484640046954155, -0.01614358276128769, 0.016185995191335678, -0.02244028076529503, 0.009089712053537369, 0.09902691841125488, 0.06374017149209976, 0.02792944200336933, 0.01352414395660162, -0.007922428660094738, 0.030091704800724983, -0.0020293251145631075, 0.03503410518169403, -0.02280517667531967, -0.00818056520074606, -0.034096185117959976, -0.006649020593613386, 0.02822011150419712, 0.029003245756030083, 0.1223134994506836, -0.03020251914858818, 0.022645574063062668, 0.032206013798713684, 0.04303281754255295, -0.013242791406810284, 0.03819473460316658, -0.029206719249486923, 0.007793333847075701, -0.014746873639523983, -0.0037428922951221466, 0.05931403487920761, 0.10861541330814362, 0.02342195250093937, -0.0026303711347281933, -0.03908706456422806, -0.0052725146524608135, -0.06336856633424759, 0.009544331580400467, -0.03570503741502762, 0.03150073438882828, 0.0008649211376905441, 0.0005481760599650443, 0.07286684960126877, 0.024554140865802765, 0.021221859380602837, 0.006905552931129932, 0.02448994666337967, -0.023657046258449554, 0.069448322057724, 0.0434788353741169, -0.05609758570790291, 0.036211609840393066, -0.010648011229932308, -0.00319463643245399, -0.027412032708525658, 0.05886561796069145, -0.03694429248571396, -0.008126226253807545, 0.031443480402231216, 0.038125164806842804, -0.08586853742599487, -0.030667874962091446, -0.06304391473531723, 0.00588903296738863, -0.06682038307189941, 0.004749508108943701, -0.03580765798687935, -0.024559268727898598, 0.010740899480879307, 0.06960991770029068, 0.007748657837510109, -0.08926074951887131, 0.03396375849843025, 0.006628534756600857, -0.04460854083299637, -0.013359389267861843, -0.025846723467111588, 0.04329969733953476, 0.053330231457948685, -0.03569289669394493, 0.009634044952690601, 0.004003116860985756, 0.0008129683556035161, -0.024892453104257584, -0.026107441633939743, -0.03345152363181114, -0.023471586406230927, 0.07943018525838852, 0.03247543051838875, 0.03303270787000656, -0.03470047563314438, -0.019456947222352028, -0.07208188623189926, -0.03252934664487839, 0.02436584047973156, -0.06769496202468872, -0.014487228356301785, -0.08739186078310013, 0.012009168043732643, 0.002778285648673773, -0.01658967137336731, -0.0008334640879184008, -0.03179200366139412, -0.08706255257129669, -0.10466842353343964, 0.019345460459589958, -0.015106276609003544, -0.04872061684727669, -0.0334165133535862, 0.0857110247015953, -0.023489532992243767, -0.04616360366344452, 0.011135794222354889, 0.03850827366113663, 0.016685428097844124, 0.02112153172492981, -0.012919926084578037, -0.03257431089878082, 0.014619383029639721, -0.04101965203881264, 0.04521064832806587, -0.03348102048039436, 0.03801468014717102, 0.05472603067755699, -0.05234278738498688, -0.011223629117012024, -0.011149025522172451, -0.04415569081902504, -0.03507065027952194, 0.049159590154886246, 0.019381847232580185, -0.03593088686466217, 0.02644975855946541, -0.025307482108473778, 0.0026807906106114388, 0.028952989727258682, -0.03363693132996559, -0.03361443430185318, -0.07242636382579803, 0.005335166584700346, -0.017061807215213776, 0.03716766834259033, -0.009141194634139538, 0.056518759578466415, 0.02284613996744156, -0.029573939740657806, 0.03756069391965866, 0.06027529016137123, -0.008403530344367027, -0.0038941693492233753, 0.06453306972980499, -0.10392549633979797, 0.03923177346587181, 0.032073888927698135, -0.010750065557658672, 0.04447201266884804, 0.014373877085745335, -0.023266330361366272, -0.0023268864024430513, 0.05232487618923187, -0.07098386436700821, 0.019977524876594543, -0.006695863325148821, -0.011583127081394196, -0.05874452739953995, 0.013756337575614452, -0.04071377217769623, -0.03511497378349304, 0.02389203943312168, -0.016835911199450493, 0.06506220996379852, 0.012993299402296543, -0.04636091738939285, -0.052439652383327484, -0.06595643609762192, -0.011548085138201714, 0.002721753902733326, -0.09504082798957825, -0.028998196125030518, -0.022763483226299286, 0.07185013592243195, 0.0503842867910862, 0.019856033846735954, -0.03582509979605675, -0.07503432035446167, -0.007805713452398777, -0.04571709409356117, -0.09991810470819473, 0.027650224044919014, 0.056694984436035156, -0.035860575735569, 0.04605993255972862, 0.007654563989490271, 0.003756829770281911, -0.0599532388150692, -0.010590903460979462, 0.031008455902338028, 0.018854398280382156, -0.06298873573541641, 0.02265544794499874, -0.05084763839840889, -0.04869705066084862, -0.03471538797020912, 0.02217327244579792, -0.049465302377939224, 0.02051343210041523, -0.08295508474111557, -0.04356186091899872, -0.07618596404790878, 0.0041196104139089584, -0.02533600479364395, 0.0555928498506546, 0.054096248000860214, -0.06900127232074738, 0.00648953951895237, 0.006284619681537151, 0.022683776915073395, -0.012404573149979115, -0.03398270905017853, 0.010324527509510517, -0.05729582905769348, 0.017880894243717194, -0.009671999141573906, -0.06154685840010643, 0.037393130362033844, -0.012476297095417976, -0.00940683577209711, 0.03705555945634842, 0.047050416469573975, 0.07655710726976395, 0.05908879265189171, 0.021265795454382896, -0.026416882872581482, -0.009279188700020313, 0.1523096114397049, -0.02392003685235977, 0.012244369834661484, -0.037054695188999176, -0.008375671692192554, 0.011295865289866924, 0.02027636207640171, -0.1181439533829689, -0.03442784398794174, 0.08369064331054688, -0.0011867709690704942, -0.002246433636173606, 0.05248400941491127, 0.03632526099681854, 0.012507549487054348, -0.0025828597135841846, -0.06515567004680634, -0.017468782141804695, 0.06377408653497696, -0.04381854087114334, 0.029223673045635223, 0.06724153459072113, -0.06184937432408333, 0.027219820767641068, 0.01892222836613655, -0.007119778078049421, 0.020667187869548798, -0.009273574687540531, -0.0487898550927639, -0.002287660026922822, 0.06429184228181839, -0.07989784330129623, 0.04651126638054848, 0.006116641219705343, 0.0033218415919691324, 0.005484997760504484, 0.01631234399974346, 0.022772595286369324, -0.022020747885107994, 0.09341093897819519, 0.021885020658373833, -0.045326557010412216, 0.01765185408294201, 0.020092559978365898, -0.03507394716143608, 0.019535141065716743, 0.03341061249375343, -0.00040307341259904206, -0.06795550137758255, -0.04926113411784172, 0.008217381313443184, -0.007905852049589157, -0.09641934186220169, 0.0034911474213004112, -0.07780604064464569, 0.03207520395517349, 0.05185059458017349, -0.021427204832434654, 0.004852463956922293, 0.023483766242861748, -0.020488817244768143, -0.07305894792079926, 0.005224318243563175, 0.11428827792406082, -0.1119404211640358, 0.014824586920440197, -0.06001835688948631, -0.014432946220040321, 0.03468960523605347, 0.12391416728496552, -0.03591921925544739, 0.02761121094226837, -0.00278627616353333, 0.014783804304897785, -0.018738344311714172, 0.0069574834778904915, -0.05728898569941521, -0.10360923409461975, -0.04183357581496239, -0.03875426575541496, 0.002402928192168474, 0.10425987839698792, 0.05693146586418152, -0.038037460297346115, 0.017821159213781357, -0.03767068684101105, -0.007975844666361809, -0.01127728819847107, -0.016077404841780663, 0.0349426195025444, -0.03820652514696121, -0.04731626436114311, 0.0957450121641159, -0.03923708572983742, -0.006532146595418453, 0.09035274386405945, -0.08969539403915405, 0.002066204557195306, -0.01902383752167225, -0.002444082871079445, 0.048540715128183365, 0.04546252265572548, -0.05474945902824402, 0.03337779641151428, -0.025489842519164085, 0.026100361719727516, 0.03192296251654625, -0.0013707417529076338, 0.049444977194070816, -0.006968021392822266, -0.03204891458153725, -0.041559383273124695, 0.0370490737259388, -0.045710619539022446, 0.01537428516894579, 0.08547669649124146, -0.06503105908632278, 0.031157702207565308, 0.010215573012828827, 0.04636635258793831, 0.012885716743767262, 0.0036063911393284798, -0.04689061641693115, 0.05182557553052902, 0.06876654177904129, 0.044425781816244125, 0.022359495982527733, -0.030322495847940445, -0.03043517842888832, -0.022460201755166054, 0.05571644753217697, -0.0057693831622600555, -0.010629280470311642, 0.02807900495827198, 0.01625872775912285, -0.01941821537911892, 0.0046349624171853065, -0.04519329220056534, -0.0013249770272523165, -0.13062861561775208, -0.1160096675157547, 0.031415220350027084, 0.03152138367295265, 0.08820345252752304, -0.02682286687195301, 0.05537969991564751, -0.01864001154899597, 0.08709549158811569, -0.13086353242397308, -0.04190211370587349, 0.04716598615050316, -0.037522584199905396, 0.019762663170695305, 0.07115449756383896, -0.0028018963057547808, -0.018548887223005295, 0.0568617507815361, -0.05181897059082985, 0.039409805089235306, -0.015639685094356537, 0.034139398485422134, -0.05576756224036217, 0.06834769994020462, 0.021177735179662704, 0.010476832278072834, 0.024269917979836464, -0.028133319690823555, 0.003227528650313616, -0.12468483299016953, 0.052469652146101, 0.016423871740698814, -0.007920593023300171, -0.01411235798150301, -0.025192027911543846, -0.013512972742319107, 0.032786332070827484, -0.017155328765511513, -0.04682624340057373, -0.029766127467155457, -0.017137445509433746, 0.05029536411166191, 0.06709133833646774, 0.007542955223470926, 0.010657597333192825, 0.05073079466819763, -0.00015660923963878304, 0.03069891221821308, -0.03638015314936638, 0.015206390991806984, -0.034256711602211, 0.0213168915361166, -0.03936222568154335, -0.00997207686305046, -0.041299622505903244, 0.013697497546672821, -0.07023656368255615, -0.0334465466439724, -0.01306274812668562, 0.005334186367690563, 0.06994348019361496, 0.007114794105291367, 0.017276093363761902, -0.010575521737337112, 0.03108055144548416, 0.061231356114149094, -0.024643367156386375, -0.032233335077762604, 0.024385707452893257, -0.002352141309529543, 0.008253281004726887, -0.015882249921560287, 0.01797083392739296, -0.0021356260403990746, -0.09621306508779526, 0.012213361449539661, 0.010029536671936512, 0.03680982440710068, 0.05301898345351219, -0.018681343644857407, 0.018449613824486732, 0.05400998890399933, -0.005453102290630341, -0.04512442275881767, 0.055930886417627335, 0.1382872462272644, 0.01167762279510498, -0.038215067237615585, -0.0177482757717371, 0.00968316663056612, 0.015331597067415714, -0.015350784175097942, 0.036088939756155014, 0.06017172336578369, 0.005235281307250261, 0.01793149672448635, -0.003958466462790966, 0.06453865021467209, 0.003172461409121752, -0.0019620826933532953, 0.0860116258263588, 0.020843062549829483, 0.04045694321393967, 0.06018654629588127, 0.000765267584938556, -0.01950029470026493, 0.031422171741724014, -0.07090622931718826, 0.015763211995363235 ]
117
117
Statistical Learning of Arbitrary Computable Classifiers
Statistical learning theory chiefly studies restricted hypothesis classes, particularly those with finite Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) dimension. The fundamental quantity of interest is the sample complexity: the number of samples required to learn to a specified level of accuracy. Here we consider learning over the set of all computable labeling functions. Since the VC-dimension is infinite and a priori (uniform) bounds on the number of samples are impossible, we let the learning algorithm decide when it has seen sufficient samples to have learned. We first show that learning in this setting is indeed possible, and develop a learning algorithm. We then show, however, that bounding sample complexity independently of the distribution is impossible. Notably, this impossibility is entirely due to the requirement that the learning algorithm be computable, and not due to the statistical nature of the problem.
[ -0.053680673241615295, -0.034459710121154785, 0.06808076053857803, -0.037133220583200455, -0.038640961050987244, -0.050602108240127563, 0.0014228300424292684, -0.000701150216627866, -0.06548252701759338, 0.0411100909113884, -0.036984577775001526, 0.01697547920048237, 0.006123736500740051, 0.05355287343263626, 0.05709056556224823, -0.0034510772675275803, 0.028993532061576843, 0.059909041970968246, 0.042992670089006424, -0.03475293144583702, 0.03465710207819939, -0.01620950922369957, -0.010640767402946949, -0.009270579554140568, 0.053034164011478424, -0.026401756331324577, 0.010746151208877563, -0.03672746568918228, -0.0458136647939682, 0.04564522206783295, -0.08220019936561584, -0.010820718482136726, -0.02077181451022625, -0.011486129835247993, -0.02987091988325119, -0.016978463158011436, -0.0044469102285802364, -0.0073831453919410706, -0.07839268445968628, -0.045799627900123596, 0.0005211397656239569, -0.01844392903149128, 0.041047852486371994, -0.006507483776658773, -0.0021539966110140085, -0.014408927410840988, -0.007020600605756044, -0.04246176779270172, -0.000387054868042469, 0.010939951054751873, -0.08216577768325806, 0.036214716732501984, -0.004527631215751171, -0.0261415746062994, 0.03001224435865879, 0.0233805850148201, -0.02273344062268734, 0.02258518896996975, -0.05304763838648796, -0.021525824442505836, 0.011863112449645996, 0.06897294521331787, 0.043441347777843475, -0.1040559858083725, -0.026646064594388008, -0.04637570679187775, -0.10099050402641296, -0.011186713352799416, -0.028550611808896065, -0.00037740403786301613, 0.014974609017372131, -0.08414990454912186, 0.064862459897995, 0.01010091882199049, 0.07885658740997314, 0.01187276653945446, -0.04662316292524338, 0.022428900003433228, -0.047465354204177856, 0.02311769314110279, 0.00036933564115315676, 0.06642946600914001, 0.03496231511235237, 0.0064407773315906525, -0.0836624875664711, 0.03284969553351402, 0.02509622648358345, 0.03977454453706741, 0.01397691760212183, 0.017436442896723747, -0.04724393039941788, 0.05059652402997017, -0.04542800784111023, 0.011356199160218239, 0.030539290979504585, 0.046729546040296555, -0.03280382603406906, -0.010565999895334244, -0.030307931825518608, 0.0003996020241174847, 0.019842157140374184, -0.0091761639341712, 0.051480282098054886, 0.025302760303020477, 0.022890472784638405, -0.03331160172820091, -0.05173671245574951, 0.03630794957280159, 0.05028260499238968, -0.02299649827182293, 0.05471991375088692, -0.011291895061731339, -0.029950428754091263, -0.0005817519268020988, -0.0354016050696373, 0.05486585944890976, -0.002025325782597065, 0.11331655085086823, 0.0567064993083477, -0.025581715628504753, -0.024874070659279823, 0.05344846844673157, -0.08513633906841278, 0.04836735129356384, 0.023022854700684547, -0.008609949611127377, -0.042960025370121, -0.006570019759237766, 0.09405779093503952, 0.000909404712729156, -0.016666779294610023, -0.06542868912220001, 0.0006709804874844849, -0.020466158166527748, -0.06356733292341232, -0.03933282196521759, 0.026633048430085182, -0.004286682698875666, -0.011756045743823051, -0.018998751416802406, -0.0405319444835186, -0.030464673414826393, -0.03589920327067375, 0.0070640831254422665, 0.02921188995242119, 0.07513465732336044, -0.09978385269641876, 0.025505684316158295, 0.06492020934820175, 0.03897853568196297, 0.03676561266183853, -0.03997194394469261, 0.013742079958319664, 0.02725578099489212, 0.04608813673257828, -0.05963442474603653, -0.01342087984085083, 0.032399289309978485, -0.01611892692744732, 0.02192114107310772, 0.0013269144110381603, -0.002845152048394084, 0.023043693974614143, 0.05827489122748375, -0.004048687871545553, -0.04281475767493248, 0.002605286194011569, -0.02753288298845291, -0.030971787869930267, -0.07414984703063965, -0.027704434469342232, -0.01520990114659071, 0.0414162315428257, 0.001015891321003437, 0.08049190789461136, -0.021825747564435005, 0.0065693845972418785, 0.05011748895049095, 0.008385872468352318, -0.025657810270786285, 0.05462603643536568, -0.028404057025909424, -0.01718846894800663, -0.007772656157612801, 0.05175487697124481, 0.10250134766101837, 0.012317292392253876, 0.060715168714523315, 0.047749798744916916, -0.04937320947647095, -0.0023134590592235327, -0.01998080126941204, -0.013051463291049004, -0.018881766125559807, -0.06595581769943237, 0.017761211842298508, -0.03675079345703125, -0.06325460970401764, -0.008298560045659542, 0.1022799089550972, 0.04599622264504433, -0.02609272487461567, -0.013893592171370983, -0.013164638541638851, -0.03564995899796486, 0.031579967588186264, 0.024399692192673683, -0.06823255121707916, -0.04541996866464615, 0.0345396064221859, -0.00018930138321593404, -0.023542363196611404, -0.0198011826723814, -0.014067350886762142, 0.019437581300735474, -0.07757630944252014, -0.03193141147494316, 0.006888685282319784, 0.08807751536369324, 0.045448705554008484, -0.04632434993982315, 0.02310497872531414, 0.016500717028975487, 0.08203278481960297, -0.04787915199995041, 0.027642030268907547, 0.06315334886312485, -0.051526136696338654, -0.03332282230257988, 0.038224633783102036, -0.13946418464183807, -0.110397107899189, -0.041376326233148575, -0.04634081944823265, -0.0023241499438881874, 0.013015837408602238, -0.05054806172847748, 0.028212085366249084, -0.08256440609693527, -0.005285439547151327, -0.07288941740989685, 0.03675509989261627, -0.01974729634821415, -0.04508945718407631, 0.036902423948049545, -0.06272412836551666, 0.04454690217971802, 0.006832972168922424, 0.00859968550503254, -0.050659120082855225, 0.015533413738012314, 0.016178088262677193, -0.029286503791809082, -0.004450561944395304, 0.011598893441259861, 0.0258804764598608, 0.04799116030335426, 0.07285096496343613, 0.07051496207714081, 0.07118593901395798, 0.023213405162096024, 0.0364510640501976, -0.04878352954983711, 0.003454633755609393, 0.07746188342571259, 0.027731578797101974, -0.07233277708292007, 0.03282429277896881, -0.015695303678512573, -0.007694766856729984, -0.02966667339205742, -0.03463304415345192, -0.06747245788574219, 0.016738543286919594, -0.1378200501203537, -0.0243073683232069, 0.027053093537688255, -0.008402314968407154, 0.053404245525598526, -0.04162504896521568, -0.022003037855029106, 0.06331931054592133, -0.011847066693007946, -0.0004625256115105003, 0.08132772147655487, 0.07258063554763794, 0.010405013337731361, 0.0016142483800649643, -0.03519924357533455, 0.022533247247338295, -0.013193472288548946, -0.005974605213850737, -0.012663943693041801, 0.03917831927537918, 0.008327910676598549, -0.01448606513440609, 0.033469364047050476, 0.010494403541088104, 0.010856579057872295, -0.0042093731462955475, -0.00581657188013196, 0.026443256065249443, 0.03845568001270294, -0.024400264024734497, 0.028020808473229408, 0.0255341287702322, 0.02100246213376522, 0.03253288194537163, -0.020353857427835464, 0.05618230998516083, 0.024641020223498344, -0.018549932166934013, -0.018204178661108017, 0.024271203204989433, -0.037196069955825806, -0.05838336423039436, -0.0007745215552859008, -0.07854773849248886, 0.004788835998624563, -0.001823500613681972, 0.031662728637456894, -0.0718185156583786, -0.04931307211518288, 0.017135512083768845, -0.06243535503745079, 0.004777615889906883, 0.06689269840717316, 0.04443664848804474, -0.022607140243053436, 0.035378243774175644, -0.04512421786785126, -0.009266383945941925, 0.02374117262661457, 0.032222650945186615, 0.08227661997079849, 0.036765292286872864, -0.023604456335306168, 0.009404846467077732, -0.06712061911821365, 0.055042754858732224, -0.026721419766545296, -0.10553088784217834, 0.02627287618815899, 0.007169204764068127, -0.03882575407624245, 0.015954263508319855, 0.09007426351308823, -0.012025316245853901, -0.04644719883799553, 0.04826381057500839, -0.10121544450521469, -0.0014947865856811404, -0.014272079803049564, 0.04856865853071213, 0.04548506811261177, 0.05384112894535065, 0.05361076816916466, -0.10996996611356735, 0.04345402494072914, -0.014131850562989712, -0.053947679698467255, 0.012660265900194645, -0.05205392464995384, 0.01262458972632885, -0.03212931752204895, 0.03732959181070328, -0.02752699889242649, -0.029639797285199165, -0.03405100479722023, -0.07013227790594101, -0.03856354206800461, 0.08107920736074448, 0.04881393164396286, 0.026682011783123016, 0.046025004237890244, -0.03987942263484001, 0.001238964032381773, -0.04272383078932762, 0.014803433790802956, 0.06336234509944916, -0.026369860395789146, -0.01648128777742386, -0.020235557109117508, 0.009350962936878204, 0.015334735624492168, -0.007938613183796406, -0.03694234788417816, -0.006472413428127766, 0.07753849774599075, 0.02780873328447342, -0.005683900322765112, -0.07053536921739578, -0.07263346761465073, -0.012111224234104156, -0.00270083942450583, 0.030147241428494453, 0.007440601009875536, -0.039935868233442307, 0.0013854227727279067, -0.007069587707519531, -0.046024370938539505, -0.05133620277047157, 0.003941414877772331, -0.006621632259339094, -0.07589618116617203, 0.03781518340110779, 0.005569418426603079, 0.06119058281183243, 0.019752822816371918, 0.09778865426778793, 0.05249497666954994, 0.01801745966076851, -0.0289433803409338, 0.0571465790271759, -0.006481016520410776, 0.040504325181245804, -0.039477065205574036, -0.0009016161202453077, 0.06068287417292595, -0.0691143199801445, 0.04912948980927467, 0.029455645009875298, -0.020940646529197693, -0.0367170087993145, -0.024067524820566177, -0.04037624970078468, 0.013833207078278065, 0.07345012575387955, -0.031898971647024155, 0.025402098894119263, 0.014769839122891426, -0.019663464277982712, -0.06702060997486115, 0.021068256348371506, 0.05802569165825844, -0.09197955578565598, -0.006964267231523991, -0.018689924851059914, 0.015259942039847374, -0.032496921718120575, -0.06942695379257202, 0.037807647138834, 0.0251100305467844, 0.030577268451452255, -0.03545643389225006, 0.027182256802916527, 0.012693497352302074, -0.04695698991417885, 0.03707592189311981, 0.006187430117279291, -0.0009056966518983245, 0.035471610724925995, 0.08729558438062668, -0.03741396218538284, 0.04215129092335701, 0.06903640925884247, 0.04637185111641884, -0.09165521711111069, 0.11829250305891037, -0.022717352956533432, -0.013523024506866932, -0.07452648133039474, 0.07629678398370743, 0.029530657455325127, -0.08140144497156143, 0.03629257529973984, -0.015835626050829887, -0.005093603394925594, 0.025719214230775833, -0.03155292198061943, -0.01092175580561161, 0.08024951815605164, -0.08207953721284866, -0.08107589930295944, 0.014354097656905651, 0.021614927798509598, 0.054898377507925034, -0.037544697523117065, 0.008311684243381023, -0.0598008818924427, -0.007841149345040321, -0.06103396788239479, -0.06084274873137474, 0.02573779597878456, 0.03897418454289436, 0.011448584496974945, -0.04607904702425003, 0.01340525597333908, 0.03188121318817139, 0.0427633561193943, 0.05160478129982948, -0.016850100830197334, 0.02639857865869999, -0.027309687808156013, -0.04739685729146004, -0.00588909350335598, 0.036292389035224915, -0.0029822324868291616, 0.009345374070107937, 0.12432176619768143, 0.04764001816511154, 0.003615247318521142, 0.02840396761894226, -0.023811306804418564, 0.08621162921190262, -0.02519649639725685, 0.05277285352349281, -0.017265917733311653, -0.02358817681670189, 0.09350734949111938, -0.008705280721187592, 0.07813984900712967 ]
118
118
Agnostically Learning Juntas from Random Walks
We prove that the class of functions g:{-1,+1}^n -> {-1,+1} that only depend on an unknown subset of k<<n variables (so-called k-juntas) is agnostically learnable from a random walk in time polynomial in n, 2^{k^2}, epsilon^{-k}, and log(1/delta). In other words, there is an algorithm with the claimed running time that, given epsilon, delta > 0 and access to a random walk on {-1,+1}^n labeled by an arbitrary function f:{-1,+1}^n -> {-1,+1}, finds with probability at least 1-delta a k-junta that is (opt(f)+epsilon)-close to f, where opt(f) denotes the distance of a closest k-junta to f.
[ -0.060092151165008545, -0.009502646513283253, 0.07856094837188721, -0.056448761373758316, 0.01026847679167986, -0.06410728394985199, 0.03254655376076698, 0.025862423703074455, -0.03709201514720917, 0.03296805918216705, -0.009048601612448692, -0.004577141720801592, 0.018111607059836388, 0.13069458305835724, -0.002180705312639475, -0.015517995692789555, -0.029203521087765694, 0.030193336308002472, 0.0073805879801511765, -0.026796089485287666, 0.04448293522000313, -0.05685274675488472, 0.024158868938684464, -0.05418301001191139, 0.007539242040365934, -0.0691920593380928, 0.0012985916109755635, 0.0206234622746706, -0.0443340539932251, -0.04341340437531471, -0.021159881725907326, -0.025971028953790665, -0.0020041188690811396, -0.015276184305548668, 0.02263420633971691, -0.037048060446977615, 0.019592640921473503, 0.03412013128399849, -0.06578168272972107, 0.04116353765130043, 0.03515990450978279, -0.03084775246679783, 0.02760152332484722, 0.0017628438072279096, 0.01978425867855549, 0.034156955778598785, 0.04942923039197922, -0.0015219009947031736, -0.08199436962604523, 0.05168936774134636, -0.01236500684171915, -0.01458703726530075, -0.018680421635508537, -0.038647230714559555, 0.0093317162245512, 0.002486948622390628, -0.01979241520166397, -0.006835287902504206, -0.09726713597774506, -0.01279930304735899, 0.032136935740709305, 0.1428578495979309, 0.021519403904676437, -0.07038343697786331, -0.016484737396240234, 0.0008163125021383166, -0.04622871056199074, 0.013323646038770676, 0.008436298929154873, 0.009741867892444134, 0.026816384866833687, -0.019134003669023514, 0.05681027099490166, 0.03289198502898216, 0.003378260415047407, 0.0041290647350251675, 0.014366719871759415, 0.0424116812646389, -0.004673548508435488, 0.05701897293329239, -0.07141076773405075, -0.030946962535381317, -0.03332100808620453, -0.044714510440826416, 0.013058400712907314, 0.055596377700567245, 0.013616743497550488, 0.004279116168618202, -0.06630201637744904, 0.0000954938805080019, -0.02972348779439926, 0.03979851305484772, -0.12087155133485794, -0.029026398435235023, -0.04417070746421814, 0.15485744178295135, 0.0075142900459468365, -0.009160426445305347, 0.021783651784062386, 0.06322093307971954, 0.027638539671897888, -0.028534574434161186, 0.13768215477466583, 0.06056561321020126, -0.009938775561749935, -0.02670818753540516, -0.027818551287055016, -0.0433509536087513, 0.05728943273425102, -0.04249497503042221, 0.007757670246064663, -0.02425295114517212, 0.004982374608516693, 0.03064245544373989, -0.05717961862683296, 0.03596484661102295, 0.03432496637105942, 0.04595179855823517, 0.04831496626138687, 0.09859810024499893, 0.043302323669195175, -0.03869188204407692, -0.020887723192572594, 0.0372999906539917, 0.005076988134533167, -0.032854579389095306, -0.037098560482263565, -0.05624091997742653, 0.12276501953601837, 0.06736622005701065, -0.04099144786596298, -0.028920277953147888, -0.03576738387346268, -0.0018126125214621425, -0.08543192595243454, -0.023625198751688004, -0.006219599861651659, -0.030845070257782936, 0.004646118264645338, 0.025358421728014946, -0.0020285022910684347, -0.06784509867429733, -0.0587313175201416, -0.03745108097791672, -0.006475386675447226, 0.013802180998027325, -0.02663559280335903, -0.037036847323179245, 0.006154676899313927, -0.00476347841322422, -0.006852254271507263, 0.02710791490972042, -0.020003296434879303, 0.03544211387634277, 0.07941846549510956, 0.040846772491931915, -0.0420931875705719, 0.03884527087211609, -0.0473652146756649, 0.08037187159061432, 0.004711979068815708, -0.012392507866024971, -0.024208229035139084, 0.04370485246181488, 0.05173199996352196, -0.012722372077405453, -0.04773253947496414, -0.029444416984915733, 0.03170180320739746, -0.037396710366010666, 0.05773978307843208, -0.018379921093583107, 0.0038375607691705227, -0.03784068673849106, 0.048154380172491074, 0.027102632448077202, 0.02251085266470909, -0.009094093926250935, -0.012148459441959858, -0.04856207221746445, -0.010589111596345901, -0.12657679617404938, 0.012700468301773071, 0.09367670863866806, 0.048777367919683456, 0.11942353844642639, 0.015243570320308208, -0.05390900745987892, 0.06850287318229675, -0.03115537203848362, 0.0044031827710568905, 0.012819014489650726, -0.027605807408690453, -0.013768365606665611, -0.03044860064983368, 0.050966911017894745, -0.01843057945370674, -0.03429156914353371, -0.0008956033270806074, 0.1294044554233551, 0.03250642120838165, 0.049415141344070435, -0.01395952794700861, -0.05482194945216179, -0.08153939992189407, 0.0173381008207798, 0.004703263286501169, -0.057371534407138824, -0.02110087312757969, -0.037109099328517914, 0.0014528324827551842, -0.044436756521463394, 0.012968535535037518, -0.06145418807864189, 0.0165446437895298, -0.06396031379699707, -0.0791425108909607, -0.05105684697628021, 0.025573259219527245, 0.014800584875047207, -0.050558190792798996, 0.022774947807192802, 0.05101608484983444, 0.016033420339226723, -0.11292175203561783, -0.00040179677307605743, -0.0036599733866751194, 0.03565479442477226, -0.02145083248615265, 0.007434702944010496, -0.08396971225738525, -0.0017702201148495078, -0.0211638156324625, 0.0041209193877875805, -0.0351535864174366, 0.009339307434856892, 0.004137123003602028, 0.021014276891946793, -0.053869158029556274, 0.026776421815156937, -0.025811541825532913, 0.07041853666305542, -0.03652413189411163, -0.031152144074440002, 0.041216325014829636, -0.048827797174453735, 0.11676094681024551, 0.05484343692660332, 0.050114940851926804, 0.031888220459222794, -0.020957861095666885, -0.0520494244992733, -0.02430514432489872, -0.028534527868032455, 0.02588745206594467, 0.10159309208393097, -0.06445059925317764, 0.031074630096554756, 0.04404112696647644, 0.015177369117736816, -0.006500668823719025, 0.0715336799621582, -0.06083611771464348, -0.0618104413151741, 0.05129183083772659, -0.0025839863810688257, -0.01221199706196785, -0.02258940227329731, -0.031074386090040207, -0.016623113304376602, 0.07100166380405426, -0.02252207137644291, -0.03265366330742836, 0.1255466639995575, -0.06732471287250519, -0.06529068946838379, -0.015429108403623104, -0.013213924132287502, 0.014669911935925484, -0.023658251389861107, -0.1003105491399765, 0.021435806527733803, -0.05509699881076813, -0.018328439444303513, -0.029801711440086365, 0.05798313766717911, -0.0504361055791378, -0.06095477566123009, 0.02332073636353016, 0.037288010120391846, -0.009950101375579834, 0.025241265073418617, -0.1221478059887886, -0.05758426710963249, -0.006928019691258669, -0.04520570486783981, 0.04212820157408714, -0.01994318887591362, 0.008730925619602203, -0.009807239286601543, -0.034549031406641006, -0.024199532344937325, -0.059890035539865494, 0.09684847295284271, 0.04231981188058853, 0.02966444008052349, 0.04155758395791054, 0.030089231207966805, -0.051055725663900375, 0.027482684701681137, 0.040415503084659576, -0.02814757078886032, 0.016792282462120056, 0.00983077846467495, 0.010784387588500977, -0.05135917291045189, -0.008536373265087605, -0.022456524893641472, 0.018675480037927628, 0.07821572571992874, 0.015303142368793488, -0.029018906876444817, -0.0014409497380256653, 0.012670820578932762, -0.07448523491621017, -0.049758430570364, 0.05271439626812935, -0.010164249688386917, -0.006156439892947674, 0.0035144865978509188, 0.010633439756929874, -0.007362712174654007, 0.012646268121898174, 0.04434938728809357, -0.03648117929697037, -0.06063232198357582, 0.02209945023059845, 0.00620823260396719, 0.043688446283340454, -0.030096793547272682, 0.050930388271808624, -0.05457882583141327, 0.00946155283600092, -0.06426871567964554, 0.03481490910053253, 0.03850344568490982, 0.05509423092007637, -0.025175148621201515, -0.017762910574674606, -0.0033029173500835896, -0.08294891566038132, -0.04087155684828758, -0.08373595774173737, 0.0596548356115818, -0.002430062973871827, 0.10188762098550797, 0.0782250463962555, -0.03841517120599747, -0.026939503848552704, -0.016459457576274872, -0.012741762213408947, 0.04992954805493355, -0.044061802327632904, -0.0372210331261158, 0.023099679499864578, 0.04539695382118225, -0.030860912054777145, 0.007761957123875618, -0.052757278084754944, 0.009589314460754395, -0.0320512056350708, -0.005512503907084465, -0.018306275829672813, -0.0001529533474240452, -0.01160337496548891, -0.06941453367471695, 0.017593899741768837, -0.007589683402329683, 0.042552098631858826, 0.055535443127155304, -0.016315342858433723, 0.030709482729434967, 0.012581013143062592, -0.008984931744635105, 0.004235733300447464, -0.06141625717282295, -0.03912884369492531, 0.06802757829427719, -0.014220595359802246, 0.04597524181008339, 0.003350734245032072, -0.062876857817173, 0.016078444197773933, 0.020879287272691727, 0.015567041002213955, 0.03207872807979584, 0.03513098135590553, 0.022506842389702797, -0.028548790141940117, -0.08023462444543839, 0.03637225925922394, -0.05247054621577263, -0.0362224206328392, -0.05294746905565262, -0.0524478405714035, -0.01650092378258705, 0.02588854916393757, -0.005565842613577843, -0.04430394247174263, 0.07107425481081009, 0.018341490998864174, -0.00837409682571888, -0.031174825504422188, 0.01328368205577135, -0.04327719658613205, -0.0058342511765658855, -0.04629066213965416, 0.02945413626730442, -0.04610244184732437, -0.05407095327973366, -0.047830235213041306, 0.04422064498066902, 0.04758363962173462, -0.01576848141849041, 0.0005039825919084251, 0.0022320630960166454, 0.036429207772016525, 0.0011346699902787805, -0.024608291685581207, 0.036668673157691956, -0.12397122383117676, -0.06720103323459625, -0.008325091563165188, -0.021805059164762497, 0.004403369035571814, -0.04107290133833885, -0.04599741846323013, -0.04436337202787399, -0.04326286539435387, 0.024752642959356308, -0.01329834759235382, -0.008800766430795193, -0.0027455247472971678, -0.029427964240312576, 0.015818960964679718, 0.041765499860048294, 0.00002815875268424861, -0.025118866935372353, 0.03216012567281723, 0.08049889653921127, 0.04902566596865654, 0.0027215201407670975, -0.03130670636892319, -0.021243581548333168, 0.037101827561855316, 0.0015423631994053721, -0.026963021606206894, 0.03548477962613106, 0.06761015951633453, -0.0002815758634824306, -0.07006955146789551, -0.024288130924105644, 0.01597169227898121, 0.045123279094696045, -0.06583407521247864, -0.04477723315358162, -0.0008865841082297266, -0.012574790976941586, 0.023567145690321922, -0.02563522756099701, -0.006566296797245741, 0.07947791367769241, -0.011442680843174458, -0.0858626514673233, -0.04792999476194382, -0.03584268316626549, 0.011127420701086521, 0.002860231092199683, 0.054944489151239395, -0.010004824958741665, 0.01581411249935627, -0.012147556059062481, -0.07800695300102234, 0.027037225663661957, 0.09717526286840439, 0.000697274343110621, 0.031809404492378235, 0.07651473581790924, 0.04364815354347229, 0.0243949256837368, -0.019541673362255096, -0.006760850548744202, 0.019682157784700394, -0.022479945793747902, -0.04654712975025177, -0.031455207616090775, 0.007323116529732943, -0.01995246484875679, 0.01585022546350956, 0.017537595704197884, 0.0416664220392704, -0.04104316607117653, 0.006619631312787533, 0.04091678187251091, -0.016957595944404602, 0.003504945896565914, -0.002829811768606305, -0.07333104312419891, -0.032174717634916306, 0.03360976651310921, 0.03473692014813423, 0.013073696754872799 ]
119
119
On Sequences with Non-Learnable Subsequences
The remarkable results of Foster and Vohra was a starting point for a series of papers which show that any sequence of outcomes can be learned (with no prior knowledge) using some universal randomized forecasting algorithm and forecast-dependent checking rules. We show that for the class of all computationally efficient outcome-forecast-based checking rules, this property is violated. Moreover, we present a probabilistic algorithm generating with probability close to one a sequence with a subsequence which simultaneously miscalibrates all partially weakly computable randomized forecasting algorithms. %subsequences non-learnable by each randomized algorithm. According to the Dawid's prequential framework we consider partial recursive randomized algorithms.
[ -0.076962910592556, -0.04005937650799751, 0.06747742742300034, -0.02702198550105095, 0.04211248829960823, -0.028847841545939445, -0.0048443651758134365, 0.012258199043571949, 0.024966269731521606, 0.03083713911473751, -0.04056336358189583, -0.07142769545316696, -0.0504106767475605, 0.07721886783838272, 0.06128757447004318, 0.0210474394261837, -0.09267667680978775, 0.0740518718957901, -0.04158203303813934, -0.05988172069191933, 0.003214447759091854, 0.006975168362259865, 0.03731195628643036, -0.009563793428242207, 0.06467347592115402, 0.0033216667361557484, 0.0028612674213945866, 0.01446864940226078, -0.02900427207350731, -0.019975772127509117, -0.12482934445142746, 0.02303227037191391, -0.03889148309826851, 0.008623424917459488, 0.040345437824726105, 0.05219636857509613, -0.025754373520612717, -0.03357323259115219, -0.09868453443050385, -0.015336913987994194, 0.07014615833759308, -0.06390474736690521, 0.020012078806757927, -0.00024497415870428085, 0.021377384662628174, 0.013875411823391914, 0.04609365016222, 0.0009989951504394412, 0.00894317775964737, -0.0007810092647559941, -0.03342470899224281, -0.011131003499031067, -0.016841063275933266, -0.008841599337756634, -0.03856471925973892, 0.03220894932746887, -0.03327055275440216, 0.05853152275085449, -0.04374547302722931, -0.013088702224195004, 0.025781331583857536, 0.07171140611171722, 0.03864020109176636, -0.07305160164833069, -0.04153037071228027, -0.011016259901225567, -0.033573657274246216, 0.006396369077265263, 0.06749072670936584, -0.02149292081594467, -0.0015367295127362013, -0.09698786586523056, 0.08826093375682831, 0.03453013673424721, 0.031258195638656616, 0.014287875033915043, -0.016158053651452065, 0.07107222825288773, -0.014986133202910423, 0.03701094537973404, -0.07619006186723709, 0.07793601602315903, 0.016852550208568573, -0.032662615180015564, -0.02200162783265114, -0.007899804972112179, -0.0362536646425724, -0.0008310055127367377, 0.03172134608030319, -0.09381469339132309, -0.0439571812748909, 0.028747284784913063, -0.08507420867681503, 0.07232046127319336, 0.012221135199069977, 0.04133719205856323, 0.048257194459438324, 0.050573933869600296, -0.02840341441333294, 0.02127835713326931, 0.06734437495470047, 0.00785877276211977, 0.06522725522518158, 0.04767141491174698, -0.013723095878958702, 0.014388635754585266, 0.05130758509039879, -0.02706243470311165, 0.0552343986928463, -0.01428298931568861, 0.028627434745430946, -0.013558800332248211, 0.027323024347424507, 0.0023741654586046934, -0.011154296807944775, 0.05045214667916298, -0.032463885843753815, 0.09350430220365524, 0.04052884504199028, -0.019139189273118973, 0.0379345528781414, -0.008575891144573689, -0.00471752043813467, 0.028944334015250206, 0.01824520342051983, 0.014808641746640205, -0.07018754631280899, -0.042945533990859985, 0.12833619117736816, -0.03167802095413208, -0.018944114446640015, 0.022012704983353615, -0.00416858633980155, -0.005598274990916252, -0.034972067922353745, 0.0545637346804142, 0.0012266209814697504, 0.035148244351148605, -0.04131187126040459, -0.03408151492476463, -0.0058769225142896175, -0.12450916320085526, -0.007859451696276665, 0.03855377435684204, -0.05446423590183258, 0.059597283601760864, -0.008761280216276646, 0.024087710306048393, -0.10995946079492569, 0.0069533055648207664, 0.00672451127320528, 0.015771791338920593, -0.006324831862002611, 0.04471282288432121, 0.04810571298003197, -0.04714377224445343, -0.03045697696506977, 0.055923942476511, -0.098604217171669, 0.07462148368358612, -0.03197796270251274, 0.0036878748796880245, -0.021966321393847466, 0.07430850714445114, 0.0325731486082077, 0.06491640955209732, 0.006384664215147495, 0.028650827705860138, -0.07418288290500641, -0.013591660186648369, 0.027007881551980972, 0.0293424092233181, 0.06869412213563919, -0.04327782243490219, 0.00996373686939478, -0.022403337061405182, -0.021165208891034126, 0.01585375890135765, -0.03001367673277855, -0.046108536422252655, -0.009822303429245949, -0.054760854691267014, -0.05723314732313156, 0.025828732177615166, 0.01002816203981638, 0.09993685036897659, 0.03395545110106468, 0.0010354326805099845, 0.09134042263031006, 0.040493689477443695, -0.016282696276903152, -0.0036599505692720413, -0.055686790496110916, -0.043375544250011444, -0.03256986290216446, -0.03703054413199425, -0.022258713841438293, -0.0250838715583086, -0.02684292383491993, 0.09870599955320358, -0.03399248421192169, 0.050217464566230774, -0.03163923695683479, -0.024334179237484932, -0.054237861186265945, -0.012321386486291885, 0.009235143661499023, -0.0852661281824112, 0.05038156732916832, -0.023896697908639908, 0.017362764105200768, -0.009709450416266918, 0.0046150414273142815, -0.01293237041682005, 0.0298274178057909, -0.09273534268140793, -0.052215225994586945, -0.12675324082374573, 0.08368201553821564, 0.0186451468616724, -0.021127775311470032, 0.021770337596535683, -0.03456728532910347, 0.033339764922857285, -0.0785859227180481, -0.057403553277254105, 0.04609568417072296, 0.014439612627029419, -0.08474026620388031, 0.026974044740200043, -0.03999411687254906, -0.02500108815729618, -0.018834641203284264, -0.005316021852195263, 0.08333056420087814, 0.03544456511735916, 0.04627421125769615, -0.0500437431037426, -0.012135349214076996, 0.009376531466841698, -0.02305380441248417, -0.006631134077906609, 0.03285083547234535, 0.09379445016384125, 0.020365651696920395, -0.0013047161046415567, 0.025850804522633553, -0.004523002542555332, -0.027352454140782356, -0.01446130033582449, 0.030283018946647644, -0.0030769414734095335, -0.029957784339785576, -0.0277660321444273, 0.06503991037607193, 0.0019231811165809631, -0.031605109572410583, 0.09829127043485641, 0.05382467061281204, -0.0477616973221302, 0.04307767376303673, 0.022921252995729446, -0.019383873790502548, 0.05335598438978195, 0.023080848157405853, 0.07966058701276779, -0.012216413393616676, -0.00676161702722311, -0.053420182317495346, 0.016414368525147438, -0.00808274932205677, -0.0012066210620105267, -0.061926066875457764, 0.09043082594871521, -0.0617932565510273, -0.05524524673819542, 0.04934527724981308, -0.021980538964271545, 0.009939134120941162, -0.011231737211346626, -0.023382216691970825, 0.06650414317846298, -0.05380571261048317, -0.014432720839977264, 0.016510114073753357, -0.03453412279486656, -0.020916622132062912, 0.0015387543244287372, -0.029854929074645042, 0.06876713037490845, -0.005846987944096327, 0.007721852045506239, 0.003061456372961402, 0.01318086963146925, 0.06532315909862518, -0.07891377806663513, 0.010485203005373478, 0.01266100350767374, -0.011118672788143158, -0.026484668254852295, -0.0009019541903398931, -0.022065401077270508, -0.00835745595395565, 0.07952705025672913, 0.03417797386646271, 0.03285592049360275, 0.023143749684095383, 0.050809718668460846, -0.0062151262536644936, 0.04461340606212616, 0.02929786592721939, -0.03822464123368263, 0.027013348415493965, 0.0009018960408866405, 0.010033542290329933, 0.008625278249382973, -0.03988943248987198, -0.04686008766293526, 0.020133068785071373, 0.001300205010920763, 0.036472149193286896, -0.0032759197056293488, -0.007075451780110598, 0.03549816086888313, -0.04308867081999779, 0.01714775338768959, -0.008007016964256763, -0.026642216369509697, -0.09211099147796631, 0.002981892554089427, 0.03593128174543381, 0.03293031081557274, 0.03203389793634415, 0.06111516058444977, -0.07025580108165741, 0.016033995896577835, -0.08423279970884323, 0.06083385646343231, 0.03557658940553665, -0.004763423930853605, -0.013738486915826797, -0.07756885886192322, -0.02928760088980198, -0.033120304346084595, 0.02324223332107067, 0.04041473567485809, 0.10081228613853455, 0.02694937400519848, 0.011734899133443832, -0.0015339560341089964, -0.05003305524587631, -0.02689979039132595, 0.020109273493289948, 0.07167209684848785, 0.005970242898911238, 0.02758108265697956, 0.057997144758701324, -0.011628189124166965, -0.02190685085952282, 0.014234640635550022, 0.028354836627840996, 0.02380596660077572, -0.01426602527499199, -0.025941651314496994, 0.025157667696475983, 0.05310758203268051, 0.03540632501244545, -0.010400216095149517, -0.03873191773891449, -0.03081466443836689, 0.034126561135053635, 0.024825403466820717, 0.018370192497968674, 0.06507250666618347, 0.0424298420548439, 0.02135263755917549, 0.09789472818374634, -0.11312766373157501, -0.055248357355594635, 0.07808151841163635, -0.017967982217669487, 0.0013789581134915352, -0.024751394987106323, -0.04548604413866997, -0.03447816148400307, -0.00591884134337306, -0.04122201353311539, -0.003571938956156373, 0.049434810876846313, -0.0001770944072632119, 0.01321229338645935, -0.028746474534273148, 0.020194020122289658, 0.061170440167188644, -0.028973272070288658, -0.013234990648925304, 0.03780081123113632, -0.06222844123840332, -0.05443890765309334, -0.046366143971681595, 0.021301601082086563, -0.1157413125038147, 0.059326086193323135, -0.012929241172969341, -0.06468109786510468, 0.03208288550376892, 0.07406260818243027, 0.06492278724908829, 0.007267091888934374, 0.023008951917290688, 0.017636118456721306, 0.07948730140924454, -0.006929861381649971, 0.02675790712237358, -0.06721486151218414, 0.03903926908969879, 0.06229919195175171, -0.01692916266620159, -0.062458641827106476, -0.011517174541950226, -0.019927114248275757, 0.03368740156292915, 0.00801390316337347, -0.0332132913172245, 0.041040629148483276, -0.04912335053086281, 0.0355791412293911, 0.08824712783098221, -0.06430596113204956, -0.006306787021458149, -0.059687405824661255, -0.061309389770030975, -0.09767033159732819, 0.006538470275700092, -0.006862387992441654, -0.03557882830500603, -0.003943272400647402, -0.02212556265294552, -0.05549149960279465, 0.013728629797697067, -0.08046114444732666, 0.005113924853503704, -0.0028493155259639025, 0.07251860201358795, -0.005133950151503086, 0.060909025371074677, -0.00016988703282549977, -0.04663093760609627, 0.048131830990314484, -0.010772617533802986, 0.05206502601504326, 0.02549242042005062, 0.012419202364981174, -0.027402164414525032, 0.025638053193688393, 0.00514569878578186, 0.030618838965892792, -0.08408892899751663, 0.018753115087747574, -0.016791226342320442, -0.04698392376303673, -0.02940901182591915, -0.001303436583839357, 0.011637778021395206, -0.022285787388682365, -0.07584840059280396, 0.04106845706701279, 0.021777359768748283, 0.09986612200737, -0.016309330239892006, 0.008158489130437374, 0.04691220074892044, -0.0022783586755394936, -0.005071718245744705, -0.0367901474237442, -0.02319532260298729, 0.05305358022451401, -0.04154200479388237, 0.02276494912803173, 0.03979112207889557, 0.04938181862235069, 0.05147367715835571, -0.0715770572423935, 0.0078884931281209, 0.0576026476919651, 0.08271049708127975, 0.0029028886929154396, -0.02818029187619686, 0.024148153141140938, 0.06056004390120506, 0.05439101159572601, 0.016732901334762573, 0.00891184899955988, 0.021690085530281067, 0.03206728398799896, 0.008091415278613567, 0.019315868616104126, -0.03174047917127609, 0.01434475276619196, 0.04531726613640785, -0.009595011360943317, 0.02610928565263748, 0.01637178659439087, 0.04762378707528114, 0.03868666663765907, 0.011278803460299969, 0.0243330467492342, -0.01290128007531166, -0.005270424298942089, 0.03881102800369263, -0.002485521137714386, 0.0632186233997345 ]
120
120
Prediction with Expert Advice in Games with Unbounded One-Step Gains
The games of prediction with expert advice are considered in this paper. We present some modification of Kalai and Vempala algorithm of following the perturbed leader for the case of unrestrictedly large one-step gains. We show that in general case the cumulative gain of any probabilistic prediction algorithm can be much worse than the gain of some expert of the pool. Nevertheless, we give the lower bound for this cumulative gain in general case and construct a universal algorithm which has the optimal performance; we also prove that in case when one-step gains of experts of the pool have ``limited deviations'' the performance of our algorithm is close to the performance of the best expert.
[ -0.04121117666363716, -0.019013455137610435, -0.038338981568813324, -0.0539836511015892, -0.022208523005247116, -0.061236437410116196, 0.029897574335336685, -0.0643918439745903, -0.00018211067072115839, 0.023839721456170082, -0.03214468061923981, -0.03979955241084099, -0.003053446300327778, -0.02451220527291298, 0.06581130623817444, -0.04910597577691078, -0.025936562567949295, 0.09840412437915802, -0.04185112193226814, -0.025237202644348145, 0.09811581671237946, -0.0007538144127465785, 0.034582048654556274, -0.08649361878633499, -0.037746064364910126, -0.0007989620207808912, 0.02962675504386425, -0.019767696037888527, 0.004798634443432093, -0.008122664876282215, -0.02596985176205635, -0.02524738200008869, 0.021372133865952492, 0.06668141484260559, 0.04443694278597832, -0.08504214137792587, 0.03778016194701195, -0.1029641330242157, -0.04148904234170914, 0.01141349971294403, 0.034286774694919586, 0.008940589614212513, -0.005790689028799534, 0.0003954118292313069, 0.0003455070254858583, -0.014790304936468601, -0.009854000061750412, 0.0023162756115198135, -0.050988782197237015, 0.006247528828680515, -0.06618709862232208, -0.016307920217514038, 0.005043951794505119, -0.005376091226935387, 0.005941126029938459, 0.04384738951921463, -0.02543269284069538, -0.0774436742067337, -0.062201645225286484, -0.0874587818980217, -0.008970679715275764, 0.1015574112534523, -0.025534166023135185, -0.05551232770085335, -0.04474926367402077, -0.009635601192712784, -0.0512157678604126, 0.02298099361360073, 0.04577456787228584, -0.06011386960744858, 0.05628225952386856, 0.01390931848436594, 0.09032785892486572, 0.017083371058106422, 0.042774226516485214, 0.03618445619940758, -0.004668394103646278, 0.02558877505362034, 0.025364624336361885, 0.0782034769654274, -0.03958231210708618, -0.01519564725458622, 0.04330459609627724, 0.043210968375205994, 0.022685790434479713, 0.0033534520771354437, 0.0042165773920714855, -0.009174817241728306, -0.034948527812957764, -0.07453768700361252, 0.036922700703144073, 0.032797858119010925, -0.02417665906250477, 0.020047612488269806, -0.02405223809182644, 0.09901546686887741, -0.06377285718917847, -0.020272156223654747, 0.03557028993964195, -0.006681020371615887, 0.022073376923799515, -0.012729966081678867, 0.006071298848837614, 0.06097438931465149, 0.0032513095065951347, 0.028302455320954323, -0.010431640781462193, 0.03302210569381714, 0.06052241101861, -0.03788866102695465, 0.07326845079660416, -0.08776454627513885, -0.006009363569319248, 0.0062202271074056625, -0.05901459977030754, 0.10104489326477051, -0.03211818262934685, 0.026155559346079826, 0.038947705179452896, 0.04493821784853935, 0.06920959800481796, -0.038664888590574265, -0.013544022105634212, 0.030845412984490395, 0.01315993256866932, -0.04486836865544319, -0.019808072596788406, -0.06658342480659485, 0.12644019722938538, 0.010685162618756294, -0.01246703416109085, 0.025030938908457756, -0.0687619224190712, -0.04284410551190376, -0.02895297482609749, 0.06478053331375122, 0.014507133513689041, -0.04033203050494194, -0.06154942139983177, 0.09975013881921768, -0.04840955138206482, 0.016070164740085602, -0.012852012179791927, 0.051619041711091995, 0.009760390035808086, 0.017978448420763016, 0.0060032568871974945, 0.013947388157248497, -0.06349825114011765, 0.015523682348430157, 0.0017419246723875403, 0.0786777138710022, 0.03162455931305885, 0.06695046275854111, 0.05383535102009773, -0.03002246841788292, -0.054996587336063385, -0.023633163422346115, -0.09082287549972534, 0.030756834894418716, 0.028888143599033356, 0.05539523810148239, 0.03137481212615967, -0.009133486077189445, 0.06924692541360855, 0.02120628021657467, -0.05365703999996185, -0.013477230444550514, 0.0030350876040756702, -0.06373841315507889, 0.05141393095254898, 0.008434413000941277, -0.020138639956712723, -0.02714887075126171, -0.015609712339937687, -0.10663504898548126, 0.02160489559173584, -0.02095395140349865, 0.07190383225679398, -0.036936040967702866, 0.017544690519571304, 0.003608807921409607, -0.004954999778419733, 0.001992969075217843, 0.08852455019950867, 0.08005529642105103, 0.022255059331655502, 0.03740004450082779, 0.06624264270067215, 0.026011820882558823, 0.03242398798465729, 0.011654685251414776, -0.013280658982694149, -0.07387632876634598, -0.052798815071582794, 0.02766486443579197, -0.046541277319192886, -0.03386309742927551, -0.004788110498338938, 0.025139855220913887, 0.05630530044436455, 0.07542674243450165, -0.08517123013734818, -0.019093088805675507, -0.047470033168792725, -0.01893223449587822, 0.03153092414140701, -0.10577977448701859, -0.02609401009976864, 0.004996084608137608, 0.01108195073902607, -0.015445457771420479, -0.030419766902923584, -0.03565099835395813, 0.017100002616643906, -0.07797607779502869, -0.02206408977508545, -0.08601070195436478, 0.007275069132447243, 0.020905060693621635, -0.016339175403118134, 0.045350901782512665, 0.030127964913845062, 0.0031090914271771908, -0.10801943391561508, -0.053302962332963943, 0.0245636235922575, 0.04269615560770035, -0.04280369356274605, 0.06643886119127274, -0.03811793774366379, -0.04518771544098854, -0.01647176221013069, -0.002447092439979315, -0.04028409719467163, 0.018025455996394157, -0.026540637016296387, -0.07803857326507568, -0.04667344316840172, 0.009724467992782593, 0.07265439629554749, -0.0421094112098217, -0.058685239404439926, 0.03626062348484993, 0.026947451755404472, -0.03742431476712227, 0.07122068107128143, 0.011810512281954288, -0.08021466434001923, 0.023232169449329376, 0.09523474425077438, -0.02715516835451126, -0.0011604705359786749, -0.0035737252328544855, -0.041093163192272186, 0.05895378068089485, -0.025589969009160995, 0.08948415517807007, 0.10127408057451248, 0.015075155533850193, 0.009182336740195751, 0.02353990077972412, -0.007328617386519909, -0.042931050062179565, 0.06569843739271164, 0.024009723216295242, -0.011100716888904572, 0.0518951341509819, -0.05982057750225067, 0.03811930492520332, -0.009545031003654003, -0.03476657345890999, 0.01955266483128071, 0.10645002871751785, -0.030687062069773674, -0.09652096033096313, 0.0005642108735628426, 0.01383402943611145, 0.06600137799978256, -0.004927471745759249, -0.007223172578960657, 0.06165573000907898, -0.016323909163475037, -0.01784178614616394, 0.0019682131242007017, 0.0077821738086640835, -0.03198437765240669, 0.003823878476396203, 0.018526168540120125, 0.06413828581571579, -0.04127976670861244, -0.023068126291036606, -0.05650835111737251, -0.0471213199198246, 0.007986526936292648, -0.018354371190071106, 0.08526044338941574, 0.019948113709688187, 0.06738126277923584, 0.024819988757371902, -0.03960082307457924, 0.08205527067184448, 0.013224600814282894, 0.07497505098581314, 0.03340351954102516, 0.07017919421195984, 0.027996761724352837, 0.060432277619838715, 0.006688975729048252, -0.015228317119181156, -0.0005272245034575462, -0.0329124890267849, 0.003265769686549902, 0.05541989579796791, 0.02864159271121025, 0.02894207090139389, -0.053423792123794556, -0.005211908835917711, -0.052863359451293945, 0.015360225923359394, -0.02136288210749626, -0.02585737779736519, -0.009795577265322208, 0.06217312812805176, -0.07374407351016998, 0.023524774238467216, -0.001086452160961926, 0.05100051313638687, -0.05606057122349739, 0.05428760126233101, 0.0025736105162650347, 0.04482375457882881, -0.03880765661597252, 0.052787892520427704, -0.1059664934873581, 0.008044865913689137, -0.07219429314136505, 0.005544212181121111, 0.0898451954126358, 0.025179224088788033, -0.044067978858947754, -0.0429430715739727, -0.04134729877114296, -0.0330355241894722, 0.001865274622105062, 0.06885094940662384, 0.09787163883447647, 0.08200235664844513, -0.05035344138741493, 0.027428623288869858, 0.009611232206225395, -0.049389418214559555, -0.029490066692233086, 0.03056659735739231, 0.02077282965183258, 0.051571495831012726, 0.06468304246664047, -0.0018458690028637648, -0.06937580555677414, 0.022022834047675133, 0.010875470004975796, -0.03303691744804382, 0.03846634924411774, -0.06093866005539894, 0.05783460661768913, 0.08424347639083862, -0.010845646262168884, -0.006976315286010504, -0.02874578721821308, -0.03213405981659889, -0.009197081439197063, 0.04106208682060242, -0.01619788259267807, -0.003907804377377033, 0.02448313869535923, -0.03475430607795715, 0.056839440017938614, -0.03202904015779495, -0.01961049810051918, 0.08763930946588516, -0.02261468954384327, 0.03243257850408554, -0.037617359310388565, -0.038809407502412796, -0.013961227610707283, -0.02567382901906967, -0.06448762863874435, 0.011805754154920578, 0.030734870582818985, -0.023406988009810448, -0.013251950964331627, -0.02722681500017643, -0.019664255902171135, 0.04164625331759453, -0.006957483012229204, 0.007777616381645203, 0.08264521509408951, -0.0390012226998806, -0.0532439760863781, -0.02161983586847782, 0.020086275413632393, -0.06423217058181763, -0.0014390064170584083, -0.038055337965488434, -0.03899293765425682, -0.006082569714635611, 0.06734330952167511, 0.02781900204718113, 0.018153265118598938, 0.024850111454725266, 0.05184720456600189, 0.06388354301452637, -0.0244999248534441, -0.026748133823275566, -0.007021901663392782, -0.01273424830287695, -0.013363596983253956, 0.01942647434771061, 0.019378168508410454, -0.04309134557843208, -0.004415147937834263, 0.02802412584424019, 0.008288223296403885, -0.010685817338526249, 0.01805753819644451, -0.05085636302828789, 0.02965785376727581, -0.010889080353081226, 0.001917220652103424, 0.013669048435986042, -0.0723985806107521, -0.04274174943566322, -0.03150084614753723, -0.09755675494670868, 0.0369451567530632, -0.015484917908906937, 0.055299025028944016, -0.045877210795879364, 0.0008645669440738857, 0.008790378458797932, -0.08378838747739792, 0.00557995680719614, 0.05463697388768196, 0.05634799599647522, -0.07521285861730576, 0.0437602661550045, -0.039041295647621155, -0.04411713406443596, -0.002612140029668808, -0.006485032383352518, -0.0005404083640314639, 0.04188884422183037, -0.014712112955749035, -0.04510773345828056, 0.02097558230161667, 0.018336458131670952, -0.03421160206198692, 0.006986526306718588, 0.04899945855140686, -0.08844225108623505, -0.053998224437236786, -0.05158271640539169, -0.006990659050643444, 0.001934814383275807, -0.05102657899260521, -0.024851396679878235, -0.052164312452077866, -0.05528116226196289, 0.035655777901411057, 0.005649728700518608, -0.06048641353845596, 0.01571636088192463, -0.0030128725338727236, -0.07982931286096573, -0.03548730909824371, -0.019470639526844025, 0.000617160985711962, -0.021812496706843376, 0.01008277852088213, 0.024008741602301598, 0.00581288943067193, 0.006442524958401918, -0.020599225535988808, 0.02732972986996174, 0.08529510349035263, 0.05216086655855179, -0.020239446312189102, -0.032890211790800095, 0.028372274711728096, 0.007487636990845203, 0.022058691829442978, -0.009592747315764427, -0.01989629864692688, -0.017494890838861465, 0.06727476418018341, 0.026270432397723198, 0.08382932841777802, -0.026629602536559105, -0.027557440102100372, 0.05313170328736305, 0.005728058982640505, -0.029353149235248566, 0.04777980223298073, 0.025272781029343605, 0.0359770767390728, -0.0018402927089482546, -0.00240710168145597, 0.006428620312362909, -0.01901989057660103, 0.02600046433508396, 0.02799251489341259, 0.029684562236070633 ]
121
121
Computationally Efficient Estimators for Dimension Reductions Using Stable Random Projections
The method of stable random projections is a tool for efficiently computing the $l_\alpha$ distances using low memory, where $0<\alpha \leq 2$ is a tuning parameter. The method boils down to a statistical estimation task and various estimators have been proposed, based on the geometric mean, the harmonic mean, and the fractional power etc. This study proposes the optimal quantile estimator, whose main operation is selecting, which is considerably less expensive than taking fractional power, the main operation in previous estimators. Our experiments report that the optimal quantile estimator is nearly one order of magnitude more computationally efficient than previous estimators. For large-scale learning tasks in which storing and computing pairwise distances is a serious bottleneck, this estimator should be desirable. In addition to its computational advantages, the optimal quantile estimator exhibits nice theoretical properties. It is more accurate than previous estimators when $\alpha>1$. We derive its theoretical error bounds and establish the explicit (i.e., no hidden constants) sample complexity bound.
[ 0.012880251742899418, -0.01590515300631523, 0.01731749065220356, -0.02493799664080143, 0.01770070381462574, 0.01509812567383051, 0.06836329400539398, -0.05563484877347946, -0.06827880442142487, 0.05208424851298332, -0.030851900577545166, 0.027269452810287476, -0.07409243285655975, 0.048085954040288925, -0.017393045127391815, -0.03880868852138519, -0.08692445605993271, 0.016152072697877884, 0.0850592628121376, -0.003933608066290617, -0.05526391789317131, -0.06130713224411011, 0.02726980485022068, -0.06731219589710236, 0.024423157796263695, 0.02167634852230549, 0.014520908705890179, -0.024371298030018806, -0.05883782356977463, -0.004774670582264662, -0.028080709278583527, 0.03397176042199135, 0.018030155450105667, -0.0070825195871293545, -0.003934375010430813, -0.01951560564339161, 0.06911340355873108, 0.019756803289055824, -0.017110096290707588, -0.07846987247467041, -0.022123096510767937, -0.07666447758674622, -0.021745268255472183, -0.030867457389831543, 0.02304912358522415, 0.005449294112622738, -0.00024556004791520536, 0.06998182088136673, -0.023762058466672897, -0.0033390778116881847, 0.045531146228313446, -0.007627266459167004, -0.033230431377887726, 0.0003582514764275402, 0.027775952592492104, 0.02000034786760807, -0.02257656492292881, -0.03257516026496887, -0.0199650339782238, 0.010213884525001049, 0.006136735435575247, 0.09600713849067688, 0.006328311283141375, -0.04141852259635925, -0.012798503041267395, -0.0041528563015162945, -0.027088353410363197, -0.01851309835910797, -0.0547625757753849, -0.050782881677150726, -0.019425317645072937, -0.06347976624965668, -0.027818888425827026, 0.01675180159509182, 0.00817071832716465, -0.028729338198900223, 0.001408578478731215, -0.02512778900563717, 0.059437286108732224, 0.047995246946811676, -0.05223195627331734, -0.019647587090730667, -0.023242322728037834, 0.040952958166599274, -0.08594048768281937, 0.012886322103440762, 0.03448345139622688, 0.0013446439988911152, 0.021367309615015984, -0.04784821718931198, -0.02623727358877659, 0.025616072118282318, -0.07366660237312317, 0.012688507325947285, -0.06091136112809181, 0.041587572544813156, 0.004296578001230955, -0.010353545658290386, -0.024365196004509926, 0.06002671271562576, -0.003958981484174728, -0.052984416484832764, 0.047498904168605804, 0.09106307476758957, 0.04063468053936958, 0.01663866825401783, -0.07834672182798386, 0.025056833401322365, 0.017902323976159096, -0.0017837201012298465, -0.010472298599779606, -0.049244578927755356, 0.03667023405432701, 0.016566284000873566, -0.051732782274484634, 0.05083482712507248, 0.013161662966012955, 0.0066840071231126785, 0.008165196515619755, 0.009398926049470901, 0.06347817927598953, 0.017039507627487183, -0.009888490661978722, -0.00890541821718216, 0.04423188790678978, 0.00788415689021349, 0.055332545191049576, -0.08797059953212738, 0.1179220899939537, -0.0639326423406601, -0.021700089797377586, -0.0035114490892738104, -0.06947020441293716, -0.020843230187892914, -0.09229546785354614, -0.0036372931208461523, 0.03654380515217781, -0.05822400003671646, 0.03422108292579651, 0.09382407367229462, -0.023853907361626625, -0.01513297576457262, -0.03222646191716194, 0.0008580240537412465, 0.01833934523165226, -0.03144348785281181, -0.03337381035089493, 0.012319406494498253, -0.018289312720298767, -0.030822981148958206, 0.003244364634156227, -0.07260962575674057, 0.009173659607768059, -0.02935858443379402, 0.06145801767706871, -0.06348995864391327, 0.03824405372142792, -0.018305031582713127, 0.016020698472857475, 0.03740191087126732, -0.040833812206983566, 0.03667594492435455, -0.0019501815550029278, -0.020880037918686867, -0.02198616974055767, 0.060052983462810516, -0.04671069607138634, -0.05381911247968674, 0.013094129972159863, -0.03334382176399231, -0.00009393258369527757, 0.02246098965406418, -0.08743393421173096, 0.009463224560022354, 0.0025125460233539343, -0.0017290000105276704, 0.02442641369998455, -0.04517306014895439, -0.022022247314453125, -0.03613258898258209, 0.056034769862890244, -0.04786024987697601, 0.02124052867293358, 0.0024951340164989233, 0.03553614020347595, 0.1162882074713707, -0.0657343938946724, 0.022776998579502106, 0.03662785142660141, 0.0012277512578293681, 0.04619479551911354, -0.022135138511657715, 0.01654152385890484, -0.047299936413764954, -0.001788624911569059, 0.04419376328587532, -0.07360842823982239, -0.05967002734541893, 0.05378349497914314, 0.034084685146808624, 0.06721796095371246, 0.0561920665204525, -0.05511470139026642, -0.010801672004163265, -0.08331447094678879, 0.03067474439740181, -0.021399904042482376, -0.020336028188467026, 0.015753094106912613, -0.06726706027984619, 0.06424332410097122, -0.03470539674162865, 0.01191026996821165, -0.10115401446819305, 0.009945712052285671, -0.034792955964803696, -0.029459642246365547, -0.025398341938853264, 0.03936466947197914, 0.050754424184560776, -0.0190002229064703, 0.009974497370421886, -0.0517459399998188, 0.08481283485889435, -0.011597562581300735, 0.011247789487242699, 0.06217488646507263, 0.038030095398426056, -0.03749195858836174, 0.01947067305445671, 0.057532135397195816, 0.003104659030213952, -0.0021928157657384872, 0.01637231931090355, -0.07373521476984024, 0.004143193364143372, -0.03822130709886551, -0.042817067354917526, -0.007831928320229053, -0.013932466506958008, -0.033228904008865356, 0.02728787623345852, -0.015050841495394707, -0.04813576489686966, -0.03520582988858223, -0.000005818799309054157, 0.08225147426128387, 0.04026610776782036, -0.02751145511865616, 0.05347949638962746, 0.032852061092853546, 0.03692569583654404, 0.0012897811830043793, -0.055872272700071335, 0.02657065913081169, 0.04902620241045952, 0.04640791565179825, 0.04143459349870682, 0.07492923736572266, 0.12976637482643127, 0.0007937991176731884, 0.03713065758347511, -0.003014263231307268, 0.03540721908211708, 0.052522215992212296, 0.060676030814647675, -0.042744267731904984, 0.0632973313331604, 0.00030742952367290854, 0.044757165014743805, 0.005643024109303951, -0.06603957712650299, -0.03870970010757446, 0.09686289727687836, -0.023184364661574364, 0.010610544122755527, 0.06710393726825714, 0.007483752444386482, 0.07415326684713364, -0.005479300860315561, -0.06333010643720627, -0.02081937901675701, -0.0051468596793711185, 0.020516688004136086, -0.05255473032593727, 0.06091451272368431, -0.04580584540963173, 0.0004369397065602243, -0.03938865661621094, -0.023479238152503967, -0.047409120947122574, 0.05840957164764404, 0.004666465800255537, -0.050386443734169006, 0.02452995441854, 0.0438208244740963, 0.04466976970434189, -0.025519181042909622, 0.09665223211050034, 0.019049977883696556, -0.04848877340555191, 0.047992948442697525, 0.05251774564385414, 0.08063270151615143, -0.03305167332291603, 0.04269421100616455, 0.08939298987388611, 0.012085694819688797, -0.051074493676424026, 0.02115027606487274, -0.002331014024093747, -0.01793541945517063, -0.050726961344480515, -0.006761977449059486, -0.03789304196834564, -0.04009087011218071, 0.008628029376268387, -0.05941464751958847, 0.046850793063640594, 0.021320201456546783, 0.06483827531337738, -0.017057685181498528, 0.08854823559522629, -0.018759362399578094, -0.08511187136173248, -0.016704291105270386, 0.05433136597275734, -0.008530238643288612, -0.027480032294988632, -0.0073408931493759155, -0.07158491760492325, 0.05155099183320999, -0.07499055564403534, 0.11679152399301529, 0.027991507202386856, 0.002711342880502343, -0.10127513855695724, -0.058632005006074905, -0.022572200745344162, -0.005094101186841726, -0.0034722185228019953, -0.008747313171625137, -0.015285490080714226, -0.022407574579119682, 0.05456658452749252, -0.010028766468167305, 0.12547095119953156, -0.018239052966237068, 0.037166792899370193, -0.013924268074333668, -0.04447520524263382, 0.003639718983322382, -0.005102239549160004, -0.002834934275597334, 0.01730327308177948, 0.10653100907802582, 0.02334761433303356, 0.013879258185625076, 0.03752964362502098, 0.06807981431484222, 0.005608539562672377, 0.04088704288005829, 0.0013090039137750864, -0.03585897386074066, 0.03447648882865906, 0.05797402560710907, -0.05283746123313904, -0.0016663902206346393, -0.0719783753156662, 0.028308134526014328, -0.04148381948471069, 0.06183911859989166, 0.022054187953472137, 0.05423654988408089, 0.025758346542716026, -0.011311220936477184, 0.045738305896520615, -0.046245478093624115, -0.02062905952334404, 0.07897938787937164, -0.06878728419542313, -0.025150204077363014, -0.022182419896125793, -0.011569839902222157, -0.037294771522283554, -0.013917096890509129, -0.009759234264492989, 0.012010209262371063, 0.024333128705620766, 0.065005823969841, -0.017890464514493942, -0.07162752747535706, 0.013144027441740036, 0.03938283026218414, 0.07006355375051498, 0.039059288799762726, 0.011230984702706337, -0.07019151747226715, 0.008899781852960587, -0.06045476347208023, 0.04735454544425011, -0.0625280812382698, -0.006365572568029165, -0.10854627937078476, -0.10027913004159927, -0.02292110212147236, -0.013474715873599052, 0.11670894920825958, -0.08757290989160538, 0.05576825514435768, 0.02308810129761696, -0.0002018161176238209, -0.01159292459487915, 0.05448427051305771, 0.012890025041997433, -0.06281444430351257, -0.018199410289525986, -0.06318718940019608, -0.04630682244896889, -0.09170801192522049, -0.008980217389762402, -0.005485674366354942, 0.030342157930135727, -0.04242696240544319, 0.11648257076740265, -0.014171812683343887, -0.0002946359454654157, -0.037029366940259933, -0.0036409858148545027, 0.0912969633936882, 0.01035722903907299, -0.016183212399482727, -0.034926123917102814, -0.056278590112924576, 0.029582049697637558, -0.02564449980854988, -0.02170214243233204, -0.02647274173796177, -0.023494286462664604, 0.038630783557891846, -0.04169905185699463, 0.04640917852520943, -0.06281892210245132, 0.021983090788125992, -0.05347801744937897, 0.04875779151916504, 0.059062182903289795, -0.009015243500471115, 0.05311925336718559, 0.014911949634552002, 0.010750416666269302, 0.029461229220032692, 0.06420348584651947, -0.061236780136823654, 0.004731510765850544, 0.05015285313129425, -0.02851441316306591, 0.008865004405379295, 0.026328008621931076, 0.007562043145298958, -0.028025448322296143, -0.0592682883143425, 0.033743441104888916, 0.08607208728790283, -0.039756979793310165, 0.018527353182435036, -0.021025262773036957, 0.03889598324894905, 0.02367951162159443, 0.0024590615648776293, -0.04235656186938286, 0.08173507452011108, -0.01901550218462944, -0.014651467092335224, 0.021497944369912148, -0.0016083474038168788, 0.01737365871667862, -0.036436330527067184, 0.03580746799707413, 0.002354505006223917, -0.001049898681230843, -0.02826484479010105, -0.032400865107774734, -0.011303119361400604, 0.07666623592376709, 0.053017958998680115, -0.0011311114067211747, 0.0037564467638731003, 0.059409670531749725, 0.024034859612584114, -0.001685001770965755, 0.00861327163875103, 0.005963070783764124, -0.009449954144656658, -0.051554061472415924, -0.0013372403336688876, -0.03767579048871994, 0.0272710882127285, 0.059824489057064056, 0.020552387461066246, -0.0031250636093318462, -0.06930427253246307, 0.07350073009729385, 0.02746271900832653, 0.04737548902630806, 0.014287176541984081, 0.014353573322296143, 0.010547459125518799, -0.0394192598760128, 0.020089341327548027, -0.028315553441643715, 0.019282745197415352 ]
122
122
On Approximating the Lp Distances for p>2
Applications in machine learning and data mining require computing pairwise Lp distances in a data matrix A. For massive high-dimensional data, computing all pairwise distances of A can be infeasible. In fact, even storing A or all pairwise distances of A in the memory may be also infeasible. This paper proposes a simple method for p = 2, 4, 6, ... We first decompose the l_p (where p is even) distances into a sum of 2 marginal norms and p-1 ``inner products'' at different orders. Then we apply normal or sub-Gaussian random projections to approximate the resultant ``inner products,'' assuming that the marginal norms can be computed exactly by a linear scan. We propose two strategies for applying random projections. The basic projection strategy requires only one projection matrix but it is more difficult to analyze, while the alternative projection strategy requires p-1 projection matrices but its theoretical analysis is much easier. In terms of the accuracy, at least for p=4, the basic strategy is always more accurate than the alternative strategy if the data are non-negative, which is common in reality.
[ -0.012602053582668304, -0.02857205830514431, 0.054064080119132996, -0.06576362252235413, 0.0313761942088604, 0.04448240250349045, 0.008205358870327473, -0.0028694956563413143, -0.01773194409906864, 0.05745412036776543, -0.026012539863586426, -0.06968092173337936, -0.013038664124906063, 0.044068221002817154, 0.004528892692178488, 0.05896126851439476, -0.11887511610984802, 0.040692903101444244, 0.06705828756093979, -0.059136927127838135, 0.00663550291210413, -0.031625740230083466, -0.07080559432506561, -0.010774056427180767, 0.005693361163139343, 0.009874195791780949, 0.007285161409527063, 0.03945394977927208, -0.029960373416543007, -0.01654631458222866, -0.017536306753754616, -0.013312706723809242, 0.011676822789013386, 0.005876277573406696, -0.04330761358141899, -0.01985834166407585, 0.06749631464481354, 0.01894051395356655, -0.08255839347839355, 0.005507458467036486, -0.04898740351200104, -0.0004416468436829746, 0.038068655878305435, 0.009127415716648102, 0.02276727557182312, 0.06153888627886772, 0.02459091506898403, 0.035797130316495895, -0.010504519566893578, 0.030529405921697617, -0.05286407470703125, 0.03121495246887207, -0.01151270605623722, 0.007431383244693279, -0.001468596630729735, -0.05685633048415184, -0.025311408564448357, -0.01434242632240057, 0.024633795022964478, -0.044476017355918884, 0.04213912785053253, 0.05948333442211151, -0.051606133580207825, -0.008366424590349197, 0.03199584037065506, -0.028816718608140945, -0.02609565109014511, -0.03139380365610123, -0.06085145100951195, -0.06185339018702507, 0.03084668330848217, -0.13636454939842224, 0.018247567117214203, 0.0052308267913758755, 0.029490577057003975, 0.010776561684906483, -0.012709030881524086, -0.05115979164838791, 0.07449402660131454, 0.12515628337860107, -0.02669130451977253, 0.037529002875089645, -0.07501070201396942, 0.014172835275530815, -0.07115145027637482, -0.017471211031079292, -0.017060494050383568, -0.10230914503335953, -0.002357902005314827, -0.08042968064546585, -0.05218435823917389, 0.025035429745912552, -0.10606057941913605, 0.045244622975587845, -0.08494163304567337, 0.020092012360692024, -0.02958816848695278, 0.006391526665538549, -0.010501358658075333, 0.050185929983854294, 0.0368245393037796, -0.03878267481923103, 0.046405401080846786, 0.06047844514250755, 0.01799307018518448, 0.08710383623838425, -0.01912311278283596, 0.060407478362321854, 0.03491920977830887, -0.05263252556324005, 0.049617353826761246, -0.035500653088092804, 0.03911476582288742, -0.016382992267608643, -0.05372041091322899, 0.1007857471704483, 0.049780335277318954, 0.08992254734039307, -0.06244783103466034, -0.023542897775769234, 0.031610697507858276, 0.007391293067485094, 0.05057934671640396, -0.01727611944079399, -0.03169433772563934, -0.03349553421139717, 0.010524354875087738, -0.05483739450573921, 0.08311116695404053, -0.0038194942753762007, -0.058771003037691116, 0.04246435686945915, -0.03547772020101547, 0.015809187665581703, -0.06383315473794937, 0.03298445791006088, 0.028707189485430717, -0.044667795300483704, 0.015421021729707718, 0.11091339588165283, -0.06985022872686386, -0.05062045156955719, 0.006521546747535467, -0.01481627207249403, 0.042176250368356705, 0.012755867093801498, -0.029382096603512764, 0.01495184376835823, 0.027469724416732788, 0.0016665066359564662, -0.01985124684870243, -0.05396734178066254, 0.044216398149728775, 0.00842011533677578, 0.03345398232340813, -0.05393373593688011, -0.003946524113416672, -0.06482626497745514, 0.026993045583367348, 0.022196076810359955, -0.08318307250738144, 0.005971225909888744, -0.07189382612705231, 0.026657873764634132, -0.009600586257874966, -0.013854057528078556, -0.04645000398159027, -0.10636480152606964, -0.03294467553496361, -0.03627488389611244, 0.05514390021562576, -0.01397404819726944, -0.01655857264995575, -0.007165106479078531, 0.010813205502927303, -0.017286285758018494, -0.0342879593372345, -0.03142758086323738, 0.02915901504456997, -0.024911945685744286, 0.009253987111151218, -0.012278944253921509, 0.014339002780616283, 0.0021474212408065796, -0.03900790214538574, 0.14928647875785828, -0.02880842238664627, -0.0003674596664495766, 0.03168511763215065, 0.02880052663385868, 0.11945190280675888, -0.01251603290438652, 0.051356781274080276, 0.040193334221839905, -0.013279103673994541, 0.023325240239501, -0.06566434353590012, -0.07960451394319534, 0.06246098130941391, 0.028145214542746544, 0.03383547440171242, 0.04045475274324417, -0.008222287520766258, -0.0796126052737236, -0.01968248374760151, 0.034776631742715836, -0.02245529182255268, -0.006558397319167852, 0.039544787257909775, 0.01993677206337452, 0.0010759951546788216, -0.03572355583310127, -0.018989216536283493, -0.06286779791116714, -0.01295390073210001, -0.03953953832387924, -0.05059557035565376, -0.009109296835958958, 0.04558715224266052, 0.03263644501566887, -0.051209915429353714, 0.007068607024848461, -0.057751987129449844, 0.07856778800487518, -0.0421459823846817, 0.017704172059893608, 0.03899584338068962, -0.035519763827323914, -0.02880265936255455, 0.0002888429444283247, 0.043222490698099136, 0.01414129976183176, -0.0006634711753576994, 0.019360849633812904, -0.02961275540292263, 0.07701782137155533, -0.0459752082824707, -0.022777637466788292, 0.07148285210132599, 0.05364258959889412, -0.007641896605491638, 0.06595513969659805, 0.06941583752632141, -0.030373161658644676, -0.04761912301182747, -0.02327706478536129, 0.06072502210736275, 0.07094825804233551, 0.016832591965794563, 0.004840675741434097, -0.021260472014546394, 0.00857383944094181, -0.0019535289611667395, 0.0022566241677850485, 0.013299134559929371, 0.019572563469409943, -0.02226555533707142, 0.06406977027654648, 0.05638030543923378, 0.08236642181873322, -0.026080962270498276, 0.034026965498924255, -0.0007649673498235643, 0.0706295445561409, 0.06938759982585907, 0.07262147963047028, -0.005813919939100742, 0.029519934207201004, -0.03161028400063515, 0.03287934139370918, 0.014669181779026985, -0.04853381589055061, -0.054985128343105316, 0.08931117504835129, -0.01568194478750229, -0.025651467964053154, 0.04741575941443443, 0.10187043994665146, -0.01720796525478363, -0.07494636625051498, -0.08276289701461792, -0.0033305613324046135, 0.028949176892638206, -0.002093214774504304, -0.003433398436754942, 0.02233581617474556, 0.02238508127629757, -0.024784807115793228, 0.04282483458518982, 0.0005164230824448168, -0.05162970721721649, 0.05214470252394676, -0.029969723895192146, -0.0011896388605237007, -0.01312672533094883, -0.016920164227485657, 0.058379385620355606, -0.030195889994502068, 0.054919470101594925, -0.04097921773791313, -0.02574458345770836, -0.0037326952442526817, 0.05423242598772049, -0.010053270496428013, -0.02901798114180565, 0.06102916598320007, 0.0793805792927742, 0.04245814308524132, -0.1143733412027359, -0.025462497025728226, -0.012415066361427307, 0.01573643833398819, -0.07725979387760162, -0.029130125418305397, -0.0041801948100328445, -0.03495839238166809, -0.042973387986421585, 0.010031606070697308, -0.013126655481755733, -0.012887074612081051, 0.02406730316579342, 0.027094393968582153, 0.08359327167272568, -0.04301288351416588, -0.06784988939762115, -0.008786244317889214, -0.00005477645026985556, 0.03098655492067337, -0.03378935903310776, -0.01943536102771759, -0.04561540111899376, 0.07434159517288208, -0.05850944668054581, 0.08282291144132614, -0.022204037755727768, -0.00781730841845274, -0.038177914917469025, -0.013487310148775578, 0.0006057517603039742, 0.003878799732774496, -0.01718400977551937, -0.034463878720998764, -0.03421490639448166, -0.0003254912153352052, 0.05505845695734024, 0.05151316896080971, 0.11730852723121643, -0.04380817338824272, 0.019080525264143944, 0.02030077949166298, -0.0551014244556427, 0.06049063429236412, 0.049678873270750046, 0.02833959460258484, 0.03323992341756821, 0.12659640610218048, 0.05088385194540024, 0.027843547984957695, -0.04117386415600777, 0.02656637877225876, 0.028162194415926933, 0.06785422563552856, -0.021371012553572655, -0.027371270582079887, 0.031392015516757965, 0.03658100590109825, -0.0031650953460484743, -0.022866278886795044, -0.025269679725170135, 0.02223001793026924, 0.040691252797842026, 0.04195861890912056, 0.05231833830475807, 0.0383162796497345, 0.0000056008029787335545, -0.02671530470252037, 0.07760865986347198, -0.019722076132893562, 0.024589888751506805, 0.11261400580406189, -0.0007867341628298163, -0.02158607542514801, -0.044554464519023895, 0.00137995183467865, 0.0009041276061907411, -0.017999842762947083, 0.006026408635079861, -0.023810558021068573, 0.05029338598251343, -0.014810927212238312, -0.01705368421971798, 0.02089701220393181, 0.022206423804163933, 0.00875227339565754, 0.05298515036702156, 0.005217843689024448, 0.04412536695599556, 0.020463231950998306, -0.025442494079470634, -0.05942058563232422, 0.02947545237839222, 0.0008293226710520685, 0.018892791122198105, -0.11897459626197815, -0.05877038836479187, 0.024744130671024323, -0.05520554259419441, 0.07557392865419388, -0.024631859734654427, 0.011987535282969475, 0.008285020478069782, -0.02364294044673443, 0.010255934670567513, 0.07466620206832886, -0.013881778344511986, 0.014052839949727058, -0.06445249170064926, -0.050279680639505386, -0.041236162185668945, -0.04573061317205429, -0.049490317702293396, -0.02144850231707096, -0.009874996729195118, 0.007479229476302862, -0.0013590643648058176, 0.005627123638987541, 0.0035079997032880783, 0.0420663058757782, 0.060961056500673294, 0.06596653163433075, -0.04344679415225983, 0.010643400251865387, -0.03987850993871689, 0.06749190390110016, 0.024114375934004784, 0.00126927241217345, -0.045510433614254, -0.043876875191926956, 0.03275058791041374, -0.01181076280772686, -0.0012592754792422056, -0.012578976340591908, -0.04133390262722969, -0.0038202214054763317, 0.03207903355360031, 0.05835383012890816, 0.10971840471029282, 0.053013164550065994, 0.05405126139521599, 0.06089266389608383, 0.07395632565021515, 0.04887133836746216, 0.017408203333616257, -0.021452365443110466, 0.02524334192276001, 0.045004427433013916, 0.00007081375952111557, 0.05293312296271324, 0.08233331888914108, -0.014584636315703392, -0.04170453920960426, -0.015447383746504784, 0.009356425143778324, 0.015804121270775795, -0.05214923992753029, 0.0041510239243507385, 0.057925768196582794, 0.015207362361252308, 0.02941281534731388, 0.019128603860735893, -0.03464489057660103, 0.04259999468922615, -0.010955393314361572, -0.04369238391518593, 0.019702915102243423, 0.0010568681173026562, -0.012689057737588882, -0.024484597146511078, -0.039312977343797684, 0.02161903865635395, 0.0075851245783269405, -0.05040489882230759, -0.002875647274777293, -0.0047915237955749035, 0.022634468972682953, 0.061845216900110245, -0.048223044723272324, -0.03164980188012123, 0.03182157501578331, -0.03525599464774132, 0.0194306168705225, -0.0031252624467015266, 0.01906396821141243, 0.008098481222987175, -0.020489512011408806, -0.013362186029553413, 0.02818809263408184, 0.00842843484133482, 0.03025886043906212, 0.040007177740335464, -0.001281779259443283, -0.039094630628824234, 0.06176353618502617, 0.01710331067442894, 0.10227542370557785, 0.020636163651943207, -0.0053850747644901276, -0.04434747248888016, -0.024498047307133675, 0.05921834334731102, -0.054759055376052856, -0.016771050170063972 ]
123
123
On empirical meaning of randomness with respect to a real parameter
We study the empirical meaning of randomness with respect to a family of probability distributions $P_\theta$, where $\theta$ is a real parameter, using algorithmic randomness theory. In the case when for a computable probability distribution $P_\theta$ an effectively strongly consistent estimate exists, we show that the Levin's a priory semicomputable semimeasure of the set of all $P_\theta$-random sequences is positive if and only if the parameter $\theta$ is a computable real number. The different methods for generating ``meaningful'' $P_\theta$-random sequences with noncomputable $\theta$ are discussed.
[ -0.10086672008037567, -0.05420957878232002, -0.006130519788712263, -0.09196089953184128, 0.005997326225042343, 0.013903568498790264, 0.05067325755953789, -0.008842165581882, -0.0015047729248180985, 0.016593391075730324, -0.031688325107097626, -0.12241115421056747, -0.023277683183550835, 0.0554632805287838, -0.00889468565583229, 0.0017697998555377126, -0.06625419855117798, 0.07145805656909943, -0.046913109719753265, -0.051779333502054214, -0.02351462095975876, 0.05293717980384827, 0.05402018502354622, 0.006614977959543467, 0.02700832299888134, -0.04332994297146797, 0.03570009022951126, 0.030590908601880074, -0.03461545705795288, -0.019311487674713135, -0.037380751222372055, 0.044949088245630264, -0.00029358011670410633, -0.009290207177400589, 0.03430681303143501, 0.02338014543056488, 0.012855513952672482, 0.01194537989795208, -0.07580126076936722, -0.016861148178577423, -0.007208783645182848, -0.10652317851781845, 0.032079391181468964, -0.011540691368281841, 0.05944981053471565, 0.009097723290324211, 0.06334351003170013, 0.00884455256164074, 0.04512597620487213, -0.009816422127187252, -0.015871785581111908, -0.006330758333206177, 0.021530145779252052, -0.008977735415101051, 0.016590571030974388, -0.009529308415949345, 0.05989651754498482, -0.002265784190967679, -0.0882759690284729, 0.06435704976320267, 0.011233209632337093, 0.052564166486263275, -0.03415670990943909, -0.015863414853811264, 0.03902397304773331, -0.027094310149550438, -0.043840326368808746, -0.0029771560803055763, -0.02949184738099575, -0.08512716740369797, 0.007906443439424038, -0.08621540665626526, 0.02116689644753933, 0.03998585045337677, -0.027282776311039925, -0.024764418601989746, -0.05120772123336792, 0.029637081548571587, -0.006235498934984207, 0.0557534396648407, -0.01873258873820305, 0.04355565458536148, -0.013874506577849388, -0.0063354382291436195, -0.0741875022649765, -0.045301564037799835, -0.013819975778460503, 0.028309287503361702, 0.029207495972514153, -0.04989723861217499, -0.05955149233341217, -0.03292771056294441, -0.08811025321483612, 0.04035656899213791, -0.03814489021897316, 0.041443273425102234, 0.05232148617506027, -0.05585324019193649, 0.020047876983880997, 0.06398065388202667, 0.04089021682739258, -0.025875737890601158, 0.08998382091522217, 0.027040988206863403, 0.009165499359369278, 0.04001873731613159, 0.04869202524423599, -0.03347384184598923, -0.019108764827251434, -0.0077823190949857235, -0.00147875992115587, -0.044500332325696945, 0.012450196780264378, -0.013791336677968502, -0.07112438976764679, 0.08761703968048096, 0.043402958661317825, 0.05876247212290764, -0.013459923677146435, 0.016014229506254196, 0.06171116232872009, 0.026967504993081093, -0.04426173120737076, 0.03008515015244484, 0.030316602438688278, -0.05198008567094803, -0.01919986680150032, -0.04474935308098793, 0.09457419812679291, -0.03484653681516647, -0.010409167967736721, -0.029860131442546844, -0.015762900933623314, -0.03926539421081543, -0.005101929884403944, 0.02057654783129692, -0.02542680688202381, -0.007447775918990374, -0.005861994810402393, 0.0444018691778183, -0.03767184913158417, -0.07969541847705841, -0.03785254806280136, -0.00690000643953681, 0.0939594954252243, 0.04718602076172829, -0.07537457346916199, 0.0049533536657691, 0.00018915014516096562, 0.03287004306912422, -0.07515086233615875, -0.06369530409574509, -0.059111882001161575, 0.010424262844026089, 0.06459333002567291, -0.08430198580026627, -0.019052866846323013, 0.03692442551255226, -0.08107155561447144, 0.0891222357749939, -0.06511469930410385, -0.02823595143854618, -0.008565248921513557, 0.08322795480489731, -0.037350837141275406, 0.0431506372988224, -0.026631509885191917, -0.007263255305588245, 0.0024839749094098806, -0.006997732911258936, 0.001214205869473517, 0.052002064883708954, -0.034387536346912384, -0.022805795073509216, -0.014054929837584496, -0.034123495221138, 0.0029640868306159973, 0.005266915541142225, 0.00874475110322237, -0.021565714851021767, -0.04454580694437027, -0.04445191100239754, -0.034456804394721985, 0.03754183650016785, -0.05890776589512825, 0.08569476753473282, 0.0012842529686167836, 0.0029125686269253492, 0.02632848173379898, -0.01753345876932144, 0.020602518692612648, -0.029657632112503052, -0.05711419880390167, -0.04536843299865723, -0.05557732656598091, 0.020347505807876587, -0.05332730710506439, -0.05157111585140228, 0.021944329142570496, 0.07023546099662781, 0.004776296205818653, 0.027152303606271744, -0.0945553332567215, -0.023451611399650574, 0.021195020526647568, -0.0017521134577691555, -0.05392942205071449, -0.014310968108475208, 0.01167234219610691, -0.020563578233122826, 0.0107685886323452, 0.028446149080991745, -0.016555078327655792, -0.0564090721309185, 0.019704310223460197, -0.0845770463347435, 0.0038332962431013584, 0.0072599537670612335, 0.002684610430151224, 0.03444785997271538, -0.03587861359119415, -0.005920181982219219, 0.005424943752586842, 0.08884795010089874, -0.03499886393547058, -0.031776584684848785, 0.11859006434679031, 0.019625993445515633, -0.04058406874537468, 0.04402751103043556, -0.05673002079129219, -0.015529570169746876, -0.018399450927972794, -0.044141680002212524, -0.020765071734786034, 0.026097210124135017, 0.01773872599005699, -0.0108683742582798, 0.02098277024924755, 0.05195177346467972, 0.0015380459371954203, 0.0277852900326252, 0.01905411295592785, -0.006013177335262299, -0.04905620962381363, -0.05787288025021553, 0.07443565875291824, 0.04830266535282135, -0.043533939868211746, 0.0893731415271759, 0.009471816942095757, -0.015051133930683136, 0.04681147262454033, -0.03084065206348896, 0.04329118877649307, 0.01937461458146572, -0.05276482552289963, -0.007517590187489986, 0.0168183371424675, -0.0036386584397405386, -0.07352857291698456, 0.07311376184225082, 0.02641509659588337, 0.028740400448441505, 0.007316157687455416, 0.045539796352386475, 0.0019296109676361084, 0.03816920146346092, -0.0013900075573474169, 0.006927605718374252, 0.06407950818538666, -0.03402804583311081, -0.11355550587177277, 0.09052743017673492, -0.0464651957154274, -0.037066761404275894, 0.05549141764640808, 0.03157539665699005, -0.04708682745695114, -0.051042590290308, -0.06109220162034035, 0.008239181712269783, -0.03470334783196449, 0.004628152120858431, -0.013675518333911896, 0.03483714535832405, 0.0005825021071359515, -0.025635361671447754, -0.03758189454674721, 0.011658193543553352, 0.026222551241517067, 0.031214166432619095, -0.04679447039961815, -0.09118375927209854, 0.03473006933927536, 0.025002576410770416, 0.008798087947070599, -0.04924139752984047, 0.07304712384939194, -0.002004869282245636, -0.06455440819263458, 0.023749377578496933, 0.12783190608024597, 0.06824707984924316, 0.005897236987948418, 0.013104943558573723, 0.05036814510822296, 0.04843882843852043, -0.06923681497573853, 0.002278812462463975, 0.021319303661584854, -0.0015148314414545894, 0.01691250316798687, -0.00873411726206541, 0.002416766481474042, -0.013795179314911366, -0.01905755326151848, -0.04767768457531929, 0.009207597933709621, -0.0052657220512628555, 0.018837222829461098, 0.005299231503158808, 0.01260991208255291, -0.03484869375824928, -0.0902523398399353, -0.05729616433382034, 0.08636507391929626, -0.03719209507107735, -0.10463729500770569, 0.006880980916321278, 0.058390770107507706, 0.07384546846151352, 0.02880462445318699, 0.07707369327545166, 0.01953306421637535, 0.04563156142830849, -0.05008379742503166, -0.03930634260177612, 0.030018597841262817, 0.01686033047735691, -0.02466242015361786, -0.02951056696474552, -0.003204998793080449, -0.015263139270246029, 0.016910197213292122, 0.051707714796066284, 0.13356275856494904, 0.001640805508941412, 0.004731315653771162, 0.011468075215816498, -0.06704011559486389, 0.07068946212530136, 0.04207759350538254, 0.04444460943341255, 0.0004275020328350365, 0.09045378118753433, 0.020796559751033783, 0.029609551653265953, 0.03497050702571869, -0.012879678048193455, 0.04867037013173103, -0.019403673708438873, 0.015445665456354618, 0.04247964918613434, 0.034418340772390366, 0.009042222052812576, -0.005659001879394054, -0.0771455466747284, -0.03528964892029762, 0.027045298367738724, 0.04502156004309654, -0.057974446564912796, 0.050406575202941895, 0.08117738366127014, 0.034846190363168716, -0.011604552157223225, 0.08717808872461319, -0.07387144863605499, 0.02359241247177124, 0.04932943731546402, -0.019686434417963028, 0.016294773668050766, 0.04905477911233902, 0.00958691630512476, -0.00711732916533947, -0.05207664147019386, 0.014513582922518253, 0.0002781790972221643, 0.04933451861143112, -0.016658546403050423, 0.029996821656823158, -0.01258532702922821, -0.007650049403309822, 0.04428626596927643, 0.04072946682572365, -0.0017131816130131483, -0.0010954812169075012, -0.047405462712049484, 0.04697031527757645, -0.08804265409708023, 0.004638021346181631, -0.07108977437019348, 0.004490809515118599, 0.01153550948947668, -0.04357341304421425, -0.017209868878126144, -0.07568519562482834, 0.07039647549390793, -0.03605996072292328, 0.08812490850687027, 0.002815911779180169, -0.020936477929353714, -0.06224486604332924, -0.02500825747847557, -0.014622583985328674, 0.057880744338035583, 0.025535183027386665, -0.0016359435394406319, -0.04094761610031128, -0.026764817535877228, 0.011527922004461288, 0.05044608563184738, -0.005536302924156189, -0.09466835856437683, 0.003564662765711546, -0.033690180629491806, -0.0334600992500782, -0.025441480800509453, 0.01462587434798479, -0.05881131440401077, 0.018343815580010414, 0.003553115762770176, -0.015295629389584064, -0.04469054192304611, 0.046688612550497055, -0.08832857757806778, -0.019156642258167267, -0.0025295810773968697, -0.00459173833951354, 0.020940175279974937, -0.02473428100347519, 0.02164878323674202, -0.043019648641347885, 0.032767780125141144, -0.002712115179747343, -0.015117455273866653, 0.08023279905319214, -0.04237068071961403, 0.06443856656551361, 0.02868126891553402, 0.0901150107383728, -0.007013221271336079, 0.047734227031469345, -0.03521515801548958, 0.028410252183675766, 0.0843624472618103, -0.028581731021404266, 0.014952206052839756, 0.010633916594088078, -0.005324705969542265, -0.04968433082103729, -0.021172691136598587, -0.036926571279764175, -0.013275038450956345, -0.046589773148298264, -0.014196144416928291, 0.031794432550668716, 0.010252115316689014, 0.030558010563254356, -0.014455997385084629, 0.01081238966435194, -0.02679620310664177, -0.007911757566034794, 0.04625825956463814, -0.014591083861887455, 0.011124368757009506, -0.006296454928815365, 0.06106993556022644, 0.04735283926129341, -0.008919053710997105, -0.020540621131658554, 0.04528924822807312, -0.11456193029880524, 0.06472259759902954, 0.07397433370351791, 0.12045326828956604, -0.04971868172287941, -0.02435719408094883, 0.027052197605371475, -0.00620040949434042, 0.11915533244609833, -0.01064126007258892, -0.0037267047446221113, 0.033608634024858475, -0.019524117931723595, 0.04078080877661705, -0.040873028337955475, 0.008199667558073997, 0.0009468625066801906, 0.028369994834065437, 0.017920004203915596, 0.0198673065751791, 0.06135629490017891, 0.002375774784013629, -0.010087070986628532, -0.007255452685058117, 0.01315260212868452, -0.04543456807732582, -0.04050777107477188, 0.040163472294807434, -0.040794145315885544, -0.04122369736433029 ]
124
124
Sparse Online Learning via Truncated Gradient
We propose a general method called truncated gradient to induce sparsity in the weights of online learning algorithms with convex loss functions. This method has several essential properties: The degree of sparsity is continuous -- a parameter controls the rate of sparsification from no sparsification to total sparsification. The approach is theoretically motivated, and an instance of it can be regarded as an online counterpart of the popular $L_1$-regularization method in the batch setting. We prove that small rates of sparsification result in only small additional regret with respect to typical online learning guarantees. The approach works well empirically. We apply the approach to several datasets and find that for datasets with large numbers of features, substantial sparsity is discoverable.
[ 0.01752752996981144, -0.0605628676712513, 0.06792991608381271, -0.019325265660881996, 0.02393404394388199, -0.037193138152360916, 0.006163075100630522, 0.01369605865329504, -0.04513747617602348, 0.050164252519607544, -0.004697601310908794, -0.01751912757754326, 0.0152510404586792, 0.06161745637655258, -0.007869715802371502, -0.012141549028456211, -0.022948410362005234, -0.007181110326200724, 0.05558789148926735, -0.07211393862962723, 0.022634277120232582, -0.016615698114037514, 0.04939819499850273, -0.06224691495299339, 0.05395664647221565, 0.05952010676264763, -0.026227712631225586, 0.029724478721618652, 0.09037676453590393, 0.02608116902410984, -0.07915417104959488, -0.007488012779504061, 0.04151184484362602, 0.048327427357435226, -0.008052055723965168, -0.043579939752817154, 0.018998466432094574, 0.0488118939101696, -0.0290230643004179, -0.005830614827573299, 0.03521961718797684, 0.01942811720073223, 0.017626993358135223, -0.016959181055426598, 0.029063455760478973, -0.023381320759654045, 0.041085246950387955, -0.04167613759636879, -0.03927522897720337, 0.01014348678290844, -0.06656979024410248, 0.009011887945234776, -0.04606764763593674, -0.06740625202655792, 0.024291502311825752, 0.03584408387541771, -0.011056151241064072, -0.01550185028463602, -0.03384112939238548, -0.04583888128399849, -0.005872166249901056, 0.04499691724777222, 0.0035525972489267588, 0.047597091645002365, -0.013508789241313934, 0.036507539451122284, -0.08890142291784286, -0.02611391991376877, -0.027480192482471466, 0.003995244391262531, -0.04452327638864517, -0.09122377634048462, 0.052288711071014404, 0.10280635952949524, 0.013561866246163845, 0.021387478336691856, -0.0013323473976925015, -0.01911480352282524, 0.007005893625319004, 0.031324345618486404, -0.05227678269147873, 0.09168537706136703, 0.005759924650192261, 0.047062020748853683, 0.00940952729433775, -0.05210942402482033, 0.01720132678747177, -0.0741642415523529, 0.044206876307725906, -0.026024457067251205, -0.05574919655919075, 0.021874716505408287, -0.07415669411420822, 0.00824323482811451, 0.02491830475628376, 0.0259043388068676, -0.08227016776800156, -0.0389341339468956, -0.03990362584590912, 0.01177135482430458, 0.0026534926146268845, 0.005420364905148745, 0.05857773870229721, 0.02864375337958336, 0.008920114487409592, 0.056149471551179886, -0.049381159245967865, 0.05560406297445297, 0.025336597114801407, 0.008799160830676556, -0.0007272504735738039, 0.013737864792346954, 0.02831941656768322, -0.002213397528976202, -0.012090682983398438, 0.06078341230750084, -0.01700695790350437, 0.10252558439970016, 0.02706058882176876, 0.0060454681515693665, 0.051468025892972946, 0.06107103452086449, -0.04904532432556152, -0.040351517498493195, 0.02721587009727955, -0.0790746882557869, 0.01217969972640276, -0.0372990183532238, 0.11189939081668854, 0.0073906355537474155, -0.009440837427973747, 0.03424464166164398, -0.008350095711648464, -0.0494726188480854, -0.05303733050823212, 0.0012006500037387013, 0.009886839427053928, 0.009673585183918476, 0.017278706654906273, -0.0013650243636220694, 0.020854374393820763, -0.02383337914943695, -0.06875086575746536, -0.017449913546442986, 0.029538709670305252, 0.029698994010686874, 0.04387780651450157, 0.03789813071489334, -0.02544153295457363, -0.014261060394346714, 0.006277240347117186, -0.004704403690993786, 0.014008261263370514, 0.058088481426239014, 0.05270371586084366, -0.07069667428731918, -0.01748613454401493, -0.03421127423644066, 0.031437408179044724, 0.02756192348897457, 0.02397018112242222, -0.011413219384849072, 0.05864235758781433, -0.020121920853853226, -0.01333559863269329, -0.07101276516914368, 0.0345388799905777, -0.045141711831092834, -0.049218274652957916, -0.07319869101047516, -0.0178056750446558, -0.049170296639204025, 0.040850624442100525, -0.013597019016742706, 0.0027351132594048977, 0.08750862628221512, 0.02229168824851513, 0.022812290117144585, 0.018059387803077698, -0.060831375420093536, 0.05473048985004425, 0.04419347643852234, 0.009775775484740734, 0.02402695268392563, 0.04697634279727936, 0.02533739060163498, 0.018780823796987534, 0.05900033563375473, 0.04102740436792374, 0.023834021762013435, 0.06179782375693321, -0.037994202226400375, 0.01716734655201435, 0.017820928245782852, -0.07220036536455154, 0.0827661007642746, -0.0532536581158638, -0.058516208082437515, 0.026637353003025055, 0.06404456496238708, 0.04597773775458336, -0.02541031502187252, -0.035066183656454086, -0.025062162429094315, -0.10502633452415466, 0.05030503496527672, 0.007405319716781378, -0.008787852711975574, -0.026085911318659782, 0.08642797917127609, 0.016673678532242775, 0.0024749254807829857, -0.016634317114949226, -0.07028058171272278, -0.04104812070727348, 0.05486997961997986, 0.01994752138853073, -0.02511410042643547, 0.11071574687957764, 0.04302698373794556, 0.015979835763573647, 0.03561389446258545, -0.030513349920511246, 0.019721055403351784, -0.012373761273920536, 0.06543993949890137, 0.0327799990773201, -0.010672283358871937, -0.0820825845003128, 0.08448415994644165, -0.017398836091160774, 0.028633270412683487, -0.039912402629852295, -0.014882025308907032, -0.0419670045375824, 0.0034181433729827404, -0.07735438644886017, -0.04823477938771248, 0.0002297114406246692, -0.03335505351424217, -0.011497022584080696, 0.033946745097637177, 0.024755125865340233, -0.01763230562210083, 0.03836487978696823, 0.01540086604654789, 0.06462476402521133, 0.025934191420674324, 0.022739116102457047, -0.08131124079227448, 0.007007904350757599, 0.0770585685968399, -0.050611142069101334, -0.0579923577606678, -0.023452766239643097, 0.027307437732815742, -0.0269547700881958, 0.02646843157708645, 0.017582109197974205, 0.037556182593107224, 0.01776157319545746, 0.04872148111462593, -0.07511439919471741, -0.013736325316131115, 0.04556313157081604, 0.007497721817344427, -0.020664509385824203, -0.00004384144995128736, -0.03574031591415405, 0.07488857209682465, 0.06897014379501343, -0.04371941089630127, 0.026348164305090904, 0.08159191161394119, -0.026104850694537163, 0.058939091861248016, 0.07390233874320984, 0.02843816764652729, 0.07369400560855865, -0.016135770827531815, -0.10356876999139786, 0.011766116134822369, 0.07962381839752197, -0.02266322448849678, -0.0030162562616169453, 0.009884832426905632, 0.02994590625166893, -0.03850056231021881, 0.03376786783337593, -0.00022979833011049777, -0.05267919972538948, -0.019259678199887276, -0.0016313934465870261, 0.05400697886943817, 0.047217585146427155, 0.026953207328915596, 0.09005671739578247, -0.032763414084911346, -0.06580572575330734, -0.012918195687234402, 0.022350408136844635, -0.08207596093416214, -0.03809040039777756, 0.0007966743432916701, -0.008764305151998997, 0.053838592022657394, 0.041311606764793396, 0.09033473581075668, -0.11350362747907639, 0.008489799685776234, 0.07697704434394836, -0.03552408888936043, -0.04509774595499039, -0.0912371352314949, 0.022146932780742645, 0.009634878486394882, 0.010903090238571167, 0.02310176193714142, -0.037617649883031845, -0.021579526364803314, 0.02097569964826107, 0.046070635318756104, 0.02517998404800892, -0.056897226721048355, -0.11297047138214111, -0.06578259915113449, -0.054366398602724075, 0.058790937066078186, -0.03152947500348091, -0.038058098405599594, -0.10823486000299454, -0.035325609147548676, -0.09199177473783493, 0.04182618483901024, 0.04050673171877861, -0.04972779378294945, -0.05697588622570038, -0.07433513551950455, -0.03456580266356468, -0.01071973703801632, 0.012674001976847649, -0.013973431661725044, -0.03569496050477028, -0.024855811148881912, 0.028499599546194077, 0.01567634753882885, -0.015672722831368446, -0.014601641334593296, -0.11720483005046844, 0.10788644105195999, -0.07109384983778, 0.03569317236542702, -0.03952118754386902, -0.01979784108698368, -0.00573791703209281, 0.01881861872971058, 0.03870048373937607, -0.006252433639019728, -0.0613853745162487, 0.023770952597260475, -0.02639918029308319, 0.03469017148017883, -0.051797062158584595, -0.026731496676802635, 0.01903347298502922, 0.09939467906951904, 0.022251378744840622, 0.014547590166330338, -0.08307969570159912, 0.05409324914216995, 0.05579700693488121, 0.03711234778165817, -0.013117139227688313, 0.008259458467364311, 0.050269510596990585, -0.05956990271806717, 0.016259504482150078, -0.023128263652324677, -0.02656235732138157, 0.017889458686113358, -0.021795455366373062, -0.01752636395394802, 0.0033963096793740988, -0.022263549268245697, -0.014187612570822239, -0.046279437839984894, -0.04641395062208176, -0.05963713303208351, 0.04281345754861832, 0.0033905627205967903, -0.01972842961549759, -0.07212008535861969, -0.026001259684562683, -0.038575466722249985, 0.00797340925782919, 0.03530500456690788, -0.002301167231053114, 0.004047383554279804, -0.004529472440481186, 0.05430922284722328, -0.0415710024535656, 0.09588775783777237, -0.015303694643080235, 0.0027720965445041656, -0.09625308215618134, 0.04726751148700714, 0.058621007949113846, 0.033316854387521744, 0.006898399908095598, -0.0031424961052834988, 0.048639681190252304, 0.02397332899272442, 0.003598908893764019, 0.06668633967638016, 0.0408814400434494, 0.020553484559059143, 0.019647866487503052, 0.0011558154365047812, -0.012159671634435654, -0.05666062980890274, 0.035585418343544006, -0.003982682712376118, 0.00793912261724472, 0.022197701036930084, -0.002940588863566518, -0.002412700792774558, 0.03849601745605469, 0.14205874502658844, -0.04481001943349838, 0.032302066683769226, -0.0771462544798851, -0.04691638424992561, -0.05107218399643898, -0.02628890797495842, 0.010690312832593918, 0.03261419013142586, -0.007216672413051128, -0.036331452429294586, -0.03237172216176987, -0.021416274830698967, -0.01083468459546566, 0.004922326188534498, 0.0195014588534832, 0.03274604678153992, 0.0024955119006335735, 0.07296339422464371, 0.038141217082738876, -0.04960741847753525, 0.10927816480398178, 0.023633122444152832, 0.00906633585691452, 0.021446164697408676, 0.016784735023975372, -0.032579731196165085, -0.09016234427690506, -0.03302224352955818, 0.039464108645915985, 0.00841244775801897, 0.09574086219072342, -0.06662381440401077, -0.05768098682165146, -0.007682233117520809, 0.0676671639084816, -0.01562727615237236, -0.06943120062351227, 0.001928266603499651, -0.0250235628336668, 0.006840209476649761, -0.016897913068532944, 0.03177114948630333, -0.01850184239447117, 0.024691453203558922, -0.025011098012328148, -0.0670081228017807, 0.05968726426362991, 0.014288408681750298, 0.015602566301822662, -0.03803787752985954, -0.0274527408182621, 0.006194925867021084, 0.0012317219516262412, 0.0005511833587661386, 0.005943123251199722, 0.0725361704826355, 0.020241791382431984, -0.006175959017127752, -0.04145625978708267, 0.07061295956373215, 0.0034777054097503424, 0.05004127696156502, 0.06886225193738937, -0.006634986028075218, 0.03321045637130737, 0.0009151468402706087, 0.035951726138591766, -0.0032154202926903963, 0.06982199102640152, -0.02120538428425789, 0.022333718836307526, 0.035979095846414566, 0.03265746310353279, -0.01061002817004919, 0.03849167376756668, 0.004615467041730881, 0.03808945417404175, 0.05036519840359688, 0.027430696412920952, -0.017586776986718178, -0.015323343686759472, 0.017582356929779053, -0.03477217257022858, 0.032486602663993835 ]
125
125
Graph Kernels
We present a unified framework to study graph kernels, special cases of which include the random walk graph kernel \citep{GaeFlaWro03,BorOngSchVisetal05}, marginalized graph kernel \citep{KasTsuIno03,KasTsuIno04,MahUedAkuPeretal04}, and geometric kernel on graphs \citep{Gaertner02}. Through extensions of linear algebra to Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHS) and reduction to a Sylvester equation, we construct an algorithm that improves the time complexity of kernel computation from $O(n^6)$ to $O(n^3)$. When the graphs are sparse, conjugate gradient solvers or fixed-point iterations bring our algorithm into the sub-cubic domain. Experiments on graphs from bioinformatics and other application domains show that it is often more than a thousand times faster than previous approaches. We then explore connections between diffusion kernels \citep{KonLaf02}, regularization on graphs \citep{SmoKon03}, and graph kernels, and use these connections to propose new graph kernels. Finally, we show that rational kernels \citep{CorHafMoh02,CorHafMoh03,CorHafMoh04} when specialized to graphs reduce to the random walk graph kernel.
[ -0.005781250074505806, -0.10611788928508759, 0.040739983320236206, -0.051071152091026306, -0.01809852384030819, -0.027576718479394913, 0.06161327660083771, -0.026906516402959824, -0.0736263319849968, 0.018099265173077583, 0.031134018674492836, -0.07359867542982101, -0.04319239407777786, 0.07189244776964188, -0.0004396037256810814, 0.046652086079120636, 0.028328482061624527, 0.013697504065930843, 0.02128816768527031, -0.007912185043096542, 0.032584335654973984, 0.02760683186352253, 0.027878087013959885, -0.06854070723056793, 0.006932028569281101, 0.028787706047296524, 0.04499106854200363, 0.03296360373497009, 0.03252366930246353, 0.039064910262823105, -0.05020544305443764, 0.0492534264922142, -0.009958586655557156, -0.024405023083090782, -0.05508575960993767, 0.017560424283146858, 0.05961677432060242, 0.047111496329307556, -0.05071210488677025, 0.0013791407691314816, 0.11159629374742508, -0.06784966588020325, -0.01598062738776207, 0.0015342122642323375, -0.002168971346691251, 0.04377605766057968, -0.008036809973418713, 0.05414656549692154, -0.014647604897618294, 0.10751833766698837, -0.07403455674648285, 0.02369464375078678, -0.03354732692241669, -0.05137856304645538, -0.031221013516187668, 0.014117096550762653, -0.06258608400821686, -0.014962092973291874, 0.03579307347536087, 0.022577419877052307, 0.025033142417669296, 0.06740159541368484, -0.03851497545838356, -0.03273699805140495, 0.022986309602856636, 0.02294243685901165, 0.07963059842586517, 0.009159338660538197, -0.039503224194049835, -0.010518650524318218, 0.06048491224646568, -0.017000770196318626, 0.06338967382907867, 0.1089635118842125, 0.015133453533053398, 0.026152560487389565, -0.05548524484038353, -0.01242358423769474, 0.05476083606481552, 0.12009759992361069, -0.04968004673719406, 0.06239878386259079, -0.012347148731350899, 0.019148975610733032, -0.03484348952770233, 0.0904318243265152, 0.034368596971035004, -0.03034927323460579, -0.01980108581483364, -0.02799062244594097, -0.09026801586151123, 0.016263829544186592, -0.047863081097602844, 0.053346626460552216, -0.0685163140296936, 0.041680291295051575, -0.060396838933229446, -0.054883990436792374, 0.03570082038640976, 0.0210555512458086, -0.02024265192449093, -0.05490577965974808, -0.007907794788479805, 0.046155527234077454, -0.03211168944835663, 0.04261699691414833, -0.04912330582737923, -0.007500740699470043, 0.03096827119588852, -0.05189170315861702, 0.018535636365413666, -0.006558427587151527, -0.04955946281552315, 0.022803977131843567, -0.0584980845451355, -0.0014623318566009402, -0.00243097310885787, 0.06514038145542145, 0.0032017193734645844, -0.0017375476891174912, -0.0028695142827928066, -0.06509347259998322, -0.05166202038526535, -0.04867696389555931, 0.0358356237411499, -0.0933578610420227, -0.03481914475560188, -0.032609183341264725, 0.03311539813876152, 0.022149108350276947, -0.030365336686372757, 0.01181323267519474, -0.023467356339097023, -0.03394085913896561, -0.10167863965034485, 0.012193954549729824, 0.0490989089012146, -0.04713480919599533, -0.04010464996099472, 0.05022180825471878, 0.011912718415260315, 0.0018999922322109342, -0.004191672429442406, -0.00011662414908641949, 0.006610379088670015, 0.027005378156900406, -0.033267341554164886, -0.03547751531004906, 0.06869418919086456, -0.07968746870756149, 0.04403785988688469, -0.00932384841144085, -0.0236106775701046, 0.017517155036330223, 0.0068644131533801556, -0.04928060248494148, -0.08888393640518188, 0.049211736768484116, -0.01695888675749302, 0.07066123187541962, 0.03439526632428169, -0.026470797136425972, 0.002166720572859049, -0.0064818356186151505, 0.060596730560064316, 0.01385931670665741, -0.051694903522729874, -0.053322773426771164, -0.014176413416862488, 0.05109426751732826, -0.011417488567531109, 0.008157842792570591, -0.003805550280958414, 0.050722572952508926, 0.03869089111685753, 0.027123048901557922, 0.07684765011072159, 0.049006301909685135, -0.010219142772257328, -0.12375088781118393, 0.05006232485175133, -0.016377342864871025, -0.019961055368185043, 0.013981522060930729, 0.00023822917137295008, 0.07234501093626022, -0.03932691738009453, -0.04578790441155434, 0.01985403150320053, 0.03498995304107666, 0.02137899585068226, -0.014586422592401505, 0.08177345246076584, -0.02891564555466175, -0.06900838762521744, 0.038937222212553024, -0.051894739270210266, 0.005330422893166542, 0.041677989065647125, 0.07681877911090851, 0.07078896462917328, 0.02448761649429798, -0.06560567766427994, -0.1267726570367813, -0.03646298870444298, 0.03282288834452629, 0.009608590044081211, -0.016109531745314598, -0.08729463815689087, 0.0133254025131464, -0.011720893904566765, 0.027471574023365974, -0.02565091662108898, -0.049640800803899765, -0.06723078340291977, -0.09165211021900177, 0.022034745663404465, -0.04788079485297203, 0.05459937825798988, 0.053105056285858154, -0.01789802499115467, 0.042716700583696365, -0.0033447747118771076, 0.04291825741529465, -0.06820886582136154, -0.005298781208693981, 0.002551301848143339, -0.02440868504345417, -0.005021565593779087, 0.0011118147522211075, -0.020678065717220306, -0.05532585829496384, -0.007811931427568197, 0.007961145602166653, 0.05157044529914856, 0.09713930636644363, -0.03002551943063736, -0.034200605005025864, -0.022152230143547058, -0.0034690662287175655, -0.011887549422681332, 0.028233107179403305, 0.006415101233869791, -0.07039721310138702, -0.027808085083961487, 0.026975303888320923, -0.06886396557092667, 0.08164693415164948, -0.008313082158565521, 0.0030157179571688175, -0.04439904913306236, 0.002508046803995967, -0.07008606940507889, -0.02331703156232834, 0.06529519706964493, 0.010431556031107903, -0.051212698221206665, 0.03621809557080269, 0.06252075731754303, 0.10332964360713959, 0.06308940798044205, -0.00739610381424427, -0.04558731988072395, -0.04039181023836136, 0.0775487944483757, 0.012089929543435574, -0.024272950366139412, 0.023851927369832993, -0.007532635238021612, 0.05174547806382179, 0.03538459166884422, -0.11577417701482773, -0.12155648320913315, 0.09379242360591888, -0.010813687928020954, 0.026296671479940414, 0.04350415617227554, 0.019405120983719826, -0.012582840397953987, 0.011554266326129436, 0.0019373254617676139, -0.030434103682637215, -0.04372372850775719, -0.07565515488386154, -0.08438608050346375, 0.048586755990982056, -0.06906776875257492, -0.015210600569844246, 0.029276655986905098, 0.034871768206357956, -0.02484893426299095, 0.05582152307033539, -0.047808222472667694, -0.04206730052828789, 0.03145739808678627, -0.06947179138660431, 0.04577755182981491, -0.05618388205766678, 0.03716941550374031, 0.047853365540504456, 0.022374756634235382, 0.0006108878878876567, -0.03397749736905098, 0.012051311321556568, 0.01934070698916912, -0.016553357243537903, 0.032710831612348557, 0.004825415089726448, -0.04118361696600914, 0.015783274546265602, 0.023037172853946686, -0.021983223035931587, -0.030833661556243896, -0.011712645180523396, -0.009169205091893673, -0.017659002915024757, 0.00043855851981788874, 0.009604811668395996, -0.0499170757830143, 0.039319440722465515, 0.014755558222532272, 0.015770314261317253, 0.028942618519067764, -0.0852385088801384, -0.013649193570017815, -0.013292450457811356, 0.013076035305857658, 0.0701184943318367, -0.07786846160888672, -0.041624706238508224, -0.023376645520329475, 0.008624453097581863, 0.009462269023060799, 0.07187667489051819, 0.05046059191226959, -0.03380034863948822, -0.04495719075202942, -0.0004709089989773929, -0.010467533022165298, -0.020445700734853745, 0.006949525326490402, -0.03187980502843857, 0.0070765516720712185, -0.05719800665974617, 0.11430186778306961, 0.08961012214422226, 0.042046550661325455, -0.037803299725055695, -0.04334079846739769, 0.0340612418949604, -0.034041181206703186, -0.027344053611159325, 0.007127598859369755, 0.012020944617688656, -0.03278423473238945, 0.05089469626545906, 0.048487287014722824, -0.01286965049803257, -0.008488529361784458, 0.03196818009018898, -0.015246928669512272, 0.008866069838404655, -0.01510535180568695, 0.06100599467754364, -0.010975333862006664, 0.0063299695029854774, -0.02013511024415493, 0.014996584504842758, 0.022941702976822853, 0.05352354794740677, 0.023817915469408035, 0.01891188696026802, 0.07356857508420944, 0.01733686588704586, -0.042271971702575684, -0.05378951504826546, 0.013377035968005657, -0.005041337572038174, -0.00944883469492197, 0.05535551533102989, -0.048511065542697906, 0.07460886240005493, -0.04684794694185257, 0.09070511162281036, -0.006158099044114351, -0.005397481378167868, 0.0017084379214793444, 0.03951910138130188, 0.03398779779672623, -0.004383143037557602, 0.01700693368911743, 0.01763107255101204, 0.02934471145272255, 0.03564845770597458, 0.038048144429922104, 0.011896586045622826, -0.0197851974517107, -0.00017048820154741406, 0.012099972926080227, -0.007539394311606884, -0.03830599784851074, -0.0855412408709526, -0.006453338079154491, -0.022218940779566765, -0.07066618651151657, -0.02522221766412258, -0.007185052614659071, -0.024056177586317062, 0.021249350160360336, 0.05657444894313812, -0.014841598458588123, 0.0002491146151442081, -0.07805923372507095, -0.04873744398355484, -0.011546616442501545, 0.01100675854831934, -0.047429442405700684, 0.042506586760282516, -0.025670859962701797, -0.06508233398199081, -0.024227017536759377, 0.006418523378670216, 0.06132196635007858, 0.04390856623649597, -0.07034379988908768, -0.0017372966976836324, 0.050102587789297104, 0.0990949347615242, 0.10511113703250885, -0.01495418418198824, -0.025655517354607582, -0.041544992476701736, -0.06712725758552551, 0.03828693553805351, 0.0877106711268425, -0.04008551314473152, 0.024072814732789993, 0.037111084908246994, 0.028925638645887375, -0.021758396178483963, 0.026485417038202286, -0.008441226556897163, -0.03986167162656784, -0.0011604526080191135, 0.054353341460227966, 0.0365908220410347, 0.006862975656986237, -0.025047624483704567, 0.05160587280988693, 0.03782467171549797, 0.011817960068583488, 0.031580206006765366, -0.012491815723478794, 0.017582248896360397, -0.03434549272060394, -0.05883285775780678, 0.053393516689538956, -0.024006985127925873, -0.019408436492085457, -0.012553399428725243, -0.02696976438164711, 0.013341762125492096, -0.06944964081048965, 0.0004196446679998189, -0.031477414071559906, -0.007513119373470545, -0.01186863798648119, 0.0442052036523819, 0.08757354319095612, 0.005242175422608852, -0.025692539289593697, 0.08831267058849335, 0.033556658774614334, -0.10463261604309082, 0.034300897270441055, -0.0019335434772074223, 0.0613349974155426, -0.08565714210271835, 0.006423416547477245, -0.01644863188266754, 0.0007558276411145926, 0.07640393078327179, -0.005782240070402622, -0.043617039918899536, -0.027883313596248627, 0.027972662821412086, 0.028375323861837387, 0.024902457371354103, 0.024087410420179367, -0.020725224167108536, 0.031238390132784843, 0.006763139273971319, -0.04699208214879036, 0.01938818022608757, -0.016747528687119484, 0.018622271716594696, -0.030069371685385704, 0.006836064159870148, -0.019121576100587845, 0.01272774487733841, 0.04101558402180672, -0.0032977801747620106, -0.0038197096437215805, 0.03973260894417763, 0.07395204901695251, 0.03615391626954079, 0.030272064730525017, -0.013541998341679573, -0.02739112637937069, 0.05172162875533104, 0.011145669035613537, -0.03565148636698723 ]
126
126
Catching Up Faster by Switching Sooner: A Prequential Solution to the AIC-BIC Dilemma
Bayesian model averaging, model selection and its approximations such as BIC are generally statistically consistent, but sometimes achieve slower rates og convergence than other methods such as AIC and leave-one-out cross-validation. On the other hand, these other methods can br inconsistent. We identify the "catch-up phenomenon" as a novel explanation for the slow convergence of Bayesian methods. Based on this analysis we define the switch distribution, a modification of the Bayesian marginal distribution. We show that, under broad conditions,model selection and prediction based on the switch distribution is both consistent and achieves optimal convergence rates, thereby resolving the AIC-BIC dilemma. The method is practical; we give an efficient implementation. The switch distribution has a data compression interpretation, and can thus be viewed as a "prequential" or MDL method; yet it is different from the MDL methods that are usually considered in the literature. We compare the switch distribution to Bayes factor model selection and leave-one-out cross-validation.
[ -0.06031470745801926, -0.053769078105688095, 0.012396438047289848, 0.009789427742362022, 0.06426365673542023, -0.01622576080262661, 0.009797151200473309, 0.014414547011256218, 0.02014554850757122, 0.07714980095624924, -0.027720481157302856, -0.08426515758037567, -0.06048697233200073, -0.04489176720380783, 0.02832118421792984, -0.03939347714185715, -0.054430041462183, -0.049574919044971466, 0.06832440197467804, -0.04469240456819534, -0.056371722370386124, 0.0006247904384508729, 0.04714360460639, -0.009535226970911026, -0.0026581771671772003, -0.010015741921961308, -0.01035663764923811, -0.01713656261563301, 0.031173542141914368, 0.02068394050002098, -0.09066750109195709, -0.01846153847873211, 0.023952802643179893, 0.002734256209805608, 0.10155916959047318, -0.010191749781370163, -0.005462932866066694, -0.04222302883863449, -0.03325729817152023, -0.03739809989929199, 0.01158743817359209, -0.08493803441524506, 0.0369378961622715, 0.06795164197683334, 0.03318089246749878, 0.054050810635089874, 0.02775525115430355, 0.09474427998065948, -0.028414614498615265, 0.05681096762418747, -0.012627359479665756, 0.03843413665890694, -0.09837738424539566, 0.04527217894792557, 0.04686616361141205, 0.016004709526896477, -0.059118662029504776, 0.010379997082054615, -0.03056555613875389, -0.0543183870613575, 0.007016568444669247, 0.04483160004019737, -0.034471314400434494, -0.01684841513633728, -0.07021784782409668, 0.0013920898782089353, -0.09873755276203156, -0.03277547284960747, -0.01174917072057724, -0.033969946205616, 0.028598887845873833, -0.04023582488298416, 0.008886387571692467, 0.027668405324220657, -0.025199173018336296, -0.02291763946413994, -0.09035726636648178, 0.02737591229379177, 0.06199723854660988, 0.03349890187382698, -0.06190820783376694, 0.020307419821619987, -0.011274492368102074, 0.001092068967409432, 0.006446133367717266, -0.012420683167874813, 0.004214808344841003, 0.005576816387474537, 0.052036724984645844, -0.0395125076174736, -0.026450535282492638, 0.03573792055249214, -0.09612144529819489, 0.04027887061238289, -0.04691270738840103, 0.005044049117714167, -0.0021908741910010576, 0.01712837629020214, -0.05478495731949806, -0.006893191020935774, -0.04679054394364357, -0.004847051575779915, 0.016237793490290642, 0.1015239804983139, -0.028913326561450958, -0.06737861037254333, -0.043917346745729446, 0.04140269383788109, 0.0308365561068058, 0.01529951486736536, 0.04760228097438812, -0.03698904439806938, 0.07125255465507507, 0.02029620110988617, -0.028994029387831688, 0.09399095922708511, -0.047855984419584274, -0.008555163629353046, -0.03109256736934185, -0.033630505204200745, -0.0020991743076592684, 0.01927304081618786, -0.04370233044028282, 0.02981911227107048, 0.06038234382867813, -0.0014139802660793066, 0.022539189085364342, -0.08695115894079208, 0.10400411486625671, -0.07481767982244492, -0.04789724946022034, 0.03524363785982132, 0.010102657601237297, -0.04932843893766403, -0.0678153932094574, 0.06365914642810822, 0.07211170345544815, -0.014980610460042953, -0.02712484821677208, 0.03444977104663849, -0.09873146563768387, -0.013934064656496048, -0.01633603498339653, 0.03085041418671608, -0.03158942610025406, 0.06940911710262299, 0.04806886240839958, -0.000404639431508258, -0.08351954817771912, -0.020880140364170074, -0.013587563298642635, -0.004773490596562624, 0.026522023603320122, 0.02673845924437046, -0.00045975841931067407, 0.021639423444867134, -0.013556716032326221, 0.06702108681201935, -0.03830515220761299, 0.04803565889596939, 0.03621403127908707, 0.0869244933128357, 0.03699841722846031, -0.03241465240716934, -0.016251105815172195, 0.08313064277172089, 0.0014000169467180967, 0.03961977735161781, -0.03341240435838699, -0.09519372880458832, -0.03375577926635742, -0.06103365495800972, -0.059005606919527054, -0.04742761701345444, 0.027445098385214806, -0.04960060864686966, 0.11197948455810547, 0.011654683388769627, -0.016535164788365364, 0.038535453379154205, 0.01461025420576334, -0.023967867717146873, -0.01641150191426277, -0.009182062931358814, 0.03311266005039215, 0.06215084344148636, -0.032673902809619904, 0.025636503472924232, 0.10410947352647781, 0.10411897301673889, 0.03487374261021614, 0.032772354781627655, 0.02785312384366989, -0.06432726234197617, -0.010207694955170155, -0.024913297966122627, -0.05251626670360565, 0.0061598909087479115, -0.019829586148262024, 0.04223692789673805, 0.027792416512966156, -0.009102948009967804, -0.06740221381187439, -0.03588857129216194, -0.04685487225651741, 0.08000826835632324, 0.10613903403282166, -0.036424729973077774, 0.07230228185653687, -0.07395478338003159, -0.04284963011741638, 0.007287697866559029, -0.05579422786831856, -0.04005681350827217, 0.07069797813892365, -0.036823756992816925, -0.057265378534793854, -0.06699109822511673, -0.04167211800813675, -0.006366662681102753, -0.01457187719643116, 0.021262599155306816, -0.015774259343743324, 0.032442133873701096, -0.09453194588422775, 0.02643539011478424, -0.012156197801232338, 0.03465244174003601, -0.035454824566841125, 0.07148700952529907, -0.05471350625157356, -0.012084592133760452, 0.014968969859182835, 0.020397499203681946, -0.01207999512553215, 0.02646876499056816, 0.002451904583722353, -0.09728936851024628, 0.054612644016742706, -0.018567265942692757, -0.05423027649521828, -0.003026556223630905, 0.010183777660131454, -0.06562995910644531, 0.007307783700525761, 0.029414497315883636, 0.0211991798132658, 0.01486494392156601, -0.006588588003069162, 0.013179448433220387, -0.0056266444735229015, 0.03131730481982231, -0.006474911235272884, 0.020687978714704514, -0.015851542353630066, -0.014744583517313004, -0.07333932816982269, 0.11336986720561981, 0.037229984998703, 0.0154612697660923, 0.0778512954711914, 0.018953505903482437, -0.06404293328523636, -0.0009944643825292587, 0.07996778190135956, 0.0032581822015345097, 0.05986431986093521, -0.019045978784561157, -0.03400689363479614, -0.014101455919444561, 0.015224349685013294, -0.07014995068311691, -0.06840057671070099, 0.05657677724957466, 0.020743921399116516, -0.023420240730047226, 0.0661485493183136, -0.017454834654927254, 0.07814623415470123, -0.05430625379085541, -0.042007751762866974, 0.08470182120800018, 0.010215823538601398, -0.023397954180836678, -0.05971581116318703, -0.008592749945819378, -0.018028302118182182, 0.056811679154634476, -0.0032478037755936384, -0.016084952279925346, -0.10245993733406067, 0.05430500954389572, -0.019941918551921844, 0.01382316555827856, 0.016067340970039368, -0.03222983330488205, 0.04921029880642891, -0.02099459432065487, 0.0547025129199028, -0.015429937280714512, -0.008264199830591679, 0.037402864545583725, 0.04566704481840134, 0.051563508808612823, 0.010562742128968239, 0.07638963311910629, 0.014292566105723381, 0.012900046072900295, -0.045927952975034714, 0.008952125906944275, -0.0036447420716285706, 0.016150593757629395, -0.02596646174788475, 0.035735875368118286, 0.016699254512786865, -0.00019610220624599606, -0.06994640827178955, -0.04294872656464577, 0.010445737279951572, 0.042066533118486404, 0.04470933973789215, 0.07932054251432419, 0.029848244041204453, -0.012832775712013245, -0.009383679367601871, -0.01963745430111885, 0.06110003963112831, 0.015579139813780785, -0.015382531099021435, 0.04337864741683006, -0.06509847193956375, 0.01478253398090601, -0.04959408938884735, 0.10016805678606033, -0.01829603873193264, 0.03372707590460777, -0.020678680390119553, 0.02122844196856022, 0.038998574018478394, -0.019914748147130013, -0.052960190922021866, 0.006106717977672815, -0.011039483360946178, 0.0020878929644823074, 0.0568724200129509, 0.028786558657884598, 0.06479812413454056, 0.01574566215276718, 0.0061999657191336155, 0.030053099617362022, -0.009183795191347599, 0.09714454412460327, -0.012231478467583656, 0.00248371297493577, -0.06821750849485397, 0.015964778140187263, 0.01744331605732441, 0.036077745258808136, 0.06580646336078644, 0.04122031480073929, -0.02750677615404129, -0.01780260168015957, -0.03144514933228493, -0.011210416443645954, -0.01612607203423977, 0.08815567940473557, -0.05195965990424156, 0.03389342501759529, -0.04340876638889313, 0.04128161072731018, -0.01627194695174694, -0.01423671841621399, 0.037155378609895706, 0.004535201005637646, 0.08137501031160355, 0.02990957535803318, 0.031457919627428055, 0.02802884206175804, -0.011689338833093643, 0.08251488208770752, 0.021419024094939232, -0.04093799367547035, -0.02022959105670452, -0.03773045912384987, -0.015981992706656456, -0.056948255747556686, 0.008706054650247097, 0.0013773302780464292, 0.055407844483852386, -0.004057807382196188, -0.013228136114776134, -0.009352829307317734, -0.038933541625738144, 0.08468451350927353, 0.07056469470262527, 0.01803198643028736, 0.012543415650725365, -0.026676807552576065, -0.05531245470046997, 0.038804735988378525, -0.018413599580526352, 0.0010930910939350724, -0.032990485429763794, -0.028109673410654068, -0.07534932345151901, -0.0021131401881575584, -0.02975093200802803, 0.05205632373690605, 0.03682819381356239, 0.056720372289419174, 0.0012913270620629191, -0.0009786745067685843, 0.04231293871998787, 0.023061929270625114, 0.04820810258388519, 0.08547854423522949, 0.05040479823946953, -0.007151311729103327, -0.047177065163850784, -0.09646732360124588, 0.027443474158644676, 0.04489867016673088, -0.011594126001000404, -0.039163753390312195, -0.011634746566414833, 0.013928794302046299, -0.007376807276159525, 0.04549751803278923, 0.007318145129829645, 0.1065741777420044, -0.05151043459773064, -0.06245932728052139, -0.06583040207624435, -0.0327160619199276, 0.007026840001344681, -0.006647170055657625, 0.04620872437953949, 0.007354795467108488, 0.030141346156597137, -0.031597305089235306, 0.03114232048392296, 0.027046658098697662, 0.050265174359083176, -0.007546004839241505, 0.00961589440703392, 0.040622778236866, 0.0331326499581337, 0.059695903211832047, 0.002259688451886177, 0.016561267897486687, 0.012052817270159721, 0.0007829631795175374, 0.00700288824737072, -0.0672808587551117, -0.0014988718321546912, 0.024078747257590294, -0.012501009739935398, -0.03515981510281563, 0.0539354532957077, -0.034230682998895645, -0.07414402067661285, -0.05165214091539383, -0.01504666917026043, 0.029961196705698967, -0.08940664678812027, 0.01095537468791008, 0.0670463889837265, 0.01122315414249897, 0.05158252641558647, 0.011560006998479366, -0.010551509447395802, -0.01785903610289097, 0.047318942844867706, 0.00472728256136179, 0.04865434765815735, -0.004009074531495571, -0.02851398102939129, -0.03654879331588745, -0.033386874943971634, -0.057229071855545044, 0.0826314389705658, 0.00005358075941330753, -0.06504924595355988, 0.07472740858793259, 0.027850065380334854, -0.009167646057903767, -0.017789220437407494, -0.02124888449907303, 0.027919545769691467, -0.0008176499395631254, -0.004849236458539963, -0.007243475876748562, -0.037121620029211044, 0.023868894204497337, -0.02748989686369896, 0.07043633610010147, 0.02160615660250187, -0.021694382652640343, 0.03897152468562126, 0.03363748639822006, 0.04561179503798485, -0.01355463545769453, 0.07853250950574875, -0.032622210681438446, -0.02149035967886448, 0.022116240113973618, 0.05822286009788513, 0.007597129791975021, -0.021001823246479034, 0.043915778398513794, -0.034151576459407806, -0.03181896731257439 ]
127
127
Algorithm Selection as a Bandit Problem with Unbounded Losses
Algorithm selection is typically based on models of algorithm performance, learned during a separate offline training sequence, which can be prohibitively expensive. In recent work, we adopted an online approach, in which a performance model is iteratively updated and used to guide selection on a sequence of problem instances. The resulting exploration-exploitation trade-off was represented as a bandit problem with expert advice, using an existing solver for this game, but this required the setting of an arbitrary bound on algorithm runtimes, thus invalidating the optimal regret of the solver. In this paper, we propose a simpler framework for representing algorithm selection as a bandit problem, with partial information, and an unknown bound on losses. We adapt an existing solver to this game, proving a bound on its expected regret, which holds also for the resulting algorithm selection technique. We present preliminary experiments with a set of SAT solvers on a mixed SAT-UNSAT benchmark.
[ -0.003610158571973443, -0.023992538452148438, 0.04116547852754593, 0.0327543206512928, 0.014126546680927277, -0.07393966615200043, 0.03226855769753456, -0.02666521444916725, -0.004477400798350573, 0.005681643262505531, 0.023945298045873642, -0.0029865154065191746, 0.0026387220714241266, 0.01977224089205265, 0.0023010391741991043, 0.0019500171765685081, 0.008217022754251957, -0.035583823919296265, 0.006945659872144461, -0.02879687026143074, -0.0008051160839386284, 0.02815672941505909, 0.12220897525548935, -0.00018370620091445744, -0.03175724297761917, 0.03330052271485329, -0.008410051465034485, -0.05067025125026703, -0.01943117380142212, 0.04703379049897194, -0.01200065203011036, 0.014787927269935608, 0.012338049709796906, 0.049018923193216324, 0.03722091764211655, -0.048943668603897095, 0.08425507694482803, -0.06690099835395813, 0.0022773020900785923, -0.09224949032068253, 0.011706337332725525, -0.003949825186282396, -0.01005655899643898, 0.043385233730077744, 0.03572897985577583, 0.03325773775577545, 0.02867088094353676, 0.04530836269259453, -0.02526221238076687, 0.01081395335495472, -0.024581043049693108, -0.006916970945894718, -0.04365942254662514, -0.018030177801847458, -0.005235477816313505, 0.02201925963163376, -0.06726911664009094, -0.04784770682454109, 0.06793120503425598, -0.03588353469967842, 0.005338999442756176, 0.07189953327178955, 0.03194752708077431, -0.07107727974653244, -0.03992336243391037, 0.02179962396621704, -0.052446335554122925, -0.0038120944518595934, -0.028286876156926155, -0.06467779725790024, 0.09537914395332336, -0.04426346719264984, 0.027265964075922966, 0.004328413400799036, 0.07083792239427567, -0.00959876086562872, 0.03878147527575493, 0.0006434491369873285, 0.0003380115085747093, 0.08419658243656158, -0.072678342461586, -0.010373289696872234, 0.006850448902696371, 0.08866830915212631, 0.01447291113436222, -0.03622229024767876, 0.03953532874584198, 0.039645109325647354, -0.035957444459199905, -0.01928062178194523, -0.030720707029104233, 0.03263299912214279, -0.04010378196835518, 0.039420925080776215, 0.024291416630148888, 0.056347090750932693, -0.03459719941020012, 0.03489913418889046, 0.07262109965085983, 0.0869234949350357, 0.03768477588891983, 0.001497533405199647, 0.055193621665239334, 0.10394103825092316, -0.14809373021125793, -0.008024978451430798, 0.04249067232012749, 0.034037549048662186, 0.02593536488711834, -0.027679868042469025, -0.01806235872209072, 0.024662073701620102, 0.05686425045132637, -0.00450962595641613, -0.03694283589720726, -0.011682883836328983, -0.06697843223810196, 0.062332361936569214, 0.025613917037844658, 0.03420303389430046, -0.009119187481701374, 0.08843356370925903, -0.039922695606946945, 0.08286929875612259, 0.010404468514025211, -0.062240228056907654, -0.001014125533401966, -0.049301713705062866, 0.09223631024360657, -0.001229733694344759, -0.09134560078382492, -0.005889971740543842, -0.0983482152223587, -0.0406142920255661, -0.03351292759180069, 0.04154602810740471, 0.04676193371415138, 0.02289431169629097, 0.007190198637545109, 0.055106423795223236, 0.017284784466028214, -0.04067779332399368, -0.055738236755132675, 0.006278579588979483, -0.0189651045948267, 0.012347300536930561, 0.013062294572591782, 0.005552894901484251, 0.006847477983683348, 0.01771276257932186, -0.02192576602101326, 0.039283569902181625, -0.019831029698252678, 0.04395275563001633, 0.009258703328669071, 0.0052894847467541695, -0.04963134601712227, -0.06624148041009903, -0.09439645707607269, -0.020718369632959366, 0.0408635288476944, 0.020862432196736336, 0.015065177343785763, 0.01859058439731598, 0.07293178886175156, 0.06582687050104141, 0.011288035660982132, -0.01283588819205761, 0.02706066705286503, -0.055752240121364594, 0.020412366837263107, -0.036504875868558884, -0.03966865688562393, 0.005455121397972107, 0.032311320304870605, 0.01238144189119339, 0.01755364052951336, -0.0143663315102458, -0.07697832584381104, -0.06363372504711151, 0.019239269196987152, -0.08357095718383789, 0.023187881335616112, -0.045051053166389465, 0.06523309648036957, 0.0479704812169075, 0.005832953378558159, 0.05894871801137924, 0.048761818557977676, 0.03474072739481926, -0.009242854081094265, 0.04972940310835838, 0.030966410413384438, -0.04204801097512245, -0.030095228925347328, 0.011342491954565048, -0.07832194864749908, -0.026984339579939842, 0.022122858092188835, 0.030151033774018288, 0.013296248391270638, 0.030361764132976532, -0.048540350049734116, -0.05984634533524513, -0.03290539234876633, 0.016186881810426712, 0.018669115379452705, -0.022028299048542976, 0.006801775190979242, -0.0802423506975174, 0.05310998111963272, 0.010311799123883247, -0.03370380029082298, -0.013474947772920132, 0.0022978559136390686, -0.03403649851679802, -0.018902290612459183, -0.07654951512813568, 0.07363646477460861, -0.004324167035520077, -0.02731974422931671, 0.052012477070093155, 0.0386195182800293, -0.04359453544020653, -0.035893164575099945, -0.008584944531321526, 0.03433092311024666, -0.050425928086042404, -0.07642659544944763, 0.05403243005275726, 0.031993284821510315, -0.05359439551830292, 0.0019818583969026804, 0.06152239069342613, -0.03510477393865585, 0.07269369065761566, 0.0056295073591172695, -0.057771679013967514, -0.023366963490843773, -0.003381398506462574, 0.017435507848858833, -0.020738521590828896, -0.06579291820526123, -0.07920542359352112, 0.07386334985494614, 0.008124373853206635, 0.03689019754528999, 0.012241233140230179, -0.026598438620567322, -0.003838958917185664, 0.06623511016368866, -0.02436896413564682, -0.06084895506501198, 0.0017493697814643383, 0.0611737035214901, -0.005780912470072508, 0.019916977733373642, 0.05947079136967659, 0.04394909366965294, 0.039251673966646194, -0.02531718835234642, 0.0588422492146492, -0.08302107453346252, -0.002806637668982148, 0.041637860238552094, 0.021262051537632942, -0.036631595343351364, 0.04163721576333046, 0.01818171516060829, 0.025771768763661385, 0.025944041088223457, -0.0345320887863636, -0.011317361146211624, 0.1798868328332901, -0.08302292972803116, -0.057999562472105026, 0.040537379682064056, -0.017277268692851067, 0.039343394339084625, 0.0802365094423294, -0.0949731096625328, -0.03444055840373039, -0.005235199350863695, 0.0020097687374800444, -0.028449930250644684, 0.0674154981970787, -0.02534208819270134, -0.033976759761571884, -0.043525803834199905, 0.040529534220695496, 0.014317545108497143, 0.013884921558201313, -0.07687771320343018, -0.028919465839862823, 0.02645125240087509, -0.06868800520896912, -0.040803663432598114, 0.009196880273520947, -0.015844499692320824, -0.02056245319545269, -0.04611610993742943, -0.00939649436622858, 0.11494742333889008, 0.02521783672273159, -0.0031247176229953766, 0.04699995741248131, 0.1261683851480484, 0.006986246909946203, -0.0041656577959656715, -0.020975302904844284, 0.04800610989332199, -0.03109966777265072, -0.00033892603823915124, -0.01832589879631996, 0.007430559489876032, 0.018603390082716942, -0.011952589266002178, 0.03412417322397232, -0.009680520743131638, 0.033929090946912766, -0.017496658489108086, -0.006481677759438753, 0.03495458886027336, 0.0338735356926918, -0.1204780787229538, -0.017848791554570198, -0.003136104205623269, 0.03899189084768295, -0.03906029090285301, 0.0238543301820755, -0.08920372277498245, -0.025700891390442848, -0.008645237423479557, 0.06742491573095322, -0.05059659853577614, -0.004272610414773226, -0.013670198619365692, -0.006159637589007616, 0.027501752600073814, -0.029218891635537148, -0.03459065407514572, -0.11925184726715088, -0.017865626141428947, -0.03026849962770939, 0.028528526425361633, 0.03978073596954346, 0.07146507501602173, 0.09079426527023315, 0.021229609847068787, 0.03400513529777527, -0.02615121565759182, -0.05727999284863472, -0.07107541710138321, 0.0738079845905304, -0.04555642977356911, -0.034469932317733765, 0.018305819481611252, -0.04337045177817345, -0.04122701659798622, 0.03235064446926117, -0.07814809679985046, -0.04007181152701378, -0.007777503691613674, -0.03658600524067879, 0.07686352729797363, 0.01918327435851097, -0.0580160953104496, 0.014899468049407005, -0.09599729627370834, 0.06536434590816498, -0.014810633845627308, 0.013568946160376072, 0.0012459094868972898, -0.04259498044848442, -0.01685536652803421, -0.020532269030809402, -0.009205449372529984, -0.07522516697645187, 0.01270105130970478, 0.06064845994114876, -0.08583425730466843, 0.01206320058554411, -0.04264460876584053, 0.022887161001563072, -0.02338581532239914, -0.006747472565621138, -0.044225625693798065, 0.026402097195386887, 0.07931855320930481, -0.05838044732809067, -0.03229214996099472, -0.010385979898273945, 0.009389646351337433, 0.04223867505788803, 0.03674927353858948, 0.04392852261662483, 0.022196725010871887, -0.04323028028011322, -0.010422966443002224, 0.031233055517077446, -0.004017794504761696, -0.030219167470932007, -0.031023818999528885, -0.08279718458652496, -0.04940519109368324, 0.044166408479213715, 0.07068365067243576, 0.05661870539188385, 0.002590576186776161, 0.06773754954338074, 0.012818712741136551, 0.03247104585170746, 0.002955929609015584, -0.0076207625679671764, -0.04753931984305382, -0.032687511295080185, -0.01623164676129818, 0.00871914904564619, -0.00602330919355154, -0.04897188022732735, 0.030540186911821365, -0.04971190169453621, -0.027361208572983742, -0.06963177770376205, 0.007098850794136524, -0.03270974010229111, 0.03928394243121147, 0.048844415694475174, -0.006808863952755928, 0.016312427818775177, -0.08146977424621582, 0.010283201932907104, -0.01980341039597988, -0.03822525590658188, 0.02071991004049778, 0.020696569234132767, 0.04548078775405884, -0.014244534075260162, -0.04014630243182182, -0.0309051051735878, 0.021983228623867035, 0.000527022872120142, -0.041865333914756775, -0.00044660631101578474, -0.05841240659356117, 0.05474478006362915, 0.0005042004631832242, -0.02105492539703846, 0.03599263355135918, 0.0014688310911878943, -0.00904525350779295, -0.03152555599808693, -0.02254403941333294, 0.000811118574347347, -0.038114383816719055, -0.03505891561508179, 0.0030566449277102947, -0.021919218823313713, -0.005512706935405731, -0.024771472439169884, 0.014194139279425144, -0.04153461009263992, 0.023499958217144012, 0.005994013976305723, -0.021048564463853836, 0.02531498484313488, -0.010894219391047955, -0.0007906758110038936, 0.07526940107345581, 0.02692253142595291, -0.07873933017253876, 0.04166577383875847, 0.010112304240465164, -0.05939948558807373, -0.057171761989593506, -0.029260464012622833, 0.030623534694314003, -0.033260416239500046, 0.036036260426044464, 0.0370396263897419, 0.02431538701057434, 0.011848989874124527, 0.05538669973611832, -0.03826816752552986, 0.08706764876842499, -0.037498828023672104, -0.0744098499417305, 0.044588785618543625, 0.03945927694439888, 0.04852189123630524, -0.004041314125061035, -0.011022998951375484, 0.027375614270567894, 0.04130960628390312, -0.037388332188129425, 0.02485174685716629, 0.04825708642601967, -0.0886862576007843, 0.0672900527715683, 0.03814609721302986, -0.028989437967538834, -0.00834672525525093, 0.017688078805804253, 0.07203006744384766, 0.03706330433487892, 0.006377788260579109, 0.06957534700632095, 0.0650024339556694, -0.008493765257298946, 0.03339186683297157, -0.014107710681855679, 0.046532031148672104 ]
128
128
Multi-Instance Learning by Treating Instances As Non-I.I.D. Samples
Multi-instance learning attempts to learn from a training set consisting of labeled bags each containing many unlabeled instances. Previous studies typically treat the instances in the bags as independently and identically distributed. However, the instances in a bag are rarely independent, and therefore a better performance can be expected if the instances are treated in an non-i.i.d. way that exploits the relations among instances. In this paper, we propose a simple yet effective multi-instance learning method, which regards each bag as a graph and uses a specific kernel to distinguish the graphs by considering the features of the nodes as well as the features of the edges that convey some relations among instances. The effectiveness of the proposed method is validated by experiments.
[ 0.006046795751899481, -0.07166676223278046, 0.035148635506629944, 0.049344878643751144, 0.0485566183924675, -0.083251953125, -0.0498025044798851, 0.02592192031443119, -0.017024552449584007, 0.015916919335722923, 0.005110342055559158, 0.006812841631472111, 0.046988777816295624, -0.003836854360997677, 0.0982905924320221, 0.09923931956291199, -0.008125143125653267, -0.06263120472431183, 0.005174328573048115, -0.03611643239855766, 0.07316971570253372, -0.0106178168207407, 0.10527581721544266, -0.023278195410966873, 0.051828961819410324, 0.003731378121301532, 0.02308330126106739, -0.012080037035048008, -0.0697569027543068, 0.019530069082975388, 0.021694783121347427, -0.005345422774553299, 0.05471380800008774, -0.002854915102943778, 0.059429652988910675, 0.01347067765891552, 0.00027750353910960257, -0.035026609897613525, -0.08184557408094406, 0.023917000740766525, 0.025516247376799583, -0.09019841253757477, 0.05287415534257889, 0.014118317514657974, 0.04952697828412056, 0.02700895629823208, 0.04481231048703194, -0.028743447735905647, 0.02745593711733818, 0.059290580451488495, -0.06317523121833801, 0.013700121082365513, 0.026269586756825447, 0.03239639475941658, -0.00022636624635197222, 0.056444887071847916, -0.04497282952070236, -0.00918525643646717, -0.0428987592458725, 0.019867096096277237, -0.011299128644168377, 0.05004280433058739, -0.020738402381539345, -0.0005336998729035258, -0.02856934256851673, 0.0702386349439621, -0.021054670214653015, 0.0069242981262505054, -0.061001040041446686, -0.008819959126412868, -0.06496014446020126, -0.026847288012504578, -0.025449732318520546, 0.09464836120605469, 0.06451588869094849, 0.023499105125665665, 0.0172929335385561, 0.00047134808846749365, 0.018835902214050293, 0.04970460757613182, -0.11356940865516663, -0.02625497430562973, -0.05242184177041054, -0.026403550058603287, -0.017946012318134308, 0.017677655443549156, 0.016042646020650864, 0.009837937541306019, 0.014073679223656654, 0.04992542788386345, -0.033088311553001404, -0.006617835722863674, -0.08333931863307953, 0.06587839871644974, -0.024035120382905006, -0.0303049199283123, -0.042213719338178635, -0.04904245212674141, 0.010150955989956856, 0.00416013365611434, -0.0026289753150194883, -0.0686068907380104, -0.04077446833252907, 0.07840616255998611, -0.04324432462453842, -0.05473571643233299, 0.012708643451333046, 0.012570546008646488, 0.10700585693120956, -0.020660126581788063, 0.052303336560726166, -0.005499774124473333, -0.043039217591285706, 0.06844744831323624, -0.03979426994919777, 0.0789547711610794, -0.07146170735359192, 0.08159635215997696, 0.021496178582310677, -0.02084396407008171, -0.025569187477231026, -0.05014880746603012, -0.1165158823132515, 0.008399606682360172, 0.02576557919383049, -0.05302060395479202, -0.07349995523691177, -0.0664278045296669, 0.07554985582828522, 0.014108076691627502, -0.04442247003316879, 0.05427822098135948, -0.05990595743060112, -0.019329115748405457, -0.008281446993350983, -0.016359062865376472, -0.013531271368265152, -0.038177862763404846, -0.0018069713842123747, 0.07982566952705383, 0.02766004204750061, -0.05265551432967186, -0.004018943756818771, 0.01883147656917572, -0.006841006223112345, 0.023481547832489014, 0.012114581651985645, 0.03141522780060768, 0.0022594723850488663, -0.053605031222105026, 0.027953989803791046, -0.05122702941298485, 0.03777752071619034, 0.035401564091444016, 0.036824338138103485, -0.025499893352389336, -0.04656358063220978, 0.011820984072983265, 0.055364836007356644, 0.07467302680015564, -0.04244862496852875, 0.039197541773319244, 0.0291761364787817, 0.008433413691818714, 0.05209479480981827, 0.012633442878723145, -0.01884462870657444, 0.02008740045130253, -0.044715575873851776, -0.007743473630398512, -0.01812967099249363, 0.01843566633760929, -0.01927722617983818, -0.05638890713453293, -0.02024369314312935, -0.014660784974694252, -0.04801970720291138, 0.014123032800853252, 0.015418053604662418, -0.01517582219094038, -0.0273317638784647, -0.06207088381052017, -0.020254360511898994, 0.05485699698328972, 0.02719423547387123, 0.022422347217798233, -0.010163656435906887, 0.08049704134464264, 0.012725076638162136, 0.02734837494790554, -0.022200679406523705, -0.03601241856813431, 0.06378758698701859, 0.018706435337662697, -0.04126147925853729, 0.09318304806947708, -0.009181078523397446, -0.030553128570318222, -0.01889731176197529, 0.030780469998717308, -0.009580584242939949, -0.09445266425609589, 0.0892009362578392, -0.03500960394740105, -0.005954126361757517, -0.01883566752076149, 0.0837370753288269, -0.04282429814338684, -0.03581521287560463, -0.05078613758087158, 0.02303336188197136, 0.0014015103224664927, -0.03296111896634102, -0.059878118336200714, 0.003227372420951724, -0.044460441917181015, -0.000737891357857734, -0.08411993831396103, 0.025354348123073578, 0.04800151288509369, 0.014215153641998768, 0.015829741954803467, -0.011043825186789036, -0.04926800727844238, -0.013037932105362415, 0.0023308072704821825, 0.07869899272918701, -0.008592943660914898, -0.013092784211039543, 0.041378166526556015, -0.03451209515333176, -0.028461022302508354, -0.05802452936768532, -0.06818316876888275, 0.03939817473292351, 0.03224484622478485, -0.11624913662672043, -0.00012039575085509568, 0.01942114531993866, -0.029449505731463432, -0.02284349873661995, 0.03454333171248436, -0.053201768547296524, -0.025135962292551994, -0.032243501394987106, -0.024947693571448326, 0.05633653327822685, 0.0490315780043602, -0.02282651513814926, -0.004536991473287344, -0.053212277591228485, 0.027596423402428627, -0.004563221707940102, -0.0582076720893383, -0.053860411047935486, -0.04220547154545784, 0.001404588227160275, 0.06381732225418091, 0.037646692246198654, 0.07438711822032928, 0.06764419376850128, -0.0015127588994801044, -0.04907836392521858, 0.0004264221934136003, 0.05966087803244591, 0.040649931877851486, 0.05561616271734238, -0.024644244462251663, -0.04448582977056503, -0.004842974711209536, 0.008872667327523232, -0.11367838084697723, -0.0445997528731823, 0.07062157243490219, -0.021716227754950523, 0.008574661798775196, -0.059294167906045914, -0.02096029371023178, 0.006638873368501663, -0.11251691728830338, -0.030814314261078835, 0.03369241580367088, 0.06660907715559006, -0.03994370251893997, -0.0787920206785202, -0.004181606229394674, 0.015487120486795902, -0.042814936488866806, 0.07852122187614441, 0.02875875122845173, -0.015496935695409775, -0.014965889975428581, -0.04885805398225784, 0.029886500909924507, 0.009435347281396389, -0.08635752648115158, -0.003663034411147237, -0.07757777720689774, -0.018940599635243416, 0.02173173613846302, 0.03842609375715256, -0.0007786044734530151, 0.04186858609318733, 0.03773495927453041, 0.015785112977027893, 0.07027571648359299, -0.008606132119894028, 0.06978700309991837, -0.05492226779460907, -0.045558519661426544, -0.01655871793627739, -0.039651572704315186, 0.03022637963294983, -0.013899751007556915, -0.01605144888162613, 0.0005759805208072066, -0.047858819365501404, 0.0012145756045356393, -0.04878732189536095, 0.02203877456486225, -0.05278436467051506, 0.010716760531067848, 0.02978036366403103, -0.061139751225709915, -0.04844660684466362, -0.04880212992429733, 0.05865038186311722, 0.10612546652555466, -0.0932651236653328, 0.0028975405730307102, -0.06866730749607086, -0.018138935789465904, -0.0408092625439167, 0.11712159961462021, -0.02073412574827671, 0.021190641447901726, -0.010558842681348324, 0.0044999332167208195, -0.06264553964138031, -0.05799702927470207, -0.03136998787522316, -0.012797041796147823, -0.027579229325056076, -0.03049394302070141, 0.0301924180239439, 0.06360292434692383, 0.04394138231873512, -0.028284333646297455, 0.0020285136997699738, -0.0051224990747869015, -0.04357556998729706, 0.07471033185720444, -0.027369048446416855, 0.043602146208286285, -0.03240317106246948, -0.005122477188706398, 0.08170178532600403, -0.038885269314050674, -0.07634850591421127, 0.06772036105394363, -0.017346108332276344, 0.039017025381326675, -0.03155691176652908, 0.05770701915025711, -0.020084891468286514, 0.02104509249329567, -0.05834615230560303, 0.030375303700566292, -0.042281750589609146, -0.02472943440079689, 0.02489876188337803, 0.010567366145551205, 0.03321775421500206, -0.004759983159601688, -0.03291110321879387, -0.016598157584667206, -0.0017248977674171329, -0.06022244691848755, -0.008774062618613243, 0.06033458560705185, -0.051961518824100494, -0.04285614192485809, -0.034302812069654465, 0.08210937678813934, -0.025777915492653847, -0.043128155171871185, -0.019367573782801628, 0.04790440574288368, 0.06106039509177208, 0.004286360461264849, -0.016427407041192055, -0.01902722381055355, 0.009692804887890816, 0.0071935406886041164, 0.04723958298563957, 0.034580402076244354, -0.056683946400880814, 0.05195123329758644, -0.04340832680463791, 0.11158139258623123, 0.007192496210336685, -0.013437052257359028, 0.04439409077167511, -0.07909891754388809, -0.07371186465024948, 0.055241405963897705, 0.013219229876995087, 0.10540714114904404, -0.0361936055123806, 0.032597728073596954, 0.007430568337440491, 0.10270800441503525, -0.06996916234493256, -0.06469355523586273, 0.00361848552711308, 0.023304155096411705, 0.004557544831186533, -0.013482928276062012, 0.027420155704021454, -0.06602159142494202, -0.024761054664850235, 0.03532826527953148, 0.024956142529845238, -0.04366868734359741, -0.0025057890452444553, -0.016130700707435608, 0.012981578707695007, 0.03305419534444809, 0.0402076281607151, 0.0003293021582067013, -0.098274827003479, 0.03996807336807251, -0.09710819274187088, -0.04357847571372986, 0.01958218403160572, 0.02520216815173626, 0.07668517529964447, -0.046131398528814316, 0.02303187921643257, 0.054899174720048904, 0.03796505182981491, 0.017429515719413757, 0.031060701236128807, 0.00407377677038312, -0.0010296925902366638, 0.10834406316280365, 0.01950930245220661, -0.011351773515343666, 0.034923382103443146, 0.06428288668394089, 0.0043302420526742935, -0.0012574001448228955, 0.016284428536891937, -0.004743873607367277, -0.033126235008239746, -0.05357380956411362, 0.03643492981791496, -0.07802455127239227, 0.007164288777858019, -0.05092107504606247, -0.009679150767624378, -0.010147606022655964, 0.050357215106487274, -0.007720292080193758, -0.006732857320457697, 0.002705690450966358, 0.08611532300710678, 0.017058512195944786, -0.04269309714436531, -0.0015721442177891731, -0.06638995558023453, -0.0052820853888988495, 0.008847811259329319, -0.07187548279762268, -0.012087708339095116, 0.023071791976690292, 0.00499945180490613, -0.07223311811685562, 0.03368470445275307, 0.02427755482494831, 0.03491620346903801, 0.014910927042365074, -0.03344598785042763, -0.008018653839826584, -0.009008049964904785, -0.009728273376822472, 0.008986467495560646, -0.01470919605344534, -0.01522294245660305, 0.027874259278178215, 0.02236473374068737, -0.01680753193795681, -0.005775995086878538, 0.030597157776355743, -0.026112046092748642, -0.010259510017931461, -0.016026750206947327, 0.015041112899780273, 0.02930610440671444, -0.011246545240283012, -0.009094007313251495, -0.006650897674262524, 0.029668886214494705, 0.004401379264891148, 0.07720888406038284, -0.006078982725739479, 0.03661186248064041, -0.02765020541846752, -0.028669318184256554, 0.04517488181591034, 0.0043493397533893585, 0.008197590708732605 ]
129
129
Algorithms for Dynamic Spectrum Access with Learning for Cognitive Radio
We study the problem of dynamic spectrum sensing and access in cognitive radio systems as a partially observed Markov decision process (POMDP). A group of cognitive users cooperatively tries to exploit vacancies in primary (licensed) channels whose occupancies follow a Markovian evolution. We first consider the scenario where the cognitive users have perfect knowledge of the distribution of the signals they receive from the primary users. For this problem, we obtain a greedy channel selection and access policy that maximizes the instantaneous reward, while satisfying a constraint on the probability of interfering with licensed transmissions. We also derive an analytical universal upper bound on the performance of the optimal policy. Through simulation, we show that our scheme achieves good performance relative to the upper bound and improved performance relative to an existing scheme. We then consider the more practical scenario where the exact distribution of the signal from the primary is unknown. We assume a parametric model for the distribution and develop an algorithm that can learn the true distribution, still guaranteeing the constraint on the interference probability. We show that this algorithm outperforms the naive design that assumes a worst case value for the parameter. We also provide a proof for the convergence of the learning algorithm.
[ -0.04222193360328674, -0.011115671135485172, 0.0036346109118312597, -0.022985516116023064, 0.02677972987294197, -0.0590691976249218, -0.041046977043151855, -0.004780442453920841, -0.056926529854536057, 0.020338404923677444, 0.03859424218535423, -0.07006627321243286, 0.009968667291104794, 0.03627140820026398, 0.07061254233121872, -0.08118495345115662, 0.023172127082943916, 0.002614058554172516, 0.018036918714642525, -0.04110217094421387, 0.0032209681812673807, -0.004772397223860025, -0.006712422706186771, -0.0004131504683755338, -0.02606699988245964, 0.018261989578604698, -0.028048474341630936, -0.00770870316773653, 0.024937855079770088, 0.0010884236544370651, -0.10386571288108826, -0.008886143565177917, -0.017507951706647873, 0.02326042391359806, 0.025112338364124298, -0.04769216477870941, 0.003453654469922185, -0.07057631760835648, -0.07389384508132935, -0.031943097710609436, -0.004593562334775925, -0.0019049656111747026, -0.020869627594947815, 0.007159463129937649, 0.0880497395992279, -0.013836703263223171, -0.038487307727336884, 0.011458450928330421, 0.041974782943725586, 0.013232957571744919, -0.08292781561613083, 0.008927911520004272, 0.010514207184314728, 0.029785480350255966, 0.013254567980766296, 0.03417409211397171, -0.04138784110546112, 0.0010216694790869951, -0.008451753295958042, -0.016414828598499298, 0.026269730180501938, 0.10478246212005615, -0.05821661651134491, 0.00025679278769530356, -0.059597503393888474, -0.022306660190224648, -0.08487028628587723, 0.014657261781394482, -0.009096689522266388, 0.0494583323597908, -0.000981896067969501, 0.018606780096888542, 0.0021231602877378464, -0.02590114250779152, 0.06662910431623459, 0.04528486728668213, -0.05085064098238945, 0.06403855234384537, -0.00566438352689147, 0.003076696302741766, -0.08701866865158081, 0.12044736742973328, -0.003736155340448022, 0.012618458829820156, -0.01003614068031311, -0.02694035694003105, -0.05473439395427704, 0.004289932548999786, -0.03230147063732147, 0.014027333818376064, -0.04611010476946831, 0.0427098423242569, -0.028966961428523064, 0.0061088562943041325, 0.040237780660390854, 0.04017169028520584, -0.03906591236591339, 0.004861630033701658, 0.006261245813220739, 0.031736042350530624, 0.010770464316010475, -0.014650380238890648, 0.043393541127443314, 0.05264807119965553, 0.01568462699651718, 0.01050573494285345, -0.017448963597416878, 0.002411658177152276, -0.05620090290904045, -0.039291612803936005, 0.03788575530052185, -0.04535893723368645, -0.022821925580501556, -0.011650582775473595, -0.059501465409994125, 0.0403725691139698, -0.004882878623902798, 0.050476983189582825, 0.00431640213355422, 0.09600108861923218, -0.027113966643810272, 0.010790292173624039, -0.07031122595071793, -0.009010392241179943, 0.030781304463744164, 0.001434178790077567, 0.025649916380643845, -0.0618184469640255, 0.06599297374486923, 0.047594208270311356, -0.050480034202337265, 0.014998821541666985, 0.021113023161888123, -0.05730566009879112, 0.003975067287683487, 0.0749572142958641, 0.0026492851320654154, 0.013092837296426296, -0.042203474789857864, 0.03975870460271835, 0.038977932184934616, -0.00011709121463354677, -0.0030900321435183287, 0.02742605283856392, 0.040911946445703506, -0.010480568744242191, 0.023867450654506683, -0.0006113117560744286, -0.04087013006210327, -0.04776965454220772, -0.050792042165994644, 0.01330286543816328, 0.025084802880883217, 0.06180958077311516, -0.011571832001209259, -0.10014195740222931, -0.004970024339854717, -0.015064054168760777, -0.030493780970573425, 0.0569780208170414, -0.015715012326836586, 0.06920422613620758, 0.039147570729255676, 0.09094344079494476, -0.04008622467517853, 0.05380311235785484, -0.09731322526931763, 0.05171018838882446, 0.003391171805560589, -0.02432013861835003, -0.033741164952516556, -0.02895515225827694, -0.012567873112857342, 0.018784429877996445, 0.05057912319898605, -0.049811553210020065, -0.02319917641580105, -0.013643770478665829, 0.0015375304501503706, 0.04194654896855354, 0.015106309205293655, -0.07908795773983002, -0.008809970691800117, -0.03911425545811653, 0.024108273908495903, 0.04668203741312027, 0.0317075178027153, 0.09797221422195435, 0.07389282435178757, 0.03302453085780144, -0.013704901561141014, 0.013438423164188862, 0.005569676868617535, -0.019836992025375366, -0.04135800153017044, -0.0179993137717247, -0.06418509036302567, 0.033525656908750534, 0.014187144115567207, 0.0072179208509624004, 0.11488761752843857, -0.023074135184288025, -0.08206181228160858, 0.0703759491443634, 0.01802721992135048, 0.021102996543049812, 0.00041149326716549695, -0.00965987890958786, 0.061477549374103546, -0.022520599886775017, 0.01311091985553503, 0.011961639858782291, 0.005652181804180145, 0.0197073295712471, 0.059791091829538345, 0.021170061081647873, -0.018398627638816833, -0.03650319576263428, -0.00663802120834589, -0.009621710516512394, -0.08215446025133133, 0.06512422114610672, 0.10767325758934021, -0.013235552236437798, -0.12361606955528259, -0.037541814148426056, 0.016173530369997025, 0.02344713918864727, -0.08956150710582733, 0.02474505454301834, -0.03210733085870743, -0.04513402283191681, 0.008752476423978806, -0.027508189901709557, -0.02121332474052906, 0.05218943580985069, -0.045561645179986954, 0.010765946470201015, -0.03476499766111374, -0.03831634670495987, 0.03550709784030914, 0.03348495438694954, 0.008836759254336357, -0.02070089988410473, 0.10957726091146469, 0.0495300367474556, -0.046527206897735596, -0.004045328591018915, -0.08066119998693466, -0.017245717346668243, 0.047073736786842346, -0.0392264798283577, -0.021929197013378143, 0.07850518077611923, 0.002356728771701455, -0.050686199218034744, 0.04899317026138306, -0.0035123510751873255, 0.04298979043960571, -0.02991463430225849, -0.031185060739517212, -0.01885952427983284, -0.035573024302721024, 0.057420872151851654, 0.03847268223762512, -0.0006662768428213894, -0.007361255586147308, 0.013874474912881851, -0.03627602756023407, -0.004534448031336069, -0.020756417885422707, -0.05821080878376961, -0.05678481236100197, 0.03610730543732643, 0.013617477379739285, -0.02327846549451351, 0.04680074751377106, 0.060163263231515884, -0.032206941395998, -0.05497538298368454, 0.003923309966921806, 0.01936492696404457, 0.027665335685014725, -0.01986551471054554, 0.08727385103702545, 0.03722038492560387, -0.03004840761423111, 0.03233403339982033, 0.011202574707567692, 0.021968206390738487, -0.034408409148454666, -0.027006501331925392, -0.07187771797180176, 0.05354172736406326, 0.02459373138844967, -0.03542306274175644, -0.02502538077533245, 0.01745457760989666, 0.04617885872721672, -0.06939295679330826, -0.005350985564291477, 0.009199978783726692, 0.044901054352521896, 0.002272657584398985, 0.010060694068670273, 0.04556983709335327, 0.04679027199745178, 0.02313181757926941, -0.008675660938024521, 0.04628652706742287, 0.02217642217874527, 0.07644296437501907, -0.07447174936532974, 0.022669252008199692, 0.07020854204893112, 0.02833612449467182, -0.01186705008149147, -0.05835333466529846, -0.04655959829688072, 0.019813410937786102, -0.01723591238260269, -0.021412832662463188, 0.04334918409585953, 0.07960361987352371, -0.05820928514003754, -0.026982735842466354, -0.028793586418032646, 0.083833709359169, -0.07907295972108841, 0.035228680819272995, -0.08887138962745667, 0.01648838259279728, -0.03425600379705429, 0.11511872708797455, -0.07902651280164719, 0.004987815860658884, -0.10633529722690582, -0.041023850440979004, 0.022220371291041374, 0.10100448876619339, -0.056397922337055206, -0.08715952187776566, -0.045042894780635834, -0.006110465619713068, 0.011236555874347687, 0.07559484988451004, 0.07408110052347183, -0.03629724681377411, -0.01959574967622757, 0.019430415704846382, -0.05233042314648628, 0.029279794543981552, -0.02605510503053665, -0.050920333713293076, -0.08050768822431564, 0.01858912780880928, 0.04727789759635925, -0.031048275530338287, 0.008096674457192421, 0.05494939535856247, -0.07226841151714325, -0.0009796102531254292, -0.06428775191307068, -0.027864521369338036, 0.023058857768774033, 0.05609699338674545, -0.020443463698029518, -0.04200258105993271, -0.07840090245008469, -0.01730763353407383, 0.00882537942379713, -0.019098104909062386, 0.009499745443463326, -0.0005132881342433393, 0.03277451917529106, 0.00390642462298274, 0.03619351238012314, -0.08863714337348938, 0.002344573149457574, 0.01885027065873146, -0.038821589201688766, -0.01965811662375927, 0.0237971730530262, -0.014120184816420078, 0.009162932634353638, 0.020508097484707832, -0.05933312699198723, 0.030329929664731026, 0.09054762870073318, -0.054866790771484375, -0.06778427213430405, 0.0051267254166305065, 0.0236999299377203, 0.0685291662812233, 0.061940256506204605, -0.02939329296350479, 0.034157391637563705, 0.041944004595279694, -0.029928790405392647, 0.034913383424282074, 0.06767257302999496, 0.014877856709063053, -0.02112787589430809, -0.09933662414550781, -0.09336923062801361, -0.03464465215802193, 0.02063339576125145, 0.04143466800451279, 0.0008554396335966885, 0.08249993622303009, 0.008842188864946365, 0.017603693529963493, -0.022592898458242416, 0.04269547015428543, -0.0707329586148262, 0.013983768410980701, -0.0557095892727375, -0.02407502941787243, 0.0481254979968071, -0.10467089712619781, -0.0007064735400490463, -0.03398728743195534, 0.05570687726140022, -0.05771554633975029, -0.06617317348718643, -0.0722283273935318, 0.09701289981603622, 0.036398835480213165, -0.006934484466910362, 0.06621716171503067, -0.027392733842134476, -0.06950198113918304, -0.05318692699074745, -0.0019342510495334864, 0.029431210830807686, -0.022901812568306923, 0.04412541165947914, 0.006744159385561943, 0.014569045975804329, -0.02191307581961155, -0.014583948999643326, 0.007046350743621588, -0.016821522265672684, -0.04005082696676254, 0.03306960314512253, 0.029213638976216316, 0.07344017177820206, -0.009679886512458324, 0.03485560417175293, -0.00860771257430315, 0.005376038607209921, -0.004396294709295034, 0.06540566682815552, -0.024592077359557152, 0.017368806526064873, 0.02317863143980503, 0.023225627839565277, -0.0007553942268714309, 0.05026394501328468, 0.0008499777177348733, -0.033909160643815994, -0.046934738755226135, -0.02290552854537964, -0.01694042980670929, -0.030440649017691612, -0.016482139006257057, -0.01598375476896763, -0.04008057713508606, 0.058420579880476, -0.016914287582039833, -0.07644269615411758, 0.030763452872633934, -0.07351584732532501, -0.010910384356975555, -0.0011487395968288183, 0.04553023353219032, 0.1168576031923294, 0.04983912408351898, 0.004027092829346657, -0.035228852182626724, 0.018636945635080338, 0.07625920325517654, -0.01996217481791973, 0.01467815786600113, 0.08761198073625565, 0.02736557647585869, 0.035410236567258835, -0.01627616584300995, 0.04782477393746376, 0.04585312679409981, -0.027456264942884445, -0.02495076321065426, 0.0013549545546993613, -0.05501547455787659, 0.018404582515358925, 0.03865174204111099, 0.029134677723050117, -0.02863483503460884, -0.006941576488316059, 0.012449627742171288, 0.02898884192109108, -0.04872383922338486, 0.0277522262185812, 0.039984673261642456, -0.003485583933070302, 0.008091850206255913, 0.07325880974531174, 0.02913803607225418, -0.008274477906525135, 0.032077644020318985, -0.11653268337249756, 0.03290437161922455 ]
130
130
On Probability Distributions for Trees: Representations, Inference and Learning
We study probability distributions over free algebras of trees. Probability distributions can be seen as particular (formal power) tree series [Berstel et al 82, Esik et al 03], i.e. mappings from trees to a semiring K . A widely studied class of tree series is the class of rational (or recognizable) tree series which can be defined either in an algebraic way or by means of multiplicity tree automata. We argue that the algebraic representation is very convenient to model probability distributions over a free algebra of trees. First, as in the string case, the algebraic representation allows to design learning algorithms for the whole class of probability distributions defined by rational tree series. Note that learning algorithms for rational tree series correspond to learning algorithms for weighted tree automata where both the structure and the weights are learned. Second, the algebraic representation can be easily extended to deal with unranked trees (like XML trees where a symbol may have an unbounded number of children). Both properties are particularly relevant for applications: nondeterministic automata are required for the inference problem to be relevant (recall that Hidden Markov Models are equivalent to nondeterministic string automata); nowadays applications for Web Information Extraction, Web Services and document processing consider unranked trees.
[ -0.13309331238269806, 0.011930723674595356, 0.009695340879261494, -0.03839338943362236, 0.0671045333147049, -0.038148220628499985, 0.020244328305125237, 0.006966207642108202, -0.02627883478999138, -0.01181687694042921, -0.00400739349424839, 0.028940843418240547, -0.00598769960924983, 0.07763946056365967, 0.10130228847265244, -0.019095024093985558, -0.06213730201125145, 0.004498286638408899, -0.03620271384716034, -0.010988387279212475, 0.02929992973804474, 0.06483789533376694, 0.0017038930673152208, -0.026523662731051445, 0.04172227159142494, 0.013962319120764732, 0.015677975490689278, -0.01989944651722908, -0.03468165919184685, -0.04328744485974312, -0.039489079266786575, 0.0012536353897303343, 0.022239400073885918, -0.009220311418175697, 0.032764554023742676, 0.021401606500148773, 0.0303039513528347, -0.02536311186850071, -0.11938688904047012, -0.019253358244895935, 0.0031543101649731398, -0.08731608092784882, 0.007834252901375294, -0.022548427805304527, 0.017955923452973366, 0.02227398008108139, 0.02042655274271965, -0.03194182738661766, 0.010040686465799809, 0.03633826971054077, -0.051389195024967194, -0.011921556666493416, 0.00010515916073927656, 0.0016707947943359613, 0.013588210567831993, 0.0968732014298439, 0.009424335323274136, 0.044244132936000824, 0.010624428279697895, 0.018147677183151245, 0.04666025936603546, 0.0683632344007492, -0.014122070744633675, -0.030420534312725067, -0.024703120812773705, -0.01645643077790737, -0.07960247248411179, -0.020735498517751694, -0.043009765446186066, -0.020705627277493477, 0.06006333976984024, 0.001423927373252809, 0.026649078354239464, 0.12734612822532654, -0.0007492348668165505, 0.0004124512488488108, -0.012553327716886997, -0.019007576629519463, -0.013455239124596119, 0.0742417499423027, -0.07413691282272339, 0.04880373924970627, -0.02865620329976082, -0.0444842204451561, -0.05887102335691452, 0.016249559819698334, 0.03808417543768883, -0.030410727486014366, 0.039940349757671356, -0.06618891656398773, -0.05415935069322586, 0.00943094864487648, -0.08901222050189972, -0.006666774395853281, -0.027180446311831474, 0.11286747455596924, -0.03252052515745163, -0.05763190612196922, 0.023683995008468628, 0.03226812556385994, -0.007256707176566124, -0.01646103709936142, 0.06307010352611542, 0.04934991896152496, 0.01166993286460638, 0.05755379796028137, 0.042467858642339706, -0.0012088095536455512, 0.03884419426321983, -0.006595177110284567, 0.0733746886253357, -0.01733209192752838, 0.016781531274318695, 0.02855808101594448, -0.012192691676318645, 0.05584534630179405, 0.024167589843273163, 0.04763641953468323, 0.06188571825623512, 0.051155976951122284, -0.009061885066330433, -0.03259221464395523, -0.006726351100951433, 0.0735538899898529, 0.029523449018597603, -0.03609796613454819, -0.03517158702015877, -0.036172255873680115, 0.05880192667245865, 0.023003336042165756, -0.048346441239118576, 0.011231767944991589, -0.09655066579580307, 0.01660696603357792, -0.03005296364426613, 0.02409178577363491, -0.029229165986180305, 0.01755455881357193, 0.06337819993495941, 0.05529326573014259, 0.020162761211395264, -0.002817396307364106, 0.022221630439162254, -0.026257101446390152, 0.036681849509477615, 0.06722719222307205, -0.009261907078325748, 0.01603393629193306, 0.04316099360585213, -0.01043221540749073, -0.08888549357652664, -0.03754398971796036, 0.009101435542106628, 0.022013863548636436, 0.07842617481946945, 0.007277276366949081, -0.03883226588368416, 0.0021520964801311493, 0.012721624225378036, 0.0283554345369339, -0.04728512465953827, 0.01844766177237034, -0.025545382872223854, 0.08165831118822098, 0.04079914093017578, 0.10125050693750381, -0.0009211929864250124, -0.03436334431171417, 0.030679628252983093, -0.017936812713742256, 0.023995505645871162, 0.015005737543106079, 0.05224571377038956, -0.01467126701027155, 0.010595506057143211, -0.08026392757892609, -0.008687939494848251, -0.005171801894903183, -0.03571255877614021, -0.028011402115225792, 0.052554380148649216, -0.13643203675746918, -0.031109657138586044, 0.006690945941954851, -0.025154100731015205, 0.11220340430736542, 0.009646475315093994, 0.051208533346652985, -0.025921709835529327, 0.017294831573963165, 0.04435642063617706, -0.023270174860954285, 0.016004493460059166, -0.03680826351046562, -0.04343569651246071, -0.0666857585310936, -0.056340593844652176, -0.029591195285320282, -0.012250915169715881, 0.02485082857310772, 0.016293009743094444, 0.02341143973171711, -0.06522724032402039, -0.011093411594629288, -0.036702558398246765, -0.005383456591516733, 0.10612120479345322, -0.00877443142235279, -0.020029772073030472, -0.011740467511117458, -0.0007214536308310926, 0.055286917835474014, -0.042221102863550186, -0.043153174221515656, 0.0259053073823452, 0.007886097766458988, -0.021689390763640404, -0.0490838922560215, 0.060604143887758255, 0.026468578726053238, 0.007069994229823351, 0.024659130722284317, 0.015427634119987488, 0.050391629338264465, -0.018788835033774376, -0.046062447130680084, 0.08489785343408585, -0.05069954693317413, -0.023389490321278572, 0.0336410328745842, 0.011867711320519447, -0.008473292924463749, -0.008220812305808067, -0.032251372933387756, 0.09445630759000778, 0.05910719558596611, -0.024468909949064255, -0.07173945009708405, -0.009052036330103874, 0.01975889690220356, -0.08400239795446396, 0.0780201405286789, 0.007583193946629763, -0.019805334508419037, 0.01714824140071869, -0.02439720183610916, 0.02816588431596756, 0.02232193388044834, -0.041279006749391556, -0.0073968456126749516, 0.011178777553141117, -0.07592760026454926, 0.02326999045908451, -0.08280889689922333, 0.015443144366145134, 0.04153580963611603, -0.013478080742061138, 0.05138011276721954, 0.028430627658963203, 0.011929795145988464, 0.05183391273021698, 0.005672814790159464, -0.028704602271318436, 0.06341664493083954, 0.054222337901592255, 0.06977491080760956, 0.013046901673078537, 0.01625552400946617, 0.008336084894835949, -0.016650507226586342, 0.02508644573390484, -0.0655180886387825, -0.03205472230911255, 0.0948510468006134, -0.0448213592171669, 0.012807657942175865, 0.04452715069055557, -0.04928659647703171, -0.051326196640729904, -0.056301191449165344, -0.019907543435692787, -0.04097488895058632, 0.016724688932299614, -0.042997587472200394, 0.011205749586224556, 0.006989703979343176, -0.004426442552357912, 0.02497047185897827, 0.018130654469132423, 0.06541558355093002, 0.02105860784649849, -0.029320109635591507, -0.017504576593637466, -0.0955100953578949, 0.07419148832559586, -0.018205394968390465, 0.0002622090687509626, 0.007563390769064426, 0.05794954299926758, -0.02151200920343399, -0.040350280702114105, 0.028872672468423843, 0.0542132668197155, 0.05851053074002266, 0.03753272816538811, 0.02225651778280735, 0.03530971333384514, 0.010646418668329716, -0.08107937127351761, -0.010379144921898842, -0.021660257130861282, -0.011956586502492428, -0.040766168385744095, -0.013806660659611225, 0.0055643715895712376, -0.019306886941194534, -0.03759239241480827, -0.07079528272151947, -0.039840925484895706, -0.03600826859474182, 0.04154568910598755, -0.011607375927269459, -0.014231459237635136, -0.022690299898386, -0.0489683672785759, 0.004866200033575296, -0.0030900822021067142, 0.06300757080316544, -0.09206101298332214, 0.02011324092745781, 0.005779063794761896, 0.045732684433460236, 0.024434968829154968, 0.09850423783063889, -0.012907898984849453, 0.06505044549703598, -0.007133371662348509, 0.00023768121900502592, 0.03571844473481178, 0.00001588467785040848, -0.04333837330341339, -0.02657913975417614, -0.02847002074122429, -0.06842978298664093, 0.04334557428956032, 0.02852318435907364, 0.018458278849720955, -0.02543368749320507, 0.035395845770835876, 0.02021840400993824, -0.05188402906060219, 0.08470482379198074, -0.03300309181213379, 0.10755053162574768, 0.011077415198087692, 0.011053798720240593, -0.007699469570070505, -0.05366372689604759, 0.07623205333948135, 0.00374960876069963, 0.027827627956867218, 0.039838388562202454, 0.02552701160311699, 0.006965165492147207, -0.003699218388646841, 0.04145132005214691, -0.02990502305328846, -0.05609668791294098, 0.020987719297409058, 0.004969222005456686, 0.04858725890517235, 0.03042800910770893, 0.013212399557232857, 0.0701809898018837, 0.0016912290593609214, -0.044121623039245605, 0.019631849601864815, -0.04119672253727913, 0.005395684391260147, -0.03860989585518837, -0.058185264468193054, -0.10101640224456787, 0.006017645355314016, -0.0019351515220478177, -0.040994081646203995, -0.12158891558647156, -0.028686201199889183, 0.025378333404660225, 0.054833363741636276, -0.0322672575712204, 0.04633533954620361, -0.0026243177708238363, 0.05593812093138695, 0.02043762616813183, -0.017951080575585365, 0.00542235653847456, 0.02278679795563221, -0.0803447887301445, 0.04245203360915184, -0.058273620903491974, -0.020707152783870697, -0.07430621981620789, 0.0356915146112442, -0.010825728997588158, -0.04318583011627197, 0.07058193534612656, 0.016433335840702057, 0.07307282090187073, -0.02234591543674469, -0.03617553412914276, 0.0518198125064373, 0.07440201938152313, -0.08083795011043549, -0.03954561799764633, 0.06360149383544922, 0.013250553049147129, 0.05004284903407097, 0.006648997776210308, -0.050580620765686035, -0.012171999551355839, -0.004133935552090406, -0.021716399118304253, -0.01684829406440258, -0.05241549015045166, 0.008054808713495731, -0.03899289295077324, 0.05971228703856468, 0.11016616970300674, -0.04203224927186966, 0.05134839937090874, -0.011301081627607346, -0.005434482358396053, -0.11107312142848969, 0.04261099919676781, -0.015577591024339199, -0.01964862272143364, -0.0030896603129804134, -0.07161200046539307, 0.04284699633717537, 0.017916399985551834, -0.030094264075160027, 0.047638680785894394, 0.050018057227134705, -0.006801615469157696, 0.041979677975177765, 0.06519067287445068, 0.014796859584748745, -0.03256800398230553, 0.04744204506278038, 0.00024667245452292264, 0.046428196132183075, 0.019996020942926407, 0.05712658911943436, -0.053236279636621475, 0.0010560991941019893, -0.05650094896554947, -0.021908558905124664, -0.03009766712784767, 0.07825486361980438, -0.0029873137827962637, -0.021579088643193245, 0.035081543028354645, -0.01638508401811123, 0.0561089888215065, 0.0009112519328482449, -0.05673510208725929, 0.07051067799329758, 0.003872075816616416, 0.022326050326228142, 0.019612889736890793, -0.023358849808573723, 0.017470667138695717, 0.03626830875873566, -0.04482106491923332, -0.0014651796082034707, 0.046787988394498825, 0.013491213321685791, 0.013156548142433167, -0.007540772203356028, -0.03669318929314613, 0.027231324464082718, -0.021387696266174316, -0.07876893877983093, 0.03313446789979935, 0.0298226960003376, 0.013944913633167744, 0.028447343036532402, -0.04185007885098457, 0.07806794345378876, -0.03248897194862366, 0.05027911439538002, -0.029505198821425438, -0.016051094979047775, 0.04320455342531204, 0.014523354358971119, 0.09134171158075333, -0.0566227063536644, 0.02266998216509819, -0.03630577772855759, 0.023101769387722015, 0.05217105895280838, -0.08409612625837326, 0.05975561961531639, -0.015539432875812054, 0.056729964911937714, 0.02033757045865059, 0.05199223384261131, -0.07260752469301224, 0.048859208822250366, 0.06421594321727753, -0.02666242979466915, -0.11073201894760132 ]
131
131
Universal Denoising of Discrete-time Continuous-Amplitude Signals
We consider the problem of reconstructing a discrete-time signal (sequence) with continuous-valued components corrupted by a known memoryless channel. When performance is measured using a per-symbol loss function satisfying mild regularity conditions, we develop a sequence of denoisers that, although independent of the distribution of the underlying `clean' sequence, is universally optimal in the limit of large sequence length. This sequence of denoisers is universal in the sense of performing as well as any sliding window denoising scheme which may be optimized for the underlying clean signal. Our results are initially developed in a ``semi-stochastic'' setting, where the noiseless signal is an unknown individual sequence, and the only source of randomness is due to the channel noise. It is subsequently shown that in the fully stochastic setting, where the noiseless sequence is a stationary stochastic process, our schemes universally attain optimum performance. The proposed schemes draw from nonparametric density estimation techniques and are practically implementable. We demonstrate efficacy of the proposed schemes in denoising gray-scale images in the conventional additive white Gaussian noise setting, with additional promising results for less conventional noise distributions.
[ -0.020514898002147675, -0.01939248852431774, 0.029713191092014313, -0.05008462071418762, -0.010237663052976131, 0.017244461923837662, 0.050029218196868896, -0.05930199846625328, -0.04311611130833626, 0.0342634841799736, -0.023604681715369225, -0.009659862145781517, -0.07721316814422607, -0.00946554634720087, -0.027154652401804924, -0.053726598620414734, -0.07222846895456314, 0.026650376617908478, 0.011107808910310268, -0.041121404618024826, -0.043012477457523346, -0.013658374547958374, -0.011343549005687237, -0.05608038604259491, 0.05663852021098137, 0.09208323806524277, -0.00628160685300827, 0.037954509258270264, -0.06518862396478653, -0.043054115027189255, -0.05801783502101898, 0.10958974808454514, 0.0307530015707016, 0.07076039165258408, 0.009150441735982895, 0.004094446077942848, 0.003679704386740923, -0.01885548233985901, -0.03577734902501106, -0.023666176944971085, -0.023910481482744217, -0.018402766436338425, -0.008332555182278156, 0.008608491159975529, 0.012390077114105225, 0.060804784297943115, -0.00904486607760191, -0.08195596188306808, 0.06379377096891403, -0.00735661992803216, -0.02170628309249878, -0.009157773107290268, -0.02548145316541195, 0.03743606060743332, 0.028541645035147667, 0.09677760303020477, -0.08497333526611328, -0.07657598704099655, -0.032735999673604965, -0.023446129634976387, 0.020403660833835602, 0.02559071220457554, -0.03205931559205055, 0.04428258538246155, -0.017675653100013733, -0.04488643631339073, -0.08768955618143082, -0.00193875003606081, -0.0631510391831398, 0.010080160573124886, -0.014263413846492767, -0.0704171434044838, 0.013930789195001125, 0.023182930424809456, -0.013393796049058437, 0.034920185804367065, -0.0034376017283648252, 0.028531670570373535, 0.08218429982662201, 0.13897792994976044, -0.10984601825475693, 0.051273442804813385, -0.035331547260284424, 0.012139618396759033, -0.0014357090694829822, 0.0011802889639511704, -0.033457040786743164, 0.004841523244976997, -0.05277275666594505, -0.01592874526977539, -0.10195787250995636, -0.034611109644174576, -0.016322841867804527, 0.08341152966022491, -0.010360668413341045, 0.11713387072086334, 0.03613470867276192, -0.07576301693916321, -0.04360225796699524, 0.038209185004234314, -0.014520233497023582, 0.015309669077396393, 0.05829973146319389, 0.10497616231441498, -0.036652158945798874, -0.04616037383675575, 0.009934191592037678, -0.013587750494480133, 0.06396740674972534, -0.024168485775589943, 0.00283627538010478, -0.01841716654598713, -0.03617990016937256, -0.08302614837884903, 0.006460356991738081, -0.0038413340225815773, -0.014873076230287552, 0.018774785101413727, 0.026518629863858223, 0.029598858207464218, 0.02961677685379982, -0.030582332983613014, 0.012391592375934124, -0.03227648138999939, 0.060172367841005325, 0.011247788555920124, 0.006621306762099266, -0.034866876900196075, 0.1495126336812973, -0.05083196610212326, -0.0903947651386261, -0.07217296212911606, 0.012076647020876408, -0.02609693817794323, -0.05852622538805008, 0.03426619991660118, 0.06103326752781868, -0.02926415391266346, -0.05033067986369133, 0.07810753583908081, 0.011542923748493195, -0.021792907267808914, -0.017269674688577652, -0.03170746564865112, 0.04080204665660858, 0.05540577694773674, -0.004848959390074015, -0.0036990654189139605, 0.021908404305577278, -0.021881112828850746, 0.001680007204413414, 0.010004469193518162, -0.015479662455618382, 0.005289835389703512, 0.033457014709711075, -0.0990443304181099, -0.041447173804044724, -0.03516141325235367, -0.02664608135819435, 0.08698715269565582, -0.08429290354251862, 0.04072520509362221, 0.029964225366711617, 0.08229219913482666, 0.021206842735409737, -0.046784646809101105, 0.008417055942118168, -0.01580142043530941, -0.03784825652837753, 0.03181416168808937, -0.0787850096821785, 0.048420652747154236, 0.039808906614780426, 0.02199987880885601, -0.009377826005220413, 0.0662192553281784, -0.007739297579973936, 0.02983679249882698, 0.00380156934261322, -0.06005432829260826, 0.0677088275551796, -0.010381365194916725, -0.03492416813969612, 0.06617143005132675, 0.005515941418707371, 0.03310106694698334, -0.07712622731924057, 0.07762071490287781, 0.05232936143875122, 0.029637577012181282, 0.05185306817293167, -0.016004573553800583, -0.022154273465275764, 0.001817455398850143, -0.05149189382791519, 0.07833860069513321, -0.03376317024230957, -0.018278200179338455, -0.01979340985417366, 0.07252629101276398, 0.0745781734585762, -0.025746271014213562, -0.07713203132152557, -0.055967893451452255, -0.08372137695550919, -0.005579375196248293, 0.0301656536757946, 0.010768783278763294, 0.04448958486318588, -0.03980177268385887, -0.03318784758448601, 0.023434365168213844, -0.01879415661096573, -0.042697977274656296, 0.028131043538451195, -0.06714499741792679, 0.010828793980181217, 0.047408558428287506, -0.028620850294828415, 0.04426991194486618, -0.03597504273056984, 0.04420255497097969, -0.055849816650152206, 0.0791909396648407, -0.06551878899335861, 0.0354570634663105, 0.03673752397298813, 0.022939316928386688, -0.06602713465690613, 0.03735404461622238, 0.001496997894719243, -0.00014856591587886214, -0.03209000825881958, -0.058334823697805405, -0.02454945631325245, 0.019269099459052086, -0.039692483842372894, -0.026983201503753662, 0.011315356008708477, -0.03300992399454117, -0.018805701285600662, 0.035697683691978455, 0.017475567758083344, 0.0454690158367157, 0.025528008118271828, 0.011983945965766907, -0.007384858559817076, -0.006134675350040197, 0.011735029518604279, 0.09426548331975937, 0.031354255974292755, 0.004382273647934198, -0.045279745012521744, 0.009254339151084423, 0.0773666724562645, -0.03068608045578003, -0.03495955467224121, 0.0031938340980559587, 0.0409030057489872, 0.012915772385895252, 0.029596103355288506, -0.015806881710886955, -0.07406041026115417, 0.04206112027168274, 0.04360950365662575, 0.0013854296412318945, -0.0431155189871788, -0.03235873579978943, -0.004477169830352068, 0.047271136194467545, 0.045677147805690765, -0.010642637498676777, -0.04585496708750725, 0.029665794223546982, 0.033662039786577225, -0.015790553763508797, 0.047292228788137436, 0.04005778953433037, -0.07408392429351807, 0.030286436900496483, -0.06124022975564003, 0.04752636328339577, -0.05465537682175636, -0.022913364693522453, -0.028811786323785782, 0.013165452517569065, 0.03050936385989189, 0.033836472779512405, -0.021120738238096237, 0.016352713108062744, 0.04699227958917618, 0.0484497956931591, -0.07217022776603699, 0.013191663660109043, 0.014872299507260323, -0.031083550304174423, 0.032238252460956573, -0.10513872653245926, 0.030319709330797195, -0.02001728117465973, 0.008858847431838512, -0.05702575668692589, -0.029778484255075455, 0.018694551661610603, 0.02743685245513916, 0.045393746346235275, 0.04638510197401047, 0.04577180743217468, -0.021288806572556496, 0.03780285269021988, 0.06426440179347992, 0.026413148269057274, -0.06509149074554443, 0.0015320336678996682, -0.01428657304495573, -0.05903937295079231, 0.098133385181427, -0.0015623216750100255, 0.01335235871374607, -0.026286328211426735, -0.0022716224193573, -0.02406487986445427, -0.04221272096037865, -0.02670201286673546, -0.06028785556554794, -0.04993525519967079, -0.045329511165618896, 0.06000003218650818, -0.028960231691598892, -0.018377820029854774, 0.04186449199914932, 0.022950759157538414, -0.01924421265721321, 0.07844164222478867, -0.004452634137123823, 0.040076080709695816, 0.0030923737213015556, -0.007831568829715252, -0.03327096253633499, 0.03972630947828293, -0.0578642301261425, -0.026759352535009384, -0.009585692547261715, -0.04855538159608841, 0.03120112232863903, 0.0505705326795578, 0.11169913411140442, -0.006817762274295092, 0.010553347878158092, 0.027489816769957542, -0.025247221812605858, 0.023111913353204727, 0.0436660572886467, 0.006088232155889273, 0.050423625856637955, 0.07192450016736984, 0.03496157377958298, 0.03350653499364853, -0.0676962286233902, 0.09831506013870239, 0.016475152224302292, 0.031504739075899124, 0.009604064747691154, 0.017476951703429222, 0.03664642199873924, 0.07804882526397705, 0.01079245563596487, -0.03086318075656891, -0.05241606757044792, 0.028218239545822144, -0.03261236101388931, -0.0050731319934129715, -0.003385971998795867, 0.057146698236465454, 0.03810060769319534, 0.010335050523281097, 0.0756361186504364, -0.07808879762887955, -0.081487275660038, -0.004805205389857292, -0.05383453145623207, -0.058578792959451675, 0.07049772143363953, 0.0045111337676644325, -0.04286593198776245, 0.02568514458835125, 0.004487653262913227, -0.008865953423082829, 0.021300220862030983, -0.0541657917201519, -0.056503765285015106, -0.03213886171579361, -0.05239523947238922, 0.0648592859506607, 0.07736728340387344, -0.024265561252832413, 0.005404873285442591, 0.02203446254134178, 0.12909536063671112, -0.013311151415109634, 0.0224508885294199, 0.030216950923204422, -0.02658233419060707, -0.015267249196767807, -0.0938042625784874, 0.004875722341239452, 0.03202676400542259, -0.020170999690890312, -0.00826339703053236, 0.004222279414534569, 0.06763012707233429, 0.009829908609390259, 0.018573438748717308, 0.019751572981476784, 0.024169055745005608, 0.06804894655942917, 0.056391552090644836, 0.004496194422245026, 0.006238625384867191, -0.035344336181879044, -0.0026527270674705505, 0.03967546671628952, 0.01779053919017315, -0.06750448048114777, -0.08047475665807724, -0.016127435490489006, 0.03793950751423836, 0.03629439324140549, -0.06810906529426575, 0.05971929803490639, -0.05173040181398392, -0.07320376485586166, -0.0069429222494363785, 0.024405939504504204, 0.053531378507614136, -0.03355148062109947, 0.059242747724056244, -0.04176179692149162, -0.09010206162929535, 0.010704356245696545, -0.03170754015445709, -0.04581521824002266, -0.03338995575904846, 0.034167952835559845, 0.02632933482527733, -0.017116548493504524, 0.06725471466779709, -0.022597916424274445, 0.037245992571115494, -0.05278729274868965, -0.0028736491221934557, 0.06445374339818954, 0.00029016536427661777, -0.02483675442636013, -0.016136430203914642, 0.005085099954158068, -0.0008453406626358628, 0.00413158955052495, 0.00380606553517282, -0.013941421173512936, -0.02298954501748085, -0.013465611264109612, 0.05228050425648689, -0.03589259088039398, -0.03672410547733307, -0.024724753573536873, -0.011770092882215977, 0.01931098662316799, 0.0255887433886528, 0.06260506063699722, -0.04589251056313515, 0.06285292655229568, 0.026002248749136925, -0.012045538984239101, 0.06848136335611343, -0.012210688553750515, 0.02591954730451107, -0.004634975455701351, 0.02554916776716709, 0.050486452877521515, -0.04655706137418747, 0.057503893971443176, -0.015313523821532726, 0.02992158755660057, 0.06091315299272537, 0.03817874565720558, -0.03396032750606537, 0.03686505928635597, 0.01869557797908783, 0.023753175511956215, 0.08730044960975647, 0.0013861615443602204, -0.031165460124611855, 0.03627161681652069, 0.00042706209933385253, -0.030434589833021164, 0.02851640060544014, 0.027295736595988274, 0.02296307310461998, 0.022382400929927826, 0.020597081631422043, -0.009309983812272549, -0.014645352959632874, 0.02629019320011139, -0.04572751745581627, -0.014003770425915718, -0.03739401325583458, -0.03890317305922508, 0.03484349697828293, -0.007947921752929688, 0.021110432222485542, -0.012972553260624409 ]
132
132
Positive factor networks: A graphical framework for modeling non-negative sequential data
We present a novel graphical framework for modeling non-negative sequential data with hierarchical structure. Our model corresponds to a network of coupled non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) modules, which we refer to as a positive factor network (PFN). The data model is linear, subject to non-negativity constraints, so that observation data consisting of an additive combination of individually representable observations is also representable by the network. This is a desirable property for modeling problems in computational auditory scene analysis, since distinct sound sources in the environment are often well-modeled as combining additively in the corresponding magnitude spectrogram. We propose inference and learning algorithms that leverage existing NMF algorithms and that are straightforward to implement. We present a target tracking example and provide results for synthetic observation data which serve to illustrate the interesting properties of PFNs and motivate their potential usefulness in applications such as music transcription, source separation, and speech recognition. We show how a target process characterized by a hierarchical state transition model can be represented as a PFN. Our results illustrate that a PFN which is defined in terms of a single target observation can then be used to effectively track the states of multiple simultaneous targets. Our results show that the quality of the inferred target states degrades gradually as the observation noise is increased. We also present results for an example in which meaningful hierarchical features are extracted from a spectrogram. Such a hierarchical representation could be useful for music transcription and source separation applications. We also propose a network for language modeling.
[ -0.035149890929460526, -0.03396229445934296, 0.01510441955178976, -0.02048218622803688, 0.06520626693964005, 0.009684531949460506, -0.02420661225914955, 0.01761830784380436, 0.011307195760309696, 0.021623831242322922, -0.0354708656668663, 0.0033168995287269354, -0.0581778921186924, 0.0000443682620243635, -0.034853607416152954, -0.016536930575966835, 0.008248833008110523, -0.038852035999298096, -0.038551170378923416, -0.09672122448682785, -0.052116695791482925, 0.006275201216340065, -0.016145743429660797, -0.0464763343334198, 0.006866652052849531, 0.04609116539359093, -0.09081461280584335, -0.0392514169216156, 0.020107509568333626, -0.027385616675019264, -0.03651903197169304, -0.03214680403470993, 0.07554501295089722, 0.012999087572097778, 0.05771952122449875, 0.04400135204195976, 0.01793164201080799, -0.03159649670124054, -0.05931345000863075, -0.022702867165207863, -0.012585354968905449, 0.007601797580718994, 0.006514459848403931, -0.06449376046657562, -0.010234316810965538, 0.05100660398602486, 0.07263853400945663, -0.01630391739308834, 0.0926310271024704, 0.04208483174443245, -0.06593122333288193, -0.011761966161429882, 0.010646356269717216, -0.030455943197011948, -0.028768742457032204, 0.02627403289079666, -0.029988696798682213, 0.05012986809015274, 0.01974453032016754, -0.008479397743940353, 0.05383174121379852, 0.10385291278362274, -0.042408570647239685, -0.008016778156161308, -0.00158013089094311, -0.022182485088706017, -0.05477995052933693, 0.048539768904447556, -0.05209963023662567, -0.012545802630484104, -0.06496547907590866, 0.04810316115617752, -0.035887572914361954, -0.00204554945230484, 0.03580998629331589, 0.014937187545001507, -0.018254006281495094, 0.01659999042749405, 0.08136821538209915, 0.08363892883062363, -0.07691982388496399, 0.031793948262929916, -0.004984454717487097, -0.027848850935697556, -0.0626642033457756, 0.003152464283630252, -0.02060326188802719, -0.03366401791572571, 0.0681833028793335, -0.003299878677353263, -0.03250756859779358, 0.0373295322060585, -0.06202899292111397, 0.08428636193275452, -0.05214303359389305, -0.019107583910226822, -0.019065530970692635, -0.02213413640856743, 0.005353781394660473, 0.025158897042274475, -0.03378288820385933, -0.026052016764879227, 0.10704213380813599, 0.029979513958096504, -0.05370050668716431, -0.0027657647151499987, 0.0012843126896768808, -0.09028010070323944, 0.07948120683431625, -0.006035604979842901, 0.09751836955547333, 0.03781130909919739, 0.03932873532176018, 0.03427782654762268, -0.06928498297929764, 0.04408137500286102, 0.0022162855602800846, 0.09213337302207947, 0.034782275557518005, 0.011506223119795322, -0.013024881482124329, -0.0033198827877640724, -0.06805624812841415, 0.008364207111299038, 0.04130517691373825, -0.03907974064350128, -0.02853057160973549, -0.01984124816954136, 0.08886634558439255, 0.004515260923653841, -0.06541892141103745, 0.0832328274846077, 0.017008516937494278, 0.01350079569965601, -0.019590899348258972, 0.057848576456308365, -0.026130996644496918, -0.06277058273553848, -0.015166443772614002, 0.007690173573791981, 0.026364203542470932, -0.05236523598432541, -0.010357494466006756, -0.09153871983289719, 0.040649205446243286, 0.08290215581655502, -0.05335010215640068, -0.01546755526214838, 0.009698519483208656, -0.04692201688885689, -0.05688730999827385, -0.08647146821022034, 0.04262571409344673, -0.010743574239313602, 0.03303738683462143, -0.05569181591272354, -0.07083896547555923, -0.08404471725225449, 0.00135056022554636, 0.01651897467672825, -0.10134559124708176, -0.04732275381684303, -0.023300081491470337, 0.0822511538863182, -0.02671085111796856, -0.051699962466955185, -0.06903721392154694, 0.06975773721933365, -0.060972705483436584, -0.005514813587069511, -0.005431443452835083, 0.04494282603263855, -0.039325110614299774, 0.013097248040139675, 0.004266563802957535, -0.047025468200445175, -0.03833827003836632, 0.01178917195647955, 0.005765634588897228, 0.02719740942120552, 0.005004444159567356, -0.046510133892297745, -0.0028671259060502052, 0.016540389508008957, 0.025274449959397316, 0.0475064180791378, -0.07755666971206665, 0.09071771055459976, 0.06371716409921646, -0.0027437873650342226, 0.02768619731068611, 0.06218337267637253, -0.008189881220459938, 0.0003518694138620049, -0.060161739587783813, 0.04083869606256485, -0.0644514411687851, 0.005130041390657425, 0.01063081156462431, 0.09750774502754211, 0.06702454388141632, 0.0277318824082613, -0.020191732794046402, 0.02640399895608425, -0.06763327866792679, -0.05064836144447327, 0.024008087813854218, 0.008516277186572552, -0.01062074676156044, -0.037591710686683655, 0.0442805252969265, -0.018534108996391296, -0.045669399201869965, 0.0363178513944149, -0.008207662962377071, -0.018049508333206177, -0.035777878016233444, -0.060437873005867004, 0.0076315319165587425, 0.08571732044219971, -0.022785380482673645, 0.009739147499203682, -0.06263577938079834, 0.016743134707212448, -0.06244638189673424, -0.03255479782819748, 0.008934739045798779, -0.008284817449748516, -0.0775424912571907, 0.02963734231889248, -0.06125166639685631, -0.06414657086133957, -0.018855681642889977, -0.05513710901141167, 0.05739465728402138, 0.03556780889630318, -0.013768264092504978, 0.043623827397823334, -0.03682887181639671, -0.013053327798843384, -0.049236055463552475, 0.10652962327003479, 0.019007133319973946, 0.05703916400671005, -0.004177264869213104, -0.058215197175741196, -0.007702709175646305, 0.05593348667025566, -0.0067235915921628475, 0.011666582897305489, 0.0019196042558178306, -0.021680202335119247, 0.03748371824622154, 0.05766056478023529, 0.07086646556854248, 0.015538002364337444, -0.05850255861878395, -0.014307620003819466, 0.037579070776700974, 0.006575350649654865, 0.08811989426612854, 0.011812684126198292, -0.037128183990716934, 0.07766371965408325, 0.0438840314745903, 0.020044051110744476, -0.00019876548321917653, 0.029412033036351204, 0.0487193688750267, -0.03414403647184372, 0.033263690769672394, -0.04843365028500557, -0.006010627374053001, 0.01932571269571781, 0.05900361388921738, 0.020080365240573883, 0.033697377890348434, 0.04239019751548767, -0.010487751103937626, -0.0118652218952775, -0.03553637117147446, -0.006193988025188446, -0.0010604027193039656, 0.08949556201696396, 0.005276187788695097, 0.019232414662837982, 0.011692440137267113, 0.007965655997395515, -0.0005258088931441307, 0.0036127676721662283, -0.028707465156912804, -0.03350817412137985, -0.08997607976198196, 0.007933273911476135, 0.06830409914255142, -0.08617407083511353, 0.02922307699918747, 0.0008452614420093596, 0.01295540388673544, -0.037204861640930176, -0.037049949169158936, -0.03505595028400421, 0.09186215698719025, -0.032825008034706116, 0.027099888771772385, 0.022180505096912384, -0.00018629817350301892, 0.04813937470316887, 0.05400289595127106, 0.004242709372192621, -0.039500825107097626, 0.02615986205637455, -0.02596774511039257, 0.019271545112133026, 0.022770443931221962, -0.02928985469043255, -0.025423696264624596, -0.009508680552244186, -0.0729256346821785, 0.02854498103260994, 0.0063864500261843204, 0.021899627521634102, -0.046733055263757706, -0.06664718687534332, -0.04515603929758072, -0.0230764951556921, -0.03335649520158768, 0.09262765198945999, -0.0484754778444767, 0.06403996795415878, -0.009446482174098492, 0.01638553850352764, -0.037483178079128265, 0.1794307976961136, 0.0012122420594096184, -0.026250462979078293, -0.025709407404065132, -0.013899077661335468, -0.021598877385258675, 0.05093011260032654, -0.057689085602760315, -0.07825475186109543, -0.01274292916059494, 0.009571727365255356, -0.008353679440915585, 0.0981673151254654, 0.053946878761053085, -0.02139546163380146, 0.0583978109061718, -0.010333605110645294, -0.014553354121744633, 0.03869200125336647, -0.046928662806749344, 0.0220339335501194, -0.036549363285303116, 0.07666119188070297, 0.09725061804056168, 0.01310250349342823, -0.01553224865347147, -0.008558646775782108, -0.01063490565866232, 0.01742655038833618, 0.034351661801338196, 0.03584098443388939, -0.0017987143946811557, 0.09166619926691055, -0.037072598934173584, -0.03197295218706131, -0.04412143677473068, -0.05738834664225578, 0.08286349475383759, -0.012597061693668365, 0.05864747241139412, 0.000272926758043468, 0.057581957429647446, -0.021301614120602608, 0.03400367125868797, -0.04600133001804352, -0.02494211494922638, -0.013363494537770748, -0.058623384684324265, -0.06823089718818665, -0.011233706027269363, 0.022625446319580078, -0.010509517975151539, -0.04439905285835266, -0.03927657753229141, 0.023917946964502335, 0.03263942152261734, 0.0077002989128232, -0.02340741641819477, -0.007367262151092291, -0.038705043494701385, 0.01991354674100876, -0.013602209277451038, 0.017703400924801826, 0.04781971871852875, 0.033440642058849335, -0.07063841074705124, 0.03349632769823074, -0.024443846195936203, -0.04630318284034729, -0.0771334245800972, -0.04443985968828201, -0.056152213364839554, 0.01448779832571745, -0.01925184763967991, 0.04369314759969711, 0.004401468206197023, 0.06501658260822296, 0.006477546878159046, 0.07100240886211395, -0.000269607495283708, -0.037080999463796616, -0.011623566038906574, 0.015816878527402878, 0.026403354480862617, 0.001221058308146894, -0.015469805337488651, -0.02975701354444027, -0.015367311425507069, -0.03397351875901222, -0.0029907075222581625, 0.04385019838809967, -0.04365312308073044, -0.013455926440656185, 0.038452666252851486, 0.05238589271903038, 0.04433170333504677, 0.034795913845300674, -0.12755142152309418, 0.03578832373023033, -0.013707036152482033, -0.00980608630925417, 0.012813255190849304, -0.028539879247546196, 0.033973682671785355, 0.009432476945221424, 0.03493289649486542, 0.03984019532799721, -0.089816614985466, -0.04186611995100975, 0.024616491049528122, 0.0013878982281312346, 0.018781887367367744, -0.014294263906776905, 0.10863123089075089, -0.05421089380979538, 0.1098521277308464, 0.002980839693918824, 0.0030550516676157713, -0.0003662856761366129, 0.09838663041591644, -0.0022219864185899496, -0.008394556120038033, 0.04123261198401451, -0.008187508210539818, -0.01653183624148369, 0.02393893525004387, -0.010916213504970074, 0.03042197972536087, 0.023575063794851303, 0.04679235443472862, -0.010931377299129963, -0.026170630007982254, -0.05130466818809509, 0.032966699451208115, 0.05645238608121872, 0.0013680735137313604, -0.019070224836468697, -0.04813288152217865, 0.042632799595594406, 0.02314062975347042, 0.013414802961051464, -0.007743006106466055, -0.014643440954387188, 0.06393584609031677, 0.005037522409111261, -0.03346941992640495, -0.07559744268655777, 0.09404613077640533, 0.04394679144024849, -0.021318363025784492, 0.005308999679982662, -0.038940608501434326, 0.07808943092823029, 0.0430247001349926, -0.005258428864181042, -0.0025297862011939287, 0.008740442804992199, -0.023679079487919807, 0.012425302527844906, -0.0037154173478484154, 0.010653501376509666, 0.04553601145744324, -0.03421712666749954, -0.03345676511526108, -0.029792826622724533, 0.022298844531178474, 0.032467134296894073, 0.05994250997900963, 0.03430674970149994, 0.03151953965425491, 0.026543043553829193, 0.03955689072608948, 0.02799193188548088, 0.04728955402970314, 0.027774807065725327, -0.02721489407122135, 0.05443371832370758, -0.008163996040821075, 0.0070616151206195354 ]
133
133
Mutual information is copula entropy
We prove that mutual information is actually negative copula entropy, based on which a method for mutual information estimation is proposed.
[ 0.013880127109587193, 0.007225424982607365, 0.04480390623211861, -0.0003009704523719847, -0.0738242045044899, -0.0711357519030571, 0.06075200065970421, 0.018092911690473557, -0.041821014136075974, -0.016211846843361855, -0.01577853411436081, -0.04014219716191292, -0.08045676350593567, -0.004442015662789345, -0.035657525062561035, -0.02723088674247265, 0.031155778095126152, 0.01920340768992901, 0.036419957876205444, 0.03173637017607689, -0.11127154529094696, 0.0846986249089241, -0.029408752918243408, -0.026529956609010696, -0.046714454889297485, -0.02660386636853218, -0.032282814383506775, 0.0301450714468956, -0.05678735673427582, 0.010385214351117611, -0.05849072337150574, -0.0004167693550698459, 0.049516573548316956, 0.05376724898815155, -0.008275136351585388, -0.0034008591901510954, 0.06200845167040825, 0.005034300498664379, -0.03572583198547363, 0.05293770879507065, 0.005897472612559795, 0.036914438009262085, -0.018551304936408997, 0.01572944037616253, -0.027467286214232445, 0.024873819202184677, 0.07704363018274307, 0.06201869994401932, -0.01716271974146366, 0.04851360619068146, -0.06451653689146042, -0.06267229467630386, 0.02924215979874134, -0.017801012843847275, -0.030951928347349167, 0.018061429262161255, 0.07074299454689026, 0.013059129007160664, 0.04282425343990326, -0.027102814987301826, 0.026184426620602608, 0.11635816097259521, -0.054515138268470764, 0.05790572240948677, -0.024121927097439766, 0.005048725754022598, -0.07763810455799103, 0.026992352679371834, -0.031047983095049858, -0.0395808145403862, -0.005721639841794968, -0.019899267703294754, 0.05199044197797775, 0.004635158460587263, 0.04310280829668045, -0.03435438871383667, 0.003656804095953703, 0.04132046550512314, -0.023769192397594452, 0.0879516750574112, -0.045307792723178864, 0.006992760114371777, -0.02244310826063156, -0.0395466610789299, -0.046356916427612305, 0.016715332865715027, -0.01926584355533123, -0.021289922297000885, 0.03810717910528183, 0.013803216628730297, 0.11130782961845398, 0.006223023869097233, -0.0726768895983696, 0.04821823909878731, -0.0014829731080681086, 0.1008516401052475, -0.01268825214356184, -0.030168617144227028, 0.037754714488983154, -0.03804394230246544, 0.017780736088752747, -0.02114957757294178, 0.01744881458580494, 0.048927441239356995, -0.04739537090063095, 0.020465988665819168, -0.0496387779712677, -0.041162312030792236, 0.04303770512342453, -0.08048538118600845, -0.015489839017391205, -0.037641849368810654, -0.05570514500141144, -0.012052692472934723, -0.052188485860824585, 0.03777819499373436, -0.06453040987253189, 0.008926655165851116, -0.033807411789894104, 0.027010496705770493, -0.0031585886608809233, -0.06601285189390182, 0.03405768796801567, 0.007735047023743391, -0.013191203586757183, -0.014084242284297943, -0.08646069467067719, -0.031628452241420746, 0.08519384264945984, 0.023735173046588898, -0.053851645439863205, 0.016193170100450516, 0.0412478931248188, -0.059102267026901245, 0.0014397486811503768, 0.0786760225892067, -0.036970268934965134, -0.01607096754014492, -0.014218985103070736, 0.00969722494482994, -0.016175026074051857, -0.03532027080655098, -0.02331133373081684, 0.014002062380313873, 0.03308967128396034, 0.09329156577587128, 0.011780004017055035, 0.015440544113516808, -0.018347356468439102, 0.01768861711025238, -0.017117859795689583, 0.03705985099077225, 0.008693589828908443, 0.07613211125135422, -0.015751853585243225, -0.06714309006929398, -0.061508968472480774, -0.01726711168885231, -0.08444248139858246, -0.00003985590592492372, -0.07055942714214325, -0.007701427675783634, 0.04538276791572571, 0.044011056423187256, -0.02044897899031639, -0.010425103828310966, -0.11250744014978409, -0.06013698875904083, 0.07515082508325577, -0.009221554733812809, 0.04700101539492607, 0.028955062851309776, -0.006656702607870102, 0.0007741717272438109, -0.019467024132609367, 0.055088259279727936, -0.053153298795223236, -0.024301761761307716, 0.02634451910853386, 0.02980034239590168, -0.03693264722824097, -0.008772434666752815, -0.03434478119015694, -0.031053317710757256, 0.06848037987947464, 0.08150892704725266, -0.0027247429825365543, -0.02230069600045681, 0.05070818215608597, 0.04416580870747566, 0.09344705194234848, -0.00808537844568491, -0.023846035823225975, -0.013688084669411182, -0.033576346933841705, 0.052005983889102936, -0.03956907242536545, 0.04647325351834297, -0.0026804511435329914, 0.08011790364980698, 0.06409642845392227, 0.03457104414701462, -0.013185066170990467, -0.04272739589214325, -0.034737538546323776, -0.040809378027915955, 0.005028981249779463, -0.008720671758055687, -0.0102483369410038, -0.015980249270796776, 0.0055978368036448956, 0.037073925137519836, 0.04843689501285553, -0.009705829434096813, 0.01719001866877079, -0.01341826468706131, -0.01939444988965988, -0.007117363624274731, -0.007910079322755337, 0.05025685951113701, 0.002865089103579521, 0.01607096754014492, -0.04105044901371002, 0.00030957531998865306, 0.002708200365304947, -0.010777294635772705, 0.0125265596434474, 0.08752115815877914, -0.043392572551965714, -0.004187704995274544, 0.014927919954061508, -0.06505764275789261, -0.03469884768128395, -0.07073679566383362, 0.00410792650654912, 0.03760302811861038, -0.02763131447136402, 0.04783935844898224, -0.044630441814661026, 0.024684911593794823, -0.05133146792650223, 0.02152445539832115, -0.008359534665942192, 0.09655173867940903, -0.043390970677137375, -0.013088345527648926, 0.0005056196241639555, 0.1121893972158432, 0.059656184166669846, -0.04313055798411369, -0.029615171253681183, -0.10027451813220978, -0.028612468391656876, -0.012832600623369217, 0.0012613809667527676, -0.0015239296481013298, -0.048503730446100235, 0.07249545305967331, 0.08742230385541916, 0.04920119419693947, -0.04883192107081413, 0.03286207839846611, -0.051188454031944275, -0.04893944784998894, 0.03833957761526108, -0.0539785660803318, -0.01394989900290966, 0.0019338950514793396, 0.04551323875784874, 0.032400213181972504, -0.02305092103779316, 0.01105799525976181, -0.041684940457344055, 0.029333943501114845, 0.007136040832847357, 0.003047659294679761, 0.04205901548266411, 0.08744151890277863, -0.01306132972240448, -0.04897173494100571, -0.04000959172844887, 0.08470717072486877, -0.05131332203745842, 0.0367741584777832, -0.0022775563411414623, -0.00008458123193122447, -0.0017199072754010558, 0.0436239019036293, 0.03436506167054176, 0.011398454196751118, -0.0352540984749794, 0.06179286167025566, -0.014298629947006702, -0.0007353497785516083, 0.011472596786916256, -0.013636388815939426, -0.018906839191913605, 0.010136139579117298, 0.06565851718187332, -0.0036519349087029696, -0.04155072942376137, 0.006552110426127911, 0.0011315741576254368, -0.04462900757789612, 0.06831708550453186, -0.04340584576129913, 0.1007557213306427, -0.020819788798689842, -0.028166349977254868, -0.023552004247903824, 0.033036306500434875, -0.08203472197055817, -0.0002150551154045388, -0.010694055818021297, 0.08414044976234436, 0.018113724887371063, 0.006600270979106426, -0.04148482531309128, -0.03271038830280304, -0.08951935917139053, -0.005672011990100145, -0.03364625573158264, -0.03289622813463211, -0.10312987118959427, -0.10081655532121658, 0.034934185445308685, -0.026467587798833847, -0.1164083257317543, -0.06678768992424011, 0.024550769478082657, -0.0065818605944514275, -0.00008804986282484606, -0.04336428642272949, 0.07326602190732956, -0.06315309554338455, 0.0019308601040393114, -0.036281343549489975, -0.006296899169683456, 0.03769494593143463, 0.006378545425832272, -0.09841733425855637, -0.05991659313440323, -0.011932357214391232, 0.008020942099392414, 0.011522858403623104, 0.05371575430035591, 0.06089581921696663, -0.018506480380892754, -0.029460549354553223, 0.020566314458847046, -0.050730593502521515, -0.03773070126771927, 0.05250546708703041, 0.005529765039682388, -0.04279116541147232, 0.01595783606171608, 0.07083359360694885, 0.02442609891295433, -0.040244657546281815, -0.004432510118931532, -0.0006934927077963948, 0.0676308274269104, 0.049102138727903366, 0.01533348299562931, 0.10379423946142197, 0.06295564770698547, -0.008168892934918404, -0.059284768998622894, -0.052954789251089096, 0.02924695983529091, 0.022453248500823975, -0.019238626584410667, 0.10072264075279236, -0.021356360986828804, -0.021954966709017754, -0.04379226267337799, 0.05541898310184479, 0.02662254311144352, -0.032909832894802094, -0.03256777673959732, -0.0031847369391471148, -0.016067231073975563, -0.024334313347935677, -0.02098681777715683, -0.05849819630384445, 0.031153639778494835, -0.004217855166643858, 0.07828433066606522, 0.039898861199617386, 0.08127562701702118, -0.029079802334308624, -0.04505020007491112, 0.013996192254126072, 0.043211668729782104, -0.008913980796933174, 0.024956265464425087, -0.004838473163545132, -0.013817157596349716, -0.06835657358169556, -0.08252459764480591, -0.008139543235301971, -0.01108254212886095, 0.003933961037546396, -0.04533340409398079, -0.026994554325938225, -0.0018055557738989592, -0.052705712616443634, -0.004459058400243521, -0.04221323877573013, 0.05190032348036766, -0.0021281384397298098, 0.0071549853309988976, -0.016802581027150154, -0.02556394413113594, 0.04327010363340378, 0.06844409555196762, -0.006994894240051508, -0.060746930539608, 0.0396566241979599, -0.03566819801926613, 0.030152540653944016, -0.00401387270539999, -0.02839728072285652, -0.037653323262929916, -0.0035897663328796625, 0.043932076543569565, 0.0077985492534935474, 0.010378677397966385, 0.030773693695664406, -0.020176758989691734, -0.03904077410697937, -0.023623710498213768, -0.012627817690372467, -0.052464909851551056, 0.04288775473833084, -0.02742352895438671, 0.01199265755712986, 0.04658851772546768, 0.05591646581888199, -0.028068695217370987, -0.05066709220409393, 0.039356689900159836, 0.0342065691947937, 0.09669449180364609, 0.03903650864958763, -0.012908093631267548, 0.0059328265488147736, 0.020445778965950012, 0.09714727848768234, 0.07545819878578186, 0.012628484517335892, -0.029285918921232224, 0.04754532128572464, 0.05412070453166962, 0.05064454302191734, 0.004040821455419064, -0.02247672900557518, -0.058973126113414764, 0.08562075346708298, -0.02301923558115959, -0.06303062289953232, -0.011002764105796814, 0.02555553801357746, 0.012380877509713173, -0.060774680227041245, -0.061938006430864334, -0.01702084019780159, 0.002601739950478077, 0.0837797150015831, -0.05791846662759781, -0.014038615860044956, -0.06156899780035019, 0.06120853126049042, 0.0039259567856788635, 0.021384242922067642, 0.04036205634474754, -0.02267203852534294, 0.03306565806269646, -0.010332250967621803, -0.06871944665908813, 0.013993040658533573, 0.017237495630979538, -0.08115742355585098, -0.009825964458286762, 0.02574044279754162, 0.06969533860683441, -0.019262339919805527, 0.034009795635938644, 0.0527266226708889, 0.004950003232806921, 0.07722773402929306, 0.019060127437114716, -0.0928952768445015, 0.0035114551428705454, 0.0345735102891922, 0.03728724643588066, 0.03242862969636917, 0.006591399200260639, -0.025824224576354027, 0.06813965737819672, -0.010963008739054203, -0.01546395756304264, 0.019145242869853973, 0.03992233797907829, 0.020237592980265617, 0.02427014335989952, 0.052075888961553574, -0.03684433177113533, -0.11071869730949402, 0.06558007001876831, 0.04269324243068695, -0.005136242136359215 ]
134
134
Building an interpretable fuzzy rule base from data using Orthogonal Least Squares Application to a depollution problem
In many fields where human understanding plays a crucial role, such as bioprocesses, the capacity of extracting knowledge from data is of critical importance. Within this framework, fuzzy learning methods, if properly used, can greatly help human experts. Amongst these methods, the aim of orthogonal transformations, which have been proven to be mathematically robust, is to build rules from a set of training data and to select the most important ones by linear regression or rank revealing techniques. The OLS algorithm is a good representative of those methods. However, it was originally designed so that it only cared about numerical performance. Thus, we propose some modifications of the original method to take interpretability into account. After recalling the original algorithm, this paper presents the changes made to the original method, then discusses some results obtained from benchmark problems. Finally, the algorithm is applied to a real-world fault detection depollution problem.
[ -0.014126496389508247, -0.0016772150993347168, 0.057172760367393494, -0.011975296773016453, 0.06807610392570496, -0.07742838561534882, -0.07488720864057541, -0.07668718695640564, -0.004789028316736221, -0.008002297952771187, 0.05168260261416435, -0.012630840763449669, 0.01217731274664402, 0.01849193684756756, -0.03912494331598282, -0.019834229722619057, 0.025204842910170555, -0.013915566727519035, 0.004984573926776648, -0.04751509800553322, 0.010661106556653976, 0.02096523717045784, 0.0115354023873806, -0.09894438087940216, -0.011462793685495853, 0.021314367651939392, -0.009057393297553062, -0.0036163991317152977, -0.03338053449988365, 0.00027192372363060713, -0.07842564582824707, 0.017882104963064194, 0.07797837257385254, 0.017014537006616592, 0.012521706521511078, -0.0028378120623528957, 0.01611434482038021, -0.0009070527157746255, 0.02293877862393856, 0.026046423241496086, 0.014679395593702793, -0.03947973996400833, 0.01296800933778286, 0.04799598827958107, 0.036485012620687485, 0.021044503897428513, 0.02134585566818714, -0.0089665362611413, 0.00026777220773510635, 0.052003610879182816, -0.058144550770521164, 0.05750580504536629, -0.035386133939027786, 0.0029459279030561447, -0.03166954591870308, 0.08009497821331024, 0.0006690031732432544, 0.018274953588843346, 0.0033448105677962303, -0.0028161087539047003, -0.02621643804013729, 0.1183152049779892, 0.049144446849823, -0.06509243696928024, 0.02554403617978096, 0.02885543741285801, -0.0793919637799263, -0.0008110985509119928, -0.012129629962146282, 0.010629434138536453, 0.08451689779758453, 0.0153850968927145, 0.0936501994729042, -0.025678196921944618, 0.07292191684246063, -0.015295608900487423, 0.038149237632751465, 0.014105796813964844, -0.03291638568043709, 0.05466669425368309, -0.05191942676901817, 0.024858584627509117, -0.0163157656788826, 0.004573448095470667, -0.013630082830786705, 0.03642301261425018, 0.018888816237449646, -0.05633574724197388, 0.021544605493545532, 0.044976022094488144, 0.022537976503372192, 0.007203693501651287, -0.011139684356749058, -0.02777988836169243, -0.048093486577272415, 0.024775374680757523, -0.03668537735939026, -0.06274157762527466, 0.006136659532785416, 0.0007665280718356371, 0.017090605571866035, 0.0307233277708292, 0.05389484763145447, 0.028731852769851685, -0.05911911651492119, -0.007296491414308548, -0.06587987393140793, 0.024060871452093124, 0.03931817412376404, -0.01204388402402401, 0.03868268057703972, 0.010516711510717869, -0.002038823440670967, 0.01460537500679493, -0.04280073940753937, 0.03046930395066738, -0.012425223365426064, 0.08852622658014297, 0.019654477015137672, -0.004485465120524168, -0.03531460836529732, 0.0471133291721344, 0.05125078186392784, -0.03463897481560707, 0.0551176555454731, -0.02209683507680893, -0.013287295587360859, -0.0732128694653511, 0.08984510600566864, 0.006713439244776964, -0.12154657393693924, 0.07253191620111465, -0.03660299628973007, 0.03819432854652405, -0.013902462087571621, 0.029009876772761345, -0.006239416543394327, 0.028307219967246056, 0.006068893242627382, 0.00800000037997961, -0.06286915391683578, 0.06750550866127014, -0.033107392489910126, -0.039181169122457504, 0.0030785833951085806, -0.017977289855480194, -0.029643578454852104, -0.023559313267469406, -0.0440552644431591, -0.0891217440366745, -0.009447265416383743, 0.02857024036347866, 0.028771212324500084, 0.003913243766874075, 0.030590059235692024, -0.034425389021635056, -0.008602944202721119, -0.01883159764111042, -0.05404507368803024, 0.05060328543186188, 0.015421675518155098, -0.020969519391655922, -0.042970139533281326, -0.03086615353822708, 0.07098998129367828, 0.007903628051280975, -0.02239115722477436, -0.08195836842060089, -0.02042859047651291, -0.0690317153930664, -0.007960074581205845, -0.005213407799601555, 0.00940653495490551, 0.03855503350496292, 0.05261071026325226, -0.05129697173833847, -0.02686755545437336, -0.0025884192436933517, -0.056158095598220825, -0.03375856205821037, -0.021249089390039444, -0.0686083734035492, -0.005394432693719864, 0.024352455511689186, 0.01830865442752838, 0.07439374923706055, 0.026768675073981285, 0.05693524703383446, 0.007665314245969057, -0.002257048850879073, 0.05502597242593765, 0.06295838207006454, -0.0029373401775956154, 0.009615760296583176, -0.018131665885448456, 0.025481577962636948, -0.039481814950704575, -0.009701439179480076, 0.012089896015822887, 0.07147976756095886, 0.0628947988152504, 0.04672468453645706, -0.02005738951265812, -0.046555325388908386, -0.036122675985097885, -0.015235129743814468, 0.031099222600460052, -0.021609211340546608, 0.033922117203474045, 0.024378495290875435, 0.04117441177368164, -0.025754626840353012, 0.017346810549497604, 0.01364259235560894, 0.026571404188871384, -0.047129880636930466, -0.028997331857681274, -0.027582798153162003, 0.09638117998838425, 0.040432900190353394, -0.009342172183096409, 0.025665106251835823, -0.006588009186089039, 0.039499688893556595, -0.06238897144794464, 0.03304283320903778, 0.049820829182863235, -0.010970423929393291, -0.035656530410051346, 0.014749749563634396, 0.01854059286415577, -0.04659074917435646, -0.06243789941072464, 0.028925824910402298, 0.16034556925296783, 0.08054768294095993, 0.030429746955633163, -0.004099266603589058, -0.0364345982670784, -0.02810751460492611, 0.008599238470196724, 0.04676928371191025, -0.01781737245619297, -0.029997387900948524, -0.005575754214078188, -0.036722179502248764, -0.002877409104257822, 0.05458630248904228, 0.006739582866430283, -0.08974999189376831, -0.034627657383680344, -0.04113997891545296, -0.025812193751335144, 0.00017234038386959583, 0.06180056929588318, 0.0823776125907898, -0.05633135139942169, -0.04218010604381561, 0.05566715449094772, 0.05159425735473633, -0.01349588856101036, 0.025750741362571716, -0.02748509682714939, -0.03946038708090782, -0.005514140240848064, -0.03531892970204353, -0.05621238797903061, 0.04761195927858353, -0.02598673477768898, 0.007023517042398453, -0.010768539272248745, -0.034593455493450165, 0.011653943918645382, 0.07709407806396484, -0.07598342001438141, 0.014590897597372532, 0.0017928923480212688, 0.04435066506266594, 0.05357801541686058, -0.00941199716180563, -0.07929763197898865, -0.01763746328651905, 0.021587353199720383, 0.06708593666553497, -0.05221592262387276, 0.04362446069717407, 0.06361263990402222, -0.019545655697584152, 0.0021724430844187737, -0.027432652190327644, -0.09771019220352173, 0.007212337572127581, -0.0604533925652504, -0.020787741988897324, 0.02561468444764614, -0.11829237639904022, 0.07489417493343353, 0.019112609326839447, 0.01703467406332493, -0.013329572044312954, 0.038679562509059906, -0.02139803022146225, 0.03597049415111542, -0.004394401330500841, -0.01178637146949768, -0.0011977050453424454, 0.048808470368385315, 0.06942036002874374, 0.0010511359432712197, -0.0369611456990242, 0.030469102784991264, -0.06444905698299408, 0.020978396758437157, -0.011043315753340721, 0.0005791871226392686, -0.08696714788675308, -0.04921767860651016, -0.06503207981586456, -0.05914593115448952, -0.06607505679130554, -0.029960274696350098, 0.013630205765366554, 0.05798013508319855, -0.027545008808374405, -0.01688361167907715, -0.011539540253579617, -0.045336414128541946, 0.003252617781981826, -0.12050560116767883, 0.059537794440984726, -0.10244130343198776, 0.025545241311192513, -0.021269191056489944, 0.03278965502977371, -0.09867940098047256, -0.05729389563202858, -0.05358879268169403, -0.033100444823503494, -0.015435374341905117, 0.02920120768249035, -0.04449514299631119, -0.08688303828239441, -0.0011372048174962401, -0.005723229609429836, 0.016730012372136116, -0.06783340126276016, 0.012755226343870163, 0.006897208746522665, -0.04757411405444145, 0.01806333288550377, -0.02792237140238285, -0.020312143489718437, -0.06202785670757294, -0.02337563782930374, 0.03847983852028847, 0.05974513292312622, 0.005651210434734821, -0.02620118111371994, 0.022195719182491302, 0.08806834369897842, 0.029676400125026703, 0.05471816286444664, -0.0007135968189686537, -0.04512619599699974, 0.014337384141981602, 0.06292826682329178, -0.0005323772202245891, 0.058869149535894394, -0.04969172924757004, 0.062970831990242, 0.04238792508840561, 0.04271099343895912, 0.08634962141513824, -0.023532724007964134, 0.023182637989521027, 0.01795407570898533, 0.06531883776187897, -0.03675959259271622, -0.04091629758477211, 0.022488657385110855, -0.0900070071220398, -0.050645072013139725, -0.020517969503998756, -0.019237777218222618, -0.06892582774162292, -0.05260608717799187, -0.08870840072631836, 0.005705724935978651, 0.02054978534579277, -0.023072950541973114, -0.021993977949023247, 0.003040358889847994, 0.007107947953045368, 0.017377471551299095, 0.03676203638315201, 0.07137135416269302, -0.02554740197956562, 0.0060837771743535995, -0.050732869654893875, 0.006525850854814053, -0.04476568102836609, -0.0460607185959816, -0.053699176758527756, -0.06301765143871307, -0.12024924904108047, 0.03627434000372887, 0.024097008630633354, 0.1200510561466217, 0.005516052711755037, 0.05500704050064087, -0.05741354078054428, 0.040428515523672104, 0.0077161844819784164, -0.02624203823506832, -0.001988622359931469, 0.019678296521306038, -0.03190670907497406, -0.02549741044640541, -0.01846909336745739, -0.023372892290353775, -0.02356426790356636, 0.02878403663635254, 0.028007913380861282, -0.034616559743881226, -0.016156399622559547, 0.054025035351514816, 0.04771644249558449, 0.0534539520740509, 0.026691464707255363, 0.13262656331062317, -0.04047105833888054, -0.07684224843978882, -0.10857583582401276, 0.016948549076914787, -0.01709420047700405, -0.003619710449129343, 0.010936177335679531, -0.02923080511391163, 0.014661912806332111, 0.04946209117770195, -0.06230102851986885, -0.02252943255007267, -0.013662545010447502, 0.021626664325594902, 0.08642924576997757, 0.019969401881098747, 0.011732446029782295, 0.0005519501864910126, 0.05544859915971756, -0.005792558658868074, 0.01864153891801834, 0.030230233445763588, 0.04240349307656288, -0.014740661717951298, -0.033776137977838516, -0.009706726297736168, -0.018435800448060036, 0.00435389019548893, 0.05480824410915375, -0.044449638575315475, -0.027659161016345024, 0.043545305728912354, -0.008727889508008957, 0.039061617106199265, -0.047983475029468536, -0.01759832352399826, -0.033743858337402344, 0.0398838073015213, 0.08439251035451889, -0.007012254558503628, 0.015136543661355972, 0.03852798789739609, 0.050434403121471405, -0.05697105452418327, -0.02310924418270588, -0.01614893600344658, 0.09202384948730469, -0.08530683815479279, -0.07990124076604843, -0.03514229878783226, 0.015628427267074585, 0.09140223264694214, 0.05520302802324295, 0.03807015344500542, 0.02754811942577362, 0.0318719781935215, -0.05714396387338638, 0.008224891498684883, 0.03732449188828468, -0.02325400896370411, 0.03142918646335602, -0.033814527094364166, 0.009778755716979504, 0.0016393883852288127, 0.08707642555236816, 0.004013328813016415, -0.03897152841091156, -0.0664069652557373, 0.04463906213641167, 0.015248824842274189, 0.02270536497235298, -0.01680375263094902, -0.0208187997341156, 0.0027153382543474436, 0.055556461215019226, 0.07230081409215927, 0.05477600544691086, -0.056901879608631134, 0.0037703244015574455, 0.02284700609743595, -0.04090789332985878, 0.03595591336488724 ]
135
135
Multi-Instance Multi-Label Learning
In this paper, we propose the MIML (Multi-Instance Multi-Label learning) framework where an example is described by multiple instances and associated with multiple class labels. Compared to traditional learning frameworks, the MIML framework is more convenient and natural for representing complicated objects which have multiple semantic meanings. To learn from MIML examples, we propose the MimlBoost and MimlSvm algorithms based on a simple degeneration strategy, and experiments show that solving problems involving complicated objects with multiple semantic meanings in the MIML framework can lead to good performance. Considering that the degeneration process may lose information, we propose the D-MimlSvm algorithm which tackles MIML problems directly in a regularization framework. Moreover, we show that even when we do not have access to the real objects and thus cannot capture more information from real objects by using the MIML representation, MIML is still useful. We propose the InsDif and SubCod algorithms. InsDif works by transforming single-instances into the MIML representation for learning, while SubCod works by transforming single-label examples into the MIML representation for learning. Experiments show that in some tasks they are able to achieve better performance than learning the single-instances or single-label examples directly.
[ -0.017352376133203506, -0.08011061698198318, -0.007848142646253109, 0.02201496623456478, 0.05142580345273018, -0.06487203389406204, -0.03886435553431511, -0.0013628075830638409, -0.01493682712316513, -0.007925963029265404, -0.047887738794088364, 0.03192723169922829, -0.009023770689964294, 0.021663615480065346, 0.06547463685274124, 0.07523808628320694, -0.013720721937716007, -0.006621822714805603, -0.026799313724040985, -0.020999448373913765, -0.005478228442370892, -0.03422030434012413, 0.03277457505464554, -0.06974329054355621, 0.059892814606428146, 0.025180846452713013, -0.029606210067868233, -0.021019311621785164, -0.02973252721130848, -0.06442740559577942, 0.00620778976008296, -0.0013715014792978764, 0.010267182253301144, 0.001617091940715909, -0.04284960404038429, 0.027277464047074318, -0.009171053767204285, -0.015107734128832817, -0.10625983774662018, -0.05581017583608627, -0.011295904405415058, -0.016763079911470413, 0.0152152543887496, 0.034864142537117004, 0.10157986730337143, 0.10694528371095657, 0.024843011051416397, -0.030761558562517166, 0.0009830159833654761, 0.12221810221672058, -0.10878275334835052, 0.054215483367443085, -0.049582723528146744, 0.025218093767762184, 0.0493314303457737, 0.017079316079616547, -0.02057659439742565, -0.009545031934976578, 0.000042232208215864375, 0.012436678633093834, 0.016358017921447754, 0.048250630497932434, -0.0117839016020298, 0.016142085194587708, -0.0481361448764801, 0.002715438138693571, 0.027162840589880943, -0.044369783252477646, -0.04853138327598572, -0.0328550711274147, -0.022986391559243202, -0.12670254707336426, 0.012935573235154152, 0.04155677556991577, 0.07398925721645355, 0.029094688594341278, 0.006320875138044357, 0.020123567432165146, 0.013710943050682545, 0.032389286905527115, -0.02216118946671486, -0.03844257816672325, -0.028899060562253, 0.016885269433259964, -0.0009076498099602759, -0.02030593901872635, -0.0210463535040617, 0.00905733834952116, 0.047071896493434906, 0.027444439008831978, 0.008521288633346558, -0.013224220834672451, -0.0760699063539505, 0.054888345301151276, 0.0018895725952461362, 0.035494476556777954, -0.014977485872805119, -0.0719807967543602, -0.06665646284818649, 0.00380324712023139, 0.03204933553934097, 0.016414616256952286, 0.0199644286185503, 0.03924502059817314, -0.06592844426631927, 0.002159037161618471, 0.004376373719424009, 0.06973959505558014, 0.044009823352098465, -0.011172502301633358, 0.033670470118522644, 0.004259609617292881, 0.05571902170777321, 0.03438199311494827, 0.0023041495587676764, 0.026652315631508827, -0.02937900461256504, 0.041796647012233734, 0.06127862259745598, -0.03369037061929703, -0.017541715875267982, -0.03440804407000542, -0.036040663719177246, 0.03522535413503647, 0.05846240743994713, -0.055567726492881775, -0.07052984088659286, -0.04124553129076958, 0.12319200485944748, -0.08517029881477356, -0.008532020263373852, 0.032049648463726044, -0.028486646711826324, 0.04010898619890213, -0.01119975931942463, 0.015507440082728863, 0.027001114562153816, -0.0708378255367279, -0.0875605046749115, 0.010717272758483887, 0.05633433535695076, 0.02036348730325699, 0.004282344598323107, -0.012527517974376678, 0.02802276238799095, 0.00807203259319067, -0.059178512543439865, 0.02198018692433834, 0.03209847956895828, -0.010227682068943977, -0.07463614642620087, -0.049399424344301224, 0.07119796425104141, -0.0017143908189609647, 0.014992058277130127, -0.07298983633518219, 0.035067204385995865, -0.012309500016272068, 0.01330566592514515, 0.006958336103707552, -0.022843001410365105, 0.05217142775654793, 0.058528363704681396, 0.039606038480997086, 0.0009379254188388586, 0.03749628737568855, -0.008667818270623684, -0.0228047426789999, -0.06895039975643158, -0.005574685055762529, -0.013603290542960167, 0.002111047739163041, 0.016909874975681305, 0.015748122707009315, 0.0005828550201840699, -0.05374157056212425, -0.0670396164059639, 0.04869671165943146, -0.016856618225574493, 0.0010739731369540095, -0.0181747917085886, 0.003596464404836297, 0.002751684281975031, -0.011619986034929752, 0.033815253525972366, 0.044194165617227554, -0.021828075870871544, 0.032484862953424454, 0.02710709162056446, 0.04926292970776558, -0.00687312800437212, -0.017670856788754463, 0.05179521441459656, -0.0016103140078485012, -0.04444257542490959, 0.06393700838088989, -0.03686097636818886, 0.001650992431677878, 0.0005933918873779476, -0.01668340340256691, -0.02464098297059536, -0.047234129160642624, -0.01707788184285164, -0.09279204905033112, -0.06322578340768814, 0.04402900114655495, 0.02503587305545807, -0.029740698635578156, -0.11809022724628448, -0.03234153613448143, -0.018795059993863106, 0.007253804709762335, 0.03301281854510307, 0.008810530416667461, -0.03962843492627144, -0.04493653029203415, 0.04075027257204056, -0.051735568791627884, 0.08879492431879044, 0.09556597471237183, 0.043469734489917755, 0.010184790007770061, -0.034082479774951935, 0.04849784076213837, -0.04031140357255936, 0.006641448941081762, 0.0519881509244442, -0.030714308843016624, -0.04970819130539894, 0.0025710046757012606, 0.009088519960641861, -0.05596195161342621, -0.12945397198200226, -0.031110916286706924, 0.01682332716882229, -0.01879330351948738, -0.07953370362520218, -0.03986714407801628, 0.02190309576690197, -0.029424428939819336, 0.03237941116094589, 0.02022203989326954, -0.03394826874136925, -0.04287863150238991, 0.016241565346717834, -0.020268982276320457, 0.032587066292762756, -0.025065671652555466, -0.03068649210035801, 0.02155567891895771, 0.023772036656737328, 0.04619278386235237, 0.0372922345995903, -0.004982212092727423, 0.028725536540150642, -0.06836795061826706, 0.011475866660475731, 0.08150877058506012, 0.04567793756723404, 0.08846230804920197, 0.007201021071523428, 0.03446318209171295, -0.016854122281074524, -0.0025223856791853905, 0.05240972340106964, 0.03156353905797005, 0.026719750836491585, -0.013180866837501526, 0.00901321042329073, -0.010712703689932823, -0.0693879947066307, -0.012309443205595016, -0.010367642156779766, 0.026318958029150963, -0.02599221281707287, 0.039629507809877396, -0.03154958784580231, 0.0898275077342987, 0.042318131774663925, -0.06861750036478043, -0.05740253999829292, 0.029518011957406998, -0.02631126344203949, -0.06450141221284866, -0.04664573445916176, -0.045047543942928314, 0.0675235465168953, -0.06026598811149597, -0.01017746701836586, 0.04388660192489624, -0.009143369272351265, 0.046911437064409256, -0.057506367564201355, -0.0009240072104148567, 0.023803792893886566, -0.06502168625593185, 0.00679364800453186, 0.013601154088973999, 0.0327443927526474, 0.023809032514691353, 0.04959812015295029, 0.04096582531929016, 0.08221534639596939, 0.06841714680194855, -0.003927236422896385, 0.09038431942462921, -0.0037950496189296246, 0.09756278991699219, -0.033659230917692184, -0.043275151401758194, 0.012752695009112358, 0.015090425498783588, 0.0018042812589555979, -0.014249999076128006, 0.008695405907928944, -0.0007834207499399781, 0.03862756863236427, -0.011308957822620869, -0.06485819071531296, -0.01696319505572319, 0.01674816943705082, -0.0008290116675198078, -0.00314619904384017, -0.0009703306714072824, -0.100995272397995, -0.034718215465545654, -0.03147267550230026, -0.006643325090408325, -0.08835144340991974, 0.005781437736004591, -0.04802672937512398, -0.014082285575568676, 0.015114769339561462, 0.047417789697647095, 0.013609014451503754, -0.02658723294734955, -0.0049720387905836105, -0.003593209432438016, -0.07279623299837112, -0.04005247727036476, -0.09646658599376678, -0.009409741498529911, -0.06819142401218414, -0.020221812650561333, -0.00465136906132102, 0.005174029618501663, 0.027777161449193954, 0.051870234310626984, 0.013118370436131954, 0.03980338200926781, -0.06655742973089218, 0.043987907469272614, -0.04730241745710373, 0.058010123670101166, -0.017888693138957024, -0.031125405803322792, 0.0645703375339508, -0.05114739388227463, -0.045974407345056534, 0.04732012003660202, 0.06542415171861649, 0.042924799025058746, -0.007105855271220207, -0.004320281557738781, 0.00476165721192956, 0.03168043866753578, -0.07236529141664505, 0.09367355704307556, -0.05791029706597328, -0.008817801252007484, -0.015268557704985142, 0.049107909202575684, -0.021000929176807404, -0.005904605612158775, 0.018474087119102478, -0.00704546645283699, -0.00022951785649638623, -0.024486221373081207, -0.08079879730939865, 0.05640968680381775, -0.059884946793317795, -0.04796471446752548, -0.07759532332420349, 0.0011730203405022621, -0.04877704381942749, -0.01408039778470993, -0.0396076962351799, 0.006191741209477186, 0.02882695011794567, 0.014103113673627377, -0.04784015566110611, -0.0022665453143417835, -0.02507159672677517, -0.01617434062063694, 0.04259214550256729, 0.0769897848367691, -0.06359650939702988, -0.05141102150082588, -0.058112021535634995, 0.005231989547610283, 0.04348629340529442, 0.0190278310328722, 0.04091741517186165, -0.10181833058595657, -0.03429453447461128, 0.016073046252131462, -0.03301205486059189, 0.08381102234125137, -0.022343255579471588, 0.02036188915371895, 0.041943710297346115, 0.05843714252114296, -0.004857328720390797, -0.013923839665949345, 0.019226688891649246, 0.0006739189266227186, 0.04281759634613991, 0.049627937376499176, 0.019201133400201797, -0.06525502353906631, 0.01378896925598383, 0.036021627485752106, 0.05787395313382149, -0.0351545475423336, 0.004195323679596186, 0.03174978494644165, 0.013695068657398224, 0.1140749603509903, 0.020412418991327286, 0.07594987750053406, -0.1000136286020279, 0.012097443453967571, -0.1135987862944603, -0.027377087622880936, -0.023166976869106293, 0.05200500413775444, 0.04722476378083229, 0.07115157693624496, -0.004790010862052441, 0.0564010888338089, -0.037689659744501114, 0.029649855569005013, 0.07746928930282593, 0.05468497425317764, 0.016047082841396332, 0.08440014719963074, -0.014366037212312222, 0.010400544852018356, 0.07892458140850067, 0.039071954786777496, 0.007582241669297218, -0.0077679771929979324, 0.028441879898309708, -0.04928886890411377, -0.02887880802154541, -0.009973333217203617, -0.02498982846736908, 0.0011507658055052161, -0.01269310712814331, -0.034205030649900436, 0.020172305405139923, -0.05518333613872528, 0.07052457332611084, 0.03638548403978348, -0.056826457381248474, 0.025277283042669296, 0.09337292611598969, 0.035121168941259384, -0.00401334697380662, 0.015507818199694157, -0.05959233269095421, 0.021163733676075935, 0.002613085089251399, -0.019005075097084045, 0.00621451111510396, 0.05244419723749161, 0.0008629046496935189, -0.13224640488624573, 0.0637846365571022, 0.02680639736354351, 0.05958227813243866, 0.020937394350767136, -0.041038453578948975, 0.037929680198431015, -0.01757286861538887, 0.04032234475016594, -0.019444720819592476, -0.01392187550663948, -0.0683569610118866, 0.037895381450653076, 0.025559742003679276, -0.019752249121665955, 0.05453287437558174, 0.05775501951575279, -0.06785045564174652, -0.05256883427500725, 0.04282592236995697, -0.006959181744605303, -0.021952832117676735, -0.008076910860836506, 0.022453540936112404, -0.05007859691977501, 0.0328482985496521, -0.014180165715515614, 0.06334603577852249, -0.015727106481790543, 0.07258889824151993, 0.0137429628521204, -0.03730997070670128, 0.047171756625175476, -0.04601840302348137, 0.051615387201309204 ]
136
136
A game-theoretic version of Oakes' example for randomized forecasting
Using the game-theoretic framework for probability, Vovk and Shafer. have shown that it is always possible, using randomization, to make sequential probability forecasts that pass any countable set of well-behaved statistical tests. This result generalizes work by other authors, who consider only tests of calbration. We complement this result with a lower bound. We show that Vovk and Shafer's result is valid only when the forecasts are computed with unrestrictedly increasing degree of accuracy. When some level of discreteness is fixed, we present a game-theoretic generalization of Oakes' example for randomized forecasting that is a test failing any given method of deferministic forecasting; originally, this example was presented for deterministic calibration.
[ -0.08746813982725143, -0.036124736070632935, 0.0035622993018478155, -0.05368894711136818, -0.0009305955609306693, 0.005557795986533165, 0.04836422950029373, -0.008738573640584946, 0.006866678595542908, 0.022051576524972916, -0.03792704641819, -0.06838501244783401, -0.02835773676633835, 0.060900695621967316, 0.07993830740451813, -0.026780419051647186, -0.013849681243300438, 0.087213434278965, -0.029730679467320442, -0.058453332632780075, -0.00467553548514843, -0.02566261775791645, 0.08097279816865921, -0.0027441156562417746, -0.05128799378871918, -0.041555266827344894, 0.06593706458806992, -0.01902923546731472, -0.04129515960812569, -0.01945769041776657, -0.08891856670379639, 0.05297527462244034, -0.013774195685982704, -0.009341347962617874, 0.05731477588415146, 0.03251209110021591, -0.01757355034351349, -0.0600866861641407, -0.09750103950500488, -0.052874695509672165, 0.02472924441099167, -0.04479391127824783, 0.03065352700650692, 0.00477487500756979, -0.0031565073877573013, 0.0314316526055336, -0.013632903806865215, 0.011666730046272278, 0.012938449159264565, 0.0033660647459328175, -0.039107102900743484, -0.008976484648883343, -0.0024441606365144253, -0.0522189661860466, -0.026525793597102165, 0.04907377436757088, -0.06063336879014969, 0.0736822783946991, -0.009435279294848442, 0.018976856023073196, -0.03861822187900543, 0.055253662168979645, 0.012978401966392994, -0.03046439029276371, 0.000909492839127779, -0.04519544914364815, -0.0196909848600626, -0.033003728836774826, 0.07306493818759918, -0.031937938183546066, 0.031404122710227966, -0.03273926302790642, 0.017680861055850983, 0.0017863826360553503, 0.03188253939151764, 0.024157263338565826, -0.04454110935330391, 0.004025797359645367, -0.04194825887680054, 0.08001609146595001, 0.01737765409052372, 0.019637824967503548, 0.04055061936378479, 0.025218412280082703, 0.0027354969643056393, -0.0026144501753151417, -0.022508827969431877, -0.008666560053825378, 0.0073802354745566845, -0.08002025634050369, -0.060158051550388336, 0.05795535817742348, -0.020157940685749054, 0.05799729749560356, 0.04029099643230438, 0.06534548103809357, 0.005600627511739731, -0.03817010670900345, -0.038439687341451645, 0.04755450040102005, 0.03626691550016403, -0.001984758535400033, 0.029417525976896286, 0.03879719227552414, -0.047339048236608505, 0.04263204708695412, 0.006322536151856184, -0.00026698512374423444, 0.039600592106580734, -0.014205309562385082, 0.039172541350126266, -0.07202103734016418, 0.038731783628463745, 0.01164676621556282, -0.04092000797390938, 0.15419842302799225, 0.023938922211527824, -0.0033933159429579973, 0.05874701216816902, -0.045394379645586014, 0.09171631932258606, 0.03787583112716675, 0.006008272524923086, 0.02900470793247223, -0.0024456284008920193, -0.003177455859258771, 0.020798197016119957, -0.03198474273085594, 0.058041855692863464, -0.07455602288246155, -0.01267596147954464, 0.01832958124577999, -0.09532488882541656, -0.00002441744254610967, -0.028958987444639206, 0.03615512326359749, 0.023976070806384087, 0.09598800539970398, -0.07971007376909256, 0.014685592614114285, -0.014706246554851532, -0.07117508351802826, -0.003311891108751297, 0.04928292706608772, -0.018505537882447243, 0.00793096236884594, -0.0019449632382020354, 0.009236044250428677, -0.09398990124464035, 0.015908103436231613, -0.0038688110653311014, -0.02844839356839657, 0.015497321262955666, 0.04836678132414818, 0.026223018765449524, 0.013411936350166798, -0.05189124122262001, 0.05871135741472244, -0.10606390982866287, 0.11066430807113647, -0.007268070243299007, -0.04289240762591362, 0.03669093921780586, 0.06745606660842896, -0.008529316633939743, 0.032818663865327835, -0.0021754044573754072, 0.0506431944668293, -0.07773425430059433, -0.06604810059070587, 0.01939401589334011, -0.03889119252562523, 0.0031082266941666603, -0.03390666842460632, -0.021849708631634712, -0.02699759602546692, 0.052470579743385315, 0.008741348050534725, 0.008323729038238525, -0.05039689689874649, 0.024227267131209373, -0.036106277257204056, -0.03566834330558777, 0.006581310648471117, 0.02086230181157589, 0.12336845695972443, -0.04356781765818596, 0.023174354806542397, 0.033513814210891724, 0.025392699986696243, 0.0003170725249219686, 0.01912393793463707, -0.08344141393899918, -0.07221604883670807, -0.008947506546974182, -0.05402525141835213, -0.07201166450977325, -0.03745083883404732, 0.01540875993669033, 0.06780251115560532, -0.009528527967631817, -0.010128716006875038, -0.08809808641672134, 0.03900414705276489, -0.05695342645049095, 0.024254726245999336, -0.01243741624057293, -0.03430263698101044, -0.008230076171457767, -0.027804244309663773, 0.0031439417507499456, -0.06081319972872734, -0.06795769184827805, -0.05702735111117363, 0.024301035329699516, -0.06242366135120392, -0.043100278824567795, -0.11130480468273163, 0.06150312349200249, -0.010514682158827782, -0.027740823104977608, 0.041579097509384155, -0.021637195721268654, 0.030240459367632866, -0.11964400112628937, -0.04408136382699013, -0.0007352686952799559, 0.054899927228689194, -0.031995050609111786, 0.04005260393023491, -0.05400027707219124, -0.03763183578848839, 0.022284992039203644, 0.022075001150369644, -0.06649661809206009, 0.05577961355447769, 0.015744024887681007, -0.05222822725772858, -0.025102650746703148, 0.011960622854530811, -0.030954284593462944, -0.06341905891895294, 0.014899245463311672, -0.012272384017705917, 0.023482931777834892, -0.06323713064193726, 0.012789906933903694, 0.004096076823771, -0.03399810567498207, 0.025603199377655983, 0.06823625415563583, -0.027717942371964455, 0.016421932727098465, -0.045232780277729034, 0.03205849602818489, -0.0009963582269847393, -0.010476955212652683, 0.06831034272909164, 0.053136326372623444, -0.029737435281276703, 0.04122227430343628, 0.03846028074622154, -0.033583346754312515, 0.02741987816989422, 0.02334502339363098, 0.0825854167342186, -0.048295628279447556, -0.012421938590705395, -0.006409034598618746, 0.002734330017119646, 0.015878910198807716, 0.015168264508247375, -0.05863974243402481, 0.09610078483819962, 0.001012084074318409, -0.031432006508111954, 0.057067230343818665, 0.012153668329119682, 0.049013324081897736, -0.04433630034327507, 0.036632537841796875, 0.1289137750864029, -0.07168839871883392, -0.025125373154878616, 0.08530844748020172, -0.027548164129257202, 0.003576885908842087, 0.014143557287752628, -0.0712197870016098, -0.01764504425227642, -0.04205078259110451, -0.02183004468679428, 0.0015269702998921275, -0.02229955978691578, 0.04705977812409401, -0.0250332560390234, 0.03405527397990227, 0.0024305095430463552, 0.04306818172335625, 0.021578127518296242, -0.027424203231930733, 0.05683375149965286, 0.006451572757214308, 0.0508418008685112, -0.0039597563445568085, 0.03726005554199219, 0.0412585586309433, 0.03444388136267662, 0.02223617024719715, -0.014986897818744183, 0.033901844173669815, -0.021302588284015656, -0.0012596111046150327, -0.023324932903051376, -0.04958071932196617, -0.0314629040658474, -0.02721572108566761, -0.07459503412246704, 0.030612388625741005, 0.012807062827050686, 0.026097210124135017, -0.036184363067150116, 0.019400708377361298, 0.04477635398507118, -0.04960738867521286, 0.011854060925543308, 0.015592770650982857, 0.026145046576857567, -0.03426862880587578, -0.02995799109339714, -0.028860468417406082, 0.017868153750896454, 0.017942925915122032, 0.09672414511442184, -0.049821700900793076, 0.02641216665506363, -0.0164811909198761, -0.038826242089271545, 0.027452366426587105, 0.05380992218852043, -0.008036159910261631, -0.04795241728425026, -0.03870673477649689, -0.01855582743883133, 0.005824722349643707, 0.04915667697787285, 0.11684302985668182, 0.02446797303855419, -0.010857969522476196, -0.05348700284957886, -0.037390366196632385, -0.023078089579939842, 0.020237138494849205, 0.03192645683884621, -0.0012497303541749716, 0.07689708471298218, -0.023894328624010086, -0.03656300902366638, -0.017484357580542564, 0.08456674218177795, -0.022684575989842415, 0.007208135910332203, -0.006571708247065544, -0.06260591745376587, 0.057882752269506454, 0.06518298387527466, 0.03211335465312004, -0.039728082716464996, -0.03200678899884224, -0.05636649206280708, -0.029915591701865196, 0.0531047061085701, 0.02008878067135811, 0.0743761956691742, -0.009505153633654118, -0.005958608817309141, 0.007229724898934364, -0.043971993029117584, -0.04848993197083473, 0.06520681828260422, 0.03276016190648079, 0.015888215973973274, -0.05630114674568176, -0.04192453622817993, 0.00012174562289146706, -0.03567918762564659, -0.04962288588285446, -0.03996201604604721, 0.020178550854325294, 0.030005833134055138, -0.019141821190714836, -0.033920105546712875, -0.03353149816393852, 0.037803564220666885, 0.0444614440202713, 0.011699981987476349, 0.0776682198047638, -0.06975177675485611, -0.019609902054071426, 0.006813921965658665, -0.01927310600876808, -0.07406139373779297, 0.025033483281731606, 0.051138736307621, -0.07674764096736908, 0.01167737040668726, 0.03710045665502548, 0.030074775218963623, 0.01731274090707302, 0.05222342163324356, -0.022722143679857254, 0.04972626268863678, 0.0000850435535539873, -0.02429702691733837, -0.017139634117484093, 0.036286331713199615, 0.06760476529598236, -0.03522692993283272, -0.05188749358057976, 0.0049062869511544704, -0.015756968408823013, 0.02122586779296398, 0.012253286316990852, -0.015688611194491386, 0.021551216021180153, -0.0725928246974945, 0.036596350371837616, 0.03620593249797821, -0.03772098943591118, 0.036565233021974564, -0.05337240546941757, -0.020405568182468414, -0.10382407903671265, -0.05662306770682335, -0.04769619554281235, -0.10993770509958267, -0.038210414350032806, -0.07091925293207169, -0.04596586152911186, 0.05639452487230301, -0.09479943662881851, -0.03205926716327667, -0.014085549861192703, 0.06354878842830658, -0.01574265956878662, 0.02885415591299534, 0.013065533712506294, -0.014332854188978672, -0.004498704802244902, 0.006797153502702713, 0.02597397193312645, 0.07298643887042999, 0.005392500199377537, -0.06609847396612167, 0.05490046367049217, 0.054578591138124466, 0.02575605735182762, 0.00850647408515215, 0.02391946129500866, 0.010549183003604412, -0.06996900588274002, -0.0862237960100174, -0.03021697886288166, 0.057719431817531586, -0.05731867253780365, -0.013442599214613438, -0.021693317219614983, -0.04683581739664078, 0.06264478713274002, -0.06106417998671532, -0.027460262179374695, 0.07856115698814392, -0.047820501029491425, -0.03708652779459953, 0.020296994596719742, -0.04167948663234711, 0.06227540969848633, -0.016405275091528893, 0.04618844762444496, -0.012774523347616196, 0.09083970636129379, 0.021286679431796074, -0.04389225319027901, -0.011743278242647648, 0.09523805230855942, 0.03979334980249405, -0.030259285122156143, -0.016208158805966377, -0.008486618287861347, 0.0471697673201561, -0.005015950184315443, 0.0419900082051754, 0.0377190075814724, -0.023812320083379745, 0.08373743295669556, 0.03474646434187889, 0.030252870172262192, 0.030604291707277298, -0.008786515332758427, 0.01520418468862772, -0.047813136130571365, 0.03437555208802223, -0.009475992992520332, -0.035197772085666656, 0.03429033234715462, 0.014834064990282059, -0.04552231356501579, -0.0018254885217174888, -0.005977187771350145, 0.008114631287753582, -0.0034939248580485582, 0.03298186883330345 ]
137
137
A Variational Inference Framework for Soft-In-Soft-Out Detection in Multiple Access Channels
We propose a unified framework for deriving and studying soft-in-soft-out (SISO) detection in interference channels using the concept of variational inference. The proposed framework may be used in multiple-access interference (MAI), inter-symbol interference (ISI), and multiple-input multiple-outpu (MIMO) channels. Without loss of generality, we will focus our attention on turbo multiuser detection, to facilitate a more concrete discussion. It is shown that, with some loss of optimality, variational inference avoids the exponential complexity of a posteriori probability (APP) detection by optimizing a closely-related, but much more manageable, objective function called variational free energy. In addition to its systematic appeal, there are several other advantages to this viewpoint. First of all, it provides unified and rigorous justifications for numerous detectors that were proposed on radically different grounds, and facilitates convenient joint detection and decoding (utilizing the turbo principle) when error-control codes are incorporated. Secondly, efficient joint parameter estimation and data detection is possible via the variational expectation maximization (EM) algorithm, such that the detrimental effect of inaccurate channel knowledge at the receiver may be dealt with systematically. We are also able to extend BPSK-based SISO detection schemes to arbitrary square QAM constellations in a rigorous manner using a variational argument.
[ 0.01897537335753441, 0.03952176123857498, -0.004130702931433916, 0.07229599356651306, 0.015601202845573425, -0.016226202249526978, -0.027042390778660774, -0.030116353183984756, 0.015025647357106209, -0.03654705360531807, 0.0391857847571373, -0.01168516930192709, 0.00680906604975462, -0.06600191444158554, 0.048125579953193665, -0.046620361506938934, 0.018746227025985718, 0.018830329179763794, -0.00036193960113450885, 0.011189053766429424, 0.0004912199219688773, -0.03189340606331825, 0.008420513942837715, -0.02142365090548992, 0.06744761765003204, 0.001321987365372479, -0.00177798664662987, -0.030794227495789528, -0.0021450163330882788, 0.03748567774891853, -0.12313906103372574, 0.020214762538671494, 0.048721134662628174, -0.007809020578861237, -0.019725505262613297, -0.11216982454061508, -0.018349269405007362, -0.11488492041826248, 0.0038924440741539, -0.012864659540355206, -0.02988787367939949, -0.022726571187376976, 0.04114222154021263, 0.01579790562391281, 0.021105989813804626, 0.02341805025935173, -0.009704685769975185, 0.016081638634204865, 0.0046682823449373245, 0.017239633947610855, -0.07409918308258057, 0.015946796163916588, -0.02262728661298752, 0.04390927776694298, 0.04762892425060272, 0.032292746007442474, 0.03198716416954994, -0.03526400029659271, -0.034878380596637726, -0.024627702310681343, 0.012422699481248856, 0.11532553285360336, -0.02516411803662777, 0.0026636975817382336, -0.042389608919620514, 0.023874560371041298, -0.05785410478711128, 0.011479017324745655, -0.04760744795203209, 0.006593279540538788, -0.050741471350193024, -0.07947549968957901, -0.01593683287501335, -0.017804736271500587, 0.012073676101863384, 0.011683815158903599, 0.1047862246632576, -0.007118995301425457, 0.04120340570807457, 0.03188006952404976, -0.050115328282117844, 0.02387871779501438, -0.02760295383632183, 0.045119497925043106, -0.01921839453279972, 0.008291389793157578, -0.038895152509212494, 0.012793008238077164, 0.036731455475091934, -0.016781756654381752, 0.0036038619000464678, -0.04421545937657356, -0.06563255935907364, 0.00515776127576828, 0.004081695806235075, -0.023862561210989952, 0.01696353405714035, -0.021474696695804596, -0.0521046407520771, 0.008619742467999458, 0.051761213690042496, 0.051788900047540665, 0.02915285713970661, 0.15692608058452606, -0.06256961822509766, -0.01855984516441822, -0.001271488843485713, 0.045181047171354294, -0.04380323365330696, -0.06108400225639343, 0.022165849804878235, -0.005902591627091169, 0.02175925113260746, 0.0071442085318267345, 0.04140596464276314, 0.0822734385728836, 0.0011807503178715706, 0.03290367126464844, 0.10627240687608719, 0.026536544784903526, 0.02996017225086689, -0.009746907278895378, -0.04805693030357361, -0.008479144424200058, -0.002222810173407197, -0.03716380149126053, -0.02584660053253174, -0.09872893244028091, 0.10340878367424011, 0.08486514538526535, -0.06339647620916367, 0.0014485171996057034, -0.014878380112349987, 0.029291696846485138, -0.002653569681569934, 0.05017664656043053, -0.07028031349182129, 0.01119331456720829, 0.000980100128799677, 0.08303971588611603, -0.007202284410595894, 0.002651113783940673, -0.037728406488895416, 0.01004116702824831, 0.02777215838432312, -0.053989894688129425, 0.021348601207137108, 0.043018169701099396, -0.07031109184026718, -0.007119323126971722, -0.00829475000500679, -0.08645394444465637, 0.041171442717313766, 0.08969437330961227, -0.029631908982992172, -0.03995990753173828, -0.03405909985303879, 0.035890329629182816, -0.023871958255767822, 0.08507693558931351, -0.0003207992995157838, -0.009024569764733315, 0.10572537779808044, 0.11110571771860123, 0.010389198549091816, 0.018932007253170013, -0.019382495433092117, 0.04803129658102989, -0.02777729369699955, 0.028877118602395058, -0.0175237525254488, -0.0038755389396101236, 0.0012624391820281744, 0.007818362675607204, 0.03798260912299156, 0.030860958620905876, 0.025759510695934296, 0.009130684658885002, 0.005926793906837702, -0.005736075341701508, 0.002470576437190175, -0.06326791644096375, -0.01673576980829239, 0.05109730735421181, 0.0862872302532196, 0.03544372320175171, -0.05693218111991882, -0.0013992467429488897, 0.0703812688589096, -0.009311779402196407, 0.009819099679589272, 0.08222570270299911, -0.006630641408264637, -0.008926231414079666, 0.0463404543697834, 0.039824116975069046, 0.02386491186916828, 0.0581318661570549, -0.07290870696306229, -0.004186330363154411, 0.035475559532642365, -0.08293458074331284, -0.004621948581188917, -0.023604072630405426, -0.04428127780556679, 0.0011015220079571009, 0.04154256358742714, -0.03667091205716133, 0.06256631016731262, 0.053953927010297775, -0.008310194127261639, -0.0009245551191270351, 0.04950900375843048, 0.036312732845544815, 0.05594383180141449, -0.017146382480859756, -0.033796004951000214, -0.11212670803070068, -0.04864959418773651, 0.01609717682003975, 0.005301032681018114, 0.05033602565526962, -0.0015259961364790797, 0.0018766457214951515, -0.049785107374191284, -0.0495179146528244, -0.004193841479718685, 0.022630387917160988, -0.09515416622161865, -0.0020708462689071894, -0.06562411785125732, -0.034123219549655914, -0.11555081605911255, -0.015145733952522278, -0.002096099080517888, 0.03891493007540703, -0.09667777270078659, -0.06581857800483704, 0.07040847092866898, -0.055235009640455246, 0.0036007382441312075, 0.041217975318431854, -0.03375663608312607, 0.06987754255533218, 0.07311496138572693, -0.010347153060138226, 0.03199416771531105, 0.09814463555812836, 0.020083783194422722, 0.06828583031892776, -0.049038372933864594, -0.0037630642764270306, -0.04142314940690994, 0.002835514722391963, 0.02775406464934349, -0.01958942413330078, 0.018545396625995636, -0.016792988404631615, -0.02345399744808674, 0.09394479542970657, 0.030158180743455887, 0.02145959436893463, 0.008792063221335411, 0.003780724247917533, 0.030945641919970512, 0.0070040528662502766, 0.010173866525292397, -0.024796459823846817, -0.022215694189071655, -0.03927622362971306, -0.06039116531610489, -0.045076340436935425, -0.020151184871792793, 0.01566125452518463, -0.03866254910826683, -0.04090956598520279, 0.004794931970536709, 0.04437338933348656, 0.02556537836790085, -0.023951662704348564, -0.04712686315178871, -0.011923848651349545, 0.04922401160001755, -0.05543314293026924, 0.0017071750480681658, -0.10276559740304947, -0.0020175522658973932, 0.0060796961188316345, -0.020604757592082024, 0.03610602021217346, -0.023599663749337196, 0.007164075970649719, -0.08420731872320175, -0.0026629671920090914, 0.0023490379098802805, -0.016924967989325523, -0.05540119484066963, 0.06166814640164375, 0.0011088689789175987, -0.042198002338409424, -0.06214692071080208, 0.02368082106113434, -0.007715668994933367, 0.015452373772859573, -0.00512134563177824, 0.040585894137620926, 0.06863891333341599, 0.042735420167446136, 0.008945869281888008, 0.02941029705107212, 0.02451525814831257, 0.02344531938433647, -0.04166066274046898, 0.015071341767907143, 0.037818025797605515, 0.007847271859645844, -0.0018535321578383446, -0.07717376202344894, -0.06544920802116394, -0.0718734934926033, 0.02595296874642372, -0.02415420673787594, 0.008018760941922665, -0.08342006802558899, -0.01351200696080923, 0.009915572591125965, -0.1019158586859703, 0.00016699818661436439, -0.07618938386440277, 0.04566984996199608, -0.06374825537204742, -0.023168934509158134, 0.019351540133357048, 0.10070732980966568, -0.026362696662545204, -0.03468521684408188, 0.04564444348216057, -0.042310357093811035, 0.005822619888931513, 0.013173677958548069, 0.013208596967160702, -0.07453151047229767, 0.007258422207087278, 0.018352828919887543, -0.034775879234075546, -0.001207346678711474, 0.08452131599187851, 0.041956909000873566, -0.0555582195520401, 0.02920772321522236, -0.033700160682201385, 0.01698445901274681, -0.025700032711029053, -0.03006458654999733, -0.06642172485589981, 0.06261833757162094, -0.015770791098475456, 0.00048672521370463073, -0.05167442560195923, 0.07105185836553574, -0.020763207226991653, 0.005008936859667301, -0.023371074348688126, -0.0016561219235882163, 0.013709253631532192, 0.06042749807238579, -0.033432893455028534, 0.025120804086327553, 0.021538550034165382, 0.030974652618169785, -0.061491888016462326, 0.07350517809391022, 0.007027330342680216, -0.030320674180984497, -0.00015465715841855854, -0.027128878980875015, 0.011255725286900997, -0.08386771380901337, -0.016728602349758148, -0.0012653813464567065, -0.009977223351597786, 0.014109168201684952, -0.03159195929765701, 0.014185796491801739, -0.04359138384461403, -0.025315023958683014, -0.026043450459837914, 0.022588318213820457, -0.0031588494312018156, 0.023514043539762497, -0.029213154688477516, 0.04058707132935524, 0.02114105224609375, 0.08291343599557877, 0.026695506647229195, -0.0013102063676342368, -0.06446745246648788, -0.01615733839571476, -0.06371760368347168, 0.07727640122175217, -0.00926858838647604, -0.012590333819389343, -0.030167143791913986, -0.014721119776368141, -0.013786613941192627, -0.032112158834934235, 0.01760903373360634, -0.007319370750337839, -0.043345578014850616, 0.06377235054969788, 0.06022411957383156, -0.09079120308160782, 0.00017021149687934667, 0.011978904716670513, -0.040105707943439484, 0.0659303292632103, -0.015937870368361473, 0.04791448637843132, 0.00034822849556803703, -0.028027748689055443, 0.05378146469593048, 0.027169547975063324, 0.037751659750938416, -0.06570132076740265, -0.022430017590522766, 0.01573801599442959, 0.048599354922771454, 0.00991558376699686, -0.10090389102697372, -0.014579685404896736, -0.03428865969181061, -0.048541124910116196, -0.044859353452920914, -0.035984255373477936, 0.05788426101207733, 0.0002839711669366807, 0.06818123906850815, -0.1184740662574768, 0.04707729443907738, 0.013224550522863865, 0.003983944188803434, 0.029625924304127693, 0.05088305473327637, 0.0221396591514349, -0.005115095060318708, -0.04275486618280411, 0.015653446316719055, -0.014818503521382809, 0.0908069759607315, 0.02023998461663723, 0.010934349149465561, 0.042986419051885605, 0.0019500982016324997, -0.011975022964179516, 0.021475963294506073, 0.08543728291988373, -0.04328424111008644, -0.054961107671260834, 0.055669814348220825, -0.020259074866771698, -0.05058300122618675, -0.02885294146835804, 0.0786137580871582, -0.03379220888018608, -0.020595017820596695, -0.04223000258207321, -0.0016624005511403084, -0.02096697688102722, -0.011443176306784153, -0.04797680303454399, -0.05174627527594566, -0.02915097400546074, 0.06220699101686478, -0.01091815810650587, 0.011567356064915657, 0.047098007053136826, -0.014040346257388592, 0.04582643136382103, 0.04456431791186333, -0.021465575322508812, 0.07574070245027542, -0.02630847692489624, -0.006666925270110369, 0.07829222083091736, 0.08303935825824738, 0.0797135978937149, -0.07656916975975037, 0.027036143466830254, 0.033302102237939835, -0.019059376791119576, 0.037317804992198944, -0.010272333398461342, -0.018048394471406937, -0.03919880464673042, 0.00004036399332107976, 0.07350896298885345, -0.04135947301983833, 0.047624096274375916, 0.07665278017520905, -0.029796062037348747, 0.05066410079598427, -0.010565285570919514, 0.03676261380314827, -0.014952589757740498, -0.008225804194808006, 0.06895948201417923, 0.0005526388413272798, 0.03709282726049423, -0.0698792040348053, -0.014192825183272362, -0.050838369876146317, -0.0338355228304863 ]
138
138
A Uniform Approach to Analogies, Synonyms, Antonyms, and Associations
Recognizing analogies, synonyms, antonyms, and associations appear to be four distinct tasks, requiring distinct NLP algorithms. In the past, the four tasks have been treated independently, using a wide variety of algorithms. These four semantic classes, however, are a tiny sample of the full range of semantic phenomena, and we cannot afford to create ad hoc algorithms for each semantic phenomenon; we need to seek a unified approach. We propose to subsume a broad range of phenomena under analogies. To limit the scope of this paper, we restrict our attention to the subsumption of synonyms, antonyms, and associations. We introduce a supervised corpus-based machine learning algorithm for classifying analogous word pairs, and we show that it can solve multiple-choice SAT analogy questions, TOEFL synonym questions, ESL synonym-antonym questions, and similar-associated-both questions from cognitive psychology.
[ -0.020896507427096367, 0.03481752425432205, 0.08559887856245041, 0.07608014345169067, 0.056926608085632324, -0.06216725707054138, -0.07880260795354843, -0.021175574511289597, -0.020834770053625107, -0.010322186164557934, 0.013815565966069698, -0.03510507196187973, 0.022507425397634506, 0.022494787350296974, -0.013116870075464249, -0.00015464899479411542, -0.05149461701512337, -0.08214573562145233, -0.019106080755591393, -0.07643260806798935, 0.0008331553544849157, -0.006906410213559866, 0.032742299139499664, -0.07728816568851471, 0.017426470294594765, -0.07562941312789917, -0.09695109724998474, -0.02426763065159321, -0.035211097449064255, -0.03187800571322441, 0.016482045873999596, -0.05896211043000221, 0.06988318264484406, 0.0015877808909863234, 0.007954739965498447, 0.0615055151283741, -0.027125868946313858, -0.018358880653977394, -0.07394357770681381, -0.03427176922559738, -0.02827094867825508, 0.005403616465628147, -0.010773963294923306, 0.07110398262739182, 0.07456620037555695, 0.07063999027013779, 0.03855369612574577, -0.02196718379855156, 0.023631077259778976, 0.0691569447517395, -0.07677530497312546, -0.004445391241461039, 0.040998704731464386, -0.009755048900842667, 0.025139693170785904, 0.027469931170344353, 0.017354251816868782, -0.006898405030369759, 0.003119116183370352, 0.028675789013504982, 0.039337705820798874, 0.08295289427042007, -0.017078250646591187, 0.00975299533456564, -0.05337915197014809, 0.020818373188376427, -0.0695333182811737, -0.022124750539660454, 0.07423553615808487, -0.00343595864251256, 0.015928631648421288, -0.03606444224715233, 0.0013149309670552611, -0.011189975775778294, 0.09111640602350235, 0.0748712569475174, 0.003884926438331604, -0.014517600648105145, -0.013141491450369358, 0.05692927911877632, -0.014912785962224007, -0.02120090276002884, -0.020230580121278763, -0.039566535502672195, -0.07023973017930984, -0.014936598017811775, 0.0648379698395729, -0.037341587245464325, -0.0029210513457655907, -0.005714671686291695, -0.07572664320468903, -0.05965825170278549, -0.08167768269777298, 0.018758120015263557, 0.016251251101493835, 0.04423599690198898, 0.04525570198893547, -0.084846630692482, 0.01006599422544241, 0.019198592752218246, 0.012195233255624771, 0.028461981564760208, 0.04458140954375267, 0.03371024131774902, -0.07239221781492233, 0.0289057157933712, -0.02023647539317608, 0.037713706493377686, 0.0327492393553257, 0.06342195719480515, -0.015981651842594147, 0.018234970048069954, -0.023090574890375137, -0.006634300574660301, 0.007501231040805578, 0.057177506387233734, -0.022803019732236862, 0.11729660630226135, -0.01619749143719673, -0.06130436807870865, -0.10904043167829514, -0.026352573186159134, -0.032909877598285675, 0.02841261588037014, -0.0436088852584362, -0.08427370339632034, -0.0030744648538529873, -0.004565333016216755, 0.07666416466236115, -0.017182597890496254, -0.09434399008750916, 0.001883824123069644, -0.07168105244636536, 0.014069341123104095, -0.040685076266527176, 0.007815679535269737, 0.034947313368320465, -0.011630075983703136, -0.0444849468767643, 0.009199059568345547, 0.03363196551799774, -0.0006822098512202501, -0.01947956718504429, 0.006918259896337986, 0.022305794060230255, 0.008847629651427269, -0.0023684438783675432, -0.09064669162034988, 0.05609435960650444, -0.019696351140737534, -0.015405440703034401, -0.03666890412569046, 0.05236835777759552, 0.07191042602062225, 0.04822888597846031, -0.012271652929484844, -0.0014062434202060103, -0.025653425604104996, 0.01171067077666521, 0.05728784576058388, -0.014141248539090157, 0.018632598221302032, 0.04336800053715706, 0.010968944057822227, -0.0063911061733961105, 0.03516926243901253, -0.02169378660619259, -0.033519115298986435, 0.013351790606975555, -0.11761559545993805, -0.048137109726667404, 0.025099843740463257, -0.07696472108364105, 0.02616387978196144, -0.06207720935344696, -0.07298103719949722, -0.059834934771060944, 0.019752616062760353, -0.020378176122903824, 0.03706449642777443, -0.005919677205383778, -0.09029533714056015, -0.006097447592765093, 0.018175840377807617, 0.02173801138997078, 0.10957025736570358, 0.002857233863323927, 0.11791452020406723, -0.0511745885014534, -0.03349184989929199, 0.026797257363796234, 0.005840776488184929, 0.004219400230795145, 0.042172934859991074, -0.05399353429675102, -0.05304689705371857, -0.029222307726740837, 0.06087382137775421, -0.005685531534254551, 0.02591194584965706, 0.009006001986563206, -0.013971497304737568, 0.0007469054544344544, -0.046167708933353424, -0.04714428260922432, -0.015929291024804115, 0.02824040874838829, -0.028573807328939438, -0.005654019769281149, -0.0032171658240258694, 0.02033253386616707, 0.08043225854635239, -0.007568993605673313, 0.03595562279224396, 0.001750671654008329, -0.011053839698433876, -0.051020342856645584, -0.061449937522411346, 0.028089161962270737, 0.034697212278842926, -0.01237323135137558, 0.001653176499530673, 0.009883728809654713, 0.04948911443352699, -0.02476523257791996, 0.020233523100614548, 0.01367411483079195, -0.004553790669888258, 0.00013421764015220106, -0.0009550515096634626, -0.09321744740009308, -0.05879848450422287, -0.11993522942066193, -0.10847065597772598, 0.05991103872656822, 0.0034299406688660383, -0.0011443806579336524, -0.022024264559149742, 0.028058534488081932, -0.015446944162249565, 0.006596124265342951, 0.030613955110311508, 0.011388184502720833, -0.009645616635680199, -0.03281733766198158, -0.044198356568813324, 0.019513040781021118, -0.0572751984000206, -0.009583152830600739, -0.04234306514263153, 0.0204158965498209, -0.07654798775911331, 0.014758837409317493, -0.024227021262049675, -0.005700159352272749, 0.013371622189879417, -0.03204864263534546, 0.0355154313147068, -0.013843657448887825, 0.03172556683421135, 0.009705768898129463, 0.10437621921300888, -0.007565374951809645, -0.018216155469417572, 0.058161329478025436, -0.022163162007927895, -0.005121849477291107, 0.02579895593225956, -0.015438653528690338, -0.01612708903849125, -0.07297534495592117, -0.06532970815896988, -0.020476728677749634, 0.00847094040364027, -0.09251703321933746, 0.01057366468012333, 0.0559820681810379, 0.029240887612104416, -0.01452375017106533, -0.037135716527700424, -0.07834071666002274, 0.007364213932305574, -0.006917694117873907, 0.0041250139474868774, -0.05307524651288986, -0.00035761171602644026, -0.004213414620608091, -0.03478825464844704, -0.02434193529188633, -0.03336571156978607, -0.07720661908388138, 0.047378070652484894, -0.04935112223029137, 0.019154006615281105, 0.021398084238171577, -0.09654182195663452, -0.01349515002220869, 0.029879802837967873, 0.049865081906318665, -0.00804708432406187, -0.026750249788165092, 0.06775010377168655, 0.030505074188113213, 0.02355424128472805, 0.01862790808081627, 0.044718172401189804, 0.019847817718982697, 0.04471156373620033, -0.03684249147772789, -0.00844090897589922, 0.004490699153393507, -0.049251772463321686, -0.009039903059601784, 0.02213224023580551, -0.04288158193230629, -0.047181423753499985, -0.0314658023416996, 0.022505275905132294, -0.08796653151512146, 0.052697546780109406, 0.060054078698158264, 0.006545946002006531, 0.04141636937856674, 0.027429718524217606, -0.0424523651599884, -0.03464273735880852, 0.010359283536672592, -0.023872848600149155, -0.10965227335691452, 0.04247533157467842, 0.016898421570658684, 0.02560359239578247, 0.09065179526805878, 0.09943807125091553, 0.0037156608887016773, 0.04244156926870346, 0.010585579089820385, 0.04641079530119896, -0.026797769591212273, 0.030700132250785828, -0.08210300654172897, 0.00482554268091917, 0.020568562671542168, 0.10028208047151566, 0.015453115105628967, -0.025531070306897163, 0.046434637159109116, 0.019364457577466965, -0.019959967583417892, -0.03641786798834801, -0.06772848218679428, -0.010284182615578175, -0.08798521757125854, 0.0253109410405159, 0.012606251053512096, 0.01535396184772253, 0.03163755685091019, -0.05373578146100044, -0.04293861240148544, 0.0284440815448761, 0.06843304634094238, 0.07885893434286118, -0.04909423738718033, -0.012605861760675907, -0.02036410942673683, 0.008619272150099277, -0.033842723816633224, -0.04282580688595772, -0.07397661358118057, -0.04221443831920624, 0.0002603747707325965, 0.02118314988911152, -0.007577806245535612, -0.048904333263635635, -0.052187539637088776, -0.026491587981581688, 0.0410798005759716, 0.010894975624978542, -0.02239343896508217, 0.027745800092816353, -0.022269049659371376, -0.037990469485521317, -0.05020377039909363, 0.0454971119761467, -0.013681107200682163, 0.030264724045991898, -0.05109677463769913, 0.0010706526227295399, 0.04933863505721092, 0.09698548167943954, 0.003006773767992854, -0.06128628924489021, 0.0072469948790967464, 0.03860488906502724, 0.04023832082748413, -0.03670631721615791, -0.03693956881761551, -0.04420722275972366, -0.029294367879629135, 0.022248752415180206, -0.04896736890077591, -0.04415484145283699, -0.0033705956302583218, -0.06562910974025726, -0.08120299130678177, 0.04675981402397156, 0.027351506054401398, 0.12295812368392944, 0.0012778568780049682, 0.038221631199121475, 0.02464638650417328, 0.05093209072947502, -0.055980779230594635, 0.025583770126104355, 0.011639256961643696, 0.014086044393479824, 0.05937778949737549, -0.035551007837057114, 0.023442381992936134, -0.07597140222787857, -0.07658854126930237, -0.006534879095852375, -0.03222908079624176, -0.003912562038749456, -0.03910600766539574, -0.004290150478482246, 0.03529403731226921, -0.021316424012184143, 0.06284594535827637, -0.0005673995474353433, -0.006860935594886541, -0.01072921883314848, -0.1215098649263382, 0.027270838618278503, 0.04521464556455612, 0.04276322200894356, 0.05382248014211655, 0.017699774354696274, 0.010290458798408508, -0.04752960801124573, -0.08266805857419968, 0.019122984260320663, 0.02388540469110012, -0.015932146459817886, 0.06571069359779358, 0.018558165058493614, -0.01775294728577137, 0.015359736979007721, 0.03104092925786972, 0.037278637290000916, 0.02869586832821369, -0.03100627474486828, -0.008833661675453186, -0.0901956632733345, -0.0016191554022952914, -0.07178344577550888, -0.06004784628748894, -0.10976389795541763, 0.03675951436161995, -0.05071939900517464, -0.04167931154370308, -0.030043046921491623, -0.02141231670975685, -0.04710663855075836, -0.022278305143117905, -0.02931240014731884, 0.0797811970114708, 0.06422746926546097, 0.03364837169647217, -0.0024861120618879795, -0.05318325385451317, -0.017459653317928314, -0.024355875328183174, 0.0025800548028200865, -0.023164579644799232, 0.004671722650527954, 0.019915539771318436, -0.039465248584747314, -0.01782507821917534, -0.08232544362545013, 0.053287915885448456, -0.0060867187567055225, -0.05684987083077431, -0.019579656422138214, -0.007893885485827923, 0.010039363987743855, 0.014929302036762238, 0.014181332662701607, -0.0030625099316239357, 0.009947018697857857, 0.0302914809435606, -0.022760555148124695, 0.02825040929019451, 0.020478524267673492, -0.022284353151917458, -0.03116566874086857, 0.024863559752702713, -0.018161067739129066, -0.0331755094230175, 0.048217255622148514, 0.02930791862308979, -0.030432401224970818, 0.003154630772769451, 0.07873412221670151, 0.03537531569600105, 0.03627920150756836, 0.04489866644144058, 0.05429372936487198, -0.033610571175813675, 0.03697426989674568, -0.07711362838745117, -0.013070989400148392 ]
139
139
Quantum classification
Quantum classification is defined as the task of predicting the associated class of an unknown quantum state drawn from an ensemble of pure states given a finite number of copies of this state. By recasting the state discrimination problem within the framework of Machine Learning (ML), we can use the notion of learning reduction coming from classical ML to solve different variants of the classification task, such as the weighted binary and the multiclass versions.
[ -0.027669627219438553, -0.0816115140914917, 0.054986827075481415, 0.04855519160628319, 0.03992775082588196, -0.06704001873731613, -0.03464725986123085, 0.0326642282307148, 0.0026827771216630936, 0.00018066063057631254, -0.0719698891043663, 0.04141617566347122, 0.03517486900091171, -0.012654460035264492, 0.029525674879550934, 0.05021338537335396, -0.006443669553846121, -0.03040187992155552, -0.009857682511210442, -0.1015670970082283, 0.02431347966194153, -0.007883950136601925, 0.004896234720945358, 0.0009168888791464269, 0.04525259882211685, -0.015318010933697224, -0.060320332646369934, 0.015237296931445599, -0.010132592171430588, 0.016603173688054085, -0.002611675998196006, 0.021687613800168037, -0.013586336746811867, -0.010575180873274803, 0.0632096379995346, -0.03806525841355324, -0.005540957674384117, -0.0526207759976387, -0.011769847013056278, -0.049571190029382706, 0.02379056066274643, -0.06796824187040329, -0.04351092129945755, 0.036295086145401, 0.017274945974349976, 0.0222353283315897, 0.08158012479543686, -0.009007459506392479, -0.04329444840550423, 0.09166044741868973, -0.1075315773487091, 0.054356832057237625, -0.0924796611070633, -0.058395445346832275, 0.0352531261742115, -0.01740489900112152, 0.0016020929906517267, -0.035194914788007736, -0.029495786875486374, -0.011649790219962597, 0.07775651663541794, 0.06986519694328308, -0.009728997945785522, 0.007663828786462545, -0.007802988402545452, 0.03360854461789131, -0.07395084947347641, -0.04340045154094696, 0.06012982502579689, 0.03668874129652977, 0.009733349084854126, 0.02234387770295143, 0.007575789000838995, 0.028448054566979408, -0.004939240403473377, 0.03920143097639084, 0.015413126908242702, 0.03883931413292885, 0.02963796630501747, 0.07338880002498627, -0.04174204170703888, -0.01812387816607952, 0.024134021252393723, 0.025016264989972115, -0.02465364709496498, 0.06089571863412857, 0.01757255755364895, -0.09740737080574036, -0.058990899473428726, -0.034063346683979034, -0.029783032834529877, -0.014582272619009018, -0.0339297354221344, 0.02326633408665657, -0.02843754179775715, 0.04640350490808487, -0.009242869913578033, -0.12072829157114029, -0.017396071925759315, 0.027521226555109024, 0.05669676885008812, 0.00866711139678955, 0.023095980286598206, 0.10105860233306885, -0.01548291090875864, 0.03871212899684906, -0.04522257670760155, 0.02126213349401951, 0.04523294419050217, 0.024313975125551224, 0.056984852999448776, 0.007705064956098795, 0.06223678216338158, -0.026621434837579727, 0.02565002255141735, -0.041863858699798584, -0.02701660990715027, 0.02246926724910736, 0.0876426249742508, 0.05145550146698952, -0.026995399966835976, -0.009686150588095188, -0.024412652477622032, 0.05814101919531822, 0.027135077863931656, -0.04480424150824547, -0.05150071531534195, -0.0069620804861187935, 0.11419324576854706, 0.012057666666805744, -0.03369275480508804, -0.021147528663277626, -0.03663381189107895, -0.046255338937044144, 0.019598914310336113, -0.012152276933193207, 0.053053829818964005, -0.03323190659284592, 0.003302233526483178, 0.016337882727384567, -0.030519265681505203, 0.030854834243655205, -0.014903642237186432, 0.04039955139160156, 0.062212664633989334, 0.02264428697526455, -0.007517591584473848, -0.04147595167160034, 0.0392618402838707, 0.05006246268749237, -0.0510302297770977, 0.020994385704398155, 0.016161905601620674, 0.0257300715893507, 0.07733961194753647, -0.04259887710213661, 0.014154183678328991, 0.026282403618097305, -0.00864761509001255, 0.07948955148458481, -0.016961870715022087, -0.007986996322870255, -0.04000357538461685, 0.02675224095582962, -0.059855204075574875, 0.059760671108961105, -0.006205972284078598, 0.055220965296030045, 0.00023321736080106348, -0.0018926456104964018, 0.01993563212454319, 0.046792685985565186, -0.0507439486682415, 0.08432555198669434, -0.0071273744106292725, -0.020263200625777245, -0.029495934024453163, 0.04658487066626549, -0.06259020417928696, -0.01878090761601925, 0.004750719293951988, -0.0833553671836853, -0.05393553152680397, 0.04837872087955475, -0.011782604269683361, 0.07023631781339645, -0.06365592032670975, 0.03412984311580658, 0.022982122376561165, -0.02533848024904728, -0.003934875596314669, -0.04393172264099121, 0.03058677166700363, -0.0031713685020804405, -0.05951809883117676, 0.046086836606264114, -0.03398171067237854, -0.04062683880329132, 0.08201231062412262, 0.019795143976807594, 0.026214515790343285, 0.012571907602250576, -0.009322823025286198, -0.023370150476694107, -0.08430247753858566, 0.05317419022321701, 0.04063044488430023, -0.010357673279941082, -0.012137065641582012, 0.0070282514207065105, -0.005985664669424295, 0.0001069955324055627, 0.03172414377331734, 0.04518885537981987, -0.015038068406283855, -0.10246886312961578, -0.019789068028330803, -0.024571051821112633, -0.04290834441781044, 0.0929219201207161, -0.0027269325219094753, 0.046632833778858185, 0.004758743569254875, 0.04556121304631233, 0.004303803667426109, -0.009356193244457245, 0.111068494617939, -0.04854455217719078, -0.031208055093884468, 0.026750147342681885, -0.028027286753058434, -0.07348562777042389, -0.07173854112625122, 0.014517628587782383, 0.010187065228819847, 0.017618853598833084, -0.03757040947675705, -0.05460437387228012, 0.012907084077596664, -0.04272130876779556, 0.021415110677480698, 0.03362473100423813, -0.05146045982837677, -0.07751462608575821, 0.03764868155121803, 0.0026378333568573, -0.019082630053162575, 0.01621503010392189, -0.03410157561302185, -0.0065533132292330265, -0.07794346660375595, 0.0015665917890146375, 0.013967943377792835, -0.06935060024261475, 0.017293913289904594, -0.021518433466553688, -0.019632549956440926, 0.07366738468408585, 0.0428532138466835, 0.04266730695962906, 0.008927715010941029, 0.02715570107102394, -0.07531648874282837, 0.03864172846078873, 0.040872085839509964, 0.023987194523215294, 0.03888344764709473, 0.011840644292533398, -0.004764119163155556, -0.007309055421501398, -0.052744943648576736, -0.06774541735649109, 0.012392999604344368, 0.03001180849969387, -0.05251116678118706, 0.0069874487817287445, -0.0883062332868576, 0.013653479516506195, 0.07014042884111404, -0.03932946175336838, -0.04150606319308281, -0.01418607123196125, -0.03237377852201462, 0.03376537933945656, -0.025556810200214386, -0.026280105113983154, 0.03054974041879177, 0.004042298998683691, 0.09223750233650208, 0.0026234756223857403, -0.017116054892539978, 0.0401996448636055, 0.0025245491415262222, -0.056281592696905136, 0.0522746816277504, 0.027178263291716576, 0.028652265667915344, 0.041422758251428604, -0.013162367045879364, -0.06001672148704529, 0.008053448051214218, 0.019422564655542374, 0.03345031663775444, 0.026684602722525597, 0.004608522169291973, 0.00669090636074543, -0.007341388147324324, -0.017503902316093445, -0.0886993259191513, 0.015880711376667023, 0.012436410412192345, 0.0007327176863327622, 0.0439782552421093, -0.013446817174553871, -0.011810139752924442, -0.00665948586538434, 0.045491382479667664, 0.024114184081554413, 0.011271023191511631, -0.0010501430369913578, 0.039270464330911636, 0.04542957991361618, -0.006679749581962824, -0.005158144980669022, -0.07531749457120895, 0.0190300140529871, -0.023615507408976555, 0.001958848675712943, -0.08274255692958832, 0.06681642681360245, -0.06576607376337051, -0.05859244242310524, 0.027726810425519943, 0.06743437796831131, -0.036769770085811615, 0.05567135289311409, -0.027851613238453865, 0.019843243062496185, 0.05290650948882103, 0.041802212595939636, -0.07052464783191681, -0.0708756297826767, -0.03291868045926094, 0.0074685909785330296, -0.06390520930290222, -0.045874062925577164, 0.01882481388747692, 0.046295858919620514, -0.024132171645760536, 0.035513684153556824, -0.023911012336611748, 0.06594081223011017, -0.10388074070215225, 0.0978868305683136, -0.0234054047614336, 0.051326215267181396, 0.06426922231912613, 0.013976273126900196, 0.0044934069737792015, -0.009693942964076996, 0.01615377888083458, -0.020339203998446465, -0.013242151588201523, 0.006763096433132887, -0.025901801884174347, 0.09691383689641953, -0.06934711337089539, 0.0008483459241688251, -0.042656078934669495, -0.022933080792427063, -0.005592190660536289, 0.04412142559885979, -0.008592911064624786, 0.08415020257234573, 0.10763765126466751, -0.033430974930524826, 0.04542994871735573, -0.05956191569566727, 0.019249550998210907, -0.048341333866119385, -0.11293572187423706, 0.029035843908786774, -0.06224142760038376, 0.07312341779470444, -0.030723655596375465, -0.06922122091054916, 0.00754605932161212, -0.00592969311401248, 0.027561798691749573, -0.025615908205509186, 0.016023950651288033, -0.0013609869638457894, -0.020634986460208893, -0.015568064525723457, 0.007883094251155853, -0.04469357430934906, 0.012372895143926144, 0.020564645528793335, -0.011008797213435173, -0.023593835532665253, 0.021267374977469444, -0.05275297164916992, 0.0460415780544281, -0.13550381362438202, -0.029172750189900398, 0.0907098576426506, 0.024122795090079308, 0.07514014840126038, -0.055428214371204376, -0.020251750946044922, 0.06565601378679276, 0.02192617394030094, 0.0029873100575059652, -0.021831145510077477, 0.062153249979019165, -0.02885802835226059, 0.028295224532485008, -0.021289294585585594, 0.012882357463240623, -0.11066751182079315, -0.017439259216189384, 0.026689786463975906, 0.07504285871982574, 0.008503474295139313, -0.04721248522400856, 0.08010149002075195, 0.02399384416639805, 0.009837144054472446, 0.021671205759048462, 0.04604516178369522, -0.01970404013991356, 0.016038646921515465, -0.017926784232258797, -0.05249506235122681, -0.017216792330145836, -0.08322679251432419, -0.0038291194941848516, 0.02002982795238495, -0.00709960563108325, 0.04510016366839409, -0.07864052802324295, 0.02943393774330616, 0.028063980862498283, 0.02310406044125557, 0.07450694590806961, 0.05108323693275452, 0.03445648401975632, -0.020776113495230675, 0.054843924939632416, 0.023631250485777855, 0.06701256334781647, -0.019756555557250977, 0.077071413397789, -0.05138707160949707, -0.008677841164171696, -0.019697507843375206, 0.013109478168189526, -0.06259498000144958, 0.02826133742928505, -0.010343058034777641, -0.017554018646478653, 0.022223148494958878, 0.0705249160528183, 0.00020574158406816423, 0.004018843639642, 0.0008426208514720201, -0.008142570033669472, -0.001261226600036025, 0.039949703961610794, -0.042289454489946365, -0.05483274534344673, 0.06942597031593323, -0.01462992187589407, -0.03886820748448372, 0.0063107311725616455, 0.01382859330624342, 0.045493051409721375, -0.04920163005590439, 0.04753897339105606, -0.02655806392431259, 0.10727602243423462, -0.007401873357594013, -0.014533542096614838, 0.047223325818777084, 0.04557644948363304, -0.04982764273881912, -0.062242958694696426, 0.07314789295196533, 0.02969418093562126, -0.007690786384046078, 0.02178966999053955, 0.0007440326153300703, 0.005026243161410093, -0.03462354838848114, -0.030899114906787872, -0.08018548786640167, 0.02130281925201416, 0.04915819317102432, 0.0001721660082694143, 0.013488245196640491, -0.01966346800327301, 0.05738891661167145, 0.057541850954294205, -0.0007508564740419388, 0.08508775383234024, 0.0311480313539505, 0.004789712373167276, 0.006025018636137247, 0.045302603393793106, 0.113423652946949, 0.004211661405861378, -0.0529179610311985 ]
140
140
Principal Graphs and Manifolds
In many physical, statistical, biological and other investigations it is desirable to approximate a system of points by objects of lower dimension and/or complexity. For this purpose, Karl Pearson invented principal component analysis in 1901 and found 'lines and planes of closest fit to system of points'. The famous k-means algorithm solves the approximation problem too, but by finite sets instead of lines and planes. This chapter gives a brief practical introduction into the methods of construction of general principal objects, i.e. objects embedded in the 'middle' of the multidimensional data set. As a basis, the unifying framework of mean squared distance approximation of finite datasets is selected. Principal graphs and manifolds are constructed as generalisations of principal components and k-means principal points. For this purpose, the family of expectation/maximisation algorithms with nearest generalisations is presented. Construction of principal graphs with controlled complexity is based on the graph grammar approach.
[ 0.023058105260133743, -0.04060923680663109, 0.0428079292178154, -0.049125250428915024, -0.043338630348443985, 0.048959411680698395, 0.06251870095729828, -0.07593875378370285, -0.06386259198188782, 0.02365328185260296, 0.0035420674830675125, 0.007060692645609379, -0.05059170722961426, 0.09111092984676361, -0.03151765093207359, -0.017476826906204224, -0.0769556313753128, 0.009743254631757736, 0.017248816788196564, -0.023740874603390694, 0.024842141196131706, 0.025766365230083466, -0.05671374499797821, 0.002017645165324211, 0.037812743335962296, 0.01388958003371954, -0.007928214967250824, -0.025765588507056236, -0.05308889225125313, -0.02775968797504902, -0.05712129920721054, 0.00628176424652338, 0.03232179954648018, 0.01912311650812626, 0.012287145480513573, 0.004777768161147833, 0.011371289379894733, 0.029678715392947197, -0.1118813157081604, -0.04387287050485611, 0.03214046359062195, 0.034334488213062286, 0.01370044331997633, -0.028368297964334488, 0.04570180922746658, -0.02711373195052147, -0.022032558917999268, -0.026841219514608383, 0.027114644646644592, 0.022943545132875443, -0.07565116137266159, 0.0479760579764843, 0.0059734913520514965, 0.006413648370653391, -0.06361473351716995, -0.00627705967053771, -0.04652007296681404, 0.01472531072795391, -0.023898834362626076, -0.0022110354620963335, 0.05038895830512047, 0.09096762537956238, -0.028105642646551132, -0.04041967913508415, -0.05541021749377251, -0.026495281606912613, -0.07340783625841141, -0.0074963318184018135, -0.05621247738599777, -0.10589625686407089, 0.005914736073464155, -0.039920516312122345, -0.032821498811244965, 0.03490744158625603, 0.0004805376229342073, -0.017848411574959755, -0.025775978341698647, -0.009879542514681816, 0.012517196126282215, 0.09949176758527756, 0.0007382398471236229, 0.04258754476904869, -0.06588463485240936, 0.039845336228609085, -0.01857413537800312, 0.007194897159934044, 0.06000445410609245, 0.028695672750473022, 0.028505828231573105, -0.0033339685760438442, -0.06442931294441223, 0.013036676682531834, -0.03769638389348984, 0.05759068951010704, -0.11810600757598877, -0.010483928956091404, -0.08244169503450394, 0.02462056279182434, 0.02179839462041855, 0.049893271178007126, -0.07873418182134628, -0.013330687768757343, 0.03653310611844063, 0.05474868044257164, 0.0570354126393795, 0.018448863178491592, -0.04105665907263756, 0.027119118720293045, -0.01190855447202921, -0.04427517578005791, 0.0840834528207779, -0.018878042697906494, -0.008794303983449936, 0.01888006366789341, -0.03701968118548393, 0.05619393289089203, 0.03620610386133194, 0.0917590782046318, 0.0424322709441185, 0.0014823592500761151, 0.021393483504652977, 0.012373809702694416, -0.004508143290877342, 0.02130035310983658, 0.026057811453938484, -0.021238483488559723, 0.013411573134362698, -0.008285884745419025, 0.059986699372529984, 0.0005602572928182781, 0.010028817690908909, -0.005010602064430714, -0.014337373897433281, 0.0549314022064209, -0.09238392859697342, 0.023206802085042, -0.0018026679754257202, -0.05135391280055046, 0.05287471413612366, 0.07583208382129669, 0.00545855425298214, -0.04431586340069771, -0.00797197874635458, -0.017987340688705444, 0.09869727492332458, 0.04989752173423767, -0.003275675233453512, -0.0018376189982518554, -0.006020392756909132, -0.023966006934642792, -0.05284033343195915, -0.07467070966959, 0.04893527552485466, 0.024803033098578453, -0.011196787469089031, -0.015109708532691002, 0.01195561233907938, 0.007102610543370247, 0.016969291493296623, 0.026108231395483017, -0.007597733289003372, -0.03629455342888832, -0.0303006861358881, 0.08125908672809601, 0.014028485864400864, -0.023481598123908043, 0.008213099092245102, -0.060510702431201935, 0.040739964693784714, -0.008106575347483158, 0.0021184468641877174, -0.03700945898890495, -0.015388491563498974, -0.013429952785372734, 0.03876631706953049, -0.02399802953004837, -0.05667834356427193, -0.0356755256652832, 0.02322978526353836, -0.023234102874994278, 0.03344011679291725, -0.007829416543245316, -0.006186614278703928, 0.05736561864614487, -0.0002599321014713496, 0.03113008290529251, 0.0037149027921259403, 0.037768177688121796, 0.02999512478709221, -0.04129703715443611, 0.03564315289258957, 0.008463559672236443, 0.0924919918179512, 0.04090896621346474, -0.0011994382366538048, 0.02379041723906994, 0.015503567643463612, -0.10207773745059967, 0.09348186105489731, 0.0367218479514122, 0.08282402157783508, -0.0037857601419091225, -0.04020940884947777, -0.10855777561664581, -0.05115382373332977, -0.00817070621997118, -0.003444360801950097, 0.00920345913618803, -0.06498947739601135, -0.03232834115624428, 0.002883889013901353, -0.04862278699874878, -0.03339780494570732, -0.07452442497015, 0.0021108309738337994, -0.04252070188522339, -0.02359730564057827, -0.013251710683107376, -0.006194895599037409, 0.05223394185304642, -0.028915708884596825, 0.029277531430125237, -0.023044854402542114, 0.01736493594944477, -0.03323991969227791, -0.003956703469157219, -0.025430327281355858, 0.0016782816965132952, -0.06517834216356277, -0.011018555611371994, -0.07806948572397232, -0.01970483362674713, -0.054393328726291656, -0.02563519962131977, 0.02721581980586052, 0.032936204224824905, -0.003150179283693433, 0.06531242281198502, -0.0077994149178266525, -0.05299312621355057, 0.022601306438446045, 0.04309184476733208, 0.01722504012286663, -0.05229340121150017, -0.015080675482749939, -0.0034488614182919264, 0.061368685215711594, 0.06719154864549637, -0.010634234175086021, 0.03097321279346943, 0.01410915981978178, -0.0011795733589679003, -0.014281888492405415, -0.0015832488425076008, 0.02855047583580017, 0.03903700411319733, -0.05121546611189842, 0.09745483845472336, 0.05200573056936264, 0.06478732824325562, 0.034514084458351135, 0.08239343762397766, 0.04357569292187691, -0.012928743846714497, 0.050992537289857864, 0.015416811220347881, 0.044517386704683304, 0.12323315441608429, -0.005228376016020775, -0.038246698677539825, 0.06565797328948975, -0.09042426943778992, -0.04039173573255539, 0.048003267496824265, -0.05120905488729477, 0.03162635862827301, 0.0326341837644577, 0.09717065840959549, -0.011584077961742878, -0.05035243183374405, -0.07324444502592087, 0.030137475579977036, -0.021782085299491882, -0.04277656227350235, -0.041827812790870667, 0.0822395458817482, -0.0029547451995313168, 0.017196735367178917, -0.00585705554112792, -0.004746266175061464, -0.06631360948085785, 0.0050059431232512, -0.08109620213508606, -0.032998569309711456, 0.0457860492169857, -0.11853329092264175, 0.06906051933765411, -0.06301531940698624, 0.0415063314139843, -0.0003276501956861466, -0.013100521638989449, 0.01564367301762104, 0.031461868435144424, 0.02985929138958454, 0.008428407832980156, 0.02600729465484619, 0.10400497168302536, 0.022117145359516144, -0.01825111173093319, -0.017899861559271812, 0.06270160526037216, -0.043171774595975876, 0.025576964020729065, 0.029797986149787903, 0.014199222438037395, -0.04732391983270645, -0.06470613926649094, -0.0025994230527430773, -0.008364259265363216, 0.043056320399045944, -0.06657595187425613, 0.030951516702771187, 0.022885724902153015, -0.03794003278017044, -0.058343369513750076, -0.024548767134547234, 0.040620867162942886, 0.041528478264808655, -0.10265318304300308, -0.03969988971948624, -0.06721668690443039, -0.03593525290489197, -0.03800636902451515, 0.09266532212495804, 0.03440633416175842, 0.041413240134716034, -0.034157875925302505, -0.02065948024392128, -0.022005310282111168, -0.006278345361351967, -0.038756031543016434, -0.09704826027154922, 0.037594061344861984, -0.06508128345012665, 0.04345566779375076, 0.10006645321846008, 0.07892889529466629, 0.027369299903512, -0.014177056029438972, -0.033122435212135315, -0.06450461596250534, 0.02933185175061226, 0.011827793903648853, -0.012159490957856178, 0.005016169045120478, 0.10308289527893066, 0.0632644072175026, 0.00761418417096138, 0.03129102662205696, -0.04538741335272789, -0.006715576164424419, 0.0010265737073495984, -0.007748364005237818, 0.07575652003288269, 0.018792742863297462, 0.03342200443148613, -0.04429052025079727, -0.01584971509873867, 0.03903447464108467, -0.0333072766661644, 0.0035969114396721125, 0.027930038049817085, 0.0012275477638468146, 0.03150550648570061, -0.006846968550235033, -0.0008600836736150086, 0.038936786353588104, 0.001991000957787037, -0.0226132832467556, -0.0052527207881212234, -0.08400079607963562, -0.04004109650850296, -0.04755212366580963, 0.02789628878235817, -0.08411325514316559, -0.016950402408838272, -0.0016390597447752953, 0.012470939196646214, 0.04642188549041748, -0.02004697546362877, -0.0028984216041862965, 0.011630833148956299, 0.053854700177907944, -0.0386105477809906, 0.028044501319527626, 0.05305685102939606, 0.022774849086999893, 0.053352560847997665, -0.010159354656934738, -0.04364095628261566, 0.05914365127682686, -0.03366750478744507, -0.02856316603720188, -0.058340318500995636, -0.038194090127944946, 0.004248578567057848, -0.04554842785000801, 0.02222190983593464, 0.017670761793851852, 0.08339034020900726, 0.03472668677568436, -0.014783116057515144, -0.010048054158687592, 0.026183998212218285, 0.03088330291211605, 0.0537317655980587, 0.10466174781322479, -0.007579246070235968, 0.06973187625408173, -0.04285356029868126, 0.042228277772665024, -0.02494906634092331, 0.006859212648123503, -0.015020218677818775, -0.003944028168916702, -0.032621316611766815, 0.024111153557896614, 0.03584687411785126, 0.01369362324476242, -0.054005544632673264, -0.017707163468003273, -0.047723643481731415, -0.08235780149698257, 0.06333918124437332, 0.030626922845840454, -0.03272628039121628, 0.009297307580709457, -0.0427415668964386, 0.027041414752602577, 0.021802818402647972, 0.03958997130393982, 0.06468265503644943, -0.04926157370209694, -0.025297997519373894, -0.054390039294958115, -0.017498871311545372, 0.05050406605005264, 0.024059228599071503, 0.031230337917804718, 0.04135096073150635, 0.02026955969631672, -0.019155409187078476, 0.014758878387510777, -0.04696907103061676, 0.03792139142751694, 0.010483836755156517, 0.021776780486106873, -0.10229461640119553, -0.04008848965167999, -0.06286768615245819, 0.051953885704278946, 0.005837155040353537, -0.01038407813757658, 0.006536468863487244, -0.04717952385544777, 0.007357456721365452, 0.00023574526130687445, 0.12998834252357483, 0.034808047115802765, 0.022041162475943565, -0.01963098905980587, 0.06596876680850983, -0.02362433820962906, 0.005375150125473738, -0.053209397941827774, -0.03133387118577957, 0.018340393900871277, -0.011161803267896175, -0.029781373217701912, -0.011005773209035397, 0.023314613848924637, 0.03283645957708359, -0.031969957053661346, 0.042906053364276886, 0.04677479714155197, 0.10305562615394592, 0.03890790045261383, -0.006860865745693445, 0.03929631784558296, -0.014630351215600967, 0.024658000096678734, -0.048068027943372726, -0.04008488357067108, 0.03349484130740166, -0.09688124060630798, -0.010592800565063953, -0.049073558300733566, -0.04763789102435112, 0.044205766171216965, 0.0026318137533962727, -0.02528470568358898, -0.05987504869699478, 0.045927178114652634, 0.03387678414583206, 0.052353739738464355, 0.04709341377019882, 0.03726555034518242, 0.02685527503490448, -0.07761089503765106, 0.08807794004678726, -0.02878538891673088, -0.033735763281583786 ]
141
141
Entropy Concentration and the Empirical Coding Game
We give a characterization of Maximum Entropy/Minimum Relative Entropy inference by providing two `strong entropy concentration' theorems. These theorems unify and generalize Jaynes' `concentration phenomenon' and Van Campenhout and Cover's `conditional limit theorem'. The theorems characterize exactly in what sense a prior distribution Q conditioned on a given constraint, and the distribution P, minimizing the relative entropy D(P ||Q) over all distributions satisfying the constraint, are `close' to each other. We then apply our theorems to establish the relationship between entropy concentration and a game-theoretic characterization of Maximum Entropy Inference due to Topsoe and others.
[ 0.009477123618125916, -0.016630563884973526, -0.0251041017472744, -0.07965440303087234, -0.009210935793817043, -0.1120886579155922, 0.0331549271941185, -0.016737578436732292, -0.09926201403141022, 0.07325410842895508, 0.020451843738555908, -0.0713057667016983, -0.02139529585838318, -0.0030700911302119493, 0.01707448996603489, -0.03824001923203468, -0.04454730823636055, 0.027714215219020844, -0.004822355695068836, -0.059091705828905106, 0.013021224178373814, 0.009628194384276867, -0.016613489016890526, -0.05382120609283447, -0.030674045905470848, -0.03307986259460449, -0.03830708563327789, -0.0018841899000108242, -0.04093725234270096, -0.023725608363747597, -0.03417132794857025, 0.07004948705434799, -0.015639254823327065, -0.020553957670927048, 0.032730404287576675, -0.014089446514844894, 0.01447963435202837, -0.08776230365037918, -0.016319092363119125, -0.02862023003399372, 0.03195899352431297, -0.00784385111182928, 0.010357576422393322, 0.0007364876219071448, -0.029246892780065536, -0.023546602576971054, 0.002562832785770297, 0.06478820741176605, 0.03719039633870125, 0.05800430849194527, -0.08427325636148453, -0.0010440862970426679, -0.027229314669966698, -0.07535548508167267, 0.05612533912062645, 0.04079645872116089, -0.001934399246238172, 0.038560524582862854, -0.04434823617339134, 0.04198165982961655, 0.02406414970755577, 0.08559539914131165, -0.04132666438817978, 0.061437711119651794, -0.04296667128801346, -0.03577226400375366, -0.056501079350709915, 0.03944021090865135, 0.08067915588617325, -0.03706781938672066, 0.011377474293112755, -0.045273683965206146, 0.052795469760894775, 0.09060212969779968, 0.01744740456342697, -0.03320658579468727, -0.021570583805441856, -0.014515242539346218, -0.02187289111316204, 0.02917490340769291, -0.04694167152047157, 0.08668933808803558, -0.026191672310233116, 0.03206309303641319, -0.05226520076394081, 0.02722003497183323, -0.009852917864918709, 0.004469180479645729, -0.07359422743320465, -0.09762106090784073, -0.037917643785476685, 0.014203043654561043, -0.026390666142106056, 0.032469213008880615, -0.015046162530779839, 0.09005061537027359, -0.0330897681415081, -0.024632932618260384, 0.014652582816779613, -0.012388226576149464, 0.04598440229892731, -0.044532451778650284, 0.02811349928379059, 0.09856011718511581, -0.019484495744109154, -0.01624569110572338, 0.013566910289227962, -0.009867200627923012, -0.007565168663859367, -0.08623570948839188, -0.0028255959041416645, -0.09532991051673889, 0.0028062190394848585, 0.00004169067688053474, -0.08285809308290482, 0.052928391844034195, -0.005980383139103651, -0.01864505186676979, 0.04940836504101753, 0.07240435481071472, 0.05442499369382858, -0.0452766977250576, 0.04916505515575409, 0.01071251556277275, 0.03199353069067001, 0.018731823191046715, -0.050587479025125504, -0.03764136880636215, 0.13180574774742126, -0.0982566624879837, 0.10483905673027039, -0.017234891653060913, 0.015552181750535965, -0.05608435720205307, -0.046907663345336914, 0.015412035398185253, -0.027758752927184105, -0.06236680969595909, 0.032283715903759, 0.03440702334046364, 0.009525787085294724, 0.011204240843653679, 0.012809187173843384, 0.02358195185661316, 0.027049466967582703, 0.033163994550704956, -0.025926247239112854, 0.030972560867667198, -0.027086494490504265, 0.0015865751774981618, -0.025681274011731148, -0.04755185544490814, -0.01461661048233509, 0.05322038382291794, 0.06287126988172531, -0.06531907618045807, -0.060317493975162506, -0.03691272810101509, -0.032300882041454315, 0.06923329830169678, -0.024624114856123924, -0.024643901735544205, 0.004695441573858261, 0.05891755595803261, -0.09395108371973038, -0.026313405483961105, -0.0032801516354084015, 0.02911377139389515, 0.007782192435115576, -0.09660115092992783, -0.0297368373721838, 0.013617931865155697, -0.04656483232975006, -0.05551370605826378, -0.050090037286281586, -0.017216196283698082, 0.024627935141324997, -0.015493103303015232, 0.05093532055616379, -0.018807802349328995, -0.08622739464044571, 0.007281157188117504, -0.004115700256079435, 0.004114407114684582, 0.007819977588951588, 0.05108942836523056, -0.039433009922504425, 0.010218270123004913, 0.05478591471910477, 0.01728632301092148, 0.02323569357395172, -0.02019117958843708, -0.0037090862169861794, -0.014841269701719284, -0.01794123277068138, -0.06234113126993179, -0.003786040935665369, 0.04960580915212631, 0.0014224733458831906, 0.02132483199238777, 0.013296258635818958, -0.046682242304086685, -0.07289843261241913, 0.03845582529902458, -0.006045096088200808, 0.06499674916267395, 0.021361690014600754, -0.04090702906250954, -0.02709008939564228, -0.036867495626211166, -0.017879996448755264, -0.008426711894571781, -0.020793136209249496, -0.05636293441057205, 0.04330169036984444, -0.02482873760163784, -0.027777167037129402, -0.04632759466767311, -0.0029622213914990425, -0.010917174629867077, -0.0042193615809082985, 0.018946820870041847, -0.024498378857970238, 0.08411286771297455, -0.05526355654001236, -0.024475136771798134, -0.002555993851274252, 0.06659749150276184, 0.03189721331000328, 0.019587287679314613, -0.1128808856010437, -0.013425879180431366, -0.017436839640140533, -0.06599228829145432, -0.07443248480558395, -0.014121494255959988, -0.0649375170469284, 0.055915333330631256, -0.014335770159959793, 0.008770689368247986, 0.005678690969944, -0.0020324301440268755, 0.06009248271584511, 0.03253044933080673, -0.025586586445569992, -0.02922157570719719, -0.030728721991181374, 0.0018831988563761115, -0.032703738659620285, 0.04353530704975128, -0.011380852200090885, 0.02348039485514164, 0.006791902240365744, -0.05546637997031212, 0.04290083423256874, -0.05627516284584999, 0.03447076305747032, 0.05722835287451744, 0.002136621158570051, 0.0259125754237175, -0.06363681703805923, 0.033734384924173355, 0.00027818907983601093, 0.05590002238750458, 0.0007732203812338412, 0.03326330706477165, -0.010654736310243607, 0.04273446649312973, 0.08299470692873001, -0.013882527127861977, -0.024339459836483, 0.0007378262234851718, -0.03185288980603218, 0.07750439643859863, 0.0032134538050740957, 0.037666384130716324, 0.022474637255072594, 0.04447709023952484, 0.011250386014580727, -0.028003619983792305, -0.044533129781484604, 0.04377884790301323, 0.026421768590807915, 0.0357666090130806, -0.00036789008299820125, 0.022030416876077652, -0.018358608707785606, 0.009177406318485737, 0.01488157082349062, 0.056982629001140594, -0.043833132833242416, 0.05165310949087143, 0.04033083841204643, -0.029421044513583183, 0.03270329535007477, 0.04221685230731964, 0.016371337696909904, -0.010323770344257355, 0.03852573409676552, 0.0005481908447109163, -0.0483810156583786, -0.0231506135314703, 0.04644424468278885, -0.010157481767237186, 0.02996179461479187, 0.03841264545917511, 0.0517519935965538, 0.05736863240599632, -0.05623406544327736, -0.039516836404800415, -0.05476579815149307, -0.006887794006615877, 0.058161716908216476, -0.05756307393312454, 0.01220021490007639, -0.0674932524561882, -0.011435002088546753, -0.08411366492509842, 0.04744647070765495, -0.024455083534121513, -0.015478456392884254, -0.045777663588523865, 0.025589236989617348, 0.06588613241910934, -0.10637293010950089, 0.014807235449552536, 0.07858741283416748, -0.0344749391078949, -0.08034343272447586, -0.025503413751721382, -0.052099622786045074, -0.03940507024526596, -0.04118939861655235, 0.08447066694498062, 0.022078916430473328, 0.06222757324576378, -0.030167831107974052, -0.0476667545735836, -0.012038611806929111, 0.03687974438071251, -0.028604507446289062, -0.04665719345211983, -0.051831088960170746, 0.01532419491559267, 0.015305835753679276, 0.04598622024059296, 0.04995204508304596, 0.11944270133972168, -0.04073626175522804, -0.03692115098237991, -0.04089900851249695, 0.013921203091740608, 0.004283613059669733, -0.004598990082740784, -0.03686121106147766, 0.03744736686348915, 0.06086929887533188, 0.002923207823187113, 0.030278300866484642, -0.02182808332145214, 0.003481337334960699, 0.04966846480965614, 0.019425082951784134, -0.05875344201922417, 0.027615660801529884, 0.06970536708831787, -0.0201027300208807, -0.0739029124379158, -0.05301989987492561, -0.004211889114230871, -0.030155900865793228, 0.020726406946778297, -0.04022817313671112, 0.036484695971012115, -0.005325821693986654, -0.08755021542310715, 0.05360204353928566, -0.030700426548719406, -0.014458139427006245, 0.08421766757965088, -0.028291484341025352, -0.026921909302473068, -0.034467220306396484, -0.014679692685604095, -0.08536344766616821, -0.0578509084880352, 0.012430739589035511, -0.07277081161737442, 0.03756677359342575, 0.0011532156495377421, -0.031065313145518303, -0.025222573429346085, 0.060694050043821335, 0.0767870545387268, 0.04150083288550377, 0.005759044550359249, 0.007330200169235468, 0.060100384056568146, -0.08955437690019608, -0.006673503667116165, 0.03554322570562363, -0.024916470050811768, 0.018285103142261505, -0.002800500951707363, 0.0008689023088663816, 0.005031082313507795, 0.02966420166194439, 0.021731499582529068, 0.021360354498028755, 0.06527595221996307, 0.03268849477171898, 0.02718942053616047, -0.03359631448984146, 0.05911727622151375, -0.014640672132372856, 0.0491560623049736, 0.07077538222074509, 0.019339587539434433, 0.030551467090845108, -0.05035173147916794, -0.05676574632525444, 0.07455301284790039, 0.07700370997190475, 0.014804335311055183, 0.07253012806177139, 0.05974835157394409, 0.08445039391517639, 0.04337053373456001, 0.02346956357359886, 0.05530855804681778, 0.011468665674328804, -0.009874920360744, -0.06367502361536026, -0.08993397653102875, 0.01344161294400692, -0.05729188024997711, -0.031110582873225212, 0.00788010936230421, 0.05455365404486656, -0.001848379848524928, -0.023229271173477173, 0.11331525444984436, 0.052494071424007416, 0.01950639858841896, -0.048804499208927155, 0.021249528974294662, 0.04575005918741226, -0.02280343510210514, 0.04730981960892677, 0.04370952397584915, 0.07237917184829712, 0.053698837757110596, 0.031189771369099617, -0.008850093930959702, 0.048729058355093, 0.02904839627444744, -0.08415605127811432, -0.005543840117752552, -0.008235936053097248, -0.00946711003780365, 0.004737401846796274, -0.0994928777217865, 0.02819359302520752, -0.0384809784591198, -0.06199001893401146, -0.03161153942346573, -0.009466630406677723, 0.006428298074752092, 0.036119356751441956, 0.03019540198147297, -0.0058847530744969845, -0.016880642622709274, 0.0603848360478878, -0.005545327439904213, -0.033668745309114456, 0.0255200807005167, 0.005861477926373482, -0.021005291491746902, 0.030216241255402565, -0.09009596705436707, 0.006326910573989153, -0.06486029922962189, -0.09088712930679321, -0.024962695315480232, 0.06491614133119583, 0.04572645574808121, 0.00750552536919713, -0.020316746085882187, 0.07193972915410995, 0.03378891572356224, 0.002185381483286619, -0.04257023707032204, -0.008329778909683228, -0.03152192756533623, 0.05610315501689911, 0.01740708015859127, 0.010915783233940601, -0.05735776573419571, -0.024255702272057533, -0.007690733764320612, 0.013932639732956886, 0.011500924825668335, 0.04933537170290947, 0.0047100684605538845, 0.07610461115837097, 0.032534949481487274, -0.016391297802329063, -0.012433541938662529, 0.001306001446209848, 0.02668856270611286, -0.07235042750835419, -0.02828722633421421 ]
142
142
A New Framework of Multistage Estimation
In this paper, we have established a unified framework of multistage parameter estimation. We demonstrate that a wide variety of statistical problems such as fixed-sample-size interval estimation, point estimation with error control, bounded-width confidence intervals, interval estimation following hypothesis testing, construction of confidence sequences, can be cast into the general framework of constructing sequential random intervals with prescribed coverage probabilities. We have developed exact methods for the construction of such sequential random intervals in the context of multistage sampling. In particular, we have established inclusion principle and coverage tuning techniques to control and adjust the coverage probabilities of sequential random intervals. We have obtained concrete sampling schemes which are unprecedentedly efficient in terms of sampling effort as compared to existing procedures.
[ -0.014360135421156883, -0.030645528808236122, 0.020917564630508423, 0.0038999521639198065, 0.017528466880321503, -0.06022419407963753, -0.0420883446931839, 0.023875098675489426, -0.04245255887508392, 0.0038513883482664824, -0.0562627837061882, -0.08797428011894226, -0.0688575729727745, -0.0393228605389595, -0.06583604961633682, -0.0031157867051661015, -0.06587479263544083, -0.0035185047890990973, -0.0026937893126159906, -0.10851691663265228, -0.06761100143194199, 0.011068861000239849, 0.07674141973257065, -0.03646811097860336, 0.03212286904454231, -0.008984687738120556, 0.02821473777294159, -0.027755344286561012, -0.0816110298037529, 0.02980693243443966, -0.05891238898038864, 0.04193377494812012, -0.00858636386692524, -0.01799628883600235, 0.06082029640674591, -0.019291309639811516, -0.027193643152713776, -0.0323244147002697, -0.067605160176754, -0.07112299650907516, 0.011438028886914253, -0.07971367239952087, -0.013399968855082989, 0.029644783586263657, 0.04719166457653046, 0.04482625424861908, 0.06581541150808334, 0.034426525235176086, -0.008628439158201218, -0.032461851835250854, -0.050084587186574936, 0.05313798785209656, -0.031754665076732635, -0.087394118309021, 0.014982860535383224, -0.029246658086776733, -0.06987709552049637, 0.03868938609957695, -0.05734701082110405, 0.017367210239171982, -0.013577602803707123, 0.05700698867440224, 0.010311816819012165, -0.04370250180363655, -0.040054041892290115, 0.056134529411792755, -0.07713709026575089, -0.026281967759132385, -0.08180343359708786, -0.0405423603951931, 0.036646924912929535, -0.013655516318976879, -0.004158776719123125, 0.005283582489937544, 0.027979854494333267, 0.0037295562215149403, -0.01311268750578165, 0.014860827475786209, 0.054426856338977814, 0.004062748048454523, -0.02405223622918129, 0.047416169196367264, -0.07548221200704575, -0.0017894390039145947, -0.05147477611899376, -0.029997998848557472, 0.02204171009361744, 0.01902252621948719, 0.01656435802578926, -0.06585905700922012, -0.05833246186375618, -0.024626491591334343, -0.06947526335716248, 0.09562202543020248, -0.04400989040732384, 0.039395298808813095, -0.01695624738931656, -0.011042367666959763, -0.002440300304442644, 0.036297257989645004, 0.015118940733373165, -0.14670835435390472, 0.05878697335720062, 0.0630672425031662, 0.0528196357190609, 0.037135329097509384, 0.025640234351158142, 0.03296390920877457, 0.029078582301735878, 0.0154045345261693, -0.018159957602620125, -0.10941114276647568, -0.018912125378847122, -0.005629333201795816, -0.0474943071603775, 0.02990151010453701, -0.03661785274744034, -0.018785245716571808, 0.035393405705690384, -0.016354581341147423, 0.08707080781459808, 0.018323196098208427, -0.02392406389117241, -0.0005983294686302543, 0.0660133957862854, 0.037296418100595474, -0.0010414031567052007, -0.06374913454055786, 0.12750448286533356, -0.033159948885440826, -0.0228571854531765, 0.019437819719314575, -0.032161276787519455, 0.10106946527957916, -0.041724272072315216, -0.023093972355127335, 0.03646768257021904, 0.024356072768568993, -0.023951496928930283, -0.0036312085576355457, -0.030491480603814125, -0.04536860063672066, -0.01801733672618866, 0.0541636161506176, 0.016710706055164337, 0.018324200063943863, -0.014294198714196682, 0.038530945777893066, -0.06984104961156845, 0.04042073339223862, -0.08305060863494873, -0.07588657736778259, -0.06807833164930344, 0.07136324048042297, 0.04328148439526558, -0.005753027740865946, -0.012540851719677448, -0.04634646698832512, -0.05320171266794205, 0.033156704157590866, -0.10439706593751907, 0.06566422432661057, 0.03113039769232273, 0.06282881647348404, -0.03772865608334541, -0.014869781211018562, 0.009344995953142643, 0.04970468208193779, 0.031568076461553574, -0.008356177248060703, -0.014825664460659027, -0.011278892867267132, -0.049225691705942154, -0.038661595433950424, -0.044032204896211624, -0.01920214481651783, 0.029652247205376625, 0.01876537688076496, -0.022210801020264626, -0.05095873773097992, 0.01597059890627861, -0.11449740827083588, -0.029934925958514214, -0.02678084932267666, -0.005552841350436211, 0.03920383006334305, -0.013058805838227272, 0.053885817527770996, 0.05017997324466705, -0.014520089142024517, -0.0412682481110096, -0.004810502287000418, -0.004711303394287825, -0.02214614488184452, -0.015300864353775978, 0.037644099444150925, -0.020539037883281708, 0.02032749354839325, 0.02628418803215027, 0.020622629672288895, -0.022405238822102547, -0.06737508624792099, -0.012674539349973202, -0.027367038652300835, -0.021887274459004402, 0.060739800333976746, 0.05986999720335007, -0.02901272475719452, 0.061939626932144165, -0.03005463257431984, -0.04935756325721741, -0.06229891628026962, -0.00376480957493186, -0.11148442327976227, 0.08454713970422745, -0.07816338539123535, 0.00007442088826792315, -0.03466394916176796, 0.0648697093129158, 0.012162672355771065, 0.03720846399664879, 0.0316876620054245, -0.0347423329949379, 0.06028349697589874, -0.0624096505343914, -0.04034416377544403, 0.06635710597038269, -0.07041027396917343, -0.02777739241719246, -0.0037746550515294075, 0.010844549164175987, 0.0029564141295850277, 0.0072969733737409115, -0.012896943837404251, -0.013118102215230465, 0.060102254152297974, -0.02591806650161743, 0.015189822763204575, 0.022433768957853317, -0.010378711856901646, 0.012133177369832993, 0.07942907512187958, 0.00997905433177948, -0.020645255222916603, -0.02749948389828205, -0.018802151083946228, 0.06132097542285919, 0.11550207436084747, -0.0083346301689744, 0.10159660130739212, 0.010603475384414196, -0.03252503648400307, 0.017841162160038948, 0.020402975380420685, 0.021302148699760437, 0.012380133382976055, 0.01980445347726345, 0.09038588404655457, 0.039611633867025375, 0.07291698455810547, 0.03488399088382721, -0.034282464534044266, -0.08587431162595749, 0.002606554189696908, 0.005116194952279329, 0.0360608734190464, -0.04931005835533142, 0.03995947539806366, -0.009170044213533401, -0.045213744044303894, 0.0022857615258544683, 0.003145033260807395, -0.07125189155340195, 0.07527399808168411, 0.03173241391777992, -0.05917937681078911, 0.010224126279354095, -0.018655475229024887, -0.0416434183716774, -0.02573399804532528, -0.013849272392690182, 0.07356912642717361, 0.030991515144705772, 0.025325527414679527, 0.019788341596722603, 0.05141197890043259, 0.009411347098648548, -0.04114370420575142, -0.06665917485952377, 0.017244359478354454, -0.027559373527765274, 0.05689414218068123, -0.03267648071050644, -0.018555128946900368, 0.04993000999093056, 0.04607456922531128, 0.014079783111810684, 0.035637471824884415, 0.04945845529437065, 0.03587735816836357, -0.058098841458559036, 0.012525309808552265, 0.0630987137556076, 0.0359288826584816, -0.031270191073417664, 0.0515836626291275, 0.09331648051738739, 0.061247553676366806, -0.09560317546129227, -0.016232747584581375, 0.01831882633268833, -0.022138867527246475, -0.04779622703790665, -0.055540505796670914, -0.041739098727703094, -0.01974046230316162, -0.03063068352639675, -0.0028567996341735125, 0.00023888543364591897, 0.07721275836229324, 0.05373748391866684, -0.03401707485318184, 0.006236730609089136, -0.05114061012864113, -0.10508657246828079, -0.021380241960287094, -0.02881641872227192, -0.016962813213467598, 0.004275387618690729, -0.02677377313375473, -0.024892622604966164, 0.05353317782282829, -0.011899353936314583, 0.10506921261548996, 0.0034211224410682917, -0.008639284409582615, 0.014959362335503101, 0.040270909667015076, -0.0042580957524478436, -0.009816426783800125, -0.001507110078819096, -0.062373872846364975, 0.03959855064749718, -0.011641775257885456, 0.012241911143064499, 0.058404590934515, 0.10301556438207626, -0.02647322043776512, -0.033670827746391296, -0.10124770551919937, -0.0936698466539383, -0.04955599457025528, 0.002399537479504943, 0.039818715304136276, -0.019198698922991753, 0.029017150402069092, 0.08074864745140076, -0.005677608773112297, -0.010349408723413944, 0.052081622183322906, -0.03762790933251381, -0.011075709946453571, 0.014149284921586514, -0.01073770597577095, 0.0125102698802948, -0.00007996358181117103, -0.03590186685323715, 0.01086512766778469, 0.0065110367722809315, -0.025256669148802757, -0.04350769519805908, 0.04196246713399887, 0.01773112826049328, 0.07717092335224152, 0.03676794096827507, 0.032416652888059616, 0.010336675681173801, -0.011370833963155746, -0.04151111841201782, 0.09921862930059433, -0.020175697281956673, -0.023645326495170593, 0.0207064151763916, -0.01593475602567196, 0.021301746368408203, 0.0034059167373925447, -0.011283236555755138, 0.04747472330927849, 0.07148362696170807, -0.04417114332318306, 0.017964038997888565, -0.04213907942175865, -0.0012040312867611647, 0.10582172125577927, 0.05740070343017578, 0.09562869369983673, 0.04379023239016533, -0.017907151952385902, -0.03705265000462532, -0.08048856258392334, 0.050527818500995636, -0.06663583219051361, -0.013901659287512302, -0.06877775490283966, -0.02973783016204834, -0.026383519172668457, -0.02095763012766838, -0.026148701086640358, -0.08291660994291306, 0.08477464318275452, -0.017504513263702393, 0.008421476930379868, -0.014412318356335163, -0.02137194573879242, -0.011632177978754044, 0.040337637066841125, 0.02482086792588234, -0.04067930579185486, -0.05243804678320885, -0.03213416039943695, -0.00961278472095728, 0.033599548041820526, 0.004606065806001425, -0.02265353314578533, 0.05339081957936287, 0.010895716957747936, 0.06324818730354309, 0.011591294780373573, -0.009018425829708576, -0.004091768059879541, -0.06670878082513809, -0.05504658445715904, -0.0033287396654486656, 0.0071877953596413136, -0.00845008809119463, -0.04928973689675331, -0.030060717836022377, -0.004812291823327541, 0.05149995908141136, -0.014934718608856201, -0.036055151373147964, 0.03674885258078575, -0.0073229107074439526, -0.02410966157913208, -0.044854242354631424, 0.01671004667878151, 0.05324774608016014, 0.005717788357287645, -0.0002654109266586602, -0.005230882205069065, -0.018197596073150635, 0.05878916382789612, -0.03846755623817444, 0.004695301875472069, 0.0138423852622509, 0.061586178839206696, -0.000670404639095068, -0.021137865260243416, 0.05429588630795479, 0.024721462279558182, -0.003695018356665969, -0.03991442173719406, 0.014567245729267597, 0.008573723025619984, -0.06526175886392593, 0.03672916069626808, 0.02318228967487812, 0.04512442275881767, 0.05841037258505821, -0.005555294454097748, -0.0610966831445694, 0.03321549668908119, -0.01290037576109171, 0.06177764758467674, 0.04004015773534775, -0.028508402407169342, -0.011145567521452904, -0.045698609203100204, 0.02669043466448784, -0.06162827089428902, 0.010357780382037163, -0.008643356151878834, -0.0798463374376297, 0.015463442541658878, 0.060072027146816254, 0.044168584048748016, -0.03880912438035011, -0.003715662518516183, -0.018582677468657494, 0.04344209283590317, 0.011477196589112282, 0.023730935528874397, 0.02504585310816765, 0.03450946882367134, 0.0019928799010813236, 0.05880075693130493, -0.03132951632142067, -0.007373012136667967, -0.014640690758824348, 0.03218974173069, 0.04109818488359451, -0.03517332300543785, 0.020238231867551804, -0.024617496877908707, 0.009309332817792892, 0.07653544843196869, 0.039035845547914505, -0.02645559422671795, -0.004476723726838827, -0.033839307725429535, 0.00584285706281662, -0.04046574607491493 ]
143
143
Predictive Hypothesis Identification
While statistics focusses on hypothesis testing and on estimating (properties of) the true sampling distribution, in machine learning the performance of learning algorithms on future data is the primary issue. In this paper we bridge the gap with a general principle (PHI) that identifies hypotheses with best predictive performance. This includes predictive point and interval estimation, simple and composite hypothesis testing, (mixture) model selection, and others as special cases. For concrete instantiations we will recover well-known methods, variations thereof, and new ones. PHI nicely justifies, reconciles, and blends (a reparametrization invariant variation of) MAP, ML, MDL, and moment estimation. One particular feature of PHI is that it can genuinely deal with nested hypotheses.
[ -0.03972598910331726, -0.09631402045488358, -0.003954010084271431, -0.01869329996407032, 0.019965244457125664, -0.03768348693847656, 0.03125941753387451, 0.002385779283940792, 0.0142800472676754, 0.05077036842703819, 0.0012202417710795999, 0.004118080250918865, 0.013663383200764656, 0.00008510988118359819, -0.019572649151086807, 0.07099910080432892, -0.032653968781232834, -0.021792709827423096, -0.017891447991132736, -0.05053962022066116, -0.009321857243776321, 0.0900009274482727, -0.04000704735517502, -0.008853604085743427, -0.013941388577222824, 0.06543853133916855, 0.015269316732883453, -0.019801625981926918, -0.041189178824424744, 0.008754245936870575, -0.08952312171459198, 0.045328300446271896, 0.01780257560312748, -0.039206620305776596, 0.03812829405069351, -0.04567495733499527, 0.017841201275587082, -0.0632355660200119, -0.03495568037033081, -0.0480063371360302, 0.0030052494257688522, -0.09042395651340485, 0.0243842750787735, 0.055272094905376434, 0.029933853074908257, 0.05289993807673454, 0.013663941994309425, 0.0678885281085968, 0.025833262130618095, 0.013491601683199406, -0.05152377113699913, 0.011182687245309353, -0.08164861053228378, -0.007816120982170105, -0.004768803715705872, 0.009253770112991333, -0.09988100081682205, 0.047096844762563705, -0.036111727356910706, -0.043126918375492096, 0.001449167844839394, 0.10439133644104004, -0.008911017328500748, -0.026641912758350372, -0.051163095980882645, 0.005184815730899572, -0.0667676255106926, 0.014359751716256142, 0.0014900368405506015, -0.05020406097173691, 0.0011531934142112732, -0.08753256499767303, 0.008734872564673424, 0.034074150025844574, 0.04995671659708023, -0.009111447259783745, -0.03382274508476257, 0.015867382287979126, 0.016941778361797333, 0.0552549734711647, 0.010709512047469616, 0.02281595766544342, 0.03375806286931038, 0.015490544028580189, -0.05720236152410507, 0.01263734232634306, 0.0017451293533667922, -0.05614318698644638, 0.0227616298943758, -0.0023065621498972178, -0.05323263257741928, 0.06695296615362167, -0.015446098521351814, 0.06766533851623535, -0.03159341216087341, 0.023077407851815224, -0.061450425535440445, 0.0290423221886158, 0.02155846171081066, 0.04947381466627121, 0.0290512777864933, -0.03662659227848053, 0.08526647835969925, 0.08358418196439743, 0.018240271136164665, -0.0051488615572452545, 0.0012782334815710783, 0.01131322793662548, -0.04086316376924515, -0.009520008228719234, 0.0842311754822731, -0.057077258825302124, 0.09256196767091751, 0.014403430745005608, 0.000989499851129949, 0.15977312624454498, -0.030657799914479256, 0.0725119560956955, 0.028225328773260117, -0.034713007509708405, 0.05420428514480591, 0.018417388200759888, -0.031671490520238876, 0.00590517045930028, 0.000893488060683012, 0.02531205490231514, -0.010028114542365074, -0.10521979629993439, 0.02891945280134678, -0.009379186667501926, -0.010742413811385632, 0.07203424721956253, -0.055578336119651794, 0.03181878849864006, -0.05515993386507034, 0.0031104283407330513, -0.01853141561150551, 0.03210381045937538, 0.009349976666271687, 0.056617118418216705, 0.0004624000284820795, 0.009650939144194126, -0.03839428722858429, 0.008977110497653484, -0.005510474555194378, 0.05568774417042732, 0.02285066619515419, -0.022769061848521233, -0.07959543913602829, 0.029467040672898293, -0.011107996106147766, -0.0718943253159523, 0.030714010819792747, 0.012624744325876236, 0.04509108141064644, -0.02806605026125908, -0.0394907109439373, 0.007319794036448002, -0.03968937695026398, 0.04161054268479347, -0.08276621252298355, 0.0132448123767972, -0.02092171087861061, 0.037170954048633575, -0.01077895238995552, 0.04666958004236221, 0.017264436930418015, 0.05633676424622536, -0.04961913451552391, -0.08052641898393631, -0.03461232781410217, -0.04246518015861511, -0.06896041333675385, -0.01786894164979458, -0.01749289035797119, -0.08076826483011246, -0.0066525256261229515, -0.022371312603354454, -0.023624705150723457, 0.028632914647459984, -0.019152555614709854, -0.05438712239265442, -0.03990382328629494, -0.0003778212994802743, 0.02589770033955574, 0.10957443714141846, -0.032936859875917435, 0.029243657365441322, 0.07640372216701508, 0.01940181665122509, 0.00913459062576294, 0.022385796532034874, -0.019775327295064926, -0.012411879375576973, -0.02774675562977791, 0.00811813771724701, 0.03845043480396271, -0.036841198801994324, 0.03654797747731209, 0.035675253719091415, 0.04667755961418152, -0.019738927483558655, -0.03732110932469368, 0.0069728512316942215, -0.008092984557151794, 0.060830142349004745, 0.06974883377552032, -0.04111927002668381, -0.022959241643548012, -0.05430329963564873, 0.061953261494636536, -0.06430252641439438, -0.029537994414567947, -0.01814217120409012, 0.04543155059218407, -0.04837312921881676, -0.03420606255531311, -0.07796252518892288, 0.028922157362103462, 0.046316638588905334, -0.024112317711114883, 0.07583079487085342, -0.04828367754817009, 0.07319600135087967, -0.040220510214567184, -0.04755300655961037, 0.035250212997198105, -0.062368519604206085, -0.00340187456458807, 0.07530366629362106, -0.05660656839609146, -0.03843199834227562, -0.04787130653858185, -0.0021828929893672466, -0.0072390176355838776, 0.0452406145632267, -0.04251259192824364, -0.07096870243549347, -0.02395114116370678, -0.0024334148038178682, -0.0143929123878479, 0.06526949256658554, -0.03811446577310562, 0.01115292776376009, -0.024013850837945938, -0.07925369590520859, 0.009753775782883167, -0.04072776064276695, -0.05909193307161331, 0.02826983854174614, 0.01769672892987728, -0.01395542174577713, -0.03195469081401825, -0.005498397164046764, -0.02585357427597046, -0.02987593226134777, -0.02402442693710327, 0.049264974892139435, 0.02288014627993107, 0.08026205003261566, 0.028891801834106445, 0.045361973345279694, -0.05128305405378342, -0.015218529850244522, 0.034376777708530426, -0.018567882478237152, -0.06059262156486511, 0.03005445934832096, -0.01779865100979805, -0.013902301900088787, -0.04719139635562897, -0.03320932760834694, -0.06352365016937256, 0.041435595601797104, -0.0458761602640152, -0.05496302619576454, 0.04027891904115677, 0.01871502585709095, 0.07344313710927963, -0.04470092058181763, -0.07779692858457565, -0.02343863621354103, 0.003080899827182293, 0.07034265249967575, -0.005231827963143587, 0.034689851105213165, -0.05969409644603729, -0.04377974197268486, -0.032821591943502426, -0.0015055841067805886, -0.047021426260471344, 0.02550273947417736, -0.07680919021368027, -0.02325313538312912, -0.007519918959587812, -0.04741854593157768, 0.046711474657058716, 0.023044325411319733, 0.059113502502441406, -0.040617186576128006, -0.02897745743393898, 0.0376037172973156, 0.07079233974218369, 0.053371965885162354, 0.04210834205150604, 0.03948051109910011, 0.049918774515390396, -0.0003573932917788625, -0.046728938817977905, 0.024924499914050102, 0.03892148658633232, -0.0798085629940033, 0.009780265390872955, 0.005806663539260626, -0.03055865690112114, -0.05541597306728363, -0.08713191002607346, -0.04713236913084984, 0.0025431353133171797, -0.05148313567042351, 0.033129651099443436, 0.036362141370773315, 0.042062439024448395, -0.009796498343348503, -0.035012491047382355, 0.018929632380604744, 0.02027028799057007, -0.0020363936200737953, -0.06904434412717819, 0.029046066105365753, -0.04849880561232567, -0.04359819367527962, -0.04755009710788727, 0.09791871905326843, -0.040717579424381256, -0.004323464818298817, 0.028039079159498215, 0.05337275564670563, 0.044666364789009094, 0.05755140259861946, -0.054613228887319565, -0.0658743679523468, -0.00018479888967704028, -0.008455445058643818, 0.008996308781206608, 0.07142818719148636, 0.08817622810602188, 0.03496488183736801, 0.013541202992200851, 0.005689133889973164, -0.04817458242177963, 0.022484276443719864, 0.04312002658843994, 0.08017336577177048, -0.03867081180214882, 0.11734712868928909, 0.008929358795285225, -0.04387431591749191, 0.019496945664286613, 0.039665672928094864, 0.0008099147235043347, 0.045055583119392395, -0.025948068127036095, -0.02040359191596508, 0.04616671800613403, 0.010812047868967056, -0.027470922097563744, 0.019598402082920074, -0.047369856387376785, 0.02260088361799717, 0.0024385901633650064, 0.057394254952669144, 0.051214057952165604, 0.04935247078537941, 0.03056393191218376, 0.050255317240953445, 0.07014075666666031, -0.05063634738326073, 0.04453812912106514, 0.15015368163585663, -0.05361402779817581, -0.02601025439798832, -0.06810291856527328, 0.0017865928821265697, -0.0359928198158741, -0.03291021287441254, -0.07238749414682388, 0.007300348952412605, 0.029365234076976776, -0.03355252370238304, -0.028335534036159515, -0.03117496892809868, 0.017972998321056366, 0.07069610804319382, 0.041874855756759644, 0.03161350637674332, 0.004984944127500057, -0.10134764760732651, -0.08050090819597244, -0.038058266043663025, 0.038267116993665695, -0.04478822275996208, 0.021238751709461212, -0.08087781071662903, 0.00039662502240389585, 0.019336340948939323, 0.04383346065878868, 0.08437775075435638, -0.06321194767951965, 0.07957131415605545, 0.02681857720017433, 0.0028350036591291428, -0.02364688366651535, 0.002333803800866008, 0.04662914201617241, -0.002870282158255577, 0.04706719517707825, -0.018024057149887085, -0.06700534373521805, -0.06295996159315109, 0.02013183943927288, 0.020236816257238388, 0.007310261484235525, 0.023994969204068184, 0.007913300767540932, -0.015169257298111916, 0.02581368386745453, 0.0016237609088420868, 0.05587400123476982, -0.020430970937013626, -0.03882306069135666, -0.030756918713450432, -0.09657692164182663, 0.01899883896112442, 0.029820319265127182, -0.028754042461514473, 0.07210418581962585, -0.0010233975481241941, -0.03273598849773407, 0.00573705555871129, -0.014182294718921185, 0.023253124207258224, 0.053474053740501404, 0.004159001167863607, -0.11279764026403427, 0.07468681037425995, 0.006581436842679977, 0.034927379339933395, 0.03386005014181137, -0.05047699064016342, 0.07975254207849503, 0.02285952679812908, -0.005059139337390661, -0.022522997111082077, 0.017035191878676414, -0.004998002666980028, -0.029299458488821983, -0.04703526571393013, 0.008378099650144577, -0.028980504721403122, 0.013972433283925056, -0.02020782046020031, 0.017312226817011833, 0.06308815628290176, -0.07252547144889832, -0.02284187451004982, 0.04585254564881325, 0.05587950721383095, 0.016862332820892334, 0.012475471012294292, -0.044419560581445694, -0.020832493901252747, 0.04156210273504257, -0.03214731439948082, -0.015994936227798462, -0.0343509204685688, 0.005695810075849295, -0.0408334881067276, -0.02538135088980198, -0.06258481740951538, 0.05023975670337677, 0.016354747116565704, -0.0097182746976614, 0.0244771596044302, 0.02339588664472103, 0.09904222935438156, -0.05205460265278816, -0.01789090223610401, -0.0009935896378010511, 0.009136630222201347, 0.002623411361128092, 0.006215847562998533, 0.03990517556667328, 0.04423707351088524, -0.008185056038200855, 0.018994102254509926, -0.059258121997117996, -0.021894756704568863, 0.04799547418951988, -0.023156480863690376, 0.03801281377673149, -0.014697412960231304, 0.0172707699239254, -0.020950907841324806, 0.1014973372220993, 0.04289434105157852, 0.037069547921419144, -0.004177088849246502, -0.006674323230981827, -0.029535513371229172, -0.04704109951853752, -0.020556079223752022 ]
144
144
Exploring Large Feature Spaces with Hierarchical Multiple Kernel Learning
For supervised and unsupervised learning, positive definite kernels allow to use large and potentially infinite dimensional feature spaces with a computational cost that only depends on the number of observations. This is usually done through the penalization of predictor functions by Euclidean or Hilbertian norms. In this paper, we explore penalizing by sparsity-inducing norms such as the l1-norm or the block l1-norm. We assume that the kernel decomposes into a large sum of individual basis kernels which can be embedded in a directed acyclic graph; we show that it is then possible to perform kernel selection through a hierarchical multiple kernel learning framework, in polynomial time in the number of selected kernels. This framework is naturally applied to non linear variable selection; our extensive simulations on synthetic datasets and datasets from the UCI repository show that efficiently exploring the large feature space through sparsity-inducing norms leads to state-of-the-art predictive performance.
[ -0.0010957646882161498, -0.05190025269985199, 0.023274535313248634, -0.013136009685695171, 0.010850664228200912, -0.09682444483041763, 0.0013430118560791016, 0.03737611696124077, -0.06516143679618835, -0.005657108034938574, 0.002636719262227416, -0.07654465734958649, 0.01141424011439085, 0.052151553332805634, -0.03539640083909035, 0.06198955327272415, 0.023551026359200478, -0.05155058205127716, 0.005785190034657717, -0.060911692678928375, 0.05812765657901764, -0.035734664648771286, 0.057677604258060455, -0.04177844896912575, -0.010514229536056519, 0.05564068630337715, 0.011264827102422714, -0.01047322154045105, 0.033934611827135086, 0.011176187545061111, -0.08267083019018173, -0.0055193183943629265, -0.007564900908619165, -0.007924509234726429, -0.03298988565802574, -0.027281692251563072, -0.03481847792863846, 0.0327974408864975, -0.03924236074090004, -0.0176297128200531, 0.028169244527816772, -0.05008073151111603, -0.029387708753347397, 0.0025106517132371664, -0.0033041206188499928, 0.05709385871887207, -0.015883099287748337, -0.06588605791330338, -0.023303451016545296, 0.028859948739409447, -0.07367876917123795, 0.05457966402173042, 0.01927722804248333, 0.001165849738754332, -0.04340212419629097, -0.004508886951953173, -0.05738154053688049, -0.02757970057427883, 0.04693122208118439, -0.02380652353167534, 0.02679666504263878, 0.04831483215093613, -0.03206378221511841, 0.018667293712496758, 0.015186183154582977, 0.031246662139892578, 0.00929209403693676, -0.001475707278586924, -0.019426114857196808, -0.01944558508694172, 0.05432760342955589, -0.08536786586046219, -0.021579498425126076, 0.06533494591712952, 0.04958825558423996, 0.011922997422516346, -0.03690613806247711, 0.010229641571640968, 0.06933722645044327, 0.12946800887584686, -0.04262876138091087, 0.05201559513807297, 0.05590953305363655, 0.030762042850255966, -0.03962487727403641, 0.020480645820498466, 0.019823841750621796, -0.07286339998245239, 0.001998992171138525, 0.030243191868066788, -0.0419374518096447, 0.08002541959285736, -0.03121337667107582, 0.07143096625804901, -0.04051819443702698, -0.01485324464738369, -0.08115094155073166, -0.010184954851865768, 0.02346641570329666, 0.01143551804125309, 0.016606507822871208, -0.01360006257891655, 0.02204233780503273, 0.08538339287042618, -0.07739123702049255, 0.038469720631837845, -0.02305516228079796, -0.027051499113440514, -0.0155011722818017, -0.0043245162814855576, 0.03992016986012459, -0.04657901078462601, 0.019008586183190346, 0.011988753452897072, -0.09528931230306625, 0.0863087847828865, -0.034051310271024704, 0.059892259538173676, -0.003862714162096381, -0.009441879577934742, 0.04294784367084503, 0.025410719215869904, -0.11605627834796906, -0.013488620519638062, -0.013987686485052109, -0.08669113367795944, 0.001358715584501624, -0.07942426204681396, 0.08251556009054184, 0.11230003088712692, -0.022198844701051712, 0.09674957394599915, -0.007525416556745768, -0.011476277373731136, -0.029692191630601883, 0.052579574286937714, 0.014305160380899906, -0.04853910207748413, 0.00005917937960475683, 0.06858202069997787, -0.07945700734853745, -0.05944007635116577, -0.004439210053533316, 0.01756219193339348, -0.01037835143506527, 0.003399318316951394, -0.034106891602277756, 0.029670702293515205, 0.01909189671278, -0.03464619070291519, 0.03552622348070145, -0.08386002480983734, 0.04915548488497734, 0.04584740474820137, 0.017134932801127434, -0.0746329203248024, -0.011804393492639065, 0.00844863336533308, 0.038292381912469864, -0.015128258615732193, -0.03601699694991112, -0.0010179111268371344, 0.0028802587185055017, 0.01114056259393692, 0.013118649832904339, -0.037746284157037735, -0.047184497117996216, 0.0212585236877203, -0.039794597774744034, -0.04164250195026398, -0.006928541231900454, 0.002051763469353318, -0.016344884410500526, 0.013393950648605824, 0.00809694267809391, 0.022949054837226868, 0.010634002275764942, 0.03620177507400513, -0.012663539499044418, -0.07714716345071793, 0.03923233225941658, 0.040360040962696075, -0.030721765011548996, 0.011579900979995728, 0.014504758641123772, 0.04961434751749039, -0.02254393696784973, 0.01015749666839838, 0.03737734258174896, -0.01652633398771286, 0.01896335557103157, -0.01813669688999653, 0.04820677265524864, 0.028904832899570465, -0.07926879823207855, 0.05263582989573479, -0.019918544217944145, -0.019070319831371307, 0.035826969891786575, 0.10282602906227112, 0.08464274555444717, -0.013446113094687462, 0.04408375173807144, -0.08323216438293457, -0.07251770049333572, 0.0018687167903408408, 0.10401340574026108, -0.031797606498003006, -0.0549127571284771, 0.03591593727469444, 0.012315466068685055, 0.00224803457967937, -0.0077409157529473305, -0.014675116166472435, -0.003251135814934969, -0.04562869295477867, 0.05191123113036156, 0.00272310059517622, 0.06334469467401505, 0.026030361652374268, -0.04472385346889496, 0.025633295997977257, -0.03145628795027733, -0.006028244271874428, -0.08128079026937485, 0.005276525858789682, 0.001043224474415183, -0.11719733476638794, -0.015269927680492401, 0.05871516838669777, -0.08331002295017242, -0.01850559562444687, -0.0039100851863622665, -0.024806804955005646, -0.0370151586830616, 0.0398394949734211, -0.0345967672765255, -0.050336290150880814, 0.021235555410385132, 0.023795777931809425, 0.008395474404096603, -0.0095003517344594, -0.026200076565146446, -0.040060173720121384, 0.011041823774576187, -0.054266754537820816, 0.04493756219744682, 0.0762285590171814, -0.011188268661499023, -0.00894783902913332, -0.05223718285560608, -0.061313360929489136, -0.017664557322859764, -0.022120334208011627, -0.04454978182911873, 0.002017825609073043, -0.03965926915407181, 0.00425031827762723, 0.05147303268313408, 0.05180659517645836, 0.03796064481139183, 0.005974170286208391, -0.03470019996166229, -0.02875368297100067, 0.015115570276975632, -0.04289056733250618, 0.007414492778480053, 0.005118049681186676, -0.03986060991883278, 0.06744938343763351, -0.006305770482867956, -0.09478731453418732, -0.057899244129657745, 0.07266036421060562, -0.03832913562655449, 0.014813205227255821, 0.010485874488949776, 0.011560455895960331, 0.06461358070373535, -0.053317293524742126, -0.003807349596172571, -0.006098379381000996, -0.009249774739146233, -0.0658244788646698, -0.05478298291563988, 0.0204226803034544, -0.03890671953558922, -0.03205801174044609, 0.05946004018187523, 0.05316152423620224, -0.011798388324677944, 0.018438948318362236, -0.07117636501789093, -0.019760875031352043, 0.060757361352443695, -0.06196284294128418, 0.06401412189006805, -0.0263055469840765, -0.021790754050016403, 0.0038660706486552954, 0.07672768831253052, 0.00427494291216135, 0.032918304204940796, -0.029242899268865585, 0.045857984572649, 0.025280270725488663, 0.0900966078042984, 0.046827178448438644, -0.08654218912124634, 0.030673891305923462, 0.06179031357169151, 0.03714248165488243, -0.00461275689303875, 0.011853364296257496, -0.017243249341845512, -0.022548481822013855, -0.024290336295962334, 0.010217954404652119, -0.09780199080705643, 0.0028750700876116753, 0.0015926244668662548, 0.059669025242328644, 0.02744092047214508, -0.041061364114284515, -0.11042118817567825, -0.03474999591708183, 0.06271684914827347, 0.06289558857679367, -0.09102103114128113, -0.025625644251704216, -0.015950612723827362, 0.00009735727508086711, -0.05182972177863121, 0.08383210003376007, -0.02591354213654995, -0.0013203812995925546, -0.11157441884279251, -0.05250613018870354, -0.07879360020160675, -0.036179039627313614, 0.012337555177509785, -0.050592195242643356, 0.006757623981684446, 0.02636445127427578, 0.04495298117399216, 0.05529385805130005, 0.048135969787836075, -0.042469192296266556, -0.10827897489070892, 0.09243994206190109, -0.054859619587659836, 0.07460980117321014, -0.04401770606637001, 0.03466445580124855, -0.07005499303340912, 0.0881110206246376, 0.07525501400232315, -0.08835233747959137, -0.030797496438026428, -0.007132250349968672, -0.042916879057884216, 0.03423150256276131, 0.0014689970994368196, 0.043186724185943604, 0.05118297040462494, 0.03927552327513695, -0.021746419370174408, -0.011589271016418934, -0.09763230383396149, 0.017415590584278107, 0.029293280094861984, 0.09413010627031326, 0.04079194366931915, 0.002909216098487377, -0.03495320305228233, -0.08542437106370926, 0.0024291928857564926, -0.0359635166823864, 0.06395343691110611, 0.04126274958252907, 0.015684233978390694, 0.02303934283554554, -0.033421073108911514, 0.035597145557403564, -0.02781769260764122, -0.059439223259687424, 0.0054329982958734035, 0.029564611613750458, 0.06094151362776756, 0.0031584794633090496, 0.0029271310195326805, -0.03656959906220436, -0.015260118059813976, 0.004059205297380686, 0.04891052842140198, -0.028415482491254807, 0.052563637495040894, -0.03605525568127632, -0.024707024917006493, 0.021748948842287064, -0.03280407935380936, 0.011009057983756065, -0.00922381691634655, -0.040022946894168854, -0.05615082383155823, 0.00225279713049531, -0.007369908969849348, 0.030764034017920494, 0.020596355199813843, 0.05075258016586304, 0.0005235811113379896, 0.022863497957587242, -0.017193052917718887, -0.03799724951386452, -0.003588753053918481, 0.017117999494075775, -0.04796686768531799, -0.04437698423862457, -0.03729790449142456, -0.046058885753154755, -0.02510218322277069, -0.0007695709355175495, 0.013615217991173267, 0.025438407436013222, -0.011026247404515743, 0.00006568542448803782, 0.009112399071455002, 0.027223628014326096, 0.03482514247298241, -0.011251276358962059, -0.04890728369355202, -0.01788603514432907, -0.10059669613838196, -0.01404308807104826, 0.06325627863407135, 0.0016802630852907896, 0.040871310979127884, -0.015438308008015156, 0.02067762427031994, -0.02083410881459713, 0.0284733809530735, -0.0589950755238533, 0.03850835561752319, -0.003865482984110713, 0.037539318203926086, 0.03845423832535744, -0.011760302819311619, -0.022392766550183296, 0.08182777464389801, 0.06944065541028976, -0.023558974266052246, -0.042598675936460495, 0.04121509939432144, -0.01610642671585083, -0.012913994491100311, -0.004119241144508123, 0.05656014755368233, -0.038805700838565826, 0.03264136612415314, -0.03760470822453499, -0.006873378064483404, -0.05893506109714508, 0.04468100890517235, 0.03909977898001671, -0.09468993544578552, 0.012430464848876, 0.05469674617052078, 0.05544388294219971, -0.006145791616290808, -0.013314344920217991, -0.045860759913921356, 0.0554688461124897, -0.010617081075906754, -0.09092991799116135, 0.04583340883255005, -0.01628480665385723, 0.010928641073405743, -0.038203440606594086, -0.02440560795366764, 0.023197239264845848, 0.023242874071002007, -0.010762527585029602, -0.033680614084005356, 0.010238558985292912, -0.0682109147310257, 0.03870132938027382, 0.012499198317527771, 0.023947201669216156, -0.00780145451426506, -0.0030727065168321133, -0.07393313199281693, -0.005475588608533144, -0.011081147007644176, -0.0011823506793007255, 0.007616890128701925, -0.0012897260021418333, 0.013552689924836159, -0.038638267666101456, 0.045445721596479416, 0.02228068746626377, 0.004618232604116201, 0.010605876334011555, 0.0517742857336998, -0.010784180834889412, 0.14211849868297577, 0.020654818043112755, 0.025028763338923454, -0.036024369299411774, 0.013982248492538929, 0.04134601727128029, 0.010837375186383724, 0.015207969583570957 ]
145
145
When is there a representer theorem? Vector versus matrix regularizers
We consider a general class of regularization methods which learn a vector of parameters on the basis of linear measurements. It is well known that if the regularizer is a nondecreasing function of the inner product then the learned vector is a linear combination of the input data. This result, known as the {\em representer theorem}, is at the basis of kernel-based methods in machine learning. In this paper, we prove the necessity of the above condition, thereby completing the characterization of kernel methods based on regularization. We further extend our analysis to regularization methods which learn a matrix, a problem which is motivated by the application to multi-task learning. In this context, we study a more general representer theorem, which holds for a larger class of regularizers. We provide a necessary and sufficient condition for these class of matrix regularizers and highlight them with some concrete examples of practical importance. Our analysis uses basic principles from matrix theory, especially the useful notion of matrix nondecreasing function.
[ 0.0014649444492533803, -0.060095809400081635, 0.06937357038259506, -0.059223078191280365, -0.00939339492470026, -0.03337147831916809, 0.007249616552144289, 0.017454316839575768, -0.024541357532143593, 0.05052120238542557, 0.03129131719470024, 0.05861462280154228, -0.043494876474142075, 0.08895360678434372, 0.019931133836507797, 0.01840207912027836, 0.05635887756943703, -0.021217161789536476, 0.02323458157479763, -0.06284759193658829, 0.00814745295792818, -0.044580601155757904, -0.022987181320786476, -0.036057669669389725, -0.016185572370886803, 0.021087218075990677, -0.014549472369253635, -0.023360097780823708, -0.0068428064696490765, -0.06067797914147377, -0.021621063351631165, 0.038574013859033585, -0.008327835239470005, -0.039194297045469284, -0.031287748366594315, 0.01858110912144184, 0.07656791061162949, 0.04201111942529678, -0.08678299188613892, 0.034755829721689224, 0.02386590465903282, -0.016792796552181244, 0.028842095285654068, -0.0009462271118536592, -0.015582981519401073, 0.03440875932574272, 0.028471814468503, -0.07467225939035416, -0.03483569994568825, 0.093965545296669, -0.045804303139448166, 0.03608545660972595, -0.05553510785102844, -0.023145653307437897, -0.0013251175405457616, 0.03219934180378914, 0.04115476459264755, 0.0037482038605958223, -0.001498902915045619, -0.02794184349477291, 0.06485158950090408, 0.05801764875650406, 0.05725538730621338, -0.0013650516048073769, 0.06080125272274017, 0.019468769431114197, -0.06631714850664139, -0.03901604935526848, -0.03618140146136284, -0.07351291179656982, -0.012058760970830917, -0.043849073350429535, -0.005904282908886671, 0.007367179729044437, 0.028264088556170464, -0.0031576596666127443, -0.03668460249900818, -0.011031415313482285, 0.018542766571044922, 0.06710875034332275, -0.021730663254857063, -0.0027869793120771646, -0.012673087418079376, 0.04352954030036926, -0.028455423191189766, 0.013332358561456203, -0.03591790422797203, -0.018693234771490097, 0.03149066120386124, 0.01936281844973564, 0.022624313831329346, 0.0008462732075713575, -0.06357266753911972, 0.049710698425769806, 0.020783523097634315, -0.049216706305742264, -0.043369539082050323, -0.10379520058631897, -0.00562390498816967, -0.0062576658092439175, 0.045081980526447296, 0.02489974908530712, 0.04132034629583359, 0.10650264471769333, -0.06444896012544632, -0.008506685495376587, 0.009888710454106331, 0.04483473673462868, 0.017923790961503983, 0.03298921510577202, 0.04003973677754402, -0.0472453348338604, 0.055767256766557693, -0.02758442796766758, -0.009729943238198757, 0.05701228603720665, 0.02753360942006111, 0.09420910477638245, -0.0040533458814024925, -0.010773997753858566, -0.014618555083870888, -0.021286794915795326, 0.017235342413187027, 0.04395794868469238, 0.038446810096502304, 0.00258105481043458, 0.017260173335671425, -0.11791631579399109, 0.08808448165655136, 0.04302751645445824, -0.011335691437125206, -0.001092584920115769, -0.0002714893489610404, -0.04767345264554024, -0.022154202684760094, -0.0046023218892514706, 0.021905018016695976, -0.03880685195326805, -0.08342012763023376, -0.006381317973136902, -0.026553545147180557, 0.010897030122578144, 0.009796466678380966, -0.012864149175584316, -0.0015797681408002973, 0.052483826875686646, -0.03148772194981575, -0.03280901908874512, 0.005243418738245964, -0.040089577436447144, 0.026113973930478096, 0.04990213364362717, 0.0319434255361557, -0.010474452748894691, 0.04853711649775505, -0.06271085888147354, -0.02488512359559536, -0.0022993595339357853, -0.025379719212651253, 0.0596235953271389, -0.06492966413497925, -0.0050368099473416805, -0.003397779306396842, 0.07282638549804688, -0.072543665766716, -0.05740008503198624, -0.05448710545897484, -0.04535527527332306, -0.0924782082438469, -0.007413612212985754, -0.10740072280168533, -0.0250533539801836, -0.021141139790415764, 0.019641077145934105, 0.006867079995572567, -0.04223979637026787, -0.010244312696158886, 0.02758815698325634, -0.0868343859910965, -0.10623607784509659, -0.022930443286895752, -0.059255488216876984, -0.02021244540810585, 0.008248811587691307, 0.045670200139284134, 0.0691155344247818, -0.010056612081825733, -0.0508527047932148, 0.04055304080247879, 0.026692425832152367, 0.0761609897017479, -0.053894173353910446, -0.0713377296924591, 0.03389563038945198, -0.03139490261673927, 0.059453047811985016, -0.055517956614494324, -0.03759726509451866, 0.013140284456312656, -0.0061832149513065815, 0.04211343079805374, -0.05714401975274086, 0.03661571443080902, -0.11011300981044769, -0.09927495568990707, 0.03816908225417137, 0.0942368283867836, -0.061499327421188354, -0.05230051279067993, -0.01252678781747818, -0.007349096238613129, -0.01005344558507204, 0.01109399925917387, -0.045445822179317474, -0.0017146056052297354, -0.11385726928710938, 0.013166350312530994, -0.028963955119252205, 0.032760217785835266, 0.035065580159425735, -0.050923120230436325, 0.026976406574249268, 0.004489200655370951, 0.055657923221588135, -0.09173335880041122, -0.025851430371403694, 0.019082969054579735, 0.008219894021749496, -0.05154312774538994, 0.019104884937405586, -0.058998171240091324, -0.06434328854084015, -0.027465282008051872, -0.02500939555466175, -0.008023395203053951, 0.02472085691988468, -0.08870004862546921, -0.05153196305036545, 0.006887229159474373, -0.03208093345165253, -0.015713751316070557, 0.020983438938856125, -0.020675053820014, -0.06391175836324692, -0.03429261967539787, -0.029858393594622612, -0.005856472998857498, 0.06327331811189651, -0.037947893142700195, -0.1105571761727333, 0.03238533437252045, 0.025908181443810463, -0.019893964752554893, -0.04974827170372009, 0.012067177332937717, 0.02461257018148899, -0.047120336443185806, 0.013226496055722237, 0.0369517020881176, 0.005855104885995388, 0.022062841802835464, 0.013396399095654488, -0.09093111008405685, 0.07697899639606476, 0.06033561751246452, -0.03460448607802391, 0.022492598742246628, 0.0010652575874701142, 0.010545379482209682, 0.052266985177993774, -0.011799073778092861, -0.08202581852674484, -0.08651304990053177, 0.0024133138358592987, -0.0026917082723230124, 0.006897771265357733, -0.002589445561170578, 0.0031097563914954662, -0.013853500597178936, -0.07413740456104279, -0.012400131672620773, 0.020150786265730858, 0.009442133828997612, -0.03022516332566738, -0.08508139848709106, -0.026752101257443428, 0.03042435646057129, 0.0513625293970108, 0.05998731404542923, 0.0665743499994278, -0.05607803538441658, 0.04715118184685707, -0.0349971167743206, 0.005242057144641876, 0.04869088530540466, -0.05624882131814957, 0.06553482264280319, -0.022345850244164467, -0.02214318886399269, 0.02051527425646782, 0.0595381073653698, 0.005986467469483614, 0.009070031344890594, 0.005957281216979027, 0.08070959150791168, 0.030434072017669678, 0.07327185571193695, 0.0763116180896759, 0.02008666843175888, 0.009001543745398521, -0.043762143701314926, -0.07655273377895355, 0.027422070503234863, -0.06311345845460892, 0.0037001254968345165, 0.0027814223431050777, -0.008598160929977894, -0.038811154663562775, -0.016777150332927704, 0.010480595752596855, 0.020508991554379463, 0.035728082060813904, 0.01661531813442707, -0.02066262997686863, -0.09094970673322678, -0.008009282872080803, -0.05217037722468376, 0.02538810670375824, -0.0721500962972641, -0.05497413128614426, -0.039852868765592575, 0.0062444331124424934, 0.029684584587812424, 0.06644994020462036, 0.011537197045981884, 0.0061788009479641914, -0.017185447737574577, -0.014859145507216454, -0.08209113776683807, 0.008301645517349243, -0.07687437534332275, -0.1309545487165451, -0.04833567887544632, 0.01897280663251877, -0.004470903892070055, 0.03157895430922508, 0.04629801958799362, -0.06780542433261871, -0.07632370293140411, -0.021447615697979927, -0.05724519118666649, 0.032444506883621216, -0.03514379635453224, -0.008230466395616531, -0.04176343232393265, 0.04415380209684372, 0.07828644663095474, -0.01948660984635353, 0.015699727460741997, -0.009073931723833084, 0.0016036608722060919, 0.01850791648030281, -0.029389433562755585, 0.05667751654982567, 0.0039519076235592365, 0.04259687662124634, -0.0030278139747679234, 0.017102984711527824, 0.015775978565216064, -0.001927424455061555, -0.030075307935476303, 0.03584533929824829, 0.07426692545413971, 0.028320955112576485, 0.028128301724791527, -0.07152801007032394, 0.038644347339868546, -0.02200418710708618, 0.04681944474577904, 0.03305544704198837, -0.02577991411089897, 0.0068392506800591946, -0.016567060723900795, 0.06474626809358597, -0.00912319403141737, -0.04473316669464111, 0.002125766593962908, -0.02052590809762478, 0.07168073207139969, -0.01436424721032381, -0.06535407155752182, -0.0036911156494170427, -0.03495209291577339, 0.023616589605808258, 0.021852444857358932, 0.003194012911990285, 0.05529237538576126, 0.02106057107448578, -0.00024412076163571328, -0.009448276832699776, -0.01110820472240448, -0.027615193277597427, 0.03340373560786247, -0.05180692300200462, -0.044779300689697266, 0.03836420550942421, -0.011217963881790638, 0.053058817982673645, -0.03197972849011421, 0.02295794151723385, 0.0007461715140379965, 0.010843783617019653, -0.10249783843755722, -0.020543470978736877, 0.034209419041872025, 0.056279588490724564, 0.013289287686347961, -0.01683528907597065, 0.05305994674563408, -0.09221047163009644, 0.02649019844830036, 0.04759053513407707, 0.0630388855934143, 0.02455708384513855, -0.03032238408923149, 0.019343474879860878, 0.05248550698161125, 0.0903514176607132, 0.024235909804701805, -0.03346911817789078, -0.03924965485930443, 0.08965490758419037, -0.06590954214334488, 0.013376069255173206, 0.02965146116912365, -0.03290916234254837, 0.0670386478304863, 0.03626416251063347, 0.014409043826162815, 0.014147097244858742, -0.03710654750466347, -0.0006300274399109185, 0.003227311186492443, -0.04662150889635086, 0.08335860073566437, 0.05816764757037163, 0.024084480479359627, -0.006502827163785696, 0.05551723390817642, 0.025087282061576843, -0.026323674246668816, 0.005009884480386972, 0.032983578741550446, -0.016118356958031654, 0.055130597203969955, 0.03433019667863846, 0.06919848173856735, 0.02127489075064659, -0.010683775879442692, -0.056767985224723816, -0.027987463399767876, -0.02082974649965763, 0.03250317648053169, -0.006631502415984869, -0.09984876215457916, 0.011966471560299397, 0.03754314407706261, 0.010254282504320145, -0.02426435798406601, -0.004585193004459143, -0.05982941389083862, 0.03099415823817253, 0.025276079773902893, -0.015336739830672741, 0.03692595660686493, 0.04726382717490196, -0.013301946222782135, -0.037973079830408096, 0.004826121497899294, 0.04035014659166336, 0.018296457827091217, -0.09373505413532257, 0.050677720457315445, 0.01763947121798992, 0.01015335414558649, 0.01814216934144497, 0.01824217662215233, 0.009522050619125366, 0.06463253498077393, -0.002858576364815235, -0.054161377251148224, 0.06643062829971313, 0.024922259151935577, -0.0013981626834720373, 0.008928230032324791, -0.049633391201496124, -0.08962893486022949, 0.0033375006169080734, 0.012507292442023754, 0.09740062057971954, -0.0030010708142071962, 0.013672315515577793, 0.01177739817649126, -0.011160488240420818, 0.06345546245574951, 0.021548796445131302, 0.03900764510035515, -0.07541172951459885, 0.015641648322343826, 0.12070567160844803, -0.01867319829761982, 0.05906078219413757 ]
146
146
Low congestion online routing and an improved mistake bound for online prediction of graph labeling
In this paper, we show a connection between a certain online low-congestion routing problem and an online prediction of graph labeling. More specifically, we prove that if there exists a routing scheme that guarantees a congestion of $\alpha$ on any edge, there exists an online prediction algorithm with mistake bound $\alpha$ times the cut size, which is the size of the cut induced by the label partitioning of graph vertices. With previous known bound of $O(\log n)$ for $\alpha$ for the routing problem on trees with $n$ vertices, we obtain an improved prediction algorithm for graphs with high effective resistance. In contrast to previous approaches that move the graph problem into problems in vector space using graph Laplacian and rely on the analysis of the perceptron algorithm, our proof are purely combinatorial. Further more, our approach directly generalizes to the case where labels are not binary.
[ 0.044105302542448044, -0.05496208742260933, 0.03707534447312355, -0.06367719173431396, 0.003529015462845564, -0.03909192234277725, 0.06391755491495132, -0.0426676981151104, -0.01835930533707142, 0.04518292099237442, -0.0018108260119333863, -0.0551302470266819, -0.023230547085404396, -0.00011482732952572405, 0.09503716230392456, -0.034242577850818634, -0.005980946589261293, 0.06219294294714928, -0.006840490736067295, -0.0009608433465473354, 0.002181068994104862, 0.010710880160331726, -0.023211708292365074, -0.003443158697336912, 0.08047150075435638, -7.504399945901241e-8, -0.008165608160197735, 0.05576641485095024, -0.011649896390736103, 0.04238465428352356, -0.08618739247322083, 0.0187003742903471, -0.004615026526153088, 0.039736729115247726, 0.02983352355659008, -0.0406733900308609, 0.013351968489587307, 0.007376129738986492, -0.012152095325291157, -0.07286408543586731, 0.10929420590400696, -0.07657498121261597, -0.020816484466195107, -0.007708382327109575, -0.017115633934736252, -0.07118415832519531, -0.04149752855300903, 0.02719895727932453, -0.018321862444281578, 0.08563340455293655, -0.03454672917723656, 0.024235360324382782, -0.08179458975791931, 0.02055301144719124, 0.030926132574677467, 0.02289205603301525, -0.04673870652914047, -0.03911648690700531, 0.057456932961940765, -0.07037760317325592, 0.028769811615347862, 0.10558054596185684, -0.07013384252786636, -0.05302877351641655, -0.09452894330024719, 0.05234641209244728, 0.0032433553133159876, 0.025258056819438934, 0.040770236402750015, 0.021323611959815025, -0.03249529376626015, -0.015882708132267, 0.017202772200107574, 0.08841211348772049, 0.0280730202794075, 0.013472619466483593, -0.027371808886528015, -0.040755655616521835, -0.007036901079118252, 0.07485833019018173, -0.04754485934972763, 0.10501261055469513, -0.050593577325344086, 0.031163962557911873, 0.031897254288196564, 0.03193347156047821, 0.014922627247869968, 0.0019459909526631236, -0.008030261844396591, -0.043380916118621826, 0.0008591762743890285, 0.01949401944875717, -0.058497194200754166, -0.00206518592312932, -0.056329187005758286, 0.027224475517868996, -0.009859245270490646, -0.029132580384612083, -0.010217368602752686, 0.037649236619472504, -0.019843274727463722, 0.012170475907623768, -0.007106056436896324, 0.012190586887300014, -0.0779556855559349, 0.017451882362365723, -0.016421137377619743, 0.030545350164175034, 0.09575870633125305, -0.09141980111598969, 0.018116721883416176, 0.057550616562366486, -0.04355937987565994, 0.0054259891621768475, 0.0345383919775486, 0.02406257763504982, -0.029284995049238205, 0.06675013154745102, -0.04070895537734032, 0.001494976575486362, 0.011427844874560833, 0.028439873829483986, -0.04283498600125313, 0.028387323021888733, -0.028546016663312912, -0.06209280714392662, -0.039624109864234924, -0.01109354943037033, 0.04154878109693527, 0.04056094214320183, -0.09502523392438889, 0.0850115641951561, -0.008252752013504505, -0.006814165506511927, -0.10310614854097366, 0.014002930372953415, 0.05204235389828682, -0.007893913425505161, -0.050530191510915756, 0.04554970934987068, -0.027522286400198936, -0.07140810787677765, -0.020424334332346916, 0.020723911002278328, 0.04219517856836319, 0.09473858773708344, -0.013692667707800865, -0.05342410132288933, -0.0039045142475515604, -0.019947316497564316, 0.0062465849332511425, -0.01553464774042368, 0.021816611289978027, 0.038140591233968735, 0.07176585495471954, -0.07470184564590454, -0.06345536559820175, -0.04770112782716751, -0.019251730293035507, 0.014617870561778545, -0.000587577058468014, 0.0368582084774971, -0.017996612936258316, 0.003544118022546172, 0.012274461798369884, -0.005461071617901325, 0.015652718022465706, 0.003620903007686138, -0.02834862284362316, -0.052308909595012665, 0.06592758744955063, -0.05218503251671791, -0.006034443154931068, 0.013241221196949482, 0.01009016577154398, -0.05753597617149353, 0.059480562806129456, -0.02467603236436844, -0.04158487170934677, -0.03340356424450874, 0.08467645198106766, -0.04792111739516258, 0.014261881820857525, -0.014608629047870636, 0.06208634376525879, 0.07471867650747299, 0.0058934953995049, 0.0330093577504158, 0.050987374037504196, 0.08182261139154434, -0.024998823180794716, 0.05729701370000839, 0.010341903194785118, 0.038295287638902664, -0.054506879299879074, 0.03810201957821846, -0.025748243555426598, 0.03162653371691704, -0.010054885409772396, -0.01635945774614811, 0.05297442153096199, 0.04392895847558975, -0.07727210968732834, -0.0911535993218422, -0.04538033530116081, 0.006956178694963455, 0.061059702187776566, -0.0878947377204895, -0.008290620520710945, -0.052113112062215805, -0.0325508676469326, 0.01193137839436531, 0.009394487366080284, -0.001401506713591516, 0.01852240040898323, -0.011783729307353497, 0.011221708729863167, -0.05682952329516411, 0.04540213942527771, -0.007687937933951616, -0.0005398165085352957, 0.10862402617931366, -0.012523366138339043, -0.012158478610217571, -0.05116375535726547, 0.06480792164802551, 0.044440336525440216, -0.0075887106359004974, 0.01650744490325451, 0.08702542632818222, 0.01239263266324997, -0.12087006866931915, -0.019942067563533783, 0.02069353312253952, -0.015347225591540337, 0.13619935512542725, -0.018818648532032967, -0.009128612466156483, -0.07257408648729324, -0.013104323297739029, -0.01665141060948372, 0.018818972632288933, -0.03759274259209633, -0.05470126122236252, 0.003959102556109428, 0.029781511053442955, 0.054236460477113724, 0.004604720044881105, 0.011762036941945553, -0.020454052835702896, -0.04565401375293732, -0.012737949378788471, -0.027013758197426796, -0.04690006002783775, -0.017088700085878372, 0.02535098046064377, 0.007143778260797262, 0.0879591703414917, 0.1348332166671753, 0.10634659975767136, 0.005037663970142603, 0.014888819307088852, -0.08963043242692947, 0.007173360791057348, 0.07774204760789871, 0.019819136708974838, 0.023999731987714767, 0.010821985080838203, 0.01791328378021717, -0.012479417026042938, 0.0165314432233572, -0.026997528970241547, -0.08071985840797424, 0.09513001888990402, -0.004157530143857002, -0.008682840503752232, -0.004709896165877581, -0.009001657366752625, 0.021867385134100914, -0.021356651559472084, -0.03927019238471985, -0.031109634786844254, 0.09618905931711197, 0.028003890067338943, -0.003810073947533965, 0.01012478582561016, 0.010824025608599186, -0.05098269134759903, 0.06079340726137161, 0.03421039879322052, -0.06068902462720871, 0.04255793243646622, -0.0831805169582367, 0.01990543119609356, -0.007872936315834522, -0.08968695998191833, 0.02624044567346573, 0.004604944959282875, 0.008392710238695145, -0.017568061128258705, -0.003920198418200016, 0.04744797945022583, 0.09791167080402374, 0.06677074730396271, 0.028530308976769447, 0.0619593970477581, 0.01965339295566082, -0.03585776686668396, 0.0035127797164022923, -0.0318499319255352, -0.006755020469427109, -0.025527946650981903, -0.01032306719571352, -0.05755646526813507, 0.014234887436032295, -0.030494488775730133, -0.03752278909087181, -0.034798797219991684, -0.042379606515169144, 0.05099257826805115, -0.018356913700699806, -0.0008850044687278569, -0.012814403511583805, 0.01401052437722683, -0.037821054458618164, 0.022077864035964012, 0.013858703896403313, 0.026893047615885735, -0.06216038018465042, -0.013210390694439411, -0.04458797350525856, -0.0188345517963171, -0.06105561926960945, 0.03068096935749054, 0.007411905564367771, 0.009815560653805733, -0.0723370909690857, 0.028572848066687584, -0.032538700848817825, 0.009884283877909184, -0.047989632934331894, -0.07501372694969177, -0.018800143152475357, 0.029110709205269814, -0.02667507529258728, 0.006572963669896126, 0.042685944586992264, -0.011433033272624016, -0.008482460863888264, 0.012348800897598267, -0.07799296826124191, -0.0108614731580019, 0.011560162529349327, 0.04931753873825073, -0.007209812290966511, -0.024116920307278633, 0.06987232714891434, -0.08601006865501404, -0.017011038959026337, 0.028626123443245888, -0.016772354021668434, 0.00016730809875298291, -0.03139444813132286, 0.00026342945056967437, 0.047218985855579376, 0.024219350889325142, -0.03737267851829529, -0.013876943849027157, -0.050663866102695465, 0.08041555434465408, 0.05444161966443062, 0.007759869564324617, -0.00657509034499526, -0.04141852259635925, 0.058314621448516846, -0.0070271724835038185, 0.0458599291741848, -0.10789410024881363, 0.01918254792690277, 0.07424817234277725, 0.006368416361510754, 0.06577684730291367, -0.05637405067682266, -0.004133653827011585, 0.05137670040130615, -0.03173490986227989, -0.009854578413069248, -0.03483114391565323, 0.06252457201480865, 0.009641182608902454, 0.04468019679188728, -0.010671782307326794, 0.017150215804576874, -0.029987221583724022, 0.004488696809858084, -0.007968652993440628, 0.015397397801280022, 0.006119167897850275, 0.01623387821018696, -0.009414770640432835, 0.016697801649570465, -0.013849440962076187, 0.007114764302968979, -0.032019779086112976, -0.09760726988315582, 0.016814077273011208, 0.030416304245591164, 0.006772811058908701, -0.024403078481554985, 0.030563540756702423, 0.04575926437973976, 0.08283128589391708, -0.06745018810033798, 0.0022384324111044407, 0.0029814401641488075, 0.006174838170409203, 0.02840341441333294, 0.020275933668017387, 0.0012365450384095311, -0.029233185574412346, 0.0288563072681427, 0.017007511109113693, 0.040005121380090714, -0.006452683359384537, -0.0007891227141954005, -0.0415930449962616, 0.028857396915555, 0.04118886962532997, -0.014774782583117485, 0.015306363813579082, -0.05315186455845833, -0.050365790724754333, -0.07248914241790771, -0.0059961252845823765, 0.028256943449378014, -0.0018195167649537325, -0.004963585641235113, -0.002159522380679846, -0.028893740847706795, -0.012516639195382595, -0.021549636498093605, 0.029916120693087578, 0.04371049255132675, 0.03372630476951599, -0.008415824733674526, 0.0739683136343956, 0.011752130463719368, 0.0165551770478487, 0.04326380789279938, -0.07146086543798447, 0.01404864713549614, 0.027814533561468124, 0.02864929847419262, -0.015111900866031647, -0.03861737996339798, -0.02917986921966076, -0.010417218320071697, -0.004149655811488628, 0.035346899181604385, -0.11293990164995193, -0.012639861553907394, -0.031088093295693398, 0.04025993496179581, -0.07001729309558868, 0.012122102081775665, 0.0037320482078939676, 0.019761571660637856, -0.025450842455029488, 0.026283269748091698, -0.03517546132206917, -0.08959514647722244, 0.07840675860643387, -0.020129116252064705, -0.06831453740596771, -0.007861879654228687, -0.004064613487571478, 0.03092840500175953, 0.031068675220012665, 0.05428100377321243, 0.02044338546693325, 0.02065867930650711, 0.02081269398331642, -0.06933213025331497, -0.02894369140267372, 0.06654341518878937, 0.07478969544172287, -0.079554483294487, 0.029762035235762596, 0.07908648997545242, 0.039156194776296616, -0.022628119215369225, -0.059166815131902695, -0.07597402483224869, 0.036196574568748474, 0.005238654091954231, 0.08166257292032242, 0.057129766792058945, 0.005618614610284567, -0.009880008175969124, 0.0877436101436615, 0.06550562381744385, 0.018120884895324707, 0.032657768577337265, 0.06920973211526871, 0.06397246569395065, 0.042728520929813385, 0.019500063732266426, 0.011824313551187515, -0.009699134156107903, -0.0042697470635175705, -0.043126534670591354, 0.04682181403040886 ]
147
147
Clustered Multi-Task Learning: A Convex Formulation
In multi-task learning several related tasks are considered simultaneously, with the hope that by an appropriate sharing of information across tasks, each task may benefit from the others. In the context of learning linear functions for supervised classification or regression, this can be achieved by including a priori information about the weight vectors associated with the tasks, and how they are expected to be related to each other. In this paper, we assume that tasks are clustered into groups, which are unknown beforehand, and that tasks within a group have similar weight vectors. We design a new spectral norm that encodes this a priori assumption, without the prior knowledge of the partition of tasks into groups, resulting in a new convex optimization formulation for multi-task learning. We show in simulations on synthetic examples and on the IEDB MHC-I binding dataset, that our approach outperforms well-known convex methods for multi-task learning, as well as related non convex methods dedicated to the same problem.
[ 0.022790787741541862, -0.013004813343286514, 0.012628661468625069, 0.040346380323171616, 0.048384904861450195, -0.06164025515317917, -0.01720968261361122, -0.023712830618023872, -0.03231888264417648, 0.06696486473083496, -0.02865535207092762, -0.057816702872514725, 0.017730940133333206, 0.007888125255703926, 0.0017603730084374547, 0.042666275054216385, 0.008526728488504887, -0.03302609920501709, 0.052494846284389496, -0.07590032368898392, 0.07087267935276031, -0.03217117115855217, 0.06704456359148026, -0.058453164994716644, 0.020167799666523933, 0.07138039171695709, -0.011523397639393806, -0.014362316578626633, -0.00961723830550909, 0.04939480870962143, -0.038295671343803406, 0.009923900477588177, 0.029865864664316177, -0.03921084478497505, 0.014162573032081127, -0.01645866595208645, 0.04405368119478226, 0.0154503108933568, -0.07148674875497818, -0.013403093442320824, -0.009255333803594112, -0.022353122010827065, 0.009634854272007942, -0.04958876967430115, 0.0447864904999733, -0.007271801121532917, 0.017509669065475464, -0.0296719279140234, 0.009578495286405087, 0.012716946192085743, -0.027561094611883163, 0.025756819173693657, -0.055363476276397705, 0.05212463438510895, 0.020856022834777832, 0.005626108963042498, -0.04021408036351204, 0.02702106162905693, -0.022648345679044724, -0.023985035717487335, 0.033460795879364014, 0.0592033825814724, -0.042409833520650864, -0.013491624034941196, -0.021906979382038116, -0.013263427652418613, -0.0705544501543045, -0.08394570648670197, 0.017197085544466972, 0.022037342190742493, -0.011629483662545681, -0.0368715301156044, -0.05792251229286194, 0.027580447494983673, 0.01201570127159357, 0.04844878986477852, 0.04123595729470253, 0.023065321147441864, -0.026380814611911774, 0.052473586052656174, -0.04466434568166733, 0.02172486111521721, 0.01769128255546093, 0.03526167571544647, -0.06400676816701889, -0.006019638851284981, 0.028701961040496826, -0.027060799300670624, -0.0001347873912891373, 0.02613813430070877, 0.010519825853407383, -0.036700110882520676, -0.043484851717948914, 0.0627514123916626, -0.014093737117946148, 0.03760271891951561, -0.03244714066386223, -0.07412053644657135, -0.024588817730545998, 0.02174273319542408, 0.06379645317792892, 0.005224774591624737, 0.09862535446882248, 0.034552767872810364, -0.029648520052433014, 0.006528272293508053, -0.04424891248345375, 0.006930552423000336, -0.016536088660359383, 0.08146348595619202, 0.012610120698809624, -0.005516956560313702, 0.0526820607483387, -0.016835076734423637, -0.0062019401229918, 0.0089810686185956, -0.03504685312509537, 0.0950128361582756, 0.0556863471865654, 0.04235231131315231, -0.035610560327768326, 0.02422928437590599, -0.058581288903951645, 0.04464559629559517, 0.02962605655193329, -0.03152640163898468, 0.039298176765441895, -0.05805189907550812, 0.10507595539093018, 0.061697665601968765, 0.0016361717134714127, 0.0462241992354393, 0.025560159236192703, -0.020546266809105873, -0.06316116452217102, -0.03715896233916283, 0.06546293944120407, -0.02948821522295475, 0.015804875642061234, 0.06693968921899796, -0.014240815304219723, -0.008570089004933834, -0.031732767820358276, 0.03322692960500717, 0.04243471845984459, 0.002110306406393647, 0.002552781021222472, 0.02943860925734043, -0.01285394188016653, 0.012322681955993176, -0.04449470713734627, -0.05730030685663223, 0.09119869768619537, 0.029088953509926796, 0.013563022948801517, -0.05130350962281227, 0.022614896297454834, -0.025747379288077354, -0.026019610464572906, 0.017005300149321556, -0.016631321981549263, -0.02125115692615509, 0.02777220867574215, 0.020832287147641182, -0.01715267449617386, 0.020954959094524384, 0.005129112396389246, 0.016995664685964584, -0.00811763945966959, -0.04559360817074776, -0.09672901034355164, -0.0005256014410406351, -0.021151479333639145, 0.01732083037495613, -0.04060941934585571, -0.017328105866909027, -0.022029899060726166, 0.030858900398015976, -0.031035179272294044, -0.029486505314707756, -0.0021621049381792545, -0.06567133963108063, 0.015328113920986652, 0.04158259183168411, 0.02732463739812374, 0.11763373762369156, -0.008674451150000095, 0.00835602916777134, 0.05639137700200081, -0.037113554775714874, 0.03085702285170555, -0.04483515024185181, -0.028424305841326714, 0.027465449646115303, -0.08113928884267807, 0.07974530011415482, 0.0128455376252532, 0.027226511389017105, 0.09751562774181366, 0.05073239281773567, 0.04082552343606949, -0.05632023140788078, 0.0046775382943451405, -0.05236268416047096, -0.07127327471971512, -0.0014030522434040904, 0.04377942159771919, -0.04970995709300041, -0.010212542489171028, -0.008696171455085278, 0.00566239096224308, -0.03087024576961994, -0.027347328141331673, -0.015080940909683704, -0.030722247436642647, -0.03684251010417938, 0.0011604176834225655, -0.05959837883710861, -0.017349444329738617, 0.027684442698955536, -0.02620539627969265, 0.01114305853843689, -0.10893774777650833, 0.01649489440023899, -0.09996940195560455, -0.009402196854352951, 0.034035827964544296, -0.06008840352296829, -0.04954547807574272, 0.029632888734340668, -0.05506693199276924, -0.06243867799639702, -0.018990779295563698, 0.000975571689195931, 0.04592449218034744, 0.031310759484767914, -0.03676118329167366, -0.0428469218313694, -0.0320274792611599, -0.08902957290410995, 0.028677923604846, -0.02515973150730133, -0.0121858986094594, -0.01055887434631586, 0.016083423048257828, -0.08229960501194, -0.013189582154154778, 0.003414955921471119, -0.04611021652817726, 0.002577606588602066, -0.005221656523644924, 0.05934061110019684, 0.016697142273187637, 0.03477994725108147, -0.003326395293697715, -0.03986693546175957, -0.026670072227716446, 0.07783306390047073, 0.05807286128401756, 0.058888040482997894, 0.01650081016123295, 0.040853507816791534, -0.05348781496286392, -0.0012019240530207753, 0.0967361181974411, -0.02433226816356182, -0.05056050047278404, -0.0002741951902862638, -0.04463246092200279, 0.016504067927598953, -0.038377054035663605, -0.0894654393196106, -0.04649302363395691, 0.035769812762737274, -0.0499262735247612, 0.006573309190571308, -0.025695670396089554, 0.033994343131780624, 0.04768705740571022, -0.011671838350594044, -0.051662445068359375, 0.06689512729644775, 0.0006164000951685011, -0.011243024840950966, -0.08486957848072052, -0.05306019261479378, 0.035042859613895416, -0.03672550246119499, 0.08892616629600525, 0.06050831824541092, -0.02756636217236519, 0.0009451902587898076, -0.008042116649448872, 0.07139215618371964, 0.06775286793708801, -0.03688966482877731, 0.035542476922273636, 0.07843243330717087, -0.008062470704317093, -0.0142487408593297, 0.07221314311027527, -0.03810356557369232, -0.02562723681330681, 0.016079207882285118, 0.0043489341624081135, 0.08548770099878311, 0.08310612291097641, 0.09092529863119125, -0.011400940828025341, -0.007595428265631199, -0.044259991496801376, -0.014872116036713123, -0.0083203986287117, -0.058076974004507065, -0.01744895800948143, -0.06197758764028549, -0.050330691039562225, 0.05773596838116646, -0.04678253456950188, -0.006711489055305719, 0.09728950262069702, 0.0239449143409729, 0.05246520787477493, -0.04937237873673439, -0.0670119971036911, -0.0637967512011528, 0.004426595754921436, 0.03553241491317749, -0.028565552085638046, 0.019389359280467033, -0.06427852064371109, -0.04844078794121742, -0.05280308797955513, 0.04179280623793602, 0.05050402134656906, -0.05639214441180229, -0.05753807723522186, -0.026536572724580765, -0.02706964686512947, 0.012661797925829887, -0.007044932339340448, -0.0924360528588295, -0.021790800616145134, -0.008382217027246952, -0.026020942255854607, 0.02842457965016365, 0.017026077955961227, -0.009062760509550571, -0.062157679349184036, -0.044110819697380066, -0.10940854251384735, -0.005857905838638544, -0.12314219772815704, 0.009723319672048092, -0.0602501779794693, 0.003979110158979893, 0.07946818321943283, 0.009757010266184807, 0.0031730507034808397, 0.009185337461531162, -0.030414538457989693, 0.016369087621569633, -0.04165516793727875, -0.033421359956264496, -0.034839943051338196, 0.06616047024726868, -0.01631443202495575, -0.003802687395364046, -0.10222062468528748, -0.033553119748830795, 0.0063938875682652, -0.019374888390302658, 0.02227323316037655, -0.012834927067160606, 0.004210886545479298, -0.023989833891391754, -0.0003289837040938437, -0.027144357562065125, 0.008031542412936687, 0.00020843591482844204, -0.022785596549510956, -0.01471847016364336, 0.00867432914674282, 0.06789503246545792, 0.004758686292916536, -0.04206674173474312, 0.003644439624622464, -0.09147156029939651, 0.03331688791513443, 0.0027873062063008547, -0.06385595351457596, -0.07667309045791626, -0.049350716173648834, 0.004937849473208189, 0.05397927761077881, 0.0021135250572115183, -0.025932447984814644, 0.0011313551804050803, -0.07694289088249207, 0.013297142460942268, -0.028796261176466942, 0.02766788750886917, -0.014105021953582764, -0.083861343562603, -0.07220790535211563, 0.06768324971199036, 0.01985234022140503, 0.07964491844177246, -0.04088922217488289, 0.004603907000273466, 0.01686175726354122, 0.052412234246730804, -0.07263046503067017, 0.1044648289680481, -0.011221807450056076, -0.03141108527779579, 0.01522351335734129, 0.03568923845887184, 0.03160741925239563, -0.09252025187015533, 0.026152456179261208, -0.04453327879309654, 0.026594465598464012, 0.007627573329955339, -0.01104197558015585, -0.0010794696863740683, 0.06395331770181656, 0.06325659900903702, -0.023118045181035995, 0.103826142847538, -0.04066479206085205, -0.05703740939497948, -0.0946497768163681, -0.02514159493148327, 0.04647701978683472, 0.018470915034413338, 0.06466154009103775, -0.010268336161971092, 0.05749134719371796, -0.03326556086540222, -0.042004987597465515, 0.0671200305223465, 0.002353599527850747, -0.05246821790933609, 0.020975900813937187, 0.1336013823747635, 0.07218388468027115, -0.006862057838588953, 0.055752597749233246, 0.0010985811240971088, -0.021408021450042725, -0.0029021860100328922, 0.07186634093523026, 0.002997121075168252, -0.0319720022380352, -0.0020577332470566034, 0.031236618757247925, -0.041772156953811646, 0.06513241678476334, -0.076207734644413, -0.05933699011802673, -0.017457205802202225, 0.046057652682065964, 0.008292888291180134, -0.07690940797328949, 0.07005403190851212, 0.00891084410250187, -0.01019033882766962, 0.006762845441699028, 0.003502492094412446, -0.07537513971328735, 0.038085196167230606, 0.009980191476643085, -0.032603293657302856, 0.01124474499374628, 0.022854667156934738, 0.04847228527069092, -0.03890623524785042, -0.048668380826711655, 0.0041045332327485085, 0.014912106096744537, 0.007454695645719767, 0.035750456154346466, -0.00602452177554369, 0.022815879434347153, -0.0046679554507136345, 0.0538252517580986, 0.008644286543130875, 0.054414600133895874, 0.06036350503563881, 0.004719882272183895, 0.027127206325531006, -0.025058774277567863, -0.01200998853892088, -0.04574061557650566, -0.026702674105763435, 0.0031441592145711184, -0.039677973836660385, 0.01813342608511448, 0.09728284925222397, -0.020816903561353683, -0.04279807209968567, 0.09860683232545853, 0.05346629396080971, 0.03466123715043068, 0.0063893296755850315, 0.05240834876894951, -0.009196219965815544, 0.027797404676675797, 0.08029433339834213, -0.034803904592990875, -0.021982325240969658 ]
148
148
Algorithmic information theory
We introduce algorithmic information theory, also known as the theory of Kolmogorov complexity. We explain the main concepts of this quantitative approach to defining `information'. We discuss the extent to which Kolmogorov's and Shannon's information theory have a common purpose, and where they are fundamentally different. We indicate how recent developments within the theory allow one to formally distinguish between `structural' (meaningful) and `random' information as measured by the Kolmogorov structure function, which leads to a mathematical formalization of Occam's razor in inductive inference. We end by discussing some of the philosophical implications of the theory.
[ -0.06043029949069023, -0.020788822323083878, 0.012229776941239834, 0.03709021583199501, -0.02887825295329094, -0.03764789178967476, 0.03050042875111103, -0.02023322507739067, -0.03110526129603386, 0.03189869225025177, 0.06914645433425903, -0.08308093249797821, -0.03515513613820076, 0.0202072374522686, -0.01137735228985548, 0.0005273508140817285, 0.0205768384039402, -0.03045537881553173, 0.033678993582725525, -0.006319973152130842, -0.0571652352809906, 0.05111442506313324, 0.011064911261200905, -0.012783365324139595, -0.017395226284861565, -0.028279975056648254, 0.03517824411392212, 0.030209124088287354, -0.09046422690153122, 0.03434683382511139, -0.07137921452522278, 0.0231731366366148, 0.053328920155763626, 0.017345964908599854, 0.03580518811941147, 0.034821320325136185, -0.06063108146190643, 0.022951630875468254, -0.06173178553581238, -0.004102763254195452, 0.055946674197912216, 0.04480385407805443, -0.036992285400629044, -0.010140342637896538, 0.028326932340860367, -0.017355473712086678, 0.02605750970542431, 0.02402753382921219, 0.047330234199762344, 0.04258549213409424, -0.03896471485495567, 0.016446663066744804, -0.000035423330700723454, -0.05844150483608246, -0.015566296875476837, 0.056662820279598236, 0.00832952931523323, -0.039468903094530106, -0.0048706489615142345, 0.03216888755559921, -0.007658617105334997, 0.07516568899154663, 0.01986077055335045, -0.003573637455701828, -0.07636536657810211, -0.017045045271515846, -0.11524036526679993, -0.00489627942442894, 0.005144129972904921, -0.09850647300481796, -0.03919306397438049, -0.007710389792919159, 0.06596600264310837, 0.06387270241975784, 0.02340528927743435, -0.022811653092503548, -0.012105404399335384, 0.0254807248711586, -0.0038620568811893463, 0.0857120156288147, 0.00578654371201992, 0.09773418307304382, -0.00021045970788691193, -0.07101092487573624, -0.081299789249897, 0.022479666396975517, 0.01482244674116373, -0.0020566985476762056, 0.08774837851524353, -0.0024310338776558638, 0.02397760935127735, -0.026478007435798645, -0.013032704591751099, 0.05420037358999252, 0.05073561146855354, 0.07773502916097641, -0.013756241649389267, -0.03492351248860359, 0.03859985992312431, -0.037469808012247086, 0.0017348560504615307, -0.02754383347928524, 0.05766600742936134, -0.007868349552154541, -0.032705895602703094, -0.01892482489347458, -0.03982892259955406, 0.03487912192940712, 0.009319726377725601, -0.036160826683044434, 0.0016423051711171865, -0.01982036419212818, -0.043994203209877014, 0.007643401622772217, -0.07172055542469025, 0.07984845340251923, -0.0058980099856853485, 0.041973747313022614, -0.00017482573457527906, -0.044582147151231766, 0.051133498549461365, 0.057259149849414825, 0.03179166838526726, 0.019922995939850807, -0.012836409732699394, -0.08069178462028503, -0.061570651829242706, -0.0224726814776659, 0.12735259532928467, -0.01572401449084282, -0.08935737609863281, 0.016878509894013405, 0.0416201651096344, 0.0028075664304196835, -0.05845530331134796, 0.0034910589456558228, 0.06884145736694336, -0.03513631597161293, -0.05692851170897484, 0.004011801443994045, 0.05698303133249283, -0.030567673966288567, -0.06179799512028694, -0.09324141591787338, 0.0195208378136158, 0.10145433247089386, 0.003325612051412463, 0.007292094640433788, 0.0781235545873642, -0.013196204788982868, -0.04293382167816162, -0.005914978217333555, 0.02952173911035061, 0.024197407066822052, -0.0030453207436949015, -0.0068910629488527775, -0.054741270840168, 0.011870378628373146, -0.013430362567305565, 0.023338984698057175, -0.013363736681640148, -0.004732649773359299, -0.002623895648866892, 0.05087550729513168, -0.010768110863864422, 0.01248993631452322, -0.059779196977615356, -0.0724974051117897, -0.026767274364829063, 0.03840985521674156, 0.07152928411960602, 0.003946212586015463, 0.027640996500849724, 0.04141125828027725, 0.06940434873104095, -0.06844773143529892, -0.07900819927453995, 0.03915790095925331, 0.024471603333950043, -0.12001610547304153, -0.033217284828424454, -0.08058340847492218, -0.037150029093027115, 0.0339757539331913, -0.024406662210822105, 0.10008537024259567, 0.01459111925214529, -0.029094507917761803, 0.0180367399007082, -0.02282329834997654, 0.018280817195773125, 0.021188819780945778, 0.03931558504700661, 0.010899050161242485, 0.01508332509547472, 0.01286615151911974, -0.002390936017036438, 0.017764993011951447, -0.04540744423866272, 0.0835520327091217, 0.02399177849292755, 0.07458715885877609, -0.008143479935824871, -0.06402166187763214, -0.03456306457519531, -0.002770940540358424, 0.01706811413168907, 0.009122534655034542, -0.010743638500571251, 0.008931499905884266, 0.021828757598996162, 0.04219961166381836, 0.005368404556065798, -0.0016376571729779243, 0.09509100019931793, -0.03524232283234596, -0.06735888868570328, -0.021372491493821144, 0.05075004696846008, 0.019181648269295692, 0.0005335084861144423, -0.027565311640501022, 0.07814280688762665, 0.038093578070402145, -0.05083511769771576, -0.051839545369148254, 0.007867556065320969, 0.014802167192101479, -0.07586412131786346, -0.011339336633682251, -0.07380715012550354, -0.04332404211163521, -0.06933117657899857, -0.020687410607933998, 0.08182580769062042, 0.048906002193689346, 0.018391894176602364, -0.017727555707097054, -0.00266198068857193, -0.01476332638412714, -0.05011281371116638, 0.07393576949834824, -0.016771312803030014, 0.025415334850549698, 0.02257118560373783, 0.0006066593341529369, 0.06378297507762909, 0.05275477096438408, -0.021048860624432564, -0.09851007908582687, 0.013048755005002022, -0.017088547348976135, -0.01843642070889473, 0.011965030804276466, 0.03156191110610962, -0.00913225393742323, -0.05938492715358734, 0.039856214076280594, 0.06708233803510666, 0.030044732615351677, -0.0425853356719017, 0.0362677164375782, -0.042915210127830505, 0.03021656535565853, -0.020830772817134857, 0.012189321219921112, 0.022445548325777054, 0.05544324964284897, 0.002820677123963833, -0.01374468021094799, 0.0023647358175367117, 0.05511791259050369, 0.011496447026729584, 0.10269169509410858, -0.06657791137695312, -0.026205850765109062, 0.04508497565984726, -0.02477303333580494, -0.05537146329879761, -0.11990762501955032, -0.0309086125344038, 0.05228838697075844, -0.05240551382303238, -0.04107506945729256, -0.058401115238666534, 0.06634774059057236, -0.015618459321558475, -0.018630877137184143, -0.023761309683322906, 0.014049019664525986, -0.07527077943086624, 0.06394940614700317, -0.11888986825942993, -0.047290269285440445, -0.017456432804465294, -0.06162913143634796, 0.024604450911283493, -0.0309667456895113, 0.041162654757499695, -0.08623016625642776, 0.0001345159689662978, -0.07626611739397049, 0.07332605868577957, 0.008186855353415012, -0.0025537111796438694, -0.008320312015712261, 0.09811323136091232, 0.03827359527349472, -0.08383308351039886, 0.05473731458187103, 0.01730443723499775, 0.03189020976424217, -0.03258881717920303, -0.014214839786291122, -0.046090591698884964, -0.005924608558416367, 0.006074251141399145, -0.02619774639606476, 0.0033833454363048077, -0.06675991415977478, -0.03941614180803299, -0.06923751533031464, -0.024621805176138878, -0.0714377760887146, -0.08020547032356262, 0.0112073365598917, 0.031286098062992096, -0.08634717762470245, -0.060386624187231064, 0.058427467942237854, -0.09139733016490936, 0.033307384699583054, 0.058061398565769196, 0.12960822880268097, -0.01782541163265705, -0.058334268629550934, 0.008655873127281666, 0.025413878262043, 0.005481916479766369, 0.030838824808597565, 0.012108873575925827, -0.057321082800626755, 0.040321577340364456, -0.029739471152424812, 0.06201861426234245, -0.008526256307959557, 0.060428135097026825, -0.03613632544875145, 0.008398044854402542, -0.06115179508924484, -0.007185838185250759, 0.0217453446239233, -0.02131868153810501, -0.03831220790743828, -0.003247452201321721, 0.08741194009780884, 0.027179613709449768, 0.013981184922158718, 0.00361918518319726, 0.022419294342398643, 0.08572367578744888, 0.03668811172246933, 0.028176698833703995, -0.022567683830857277, 0.014572867192327976, 0.05735627934336662, 0.0009413734078407288, 0.009306665509939194, 0.011393468827009201, 0.05879885330796242, 0.058931976556777954, 0.049963030964136124, 0.02006184123456478, -0.06391306966543198, -0.0012596867745742202, -0.04282168671488762, -0.001597612164914608, 0.023817192763090134, -0.03445917367935181, 0.025044018402695656, -0.025979457423090935, -0.02008681558072567, 0.024277662858366966, -0.03408421203494072, -0.04090694338083267, 0.001502187573350966, -0.004423917271196842, 0.02393471822142601, 0.07045071572065353, 0.05897080525755882, 0.026308981701731682, 0.03464315086603165, -0.03422817587852478, -0.01203964278101921, 0.02503674477338791, -0.023306142538785934, 0.016365818679332733, -0.06607665866613388, -0.006327970884740353, 0.010875876061618328, -0.004527641460299492, -0.07375173270702362, 0.026722488924860954, 0.022729968652129173, -0.05138382688164711, 0.007913632318377495, -0.04497439041733742, 0.053189557045698166, -0.027426954358816147, -0.03608153387904167, 0.015574745833873749, -0.03608592599630356, 0.045207854360342026, 0.01799934357404709, 0.037331629544496536, 0.02595122531056404, -0.0024737007915973663, 0.020998792722821236, 0.053280506283044815, -0.05566676706075668, 0.0315609835088253, -0.0421939454972744, -0.024936066940426826, -0.025045912712812424, -0.01655600592494011, -0.013389595784246922, 0.03343290090560913, 0.025678222998976707, 0.0031429436057806015, -0.06067926809191704, -0.003342651529237628, -0.00277799554169178, -0.006775622721761465, -0.00225093774497509, 0.05431060492992401, 0.005589603446424007, 0.013735559768974781, 0.03853028640151024, -0.00039896604721434414, -0.0628751814365387, 0.02240852080285549, 0.0026666331104934216, 0.06925260275602341, 0.0435582771897316, 0.03508083149790764, -0.014723632484674454, 0.04136629402637482, -0.013337559998035431, -0.022304410114884377, 0.05355311557650566, -0.016739146783947945, 0.014426128938794136, 0.049256838858127594, 0.003760713152587414, -0.018296927213668823, 0.037027884274721146, -0.019037438556551933, -0.0007406588410958648, 0.07034812122583389, 0.02263881266117096, -0.07064270973205566, -0.03306439146399498, -0.012554426677525043, -0.0684853345155716, -0.03829067572951317, -0.03884409740567207, 0.028933091089129448, 0.007320830598473549, 0.0638837218284607, 0.011517112143337727, -0.04364297538995743, -0.0295321736484766, -0.020552126690745354, -0.06333857774734497, 0.05999486520886421, -0.01681685261428356, 0.01974366419017315, -0.05333033204078674, -0.003258549375459552, -0.06660851836204529, 0.029283933341503143, 0.017059652134776115, -0.05007651820778847, 0.037815213203430176, 0.04772491380572319, 0.008086425252258778, -0.07589369267225266, -0.05532165989279747, 0.04739093407988548, 0.045582715421915054, 0.07075408846139908, -0.04491867870092392, -0.07531527429819107, -0.03038191609084606, -0.017370223999023438, 0.0013199991080909967, 0.00790381245315075, -0.014401551336050034, -0.026429012417793274, 0.05483505502343178, -0.01593814417719841, -0.012085646390914917, -0.06656534969806671, 0.0264851376414299, 0.03602205961942673, 0.00036103991442359984, 0.1387568861246109, 0.0028050083201378584, -0.007048226427286863, 0.04608264937996864, 0.020224763080477715, -0.011510238982737064 ]
149
149
Predicting Abnormal Returns From News Using Text Classification
We show how text from news articles can be used to predict intraday price movements of financial assets using support vector machines. Multiple kernel learning is used to combine equity returns with text as predictive features to increase classification performance and we develop an analytic center cutting plane method to solve the kernel learning problem efficiently. We observe that while the direction of returns is not predictable using either text or returns, their size is, with text features producing significantly better performance than historical returns alone.
[ 0.003942159004509449, -0.05715882405638695, 0.07841263711452484, -0.010879473760724068, 0.05653282627463341, -0.004471910186111927, -0.05873655155301094, -0.015040324069559574, -0.03938896209001541, 0.016571737825870514, 0.04585529491305351, 0.045526083558797836, -0.021468354389071465, 0.018143728375434875, 0.020655563101172447, -0.06036841869354248, 0.027020730078220367, 0.025504877790808678, -0.01287695299834013, -0.05250142142176628, 0.02377864345908165, 0.020480575039982796, 0.020562058314681053, -0.054867617785930634, -0.00259983423165977, -0.024234633892774582, -0.024638062343001366, -0.02266155555844307, 0.037296850234270096, 0.06635180860757828, -0.04285280406475067, 0.011632133275270462, -0.02380257099866867, 0.037558235228061676, -0.012847241014242172, -0.0073743220418691635, 0.020191267132759094, 0.05556444823741913, -0.0588272362947464, -0.03193236142396927, -0.014852422289550304, 0.05252103880047798, 0.022572172805666924, 0.027104653418064117, 0.020984875038266182, 0.04925943538546562, -0.0590127669274807, -0.0030248379334807396, -0.008540846407413483, 0.02736910618841648, -0.03142328932881355, -0.015691276639699936, -0.011622142978012562, 0.05196132883429527, -0.04601399227976799, -0.006680299062281847, -0.000037809735658811405, 0.036716729402542114, 0.034053873270750046, -0.07233400642871857, 0.004198568873107433, 0.05192692205309868, 0.016253240406513214, 0.05424842610955238, -0.00021265997202135623, -0.017338827252388, -0.0250056404620409, -0.11006618291139603, 0.0034540535416454077, -0.06877708435058594, -0.062003690749406815, -0.0285824965685606, 0.004461904522031546, 0.09061479568481445, -0.03379889577627182, -0.0007676542736589909, -0.06318531930446625, -0.05943496152758598, 0.017154615372419357, 0.050016265362501144, -0.026822464540600777, 0.03418363630771637, 0.05321146175265312, 0.023180410265922546, 0.008150291629135609, -0.0012702448293566704, -0.027490364387631416, -0.020786577835679054, -0.007633887697011232, -0.052515819668769836, 0.021967295557260513, 0.02882620319724083, -0.026910405606031418, -0.013451900333166122, -0.027252154424786568, -0.042838506400585175, -0.03185873106122017, -0.022703170776367188, -0.003586664330214262, -0.03499603271484375, 0.00021088021458126605, -0.050779618322849274, 0.026681290939450264, 0.037679534405469894, -0.047371845692396164, -0.04051417484879494, 0.00006144081271486357, 0.035913705825805664, 0.0063608442433178425, 0.07476028054952621, 0.05582638457417488, -0.005036090034991503, 0.06144002452492714, 0.13432231545448303, -0.07797805964946747, 0.09968013316392899, -0.043917465955019, 0.1069859191775322, 0.003424044931307435, -0.0702562928199768, 0.052425567060709, 0.02957029640674591, -0.09332294017076492, 0.08503425121307373, 0.09866651147603989, -0.05183888226747513, 0.04494558647274971, -0.019246617332100868, 0.021910779178142548, 0.015339677222073078, -0.10752265155315399, 0.09218201041221619, -0.024623310193419456, 0.09266042709350586, 0.018871011212468147, 0.001108564785681665, 0.05937279015779495, 0.021498866379261017, -0.08186867088079453, -0.03083004057407379, -0.02511983923614025, 0.03204833343625069, 0.01693274825811386, 0.004165596328675747, 0.005412743892520666, 0.05670942738652229, 0.00838399212807417, 0.013983075506985188, 0.001995630096644163, -0.005698017310351133, -0.009132592007517815, -0.04602989926934242, 0.020062729716300964, 0.02697206288576126, 0.03881572559475899, -0.09630850702524185, -0.024421073496341705, -0.054894350469112396, -0.031833499670028687, 0.011147147975862026, 0.05008602887392044, -0.03447970375418663, 0.026294058188796043, -0.03915759176015854, -0.04994602128863335, -0.026507075875997543, 0.04233726114034653, 0.04338753968477249, 0.0457109659910202, -0.040631067007780075, -0.040882762521505356, -0.02534565143287182, -0.033512771129608154, 0.06058214604854584, -0.041056305170059204, 0.021743642166256905, -0.06340533494949341, -0.003249343251809478, -0.07750726491212845, 0.03901360183954239, 0.010272975079715252, -0.12938521802425385, -0.04312267154455185, 0.0015697168419137597, 0.11857124418020248, 0.09752624481916428, 0.039551906287670135, 0.05672140046954155, 0.10067924857139587, -0.0017605749890208244, 0.025656627491116524, -0.032051026821136475, 0.04076189920306206, -0.005438273772597313, -0.04424323886632919, 0.05446505546569824, -0.05061528831720352, -0.0813772976398468, 0.05480939894914627, 0.0415055975317955, 0.0065442281775176525, 0.019297676160931587, -0.006239080335944891, -0.01356026716530323, -0.0021668614353984594, -0.019656077027320862, 0.06401234865188599, -0.08211716264486313, -0.025005167350172997, 0.06414302438497543, -0.014679035171866417, -0.07260861247777939, 0.004174257628619671, 0.030149811878800392, 0.015195399522781372, -0.043279606848955154, 0.03317094221711159, 0.03696143627166748, 0.031235000118613243, 0.06125105172395706, -0.03709877282381058, 0.02131839096546173, -0.006730942986905575, -0.000942791230045259, -0.054098647087812424, -0.01680152304470539, 0.014243333600461483, -0.09590984880924225, -0.06991541385650635, 0.03560490161180496, -0.03208610787987709, -0.10054026544094086, -0.025072360411286354, -0.033317308872938156, 0.07919082045555115, 0.08508061617612839, 0.026691297069191933, -0.02920977771282196, 0.026036271825432777, -0.03130459785461426, -0.042611803859472275, 0.018348952755331993, 0.01218643132597208, -0.03720970079302788, -0.01952490583062172, -0.06821801513433456, -0.01412256807088852, 0.03730270266532898, -0.010118592530488968, -0.059350207448005676, 0.03302853927016258, 0.03842465579509735, -0.07147844135761261, -0.056357067078351974, -0.06864981353282928, 0.00703941285610199, -0.031106770038604736, -0.025678621605038643, 0.059650152921676636, 0.010431669652462006, -0.019688844680786133, -0.04574771970510483, -0.0003401689464226365, -0.017493724822998047, 0.12798957526683807, 0.037658512592315674, -0.03972944617271423, 0.006491418927907944, 0.0076878732070326805, 0.025308523327112198, -0.08762148022651672, -0.0740518644452095, 0.0008571656071580946, 0.05406993255019188, -0.05512560158967972, 0.0648510605096817, 0.023563213646411896, 0.012248039245605469, -0.004820345435291529, -0.006372127681970596, 0.032260164618492126, 0.037859681993722916, -0.0685344859957695, 0.015307819470763206, -0.00039514334639534354, 0.02445235662162304, -0.0039821043610572815, 0.016745952889323235, 0.045867159962654114, -0.00027139161829836667, -0.0322674997150898, 0.01230635680258274, -0.09592772275209427, 0.02757262997329235, 0.07238374650478363, -0.08731738477945328, 0.05784551054239273, 0.013625029474496841, 0.017653387039899826, -0.022221503779292107, 0.05083882436156273, 0.07052638381719589, 0.00451741274446249, -0.026368174701929092, -0.03306508809328079, 0.06448054313659668, 0.04987271875143051, -0.07194828242063522, 0.006116634234786034, -0.015507091768085957, -0.025726931169629097, -0.03189507871866226, -0.0006844560266472399, 0.00036906017339788377, -0.012106317095458508, -0.020218636840581894, -0.029903067275881767, -0.06232546642422676, 0.06686073541641235, 0.00930396281182766, 0.04496700316667557, 0.014189762994647026, -0.021370192989706993, -0.031397778540849686, 0.014659873209893703, 0.018106848001480103, -0.058161333203315735, 0.018038881942629814, -0.11184529960155487, -0.030340252444148064, -0.005078725051134825, -0.03962317109107971, -0.039044324308633804, 0.08136370033025742, -0.023517852649092674, 0.020439917221665382, 0.022003760561347008, -0.02134310081601143, 0.0009693650645203888, -0.04165572673082352, -0.06469336897134781, 0.010036447085440159, -0.04289759695529938, 0.019745856523513794, -0.00022985429677646607, 0.02435690350830555, 0.08369366079568863, 0.007604759186506271, -0.03312791883945465, 0.009794292971491814, 0.044185396283864975, 0.044509805738925934, -0.015667308121919632, -0.007377861067652702, -0.013828234747052193, 0.09839911758899689, 0.009004144929349422, 0.027242222800850868, 0.00153643568046391, -0.04364089295268059, 0.0024416742380708456, -0.022582296282052994, -0.07513394951820374, -0.03969049081206322, 0.04885329678654671, 0.010305010713636875, -0.022835545241832733, 0.04642908647656441, -0.024246815592050552, 0.007037711795419455, 0.02154434844851494, 0.04251126945018768, 0.04544971138238907, -0.06706167012453079, -0.0054077208042144775, 0.014407525770366192, -0.026144322007894516, -0.07106062769889832, 0.03621235117316246, 0.02955789677798748, -0.018042678013443947, -0.014267207123339176, -0.07627610862255096, -0.0014384309761226177, -0.037855807691812515, 0.003252497175708413, -0.09795641154050827, 0.02253306284546852, 0.02738901786506176, -0.01703450083732605, -0.03590896353125572, 0.000024303431928274222, -0.02868560142815113, 0.009019660763442516, 0.028650827705860138, -0.006696059834212065, 0.015455598942935467, -0.04492395371198654, -0.014999592676758766, 0.009501049295067787, 0.009659778326749802, -0.020827943459153175, 0.004824567586183548, -0.015880383551120758, -0.046490151435136795, -0.05284693092107773, 0.06164133548736572, -0.02195337414741516, 0.018950877711176872, 0.029760530218482018, -0.014718862250447273, -0.01943032629787922, 0.05071234330534935, 0.026829129084944725, 0.00853673368692398, 0.048514313995838165, -0.018985943868756294, -0.053604789078235626, -0.025577908381819725, -0.08862664550542831, 0.026063621044158936, 0.030000993981957436, 0.0648065134882927, 0.05210600420832634, -0.06787875294685364, -0.02839815430343151, 0.028987964615225792, 0.012839291244745255, -0.030353553593158722, 0.01456267386674881, -0.02412966825067997, 0.08537054061889648, -0.07354993373155594, -0.028967950493097305, 0.05609336867928505, -0.034962769597768784, 0.06082984432578087, 0.030785584822297096, 0.053148381412029266, 0.006538725458085537, -0.009129547514021397, -0.05874873325228691, 0.031389664858579636, -0.020355578511953354, 0.028752798214554787, 0.0569266639649868, -0.04204679653048515, 0.007267937064170837, 0.028974594548344612, -0.013732397928833961, 0.0049667987041175365, 0.02367684617638588, 0.01483367569744587, -0.00023350278206635267, -0.0016721709398552775, -0.024970607832074165, -0.10075043886899948, 0.00023868381686042994, 0.05151710286736488, -0.08180934190750122, -0.018059169873595238, -0.032015666365623474, 0.005900216288864613, 0.030629225075244904, -0.06453148275613785, 0.08152949064970016, 0.04348758980631828, 0.0028622134122997522, 0.0767361968755722, 0.01563614420592785, -0.053789958357810974, -0.05776116997003555, 0.03227292001247406, -0.06620108336210251, 0.011092444881796837, -0.035728923976421356, -0.021449508145451546, -0.08902183175086975, -0.02841794863343239, -0.008466399274766445, 0.0814744383096695, -0.06863652914762497, -0.050860852003097534, 0.018774865195155144, 0.035324253141880035, -0.019470667466521263, -0.02158292941749096, -0.04048251733183861, -0.006868121679872274, -0.04652800038456917, 0.02552267536520958, -0.007051604334264994, -0.032924585044384, 0.057745981961488724, -0.00558810867369175, -0.020932037383317947, -0.004663589410483837, 0.006350541952997446, -0.006488012615591288, 0.011933241970837116, 0.11844903230667114, -0.02137531340122223, -0.004190947860479355, -0.008177699521183968, 0.06204672157764435, 0.006731283850967884, 0.056368909776210785, 0.03220123425126076, -0.04154030978679657, 0.024460049346089363, 0.06754337251186371, 0.012298841029405594 ]
150
150
A New Framework of Multistage Hypothesis Tests
In this paper, we have established a general framework of multistage hypothesis tests which applies to arbitrarily many mutually exclusive and exhaustive composite hypotheses. Within the new framework, we have constructed specific multistage tests which rigorously control the risk of committing decision errors and are more efficient than previous tests in terms of average sample number and the number of sampling operations. Without truncation, the sample numbers of our testing plans are absolutely bounded.
[ 0.017772173509001732, -0.060338184237480164, 0.05502018332481384, -0.017802299931645393, -0.0881732627749443, -0.04514181241393089, -0.03335726633667946, -0.01948799379169941, 0.01700344868004322, 0.03753596544265747, -0.006589540746062994, -0.07476221770048141, -0.005843022372573614, 0.05269340053200722, -0.012865490280091763, -0.024049997329711914, -0.01872319169342518, 0.022210020571947098, 0.021648120135068893, -0.08076032996177673, -0.035101406276226044, 0.027768228203058243, 0.046027250587940216, -0.024578554555773735, -0.022699907422065735, 0.03625522926449776, 0.021153077483177185, -0.01746215671300888, -0.0007896003080531955, -0.04824128374457359, -0.10045118629932404, 0.0739579051733017, 0.05852194130420685, 0.011951243504881859, 0.10124677419662476, -0.03954868018627167, -0.0488201268017292, 0.004505980294197798, -0.038120854645967484, -0.06513410061597824, 0.03599173203110695, -0.08412642776966095, -0.022122373804450035, -0.017859168350696564, 0.005207627546042204, -0.00787503831088543, 0.04872504994273186, -0.013582375831902027, 0.03647840768098831, 0.002398915123194456, -0.04017994552850723, 0.03969617560505867, 0.014916390180587769, -0.02340579405426979, 0.007191460579633713, 0.04806343838572502, -0.11625199764966965, 0.02944035828113556, 0.004396379459649324, 0.002245635259896517, -0.018739530816674232, 0.021566586568951607, -0.014244098216295242, 0.017865367233753204, -0.04587380215525627, -0.021302323788404465, -0.098533995449543, -0.03704541176557541, -0.00904153659939766, -0.03293744847178459, 0.016608737409114838, -0.03445190563797951, -0.03903447836637497, 0.016968125477433205, 0.02678380347788334, 0.023977017030119896, -0.005579216871410608, -0.006657011341303587, -0.009201527573168278, 0.08039724081754684, -0.03232763335108757, 0.0848659947514534, -0.044261395931243896, 0.024097343906760216, -0.02138122171163559, 0.01793079264461994, -0.0007077687187120318, 0.018335122615098953, -0.006698125507682562, -0.09914742410182953, -0.055429451167583466, 0.02974938601255417, -0.031831223517656326, 0.0672404021024704, 0.004427011590451002, 0.057622455060482025, -0.06152910366654396, -0.001918506808578968, -0.11388425529003143, -0.018757324665784836, -0.013410696759819984, -0.06017288938164711, 0.01770632714033127, 0.06263016909360886, -0.04720284044742584, 0.010901674628257751, -0.023552116006612778, 0.025290904566645622, -0.02214602567255497, -0.0008763207006268203, 0.015991415828466415, -0.10167539864778519, 0.013463659211993217, 0.0023631800431758165, -0.023339014500379562, 0.13982512056827545, -0.06193094700574875, 0.016388488933444023, 0.01875908486545086, -0.01677175983786583, 0.04880088195204735, -0.01311019342392683, -0.0052963737398386, 0.011111880652606487, 0.0025396377313882113, -0.03272966668009758, 0.017097655683755875, -0.10534487664699554, 0.12333620339632034, 0.006539307069033384, 0.006972424685955048, 0.003143734997138381, -0.01117671187967062, 0.06876900047063828, -0.019434791058301926, -0.022461751475930214, 0.02587280049920082, -0.052055902779102325, -0.06865298748016357, 0.04140821099281311, 0.03955506160855293, -0.04460176080465317, -0.036668453365564346, 0.014623637311160564, 0.06521786749362946, -0.010928723029792309, 0.03506449982523918, 0.02292078360915184, -0.026432203128933907, 0.07060615718364716, -0.05136128142476082, -0.005894013214856386, 0.021705595776438713, 0.02820117026567459, -0.023610491305589676, -0.022030532360076904, -0.04613557457923889, 0.03659256547689438, -0.014878475107252598, 0.024684876203536987, -0.017649909481406212, 0.05698603764176369, -0.026043333113193512, 0.023944735527038574, 0.02530614472925663, -0.06616240739822388, -0.0430343858897686, -0.010128887370228767, -0.012005466036498547, -0.08082568645477295, -0.01899947039783001, -0.07592600584030151, 0.009141447022557259, 0.02194688655436039, -0.017309920862317085, -0.006699667312204838, 0.03932146355509758, -0.013576827012002468, -0.023747643455863, 0.021883660927414894, 0.025872286409139633, -0.0984015166759491, -0.0539596788585186, -0.05529933050274849, 0.038772162050008774, 0.10966593772172928, -0.0029235207475721836, 0.08240672945976257, 0.08204549551010132, -0.016118628904223442, -0.04777762293815613, -0.017831718549132347, -0.01336630154401064, -0.03698454797267914, -0.017807142809033394, -0.042135801166296005, -0.04897776618599892, 0.023536236956715584, -0.03802982717752457, 0.04967893287539482, 0.035148631781339645, -0.020758599042892456, 0.03833930566906929, -0.004589859861880541, 0.06999202072620392, 0.09139077365398407, 0.03333595022559166, 0.006868461146950722, 0.014890823513269424, -0.0843658521771431, -0.022878875955939293, -0.07425123453140259, -0.05501800402998924, -0.027630869299173355, 0.06416559219360352, -0.03444856032729149, 0.017582226544618607, -0.060755666345357895, 0.05291396751999855, -0.08321285992860794, -0.03174309432506561, 0.05899443477392197, -0.04734303057193756, 0.07294321060180664, -0.0704154521226883, -0.0352909229695797, 0.05633552372455597, 0.03590778633952141, 0.056311678141355515, 0.02404722198843956, -0.07407761365175247, -0.025464216247200966, -0.010497350245714188, 0.009200588800013065, -0.0332413874566555, 0.06775268912315369, -0.058996111154556274, -0.026789946481585503, 0.034994691610336304, 0.010971339419484138, -0.010371563956141472, 0.0023693761322647333, -0.006410660222172737, 0.00515592098236084, -0.04516533017158508, 0.04433014616370201, 0.013989281840622425, 0.03803981468081474, -0.0549512580037117, 0.011839539743959904, 0.016413142904639244, -0.015543515793979168, -0.03202928602695465, 0.05067870393395424, -0.011908946558833122, 0.0200322438031435, 0.05644272267818451, 0.08186306804418564, 0.07198795676231384, 0.07805486023426056, 0.07264745235443115, -0.001640948699787259, -0.11631841957569122, -0.07817798852920532, -0.01720486767590046, 0.017989084124565125, -0.027939245104789734, 0.033740658313035965, 0.0034419710282236338, -0.0838799700140953, -0.016929809004068375, -0.03602362051606178, -0.03207232430577278, -0.009451616555452347, -0.013558250851929188, -0.06646119803190231, 0.009661824442446232, 0.012408260256052017, 0.04958908259868622, 0.006391895469278097, -0.04064873605966568, 0.017955556511878967, 0.010104267857968807, 0.039371754974126816, -0.012205023318529129, 0.025459127500653267, -0.022981153801083565, -0.015967892482876778, -0.03037329576909542, -0.052631739526987076, -0.06738697737455368, 0.022588348016142845, -0.04511578381061554, -0.0027718371711671352, -0.0039022439159452915, -0.007974212057888508, 0.023057492449879646, 0.0675952136516571, 0.07079695165157318, 0.002704671584069729, -0.06339012086391449, 0.03577655926346779, -0.005699057597666979, 0.03858713433146477, -0.010666090063750744, 0.011817644350230694, 0.0013547582784667611, -0.028814245015382767, -0.1145670935511589, 0.03368333727121353, 0.025549598038196564, -0.02599140629172325, -0.015831511467695236, 0.028509406372904778, 0.03876493498682976, -0.04089648649096489, 0.004817349836230278, -0.04155394807457924, 0.026327166706323624, 0.015358508564531803, 0.014396419748663902, 0.030372371897101402, -0.01504666917026043, -0.027047157287597656, -0.09120500087738037, -0.0018429291667416692, 0.015959490090608597, -0.015269437804818153, -0.020207570865750313, 0.040691107511520386, -0.08157159388065338, 0.08347001671791077, -0.007606311235576868, 0.13686351478099823, -0.011285188607871532, -0.05743258818984032, 0.045241523534059525, -0.0008286663214676082, 0.013123449869453907, 0.07415777444839478, -0.03851091489195824, -0.03894944116473198, 0.015620965510606766, -0.036459553986787796, 0.028374608606100082, 0.05181324854493141, 0.05785142630338669, -0.01004890538752079, -0.05525946989655495, 0.011301848106086254, -0.04635664448142052, -0.08000719547271729, 0.00787382759153843, 0.02982124127447605, -0.014917755499482155, 0.03391405567526817, 0.01993929222226143, 0.011541563086211681, -0.043815065175294876, 0.051300566643476486, -0.005963666830211878, -0.02947942540049553, 0.04472190514206886, -0.000054260795877780765, 0.08067400008440018, -0.04359837621450424, -0.05540001019835472, -0.050946641713380814, 0.010944473557174206, -0.015225856564939022, -0.026872659102082253, 0.07730379700660706, 0.01518825814127922, 0.06698354333639145, 0.013345382176339626, 0.027917884290218353, 0.09338989853858948, -0.10182637721300125, -0.1003701463341713, 0.019809000194072723, 0.013657073490321636, -0.03406926244497299, -0.03626435995101929, -0.0016457494348287582, 0.014416107907891273, -0.025740286335349083, 0.031227750703692436, -0.004424544982612133, 0.06556650996208191, 0.014444602653384209, 0.000967137049883604, 0.025339120998978615, -0.05707196518778801, 0.08337006717920303, 0.01678420417010784, 0.038318783044815063, -0.016679292544722557, -0.0417364202439785, -0.036854274570941925, -0.09604953974485397, 0.03634416684508324, -0.08257172256708145, 0.015480667352676392, 0.00013207350275479257, -0.05329185351729393, -0.010298937559127808, 0.03189314901828766, 0.029517829418182373, -0.07723891735076904, 0.07560819387435913, 0.0363975428044796, 0.0008659265586175025, 0.008312472142279148, 0.02919371798634529, -0.017582491040229797, 0.04376300796866417, 0.06404030323028564, -0.062014006078243256, -0.06861242651939392, -0.02973487414419651, -0.04837685078382492, 0.0065213595516979694, -0.012452654540538788, -0.014035643078386784, 0.045520052313804626, -0.025131478905677795, -0.007701289374381304, 0.005314651411026716, 0.026065705344080925, 0.000532362493686378, -0.046028923243284225, -0.10508175939321518, -0.04126639664173126, 0.07805240154266357, -0.027609584853053093, -0.09017916023731232, 0.009051422588527203, -0.000028523254513856955, -0.045429546386003494, -0.04201679676771164, -0.0469815693795681, 0.027905728667974472, 0.004342008847743273, 0.03574086353182793, -0.058106619864702225, 0.018507173284888268, -0.028019612655043602, -0.011699164286255836, -0.038021933287382126, 0.027332907542586327, 0.028781037777662277, 0.04474155232310295, 0.009532811120152473, 0.043747350573539734, 0.0007056546746753156, -0.032209496945142746, 0.020392298698425293, 0.015785999596118927, 0.03570704907178879, -0.01324478816241026, -0.027912862598896027, -0.00756493303924799, 0.009236226789653301, 0.07919997721910477, -0.08915639668703079, -0.036335621029138565, 0.03277180343866348, 0.03785897418856621, -0.02847009338438511, -0.020956844091415405, -0.019861549139022827, 0.01480408851057291, -0.03996201977133751, 0.02547970600426197, -0.00015534466365352273, -0.04589211568236351, 0.024578996002674103, -0.032483432441949844, 0.0374721884727478, -0.09166374802589417, 0.04059544950723648, -0.0008761885692365468, -0.04653673991560936, 0.004535224754363298, -0.0003075292333960533, 0.08487128466367722, -0.045825183391571045, 0.0033844071440398693, -0.0005843826220370829, 0.032909657806158066, -0.007931677624583244, 0.02492700144648552, 0.02549191750586033, 0.031300727277994156, 0.00975881703197956, 0.0006647828267887235, -0.017039410769939423, -0.03516804426908493, -0.008894002996385098, -0.04952363669872284, -0.030873248353600502, 0.08090417087078094, -0.0038943574763834476, 0.05443890765309334, 0.05257395654916763, 0.0400732159614563, 0.03024013340473175, -0.049251802265644073, 0.04603881016373634, -0.042665064334869385, -0.005124738439917564, -0.014192815870046616 ]
151
151
Generalized Prediction Intervals for Arbitrary Distributed High-Dimensional Data
This paper generalizes the traditional statistical concept of prediction intervals for arbitrary probability density functions in high-dimensional feature spaces by introducing significance level distributions, which provides interval-independent probabilities for continuous random variables. The advantage of the transformation of a probability density function into a significance level distribution is that it enables one-class classification or outlier detection in a direct manner.
[ -0.07697117328643799, -0.04713958874344826, 0.03231223672628403, -0.01254682894796133, 0.03646450117230415, 0.00927602406591177, -0.07199547439813614, 0.015593396499752998, -0.038712382316589355, 0.03568865358829498, -0.01928168535232544, -0.054466892033815384, 0.0032277600839734077, -0.030264008790254593, -0.02722792699933052, 0.00838362704962492, -0.008884607814252377, -0.031177474185824394, 0.011296501383185387, -0.12121322751045227, 0.048563260585069656, -0.01219229120761156, -0.03470056876540184, -0.03365524113178253, -0.03840167447924614, -0.0049675386399030685, 0.0888039842247963, 0.015453018248081207, -0.029947858303785324, -0.003103556577116251, -0.037678368389606476, 0.01601981930434704, 0.04519400745630264, -0.02598443627357483, 0.00859824474900961, -0.024252712726593018, -0.06694434583187103, 0.0035122616682201624, -0.09268448501825333, -0.013791431672871113, -0.03000822104513645, -0.04158896952867508, 0.03065435215830803, 0.0033400440588593483, 0.06666857749223709, 0.05555830895900726, 0.05088447034358978, -0.02594655565917492, -0.017533959820866585, -0.004329000599682331, -0.09174224734306335, -0.001563390833325684, -0.036240771412849426, -0.05038704723119736, 0.012015705928206444, -0.02831372246146202, 0.010424253530800343, 0.02903555892407894, -0.07402928173542023, -0.02631714567542076, 0.02067563124001026, 0.04921744018793106, -0.021277347579598427, 0.002190783154219389, -0.019077550619840622, -0.01275000162422657, -0.06457505375146866, 0.016309339553117752, 0.024131301790475845, -0.033495113253593445, 0.014135743491351604, -0.02202192321419716, -0.020726880058646202, 0.057311300188302994, 0.05238189920783043, -0.022138778120279312, -0.024974653497338295, 0.021067162975668907, 0.03760179877281189, 0.07009827345609665, -0.020356491208076477, 0.01566247083246708, -0.012540246360003948, -0.03647797182202339, -0.03450261428952217, -0.0075753964483737946, -0.01800573244690895, -0.06080852448940277, 0.04790234565734863, -0.05484214425086975, -0.07433966547250748, 0.014468765817582607, -0.02162010781466961, -0.0078562768176198, -0.024027157574892044, 0.05377817526459694, -0.015619121491909027, -0.023927293717861176, 0.06900376081466675, 0.06461242586374283, -0.005239628255367279, -0.11931844800710678, 0.10793352872133255, 0.015408644452691078, 0.0509297177195549, 0.0346066839993, -0.005279242061078548, 0.028483064845204353, 0.010665059089660645, 0.007826550863683224, 0.048282504081726074, -0.0850350484251976, -0.009446380659937859, -0.019849777221679688, -0.027245094999670982, 0.08668595552444458, -0.01088299136608839, 0.0368385873734951, 0.0409264862537384, 0.034886326640844345, 0.09438541531562805, 0.04119376838207245, -0.01871613971889019, 0.026657365262508392, 0.029351914301514626, 0.018515080213546753, -0.06644927710294724, -0.04868469387292862, 0.10781279951334, 0.03181210905313492, -0.07077576965093613, 0.030582768842577934, -0.10475488752126694, 0.04421694204211235, -0.06261342018842697, -0.002002144930884242, 0.04671192169189453, -0.005821772385388613, -0.006744990590959787, 0.027011575177311897, -0.006473345682024956, 0.02541998215019703, 0.03101450949907303, -0.03112855553627014, 0.019153766334056854, 0.07898714393377304, 0.0016950255958363414, 0.005674685351550579, -0.04630831256508827, -0.0029635149985551834, -0.07761390507221222, -0.061271507292985916, 0.02612478658556938, 0.026423292234539986, 0.06079758331179619, -0.04152030497789383, -0.019366154447197914, -0.00234602321870625, -0.03704991191625595, 0.013456596061587334, -0.09799551963806152, 0.023285696282982826, 0.05505656078457832, -0.02889963798224926, -0.05582417547702789, 0.015608689747750759, 0.010816322639584541, 0.011172076687216759, -0.030288519337773323, -0.053146135061979294, -0.04252037778496742, -0.0007612364133819938, 0.012719173915684223, -0.013090714812278748, -0.014656739309430122, -0.025683071464300156, -0.05981438606977463, 0.03734211251139641, -0.058513518422842026, -0.0707419216632843, 0.01705530285835266, -0.08554632216691971, -0.01812889240682125, 0.09344329684972763, -0.017530998215079308, 0.10649470239877701, 0.023596709594130516, 0.02082141302525997, 0.04127449169754982, -0.037621546536684036, 0.017590830102562904, 0.004737850744277239, -0.02684219367802143, 0.010614569298923016, -0.07067810744047165, 0.036322202533483505, -0.0005256035947240889, -0.07987351715564728, 0.0213017575442791, 0.058080337941646576, -0.009133988991379738, -0.011059045791625977, -0.05094465613365173, -0.00960906594991684, -0.031037019565701485, 0.0717468410730362, 0.058578748255968094, -0.0657811164855957, 0.0017382038058713078, 0.04774920269846916, -0.03685479238629341, -0.048595819622278214, 0.04611435905098915, -0.003938963171094656, 0.06723689287900925, -0.0960024893283844, -0.05346531420946121, -0.011229502968490124, 0.07034996151924133, 0.07327510416507721, 0.015965279191732407, 0.012089034542441368, -0.014105561189353466, 0.04399857670068741, -0.10092996060848236, 0.015634212642908096, -0.004701029043644667, -0.10532246530056, -0.06009351834654808, 0.06113642454147339, -0.005121253896504641, 0.01648675464093685, 0.01099226251244545, -0.05035301670432091, 0.05314662680029869, 0.013031970709562302, -0.1098748967051506, -0.043961301445961, 0.019578544422984123, 0.07252246141433716, -0.032777875661849976, 0.07220504432916641, -0.024759260937571526, 0.005137130618095398, 0.03238065540790558, -0.07936932891607285, 0.026608232408761978, 0.09552929550409317, 0.0657329112291336, 0.06996285915374756, -0.03308284282684326, -0.0834016278386116, 0.047423478215932846, -0.01664176769554615, 0.006677505560219288, 0.046902887523174286, -0.03787320852279663, 0.014161532744765282, 0.044664300978183746, 0.013889627531170845, -0.017921265214681625, 0.07595126330852509, -0.05309249460697174, 0.04253534600138664, -0.011062881909310818, -0.0016230966430157423, -0.026221536099910736, 0.030154993757605553, -0.022281458601355553, 0.014794938266277313, -0.06320195645093918, 0.00139789585955441, -0.022588293999433517, 0.037986673414707184, -0.018089493736624718, -0.0842677429318428, 0.05816875770688057, 0.016980959102511406, 0.00003590451160562225, -0.1252831518650055, -0.032679084688425064, 0.021620897576212883, -0.011405379511415958, 0.009463093243539333, 0.01714726723730564, 0.06267742812633514, 0.06321969628334045, -0.028005115687847137, 0.002552866470068693, 0.04254578426480293, -0.017274122685194016, 0.02874305658042431, -0.033995650708675385, 0.0027263881638646126, 0.02967059798538685, 0.023860447108745575, 0.045043908059597015, -0.006758986506611109, 0.05160810425877571, 0.030462170019745827, -0.033929914236068726, 0.060335177928209305, 0.07972731441259384, -0.021659202873706818, 0.04209335520863533, 0.09462099522352219, 0.038194503635168076, 0.0633564218878746, -0.07092949002981186, 0.022624289616942406, -0.024789204820990562, 0.019800908863544464, -0.04662266746163368, -0.007083469536155462, -0.004347838927060366, -0.08797187358140945, 0.009375686757266521, -0.010656905360519886, -0.006348464637994766, 0.03195258602499962, 0.019477158784866333, 0.0066024805419147015, -0.020598404109477997, -0.029059771448373795, -0.06137929856777191, 0.0348287969827652, 0.04763146489858627, 0.005249756388366222, -0.05185958743095398, 0.005619739647954702, -0.002618142869323492, -0.023280644789338112, 0.002420541364699602, 0.08731447905302048, -0.05718206614255905, 0.04892106354236603, -0.019729485735297203, -0.005991951562464237, 0.024865267798304558, 0.010709116235375404, 0.026191961020231247, -0.027804842218756676, 0.06512075662612915, 0.0035416397731751204, -0.03527628257870674, 0.0650511309504509, 0.030971059575676918, 0.0036966961342841387, -0.043357256799936295, 0.010904540307819843, -0.07306502014398575, 0.04892078414559364, -0.00018615653971210122, 0.03100048191845417, 0.056606072932481766, 0.13379469513893127, 0.0654209554195404, -0.05585628002882004, 0.013104995712637901, 0.0432688370347023, 0.007371008861809969, 0.0551893375813961, -0.0797363743185997, 0.000009925647646014113, 0.005009768530726433, 0.06528979539871216, 0.011327696964144707, 0.007463010959327221, -0.017842872068285942, 0.039461296051740646, 0.024738969281315804, -0.0025228364393115044, -0.03953264281153679, 0.053286030888557434, 0.04070376604795456, -0.01051541417837143, 0.03199370577931404, 0.005416821222752333, 0.022204838693141937, 0.06374119222164154, -0.02115737460553646, -0.02543097920715809, -0.024950243532657623, -0.018781958147883415, -0.028996046632528305, -0.06196850538253784, -0.03763314709067345, -0.058282796293497086, 0.016646072268486023, -0.07952186465263367, -0.002077863784506917, -0.07090002298355103, -0.04784304276108742, -0.0005902722477912903, 0.013374785892665386, 0.0023315143771469593, 0.05671059712767601, 0.009639525786042213, 0.007710500620305538, 0.004943782929331064, -0.02407696470618248, -0.08637310564517975, 0.002697143005207181, -0.009912480600178242, -0.009349757805466652, 0.0026335378643125296, -0.006003649905323982, 0.036534689366817474, -0.10789300501346588, 0.055945660918951035, -0.0188229288905859, 0.019542740657925606, -0.037658821791410446, 0.0020990720950067043, 0.027801841497421265, 0.04850390926003456, -0.05086013674736023, -0.031134579330682755, -0.023492997512221336, -0.02641550451517105, -0.00956250075250864, 0.06664677709341049, -0.04365892708301544, 0.04984184727072716, -0.0005484427092596889, -0.019347315654158592, 0.04132462665438652, 0.021766742691397667, 0.0037789372727274895, -0.0031563688535243273, -0.06889332085847855, -0.004974319599568844, -0.08330859988927841, 0.023790791630744934, 0.046821508556604385, -0.019618751481175423, -0.014394368045032024, -0.03936795890331268, -0.024695152416825294, -0.004284942988306284, -0.0453178770840168, 0.025002099573612213, -0.00038882208173163235, -0.0005421632085926831, 0.00979246199131012, 0.023408932611346245, 0.09139334410429001, 0.03901929408311844, 0.005220536142587662, -0.006389762740582228, 0.048447467386722565, 0.09342911839485168, 0.0010114476317539811, 0.002667163498699665, -0.03669421002268791, -0.025298653170466423, 0.005223372485488653, 0.02940179593861103, 0.018528956919908524, 0.016886364668607712, -0.026616841554641724, -0.06331906467676163, -0.024170169606804848, -0.02349218726158142, -0.071291983127594, 0.03298851102590561, 0.08428353816270828, 0.04172160103917122, -0.01730627939105034, 0.042801015079021454, -0.059830792248249054, 0.01205119676887989, 0.04069029539823532, -0.06362664699554443, 0.04064406082034111, -0.07894156128168106, 0.02563379518687725, -0.042254600673913956, -0.08284959197044373, -0.030443862080574036, -0.033830806612968445, -0.03289835900068283, -0.03714846074581146, -0.037969451397657394, 0.07670984417200089, 0.06620488315820694, -0.01240584533661604, 0.009566400200128555, -0.06265484541654587, -0.03243686631321907, 0.03085276298224926, -0.007122310809791088, -0.04061007872223854, -0.01536814495921135, 0.016112618148326874, 0.003519756253808737, -0.02374149113893509, 0.004981206730008125, -0.04557989165186882, 0.0020610534120351076, -0.023441873490810394, -0.02727922610938549, 0.017668766900897026, -0.10885690897703171, 0.018242783844470978, 0.07650000602006912, -0.01624038629233837, -0.027264539152383804, 0.031776051968336105, 0.007958509027957916, -0.0022146855480968952, -0.07148057967424393 ]
152
152
Robust Near-Isometric Matching via Structured Learning of Graphical Models
Models for near-rigid shape matching are typically based on distance-related features, in order to infer matches that are consistent with the isometric assumption. However, real shapes from image datasets, even when expected to be related by "almost isometric" transformations, are actually subject not only to noise but also, to some limited degree, to variations in appearance and scale. In this paper, we introduce a graphical model that parameterises appearance, distance, and angle features and we learn all of the involved parameters via structured prediction. The outcome is a model for near-rigid shape matching which is robust in the sense that it is able to capture the possibly limited but still important scale and appearance variations. Our experimental results reveal substantial improvements upon recent successful models, while maintaining similar running times.
[ -0.009379569441080093, -0.04251464456319809, 0.02122955583035946, -0.052224453538656235, -0.028312712907791138, -0.021632550284266472, 0.024678174406290054, 0.0012750114547088742, -0.04965781792998314, 0.053961899131536484, -0.0038632366340607405, -0.0960303321480751, -0.02485923282802105, -0.01285679079592228, 0.007646748796105385, -0.007871146313846111, 0.0335579551756382, -0.0021521763410419226, -0.016498366370797157, -0.02981310524046421, 0.023792101070284843, 0.028411803767085075, -0.05495848506689072, -0.03306006267666817, 0.09708672016859055, 0.04828782379627228, 0.022518904879689217, -0.009088010527193546, 0.0402948334813118, 0.027050720527768135, -0.003449469106271863, -0.03747884929180145, -0.005301634781062603, -0.05201566964387894, 0.005176785867661238, 0.15977546572685242, 0.03547057881951332, -0.028185207396745682, -0.0014867358841001987, -0.002844336209818721, -0.03543486073613167, 0.03553247079253197, 0.055123958736658096, -0.01777886599302292, -0.00006979232421144843, 0.011681567877531052, -0.03227002173662186, 0.004980282858014107, 0.009339489042758942, 0.05821028724312782, -0.02836979553103447, 0.022334858775138855, 0.016635950654745102, 0.04782857373356819, 0.0062914686277508736, 0.05379370599985123, 0.033697910606861115, 0.015606813132762909, -0.041416577994823456, 0.031973306089639664, 0.026581071317195892, 0.08972666412591934, -0.0006931781535968184, -0.028433702886104584, 0.06885973364114761, -0.03211391344666481, -0.06596796959638596, 0.027227334678173065, -0.04755275323987007, -0.078713558614254, -0.07301230728626251, -0.03660839423537254, -0.03530623018741608, 0.0520896390080452, 0.02466540038585663, 0.006462413351982832, 0.021568771451711655, -0.012607196345925331, 0.054094646126031876, 0.04502299427986145, -0.025391079485416412, -0.01944843865931034, -0.05357848107814789, -0.008299669250845909, -0.007874478586018085, 0.026757454499602318, -0.015583398751914501, 0.015001495368778706, 0.06192106381058693, 0.02076508291065693, -0.035548776388168335, -0.009474205784499645, -0.031842462718486786, 0.06743236631155014, -0.07021421939134598, -0.012603379786014557, 0.06423890590667725, 0.007469418458640575, -0.0382441021502018, 0.09675567597150803, -0.008954380638897419, 0.0289651807397604, 0.012044589966535568, 0.0023437996860593557, -0.0411824956536293, -0.01863248646259308, 0.00047530539450235665, 0.06389423459768295, 0.008015376515686512, -0.07337179780006409, -0.0011091118212789297, -0.029216038063168526, -0.03505953028798103, -0.033253490924835205, -0.04171345382928848, 0.03362702578306198, -0.029129758477211, 0.1010376513004303, 0.05230041965842247, 0.01819070428609848, -0.030752353370189667, 0.04806333780288696, -0.040074773132801056, 0.037439726293087006, 0.05826869234442711, -0.02428821660578251, -0.026602553203701973, -0.046948276460170746, 0.11056201159954071, -0.009741025045514107, -0.06468553841114044, -0.014460677281022072, -0.018526647239923477, 0.003680806839838624, -0.14259064197540283, 0.015298068523406982, -0.06695280969142914, 0.033920593559741974, -0.06009034067392349, 0.08194705098867416, 0.0054637352004647255, -0.022263219580054283, -0.009915719740092754, 0.013702090829610825, -0.02749449945986271, 0.04739813134074211, 0.009265076369047165, 0.00024998351000249386, 0.031814418733119965, -0.0057382117956876755, -0.024283187463879585, -0.06854134052991867, 0.03684606775641441, 0.03185877203941345, -0.02468036115169525, -0.04804610460996628, -0.003839764278382063, -0.014120100066065788, -0.039743758738040924, 0.045492783188819885, 0.04978878051042557, 0.02912348508834839, 0.005521595478057861, -0.01539094652980566, 0.0007394267595373094, -0.017102327197790146, 0.021069934591650963, -0.03140659257769585, -0.05360310897231102, 0.0175176989287138, -0.04165282100439072, 0.026964975520968437, -0.08165507018566132, 0.011344902217388153, -0.0031006704084575176, -0.0545913428068161, 0.026058577001094818, 0.07269124686717987, -0.015787599608302116, 0.0042083836160600185, -0.007840891368687153, -0.08413241803646088, 0.02698931284248829, 0.07378014922142029, 0.03337711840867996, 0.1142776608467102, -0.056499987840652466, -0.050539273768663406, 0.0027985083870589733, 0.02212073653936386, -0.02684161625802517, -0.019927551969885826, 0.00209083897061646, 0.026023948565125465, -0.0413677841424942, 0.04191121459007263, 0.017232026904821396, 0.013432278297841549, 0.01590866968035698, 0.031209491193294525, 0.03780811280012131, -0.015791429206728935, -0.06595494598150253, -0.05336850881576538, -0.09332458674907684, -0.049754831939935684, 0.037694208323955536, -0.00006075572673580609, 0.00036724997335113585, 0.019286423921585083, 0.05952088534832001, -0.003221620572730899, -0.08376213908195496, -0.06620294600725174, -0.025461513549089432, -0.01917683519423008, 0.0009928833460435271, -0.05623537674546242, 0.02693020924925804, 0.03589140996336937, -0.028716662898659706, 0.04531681537628174, -0.012985656037926674, 0.03157833591103554, -0.029597807675600052, 0.04510593041777611, 0.0025647778529673815, -0.058096569031476974, -0.10645405203104019, 0.046691037714481354, -0.007052641827613115, -0.02202114835381508, -0.01721237413585186, -0.037357792258262634, 0.02565775439143181, -0.02655644156038761, -0.029401805251836777, -0.015193118713796139, -0.037274934351444244, -0.025479933246970177, 0.018716031685471535, 0.02125747874379158, 0.06926985085010529, -0.03998600319027901, -0.07278982549905777, -0.03298752009868622, 0.07170276343822479, 0.01226808037608862, 0.03332960978150368, 0.011792885139584541, -0.0015864851884543896, 0.005563782062381506, -0.010290192440152168, -0.1349986046552658, 0.033310070633888245, -0.009041172452270985, 0.01895599626004696, -0.019836418330669403, 0.055765245109796524, 0.06043371185660362, 0.056562814861536026, 0.04924344643950462, 0.0004740086442325264, -0.035632070153951645, 0.07779427617788315, -0.08732758462429047, 0.005845156963914633, 0.0037359423004090786, 0.01073878351598978, -0.007131424266844988, 0.08537468314170837, -0.11469761282205582, -0.014866777695715427, -0.0028724700678139925, -0.018544351682066917, 0.049409616738557816, 0.03849545121192932, 0.07574474066495895, -0.02999858185648918, -0.04614848643541336, -0.11205928027629852, -0.007355961017310619, -0.023369507864117622, -0.08372334390878677, -0.033638373017311096, 0.057850103825330734, -0.04577004164457321, 0.007497168146073818, 0.05819891393184662, -0.08768726140260696, -0.04093844071030617, 0.06337939947843552, -0.10671112686395645, -0.01586737483739853, 0.04260517284274101, -0.052979644387960434, 0.028171628713607788, 0.005966633558273315, 0.04183371365070343, 0.04147262126207352, -0.00391633715480566, 0.024922048673033714, -0.018063053488731384, 0.04467036947607994, 0.055497705936431885, -0.08193238079547882, 0.029313920065760612, 0.03247023746371269, -0.08944438397884369, -0.016861341893672943, -0.030463386327028275, -0.06984276324510574, -0.03618089482188225, -0.010043364018201828, -0.0033502643927931786, -0.04177095741033554, -0.04933593049645424, 0.05417521670460701, 0.009571158327162266, 0.043514806777238846, 0.04148201644420624, -0.06644729524850845, -0.028513742610812187, 0.027109166607260704, -0.019114352762699127, -0.11946194618940353, -0.058547213673591614, 0.00834127888083458, -0.07692509144544601, -0.03382817283272743, -0.05688280239701271, -0.021121522411704063, -0.04272132366895676, 0.06671103835105896, -0.053074996918439865, 0.0580274872481823, -0.043332289904356, -0.042032331228256226, 0.014855357818305492, -0.02608386054635048, -0.014244728721678257, -0.07193738222122192, -0.0010277301771566272, -0.06977282464504242, 0.011266081593930721, 0.07981842011213303, 0.10390226542949677, -0.05248870328068733, 0.006293121259659529, 0.0044514271430671215, -0.017226390540599823, 0.0071103270165622234, -0.020644398406147957, 0.007127382792532444, 0.024468183517456055, 0.034269846975803375, 0.028506670147180557, 0.04624846205115318, 0.005135905928909779, 0.015188416466116905, 0.03761068359017372, 0.04299810901284218, -0.05768337473273277, 0.03203753009438515, -0.025629635900259018, 0.09920569509267807, -0.08647456020116806, 0.01883927546441555, 0.01399726327508688, 0.028884241357445717, 0.01456909254193306, 0.01943053863942623, 0.020697880536317825, -0.027990002185106277, 0.013954885303974152, 0.03558196872472763, 0.03415781259536743, -0.015735965222120285, 0.057265084236860275, -0.028337595984339714, -0.005265029612928629, -0.01101278979331255, -0.00981659721583128, -0.06590508669614792, -0.044509779661893845, 0.005832991562783718, -0.03237822651863098, 0.022320443764328957, 0.008994126692414284, 0.02240653522312641, 0.00570108275860548, -0.02589433640241623, 0.06552965939044952, -0.06141252443194389, 0.03432096168398857, 0.008314885199069977, 0.016995565965771675, 0.0018279983196407557, 0.04353933781385422, 0.026239890605211258, -0.043150171637535095, -0.0004271072684787214, -0.08263743668794632, -0.027367157861590385, -0.10596506297588348, -0.055948905646800995, -0.010446728207170963, 0.04078270494937897, 0.01056064572185278, 0.0705474466085434, -0.027211936190724373, 0.00379572669044137, -0.0009059394942596555, 0.0015321980463340878, 0.05318528786301613, 0.012937928549945354, -0.008830979466438293, 0.021252095699310303, -0.014039108529686928, -0.008245827630162239, 0.041487544775009155, -0.0010403894120827317, 0.019321506842970848, 0.029717516154050827, -0.03312912955880165, -0.04863130673766136, 0.05848648026585579, 0.002873691264539957, -0.06811147183179855, 0.07578904181718826, 0.018318595364689827, 0.043934110552072525, -0.08850926905870438, 0.007460672874003649, -0.04767261818051338, -0.0009361196425743401, 0.08878923207521439, -0.057412393391132355, -0.039465632289648056, -0.0025773034431040287, -0.03807583451271057, -0.012576249428093433, -0.0031395265832543373, 0.006316333077847958, -0.01625611074268818, 0.05039152503013611, -0.01168396882712841, -0.01755177415907383, 0.027556687593460083, 0.06511058658361435, -0.03913429379463196, -0.04843652620911598, -0.04797910153865814, -0.022575804963707924, -0.0038905355613678694, 0.01435849443078041, -0.035121552646160126, -0.06463783234357834, 0.04584198445081711, -0.06847400963306427, -0.022528907284140587, -0.025649523362517357, 0.007424596231430769, 0.04028903692960739, -0.07003534585237503, 0.07337435334920883, 0.057602234184741974, 0.0441281720995903, 0.05698384344577789, -0.002126183593645692, -0.04528746381402016, -0.012637365609407425, 0.10839714854955673, -0.013548550195991993, 0.000037575453461613506, 0.026677699759602547, 0.06576574593782425, -0.07164783775806427, 0.007847793400287628, -0.005208832677453756, 0.021832715719938278, -0.0009999036556109786, -0.046453848481178284, 0.009033789858222008, 0.005478226579725742, 0.045885831117630005, -0.040485039353370667, 0.04121685400605202, 0.08099278062582016, 0.007251763250678778, 0.022446567192673683, -0.013796388171613216, 0.019166065379977226, 0.07301721721887589, -0.03675661236047745, 0.010837437584996223, 0.01655803993344307, -0.0053169457241892815, 0.09391993284225464, -0.053862906992435455, 0.041182368993759155, -0.046432167291641235, 0.006951099261641502, 0.051202621310949326, 0.045066311955451965, 0.02555140107870102, 0.035090476274490356, -0.01668093539774418, 0.004896527621895075, 0.014236494898796082, -0.07564622908830643, 0.010839803144335747 ]
153
153
Learning Hidden Markov Models using Non-Negative Matrix Factorization
The Baum-Welsh algorithm together with its derivatives and variations has been the main technique for learning Hidden Markov Models (HMM) from observational data. We present an HMM learning algorithm based on the non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) of higher order Markovian statistics that is structurally different from the Baum-Welsh and its associated approaches. The described algorithm supports estimation of the number of recurrent states of an HMM and iterates the non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) algorithm to improve the learned HMM parameters. Numerical examples are provided as well.
[ -0.07468575984239578, -0.06271033734083176, 0.024424098432064056, -0.040718890726566315, 0.007826384156942368, -0.04619688168168068, -0.022206179797649384, 0.05129013583064079, 0.038433946669101715, 0.0030701749492436647, -0.050767917186021805, -0.028640368953347206, -0.037749871611595154, 0.05012431740760803, 0.013097651302814484, -0.009247055277228355, 0.020245715975761414, -0.0008039966924116015, 0.023812176659703255, -0.06865310668945312, 0.0017039659433066845, 0.007567562162876129, 0.033619195222854614, -0.05778759345412254, -0.014468350447714329, 0.06295771896839142, -0.005208900664001703, -0.022381572052836418, 0.0006167445098981261, -0.04058109223842621, -0.025031471624970436, -0.013057195581495762, 0.07642938941717148, -0.011201459914445877, 0.010625505819916725, -0.016114171594381332, 0.03663233667612076, -0.020167846232652664, -0.04086890444159508, -0.016503339633345604, -0.003532113740220666, -0.02784457616508007, 0.03764642775058746, -0.04363293573260307, -0.021320050582289696, 0.08489689230918884, 0.10345432907342911, 0.020011434331536293, -0.03129303827881813, 0.04101016744971275, -0.03412758186459541, 0.004091016948223114, -0.03656185418367386, 0.0017475177301093936, -0.03780451789498329, 0.09327428787946701, -0.03687014430761337, 0.04684867709875107, 0.031337980180978775, -0.013838647864758968, 0.038397639989852905, 0.05138491466641426, 0.019012276083230972, -0.01022100355476141, 0.034393925219774246, 0.0163807962089777, -0.11677372455596924, -0.02600725181400776, -0.03966107219457626, -0.044332608580589294, 0.01870638132095337, 0.01953032612800598, 0.04711243510246277, 0.0016735406825318933, -0.007748874370008707, 0.015153177082538605, -0.04360039532184601, 0.07451992481946945, 0.08982383459806442, 0.12899725139141083, -0.03184719756245613, 0.021109826862812042, 0.03959828242659569, 0.045655522495508194, -0.025218581780791283, -0.020206846296787262, -0.013363994657993317, -0.030771952122449875, -0.0025213814806193113, -0.014529556967318058, 0.006303707603365183, 0.03307892754673958, -0.06905537098646164, 0.020909061655402184, -0.02991292253136635, 0.03717440739274025, -0.024273471906781197, -0.012323575094342232, -0.013050753623247147, -0.042781416326761246, 0.01202655490487814, -0.021636560559272766, 0.06635318696498871, 0.03224357217550278, -0.06607173383235931, 0.0016549648717045784, -0.06808264553546906, -0.004679321311414242, 0.03377148509025574, -0.051207285374403, 0.13122768700122833, 0.02413003146648407, 0.06809059530496597, 0.045679401606321335, -0.01790076494216919, 0.036490265280008316, 0.011098833754658699, 0.03383117541670799, 0.007930252701044083, 0.03545743599534035, -0.04176437854766846, 0.015665652230381966, 0.0404842384159565, 0.027415921911597252, 0.0655200406908989, -0.04089382663369179, 0.008089783601462841, -0.023344507440924644, 0.13559068739414215, -0.020602552220225334, -0.0019868810195475817, 0.002458699746057391, 0.04424571618437767, -0.032127056270837784, -0.04443611949682236, -0.03299621120095253, 0.02843688428401947, 0.052416879683732986, -0.01487499475479126, 0.05089576169848442, 0.004249395336955786, 0.031299713999032974, 0.00844079814851284, -0.032466158270835876, -0.06299634277820587, -0.034249112010002136, -0.034095991402864456, 0.03239412605762482, -0.022443538531661034, -0.03903632238507271, -0.0317082554101944, -0.018956825137138367, 0.02946399338543415, -0.02119358256459236, 0.0035796738229691982, -0.01082735974341631, -0.010713513009250164, 0.029218154028058052, -0.008754922077059746, -0.005496894009411335, -0.02862457185983658, 0.004918754566460848, -0.046968258917331696, 0.041295066475868225, 0.0367109552025795, -0.03357658162713051, -0.08406542986631393, 0.03501595929265022, -0.040597036480903625, 0.01643366925418377, -0.025964410975575447, 0.00032058372744359076, 0.051662180572748184, 0.00047319746227003634, 0.02235049568116665, 0.023961864411830902, -0.00006293928890954703, 0.03221798315644264, 0.0034029404632747173, 0.05080883204936981, -0.05342281609773636, -0.05250005051493645, -0.05224791541695595, -0.02460394613444805, 0.09700208157300949, 0.009991141967475414, 0.02738768234848976, 0.02413741871714592, 0.07601679116487503, -0.018156275153160095, 0.015790501609444618, 0.011098867282271385, -0.01206949632614851, -0.032171010971069336, -0.03336459398269653, 0.001976905157789588, -0.0568196102976799, -0.013266405090689659, 0.051823120564222336, 0.13066725432872772, -0.007257722318172455, -0.04166875034570694, -0.03142135590314865, 0.005243894178420305, -0.005995833780616522, -0.0003314900677651167, 0.005515780299901962, 0.04616548866033554, -0.021563436836004257, -0.025590665638446808, -0.015303649939596653, -0.0034340748097747564, -0.0452822707593441, -0.0456446036696434, 0.022711319848895073, -0.13243094086647034, 0.008366363123059273, -0.032423365861177444, 0.045549146831035614, 0.06646984815597534, -0.06860397011041641, 0.023400790989398956, 0.005960006732493639, 0.06658493727445602, -0.08444245159626007, -0.043962396681308746, 0.02083004266023636, -0.0013063376536592841, -0.008571287617087364, 0.004658482503145933, -0.018685560673475266, -0.07220333069562912, 0.007265505846589804, -0.05286559835076332, 0.014894895255565643, 0.01208182517439127, -0.01839926838874817, -0.03176417946815491, -0.034586403518915176, -0.005701459012925625, -0.04852496460080147, 0.08019884675741196, -0.00042528577614575624, 0.0645693987607956, 0.0031816635746508837, -0.09299460053443909, -0.0247935988008976, 0.03842838481068611, -0.013026862405240536, -0.04127436876296997, 0.017165444791316986, 0.02198067493736744, -0.03132885321974754, -0.008097422309219837, 0.010855203494429588, 0.042703088372945786, -0.040442608296871185, 0.09031325578689575, -0.0043883188627660275, 0.03930063173174858, 0.048228565603494644, 0.03412706032395363, -0.07719647139310837, 0.06427323073148727, 0.08794010430574417, -0.036259572952985764, -0.056533511728048325, -0.023642081767320633, 0.042153798043727875, -0.036189060658216476, 0.08172427117824554, -0.05483243241906166, 0.006599664222449064, 0.11882833391427994, 0.010734410025179386, -0.024125320836901665, -0.02513493411242962, 0.03224071115255356, 0.02500205673277378, -0.0787762925028801, -0.03150218352675438, 0.011992199346423149, -0.0377415269613266, 0.009263364598155022, 0.0010277304099872708, -0.015680436044931412, 0.009107538498938084, 0.03982554376125336, -0.03178749606013298, -0.015080428682267666, -0.06144562363624573, -0.0023730392567813396, -0.03360474109649658, 0.0248065497726202, 0.02725433185696602, -0.029527993872761726, 0.05727988854050636, -0.06568333506584167, -0.030168864876031876, 0.006717456504702568, 0.039660029113292694, -0.04949680715799332, 0.06143469735980034, -0.008977196179330349, -0.01769479364156723, -0.006914989557117224, 0.0245856661349535, 0.053345829248428345, -0.026609860360622406, 0.037123046815395355, 0.009080558083951473, -0.003312676679342985, -0.03623563051223755, -0.02598745748400688, 0.02861950173974037, -0.026356011629104614, 0.01467971783131361, -0.05159609019756317, -0.038516487926244736, -0.04794352501630783, 0.05240626633167267, 0.024907311424613, 0.062647745013237, -0.01598994806408882, -0.0037732096388936043, -0.028259575366973877, -0.0005281794001348317, 0.07195453345775604, -0.02916298247873783, 0.062343891710042953, -0.050336092710494995, 0.052514784038066864, -0.03487006947398186, 0.08012143522500992, 0.0006114382995292544, -0.02125600539147854, 0.008765812031924725, -0.017916996031999588, -0.004550188779830933, 0.001352141727693379, -0.07500924170017242, -0.10016198456287384, -0.008474188856780529, -0.0013438250171020627, 0.04760723561048508, 0.0526619516313076, 0.06281888484954834, -0.023881543427705765, -0.003704211674630642, 0.0021922544110566378, 0.055324044078588486, 0.013865235261619091, -0.016768569126725197, 0.06603775173425674, -0.01886150985956192, 0.053300630301237106, 0.042169682681560516, 0.06676551699638367, 0.05288352072238922, 0.05607093125581741, -0.012774958275258541, 0.036521874368190765, 0.02719196304678917, -0.0576208271086216, 0.04874778911471367, 0.06179411709308624, -0.03400321304798126, -0.014263246208429337, -0.06257887184619904, -0.017030850052833557, 0.0009062995668500662, 0.012854332104325294, 0.14235365390777588, -0.002153136068955064, 0.03828510642051697, 0.018275022506713867, 0.04174625501036644, -0.023215489462018013, 0.014860491268336773, 0.04881126433610916, -0.026333477348089218, -0.09377996623516083, 0.03841589391231537, 0.01688050851225853, -0.05095528066158295, 0.018504656851291656, -0.07539217919111252, 0.08348462730646133, 0.03795018419623375, -0.059322722256183624, -0.06558046489953995, -0.019018687307834625, -0.03701525181531906, 0.08014818280935287, 0.011143720708787441, 0.029852813109755516, 0.00920162908732891, -0.013012751005589962, -0.05069475993514061, 0.018184466287493706, -0.014282037504017353, -0.07526589930057526, 0.015677262097597122, -0.10688526928424835, -0.025432255119085312, 0.06272847950458527, 0.06651569157838821, 0.08186525106430054, -0.010251794941723347, 0.039141278713941574, 0.005855692084878683, 0.04796428605914116, -0.044498175382614136, -0.026466267183423042, 0.06958054006099701, 0.06514976918697357, -0.005840562749654055, -0.0400892049074173, 0.0061202035285532475, -0.05695737153291702, -0.02143438346683979, -0.030375998467206955, 0.009399620816111565, 0.0330696664750576, -0.09426555037498474, 0.0041756103746593, -0.05489903688430786, 0.08297919481992722, -0.027811480686068535, 0.028425440192222595, -0.09928493201732635, 0.013638350181281567, -0.0045802597887814045, -0.03710471838712692, 0.0034629853907972574, -0.03319603577256203, 0.03734603524208069, 0.016478417441248894, 0.003367325523868203, 0.04316500201821327, -0.045004844665527344, -0.04149238020181656, -0.03863642364740372, 0.044681958854198456, 0.016445256769657135, 0.021315928548574448, 0.05716993287205696, -0.028204813599586487, 0.06301679462194443, 0.008587311953306198, -0.021440329030156136, 0.05948513373732567, -0.003304108278825879, -0.03956099599599838, 0.020187143236398697, 0.02350773476064205, 0.027520379051566124, 0.005119062028825283, 0.07070748507976532, 0.049948155879974365, 0.00007136062777135521, 0.021054327487945557, -0.000714432040695101, 0.03140668943524361, -0.061865806579589844, -0.06987833976745605, 0.022000182420015335, 0.037803713232278824, 0.06893305480480194, -0.024193691089749336, -0.09067796915769577, -0.010273706167936325, 0.01926504634320736, 0.016976527869701385, 0.02989472821354866, 0.05315627530217171, 0.09823901951313019, -0.0313432440161705, -0.05423780158162117, -0.035570453852415085, 0.07801502197980881, 0.03743062540888786, 0.015560177154839039, 0.04708349332213402, -0.05140025541186333, 0.06703078746795654, 0.0956902801990509, 0.06617844849824905, 0.034750957041978836, 0.035334717482328415, 0.024133628234267235, -0.0035696092527359724, 0.057969097048044205, -0.013887376524508, 0.017543332651257515, -0.0160254817456007, -0.036623697727918625, -0.034869901835918427, -0.048509348183870316, 0.024142784997820854, 0.045389678329229355, 0.03983244299888611, -0.04960080236196518, -0.02128835953772068, 0.12637606263160706, 0.014579806476831436, 0.0436369888484478, -0.028117531910538673, -0.0346112921833992, 0.11798910051584244, 0.03236233815550804, 0.014439120888710022 ]
154
154
Surrogate Learning - An Approach for Semi-Supervised Classification
We consider the task of learning a classifier from the feature space $\mathcal{X}$ to the set of classes $\mathcal{Y} = \{0, 1\}$, when the features can be partitioned into class-conditionally independent feature sets $\mathcal{X}_1$ and $\mathcal{X}_2$. We show the surprising fact that the class-conditional independence can be used to represent the original learning task in terms of 1) learning a classifier from $\mathcal{X}_2$ to $\mathcal{X}_1$ and 2) learning the class-conditional distribution of the feature set $\mathcal{X}_1$. This fact can be exploited for semi-supervised learning because the former task can be accomplished purely from unlabeled samples. We present experimental evaluation of the idea in two real world applications.
[ 0.0034985935781151056, -0.06387408822774887, 0.00852201972156763, 0.002755429595708847, 0.096193328499794, -0.07062529027462006, -0.029216403141617775, 0.045565132051706314, -0.02509024366736412, 0.044542450457811356, -0.04119820147752762, 0.03445672243833542, -0.02640264667570591, 0.008999558165669441, 0.07682358473539352, 0.07333405315876007, -0.006094474345445633, 0.034066092222929, -0.011891636997461319, -0.051962610334157944, 0.0488194115459919, -0.06707808375358582, 0.0025307312607765198, -0.03038458712399006, 0.0048584179021418095, -0.05479924753308296, -0.054166797548532486, 0.006770802661776543, -0.09014704823493958, -0.04003724828362465, -0.021789534017443657, -0.04726569354534149, -0.058036837726831436, -0.04101830720901489, -0.01667344942688942, -0.007632892113178968, -0.0008676756406202912, 0.025191273540258408, -0.07643923163414001, 0.04383007436990738, 0.02646818198263645, 0.07953477650880814, 0.017970066517591476, 0.018637945875525475, 0.008727934211492538, 0.04798785597085953, -0.007044478319585323, -0.09892114251852036, -0.006973429583013058, 0.09300533682107925, -0.13363830745220184, -0.05428808182477951, -0.023643620312213898, 0.014725607819855213, -0.027294421568512917, 0.005687488708645105, -0.008098939433693886, 0.06161009892821312, -0.018382329493761063, 0.007977942936122417, 0.008261221460998058, 0.14068783819675446, -0.003838250646367669, 0.03311789780855179, -0.03180071339011192, -0.024959050118923187, -0.06259573251008987, -0.02808361127972603, 0.050454575568437576, -0.01790815405547619, -0.013199329376220703, -0.0578768253326416, 0.011430606245994568, 0.06320597231388092, 0.02868315763771534, 0.05741986259818077, 0.03549206629395485, 0.0270357858389616, -0.018962278962135315, 0.07632748782634735, -0.039455004036426544, -0.03496536985039711, 0.059323422610759735, -0.03724164888262749, -0.029520055279135704, -0.01653016358613968, 0.006363305263221264, -0.011794638819992542, 0.01632280834019184, 0.03762994334101677, 0.009768984280526638, 0.019007602706551552, -0.07300803810358047, -0.02006983943283558, -0.03312721475958824, -0.026100067421793938, 0.04711874574422836, -0.05268165469169617, 0.033054180443286896, 0.05754956230521202, 0.01563379541039467, -0.05431169643998146, 0.05163085088133812, 0.03633309528231621, -0.02035522647202015, 0.010460449382662773, -0.021067852154374123, 0.04430549964308739, 0.04404742270708084, -0.019218839704990387, 0.041233569383621216, -0.0037324542645365, 0.06862763315439224, -0.017069106921553612, -0.06799360364675522, 0.05671508237719536, -0.014994209632277489, 0.07190471887588501, 0.08183382451534271, 0.03456941992044449, -0.005987945012748241, 0.022141771391034126, -0.10528181493282318, 0.04796872287988663, 0.029159871861338615, -0.026566142216324806, -0.056989140808582306, -0.07346570491790771, 0.11106013506650925, 0.05242258682847023, -0.04773419350385666, 0.052026595920324326, -0.020425787195563316, -0.017309898510575294, -0.0029589494224637747, -0.0024765017442405224, 0.04633212462067604, -0.00869409367442131, -0.025555673986673355, 0.027434105053544044, -0.025265676900744438, -0.028279269114136696, 0.026435285806655884, 0.01683969236910343, 0.06802265346050262, 0.021704990416765213, 0.015995478257536888, 0.0009732238249853253, 0.06630867719650269, 0.026946719735860825, 0.008773775771260262, -0.04513884335756302, 0.05406126007437706, 0.06843113154172897, 0.04586995765566826, -0.02988259866833687, 0.04048115760087967, 0.0031756709795445204, 0.028176534920930862, 0.08954797685146332, -0.021466819569468498, 0.0046407682821154594, 0.07482901960611343, 0.025723932310938835, -0.04576040059328079, 0.022090328857302666, -0.0020004778634756804, -0.0055642700754106045, -0.03154260665178299, -0.02908013015985489, -0.01850602589547634, 0.0788201168179512, -0.04634268954396248, -0.02857058495283127, 0.013172798790037632, -0.0027963106986135244, -0.0826633870601654, -0.014440379105508327, 0.012412595562636852, 0.03280387818813324, 0.025534318760037422, -0.03339201211929321, -0.029833240434527397, 0.010788863524794579, -0.011104605160653591, 0.0402594730257988, 0.028553441166877747, 0.04981401562690735, 0.059301819652318954, -0.034260187298059464, 0.053390275686979294, 0.043260108679533005, -0.045718349516391754, -0.03986518085002899, -0.0989958867430687, 0.061209969222545624, 0.022351346909999847, -0.014326243661344051, 0.03834958001971245, 0.053327448666095734, 0.013529214076697826, 0.008347765542566776, -0.012082498520612717, -0.013003683649003506, -0.064173623919487, 0.05921672284603119, 0.031617309898138046, 0.004271657206118107, 0.020217563956975937, -0.0335952453315258, -0.0022983397357165813, -0.0167377982288599, 0.025115637108683586, 0.041744060814380646, -0.04482041671872139, -0.03416687250137329, -0.12110409885644913, -0.03420241177082062, 0.05177593603730202, 0.09239231050014496, 0.005088030360639095, -0.04829799011349678, -0.053334664553403854, 0.0755654126405716, 0.00910291075706482, 0.03384660556912422, 0.0035780351608991623, -0.039558276534080505, -0.014625335112214088, 0.007177968975156546, -0.1232624277472496, -0.03611038625240326, -0.08715645968914032, -0.03566484525799751, 0.04245404154062271, 0.005081027280539274, -0.10254353284835815, 0.021438203752040863, -0.024007072672247887, 0.021289914846420288, -0.012555564753711224, 0.0026075122877955437, 0.0031982760410755873, 0.036189597100019455, 0.026603499427437782, 0.0027727624401450157, 0.008469164371490479, 0.041550423949956894, 0.011761883273720741, 0.006931266747415066, -0.0227966271340847, 0.05163148418068886, -0.010435785166919231, -0.05943923071026802, 0.01540494617074728, 0.015695830807089806, -0.04659373313188553, 0.005732565652579069, -0.011119061149656773, 0.009048574604094028, 0.04416199028491974, -0.01087296660989523, -0.00847262516617775, 0.03715616837143898, 0.07996637374162674, 0.026262734085321426, 0.02395596355199814, 0.016541332006454468, -0.015546868555247784, 0.05301223695278168, -0.011898968368768692, -0.11330537497997284, -0.047041427344083786, 0.002905560191720724, -0.06154191121459007, 0.037050746381282806, 0.018765335902571678, 0.0006838746485300362, 0.04460196942090988, -0.09807054698467255, 0.025738757103681564, 0.022074641659855843, 0.016752224415540695, -0.02161695621907711, 0.0352916456758976, -0.06487882882356644, -0.03330805525183678, -0.03717822954058647, 0.002131188055500388, 0.0028281835839152336, -0.03527963533997536, 0.03275392949581146, 0.030446624383330345, 0.02799353189766407, 0.07729950547218323, -0.07769323885440826, 0.03189005330204964, -0.015966489911079407, 0.009196022525429726, -0.03223134204745293, 0.03439413383603096, 0.02661365643143654, 0.03835591673851013, 0.017230551689863205, 0.051201123744249344, 0.05427304655313492, 0.038003917783498764, 0.03501249849796295, -0.03195364773273468, 0.021173670887947083, 0.01898350939154625, 0.03147685527801514, 0.022219985723495483, 0.0607614703476429, -0.01202757004648447, -0.006831817328929901, -0.015423993580043316, -0.04733966663479805, -0.013055654242634773, -0.013718917965888977, 0.09708059579133987, -0.035980451852083206, -0.033170185983181, -0.022281717509031296, -0.09257583320140839, -0.02740669809281826, 0.04751821234822273, 0.03219955414533615, -0.11140190809965134, -0.008041709661483765, -0.026996202766895294, -0.06892500072717667, -0.009253028780221939, 0.09478530287742615, -0.020920738577842712, 0.023268071934580803, -0.09433498233556747, -0.01867811009287834, -0.0059692165814340115, -0.01659698598086834, -0.037700675427913666, -0.03006932884454727, 0.020394286140799522, -0.016406090930104256, -0.0004196509544271976, -0.03739931806921959, 0.020130004733800888, -0.006494714878499508, -0.045064184814691544, 0.0902339294552803, -0.03886855021119118, 0.042430534958839417, -0.10011513531208038, 0.020915504544973373, -0.05594787001609802, -0.005068127531558275, 0.05240480974316597, -0.012689917348325253, -0.016497954726219177, -0.030234379693865776, 0.0036900367122143507, 0.033337149769067764, -0.0690835639834404, 0.05665501952171326, -0.011169776320457458, 0.07384832203388214, 0.04794265702366829, -0.03538363054394722, -0.035408198833465576, -0.05156627297401428, -0.03615228831768036, -0.019596042111516, 0.039001885801553726, -0.004256928339600563, -0.03842158988118172, -0.037422019988298416, 0.005761537700891495, -0.023193610832095146, 0.01447854470461607, 0.04342859238386154, -0.05756405368447304, 0.03009328991174698, -0.03661339730024338, 0.03111420013010502, -0.042533207684755325, -0.0581650584936142, -0.04312938079237938, 0.011269507929682732, 0.08028590679168701, -0.012568851932883263, -0.026065025478601456, -0.07266022264957428, -0.029035497456789017, -0.008825181983411312, 0.009708259254693985, -0.07383609563112259, -0.022207053378224373, 0.04492432251572609, -0.023567719385027885, -0.028562217950820923, -0.017431532964110374, 0.0004571114550344646, -0.008462026715278625, -0.08848399668931961, -0.079783134162426, 0.03989727795124054, 0.00384912989102304, 0.12378446757793427, 0.016315821558237076, 0.01249038614332676, 0.033179838210344315, 0.03248533234000206, -0.03465024381875992, 0.030312752351164818, 0.0051658679731190205, 0.04532298073172569, 0.033044129610061646, 0.012685227207839489, 0.0033000828698277473, -0.07947249710559845, -0.02317619137465954, 0.04991358146071434, 0.029099609702825546, -0.019499044865369797, 0.07232620567083359, 0.031768254935741425, 0.04282742366194725, 0.05271965637803078, -0.0023096275981515646, 0.007289716973900795, -0.033441513776779175, 0.05312846228480339, -0.0882699266076088, 0.005062691867351532, 0.08152130246162415, -0.01995026506483555, 0.053511008620262146, -0.004051032941788435, 0.04866447672247887, 0.05712469667196274, -0.1146974191069603, 0.03120942786335945, 0.05474640429019928, 0.013497425243258476, 0.050848789513111115, 0.04731228947639465, 0.03150046244263649, -0.04661744460463524, 0.04460511729121208, 0.057487938553094864, -0.022463366389274597, -0.026063160970807076, 0.04224441200494766, -0.005622920114547014, 0.04101954773068428, -0.005110643804073334, 0.014715615659952164, -0.0711163654923439, 0.07441996783018112, 0.01773357018828392, -0.04758710786700249, -0.004456768278032541, -0.00023516260262113065, -0.009433972649276257, -0.02705640159547329, 0.03949222341179848, 0.04662589728832245, -0.012887478806078434, -0.052884284406900406, 0.017462391406297684, -0.0719333216547966, 0.02239295281469822, -0.09177257120609283, -0.026292072609066963, 0.04579296335577965, -0.08053088933229446, 0.020098702982068062, -0.027257433161139488, 0.008029913529753685, -0.01415866520255804, 0.04539826512336731, -0.0508834645152092, -0.018406154587864876, -0.018309935927391052, 0.012760034762322903, -0.011655671522021294, 0.03475671634078026, -0.04824945703148842, -0.018763475120067596, 0.021339301019906998, -0.010980034247040749, 0.0012620554771274328, -0.016489481553435326, -0.009217409417033195, 0.10467813163995743, -0.07230324298143387, -0.026369398459792137, 0.059621892869472504, -0.014439795166254044, 0.03264559432864189, -0.0037776753306388855, -0.00031378466519527137, 0.05503244698047638, -0.015471878461539745, 0.00908655021339655, 0.02357468008995056, -0.03863079845905304, -0.051166463643312454, -0.034040458500385284, 0.04162516072392464, 0.03675256669521332, 0.04613405093550682 ]
155
155
Multi-Armed Bandits in Metric Spaces
In a multi-armed bandit problem, an online algorithm chooses from a set of strategies in a sequence of trials so as to maximize the total payoff of the chosen strategies. While the performance of bandit algorithms with a small finite strategy set is quite well understood, bandit problems with large strategy sets are still a topic of very active investigation, motivated by practical applications such as online auctions and web advertisement. The goal of such research is to identify broad and natural classes of strategy sets and payoff functions which enable the design of efficient solutions. In this work we study a very general setting for the multi-armed bandit problem in which the strategies form a metric space, and the payoff function satisfies a Lipschitz condition with respect to the metric. We refer to this problem as the "Lipschitz MAB problem". We present a complete solution for the multi-armed problem in this setting. That is, for every metric space (L,X) we define an isometry invariant which bounds from below the performance of Lipschitz MAB algorithms for X, and we present an algorithm which comes arbitrarily close to meeting this bound. Furthermore, our technique gives even better results for benign payoff functions.
[ -0.03706546127796173, -0.03215058892965317, 0.07959707826375961, -0.013793213292956352, -0.0574040524661541, 0.019084274768829346, -0.035650406032800674, -0.0515364408493042, -0.07419878989458084, 0.04920778423547745, -0.03636649623513222, -0.06909734010696411, -0.02067057602107525, 0.06967451423406601, 0.043400704860687256, -0.05293073132634163, 0.020761512219905853, 0.036970604211091995, -0.010951408185064793, -0.002277353312820196, 0.0574507862329483, 0.06766604632139206, 0.011761166155338287, -0.05791117995977402, 0.028040612116456032, 0.02283022366464138, -0.01832648180425167, -0.03504957631230354, -0.01513161975890398, 0.004575024824589491, -0.03144088014960289, 0.007888520136475563, -0.002673680894076824, 0.04787404090166092, 0.030674124136567116, 0.025290682911872864, 0.07835143804550171, -0.04521060734987259, 0.029187677428126335, -0.035314105451107025, -0.002950673922896385, -0.04615027830004692, 0.029119791463017464, 0.03367471322417259, 0.0722523182630539, 0.0349920317530632, -0.0017614212119951844, -0.0039635030552744865, 0.0273883156478405, -0.01259708497673273, -0.0645994246006012, 0.05232737958431244, -0.04778757691383362, 0.017671087756752968, 0.024699989706277847, 0.0735287219285965, -0.034930430352687836, 0.014368257485330105, 0.04628273472189903, 0.0009818751132115722, 0.02043760195374489, 0.09176904708147049, 0.00946598220616579, -0.03180619701743126, -0.00792160164564848, -0.0341775044798851, -0.10767015069723129, -0.023236094042658806, -0.04391717538237572, -0.06927794218063354, 0.027792835608124733, -0.06899190694093704, 0.033269003033638, -0.002866567112505436, 0.0231898482888937, 0.03676999360322952, 0.054826389998197556, -0.06285002827644348, -0.01210848893970251, 0.04358810558915138, -0.07842034101486206, -0.011723355390131474, -0.01543936226516962, 0.10000096261501312, 0.023050447925925255, -0.09190748631954193, 0.05378597602248192, -0.010317099280655384, -0.03150223568081856, 0.00559857627376914, 0.003545725252479315, -0.052978139370679855, -0.036748096346855164, -0.009381437674164772, -0.029544971883296967, 0.04163401201367378, -0.02907271683216095, -0.01613452285528183, -0.03216612711548805, 0.016739876940846443, 0.03728316351771355, 0.05605708435177803, 0.09674905240535736, 0.05652669817209244, -0.05000278353691101, -0.015166005119681358, 0.011792153120040894, 0.049598321318626404, -0.005249890498816967, -0.011629871092736721, -0.015531222335994244, -0.042740803211927414, 0.07340256124734879, -0.01154421642422676, -0.03753791004419327, 0.015347487293183804, -0.019877765327692032, 0.004956524819135666, 0.017816711217164993, 0.03369678184390068, 0.012782882899045944, 0.021903716027736664, -0.00839654728770256, -0.0006041364395059645, 0.03756030648946762, -0.01569497212767601, 0.0583190843462944, -0.013572669588029385, 0.17489773035049438, 0.008120095357298851, -0.08954858779907227, 0.08112098276615143, 0.010620416142046452, -0.07748065888881683, -0.02329140529036522, 0.08158333599567413, 0.02468295581638813, 0.00945057813078165, 0.01596784219145775, 0.11624984443187714, -0.07148607075214386, -0.048487588763237, -0.05496739223599434, -0.005757361184805632, 0.01232425682246685, -0.0493633933365345, -0.02122986875474453, 0.0328669436275959, 0.04664932191371918, 0.06492345035076141, -0.04380890727043152, -0.03356863185763359, 0.03899603337049484, 0.031594809144735336, -0.02725411020219326, 0.005349261220544577, 0.05553935468196869, -0.05210333317518234, -0.03389417752623558, -0.006587221287190914, -0.0016768112545832992, 0.02310067228972912, -0.02524811401963234, 0.01676325313746929, 0.058719001710414886, -0.014520637691020966, 0.03818713128566742, 0.02669207751750946, -0.03982066735625267, -0.0408206507563591, -0.02340507321059704, -0.07956837117671967, -0.017969729378819466, 0.043726127594709396, -0.00972803495824337, -0.01571648195385933, -0.014380796812474728, -0.024167878553271294, 0.005548164714127779, 0.025740332901477814, -0.027485059574246407, 0.031580183655023575, 0.0007678448455408216, 0.018981510773301125, 0.02967359498143196, 0.03265086188912392, 0.01759866066277027, 0.007607556879520416, 0.10247235745191574, 0.04996976628899574, 0.000659331155475229, 0.016072360798716545, 0.010859834030270576, 0.021383756771683693, -0.00308451266027987, 0.001927249482832849, -0.026114320382475853, -0.07731765508651733, -0.017900846898555756, -0.037251971662044525, 0.02008904702961445, -0.05430864915251732, -0.0028489516116678715, 0.0008747485699132085, -0.03776833787560463, -0.020380061119794846, -0.01385785173624754, 0.008909080177545547, 0.00008702197374077514, -0.011485069990158081, -0.0581476204097271, -0.044838644564151764, 0.005343541968613863, -0.03269365429878235, 0.00934473518282175, -0.02866346575319767, -0.016047712415456772, -0.006972079630941153, -0.026545725762844086, -0.031134389340877533, -0.03432483971118927, 0.08038697391748428, 0.05835500359535217, -0.040986888110637665, 0.018378866836428642, 0.030512241646647453, -0.021610647439956665, -0.012288868427276611, -0.08324982970952988, 0.004757882095873356, -0.009261325933039188, -0.09883605688810349, 0.050783999264240265, 0.015143797732889652, -0.05989764258265495, 0.10781031847000122, -0.03860441595315933, -0.0742390975356102, 0.02012595906853676, -0.06251341104507446, -0.008042576722800732, -0.006212056148797274, 0.010134156793355942, -0.06471464782953262, 0.020252637565135956, -0.0012840019771829247, 0.04847431182861328, 0.005342746619135141, -0.04369904473423958, 0.004261931404471397, 0.029482822865247726, -0.09345735609531403, -0.05548391491174698, -0.006778792478144169, 0.04620692878961563, 0.009996894747018814, 0.02403116226196289, 0.059188589453697205, 0.06459330022335052, 0.03756866976618767, -0.03788616880774498, 0.06648123264312744, -0.03805442526936531, -0.026572858914732933, 0.03355716913938522, 0.023677345365285873, -0.025612205266952515, 0.03453382849693298, 0.021664133295416832, -0.054958295077085495, 0.0034804295282810926, -0.00717014167457819, -0.0748341903090477, 0.042827628552913666, -0.05678068473935127, -0.05887996777892113, -0.0016196324722841382, 0.01638982817530632, 0.034125834703445435, -0.023251177743077278, -0.049755193293094635, 0.031094877049326897, 0.03154657036066055, -0.08104325085878372, -0.01149497739970684, 0.014952930621802807, 0.103260837495327, -0.030177798122167587, -0.014767195098102093, 0.025281716138124466, -0.013951688073575497, 0.009227483533322811, -0.022893153131008148, 0.00009664245590101928, 0.019608402624726295, -0.010330740362405777, 0.010834942571818829, 0.02030530944466591, -0.038352128118276596, -0.055094677954912186, -0.010986470617353916, -0.09416629374027252, 0.06888338923454285, -0.020920351147651672, 0.010859357193112373, 0.09854620695114136, 0.056703295558691025, 0.02595217525959015, -0.10361869633197784, -0.0457879938185215, 0.047663021832704544, -0.003170719835907221, -0.023389805108308792, 0.03556422144174576, 0.07320299744606018, 0.0004706376639660448, -0.08610623329877853, 0.010013141669332981, -0.004644742235541344, 0.08571846783161163, 0.04236181080341339, 0.01453503780066967, 0.0021464689634740353, 0.027085136622190475, -0.12185493856668472, -0.056928496807813644, -0.07022970169782639, -0.02679670974612236, -0.015866674482822418, 0.006094835698604584, -0.07717809081077576, 0.055144209414720535, -0.02538583241403103, 0.00473471824079752, -0.07871785759925842, 0.021195558831095695, -0.042513564229011536, -0.03952515125274658, 0.006208671722561121, 0.04322221502661705, -0.09221631288528442, -0.11899713426828384, -0.07486528158187866, 0.02949363738298416, -0.059906087815761566, 0.053014423698186874, 0.02521538734436035, 0.06077117472887039, 0.009344460442662239, -0.0015181456692516804, -0.08143829554319382, 0.029742531478405, -0.025608522817492485, 0.06720250844955444, -0.07843472063541412, 0.01873837411403656, 0.053254056721925735, 0.007101915311068296, -0.03184818476438522, -0.004702124744653702, -0.05599232017993927, -0.0193680040538311, -0.01254928857088089, 0.05253727361559868, 0.034686073660850525, 0.0923357754945755, -0.0037674924824386835, 0.025738809257745743, -0.09960634261369705, 0.009102912619709969, -0.02015967294573784, 0.03161565214395523, 0.020947664976119995, -0.04246032238006592, 0.02952144853770733, -0.009110926650464535, 0.013794776052236557, -0.026820581406354904, -0.00018800476391334087, 0.03918294236063957, 0.0144690852612257, -0.0502239391207695, 0.011721402406692505, -0.03408525884151459, 0.031002884730696678, -0.037195853888988495, -0.06014762073755264, -0.007762213237583637, 0.09549959003925323, 0.02562691457569599, -0.04785946384072304, -0.08511141687631607, 0.02088768035173416, -0.022734155878424644, 0.04761528596282005, 0.08219342678785324, 0.003372613340616226, -0.08188427984714508, -0.003857177682220936, -0.025943612679839134, 0.027871226891875267, 0.00775348162278533, -0.0006633403245359659, -0.08468570560216904, -0.08474034816026688, 0.0467909500002861, 0.07788963615894318, 0.08611366152763367, -0.04667830467224121, 0.058252811431884766, 0.0005379722570069134, 0.04794091731309891, -0.051390640437603, 0.030710386112332344, -0.005841026548296213, -0.03807075321674347, 0.02573016844689846, -0.01609174907207489, -0.0044858865439891815, -0.05290302634239197, -0.001966871554031968, -0.034583739936351776, -0.02906903624534607, -0.04896603897213936, -0.04122493416070938, -0.019148338586091995, -0.028499675914645195, 0.09504491835832596, -0.03808654472231865, 0.0037827263586223125, -0.06367003172636032, -0.0015347128501161933, -0.05158032476902008, -0.04860924556851387, -0.04354899004101753, -0.02587873674929142, -0.020814398303627968, -0.04445170238614082, -0.0357896164059639, 0.00041796336881816387, -0.02108960971236229, 0.04676561802625656, -0.04101180285215378, 0.024523330852389336, 0.0025970914866775274, 0.008323948830366135, 0.034823693335056305, 0.03018759749829769, 0.04806338623166084, 0.035169776529073715, 0.0031858314760029316, -0.029179081320762634, 0.019044887274503708, -0.01945977658033371, 0.011366725899279118, 0.043584633618593216, -0.007283695973455906, -0.039744649082422256, 0.03578947111964226, -0.005401249043643475, -0.012262040749192238, 0.0029793400317430496, 0.08375302702188492, -0.01804385520517826, -0.016210243105888367, 0.03193196654319763, -0.01231159083545208, 0.031181160360574722, 0.04220299422740936, -0.06114768236875534, -0.08555794507265091, -0.038560137152671814, 0.03746061772108078, -0.018895480781793594, -0.009116425178945065, -0.006680512800812721, -0.0453428216278553, 0.0004549618752207607, -0.017072953283786774, 0.05890364572405815, -0.037150535732507706, 0.001351001439616084, 0.013034883886575699, -0.01897902972996235, 0.03324195370078087, -0.012411536648869514, -0.10654746741056442, -0.018212376162409782, -0.02135011926293373, -0.014038226567208767, -0.006539191119372845, 0.020243898034095764, 0.0462898425757885, -0.009685307741165161, 0.036863502115011215, -0.0391366109251976, 0.05646174028515816, -0.03909249231219292, 0.01518971100449562, 0.02772020734846592, 0.017339568585157394, -0.04927289858460426, 0.024756843224167824, 0.06059086322784424, 0.026438891887664795, -0.02994009107351303, 0.09924302995204926, -0.013026452623307705, -0.03742898628115654, 0.057519759982824326, -0.029873639345169067, 0.08316795527935028 ]
156
156
Thresholded Basis Pursuit: An LP Algorithm for Achieving Optimal Support Recovery for Sparse and Approximately Sparse Signals from Noisy Random Measurements
In this paper we present a linear programming solution for sign pattern recovery of a sparse signal from noisy random projections of the signal. We consider two types of noise models, input noise, where noise enters before the random projection; and output noise, where noise enters after the random projection. Sign pattern recovery involves the estimation of sign pattern of a sparse signal. Our idea is to pretend that no noise exists and solve the noiseless $\ell_1$ problem, namely, $\min \|\beta\|_1 ~ s.t. ~ y=G \beta$ and quantizing the resulting solution. We show that the quantized solution perfectly reconstructs the sign pattern of a sufficiently sparse signal. Specifically, we show that the sign pattern of an arbitrary k-sparse, n-dimensional signal $x$ can be recovered with $SNR=\Omega(\log n)$ and measurements scaling as $m= \Omega(k \log{n/k})$ for all sparsity levels $k$ satisfying $0< k \leq \alpha n$, where $\alpha$ is a sufficiently small positive constant. Surprisingly, this bound matches the optimal \emph{Max-Likelihood} performance bounds in terms of $SNR$, required number of measurements, and admissible sparsity level in an order-wise sense. In contrast to our results, previous results based on LASSO and Max-Correlation techniques either assume significantly larger $SNR$, sublinear sparsity levels or restrictive assumptions on signal sets. Our proof technique is based on noisy perturbation of the noiseless $\ell_1$ problem, in that, we estimate the maximum admissible noise level before sign pattern recovery fails.
[ 0.005998962093144655, -0.036091454327106476, -0.01307927817106247, -0.054416872560977936, -0.0577872171998024, -0.0018578560557216406, 0.024592073634266853, -0.02903890050947666, -0.0380571223795414, 0.0675334557890892, 0.041521355509757996, -0.03135305270552635, -0.01922052912414074, 0.09698159247636795, -0.0450933575630188, -0.03940688818693161, -0.007544369902461767, -0.002054486656561494, -0.03130745515227318, -0.087297722697258, -0.008030831813812256, -0.03395168483257294, -0.0003379901172593236, -0.08897092938423157, 0.0007932090666145086, -0.00868635531514883, 0.000012974907804164104, 0.02470177784562111, 0.0021918942220509052, -0.024039961397647858, -0.08056468516588211, 0.01428000908344984, 0.03345293924212456, 0.03218585625290871, -0.003465416142717004, -0.026154745370149612, 0.08000684529542923, 0.06117529049515724, -0.0008034771308302879, -0.034087058156728745, -0.014287885278463364, -0.005578795447945595, 0.04584905877709389, -0.0513039268553257, 0.05280059576034546, 0.00593605637550354, 0.03222858905792236, -0.026774495840072632, -0.03395545855164528, 0.0756053477525711, -0.026309652253985405, 0.028436345979571342, 0.0100569361820817, -0.022813238203525543, 0.0031042336486279964, -0.019732648506760597, -0.046868279576301575, 0.007179637905210257, -0.018611466512084007, 0.011798149906098843, 0.01544368825852871, 0.03913739696145058, -0.0428379625082016, 0.03923657909035683, 0.006628807634115219, -0.02084844931960106, -0.0970282331109047, 0.03286422789096832, -0.07968585938215256, 0.033530618995428085, -0.01308044046163559, -0.091254323720932, 0.01398500893265009, 0.014508573338389397, 0.03948670253157616, 0.022313565015792847, 0.03069443069398403, -0.04460621252655983, -0.04111185669898987, 0.13076001405715942, -0.039054933935403824, 0.026228047907352448, 0.005870135501027107, 0.011244507506489754, -0.07722215354442596, 0.0174460057169199, -0.015199510380625725, 0.0034060394391417503, -0.046154823154211044, -0.04420807957649231, -0.1289493888616562, 0.03469012305140495, -0.05894367769360542, 0.06347281485795975, 0.02138625830411911, 0.04503955319523811, 0.010800061747431755, -0.0004614265344571322, -0.030262770131230354, 0.03860049322247505, -0.014531266875565052, -0.050933439284563065, 0.09542641043663025, 0.07207967340946198, -0.012564902193844318, 0.0826713964343071, -0.031869225203990936, -0.06683710217475891, -0.013291655108332634, -0.01332263182848692, 0.02266620472073555, -0.0042529175989329815, 0.02270965464413166, -0.04399373382329941, -0.02910754829645157, 0.04385482892394066, -0.010879780165851116, 0.0480058379471302, -0.010685818269848824, 0.02028760500252247, 0.08170928806066513, -0.01018532458692789, -0.05495297163724899, -0.06737972795963287, 0.007446051109582186, 0.022660499438643456, 0.008768287487328053, -0.04008716717362404, 0.11264873296022415, -0.026737913489341736, -0.09587351977825165, 0.014319893904030323, -0.07206395268440247, -0.030491571873426437, -0.1306784301996231, 0.0838344469666481, 0.024843432009220123, -0.08842194080352783, -0.05229824408888817, 0.0492720827460289, -0.029759975150227547, -0.05366463214159012, -0.012665845453739166, -0.07889005541801453, 0.06277603656053543, -0.01973903179168701, 0.011084433645009995, 0.01361628994345665, -0.052392635494470596, 0.003415203420445323, 0.032356876879930496, -0.016041887924075127, 0.037611935287714005, 0.08317703753709793, 0.07189718633890152, -0.06511063128709793, -0.00990533921867609, -0.07453129440546036, -0.02879725769162178, 0.06431127339601517, -0.1089726909995079, -0.045984409749507904, 0.04225591942667961, 0.10091383755207062, -0.047770675271749496, -0.059204861521720886, 0.03527459502220154, -0.026725009083747864, -0.04785110056400299, 0.00815903302282095, -0.06363508105278015, 0.05266294628381729, -0.02857265993952751, -0.012944640591740608, 0.018605904653668404, -0.004121383186429739, 0.042210355401039124, 0.016769686713814735, -0.01884465664625168, -0.07579535245895386, 0.03373129665851593, -0.0075591569766402245, -0.01746525801718235, 0.024645833298563957, 0.0286241564899683, 0.0698402151465416, 0.055368199944496155, 0.06508432328701019, 0.044853147119283676, 0.023111434653401375, 0.02113961987197399, 0.04105902090668678, 0.018111703917384148, 0.009544232860207558, -0.00044773166882805526, 0.05389898642897606, -0.016955211758613586, -0.02410958893597126, -0.006980446167290211, 0.04078333452343941, 0.07095544785261154, 0.014137517660856247, -0.0821751058101654, -0.12680259346961975, -0.0890859067440033, 0.011295806616544724, 0.021497244015336037, -0.038747068494558334, -0.007336229085922241, 0.025531727820634842, 0.014096038416028023, 0.033773720264434814, 0.06493153423070908, -0.0574195571243763, -0.00782268587499857, -0.024292031303048134, -0.005057992413640022, 0.004941814579069614, 0.030076852068305016, -0.004434952978044748, -0.0752386674284935, 0.04699016362428665, 0.0059010847471654415, 0.03367609903216362, -0.06315407902002335, -0.016869481652975082, -0.02392354980111122, 0.0010066044051200151, -0.08804293721914291, -0.01323994342237711, -0.02087804302573204, -0.049059171229600906, -0.08872398734092712, 0.008641649968922138, 0.0035693140234798193, 0.057073187083005905, 0.0111002866178751, -0.02372150868177414, 0.02180827409029007, 0.0512889139354229, -0.005684990435838699, 0.04755643382668495, -0.04841836169362068, 0.0004615748766809702, 0.049217015504837036, -0.039620865136384964, 0.065994493663311, 0.0604054220020771, -0.04731408506631851, -0.0007338787545450032, -0.013530947268009186, 0.032361336052417755, 0.00027917991974391043, 0.012300620786845684, 0.04872151091694832, 0.03726737201213837, -0.007036679424345493, -0.02930937148630619, 0.021749019622802734, 0.028329115360975266, 0.000829803931992501, 0.03489593416452408, -0.09848417341709137, 0.004738687537610531, 0.061059292405843735, 0.03731660172343254, -0.009277532808482647, -0.001738598570227623, 0.024992451071739197, 0.033035945147275925, 0.0038603264838457108, -0.04969203844666481, -0.04503859952092171, 0.05270441994071007, -0.08501332998275757, 0.011018842458724976, 0.05739746615290642, 0.035871099680662155, -0.0415419340133667, 0.013776358217000961, -0.05203718692064285, 0.03412897512316704, -0.04452303797006607, -0.05819271504878998, 0.0017485844437032938, 0.018248938024044037, 0.09546336531639099, 0.04088921472430229, -0.06105039641261101, 0.03730021417140961, 0.0005784232052974403, 0.046930745244026184, -0.007327382918447256, 0.015681607648730278, 0.06603830307722092, -0.06054322421550751, 0.02557658962905407, -0.052442505955696106, 0.004510049242526293, -0.00200575590133667, -0.026722274720668793, -0.06694625318050385, 0.015063516795635223, -0.03871433436870575, 0.002014988800510764, 0.020273156464099884, 0.08560410887002945, 0.057853393256664276, -0.05006835609674454, 0.0015824799193069339, 0.06795065104961395, 0.04823233187198639, -0.09691960364580154, -0.08061172068119049, -0.005757434293627739, -0.010410044342279434, -0.006042283959686756, -0.057180725038051605, 0.00925228651612997, -0.004427474923431873, 0.02026194892823696, 0.023899095132946968, -0.009387925267219543, -0.02560930699110031, -0.04798530787229538, -0.033092573285102844, -0.037232328206300735, 0.014383663423359394, -0.039962686598300934, -0.03953661769628525, 0.060358840972185135, 0.021334422752261162, -0.041080668568611145, 0.11828412115573883, -0.019097480922937393, -0.01564909517765045, -0.01818322017788887, -0.0255211740732193, -0.06378597021102905, -0.00027174383285455406, -0.025644326582551003, -0.03427368402481079, -0.04752342775464058, 0.007962750270962715, 0.03418624773621559, 0.019830372184515, 0.05982951074838638, -0.06593992561101913, -0.011984293349087238, 0.035907477140426636, -0.03050539642572403, -0.002267936011776328, 0.011368666775524616, 0.019158119335770607, -0.0014179266290739179, 0.11579245328903198, 0.08691234886646271, 0.04357074573636055, -0.07138973474502563, 0.09143143147230148, -0.01397804543375969, -0.0007300988654606044, -0.01650954969227314, 0.019633984193205833, -0.0125614358112216, 0.08379948139190674, 0.031747967004776, -0.011682664044201374, 0.023611990734934807, 0.04474162310361862, 0.010677660815417767, -0.017368720844388008, 0.049792345613241196, 0.04083799198269844, 0.00805899128317833, -0.04150617867708206, 0.0285447109490633, -0.06603547930717468, 0.024756109341979027, 0.07474985718727112, 0.015308044850826263, 0.02332127094268799, 0.0008360549691133201, 0.08595900237560272, 0.046157356351614, 0.018219511955976486, -0.05120058357715607, 0.00689256377518177, 0.008444283157587051, -0.02573876827955246, -0.005333874840289354, -0.04575682058930397, -0.024760600179433823, 0.05736760050058365, 0.03661495819687843, 0.026395980268716812, -0.019224494695663452, 0.027446802705526352, 0.05962676182389259, 0.003262575715780258, -0.012195057235658169, -0.003347421297803521, 0.03806230425834656, -0.0847071185708046, -0.0555054247379303, 0.0027014659717679024, -0.02705705538392067, -0.010901686735451221, -0.05073945224285126, 0.013059579767286777, 0.04464142024517059, -0.02129421755671501, -0.0850999727845192, 0.027118969708681107, -0.00014529177860822529, 0.0797380581498146, -0.021395243704319, 0.007585754152387381, 0.016557317227125168, -0.008459133096039295, 0.014301248826086521, 0.021037662401795387, -0.008617142215371132, -0.03615498170256615, 0.017840208485722542, -0.0059717982076108456, 0.04696010425686836, 0.07070310413837433, -0.03193254396319389, -0.011518475599586964, -0.0613640733063221, 0.00025253251078538597, -0.030814267694950104, 0.007997963577508926, -0.004702305421233177, -0.03685105964541435, 0.01320585049688816, -0.03772227466106415, -0.058601222932338715, 0.0488751195371151, -0.010073804296553135, -0.04507879167795181, -0.08476956188678741, 0.02570490352809429, 0.029242420569062233, -0.022570529952645302, 0.11112100630998611, 0.011794126592576504, 0.07206706702709198, 0.020034344866871834, -0.006897701416164637, 0.0003887258062604815, -0.01804744452238083, -0.005788829643279314, 0.016605941578745842, 0.08052916824817657, 0.03686516359448433, -0.020989172160625458, 0.08136223256587982, 0.0022449588868767023, -0.030216382816433907, -0.01799178309738636, -0.009644906036555767, -0.025929762050509453, -0.021404478698968887, -0.005417711567133665, 0.003940960858017206, 0.06105554848909378, -0.01603047549724579, -0.008030902594327927, -0.061426542699337006, 0.01867157407104969, -0.05578572675585747, -0.048384200781583786, 0.0448152981698513, -0.023569438606500626, 0.007944178767502308, -0.04951183870434761, -0.007953585125505924, 0.05048011243343353, -0.01650267280638218, 0.023950627073645592, 0.02881796844303608, -0.009696739725768566, 0.03553210571408272, 0.05015759915113449, -0.0450303889811039, -0.006308117415755987, 0.08424912393093109, -0.006537589244544506, 0.0473090298473835, 0.02183549664914608, 0.04572565108537674, 0.07432439923286438, -0.023851659148931503, 0.01566951908171177, 0.01652619242668152, 0.0019364902982488275, 0.01563260331749916, 0.051432251930236816, 0.0070681204088032246, -0.0056691416539251804, -0.018875133246183395, 0.011483825743198395, 0.021071776747703552, 0.08873371034860611, -0.0220893993973732, -0.02667016163468361, -0.08115661889314651, 0.042114514857530594, -0.030610954388976097, 0.02704399824142456 ]
157
157
Bias-Variance Techniques for Monte Carlo Optimization: Cross-validation for the CE Method
In this paper, we examine the CE method in the broad context of Monte Carlo Optimization (MCO) and Parametric Learning (PL), a type of machine learning. A well-known overarching principle used to improve the performance of many PL algorithms is the bias-variance tradeoff. This tradeoff has been used to improve PL algorithms ranging from Monte Carlo estimation of integrals, to linear estimation, to general statistical estimation. Moreover, as described by, MCO is very closely related to PL. Owing to this similarity, the bias-variance tradeoff affects MCO performance, just as it does PL performance. In this article, we exploit the bias-variance tradeoff to enhance the performance of MCO algorithms. We use the technique of cross-validation, a technique based on the bias-variance tradeoff, to significantly improve the performance of the Cross Entropy (CE) method, which is an MCO algorithm. In previous work we have confirmed that other PL techniques improve the perfomance of other MCO algorithms. We conclude that the many techniques pioneered in PL could be investigated as ways to improve MCO algorithms in general, and the CE method in particular.
[ 0.051584016531705856, -0.04160693287849426, 0.011006460525095463, 0.006295771803706884, 0.02796289697289467, -0.06660031527280807, 0.016225624829530716, -0.019689053297042847, -0.055560432374477386, 0.0017437837086617947, 0.019270850345492363, -0.013236092403531075, -0.0058275735937058926, 0.020906053483486176, -0.028941188007593155, 0.03176658973097801, 0.03203221783041954, -0.01063140481710434, 0.04042920842766762, -0.03228351101279259, -0.0465044341981411, 0.035768184810876846, -0.04504908621311188, -0.028575647622346878, 0.009302210994064808, 0.02152492292225361, -0.03364641219377518, -0.012239753268659115, -0.033888693898916245, -0.03562488779425621, -0.04549318924546242, -0.03267422690987587, 0.04807596281170845, -0.026294773444533348, -0.014457721263170242, 0.008657383732497692, 0.058163877576589584, 0.009843748062849045, -0.039748404175043106, -0.027736075222492218, -0.016895003616809845, -0.053169723600149155, 0.02028558775782585, -0.007056696806102991, -0.0041818474419415, -0.0028266538865864277, 0.03726959973573685, 0.04481736943125725, -0.06845373660326004, 0.04149399697780609, -0.07296431809663773, 0.041524700820446014, 0.021289683878421783, -0.043700601905584335, 0.03757766634225845, -0.03867385908961296, 0.03618188202381134, -0.0023869855795055628, -0.009082614444196224, -0.038179196417331696, 0.05166839063167572, 0.0803401917219162, 0.01747758872807026, 0.0016868787351995707, -0.05659753456711769, -0.005749390460550785, -0.08428926020860672, -0.052255209535360336, -0.06009211018681526, -0.021015556529164314, 0.021879402920603752, -0.046722184866666794, 0.01931050606071949, 0.02132185362279415, 0.035319019109010696, -0.04515404626727104, -0.026892192661762238, 0.013434636406600475, 0.00022718032414559275, 0.012216267175972462, 0.007707479875534773, -0.014567636884748936, -0.011589244939386845, 0.07883778214454651, 0.0069764298386871815, -0.01934577152132988, -0.016103360801935196, 0.02305811643600464, -0.034697722643613815, 0.013338332064449787, 0.02706548571586609, 0.028792381286621094, -0.11356572061777115, 0.05537550523877144, 0.020702365785837173, -0.014620090834796429, -0.05905665084719658, -0.047665778547525406, -0.018867723643779755, -0.0035063999239355326, -0.01457966212183237, -0.027849160134792328, 0.06020936742424965, 0.05719802528619766, 0.037010014057159424, 0.03818003088235855, -0.023986952379345894, 0.10873699188232422, 0.02309570275247097, 0.012991092167794704, 0.025068460032343864, -0.05260258913040161, 0.07799752801656723, -0.002357805846258998, -0.08384720981121063, 0.06702274084091187, -0.04558670148253441, 0.027560699731111526, 0.019030693918466568, 0.021371278911828995, 0.03605378791689873, 0.0051933759823441505, -0.04386959969997406, -0.060662511736154556, 0.0330432690680027, 0.04387051984667778, 0.04568484053015709, -0.11077942699193954, 0.08530930429697037, -0.05802129581570625, -0.01680668629705906, 0.1516297161579132, 0.02978801727294922, -0.0028212538454681635, -0.040284641087055206, -0.0017568307230249047, 0.004782628268003464, -0.02604866214096546, -0.06445653736591339, 0.023610195145010948, -0.07452130317687988, -0.018337901681661606, -0.022037291899323463, 0.04798136278986931, 0.010595015250146389, 0.0213072057813406, 0.05901333689689636, 0.04340723529458046, -0.0461762435734272, 0.01974339410662651, -0.06383500248193741, -0.02875608578324318, 0.01497363019734621, 0.065541572868824, -0.000266284157987684, -0.057873908430337906, -0.04373693838715553, -0.0004922542138956487, -0.010501662269234657, 0.10365264117717743, -0.0393945537507534, 0.008136417716741562, -0.00716966250911355, 0.02557368203997612, -0.020037025213241577, 0.012257272377610207, -0.04900044575333595, 0.006857133936136961, 0.023635005578398705, -0.09077013283967972, -0.0836346298456192, 0.025320857763290405, -0.008838629350066185, -0.0417574979364872, 0.0010726151522248983, 0.04772865027189255, 0.037309713661670685, -0.025344781577587128, 0.0015143259661272168, 0.021476993337273598, 0.012479000724852085, -0.05443340912461281, -0.009741213172674179, 0.0328667014837265, 0.0026478865183889866, 0.04762052744626999, 0.005018841940909624, -0.0059176115319132805, 0.016114478930830956, 0.028589200228452682, 0.053059615194797516, -0.019340788945555687, 0.0029810937121510506, -0.015210289508104324, 0.05099428817629814, 0.007265410851687193, 0.05522378906607628, -0.04345618188381195, -0.030035480856895447, 0.02915678732097149, 0.03577810153365135, -0.0723673477768898, -0.05585771054029465, 0.022927390411496162, -0.03050754964351654, 0.045588910579681396, 0.034062113612890244, -0.03462700545787811, 0.017153002321720123, 0.0011987983016297221, -0.029070155695080757, 0.017841078341007233, -0.0027149063535034657, -0.08409790694713593, -0.0010911402059718966, -0.027368659153580666, -0.027169236913323402, -0.03397384285926819, -0.006408386398106813, 0.014815546572208405, -0.030750731006264687, -0.02205587364733219, -0.032181672751903534, 0.06438902765512466, -0.029686572030186653, 0.0057188100181519985, -0.012075195088982582, 0.04452100023627281, -0.07431480288505554, -0.0062340423464775085, -0.038298316299915314, -0.061208199709653854, -0.008882072754204273, -0.02791905589401722, -0.0772676020860672, 0.025404201820492744, -0.10340346395969391, -0.07073099911212921, -0.0012999605387449265, 0.012845778837800026, -0.02257450297474861, 0.033394455909729004, 0.038701385259628296, 0.03776697814464569, 0.030824681743979454, -0.03949279710650444, 0.0322035513818264, 0.044725339859724045, -0.06913898140192032, -0.038055334240198135, -0.05997772142291069, -0.001884732861071825, -0.003677569329738617, -0.05392356961965561, -0.02556498721241951, -0.03989490494132042, -0.006375218275934458, 0.037190161645412445, 0.033931612968444824, 0.0513039231300354, -0.0162819754332304, 0.05041913315653801, -0.038568634539842606, -0.05447489395737648, 0.11703479290008545, -0.009434514679014683, -0.038170985877513885, 0.04732181504368782, 0.040669556707143784, 0.019073188304901123, -0.0647222176194191, 0.0028355803806334734, -0.013265399262309074, 0.05552533641457558, -0.016701940447092056, 0.0018585184589028358, 0.06594721227884293, 0.018174616619944572, 0.0769478902220726, -0.053433604538440704, -0.07021503895521164, 0.08378340303897858, -0.03846541792154312, 0.005779861006885767, 0.03363405913114548, -0.015161723829805851, -0.03776704519987106, -0.007801251020282507, 0.033323440700769424, 0.03350582346320152, -0.03838539123535156, 0.08733713626861572, -0.07621210813522339, -0.025362586602568626, 0.046572018414735794, -0.03045942820608616, 0.06257770955562592, 0.02270561456680298, 0.018974684178829193, -0.030303718522191048, 0.04497779905796051, 0.015326601453125477, 0.07343611121177673, -0.010067721828818321, -0.02159854769706726, 0.10175502300262451, 0.04360831901431084, 0.030764196068048477, -0.03303700312972069, -0.07500099390745163, 0.1068352609872818, -0.048918284475803375, -0.0267489030957222, -0.008455966599285603, -0.03654034808278084, -0.007405202370136976, -0.09490817040205002, 0.03963419049978256, 0.027654798701405525, -0.02382860891520977, 0.04569472745060921, 0.03888548165559769, 0.04725603014230728, -0.10901516675949097, -0.009182457812130451, 0.007737031672149897, -0.019303491339087486, 0.0064690569415688515, -0.09691530466079712, 0.0228787399828434, -0.09752415865659714, -0.01826990209519863, 0.005322345998138189, 0.10309379547834396, -0.024085965007543564, 0.019886692985892296, -0.0295085608959198, 0.02084125578403473, 0.03316035866737366, -0.05499923229217529, -0.05274375528097153, -0.0734693706035614, -0.03248272463679314, -0.008329317905008793, 0.013985362835228443, 0.05028053745627403, 0.09863102436065674, 0.02837860770523548, -0.041888248175382614, -0.00811223965138197, 0.012245799414813519, -0.023254144936800003, -0.01199596282094717, -0.0006292163161560893, -0.0290848258882761, 0.06619560718536377, -0.020010678097605705, -0.007220850326120853, 0.07919426262378693, 0.01580900326371193, -0.04284486919641495, 0.004220413509756327, -0.05945756286382675, -0.009969638660550117, 0.03544434905052185, 0.020352907478809357, 0.014981434680521488, 0.00033198032178916037, 0.04317290335893631, -0.011176032945513725, -0.12161560356616974, 0.028666984289884567, -0.004843840375542641, 0.09599736332893372, 0.0005518572288565338, -0.0056982263922691345, 0.10008100420236588, 0.005506483372300863, -0.05250753089785576, 0.06574718654155731, 0.002772498643025756, -0.0750465840101242, -0.04002179205417633, -0.06533137708902359, 0.0027972811367362738, -0.0401565358042717, -0.03246775269508362, -0.023157982155680656, 0.061317671090364456, 0.027789905667304993, -0.09092874079942703, 0.0012994115240871906, -0.047783780843019485, -0.013157918117940426, 0.06356222927570343, 0.04390557482838631, 0.03864697739481926, 0.006315724924206734, 0.001231594244018197, -0.0011417213827371597, -0.05443108454346657, -0.020840607583522797, -0.006129932589828968, -0.024142196401953697, -0.05549619346857071, -0.024142146110534668, -0.027172008529305458, 0.032970305532217026, -0.04563818499445915, 0.01955767534673214, -0.04478858783841133, -0.01384709868580103, 0.009427618235349655, -0.012349849566817284, 0.051456518471241, 0.031624581664800644, 0.029704274609684944, -0.05214926600456238, -0.022697491571307182, -0.10509765893220901, -0.028249170631170273, -0.009437757544219494, -0.0009101454052142799, -0.00577733526006341, 0.025285908952355385, 0.0808161273598671, 0.0701526626944542, 0.04966733604669571, 0.019090762361884117, 0.08112814277410507, -0.08337423950433731, -0.03514348343014717, -0.047793198376894, -0.041366104036569595, -0.03145518898963928, -0.02746277116239071, 0.08043777942657471, 0.010397967882454395, -0.012825937941670418, -0.07786224037408829, -0.06349451094865799, 0.05903417989611626, 0.04830547049641609, 0.015412095002830029, -0.03447438031435013, 0.07087443768978119, -0.005246216431260109, 0.0474855937063694, 0.04167235270142555, 0.05885260924696922, -0.0018689008429646492, 0.01701471395790577, 0.03463941439986229, -0.04092889651656151, -0.01008580345660448, -0.017144108191132545, -0.05022620037198067, -0.013378170318901539, 0.04725167155265808, -0.004339701030403376, -0.02033602073788643, -0.026879839599132538, -0.06270668655633926, 0.013928808271884918, -0.07800204306840897, -0.017438840121030807, -0.01446691993623972, -0.0005830499576404691, 0.047540999948978424, 0.026037441566586494, 0.0024149285163730383, -0.017513202503323555, -0.01194333378225565, -0.061787400394678116, -0.027731191366910934, 0.021528813987970352, -0.03706536814570427, -0.08830191195011139, 0.019973663613200188, 0.00125968421343714, 0.0604979582130909, -0.017815569415688515, 0.030969275161623955, 0.1006782054901123, 0.05469197407364845, 0.05107644572854042, -0.08527801185846329, 0.03598412498831749, -0.02934695966541767, 0.010146776214241982, 0.053894512355327606, 0.04187943413853645, -0.02019430883228779, -0.03832658380270004, 0.0012959189480170608, 0.09811954945325851, -0.013414437882602215, 0.011323320679366589, 0.06986651569604874, 0.02032340317964554, -0.022020427510142326, -0.004055739846080542, 0.13496196269989014, 0.011420232243835926, 0.025558561086654663, 0.012155107222497463, 0.04171490669250488, 0.03467627614736557, 0.00694070803001523, 0.02319788932800293, -0.06484189629554749, -0.034374915063381195 ]
158
158
Blind Cognitive MAC Protocols
We consider the design of cognitive Medium Access Control (MAC) protocols enabling an unlicensed (secondary) transmitter-receiver pair to communicate over the idle periods of a set of licensed channels, i.e., the primary network. The objective is to maximize data throughput while maintaining the synchronization between secondary users and avoiding interference with licensed (primary) users. No statistical information about the primary traffic is assumed to be available a-priori to the secondary user. We investigate two distinct sensing scenarios. In the first, the secondary transmitter is capable of sensing all the primary channels, whereas it senses one channel only in the second scenario. In both cases, we propose MAC protocols that efficiently learn the statistics of the primary traffic online. Our simulation results demonstrate that the proposed blind protocols asymptotically achieve the throughput obtained when prior knowledge of primary traffic statistics is available.
[ 0.005456584505736828, -0.006783141288906336, -0.009641489014029503, -0.00990188680589199, -0.053020548075437546, 0.03621241822838783, -0.043824128806591034, -0.05863787606358528, 0.024461915716528893, 0.03396378457546234, 0.04898655787110329, -0.08276938647031784, 0.000825066992547363, -0.02167881652712822, -0.018018679693341255, -0.05899547040462494, 0.028676284477114677, 0.06187693402171135, 0.0008126745233312249, -0.028114883229136467, -0.03888985142111778, -0.03123033232986927, -0.02400839701294899, 0.009306538850069046, 0.03547197952866554, 0.021208003163337708, -0.019430063664913177, -0.023206401616334915, -0.021179964765906334, -0.024739060550928116, -0.10623735189437866, -0.02853335067629814, -0.03733082860708237, 0.012961686588823795, 0.0478968508541584, -0.0010572313331067562, 0.06138189882040024, -0.028083832934498787, -0.040121905505657196, 0.004219000693410635, -0.009892918169498444, -0.06637845933437347, -0.026478344574570656, 0.040310509502887726, 0.01791355200111866, -0.018043430522084236, -0.07148933410644531, 0.033353470265865326, 0.08235813677310944, -0.04514968395233154, -0.11098174750804901, -0.009292777627706528, 0.006453958805650473, 0.034772418439388275, -0.05972857028245926, 0.020099911838769913, -0.07163942605257034, -0.0404394157230854, 0.046189043670892715, -0.05178398638963699, -0.01782527007162571, 0.11201948672533035, -0.05341701954603195, 0.056062452495098114, -0.00206551281735301, 0.03586338832974434, -0.09791376441717148, -0.007801706437021494, -0.057115305215120316, -0.07974943518638611, -0.04527047649025917, -0.06636423617601395, 0.019103625789284706, -0.08492403477430344, 0.03617123141884804, -0.0029100882820785046, -0.015729721635580063, 0.008588789030909538, -0.0363321378827095, 0.05563778430223465, -0.0749078243970871, 0.04586188495159149, -0.0676795169711113, -0.03357068821787834, -0.01734478399157524, -0.02310476265847683, 0.0057524424046278, 0.0510084331035614, 0.040564343333244324, 0.006585258059203625, -0.022655941545963287, -0.04670920968055725, -0.035782888531684875, -0.00003718967491295189, 0.021877843886613846, -0.05372396484017372, 0.02318035252392292, -0.008018579334020615, -0.015206461772322655, 0.06493029743432999, 0.029316416010260582, 0.025952959433197975, 0.010806143283843994, 0.013844951055943966, -0.061258841305971146, -0.04905816540122032, 0.06210273504257202, 0.09444315731525421, -0.028189154341816902, -0.005140501074492931, 0.03222161903977394, -0.027417343109846115, 0.029725832864642143, -0.01854490488767624, -0.05168619751930237, 0.05215203016996384, -0.025237616151571274, -0.022463425993919373, -0.04879533499479294, 0.03313584625720978, -0.04847398027777672, -0.00836317427456379, -0.045731574296951294, -0.017360307276248932, -0.04365680739283562, 0.001914864988066256, -0.01084926724433899, -0.04636716470122337, 0.06319551169872284, -0.01977650634944439, -0.08756722509860992, 0.027922116219997406, -0.0049990215338766575, 0.012952200137078762, -0.007429658435285091, 0.06329979747533798, 0.014062291011214256, 0.02665361948311329, -0.09752195328474045, 0.03322054445743561, -0.0012185652740299702, -0.044320642948150635, -0.03537291660904884, 0.00109212810639292, 0.05067412927746773, 0.012775530107319355, 0.06284327059984207, -0.018726680427789688, -0.007236149627715349, -0.03746148198843002, 0.022354090586304665, -0.035908278077840805, 0.0059067788533866405, 0.024818934500217438, -0.01978636160492897, -0.007244058419018984, -0.041697729378938675, -0.04603499174118042, -0.03927449509501457, 0.08417145162820816, -0.007029906380921602, 0.09545638412237167, 0.0770701915025711, 0.11804435402154922, 0.011487036012113094, 0.07018230855464935, -0.05486056208610535, -0.003810121910646558, -0.0687108114361763, -0.006427844054996967, 0.014831488020718098, -0.02582784742116928, -0.025544224306941032, 0.044674694538116455, 0.016252776607871056, 0.013518668711185455, 0.017174603417515755, -0.06754881143569946, -0.006107857916504145, 0.050828393548727036, 0.012128100730478764, -0.07499432563781738, -0.005862468853592873, -0.04333239793777466, 0.046761393547058105, 0.08851419389247894, 0.02472272887825966, 0.10097548365592957, 0.10044096410274506, 0.04071115702390671, -0.05742848291993141, 0.020013216882944107, 0.04683278873562813, -0.010551217012107372, -0.08858823031187057, 0.037003543227910995, -0.026590047404170036, 0.0020066597498953342, 0.02755911834537983, -0.00726565346121788, 0.03603920340538025, -0.0967429131269455, -0.05548298731446266, -0.017504841089248657, 0.0076659442856907845, -0.013265907764434814, -0.039689499884843826, -0.03443026542663574, 0.1076836884021759, -0.05115123838186264, -0.06429356336593628, 0.02659057453274727, -0.007338938303291798, 0.07348988205194473, -0.019698848947882652, -0.02920299954712391, -0.008234699256718159, -0.009217719547450542, -0.001954092178493738, 0.0033280423376709223, -0.06524094939231873, 0.036409892141819, 0.016421213746070862, 0.0280372966080904, -0.08708823472261429, 0.053946636617183685, 0.035065338015556335, 0.018339399248361588, -0.07083949446678162, 0.0019341708393767476, -0.027866430580615997, -0.07215438038110733, -0.058855652809143066, -0.012821653857827187, -0.00853797234594822, 0.09712927043437958, -0.06211484596133232, -0.033218082040548325, 0.01586042158305645, -0.01014885026961565, 0.034064363688230515, 0.030658239498734474, -0.014976294711232185, 0.020121492445468903, 0.10423025488853455, 0.07287601381540298, 0.023502875119447708, 0.033034421503543854, 0.010102247819304466, -0.011050088331103325, 0.02261127531528473, 0.011582724750041962, -0.0050269244238734245, 0.02698413096368313, 0.012150605209171772, -0.05310219153761864, 0.010331593453884125, 0.05297977849841118, 0.03690437972545624, 0.07172757387161255, 0.011180110275745392, -0.029785240069031715, -0.014196246862411499, 0.04086459428071976, 0.032981567084789276, 0.024002835154533386, -0.007934014312922955, 0.04316449910402298, -0.06995141506195068, 0.0017418310744687915, -0.018377207219600677, -0.05471106246113777, -0.021154038608074188, 0.05626086890697479, -0.013680239208042622, -0.060414522886276245, 0.040309369564056396, 0.004153230227530003, -0.025011058896780014, -0.003994079306721687, 0.0013962016673758626, -0.012692678719758987, 0.002342137275263667, -0.05301942676305771, -0.004213337320834398, -0.04035746678709984, -0.012370113283395767, 0.024021944031119347, -0.016936838626861572, 0.011092939414083958, -0.017548618838191032, 0.010798863135278225, -0.010556487366557121, 0.026303909718990326, -0.0022131185978651047, -0.04993702098727226, -0.07090846449136734, 0.02921326458454132, 0.026156669482588768, -0.11737939715385437, -0.016497844830155373, -0.011099863797426224, 0.025224141776561737, 0.10189921408891678, -0.013236990198493004, 0.08251489698886871, 0.07089636474847794, -0.03788084536790848, 0.016293322667479515, -0.006260361988097429, 0.020194198936223984, 0.055052004754543304, -0.06587398797273636, 0.06858789920806885, 0.0838664248585701, -0.010419761762022972, 0.016199326142668724, -0.01979212276637554, -0.026505282148718834, -0.004629968199878931, 0.06736257672309875, 0.037289898842573166, -0.04261641949415207, -0.019750872626900673, -0.016909420490264893, -0.021677419543266296, -0.06580070406198502, 0.010713323950767517, -0.0027150094974786043, 0.03920849785208702, -0.05032973363995552, 0.01029281411319971, -0.04327959567308426, 0.03404335677623749, -0.049468208104372025, 0.03962310776114464, 0.008507173508405685, 0.008226956240832806, -0.007971865125000477, 0.044016845524311066, -0.02827484719455242, -0.05580049008131027, -0.018860815092921257, -0.02702254429459572, -0.04963686689734459, 0.001746954396367073, 0.08437469601631165, 0.011911379173398018, -0.007859948091208935, -0.024973077699542046, -0.041832730174064636, 0.052529510110616684, -0.026000265032052994, -0.08808501809835434, -0.06022150442004204, -0.03567599505186081, 0.018245447427034378, 0.00451153889298439, 0.008233628235757351, 0.05333678051829338, -0.00743604451417923, 0.04572547599673271, -0.07327265292406082, -0.02013959363102913, 0.04536963999271393, 0.09552638232707977, -0.008366652764379978, -0.047326114028692245, -0.08943480998277664, -0.054611194878816605, -0.039400264620780945, -0.07623746991157532, -0.011272693052887917, -0.02280081994831562, 0.04443150758743286, 0.021968146786093712, -0.022454677149653435, -0.08804501593112946, 0.0015038716373965144, -0.03988650068640709, -0.02618885040283203, 0.017262404784560204, 0.01507850643247366, 0.013727005571126938, -0.009478922002017498, -0.02379024587571621, 0.013715216889977455, -0.03679569065570831, 0.10267956554889679, -0.040084801614284515, -0.0761289894580841, 0.01468644943088293, -0.024203764274716377, 0.07709965854883194, 0.026427948847413063, -0.05871296674013138, -0.04712141677737236, 0.018385428935289383, -0.026104021817445755, 0.02986316755414009, 0.03766424581408501, -0.05630916357040405, -0.09562093764543533, 0.00695441709831357, -0.07149693369865417, -0.0597507543861866, -0.016842547804117203, 0.059431686997413635, -0.029524553567171097, -0.010739851742982864, 0.01909690350294113, -0.003165292087942362, -0.032359909266233444, 0.03578929230570793, -0.0037030111998319626, 0.04537593573331833, -0.0047407085075974464, -0.08099520206451416, 0.022836748510599136, -0.12528778612613678, -0.030815212056040764, 0.037890102714300156, 0.01507989689707756, -0.07845045626163483, -0.024735476821660995, -0.03990454599261284, 0.10684265196323395, 0.0077794380486011505, -0.060592010617256165, -0.01861158199608326, -0.03884214907884598, -0.016174092888832092, -0.05785411223769188, -0.023998329415917397, 0.019066529348492622, 0.0037499016616493464, -0.02681838907301426, 0.019726824015378952, -0.020418157801032066, 0.019398095086216927, 0.010345743969082832, 0.008382639847695827, 0.04776747152209282, 0.005716708023101091, 0.06091810390353203, 0.011263862252235413, -0.005148035008460283, 0.020792562514543533, 0.033174291253089905, -0.01991221122443676, 0.028503285720944405, -0.007558347657322884, 0.08873437345027924, -0.0728134885430336, -0.03276192024350166, -0.04300394281744957, -0.002153173554688692, -0.03295581415295601, 0.060609664767980576, -0.026374127715826035, 0.02368158847093582, 0.0497400276362896, -0.03087574988603592, -0.02319459617137909, -0.039006397128105164, 0.04820239171385765, -0.039426323026418686, -0.06715594977140427, 0.044948093593120575, -0.003411893267184496, -0.07672706246376038, 0.00249766674824059, -0.0023962189443409443, -0.07858617603778839, 0.052592113614082336, 0.04058888927102089, 0.036467548459768295, 0.08030929416418076, -0.00858941487967968, -0.0031850594095885754, 0.06169373542070389, 0.010192705318331718, 0.029303638264536858, 0.0056566414423286915, 0.07027020305395126, 0.02250775136053562, -0.013378666713833809, 0.00008595020335633308, -0.04472319781780243, 0.056030429899692535, -0.021625934168696404, -0.05710654333233833, 0.024975435808300972, -0.025299953296780586, 0.008072097785770893, 0.03545044735074043, 0.035704903304576874, -0.018694652244448662, -0.014669357798993587, -0.020438430830836296, 0.05957121402025223, -0.00679387990385294, 0.056691963225603104, 0.017855610698461533, 0.05382722243666649, 0.022761065512895584, 0.10223238170146942, 0.021118314936757088, -0.04521748796105385, 0.011991393752396107, -0.005041520576924086, 0.038572780787944794 ]
159
159
A Gaussian Belief Propagation Solver for Large Scale Support Vector Machines
Support vector machines (SVMs) are an extremely successful type of classification and regression algorithms. Building an SVM entails solving a constrained convex quadratic programming problem, which is quadratic in the number of training samples. We introduce an efficient parallel implementation of an support vector regression solver, based on the Gaussian Belief Propagation algorithm (GaBP). In this paper, we demonstrate that methods from the complex system domain could be utilized for performing efficient distributed computation. We compare the proposed algorithm to previously proposed distributed and single-node SVM solvers. Our comparison shows that the proposed algorithm is just as accurate as these solvers, while being significantly faster, especially for large datasets. We demonstrate scalability of the proposed algorithm to up to 1,024 computing nodes and hundreds of thousands of data points using an IBM Blue Gene supercomputer. As far as we know, our work is the largest parallel implementation of belief propagation ever done, demonstrating the applicability of this algorithm for large scale distributed computing systems.
[ -0.04122307151556015, -0.055845070630311966, 0.028667423874139786, -0.029892662540078163, 0.06949397176504135, -0.034684374928474426, 0.010292970575392246, -0.025095675140619278, -0.049233853816986084, -0.0015643659280613065, 0.05632806569337845, 0.006295990664511919, -0.003869289066642523, 0.03761857748031616, 0.024165812879800797, -0.03290122002363205, 0.035483770072460175, 0.1268458217382431, 0.08561630547046661, -0.044564250856637955, 0.10298372805118561, 0.00009086147474590689, 0.021757544949650764, -0.03369109705090523, -0.005588519386947155, 0.062336478382349014, -0.0979556068778038, 0.00357798277400434, 0.06909462064504623, 0.019817255437374115, -0.07042626291513443, 0.026478450745344162, -0.007850228808820248, 0.019491635262966156, 0.019311191514134407, -0.02915041521191597, -0.04368080943822861, -0.021156182512640953, -0.04014917463064194, -0.03607887774705887, -0.05348113179206848, -0.03902595490217209, 0.00807857420295477, 0.02214837074279785, 0.06648506969213486, 0.03583422675728798, 0.08793067187070847, 0.06165095791220665, -0.0407986119389534, 0.058854345232248306, -0.03536459431052208, -0.011256799101829529, -0.07919920980930328, 0.04504961147904396, -0.010655904188752174, -0.008361410349607468, 0.005110111087560654, -0.0018833538051694632, 0.004239419940859079, 0.01176829170435667, 0.04734586179256439, 0.08156247437000275, 0.04731723666191101, 0.02852252870798111, -0.028521213680505753, -0.023429658263921738, -0.0008717713644728065, -0.09073854237794876, -0.01476381253451109, -0.029613517224788666, 0.07686512172222137, -0.04607319459319115, 0.058613065630197525, 0.05923408642411232, 0.0896051675081253, 0.009870616719126701, 0.026061659678816795, 0.00802362710237503, 0.025625167414546013, 0.042683739215135574, 0.03774099051952362, 0.012581815011799335, 0.06425195187330246, 0.07702024281024933, -0.02628302574157715, -0.0075010922737419605, -0.04712183028459549, -0.029859397560358047, 0.038673579692840576, 0.0107367979362607, 0.017201406881213188, 0.05427103489637375, -0.020667968317866325, 0.04408526420593262, 0.0010921686189249158, -0.03700469434261322, -0.033697281032800674, -0.08515443652868271, -0.002434368245303631, 0.03466105833649635, -0.03776030242443085, 0.04791847988963127, 0.002093304181471467, 0.047953106462955475, -0.05419645458459854, 0.04846997931599617, -0.05028291791677475, 0.034832846373319626, -0.016844509169459343, 0.010720030404627323, 0.0495590940117836, -0.008718172088265419, 0.008191374130547047, -0.0001399356551701203, -0.0654011070728302, 0.0476175919175148, -0.038924455642700195, 0.034669145941734314, 0.031145773828029633, 0.006809539627283812, -0.010242714546620846, -0.006665156222879887, -0.07920222729444504, 0.09053951501846313, 0.05251727253198624, -0.12891018390655518, 0.040166497230529785, -0.0025476303417235613, 0.1049668937921524, 0.10275772213935852, -0.007712721824645996, -0.05245917662978172, -0.003766116453334689, 0.0011160947615280747, -0.055705003440380096, -0.027095818892121315, 0.026424571871757507, -0.05238780751824379, -0.068904347717762, 0.0662846714258194, 0.0005063657881692052, -0.032357487827539444, 0.013794961385428905, 0.033594582229852676, 0.06387592852115631, 0.017778752371668816, -0.027935095131397247, 0.04273821786046028, 0.023186691105365753, 0.07269087433815002, -0.04805856570601463, -0.022692624479532242, -0.0068920450285077095, 0.04490046203136444, 0.056362975388765335, -0.023231234401464462, -0.03439592942595482, -0.059987809509038925, 0.025792280212044716, 0.0695938915014267, -0.006675886455923319, 0.053237609565258026, 0.024828704074025154, 0.016270961612462997, 0.029896268621087074, 0.0015617839526385069, -0.009567160159349442, -0.06669685989618301, -0.02713656798005104, -0.06988780200481415, 0.04614366590976715, -0.02353949099779129, 0.05151218920946121, 0.04534854367375374, -0.018613003194332123, 0.0016139926156029105, 0.004964581225067377, -0.008268755860626698, 0.0001856983726611361, -0.009172937832772732, 0.040627580136060715, -0.059288714081048965, -0.012765959836542606, -0.03697853535413742, 0.06950891017913818, 0.040161799639463425, 0.014275302179157734, 0.019520943984389305, -0.00524904252961278, 0.029297159984707832, 0.04966922104358673, 0.01058655884116888, 0.1000106930732727, -0.11346136778593063, -0.05335945263504982, -0.01030982006341219, -0.01338243205100298, -0.09286516159772873, 0.03814024478197098, 0.05137144401669502, -0.017303382977843285, 0.008193038403987885, -0.008023951202630997, -0.0012843337608501315, 0.02786925621330738, 0.009113587439060211, 0.0273913387209177, -0.0099534522742033, 0.008814621716737747, -0.017281116917729378, -0.001724890898913145, 0.031650375574827194, 0.02647089771926403, -0.040032148361206055, -0.03083961270749569, -0.03843245655298233, 0.011384605430066586, -0.11345641314983368, 0.012997806072235107, 0.04096256569027901, -0.006297166924923658, 0.04960750415921211, -0.09027931094169617, 0.038797952234745026, -0.02827480435371399, 0.043652795255184174, -0.02727566845715046, -0.016150424256920815, -0.03967176377773285, 0.06429446488618851, 0.012244603596627712, -0.019827578216791153, -0.03151246905326843, 0.044495876878499985, 0.01610054261982441, 0.09541469067335129, -0.04932345449924469, -0.07732299715280533, 0.044833291321992874, 0.018325675278902054, -0.0184615571051836, -0.044815532863140106, -0.07393199950456619, -0.011239024810492992, 0.1259215623140335, -0.02391611598432064, -0.03791152685880661, 0.05428814888000488, -0.014818009920418262, 0.04448269307613373, 0.054755523800849915, 0.057770710438489914, -0.05563083291053772, -0.02973119355738163, 0.0559445358812809, -0.0068432241678237915, -0.004736697766929865, 0.05277922376990318, 0.06384921073913574, 0.06849932670593262, 0.007928045466542244, 0.039412450045347214, -0.011518350802361965, -0.004864645656198263, 0.1071038544178009, 0.019436363130807877, -0.05634700879454613, -0.02414010278880596, -0.03563385084271431, 0.056077152490615845, -0.041040048003196716, -0.06297894567251205, 0.004046563524752855, 0.05846809595823288, -0.028556721284985542, 0.0034316368401050568, 0.04769952595233917, 0.08883637934923172, -0.06559900939464569, -0.03374345973134041, -0.06432454288005829, 0.010390812531113625, 0.023356419056653976, -0.022772308439016342, 0.02008664980530739, -0.012174087576568127, -0.093866728246212, -0.024886593222618103, -0.0035199332050979137, 0.009660549461841583, -0.023137012496590614, 0.06875163316726685, -0.06129012629389763, -0.017469605430960655, 0.024500040337443352, -0.05393322557210922, 0.00607725465670228, 0.002821130445227027, 0.052159521728754044, -0.0031592957675457, 0.05911005288362503, 0.04586407169699669, 0.06620705872774124, -0.013001429848372936, 0.0009800054831430316, 0.055424295365810394, 0.04153488948941231, 0.007713183294981718, -0.08940631151199341, -0.015113254077732563, 0.06858308613300323, 0.002113680588081479, -0.006521656643599272, -0.02694622427225113, 0.032604821026325226, 0.02378200925886631, -0.004172971472144127, 0.058253075927495956, -0.06880149245262146, 0.011983109638094902, 0.03352520987391472, -0.0128224678337574, 0.000520659436006099, -0.047374892979860306, -0.051541026681661606, -0.0009479041327722371, 0.02677074633538723, 0.11020596325397491, -0.01767544448375702, 0.007763582747429609, -0.06553852558135986, 0.03453870117664337, -0.04251222312450409, 0.12355367839336395, -0.009458376094698906, -0.04104301705956459, -0.05318162217736244, 0.03572581708431244, 0.03465797007083893, -0.01754399947822094, -0.003153950674459338, 0.006286182440817356, 0.03706550970673561, 0.03944907337427139, 0.007537039462476969, 0.08399353176355362, 0.07127846032381058, -0.027761880308389664, -0.04741046205163002, -0.006007346790283918, -0.03952550143003464, 0.04635224491357803, -0.04017346724867821, 0.08549948036670685, -0.03158608078956604, 0.0034975658636540174, 0.028556382283568382, -0.08850208669900894, -0.0240107923746109, 0.028085922822356224, -0.023306692019104958, -0.021642429754137993, -0.009486058726906776, 0.028148556128144264, -0.009624039754271507, 0.015611773356795311, -0.03856760635972023, 0.005047417711466551, -0.017094841226935387, 0.012375565245747566, 0.010396716184914112, 0.012907224707305431, 0.010446970351040363, -0.00955500639975071, 0.011391349136829376, -0.02991841919720173, 0.007520426996052265, 0.07437310367822647, -0.01472989097237587, 0.06383016705513, -0.07306565344333649, 0.04977448284626007, -0.08672716468572617, 0.0005551818758249283, 0.023827752098441124, -0.017670735716819763, -0.04529564455151558, -0.021511873230338097, -0.008944781497120857, -0.025559911504387856, -0.027471249923110008, -0.04432453215122223, -0.004227936267852783, 0.018497256562113762, -0.01514031644910574, 0.037088800221681595, 0.03280814364552498, -0.02594468742609024, -0.009360610507428646, 0.0033680922351777554, -0.0031561057548969984, -0.02556006610393524, 0.008948729373514652, -0.013303774408996105, -0.00987142976373434, 0.001738977269269526, -0.03759739175438881, 0.11964252591133118, 0.0025826452765613794, 0.0931217148900032, 0.013865109533071518, 0.046466726809740067, -0.07130870968103409, 0.04453570023179054, 0.0007656280067749321, -0.018810588866472244, -0.055621810257434845, 0.015154508873820305, -0.0007141751702874899, -0.03118138201534748, -0.053223155438899994, 0.05157703161239624, 0.043035075068473816, -0.018484776839613914, 0.014078513719141483, 0.05723482742905617, 0.12261095643043518, 0.06104487180709839, 0.03389823064208031, -0.02402683161199093, -0.07947157323360443, -0.01579246297478676, -0.04968556761741638, -0.02440902218222618, 0.05723532661795616, 0.07540464401245117, 0.036774542182683945, -0.035347212105989456, 0.022612586617469788, 0.025600604712963104, -0.002140170196071267, 0.023916268721222878, 0.004131450317800045, -0.03609014302492142, 0.017259962856769562, 0.0008196700364351273, 0.032649412751197815, 0.003442417597398162, 0.049607064574956894, 0.07864312082529068, -0.018076501786708832, 0.07216332852840424, -0.026214029639959335, 0.004996608477085829, -0.017427988350391388, -0.047788411378860474, -0.05265555530786514, 0.006188156548887491, 0.020831022411584854, 0.002352067967876792, 0.07292640209197998, -0.004092540126293898, -0.06486879289150238, 0.03552566096186638, -0.010831983759999275, 0.04070933535695076, -0.030611369758844376, -0.0382109172642231, 0.03832574561238289, 0.014190996997058392, -0.052431873977184296, 0.01404563058167696, -0.02704503946006298, -0.03472631424665451, 0.027849478647112846, 0.015107478946447372, 0.00843757577240467, -0.05696447566151619, 0.04094349592924118, -0.05217578634619713, -0.03261116147041321, -0.025701483711600304, -0.054752983152866364, 0.02813832275569439, 0.025170497596263885, 0.04273141920566559, -0.04473496973514557, 0.03417705371975899, 0.009380846284329891, -0.014718747697770596, 0.0005594839458353817, -0.003104171250015497, -0.02449267916381359, -0.008254620246589184, -0.03245168924331665, -0.01332815084606409, 0.01407949160784483, 0.015620329417288303, 0.023519795387983322, 0.0000934434137889184, -0.015377379022538662, -0.014680212363600731, 0.04248395189642906, 0.12487322837114334, 0.005931209307163954, 0.01481610257178545, 0.028136510401964188, -0.060205988585948944, -0.02529931254684925, 0.04958350956439972, -0.08492159843444824, -0.03523281216621399 ]
160
160
Faster and better: a machine learning approach to corner detection
The repeatability and efficiency of a corner detector determines how likely it is to be useful in a real-world application. The repeatability is importand because the same scene viewed from different positions should yield features which correspond to the same real-world 3D locations [Schmid et al 2000]. The efficiency is important because this determines whether the detector combined with further processing can operate at frame rate. Three advances are described in this paper. First, we present a new heuristic for feature detection, and using machine learning we derive a feature detector from this which can fully process live PAL video using less than 5% of the available processing time. By comparison, most other detectors cannot even operate at frame rate (Harris detector 115%, SIFT 195%). Second, we generalize the detector, allowing it to be optimized for repeatability, with little loss of efficiency. Third, we carry out a rigorous comparison of corner detectors based on the above repeatability criterion applied to 3D scenes. We show that despite being principally constructed for speed, on these stringent tests, our heuristic detector significantly outperforms existing feature detectors. Finally, the comparison demonstrates that using machine learning produces significant improvements in repeatability, yielding a detector that is both very fast and very high quality.
[ 0.04011434316635132, -0.02275083400309086, 0.045040957629680634, -0.008345809765160084, -0.014046024531126022, -0.04230169579386711, -0.024218713864684105, 0.029556626453995705, -0.027357786893844604, 0.08481499552726746, 0.023183127865195274, -0.002546226140111685, -0.03118489310145378, -0.021979469805955887, -0.0068336972035467625, 0.009837590157985687, 0.048880159854888916, -0.04437142238020897, 0.005475005600601435, -0.0005329949199222028, 0.013907813467085361, 0.0028539749328047037, 0.006834067869931459, -0.042393267154693604, 0.07963753491640091, 0.01244629081338644, -0.010715287178754807, 0.034034471958875656, -0.017834065482020378, 0.000914958247449249, 0.011730041354894638, -0.04037303850054741, 0.018930615857243538, -0.01990831457078457, -0.013806597329676151, 0.05198404937982559, 0.07943091541528702, -0.03310733661055565, -0.002071635564789176, 0.008252239786088467, 0.04648932069540024, 0.028918713331222534, 0.03433182090520859, 0.008578624576330185, 0.024806328117847443, 0.022223375737667084, -0.037322819232940674, 0.07731825113296509, 0.0610688291490078, 0.0475551076233387, -0.0002733183791860938, 0.010810359381139278, -0.10684742033481598, 0.014856487512588501, 0.02862805500626564, 0.11933743208646774, -0.04735251143574715, -0.024948617443442345, 0.05788480490446091, -0.04197006672620773, -0.04263361915946007, 0.12400393933057785, 0.030772652477025986, 0.06806804239749908, -0.049057476222515106, -0.03710446506738663, 0.010247888043522835, -0.024316774681210518, 0.023051925003528595, -0.06949864327907562, -0.051053136587142944, -0.08499467372894287, 0.03371231257915497, -0.01542250718921423, 0.08467312902212143, 0.0117123331874609, -0.0017340214690193534, 0.028291616588830948, 0.07606378197669983, 0.05478890612721443, -0.036596111953258514, 0.01729755476117134, 0.02746564894914627, -0.015480919741094112, -0.04179491847753525, 0.018844524398446083, -0.009559951722621918, 0.05671491101384163, -0.022393634542822838, 0.03236674144864082, 0.0018761041574180126, -0.011733640916645527, -0.09032246470451355, 0.0668850764632225, 0.01197653729468584, -0.034821465611457825, -0.0025128989946097136, -0.010469572618603706, -0.04465186968445778, 0.07607877999544144, 0.006255597807466984, -0.020545287057757378, 0.061336126178503036, 0.04322830215096474, -0.04522963613271713, -0.03574097156524658, -0.023257888853549957, 0.037032805383205414, -0.025985168293118477, -0.043076902627944946, 0.026880230754613876, 0.017863472923636436, -0.013585817068815231, -0.032670214772224426, -0.05776762589812279, 0.053813546895980835, -0.026307938620448112, 0.1025145947933197, -0.014759804122149944, 0.005958721041679382, 0.005612644366919994, 0.08758247643709183, 0.007684522308409214, 0.007969832047820091, 0.038970403373241425, -0.025138357654213905, 0.02886706218123436, -0.07006856054067612, 0.14223138988018036, -0.026514293625950813, -0.05679609254002571, 0.04717208445072174, 0.01337889302521944, 0.05163983628153801, -0.10390878468751907, -0.02025856077671051, 0.011178702116012573, 0.04897322133183479, -0.07857761532068253, 0.09974748641252518, -0.021476566791534424, -0.06551660597324371, 0.03280893713235855, 0.0747993215918541, 0.01645236648619175, 0.048266973346471786, -0.05025104433298111, 0.00816380139440298, 0.004545158706605434, -0.03286046162247658, 0.1129046157002449, -0.03463394194841385, 0.011843881569802761, 0.04810469597578049, 0.06707875430583954, -0.02886507473886013, 0.004368968773633242, -0.0031754677183926105, 0.07776933908462524, 0.07473921775817871, 0.05377383902668953, 0.012688042595982552, -0.026779113337397575, 0.059331297874450684, 0.009697280824184418, 0.011826170608401299, -0.056378062814474106, -0.06024574860930443, 0.04528646543622017, 0.005009831395000219, -0.10282264649868011, 0.01809404231607914, -0.06988455355167389, -0.022108126431703568, 0.0872764065861702, 0.008336199447512627, -0.03747832775115967, 0.0230328980833292, -0.04161253571510315, -0.005820418708026409, 0.025495383888483047, -0.016558879986405373, 0.008594788610935211, -0.04850777983665466, 0.008130766451358795, 0.02690170519053936, -0.0012170854024589062, -0.02017177641391754, 0.08027230948209763, 0.036432258784770966, -0.03144010156393051, -0.04555732011795044, 0.040383417159318924, 0.01771441660821438, -0.004895751364529133, 0.07909966260194778, -0.03517033904790878, -0.052482280880212784, 0.03443608433008194, 0.08266516029834747, 0.04208758845925331, -0.02183648757636547, -0.037310775369405746, -0.03331872448325157, -0.024443121626973152, 0.0005379441427066922, -0.011807846836745739, -0.04839927330613136, 0.02971545234322548, -0.0831446722149849, 0.09953159093856812, 0.04152686893939972, -0.0278337262570858, 0.049847789108753204, -0.0071272156201303005, -0.021053265780210495, -0.04709164798259735, -0.03452536463737488, 0.06636230647563934, 0.01381554827094078, -0.06402641534805298, 0.001712994184345007, -0.0813622921705246, 0.0581916905939579, -0.010690011084079742, 0.029641196131706238, 0.01489405520260334, 0.009874120354652405, -0.03885939344763756, -0.010327073745429516, -0.029832612723112106, 0.019590236246585846, -0.01796264946460724, -0.040996961295604706, -0.00042892489000223577, 0.019739480689167976, -0.0454326868057251, -0.01850220002233982, -0.015924770385026932, -0.08024788647890091, -0.04672795906662941, 0.09393081068992615, 0.038215503096580505, -0.01212499849498272, -0.031491074711084366, 0.034348055720329285, 0.010774432681500912, 0.030423922464251518, 0.00574609637260437, -0.02258356846868992, -0.018170710653066635, -0.02207360230386257, 0.013145622797310352, -0.05568188428878784, 0.011957928538322449, 0.012272757478058338, -0.0053077624179422855, -0.0642695426940918, 0.09768635779619217, 0.07989376783370972, 0.06158112362027168, 0.006784957367926836, -0.009735366329550743, -0.013186990283429623, 0.057302914559841156, -0.03544400632381439, -0.035269711166620255, -0.0087037468329072, 0.04046858847141266, 0.02101966179907322, -0.015105554834008217, -0.03257875144481659, -0.0007939115166664124, 0.027978505939245224, 0.019716134294867516, -0.02242404967546463, 0.08860345929861069, 0.07661067694425583, -0.040080904960632324, 0.015020149759948254, -0.03521673008799553, -0.005526740103960037, -0.001171488780528307, 0.030160419642925262, 0.025960270315408707, 0.09781349450349808, -0.011389500461518764, -0.05474809557199478, -0.018406584858894348, -0.019323278218507767, -0.057937972247600555, 0.09190643578767776, -0.01100569125264883, -0.03093062713742256, 0.027761384844779968, 0.00042044196743518114, 0.050497207790613174, -0.013986190780997276, -0.04303703084588051, 0.0021004846785217524, 0.04661845415830612, 0.043665312230587006, 0.02960226498544216, 0.054171811789274216, 0.0053490749560296535, 0.029377631843090057, 0.05352701246738434, 0.03159552440047264, -0.04354466125369072, 0.07675455510616302, 0.06454335153102875, -0.009674493223428726, -0.09776618331670761, 0.05843503028154373, 0.0003482906904537231, -0.0473099984228611, 0.009754716418683529, -0.005225810222327709, 0.0020415226463228464, -0.02564232610166073, -0.023297376930713654, -0.09462425857782364, 0.00905048381537199, 0.021057695150375366, -0.04007848724722862, -0.07330125570297241, -0.060561567544937134, -0.0007154207560233772, 0.006890836637467146, -0.004699064418673515, -0.06393218040466309, 0.014944646507501602, -0.04955517500638962, 0.07921738177537918, -0.03415120765566826, 0.01549842394888401, 0.0667945072054863, -0.003977166023105383, -0.024863025173544884, 0.01488807238638401, 0.010034261271357536, -0.02496262639760971, -0.015108717605471611, -0.04412895068526268, 0.01573449745774269, 0.03407224640250206, 0.07085555046796799, 0.025314463302493095, 0.01312941126525402, 0.08006274700164795, -0.02927408367395401, 0.026677735149860382, -0.03399721160531044, -0.08185004442930222, -0.034854136407375336, 0.06065129488706589, -0.018098430708050728, -0.0060058701783418655, -0.046740952879190445, 0.05080445110797882, 0.007815038785338402, 0.03796614333987236, -0.08202391117811203, -0.03202167898416519, 0.031262993812561035, 0.06587730348110199, 0.03540768101811409, 0.07460644841194153, 0.05086454376578331, -0.00016216108633670956, -0.057952504605054855, 0.058173224329948425, 0.05064811930060387, -0.0023613637313246727, 0.04846683144569397, 0.009500929154455662, 0.03658568859100342, -0.009545507840812206, -0.029438065364956856, 0.06688061356544495, -0.07893233001232147, 0.02445063926279545, -0.013854199089109898, -0.043656934052705765, -0.06779765337705612, 0.07730549573898315, 0.013271317817270756, 0.03175443783402443, 0.046988580375909805, 0.03418105095624924, -0.01471283845603466, -0.03013274073600769, -0.04792565107345581, 0.025775210931897163, 0.0036331152077764273, -0.027564337477087975, 0.047660551965236664, -0.011800720356404781, 0.026791095733642578, -0.02670885995030403, -0.017517875880002975, -0.03184646740555763, -0.02009156160056591, 0.03425367921590805, -0.05108121410012245, -0.00044569637975655496, -0.0189671590924263, 0.05978138744831085, -0.032638996839523315, -0.023143170401453972, 0.03970665484666824, -0.0003714169724844396, 0.04573963209986687, 0.0017103580757975578, -0.015304057858884335, 0.06085525453090668, -0.06728965789079666, -0.12082429975271225, 0.052020907402038574, -0.0693611428141594, 0.023224735632538795, -0.008566353470087051, 0.07011640071868896, 0.007792080286890268, -0.0352826863527298, -0.00723964162170887, 0.07020433247089386, -0.02650711126625538, 0.0038659211713820696, 0.09036868065595627, 0.012471610680222511, 0.034200090914964676, -0.021035369485616684, -0.006992687005549669, 0.039646588265895844, 0.03753311187028885, 0.07127875089645386, -0.027179984375834465, -0.06316512823104858, 0.010031180456280708, -0.08725543320178986, -0.0065712956711649895, -0.03297984600067139, -0.052145399153232574, -0.0450606495141983, 0.05771494284272194, -0.03729923442006111, 0.020258013159036636, 0.07708441466093063, 0.004387937486171722, -0.03490704670548439, -0.013054708018898964, 0.03282688185572624, 0.03079293482005596, 0.05663339048624039, 0.05328260362148285, -0.0023597872350364923, 0.003126639872789383, 0.05490301921963692, 0.046940311789512634, -0.02872302383184433, -0.053557876497507095, 0.03293868899345398, 0.047684140503406525, 0.015298032201826572, 0.041055917739868164, -0.0804639682173729, 0.008738219738006592, 0.07556676119565964, 0.01186396274715662, -0.05810932442545891, 0.03537004813551903, 0.04180288314819336, -0.047361064702272415, 0.05132529139518738, -0.018600743263959885, 0.040229056030511856, 0.024176012724637985, -0.017091039568185806, 0.022059593349695206, 0.014051376841962337, 0.015249807387590408, -0.034922629594802856, -0.009348575957119465, 0.01215635146945715, 0.033082086592912674, -0.07039953768253326, -0.034939661622047424, 0.01896890252828598, -0.01175947580486536, 0.009576094336807728, -0.0029506066348403692, 0.06225711107254028, 0.0554228201508522, -0.00009986951044993475, -0.03175060823559761, 0.03045169822871685, -0.005571672227233648, 0.03964255377650261, -0.03290488198399544, -0.009909204207360744, -0.02291289158165455, -0.010903703980147839, -0.021577609702944756, 0.053538329899311066, 0.054651014506816864, 0.02604384534060955, -0.025161296129226685, 0.04286374896764755, -0.02188916876912117, -0.08101736009120941, 0.08848196268081665 ]
161
161
A Simple Linear Ranking Algorithm Using Query Dependent Intercept Variables
The LETOR website contains three information retrieval datasets used as a benchmark for testing machine learning ideas for ranking. Algorithms participating in the challenge are required to assign score values to search results for a collection of queries, and are measured using standard IR ranking measures (NDCG, precision, MAP) that depend only the relative score-induced order of the results. Similarly to many of the ideas proposed in the participating algorithms, we train a linear classifier. In contrast with other participating algorithms, we define an additional free variable (intercept, or benchmark) for each query. This allows expressing the fact that results for different queries are incomparable for the purpose of determining relevance. The cost of this idea is the addition of relatively few nuisance parameters. Our approach is simple, and we used a standard logistic regression library to test it. The results beat the reported participating algorithms. Hence, it seems promising to combine our approach with other more complex ideas.
[ -0.01490584947168827, -0.056390002369880676, 0.024710413068532944, -0.0236155204474926, 0.11139421910047531, -0.03316744789481163, 0.014985992573201656, 0.04947933554649353, -0.11965309828519821, -0.06245259568095207, -0.0295364148914814, -0.07994737476110458, 0.0349343940615654, 0.06172414869070053, 0.03202952444553375, -0.00641104718670249, -0.037340596318244934, -0.04413709416985512, 0.01749434880912304, -0.023382972925901413, 0.021463528275489807, 0.03222169727087021, 0.1049940288066864, -0.08658318221569061, -0.004376571159809828, -0.04016593098640442, -0.04838990420103073, -0.08267970383167267, -0.008767339400947094, 0.0211770161986351, -0.008462298661470413, 0.023965416476130486, 0.07001639902591705, -0.043123673647642136, -0.012889194302260876, -0.062478817999362946, 0.06671339273452759, 0.036129795014858246, -0.06912238150835037, 0.008534528315067291, 0.006212415639311075, -0.0709851086139679, 0.008448156528174877, 0.026401489973068237, 0.04557418450713158, 0.015493770129978657, -0.019211620092391968, -0.00298388977535069, 0.07603338360786438, 0.05382069945335388, -0.10452084243297577, -0.009068159386515617, -0.04011605307459831, 0.034925322979688644, -0.003236703108996153, -0.001318623311817646, -0.03371186554431915, -0.016115369275212288, 0.03170875087380409, -0.018642447888851166, 0.0009637652547098696, 0.07031306624412537, 0.001389694749377668, -0.045717835426330566, -0.0013281683204695582, 0.015001114457845688, -0.012231506407260895, -0.016877368092536926, -0.005607035011053085, -0.014870624989271164, -0.015049112029373646, -0.04858412221074104, -0.028277002274990082, -0.03129832446575165, 0.005478210747241974, -0.01974675990641117, 0.008864987641572952, -0.02424304001033306, 0.0485960878431797, 0.04651709273457527, -0.06038076803088188, 0.034993719309568405, -0.02796877548098564, 0.016475951299071312, -0.016665978357195854, 0.033074185252189636, 0.0386628694832325, 0.016321761533617973, -0.09853047132492065, -0.01513774786144495, 0.0025867042131721973, -0.00934299174696207, -0.032718341797590256, 0.020167365670204163, -0.053854890167713165, 0.00722524244338274, -0.045662835240364075, -0.005490502808243036, 0.05371218919754028, 0.03231219947338104, 0.03174653276801109, -0.0028817455749958754, 0.0035162917338311672, 0.015279085375368595, -0.0714670941233635, 0.037107914686203, -0.03577909991145134, 0.03428393974900246, 0.006460300646722317, 0.032051049172878265, -0.0015132363187149167, -0.007045883685350418, 0.004373295232653618, 0.06064016371965408, -0.03469160571694374, 0.022818423807621002, -0.04464361071586609, 0.07987286895513535, 0.008490165695548058, 0.009578264318406582, -0.00825087446719408, 0.05103136971592903, -0.04026434198021889, 0.03648947924375534, 0.03380614519119263, -0.009501309134066105, -0.03824205324053764, -0.016700664535164833, 0.10833334177732468, -0.01330632995814085, -0.017082806676626205, 0.10619676113128662, -0.05308354273438454, 0.02442183531820774, -0.026829272508621216, -0.037857234477996826, 0.02430851198732853, -0.037299349904060364, 0.025482511147856712, -0.03256215527653694, -0.028841601684689522, 0.06529495865106583, -0.06911727786064148, 0.007584721781313419, 0.0314817950129509, 0.08654226362705231, -0.036431677639484406, 0.018476886674761772, 0.009012308903038502, -0.007808411959558725, -0.0261747557669878, -0.062167827039957047, 0.01657978631556034, 0.029197489842772484, -0.019082212820649147, -0.04028559848666191, -0.06380277127027512, -0.027433214709162712, -0.022135445848107338, 0.05232023820281029, 0.04488059878349304, 0.032386068254709244, 0.017301633954048157, -0.026332436129450798, -0.023925073444843292, -0.026574473828077316, -0.0591999851167202, -0.012531890533864498, -0.06326481699943542, -0.08656243979930878, -0.030239932239055634, 0.011904790997505188, -0.025417782366275787, -0.02198854833841324, 0.005362454801797867, -0.10793442279100418, 0.022508282214403152, -0.049665581434965134, -0.08352881669998169, -0.033907026052474976, 0.06526397168636322, -0.11533653736114502, 0.031043704599142075, -0.024355413392186165, 0.04327639564871788, 0.086241714656353, 0.06166846305131912, 0.029869340360164642, 0.017933888360857964, -0.04553643614053726, 0.01214371994137764, -0.06620554625988007, 0.0600326843559742, 0.05665752291679382, -0.06913885474205017, 0.05939526855945587, 0.011867162771522999, -0.07783354073762894, 0.008033757098019123, 0.01729637011885643, 0.018244188278913498, 0.029512152075767517, -0.06775791943073273, -0.04087398201227188, 0.013370958156883717, -0.03192755952477455, 0.034626077860593796, -0.07817504554986954, -0.014624807983636856, 0.001088488264940679, 0.09897702932357788, 0.02086988091468811, 0.03287356346845627, 0.03503318503499031, -0.008739596232771873, -0.06356795877218246, -0.0006238130736164749, -0.05916217342019081, 0.042111609131097794, 0.0005431785830296576, -0.03873095288872719, 0.013426327146589756, -0.052767008543014526, 0.07567466795444489, -0.03792306408286095, 0.025528615340590477, 0.019471630454063416, -0.07367351651191711, -0.10771418362855911, 0.025778980925679207, -0.027666326612234116, -0.021934572607278824, -0.06202343851327896, 0.013287895359098911, 0.022773001343011856, 0.04461025819182396, -0.12470914423465729, -0.06699590384960175, 0.036212846636772156, -0.026618169620633125, 0.006540929898619652, 0.04660424962639809, 0.0018328367732465267, -0.05608971044421196, 0.028487661853432655, -0.016207708045840263, -0.00941431988030672, -0.002892220625653863, -0.028667433187365532, -0.008812262676656246, 0.03968749940395355, -0.07390986382961273, -0.07465634495019913, 0.01818196289241314, 0.07076654583215714, 0.046334754675626755, 0.06836909800767899, 0.0025966186076402664, 0.0009338744566775858, 0.04690471291542053, -0.04405813291668892, 0.03981982544064522, -0.011025264859199524, 0.019770547747612, 0.019909892231225967, -0.035971302539110184, -0.04710868373513222, 0.028366608545184135, 0.03356916829943657, -0.011572370305657387, 0.0015033358940854669, -0.08204875141382217, -0.021799150854349136, 0.11102534085512161, -0.06184513121843338, 0.036112185567617416, 0.01939847320318222, 0.04276528209447861, 0.002407793188467622, 0.027396073564887047, -0.02378622628748417, -0.038662996143102646, 0.036613207310438156, 0.02104288339614868, -0.010857335291802883, 0.013272730633616447, -0.010237491689622402, -0.06756263971328735, 0.03629792854189873, -0.027969492599368095, -0.03953550383448601, 0.036497216671705246, -0.08679180592298508, 0.006308277603238821, 0.028796307742595673, -0.05554870143532753, 0.038123778998851776, 0.007910668849945068, -0.021577658131718636, -0.010061748325824738, -0.05522807687520981, 0.021798480302095413, 0.158921018242836, 0.07723312079906464, 0.04223490133881569, 0.04953214153647423, 0.012071683071553707, 0.040301788598299026, -0.01520951371639967, -0.07553557306528091, 0.03758556768298149, 0.03578314557671547, -0.038301464170217514, 0.016306884586811066, 0.038179781287908554, -0.00025428153458051383, -0.00730314152315259, -0.01681775599718094, -0.005854656919836998, -0.015761716291308403, 0.05706315115094185, 0.020046425983309746, 0.05058862268924713, -0.04699314758181572, -0.006568507291376591, -0.032264016568660736, -0.023559337481856346, 0.004327013622969389, -0.08480261266231537, 0.03506671264767647, -0.13232259452342987, -0.013566135428845882, 0.04182453453540802, 0.015627825632691383, 0.002189155202358961, 0.058208875358104706, -0.016921157017350197, 0.0019604123663157225, 0.016191624104976654, 0.024990716949105263, -0.08672347664833069, -0.09774072468280792, -0.011326126754283905, -0.019723927602171898, 0.054367419332265854, 0.01160344947129488, 0.027811065316200256, 0.02365478314459324, -0.003851970424875617, 0.04614735394716263, -0.021031029522418976, 0.07162807136774063, -0.03986688330769539, 0.04517553001642227, -0.02393103949725628, 0.031565964221954346, 0.0021204676013439894, 0.07027864456176758, 0.039280712604522705, 0.05215609818696976, -0.014480328187346458, 0.03312996029853821, -0.04222569242119789, 0.022765187546610832, 0.0404936783015728, 0.008597191423177719, 0.000041067192796617746, -0.03393131121993065, -0.024027450010180473, 0.02563595585525036, 0.05956507846713066, -0.012674198485910892, 0.0768505111336708, -0.01692504622042179, -0.04228353500366211, -0.02011152170598507, -0.019053461030125618, 0.009837781079113483, -0.0009510532254353166, 0.07149054855108261, -0.06281255185604095, -0.029614824801683426, 0.014578765258193016, 0.07221994549036026, -0.05956582725048065, -0.031002964824438095, 0.03323423117399216, -0.006460549775511026, 0.08289952576160431, 0.06376813352108002, 0.018146688118577003, -0.05114040896296501, -0.01817065104842186, -0.0006016267579980195, 0.08598969131708145, -0.016258912160992622, -0.0391668863594532, -0.06951294094324112, -0.054438382387161255, -0.0346212312579155, -0.05583517625927925, -0.0011074268259108067, 0.029600461944937706, -0.04686333239078522, -0.06490141898393631, 0.06321468949317932, -0.002569166710600257, 0.0519101656973362, 0.03742402419447899, -0.003798440098762512, 0.007016890216618776, 0.03370998799800873, -0.06596192717552185, -0.0035525609273463488, -0.03493591398000717, 0.027205856516957283, 0.04463127255439758, 0.002662039827555418, -0.0653761550784111, -0.023263322189450264, -0.03214101120829582, -0.0007563240360468626, 0.047457724809646606, -0.007579063531011343, -0.025738634169101715, -0.003064818447455764, 0.06070875748991966, -0.007996383123099804, 0.0672403946518898, 0.05191565677523613, 0.02360941842198372, 0.05178293585777283, 0.0008680308819748461, 0.032785363495349884, 0.04106224328279495, -0.0027306252159178257, 0.014847812242805958, 0.0027543692849576473, -0.08414745330810547, 0.023147406056523323, -0.045878197997808456, 0.0069572231732308865, 0.020170532166957855, -0.028294352814555168, 0.018222346901893616, 0.04179627075791359, 0.05637764558196068, -0.02404731698334217, 0.02573731541633606, 0.006949177011847496, 0.018790820613503456, -0.058761924505233765, -0.02911619283258915, 0.08123032748699188, -0.03494985029101372, -0.004064563661813736, -0.02306305803358555, -0.00003786518209381029, 0.05958819389343262, -0.010857127606868744, -0.06120727211236954, -0.03526419401168823, 0.03806057572364807, 0.010231945663690567, -0.055892087519168854, 0.04201424866914749, 0.03290325775742531, -0.027225418016314507, 0.06644217669963837, 0.022410772740840912, -0.07529010623693466, -0.003032614244148135, 0.030950361862778664, -0.1034366711974144, -0.00473076943308115, 0.041293829679489136, -0.014699794352054596, -0.053691159933805466, -0.011325513012707233, -0.040291402488946915, 0.045565128326416016, 0.04624410346150398, 0.05312362685799599, 0.06355467438697815, 0.06226842477917671, 0.04067302122712135, -0.05084928870201111, -0.014054916799068451, -0.0012161724735051394, 0.013437035493552685, -0.020095568150281906, -0.03205466642975807, -0.021527526900172234, 0.023123256862163544, -0.030639775097370148, 0.01703779026865959, -0.007976245135068893, -0.03390125930309296, 0.013944855891168118, -0.04251163825392723, 0.012439650483429432, -0.04146755114197731, 0.014616522006690502, -0.06672678887844086, 0.07423940300941467, 0.024802250787615776, 0.06962049752473831, -0.003010350978001952, -0.012545723468065262, 0.08942758291959763, -0.06797269731760025, -0.019052106887102127 ]
162
162
The many faces of optimism - Extended version
The exploration-exploitation dilemma has been an intriguing and unsolved problem within the framework of reinforcement learning. "Optimism in the face of uncertainty" and model building play central roles in advanced exploration methods. Here, we integrate several concepts and obtain a fast and simple algorithm. We show that the proposed algorithm finds a near-optimal policy in polynomial time, and give experimental evidence that it is robust and efficient compared to its ascendants.
[ -0.03575422242283821, -0.05122927948832512, 0.006547057069838047, 0.03889522701501846, 0.011844949796795845, -0.1121802031993866, -0.0036842261906713247, -0.01842116191983223, -0.03664889931678772, 0.05633589252829552, 0.021454259753227234, -0.039940401911735535, -0.00936654768884182, 0.03556319326162338, 0.0026238569989800453, -0.03976145759224892, 0.005556093994528055, -0.028765792027115822, -0.0030167081858962774, -0.028383227065205574, -0.03684026375412941, -0.016244716942310333, -0.006961286533623934, -0.0738958939909935, -0.017574524506926537, -0.016357505694031715, 0.03557419404387474, -0.045877717435359955, 0.00528696971014142, -0.014991694130003452, -0.04202155023813248, 0.03716885298490524, 0.03940592333674431, -0.015828842297196388, -0.04056013002991676, -0.02040124498307705, 0.06021643802523613, -0.07234132289886475, -0.006926792208105326, 0.01183188334107399, 0.006696777883917093, 0.024239348247647285, 0.019999371841549873, -0.02990296483039856, 0.07594899833202362, 0.03099720925092697, 0.03771720826625824, 0.0344221256673336, -0.032621726393699646, 0.082708939909935, -0.03265414759516716, 0.05295804515480995, -0.026041455566883087, -0.015194142237305641, 0.016323063522577286, -0.005002343095839024, -0.13878090679645538, -0.013525450602173805, -0.005334560293704271, -0.04160298779606819, 0.0026316603180021048, 0.11799692362546921, -0.07268504053354263, 0.00096595921786502, -0.038660041987895966, 0.0528939925134182, 0.0555168092250824, 0.033842891454696655, -0.03650129213929176, -0.02051907405257225, 0.07316119968891144, -0.05817825347185135, 0.08196412026882172, -0.010265236720442772, 0.007899033837020397, 0.04178272560238838, -0.01746135950088501, -0.01570267602801323, 0.035472724586725235, 0.07576202601194382, -0.06451079994440079, 0.07487403601408005, -0.014002163894474506, 0.07751069217920303, 0.012645650655031204, -0.008583641611039639, -0.04707631841301918, -0.020266057923436165, -0.00905037485063076, 0.02340930514037609, 0.02466655895113945, 0.07703161984682083, -0.031191468238830566, 0.061718542128801346, -0.053118158131837845, 0.08304211497306824, -0.03382197394967079, 0.010279561392962933, -0.017565565183758736, 0.09241779148578644, 0.0503217987716198, -0.03505876287817955, 0.05515990033745766, 0.07804344594478607, -0.015339122153818607, 0.01928376406431198, -0.007938768714666367, -0.018866783007979393, 0.0033110028598457575, -0.08062349259853363, 0.028921831399202347, -0.0627884566783905, 0.01687389612197876, -0.007313152309507132, -0.0780801996588707, 0.03433317318558693, -0.0075353109277784824, 0.0016859228489920497, 0.03627009317278862, 0.0838005468249321, 0.00814121589064598, 0.01692574843764305, -0.03789052739739418, 0.00417213374748826, -0.0071114967577159405, -0.03232428431510925, -0.043299201875925064, -0.06316076219081879, 0.1327054798603058, -0.01640157401561737, 0.0009393927175551653, -0.07175073772668839, -0.008159901015460491, -0.08045821636915207, -0.0686834305524826, 0.08604386448860168, -0.03183867037296295, -0.0651077926158905, 0.008026218973100185, 0.054049208760261536, 0.003646282944828272, -0.0502464659512043, -0.02625398337841034, 0.009776443243026733, -0.024236463010311127, -0.07591719925403595, -0.025691840797662735, -0.02692740224301815, -0.008044367656111717, 0.0020895726047456264, -0.04964312165975571, -0.01247668731957674, 0.01672716625034809, 0.09049816429615021, -0.007963576354086399, -0.01764734834432602, -0.03882056474685669, 0.03284532204270363, -0.06972900778055191, 0.07129683345556259, 0.018408942967653275, 0.027773885056376457, -0.013286539353430271, 0.015173722058534622, -0.0651828795671463, -0.012576868757605553, -0.019131114706397057, 0.01268906518816948, -0.0033985646441578865, -0.09182132035493851, 0.001568404957652092, -0.0006779363029636443, -0.004119875840842724, 0.0017843127716332674, 0.04660104587674141, 0.028201743960380554, 0.019893793389201164, -0.026596706360578537, -0.009189729578793049, 0.01846197061240673, 0.010393078438937664, -0.012786041013896465, -0.016783298924565315, -0.005251844879239798, 0.04451126232743263, 0.0606067068874836, -0.018397552892565727, 0.022982534021139145, 0.029735932126641273, 0.054157059639692307, -0.05770476534962654, 0.02270403318107128, -0.03062404878437519, -0.007981295697391033, -0.016846558079123497, 0.008609161712229252, -0.0099860904738307, -0.019282761961221695, -0.021496973931789398, 0.0746142715215683, 0.07061339169740677, 0.06743140518665314, -0.11022774875164032, -0.029953278601169586, -0.0173505786806345, -0.06500741094350815, 0.010449878871440887, 0.01624423824250698, 0.038807980716228485, -0.02999839186668396, 0.03713630512356758, -0.01364354882389307, -0.053241610527038574, -0.01947045885026455, 0.030010642483830452, 0.009390447288751602, -0.033506736159324646, -0.016759784892201424, -0.0006337108206935227, -0.010251626372337341, -0.0434182845056057, 0.050521694123744965, -0.03155604377388954, 0.019436201080679893, -0.07013969868421555, -0.06330206990242004, 0.04901065304875374, 0.027047108858823776, -0.07289707660675049, 0.015423843637108803, 0.019080480560660362, -0.09471806138753891, -0.03030426986515522, 0.011839840561151505, -0.051109492778778076, 0.031097890809178352, 0.009251989424228668, -0.059553131461143494, 0.05449294298887253, -0.026356736198067665, -0.005863244645297527, 0.0691705048084259, 0.06658928096294403, -0.05243896320462227, 0.034915219992399216, 0.002408824395388365, 0.042872510850429535, 0.024137167260050774, -0.09043040871620178, 0.03215675801038742, 0.05025738477706909, -0.036757417023181915, -0.04146146401762962, 0.045501913875341415, 0.044473420828580856, -0.04168366640806198, 0.0188700333237648, 0.06426309794187546, 0.01647300273180008, 0.039526838809251785, 0.021350201219320297, 0.04508155584335327, -0.009978891350328922, 0.03727087005972862, 0.03340049088001251, 0.0025745579041540623, -0.06837472319602966, 0.03420982137322426, 0.06497903913259506, -0.013490132987499237, 0.01063486561179161, -0.008150612935423851, -0.0002633108233567327, 0.09477181732654572, -0.03714464232325554, -0.06719654053449631, 0.06354307383298874, 0.036727745085954666, -0.01011449471116066, -0.0032643915619701147, -0.11135424673557281, 0.022655567154288292, 0.010869630612432957, 0.0002981442667078227, -0.011751451529562473, 0.03772483393549919, -0.033400073647499084, -0.03671478480100632, -0.027148457244038582, 0.006290205754339695, -0.07256519049406052, 0.02825595811009407, -0.09920065850019455, 0.006260117515921593, 0.0396406464278698, -0.04428989812731743, 0.03625037893652916, -0.010426084510982037, 0.026462145149707794, 0.0026544060092419386, -0.005766990594565868, -0.030490297824144363, 0.03220326825976372, 0.013419631868600845, 0.027323542162775993, 0.040724270045757294, 0.06531143933534622, 0.05039457231760025, -0.07401891052722931, -0.022674694657325745, 0.0436730720102787, 0.03666854649782181, -0.07590719312429428, -0.027047399431467056, 0.029224857687950134, -0.01566796377301216, -0.006441514939069748, -0.02946518547832966, -0.039609018713235855, 0.06220318004488945, 0.015085792168974876, -0.0787186473608017, 0.06816201657056808, 0.04887917637825012, -0.061234697699546814, -0.12437114119529724, 0.014382309280335903, -0.010492343455553055, -0.029973886907100677, 0.041248224675655365, -0.054887983947992325, -0.016651321202516556, -0.05764209106564522, 0.04056433215737343, -0.08362862467765808, -0.013454960659146309, -0.1062694787979126, -0.03294629603624344, 0.06351786106824875, 0.05259784683585167, -0.01651267521083355, -0.1330566257238388, -0.05782691016793251, -0.01251977775245905, -0.009267907589673996, 0.07854101806879044, 0.029402215033769608, 0.020789451897144318, 0.027735598385334015, 0.016356846317648888, -0.021782517433166504, -0.041716087609529495, -0.024542510509490967, 0.050730373710393906, -0.058385785669088364, 0.03799283131957054, -0.026732061058282852, -0.0008235417772084475, -0.0267014317214489, -0.004909871146082878, -0.014694689773023129, 0.034657809883356094, -0.003063090378418565, -0.024591026827692986, -0.006523866206407547, 0.04802697151899338, 0.0015376919182017446, -0.034220386296510696, -0.04448094591498375, -0.06127835065126419, -0.0546560101211071, -0.017913054674863815, 0.021603917703032494, -0.055739760398864746, 0.06021680310368538, -0.053396277129650116, 0.08486824482679367, -0.03454141691327095, -0.09612668305635452, 0.08275232464075089, -0.030428705736994743, -0.04606066271662712, -0.018498143181204796, -0.07733537256717682, -0.017523162066936493, -0.0265712458640337, -0.05328571796417236, 0.03737330809235573, 0.06720929592847824, 0.003967670723795891, -0.05409121513366699, -0.06738115847110748, 0.05417998135089874, 0.035772934556007385, 0.07949257642030716, 0.03068174421787262, 0.06878728419542313, -0.03900117427110672, -0.046469174325466156, -0.017251787707209587, -0.03345222771167755, -0.02736089937388897, -0.050350483506917953, -0.09902995824813843, 0.01610509306192398, -0.027591712772846222, -0.004762249533087015, 0.07916168868541718, -0.01315862312912941, 0.03597342595458031, 0.01778070069849491, 0.029126590117812157, 0.001936169108375907, -0.019434472545981407, -0.0706334039568901, 0.029704991728067398, -0.04941634088754654, 0.016370320692658424, -0.016395658254623413, -0.05294637754559517, 0.03407834470272064, -0.05636231228709221, -0.02583925984799862, -0.029208187013864517, 0.007577953394502401, -0.0423857606947422, 0.059308260679244995, 0.05181437358260155, -0.05780961737036705, 0.015684539452195168, -0.029267406091094017, -0.021663039922714233, -0.057800281792879105, -0.06707870215177536, -0.01584557443857193, 0.016822097823023796, 0.008393920958042145, 0.0342155285179615, -0.0001303010358242318, 0.0564272403717041, 0.023098884150385857, 0.006461148150265217, -0.03772464767098427, -0.0013307020999491215, -0.05518738552927971, 0.08502745628356934, -0.027026772499084473, 0.013051481917500496, 0.01768806204199791, 0.05335693806409836, 0.031065531075000763, -0.007723006419837475, 0.019840868189930916, -0.03147723898291588, 0.012619917280972004, 0.00926805380731821, 0.00033239685581065714, 0.000703690224327147, 0.060539864003658295, -0.010436044074594975, -0.07261436432600021, -0.0545516200363636, 0.020529931411147118, 0.019997766241431236, 0.006046897731721401, -0.0035752931144088507, 0.01210150495171547, 0.015103106386959553, 0.12732601165771484, 0.04795954376459122, -0.003979938104748726, -0.002843486610800028, 0.02235078066587448, 0.00638755364343524, -0.021993257105350494, -0.0004031237622257322, 0.006523365620523691, 0.002124822698533535, 0.01789402961730957, 0.019203605130314827, -0.0017460152739658952, 0.07607951015233994, -0.026006527245044708, 0.04154668748378754, 0.04092135652899742, 0.06466732919216156, -0.06597304344177246, 0.06331387162208557, -0.00001871117638074793, 0.0033705951645970345, -0.010043308138847351, 0.016155537217855453, 0.032758768647909164, -0.014326905831694603, 0.032759685069322586, 0.017382973805069923, 0.06746458262205124, -0.015433094464242458, 0.015193536877632141, 0.03696153685450554, 0.053083065897226334, -0.018338702619075775, 0.002684866078197956, -0.01930127665400505, 0.07939864695072174, 0.04551983252167702, 0.010657462291419506, 0.03312494605779648, -0.028104020282626152, -0.032934434711933136, -0.0701562836766243, 0.03175732493400574 ]
163
163
The use of entropy to measure structural diversity
In this paper entropy based methods are compared and used to measure structural diversity of an ensemble of 21 classifiers. This measure is mostly applied in ecology, whereby species counts are used as a measure of diversity. The measures used were Shannon entropy, Simpsons and the Berger Parker diversity indexes. As the diversity indexes increased so did the accuracy of the ensemble. An ensemble dominated by classifiers with the same structure produced poor accuracy. Uncertainty rule from information theory was also used to further define diversity. Genetic algorithms were used to find the optimal ensemble by using the diversity indices as the cost function. The method of voting was used to aggregate the decisions.
[ -0.0625295639038086, 0.01370385754853487, -0.0004961272934451699, 0.0036421730183064938, 0.0417449027299881, -0.05857277289032936, -0.03678863123059273, -0.003316268092021346, -0.09644952416419983, -0.04777947813272476, 0.0010392272379249334, 0.017630044370889664, 0.0068445149809122086, 0.009718568995594978, 0.018353288993239403, 0.01390829123556614, -0.03287093713879585, -0.07749344408512115, -0.02428545616567135, -0.011437520384788513, -0.03641873970627785, -0.015252623707056046, 0.016263630241155624, -0.02033008076250553, -0.052745673805475235, -0.008971034549176693, -0.04028991237282753, 0.04451597481966019, -0.05797442048788071, -0.025582365691661835, -0.037228211760520935, -0.016794895753264427, 0.04826066270470619, 0.034669872373342514, 0.043936628848314285, -0.04138518497347832, -0.04803619533777237, -0.035075075924396515, -0.09908303618431091, -0.001961309462785721, -0.009220562875270844, 0.0017784774536266923, 0.015061945654451847, -0.04817038029432297, 0.037666816264390945, 0.060361750423908234, 0.06566548347473145, -0.05996304377913475, 0.04835430532693863, 0.0778825655579567, -0.09787610918283463, 0.01523479912430048, 0.06790056079626083, -0.013717821799218655, -0.03980369120836258, 0.06851931661367416, -0.007191919256001711, -0.02226105146110058, 0.0021581677719950676, -0.02429930865764618, 0.07761889696121216, 0.0887029841542244, 0.015181821770966053, 0.01611553691327572, -0.0023922210093587637, -0.02360289730131626, -0.06872072070837021, -0.02607988379895687, -0.03108704276382923, -0.024037126451730728, 0.011417552828788757, -0.04227945953607559, -0.02447487972676754, 0.019790343940258026, 0.03195062652230263, 0.0035551816690713167, 0.07109302282333374, 0.022322621196508408, 0.029024668037891388, 0.01825118064880371, -0.09469547122716904, 0.0005273341084830463, 0.0076864794827997684, 0.03691695258021355, -0.050410911440849304, -0.024258902296423912, 0.028558723628520966, -0.042651016265153885, -0.004334089811891317, 0.026581820100545883, -0.039417799562215805, 0.004908652976155281, -0.11376815289258957, 0.052861060947179794, 0.01581854559481144, 0.10730116814374924, -0.04208418354392052, 0.0005994384409859776, 0.05077073723077774, 0.007427495438605547, 0.01366383396089077, -0.003702097339555621, 0.05673370882868767, 0.006234189495444298, -0.049186836928129196, 0.007822057232260704, -0.011560364626348019, 0.04293680563569069, -0.024846578016877174, -0.009590930305421352, 0.01798933558166027, -0.02756630629301071, -0.049014925956726074, 0.01451962348073721, -0.03136598318815231, 0.02973671443760395, -0.027034051716327667, 0.0488530732691288, 0.015114658512175083, -0.011078894138336182, 0.03686780482530594, -0.03312268480658531, -0.02963411435484886, 0.006546244956552982, 0.04172784462571144, 0.020203284919261932, -0.03452513739466667, -0.027488509193062782, 0.0677013173699379, -0.04092034697532654, -0.07770741730928421, 0.04668378457427025, -0.05315357819199562, 0.0195468720048666, -0.012038749642670155, -0.04511541128158569, 0.044486597180366516, 0.025101492181420326, 0.024066802114248276, 0.049704667180776596, 0.018794750794768333, -0.040632009506225586, 0.051113784313201904, 0.07283632457256317, -0.0013048173859715462, 0.014992390759289265, 0.02780318818986416, 0.0771552175283432, 0.011532897129654884, 0.061092156916856766, -0.06000855565071106, -0.046094659715890884, 0.0744081363081932, 0.045329272747039795, 0.06241706758737564, -0.06551100313663483, -0.03796423599123955, 0.001399915898218751, -0.014285500161349773, -0.0033233752474188805, -0.055555928498506546, 0.01564352586865425, 0.01449873298406601, 0.0325644388794899, 0.03365734964609146, 0.013485148549079895, -0.007370671723037958, -0.030052190646529198, 0.025252321735024452, -0.045125026255846024, 0.011957746930420399, 0.012563483789563179, 0.008020913228392601, 0.011451805010437965, 0.08385172486305237, -0.029580097645521164, -0.0051265680231153965, 0.040229808539152145, -0.01897439733147621, 0.04250970855355263, 0.10730724781751633, -0.07495973259210587, -0.09994887560606003, 0.010415907949209213, 0.05232330411672592, 0.05313102900981903, -0.010741589590907097, -0.019254937767982483, -0.007353906519711018, 0.06491842120885849, 0.03280124068260193, -0.0017429862637072802, 0.017747968435287476, 0.022266125306487083, -0.0437292642891407, 0.0047735897824168205, -0.05730661377310753, 0.012573239393532276, 0.001214402262121439, 0.04982259124517441, 0.05399346724152565, 0.025263316929340363, -0.014710213989019394, -0.03928923234343529, -0.0015592171112075448, 0.05361412838101387, 0.06548454612493515, 0.023519491776823997, 0.0554211400449276, -0.0480530671775341, -0.04595872759819031, -0.02650221809744835, 0.07700087130069733, -0.006852402817457914, 0.09304280579090118, -0.039702702313661575, -0.10870959609746933, -0.03801563009619713, 0.019872356206178665, 0.056679610162973404, -0.001148254843428731, 0.013390328735113144, -0.013183952309191227, 0.052113864570856094, -0.05461401864886284, 0.019558269530534744, 0.018491756170988083, 0.061605777591466904, -0.02598172053694725, 0.11967568844556808, -0.047578126192092896, -0.054722171276807785, -0.044934436678886414, -0.13142091035842896, -0.058976635336875916, 0.11100282520055771, -0.04999424144625664, 0.027104636654257774, 0.0543709471821785, 0.019565697759389877, -0.0596453882753849, 0.09738083183765411, -0.0035685182083398104, 0.013912067748606205, 0.010897224768996239, -0.05125100910663605, 0.025721082463860512, 0.05277349054813385, -0.036594606935977936, 0.02891446463763714, -0.01862955465912819, -0.0035209027118980885, 0.008859970606863499, 0.04895910993218422, 0.017619069665670395, 0.011933532543480396, -0.015189792960882187, -0.007981272414326668, 0.012532243505120277, 0.08195975422859192, 0.029671309515833855, 0.05433749035000801, 0.07165656238794327, -0.04576640948653221, -0.0154518261551857, -0.008091283030807972, 0.0048975106328725815, 0.028181826695799828, -0.01728624477982521, -0.0037338430993258953, -0.005943636409938335, 0.019340896978974342, 0.006814601831138134, 0.027232103049755096, -0.0964016392827034, 0.018982188776135445, 0.0643015056848526, 0.06710421293973923, 0.030950060114264488, -0.09827367216348648, -0.039757758378982544, 0.03393488749861717, 0.0464029386639595, 0.0780813992023468, -0.02925167605280876, -0.02659926563501358, -0.024069249629974365, 0.04277242347598076, -0.028691880404949188, -0.035132937133312225, -0.0508163757622242, 0.10243827104568481, -0.08411254733800888, -0.018917914479970932, 0.014402911067008972, 0.04763682559132576, 0.04190574958920479, 0.03273719176650047, 0.08312232792377472, 0.023644927889108658, 0.00685687642544508, 0.04926460236310959, 0.06491655856370926, 0.02165943942964077, 0.04521491378545761, 0.03925613686442375, 0.015388065949082375, 0.04981936141848564, -0.116056427359581, 0.03570568189024925, 0.009787607938051224, -0.03810039162635803, -0.05917159467935562, -0.036256223917007446, -0.018985364586114883, -0.05712931975722313, -0.003450169460847974, -0.02975357323884964, -0.020747309550642967, -0.04077134281396866, 0.00010513236338738352, -0.02426539547741413, -0.010996714234352112, -0.015192740596830845, -0.08487347513437271, -0.026345858350396156, 0.0018524281913414598, 0.015222953632473946, -0.10411690920591354, 0.09896455705165863, -0.04937220737338066, -0.034101251512765884, -0.030679069459438324, 0.058779969811439514, -0.09900914877653122, 0.013306518085300922, -0.004825514275580645, 0.06941544264554977, -0.05341256782412529, -0.058366693556308746, 0.03629903867840767, 0.03355453163385391, 0.04293803870677948, 0.0012937035644426942, 0.042122792452573776, -0.029733838513493538, 0.09661441296339035, 0.0071385763585567474, 0.024489372968673706, 0.028700701892375946, -0.09025183320045471, 0.05096358433365822, -0.06389817595481873, 0.0030925937462598085, -0.05765289068222046, 0.01748831570148468, 0.026256972923874855, -0.004246182274073362, 0.050071824342012405, -0.012581352144479752, -0.0518776997923851, 0.060594867914915085, -0.008383632637560368, -0.008271787315607071, 0.018837882205843925, 0.07445389032363892, -0.04903844743967056, 0.0009562807972542942, 0.009666051715612411, -0.008872144855558872, 0.014140857383608818, 0.04867633804678917, 0.011573519557714462, 0.017811845988035202, -0.00762954680249095, -0.06704919040203094, 0.026784265413880348, -0.0017538266256451607, -0.0676063522696495, -0.0037065986543893814, -0.046937499195337296, -0.009422383271157742, 0.02464200183749199, -0.023222988471388817, 0.0008737664320506155, -0.03173138201236725, 0.05196626856923103, 0.009302234277129173, 0.0805826410651207, 0.04052647948265076, 0.05560149997472763, -0.046110253781080246, -0.06767772883176804, 0.0027607271913439035, 0.036311473697423935, 0.008496273308992386, 0.03704538568854332, -0.011772423051297665, -0.033548761159181595, 0.014548875391483307, 0.034322984516620636, -0.03025093674659729, -0.016496485099196434, -0.09728730469942093, -0.060532379895448685, 0.00790077168494463, 0.046085331588983536, 0.09845274686813354, -0.024660563096404076, 0.03312750905752182, 0.05713849142193794, 0.0005767995025962591, -0.009430702775716782, -0.06913105398416519, 0.03776858374476433, 0.06964734196662903, 0.04541622847318649, -0.02191954106092453, 0.003955186810344458, -0.07767787575721741, -0.008290043100714684, -0.012237383984029293, 0.02083546668291092, -0.0055153933353722095, 0.031646039336919785, 0.04665842279791832, 0.03561047092080116, 0.026906803250312805, 0.022720741108059883, 0.04807093366980553, -0.0336751863360405, -0.006358110811561346, -0.012575997970998287, 0.01063493825495243, 0.06182194501161575, -0.019743895158171654, 0.0023078846279531717, -0.07885012030601501, -0.002541962079703808, 0.048604872077703476, -0.03570191189646721, 0.023567603901028633, 0.009993121027946472, 0.035160187631845474, 0.03822660818696022, -0.031461555510759354, 0.05162244290113449, -0.038273416459560394, 0.011135807260870934, 0.02187739685177803, -0.03171234577894211, -0.020510446280241013, 0.010146194137632847, -0.03302881494164467, 0.04367643967270851, -0.041681770235300064, 0.0023134415969252586, -0.030881669372320175, 0.07566439360380173, -0.07190807908773422, 0.00883405189961195, -0.07599209249019623, -0.02420683763921261, -0.026365311816334724, -0.0554647333920002, 0.026833776384592056, 0.026364829391241074, -0.006261694710701704, 0.05820491909980774, 0.03334303945302963, -0.05644392594695091, -0.02319587767124176, -0.052692119032144547, -0.1055988222360611, -0.001995849423110485, 0.005715847015380859, -0.05016067624092102, 0.01059724111109972, -0.0008002963731996715, -0.08039526641368866, 0.022970451042056084, 0.04835977032780647, -0.024385565891861916, 0.14109554886817932, -0.015173648484051228, -0.04034542664885521, -0.04535835608839989, 0.030553603544831276, -0.0071875243447721004, 0.00020477398356888443, 0.009597702883183956, 0.03510531783103943, -0.035888176411390305, 0.025029752403497696, 0.05467785522341728, 0.015223969705402851, -0.0067466432228684425, 0.0045562973245978355, -0.019285252317786217, 0.003354633692651987, 0.03462589532136917, -0.02753601036965847, 0.024032138288021088, -0.006678218487650156, 0.0332396999001503, -0.021941132843494415, 0.05705052614212036, -0.01664133556187153, -0.014190701767802238, 0.0024973638355731964, -0.0014087234158068895, -0.057961806654930115 ]
164
164
A Minimum Relative Entropy Principle for Learning and Acting
This paper proposes a method to construct an adaptive agent that is universal with respect to a given class of experts, where each expert is an agent that has been designed specifically for a particular environment. This adaptive control problem is formalized as the problem of minimizing the relative entropy of the adaptive agent from the expert that is most suitable for the unknown environment. If the agent is a passive observer, then the optimal solution is the well-known Bayesian predictor. However, if the agent is active, then its past actions need to be treated as causal interventions on the I/O stream rather than normal probability conditions. Here it is shown that the solution to this new variational problem is given by a stochastic controller called the Bayesian control rule, which implements adaptive behavior as a mixture of experts. Furthermore, it is shown that under mild assumptions, the Bayesian control rule converges to the control law of the most suitable expert.
[ 0.014279582537710667, -0.05100975185632706, -0.02946529909968376, -0.01764245145022869, 0.028316600248217583, -0.09532339125871658, -0.04302074387669563, 0.017764713615179062, 0.027111122384667397, 0.017097095027565956, -0.007313260342925787, -0.05580461397767067, -0.03810224309563637, -0.04146634414792061, -0.012523937970399857, -0.12203598022460938, -0.018710801377892494, -0.017637697979807854, -0.05342818424105644, 0.03547376021742821, 0.034187160432338715, 0.0412808433175087, 0.046325139701366425, -0.051249910145998, -0.08457741886377335, -0.050859637558460236, -0.050242580473423004, 0.03047901764512062, 0.0018409237964078784, -0.025264862924814224, -0.07093559205532074, -0.039535120129585266, -0.018434373661875725, 0.028550347313284874, 0.12728148698806763, -0.034132733941078186, 0.06396982073783875, -0.02542847767472267, -0.018566865473985672, 0.010537425987422466, -0.028165437281131744, 0.009521249681711197, 0.04888090491294861, 0.029965249821543694, -0.0015964775811880827, 0.01748853549361229, 0.03693217411637306, 0.04241334646940231, -0.005002249032258987, 0.05017615109682083, -0.05955148860812187, -0.019315749406814575, -0.008611075580120087, -0.03123205527663231, -0.029980581253767014, 0.04357701539993286, -0.00851628091186285, -0.06721843034029007, -0.07467535883188248, -0.04959721118211746, 0.0004416118608787656, 0.10431629419326782, -0.057776521891355515, -0.03759700059890747, 0.002325903158634901, 0.0589325986802578, -0.12393218278884888, -0.02898859605193138, 0.03281933441758156, 0.08030968904495239, 0.033283963799476624, -0.011178501881659031, 0.011343137361109257, -0.04026932269334793, -0.0066400570794939995, 0.006989644840359688, -0.007750560063868761, 0.05703511834144592, -0.03659521043300629, 0.033950988203287125, -0.10880672186613083, 0.03144417703151703, -0.010630308650434017, 0.10082033276557922, -0.03398597985506058, 0.03415975347161293, -0.04298573359847069, -0.01949162594974041, -0.06855577975511551, 0.028832709416747093, 0.03097936511039734, -0.0008501007687300444, -0.02175944484770298, -0.03583408519625664, -0.01415849756449461, 0.11121435463428497, -0.030393686145544052, -0.06776327639818192, 0.04482824727892876, 0.015366332605481148, 0.042476214468479156, 0.042042963206768036, 0.08306865394115448, 0.10289175808429718, 0.008623691275715828, 0.007629917468875647, 0.008038272149860859, 0.059060294181108475, 0.050233982503414154, 0.009914645925164223, 0.00847411435097456, -0.03157394006848335, -0.005836730822920799, 0.019356463104486465, -0.04743697866797447, 0.04159894585609436, -0.032237712293863297, 0.04168127477169037, -0.03807995468378067, 0.00965061690658331, 0.06209167465567589, -0.01756349205970764, -0.023560702800750732, 0.0011020691599696875, 0.07275549322366714, -0.050774797797203064, 0.03992799296975136, -0.03221123293042183, 0.09029140323400497, -0.018298905342817307, 0.008747229352593422, -0.055180612951517105, 0.040355660021305084, -0.10322514921426773, -0.053734783083200455, 0.06764812767505646, 0.03295537084341049, -0.029971947893500328, -0.006015399470925331, 0.014481513760983944, 0.03388747572898865, -0.011549266055226326, -0.02374669723212719, 0.032366443425416946, 0.02497008442878723, 0.04549071192741394, 0.019476519897580147, 0.016533413901925087, -0.06533002853393555, -0.02319878153502941, -0.06905966997146606, 0.07208836823701859, -0.015777429565787315, 0.059436094015836716, 0.0361257866024971, -0.02795802429318428, -0.05041436851024628, 0.016422925516963005, -0.1204514428973198, 0.05146936699748039, 0.02043907903134823, 0.08844901621341705, 0.055373575538396835, 0.06319675594568253, 0.03823902830481529, 0.08326072990894318, -0.024745777249336243, -0.02091308869421482, -0.030938204377889633, -0.08032721281051636, -0.1004466712474823, -0.058649517595767975, -0.05777207016944885, -0.02396889589726925, 0.0026529317256063223, -0.017873160541057587, -0.01393574196845293, 0.031544093042612076, 0.005219743587076664, -0.003401277819648385, 0.02617722935974598, -0.040666788816452026, -0.08742858469486237, -0.052973322570323944, 0.026485618203878403, 0.07251600921154022, 0.0182358231395483, 0.06042991951107979, 0.10927773267030716, 0.046164337545633316, 0.002554824110120535, 0.008111618459224701, -0.005396940745413303, -0.019544264301657677, 0.02516324073076248, -0.0064794453792274, -0.011908425018191338, 0.0032407690305262804, -0.05288773775100708, -0.011310804635286331, 0.03202194720506668, 0.028741927817463875, -0.05397706851363182, -0.07035509496927261, -0.07097799330949783, 0.046521928161382675, -0.01423782017081976, -0.06897206604480743, 0.046934470534324646, -0.04649630934000015, -0.0054037063382565975, -0.038378212600946426, 0.035861436277627945, -0.04708943888545036, 0.10775751620531082, -0.11002489924430847, -0.005798321217298508, -0.08324740082025528, -0.023600848391652107, -0.0026320163160562515, 0.026310812681913376, 0.031177924945950508, -0.0019764266908168793, 0.027703285217285156, -0.04849286004900932, -0.04027917608618736, 0.011222667060792446, 0.030535172671079636, -0.014434212818741798, 0.08129384368658066, -0.08225962519645691, -0.0700940266251564, -0.042577583342790604, 0.008779780939221382, -0.038028184324502945, 0.0071328021585941315, 0.020296389237046242, -0.03983457759022713, 0.0200117789208889, -0.008276126347482204, -0.022920623421669006, 0.07717519253492355, -0.029172834008932114, -0.022172898054122925, 0.017456987872719765, 0.0017018828075379133, -0.012372339144349098, 0.03268711641430855, -0.0492670051753521, 0.05837075412273407, 0.01979636773467064, -0.0017521955305710435, 0.01612323336303234, 0.0759621113538742, 0.004766632337123156, 0.008454753085970879, -0.009180299937725067, 0.056662436574697495, 0.06749601662158966, 0.03604764863848686, 0.03208835795521736, 0.05208131670951843, -0.026098554953932762, -0.00010833579290192574, -0.03891554847359657, -0.001708454918116331, 0.0017445465782657266, 0.03426298871636391, 0.01154824998229742, 0.029661253094673157, -0.013218957930803299, -0.0024425580631941557, -0.06697051972150803, 0.05836549401283264, -0.035299088805913925, -0.024348614737391472, -0.012844612821936607, 0.03236262872815132, 0.0050240992568433285, -0.014220746234059334, -0.008596518076956272, 0.045226581394672394, 0.02414523996412754, 0.008719909004867077, -0.026643117889761925, -0.012300018221139908, 0.05501802638173103, 0.034684114158153534, 0.0002208922669524327, 0.0603284016251564, -0.08083416521549225, 0.06468895822763443, -0.04263870418071747, -0.00526855792850256, -0.005459046922624111, -0.07051247358322144, 0.024630675092339516, 0.00571177015081048, 0.003960610367357731, 0.034567538648843765, 0.035522885620594025, 0.012847497127950191, -0.05134569853544235, 0.05656587332487106, 0.03242473304271698, 0.07583899050951004, 0.05889810249209404, 0.0030177587177604437, 0.004134175833314657, 0.038559701293706894, 0.03265467286109924, 0.0348346009850502, -0.04048514738678932, 0.01441139355301857, 0.08210387825965881, 0.032510530203580856, -0.09654178470373154, -0.04405032470822334, -0.03595244884490967, 0.03621445596218109, -0.018409954383969307, -0.04100978374481201, -0.0006113735144026577, 0.0817435160279274, -0.11914536356925964, 0.02574921026825905, 0.04897131398320198, -0.026746295392513275, -0.027590226382017136, 0.09530965983867645, -0.013625829480588436, -0.03504472225904465, -0.0015028492780402303, 0.061463139951229095, -0.08561281114816666, 0.020731661468744278, -0.02546232007443905, 0.020186813548207283, 0.016527807340025902, -0.01444425992667675, -0.08886139839887619, -0.08424832671880722, -0.017845794558525085, 0.012902747839689255, 0.02330970950424671, 0.06202051043510437, 0.08603493124246597, 0.009387456811964512, -0.022306902334094048, 0.0015929682413116097, -0.0481058768928051, 0.012949188239872456, 0.001980041153728962, 0.014829306863248348, -0.12084300071001053, -0.05262162536382675, 0.04528004303574562, 0.007195223588496447, 0.010195581242442131, 0.01282359566539526, 0.006167140789330006, -0.002852954203262925, 0.0030975607223808765, -0.029878372326493263, 0.04470374807715416, -0.014888121746480465, -0.020606478676199913, 0.03973905369639397, -0.031741902232170105, -0.03682228550314903, -0.007154418621212244, 0.007424465846270323, 0.031718384474515915, 0.024275505915284157, 0.0599532425403595, -0.03394957259297371, 0.03262096643447876, -0.002571525052189827, -0.033769428730010986, 0.08049740642309189, -0.02191898226737976, 0.012866371311247349, 0.008113086223602295, 0.0001484550884924829, -0.0154414102435112, -0.0020732362754642963, -0.03568904101848602, -0.06965911388397217, 0.08419753611087799, -0.06785289198160172, -0.05488954484462738, 0.003888853592798114, -0.011757811531424522, 0.0934038907289505, 0.03984697163105011, -0.0020381249487400055, 0.0002812375605572015, -0.03902148827910423, -0.07438354939222336, 0.026968257501721382, 0.03143511340022087, -0.04088844731450081, 0.05702509731054306, -0.04698382690548897, -0.0036030462943017483, -0.022183585911989212, 0.09137870371341705, 0.0389041043817997, 0.00829250831156969, 0.004585837945342064, 0.039887357503175735, 0.026092907413840294, -0.057112932205200195, -0.04496251791715622, -0.017433255910873413, 0.02433328703045845, -0.001627728808671236, 0.017151055857539177, 0.012928883545100689, -0.09148286283016205, -0.0032178726978600025, -0.003124916460365057, 0.012338253669440746, 0.04566430300474167, 0.043220505118370056, -0.01968868263065815, 0.08242398500442505, 0.010424942709505558, -0.0013201831607148051, 0.03109644167125225, -0.025938499718904495, -0.0855487659573555, -0.04827263206243515, -0.02913259156048298, -0.009965475648641586, -0.001610358594916761, 0.00793248601257801, 0.01766764186322689, 0.058024123311042786, -0.0020580855198204517, -0.03170241415500641, 0.04768062010407448, 0.00800374522805214, 0.007100468035787344, 0.07453878223896027, 0.014140940271317959, 0.016013920307159424, 0.026006381958723068, 0.027155060321092606, 0.004042707849293947, -0.06049283966422081, 0.03969460353255272, -0.003715922823175788, -0.06142571568489075, 0.025309059768915176, -0.048163577914237976, -0.010683281347155571, 0.00026704545598477125, 0.016520310193300247, -0.014424781315028667, 0.03524632751941681, 0.0008420940139330924, -0.026681486517190933, 0.008534042164683342, -0.03752536326646805, -0.04526911675930023, -0.0010580644011497498, -0.03622066602110863, 0.07377776503562927, -0.033902086317539215, -0.030860718339681625, -0.030838461592793465, -0.012801897712051868, -0.031833577901124954, -0.034721739590168, 0.03736202418804169, -0.057821858674287796, 0.05413731932640076, -0.016521599143743515, -0.04329466074705124, 0.00087129813618958, 0.07783201336860657, -0.03689572960138321, -0.011275089345872402, 0.031180890277028084, 0.026903217658400536, 0.017857007682323456, -0.012422500178217888, 0.07153953611850739, 0.050106294453144073, 0.02435433305799961, -0.02463725581765175, -0.010813578963279724, 0.0055299606174230576, 0.06348814815282822, 0.0232993271201849, 0.042150743305683136, -0.03132752329111099, 0.01940837688744068, 0.04922405630350113, 0.022645145654678345, -0.05306770280003548, 0.06123654916882515, 0.04398796707391739, 0.01920670084655285, 0.01158921793103218, 0.03325042501091957, 0.019686579704284668, -0.04751880466938019, -0.004621636588126421, -0.016515951603651047, 0.021111100912094116 ]
165
165
Quantum reinforcement learning
The key approaches for machine learning, especially learning in unknown probabilistic environments are new representations and computation mechanisms. In this paper, a novel quantum reinforcement learning (QRL) method is proposed by combining quantum theory and reinforcement learning (RL). Inspired by the state superposition principle and quantum parallelism, a framework of value updating algorithm is introduced. The state (action) in traditional RL is identified as the eigen state (eigen action) in QRL. The state (action) set can be represented with a quantum superposition state and the eigen state (eigen action) can be obtained by randomly observing the simulated quantum state according to the collapse postulate of quantum measurement. The probability of the eigen action is determined by the probability amplitude, which is parallelly updated according to rewards. Some related characteristics of QRL such as convergence, optimality and balancing between exploration and exploitation are also analyzed, which shows that this approach makes a good tradeoff between exploration and exploitation using the probability amplitude and can speed up learning through the quantum parallelism. To evaluate the performance and practicability of QRL, several simulated experiments are given and the results demonstrate the effectiveness and superiority of QRL algorithm for some complex problems. The present work is also an effective exploration on the application of quantum computation to artificial intelligence.
[ 0.016886208206415176, -0.03660961240530014, 0.04785327985882759, -0.0431860014796257, 0.02141902595758438, -0.05435987561941147, 0.03628277778625488, 0.011310254223644733, -0.07920455932617188, 0.03431100770831108, -0.00009177293395623565, -0.02661864273250103, 0.039664607495069504, 0.048094213008880615, 0.0367412194609642, 0.004501305986195803, -0.02215774543583393, 0.04939495399594307, 0.03351706638932228, -0.038675423711538315, 0.0381050668656826, -0.034631676971912384, 0.054630376398563385, -0.03121895156800747, 0.025546059012413025, -0.002001807326450944, -0.0747440904378891, -0.012728642672300339, 0.030139146372675896, -0.021073637530207634, -0.007695149630308151, 0.0009640250355005264, -0.01942978799343109, -0.04995044320821762, 0.0312829427421093, 0.03374439477920532, 0.09617303311824799, -0.029318135231733322, 0.016232432797551155, 0.01461970154196024, -0.04483875632286072, -0.04655732959508896, 0.008259362541139126, 0.04154170677065849, 0.039905060082674026, 0.049203164875507355, 0.09065672755241394, 0.019910946488380432, -0.0690082460641861, 0.09192405641078949, -0.04153447225689888, 0.045640721917152405, -0.054238565266132355, -0.028503458946943283, 0.03210202232003212, 0.019194666296243668, 0.010893370024859905, -0.02856905572116375, -0.06426216661930084, -0.045454125851392746, 0.013643195852637291, 0.0869968831539154, 0.055184993892908096, 0.03633739799261093, 0.011683069169521332, 0.05372226610779762, -0.06435930728912354, -0.0721110999584198, -0.013495899736881256, -0.04418165236711502, 0.03469328209757805, 0.005918813869357109, 0.03197254613041878, -0.013399346731603146, -0.001243043690919876, -0.00031394249526783824, -0.007172442972660065, -0.045596275478601456, 0.04540000483393669, 0.0555676706135273, -0.01485283114016056, 0.046029604971408844, -0.021825194358825684, 0.1159467101097107, -0.0175542701035738, 0.00608839513733983, -0.0032078633084893227, -0.037121936678886414, -0.01806371845304966, 0.010240166448056698, 0.04469742253422737, 0.015723109245300293, -0.05200628563761711, 0.025127151980996132, -0.01079661212861538, 0.0270349383354187, -0.0656493604183197, -0.052823495119810104, -0.023935383185744286, -0.034941885620355606, -0.00951846968382597, -0.004425432067364454, 0.0429205596446991, 0.07610517740249634, -0.007664607372134924, -0.00881640613079071, -0.005601408891379833, -0.028151994571089745, 0.023565182462334633, -0.00605893786996603, 0.01100332010537386, 0.005669706501066685, 0.0064801922999322414, -0.03193553909659386, -0.06126987189054489, 0.033157479017972946, -0.014312252402305603, 0.01037185825407505, -0.00477098673582077, 0.09189540147781372, 0.0004926517140120268, -0.016630642116069794, -0.028396595269441605, 0.008322106674313545, 0.03356907144188881, -0.05251581221818924, -0.052996113896369934, -0.0773981437087059, 0.14936164021492004, 0.004287335556000471, 0.013377593830227852, -0.09218303114175797, 0.03388131782412529, -0.09440075606107712, 0.002020502695813775, 0.0017688381485641003, -0.02183014340698719, -0.0572335459291935, -0.028250856325030327, 0.031621675938367844, 0.06725065410137177, 0.04896682873368263, -0.06344778835773468, 0.012852816842496395, 0.01624944619834423, -0.010315388441085815, -0.0154483737424016, 0.01009454857558012, 0.05226919800043106, 0.027357738465070724, -0.000297519814921543, 0.03660719096660614, 0.023563874885439873, 0.03974626958370209, 0.01999085023999214, -0.02232145331799984, -0.06724704056978226, -0.04685378074645996, 0.0009900551522150636, 0.13303519785404205, 0.022925175726413727, 0.004297058098018169, -0.038352120667696, 0.003715797793120146, -0.05167253687977791, -0.02528734877705574, -0.08697615563869476, 0.03894049674272537, -0.0798988863825798, -0.023167280480265617, 0.034246280789375305, 0.0183868408203125, 0.013888548128306866, 0.02108921855688095, 0.023772504180669785, -0.03748633712530136, -0.07541495561599731, 0.019029926508665085, -0.014700164087116718, -0.011758879758417606, -0.043265219777822495, -0.05029720813035965, -0.016493961215019226, -0.017059359699487686, 0.04851078242063522, 0.03261677175760269, -0.04728839546442032, 0.028787579387426376, 0.018010923638939857, -0.03346671909093857, -0.024817144498229027, -0.006559312343597412, -0.02071436122059822, 0.010170024819672108, -0.025082414969801903, 0.04888574406504631, -0.05530766025185585, -0.09230592101812363, 0.0862894207239151, 0.005328610073775053, 0.02755650505423546, 0.10338524729013443, -0.04661437124013901, -0.04222188889980316, -0.057048093527555466, 0.021973248571157455, -0.025537554174661636, 0.03785058110952377, -0.04632142558693886, 0.01786835677921772, 0.07692437618970871, -0.03563261032104492, -0.007305947132408619, -0.07021917402744293, 0.0035009633284062147, -0.07744675129652023, -0.01602885313332081, -0.07279524952173233, 0.003366700140759349, 0.024498384445905685, -0.041665781289339066, 0.06640031933784485, -0.031347259879112244, 0.09208519756793976, 0.012564359232783318, -0.03212110325694084, 0.059180229902267456, -0.02969386987388134, -0.06332376599311829, -0.04845910146832466, 0.02677970938384533, -0.07880313694477081, -0.07874304056167603, -0.008321228437125683, 0.015561768785119057, 0.028308724984526634, -0.02601122483611107, -0.024060212075710297, 0.04835652559995651, 0.04840436205267906, 0.022128034383058548, 0.05670193210244179, 0.03276090323925018, -0.0637180507183075, 0.07728828489780426, -0.023177318274974823, 0.003573081688955426, 0.013686569407582283, -0.050860848277807236, -0.04382169246673584, 0.06367292255163193, 0.020917870104312897, -0.05190118029713631, -0.0015716548077762127, 0.08877196162939072, 0.06058933213353157, -0.026231007650494576, 0.01470402255654335, 0.03371484950184822, -0.022753281518816948, -0.07486093789339066, 0.03871072083711624, -0.006101824343204498, 0.06647202372550964, 0.07790057361125946, -0.0026397723704576492, -0.003156111342832446, 0.00397528288885951, -0.04423047974705696, 0.02720138616859913, 0.01147190760821104, 0.03934098035097122, 0.03786544129252434, 0.04016267880797386, -0.0337035246193409, -0.06561099737882614, 0.06491690874099731, 0.039205897599458694, -0.006651092320680618, -0.05266015976667404, -0.06746646016836166, -0.059391457587480545, -0.06784995645284653, -0.01657363586127758, 0.0317552424967289, -0.0012870754580944777, -0.02141197770833969, -0.0060203662142157555, 0.02243613265454769, 0.03906462341547012, -0.008380427956581116, 0.0399111732840538, -0.06154388561844826, -0.05822424218058586, 0.05481340363621712, -0.012088235467672348, 0.025558684021234512, -0.06898054480552673, -0.026387207210063934, -0.06287333369255066, 0.022846102714538574, -0.012927073985338211, 0.0599343404173851, -0.006807198282331228, -0.01991995796561241, 0.0388842336833477, 0.00937079917639494, 0.05759197473526001, -0.1317339837551117, -0.00014073235797695816, 0.04342592507600784, 0.004305239301174879, 0.04508329927921295, -0.0707947239279747, 0.04200059175491333, 0.06469272077083588, 0.0008878181106410921, -0.028077013790607452, 0.016159679740667343, 0.02712148055434227, 0.06571926921606064, -0.009256774559617043, -0.012383668683469296, -0.014095278456807137, -0.09874336421489716, 0.0026073656044900417, -0.008654600009322166, -0.005406039766967297, -0.0212244875729084, 0.09033447504043579, -0.08239384740591049, 0.001133662648499012, -0.0022636125795543194, 0.10838142782449722, -0.005520214792340994, -0.05048438161611557, -0.10096721351146698, -0.013555843383073807, 0.05983877182006836, 0.04458111897110939, -0.021447425708174706, -0.1338449865579605, -0.04478141665458679, 0.020984355360269547, -0.03336305916309357, -0.00198556249961257, 0.05677875503897667, -0.028500301763415337, 0.0544627383351326, -0.004808277357369661, 0.040409866720438004, -0.04769853502511978, -0.07396861165761948, 0.040359023958444595, -0.015337365679442883, 0.04233916848897934, -0.04296884685754776, 0.08070544898509979, -0.062122344970703125, 0.009316187351942062, 0.03584090620279312, 0.037488903850317, 0.002279275096952915, -0.021460913121700287, -0.003220640355721116, 0.06400319188833237, -0.013761808164417744, -0.01970156654715538, -0.05374717712402344, -0.04166962578892708, -0.016042781993746758, -0.01410706341266632, 0.039337821304798126, -0.034984055906534195, 0.06657204031944275, -0.02637159265577793, 0.08112964779138565, -0.0058638048358261585, 0.020537937059998512, 0.07176917791366577, -0.10414596647024155, -0.03675629571080208, 0.00916849635541439, 0.009244097396731377, 0.02186238206923008, -0.039619795978069305, -0.07192441821098328, 0.024726711213588715, 0.03746474161744118, -0.029139986261725426, -0.06535059958696365, 0.012064251117408276, 0.0151353869587183, 0.008202058263123035, 0.0022320591378957033, -0.027917232364416122, 0.01095934584736824, -0.008140739984810352, 0.025599025189876556, -0.008476374670863152, -0.012261473573744297, -0.08232808858156204, 0.027056090533733368, -0.1025872454047203, -0.010880217887461185, 0.01734107919037342, 0.018302394077181816, 0.06460506469011307, -0.057031791657209396, 0.03822259232401848, 0.04547334089875221, 0.0484454520046711, -0.007692791521549225, -0.06630891561508179, -0.03465136140584946, -0.02785295434296131, 0.000913830881472677, -0.012995678000152111, 0.0223501268774271, -0.10982008278369904, -0.054832588881254196, -0.04426420107483864, 0.06998603790998459, -0.016472136601805687, 0.00562850758433342, 0.06438784301280975, 0.027913667261600494, 0.022110391408205032, 0.05032145604491234, -0.04573030024766922, -0.021769801154732704, 0.042007170617580414, 0.013617625460028648, -0.04679754003882408, 0.032301824539899826, -0.04228048399090767, -0.08605626225471497, 0.028966879472136497, 0.013824527151882648, 0.043867673724889755, 0.07215246558189392, 0.008595849387347698, -0.002397477626800537, 0.027952389791607857, 0.029505526646971703, 0.07806193083524704, 0.06999627500772476, -0.054372698068618774, 0.0441892184317112, 0.03129078075289726, 0.027455119416117668, 0.00762732932344079, 0.025984449312090874, -0.014787653461098671, 0.046377431601285934, 0.05048214644193649, -0.010578855872154236, 0.004877767525613308, 0.015995480120182037, 0.0062036351300776005, -0.011918851174414158, -0.0036987473722547293, 0.028569461777806282, 0.028090232983231544, 0.008984576910734177, -0.002639689249917865, -0.009759156033396721, -0.016830703243613243, 0.0667986199259758, -0.03380399942398071, -0.02472366765141487, 0.03772781416773796, 0.02780028246343136, -0.01523884292691946, -0.06288668513298035, 0.04790668934583664, 0.0234087985008955, -0.04139798507094383, 0.0252536628395319, 0.03512490168213844, 0.034578535705804825, -0.007375113666057587, -0.043035801500082016, -0.013172382488846779, 0.01749483309686184, 0.022331127896904945, -0.055377136915922165, 0.08945940434932709, 0.03655099868774414, -0.001402800902724266, 0.017423920333385468, -0.07136064022779465, 0.02765652909874916, -0.07504858821630478, 0.03942394629120827, -0.016418974846601486, -0.01634449139237404, 0.009543284773826599, 0.020724838599562645, 0.035189174115657806, -0.02510368451476097, 0.00717531144618988, -0.019339824095368385, 0.018189283087849617, 0.03341002017259598, 0.03667600080370903, 0.05810319632291794, 0.013633305206894875, 0.03722018003463745, 0.07058799266815186, -0.04539858549833298, -0.0387241430580616 ]
166
166
Efficient Exact Inference in Planar Ising Models
We give polynomial-time algorithms for the exact computation of lowest-energy (ground) states, worst margin violators, log partition functions, and marginal edge probabilities in certain binary undirected graphical models. Our approach provides an interesting alternative to the well-known graph cut paradigm in that it does not impose any submodularity constraints; instead we require planarity to establish a correspondence with perfect matchings (dimer coverings) in an expanded dual graph. We implement a unified framework while delegating complex but well-understood subproblems (planar embedding, maximum-weight perfect matching) to established algorithms for which efficient implementations are freely available. Unlike graph cut methods, we can perform penalized maximum-likelihood as well as maximum-margin parameter estimation in the associated conditional random fields (CRFs), and employ marginal posterior probabilities as well as maximum a posteriori (MAP) states for prediction. Maximum-margin CRF parameter estimation on image denoising and segmentation problems shows our approach to be efficient and effective. A C++ implementation is available from http://nic.schraudolph.org/isinf/
[ -0.01629483699798584, -0.07663381844758987, 0.08333398401737213, 0.02272298000752926, -0.0218837708234787, -0.024742024019360542, 0.06938197463750839, -0.030545301735401154, -0.015265663154423237, 0.005311345681548119, -0.042800452560186386, -0.07757020741701126, -0.028174616396427155, 0.017676759511232376, 0.06693575531244278, 0.06662963330745697, -0.03489648550748825, -0.015232258476316929, -0.0017287868540734053, 0.005388607736676931, -0.027746757492423058, 0.05944064259529114, 0.049036987125873566, 0.010042866691946983, 0.006714648567140102, -0.008074394427239895, 0.007491810712963343, 0.03447602316737175, -0.04408016428351402, 0.015858778730034828, -0.03627469018101692, 0.015748407691717148, -0.06290899962186813, 0.0007010013796389103, 0.027150236070156097, -0.04127082973718643, 0.05343685299158096, -0.058196403086185455, 0.014051360078155994, -0.0458473339676857, 0.05811548978090286, 0.01005270704627037, -0.06965426355600357, 0.01334382127970457, 0.030448907986283302, 0.002186013152822852, 0.010789093561470509, 0.022651148959994316, 0.01676139608025551, 0.05916094034910202, -0.06085113435983658, 0.04785804823040962, -0.01567988470196724, -0.03536718338727951, -0.002739398507401347, 0.025544896721839905, -0.039251916110515594, 0.026446448639035225, 0.012389866635203362, -0.00976979173719883, 0.07644619792699814, 0.09907226264476776, -0.03988925367593765, -0.024727214127779007, -0.07900473475456238, 0.000556530081667006, -0.009327080100774765, 0.005812636576592922, -0.041779354214668274, 0.017526166513562202, 0.03984512761235237, -0.028498122468590736, 0.08136967569589615, 0.06303813308477402, 0.0034608538262546062, -0.016401484608650208, 0.0007631015032529831, 0.0009406032622791827, 0.078367218375206, 0.13869179785251617, -0.045175034552812576, 0.058906666934490204, -0.029545262455940247, 0.035538021475076675, -0.052250321954488754, 0.10465262085199356, 0.019753457978367805, -0.006495218258351088, -0.07844660431146622, -0.022998880594968796, -0.0316416397690773, 0.018285835161805153, -0.02461385913193226, 0.10277973115444183, -0.12814949452877045, 0.06477978825569153, -0.029390769079327583, -0.02709279954433441, 0.027751879766583443, 0.05787333846092224, -0.008385302498936653, -0.04162115603685379, -0.027707824483513832, 0.05765986442565918, -0.0946994349360466, -0.0084805553779006, -0.01073573436588049, -0.04157986864447594, 0.07198116928339005, -0.059534426778554916, 0.015658125281333923, -0.03118234872817993, -0.02005062811076641, 0.02994127757847309, -0.05574112758040428, -0.007724004797637463, -0.04607153311371803, 0.07998385280370712, 0.007308919448405504, 0.04768333584070206, -0.0709112286567688, -0.032501015812158585, -0.04453497380018234, -0.0016771871596574783, -0.00606239540502429, -0.0564495250582695, -0.06955774128437042, -0.0648735761642456, 0.1046530157327652, -0.026771845296025276, -0.08821897953748703, 0.01044685859233141, -0.010156151838600636, 0.0399894192814827, -0.13491575419902802, 0.03474360331892967, 0.056891296058893204, 0.023499634116888046, -0.015467675402760506, 0.09589013457298279, -0.024888191372156143, 0.009937637485563755, 0.05996120348572731, 0.010565359145402908, -0.024160020053386688, 0.08457913994789124, 0.008705795742571354, 0.0059585850685834885, -0.01314164325594902, -0.024828070774674416, 0.013394013978540897, -0.06354060769081116, 0.03695662319660187, 0.05313355103135109, -0.003643784672021866, -0.034184686839580536, 0.023991450667381287, -0.025123953819274902, -0.01958266831934452, -0.019431976601481438, -0.024878695607185364, -0.056608956307172775, -0.003921119030565023, 0.10538171231746674, 0.007650190498679876, -0.05962461233139038, 0.018716756254434586, 0.001990247517824173, 0.03636454418301582, 0.014383392408490181, 0.035599615424871445, 0.00773866381496191, -0.01759222149848938, 0.04064609110355377, 0.04281984642148018, -0.0018448479240760207, -0.01898469775915146, 0.038308460265398026, -0.03624716401100159, 0.008210700936615467, 0.05917193368077278, -0.021982012316584587, 0.05166689306497574, 0.045146193355321884, 0.03943333029747009, 0.08295271545648575, -0.06659688800573349, 0.016490114852786064, 0.0801219642162323, 0.07800685614347458, 0.042525142431259155, 0.029527951031923294, 0.03751242160797119, 0.045861389487981796, -0.0363566018640995, 0.08707502484321594, -0.040697284042835236, 0.026460198685526848, 0.013094866648316383, 0.015409402549266815, 0.04438532143831253, 0.015439246781170368, -0.0449756495654583, -0.07391192018985748, -0.016816796734929085, 0.013441815041005611, 0.025405144318938255, -0.06119348481297493, -0.022465720772743225, 0.02162349969148636, 0.05815768241882324, -0.041048988699913025, -0.008430051617324352, 0.04695380479097366, 0.015547382645308971, -0.06845448166131973, 0.0014972309581935406, 0.0041683129966259, -0.01267934124916792, 0.016587842255830765, 0.03805326297879219, 0.04495370388031006, -0.058625925332307816, 0.058219507336616516, -0.06989861279726028, -0.011487589217722416, 0.03720906376838684, -0.018528349697589874, -0.042846158146858215, 0.04880518466234207, 0.0008407963323406875, -0.006860166788101196, -0.0037776276003569365, 0.004554642364382744, -0.023697316646575928, 0.056666649878025055, -0.030299950391054153, -0.027720721438527107, -0.015335604548454285, 0.023172739893198013, -0.03546253219246864, 0.06434886157512665, 0.05531857907772064, -0.024146294221282005, -0.010345938615500927, -0.005612532142549753, -0.012677536346018314, 0.10250423103570938, 0.05162160098552704, 0.03318104147911072, -0.07474347949028015, 0.019401876255869865, 0.02781330607831478, -0.025337761268019676, 0.03281552344560623, -0.029774338006973267, -0.036858364939689636, 0.0291809793561697, 0.07334297895431519, 0.10713152587413788, 0.046587854623794556, 0.006202160846441984, -0.056073013693094254, -0.06026366725564003, 0.06742576509714127, 0.0748729482293129, 0.0441054068505764, -0.05914987623691559, 0.04214727506041527, -0.03479640185832977, -0.034402620047330856, -0.02719690650701523, -0.05244116857647896, 0.049295973032712936, 0.058722615242004395, 0.05181535705924034, -0.024774163961410522, 0.02225085161626339, -0.058160703629255295, 0.025679469108581543, -0.018242351710796356, -0.03891364485025406, 0.02476222813129425, -0.036528199911117554, -0.0004646250745281577, 0.055192336440086365, -0.042591504752635956, 0.051694612950086594, 0.053359709680080414, 0.043910861015319824, -0.0755174309015274, -0.015249261632561684, 0.0029412764124572277, -0.0020536601077765226, 0.012665482237935066, -0.04751482233405113, 0.01968362182378769, -0.0018051274819299579, 0.007401959504932165, -0.008192082867026329, 0.007341574877500534, 0.0388842448592186, 0.025993244722485542, -0.029981153085827827, 0.025653889402747154, -0.00015821214765310287, 0.0724969208240509, -0.051575951278209686, -0.06189757212996483, -0.004180555697530508, 0.034122660756111145, 0.0485355518758297, -0.03626830875873566, -0.07006163895130157, 0.03771428391337395, -0.017356785014271736, -0.03066415898501873, -0.024550866335630417, -0.03828840330243111, 0.034908127039670944, -0.028619978576898575, 0.006693943869322538, 0.00504967849701643, -0.014701278880238533, -0.06726071983575821, -0.005774992983788252, -0.029922494664788246, 0.08382169157266617, -0.0491313636302948, 0.01809777319431305, -0.05155888572335243, -0.035726744681596756, -0.059683658182621, 0.04680447280406952, 0.029386071488261223, 0.00816513691097498, 0.021210622042417526, -0.03456881269812584, -0.02241087518632412, -0.005295085720717907, -0.0644235759973526, -0.09569921344518661, -0.009568480774760246, -0.04909085854887962, 0.02081131935119629, 0.04828580841422081, 0.008624283596873283, 0.006665796972811222, -0.024192294105887413, -0.00039603025652468204, -0.047506991773843765, 0.0390884168446064, -0.0072354525327682495, 0.038705822080373764, 0.037246186286211014, 0.07970644533634186, 0.10375764220952988, 0.022363215684890747, -0.04616411402821541, -0.0016448270762339234, -0.07690838724374771, -0.011446927674114704, 0.05494574084877968, 0.019635263830423355, 0.03854387626051903, 0.05354057624936104, -0.09221415966749191, 0.015243441797792912, 0.006471970584243536, 0.07011264562606812, -0.032401103526353836, 0.019859543070197105, 0.002501336857676506, -0.03554414585232735, 0.07496330887079239, 0.052838284522295, 0.06544876843690872, -0.07215376198291779, 0.018228044733405113, 0.01601293869316578, -0.037403229624032974, -0.02031547576189041, 0.014824729412794113, -0.013361715711653233, -0.038241468369960785, -0.058229733258485794, -0.023675158619880676, 0.0172056145966053, 0.07619838416576385, -0.000410906330216676, 0.029402485117316246, 0.012176764197647572, -0.0000893452379386872, 0.010457554832100868, 0.0703076645731926, -0.03179914504289627, -0.061708904802799225, 0.09062730520963669, 0.01190850231796503, -0.01971355639398098, 0.0031127615366131067, -0.07001093029975891, 0.05336093157529831, -0.08404769748449326, 0.00017836542974691838, -0.019432034343481064, 0.036957744508981705, -0.03653216361999512, 0.016587989404797554, 0.07014081627130508, 0.08606255054473877, 0.03669309988617897, 0.01786249317228794, -0.04901747405529022, 0.007137907203286886, 0.0330267995595932, 0.029375942423939705, 0.00514391390606761, 0.012500681914389133, -0.0154328104108572, 0.04351937398314476, 0.024766696617007256, 0.015361648052930832, -0.03805653378367424, -0.04318208619952202, 0.007799025624990463, 0.03107461892068386, 0.08004390448331833, -0.04892299324274063, -0.00744644133374095, -0.05095309764146805, -0.07245474308729172, -0.03378189355134964, 0.013509603217244148, 0.004135678522288799, -0.014039717614650726, 0.03192928805947304, -0.05885425582528114, 0.0055638873018324375, 0.03177238255739212, 0.05339229479432106, 0.041416652500629425, -0.012496188282966614, 0.025036390870809555, -0.017224498093128204, -0.018056785687804222, 0.07312490046024323, 0.008452383801341057, 0.10337361693382263, -0.01731136068701744, -0.02487589232623577, 0.06002497300505638, 0.06865125894546509, 0.026117611676454544, -0.04918890818953514, -0.009305576793849468, -0.01433208491653204, -0.04870408773422241, 0.03774719685316086, -0.04001396894454956, -0.010452344082295895, -0.020999949425458908, 0.040250733494758606, 0.03611007332801819, -0.06164320185780525, 0.021102003753185272, -0.04225790873169899, 0.05243029445409775, 0.08259075880050659, 0.005719055887311697, -0.05512410029768944, 0.01722104288637638, 0.049000199884176254, -0.020251460373401642, -0.010272996500134468, -0.02602394111454487, 0.029268896207213402, 0.00565110519528389, 0.012018389999866486, -0.013447106815874577, 0.0402039997279644, 0.027432918548583984, -0.06268803775310516, -0.08999272435903549, 0.01790025271475315, 0.048690326511859894, -0.015031714923679829, -0.03852415457367897, 0.05781608819961548, 0.009935564361512661, -0.007465717848390341, -0.011419866234064102, 0.030616089701652527, 0.02835097163915634, -0.01926794834434986, 0.021464163437485695, 0.07090739905834198, 0.01199615839868784, 0.054799724370241165, -0.037389326840639114, 0.016440292820334435, 0.026147516444325447, 0.05001075565814972, 0.027124784886837006, 0.09691928327083588, 0.024251138791441917, 0.02539418265223503, -0.012608305551111698, -0.04459458589553833, -0.0008497217204421759, 0.0033873082138597965, 0.028296707198023796 ]
167
167
Learning Isometric Separation Maps
Maximum Variance Unfolding (MVU) and its variants have been very successful in embedding data-manifolds in lower dimensional spaces, often revealing the true intrinsic dimension. In this paper we show how to also incorporate supervised class information into an MVU-like method without breaking its convexity. We call this method the Isometric Separation Map and we show that the resulting kernel matrix can be used as a binary/multiclass Support Vector Machine-like method in a semi-supervised (transductive) framework. We also show that the method always finds a kernel matrix that linearly separates the training data exactly without projecting them in infinite dimensional spaces. In traditional SVMs we choose a kernel and hope that the data become linearly separable in the kernel space. In this paper we show how the hyperplane can be chosen ad-hoc and the kernel is trained so that data are always linearly separable. Comparisons with Large Margin SVMs show comparable performance.
[ -0.013503379188477993, -0.02371511608362198, 0.021860480308532715, 0.03412340581417084, -0.049001965671777725, -0.026477573439478874, -0.016434993594884872, -0.012578357011079788, -0.04214920476078987, 0.026875725015997887, -0.016469409689307213, 0.05669141188263893, -0.05422461777925491, 0.012037904933094978, -0.00243853940628469, 0.03624190390110016, 0.04661460220813751, 0.05013468861579895, -0.029520899057388306, -0.060926780104637146, -0.00037440983578562737, 0.0011636413400992751, 0.059559617191553116, -0.039776790887117386, -0.013214259408414364, 0.061010170727968216, -0.00714906258508563, -0.049963779747486115, -0.00048411698662675917, 0.08484642952680588, -0.05666430667042732, -0.05171243101358414, -0.006650263909250498, -0.07287991046905518, -0.005604127421975136, 0.05614349991083145, 0.046138450503349304, -0.06697112321853638, -0.057993099093437195, -0.00873138289898634, -0.03930915519595146, 0.07254121452569962, 0.002865185961127281, -0.013303900137543678, 0.019075393676757812, 0.05485616624355316, -0.04911006614565849, -0.022735079750418663, -0.005855894647538662, 0.07319653779268265, -0.11244738101959229, 0.05262339487671852, -0.0809219554066658, 0.014589481987059116, 0.015432768501341343, 0.0022708442993462086, -0.008983368054032326, 0.0355265773832798, 0.025449275970458984, 0.0505831316113472, 0.06237770617008209, 0.0927843526005745, 0.016590844839811325, 0.003561094170436263, 0.0063811070285737514, -0.06809675693511963, -0.057862572371959686, -0.09054913371801376, 0.004147991072386503, -0.030987419188022614, 0.0043727802112698555, -0.02538861520588398, 0.0252511166036129, 0.0630694106221199, 0.06597863137722015, -0.0005702023627236485, 0.003680233610793948, 0.02505713701248169, -0.0166169386357069, 0.054728005081415176, -0.012929417192935944, -0.017968200147151947, 0.07748632878065109, 0.03645188733935356, -0.009395845234394073, 0.025911370292305946, 0.013789189048111439, 0.0028521462809294462, 0.00035588827449828386, -0.020664894953370094, 0.017797162756323814, -0.017293604090809822, -0.016746198758482933, 0.045143287628889084, -0.03322837874293327, -0.03664986416697502, -0.00617289450019598, -0.08922610431909561, 0.04067869111895561, 0.02642037533223629, -0.028563018888235092, 0.04039386287331581, 0.028064044192433357, 0.015096429735422134, -0.018922608345746994, -0.004931369796395302, -0.049237411469221115, 0.08602280169725418, -0.02657013013958931, -0.01536454539746046, 0.02119491808116436, -0.04340571165084839, 0.03204422444105148, 0.011093302629888058, 0.021172545850276947, 0.020151132717728615, -0.02497478388249874, 0.06350374966859818, 0.042701318860054016, 0.03954505920410156, -0.022109080106019974, 0.009512772783637047, 0.05363108962774277, -0.01933770254254341, 0.036780279129743576, -0.028835229575634003, 0.02059091255068779, -0.059746742248535156, 0.10154026746749878, -0.06096538528800011, -0.10632507503032684, 0.05354919657111168, -0.03388785943388939, 0.08457529544830322, -0.015084873884916306, 0.02803838811814785, -0.0054583679884672165, -0.013826744630932808, -0.048438671976327896, 0.08392008394002914, 0.0232919342815876, 0.050006233155727386, -0.002344982698559761, 0.025916943326592445, 0.026889536529779434, -0.009562976658344269, -0.02005886286497116, 0.04161382094025612, 0.05087238550186157, -0.05130394920706749, -0.05246317386627197, -0.03584872931241989, 0.04897548630833626, 0.057996250689029694, 0.030883729457855225, -0.07160402834415436, 0.01108400709927082, 0.0051678079180419445, 0.030045870691537857, 0.0510866679251194, -0.06412872672080994, 0.014356539584696293, 0.02513228915631771, 0.05255508050322533, -0.005711403675377369, -0.04355257749557495, 0.07737752050161362, -0.0008131810463964939, -0.06518132239580154, -0.09223288297653198, 0.0036601617466658354, 0.0007425299263559282, 0.0131272803992033, -0.01613702066242695, 0.009100363589823246, -0.049263257533311844, -0.0645151287317276, 0.05330808088183403, 0.018371641635894775, 0.0070316302590072155, -0.013424064964056015, 0.002604606095701456, -0.05438770353794098, 0.008983870036900043, 0.059629764407873154, 0.04887472465634346, -0.022989938035607338, 0.01654011942446232, 0.06545840948820114, 0.025514204055070877, 0.07600662112236023, -0.023761887103319168, 0.032068707048892975, -0.04547930881381035, -0.021789144724607468, 0.02957192249596119, 0.008426795713603497, -0.0025193283800035715, 0.06531921029090881, 0.02930990234017372, 0.05201880261301994, -0.03459365665912628, -0.004049163777381182, -0.049149736762046814, -0.016100935637950897, -0.0033143251203000546, 0.027866633608937263, 0.0073960935696959496, 0.006917879451066256, 0.011195571161806583, -0.04874284565448761, 0.026217252016067505, 0.019494179636240005, -0.01193016953766346, 0.011387922801077366, -0.054206546396017075, 0.021954555064439774, -0.04364464804530144, -0.002032063901424408, 0.08811881393194199, 0.01679149456322193, 0.03559653088450432, 0.003904369194060564, 0.0499601736664772, -0.0029034786857664585, -0.018259776756167412, -0.035777706652879715, -0.049307696521282196, -0.05860237777233124, 0.037875283509492874, -0.06294145435094833, -0.08519166707992554, -0.06824693083763123, -0.06331457942724228, 0.01455660630017519, 0.050215426832437515, -0.052066657692193985, -0.036773066967725754, 0.10128827393054962, -0.03285533934831619, 0.01688532344996929, -0.010016967542469501, 0.014823133125901222, -0.00565577344968915, -0.03144705295562744, -0.0446416512131691, 0.03821608051657677, 0.06952180713415146, -0.012159631587564945, 0.03563717007637024, -0.001083817915059626, 0.03320187330245972, -0.0076554627157747746, -0.05544241517782211, -0.0625138059258461, -0.08036398887634277, -0.03524253889918327, -0.0033597047440707684, 0.03432942554354668, 0.06947119534015656, 0.0646432414650917, -0.035029493272304535, -0.0006844163872301579, -0.05428316071629524, 0.12053751945495605, 0.03321649134159088, -0.004992141388356686, 0.03227163106203079, -0.0016876388108357787, 0.029278753325343132, -0.01551000215113163, -0.05763914808630943, -0.00009662707452662289, 0.03313961252570152, -0.06171290948987007, 0.04736315831542015, 0.03402714058756828, 0.04812997207045555, 0.025326628237962723, -0.0305497869849205, -0.015874525532126427, 0.04634283110499382, -0.020792558789253235, -0.06017088145017624, -0.08725830167531967, -0.07460260391235352, 0.045519132167100906, 0.046891506761312485, 0.03749143332242966, 0.071971595287323, -0.035209689289331436, 0.010722788982093334, -0.02961016073822975, -0.0379595085978508, 0.06571691483259201, -0.055478665977716446, 0.009632077068090439, 0.013234943151473999, 0.020283745601773262, -0.010512523353099823, 0.1205470860004425, 0.005409296602010727, 0.033829350024461746, -0.04187668114900589, 0.04489155486226082, 0.039706554263830185, 0.06245553493499756, -0.0007886599632911384, -0.01935720443725586, -0.03358893841505051, -0.009981779381632805, -0.03529808297753334, 0.04946045204997063, -0.07446012645959854, -0.032132670283317566, -0.07533838599920273, -0.03697463124990463, 0.02164323255419731, 0.00957303587347269, 0.009790956042706966, 0.029313188046216965, 0.06400661170482635, 0.0026671243831515312, -0.06902985274791718, -0.07730887830257416, -0.06197400391101837, -0.03499143198132515, 0.01656646467745304, -0.09047624468803406, -0.013224759139120579, -0.08133606612682343, -0.12773674726486206, -0.031809624284505844, 0.0829315185546875, 0.029220499098300934, -0.038866616785526276, 0.025244321674108505, -0.054115261882543564, -0.010541551746428013, -0.05582716688513756, -0.04764280840754509, -0.06430862098932266, 0.0344218946993351, -0.058895617723464966, -0.01833702065050602, 0.06366555392742157, 0.04576492682099342, -0.01858140528202057, -0.016342591494321823, 0.05549541488289833, 0.021459024399518967, 0.002768920734524727, -0.05431715026497841, 0.06645449995994568, -0.03371325880289078, 0.03846181184053421, 0.06179415062069893, -0.0027737426571547985, -0.025276655331254005, -0.011162547394633293, 0.01390128955245018, -0.04144807904958725, -0.019647132605314255, 0.008934942074120045, 0.03264974430203438, 0.05592038482427597, 0.00036709531559608877, 0.04316382482647896, 0.004500080365687609, -0.009178826585412025, -0.06366975605487823, 0.032406143844127655, 0.04956541582942009, 0.009522837586700916, 0.01689712330698967, -0.006603330839425325, 0.024968083947896957, -0.00869614165276289, -0.05993049219250679, 0.016243331134319305, 0.02065611630678177, -0.02597900480031967, -0.021624304354190826, 0.04263775423169136, -0.080703504383564, -0.03440630063414574, -0.025922177359461784, 0.013449679128825665, 0.04052424058318138, 0.006345025729387999, -0.05651647225022316, 0.008082329295575619, -0.010268195532262325, 0.005918854847550392, 0.11212700605392456, 0.039000254124403, -0.04405685514211655, -0.04637530818581581, -0.04933660849928856, 0.011040831916034222, -0.02740342542529106, 0.017765996977686882, -0.011251043528318405, -0.0427045002579689, 0.003200926585122943, -0.030251353979110718, -0.029937099665403366, 0.030028054490685463, 0.004220058675855398, 0.07769633829593658, 0.017291614785790443, 0.008131839334964752, -0.016714023426175117, 0.04508478567004204, 0.027918066829442978, 0.05587862804532051, -0.06462851911783218, 0.03065422549843788, 0.03837261721491814, -0.06560362875461578, 0.01764036901295185, 0.04832727089524269, -0.010843605734407902, -0.059221044182777405, -0.039801597595214844, 0.026783108711242676, 0.020444685593247414, 0.1136178970336914, -0.013141172006726265, -0.01638844422996044, -0.08860262483358383, -0.0036080400459468365, -0.013391146436333656, -0.04654325544834137, 0.09235798567533493, 0.0057108644396066666, 0.07933098822832108, -0.06831751763820648, 0.032555412501096725, 0.028742916882038116, -0.07902368903160095, 0.09119579195976257, 0.0023404129315167665, -0.02338602766394615, -0.01745280623435974, 0.02545633353292942, 0.03845692053437233, 0.019652411341667175, 0.07453601062297821, 0.06311889737844467, -0.03772163391113281, 0.01654793508350849, -0.004876451566815376, -0.029415015131235123, 0.009751072153449059, -0.016363007947802544, 0.030853740870952606, -0.07790862768888474, 0.009575670585036278, -0.0075123305432498455, -0.01792174018919468, -0.03693276271224022, -0.0009348246967419982, 0.026752900332212448, -0.08324580639600754, 0.018117189407348633, 0.002872766926884651, 0.0595698244869709, 0.039220504462718964, 0.013325583189725876, -0.04374602437019348, -0.02349836379289627, 0.07177334278821945, -0.034557946026325226, 0.08640586584806442, -0.0419609434902668, -0.0020974662620574236, -0.06064234673976898, -0.0716727152466774, -0.06659211218357086, -0.006116613280028105, -0.0568954236805439, -0.027275560423731804, -0.038053397089242935, 0.0034184325486421585, 0.02229098603129387, -0.02466743253171444, -0.015122944489121437, 0.055958181619644165, 0.027152422815561295, 0.019745009019970894, 0.05749902129173279, -0.007331063039600849, -0.014135695062577724, 0.009663501754403114, 0.0004120744706597179, -0.06267740577459335, 0.037260644137859344, -0.017913032323122025, -0.025680148974061012, -0.021695755422115326, -0.06027881056070328, 0.03913090378046036, -0.02878507971763611, 0.1437445878982544, 0.023894278332591057, 0.054704807698726654, -0.015887564048171043, -0.052691202610731125, 0.0841081365942955, 0.0061912015080451965, -0.0361807644367218 ]
168
168
A Novel Clustering Algorithm Based on a Modified Model of Random Walk
We introduce a modified model of random walk, and then develop two novel clustering algorithms based on it. In the algorithms, each data point in a dataset is considered as a particle which can move at random in space according to the preset rules in the modified model. Further, this data point may be also viewed as a local control subsystem, in which the controller adjusts its transition probability vector in terms of the feedbacks of all data points, and then its transition direction is identified by an event-generating function. Finally, the positions of all data points are updated. As they move in space, data points collect gradually and some separating parts emerge among them automatically. As a consequence, data points that belong to the same class are located at a same position, whereas those that belong to different classes are away from one another. Moreover, the experimental results have demonstrated that data points in the test datasets are clustered reasonably and efficiently, and the comparison with other algorithms also provides an indication of the effectiveness of the proposed algorithms.
[ -0.03909580409526825, -0.053726233541965485, -0.014584837481379509, 0.02557949163019657, 0.04862814396619797, -0.04476704075932503, -0.048885878175497055, 0.010416637174785137, -0.03935089707374573, 0.04321597144007683, -0.012772081419825554, -0.008849590085446835, -0.02172798663377762, -0.02590840682387352, -0.020675132051110268, 0.011284655891358852, -0.020721405744552612, 0.026482166722416878, 0.001871165237389505, -0.07553869485855103, 0.020907333120703697, -0.04564686864614487, 0.0560288242995739, 0.035254158079624176, -0.00704666692763567, -0.06938587874174118, -0.0027188556268811226, -0.01125625055283308, -0.016436729580163956, -0.03556835278868675, 0.015210621058940887, 0.002043718472123146, 0.030652502551674843, 0.010223307646811008, 0.06363651156425476, -0.02093757502734661, -0.007964721880853176, 0.03602309897542, -0.05273601412773132, 0.018228542059659958, -0.0175704974681139, -0.009394990280270576, 0.004289109725505114, 0.02844989113509655, -0.027315787971019745, 0.01339203305542469, -0.015042534098029137, 0.07305767387151718, -0.02442510984838009, 0.05160748213529587, -0.07977404445409775, 0.00645366869866848, -0.05117703974246979, -0.007633810397237539, -0.0612766370177269, 0.0276245828717947, -0.07271081209182739, 0.027854088693857193, -0.09435942769050598, -0.05301544815301895, 0.04671121761202812, 0.07761579006910324, -0.031715355813503265, -0.05711900815367699, 0.028943054378032684, 0.0010467064566910267, 0.058948539197444916, -0.05986781418323517, 0.013593465089797974, -0.020959163084626198, 0.047299593687057495, 0.014382322318851948, -0.009216135367751122, -0.018334465101361275, -0.07674457877874374, 0.007491555530577898, 0.005476480349898338, 0.02127566933631897, 0.003829935798421502, 0.024867143481969833, -0.039777979254722595, -0.03640861436724663, -0.03505323454737663, 0.03978802636265755, -0.030857613310217857, -0.01444422546774149, 0.002120044780895114, -0.03151802346110344, 0.0004892314318567514, -0.06547504663467407, -0.0335967019200325, -0.0247868150472641, -0.07815169543027878, 0.018904218450188637, -0.06695245206356049, 0.048189375549554825, -0.031513016670942307, -0.017054826021194458, 0.10305880755186081, 0.11110403388738632, -0.06600062549114227, -0.0267807487398386, 0.05067548155784607, 0.06730645895004272, 0.0083477683365345, 0.017628589645028114, -0.06508100777864456, 0.0337320901453495, 0.016716111451387405, -0.011995705775916576, 0.05090660601854324, -0.009364919736981392, -0.022208118811249733, 0.07616376876831055, -0.008240869268774986, 0.05648540332913399, 0.003978922497481108, 0.05536956340074539, -0.05918961763381958, -0.014417359605431557, 0.025949891656637192, -0.019346706569194794, 0.004540300462394953, 0.005942597519606352, -0.03069048933684826, -0.026274695992469788, -0.03983202949166298, -0.018298272043466568, 0.084266796708107, -0.004505862481892109, -0.11802691221237183, 0.02030516415834427, -0.057834550738334656, -0.022175859659910202, -0.02717355638742447, -0.00914572924375534, 0.027463644742965698, -0.03355413302779198, 0.034233562648296356, 0.04550806060433388, 0.006389339920133352, -0.034843992441892624, -0.08348705619573593, 0.04513681307435036, 0.026008134707808495, 0.016682054847478867, -0.004592817276716232, 0.08975198864936829, 0.039787452667951584, 0.08516343683004379, -0.04972217604517937, -0.050051480531692505, -0.017920034006237984, 0.006599202752113342, 0.04376112297177315, 0.000266905379248783, -0.06285310536623001, -0.013988477177917957, -0.05161571130156517, 0.08815386146306992, -0.04092903435230255, 0.03525439277291298, -0.05095765367150307, -0.03776509314775467, -0.01662001945078373, 0.008837207220494747, -0.05721844732761383, -0.024143734946846962, -0.0350276418030262, -0.03984450921416283, 0.045243505388498306, 0.014490243047475815, -0.014356580562889576, 0.0077133080922067165, 0.048499710857868195, -0.06239917874336243, -0.06741373240947723, -0.010358041152358055, 0.024398738518357277, -0.013713072054088116, 0.04626396298408508, -0.047024261206388474, -0.03292999044060707, 0.10561948269605637, 0.027592089027166367, 0.14750069379806519, 0.034692153334617615, 0.08336905390024185, 0.05002103000879288, -0.006276959553360939, 0.0008219033479690552, 0.04416852816939354, 0.04227888956665993, -0.06263548135757446, -0.12111883610486984, 0.07508359104394913, 0.017514752224087715, -0.06579510867595673, 0.07634135335683823, 0.047870781272649765, -0.024696161970496178, 0.05613851174712181, -0.0989917740225792, -0.007053421810269356, -0.0169826727360487, -0.024156033992767334, 0.07531905919313431, -0.03422681242227554, -0.002373984782025218, -0.05122268199920654, -0.021865738555788994, -0.044613540172576904, 0.01174069195985794, -0.07165486365556717, 0.019024448469281197, -0.024774722754955292, -0.0807684063911438, -0.06044671684503555, 0.0476032979786396, 0.04278533533215523, -0.07929056882858276, 0.0002686556545086205, -0.09381452202796936, 0.06142923980951309, -0.06202666088938713, 0.0016699235420674086, 0.06598210334777832, -0.027238743379712105, -0.06747713685035706, 0.0010904164519160986, -0.06386704742908478, -0.044644132256507874, -0.006261604372411966, 0.059761639684438705, -0.006612173747271299, 0.022503552958369255, -0.028712039813399315, -0.047069840133190155, 0.007160106673836708, -0.019765859469771385, -0.06240411847829819, 0.04803783819079399, -0.022240050137043, -0.04238349199295044, 0.05978908762335777, -0.01584131270647049, -0.010186753235757351, 0.10607585310935974, -0.054614268243312836, 0.029723023995757103, 0.009152420796453953, 0.030118947848677635, 0.011530539952218533, -0.042908672243356705, 0.031325630843639374, -0.005139265675097704, -0.05648311600089073, -0.005908316466957331, 0.07509053498506546, 0.03267238289117813, 0.04374470189213753, 0.0445365235209465, -0.0056016650050878525, 0.0026034056209027767, 0.060575149953365326, 0.026274075731635094, 0.03019973635673523, 0.026185210794210434, 0.029368679970502853, -0.03880002349615097, 0.0056739430874586105, -0.10745012015104294, -0.10076680034399033, 0.05473051220178604, -0.06738292425870895, -0.010946533642709255, 0.0005887807928957045, 0.004246271215379238, -0.035838183015584946, -0.06682897359132767, -0.03063729591667652, 0.027756555005908012, 0.03343215584754944, -0.05789376050233841, -0.011053516529500484, 0.022624535486102104, -0.05894334986805916, -0.03500979766249657, -0.017126699909567833, 0.016175149008631706, -0.029417628422379494, 0.04025654122233391, -0.05402758717536926, -0.089517742395401, 0.022583745419979095, -0.07324077934026718, 0.0150092588737607, 0.0426156185567379, 0.07523622363805771, 0.019208483397960663, 0.012390135787427425, 0.008444632403552532, -0.008636247366666794, 0.0735967755317688, -0.010836731642484665, 0.028874723240733147, 0.096840038895607, 0.0878407284617424, -0.04801463335752487, 0.07250520586967468, -0.022581681609153748, 0.055553559213876724, -0.044778089970350266, -0.026727765798568726, 0.006581700872629881, 0.058569714426994324, 0.008338617160916328, 0.0034671705216169357, 0.011477146297693253, 0.03084828332066536, 0.07700396329164505, -0.03299085423350334, 0.034463439136743546, -0.0028059312608093023, -0.053195226937532425, -0.017231015488505363, 0.019933700561523438, -0.015717199072241783, 0.005762180779129267, 0.005746694281697273, -0.03826317563652992, 0.053986966609954834, -0.05167092755436897, 0.03999783843755722, -0.04173309728503227, -0.04534563422203064, 0.014300495386123657, 0.014258923940360546, 0.05465931445360184, 0.0029341767076402903, -0.0017067177686840296, 0.0037602430675178766, 0.06495878845453262, -0.04294314980506897, -0.007359372451901436, 0.059836503118276596, 0.021258722990751266, -0.017892539501190186, 0.02406376786530018, -0.06260188668966293, -0.04480516165494919, 0.024494076147675514, -0.07803263515233994, 0.018854577094316483, -0.025809427723288536, 0.052240584045648575, 0.041631583124399185, 0.040549084544181824, 0.004939386621117592, -0.02925017476081848, 0.016125788912177086, 0.02531576156616211, -0.012941667810082436, 0.0032691489905118942, -0.041051872074604034, 0.04668371379375458, -0.008631276898086071, -0.007300932426005602, -0.01093685906380415, -0.08338001370429993, 0.054384201765060425, -0.008326539769768715, -0.010983359068632126, 0.013940484263002872, 0.03367822989821434, -0.04300147294998169, 0.026846233755350113, -0.017013350501656532, -0.013395599089562893, 0.07818122953176498, 0.0029251286759972572, 0.037260379642248154, -0.02299167774617672, -0.01650877483189106, 0.012640558183193207, -0.008859066292643547, -0.007182140834629536, 0.019965853542089462, 0.01055615022778511, -0.004461735021322966, 0.0062979464419186115, -0.06071912869811058, 0.03794971853494644, 0.04293738305568695, -0.01013324037194252, -0.03792998939752579, 0.00888768956065178, -0.026091093197464943, -0.005944289267063141, -0.06172509863972664, 0.003750867210328579, -0.0925060510635376, -0.07241759449243546, -0.10297511518001556, -0.06933841109275818, -0.02302352711558342, -0.05106786638498306, 0.038649607449769974, 0.08531991392374039, 0.03270002827048302, -0.00868928898125887, -0.04529955983161926, -0.034042708575725555, -0.001300075906328857, -0.037288665771484375, 0.009797723032534122, -0.06724285334348679, 0.02441493235528469, 0.016910728067159653, -0.06032152101397514, -0.05959708243608475, 0.0134695153683424, 0.0507260225713253, 0.0007364749908447266, -0.00038702061283402145, 0.02721436507999897, 0.10278771817684174, 0.0686865970492363, 0.1100616604089737, 0.06521278619766235, -0.11077344417572021, 0.031284134835004807, 0.010172929614782333, -0.007322906516492367, 0.003759152488783002, -0.06202511116862297, -0.013548895716667175, -0.04851073399186134, -0.018877213820815086, 0.04967048391699791, 0.018758924677968025, -0.015302471816539764, -0.030797559767961502, -0.02021428383886814, 0.026991363614797592, 0.06252510845661163, 0.00828282255679369, -0.0020167988259345293, 0.04231303557753563, 0.05332797020673752, -0.0522121787071228, -0.009617401286959648, -0.009535161778330803, 0.049106549471616745, 0.07354911416769028, -0.012704937718808651, 0.03244020417332649, 0.03252933919429779, -0.005477637983858585, -0.0760752260684967, -0.08371543139219284, 0.0027122534811496735, -0.06302688270807266, 0.013071977533400059, -0.008992008864879608, 0.012050742283463478, 0.012635684572160244, -0.009276138618588448, 0.0404692217707634, 0.022967807948589325, -0.03483857214450836, -0.004103765357285738, -0.038435809314250946, -0.07587287575006485, -0.0100572369992733, -0.006508199963718653, 0.025553245097398758, -0.01554445642977953, -0.05391955003142357, -0.0075360797345638275, 0.03081589937210083, 0.02492040954530239, 0.021879971027374268, 0.017379600554704666, 0.019973024725914, -0.06573399156332016, -0.028101913630962372, 0.0040744212456047535, 0.03979792073369026, 0.014470127411186695, 0.024104204028844833, -0.021597832441329956, 0.00214827130548656, 0.04938754066824913, 0.006562278140336275, 0.005455565173178911, 0.028349729254841805, 0.045837923884391785, -0.024149782955646515, 0.04899649694561958, 0.042693957686424255, -0.058062031865119934, 0.02536742389202118, -0.014506966806948185, 0.06812175363302231, 0.05003490671515465, -0.002102235797792673, -0.05300882086157799, -0.027802346274256706, 0.10022629052400589, 0.022804001346230507, -0.0031960317865014076 ]
169
169
A Theory of Truncated Inverse Sampling
In this paper, we have established a new framework of truncated inverse sampling for estimating mean values of non-negative random variables such as binomial, Poisson, hyper-geometrical, and bounded variables. We have derived explicit formulas and computational methods for designing sampling schemes to ensure prescribed levels of precision and confidence for point estimators. Moreover, we have developed interval estimation methods.
[ -0.0397481694817543, 0.0398087352514267, 0.03024161048233509, -0.04508775472640991, -0.03534501791000366, -0.04723140969872475, 0.04453328624367714, 0.02431478537619114, -0.000991167384199798, -0.038085244596004486, -0.015530245378613472, -0.09163239598274231, -0.057789720594882965, 0.027677584439516068, -0.03517366573214531, 0.006440131459385157, 0.00026977600646205246, -0.047107577323913574, 0.010530213825404644, -0.07762078940868378, -0.04312952980399132, 0.012491867877542973, 0.013735953718423843, 0.019814837723970413, 0.06313049793243408, 0.0333799347281456, 0.06312849372625351, -0.049565114080905914, 0.012290877290070057, 0.0031677500810474157, -0.04988538846373558, 0.0019343431340530515, -0.06361229717731476, 0.01101749949157238, 0.04340716823935509, -0.008490298874676228, -0.000292737822746858, -0.022229574620723724, -0.021616825833916664, -0.013605063781142235, -0.02315366081893444, -0.013502337038516998, 0.017268748953938484, 0.02087530493736267, 0.035919491201639175, 0.07438758760690689, 0.0571405254304409, -0.00015832921781111509, -0.026262275874614716, 0.020881446078419685, -0.04762827977538109, 0.018267160281538963, -0.03538471460342407, -0.035075895488262177, 0.019744135439395905, -0.04496762901544571, 0.050625745207071304, 0.04240747168660164, -0.09697557985782623, 0.011045741848647594, 0.03666246682405472, 0.022452224045991898, 0.04601197689771652, -0.05793822184205055, -0.03126779943704605, 0.03957116976380348, -0.07998304814100266, -0.012835090979933739, -0.0028351801447570324, -0.07334699481725693, -0.018252922222018242, -0.04132914915680885, -0.010437213815748692, -0.05023619532585144, -0.0563480406999588, -0.009370316751301289, -0.021491514518857002, 0.006616406142711639, 0.07007618993520737, 0.018368834629654884, -0.03350578248500824, -0.016891557723283768, -0.031421761959791183, 0.015358231961727142, -0.06254872679710388, -0.02280477248132229, 0.046751417219638824, -0.04038267582654953, 0.024276932701468468, -0.06580626964569092, -0.03185828775167465, 0.022039297968149185, -0.13230887055397034, 0.0465669222176075, -0.07621347904205322, 0.06459444016218185, 0.04276348277926445, -0.010313906706869602, -0.03766526281833649, -0.023877659812569618, -0.015864670276641846, -0.14508457481861115, 0.08407631516456604, -0.03400060534477234, 0.050457123667001724, 0.04763419181108475, -0.07205840200185776, 0.010756585747003555, 0.030893540009856224, -0.012217478826642036, 0.0247102752327919, -0.018024306744337082, -0.013468044809997082, 0.05516485869884491, -0.07246381044387817, 0.05184933543205261, 0.044331908226013184, 0.01611095666885376, 0.054255411028862, -0.008303847163915634, 0.0805833637714386, 0.0004023076908197254, 0.00908605195581913, 0.051593244075775146, 0.017687750980257988, 0.007933450862765312, 0.022041073068976402, -0.030609292909502983, 0.07525893300771713, -0.008867363445460796, -0.0014239446027204394, 0.06550167500972748, -0.08157746493816376, 0.03991958126425743, -0.08772458136081696, 0.0003280077362433076, -0.03956617787480354, -0.023806091398000717, -0.04042799770832062, -0.002021013991907239, -0.010234944522380829, -0.04481520876288414, 0.017153464257717133, -0.009489336982369423, 0.045439463108778, 0.008046034723520279, -0.03716025501489639, 0.022946028038859367, -0.07984648644924164, 0.0252273790538311, -0.0896923765540123, -0.09087195247411728, -0.04013310745358467, 0.06602297723293304, 0.018189551308751106, 0.01268413569778204, -0.007079050876200199, -0.02211306057870388, -0.013363607227802277, 0.060016464442014694, -0.1184108704328537, 0.06726372241973877, 0.10098055750131607, 0.05814485251903534, -0.08173356205224991, 0.009889614768326283, 0.005305929109454155, -0.01697157323360443, 0.00564704742282629, -0.04497303068637848, -0.09561745077371597, -0.0020264284685254097, -0.007155970670282841, -0.0001955261977855116, -0.09039396792650223, -0.012774979695677757, 0.01485450193285942, -0.004697491880506277, -0.017831185832619667, -0.040075451135635376, 0.0312744677066803, -0.06218633055686951, -0.05644004046916962, -0.023525211960077286, -0.000816096318885684, 0.07616116851568222, -0.05369766056537628, 0.021905727684497833, 0.04949289560317993, -0.005799808539450169, 0.05909664183855057, -0.06924048811197281, -0.06517229229211807, -0.03045315481722355, -0.028730016201734543, -0.0033063918817788363, -0.0005265921354293823, 0.04494370147585869, 0.028349142521619797, 0.0794111117720604, -0.05676957964897156, -0.05254340544342995, -0.007556774187833071, 0.002710281405597925, -0.01910802349448204, 0.03709262236952782, 0.0038039872888475657, -0.06316152960062027, -0.0001448648690711707, -0.029094498604536057, -0.03253277763724327, -0.012161278165876865, -0.03867936506867409, -0.07247236371040344, 0.05311775207519531, -0.08587601035833359, 0.034919172525405884, -0.014551203697919846, 0.06237524002790451, 0.014837931841611862, 0.0020775911398231983, 0.014601696282625198, -0.09768267720937729, 0.037809740751981735, -0.003931354731321335, -0.06996127963066101, 0.018739983439445496, 0.028332548215985298, -0.04741169512271881, 0.022659679874777794, -0.00440575648099184, -0.023578204214572906, 0.023008620366454124, 0.009981311857700348, -0.015056444332003593, 0.028198888525366783, -0.01539382804185152, 0.03368726000189781, 0.009557696059346199, 0.013475866056978703, -0.014429056085646152, 0.04141981899738312, 0.0012720358790829778, -0.008841418661177158, -0.07034210115671158, -0.09361213445663452, 0.05034106224775314, 0.0952334925532341, 0.0010090154828503728, 0.05697385221719742, -0.010770986787974834, -0.0033758850768208504, -0.02148732729256153, 0.016740214079618454, -0.024717018008232117, 0.057419225573539734, -0.049911219626665115, -0.004558567889034748, 0.073023721575737, 0.08615302294492722, 0.011989716440439224, 0.018536170944571495, -0.08532670885324478, 0.02288629114627838, 0.0476418137550354, -0.004812175408005714, -0.066959448158741, 0.03618056699633598, 0.021039972081780434, -0.033191125839948654, 0.04521067067980766, -0.018893036991357803, -0.09760331362485886, -0.0257007647305727, -0.011327019892632961, -0.0567735880613327, 0.021500036120414734, 0.010677134618163109, -0.0009724169503897429, 0.02031777799129486, -0.06492412835359573, -0.021769987419247627, 0.007824939675629139, 0.019219523295760155, 0.015987826511263847, 0.07790204882621765, -0.005047458689659834, -0.0982961356639862, -0.030109480023384094, 0.04557425156235695, -0.009005310013890266, -0.0032725664786994457, -0.023561758920550346, -0.005806025117635727, 0.04666097089648247, 0.03038782998919487, 0.049170076847076416, -0.014536984264850616, 0.03889216482639313, 0.020377589389681816, -0.04552070423960686, 0.03601674735546112, 0.07842966914176941, 0.006071840412914753, -0.025548454374074936, 0.03538026660680771, 0.0777650773525238, 0.03100408799946308, -0.03614446893334389, 0.02054147981107235, -0.009604597464203835, -0.08185859024524689, -0.04304935410618782, 0.021323082968592644, -0.05824800580739975, -0.02573101595044136, -0.030873587355017662, -0.08349510282278061, -0.001708698458969593, 0.03216414898633957, 0.019627520814538002, 0.006370519287884235, -0.002868121722713113, -0.07989785820245743, -0.06631479412317276, 0.0011613252572715282, 0.01717381738126278, 0.05116193741559982, -0.02822241559624672, -0.05822649970650673, -0.02371141128242016, 0.021586818620562553, -0.029356403276324272, 0.10797658562660217, 0.028335656970739365, 0.045247871428728104, -0.0012479585129767656, -0.02481788955628872, 0.012164988555014133, -0.04961331933736801, -0.002688886132091284, -0.06408626586198807, 0.05111416056752205, -0.03290265053510666, -0.000011443295989010949, 0.04575598984956741, 0.0944838747382164, -0.024912744760513306, -0.04518451541662216, -0.00022089446429163218, -0.08050946146249771, -0.00502336909994483, -0.004885959904640913, 0.055107105523347855, -0.04032514616847038, 0.08161027729511261, 0.08348286896944046, 0.04148790240287781, -0.008797488175332546, 0.08012022078037262, -0.037298575043678284, 0.0007304658065550029, 0.035831332206726074, 0.01081864070147276, 0.029212014749646187, 0.033947255462408066, 0.009930135682225227, -0.0001975065388251096, -0.0043962812051177025, -0.013138758949935436, -0.025690509006381035, 0.007303686812520027, 0.05010002851486206, 0.06675369292497635, 0.04367092624306679, 0.04999613016843796, 0.04777314141392708, 0.030943749472498894, -0.002968789543956518, 0.029232820495963097, 0.039256248623132706, 0.013316838070750237, 0.02995275892317295, -0.010756648145616055, 0.004229851998388767, -0.0700644850730896, -0.01347378920763731, 0.0280055683106184, 0.0977608934044838, -0.002861312823370099, 0.0225942675024271, -0.03637569397687912, 0.021596521139144897, 0.044686459004879, 0.023842064663767815, 0.07093610614538193, -0.015605848282575607, -0.024939214810729027, -0.014663211070001125, -0.06712263822555542, -0.034215882420539856, -0.009943685494363308, -0.01395585760474205, -0.05924634262919426, -0.02918373793363571, -0.025626815855503082, -0.00986933521926403, 0.031956177204847336, -0.023521700873970985, 0.09134743362665176, -0.06702397763729095, 0.029659418389201164, 0.00247977371327579, 0.025349119678139687, -0.059952445328235626, 0.05615893378853798, -0.01579836569726467, -0.02768390253186226, -0.07441752403974533, 0.004849250428378582, -0.004952277522534132, 0.021004829555749893, -0.020341768860816956, 0.01442281436175108, 0.0491596981883049, -0.036092907190322876, 0.01984867826104164, 0.05073290690779686, 0.031604353338479996, -0.003499367507174611, -0.06356531381607056, -0.042196109890937805, 0.012434050440788269, -0.0007225445006042719, 0.017231957986950874, -0.04141325131058693, -0.0024129939265549183, 0.011690361425280571, -0.007192907389253378, -0.007102113217115402, -0.07372551411390305, 0.08116282522678375, -0.015820249915122986, -0.02183716744184494, -0.06260508298873901, 0.022169463336467743, 0.022250855341553688, -0.04726430028676987, 0.07795378565788269, 0.05678718909621239, 0.025483280420303345, 0.04407449811697006, 0.02396007999777794, -0.037952035665512085, 0.05528707802295685, 0.01669853925704956, -0.04589088261127472, -0.00891830027103424, 0.05513046681880951, -0.067017562687397, -0.07333636283874512, -0.023461176082491875, 0.00593196414411068, 0.0850922018289566, -0.11670808494091034, 0.05110633745789528, -0.015282728709280491, 0.07290805876255035, 0.035799216479063034, -0.04858986660838127, -0.04603724554181099, -0.015216951258480549, 0.04797932133078575, 0.03874707594513893, -0.0014857484493404627, -0.015792500227689743, 0.016255445778369904, -0.000012583866009663325, 0.01715807616710663, 0.012859281152486801, 0.00022420338063966483, -0.028477713465690613, -0.07387501746416092, 0.011077712289988995, -0.015275985933840275, 0.07612687349319458, 0.03796948492527008, 0.05115306004881859, 0.0034979134798049927, 0.023684639483690262, 0.03905974328517914, 0.05414341017603874, -0.023073144257068634, -0.06999389082193375, -0.013394434936344624, 0.0261944942176342, -0.06778412312269211, 0.03478681668639183, -0.03139178082346916, 0.004866145551204681, 0.06198761984705925, 0.009293410927057266, 0.059589970856904984, -0.05491548776626587, 0.08565491437911987, 0.06528981029987335, 0.041884519159793854, -0.006196977104991674, -0.04688016325235367, 0.029902171343564987, 0.020452139899134636, -0.0015058023855090141 ]
170
170
A branch-and-bound feature selection algorithm for U-shaped cost functions
This paper presents the formulation of a combinatorial optimization problem with the following characteristics: i.the search space is the power set of a finite set structured as a Boolean lattice; ii.the cost function forms a U-shaped curve when applied to any lattice chain. This formulation applies for feature selection in the context of pattern recognition. The known approaches for this problem are branch-and-bound algorithms and heuristics, that explore partially the search space. Branch-and-bound algorithms are equivalent to the full search, while heuristics are not. This paper presents a branch-and-bound algorithm that differs from the others known by exploring the lattice structure and the U-shaped chain curves of the search space. The main contribution of this paper is the architecture of this algorithm that is based on the representation and exploration of the search space by new lattice properties proven here. Several experiments, with well known public data, indicate the superiority of the proposed method to SFFS, which is a popular heuristic that gives good results in very short computational time. In all experiments, the proposed method got better or equal results in similar or even smaller computational time.
[ -0.0031258845701813698, -0.06694232672452927, 0.006396740674972534, -0.02185133285820484, -0.018762584775686264, -0.033154986798763275, 0.010690831579267979, -0.0023080429527908564, -0.013310672715306282, 0.055086649954319, 0.05386487767100334, -0.04326564073562622, -0.002950522117316723, 0.016289910301566124, -0.043044064193964005, 0.0037826194893568754, 0.05061512440443039, -0.011348498985171318, -0.049290794879198074, -0.046905167400836945, -0.01575087010860443, 0.04676661267876625, 0.005182978231459856, -0.011885948479175568, 0.10605000704526901, 0.012929441407322884, -0.01876545324921608, -0.010444381274282932, -0.06778161227703094, 0.03928448259830475, -0.08645746856927872, 0.038070715963840485, -0.04266646131873131, 0.008478202857077122, 0.053083620965480804, -0.007842936553061008, 0.026590485125780106, -0.019308429211378098, 0.0029591042548418045, 0.000025498869945295155, 0.03606629744172096, -0.020584743469953537, 0.02821803092956543, 0.01695985719561577, 0.06568964570760727, 0.0035976404324173927, -0.020887412130832672, -0.017138401046395302, 0.02154109999537468, -0.04807014390826225, -0.02002776600420475, 0.0066553750075399876, -0.021637214347720146, 0.0008272142731584609, -0.006642928812652826, 0.05882580950856209, -0.06342795491218567, -0.001509481924585998, 0.10971899330615997, 0.08722265064716339, 0.03012986294925213, 0.12890487909317017, 0.043959785252809525, -0.01640535518527031, -0.04754234105348587, -0.0482356920838356, -0.011681940406560898, -0.0320601649582386, -0.02696213684976101, -0.05136976018548012, 0.028903255239129066, -0.012179386802017689, 0.06457065790891647, -0.009317505173385143, 0.029507989063858986, 0.010635550133883953, 0.02175643853843212, 0.02426506020128727, -0.035650186240673065, 0.0050319586880505085, 0.003961056936532259, -0.014649626798927784, -0.010581213980913162, -0.019013704732060432, -0.06363022327423096, -0.0022827251814305782, 0.05884772911667824, 0.05539683625102043, 0.029989633709192276, -0.004832842852920294, -0.08930110931396484, 0.0645354837179184, -0.03346624597907066, 0.04743310064077377, 0.0002674334100447595, 0.008448600769042969, -0.007212135940790176, 0.02205447107553482, 0.01599082164466381, 0.05850394442677498, -0.055849745869636536, 0.015092051587998867, 0.0530051663517952, 0.006660004146397114, -0.11709891259670258, -0.029863080009818077, -0.07654427736997604, 0.005218735430389643, -0.017815811559557915, -0.06530188024044037, 0.035615354776382446, -0.011253665201365948, 0.00002341514300496783, -0.0006069571245461702, -0.08438840508460999, 0.06189686805009842, 0.041534651070833206, 0.07512935250997543, 0.04422437772154808, 0.02707953378558159, -0.03299058973789215, 0.0177482757717371, -0.00571998069062829, 0.06886976957321167, 0.009558120742440224, -0.07137821614742279, 0.05056331679224968, -0.08213075250387192, 0.09504567086696625, 0.023822512477636337, -0.06435012072324753, 0.07716155052185059, -0.043729621917009354, -0.004791690036654472, -0.08146493881940842, 0.04399309307336807, 0.0280519500374794, 0.016982441768050194, 0.02409343421459198, 0.0947965681552887, -0.05366749316453934, -0.038203660398721695, 0.00827029813081026, 0.04079984873533249, -0.013474044390022755, -0.038898613303899765, -0.034695591777563095, 0.007930168882012367, 0.04204992577433586, 0.014304581098258495, -0.057863667607307434, -0.08691715449094772, 0.010442116297781467, 0.03508893772959709, -0.0028138034977018833, -0.05045092850923538, -0.008228115737438202, -0.03415914997458458, 0.020687807351350784, 0.01669858768582344, -0.029501456767320633, -0.028647854924201965, -0.043468378484249115, 0.05749177560210228, 0.01871393620967865, -0.0072560301050543785, 0.04428105801343918, -0.05134037882089615, -0.0009531437535770237, -0.08065073937177658, -0.03475227579474449, 0.003216496901586652, -0.04567646235227585, 0.04501575231552124, 0.07788850367069244, 0.02318156510591507, 0.017220228910446167, -0.07038772106170654, -0.04485451802611351, 0.029258275404572487, 0.08530037105083466, -0.06738452613353729, 0.013151519000530243, 0.024266725406050682, 0.047146912664175034, 0.05201883614063263, 0.0240035243332386, 0.00533690769225359, 0.10588497668504715, 0.05064806714653969, 0.03435303643345833, 0.06442388147115707, 0.04393870383501053, -0.010618643835186958, -0.0403650626540184, 0.04157358035445213, -0.020695945248007774, -0.04299386218190193, 0.0187771487981081, -0.008639220148324966, 0.029219429939985275, 0.025903506204485893, -0.006272758822888136, -0.014479057863354683, -0.04197709634900093, -0.04723411425948143, -0.004544897470623255, -0.004602210130542517, 0.016723182052373886, -0.04632614180445671, 0.03158525750041008, -0.013872216455638409, 0.0365983322262764, 0.009443039074540138, -0.009346624836325645, -0.017525017261505127, -0.05417194962501526, -0.014554496854543686, 0.009674242697656155, 0.03661983460187912, -0.027306431904435158, 0.01742653362452984, 0.03489819914102554, 0.0586467906832695, 0.009838017635047436, -0.0024489127099514008, 0.005685136653482914, -0.018504980951547623, -0.026790225878357887, 0.07451542466878891, -0.014981268905103207, -0.09653430432081223, -0.015877852216362953, -0.05216158926486969, 0.012345602735877037, 0.05022617056965828, 0.04461885243654251, -0.046995796263217926, -0.017143595963716507, -0.025920458137989044, -0.05791731923818588, 0.02184932678937912, -0.03282290697097778, -0.06442822515964508, -0.017661675810813904, -0.019101781770586967, 0.043815094977617264, 0.03266751766204834, 0.004229163751006126, -0.04993106424808502, -0.07587547600269318, -0.09824312478303909, -0.020913798362016678, -0.039977844804525375, 0.04119671881198883, -0.043409962207078934, -0.04680740833282471, -0.014842336997389793, 0.01632203534245491, 0.01174142211675644, 0.0565800815820694, 0.061371445655822754, -0.05536821857094765, 0.0047528911381959915, 0.0293586365878582, 0.029003415256738663, -0.02249053120613098, -0.04062940180301666, 0.0433647483587265, 0.0006038912106305361, -0.017719386145472527, -0.08230609446763992, -0.09144941717386246, 0.04661612957715988, -0.024933623149991035, -0.012823744677007198, 0.040970586240291595, -0.003281509270891547, -0.04105205833911896, -0.019337357953190804, -0.04871993884444237, 0.005974892061203718, 0.049699436873197556, -0.016262521967291832, 0.02249252237379551, 0.04438639059662819, -0.058267731219530106, -0.0017008819850161672, -0.005711806006729603, 0.026239784434437752, -0.019778721034526825, 0.015258206985890865, -0.037910282611846924, -0.0011514249490574002, 0.0382467582821846, -0.05610344186425209, 0.04879387095570564, 0.02719411812722683, -0.010096784681081772, 0.03283213451504707, 0.03217150270938873, 0.02422422356903553, 0.042873315513134, 0.007789649069309235, 0.06995071470737457, 0.030558260157704353, 0.0623762272298336, 0.01105552352964878, -0.035774920135736465, 0.01688368432223797, 0.044524531811475754, 0.010775537230074406, -0.030700450763106346, -0.07102224230766296, -0.026600517332553864, -0.08840342611074448, -0.031412482261657715, -0.018788713961839676, -0.07657136023044586, 0.038347382098436356, 0.03851095214486122, 0.005008184816688299, 0.015114199370145798, 0.06989022344350815, -0.12910012900829315, -0.07132712006568909, 0.02080167457461357, 0.0064684925600886345, -0.1208496168255806, -0.021278170868754387, -0.042966846376657486, 0.012972710654139519, -0.043771207332611084, 0.0755344033241272, -0.07626990228891373, 0.004568333271890879, 0.05036434903740883, 0.030810721218585968, -0.004994602873921394, -0.014232421293854713, -0.03278697282075882, -0.03326650336384773, -0.004958418197929859, -0.03665313124656677, -0.00006675333861494437, 0.06032325699925423, 0.04124120995402336, -0.0334637276828289, 0.05171426013112068, 0.02841419354081154, -0.04722026363015175, 0.08239738643169403, -0.038303568959236145, -0.004765049554407597, -0.055668897926807404, 0.04641922563314438, 0.10795354098081589, -0.009327800944447517, -0.0012475791154429317, -0.006804961245507002, -0.009045282378792763, 0.004072488751262426, 0.04049716144800186, 0.037400662899017334, -0.045492444187402725, 0.03943389281630516, -0.06622326374053955, 0.01230916753411293, -0.01472387183457613, 0.025107968598604202, 0.04547615349292755, 0.04819716140627861, 0.04769621044397354, -0.042141880840063095, 0.005981468595564365, 0.009264473803341389, 0.009613757021725178, -0.040521129965782166, -0.0002869940362870693, 0.06462536752223969, -0.10445941239595413, -0.05032419040799141, -0.005210161674767733, -0.012574894353747368, -0.0007412256090901792, -0.03616609424352646, -0.03530101478099823, 0.029000425711274147, 0.025804739445447922, -0.038593560457229614, 0.06812595576047897, -0.10125403106212616, 0.05633942037820816, 0.01446143351495266, 0.04007759317755699, 0.023414814844727516, -0.04392511397600174, -0.08332384377717972, 0.05963148549199104, -0.034913320094347, -0.06312993913888931, -0.012895122170448303, -0.014477665536105633, -0.008331906981766224, -0.06146956607699394, 0.01706675812602043, 0.07817134261131287, 0.043097611516714096, -0.02498089335858822, 0.07424645125865936, 0.025434957817196846, 0.06677969545125961, -0.05068369582295418, 0.05724845081567764, 0.0029455639887601137, 0.0317535400390625, -0.025110026821494102, -0.04460307955741882, -0.019504571333527565, -0.023365726694464684, 0.005762958433479071, -0.005841860082000494, -0.015362541191279888, -0.027636228129267693, 0.022765185683965683, -0.044311363250017166, 0.08983701467514038, 0.02163180522620678, -0.029799088835716248, 0.02831692062318325, -0.09562437981367111, 0.04926992580294609, -0.09374985098838806, 0.015053984709084034, 0.0067068287171423435, 0.008196840062737465, 0.040847763419151306, -0.027760805562138557, 0.015621206723153591, -0.012828764505684376, 0.02530074492096901, 0.001238256343640387, -0.011328022927045822, -0.031047293916344643, -0.004600130952894688, -0.030684448778629303, -0.00342334876768291, -0.05842107534408569, 0.049671467393636703, 0.01018624845892191, -0.028555482625961304, -0.08076896518468857, -0.006883940659463406, 0.02245699241757393, 0.031640131026506424, -0.026328595355153084, 0.0005557616823352873, -0.07920587807893753, 0.04317363351583481, 0.04475173354148865, -0.056624334305524826, -0.08209621161222458, 0.034065064042806625, 0.01478039100766182, -0.035324826836586, 0.0585973896086216, -0.05418407544493675, -0.0381355956196785, 0.0783647820353508, 0.06784198433160782, -0.0650637149810791, 0.05193880572915077, 0.0857183039188385, -0.08917191624641418, 0.014179849997162819, -0.04111988842487335, 0.07387865334749222, -0.009941255673766136, -0.03867056593298912, -0.03570486605167389, 0.036333199590444565, -0.0007776805432513356, -0.0321178212761879, -0.02459005080163479, 0.033813394606113434, -0.05546503886580467, -0.027445480227470398, -0.02719123102724552, 0.057878412306308746, -0.0511368028819561, -0.03306543081998825, 0.04496917873620987, 0.03426830470561981, 0.0252591073513031, 0.013806460425257683, 0.023391587659716606, -0.010418126359581947, -0.04218112304806709, 0.08925008028745651, -0.008052396588027477, 0.024483559653162956, 0.01313924789428711, -0.022027529776096344, 0.09624729305505753, 0.09641507267951965, -0.011445616371929646, 0.010373855009675026, -0.09257064759731293, -0.024427244439721107, -0.040884535759687424, -0.05210418999195099, -0.04257851466536522 ]
171
171
Temporal Difference Updating without a Learning Rate
We derive an equation for temporal difference learning from statistical principles. Specifically, we start with the variational principle and then bootstrap to produce an updating rule for discounted state value estimates. The resulting equation is similar to the standard equation for temporal difference learning with eligibility traces, so called TD(lambda), however it lacks the parameter alpha that specifies the learning rate. In the place of this free parameter there is now an equation for the learning rate that is specific to each state transition. We experimentally test this new learning rule against TD(lambda) and find that it offers superior performance in various settings. Finally, we make some preliminary investigations into how to extend our new temporal difference algorithm to reinforcement learning. To do this we combine our update equation with both Watkins' Q(lambda) and Sarsa(lambda) and find that it again offers superior performance without a learning rate parameter.
[ -0.020265260711312294, -0.06339167803525925, 0.08806364983320236, 0.019702784717082977, -0.045272305607795715, -0.037702374160289764, 0.02436595968902111, -0.0008942328277043998, 0.027363371104002, 0.033825721591711044, -0.034158334136009216, -0.000006867410775157623, -0.00038965523708611727, 0.06745903193950653, 0.04283532872796059, -0.03984406217932701, -0.0042828889563679695, 0.03938329964876175, 0.035215556621551514, -0.028546087443828583, 0.013796566985547543, -0.018201839178800583, 0.051664941012859344, -0.0366969034075737, 0.050195105373859406, -0.02788432687520981, -0.022282706573605537, 0.021614650264382362, 0.10412220656871796, -0.01019125897437334, -0.06586724519729614, 0.025960544124245644, 0.019579021260142326, 0.0012848415644839406, 0.028496691957116127, -0.029556743800640106, 0.051902662962675095, -0.04339614138007164, -0.04019490256905556, 0.021176323294639587, 0.027617424726486206, 0.023289714008569717, 0.021499404683709145, 0.01728547364473343, 0.060918714851140976, 0.001134138903580606, 0.10274747759103775, -0.015797952190041542, -0.04356299340724945, 0.0827600434422493, -0.037371810525655746, -0.00894501619040966, -0.006618232931941748, -0.01819896139204502, -0.01473314967006445, 0.026680152863264084, -0.01163583341985941, -0.006210390944033861, -0.010300882160663605, -0.02982494793832302, -0.037580639123916626, 0.10682196915149689, 0.03331732377409935, 0.042691703885793686, 0.005230804905295372, 0.04444049671292305, -0.021878134459257126, -0.024369139224290848, -0.023037651553750038, 0.03005770593881607, -0.009062446653842926, 0.018326587975025177, 0.0021041790023446083, 0.027041437104344368, -0.008786164224147797, 0.0062370942905545235, 0.05035049468278885, 0.012208237312734127, 0.02539043314754963, 0.03165228292346001, -0.003329233033582568, -0.011825578287243843, 0.025919172912836075, -0.016416795551776886, 0.011760832741856575, 0.05110354349017143, 0.021502915769815445, 0.002695464063435793, -0.035202670842409134, -0.0249741580337286, -0.01951614022254944, 0.02666451595723629, -0.1291620135307312, -0.0746089443564415, -0.0767718181014061, 0.029698770493268967, 0.00038533052429556847, -0.02598981186747551, 0.03165595233440399, -0.009989675134420395, 0.08285405486822128, 0.013175184838473797, 0.04155828058719635, 0.06108758971095085, 0.01236754097044468, 0.007599754258990288, 0.07475344836711884, 0.011067932471632957, 0.004666030872613192, -0.03674496337771416, 0.057485755532979965, 0.026999227702617645, 0.0048441835679113865, -0.033251065760850906, -0.005959332920610905, 0.08398108184337616, -0.03644784167408943, 0.05023960769176483, 0.07404215633869171, 0.05621577426791191, -0.016499241814017296, 0.03443119674921036, -0.046511776745319366, 0.036690566688776016, 0.01985524594783783, 0.019940782338380814, -0.03177449107170105, -0.06901007890701294, 0.06439485400915146, -0.03600360453128815, -0.023321622982621193, -0.01607724465429783, -0.005540031474083662, -0.1007186770439148, 0.02334040217101574, 0.0792166218161583, -0.06711950898170471, -0.04922526702284813, -0.03935960307717323, -0.019502129405736923, 0.035196952521800995, 0.03982561454176903, -0.10360683500766754, -0.03293135017156601, 0.010472395457327366, 0.034708935767412186, -0.004568756092339754, -0.036311302334070206, 0.0003477682184893638, 0.005332584958523512, 0.05500143766403198, 0.0467744879424572, -0.024376902729272842, 0.06627999991178513, 0.007955786772072315, -0.057649530470371246, -0.022078415378928185, 0.002248764503747225, 0.01024847012013197, 0.15254297852516174, 0.01949884183704853, -0.03629371523857117, -0.03311624005436897, 0.017420006915926933, -0.015612599439918995, -0.08043711632490158, 0.04134596139192581, -0.03374062106013298, -0.014879689551889896, -0.0824907198548317, -0.056464292109012604, -0.030606577172875404, 0.03216664865612984, -0.0117624681442976, 0.005289922002702951, 0.05216614902019501, 0.036857541650533676, 0.0019061560742557049, -0.015154073014855385, -0.02767861634492874, 0.010883783921599388, -0.05472270026803017, -0.0012626760872080922, -0.009386030957102776, 0.04754793271422386, 0.016033409163355827, -0.021760378032922745, -0.026657184585928917, 0.02706906944513321, -0.008258816786110401, -0.03712603822350502, 0.034617189317941666, -0.036929287016391754, 0.029212508350610733, 0.0032788189128041267, -0.004766900558024645, -0.002206492703408003, -0.03147237002849579, 0.05523824691772461, 0.08196549862623215, 0.06104818731546402, -0.028067870065569878, -0.08494827151298523, -0.026637401431798935, -0.07356197386980057, 0.08080548048019409, 0.0029023149982094765, -0.011825749650597572, -0.012121629901230335, 0.04400293529033661, 0.04208189249038696, -0.03569844737648964, -0.06684836000204086, -0.06592197716236115, 0.035360172390937805, -0.0205018799751997, -0.05154316499829292, -0.053654592484235764, 0.006777874194085598, 0.02475077472627163, 0.01787399686872959, 0.023128315806388855, 0.0232862401753664, 0.08862997591495514, -0.04926396161317825, -0.07491672784090042, 0.020403802394866943, -0.025477178394794464, -0.04874636232852936, -0.0011500464752316475, -0.027241967618465424, -0.04888608679175377, -0.05423916503787041, 0.017880676314234734, -0.01425931416451931, 0.03989037498831749, -0.017917532473802567, -0.050990838557481766, 0.04244595766067505, 0.016823461279273033, -0.0368618443608284, 0.11738033592700958, -0.012519905343651772, -0.004641640465706587, 0.03663796931505203, -0.06696319580078125, 0.01243238989263773, 0.008928671479225159, -0.08714210987091064, -0.04834376275539398, 0.002006980823352933, -0.015584239736199379, -0.10589731484651566, -0.07245529443025589, 0.02384805865585804, 0.018948333337903023, -0.05026106908917427, 0.06819900125265121, -0.0008220468298532069, -0.02779071405529976, -0.03374754637479782, 0.04648138955235481, -0.06944449245929718, 0.03655856102705002, 0.0785846933722496, -0.048619117587804794, 0.010118041187524796, -0.01250404492020607, -0.01244973111897707, -0.039475131779909134, 0.009561237879097462, -0.06715582311153412, 0.07817752659320831, 0.08976700901985168, -0.01081971824169159, -0.018082184717059135, 0.10036411881446838, 0.009960216470062733, 0.011153300292789936, 0.01746390387415886, -0.06673595309257507, -0.04590224474668503, 0.008518706075847149, -0.045620162039995193, -0.00011140004062326625, 0.09822119772434235, 0.0014672569232061505, 0.027209725230932236, 0.02549884282052517, -0.04962022230029106, -0.0012607118114829063, -0.06669595837593079, -0.06307756900787354, 0.004212724510580301, 0.0563482865691185, -0.04136761650443077, 0.01917523331940174, -0.07137096673250198, 0.000845004222355783, -0.005708850454539061, -0.05127636343240738, 0.018349356949329376, 0.04828215762972832, 0.04456738755106926, 0.020039744675159454, 0.015604936517775059, 0.024557340890169144, 0.07764846831560135, -0.055921535938978195, 0.041579678654670715, 0.07914809137582779, 0.0001209801557706669, -0.03769923001527786, 0.022647809237241745, -0.008303043432533741, 0.0171385258436203, -0.011580976657569408, -0.06448492407798767, -0.0027614054270088673, 0.02593957632780075, 0.05454108491539955, 0.03907535970211029, 0.034417275339365005, 0.06699908524751663, -0.13993047177791595, 0.012569715268909931, -0.013427107594907284, 0.01642141304910183, 0.009522171691060066, 0.10599097609519958, -0.057607054710388184, -0.03569088876247406, 0.02579730749130249, 0.0037244248669594526, -0.0496349036693573, -0.02492590993642807, -0.03613981604576111, 0.027795279398560524, 0.05331287160515785, 0.006396779790520668, -0.018974972888827324, -0.07771129161119461, -0.049054019153118134, -0.037938643246889114, -0.010938212275505066, 0.01573021709918976, 0.03459572046995163, 0.026210594922304153, 0.014290186576545238, -0.005190570838749409, -0.015722932294011116, -0.0881573036313057, -0.04727942496538162, 0.014814048074185848, -0.007535798475146294, 0.040085140615701675, -0.048470303416252136, 0.025142978876829147, 0.04234832152724266, 0.04177236557006836, 0.022198868915438652, 0.04695798456668854, -0.020575055852532387, -0.08703834563493729, -0.01836893893778324, 0.06736987084150314, -0.023826785385608673, 0.0020130425691604614, -0.03263054043054581, 0.011647921055555344, 0.06762734800577164, 0.007339303381741047, 0.0464465506374836, 0.03718028962612152, 0.053996674716472626, -0.016568822786211967, 0.09940861910581589, -0.07094690948724747, -0.04687553271651268, 0.06578688323497772, -0.05788850411772728, -0.04159804806113243, 0.0020115573424845934, -0.0584275983273983, -0.05405231937766075, -0.07215339690446854, -0.0032174994703382254, 0.06050108000636101, 0.003806754946708679, 0.01941443234682083, -0.11030208319425583, -0.08654647320508957, -0.021035369485616684, 0.03815967217087746, 0.0019806537311524153, -0.02883874997496605, 0.026925014331936836, 0.003400098066776991, -0.04592691361904144, -0.0005598890711553395, 0.035185810178518295, -0.05546684190630913, 0.09325090050697327, -0.04456472396850586, -0.05760730430483818, 0.06373941153287888, 0.06205832585692406, 0.032528288662433624, 0.023874476552009583, 0.012432025745511055, 0.01193612813949585, 0.007050418760627508, 0.014410076662898064, -0.04653630778193474, -0.02297717146575451, -0.020315885543823242, 0.038674842566251755, 0.009903786703944206, 0.020834870636463165, -0.044462621212005615, 0.057154200971126556, -0.018716705963015556, 0.10793028026819229, -0.019150635227560997, -0.029519760981202126, -0.007301006466150284, -0.02035573124885559, 0.08318514376878738, -0.07100740075111389, 0.06544724106788635, -0.03189564496278763, -0.07209543883800507, -0.07337100058794022, -0.04284418374300003, 0.016596773639321327, -0.0008173782262019813, -0.032402172684669495, 0.013584562577307224, -0.04637853801250458, 0.012347370386123657, -0.007173419930040836, 0.02156035788357258, 0.05711199715733528, 0.017036160454154015, 0.011462334543466568, 0.09945395588874817, 0.022794470191001892, -0.026438094675540924, 0.06920203566551208, 0.05760655179619789, 0.0395800918340683, 0.010388568975031376, 0.004940073471516371, 0.002584470435976982, 0.025071322917938232, 0.020409779623150826, 0.021644461899995804, 0.04064023494720459, 0.06081045791506767, -0.02269972302019596, -0.026972128078341484, -0.0234882440418005, -0.03495529294013977, 0.015845367684960365, -0.065744549036026, -0.01784048229455948, -0.027619987726211548, 0.0060639032162725925, 0.05363786220550537, -0.02114306017756462, -0.05684582516551018, 0.0305262990295887, 0.008806396275758743, -0.027339862659573555, -0.08701284974813461, 0.10724657773971558, 0.0444256030023098, 0.004994376562535763, -0.03564000874757767, 0.047375258058309555, 0.058262888342142105, 0.0409441813826561, 0.013837744481861591, 0.05116144195199013, 0.04654087498784065, 0.03399962931871414, -0.01684100180864334, 0.020262926816940308, 0.06233500316739082, -0.010381191037595272, 0.03077194094657898, -0.037448521703481674, -0.00934770330786705, -0.004418134689331055, 0.0036851060576736927, -0.061626873910427094, -0.038359805941581726, -0.010718121193349361, -0.006032139994204044, -0.038343027234077454, 0.059743691235780716, 0.02149142138659954, 0.03599809482693672, 0.03630395978689194, 0.019643418490886688, 0.057640161365270615, 0.014866610988974571, 0.015921352431178093, 0.04362892359495163, 0.028070392087101936, 0.005210885312408209, 0.06249653548002243 ]
172
172
On the Possibility of Learning in Reactive Environments with Arbitrary Dependence
We address the problem of reinforcement learning in which observations may exhibit an arbitrary form of stochastic dependence on past observations and actions, i.e. environments more general than (PO)MDPs. The task for an agent is to attain the best possible asymptotic reward where the true generating environment is unknown but belongs to a known countable family of environments. We find some sufficient conditions on the class of environments under which an agent exists which attains the best asymptotic reward for any environment in the class. We analyze how tight these conditions are and how they relate to different probabilistic assumptions known in reinforcement learning and related fields, such as Markov Decision Processes and mixing conditions.
[ -0.05428400635719299, -0.09951157122850418, 0.004967879503965378, -0.026669781655073166, 0.048742424696683884, -0.059994395822286606, -0.03206606209278107, 0.02098718285560608, -0.02971072867512703, 0.046470608562231064, -0.016235575079917908, -0.05279228836297989, 0.017111418768763542, 0.03564469516277313, 0.00029436603654175997, -0.05207479000091553, -0.07123719900846481, 0.045190829783678055, -0.06897886097431183, -0.07814823091030121, 0.05256838724017143, 0.03470165655016899, 0.009603609330952168, 0.0030566456262022257, -0.02584063820540905, 0.010752502828836441, -0.018430495634675026, -0.01764853298664093, 0.014193352311849594, -0.025946592912077904, 0.011797606945037842, -0.011452668346464634, -0.03039609268307686, -0.025226179510354996, 0.014475221745669842, -0.008267465978860855, -0.003549837274476886, 0.04827362298965454, -0.08235885947942734, -0.020445451140403748, -0.038079410791397095, -0.005262797698378563, 0.02944924123585224, -0.02879551611840725, 0.03833002224564552, 0.038731854408979416, 0.047573503106832504, 0.03579244390130043, -0.012711177580058575, 0.05345650389790535, -0.08440249413251877, 0.09437046200037003, -0.013666759245097637, -0.06701945513486862, -0.02088306099176407, 0.05201205611228943, -0.0250859297811985, 0.03032699227333069, -0.1057976558804512, -0.03542710468173027, 0.0792401060461998, 0.08522768318653107, -0.05544444918632507, -0.012906607240438461, 0.032403331249952316, -0.03899039700627327, -0.023439330980181694, 0.026827719062566757, 0.012064549140632153, -0.007602410856634378, 0.02812478132545948, -0.09199512749910355, 0.08381125330924988, 0.006598872132599354, 0.014594622887670994, 0.07639220356941223, 0.0472605936229229, -0.000007604118309245678, 0.0035732085816562176, 0.09023650735616684, -0.08720854669809341, 0.07067983597517014, -0.03544345125555992, 0.049977365881204605, -0.020932501181960106, -0.011807238683104515, -0.028217673301696777, -0.012019315734505653, -0.03617183864116669, -0.05526963621377945, -0.037954650819301605, 0.03135750815272331, -0.022229591384530067, -0.027326293289661407, -0.039052292704582214, 0.10825345665216446, -0.02592380717396736, 0.019501499831676483, -0.05800846219062805, 0.018613552674651146, 0.08359547704458237, -0.019437173381447792, 0.06754849851131439, 0.036790624260902405, 0.029852230101823807, 0.014566583558917046, 0.03930468112230301, 0.003891966538503766, -0.012066756375133991, -0.018977390602231026, 0.021475736051797867, -0.06630195677280426, 0.04944756627082825, 0.020023711025714874, -0.05572862550616264, 0.09340428560972214, -0.023495830595493317, 0.00522520300000906, 0.020245421677827835, 0.03917781263589859, 0.03033207170665264, -0.07352997362613678, -0.06798109412193298, 0.005473029334098101, 0.043724965304136276, -0.02040928602218628, -0.029280873015522957, -0.008616584353148937, 0.08829246461391449, -0.039070013910532, -0.01560580637305975, -0.045324571430683136, 0.006988548208028078, -0.15562543272972107, -0.031803734600543976, 0.024205263704061508, -0.02453049272298813, -0.034001171588897705, -0.07342379540205002, 0.05562317371368408, 0.02221006341278553, -0.01196393370628357, 0.01809467002749443, -0.0065465024672448635, -0.005998831242322922, -0.008834118954837322, -0.00035571615444496274, 0.05531313642859459, -0.011096707545220852, 0.06702802330255508, -0.0807722881436348, 0.05258035287261009, 0.03401031345129013, 0.07103504985570908, 0.011169841513037682, 0.004721696022897959, -0.036312948912382126, -0.0036644896026700735, -0.06631982326507568, 0.05003766715526581, 0.0005717966123484075, 0.044463861733675, 0.010230885818600655, 0.05738598853349686, -0.043064747005701065, -0.029202384874224663, -0.015426518395543098, 0.04751057177782059, -0.03723515570163727, -0.040329448878765106, -0.057217955589294434, -0.020165594294667244, -0.007978062145411968, -0.0036646397784352303, -0.03836042433977127, -0.020273977890610695, -0.06529571861028671, 0.019745903089642525, -0.008110616356134415, -0.023249339312314987, -0.024772511795163155, -0.010662777349352837, -0.04493609070777893, 0.04723929986357689, -0.03798772767186165, 0.04946182295680046, -0.05038284510374069, -0.0025751017965376377, 0.03253746032714844, -0.0002494262589607388, -0.022223489359021187, 0.013231039047241211, -0.06576533615589142, -0.03755313903093338, 0.013444053009152412, -0.06764061003923416, -0.01264447346329689, -0.0067463344894349575, 0.03578636422753334, 0.01142945047467947, 0.01835600659251213, 0.022776653990149498, -0.08134123682975769, -0.010450546629726887, -0.011232583783566952, 0.009305902756750584, 0.026867104694247246, 0.02206176519393921, -0.03805137053132057, -0.04031877592206001, -0.028292043134570122, -0.01773902028799057, -0.02541111223399639, -0.0258990116417408, 0.0569704994559288, -0.14516931772232056, -0.01234499178826809, -0.06548574566841125, 0.02471604011952877, -0.0041751014068722725, -0.05064588785171509, 0.05159950628876686, -0.020613159984350204, 0.029228180646896362, -0.11242979019880295, -0.03775729611515999, 0.03500919044017792, -0.006699144374579191, -0.023472432047128677, -0.049165207892656326, -0.08463401347398758, -0.03229774162173271, -0.026902908459305763, 0.021340927109122276, -0.010074254125356674, 0.05886616185307503, -0.023798709735274315, -0.043442144989967346, -0.026629537343978882, -0.007159839849919081, -0.05610860884189606, 0.05542311817407608, 0.0979626253247261, -0.04025343060493469, 0.02026430331170559, -0.033182863146066666, -0.007910952903330326, -0.03341182321310043, -0.059837423264980316, 0.005435532424598932, 0.09336525946855545, -0.03729484602808952, 0.029753083363175392, 0.03661087900400162, 0.028936661779880524, -0.02689632587134838, 0.018073732033371925, 0.05258253216743469, 0.01002788171172142, -0.0015809297328814864, 0.0013098092749714851, 0.05224056914448738, -0.05699551850557327, 0.0984017625451088, 0.054006293416023254, 0.07641828805208206, -0.012317609041929245, 0.01919933408498764, 0.07748065143823624, -0.04391210898756981, -0.016285017132759094, 0.012787568382918835, -0.04145465046167374, 0.03264961019158363, 0.011593624018132687, -0.0005797301419079304, 0.032243724912405014, 0.042195532470941544, 0.009477291256189346, -0.05915483832359314, -0.041734084486961365, -0.015561338514089584, -0.01810661517083645, -0.029684631153941154, -0.007167649921029806, 0.07055624574422836, -0.005438873544335365, 0.05216408148407936, -0.030292067676782608, 0.01631755754351616, -0.038009967654943466, 0.002121108816936612, -0.06596885621547699, -0.005478739272803068, 0.02538999728858471, 0.02094893902540207, 0.03814409300684929, 0.03031339682638645, 0.021638663485646248, 0.013699803501367569, 0.009519753977656364, -0.07267485558986664, -0.014775608666241169, -0.02555711939930916, 0.030243542045354843, 0.08439027518033981, -0.0302969329059124, 0.013481765985488892, -0.06122780218720436, 0.021558750420808792, 0.04640554264187813, 0.009801875799894333, -0.044188402593135834, 0.06087429076433182, 0.0886726826429367, -0.056320179253816605, -0.030333386734128, -0.0659211054444313, 0.001268657622858882, 0.023729853332042694, 0.01659746840596199, 0.02649928815662861, 0.035694289952516556, 0.05354763939976692, -0.09446237981319427, -0.013082996942102909, -0.0029710172675549984, 0.05528341978788376, -0.00005022351979278028, 0.001771032577380538, -0.008599754422903061, -0.002655346877872944, -0.01661977916955948, 0.057335902005434036, -0.0782788023352623, 0.0095543647184968, -0.07470716536045074, -0.04930487647652626, 0.02635842002928257, 0.06454908102750778, 0.004364344757050276, -0.19175393879413605, -0.033357616513967514, -0.008322713896632195, 0.05109512433409691, 0.07814101874828339, 0.04465233162045479, 0.02211708016693592, -0.0035529262386262417, 0.00641480041667819, -0.007728307042270899, -0.005122072529047728, -0.008794511668384075, 0.05836991220712662, -0.03936106339097023, -0.016726069152355194, -0.029444320127367973, 0.006719440687447786, 0.060751087963581085, -0.023132888600230217, -0.03200371935963631, 0.0013198351953178644, -0.004314945545047522, -0.05488121137022972, -0.0015936847776174545, 0.05036379396915436, 0.010553209111094475, -0.03190181776881218, -0.04665263369679451, -0.047364894300699234, -0.055492933839559555, 0.018702594563364983, 0.034732427448034286, 0.051444947719573975, 0.04163311794400215, -0.0266389362514019, 0.10237149894237518, -0.0161843653768301, -0.009772122837603092, 0.08398295938968658, 0.010539572685956955, -0.06997276097536087, 0.025849388912320137, -0.02424023672938347, -0.06293246150016785, -0.054962173104286194, -0.02002830244600773, -0.02448614127933979, 0.0952688679099083, -0.020493755117058754, -0.04470980912446976, 0.01156284473836422, 0.002626977162435651, 0.0374191552400589, 0.010792368091642857, 0.010485079139471054, 0.055593956261873245, 0.023838624358177185, -0.12280695140361786, 0.017769768834114075, 0.047650087624788284, -0.06545786559581757, -0.015913140028715134, -0.03798156604170799, -0.0017065374413505197, 0.013743937015533447, 0.03237830847501755, 0.09265022724866867, -0.034228552132844925, 0.07285868376493454, 0.025433119386434555, 0.022276321426033974, -0.05032125860452652, 0.004772143438458443, -0.029617061838507652, -0.02250908501446247, -0.021641599014401436, -0.015061378479003906, -0.01139847468584776, -0.04719104617834091, -0.0308991651982069, -0.018775014206767082, -0.003370525548234582, 0.07220818102359772, 0.004357704892754555, -0.0918932557106018, 0.030192850157618523, 0.07322072237730026, -0.02170388586819172, 0.010357479564845562, -0.06369925290346146, -0.02039305679500103, -0.07299703359603882, -0.04761175811290741, 0.03433729708194733, -0.018980801105499268, -0.026972506195306778, -0.005936915520578623, -0.004753356333822012, 0.01738441176712513, -0.05004315823316574, 0.041640907526016235, 0.042818620800971985, 0.03965354710817337, -0.020368358120322227, 0.06004878506064415, 0.04430136829614639, 0.0229403804987669, 0.08556801825761795, 0.044974908232688904, 0.022851863875985146, 0.07163549214601517, -0.015673555433750153, -0.05038698390126228, 0.048713769763708115, -0.01238148845732212, 0.03018321841955185, -0.01604471728205681, 0.02276836521923542, 0.04063892364501953, -0.020993303507566452, -0.0497053824365139, 0.022158078849315643, 0.027692995965480804, -0.03103475458920002, -0.07187613844871521, 0.03615310788154602, 0.038078680634498596, 0.0727432444691658, -0.023702679201960564, -0.08565463125705719, 0.03678503260016441, -0.005651795770972967, 0.011530358344316483, 0.03320059925317764, -0.010924223810434341, 0.029353216290473938, -0.046690139919519424, -0.0495670810341835, 0.03230992704629898, 0.013397812843322754, 0.023098375648260117, -0.006673144642263651, -0.01790066622197628, 0.024998454377055168, 0.08915191143751144, 0.02133610099554062, 0.0033952947705984116, 0.01377719733864069, -0.016211476176977158, 0.003921390511095524, 0.03193795308470726, 0.06152033433318138, -0.03067389316856861, 0.08437182009220123, -0.025131583213806152, -0.014416477642953396, -0.00461133848875761, -0.03962405025959015, 0.001940839341841638, 0.01006378699094057, -0.002038616454228759, 0.01085756253451109, -0.021244732663035393, 0.03061380237340927, -0.02111789397895336, 0.01202834490686655, -0.0013112316373735666, -0.056952692568302155, 0.03575769439339638, -0.032996729016304016, 0.06705736368894577 ]
173
173
Entropy, Perception, and Relativity
In this paper, I expand Shannon's definition of entropy into a new form of entropy that allows integration of information from different random events. Shannon's notion of entropy is a special case of my more general definition of entropy. I define probability using a so-called performance function, which is de facto an exponential distribution. Assuming that my general notion of entropy reflects the true uncertainty about a probabilistic event, I understand that our perceived uncertainty differs. I claim that our perception is the result of two opposing forces similar to the two famous antagonists in Chinese philosophy: Yin and Yang. Based on this idea, I show that our perceived uncertainty matches the true uncertainty in points determined by the golden ratio. I demonstrate that the well-known sigmoid function, which we typically employ in artificial neural networks as a non-linear threshold function, describes the actual performance. Furthermore, I provide a motivation for the time dilation in Einstein's Special Relativity, basically claiming that although time dilation conforms with our perception, it does not correspond to reality. At the end of the paper, I show how to apply this theoretical framework to practical applications. I present recognition rates for a pattern recognition problem, and also propose a network architecture that can take advantage of general entropy to solve complex decision problems.
[ -0.08703874051570892, -0.040291961282491684, 0.04429938644170761, -0.06934336572885513, -0.0854390561580658, -0.0760316476225853, -0.007963938638567924, 0.013127794489264488, -0.01223068218678236, 0.09466713666915894, -0.00652454886585474, -0.0300618764013052, -0.034878917038440704, 0.032461173832416534, 0.05486810579895973, -0.031346168369054794, -0.014504161663353443, 0.0229813139885664, -0.04422946646809578, -0.057473376393318176, -0.023090751841664314, 0.03339818865060806, -0.02346978709101677, -0.08433940261602402, -0.054169319570064545, -0.020618457347154617, -0.051186852157115936, -0.02567264437675476, -0.02808043733239174, -0.02250772900879383, -0.039382435381412506, -0.004497217480093241, 0.024903522804379463, 0.013624712824821472, 0.034616656601428986, 0.046932075172662735, 0.01854759268462658, -0.0638868659734726, -0.02829662896692753, -0.03948401287198067, 0.06339104473590851, -0.016036229208111763, 0.013900521211326122, 0.03836626186966896, -0.01934065856039524, 0.025816690176725388, 0.021646203473210335, 0.029886886477470398, 0.04499036446213722, 0.10288438200950623, -0.10571982711553574, -0.011229566298425198, -0.06029188260436058, -0.05693328380584717, 0.04345192015171051, 0.07522432506084442, 0.002911880612373352, -0.027447408065199852, -0.06534688174724579, 0.0073141977190971375, -0.04774508625268936, 0.08203716576099396, -0.01798836886882782, 0.027646973729133606, 0.03554413840174675, -0.0008322458015754819, -0.10962242633104324, 0.045057591050863266, -0.005980303511023521, -0.03469135984778404, -0.008551129139959812, -0.007764669135212898, 0.015521742403507233, 0.025040792301297188, 0.04867180436849594, -0.04638668894767761, 0.0031324103474617004, -0.016097646206617355, 0.020074281841516495, 0.05317648872733116, -0.08635587990283966, 0.04809647798538208, 0.008474129252135754, -0.04886438697576523, -0.015950631350278854, -0.02044418826699257, -0.03712189197540283, -0.02329294942319393, -0.024952586740255356, -0.05519739165902138, -0.05481988191604614, 0.046078041195869446, -0.04091116413474083, 0.06375012546777725, 0.00044090484152548015, 0.09111635386943817, -0.03191385418176651, -0.05851610749959946, 0.049784619361162186, -0.009195658378303051, 0.08196894079446793, -0.025291137397289276, 0.051368698477745056, 0.006689133588224649, -0.0002706643717829138, -0.036424681544303894, 0.042449116706848145, 0.03185131773352623, 0.04458071291446686, -0.10596543550491333, 0.042053744196891785, -0.0361575223505497, 0.013719704933464527, -0.04873242601752281, -0.04854914918541908, 0.043235186487436295, 0.00638368958607316, 0.07351133227348328, 0.010523471049964428, 0.04248699173331261, 0.05641172081232071, 0.05752475559711456, 0.03727792203426361, 0.002873453078791499, 0.00424908846616745, -0.034098509699106216, -0.07516982406377792, -0.05482128635048866, 0.13552848994731903, -0.019322793930768967, -0.03413977846503258, 0.0005483596469275653, -0.023577211424708366, 0.006116378586739302, -0.006955581251531839, 0.04706434905529022, 0.010353137739002705, -0.03361932933330536, -0.05634169653058052, 0.03167653828859329, 0.05489286780357361, -0.01229163259267807, -0.03246443346142769, -0.041691556572914124, 0.04948989301919937, 0.06250075995922089, 0.00011253132834099233, 0.041848257184028625, -0.013239032588899136, -0.056435346603393555, 0.0011162548325955868, -0.010394672863185406, -0.041085999459028244, 0.10923308879137039, -0.02516835369169712, -0.04569166898727417, -0.08658929169178009, -0.0032570750918239355, -0.03611014410853386, 0.07136492431163788, -0.009409623220562935, 0.019765373319387436, 0.017582830041646957, 0.07729718089103699, -0.046352170407772064, 0.01934758946299553, 0.012330891564488411, -0.04758929833769798, 0.019383970648050308, -0.06309902667999268, -0.036481961607933044, 0.07167516648769379, -0.04521337151527405, -0.041801754385232925, -0.06560154259204865, 0.021496105939149857, -0.05353071168065071, 0.016836905851960182, 0.03018016554415226, 0.015203284099698067, -0.029121723026037216, -0.04294249415397644, -0.05146545544266701, -0.003862549550831318, -0.01593373715877533, 0.03146839886903763, -0.029746590182185173, 0.0019130584551021457, 0.07026759535074234, -0.007429935969412327, 0.03480003401637077, 0.016585515812039375, -0.027516428381204605, -0.07652581483125687, 0.02045147866010666, 0.00859804917126894, -0.0045768930576741695, -0.020896373316645622, -0.03150533139705658, 0.0746275931596756, 0.027334854006767273, 0.01259449403733015, -0.10578738898038864, -0.010291814804077148, 0.0069149755872786045, 0.07770334929227829, 0.007018957287073135, -0.0644153282046318, 0.008684222586452961, -0.0031775813549757004, -0.0059404317289590836, 0.0041840518824756145, -0.001714858110062778, -0.008918501436710358, 0.029569344595074654, -0.07083611935377121, -0.0695757046341896, -0.0030848460737615824, 0.004555081017315388, 0.05192010477185249, 0.03546273335814476, 0.05359737575054169, -0.013265558518469334, 0.08074408769607544, -0.10583356022834778, -0.008756542578339577, -0.003424695460125804, 0.0415470153093338, -0.018236136063933372, 0.0793229192495346, -0.05123893544077873, -0.008198386058211327, -0.05614200234413147, -0.018709711730480194, 0.006968355271965265, 0.0950470119714737, -0.10172678530216217, 0.02123885415494442, 0.013447891920804977, -0.013607817701995373, -0.025221243500709534, 0.09960747510194778, -0.0413796566426754, 0.04592014476656914, -0.03473399579524994, -0.030060969293117523, -0.008046609349548817, 0.03714407980442047, -0.01907188445329666, 0.010155669413506985, -0.015273411758244038, 0.053867217153310776, 0.01654886268079281, -0.02257762849330902, 0.05090363696217537, -0.016176437959074974, -0.023598946630954742, -0.010560888797044754, 0.0614817850291729, -0.013523180037736893, 0.012416520155966282, 0.06932460516691208, -0.03689967095851898, -0.013684207573533058, 0.0333850122988224, 0.008533443324267864, -0.035232607275247574, -0.013461058959364891, 0.061285827308893204, -0.0053172120824456215, 0.049457624554634094, 0.005229896400123835, -0.054106224328279495, 0.0812952071428299, 0.025962671265006065, -0.041813019663095474, 0.04232718050479889, 0.03688766807317734, -0.06844257563352585, -0.05277688428759575, -0.02431860938668251, -0.0024915009271353483, -0.032713212072849274, -0.029734814539551735, -0.0218433178961277, 0.004564972128719091, 0.013380135409533978, 0.009207622148096561, 0.007407809142023325, 0.04772643744945526, 0.008370371535420418, 0.10690633952617645, -0.08691641688346863, -0.027027027681469917, 0.012086719274520874, -0.024383584037423134, 0.05312178283929825, -0.0715261772274971, -0.00390563253313303, -0.026826152577996254, -0.025938227772712708, 0.004474563989788294, 0.0776415467262268, 0.024668293073773384, -0.044538382440805435, 0.0634421855211258, 0.040297508239746094, 0.0807434692978859, -0.061229150742292404, 0.017940130084753036, -0.024092456325888634, -0.03955365717411041, -0.036847155541181564, -0.026977496221661568, 0.011487268842756748, -0.010838236659765244, -0.03646315634250641, -0.026760520413517952, -0.0076134600676596165, 0.04795616865158081, 0.019814688712358475, -0.06279073655605316, -0.04192713275551796, -0.04526843875646591, -0.0778251364827156, 0.00625631446018815, -0.023175373673439026, -0.015700941905379295, -0.0898631289601326, 0.05176972970366478, -0.03758656606078148, -0.0034813424572348595, 0.007865482941269875, 0.14826147258281708, -0.05449993908405304, 0.02544984221458435, 0.028678860515356064, -0.029294321313500404, 0.03274485841393471, -0.006093939766287804, -0.0416194312274456, -0.012749983929097652, -0.010472503490746021, -0.026861906051635742, 0.02838228829205036, 0.04253280162811279, 0.05714694410562515, -0.00316341919824481, -0.02661210298538208, -0.017578285187482834, 0.007199479267001152, 0.0571935772895813, 0.04275267943739891, 0.00241675041615963, 0.014832377433776855, 0.04881856590509415, -0.04131003096699715, -0.007164511829614639, -0.007905959151685238, 0.019111089408397675, 0.03440427407622337, 0.0635828971862793, -0.0610882043838501, -0.03647752106189728, 0.1173311397433281, 0.08928500860929489, -0.0062425220385193825, -0.03057052008807659, -0.027729015797376633, 0.012463842518627644, 0.011907823383808136, 0.016600551083683968, 0.03571844846010208, -0.018671616911888123, -0.008081057108938694, -0.044407740235328674, 0.03507032245397568, 0.001937499619089067, 0.014186304993927479, 0.12628072500228882, -0.030430365353822708, -0.04866720736026764, 0.013210084289312363, -0.016980409622192383, 0.005275023635476828, -0.023835640400648117, 0.005707911681383848, -0.05744211748242378, 0.006346254143863916, -0.019191494211554527, 0.01221400871872902, -0.07907109707593918, 0.06137964129447937, 0.04707275331020355, 0.08287108689546585, -0.0073803686536848545, 0.027649905532598495, -0.010316222906112671, 0.021928774192929268, 0.022386599332094193, -0.008081244304776192, -0.08943816274404526, -0.029657721519470215, 0.02070242166519165, -0.0171419195830822, -0.011060360819101334, 0.06441378593444824, 0.013387707993388176, -0.02130948007106781, 0.04802257940173149, -0.004597678314894438, -0.03233833983540535, -0.014422554522752762, 0.03262379765510559, -0.011371571570634842, 0.004083083011209965, 0.04122621566057205, -0.0032811518758535385, -0.02016744203865528, -0.06067683547735214, -0.09637036174535751, 0.04615100845694542, 0.09295682609081268, 0.007376312743872404, -0.01367686502635479, 0.07767166197299957, 0.06889878213405609, 0.07197916507720947, 0.007105179131031036, -0.008421759121119976, -0.050276461988687515, -0.01223090011626482, -0.0637795478105545, -0.04606649652123451, 0.029471205547451973, -0.022539643570780754, 0.0606786385178566, 0.0032303305342793465, 0.01799066551029682, -0.04654180258512497, -0.05034226179122925, 0.013827710412442684, 0.02332150563597679, 0.023144058883190155, 0.0029522867407649755, -0.023078996688127518, 0.056477636098861694, -0.043674368411302567, 0.08380834758281708, 0.009411446750164032, 0.1090548187494278, 0.012019572779536247, -0.028741253539919853, -0.022346682846546173, 0.05190473794937134, 0.008740211836993694, -0.030477188527584076, 0.02025759220123291, -0.02650907076895237, -0.011182042770087719, 0.01034223660826683, -0.015964167192578316, -0.00022181117674335837, -0.011221886612474918, -0.0426153764128685, -0.020488115027546883, -0.010929214768111706, -0.031095169484615326, 0.04802793636918068, 0.01929745078086853, -0.048264820128679276, -0.02238822542130947, 0.032858770340681076, -0.019778339192271233, -0.010895367711782455, -0.026569409295916557, 0.06378340721130371, -0.032258711755275726, -0.017156077548861504, -0.07521137595176697, 0.033237274736166, 0.042960986495018005, -0.08312733471393585, 0.028633950278162956, 0.04185043275356293, 0.022137703374028206, -0.029263146221637726, 0.030828114598989487, 0.06520310044288635, 0.048205386847257614, 0.07510238140821457, 0.02141983062028885, -0.0510970763862133, -0.022051824256777763, 0.10121163725852966, 0.03851940855383873, 0.030824990943074226, 0.001069864141754806, -0.027690071612596512, 0.041510604321956635, 0.027295993641018867, 0.021912015974521637, 0.027129163965582848, 0.01524337101727724, -0.018529752269387245, 0.024511178955435753, 0.04249979183077812, -0.04490307718515396, 0.055777404457330704, -0.04046905040740967, -0.02312249317765236, -0.036098383367061615 ]
174
174
Effect of Tuned Parameters on a LSA MCQ Answering Model
This paper presents the current state of a work in progress, whose objective is to better understand the effects of factors that significantly influence the performance of Latent Semantic Analysis (LSA). A difficult task, which consists in answering (French) biology Multiple Choice Questions, is used to test the semantic properties of the truncated singular space and to study the relative influence of main parameters. A dedicated software has been designed to fine tune the LSA semantic space for the Multiple Choice Questions task. With optimal parameters, the performances of our simple model are quite surprisingly equal or superior to those of 7th and 8th grades students. This indicates that semantic spaces were quite good despite their low dimensions and the small sizes of training data sets. Besides, we present an original entropy global weighting of answers' terms of each question of the Multiple Choice Questions which was necessary to achieve the model's success.
[ 0.013109337538480759, -0.040848180651664734, -0.018239716067910194, 0.031672894954681396, -0.00713183032348752, -0.07628443092107773, -0.08593539148569107, -0.001016045338474214, -0.05371220037341118, 0.026932109147310257, 0.010346571914851665, -0.016875114291906357, -0.006891519762575626, 0.038498252630233765, -0.04899228364229202, -0.03242471441626549, 0.02967195212841034, -0.0064726220443844795, 0.026483649387955666, -0.07313897460699081, -0.01925092376768589, 0.010959711857140064, 0.07657550275325775, -0.10600446909666061, 0.05885636433959007, 0.011690638028085232, -0.06569188833236694, -0.057844504714012146, 0.0038860472850501537, -0.03740270808339119, -0.031874384731054306, 0.007502811029553413, 0.003282267600297928, 0.06790535897016525, 0.025563344359397888, 0.0014259079471230507, 0.0062685939483344555, 0.020119667053222656, -0.05166097357869148, -0.04389623925089836, 0.06806830316781998, -0.018355533480644226, 0.0392303541302681, 0.027716223150491714, 0.09922681003808975, 0.02808755822479725, 0.077263243496418, 0.000050672213546931744, 0.003396386746317148, 0.06034024432301521, -0.048199430108070374, 0.055637381970882416, 0.041758839040994644, -0.016796542331576347, -0.013079489581286907, -0.011092258617281914, -0.008231084793806076, -0.01833794079720974, 0.011331511661410332, 0.012045900337398052, 0.017275923863053322, 0.07795044034719467, 0.022933511063456535, -0.012444619089365005, 0.037178654223680496, 0.004554504994302988, -0.08832284808158875, 0.006243535783141851, 0.004761357791721821, -0.005855712573975325, 0.021819932386279106, -0.05714438483119011, -0.01023163367062807, 0.025174807757139206, 0.05832348391413689, 0.008680933155119419, -0.0030943872407078743, -0.03437455743551254, -0.015145091339945793, 0.05091242864727974, -0.044232919812202454, 0.023891422897577286, -0.006242262199521065, 0.021979689598083496, -0.041725873947143555, -0.03847581520676613, 0.05438592657446861, -0.013688845559954643, -0.051196273416280746, -0.014039622619748116, -0.0009456003317609429, -0.008658254519104958, -0.03311759606003761, 0.047213226556777954, 0.0050322674214839935, 0.06335771083831787, 0.017297785729169846, -0.04585085064172745, 0.033285755664110184, -0.018466338515281677, 0.019642377272248268, -0.047606512904167175, 0.00745428865775466, 0.017561566084623337, -0.028165198862552643, 0.04237531125545502, -0.031299691647291183, 0.09201128035783768, 0.04307987913489342, -0.005310001317411661, -0.05665494129061699, 0.008868829347193241, 0.05047919973731041, 0.023916900157928467, -0.01452611479908228, 0.05243711173534393, 0.007331810891628265, 0.13699497282505035, 0.0716099888086319, -0.026610566303133965, -0.024190576747059822, 0.0529136061668396, -0.0695413276553154, -0.010704959742724895, 0.018669050186872482, -0.03908885642886162, -0.00008999295096145943, -0.08586583286523819, 0.06344885379076004, -0.051248226314783096, -0.0344899445772171, 0.03263825923204422, -0.05450420454144478, 0.004929836839437485, -0.02884349226951599, 0.032479967921972275, 0.0432380847632885, -0.09092157334089279, -0.04567544534802437, 0.031947940587997437, -0.009307075291872025, -0.06358563899993896, -0.04833526536822319, -0.0032332437112927437, 0.018556863069534302, 0.03498450294137001, -0.04195817932486534, -0.034346260130405426, 0.047959357500076294, 0.038051385432481766, -0.04476995766162872, -0.0794963538646698, 0.0004927616100758314, 0.06561695784330368, 0.08192731440067291, -0.11290822178125381, -0.058548733592033386, -0.10616757720708847, 0.003861449658870697, 0.04781614989042282, -0.0014658106956630945, 0.010853828862309456, -0.05760890245437622, 0.018795814365148544, -0.0239049531519413, -0.011621230281889439, -0.06600993126630783, -0.003162485547363758, -0.018068207427859306, -0.09704193472862244, -0.027085330337285995, 0.01764245331287384, -0.02666962891817093, 0.06783647835254669, 0.017102934420108795, -0.06270323693752289, 0.042513519525527954, -0.005114537663757801, -0.022059733048081398, 0.019632410258054733, -0.0056751808151602745, -0.03035130724310875, 0.0028599188663065434, -0.020669834688305855, 0.04562734067440033, 0.06616700440645218, -0.02936522103846073, 0.02318512462079525, 0.06324207037687302, -0.028767194598913193, 0.0314779132604599, 0.018921077251434326, 0.041500531136989594, 0.021607214584946632, -0.011555319651961327, -0.026267044246196747, 0.03699219226837158, 0.0060026878491044044, 0.051850151270627975, 0.08462075144052505, 0.0365925095975399, -0.01790153793990612, 0.0037773356307297945, -0.0721176415681839, 0.05698919668793678, -0.02237766981124878, -0.02661929838359356, 0.002373512601479888, 0.029092466458678246, 0.03141654655337334, 0.02784198336303234, -0.007990271784365177, 0.044601697474718094, 0.013628076761960983, 0.00910087488591671, -0.011825785972177982, 0.01667015254497528, -0.040658336132764816, 0.052352529019117355, 0.03227582573890686, -0.01618158258497715, 0.013650783337652683, 0.03551460802555084, 0.07067422568798065, -0.03602571785449982, 0.008071588352322578, 0.05785179138183594, -0.0657910704612732, 0.05164911597967148, 0.07301097363233566, -0.012480140663683414, -0.08856348693370819, -0.08364053070545197, -0.06501925736665726, 0.06283571571111679, 0.05263344570994377, -0.04662705212831497, 0.06117970868945122, 0.019144656136631966, 0.03759979084134102, -0.009092996828258038, 0.0579502135515213, -0.03616226837038994, 0.005493286997079849, -0.020840246230363846, -0.03483972325921059, 0.07207643985748291, 0.013358988799154758, -0.032209042459726334, 0.038058407604694366, -0.021298278123140335, -0.08676418662071228, -0.04153350368142128, 0.046080972999334335, 0.07894919812679291, -0.0008284596260637045, -0.015983518213033676, -0.013256066478788853, -0.003970329649746418, 0.08859387040138245, -0.07330910116434097, 0.04606999456882477, -0.0621073916554451, -0.11176692694425583, 0.06942662596702576, -0.05621649697422981, -0.010004272684454918, -0.031177647411823273, 0.03139134868979454, -0.008359823375940323, 0.004924515727907419, -0.04294919595122337, 0.008713307790458202, 0.000962390739005059, -0.043102871626615524, 0.02724582329392433, 0.03894186392426491, 0.04420756921172142, 0.06718946993350983, -0.011283270083367825, -0.04333936423063278, 0.0038340771570801735, 0.03294892609119415, 0.05115937069058418, -0.0010228636674582958, 0.04530898854136467, 0.03356768935918808, 0.01455245167016983, -0.009705559350550175, -0.006339095067232847, -0.037579018622636795, 0.061253733932971954, -0.038992322981357574, 0.029666706919670105, 0.031051447615027428, -0.05045614391565323, 0.031325168907642365, 0.02648237533867359, 0.03473880887031555, 0.013070154935121536, -0.05153318867087364, -0.00985803548246622, 0.08848746865987778, 0.01011232566088438, 0.04509531706571579, 0.048869334161281586, 0.05003147944808006, 0.04742291569709778, -0.0750352069735527, -0.02097354270517826, 0.07290808856487274, 0.01177522074431181, -0.046280961483716965, -0.013637724332511425, -0.022587861865758896, -0.0440240278840065, -0.04217447713017464, 0.024139540269970894, -0.012240694835782051, 0.014077452942728996, 0.04773386940360069, 0.053354810923337936, 0.07876795530319214, -0.002260436536744237, -0.05130704119801521, -0.00823909416794777, -0.018542015925049782, 0.021351106464862823, -0.09941789507865906, 0.0705120638012886, -0.06480182707309723, -0.05566249415278435, 0.017611300572752953, 0.08197847753763199, 0.004874362610280514, 0.0012785902945324779, -0.09288841485977173, -0.0313490591943264, -0.03309549391269684, -0.01664988324046135, 0.0013146838173270226, 0.030654827132821083, -0.023897459730505943, -0.0020539104007184505, 0.0022996317129582167, -0.01454441249370575, 0.05019056797027588, 0.017011050134897232, -0.055058613419532776, 0.020406456664204597, -0.03865369036793709, -0.006353347096592188, -0.0745338648557663, 0.09942393749952316, -0.010336832143366337, 0.06843211501836777, 0.0434282124042511, -0.01904076337814331, 0.040944408625364304, 0.015087218023836613, -0.0019278159597888589, 0.06067688390612602, -0.026711326092481613, -0.04737713932991028, 0.00023837562184780836, 0.10263659805059433, -0.01105282548815012, -0.028463276103138924, -0.0537920780479908, 0.03603101521730423, 0.016902800649404526, 0.00044473056914284825, 0.06280568987131119, 0.022757234051823616, 0.017908042296767235, -0.05298566445708275, 0.07317440211772919, -0.11724714934825897, -0.0356266088783741, 0.08781203627586365, -0.029127247631549835, -0.041749630123376846, -0.11989092826843262, -0.0032697278074920177, -0.031911250203847885, -0.0009488677023909986, -0.007304287049919367, -0.02462027408182621, 0.03192805126309395, 0.016880225390195847, -0.008146430365741253, -0.043473564088344574, -0.048296552151441574, 0.03716850280761719, 0.06063758581876755, -0.03344637528061867, -0.005861642304807901, -0.013518139719963074, -0.10540077090263367, -0.00975275319069624, -0.020763710141181946, -0.00461925845593214, -0.015604718588292599, -0.044887252151966095, -0.06845898926258087, 0.025473330169916153, 0.02535480633378029, 0.06586258858442307, -0.06068677082657814, 0.06154123321175575, -0.0009201598586514592, 0.06368473917245865, 0.011036645621061325, -0.0032456121407449245, -0.007372946012765169, 0.07788638025522232, 0.006615753285586834, -0.04773232713341713, 0.07208625227212906, -0.07727499306201935, -0.0245012529194355, 0.04232531040906906, 0.02341650240123272, -0.006057499907910824, 0.027026699855923653, -0.017644168809056282, 0.06576501578092575, 0.022039050236344337, 0.02654033713042736, 0.061442337930202484, -0.04875784367322922, 0.03669431805610657, -0.08042042702436447, -0.009710289537906647, 0.022715002298355103, -0.018107576295733452, 0.02970847301185131, -0.026120401918888092, -0.016852140426635742, -0.019262943416833878, -0.09270825982093811, 0.0006952919065952301, 0.06507522612810135, 0.015103274025022984, 0.007790033705532551, 0.013317993842065334, 0.02948523871600628, -0.0054566822946071625, 0.04298117011785507, -0.027761094272136688, -0.0005739960470236838, 0.009963197633624077, 0.004060405306518078, 0.05274570733308792, -0.0008150904905050993, -0.022372113540768623, -0.04090186208486557, -0.08507012575864792, 0.030525051057338715, -0.05451957508921623, -0.0008198001887649298, -0.02794516272842884, 0.010480007156729698, 0.03423801809549332, -0.07236257940530777, 0.05523909255862236, 0.02868770807981491, 0.02549751289188862, 0.06460421532392502, 0.06022350862622261, -0.09395959973335266, -0.07153784483671188, -0.008692617528140545, -0.04503810405731201, -0.04332884028553963, 0.02642347663640976, -0.013890276663005352, -0.10637643188238144, -0.032265204936265945, -0.06329382956027985, 0.008680969476699829, 0.00574883259832859, 0.037079107016325, 0.04456392303109169, -0.035678762942552567, 0.02245054952800274, -0.018576161935925484, 0.014956084080040455, -0.02839544042944908, 0.006683144252747297, 0.003596629947423935, -0.007507269270718098, -0.0025386360939592123, -0.009456518106162548, 0.009234459139406681, 0.05394201725721359, 0.00974999088793993, -0.0590679869055748, 0.0480765625834465, 0.031718332320451736, -0.0051885321736335754, -0.028839580714702606, 0.06416108459234238, 0.07774116098880768, 0.037026967853307724, 0.026948915794491768, 0.05044211074709892, -0.010824024677276611, 0.039791665971279144, -0.020734921097755432, -0.0769696980714798, -0.0017834285972639918 ]
175
175
Adaptive Base Class Boost for Multi-class Classification
We develop the concept of ABC-Boost (Adaptive Base Class Boost) for multi-class classification and present ABC-MART, a concrete implementation of ABC-Boost. The original MART (Multiple Additive Regression Trees) algorithm has been very successful in large-scale applications. For binary classification, ABC-MART recovers MART. For multi-class classification, ABC-MART considerably improves MART, as evaluated on several public data sets.
[ -0.05308176577091217, -0.07941802591085434, -0.022059250622987747, -0.012914738617837429, 0.037292588502168655, -0.0017844343092292547, -0.07419538497924805, -0.018833795562386513, -0.04710952937602997, -0.034880343824625015, -0.0009399811970070004, -0.018530162051320076, 0.010558456182479858, 0.029178453609347343, 0.07095108181238174, -0.04296764358878136, -0.007226772140711546, -0.002214281354099512, 0.0133909210562706, -0.05482301861047745, 0.06211847811937332, -0.04889744892716408, -0.014937321655452251, -0.019009053707122803, 0.014399911276996136, -0.018557017669081688, 0.029884936287999153, -0.042619287967681885, -0.04904208704829216, -0.016614863649010658, 0.02985500730574131, -0.05465472489595413, 0.019967611879110336, 0.027620699256658554, -0.05307424068450928, 0.030824195593595505, 0.06870995461940765, 0.01676994375884533, -0.04165324568748474, 0.029259681701660156, -0.08134949952363968, -0.0008581369766034186, -0.03801256790757179, 0.010041882283985615, 0.09841617196798325, 0.02208455093204975, 0.051347605884075165, -0.0345066674053669, -0.0028074653819203377, 0.021852612495422363, -0.06927608698606491, 0.03824859857559204, -0.017300153151154518, -0.0032399455085396767, -0.04808180034160614, 0.010790850967168808, -0.04272066801786423, 0.052352096885442734, 0.03757312521338463, -0.03254729136824608, 0.07240007072687149, 0.07488613575696945, -0.020342478528618813, -0.004143054131418467, -0.03990211337804794, 0.04185475781559944, -0.0739995464682579, -0.02079044282436371, -0.04090675711631775, -0.03009246289730072, 0.02633783407509327, -0.012948363088071346, -0.0004008193500339985, 0.07781169563531876, -0.0030162660405039787, 0.0027823576238006353, 0.019965965300798416, 0.024228224530816078, -0.030620787292718887, -0.03983557969331741, -0.011409618891775608, 0.013785824179649353, -0.01593203842639923, 0.012215333990752697, 0.029484231024980545, -0.06783617287874222, 0.03260126709938049, -0.007505819667130709, 0.061685431748628616, -0.07578828185796738, 0.0005401783273555338, -0.042969025671482086, -0.11291176080703735, 0.02852644771337509, 0.03790365904569626, -0.014517254196107388, 0.017986221238970757, -0.03247099369764328, -0.01400506030768156, 0.014527765102684498, 0.056047018617391586, 0.03515969216823578, 0.06524466723203659, 0.07791093736886978, -0.01684807986021042, -0.00269890739582479, 0.0011874927440658212, 0.013097567483782768, 0.059969477355480194, -0.020860617980360985, 0.047523584216833115, -0.016454050317406654, 0.014162234961986542, 0.06706879287958145, -0.020222840830683708, -0.011137431487441063, -0.01081792637705803, 0.051499467343091965, 0.041400328278541565, -0.0681668370962143, -0.019400574266910553, -0.03647865355014801, 0.0034094080328941345, 0.13091441988945007, 0.047056231647729874, -0.0923820436000824, 0.022189611569046974, -0.0592399463057518, 0.06626732647418976, -0.009918278083205223, -0.0102774016559124, 0.08993854373693466, -0.022929076105356216, 0.011117275804281235, -0.06452451646327972, -0.009656600654125214, 0.028109688311815262, -0.025765258818864822, 0.06913400441408157, 0.030329570174217224, 0.0019813026301562786, -0.010818532668054104, 0.027799533680081367, 0.08485888689756393, 0.034467779099941254, 0.0025298288092017174, 0.009258377365767956, 0.03955468907952309, -0.01139863207936287, -0.011621186509728432, -0.0418599508702755, -0.03001837059855461, 0.006878828629851341, 0.05813424661755562, 0.05464343726634979, 0.026353558525443077, -0.028458841145038605, -0.06556810438632965, -0.011798543855547905, -0.03484710305929184, -0.06369796395301819, 0.12915492057800293, 0.037528011947870255, -0.015782730653882027, -0.007967987097799778, 0.07822590321302414, 0.031877920031547546, -0.012582988478243351, -0.022310934960842133, -0.0687338337302208, -0.0763334408402443, -0.012396441772580147, -0.058554310351610184, 0.06710304319858551, 0.0017710963729768991, -0.04378171265125275, 0.003382797120139003, 0.03746413066983223, -0.0012960992753505707, 0.01736704260110855, 0.029345300048589706, -0.0697673037648201, -0.09240452945232391, -0.02319847233593464, 0.03797043859958649, 0.04802704229950905, -0.0029367899987846613, 0.014053930528461933, 0.08237766474485397, 0.04771622642874718, 0.017018839716911316, -0.03778678923845291, -0.010867688804864883, 0.06767546385526657, -0.010587088763713837, 0.06901929527521133, -0.004934512544423342, -0.05232229828834534, -0.0106546925380826, -0.04144299775362015, -0.03538767248392105, -0.07268271595239639, -0.017163993790745735, -0.07346443086862564, -0.047405242919921875, 0.0009045791812241077, 0.05853424221277237, -0.03905825689435005, 0.03138068690896034, -0.05721487104892731, 0.018845677375793457, 0.015121187083423138, 0.020620981231331825, 0.03388255089521408, 0.0008450640016235411, -0.05957333743572235, -0.030703702941536903, 0.03603574261069298, 0.06606221944093704, 0.05007088556885719, 0.0009220747742801905, 0.07088208943605423, -0.06843055039644241, 0.04489327594637871, 0.012066874653100967, 0.010237480513751507, 0.046905312687158585, -0.010474827140569687, -0.08634548634290695, 0.03756308928132057, -0.007262714672833681, -0.09038694202899933, -0.009144796058535576, 0.00995668675750494, 0.02873857691884041, 0.06648124754428864, -0.024316221475601196, -0.014842814765870571, 0.06066519767045975, -0.043456174433231354, -0.002626043511554599, 0.09535131603479385, -0.04396628960967064, -0.05452405661344528, 0.027559885755181313, 0.022301938384771347, 0.0001905048848129809, 0.07488109916448593, -0.09605974704027176, 0.007863338105380535, -0.002590987365692854, -0.018738118931651115, 0.02995699644088745, 0.006653332617133856, 0.022327760234475136, -0.01197855919599533, -0.006608069408684969, 0.14051306247711182, 0.02698994055390358, 0.06974367052316666, 0.03675699606537819, 0.05036984756588936, -0.019939886406064034, -0.01748596504330635, 0.020498154684901237, 0.031196001917123795, 0.023595701903104782, -0.01287230383604765, 0.002952582435682416, -0.016929827630519867, -0.03678539767861366, -0.04505768045783043, -0.019529562443494797, 0.031995739787817, -0.0744888186454773, -0.013844205066561699, -0.01960884965956211, -0.03790002688765526, 0.020763540640473366, -0.07424279302358627, -0.058659326285123825, 0.012415493838489056, -0.003565905848518014, 0.0018556439317762852, -0.044232167303562164, -0.005195891484618187, 0.03139056637883186, 0.003163994289934635, -0.03710872679948807, 0.07126391679048538, -0.008182129822671413, 0.037050116807222366, 0.0013711852952837944, -0.014789181761443615, 0.02997957170009613, -0.011881588026881218, -0.0012888329802080989, 0.08703137934207916, 0.021599002182483673, -0.002302753971889615, 0.04811137914657593, 0.01901000365614891, 0.060128435492515564, 0.09202871471643448, 0.014424110762774944, 0.071337029337883, 0.01868405006825924, 0.09369561821222305, -0.05710899084806442, -0.006653549149632454, -0.009838175028562546, -0.04787012189626694, 0.04720674082636833, -0.02590390108525753, 0.020754890516400337, 0.07920055091381073, -0.08758215606212616, -0.025146234780550003, 0.03561059385538101, 0.04265034571290016, 0.05206888169050217, 0.06485141068696976, 0.0032569975592195988, 0.010323163121938705, -0.10940226912498474, -0.015405896119773388, -0.04079161584377289, 0.034960512071847916, -0.05041680857539177, -0.002711074659600854, -0.10639380663633347, -0.042719632387161255, -0.02810138463973999, 0.008957362733781338, -0.004151748027652502, -0.02219683676958084, 0.006536032073199749, -0.019962241873145103, 0.04377248138189316, -0.016625946387648582, -0.0625549778342247, 0.02931729331612587, -0.0323951318860054, 0.04756990447640419, -0.02186526358127594, 0.018203606829047203, -0.008517421782016754, 0.02193576470017433, -0.03847162425518036, 0.004180767573416233, -0.04290414974093437, 0.07418890297412872, -0.10165940970182419, 0.0494111143052578, -0.03143654763698578, 0.033400293439626694, 0.10429313033819199, 0.007977675646543503, 0.013030736707150936, -0.009209674783051014, 0.025053998455405235, -0.05244794487953186, -0.03612765297293663, 0.03230771794915199, -0.02515101432800293, -0.004000883549451828, 0.022643284872174263, 0.06596780568361282, 0.04137803241610527, -0.014169721864163876, -0.008681239560246468, 0.03878834471106529, -0.014359858818352222, -0.04314086586236954, 0.07355387508869171, 0.011506740935146809, 0.05697404220700264, 0.010446734726428986, 0.03710468113422394, 0.034710340201854706, -0.038818877190351486, -0.023707175627350807, -0.03498828038573265, 0.004086869303137064, -0.0656866580247879, -0.03957778587937355, -0.062368299812078476, -0.022966293618083, 0.024327335879206657, -0.02960803546011448, -0.02358333207666874, -0.0701272264122963, 0.029424061998724937, -0.013738215900957584, -0.03273424878716469, 0.017244184389710426, -0.005800721235573292, -0.08581383526325226, -0.04906051233410835, -0.02721860446035862, 0.05876034498214722, -0.04115108773112297, -0.03402537852525711, -0.0674518346786499, -0.04323268309235573, 0.02421511895954609, -0.043290045112371445, 0.0996958389878273, -0.05053658410906792, -0.055369555950164795, 0.01621793769299984, 0.03844504803419113, -0.06283015012741089, 0.022761819884181023, 0.05321100354194641, 0.0362003818154335, 0.0666617900133133, -0.046813853085041046, 0.02390192821621895, -0.07835164666175842, -0.013849741779267788, -0.005955758970230818, -0.0007701293798163533, 0.05509620159864426, 0.05402717739343643, 0.06846606731414795, 0.050573479384183884, 0.10107515752315521, -0.02931356243789196, 0.0235874205827713, -0.06963754445314407, 0.09299319237470627, -0.08818267285823822, -0.03759168088436127, 0.024976376444101334, 0.0270401444286108, 0.06918314099311829, 0.03316207975149155, -0.024127954617142677, -0.012993324548006058, 0.016929464414715767, -0.0059301103465259075, 0.018843751400709152, -0.0056764353066682816, 0.019750744104385376, 0.10657650977373123, -0.03142852336168289, 0.04914580285549164, 0.02658841758966446, 0.02713986299932003, 0.0058627561666071415, -0.04984553903341293, -0.07219263911247253, -0.029470667243003845, 0.007256010547280312, -0.05464745685458183, -0.08114660531282425, -0.07153762131929398, -0.002513868734240532, -0.030405277386307716, 0.010209798812866211, 0.018795177340507507, -0.022950323298573494, 0.013374095782637596, -0.012180634774267673, 0.02034926973283291, 0.002040125662460923, 0.0071904403157532215, -0.028437888249754906, 0.05053281784057617, -0.07046911865472794, -0.04280994459986687, 0.02011890709400177, 0.01247918326407671, -0.021089619025588036, -0.026766963303089142, -0.017381034791469574, -0.03845899924635887, -0.006601543631404638, 0.006191635504364967, 0.03567400202155113, 0.05525548756122589, 0.022692030295729637, 0.01452327799052, -0.026114197447896004, 0.0021335508208721876, -0.007039100397378206, -0.027190230786800385, -0.018991578370332718, 0.014191781170666218, 0.03819909319281578, 0.06130152568221092, 0.06659193336963654, 0.016884367913007736, -0.006112505681812763, 0.0034638193901628256, 0.008510728366672993, 0.04207992926239967, -0.007422910537570715, 0.10001944750547409, 0.009881686419248581, -0.049891646951436996, 0.08049673587083817, -0.00977303646504879, 0.02863950841128826, 0.037033941596746445, 0.013748563826084137, -0.07384348660707474, 0.009781816974282265, 0.0451374389231205, -0.0285544041544199, -0.06745927035808563 ]
176
176
Stability Bound for Stationary Phi-mixing and Beta-mixing Processes
Most generalization bounds in learning theory are based on some measure of the complexity of the hypothesis class used, independently of any algorithm. In contrast, the notion of algorithmic stability can be used to derive tight generalization bounds that are tailored to specific learning algorithms by exploiting their particular properties. However, as in much of learning theory, existing stability analyses and bounds apply only in the scenario where the samples are independently and identically distributed. In many machine learning applications, however, this assumption does not hold. The observations received by the learning algorithm often have some inherent temporal dependence. This paper studies the scenario where the observations are drawn from a stationary phi-mixing or beta-mixing sequence, a widely adopted assumption in the study of non-i.i.d. processes that implies a dependence between observations weakening over time. We prove novel and distinct stability-based generalization bounds for stationary phi-mixing and beta-mixing sequences. These bounds strictly generalize the bounds given in the i.i.d. case and apply to all stable learning algorithms, thereby extending the use of stability-bounds to non-i.i.d. scenarios. We also illustrate the application of our phi-mixing generalization bounds to general classes of learning algorithms, including Support Vector Regression, Kernel Ridge Regression, and Support Vector Machines, and many other kernel regularization-based and relative entropy-based regularization algorithms. These novel bounds can thus be viewed as the first theoretical basis for the use of these algorithms in non-i.i.d. scenarios.
[ -0.04976803809404373, -0.08493182063102722, 0.0752381756901741, -0.047606050968170166, 0.07289162278175354, -0.019619690254330635, 0.023235907778143883, 0.030109215527772903, -0.02793215960264206, 0.08983610570430756, 0.015471621416509151, -0.012960285879671574, -0.031364522874355316, 0.010177994146943092, -0.04016696289181709, -0.050044938921928406, -0.03589780628681183, 0.041620947420597076, -0.016485681757330894, -0.06138339266180992, 0.03534221649169922, 0.020414792001247406, 0.033144451677799225, -0.05938456580042839, -0.047232165932655334, 0.036908138543367386, -0.004735961556434631, -0.019771955907344818, -0.07397051155567169, -0.02885052002966404, -0.04836597666144371, -0.017527533695101738, -0.029073964804410934, -0.029844915494322777, 0.0342465378344059, 0.012104799970984459, 0.0014445766573771834, 0.007997398264706135, -0.04733797907829285, -0.049484241753816605, 0.013598415069282055, -0.03098360449075699, 0.04589231684803963, 0.001578649738803506, 0.04544425755739212, 0.01692454144358635, 0.06437071412801743, 0.006962849758565426, -0.04099736735224724, 0.07402869313955307, -0.06031916290521622, 0.020462021231651306, -0.032418474555015564, -0.08048100769519806, 0.07887791097164154, 0.05236375704407692, -0.004567146301269531, -0.004877269268035889, -0.026729637756943703, 0.01961238868534565, 0.018600745126605034, 0.07374336570501328, -0.008255839347839355, -0.07264421880245209, -0.056655313819646835, 0.0027312193997204304, -0.09376045316457748, 0.002650080481544137, 0.027216505259275436, 0.011001118458807468, -0.05897848308086395, -0.04706112667918205, 0.041827574372291565, 0.02477625198662281, 0.058472905308008194, -0.012931574136018753, 0.02058698609471321, 0.009763206355273724, 0.022215982899069786, 0.030065327882766724, -0.07116849720478058, -0.030852509662508965, -0.014008866623044014, 0.04098290205001831, -0.092336006462574, -0.019357431679964066, -0.001618103706277907, 0.020973820239305496, 0.021057121455669403, -0.04866795614361763, -0.00701121985912323, 0.01083444245159626, -0.07124315947294235, -0.0498456247150898, -0.04357869178056717, 0.036676786839962006, -0.0114524457603693, -0.03542585298418999, -0.02409929223358631, 0.019357850775122643, 0.005129462108016014, 0.014505925588309765, 0.09024453163146973, 0.05918378755450249, -0.00706735672429204, 0.033049337565898895, -0.022341715171933174, 0.007641914300620556, 0.04222475364804268, 0.026782965287566185, -0.005709355231374502, -0.11104170233011246, 0.024307535961270332, -0.015556547790765762, -0.058527443557977676, 0.0738261267542839, 0.011501000262796879, 0.054254207760095596, 0.047774869948625565, 0.044983889907598495, 0.1070205494761467, -0.012902447953820229, -0.001855754991993308, 0.0027553807012736797, 0.03420769050717354, 0.06140735372900963, 0.01587398536503315, -0.08057262748479843, 0.11337096244096756, -0.013577432371675968, 0.002320649800822139, 0.004183734301477671, -0.006363256834447384, 0.027461834251880646, 0.008731427602469921, -0.018758483231067657, -0.0810120478272438, 0.024431820958852768, -0.05118531733751297, 0.04434533044695854, 0.041221197694540024, 0.02686162292957306, -0.01578489877283573, -0.012728823348879814, -0.005295563954859972, 0.04057212918996811, 0.07747785747051239, 0.019570037722587585, -0.016913972795009613, -0.0014980395790189505, 0.0018262320663779974, 0.01982218772172928, 0.008498981595039368, 0.03719048947095871, 0.07729076594114304, -0.04727935791015625, -0.0201535876840353, 0.05699767544865608, -0.052034538239240646, 0.060433778911828995, -0.04101547598838806, 0.04262009263038635, -0.011936127208173275, -0.00002211004357377533, -0.024816473945975304, -0.010044975206255913, 0.032602835446596146, -0.029123006388545036, 0.005803368985652924, 0.020036453381180763, -0.04764159768819809, 0.0033550907392054796, -0.07175862044095993, 0.009586773812770844, -0.05729496479034424, -0.029704026877880096, 0.037905897945165634, -0.003271979745477438, -0.04274656996130943, -0.012573575600981712, 0.017521850764751434, -0.014563188888132572, -0.002518887398764491, 0.06518049538135529, 0.05615678429603577, 0.13965432345867157, -0.005683099385350943, 0.007788486313074827, 0.07947831600904465, 0.0019677195232361555, 0.038990579545497894, -0.04209131374955177, -0.06863284856081009, -0.026769904419779778, -0.07123980671167374, 0.01570196822285652, 0.013233747333288193, 0.0033842946868389845, 0.02053111419081688, 0.014009334146976471, 0.04574117437005043, -0.005997776985168457, -0.05790313333272934, -0.041100990027189255, -0.03449521213769913, 0.03805573657155037, 0.05687975138425827, -0.09986752271652222, -0.02969229780137539, -0.06816094368696213, -0.022376470267772675, -0.015619652345776558, -0.00720160361379385, -0.03889855742454529, -0.011301238089799881, -0.08008801937103271, -0.06386673450469971, -0.0359455905854702, 0.09453558176755905, -0.017694059759378433, 0.003123319474980235, 0.036439478397369385, -0.01399779599159956, 0.058574553579092026, -0.05666185915470123, 0.019716452807188034, 0.03245789185166359, 0.0562148280441761, -0.0537027046084404, 0.04505418986082077, -0.07539326697587967, -0.06414609402418137, 0.010319352149963379, -0.020666496828198433, -0.020297637209296227, -0.001081288093701005, -0.03989063575863838, -0.007879308424890041, -0.009609164670109749, -0.005056755617260933, 0.007582460530102253, -0.016521915793418884, 0.006120920646935701, 0.011972232721745968, 0.019171396270394325, -0.01547322515398264, 0.04561065137386322, 0.000030275245080702007, -0.003892074106261134, -0.001662275055423379, 0.05539971590042114, -0.008288800716400146, -0.04339636117219925, -0.08905995637178421, 0.039988793432712555, -0.04531187564134598, -0.010530686005949974, 0.011341214179992676, 0.027307603508234024, 0.03513828292489052, 0.03526673838496208, 0.05181445553898811, -0.03309542313218117, 0.01962682232260704, 0.06835886836051941, 0.011666051112115383, -0.08166592568159103, 0.020751522853970528, 0.03302477300167084, 0.045873310416936874, -0.07387036830186844, -0.0446961373090744, -0.05243111774325371, 0.013824432156980038, -0.0664321780204773, 0.020865660160779953, 0.05134132131934166, -0.03552991896867752, 0.04486028850078583, 0.026271095499396324, -0.022961119189858437, 0.06574272364377975, -0.002443392062559724, 0.0055303615517914295, -0.05918832868337631, 0.037521034479141235, -0.0547441728413105, 0.0595359168946743, 0.008278786204755306, 0.013484970666468143, -0.017351027578115463, 0.03258843719959259, -0.04638556018471718, 0.027450449764728546, 0.000636903103441, -0.04630601778626442, 0.034522589296102524, -0.03677511215209961, 0.0447855107486248, 0.0007183037814684212, -0.005173998419195414, -0.014007223770022392, 0.006878355517983437, 0.015222116373479366, 0.006986011750996113, 0.0545477457344532, -0.019429035484790802, 0.014663223177194595, -0.03229789063334465, 0.08039380609989166, 0.015123131684958935, -0.09834986925125122, -0.017164701595902443, -0.029682202264666557, -0.06466694176197052, -0.012487654574215412, -0.0780184417963028, -0.03418903052806854, 0.03206894174218178, -0.010238896124064922, 0.036001067608594894, 0.032872505486011505, -0.014598920941352844, -0.01666044443845749, -0.08901937305927277, -0.040602173656225204, -0.018651388585567474, 0.006579138804227114, -0.010824434459209442, -0.0015074179973453283, -0.04445085674524307, 0.01366863027215004, -0.0024040883872658014, 0.04164706915616989, -0.012794784270226955, 0.033990081399679184, -0.049891166388988495, 0.014200516976416111, -0.057795923203229904, 0.02977243810892105, 0.0132617661729455, -0.09147202968597412, 0.04350079223513603, 0.004554359242320061, -0.0076606362126767635, 0.028307747095823288, 0.11270958930253983, 0.0027492304798215628, -0.004232908133417368, -0.010155861265957355, -0.0990925058722496, 0.01575130969285965, -0.016882112249732018, 0.0008421801612712443, -0.05204074829816818, 0.00446107005700469, -0.020169697701931, -0.020818844437599182, 0.06389617919921875, 0.01675650291144848, 0.05434641242027283, 0.05672142654657364, -0.030029350891709328, -0.0443972572684288, 0.006748111918568611, 0.06036520004272461, -0.039829324930906296, -0.018779756501317024, -0.04327643662691116, -0.03457682207226753, -0.07856518775224686, 0.02568063698709011, 0.07575605064630508, 0.10278814285993576, 0.0077148312702775, -0.007826881483197212, 0.04501757398247719, -0.03965297341346741, 0.007686035707592964, 0.07997752726078033, -0.09620960801839828, -0.029370194301009178, -0.014468920417129993, 0.009926064871251583, -0.06351405382156372, -0.010842377319931984, 0.008158506825566292, -0.06986741721630096, 0.04018750786781311, -0.0800485610961914, -0.04870651289820671, -0.05680875852704048, 0.014604142867028713, 0.07089056074619293, 0.0420202910900116, 0.021550709381699562, 0.04323671758174896, -0.009429162368178368, -0.011062996461987495, -0.05862525478005409, 0.06285242736339569, -0.02137352153658867, 0.04990365728735924, -0.03220285102725029, -0.057459406554698944, -0.0011757774045690894, 0.08850407600402832, 0.023703504353761673, 0.03478020057082176, 0.07085705548524857, -0.001978570129722357, 0.03765226900577545, -0.10238093137741089, -0.025819357484579086, -0.008487427607178688, -0.023339496925473213, 0.06314738839864731, 0.009980144910514355, 0.03630303218960762, -0.0530356764793396, -0.04861731082201004, 0.03919683024287224, 0.020377347245812416, 0.02503831312060356, 0.05080065503716469, -0.0002554932434577495, 0.01741577684879303, 0.11026465147733688, 0.004923147149384022, 0.017013005912303925, -0.045231934636831284, -0.013415521010756493, -0.13604548573493958, -0.03871791437268257, 0.06070658192038536, -0.029827265068888664, 0.05452655255794525, 0.042871326208114624, -0.02966165356338024, -0.04887062683701515, -0.06744992733001709, 0.11900912970304489, 0.0356091633439064, -0.012544364668428898, -0.006436692085117102, 0.10872182995080948, 0.018803071230649948, -0.043524276465177536, 0.05869732424616814, 0.030357258394360542, 0.02121783420443535, -0.03747214376926422, 0.01260311808437109, -0.07013630867004395, 0.033995483070611954, 0.028565680608153343, -0.0036335824988782406, 0.03185088932514191, 0.015669813379645348, 0.05710176005959511, -0.04518018290400505, -0.0737411230802536, 0.04464147984981537, 0.023114750161767006, -0.0588710680603981, -0.041848599910736084, 0.00836822111159563, 0.04501938447356224, 0.052595991641283035, -0.07466209679841995, -0.014912974089384079, -0.004038900602608919, 0.020233092829585075, -0.06498615443706512, -0.009483972564339638, 0.025325415655970573, 0.055187128484249115, -0.05907430499792099, -0.018848367035388947, 0.005714870058000088, -0.02549230493605137, -0.05526242032647133, -0.009859406389296055, 0.019003236666321754, 0.05295272916555405, 0.037969041615724564, 0.04736977815628052, -0.01389311347156763, 0.05520501360297203, 0.06193489581346512, 0.05141540616750717, 0.0001533760514575988, 0.01077336072921753, -0.011158498004078865, 0.040415503084659576, -0.015482793562114239, -0.054011113941669464, -0.042189307510852814, 0.011967222206294537, 0.059735625982284546, 0.07321200519800186, -0.025096548721194267, 0.08653800189495087, 0.030632462352514267, 0.03813692554831505, -0.02641245163977146, -0.021072709932923317, 0.030277526006102562, -0.04160996153950691, 0.014880422502756119, 0.0454750657081604, -0.02392260916531086 ]
177
177
Robust Regression and Lasso
Lasso, or $\ell^1$ regularized least squares, has been explored extensively for its remarkable sparsity properties. It is shown in this paper that the solution to Lasso, in addition to its sparsity, has robustness properties: it is the solution to a robust optimization problem. This has two important consequences. First, robustness provides a connection of the regularizer to a physical property, namely, protection from noise. This allows a principled selection of the regularizer, and in particular, generalizations of Lasso that also yield convex optimization problems are obtained by considering different uncertainty sets. Secondly, robustness can itself be used as an avenue to exploring different properties of the solution. In particular, it is shown that robustness of the solution explains why the solution is sparse. The analysis as well as the specific results obtained differ from standard sparsity results, providing different geometric intuition. Furthermore, it is shown that the robust optimization formulation is related to kernel density estimation, and based on this approach, a proof that Lasso is consistent is given using robustness directly. Finally, a theorem saying that sparsity and algorithmic stability contradict each other, and hence Lasso is not stable, is presented.
[ 0.028825465589761734, -0.0450543537735939, -0.03454694151878357, -0.05900450795888901, -0.0063365427777171135, -0.005661963950842619, -0.0015322458930313587, -0.01464102603495121, 0.011962778866291046, 0.11888153105974197, 0.029304074123501778, -0.044389758259058, -0.015461252070963383, 0.07211437821388245, -0.019518950954079628, 0.02318694442510605, 0.061437465250492096, 0.060531135648489, 0.03281797096133232, -0.058128904551267624, -0.03349560126662254, -0.01518457941710949, 0.02704247273504734, -0.09901393204927444, 0.008853539824485779, 0.01626438833773136, 0.016302643343806267, 0.06187385320663452, 0.04141030088067055, 0.015767375007271767, -0.05663555487990379, 0.08513221889734268, 0.05265912413597107, -0.05922913923859596, 0.013899439945816994, -0.046494390815496445, 0.06464188545942307, 0.07719352841377258, -0.02855193242430687, -0.05713329836726189, 0.04177860543131828, 0.002459427108988166, 0.08091606944799423, -0.01707030087709427, 0.023784523829817772, 0.015765415504574776, 0.0685938373208046, 0.05213102325797081, -0.005401976872235537, -0.01603969931602478, -0.04585988074541092, 0.01764252781867981, -0.03577997535467148, -0.029190685600042343, 0.05239596590399742, 0.024476848542690277, -0.06021493673324585, -0.06104383245110512, -0.04322291910648346, 0.03101895935833454, 0.011349945329129696, 0.06454415619373322, -0.029073847457766533, -0.04118725284934044, 0.03602026402950287, -0.03462623804807663, -0.03276948630809784, 0.029201213270425797, -0.04663271829485893, -0.04282630607485771, -0.03782137483358383, -0.062037143856287, 0.025947777554392815, 0.07712222635746002, 0.07174506783485413, -0.026662791147828102, -0.03507794067263603, -0.055670350790023804, -0.013907103799283504, 0.061711397022008896, -0.05514846369624138, -0.01335106324404478, -0.004099240992218256, 0.05239894986152649, -0.09572792053222656, -0.047489672899246216, 0.010434907861053944, 0.009353294037282467, 0.07439666986465454, 0.008250955492258072, -0.023241674527525902, 0.05193498730659485, -0.03955230861902237, 0.030111808329820633, 0.000401160039473325, 0.006418035365641117, 0.017191624268889427, -0.019409166648983955, -0.011581595987081528, 0.094965361058712, -0.01116713136434555, 0.020780295133590698, 0.08052387088537216, 0.11670937389135361, -0.033421147614717484, 0.024263231083750725, -0.04186486825346947, 0.05733921751379967, -0.02695310488343239, 0.008703497238457203, -0.048315275460481644, -0.08043753355741501, 0.004471100401133299, -0.04174569249153137, -0.04865627363324165, 0.08561442792415619, 0.007587742991745472, 0.08264768123626709, 0.015736553817987442, 0.015248307026922703, 0.07574011385440826, 0.041179023683071136, -0.034032661467790604, -0.021610712632536888, 0.007151302881538868, 0.014861400239169598, 0.03134547173976898, -0.10646908730268478, 0.13837724924087524, -0.05402609333395958, -0.032026614993810654, -0.05411624535918236, 0.007670459803193808, 0.008877314627170563, -0.05014995113015175, 0.051023367792367935, -0.009406579658389091, -0.03214558959007263, -0.025229930877685547, 0.0784391462802887, 0.02063962258398533, 0.021904924884438515, -0.019816497340798378, -0.0068918983452022076, 0.015807630494236946, 0.022116273641586304, 0.05087189003825188, -0.058271367102861404, 0.00413014879450202, -0.019233400002121925, 0.04220108687877655, -0.0072780391201376915, -0.005868610460311174, 0.03131531551480293, 0.06669172644615173, -0.12283894419670105, -0.011132384650409222, -0.005762646906077862, -0.017018267884850502, 0.056655075401067734, -0.05654812231659889, 0.02630532719194889, 0.044166889041662216, 0.013761080801486969, -0.03127392753958702, -0.07685509324073792, 0.030423365533351898, 0.018104374408721924, -0.058537062257528305, 0.025412656366825104, -0.021796364337205887, -0.0060610296204686165, -0.0379943922162056, 0.006546595599502325, -0.030349062755703926, 0.04864249750971794, 0.06441322714090347, 0.0017921293620020151, -0.014249609783291817, -0.08721467107534409, 0.029990272596478462, 0.04216267541050911, -0.014788544736802578, 0.08505197614431381, 0.020969117060303688, 0.09903375059366226, -0.006662333849817514, 0.04300916939973831, 0.02103334479033947, -0.01628681644797325, 0.05057130381464958, -0.05625711753964424, -0.002420197008177638, -0.0009440518915653229, -0.009407621808350086, 0.060101207345724106, -0.03662531077861786, -0.062362827360630035, -0.007953157648444176, 0.02816002629697323, 0.06641972064971924, 0.00820315070450306, -0.018141131848096848, -0.08674256503582001, -0.03881674259901047, -0.033231768757104874, 0.04051616042852402, -0.056223586201667786, 0.007665385492146015, 0.014060594141483307, -0.00012780794349964708, -0.010817171074450016, 0.016860900446772575, -0.11896569281816483, 0.021437453106045723, 0.0183127298951149, 0.023608611896634102, -0.051724471151828766, 0.06976717710494995, 0.030507396906614304, -0.06009769067168236, 0.05175479128956795, 0.020766835659742355, -0.0019153400789946318, 0.01635834202170372, 0.025058386847376823, 0.03823794424533844, 0.01030102837830782, -0.004594889935106039, 0.034552015364170074, -0.0006610623095184565, -0.048125509172677994, 0.0016481289640069008, -0.028340328484773636, -0.024074289947748184, 0.025810787454247475, -0.031150948256254196, -0.059500839561223984, 0.012988178059458733, -0.022868746891617775, -0.019986402243375778, 0.02709554135799408, 0.08793289959430695, -0.06068155914545059, -0.030876995995640755, -0.040585581213235855, 0.037290628999471664, 0.005283916834741831, -0.0013252707431092858, 0.002875015838071704, -0.007472135126590729, 0.05166274309158325, -0.0011508588213473558, -0.019577832892537117, 0.025671783834695816, -0.03127375245094299, -0.030082743614912033, -0.03141551837325096, -0.02084221877157688, 0.05911531671881676, -0.03567663952708244, 0.1253625750541687, -0.06333529204130173, 0.006983653642237186, 0.06438145786523819, 0.00016495303134433925, -0.03149265795946121, 0.05412903428077698, -0.015569087117910385, 0.06426657736301422, 0.0129531966522336, 0.002636569319292903, -0.04452025517821312, 0.038483429700136185, -0.06584284454584122, 0.0018726408015936613, 0.03886628523468971, 0.02207358554005623, -0.02633236162364483, -0.008408301509916782, -0.05078301578760147, 0.05456826090812683, -0.00802440382540226, -0.06158504635095596, -0.03430677205324173, -0.01716482825577259, 0.019384494051337242, 0.03337385877966881, -0.051571074873209, 0.027698837220668793, -0.1170453131198883, 0.026787875220179558, 0.032313618808984756, -0.03563588857650757, 0.015933183953166008, 0.005185337271541357, 0.0890083834528923, -0.0352134183049202, 0.012989983893930912, 0.04148121550679207, 0.004642073530703783, -0.07009106874465942, -0.001690724748186767, -0.05703231692314148, -0.014161702245473862, 0.029827745631337166, 0.05957828462123871, 0.025409024208784103, -0.0445559099316597, 0.035913195461034775, -0.0009458103450015187, -0.010615055449306965, -0.06973453611135483, -0.1081852838397026, -0.032179854810237885, -0.0013774214312434196, -0.015890322625637054, -0.011522357352077961, 0.0032289691735059023, -0.0012068116338923573, 0.009594657458364964, -0.047008369117975235, 0.05470973998308182, 0.0040995534509420395, -0.08880578726530075, -0.13005425035953522, -0.06031133607029915, 0.0066294241696596146, -0.057874906808137894, -0.054892513900995255, -0.022322673350572586, -0.025333352386951447, -0.04112877696752548, 0.02710561454296112, -0.01718752644956112, 0.03233560919761658, -0.0636921226978302, -0.06047589331865311, -0.08669596165418625, 0.007472107652574778, 0.007441717199981213, -0.03368404135107994, -0.04169239103794098, 0.030337020754814148, 0.046023428440093994, 0.037038691341876984, 0.046014461666345596, -0.06920868158340454, -0.08045237511396408, 0.025484804064035416, -0.09935679286718369, 0.02764776721596718, 0.045921698212623596, -0.03367561474442482, -0.04801085591316223, 0.009673768654465675, 0.11656255275011063, -0.014017734676599503, -0.018826924264431, -0.0036804580595344305, 0.03256376460194588, 0.04517146199941635, -0.030328813940286636, 0.007413045968860388, -0.027446890249848366, 0.09879601001739502, -0.05155831202864647, 0.028490634635090828, -0.008153155446052551, 0.031077619642019272, -0.011842635460197926, 0.015664558857679367, 0.011407166719436646, -0.006926753092557192, 0.043874554336071014, -0.0508853904902935, 0.03800230845808983, -0.029695818200707436, -0.06128068268299103, -0.0011388480197638273, -0.025981830433011055, -0.028262974694371223, -0.027211403474211693, -0.044654421508312225, -0.01614375226199627, -0.03326832130551338, -0.039755694568157196, -0.031463559716939926, 0.07209540903568268, 0.004248669371008873, -0.00403550174087286, -0.022540606558322906, -0.0005176183767616749, 0.005798935424536467, 0.045530978590250015, 0.014161601662635803, -0.007388611324131489, -0.06967739760875702, 0.02687234990298748, -0.06254860013723373, 0.018625004217028618, 0.017636524513363838, 0.007134616374969482, -0.04250464588403702, -0.05375927686691284, -0.05907614529132843, 0.027618270367383957, 0.032672274857759476, 0.0028185476548969746, 0.03031718172132969, 0.05383741110563278, -0.04823702201247215, -0.08551501482725143, 0.06888505071401596, 0.03932837396860123, 0.03270504251122475, 0.01482608262449503, -0.057427454739809036, 0.023111708462238312, -0.08860210329294205, 0.04236743226647377, 0.01692713424563408, -0.025494050234556198, -0.020600438117980957, 0.05051247775554657, -0.011035002768039703, 0.0236480962485075, 0.05983991175889969, -0.036962542682886124, 0.036780666559934616, 0.006440264172852039, 0.006477109156548977, -0.10496506094932556, -0.035448528826236725, -0.025800125673413277, 0.01818958669900894, -0.005582963116466999, -0.008039549924433231, -0.09770693629980087, 0.03806609287858009, 0.051557622849941254, -0.04805266857147217, -0.026589805260300636, 0.008876669220626354, 0.011809337884187698, 0.05646046623587608, 0.04744942858815193, -0.0029326877556741238, 0.04403424635529518, 0.032457269728183746, -0.028020314872264862, -0.0081249438226223, -0.025383235886693, -0.027388790622353554, 0.011870422400534153, -0.0027332978788763285, -0.014220225624740124, -0.033994339406490326, 0.11317891627550125, -0.02345348708331585, -0.03466202691197395, -0.030746692791581154, 0.02595824934542179, -0.006463887169957161, -0.03175558149814606, 0.02227781154215336, -0.037009336054325104, 0.02266242355108261, -0.014415306970477104, 0.01281373854726553, 0.015018759295344353, -0.017714429646730423, -0.009858354926109314, -0.009558874182403088, 0.04806147515773773, -0.06840525567531586, 0.0323709174990654, -0.07108424603939056, 0.007593066431581974, 0.00678987056016922, -0.06591623276472092, -0.048871949315071106, -0.02614498883485794, 0.03384539112448692, 0.04548812657594681, 0.009958664886653423, -0.020940735936164856, 0.0627981498837471, 0.005962254945188761, -0.004329080227762461, 0.034547094255685806, 0.04413345828652382, 0.02490811049938202, 0.010079077444970608, 0.0260402113199234, 0.03729107603430748, 0.030994081869721413, -0.009466785937547684, 0.0035768775269389153, -0.02863987348973751, -0.04821065440773964, -0.06270868331193924, -0.03306036815047264, 0.01574035733938217, -0.0037877236027270555, 0.07628711313009262, 0.02622910961508751, -0.06571320444345474, -0.006926275789737701, -0.022850021719932556, -0.08360391855239868, -0.02424287237226963 ]
178
178
Land Cover Mapping Using Ensemble Feature Selection Methods
Ensemble classification is an emerging approach to land cover mapping whereby the final classification output is a result of a consensus of classifiers. Intuitively, an ensemble system should consist of base classifiers which are diverse i.e. classifiers whose decision boundaries err differently. In this paper ensemble feature selection is used to impose diversity in ensembles. The features of the constituent base classifiers for each ensemble were created through an exhaustive search algorithm using different separability indices. For each ensemble, the classification accuracy was derived as well as a diversity measure purported to give a measure of the inensemble diversity. The correlation between ensemble classification accuracy and diversity measure was determined to establish the interplay between the two variables. From the findings of this paper, diversity measures as currently formulated do not provide an adequate means upon which to constitute ensembles for land cover mapping.
[ -0.028116589412093163, -0.023161813616752625, 0.023041483014822006, 0.021244676783680916, -0.005184421315789223, -0.006995121482759714, -0.09067901223897934, -0.0018799157114699483, -0.02844434417784214, -0.05847819894552231, -0.014518783427774906, 0.08306041359901428, -0.0439666211605072, 0.03930849954485893, -0.006427718326449394, -0.025459766387939453, 0.013082241639494896, -0.028639983385801315, -0.00881316140294075, -0.037447698414325714, 0.013358475640416145, -0.026253558695316315, 0.04846251755952835, -0.05298258364200592, -0.0308736190199852, 0.017311478033661842, -0.016310280188918114, 0.036103807389736176, -0.06501224637031555, 0.03849814087152481, -0.004821412265300751, 0.016667261719703674, 0.023514363914728165, 0.024406882002949715, 0.04584983363747597, -0.06247004494071007, 0.017892716452479362, 0.008318510837852955, -0.04994317889213562, 0.01152181625366211, -0.02224663831293583, 0.025289252400398254, -0.029374392703175545, 0.023615023121237755, 0.0068307677283883095, 0.09979212284088135, 0.037073273211717606, -0.07781114429235458, 0.02338612824678421, 0.010281050577759743, -0.06690113991498947, 0.026673786342144012, 0.05715752765536308, -0.01247269008308649, -0.08876590430736542, 0.060794223099946976, -0.011076169088482857, -0.024996617808938026, -0.004265615716576576, -0.020697852596640587, 0.13500507175922394, 0.050589848309755325, 0.04477553814649582, 0.000754844571929425, -0.0100339874625206, -0.03384833037853241, -0.04947860538959503, -0.030076781287789345, -0.01080396305769682, -0.07664791494607925, -0.0005319237825460732, -0.002270192140713334, -0.053238507360219955, -0.014549915678799152, 0.026360295712947845, -0.01624840497970581, 0.11800525337457657, -0.0011716308072209358, 0.018580302596092224, 0.02575627528131008, -0.08244896680116653, -0.012234166264533997, 0.08124376833438873, 0.029041724279522896, -0.01249490026384592, 0.008153675124049187, -0.0068925232626497746, -0.003599033923819661, 0.024105636402964592, 0.07159456610679626, -0.055848605930805206, -0.009112176485359669, -0.03850758820772171, 0.04736638441681862, -0.03367011249065399, -0.023584678769111633, 0.014148501679301262, -0.007354374043643475, 0.028533656150102615, 0.07893281430006027, -0.02437271922826767, -0.026402616873383522, 0.04663747176527977, 0.028950724750757217, -0.03608220815658569, 0.039316799491643906, 0.01009351760149002, 0.11535310000181198, -0.0002499848778825253, 0.019254352897405624, 0.0386400930583477, -0.04503695294260979, 0.0033455125521868467, 0.04857129603624344, 0.04475681856274605, -0.06429263949394226, -0.09276630729436874, 0.05813410133123398, 0.06162136048078537, -0.024348359555006027, -0.00486465310677886, -0.01330938097089529, -0.03592349588871002, 0.04511240869760513, 0.050632841885089874, 0.04201563820242882, 0.01442889403551817, 0.009199327789247036, 0.035571057349443436, -0.05127951502799988, -0.09463229775428772, 0.06550008058547974, -0.0064967782236635685, 0.10505999624729156, -0.019003307446837425, -0.0414171926677227, -0.04016697779297829, 0.05674905329942703, 0.04477236792445183, 0.05204089730978012, -0.05477377027273178, -0.030122382566332817, 0.030776724219322205, 0.09979836642742157, 0.0019425664795562625, 0.05441136285662651, 0.013021157123148441, 0.0359964445233345, 0.0005412051104940474, 0.0012279534712433815, -0.03026794269680977, -0.08856578916311264, 0.06491275131702423, 0.055425114929676056, 0.010054409503936768, -0.03529145568609238, 0.03927307948470116, 0.013439169153571129, 0.03636530786752701, 0.01795799843966961, -0.034541599452495575, 0.02296586148440838, 0.022103866562247276, 0.051814474165439606, 0.04641041159629822, 0.037811342626810074, 0.04126502573490143, 0.0596390925347805, 0.02767954021692276, -0.0654621571302414, 0.04684106260538101, 0.032068271189928055, 0.00019573963072616607, -0.02684110775589943, 0.09094798564910889, -0.005563714541494846, -0.028407229110598564, 0.04462720453739166, -0.07881054282188416, 0.021291343495249748, 0.10941868275403976, -0.07499568909406662, -0.01912263035774231, 0.03480786830186844, 0.04804259166121483, 0.03899305313825607, -0.03620937839150429, 0.013185524381697178, -0.030117793008685112, -0.0021711583249270916, 0.04124568775296211, 0.013914722949266434, -0.009548365138471127, -0.003920768387615681, -0.05525844171643257, 0.08421836048364639, -0.012487921863794327, 0.006953796837478876, 0.07116924971342087, 0.008746764622628689, 0.03485364839434624, -0.012421808205544949, -0.019617313519120216, -0.06608588248491287, -0.02703235112130642, 0.07046680152416229, 0.010643914341926575, -0.0027129945810884237, 0.03294741362333298, -0.06267493218183517, -0.012458297424018383, -0.027777934446930885, 0.03872421383857727, 0.04918869957327843, 0.007390154059976339, -0.06848195940256119, -0.09718942642211914, 0.00044987924047745764, 0.05349235609173775, 0.033946216106414795, -0.04132562130689621, -0.005405737087130547, -0.012646653689444065, 0.004294963553547859, 0.016379129141569138, -0.011377871036529541, 0.06714168936014175, -0.0745825320482254, -0.0315425843000412, 0.04296841844916344, -0.14221392571926117, -0.04690701141953468, -0.06542646884918213, -0.09879623353481293, -0.07443541288375854, 0.06119567155838013, -0.06392823159694672, -0.03344845399260521, 0.08289451152086258, -0.012366092763841152, 0.01805291138589382, 0.07963861525058746, -0.004033371806144714, 0.01280887145549059, 0.020704615861177444, -0.03850673884153366, -0.0067075216211378574, 0.013150700367987156, -0.04078466445207596, 0.057177137583494186, -0.05705910921096802, -0.05591833218932152, 0.054461974650621414, -0.006342580076307058, -0.023513326421380043, 0.0729789063334465, -0.00412776367738843, 0.012682498432695866, 0.016895566135644913, 0.061726897954940796, 0.00898407120257616, 0.06376997381448746, 0.036319587379693985, -0.018081357702612877, 0.015533370897173882, 0.0718737468123436, 0.052388936281204224, -0.05329495668411255, 0.04316352307796478, 0.007601565681397915, 0.031278204172849655, -0.037530817091464996, 0.026637425646185875, 0.08848589658737183, -0.013941076584160328, -0.0027136276476085186, -0.003818131284788251, 0.032266661524772644, 0.05093373730778694, -0.06296144425868988, 0.0028888387605547905, -0.0035954387858510017, 0.010741887614130974, 0.006744768936187029, -0.03221821039915085, -0.03556777164340019, -0.0012038103304803371, 0.0033881382551044226, -0.024538690224289894, -0.04351542145013809, 0.015688640996813774, 0.07761060446500778, -0.047890566289424896, -0.03558062016963959, 0.027455946430563927, 0.01678404025733471, 0.016012277454137802, 0.024552680552005768, 0.06474483013153076, 0.01652437634766102, 0.028037041425704956, 0.038675468415021896, 0.08106578886508942, -0.03041212446987629, 0.029728244990110397, -0.0016452019335702062, 0.08954326808452606, 0.1049741804599762, -0.07958563417196274, -0.01881074160337448, 0.03742038831114769, -0.03139397129416466, -0.056018177419900894, -0.03752529248595238, -0.011888088658452034, -0.10214265435934067, -0.032703399658203125, 0.0050812773406505585, 0.001941356691531837, -0.020252006128430367, 0.05885568633675575, -0.026127992197871208, -0.003511191811412573, -0.021571336314082146, -0.057507362216711044, -0.0665525421500206, 0.010780076496303082, 0.009902427904307842, -0.08128292113542557, 0.05569075047969818, -0.053267575800418854, -0.043278537690639496, 0.0035424495581537485, 0.02749435417354107, -0.02319439873099327, 0.008052709512412548, -0.02913479506969452, 0.06308338791131973, -0.060196734964847565, -0.028765110298991203, 0.058739423751831055, -0.011170245707035065, 0.007054746616631746, -0.04544750228524208, -0.0012930080993101, 0.007655459921807051, 0.09022607654333115, 0.0028920299373567104, 0.0003309322928544134, 0.02159617468714714, -0.03181637451052666, 0.03747284784913063, -0.07894258946180344, 0.024126002565026283, -0.036754876375198364, 0.02459547109901905, 0.020454617217183113, 0.012003875337541103, 0.0010261842980980873, -0.009948238730430603, -0.10309050232172012, 0.03821062669157982, -0.042432937771081924, 0.02301419898867607, 0.029782496392726898, 0.062281545251607895, 0.0169407669454813, -0.010442914441227913, 0.05848504975438118, -0.03083268366754055, 0.013161392882466316, 0.09602481126785278, 0.021910546347498894, 0.021110206842422485, 0.002065850654616952, -0.0717485100030899, 0.006965551059693098, -0.008939691819250584, -0.017230309545993805, 0.044441305100917816, -0.03150932490825653, -0.009096835739910603, 0.00578687759116292, 0.017836248502135277, -0.006382765248417854, -0.014119495637714863, 0.05633632093667984, 0.03754900023341179, -0.0057119037955999374, 0.026465121656656265, 0.014082593843340874, -0.02197144739329815, -0.032494526356458664, -0.015866611152887344, 0.007146212738007307, 0.050205640494823456, 0.046101298183202744, 0.007494044490158558, -0.017941493541002274, 0.04125543683767319, 0.013547481037676334, 0.046244725584983826, -0.025085940957069397, -0.08335794508457184, -0.07386614382266998, 0.04254031553864479, -0.02166231907904148, 0.07413241267204285, 0.019221480935811996, 0.016429513692855835, 0.040163714438676834, 0.02719067595899105, 0.0338771790266037, -0.10030943155288696, 0.08756573498249054, 0.07296872138977051, 0.03155894577503204, 0.03451564535498619, -0.033206380903720856, -0.009920216165482998, 0.014581984840333462, -0.011136352084577084, 0.06159880757331848, -0.024593470618128777, -0.01929589733481407, 0.045867566019296646, 0.010089445859193802, 0.03754580765962601, 0.017597440630197525, 0.03106452338397503, -0.009223543107509613, -0.04328334331512451, -0.01175994984805584, 0.024805543944239616, 0.07799001783132553, -0.0062037198804318905, -0.012820509262382984, -0.08939928561449051, -0.03522816672921181, 0.08617205917835236, -0.07146134972572327, -0.006087432149797678, 0.013447913341224194, 0.005889965686947107, 0.01602119952440262, 0.008700717240571976, 0.055551569908857346, 0.07239804416894913, 0.03284326568245888, -0.03727894648909569, -0.08848505467176437, -0.060571830719709396, -0.016536962240934372, 0.020877430215477943, -0.06836088001728058, -0.05673865228891373, 0.023070553317666054, 0.00940646231174469, 0.05022166669368744, -0.06372127681970596, -0.01949365809559822, -0.02988075278699398, 0.030361635610461235, -0.010906160809099674, -0.03747037053108215, 0.018246954306960106, 0.03917742148041725, -0.006764013785868883, 0.03643092140555382, 0.013288785703480244, -0.05616346001625061, -0.026240888983011246, -0.06270215660333633, -0.036910280585289, 0.038913846015930176, -0.052444204688072205, 0.03328636288642883, -0.009243592619895935, 0.017225097864866257, 0.0027164455968886614, 0.05802327021956444, 0.04009772092103958, 0.003160889260470867, 0.0905252993106842, 0.05294303968548775, 0.005433926824480295, -0.0712427869439125, -0.0073437015525996685, -0.0166862104088068, -0.039023708552122116, 0.01813892461359501, 0.05583461374044418, 0.027164997532963753, -0.01616707630455494, -0.00040444463957101107, -0.00035341287730261683, -0.005658994894474745, 0.014705410227179527, 0.0064960261806845665, -0.06528434157371521, -0.05868234857916832, -0.05491482838988304, 0.010366938076913357, -0.09031038731336594, 0.06592387706041336, -0.03201913833618164, 0.03749193251132965, 0.005648516118526459, -0.014040839858353138, 0.009205488488078117, -0.006882648449391127, -0.062381427735090256 ]
179
179
A Spectral Algorithm for Learning Hidden Markov Models
Hidden Markov Models (HMMs) are one of the most fundamental and widely used statistical tools for modeling discrete time series. In general, learning HMMs from data is computationally hard (under cryptographic assumptions), and practitioners typically resort to search heuristics which suffer from the usual local optima issues. We prove that under a natural separation condition (bounds on the smallest singular value of the HMM parameters), there is an efficient and provably correct algorithm for learning HMMs. The sample complexity of the algorithm does not explicitly depend on the number of distinct (discrete) observations---it implicitly depends on this quantity through spectral properties of the underlying HMM. This makes the algorithm particularly applicable to settings with a large number of observations, such as those in natural language processing where the space of observation is sometimes the words in a language. The algorithm is also simple, employing only a singular value decomposition and matrix multiplications.
[ -0.0564594492316246, -0.03300008177757263, 0.04448811337351799, -0.0026274723932147026, -0.039985135197639465, -0.05524579435586929, -0.052556734532117844, 0.03239898383617401, -0.02351471222937107, 0.03350166603922844, 0.007640551775693893, -0.012153958901762962, -0.01912384293973446, 0.09830250591039658, -0.049924109131097794, -0.04682252183556557, 0.019185593351721764, 0.012425249442458153, 0.011022957041859627, -0.06148386001586914, -0.027253752574324608, 0.007228758651763201, 0.05768849700689316, -0.10360298305749893, -0.02010205201804638, 0.0660935714840889, 0.001830334891565144, 0.03661470487713814, 0.014308607205748558, -0.03542818874120712, -0.07478021830320358, 0.04288532957434654, 0.04627351090312004, -0.06448311358690262, -0.022684114053845406, 0.008679411374032497, 0.05465191230177879, 0.025872278958559036, -0.08539595454931259, -0.06538720428943634, -0.006455108057707548, 0.03184755519032478, 0.10439778119325638, -0.0022205915302038193, -0.0010554696200415492, 0.10632748156785965, 0.05777870863676071, 0.027289453893899918, -0.009214757941663265, 0.05067678540945053, -0.04145984724164009, 0.00486229220405221, -0.06920205056667328, -0.0008479923126287758, -0.014135107398033142, 0.0477827712893486, -0.05002596229314804, 0.07458016276359558, 0.06058257445693016, -0.04125940799713135, 0.024967506527900696, 0.07241037487983704, 0.006220103707164526, -0.0035488801077008247, -0.007221781648695469, -0.04349736124277115, -0.15943044424057007, -0.026261748746037483, -0.012537632137537003, -0.03018879145383835, 0.041546780616045, -0.07063734531402588, 0.06805958598852158, -0.02815445326268673, 0.012360647320747375, 0.05089174583554268, 0.030505308881402016, 0.04591559246182442, 0.013030357658863068, 0.09337779879570007, -0.017480680719017982, -0.019280780106782913, 0.06303456425666809, 0.026162128895521164, -0.0557401217520237, -0.058222655206918716, -0.057588063180446625, -0.014923821203410625, 0.030094154179096222, -0.007750925607979298, -0.07099012285470963, -0.02046675607562065, -0.08764755725860596, 0.035723838955163956, -0.06381344050168991, 0.0634567141532898, 0.0026974789798259735, -0.028399722650647163, -0.007713956758379936, 0.0004963784595020115, -0.007343442179262638, -0.030993765220046043, 0.11705143749713898, 0.09025603532791138, -0.018501682206988335, 0.06892398744821548, -0.04862576723098755, 0.07101510465145111, -0.003389922669157386, -0.06421731412410736, 0.025985512882471085, 0.00010299661516910419, 0.09404414147138596, -0.08065307885408401, -0.010149381123483181, 0.07587392628192902, 0.010812405496835709, 0.04940265417098999, -0.008188954554498196, -0.011452327482402325, -0.023836761713027954, 0.028706412762403488, 0.0034792127553373575, 0.027352292090654373, 0.05905524268746376, -0.03360773250460625, -0.033803150057792664, -0.026867741718888283, 0.1261814683675766, -0.010984877124428749, -0.049232322722673416, -0.03133953735232353, 0.02542341686785221, -0.008214885368943214, -0.0575571209192276, 0.010591867379844189, 0.04716034233570099, -0.03143809735774994, -0.01489673275500536, 0.03590153530240059, -0.0008733893628232181, 0.0036401296965777874, 0.045374006032943726, -0.06491430848836899, -0.007741633336991072, -0.0004951247829012573, -0.03748181089758873, 0.02124745026230812, -0.015232076868414879, 0.04061884433031082, 0.0021152852568775415, -0.05363436043262482, 0.03591879829764366, 0.04248841479420662, 0.036393534392118454, -0.019080301746726036, 0.02412397973239422, -0.02142302133142948, 0.05051066353917122, 0.028974395245313644, -0.09748068451881409, 0.006662508938461542, -0.012833613902330399, 0.03706786036491394, -0.00920885056257248, -0.007169722113758326, 0.00048119790153577924, 0.020366240292787552, -0.0016253143548965454, -0.02895117551088333, 0.006910786963999271, -0.038551103323698044, 0.05174415186047554, 0.0019191027386114001, 0.0161347184330225, 0.024379603564739227, 0.008635111153125763, 0.06604458391666412, 0.018650589510798454, 0.008879287168383598, -0.00030461602727882564, -0.07925593107938766, -0.005992747377604246, -0.051505863666534424, 0.009274703450500965, 0.04448351263999939, 0.032975610345602036, 0.08960743993520737, 0.05816623196005821, 0.03802865371108055, 0.018198926001787186, 0.007153509184718132, 0.025334106758236885, -0.04028981924057007, -0.07367470860481262, -0.039968788623809814, -0.042866889387369156, -0.03126927465200424, 0.023546578362584114, 0.06831642985343933, 0.02736024372279644, -0.015783850103616714, -0.023486655205488205, -0.07589571177959442, -0.005068135913461447, 0.03133546561002731, 0.040508270263671875, 0.02968279831111431, 0.01905793510377407, 0.007257335819303989, 0.03356114402413368, 0.009256809018552303, -0.04162091389298439, -0.009525605477392673, 0.02193010225892067, -0.07921863347291946, -0.03640288487076759, -0.016877515241503716, 0.03022894263267517, 0.045829176902770996, -0.08543222397565842, 0.018425391986966133, 0.02133283019065857, 0.06434600800275803, -0.04655276611447334, -0.0019887732341885567, 0.06769344210624695, 0.02175646647810936, -0.007435966748744249, 0.005095470696687698, -0.0367906279861927, -0.05455069988965988, -0.007823404856026173, -0.0005791343282908201, -0.0027364662382751703, 0.0347626693546772, -0.00894185621291399, 0.03902044892311096, -0.0380401574075222, 0.08471526950597763, -0.061730582267045975, 0.01535765454173088, 0.008280336856842041, 0.05035777762532234, -0.026916924864053726, -0.035259462893009186, -0.009093627333641052, 0.021389348432421684, 0.030608927831053734, 0.007320711854845285, 0.008626429364085197, 0.046289049088954926, -0.10246165841817856, -0.01103080902248621, 0.010677234269678593, -0.0334634892642498, -0.03948467969894409, 0.09662940353155136, -0.013286127708852291, 0.10540636628866196, 0.014587363228201866, -0.025498544797301292, -0.034703005105257034, 0.06475081294775009, 0.11477518081665039, -0.01690068282186985, -0.060783300548791885, -0.02377917990088463, -0.0006740366807207465, 0.004882690031081438, 0.0215069018304348, -0.017624881118535995, 0.010590750724077225, 0.10077475756406784, -0.03912024572491646, 0.06818479299545288, 0.005883520934730768, 0.10387290269136429, 0.0002830963348969817, -0.018518216907978058, -0.02885659784078598, 0.052400100976228714, 0.004477602429687977, -0.069943368434906, 0.004067115020006895, 0.00712575064972043, -0.02796817570924759, 0.016582772135734558, -0.05449320003390312, 0.0185948945581913, -0.04921041801571846, 0.05003714561462402, -0.06895925104618073, -0.03360619395971298, 0.032920096069574356, -0.04158104956150055, 0.06192559376358986, -0.045808907598257065, 0.03273722156882286, -0.012567308731377125, 0.00449440348893404, -0.035438839346170425, 0.04411664605140686, -0.008380299434065819, 0.008520707488059998, 0.034849368035793304, 0.0743275061249733, 0.010925555601716042, -0.0445767380297184, 0.03559403494000435, 0.024300599470734596, 0.041718389838933945, -0.029209624975919724, 0.013994479551911354, -0.03604395315051079, -0.0591127835214138, 0.032712578773498535, -0.02472492679953575, -0.06503172218799591, -0.056208301335573196, -0.01045295037329197, -0.02254646085202694, 0.03309516981244087, 0.007768371608108282, -0.01275379117578268, -0.06400922685861588, 0.020994869992136955, 0.06515292078256607, -0.06010795757174492, 0.040784675627946854, -0.00792760867625475, 0.05056626349687576, -0.02587408758699894, 0.06798947602510452, 0.07083268463611603, -0.04097675159573555, -0.03231125697493553, 0.046313632279634476, -0.031161382794380188, 0.0012568269157782197, -0.0861821174621582, -0.06796994060277939, -0.014700598083436489, 0.0028044618666172028, 0.05518602207303047, 0.011729246936738491, 0.045629676431417465, -0.028414543718099594, -0.04051759093999863, -0.010092481970787048, -0.009861224330961704, -0.021702248603105545, 0.027853142470121384, 0.0027321402449160814, 0.011108407750725746, 0.037288062274456024, 0.021235497668385506, -0.008991978131234646, -0.004307846073061228, 0.0583326555788517, 0.020763520151376724, 0.03607330843806267, 0.033230412751436234, -0.0018740581581369042, 0.06080308184027672, 0.06923775374889374, -0.04779382422566414, -0.026225857436656952, -0.07763303816318512, 0.0004965759580954909, -0.009640139527618885, 0.0070165242068469524, 0.0640503391623497, 0.010087345726788044, -0.01798924431204796, 0.007073183543980122, 0.03406188264489174, -0.04607377573847771, 0.018549682572484016, 0.04495770111680031, -0.010919656604528427, -0.03135499730706215, -0.06739308685064316, 0.05740433558821678, 0.030002249404788017, -0.011577246710658073, -0.053451891988515854, 0.03560968115925789, 0.04905305057764053, -0.026018142700195312, -0.0877387672662735, -0.014389043673872948, -0.03186903893947601, 0.06116801127791405, 0.046859193593263626, 0.02097255550324917, 0.007949170656502247, -0.024091223254799843, -0.05060777813196182, 0.008868406526744366, -0.011516441591084003, 0.0214817076921463, 0.021320248022675514, -0.07278791815042496, -0.05459131300449371, 0.004272368736565113, 0.018491113558411598, 0.020270870998501778, -0.018293827772140503, 0.09539660066366196, 0.001431416836567223, 0.05681072548031807, -0.050492063164711, 0.013825069181621075, 0.005702342372387648, 0.09758063405752182, -0.05815337225794792, -0.025441616773605347, 0.01681032031774521, -0.036332063376903534, -0.006869541015475988, 0.05746321380138397, -0.05421558767557144, -0.03903315216302872, -0.0638282373547554, -0.04659782722592354, 0.01252505648881197, 0.07141121476888657, -0.03323504701256752, 0.016548344865441322, -0.09058624505996704, 0.008768909610807896, -0.021017063409090042, -0.011497910134494305, 0.08015529066324234, -0.01437284704297781, 0.03046923503279686, -0.035091400146484375, 0.05841987952589989, 0.05925106257200241, -0.06496015191078186, -0.043584201484918594, -0.015534622594714165, -0.030485134571790695, 0.039024967700242996, -0.004080173093825579, 0.04731535539031029, -0.046407923102378845, 0.03712816163897514, 0.00033754261676222086, 0.05348014459013939, 0.07724808901548386, 0.007989943958818913, -0.017690930515527725, -0.002706766128540039, 0.0004218332760501653, 0.028086377307772636, -0.01419202983379364, 0.07726968079805374, 0.012915209867060184, -0.049524180591106415, -0.01105518452823162, -0.03237561136484146, 0.03373502194881439, -0.016494471579790115, -0.04914321005344391, 0.02864553965628147, 0.0914255753159523, 0.03831787034869194, 0.044621553272008896, -0.0529797226190567, -0.03332667052745819, -0.02553459443151951, 0.023373661562800407, 0.01841161772608757, 0.06063823029398918, 0.057876743376255035, -0.08540581911802292, -0.03798656538128853, -0.030011789873242378, 0.01856289431452751, -0.011448422446846962, -0.020475367084145546, -0.005242630839347839, -0.03111644834280014, 0.07349838316440582, 0.05661186948418617, 0.024393146857619286, 0.02956310100853443, 0.043240077793598175, -0.02484179101884365, -0.03752318397164345, 0.10122732818126678, 0.005997681058943272, -0.04587401822209358, -0.00084475934272632, 0.0369919054210186, 0.007947363890707493, -0.02324734441936016, -0.006422543432563543, 0.03257729113101959, -0.02407524175941944, -0.019561950117349625, -0.009504104033112526, 0.1082526296377182, 0.01880168356001377, 0.023323995992541313, -0.06429464370012283, -0.04617096856236458, 0.08003182709217072, 0.0030244148802012205, 0.02643066644668579 ]
180
180
Learning Class-Level Bayes Nets for Relational Data
Many databases store data in relational format, with different types of entities and information about links between the entities. The field of statistical-relational learning (SRL) has developed a number of new statistical models for such data. In this paper we focus on learning class-level or first-order dependencies, which model the general database statistics over attributes of linked objects and links (e.g., the percentage of A grades given in computer science classes). Class-level statistical relationships are important in themselves, and they support applications like policy making, strategic planning, and query optimization. Most current SRL methods find class-level dependencies, but their main task is to support instance-level predictions about the attributes or links of specific entities. We focus only on class-level prediction, and describe algorithms for learning class-level models that are orders of magnitude faster for this task. Our algorithms learn Bayes nets with relational structure, leveraging the efficiency of single-table nonrelational Bayes net learners. An evaluation of our methods on three data sets shows that they are computationally feasible for realistic table sizes, and that the learned structures represent the statistical information in the databases well. After learning compiles the database statistics into a Bayes net, querying these statistics via Bayes net inference is faster than with SQL queries, and does not depend on the size of the database.
[ -0.05788031965494156, -0.09010431915521622, 0.007363991346210241, 0.05307737737894058, 0.0758427157998085, -0.05009746551513672, -0.03244788572192192, 0.01948804035782814, -0.05561370775103569, 0.005144355818629265, -0.011994551867246628, 0.015038171783089638, -0.009105327539145947, 0.04805607721209526, -0.003975990228354931, -0.043933019042015076, -0.07733489573001862, -0.011032129637897015, 0.0635375902056694, -0.06796076893806458, 0.05324088782072067, -0.0367785319685936, 0.006223525386303663, -0.057517215609550476, 0.054648272693157196, 0.015914849936962128, -0.000056191449402831495, -0.0030487743206322193, 0.022792300209403038, 0.007045262027531862, 0.04390351474285126, 0.011519677005708218, -0.02851451374590397, 0.017238691449165344, -0.027387117967009544, 0.012924457900226116, 0.0008824053220450878, 0.022262167185544968, -0.05716400220990181, 0.018231751397252083, -0.03416365757584572, -0.03445518761873245, 0.007436366751790047, 0.040824975818395615, 0.038388486951589584, 0.019305620342493057, 0.0671241506934166, 0.004789865110069513, -0.037779487669467926, 0.01845662109553814, -0.11573556810617447, -0.03703857213258743, 0.03460436314344406, 0.019533604383468628, -0.07957999408245087, 0.061520591378211975, -0.055093809962272644, -0.01419784501194954, -0.012603717856109142, 0.015076737850904465, 0.05584370344877243, -0.0011993435909971595, -0.0047872853465378284, 0.02673312835395336, -0.003912025131285191, 0.029500877484679222, 0.0012110634706914425, -0.04692357778549194, -0.03711935505270958, -0.044096287339925766, -0.015798931941390038, -0.05173138529062271, 0.05249428376555443, 0.054899588227272034, 0.024550436064600945, -0.05113191157579422, -0.0025870425160974264, 0.001931333332322538, 0.00535293435677886, 0.05208355188369751, -0.0367998331785202, 0.04978890344500542, 0.006713055539876223, -0.017519574612379074, 0.0004209190374240279, -0.027687568217515945, 0.05180872976779938, -0.03851807862520218, 0.002411364810541272, 0.061090435832738876, 0.006295730825513601, 0.028023740276694298, -0.03711337596178055, -0.0006988595123402774, -0.044608224183321, 0.001993604004383087, -0.06749218702316284, 0.08884267508983612, 0.006405095104128122, -0.035494327545166016, 0.02672978676855564, -0.06748015433549881, 0.015983927994966507, 0.06686295568943024, -0.02405395545065403, 0.049451619386672974, 0.039298366755247116, 0.027317214757204056, 0.004237676504999399, -0.012634365819394588, 0.038862306624650955, 0.02890041097998619, -0.028467385098338127, 0.03569832071661949, -0.043573930859565735, 0.01979476399719715, -0.02107003889977932, 0.07222402840852737, -0.012976388446986675, -0.06782826781272888, -0.01923331245779991, 0.0048337033949792385, -0.10647036135196686, 0.012136721052229404, 0.005625862628221512, -0.05715693160891533, 0.018384899944067, -0.01294466108083725, 0.10495776683092117, -0.03544098511338234, -0.061381272971630096, 0.03453720733523369, -0.0440419502556324, 0.011838816106319427, -0.017762847244739532, -0.033737290650606155, 0.01856125518679619, -0.03758694976568222, 0.02068464457988739, -0.02130516991019249, -0.04611574485898018, -0.028945110738277435, -0.029258962720632553, -0.03434249013662338, -0.052012182772159576, 0.08165009319782257, 0.007610534317791462, 0.05096869543194771, 0.057842154055833817, 0.02724514715373516, -0.04076260328292847, -0.09342270344495773, -0.010007078759372234, 0.07925928384065628, 0.023324264213442802, -0.014343087561428547, -0.10912832617759705, -0.05356146767735481, 0.02203076332807541, 0.05574038624763489, 0.014720604754984379, 0.011873251758515835, 0.0016857119044288993, 0.005605772137641907, -0.005838544107973576, -0.013385971076786518, -0.0325976237654686, 0.01519518718123436, -0.0028267111629247665, -0.0007637642556801438, -0.046945929527282715, 0.059499118477106094, -0.056768473237752914, 0.004463421180844307, 0.020578691735863686, -0.060196347534656525, -0.010128175839781761, -0.016942743211984634, -0.029719768092036247, -0.012874431908130646, 0.08925336599349976, -0.06271541863679886, -0.0017359268385916948, 0.00902650412172079, 0.006179848685860634, 0.09133689105510712, 0.022019002586603165, 0.06721878051757812, 0.018823372200131416, -0.03195253759622574, 0.017237216234207153, 0.015377615578472614, -0.003235745942220092, 0.043912895023822784, -0.062431611120700836, 0.0091531528159976, 0.0005716825253330171, -0.03378249704837799, 0.007200874388217926, 0.000011091225132986438, 0.019064661115407944, -0.0380595438182354, 0.019772449508309364, -0.021466616541147232, -0.09908822178840637, -0.002259779255837202, -0.006896153558045626, -0.05129753425717354, -0.08102036267518997, 0.028294874355196953, 0.06213582679629326, 0.04586310684680939, -0.04863857105374336, 0.018930258229374886, 0.02340109646320343, -0.04666117951273918, -0.0974985882639885, -0.07082337141036987, 0.09082189202308655, 0.024703249335289, 0.026556963101029396, 0.04476921260356903, -0.09869587421417236, 0.02880646102130413, -0.04590500518679619, 0.06980282068252563, -0.015639422461390495, -0.051825955510139465, -0.0682513490319252, 0.017839603126049042, -0.014723055064678192, -0.03157563507556915, -0.03049657493829727, 0.05912073329091072, 0.09799415618181229, 0.0035063575487583876, -0.02614486962556839, 0.025725416839122772, -0.031154466792941093, 0.0010021273046731949, -0.07126912474632263, 0.068243607878685, 0.026210825890302658, 0.010305759496986866, 0.055341508239507675, -0.057221222668886185, 0.04922979697585106, -0.024526603519916534, -0.03091207519173622, -0.04634504392743111, 0.04419427365064621, -0.01357418391853571, -0.050481073558330536, -0.03801482915878296, 0.1035497635602951, 0.06063811853528023, -0.05184973403811455, 0.08750534802675247, 0.025349540635943413, 0.08181905001401901, 0.053249794989824295, -0.05830347165465355, -0.015000363811850548, 0.015832457691431046, 0.06685367226600647, 0.02021556906402111, -0.025756899267435074, 0.04789741709828377, -0.0060301790945231915, -0.004517043009400368, 0.007471167482435703, -0.023251239210367203, 0.033188991248607635, 0.018504776060581207, -0.11778920888900757, -0.031296487897634506, 0.08080045878887177, 0.03052973560988903, 0.00867463368922472, -0.0609595812857151, -0.0036242755595594645, 0.0452144481241703, -0.004305641632527113, -0.04621235281229019, -0.08462285995483398, 0.019889866933226585, 0.029251325875520706, 0.03801025450229645, 0.03137493133544922, -0.005631808657199144, -0.06336650252342224, 0.018097244203090668, -0.03353029116988182, -0.00616050697863102, 0.07177950441837311, -0.06609642505645752, 0.025910958647727966, -0.017064720392227173, 0.0636686384677887, 0.005340848118066788, -0.04770738258957863, 0.049360934644937515, 0.05507146194577217, 0.00036810606252402067, 0.006841734517365694, 0.07869865000247955, -0.016869233921170235, 0.08280886709690094, -0.057476647198200226, -0.015792420133948326, 0.018182186409831047, -0.059387098997831345, 0.020139573141932487, 0.025600584223866463, 0.023434214293956757, -0.0180798526853323, 0.005720343440771103, -0.04783328250050545, -0.06793148070573807, -0.0219563040882349, 0.04745503142476082, 0.04820701479911804, 0.009586382657289505, 0.034615617245435715, -0.08896525204181671, 0.027806581929326057, 0.03948310762643814, 0.016767103224992752, -0.016683470457792282, 0.023289764299988747, -0.10267835110425949, -0.0485374741256237, 0.009625053033232689, 0.0814693495631218, -0.020268989726901054, 0.08712809532880783, -0.08660169690847397, -0.02343122288584709, -0.041059087961912155, 0.02599606290459633, -0.05075075849890709, -0.03316716477274895, -0.019943751394748688, 0.01115424744784832, 0.0474090650677681, 0.00349618773907423, 0.10216137021780014, -0.03712804615497589, 0.02504909783601761, 0.054239772260189056, -0.08201279491186142, 0.02571951039135456, -0.022949689999222755, 0.06639263778924942, -0.04623360559344292, 0.04575110971927643, 0.031225308775901794, 0.015863869339227676, 0.03093068301677704, -0.013329461216926575, 0.1010499969124794, 0.00026721780886873603, -0.030230779200792313, -0.025404799729585648, 0.0505598708987236, 0.05116189271211624, -0.05068409442901611, -0.01116732694208622, -0.08529187738895416, -0.0028570014983415604, 0.0589577741920948, -0.022998588159680367, -0.003292939392849803, 0.00883326306939125, 0.003911064472049475, -0.012739873491227627, -0.06472010165452957, 0.010368107818067074, -0.011998596601188183, 0.04181625321507454, -0.07160864770412445, -0.028012320399284363, -0.030284695327281952, -0.01162730809301138, -0.052745457738637924, -0.06738544255495071, -0.021730421110987663, -0.030439384281635284, 0.040075890719890594, 0.027960265055298805, 0.018866777420043945, -0.03206321597099304, 0.032115668058395386, -0.011315661482512951, 0.02969229221343994, 0.006536136846989393, -0.0008544205920770764, 0.03751586005091667, -0.048400670289993286, 0.03176214545965195, -0.03851993754506111, -0.04560472071170807, 0.016773980110883713, -0.023493988439440727, -0.0584426149725914, 0.034487415105104446, -0.013325565494596958, 0.13420861959457397, -0.011054392904043198, 0.013696106150746346, 0.01525502186268568, 0.04727583006024361, -0.022194484248757362, -0.04543241113424301, -0.010618571192026138, 0.035836149007081985, 0.021822242066264153, -0.047141656279563904, -0.022812722250819206, -0.07647526264190674, -0.006394800264388323, 0.013374656438827515, 0.003290780819952488, -0.010366645641624928, -0.016079697757959366, -0.05295504257082939, 0.01993466727435589, 0.018027573823928833, -0.05572473630309105, 0.0018198143225163221, -0.011498638428747654, -0.00860444363206625, -0.12836392223834991, -0.013669935055077076, 0.049759622663259506, 0.07882097363471985, 0.0006916274433024228, -0.04901199787855148, 0.007988311350345612, 0.03781156614422798, -0.013943885453045368, 0.05036451667547226, 0.009698241949081421, 0.02191343531012535, 0.04640224203467369, 0.03441457077860832, 0.05889866501092911, 0.03525855019688606, 0.1021823063492775, 0.03603427857160568, -0.013557781465351582, -0.029013609513640404, -0.021773027256131172, -0.04054766893386841, -0.0766337439417839, -0.01635139435529709, 0.0014630660880357027, -0.07540838420391083, 0.05740203708410263, -0.07186571508646011, 0.03795910254120827, -0.045127008110284805, -0.032163355499506, 0.010092833079397678, -0.0750318169593811, -0.06021996587514877, 0.04713074862957001, 0.0686117559671402, 0.030194057151675224, 0.011405969969928265, -0.044557955116033554, 0.026785288006067276, 0.01875016652047634, -0.05083749070763588, -0.021143758669495583, 0.06277957558631897, 0.006853106897324324, -0.04207983985543251, -0.08182498812675476, -0.005514669697731733, -0.009628993459045887, -0.0038405931554734707, 0.06238056346774101, 0.026249196380376816, 0.06452018767595291, 0.04152662307024002, 0.011377218179404736, -0.021942850202322006, -0.030436165630817413, 0.04405504837632179, -0.024319186806678772, -0.07093904912471771, 0.0088858213275671, 0.012785641476511955, 0.02406795136630535, -0.06764514744281769, -0.009859488345682621, -0.014117378741502762, 0.007116734050214291, 0.05181437358260155, -0.011253493838012218, -0.04840613901615143, 0.04441095143556595, 0.012162063270807266, 0.11565020680427551, 0.025056667625904083, 0.019683267921209335, 0.02160964347422123, -0.033221542835235596, -0.005919241346418858, -0.018267236649990082, -0.02992325648665428 ]
181
181
k-means requires exponentially many iterations even in the plane
The k-means algorithm is a well-known method for partitioning n points that lie in the d-dimensional space into k clusters. Its main features are simplicity and speed in practice. Theoretically, however, the best known upper bound on its running time (i.e. O(n^{kd})) can be exponential in the number of points. Recently, Arthur and Vassilvitskii [3] showed a super-polynomial worst-case analysis, improving the best known lower bound from \Omega(n) to 2^{\Omega(\sqrt{n})} with a construction in d=\Omega(\sqrt{n}) dimensions. In [3] they also conjectured the existence of superpolynomial lower bounds for any d >= 2. Our contribution is twofold: we prove this conjecture and we improve the lower bound, by presenting a simple construction in the plane that leads to the exponential lower bound 2^{\Omega(n)}.
[ -0.06192509084939957, 0.012823398225009441, 0.04636450484395027, -0.050468020141124725, -0.046982813626527786, 0.007066437974572182, 0.06090307608246803, -0.03036433272063732, -0.04354342073202133, -0.004478441551327705, -0.01140680629760027, -0.046980854123830795, -0.037548549473285675, 0.06153436377644539, -0.0000631143047939986, -0.03138275071978569, 0.003568971762433648, 0.05027533695101738, 0.020836735144257545, -0.0674557089805603, 0.03443736582994461, -0.060730528086423874, 0.005566905718296766, -0.037921156734228134, -0.009598702192306519, 0.008158206939697266, 0.05067286640405655, -0.08590591698884964, -0.009688031859695911, -0.004761149175465107, -0.05594140291213989, 0.01191844791173935, 0.03148435801267624, -0.05059749260544777, 0.03109612502157688, -0.07313112169504166, 0.03857974335551262, 0.028472505509853363, -0.043950580060482025, -0.009670151397585869, 0.017957843840122223, 0.00738237239420414, -0.028662899509072304, -0.032812342047691345, 0.015694784000515938, -0.04269825667142868, -0.0114975580945611, 0.021950405091047287, 0.02832055650651455, 0.08176323026418686, -0.07262604683637619, 0.10229016840457916, -0.0626528263092041, 0.053945478051900864, -0.007340736221522093, 0.04123464971780777, 0.003565204795449972, 0.04300346598029137, 0.0025813360698521137, -0.025560079142451286, 0.06112052872776985, 0.05892110615968704, 0.05843481793999672, -0.0391860269010067, -0.00879631843417883, -0.07567502558231354, -0.012189489789307117, -0.001281076343730092, -0.025988465175032616, -0.04961757734417915, -0.034628041088581085, 0.013531259261071682, 0.002050392795354128, 0.003991567064076662, 0.024117356166243553, -0.06549766659736633, -0.02073817327618599, -0.012847361154854298, 0.05341886729001999, 0.11741139739751816, -0.06749297678470612, -0.022823097184300423, -0.006685533560812473, 0.038726557046175, -0.06632035970687866, 0.020019996911287308, 0.059394847601652145, 0.0013072413858026266, -0.052014727145433426, 0.015213730745017529, -0.015580721199512482, 0.03349650278687477, -0.0037431400269269943, 0.06495022773742676, -0.020274555310606956, 0.08058849722146988, -0.01736842468380928, 0.021776454523205757, 0.06227920949459076, 0.05447166785597801, 0.002352422336116433, -0.006336461286991835, 0.05609113350510597, 0.11837821453809738, 0.06256825476884842, -0.022296994924545288, -0.053451307117938995, 0.041786376386880875, -0.06040213629603386, -0.06556171923875809, 0.02802402712404728, -0.06570592522621155, 0.04991063103079796, -0.004097363445907831, 0.0022913566790521145, 0.024564914405345917, 0.013379146344959736, 0.03013477474451065, 0.019541922956705093, 0.004806147888302803, 0.03812476992607117, -0.0005414002225734293, 0.004251967184245586, 0.06026190146803856, 0.03849726915359497, -0.026947012171149254, -0.011326747015118599, 0.018162427470088005, 0.0840054377913475, 0.047373104840517044, -0.03318864479660988, 0.033023301512002945, -0.037572503089904785, -0.006171816028654575, -0.09633421897888184, -0.03537711873650551, 0.0422942228615284, -0.019575633108615875, 0.05772829428315163, 0.09006637334823608, -0.0161605142056942, -0.09773094952106476, -0.011781563982367516, -0.045336052775382996, 0.005689449608325958, 0.01072987075895071, -0.03405691310763359, 0.048861321061849594, 0.012734533287584782, -0.023626012727618217, -0.03721791133284569, -0.0327715240418911, 0.06112976744771004, 0.027252746745944023, 0.015050653368234634, 0.04502175375819206, -0.0042100101709365845, 0.07054655253887177, -0.007323239929974079, 0.0604013055562973, -0.06361977010965347, -0.006729820743203163, -0.0035365931689739227, 0.029776647686958313, 0.025523176416754723, 0.024034997448325157, 0.008637486025691032, -0.09898604452610016, 0.03633845970034599, 0.04459943249821663, 0.035731300711631775, -0.07341516762971878, -0.0089335348457098, 0.0010715819662436843, -0.014405381865799427, -0.018208768218755722, -0.04118514806032181, -0.03687591105699539, 0.006013813894242048, -0.07359473407268524, 0.013429577462375164, -0.0005303270881995559, 0.01767914555966854, 0.09217452257871628, 0.01513424701988697, 0.09974856674671173, 0.0010586305288597941, 0.011834369041025639, 0.08639395982027054, -0.0025502440985292196, 0.06063173711299896, -0.01785844936966896, 0.048139069229364395, -0.02156980335712433, -0.0326981283724308, 0.06471895426511765, -0.05137800797820091, -0.047995906323194504, 0.06291316449642181, 0.03537238761782646, 0.06910160183906555, 0.030711231753230095, -0.09969820827245712, -0.06775342673063278, 0.017196794971823692, -0.004688647575676441, 0.03646741434931755, -0.08546557277441025, -0.05073494836688042, -0.06659136712551117, -0.010575075633823872, -0.05611780285835266, 0.042353563010692596, 0.015679728239774704, 0.04482054337859154, -0.04666101932525635, -0.004841899033635855, 0.01825798861682415, 0.017894871532917023, 0.014000439085066319, -0.055476151406764984, 0.011320439167320728, -0.0212735403329134, 0.0430811308324337, -0.04177456349134445, 0.031112147495150566, 0.00692754378542304, -0.02123250998556614, -0.04545300081372261, 0.017577361315488815, -0.04807699844241142, -0.013312369585037231, -0.018318532034754753, 0.03432733565568924, 0.00019421041361056268, -0.004154903348535299, 0.03500453755259514, 0.037683937698602676, 0.06377220898866653, 0.024612724781036377, 0.013316011987626553, -0.03942662477493286, -0.06908419728279114, -0.041708238422870636, 0.03264474496245384, -0.018008040264248848, 0.07832954078912735, 0.05445858836174011, -0.00988783873617649, 0.007938789203763008, -0.034436751157045364, -0.0029926712159067392, -0.02892404794692993, -0.06667544692754745, 0.0076651806011796, 0.022542502731084824, -0.075410857796669, 0.10649903118610382, 0.048735085874795914, 0.04087894782423973, -0.027459770441055298, 0.07548120617866516, -0.017821406945586205, -0.01719348505139351, 0.029132185503840446, 0.002872755518183112, 0.0002798273926600814, 0.10834868252277374, -0.023490099236369133, 0.05391139164566994, 0.06400454044342041, -0.05837026238441467, -0.01154283806681633, 0.08191931247711182, -0.048024553805589676, -0.04169158264994621, 0.016267886385321617, 0.06233975291252136, 0.0353427492082119, -0.07866320759057999, -0.020501362159848213, 0.04462941735982895, -0.06786098331212997, -0.03096930682659149, -0.023471543565392494, 0.06919997185468674, 0.05370776355266571, -0.026512110605835915, -0.018490754067897797, 0.03597993031144142, 0.00508109712973237, 0.06102696433663368, -0.07589565217494965, -0.06394149363040924, 0.04025571793317795, -0.06885648518800735, 0.09048262238502502, 0.036429114639759064, 0.015178030356764793, -0.052336182445287704, -0.019025353714823723, -0.03973999246954918, 0.037421829998493195, 0.008108788169920444, -0.022732406854629517, 0.0843416154384613, 0.0963289886713028, 0.0007462375215254724, -0.057716380804777145, 0.03406434506177902, 0.0013321377336978912, -0.017067091539502144, 0.01860341615974903, 0.031119713559746742, -0.00921775121241808, -0.05718341842293739, -0.04566720128059387, -0.028889531269669533, -0.007655589375644922, 0.07171827554702759, -0.022240009158849716, 0.05109367519617081, -0.03692002594470978, 0.012863446027040482, -0.04202217981219292, -0.04278477653861046, 0.036625269800424576, -0.028895488008856773, -0.013782930560410023, -0.0696437656879425, -0.08376282453536987, 0.025055592879652977, -0.0385926216840744, 0.025066955015063286, 0.001671760343015194, -0.05100305750966072, -0.027813684195280075, -0.04978109151124954, -0.016199996694922447, 0.020094146952033043, 0.005398938897997141, -0.07886215299367905, 0.07852765917778015, -0.04365367442369461, -0.03575197979807854, 0.08464286476373672, -0.02142474241554737, -0.0018931986996904016, 0.00773415993899107, -0.00009917558782035485, -0.15220974385738373, 0.013961389660835266, 0.00020383844093885273, -0.05174308270215988, -0.025819817557930946, 0.04149232804775238, 0.04297392815351486, -0.020237931981682777, 0.04613179340958595, -0.028334079310297966, 0.008798493072390556, 0.05855061113834381, -0.03866911306977272, 0.04915771260857582, 0.048393864184617996, 0.08308834582567215, -0.007702790200710297, 0.004258852452039719, -0.040985506027936935, -0.01879250817000866, -0.053839705884456635, 0.019676916301250458, -0.05016105994582176, 0.016573235392570496, 0.0028180875815451145, -0.042677558958530426, 0.008036542683839798, -0.018128391355276108, 0.016300173476338387, -0.021637702360749245, -0.05993872508406639, -0.01539689488708973, -0.00624546455219388, -0.00722759123891592, -0.047697875648736954, -0.024524061009287834, 0.04605298116803169, 0.013421191833913326, 0.031480830162763596, 0.04835980013012886, 0.0280159842222929, -0.040188148617744446, -0.015175105072557926, 0.012502381578087807, 0.015194971114397049, 0.02968565560877323, 0.05228143557906151, 0.031641747802495956, -0.0007115185144357383, -0.05574746057391167, 0.026262780651450157, -0.034646086394786835, -0.020383210852742195, 0.017381012439727783, -0.0773443654179573, 0.011881031095981598, 0.014247255399823189, -0.0017290891846641898, -0.04224575683474541, 0.007665147073566914, -0.008353730663657188, -0.06426071375608444, -0.026527462527155876, 0.04981643706560135, -0.04183334484696388, -0.01452971063554287, -0.0081642372533679, 0.007143609691411257, 0.10304027795791626, -0.0817994698882103, 0.018333181738853455, 0.033381860703229904, 0.06044597551226616, -0.08417519927024841, -0.05218008533120155, -0.024856284260749817, 0.028062907978892326, 0.059672243893146515, -0.029957247897982597, -0.023075994104146957, -0.038031015545129776, -0.09467877447605133, -0.09049364179372787, -0.034442439675331116, 0.06771335005760193, -0.026198377832770348, 0.004068877547979355, -0.07186461240053177, 0.03406493365764618, 0.05996761471033096, -0.06076058745384216, 0.02017231285572052, -0.01216674130409956, 0.003165451344102621, -0.005559644661843777, 0.02865881286561489, 0.05535820871591568, -0.047840312123298645, -0.008457403630018234, 0.03374683856964111, 0.005894323345273733, 0.07905682921409607, 0.014094068668782711, -0.04201960936188698, 0.04292776435613632, -0.0021920253057032824, 0.01986023224890232, 0.028305375948548317, 0.02995174564421177, -0.048444703221321106, 0.0063048494048416615, -0.026627996936440468, 0.01689433492720127, -0.04577405005693436, -0.0017402959056198597, 0.016838200390338898, -0.04556148871779442, 0.03448246791958809, -0.05386999994516373, -0.056452468037605286, -0.010642128065228462, 0.08822270482778549, -0.010875824838876724, -0.0377376563847065, -0.03206925094127655, -0.00729111023247242, 0.0759393721818924, -0.020619330927729607, 0.04938910901546478, 0.03456990048289299, -0.04168916121125221, -0.018601028248667717, -0.01672312058508396, 0.029774924740195274, 0.09396122395992279, 0.0027343672700226307, -0.05931214615702629, 0.010543734766542912, 0.006086292210966349, 0.03560851141810417, -0.010476711206138134, -0.015572075732052326, -0.04033246263861656, -0.04265312850475311, -0.10808203369379044, 0.015508120879530907, 0.013972015120089054, -0.019071737304329872, 0.011923084035515785, 0.01404760405421257, -0.038261424750089645, -0.04347456246614456, 0.03907504305243492, 0.06318715214729309, -0.0394720621407032, 0.004510727245360613, 0.017821436747908592, -0.0452735461294651, -0.025470394641160965, 0.01198233850300312, 0.06888975948095322, -0.019037632271647453 ]
182
182
Approximation Algorithms for Bregman Co-clustering and Tensor Clustering
In the past few years powerful generalizations to the Euclidean k-means problem have been made, such as Bregman clustering [7], co-clustering (i.e., simultaneous clustering of rows and columns of an input matrix) [9,18], and tensor clustering [8,34]. Like k-means, these more general problems also suffer from the NP-hardness of the associated optimization. Researchers have developed approximation algorithms of varying degrees of sophistication for k-means, k-medians, and more recently also for Bregman clustering [2]. However, there seem to be no approximation algorithms for Bregman co- and tensor clustering. In this paper we derive the first (to our knowledge) guaranteed methods for these increasingly important clustering settings. Going beyond Bregman divergences, we also prove an approximation factor for tensor clustering with arbitrary separable metrics. Through extensive experiments we evaluate the characteristics of our method, and show that it also has practical impact.
[ -0.03647404536604881, -0.00852827075868845, -0.005765820853412151, -0.021611403673887253, -0.03902613744139671, -0.0778728723526001, 0.08053267747163773, -0.028420517221093178, -0.024079622700810432, 0.031049298122525215, 0.006662311032414436, 0.013631231151521206, -0.045758552849292755, 0.08654317259788513, 0.04547293111681938, -0.022769922390580177, 0.022071262821555138, -0.013983845710754395, 0.023865535855293274, -0.052102625370025635, 0.06716524064540863, -0.004050786606967449, -0.020012931898236275, -0.00002360611870244611, 0.016253067180514336, -0.03285915404558182, 0.003784348489716649, -0.0036565533373504877, -0.019269462674856186, -0.001829028595238924, -0.012549765408039093, -0.01644975133240223, 0.0679757297039032, -0.051388371735811234, -0.003099746536463499, 0.010168283246457577, 0.06608392298221588, 0.09345635026693344, -0.03530282899737358, -0.03179335966706276, 0.05057999864220619, -0.0409487709403038, 0.013597986660897732, -0.03138579800724983, 0.00890014972537756, -0.0009302368853241205, 0.023786740377545357, -0.023058606311678886, 0.01575227826833725, 0.06173902004957199, -0.0857897475361824, 0.05596495419740677, -0.06669535487890244, 0.023572424426674843, -0.018627556040883064, 0.03434121981263161, 0.06696626543998718, 0.03970226272940636, -0.00914731714874506, -0.007735555060207844, 0.05347776785492897, 0.0070022838190197945, -0.011689498089253902, -0.026339689269661903, -0.057453613728284836, -0.05874241515994072, -0.0603180006146431, -0.039492715150117874, -0.03346867114305496, -0.05456557497382164, -0.010356287471950054, -0.05308281257748604, -0.026520222425460815, 0.017751511186361313, 0.03626909852027893, -0.02900836057960987, 0.005527451168745756, 0.019678127020597458, 0.02071225643157959, 0.08579066395759583, -0.03583754971623421, 0.0030815829522907734, 0.011244097724556923, 0.02888123132288456, -0.0619029626250267, -0.004122561775147915, -0.014709051698446274, -0.03760356828570366, 0.02080896683037281, -0.022966178134083748, 0.019442496821284294, -0.01747128739953041, -0.08145173639059067, 0.043854936957359314, -0.010050666518509388, -0.007119912188500166, -0.07095379382371902, -0.0015209250850602984, 0.025402728468179703, 0.012263305485248566, -0.006065766327083111, 0.06996078044176102, 0.0006906444323249161, 0.07347434014081955, 0.023631516844034195, 0.07793068885803223, -0.0860787183046341, 0.07356909662485123, -0.023347456008195877, -0.03149503841996193, 0.00186717021279037, -0.045988764613866806, 0.028622811660170555, -0.02569993957877159, 0.011198989115655422, 0.021937066689133644, 0.008680606260895729, 0.04242962971329689, -0.020836224779486656, 0.03438810631632805, 0.01989479549229145, 0.03806419298052788, -0.025536783039569855, 0.04330927133560181, 0.07748285681009293, -0.05236120522022247, -0.054266221821308136, 0.0007147951400838792, 0.005669397301971912, 0.06328705698251724, -0.03808244317770004, 0.0027715633623301983, -0.019941262900829315, 0.01433775294572115, -0.05995374917984009, 0.023836474865674973, 0.00021112104877829552, -0.0313069112598896, 0.026345249265432358, 0.10675910115242004, -0.01078357920050621, 0.01578863523900509, 0.032659851014614105, -0.037771791219711304, 0.103322334587574, 0.019443975761532784, -0.05162660777568817, -0.0062488168478012085, -0.0629236176609993, -0.038267068564891815, -0.03375241905450821, -0.04428107291460037, 0.016364391893148422, 0.02722816914319992, -0.021241698414087296, -0.016784122213721275, -0.060241036117076874, 0.03578704223036766, 0.014850808307528496, 0.11291512846946716, -0.047089774161577225, 0.04838138446211815, -0.020542774349451065, 0.03763312101364136, -0.008782071061432362, 0.06932403892278671, -0.042836301028728485, -0.036594267934560776, 0.03252330422401428, -0.0004828695673495531, -0.004521655850112438, 0.004387254826724529, -0.015317163430154324, 0.00032031707814894617, 0.012701977975666523, 0.02090585045516491, -0.03643432632088661, -0.01927129738032818, -0.05136298015713692, -0.04626050591468811, 0.03744930773973465, -0.020107591524720192, -0.010159425437450409, 0.040537748485803604, 0.04651621729135513, 0.09300142526626587, -0.0033392065670341253, -0.07117908447980881, 0.017245791852474213, -0.004573386628180742, 0.06874705851078033, -0.029478687793016434, -0.03278050571680069, 0.017512833699584007, -0.0139333326369524, 0.00726128276437521, 0.0015498450957238674, -0.07753204554319382, 0.05950948968529701, 0.06963503360748291, 0.02261226996779442, 0.018101690337061882, 0.03223864734172821, -0.0475749745965004, -0.017925161868333817, 0.00346303335390985, 0.12413190305233002, -0.044556356966495514, -0.02955079823732376, -0.029388150200247765, 0.025865476578474045, -0.043924879282712936, 0.019280124455690384, 0.01915319263935089, 0.0028014169074594975, -0.08770424127578735, -0.034442272037267685, -0.037769563496112823, 0.0004280174325685948, -0.008668134920299053, -0.07536107301712036, 0.09268119931221008, -0.06688349694013596, 0.06009676679968834, -0.04539695754647255, -0.023863686248660088, 0.0069273789413273335, -0.05044151842594147, -0.055459678173065186, -0.051606371998786926, -0.019903503358364105, 0.021577859297394753, -0.028731098398566246, -0.0364508181810379, -0.005801424849778414, 0.0008317552856169641, -0.05721833556890488, -0.07828297466039658, 0.027227886021137238, 0.011559185571968555, -0.02460557222366333, 0.03682584688067436, 0.03425704687833786, -0.05021942779421806, -0.00477251410484314, -0.04212594032287598, 0.06300900131464005, 0.046397071331739426, -0.018174774944782257, 0.009065119549632072, 0.018673954531550407, 0.04277019947767258, -0.002255651168525219, -0.09719597548246384, 0.007359965238720179, 0.05553373321890831, -0.01270382758229971, 0.10179860889911652, 0.10731766372919083, 0.03206326439976692, 0.005435936152935028, 0.05569562688469887, 0.003416249295696616, -0.08808828145265579, 0.02094488963484764, 0.03501666337251663, -0.0289358701556921, 0.03522303327918053, -0.02371961623430252, -0.026932362467050552, 0.0016246825689449906, -0.06775947660207748, -0.09907648712396622, 0.028892727568745613, 0.012889327481389046, -0.05710803344845772, 0.025895552709698677, 0.08733685314655304, -0.005586124956607819, -0.016056939959526062, -0.06544613838195801, 0.011102101765573025, -0.03497520089149475, -0.011384345591068268, 0.010382654145359993, 0.04680197685956955, 0.01049633976072073, -0.011782441288232803, -0.027512747794389725, 0.04574017971754074, -0.016017014160752296, 0.031151218339800835, -0.11994760483503342, -0.02066732756793499, 0.01012440212070942, -0.06163671985268593, 0.04776395484805107, 0.03822910040616989, 0.05133700370788574, 0.013270609080791473, 0.03952689841389656, 0.04417724534869194, -0.00016608493751846254, 0.03906119987368584, 0.048245299607515335, 0.09206065535545349, 0.06408670544624329, 0.05193045362830162, 0.02751232497394085, 0.006038669031113386, 0.05656125023961067, 0.0058206915855407715, 0.009038477204740047, 0.03426111117005348, 0.023995913565158844, 0.006065665744245052, 0.028108801692724228, 0.04097091779112816, 0.019518783316016197, 0.05978994444012642, 0.03644183278083801, 0.00553656741976738, -0.06312374025583267, -0.022875899448990822, -0.08443555980920792, -0.005209420341998339, 0.019740698859095573, -0.024702288210392, -0.00974726676940918, -0.013429724611341953, -0.01206465158611536, 0.07901906222105026, 0.002923565451055765, 0.0049049570225179195, -0.006105383392423391, 0.00758016062900424, -0.010046441107988358, -0.029018301516771317, 0.025062212720513344, -0.008931664749979973, -0.03469383344054222, -0.08202371001243591, 0.03173210471868515, -0.058861128985881805, 0.001492628245614469, 0.12262335419654846, 0.07792723178863525, 0.001059221918694675, -0.023954110220074654, 0.057231605052948, -0.1339574009180069, 0.018985414877533913, -0.027009839192032814, 0.01407967135310173, 0.023182498291134834, 0.020960837602615356, 0.03358786553144455, 0.07639995217323303, 0.041425514966249466, -0.0266692116856575, -0.040284447371959686, 0.054948002099990845, -0.038948796689510345, 0.05412692949175835, 0.060508836060762405, 0.10565894842147827, -0.015179427340626717, -0.01447385922074318, -0.010680782608687878, 0.01700359769165516, -0.00038574630161747336, 0.06213904544711113, 0.11607512086629868, -0.04933426156640053, 0.03762207552790642, -0.06258054822683334, 0.10031356662511826, 0.056953247636556625, 0.041499704122543335, 0.00006375701923388988, 0.006456502713263035, 0.011958379298448563, -0.005733835510909557, 0.019742073491215706, -0.04503151401877403, 0.055712178349494934, 0.044033803045749664, 0.0339142270386219, 0.06731187552213669, -0.0032383122015744448, 0.00013575187767855823, -0.03863263875246048, -0.005496233236044645, -0.025011902675032616, 0.0344604030251503, -0.04673919081687927, 0.06976431608200073, 0.011502671986818314, 0.0032155506778508425, -0.018729282543063164, 0.02519557997584343, -0.01004992239177227, -0.014976682141423225, -0.08292458206415176, -0.05137085169553757, 0.010017024353146553, -0.06171641871333122, 0.0158003568649292, -0.052733879536390305, -0.014780254103243351, 0.024650774896144867, -0.05357635021209717, -0.13186734914779663, 0.03942213952541351, 0.0536016970872879, -0.04144709184765816, -0.0061130463145673275, 0.03265431523323059, 0.08795054256916046, -0.04880426824092865, -0.013711623847484589, -0.014913187362253666, 0.03163442015647888, 0.016857635229825974, -0.040233053267002106, 0.01026879157871008, 0.0777570828795433, 0.04090842977166176, 0.03657136112451553, 0.013450364582240582, -0.0234981719404459, -0.0331045500934124, -0.05919838324189186, -0.001577446237206459, 0.06658453494310379, -0.05124527961015701, -0.02717958763241768, -0.04583427309989929, 0.012197534553706646, 0.010443774051964283, -0.017360715195536613, 0.0812615156173706, -0.04959740489721298, -0.053388457745313644, -0.0562734492123127, 0.08403411507606506, 0.06156650185585022, -0.033844150602817535, -0.03240223601460457, 0.0518483929336071, -0.002139793010428548, -0.016614314168691635, 0.031477443873882294, -0.033864133059978485, 0.019726522266864777, -0.05669543892145157, 0.04494984447956085, 0.011976373381912708, -0.016931530088186264, -0.1041363775730133, -0.07890655845403671, 0.03841264545917511, -0.022731348872184753, 0.031180962920188904, -0.049439653754234314, 0.06687765568494797, -0.030888060107827187, -0.012514741159975529, -0.01831538788974285, -0.018735792487859726, 0.009787291288375854, 0.04173482581973076, -0.015696782618761063, 0.026974905282258987, -0.01460210420191288, 0.031704023480415344, -0.010017056949436665, -0.01917053572833538, -0.026644164696335793, 0.053485073149204254, 0.0011416443157941103, -0.012818831019103527, -0.06904646754264832, 0.0769633874297142, 0.02461857534945011, 0.06573517620563507, -0.011810190044343472, 0.05974782258272171, 0.0673258975148201, -0.04547331854701042, 0.011696843430399895, 0.03949180617928505, -0.014736829325556755, -0.05832112953066826, -0.07467944920063019, -0.039274852722883224, 0.0277943667024374, 0.027156300842761993, -0.04794802516698837, 0.06692031025886536, -0.026279360055923462, -0.06252303719520569, 0.041423145681619644, 0.012806461192667484, -0.026304002851247787, 0.03330512344837189, -0.004594698082655668, -0.007430923171341419, -0.031763579696416855, 0.06668516248464584, 0.014628714881837368, -0.06993649899959564 ]
183
183
A Novel Clustering Algorithm Based on Quantum Games
Enormous successes have been made by quantum algorithms during the last decade. In this paper, we combine the quantum game with the problem of data clustering, and then develop a quantum-game-based clustering algorithm, in which data points in a dataset are considered as players who can make decisions and implement quantum strategies in quantum games. After each round of a quantum game, each player's expected payoff is calculated. Later, he uses a link-removing-and-rewiring (LRR) function to change his neighbors and adjust the strength of links connecting to them in order to maximize his payoff. Further, algorithms are discussed and analyzed in two cases of strategies, two payoff matrixes and two LRR functions. Consequently, the simulation results have demonstrated that data points in datasets are clustered reasonably and efficiently, and the clustering algorithms have fast rates of convergence. Moreover, the comparison with other algorithms also provides an indication of the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
[ -0.05017776042222977, -0.016688577830791473, 0.024591531604528427, 0.003860851749777794, 0.01571093499660492, -0.04979099705815315, 0.012030121870338917, -0.08823735266923904, -0.02971305325627327, 0.03539131581783295, -0.017903247848153114, -0.05571981891989708, 0.01897723227739334, 0.06306865811347961, 0.11456256359815598, 0.022126322612166405, -0.026713991537690163, 0.033081721514463425, 0.0009038402931764722, -0.027401747182011604, 0.042647793889045715, -0.06554949283599854, 0.03683711215853691, 0.0521690770983696, 0.01794121041893959, -0.031266070902347565, 0.04489562660455704, 0.01811901479959488, -0.0601695254445076, 0.04172704741358757, 0.005690332036465406, 0.03755716606974602, 0.06933828443288803, 0.0024468873161822557, 0.0229877270758152, -0.07944474369287491, 0.09856495261192322, -0.053908854722976685, -0.01757735013961792, -0.06790730357170105, -0.07712238281965256, -0.036118585616350174, 0.008244876749813557, 0.0595075823366642, -0.032403651624917984, 0.011930990032851696, 0.009769408032298088, 0.04160066694021225, 0.0038256035186350346, 0.0166839137673378, -0.132418692111969, 0.028262801468372345, -0.04363997280597687, -0.05972239002585411, -0.001337268971838057, 0.004644116852432489, -0.051128875464200974, 0.03555760160088539, -0.03983411192893982, -0.020292680710554123, 0.0818287581205368, 0.06706125289201736, -0.044489264488220215, -0.043074723333120346, -0.008354601450264454, 0.0032330546528100967, 0.04580795019865036, -0.04417823255062103, -0.00602000905200839, -0.05013638362288475, -0.00855958927422762, 0.03546540066599846, 0.01438952423632145, -0.006537741050124168, -0.07454915344715118, 0.04825623705983162, -0.010853325948119164, -0.004060874693095684, -0.007372209802269936, 0.06383001804351807, -0.002245003590360284, -0.05904602259397507, -0.027026785537600517, 0.06939013302326202, -0.008647658862173557, -0.0024158067535609007, 0.03738504275679588, -0.05165481939911842, -0.011701014824211597, -0.01658647693693638, -0.014158843085169792, -0.017967818304896355, -0.040980082005262375, -0.0323304645717144, 0.009213165380060673, 0.04768681153655052, -0.12803269922733307, -0.025074273347854614, 0.0030962927266955376, 0.024151980876922607, -0.0377657487988472, 0.0010591661557555199, 0.02029518224298954, 0.1242671012878418, -0.023341810330748558, 0.04241521283984184, -0.1175447404384613, 0.03976818919181824, 0.029025889933109283, -0.038670580834150314, 0.0054495506919920444, -0.0006054787081666291, -0.005206070374697447, 0.028634434565901756, 0.004597052000463009, 0.05569356679916382, 0.0035255514085292816, 0.09694952517747879, -0.02685890533030033, 0.09933636337518692, 0.02251541055738926, -0.012030051089823246, -0.03386074677109718, -0.02093963883817196, -0.04132707417011261, -0.0411345399916172, -0.08077523112297058, 0.014034095220267773, 0.10126635432243347, 0.05651089921593666, -0.07501430809497833, 0.030378928408026695, -0.08099633455276489, -0.11668027192354202, -0.03029933013021946, -0.0037505216896533966, 0.02961156517267227, -0.01603236049413681, 0.052360501140356064, 0.02334495820105076, -0.01653573289513588, -0.008503434248268604, -0.05265726149082184, 0.0013352890964597464, 0.05745904520153999, -0.0004436550079844892, -0.019472088664770126, 0.06364577263593674, 0.0750906690955162, 0.03678900748491287, -0.005175315774977207, 0.00894500594586134, -0.031248293817043304, 0.02331782877445221, 0.014281964860856533, 0.032638270407915115, -0.07044082134962082, -0.07731568068265915, -0.05447959899902344, 0.04100543633103371, -0.023349367082118988, -0.008749594911932945, -0.05927283316850662, -0.019234389066696167, -0.013097965158522129, 0.02751067467033863, -0.05288117378950119, 0.022600028663873672, -0.025001775473356247, 0.0025593747850507498, 0.07549235224723816, -0.03671986237168312, -0.03610111400485039, -0.01913653500378132, 0.046818140894174576, -0.054187119007110596, -0.029998110607266426, 0.01038674358278513, 0.0033513440284878016, -0.04028089717030525, -0.06335598230361938, -0.017958497628569603, 0.0013678406830877066, 0.03321168199181557, 0.060387831181287766, 0.1250619888305664, 0.03356185555458069, 0.03136090561747551, 0.02256244234740734, 0.030591510236263275, 0.006102736108005047, 0.007746608462184668, 0.04697529226541519, -0.0009792910423129797, -0.047404952347278595, -0.01919645443558693, -0.054513439536094666, -0.0856536254286766, 0.062132734805345535, 0.037078797817230225, 0.013552953489124775, 0.06578139960765839, -0.0662463828921318, -0.012651443481445312, -0.04069230332970619, -0.04506773129105568, -0.025465957820415497, 0.034544702619314194, -0.07443860173225403, -0.038172364234924316, 0.013461020775139332, -0.057795289903879166, -0.039159517735242844, -0.05445975810289383, 0.036064982414245605, 0.0197082981467247, -0.09640029072761536, -0.09893732517957687, 0.04310274124145508, -0.015567701309919357, -0.067452073097229, 0.047676391899585724, -0.05591564252972603, 0.05922582000494003, -0.018165400251746178, 0.0077927508391439915, 0.04768655076622963, -0.01856585033237934, -0.07065856456756592, -0.06565915048122406, -0.017855001613497734, -0.02167525328695774, -0.04817274585366249, 0.009656116366386414, 0.007811699993908405, 0.03177784010767937, -0.038516558706760406, -0.03337017819285393, -0.02795363776385784, 0.015145281329751015, -0.06292424350976944, -0.02048693411052227, -0.0005416270578280091, -0.02030596137046814, 0.07904782891273499, -0.05779387056827545, 0.016692860051989555, 0.06914816051721573, -0.03653401508927345, -0.011055784299969673, 0.033799171447753906, 0.042778655886650085, -0.04830657318234444, -0.03401004150509834, 0.057049449533224106, -0.0032941210083663464, 0.017323512583971024, 0.0037760487757623196, 0.04382284730672836, 0.025760645046830177, -0.04704325273633003, 0.04436475783586502, -0.02806832827627659, -0.027524832636117935, 0.0850067138671875, 0.027989089488983154, -0.0012606509262695909, 0.07805841416120529, -0.0489811971783638, 0.02205698937177658, 0.043775904923677444, -0.032892558723688126, 0.013475104235112667, 0.0758371502161026, -0.045872557908296585, -0.07957549393177032, 0.002961006248369813, 0.0007282367441803217, -0.00646232720464468, -0.06068117171525955, -0.03223095461726189, 0.00827047973871231, -0.0018748557195067406, -0.018492914736270905, -0.015367225743830204, -0.056411124765872955, -0.011420275084674358, 0.010105927474796772, 0.03155819699168205, 0.039269451051950455, -0.026147734373807907, -0.0017100960249081254, -0.0011444160481914878, -0.07451516389846802, 0.03506398946046829, -0.03717385604977608, 0.06403829157352448, 0.006227441597729921, 0.011638937518000603, -0.08967418223619461, -0.06413420289754868, -0.025704478845000267, 0.020693179219961166, 0.022713642567396164, -0.002907978603616357, 0.04470105841755867, 0.04159242659807205, 0.02145625464618206, -0.05594901368021965, -0.030865492299199104, 0.002233871491625905, 0.027985354885458946, 0.01943349838256836, -0.0468364842236042, 0.00952694658190012, 0.07970380783081055, 0.033021312206983566, 0.00309030176140368, 0.039503492414951324, 0.00892405491322279, 0.04676948860287666, 0.01733127236366272, 0.008200609125196934, -0.018852317705750465, -0.02611398510634899, -0.0071439617313444614, -0.003605135018005967, 0.027987491339445114, 0.02729128859937191, 0.05310176685452461, -0.08150222152471542, -0.009998912923038006, 0.010601232759654522, 0.04675177112221718, -0.027050292119383812, 0.03947100788354874, -0.04097172990441322, -0.030773159116506577, 0.01752421446144581, 0.06766305863857269, -0.04782284423708916, -0.0534222275018692, -0.04488113522529602, -0.0005255684372968972, -0.0001772752293618396, -0.010799385607242584, 0.05072137340903282, 0.02302796021103859, -0.023726938292384148, -0.00824696384370327, -0.014736290089786053, 0.060457199811935425, -0.09597218781709671, 0.04988130182027817, -0.020383629947900772, 0.06804678589105606, 0.04772059991955757, 0.0972582995891571, -0.0008634766563773155, 0.003242973005399108, 0.023014774546027184, 0.0019377184798941016, 0.005898468196392059, 0.031699344515800476, 0.045820217579603195, 0.05459718406200409, -0.027858883142471313, -0.03204621747136116, -0.03758522495627403, -0.05274315923452377, 0.010768606327474117, 0.032434072345495224, -0.011586563661694527, -0.021793711930513382, 0.01157479640096426, -0.039574142545461655, -0.0038311509415507317, -0.002885191235691309, 0.03278764337301254, -0.014923487789928913, -0.012554078362882137, 0.036684222519397736, -0.004430552013218403, -0.015036006458103657, 0.01489506009966135, 0.01805543340742588, 0.025080569088459015, -0.029556768015027046, 0.029821714386343956, 0.028884852305054665, -0.024977272376418114, -0.05907174572348595, 0.024410879239439964, -0.012176782824099064, 0.023623641580343246, -0.0890938863158226, 0.036829084157943726, -0.021745353937149048, 0.016672149300575256, -0.07480233907699585, -0.013624893501400948, -0.07842137664556503, -0.021731391549110413, -0.11559877544641495, -0.07095500081777573, 0.08974261581897736, 0.01911768689751625, 0.010342342779040337, 0.026439223438501358, 0.026542149484157562, -0.02056490257382393, 0.006917712278664112, -0.0359073206782341, -0.032241079956293106, -0.005279971286654472, -0.05014824867248535, 0.013398680835962296, 0.009722455404698849, 0.03938885033130646, -0.060373056679964066, -0.024149663746356964, -0.0176566019654274, 0.06185786426067352, -0.016295162960886955, -0.04186057299375534, 0.06875020265579224, 0.011384586803615093, -0.01806246116757393, 0.09615900367498398, 0.1076345220208168, -0.013929590582847595, 0.023058583959937096, -0.009583336301147938, -0.0005635179695673287, -0.00416326429694891, -0.05869481712579727, -0.00124402716755867, -0.0067359753884375095, -0.06577730923891068, 0.0567358061671257, 0.05020106956362724, -0.03858527913689613, -0.06846045702695847, -0.035877808928489685, 0.006463177502155304, 0.025988413020968437, 0.05365373194217682, -0.011201241053640842, 0.05117177963256836, 0.041259221732616425, 0.02452154830098152, 0.014147266745567322, 0.04872642457485199, -0.030897879973053932, 0.06697674840688705, 0.06233203038573265, 0.056967489421367645, -0.008604680188000202, -0.025530952960252762, -0.07885555177927017, -0.07875288277864456, -0.04825488105416298, 0.007668423466384411, 0.03084671124815941, -0.02865711785852909, 0.0297971423715353, -0.07202966511249542, -0.049378592520952225, 0.055680952966213226, -0.028966320678591728, -0.023740675300359726, 0.05456976220011711, 0.008693368174135685, -0.09151869267225266, 0.01166788674890995, 0.049868516623973846, 0.03429213538765907, 0.010582253336906433, 0.008708097040653229, 0.04363507032394409, 0.03861020877957344, 0.01137249730527401, 0.08729173243045807, -0.01632106862962246, 0.06279940158128738, -0.022811535745859146, -0.07967347651720047, 0.06216045469045639, 0.018635733053088188, -0.0222226120531559, -0.01551094837486744, -0.04053601622581482, 0.00945103820413351, -0.032449617981910706, -0.01100156083703041, -0.04748011752963066, 0.057569488883018494, 0.007626010105013847, 0.032894790172576904, 0.04848610237240791, 0.003384974552318454, 0.0059944516979157925, -0.00231424393132329, -0.03027147613465786, 0.05189406871795654, -0.006096542347222567, 0.07550211250782013, -0.029955314472317696, -0.025981228798627853, 0.08787568658590317, -0.05051840841770172, 0.01303689181804657 ]
184
184
Decision trees are PAC-learnable from most product distributions: a smoothed analysis
We consider the problem of PAC-learning decision trees, i.e., learning a decision tree over the n-dimensional hypercube from independent random labeled examples. Despite significant effort, no polynomial-time algorithm is known for learning polynomial-sized decision trees (even trees of any super-constant size), even when examples are assumed to be drawn from the uniform distribution on {0,1}^n. We give an algorithm that learns arbitrary polynomial-sized decision trees for {\em most product distributions}. In particular, consider a random product distribution where the bias of each bit is chosen independently and uniformly from, say, [.49,.51]. Then with high probability over the parameters of the product distribution and the random examples drawn from it, the algorithm will learn any tree. More generally, in the spirit of smoothed analysis, we consider an arbitrary product distribution whose parameters are specified only up to a [-c,c] accuracy (perturbation), for an arbitrarily small positive constant c.
[ -0.04098362475633621, -0.04505787417292595, 0.08585278689861298, -0.03732198849320412, 0.043729547411203384, -0.11998070031404495, -0.041272569447755814, 0.041089773178100586, -0.006087595596909523, 0.0007092490559443831, -0.02171638049185276, -0.010292977094650269, 0.032333794981241226, 0.012352834455668926, -0.013794906437397003, -0.040060386061668396, -0.00624974025413394, -0.018413716927170753, -0.021001458168029785, -0.03668922930955887, 0.022482817992568016, -0.04715713858604431, 0.01549416221678257, 0.014618036337196827, -0.015625296160578728, 0.00596344331279397, 0.033807724714279175, 0.021022723987698555, 0.0006572875427082181, -0.07693561911582947, -0.056043390184640884, 0.012200982309877872, -0.045234959572553635, 0.036563415080308914, 0.02660982497036457, -0.023684043437242508, 0.03984816372394562, 0.008692235685884953, 0.02303982339799404, 0.0005606669583357871, -0.05339229851961136, 0.0275891050696373, 0.023728961125016212, -0.0014718687161803246, 0.025716632604599, 0.012751217000186443, -0.0007034335285425186, -0.0177986491471529, -0.01606457121670246, 0.01121077686548233, -0.05198268964886665, -0.000524683971889317, -0.06024346873164177, -0.02946697734296322, -0.03614356368780136, 0.02459111623466015, 0.01933283545076847, 0.020353445783257484, 0.009328602813184261, -0.04359608516097069, 0.028822820633649826, 0.15017732977867126, -0.053153470158576965, -0.0009270189329981804, 0.002080893376842141, -0.05550676956772804, -0.05867961421608925, 0.016137385740876198, 0.0037318295799195766, -0.049036361277103424, 0.05094008892774582, -0.04394840449094772, -0.026678675785660744, 0.0006749634630978107, -0.003543545724824071, -0.04168439283967018, 0.015645239502191544, 0.08785565197467804, -0.05648710951209068, 0.07538091391324997, -0.06914976239204407, 0.03501928597688675, 0.04808228462934494, 0.010272159241139889, -0.05673258379101753, -0.029084281995892525, 0.0010825874051079154, -0.03278419002890587, -0.04586399346590042, -0.017216311767697334, -0.0704713985323906, 0.08723994344472885, -0.05322082340717316, -0.011169616132974625, -0.06763728708028793, 0.022022845223546028, -0.02222488634288311, 0.029057350009679794, -0.010281700640916824, 0.06963270902633667, -0.007702639326453209, -0.05089043080806732, 0.03263242915272713, 0.031442467123270035, 0.003848747815936804, 0.0025845891796052456, 0.010419564321637154, 0.04864603281021118, 0.00491745350882411, -0.020973533391952515, 0.051676493138074875, 0.01683499477803707, 0.006084890570491552, -0.03022526204586029, -0.06000731140375137, 0.06485845148563385, -0.05765567347407341, 0.045407846570014954, -0.03193444013595581, 0.031076209619641304, -0.01897144876420498, 0.02325708046555519, -0.04844674840569496, 0.024866729974746704, 0.03505183011293411, -0.02825912833213806, 0.05477634072303772, -0.03728070855140686, 0.04213743656873703, 0.03101171925663948, -0.021602924913167953, 0.11049209535121918, -0.04263993725180626, -0.020619485527276993, -0.056745223701000214, -0.0125122694298625, 0.03286796063184738, -0.025934167206287384, 0.01888529397547245, 0.044612377882003784, -0.06647825241088867, -0.09706202894449234, 0.04206443578004837, -0.025998806580901146, 0.013352235779166222, 0.008930414915084839, 0.028932128101587296, 0.07271639257669449, 0.03751446306705475, -0.011410107836127281, -0.02971458248794079, -0.061687275767326355, 0.03661814704537392, 0.07765804976224899, 0.038124796003103256, 0.002143565099686384, 0.04317774996161461, 0.05388610064983368, -0.025917435064911842, 0.05180419608950615, -0.04961184412240982, 0.04917091131210327, -0.01111314631998539, -0.0015081496676430106, 0.06546791642904282, 0.014576494693756104, -0.045395854860544205, -0.03334038332104683, -0.043556760996580124, -0.06759040802717209, -0.0379490964114666, 0.015660841017961502, -0.03105310909450054, -0.058470629155635834, -0.015815315768122673, -0.026528889313340187, 0.011612658388912678, 0.02448999136686325, -0.05004996806383133, -0.0022279825061559677, 0.06887276470661163, -0.045368492603302, -0.015212113969027996, -0.02392801269888878, -0.02883952669799328, 0.06901947408914566, 0.007691164501011372, 0.03394893929362297, 0.07417294383049011, 0.09321623295545578, 0.035206712782382965, -0.05583029240369797, 0.03883383795619011, 0.012067976407706738, -0.026678618043661118, -0.02141917310655117, -0.09258244931697845, -0.10961615294218063, -0.00455496134236455, 0.09737902134656906, 0.056540023535490036, 0.030482331290841103, -0.032725971192121506, -0.07472368329763412, -0.028141845017671585, 0.008560634218156338, 0.060877714306116104, -0.0396852120757103, 0.019827984273433685, -0.03396347537636757, -0.04443465918302536, 0.11025992035865784, -0.010508614592254162, -0.023355508223176003, 0.02629350684583187, -0.0385860912501812, -0.02261677384376526, -0.03534264490008354, 0.04221011698246002, 0.06256603449583054, -0.02787085995078087, -0.0014925847062841058, -0.007430688012391329, 0.07268209010362625, -0.06046024337410927, 0.06722825765609741, 0.05341363325715065, 0.014430312439799309, -0.02156820334494114, 0.06377390772104263, -0.06847436726093292, -0.014135829173028469, -0.02087169699370861, 0.0006070186500437558, -0.037906330078840256, 0.09115910530090332, 0.03400261327624321, -0.03546586260199547, -0.02601052261888981, 0.058331169188022614, 0.02390599437057972, 0.04568754881620407, -0.028350068256258965, -0.02871371991932392, -0.014263086020946503, 0.045828212052583694, 0.004143344704061747, 0.08623839169740677, -0.005007864907383919, 0.01998097263276577, -0.03647272288799286, -0.05023974925279617, -0.051451314240694046, 0.0022622758988291025, -0.05123554915189743, -0.02614804171025753, -0.04501606151461601, 0.08061812818050385, 0.05827073007822037, -0.03438131511211395, 0.021324068307876587, -0.00906539335846901, 0.03303965926170349, -0.0021240641362965107, 0.049371637403964996, 0.07993937283754349, -0.004166776780039072, -0.01747632771730423, 0.0021994225680828094, 0.10022671520709991, -0.009521108120679855, -0.062307726591825485, -0.008134684525430202, 0.08951742202043533, -0.04398134723305702, 0.027699416503310204, 0.025997912511229515, -0.00009372463682666421, 0.04119246453046799, -0.05857865884900093, -0.07740271836519241, -0.05070898309350014, 0.026566753163933754, 0.05368119850754738, -0.036666445434093475, 0.07310296595096588, -0.044597260653972626, 0.017038660123944283, 0.05798334255814552, 0.08372475206851959, 0.04144347086548805, 0.07154344767332077, -0.025349264964461327, -0.022324617952108383, 0.0025971694849431515, -0.011839138343930244, 0.0825425460934639, -0.035733237862586975, 0.04500768333673477, -0.029937410727143288, 0.012657057493925095, -0.040465593338012695, 0.04924265667796135, 0.05622324347496033, 0.04389159381389618, 0.032658301293849945, -0.008218321017920971, -0.008292862214148045, -0.059070225805044174, 0.029704956337809563, 0.042276784777641296, 0.04690942168235779, -0.04981273040175438, 0.06908524036407471, -0.020939823240041733, -0.01272488385438919, -0.006334618665277958, -0.01617688313126564, 0.01984870433807373, 0.04167651757597923, -0.03623052313923836, 0.001736697624437511, -0.041481032967567444, -0.005720831453800201, -0.024994537234306335, -0.016115106642246246, 0.06685122847557068, 0.08179076015949249, -0.05769473686814308, -0.0042482465505599976, 0.05375754460692406, -0.0022613273467868567, -0.029087169095873833, 0.09495890885591507, -0.08567801862955093, 0.04650484770536423, -0.05662047863006592, 0.02626078762114048, -0.0009626928367651999, 0.006675345823168755, 0.0013917845208197832, -0.04873164743185043, 0.003913257736712694, -0.0258747898042202, 0.02845109812915325, 0.0640278160572052, 0.04147237539291382, -0.009315542876720428, -0.021410804241895676, 0.0509873628616333, -0.07791806757450104, 0.01046544685959816, -0.012985937297344208, 0.046000294387340546, -0.021324602887034416, 0.037156280130147934, 0.014237633906304836, -0.055928364396095276, -0.004959391430020332, -0.006260141730308533, -0.052038535475730896, -0.00999982189387083, -0.06018419936299324, -0.009765745140612125, -0.0014293089043349028, 0.04090038686990738, 0.020542073994874954, -0.0012046379270032048, -0.02563357539474964, -0.03590720519423485, -0.029355956241488457, -0.013025298714637756, 0.046590063720941544, 0.05137481540441513, -0.00028884163475595415, -0.02493908442556858, 0.08160921931266785, 0.007315673865377903, -0.008951239287853241, 0.039526235312223434, -0.012529830448329449, -0.055337194353342056, -0.0017092464258894324, -0.049381885677576065, 0.031442731618881226, -0.0246437881141901, -0.018139023333787918, -0.017643950879573822, 0.1315118670463562, 0.010616296902298927, 0.051550015807151794, -0.06198752298951149, -0.039998609572649, -0.04713856801390648, -0.007957994006574154, -0.015507424250245094, 0.040249649435281754, -0.008430836722254753, -0.00221141055226326, -0.017432624474167824, 0.02325425297021866, -0.07556471973657608, 0.04482797905802727, -0.052779436111450195, -0.058771487325429916, -0.030496729537844658, -0.023109611123800278, 0.06143895536661148, -0.006552133709192276, 0.016200711950659752, 0.007842345163226128, 0.04824119433760643, -0.01315773744136095, 0.049131132662296295, 0.017078932374715805, 0.009046122431755066, -0.0451652966439724, -0.06629633158445358, -0.005359367933124304, -0.07831832766532898, 0.006817799061536789, 0.03410538658499718, -0.025642184540629387, -0.042724382132291794, 0.015305092558264732, -0.05085494741797447, 0.027498655021190643, 0.06055733561515808, -0.009823461063206196, 0.09214645624160767, -0.024668289348483086, -0.014489337801933289, -0.02610510215163231, 0.037225913256406784, -0.033160336315631866, -0.029892925173044205, 0.01612742617726326, -0.02269342914223671, 0.02151099219918251, -0.020560257136821747, -0.11750338971614838, -0.039091527462005615, 0.024951642379164696, -0.022484632208943367, 0.005670891609042883, 0.10778278857469559, 0.009097429923713207, -0.015681039541959763, -0.008987323381006718, 0.04589395225048065, -0.02011169120669365, -0.055403321981430054, 0.039673998951911926, -0.06029082462191582, 0.007065219338983297, 0.007555728778243065, 0.04070865362882614, -0.01288844458758831, 0.08089067041873932, 0.002383176703006029, -0.013296111486852169, -0.06452435255050659, 0.006014040671288967, 0.02593405544757843, -0.08512666821479797, 0.009590616449713707, 0.11861839890480042, 0.03465183451771736, 0.012922189198434353, 0.07051810622215271, -0.030869901180267334, 0.05187832936644554, -0.05281687155365944, -0.07144718617200851, 0.005697822198271751, -0.001270486623980105, 0.024080095812678337, -0.05648156628012657, 0.05137719586491585, -0.01453421637415886, -0.011814027093350887, -0.03549399971961975, -0.05932311713695526, 0.0013139628572389483, 0.05340413749217987, -0.03358348086476326, -0.0019311917712911963, -0.019522903487086296, 0.02207067422568798, 0.029611462727189064, 0.04506577178835869, -0.01362530142068863, 0.05617871508002281, 0.03256268799304962, 0.021049920469522476, 0.04628223925828934, 0.06764166057109833, -0.007226040121167898, 0.02875469997525215, -0.004166018217802048, 0.07743677496910095, -0.04585273563861847, 0.1721377968788147, 0.020071662962436676, 0.08993525058031082, -0.015714533627033234, 0.024076059460639954, -0.016077574342489243, 0.0017135703237727284, 0.03214658796787262, -0.01658465899527073, 0.04417639225721359 ]
185
185
Uncovering protein interaction in abstracts and text using a novel linear model and word proximity networks
We participated in three of the protein-protein interaction subtasks of the Second BioCreative Challenge: classification of abstracts relevant for protein-protein interaction (IAS), discovery of protein pairs (IPS) and text passages characterizing protein interaction (ISS) in full text documents. We approached the abstract classification task with a novel, lightweight linear model inspired by spam-detection techniques, as well as an uncertainty-based integration scheme. We also used a Support Vector Machine and the Singular Value Decomposition on the same features for comparison purposes. Our approach to the full text subtasks (protein pair and passage identification) includes a feature expansion method based on word-proximity networks. Our approach to the abstract classification task (IAS) was among the top submissions for this task in terms of the measures of performance used in the challenge evaluation (accuracy, F-score and AUC). We also report on a web-tool we produced using our approach: the Protein Interaction Abstract Relevance Evaluator (PIARE). Our approach to the full text tasks resulted in one of the highest recall rates as well as mean reciprocal rank of correct passages. Our approach to abstract classification shows that a simple linear model, using relatively few features, is capable of generalizing and uncovering the conceptual nature of protein-protein interaction from the bibliome. Since the novel approach is based on a very lightweight linear model, it can be easily ported and applied to similar problems. In full text problems, the expansion of word features with word-proximity networks is shown to be useful, though the need for some improvements is discussed.
[ 0.06831309199333191, -0.007029724307358265, 0.0507265105843544, 0.05905970185995102, 0.026345089077949524, 0.02612040936946869, -0.05009470880031586, -0.0346207395195961, -0.0778995081782341, -0.002310830634087324, -0.03271821513772011, -0.08450458198785782, 0.01189777534455061, -0.005817907862365246, 0.0016112683806568384, 0.018547363579273224, -0.04616353288292885, -0.06372520327568054, -0.061795637011528015, -0.03693516179919243, 0.039865512400865555, 0.0928153544664383, -0.09528811275959015, 0.01607554592192173, 0.029969915747642517, 0.0007468356634490192, -0.03178960457444191, 0.030743135139346123, 0.08651136606931686, 0.03965071216225624, -0.025130383670330048, -0.008699459955096245, 0.06616877019405365, 0.045985084027051926, -0.0492827333509922, 0.00535049382597208, 0.00810782890766859, 0.00808076560497284, -0.01905227079987526, -0.004697011783719063, 0.007052718196064234, -0.11143825203180313, 0.03744259476661682, -0.014276202768087387, 0.10167810320854187, 0.02389058656990528, -0.05421243607997894, 0.05178765952587128, 0.007867355830967426, 0.006556077394634485, -0.06909266114234924, -0.029601765796542168, 0.04285376891493797, 0.0012054957915097475, -0.06353170424699783, -0.019188757985830307, -0.06538484990596771, 0.03324513882398605, 0.07639721035957336, 0.011799477972090244, 0.04849623143672943, 0.026923945173621178, 0.003415052080526948, 0.0025056006852537394, -0.05458122864365578, -0.028665047138929367, 0.008539329282939434, -0.023568591102957726, 0.017215797677636147, 0.03831794485449791, -0.012077920138835907, -0.044449176639318466, 0.014239894226193428, 0.0454767681658268, 0.0359637588262558, 0.05376238748431206, -0.0003133089339826256, -0.06057252362370491, 0.058792293071746826, 0.023844139650464058, -0.04536782577633858, -0.004874454811215401, 0.0013964750105515122, 0.006913155782967806, -0.025113416835665703, -0.026141636073589325, -0.008196573704481125, -0.013143433257937431, -0.011828429065644741, 0.0034088531974703074, -0.008360615000128746, -0.0344964936375618, -0.07864979654550552, -0.008293242193758488, 0.018111351877450943, 0.015781057998538017, -0.02805585414171219, -0.007858993485569954, 0.057085949927568436, 0.051511019468307495, 0.004822409711778164, -0.033174898475408554, 0.021041324362158775, -0.0019484482472762465, -0.03500772640109062, -0.02877892181277275, -0.08119788020849228, 0.04868290200829506, -0.01081516407430172, 0.04182526096701622, -0.04089057072997093, 0.039076630026102066, 0.016326433047652245, 0.07216423749923706, -0.039031580090522766, 0.0499219074845314, 0.0002353797317482531, 0.10429764539003372, 0.05069340020418167, -0.02038315124809742, -0.017722949385643005, 0.030563926324248314, -0.08083783090114594, 0.02401055209338665, 0.04436594620347023, -0.05488166585564613, -0.06863951683044434, -0.0194881372153759, 0.04307049512863159, -0.018081478774547577, -0.08212834596633911, 0.048333391547203064, -0.022322164848446846, 0.005346619989722967, -0.035302724689245224, 0.024840831756591797, 0.029926089569926262, -0.017037872225046158, -0.03277911990880966, -0.003284989157691598, -0.02585313841700554, -0.002194796223193407, 0.003970221150666475, 0.0014540936099365354, -0.023374542593955994, -0.004275165498256683, -0.046853870153427124, 0.01362521294504404, 0.025009093806147575, 0.006476764567196369, -0.053426265716552734, -0.042864423245191574, 0.02266031876206398, 0.04962990805506706, -0.007808626629412174, -0.029039157554507256, -0.05922038108110428, -0.10306794941425323, -0.018928376957774162, 0.0459020771086216, -0.03795403987169266, -0.0164693221449852, 0.01209526788443327, -0.03759726136922836, -0.06774521619081497, 0.018685096874833107, -0.058107927441596985, -0.036519624292850494, 0.009005608968436718, -0.03405323997139931, -0.0043140738271176815, -0.016223153099417686, 0.06632401049137115, 0.07150361686944962, 0.025345830246806145, -0.012382342480123043, -0.04948532208800316, 0.005631768610328436, -0.08213415741920471, 0.0339609794318676, 0.07959624379873276, -0.10173919796943665, -0.0019482679199427366, 0.013967777602374554, 0.022110214456915855, 0.07283669710159302, 0.02878597192466259, 0.011734173633158207, 0.03376489877700806, -0.03876512125134468, 0.017775464802980423, 0.02924218960106373, 0.05698275566101074, 0.08480563014745712, -0.021622925996780396, -0.008868868462741375, 0.06595420092344284, -0.06558198481798172, 0.01558357011526823, 0.03425552695989609, -0.009329382330179214, 0.023783499374985695, 0.0013842071639373899, -0.06311467289924622, 0.020823128521442413, 0.01885892078280449, -0.002450572559610009, -0.04932247847318649, 0.011253885924816132, 0.027608705684542656, 0.07386638969182968, -0.03705001249909401, 0.10789909958839417, 0.08716921508312225, -0.005039946176111698, 0.04087984561920166, 0.008439571596682072, -0.05540290102362633, 0.0043892571702599525, 0.04389457032084465, 0.04166296496987343, 0.03413769230246544, 0.019833585247397423, 0.04449353739619255, -0.0309714674949646, 0.03720865771174431, -0.033780649304389954, -0.05205240845680237, -0.05720209330320358, 0.007756339386105537, -0.03674876317381859, -0.04857158288359642, -0.08313871920108795, -0.07014865428209305, 0.0756528228521347, -0.053791433572769165, -0.06211535260081291, -0.011614413000643253, 0.012219639495015144, -0.03360810875892639, -0.018842875957489014, 0.026300352066755295, 0.05742643401026726, -0.07872813194990158, 0.05173342302441597, 0.021544672548770905, 0.04421377182006836, 0.0358528271317482, -0.041361574083566666, 0.021897880360484123, -0.0401155911386013, -0.08903449773788452, -0.034488484263420105, 0.06131991371512413, 0.07017513364553452, 0.03802710399031639, 0.022049956023693085, -0.0031126909889280796, -0.007271126378327608, 0.02827656827867031, -0.03904830664396286, 0.05153068155050278, 0.00561589514836669, 0.0043982709757983685, 0.053548455238342285, 0.00512367719784379, -0.026352060958743095, 0.02321767807006836, -0.04762253910303116, 0.0234682634472847, 0.02405528724193573, -0.08214269578456879, -0.010358267463743687, 0.04557777941226959, -0.06173162907361984, -0.024385793134570122, 0.020567284896969795, 0.11634033173322678, -0.03657934442162514, 0.034434277564287186, -0.03776121139526367, -0.009929017163813114, 0.0209808349609375, 0.004786685109138489, 0.004256545566022396, 0.022264525294303894, 0.023359039798378944, 0.023714208975434303, 0.006113398354500532, -0.056606225669384, -0.118087999522686, 0.02600632607936859, -0.033102747052907944, 0.028723254799842834, 0.06757590919733047, -0.04856056347489357, -0.04424719139933586, 0.08506812155246735, 0.08960946649312973, 0.016676364466547966, -0.024378560483455658, 0.0031139927450567484, 0.05681336671113968, -0.008759464137256145, 0.05592433735728264, 0.003172778058797121, 0.0729018971323967, 0.07139317691326141, -0.011334513314068317, -0.034420475363731384, -0.08093543350696564, 0.042965780943632126, -0.05544900894165039, -0.004946054890751839, -0.0009457763517275453, -0.04330000653862953, -0.05857757106423378, 0.03601454570889473, -0.057231415063142776, -0.05954905226826668, 0.04392271488904953, 0.043146442621946335, 0.04521989822387695, -0.0363074392080307, -0.053329382091760635, -0.012759058736264706, -0.06767687946557999, 0.0391308031976223, -0.07823140174150467, 0.02543729729950428, -0.11887899041175842, 0.005109778605401516, 0.018513156101107597, 0.01145952008664608, -0.043912794440984726, -0.012669285759329796, -0.06490057706832886, -0.021449195221066475, 0.008738595061004162, 0.08944971859455109, -0.04509942978620529, -0.037895165383815765, -0.0302400104701519, 0.06074787303805351, -0.052358001470565796, 0.03138606622815132, 0.05815977230668068, -0.010504377074539661, 0.07969574630260468, -0.007435513660311699, -0.0261265616863966, 0.07231003791093826, -0.017251934856176376, -0.0004969891742803156, -0.034003548324108124, 0.08997073024511337, -0.011777968145906925, 0.0006711167516186833, -0.02955564297735691, -0.03914672136306763, -0.008493811823427677, 0.03211908042430878, -0.011168728582561016, -0.027632279321551323, -0.026423459872603416, 0.0017430313164368272, -0.05427267774939537, 0.015388384461402893, 0.004130553919821978, 0.033840663731098175, 0.03694719448685646, -0.013784433715045452, 0.018807904794812202, -0.04897817224264145, -0.05175165832042694, -0.018594427034258842, 0.030117008835077286, -0.05459808558225632, -0.0264902263879776, 0.0450899712741375, -0.0030672543216496706, 0.010943906381726265, -0.06431274861097336, 0.04671386256814003, -0.013046814128756523, -0.00405116705223918, -0.0869918018579483, 0.003326146863400936, 0.05070754140615463, 0.059960510581731796, -0.05238136276602745, -0.04958287999033928, 0.006559785455465317, -0.040251098573207855, 0.01004023663699627, -0.004295538179576397, -0.058328233659267426, -0.003343045711517334, 0.019263798370957375, -0.042233631014823914, 0.02797681652009487, -0.06543424725532532, -0.02421802282333374, -0.01919553615152836, -0.039144646376371384, -0.03493529558181763, -0.0031847881618887186, 0.07823194563388824, 0.005114679224789143, 0.0355377271771431, 0.035680945962667465, 0.023717429488897324, 0.022758033126592636, 0.0018066107295453548, 0.022074999287724495, -0.01480865478515625, 0.0814114511013031, -0.05038635805249214, 0.03797350078821182, -0.03857976943254471, -0.032052215188741684, 0.0052079749293625355, 0.04726554825901985, 0.04611586779356003, 0.02819938212633133, 0.024224113672971725, 0.12344072014093399, 0.06103210896253586, 0.032421234995126724, -0.003190091112628579, 0.022976050153374672, 0.00944777112454176, -0.08209040015935898, 0.045973487198352814, 0.028855228796601295, -0.004972333088517189, 0.005484561901539564, -0.004383276216685772, 0.048223257064819336, -0.033345744013786316, -0.026401517912745476, -0.016009896993637085, 0.012784686870872974, 0.011996575631201267, 0.06477291136980057, 0.005128616001456976, 0.008146476000547409, 0.01937936246395111, 0.0810534879565239, -0.0343412347137928, 0.02588423155248165, -0.03740273416042328, -0.06735031306743622, 0.05142882838845253, -0.07366165518760681, -0.048255130648612976, -0.07604969292879105, -0.05124383792281151, 0.09379911422729492, -0.030912723392248154, -0.001536873634904623, 0.040744926780462265, -0.04670923575758934, 0.00030839559622108936, -0.05773141607642174, 0.042565394192934036, 0.07357398420572281, 0.009651600383222103, 0.07418185472488403, 0.0024223949294537306, -0.07974269986152649, -0.05184660851955414, 0.06697580963373184, -0.018673188984394073, -0.029199182987213135, -0.02493835799396038, -0.012729375623166561, -0.04840981215238571, 0.00605965219438076, -0.09081215411424637, -0.05609423667192459, -0.02338365651667118, -0.0273300688713789, 0.012842723168432713, 0.04673571512103081, 0.04037608578801155, -0.036989372223615646, -0.03884883224964142, -0.04054223373532295, -0.01608734019100666, 0.05491163954138756, -0.038633521646261215, -0.022858142852783203, 0.07566971331834793, 0.05298632010817528, -0.02676260471343994, -0.0024617970921099186, 0.015919921919703484, 0.0328972265124321, -0.029876431450247765, 0.06403441727161407, -0.07086823135614395, 0.007875125855207443, -0.02358834818005562, 0.027852121740579605, 0.04039895907044411, 0.07484883069992065, -0.006223571021109819, -0.03139546886086464, 0.034291308373212814, -0.07703639566898346, -0.026132579892873764 ]
186
186
Decomposition Principles and Online Learning in Cross-Layer Optimization for Delay-Sensitive Applications
In this paper, we propose a general cross-layer optimization framework in which we explicitly consider both the heterogeneous and dynamically changing characteristics of delay-sensitive applications and the underlying time-varying network conditions. We consider both the independently decodable data units (DUs, e.g. packets) and the interdependent DUs whose dependencies are captured by a directed acyclic graph (DAG). We first formulate the cross-layer design as a non-linear constrained optimization problem by assuming complete knowledge of the application characteristics and the underlying network conditions. The constrained cross-layer optimization is decomposed into several cross-layer optimization subproblems for each DU and two master problems. The proposed decomposition method determines the necessary message exchanges between layers for achieving the optimal cross-layer solution. However, the attributes (e.g. distortion impact, delay deadline etc) of future DUs as well as the network conditions are often unknown in the considered real-time applications. The impact of current cross-layer actions on the future DUs can be characterized by a state-value function in the Markov decision process (MDP) framework. Based on the dynamic programming solution to the MDP, we develop a low-complexity cross-layer optimization algorithm using online learning for each DU transmission. This online algorithm can be implemented in real-time in order to cope with unknown source characteristics, network dynamics and resource constraints. Our numerical results demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed online algorithm.
[ -0.019019311293959618, -0.11608628928661346, 0.020553497597575188, -0.0017849745927378535, -0.005925649777054787, -0.061641305685043335, 0.02593468874692917, -0.08064007014036179, -0.041391726583242416, 0.05928317829966545, 0.002791563980281353, -0.05806289613246918, 0.028505150228738785, -0.03243456035852432, 0.0195674616843462, 0.011330658569931984, 0.021746762096881866, 0.03825028985738754, 0.007228665053844452, -0.04112108051776886, -0.052108488976955414, -0.041380781680345535, -0.07879253476858139, 0.016066815704107285, 0.033741503953933716, 0.03698398172855377, -0.09330093115568161, 0.013357351534068584, 0.040256161242723465, 0.00042671270784921944, -0.05627911165356636, 0.039322592318058014, 0.02504913881421089, 0.002201341325417161, -0.010842464864253998, 0.008767453022301197, -0.023276468738913536, -0.060306139290332794, -0.04683111608028412, 0.02177773229777813, 0.034137528389692307, -0.03715720772743225, 0.001807557069696486, -0.048896148800849915, 0.07468830049037933, 0.052197784185409546, 0.03661966323852539, -0.008854749612510204, -0.03017832711338997, 0.00854052510112524, -0.053794898092746735, 0.013078895397484303, -0.08874733746051788, 0.06678023189306259, -0.02794729359447956, 0.0721815824508667, -0.027095258235931396, -0.054088544100522995, 0.005669756792485714, -0.06306244432926178, 0.030570410192012787, -0.004378302954137325, -0.06568653881549835, 0.04489513859152794, -0.10624674707651138, 0.03604377433657646, 0.03471890836954117, -0.0052557033486664295, -0.028925102204084396, -0.016784576699137688, -0.01239276397973299, -0.035175472497940063, -0.012190076522529125, 0.011184144765138626, 0.01770743355154991, 0.017289690673351288, 0.018843315541744232, -0.002064803149551153, -0.0004580106760840863, 0.10968909412622452, -0.09854798018932343, 0.03347591310739517, -0.08947096019983292, -0.008631976321339607, 0.04705948010087013, -0.005623189732432365, -0.020719638094305992, -0.024526318535208702, -0.00819737371057272, 0.01032086182385683, -0.03815923631191254, 0.029489604756236076, -0.07905911654233932, -0.01782388426363468, 0.009004566818475723, 0.027035541832447052, -0.07471521198749542, 0.006780456751585007, -0.059413596987724304, 0.01716754212975502, 0.026328815147280693, -0.023594627156853676, 0.060367148369550705, 0.06136992573738098, 0.01723083108663559, 0.0024079415015876293, 0.04991106316447258, 0.04274727404117584, 0.03877990320324898, -0.07164710015058517, 0.004498992580920458, 0.0052441819570958614, -0.04471829906105995, -0.01939869485795498, -0.0790642499923706, 0.04650696739554405, -0.04312708228826523, 0.02968643605709076, -0.039364900439977646, 0.018201641738414764, -0.04707811772823334, 0.014930755831301212, -0.01886790059506893, -0.06321518123149872, 0.08595241606235504, -0.0015394458314403892, -0.03685671091079712, -0.00791359692811966, 0.08921003341674805, 0.058111175894737244, -0.048020463436841965, 0.056687504053115845, 0.05842354893684387, 0.045184098184108734, -0.013713479042053223, 0.06281444430351257, 0.04183143377304077, 0.017525052651762962, -0.053039491176605225, -0.0381304994225502, 0.054406050592660904, 0.005015938077121973, -0.04082733765244484, -0.05600743368268013, 0.032901838421821594, 0.01081904862076044, -0.030780786648392677, 0.04254553094506264, 0.015054065734148026, -0.0014752786373719573, -0.03318650647997856, -0.054985810071229935, 0.03766822814941406, 0.01958625018596649, -0.01903017796576023, -0.03684203699231148, -0.06785989552736282, -0.03221729025244713, 0.0032151835039258003, 0.04307635501027107, -0.016916900873184204, 0.09889727085828781, -0.030129393562674522, -0.004054951015859842, 0.06812334060668945, -0.02406064234673977, -0.03294312208890915, -0.012518695555627346, -0.10229102522134781, -0.060284070670604706, -0.03438126668334007, -0.05158444866538048, -0.02634498104453087, 0.06725503504276276, 0.009810155257582664, 0.06563286483287811, -0.0417628288269043, -0.00576261430978775, -0.06155722588300705, -0.004054564516991377, 0.0264966432005167, -0.030061330646276474, 0.012126864865422249, 0.005635151639580727, 0.004386257380247116, 0.03778398409485817, -0.007989998906850815, 0.03882510960102081, 0.06138202175498009, 0.016085734590888023, -0.026378851383924484, 0.057912200689315796, 0.03171381726861, 0.014149674214422703, 0.015830496326088905, 0.023590967059135437, -0.06961535662412643, 0.0480726882815361, 0.041669007390737534, 0.03301538527011871, 0.054371509701013565, -0.05522126704454422, -0.031015316024422646, -0.049845725297927856, -0.0326969251036644, 0.06236130744218826, 0.04260154440999031, -0.025386041030287743, -0.029662353917956352, -0.0528053380548954, -0.052328772842884064, -0.05620056390762329, -0.021059807389974594, 0.0565243698656559, 0.023780005052685738, -0.04361201450228691, -0.03772177919745445, -0.02489730902016163, -0.024943789467215538, -0.08827318251132965, -0.007413920015096664, 0.07905840128660202, -0.005965267773717642, 0.008314268663525581, -0.03785273805260658, -0.024063661694526672, 0.03913194313645363, 0.032662421464920044, -0.0343659445643425, 0.013929578475654125, -0.04183109477162361, -0.06471182405948639, -0.06391308456659317, 0.06552184373140335, 0.03806602209806442, 0.03469416871666908, -0.029513103887438774, -0.047319311648607254, -0.013937142677605152, -0.040207576006650925, 0.005347960162907839, 0.0176449716091156, -0.05978349223732948, 0.0162217915058136, 0.09939324855804443, -0.0012152820127084851, 0.06421374529600143, -0.013702747412025928, -0.039710335433483124, -0.007097206544131041, -0.009063035249710083, -0.03802681341767311, 0.015908807516098022, 0.03878632187843323, -0.029330601915717125, 0.003689249511808157, 0.013914534822106361, 0.08509822934865952, 0.08122096955776215, 0.06140046566724777, -0.05123599246144295, -0.06644561141729355, -0.0610336996614933, -0.010603140108287334, 0.0509132482111454, 0.0633106455206871, 0.03812523931264877, 0.08019404113292694, -0.007046656217426062, 0.06117355823516846, 0.022865865379571915, -0.03173275664448738, -0.07238565385341644, 0.09979216009378433, 0.011466006748378277, -0.024801071733236313, 0.010220302268862724, 0.03027321957051754, -0.018374823033809662, -0.04258805885910988, -0.03134525194764137, 0.0008912825142033398, -0.03182526305317879, 0.01214170828461647, -0.0679883062839508, 0.025613093748688698, 0.012464342638850212, 0.0319254994392395, 0.04057174548506737, 0.028181619942188263, -0.04167111590504646, -0.0037299932446330786, -0.08889801055192947, -0.061247818171978, 0.025927815586328506, -0.10446169972419739, 0.015647808089852333, -0.041655465960502625, 0.004650705959647894, -0.019416073337197304, 0.03965544328093529, -0.06496401131153107, 0.07408665120601654, 0.010304775089025497, -0.04722297564148903, 0.046296484768390656, 0.0011930905748158693, -0.06010929122567177, -0.061618052423000336, -0.0043607717379927635, -0.005443881265819073, 0.010143043473362923, -0.030213303864002228, 0.01884380169212818, 0.04135453701019287, -0.030672293156385422, -0.07361876964569092, -0.039915431290864944, -0.07878763228654861, 0.06323103606700897, 0.024680236354470253, 0.0354246124625206, 0.012569500133395195, -0.025253497064113617, -0.032692063599824905, 0.044528257101774216, 0.009616564959287643, -0.007187406532466412, 0.016124071553349495, -0.012343685142695904, -0.0899927094578743, 0.015087496489286423, -0.06232757493853569, 0.011027447879314423, -0.05426039919257164, -0.013978563249111176, -0.11972043663263321, -0.015104313381016254, 0.00921706948429346, 0.04469044879078865, -0.05301083251833916, -0.058616019785404205, -0.03429700434207916, -0.09613095223903656, 0.014567840844392776, 0.09222456067800522, 0.055303361266851425, 0.06651849299669266, -0.03986683487892151, 0.03455071151256561, 0.011740267276763916, -0.02157171629369259, -0.04226801171898842, -0.06327055394649506, -0.010587478056550026, -0.04196791350841522, -0.007815519347786903, -0.05596427246928215, -0.010762367397546768, 0.007070604711771011, 0.0002562966546975076, -0.01610046625137329, -0.005760387051850557, 0.0021077522542327642, 0.031520240008831024, 0.00029301157337613404, -0.04256345331668854, -0.000223689348786138, -0.04182609170675278, 0.027209129184484482, -0.01728072576224804, 0.018298598006367683, -0.04196343570947647, -0.01080442313104868, 0.02207079716026783, -0.005602883640676737, 0.05429475009441376, -0.06565197557210922, -0.01530216634273529, -0.024572273716330528, -0.03013095259666443, 0.00529616791754961, -0.0006467832718044519, 0.00737486407160759, -0.01763133704662323, -0.003672222141176462, -0.012343679554760456, 0.008719464763998985, 0.06341957300901413, -0.005777535494416952, -0.1069476529955864, 0.01027734111994505, -0.06853306293487549, -0.012935486622154713, 0.07697897404432297, 0.018111390992999077, 0.04680450260639191, 0.010438923723995686, -0.040107253938913345, 0.10461416095495224, 0.057571571320295334, -0.05041574686765671, 0.0009754408383741975, -0.035817038267850876, -0.08171320706605911, -0.04580063372850418, -0.009933392517268658, 0.025480953976511955, 0.031002655625343323, 0.04870827868580818, -0.0020010608714073896, 0.051663726568222046, 0.005567108280956745, -0.014588202349841595, -0.03264965862035751, 0.04238283261656761, 0.04421890899538994, 0.00840155128389597, -0.05693826824426651, -0.04622461274266243, -0.03216037526726723, 0.0398075096309185, 0.056500133126974106, -0.052720844745635986, -0.02823522873222828, -0.06435031443834305, 0.02859019674360752, 0.051673680543899536, -0.07119037955999374, 0.027732543647289276, -0.06433666497468948, -0.05926765874028206, -0.029837023466825485, -0.02557484060525894, 0.007682628929615021, 0.07778293639421463, 0.01642938330769539, -0.01066493708640337, 0.010433091782033443, -0.03477736935019493, 0.047096189111471176, -0.00877887848764658, 0.06442852318286896, 0.026765480637550354, -0.004440750926733017, 0.0406746044754982, 0.06636489927768707, 0.05434632673859596, -0.0018393035279586911, -0.028931504115462303, -0.007538379170000553, 0.09095519036054611, 0.10067801922559738, -0.01843097247183323, 0.041241295635700226, -0.023499513044953346, 0.000736186106223613, -0.015371350571513176, 0.07714974135160446, -0.020664678886532784, 0.02426823414862156, -0.0044522942043840885, 0.015220342203974724, -0.0035620129201561213, -0.0049810330383479595, -0.019513163715600967, -0.023846585303544998, 0.0004249886842444539, 0.03287019208073616, -0.015091829001903534, -0.048568300902843475, 0.04923040792346001, 0.06421538442373276, -0.041613224893808365, 0.004851715173572302, -0.01635795459151268, 0.013117240741848946, 0.061081741005182266, 0.011767860502004623, -0.02237296849489212, 0.06146404519677162, 0.1091146320104599, 0.02229902520775795, 0.027000144124031067, 0.06770409643650055, 0.014000738970935345, -0.038177601993083954, 0.01183859072625637, 0.00648501655086875, 0.039395712316036224, -0.06148679926991463, -0.08178291469812393, -0.041925784200429916, 0.03515225648880005, -0.05448637157678604, 0.01730012334883213, 0.04290110245347023, -0.032837558537721634, 0.09429701417684555, -0.012376782484352589, -0.0013643607962876558, 0.030730240046977997, 0.004477705340832472, 0.09708508104085922, 0.04017425701022148, 0.01164916343986988, 0.04025492072105408, 0.07226250320672989, 0.0034849473740905523, -0.01561411377042532, -0.04146198183298111, 0.07756097614765167 ]
187
187
A Novel Clustering Algorithm Based on Quantum Random Walk
The enormous successes have been made by quantum algorithms during the last decade. In this paper, we combine the quantum random walk (QRW) with the problem of data clustering, and develop two clustering algorithms based on the one dimensional QRW. Then, the probability distributions on the positions induced by QRW in these algorithms are investigated, which also indicates the possibility of obtaining better results. Consequently, the experimental results have demonstrated that data points in datasets are clustered reasonably and efficiently, and the clustering algorithms are of fast rates of convergence. Moreover, the comparison with other algorithms also provides an indication of the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
[ -0.044145066291093826, -0.020464308559894562, 0.005624027922749519, -0.00983361154794693, 0.04475073888897896, -0.002505896845832467, -0.03559152036905289, -0.05289888381958008, -0.07022775709629059, 0.049549754709005356, -0.031278084963560104, -0.03111274540424347, -0.0007831595139577985, 0.02142215333878994, 0.04292645305395126, 0.03458213061094284, -0.0607871413230896, 0.04237941652536392, -0.02987687848508358, -0.07945483922958374, 0.04865817353129387, -0.045870184898376465, 0.04711328446865082, 0.03372404724359512, 0.0489533357322216, -0.06434877216815948, 0.026914335787296295, 0.04150591418147087, -0.032620128244161606, -0.030111080035567284, 0.034508127719163895, -0.011081807315349579, 0.068816639482975, -0.016020745038986206, 0.04128585383296013, -0.023986052721738815, 0.06730736047029495, 0.004678554832935333, -0.021491480991244316, 0.005170727148652077, 0.006312408484518528, -0.045776352286338806, -0.0009714996558614075, 0.030333220958709717, -0.021163254976272583, 0.0029917277861386538, -0.003253777278587222, 0.06223898380994797, -0.04162205383181572, 0.004042727407068014, -0.06961095333099365, -0.0026505794376134872, -0.07104172557592392, 0.0014816437615081668, -0.0139960628002882, 0.0021738591603934765, -0.02692127786576748, 0.017805347219109535, -0.05748242512345314, -0.05265522375702858, 0.06374932825565338, 0.05055062100291252, -0.03320937603712082, -0.048079103231430054, 0.03534293174743652, -0.03611394390463829, 0.033117763698101044, -0.052688974887132645, 0.026932690292596817, -0.03571074455976486, 0.013273299671709538, -0.0071252998895943165, 0.024897318333387375, -0.01711856760084629, -0.03992192819714546, 0.039606399834156036, -0.02729726769030094, -0.009555157274007797, -0.01633450761437416, 0.057941097766160965, -0.010871103964745998, -0.02374572679400444, -0.04900655522942543, 0.05141216889023781, -0.03567802160978317, 0.003722346853464842, -0.00020010292064398527, -0.06372566521167755, -0.003854090115055442, -0.06413660198450089, -0.02228381298482418, -0.02695051021873951, -0.07939206808805466, 0.012437207624316216, -0.01524724718183279, 0.054345354437828064, -0.05378487706184387, 0.003443216672167182, 0.06457256525754929, 0.03818206861615181, -0.047438666224479675, -0.03251074627041817, 0.025899557396769524, 0.07856582850217819, 0.013380314223468304, 0.04423755034804344, -0.12595798075199127, 0.03777889907360077, 0.012557593174278736, -0.04404319077730179, 0.030503297224640846, 0.01916416734457016, -0.005039595067501068, 0.0012017261469736695, -0.010682912543416023, 0.014976243488490582, -0.0038806244265288115, 0.04395298659801483, -0.03714727982878685, 0.08774955570697784, 0.006239641457796097, -0.016214730218052864, -0.007633222732692957, -0.018046610057353973, -0.0013836575672030449, -0.04188433662056923, -0.03758295252919197, 0.025347670540213585, 0.12875032424926758, 0.022773928940296173, -0.0887855514883995, 0.01048915833234787, -0.0471041165292263, -0.025023842230439186, -0.030281735584139824, -0.07602385431528091, 0.040258921682834625, 0.0003037035057786852, 0.09183620661497116, 0.031077714636921883, 0.028847377747297287, -0.02683304436504841, -0.08726882934570312, 0.012696029618382454, 0.04493405669927597, -0.017031434923410416, -0.04799337685108185, 0.06440717726945877, 0.03869817778468132, 0.02447972632944584, -0.051559314131736755, -0.028981365263462067, -0.013831681571900845, -0.004455520771443844, 0.0350118987262249, -0.009189968928694725, -0.0814482644200325, -0.012160497717559338, -0.00761724216863513, 0.070557601749897, -0.010155499912798405, 0.011138214729726315, -0.07142657041549683, -0.041428521275520325, -0.01734854280948639, 0.00603592861443758, -0.07505560666322708, -0.014934681355953217, -0.04390993341803551, 0.0070891594514250755, 0.07482840865850449, 0.017593804746866226, 0.007143295370042324, -0.016417281702160835, 0.06056161969900131, -0.0312734916806221, -0.040376655757427216, -0.0076099541038274765, 0.036273978650569916, -0.0770147442817688, -0.012215444818139076, -0.032412413507699966, -0.052247192710638046, 0.11509411036968231, 0.0325162373483181, 0.14230476319789886, -0.051121294498443604, 0.06948789954185486, 0.05350327119231224, -0.04113053157925606, 0.031756654381752014, -0.01764572411775589, 0.060083117336034775, -0.07646765559911728, -0.09454695135354996, 0.04193221405148506, -0.05583063140511513, -0.11692453920841217, 0.07685590535402298, 0.0878579393029213, -0.015270482748746872, 0.0810447484254837, -0.050625305622816086, -0.035744503140449524, -0.029557254165410995, -0.025094203650951385, 0.039307620376348495, 0.048309169709682465, -0.01605905592441559, -0.015503216534852982, -0.02411065064370632, -0.058513689786195755, 0.007071927655488253, -0.034988198429346085, 0.046660054475069046, -0.051462315022945404, -0.062426891177892685, -0.06470047682523727, 0.028351960703730583, 0.0416545569896698, -0.06873904913663864, 0.041227202862501144, -0.05208776146173477, 0.13608920574188232, -0.050112638622522354, 0.0033286239486187696, 0.07312639057636261, -0.07380099594593048, -0.06769595295190811, -0.02552642673254013, -0.025532104074954987, 0.0003497795551083982, -0.041224636137485504, -0.006459916941821575, 0.057447489351034164, 0.020248811691999435, -0.031105509027838707, -0.06401822715997696, 0.028322188183665276, 0.046161796897649765, -0.04884057864546776, 0.039731014519929886, -0.00646970234811306, -0.04828276112675667, 0.08592916280031204, -0.022017741575837135, -0.007520543877035379, 0.1058354303240776, 0.035857778042554855, 0.02703278139233589, -0.0019146063132211566, -0.016635116189718246, 0.005857877433300018, -0.06793515384197235, 0.01995551586151123, 0.029283681884407997, -0.01892593502998352, 0.04443225637078285, 0.05039502680301666, 0.07562050968408585, -0.007107885554432869, 0.025123383849859238, -0.025958837941288948, 0.0032142510171979666, 0.0844784751534462, 0.033344581723213196, -0.03573794662952423, 0.039252135902643204, -0.05927448347210884, 0.03443354740738869, 0.0187545046210289, -0.08822385966777802, 0.004359161015599966, 0.059836503118276596, -0.03365282341837883, -0.04612074792385101, 0.018617020919919014, 0.013039314188063145, -0.0037375844549387693, -0.03390819951891899, -0.05280337482690811, -0.001062255003489554, -0.02512941136956215, -0.03986566513776779, 0.004959337878972292, -0.03978370502591133, -0.06365673989057541, 0.0020184435416013002, -0.0019430668326094747, 0.005973964463919401, 0.003971826285123825, 0.057130247354507446, -0.02047223225235939, -0.06152883544564247, 0.046817779541015625, 0.010714273899793625, 0.06282053142786026, -0.03260768949985504, 0.021161694079637527, -0.012768174521625042, -0.04104846343398094, -0.0046769618056714535, 0.022133342921733856, 0.03860318288207054, -0.01079543586820364, -0.027493039146065712, 0.05490056052803993, 0.0730312392115593, -0.0912526324391365, 0.022628387436270714, 0.023792291060090065, 0.06897833943367004, 0.022846831008791924, -0.05947469547390938, -0.007508293725550175, 0.05674896761775017, 0.06221567094326019, -0.007818670012056828, 0.07731498032808304, 0.0341121107339859, 0.04092472419142723, -0.03579293563961983, 0.034320391714572906, -0.07002390921115875, 0.01717648096382618, -0.029520750045776367, -0.018034707754850388, -0.04660810902714729, -0.01967936009168625, 0.005855254363268614, -0.035955168306827545, 0.05960042402148247, -0.035417377948760986, 0.07577811181545258, 0.01902124285697937, 0.018379870802164078, -0.028100397437810898, 0.03768086060881615, 0.017822111025452614, -0.0021254715975373983, 0.006481414195150137, 0.009862301871180534, 0.03971337154507637, -0.012948686257004738, 0.03764980658888817, 0.04346619173884392, 0.03132233768701553, 0.037511616945266724, -0.00525274220854044, -0.00026981442351825535, -0.047600507736206055, 0.05720371752977371, -0.044732026755809784, 0.03053583949804306, 0.02079988643527031, 0.09437588602304459, 0.04984763637185097, 0.06436140090227127, 0.030840886756777763, 0.035994287580251694, 0.020359214395284653, 0.04932309687137604, -0.01694028079509735, -0.0045397402718663216, -0.03907268866896629, 0.06398458778858185, -0.025846805423498154, -0.010279057547450066, -0.017204253003001213, -0.037822723388671875, -0.009209790267050266, 0.012010578997433186, 0.025092801079154015, -0.031285710632801056, -0.004889392759650946, -0.007765399292111397, -0.02137252502143383, 0.005119064822793007, 0.019212773069739342, 0.0073109897784888744, -0.029588880017399788, 0.006766275502741337, 0.0013197057414799929, 0.0012436886318027973, 0.017449256032705307, 0.0212904904037714, -0.010455162264406681, 0.00846784096211195, 0.002979667391628027, 0.015985924750566483, 0.011152303777635098, -0.07348449528217316, 0.004775929264724255, -0.015073941089212894, -0.010821294970810413, -0.0885283425450325, 0.017743678763508797, 0.008108981885015965, 0.04073940962553024, -0.06608991324901581, -0.02992992103099823, -0.10675203800201416, -0.08587421476840973, -0.11850418895483017, -0.03700416162610054, 0.0403766855597496, -0.0358315072953701, 0.010737103410065174, 0.01015943381935358, 0.028741158545017242, -0.00837731920182705, -0.010675043798983097, -0.015540394932031631, 0.02796868234872818, 0.004685649648308754, -0.022999949753284454, -0.053448501974344254, 0.011114919558167458, 0.04709808900952339, -0.09966286271810532, -0.06774034351110458, 0.014433802105486393, 0.07810135930776596, -0.046467844396829605, -0.01075830403715372, 0.05828305706381798, 0.06125723570585251, 0.026608631014823914, 0.1003182977437973, 0.10471374541521072, -0.05792146548628807, 0.03830777108669281, 0.012901932932436466, -0.004536279011517763, -0.005491229239851236, -0.058574430644512177, -0.02564338594675064, -0.023891422897577286, -0.026151124387979507, 0.06923031061887741, 0.03447316214442253, -0.018751440569758415, -0.04208577796816826, -0.040191344916820526, 0.004637554287910461, 0.012889071367681026, 0.07101760059595108, -0.03032776154577732, 0.030482176691293716, 0.041553426533937454, -0.008714576251804829, 0.05498568341135979, -0.0184816662222147, -0.0036926288157701492, 0.048086512833833694, 0.0009119711467064917, 0.014663297683000565, -0.04369475319981575, -0.016147250309586525, -0.05307059362530708, -0.0781569555401802, 0.026273539289832115, -0.06923820078372955, 0.0039423927664756775, 0.0023926899302750826, 0.0373823344707489, -0.0433068610727787, -0.03296416997909546, 0.10512714833021164, 0.0013204088900238276, -0.01711588352918625, 0.07288072258234024, -0.006388907786458731, -0.09748221188783646, 0.01724974997341633, 0.006209571845829487, 0.028016678988933563, -0.01871681585907936, 0.004262516275048256, 0.024504078552126884, 0.027968276292085648, 0.004813117440789938, -0.009410299360752106, -0.004447408951818943, 0.019802413880825043, 0.0044944873079657555, -0.07278186082839966, 0.03678741306066513, 0.026822740212082863, 0.014339037239551544, 0.0025441935285925865, -0.04745673015713692, 0.008226731792092323, -0.0004747306229546666, -0.046896498650312424, 0.010018098168075085, 0.030662527307868004, 0.007446965202689171, 0.028264319524168968, 0.02789951115846634, 0.042427849024534225, -0.05402110889554024, 0.05850381776690483, -0.03536811098456383, 0.05009234696626663, 0.010587742552161217, -0.009121466428041458, -0.056917786598205566, 0.010614503175020218, 0.08314811438322067, 0.04333266615867615, -0.08837929368019104 ]
188
188
Convex Sparse Matrix Factorizations
We present a convex formulation of dictionary learning for sparse signal decomposition. Convexity is obtained by replacing the usual explicit upper bound on the dictionary size by a convex rank-reducing term similar to the trace norm. In particular, our formulation introduces an explicit trade-off between size and sparsity of the decomposition of rectangular matrices. Using a large set of synthetic examples, we compare the estimation abilities of the convex and non-convex approaches, showing that while the convex formulation has a single local minimum, this may lead in some cases to performance which is inferior to the local minima of the non-convex formulation.
[ 0.062086258083581924, -0.006697092205286026, 0.0528610460460186, 0.007452294230461121, -0.024998297914862633, -0.010793558321893215, -0.008863150142133236, -0.024322032928466797, 0.010776767507195473, 0.06406005471944809, 0.015350844711065292, -0.0029637585394084454, -0.0010677776299417019, 0.057949550449848175, 0.0026547096204012632, -0.043643537908792496, -0.0010819588787853718, -0.024171289056539536, 0.07058493047952652, -0.05446721613407135, -0.011996086686849594, -0.016501732170581818, -0.01304428931325674, -0.04332764446735382, 0.0011886385036632419, 0.07848186045885086, 0.0036951543297618628, 0.017913654446601868, 0.08400702476501465, -0.006265017203986645, -0.07636161893606186, 0.04681139439344406, 0.07374320179224014, -0.006111709866672754, -0.06943201273679733, 0.007185729686170816, 0.05810603126883507, 0.04861883819103241, -0.03999156504869461, -0.03159673884510994, -0.0544857457280159, 0.07225088775157928, 0.0399155467748642, -0.015057393349707127, 0.031902071088552475, 0.01397259533405304, 0.0029180794954299927, -0.07844756543636322, -0.027790745720267296, 0.09180212020874023, 0.005424502771347761, -0.006644661538302898, -0.03714011237025261, 0.010262309573590755, 0.0022684098221361637, 0.039437390863895416, -0.018170179799199104, -0.016775257885456085, 0.0021483642049133778, -0.061232082545757294, 0.043933432549238205, 0.10981705039739609, 0.031332965940237045, -0.026465198025107384, -0.026764322072267532, 0.024106668308377266, -0.109639972448349, -0.010454612784087658, -0.0009658091003075242, 0.03317151963710785, -0.007578021381050348, -0.02280067279934883, -0.03505511209368706, 0.040085189044475555, -0.015076326206326485, 0.03209107369184494, -0.014461962506175041, 0.02369474433362484, 0.013669395819306374, 0.0979728251695633, -0.05190814286470413, 0.07523147016763687, -0.015485609881579876, 0.07035109400749207, -0.02655680663883686, -0.02363463304936886, -0.042856208980083466, -0.013134961947798729, 0.030253442004323006, 0.0065166843123734, -0.04858744889497757, 0.04028936102986336, -0.08964274078607559, 0.07045257836580276, -0.011287622153759003, 0.03724854066967964, -0.0851934552192688, 0.026459841057658195, -0.09558861702680588, -0.053565628826618195, 0.035878829658031464, -0.012756932526826859, 0.016947943717241287, 0.027841994538903236, -0.040606629103422165, 0.00028627936262637377, -0.07052931189537048, 0.07552822679281235, -0.02743465080857277, -0.04581437632441521, 0.02291846089065075, -0.019618675112724304, 0.001645220909267664, -0.07949569821357727, -0.0693635642528534, -0.00840920489281416, 0.027145303785800934, 0.05156240984797478, 0.0034753058571368456, 0.00838569737970829, 0.032935965806245804, 0.027614209800958633, 0.01524948887526989, -0.012234576046466827, 0.015479478985071182, -0.07797617465257645, 0.055767305195331573, -0.09563107043504715, 0.11846652626991272, 0.009221531450748444, -0.07091213762760162, -0.008538520894944668, -0.00035100209061056376, -0.0027867285534739494, -0.08614635467529297, 0.06511405855417252, 0.009047158062458038, -0.034232042729854584, -0.026607481762766838, 0.08205407112836838, -0.013509846292436123, 0.005376178305596113, -0.033127330243587494, -0.031000392511487007, 0.003366231918334961, 0.012769014574587345, -0.00666474737226963, 0.020572591572999954, -0.021830691024661064, -0.026632139459252357, -0.014342300593852997, -0.011078125797212124, 0.16292163729667664, 0.011181031353771687, 0.005062333773821592, -0.02007479779422283, 0.01519065722823143, -0.0852300226688385, 0.04489143565297127, -0.007592283189296722, -0.09225927293300629, -0.024126147851347923, 0.046070314943790436, 0.0025608129799365997, -0.00944772083312273, -0.05994642153382301, -0.008058841340243816, -0.0025919643230736256, -0.08648622781038284, -0.022765973582863808, -0.04004991427063942, -0.019680200144648552, 0.04983114078640938, 0.03438834846019745, 0.011526447720825672, 0.02068241313099861, -0.005024261772632599, 0.06362146884202957, -0.0067171757109463215, 0.012460796162486076, 0.02999168634414673, -0.026478568091988564, -0.018431726843118668, 0.026480603963136673, 0.014874277636408806, 0.02456439845263958, 0.02829143963754177, 0.06323515623807907, -0.027909956872463226, -0.0348321832716465, 0.0546051561832428, -0.06422750651836395, -0.0093381367623806, 0.07471765577793121, -0.0653531476855278, 0.06767204403877258, -0.016028448939323425, -0.02532980591058731, 0.06683643162250519, 0.06293706595897675, 0.08557875454425812, -0.03804442659020424, -0.05024541914463043, -0.01917259953916073, -0.06096641346812248, -0.023614998906850815, 0.014065701514482498, -0.006242815870791674, -0.005498113110661507, 0.015736542642116547, 0.02747689187526703, 0.018731480464339256, 0.013861291110515594, -0.049015630036592484, 0.02911524474620819, 0.0661160871386528, -0.026272622868418694, -0.004355289973318577, 0.028566665947437286, 0.01852087303996086, -0.04341023787856102, 0.058776043355464935, 0.021515976637601852, -0.016765248030424118, -0.048689328134059906, -0.06278456002473831, -0.02206924557685852, -0.06949162483215332, -0.07311191409826279, 0.0007416590233333409, -0.051310718059539795, -0.008023996837437153, -0.071949802339077, -0.05511583015322685, 0.01575762778520584, -0.004865155089646578, -0.051072824746370316, -0.013313819654285908, -0.03569590672850609, -0.015875784680247307, 0.0018813570495694876, 0.07703062891960144, -0.07943735271692276, 0.033095523715019226, 0.01974344812333584, -0.031758591532707214, 0.033737167716026306, 0.03342261537909508, -0.017781194299459457, 0.018723318353295326, 0.033668819814920425, 0.009844940155744553, -0.003236336400732398, 0.03877805173397064, -0.004834338556975126, -0.015523246489465237, 0.01228923350572586, 0.044146828353405, 0.04564891755580902, 0.048407815396785736, 0.0005148786003701389, 0.06255457550287247, -0.026223599910736084, 0.0702148824930191, 0.06370163708925247, -0.03642570972442627, -0.07495120912790298, 0.05447164177894592, 0.03848866745829582, 0.06581047177314758, 0.029690295457839966, -0.04101521149277687, 0.005182364489883184, 0.028010042384266853, -0.07002820074558258, 0.04195958003401756, 0.09050370007753372, 0.05172993987798691, 0.043179985135793686, -0.06516874581575394, -0.05693405494093895, 0.015478239394724369, 0.00797689612954855, -0.024917857721447945, 0.028803007677197456, 0.02523489110171795, 0.04647265374660492, -0.029056664556264877, 0.05488559603691101, -0.014308714307844639, -0.0629088506102562, 0.05086180567741394, -0.04245658218860626, 0.009764161892235279, 0.02676588110625744, 0.003239442827180028, 0.033888936042785645, -0.055995237082242966, -0.05742835998535156, 0.05144915357232094, 0.056767188012599945, -0.028671547770500183, 0.002552202669903636, -0.04338708147406578, 0.025203650817275047, 0.013396692462265491, 0.08349304646253586, 0.016830982640385628, -0.01830839179456234, 0.03713789954781532, -0.03410593792796135, 0.03900759667158127, -0.049122996628284454, -0.06840553134679794, -0.01125861331820488, -0.06427791714668274, 0.00153407733887434, 0.00802774541079998, 0.029247891157865524, -0.07032329589128494, -0.03250212222337723, 0.10070694983005524, -0.014223803766071796, -0.010064725764095783, -0.02733578160405159, -0.01007266528904438, 0.001484579755924642, 0.07087500393390656, -0.128802090883255, 0.010417867451906204, -0.06870421022176743, -0.025645170360803604, -0.06860817968845367, 0.06532523036003113, 0.020672766491770744, 0.02635236829519272, -0.055243074893951416, 0.004187023267149925, -0.06998228281736374, -0.013844351284205914, -0.02353762276470661, -0.05806639418005943, -0.025564715266227722, 0.031782083213329315, 0.05015555024147034, 0.027979718521237373, 0.030512729659676552, -0.07507441192865372, -0.023857075721025467, 0.010763557627797127, -0.048420846462249756, -0.03535107150673866, 0.00934246089309454, -0.025181248784065247, 0.00737927807494998, 0.042001135647296906, 0.010717811994254589, -0.018005967140197754, -0.0063090138137340546, 0.05805154889822006, -0.06674972176551819, 0.06375269591808319, -0.008735910058021545, -0.06971628218889236, -0.013288792222738266, 0.07870451360940933, -0.027529889717698097, -0.03563475236296654, -0.05442306399345398, 0.05969078466296196, -0.02746747061610222, 0.04522468522191048, 0.06983692944049835, -0.06816063821315765, -0.011649798601865768, -0.05629140883684158, 0.06892083585262299, -0.05033409222960472, 0.019854078069329262, 0.007580876350402832, -0.006353628821671009, -0.040661346167325974, 0.0162607841193676, 0.04396704584360123, 0.014389713294804096, -0.02234678901731968, -0.01518710795789957, 0.031188631430268288, 0.056485630571842194, 0.09154398739337921, -0.02986306883394718, -0.0480349026620388, 0.0097479447722435, -0.05151951313018799, 0.026967011392116547, -0.046236079186201096, -0.015633124858140945, 0.03355022892355919, -0.017091674730181694, -0.016070570796728134, -0.020527975633740425, -0.002102707279846072, -0.027386397123336792, -0.0478120781481266, -0.10477045178413391, -0.08171592652797699, -0.010906741954386234, 0.04961513355374336, -0.028040146455168724, 0.07166250795125961, -0.00922456942498684, 0.025297468528151512, -0.04550354182720184, 0.06430953741073608, -0.003362660761922598, 0.020849458873271942, -0.06541558355093002, 0.03350057452917099, 0.016183990985155106, -0.07264342904090881, 0.014323912560939789, -0.03320940583944321, -0.02111389860510826, -0.0005184311885386705, -0.022064678370952606, -0.038372818380594254, 0.07528673857450485, 0.12849828600883484, -0.001113191363401711, 0.06457092612981796, -0.0807182639837265, -0.032268669456243515, -0.04094845429062843, 0.03645242005586624, 0.03995098918676376, 0.01924862712621689, 0.037749532610177994, -0.036975134164094925, -0.040999893099069595, -0.012091199867427349, -0.0407341867685318, -0.06421015411615372, 0.04939032718539238, -0.005909587722271681, -0.013581420294940472, 0.06266767531633377, 0.05400655046105385, -0.04024340957403183, 0.08993315696716309, 0.029635874554514885, 0.011099020950496197, 0.01174001581966877, 0.05892070755362511, -0.00855716411024332, -0.019941363483667374, -0.016630016267299652, 0.09539654850959778, 0.0625009834766388, 0.07028866559267044, 0.0008994041127152741, -0.05488134175539017, 0.02217189222574234, 0.017900856211781502, -0.005789394956082106, -0.023468060418963432, 0.011745539493858814, 0.005266890861093998, 0.010189025662839413, 0.03591325506567955, 0.060234829783439636, -0.03738880529999733, 0.05827945098280907, -0.024550193920731544, -0.025314420461654663, 0.011965186335146427, 0.01128851156681776, 0.04983232915401459, -0.019529445096850395, -0.006410738918930292, 0.016742855310440063, -0.010829359292984009, -6.050233309906616e-7, 0.0016224918654188514, 0.022282686084508896, -0.0508761927485466, 0.013088521547615528, -0.011877198703587055, 0.04069098085165024, 0.02025137096643448, 0.0316559374332428, -0.004554021637886763, -0.01644584909081459, 0.025585493072867393, 0.006257166154682636, -0.027610551565885544, 0.024165578186511993, 0.06843239068984985, -0.010962676256895065, 0.009610298089683056, -0.006220584269613028, 0.04026840627193451, -0.007691012695431709, 0.018147248774766922, 0.05115445703268051, 0.031877126544713974, 0.0697907879948616, 0.09167785942554474, -0.028940649703145027, -0.02330806851387024, 0.08440671861171722, -0.044077176600694656, 0.0007543092360720038 ]
189
189
Characterizing Truthful Multi-Armed Bandit Mechanisms
We consider a multi-round auction setting motivated by pay-per-click auctions for Internet advertising. In each round the auctioneer selects an advertiser and shows her ad, which is then either clicked or not. An advertiser derives value from clicks; the value of a click is her private information. Initially, neither the auctioneer nor the advertisers have any information about the likelihood of clicks on the advertisements. The auctioneer's goal is to design a (dominant strategies) truthful mechanism that (approximately) maximizes the social welfare. If the advertisers bid their true private values, our problem is equivalent to the "multi-armed bandit problem", and thus can be viewed as a strategic version of the latter. In particular, for both problems the quality of an algorithm can be characterized by "regret", the difference in social welfare between the algorithm and the benchmark which always selects the same "best" advertisement. We investigate how the design of multi-armed bandit algorithms is affected by the restriction that the resulting mechanism must be truthful. We find that truthful mechanisms have certain strong structural properties -- essentially, they must separate exploration from exploitation -- and they incur much higher regret than the optimal multi-armed bandit algorithms. Moreover, we provide a truthful mechanism which (essentially) matches our lower bound on regret.
[ 0.026074938476085663, -0.03472534939646721, 0.04249138385057449, -0.008739767596125603, -0.06987575441598892, -0.03854390233755112, -0.026469115167856216, -0.037917111068964005, -0.041970398277044296, 0.009639384225010872, 0.03271033614873886, -0.02170827053487301, -0.03828852251172066, -0.01424613781273365, 0.04772116243839264, -0.0013857795856893063, 0.01770075596868992, -0.008925964124500751, 0.00137913238722831, -0.023478928953409195, 0.0827125832438469, -0.012752187438309193, 0.04500371217727661, 0.036449823528528214, -0.031851399689912796, 0.04038887470960617, 0.03176652267575264, -0.015856442973017693, -0.030117083340883255, -0.040744196623563766, -0.07281534373760223, 0.02663923054933548, -0.026667578145861626, -0.0017533315112814307, -0.059002261608839035, -0.03953348100185394, 0.014270889572799206, -0.06556621193885803, -0.010699423030018806, -0.010316187515854836, 0.027563638985157013, -0.01574648544192314, -0.06405671685934067, 0.012590322643518448, 0.06643698364496231, 0.04640568047761917, 0.017036190256476402, -0.003592311404645443, 0.06267369538545609, -0.015318012796342373, -0.0768221765756607, 0.018751440569758415, -0.010355578735470772, -0.0504462756216526, -0.0033184411004185677, -0.01329568400979042, -0.005321995355188847, -0.025902757421135902, 0.03526938334107399, 0.01886807195842266, 0.015059051103889942, 0.06193713843822479, -0.027810849249362946, -0.00917173270136118, 0.03556409478187561, 0.041351720690727234, -0.07248727977275848, -0.0052172960713505745, -0.10956384241580963, -0.07648886740207672, 0.036883555352687836, 0.016268569976091385, 0.03587658330798149, -0.0003598043113015592, 0.01494383905082941, -0.023141931742429733, 0.016299884766340256, -0.017964135855436325, -0.028601273894309998, 0.038734689354896545, -0.16018450260162354, 0.09175068885087967, 0.00944247655570507, 0.009180527180433273, 0.005926533602178097, -0.061122290790081024, 0.012308381497859955, -0.03764275833964348, -0.029571155086159706, 0.02262437529861927, 0.012185418978333473, 0.008048640564084053, -0.003812816459685564, 0.01163271814584732, -0.0008365128887817264, -0.0025853822007775307, -0.01083432137966156, -0.03625933825969696, 0.022604383528232574, 0.04735463857650757, 0.03068864345550537, 0.02835165336728096, 0.03848060965538025, 0.058836761862039566, -0.034410566091537476, -0.0038631625939160585, 0.06801138073205948, 0.006190476007759571, 0.0007787231006659567, -0.050374168902635574, -0.003927086014300585, -0.08340446650981903, -0.01916511356830597, -0.02217463217675686, -0.04953138902783394, -0.022686921060085297, -0.04439939931035042, 0.06840948760509491, 0.036091722548007965, 0.02988939732313156, 0.010755729861557484, 0.012096639722585678, -0.004895329941064119, 0.02567172609269619, 0.013542640954256058, -0.1515805870294571, 0.001445935107767582, -0.0628400593996048, 0.11202488839626312, 0.028787920251488686, -0.06128251925110817, 0.012711811810731888, 0.008834709413349628, -0.09414215385913849, -0.021504346281290054, 0.0500124953687191, 0.028650378808379173, -0.05028660222887993, 0.045628584921360016, 0.04133336618542671, -0.021208548918366432, 0.021739130839705467, -0.06411493569612503, -0.027354208752512932, 0.016870049759745598, 0.012726092711091042, 0.03545636683702469, 0.025737501680850983, 0.020037338137626648, -0.01232624426484108, -0.07421083748340607, -0.0014687749790027738, 0.009392165578901768, 0.05592285469174385, 0.04474499821662903, -0.007440783549100161, -0.030213039368391037, -0.06835401803255081, -0.10714094340801239, 0.027042778208851814, 0.006368852220475674, -0.00834040716290474, 0.09838253259658813, 0.007452684920281172, 0.025239918380975723, 0.03673340007662773, -0.024677960202097893, 0.025016896426677704, -0.04979049414396286, -0.09950330853462219, -0.015974529087543488, -0.050466664135456085, 0.010981960222125053, 0.0076233996078372, 0.07106180489063263, -0.03106098249554634, -0.02554251067340374, -0.00584383076056838, -0.018634993582963943, 0.006525431293994188, -0.013702060095965862, -0.07834011316299438, 0.00953684188425541, -0.03624975308775902, 0.06563090533018112, 0.07953036576509476, 0.04114401713013649, 0.04697120562195778, 0.07254577428102493, 0.07656186819076538, 0.017499787732958794, 0.005727642681449652, -0.006310202647000551, -0.04490901157259941, -0.03458046168088913, -0.027989203110337257, 0.014375711791217327, -0.08246614038944244, -0.05322589725255966, -0.06534503400325775, -0.0010139911901205778, -0.035749610513448715, -0.017778882756829262, 0.026507815346121788, 0.05747352913022041, -0.0016252492787316442, 0.020256802439689636, -0.013395524583756924, -0.013220971450209618, -0.035269320011138916, 0.026903625577688217, -0.032854121178388596, 0.011441176757216454, -0.05920357629656792, 0.07695463299751282, -0.027247510850429535, -0.005750120617449284, -0.058454837650060654, 0.04880985617637634, -0.06252723187208176, -0.012745348736643791, 0.02595825493335724, 0.0345640704035759, -0.013171766884624958, -0.005656227469444275, 0.002017285441979766, 0.037687644362449646, 0.02434595860540867, -0.036069370806217194, -0.006992661394178867, -0.013996599242091179, -0.03688718006014824, -0.016294972971081734, 0.05592940375208855, -0.0835319459438324, 0.04896164312958717, -0.06063815951347351, -0.06704980880022049, 0.03427368402481079, 0.0021375021897256374, -0.02512858621776104, 0.017150120809674263, -0.032163187861442566, -0.03862427547574043, 0.02759043499827385, 0.020532459020614624, 0.055795423686504364, 0.07825876772403717, -0.004422259051352739, -0.03770013898611069, 0.12385249882936478, 0.017402218654751778, -0.09509778022766113, 0.012377191334962845, 0.08086276799440384, 0.014061175286769867, -0.006854663137346506, 0.04263908416032791, -0.0009655695757828653, -0.014853280037641525, -0.02451036125421524, 0.022737527266144753, -0.06333502382040024, -0.004396743141114712, 0.019636120647192, -0.006119856610894203, -0.061779044568538666, -0.017564130946993828, -0.00508020119741559, 0.029092643409967422, -0.001853708061389625, -0.0687110647559166, -0.011638031341135502, 0.14228685200214386, -0.07515916228294373, -0.05426124855875969, 0.038103461265563965, 0.029350852593779564, -0.03792191669344902, 0.04076423868536949, -0.11196158081293106, 0.0010850579710677266, 0.034548625349998474, 0.022635873407125473, -0.009512148797512054, 0.06145045533776283, -0.050834719091653824, 0.03395358473062515, 0.04571910575032234, -0.014005408622324467, -0.07388417422771454, -0.01794765517115593, -0.03693258762359619, -0.06291432678699493, 0.037244219332933426, -0.024394692853093147, -0.07565449923276901, -0.012542502954602242, 0.06120078265666962, -0.019659187644720078, -0.020517723634839058, 0.01357785239815712, 0.04159149155020714, -0.010251511819660664, -0.007496639620512724, 0.040774233639240265, 0.038016851991415024, 0.03779967501759529, -0.038217924535274506, -0.055340804159641266, 0.08121135830879211, -0.03724043443799019, -0.050282496958971024, -0.0523260198533535, 0.11266202479600906, 0.0709739699959755, 0.02975314110517502, -0.04191103205084801, 0.011629689484834671, 0.04740883409976959, -0.09627871215343475, -0.041721899062395096, -0.02284821681678295, 0.024704113602638245, -0.1414487212896347, -0.02734655700623989, -0.026091841980814934, -0.0062016816809773445, -0.015959367156028748, 0.062052927911281586, -0.06723153591156006, 0.03285224363207817, -0.04785466194152832, 0.08770899474620819, -0.12023349106311798, -0.02278505079448223, -0.025039419531822205, 0.017995614558458328, 0.028016144409775734, 0.04576246812939644, -0.09951379150152206, -0.03366813063621521, -0.01728689670562744, 0.02682490088045597, 0.057913389056921005, 0.12148606777191162, -0.0032055398914963007, -0.012117516249418259, -0.00659798551350832, 0.03430061414837837, 0.00664081797003746, -0.010571553371846676, 0.03794199228286743, 0.05445338413119316, -0.047840800136327744, 0.04268115386366844, -0.04752342030405998, 0.051775477826595306, -0.028870346024632454, 0.0072276112623512745, -0.017699487507343292, -0.05980038642883301, 0.02106712944805622, 0.05266520008444786, 0.11631740629673004, 0.021252315491437912, 0.036760520190000534, 0.008039119653403759, -0.06937108188867569, -0.02415916696190834, 0.0004630392068065703, 0.0002287433308083564, 0.008550021797418594, -0.03777517378330231, -0.019347403198480606, -0.029266055673360825, -0.06656970828771591, -0.07518002390861511, -0.0029665068723261356, 0.06904926151037216, 0.003922355826944113, -0.025156890973448753, 0.006928666029125452, -0.030339131131768227, 0.052453599870204926, -0.038587071001529694, -0.010640651918947697, 0.006075228564441204, 0.09281370788812637, -0.03703265264630318, 0.013571781106293201, -0.07381784170866013, 0.03995955362915993, 0.03065532073378563, 0.013854200020432472, -0.014451351948082447, 0.06915123015642166, -0.06867406517267227, -0.07128999382257462, 0.02195965126156807, 0.02187979780137539, 0.03099968098104, -0.01101828645914793, -0.014171391725540161, -0.052403032779693604, 0.00212439545430243, -0.02871604822576046, 0.03016120381653309, 0.003391000907868147, -0.015483813360333443, 0.016981864348053932, 0.005875494796782732, 0.012956664897501469, 0.03288763016462326, 0.013960767537355423, 0.0733824223279953, 0.06418494880199432, 0.005879539996385574, -0.005681040231138468, -0.032885514199733734, 0.06394506990909576, -0.07843790203332901, -0.033914923667907715, -0.03555596247315407, -0.019291121512651443, -0.04616321995854378, -0.02883721888065338, 0.04593363031744957, -0.04747646301984787, 0.019165953621268272, -0.006142651662230492, 0.01791260577738285, -0.005417961627244949, -0.04593545198440552, -0.02257157303392887, -0.010763355530798435, -0.0297633595764637, -0.041185490787029266, -0.012765053659677505, 0.0033400061074644327, 0.01629040390253067, -0.001172361895442009, 0.004549185745418072, 0.028943601995706558, 0.027683718129992485, 0.0020487282890826464, 0.02413666434586048, -0.010780973359942436, 0.05290328338742256, 0.025910770520567894, 0.006658628117293119, 0.005840429104864597, 0.021078690886497498, -0.04473574087023735, -0.058658014982938766, 0.030297623947262764, -0.003815311938524246, 0.02527596801519394, 0.043805211782455444, 0.044773925095796585, 0.005509124603122473, -0.03713905066251755, 0.05736619234085083, -0.03922033682465553, -0.04654981940984726, 0.047258954495191574, 0.03700127825140953, -0.012350562028586864, 0.04866636171936989, 0.03784281760454178, -0.08214357495307922, -0.03546862304210663, 0.009643184021115303, -0.0644683986902237, -0.04905564710497856, -0.008167780935764313, -0.015385978855192661, -0.036549512296915054, 0.024993566796183586, 0.020791297778487206, -0.05009772628545761, 0.00632232241332531, 0.011271986179053783, -0.07093396037817001, 0.05876746028661728, -0.0027277006302028894, -0.06717802584171295, -0.04142404720187187, 0.023326678201556206, -0.019876807928085327, 0.03838573023676872, -0.0600888654589653, 0.025212468579411507, 0.046563390642404556, 0.03013473190367222, -0.0016473543364554644, 0.06535617262125015, -0.010153301060199738, 0.05023758113384247, 0.015936873853206635, -0.007624835707247257, 0.004852446727454662, 0.04302176088094711, 0.05295160412788391, 0.045217014849185944, -0.04189031943678856, 0.09861788153648376, -0.03529664874076843, 0.020356502383947372, -0.04225734993815422, -0.05282643064856529, 0.029517775401473045 ]
190
190
Feature Selection By KDDA For SVM-Based MultiView Face Recognition
Applications such as face recognition that deal with high-dimensional data need a mapping technique that introduces representation of low-dimensional features with enhanced discriminatory power and a proper classifier, able to classify those complex features. Most of traditional Linear Discriminant Analysis suffer from the disadvantage that their optimality criteria are not directly related to the classification ability of the obtained feature representation. Moreover, their classification accuracy is affected by the "small sample size" problem which is often encountered in FR tasks. In this short paper, we combine nonlinear kernel based mapping of data called KDDA with Support Vector machine classifier to deal with both of the shortcomings in an efficient and cost effective manner. The proposed here method is compared, in terms of classification accuracy, to other commonly used FR methods on UMIST face database. Results indicate that the performance of the proposed method is overall superior to those of traditional FR approaches, such as the Eigenfaces, Fisherfaces, and D-LDA methods and traditional linear classifiers.
[ 0.021976158022880554, -0.07793587446212769, 0.014439597725868225, -0.007471960037946701, -0.0300381388515234, -0.024891072884202003, -0.001367297605611384, 0.01149294525384903, -0.04813011363148689, 0.007879195734858513, 0.02188100852072239, 0.021448450163006783, -0.03672223538160324, 0.05601876229047775, -0.014635959640145302, 0.026457082480192184, 0.05165935307741165, -0.018118811771273613, 0.03733362630009651, -0.050341568887233734, 0.04921901598572731, -0.056495822966098785, -0.03084336221218109, -0.07776768505573273, 0.04812643304467201, 0.06247354671359062, -0.01716110110282898, -0.011173384264111519, -0.03200811147689819, 0.031679023057222366, 0.00042206692160107195, -0.020803453400731087, 0.036011360585689545, -0.015085607767105103, -0.029322350397706032, -0.014734500087797642, 0.010147854685783386, -0.027862094342708588, -0.060088180005550385, -0.019243186339735985, 0.026381712406873703, 0.048976995050907135, 0.01239017304033041, -0.002581034554168582, 0.03555237874388695, 0.07797065377235413, 0.010747401043772697, -0.03554245084524155, 0.017888003960251808, 0.05894751101732254, -0.05084940418601036, 0.02542681060731411, -0.06394825130701065, -0.025009628385305405, -0.03690352290868759, -0.016652550548315048, 0.016937389969825745, 0.04157824441790581, 0.032267071306705475, 0.013847307302057743, 0.07727428525686264, 0.0920376181602478, -0.007608011830598116, -0.025262515991926193, 0.03171493113040924, -0.05092999339103699, -0.012518768198788166, 0.004877873696386814, -0.035482779145240784, 0.013789614662528038, -0.047738298773765564, -0.039390068501234055, -0.05656781420111656, 0.05290868505835533, -0.005032343324273825, 0.029232358559966087, -0.027400866150856018, -0.0664542019367218, 0.09476915746927261, 0.054265156388282776, 0.028527500107884407, 0.022235814481973648, 0.013962809927761555, 0.0009341515833511949, 0.020308077335357666, 0.07615239173173904, 0.03472178801894188, -0.02567698061466217, -0.006642973981797695, 0.06463739275932312, 0.01049435418099165, -0.0030455354135483503, -0.027858566492795944, 0.0014765089144930243, -0.03573884442448616, -0.00719066895544529, 0.011849895119667053, -0.029929138720035553, 0.09878356009721756, -0.02573598548769951, -0.02393265999853611, -0.009349627420306206, 0.10816054046154022, 0.01289310585707426, -0.007768800016492605, 0.09440961480140686, -0.0638662725687027, 0.028782283887267113, -0.04470958560705185, -0.07454551756381989, 0.054973628371953964, -0.04793286696076393, -0.008940973319113255, 0.016796797513961792, -0.021442018449306488, 0.01429026760160923, -0.052670035511255264, 0.05091803893446922, 0.03418683260679245, -0.0422443263232708, -0.0216732919216156, 0.04231388494372368, -0.012580365873873234, -0.04291873797774315, 0.07053595781326294, -0.03857201710343361, -0.00426244642585516, -0.07019220292568207, 0.07302343845367432, 0.022284388542175293, -0.10809812694787979, 0.06467311084270477, -0.018095990642905235, 0.0226944237947464, -0.09612029790878296, -0.020702093839645386, 0.019953260198235512, -0.012739773839712143, -0.032305262982845306, 0.10080426186323166, -0.024550219997763634, 0.03386184200644493, -0.03568504750728607, -0.005656144116073847, 0.0859890952706337, 0.015094581060111523, -0.022326171398162842, 0.0044381567277014256, 0.03877221792936325, -0.05055974796414375, -0.012583430856466293, -0.123207226395607, 0.023570967838168144, -0.0302308090031147, 0.039509110152721405, -0.06600462645292282, -0.002204322488978505, 0.0018185069784522057, 0.034209731966257095, 0.08329680562019348, 0.006249721627682447, -0.04199812188744545, -0.03400309011340141, -0.0012270384468138218, -0.012596037238836288, -0.045076798647642136, 0.007037512958049774, -0.006206877063959837, -0.01704837754368782, -0.09062992036342621, -0.0031751387286931276, -0.005252230912446976, -0.02003740333020687, 0.03768666833639145, -0.00038162764394655824, -0.005363389849662781, -0.02161025069653988, 0.010416640900075436, -0.058036092668771744, -0.037062354385852814, -0.0076469979248940945, -0.027166621759533882, -0.026143517345190048, 0.03628905862569809, 0.04526081681251526, 0.08546148240566254, -0.048040758818387985, -0.020627276971936226, -0.01353919506072998, 0.039570152759552, 0.022940967231988907, 0.07519824802875519, 0.05426475778222084, -0.042199645191431046, -0.04401474818587303, 0.07688538730144501, -0.03233087435364723, -0.04879772663116455, 0.0563933327794075, 0.07356026768684387, 0.0742281973361969, -0.05695107579231262, -0.06333533674478531, -0.07276301831007004, -0.08469202369451523, -0.015830693766474724, 0.054660651832818985, -0.02074468322098255, 0.031736262142658234, -0.047328636050224304, 0.039486486464738846, 0.017903806641697884, 0.03383361175656319, -0.010796218179166317, -0.0017742636846378446, -0.01870538294315338, -0.010455588810145855, -0.025638123974204063, -0.009032717905938625, 0.06490951776504517, -0.05800911784172058, 0.009051132015883923, -0.024692554026842117, 0.08269937336444855, -0.06641343235969543, -0.00793179776519537, 0.020862137898802757, -0.04271703213453293, -0.05369218438863754, 0.04290500283241272, -0.023989906534552574, -0.04619959741830826, -0.062099751085042953, -0.04965639114379883, 0.013753218576312065, -0.028661692515015602, -0.06399626284837723, 0.019262397661805153, 0.06255556643009186, 0.01237463392317295, -0.03247814625501633, 0.05128227919340134, -0.05043956637382507, -0.07799756526947021, -0.03506163880228996, -0.06051891669631004, 0.020387975499033928, 0.06288287043571472, 0.07759453356266022, -0.00658341683447361, -0.022345947101712227, -0.005988229997456074, -0.009368539787828922, -0.08990760147571564, -0.026153994724154472, -0.013890977948904037, -0.040156736969947815, 0.019662536680698395, 0.11969078332185745, 0.0458550862967968, 0.07330135256052017, 0.01376871857792139, -0.025833507999777794, -0.050457436591386795, 0.03070826083421707, 0.04301557317376137, 0.0052489484660327435, 0.009890781715512276, -0.035209767520427704, 0.05685143545269966, -0.03056326135993004, -0.10211101174354553, 0.013677110895514488, 0.038430552929639816, -0.03284437209367752, -0.011998745612800121, 0.04549176245927811, 0.06273874640464783, -0.00950289610773325, -0.08232706785202026, -0.018624957650899887, 0.015498723834753036, -0.01953040063381195, -0.055666811764240265, -0.020873360335826874, 0.025342890992760658, 0.024955905973911285, 0.041310857981443405, 0.0226676594465971, -0.033844806253910065, -0.01598273031413555, 0.07025453448295593, -0.07643594592809677, -0.059582408517599106, 0.04159073159098625, -0.07458540052175522, 0.10255007445812225, 0.03253576159477234, 0.0165264792740345, -0.057351771742105484, -0.000862211745698005, 0.031131453812122345, 0.04306313022971153, 0.04493957385420799, 0.018563687801361084, 0.052064262330532074, 0.0684594213962555, 0.023207956925034523, -0.023589162155985832, 0.02292666956782341, 0.006144772749394178, 0.04760940372943878, -0.03206415846943855, -0.03341639041900635, 0.05797697976231575, -0.05403122305870056, -0.055807892233133316, 0.051069099456071854, 0.03225192055106163, 0.07284509390592575, 0.04164426401257515, 0.04501613974571228, 0.006634739227592945, 0.024429285898804665, -0.009352866560220718, -0.04435143247246742, -0.09487618505954742, 0.016791746020317078, -0.06540700793266296, -0.002517124405130744, -0.0563032329082489, -0.019745847210288048, 0.03169669210910797, 0.04179946333169937, -0.017096130177378654, 0.06797001510858536, -0.0022700843401253223, -0.026585428044199944, -0.04618543013930321, 0.005176900885999203, -0.03701144456863403, -0.054234981536865234, 0.021456141024827957, -0.0334414467215538, -0.005264760926365852, 0.053624629974365234, 0.036300137639045715, 0.01683640293776989, -0.014336257241666317, 0.0797521099448204, -0.01914469711482525, 0.093363456428051, -0.041429970413446426, 0.018535995855927467, -0.007130793761461973, 0.104763925075531, 0.05279712751507759, -0.05595288798213005, -0.017589274793863297, 0.032355792820453644, 0.017347324639558792, 0.07215682417154312, -0.05854827165603638, 0.03464888781309128, 0.04825223237276077, 0.06210850924253464, -0.060092054307460785, 0.07563415914773941, -0.025524774566292763, 0.029079750180244446, 0.0503418892621994, 0.03591740131378174, 0.014003907330334187, 0.03302197903394699, 0.06018334627151489, -0.027073048055171967, -0.022534148767590523, 0.05628800392150879, 0.04369712248444557, 0.0049393973313272, -0.03523360192775726, 0.010388579219579697, -0.0007826199871487916, -0.008002310991287231, -0.05835573002696037, -0.0157796461135149, 0.025399446487426758, -0.025393467396497726, -0.01432709489017725, 0.014582152478396893, 0.01744256541132927, 0.010989820584654808, -0.029268542304635048, -0.03521142899990082, 0.03678533062338829, 0.010053979232907295, 0.03291545808315277, -0.0700499638915062, 0.0008176211267709732, 0.032264307141304016, 0.000004872966201219242, -0.025382548570632935, -0.002883186563849449, -0.09478084743022919, -0.09679228067398071, 0.0016652971971780062, 0.013720923103392124, 0.08712189644575119, -0.062053173780441284, -0.00020402228983584791, 0.03847957402467728, -0.008858965709805489, 0.02100803330540657, -0.0045072948560118675, 0.06076432764530182, -0.008869738318026066, -0.06201352924108505, -0.06376969069242477, 0.019123349338769913, -0.05887944623827934, 0.03993900865316391, 0.00800204649567604, 0.057900723069906235, 0.023754607886075974, -0.07530724257230759, 0.004665307700634003, 0.03394365683197975, -0.0019354874966666102, -0.019481446593999863, 0.10569849610328674, -0.01652180776000023, 0.05370306596159935, -0.029523972421884537, 0.018829720094799995, 0.11191051453351974, 0.04573427885770798, 0.0843939557671547, -0.08724074065685272, -0.009034225717186928, 0.041028942912817, -0.03477325290441513, -0.007090420462191105, -0.01530527789145708, -0.019702674821019173, 0.05567231774330139, 0.007244170643389225, 0.018722442910075188, 0.021019957959651947, 0.05759012699127197, -0.015596624463796616, -0.007178271189332008, 0.01157398335635662, 0.08358767628669739, -0.05670686811208725, -0.013112565502524376, -0.04033154621720314, -0.014320957474410534, -0.05817914754152298, 0.024776216596364975, -0.056808143854141235, -0.011902058497071266, -0.09185870736837387, 0.01804707944393158, 0.008924857713282108, -0.07267390936613083, 0.014819209463894367, 0.005654837470501661, 0.010097040794789791, -0.014653956517577171, 0.019976288080215454, -0.06495405733585358, 0.022499514743685722, 0.03916598856449127, -0.05498179793357849, 0.0134595250710845, -0.033261872828006744, 0.017166942358016968, -0.04251183941960335, -0.08207889646291733, -0.027480263262987137, -0.01375450100749731, -0.005114604253321886, 0.0164332278072834, 0.028790121898055077, 0.033578403294086456, -0.0504482202231884, -0.0061242892406880856, -0.019659532234072685, 0.00832928903400898, -0.054131653159856796, -0.033023931086063385, 0.06204346939921379, -0.01635769009590149, 0.05384013429284096, -0.07863522320985794, -0.042453426867723465, 0.005500897765159607, -0.027808532118797302, -0.011945480480790138, 0.01040889136493206, -0.02266547828912735, 0.0062173581682145596, 0.013753215782344341, 0.004074259661138058, 0.055054374039173126, -0.014549186453223228, -0.008957549929618835, -0.039455823600292206, 0.030232489109039307, 0.060407787561416626, -0.08741622418165207, -0.004174302332103252 ]
191
191
Face Detection Using Adaboosted SVM-Based Component Classifier
Recently, Adaboost has been widely used to improve the accuracy of any given learning algorithm. In this paper we focus on designing an algorithm to employ combination of Adaboost with Support Vector Machine as weak component classifiers to be used in Face Detection Task. To obtain a set of effective SVM-weaklearner Classifier, this algorithm adaptively adjusts the kernel parameter in SVM instead of using a fixed one. Proposed combination outperforms in generalization in comparison with SVM on imbalanced classification problem. The proposed here method is compared, in terms of classification accuracy, to other commonly used Adaboost methods, such as Decision Trees and Neural Networks, on CMU+MIT face database. Results indicate that the performance of the proposed method is overall superior to previous Adaboost approaches.
[ 0.01510415319353342, -0.000876979436725378, 0.0004504602402448654, -0.016902239993214607, -0.01861460879445076, -0.00010010789992520586, -0.04915734380483627, 0.04550843685865402, -0.0650966688990593, -0.014794332906603813, 0.05338931828737259, 0.02031751163303852, -0.01861690729856491, 0.04500754177570343, 0.009271594695746899, -0.024319982156157494, 0.1028519868850708, -0.017224837094545364, 0.014824394136667252, -0.07915586978197098, 0.03906727209687233, -0.022943928837776184, 0.020822087302803993, -0.10417209565639496, -0.013614114373922348, 0.06921201199293137, -0.0058737522922456264, -0.022764436900615692, 0.0077349417842924595, 0.07457447797060013, -0.02042684517800808, -0.041214749217033386, -0.006770695094019175, 0.01757529005408287, 0.018777107819914818, 0.006522233597934246, -0.012794483453035355, -0.052192579954862595, -0.04835280403494835, -0.00697565171867609, -0.013164211995899677, 0.05642981454730034, 0.009406237863004208, 0.05388698726892471, 0.0727684423327446, 0.018117541447281837, 0.047586310654878616, 0.007347755134105682, -0.017136134207248688, 0.08932741731405258, -0.07153322547674179, -0.016695596277713776, -0.056664593517780304, -0.04673253372311592, 0.03925417363643646, -0.001290882588364184, 0.012920249253511429, -0.006133286748081446, 0.020065611228346825, 0.018431857228279114, 0.03892652317881584, 0.08366906642913818, 0.009705753065645695, 0.019307516515254974, 0.005930595099925995, -0.06559357047080994, -0.038280367851257324, 0.0123941944912076, -0.036811891943216324, 0.010464738123118877, 0.02604847401380539, -0.025703856721520424, 0.08409298956394196, 0.06447511911392212, -0.0017469851300120354, 0.029456911608576775, -0.04402986541390419, 0.05345713719725609, 0.06822022050619125, 0.04163401946425438, -0.023486796766519547, -0.008062529377639294, 0.048431798815727234, 0.07744722068309784, 0.02837340719997883, 0.01742878369987011, -0.04528752714395523, -0.00579339312389493, 0.021558566018939018, 0.02563028782606125, 0.01921909675002098, 0.057228103280067444, -0.02126522734761238, -0.015881896018981934, -0.015005259774625301, 0.006818737834692001, 0.057668764144182205, 0.03581225499510765, 0.04500633850693703, -0.007718161214143038, -0.006016791798174381, 0.05801697447896004, 0.03266846016049385, -0.0228886716067791, -0.09547531604766846, 0.02976255863904953, -0.06429687887430191, 0.016682084649801254, 0.005204253830015659, -0.03129976615309715, 0.03587837517261505, -0.029152842238545418, 0.008578075096011162, 0.06025374308228493, -0.022877054288983345, 0.017135366797447205, -0.042659055441617966, 0.06215955317020416, 0.06284282356500626, -0.01790868677198887, -0.012311914004385471, 0.061129603534936905, -0.012730363756418228, 0.02880828082561493, 0.07427558302879333, -0.059757642447948456, 0.04889101907610893, -0.031475573778152466, 0.08473995327949524, -0.02688644640147686, -0.13158127665519714, 0.08513369411230087, -0.01027799304574728, -0.0066933766938745975, -0.03529851511120796, 0.009321221150457859, 0.11757820844650269, -0.04204593226313591, -0.03985636681318283, 0.05440821126103401, 0.044171903282403946, 0.03119458258152008, -0.01911558024585247, 0.025845587253570557, 0.01626408100128174, -0.04652047157287598, 0.017930785194039345, 0.016527388244867325, 0.0050018662586808205, 0.0044388785026967525, -0.008785565383732319, -0.037767697125673294, -0.0036995888222008944, 0.028191082179546356, 0.05765847861766815, -0.032074183225631714, 0.021379437297582626, -0.047118544578552246, -0.007079848553985357, 0.0369734950363636, 0.014823965728282928, 0.06282459199428558, 0.02660580351948738, -0.031881291419267654, 0.018150683492422104, 0.0223544891923666, -0.0004395607684273273, -0.02230571024119854, -0.027661310508847237, -0.03957409784197807, -0.009317537769675255, 0.06915333122015, -0.06973778456449509, -0.025536978617310524, 0.004237353801727295, -0.04354507848620415, -0.0069219740107655525, 0.005796451587229967, -0.018052242696285248, 0.028555788099765778, -0.023248260840773582, -0.013459078967571259, -0.04575762152671814, 0.02502789907157421, 0.07981108129024506, 0.10195823013782501, 0.024533910676836967, 0.03569090738892555, 0.0035016818437725306, -0.04045141860842705, 0.005272709298878908, 0.013021981343626976, 0.021817153319716454, -0.036358918994665146, -0.04848458990454674, 0.08410392701625824, -0.06600413471460342, -0.06322365999221802, 0.027558503672480583, 0.08392566442489624, 0.05894618108868599, -0.0232248418033123, -0.046736154705286026, -0.02884930558502674, -0.009570799767971039, -0.04315045475959778, 0.023445401340723038, -0.03617442399263382, 0.04758972302079201, 0.011011193506419659, 0.018557613715529442, 0.0890442356467247, 0.07864221930503845, 0.029841754585504532, -0.03716595098376274, -0.028233127668499947, -0.012237755581736565, -0.020951855927705765, -0.020239971578121185, 0.06718053668737411, 0.00019099876226391643, 0.05379810556769371, 0.005589000880718231, 0.06253009289503098, 0.0012314183404669166, 0.00297255115583539, -0.011321617290377617, 0.031931180506944656, -0.03939167037606239, 0.0716906264424324, -0.08129531890153885, -0.06213093176484108, -0.056655511260032654, -0.009284865111112595, 0.013139447197318077, -0.028335127979516983, 0.01583429053425789, 0.007838595658540726, 0.06649370491504669, -0.04152064397931099, 0.008498228155076504, 0.01572028361260891, -0.05240848287940025, -0.057681068778038025, 0.006268965546041727, 0.03151581436395645, 0.006710822694003582, 0.04862021654844284, -0.06986978650093079, -0.00816590990871191, 0.027747569605708122, 0.011557725258171558, 0.0360349602997303, -0.005263994913548231, 0.007911212742328644, 0.009265400469303131, 0.028218453750014305, 0.06097737327218056, 0.012498504482209682, 0.05891675502061844, 0.06824769079685211, 0.08229590207338333, -0.030978895723819733, -0.08770740777254105, 0.01824413798749447, -0.03448865935206413, -0.015543434768915176, -0.00520744314417243, 0.019971691071987152, 0.023509124293923378, -0.06689196079969406, -0.07134971022605896, 0.03651111572980881, 0.03721294552087784, -0.009550182148814201, 0.04960090294480324, -0.007893731817603111, 0.04249732568860054, 0.005459004081785679, -0.02519722282886505, -0.003358660265803337, -0.021397871896624565, 0.019050072878599167, 0.005282119382172823, -0.054053597152233124, -0.023526521399617195, -0.03767910227179527, -0.008701288141310215, 0.04922637715935707, -0.0257113054394722, -0.0888509675860405, 0.06785868108272552, -0.0225826483219862, -0.03134026750922203, 0.026160137727856636, -0.07855565845966339, 0.037966616451740265, 0.10529865324497223, 0.04058382660150528, -0.014933699741959572, 0.029645182192325592, 0.03261328116059303, -0.022323429584503174, 0.01879127137362957, -0.042233988642692566, 0.009247715584933758, 0.06598638743162155, 0.03634988144040108, -0.036159537732601166, 0.041661981493234634, 0.004506619647145271, -0.03685835376381874, -0.009357231669127941, -0.07418568432331085, 0.04017144814133644, 0.004403027705848217, -0.0217876173555851, -0.015138340182602406, -0.029496271163225174, 0.04539947584271431, 0.017024943605065346, -0.012774359434843063, -0.01927276886999607, 0.020436523482203484, -0.11646970361471176, -0.008495794609189034, -0.08214712142944336, 0.03434133902192116, -0.09487468004226685, -0.015175134874880314, -0.0566064789891243, 0.0055978442542254925, 0.0022026116494089365, 0.052368879318237305, 0.03325957432389259, 0.0015645725652575493, 0.03503987938165665, 0.04518946632742882, -0.010387479327619076, -0.03789975121617317, -0.063032366335392, -0.015810752287507057, 0.10784783214330673, -0.013319728896021843, -0.03181750699877739, 0.003485675435513258, 0.0669967383146286, -0.013098044320940971, -0.021354898810386658, 0.03271276503801346, -0.04006487503647804, 0.08816304057836533, -0.059221792966127396, 0.018819604068994522, -0.07192269712686539, -0.02115154080092907, -0.007545221596956253, -0.1084083691239357, 0.005945362616330385, -0.026458589360117912, 0.0367075614631176, -0.02679392695426941, -0.012753462418913841, -0.02744096890091896, -0.014555118978023529, -0.007853209041059017, -0.04294871538877487, 0.037976592779159546, -0.01575685478746891, -0.06342437118291855, 0.0029955313075333834, 0.020332327112555504, 0.02018262818455696, 0.007429562509059906, 0.0653873085975647, 0.03626471757888794, 0.0674799308180809, 0.050420403480529785, 0.004597993567585945, 0.050206560641527176, -0.03543010354042053, 0.0008560224669054151, -0.026318415999412537, -0.029769210144877434, 0.0021328742150217295, 0.011373124085366726, -0.09168440848588943, -0.019794372841715813, 0.046187251806259155, 0.004004416987299919, 0.01737774722278118, -0.07990866154432297, -0.041712239384651184, 0.05085785686969757, 0.056029241532087326, 0.0346001572906971, -0.026778647676110268, -0.024416256695985794, -0.018565349280834198, -0.03480968624353409, -0.012832039035856724, -0.10825100541114807, 0.06512461602687836, -0.05589067190885544, -0.0922786295413971, -0.042405735701322556, 0.0294225811958313, 0.10455207526683807, 0.005309741012752056, 0.026453249156475067, -0.03212573379278183, 0.06676366180181503, -0.048158612102270126, 0.0267315860837698, 0.054046954959630966, 0.04072444513440132, -0.036880012601614, -0.0020460712257772684, 0.027468502521514893, -0.0893079861998558, -0.026834651827812195, 0.04365389794111252, 0.018131090328097343, 0.029927905648946762, -0.011448024772107601, 0.08559201657772064, 0.06853839755058289, 0.07714851945638657, -0.003453996032476425, 0.07511482387781143, -0.052531130611896515, 0.04041886329650879, -0.053805649280548096, -0.0634966790676117, 0.10501779615879059, 0.036241546273231506, 0.17197412252426147, -0.019005652517080307, -0.055133506655693054, 0.024146180599927902, -0.05171072483062744, 0.01053044106811285, -0.005160325672477484, -0.003963065333664417, -0.042795438319444656, 0.011054722592234612, -0.072945237159729, 0.036276623606681824, 0.09082885086536407, -0.0035902594681829214, -0.015362282283604145, -0.004871834069490433, 0.03000752069056034, -0.061663221567869186, 0.021206015720963478, -0.016094474121928215, -0.06117876619100571, -0.06307792663574219, -0.0025866739451885223, -0.014336231164634228, 0.004778773058205843, 0.0006099317106418312, -0.03243269771337509, -0.009110985323786736, -0.04901983216404915, -0.021004628390073776, 0.01668788120150566, -0.04576091095805168, 0.08520638197660446, 0.023705745115876198, -0.05051152780652046, -0.0005838912911713123, 0.001986868679523468, 0.00040684599662199616, -0.015629207715392113, 0.01321814488619566, 0.04234709218144417, -0.10084059089422226, 0.021225836127996445, -0.03851666674017906, 0.030628131702542305, 0.03318864852190018, -0.00960179977118969, 0.06642515957355499, 0.007286038715392351, -0.021262073889374733, -0.0034942319616675377, 0.042266808450222015, -0.03416749835014343, -0.0059325117617845535, 0.024096334353089333, 0.03655661642551422, 0.0311571191996336, 0.018863525241613388, -0.056262921541929245, -0.024464212357997894, -0.002686395077034831, -0.04835715889930725, -0.011524070985615253, 0.060854531824588776, 0.04892615228891373, 0.022489991039037704, 0.012227616272866726, 0.042065512388944626, 0.04106437414884567, -0.013202037662267685, 0.05700499564409256, -0.06324124336242676, 0.032008636742830276, 0.05008498579263687, -0.09396727383136749, -0.05219747871160507 ]
192
192
Binary Classification Based on Potentials
We introduce a simple and computationally trivial method for binary classification based on the evaluation of potential functions. We demonstrate that despite the conceptual and computational simplicity of the method its performance can match or exceed that of standard Support Vector Machine methods.
[ -0.04796949028968811, -0.030414855107665062, 0.029208675026893616, -0.02005901373922825, 0.020380450412631035, -0.011817756108939648, -0.06649629771709442, -0.007706317584961653, -0.02898446097970009, 0.0075388397090137005, 0.0264600720256567, 0.008933174423873425, -0.04474632814526558, 0.018602225929498672, 0.024627160280942917, 0.10848376154899597, 0.0038914773613214493, 0.020111195743083954, -0.008669322356581688, -0.013098180294036865, 0.022844646126031876, 0.03167503699660301, -0.015667419880628586, -0.03439386934041977, 0.01650156080722809, -0.026401283219456673, 0.012642307206988335, 0.020535241812467575, -0.014566285535693169, -0.006723403465002775, -0.03998115658760071, -0.012692056596279144, 0.018204988911747932, 0.028540968894958496, 0.046799808740615845, 0.01418492291122675, 0.03406703844666481, -0.032355427742004395, -0.04114856570959091, -0.01501874066889286, -0.020714569836854935, -0.005073693580925465, -0.023003730922937393, 0.026547567918896675, 0.07787299156188965, 0.017106549814343452, 0.049922339618206024, -0.025696130469441414, 0.03968099504709244, 0.05666464939713478, -0.06692976504564285, 0.003403665963560343, 0.014847047626972198, -0.016287468373775482, 0.027349334210157394, 0.015556415542960167, -0.04762132093310356, -0.024695252999663353, -0.034890756011009216, -0.008714448660612106, 0.05957062914967537, 0.09597301483154297, 0.009322095662355423, -0.021191025152802467, -0.05740230903029442, -0.040298569947481155, -0.03290548548102379, -0.07024543732404709, 0.034255027770996094, 0.03339766338467598, 0.011940800584852695, -0.08358408510684967, -0.015832049772143364, 0.0047056227922439575, 0.02394859306514263, -0.017305832356214523, 0.004927786532789469, -0.011169645003974438, -0.003370664082467556, 0.0061545115895569324, -0.025534652173519135, 0.007800575345754623, 0.06415457278490067, 0.022586215287446976, 0.022851672023534775, -0.013881108723580837, -0.02076663449406624, -0.04803526774048805, 0.0567050576210022, 0.051948241889476776, -0.049697283655405045, 0.011035548523068428, -0.08889931440353394, -0.012180984020233154, -0.07286552339792252, 0.016474274918437004, 0.023748453706502914, -0.041280876845121384, 0.053764134645462036, 0.08543674647808075, 0.05390632152557373, -0.029116315767169, 0.03661626949906349, 0.029722729697823524, 0.005765762645751238, 0.01260235533118248, -0.0475127287209034, 0.05751130357384682, -0.013480073772370815, 0.036270830780267715, 0.07381798326969147, -0.011791324242949486, 0.02338995411992073, -0.03788256272673607, -0.003572016954421997, 0.05903177708387375, -0.016397392377257347, 0.08771838992834091, 0.06385684013366699, -0.05532483011484146, 0.007058585993945599, 0.019062655046582222, -0.09804130345582962, 0.07430348545312881, 0.04639999195933342, -0.04762806370854378, -0.060023918747901917, -0.10239867866039276, 0.04935655742883682, 0.010152171365916729, -0.08283229917287827, 0.017299851402640343, -0.032322123646736145, 0.1258361041545868, -0.05018095299601555, -0.02241995371878147, 0.040772445499897, -0.05710335448384285, 0.02842848189175129, 0.06123735383152962, -0.0006702136597596109, -0.019721858203411102, -0.05077369511127472, 0.04827573895454407, 0.10383055359125137, 0.06032758206129074, -0.03565818816423416, 0.00782928615808487, -0.0023700527381151915, -0.007837185636162758, -0.05498060584068298, -0.01726878620684147, 0.03627706319093704, 0.07914324104785919, 0.017838969826698303, -0.042748525738716125, -0.05073556676506996, 0.026841357350349426, -0.0427718423306942, 0.05865554139018059, -0.03335465490818024, -0.05566844344139099, 0.05488521233201027, 0.030181337147951126, -0.06138736009597778, 0.013610562309622765, 0.013765811920166016, 0.049133822321891785, -0.024900326505303383, -0.07805831730365753, -0.01396085973829031, 0.029259108006954193, -0.04739680141210556, 0.014474153518676758, -0.020464302971959114, 0.01584177277982235, -0.04748612269759178, 0.008451269008219242, -0.057124849408864975, 0.002469779923558235, 0.06306449323892593, -0.1448487937450409, -0.09023761749267578, 0.07874174416065216, 0.06630314886569977, 0.11107438802719116, -0.015028461813926697, 0.05457106605172157, 0.029452942311763763, -0.01344917993992567, 0.05933350324630737, 0.005352898500859737, 0.0188091229647398, -0.011182025074958801, -0.050566643476486206, -0.011820489540696144, -0.03293222188949585, -0.06808896362781525, -0.01816534250974655, 0.017220593988895416, -0.012723653577268124, 0.05176746845245361, -0.07194770127534866, -0.01923142559826374, -0.012065744027495384, 0.017645668238401413, 0.050013553351163864, -0.007470482029020786, -0.01951402798295021, -0.019424954429268837, 0.033472705632448196, -0.07232595980167389, 0.05801692605018616, 0.0007013545837253332, -0.02438502013683319, 0.000015570467439829372, -0.04996160417795181, 0.04250938445329666, 0.04015235975384712, 0.06893781572580338, 0.042776402086019516, 0.013757712207734585, -0.1351984292268753, 0.053383760154247284, -0.009634282439947128, 0.013291101902723312, -0.005390913225710392, -0.018071312457323074, -0.08285307139158249, 0.09925967454910278, -0.024253012612462044, -0.0904369205236435, -0.058573510497808456, -0.014733725227415562, 0.022325294092297554, -0.01660275086760521, -0.0548311322927475, -0.026256971061229706, 0.024023329839110374, -0.040963541716337204, -0.03263600170612335, 0.11066059023141861, -0.04251997917890549, -0.0678471252322197, 0.03271696716547012, -0.07772717624902725, 0.04659230262041092, 0.047088734805583954, 0.0002973959199152887, 0.04577094316482544, -0.04083988815546036, -0.01391057949513197, -0.05995769053697586, -0.057496797293424606, 0.03197452425956726, 0.03811223432421684, -0.04675469174981117, 0.007005798630416393, 0.050288427621126175, 0.07367660850286484, 0.0023585078306496143, 0.07384376972913742, 0.03593352437019348, 0.015127448365092278, 0.008255479857325554, 0.009508276358246803, -0.02626834623515606, -0.057352177798748016, 0.007483545690774918, -0.04177488014101982, -0.018384544178843498, -0.034872375428676605, -0.03299632668495178, 0.013612251728773117, -0.030124826356768608, -0.0007335588452406228, 0.013289278373122215, -0.002883194712921977, 0.009977098554372787, -0.09708800911903381, -0.016028331592679024, 0.02314014360308647, 0.04325612261891365, 0.02516779862344265, 0.030796406790614128, -0.010661649517714977, -0.013079951517283916, -0.057061731815338135, 0.026052353903651237, 0.007482862565666437, -0.05923301354050636, 0.045655399560928345, -0.08222118020057678, -0.029949374496936798, 0.02942267432808876, -0.03136598318815231, 0.013723884709179401, 0.029309144243597984, 0.056158341467380524, -0.0521581768989563, -0.03899087756872177, 0.05760791525244713, -0.02680867910385132, 0.017420694231987, 0.014049477875232697, 0.07841256260871887, 0.029575377702713013, 0.006043164059519768, -0.008840183727443218, 0.03947272524237633, 0.0011681647738441825, -0.0051192655228078365, -0.05605125054717064, -0.04716339707374573, -0.0007710798527114093, -0.04495413973927498, 0.005058303475379944, -0.048842351883649826, 0.021869327872991562, -0.007472456898540258, 0.04698755592107773, -0.0016770530492067337, -0.01776886358857155, -0.051087841391563416, -0.04237521439790726, 0.0051449378952383995, -0.0030591029208153486, -0.02245803363621235, -0.06859485059976578, 0.04861873388290405, -0.03322676941752434, 0.0014765359228476882, -0.020808523520827293, 0.11046433448791504, -0.04541563242673874, -0.0019100974313914776, 0.024563057348132133, 0.036163583397865295, -0.010264468379318714, -0.045043159276247025, -0.07345613837242126, 0.010673744603991508, -0.048101119697093964, -0.007060636766254902, -0.06028398498892784, 0.012483488768339157, 0.05807419493794441, -0.012268312275409698, -0.018858114257454872, 0.04656302183866501, -0.05596492812037468, 0.11020791530609131, -0.01767650432884693, 0.038759201765060425, -0.0620461031794548, 0.09262862801551819, 0.0618680864572525, -0.05497217923402786, 0.0022302984725683928, 0.0019012677948921919, 0.03197421878576279, -0.004710047040134668, 0.007492052856832743, 0.04115547612309456, 0.029637470841407776, 0.05085967481136322, -0.016444139182567596, 0.025911135599017143, -0.013624993152916431, -0.04243185371160507, -0.015094845555722713, -0.04201033338904381, 0.00671155471354723, -0.025308312848210335, 0.03285900130867958, -0.001886532991193235, 0.0216384194791317, -0.04910067096352577, 0.013313128612935543, 0.07329816371202469, -0.02489117532968521, -0.005545282736420631, -0.03894075006246567, 0.022244196385145187, -0.0208036620169878, -0.05595904216170311, -0.08662587404251099, -0.03483348712325096, 0.06465495377779007, -0.01583113893866539, -0.03001486510038376, -0.08157223463058472, -0.05182519555091858, 0.022138316184282303, 0.044241998344659805, 0.04470987245440483, 0.04996752738952637, -0.045527130365371704, 0.03715280443429947, -0.03142596781253815, -0.08838191628456116, -0.08492355048656464, 0.0020064255222678185, -0.06436178088188171, -0.05551045760512352, 0.09710381180047989, 0.024718914180994034, 0.045739348977804184, -0.003964544739574194, 0.03674265369772911, 0.04451117664575577, 0.04066215828061104, -0.029130900278687477, -0.012013526633381844, 0.008681180886924267, -0.014478559605777264, -0.021229229867458344, -0.08013594895601273, -0.04967537894845009, -0.01161146629601717, 0.01970187947154045, 0.08807078748941422, -0.041393741965293884, 0.036607228219509125, -0.013912932947278023, 0.002327139023691416, 0.015287117101252079, 0.09200094640254974, 0.004497358575463295, 0.028748398646712303, -0.07099281996488571, 0.0007073169108480215, -0.05643618106842041, -0.01583068259060383, 0.005864977370947599, 0.018262865021824837, 0.021980635821819305, -0.035592224448919296, 0.0069538080133497715, 0.019174763932824135, -0.08041712641716003, -0.03216888755559921, 0.0160507969558239, 0.044525761157274246, 0.02536391094326973, 0.04093802347779274, -0.011265725828707218, -0.030849270522594452, 0.07498736679553986, 0.00007109247235348448, 0.06286883354187012, 0.0026161610148847103, -0.0488772876560688, -0.01375608891248703, -0.042127110064029694, -0.012788175605237484, 0.0034886959474533796, -0.049704235047101974, -0.007569221314042807, -0.02473083697259426, -0.048465926200151443, -0.021805260330438614, -0.02678302489221096, 0.038352109491825104, -0.036514341831207275, -0.01770639233291149, 0.019477209076285362, -0.04869135469198227, 0.028799133375287056, -0.005897712893784046, -0.10098898410797119, -0.014377692714333534, -0.011975283734500408, -0.025071414187550545, 0.010486063547432423, -0.015212859027087688, -0.03640640899538994, -0.032999664545059204, -0.01583218388259411, -0.09843823313713074, 0.039640165865421295, 0.008744791150093079, -0.05364261195063591, 0.03894409164786339, 0.016012126579880714, -0.055240657180547714, -0.07651645690202713, 0.03205769136548042, -0.011111654341220856, 0.014941887930035591, 0.02454422041773796, 0.0521145798265934, -0.03805999457836151, 0.002199613256379962, 0.013974379748106003, -0.09332679212093353, -0.07991538196802139, 0.031169718131422997, 0.022479500621557236, 0.04901370406150818, 0.025282489135861397, 0.03954150155186653, 0.0845012217760086, 0.040784671902656555, -0.04192662984132767, 0.0665559247136116, 0.0018798490054905415, -0.022957095876336098, 0.03052578493952751, 0.07447300851345062, -0.0539974644780159, -0.015984414145350456 ]
193
193
Comparison of Binary Classification Based on Signed Distance Functions with Support Vector Machines
We investigate the performance of a simple signed distance function (SDF) based method by direct comparison with standard SVM packages, as well as K-nearest neighbor and RBFN methods. We present experimental results comparing the SDF approach with other classifiers on both synthetic geometric problems and five benchmark clinical microarray data sets. On both geometric problems and microarray data sets, the non-optimized SDF based classifiers perform just as well or slightly better than well-developed, standard SVM methods. These results demonstrate the potential accuracy of SDF-based methods on some types of problems.
[ 0.028956543654203415, -0.010620096698403358, -0.00633629085496068, -0.005016044247895479, 0.06719879060983658, -0.026470618322491646, 0.0319516621530056, 0.0038577530067414045, -0.08167274296283722, 0.08652930706739426, 0.04575708508491516, 0.013586239889264107, -0.05686072260141373, 0.05899389088153839, 0.023871082812547684, 0.013085519894957542, 0.025997387245297432, 0.018095597624778748, 0.011451859958469868, -0.077684685587883, 0.103317029774189, -0.03038509003818035, 0.013852331787347794, -0.08400057256221771, 0.005614152178168297, 0.09569176286458969, 0.04669054597616196, 0.04878419265151024, 0.03608187288045883, -0.0009346549049951136, 0.0024142565671354532, -0.03452776372432709, 0.057690881192684174, -0.032433364540338516, -0.011020893231034279, -0.009495182894170284, -0.0006088531226851046, -0.04000948742032051, -0.06549036502838135, -0.0692204013466835, -0.020828532055020332, 0.01634894497692585, 0.022978052496910095, 0.0049824039451777935, 0.054215990006923676, 0.027901671826839447, 0.0071328990161418915, 0.04906167462468147, 0.028850460425019264, 0.08711685240268707, -0.037283968180418015, 0.024601422250270844, 0.019428670406341553, 0.029240360483527184, -0.049211807548999786, -0.003446785267442465, 0.03836991265416145, 0.0004399333265610039, -0.018462687730789185, 0.01980149745941162, -0.02629462070763111, 0.0778435617685318, 0.034381620585918427, -0.030445342883467674, 0.02029542438685894, -0.07775396853685379, -0.005316533613950014, -0.05534727871417999, 0.01022094115614891, -0.037688568234443665, 0.02031206339597702, -0.0815204381942749, -0.061283841729164124, 0.03707878291606903, 0.02390630915760994, 0.013511150144040585, -0.065242238342762, 0.0582461915910244, 0.05164533853530884, 0.039741355925798416, 0.0005932095809839666, 0.03593825921416283, 0.042032063007354736, 0.045354485511779785, 0.024012695997953415, 0.02668803371489048, -0.016129666939377785, 0.003968179225921631, 0.0008034119964577258, 0.05494828522205353, -0.02254997007548809, 0.03717527538537979, -0.11498613655567169, 0.0037295890506356955, -0.0505426824092865, -0.01928686536848545, 0.017337782308459282, -0.013193883001804352, 0.03951757773756981, 0.010431736707687378, -0.03347516432404518, -0.03290197625756264, 0.046461232006549835, 0.02239125594496727, 0.025440124794840813, 0.02859971858561039, -0.03878860920667648, 0.013607131317257881, -0.09419340640306473, 0.01202426664531231, 0.028467977419495583, -0.0206680279225111, -0.010996992699801922, 0.04371287673711777, -0.03522932156920433, 0.04412160813808441, 0.006181913893669844, 0.0456356406211853, 0.07817690819501877, -0.003440012689679861, -0.007076227106153965, 0.0934901237487793, -0.033852946013212204, 0.03352995961904526, 0.05504798889160156, -0.017768144607543945, -0.02694222331047058, 0.0077585517428815365, 0.08577819168567657, -0.01944955438375473, -0.09348169714212418, 0.07774310559034348, -0.037138644605875015, 0.10964387655258179, -0.12160960584878922, 0.011453726328909397, 0.07011625170707703, -0.038664545863866806, -0.010704901069402695, 0.03236004710197449, -0.018222659826278687, -0.022175805643200874, 0.02588040940463543, -0.04397188127040863, 0.07110007852315903, -0.004117829725146294, 0.02346596121788025, 0.04129686951637268, -0.0040167407132685184, 0.013717610388994217, -0.029209714382886887, -0.07827947288751602, 0.029860980808734894, -0.040219131857156754, 0.02669920213520527, -0.052387263625860214, -0.04208420217037201, -0.01568162627518177, -0.03154950961470604, 0.1018056869506836, -0.01739027351140976, 0.014443067833781242, -0.00574273057281971, 0.0063291750848293304, 0.02613254263997078, 0.004446838051080704, 0.026884322986006737, -0.042771268635988235, 0.013561945408582687, -0.03766993433237076, -0.03546789661049843, -0.015177172608673573, -0.024936916306614876, -0.06092318892478943, 0.03259547799825668, 0.031537048518657684, -0.019731555134058, 0.005753085017204285, -0.02570740506052971, 0.032532572746276855, -0.011164357885718346, -0.05410602316260338, -0.027815833687782288, 0.008129766210913658, 0.06999052315950394, 0.11452095955610275, 0.019687263295054436, 0.0010702055878937244, -0.011158996261656284, -0.014553697779774666, 0.07396195828914642, 0.010278938338160515, 0.06514602899551392, -0.06772708147764206, -0.05338934063911438, 0.056606475263834, 0.036032795906066895, -0.07132553309202194, 0.012290677055716515, 0.05320090055465698, 0.018869685009121895, -0.025016942992806435, -0.046966224908828735, -0.08569981902837753, -0.032096028327941895, -0.022089490666985512, -0.010861299000680447, -0.0504378117620945, 0.059493936598300934, -0.012613581493496895, -0.024287594482302666, 0.027563050389289856, 0.06560269743204117, 0.006844398099929094, 0.010953309014439583, -0.020606761798262596, -0.050336260348558426, -0.03753029927611351, 0.07238832116127014, 0.002727462211623788, -0.01511120144277811, -0.0007095349137671292, -0.08236947655677795, 0.07016899436712265, -0.04056474566459656, 0.052169643342494965, -0.07404473423957825, 0.0017933656927198172, -0.0396641343832016, 0.05641734227538109, -0.014539976604282856, -0.04924087971448898, -0.03009979799389839, 0.0015436835819855332, 0.06909151375293732, 0.05718814209103584, -0.023676563054323196, 0.0349835529923439, -0.017895812168717384, 0.020147060975432396, -0.024017468094825745, 0.05312098562717438, -0.02605629339814186, -0.0518062561750412, 0.03732958808541298, -0.09487645328044891, 0.0207957923412323, 0.0348690040409565, 0.03997218608856201, 0.056124668568372726, -0.00654867896810174, 0.05917985737323761, -0.040789894759655, -0.03965524956583977, 0.08967472612857819, 0.020084599032998085, 0.009656073525547981, -0.0038866985123604536, 0.013629461638629436, 0.09424439072608948, 0.05059635266661644, 0.09427585452795029, -0.00034500317997299135, 0.003241568570956588, 0.028090575709939003, 0.028370866551995277, -0.08778683096170425, 0.05382075533270836, 0.01223389245569706, -0.0157668087631464, 0.0005072299973107874, -0.07920727133750916, -0.033374689519405365, -0.011051353998482227, -0.02370210736989975, 0.036745328456163406, 0.07763216644525528, 0.0997430682182312, -0.056142985820770264, -0.05008074641227722, -0.035426583141088486, 0.002953762887045741, -0.014049562625586987, -0.012150051072239876, -0.04080137982964516, -0.012710305862128735, -0.016215797513723373, -0.015169036574661732, 0.014466218650341034, -0.07776203751564026, -0.03307546675205231, 0.0807984471321106, -0.03195749968290329, -0.01267615519464016, 0.07018826901912689, -0.06491459906101227, -0.0038774251006543636, 0.018825728446245193, 0.07220382243394852, 0.017959007993340492, -0.030517082661390305, 0.029489737004041672, 0.03984997794032097, 0.0019130894215777516, -0.03584713488817215, 0.04380599036812782, 0.0692567303776741, -0.039150986820459366, -0.034640587866306305, 0.02662591077387333, 0.014947202987968922, 0.01029864139854908, -0.05930063873529434, -0.05277392268180847, 0.05733179673552513, -0.025170428678393364, 0.04360419139266014, 0.02506238967180252, 0.013220527209341526, 0.015990955755114555, 0.03016030602157116, 0.032865483313798904, 0.0014562122523784637, -0.0375186987221241, -0.1028842180967331, -0.0002925523149315268, 0.02614123560488224, 0.01131542306393385, -0.10293391346931458, 0.007907312363386154, -0.07962451875209808, 0.0013151970924809575, -0.0610293485224247, 0.08938761055469513, -0.04450767859816551, 0.001112796482630074, 0.0034923118073493242, -0.029245873913168907, -0.034775856882333755, -0.0008264824282377958, 0.0030100028961896896, 0.03424695506691933, 0.020362744107842445, -0.02488822117447853, 0.019837811589241028, 0.017581313848495483, 0.03139925003051758, -0.01814957521855831, -0.028705593198537827, 0.009319585748016834, -0.08356525003910065, 0.04032890126109123, 0.04139642417430878, 0.04606363922357559, -0.04877949506044388, 0.056969884783029556, -0.00439914595335722, 0.017376020550727844, 0.014814572408795357, 0.03811240196228027, 0.018182970583438873, 0.02146662026643753, -0.04124875366687775, -0.010715537704527378, -0.00030802033143118024, 0.050578802824020386, -0.0974920466542244, 0.05901328846812248, -0.053565941751003265, -0.010527576319873333, -0.03386395424604416, -0.0023463217075914145, 0.07307430356740952, 0.051706697791814804, 0.02255568467080593, 0.037290532141923904, 0.014935620129108429, 0.00645655719563365, -0.027518216520547867, 0.008137871511280537, -0.004300159402191639, 0.02844732068479061, 0.013755965046584606, -0.03627393767237663, -0.023271825164556503, -0.02494506910443306, 0.0063033802434802055, 0.0087364437058568, 0.025351066142320633, 0.017229996621608734, 0.03861839696764946, -0.0780937597155571, -0.04817335307598114, 0.017102882266044617, -0.008980389684438705, 0.02713893912732601, -0.022594023495912552, -0.030198996886610985, -0.018344977870583534, -0.0569666288793087, 0.002815188840031624, 0.017773911356925964, -0.01617308147251606, -0.03855316340923309, -0.07919884473085403, -0.040419138967990875, -0.020945733413100243, 0.12608405947685242, -0.030753308907151222, 0.10000922530889511, 0.012506844475865364, 0.002328787697479129, -0.033303532749414444, 0.036239344626665115, 0.0434846356511116, 0.05867677554488182, -0.03864805027842522, -0.016591552644968033, 0.035474956035614014, -0.07497157156467438, -0.02978096902370453, 0.10206615924835205, -0.05037953704595566, 0.07532811909914017, 0.013016211800277233, 0.01020661648362875, 0.01183239370584488, 0.07300136238336563, -0.017175093293190002, 0.07796655595302582, -0.08313709497451782, 0.025347299873828888, -0.05091850832104683, 0.0016497100004926324, 0.016905922442674637, -0.014374207705259323, 0.08418732136487961, -0.07541530579328537, -0.021271517500281334, 0.020845316350460052, -0.034756917506456375, 0.04268031567335129, -0.004889188800007105, -0.046235281974077225, -0.07188180088996887, -0.010318146087229252, 0.06674807518720627, 0.030172400176525116, 0.04150351509451866, 0.031457170844078064, -0.03083624131977558, -0.008033418096601963, -0.004552960395812988, -0.017596853896975517, 0.013897411525249481, -0.045278191566467285, 0.00856255367398262, -0.04539566487073898, 0.015140972100198269, -0.043684545904397964, 0.0017096995143219829, -0.010450354777276516, -0.028909573331475258, 0.036864958703517914, -0.022609611973166466, 0.09791109710931778, 0.04275129735469818, 0.035748932510614395, 0.025419000536203384, 0.017870573326945305, -0.1037188321352005, 0.08886963129043579, -0.02179122529923916, -0.034245237708091736, -0.0008832489838823676, -0.0396084226667881, 0.005871464032679796, -0.09466349333524704, -0.04011747986078262, -0.023542925715446472, -0.07029669731855392, -0.054516203701496124, 0.005539452191442251, -0.014482476748526096, 0.02485544979572296, 0.021367542445659637, 0.01190184522420168, 0.0057360450737178326, -0.01610378734767437, -0.06353946030139923, -0.01670636236667633, -0.000747602665796876, -0.07602737098932266, 0.016971256583929062, -0.08248396962881088, -0.032948046922683716, -0.029586151242256165, 0.02214137464761734, -0.02985675446689129, 0.03494061902165413, 0.015537652187049389, 0.041873663663864136, 0.06929994374513626, 0.016592929139733315, -0.022780103608965874, 0.00008331514982273802, 0.006187865044921637, -0.06079452857375145, 0.024849558249115944, 0.0634571835398674, -0.049528349190950394, -0.01647406816482544 ]
194
194
Quantum Predictive Learning and Communication Complexity with Single Input
We define a new model of quantum learning that we call Predictive Quantum (PQ). This is a quantum analogue of PAC, where during the testing phase the student is only required to answer a polynomial number of testing queries. We demonstrate a relational concept class that is efficiently learnable in PQ, while in any "reasonable" classical model exponential amount of training data would be required. This is the first unconditional separation between quantum and classical learning. We show that our separation is the best possible in several ways; in particular, there is no analogous result for a functional class, as well as for several weaker versions of quantum learning. In order to demonstrate tightness of our separation we consider a special case of one-way communication that we call single-input mode, where Bob receives no input. Somewhat surprisingly, this setting becomes nontrivial when relational communication tasks are considered. In particular, any problem with two-sided input can be transformed into a single-input relational problem of equal classical one-way cost. We show that the situation is different in the quantum case, where the same transformation can make the communication complexity exponentially larger. This happens if and only if the original problem has exponential gap between quantum and classical one-way communication costs. We believe that these auxiliary results might be of independent interest.
[ 0.0045016612857580185, 0.026346657425165176, 0.05299326404929161, -0.019543588161468506, -0.0030921020079404116, -0.055085688829422, -0.04133576154708862, -0.022771092131733894, -0.04024429991841316, 0.04580322653055191, 0.0024446623865514994, 0.0013219948159530759, 0.0228982325643301, 0.080736443400383, 0.09135881066322327, 0.05106336623430252, -0.020385680720210075, 0.07991589605808258, -0.035510431975126266, -0.04902556911110878, 0.030289385467767715, -0.0090322932228446, 0.010087231174111366, 0.04811737686395645, 0.0166176650673151, 0.013595896773040295, 0.02157592959702015, -0.021393226459622383, -0.015491497702896595, -0.026453925296664238, -0.044064417481422424, -0.005642321892082691, -0.020611902698874474, -0.0015727238496765494, 0.024377256631851196, 0.0239043440669775, 0.08455062657594681, -0.060382772237062454, -0.005653948988765478, 0.009947704151272774, -0.0125740310177207, -0.04203161597251892, -0.019829628989100456, 0.0040694549679756165, -0.026266196742653847, -0.08543576300144196, -0.06346569210290909, -0.0369887612760067, -0.024488285183906555, 0.055753111839294434, -0.0958421379327774, -0.049750689417123795, -0.00971432775259018, -0.003605299862101674, -0.05874893441796303, -0.018819641321897507, -0.05486820638179779, -0.04942638427019119, -0.0064472113735973835, -0.002126812469214201, 0.03342141956090927, 0.08098065853118896, 0.007691388484090567, 0.013745009899139404, -0.04272633418440819, 0.061095111072063446, -0.059130601584911346, -0.001924344222061336, 0.016872113570570946, 0.01444339845329523, 0.004591017961502075, -0.0062424917705357075, 0.042363490909338, 0.007966105826199055, 0.000015752171748317778, -0.037367451936006546, -0.042494140565395355, -0.02919764257967472, -0.014951556921005249, 0.048621293157339096, -0.000012421754036040511, 0.02248677797615528, 0.005875485949218273, 0.05688296630978584, -0.04259425401687622, -0.023586180061101913, 0.012258360162377357, -0.013073408976197243, -0.01749502308666706, -0.0034451549872756004, -0.0006755914655514061, 0.05322202295064926, -0.05137928947806358, 0.01739794947206974, -0.011386532336473465, -0.04047847166657448, 0.010780963115394115, -0.04948968440294266, -0.057697467505931854, -0.024253515526652336, 0.005538739264011383, -0.06828582286834717, 0.05670603737235069, 0.07266349345445633, -0.022041477262973785, 0.0444466732442379, -0.0114362221211195, -0.019849468022584915, 0.040893469005823135, -0.02323494851589203, 0.017721429467201233, 0.051594652235507965, 0.03997712954878807, -0.04170370101928711, -0.05282691493630409, 0.08592640608549118, -0.001888371305540204, 0.09670991450548172, 0.045181918889284134, -0.01687147468328476, -0.026135023683309555, -0.0002881861582864076, -0.04715960472822189, -0.011422882787883282, 0.0032637512777000666, -0.019622255116701126, -0.007090748753398657, -0.03991139307618141, 0.09551240503787994, 0.00008485002035740763, -0.05041145905852318, 0.014177382923662663, -0.044330645352602005, -0.09315967559814453, 0.010886567644774914, 0.02040162868797779, 0.00792416837066412, -0.07957601547241211, -0.03488466888666153, -0.0052813258953392506, 0.011059804819524288, -0.003419696120545268, -0.07844795286655426, -0.03245343267917633, 0.009352019988000393, 0.04060457646846771, -0.025130832567811012, -0.039889197796583176, 0.07544625550508499, -0.03937993943691254, -0.01406194269657135, 0.020882513374090195, -0.005591103807091713, 0.02790602296590805, 0.02698192372918129, -0.03569917753338814, -0.04539378732442856, -0.02970050647854805, 0.022960564121603966, 0.12608307600021362, 0.02974456362426281, -0.0003117314481642097, -0.04529634863138199, 0.022559845820069313, -0.057078227400779724, 0.021417206153273582, -0.062380269169807434, 0.023389218375086784, -0.08390665054321289, 0.011193239130079746, -0.0023367577232420444, -0.028002962470054626, 0.004514356143772602, 0.007461937144398689, 0.0439579077064991, -0.07292672991752625, -0.03888930380344391, 0.02908308058977127, -0.022944621741771698, -0.06679344922304153, 0.015076863579452038, -0.12085480988025665, -0.015553739853203297, -0.03508280962705612, 0.005692003760486841, 0.11543892323970795, 0.0018745636334642768, 0.07600262761116028, 0.08582304418087006, -0.0730975866317749, 0.012275747023522854, 0.04182989522814751, -0.002036400604993105, 0.04975325986742973, -0.03862033784389496, -0.02356857992708683, -0.08827140182256699, -0.0593193843960762, -0.039214976131916046, 0.03562331572175026, 0.040078599005937576, 0.04052566736936569, 0.01776309497654438, 0.009682443924248219, -0.09653220325708389, 0.022533835843205452, 0.03405991941690445, 0.01805349998176098, -0.04884485900402069, 0.014329825527966022, 0.06470020860433578, -0.005836638156324625, -0.053595803678035736, 0.0439981147646904, -0.02866015024483204, -0.0905928835272789, -0.02195601910352707, -0.05615602061152458, -0.049863919615745544, 0.019620602950453758, -0.005021870136260986, 0.08515676110982895, 0.003716549836099148, 0.06056499481201172, 0.03722701594233513, -0.03083309531211853, 0.046430449932813644, -0.010304114781320095, -0.05008935183286667, -0.00016916156164370477, -0.07059482485055923, 0.0004614508361555636, -0.07851366698741913, 0.02547445148229599, 0.037831541150808334, 0.0004503475793171674, -0.03515249490737915, -0.012678653001785278, -0.02744065783917904, 0.003396413056179881, -0.03525412082672119, 0.03600737825036049, -0.027844149619340897, -0.023299306631088257, 0.09712091833353043, -0.032329902052879333, 0.001162149477750063, 0.019144969061017036, -0.06560631096363068, -0.010937570594251156, -0.0005642603500746191, 0.0012675555190071464, -0.025658128783106804, 0.02400485798716545, 0.007722426205873489, -0.024958129972219467, -0.021169450134038925, -0.005325244273990393, 0.03755256161093712, -0.0007024487131275237, -0.043915044516325, -0.013298197649419308, -0.019533462822437286, 0.06551628559827805, 0.06545001268386841, 0.011179087683558464, 0.020798824727535248, 0.06040163338184357, -0.09346979111433029, 0.06642135977745056, 0.036774955689907074, -0.07416659593582153, 0.03285287693142891, 0.029381340369582176, -0.09669619053602219, -0.01358629297465086, 0.05734167993068695, 0.019940244033932686, 0.03975483402609825, -0.011685377918183804, -0.08096843957901001, -0.06197761744260788, -0.06228691712021828, -0.00907665491104126, -0.03397851064801216, -0.015434685163199902, -0.060183487832546234, 0.011960717849433422, 0.03427765145897865, -0.04221891611814499, -0.026028243824839592, -0.027242733165621758, -0.027814919129014015, -0.04803667962551117, 0.052793994545936584, -0.007276405114680529, -0.0025470347609370947, -0.03523488715291023, -0.0019223365234211087, -0.116965152323246, -0.024451840668916702, 0.09391166269779205, 0.038682691752910614, 0.05948798358440399, 0.04262158274650574, 0.011984312906861305, 0.02074373885989189, 0.0010112093295902014, -0.07071834057569504, 0.026891961693763733, 0.025310035794973373, 0.02465757727622986, 0.09121160209178925, 0.027042366564273834, 0.013860641047358513, 0.02735135518014431, 0.05865171551704407, -0.017210867255926132, 0.01164848543703556, -0.007811165880411863, 0.08967223018407822, 0.02343621477484703, -0.0071820602752268314, -0.05350247770547867, -0.07893624156713486, 0.02667256072163582, -0.0051265438087284565, 0.011023541912436485, -0.06619448959827423, 0.08150559663772583, -0.08475443720817566, -0.05784726142883301, 0.058193985372781754, 0.1262073814868927, 0.023595498874783516, 0.02782520093023777, -0.07358069717884064, -0.05278920382261276, -0.008514991030097008, 0.11209254711866379, -0.05650189518928528, -0.07387597113847733, 0.01574631966650486, 0.09398727118968964, 0.0020675454288721085, -0.04441341757774353, 0.09932160377502441, -0.04271336644887924, -0.014778096228837967, 0.10349702090024948, 0.026913704350590706, 0.016662705689668655, -0.031214214861392975, 0.04761885479092598, -0.0028822931926697493, 0.01735243946313858, -0.014489788562059402, 0.001119927386753261, -0.005514746066182852, -0.013653771951794624, 0.10888868570327759, -0.06691505014896393, -0.039382386952638626, -0.004366368055343628, -0.056622929871082306, 0.05137411504983902, -0.07106305658817291, -0.0662488266825676, -0.060682568699121475, -0.022822007536888123, 0.007985913194715977, -0.027898741886019707, 0.003981906920671463, 0.010421810671687126, 0.022596513852477074, -0.0059189461171627045, 0.01885705441236496, -0.016197871416807175, 0.02579634264111519, -0.040567796677351, -0.0329078808426857, 0.025783458724617958, -0.03882052004337311, 0.040585704147815704, -0.03768649324774742, -0.022837895900011063, -0.018594171851873398, 0.03715304657816887, 0.042086247354745865, 0.022158754989504814, -0.034565672278404236, -0.027686243876814842, 0.002750298473984003, -0.061490558087825775, -0.01437625102698803, -0.1022908091545105, 0.06159022077918053, 0.01565610058605671, -0.0261851716786623, -0.009864095598459244, -0.0040763565339148045, -0.08498001843690872, 0.006941045634448528, -0.066883884370327, -0.07006209343671799, 0.022981639951467514, 0.0021566348150372505, 0.06753124296665192, -0.027097105979919434, 0.029334761202335358, 0.051563408225774765, 0.043455541133880615, -0.008995017036795616, 0.034592725336551666, -0.023868275806307793, 0.0027567443903535604, -0.013906246051192284, -0.04000923037528992, -0.03581278771162033, -0.13026300072669983, 0.002590641612187028, -0.003819528967142105, 0.04328085482120514, -0.048574067652225494, 0.06540665775537491, -0.04138552397489548, -0.00865449570119381, -0.02204306609928608, 0.04465605691075325, -0.00032502360409125686, 0.007229520007967949, 0.029714275151491165, -0.04377605393528938, 0.0012127216905355453, -0.03849930688738823, -0.014440156519412994, -0.028925593942403793, 0.05058983340859413, 0.017880180850625038, 0.06570840626955032, -0.03196941688656807, 0.032811135053634644, 0.033853497356176376, 0.012163275852799416, 0.031068909913301468, 0.00029004501993767917, 0.04096169024705887, -0.0033120806328952312, 0.061023592948913574, 0.033440012484788895, 0.0473116859793663, -0.030651144683361053, 0.003104457398876548, -0.06854633241891861, -0.01795700564980507, -0.012077913619577885, 0.020220112055540085, -0.03544224053621292, 0.04181492701172829, -0.00705615384504199, -0.030563803389668465, 0.06498707830905914, 0.03344333544373512, 0.045086849480867386, -0.01937623880803585, -0.046358391642570496, 0.034356068819761276, 0.032766759395599365, 0.0032126682344824076, -0.04914574697613716, -0.031262919306755066, 0.026065608486533165, -0.05435247719287872, -0.0561915822327137, -0.03228913992643356, 0.052922334522008896, 0.01654026098549366, -0.006243159994482994, 0.07016949355602264, -0.009605866856873035, 0.03472791984677315, 0.0541585274040699, -0.02003655396401882, -0.009210295975208282, 0.053472813218832016, 0.025858527049422264, -0.0987817719578743, 0.05213388055562973, 0.009479494765400887, -0.0010476382449269295, 0.013831165619194508, -0.058106929063797, 0.045047324150800705, -0.044504594057798386, -0.015309946611523628, -0.013210461474955082, 0.0251217782497406, 0.009593228809535503, 0.04067444056272507, 0.02616320736706257, 0.0297074057161808, 0.08898232877254486, 0.02751912735402584, -0.026631787419319153, 0.059330832213163376, -0.008700094185769558, 0.05994759872555733, 0.00679634977132082, -0.06403492391109467, 0.0686495453119278, 0.00390193541534245, 0.0035062043461948633 ]
195
195
Linearly Parameterized Bandits
We consider bandit problems involving a large (possibly infinite) collection of arms, in which the expected reward of each arm is a linear function of an $r$-dimensional random vector $\mathbf{Z} \in \mathbb{R}^r$, where $r \geq 2$. The objective is to minimize the cumulative regret and Bayes risk. When the set of arms corresponds to the unit sphere, we prove that the regret and Bayes risk is of order $\Theta(r \sqrt{T})$, by establishing a lower bound for an arbitrary policy, and showing that a matching upper bound is obtained through a policy that alternates between exploration and exploitation phases. The phase-based policy is also shown to be effective if the set of arms satisfies a strong convexity condition. For the case of a general set of arms, we describe a near-optimal policy whose regret and Bayes risk admit upper bounds of the form $O(r \sqrt{T} \log^{3/2} T)$.
[ -0.002217022469267249, -0.02551545388996601, 0.11017677187919617, -0.04077994450926781, -0.0038312203250825405, -0.04174257814884186, -0.03831484913825989, -0.0038460134528577328, -0.11775554716587067, 0.05427775904536247, 0.05675835907459259, -0.06060512363910675, 0.0018555549904704094, 0.06784559786319733, 0.007231234107166529, -0.08386579155921936, -0.04930528625845909, 0.006990891881287098, 0.020185692235827446, -0.09366205334663391, 0.054551128298044205, 0.03305143862962723, 0.0038491140585392714, 0.01412041112780571, 0.019137617200613022, 0.007960042916238308, 0.022585554048419, -0.013363380916416645, 0.008458666503429413, -0.01899164356291294, -0.04632772505283356, 0.02302503027021885, -0.04128802567720413, 0.01765773817896843, 0.04259445145726204, -0.01897175796329975, 0.047672174870967865, -0.03413951396942139, 0.007274253759533167, 0.017643015831708908, -0.020164867863059044, -0.011919360607862473, -0.05345846340060234, 0.01957709901034832, 0.10268767923116684, 0.009340704418718815, -0.007637009955942631, 0.012675272300839424, -0.09554703533649445, -0.011445126496255398, -0.10420271009206772, 0.037212688475847244, -0.06390511989593506, -0.04748614504933357, -0.004179758485406637, 0.020903216674923897, -0.015290968120098114, 0.007527830079197884, 0.014864902012050152, 0.0142043586820364, 0.01234197523444891, 0.042721036821603775, -0.05397564172744751, -0.004747452214360237, -0.03236428275704384, 0.014807349070906639, -0.09044244140386581, -0.04194088652729988, -0.004229307174682617, -0.025859812274575233, 0.048048850148916245, -0.05890877544879913, 0.0040911841206252575, 0.030324662104249, 0.026219245046377182, -0.026539666578173637, 0.0016061188653111458, -0.0637364462018013, -0.05040073022246361, 0.09419634938240051, -0.10127416253089905, 0.018167776986956596, -0.0011062573175877333, 0.10306884348392487, -0.02495332434773445, -0.05894901603460312, -0.013584762811660767, -0.010190639644861221, -0.026980573311448097, -0.020171064883470535, 0.010727598331868649, -0.03918811306357384, -0.004078540485352278, 0.06558074802160263, 0.011028694920241833, 0.08843217045068741, -0.06793063879013062, -0.0007989770965650678, -0.028714150190353394, 0.02374866232275963, 0.13282893598079681, 0.07847943902015686, 0.03958522528409958, 0.0798349678516388, -0.026777205988764763, 0.010290957055985928, 0.024673549458384514, 0.06883107870817184, -0.017531558871269226, -0.07016538083553314, 0.010478450916707516, -0.06009354069828987, 0.05131262540817261, 0.006880593951791525, -0.05199004337191582, 0.031875502318143845, -0.06071353331208229, -0.030526053160429, 0.021502431482076645, 0.016490178182721138, 0.025261929258704185, 0.04057071730494499, -0.010178077034652233, 0.02456088736653328, -0.013116998597979546, -0.10900899022817612, 0.021679038181900978, -0.003900364972651005, 0.13152427971363068, 0.025860991328954697, -0.0030339527875185013, -0.00405829306691885, 0.059378959238529205, -0.09567248821258545, -0.000732654647435993, 0.01146710105240345, 0.030331965535879135, 0.010346269235014915, 0.03853932023048401, 0.07893351465463638, 0.010668294504284859, -0.017791355028748512, -0.016185706481337547, 0.03359772264957428, -0.04279332235455513, -0.05720175430178642, 0.007011660374701023, 0.06010657176375389, -0.044226039201021194, 0.036468468606472015, -0.04776512458920479, 0.02724803239107132, -0.045668430626392365, 0.044084347784519196, 0.04417221248149872, 0.01588352955877781, -0.011839422397315502, 0.03475048020482063, -0.05460473150014877, 0.021776480600237846, 0.016334589570760727, -0.006719950586557388, -0.0267014279961586, 0.03408344089984894, 0.03663641959428787, -0.0031020203605294228, 0.04277511313557625, 0.05380643531680107, -0.027693381533026695, -0.061537403613328934, -0.025538384914398193, -0.026798229664564133, -0.0012520311865955591, -0.0017051305621862411, -0.05148744583129883, 0.038175150752067566, 0.009977642446756363, -0.02831965684890747, -0.011070230975747108, -0.06178721413016319, 0.012617489323019981, -0.014052421785891056, 0.026761895045638084, 0.06746982783079147, 0.022666482254862785, 0.10367261618375778, 0.050049979239702225, -0.04293971508741379, 0.049072399735450745, -0.01271249633282423, -0.02298295684158802, -0.03542913869023323, 0.008403511717915535, -0.041725821793079376, 0.018212493509054184, 0.006949424743652344, -0.00858172494918108, -0.05183101445436478, 0.03354182839393616, 0.0232044979929924, 0.0019393026595935225, 0.06547144800424576, -0.07604047656059265, -0.015061353333294392, 0.07257764041423798, -0.004105797037482262, 0.008254285901784897, 0.01075778715312481, 0.00024218652106355876, -0.029205480590462685, -0.06380360573530197, -0.051897719502449036, -0.04482283443212509, -0.01958310790359974, 0.0343499593436718, -0.06734363734722137, 0.0207685399800539, -0.008005334064364433, 0.02645282819867134, 0.030475376173853874, -0.06747543811798096, 0.08341048657894135, -0.005521981045603752, 0.024919696152210236, -0.0726194903254509, 0.024281661957502365, 0.07007787376642227, 0.007036425173282623, -0.0312841460108757, 0.009336122311651707, -0.029820000752806664, -0.057238608598709106, -0.0013619798701256514, 0.08943618834018707, -0.052546579390764236, 0.10849127918481827, 0.03626055642962456, -0.08209562301635742, 0.0354485847055912, 0.0060488940216600895, -0.009971004910767078, -0.027541523799300194, 0.021634403616189957, 0.004657223355025053, 0.0034978603944182396, -0.001487432629801333, 0.04641067236661911, 0.05147768557071686, 0.010110030882060528, 0.021958623081445694, 0.07853714376688004, -0.06755015254020691, -0.09448911249637604, 0.04170866310596466, 0.09577223658561707, 0.009493059478700161, 0.04182375967502594, 0.04948652908205986, 0.07640492916107178, -0.08799121528863907, -0.02206249348819256, 0.01389993354678154, -0.09055045247077942, 0.0323760099709034, 0.006553958170115948, 0.010427765548229218, -0.02423097938299179, 0.03493405878543854, 0.026569096371531487, 0.02246568165719509, 0.026575153693556786, -0.005757841281592846, -0.0539635606110096, 0.0801905170083046, -0.04979613050818443, -0.021768299862742424, 0.019373435527086258, 0.0364033579826355, 0.011661539785563946, -0.010547420009970665, -0.060748640447854996, 0.04059525579214096, 0.04450863227248192, 0.01840047538280487, -0.0038684685714542866, 0.05256048962473869, 0.021969014778733253, 0.013711192645132542, 0.00922767911106348, 0.045600321143865585, -0.04951835051178932, -0.01692866161465645, -0.049726445227861404, 0.003951092716306448, 0.02578192576766014, -0.018162978813052177, -0.012135151773691177, 0.01203631330281496, 0.004400395322591066, -0.01378396525979042, -0.03403837978839874, -0.04284236952662468, 0.04594419151544571, 0.015560109168291092, 0.03191733360290527, 0.05408462882041931, 0.020654112100601196, 0.044287677854299545, -0.06399683654308319, -0.019313329830765724, -0.010709903202950954, -0.03837301582098007, 0.011660638265311718, 0.005520734935998917, 0.019167177379131317, 0.029624227434396744, 0.06563014537096024, -0.024198373779654503, -0.05317328870296478, 0.07250171154737473, -0.014911449514329433, 0.029037827625870705, 0.0403282567858696, 0.025954613462090492, -0.06774043291807175, -0.07495761662721634, -0.012722577899694443, 0.014136113226413727, 0.01998116448521614, -0.012205064296722412, -0.07436177134513855, 0.02701173909008503, -0.03339531645178795, 0.0262758806347847, -0.06082390248775482, 0.0006318644736893475, -0.09186377376317978, -0.04523675888776779, 0.06288443505764008, 0.03624383732676506, 0.010023705661296844, -0.08744890242815018, -0.023072419688105583, -0.06016319617629051, -0.010745290666818619, 0.10994039475917816, 0.0667995810508728, 0.018620984628796577, -0.015476847067475319, 0.0544244647026062, -0.08865640312433243, -0.03604903817176819, 0.000831200391985476, 0.11962990462779999, -0.0905357152223587, 0.03732065111398697, -0.017493734136223793, 0.014198129065334797, -0.024691976606845856, -0.01979290135204792, -0.06033068522810936, -0.04779618978500366, -0.014364691451191902, 0.044045060873031616, 0.023933321237564087, 0.06439626961946487, -0.041294798254966736, 0.02800360694527626, -0.052630238234996796, -0.06690066307783127, -0.054840147495269775, -0.022575782611966133, 0.05604936182498932, 0.005275934934616089, -0.01895599067211151, -0.03253215178847313, 0.026055926457047462, -0.008075641468167305, -0.04102028161287308, 0.07307936251163483, -0.030959846451878548, -0.012375380843877792, -0.06430135667324066, -0.05085623264312744, -0.0210249125957489, -0.05657494068145752, 0.02447354421019554, -0.014405487105250359, 0.12680044770240784, -0.028254246339201927, -0.009498397819697857, -0.0793582946062088, 0.12215728312730789, -0.004977738484740257, 0.057893361896276474, 0.01101680938154459, 0.04409371688961983, -0.030904263257980347, -0.011665347963571548, 0.025691209360957146, -0.001440325751900673, -0.06507238000631332, -0.006043756380677223, -0.019308993592858315, -0.007852546870708466, 0.005322954151779413, 0.04759053885936737, 0.03013434261083603, -0.06240297853946686, 0.002402473473921418, 0.00010811311221914366, 0.04040319472551346, -0.03929591178894043, 0.03440540283918381, 0.003617015201598406, -0.0021453530061990023, -0.01684892550110817, 0.005956187844276428, 0.017467740923166275, -0.0007786844507791102, 0.005955067928880453, -0.028099365532398224, 0.014963841997087002, -0.038138214498758316, -0.010263295844197273, -0.057336222380399704, 0.007294356357306242, 0.05178568512201309, -0.06020102649927139, 0.026478344574570656, 0.01734442263841629, -0.07445856928825378, 0.02034631185233593, -0.025540504604578018, -0.027034953236579895, -0.026292694732546806, -0.0852644219994545, 0.040548693388700485, -0.01659041829407215, 0.0020298026502132416, -0.04136509448289871, 0.0344056636095047, -0.05185148864984512, 0.012651345692574978, -0.0005405940464697778, 0.06483681499958038, 0.011864210478961468, 0.0010321815498173237, 0.014835362322628498, 0.06659970432519913, -0.01568247750401497, 0.014015479013323784, 0.0061163390055298805, -0.046628180891275406, 0.008231879211962223, 0.06312022358179092, 0.027570273727178574, 0.06494957953691483, -0.0011217650026082993, -0.03403237462043762, -0.012870971113443375, -0.07072587311267853, 0.03586855158209801, -0.005422488786280155, -0.0422079935669899, 0.013673169538378716, 0.07376608997583389, 0.032629355788230896, 0.015398270450532436, -0.007764652371406555, -0.020927514880895615, 0.02340194396674633, 0.025777701288461685, -0.0423949770629406, -0.014783299528062344, 0.019884424284100533, 0.04649122431874275, -0.008988551795482635, 0.005847165361046791, -0.012254642322659492, -0.039619080722332, -0.02864270843565464, -0.043615635484457016, -0.06412379443645477, 0.009047864004969597, 0.03357640653848648, -0.047374922782182693, 0.05029427260160446, 0.06248116120696068, 0.019905803725123405, -0.00938212126493454, -0.0002560434804763645, 0.01136509608477354, -0.036204006522893906, 0.07298707962036133, -0.013749334029853344, 0.09022529423236847, -0.07315083593130112, 0.04095686599612236, 0.07454203069210052, 0.058698419481515884, -0.020062172785401344, 0.03227145969867706, 0.016900649294257164, 0.05596824735403061, -0.014270702376961708, 0.04270249232649803, -0.0007521554944105446, -0.03619525954127312, -0.022373193874955177, -0.014677553437650204, 0.04232603311538696 ]
196
196
The Offset Tree for Learning with Partial Labels
We present an algorithm, called the Offset Tree, for learning to make decisions in situations where the payoff of only one choice is observed, rather than all choices. The algorithm reduces this setting to binary classification, allowing one to reuse of any existing, fully supervised binary classification algorithm in this partial information setting. We show that the Offset Tree is an optimal reduction to binary classification. In particular, it has regret at most $(k-1)$ times the regret of the binary classifier it uses (where $k$ is the number of choices), and no reduction to binary classification can do better. This reduction is also computationally optimal, both at training and test time, requiring just $O(\log_2 k)$ work to train on an example or make a prediction. Experiments with the Offset Tree show that it generally performs better than several alternative approaches.
[ -0.038614287972450256, -0.02784367837011814, -0.02162046730518341, -0.03899528458714485, 0.010988399386405945, -0.053812503814697266, 0.01498184073716402, -0.015103067271411419, -0.05712936818599701, 0.0031053724233061075, -0.008508674800395966, -0.0014760720077902079, -0.015015504322946072, -0.01124548725783825, 0.048576369881629944, -0.03874203935265541, -0.030817342922091484, -0.044448256492614746, -0.029578922316432, -0.06438002735376358, 0.04860398918390274, 0.0031089400872588158, 0.04295717552304268, -0.031492020934820175, -0.018511150032281876, -0.0015169280814006925, 0.09170233458280563, 0.05523201823234558, -0.0745282918214798, -0.026882655918598175, -0.02874443493783474, -0.00964814517647028, -0.025648590177297592, 0.029625914990901947, 0.01691652275621891, -0.0004405952640809119, 0.017127124592661858, -0.07241441309452057, -0.034173425287008286, -0.05826548486948013, 0.02115139178931713, 0.04635423421859741, -0.05417099967598915, -0.01239435002207756, 0.04222754389047623, 0.04203372448682785, 0.01921675354242325, -0.03757169842720032, 0.015021247789263725, 0.07390366494655609, -0.08694368600845337, 0.046521563082933426, -0.031094828620553017, -0.058420419692993164, -0.0013652404304593801, -0.0005915321526117623, -0.0383753776550293, 0.032347168773412704, 0.025074364617466927, -0.05228551849722862, 0.055237267166376114, 0.12237469106912613, -0.008118908852338791, 0.007985441014170647, -0.0428885817527771, 0.01872030273079872, -0.03879469633102417, -0.02493576891720295, 0.00259538646787405, 0.029541851952672005, 0.04703016206622124, -0.056789807975292206, -0.014004033990204334, 0.029277384281158447, 0.02465946413576603, 0.03677830100059509, 0.07093708217144012, 0.06584116816520691, -0.036940112709999084, 0.06497080624103546, -0.035279322415590286, 0.001128996373154223, 0.03671041876077652, 0.00042979751015082, 0.008757036179304123, -0.022329844534397125, 0.02060014009475708, -0.017260968685150146, 0.007321647368371487, 0.04033320024609566, -0.029666798189282417, 0.02678874135017395, -0.02246234007179737, -0.02734042890369892, -0.031005315482616425, 0.025406107306480408, -0.014399736188352108, -0.010127780959010124, 0.01146735716611147, 0.025918222963809967, 0.041076645255088806, 0.000433512672316283, -0.03650129958987236, 0.06740981340408325, -0.024957524612545967, 0.00504277041181922, 0.011892035603523254, 0.007403452880680561, 0.025899790227413177, -0.06312767416238785, 0.03723381832242012, -0.029574140906333923, 0.012282620184123516, 0.009737725369632244, -0.029520493000745773, 0.08715374022722244, -0.05922775715589523, 0.0716594010591507, 0.00793007854372263, 0.017412956804037094, 0.02103765495121479, 0.01624113880097866, -0.07828308641910553, 0.052005406469106674, 0.01632976531982422, -0.0670418068766594, -0.019756171852350235, -0.057132285088300705, 0.07362621277570724, -0.006472631357610226, -0.1227179616689682, 0.10606814920902252, -0.039909347891807556, 0.0015853983350098133, -0.04256811365485191, 0.06559932231903076, 0.04138180613517761, -0.017462261021137238, 0.015279003418982029, 0.03063354454934597, 0.015570173040032387, -0.015342699363827705, 0.024863235652446747, -0.009256578981876373, -0.010229934006929398, 0.035713210701942444, 0.014133707620203495, 0.068560391664505, 0.03588990122079849, -0.026658542454242706, -0.031712815165519714, 0.00796814076602459, 0.010113075375556946, 0.06484819948673248, 0.0506819449365139, -0.06594536453485489, -0.008136446587741375, 0.006622419226914644, -0.000787404365837574, 0.0066022807732224464, -0.09847930073738098, -0.00041036782204173505, 0.010207383893430233, 0.016350673511624336, 0.015018254518508911, 0.030980030074715614, 0.027463532984256744, 0.06522632390260696, -0.00638603838160634, -0.02937629073858261, 0.07599566131830215, -0.0019396772840991616, -0.06939297169446945, 0.08306945115327835, 0.04742399975657463, -0.04765599966049194, -0.020095301792025566, 0.03512942045927048, -0.03673231974244118, 0.0221023578196764, 0.07343273609876633, -0.06353189051151276, -0.0806526243686676, 0.004549295641481876, 0.04266337305307388, 0.08531570434570312, 0.042018912732601166, 0.045398663729429245, 0.07706791907548904, 0.0470987893640995, 0.02583310566842556, -0.04942333325743675, 0.03801610693335533, -0.0002552111982367933, -0.001277066534385085, -0.04161158949136734, -0.030647529289126396, -0.0023567904718220234, -0.0018045274773612618, 0.02779310941696167, 0.05583884194493294, 0.03650819510221481, -0.018179982900619507, -0.0002766209654510021, -0.053695306181907654, -0.02233019843697548, 0.06942176073789597, 0.0010650635231286287, -0.0017570586642250419, -0.05821048095822334, -0.004283573012799025, 0.012155660428106785, -0.03564363345503807, -0.004590109921991825, -0.01908574253320694, -0.03147922828793526, -0.09288150072097778, -0.012674459256231785, 0.05667949840426445, -0.028638100251555443, -0.07400716096162796, 0.06432686001062393, 0.03571367636322975, 0.020812170580029488, -0.045736413449048996, -0.04741279035806656, 0.01111559383571148, 0.00525352219119668, -0.06108454242348671, 0.08931752294301987, 0.00812271423637867, -0.07668617367744446, -0.04989215359091759, -0.03868230804800987, -0.01297108456492424, 0.05837805196642876, 0.016548804938793182, -0.04988258332014084, -0.005166349466890097, -0.0842018872499466, 0.012172861956059933, 0.03931050002574921, -0.014406689442694187, -0.03704695403575897, 0.05396164208650589, -0.010717307217419147, 0.07940434664487839, 0.04620002210140228, -0.035979319363832474, -0.019255485385656357, 0.002129157306626439, 0.020710844546556473, -0.04687107726931572, 0.054002661257982254, 0.017149116843938828, -0.04421181231737137, -0.03365142643451691, 0.06946961581707001, 0.02330603264272213, 0.06216096878051758, 0.025214724242687225, 0.062066636979579926, -0.05024914816021919, -0.015489046461880207, 0.01261360477656126, 0.10038770735263824, -0.029377641156315804, -0.05468828231096268, 0.041787754744291306, -0.00445268489420414, 0.045804496854543686, -0.05949204042553902, -0.027591988444328308, 0.07436758279800415, -0.052316196262836456, 0.035232022404670715, 0.07481123507022858, -0.01068468764424324, 0.025512127205729485, -0.053265780210494995, -0.04612445458769798, 0.010972412303090096, 0.015088848769664764, 0.053169723600149155, -0.007819395512342453, -0.036602966487407684, 0.014956967905163765, -0.0010826434008777142, 0.021494900807738304, 0.03341670706868172, -0.058715492486953735, 0.039193373173475266, -0.06253982335329056, -0.04299423471093178, 0.045021574944257736, -0.03319521248340607, 0.02809724397957325, 0.0028109264094382524, 0.04529726877808571, 0.005056977737694979, 0.018877679482102394, -0.001327509991824627, 0.07242743670940399, 0.0034653900656849146, -0.012651003897190094, 0.008376768790185452, 0.04869001358747482, 0.02804446965456009, -0.023760948330163956, -0.02556033246219158, 0.0415935255587101, -0.023758839815855026, -0.03556102514266968, 0.052848752588033676, -0.020692136138677597, -0.0054804859682917595, 0.006267057731747627, -0.06027185916900635, 0.006322179455310106, 0.012136785313487053, 0.03646428510546684, 0.026320219039916992, 0.019300630316138268, -0.03424938768148422, -0.10133851319551468, -0.056080546230077744, 0.010603691451251507, -0.0016830024542286992, -0.11609227955341339, 0.03017456829547882, -0.018201757222414017, -0.045153532177209854, -0.004717206582427025, 0.0781976580619812, -0.08337172865867615, 0.04954312741756439, -0.03179183974862099, 0.01355348527431488, 0.0015415142988786101, 0.007396802306175232, -0.0726548358798027, -0.02229289337992668, -0.04907216876745224, -0.0034681858960539103, 0.06967805325984955, -0.0265341866761446, 0.06947771459817886, 0.013949038460850716, 0.07365213334560394, 0.049741022288799286, -0.07260569930076599, 0.09910914301872253, -0.09912989288568497, 0.08823473751544952, -0.08494844287633896, 0.026734380051493645, 0.06576045602560043, -0.004246816039085388, 0.02554894983768463, -0.06142504885792732, 0.005837209988385439, 0.0027530668303370476, -0.038145072758197784, 0.01319766603410244, 0.007068748585879803, 0.035914096981287, -0.030136045068502426, 0.026239342987537384, 0.0016198442317545414, -0.007083972916007042, 0.0062048849649727345, 0.03583671897649765, -0.018509848043322563, -0.011806780472397804, 0.060022853314876556, 0.005206610541790724, 0.03161704167723656, -0.02269381657242775, -0.028248051181435585, 0.0154079869389534, -0.043396614491939545, -0.02380397543311119, -0.02700786106288433, 0.008296553045511246, 0.00915994867682457, -0.08534664660692215, -0.08747151494026184, 0.07579231262207031, 0.13115215301513672, -0.03142739459872246, 0.09443089365959167, -0.0772833377122879, -0.0014868087600916624, 0.005998082924634218, 0.03953574225306511, -0.029339592903852463, 0.041161466389894485, -0.030763432383537292, -0.04035664349794388, -0.03903104364871979, 0.015490605495870113, -0.04082363098859787, -0.007016745861619711, -0.1542467176914215, -0.060638993978500366, 0.023152900859713554, 0.05781169608235359, 0.04718391224741936, -0.007045097183436155, -0.006719307042658329, 0.010895278304815292, 0.0468350425362587, 0.00871187448501587, 0.011346192099153996, 0.0013238356914371252, 0.048354580998420715, 0.06640765815973282, -0.07863060384988785, -0.02395297773182392, -0.027543969452381134, 0.02131163515150547, 0.028306789696216583, -0.017921578139066696, -0.0021359079983085394, -0.03256286308169365, 0.0039052607025951147, 0.03852417692542076, 0.08338725566864014, -0.040348801761865616, 0.10386589169502258, -0.08559625595808029, -0.036240700632333755, -0.08935749530792236, -0.024016525596380234, 0.01401310320943594, 0.04037328436970711, 0.04796535521745682, -0.0006444301106967032, -0.04260275512933731, 0.021390276029706, -0.07395611703395844, -0.010876897722482681, 0.004114639479666948, 0.025095442309975624, -0.030203498899936676, 0.06289603561162949, -0.025074006989598274, 0.005716217681765556, 0.02477501891553402, -0.016399621963500977, 0.01677803322672844, -0.02070915699005127, 0.012079509906470776, -0.03483092784881592, -0.038347408175468445, -0.04958006739616394, 0.03475276753306389, -0.04470892995595932, -0.036055561155080795, 0.010128757916390896, -0.06386639922857285, -0.0721510648727417, -0.04490135982632637, 0.017209436744451523, -0.02319049835205078, -0.021942706778645515, 0.05641109496355057, -0.029712967574596405, 0.07671745121479034, 0.008506500162184238, -0.06042037159204483, 0.01435867976397276, -0.04896114021539688, -0.07972367107868195, 0.041676413267850876, -0.05189428851008415, 0.005626432131975889, -0.07956031709909439, 0.02904283069074154, -0.04747940972447395, 0.018663078546524048, 0.03660641983151436, -0.03850913420319557, 0.06428839266300201, 0.100739024579525, -0.03076394833624363, -0.05328745022416115, 0.00779887568205595, 0.053413718938827515, -0.009818602353334427, -0.01653570681810379, 0.05527520552277565, 0.06414597481489182, 0.004224693868309259, 0.07921908050775528, 0.009016256779432297, 0.024194417521357536, 0.0022963250521570444, 0.011156326159834862, 0.05701558291912079, 0.04107407107949257, -0.026011066511273384, 0.011029995046555996, 0.03361181914806366, 0.03885132446885109, 0.04276737943291664, 0.0001870058331405744, -0.03818393871188164, 0.03206644579768181, 0.037623193114995956, -0.03563946485519409, 0.011206312105059624 ]
197
197
Client-server multi-task learning from distributed datasets
A client-server architecture to simultaneously solve multiple learning tasks from distributed datasets is described. In such architecture, each client is associated with an individual learning task and the associated dataset of examples. The goal of the architecture is to perform information fusion from multiple datasets while preserving privacy of individual data. The role of the server is to collect data in real-time from the clients and codify the information in a common database. The information coded in this database can be used by all the clients to solve their individual learning task, so that each client can exploit the informative content of all the datasets without actually having access to private data of others. The proposed algorithmic framework, based on regularization theory and kernel methods, uses a suitable class of mixed effect kernels. The new method is illustrated through a simulated music recommendation system.
[ -0.03833691403269768, -0.02089335210621357, 0.008252909407019615, 0.05371282994747162, 0.05938824638724327, -0.09150727093219757, 0.02318359538912773, 0.0240920502692461, -0.040201444178819656, 0.024904482066631317, -0.040592364966869354, -0.019353682175278664, 0.013071339577436447, 0.01659068651497364, -0.002786958357319236, 0.01739732176065445, 0.0016696146922186017, 0.023801501840353012, 0.0026342093478888273, -0.06567008048295975, 0.06831944733858109, 0.000002503088126104558, 0.049693744629621506, -0.01249578595161438, -0.017003996297717094, 0.0010052864672616124, -0.008606987074017525, -0.03844752162694931, -0.030988240614533424, 0.032245051115751266, -0.0324944444000721, -0.03744087368249893, 0.005021686665713787, -0.012836090289056301, 0.04582560807466507, -0.039802372455596924, 0.02575720101594925, -0.02186998538672924, -0.07924602180719376, 0.009030020795762539, 0.03314412757754326, 0.003405357012525201, 0.006062195170670748, -0.00600339425727725, 0.018773945048451424, 0.0737052634358406, 0.006083712913095951, 0.014430793933570385, 0.05592091754078865, 0.05686953291296959, -0.1189819723367691, -0.004878678359091282, 0.03812681883573532, 0.02920776791870594, -0.002250475576147437, -0.006365008186548948, 0.0838431790471077, 0.011971671134233475, 0.007317559327930212, -0.031213674694299698, 0.0353432297706604, 0.03439674526453018, -0.057552874088287354, -0.010447709821164608, 0.01793687231838703, -0.026490332558751106, -0.04936281591653824, 0.0015579797327518463, -0.046368490904569626, -0.05217743292450905, 0.02400430664420128, -0.020618489012122154, 0.025677138939499855, 0.020737895742058754, 0.02999095246195793, 0.07236433029174805, -0.003941671922802925, 0.0341736376285553, -0.03619598224759102, 0.06545272469520569, -0.0906001403927803, -0.055016737431287766, -0.027658987790346146, 0.059774965047836304, -0.003560091368854046, -0.0588572695851326, 0.003859142540022731, -0.00976946298032999, 0.027468476444482803, 0.025306804105639458, 0.011380165815353394, -0.024328676983714104, -0.08490770310163498, 0.0037518481258302927, 0.05518981069326401, -0.016166962683200836, -0.06691300868988037, -0.05743321031332016, 0.08946842700242996, 0.0180800948292017, 0.011525803245604038, -0.012009902857244015, 0.04906256124377251, 0.09293147921562195, -0.0312977097928524, 0.04755077883601189, -0.005220081657171249, 0.025385258719325066, 0.04147109016776085, 0.03601647913455963, -0.013778477907180786, -0.028876570984721184, -0.016852281987667084, 0.023110996931791306, 0.00028871456743218005, 0.05051795020699501, -0.014217262156307697, 0.09402193129062653, -0.07213393598794937, -0.006514058914035559, 0.06887081265449524, -0.06937891244888306, -0.1106983870267868, -0.009216832928359509, 0.0899580642580986, -0.10885961353778839, -0.015667738392949104, -0.027296409010887146, 0.10429804027080536, 0.056542955338954926, -0.029377253726124763, 0.10954878479242325, 0.016747333109378815, -0.0818602666258812, 0.030626336112618446, -0.0031567267142236233, -0.002707195235416293, -0.025327591225504875, -0.030388424172997475, -0.0034611020237207413, 0.0013681313721463084, 0.012560744769871235, 0.00013218040112406015, -0.005497638136148453, 0.07138311117887497, -0.01666075922548771, -0.005303444340825081, 0.013643315993249416, 0.04531462863087654, -0.053161632269620895, -0.0024730623699724674, -0.05808182433247566, 0.00903316680341959, 0.02612362802028656, 0.011537296697497368, -0.10793694853782654, -0.0534917451441288, -0.002365959109738469, -0.041084036231040955, 0.0662447065114975, 0.014261918142437935, 0.055426374077796936, 0.04275350645184517, 0.01383887603878975, -0.017916634678840637, 0.025387387722730637, -0.042420171201229095, 0.014260915108025074, -0.02933143451809883, -0.03738715127110481, 0.01390673965215683, -0.02815982699394226, -0.08482001721858978, 0.018800882622599602, -0.011333518661558628, 0.028261849656701088, -0.03698237985372543, 0.01849476993083954, -0.04579978063702583, -0.007173832971602678, 0.011330394074320793, -0.03954014927148819, -0.04618760198354721, -0.024808304384350777, 0.042875342071056366, 0.03263126313686371, 0.021517110988497734, 0.05621705204248428, 0.08269013464450836, 0.03918126970529556, 0.03876243531703949, -0.0213219802826643, 0.0229947492480278, -0.027905987575650215, -0.10793405026197433, 0.12342807650566101, -0.05698227137327194, -0.012205647304654121, -0.0003027557104360312, 0.05143192410469055, 0.02774273417890072, -0.006002121604979038, 0.040938470512628555, -0.02900158055126667, -0.10260648280382156, -0.024603601545095444, 0.08788774907588959, -0.038739219307899475, 0.021095342934131622, -0.030266543850302696, 0.03297398239374161, -0.008772949688136578, -0.028020232915878296, -0.06393653899431229, -0.011887219734489918, -0.06069198250770569, -0.023250602185726166, -0.0447307750582695, 0.03391492739319801, 0.019509345293045044, -0.06556356698274612, 0.012823288328945637, -0.0822308287024498, 0.029180780053138733, -0.08738353103399277, 0.014796728268265724, 0.08222666382789612, 0.014649935066699982, -0.044143520295619965, 0.0016421646578237414, -0.04736791551113129, -0.07093726843595505, -0.07796633243560791, 0.02084651030600071, -0.000575206708163023, 0.025799041613936424, -0.00638355128467083, -0.0621311217546463, 0.009036501869559288, -0.013634970411658287, 0.0005976737593300641, 0.026492010802030563, 0.04203101247549057, 0.039769917726516724, -0.007392773404717445, -0.020939473062753677, -0.03367817401885986, 0.02582663483917713, -0.019449543207883835, -0.027914008125662804, 0.02977224811911583, 0.010481243021786213, -0.008953358046710491, -0.020251480862498283, 0.057377927005290985, -0.050766721367836, 0.023284053429961205, 0.015021085739135742, 0.08266397565603256, 0.04117037355899811, 0.029413459822535515, -0.07455301284790039, -0.0018181967316195369, -0.006566297262907028, 0.08491799235343933, 0.025888029485940933, 0.03942915052175522, 0.02793188765645027, -0.01265766192227602, 0.007754190359264612, -0.011538495309650898, -0.1266799420118332, -0.034744322299957275, 0.02596639096736908, -0.07525603473186493, -0.004652510862797499, -0.06735526025295258, 0.11491114646196365, 0.02894449420273304, -0.07317882031202316, -0.02190357632935047, -0.0017617630073800683, -0.03748404607176781, 0.004479399416595697, -0.08537626266479492, 0.01001044176518917, 0.0021592823322862387, -0.02066771686077118, 0.0297301784157753, 0.029964173212647438, -0.0003418089763727039, 0.02013086900115013, -0.08970081061124802, 0.0073165143840014935, 0.03059965930879116, -0.08252266049385071, 0.01011840533465147, 0.05298098921775818, 0.012553024105727673, -0.05745094642043114, 0.020207565277814865, -0.015894660726189613, 0.049774281680583954, 0.042072445154190063, 0.0772080346941948, 0.06415875256061554, 0.0062559256330132484, 0.09518470615148544, -0.028662804514169693, -0.037160154432058334, 0.019841361790895462, 0.023055385798215866, -0.0026759079191833735, -0.026893386617302895, 0.02872830629348755, 0.05423986166715622, 0.018182119354605675, 0.046448323875665665, 0.03351658210158348, -0.010043881833553314, 0.04900464043021202, -0.029055554419755936, 0.006244888994842768, -0.04236792027950287, -0.08520698547363281, -0.09737566858530045, -0.018798641860485077, -0.024306703358888626, -0.028157083317637444, 0.004336287267506123, -0.00555825000628829, -0.036950740963220596, -0.028487810865044594, 0.06284099072217941, -0.021687980741262436, 0.007078072987496853, -0.0336449109017849, -0.02438274584710598, -0.020959706977009773, 0.021144354715943336, -0.09580036252737045, -0.023980312049388885, -0.02899244986474514, -0.05670130252838135, 0.06256463378667831, 0.08476894348859787, 0.059276778250932693, 0.04170254245400429, 0.019140422344207764, 0.012790371663868427, -0.029859378933906555, 0.05929756909608841, -0.080254465341568, -0.030864156782627106, -0.053143732249736786, -0.026386214420199394, 0.061684999614953995, 0.025042755529284477, 0.010372241027653217, -0.00038935893098823726, 0.031032079830765724, 0.0368853323161602, -0.03893614932894707, 0.042625486850738525, 0.0060146222822368145, 0.020137397572398186, -0.10116516798734665, 0.002015978330746293, -0.04951579123735428, -0.04412125051021576, 0.09183564782142639, 0.007771830540150404, -0.009757354855537415, -0.013004684820771217, -0.03416748344898224, -0.11161413043737411, 0.0028586711268872023, -0.031369034200906754, 0.011602342128753662, -0.007994973100721836, -0.04169580712914467, 0.03548933565616608, -0.035021595656871796, 0.07144157588481903, 0.0006511443061754107, 0.033875755965709686, -0.012474669143557549, -0.013593324460089207, 0.05316589027643204, 0.03551234304904938, -0.10178284347057343, 0.006956437136977911, -0.03583686053752899, 0.061729796230793, 0.030430221930146217, -0.008162280544638634, -0.008811205625534058, 0.025376131758093834, -0.0409105084836483, 0.01925792545080185, 0.0038228663615882397, -0.027486726641654968, -0.028952989727258682, -0.11397366970777512, -0.047372348606586456, 0.05599332973361015, -0.017670422792434692, 0.08369094133377075, 0.01981516182422638, 0.018010307103395462, 0.03814292699098587, 0.015707701444625854, -0.026665398851037025, -0.005824156105518341, -0.02510862797498703, 0.01076518278568983, 0.053482357412576675, 0.01919727958738804, 0.025504497811198235, -0.08109357208013535, 0.01703547313809395, -0.05630685016512871, 0.07231778651475906, -0.058127984404563904, -0.022810833528637886, -0.03394809737801552, -0.013425732962787151, 0.0936262309551239, 0.037013035267591476, 0.06749829649925232, -0.08748947829008102, -0.033322773873806, 0.0006074662087485194, -0.032664526253938675, 0.06211377680301666, 0.022496294230222702, 0.08801478147506714, -0.02706613391637802, -0.005479603540152311, 0.016060899943113327, -0.029758792370557785, 0.0013114212779328227, 0.08781974017620087, -0.0320594348013401, 0.03920230641961098, 0.06031445041298866, 0.05501450598239899, 0.011215430684387684, 0.0446290597319603, 0.03523801639676094, 0.04014866054058075, 0.03187919035553932, 0.07072713226079941, -0.007624996360391378, 0.00245060701854527, -0.016750220209360123, 0.016656478866934776, -0.0035167085006833076, -0.00728572765365243, -0.08073275536298752, -0.04298671707510948, -0.0017303890781477094, 0.002690440509468317, 0.016054118052124977, -0.010118048638105392, 0.0170542411506176, 0.001635190681554377, 0.0432807132601738, 0.029651131480932236, 0.014779574237763882, -0.04450778290629387, 0.00869388785213232, -0.004859092645347118, -0.07529357075691223, -0.026681412011384964, -0.0021037831902503967, 0.011789427138864994, -0.014712600968778133, -0.013224730268120766, 0.030222903937101364, 0.002861472312361002, 0.05627122148871422, 0.04005433991551399, 0.030169958248734474, 0.0034652689937502146, 0.04202122613787651, 0.07626381516456604, 0.011609458364546299, -0.011338230222463608, 0.029338182881474495, 0.039090823382139206, -0.04200601950287819, -0.019517695531249046, 0.02066589891910553, -0.0817423015832901, -0.03120913729071617, 0.04772467911243439, 0.0034935814328491688, 0.02815118432044983, 0.052326980978250504, -0.018793845549225807, -0.004150785505771637, 0.02837776020169258, 0.056635696440935135, 0.06658453494310379, -0.00007651057239854708, 0.06290507316589355, -0.007252102717757225, 0.010340381413698196, 0.03310864046216011, -0.044559478759765625, 0.03762459009885788 ]
198
198
The Latent Relation Mapping Engine: Algorithm and Experiments
Many AI researchers and cognitive scientists have argued that analogy is the core of cognition. The most influential work on computational modeling of analogy-making is Structure Mapping Theory (SMT) and its implementation in the Structure Mapping Engine (SME). A limitation of SME is the requirement for complex hand-coded representations. We introduce the Latent Relation Mapping Engine (LRME), which combines ideas from SME and Latent Relational Analysis (LRA) in order to remove the requirement for hand-coded representations. LRME builds analogical mappings between lists of words, using a large corpus of raw text to automatically discover the semantic relations among the words. We evaluate LRME on a set of twenty analogical mapping problems, ten based on scientific analogies and ten based on common metaphors. LRME achieves human-level performance on the twenty problems. We compare LRME with a variety of alternative approaches and find that they are not able to reach the same level of performance.
[ -0.003369002602994442, -0.015605823136866093, 0.05334192141890526, -0.03421464189887047, 0.01686343178153038, -0.08723443746566772, -0.0103862714022398, -0.026166507974267006, -0.005851773079484701, -0.004265203140676022, 0.03563304245471954, -0.055365849286317825, -0.0036742850206792355, 0.10964144021272659, -0.013196807354688644, 0.004863545764237642, -0.01610841229557991, -0.021166527643799782, 0.026321399956941605, -0.0009996573207899928, -0.01210692711174488, 0.05110399052500725, -0.042767565697431564, -0.0800386518239975, 0.04121982678771019, -0.009970598854124546, -0.08839230984449387, -0.03256957605481148, 0.005823955405503511, -0.02685837261378765, -0.028955498710274696, 0.010520103387534618, 0.09178361296653748, 0.057907454669475555, -0.006378864403814077, 0.07361641526222229, 0.012905717827379704, -0.03532962501049042, -0.05789110064506531, -0.017484834417700768, 0.011813790537416935, -0.03141315281391144, -0.03144324570894241, 0.01565868780016899, 0.05822793394327164, 0.06222392991185188, -0.043055374175310135, -0.018510503694415092, 0.05077602341771126, 0.056560762226581573, -0.06324442476034164, 0.03963198512792587, 0.045232441276311874, 0.05315038934350014, -0.01554170437157154, 0.031483590602874756, 0.01587378792464733, 0.015630921348929405, 0.04196162149310112, 0.021774772554636, 0.002737909322604537, 0.09285075217485428, -0.014820236712694168, -0.0193935576826334, -0.00689255865290761, 0.021582702174782753, -0.018184399232268333, 0.023793941363692284, -0.048171281814575195, 0.009828519076108932, -0.02035621367394924, -0.03961264342069626, 0.02123064547777176, -0.04031506925821304, 0.04648466035723686, 0.027372976765036583, -0.02505202405154705, -0.09088029712438583, 0.0679570734500885, 0.0626116544008255, -0.011692731641232967, 0.030465897172689438, -0.0037397127598524094, -0.0030063369777053595, -0.021779421716928482, 0.04255455359816551, 0.0477493554353714, 0.0016550255240872502, -0.0015577883459627628, -0.01699981465935707, -0.013473882339894772, -0.018138552084565163, -0.07430649548768997, 0.0500577948987484, -0.04508811607956886, 0.07412165403366089, 0.0005925016012042761, -0.05830003693699837, 0.03380962833762169, 0.02654007263481617, -0.000022487771275336854, -0.024234626442193985, 0.025909526273608208, 0.032424286007881165, -0.09510520100593567, 0.06571946293115616, 0.024451902136206627, 0.0678723081946373, 0.015586059540510178, 0.05570834130048752, -0.004489148035645485, 0.014844221994280815, 0.005760794971138239, 0.024328071624040604, -0.01383274793624878, 0.018587350845336914, -0.04341542720794678, 0.08607422560453415, -0.00720918970182538, -0.04003147408366203, -0.08832442760467529, 0.015243792906403542, -0.04544233903288841, -0.017669707536697388, -0.03524615243077278, -0.045033954083919525, -0.031571175903081894, 0.03403162211179733, 0.04884500801563263, -0.06540858745574951, -0.08808153122663498, -0.01990513689815998, -0.03774381801486015, 0.04059475287795067, -0.03050801157951355, -0.05944415181875229, -0.05897245183587074, -0.02562514692544937, -0.03634782135486603, 0.004694934468716383, 0.04308738186955452, 0.001463678083382547, -0.017535775899887085, 0.007964377291500568, 0.05389753356575966, 0.07645139843225479, -0.0447266511619091, -0.056675996631383896, 0.07679810374975204, -0.0573955774307251, -0.013262100517749786, -0.08946987241506577, -0.0104893259704113, 0.013250913470983505, -0.004445306491106749, -0.04896453395485878, -0.08918213844299316, -0.09362217038869858, 0.02026425115764141, 0.06866590678691864, 0.01534271240234375, -0.04525100067257881, -0.04148149490356445, 0.05331098288297653, -0.025501281023025513, -0.014372670091688633, -0.08846480399370193, -0.04830588400363922, 0.014456888660788536, -0.07362320274114609, -0.020051613450050354, 0.04080556333065033, -0.019695930182933807, 0.04336356744170189, -0.03170333430171013, -0.10214492678642273, -0.02836792543530464, -0.04665249213576317, 0.043533749878406525, 0.003643589559942484, -0.06666259467601776, -0.013092810288071632, 0.013996390625834465, -0.015259651467204094, 0.016989288851618767, 0.13290782272815704, 0.00647071935236454, 0.0745859444141388, 0.002075725933536887, -0.011770656332373619, 0.013240163214504719, 0.0048963953740894794, -0.0126007329672575, 0.013048888184130192, -0.01739959977567196, -0.06752227246761322, 0.07290297001600266, 0.019679469987750053, -0.009536808356642723, 0.04915018007159233, 0.00020981699344702065, 0.012903579510748386, -0.0260813869535923, -0.07809216529130936, 0.02946014516055584, -0.03159623593091965, 0.029508106410503387, -0.043187256902456284, -0.046672381460666656, -0.044208694249391556, 0.01021980307996273, 0.014227858744561672, 0.011991146020591259, 0.015339571982622147, 0.00314205139875412, -0.024373045191168785, -0.0025364025495946407, -0.049857690930366516, 0.040439072996377945, -0.0010006593074649572, -0.0780629962682724, 0.04003869369626045, 0.04750615358352661, 0.14472554624080658, 0.006315220613032579, 0.0022695036605000496, 0.0353342704474926, -0.0621945820748806, 0.02597624808549881, 0.032153498381376266, -0.05573302134871483, -0.02976370044052601, -0.07840672880411148, -0.05273769423365593, 0.05711240693926811, -0.0004962390521541238, -0.04100145399570465, -0.029057029634714127, -0.024578502401709557, -0.004650247748941183, -0.04046988859772682, 0.03322349116206169, 0.009710812009871006, -0.05737796425819397, 0.02786378376185894, -0.04490365833044052, 0.056545209139585495, -0.052432503551244736, 0.0014333241852000356, -0.04762442782521248, 0.013844714500010014, -0.03315463662147522, -0.029932120814919472, -0.023251425474882126, 0.057708144187927246, 0.08504711836576462, 0.004580522421747446, -0.0334605909883976, 0.03662624582648277, 0.052240610122680664, -0.023354893550276756, 0.03102676011621952, 0.006252065300941467, -0.03163790702819824, 0.07868748903274536, -0.015413451008498669, 0.017442947253584862, 0.01473425142467022, 0.015913324430584908, -0.05779489502310753, 0.00004984082988812588, -0.03630128875374794, -0.0019689658656716347, 0.00615960918366909, -0.08781962841749191, -0.0019131661392748356, 0.04830273985862732, 0.05750136449933052, -0.03489259257912636, -0.05268378555774689, -0.04759247973561287, 0.00034829185460694134, -0.007329660002142191, -0.017820613458752632, -0.03332607075572014, 0.02317550592124462, 0.04469441622495651, 0.018206819891929626, 0.027515893802046776, -0.047176800668239594, -0.09010355174541473, 0.014054210856556892, -0.03441229462623596, -0.013023491948843002, 0.0015889981295913458, -0.12256354093551636, -0.003396417712792754, -0.034644801169633865, 0.12010886520147324, 0.0035373871214687824, -0.01348341628909111, 0.08233696222305298, 0.09908373653888702, 0.032487981021404266, -0.022983450442552567, 0.029344195500016212, 0.022362640127539635, 0.11798011511564255, -0.003869084408506751, -0.07162284106016159, 0.04061274975538254, -0.004033233970403671, -0.04751400649547577, -0.012201588600873947, -0.0400770902633667, -0.04479774832725525, -0.06094576418399811, 0.0440932996571064, -0.006216763518750668, 0.022235535085201263, 0.029654892161488533, 0.007753250189125538, 0.01683834008872509, 0.06036875396966934, 0.02345440350472927, -0.05915415287017822, -0.005088020581752062, -0.04445112496614456, -0.02592308446764946, 0.06605830788612366, -0.024738354608416557, -0.03211237117648125, 0.00133200001437217, 0.06940819323062897, -0.05640064924955368, 0.06164681911468506, 0.01080028060823679, -0.008434576913714409, 0.00719102518633008, 0.039678335189819336, -0.07270906865596771, 0.019258642569184303, 0.007091074716299772, 0.03617867827415466, -0.019304340705275536, 0.027859879657626152, 0.07613761723041534, 0.05735986679792404, 0.002357486868277192, 0.038323577493429184, 0.04569336399435997, -0.045478321611881256, -0.06486457586288452, 0.017194334417581558, 0.08627192676067352, 0.016702385619282722, 0.006385049317032099, 0.019628074020147324, -0.03244693949818611, 0.02975877933204174, 0.06685660779476166, 0.05582544580101967, -0.027764026075601578, -0.023071739822626114, 0.05244544893503189, 0.06842128932476044, -0.04586517810821533, -0.0020675708074122667, -0.053386278450489044, -0.0031533120200037956, 0.02593476139008999, 0.033138688653707504, -0.02712612971663475, -0.0442923977971077, -0.021292850375175476, -0.07795871794223785, 0.13711197674274445, -0.03662385046482086, 0.010840378701686859, 0.051850877702236176, -0.013957643881440163, -0.05845993012189865, -0.03626878559589386, 0.012312812730669975, -0.03167358785867691, 0.043901827186346054, -0.007279281970113516, 0.02464888244867325, 0.02281031757593155, 0.03963813558220863, -0.00009014218085212633, 0.020415641367435455, 0.037860315293073654, -0.00593225983902812, 0.1212221160531044, 0.0297869686037302, -0.017149223014712334, -0.10196676105260849, -0.033032335340976715, -0.0045129042118787766, -0.025287752971053123, 0.00822641234844923, -0.030316876247525215, -0.03146207332611084, -0.04253062233328819, 0.03772817924618721, -0.009378562681376934, 0.025821907445788383, 0.0035816810559481382, 0.025927992537617683, 0.03925010561943054, -0.02389422245323658, -0.018252719193696976, -0.050781600177288055, 0.04136873781681061, 0.07639933377504349, 0.044937457889318466, -0.012338194064795971, 0.057027418166399, -0.041856177151203156, -0.05323801562190056, -0.02340402640402317, 0.01746191270649433, -0.03396223485469818, -0.07275055348873138, -0.018057912588119507, 0.07447884976863861, -0.01675855927169323, 0.06784480065107346, 0.00954888854175806, 0.0409216471016407, 0.003590647131204605, -0.12305985391139984, 0.04647647589445114, 0.0379536971449852, -0.020859764888882637, -0.018113180994987488, -0.04894924536347389, -0.04918277636170387, 0.002219210844486952, -0.023478318005800247, -0.011560645885765553, 0.03107733465731144, 0.004743240773677826, 0.006811712868511677, 0.03287375345826149, 0.03597981855273247, 0.07066959142684937, 0.07105563580989838, -0.010954199358820915, -0.028075724840164185, 0.0011526609305292368, 0.005575727205723524, -0.03301651403307915, -0.06386248022317886, -0.025295842438936234, -0.015225578099489212, 0.0006313807098194957, 0.054715171456336975, -0.07280406355857849, -0.011729412712156773, -0.026421859860420227, 0.012574204243719578, -0.009576910175383091, -0.07933415472507477, -0.034747663885354996, 0.03187635913491249, 0.034095510840415955, 0.025935042649507523, 0.02110692672431469, -0.04724636301398277, 0.0029933254700154066, -0.01935904659330845, -0.009458266198635101, -0.011823526583611965, 0.05017303302884102, -0.0018795261858031154, -0.03597649931907654, -0.0798664540052414, -0.03382372856140137, -0.010632572695612907, -0.0011559096165001392, 0.011263139545917511, -0.00758698582649231, 0.040220778435468674, 0.0030667141545563936, -0.03974591940641403, -0.005795357748866081, 0.019599471241235733, 0.019670654088258743, 0.03197847679257393, -0.02093123272061348, 0.04274258762598038, 0.02604079805314541, 0.05216619372367859, 0.0196982529014349, 0.00813278742134571, -0.053392741829156876, 0.02643081545829773, 0.07976499199867249, 0.08103042840957642, 0.006808742880821228, -0.01582486182451248, 0.05485875532031059, 0.05183756351470947, 0.04340263456106186, 0.05982358753681183, 0.041784219443798065, 0.0025134964380413294, 0.02910570800304413, -0.13376019895076752, -0.013783624395728111 ]
199
199
Feature Markov Decision Processes
General purpose intelligent learning agents cycle through (complex,non-MDP) sequences of observations, actions, and rewards. On the other hand, reinforcement learning is well-developed for small finite state Markov Decision Processes (MDPs). So far it is an art performed by human designers to extract the right state representation out of the bare observations, i.e. to reduce the agent setup to the MDP framework. Before we can think of mechanizing this search for suitable MDPs, we need a formal objective criterion. The main contribution of this article is to develop such a criterion. I also integrate the various parts into one learning algorithm. Extensions to more realistic dynamic Bayesian networks are developed in a companion article.
[ -0.068334199488163, -0.10462959110736847, 0.06755398213863373, 0.018995167687535286, -0.00818436499685049, -0.12266497313976288, -0.022916946560144424, 0.025584502145648003, -0.02170238271355629, 0.023392995819449425, 0.020956043154001236, -0.07225611060857773, 0.013694842346012592, 0.04768704995512962, 0.04038377106189728, -0.04386435076594353, -0.016560396179556847, -0.0009747924050316215, 0.050936009734869, -0.03231732174754143, 0.07935034483671188, 0.01687535271048546, -0.019237391650676727, 0.01735479198396206, -0.01845625229179859, 0.04977627843618393, -0.03349137678742409, -0.028025537729263306, 0.019626427441835403, 0.02014230005443096, -0.042348820716142654, -0.03774123638868332, 0.004445145837962627, -0.005608441308140755, 0.020530972629785538, -0.03885427117347717, -0.03727651387453079, -0.03700621798634529, -0.09378647804260254, -0.00977662205696106, -0.02343403548002243, -0.0814656913280487, -0.022160198539495468, -0.005904114339500666, 0.07068034261465073, 0.08429497480392456, 0.03149547427892685, 0.010388480499386787, 0.02930995263159275, 0.058059725910425186, -0.0866909921169281, -0.015740644186735153, -0.033006973564624786, -0.04262256994843483, -0.005166863091289997, 0.04362563043832779, -0.0020983931608498096, -0.02048409916460514, -0.06408289074897766, -0.04616052657365799, -0.001810153597034514, 0.04282018914818764, 0.007684304378926754, 0.019434701651334763, -0.02371184527873993, -0.029867609962821007, -0.06204385682940483, 0.03105388581752777, -0.034911345690488815, -0.011233360506594181, 0.05296286568045616, -0.060898441821336746, -0.012412638403475285, 0.04138815030455589, 0.016735302284359932, 0.027969840914011, -0.03743886202573776, 0.05446641147136688, -0.03921572118997574, 0.10293804854154587, -0.05419555678963661, 0.07984490692615509, -0.06728158891201019, 0.07027386873960495, -0.03611458092927933, 0.0041023376397788525, -0.05022934824228287, -0.03448806703090668, 0.0004565701528917998, -0.003779252292588353, -0.0025964195374399424, -0.007799390237778425, -0.06642891466617584, -0.021302545443177223, -0.008135060779750347, 0.029936810955405235, -0.08241301774978638, 0.017015978693962097, -0.02493874542415142, 0.02805415540933609, 0.04092864319682121, -0.029435841366648674, 0.07749298214912415, 0.037817586213350296, -0.00484734820201993, 0.010596798732876778, -0.0034805121831595898, 0.04014964401721954, 0.03755555674433708, -0.008395290933549404, 0.0633639544248581, 0.046701304614543915, -0.03518068790435791, -0.005129947327077389, -0.0626063272356987, 0.01324042771011591, -0.034575220197439194, 0.08730487525463104, 0.06139036640524864, 0.08646570891141891, -0.016141146421432495, -0.0059094857424497604, -0.0826776772737503, 0.013827604241669178, 0.07792142778635025, -0.09949406236410141, -0.008125199005007744, -0.03202509507536888, 0.10894777625799179, -0.018061628565192223, 0.021191442385315895, -0.01835128851234913, 0.01297714002430439, -0.12908940017223358, -0.061760589480400085, -0.010813146829605103, 0.0024858673568814993, -0.08852902054786682, -0.02443739026784897, 0.030691031366586685, 0.017838194966316223, 0.02728133462369442, 0.002092586364597082, -0.01804695837199688, -0.022366400808095932, -0.0014133222866803408, 0.008267001248896122, 0.025583989918231964, -0.0065020290203392506, 0.05501945689320564, 0.003439520951360464, -0.019107406958937645, -0.01467994786798954, 0.06607209891080856, -0.04065733775496483, 0.027888167649507523, -0.06322415918111801, -0.015293174423277378, -0.031227324157953262, 0.0658908560872078, 0.01036589965224266, 0.05191411077976227, 0.013607052154839039, 0.034109875559806824, 0.03253515809774399, -0.002874443307518959, -0.06372861564159393, 0.04354513809084892, -0.030634554103016853, -0.09880093485116959, -0.10866628587245941, -0.01386332605034113, 0.015467756427824497, 0.06012267246842384, -0.021941399201750755, -0.023619327694177628, -0.02428409643471241, -0.0012398854596540332, 0.013936895877122879, -0.01770346611738205, -0.021459579467773438, -0.03673677518963814, -0.012268181890249252, -0.029638148844242096, 0.0318525992333889, -0.018069498240947723, 0.01934465579688549, -0.026462554931640625, 0.04627827927470207, 0.0031391489319503307, -0.07483213394880295, 0.011282597668468952, -0.001627014484256506, -0.0018576692091301084, 0.002097941702231765, 0.02161215990781784, 0.011377481743693352, 0.005205274559557438, 0.017024103552103043, 0.04660375788807869, 0.061597634106874466, -0.038452938199043274, -0.027706053107976913, -0.008289440535008907, -0.053727615624666214, 0.08291684836149216, 0.042620979249477386, -0.04767822474241257, -0.0033620651811361313, 0.018931109458208084, 0.017514992505311966, 0.012602890841662884, -0.04082849994301796, -0.0022930968552827835, 0.0732572004199028, -0.05095694214105606, -0.008209256455302238, -0.07450567930936813, 0.028752325102686882, 0.017271753400564194, 0.0008663085172884166, 0.028003564104437828, 0.01698438823223114, 0.06169652193784714, -0.056005727499723434, -0.0362267829477787, 0.031503960490226746, -0.06934089958667755, -0.06805207580327988, 0.0653589740395546, -0.031487174332141876, 0.007411693688482046, 0.020245399326086044, -0.012377540580928326, -0.021865198388695717, 0.028887279331684113, -0.038025956600904465, -0.028618616983294487, -0.008529574610292912, -0.022557485848665237, -0.0376407653093338, 0.10869649052619934, 0.006068528164178133, -0.08722403645515442, 0.050272274762392044, -0.0030031870119273663, 0.01010629627853632, -0.010654745623469353, -0.037993647158145905, -0.02544008567929268, -0.014942487701773643, 0.023829007521271706, -0.020661283284425735, 0.012724089436233044, 0.020944805815815926, 0.013245115987956524, 0.01636296510696411, 0.06140798702836037, 0.044930025935173035, 0.03584237024188042, -0.07341846078634262, 0.0006949060480110347, -0.04082898423075676, 0.08372227847576141, 0.056852150708436966, 0.022107459604740143, 0.020512299612164497, 0.059727754443883896, 0.0459284670650959, -0.03359050303697586, -0.010385246947407722, -0.0025607971474528313, -0.03354131057858467, 0.07675881683826447, -0.025676051154732704, -0.032917141914367676, -0.02483772486448288, -0.00998852401971817, 0.006034108344465494, -0.027611449360847473, -0.0891631618142128, 0.008647092618048191, 0.04534956440329552, -0.0019548258278518915, 0.06754479557275772, 0.04775043576955795, 0.029303457587957382, 0.020729023963212967, 0.04197508469223976, 0.015021654777228832, -0.06084318459033966, -0.034294068813323975, -0.03966742008924484, 0.01819431036710739, 0.0763547345995903, -0.0703328549861908, -0.030580319464206696, -0.04303378984332085, -0.026164038106799126, -0.00763813266530633, -0.03218943625688553, -0.034409016370773315, 0.07925566285848618, 0.015910591930150986, -0.02399003691971302, 0.08054475486278534, -0.01320713572204113, 0.052377037703990936, -0.04553918540477753, 0.03256506100296974, 0.09842050820589066, 0.045040227472782135, -0.013234606944024563, -0.014718365855515003, 0.03698733076453209, -0.01880783401429653, -0.021090563386678696, 0.0034965178929269314, -0.071559377014637, 0.027523307129740715, -0.04298415035009384, -0.025650829076766968, 0.03392836079001427, 0.0469786562025547, -0.04346788674592972, -0.006666951347142458, 0.006603641901165247, 0.05329398065805435, -0.057357676327228546, 0.06058468669652939, -0.06118631735444069, -0.021136390045285225, 0.03450997173786163, 0.06998433917760849, -0.05418463796377182, -0.017372867092490196, -0.0994427278637886, -0.02343382127583027, 0.06385096907615662, 0.04318387806415558, -0.05038487911224365, -0.13063286244869232, -0.050636712461709976, -0.0502329058945179, 0.04527077451348305, 0.08516070991754532, 0.08690639585256577, -0.008730988949537277, -0.011730167083442211, 0.062481239438056946, 0.005972395185381174, 0.024353820830583572, -0.031069016084074974, 0.09846556186676025, -0.02066551148891449, -0.059099700301885605, 0.031192252412438393, 0.008486590348184109, 0.011330263689160347, 0.029215790331363678, -0.07740282267332077, -0.011676531285047531, -0.006109090056270361, -0.01864585652947426, 0.0040675001218914986, 0.02051321603357792, 0.001521577243693173, -0.001941204653121531, -0.03565908968448639, -0.04659602418541908, -0.001985380658879876, 0.021159349009394646, 0.045026861131191254, -0.030699091032147408, 0.0822342038154602, -0.050796665251255035, 0.09094327688217163, 0.016047589480876923, -0.031226499006152153, 0.12641899287700653, -0.09864455461502075, -0.019893595948815346, -0.01807294599711895, -0.06594157218933105, -0.08089122176170349, -0.04818549379706383, -0.01251846831291914, -0.0184991005808115, 0.03262767195701599, -0.03341951593756676, -0.05989056080579758, 0.002724843332543969, 0.02214811183512211, 0.033309146761894226, 0.00002431524444546085, -0.036147791892290115, 0.055956363677978516, 0.04466034471988678, -0.003989774733781815, 0.0091411042958498, 0.0189159344881773, -0.020901622250676155, 0.06852632015943527, -0.027018720284104347, -0.0384521558880806, 0.007703708950430155, 0.05856397747993469, 0.03329238295555115, 0.016238410025835037, 0.056675948202610016, 0.05896459147334099, 0.08745869994163513, 0.03442114591598511, -0.07769469171762466, 0.001260340795852244, 0.0541808158159256, 0.030879054218530655, 0.05202334746718407, -0.023984039202332497, -0.05454353615641594, -0.06164591759443283, -0.019716857001185417, 0.0018032689113169909, 0.03815411031246185, -0.03391890227794647, 0.011716775596141815, 0.023882145062088966, 0.051199641078710556, 0.020262455567717552, 0.022467434406280518, -0.012323585338890553, -0.0495821088552475, -0.07162019610404968, -0.00009173708531307057, 0.03453098610043526, -0.013696983456611633, -0.021135302260518074, 0.010525759309530258, -0.017305368557572365, -0.007698646280914545, -0.039041973650455475, 0.03458641469478607, 0.05438455939292908, 0.007625509053468704, 0.04625225067138672, 0.08427879959344864, 0.028349896892905235, 0.020332347601652145, 0.057260483503341675, 0.007390810642391443, -0.017293186858296394, 0.05182427167892456, 0.13425329327583313, -0.006144390907138586, 0.028769096359610558, 0.013172274455428123, 0.03241658955812454, 0.01428721472620964, 0.076287180185318, 0.012737251818180084, -0.025302499532699585, -0.03265231102705002, 0.03156689181923866, -0.028641952201724052, -0.044680338352918625, -0.008588067255914211, 0.020806169137358665, -0.010871774516999722, 0.09828557819128036, -0.0033870371989905834, -0.05226392298936844, 0.049045268446207047, 0.0013369983062148094, -0.01896921917796135, -0.040928926318883896, 0.02872714027762413, -0.015411358326673508, -0.034301724284887314, -0.042362943291664124, -0.024733902886509895, 0.04680967330932617, 0.023936070501804352, -0.015701713040471077, 0.021768352016806602, 0.032453130930662155, 0.024807576090097427, -0.0034059600438922644, -0.044920749962329865, 0.022736677899956703, 0.019916055724024773, -0.02170797809958458, -0.07671267539262772, 0.02245137467980385, -0.020856834948062897, -0.00498864334076643, -0.026351921260356903, 0.03423507139086723, -0.027764534577727318, 0.07218147069215775, -0.0013336233096197248, 0.04755869135260582, -0.06956052780151367, 0.016438089311122894, 0.036400046199560165, 0.0615767203271389, -0.005988711025565863, 0.030560210347175598, 0.01187601126730442, -0.0034084455110132694, 0.03628137707710266, -0.08656208217144012, 0.044926028698682785 ]